instruction
stringclasses 1
value | input
stringlengths 1.14k
484k
| answers
sequencelengths 1
1
| input_length
int64 194
85k
| total_length
int64 194
85k
| length_bucket
int64 1k
128k
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in this paper we study the effects of rotation on the radiation driven winds of early - type supergiants . we will focus on the explanation for the occurrence of disks around fast rotating b[e ] supergiants . b[e ] supergiants , also designated sgb[e ] stars ( lamers et al . @xcite ) , are b type supergiants that exhibit forbidden emission lines in their optical spectra . the observations of hybrid spectra , i.e. spectra with _ broad _ uv p cygni features and _ narrow _ emission lines and dust emission of b[e ] supergiants in the magellanic clouds led to the proposal of a disk wind model by zickgraf et al.(@xcite ) . this model postulates a dense disk of outflowing material in a fast line driven wind to explain the observed characteristics of the spectra of these stars ( see zickgraf @xcite ) . the stellar wind at the equator is about ten times slower than that at the pole . also , the wind at the equator is about a hundred times denser than at the pole . additional evidence for a two - component outflow has been obtained from polarimetric measurements , e.g. by zickgraf & schulte - ladbeck ( @xcite ) . the precise mechanism behind the formation of these disks is still a mystery ( cassinelli 1998 ) . it is however clear that the origin of an axisymmetric wind structure such as a disk may well be connected to the fast rotation of a star . two theories using rotation in a different way have been considered for the formation of these disk winds : ( 1 ) the wind compressed disk ( wcd ) model of bjorkman & cassinelli ( @xcite ) , that invokes the kinematics of the winds from rotating stars . the streamlines of the gas in the wind from both hemispheres of a rapidly rotating star cross in the equatorial plane . the concentration of the gas and the shock in the equatorial plane produce an outflowing equatorial disk , with a thickness on the order of a few degrees . owocki & cranmer ( 1994 ) have argued that the motion to the equatorial plane may be counteracted by the radiation force perpendicular from the plane due to lines . however , this `` wind - inhibition effect '' may not be effective in winds with a strong density gradient in the equatorial direction . we return to this in sect . ( 2 ) the rotationally induced bi - stability model ( rib ) of lamers & pauldrach ( @xcite ) invokes an increase in the mass flux from the equator and a decrease in the equatorial wind velocity compared to the poles from the bi - stability jump . this jump in mass flux and in wind velocity is due to the temperature difference between the pole and the equator of a fast rotating b[e ] supergiant with gravity darkening . the jump will occur for stars with effective temperatures between 20 000 and 30 000 k. in reality , both effects , i.e. the wind compression and the rotation induced bi - stability , may be operating together and amplifying one another in the line driven winds of rapidly rotating early - b stars . ( for a detailed explanation of both models , see lamers & cassinelli ( 1999 ) ( hereafter @xmath5 ) , chapter 11 . ) the theory of radiation driven winds for non - rotating stars was developed by castor et al . ( @xcite ) ( hereafter cak ) and predicts the mass loss rate and @xmath6 for spherical winds . the influence of rotation on line driven winds was investigated by friend & abbott ( @xcite ) . they found an increase in the mass - loss rate at the equator and a corresponding decrease in @xmath6 , but these authors did not consider the effects of gravity darkening and the oblate shape of the star . cranmer & owocki ( @xcite ) described the finite disk correction factor in case of an oblate star . in this paper we will modify the line driven wind theory , including these effects of oblateness and gravity darkening as well as the rotational terms in the equation of motion . this will then be applied to rapidly rotating b[e ] supergiants to investigate whether these effects can explain the occurrence of disks . we will also apply recent bi - stability calculations to study the effect of the rib - model to explain the occurrence of outflowing disks around rapidly rotating b[e ] supergiants . in sect . 2 we describe the theoretical background of the radiation driven wind theory and the bi - stability effect . in sect . 3 we derive the equations for the winds from oblate rotating stars with a temperature gradient between poles and equator due to gravity darkening . in sect . 4 we describe the method for solving the equations and for calculating the winds from rotating stars . these calculations will be applied to b[e ] supergiants in sect . [ s_b[e ] ] . in sect . [ s_bs ] we will investigate the effect of bi - stability on rotating stars and sect . [ s_concl ] concludes with a summary of this work and a discussion on the formation of disks of b[e ] supergiants . the computation of the dynamics of line driven stellar winds is a complicated problem in radiation hydrodynamics . it involves the simultaneous solution of the equations of motion , the rate equations and the radiative transfer equations in order to calculate the radiative acceleration . for hot luminous stars the line forces are the most important driving forces in the wind . cak have shown that the line acceleration can be parameterized in terms of the optical depth parameter @xmath7 as @xmath8 , where @xmath0 and @xmath1 are parameters that depend on composition and temperature of the wind . in this expression @xmath0 is a measure of the number of lines and @xmath1 is a measure of the distribution of the line strengths with @xmath9 or 1 for a pure mix of optically thin or thick lines respectively . in this paper we adopt the cak formalism and simplify the equations of motion by assuming a stationary , radial flow of a viscousless fluid . the possible influence of magnetic fields will be ignored . these simplifications are subject to the following restrictions ( see e.g. abbott 1980 ) : * the cak theory treats the line acceleration in a simplified way in terms of the force multipliers , described above . detailed calculations of the line driving , including millions of lines , show that the total line acceleration can be well described by this simple representation ( pauldrach et al . both observations and calculations show that line driven stellar winds are not stationary . even a wind in a stationary solution will develop shocks ( see e.g. lucy @xcite ) . however , the time - averaged structure follows the stationary state quite well ( see owocki et al . @xcite , and feldmeier 1999 ) . therefore we will restrict ourselves to stationary models . * a sectorial model will be adopted . this means that for every latitude a one dimensional problem will be solved . wind compression as in the wcd model will thus be neglected , but the main effect of wind compression is expected to _ redistribute _ the mass loss and not to change the _ total _ mass that is lost from the rotating star . * the absence of viscosity is a good approximation at the high density of line driven winds ( see cak ) . the representation of the line force by a simple power law may seem to be a gross simplification of the underlying physics of myriad line absorption processes , but it can be shown to hold for a homogeneously distributed mix of optically thick and thin lines ( abbott @xcite , gayley @xcite ) . calculations of cak and more recently in nlte by vink et al . ( @xcite ) of realistic model atmospheres , based on calculations of unified atmosphere / wind models with the isa - wind code ( de koter et al . 1997 ) , confirm this to be generally true to good accuracy for the important part of the wind ( from about the sonic point up to a few stellar radii ) . therefore , the complex physics of ion populations can be ignored in the investigation of the various effects of rotation on the stellar wind . however , there is one notable exception which is called the bi - stability jump . this refers to a jump in @xmath6 around the temperature of 21000 k where @xmath10 climbs from 1.3 ( lower temperature ) to 2.6 ( higher temperature ) . this jump was observed by lamers et al . ( @xcite ) in b supergiants . it is linked to a shift in ionization states of fe in the lower part of the wind . the line driving in the lower part of the wind is dominated by iron . below about @xmath11 k , fe iv recombines to fe iii and since fe iii is a more efficient line driver than fe iv , the wind structure changes dramatically ( vink et al . @xcite ) . the bi - stability jump may also occur in the temperature difference between the pole and the equator of a fast rotating star with gravity darkening . therefore two sets of force multiplier parameters for the wind will be adopted to reflect the sudden change in ionization states ( a high - temperature set for the pole and a low - temperature set for the equator ) . intuitively it is clear that rotation has an effect on the shape of a star and on the motion of the gas in the wind . an additional effect that the rotation of a star can have is the darkening of the equatorial regions of a star via the von zeipel effect . these effects will modify the wind of a star considerably and we will incorporate them in the line driven wind theory for rotating stars . the shape of a uniformly rotating star with all its mass concentrated in the core is determined by the equipotential surfaces of the potential in a rotating frame ( roche model ) : @xmath12 where @xmath13 , @xmath14 is the co - latitude ( @xmath14 = 0 at the pole ) and @xmath15 . @xmath16 is of course independent of the longitude @xmath17 . note that @xmath18 . so the maximum oblateness is @xmath19 . the critical ( break - up ) velocity is defined in this paper as : @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the effective mass of the star , @xmath22 which is the reduced mass due to radiation pressure by electron scattering ( see below ) . the surface of a rotating star is implicitly given by eq . [ eq_firot ] . solving this expression for @xmath23 is equivalent to the solution of a 3rd degree polynomial , which results in @xmath24 because of the difference in radius @xmath25 and the difference in rotational velocity between pole and equator , the radial escape velocity at the equatorial region is smaller than at the pole @xmath26 we can then roughly estimate the effect of rotation on @xmath6 as this value has an almost linear dependence on @xmath27 ( see later in [ s_ssol ] ) . the von zeipel theorem ( @xcite ) for distorted stars states that the radiative flux from a point on the star is proportional to the local effective gravity : @xmath28 with @xmath29 the boltzmann constant . as @xmath30 , we can write down the flux of a rotating star as a function of the co - latitude @xmath14 . this ( lengthy ) expression for the flux as a function of @xmath14 is plotted in fig . [ fg_f ] for a few different values of @xmath31 . the rotation of the star can induce a @xmath14 component of the flow of the matter in the wind . in this study a possible @xmath14 component is neglected as was discussed in [ s_physics ] , but the motion in the longitudinal @xmath17 direction must still be taken into account . in the absence of forces that can exert a torque on the wind , the equation of motion for @xmath32 is given by the conservation of angular momentum . note however that there could be a torque from the line forces themselves , which is dependent on the velocity gradient of the gas . we assume that there are no external torques , so conservation of angular momentum gives : @xmath33 the equation of motion for the radial direction becomes : @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the radial velocity and @xmath36 is the stellar mass . the conservation of mass for a non - spherical sectorial wind can be written as @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the local mass loss rate , i.e. the total mass loss rate if the solution for this latitude where valid for a spherical star . the total mass loss rate from the star is @xmath39 the equation of motion together with the conservation of mass governs the dynamics of the wind given the equation of state , @xmath40 ( @xmath41 is the isothermal sound speed ) , and the radiative acceleration @xmath42 . using the conservation of mass , the pressure term can be rewritten as : @xmath43 as in the cak - theory the temperature structure is specified a priori as a function of @xmath44 . ( the results depend only very weakly on the chosen temperature structure ; see pauldrach et al . @xcite ) . the radiative acceleration consists of two components . the continuum component due to the electron scattering , @xmath45 , and a second component , @xmath46 , due to line scattering and absorption processes . the continuum acceleration is given in terms of @xmath47 : @xmath48 where @xmath49 is the electron opacity , @xmath50 is the stellar luminosity and @xmath51 is the radiation flux . the contributions by other continuum opacities are small . nevertheless , they were included in the calculation of the force multipliers by vink et al . ( 1999 ) used in our bi - stable wind models ( sect . for a homogeneous spherical star , @xmath47 is given by as the ratio between the continuum force and gravity and not as the ratio between continuum force and the critical radiation force for a rotating star ] : @xmath52 in the more general case of a non - homogeneous , non - spherical star the continuum acceleration can be defined as a correction to the classical continuum acceleration of eq . [ eq_gam ] : @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the continuum correction factor which is given by : @xmath55 the line acceleration @xmath56 has a more complicated form , since it is a function of distance @xmath44 as well as the velocity @xmath35 and velocity gradient @xmath57 . combining the equation of motion ( eq . [ eq_bewvgl ] ) with the rewritten pressure and continuum acceleration terms and multiplying by @xmath58 , one finds : @xmath59 this equation is valid for each co - latitude @xmath14 . following cak , the critical point of this equation is found by imposing the singularity condition ( where the subscript @xmath60 indicates values at the critical point ) : @xmath61 and the regularity condition : @xmath62 note that the critical point is not the sonic point @xmath63 ( @xmath64 ) due to the fact that there is an additional dependence on @xmath65 in the line acceleration @xmath46 ( abbott 1980 ; @xmath5 chapt 3.3 ) . the line forces are described within the framework of cak in the sobolev approximation . this means that the intristic line absorption profiles are considered to be infinitely sharp . then the line force becomes a function of local properties of the wind only . the acceleration due to an ensemble of lines is given by the summation of the contributions of all individual lines with rest frequencies @xmath66 . @xmath46 is given by ( castor @xcite ) : @xmath67 where @xmath68 is the absorption coefficient per gram for the @xmath69th line , @xmath70 , @xmath71 the intensity at the rest frequency @xmath72 and @xmath73 is the sobolev optical depth of @xmath69th line , defined as @xmath74 . the integration is performed over the complete visible disk of the star . following cak , the line acceleration can be rewritten in terms of the force multiplier as a function of the optical depth parameter @xmath75 . where @xmath75 is defined as : @xmath76 with @xmath77 being the thermal velocity of the protons and @xmath78 is some reference value for the electron scattering @xmath79 @xmath80 g@xmath81 ( see _ isw _ , chapt . the line acceleration in terms of the continuum acceleration is give by : @xmath82 if the star is assumed to be a point source , @xmath83 can be approximated by a simple power law parameterization ( cak , abbott 1982 ) : @xmath84 where the @xmath85 accounts for the effect of the electron density on the ionization balance in the wind . here @xmath86 is the electron density in units of @xmath87 @xmath88 and @xmath89 is the geometric dilution factor . friend & abbott ( 1986 ) and pauldrach et al . ( 1986 ) showed the importance of the finite disk correction on the line force in case of an extended source . this finite disk correction factor @xmath90 is given by ( cak ) : @xmath91 where @xmath92 this expression is completely general : the actual shape of the star and its intensity distribution enter through the integration domain and the @xmath93 dependence . however , here we assume the intensity @xmath94 to be locally isotropic , i.e. we neglect limb darkening . we have tested the effect of limbdarkening . the inclusion of limbdarkening results in a small @xmath14-independent correction on @xmath90 . the line acceleration @xmath46 including all the neccesary correction factors is now given by : @xmath95 combining eqs . [ eq_bewvglf ] and [ eq_gl ] gives the full equation of motion for the sectorial wind of a rotating star @xmath96 for line driven winds of non - rotating stars solutions of the equation of motion have been retrieved by e.g. cak and pauldrach et al . ( 1986 ) . these will be presented to serve as an illustration of the solution of the equation of motion and as a basis to interpret the more complicated results from the full equation of motion ( [ eq_bewvglrot ] ) . if the star is considered to be a point soure the integral of the line acceleration in eq . [ eq_gmeerlijn ] collapses to one point . in this case @xmath90 disappears from eq . [ eq_gl ] and the line acceleration becomes a simple function @xmath97 . the solution of eq . [ eq_bewvglf ] was found by cak and can easily be explained by neglecting the gas pressure terms ( @xmath98 ) . in this case [ eq_bewvglf ] reduces to @xmath99 where @xmath100 is a constant containing the mass loss rate . the equation is solved by imposing uniqueness of the solution ( kudritzki et al . 1989 ) which then fixes the value of the constant and thus @xmath101 . the solution for the mass loss and velocity law is given by @xmath102 @xmath103 with @xmath104 this simplified solution is equal to the full cak solution , in the limit of small sound speed , @xmath105 ( see also @xmath5 chapt 8) . in case of a homogeneous spherical star the finite disk correction factor @xmath90 ( eq . [ eq_corr ] ) can be calculated analytically ( cak ) : @xmath106 including the finite disk correction results in an increase in @xmath6 , a decrease in @xmath107 and a modification of the simple scaling laws that were found in the original cak approach ( see friend & abbott @xcite ; pauldrach et al . the decrease of the mass loss rate compared to the point source case is due to the decrease in @xmath46 close to the star where @xmath101 is determined . close to the stellar photosphere the finite disk correction is smaller than one , viz . @xmath108 . the accompanying increase in @xmath6 of typically a factor of two is due to two effects : ( 1 ) a reduction of @xmath107 results in a smaller amount of material to be accelerated and ( 2 ) far from the photosphere , the correction factor @xmath90 becomes larger than 1 . the resulting dependence between @xmath6 and @xmath27 is approximated by friend & abbott ( 1986 ) : @xmath109 they also found a relation for the modified mass loss rate : @xmath110 the solution of eq . [ eq_bewvglrot ] gives the mass loss rate , or rather the local mass loss rate @xmath38 , and velocity structure of the wind . the solution is complicated however by the presence of @xmath90 . this is an integral of a velocity - dependent function times the surface intensity over the visible section of the star . the appearance of the star varies throughout the wind in intensity distribution as well as in shape , as the star is no longer spherical and @xmath111 is a function of latitude . since the analytic solution would be cumbersome , a numerical approach of the solution is chosen . this is done with the analytic solutions of simple , i.e. the non - rotating , models in mind for comparison . the numerical solution of eq . [ eq_bewvglrot ] is relatively straightforward in case the function @xmath90 is a given function of @xmath44 . therefore we solve eq . [ eq_bewvglrot ] with @xmath112 in an iterative way as follows : 1 . a @xmath113 law for @xmath114 is assumed , viz . @xmath112 is calculated using this velocity law . note that @xmath90 is not dependent on the actual value of @xmath114 but on the velocity gradient . 3 . eq . [ eq_bewvglrot ] is solved using this correction factor @xmath112 , obtaining a new velocity law @xmath114 . step 2 - 3 are repeated until convergence is reached . typically three iterations are sufficient , since further iterations changed the obtained values by less than 0.5 % . we checked that the solutions converged to the same value , independent of the starting value . the calculation of the correction factor @xmath90 from the velocity law ( step 1 . in the scheme described above ) is performed by numerical evaluation of eq . [ eq_corr ] . this is a non - trivial task , since both the integrand ( eq . [ eq_zeipel ] ) and the shape of the visible `` disk '' ( eq . [ eq_rtheta ] ) are dependent on @xmath44 . the main parameters needed to obtain @xmath90 for a fixed co - latitude @xmath116 are : the stellar surface @xmath117 and the surface temperature @xmath118 , both given as a function of the co - latitude @xmath14 , as well as the velocity law @xmath114 . it is convenient to change the integration variables in eq . [ eq_corr ] from the wind centered coordinates @xmath14 and @xmath17 to the star centered coordinates @xmath119 and @xmath17 . for the definition of these coordinates , see fig . [ fg_ofr ] . note that here @xmath17 is not the stellar longitude anymore , but the angle of rotation around the line from a point @xmath120 in the wind to the stellar center . @xmath121 where @xmath94 is the frequency - integrated intensity @xmath122 the angles are related to one another via @xmath123 with the stellar surface given by @xmath124 , and @xmath125 equation [ eq_coint ] can be integrated , considering that the limb angle @xmath126 can be determined numerically , yielding the finite disk correction for the line acceleration of an arbitrary shaped star . the correction factor @xmath54 for the electron acceleration ( defined in eq . [ eq_dc ] ) similarly becomes : @xmath127 this correction is also included in the solution of the equation of motion . [ tb_res1 ] [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] ( 1 ) : the adopted stellar parameters are : @xmath128 ; @xmath129 ; @xmath130 k. to solve the equation of motion it is neccesary to determine the conditions at the critical point : @xmath131 , @xmath132 and @xmath133 , or , equivalently , @xmath131 , @xmath132 and @xmath134 , as well as the local mass loss rate @xmath135 . apart from eqs . [ eq_sing ] and [ eq_regu ] and the equation of motion ( [ eq_bewvglrot ] ) itself the additional constraint for the continuum optical depth @xmath136 at the stellar radius is neccesary ( pauldrach et al . 1986 ) to uniquely determine these quantities : @xmath137 if the condition for @xmath138 is used one may adopt any small value , say @xmath139 km / s , since even a large error in @xmath138 will only yield a relatively small error in @xmath6 and @xmath135 . this is due to the fact that at the surface of the star @xmath114 and thus also @xmath140 vary exponentially with scale height @xmath141 . this means that the radius where eq . [ eq_tau2/3 ] is fulfilled is very close to @xmath142 . this has been checked a posteriori . in our calculations we have adopted this boundary condition for @xmath138 in the solution of the full momentum equation . a first guess for the local mass loss rate obtained from the cak solution is used to integrate the equation of motion from the stellar surface outward . this gives an approximate value for the critical point where @xmath143 if @xmath144 . this approximate value for the critical point can then be used to consecutively improve the guessed value of @xmath135 using eqs . [ eq_sing ] and [ eq_regu ] . this iterative procedure is terminated when the local mass loss rate converges . the calculation is then completed by integrating past the critical point on the solution which extends to infinity ( see cak or abbott 1980 for a description of the topology of the solutions ) . to deal with a numerical singularity at the sonic point the equations are solved for @xmath145 rather than for @xmath114 . we have calculated models for rotating b[e ] stars using the above described method . for the first models we adopted the following stellar parameters , which are typical for b[e ] stars : @xmath146 , @xmath147 , @xmath148 , @xmath149 and solar abundances . the effective temperature is defined as @xmath150 where @xmath151 is the total surface of the distorted star . the following force multiplier parameters from pauldrach et al . ( @xcite ) were adopted to describe the line acceleration : @xmath152 , @xmath153 , @xmath154 . an overview of the results for this generic b[e ] star rotating at @xmath31 = 0 , 0.3 , 0.4 , 0.5 and 0.6 times the critical rotation speed is given in table 1 . the calculation of models with higher values of @xmath31 runs into numerical problems , because in the iteration , the approximate critical point can be below the sonic point . the table shows for different co - latitudes @xmath14 and different rotation velocities @xmath31 the values of @xmath6 , the local mass loss rate @xmath38 and the value of the velocity law parameter @xmath113 , obtained by fitting the calculated velocity structure from @xmath155 to @xmath156 to a @xmath113-law . we see that the value of @xmath113 does not change much . [ fg_vr ] shows the velocity structure of the wind and the location of the critical point for @xmath31 = 0 , 0.3 and 0.6 . note that the critical point is very close the star . this is true for all finite disk corrected solutions . figure [ fg_vmp ] shows the behaviour of @xmath6 versus @xmath135 for various rotational speeds and latitudes . as expected , @xmath6 at the equator is smaller than at the pole because @xmath6 scales roughly with @xmath27 and due to the smaller value of @xmath27 at the equator . figure [ fg_mp ] shows the latitude dependence of the local mass - loss rate and of the terminal velocity from equator to pole , for different rotational speeds , indicated by @xmath31 . at the pole ( @xmath157 ) @xmath6 is about constant for various rotational speeds the mass - loss rate at the equator decreases slightly with increasing rotation . the increase of the mass loss rate at the equator as calculated by pauldrach et al . ( @xcite ) and friend & abbott ( @xcite ) is offset by a decrease in mass loss rate due to the smaller radiative flux at the equator due to the von zeipel effect . the mass loss rate at the pole increases strongly with increasing rotation rate due to the increase in luminosity at the pole . this is because the total luminosity of the star is fixed and the smaller luminosity at the equator must therefore be compensated by a higher luminosity at the pole . the overall effect of rotation is to increase the mass loss rate of a star . this can be seen in fig . [ fg_mp ] where the overall mass - loss rate ( i.e. @xmath135 integrated over the stellar surface ) is plotted vs. the rotational velocity . the mass - loss rate of the models with @xmath158 vary with @xmath31 as @xmath159 . figure [ fg_ldens ] shows the resulting density contrast ( far from the star ) between pole and equator ( @xmath160 ) . the densities at pole and equator are essentially the same : the smaller @xmath6 at the equator is offset by the larger mass loss rate @xmath135 at the pole . [ fg_dc ] we have also calculated models for different luminosities ( see table 2 ) , and different stellar masses ( see table 3 ) . the mass - loss rate for the different luminosities is also plotted in fig . [ fg_mp ] . the density contrast for various luminosities is plotted in fig . [ fg_ldens ] . we see that the density at the pole compared to the equator increases for increasing luminosity and the effect on the mass - loss rate is only visible for the highest luminosity . this is an effect of the continuum acceleration @xmath54 . 7 illustrates the effect of the continuum acceleration on the forces in the wind for a star with high luminosity ( @xmath162 ) . the net effect of the continuum radiation pressure and the gravity , i.e. @xmath163 , is an inward force in the equatorial region and an outward force in the polar region where the flux is higher . for small luminosity the variation in @xmath164 through @xmath54 is not important because @xmath47 itself is small . for high luminosity @xmath165 increases and thus the effect of @xmath166 on @xmath164 becomes noticeable ( this is with all other properties of the star fixed ) . in eq . [ eq_vinfsimple ] we see that a larger value of @xmath166 at the pole causes a relatively larger decrease ( through @xmath164 ) in @xmath27 and thus in @xmath6 , whereas the mass loss rate at the equator will increase less because of the smaller @xmath54 . this is only a qualitative explanation and the actual dependence of @xmath167 does not follow the relation suggested by eqs . 29 and 31 . we have found that the actual values of @xmath167 could be approximated quite well ( within 10 percent ) with the following relation : @xmath168 where the @xmath169 is the radius where @xmath54 reaches its minimum value . so we see that although rotation alone modifies the wind structure considerably , it can not be responsible for the density contrast between the equatorial and polar wind observed in b[e ] stars , in case only radial effects are considered . we conclude that at least one other physical effect must be responsible for the formation of disks of rotating b[e ] stars . the two most likely additional effects are the bi - stability and the flow of the wind material towards the equator . in the section above we have shown that rotation alone can not explain the observed large density contrast between the poles and the equator of b[e ] stars . one of the possible additional mechanisms to enhance this contrast is the bi - stability jump . to investigate whether the bi - stability jump observed in normal b - supergiants can explain the formation of disks around b[e ] stars , we have calculated bi - stable wind models for a fast rotating typical b[e ] supergiant . spherical , nlte wind models for normal b supergiants have been calculated by vink et al . ( 1999 ) . from these models cak - like force multiplier parameters have been derived using a monte - carlo method to simulate photon - gas interactions . these models show the occurence of a bi - stability jump around @xmath11 k. for two models on either side of the bi - stability jump ( @xmath170 = 17 500 and 30 000 k ) , the cak parameters were determined by fitting a power law from about the sonic point to about @xmath171 ( from @xmath172 to @xmath173 in optical depth , @xmath75 is defined in eq . [ eq_t ] ) to the calculated force multiplier values . the resulting values for @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 are listed in table [ tb_ka ] . note that the @xmath2 parameter is taken equal to zero as it was not possible to extract it explicitly from the models . its effect is hidden in the constant @xmath0 . as expected , the values for the force multiplier parameters are quite different for the two cases , because the ionization has changed dramatically over the bi - stability jump . cccc & @xmath0 & @xmath1 & @xmath2 + 17500 k & 0.57 & 0.45 & 0.0 + 30000 k & 0.06 & 0.65 & 0.0 + [ tb_ka ] the predicted bi - stability jump occurs around @xmath174 kk . therefore we calculated a model for a rotating b[e ] star with the following properties : @xmath175 k , @xmath176 , @xmath177 and solar abundances . this implies that the pole of the rapidly rotating star will be hotter than 25 kk and the equator will be cooler than 25 kk . for the pole , the force multipliers @xmath0 and @xmath1 from the hot monte carlo model of 30 000 k were used , whereas for the equator , @xmath0 and @xmath1 from the cool model of 17 500 k were used . the resulting @xmath178 and mass loss rates @xmath38 are plotted in figs . [ fg_vtheta ] and [ fg_mdtheta ] for @xmath31 = 0.6 . clearly visible is the drastic decrease in @xmath6 and the drastic increase of @xmath135 towards the equator . this occurs around a co - latitude @xmath14 ( angle from the pole ) of about 60 degrees , where @xmath179 k. ( the precise location of the jump depends on the effective temperature of the star ) . since both @xmath135 and @xmath6 have a equator / pole contrast of about a factor of three , the resulting density contrast is about a factor of 10 in a disklike region with a half opening angle of 30 degrees . our calculations show that the density contrast in the wind between pole and equator due to the bi - stability jump is significantly larger than without the bi - stability jump . yet , the calculated value of about a factor 10 is not sufficient to explain the observed density contrast of a factor @xmath180 . so another mechanism is needed to enhance the density contrast even further . this is most likely the wind compression mechanism ( bjorkman & cassinelli 1993 ; bjorkman 1998 ) . we have modified the line driven wind theory for rotating stars by including the effects of oblateness and gravity darkening as well as rotational terms in the equation of motion . we considered a sectorial wind , i.e. we neglected the effect of the motion of the wind towards the equator or towards the pole . this assumption is justified close to the stellar surface below the critical point of the momentum equation . this implies that our method will predict about the correct distibution of mass - loss rates from the star as a function of stellar latitude , but it may not be accurate enough to predict the velocity and density distribution further away from the star , if motions in the @xmath14 direction become important . the equation of motion was solved using an iterative numerical scheme , that includes the conservation of angular momentum and the correction factors to the radiative acceleration by lines and by the continuum , due to the non - spherical shape of the star and due to the latitude dependence of the radiative flux . this method was applied to study its possible effects on the formation of disks around fast rotating b[e ] supergiants . the models with constant force multiplier parameters @xmath0 , @xmath1 and @xmath2 show a decrease of _ both _ the mass loss rate and the terminal velocity from pole to equator . this is mainly due to two effects : the reduction of the escape velocity from pole to equator , resulting in a higher terminal velocity at the pole , and the reduction of the radiative flux from the pole to the equator due to gravity darkening , which results in a decrease in mass loss rate at the equator . for a star with a fixed luminosity and a fixed polar radius , the temperature at the pole increases and the temperature at the equator decreases with increasing rotation rate . the terminal velocity of the wind from the poles is almost independent of @xmath181 but at the equator @xmath6 decreases with increasing rotation rate . the mass - loss rate at the pole increases with increasing @xmath181 , due to the increase in @xmath170 at the poles , but the mass loss rate from the equator is almost independent of the rotation . the combination of these effects alone produce a density contrast between the polar and the equatorial wind of a factor @xmath182 , except for fast rotating stars with high luminosity ( in which case @xmath183 ) . our results agree quantitatively with those obtained by maeder ( @xcite ) for the latitudinal dependence of @xmath135 . our predictions of the global mass loss rates are also in general agreement with those of maeder for models with luminosities far from the eddington limit . for high luminosities we find a strong polar outflow , whereas maeder s models predict an enhanced equatorial outflow on the basis of the original cak scaling laws . this difference is due to the fact that we have included an improved description of the radiation pressure in a rotating star . the difference between the polar wind and the equatorial wind is strongly enhanced when the bi - stability of radiation driven winds between @xmath149 and 30 000 k is taken into account . in this case the force multipliers @xmath0 and @xmath1 of a rapidly rotating star change drastically with stellar latitude if the pole is hotter than 25 000 k and the equator is cooler . in [ s_bs ] we have applied the newly calculated force multipliers from vink et al . ( 1999 ) above and below the bi - stability jump to the models of rotating b[e ] supergiants . one might argue that it is not allowed to apply the force multipliers of ( bi - stable ) spherical wind models to aspherical winds of rotating stars . however , we have shown that a disk formed through bi - stability will be sufficiently thick ( typically about 30 degrees for a star with an effective temperature equal to about 25 000 ) to make these spherical models reasonable approximations for the conditions in the wind close to the star , where the mass loss rate is determined . we find that rotationally induced bi - stability models of b[e ] stars reach a density contrast of about a factor 10 between the dense equatorial wind and the less dense polar wind . this is less than the factor @xmath184 that is observed ( see e.g. bjorkman @xcite ) . the extra density increase is most likely due to the wind compression . the gas that leaves the photosphere from a rotating wind , will follow an orbit in a tilted plane defined by the local rotation vector and the center of the star . if the rotational velocity is large or the wind velocity is small , this orbit will cross the equatorial plane where the streamlines of the wind from different stellar latitudes cross . the resulting shock will compress the gas into a thin outflowing disk with an opening angle of only a few degrees ( bjorkman & cassinelli 1993 ; @xmath5 chapt 11 ) . we have not considered this wind compression in our model . however , it is likely to occur in rotationally induced bi - stable winds , because the wind velocity in the equatorial plane is about a factor three smaller than from the poles , thus facillitating the wind compression . owocki & cranmer ( 1994 ) have argued that the flow of the wind towards the equatorial plane , predicted in the wcd - theory , may be offset by a @xmath14-component of the line acceleration towards the polar regions . this `` disk inhibition '' mechanism operates in wind models with constant force multipliers @xmath0 and @xmath1 . however , it is not clear that this mechanism is sufficiently strong to overcome the wind compression in the rib - model . this is because @xmath0 and @xmath1 change with latitude in the rib - model and there is a strong density gradient in the wind from the equator to the poles ( owocki et al . 1998 , puls et al . 1999 ) . the combination of the rib and the wcd mechanism may offer the best possibility for explaining the disks of b[e]-supergiants . whether the compression is strong enough to explain the observed high density contrast between the polar and the equatorial wind , remains to be seen . it can be calculated by combining the solutions of the wind momentum equation of rotating oblate stars with gravity darkening ( derived in this paper ) , and the calculation of the resulting trajectories of the wind . the combination of the rotation induced bi - stability model and the wind compressed disk model is promising for explaining the disks of b[e ] stars because the rib - mechanism explains the increased mass loss and the small velocity from the equatorial regions and the wcd - mechanism explains the strong compression of the disk . abbott d.c . , 1980 , apj 242 , 1183 abbott d.c . , 1982 , apj 259 , 282 bjorkman j.e . , 1998 , in _ b[e ] stars _ , eds a.m. hubert , c. jaschek kluwer : dordrecht , assl 233 , p 189 bjorkman j.e . , cassinelli j.p . , 1993 , apj 409 , 429 cassinelli 1998 in _ b[e ] stars _ , eds a.m. hubert , c. jaschek kluwer : dordrecht , assl 233 , p 177 castor j.i . , 1974 , mnras 169 , 279 castor j.i . , abbott d.c . , klein r.i . , 1975 , apj 195 , 157 cranmer s.r . , owocki s.p . , 1994 , apj 440 , 308 feldmeier a. , 1999 in _ variable and non - spherical stellar winds in luminous hot stars _ , lecture notes in physics , eds . b. wolf et al . springer : heidelberg , p 285 . friend d.b . , abbott d.c . , 1986 , apj 311 , 701 gayley k.g . , 1995 , apj 454 , 410 kudritzki r.p . , pauldrach a. , puls j. , abbott d.c . , 1989 , a&a 219 , 205 lamers h.j.g.l.m . , cassinelli j.p . , 1999 , introduction to stellar winds , cambridge univ . press . ( @xmath5 ) lamers h.j.g.l.m . , pauldrach a. , 1991 , a&a 244 , l5 lamers h.j.g.l.m . , , lindholm d.m . , 1995 , apj 455 , 269 lamers h.j.g.l.m . , zickgraf f .- j . , de winter d. , houziaux l. , zorec j. , 1998 , a&a 340 , 117 lucy l.b . , 1982 , apj 255 , 286 maeder a. , 1999 , a&a 347 , 185 owocki s.p . , castor j.i . , rybicki g.b . , 1988 , apj 335 , 914 owocki s.p . , cranmer r.c . , 1994 , apj 424 , 887 owocki s.p . , cranmer r.c . , gayley k.g . , 1998 , ap&ss 260 , 149 pauldrach a. , puls j. , kudritzki r.p . , 1986 , a&a 164 , 86 puls j. , petrenz p. , owocki s.p . , 1999 in _ variable and non - spherical stellar winds in luminous hot stars _ , lecture notes in physics , eds . b. wolf et al . springer : heidelberg , p 131 . , de koter a. , lamers h.j.g.l.m . , 1999 , a&a 350 , 181 von zeipel h. , 1924 , mnras 84 , 665 zickgraf f .- j . , 1992 , in _ astronomical ccd observing and reduction techniques _ howell s.b . , asp conference series vol . 22 , 75 zickgraf f .- j . , schulte - ladbeck r.e . , 1989 , a&a 214 , 274 zickgraf f .- j . , wolf b. , stahl o. , leitherer c. , klare g. , 1985 , a&a 143 , 421
Abstract: | [
"we have formulated the momentum equation for sectorial line driven winds from rotating stars including : ( a ) the oblateness of the star , ( b ) gravity darkening ( von zeipel effect ) , ( c ) conservation of angular momentum , ( d ) line driving specified by the force multiplier parameters ( @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 ) , ( e ) finite disk correction factors for an oblate star with gravity darkening for both the continuum and the line driving . the equations are solved numerically . we calculated the distribution of the mass flux and the wind velocity from the pole to the equator for the winds of b[e]-supergiants . rotation decreases the terminal velocity in the equatorial region but hardly affects the wind velocity from the poles ; it enhances the mass flux from the poles while the mass flux from the equator remains nearly the same . these effects increase with increasing rotation rates . we also calculated models with a bi - stability jump around 25 000 k , using force multipliers recently calculated with a monte carlo technique . in this case the mass flux increases drastically from the pole to the equator and the terminal velocity decreases drastically from pole to equator . this produces a density contrast in the wind @xmath3 of about a factor 10 independent of the rotation rate of the star . we suggest that the observed density contrast of a factor @xmath4 of the disks of b[e ] stars may be reached by taking into account the wind compression due to the trajectories of the gas above the critical point towards the equatorial plane ."
] | 7,943 | 7,943 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: we consider the problem of reconstruction of refractive indices or dielectric constants of unknown targets placed in a homogeneous domain from blind backscattered experimental data . we work with time resolved backscattering experimental data of wave propagation for a 3-d hyperbolic coefficient inverse problem ( cip ) . our data are generated by a single location of the point source . the backscattering signal is measured on a part of a plane . we present a combination of the approximately globally convergent method of @xcite with a finite element method ( fem ) for the numerical solution of this cip . given a certain function computed by the technique of @xcite , the fem reconstructs the unknown coefficient in an explicit form . as a result , we can reconstruct refractive indices and locations of targets . in addition , we estimate their sizes . we believe that these results can be used as initial guesses for locally convergent methods in order to obtain better shapes , see , e.g. section 5.9 in @xcite , where the image obtained by the globally convergent method for transmitted experimental data was refined via a locally convergent adaptivity technique . experimental data were collected by the device which was recently built at university of north carolina at charlotte . in our experiments we image targets standing in the air . a potential application of our experiments is in imaging of explosives . note that explosives can be located in the air @xcite , e.g. improvised explosive devices ( ieds ) . the work on real data for the case when targets are hidden in a soil is ongoing . we have collected backscattering time resolved experimental data of electrical waves propagation in a non - attenuating medium . as it was pointed out in @xcite , the main difficulty of working with such data is caused by a huge mismatch between these data and ones produced by computational simulations . conventional data denoising techniques do not help in this case . therefore , it is unlikely that any numerical method would successfully invert the raw data . to get the data , which would look somewhat similar with ones obtained in computational simulations , a heuristic data pre - processing procedure should be applied . the pre - processed data are used as the input for the globally convergent method . previously our research group has applied the method of @xcite to the simpler case of transmitted experimental data which were produced by a similar device ( chapter 5 of @xcite ) . the backscattering real data are much harder to work with than transmitted ones since the backscattered signal is significantly weaker than the transmitted one , as well as because some unwanted signals are mixed up with the true one , see figure [ fig2]-a ) for the latter . we refer to our research in @xcite and section 6.9 of @xcite for the case of backscattering real data in 1-d . in the current paper we present results of reconstruction of the 3-d version of the method of @xcite . the approximately globally convergent method of @xcite relies on the structure of the underlying pde operator and does not use optimization techniques . each iterative step consists of solutions of two problems : the dirichlet boundary value problem for an elliptic pde and the cauchy problem for the underlying hyperbolic pde . approximate global convergence " ( global convergence in short ) means that we use a certain reasonable approximate mathematical model . approximation is used because of one inevitably faces with substantial challenges when trying to develop globally convergent numerical methods for multidimensional cips for hyperbolic pdes with single source . it is rigorously established in the framework of this model that the method of @xcite results in obtaining some points in a small neighborhood of the exact coefficient without a priori knowledge of any point in this neighborhood , see theorem 2.9.4 in @xcite and theorem 5.1 in @xcite . the distance between those points and the exact solution depends on the error in the data , the step size @xmath1 of a certain discretization of the pseudo - frequency interval and the computational domain @xmath2 where the inverse problem is solved ( see section [ sec:4.3 ] for definition of @xmath1 ) . a knowledge of the background medium in @xmath3 is also not required by this method . because of these theorems , convergence analysis is not presented here . a rigorous definition of the approximate global convergence property can be found in section 1.1.2 of @xcite and in @xcite . we use a mild approximation , since it amounts only to the truncation of a certain asymptotic series , and it is used only on the first iterative step ( section [ sec:4.2 ] ) . the validity of this approximate model was verified computationally on both synthetic and transmitted experimental data in @xcite as well as in the current work in the case of experimental backscattering data . different imaging methods are used to compute geometrical information of targets , such as their shapes , sizes and locations , see , e.g. @xcite . on the other hand , refractive indices , which is our main interest , characterize constituent materials of targets , and they are much more difficult to compute . as to the gradient - like methods , we refer to , e.g. @xcite and references therein . convergence of these methods is guaranteed only if the starting point of iterations is chosen to be sufficiently close to the correct solution . on the other hand , it was shown in section 5.8.4 of @xcite that the gradient method failed to work for transmitted experimental data of @xcite in the case when its starting point was the background medium . an outline of this paper is as follows . in section 2 we state forward and inverse problems . in section 3 we describe the experimental data and briefly outline the data pre - processing procedure . in section 4 we briefly outline the method of @xcite : for reader s convenience . in section 5 we describe a version of the fem which works for our case . in section 6 we describe our algorithm . in section 7 we outline some details of our numerical implementation . results are presented in section 8 and summary is in section 9 . let @xmath4 be a convex bounded domain with the boundary @xmath5 denote by @xmath6 we model the electromagnetic wave propagation in an isotropic and non - magnetic space @xmath7 with the dimensionless coefficient @xmath8 which describes the spatially distributed dielectric constant of the medium . we consider the following cauchy problem for the hyperbolic equation @xmath9@xmath10we assume that the coefficient @xmath11 of equation ( [ 2.1 ] ) is such that @xmath12,~~\varepsilon _ { r}(\mathbf{x})=1\text { for } \mathbf{x}\in \mathbb{r}^{3}\diagdown \omega , \label{2.20}\]]where @xmath13 we _ a priori _ assume knowledge of the constant @xmath14 which amounts to the knowledge of the set of admissible coefficients in ( 2.20 ) . however , we do not assume that the number @xmath15 is small , i.e. we do not impose smallness assumptions on the unknown coefficient @xmath16 . below @xmath17 are hlder spaces , where @xmath18 is an integer and @xmath19 let @xmath20 be a part of the boundary @xmath21 later we will designate @xmath22 as the backscattering side of @xmath2 and will explain how we deal with the absence of the data at @xmath23 * coefficient inverse problem ( cip ) . * _ suppose that the coefficient _ @xmath24 _ _ satisfies . determine the function _ _ @xmath24 _ _ for _ _ @xmath25 _ _ , assuming that the following function _ _ @xmath26 _ _ is known for a single source position _ _ @xmath27 @xmath28 the function @xmath26 in ( [ 2.5 ] ) models time dependent measurements of the wave field at the part @xmath22 of the boundary @xmath29 of the domain of interest @xmath2 . we assume below that the source position is fixed and @xmath30 . this assumption allows us to simplify the resulting integral - differential equation because @xmath31 in @xmath32 . the assumption @xmath33 for @xmath34 means that the coefficient @xmath11 has a known constant value outside of the domain of interest @xmath35 this is a cip with single measurement data . uniqueness theorem for such cips in the multidimensional case are currently known only if the function @xmath36 in ( [ 2.2 ] ) is replaced with a function @xmath37 such that @xmath38 @xmath39 a proper example of such function @xmath40 is a narrow gaussian centered around @xmath41 , which approximates the function @xmath36 in the distribution sense . from the physics standpoint this gaussian is equivalent to @xmath42 that uniqueness theorem can be proved by the method , which was originated in @xcite . this method is based on carleman estimates , also see , e.g. sections 1.10 , 1.11 of the book @xcite about this method . the authors believe that , because of applications , it still makes sense to develop numerical methods for this cip without completely addressing the uniqueness question . the function @xmath43 in ( [ 2.1 ] ) represents the voltage of one component of the electric field @xmath44 in our computer simulations the incident field has only one non - zero component @xmath45 . this component propagates along the @xmath46axis until it reaches the target , where it is scattered . so , we assume that in our experiment @xmath47 we now comment on five main discrepancies between our mathematical model ( [ 2.1])- ( [ 2.20 ] ) and the reality . the first discrepancy which causes the main difficulties , is the aforementioned huge mismatch between experimental data and computational simulations . the second one is that , although we realize that equation ( [ 2.1 ] ) can be derived from maxwell equations only in the 2-d case , we use it to model the full 3-d case . the reason is that our current receiver can measure only one of the polarization components of the scattered electric field @xmath48 . in addition , if using a more complicated mathematical model than the one of ( [ 2.1 ] ) , for example the one that includes vector scattering and thus depolarization effects on scattering , then one would need to develop a globally convergent inverse method for this case . the latter is a quite time consuming task with yet unknown outcome . * * * * equation ( [ 2.1 ] ) was used in chapter 5 of @xcite for the case of transmitted experimental data , and accurate solutions were obtained . a partial explanation of the latter can be found in @xcite , where the maxwell s system in a non - magnetic and non - conductive medium was solved numerically in time domain . it was shown numerically in section 7.2.2 of @xcite that the component of the vector @xmath49 which was initially incident upon the medium , dominates two other components . this is true for at least a rather simple medium such as ours . therefore , the function @xmath43 in ( [ 2.1 ] ) represents the voltage of the computed component @xmath50 of the electric field , which is emitted and measured by our antennas . the third discrepancy is that the condition @xmath51 is violated on the inclusion / background interface in our experiments . the fourth discrepancy is that formally equation ( [ 2.1 ] ) is invalid for the case when metallic targets are present . on the other hand , it was demonstrated computationally in kbksnf that one can treat metallic targets as dielectrics with large dielectric constants , which we call _ appearing dielectric constant _ , @xmath52modeling metallic targets as integral parts of the unknown coefficient @xmath24 is convenient for the above application to imaging of explosives . indeed , ieds usually consist of mixtures of some dielectrics with a number of metallic parts . such targets are heterogeneous ones , and we consider three heterogeneous cases in section [ sec:8.2 ] . on the other hand , modeling metallic parts of heterogeneous targets as a separate matter than the rest of an a priori unknown background medium would result in significant additional complications of the already difficult problem with yet unknown outcome . the fifth discrepancy is that we use the incident plane wave instead of the point source in our computations . we have discovered that the plane wave case works better in image reconstructions than the point source , while the point source case is more convenient for the convergence analysis in bk , bkjiip12 . in addition , since the distance between our measurement plane and targets is much larger than the wavelength of our signal , it is reasonable to approximate the incident wave as a plane wave . thus , our results of section [ sec:8.2 ] demonstrate the well known fact that computational results are often less pessimistic than the theory , since the theory can not grasp all nuances of the reality . in summary , we believe that accurate solutions of the above cip for experimental data justify our mathematical model . figure [ fig1]-a ) is a photograph explaining the data collection . the data collection is done in a regular room , which contains office furniture , computers , etc . keeping in mind our desired application ( see introduction ) , we intentionally did not arrange a special waveguide , which would protect our data from unwanted signals caused by reflections from various objects in the room . below @xmath53 and @xmath54 are horizontal and vertical axis respectively and the @xmath55 axis is perpendicular to the measurement plane , the positive direction of @xmath55 axis is in the direction from the target to the measurement plane . we dimensionalize our coordinates as @xmath56 where m " stands for meter . however , we do not change notations of coordinates for brevity . hence , below , e.g. 0.05 of length actually means 5 centimeters . `` the transmitter sends the pulse into the medium which contains targets of interest . the electric wave caused by the pulse is scattered by the targets , and the backscattered signal is detected by the detector . the detected signal is recorded by the real time oscilloscope . '' two main pieces of our device are picosecond pulse generator ( figure [ fig1]-b ) ) and textronix oscilloscope ( figure [ fig1]-c ) ) . the picosecond pulse generator generates electric pulses . the duration of each pulse is 300 picoseconds . this pulse goes to the transmitter , which is a horn antenna ( source ) . the transmitter sends the pulse into the medium which contains targets of interest . the electric wave caused by the pulse is scattered by the targets , and the backscattered signal is detected by the detector . the detected signal is recorded by the real time oscilloscope . the oscilloscope produces a digitized time resolved signal with the step size in time of 10 picoseconds . the total time of measurements for one pulse is 10 nanoseconds=10@xmath57 picoseconds=10@xmath58 second . to decrease the measurement noise , the pulse is generated 800 times for each position of the detector , the backscattering signal is also measured 800 times and resulting signals are averaged . the detector moves in both horizontal and vertical directions covering the square @xmath59 on the measurement plane . we have chosen the step size of this movement to be 0.02 . although we can choose any step size , we found that 0.02 provides a good compromise between the precision of measurements and the total time spent on data collection . the distance between our targets and the measurement plane is approximately 0.8 with about 0.05 deviations , and the wavelength of our signal is about 0.03 . therefore , the distance between the measurement plane and our targets is of about 26 wavelengths . this is in the far field zone . the main difficulty working with experimental data is that there is a huge mismatch between these data and computationally simulated ones . indeed , figure [ fig2]-a ) depicts a sample of experimentally measured data for a wooden block at one position of the detector , see figure [ fig1]-a ) for data collection scheme . on this figure , the direct signal is the signal going directly to the receiver . we use this direct signal as the time reference for data pre - processing . unwanted signals are due to reflections of the electric wave from several objects present in the room . figure [ fig2]-b ) presents the computationally simulated data for the same target , see section [ sec:7.1 ] for data simulations . these figures show a huge mismatch between real and computationally simulated data . therefore , data pre - processing is necessary . we refer to @xcite for details of our data pre - processing procedure . the main steps of this procedure include : 1 . _ time - zero correction_. the time - zero correction is to shift the measured data in time . so that its starting time is the same as when the incident pulse is emitted from the transmitter this is done using the direct signals from the transmitter to the detector as the time reference . 2 . _ extraction of scattered signals_. apart from the backscattered wave by the targets , our measured data also contain various types of signals , e.g. direct signals from the horn to the detector , scattered signals from structures inside the room , etc . what we need , however , is the scattered signals by the targets only . to obtain them , we single out the scattered signals caused by the targets only and remove all unwanted signals . data propagation_. after getting the scattered signals , the next step of data pre - processing is to propagate the data closer to the targets , i.e. to approximate the scattered wave on a plane which is much closer to the targets then the measurement plane . the distance between that propagated plane and the front surface of a target is usually between 0.02 and 0.06 ( compare with the 0.8 distance from the measurement plane ) . there are two reasons for doing this . the first one is that the method of @xcite works with the laplace transform of the function @xmath43 ( section [ sec:4 ] ) . that laplace transform decays exponentially in terms of the time delay , which is proportional to the distance from the target to the measurement plane . hence , the amplitude of the laplace transformed experimental data on the measurement plane is very small and can be dominated by computational round - off error . the second reason is that this propagation procedure helps to substantially reduce the computational cost since the computational domain for the inverse problem is reduced . 4 . _ data calibration . _ finally , since the amplitudes of the experimental incident and scattered waves are usually significantly different from simulations , we need to bring the former to the same level of the amplitude as the latter . this is done using a known target referred to as _ calibrating object_. in this paper , the result of data pre - processing is used as the measured data @xmath60 on the backscattering boundary @xmath22 of our computational domain @xmath2 for the inverse problem . in this section we briefly outline the globally convergent method for reader s convenience . we refer to sections 2.3 , 2.5 , 2.6.1 and 2.9.2 of bk as well as @xcite for details . the first step of our inverse algorithm is the laplace transform of the function @xmath61@xmath62where @xmath63 is a certain number . we assume that the number @xmath63 is sufficiently large , and we call the parameter @xmath64 _ pseudo frequency_. it follows from ( [ 2.1 ] ) , ( [ 2.2 ] ) and ( [ 2.6 ] ) that the function @xmath65 is the solution of the following problem @xmath66@xmath67the limit ( [ 2.8 ] ) is proved in theorem 2.7.1 of @xcite . in addition , it was proven in theorem 2.7.2 of @xcite that for the function @xmath24 satisfying ( [ 2.20 ] ) there exists unique solution @xmath68 of the problem ( 2.7 ) , ( [ 2.8 ] ) for every @xmath69 such that @xmath70where @xmath71 is the solution of the problem ( 2.7 ) , ( [ 2.8 ] ) for the case @xmath72@xmath73 it follows from theorem 2.7.2 of @xcite that @xmath74 hence , we can consider the functions @xmath75 , @xmath76 @xmath77substituting @xmath78 in ( [ 2.7 ] ) and keeping in mind that the source @xmath30 , we obtain @xmath79using ( [ transform ] ) we obtain @xmath80where the truncation pseudo frequency @xmath81 is a large number , which is chosen numerically , see section [ sec:8 ] for details . we call @xmath82 the _ tail function , _ and it is unknown . it follows from ( [ transform ] ) and ( 3.7 ) that @xmath83it follows from @xcite ( section 2.3 ) that , under some conditions , there exists a function @xmath84 such that the following asymptotic behavior with respect to @xmath85 holds for functions @xmath86 and @xmath87 @xmath88@xmath89 differentiating both sides of equation ( [ new3.2 ] ) with respect to @xmath64 then using ( [ transform ] ) and ( [ 3.7 ] ) , we obtain the following nonlinear integral differential equation @xmath90 . \end{split } \label{3.8}\]]in addition , ( [ 2.5 ] ) and ( [ transform ] ) lead to the following dirichlet boundary condition for the function @xmath87 @xmath91 , \label{3.9}\]]@xmath92here @xmath93 is the laplace transform ( 2.6 ) of the function @xmath60 in ( [ 2.5 ] ) . we now need to complement the boundary data ( [ 3.9 ] ) at the backscattering side @xmath22 with the boundary data at the rest of the boundary @xmath94 using computationally simulated data , it was shown numerically in section 6.8.5 of @xcite as well as in @xcite that it is reasonable to approximate the boundary data on @xmath95 by the solution of the forward problem for the homogeneous medium for the case @xmath96 : recall that this equality holds outside of the domain @xmath97 see ( [ 2.20 ] ) . thus , we use below the following dirichlet boundary condition for the function @xmath98@xmath99 , \label{3.91}\]]@xmath100 , \\ \psi ^{0}\left ( \mathbf{x},s\right ) , \forall \left ( \mathbf{x},s\right ) \in \left ( \partial \omega \setminus \gamma \right ) \times \left [ \underline{s},\overline{s}\right ] .\end{array}\right . \label{3.92}\]]where the function @xmath101 is the function @xmath102 in ( [ 3.90 ] ) computed for the case @xmath103 . even though equation ( [ 3.8 ] ) with the boundary condition ( [ 3.91 ] ) has two unknown functions @xmath87 and @xmath86 , we can approximate both of them because approximation procedures for them are different , see section 7.1 . suppose for a moment that functions @xmath87 and @xmath86 are approximated in @xmath2 together with their derivatives @xmath104 then the corresponding approximation for the coefficient @xmath11 can be found via backwards calculation using ( [ new3.2 ] ) . to start iterations , we need the first approximation @xmath105 for the tail function . in this section we show how to calculate @xmath106 this is the same choice as the one in section 2.9.2 of the book @xcite as well as in @xcite . let the function @xmath107 satisfying ( 2.20 ) be the exact solution of our cip for the exact data @xmath108 in ( [ 2.5 ] ) . let @xmath109 be the exact tail function defined as @xmath110let @xmath111 $ ] be the corresponding exact function @xmath98 satisfying equation ( [ 3.8 ] ) . let @xmath112 $ ] be the corresponding exact dirichlet boundary condition for @xmath113 as defined in ( 3.91 ) . following ( [ 3.92 ] ) , we assume that @xmath114 for @xmath115 .$]hence , ( [ 3.8 ] ) and ( [ 3.91 ] ) hold for functions @xmath116 setting in ( 3.8 ) @xmath117 we obtain @xmath118next , truncating the second term in each of the asymptotics ( [ 2.b ] ) and ( [ 2c ] ) , we obtain that there exists a function @xmath119 such that @xmath120substituting formulae ( [ asymptotic ] ) into ( [ 4.18 * * ] ) , we obtain the following approximate dirichlet boundary value problem for the function @xmath121 @xmath122@xmath123thus , using ( [ 4.17 * ] ) and ( [ asymptotic ] ) , we obtain the following approximate mathematical model . * approximate mathematical model . * _ we assume that there exists a function _ @xmath124 _ _ such that the exact tail function _ _ @xmath125 _ _ has the form _ _ @xmath126__and the function _ _ @xmath127 _ _ is__@xmath128 because of ( [ 2.917 ] ) , ( [ 2.918 ] ) and ( [ 2.914 ] ) , we set for the first tail @xmath129where the function @xmath130 is the solution of the following dirichlet boundary value problem @xmath131@xmath132we point out that we calculate @xmath105 without any advanced knowledge of a small neighborhood of the exact coefficient @xmath133 using ( [ asymptotic])-([2.925 ] ) and schauder theorem @xcite , we obtain @xmath134where the number @xmath135 depends only from the domain @xmath35 hence , the error in the calculation of @xmath105 depends only on the error in the boundary data @xmath136 on the other hand , since the boundary function @xmath137 is generated by the function @xmath26 in ( [ 2.5 ] ) , then the error in @xmath138 is generated by the error in measurements . the estimate ( [ 2.926 ] ) is one of elements of the proof of the approximate global convergence theorem for this numerical method , see theorem 2.9.4 in @xcite and theorem 5.1 in @xcite . although a good approximation for the exact solution @xmath107 can be derived from the function @xmath139 we have observed computationally that better approximations are delivered via iterations described below in sections [ sec:6.1 ] , [ sec:6.2 ] . to approximate both functions @xmath87 and @xmath86 using ( [ 3.8 ] ) and ( [ 3.91 ] ) , we consider the layer stripping procedure with respect to @xmath64 . we divide the interval @xmath140 $ ] into @xmath141 small subintervals with the uniform step size @xmath142 . here , @xmath143 we approximate the function @xmath144 as a piecewise constant function with respect to @xmath145 i.e. we assume that @xmath146 for @xmath147 hence , using ( [ 3.7 ] ) , we approximate the function @xmath148 as @xmath149to obtain a sequence of dirichlet boundary value problems for elliptic pdes for functions @xmath150 we introduce the @xmath151dependent carleman weight function ( cwf ) @xmath152 , $ ] where @xmath153 is a large parameter . in our numerical studies we take @xmath154 . this function mitigates the influence of the nonlinear term in the resulting integral - differential equations on every pseudo - frequency interval @xmath155 . multiply both sides of equation ( [ 3.8 ] ) by @xmath156 and integrate with respect to @xmath157 we obtain @xmath158here @xmath159 is such an approximation of the tail function @xmath160 which corresponds to the function @xmath161 ( section [ sec:6.1 ] ) . numbers @xmath162 are computed explicitly . furthermore , @xmath163 for this reason we ignore the nonlinear term in ( [ 4.21 ] ) , thus setting@xmath164note that ( [ 4.22 ] ) is not a linearization , since ( [ 4.21 ] ) contains products @xmath165 and also because the tail function @xmath166 depends nonlinearly on functions @xmath167 see ( [ 2.a ] ) and step 6 in section [ sec:6.1 ] . in this section we explain how we compute functions @xmath169 on every pseudo - frequency interval @xmath170 using the fem . once the functions @xmath171 along with the function @xmath172 in ( [ 4.21 ] ) are calculated , we compute the function @xmath173 using the direct analog of ( [ 4.20 ] ) , @xmath174using ( [ transform ] ) , we set @xmath175 . \label{3.104}\ ] ] to find the function @xmath176 we note that the function @xmath177 is the solution of the following analog of the problem ( [ 2.7 ] ) , ( [ 2.8])@xmath178@xmath179where @xmath180 \text { for } \mathbf{x}\in \partial \omega . \label{3.107}\]]to compute the function @xmath181 from ( [ 3.105 ] ) , ( [ 3.106 ] ) and ( [ 3.107 ] ) , we apply a version of the fem as described below in sections [ sec:5.1 ] , [ sec:5.2 ] . following @xcite we discretize in computations our bounded domain @xmath4 by an unstructured tetrahedral mesh @xmath182 using non - overlapping tetrahedral elements @xmath183 . the elements @xmath184 are such that @xmath185 , where @xmath186 is the total number of elements in @xmath2 , and @xmath187we associate with the mesh @xmath182 the mesh function @xmath188 as a piecewise - constant function such that @xmath189where @xmath190 is the diameter of @xmath184 which we define as the longest side of @xmath184 . we impose the following shape regularity assumption of the mesh @xmath182 for every element @xmath191 @xmath192where @xmath193 is the radius of the maximal sphere contained in the element @xmath184 . define the set of polynomials @xmath194 as @xmath195we introduce now the finite element space @xmath196 as @xmath197where @xmath198 denotes the set of linear functions on @xmath184 defined by ( polynom ) for @xmath199 . hence , the finite element space @xmath196 consists of continuous piecewise linear functions in @xmath2 . to approximate functions @xmath200 we introduce the space of piecewise constant functions @xmath201 , @xmath202where @xmath203 is the piecewise constant function on @xmath184 defined by ( polynom ) for @xmath204 . to compute the function @xmath205 from ( [ 3.105 ] ) , we formulate the finite element method for the problem ( [ 3.106])-([3.107 ] ) as : find the function @xmath206 for the known function @xmath207 such that @xmath208where @xmath209 is the scalar product in @xmath210 . we expand @xmath211 in terms of the standard continuous piecewise linear functions @xmath212 in the space @xmath196 as @xmath213where @xmath214 denote the nodal values of the function @xmath211 at the nodes @xmath215 of the elements @xmath184 in the mesh @xmath182 . we can determine @xmath214 by knowing already computed functions @xmath216 using the following analog of ( [ 3.104 ] ) @xmath217 , \forall \mathbf{x}\in \omega .\]]substitute ( [ 3.200 ] ) into ( [ 3.107_1 ] ) and choose @xmath218 then we obtain the following linear algebraic system of equations @xmath219 , \label{3.108}\]]where @xmath220 $ ] is the scalar product in @xmath221 the system ( [ 3.108 ] ) can be rewritten in the matrix form for the unknown vector @xmath222 and known vector @xmath223 as @xmath224here @xmath225 is the block mass matrix in space , @xmath226 is the stiffness matrix corresponding to the term containing @xmath227 in ( [ 3.108 ] ) and @xmath228 is the load vector . at the element @xmath184 the matrix entries in ( [ 3.108_1 ] ) are explicitly given by : @xmath229 to obtain an explicit scheme for the computation of coefficients @xmath205 , we approximate the matrix @xmath225 by the lumped mass matrix @xmath230 in space , i.e. , the diagonal approximation is obtained by taking the row sum of @xmath225 @xcite . we obtain @xmath231note that for the case of linear lagrange elements which are used in our computations in section [ sec:8 ] we have @xmath232 . thus , the lumping procedure does not include approximation errors in this case . we present now our algorithm for the numerical solution of equations ( 4.21 ) and computing the functions @xmath205 using the equation([3.109 ] ) . in this algorithm the index @xmath233 denotes the number of inner iterations inside every pseudo - frequency interval @xmath234 when we update tails . step 0 : : set @xmath235 . compute the initial tail function @xmath236 as in ( 2.923)-([2.925 ] ) . step 1 : : here we describe iterations which update tails inside every pseudo - frequency interval @xmath155 . let @xmath237 suppose that functions @xmath238 are computed . solve the dirichlet boundary value problem for the function @xmath239 @xmath240 step 2 : : compute functions @xmath241 and @xmath242 @xmath243@xmath244 .\ ] ] step 3 : : compute the function @xmath245 via backwards calculations , using the finite element formulation of equation ( [ 3.109 ] ) as @xmath246since by ( [ 2.20 ] ) we should have @xmath247 and also since we need to extend the function @xmath248 outside of the domain @xmath2 by unity , we set @xmath249 step 4 : : solve the forward problem ( [ 2.1])-([2.2 ] ) with @xmath250 and compute the laplace transform ( [ 2.6 ] ) for @xmath251 . we obtain the function @xmath252 . step 5 : : update the tail function as@xmath253continue inner iterations with respect to @xmath233 until the stopping criterion of step 1 of section [ sec:6.2 ] is met at @xmath254 . step 6 : : set for the pseudo - frequency interval @xmath255 @xmath256 step 7 : : if either the stopping criterion with respect to @xmath257 of step 4 of section [ sec:6.2 ] is met , or @xmath258 then set the resulting function @xmath259 as the solution of our cip . otherwise , set @xmath260 and go to step 1 . when testing the algorithm of section [ sec:6.1 ] on experimental data , we have developed a reliable stopping criterion for iterations @xmath261 in this algorithm . on every pseudo - frequency interval @xmath155 we define first norms @xmath262 as @xmath263 in ( [ first_norms ] ) the function @xmath264 is the computed tail functions at the inner iteration @xmath265 as in ( [ 7.104 ] ) . functions @xmath266 in ( [ first_norms ] ) are obtained from the known measured function @xmath26 in ( [ 2.5 ] ) as @xmath267where @xmath268 is the laplace transform of the function @xmath26 at @xmath269 . we have observed that computed first norms @xmath262 always achieve only one minimum at a certain @xmath270 , where the number @xmath271 depends on the specific set of experimental data . furthermore , in non - blind cases of non - metallic targets , the corresponding values of @xmath272 were in a good agreement with a priori known ones . however , in the cases of non - blind metallic targets we have observed that @xmath273 this contradicts with ( [ 2.51 ] ) . therefore , we have developed the following stopping criterion which consists of four steps . * the stopping criterion * the first step in our criterion is for stopping inner iterations with respect to @xmath233 in step 5 of section [ sec:6.1 ] . as to steps 2 - 4 , they are for stopping outer iterations with respect to @xmath257 ( step 7 in section [ sec:6.1 ] ) . first , we define numbers @xmath274 and @xmath275 as@xmath276@xmath277 in ( [ 7.6_1 ] ) functions @xmath278 are computed tail functions corresponding to @xmath279 ( step 6 in section [ sec:6.1 ] ) and functions @xmath280 are calculated using ( [ obstail ] ) . * * step 1 . * iterate with respect to @xmath233 and stop iterations at @xmath281 such that@xmath282or @xmath283 where @xmath284 is a chosen tolerance . * * for every @xmath257 * * * * compute final norms @xmath285 as @xmath286 in ( [ final_norms ] ) functions @xmath287 are computed as in ( [ 7.104 ] ) . * * step 3*. compute the number @xmath288 of the pseudo frequency interval such that the first norms @xmath262 in ( [ first_norms ] ) achieve its first minimum with respect to @xmath257 and get corresponding @xmath289 on this interval . compute the number @xmath290 of the pseudo frequency interval such that the final norms @xmath291 in ( [ final_norms ] ) achieve its first minimum or they are stabilized with respect to @xmath257 , and get corresponding @xmath292 on this interval . next , compute the number @xmath293 @xmath294 * * step 4*. if @xmath295 or @xmath296 then take the final reconstructed value of the refractive index @xmath297 as the computed function @xmath298 take @xmath299 and stop iterations . however , if @xmath300 then continue iterations and compute the number @xmath301 $ ] of the pseudo frequency interval such that the global minimum with respect to @xmath257 of final norms @xmath285 in ( [ final_norms ] ) is achieved . then , similarly with ( [ 7.7 ] ) , compute the number @xmath302 @xmath303and take @xmath304 as the final reconstructed value of the refractive index . also , take the function @xmath305 as the computed coefficient @xmath24 and stop iterations . we have observed in all our computations that conditions of our stopping criterion are always achieved . more precisely , one of conditions ( [ 7.5 ] ) , ( [ 7.5_1 ] ) is always achieved for iterations with respect to @xmath233 and the minimal values mentioned in steps 3 and 4 are always achieved . figure [ fig : finalnorms ] displays a typical @xmath306dependence of sequences @xmath307and @xmath308 in this section we present some additional details of our numerical implementation . because of ( [ 2.51 ] ) , we define in all our tests the upper value of the function @xmath309 as @xmath310 see ( [ 2.20 ] ) . thus , we set lower and upper bounds for the reconstructed function @xmath311 in @xmath3 as @xmath312 \}. \label{4.30}\]]as to the lower bound , we ensure it via ( [ 7.101 ] ) . we ensure the upper bound 15 similarly via truncating to 15 those values of @xmath313 which exceed this number . to solve dirichlet boundary value problems ( [ 7.102 ] ) , we use fem . we reconstruct refractive indices rather than dielectric constants of material since they can be directly measured . to compare our computational results with directly measured refractive indices @xmath314 of dielectric targets and with appearing dielectric constants of metallic targets ( see ( [ 2.51 ] ) ) , we consider maximal values of computed functions @xmath315 , @xmath316 see step 4 of section [ sec:6.2 ] for the definition of @xmath317 using experimental data for non - blind targets and comparing reconstruction results with cases of synthetic data , we have found that our algorithm provided accurate results with the following pseudo frequency interval , which we use in all our computations @xmath318,\underline{s}=8,\overline{s}=10,h=0.05.\ ] ] as it is clear from step 4 of section [ sec:6.1 ] , we need to solve the forward problem ( [ 2.1 ] ) , ( [ 2.2 ] ) on each iterative step of inner iterations to update the tail via ( [ 7.103 ] ) . since it is impossible to computationally solve equation ( [ 2.1 ] ) in the infinite space @xmath319 we work with a truncated domain . namely , we choose the domain @xmath226 as @xmath320 we use the hybrid fem / fdm method described in @xcite and the software package waves @xcite . we split @xmath226 into two subdomains @xmath321 and @xmath322 so that @xmath323 . we solve the forward problem in @xmath226 and the inverse problem via the algorithm of section [ sec:6.1 ] in @xmath324 the space mesh in @xmath325 and in @xmath322 consists of tetrahedral and cubes , respectively . below @xmath326 since by ( [ 2.20 ] ) @xmath33 in @xmath327 then it is computationally efficient to use fdm in @xmath322 and to use fem in @xmath328 as it is done in the hybrid method of @xcite . the front and back sides of the rectangular prism @xmath226 are @xmath329 and @xmath330 , respectively . the boundary of the domain @xmath226 is @xmath331 here , @xmath332 and @xmath333 are , respectively , front and back sides of the domain @xmath226 , and @xmath334 is the union of left , right , top and bottom sides of this domain . the front side @xmath22 of the rectangular prism @xmath2 where the propagated data @xmath60 in ( [ 2.5 ] ) are given , is @xmath335 now we describe the forward problem which is used in our computations . to compute tail functions @xmath336 via steps 4 , 5 of the algorithm of section [ sec:6.1 ] , we computationally solve the following forward problem in our tests : @xmath337 , \\ { n}u & = -\partial _ { t}u,~\mbox{on}~\partial _ { 1}g\times ( t_{1},t ) , \\ \partial _ { n}u & = -\partial _ { t}u,~\mbox{on}~\partial _ { 2}g\times ( 0,t ) , \\ \partial _ { n}u & = 0,~\mbox{on}~\partial _ { 3}g\times ( 0,t ) , \end{split } \label{8.2}\]]where @xmath338 is the amplitude of the initialized plane wave , @xmath339we use @xmath340 and @xmath341 we solve the problem ( [ 8.2 ] ) using the explicit scheme with the time step size @xmath342 which satisfies the cfl condition . our reconstruction procedure is done in two stages described in this section . in the first stage we follow the algorithm of section [ sec:6.1 ] . we have observed that this stage provides accurate locations of targets of interest . it also provides accurate values of refractive indices @xmath343 of dielectric targets and large values of appearing dielectric constants @xmath344 for metallic targets , see ( [ 7.7 ] ) and ( [ 7.8 ] ) . however , the algorithm of section [ sec:6.1 ] does not reconstruct well sizes / shapes of targets . thus , we need a postprocessing procedure , which is done in the second stage . let @xmath345 be the function in ( 7.101 ) . then we set @xmath346next , we determine minimal @xmath347 and maximal @xmath348 values in @xmath53 and @xmath54 directions , where the function @xmath349 next , we set@xmath350 , y\in \left [ y_{\min } , y_{\max } \right ] , \\ 1 & \text { otherwise}\end{cases}\]]and proceed with step 5 of the algorithm of section [ sec:6.1 ] . in this second stage we perform the same number of iterations with respect to both indices @xmath351 as ones of the first stage . we are concerned in the second stage only with sized and shapes of targets , and we are not concerned with values of @xmath352 rather , we take these values from the first stage . let @xmath353 be the function @xmath24 obtained at the last iteration of the second stage . then we form the image of the target based on the function @xmath354@xmath355 .__object names . _ _ [ cols="^,<,<",options="header " , ] we collected experimental backscattering time resolved data of electrical wave propagation and have applied the approximately globally convergent numerical method of @xcite to these data . results for four non - blind and seven blind cases show a good accuracy of reconstruction of refractive indices of dielectric targets and appearing dielectric constants of metallic targets . in the case of dielectrics , the average reconstruction error is at least three times less than the error of direct measurements . we confidently differentiate between metallic and dielectric targets . in particular , we have accurately computed maximal values of refractive indices / dielectric constants of three blind heterogeneous targets . these targets represent simplified models of improvised explosive devices ieds , which are heterogeneous ones . locations of targets and their sizes in @xmath356 directions are accurately reconstructed . the most difficult cases of sizes in the @xmath46direction ( depth ) are well reconstructed in some cases . in addition , shapes of some targets are well reconstructed in some cases . we believe that a follow up application of the locally convergent adaptivity technique might improve reconstructions of shapes of targets . the adaptivity takes the solution obtained by the approximately globally convergent method as the starting point for the minimization of the tikhonov functional on a sequence of adaptively refined meshes . a significant refinement via the adaptivity was demonstrated in section 5.9 of @xcite for the case of transmitted experimental data , see figures 5.13 and 5.16 in @xcite . this research was supported by us army research laboratory and us army research office grants w911nf-11 - 1 - 0325 and w911nf-11 - 1 - 0399 , the swedish research council , the swedish foundation for strategic research ( ssf ) through the gothenburg mathematical modelling centre ( gmmc ) and by the swedish institute , visby program . the authors are grateful to mr . steven kitchin for his excellent work on data collection . l. beilina , k. samuelsson and k. ahlander , efficiency of a hybrid method for the wave equation . in _ international conference on finite element methods _ , gakuto international series mathematical sciences and applications , gakkotosho co. , ltd , 2001 . l. beilina and m.v . klibanov , a new approximate mathematical model for global convergence for a coefficient inverse problem with backscattering data , _ j. inverse and ill - posed problems _ , 20 , 513 - 565 , 2012 . l. beilina , energy estimates and numerical verification of the stabilized domain decomposition finite element / finite difference approach for the maxwell s system in time domain , _ central european journal of mathematics _ , 11 , 702 - 733 , 2013 . kuzhuget , l. beilina , m.v . klibanov , a. sullivan , l. nguyen and m.a . fiddy , blind experimental data collected in the field and an approximately globally convergent inverse algorithm , _ inverse problems _ , 28 , 095007 , 2012 . n. t. thnh , l. beilina , m. v. klibanov , and m. a. fiddy . reconstruction of the refractive index from experimental backscattering data using a globally convergent inverse method , preprint , arxiv:1306.3150 [ math - ph ] , 2013 .
Abstract: | [
"we consider the problem of reconstruction of dielectrics from blind backscattered experimental data . experimental data were collected by a device , which was built at university of north carolina at charlotte . this device sends electrical pulses into the medium and collects the time resolved backscattered data on a part of a plane . the spatially distributed dielectric constant @xmath0 is the unknown coefficient of a wave - like pde . this coefficient is reconstructed from those data in blind cases . to do this , a globally convergent numerical method is used . * keywords * : coefficient inverse problem ( cip ) , finite element method , globally convergent numerical method for cip , experimental backscattered data . * ams classification codes : * 65n15 , 65n30 , 35j25 ."
] | 7,879 | 7,879 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: recent advances in atom de broglie waveguide technology @xcite and its potential applicability to atom interferometry @xcite and integrated atom optics @xcite create a need for accurate theoretical modelling of such systems in the low temperature , tight waveguide regime where transverse excitations are frozen out and the quantum dynamics becomes essentially one - dimensional ( 1d ) ( tonks - gas limit ) . it has been shown by olshanii @xcite , and also recently by petrov et al . @xcite , that at sufficiently low temperatures and densities , high transverse frequencies @xmath0 , and large positive scattering length , where thermal and longitudinal zero - point energies are small compared with @xmath1 , a bose - einstein condensate ( bec ) in a thin cigar - shaped trap has dynamics which reduce to those of a 1d gas of hard core , or impenetrable , point bosons . this is a model for which the exact many - body energy eigensolutions were found in 1960 using an exact mapping from the hilbert space of energy eigenstates of an _ ideal _ gas of spinless fermions to that of many - body eigenstates of hard core , and therefore _ strongly interacting _ , bosons @xcite . in this limit there are strong short - range pair correlations which are omitted in the gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) approximation , which assumes that all @xmath2 bosons occupy the same orbital ( complete bec , condensed fraction unity ) . in the absence of a trap potential it is known @xcite that the occupation of the lowest orbital is of order @xmath3 where @xmath2 is the total number of atoms , in contrast to @xmath2 for the ideal bose gas as well as the gp approximation . nevertheless , this system exhibits some bec - like behavior such as talbot recurrences following an optical lattice pulse @xcite and dark soliton - like behavior in response to a phase - imprinting pulse @xcite . the case of harmonically trapped , hard core bosons in 1d is more relevant to recent atom waveguide experiments @xcite . the spatial profile of the single - particle density is expressible in closed form , and has recently been shown @xcite to be well approximated by a modified 1d effective field theory , although we have recently shown in a numerically accurate time - dependent calculation @xcite that spatial interference fringes of separated and recombined condensates in the exact many - body solution are much weaker than those predicted by the corresponding time - dependent mean field theory @xcite . although the fermi - bose mapping theorem @xcite implies that all physical properties expressible in terms of spatial configurational probabilities are the same for the actual bosonic system and the fictitious spinless fermion " system used for the mapping , the momentum distribution of the bosonic system , or more generally its occupation distribution over the relevant orbitals for a given geometry , is very different in the bosonic system . it is known @xcite that for a spatially uniform system of hard core bosons in 1d , the momentum distribution is strongly peaked in the neighborhood of zero momentum , whereas that of the corresponding fermi system is merely a filled fermi sea . in the case of hard core bosons in a 1d harmonic trap , it has been an interesting question whether the system undergoes true bec or merely an attenuated one such as that in the uniform system . ketterle and van druten @xcite have shown that true bec occurs for a finite number of atoms in a 1d harmonic oscillator ( ho ) in the case of an _ ideal _ gas , but the behavior turns out to be different for the exact many - body solutions in the tonks ( 1d ) limit . the most fundamental definition of bec and the condensate orbital is based on the large distance behavior of the one - particle reduced density matrix @xmath4 . if off - diagonal long - range order ( odlro ) is present and hence the largest eigenvalue of @xmath5 is macroscopic ( proportional to @xmath2 ) then the system is said to exhibit true bec and the corresponding eigenfunction , the condensate orbital , plays the role of an order parameter @xcite . although the precise definition of odlro requires a thermodynamic limit not strictly applicable to mesoscopic traps , the gp approximation assumes from the start that odlro and macroscopic occupation of a single orbital are good approximations in a trap , so examination of this assumption is important . we have recently @xcite used the fermi - bose mapping theorem to determine , for this case of 1d impenetrable bosons in a harmonic trap , the exact many - body ground state and its salient features , including the one - particle reduced density matrix and its eigenvalues ( occupation number distribution function ) and eigenfunctions ( natural orbitals ) , as well as the momentum distribution function . we find that the largest eigenvalue of the one - particle density matrix is proportional to lower than the first power of @xmath2 , as is the momentum distribution function at @xmath6 , so that the tonks gas does not show true bec . in this paper we give an overview of our recent work on exact many - body quantum solutions for 1d tonks gases . in particular , secs . ii and iii describe the ground state and dynamic properties of tonks gases , respectively . for the most part we investigate 1d tonks gases assuming the conditions are satisfied for realizing them . in sec . iv we examine the use of bessel optical dipole traps for experimental realization of 1d tonks gases . we first describe the fermi - bose mapping method for obtaining exact solutions of the time - independent many - body schrdinger equation in the tonks limit ( impenetrable point bosons ) and its application to the spatially uniform case ( no trap potential ) . this description is very brief and the original literature @xcite should be consulted for details . some salient features of the recent generalization to the harmonically trapped tonks gas @xcite are then described . our basic model consists of @xmath2 bosonic atoms at zero temperature moving in 1d ( @xmath7 ) , the quantum motion in the other two spatial dimensions having been frozen out by tight transverse confinement via an atomic waveguide . the schrdinger hamiltonian is then assumed to have the structure : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the one - dimensional position of the @xmath10 particle ( atom ) and @xmath11 is symmetric ( invariant ) under permutations of the particles . the two - particle interaction potential is assumed to contain a hard core of 1d diameter @xmath12 . this is conveniently treated as a constraint on allowed wave functions @xmath13 : @xmath14 rather than as an infinite contribution to @xmath11 , which then consists of all other ( finite ) interactions and external potentials . let @xmath15 be a fermionic solution of @xmath16 which is antisymmetric under all particle pair exchanges @xmath17 , hence all permutations . one can consider @xmath18 to be either the wave function of a fictitious system of `` spinless fermions '' , or else that of a system of real fermions whose spins are all aligned , as in magnetically trapped atomic vapor becs . define a unit antisymmetric function " @xcite @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the algebraic sign of the coordinate difference @xmath21 , i.e. , it is + 1(-1 ) if @xmath22(@xmath23 ) . for given antisymmetric @xmath18 , define a bosonic wave function @xmath24 by @xmath25 which defines the fermi - bose mapping . @xmath24 satisfies the hard core constraint ( 2 ) if @xmath18 does , is totally symmetric ( bosonic ) under permutations , obeys the same boundary conditions as @xmath18 , and @xmath26 follows from @xmath27 @xcite . in the case of periodic boundary conditions ( no trap potential , spatially uniform system ) one must add the proviso that the boundary conditions are only preserved under the mapping if @xmath2 is odd , but the case of even @xmath2 is easily accomodated by imposing periodic boundary conditions on @xmath18 but _ anti_periodic boundary conditions on @xmath24 . for a trapped system the boundary condition that wave functions vanish at infinity is preserved for all @xmath2 . the mapping theorem leads to explicit expressions for all many - body energy eigenstates and eigenvalues of a 1d scalar condensate ( bosons all of the same spin ) under the assumption that the only two - particle interaction is a zero - range hard core repulsion , represented by the @xmath28 limit of the hard - core constraint . such solutions were obtained in sec . 3 of the original work @xcite for periodic boundary conditions and no external potential . such a situation could be realized experimentally , for example , by trapping the tonks gas around the peak of an tight toroidal optical dipole trap formed using a red - detuned laguerre - gaussian laser beam @xcite . in a system of 1d bosons with a hard - sphere interaction of diameter @xmath12 , it is sufficient at low densities @xcite to consider the case of impenetrable point particles , the zero - range limit @xmath28 . since wave functions of spinless fermions " are antisymmetric under coordinate exchanges , their wave functions vanish automatically whenever any @xmath29 , the constraint has no effect , and the corresponding fermionic ground state is the ground state of the _ ideal _ gas of fermions , a slater determinant of the lowest @xmath2 single - particle plane - wave orbitals . the exact many body ground state was found to be a pair product of bijl - jastrow form @xmath30| , \ ] ] where @xmath31 is the perimeter of the annular trap . in spite of the very long range of the individual pair correlation factors @xmath32|$ ] , the pair distribution function @xmath33 , which is physically the joint probability density that if one particle is found at @xmath34 a second will be found at @xmath9 , was found to be of short range @xmath35 with @xmath36 the linear number density of the system . clearly , @xmath37 which reflects the hard core nature of the two - particle interaction . by examination of the excited states the system was also found to support propagation of sound with speed @xmath38 @xcite . here we briefly review our recently - obtained exact solution for the many - body ground state of a harmonically trapped tonks gas @xcite . the hamiltonian of n bosons in a 1d harmonic trap is @xmath39 .\ ] ] we again assume that the two - body interaction potential consists only of a hard core of negligible diameter @xmath40 . it follows from the mapping theorem that the exact n - boson ground state @xmath41 is @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the ground state of a fictitious system of @xmath2 spinless fermions with the same hamiltonian and constraint . since the hard - core interaction has no effect in the zero - range limit for fermions , whose wave functions already vanish at contact due to antisymmetry , it follows that the fermionic ground state is a slater determinant of the lowest @xmath2 single - particle eigenfunctions @xmath44 of the harmonic oscillator ( ho ) : @xmath45 the ho orbitals are @xmath46 with @xmath47 the hermite polynomials and @xmath48 being the ground state width of the harmonic trap for a single atom . by factoring the gaussians out of the determinant and carrying out elementary row and column operations , one can cancel all terms in each @xmath49 except the one of highest degree , with the result @xcite @xmath50 substitution into ( 6 ) then yields a simple but exact analytical expression of bijl - jastrow pair product form for the @xmath2-boson ground state : @xmath51 \prod_{1\le j < k\le n}|x_{k}-x_{j}|\ ] ] with @xmath52 and normalization constant @xmath53^{-1/2 } .\ ] ] it is interesting to note the strong similarity between this exact 1d @xmath2-boson wave function and the famous laughlin variational wave function of the 2d ground state for the quantized fractional hall effect @xcite , as well as the closely - related wave functions for bosons with weak repulsive delta - function interactions in a harmonic trap in 2d found recently by smith and wilkin @xcite . both the single particle density and pair distribution function depend only on the absolute square of the many - body wave function , and since @xmath54 they reduce to standard ideal fermi gas expressions . the single particle density , normalized to @xmath2 , is @xmath55 we shall not exhibit it here since it has recently been calculated by kolomeisky _ _ @xcite ; see also our recent discussion of the time - dependent case @xcite . the pair distribution function , normalized to @xmath56 , is @xmath57 noting that terms with @xmath58 , which vanish by antisymmetry , can be formally added to the summation ( 13 ) , one can write @xmath59 although the hermite polynomials have disappeared from the expression ( 10 ) for the many - body wave function , they reappear upon integrating @xmath60 over @xmath61 coordinates to get the single particle density @xmath62 and over @xmath63 to get the pair distribution function @xmath64 , and the expressions in terms of the ho orbitals @xmath65 are the most convenient for evaluation . figure [ fig : one ] shows a gray scale plot of the dimensionless pair distribution function @xmath66 versus the normalized coordinates @xmath67 for a ) @xmath68 , b ) @xmath69 , and c ) @xmath70 . some qualitative features of the pair distribution function are apparent : in the first place it follows either from the original expression ( 12 ) or from eq . ( 14 ) that @xmath71 vanishes at contact @xmath72 , as it must because of impenetrability of the particles , and we see this to be true in fig . [ fig : one ] . furthermore , the correlation term @xmath73 is a truncated closure sum and approaches the dirac delta function @xmath74 as @xmath75 , as is to be expected since the healing length in a spatially uniform 1d hard core bose gas varies inversely with particle number @xcite . as a result the width of the null around the diagonal @xmath76 decreases with increasing @xmath2 , and vanishes in the limit . away from the diagonal along @xmath77 the pair distribution function rises , exhibits modulations for @xmath78 , due to the oscillatory nature of the ho orbitals , before decreasing back to zero at large distances . for @xmath79 much larger than the healing length , @xmath80 reduces to the uncorrelated density product @xmath81 , so the spatial extent of the pair distribution function is that of the density and varies as @xmath82 @xcite . the reduced single - particle density matrix with normalization @xmath83 is @xmath84 although this multi - dimensional integral can not be evaluated analytically , it can be evaluated numerically by monte carlo integration for not too large values of @xmath2 ( the computing time scales as @xmath85 ) . figure [ fig : two ] shows a gray scale plot of the dimensionless reduced single - particle density matrix @xmath86 versus the normalized coordinates @xmath87 and @xmath88 for a ) @xmath68 , b ) @xmath69 , and c ) @xmath70 . along the diagonal @xmath89 reproduces the single - particle density @xcite . the off - diagonal elements relate to odlro , and it is clear that as @xmath2 increases the off - diagonal elements are decreasing , in contrast with the diagonal . this is an indication that odlro vanishes for a system of hard core bosons in a 1d ho in the thermodynamic limit , although at present only numerical evidence exists , there being no analytical proof generalizing the result of lenard for the untrapped tonks gas @xcite . in a macroscopic system , the presence or absence of bec is determined by the behavior of @xmath4 as @xmath90 . off - diagonal long - range order is present if the largest eigenvalue of @xmath5 is macroscopic ( proportional to @xmath2 ) , in which case the system exhibits bec and the corresponding eigenfunction , the condensate orbital , plays the role of an order parameter @xcite . although this criterion is not strictly applicable to mesoscopic systems , if the largest eigenvalue of @xmath5 is much larger than one then it is reasonable to expect that the system will exhibit some bec - like coherence effects . thus we examine here the spectrum of eigenvalues @xmath91 and associated eigenfunctions @xmath92 ( `` natural orbitals '' ) of @xmath5 . although natural orbitals are a much - used tool in theoretical chemistry , they have only recently been applied to mesoscopic atomic condensates @xcite . the relevant eigensystem equation is @xmath93 @xmath91 represents the occupation of the orbital @xmath94 , and one has @xmath95 . numerical evaluation of the integral by discretization yields a matrix eigensystem equation giving accurate numerical results for the largest eigenvalues and associated eigenvectors . we remark that for the corresponding problem of @xmath2 free fermions in a 1d ho , in which case @xmath96 is evaluated using the fermion wave function @xmath97 , the natural orbitals are simply the ho orbitals , and @xmath98 , all higher eigenvalues being zero ( filled fermi sea ) . however , the n - boson wave function is the modulus of the fermion wave function , and this leads to significant differences in the spectrum of natural orbitals and eigenvalues for the hard core bose gas . in fig . [ fig : three](a ) we show a log - log plot of the fractional occupation of the lowest orbital @xmath99 versus the total particle number @xmath2 ( solid line ) , along with a best fit power - law @xmath100 ( dashed line ) . this is to be contrasted with the case of a spatially uniform system of hard core bosons for which @xmath101 @xcite . in both cases the fractional occupation decreases with increasing @xmath2 , and thus does not correspond to a true condensate for which @xmath102 . nevertheless , the occupation of the lowest orbital may still be large , @xmath103 , and is larger than the spatially uniform case @xmath104 , so macroscopic quantum coherence effects reminiscent of bec can still result @xcite . figure [ fig : three](b ) shows the distribution of occupations @xmath91 versus orbital number @xmath105 ( the orbitals are ordered according to eigenvalue magnitude , the largest eigenvalue being @xmath106 ) for @xmath68 ( circles ) , @xmath69 ( stars ) , and @xmath70 ( squares ) . this figure shows that as the lowest orbital occupation @xmath107 increases with increasing @xmath2 so does the range of significantly occupied higher - order orbitals with @xmath108 . this means that the dominance of the lowest orbital decreases with increasing @xmath2 , so singling out @xmath109 as a macroscopic wave function for the whole system becomes more problematic with increasing @xmath2 @xcite . next we examine the momentum distribution for the trapped 1d tonks gas . for a spatially uniform system ( no trap ) the natural orbitals are plane waves , so the occupation distribution of the natural orbitals is the same as the momentum distribution . although this is not the case here due to the effect of the harmonic trap potential , the momentum distribution is still physically important . in terms of the boson annihilation and creation operators in position representation ( quantized bose field operators ) the one - particle reduced density matrix is @xmath110 the momentum distribution function @xmath111 , normalized to @xmath112 , is @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the annihilation operator for a boson with momentum @xmath115 . then @xmath116 the spectral representation of the density matrix then leads to @xmath117 where the @xmath118 are fourier transforms of the natural orbitals : @xmath119 . figure [ fig : four ] shows the numerically calculated dimensionless momentum spectrum @xmath120 versus normalized momentum @xmath121 , with @xmath122 , for a ) @xmath68 , b ) @xmath69 , and c ) @xmath70 . the key features are that the momentum spectrum maintains the sharp peaked structure reminiscent of the spatially uniform case @xcite for the 1d ho , and that the peak becomes sharper with increasing atom number @xmath2 . this is to be expected since as the number of atoms increase the many - body repulsion causes the system to become more spatially uniform within the trap interior . by way of contrast , for a 1d fermi gas the corresponding momentum spectrum is a filled fermi - sea , here rounded out by the trapping potential . in particular , the momentum distribution for the 1d trapped fermi gas can be expressed as @xmath123 thus , the momentum spectrum provides a means of distinguishing between the 1d fermi and tonks gases . figure [ fig : five ] shows an example of the tonks ( dashed line ) and fermi gas ( solid line ) momentum spectra for @xmath70 atoms in a harmonic trap , and the difference is clearly seen . furthermore , the distinction only grows larger with increasing number of atoms , as the filled fermi - sea broadens whereas the tonks spectrum becomes narrower . in a recent paper we have devised a scheme to measure the momentum spectrum of trapped gases based on raman outcoupling , and we refer the reader to our paper for details @xcite . the fermi - bose mapping theorem is very easily generalized so as to yield exact solutions of the time - dependent many - body schrdinger equation ( tdmbse ) by noting that since the mapping function @xmath124 of eq . ( 3 ) is independent of time , one can merely replace @xmath125 by @xmath126 , implying that the relationship of eq . ( 4 ) , with time arguments added to the bose and fermi wave functions , is valid for solutions of the tdmbse . in the special case where the only interatomic interaction is that of hard cores of vanishing diameter , but external potentials including a trap potential as well as time - dependent fields may be present , the many - fermion solutions of the tdmbse are slater determinants of solutions of the _ single particle _ tdse in the given external potential , and each many - boson solution is obtained by multiplying the corresponding determinant by the mapping function @xmath124 . some salient features of our recently - obtained dynamical solutions for solitons in a ring geometry and for interference effects in a dynamically split , harmonically trapped tonks gas will be described . the description will again be brief since details are available in the literature @xcite . dark and gray solitons are a generic feature of the nonlinear schrdinger equation with repulsive interactions , and several calculations of their dynamics based on the mean - field gross - pitaevskii ( gp ) equation have appeared @xcite , as well as experiments demonstrating their existence in atomic becs @xcite . since the underlying _ many - body _ schrdinger equation is linear , this raises the question of how observed solitonic behavior arises . here this issue will be examined with the aid of exact many - body solutions for the tonks gas . the model consists of a 1d hard - core bose gas in a toroidal trap , or ring , with cross section so small that motion is essentially circumferencial . the fermi - bose mapping is employed to generate exact solutions for this problem . we identify stationary solutions which reflect some properties of dark solitons from the gp theory when the ring is pierced at a point by an intense blue - detuned laser . we also present dynamical solutions when half of an initially homogeneous ring bec is phase - imprinted via the light - shift potential of an applied laser , leading to gray soliton - like structures whose velocity depends on the imposed phase - shift @xcite . such structures are apparent for times less than the echo time @xmath127 , with @xmath31 the ring circumference and @xmath128 the speed of sound in the bec . on longer time scales the dynamics becomes very complex showing talbot recurrences which are beyond the gp theory . consider @xmath2 bosons in a tight toroidal trap , for example a toroidal optical dipole potential @xcite , and denote their 1d positions measured around the circumference by @xmath9 . this is equivalent to the exactly - solved model @xcite of @xmath2 impenetrable point bosons in 1d with wave functions satisfying periodic boundary conditions with period @xmath31 equal to the torus circumference , and the fundamental periodicity cell may be chosen as @xmath129 . however , the rotationally invariant quantum states of this problem do not reveal any dark soliton - like structures . to proceed we therefore consider the case that a blue - detuned laser field pierces the ring at @xmath130 by virtue of the associated repulsive dipole force : the light sheet then provides a reference position for the null of the dark soliton . assume that the light sheet is so intense and narrow that it may be replaced by a constraint that the many - body wave function ( hence the orbitals @xmath131 ) must vanish whenever any @xmath132 . then the appropriate orbitals @xmath133 are free - particle energy eigenstates vanishing at @xmath130 and periodic with period @xmath31 . the complete orthonormal set of even - parity eigenstates @xmath134 and odd - parity eigenstates @xmath135 are @xmath136 , \nonumber\\ \phi_{n}^{(-)}(x ) & = & \sqrt{2/l}\sin(2n\pi x / l ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath137 running from @xmath138 to @xmath139 . the odd eigenstates are the same as those of free particles with no @xmath130 constraint , since these already vanish at @xmath130 . however , the even ones are strongly affected by the constraint , their cusp at @xmath130 being a result of the impenetrable light sheet at that point . if one bends a 1d box @xmath140 with impenetrable walls into a ring , identifying the walls at @xmath141 , then those particle - in - a - box eigenfunctions which are even about the box center become identical with the @xmath134 , and their cusp results from the nonzero slope of these functions at the walls . the @xmath2-fermion ground state is obtained by inserting the lowest @xmath2 of these orbitals into a slater determinant ( filled fermi sea ) . since @xmath142 , the one - particle density @xmath62 of the corresponding many - boson ground state given by eq . ( 4 ) is the same as that of the @xmath2-fermion ground state . in the thermodynamic limit @xmath75 , @xmath143 , @xmath144 for fixed @xmath7 , @xmath145 , one finds @xcite @xmath146 .\ ] ] @xmath62 vanishes at @xmath130 and approaches the mean density @xmath147 over a healing length @xmath148 with damped spatial oscillations about its limiting value . suppose next that the light - sheet is turned off at @xmath149 by removing the constraint that the wave function vanish at @xmath130 . the solution of the tdmbsb for the many - boson system is then still given by the mapping theorem , but the slater determinant representing the corresponding many - fermion state has to be built from solutions of the time - dependent single - particle schrdinger equation satisfying the initial conditions of eq . ( [ lightsheet ] ) . the odd - parity solutions are stationary in time since they already vanish at the position of the light sheet . the even - parity solutions are nontrivial , but are expressible as sums over the space - periodic , even - parity solutions of the time - independent free - particle schrdinger equation @xcite : @xmath150 where @xmath151 and @xmath152 . the time - dependent density @xmath153 is then the sum of absolute squares of all @xmath2 orbitals in the fermi sea . it is found @xcite that there are two important time scales : one is the poincar recurrence time @xmath154 . noting that @xmath155 is proportional to @xmath156 , one finds that all terms in the sum are time - periodic with period @xmath157 , which is therefore the recurrence time for the density and in fact all properties of our model @xcite . the other important time is the echo time @xmath158 , the time for sound to make one circuit around the torus . recalling that the speed of sound in this system is @xmath38 @xcite , one finds @xmath159 . for @xmath160 after the constraint is removed , the initial density develops sound waves that propagate around the ring , and that we examine below in the context of phase - imprinting . for @xmath161 the evolution is very complex , but complete recurrences occur for times @xmath162 with fractional revivals in between . suppose next that the toroidal impenetrable point bose gas is in its ground state for times @xmath163 ( no light sheet obstacle in this case ) , and a phase - imprinting laser pulse is applied as a delta - function pulse over half the ring at @xmath149 . this is described by the hamiltonian @xmath164\ ] ] where @xmath165 , i.e. , unity for @xmath166 and zero elsewhere . this is the technique used in recent experiments @xcite , here idealized to a delta - function in time and to sharp spatial edges . before the pulse the most convenient free - particle orbitals in ( 5 ) are plane waves @xmath167 where @xmath168 and @xmath169 with @xmath170 . let @xmath171 be the solution of the corresponding single - particle tdse reducing to the above @xmath172 just before the pulse . then the solutions just after the pulse are @xmath173 . the potential gradients at the pulse edges impart momentum kicks to the particles there which induce both compressional waves propagating at the speed , @xmath128 , of sound and density dips ( gray solitons ) moving at speeds @xmath174 . the expansion of @xmath171 in terms of the unperturbed plane waves is evaluated as @xmath175 and the time - dependent density is the sum of the absolute squares of the lowest @xmath2 of these . figure [ fig : six ] shows numerical simulations for @xmath176 , @xmath177 , and @xmath178 ( solid line ) , and @xmath179 ( dashed line ) : due to symmetry we show only half of the ring @xmath180 , the phase shift being imposed at @xmath181 . considering times short compared to the echo time means that the corresponding results are not very sensitive to the periodic boundary conditions , and also therefore apply to a linear geometry . the initial density profile is flat with a value @xmath182 . for both phase shifts two distinct maxima are seen , which travel at close to the speed of sound @xmath128 , and two distinct minima , which are analogous to gray solitons and travel at velocities @xmath183 . in addition , there are also high wavevector oscillations which radiate at velocities greater than @xmath128 , analogous to precursors in electromagnetic wave propagation in a medium . in the case of a phase shift @xmath178 , the density is symmetric about @xmath181 , whereas for a phase - shift other than a multiple of @xmath184 the evolution is not symmetric , see the dashed line where the global minimum moves to the right in reponse to the phase shift . in fig . [ fig : seven ] we plot the calculated velocity of the global density minimum relative to the speed of sound for a variety of phase shifts @xmath185 . the basic trend is that larger phase - shift means lower velocity , in qualitative agreement with recent experiments @xcite , but there is a sharp velocity peak at @xmath186 : this peak results from the cross - over between two local minima in the density . these general features , the generation of gray solitons and density waves , agree with those of the gp theory , but here arise out of the exact many - body calculation . a detailed comparison between our results and current experiments is not possible as they do not conform to the conditions for a 1d system . however , some estimates are in order to set the appropriate time scales : if we consider @xmath187rb with a ring of circumference @xmath188 @xmath189 m , and a high transverse trapping frequency @xmath190 hz , then we are limited to atom numbers @xmath191 @xcite , so these are small condensates . we then obtain @xmath192 s , and @xmath193 ms for @xmath176 . finally , we remark that since our approach relied on the mapping between the strongly - interacting bose system and a non - interacting spinless fermi gas " model , this suggests that dark and gray solitons should also manifest themselves in the density for the 1d fermi system . although real fermions have spin , the interactions used here to generate solitons were spin - independent . mean - field theory ( mft ) has proven remarkably successful at predicting both the static and dynamic behavior of bose - einstein condensates ( becs ) in weakly - interacting atomic vapors @xcite , including the ground state properties @xcite , the spectrum of collective excitations @xcite , four - wave mixing @xcite , matter - wave solitons @xcite , and interference between becs @xcite . the basic notion underlying mft is of a macroscopic wave function @xcite , or order parameter , which defines the spatial mode into which a significant fraction of the atoms condense below the critical temperature . the macroscopic wave function typically obeys a nonlinear schrdinger equation ( nlse ) , the gross - pitaevskii equation , and is most suitable for dilute bose gases . however , the success of mft is not assured in all cases . for example , in one - dimension ( 1d ) a spatially homogeneous ideal gas in its many - body ground state exhibits complete bec into the lowest single - particle state , but no bec at any nonzero temperature . furthermore , previous exact analysis @xcite of a spatially uniform tonks gas by one of us ( mg ) and its extension by lenard @xcite and vaidya and tracey @xcite have shown that in the many - body ground state the occupation of the lowest single - particle state is of order @xmath3 where @xmath2 is the total number of atoms , in contrast to @xmath2 for usual bec , and similar behavior , but with a slightly larger exponent , occurs in the harmonically trapped tonks gas @xcite . we have recently shown that mean - field theory breaks down in the analysis of the dynamics of 1d atom clouds , in that it predicts interference effects that are absent in the exact theory @xcite . _ @xcite have proposed a nonlinear schrdinger equation ( nlse ) with a quartic nonlinearity to extend the usual mean - field theory for 1d atom clouds . for a harmonic trap the ground - state density profiles from their theory show excellent agreement with the exact many - body results ( see fig . 1 of their paper ) . the key question , then , is whether this extended nlse can be used in all circumstances . to address this issue we examine the problem of a 1d atomic cloud in the ground state of a harmonic trap that is split by a blue - detuned laser and recombined , both using an exact many - body treatment based on the fermi - bose mapping and the approximate nlse : the nlse predicts interference whereas the exact analysis does not . consider a tonks gas which is initially in its @xmath2-body ground state in a harmonic trap @xcite . a central gaussian repulsive potential simulating a blue - detuned laser field is turned on quasi - adiabatically at time @xmath149 to split the initial state . after some time @xmath194 both the harmonic trap and repulsive potential are turned off and the two split components allowed to recombine : this is an interference experiment of the cool , cut , interfere variety previously discussed @xcite . the external potential is taken of the specific form @xmath195 and @xmath196 for @xmath197 . figure [ fig : eight ] shows an illustrative example for @xmath70 with a repulsive potential of height @xmath198 , and width @xmath199 , with @xmath200 the ground state harmonic oscillator width , and @xmath201 . this figure shows a gray scale plot of the single - particle density @xmath202 of the @xmath2-boson system as functions of @xmath203 ( horizonatal axis ) and position @xmath204 ( vertical axis ) , with white being the highest density . the potential height was chosen such that @xmath205 , where @xmath189 is the chemical potential of the @xmath2-particle oscillator ground state @xcite , noting that the top of the @xmath2-particle fermi sea is at @xmath206 . as expected , as the repulsive potential turns on it splits the initial ground state into two separated components . upon release at @xmath207 the two components expand and subsequently recombine . what is noteworthy is that although there is some modulation upon recombination there are no strong interference fringes indicative of the interference provisionally expected for bosons : this was a generic finding from our simulations irrespective of the time scale on which the repulsive potential was turned on @xcite . in contrast , the density @xmath208 for each individual orbital @xmath209 can show strong fringes , but with a different period in each case . thus , the minimal inteference is a result of washing out of the individual interferences by summing over n orbitals . thus , the remnant of any interference fringes decreases with increasing @xmath2 and vanishes in the thermodynamic limit . physically , it makes sense that the interference fringes are all but absent since the fermi - bose mapping shows that in this 1d limit the system of bosons acts effectively like a system of free fermions insofar as effects expressible only in terms of @xmath210 are concerned , so interference is not expected @xcite . the lack of interference is therefore a signature of the fermi - bose duality that occurs in 1d systems of impenetrable particles @xcite . we next turn to the mean - field description proposed by kolomeisky _ @xcite for low - dimensional systems . in particular , they introduce an order parameter @xmath211 , normalized to the number of particles @xmath2 , for such systems . using energy functional arguments they deduce the following nlse with quartic nonlinearity for a 1d system of impenetrable bosons : @xmath212\phi .\ ] ] our goal is to compare the predictions of this nlse for the same cool , cut , interfere simulation in figure [ fig : eight ] , with the initial condition @xmath213 corresponding to the exact many - body solution , all other parameters being equal . figure [ fig : nine ] shows the corresponding gray - scale plot of the density @xmath214 , and two features are apparent : first , during the splitting phase when the repulsive potential is on there is very good overall agreement between the exact many - body theory and the nlse prediction . second , when the split components are released and recombine they produce pronounced interference fringes , in contrast to the exact theory . indeed , this interference in the mft is to be expected on the basis of previous theoretical work @xcite , even though a quartic ( rather than quadratic ) nonlinearity is employed here . thus the mft can not accurately capture the time - dependent dynamics in all situations . so far we have assumed that conditions are satisfied for the tonks limit . however , previous analysis by olshanii @xcite and petrov et al . @xcite show that there are stringent requirements on the temperature , transverse confinement , and linear atom number density to approach the tonks limit . clearly , what is needed first of all it to create a thin cigar shaped atomic trap so that the transverse mode becomes frozen and the atomic motion becomes essentially 1d . recent experimental developments suggest that tonks gases may be realizable in magnetic atom waveguides @xcite , and bongs et al . @xcite have proposed a hybrid trap composed of optical dipole trap formed with a first - order lg beam combined with magnetic longitudinal trapping . here we examine the use of bessel optical dipole traps as an all - optical means to realize 1d tonks gases . ideal bessel beams are solutions of the free - space wave equation which propagate with unchanging beam profile along the propagation axis which we take as @xmath7 in cylindrical coordinates @xmath215 . the electric field of a monochromatic , linearly polarized ideal bessel beam of order @xmath216 and frequency @xmath217 is @xcite @xmath218 where @xmath219 is a scale electric field value , @xmath220 is the @xmath216th order bessel function , @xmath221 is the azimuthal mode number which we take as positive for simplicity in notation , and @xmath222 and @xmath223 are the radial and longitudinal wavevectors such that @xmath224 with @xmath225 . the zeroth - order solution @xmath226 has a central maximum surrounded by concentric rings of roughly equal power while the higher - order solutions @xmath220 have zero on - axis intensity also with concentric rings . the ultility of bessel beams for optical dipole traps lies in the fact that they can produce very elongated , and hence low aspect ratio quasi-1d traps . in practice , of course , one can not produce an ideal bessel optical beams as it carries infinite power . however , using axiconal optics finite power approximations to bessel beams can be produced which can propagate over significant distances . the basic scheme is illustrated in figure [ fig : ten ] where an incident laguerre - gaussian beam of azimuthal mode index @xmath216 is transformed into a bessel beam of the same order . the interested reader is referred to our recent paper @xcite for details , but for an incident gaussian beam on the axiconal optics the resulting zero - order bessel beam intensity profile past the axicon is @xmath227 where @xmath228 is the input spot size , @xmath229 the input power , @xmath230 , @xmath137 and @xmath231 are the index and opening angle of the axicon , and @xmath232 which gives the longitudinal extent of the bessel beam . this intensity profile of the bessel optical beam is readily converted to an effective dipole potential @xmath233 with @xmath234 the laser detuning from the optical transition frequency @xmath235 , @xmath236 the natural linewidth of the optical transition , @xmath237 is the resonant saturation intensity , and @xmath238 . for a red - detuned laser the potential is negative and the atoms are attracted to the regions of high intensity , whereas for a blue - detuned laser the atoms are repelled into the low field regions . here for a red - detuned laser we have approximated the bessel optical dipole potential by a parabolic potential near the axis under conditions of tight confinement , where @xmath239 is the longitudinal position of the peak of the bessel beam , and @xmath240 a red - detuned ( @xmath241 ) @xmath226 optical dipole potential therefore provides confinement in both the radial and longitudinal directions . here @xmath242 is the radial oscillation frequency with corresponding ground state oscillator width @xmath243 , and @xmath244 is the ratio between the longitudinal and radial trap frequencies @xmath245 @xcite , which also determines the aspect ratio between the radial and longitudinal ground state widths @xmath246 ( in the absence of many - body repulsion ) . petrov _ et al . _ @xcite have theoretically studied the diagram of state for a one - dimensional gas of trapped bosons , assuming @xmath247 , and found that a true bec , or at least a quasi - condensate , with concomitant macroscopic occupation of a single state , is only attained for high enough particle numbers @xmath248 with @xmath249 for @xmath250 and temperatures @xmath251 , one obtains a tonks gas of impenetrable bosons for which hard core repulsion between the bosonic atoms prevents them from penetrating through each other in the one - dimensional system , and the system acquires properties reminiscent of a one - dimensional system of fermionic atoms . a highly elongated bessel beam discussed , say with parameters @xmath252 nm , @xmath253 w , @xmath254 cm , @xmath255 @xmath189 m , would be an ideal candidate for the experimental realization of a tonks gas . the low aspect ratio @xmath256 and tight radial confinement @xmath257 nm result in a high upper boundary @xmath258 for the particle number of the tonks gas . for the commonly used @xmath187rb isotope with a scattering length @xmath259 nm one finds @xmath260 . although this is still a fairly low value it should be possible to experimentally realize a small @xmath187rb tonks gas . however , more promising would be the use of the @xmath261rb isotope , where a feshbach resonance can be used to tune the normally negative scattering length to positive values of several hundred nanometers magnitude @xcite . as @xmath258 is proportional to the square of the scattering length even a moderate increase to @xmath262 nm would make it possible to create a larger tonks gas , with say @xmath263 atoms , which should be easily detectable . the bessel beam trap offers some advantages compared to alternative suggested approaches using magnetic waveguides @xcite and a hybrid magnetic - optical trap @xcite . firstly , it involves only a very simple _ all - optical _ system for which the aspect ratio of the trap may be controlled simply by varying the gaussian spot size incident on the axicon . more specifically , being all - optical , it does not involve material surfaces as in magnetic waveguides , which can cause matter - wave decoherence @xcite . furthermore , it allows for the possibility of trapping multiple magnetic sublevels and the investigation of multi - component tonks gases , which would not be possible in the hybrid magnetic - optical trap of bongs _ et al . in this paper we have given an overview of our work on the quantum dynamics of 1d trapped tonks gases . in particular , we hope to have shown that tonks gases display a rich variety of behaviors that are worthy of experimental investigation . the fermi - bose mapping approach to solving for the 1d tonks shows that many features are shared between the tonks gas of impenetrable bosons and a 1d gas of non - interacting fermions : they have the same ground state energies and density profiles , and neither shows true bec . however , the tonks and fermi gases differ markedly in their momentum spectra , and we have devised a scheme to measure this difference @xcite . furthermore , we have shown that the 1d tonks gas can show dark soliton - like solutions which are typically associated with solutions of the mean - field gross - pitaevskii equation . this is so in spite of the fact that mean - field theory greatly overestimates the coherence properties of the tonks gas , as we demonstrated in our simulations of split and recombined tonks gases . our work presented here shows that tonks gases have some degree of coherence but much less than a true bec , and this may have implications for proposed atomic interferometers employing high density , eg . atom laser , sources . in particular , strong transverse confinement is desirable in atomic interferometers to avoid multi - transverse mode effects , and at the same time one would like to keep the atomic density down to avoid many - body shifts , but these are exactly the requirements for the tonks limit ! therefore it is very important to study the bec - tonks transition @xcite and its effect on the performance of atom interferometers . we hope that our work is a first step in this direction . this work was supported at the university of arizona by office of naval research grant n00014 - 99 - 1 - 0806 and also the us army research office . we thank joe triscari for collaborations on the ground state properties of the tonks gas , and the work on bessel optical dipole traps was conducted in collaboration with j. arlt and k. dholakia from st . andrews university , scotland , and j. soneson at the university of arizona . et al . _ , . d. mller _ et al . n.h . dekker _ et al . _ , . thywissen , r.m . westervelt , and m. prentiss , . hinds , m.g . boshier , and i.g . hughes , . , ed . p.r . berman ( academic press , boston , 1997 ) . j. schmiedmayer , . m. olshanii , . d. s. petrov , g. v. shlyapnikov , and j. t. m. walraven , . m. girardeau , . girardeau , . see particularly secs . 2 , 3 , and 6 . a. lenard , . a. g. rojo , g. l. cohen , and p. r. berman , . m.d . girardeau and e.m . k. bongs _ et al . e. b. kolomeisky _ et al . _ . m.d . girardeau and e.m . vaidya and c.a . w. ketterle and n. j. van druten , . o. penrose and l. onsager , . girardeau , e.m . wright , and j.m . triscari , . e.m . wright , j. arlt , and k. dholakia , . aitken , _ determinants and matrices _ ( oliver and boyd , edinburgh and london , 1951 ) , p. 112 . r.b . laughlin , . r.a . smith and n.k . j. l. dubois and h. r. glyde , . m.d . girardeau and e.m . wright , cond - mat/0012365 ( 2000 ) . w.p . reinhardt and c.w . r. dum _ et al . scott , r.j . ballagh , and k. burnett , . jackson , g.m . kavoulakis , and c.j . pethick , . s. burger _ et al . _ , . j. denshlag _ et al . _ . a.e . muryshev _ busch and j.r . for a recent review see f. dalfovo _ et al . _ , . g. baym and c. j. pethick , . y. kagan , g. v. shlapnikov , and j. t. m. walraven , . m. edwards _ et al . s. stringari , . e. v. goldstein , k. plttner , and p. meystre , _ quantum . semiclass . opt . _ * 7 * , 743 ( 1995 ) . _ , _ science _ * 398 * , 218 ( 1999 ) . s. a. morgan , r. j. ballagh , and k. burnett , . w.p . reinhardt and c.w . m. naraschewski _ et al . _ , . j. javanainen and m. wilkens , ; _ ibid . _ * 81 * , 1345 ( 1998 ) . a. j. legget and f. sols , . e. m. wright _ et al . _ , . m.d . girardeau and e.m . k. e. cahill and r. j. glauber . j. durnin , j. j. miceli , and j. h. eberly , _ phys . * 58 * , 1499 ( 1987 ) . , to be published in _ phys . a _ ( 2001 ) . v. m. perez - garcia _ et al . _ , _ phys . a _ * 57 * , 3837 ( 1998 ) . y. s. kivshar and t. j. alexander , cond - mat/9905048 ( 1999 ) . s. l. cornish _ et al . _ , * 85 * , 1795 ( 2000 ) . c. henkel and m. wilkens , _ europhys . _ * 47 * , 414 ( 1999 ) . c. henkel , s. poetting , and m. wilkens , _ appl . b _ * 69 * , 379 ( 1999 ) . v. dunjko , v. lorent , and m. olshanii , cond - mat/0103085 ( 2001 ) .
Abstract: | [
"several experimental groups are currently working towards realizing quasi - one - dimensional ( 1d ) atom de broglie waveguides and loading them with ultracold atoms . the dynamics becomes truly 1d in a regime ( tonks gas ) of low temperatures and densities , and large positive scattering lengths for which the transverse mode becomes frozen , in which case the many - body schrdinger dynamics becomes exactly soluble via a fermi - bose mapping theorem . in this paper we review our recent work on the exact ground state and quantum dynamics of 1d tonks gases and assess the possibilty of approaching the tonks regime using bessel beam optical dipole traps . # 1#2#3#4#1 * # 2 * , # 3 ( # 4 )"
] | 8,984 | 8,984 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: understanding strong correlation effect away from equilibrium has been one of the most interesting yet challenging problems in condensed matter physics . a prominent realization of such phenomena is embodied in quantum transport through a nanostructure under finite bias voltage . to understand the interplay of the correlation effect and nonequilibrium nature , nonequilibrium version of the single impurity anderson model ( siam ) and its extensions have been serving and continue to do so as a central theoretical model . the siam is indeed considered to be one of the best studied strongly correlated model , and despite its apparent simplicity , it exhibits rich physics already in equilibrium , such as the coulomb blockade and the kondo physics that have been observed in experiments . equilibrium properties of the siam have been well understood thanks to concerted efforts of several theoretical approaches over years by perturbative treatment , fermi liquid description , as well as exact results by the bethe ansatz method and numerical renormalization group ( nrg ) calculations ( see for instance , . ) in contrast , the situation of the nonequilibrium siam is not so satisfactory . each of the above approaches has met some difficulty in treating nonequilibrium phenomena . a theoretical approach that can deal with the strong correlation effect in nonequilibrium is still called for . notwithstanding , a number of analytical and numerical methods have been devised to investigate nonequilibrium stationary phenomena : nonequilibrium perturbation approaches @xcite and its modifications @xcite , the non - crossing approximation @xcite , the functional renormalization group treatment @xcite , quantum monte carlo calculations on the keldysh contour @xcite , the iterative real - time path integral method @xcite and so on . unfortunately those approaches fail to give a consistent picture concerning the finite bias effect on the dot spectral function , particularly regarding a possible splitting of the kondo resonance . as for the equilibrium siam , the second - order perturbation regarding the coulomb interaction @xmath0 on the dot @xcite is known to capture essential features of kondo physics and agrees qualitatively well with exact results obtained by the bethe ansatz and nrg approaches @xcite . such good agreement seems to persist in nonequilibrium stationary state at finite bias voltage . for the two - terminal particle - hole ( ph ) symmetric siam , a recent study by @xcite showed that the nonequilibrium second order perturbation calculation of the spectral function agrees with that calculated by the diagrammatic quantum monte carlo simulation , excellently up to interaction strength @xmath1 ( where @xmath2 is the total relaxation rate due to leads ) ; pretty well even for @xmath3 at bias voltage @xmath4 . a typical magnitude of @xmath5 of a semiconductor quantum dot is roughly @xmath6 depending on the size and the configuration of the dot . therefore , there is a good chance of describing a realistic system within the validity of nonequilibrium perturbation approach . the great advantage of semiconductor dot systems is to allow us to control several physical parameters . those include changing gate voltage as well as configuring a more involved structure such as a multi - terminal dot @xcite or an interferometer embedding a quantum dot . theoretical treatments often limit themselves to a system with the ph symmetry where the dot occupation number is fixed to be one half per spin . although assuming the ph symmetry makes sense and comes in handy in extracting the essence of the kondo resonance , we should bear in mind that such symmetry is not intrinsic and can be broken easily in realistic systems , by gate voltage , asymmetry of the coupling with the leads , or asymmetric drops of bias voltage @xcite . the ph asymmetry commonly appears in a multi - terminal dot or in an interferometer embedding a quantum dot . it is also argued that the effect of the ph asymmetry might be responsible for the deviation observed in nonequilibrium transport experiments from the `` universal '' behavior of the ph symmetric siam @xcite . to work on realistic systems , it is imperative to understand how the ph asymmetry affects nonequilibrium transport . in this paper , we examine the second - order nonequilibrium perturbation regarding the coulomb interaction @xmath0 of the multi - terminal siam . the ph symmetry is not assumed , and miscellaneous types of asymmetry of couplings to the leads and/or voltage drops are incorporated as a generic multi - terminal configuration . our main focus is to provide solid analytical results of the behavior of the nonequilibrium self - energy and hence the dot spectral function for the full range of frequency and bias voltage , within the validity of the second - order perturbation theory of @xmath0 . the result encompasses fermi liquid behavior as well as incoherent non - fermi liquid contribution , showing analytically that increasing finite bias voltage leads to a crossover from the kondo resonance to the coulomb blockade behaviors . the present work contrasts preceding perturbative studies @xcite whose evaluations relied on either numerical means or a small - parameter expansion of bias voltage and frequency . the only notable exception , to the author s knowledge , is a recent work by @xcite , which succeeded in evaluating analytically the second - order self - energy for the two - terminal ph symmetric dot . intending to apply such analysis to a wider range of realistic systems and examine the effect that the two - terminal ph symmetric siam can not capture , we extend their approach to a generic multi - terminal dot where the ph symmetry may not necessarily be present . an embarrassing drawback of using the nonequilibrium perturbation theory is that when one has it naively apply to the ph asymmetric siam , it may disrespect the preservation of the steady current . @xcite as a result , one then needs some current - preserving prescription , and different self - consistent schemes have been proposed and adopted . @xcite as will be seen , the current preserving condition involves all the frequency range , not only of low frequency region that validates fermi liquid description but also of the incoherent non - fermi liquid part ( see eq . below ) . therefore , an approximation based on the low energy physics , particularly the fermi liquid picture , should be used with care . the self - energy we will construct analytically is checked to satisfy the spectral sum rule at finite bias voltage , so that we regard it as giving a consistent description for the full range of frequency in nonequilibrium . by taking its advantage , we also demonstrate a self - consistent , current - preserving calculation of the nonequilibrium spectral function for a system where the ph symmetry is not present . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : model ] , we introduce the multi - terminal siam in nonequilibrium . we review briefly how to obtain the exact current formula by clarifying the role of the current conservation at finite bias voltage . section [ sec : self - energy ] presents analytical expression of the retarded self - energy for a general multi - terminal dot up to the second - order of the interaction strength . subsequently in sec . [ sec : discussion ] , we examine and discuss its various analytical behaviors including high- and low - bias voltage limits . sec . [ sec : spectral - fn ] is devoted to constructing a non - equilibrium spectral function using the self - energy obtained in the previous section . we focus our attention on two particular situations : ( 1 ) self - consistent , current - preserving evaluation of the nonequilibrium spectral function for the two - terminal ph asymmetric siam , and ( 2 ) multi - terminal effect of the ph symmetric siam . finally we conclude in sec . [ sec : conclusion ] . mathematical details leading to our main analytical result eq . as well as other necessary material regarding dilogarithm is summarized in appendices . the model we consider is the single impurity anderson model connecting with multiple leads @xmath7 whose chemical potentials are sustained by @xmath8 . the total hamiltonian of the system consists of @xmath9 , where @xmath10 , @xmath11 and @xmath12 represent the dot hamiltonian with the coulomb interaction , the hopping term between the dot and the leads , and the hamiltonian of a noninteracting lead @xmath13 , respectively . they are specified by @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the dot electron number operator with spin @xmath16 and @xmath17 are electron operators at the lead @xmath13 . in the following , we consider the spin - independent transport case , but an extension to the spin - dependence situation such as in the presence of magnetic field or ferromagnetic leads is straightforward . when applying the wide - band limit , all the effect of the lead @xmath13 is encoded in terms of its chemical potential @xmath8 and relaxation rate @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the density of states of the lead @xmath13 . the dot level @xmath20 controls the average occupation number on the dot ; it corresponds roughly to @xmath21 , @xmath22 , @xmath23 for @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 , respectively . the ph symmetry is realized when @xmath27 and @xmath28 ( see eqs . and below ) . we here briefly summarize how the current through the dot is determined in a multi - terminal setting . special attention is paid to the role of the current conservation because it has been known that nonequilibrium perturbation calculation does not respect it in general . @xcite we illustrate how to ensure the current conservation by requiring minimally . the argument below is valid regardless of a specific approximation scheme chosen , whether nonequilibrium perturbation or any other approach . following the standard protocol of the keldysh formulation @xcite , we start with writing the current @xmath29 flowing from the lead @xmath13 to the dot in terms of the dot s lesser green function @xmath30 and the retarded one @xmath31 : @xmath32,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 is the fermi distribution function at the lead @xmath13 . as the present model preserves the total spin as well as charge , the net spin current flowing to the dot should vanish in the steady state , which imposes the integral relation between @xmath30 and @xmath31 , @xmath34 = 0 . \label{eq : gless - gr}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we have introduced the total relaxation rates @xmath35 and the effective fermi distribution @xmath36 weighted by the leads , @xmath37 when we ignore the energy dependence of the relaxation rates @xmath38 , we can recast eq . into a more familiar form @xmath39 because @xmath40 is the definition of the exact dot occupation number . note the quantity @xmath41 is nothing but the exact dot spectral function out of equilibrium . we emphasize that eq . ( or equivalently eq . ) is the minimum , exact requirement that ensures the current preservation . it constrains the exact @xmath42 and @xmath43 that depend on the interaction as well as bias voltage in a nontrivial way . one can accordingly eliminate @xmath44 in @xmath29 , to reach the landauer - buttiker type current formula at the lead @xmath13 , @xmath45 or , the current conservation allows us to write it as @xmath46,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath47 is the exact number of states with spin @xmath16 at finite temperature in general , defined by @xmath48 it tells us that differential conductance @xmath49 with fixing all other @xmath50 s is proportional to the nonequilibrium dot spectral function , provided changing @xmath8 does not affect the occupation number @xcite . such situation is realized , for instance , when a probe lead couples weakly to the dot . the case of a noninteracting dot always satisfies the current preserving condition eq . as @xmath51 holds for any @xmath52 ; the distribution function of dot electrons @xmath53 is equal to @xmath54 . this is not the case for an interacting dot , however . as for the interacting case , not so much can be said . we only see the special case with the two - terminal ph symmetric dot satisfy eq . by choosing @xmath55 irrespective of interaction strength . except for this ph symmetric case , a general connection between @xmath42 and @xmath43 is not known so far . it is remarked that , based on the quasiparticle picture , a noninteracting relation @xmath56 is sometimes used to deduce an approximate form of @xmath42 out of @xmath43 for an interacting dot . such approximation is called the ng s ansatz @xcite . although it might be be simple and handy , its validity is far from clear . we will not rely on such additional approximation below . it is also important to distinguish in eq . the electron occupation number @xmath57 from the quasiparticle occupation number @xmath58 , as the two quantities are different at finite bias voltage since the luttinger relation holds only in equilibrium @xcite . contribution to the dot occupation number comes from all range of frequency , including the incoherent part . one sees fulfilling the spectral weight sum rule @xmath59 crucial to have the dot occupation number @xmath57 normalized correctly . in general , one needs to determine @xmath57 appropriately to satisfy eq . as a function of interaction and chemical potentials of the leads . the applicability of quasi - particle approaches that ignores the incoherent part is unclear . in this section , we evaluate analytically the nonequilibrium retarded self - energy up to the second order of interaction strength @xmath0 for the multi - terminal siam . we first examine the contribution at the first - order and the role of current preservation . then we present the analytical result of the second - order self - energy in terms of dilogarithm . following the standard treatment of the keldysh formulation , @xcite the nonequilibrium green function and the self - energy take a matrix structure @xmath60 satisfying symmetry relations @xmath61 and @xmath62 . the retarded green function is defined by @xmath63 ; the retarded self - energy , by @xmath64 . to proceed evaluation , it is convenient to classify self - energy diagrams into the two types : the hartree - type diagram ( fig . [ fig : hartree - type ] ) that can be disconnected by cutting a single interaction line , and the rest which we call the correlation part and reassign the symbol @xmath65 to . the latter starts at the second - order . the resulting green function ( matrix ) takes a form of @xmath66^{-1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath67 represents a pauli matrix of the keldysh structure , and @xmath68 refers to the exact occupation number of the dot electron with the opposite spin . accordingly , the corresponding retarded green function becomes @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the hartree level of the dot . . the double line refers to the exact green function . ] before starting evaluating the correlation part @xmath71 that starts contributing at the second order , it is worthwhile to examine the current preserving condition eq . at the first order . at this order , it reduces to the self - consistent hartree - fock equation for the dot occupation number @xmath72 : @xmath73 . \label{eq : hf - self - consistency}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it shows how the two - terminal ph symmetric siam is special by choosing @xmath74 , @xmath75 and @xmath76 ; the second term of the right - hand side vanishes by having the solution @xmath77 even at finite bias voltage . it also indicates that the current preservation necessarily has the occupation number depend on asymmetry of the lead couplings as well as interaction strength for the ph asymmetric siam . indeed , for a small deviation from the ph symmetry and bias voltage , we see the hartree - fock occupation number behave as @xmath78 where @xmath79 is the average chemical potential weighted by leads , @xmath80 note @xmath79 vanishes when no bias voltage applies , as we incorporate the overall net offset by leads into @xmath20 . following the standard perturbation treatment of the keldysh formulation , we see there is only one diagram contributing to @xmath81 at the second order ( fig . [ fig : sigma2 ] ) after eliminating the hartree - type contribution . the contribution is written as @xmath82 where @xmath83 refer to to the unperturbed green functions ( including the hartree term ) , whose concrete expressions are found in appendix a. the polarization matrix @xmath84 is defined by @xmath85 ( fig . [ fig : pi ] ) .. ] as was shown by the current formula in the previous section , we need only the dot spectral function to study quantum transport , hence @xmath71 suffices . therefore it is more advantageous to work on the rak - representation , where the polarization parts become @xmath86 , \\ & \pi^{a}_{12 } = \frac{i\hbar}{2 } \left [ g^{a}_{12 } g^{k}_{21 } + g^{k}_{12 } g^{r}_{21 } \right ] , \\ & \pi^{k}_{12 } = \frac{i\hbar}{2 } \left [ g^{k}_{12 } g^{k}_{21 } + g^{r}_{12 } g^{a}_{21 } + g^{a}_{12 } g^{r}_{21 } \right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq : def - pi ] and their fourier transformations are given in appendix b. accordingly , we can express the retarded self - energy @xmath71 as @xmath87,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath88 the above second - order expression of @xmath71 is standard , but it has so far been mainly used for numerical evaluation , quite often restricted for the two - terminal ph symmetric siam . we intend to evaluate eqs . ( [ eq : i1],[eq : i2 ] ) analytically for the generic multi - terminal siam , along the line employed in ref . . delegating all the mathematical details to appendices c and d , we summarize our result of the analytical evaluation of @xmath71 as follows : @xmath89 , \label{eq : sigmar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , functions @xmath90 ( @xmath91 ) are found to be ( using @xmath92 ) , [ eq : xi123 ] @xmath93 \nonumber \\ & \qquad \qquad + \sum_{a , b,\beta } \tfrac{4\gamma_{a } \gamma_{b}}{\gamma^{2 } } \big [ { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(\tfrac{-\varepsilon+ \beta \zeta_{a\bar{\sigma } } } { \beta \zeta_{b \bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma } ) + \tfrac{1}{4 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2 } ( \tfrac{-\zeta_{a\bar{\sigma}}+i\gamma}{\zeta_{b\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma } ) \big ] , \\ \xi_{2}(\varepsilon ) & = 6\pi^{2 } - \sum_{a , b,\beta } \tfrac{4\gamma_{a } \gamma_{b}}{\gamma^{2 } } \big [ \lambda(\tfrac{\varepsilon -\zeta_{a\sigma } + 2i\gamma}{\beta \zeta_{b\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma } ) + \lambda(\tfrac{\varepsilon - \beta \zeta_{b\bar{\sigma } } + 2i\gamma}{\zeta_{a\sigma } + i\gamma } ) + \tfrac{1}{2 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2 } ( \tfrac{\zeta_{a\sigma } + i\gamma}{\beta \zeta_{b \bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma } ) \big ] \nonumber \\ & \qquad \qquad - \sum_{a , b,\beta } \tfrac{4\gamma_{a } \gamma_{b}}{\gamma^{2 } } \big [ \lambda ( \tfrac{\varepsilon+ \beta \zeta_{a\bar{\sigma } } + 2i\gamma } { \beta \zeta_{b\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma } ) + \tfrac{1}{4 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2 } ( \tfrac{-\zeta_{a\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma}{\zeta_{b\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma } ) \big ] , \\ \xi_{3 } & = \left[\sum_{a } \tfrac{2\gamma_{a}}{\gamma } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}\left ( \tfrac{-\zeta_{a\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma}{\zeta_{a\bar{\sigma } } + i\gamma}\right ) \right]^{2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq : xi-123 ] where the summations over @xmath94 as well as terminals @xmath95 are understood . function @xmath96 is dilogarithm , whose definition as well as various useful properties are summarized in appendix c ; @xmath97 is defined by is equivalent to that given in ref . , but we prefer writing it in this form because its analyticity is more transparent . ] @xmath98 { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}z . \label{def : lambda}\end{aligned}\ ] ] analytical formula @xmath71 given in eqs . and constitutes the main result of the present paper . consequently , the nonequilibrium spectral function of the multi - terminal siam is given analytically for full range of frequency and bias voltage , once one chooses @xmath57 to satisfy eq . . the result also applies to a more involved structured system , such as an interferometer embedding a quantum dot , by simply replacing @xmath20 and @xmath38 to take account of those geometric effect . having obtained an explicit analytical form of the second - order self - energy @xmath99 at arbitrary frequency and bias voltage , we now examine its various limiting behaviors . most of those limiting behaviors have been known for the two - terminal ph symmetric siam , so it s assuring to reproduce those expressions in such a case . simultaneously , our results below provide multi - terminal , ph asymmetric extensions of those asymptotic results . we can reproduce the equilibrium result by setting all the chemical potentials equal , @xmath100 . then we immediately see @xmath101 and @xmath102 , \\ & \xi_{2 } = 8\cdot \big[\frac{3\pi^{2}}{4 } - 3\lambda(\tfrac{\varepsilon_{\sigma } + 2i\gamma}{i\gamma } ) \big],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath103 . as a result , the correlation part of the self - energy in equilibrium becomes @xmath104 . \label{eq : sigma - equilibrium}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the ph symmetric case in particular corresponds to @xmath105 . it reproduces the perturbation results by yamada and yoshida @xcite up to the second - order of @xmath0 , when we expand the above for small @xmath52 . the ph symmetric result is indeed identical with the one obtained in ref . for arbitrary frequency ( see also eq . below ) . @xcite have evaluated analytically the self - energy and the spectral function for the two - terminal ph symmetric siam . in our notation , it corresponds to the case @xmath106 , and @xmath107 . when we parametrize the two chemical potentials by @xmath108 with @xmath109 in eqs . , the self - energy can be written as @xmath110 , \label{eq : ph - symmetric - sigmar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath111 , \\ & \xi_{2 } = 6\pi^{2 } - 6\sum_{a , b } \big [ \lambda(\tfrac{\omega -a ev/2 + 2i\gamma}{b ev/2 + i\gamma } ) + \frac{1}{4 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2 } ( \tfrac{a ev/2 + i\gamma}{b ev/2 + i\gamma } ) \big].\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above result are identical with what ref . obtained . we now employ the small - parameter expansion of @xmath71 around the half - filled equilibrium system . here we assume parameters @xmath112 and @xmath113 are much smaller than the total relaxation rate @xmath2 . the expansion of @xmath114 is found to contain the first- and second - order terms regarding @xmath115 and @xmath116 , while @xmath117 do only the second - order terms . therefore the result of the expansion up to the second - order of these small parameters is presented as @xmath118.\end{aligned}\ ] ] functions @xmath90 can be expanded straightforwardly by using the taylor expansion of dilogarithm in appendix c. they are found to behave @xmath119 , \\ & \xi_{2}(\varepsilon ) \approx - 8 \ , \big [ \frac{3 ( -\varepsilon^{2 } + 2 \varepsilon\bar{\mu } + 2 \bar{\mu}^{2 } - \overline{\mu^{2 } } - 2 \overline{\mu^{2}})}{4(i\gamma)^{2 } } \big ] \\ & \xi_{3 } \approx \frac{16 \bar{\mu}^{2}}{(i\gamma)^{2}},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath79 is defined in eq . and we have introduced @xmath120 combining all of these , we reach the small bias / frequency behavior of the self - energy @xmath81 as @xmath121 \nonumber \\ & \qquad \qquad - \frac{iu^{2}}{2\pi^{2}\gamma^{3 } } \big [ ( \omega - \bar{\mu})^{2 } + 3\ , ( \delta \mu)^{2 } \big ] . \label{eq : small - parameter - expansion}\end{aligned}\ ] ] small bias expansion of @xmath122 for the two - terminal system has been discussed and determined by the argument based on the ward identity . @xcite the dependence appearing in eq . fully conforms to it ( except for the presence of the bare interaction instead of the renormalized one ) . indeed , correspondence is made clear by noting the parameters @xmath79 and @xmath123 for the two - terminal case become @xmath124 the presence of linear term in @xmath52 and @xmath125 for the two - terminal ph asymmetric siam was also emphasized recently . @xcite one expects naively that the limit of large bias voltage @xmath126 corresponds to the high temperature limit @xmath127 in equilibrium ; it was shown to be so for the two - terminal ph symmetric siam . @xcite we now show that the same applies to the multi - terminal siam where bias voltages of the leads are pairwisely large , _ i.e. _ , half of them are positively large , and the others are negatively large . in the large bias voltage limit , all the arguments of dilogarithm functions appearing in eqs . become @xmath128 , where the values of dilogarithm are known ( see appendix c ) . accordingly , the pairwisely large bias limit of @xmath90 is found to be @xmath129 correspondingly , the retarded self - energy becomes @xmath130 it shows that the result of the multi - terminal siam is the same with that of the two - terminal ph symmetric siam except for a frequency shift . accordingly , the retarded green function @xmath131 in this limit is given by @xmath132 the form indicates that for sufficiently strong interaction @xmath133 , the dot spectral function has two peaks at @xmath134 with broadening @xmath135 , so the system is driven into the the coulomb blockade regime . on the other hand , for weak interaction @xmath136 , it has only one peak with two different values of broadening that reduce to @xmath2 and @xmath137 in the @xmath138 limit . what is the role of the current preservation condition eq . in this limit ? it just determines the dot occupation number explicitly . in fact , the condition becomes @xmath139 with @xmath140 , and @xmath57 is independent of the interaction strength because bias voltage sets the largest scale . one can evaluate the above integral exactly to have @xmath141 where @xmath142 . as a result , expanding it up to the second order of @xmath143 leads to @xmath144 the first term corresponds to the occupation number that one expects naturally from the effective distribution @xmath36 ; it corresponds , for instance , @xmath145 for the two - terminal dot with @xmath146 with @xmath147 . the second term is the deviation from it , which is proportional to the average of the inverse chemical potential weighted by the leads . we now turn our attention to the behavior of the nonequilibrium dot spectral function , using our analytical expression of the self - energy eqs . ( [ eq : sigmar],[eq : xi123 ] ) . below we particularly focus our attention on the two cases : the two - terminal ph asymmetric siam where current preservation has been an issue , and the multi - terminal ph symmetric siam where the role of multiple leads has been raising questions . in all of the calculations below , we have checked numerically the validity of the spectral weight sum rule at each configuration of bias voltages . as was emphasized in sec . [ sec : current - formula ] , when a dot system does not retain the ph symmetry , the stationary current is not automatically conserved and one must impose the current preservation condition eq . explicitly . as the right - hand side of eq . also depends on the dot occupation number @xmath57 , this requires us to determine @xmath57 self - consistently by using the retarded green function in a certain approximation the second - order perturbation theory in the present case . ) at finite bias voltage @xmath148 . the interaction strength is chosen as @xmath149 . the dotted line represents the result of @xmath150 and @xmath151 . ] figure [ fig : ph - symmetric ] shows the result of nonequilibrium dot spectral function of the two - terminal ph symmetric siam at bias voltage @xmath152 , and @xmath153 , which is essentially the same result with ref . ( of a different set of parameters ) . the occupation number is fixed to be @xmath154 in this case , so its self - consistent determination is unnecessary . the results were compared favorably with those obtained by diagrammatic quantum monte carlo calculations @xcite ; a relatively good quantitative agreement was observed up to @xmath155 ( where the bethe ansatz kondo temperature @xmath156 @xcite while the estimated half width of the kondo resonance @xmath157 ) and bias voltage @xmath158 . applying bias voltage gradually suppresses the kondo resonance without splitting it , and the two peaks at @xmath159 are developed at larger bias voltages , which corresponds to the discussion in the previous section . figure [ fig : ph - asymmetric ] shows the result of our self - consistent calculation of the nonequilibrium spectral function for the two - terminal ph asymmetric siam at ( a ) @xmath160 and ( b ) @xmath161 . a paramagnetic - type solution is assumed in determining @xmath57 . as in the ph symmetric siam , one sees increasing bias voltage not split but suppress the kondo resonance while it develops a peak around @xmath162 . the kondo resonance peak is suppressed more significantly at @xmath160 than at @xmath163 , because the kondo temperature of the former ( @xmath164 ; @xmath165 ) is smaller than that of the latter ( @xmath166 ; @xmath167 ) . an interesting feature of the ph asymmetric siam is that spectral weight of the kondo resonance seems shifting gradually toward @xmath168 with increasing bias voltage , without exhibiting a three - peak structure in the ph symmetric case . this suggests a strong spectral mixing between the kondo resonance and a coulomb peak at finite bias voltage . because of it , the interval of the two peaks at finite bias is observed as roughly @xmath169 and gets widened up to @xmath0 for larger @xmath170 . the bias dependence somehow looks similar to what was obtained by assuming equilibrium noninteracting effective distribution for @xmath57 @xcite ( which is hard to justify in our opinion ) , though we emphasize our present calculation only relies on the current - preservation condition without using any further assumption . it is remarked that the effect shown by bias voltage is quite reminiscent of finite temperature effect that was observed in the ph asymmetric siam in equilibrium @xcite . , and ( b ) @xmath171 . all the other parameters are the same with fig . [ fig : ph - symmetric ] . as an eye guide , the ph symmetric result of @xmath150 and @xmath151 is shown as a dotted line.,title="fig : " ] , and ( b ) @xmath171 . all the other parameters are the same with fig . [ fig : ph - symmetric ] . as an eye guide , the ph symmetric result of @xmath150 and @xmath151 is shown as a dotted line.,title="fig : " ] . results of the interaction strengths @xmath172 , @xmath173 , and @xmath174 are shown , while dotted lines refer to the noninteracting case as an eye guide . ( a ) spectral function of the ph symmetric siam at @xmath175 . ( b ) spectral function of the ph asymmetric siam at @xmath176.,title="fig : " ] . results of the interaction strengths @xmath172 , @xmath173 , and @xmath174 are shown , while dotted lines refer to the noninteracting case as an eye guide . ( a ) spectral function of the ph symmetric siam at @xmath175 . ( b ) spectral function of the ph asymmetric siam at @xmath176.,title="fig : " ] more insight can be gained by examining how the spectral structure depends on the interaction strength at finite bias voltage . figures [ fig : ldos - u ] ( a , b ) show a structural crossover from a noninteracting resonant peak ( the dotted line ) to correlation peaks , for ( a ) the ph symmetric siam @xmath175 , and ( b ) the ph asymmetric siam @xmath177 . the ph symmetric siam shows introducing @xmath0 leads to developing the correlation two peaks as well as the kondo peak that is suppressed by finite bias voltage . in contrast , the bias voltage effect on the ph asymmetric siam is more involved , because the kondo resonance is apparently shifted and mixed with one of the correlation peaks , eventually showing the two - peak structure at @xmath178 in large bias voltage limit . , and @xmath179 ) . other parameters are chosen as the same as in fig . [ fig : ph - symmetric ] . the dotted line correspond to the two - terminal noninteracting unbiased case , while the dashed line , to the two - terminal interacting unbiased case . ] to examine finite bias affects further and see particularly how the presence of multi - terminals affects the nonequilibrium spectral function , we configure a special setup of the multi - terminal siam that preserves the ph symmetry : the dot is connected with @xmath180 identical terminals , with bias levels being distributed equidistantly between @xmath181 and @xmath182 , and each of relaxation rates is set to be @xmath183 . the latter ensures that the unbiased spectral function is the same , hence the kondo temperature . results of the nonequilibrium spectral function are shown in fig . [ fig : nldos - by - v ] . again , we confirm that no splitting of the kondo resonance is observed in this multi - terminal setting . one sees further that the increasing the number of terminals _ enhances _ the kondo resonance . this can be understood by weakening the bias suppression effect on the kondo resonance for a larger @xmath180 . more precisely , one may estimate the suppressing effect from small bias behavior eq . . hence @xmath184 is a control parameter . in the present multi - terminal ph symmetric setting , the quantity @xmath185 is found to be @xmath186 therefore @xmath185 decreases with increasing @xmath180 , which results in weakening the suppression and enhancing the kondo resonance for a larger @xmath180 . ( @xmath187 ) . other parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : nldos - by - v ] . ( b ) the effective fermi distribution @xmath188 at zero temperature for the ph symmetric multi - terminal dot ( @xmath189 ) . the inset shows relative locations of bias levels with fixed @xmath190 as a function of the number of terminals.,title="fig : " ] ( @xmath187 ) . other parameters are the same as in fig . [ fig : nldos - by - v ] . ( b ) the effective fermi distribution @xmath188 at zero temperature for the ph symmetric multi - terminal dot ( @xmath189 ) . the inset shows relative locations of bias levels with fixed @xmath190 as a function of the number of terminals.,title="fig : " ] the preceding argument also tells us that if the spectral function bears any multi - terminal signatures at all , they would be more conspicuous by examining it with fixing @xmath185 rather than @xmath125 . this is done in fig . [ fig : nldos - by - dmu ] ( a ) ; figure [ fig : nldos - by - dmu ] ( b ) shows how the effective dot distribution @xmath188 and the relative locations of bias levels ( in the inset ) evolve for a fixed @xmath185 when @xmath180 increases . no multi - terminal signature in the nonequilibrium spectral function is seen in fig . [ fig : nldos - by - dmu ] ( a ) ; results of different @xmath180 actually collapse , not only around zero frequency but in the entire frequency range . it suggests that the suppression of the kondo resonance deeply correlates the development of coulomb peaks , and a mixing between those spectral weight is important . the parameter @xmath185 controls a crossover from the kondo resonance to the coulomb blockade structure . we may also understand the similarity between bias effect and temperature effect by the connection through the large @xmath180 limit of the effective fermi distribution @xmath188 , as shown in fig . [ fig : nldos - by - dmu ] ( b ) . although there is a consensus that bias voltage starts suppressing the kondo peak , and eventually destroys it with developing the two coulomb peaks when bias voltage is much larger than the kondo temperature , there is a controversy as to whether the kondo resonance peak will be split or not in the intermediate range of bias voltage . all the results obtained by the second - order perturbation consistently indicate that there is no split of the kondo resonance ; finite bias voltage starts to suppress the kondo resonance , and develops the two coulomb blockade peaks by shifting the spectral weight from the kondo resonance . we should mention that some other approximations draw a different conclusion . here we make a few remarks on apparent discrepancy seen in various theoretical approaches as well as experiments , as well as some speculation based on our results . typically , several approaches that rely on the infinite @xmath0 limit , notably non - crossing approximation , equation of motion method , and other approaches investigating the kondo hamiltonian , observed the splitting of the kondo resonance under finite bias voltage @xcite . those results , however , have to be interpreted with great care , in our view . generally speaking , the spectral function obtained by those approaches does not obey the spectral weight sum rule : ignoring the doubly occupied state typically leads to the sum rule @xmath191 @xcite , rather than the correct value . therefore only half of the spectral weight can be accounted for in those methods . simultaneously , such ( false ) sum rule in conjugation with the bias - suppression of the kondo resonance can not hep but lead to a two - peak structure of the spectrum within the range of attention . splitting of the kondo resonance might be an artifact of the approximation . not fulfilling the correct sum rule , those approaches may not be able to distinguish whether finite bias will split the kondo resonance or simply suppresses it with developing the coulomb peaks . as for the two - terminal ph symmetric siam , fourth - order contribution regarding the coulomb interaction @xmath0 has been evaluated numerically @xcite . the results seem unsettled , though . while @xcite suggested the fourth - order term may yield the splitting of the kondo resonance in the intermediate bias region @xmath192 for sufficiently large interaction @xmath193 , which the second - order calculation fails to report , another numerical study indicates that the spectral function remains qualitatively the same with the second - order result @xcite . experimental situation is not so transparent , either . while the splitting of the kondo resonance was reported in a three - terminal conductance measurement in a quantum ring system @xcite , a similar spitting observed in the differential conductivity was attributed to being caused by a spontaneous formation of ferromagnetic contacts , not purely to bias effect @xcite . it is also pointed out that it has been recently recognized that the rashba spin - orbit coupling induces spin polarization nonmagnetically in a quantum ring system with a dot when applying finite bias voltage @xcite ; hence such spin magnetization might possibly lead to the splitting of the kondo resonance . the kondo resonance is a manifestation of singlet formation between the dot and the lead electrons . one may naively think that when several chemical potentials are connected with the dot , such singlet formation would take place at each lead _ separately _ , causing multiple kondo resonances . the results of the multi - terminal ph symmetric siam presented in the previous section tempt us to speculate a different picture . let us suppose that ( almost ) the same dot distribution function @xmath194 is realized for a fixed @xmath185 with a different terminal number @xmath180 , as fig . [ fig : nldos - by - dmu ] ( a ) suggests . note the assumption is fully consistent to the ward identity for low bias , but it invalidates a quasiparticle ansatz @xmath195 that explicitly depends on @xmath180 . in the large @xmath180 limit with a fixed @xmath185 , the effective fermi distribution @xmath188 resembles the fermi distribution at finite temperature @xmath196 . accordingly bias voltage may well give effect similar to finite temperature . it is seen in low and large bias limit for a dot with or without the ph symmetry . it implies that a dot electron can not separately form a singlet with the lead at each chemical potential , because it needs to implicates states at different chemical potentials through coupling with other leads . our second - order perturbation results seem to support this view . in summary , we have evaluated analytically the second - order self - energy and green function for a generic multi - terminal single impurity anderson model in nonequilibrium . various limiting behaviors have been examined analytically . nonequilibrium spectral function that preserves the current is constructed and is checked to satisfy the spectral weight sum rule . the multi - terminal effect is examined for the ph - symmetric siam , particularly . within the validity of the present approach , it is shown that the kondo peak is not split due to bias voltage . it is found that most of the finite bias effect is similar to that of finite temperature in low- and high - bias limits with and without the ph symmetry . such nature could be understood by help of the ward identity and the connection through the @xmath197 terminal limit . the present analysis serves as a viable tool that can cover a wide range of experimental situations . although there is still a chance that high - order contributions might generate a new effect such as split kondo resonances in a limited range of parameters , it is believed that the second - order perturbation theory can capture the essence of the kondo physics in most of realistic situations . moreover , having a concrete analytical form that satisfies both the current conservation and the sum rule , the present work provides a good , solid , workable result that more sophisticated future treatment can base on . the author gratefully acknowledges a. sunou for fruitful collaboration that delivered some preliminary results in this work . the author also appreciates r. sakano and a. oguri for helpful discussion at the early stage of the work . the work was partially supported by grant - in - aid for scientific research ( c ) no . 22540324 and 26400382 from mext , japan . [ sec : appendix ] we start with the nonequilibrium green function @xmath198 without the coulomb interaction on the dot . its keldysh structure is specified by @xmath199 where @xmath36 is the effective dot distribution defined in eq . . we incorporate the hartree - type diagram into the unperturbed part by replacing @xmath20 to @xmath200 . note @xmath68 is the exact dot occupation that needs to be determined consistently later . after mapping to the rak representation , those components are given by @xmath201 \left [ g^{r}_{\sigma } ( \omega ) - g^{a}_{\sigma } ( \omega ) \right ] . \label{eq : gk0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the function @xmath202 reduces to @xmath203 at zero temperature . taking the fourier transformation of eqs . , using eq . , and making further manipulations , we can rewrite @xmath204 and @xmath205 as @xmath206^ { * } , \label{eq : pir}\\ \pi^{k}(\varepsilon ) & = 2i\sum_{a , b } \frac{\gamma_{a } \gamma_{b}}{\gamma^{2 } } \coth \tfrac{\beta(\varepsilon-\mu_{ab})}{2 } { \mathop{\mathrm{im}}\nolimits}\left [ \frac{\gamma b_{ab}(\varepsilon)}{\pi \varepsilon ( \varepsilon+2i\gamma ) } \right ] , \label{eq : pik}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath207 , @xmath208 is the inverse temperature , and @xmath209 is given by @xmath210 \!\left [ g^{a}(\varepsilon ' ) - g^{r}(\varepsilon'+\varepsilon ) \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the present work , we are interested in the zero temperature limit , for which @xmath211 becomes @xmath212 . the function @xmath213 in this limit is evaluated as ( with @xmath112 ) @xmath214 this corresponds to a multi - terminal extension of the result obtained for the two - terminal ph symmetric siam . to complete evaluating the remaining integral over @xmath215 of eqs . ( [ eq : i1],[eq : i2 ] ) , we take full advantage of various properties of dilogarithm function @xmath96 . a concrete integral formula we have utilized will be given in appendix d. for the sake of completeness , we here collect its definition and properties necessary to complete our evaluation . [ [ definition ] ] definition + + + + + + + + + + dilogarithm @xmath96 with a complex argument @xmath216 is not so commonly found in literature . as it is a multi - valued function , we need to specify its branch structure properly . one way to define dilogarithm @xmath96 all over the complex plane consistently is to use the integral representation @xmath217 the multivaluedness of dilogarithm @xmath218 originates from logarithm in the integrand . here we designate the principal value of logarithm as @xmath219 , which is defined by @xmath220 according to eq . , @xmath96 has a branch - cut just above the real axis of @xmath221 . accordingly , its values just above and below the real axis are different for @xmath221 : @xmath222 but @xmath223 . some special values are known analytically . we need @xmath224 , @xmath225 , @xmath226 and @xmath227 for evaluation later . [ [ sec : functional - relations ] ] functional relations + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + dilogarithm @xmath96 has interesting symmetric properties regarding its argument @xmath228 ; values at @xmath228 , @xmath229 , @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 and @xmath233 are all connected with one another . those points are ones generated by symmetric operations @xmath234 and @xmath235 defined by @xmath236 and @xmath237 forms a group . other operations correspond to @xmath238 applying a series of integral transformations in eq . , one can connect the values of dilogarithm at these values with one another @xcite . note , those functional relations are usually presented only for real arguments . extending them for complex variables needs examining its branch - cut structure carefully . by following and extending the derivations in ref for complex @xmath216 , we prove that the following functional relations are valid for any complex variable @xmath228 . @xmath239^{2 } , \label{eq : dilog - func - rel - start}\\ & { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(tz ) = -{\mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(z ) + \tfrac{\pi^{2}}{6 } - { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(tz ) { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}z , \\ & { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(tstz ) = - { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(z ) -\tfrac{1}{2 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2}(stz ) \nonumber \\ & \qquad \qquad \qquad - [ { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(tz ) + { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(stz ) ] { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}z , \\ & { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}\big ( tsz \big ) = { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(z ) - \tfrac{\pi^{2}}{6 } \nonumber \\ & \qquad \qquad \qquad -\tfrac{1}{2 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2}(sz ) - { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(sz ) { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(tz ) , \\ & { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}\big(stz \big ) = { \mathop{\mathrm{li}_{2}}\nolimits}(z ) + \tfrac{\pi^{2}}{6 } \nonumber \\ & \qquad \qquad \qquad + \tfrac{1}{2 } { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}^{2}(tz ) + { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(tz ) { \mathop{\mathrm{log}}\nolimits}(tstz ) . \label{eq : dilog - func - rel - end}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to our knowledge , the above form of extension of functional relations of dilogarithm has not been found in literature . [ [ the - taylor - expansion ] ] the taylor expansion + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + to examine various limiting behaviors , we need the taylor expansion of dilogarithm , which is derived straightforwardly from eq . , @xmath240 the presence of @xmath241 reflects the branch - cut structure of @xmath96 . in particular , we utilize the following expansion in our analysis . @xmath242 here we derive and present the central integral formula for evaluating eqs . ( [ eq : i1],[eq : i2 ] ) . by performing a simple integral transformation in eq . , we have the integration @xmath243 where all the parameters @xmath244 as well as @xmath228 may be taken as complex numbers . combined with fractional decomposition , we see the following integral be evaluated in terms of dilogarithm : @xmath245 the remaining task to complete calculating @xmath71 in the form of eqs . ( [ eq : sigmar][eq : xi123 ] ) is to collect all the relevant formulas and organize them in a form that conforms to eq . . to write concisely , we introduce the following notations @xmath247 where the hartree level @xmath248 is defined as before . we express the terms @xmath249 and @xmath250 defined in eqs . ( [ eq : i1],[eq : i2 ] ) as @xmath251 here the leads @xmath95 in @xmath249 as well as @xmath252 in @xmath250 carry spin @xmath253 , while @xmath13 in @xmath250 does spin @xmath16 . singularity on energy integration is prescribed by the principal values . equation enables us to perform and express the above integrals in terms of dilogarithm . the resulting expressions are still complicated , but we can simplify them further using functional relations of dilogarithm eqs ( [ eq : dilog - func - rel - start][eq : dilog - func - rel - end ] ) . these require straightforward but rather laborious manipulations . in this way , we reach the final expression of @xmath81 of eq . .
Abstract: | [
"we study the nonequilibrium spectral function of the single - impurity anderson model connecting with multi - terminal leads . the full dependence on frequency and bias voltage of the nonequilibrium self - energy and spectral function is obtained analytically up to the second - order perturbation regarding the interaction strength @xmath0 . high and low bias voltage properties are analyzed for a generic multi - terminal dot , showing a crossover from the kondo resonance to the coulomb peaks with increasing bias voltage . for a dot where the particle - hole symmetry is not present , we construct a current - preserving evaluation of the nonequilibrium spectral function for arbitrary bias voltage . it is shown that finite bias voltage does not split the kondo resonance in this order , and no specific structure due to multiple leads emerges . overall bias dependence is quite similar to finite temperature effect for a dot with or without the particle - hole symmetry ."
] | 8,523 | 8,523 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: photoacoustic tomography is an emerging imaging technique that combines the good contrast of optical absorption with the resolution of ultrasound images ( see for instance @xcite ) . in experiments an object is irradiated by a short - pulsed laser beam . depending on the absorption properties of the material , some light energy is absorbed and converted into heat . this leads to a thermoelastic expansion , which causes a pressure rise , resulting in an ultrasonic wave , called photoacoustic signal . the signal is detected by an array of ultrasound transducers outside the object . using this signal the pressure distribution at the time of the laser excitation is reconstructed , offering a 3d image proportional to the amount of absorbed energy at each position . this is the imaging parameter of photoacoustics . common measurement setups rely on small ultrasound sensors , which are arranged _ uniformly _ along simple geometries , such as planes , spheres , or cylinders covering the specimen of interest ( see for instance @xcite below ) . for the planar arrangement of point - like detectors there exist several approaches for reconstruction , including numerical algorithms based on filtered backprojection formulas and time - reversal algorithms ( see for instance @xcite ) . the suggested algorithm in the present work realizes a fourier inversion formula ( see below ) using the _ non - uniform fast fourier transform _ ( nufft ) . this method has been designed for evaluation of fourier transforms at non - equispaced points in frequency domain , or non - equispaced data points in spatial , respectively temporal domain . the prior is called ner - nufft ( non - equispaced range - non uniform fft ) , whereas the latter is called ned - nufft ( non - equispaced data - non uniform fft ) . both algorithms have been introduced in @xcite . both nufft methods haven proven to achieve high accuracy and simultaneously reach the computational efficiency of conventional fft computations on regular grids @xcite . this work investigates photoacoustic reconstructions from ultrasound signals recorded at _ non - equispaced _ positions on a planar surface . to the best of our knowledge , this is a novel research question in photoacoustics , where the use of regular grids is the common choice . for the reconstruction we propose a novel combination of ned- and ner - nufft , which we call nedner - nufft , based on the following considerations : 1 . the discretization of the analytic inversion formulas ( see ) contains evaluation at non - equidistant sample points in frequency domain . 2 . in addition , and this comes from the motivation of this paper , we consider evaluation at non - uniform sampling points . the first issue can be solved by a ner - nufft implementation : for * 2d * photoacoustic inversion with * uniformly * placed sensors on a measurement * line * such an implementation has been considered in @xcite . this method was used for biological photoacoustic imaging in @xcite . in both papers the imaging could be realized in 2d because integrating line detectors @xcite have been used for data recording . in this paper , however , the focus is on 3d imaging , because measurements are taken with point sensors . experimentally , we show the applicability and superiority of the ( ned)ner - nufft reconstruction formula in three spatial dimensions , compared with standard interpolation fft reconstruction . to be precise , in this paper we conduct _ three dimensional _ imaging implemented using nedner - nufft , with ultrasound detectors aligned _ non - uniformly _ on a measurement plane . to easily assess the effect of a given arrangement , also 2d numerical simulations have been conducted , to support the argumentation . we quantitatively compare the results with other computational imaging methods : as a reference we use the @xmath0-wave toolbox @xcite with a standard fft implementation of the inversion algorithm . the nedner - nufft yields an improvement of the lateral and axial resolution ( the latter even by a factor two ) . the outline of this work is as follows : in section [ sec : reconst ] we outline the basics of the fourier reconstruction approach by presenting the underlying photoacoustic model . we state the fourier domain reconstruction formula in a continuous setting . moreover , we figure out two options for its discretization . we point out the necessity of a fast and accurate algorithm for computing the occurring discrete fourier transforms with non - uniform sampling points . in section [ sec : nufft ] we briefly explain the idea behind the nufft . we state the ner - nufft ( subsection [ subsec : ner_nufft ] ) and ned - nufft ( subsection [ subsec : ned_nufft ] ) formulas in the form we need it to realize the reconstruction on a non - equispaced grid . in section [ sec : comp1_ner_nufft ] we discuss the 3d experimental setup . the ner - nufft is compared with conventional fft reconstruction . a test chart is used to quantify resolution improvements in comparison to the _ k - wave _ fft reconstruction with linear interpolation . in axial direction this improvement was about 170% while reducing the reconstruction time by roughly 35% . in section [ sec : comp2_ned_nufft ] we then turn to the nedner - nufft in 2d with simulated data , in order to test different sensor arrangements in an easily controllable environment . an equiangular arrangement turns out to yield an improvement of over 40% compared to the best choice of equispaced sensor arrangement . furthermore , we use the insights gained from the 2d simulations to develop an equi - steradian sensor arrangement for our 3d measurements . we apply our nedner - nufft approach on these data and quantitatively compare the outcomes with reconstructions from equispaced data obtained by the ner - nufft approach . our results show a significant improvement of the already superior ner - nufft . let @xmath1 be an open domain in @xmath2 , and @xmath3 a @xmath4 dimensional hyperplane not intersecting @xmath5 . mathematically , photoacoustic imaging consists in solving the operator equation @xmath6=p|_{\gamma\times(0,\infty)}\,,\ ] ] where @xmath7 is a function with compact support in @xmath5 and @xmath8 $ ] is the trace on @xmath9 of the solution of the equation @xmath10 in other words , the photoacoustic imaging problem consists in identifying the initial source @xmath7 from measurement data @xmath11 . an explicit inversion formula for @xmath12 in terms of the fourier transforms of @xmath7 and @xmath13 $ ] has been found in @xcite . let @xmath14 . assume without loss of generality ( by choice of proper basis ) that @xmath3 is the hyperplane described by @xmath15 . then the reconstruction reads as follows : @xmath16\left(\bm{k}\right)= \frac{2k_{y}}{\kappa\left(\bm{k}\right)}\mathbf{f}[\mathbf{q}f]\left(\bm k_{\bm x},\kappa\left(\bm{k}\right)\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath17 denotes the @xmath18-dimensional fourier transform : @xmath19\left(\bm{k}\right):=\frac1{(2\pi)^{n/2}}\int\limits_{\mathbb{r}^{d}}{{\mathrm{e}}}^{-{{\mathrm{i}}}\bm{k}\cdot(\bm{x},y)}f(\bm{x})\mathrm{d}\bm{x}\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath20 here , the variables @xmath21 are in @xmath22 , whereas @xmath23 . for the numerical realization these three steps have to be realized in discrete form : we denote evaluations of a function @xmath24 at sampling points @xmath25 by @xmath26 for convenience , we will modify this notation in case of evaluations on an equispaced cartesian grid . we define the @xmath18-dimensional grid @xmath27 and assume our sampling points to be located on @xmath28 , where @xmath29 and write @xmath30 where @xmath31 resp . @xmath32 are the occurring step sizes . in frequency domain , we have to sample symmetrically with respect to @xmath33 . therefore , we also introduce the interval @xmath34 since we will have to deal with evaluations that are partially in - grid , partially not necessarily in - grid , we will also use combinations of and . in this paper , we will make use of discretizations of the source function @xmath7 , the data function @xmath35 and their fourier transforms @xmath36 resp . @xmath37 . let in the following @xmath38 denote the @xmath18-dimensional discrete fourier transform with respect to space and time . by discretizing formula via riemann sums it follows @xmath39 where @xmath40 this is the formula from @xcite . note that we use the interval notation for the integer multi - indices for notational convenience . moreover , we also choose the length of the fourier transforms to be equal to @xmath41 in the first @xmath4 dimensions , respectively . this could be generalised without changes in practice . now , we assume to sample @xmath35 at @xmath42 , not necessarily uniform , points @xmath43 : then , @xmath44 the term @xmath45 represents the area of the detector surface around @xmath46 and has to fulfil @xmath47 . note that the original formula can be received from by choosing @xmath48 to contain all points on the grid @xmath49 . formula can be interpreted as follows : once we have computed the fourier transform of the data and evaluated the fourier transform at non - equidistant points with respect to the third coordinate , we obtain the ( standard , equispaced ) fourier coefficients of @xmath7 . the image can then be obtained by applying standard fft techniques . the straightforward evaluation of the sums on the right hand side of would lead to a computational complexity of order @xmath50 . usually this is improved by the use of fft methods , which have the drawback that they need both the data and evaluation grid to be equispaced in each coordinate . this means that if we want to compute efficiently , we have to interpolate both in domain- and frequency space . a simple way of doing that is by using polynomial interpolation . it is used for photoacoustic reconstruction purposes for instance in the _ k - wave _ toolbox for matlab @xcite . unfortunately , this kind of interpolation seems to be sub - optimal for fourier - interpolation with respect to both accuracy and computational costs @xcite a regularized inverse k - space interpolation has already been shown to yield better reconstruction results @xcite . the superiority of applying the nufft , compared to linear interpolation , has been shown theoretically and computationally by @xcite . this section is devoted to the brief explanation of the theory and the applicability of the non - uniform fourier transform , where we explain both the ner - nufft ( subsection [ subsec : ner_nufft ] ) and the ned - nufft ( subsection [ subsec : ned_nufft ] ) in the form ( and spatial dimensions ) we utilise them afterwards . the nedner - nufft algorithm used for implementing essentially ( up to scaling factors ) consists of the following steps : 1 . compute a @xmath4 dimensional ned - nufft in the @xmath51-coordinates due to our detector placement . 2 . compute a one - dimensional ner - nufft in the @xmath33-coordinate as indicated by the reconstruction formula . 3 . compute an equispaced @xmath18-dim inverse fft to obtain a @xmath18 dimensional picture of the initial pressure distribution . with the ner - nufft ( non equispaced range non - uniform fft ) it is possible to efficiently evaluate the discrete fourier transform at non - equispaced positions in frequency domain . to this end , we introduce the one dimensional discrete fourier transform , evaluated at non - equispaced grid points @xmath52 : @xmath53 in order to find an efficient algorithm for evaluation of , we use a window function @xmath54 , an oversampling factor @xmath55 and a parameter @xmath56 that satisfy : [ en : psi ] 1 . @xmath54 is continuous inside some finite interval @xmath57 $ ] and has its support in this interval and 2 . @xmath54 is positive in the interval @xmath58 $ ] . then ( see @xcite ) we have the following representation for the fourier modes occurring in ( [ eq : nudft1 ] ) : @xmath59 by assumption , both @xmath54 and @xmath60 are concentrated around @xmath61 . so we approximate the sum over all @xmath62 by the sum over the @xmath63 integers @xmath0 that are closest to @xmath64 . by choosing @xmath65 and inserting in , we obtain @xmath66 here @xmath67 denotes the interpolation length and @xmath68 where @xmath69 is the nearest integer ( i.e. the nearest equispaced grid point ) to @xmath70 . the choice of @xmath54 is made in accordance with the assumptions above , so we need @xmath54 to have compact support . furthermore , to make the approximation in ( [ eq : ner_nufft ] ) reasonable , its fourier transform @xmath71 needs to be concentrated as much as possible in @xmath72 $ ] . in practice , a common choice for @xmath54 is the kaiser - bessel function , which fulfils the needed conditions , and its fourier transform is analytically computable . a second major aim of the present work is to handle data measured at non - equispaced acquisition points @xmath73 in an efficient and accurate way . therefore we introduce the non - equispaced data , @xmath4 dimensional dft @xmath74 the theory for the ned - nufft is largely analogous to the ner - nufft @xcite as described in subsection [ subsec : ner_nufft ] . the representation is here used for each entry of @xmath75 and inserted ( with now setting @xmath76 ) into formula , which leads to @xmath77 where the entries in @xmath78 are the nearest integers to @xmath79 . here we have used the abbreviations @xmath80 for the needed evaluations of @xmath54 and @xmath71 . further remarks on the implementation of the ned- and ner - nufft , as well as a summery about the properties of the kaiser - bessel function and its fourier transform can be found in @xcite . before we turn to the evaluation of the algorithm we describe the photoacoustic setup . our device consists of a fp ( fabry prot ) polymer film sensor for interrogation @xcite . a @xmath81 pulsed laser source and a subsequent optical parametric oscillator ( opo ) provide optical pulses . these pulses have a very narrow bandwidth and can be tuned within the visible and near infrared spectrum . the optical pulses are then transmitted via an optical fibre . when the light is emitted it diverges and impinges upon a sample with homogeneous fluence , thus generating a photoacoustic signal . this signal is then recorded via the fp - sensor head . the sensor head consists of an approximately @xmath82 thick polymer ( parylene c ) which is sandwiched between two dichroic dielectric coatings . these dichroic mirrors have a noteworthy transmission characteristic . light from @xmath83 to @xmath84 can pass the mirrors largely unabated , whereas the reflectivity from @xmath85 to @xmath86 ( sensor interrogation band ) is about 95% @xcite . the incident photoacoustic wave produces a linear change in the optical thickness of the polymer film . a focused continuous wave laser , operating within the interrogation band , can now determine the change of thickness at the interrogation point via fp - interferometry . we choose two 2d targets for comparison , a star and a usaf ( us air force ) resolution test chart . both targets are made of glass with a vacuum - deposited durable chromium coating . the star target has 72 sectors on a pattern diameter of 5 mm , with an unresolved core diameter of @xmath87 . the targets are positioned in parallel to the sensor surface at a distance of about @xmath88 , and water is used as coupling medium between the target and the sensor . the interpolation length for the ner - nufft reconstruction is @xmath89 . the computational times are shown in tab . [ tab : ner - nufft comparison ] showing that the linearly interpolated fft is about 30 % slower than the ner - nufft . -axis of a star sample , reconstructed using fft and linear interpolation ( top left ) and using the nufft ( top right ) with a square plotted around the center . the intensity of the reconstructed image along the sidelines of the square is plotted , for both reconstructions . the purple line indicates the frequency of the star sample.[fig : starphantomreconstruction ] ] a segment of the reconstructed star target is shown in fig . [ fig : starphantomreconstruction ] . the intensity is plotted against the sides of an imaginary square ( @xmath90 ) placed around the center of the star phantom . it is clearly visible , that the fft reconstruction is not able to represent the line pairs , when the density exceeds @xmath91 , corresponding to a resolution of @xmath87 , whereas they are still largely visible for the ner - nufft reconstruction . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] for a quantitative comparison of the resolution we use the usaf chart . it is recorded on an area of @xmath92 sensor points corresponding to @xmath93 with a grid spacing of @xmath94 and a time resolution of @xmath95 . as yet there is no standardized procedure to measure the resolution of a photoacoustic imaging system . we proceed similar to @xcite , by fitting a _ line spread function _ ( lsf ) and an _ edge spread function _ ( esf ) to the intensities of our reconstructed data . for the lsf to be meaningful , its source has to approximate a spatial delta function . this is the case in the @xmath96-axis , since the chrome coating of the usaf target is just about @xmath97 thick . -mip of an usaf chart reconstruction conducted with fft ( left ) and ner - nufft ( right ) . on the bottom images the data - sets used for the quantitative resolution are marked . the black square depicts the 49 @xmath98-coordinates used for the lsf fit along the @xmath96-axis for the axial resolution . the data for a single point is shown in the bottom right inlay . the white lines show the intensity fit for the lateral resolution . the bottom left inlay shows the data for a single white line . [ fig : usaf - chart ] ] we fit a cauchy - lorentz distribution to the @xmath96-axis of our reconstructed data for 49 adjacent @xmath98-coordinates . their positions are marked as a black square within the white square , depicted in the bottom images of fig . [ fig : usaf - chart ] . the reconstruction in the @xmath96-axis for a single point is shown in the bottom right inlay of fig . [ fig : usaf - chart ] , for 8 points , covering a distance of @xmath99 in the @xmath96-direction , around the maximum intensity . a fit of the lorentz distribution is shown for both reconstruction methods . the fwhm ( _ full width , have maximum _ ) of the lorentz distribution , @xmath100 is the parameter @xmath101 . the output @xmath102 is the intensity in dependence from the @xmath96-axis , and @xmath103 and @xmath104 are fitting parameters . the average and standard deviation of @xmath101 for both of the 49 datasets are shown in table [ tab : ner - nufft comparison ] . the line spread function fwhm of the fft - reconstruction turns out to be more than twice as big as the one of the ner - nufft reconstruction . for the lateral resolution , there is no target approximating a delta function , so we have to use the esf instead : @xmath105 the @xmath101 here is the fwhm of the associated lsf , and @xmath106 , @xmath107 and @xmath104 are fitting parameters . the esf requires a step function as source , of which our target provides plenty . we choose the long side of 12 bars , marked by white lines in the bottom images of fig . [ fig : usaf - chart ] , for this fit . the data for a particular line is shown in the bottom left inlay . we omitted all datasets , where only one point marked the transition from low to high intensity , rendering the edge fit unreliable and resulting in unrealistic improvements of our new method well over 100% . finally we averaged over 15 edges . the results are shown in table [ tab : ner - nufft comparison ] . while the deviation between different edges is quite high , the improvement of our ner - nufft reconstruction for the 15 evaluated edges ranged from @xmath108 to @xmath109 . the current setups allow data acquisition at just one single sensor point for each laser pulse excitation . since our laser is operating at @xmath81 data recording of a typical sample requires several minutes . reducing this acquisition time is a crucial step in advancing photoacoustics towards clinical and preclinical application . therefore , in this work we try to maximize the image quality for a given number of acquisition points . we are able to do this , because our newly implemented nedner - nufft is ideal for dealing with non - equispaced positioned sensors . this newly gained flexibility of sensor positioning offers many possibilities to enhance the image quality , compared against a rectangular grid . for instance a hexagonal grid was found to yield an efficiency of @xmath110 compared with @xmath111 for an exact reconstruction of a wave - number limited function @xcite . also any non - equispaced grids that may arrive from a specific experimental setup can be efficiently computed via the nedner - nufft approach . here , we will use it to tackle the limited view problem . many papers deal with the limited view problem , when reconstructing images @xcite . our approach to deal with this problem is different . it takes into account that in many cases the limiting factor is the number of sensor points and the limited view largely a consequence of this limitation . in our approach we therefore use a grid arrangement that is dense close to a center of interest and becomes sparser the further away the sampling points are located . we realize this by means of an equiangular , or equi - steradian sensor arrangement , where for a given point of interest each unit angle or steradian gets assigned one sensor point . ] to understand the limited view problem , it is helpful to define a detection region . according to @xcite , this is the region which is enclosed by the normal lines from the edges of the sensor . pressure waves always travel in the direction of the normal vector of the boundary of the expanding object . therefore certain boundaries are invisible to the detector as depicted in fig . [ fig : fieldofview ] . for the equiangular sensor arrangement a point of interest is chosen . each line , connecting a sensor point with the point of interest , encloses a fixed angle to its adjacent line . in that sense we mimic a circular sensor array on a straight line . the position of the sensor points can be seen on top of the third image in fig . [ fig : tree ] . the obvious expansion of an equiangular projection to 3d is an equi - steradian projection . this problem is analogous to the problem of placing equispaced points on a 3d sphere and then projecting the points , from the center of the sphere , through the points , onto a 2d plane outside the sphere . we developed an algorithm for this problem , which is explained in detail in appendix [ app : equi - ster ] . our input variables are the grid size , the distance of the center of interest from the sensor plane and the desired number of acquisition points , which will be rounded to the next convenient value . a sensor arrangement with 1625 points on a @xmath112 grid is shown in the top left image in fig . [ fig : sensor_masks ] . to determine the weighting term @xmath45 in eq . [ eq : disc_rec ] for 3d we introduce a function that describes the density of equidistant points per unit area @xmath113 . in our specific case , @xmath113 describes the density on a sphere around a center of interest . further we assume that @xmath113 is spherically symmetric and decreases quadratically with the distance from the center of interest @xmath114 : @xmath115 . we now define @xmath116 for a plane positioned at distance @xmath117 from the center of interest . in this case @xmath118 attenuates by a factor of @xmath119 , where @xmath120 is the angle of incidence . hence @xmath121 . by applying the spacing of the regular grid . this yields a weighting term of : @xmath122 analogously we can derive @xmath45 for 2d : @xmath123 we applied a normalization after the reconstruction to all measurements . for the application of this method to the fp setup it is noteworthy that there is a frequency dependency on sensitivity which itself depends on the angle of incidence , which has been extensively discussed in @xcite . the angle of incidence for our specific setup is @xmath124 . at this angle , the frequency components around @xmath125 get attenuated by more than @xmath126 . below @xmath127 the frequency response remains quite stable ( attenuation below @xmath128 for the measurement angles occurring in our setup . ) equispaced sensor arrangement , with a distance of 13 points between each sensor . the third image shows the nedner - nufft reconstruction with equiangular arranged sensor positions . the bottom image shows the same sensor arrangement , but all omitted sensor points are linearly interpolated and afterwards a ner - nufft reconstruction was conducted . [ fig : tree ] ] a tree phantom , designed by brian hurshman and licensed under cc by 3.0 , is chosen for the 2 dimensional computational experiments on a grid with @xmath129 @xmath130 points . a forward simulation is conducted via _ k - wave _ @xcite . the forward simulation of the k - wave toolbox is based on a first order k - space model . a pml ( perfectly matched layer ) of 64 gridpoints is added , as well as @xmath131 of noise . in fig . [ fig : tree ] our computational phantom is shown at the top . for each reconstruction a subset of 32 out of the 1024 possible sensor positions was chosen . in fig . [ fig : tree ] their positions are marked at the top of each reconstructed image . for the equispaced sensor arrangements , we let the distance between two adjacent sensor points sweep from 1 to 32 . the sensor points where always centered in the @xmath132-axis . to compare the different reconstruction methods we used the correlation coefficient and the tenenbaum sharpness . these quality measures are explained in appendix [ app : qualitmeas ] . we applied the correlation coefficient only within the region of interest marked by the white circle in fig . [ fig : tree ] . the tenenbaum sharpness was calculated on the smallest rectangle , containing all pixels within the circle . the results are shown in fig . [ fig : tree_cc ] . . the straight lines indicate the results for the equiangular projection.[fig : tree_cc ] ] the tenenbaum sharpness for the equiangular sensor placement was 23001 , which is above all values for the equispaced arrangements . the correlation coefficient was 0.913 compared to 0.849 , for the best equispaced arrangement . in other words , the equiangular arrangement is 42.3 % closer to a full correlation , than any equispaced grid . in fig . [ fig : tree ] the competing reconstructions are compared . while the crown of the tree is depicted quite well for the equispaced reconstruction , the trunk of the tree is barely visible . this is due to the limited view problem . when the equispaced interval increases , the tree becomes visible , but at the cost of the crown s quality . in the equiangular arrangement a trade off between these two effects is achieved . additionally the weighting term for the outmost sensors is 17 times the weighting term for the sensor point closest to the middle . this amplifies the occurrence of artefacts , particularly outside of our region of interest . the bottom image in fig . [ fig : tree ] shows the equiangular sensor arrangement , reconstructed in a conventional manner . the missing sensor points are interpolated to an equispaced grid , and a ner - nufft reconstruction is applied afterwards . we conducted a linear interpolation from our subset to all 1024 sensor points . the correlation coefficient for this outcome was 0.7348 while the sharpness measure was 21474 . this outcome exemplifies the clear superiority of the nufft to conventional fft reconstruction when dealing with non - equispaced grids . ] for a qualitative assessment of our new sensor arrangement we need a 3d phantom . we choose a yarn which we record on a rectangular grid with @xmath133 sensor points , with a grid spacing of @xmath134 and time sampling of @xmath135 hence an area of @xmath136 is covered . as coupling medium water is used , in which the yarn is fully immersed . to determine the utility of non - equispaced grid sampling , we follow a certain routine . first we acquire a densely sampled dataset . then we use a very small subset of the initially collected sensor data , to test different sensor arrangements . therefore we can always use the complete reconstruction as our model standard together with the quality measurements explained in appendix [ app : qualitmeas ] . an upsampling factor of 2 was used for all reconstructions , hence the reconstructed image of the mip for the @xmath98 plane consists of @xmath137 pixels . the complete reconstruction with the ner - nufft took 154 seconds . maximum intensity projections ( mip ) of this full reconstruction for all axis are shown in fig . [ fig : golden - standard ] . the mip in the @xmath98 plane is our model standard , for comparison with the other reconstructions . sensor points is displayed . the intervall between two adjacent sensor points is @xmath138 for this configuration . the bottom images show mips of the ned - ner - nufft reconstruction only using the sensor points shown above . [ fig : sensor_masks ] ] for the equi - steradian sensor mask we choose our center of interest right in the center of the @xmath98-mip where the little knot can be seen , @xmath139 off the sensor surface . the resulting sensor mask , including the reconstruction is shown in fig . [ fig : sensor_masks ] , it consists of @xmath140 sensor points ( or 3.18 % of the initial number of sensor points ) . the weighting term , accounting for sensor sparsity is 9.7 times higher for the outermost sensor point , than for centermost sensor points in the @xmath98-plane . the reconstruction for this arrangement took 134 seconds . we compared this arrangement to rectangular grids , which all had @xmath141 sensor points ( or 3.29 % of the initial number of sensor points ) but varying distances between two adjacent points . the grid with an interval between sensor points of 5 is shown on the top left in fig . [ fig : sensor_masks ] . ) . in the inlay the correlation coefficient mask is shown for 20087 points which corresponds to all pixels with at least 4% of the maximum value of the model standard and is the value used in fig . [ fig : correlation - coefficient - maskdiameter ] . [ fig : correlation_coefficient_mask ] ] in fig . [ fig : correlation_coefficient_mask ] the equi - steradian grid is compared with 2 equispaced grids . to get a more precise measure of the correlation between the reconstructed images and the model standard , we calculated the correlation coefficient only within a region of interest . the region of interest is firstly confined by a centered disc , whose boundary is shown as a dotted circle in the inlay in fig . [ fig : correlation_coefficient_mask ] . the @xmath132-axis shows the number of pixels of interest used to calculate the correlation coefficient within this disc . these pixels are increased according to the intensity of the corresponding pixels of the model s standard mip . [ fig : correlation_coefficient_mask ] demonstrates that the correlation coefficient for the equi - steradian arrangement , always remains better , within the depicted disc , when competing against the two strongest equispaced grids . corresponds to the straight line in fig . [ fig : correlation_coefficient_mask ] . the other straight lines indicate the side length of the square of a particular equispaced sensor point arrangement . [ fig : correlation - coefficient - maskdiameter ] ] in fig . [ fig : correlation - coefficient - maskdiameter ] the 4 equispaced arrangements , with intervals reaching from 2 to 5 are compared to the equi - steradian grid . here the pixels of interest are set to a threshold of at least 4% of the maximum value , while the diameter is increased . the dotted straight lines indicate the side length of the square of a particular equispaced sensor point arrangement . as expected the correlation coefficient for this equispaced sensor arrangement starts to decline around that threshold . the correlation coefficient for the equi - steradian grid starts to fall behind the equispaced grid of interval 5 towards the end . this is expected , since the equi - steradian grid is only meant to give better results for a region of interest around the center . this is very clearly the case . between a diameter of 2 to 8 mm the correlation coefficient is on average 25.14 % closer to a value of @xmath142 than its strongest equispaced contender of interval 4 , and 30.87 % better than the interval 5 grid . at a diameter of @xmath143 the correlation coefficient for the equi - steradian grid was 0.960 compared to 0.947 for the interval 4 grid and 0.944 for the interval 5 grid . this is 24.8 % and 28.6% closer to full correlation . ] [ fig : tenenbaum - sharpness ] shows the normalized tenenbaum sharpness . the tenenbaum sharpness , unlike the correlation coefficient , can not be calculated on non - adjacent grid points , therefore it has been calculated on the smallest rectangle , that contains all pixels of interest . the equi - steradian has the highest sharpness for most values , with the interval 4 grid being very slightly better around a diameter of 3 - 4 mm . there is a drop of the tenenbaum sharpness towards the end . we computationally implemented a 3d non - uniform fft photoacoustic image reconstruction , called ner - nufft ( non equispaced range - non uniform fft ) to efficiently deal with the non - equispaced fourier transform evaluations arising in the reconstruction formula . this method was compared with the _ k - wave _ implemented fft reconstruction , which uses a polynomial interpolation . the two reconstruction methods where compared using 2d targets . the lateral resolution showed an improvement of @xmath144 which is in good agreement with the illustrative results for the star target . the axial resolution showed an improvement of @xmath145 . the computation time was about @xmath146 less , for the ner - nufft than the linearly interpolated fft reconstruction . in conclusion the ner - nufft reconstruction proved to be unequivocally superior to conventional linear interpolation fft reconstruction methods . we further implemented the ned - ner - nufft ( non equispaced data - ner - nufft ) , which allowed us to efficiently reconstruct from data recorded at non - equispaced placed sensor points . this newly gained flexibility was used to tackle the limited view problem , by placing sensors more sparsely further away from the center of interest . we developed an equiangular sensor placement for 2d and an equi - steradian placement in 3d , which assigns one sensor point to each angle / steradian for a given center of interest . in the 2d computational simulations we showed that this arrangement significantly enhances image quality in comparison to regular grids . in 3d we conducted experiments , where a yarn phantom was recorded . the maximum intensity projection ( mip ) of the full reconstruction was compared to mips of reconstructions that only used about 3% of the original data . within our region of interest , the correlation of our image was 0.96 , which is 24.8% closer to full correlation than the best equispaced arrangement , reconstructed from slightly more sensor points . the sensor placement to tackle the limited view problem , combined with the ned - ner - nufft gives significantly better results for an object located at the center of a bigger sensor surface . this result was confirmed in the 2d simulation as well as for real data in 3d . this work is supported by the medical university of vienna , the european projects famos ( fp7 ict 317744 ) and fun oct ( fp7 health 201880 ) , macular vision research foundation ( mvrf , usa ) , austrian science fund ( fwf ) , project p26687-n25 ( interdisciplinary coupled physics imaging ) , and the christian doppler society ( christian doppler laboratory `` laser development and their application in medicine '' ) . [ 1]#10=0=0 0 by1pt#1 10 [ 1]#1 urlstyle [ 1]doi # 1 p. beard . biomedical photoacoustic imaging . , 1:602631 , 2011 . p.c . beard . two - dimensional ultrasound receive array using an angle - tuned fabry - perot polymer film sensor for transducer field characterization and transmission ultrasound imaging . , 52(6):10021012 , june 2005 . beard , f. perennes , and t.n . transduction mechanisms of the fabry - perot polymer film sensing concept for wideband ultrasound detection . , 46(6):15751582 , november 1999 . p. burgholzer , c. hofer , g. paltauf , m. haltmeier , and o. scherzer . thermoacoustic tomography with integrating area and line detectors . , 52(9):15771583 , september 2005 . cox and p.c . the frequency - dependent directivity of a planar fabry - perot polymer film ultrasound sensor . , 54(2):394404 , 2007 . w. dan , c. tao , x .- j . liu , and x .- d . influence of limited - view scanning on depth imaging of photoacoustic tomography . , 21(1):014301 , 2012 . k. fourmont . non - equispaced fast fourier transforms with applications to tomography . , 9(5):431450 , 2003 . f. c. a. groen , i. t. young , and g. ligthart . a comparison of different focus functions for use in autofocus algorithms . , 6(2):8191 , 1985 . m. haltmeier , o. scherzer , and g. zangerl . a reconstruction algorithm for photoacoustic imaging based on the nonuniform fft . , 28(11):17271735 , november 2009 . m. jaeger , s. schpbach , a. gertsch , m. kitz , and m. frenz . fourier reconstruction in optoacoustic imaging using truncated regularized inverse k - space interpolation . , 23:s51s63 , 2007 . p. kuchment and l. kunyansky . mathematics of thermoacoustic tomography . , 19:191224 , 2008 . g. paltauf , r. nuster , m. haltmeier , and p. burgholzer . photoacoustic tomography with integrating area and line detectors . in l. v. wang , editor , _ photoacoustic imaging and spectroscopy _ , optical science and engineering , pages 251263 . crc press , boca raton , fl , 2009 . d. p. petersen and d. middleton . sampling and reconstruction of wave - number - limited functions in @xmath147-dimensional euclidean spaces . , 5:279323 , 1962 . o. scherzer , editor . . springer , new york , 2011 . r. schulze , g. zangerl , m. holotta , d. meyer , f. handle , r. nuster , g. paltauf , and o. scherzer . on the use of frequency - domain reconstruction algorithms for photoacoustic imaging . , 16(8):086002 , 2011 . funded by the austrian science fund ( fwf ) within the fsp s105 - `` photoacoustic imaging '' . c. tao and x. liu . reconstruction of high quality photoacoustic tomography with a limited - view scanning . , 18(3):27602766 , feb 2010 . b. e. treeby and b. t. cox . -wave : matlab toolbox for the simulation and reconstruction of photoacoustic wace fields . , 15:021314 , 2010 . b. e. treeby , t. k. varslot , e. z. zhang , j. g. laufer , and p. c. beard . automatic sound speed selection in photoacoustic image reconstruction using an autofocus approach . , 16(9):0905010905013 , 2011 . l. v. wang , editor . . optical science and engineering . crc press , boca raton , 2009 . m. xu and l. v. wang . exact frequency - domain reconstruction for thermoacoustic tomography i : planar geometry . , 21:823828 , 2002 . m. xu and l. v. wang . time - domain reconstruction for thermoacoustic tomography in a spherical geometry . , 21(7):814822 , 2002 . m. xu and l. v. wang . analytic explanation of spatial resolution related to bandwidth and detector aperture size in thermoacoustic or photoacoustic reconstruction . , 67(5):056605105660515 , 2003 . m. xu and l. v. wang . universal back - projection algorithm for photoacoustic computed tomography . , 71(1 ) , 2005 . m. xu and l. v. wang . photoacoustic imaging in biomedicine . , 77(4 ) , 2006 . y. xu , d. feng , and l. v. wang . exact frequency - domain reconstrcution for thermoacoustic tomography i : planar geometry . , 21(7):823828 , 2002 . y. xu , l. v. wang , g. ambartsoumian , and p. kuchment . reconstructions in limited - view thermoacoustic tomography . , 31(4):724733 , 2004 . e. zhang , j. laufer , and p. beard . backward - mode multiwavelength photoacoustic scanner using a planar fabry - perot polymer film ultrasound sensor for high - resolution three - dimensional imaging of biological tissues . , 47:561577 , 2008 . in our algorithm , the grid size and the distance of the center of interest from the sensor plane is defined . the number of sensor points @xmath147 will be rounded to the next convenient value . our point of interest is placed at @xmath148 , centered at a square @xmath98 grid . the point of interest is the center of a spherical coordinate system , with the polar angle @xmath149 at the @xmath96-axis towards the @xmath98-grid . first we determine the steradian @xmath150 of the spherical cap from the point of interest , that projects onto the acquistion point plane via @xmath151 this leads to a unit steradian @xmath152 with @xmath147 being the number of sensors one would like to record the signal with . the sphere cap is then subdivided into slices @xmath0 which satisfy the condition @xmath153 where @xmath154 encloses exactly one unit steradian @xmath155 and @xmath156 has to be a power of two , in order to guarantee some symmetry . the value of @xmath156 doubles , when @xmath157 , where @xmath158 is the chord length between two points on @xmath0 and @xmath159 is the distance to the closest point on @xmath160 . these values are chosen in order to guarantee we apply some restrictions to approximate equidistance between acquisition points on the sensor surface . the azimuthal angles for a slice @xmath0 are calulated according to : @xmath161 with @xmath162 , where @xmath163 stems from the former slice @xmath160 . the sensor points are now placed on the @xmath98-plane at the position indicated by the spherical angular coordinates : @xmath164 the correlation coefficient @xmath165 is a measure of the linear dependence between two images @xmath166 and @xmath167 . its range is @xmath168 $ ] and a correlation coefficient close to 1 indicates linear dependence @xcite . it is defined via the variance , @xmath169 of each image and the covariance , @xmath170 of the two images : @xmath171 we did not choose the widely used @xmath172 distance measure because it is a morphological distance measure , meaning it defines the distance between two images by the distance between their level sets . therefore two identical linearly dependent images can have a correlation coefficient of @xmath142 and still a huge @xmath172 distance . normalizing the images only mitigates this problem , because single , high intensity artifacts or a varying intensity over the whole image can greatly alter the @xmath172 distance . while the correlation coefficient is a good measure for the overall similarity between two images it does not include any sharpness measure . hence blurred edges are punished very little , in comparison to slight variations of homogeneous areas . to address this shortcoming we chose a sharpness measure or focus function as a second quality criterion . sharpness measures are obtained from some measure of the high frequency content of an image @xcite . they have also been used to select the best sound speed in photoacoustic image reconstruction @xcite . out of the plethora of published focus functions we select the tenenbaum function , because of its robustness to noise : like the @xmath175 norm and unlike the correlation coefficient the tenenbaum function is an extensive measure , meaning it increases with image dimensions . therefore we normalized it to @xmath176 , where @xmath147 is the number of elements in @xmath5 .
Abstract: | [
"to obtain the initial pressure from the collected data on a planar sensor arrangement in photoacoustic tomography , there exists an exact analytic frequency domain reconstruction formula . an efficient realization of this formula needs to cope with the evaluation of the data s fourier transform on a non - equispaced mesh . in this paper , we use the non - uniform fast fourier transform to handle this issue and show its feasibility in 3d experiments . this is done in comparison to the standard approach that uses polynomial interpolation . moreover , we investigate the effect and the utility of flexible sensor location on the quality of photoacoustic image reconstruction . the computational realization is accomplished by the use of a multi - dimensional non - uniform fast fourier algorithm , where non - uniform data sampling is performed both in frequency and spatial domain . we show that with appropriate sampling the imaging quality can be significantly improved . reconstructions with synthetic and real data show the superiority of this method . * keywords : * image reconstruction , photoacoustics , non - uniform fft"
] | 7,815 | 7,815 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: over the last two decades , the application of ion traps has expanded from mass spectrometry @xcite and frequency standards @xcite towards engineering of quantum systems which can be used for quantum computation @xcite and quantum simulation @xcite . it is commonly accepted that large - scale trapped ion quantum information processors require micrometer - scale ion traps @xcite . such traps usually suffer from excessive electric field noise close to metallic surfaces at room temperature , but at cryogenic temperatures this noise is strongly reduced @xcite . thus , it seems natural to move towards cryogenic experimental setups which have the additional advantage that the ambient pressure is usually a few orders of magnitude lower than at room temperature . this enables trapping of longer ion strings due to fewer collisions with background gas . furthermore , no bake - out procedure of the vacuum vessel is required , allowing for rapid trap cycle times . + the operation of paul traps requires high radio - frequency ( rf ) voltages , which are usually generated with the aid of the voltage gain present in rf resonators . for this purpose , helical resonators are typically used in the frequency regime up to 50mhz , whereas for experiments requiring higher drive frequencies coaxial resonators have been used as well @xcite . in cryogenic experiments , the resonator needs to fulfill different criteria than in room temperature experiments where the resonator can be placed outside the vacuum vessel . in particular , the connections in a cryostat need to have low thermal conductivity to limit the thermal load . following the wiedemann - franz law , this results in a low electrical conductivity between room - temperature and the cryogenic parts of the experiment . thus , the resonators have to be operated at the cold - stage . moreover , space constraints are stricter in cryogenic systems which makes helical resonators undesirable as they are generally bulky . to minimize the volume of the resonator , an rlc - series - resonator can be used @xcite . + in section [ sec : general considerations ] , we focus on the choice of the trap drive frequency , the required voltage gain , and voltage monitoring . section [ sec : coil design ] covers coil design for three types of coils , and in the following section [ sec : matching ] , we discuss impedance matching of the resonator and present an efficient way to match cryogenic resonators . section [ sec : rf shield ] focuses on the design of rf shielding , and finally , we present the results in section [ sec : results ] . in trapped ion experiments , rf - voltages of several hundreds of volts are commonly applied to the trap , which has a simple capacitor as its electrical circuit equivalent . thus , we need to design a resonator that maximizes the rf - voltage at this capacitor for a given input power . in this section , we discuss general considerations in resonator design which are not limited to a specific resonator type . at first , we consider the losses in an rlc - resonator and its scaling with frequency . from the solution of the equation of motion of a trapped ion in a paul trap ( mathieu equation ) , one obtains the trap voltages with the stability parameter @xmath0 @xcite , which scales as @xmath1 where @xmath2 is the amplitude of the rf - voltage at the trap and @xmath3 is the trap drive ( angular ) frequency . hence , for constant @xmath0 the loss power scales as @xmath4 a low trap drive frequency will reduce the losses . on the other hand , high secular motion frequencies of the ion in the trap are desirable for operation . higher secular frequencies require a higher @xmath3 , and thus the desired secular frequencies set a lower limit for @xmath3 . in this study , we aim for a @xmath0 around 0.25 , an axial secular frequency of 1mhz , and both radial frequencies to be 3.7mhz . this will require a trap drive frequency of @xmath5 42.6mhz . simulations of our trap show that we need a drive voltage of about @xmath6 to reach the desired trap frequencies . in order to limit the thermal load onto the cryostat from dissipated power in the resonator , this voltage should be reached with less than 100mw of rf input power . this power corresponds to a consumption of about 1/7l of liquid helium per hour when operating a wet cryostat at 4.2k @xcite . ( 0,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 5.2,1.75 ) ; ( 5,1.75 ) to [ r=@xmath7 ( 6.5,1.75 ) ; ( 6.3,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.9,1.75 ) ; ( 6.9,1.75 ) to [ l=@xmath8 ( 8,1.75 ) ; ( 8,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , i=@xmath9 ( 9,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 9,1.15 ) ; ( 9,1.2 ) to [ c=@xmath10 ( 9,0.8 ) ; ( 9,0.85 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 9,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,0.25 ) ; ( 0,0.35 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,1.75 ) ; ( 9,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * -o ] ( 11,0.25 ) ; ( 11,0.35 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 11,1.75 ) ; ( 11,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- * ] ( 9,1.75 ) ; at ( 2.5,1 ) * matching * ; fig . [ fig : general matching ] shows an rlc - series - resonator driven through a matching network . in the following , we will assume perfect impedance matching with a loss - less matching network . thus , we can set the input power equal to the loss power in the resonator @xmath13 , where @xmath14 with @xmath15 being the input voltage supplied to the circuit and @xmath16 the wave impedance of the connecting cable , commonly @xmath17 . we can further write @xmath18 where @xmath19 is the current in the resonator , @xmath20 its effective loss resistance , @xmath3 its frequency , @xmath21 the voltage at the capacitor , and @xmath22 the capacitor representing the trap . thus , we obtain @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the voltage gain of the circuit , defined as @xmath25 . + the quality factor @xmath26 of a resonator is defined as the resonance frequency @xmath27 divided by the bandwidth @xmath28 @xmath29 in trapped ion experiments , we are usually not interested in a small bandwidth around @xmath3 but rather in a large voltage gain at the trap drive frequency . it should be noted that the voltage gain and bandwidth are qualitatively but not necessary quantitatively the same for different types of resonators . the quantity that is of direct interest for our application is the voltage gain , which can be derived from ( [ eq : matching 1 ] ) as @xmath30 with the quality factor of an ideal rlc resonator @xmath31 . this indicates that both , the capacitive load , and the effective resistance of the resonator should be minimized . ( 0,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 3.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , i=@xmath9 ( 4.5,1.75 ) ; ( 4.4,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 5.4,1.75 ) ; ( 5.3,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.9,1.75 ) ; ( 5.9,1.75 ) to [ l , l_=@xmath8 ( 7,1.75 ) ; ( 7,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.5,1.1 ) ; ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 7.5,0.25 ) ; ( 7.5,0.9 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,0.25 ) ; ( 0,0.35 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,1.75 ) ; ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath32 , color = black , * - ] ( 9.5,1.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath33 ( 9.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 7.5,0.25 ) ; ( 7.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 8.4,1.75 ) ; ( 9.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * -o ] ( 11.5,0.25 ) to [ open , v=@xmath34 ( 11.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- * ] ( 9.5,1.75 ) ; ( 8.6,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 11.5,1.75 ) ; ( 11.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , o- * ] ( 7.5,0.25 ) ; ( 9.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 9.5,0.9 ) ; ( 9.5,1.75 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 9.5,1.1 ) ; ( 7.4,3 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7.4,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,2.5 ) ; ( 7,2.5 ) to [ l , l_=@xmath35 ( 5.9,2.5 ) ; ( 5.9,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,3 ) ; ( 7.4,3 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 7.4,3.5 ) ; ( 7.4,3.5 ) to [ open , v=@xmath36 ( 5.4,3.5 ) ; ( 5.4,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 5.4,3 ) ; ( 7.7 , 0.3 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 7.7,1.75 ) ; at ( 2.25,1 ) * matching * ; voltage pick - ups are not required for the operation of the trap , but are useful to measure the voltage on the trap and are required to actively stabilize the rf voltage on the trap . in this section , we discuss inductive and capacitive pick - up , as shown in fig . [ fig : general pickup ] . + a capacitive pick - up consists of a voltage divider parallel to the trap , where @xmath37 , which leads to the pick - up voltage @xmath38 @xmath39 has to be small compared to the trap capacitance @xmath22 , or the capacitive load of the rlc - resonator will increase significantly , reducing @xmath24 as shown in ( [ eq : matching 2 ] ) . typical values for @xmath40 are several hundred times the value of @xmath39 . + in an ideal rlc - series - resonator , the voltage on the coil is the same as the voltage at the capacitor but with a phase shift . we can monitor the voltage at the coil as a signal proportional to the voltage at the trap since we are only interested in the amplitude of the trap voltage . here , @xmath41 and @xmath42 are coupled , and the pick - up voltage can be estimated with the derivations from ref . + in order to maintain low losses , the pick - up should not add significant losses in the resonator . if one uses a coaxial cable with a wave impedance @xmath16 to monitor the pick - up signal , a resistor @xmath16 is used as a termination to avoid reflections . the losses are then @xmath43 which need to be small compared to the losses in the resonator @xmath44 . + in general , we recommend using an inductive pick - up , because it does not increase the capacitive load , which would reduce the voltage gain . however for experiments , which frequently test different traps , a capacitive pick - up may be preferable since the more accurate ratio between pick - up and applied voltage facilitates estimating trapping parameters . surface traps for cryogenic environments typically use a high - quality dielectric carrier material and thus the losses in the resonator are usually dominated by the coil . in this study , we demonstrate the design and production of compact and low - loss coils that should allow us to drive our resonator under the conditions stated in section [ sec : gen considerations - choose trap drive ] . coils produced with machines are desirable because the production process is reproducible . furthermore , we prefer toroid coils as they guide the magnetic field in their center , making them less sensitive to their environment . in our application , ferromagnetic core materials are undesirable , because they would induce spatial inhomogeneities of the magnetic field near the trap . we estimate the load capacitance of our resonator to be 10pf , which at a given resonance frequency of 42.6mhz yields a required inductance of 1.4@xmath45h . kamby and coworkers @xcite demonstrated the integration of toroidal rf - inductors into printed circuit boards ( pcb ) . these coils can be fully produced by machines and in this study we will refer to these inductors as pcb coils . @xcite provides specific formulas for the inductance @xmath41 , the resistance of one segment @xmath46 , and the resistance of one via @xmath47 of pcb coils . in order to minimize the losses of the coil we want to minimize the resistance of one winding while maintaining a constant cross - section to keep the inductance constant the resistance of one winding is defined by @xmath48 where @xmath49 and @xmath50 are the outer and the inner radius of the pcb coil , @xmath51 is the thickness of the pcb , and @xmath52 and @xmath53 are the average length - dependent resistances of a segment and a via . @xmath52 and @xmath53 depend on the exact geometry , but usually vias have similar cross - sections as the segments making their length - dependent resistances approximately equal . that means , in order to minimize ( [ eq : pcb coils minimize resistance ] ) and to keep the cross section of the coil constant , @xmath54 and @xmath51 should be similar in size . + we chose rogers 4350b as the substrate material , because it has a small loss tangent , a similar thermal expansion coefficient as copper , and is ultra - high vacuum compatible . the thickest available rogers 4350b had 3.1 mm thickness , which is unfortunately too thin to minimize the resistance for a given cross - section . + we produced this type of coil in - house and during multiple iterations , we varied the size and the number of vias . the lowest losses for our production process could be achieved with the design depicted in fig . [ fig : pcb coil ] . the pcb coil has an outer diameter of 35 mm and an inner diameter 20.4 mm with a substrate thickness of 3.1 mm . its 64 windings result in an inductance of 1.4@xmath45h . we added one winding which is galvanically isolated from the rest of the coil . this winding acts as an inductive pick - up and should thus be as reproducible as the entire coil . for the second type of coils , wire coils , we wound a single wire around a rigid structure leading to a similar geometry as the pcb coils . such a coil is less reproducible than a pcb coil since the wire length will vary for each coil . hence , its inductance and its resistance will vary as well . a coil with the same geometry as for the pcb coils above , made out of silver - plated copper on a rogers 4350b substrate , is shown in fig . [ fig : wire coil ] . + in wire coils , the cross - section of the core of a wire coil is bigger than that of a pcb coil , because the wire bends are less sharp . hence , we expect the inductance of a wire coil to be higher than the one of a pcb coil with the same nominal geometry . the 0.4 mm thick silver - plated copper wire , which we used for the wire coil , had a cross - section similar to the average cross - section of a pcb coil . therefore , we expect similar losses in both types of coils with the same geometries . these considerations allow us to characterize the production processes of the pcb coils by comparing the two types of coils . higher losses in the pcb coils are an indication that the production of the pcb coils can be improved . + since we do not need traces on the substrate , it is possible use any machinable material with a low loss tangent . we also produced wire coils with a teflon core since it has a lower loss tangent and a lower dielectric constant than rogers 4350b . thus , the losses will be less affected by the core material and the self - resonance frequency of the coil will be higher . another option to minimize the losses in the coil can be to use a superconducting wire to reduce the ohmic losses of the resonator . the quality factor of the presented coils are limited by the ohmic resistance of the conductor . thus , a coil based on a superconductor is expected to result in lower losses in the resonator . furthermore , it could be necessary to operate the experiment at temperatures above 15k to reduce the liquid helium consumption in wet cryostats . at these temperatures , a superconductor with a high critical temperature such as a high temperature superconductor ( hts ) is required . however , a coil made from a readily available hts material needs to be a two - dimensional ( 2d ) structure due to manufacturing constraints , and we choose to use a spiral coil as shown in fig . [ fig : hts coil ] . + since such coils require only 2d structuring , they can be manufactured in a very accurate and reproducible way . for the demonstrated spiral coil , a high - temperature superconductor ( hts ) was produced by _ _ ceraco ceramic coating__. our coils were made out of an yttrium barium copper oxide ( ybco ) film of 330 nm thickness on a sapphire wafer . to facilitate soldered connections , a 200 nm film of gold was placed on top of the superconductor . the critical temperature of this ybco film is above 87k , and its critical current density is higher than @xmath55a/@xmath56 at 77k . we can derive the peak current in the coil from section [ sec : general considerations ] to be 0.64a . hence , traces with a width of more than 100@xmath45 m are required to stay below the critical current density . + for our square spiral coils , we chose a trace width of 300@xmath45 m , a trace gap of 150@xmath45 m , and 10 windings . we designed 9 different coils varying the outer diameter between 14 and 20 mm . equation 4.1 of reference @xcite gives an estimate for the inductance , which results in target inductances between 1.2@xmath45h and 1.6@xmath45h for our coils . this design should allow for coils with very high quality factors already at temperatures accessible with liquid nitrogen instead of liquid helium . + it should be noted here that superconductors are perfect diamagnets , which are spatial inhomogeneities for magnetic fields . one can align the 2d plane of the spiral coil with the spatially homogeneous magnetic field of the experiment to minimize this effect , but one should always keep this in mind . the resonator is connected to the source through a cable with a given wave resistance @xmath16 , typically 50@xmath3 . the complex voltage reflection coefficient @xmath57 at the transition from the cable to the resonator @xcite is then @xmath58 where @xmath59 is the complex reflected voltage , @xmath60 is the complex incoming voltage , and @xmath61 is the complex impedance of the resonator . the reflected power coefficient @xmath62 is then just @xmath63 . since rlc - series resonators have a very low impedance on resonance , @xmath64 , the transition from a 50@xmath3-cable to the resonator on resonance will reflect almost all the inserted power . in order to minimize the reflection , a properly designed impedance matching network is required . the most commonly used matching network is the @xmath41-network as it is the simplest , consisting only of two circuit elements . + ( 0,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 1.15,5.75 ) ; ( 1.05,5.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath65 ( 1.45,5.75 ) ; ( 1.35,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.1,5.75 ) ; ( 3,5.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 4,5.75 ) ; ( 3.9,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.05,5.75 ) ; ( 4.9,5.75 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l , l=@xmath8 ( 6,5.75 ) ; ( 5.8,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,4.85 ) ; ( 6.5,4.95 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 6.5,4.55 ) ; ( 6.5,4.65 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,3.75 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,3.75 ) ; ( 0,3.85 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,5.75 ) ; ( 2.25,5.75 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 2.25,5.05 ) ; ( 2.25,5.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath66 , color = black ] ( 2.25,4.15 ) ; ( 2.25,4.35 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.25,3.75 ) ; ( 6.7 , 3.8 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 6.7,5.75 ) ; ( -1.5,6 ) node [ ] ; ( 0,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 0.85,2.25 ) ; ( 0.7,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , l=@xmath66 ] ( 1.8,2.25 ) ; ( 1.6,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.1,2.25 ) ; ( 3,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 4,2.25 ) ; ( 3.9,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.05,2.25 ) ; ( 4.9,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , l , l=@xmath8 ( 6,2.25 ) ; ( 5.8,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,1.35 ) ; ( 6.5,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 6.5,1.05 ) ; ( 6.5,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.5,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 0,0.25 ) ; ( 0,0.35 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( 0,2.25 ) ; ( 2.25,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 2.25,1.35 ) ; ( 2.25,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath68 , color = black ] ( 2.25,1.05 ) ; ( 2.25,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.25,0.25 ) ; ( 6.7 , 0.3 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 6.7,2.25 ) ; ( -1.5,2.5 ) node [ ] ; fig . [ fig : matching networks ] shows the two possible @xmath41-networks where the reactance parallel to the resonator transforms the real part of the impedance to be @xmath16 . the resulting imaginary term is small compared to @xmath16 ( for low loss resonators ) and can be compensated with the series reactance . + and matching coil @xmath69 for the matching networks of fig . [ fig : matching networks ] over a varying quality factor of the coil . the matching is calculated for a 50@xmath3-cable , an inductor of 1.4@xmath45h , and a capacitor of 10pf . ] the resonator s quality factor from ( [ eq : quality factor - bandwidth ] ) can be written as @xmath70 for an rlc - series resonator . [ fig : matching network simulation ] shows the required values for the matching capacitor @xmath71 and inductance @xmath69 as a function of the quality factor of the coil with inductance of 1.4@xmath45h . for quality factors around 1000 , the required inductance @xmath69 is in the range of 10nh . thin traces on a pcb have approximately a length - dependent inductance of 1nh / mm . therefore , small deviations in the trace length will lead to inefficient matching . the strong dependence of the matching on the reactance parallel to the resonator makes the matching network from fig . [ fig : matching networks]b ) more favorable , because capacitances of several hundred pf can be adjusted with much more precision than inductances of about 10nh . one can incorporate the inductance @xmath69 into the trace on the pcb from the coaxial connector to the matching capacitance , by setting this distance between 1 and 2 cm . hence , we expect a power reflection of 1% or less even without adding an additional inductor . + ( -0.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 3.6,2.25 ) ; ( 3.5,2.25 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 4.5,2.25 ) ; ( 4.4,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.45,2.25 ) ; ( 5.4,2.25 ) to [ l , l=@xmath8 ( 6.6,2.25 ) ; ( 6.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,1.35 ) ; ( 7,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath10 ( 7,1.05 ) ; ( 7,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 7,0.25 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( -0.5,0.25 ) ; ( -0.5,0.25 ) to [ open , v^=@xmath11 ( -0.5,2.25 ) ; ( 1.75,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 1.75 , 1.35 ) ; ( 1.75,1.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath68 , color = black ] ( 1.75,1.05 ) ; ( 1.75,1.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 1.75 , 0.25 ) ; ( 2.75,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 2.75 , 1.65 ) ; ( 2.75,1.85 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , l=@xmath72 , color = black ] ( 2.75,0.65 ) ; ( 2.75,0.85 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.75 , 0.25 ) ; ( 7.2 , 0.3 ) to [ open , v=@xmath12 ( 7.2,2.25 ) ; rf transformers or baluns on the rf input side are commonly used to avoid ground loops between the rf source and the experiment . when using the circuit from fig . [ fig : matching networks]b ) in combination with a transformer , the dc potential of the trap electrodes is not defined . we mitigate this by adding an rf - choke parallel to the matching capacitor , where @xmath73 , as depicted in fig . [ fig : matching network choice ] . + -cable , an inductor of 1.4@xmath45h , and a capacitor of 10pf , thus a resonance frequency of 42.6mhz . the red lines show the values for a fixed capacitance @xmath71 chosen for an ideal matching of @xmath74 . in a ) , one can see the required matching capacitor as a function of the quality factor of the coil @xmath75 . b ) shows the change in resonance frequency of an ideal match . in c ) , the voltage gain is plotted over @xmath75 . d ) shows the reflection coefficient of the matching network . ] in a cryostat , it is impractical to adjust the matching capacitance @xmath71 during or after a cool down . hence , we have to find an efficient way of choosing the best value for @xmath71 with a minimum number of temperature cycles . for this , we simulated our matching circuit for varying and also for a constant value of @xmath71 . [ fig : matching reflection ] shows results of simulations where the fixed capacitor value was chosen for a match at @xmath74 . fig . [ fig : matching reflection]a ) depicts an increase of the optimum @xmath71 with increasing @xmath75 . [ fig : matching reflection]b ) illustrates the dependence of the matched resonance frequency on @xmath75 . in fig . [ fig : matching reflection]c ) , the simulations confirm the dependence of the voltage gain on @xmath75 , following from ( [ eq : matching 2 ] ) . if the physical value for @xmath75 is smaller than the expected value , used to chose the fixed matching capacitor , the voltage gain is about the same than for an ideal match . but if the actual quality factor @xmath75 is higher than the expected value , the voltage gain will be lower than with an ideal match . hence underestimating the quality factor of the coil should be avoided since it would result in a significantly lower voltage gain . [ fig : matching reflection]d ) shows the reflection coefficient as a function of @xmath75 . the effect of @xmath69 is small and thus it was omitted for these simulations . we can see that even without @xmath69 , but with an ideally matched @xmath71 , a low reflection coefficient can be achieved . if one chooses a constant value for @xmath71 at a match for @xmath74 , the reflected power will stay below 5% even if @xmath75 varies between 800 and 2000 . + the parameters for exact impedance matching can be estimated with one additional cooling cycle . for the first cycle , one has to guess the value for @xmath75 and adjust @xmath71 according to simulations following the approach of fig . [ fig : matching reflection]a ) . when the resonator is cold , the reflection coefficient is measured and compared with the simulations in fig . [ fig : matching reflection]d ) . the measured reflection coefficient can then only correspond to two values for @xmath75 . if the reflection coefficient passed a minimum during cool - down , one should choose the higher value , if not , the lower value of @xmath75 . with this new value for @xmath75 , one can calculate the correct matching capacitor value @xmath71 . our experience shows that this method will yield a power reflection coefficient of less than 2% for the second cool down . rf resonators emit electromagnetic radiation , which needs to be shielded to minimize unwanted rf interference in other parts of the experiment . the rf shield needs to be grounded , and thereby generates a capacitance between the resonator and ground . this capacitance has to be minimized as suggested in ( [ eq : matching 2 ] ) . in order to keep the resonator compact , we have to find a trade - off between the size of the shield and the capacitance added by it . + ( 1,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( 2.1,2.5 ) ; ( 2,2.5 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , r=@xmath7 ( 3,2.5 ) ; ( 2.9,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.55,2.5 ) ; ( 3.4,2.5 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath8 ( 4.5,2.5 ) ; ( 4.3,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,2.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.2,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.2,1.735 ) ; ( 6.2,1.825 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c=@xmath10 ( 6.2,1.425 ) ; ( 6.2,1.525 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 6.2,1 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,1 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.5,0.75 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( 1,0.75 ) ; ( 5.5,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 4.8,2.25 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,1.725 ) ; ( 4.8,1.825 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1cm , c , l_=@xmath76 ( 4.8,1.425 ) ; ( 4.8,1.525 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,1 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 5.5,1 ) ; ( 5.1,3 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.6,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.362,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,4.538 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.4,4.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.762,4.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,4.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,3.462 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.8,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.6,3.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 5.127,2.973 ) ; ( -1.5,7 ) to [ short , color = black , o- ] ( -0.9,7 ) ; ( -1,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , r=@xmath77 ( 0,7 ) ; ( -0.1,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 0.35,7 ) ; ( 0.25,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath78 ( 1.25,7 ) ; ( 1.15,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 1.75,7 ) ; ( 1.5,7 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 1.5,6.35 ) ; ( 1.5,6.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , c , l_=@xmath79 ( 1.5,6.05 ) ; ( 1.5,6.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 1.5,5.5 ) ; ( 1.75,5.5 ) to [ short , color = black , -o ] ( -1.5,5.5 ) ; ( 2.24,6.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.25,6.25 ) ; ( 2.51,6.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.5,6.25 ) ; ( 2.74,6.25 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 2.75,6.25 ) ; ( 3.25,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.6,7 ) ; ( 3.5,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , r=@xmath77 ( 4.5,7 ) ; ( 4.4,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 4.85,7 ) ; ( 4.75,7 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , l=@xmath78 ( 5.75,7 ) ; ( 5.65,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 8,7 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 8,6.35 ) ; ( 6,7 ) to [ short , color = black , * - ] ( 6,6.35 ) ; ( 6,6.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , c , l_=@xmath79 ( 6,6.05 ) ; ( 6,6.15 ) to [ short , color = black , - * ] ( 6,5.5 ) ; ( 8,6.45 ) to [ /tikz / circuitikz / bipoles / length=1 cm , c=@xmath10 ( 8,6.05 ) ; ( 8,6.15 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 8,5.5 ) to [ short , color = black ] ( 3.25,5.5 ) ; ( -1.5,7.75 ) to[out=-90,in=-180 ] ( -1.4,8 ) to[out=0,in=-90 ] ( 0.125,8.25 ) to[out=-90,in=-180 ] ( 1.65,8 ) to[out=-0,in=-90 ] ( 1.75,7.75 ) ; ( 0.125,8.75 ) circle(0pt)node[anchor = north]half a winding ; ( -1.5,5.25 ) to[out=-90,in=180 ] ( -1.25,5 ) to[out=0,in=180 ] ( 1.5,5.25 ) to[out=0,in=+90 ] ( 2.375,4.7 ) to[out=+90,in=+180 ] ( 3.25,5.25 ) to[out=0,in=180 ] ( 6,5 ) to[out=0,in=-90 ] ( 6.25,5.25 ) ; ( 2.375,4.05 ) circle(0pt)node[anchor = south]x 2n ; first , we need to find a model for the shield capacitance @xmath80 . [ fig : shield cap model ] depicts a model where we divide the coil in 2@xmath81 half windings . each has an ohmic resistance of @xmath82 , an inductance @xmath83 , and a capacitance to the shield @xmath84 . we can estimate @xmath84 with the standard formula for a parallel - plate capacitor if we assume that the grounded shield is parallel to the coil . from the calculations of the impedance of the entire circuit , we can extract the effective capacitance @xmath80 that occurs due to the presence of the shield . + the results of these simulations for our pcb coils with an outer radius of 17.5 mm and an inner radius of 10.2 mm are shown in fig . [ fig : shield cap simulation ] . it can be seen that a distance of about 2 mm is sufficient to keep the additional capacitive load below 1pf . adapted simulations for the wire coils yield results similar to the ones for the pcb coils . hence , we can use the same shield for both types of coils . + we expect that the capacitance caused by the shield for the spiral coils is even smaller , because its surface is smaller . additionally , if we place the spiral coil in the center of the same shield , the distance to the shield will be 1.55 mm bigger than for the other coils . hence , the capacitance to ground will decrease further . moreover , the shield has an influence on the magnetic field lines of the spiral coil in this configuration and thereby also on the inductance and the losses of the coil . + at room temperature , the penetration depth due to skin effect in copper at frequencies around 40mhz is about 10@xmath45 m . thus , any mechanically stable shield , of a couple of 1/10 mm thickness , should yield a suitable attenuation . [ fig : resonator with shield ] shows a resonator encased in a silver - plated copper shield . the dimensions of this resonator are 57 mm x 40 mm x 10.2 mm . on the left side of the resonator , one can see a pcb with the matching network at the top and the smt - connector for the inductive pick - up at the bottom . on the right side is the pcb coil , and the two pcbs are connected together by soldered joints . in our measurement setup , we used a capacitive pick - up to measure the voltage at the trap . with the known ratio of this capacitive voltage divider , we could directly measure the voltage at the trap and calibrate the inductive pick - up of the coil . + lcccc * name * & * t * & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 + pcb coil & 295k & 42.4mhz & 19.4 & 60 + pcb coil & @xmath8880k & 42.8mhz & 27.1 & 115 + pcb coil & @xmath8810k & 42.9mhz & 41.5 & 208 + wire coil & 295k & 36.8mhz & 25.2 & 89 + wire coil & @xmath8880k & 37.2mhz & 36.5 & 184 + wire coil & @xmath8810k & 37.9mhz & 58.9 & 624 + hts coil & @xmath8988k & 44.3mhz & 92.1 & 1172 + table [ tab : measurement results ] shows our measurement results . the pcb coils had an inductance very close to the desired value . unfortunately , we could not achieve the expected quality factor . we had designed the wire coils to have losses similar to the pcb coils , but the pcb coils showed much higher losses than the wire coils . we think this is due to an imperfect production process that we could not improve further with our in - house techniques . + additionally to the pcb coils in copper , we produced them in silver as well . the inductances were similar , but the losses in the silver coils were even higher . this was unexpected as silver is a better conductor than copper . but the silver coils needed to be reworked after fabrication to remove shorts between the segments . during this process , the silver coating might have been scratched , resulting in higher losses . we expect that silver plating after structuring should reduce the losses compared to a copper coil , but we were unable to do so with our in - house fabrication process . + the voltage gain of about 60 of the wire coil would require 160mw rf input power to get to the desired 170@xmath90 at the trap . if we adjust the voltage to keep the stability parameter @xmath91 , only 100mw rf input power are required at the modified resonance frequency . + we expect that one can improve the quality factor of the wire coil by using a thicker wire . we also tested a resonator with a lead - plated wire , which did not show an increased voltage gain . we either could not reach the critical temperature of lead in our test setup , or the lead was not pure enough to become superconducting . + the spiral coil showed the highest voltage gain , although the shield influences the magnetic field generated by the coil . we observed a change of the resonance frequency of a couple of percent when cooling down from liquid nitrogen temperatures to liquid helium temperatures , which we attribute to the shield surrounding the coil . with a voltage gain of 92 , one would need about 70mw of rf input power to get 170@xmath90 . with a stability parameter @xmath92 at the higher resonance frequency , it would be 82mw . we have demonstrated three designs of rf resonators for trapped ion experiments with paul traps . the pcb coils have favorable mechanical properties but still need an improved production process , such as e.g. thermal annealing . the wire coils fulfill our criteria and can be further improved by using a thicker or superconducting wire . the hts spiral coil showed the highest voltage gain , which was already accessible at temperatures reached with liquid nitrogen cooling . + efficient matching is usually difficult in a cryogenic environment because normally one can not tune the matching parameters when the cryostat is cold . we have shown a recipe to efficiently match rlc - resonators without precise knowledge of their quality factors . during this empirical study we regularly achieved matching with a power reflection of less than 2% on the second cool - down . additionally , we designed and implemented a shield for resonators to minimize rf pick - up in other parts of the experiment . we thank gerhard hendl from the institute of quantum optics and quantum information of the austrian academy of science for the production of pcbs , and pcb coils for this study . furthermore , we want to thank florian ong for feedback on the manuscript . this research was funded by the office of the director of national intelligence ( odni ) , intelligence advanced research projects activity ( iarpa ) , through the army research office grant w911nf-10 - 1 - 0284 . all statements of fact , opinion or conclusions contained herein are those of the authors and should not be construed as representing the official views or policies of iarpa , the odni , or the u.s . government . w. paul , rev . * 62 * ( 1990 ) 531 - 540 m. chwalla , j. benhelm , k. kim , g. kirchmair , t. monz , m. riebe , p. schindler , a.s . villar , w. haensel , c. f. roos , r. blatt , m. abgrall , g. santarelli , g. d. rovera , ph . laurent , phys . * 102 * ( 2009 ) 023002 h. s. margolis , g. huang , g. p. barwood , s. n. lea , h. a. klein , w. r. c. rowley , p. gill , r. s. windeler , phys . rev . a * 67 * ( 2003 ) 032501 j.i . cirac , p. zoller , phys . * 74 * ( 1995 ) 4091 - 4094 d. kielpinski , c. monroe , d.j . wineland , nature * 417 * ( 2002 ) 709 - 711 t. monz , p. schindler , j.t . barreiro , m. chwalla , d. nigg , w.a . coish , m. harlander , w. hnsel , m. hennrich , r. blatt phys . * 106 * ( 2011 ) 130506 d. porras , j.i . cirac , phys . * 92 * ( 2004 ) 207901 p. jurcevic , b.p . lanyon , p. hauke , c. hempel , p. zoller , r. blatt , c.f . roos , nature * 511 * ( 2014 ) 202 - 205 q.a . turchette , b.e . king , d. leibfried , d.m . meekhof , c.j . myatt , m.a . rowe , c.a . sackett , c.s . wood , w. itano , c. monroe , d. j. wineland , physical review a * 61 * ( 2000 ) 063418 j. labaziewicz , y. ge , p. antohi , d. leibrandt , k. r. brown , i. l. chuang , physical review letters * 100 * ( 2008 ) 013001 w.w . macalpine , r.o . schildknecht , proc . ire * 47 * ( 1959 ) 2099 - 2105 j.d . siverns , l.r . simkins , s.weidt , w.k . hensinger , appl . b * 107 * ( 2012 ) 921 - 934 s.r . jefferts , c. monroe , e.w . bell , d.j . wineland , phys . rev . a * 51 * ( 1995 ) 3112 - 3116 m. e. poitzsch , j. c. bergquist , w. m. itano , d. j. wineland , rev . sci . instrum . * 67 * ( 1996 ) 129 - 134 d. gandolfi , m. niedermayr , m. kumph , m. brownnutt , r. blatt , rev . * 83 * ( 2012 ) 084705 d. j. wineland , c. monroe , w. m. itano , d. leibfried , b. e. king , d. m. meekhof , journal of research of the national institute of standards and technology * 103 * ( 1998 ) 259 - 328 j. w. ekin , _ experimental techniques for low - temperature measurements _ ( oxford university press , 2006 ) 504 - 505 p. kamby , a. knott , m.a.e . andersen , iecon 2012 - 38th annual conference on ieee industrial electronics society ( 2012 ) 680 - 684 s. s. mohan , _ the design , modeling and optimization of on - chip inductor and transformer circuits _ thesis , department of electrical engineering , stanford university , 1999 ) d.m . pozar , _ microwave engineering _ ( john wiley & sons , 2011 )
Abstract: | [
"trapping ions in paul traps requires high radio - frequency voltages , which are generated using resonators . when operating traps in a cryogenic environment , an in - vacuum resonator showing low loss is crucial to limit the thermal load to the cryostat . in this study , we present a guide for the design and production of compact , shielded cryogenic resonators . we produced and characterized three different types of resonators and furthermore demonstrate efficient impedance matching of these resonators at cryogenic temperatures ."
] | 8,268 | 8,268 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in the last few years , the universality of the stellar initial mass function ( imf ) has been questioned by the results of theoretical studies , which consistently predict that the first stars ( hereafter pop iii stars ) had characteristic masses of 100 - 600 @xmath3 ( omukai & nishi 1998 ; abel , bryan & norman 2002 ; bromm , coppi & larson 2002 ; omukai & palla 2003 ) , about 100 times more massive than those observed today ( larson 2003 ) . indeed , the physical conditions in primordial star - forming regions appear to systematically favor the formation of very massive stars . in particular , ( i ) the fragmentation scale of metal - free clouds is typically @xmath4 ( abel , bryan & norman 2002 ; bromm , coppi & larson 2002 ) ( ii ) because of the absence of dust grains the radiative feedback from the forming star is not strong enough to halt further gas accretion ( omukai & palla 2003 ) . ( iii ) since the accretion rate is as large as @xmath5-@xmath6 , the star grows up to @xmath7 within its lifetime ( stahler , palla & salpeter 1986 ; omukai & nishi 1998 ; ripamonti et al . 2002 ) . in spite of the significant progresses made by numerical simulations and semi - analytic models , many aspects of primordial star formation remain to be fully understood , the more important of which are the radiative feedback effects which operate during protostellar accretion and which are likely to ultimately set the final stellar mass . by modeling the structure of the accretion flow and the evolution of the protostar , tan & mckee ( 2004 ) have recently shown that radiative feedback becomes dynamically significant at protostellar masses @xmath8 , and are likely to constrain the mass of first stars in the range @xmath9 . on the other hand , observations of present - day stellar populations show that stars form according to a salpeter imf with a characteristic mass of 1 @xmath3 , below which the imf flattens . thus , unless the current picture of primordial star formation is lacking in some fundamental physical process , a transition in the modes of star formation must have occurred during cosmic evolution . the physical processes responsible for this transition , as well as its cosmological consequences , are currently the subject of systematic investigation . in particular , following the early study by yoshii & sabano ( 1980 ) , it has been shown that a key element driving this transition is the metallicity of the star - forming gas ( omukai 2000 ; bromm et al . 2001 ; schneider et al . 2002 , 2003 ) . the fragmentation properties of the collapsing clouds change as the mean metallicity of the gas increases above a critical threshold , @xmath10 ( schneider et al . 2002 , 2003 ) . the fragmentation of clouds with @xmath11 proceeds only down to relatively massive ( @xmath12 ) cores , whereas in clouds with @xmath13 lower mass fragments can be formed . within the critical metallicity range , low - mass cores can form if a sufficient amount of metals are depleted onto solid dust grains , which provide an efficient cooling channel in the high density regime ( schneider et al . 2003 ; omukai et al . 2005 ) . on cosmic scales , the transition between an epoch dominated by the formation of massive pop iii stars to an epoch dominated by the formation of ordinary pop ii / i stars is controlled by the strength of the so - called _ chemical feedback _ : the explosions of the first massive supernovae starts to metal - enrich the gas out of which subsequent stellar generations form . in particular , in regions of the universe where the metallicity exceeds @xmath14 , low - mass stars can form . chemical feedback self - propagates through the metal enrichment process and therefore depends on many poorly constrained parameters , such as the star formation efficiency at high redshifts , the number of supernovae per stellar mass formed , the efficiency of metal ejection and mixing . in particular , the shape of the primordial imf governs the number of pop iii stars with masses in the pair - instability supernova range ( pisn , heger & woosley 2002 ) 140 @xmath3 - 260 @xmath3 ( which contribute to the metal enrichment ) relative to that of pop iii stars which end up as massive black holes ( which instead do not contribute to the metal enrichment as all the heavy elements are captured by the black hole ) . using a semi - analytic approach , scannapieco , schneider & ferrara ( 2003 ) have modeled the probability that a collapsing halo has been impacted by metal - enriched outflows from neighboring halos . exploring different chemical feedback strengths , they concluded that the transition between the pop iii and pop ii / i dominated star formation epochs is essentially controlled by the spatial distribution of metals . because metal enrichment is generally inefficient ( the filling factor of metals is always found to be @xmath15 ) , the transition epoch is extended in time , with coeval pop iii and pop ii / i star formation episodes , and pop iii stars still contributing to the global star formation rate at redshifts @xmath16 . these findings have very important implications for the detection of pop iii stars through their strong ly@xmath17 emission ( scannapieco et al . 2003 ) as well as the corresponding pair - instability supernova rate ( scannapieco et al . 2005 ) . in this work , we investigate the cosmic transition between pop iii and pop ii / i stars following a complementary approach . we use the code pinocchio developed by monaco , theuns & taffoni ( 2002 ) and taffoni , monaco & theuns ( 2002 ) to produce random catalogues of dark matter halos at different redshifts . we then propagate metal enrichment along the hierarchy of mergers of star - forming galaxies to predict the number and mass distribution of metal - free objects , which can host pop iii stars , at each redshift . we then couple these findings to the star formation history ( of pop iii and pop ii / i stars ) and to the history of cosmic reionization and quantify their interplay through radiative feedback effects which can contribute to the extinction of pop iii stars . a similar approach has been recently undertaken by furlanetto & loeb ( 2005 ) with the aim of assessing the plausibility of the double reionization scenario suggested by cen ( 2003 ) as a way to meet both the constraints on the gas neutral fraction implied by observations of gunn - peterson troughs in the spectra of distant quasars ( fan et al . 2002 , 2003 ) and on the gas ionized fraction derived by the high optical depth to thomson scattering measured by the wmap satellite ( spergel et al . 2003 ; kogut et al . 2003 ) . here we instead focus on the extinction epoch of pop iii stars which we believe to be regulated by feedback both of radiative and chemical types . we investigate the implications that complementary observations on galaxy number counts at redshifts @xmath1 ( bouwens et al . 2005 ) and on the history of cosmic reionization ( kogut et al . 2003 ) set on the transition epoch between pop iii and pop ii / i stars and on the nature of pop iii stars as sources of uv photons contributing to cosmic reionization . in particular , the detection of galaxies at the highest redshifts is challenging because of the redshifting of uv light into the infrared and the well - known limitations of current ir instruments . in spite of these difficulties , the search for high redshift galaxies , based on the dropout technique , has provided the first tentative detection of galaxies at redshifts beyond @xmath18 ( bouwens et al . 2004 ) , stimulating a re - analysis of the small amount of deep ir data . bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) looked at the prevalence of galaxies at @xmath19 by applying the dropout technique to the wide variety of deep fields that have been imaged with the near infrared camera and multi - object spectrometer ( nicmos ) on board of the hubble space telescope . using an appropriate selection criterion for high-@xmath20 sources , bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) concluded that the number of @xmath21 sources must be three or fewer . when combined with the high optical depth to thomson scattering inferred from the _ wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe _ ( wmap ) satellite ( kogut et al 2003 ) , these data already provide a demanding benchmark for theoretical models . the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 we describe the different feedback effects that control the transition from a pop iii to a pop ii dominated star formation epoch . we illustrate the adopted chemical feedback model , predicting the number and mass function of halos which can host pop iii stars at different redshifts . in section 3 , we couple these predictions to a star formation and reionization model . in section 4 we summarize the observations of galaxy counts at redshifts @xmath22 and discuss how these can be used to set important constraints on the model . finally , in section 5 we present the main results and in section 6 we discuss their implications . throughout the paper , we adopt a @xmath23cdm cosmological model with parameters @xmath24 , @xmath25 , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 and @xmath29 , which lie within the experimental errorbars of wmap experiment ( spergel et al . we also use the ab magnitude system , where @xmath30 is the spectral energy density within a given passband in units of erg s@xmath31 @xmath32 hz@xmath31 ] . at least three types of feedback effects can be relevant to the extinction of the first massive stars : ( i ) radiative feedback caused by h@xmath34 photo - dissociating radiation emitted by the first stellar sources , which can inhibit gas cooling and star formation inside small halos ( ii ) chemical feedback due to the release of metals and dust in the first pop iii supernova explosions , which pollute the gas out of which subsequent generations of pop ii stars form ( iii ) radiative feedback due to photo - heating filtering caused by cosmic reionization , the increased temperature of the cosmic gas suppresses the formation of galaxies below the jeans mass . a thorough discussion of each of these processes is beyond the scope of this paper and can be found in the recent extensive review by ciardi & ferrara ( 2005 ) . as a first step , we build up the hierarchy of mergers of dark halos hosting the star formation sites . we use pinocchio code ( monaco , theuns & taffoni 2002 ; taffoni , monaco & theuns 2002 ) to generate random catalogues of dark matter halos in a hierarchical universe . our reference run has @xmath35 particles within a volume of comoving side 6 mpc @xmath36 so that the smallest resolved dark matter halos have total mass @xmath37 ( in the merger trees only halos with at least 10 particles are considered ) . 1 summarizes the details of our reference pinocchio run and shows the redshift evolution of the largest and smallest mass present in the simulation box and of the minimum halo mass that is allowed to form stars . the latter corresponds , at each redshift , to halos with virial temperatures @xmath38k , m_min = 10 ^ 8 ( ) ^-3/2 [ eq : min ] so that stars do not form in halos which rely only on h@xmath34 cooling ( radiative feedback ) . the chosen resolution ensures that we can follow the formation of stars in the lowest mass halos at the highest redshift . due to radiative feedback , the first star - forming halos have a total mass @xmath39 and start to form at @xmath40 . this resolution is appropriate to follow the transition from a pop iii to a pop ii star formation mode around redshift @xmath1 , which is the main scope of this analysis . in fig . 2 we compare the resulting mass function of existing halos at redshifts 30 , 20 , 10 and 5 in the simulation box , to the analytic predictions of press & schechter ( 1974 ) and sheth & tormen ( 1999 ) . the errorbars are poisson errors on the counts in each mass - bin . the agreement is very good down to redshift @xmath16 showing that the chosen resolution ensures completeness in the simulation volume in the redshift range relevant to our analysis . at each redshift , existing halos which are allowed to form stars ( @xmath41 k ) are classified as hosting pop ii ( pop iii ) stars depending on whether the halo itself or any of its progenitors have ( have not ) already experienced an episode of star formation , leading to the formation of sn progenitors which then metal - enrich the gas . note that even a single 200 @xmath3 pisn can enrich the gas within a halo with mass @xmath42 to a metallicity level well above the critical value as , z = 0.02 z _ ( ) ^3/2 where , following heger & woosley ( 2002 ) , we have assumed that the mass of metals released in a pisn explosion is 45% of the initial progenitor mass . this way of taking into account chemical feedback is very conservative as ( i ) we are assuming that all metals synthesized during a star formation episode remain confined ( or are re - accreted ) within the host halo and/or ( ii ) even if a fraction of metals is ejected out of the host halo , the metals that are kept within the potential well are sufficient to pollute the gas within the host system or within any unpolluted halo that the system will later merge with , to a metallicity level larger than @xmath14 . on the other hand , we are neglecting metal pollution from neighboring galaxies through enriched - winds ( scannapieco et al . 2003 ; sigward , ferrara & scannapieco 2005 ) . 3 shows the fraction of halos which can host pop iii stars ( hereafter pop iii halos ) at different redshifts as a function of their mass . the three different curves correspond to different assumptions on the shape of the primordial imf . in particular , we randomly classify pop iii halos as sn - forming or bh - forming depending on whether they host stars with masses in the pisn range or outside this range . sn - forming halos are metal - enriched and pollute their descendants . bh - forming halos are not enriched in metals and therefore do not propagate chemical feedback along their subsequent hierarchy of mergers . the fraction of sn - forming halos , @xmath43 , is therefore a free parameter that controls the strength of chemical feedback . the three curves shown in each panel of fig . 3 correspond ( from bottom to top ) to @xmath44 . each curve represents an average over 50 realizations of the random classification procedure and the errors are poisson errors on the counts in each mass bin . when @xmath45 , all pop iii halos are sn - forming and chemical feedback is strong . the total fraction of pop iii halos decreases with time , being @xmath46 at @xmath47 and @xmath48 at @xmath49 ; at all redshifts , pop iii stars are confined to form in the smallest halo mass bins ( close to the minimum mass to form stars shown as the vertical dotted line in each panel ) . for @xmath50 ( 50% of pop iii halos host sn ) , the number of pop iii halos at each redshift is larger than the previous case ( @xmath51 at @xmath47 and @xmath52 at @xmath53 ) but pop iii halos are still confined to the smallest mass bins ( @xmath54 ) . finally , when @xmath55 the strength of chemical feedback is significantly reduced ( as only 10% of pop iii halos at each redshift host sn ) and therefore the fraction of pop iii halos is dominant at all redshifts , being @xmath56 at @xmath47 and @xmath57 at @xmath49 , not negligible even in halos with the largest mass present in the simulation box at each redshift . hereafter we only consider @xmath55 and @xmath58 as representative of weak and strong chemical feedback models . despite the strength of chemical feedback , pop iii halos continue to form stars even at redshifts as small as @xmath16 , in agreement with the results of scannapieco et al . thus , independently of whether it preferentially propagates through galaxy mergers or through metal - enriched winds , chemical feedback always leads to a smooth transition between a pop iii and a pop ii dominated star formation epoch . note that the above results depend only on the parameter @xmath43 and on the hierarchy of galaxy mergers , and are totally independent of the star formation efficiency or of the value of critical metallicity for the transition in fragmentation scales of collapsing pre - stellar clouds . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] so far , we have taken into account radiative feedback only through the choice of the minimum halo mass that can host stars . namely , we have assumed that mini - halos with virial temperatures less than @xmath59k do not significantly contribute to the cosmic star formation history . however , radiative feedback does affect larger halos , particularly when the universe is approaching the epoch of cosmic reionization . indeed , the increase in temperature of cosmic gas during reionization will suppress the formation of small galaxies with mass below the jeans mass . to quantify this effect , we follow the method proposed by gnedin ( 2000 ) and adopt the filtering mass as the characteristic scale below which the gas fraction in star forming objects , hence the fraction of stellar mass , is reduced with respect to the universal value . in particular , before reionization , the average baryon fraction ( the ratio of the mass in baryons over the total halo mass ) has the universal value @xmath60 while after reionization it can be approximated by the fitting formula ( gnedin 2000 ) , f_b = , [ eq : fil ] where the characteristic mass , @xmath61 , is the total mass of objects which , on average , retain 50% of their universal baryon mass , @xmath62 . this characteristic mass is very well approximated by the linear - theory filtering mass , @xmath63 , with m_f^2/3 = _ 0^a da^m_j^2/3(t , a^)[1-()^1/2 ] , where the jeans mass is given by m_j(t ) = 2.56 10 ^ 5 ( _ m h^2)^-1/2(t/)^3/2 ( 1+z)^-3/2 , with @xmath64 and @xmath65 the temperature and molecular weight of the cosmic gas . here we assume the temperature of ionized regions to be @xmath66 k and we modulate the increase in temperature of the cosmic gas due to reionization with the volume filling factor of ionized regions at the corresponding redshift @xmath67 ( see section [ sec : reio ] ) . thus , the characteristic mass depends on the thermal history of the gas and it accounts for the finite time required for pressure to influence the gas distribution . the redshift evolution of the filtering mass is shown in fig . 1 for a model where reionization occurs at redshift @xmath68 ( short - dashed line ) and @xmath69 ( long - dashed line ) . the filtering mass steeply increases with time and , as expected , its value in the redshift range @xmath70 depends strongly on the reionization history . at redshift @xmath1 , the filtering mass is @xmath71 for the late reionization case , and it is a factor ten larger for the early reionization case . as can be inferred from fig . 1 and 3 , following reionization , photoionization feedback can significantly suppress the formation of pop iii stars since halos with masses @xmath72 have evaporated at least 50% of their mass . following barkana & loeb ( 2001 ) , we compute the redshift evolution of the filling factor of hii regions as , q_hii(z ) = _ z^ dz^ ^f(z^,z ) , [ eq : reio ] where @xmath73 and @xmath74 are the present - day number densities of hydrogen and baryons ( @xmath75 is the hydrogen mass fraction ) , and @xmath76 is the production rate of ionizing photons that we can express as , = f_esc n _ _ , where @xmath77 is the escape fraction , the fraction of ionizing photons that is able to escape the host galaxy , @xmath78 is the time - averaged number of ionizing photons emitted per unit stellar mass formed , and @xmath79 is the comoving star formation density , _ = f_f_b _ m_min^ dm m ( m , z ) where @xmath80 is the star formation efficiency , @xmath81 is the baryon fraction given by eq . ( [ eq : fil ] ) , @xmath42 is the minimum halo mass to form stars ( see eq . [ eq : min ] ) and @xmath82 is the number density of halos ( pop ii and pop iii ) at redshift @xmath20 . the parameter @xmath77 also affects the relative strength of the stellar continuum and the ly@xmath17 line and nebular luminosity of each galaxy . the latter contributions are particularly important for massive pop iii stars . finally , the function @xmath83 takes into account the effect of recombinations . assuming a time - independent volume - averaged clumping factor @xmath84 , common to all hii regions , we can write , f(z^,z ) = - c [ f(z^)-f(z ) ] , and f(z)= , where @xmath85 is the hydrogen recombination rate . for a given reionization history , it is straightforward to compute the optical depth to electron scattering as , _ e(z)=_0^z dz^c _ t n_e(z^ ) , where @xmath86 is the thomson cross section and @xmath87 is the number density of free electrons at redshift @xmath20 . in this paper we only consider the evolution of the filling factor of hii regions ( @xmath88 ) . however , for the purpose of computing the optical depth to electron scattering , we assume that @xmath89 and we neglect the contribution of electrons coming from heiii regions ( see also haiman & holder 2003 ) . under these assumptions we can write @xmath90 where @xmath67 is given by eq.(6 ) . bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) looked at the prevalence of galaxies at @xmath19 by applying the dropout technique to the wide variety of deep f110w- and f160w - band ( hereafter @xmath91 and @xmath92 , respectively ) fields that have been imaged with the near infrared camera and multi - object spectrometer ( nicmos ) . the principal data set is constituted by two 1.3 arcmin@xmath93 deep nicmos parallels taken with the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) hubble ultra deep field ( udf ; each has about @xmath94 orbits data ) . complementary shallower fields possessing similar @xmath95 imaging have been analyzed as well . the 5@xmath96 limiting magnitude for the udfs is @xmath97 in @xmath91 and @xmath98 in @xmath92 ( @xmath99 aperture ) . since these limiting magnitudes are reached only in the deepest regions of the two nicmos udfs , we adopt the conservative limiting magnitude @xmath100 ( bouwens , private communication ) . the primary selection criterion for high-@xmath20 sources is @xmath101 . using this criterion , bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) found eleven sources . eight of these are ruled out as credible @xmath21 sources , either as a result of detection ( @xmath102 ) blue - ward of @xmath91 or because of their colors red - ward of the break ( @xmath103 ) . the nature of the three remaining sources could not be assessed from the data , but this number appears consistent with the expected contamination from low - redshift interlopers . hence , bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) concluded that the actual number of @xmath21 sources in the nicmos parallel fields must be three or fewer . adopting the same selection criterion as in bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) , we compute the number of @xmath104 galaxies detectable in the nicmos udfs predicted by our models . assuming that the three candidates selected by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) are indeed @xmath105 galaxies , we can set interesting constraints on the models . in particular , for a given chemical feedback strength @xmath43 , we compute the number density of pop iii and pop ii halos at each redshift . we then assume a universal value for the star formation efficiency @xmath106 and escape fraction @xmath77 of ionizing photons and we characterize each stellar population ( pop iii and pop ii / i stars ) by assuming a specific template emission spectrum . in the following , we consider two models , a and b , whose details are given in table 1 . we assume two representative chemical feedback strengths ( @xmath43 = 0.1 for model a and @xmath43 = 1 for model b ) . in both cases , the emission properties of pop ii stars have been computed using a simple stellar population model taken from the galaxev library ( bruzual & charlot 2003 ) . pop ii stars have an initial metallicity of @xmath107 and are assumed to form according to a salpeter imf ( with masses in the range 0.1 @xmath3 - 100 @xmath3 ) . pop iii stars are assumed to be very massive ( with masses larger than 100 @xmath108 ) and their emission properties are computed using the stellar spectra of schaerer ( 2002 ) , including the nebular continuum emission found to be very important for stars with strong ionizing fluxes ( bromm , kudritzki & loeb 2001 ; schaerer 2002 ) , we are not forced to make any assumption about the shape of the imf of pop iii stars as long as these are assumed to be very massive . ] . for each model , we then compute the number of sources per unit solid angle with observed flux in the range @xmath109 and @xmath110 as @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the comoving volume element per unit solid angle and redshift , @xmath113 is the comoving number of objects at redshift @xmath20 with observed flux in the range @xmath114 $ ] , given by @xmath115 here @xmath116 is the halo formation rate , and the factor @xmath117 converts the number density per unit mass in unit flux interval . the average flux @xmath109 from a halo of mass @xmath118 at redshift @xmath20 that has formed at @xmath119 is , @xmath120 where @xmath121 is the template luminosity per unit solar mass for a population of age @xmath122 ( the time elapsed between the redshift @xmath123 and @xmath20 ) , @xmath124 is the luminosity distance , @xmath125 is the instrumental bandwidth , @xmath126 and @xmath127 are the restframe frequencies corresponding to the observed ones . finally , @xmath128 is the intergalactic medium ( igm ) effective optical depth at @xmath129 between redshift @xmath130 and @xmath20 ( see sect . 2.2 of salvaterra & ferrara 2003 ) we compute the expected number of @xmath1 galaxies detectable in the nicmos udfs using eqs . [ eq : counts1]-[eq : counts3 ] and applying the same selection criterion of bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) ( @xmath101 , integrated up to the magnitude limit of the survey , @xmath100 ) . assuming that only the three most luminous sources should be above the detection threshold , we derive the maximum allowed value for the star formation efficiency , @xmath80 , corresponding to a given escape fraction of ionizing photons . the results obtained for models a and b are shown in fig . 4 in terms of comoving star formation density in pop iii and pop ii stars as a function of redshift . model c will be discussed in section [ sec : reio ] . in each panel , vertically ( horizontally ) shaded regions represent the range of star formation histories for pop iii ( pop ii ) stars allowed by the nicmos - udfs counts when a value @xmath131 in assumed ( see table 1 for the corresponding values of @xmath80 ) . for both models and all the explored values of @xmath77 , the three most luminous objects in nicmos udfs are always represented by galaxies hosting pop iii stars , as their strong ly@xmath17 and nebular emission ( schaerer 2002 ) is dominant . as a consequence , @xmath80 is restricted to relatively small values , which increase with increasing @xmath77 . model b , being characterized by the strongest chemical feedback , and therefore by the smallest fraction of halos hosting pop iii stars at redshift @xmath132 ( see also fig . 3 ) , has larger allowed star formation efficiencies than model a. fig . 4 shows that in model a chemical feedback is very inefficient ( @xmath133 ) and pop iii stars dominate the cosmic star formation history down to redshift @xmath134 . conversely , model b shows that when chemical feedback is maximally efficient , the star formation density in pop iii stars is sub - dominant at all but the highest redshifts , but pop iii stars still make a significant contribution to the cosmic star formation history down to redshift 5 . because of the moderate star formation efficiencies implied by the observed nicmos udfs counts , radiative feedback is negligible for the most massive galaxies . to evaluate its impact on the predicted star formation densities shown in fig . 4 , we have assumed a clumping factor @xmath135 . for @xmath136 , the corresponding reionization redshifts vary in the range @xmath137 for model a , and in the range @xmath138 for model b. in model a , radiative feedback effect on the overall pop iii star formation density manifests itself as a progressive decrement of the upper limit ( which corresponds to the largest @xmath77 and @xmath80 ) of the shaded region for @xmath139 . in model b , where the star formation efficiencies implied by the observed counts are larger and , at each redshift , pop iii stars are confined to form only in the smallest halos , radiative feedback is more significant ; around redshift 10 , the lines corresponding to the maximum and minimum pop iii star formation efficiencies cross each other ( the highest the star formation efficiency and escape fraction , the strongest the radiative feedback ) . overall , the observed galaxy counts at redshift @xmath1 favor a cosmic star formation history where the transition from pop iii to pop ii stars is governed by strong chemical feedback , with all pop iii halos efficiently propagating metal enrichment to their descendants along the hierarchy of galaxy mergers . in fact , in less efficient chemical feedback scenarios ( @xmath140 ) , the predicted cosmic star formation density is dominated by pop iii stars down to redshift @xmath53 . stronger constraints on models a and b come from their corresponding reionization histories . figs . 5 and 6 show isocontours of redshifts of reionization as a function of the clumping factor and the escape fraction ( the star formation efficiency is set by the observed counts at @xmath1 ) . we define the redshift of reionization , @xmath141 , as the redshift when the filling factor of ionized regions , given by eq . ( [ eq : reio ] ) is @xmath142 . the shaded regions indicate the parameter space which leads to an optical depth to electron scattering within the range @xmath143 observed by the wmap satellite ( spergel et al . 2003 ; kogut et al . 2003 ) , with the dashed line corresponding to the central value . as it can be inferred from the figures , both models lead to reionization histories which are in poor agreement with observations . indeed , large escape fractions and moderate clumping factors are required to reproduce the observed range of optical depths . independent observations of the escape fraction give , with few exceptions , values in the range @xmath144 ( ciardi & ferrara 2005 and references therein ) whereas numerical simulations ( gnedin & ostriker 1997 ; iliev , scannapieco & shapiro 2005 ) and semi - analytic models ( madau , haardt & rees 1999 ) predict clumping factors in the range @xmath145 . 5 shows that in model a , even assuming an homogeneous igm ( @xmath146 ) , the escape fraction has to be @xmath147 to be marginally consistent with the observations . in model b , the agreement improves but still requires extreme assumptions on either the escape fraction or the clumping factor : when @xmath144 , the predicted optical depth lies within -1@xmath96 error from the observed value only if @xmath148 . our analysis suggests that it is very hard to reconcile the observed number counts at redshift @xmath1 with the reionization history inferred by wmap observations if pop iii stars are assumed to be all very massive , with masses @xmath149 . this result is somehow counter - intuitive because metal - free very massive stars have always believed to play an important role in an early epoch of cosmic reionization ( cen 2003 ; haiman & holder 2003 ; sokasian et al . 2004 , 2004 ; venkatesan , tumlinson & shull 2003 ; wyithe & loeb 2003 ; but see also ciardi , ferrara & white 2003 , and ricotti & ostriker 2004 for alternative interpretations ) . still , due to their strong ly@xmath17 and nebular luminosity , pop iii stars with masses @xmath150 always dominate the predicted galaxy number counts at @xmath1 , even assuming the strongest chemical feedback model . the paucity of candidate objects observed in nicmos udfs implies that star formation in halos with @xmath151 k must have occurred very inefficiently . even if all three objects identified by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) are truly @xmath1 sources , the contribution of pop iii stars to cosmic reionization is strongly constrained . the constraints are particularly severe when chemical feedback is less efficient ( model a ) , because pop iii stars can form at redshift @xmath1 in relatively large , and therefore luminous , galaxies . even if chemical feedback is assumed to be maximally efficient and pop iii stars are confined to form in the smallest halos , their contribution to cosmic reionization is in agreement with observations only for moderate ( @xmath152 ) clumping factors . unless an additional type of feedback comes into play , the transition between pop iii to pop ii halos , regulated by chemical and radiative feedback , is very smooth . thus , to relax the severe upper limits placed on the star formation efficiencies by nicmos udfs counts , the emission properties of pop iii stars have to be modified . in particular , if pop iii stars are assumed to form according to a salpeter imf with masses in the range @xmath153 , their ly@xmath17 and nebular emission is strongly suppressed . in this limit , ( see model c in table 1 ) , all pop iii halos contribute to chemical feedback , @xmath154 , because each burst of star formation leads to the formation of sn progenitors and nicmos udfs counts at @xmath1 are dominated by pop ii galaxies . as a consequence , the upper limit on the star formation efficiency set by the observed counts is @xmath155 , much higher than those found for models a and b and independent of the escape fraction . the predicted evolution of the star formation density in pop ii and pop iii stars is shown in the lowest panel of fig . similar to model b , pop ii star dominate the star formation history at all but the highest redshifts . indeed , in our approach the transition between pop iii and pop ii dominated star formation epochs is controlled only by the strength of chemical feedback ( @xmath156 ) and it is independent of the assumed star formation efficiencies ( see section [ sec : chem ] ) . however , contrary to model b , the star formation density depends on the escape fraction only indirectly , through the strength of radiative feedback . for this reason , the shaded regions representing the range of allowed star formation densities are not degenerate only after reionization which , for @xmath157 and @xmath158 occurs at redshift @xmath159 ( for pop ii stars , which are preferentially hosted in large halos , this effect is negligible ) . the implications for the history of reionization are summarized in fig . 7 , which shows that model c is in much better agreement with observations than model a and b. the optical depth observed by wmap can be reproduced with @xmath144 even if the clumping factor is as high as @xmath160 . thus , when the observed @xmath1 counts are used to set an upper limit to the allowed star formation efficiency , pop iii stars forming with a conventional imf are more efficient sources of cosmic reionization than very massive stars . note that this conclusion is independent on issues related to chemical and radiative feedback . indeed , both models b and c assume maximally efficient chemical feedback and radiative feedback plays a minor role for model c because the predicted @xmath1 counts are dominated by massive pop ii galaxies , which are largely unaffected by photoevaporation . fig.7 shows that the best - fit value of optical depth implied by wmap observations , @xmath161 , can only be reproduced by model c with @xmath144 if @xmath162 . if larger values of @xmath84 are to be favored or the observed optical depth will be corrected up - ward in future wmap data releases , a revision of model c is to be considered . however , unless the nicmos udfs counts have under - estimated by a large factor the number of @xmath1 sources , our results suggest that the only plausible revision of model c is to modify the primordial imf by increasing the characteristic mass but allowing pop iii stars to form only in the conventional mass range , @xmath163 . in fig . 8 we show the predicted optical depth as a function of the pop iii characteristic stellar mass , @xmath164 . we assume that the characteristic stellar mass enters in the definition of the stellar imf as suggested by larson ( 1998 ) , ( 1 + ) ^-1.35 , which , for @xmath165 leads to the standard salpeter imf . for a given @xmath164 , we compute @xmath166 considering the proper emission rate of ionizing photons ( taken from table 1 of ciardi & ferrara 2005 ) , assuming @xmath167 , three different clumping factors @xmath168 and 30 , and that either all 3 or none of the candidates identified by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) in nicmos udfs represent @xmath1 galaxies ( upper and lower limits to each shaded region ) . 8 shows that the predicted optical depth depends more on the clumping factor than on the assumed value of @xmath164 . if @xmath135 , the predicted @xmath166 is in agreement with the observed values even assuming @xmath165 , consistent with the results shown in fig . 7 . if @xmath169 , wmap and nicmos udfs data can be reconciled only if all three candidates are confirmed to be @xmath1 galaxies and if the characteristic pop iii stellar mass is @xmath170 . finally , if the observed @xmath166 will be corrected up - ward in future analyses of wmap data , none of the models considered , independently of the assumed @xmath164 , will be able to reconcile the observed reionization history with the counts at @xmath171 , unless @xmath172 . the tentative detections of @xmath1 galaxies in nicmos udfs by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) provides tight constraints on the relative contributions of pop iii and pop ii stars to the galaxy luminosity function . when coupled to the reionization history of the universe implied by the wmap satellite , this collection of data sets represents already a very demanding benchmark for galaxy evolution models . stimulated by these data , we have followed the assembling history of high - redshift galaxies hosting the first stars in a hierarchical model for structure formation . adopting simple prescriptions for chemical and radiative feedbacks along with available data , we have constrained the evolution of the imf of the first stars . in particular we find that : 1 . two types of feedbacks need to be considered : ( ia ) radiative feedback , which suppresses star formation in h@xmath34-cooling halos and the formation of low - mass galaxies because of photoionization heating following reionization , and ( ib ) chemical feedback due to the progressive enrichment of ( pop ii ) star forming gas by the metals released by the first ( pop iii ) stellar explosions . 2 . if chemical feedback is weak ( @xmath133 ) pop iii stars can form in relatively large halos and dominate the evolution of the cosmic star formation density down to redshift @xmath16 . more realistic scenarios are found assuming @xmath154 , where pop iii stars are confined to form only in the smallest halos at each redshift . 3 . the combined effect of radiative and chemical feedbacks fails to suppress the formation of massive pop iii stars at @xmath139 . if pop iii stars are assumed to form with a top - heavy imf , that is with masses @xmath173 , pop iii galaxy are always found to dominate the predicted @xmath1 nicmos udfs counts . because of their strong ly@xmath17 and nebular luminosities , very tight upper limits on the star formation efficiency in @xmath174 k halos are placed by the paucity of observed counts . the corresponding reionization histories fail to reproduce the observed wmap optical depths unless uncomfortably large values for the escape fraction of ionizing photons and/or too small values for the igm clumping factor are assumed . reionization constraints from wmap and observed @xmath1 counts in nicmos udfs can be reconciled if pop iii stars form according to a larson imf with stellar masses in the conventional range @xmath175 and a characteristic mass @xmath176 if the clumping factor is @xmath177 , or @xmath178 if the clumping factor is as large as 30 . in the latter case , at least 1 candidate identified by bouwens et al . ( 2005 ) has to be a galaxy at @xmath1 . our analysis is based on the assumption that chemical feedback propagates along the hierarchy of galaxy mergers from progenitors to descendants rather than through metal - enriched galaxy outflows ( scannapieco et al . 2003 ) . by adopting this simplified scheme , we are implicitly assuming that ( i ) even if a fraction of metals is ejected out of the host halo , the metals that are kept within the potential well are sufficient to pollute the gas within the host system or within any unpolluted halo that the system will later merge with , to a metallicity level larger than @xmath14 and that ( ii ) metal pollution from neighboring galaxies is negligible . in spite of these simplifying assumptions , the resulting pop iii and pop ii star formation histories are consistent with the predictions of scannapieco et al . in particular , even assuming a maximally efficient chemical feedback , the transition is always predicted to be very smooth , with pop iii stars which continue to form in the smallest halos at each redshift down to @xmath16 . interestingly enough , our conclusion is independent of the primordial imf and/or star formation efficiency . we show that models where all pop iii halos are able to metal pollute their descendants ( @xmath154 ) are favored by observations . the smoothness of the cosmic imf transition is therefore strictly linked to the inhomogeneous character of the metal enrichment process , independently of how it is implemented in the models . even if we have adopted a very approximate description of the thermal evolution of the cosmic gas , we find that radiative feedback following reionization can play an important role in the extinction of pop iii stars . in particular , if reionization occurs at redshifts @xmath179 ( @xmath1 ) the baryon fraction in @xmath180 halos is reduced to 70% ( 99% ) of its universal value ( @xmath60 ) at redshift 10 and to 10% ( 30% ) of this value at redshift 5 . thus , the baryon content in the smallest halos where pop iii stars can form at low redshift is severely limited by radiative feedback . this is strongly related to the epoch of cosmic reionization which , in turn , depends on the degree of inhomogeneities which characterize the cosmic gas . we have parametrized this quantity through a constant clumping factor @xmath84 and we have explored different values of @xmath84 ranging from 1 to 50 . however , it is likely that the degree of clumpiness of the cosmic gas varies with time , rising from @xmath181 at high redshift to a few tens at @xmath1 as structures go increasingly non - linear . recently , iliev et al . ( 2005 ) have studied the effect of igm clumping at redshifts @xmath182 , providing a fit to the evolution of the clumping factor ( see their fig . 7 ) where @xmath183 at redshift 30 and raises to @xmath184 at redshift 10 . adopting this evolution for the clumping factor and @xmath185 we find that models a and b are unable to reproduce the optical depths inferred from wmap data whereas in model c we find that reionization is complete at redshift 13.5 and that the resulting optical depth is @xmath186 in very good agreement with the observed value . thus , our analysis suggests that pop iii stars forming with masses in the same dynamical range as pop ii / i stars , but possibly with higher characteristic stellar mass , appear to be favored by observations . several scenarios that enable the formation of low - mass stars in metal - free environments have been proposed , among which the bi - modal imf ( nakamura & umemura 1999 , 2002 ) , enhanced hd - cooling in relic hii regions ( uehara & inutsuka 2000 ; nakamura & umemura 2002 ) , the influence of a strong uv radiation field due to the vicinity of a very massive star ( omukai & yoshii 2003 ) , fragmentation in shock - compressed shells induced by the first very massive sn explosions ( mackey , bromm & hernquist 2003 ; salvaterra , ferrara & schneider 2004 ) . however , all these processes either require very special conditions , generally related to the existence of a previous generation of very massive stars , or have failed to be realized in realistic numerical simulations . in spite of this , observations seem to indicate that either radiative feedback effects during the accretion phase on protostellar cores and/or a combination of the above mentioned processes can lead to the formation of pop iii stars with masses @xmath187 . according to the results of our analysis , the latter contribution to the pop iii stellar imf must be dominant at least at redshifts @xmath1 . if this scenario is correct , relics of the low - mass pop iii star formation mode should be still present in our galaxy , eventually contributing to the lowermost end of the metallicity distribution function ( salvadori , schneider & ferrara in prep ) . we acknowledge the use of pinocchio v 1.0 package written by pierluigi monaco , tom theuns & giuliano taffoni ( http://www.daut.univ.trieste.it/pinocchio ) . this work has been partially supported by the research and training network `` the physics of the intergalactic medium '' set up by the european community under the contract hprn - ct-2000 - 00126 . 99 abel t. , bryan g. l. , norman m. l. 2002 , science , 295 , 93 barkana , r. & loeb , a. 2001 , phr , 349 , 125 bouwens r. j. et al . 2004 , , apj , 616 , l79 bouwens r. j. , illingworth g. d. , thomson r. i. , & franx m , 2005 , apj , 624 , l5 bromm , v. , ferrara a. , coppi p. s. , larson r. b. 2001 , mnras , 328 , 969 bromm , v. , kudritzki , r. p. & loeb , a. 2001 , apj , 552 , 464 bromm , v. , coppi p. s. , larson r. b. 2002 , apj , 564 , 23 bruzual , g. & charlot , s. 2003 , 344 , 1000 ciardi , b. & ferrara , a. 2005 , space science reviews , 116 , 625 ciardi , b. , ferrara , a. , white , s. d. m. 2003 , mnras , 344 , l7 cen , r. 2003 , apj , 591 , 12 furlanetto , s. & loeb , a. 2005 , apj in press , ( astro - ph/0409736 ) gnedin , n. , ostriker , j. 1997 , apj , 474 , 581 gnedin , n. 2000 , apj , 542 , 535 haiman , z. & holder , g. p. 2003 , apj , 595 , 1 heger , a. & woosley , s. 2002 , apj , 567 , 532 iliev , i. , scannapieco , e. , shapiro , p. 2005 , apj , 624 , 491 kogut , a. et al . 2003 , apjs , 148 , 161 larson , r. b. 1998 , mnras , 301 , 569 mackey , j. , bromm , v. , hernquist , l. 2003 , apj , 586 , 1 madau , p. , haardt , f. , rees , m. j. 1999 , apj , 514 , 648 monaco , p. , theuns , t. & taffoni , g. 2002 , mnras , 331 , 587 nakamura , f. , umemura , m. 1999 , apj , 515 , 239 nakamura , f. , umemura , m. 2002 , apj , 569 , 549 omukai , k. & nishi , r. 1998 , apj , 508 , 141 omukai , k. 2000 , apj , 534 , 809 omukai , k. & palla , f. 2003 , apj , 589 , 677 omukai , k. & yoshii , y. 2003 , apj , 599 , 746 omukai , k. , tsuribe , t. , schneider , r. , ferrara , a. 2005 , apj , 626 , 627 ricotti , m. & ostriker , j. p. , 2004 , mnras , 350 , 539 ripamonti , e. , haardt , f. , ferrara , a. , & colpi , m. , 2002 , mnras , 334 , 401 salvaterra , r. , ferrara a. , schneider r. 2004 , new astronomy , 10 , 11 salvaterra , r. & ferrara a. 2003 , mnras , 339 , 973 scannapieco , e. , schneider , r. & ferrara , a. 2003 , apj , 589 , 1 scannapieco , e. , madau , p. , woosley , s. , heger , a. , ferrara , a. 2005 , apj , in press ( astro - ph/0507182 ) schaerer , d. 2002 , a&a , 382 , 28 schneider r. , ferrara a. , natarajan p. , omukai k. 2002 , apj , 571 , 30 schneider r. , ferrara a. , salvaterra r. , omukai k. , bromm v. 2003 , nature , 422 , 869 sigward , f. , ferrara , a. & scannapieco , e. 2005 , mnras , 358 , 755 sokasian , a. , yoshida , n. , abel , t. , hernquist , l. , springel , v. 2004 , mnras 350 , 47 spergel , d. l. et al . 2003 , apjs , 148 , 175 stahler , s. w. , palla , f. , & salpeter , e. e. 1986 , apj , 302 , 590 tan , j. c. & mckee , c. f. 2004 , apj , 603 , 383 taffoni , g. , monaco , p. & theuns , t. 2002 , mnras , 333 , 623 uehara , h. & inutsuka , s. 2000 , apj , 531 , l91 venkatesan , a. , tumlinson , j. , shull , j. m. 2003 , apj , 584 , 621 wyithe , j. s. b. & loeb , a. 2003 , apj , 588 , l69 yoshii , y. , sabano , y. 1980 , pasj , 32 , 229
Abstract: | [
"motivated by theoretical predictions that first stars were predominantly very massive , we investigate the physics of the transition from an early epoch dominated by massive pop iii stars to a later epoch dominated by familiar low - mass pop ii / i stars by means of a numerically - generated catalogue of dark matter halos coupled with a self - consistent treatment of chemical and radiative feedback . depending on the strength of the chemical feedback , pop iii stars can contribute a substantial fraction ( several percent ) of the cosmic star formation activity even at moderate redshifts , @xmath0 . we find that the three @xmath1 sources tentatively detected in nicmos udfs should be powered by pop iii stars , if these are massive ; however , this scenario fails to reproduce the derived wmap electron scattering optical depth . instead , both the udfs and wmap constraints can be fulfilled if stars at any time form with a more standard , slightly top - heavy , larson imf in the range @xmath2 . = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupeurmn @mathgroup@bold@groupeurbn @mathgroup@group @mathgroup@normal@groupmsamn @mathgroup@bold@groupmsamn = `` 019 = ' ' 016 = `` 040 = ' ' 336 = \" 33e = = = = = = = = # 1 # 1 # 1 # 1 = = = = = = = = [ firstpage ] galaxies : formation - cosmology : theory - cosmology : observations - intergalactic medium"
] | 9,115 | 9,115 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: electrons are characterized by their quantized spin and charge . in conventional electronic devices , only the charge degree of freedom has been employed for the control of the electron transport . a new field of spintronics @xcite was born from both experimental and theoretical efforts to harness the electron s spin degree of freedom in order to control the electric current in the devices . one of typical spintronic devices is the spin valve which is a hybrid structure of ferromagnetic ( fm ) metal / nonmagnetic ( nm ) material / fm metal . the current passing through the spin valve depends on the magnetization configuration of two fm metals . in the collinear case , usually more current flows through the spin valve in the parallel configuration than in the antiparallel configuration . difference in resistance between the two is called magnetoresistance . in the noncollinear case or when two magnetization orientations are neither parallel nor antiparallel , the spin polarized current from one fm electrode exerts the spin torque @xcite on the other fm electrode , and induces the magnetization dynamics . examples of a spin valve are giant magnetoresistance ( gmr ) devices,@xcite magnetic tunnel junctions,@xcite nanopillars,@xcite etc . in contrast with vertical spin valves , lateral spin valves are characterized by their multi terminal functionalities and so are more favorable for integration into semiconductor electronics . due to increased spacing between terminals , efficient spin injection and detection have been a very hot issue . the spin injection and detection experiments in the two - terminal geometry are obscured by other effects like anisotropic magnetoresistance , hall effect , etc . this defect was overcome by adopting the nonlocal spin valve geometry @xcite similar to the schematic device structure in fig.[3fmlead ] . the original spin valve devices contain two fm electrodes ( vs. three fm electrodes in fig . [ 3fmlead ] ) contacting the nonmagnetic base electrode . in this lateral spin valve system , the spin transport was clearly observed with al wires @xcite by spatially separating the spin current path from the charge current path and thereby removing other undesirable effects . the spin polarized current flows from the left of n ( base electrode ) into f1 . that is , spin polarized electrons are injected from f1 into base electrode n and is drained to the left of n. due to asymmetry of two spin states in fm , the number of injected spin - up and spin - down electrons is different . flowing from the left end of n into f1 . the electrode f1 is called the spin - injecting probe , while f@xmath0 with @xmath1 will be called the nonlocal ( voltage ) probe in this paper . ( b ) the one - dimensional model geometry of the spin valve system in ( a ) . [ 3fmlead],width=264 ] in addition to charge current in the left of n ( @xmath2 ) , diffusion of injected spins generates spin current flowing to left and right of n symmetrically . pure spin current to the right of n was detected @xcite with another fm electrode by measuring the spin - dependent nonlocal voltage drop . the nonlocal spin injection and detection technique was also used to observe @xcite the ( inverse ) spin hall effect in diffusive nonmagnetic metallic strips . in these experiments , the spatial separation of charge and spin currents as well as the efficient spin injection are essential to observing the charge hall voltage induced by the spin current . recently experimental groups @xcite studied the spin transport in the lateral spin valves with the three fm electrodes as shown in fig . [ 3fmlead ] . f1 is the spin - injection electrode ( f@xmath3 ) as usual , while f2 and f3 are the nonlocal voltage probes located outside the charge current path . while the spin polarized electrons are injected from f1 into n and are drained into the left of n , the transresistance is measured between f1 and f2 or between f1 and f3 . in the former case , f2 is the spin - detecting electrode f@xmath4 and f3 is the additional electrode f@xmath5 . in the latter case , the roles of f2 and f3 are switched . the important issue is how sensitively the transresistance is affected by f@xmath5 . one experimental group @xcite found that f@xmath5 can drain the spin current and thereby significantly suppress the transresistance . they concluded that such additional fm electrode is relevant to the spin injection and accumulation in the multi terminal lateral spin valves . on the other hand , another group @xcite found that the transresistance is weakly affected by f@xmath5 even when the contact resistance between f@xmath5 and n is ohmic . moreover the transresistance was observed @xcite to be independent of the magnetization orientation of f@xmath5 ( parallel or antiparallel to that of f@xmath3 ) . they concluded that such additional fm electrodes are irrelevant to the spin injection and accumulation in the multi terminal lateral spin valves . the existing experimental results seem to be contradictory to each other . motivated by this experimental situation , we study theoretically the spin transport in the lateral spin valve with three ferromagnetic electrodes as schematically shown in fig . [ 3fmlead ] . we adopt the semiclassical spin drift - diffusion ( sdd ) equation @xcite for the one - dimensional device structure and study the mutual effect of fm electrodes on their nonlocal spin signals such as nonlocal voltage drop and leakage spin current . we find that the efficiency of the spin current leakage into fm electrodes depends on the relative magnitude of junction resistance and the bulk resistance ( defined over spin diffusion length ) in fm and n electrodes . the voltage drop in @xmath6 is proportional to its leakage spin current with the proportionality constant given by the _ effective _ spin resistance which depends on the magnetization orientation of f@xmath4 . nonlocal spin signals are sensitive to the position of f@xmath5 relative to the positions of f@xmath3 and f@xmath4 . when f@xmath5 is located in between f@xmath3 and f@xmath4 , the transresistance can be either significantly or weakly affected by f@xmath5 depending on the relative magnitude of junction resistance and spin resistance . the effect of f@xmath5 is weak when f@xmath5 is located outside the region between f@xmath3 and f@xmath4 . even though the magnitude of the spin current and nonlocal spin signals may be modified by f@xmath5 , the flow direction of the spin current in the whole device is set by the magnetization orientation of f@xmath3 and so the nonlocal spin signals are independent of the magnetization orientation of f@xmath5 . this surprising result is already observed @xcite in experiments and is the direct consequence of no charge current in f@xmath5 . based on decoupling of charge and spin modes in the sdd equation and the kirchhoff rules at the junction , we also show that the relationship between nonlocal spin signals and magnetization holds true even in realistic three - dimensional samples . these interesting properties in fact originate from zero charge current in nonlocal voltage electrodes . irrelevance of magnetization orientation of additional fm electrode to nonlocal spin signals implies that even additional _ nonmagnetic _ electrode can modify nonlocal spin signals in the spin - detecting probe . our theoretical study may be useful for clarifying the conflicting roles @xcite of an additional fm electrode in the lateral spin valve devices . in addition , our study is relevant to device applications , because the multi terminal functionality is essential for device applications of lateral spin valves . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . in sec . ii , the spin drift - diffusion equation is briefly introduced and the detailed algebras for the lateral spin valve with three fm electrodes are included . the results of our work for spin valves relevant to experiments are presented in sec . iii . in sec . iv , our work is summarized and its relevance to experiments is discussed . some algebraic details and interesting results are included in three appendices . from now on we are going to confine our discussion to the collinear magnetizations of three fm electrodes in spin valves and so we consider the spin polarized transport in a steady state . the noncollinear magnetizations go beyond the scope of our paper since the current flow in the noncollinear magnetizations generates the spin transfer torque and induces the magnetization dynamics . in the collinear and diffusive transport , the spin drift - diffusion equations @xcite have been very useful for understanding phenomenologically the spin polarized transport in the spin valve systems . later the sdd equations were derived @xcite from the semiclassical boltzmann equation under the assumption that the spin diffusion length ( sdl ) is larger than the mean free path ( mfp ) . using the numerical solution of the spin dependent boltzmann equation , the validity of the sdd equations was further extended @xcite to the case when the sdl is comparable to the mfp . the sdd equations have been widely used for analyzing the spin injection experiments in various device geometries . the sdd formalism was also applied to the study of spin transfer torque @xcite in the case of noncollinear magnetizations . the sdd equations in the collinear magnetizations are written down for the spin - dependent electrochemical potential @xmath7 and electric current density @xmath8 . here @xmath9 represents the spin - up ( @xmath10 ) and spin - down ( @xmath11 ) states , respectively . the presence of the spin flip scattering in bulk mixes two spin states and the sdd equations can be written down in a matrix form . @xmath12 here @xmath13 is the diffusion constant for spin direction @xmath9 and @xmath14 is the average spin - flip time for an electron from the spin direction @xmath10 to @xmath11 . @xmath15 is the conductivity for electrons with spin @xmath16 and @xmath17 is the absolute value of electron charge . the matrix differential equation for the electrochemical potential can be solved @xcite by analyzing the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of the matrix in the sdd equation . one eigenvalue is @xmath18 and the corresponding eigenvector is @xmath19 . the other eigenvalue defines the spin diffusion length @xmath20 and is given by the expression @xmath21 and its eigenvector is @xmath22 . to find this form of the eigenvector , the einstein relation as well as the detailed balance relation are already invoked . obviously the first eigenvector ( charge mode ) does not discriminate between two spin states , while the second one ( spin mode ) does . in this section we analyze the spin polarized transport in the spin valve system based on the one - dimensional sdd equations . the device structure is displayed in fig . [ 3fmlead](a ) , where the base electrode is contacted to three ferromagnetic ( fm ) electrodes . our primary goal is to understand the mutual influence of the ferromagnetic electrodes on the nonlocal spin signals such as the voltage drops and the leakage spin currents . fm leads are labeled as f@xmath0 with @xmath23 from left to right . the one - dimensional geometry , corresponding to the device structure , is displayed in fig . [ 3fmlead](b ) , where the junctions between the base electrode and the fm leads are labeled as @xmath24 ( @xmath23 ) . in experiments , the base electrode is nonmagnetic , but we are going to consider the case of magnetic base electrode with its nonzero bulk spin polarization @xmath25 . nonmagnetic case is recovered by a simple replacement @xmath26 . the spin polarization ( sp ) in each fm lead is denoted as @xmath27 which is defined by the spin asymmetry in the spin dependent conductivity @xmath28 . @xmath29 with the total conductivity @xmath30 , the spin - up and spin - down conductivities can be written as @xmath31 for the base electrode , the spin polarization ( @xmath25 ) in conductivity and the spin - dependent conductivities ( @xmath32 ) are defined in a similar manner . when the spin polarized electrons are injected from f1 into the base electrode n and is drained to left , the electrochemical potential in the fm leads can be written as @xmath33 \begin{pmatrix } 1 \cr 1 \end{pmatrix } \nonumber\\ & & - i_i { \cal r}_i e^{-y/\lambda_i } \begin{pmatrix } ( 1+\beta_i)^{-1 } \cr - ( 1-\beta_i)^{-1 } \end{pmatrix}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath34 is the kronecker delta function . the spin dependent current is determined by the equation @xmath35 the charge current is given by the expression @xmath36 and flows only in f1 but not in f@xmath0 with @xmath1 . the @xmath0-th fm lead is contacted to the base electrode at @xmath24 . @xmath37 , @xmath38 , @xmath39 , and @xmath27 are the cross sectional area , the spin diffusion length , conductivity , and bulk spin polarization in conductivity of the @xmath0-th fm lead , respectively . @xmath40 , defined by the relation @xmath41 is the resistance of the fm electrode over the spin diffusion length . due to an exponential decay of spin current , this definition of resistance makes sense physically when discussing the spin current . @xmath42 is the voltage drop at each ferromagnetic electrode far away from the junction with the base electrode and is induced by the nonequilibrium spin injection and diffusion . note that the common fermi energy is dropped in writing the electrochemical potentials in this paper , because the overall constant energy shift does not change physics . the spin current in f@xmath0 @xmath43 is given by the expression @xmath44 the first term is the spin - polarized driving current , while the second comes from the spin accumulation and diffusion . though no charge current flows in the region @xmath45 , the spin current is induced in the base electrode due to the spin injection , accumulation and diffusion . the spin current decays exponentially over the spin diffusion length and in turn leaks into the other fm electrodes . @xmath46 measures the magnitude of this leakage spin current at the interface between the base electrode and f@xmath0 . the leakage spin current also decays exponentially over the sdl in the fm electrodes . the set of six unknown parameters @xmath47 are to be determined by the kirchhoff rules at the junctions . note that @xmath42 and @xmath46 are null for @xmath1 , when the injected current is not spin polarized . @xmath48 can be nonzero for the tunneling barrier even when the injected current is not spin polarized . hence we may call @xmath47 for @xmath1 as the _ nonlocal spin signals_. in the common base electrode , we have the electrochemical potential for spin - up(@xmath10 ) and spin - down(@xmath11 ) electrons @xmath49 here @xmath50 is the step function and the spin dependent current is computed from @xmath51 @xmath52 , @xmath20 , @xmath53 , and @xmath25 are the cross sectional area , the spin diffusion length , conductivity , and bulk spin polarization in conductivity of the base electrode , respectively . @xmath54 , defined by the relation @xmath55 is the resistance over the spin diffusion length in the base electrode . the charge current @xmath56 flows only at the section @xmath57 and the spin current @xmath58 is given by the equation @xmath59 the additional three unknown parameters @xmath60 are introduced for the base electrode . @xmath61 represents the redistribution of spin current in the base electrode due to its leakage into the voltage probes ( fm electrodes with @xmath62 ) . the electrochemical potentials are constructed such that the charge current is conserved at any junction in the device ( charge continuity equation ) . no net charge current flows to the right of @xmath63 and the currents for spin - up and spin - down electrons are equal in their magnitude and opposite in their sign or flowing direction . this symmetry in spin current is strictly obeyed in the nonlocal spin valve geometry even in the presence of the multiple ferromagnetic electrodes to the right of the spin - injecting fm electrode f1 . obviously the spin currents @xmath46 and @xmath61 are modified by the presence of other fm electrodes , which is our main research interest in this work . there are nine unknown parameters @xmath64 ( @xmath23 ) , which should be determined by the boundary conditions or kirchhoff rules at the junctions . as already mentioned in the above , the electrochemical potentials are constructed such that the charge current is conserved . in our work , the spin flip scattering is neglected at the interface , but is taken into account in bulks . in this case , the spin current is conserved at each junction and the following relations are obtained @xmath65 we consider the case of dirty interface between the ferromagnetic electrodes and the base electrode . due to a finite value of resistance at the interface , the electrochemical potential across the junction is not continuous and should be determined by the ohm s law . @xcite @xmath66 here @xmath67 is the difference of the electrochemical potentials at @xmath24 between the base electrode and the f@xmath0 electrode . @xmath68 is the spin dependent junction resistance between the base electrode and f@xmath0 , and is defined in terms of the spin polarization @xmath69 of junction resistance . @xmath71 is the total junction resistance or @xmath72 . the clean or transparent contact can be recovered by a simple replacement @xmath73 . for the sign of @xmath25 s ( spin polarization ) , we are going to adopt the following convention . when the spin - up(-down ) electrons belong to the majority(minority ) channel at the fermi level , the sign of @xmath25 s is positive . on the other hand , the sign of @xmath25 s is negative when the spin - up(-down ) electrons belong to the minority(majority ) channel . according to our convention , the sign of @xmath25 s is reversed under the magnetization reversal . the same convention applies to the sign of @xmath74 s which are introduced to define the spin polarization in the resistance of the interface . after some algebra as detailed in appendix [ dalgebra ] , we find the expressions for @xmath75 and @xmath42 , which contain all the information about the spin polarized transport in the one - dimensional spin valve . @xmath76 , \\ \frac{j_i}{i } & = & - \frac{1}{2 } g_{i1 } [ ( \beta_1 -\beta ) r_1 + ( \gamma_1 - \beta ) r_{t1 } ] , \\ \label{drop_v } \frac{v_i}{i } & = & - [ ( \beta - \beta_1)^2 r_1 + ( \beta^2 - 2\beta \gamma_1 + 1 ) r_{t1 } ] \delta_{i,1 } \nonumber\\ & & + [ ( \beta_i - \beta ) r_i + ( \gamma_i-\beta ) r_{ti } ] g_{i1 } \nonumber\\ & & \times [ ( \beta_1 - \beta ) r_1 + ( \gamma_1 - \beta ) r_{t1}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath77 is the element of the matrix @xmath78 defined in eq . ( [ cond_matrix ] ) of appendix [ dalgebra ] and has the dimension of conductance . the other set of material parameters , @xmath79 and @xmath80 , are introduced in appendix [ dalgebra ] and their definitions are repeated here for readers . @xmath81 these new material parameters need our special attention . they have the dimension of resistance and deserve their own terminology . they are already called the _ spin resistance _ in the literature . first of all , the spin resistance is introduced to simplify the algebra as shown in appendix [ dalgebra ] . as the above equations show , this spin resistance determines the nonlocal spin signals such as the voltage drops and the leakage spin currents in the voltage probes . more physical insights on the spin resistance are elaborated on in appendix [ s_resist ] . since we are interested in the nonlocal transport measurements , we focus on the leakage spin currents and voltage drops in the voltage probes ( f@xmath0 with @xmath1 ) . the leakage spin current in the nonlocal voltage probes is given by the expression [ eq . ( [ spin_i ] ) ] @xmath82 i.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this relation for the nonlocal spin current @xmath46 suggests that the conductance matrix @xmath78 contains all the information about the mutual effect of nonlocal voltage probes . since the conductance @xmath83 does not depend on the magnetization configuration of the fm electrodes , the leaking spin current does not depend on the magnetization orientation of voltage probes , but instead depends on the magnetization orientation of the spin - injecting fm electrode ( f1 ) and the base electrode ( if ferromagnetic , @xmath84 ) . this important observation can be understood as follows . the flow direction of spin current ( the sign of @xmath46 ) , in the base electrode as well as in the fm electrodes , is obviously determined by the magnetization configuration in the spin - injecting electrode . this means the flow direction of spin current can not be altered by the change of magnetic configurations in nonlocal voltage probes . this is due to the fact that the nonequilibrium spin current is generated by the spin - injecting electrode , but not by nonlocal voltage probes . another important observation is that the magnitude of spin current or @xmath46 is not modified under the magnetization reversal of nonlocal voltage probes , which in fact derives from the symmetry in the sdd equations . this property of @xmath46 derives from decoupling of spin and charge modes in sdd equations as well as the zero charge current in nonlocal voltage probes . detailed analysis can be found in appendix [ 3d - case ] . the relation @xmath85 simply reflects the conservation of spin current at the interface between the voltage probe and the base electrode . @xmath86 defined below is ubiquitous in the expressions of @xmath46 and @xmath42 . @xmath87 i.\end{aligned}\ ] ] we may call @xmath86 as the _ spin potential _ which is the source from the spin - injecting electrode and drives the spin current in the spin valve . the leakage spin current in nonlocal probes can be written as @xmath88 the spin current in the spin valve device can be expressed in terms of the spin potential @xmath86 and the conductance matrix @xmath78 as @xmath89 e^{-y/\lambda_1 } , \\ i_i^{s } & = & g_{i1 } v_1^{s } e^{-y/\lambda_i } , i \neq 1.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the voltage drop in the nonlocal voltage probes is given by the expression [ eq . ( [ drop_v ] ) ] @xmath90 g_{i1 } \nonumber\\ & & \times [ ( \beta_1 - \beta ) r_1 + ( \gamma_1 - \beta ) r_{t1 } ] i.\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the voltage drop can be written as the product of spin current and some sort of spin resistance as @xmath91 i_i.\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath42 is the effective measure of weighted averaging the spin - up and spin - down electrochemical potentials in f@xmath0 and so depends on the magnetization configuration of f@xmath0 . in addition , @xmath42 can be understood as a shift in the fermi level in order to satisfy the condition of zero charge current in the nonlocal voltage probes . look at appendix [ s_resist ] for details . though the leakage spin current @xmath46 in f@xmath0 is independent of the magnetization orientations of all nonlocal voltage probes ( parallel or antiparallel to that of spin - injecting probe ) , the voltage drop @xmath42 depends on the magnetization orientation of f@xmath0 , the spin - injecting probe and the base electrode , but not on that of other voltage probes . in this section our discussion is confined to the spin valve system with three ferromagnetic electrodes and _ nonmagnetic _ ( @xmath92 ) base electrode . the current @xmath93 is injected from the left of nonmagnetic base electrode and is drained to f1 ( see fig . [ 3fmlead ] ) . though the charge current is null to the right of the contact between f1 and the base electrode , the finite spin current is induced everywhere by the spin injection , accumulation and diffusion . with two nonlocal fm electrodes ( labeled as f2 and f3 ) contacted with the nonmagnetic base electrode to the right of f1 , we want to study the mutual influence of two nonlocal fm electrodes on their voltage drops and leakage spin currents or non - local spin signals . with three fm electrodes , the dimension of conductance matrix @xmath78 is @xmath94 . @xmath95 here @xmath96 for @xmath23 and @xmath97 , @xmath98 , and @xmath99 , where @xmath100 is the distance between the contacts of the @xmath0-th and @xmath101-th fm electrodes with the base electrode . after inserting the explicit expressions of @xmath83 into eq . ( [ nonlocal_i ] ) with @xmath26 or @xmath102 we find the leakage spin currents @xmath103 and @xmath104 in the nonlocal electrodes to be given by the expressions @xmath105 , \\ \label{3lead_i3 } i_3 & = & - \frac{ir}{2d } e^{-l_{13}/\lambda } ~ ( \beta_1 r_1 + \gamma_1 r_{t1 } ) ( r_2 + r_{t2 } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath106 is the determinant of the matrix @xmath107 and is given by the expression @xmath108 obviously the exponentially decaying factor can be extracted out as @xmath109 ( @xmath62 ) , where @xmath110 is negative . as mentioned in the previous section , the leaking spin current ( @xmath103 and @xmath104 ) does not depend on the magnetization configuration of the nonlocal voltage probes ( f2 and f3 ) , but only on the magnetization configuration of the spin - injecting electrode ( f1 ) . this is clearly explained by the fact that the spin current is generated by the spin - injecting electrode . the nonlocal voltage drops @xmath111 and @xmath112 are related to their leakage spin currents as @xmath113 this relation suggests that the nonlocal voltage drop @xmath42 is proportional to the corresponding nonlocal spin current @xmath46 and the proportionality constant is the effective spin resistance which depends on the magnetization orientation of f@xmath0 . this resistance is the intrinsic material properties of the relevant fm electrode so that the effect of the other fm electrode is completely embedded into the nonlocal spin current . this means that we can discuss the effect of multiple fm electrodes on transresistance in terms of the leakage spin current . from eqs . ( [ 3lead_i2 ] ) , ( [ 3lead_i3 ] ) and ( [ 3lead_v ] ) , transresistance ( @xmath114 and @xmath115 ) in f2 and f3 electrodes are reduced to the following forms . @xmath116 , \\ \label{3lead_tr3 } r_{s3 } & = & -\frac{r}{2d } e^{-l_{13}/\lambda } ~ ( \beta_1 r_1 + \gamma_1 r_{t1 } ) ( r_2 + r_{t2 } ) \nonumber\\ & & \times ( \beta_3 r_3 + \gamma_3 r_{t3 } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we denote the transresistance in the absence of an additional fm electrode using the superscript as @xmath117 and @xmath118 . the same notations with superscript will be used for nonlocal voltage drop and spin current . the effect of other nonlocal fm electrode on the transresistance can be quantified by computing the ratio : @xmath119 with @xmath62 . it follows from eq . ( [ 3lead_i ] ) and ( [ 3lead_v ] ) that @xmath120 the effect of an additional fm electrode on the transresistance can be measured by how much the nonlocal spin current is reduced or by the change of the conductance matrix @xmath78 under the other fm electrode . two important facts can be read off from eqs . ( [ 3lead_tr2 ] ) and ( [ 3lead_tr3 ] ) . ( i ) the transresistance of one fm electrode ( say , f3 ) does not depend on magnetization orientation of the other electrode ( say , f2 ) . that is , the transresistance @xmath121 in f3 does not depend on the spin polarization , @xmath122 and @xmath123 , of f2 . in ref . , the transresistance was observed to be independent of the magnetization orientation ( parallel or antiparallel to f3 ) of the intervening fm electrode f2 , which is supported by our theoretical results . however this fact does not necessarily mean @xcite that the observed transresistance is not influenced by the additional fm electrode . the transresistance can be either significantly changed or weakly influenced by the presence of the additional intervening fm electrode , depending on sample and material parameters as we shall show below . ( ii ) the transresistance can be modified @xcite even when the additional contacting electrode is nonmagnetic . the relative magnitude of the interface and bulk resistance ( defined over the sdl ) plays an important role in determining the transresistance . irrespective of the magnetic or nonmagnetic nature of the intervening electrode , the transresistance will be influenced only by spin resistance and the interface quality . according to eq . ( [ ratio0 ] ) , the effect of an additional fm electrode on the transresistance is equivalent to its effect on the nonlocal leakage spin current . after the spin current is injected from f1 electrode , it will flow into both directions in n and will leak into nonlocal probes . from this perspective we can expect that the effect will be much stronger when an additional fm electrode lies in between two ( spin - injecting and spin - detecting ) fm electrodes than when it lies outside two electrodes . in the former case , the nonlocal spin current in spin - detecting probe will be reduced proportionally by the amount of spin current drained into an intervening electrode . in the latter case , the injected spin current leaks into the spin - detecting probe first and then into an additional fm electrode , so that the effect will be weaker . mathematically this difference between two cases comes from the asymmetry between eq . ( [ 3lead_i2 ] ) and eq . ( [ 3lead_i3 ] ) . under the index exchange @xmath124 , @xmath103 and @xmath104 are inequivalent due to the additional term @xmath125 in @xmath103 . to be more quantitative , let us consider @xmath103 when @xmath126 s in eq . ( [ d ] ) are all much less than a unity . this is a good approximation in all - metallic lateral spin valve systems since the spacing between the electrodes is comparable to the sdl which is of the order of few hundred nanometers . under this approximation , we can readily show that @xmath127 therefore , @xmath128 is very weakly influenced by the fm electrode f3 and the transresistance is almost the same as that in the absence of the electrode f3 . that is , the transresistance is not much changed by the additional electrode ( f3 ) when it is contacted to the outside of f1 ( spin current injected ) and f2 ( spin current detected ) . however , the effect of an additional fm electrode f3 can not be neglected if f2 and f3 are closer to each other than the sdl . so much for this case . we now focus on the case when an additional fm electrode lies in between the spin - injecting and spin - detecting electrodes . that is , we study the effect of f2 on the nonlocal spin signals for f3 . in the absence of the intervening fm electrode f2 , @xmath118 is @xcite @xmath129 note also that @xmath118 can be obtained from @xmath121 by taking the limit @xmath130 or when the second intervening f2 is effectively decoupled from the nonmagnetic base electrode . the effect of the second intervening electrode f2 on the transresistance @xmath121 can be quantified by computing the ratio @xmath131 , @xmath132 below this general relation will be reduced to the simple forms case by case . in order to provide some physical insights , let us consider the case when @xmath133 . we find the simple form of @xmath131 @xmath134 the reduction of @xmath121 stems from the leakage of spin current into the intervening electrode f2 . the efficiency of spin leakage into f2 is quantified by the relative magnitude of the serial resistance @xmath135 in f2 and the resistance @xmath136 in base electrode over the spin diffusion length . we can understand qualitatively the results of eq . ( [ ratio2 ] ) as follows . spins are injected from f1 into the base electrode n and in turn diffuse into left and right of n. that is , the spin current flows in n and leaks into nonlocal probes . just like charge transport , the spin current at the junction with f2 will continue to flow in n and also leak into f2 . if the effective spin resistance @xmath135 of f2 is much larger than the spin resistance @xmath136 of n , the leakage into f2 will be negligible and the spin current will mostly continue to flow in n. the leakage spin current @xmath103 is larger ( smaller ) if the effective spin resistance @xmath135 of f2 is smaller ( larger ) , compared to the spin resistance @xmath136 of n. obviously the leakage into f2 reduces the spin current in n and in turn reduces the leakage spin current @xmath104 . the larger ( smaller ) @xmath135 is , the larger ( smaller ) is @xmath104 . the spin diffusion length ( sdl ) is of the order of a few hundred nanometers ( nm ) in nonmagnetic metals and the sdl in fm metals is of the order of a few nm to a few tens of nm . the resistivity depends on the sample quality such as the impurities , defects , etc . though sdl is two orders of magnitude different between fm and nm , the relative magnitude of resistance ( @xmath137 : ferromagnetic metal , @xmath138 : nonmagnetic metal ) defined over the sdl can be varied from device to device . roughly @xmath139 in the spin valve devices . usually the interface between the fm electrodes and the nonmagnetic base electrode is ohmic ( @xmath140 ) , but not in the tunneling regime . in real materials , we have the following order in resistance : @xmath141 . for our theoretical study , we will consider both cases of ohmic and tunneling interfaces as well as other parameter regimes . we consider the clean interface between the base electrode and the fm electrodes : @xmath142 . to get the simple expression of @xmath121 , we take the limit @xmath143 . suppose that the fm electrodes are the same material with roughly the same @xmath144 for @xmath23 . if the exponentially decaying factors ( @xmath126 ) are negligible , we find the simple form of the transresistance ratio @xmath145 when @xmath146 , the transresistance will be strongly suppressed by the additional intervening fm electrode . on the other hand , the transresistance will be fractionally reduced when @xmath137 is comparable to @xmath136 . in the other extreme case of @xmath147 , the transresistance wo nt be affected by the intervening fm electrode . as noted in the above , the transresistance can be affected by the nonmagnetic electrode , @xmath148 and @xmath149 . let us study this case in detail . in the clean limit of interface , @xmath150 since @xmath151 with @xmath148 , we obtain the similar result as in the previous paragraph depending on the relative magnitude of @xmath152 . if the contacts between the base electrode and f1 , f3 are clean , but the contact with the intervening electrode f2 is in the tunneling regime , the effect of an additional electrode on the transresistance is negligible . when the junction resistance is dominant compared to the resistance over the spin - diffusion length in the fm lead and the base electrode , or when @xmath153 , the expressions of the voltage drop , eqs . ( [ 3lead_tr2 ] ) and ( [ 3lead_tr3 ] ) , are simplified as @xmath154 the voltage drop at each junction is not influenced by the presence of the other fm leads , when the junctions lie in the tunneling regime . in general , the expression of @xmath112 is not affected by the presence of the second fm lead ( additional fm lead ) as far as the contact is in the tunneling regime . when @xmath155 , @xmath156 so that the second fm lead is effectively disconnected from the base electrode . when the accumulated spin is diffused efficiently into the second intervening fm lead , its effect may not be negligible . we still assume that the contacts with f1 and f3 lie in the tunneling regime . let us see the extreme case of a transparent contact of f2 electrode to the base electrode . in this case , we may set @xmath157 and the desired voltage drop is given by the expression @xmath158 that is , the transresistance can be changed by the second intervening electrode f2 if f2 is in clean contact with the base electrode or if spin leakage into f2 is efficient . using the one - dimensional spin drift - diffusion equations , we studied theoretically the mutual effect of ferromagnetic electrodes on non - local spin signals ( the leakage spin currents and the voltage drops ) in the lateral spin valve with three ferromagnetic electrodes . we found the generic expression of the leakage spin current , eq . ( [ nonlocal_i ] ) , and also a very simple relation , eq . ( [ nonlocal_v2 ] ) , between the nonlocal voltage drop and the leakage spin current . ( [ ratio0 ] ) tells us that the effect of an additional electrode on the transresistance can be discussed in terms of the leakage spin current and in turn in terms of the conductance matrix . the measured non - local spin signals depend on the position of an additional fm electrode relative to the spin - injecting and spin - detecting electrodes . when the additional electrode lies outside of the two fm electrodes , non - local spin signals are found to be weakly influenced due to the exponentially decaying spin coherence over the sdl . on the other hand , when it is located in between the two fm electrodes , the non - local spin signals can be strongly modified provided the junction resistance is lower than or comparable to the spin resistance defined over the spin diffusion length in the fm electrodes and the nonmagnetic base electrode . if the junction resistance is high , the non - local spin signals are weakly modified even when the additional fm electrode is located in between the two fm electrodes the most general expression for the transresistance ratio is given by eq . ( [ ratio ] ) . in general , the non - local spin signal is not much modified when the additional electrode is in tunneling contact with the base electrode , but is fractionally reduced when the contact is ohmic . we also found that the non - local spin signals are independent of the magnetization orientation of the additional fm electrode , which agrees with the experimental observation.@xcite this result suggests that even the intervening _ nonmagnetic _ electrode can change non - local spin signals , which was already observed @xcite experimentally . since our theoretical study is based on the one - dimensional device structure , some care is needed when we try to apply our theoretical results to interpretation of experimental data . strictly speaking , the experimental spin valve structure is not one - dimensional in terms of the current distribution . et al . _ numerically showed @xcite that the nonlocal voltage drop depends strongly on the spatial distribution of the spin - polarized current . the one - dimensional approximation is valid when the current is uniformly distributed through the contact . when the contact is clean between the fm electrode and the base nonmagnetic electrode , the current flow may well not be uniform through the interface @xcite and may be short circuited . in this case , the nonlocal spin signals may deviate from its theoretical estimate based on one - dimensional sdd equations . keeping these restrictions in mind , let us apply our theoretical results to two experimental works . @xcite for numerical estimation ( @xmath159 in this section ) , we take examples of co / cu / co and py / cu / py lateral spin valves and use the following sample size and material parameters . the thickness and width of the nonmagnetic base electrode are taken as 80 nm and 300 nm , respectively . the width of all the ferromagnetic layers is assumed to be the same as 100 nm . the separation between nearest ferromagnetic layers is taken as 200 nm , which gives 300 nm of center - to - center distance . we use material parameters measured at low temperatures . the parameters for cu are @xmath160m@xcite and @xmath161m.@xcite for co , we use @xmath162,@xcite @xmath163,@xcite @xmath164m,@xcite @xmath165 nm,@xcite and @xmath166m@xmath167.@xcite for py , we take @xmath168,@xcite @xmath169,@xcite @xmath170m,@xcite @xmath171 nm,@xcite and @xmath172m@xmath167.@xcite for the co / cu / co spin valve , @xmath173 m@xmath174 , @xmath175 m@xmath174 , and @xmath176 m@xmath174 are obtained . the estimated spin signal is reduced to the value @xmath177 by the intervening f2 electrode . @xmath178 is also reduced by the factor 0.87 due to f3 electrode . for the py / cu / py spin valve , we have @xmath173 m@xmath174 , @xmath179 m@xmath174 , and @xmath180 m@xmath174 . the reduced spin signal @xmath181 by the f2 electrode is @xmath182 . @xmath178 is reduced by the factor 0.87 due to f3 electrode . since the sdl of co is rather long , @xmath183 is comparable to @xmath184 in the co / cu / co case and @xmath185 is large . since , in the py / cu , @xmath184 is bigger than @xmath183 and @xmath186 , @xmath185 is small . the rather significant reduction of estimated @xmath178 in both cases stems from our choice of the long sdl of cu at low temperatures . the long sdl means that the chemical potential splitting between opposite spin directions , though exponentially decaying , remains significant up to the position of the f3 electrode . the significant leakage of spin currents into f3 results in reduction of the spin signal . at room temperature , the sdl of the base electrode ( nonmagnetic metal ) is a few hundreds nanometers such that the reduction of @xmath178 by the f3 electrode is only a few percents . for the experimental conditions in refs . and , @xmath184 is comparable to @xmath135 and we can estimate theoretical value of @xmath185 , eq . ( [ ratio2 ] ) : @xmath187 although the observed @xmath185 is smaller for ref . and is close to a unity for ref . . as pointed out in ref . , the contact between the permalloy electrode and the base ag wire is very clean and the point injection and detection of current is suggested . in this case , the current distribution in the devices may well be nonuniform so that our one - dimensional theory can not be straightforwardly applied . we believe that the nonuniform current distribution is the main reason why some of our theoretical estimates are in poor agreement with the results of ref . . we may discuss the relevance of the device dimensionality based on the effective spin resistance . according to our theoretical analysis , nonlocal spin signals are determined by the relative magnitude of junction resistance and spin resistance in fm and nm electrodes . this relevant resistance is defined under the assumption that the current distribution is uniform in the device . when the current distribution is not uniform as in real devices , we may still be able to define the spin resistance using the effective cross sectional area which is smaller than the geometrical cross section of the sample . nonuniform current distribution tends to increase junction resistance as well as spin resistance , and will modify the magnitude of nonlocal spin signals . this may be one of the reasons for the discrepancy between two experimental results.@xcite nonlocal spin signals ( the leakage spin current and the voltage drop ) in one nonlocal fm electrode are shown not to depend on the magnetization orientation ( parallel or antiparallel ) of the other nonlocal fm electrode . we believe this symmetry of nonlocal spin signals are robust against the sample dimensionality , though their magnitude is sensitive to samples . the spin current is generated by the spin - injecting fm electrode and so its flow direction can not be changed by the magnetization orientation of nonlocal fm electrodes . in addition , the magnitude of spin current does not depend on the magnetization orientation of nonlocal fm electrodes . this property derives from both decoupling of spin and charge modes in the sdd equations and zero charge current in nonlocal voltage probes . hence our conclusion about the relationship between nonlocal spin signals and magnetization in nonlocal voltage probes wo nt depend on the sample dimensionality and qualities . this point is demonstrated more explicitly in appendix [ 3d - case ] . finally , we would like to discuss the properties of transresistance ( tr ) and ( longitudinal ) magnetoresistance ( mr ) in spin valves under magnetization reversal . obviously , both tr and mr are modified under magnetization reversal of two probing fm electrodes . under magnetization reversal , tr changes its sign while mr changes its value . note that mr , in general , consists of the two contributions : one part ( background ) remains the same but the other changes its sign under magnetization reversal . let us consider the effect of an additional fm electrode ( f@xmath5 ) on tr and mr . for the vertical spin valves , it wo nt be easy to implement f@xmath5 . so we consider tr and mr in the lateral spin valves with f@xmath5 . usually mr is obscured by other effects in the lateral spin valves as mentioned before . however , with increased sdl , mr was successfully measured @xcite in the carbon nanotube and graphenes . to measure mr in the lateral spin valves of fig . [ 3fmlead ] , f1 and f3 are both current and voltage probes . based on the results of appendix [ 3d - case ] , we can argue that mr should be independent of the magnetization orientation of f2 , @xcite because there is no charge current in f2 ( an additional electrode ) . explicit calculation , @xcite using the sdd equations , confirms this claim . that is , both tr and mr are independent of the magnetization orientation of f@xmath5 . on the other hand , tr and mr depend on the magnetization orientation of ferromagnetic electrodes through which the charge current flows . this work was supported by the korea science and engineering foundation ( kosef ) grant funded by the korea government ( most ) ( no . r01 - 2005 - 000 - 10303 - 0 ) , by the src / erc program of most / kosef ( r11 - 2000 - 071 ) and by postech core research program . in this appendix we show that the algebraic manipulation can be highly simplified by a proper definition of material parameters and by the vector and matrix notations . kirchhoff rules lead to the constraints given by eqs . ( [ rule_i ] ) and ( [ rule_v ] ) . ( [ rule_v ] ) can be written down explicitly leading to the following six relations ( @xmath23 ) @xmath188 \nonumber\\ & & = \left [ ( 1 \pm \beta_1 ) i ~ \delta_{i,1 } \pm i_i \right ] \times \frac{{\cal r}_{ti}}{1 \pm \gamma_i}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] for algebraic convenience , we introduce new material parameters @xmath189 and @xmath190 . these new material parameters highly simplify the complicated algebra as well as determine the spin currents in the nonlocal voltage probes . then the voltage drop @xmath42 can be written as @xmath191.\end{aligned}\ ] ] addition and difference of two @xmath42 s lead to @xmath192 and @xmath193 it is much more convenient to introduce the matrix notation for the algebraic manipulation . @xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath196 , and @xmath197 . here the superscript @xmath198 represents the transpose of row vectors so that its effect is to change them into column vectors . with these notations , kirchhoff rules can be written in compact forms as @xmath199 ~ |i \rangle \nonumber\\ & & - \beta r { \bf a } |j \rangle , \\ 0 & = & ( { \bf r } + { \bf r}_t ) |i \rangle - r { \bf a } |j \rangle \nonumber\\ & & + ( \beta_1 - \gamma_1 ) r_{t1 } i ~ |1 \rangle .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath200 and @xmath201 are diagonal matrices with diagonal elements @xmath79 and @xmath80 , respectively . similarly , @xmath202 and @xmath203 are diagonal matrices with diagonal elements representing the spin polarization of each fm electrode and the junction resistance , respectively . @xmath204 is the matrix with its elements given by @xmath205 . formally , the unknown parameters can be written in a more compact matrix form as @xmath206 i { \bf g } |1 \rangle , \\ & & + [ ( \beta_1 - \beta ) r_1 + ( \gamma_1 - \beta ) r_{t1 } ] \nonumber\\ & & \times [ ( \hat{\beta } - \beta ) { \bf r } + ( \hat{\gamma } - \beta ) { \bf r}_t ] i ~ { \bf g } |1 \rangle .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the matrix @xmath78 is defined by the expression @xmath207^{-1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix @xmath78 , with the dimension of conductance , is independent of magnetization configurations ( parallel or antiparallel to the spin - injecting electrode f1 ) of the fm electrodes . the set of parameters , @xmath75 and @xmath42 , contains all the information about the spin polarized transport in nonlocal spin valves . in components , we have the spin currents @xmath208 , \\ \frac{j_i}{i } & = & -\frac{1}{2 } g_{i1 } [ ( \beta_1 - \beta ) r_1 + ( \gamma_1 - \beta ) r_{t1 } ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and the voltage drops in the fm electrodes @xmath209 \delta_{i,1 } \nonumber\\ & & + [ ( \beta_i - \beta ) r_i + ( \gamma_i - \beta ) r_{ti } ] \nonumber\\ & & \times g_{i1 } [ ( \beta_1 - \beta ) r_1 + ( \gamma_1 - \beta ) r_{t1}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the final results are written down in a very compact form , using new material parameters as well as the conductance matrix . spin resistance was defined in order to simplify the algebra . in this section we are going to infuse some physical meaning into spin resistance . let us recast eq . ( [ spin_r ] ) for @xmath1 ( nonlocal voltage probes ) into a more illuminating form as @xmath210 where @xmath211 acts as the effective electric potential of the base electrode at the junction with f@xmath0 and is defined by @xmath212 for electrons with negative charge , @xmath42 is the electric potential for both spin directions far into f@xmath0 , and @xmath213 is the electric potential for spin - up and spin - down electrons , respectively , of the base electrode at the junction with f@xmath0 . refer to eqs . ( [ ecp_fm ] ) and ( [ ecp_n ] ) . we can deduce that the current @xmath214 at the interface flows into ( out of ) f@xmath0 for spin - up ( spin - down ) electrons . the left hand side ( lhs ) of eq . ( [ spin_r2 ] ) represents the electric potential difference for both spin directions between the base electrode and f@xmath0 at the deep inside . the right hand side ( rhs ) is the product of the current @xmath214 and the effective spin - dependent resistance . the sign in front represents correctly the flowing direction of the spin - up and spin - down current , respectively . the first term in the parenthesis is the spin - dependent tunnel resistance as defined in eq . ( [ r_ts ] ) . the second term is none other than the spin resistance , which was introduced in the main text . with this spin resistance , eq . ( [ spin_r2 ] ) is the effective ohm s law for the leakage spin - up and spin - down currents . when @xmath211 is eliminated from eq . ( [ spin_r2 ] ) , the relation between the nonlocal voltage drop @xmath42 and the leakage spin current @xmath46 or eq . ( [ nonlocal_v2 ] ) is obtained . from eq . ( [ spin_r2 ] ) , we can deduce the physical meaning of @xmath42 . no charge current flows in the nonlocal fm electrodes . @xmath42 represents the shift of the electrochemical potential in f@xmath0 to satisfy the constraint of no charge current flow . if we eliminate @xmath42 from eq . ( [ spin_r2 ] ) , we find the following relation @xmath215 the material parameters are defined in appendix [ dalgebra ] . how do we interpret this relation ? this relation can be considered as the ohm s law for the leakage spin current . the lhs is the product of the spin current @xmath46 and the effective resistance . from the standpoint of f@xmath0 , the spin current @xmath46 flows from both sides of the base electrode ( @xmath136 ) through the junction ( @xmath80 ) and into f@xmath0 ( @xmath79 ) . hence the effective resistance is @xmath216 as in the above equation . the rhs is the effective spin potential which combines the source term from f1 and the sink terms from other nonlocal fm electrodes . one of key results of our paper is the independence of the spin accumulation , the spin current , and the nonlocal voltage on the magnetization directions of electrodes . this appendix is aimed to provide an insight into the origin of this independence in three - dimensional situations . we again consider the geometry in fig . 1 . similar notations will be used . the three - dimensional sdd equation is given by eq . ( [ sdde_3d ] ) and the associated charge and spin current densities @xmath217 , @xmath218 are given by @xmath219 similar relations hold for @xmath220 , @xmath221 , and @xmath222 in the f@xmath0 electrode . the system is subject to the following boundary conditions . from the condition of no leakage current to air or insulating substrate , @xmath223 should hold at the sample boundaries facing air or insulating substrate . here @xmath224 and @xmath225 denote normal vectors perpendicular to the boundaries . from the constraint of the current continuity applied to the interface between the base electrode and the electrode f@xmath0 , one finds that the following relation should hold at the interface , @xmath226 the ohm s law provides another boundary condition for the interface , @xmath227 when combined with these boundary conditions , the sdd equation completely fixes the spin - dependent electrochemical potentials . here we remark that the current density @xmath228 , instead of the current @xmath229 , appears in eq . ( [ 3d - ohms - law ] ) and thus @xmath230 in eq . ( [ 3d - ohms - law ] ) amounts to the spin - dependent junction resistance _ per unit area _ , instead of the junction resistance . we also remark that the tunneling barrier at a junction may not be uniform in realistic experimental situations and such non - uniformity can be taken into account by simply regarding @xmath231 as a position - dependent quantity since eq . ( [ 3d - ohms - law ] ) remains still valid even for the nonuniform barrier as long as the tunnelling current remains perpendicular to the interface . in order to examine the dependence of the spin accumulation on the magnetization directions , we reexpress the involved equations in terms of the spin accumulation @xmath232 and the charge potential @xmath233 . the sdd equation ( [ sdde_3d ] ) is again decomposed into the following two decoupled equations ( spin mode and charge mode ) , @xcite @xmath234 the boundary conditions for the spin accumulation can be derived from eq . ( [ 3d - no - leakage - current ] ) and one obtains @xmath235 from eq . ( [ 3d - current - continuity ] ) , one obtains @xmath236 and from eq . ( [ 3d - ohms - law ] ) , one obtains @xmath237 now we are ready to discuss the magnetization direction dependence of the spin accumulation , which is completely fixed from its sdd equation ( [ 3d - sdd - equation - spin - accumulation ] ) and boundary conditions ( [ 3d - no - leakage - current - spin - accumulation ] ) , ( [ 3d - current - continuity - spin - accumulation ] ) , and ( [ 3d - ohms - law - spin - accumulation ] ) . note that in these equations , all terms that depend on the magnetization directions are multiplied by the charge current density . thus the spin accumulation should be independent of the magnetization directions of electrodes in which the charge current density vanishes . next we discuss the magnetization direction dependence of the spin current . the spin current can be obtained from the spin accumulation as follows , @xmath238 then from the properties of the spin accumulation , it is evident that the spin current density should be independent of the magnetization directions of electrodes in which the charge current density vanishes . finally we discuss the charge potential , which is subject to the sdd equation ( [ 3d - sdd - equation - charge - potential ] ) . the boundary conditions for the charge potential can be derived from eqs . ( [ 3d - no - leakage - current ] ) , and one obtains @xmath239 from eq . ( [ 3d - current - continuity ] ) , one obtains @xmath240 and from eq . ( [ 3d - ohms - law ] ) , one obtains @xmath241 \nonumber \\ & & \,\,\,\,\,\ , \times \hat{\bf n}\cdot \nabla ( \mu_{i+}-\mu_{i- } ) \nonumber \\ & & + { { \cal r}_{ti } \over 8}\left [ ( 1+\beta_i)^2(1+\gamma_i)+(1-\beta_i)^2(1-\gamma_i)\right ] \hat{\bf n}\cdot { \bf j}^{\rm c}_i . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the sdd equation ( [ 3d - sdd - equation - charge - potential ] ) and the boundary conditions ( [ 3d - no - leakage - current - charge - potential ] ) , ( [ 3d - current - continuity - charge - potential ] ) are not dependent on the magnetization directions of any electrodes . thus the magnetization direction dependence can arise only from the boundary condition ( [ 3d - ohms - law - charge - potential ] ) . from eq . ( [ 3d - ohms - law - charge - potential ] ) and from the properties of the spin accumulation , one then finds that the charge potential at the electrode f@xmath0 is independent of the magnetization direction of other non - current - carrying electrodes . this in turn implies that the nonlocal voltage measured between the electrode f@xmath0 and the base electrode ( @xmath242 ) should be independent of the magnetization directions of other non - current - carrying electrodes f@xmath101 @xmath243 . l. berger , phys . b * 54 * , 9353 ( 1996 ) . j. slonczewski , j. magn . magn . mater . * 159 * , l1 ( 1996 ) . for a recent review , see a. bratass , g. e. w. bauer , and p. j. kelly , phys . rep . * 427 * , 157 ( 2006 ) ; y. tserkovnyak , a. brataas , g. e. w. bauer , and b. i. halperin , rev . phys . * 77 * , 1375 ( 2005 ) . m. n. baibich , j. m. broto , a. fert , f. nguyen van dau , f. petroff , p. etienne , g. creuzet , a. friederich , and j. chazelas , phys . lett . * 61 * , 2472 ( 1988 ) . g. binasch , p. grnberg , f. saurenbach , and w. zinn , phys . b * 39 * , 4828 ( 1989 ) . f. j. jedema , h. b. heersche , a. t. filip , j. j. a. baselmans , and b. j. van wees , nature ( london ) * 416 * , 713 ( 2002 ) ; f. j. jedema , m. s. nijboer , a. t. filip , and b. j. van wees , phys . b * 67 * , 085319 ( 2003 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we study the effect of the ferromagnetic ( fm ) contacts on the spin accumulation in the lateral spin valve system for the collinear magnetization configurations . when an additional fm electrode is introduced in the all - metallic lateral spin - valve system , we find that the transresistance can be fractionally suppressed or very weakly influenced depending on the position of the additional fm electrode , and relative magnitudes of contact resistance and the bulk resistance defined over the spin diffusion length . nonlocal spin signals such as nonlocal voltage drop and leakage spin currents are independent of the magnetization orientation of the additional fm electrode . even when the additional contact is nonmagnetic , nonlocal spin signals can be changed by the spin current leaking into the nonmagnetic electrode ."
] | 10,479 | 10,479 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the abelian sandpile model and rotor - routing model are combinatorial models of various dynamics on graphs that were rediscovered several times in several different communities , ranging from combinatorics to self - organized criticality , arithmetic geometry , and algorithms . ( for example , @xcite ; see @xcite for more details and references . ) the stable configurations in the abelian sandpile model on a graph @xmath1 form a group called the sandpile group or the critical group of @xmath1 ; it is also known as the picard group of the graph , which we will denote @xmath0 in analogy with the picard group of a riemann surface . it has long been known that the order of @xmath0 is equal to the number of spanning trees of @xmath1 ( see , e.g. , @xcite and references therein ) . indeed , this is a form of kirchoff s matrix tree theorem . a natural first question to ask , then , is whether there is a canonical bijection between the elements of @xmath0 and the spanning trees of @xmath1 . what does `` canonical '' mean here ? at the very least , we should require that the bijection be invariant under automorphisms of @xmath1 , for certainly it should nt depend on what we name the vertices and edges . but there is clearly no such bijection : many graphs , e.g. a complete graph or an @xmath2-cycle , do nt even have a distinguished spanning tree that could correspond to the identity element of @xmath0 . so it is natural to ask instead for the next best thing : _ is there a canonical free , transitive action of the sandpile group on the set of spanning trees ? _ in other words , is there a canonical @xmath0-torsor structure on the set of spanning trees of @xmath1 ? by `` canonical , '' we still mean an action that is invariant under automorphisms of @xmath1 . such an action would give a bijection between the sandpile group and the set of spanning trees , once we decide on a spanning tree that corresponds to the identity element . but this is still too much to ask for . for example , consider the graph @xmath1 with two vertices and @xmath2 parallel edges between them . the sandpile group @xmath0 is cyclic of order @xmath2 , and each edge of @xmath1 is itself a spanning tree . so an automorphism - invariant action of @xmath3 amounts to an automorphism - invariant cyclic ordering of the edges , which clearly does not exist . this example , and others like it , suggest that we might hope for a free transitive action that is canonically defined on @xmath1 once we ve fixed the additional structure of a cyclic ordering of the edges incident to each vertex . a graph together with such a system of cyclic orderings is called a _ ribbon graph _ ( or sometimes `` combinatorial embedding '' ) . we therefore arrive at the following question . [ q : intro ] is there a free and transitive action of @xmath0 on the spanning trees of @xmath1 that is invariant under automorphisms preserving a ribbon graph structure on @xmath1 ? holroyd _ et al . _ @xcite gave one possible way to answer question [ q : intro ] . given a ribbon graph _ and _ a choice of a basepoint vertex , they used rotor - routing to define a free and transitive action of @xmath0 on the spanning trees of @xmath1 . this action is explained in section 2 . therefore an affirmative answer to question [ q : intro ] would follow if one could prove that the basepoint in the construction of holroyd _ et al _ is unnecessary . in other words , we have the following question , which to our knowledge was first asked by ellenberg @xcite : does the rotor - routing action of @xmath0 on the spanning trees of @xmath1 depend on the choice of basepoint ? in this paper we prove that if @xmath1 is a _ planar _ ribbon graph , then miraculously , the action defined by rotor routing is independent of the basepoint and hence canonical . furthermore , we show that this characterization is tight : only planar ribbon graphs have this property . our main theorem is thus : [ theorem : main ] let @xmath1 be a connected ribbon graph . the action of the sandpile group @xmath0 on the set @xmath4 of spanning trees is independent of the choice of basepoint vertex if and only if @xmath1 is a planar ribbon graph . the proof is based on three key ideas . first , the rotor - routing action of the sandpile group on spanning trees can be partially modeled via _ rotor - routing on unicycles _ ( @xcite ) . this is a related dynamical system with the property that rotor - routing becomes periodic , rather than terminating after finitely many steps . rotor - routing on unicycles is described in section [ sec : reversibility ] . the second main idea is that the independence of the sandpile action on spanning trees can be described in terms of _ reversibility of cycles_. we introduce the notion of reversibility ( previously considered in @xcite only for planar graphs ) , and prove in proposition [ prop : reversibility2 ] that reversibility is a well - defined property of cycles in a ribbon graph . we establish a relation between reversibility and basepoint - independence in section [ sec : spanningtrees ] . third , reversibility is closely related to whether a cycle separates the surface corresponding to the ribbon graph into two components . we prove in lemma [ lemma : almostseparating ] that these conditions are almost equivalent . moreover , although they are not equivalent for individual cycles , we prove in proposition [ prop : planar_is_reversible ] that _ all _ cycles are reversible if and only if all cycles are separating , in which case the ribbon graph is planar . by a _ graph _ we mean a connected and undirected graph , with multiple edges allowed but no self - loops . we write @xmath5 and @xmath6 for the vertex set and edge set of @xmath1 , respectively . throughout , @xmath1 denotes a _ ribbon graph _ : a graph together with a cyclic ordering of the edges incident to each vertex . ribbon graphs are equivalent to graphs embedded into orientable surfaces ( hence their alternate name `` combinatorial embeddings '' ) : from any ribbon graph one can reconstruct a closed orientable surface in which it is naturally embedded , and conversely the local orientation of the surface at a vertex gives the cyclic ordering ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.7 ) ) . we denote by @xmath4 the set of spanning trees of @xmath1 . when the graph is clear from context , we sometimes write @xmath7 for @xmath4 . * the rotor - routing model . * a _ rotor configuration _ @xmath8 on a directed graph is an assignment to each vertex @xmath9 of an outgoing edge @xmath10 $ ] based at @xmath9 . when we speak about rotor - routing or rotor configurations on a ( ribbon ) graph @xmath1 , we will always mean rotor configurations on the underlying eulerian directed graph @xmath11 obtained by replacing each undirected edge of @xmath1 with two oppositely oriented edges . fix a ribbon graph @xmath1 . the _ rotor - routing model _ is a deterministic process on pairs @xmath12 consisting of a rotor configuration @xmath8 and a vertex @xmath13 . we think of @xmath14 as the position of a _ chip _ that will move around the graph as the process is iterated . one step of the rotor - routing process consists of replacing @xmath12 by a new pair @xmath15 defined as follows . first , the rotor configuration @xmath16 coincides with @xmath8 at every vertex except at @xmath14 , where @xmath17 $ ] is the edge leaving @xmath14 that follows @xmath18 $ ] in the cyclic order . second , the new position of the chip @xmath9 is the vertex at the other end of the edge @xmath17 $ ] from @xmath14 . in short , the rotor - routing process rotates the rotor @xmath18 $ ] at the current position of the chip to the next position , and then moves the chip along this edge in the new direction of the rotor . in this paper we will frequently iterate the rotor - routing process until a certain `` stopping condition '' is reached , and reason about the resulting configuration and the steps taken to reach it . * the sandpile group . * the group @xmath19 of _ divisors _ on the graph @xmath1 is the free abelian group of formal @xmath20-linear combinations @xmath21 of the vertices of @xmath1 . in this paper we will be mostly interested in the subgroup @xmath22 of `` degree-0 '' divisors : @xmath23 if we fix a vertex @xmath24 ( for `` root '' ) , @xmath22 is freely generated by the basis @xmath25 as @xmath26 ranges over the other vertices of @xmath1 . the _ graph laplacian _ of a graph @xmath1 is an operator @xmath27 closely related to the adjacency matrix of @xmath1 . with respect to the basis of vertices @xmath26 , the operator @xmath28 corresponds to the symmetric matrix whose diagonal entries are @xmath29 = degree of @xmath26 and whose off - diagonal entries @xmath30 . the sum @xmath31 of each row and column is 0 , which shows both that the image of @xmath28 is contained in @xmath22 , and that @xmath32 . the image of @xmath28 is a finite - index subgroup of @xmath22 , and the _ sandpile group _ @xmath0 is the quotient : @xmath33 for any graph @xmath1 the group @xmath0 is a finite abelian group whose order is , up to sign , the determinant @xmath34 of any @xmath35 submatrix of the graph laplacian . people who study sandpile groups usually prefer to work with the distinguished representatives of each divisor class that are recurrent under a certain dynamical process . we will not describe the beautiful story of sandpile dynamics here , but that viewpoint does implicitly play a key role in the rotor - routing action that we now define . * action of @xmath0 on @xmath4 . * given a choice of root @xmath36 , holroyd _ et al . _ @xcite defined a natural action of @xmath22 on @xmath4 , which we now describe . this action is trivial on any divisor in @xmath37 and thus descends to an action of @xmath0 on @xmath4 . . the rotor - routing process in the bottom row shows that @xmath38 and thus @xmath39 so the action of @xmath40 on @xmath41 is independent of our choice of @xmath14 or @xmath9 as basepoint . here , the white circle indicates the position of the chip , and the rotors are all oriented clockwise relative to the page.,height=192 ] for a fixed root @xmath24 , given a spanning tree @xmath42 and a divisor @xmath43 , we will write @xmath44 for the image of @xmath41 under the rotor - routing action ( based at @xmath24 ) . we define the action of @xmath22 by describing the action @xmath45 of the generators @xmath46 for each @xmath47 , as follows . given a spanning tree @xmath41 , orient the edges of @xmath41 towards @xmath24 . the resulting collection of directed edges defines a rotor configuration on @xmath1 , except that there is no rotor at the root @xmath24 ; we think of this as a rotor configuration @xmath8 on the graph obtained from @xmath11 by removing the edges leaving @xmath24 . place a chip on the vertex @xmath14 , and iterate the rotor - routing process starting with @xmath12 . stop when the chip first reaches @xmath24 ( which it necessarily must ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3.6 ) ) , and call the resulting state @xmath48 . the rotor configuration @xmath16 is in fact another spanning tree @xmath49 oriented towards @xmath24 , and we define @xmath50 to be the spanning tree @xmath49 . see figure [ f : planar ] . since @xmath22 is an abelian group , the action of different divisors @xmath51 will commute : @xmath52 . however , we emphasize that the actions corresponding to _ different _ root vertices @xmath24 and @xmath53 may _ not _ commute , so it is important to distinguish between @xmath54 and @xmath55 . the action of @xmath22 descends to the sandpile group @xmath0 . in fact , for any choice of root vertex @xmath24 , the resulting action of @xmath0 on @xmath4 is free and transitive ( * ? ? ? * lemmas 3.17 and 3.19 ) . ( this property has been vastly generalized to abelian networks by bond and levine in their recent preprint @xcite . ) we can now restate ellenberg s question @xcite as : if @xmath56 is the permutation defined by this action , does @xmath57 for all @xmath58 and @xmath59 ? in other words , is the rotor - routing @xmath0-torsor structure on the set of spanning trees @xmath4 independent of basepoint ? theorem [ theorem : main ] completely answers this question . a _ path _ @xmath60 in the graph @xmath1 is an edge - injective map @xmath61 from the length-@xmath62 path @xmath63 ; it may or may not be vertex - injective . a _ cycle _ @xmath64 in @xmath1 is the image of a vertex - injective and edge - injective map @xmath65 from the length-@xmath62 cycle @xmath66 ( a circle subdivided into @xmath62 edges ) . we consider both paths @xmath60 and cycles @xmath64 to be oriented , but we identify maps @xmath67 that differ by cyclic permutation ( in other words , we do not specify a basepoint for cycles ) . we denote by @xmath68 or @xmath69 the same path or cycle with the opposite orientation . given an oriented cycle @xmath64 in a ribbon graph and a vertex @xmath70 , the edges incident to @xmath14 naturally fall into three classes : the two edges involved in @xmath64 , the edges ( if any ) on the left of @xmath64 , and the edges ( if any ) on the right of @xmath64 . the edges to the right of @xmath64 , for example , are the ones that occur after the out - edge at @xmath14 in @xmath64 and before the in - edge at @xmath14 in @xmath64 , in the cyclic order at @xmath14 . these three classes are disjoint , since our graphs have no self - loops ; however , if an edge @xmath71 has both endpoints @xmath14 and @xmath9 on @xmath64 , it is possible that @xmath71 is on the left of @xmath64 at @xmath14 but on the right of @xmath64 at @xmath9 . a cycle @xmath64 is _ nonseparating _ if there exists a path @xmath60 in @xmath1 whose endpoints lie on @xmath64 and is disjoint from @xmath64 otherwise , with its first edge on the left of @xmath64 and its last edge on the right of @xmath64 . such a path @xmath60 is a _ witness _ that @xmath64 is nonseparating . the cycle @xmath64 is _ separating _ if no such witness exists ; this is equivalent to saying that @xmath64 is a separating curve on the surface associated to the ribbon graph @xmath1 . the ribbon graph @xmath1 is _ planar _ if every cycle is separating ( equivalently , if its associated surface is a sphere ) . * unicycles and rotor - routing . * a _ unicycle _ @xmath72 consists of a rotor configuration @xmath8 which contains exactly one directed cycle @xmath73 , together with a vertex @xmath26 lying on the cycle @xmath73 . it is not difficult to see that applying rotor - routing to the configuration @xmath72 preserves these conditions , and thus takes unicycles to unicycles ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3.4 ) . in fact , the following is is a key observation that we will use many times : [ lemma : periodic ] let @xmath72 be a unicycle on a graph with @xmath74 edges . iterating the rotor routing process @xmath75 times starting at @xmath72 , the chip traverses each edge of @xmath1 exactly once in each direction , each rotor makes exactly one full turn , and the stopping state is @xmath76 . we write @xmath77 if the configuration @xmath15 can be obtained from @xmath12 by iterating the rotor - routing process some positive number of times . by lemma [ lemma : periodic ] , the relation @xmath77 is in fact an equivalence relation on unicycles . the following lemma shows that each equivalence class is naturally in bijection with the directed edges of @xmath1 . we write @xmath78 if @xmath77 and @xmath79=e$ ] . [ lemma : therotorknows ] let @xmath12 be a unicycle . for any vertex @xmath9 and any directed edge @xmath71 based at @xmath9 , there exists a unique rotor configuration @xmath16 such that @xmath80 . run the rotor - routing process starting at @xmath12 until the next occurrence of @xmath12 . according to lemma [ lemma : periodic ] , each rotor makes precisely one full rotation in this process . since the rotor at @xmath9 only advances when the chip is at @xmath9 , this implies that at some intermediate stage @xmath15 we had @xmath79=e$ ] . the next rotor - routing step then advances the rotor at @xmath9 , so @xmath16 is unique . the _ first _ time the chip arrives at @xmath9 when rotor - routing is iterated starting with @xmath12 , the current rotor configuration @xmath16 satisfies @xmath79=\rho[y]$ ] , since @xmath9 has not previously been visited . accordingly we write @xmath81 as an abbreviation for @xmath82}(\sigma , y)$ ] . finally , when @xmath15 has already been defined , we write @xmath83 as shorthand for the rotor routing process beginning with @xmath12 and ending at the first occurrence of @xmath84 . [ def : reversible ] given a unicycle @xmath72 with directed cycle @xmath85 , let @xmath86 denote the configuration obtained from @xmath8 by reversing the edges of @xmath64 , and keeping all other rotors unchanged . we say that @xmath64 is _ reversible _ if @xmath87 . before using this terminology , we need to verify that it is well - defined : in other words , that reversibility really is a property of the _ cycle _ @xmath64 , and does not depend on the choice of @xmath8 nor the choice of @xmath26 . note that by definition , @xmath64 is reversible if and only if @xmath69 is reversible . we will prove in proposition [ prop : reversibility2 ] that reversibility is well - defined , but we first need the following technical result . this result will also be used , along with lemma [ lemma : almostseparating ] , to show that reversible cycles are quite close to being separating . [ prop : lcrc ] let @xmath64 be a directed cycle . if there exists a unicycle @xmath72 with @xmath85 such that @xmath88 , then the vertices @xmath89 can be partitioned into two sets @xmath90 such that : 1 . if @xmath89 is adjacent to @xmath91 along an edge lying on the left of @xmath64 at @xmath14 , then @xmath92 . 2 . if @xmath89 is adjacent to @xmath91 along an edge lying on the right of @xmath64 at @xmath14 , then @xmath93 . if @xmath89 is adjacent to @xmath94 , then @xmath9 and @xmath95 are either both in @xmath96 or both in @xmath97 . any separating curve @xmath64 separates the surface into two parts @xmath96 and @xmath97 as in this proposition . the key utility of proposition [ prop : lcrc ] is that it allows us to define the sets @xmath96 and @xmath97 knowing only that @xmath64 is _ reversible _ , without knowing whether or not @xmath64 is separating . for any vertex @xmath9 in @xmath1 , let @xmath98 be its degree . consider the rotor - routing process that takes @xmath72 to @xmath99 . for any vertex @xmath9 _ not _ lying on @xmath64 , the rotor ends at its initial position @xmath10={\overline}{\rho}[y]$ ] , so by lemma [ lemma : periodic ] , the vertex @xmath9 was visited either 0 or @xmath98 times . we define @xmath100 and @xmath101 . since @xmath1 has no isolated vertices ( by our convention , all graphs are connected ) , these two sets are disjoint . since no directed edge is traversed more than once , in the latter case @xmath93 the chip must arrive at @xmath9 along each of the @xmath98 adjacent edges exactly once and leave @xmath9 along each edge exactly once . now consider a vertex @xmath14 lying on @xmath64 . since the cycle @xmath64 has been reversed , the rotor at @xmath14 begins at @xmath18=c[x]$ ] and ends at @xmath102={\overline}{c}[x]$ ] . therefore the rotor rotates @xmath103 times , where @xmath104 is 1 plus the number of edges at @xmath14 on the _ right _ of @xmath64 , and so the chip visits @xmath14 precisely @xmath103 times . the first @xmath105 times the chip leaves @xmath14 , it leaves along the @xmath105 edges lying on the right of @xmath64 ; the final time it leaves @xmath14 , it leaves along the edge @xmath102={\overline}{c}[x]$ ] of the reversed cycle @xmath64 ( since this is the final state of the rotor ) . if @xmath89 is adjacent to @xmath91 along an edge lying on the right of @xmath64 at @xmath14 , the chip will leave @xmath14 along this edge at some point , so @xmath93 . similarly , if @xmath89 is adjacent to @xmath91 along an edge lying on the left of @xmath64 at @xmath14 , the chip does not leave @xmath14 along this edge ; in other words , the chip does not arrive at @xmath9 along this edge . this implies that @xmath92 , because we noted above a vertex @xmath9 lying in @xmath97 must be visited along every one of its incoming edges , and this would include the edge from @xmath14 . finally , if @xmath89 is adjacent to @xmath94 and the chip traverses this edge in either direction , then both @xmath9 and @xmath95 lie in @xmath97 ; if not , both lie in @xmath96 . the three conditions above uniquely characterize @xmath96 and @xmath97 as those vertices that can be connected by a path to the left side or right side of @xmath64 respectively ; since this description does not depend on @xmath8 or @xmath26 , the sets @xmath96 and @xmath97 depend only on the cycle @xmath64 . this seems at first to prove that @xmath64 is separating . however , it does not rule out the possibility of a witness consisting of a single edge joining the left side of @xmath91 to the right side of @xmath106 . in fact , nonseparating cycles of this form can indeed be reversible , as we will see in the proof of proposition [ prop : planar_is_reversible ] . [ prop : reversibility2 ] let @xmath64 be a directed cycle . if @xmath107 for _ some _ unicycle @xmath108 with @xmath109 , then @xmath110 for _ any _ unicycle @xmath76 with @xmath85 . in other words , the reversibility of a cycle @xmath64 , as in definition [ def : reversible ] , is well - defined : it only depends on @xmath64 , and not on a choice of unicycle . given a unicycle @xmath72 with @xmath85 , define its _ maximal reversal _ @xmath111 to be the first state @xmath111 encountered in the rotor - routing process such that @xmath112 and @xmath113={\overline}{c}[u]$ ] . in other words , the chip is on the cycle @xmath64 at the vertex @xmath114 , and the rotor at @xmath114 is about to rotate _ past _ the reversed cycle @xmath69 to the edges on the left of @xmath64 for the first time . we will prove that as long as @xmath107 for _ some _ @xmath115 and some @xmath116 , the maximal reversal of @xmath72 is @xmath99 . then we will have @xmath117 as desired . ( we can not use lemma [ lemma : therotorknows ] to deduce this from @xmath113={\overline}{c}[u]={\overline}{\rho}[u]$ ] , because we do not yet know that @xmath118 . ) assume that @xmath107 for some @xmath115 with @xmath109 , and let @xmath96 and @xmath97 be the sets defined by proposition [ prop : lcrc ] . the set of directed edges traversed in the process @xmath119 was described in the proof of that proposition : the chip traverses ( 1 ) every directed edge leaving @xmath93 , ( 2 ) each directed edge leaving @xmath91 on the right side of @xmath64 , and ( 3 ) each edge @xmath120 $ ] leaving @xmath91 . this set of directed edges only depends on @xmath64 , not on @xmath115 or @xmath121 , so we will denote it by @xmath122 . for any vertex @xmath123 , let @xmath124 denote the number of edges in @xmath122 leaving @xmath123 . ( specifically , @xmath125 for @xmath91 , @xmath126 for @xmath93 , and @xmath127 for @xmath92 . ) since the chip ends up back at @xmath26 , it leaves each vertex @xmath123 the same number of times that it arrives there , so @xmath124 is also the number of directed edges in @xmath122 _ arriving _ at @xmath123 . now consider an arbitrary rotor configuration @xmath72 with @xmath85 and @xmath128 . the key to this lemma is the observation that if @xmath111 is the maximal reversal of @xmath72 , the process @xmath129 only traverses edges in @xmath122 . assume otherwise , and let @xmath71 be the first directed edge _ not _ in @xmath122 traversed . since the chip begins on @xmath64 , and no edges connect @xmath97 to @xmath96 , this first edge @xmath71 is based at some @xmath91 . by definition of @xmath122 , either @xmath71 lies on the left side of @xmath64 , or @xmath130 $ ] itself . in either case , the rotor at @xmath14 must rotate past @xmath120 $ ] before it can reach the edge @xmath71 . but this is a contradiction , since by definition @xmath111 is the first time the rotor at @xmath91 is @xmath131 $ ] while the chip is there . in the process @xmath132 , the rotor at @xmath112 rotates from @xmath133=c[u]$ ] to @xmath113={\overline}{c}[u]$ ] , so the chip leaves @xmath114 precisely @xmath134 times . however , if @xmath135 , the chip must have arrived at @xmath114 precisely @xmath136 times , since it did not originate there . since the total number of edges in @xmath122 arriving at @xmath114 is only @xmath134 , this is a contradiction . this shows that @xmath137 , and moreover that the chip has arrived at @xmath26 along each of the @xmath138 edges in @xmath122 directed towards @xmath26 . one of these is the edge @xmath139 $ ] , where @xmath140 is the next vertex after @xmath26 in the cycle @xmath64 , so we must have @xmath141={\overline}{c}[w]$ ] as well . but if the rotor at @xmath123 has reversed from @xmath142=c[w]$ ] to @xmath141={\overline}{c}[w]$ ] , the chip must have left @xmath124 times . to arrive @xmath124 times at @xmath123 , the rotor at the _ next _ vertex after @xmath123 must have been reversed , and so on . by induction , we conclude that we have @xmath17={\overline}{c}[x]={\overline}{\rho}[x]$ ] for all @xmath91 . in particular , the directed cycle of @xmath16 is @xmath143 . since the process @xmath144 does not visit @xmath96 , we know that @xmath79=\rho[y]={\overline}{\rho}[y]$ ] for all @xmath92 . it remains to show that @xmath79=\rho[y]$ ] for @xmath93 . to do this , let @xmath145 be the maximal reversal of @xmath146 . since @xmath143 , the process @xmath147 does not visit @xmath148 , so @xmath149=\sigma[y]$ ] for all @xmath93 . but the previous paragraph shows that @xmath150=\overline{\sigma}[v]=\rho[v]$ ] . since @xmath151 , lemma [ lemma : therotorknows ] implies that @xmath152 . therefore @xmath79=\rho[y]$ ] for all @xmath89 , and @xmath17={\overline}{\rho}[x]$ ] for all @xmath91 , demonstrating that @xmath153 as desired . [ lemma : almostseparating ] let @xmath64 be a directed cycle . if @xmath64 is reversible , then any path @xmath60 witnessing that @xmath64 is nonseparating must have length 1 . conversely , if @xmath64 is a separating cycle , then @xmath64 is reversible . let @xmath60 be a path of length @xmath154 , with vertices @xmath155 , with endpoints @xmath156 and @xmath157 . if @xmath60 is a witness that @xmath64 is nonseparating , the second vertex @xmath158 lies in @xmath96 , and the second - to - last vertex @xmath159 lies in @xmath97 . but this contradicts condition ( 3 ) of proposition [ prop : lcrc ] , which says that membership in @xmath96 is locally constant along paths in @xmath160 . therefore any witness @xmath60 must have length 1 . to prove that any separating cycle is reversible , we will go through the proof of proposition [ prop : lcrc ] in reverse ; the resulting argument closely parallels ( * ? ? ? * corollary 4.11 ) , where this was proved for planar ribbon graphs . ( in fact , a special case of reversibility , for cycles in an @xmath161 planar grid graph , was proved even earlier , in ( * ? ? ? * proposition i ) . ) if @xmath64 is a separating cycle , we can partition the vertices @xmath89 into @xmath162 , where @xmath163 ( resp . @xmath164 ) if there exists a path from @xmath9 to @xmath64 ending with an edge on the left side ( resp . right side ) of @xmath64 . every @xmath9 can be connected to @xmath64 by some path , since @xmath1 is connected , so @xmath165 . if @xmath166 could be connected to both sides of @xmath64 , splicing these paths together would give a witness that @xmath64 was nonseparating , so @xmath167 . let @xmath168 be the ribbon graph obtained from @xmath1 by deleting all vertices in @xmath169 , all edges adjacent to @xmath169 , and all edges lying on the right of @xmath64 . because @xmath64 is separating , no edge on the left side of @xmath64 is removed ( every such edge either joins @xmath91 to @xmath163 , or joins @xmath91 to @xmath106 , in which case it lies on the left side of @xmath64 at both endpoints ) . since no rotor in @xmath170 points along a removed edge , we can restrict the rotor configuration @xmath8 to @xmath168 as @xmath171 . it is easy to run the rotor routing process starting at @xmath172 , because at each @xmath91 the two edges of @xmath64 are now adjacent in the cyclic order . thus at each step , the rotor at one vertex on @xmath64 is reversed , and the chip moves to the previous vertex on @xmath64 . after a number of steps equal to the length of @xmath64 , each rotor on @xmath64 has moved once , the cycle @xmath64 has been reversed , and the chip is back at @xmath26 ; in other words , the process takes @xmath173 . since rotor - routing on @xmath168 is periodic , continuing gives a rotor - routing process on @xmath168 taking @xmath174 to @xmath172 . but this segment of the process does not involve any of the deleted edges . therefore if the rotor - routing process is run in parallel on @xmath1 starting with @xmath99 , the two processes will take precisely the same series of steps . when the former terminates at @xmath175 , the latter will therefore be at @xmath76 , demonstrating that @xmath176 as desired . [ prop : planar_is_reversible ] a connected ribbon graph @xmath1 without loops is planar if and only if all cycles on @xmath1 are reversible . if @xmath1 is planar , the jordan curve theorem implies that every cycle is separating , so lemma [ lemma : almostseparating ] implies that every cycle is reversible . for the converse , suppose @xmath1 is not planar , so it has at least one nonseparating cycle , but that every cycle on @xmath1 is reversible . our first claim is that every nonseparating cycle on @xmath1 has length 2 . indeed , let @xmath60 be a path witnessing that the cycle @xmath64 is nonseparating , joining the left side of @xmath91 to the right side of @xmath106 . this path splits @xmath64 into two directed arcs from @xmath14 to @xmath177 . call them @xmath178 and @xmath179 , labeled so that @xmath180 . let @xmath181 be the cycle @xmath182 , and let @xmath183 be the cycle @xmath184 . the arc @xmath178 is now a witness that @xmath181 is nonseparating , since @xmath178 lies on the left of @xmath181 at @xmath14 but on the right of @xmath181 at @xmath177 . similarly @xmath179 witnesses that @xmath183 is nonseparating , since @xmath179 lies on the right of @xmath183 at @xmath14 but on the left of @xmath183 at @xmath177 . since all three cycles @xmath64 , @xmath181 , and @xmath183 are reversible by assumption , lemma [ lemma : almostseparating ] implies that the paths @xmath60 , @xmath179 and @xmath178 each have length 1 . in particular , the original cycle @xmath185 has length 2 , as claimed . let us rename the edge @xmath60 to @xmath186 , and the cycle @xmath64 to @xmath187 , to expose the cyclic symmetry of our notation . then the cyclic order of these edges at @xmath14 and @xmath177 is the same , namely @xmath188 and @xmath189 respectively , and @xmath190 with indices modulo 3 . see figure [ fig : a1a2a3 ] . let us say that an edge at @xmath14 _ lies between _ @xmath191 and @xmath192 , for @xmath193 , @xmath194 , or @xmath195 , if it comes after @xmath191 and before @xmath192 in the cyclic order of edges at @xmath14 . similarly , we will say that an edge at @xmath177 lies between @xmath196 and @xmath197 if it comes after @xmath196 and before @xmath197 in the cyclic ordering of edges at @xmath177 . and @xmath186 in the proof of proposition [ prop : planar_is_reversible ] . the orientation at each vertex is clockwise with respect to the page.,width=144 ] before moving on , we observe that _ any _ path from @xmath14 to @xmath177 not passing through @xmath14 or @xmath177 except at its endpoints will witness that one of the cycles @xmath198 is nonseparating , so by lemma [ lemma : almostseparating ] any such path has length 1 . indeed , each edge at @xmath14 other than the @xmath191 lies on the right side of exactly one cycle @xmath198 , and on the left side of the other two ; similarly , each edge at @xmath177 lies on the left of exactly one @xmath198 and on the right of the other two . thus the pigeonhole principle implies that no path from @xmath14 to @xmath177 can lie on the same side of @xmath198 for all three simultaneously . we may also assume that no edge @xmath71 connects @xmath14 to @xmath177 and lies between @xmath179 and @xmath186 at @xmath14 , after repeating the following reduction step . suppose @xmath71 is such an edge . if @xmath71 lies between @xmath199 and @xmath200 at @xmath177 , then replace @xmath179 with @xmath71 . if @xmath71 lies between @xmath199 and @xmath201 at @xmath177 , then replace @xmath186 with @xmath71 . if @xmath71 lies between @xmath200 and @xmath201 at @xmath177 , then replace either @xmath179 or @xmath186 with @xmath71 . in each case , this reduces the number of edges at @xmath14 between @xmath179 and @xmath186 while preserving the cyclic orderings of @xmath188 and @xmath202 at @xmath14 and @xmath177 , so we may repeat this step until there are no edges to @xmath177 lying between @xmath179 and @xmath186 at @xmath14 . let @xmath12 be any unicycle with @xmath203 ( e.g. by adding @xmath178 to a spanning tree that uses @xmath179 ; see [ sec : spanningtrees ] for details ) . we have @xmath18=a_1 $ ] and @xmath204={\overline}{a}_2 $ ] by definition . define @xmath16 by @xmath205 . we had @xmath102=a_2 $ ] and @xmath206={\overline}{a}_1 $ ] , and the latter implies @xmath207={\overline}{a}_1 $ ] . but we know moreover that @xmath17=a_3 $ ] . this is because in the rotor routing process @xmath208 , starting from the last time the chip leaves @xmath14 and ending at its arrival at @xmath177 , the chip traces out a path from @xmath14 to @xmath177 . that path has length 1 by the argument above , which means that the chip arrives for the first time at @xmath177 along some edge from @xmath14 . but we have assumed that @xmath186 is the first such edge that the rotor at @xmath14 encounters when it starts at @xmath179 . finally , define @xmath209 by @xmath210 . we had @xmath211=a_1 $ ] and @xmath212={\overline}{a_3}$ ] , and the former implies @xmath213=a_1 $ ] . we have assumed that all cycles are reversible , so @xmath214 and @xmath215 . by transitivity this implies @xmath216 ; since @xmath213=\rho[x]=a_1 $ ] , it must be that @xmath152 . however , this would mean that the rotor @xmath217 $ ] ends up at @xmath218 , which is impossible : this rotor began at @xmath212={\overline}{a}_3 $ ] , so the first edge to @xmath14 that it encounters can not be @xmath218 ( it would encounter @xmath199 first , if not some other edge ) . this contradiction completes the proof that not all cycles in @xmath1 can be reversible if @xmath1 has nonseparating cycles . * spanning trees and unicycles . * the reason that we studied unicycles so carefully in the previous section is that they are closely related to spanning trees , as we now explain . let @xmath42 be a spanning tree . any two vertices @xmath14 and @xmath9 are connected by a unique geodesic path in @xmath41 ; we write @xmath219 for that path , oriented from @xmath14 to @xmath9 . therefore if @xmath71 is an edge of @xmath1 connecting @xmath9 to @xmath14 , the undirected graph @xmath220 contains a unique cycle . now given a directed edge @xmath71 from @xmath9 to @xmath14 and a spanning tree @xmath41 , define a rotor configuration @xmath221 as follows . let @xmath222 denote the collection of directed edges obtained from @xmath41 by directing each edge towards the `` root '' @xmath9 . then the collection of directed edges @xmath223 forms a rotor configuration @xmath221 with unique directed cycle @xmath224 . we will denote this directed cycle by @xmath225 . if @xmath41 already contains @xmath71 , then @xmath225 is the length 2 cycle consisting only of @xmath226 ; note that this cycle is trivially reversible in any ribbon graph . if we took instead the edge @xmath227 from @xmath14 to @xmath9 , the rotor configuration @xmath228 comes from the directed graph @xmath229 , with directed cycle @xmath230 . the following observation will be fundamental for us . for @xmath232 this follows because @xmath233 for vertices @xmath234 , we have @xmath235=t_y[z]$ ] , since the geodesics @xmath236 and @xmath237 share an initial segment . then @xmath238=\rho_{{\overline}e}(t)[z]$ ] , and @xmath238 = { \overline}{\rho_e(t)}[z]$ ] since @xmath95 is not on the cycle . given a spanning tree @xmath239 and an edge @xmath71 from @xmath9 to @xmath14 , the rotor configuration @xmath240 is a unicycle since @xmath241 . conversely , given a unicycle @xmath72 , deleting the directed edge @xmath242 $ ] yields a spanning tree @xmath243 with all edges directed towards the root @xmath26 . this correspondence between spanning trees and rotor configurations lets us partially model the action of the sandpile group on spanning trees . [ prop : rotorscompute ] given a spanning tree @xmath41 in a ribbon graph @xmath1 , let @xmath71 be an edge not in @xmath41 , and @xmath53 any vertex on the @xmath41-geodesic between the endpoints @xmath244 of @xmath71 ( including @xmath14 or @xmath9 ) . let @xmath245 ( so that @xmath246 ) . then @xmath247 is a unicycle , and if @xmath16 is the rotor configuration defined by @xmath248 , then @xmath249 the rotor configuration @xmath8 is equal to @xmath223 , where @xmath222 is obtained by directing each edge of @xmath41 towards @xmath9 . the configuration @xmath8 then has a unique cycle , namely @xmath250 , and by assumption @xmath53 is on that cycle , so @xmath247 is a unicycle . next , by definition , @xmath251 is obtained by beginning with @xmath222 , placing the chip at @xmath53 , and running the rotor - routing process until the chip arrives at @xmath9 for the first time . the presence of the rotor @xmath10=e$ ] does not affect this process , since @xmath9 is not reached until the last step . therefore the rotor - routing process @xmath252 takes precisely the same steps as the process @xmath253 . we conclude that @xmath254 . since @xmath255 by definition , this proves the lemma . * basepoint - independence and reversible cycles . * before giving our last few lemmas and proving our main theorem , let us give some intuition as to why reversibility should be at all related to basepoint - independence . consider a spanning tree @xmath256 , and let @xmath14 and @xmath9 be adjacent vertices connected by an edge @xmath71 from @xmath14 to @xmath9 . suppose that we wish to compute @xmath257 for some divisors @xmath51 . the first step is to compute @xmath258 . by proposition [ prop : rotorscompute ] , the computation of @xmath259 can be modeled ( at least for some divisors ) by a rotor - routing process ; this process terminates with the rotor configuration @xmath260 , which is the spanning tree @xmath41 oriented towards the basepoint @xmath14 . the next step is to compute @xmath261 , and to do this we first need to re - orient the tree @xmath41 towards the basepoint @xmath9 . this does not affect any edges except those on the @xmath41-geodesic between @xmath14 and @xmath9 , which are reversed . if we add the edge @xmath71 to our rotor configuration @xmath260 to obtain @xmath262 , the reversal of the @xmath41-geodesic @xmath219 amounts to the reversal of the cycle @xmath224 in the rotor configuration @xmath221 . if this cycle is reversible , then we can compute both steps @xmath263 and @xmath264 as part of a _ single rotor - routing process _ , even though these actions involve two _ different _ basepoints . this basic observation is the heart of the relation between reversibility and basepoint - independence , upon which our main theorem rests . the next lemma capitalizes on this observation . [ lemma : ongeodesic ] given a spanning tree @xmath41 in a ribbon graph @xmath1 and an edge @xmath71 from @xmath9 to @xmath14 , let @xmath53 be any vertex on the geodesic @xmath219 ( including @xmath265 or @xmath266 ) , and set @xmath267 . let @xmath245 ; as in proposition [ prop : rotorscompute ] , @xmath247 is a unicycle . define rotor configurations @xmath270 , @xmath16 , and @xmath209 by @xmath271 note that @xmath272={\overline}{\rho}[x]={\overline}{e}$ ] , and similarly @xmath79=\rho[y]=e$ ] implies that @xmath213={\overline}{\sigma}[x]={\overline}{e}$ ] . in fact , by lemma [ lemma : ovrho ] and proposition [ prop : rotorscompute ] , we have thus we see that equality is exactly the condition @xmath276 . moreover , since @xmath272=\tau[x]={\overline}{e}$ ] , lemma [ lemma : therotorknows ] implies that this is equivalent to @xmath277 . consider the following diagram relating these six rotor configurations : @xmath278\ar_{\txt{\large ? } } @{2{<}~2{>}}[dl]&&(\sigma , y)\ar^{\txt{\large ? } } @{2{<}~2{>}}[dr]\\ ( { \overline}{\rho},s)\ar@{2{<}~2{>}}[dr]&&&&({\overline}{\sigma},y)\ar@{2{<}~2{>}}[dl]\\ & ( \psi , x)\ar_{\txt{\large ? } } @{2{<}~2{>}}[rr]&&(\tau , x ) } \ ] ] three of these edges hold by definition , namely @xmath279 , @xmath280 , and @xmath281 . by the results of section [ sec : reversibility ] , the upper left edge @xmath282 is equivalent to the cycle @xmath283 being reversible . similarly the upper right edge is equivalent to @xmath284 being reversible . finally , we have already shown that the bottom edge is equivalent to the assertion . therefore parts ( a ) and ( b ) of the lemma each assert that if two of the remaining three edges hold , the third does as well . but this follows immediately from the transitivity of this equivalence relation . by lemma [ lemma : almostseparating ] , the hypothesis of lemma [ lemma : ongeodesic](a ) is always satisfied if @xmath1 is planar , so @xmath286 now applying @xmath287 to both sides , we conclude that @xmath288 . we emphasize that we are _ not _ yet claiming that @xmath289 , since the condition of corollary [ corollary : first ] that @xmath53 lies on the @xmath41-geodesic from @xmath14 to @xmath9 need not hold for all trees @xmath41 . [ lemma : rununtil ] let @xmath290 be a spanning tree of an arbitrary ribbon graph @xmath1 . let @xmath14 , @xmath95 , and @xmath53 be arbitrary vertices such that @xmath53 is the first vertex on @xmath291 visited by the rotor - routing process starting with @xmath292 . then @xmath293 define @xmath294 by @xmath295 ; by definition , the underlying spanning tree @xmath49 of @xmath294 is equal to @xmath296 . similarly , define @xmath297 by @xmath298 , with underlying spanning tree @xmath299 . as we noted in the proof of lemma [ lemma : ovrho ] , the configurations @xmath260 and @xmath300 coincide for all vertices @xmath301 , while on this geodesic , the difference between @xmath260 and @xmath300 is that @xmath291 is reversed and thus replaced by @xmath302 . therefore if the rotor - routing processes are run in parallel starting with @xmath292 and @xmath303 , the same steps will be taken until the chip first arrives at @xmath291 . by our assumption on @xmath53 , this occurs when the chip reaches @xmath53 , i.e. when the second process reaches @xmath304 . the first process coincides except that the geodesic between @xmath14 and @xmath53 is directed towards @xmath14 instead . but by the first sentence of this paragraph , this is the directed tree @xmath305 obtained from @xmath49 by directing its edges towards @xmath14 . to sum up , we have observed that @xmath306 . by definition , @xmath307 can be computed by starting with @xmath308 and running the rotor - routing process until the chip reaches @xmath14 . the above shows that the first process reaches @xmath308 as an intermediate stage ; therefore continuing this process eventually yields @xmath309 , since @xmath298 by definition . this shows that @xmath310 . expanding out our notation , this says that @xmath311 applying @xmath312 to both sides yields @xmath313 , as desired . let @xmath53 be the first vertex on @xmath219 that is reached by the rotor - routing process starting with @xmath292 . note that @xmath53 is _ a fortiori _ the first vertex visited on @xmath302 or on @xmath315 as well . we use this to apply lemma [ lemma : rununtil ] twice , giving @xmath316 write @xmath49 for the tree @xmath296 appearing in . notice that by definition of @xmath53 , in the rotor routing process that computes @xmath296 , the chip never touches any vertex on @xmath219 until it reaches @xmath53 , so @xmath317 . so @xmath53 lies on @xmath318 by corollary [ corollary : first ] applied to @xmath49 ( with the roles of @xmath14 and @xmath9 reversed ) , we have @xmath319 the desired result follows once this equation is combined with , by applying @xmath320 to the left - hand side of and applying @xmath321 to the right - hand side of . ( @xmath322 ) first , assume that @xmath1 is a planar ribbon graph . our goal is to prove for any @xmath43 that @xmath323 as elements of @xmath324 for arbitrary vertices @xmath14 and @xmath9 . since @xmath1 is connected , it suffices to prove this when @xmath14 and @xmath9 are adjacent , with the general case following by induction . fix adjacent vertices @xmath14 and @xmath9 . the group @xmath22 is generated by divisors of the form @xmath325 as @xmath95 ranges over the vertices of @xmath1 . but we proved in corollary [ corollary : fulladjacent ] that @xmath326 when @xmath14 and @xmath9 are adjacent . it follows that @xmath323 for any @xmath43 . this completes the proof that if @xmath1 is a planar ribbon graph , the action of @xmath0 on @xmath7 is independent of the basepoint . ( @xmath327 ) conversely , assume that the action of @xmath0 on @xmath7 is independent of the basepoint . choose any edge @xmath71 of @xmath1 with endpoints @xmath14 and @xmath9 . we claim that for any @xmath239 and any @xmath43 , the cycle @xmath225 is reversible if and only if the cycle @xmath328 is reversible . ( we have dropped the subscripted basepoints , since by assumption the action of @xmath0 does not depend on them . ) we first prove the claim in the case when @xmath329 for some @xmath95 . as in the proof of corollary [ corollary : fulladjacent ] , let @xmath53 be the first vertex on @xmath219 reached by the rotor - routing process starting with @xmath292 . since we have assumed independence of basepoint , this process @xmath330 computes @xmath331 . since this process does not reach @xmath219 until the last step , the cycle @xmath225 remains unchanged , i.e. @xmath332 . we may now apply lemma [ lemma : ongeodesic ] to @xmath333 , since @xmath53 lies on the cycle @xmath332 . the condition is always satisfied by our assumption that the action is independent of the basepoint , so applying lemma [ lemma : ongeodesic](b ) implies that @xmath334 completing the proof of the claim for @xmath329 . since @xmath22 is generated by such elements , the claim follows . we now show that every cycle @xmath64 in @xmath1 is reversible . given a cycle @xmath64 , let @xmath71 be any edge of @xmath64 . extend the edge @xmath71 to a spanning tree @xmath41 , and separately extend the path @xmath335 to a spanning tree @xmath49 . since @xmath0 acts transitively on @xmath7 , there exists @xmath43 for which @xmath336 . thus the claim above shows that @xmath225 is reversible if and only if @xmath268 is reversible . but @xmath225 is the trivial cycle @xmath226 , which is always reversible in any ribbon graph , while @xmath268 is our original cycle @xmath64 . we conclude that every cycle in @xmath1 is reversible . by proposition [ prop : planar_is_reversible ] , @xmath1 is a planar ribbon graph . * acknowledgements . * we are very grateful to jordan ellenberg for calling our attention to the question considered in this paper , and we thank math overflow for providing a venue for the question . the first and third authors would also like to thank the second author for suggesting that the three of us get together to work on this problem , which was great fun ! a. holroyd , l. levine , k. mszros , y. peres , j. propp and d. wilson , chip - firing and rotor - routing on directed graphs , in _ in and out of equilibrium 2 _ , eds . v. sidoravicius and m. e. vares , _ progress in probability _ 60 , birkhuser ( 2008 ) , 331364 . ` arxiv:0801.3306 ` .
Abstract: | [
"the sandpile group @xmath0 of a finite graph @xmath1 is a discrete analogue of the jacobian of a riemann surface which was rediscovered several times in the contexts of arithmetic geometry , self - organized criticality , random walks , and algorithms . given a ribbon graph @xmath1 , holroyd _ et al . _ used the `` rotor - routing '' model to define a free and transitive action of @xmath0 on the set of spanning trees of @xmath1 . however , their construction depends _ a priori _ on a choice of basepoint vertex . ellenberg asked whether this action does in fact depend on the choice of basepoint . we answer this question by proving that the action of @xmath0 is independent of the basepoint if and only if @xmath1 is a planar ribbon graph ."
] | 8,778 | 8,778 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in the nearby universe , the population of galaxies with stellar masses greater than 10@xmath2 m@xmath5 is dominated by large early type galaxies ( baldry et al . 2004 ) with correspondingly large sizes ( shen et al . these nearby systems contain old and metal - rich stellar populations that formed quickly in the early universe ( heavens et al . 2004 ; feulner et al . 2005 ; thomas et al . however , it has remained unknown whether the stars in these galaxies were all assembled in the same system , or formed in lower mass galaxies that later merged . two major formation models have been proposed in order to explain the properties of these galaxies : the so - called monolithic collapse model ( eggen , lynden - bell & sandage 1962 ; larson 1975 ; arimoto & yoshii 1987 ; bressan , chiosi & fagotto 1994 ) and the hierarchical merging scenario ( toomre 1977 ; white & frenk 1991 ) . these two mechanisms have both observational and theoretical successes and drawbacks . for instance , evidence in favor of a fast and dissipative monolithic collapse is the fact that the bulk of stars in massive ellipticals are old ( mannucci et al . 2001 ) and have high [ @xmath11/fe ] ratios ( i.e. short star formation time - scales ; worthey et al . 1992 ) . in addition , the structural and dynamical properties of observed spheroid galaxies are well reproduced by cold dissipationless collapse ( van albada 1982 ; may & van albada 1984 ; mcglynn 1984 ; aguilar & merritt 1990 ; londrillo et al . 1991 ; udry 1993 ; hozumi et al . 2000 ; trenti et al . 2005 ) , a process that is expected to dominate the last stages of a highly dissipative collapse . on the other hand , supporting a hierarchical merger scenario , observations find a decline in the number of massive galaxies seen at higher redshifts . this decline is moderate since z@xmath61 and much stronger at even higher redshifts ( daddi , cimatti & renzini 2000 ; pozzetti et al . 2003 ; bell et al . 2004 ; drory et al . 2004 , 2005 ; daddi et al . 2005 ; saracco et al . 2005 ; faber et al . 2005 ; pozzetti et al . 2007 ) . moreover , new renditions of semi - analytical models where merging is the cornerstone of galaxy formation ( e.g. de lucia et al . 2006 ) are much better able to match the stellar population properties of elliptical galaxies . finally , it has been found theoretically that the scaling laws followed by elliptical galaxies are robust against merging ( ciotti et al . 2007 ) . exploring the assembly of massive galaxies with cosmic time through number density analysis or merger rate estimations are however difficult to conduct since , first , very massive galaxies are scarce and , second , their clustering properties make them strongly affected by field - to - field variance associated with limited observed volumes . these two difficulties make claims of the assembly of massive galaxies in the early universe based on number densities and merger rate estimations highly uncertain ( e.g. , cimatti , daddi & renzini 2006 ; renzini 2007 ) . a much more straightforward approach to the assembly problem of massive galaxies is to explore the size evolution of these systems at a given stellar mass . in a `` monolithic - like '' scenario where a galaxy is fully assembled after the formation of its stars , the stellar mass - size relation should remain unchanged as cosmic time evolves . in the hierarchical merging scenario , however , the stellar mass - size relation will evolve as a result of the increase in size after each galaxy merger . for instance , state - of - the - art hierarchical semi - analytical models predict a very strong ( a factor of 1.5 - 3 ) evolution in the size of very massive galaxies ( m@xmath0@xmath110@xmath2h@xmath3@xmath4m@xmath5 ) nine billion years ago ( khochfar & silk 2006b ) . this predicted evolution in size is a strong function of galaxy mass , with the more massive objects expected to have the largest increase in size . due to the lack of a large sample of very massive galaxies at high redshift , analysis of the evolution of the stellar mass - size relation of galaxies have mainly explored objects in the 10@xmath12@xmath8m@xmath13@xmath810@xmath2 m@xmath5 range . observations within this mass interval do not find a significant evolution of the stellar mass - size relation since z@xmath61 ( barden et al . 2005 ; mcintosh et al . 2005 ) . explorations of these objects at even earlier look - back times ( 1@xmath8z@xmath83 ) have been also attempted , and show a moderate decline in size for galaxies at a given stellar mass ( trujillo et al . 2004 ; 2006a ) . however , the size of very massive galaxies , m@xmath0@xmath110@xmath2m@xmath5 , is still largely unexplored , with only around a dozen objects studied in detail so far ( daddi et al . 2005 ; trujillo et al . 2006b ; longhetti et al . 2007 ; mcgrath et al . 2007 ) . definitive conclusions regarding the evolution of sizes for massive galaxies thus remain largely unknown . the goal of this paper is to shed some light on this issue by exploring the sizes of a large sample of very massive galaxies since z@xmath82 . this will help to clarify whether the evolutionary scenario for these objects is hierarchical or monolithic - like . the paper is structured as follows . in section 2 we give a brief summary of the palomar / deep2 data , and in section 3 we describe the determination of the stellar masses . size measurement technique and robustness estimations for our data are provided in section 4 . in section 5 we study the selection effects and in section 6 present the observed stellar mass size relations . we compare our results with other samples in section 7 , and finally , we discuss our results in section 8 . in what follows , we adopt a cosmology of @xmath14=0.3 , @xmath15=0.7 and h@xmath16=70 km s@xmath17 mpc@xmath17 . we use the palomar observatory wide - field infrared ( powir)/deep2 survey ( bundy et al . 2006 ; conselice et al . 2007a , b ; davis et al . 2003 ) to define a sample of 831 galaxies with masses larger than 10@xmath2h@xmath3@xmath4m@xmath5 located over @xmath6710 arcmin@xmath18 in the extended groth strip ( egs ) . this field ( 63 hubble space telescope tiles ) was imaged with the advanced camera for surveys ( acs ) in the v(f606w , 2660s ) and i - band ( f814w , 2100s ) . each tile was observed in 4 exposures that were combined to produce a pixel scale of 0.03 arcsec , with a point spread function ( psf ) of 0.12 arcsec full width half maximum ( fwhm ) . in addition to the hst data , optical imaging from the cfht 3.6-m telescope in the b , r and i bands taken with the cfh12k camera was used . integration times for these observations were 1 hour in b and r , and 2 hours in i. limiting magnitudes reached are b=24.5 ( ab , 8@xmath19 ) , r=24.2 ( ab , 8@xmath19 ) and i=23.5 ( ab , 8@xmath19 ) . the details of the data reduction for this data is provided in coil et al . ( 2004 ) . in the egs region , the palomar near - infrared k@xmath20-band imaging has a typical depth of greater than k@xmath21=22.5 mag ( 5 @xmath19 ) , and a j - band depth of j@xmath21=23.4 mag ( 5 @xmath19 ) . about 70% of the galaxies brighter than r@xmath21=24.1 mag in this field were targeted by the deep2 galaxy redshift survey , using the keck 10 m telescope , for a total spectroscopic redshift completeness of @xmath656% . in our case , 410 objects have a spectroscopic redshift ( @xmath650% of the full dataset ) , with a spectroscopic completeness of 61% for galaxies with z@xmath81 , and a completeness of 30% for galaxies with z@xmath91 . we supplemented our spectroscopic redshift catalogue with photometric redshifts with an accuracy for all galaxies in the total k - band survey of @xmath22z/(1+z)@xmath230.07 in the range 0.2@[email protected] and @xmath22z/(1+z)@xmath80.22 for galaxies at 1.4@xmath8z@xmath82 ( conselice et al . however , it is worth noting that , for the massive galaxies we use in this paper , the accuracy is @xmath24 at @xmath25 , and likely similarly lower for @xmath26 galaxies ( i.e. @xmath27 ) . the determination of stellar masses for each of our galaxies follows a standard multi - color ( brijk ) stellar population fitting technique , producing uncertainties of @xmath230.2 dex . the largest systematic source of error comes from the assumed initial mass function ( imf ) , in this paper we have used the chabrier imf for all stellar mass measurements . the details of these estimations are presented in bundy et al . ( 2006 ) and conselice et al . ( 2007b ) . however , because the measurement of stellar masses is an integral part of this paper , we give a brief description of how our masses are measured , and what systematics might be present . the basic mass determination method we use consists of fitting a grid of model seds constructed from bruzual & charlot ( 2003 ) ( bc03 ) stellar population synthesis models , with different star formation histories . we use an exponentially declining model to characterise the star formation , with various ages , metallicities and dust contents included . these models are parameterised by an age , and an e - folding time . these parameterisations are fairly simple , and it remains possible that stellar mass from older stars is missed under brighter younger populations . while the majority of our systems are passively evolving older stellar populations , it is possible that up to a factor of two in stellar mass is missed in any star bursting blue systems . however , stellar masses measured through our technique are roughly the expected factor of 5 - 10 smaller than dynamical masses at @xmath28 using a sample of disk galaxies ( conselice et al . 2005 ) , demonstrating their inherent reliability . we calculate the likely stellar mass , age , and absolute magnitudes for each galaxy at all star formation histories , and determine stellar masses based on this distribution . distributions with larger ranges of stellar masses have larger resulting uncertainties . it turns out that while parameters such as the age , e - folding time , metallicity , etc . are not likely accurately fit through these calculations due to various degeneracies , the stellar mass is robust . typical errors for our stellar masses are 0.2 dex from the width of the probability distributions . there are also uncertainties from the choice of the imf . our stellar masses utilise the chabrier imf , which can be converted to salpeter imf stellar masses by adding 0.25 dex . there are additional random uncertainties due to photometric errors . the resulting stellar masses thus have a total random error of 0.2 - 0.3 dex , roughly a factor of two . there is furthermore the issue of whether or not our stellar masses are overestimated based on using the bruzual & charlot ( 2003 ) models . it has recently been argued by maraston ( 2005 ) and bruzual ( 2007 ) that the exclusion of an updated treatment of thermal - pulsating agb stars in the bc03 models results in calculated stellar masses too high by a factor of a few . while we consider an uncertainty of a factor of two in our stellar masses , we must consider whether our sample is in the regime where the effects of tp - agb stars will influence our mass measurements . this has been investigated recently in maraston ( 2005 ) and bruzual ( 2007 ) who have both concluded that galaxies stellar masses computed using newer tp - agb star prescriptions are up to roughly 50 - 60% lower than without . this is particularly true for masses determined in the rest - frame infrared . this problem has also been recently investigated independently by kannappan & gawiser ( 2007 ) who come to similar conclusions , but do not advocate one model over another . furthermore , the effect of tp - agb stars is most pronounced in the rest - frame ir , and for young stellar population ages . our survey is k - selected , and the observed k - band is used as the flux in which the masses are computed . the rest - frame wavelength probed with the observed k - band ranges from 0.7@xmath29 m to 1.5@xmath29 m where the effects of tp - agb stars are minimised . the ages of our galaxies are also older than the ages where tp - agb stars have their most effect ( maraston 2005 ; bruzual 2007 ) . it is also worth noting that the effects of tp - agb stars are more important when normalising stellar masses further into the red . in this paper we find a strongest evolution at higher redshifts where we are probing the rest - frame optical at observed - k , and where the effects of tp - agb stars are minimised ( e.g. , bruzual 2007 ) . we investigate the effects of tp - agb stars in our estimations by determining how our stellar masses change between using the bc03 models and the updated charlot & bruzual ( 2007 , in prep ) models using the new tp - agb methods . we find for 1330 massive galaxies in the palomar sample a difference of @xmath60.07 in log m@xmath30 , which is neglectable . a similar conclusion has been recently achieved by mcgrath , stockton & canalizo ( 2007 ) using a sample of galaxies at [email protected] with stellar masses similar to those explored here . on comparing the new rendition of models from charlot & bruzual ( 2007 ) vs bc03 , they found that the inferred galaxy masses are slightly ( @xmath610% ) smaller using the 2007 models . although we do have spitzer data for our sources , we do not use this imaging for two reasons . the first is that by normalising the stellar masses with spitzer irac magnitudes , we are in a regime where the tp - agn stars are more pronounced , and thus would affect the stellar mass measurements to a degree even greater than using the observed k - band ( kannappan & gawiser 2007 ; bruzual 2007 ) . secondly , the large psf of the irac images makes it difficult to obtain accurate photometry for many of our sources due to contamination from other galaxies with overlapping psfs . while it is possible to correct for this , the large resulting random photometry uncertainties make the stellar masses less certain . another possible source of uncertainty is the photometric redshifts we use for our sample . while at @xmath25 about half of our sample have spectroscopic redshifts , at @xmath26 all of our systems have photometric redshifts . we can however determine the accuracy for those systems at @xmath25 . the agreement is very good for our massive systems with @xmath24 . this results in another @xmath820% uncertainty in the stellar mass measurements . for @xmath26 , if we assume @xmath31 , the uncertainty in the stellar masses would be @xmath632% . overall , however , these uncertainties can not account for the trends seen later in this paper . the structural parameters used in this paper were measured using the acs i - band filter . sizes ( as parameterised by the half - light or effective radius along the semi - major axis a@xmath32 ) were estimated using the galfit code ( peng et al . sizes were circularised , r@xmath32=a@xmath32@xmath33 , with @xmath34 being the ellipticity of the object . galfit convolves srsic ( 1968 ) r@xmath35 galaxy models with the psf of the images , and determines the best fit by comparing the convolved model with the galaxy surface brightness distribution using a levenberg - marquardt algorithm to minimise the @xmath36 of the fit . the srsic model is a flexible parametric description of the surface brightness distribution of the galaxies and contains the exponential ( n=1 ) and de vaucouleurs ( n=4 ) models as particular cases . in addition , this model is used in the structural analysis of the sdss galaxy sample ( our local comparison sample ; blanton et al . 2003 ; shen et al . 2003 ) . the srsic index n measures the shape of surface brightness profiles . in the nearby universe , galaxies with [email protected] are mostly disk - like objects , whereas galaxies with [email protected] are mainly spheroids ( ravindranath et al . we use this srsic index criterion to split our sample at higher redshifts and facilitate a comparison with the local galaxy population . during the fit , neighbouring galaxies were excluded using a mask , but in the case of closely neighbouring objects with overlapping isophotes , the objects were fitted simultaneously . the results of our fitting are shown in the appendix : table [ rawdata ] . the results presented in this paper rely on our ability to measure accurate structural parameters . to gauge the accuracy of our parameter determination realistic simulations were conducted . we have created 1000 artificial galaxies uniformly generated at random in the following ranges , matching the observed distribution of our galaxies : 18@xmath37i@xmath21@xmath3726 ( see fig . [ maghist ] ) , 0.03@xmath37r@[email protected] arcsec ( which at z@xmath61 equals 0.25 - 20.5 h@xmath38 kpc ) , 0.5@xmath37n@xmath378 , and 0@xmath37@[email protected] . to simulate the real conditions of our observations , we add a background sky image taken ( randomly at each time ) from a piece of the acs i - band image . finally , the galaxy models were convolved with the observed psf . the same procedure was used to retrieve the structural parameters in both the simulated and actual images . the results of these simulations are shown in figures [ simul1 ] and [ simul2 ] . fifty percent of our galaxies are brighter than i(ab)=21.9 mag , and for these galaxies we find dr@xmath32/r@xmath32@xmath85% and dn / n@xmath87% . for 95% of our galaxies which are at i(ab)@xmath824.2 mag , the uncertainties are dr@xmath32/r@xmath32@xmath830% and dn / n@xmath838% . as expected , at fainter apparent magnitudes the structural parameters are recovered with larger uncertainties . only for magnitudes fainter than i(ab)=24 mag is there a small bias ( @xmath620% ) of the index n towards smaller indices for galaxies with n@[email protected] . recovery of the structural parameters with larger n are more affected than those with lower values . as shown in figure [ simul2 ] , we do not find any bias of our sizes or shape parameter as a function of the size of the objects . finally , we have also explored whether the variation of the psf along the image can affect the recovery of the size of the galaxies . using different stars in the images as a psf we find that the estimation of the sizes is robust to changes in the selected psf to analyze the data : the scatter between the sizes is @xmath4010% ( 1@xmath19 ) . the sizes of the galaxies presented in this paper were measured using the acs observed i - band , which implies that for galaxies at [email protected] sizes are retrieved in the rest - frame uv . to check whether this k - correction effect can affect our size estimates we have compared our sizes measured in the i - band with sizes obtained in the near infrared camera and multi - object spectrometer ( nicmos ) h - band ( f160w ) for a subset of 27 galaxies ( with 0.8@[email protected] and median [email protected] ) that were observed at both wavelengths . these nicmos data consist of 63 pointings of camera 3 ( 52@xmath4152 arcsec , 0.203 arcsec / pixel ) in the egs field . each pointing is the combination of four sub - pixel dithered exposures , with a total exposure time of 2600 sec . the final mosaic was assembled using a drizzle task and has a pixel scale of 0.10 arcsec . we found that sizes measured in the nicmos images , and those measured with the acs i - band data , are well correlated ( see figure [ nicmos ] ) . the scatter between both measurements is 32% ( 1@xmath19 ) . there seems to be a systematic ( although statistically non - significant ) bias of 19@xmath107% between both measurements : sizes measured in the redder band ( h - band ) are slightly smaller than those measured in the bluer band ( i - band ) . consequently , if any k - correction effect is affecting our results , the size evolution found here using the i - band filter would be an upper limit . interestingly , this trend of smaller sizes at redder bands dr@xmath42)/dlog@xmath43=-0.6(@xmath100.2 ) is in qualitative agreement to what is found in nearby galaxies -0.18@xmath9dr@xmath44(@xmath43)/dlog@xmath43@xmath9 - 0.25 ( barden et al . 2005 ; mcintosh et al . 2005 ) . however , due to the large uncertainty on the bias ( and consequently in the size corrections ) , and because we do not know how this correction could evolve with redshift we avoid making any k correction in our results . in any case , it is important to note that the trend towards smaller sizes observed using the h - band does not strongly affect the main result of this paper . in fact , the evolution found in this paper would be even stronger using the near - infrared band sizes at high redshift . another source of concern in the size determination is the presence of an active galactic nuclei ( agn ) in the center of the galaxy which can bias our measurement towards smaller sizes ( daddi et al . deep ( 200 ks per pointing ) x - ray observations ( l@xmath45@xmath4610@xmath47 erg s@xmath17 at z@xmath61 ) from the chandra telescope in this field ( nandra et al . 2007 ; conselice et al . 2007b ) only detect emission in 35 objects ( i.e. @xmath64.2% our sample ) . we remove these potential agns from our sample in what follows , but our essential results are unchanged . in practice , any galaxy survey has a surface brightness limit beyond which the sample is incomplete . characterising this limit is particularly important for high - z samples , where the effects of the cosmological surface brightness dimming are severe . at a given total flux limit , the surface brightness limit translates into an upper limit on the size in which a galaxy can be detected . we have explored whether our k@xmath20-band selected sample could be incomplete at large sizes by examining the detectability of our galaxies as a function of their apparent magnitudes and sizes . to determine the detection map of the palomar k@xmath20 band image , we have created two sets of 10@xmath48 mock sources each with intrinsic exponential or de vaucouleurs profiles uniformly distributed as follows : k@xmath20 band total magnitudes between 15.5 and 20.5 ( vega ) mag ( see fig . [ maghist ] ) , effective radius r@xmath32 between 0.0625 and 3.75 arcsec ( this will be equivalently to 0.5 - 30 h@xmath38 kpc at z@xmath61 ) , and ellipticities between 0 and 0.8 . the simulated sources are placed randomly on the real image and extracted as for the real source detection . we construct from these simulations detection maps giving the number of recovered sources over the number of input artificial sources per input magnitude and input log r@xmath32 bin ( see figure [ maps ] ) . at it is expected , galaxies with a de vaucouleurs profile , and consequently more centrally concentrated , are easier to detect at a given magnitude . over - plotted on the detection maps are the distribution of our sample galaxies . k@xmath20 band magnitudes are measured using the mag@xmath49 output from sextractor . the sizes are those estimated in the i - band . we are making the implicit assumption that sizes are similar in both bands ( i.e. that k - correction effects are not relevant , see previous section ) . at a given magnitude , the observed size distribution declines more rapidly to larger sizes than the detection limit . this indicates that our sample is not affected by incompleteness for the largest galaxies at a given magnitude . the accuracy of the structural parameters and the completeness of our sample has been demonstrated in the previous section . in this section we discuss the stellar mass size relations for our massive galaxy sample . these relations are presented in figures [ disks ] ( [email protected] ; disk - like objects ) and [ spheroids ] ( [email protected] ; spheroid - like objects ) . in each of these figures , we have divided our sample ( over 0.2@xmath8z@xmath82 ) into six redshift slices with a width of dz=0.3 . over - plotted on our observed distributions are the mean and dispersion of the distribution of the srsic half - light radii from the sdss ( york et al . 2000 ) galaxies . we use the sdss sample as the local reference . as it has been done for our high - z galaxies , the sdss galaxy sizes were determined from a srsic model fit ( blanton et al . the characteristics of the sdss sample used here are detailed in shen et al . the mean of the sdss galaxies redshift distribution used for comparison is 0.1 . we use the sizes and the shapes estimated in the observed sdss r - band as this closely matches the v - band rest - frame filter at [email protected] . sdss stellar masses were derived using a kroupa ( 2001 ) imf , which gives the same masses as the chabrier imf used to measure the higher redshift sample stellar masses . figures [ disks ] and [ spheroids ] show that at a given stellar mass galaxies are progressively smaller at higher redshift . this evolution is particularly strong for more concentrated ( [email protected] ) galaxies . we find the remarkable result that there are no spheroid - like objects at [email protected] on the local relation . to illustrate this size decrease at progressively higher z , figure [ mosaico ] shows the appearance of six of our [email protected] ( i.e. spheroid - like ) galaxies with the same stellar mass , but at different look - back times . the objects shown in figure [ mosaico ] have the mean structural properties of the galaxy population at each of the different redshift slices ( see the stellar mass - size relations in the above redshift intervals in figures [ disks ] and [ spheroids ] ) . to allow a fair comparison between the sizes of objects at very different redshifts , the limiting surface brightness in each panel is changed according to the cosmological surface bright dimming @xmath6(1+z)@xmath48 . for this reason the surface brightness of the object at z=0.35 is shown down to @xmath63.25 mag brighter than the object at z=1.85 . this figure visually illustrates that the most massive galaxies are progressively smaller at increasing redshift . to quantify the size evolution , we measure the ratio between the observed size , and the expected size at a given stellar mass by comparing with the sdss ( shen et al . 2003 ) distribution at different redshifts . to estimate the expected size from sdss at a given stellar mass , we interpolate linearly between the sdss points when necessary . the evolution of the median and the dispersion of the above ratio are shown in figure [ evolution ] and listed in table [ data ] . the observed size evolution of m@xmath13@xmath910@xmath2 m@xmath5 galaxies is stronger than the one found in previous work using less massive galaxies ( see the detailed comparison of this issue in the next section ) . following recent claims ( i.e. maraston et al . 2006 ) that stellar masses could be systematically overstimated by a factor of few at high z , we have repeated our analysis under the assumption that our masses could be overestimated by a factor of 2 . in this case , at [email protected] , our galaxies will still be more compact than present - day galaxies of the same stellar mass by a factor of 1.6 for [email protected] and a factor of 3 for [email protected] . in other words , even a systematic effect of factor of 2 in the stellar mass determination can not avoid a significant evolution in the size of these galaxies . in fact , to prevent a significant evolution of the sizes of galaxies at a given stellar mass we found that , at [email protected] , our stellar masses would need to be overestimated by a factor of @xmath610 for galaxies with [email protected] and overestimated by a factor of @xmath650 for galaxies with [email protected] . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^ " , ] an interesting point to explore is how the size evolution found here for the most massive galaxies compares with the size evolution observed for galaxies with lower masses . this comparison can be done in detail in the redshift range 0@xmath8z@xmath81 using the data from one of the largest sample currently available : the gems survey ( rix et al . the stellar mass - size relation of this survey has been already derived for late - type ( barden et al . 2005 ) and early - type ( mcintosh et al . 2005 ) galaxies . the gems late- and early - type separation criteria are based on the srsic index n. late - types are defined through [email protected] , and early types through [email protected] , and a colour within the `` red sequence '' ( bell et al . the comparison of the distribution of their data points with ours are shown in figure [ gemspalomar ] . it is encouraging to see that these two independent analyses and data sets match well where there is overlap in their stellar mass ( i.e. for the small subset of gems galaxies with m@xmath13@xmath910@xmath2 m@xmath5 ) . these two data sets allow us to compare the difference in size evolution in the 0@xmath8z@xmath81 redshift interval at two different mass ranges 10@xmath12@xmath8m@xmath13@xmath810@xmath2 m@xmath5 ( gems ) , and m@xmath13@xmath910@xmath2 m@xmath5 ( palomar ) . this is shown in figure [ gemspalomarevol ] . from this comparison we can see that more massive galaxies evolve in size much faster than lower mass objects ( particularly for disk - like galaxies ) . this mass dependent evolution was hinted in previous works ( trujillo et al . 2006a ) but our current large data set show this more clearly and robustly . at higher redshift , the amount of data is more limited . at 1@xmath8z@xmath82 our results are in good agreement with recent findings ( based on a few objects ) of massive compact galaxies at high - z ( waddington et al . 2002 ; daddi et al . 2005 ; di serego alighieri et al . 2005 ; trujillo et al . 2006b ; longhetti et al . for example , using the 10 of the most massive galaxies ( 1.2@[email protected] ) in the munics survey , trujillo et al . ( 2006b ) found that these galaxies were a factor of 4@xmath50 smaller that local counterparts . at even higher z ( i.e. [email protected] ) there has been also recent claims of very compacts ( r@xmath32@xmath401 kpc ) massive galaxies ( trujillo et al . 2006a ; zirm et al . 2007 ; toft et al . as shown in section 4 the compact nature of our most massive galaxies at high - z can not be interpreted as a k - correction or agn effect . in addition , there is no observational evidence in the local universe for galaxies as massive and compact as the ones in our sample . these two observational facts raise the following two questions : first , how can these objects be so dense in the past ? second , how do these objects evolve in stellar mass and/or size in order to reach the current local relation ? addressing the first question , recent theoretical results suggest that major galaxy mergers in the early universe had a much larger component of cold gas available than in the present ( khochfar & silk 2006a ) . these wet ( dissipative ) mergers generate very efficient and massive starbursts creating a very compact massive remnant . consequently , the very dense nature of our objects at high - z could reflect the much denser condition of the universe at the time of their formation . focusing on the second question , at lower redshifts the available amount of gas is less , and new ` dry ' ( dissipationless ) mergers ( van dokkum 2005 ; bell et al . 2006 ) would be the dominant mechanisms of size and stellar mass growing ( ciotti & van albada 2001 ; nipoti , londrillo & ciotti 2003 ; khochfar & burkert 2003 ; domnguez - tenreiro et al . 2006 ; naab , khochfar & burkert 2006 ; ciotti , lanzoni & volonteri 2007 ) . dry mergers are not efficient at forming new stars , but are efficient in increasing the size of the objects . a particular effective size evolutionary mechanism ( r@xmath32@xmath6m@xmath51 ) has been recently found ( boylan - kolchin , ma & quataert 2006 ) in mergers of galaxies with radial orbits along large - scale structure filaments . this kind of mechanism would be able to evolve our compact galaxies ( a factor of 4 smaller at [email protected] ) to the local relation with just two major ( equal - mass ) mergers . since @xmath52 very few gas rich mergers occur in massive galaxies ( e.g. , conselice et al . 2003 ; conselice 2006 ) , but a few dry mergers are possible based on pair counts ( e.g. , lin et al . in addition , dry mergers of similar mass objects ( and consequently , potentially similar ages and metallicities ) will also help to understand the age - uniformity found in the local massive ( spheroid ) galaxies . on the other hand , in agreement with our results here , new semi - analytical models ( somerville et al . 2007 ) find that disc - like galaxies ( i.e. those presumably with a relative quiet live ) evolve only mildly in size since high - z . summarising our results , we find that the size evolution of the most massive galaxies is not consistent with a scenario whereby massive galaxies were fully assembled in the early universe , and have subsequently evolved passively until today ( i.e. a pure `` monolithic '' scenario ) . in fact , our findings agree with a scenario where a fraction of the most massive galaxies possibly formed in a short `` monolithic - like '' collapse and then evolved through major gas - rich , or gas - poor merging . in this sense , the two scenarios would be just different phases of galaxy formation and evolution . our results , consequently , point to a scenario whereby the stellar populations of the most massive galaxies we observe today were located in different `` primordial '' massive galaxy pieces in the early universe . authors are grateful to m. barden and d. mcintosh for providing us with the gems data points to allow us a comparison of our results with their less massive galaxies . we acknowledge useful discussions with o. almaini and a. aragn - salamanca . we also thank the useful suggestions from an anonymous referee . the palomar and deep2 surveys would not have been completed without the active help of the staff at the palomar and keck observatories . the palomar survey was supported by nsf grant ast-0307859 and nasa stsci grant hst- ar-09920.01.a . support for the acs imaging of the egs in go program 10134 was provided by nasa through nasa grant hst - go-10134.13-a from the space telescope science institute . 99 aguilar l. a. , merritt d. , 1990 , apj , 354 , 33 arimoto n , & yoshii y. , 1987 , a&a , 173 , 23 baldry i. k. , glazebrook k. , brinkmann j. , ivezi , lupton r. h , nichol r. c. szalay a. s. , 2004 , apj , 600 , 681 barden et al . , 2005 , apj , 635 , 959 bell e. f. et al . , 2004 , apj , 608 , 752 bell e. f. et al . , 2006 , apj , 640 , 241 blanton m. r. , et al . , 2003 , apj , 592 , 819 boylan - kolchin m. , ma c - p . , quataert e. , 2006 , mnras , 369 , 1081 bressan a. , chiosi c. , fagotto f. , 1994 , apjs , 94 , 63 bruzual g. astro - ph/0703052 bruzual g. , charlot s. , 2003 , mnras , 344 , 1000 bundy k. et al . , 2006 , apj , 651 , 120 cimatti a. , daddi e. , renzini a. , 2006 , a&a , 453 , l29 ciotti l. & van albada t. s. , 2001 , apj , 552 , l13 ciotti l. , lanzoni b. , & volonteri m. , 2007 , apj , 658 , 65 coil a. l. , newman j. a. , kaiser n. , davis m. , ma c .- p . , kocevski d.d . , koo d. c. , 2004 , apj , 617 , 765 conselice c. j. 2006 , apj , 639 , 120 conselice , c.j . , bundy , k. , ellis , r. , brichmann , j. , vogt , n. , phillips , a. 2005 , apj , 628 , 160 conselice c. j. , bershady , m.a . , dickinson , m. , papovich , c. 2003 , aj , 126 , 1183 conselice c. j. et al . , 2007a , apj , 660 , l55 conselice c. j. et al . , 2007b , mnras , submitted daddi e. , cimatti a. , renzini a , 2000 , a&a , 362 , l45 daddi e. et al . , 2005 , apj , 626 , 680 davis m. et al . , 2003 , spie , 4834 , 161 de lucia , g , springel v. , white s. d. m. , croton d. , kauffmann g. , 2006 , mnras , 366 , 499 di serego alighieri s. , et al . , 2005 , a&a , 442 , 125 domnguez tenreiro , r. , oorbe , j. , siz , a. , artal , h. , serna , a. , 2006 , apj , 636 , l77 n. , bender r. , feulner g. , hopp u. , maraston c. , snigula j. , hill g. j. , 2004 , apj , 608 , 742 n. , salvato m. , gabasch a. , bender r. , hopp u. , feulner g. , pannella m. , 2005 , apj , 619 , l131 eggen o. j. , lynden bell d. , sandage a. r. , 1962 , apj , 136 , 748 faber s. m. , et al . 2005 , astro - ph/0506044 g. , gabasch a. , salvato m. , drory , n. , hopp u. , bender r. , 2005 , apj , 633 , l9 a.,panter b.,jimenez r. , dunlop j. , 2004 , nature , 428 , 625 hozumi s. , burkert a. , fujiwara t. , 2000 , mnras , 311 , 377 khochfar s. , burkert a. , 2003 , apj , 597 , l117 khochfar s. , silk j. , 2006a , mnras , 370 , 902 khochfar s. , silk j. , 2006b , apj , 648 , l21 kannappan , s.j . , & gawiser , e. 2007 , apj , 657 , l5 larson r. , 1975 , mnras , 173 , 671 lin , l. , et al . 2004 , apj , 617 , l9 londrillo p. , messina a. , stiavelli m. , 1991 , mnras , 250 , 54 longhetti m. et al . , 2007 , mnras , 374 , 614 mannucci f. , basile f. , poggianti b.m . , cimatti a. , daddi e. , pozzetti l. , vanzi l. , 2001 , mnras , 326 , 745 maraston , c. 2005 , mnras , 362 , 799 may a. , van albada t.s . , 1984 , mnras , 209 , 15 mcglynn t. a. , 1984 , apj , 281 , 13 mcgrath e. j. , stockton a. , canalizo g. , 2007a , apj , in press , astro - ph/0707.1046 mcgrath e. j. , stockton a. , canalizo g. , masanori i. , maihara t. , 2007b , apj , submitted , astro - ph/0707.1050 mcintosh d. et al . , 2005 , apj , 632 , 191 nandra k. et al . , 2007 , apjl , in press , astro - ph/0607270 nipoti c. , londrillo p. & ciotti l. , 2003 , mnras , 342 , 501 peng c.y . , ho l.c . , impey c.d . , rix h.w . , 2002 , aj , 124 , 266 pozzetti l. et al . 2003 , a&a , 402 , 387 pozzetti l. et al . 2007 , a&a , astro - ph/0704.1600 ravindranath s. et al . 2002 , apj , 604 , l9 renzini a. , 2007 , astro - ph/0702148 rix h .- w . et al . , 2004 , apj , 152 , 163 saracco p. et al . , 2005 , mnras , 357 , l40 srsic j .- l . 1968 , atlas de galaxias australes ( cordoba : observatorio astronomico ) shen s.,mo h. j. , white s. d. m.,blanton m. r. , kauffmann g.,voges w.,brinkmann j. , csabai i. , 2003 , mnras , 343 , 978 somerville r. , et al . , 2007 , apj , submitted , astro - ph/0612428 thomas d.,maraston c. , bender r. , de oliveira c. m. , 2005 , apj , 621 , 673 toft s. , et al . , 2007 , apj , in press toomre a. , 1977 , in evolution of galaxies and stellar populations , ed . b. m. tinsley & r. b. larson ( new haven : yale univ . obs . ) , 401 trenti m. , bertin g. , van albada t.s . , 2005 , a&a , 433 , 57 trujillo i. et al . , 2004 , apj , 604 , 521 trujillo i. et al . , 2006a , apj , 650 , 18 trujillo i. et al . , 2006b , mnras , 373 , l36 udry s. , 1993 , a&a , 268 , 35 van albada t. s. , 1982 , mnras , 201 , 939 van dokkum p. g. , 2005 , aj , 130 , 2647 white s.d.m , frenk c. s. , 1991 , 379 , 52 worthey g. , faber s. m. , gonzalez j. j. , 1992 , apj , 398 , 69 york d. , et al . 2000 , aj , 120 , 1579 zirm a. w. , et al . , 2007 , apj , 656 , 66 note : full data table is available on the online version of mnras or by request to the authors . the following table contains the information about the structural parameters of the sample of galaxies analysed in this paper . column 1 indicates the galaxy identification , column 2 lists the apparent k - band magnitude in the vega system , column 3 is the efffective radius along the semimajor axis , column 4 indicates the value of the srsic index of the fit , column 5 is the ellipticity of the source , column 6 is the stellar mass of the galaxy in units of 10@xmath12h@xmath3@xmath4m@xmath5 , column 7 is the measured redshift of the object , column 8 and 9 are the r.a . and dec . of the source and , finally , column 10 specifies whether the redshift was determined spectroscopically ( 1 ) or photometrically ( 0 ) . 11051619 & 16.75 & 0.90 & 3.60 & 0.38 & 11.94 & 0.46 & 214.258865 & 52.399944 & 0 + 12004106 & 17.13 & 0.80 & 6.72 & 0.11 & 26.72 & 0.74 & 214.379730 & 52.443295 & 1 + 12004308 & 16.95 & 0.89 & 1.23 & 0.58 & 18.03 & 0.64 & 214.266815 & 52.412926 & 0 + 12004443 & 17.06 & 0.48 & 5.04 & 0.21 & 26.96 & 0.77 & 214.318298 & 52.429092 & 1 +
Abstract: | [
"using the combined capabilities of the large near - infrared palomar / deep-2 survey , and the superb resolution of the acs hst camera , we explore the size evolution of 831 very massive galaxies ( m@xmath0@xmath110@xmath2h@xmath3@xmath4m@xmath5 ) since z@xmath62 . we split our sample according to their light concentration using the srsic index @xmath7 . at a given stellar mass , both low ( [email protected] ) and high ( [email protected] ) concentrated objects were much smaller in the past than their local massive counterparts . this evolution is particularly strong for the highly concentrated ( spheroid - like ) objects . at [email protected] , massive spheroid - like objects were a factor of 4(@xmath100.4 ) smaller ( i.e. almost two orders of magnitudes denser ) than those we see today . these small sized , high mass galaxies do not exist in the nearby universe , suggesting that this population merged with other galaxies over several billion years to form the largest galaxies we see today . [ firstpage ] galaxies : evolution ; galaxies : elliptical and lenticular , cd ; galaxies : formation ; galaxies : fundamental parameters ; galaxies : high redshift ; galaxies : structure"
] | 7,806 | 7,806 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the be / x - ray binaries represent the largest subclass of high - mass x - ray binaries . about two - thirds of the identified systems fall into this category . these systems consist of , generally , a neutron star and a be star with a cool ( @xmath2 ) equatorial disc , which is geometrically thin and nearly keplerian . the orbit is wide @xmath3 and usually eccentric ( @xmath4 ) ( e.g. , @xcite ) . most of the be / x - ray binaries show only transient activity in the x - ray emission and are termed be / x - ray transients . be / x - ray transients show periodical ( type i ) outbursts , which are separated by the orbital period and have the lumiocity of @xmath5 , and giant ( type ii ) outbursts of @xmath6 with no orbital modulation . the transient nature in the x - ray activity of be / x - ray binaries is considered to result from the interaction between the accreted material from the circumsteller disc of the be star and the rotating magnetized neutron star @xcite . if the accreted material is dense enough to make the magnetospheric radius smaller than the corotation radius , the accretion on to the neutron star causes a bright x - ray emission ( the direct accretion regime ) . otherwise , the magnetospheric radius is larger than the corotation radius , and the accretion is prevented by the centrifugal inhibition . the system is then in quiescence ( the propeller regime ) . during the outbursts , the neutron stars in most be / x - ray binaries show spin - up ( e.g. , 4u0115 + 63 , gs1843 - 02 , exo2030 + 375 and xtej1946 + 26 ) ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , and some even show quasi - periodic oscillations ( qpos ) ( e.g. , a0535 + 26 and exo2030 + 375 ) ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . these observational features strongly suggest the presence of an accretion disc during the outbursts . the accretion disc is also indicated to exist between the outbursts in several systems ( e.g. , a0535 + 26 ) ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) . on the other hand , @xcite searched the optical / infrared contribution from the accretion disc in a0535 + 26 during the x - ray quiescent phase , and found no signature of the accretion disc in propeller regime . obviously , more work is needed to determine whether the accretion disc also exists in the quiescent state . recently , @xcite studied the interaction between the be - star disc and the neutron star , using a three - dimensional ( 3d ) smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) code ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . they also qualitatively discussed the relation between the x - ray luminosity and the accretion rate using the simulated mass - capture rate by the neutron star . in their simulations , however , the neutron star was modelled by a sink particle @xcite with the size of the roche lobe . hence , no information was available how the captured material accretes on to the neutron star . moreover , no direct comparison with the observed x - ray data was possible . in this paper , we study the accretion on to the neutron star in be / x - ray binaries , using a 3d sph code . the simulation should ideally take account of all the processes at work in a be / x - ray binary , such as the disc evolution around the be star , the mass transfer from the be - star disc to the neutron star , and the accretion on to the neutron star . such a simulation , however , would require very intense computations . therefore , we confine ourselves to simulate only the accretion flow around the neutron star , with an outer boundary condition constructed by the data of the particles captured by the neutron star from a high - resolution simulation by @xcite . this situation is illustrated in fig . 1 , where the right panel taken from their simulation shows the mass transfer from the be - star disc to the neutron star at periastron , while the left panel shows the accretion disc formed around the neutron star in one of our simulations . simulations presented here were performed with a 3d sph code . the sph code is basically the same as that used by @xcite , which is based on a version originally developed by benz ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the smoothing length is variable in time and space . the sph equation with the standard cubic - spline kernel are integrated using a second - order runge - kutta - fehlberg integrator with individual time steps for each particle @xcite , which results in an enormous computational saving when a large range of dynamical time - scales are involved . in our code , the accretion flow on to the neutron star is modelled by an ensemble of gas particles , each of which has an arbitrary and negligible mass chosen to be @xmath7 with a variable smoothing length . note that the accretion flow is nonself - gravitating in our simulations . on the other hand , the be star and the neutron star are modelled by two sink particles @xcite with corresponding masses . the gas particles which fall within a specified accretion radius are accreted by the sink particles . we assume that the neutron star has the fixed accretion radius of @xmath8 , @xmath9 being the semi - major axis of the binary . for the be star , we adopt a variable accretion radius of @xmath10 , where @xmath11 is the roche - lobe radius for a circular binary . this is because our interest is only in the flow around the neutron star . an approximate formula for @xmath11 is given by @xmath12 ( see , for example , @xcite ; @xcite ) with the mass ratio @xmath13 , where @xmath14 and @xmath15 are the masses of the neutron star and the be star , respectively , and @xmath16 is the distance between the stars . in disc simulations using a three dimensional sph code with the standard cubic spline kernel , one has an approximate relation between the shakura - sunyaev viscosity parameter @xmath17 and the linear sph artificial viscosity parameter @xmath18 as @xmath19 if the non - linear sph artifical viscosity parameter @xmath20 is set equal to zero @xcite . here @xmath21 is the sph smoothing length and @xmath22 is the scale - height of the disc . in a simulation we report in this paper , we adopt @xmath23 and @xmath24 in which case @xmath17 is variable in time and space . in the other simulations , however , we adopt a constant value of @xmath17 in order to roughly model the @xmath25 disc . in these simulations , @xmath26 was variable in time and space and @xmath27 . in our simulations , we adopt a polytropic equation of state specified by the exponent @xmath28 , in which the effects of an energy dissipation resulting from viscosity and a radiative cooling are approximately boxed . our binary configuration is the same as that of @xcite . we set the binary orbit on the @xmath29-@xmath30 plane with the semi - major axis along the @xmath29-axis . initially , the neutron star is at the periastron . it orbits about the be star with the orbital period @xmath31 and the eccentricity @xmath32 . the unit of time adopted here and throughout the paper is @xmath33 . the be disc is coplanar with the binary orbital plane . as the be star , we take a b0v star with @xmath34 , @xmath35 and @xmath36 , where @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the stellar radius and effective temprature , respectively . for the neutron star , we take @xmath39 and @xmath40 . these parameters are adopted to target 4u0115 + 63 , which has shown only type ii x - ray outbursts followed by a short series of type i x - ray outbursts @xcite . as mentioned earlier , we concentrate only on the simulations of the accretion flow on to the neutron star . this is done by constructing an outer boundary condition from the data of particles captured by the neutron star in a high - resolution simulation by @xcite , which was run for @xmath41 and finally had @xmath42 particles with @xmath43 . we first fold the data on the orbital period over @xmath44 to reduce the fluctuation noise . the phase dependence of the mass - capture rate by the neutron star obtained by this procedure is shown in fig . [ fig : mdot_cap ] . note that there is a strong phase - dependence in the mass - transfer rate . the peak comes slightly after the periastron passage and decreases by two orders of magnitude by apastron passage . we then fit the spatial and velocity distribution of the captured particles in each phase bin with separate gaussian functions . this is for running simulations with an arbitrary mass - transfer rate from the be disc . we finally model the mass - transfer process from the be disc to the neutron star by injecting gas particles at a given phase - dependent rate shown in fig . 2 with the spatial and velocity distributions specified by these gaussian functions . the injected particles are assumed to have the initial temperature of @xmath45 . as described earlier , the mass of each gas particle is arbitrary and negligible in our simulations . all the mass - related quantities discussed later , such as the disc mass and the mass - accretion rate , are normalised by using the mass - capture rate shown in fig . 2 . . the mass - capture rate is measured in units of @xmath46 , where @xmath47 is highest local density in the be - star disc normalized by @xmath48 , a typical value for be stars . the right axis shows the x - ray luminosity corresponding to the mass - capture rate with the x - ray emission efficiency @xmath49 , where @xmath50 is defined by @xmath51.,width=302,height=226 ] . , width=264 ] . , width=264 ] [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] before describing the results of our simulations , we discuss below the possibility of the formation of an accretion disc around the neutron star . we first consider the radius @xmath52 at which the material transferred from the be disc is circularized via the interaction with the previously transferred gas . we assume the circularization radius @xmath52 to be approximately given by @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is the initial specific angular momentum of the transferred material . in the upper panel of fig . [ fig : rcirc ] , we show the dependence of @xmath52 on the orbital phase , based on the data taken from a simulation by @xcite . it is noted that there is a strong phase - dependence of @xmath52 . it has a minimum of @xmath55 slightly before periastron and then rapidly increases with phase . for comparison , we also show the corotation radius , @xmath56 , for 4u0115 + 63 by the dotted line . here , @xmath56 is given by @xmath57 where @xmath58 is the spin period of the neutron star in 4u0115 + 63 . note that @xmath59 for most of the orbital phase . therefore , we expect that an accretion disc is formed around the neutron star in 4u0115 + 63 . next , we discuss whether the accretion disc formed around the neutron star is persistent or transient . this is done by comparing the viscous accretion time - scale with the orbital period . for simplicity , we assume the accretion disc to be geometrically thin and isothermal with the shakura - sunyaev viscosity parameter @xmath17 and evaluate the accretion time - scale at @xmath60 . the ratio of these two time - scales for 4u0115 + 63 is then given by @xmath61^{1/2 } \left ( \frac{t_{\rm{d}}}{10^{4}\rm{k } } \right)^{-1 } , \label{eq : tratio}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath62 is the sound speed and @xmath63 is the disc temprature . the orbital - phase dependence of @xmath64 is shown in the lower panel of fig . [ fig : rcirc ] . it is immediately observed that the viscous accretion time - scale is much longer than the orbital period for most of the orbital phase . therefore , once formed , the accretion disc around the neutron star in 4u0115 + 63 will survive over the whole orbital phase . note that this result depends little on the orbital period , because @xmath65 increases almost linearly with increasing @xmath9 . based on the procedure described in the previous section , we have performed several simulations with different parameters . details of the models are given in table [ tbl : models ] . the polytropic exponents considered are @xmath66 ( model 3 ) , 1.2 ( models 1 , 2 , 5 and 6 ) and 5/3 ( model 4 ) . we have taken the inner radius of the simulation region , @xmath67 , to be @xmath68 in all simulations but model 1 with a smaller inner radius of @xmath69 , which was run to study the effect of the inner radius on the simulation results . in models 1 - 4 and 6 , we have assumed @xmath43 , where @xmath18 varies in time and space and @xmath27 . for comparison purpose , we have also run model 5 with @xmath23 and @xmath24 , where @xmath17 varies in time and space . model 6 was run solely for clearly illustrating the initial build - up phase of an accretion disc . for this purpose , we have taken the injection rate of the sph particles in model 6 four times as high as in other models and run only for one orbital period . analysing multi - wavelength long term monitoring observations of 4u0115 + 63 , @xcite found that the be star undergoes quasi - cyclic @xmath70 activity , losing and reforming its circumsteller disc . then , the mass transfer to the neutron star should vary , depending on the state of the be disc . by the time the be disc is fully developed and becomes capable of supplying mass to the neutron star , even a large accretion disc would be exhausted . therefore , to investigate the evolution of an accretion flow around the neutron star after the be disc is fully developed , we performed 3d sph simulations based on the numerical models described above , where there is intially no gas particle around the neutron star . since all models have shown similar structure and evolution of the accretion flow , we will mainly show the results from model 1 with @xmath71 and @xmath72 . + + we consider the initial phase of accretion flow around the neutron star . as discussed in section [ sec : possibility ] , it is expected that the material transferred from the be disc near the periastron does not directly fall on to the neutron star and forms a disc - like structure with a size corresponding to its specific angular momentum . for illustration purpose , we give in fig . [ fig : model6_ss ] the snapshots of the initial accretion flow around the neutron star from model 6 , which covers @xmath73 . at @xmath74 , the be star is at periastron . each panel shows the surface density in the range of four orders of magnitude in the logarithmic scale . we note that the accreting matter first forms an elliptical ring around the neutron star , which is then relaxed to an elliptical disc via the viscous diffusion . because the viscous time - scale is longer than the orbital period , the orbits of the accreting particles are not circularized and the flow is highly eccentric during the initial phase of accretion . comparing the number of particles , @xmath75 , with the number of particles inside the effective roche radius of the neutron star , @xmath76 , we also note that most of the material transferred from the be disc stays inside the effective roche radius of the neutron star . it should be noted that these dynamical features are common to all models studied in this paper . [ fig : model6_rad ] shows the time - dependence of the radial structure of the accretion flow around the neutron star at the same times as in fig . [ fig : model6_ss ] . in each panel , the solid line , the dashed line and the dash - dotted line denote the surface density @xmath77 , the azimuthal velocity @xmath78 normalized by the keplerian velocity at the inner boundary and the radial mach number @xmath79 , respectively . in the figure , the density is integrated vertically and averaged azimuthally , while the velocity components are averaged vertically and azimuthally . from fig . [ fig : model6_rad ] we note that while the azimuthal velocity distribution gradually approaches the keplerian one , the behaviour of the radial velocity is very complex , reflecting the dynamical process of the disc formation shown in fig . [ fig : model6_ss ] . the surface density distribution also shows the initial evolution of the accretion flow described above . in the panel at @xmath80 , there appears a hump at @xmath81 caused by the infall of injected particles . outside the hump the density decreases rapidly , making a ring - like structure with a sharp outer edge . this rapid decrease in the density is due to the ram pressure of the infalling particles . as the hump moves inward , the density gradient outside the hump becomes less steep . by the next periastron passage ( @xmath82 ) , a disc - like structure is formed , the inner radius of which is at @xmath83 . in our simulations , the presence of the inner simulation boundary causes an artificial decrease in the density near the boundary , because the gas particles which pass through the boundary are removed from the simulation . as a result , the density distribution has a break near the inner boundary , as seen in fig . [ fig : model6_rad ] . we have found that our simulations are reliable for @xmath84 . + + many be / x - ray binaries with known orbital parameters have orbital eccentricities in the range of 0.3 to 0.9 . in such systems , the mass - transfer rate from the be disc is expected to have the strong phase dependence @xcite . accordingly , the structure of an accretion disc formed around the neutron star in these systems is also likely to be strongly phase dependent . in this section , we first discuss the phase - dependent structure of a developed accretion disc in model 1 and then compare that with those in other models . fig . [ fig : model1_ss ] gives a sequence of snapshots of the accretion flow around the neutron star covering one orbital period for @xmath85 . the format of the figure is the same as that of fig . [ fig : model6_ss ] , except that the surface density is shown in the range of three orders of magnitude . we note from the figure that the disc shrinks at periastron passage by a negative torque exerted by the be star and restores its radius afterwards by the viscous diffusion . we also note that the disc is significantly eccentric even after it is fully developed , although the eccentricity is much smaller than that in the initial phase of the disc formation . [ fig : model1_rad ] shows the radial disc structure at the orbital phases corresponding to fig . [ fig : model1_ss ] . the format of the figure is the same as that of fig . is noted from fig . [ fig : model1_rad ] that the disc is nearly keplerian at any phase and the accretion flow is highly subsonic except in the outermost part for a short period of time when the material transferred from the be disc falls towards the neutron star . we call this state of the accretion disc developed . we have found that these features of a developed disc hold for @xmath86 in model 1 . as in the initial phase of the disc formation , the ram pressure by the supersonic infall of matter transferred from the be disc around periastron enhances the density in the outermost part of the accretion disc , making the disc outer edge sharp ( see panels for @xmath87 in figs . [ fig : model1_ss ] and [ fig : model1_rad ] ) . afterwards , the disc gradually expands until the next periastron passage of the be star . [ fig : chardisc ] shows how hot the disc is at @xmath88 in models 1 and 3 - 5 . in each panel , the solid line , the dash - dotted line and the dashed line denote the disc temprature normalized by the initial temprature @xmath89 , the ratio of the smoothing length to the harf - thickness of the disc @xmath90 and the relative disc thickness @xmath91 , respectively . from the upper - left panel of fig . [ fig : chardisc ] , it is noted that the disc in model 1 is vertically resolved except for the innermost region of the disc ( @xmath92 ) . the disc temprature varies from @xmath93 at @xmath94 to @xmath95 at the inner boundary . the disc is geometrically thin with the relative thickness of about 0.1 - 0.2 . in this section , we describe the effects of the simulation parameters in table [ tbl : models ] on the structure of the accretion flow around the neutron star . we ran model 2 to study the effect of the inner boundary on the disc strcture . [ fig : model2 ] shows the snapshots and the radial structures of the accretion flow around the neutron star at @xmath96 ( periastron ) and @xmath97 ( apastron ) for model 2 , which has the same simulation parameters as model 1 , except for a larger inner boundary of @xmath98 . comparing fig . [ fig : model2 ] with the panels at the corresponding times in figs . [ fig : model1_ss ] and [ fig : model1_rad ] for model 1 , we note that the presence of the inner boundary artificially reduces the density in a narrow region ( @xmath99 ) near the boundary , but outside of it , the disc structure is similar for both models . in order to study the dependence of the disc structure on the polytropic exponent , we also ran models 3 ( @xmath100 ; isothermal case ) and 4 ( @xmath101 ; adiabatic case ) , for which the polytropic exponent of 1.2 for models 1 , 2 and 6 is in between . [ fig : model3 ] shows the snapshots and the radial structures of the accretion disc for model 3 ( isothermal case ) at the same times as in fig . [ fig : model2 ] . from the figure , we note that the distributions of the surface density and both of the azimuthal and radial velocity components are similar to those in the initial phase of the disc formation for @xmath102 ( see figs . [ fig : model6_ss ] and [ fig : model6_rad ] ) . consequently , in model 3 the accretion disc is still developing at @xmath103 . this is because the viscous time - scale of the isothermal disc , particularly in an inner region , is longer than those in other models ( see also fig . [ fig : rcirc ] ) . from the upper - right panel of fig . [ fig : chardisc ] , it is noted that the disc in model 3 is not vertically resolved in most of the disc region . [ fig : model4 ] shows the disc structure for model 4 ( adiabatic case ) . we note that the disc is nearly keplerian at both orbital phases and that the surface density is lower and the disc is bigger than those for model 2 with @xmath102 . this is due to a higher viscous stress in model 4 , resulting from a higher pressure . as expected , in model 4 , the accretion rate is much higher than the models with lower polytropic exponents , which we will see in a later section . from the lower - left panel of fig . [ fig : chardisc ] , it is noted that the disc in model 4 is much hotter than in other models , reaching the temprature of @xmath104 near the inner boundary . the disc is vertically resolved except for the innermost region . we also studied a model with the standard , artificial viscosity parameters . model 5 has the same simulation parameters as those in model 2 , except that it has constant articficial viscosity parameters @xmath105 and @xmath106 , for which @xmath17 varies in time and space . [ fig : model5 ] shows the disc structure for model 5 . from the figure and the lower - right panel of fig . [ fig : chardisc ] , it is immediately noted that the inner boundary affets the disc structure much more widely in this model . this is mainly because the inner disc region is not resolved vertically for this number of sph particles . since the ratio of the smoothing length to the harf - thickness of the disc @xmath90 in the inner region is much higher than unity , the shear viscosity parameter @xmath17 in this model is much higher in the inner region than that in other models . except for the above - mentioned dependence of the disc structure on the simulation parameters , the accretion discs in our models share the common features : they are nearly keplerian after developed and their structures modulate with the orbital phase . they are also significantly eccentric . we will analyse the non - axisymmentry of the accretion discs in be / x - ray binaries in a subsequent paper . + + + + + @xcite investigated the tidal / resonant truncation of circumsteller and circumbinary discs in eccentric binaries and found that a gap is always opened between the disc and the binary orbit . following their formulation , @xcite and @xcite have shown that the be disc is truncated via the resonant interaction with the neutron star , as long as @xmath107 , which has recently been confirmed by numerical simulations by @xcite . it is interesting to study whether the tidal / resonant torque by the be star also truncates the accretion disc around the neutron star . in order to have a measure of the accretion disc radius at which the disc density has a major break , we have applied a non - linear least squares fitting method to the radial distribution of the azimuthally - averaged surface density @xmath77 , adopting the following simple fitting function , @xmath108 where @xmath109 and @xmath110 are constants and @xmath111 is the radius of accretion disc . this method is the same as that adopted by @xcite . [ fig : radius ] shows the orbital - phase dependence of the accretion disc radius in model 1 . to reduce the fluctuation noise , we folded the data on the orbital period over @xmath112 . it is noted that the disc radius varies between @xmath113 and @xmath114 . the disc shirinks at periastron due to a negative torque by the be star and gradually restores its radius towards apastron due to the viscous diffusion . the rapid increase of the disc radius before periastron is due to the infall of matter from the be star . next , we examine whether the disc radius shown in fig . 13 is determined by the resonant truncation as is the case in the be disc in be / x - ray binaries . fig . 8 of @xcite gives the truncation radius of a circum - secondary disc as a function of the orbital eccentricity @xmath115 and the disc reynolds number @xmath116 for systems with the mass ratio of 0.1 , which is similar to that of be / x - ray binaries . since the accretion disc in our model is geometrically thin and nearly keplerian , the reynolds number @xmath116 is given by @xmath117 @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the keplerian velocity . in model 1 , @xmath120 for @xmath121 . from fig . 8 of @xcite , with @xmath122 and @xmath123 , we have the truncation radius of @xmath124 , which corresponds to the 6:1 resonance radius . note that this radius is much larger than the disc radius shown in fig . [ fig : radius ] . it is likely that the interaction with the be star is significantly non - linear owing to its large mass . then , the accretion disc would be truncated well inside the 6:1 radius given above . even such a strong interaction , however , is unlikely to truncate the disc at a radius as small as that shown in fig . [ fig : radius ] . it is suggestive that the disc radius is about the same as the circularization radius @xmath65 of the matter transferred from the be disc after the periastron passage ( see fig . [ fig : rcirc ] ) . since the viscous time - scale at the circularization radius is much longer than the run time of our simulations , the matter once circularized dose not have time enough to change its radius significantly . therefore , we conclude that the disc radius shown in fig . [ fig : radius ] is determined by the specific angular momentum of the matter transferred from the be disc . it is probable , however , that the disc expands well beyond the circularization radius and is truncated by a tidal torque in a time - scale longer than the viscous one . as mentioned in section 1 , most of the be / x - ray binaries show transient x - ray activities , of which nature is considered to result from the interactions between the accreted material and the rotating magnetized neutron star @xcite . in this section , we first describe the growth of the accretion disc in mass and radius . we then examine the evolution of the mass - accretion rate obtained by our simulations , from which we finally discuss the x - ray activity expected in be / x - ray binaries . [ fig : masrad](a ) shows the evolution of the disk mass in model 1 over the period of @xmath125 . in the long term , the disc mass increases with time , because the the gas transferred from the be star accumulates in the accretion disc owing to the viscous time - scale longer than the orbital period . on the other hand , in the short term , it modulates with the orbital phase . the disk mass starts increasing , when the mass - supply from the be disc begins slightly before every periastron passage . it shows a rapid increase for a short while , followed by a gradual decrease by accretion with no mass - supply from the be disc , which lasts until the next periastron passage . at first glance , the disc mass in model 1 seems to increase secularly and approach no steady average state . on closer inspection , however , we note that the increasing rate of the disc mass gradually decrases with time after the disc is developed . this suggests an interesting possibility that the disc reachs a steady average state in a time - scale much longer than the term shown in fig . 14(a ) . in fig . [ fig : masrad](b ) , we show the evolution of the disc radius over @xmath125 . one may expect that the disc radius gradually increases with the disc mass . from the figure , however , we note that this is the case only for @xmath86 . in fact , for @xmath126 , the disc radius decreases as the disc grows . this counter - intuitive decrease in radius is related to the change in the disc eccentricity . in the early stage of disc formation , the disc / ring is highly eccentric ( see fig . [ fig : model6_ss ] ) , for which the radius @xmath111 calculated by equation ( [ eq : fitting ] ) is larger than that for a circular disc with the same disc mass . since the disc eccentricity decreases with time , so does the disk radius . in model 1 , the effect of the disc circularization is balanced with that of the disc growth at @xmath127 . after this epoch , the disc radius increases with the disc mass . thus , the evolution of the accretion flow around the neutron star in be / x - ray binaries involves a two - stage process , which consists of the initial developing stage and the later developed stage . [ fig : mdot_acc](a ) shows the evolution of the mass - accretion rate and the corresponding x - ray luminosity in model 1 for @xmath128 . here we calculated the x - ray luminosity by @xmath129 with the x - ray emission effciency @xmath49 for the neutron star . the thick and thin lines denote the mass - accretion rate in models 1 and 2 , respectively . note that the mass - accretion rate in our simulations generally has double peaks per orbit . the first peak , which occurs at the periastron , is due to the contraction of the disc by the tidal torque of the be star , except that the peaks at periastron during the initial phase of disc formation are mainly due to the direct accretion of gas with low specific angular momentum . the second peak , which lags behind the peak in the mass - transfer rate from the be disc shown in fig . [ fig : mdot_cap ] , results from the viscous accretion of matter transferred from the be disc . the first peak could be artificial since it is related to the presence of the inner simulation boundary . the orbital modulation in the mass - accretion rate is significantly different between the developing disc and the developed disc . the first peak becomes weak as the disc developes . after the disc is fully developed , the second peak is higher than the first peak . [ fig : mdot_acc](a ) also shows that , once developed , the accretion disc in 4u0115 + 63 shows the peak x - ray luminosity of @xmath130 . this level of x - ray emission enters the transition regime ( see @xcite ) and is consistent with the observed x - ray luminosity in the quiescent state . for comparison purpose , we present in fig . [ fig : mdot_234 ] the evolution of the mass - accretion rate and the corresponding x - ray luminosity in models 2 - 4 for @xmath125 . the thick and thin solid lines and the thin dotted line are for models 2 , 3 and 4 , respectively . we see from the figure that the accretion rate increases with increasing polytropic exponent . in models 2 ( @xmath131 ) and 3 ( @xmath100 ) , the accretion rate profile has the double peaks as described above . the long - term change in the peak profiles is also similar to that in model 1 . we note that the disc in model 2 entered the stage of the developed disc at @xmath132 . on the other hand , the disc in model 3 is at the developing stage even at @xmath133 , which is consistent with the disc structure shown in fig . [ fig : model3 ] . in contrast to the models with low @xmath28 , the accretin rate in model 4 has a single and periodic peak per orbit , even after the disc is developed . with @xmath134 , the pressure in the disc in model 4 is much higher than that in other models . this means that much larger viscous torque exerts on the disc in model 4 than in other models , because the viscous stress in the @xmath25-viscosity prescription is proportional to the pressure . as a result , the viscous torque dominates the tidal torque in model 4 even at periastron . this is why there is no peak at periastron and the accretion rate shows the regular orbital modulation with the amplitude much higher than in other models . it is important to note that the disc evolution and its orbital modulation is sensitive to the polytropic exponent @xmath28 . this strongly implies that the cooling effciency in the accretion disc plays an important role in the x - ray activity in be / x - ray binaries . changes in the mass flux on the magnetosphere of the neutron star determine whether the system is in the direct accretion regime or in the propeller regime . while the matter falls directly on to the neutron star in the direct accretion regime , no material accretes on to the neutron star in the propeller regime by the centrifugal inhibitation . if the magnetospheric radius @xmath135 is smaller than the corotation radius @xmath136 , the system is in the direct accretion regime , otherwise , in the propeller regime . assuming the neutron star magnetic field as the dipole - like field , the magnetospheric radius @xmath135 , obtained by equating the magnetic field pressure of the neutron star to the ram pressure of the accreting matter from the accretion disc , is written by @xmath137 ( @xcite ; @xcite ; see also @xcite ) , where @xmath138 is the magnetic moment . here , @xmath139 is a constant model parameter of order unity , depending on the physics and geometry of accretion . for spherical accretion , @xmath140 . the original model calculations by @xcite for disc accretion on to the aligned rotating magnetized neutron star obtained @xmath141 , whereas calculations by @xcite , which included an induced wind not considered by @xcite , resulted in the value of @xmath142 for disc accretion . fig . [ fig : mdot_acc](b ) shows the evolution of the magnetospheric radius @xmath135 normalized by the corotation radius @xmath136 , where @xmath143 was adopted . in the figure , the thick and thin lines are for models 1 and 2 , respectively . recall that these models have the same parameters except for the radius of the inner simulation boundary @xmath67 ; @xmath144 in model 1 , while @xmath145 in model 2 . it should be noted that the magnetospheric radii in both models evolve in a very similar way , despite the different inner radii . our result on the magnetospheric radius is robust in this sense . we also note from fig . [ fig : mdot_acc](b ) that the ratio of the magnetospheric radius to the corotation radius , @xmath146 , varies between @xmath147 and @xmath148 . consequently , for a plausible range of @xmath139 ( @xmath149 ) , the magnetospheric radius in models with @xmath150 is almost always larger than the corotation radius so that the accretion on to the neutron star is inhibited , which is consistent with the oberved x - ray luminosity of 4u0115 + 63 in quiescence ( @xcite ) . on the other hand , we can see from equation ( [ eq : magnetosphere ] ) and fig . [ fig : mdot_234 ] that model 4 with @xmath101 is consistent with the observed x - ray behaviour of 4u0115 + 63 only if @xmath151 . for @xmath152 , the neutron star in model 4 enters the direct accretion regime after every peristron passage of the be star . then , the system would show regular , periodic x - ray outbursts at a level of @xmath153 , which has not been observed for 4u0115 + 63 . for the first time , we have performed numerical simulations of accretion on to the neutron star in be / x - ray binaries , taking into account the phase - dependent mass transfer from the be disc . we have adopted the mass - transfer rate from a high - resolution simulation by @xcite for a coplanar system with a short period ( @xmath31 ) and moderate eccentricity @xmath1 , which targeted 4u0115 + 63 , one of the best studied be / x - ray binaries . we have found that a nearly keplerian , non - steady accretion disc is formed around the neutron star regardless of the parameters adopted . the formation of the accretion disc involves a two - stage process , which consists of the initial developing stage and the later developed stage . the disc structure shows a strong dependence on the orbital phase , because both the tidal potential and the mass - transfer rate change periodically . the disc is also significantly eccentric , because the gas particles from the be disc originally have elliptical orbits . in 4u0115 + 63 , type i x - ray outbursts have occurred only as a short series after occasional type ii x - ray outbursts @xcite . except for such occasions , the system is in the quiescent state ( @xmath154 ) @xcite . the peak x - ray luminosity estimated from our simulations corresponds to the transition regime between the direct accretion regime and the propeller regime and is consistent with the observed x - ray behaviour . note , however , that the discussion based on the x - ray luminosity estimated from the simulations only gives the necessary condition for the quiescent state . in order to see whether our model satisfies a more stringent condition , we also have estimated the magnetospheric radius by using a general formula with the mass - accretion rate from our simulations and compared with the corotation radius for 4u0115 + 63 . the result was that our models with @xmath150 are consistent with the observed x - ray behaviour . other models with @xmath101 and @xmath155 were ruled out , because in these models the system would show an x - ray outburst after every periastron passage , which has never been observed . we have to admit , however , that the radius of our inner simulation boundary is about 60 - 100 times as large as the corotation radius of the neutron star in 4u0115 + 63 . to make the constraint on the system parameters more reliable , we need numerical simulations with a much smaller inner boundary . it is important to note that our model is not only consistent with the quiescent state of 4u0115 + 63 . it can also give a natural explanation for a short series of type i x - ray outbursts after occasional type ii x - ray outbursts . the mass - transfer rate from the be disc in the x - ray outbursts is likely much higher than in the quiescent state . suppose that the mass - transfer rate from the be disc in 4u0115 + 63 is temporarily increased by an order of magnitude . then , the estimated x - ray luminosity in our model increases by an order of magnitude to a level of several @xmath156 , a typical x - ray luminosity of type i x - ray outbursts . at the same time , the magnetosphric radius @xmath135 decreases by a factor of about two , for which @xmath135 is almost always smaller than the corotation radius , @xmath136 , if @xmath152 ( see fig . [ fig : mdot_acc](b ) ) . this means that the system is in the direct accretion regime . thus , our model explains the type i x - ray outbursts in 4u0115 + 63 as a temporal phenomena with an enhanced mass - transfer from the be disc . be / x - ray binaries are distributed over a wide range of orbital periods @xmath157 and eccentricities @xmath158 . it is interesting to consider here the effects of orbital parameters . in this paper , we have seen that the main ingredients which determines the x - ray behaviour of a system are the viscous time - scale relative to the orbital period and the mass - transfer rate from the be disc . since the former is insensitive to the orbital period itself ( see equation ( [ eq : tratio ] ) ) , the latter is most important if the viscosity parameter and the equation of state are similar in accretion discs of be / x - ray binaries . in systems with @xmath159 , the viscous time - scale in an outer part of the accretion disc is much longer than the orbital period unless the cooling is ineffective and the gas obeys an adiabatic equation of state . in these systems , persistent accretion discs are expected to form . then , the mass - transfer rate from the be disc determines whether the system shows type i x - ray outbursts . for example , for a system with a moderate orbital eccentricity of @xmath160 and a typical density of be disc , the peak mass - transfer rate is @xmath161 , for which the system stays in quiescence . it is obvious , however , that the situation should be different in systems with much higher rate of mass - transfer . a high mass - transfer rate is expected to result from a high orbital eccentricity and/or an intrinsically dense be disc . therefore , it is not strange that many systems which have regularly shown type i x - ray outbursts have orbital eccentricities higher than that of 4u0115 + 63 studied in this paper . in a subsequent paper , we will perform numerical simulations of accretion in systems with high orbital eccentricities . above we have assumed that the viscous time - scale is much longer than the orbital period in all be / x - ray binaries . however , it is possible that an accretion disc has a relatively short viscous time - scale by some reason . one possibility is that the disc has a low cooling efficiency and becomes hot , particularly in an inner region . our model 4 with @xmath101 gives an extreme example of such discs ( see also fig . [ fig : chardisc ] ) . as shown in fig . [ fig : mdot_234 ] , in a system with a short viscous time - scale , the mass - accretion rate has a high and sharp peak shortly after every periastron passage . the resemblance between the accretion rate profile in model 4 and the x - ray light curves of regular type i x - ray outbursts from systems such as exo2030 + 375 @xcite implies that these are systems with relatively short viscous time - scales . be / x - ray binaries are an ideal group of objects for studying the physics of accretion under the circumstances which have been studied little . unlike close binaries , many be / x - ray binaries have eccentric orbits . they can also be highly inclined systems . such systems provide us a valuable oppotunity to study the effects of the periodically - changing tidal potential and mass - transfer rate and the inclination angle on the structure and evolution of the accretion flow . another important characteristic of be / x - ray binaries is that they are systems with double circumstellar discs ( the be disc and the accretion disc ) . the interaction in such systems is threefold : the interactions between the neutron star and the be disc , the be star and the accretion disc and the be disc and the accretion disc ( mainly via the mass transfer ) . much more work is desirable both theoretically and observationally in order to understand this interesting and important group of objects . we acknowlege the anonymous refree for constructive comments . we would like to thank matthew r. bate for allowing us to use his sph code . kh acknowledes james r. murray for useful comments during the short stay at the swinburne university of technology , australia . kh also thanks noboru kaneko for his continuous encouragement . the simulations reported here were performed using the facility at the hokkaido university information initiative center , japan . this work was supported in part by grant - in - aid for scientific reserch ( 13640244 ) of japan society for the promotion of science . artymowicz p & lubow s.h . , 1994 , apj , 421 , 651 bate m.r . , bonnell i.a.,price n.m . , 1995 , mnras , 285 , 33 benz w. , 1990 , in buchler j. r.,ed.,the numerical modelling of nonlinear stellar pulsations . kluwer , dordrecht , p.269 benz w. , bowers r.l . , cameron a.g.w . , press w.h . , 1990 , apj , 348 , 647 bildsten , l. , chakrabarty , d. , chiu , j. , et al . 1997 , apjs , 113 , 367 campana s. , gastaldello f. , stella l. , israel g.l . , colpi m. , pizzolato f. , orlandini m. , dal fiume d. , 2001 , apj , 561 , 924 clark j.s . , lyuty v.m . , zaitseva g.v . , larionov v.m . , larionova l.v . , finger m. , tarasov a.e . , roche p. , coe m.j . , 1999 , mnras , 302 , 167 finger m.h . , wilson r.b . , harmon b.a . , 1996 , apj , 459 , 288 finger m.h . , bildsten l. , chakrabarty d. , prince t.a . , scott d.m . , wilson c.a . , wilson r.b & zhang s.n . , 1999 , apj , 517 , 449 frank j. , king a.r . , raine d.j . , 2002 , accretion power in astrophysics , 3rd edn . cambridge univ . press , cambridge ghosh p & lamb f.k . , 1979 , apj , 234 , 296 lamb f.k . , pethick c.j & pines d. , 1973 , apj , 184 , 271 negueruela i. , okazaki a.t . , fabregat j. , coe m.j . , munari u & tomov . , 2001 , a&a , 369 , 108 negueruela i & okazaki a.t . , 2001 , a&a , 369 , 108 okazaki a.t & negueruela i. , 2001 , a&a , 377 , 161 okazaki a.t . , bate m.r . , ogilvie g.i & pringle j.e . , 2002 , mnras , 337 , 967 ostriker e.c . , shu f.h . , 1995 , 447 , 813 pringle j.e & rees m.j . , 1972 , a&a , 21 , 1 stella l. , white n.e . , rosner r. , 1986 , apj , 208 , 669 warner b. , 1995 , cataclysmic variable stars . cambridge univ . press , cambridge wilson c.a & finger m.h . , coe m.j . , laycock s. , fabregat j. , 2002 , apj , 570 , 287 wilson c.a & finger m.h . , coe m.j . , negueruela i. , 2003 , apj , 584 , 996 ziolkowski j. , 2002 , mem . ital , 73 , 1038
Abstract: | [
"we study the accretion on to the neutron star in be / x - ray binaries , using a 3d sph code and the data imported from a simulation by @xcite for a coplanar system with a short period ( @xmath0 ) and a moderate eccentricity @xmath1 , which targeted the be / x - ray binary 4u0115 + 63 . for simplicity , we adopt the polytropic equation of state . we find that a time - dependent accretion disc is formed around the neutron star regardless of the simulation parameters . in the long term , the disc evolves via a two - stage process , which consists of the initial developing stage and the later developed stage . the developed disc is nearly keplerian . in the short term , the disc structure modulates with the orbital phase . the disc shrinks at the periastron passage of the be star and restores its radius afterwards . the accretion rate on to the neutron star is also phase dependent , but its peak is broader and much lower than that of the mass - transfer rate from the be disc , unless the polytropic exponent is as large as 5/3 . our simulations show that the truncated be disk model for be / x - ray binaries is consistent with the observed x - ray behaviour of 4u0115 + 63 . [ firstpage ] accretion , accretion discs hydrodynamics methods : numerical binaries : general stars : emission - line , be x - rays : binaries"
] | 8,907 | 8,907 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: perhaps the most exciting astronomical observation leading to our current understanding of black holes has been the discovery of quasars . these celestial objects , originally found in the early sixties as point - like radio emitters , were identified with apparently stellar sources , possessing somewhat unusual spectra , with prominent emission lines . the identification by @xcite of these lines as redshifted systems implied that quasars are distant and extremely luminous , commonly producing @xmath2 erg s@xmath3 ; this is a hundred times or more in excess of the total luminosity of all the stars in a galaxy . sensitive imaging of the nebulosities which often surround them implied that quasars are nuclei of galaxies , and thus are higher - luminosity counterparts of the compact nuclei of seyferts , studied some twenty years before the discovery of quasars as unusual emission line objects : hereafter , we assume that they are respectively the lower and higher luminosity end of the same population . a variety of scenarios were advanced to explain their nature , and this included multiple supernovae or massive spinning stars , but the proposal that quasars are powered by an accretion of surrounding matter onto a black hole , advanced in the mid-60s by @xcite and @xcite , became the paradigm that we are developing and testing today . while this is a viable and very attractive paradigm , only the last few years brought a solid evidence for it , allowing also to measure the mass of the central object . it is important to note here that quasars are much more numerous at a redshift @xmath4 2 than they are locally , meaning that a substantial fraction of galaxies must have undergone the quasar phase . it is thus likely that many otherwise normal local galaxies harbor supermassive black holes , `` dead quasars . '' in fact , as we discuss below , there is a number of relatively anonymous galaxies that show no signs of nuclear activity , but _ do _ show evidence for such black holes . we present the observational evidence for black holes in agn in section 2 ; in section 3 , we discuss the effects of the orientation of the accretion disk surrounding the back hole on the appearance of the nucleus . in section 4 , we discuss the jet - dominated agn known as blazars . in section 5 , we review the observations of agn in x rays and @xmath1rays , the bands that sample the regions closest to the black hole , and in section 6 , we review the radiation processes proposed to explain the emission in these bands . there are two general lines of argument that are used to `` prove '' the existence of black holes in agn . the first attempts to measure the total mass within a volume , and argues that no other form besides a black hole can have these parameters . this is done either via estimation of the volume from variability data ( via the light travel time arguments ) and mass from the luminosity ( via the eddington limit ) ; alternatively , this can be determined by a measurement of velocity of matter at a specified distance from the central object , essentially using kepler s laws . the second method , discussed in more detail in chapter 5.3 ( by a. fabian ) , relies on the distortion of the emission line shapes caused by strong gravity resulting from the presence of a black hole , and we cover it here only briefly . the variability of active galaxies generally shows the highest amplitude and the shortest time scales in the x ray and @xmath1ray bands , which happen to be clearly separated from the optical / uv bands by the strong absorption of the interstellar medium in our own galaxy . this rapid variability as well as other lines of argument indicate that the x ray / @xmath1ray radiation arises the closest to the central source , and in many cases , is the primary source of energy in active galaxies . while the total bolometric luminosity of quasars is often dominated by the optical and uv flux ( see , e. g. , laor et al . 1997 ; for a recent review , see ulrich , maraschi , & urry 1997 ) , the bulk of this flux probably arises in more distant regions from the central source than the x rays and @xmath1rays . the optical and uv radiation arising in the innermost regions of the nucleus , on the other hand , is most likely a result of reprocessing of x ray / @xmath1ray photons . this as well as the author s personal interest in x rays is the reason why this chapter focuses primarily on the high energy emission from quasars . in general , the x ray variability of quasars is aperiodic . while a measurement of periodic variability would give us a clue to the circumnuclear environment and thus the nature of the black hole , besides the ill - fated ngc 6814 ( cf . madejski et al . 1993 ) , no strict periodicity was reported for any agn . however , there were two reports of quasi - periodic variation of flux of active galaxies : ngc 5548 ( papadakis & lawrence 1993 ) and ngc 4051 ( papadakis & lawrence 1995 ) inferred from the exosat data , but the quality of the data is only modest , and these still need to be confirmed . more statistically significant is the quasi - periodic variability of of iras 18325 - 5926 by @xcite , but this is inferred from only a few ( @xmath5 10 ) cycles , and requires confirmation via further monitoring before drawing any detailed conclusions . nonetheless , we understand relatively little about the details of variability of active galaxies , although the recent light curves are sufficiently good to discriminate if the time series are linear or non - linear ; this is discussed later in this chapter . in any case , this rapid variability implies a compact source size . this is of course the standard causality argument : no stationary source of isotropic radiation can vary faster than the time it takes for light to cross it . in the x ray band , the power spectrum of variability generally is rather flat at long time scales , and above some characteristic frequency , it shows a power - law behavior , such that the variable power drops with decreasing time scale ( see , e.g. , mchardy 1989 ) ; the fourier phases of these light curves show no coherence ( cf . krolik , done , & madejski 1993 ) . as it was pointed by many authors , for this form of variability , the doubling time scale has no definitive meaning , but for the lack of better data , it suffices for the illustrative purposes : it is certainly valid as an order - of - magnitude relationship between the source radius @xmath6 and the time scale for doubling of the source flux @xmath7 such that @xmath8 @xmath7 . again , for quasars , this is particularly true in the x ray band , where the variability is most rapid : even the early x ray data gave us a clue that quasars are very compact . for example , an x ray light curve for the seyfert galaxy ngc 5506 ( by no means an extreme object ) as observed by the me detector onboard the exosat satellite shown on fig . 1 illustrates it well . this , and other observations of it , with redshift @xmath9 and a 2 - 10 kev x ray flux of @xmath10 erg @xmath11 s@xmath3 , imply a luminosity @xmath12 of @xmath13 erg s@xmath3 , corresponding to an eddington mass of at least @xmath14 @xmath15 . this corresponds to a schwarzschild radius @xmath16 of @xmath17 cm . the x ray data show a doubling time of @xmath18 s , corresponding to @xmath19 cm , which , for a @xmath20 @xmath15 black hole , would imply that the x ray emission arises from a region of radius @xmath21 @xmath16 . this example is by no means extreme we made a number of assumptions that are probably even too conservative : more realistic assumptions imply a mass of @xmath22 @xmath15 , and @xmath23 @xmath16 . a number of more extreme cases including very luminous objects were reported recently on the basis of the rosat data by @xcite . these are generally for the so - called `` narrow - line seyfert 1s , '' and we will return to those objects later . in brief , a doubling time scale of @xmath24 s for a source with @xmath25 erg s@xmath3 is not uncommon , implying that the bulk of the x ray emission arises around 10 - 100 @xmath16 . however , the use of the observed variability time scale does not provide an `` airtight '' argument for the size of the emitting region , since the observed emission may well be anisotropic , yielding an underestimate of the emitting volume , as is almost certainly the case for blazars . we discuss this in more detail later on . the other line of evidence for the presence of black holes in galaxies ( both active and `` normal '' ) is the velocity field of the matter emitting closely to the nucleus . this kind of work has been recently reviewed by @xcite , and it dates back to the ground - based observations made in the late 70s , when w. sargent and collaborators showed that the stellar velocity dispersion in the radio galaxy m 87 increases to 350 km s@xmath3 in the innermost 1.5@xmath26 from the nucleus . m 87 was in fact observed by the planetary camera by @xcite and the faint object spectrograph by @xcite onboard the repaired hubble space telescope , and the images showed the presence of a disk - like structure of ionized gas in the innermost few arc seconds . the spectroscopy provided a measure of the velocity of the gas at an angular distance from the nucleus of 0.25@xmath26 ( corresponding to @xmath27 pc , or @xmath28 cm ) , showing that in the reference frame of the object , it recedes from us on one side , and approaches us on the other , with a velocity difference of @xmath29 km s@xmath3 ( see fig . 2 ) . this implies a mass of the central object of @xmath30 @xmath31 , and besides a black hole , we know of no other form of mass concentration that can `` fit '' inside this region . as an aside , it is worth noting that m 87 is known to have a relativistic jet perpendicular to the disk structure mentioned above , expanding with the bulk lorentz factor @xmath32 of 4 . as such , this object is probably just a blazar , with the jet oriented at an angle @xmath33 to the line of sight , and thus is probably the closest to a hard evidence that blazars ( which we discuss in more detail below ) indeed _ do _ harbor black holes . besides m 87 , similar spectroscopy observations done with hubble space telescope revealed high stellar velocities in the central regions of a number of normal galaxies which otherwise show no evidence for an active nucleus . these were summarized recently by @xcite , and include well - publicized observations ( by l. ferrarese , h. ford , j. kormendy and others ) of ngc 6251 , ngc 4261 , ngc 4594 , ngc 3115 , but doubtless by now probably there are several new objects . such high velocities in the innermost regions of these galaxies can not be explained in any other way besides invoking the presence of massive ( @xmath34 @xmath15 ) black holes in their centers . ( interestingly , several of these galaxies also show weak radio jets ! ) even for our own milky way galaxy , the infrared data and velocity measurements readily performed from the ground ( cf . eckart & genzel 1997 ) , at much higher resolution than the hst data for external galaxies reveal a `` modest '' nuclear black hole with a mass of @xmath35 @xmath15 . the evidence is building that supermassive black holes are quite common ; recent estimates by @xcite as well as @xcite imply that they inhabit perhaps as many as half of all galaxies , and may well be the `` dead quasars '' of the past . active galactic nuclei are thus probably only the `` tip of the iceberg '' of their population . perhaps the most elegant observation showing the presence of a keplerian disk around a black hole and thus capable of measuring the mass of the hole independently of the otherwise uncertain estimates of its distance was the very large baseline interferometry observation of megamasers in the vicinity of the nucleus of seyfert 2 galaxy ngc 4258 reported by @xcite . the masing activity can only be observed along a line of sight where the velocity gradient is zero , meaning that these can be seen at locations with masers either between us and their source of energy , or locations at @xmath4 90@xmath36 to the line of sight . indeed , this is the spatial distribution of maser spots around the nucleus of ngc 4258 , illustrated in fig . 3 . specifically , these observations reveal individual masing spots revolving at distances ranging from @xmath37 pc to about twice that around the central object presumably , again , a black hole with a mass of @xmath38 @xmath15 . what is truly remarkable about these data is the near - perfect keplerian velocity distribution , in a slightly warped disk - like formation ; this implies that almost all the mass is located well within the inner radius where the megamasers reside . it is not possible to have a cluster of distinct , dark , massive objects responsible for such gravitational potential ; at least some of the objects would escape on a relatively short time scale , and form a potential well with a different shape , which would now force a departure of the megamaser emitting material from pure keplerian motion ( cf . maoz 1995 ) . since we know the central mass quite precisely , ngc 4258 has been a terrific laboratory to study the details of the accretion disk . in particular , this is a relatively low luminosity ( @xmath39 erg s@xmath3 ) object , making it quite sub - eddington , with @xmath40 . such sub - eddington sources are likely to obey unique solutions of accretion disk structure ( see , e.g. , ichimaru 1977 ; narayan & yi 1994 ; abramowicz et al . 1995 ) , where the accreting gas is optically thin and radiates inefficiently , and the accretion energy that is dissipated viscously , is advected with the accretion flow . with this , as was argued by @xcite , the accretion disk in ngc 4258 can well be advection - dominated ( but this does not _ have _ to be the case ; see , e.g. , neufeld & maloney 1995 ) . however , it is important to note that such low eddington rate can not be universal among quasars ; if most of them radiated at such low @xmath41 , the black hole masses of the most luminous sources would be much larger than expected on other grounds . however , an intriguing possibility ( cf . yi 1996 ) is that quasars in their `` youth , '' when the black hole masses were more modest , had standard , `` cold '' ( shakura - sunyaev ) accretion disks , and this is why they were so luminous in the past . the masses of the black holes grew with time , and even if the mass rate supplied for accretion remained constant , @xmath41 actually decreased , and thus the the inner accretion disks switched from `` cold '' ( bright , shakura - sunyaev ) phase to `` hot '' ( fainter , advection - dominated ) phase even if the rate of mass supply _ did not _ decrease . this is perhaps why some of the yesterday s bright quasars are today s dormant , `` dark '' black holes , revealed only via the kinematical studies mentioned above . nonetheless , ngc 4258 is probably _ not _ a unique object . we know of a large class of `` low activity '' active galaxies , known collectively as `` low ionization nuclear emission region '' objects , or liners ; they generally have low luminosity , coupled with the absence of the luminous inner disk as evidenced by the emission line ratios . however , unlike the _ bona fide _ seyferts with low luminosity , which seem to vary relatively rapidly in x rays , implying they are `` scaled down '' quasars with relatively low mass black holes liners are known _ not _ to vary rapidly in any band , suggesting that the low activity is not due to a low black hole mass , but rather due to a low accretion rate ( cf . ptak 1997 ) . as the nuclei of these objects are not very bright , the data are sparse , and thus the details of the radiative processes are poorly known ; while workable models exist ( see , e.g. , lasota et al . 1996 ) , they still require more work on the details of the transition between the `` standard '' and advection - dominated regions of the disk . perhaps the most convincing evidence that a strong gravitational field is present in active galactic nuclei comes from the recent measurements of the shape of the fe k@xmath0 fluorescence line , arising in a geometrically thin , but optically thick accretion disk . this is discussed in more detail by a. fabian ( chapter 5.3 ) , so what follows is a brief summary . the inner part of the disk is illuminated by x rays . because of the relative cosmic abundances and the fluorescence yields of various elements , the strongest discrete spectral feature predicted from the disk is the 6.4 kev fluorescent fe k@xmath0 line ; the strength ( equivalent width ) of the line of @xmath4 150 ev , as measured by @xcite , is in fact roughly consistent with predictions of @xcite . since this line arises from matter in motion , its profile is a tracer of the velocity field of the accreting matter . the asca observations of the x ray bright seyfert galaxy mcg-6 - 30 - 15 by tanaka et al . ( 1995 ) indeed showed that the line ( see fig . 4 ) has a characteristic two - pronged shape expected to arise from matter flowing in a disk - like structure . the matter approaching us is responsible for the blue wing of the line , while that receding produces the red wing , with an additional redshift , since the photons are emitted in a strong gravitational field ; the exact shape also depends on the inclination of the disk . a detailed spectral fitting of the line shape indicates that the emitted energy of the line is indeed 6.4 kev , while the bulk of its flux arises at @xmath5 10 @xmath16 , implying in turn the presence of nearly neutral material very closely to the black hole . the analysis of a number of seyfert spectra from the asca archives by @xcite suggests that many seyferts indeed show the fe k@xmath0 line profiles that require an emission close to the black hole , but the quality of data is only modest . fortunately , a number of more sensitive observatories such as axaf , astro - e , xmm , and constellation - x , will be launched in the next few years , providing ample opportunities for x ray observations of effects of strong gravity . the megamaser source ngc 4258 is only the first of three active galaxies showing a spatial distribution of masing spots from which it is possible to measure the mass of the central object . the other two are the well - known ngc 1068 ( greenhill 1998 ) , and ngc 4945 ( greenhill , moran , & herrnstein 1997 ) . both are also classified as seyfert 2s , which from the observational side means that they show narrow emission lines , implying velocities on the order of 1,000 km s@xmath3 ; these lines show no variability , and thus it is generally accepted that they originate in a relatively large regions , on the order of 100 pc or more . seyfert 1s as well as luminous quasars , on the other hand , exhibit generally very different spectra , with permitted emission lines , and these lines are usually broad , with velocities upwards of 1,500 km s@xmath3 , often reaching 30,000 km s@xmath3 . this , together with the variability of the lines that is commonly observed on time scales of weeks or months , implies that the broad line region is located much closer to the nucleus than the narrow line region . the likely relationship between the two classes of active galaxies was revealed by the seminal observation of the well - known seyfert 2 galaxy ngc 1068 by antonucci & miller ( 1985 ) . the spectropolarimetric study of the h@xmath42 line revealed that when observed in polarized light , the line is broad . they interpreted the polarization as due to electron scattering by material that is distributed preferentially along the symmetry axis of the system , and advanced the widely accepted scenario explaining the differences between the two types of seyferts as an orientation effect . this is illustrated in fig . 5 ; all seyfert galaxies are surrounded by a geometrically and optically thick torus , with an inner radius of a fraction of a parsec . such a torus can be , for instance , the outer regions of a severely warped disk , as recently suggested by m. begelman and j. pringle ( see chapter 8.1 ) . when an object is viewed along the axis of the torus , it is a seyfert 1 , revealing all the ingredients of the nucleus : the broad line region and the unobscured x ray source , both commonly varying on a short time scale . when viewed in or close to the plane of the torus , the broad line region is completely obscured , and the soft end of the x ray spectrum is absorbed due to the photoelectric absorption by the material in the torus . the opening of the torus contains a `` mirror '' of ionized gas with free electrons , and these are responsible for the scattering of the broad line light into the line of sight , and hence the broad lines are seen only in polarized light . in the context of this `` unification '' model , it is thus not surprising that all three megamasers with measured rotation curves are seyfert 2 objects : to even observe a megamaser , we have to be located in the plane of material which has large column density and presumably is roughly co - axial with the torus . likewise , the x rays traveling closely to the plane of the torus encounter a larger column density , resulting in the greater photoelectric absorption . this is in fact , observed ; even early x ray spectra of seyferts showed preferentially larger absorption in sources showing only narrow lines ( seyfert 2s ) , with the broad line region obscured by the same material that absorbs soft x rays . note that this is different than the case of only narrow emission lines present in some low - luminosity radio galaxies , such as m 87 ( collectively known as the fr - i objects ) : there , the broad lines can not be obscured , as we see no evidence of x ray absorption . furthermore , while seyfert 2s sometimes do show highly ionized , narrow permitted lines ( in addition to the commonly detected forbidden lines ) , fr - i objects _ do not _ , implying an absence of the very strong isotropic ionizing uv continuum . we will return to this point below . the use of the observed variability time scale does not , however , provide an `` airtight '' argument for the size of the emitting region , since the observed emission may well be anisotropic , yielding an underestimate of the emitting volume . as pointed out by @xcite , if the radiating matter moves at a relativistic speed towards the observer , the variability time scale appears shortened by the doppler effect . furthermore , the flux of radiation is boosted in the direction of motion of the emitting matter , and thus the total luminosity inferred under an assumption of isotropy is an overestimate . we are nearly certain that this is the case for blazars . this sub - class of quasars consists of sources that generally show strong radio emission and are highly variable and polarized in all observable wavelengths , and also includes members with very weak or absent emission lines , known as bl lacertae type objects . high angular resolution radio observations , performed since the late 60s using very long baseline interferometry implied compact radio emission regions , often associated with a rapid change of their structure . with the assumption that the redshifts are indeed cosmological , these structures appeared to expand at transverse speeds exceeding @xmath43 , and in many cases , they had shapes of jets . if the speed of the emitting matter is very relativistic , pointing closely to our line of sight , the apparent superluminal motion is just a projection effect , providing further support for the doppler - boosting scenario for blazars . in a number of aspects , blazars are the most extremely active galactic nuclei . observations of many blazars by the egret instrument onboard the compton gamma - ray observatory ( cgro ) indicated that usually they are strong emitters in the gev @xmath1ray band ; we know of at least 50 such objects . the gev emission can dominate the overall observed electromagnetic output of these sources , and this is illustrated in fig . 6 for 3c 279 , the first of the erget - discovered gev blazars . in a few cases , the @xmath1ray emission has been observed with cerenkov radiation telescopes to extend as far as the tev range . this is particularly exciting , as tev radiation can be observed from the ground , allowing a study of quite exotic phenomena occurring in quasars without the expense of space - borne platforms . interestingly , we know of no `` radio - quiet '' mev or gev @xmath1ray emitting quasars , implying an association of the @xmath1rays with the compact radio source and thus a jet . in many cases , the @xmath1ray emission from blazars is variable on a time scale of a day , and recent , simultaneous multi - wavelength monitoring observations indicate that the flux swings are reasonably well correlated between various bands , with the amplitude of variability increasing with the increase of the energy of the observing band . if the emission in the lower energy bands arises from a region co - spatial with that where the @xmath1rays originate and the tracking of light curves in various bands supports this then the opacity to the @xmath1-@xmath1 pair production would imply large optical thickness . similarly , even the early calculations indicated that if the radio sources are as luminous and as compact as the variability data imply , the cooling should be predominantly via the compton process , with the radiating electrons losing all their energy via upscattering of the just produced photons , regardless of the radiation mechanism . even the large @xmath1ray fluxes detected by egret are often orders of magnitude lower than the predictions of this self - compton process . both these difficulties , however , go away if the radio as well as the gev emission are both doppler - boosted , meaning that the true luminosity is lower , and source sizes are greater than inferred under an assumption of isotropy . in fact , we now believe that the entire broad - band continuum is produced in the relativistic jet ( cf . knigl 1981 ; ulrich et al . 1997 ) , and statistical considerations imply that the bulk lorentz factors @xmath32 of these jets are on the order of 10 ( cf . vermeulen & cohen 1994 ) . for the case of bl lac type blazars , the doppler enhancement ( going roughly as a square of @xmath32 ; see , e.g. , appendix a of sikora et al . 1997 ) ) is so strong that the continuum completely outshines the emission lines ; in some cases , however , it is possible that the emission lines are absent to begin with . in any case , the mechanism for an acceleration and collimation of these powerful jets to such high relativistic speeds is not known , but general considerations of jet energetics are strongly suggestive that this energy is ultimately tapped from an accretion onto a compact object : the best picture today involves the so - called blandford - znajek mechanism ( blandford & znajek 1977 ) , where the power of the jet derives from the spin of the black hole . the electromagnetic emission from jets in blazars recently reviewed by @xcite and ulrich et al . ( 1997 ) is interesting in its own right , and the comparison of the broad - band spectra of blazars and the `` radio - quiet '' quasars shows it clearly . the strong gev component which clearly dominates the spectra of the former ( cf . 6 ) is entirely absent in the latter , and the relative strength of the gev emission as compared to that in kev range is often different by a factor of @xmath44 . the radio and optical emission shows polarization , and spectra are always non - thermal . all these facts argue that the radio - through - uv emission is produced by the synchrotron process , with ultrarelativistic electrons ( with @xmath45 or more ) radiating in magnetic field on the order of a gauss . the compton upscattering of lower energy photons mentioned above is indeed present - and most current models suggest that it is responsible for the radiation observed above a few kev . in the lineless bl lac type objects , we have no evidence for any strong external radiation field , and the dominant `` seed '' photons for compton upscattering are likely to be produced by the synchrotron process internally to the jet . as was shown by @xcite as well as by @xcite and @xcite , in blazars with emission lines , the external , diffuse radiation dominates ; since this radiation is isotropic in the stationary frame , it appears doppler - boosted in the frame of the jet . this scenario predicts that there should be many objects with jets pointing farther away , up to the right angle to our line of sight . we now believe that for the quasar - type blazars , with strong emission lines , these are the giant , powerful radio galaxies . the difference between the quasar - type and bl lac type blazars may well be related to the presence of the inner , extremely luminous accretion disk in the former . as suggested by m. begelman , and , more recently @xcite , some radio galaxies ( as , for instance , m 87 ) have massive black holes , yet relatively modest luminosity , and essentially no broad emission lines ; this might argue for a very sub - eddington accretion rate , with a likelihood of an advection - dominated inner accretion disk . an intriguing possibility is that these low - luminosity radio galaxies are the `` misdirected '' bl - lac - type blazars : the absence of the inner , luminous disk would then be responsible for the absence of the strong ionizing radiation and thus broad emission lines . this in turn would mean that in bl lac - type blazars , there are no external photons to act as `` seeds '' to be comptonized by the relativistic electrons in the jet , and the only `` seed '' photons are internal , produced by the synchrotron process . we are nearly certain that there is a clear _ intrinsic _ distinction between the jet - dominated blazars , and the more common , radio - quiet quasars . however , the reason for the different behavior of these two subclasses is far from certain , and this is primarily because we do not have a good understanding of the formation and acceleration of relativistic jets . even though we can not use the causality arguments to infer the presence of black holes in blazars solely from their variability since we do not know for sure as to what extent the true variability time scales are shortened by doppler boosting more indirect evidence implies that ultimately , accretion onto a black hole powers blazars as well . as to the difference between the two categories , perhaps the most appealing scenario , advanced by @xcite , as well as by @xcite , is where the two classes differ by strong or weak spin of the black hole ; again , the jet is formed and powered by tapping the rotational energy of the hole . this is somewhat similar to the distinction between the galactic binary `` microquasars '' suggested by @xcite , discussed in chapter 2.1 ( by p. charles ) . nonetheless , this is an area of very active research where no clear conclusions have been reached . in particular , if the shape of the fluorescence fe k line seen in the seyfert galaxy mcg-6 - 30 - 15 ( see above ) and possibly in other seyferts ( nandra et al . 1997a ) indeed requires that the cold material powering the nucleus flows via a disk - like structure , this implies that the fluorescence occurs at at a distance @xmath46 @xmath16 . since the last stable orbit in a non - rotating ( schwarzschild ) black hole is at 3 @xmath16 and beyond this , the matter is in a free fall , this would imply that the black hole is spinning ( kerr ) , where the last stable orbit can be substantially closer to the black hole , depending on its spin . however , we note that an alternative scenario , advanced by @xcite does _ not _ require a disk at @xmath46 @xmath16 ; nonetheless , this still requires x ray emission at least at or just beyond 3 @xmath16 , merely eliminating the requirement of _ spinning _ black hole , but it still implies that at least a non - rotating black hole is present . as we mentioned above , active galaxies are generally variable , and the most rapid variability is observed in the x ray and @xmath1ray bands ; since we are interested in understanding the regions closest to the black hole , these bands deserve the most detailed study . a recent , excellent article by mushotzky , done , & pounds ( 1993 ) reviewed the x ray spectra of agn ; however , this covered the status of observations before the results from cgro became available , while we do include these results here . the most conclusive results are gleaned by a study of the non - blazar active galaxies , to avoid any potential contamination by the jet . since no radio - quiet (= jet - less ) active galaxy was detected above several hundred kev , the most relevant spectral region is the x ray and soft @xmath1ray bands . this covers nearly four decades in energy , from @xmath47 kev to @xmath48 mev , and often requires observations with multiple satellites , which must be made simultaneously , since active galaxies are variable in all bands . the early x ray observations of active galaxies by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite implied that , to the first order , x ray spectra of active galaxies are power laws with the energy index @xmath0 ( defined such that the flux density @xmath49 ) of about 0.7 , modified by photoelectric absorption at the low energy end . a major advance came from sensitive observations with the rosat and ginga satellites ( covering respectively the bands of 0.1 to 2 , and 2 to @xmath4 30 kev ) , revealing that the spectra are more complex , with a somewhat softer underlying continuum , with @xmath50 . this continuum is modified by photoelectric absorption in the host galaxy of the quasar ; the absorbing material can be either cold , or partially ionized , and this manifests itself as isolated edges , most notably of oxygen , seen in the rosat ( and more recently , also in asca ) data . the ginga spectra , reported by @xcite , showed a strong emission line at the rest energy of @xmath51 kev , presumably due to fluorescence of the k shell of iron , and a hardening above @xmath52 kev . these last two features were interpreted as signatures of reprocessing ( `` reflection '' ) of the primary continuum in the cold material that is accreting onto the nucleus . the fe k line is indeed the strongest expected , via the combination of the relatively high abundance of iron ( decreasing with the atomic number @xmath53 ) , and fluorescence yield ( increasing with @xmath53 ) ; as pointed out by @xcite , the line equivalent width as measured by ginga is too high to be produced in absorbing material of any column . reprocessing by the matter that accretes onto the black hole is thus the most viable alternative . the hardening , predicted earlier in a seminal paper by lightman & white ( 1988 ) , arises as an additional spectral component , due to compton reflection from cold matter . this is produced roughly at one thomson depth , or when the equivalent hydrogen column density is @xmath54 @xmath11 . the cosmic abundances of elements are such that at low energies , the photoelectric absorption dominates , and unless the accreting matter is substantially ionized , this component emerges only above the last significant absorption edge , again from iron . the strengths of the reflection component and the line are in fact in agreement with theoretical predictions by @xcite . with the intensity of the incident rays greatest closely to the central source ( as inferred from the variability of the continuum ) , its kinematic and gravitational doppler shifts are powerful diagnostics of the immediate circumnuclear region . perhaps the brightest _ bona fide _ seyfert 1 on the sky is the luminous object ic 4329a , and it has been observed simultaneously with the rosat ( 0.2 - 2 kev ) and cgro osse ( 50 - 1000 kev ) ( fabian et al . 1993 ; madejski et al . this left a gap between @xmath55 and @xmath56 kev , so the observations were supplemented by non - simultaneous data obtained by ginga a few years earlier ; the ginga data were renormalized to match the rosat flux at 2 kev , so this combined data set provided a good representation of a broad band high energy spectrum of a seyfert 1 , and is illustrated in fig . the data indeed showed a modest photoelectric absorption due to neutral material ( most likely the ism of the host galaxy ) , plus an additional modest column of ionized absorber . beyond @xmath55 kev , the spectrum is the primary continuum , with @xmath50 . at @xmath4 6.4 kev , there is a strong fe k line , which in the case of ic 4329a and many other seyfert galaxies is broad , with @xmath57 of at least 200 ev . the detailed studies of this line in another object , mcg-6 - 30 - 15 @xcite , show the characteristic two - pronged shape , implies relativistic motion in an accretion disk inclined to the line of sight as discussed above . the region beyond the fe k line shows general hardening of the spectrum , accompanied by the pseudo - edge due to fe k ; this is a signature of compton reflection , as discussed above . the intensity of this component is consistent with the reflector being a semi - infinite plane ; it peaks at @xmath58 kev , and beyond this , it steepens gradually , most likely due to the compton recoil as well as the klein - nishina effects . of course the underlying power law also can steepen there we only observe a sum of the primary and reflected spectrum . the detailed fits ( spectral decomposition ) of the data imply that the primary spectrum is consistent with the power law having an exponential cutoff at an e - folding energy of @xmath59 kev . the recent simultaneous rxte and osse observations of this object generally confirm this picture . a very important constraint on any theoretical models for radiation processes in active galaxies is the _ absence _ of strong annihilation line at 511 kev . is this high energy spectrum of ic 4329a unique ? given the variability of active galaxies , simultaneous observations in x rays and soft @xmath1rays are required , but these are sparse ; an alternative approach by @xcite is to co - add many non - simultaneous observations . this in fact produced an average spectrum that is remarkably similar to the above picture , and thus any theoretical interpretation of the data for ic 4329a is probably valid for seyfert nuclei in general . it is important to note that luminous objects similar to ic 4329a are a majority of seyfert 1s , but there is one important sub - class of seyferts that shows decidedly distinct x ray spectra , differing from the above description in soft x rays , below @xmath55 kev . these are the so - called `` ultra - soft '' seyferts . first observed in the heao data by s. pravdo and collaborators , they were suggested to be a possibly distinct class of active galaxies by f. cordova on the basis of the einstein observatory imaging proportional counter data . the exosat data analyzed by @xcite as well as by @xcite showed that in a number of active galaxies , the extrapolation of the hard power law towards low energies ( taking properly into consideration the absorption from our own galaxy ) _ underpredicted _ the soft x ray flux , indicating that there is an additional component of x ray emission . this , the so - called `` soft excess , '' meant that in a given object , the ultra - soft component can co - exist with the hard power law , implying that active galaxies generally have two - component power law spectra , where either or both components are visible . it is important to note that this component appears in both low- and high - luminosity sources ; for instance , it was observed in the einstein observatory data in the quasar pg 1211 + 143 by @xcite . for the sources where both components are present , they intersect at @xmath60 kev ( but this may be an observational artifact ) ; the spectrum of the soft component is very soft ( steep ) , and can be described as a power law with an index @xmath0 @xmath55 or even steeper ( but a power law is usually not a unique model ) , while the hard component has just the `` canonical '' hard seyfert 1 spectrum with @xmath0 @xmath48 . in the very few cases that the variability of both components has been measured , it appears that the two vary independently , showing no correlation between them ( see , e.g. , the case of mkn 335 in turner 1988 ) . on the other hand , such a lack of correlated variability may be the result of a complex spectral deconvolution procedure , since only a tail of the soft excess component is observable due to intervening absorption in the ism of the host , or our own galaxy . in fact , a correlation of uv and euv fluxes was clearly observed in the `` soft excess '' seyfert ngc 5548 ( marshall et al . this implies some coupling of the soft excess component to the uv / x ray reprocessing cycle discussed in more detail in section 6 below . similar correlation has been also detected in that source between the uv flux and soft x ray residuals observed simultaneously in ginga spectra ( cf . magdziarz et al . since the euv observations suggest much higher variability amplitude than the uv data , the lack of apparent correlation in fainter sources may be related to either variation of the cut off energy of the tail of the soft excess , or confusion with spectral index variations in the hard component . `` ultra - soft '' seyferts appear to be quite common in the rosat all - sky survey , which is not surprising , since rosat is a very sensitive instrument below 2 kev . detailed follow - up studies by @xcite showed a very interesting result : the optical / uv emission lines in these objects are generally quite narrow , with the widths on the order of 1,000 - 3,000 km s@xmath3 , as compared to @xmath61 5,000 km s@xmath3 for `` normal '' seyfert 1s . these are _ not _ similar to seyfert 2s at all ; these are widths of permitted lines , while seyfert 2s only rarely show permitted lines . important clues to the nature of these soft components may be in the variability patterns , although only very few well - sampled light curves exist . the exosat data were consistent with the hard x ray variability that is aperiodic but linear , meaning that the time series can be described as uncorrelated noise ( cf . czerny & lehto 1997 ) ; an example of a light curve for this is shown in fig . 1 . the variability of soft x rays , on the other hand , is often `` episodic , '' with large flares ( up to a factor of 100 ! ) ( see fig . 8 for an example ) , and decidedly non - linear ( cf . boller et al . ( in this case a `` non - linear '' behavior manifests itself qualitatively in an episodic , flare - like behavior such as that illustrated in fig . 8 ; see , e.g. , vio et al . quantitatively , a `` non - linear '' time series is a positive , definite one , which has the ratio of its standard deviation to its mean which is larger than unity ; see , e.g. , green 1993 . ) this difference may imply different emission mechanisms in the hard and soft x ray components ; however two observational effects have to be considered before drawing any conclusions . first , the observational noise or / and presence of additional higher frequency variability in the hard component may effectively dissolve apparent signatures of non - linearity ( cf . second , if the variability related to the energy reprocessing does indeed originate from variations of the soft excess component ( e.g. , magdziarz et al . 1998 ) , then the signatures of non - linearity should be suppressed in the uv and the hard continuum . early modeling attempted to describe the `` soft excess '' as the tail end of the thermal , multi - blackbody emission from an accretion disk ; however , this seems _ not _ to be the case , at least for the bright and well - studied ngc 5548 . magdziarz et al . ( 1998 ) have shown that the uv component in that object may be associated with rather cold disk continuum , with a temperature on the order of a few ev , while the soft excess requires a separate spectral component . we will return to this below . as it was mentioned above , the popular `` unification '' picture explains the differences between the spectra of seyfert 1s vs. seyfert 2s as due to the orientation effects . to the first order , the only difference that should be seen in the x ray spectra of the two classes is the amount of photoelectric absorption , while the underlying continuum should be the same . just as in the case of seyfert 1s , this requires simultaneous observations by multiple satellites , only the problem is more acute here , as the large amount of absorption leaves generally fewer soft x ray photons to allow for a sensitive measurement of the continuum . nonetheless , the observations with the ginga satellite by @xcite revealed that x ray spectra of seyfert 2s are in fact equivalent to spectra of seyfert 1s , absorbed by various column densities of cold gas . more detailed studies by @xcite implied that the continua of seyfert 2s may be somewhat harder , but only marginally so ; a more conclusive results should be obtained from observations by the rossi x ray timing explorer , which features a broader bandpass , extending to 50 kev ( or , for brighter sources , even to 100 kev ) . in any case , the inferred column densities in seyfert 2s are @xmath62 @xmath11 or more . in a few cases as , for instance , the well - studied ngc 1068 we only know that no primary x ray continuum is seen , so the absorber must be quite thomson - thick , with the absorbing column greater than @xmath63 @xmath11 . a good , illustrative example of a nearly - extreme seyfert 2 but , with the primary continuum still barely penetrating the absorber is ngc 4945 , a seyfert 2 which also shows megamaser emission , and thus is most likely observed in the plane of the putative torus . in the asca and ginga ranges ( below @xmath64 kev ) , the source is relatively faint , but above @xmath64 kev , the spectrum rises sharply ( @xcite ) . osse observations of it by @xcite revealed that at 50 - 100 kev , this is the second brightest radio - quiet active galaxy in the sky ( see fig . the absorbing column is large , @xmath65 @xmath11 , and while the observations were not simultaneous , a comparison of fig . 7 and fig . 9 reveals that the underlying continuum , to the first order , is consistent with that of a seyfert 1 . another interesting aspect of this source is the fact that the megamaser distribution implies a mass of the black hole of @xmath66 m@xmath67 ( greenhill et al . 1997 ) . with the bolometric luminosity of the nucleus of at least @xmath39 erg s@xmath3 ( iwasawa et al . 1993 ; done et al . 1996 ) , this source radiates at a few percent of eddington luminosity , and thus is unlikely to be advection - dominated , as may be the case for ngc 4258 . so far , we discussed primarily the relatively low - luminosity quasars , and an obvious question to be asked is : does this general picture hold for the higher luminosity counterparts ? in general , the answer is yes , but with some modifications . it is important here to compare `` apples to apples , '' and in the case of quasars , this means selecting radio - quiet objects , as radio - loud quasars tend to have higher x ray to optical flux ratios , which may be due to a contamination by a possible jet ; unfortunately , this paucity of x ray photons in the radio - quiet objects makes spectral studies somewhat more difficult . in general , the more luminous objects show a lower ratio of x ray to optical luminosities ( see , e.g. , kriss & canizares 1985 ; avni & tananbaum 1986 ) . the recent work by laor et al . ( 1997 ) ( using the rosat pspc data ) and @xcite ( using asca data ) indicates that the continuum x ray spectra of higher luminosity objects appear generally similar to those of the lower luminosity counterparts . notable exception is an absence of the fe k line and the compton reflection component in quasars ( see , e.g. , nandra et al . 1997b ) . with the more luminous central source , this may be the result of a nearly - complete ionization of the accreting material , such that the reflection component is present , but can not be distinguished by its tell - tale fe k line and spectral hardening above @xmath52 kev : for an entirely ionized reflector , the incident or emerging photons encounter no photoelectric absorption , and the reflection is ( below @xmath58 kev ) identical to the incident spectrum , with no fe k line present . unfortunately , those quasars are generally too faint to be studied in detail above @xmath64 kev , where the only instruments currently available are non - imaging proportional counters such as the rxte , dominated by uncertainties of the instrumental as well as the cosmic x ray background . as a result , any detailed studies must await x ray reflective optics sensitive beyond 10 kev , already under development ; such telescopes are essential for studies of these faint objects , as they permit subtraction of background from the same image as the source , and thus will yield the best quality data for luminous quasars . the availability of good quality high energy spectra permits us to constrain the possible emission mechanisms that can operate in active galaxies . we briefly discussed the case of blazars above ; observationally , the continuum high energy spectra of radio - quiet objects are also decidedly non - thermal , but these mechanisms are probably somewhat different than the synchrotron + compton model discussed for the blazar jets . the early work by @xcite , using the diffusion approximation , suggested that a power - law spectrum can be produced by a repeated compton - upscattering of soft photons by a compton - thick bath of hot electrons . a more general variant of this model is essentially what is used today to explain the primary , high energy spectrum in these objects as well as in the galactic black hole candidates . in summary , a successful model has to explain a power law spectrum with an energy index @xmath0 of @xmath4 0.9 1 , exponentially cutting off at @xmath68 kev : other spectral features are merely signatures of reprocessing . there are essentially two flavors of the comptonization model that can be applied to the isotropic emission in quasars : the original thermal comptonization version , and a non - thermal variant . the difference between the two is related to the distribution of electron energies . the non - thermal version , developed by a. zdziarski , a. lightman , p. coppi , as well as by c. done , r. svensson , g. ghisellini , and a. fabian ( zdziarski et al . 1990 ; zdziarski & coppi 1991 ) involves acceleration of particles to relativistic energies , and a subsequent pair cascade ; these particles comptonize uv photons , believed to be produced in abundance by the accretion disk . the attractive feature of this model is that the pairs thermalize to relatively low temperatures ( @xmath4 a few kev ) , providing the medium which , again , upscatters the uv photons to form the `` soft excess '' discussed above . one feature , however , predicted by this version of the model , is the annihilation line that should be present at @xmath69 kev . no spectrum of any active galaxy collected so far with the cgro osse detector showed such a feature ( johnson et al . 1997 ) , and thus the model is somewhat out of favor , despite its natural ability to provide the `` soft excess . '' refinements to the thermal comptonization model , primarily by @xcite , allowed the quasi - analytical calculation in the optically thin - to intermediate regime . this is the most viable current model for radio - quiet active galaxies , and is discussed in more detail in chapter 5.3 by j. poutanen . roughly , for regime relevant to the hard x ray spectra of seyferts , the energy of the exponential cutoff @xmath70 determines the temperature of the comptonizing plasma , such that @xmath71 @xmath72 @xmath73 , while the index of the power law , together with the cutoff , determine its optical depth @xmath74 , such that @xmath74 @xmath72 @xmath75 / @xmath76 ( pietrini & krolik 1995 ; poutanen , krolik , & ryde 1997 ) . for seyferts , the comptonizing plasma has to have a temperature of @xmath44 kev , and optical depth @xmath77 1 ; the soft `` seed '' photons are available in abundance from the inner accretion disk , as evidenced by the presence of the reflection component ( zdziarski et al . 1997 ) . however , a simple `` sandwich '' type structure ( with a cold disk covered by a uniform corona ) can not work , as this would produce too many `` seed '' photons for comptonization . instead , an example of a good phenomenological model is a `` patchy corona '' above a surface of the disk , proposed by haardt , maraschi , & ghisellini ( 1994 ) ; however , none of these models address the processes responsible for the particle acceleration . the issue of the `` soft excess '' remains unresolved in the context of the above models . spectral fitting to the data for the well - studied ngc 5548 imply that the soft excess can be produced by a relatively cold ( @xmath78 ev ) but optically thick ( @xmath79 ) plasma , while the hard continuum requires @xmath80 kev , but @xmath81 ( magdziarz et al . 1998 ) . coexistence of such two phases may be related to the disk structure and dynamics of possible multi - phase transition regions ( see , e.g. , magdziarz & blaes 1998 ) . in fact , such multi - phase medium appears naturally in local solutions of the disk corona transition layer ( see , e. g. , @xcite ) . however , without high quality observational data on the spectral shape and temporal correlation between both components , so far , we lack clear clues as to the time evolution of the plasma energetics . the author s prejudice ( based partially on the `` episodic '' nature of the soft light curves ) is that we probably witness some form of a limit cycle operating in the inner disk , and thus the best avenue for this is a development of a more detailed theory for the structure of the inner accretion region , and in particular , the issue of stability of the transition region between the _ bona fide _ disk and the matter free - falling onto the black hole . however , any tests of theories require sensitive observations : especially needed are well - sampled light curves obtained simultaneously over a broad energy range , from the softest energies accessible ( @xmath82 kev ) up to the end of the observable spectrum , in the mev range . the prospects for such observations are very good : with the impending launch of axaf , xmm , astro - e , integral , and , eventually , constellation - x , we should have the data for the more definitive modeling . johnson , w. n. , zdziarski , a. a. , madejski , g. m. , paciesas , w. s. , steinle , h. , & lin , y .- c . 1997 , in _ proceedings of the fourth compton symposium _ , eds . c. d. dermer , m. s. strickman , & j. d. kurfess ( aip : new york ) , aip conference proceedings 410 , p. 283
Abstract: | [
"this paper summarizes the observations which provide the best evidence for the presence of black holes in active galactic nuclei . this includes : x ray variability ; kinematical studies using optical emission lines as well as the distribution of megamaser spots ; and the shape of the fe k@xmath0 x ray emission line . it also presents the current status of our understanding of jet - dominated active galaxies ( blazars ) , and briefly reviews the currently popular agn `` unification schemes '' based on orientation effects . finally , it reviews the observations of the x ray and @xmath1ray continuum , which , at least for the radio - quiet objects , is likely to be the primary form of their radiative output , and summarizes the best current models for the radiative processes responsible for the high - energy electromagnetic emission in radio - quiet agn , as well as in jet - dominated blazars . * to appear in _ theory of black hole accretion disks , _ * * m. abramowicz , g. bjornsson , & j. pringle , eds . ( cambridge university press ) * 0.4 cm"
] | 10,448 | 10,448 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: astrophysical studies since the 1960s have provided a solid foundation for the physics of disk evolution and planetesimal formation . the core accretion model proposed by @xcite and @xcite , for example , has become part of the standard theory for planetary formation ( e.g. , @xcite ) . however , the problem of meter - size barrier , i.e. , infall of dust caused by headwind @xcite , still forms a considerable impediment to planetary formation . it is crucial to understand how to create planetesimals out of newly condensed dust particles , because the failure to form planetesimals would leave little chance for subsequent planetary formation . a number of models have been proposed to overcome this difficulty , including efficient sticking @xcite , mid - plane gravitational instability @xcite , and streaming instability @xcite , but no consensus has been reached yet . different mechanisms could result in disparate chemical structures and thus different implications for cosmochemistry @xcite . the very first prerequisite for planetesimal formation is the settling of particles towards the disk mid - plane . most of the models proposed to overcome the meter - size barrier require a higher dust - to - gas ratio than expected from the solar abundance , and dust concentration through vertical settling is one of the source mechanisms @xcite . evaluating the timescale for settling is thus essential when considering the subsequent evolution . calculations assuming a laminar disk suggest the time scale of @xmath210@xmath1 years , which is shorter than that of radial disk evolution @xcite . disk turbulence could potentially inhibit the dust growth , resulting in slow settling @xcite . the fragmentation of aggregates would also contribute to maintain small dust size and slow settling @xcite . the effect of chemistry on settling , however , has not been considered in previous studies , although it could play an important role in an early evolutionary stage . when dust grains settle through a vertical temperature gradient , the stable phases of dust - composing elements are likely to change , and even the existence of dust itself is not always guaranteed . using thermodynamic database , condensing species can be calculated at a given pressure and temperature @xcite . this allows us to predict the evolution of dust - composing species as the grains settle , but previous studies on disk evolution have rarely incorporated this thermodynamic constraint on dust settling . by building a simple thermodynamically - consistent model , we will quantify the effects of chemistry on vertical dust settling in protoplanetary disks , which is one of the most fundamental processes in planetary formation . our approach is notable at least for the following two points . first , dust properties are calculated through gibbs free energy minimization rather than using condensation temperature . second , the disk thermal structure is calculated using the opacity information consistent with results from gibbs free energy minimization . the existence of dust will affect the opacity by orders of magnitude , thus affecting the overall temperature structure . such temperature change will feed directly back to the chemistry , possibly altering the stable phases , and further modifying the opacity . thus , opacity is a key parameter connecting physics and chemistry , being crucial to make our calculations fully self - consistent . the purpose of this study is to demonstrate quantitatively this feedback between physics and chemistry during the dust settling process . the paper is organized as follows . first , a theoretical formulation for the interaction between mechanics and condensation is described in detail . modeling results then follow , exhibiting profound differences from classical calculations . implications for astronomical and cosmochemical studies are discussed , including the time scale for dust settling and the trends of element abundance recorded in various meteorites . previous radial evolution models involving both astrophysics and cosmochemistry are discussed as well . our model calculates one - dimensional ( 1-d ) dust settling , tracking the temporal and spatial evolution of dust amount and composition at an early stage of a protoplanetary disk in the terrestrial region . viscous dissipation is likely to cause an increase in temperature towards the mid - plane in the vertical direction . the chemical compositions of dust and coexisting gas at different heights will reflect such a temperature variation , and the amount of dust and its composition will also evolve as the grains settle . our calculations are centered on the following radiative heat transfer equation @xcite : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the temperature , @xmath5 is the height from the mid - plane , @xmath6 is the rosseland mean opacity , @xmath7 is the background gas density , @xmath8 is the stefan - boltzmann constant , and @xmath9 is the vertical radiation flux . the rosseland mean opacity is sensitive to dust amount , and the physics and chemistry of dust settling are connected through this opacity term . our model considers a system spanning from the mid - plane to five times the initial pressure scale height . at the outer edge of our model , therefore , the gas density is only 10@xmath10 of that at the mid - plane , and the temperature is expected to become roughly constant above the outer edge . the evolution of gas density is solved using a radial evolution model , independently from dust settling . the model is spatially discretized uniformly ; density , temperature , and gas composition are calculated for each grid cell , whereas a tracer - based method is used to solve the settling of dust grains and their composition . tracer particles , representing the dust size and the composition of a nearby region , are allocated in each grid cell . the evolution of dust density distribution is tracked by tracer particles , whose evolution is solved through the combination of classical physics and condensation theory . in our model , the equation of motion , the radiative heat transfer equation , dust opacity , and gibbs free energy minimization are solved sequentially . at each time step , we ( 1 ) populate tracer particles carrying the composition of nearby grains , ( 2 ) settle dust grains according to the equation of motion , ( 3 ) solve radiative heat transfer and gibbs free energy minimization simultaneously to obtain a new temperature profile and chemical composition . the detailed description of each step is given below . dust motion is assumed to be controlled by the solar gravity and the epstein drag @xcite . all the dust grains are assumed to be spherical and have no porous space inside , to focus on the effect of condensation . for an early - stage , high - temperature regime under consideration , this assumption is likely to be valid . the settling speed of dust particles reaches a terminal velocity in a time scale of a few seconds for grain size of @xmath21 @xmath11 m . therefore , all the grains are assumed to settle in the terminal velocity proportional to grain size given by @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the material dust density , @xmath14 is the grain size , and @xmath15 is the local keplerian angular velocity @xcite . the mean thermal speed of molecules is given by @xmath16 , where @xmath17 is the mean gas molecular mass and @xmath18 is the boltzmann constant . the temperature distribution is solved using the radiative transfer equation : equation ( [ dt / dz ] ) supplemented with @xmath19 where @xmath20 denotes the kinematic viscosity of the disk . the viscosity is scaled using the @xmath21-prescription of @xcite as @xmath22 where @xmath23 is the isothermal sound speed , @xmath24 is the pressure scale height , and @xmath21 is the constant to account for the undetermined mechanism for viscosity . observations of t - tauri stars suggest @xmath25 @xcite , whereas the recent studies of purely hydrodynamic turbulence imply @xmath26 @xcite . we employ the values between @xmath27 and @xmath28 to account for this uncertainty . whereas the value of @xmath21 may vary vertically depending on the source mechanism of viscosity , including the existence of dead zone @xcite , a constant value of @xmath21 along all height is adopter here . during the early stage of disk evolution , the terrestrial region is hot enough so that the gas is partially ionized , and a vertically uniform turbulence is likely to be generated . the rosseland mean opacity of dust particles is calculated through the mie - scattering code of @xcite using the refractive index data of silicates @xcite . the opacity varies with the amount of dust and its grain size @xcite . the temperature dependence of opacity is ignored here , because it is weak compared to the effect of dust size and amount . the rosseland mean opacity is plotted as a function of grain size in figure [ fig_op ] . dust particles of 1 @xmath11 m size have the largest opacity for near - infrared radiation . the grain size affects both opacity and settling speed , playing a crucial role in our model . when the dust first condenses , dust grains are assumed to nucleate homogeneously . for the initial grain size , we test a range of values spanning from 0.1 @xmath11 m to 10 @xmath11 m . the lower bound is taken from a typical interstellar grain size , and the upper bound is estimated from the mean free path , @xmath29 , and the thermal velocity of molecules , @xmath30 , assuming perfect aggregation at each collision . here we considered that two molecules or particles collide at an every interval of @xmath31 , and they always form an aggregate without bouncing . as molecules collide and stick , the number density becomes smaller and the interval of collision takes longer . one - hundredth of the time step ( see section [ imple ] ) is considered as the nucleation time scale , which is @xmath25 to 100 years in our calculations , and this gives the upper bound of 10 @xmath11 m as an initial nucleation size . given the assumption of perfect aggregation , it should be considered as an unlikely end - member case . this range covers the typical grain size of matrix materials ( 50 nm - 5 @xmath11 m ) in chondrites @xcite , which could be considered as the typical size of unmelted grains . grain growth occurs through additional condensation on existing grains ; i.e. , the number of dust particle is conserved by assuming heterogeneous nucleation . grain fragmentation , sticking , and dust size distribution are not considered in our model , and this simplification turns out to be justified a posteriori for most cases , as discussed in section 4 . equations ( [ dt / dz ] ) and ( [ dfz / dz ] ) are integrated from the disk surface towards the mid - plane . the surface temperature , @xmath32 , is used as a boundary condition and is converted from the effective temperature of the disk , @xmath33 , assuming that the disk is opaque to blackbody radiation due to the existence of @xmath11m - size grains . these temperatures are given by @xmath34 and @xmath35 where @xmath36 is the disk surface density @xcite . here the effective temperature is calculated by balancing viscous dissipation and blackbody radiation . the amounts of dust and its average chemical compositions at different heights in the system are calculated through gibbs free energy minimization . the disk temperature and pressure are necessary to determine stable phases , and the pressure is calculated assuming the ideal gas law ( @xmath37 ) . previous settling models have fixed the total dust amount in the system ( e.g. , @xcite ) , but our model determines the amount based on condensation calculation , making the model consistent with evolving chemistry . we have developed an original optimization method to minimize the free energy using a non - linear conjugate gradient method ( see appendix a for detail ) . only major elements ( h , o , na , mg , al , si , ca , and fe ) are considered in equilibrium calculations in this study . mineral species considered include corundum , melilite , spinel , olivine , and pyroxene . the complete list of species considered is given in table [ spec ] . thermodynamical data for silicates phases are taken from @xcite , and those for the rest of phases are from the janaf thermochemical tables . tracers are distributed uniformly in each grid cell at each time step , and they carry the information of dust amount and component in the nearby region . unlike conventional tracer methods ( e.g. , @xcite ) , the number density of tracers in our model does not correspond to the concentration of any kind . suppose that we populate @xmath38 tracers uniformly in one grid cell at @xmath5 and denote each tracer as @xmath39 @xmath40 . the tracer @xmath39 contains the total mass , average size , and average composition of all dust grains existing between @xmath41 and @xmath42 , where @xmath43 is the grid size . the tracers advect according to the settling velocity at each height . unlike grid - based methods , tracer method would not cause any numerical diffusion , thereby being able to calculate the settling accurately . although heterogeneous nucleation could cause the grain size to increase , a change in size is relatively small in our calculations , and no grains would overrun preceding grains . the distributions of temperature and dust composition are calculated based on this advected composition profile , using radiative heat transfer and gibbs free energy minimization simultaneously . after the settling is completed , we compute the average dust composition of each grid cell , by taking into account all of tracer particles in each cell . at this point , tracers still carry the dust composition calculated from the temperature profile at the previous time step . gibbs free energy minimization is then performed using the temperature and pressure at the upper node of the cell in order to obtain the new dust composition consistent with the new temperature profile . as we integrate the heat transfer equation from the disk surface to the mid - plane , the upper node is always updated first , and the upper node temperature corresponds to the new temperature for the cell . the temperature of the lower node of that cell is acquired by integrating equations ( [ dt / dz ] ) and ( [ dfz / dz ] ) , using the opacity based on the dust amount obtained from free energy minimization . when a grid cell has high dust density , however , a large opacity value of the cell could result in a substantial temperature difference between the upper and lower nodes of the grid . dust grains might not be able to remain in a solid phase anymore and evaporate at the lower end of the cell . however , using a single large opacity value will not account for this compositional variation and will result in an unrealistically high temperature at the lower node . in this case , we subdivide the grid cell and recalculate temperature and composition with higher resolution . we continue this grid refinement until additional subdivision changes the temperature of the lower node by less than 1 k. in this manner , the dust profile will be consistent with both radiative heat transfer and chemical thermodynamics . we used 100 grid cells ( size of 0.05 scale height ) and 20 tracer particles per grid cell . this particular choice of discretization is sufficient for our purpose , as shown later . the time step , @xmath44 , is chosen so that @xmath45 for the bottom 95% of dust grains by mass . the surface density @xmath36 is solved using a 1-d radial disk evolution model , derived from mass and angular momentum conservation laws , @xmath46,\ ] ] where @xmath47 is time , and @xmath48 is the radial distance from the sun @xcite . the viscosity @xmath20 is again described by the @xmath21-prescription . the disk temperature , necessary to compute the sound speed and thus the viscosity , is calculated using equation ( [ teff ] ) ( e.g. , @xcite ) . equation ( [ sigma ] ) is solved independently from the settling calculation , because dust settling in our model only causes a small difference on the mid - disk temperature and thus the viscosity . the vertical gas density profile is assumed to satisfy a hydrostatic equilibrium , and the surface density is converted to the vertical profile through @xmath49 the background gas density is assumed to vary temporally in proportion to the change of the surface density . in our model calculations , the gas composition is modified only through in situ and vertical processes such as condensation and dust settling , and we do not explicitly model the effect of radial transport on the gas composition . this is equivalent to assuming a similar chemical composition in the nearby region , and thus the radial mass flux into the system would not modify the gas composition . the evolution of gas surface density is calculated first using the radial disk evolution model of equation ( [ sigma ] ) , before solving the settling . the surface temperature is converted from the surface density using equation ( [ teff ] ) , and its evolution at 1 au and 4 au is plotted in figure [ fig_te1 ] . the timescale for disk evolution decreases inversely with the value of @xmath21 , which is proportional to viscosity . the evolution depends strongly also on an initial density profile , which is poorly constrained as well . in this study , we test two two initial disk masses , 0.35 and 0.5 solar mass , with a surface density profile inversely proportional to the distance from the sun @xcite , spanning up to 25 au ( @xmath50 , where @xmath51 is the surface density at 1 au ) . we used three values of @xmath21 ( @xmath52 , @xmath53 , and @xmath28 ) combined with two values of surface density @xmath51 ( 2.0 @xmath54 10@xmath0 and 3.0 @xmath54 10@xmath0 kg m@xmath55 , corresponding to 0.35@xmath56 and 0.5@xmath56 , respectively ) . we calculated the behavior of dust settlings at 1 au to 5 au with various parameter combinations . initially , our model has the solar composition of @xcite at all heights . when the disk interior is hot enough , si , mg , and fe evaporate , and when it is even hotter , al and ca also start to exist as gas phases . as we are considering an early stage of disk evolution , viscous heating is a major heat source of the disk , and the radiation from the sun has a negligible effect . depending on the value of @xmath21 , viscous heating is one to three orders of magnitude larger than the heat flux from the solar radiation , which is 3 w m@xmath55 at 1 au assuming a flat disk @xcite . this leads to an increase in temperature towards the mid - plane . dust first precipitates in the cooler upper region of the disk , and it sinks toward the mid - plane due to the gravity from the sun . the settling of micron - size particles is slow , but it gradually increases the dust - to - gas ratio in the lower region . in the inner region of the disk , if the value of @xmath21 is high enough , dust particles re - evaporate as they sink into the hotter interior and are prevented from further settling . figure [ fig_set1 ] shows some snapshots for the profiles of temperature and dust composition . the evaporation of dust particles creates a concentration of dust - composing elements . this leads to the formation of a dust - rich layer with high opacity , creating a large temperature gradient . any dust grain trying to cross this temperature jump will be subjected to evaporation , which prevents the grain from settling further ( figure [ fig_set1](a ) ) . this forms a `` condensation front '' , where dust particles concentrate due to a temperature jump created by themselves . figure [ fig_set1](c ) shows that mg , si , and fe are concentrated above the condensation front at @xmath22.5 times the scale height at @xmath57 year , because these elements all condense in a short range of temperature . figure [ fig_set1](b ) shows a pair of condensation and evaporation occurring above and below the front . when the total evaporated amount is larger than 10% of the total condensed amount , a condensation front is defined to have formed . the tracer method allows us to resolve condensation and evaporation within a single grid cell . all of our calculations were made with 100 grid cells and 20 tracer particles per grid , but a finer grid resolution or a denser tracer population does not change our results significantly . table [ conv ] lists the values of the mid - disk temperature at @xmath58 years obtained by varying the grid size and the number of tracers per cell . the front descends slowly with the same settling speeds as dust particles . repeating evaporation and condensation will keep the grain size in its initial nucleation size . some grains might go through collisional sticking and grow in size , but such larger grains would settle faster into a hotter region , ending up with evaporation . the condensation front and the associated temperature jump will be sustained by the remaining smaller particles . this justifies our strategy of neglecting grain growth in our calculations . some representative temporal model evolutions at 1 au are shown in figure [ fig_tev ] . as time proceeds , the average temperature decreases , and dust mass increases . by comparing the cases with @xmath59 and @xmath60 kg m@xmath55 , it can be seen that a higher surface density results in a hotter interior , keeping more dust - composing elements in the gas phase . for both cases , however , the ratio of evaporated and condensed amounts converges to almost unity , indicating that the amounts evaporating below and condensing above the front are nearly equal . the amount of dust is self - regulated below a certain value so that it would not create too large a temperature increase to prohibit the existence of the dust altogether , resulting in the ratio of evaporated and condensed close to unity . therefore , the settling of the condensation front could be even slower than the settling of individual dust particles . a larger initial nucleation size of 10 @xmath11 m or a smaller viscosity of @xmath27 would result in a lower mid - disk temperature , and thus it would take longer to form a condensation front with the ratio close to unity , but the front still forms after a certain period of time . in the outer terrestrial region , a different kind of model evolution is observed ( figure [ fig_tev3 ] ) . the ratio of evaporated and condensed would never be larger than unity , but some fraction of dust is still evaporating due to the formation of the front . even for the case of @xmath61 and @xmath62 kg m@xmath55 , the ratio rapidly decreases , due to its short radial evolution timescale . this is the case with the highest viscosity and the highest initial disk density among the parameter combinations considered in this study , so it has the highest potential to sustain a condensation front . the model with @xmath63 has a lower mid - disk temperature from the beginning , so the ratio also quickly decreases close to zero . another rise in the ratio can be seen after 5 @xmath54 10@xmath0 years , and this is caused by the condensation front formed by na and si , which condense at lower temperatures ( figure [ fig_setn ] ) . the temperature decreases slowly compared to the case with @xmath61 , and this leaves a room for a lower - temperature condensation front . because na has a small mass fraction compared to other major elements , it only has a minor effect on the evolution of the mid - disk temperature . the settling slows down as it approaches the mid - plane , because the settling speed is inversely proportional to the background gas density ( equation ( [ vset ] ) ) . both the surface and mid - disk temperatures gradually cool down as viscous heating decreases along with the dissipation of the nebular gas . the disk interior , where most of the mass exists , remains hotter than the condensation temperatures of mg , si , and fe due to the condensation front , whereas the region closer to the surface cools down within a few thousands of years . in all the cases , highly refractory species ( corundum and melilite ) do not form a condensation front . this is because ca- and al - bearing grains do not have a sufficient amount to form a front , and also because they only condense in the hot inner region , where it has too little radiation flux to form a temperature jump . the temperature gradient is proportional to the radiation flux , which is smaller in the interior . the absence of a ca or al condensation front suggests that highly refractory species settle without being affected by evolving chemistry . it is likely that ca and al dust settle simply following classical mechanics , and it is necessary to consider the grain - size evolution in a more careful manner . the formation of the condensation front inhibits dust settling , resulting in an extended settling timescale , which is comparable to that of radial evolution . at 1 au , the condensation front would last as long as @xmath64 years for @xmath65 , and @xmath66 years for @xmath61 with the initial nucleation size of 1 @xmath11 m , whereas the radial evolution occur in @xmath67 years . whether dust accumulates near the mid - plane or not has a large impact on subsequent evolution processes ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and the effect of the condensation front could be potentially crucial . figure [ fig_sum ] summarizes the condition for the formation of a condensation front as a function of the value of @xmath21 and the distance from the sun . when the value of @xmath21 is larger than 10@xmath68 , it is highly likely that a condensation front forms in the terrestrial region . if the initial nucleation size is limited to around 1 @xmath11 m , the condensation front could form as far as in the asteroid belt region ( figure [ fig_sum](b ) ) . for @xmath61 , the region spans even further close to the jovian orbit . even if the initial nucleation size is as small as interstellar grains or as large as 10 @xmath11 m , the existence of front is likely at @xmath69 . the front forms with a higher possibility when grains with 1 @xmath11 m exist , because the opacity and thus the mid - disk temperature are the highest at 1 @xmath11 m ( figure [ fig_op ] ) . given that the initial nucleation size would exhibit some finite distribution in reality , a small amount of dust with 1 @xmath11 m is expected to always exist , which would contribute to the formation of the front . the formation of condensation front could well be ubiquitous in the inner terrestrial region , causing the slow settling of dust grains . the existence of dust grains , which is necessary for the subsequent evolution to take place , is controlled by thermodynamics . in early protoplanetary disks , it is likely that silicates evaporated in the terrestrial planet region @xcite , and it would be essential to consider the complex evolution caused by condensation . our results indicate a substantially longer timescale for dust settling compared with the standard theory of planetary formation @xcite . the standard theory suggests that dust grains settle in the order of a few thousand years and grow into mm - size by the time they reach the mid - plane . when condensation is considered , however , our study shows that the fate of dust settling can be more complex , affected by the formation of a condensation front and its slow descent . dust concentrates above the front forming a temperature jump , and dust would not be able to penetrate this temperature jump created by itself . evaporation and condensation would repeat at the front , keeping the dust size in its initial nucleation size . a condensation front survives until viscous dissipation becomes weak . eventually , metallic iron , forsterite , and enstatite become stable near the cold mid - plane , and no evaporation will happen after that . even with a large initial grain size of 10 @xmath11 m , the settling takes @xmath210@xmath0 years at 1 au , which is two orders of magnitude longer than classical estimates , and with an initial size of 1 @xmath11 m , it takes longer than half a million years . in the meantime , some fraction of dust composing elements would dissipate as gas , without becoming planetesimals . this could potentially change the estimate of the minimum solar nebular mass . the prolonged time scale for dust settling will also change the interval between the formation times of cai and planets , because planet formation is not likely to start until dust settles to the mid - plane . this may affect our understanding of the solar system chronology . repeating evaporation and condensation limit the dust size to around the initial nucleation size , which again differs from the grain size predicted from pure mechanics . this could possibly explain the dominance of @xmath11m - size particles in the disks inferred from some astronomical observations @xcite . the observation of a region where a condensation front forms should show the dominance of @xmath11m - dust . what we would observe from the earth should correspond to the surface of micron - size dust - rich layer since dust is depleted in the overlying region of the front . condensation front will last for an order of radial evolution time scale , which makes @xmath11m - size dust observable for a prolonged time . this explanation , however , holds only for disks with a hot interior , while many observations of @xmath11m - size particles in cold disks also exist . the fragmentation of large - size dust aggregates could also replenish small grains , resulting in the existence of @xmath11m - size dust and slow settling @xcite . although it is neglected in our calculation , turbulent mixing could relax the concentration of dust , along with the steep temperature jump , at the condensation front . a gradual increase of temperature will still cause dust grains to evaporate at the end of the temperature jump , and repeating condensation and evaporation are likely to happen , meaning that the suppression of grain size will still occur . if turbulence is weak enough in such a upper layer , the concentration of dust above the front may even cause the layer to be gravitationally unstable . the degree of viscous turbulence could be complex depending on the source mechanism , although it is simply characterized by a constant parameter @xmath21 in this study . this assumption is reasonable for most of our cases , since the regions considered here are the hot inner part of the disks , which remain hotter than 1000 k , leading the gas to be ionized through collision . this assumption , however , could be invalid in the outer cold region . future studies are warranted to address these important complications . various element abundances recorded in chondrites have shown a depletion trend correlating with their volatility , and its origin has been debated for the past several decades @xcite . the elements with condensation temperatures between that of silicon and sulfur in particular have shown a clear trend @xcite , and this trend has been called the depletion of moderately volatile elements ( move ) . quite a few cosmochemical models have tried to explain the move depletion based on the idea of incomplete condensation , i.e. , fractional condensation in a gradually cooling and dissipating protoplanetary disk ( e.g. , @xcite ) . @xcite , for example , used an analytical disk model to calculate the move depletion trend , and his model has succeeded in reproducing the observed trend . however , the result changes substantially just by incorporating the infall of dust caused by headwind @xcite , and other mechanisms suggested by astrophysical theory , such as turbulence and grain size evolution , have also been neglected in these analytical disk models . the abundance of refractory elements , such as the al / si and mg / si ratios , have not been fully explained as well . most of chondrites show similar values of al / si and mg / si to those of the solar photosphere @xcite . however , if , for some period of time , the nebula has been hotter than the si condensation temperature , gas containing si would have dissipated , while al would have remained in the nebula as solid . under the framework of incomplete condensation , therefore , it should leave a depletion trend not only in volatile elements , but also in refractory elements . when the al / si ratio is calculated using the approach of @xcite , al / si is predicted to be at least factor of 2 higher than that of ci chondrites . furthermore , ordinary and enstatite chondrites show depletion in al , which is one of the most refractory elements . this could not be explained by incomplete condensation . figure [ fig_me ] plots the molar ratios of al / si and mg / si for various types of chondrites . the lack of a depletion trend between al and si indicates either that the highest temperature achieved in the disk must have been below the condensation temperature of si ( e.g. , @xcite ) , or that the incomplete condensation hypothesis is neglecting some important mechanisms . astrophysical models , however , show that all the elements including refractory elements might have evaporated around 1 au when the mass accretion rate is larger than @xmath70 yr@xmath71 @xcite , which is a typical accretion rate for the disk at an early phase . our dust settling model may bring a new insight into the depletion trend observed in chondrites . in the framework of incomplete condensation , it seems inevitable to produce a depletion of si , if the terrestrial region exceeds the condensation temperature of si . as discussed in the previous section , corundum and gehlenite do not form a condensation front , which indicates that al and ca bearing refractory grains would not evaporate even if they settle below the condensation front . because their grain growth is not likely to be limited by the front , it will stick to each other and grow in size . particles larger than cm - size tend to decouple from the gas and drift inward in a short time scale @xcite . whereas dust bearing mg , si , and fe is suppressed to @xmath11m - size above the condensation front , refractory grains are likely to drift inward , and they would either concentrate in the inner region or fall into the sun . therefore , as long as the infall of materials does not end up in the region under consideration , dust grains remaining above the condensation front are likely to be the planet - forming materials in the region . for the sake of discussion , we assume that planets would have the same composition with what is left above the front and compare it with the al / si and mg / si ratios of chondrites . as seen in figure [ fig_me ] , the composition above the condensation front can exhibit a significant depletion in both al and mg , and its compositional variation can cover from ordinary to enstatite chondrites . most of al - rich dust particles would penetrate through the front and settle towards the mid - plane , though those associated with albite ( naalsi@xmath72o@xmath73 ) could remain above the front . the amount of al is thus determined by albite , but when condensation front forms further up from the mid - plane in the hot inner disk , and the formation and settling of corundum ( al@xmath74o@xmath72 ) would only leave a small fraction of al left for albite to form . therefore , al above the front will be smaller in those cases , resulting in a stronger depletion . the composition of earth has long been considered to be chondritic except for volatile elements @xcite , but quite a few geochemical data are showing the possibility of a non - chondritic origin @xcite . these studies suggested the necessity of a non - chondritic reservoir to explain the bulk silicate earth ( bse ) , but how to create such a reservoir has been controversial . however , our idea of condensation front might naturally explain a possible difference between chondrites and the earth . when refractory elements are transported inward , the enrichment of refractory elements in the inner region will occur together with the depletion in the outer region , the result of which might lead to the enrichment observed in bse @xcite and the depletion in ordinary chondrites . chondrites that formed further out where the condensation front did not form would not go through such enrichment nor depletion , and therefore , abundances close to ci chondrites are likely to be recorded . how far the condensation front formed can not sharply be constrained because of the uncertainty of disk parameters , but the boundary likely exists between 2 and 5 au , which corresponds to the source region of chondrites . in some cases , na and si also formed a condensation front ( figure [ fig_setn ] ) , potentially providing another mechanism to modify the abundance of move . with our 1-d dust settling model , the al / si and mg / si ratios can not be discussed in a quantitative manner , because the effect of radial drift has yet to be considered . our model , however , has shown the importance of the physical effect of condensation in the theory of planet formation , and we plan to consider the effects of grain growth and turbulence and to expand the model to 2-d in the future . although both turbulence and grain growth have small effects on vertical dust settling , they are likely to be important in radial models . turbulence would only smear out the temperature and dust peaks at the condensation front in our current vertical model , but it could cause a substantial transport of mass in the radial model . grain growth during vertical dust settling was suppressed by a condensation front , but it would not be the case in a 2-d model . grain growth could cause the variations of grain structure and surface composition , both of which could affect the opacity to some extent @xcite . some of the previous astrophysical models have already studied the effect of condensation on radial evolution . they showed that the effects of evaporation as dust grains drift inward could lead to an order - magnitude enhancement of evaporated element concentration in the vicinity of condensation temperature @xcite . however , most of the existing astrophysical models still treat condensation temperatures as if they were constant , although they may change by 100 - 200 k as pressure changes spatially and temporarily throughout the disk . the enhancement of dust / gas ratio or the concentration of certain elements could also affect condensation temperatures significantly ( @xcite ; see also appendix a ) . moreover , most of the astrophysical models classify dust into only two classes , i.e. , ice and silicate , although this treatment will lose the important information of condensing minerals , hindering the quantitative comparison with meteoritic data . some other radial models that tried to relate to cosmochemistry ( e.g. , @xcite ) have used an analytical disk model ( e.g. , @xcite ) . however , this ignores the effect of evolving dust composition on opacity . opacity is sensitive to grain size , shape , and its composition , and it should be calculated by honoring the disk environment @xcite . in our approach , the effect of chemistry on dust migration is taken into account accurately by thermodynamic calculations , and the evolution of compositional variation within the disk is fed back to the dynamics of disk evolution through opacity calculation , making the calculation fully self - consistent . by comparing results from our future 2-d models with the meteoritic data , we may be able to estimate some disk parameters such as initial density profile , viscosity , and grain size evolution , all of which are still highly unknown . to extract such astrophysical constraints from cosmochemical data , it is of utmost importance to develop a new theory of protoplanetary disks , which is consistent with both physics and chemistry . we constructed a vertical dust settling model by incorporating the effects of chemistry to the classical physical model of dust settling in a self - consistent manner . we showed that dust grains evaporate as they settle towards the hotter interior and cause the concentration of dust - composing elements . this leads to the formation of a condensation front . concentrated dust grains act as a high opacity layer , generating a large temperature increase , which hampers further dust settling by evaporation . the formation of a condensation front is ubiquitous at around 1 au and could exist even at as far as 4 au depending on the choice of disk parameters . the existence of the front would significantly change the timescale of dust settling and also cause highly refractory grains ( with al or ca ) and moderately refractory grains ( with mg , si , or fe ) to settle in different modes . moderately refractory grains with mg , si , and fe would form a condensation front and settle in a long timescale , but grains with al and ca would not form the front and are likely to settle quickly towards the mid - plane . al and ca could end up in a large grain size and experience radial drifting . this could potentially explain the chemical diversity observed among the bulk silicate earth , ordinary chondrites , and carbonatious chondrites . * acknowledgements . * this work was supported in part by the facilities and staff of the yale university faculty of arts and sciences high performance computing center . .chemical species considered in gibbs free energy minimization [ cols="^,<",options="header " , ] the total gibbs free energy of the system that contains @xmath75 different species may be expressed as @xmath76 where @xmath77 and @xmath78 denote the quantity and chemical potential of @xmath79-th species , respectively . for solid , the chemical potential is assumed to be independent of pressure , because the pressure effect is small in the low pressure condition . the chemical potential of gas is given by @xmath80 for gas , where @xmath81 is the chemical potential at a pressure of 1 atm and temperature @xmath4 , and @xmath38 is the total number of moles of gaseous species . equilibrium state is acquired by minimizing the gibbs free energy under the constraint of mass balance equation : @xmath82 where @xmath83 is the number of elements in the system , @xmath84 is the number of atoms of element @xmath85 in @xmath79-th species , and @xmath86 is the number of moles of element @xmath85 in the system . equation ( [ mass_b1 ] ) could be written in a matrix form : @xmath87 . in the system consisted of h , o , mg , and al , for example , the corresponding row of al@xmath74o@xmath72 in @xmath88 will be @xmath89 . we use a non - linear conjugate gradient method to minimize equation ( [ n - gibbs ] ) . we start with an initial composition of @xmath90 and incrementally update the composition along the direction calculated from the gradient at each iteration . the gradient of the free energy function , @xmath91 , is given by @xmath81 for a solid species , and by @xmath92 for a gas species . this gradient , however , does not satisfy the mass balance relationship , so we project the gradient to the null - space of @xmath93 using the projection matrix , @xmath94 , so that numbers of moles of the elements are conserved . by applying @xmath93 , mass conservation can be shown to hold : @xmath95 . the updated composition @xmath96 is searched as a minimum along the direction of @xmath97 : @xmath98 , where @xmath99 denotes an adjustable step length . the line search direction @xmath97 is calculated using the polak - ribire method @xcite : @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the projected gradient , @xmath102 . for the initial search , @xmath103 is set to @xmath104 . in order to calculate the step length @xmath99 that minimizes the free energy along the search direction @xmath97 , the bisection method is adopted , by using the fact that the dot product of @xmath97 and @xmath105 is zero at the minimum . other search methods that directly compare the free energy are less reliable , because subtle changes in free energy caused by metal elements can be so small compared with the free energy of hydrogen that their effect can not be represented by limited numerical precision . another constraint on minimizing the free energy is that the number of moles of every species should be non - negative . if the result of the line search returns a negative amount for a certain species , the step length @xmath99 is adjusted to satisfy the non - negative condition for all species . at a certain iteration , a number of moles @xmath77 could be zero for some @xmath79 , but the @xmath79-th component of the search direction @xmath97 could be negative , prohibiting further optimization . in this case , we remove the @xmath79-th species from our calculation for this step and re - optimize the number of moles . we shall , however , return @xmath79-th species into our calculation in the next iteration , because there is no guarantee that @xmath77 is zero at the global minimum . similarly , when the amounts of several species are zero and their search directions are pointing towards negative , we should not remove all the species from the calculation at once . even if the @xmath79-th component of the original projected gradient is positive , the sign of the component may change by excluding some species . we should thus check whether each component of the projected gradient is positive or not every time we remove any of the species from our calculations . it is important to randomize the order of removing the species from the system , because whether the projected gradient is positive or negative depends on the set of species we choose to compose @xmath93 . it is possible that when we remove the species from our calculations in a certain order , the projected gradient could end up with a zero vector , but if we change the order of removing the species , we may obtain a non - zero gradient that points to a lower energy state , satisfying the non - negative molar amount constraint . gas species may show a extremely small amount at global minimum , but its derivative might show a large value due to the steep nature of the derivative of log function even close to the minmum . when the gradient is large despite of the composition being close to the global minimum , it causes extra iterations to converge , so removing gas species with infinitesimal amount from the calculation at certain iterations is a way to make the calculation converge faster . this serious of procedures is continued until the norm of the projected gradient becomes sufficiently small . a flowchart for this procedure is shown in figure [ fig_flow ] . the validity of our code is checked against hsc chemistry ( version 8.1 ) using the solar abundance data from @xcite . for all of the temperature range considered , our code matches the result from hsc chemistry within the order of numerical error ( figure [ fig_seq](c ) ) . the condensation sequences starting with solar abundance gas and dust - enriched gas are calculated using our method , and they are plotted in figure [ fig_seq ] . the dust - enriched gas contains 20 times more na , mg , al , si , ca and fe relative to solar composition gas . it can be seen that the condensation temperatures of these elements are up to 100 - 200 k higher in the dust - enriched system . alexander , c. m. o. , hutchison , r. , barber , d.j . 1989 , epsl , 95 , 187 alexander , c. m. o. 2005 , m&ps , 7 , 943 anders , e. 1964 , ssr , 3 , 583 armitage , p. j. 2010 , astrophysics of planet formation ( cambridge university press ) bell , k. r. , cassen , p. m. , klahr , h. h. , and henning , th . 1997 , , 486 , 372 bland , p. a. , alard , o. , benedix , g. k. , kearsley , a. t. , menzies , o. n. , watt , l. e. , and rogers , n. w. 2005 , pnas , 102 , 39 calvet , n. , hartmann , l. , and strom , s. e. 2000 , in protostars and planets iv , ed . mannings , v. , boss , a. p. , and russell , s. s. ( tucson : univ . arizona press ) campbell , i. h. and oneill , h. st . c. 2012 , nature , 483 , 553 cassen , p. , 1996 , mps , 31 , 793 chambers , j. e. 2009 , , 705 , 1206 chambers , j. e. 2014 , , in treatise on geochemistry , 2nd edition , vol . 2 , ed . holland , h. and turekian , k. ( new york : elsevier ) chiang , e. and goldreich , p. 1997 , , 490 , 368 chiang , e. 2008 , , 675 , 1549 chick , k. m. and cassen , p. 1997 , , 477 , 398 cuzzi , j. n. and zanhle , k. j. 2004 , , 614 , 490 ciesla , f. j. and cuzzi , j. n. 2006 , icarus , 181 , 178 ciesla , f. j. 2007 , , 654 , l159 ciesla , f. j. 2008 , mps , 43 , 639 ciesla , f. j. 2011 , , 740 , 9 draine , b. t. 1985 , , 57 , 587 drake , m. j. and righter , k. 2002 , nature , 416 , 39 dullemond , c. p. and dominik c. 2005 , a&a , 434 , 971 ebel , d. s. and grossman , l. 2000 , gca , 64 , 339 estrada , p. r. , cuzzi , j. n. , and morgan d. a. 2016 , , 818 , 200 fleming , t. , and stone , j. m. 2003 , apj , 585 , 908 goldreich , p. and ward , w. r. 1973 , , 183 , 1051 grossman , l. 1972 , gca , 36 , 597 hartmann , k. , calvet , n. , gullbring , e. , and dalessio , p. 1998 , , 495 , 385 hayashi , c. , nakazawa k. , and nakagawa y. 1985 , in protostars and planets ii , ed . black , d. c. and matthews , m. s. ( tucson : univ . arizona press ) hubbard , a. and ebel , d. s. 2014 , icarus , 237 , 84 hueso , r. and guillot , r. 2005 , a&a , 442 , 703 larimer , j. w. 1967 , gca , 31 , 1215 johansen , a. , henning , t. , klahr , h. 2006 , apj , 643 , 1219 johansen , a. , oishi , j. s. , mac low , m. m. , klahr , h. , henning , t. , youdin , a. 2007 , nature , 448,1022 lewis , j. s. 1974 , science , 186 , 440 lodders , k. 2003 , , 591 , 1220 lyubetskaya , t. and korenaga , j. 2007 , , 112 , b03211 mtzler , c. 2002 , tech . rep . 2002 - 11 , institut fr angewandte physik , universitt bern monaghan , j. j. 1985 , comp . , 3 , 71 nakagawa , y. , sekiya , m. , and hayashi , c. 1986 , icarus , 67 , 375 nelson , r. p. , gressel , o. , umurhan , o. m. , 2013 , , 435 , 2610 palme , h. , larimer , j. w. , and lipschutz , m. e. 1988 , meteorites and the early solar syatem palme , h. and boynton , w. v. 1993 , in protostars and planets iii , ed . levy , e. h. and lunine , j. i. ( tucson : univ . arizona press ) palme , h. and oneill , h. s .c . 2014 , in treatise on geochemistry , 2nd edition , vol . 3 , ed . holland , h. and turekian , k. ( new york : elsevier ) palme , z. and zipfel , j. 2016 , 47th lpsc , 2252 , 2016 polak , b. and ribire , g. 1969 , rev . oper . , 16 , 35 pollack , j. b. , mckay , c. p. , and christofferson b. m. 1985 , icarus , 64 , 471 pollack , j. b. , hollenback , d. , beckwith , s. , simonelli , d. p. , and fong . w. 1994 , , 421 , 615 pringle , j. e. 1981 , araa , 19 , 137 robie , r. a. and hemingway , b. s. 1995 , u.s . geological survey bulletin 2131 ruden , s. p. , pollack , j. b. , 1991 , , 375 , 740 . safronov , v. s. 1972 , evolution of the protoplanetary cloud and formation of the earth and planets ( jerusalem : israel program for scientific translations , keter publishing house ) scott , e. r. d. and krot , a. n. 2014 , in treatise on geochemistry , 2nd edition , vol . 1 , ed . holland , h. and turekian , k. ( new york : elsevier ) semenov , d. , henning , th . , helling , ch . , ilgner , m. , and sedlmayr , e. 2003 , a&a , 410 , 611 shakura , n. i. and sunyaev , r. a. 1973 , a&a , 24 , 337 stoll , m. h. r. and kley , w. 2014 , a&a , 572 , a77 tackley , p. j. and king , s. d. 2003 , ggg , 4 , 4 van boekel , r. , dullemond , c. p. , and dominik , c. 2005 , a&a , 441 , 563 wasson , j. t. and kallemeyn , g. w. 1988 , rspta , 325 , 535 weidenschilling , s. j. 1977 , , 180 , 57 weidenschilling , s. j. 1984 , icarus , 60 , 553 weidenschilling , s. j. 2011 , icarus , 214 , 671 youdin , a. n. and shu , f. h. 2002 , , 580 , 494 youdin , a. n. and goodman , j. 2005 , 620 , 459 yoneda , s. and grossman , l. 1995 , gca , 59 , 3413
Abstract: | [
"we propose the possibility of a new phenomenon affecting the settling of dust grains at the terrestrial region in early protoplanetary disks . sinking dust grains evaporate in a hot inner region during an early stage of disk evolution , and the effects of condensation and evaporation on vertical dust settling can be significant . a 1-d dust settling model considering both physical and chemical aspects is presented in this paper . modeling results show that dust grains evaporate as they sink into the hotter interior and form a `` condensation front '' above which dust - composing elements , mg , si , and fe , accumulate , creating a large temperature jump . repeating evaporation at the front inhibits grain growth , resulting in slow settling with a time scale comparable to that of radial evolution . the time scale of dust settling is predicted to be longer than 10@xmath0 years at 1 au , whereas an order of 10@xmath1 years is suggested by the standard theory of planetary formation . the new model might also explain some puzzling compositional features observed in chondrites . our results show different settling behaviors between highly refractory elements , such as al and ca , and moderately refractory elements , such as mg , si , and fe , pointing to the importance of building a more complete model that takes into account both the physical and chemical evolution of protoplanetary disks ."
] | 9,683 | 9,683 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the continuous electron beam accelerator facility ( cebaf ) at jefferson lab ( jlab ) delivers a highly polarized electron beam in the 1 11 gev energy range for currents up to @xmath2 200 @xmath1a . a key part of the jlab physics program consists of high - precision parity violating electron scattering experiments @xcite that require a fast and precise electron beam polarization measurement . conventional polarimetry techniques such as mller @xcite and mott @xcite are destructive for the beam properties due to solid targets they use and can not be operated simultaneously with the physics experiments . they can only be operated at low intensity ( @xmath3 10 @xmath1a ) and at low energy ( @xmath3 5 mev ) respectively ; therefore , the physics experiments have to assume that beam polarization remains constant when the intensity or the energy of the beam is several orders of magnitude higher . alternatively compton polarimetry has been used with great success at jlab @xcite and elsewhere @xcite to measure the electron beam polarization in a continuous and non - destructive manner . however , unlike at high - current ( @xmath4 20 ma ) storage rings @xcite and at high - energy ( @xmath4 50 gev ) colliders @xcite , the relatively low - current and low - energy nature of the cebaf electron beam has required the use of high - finesse optical cavities @xcite to enhance the laser power beyond commercially available lasers to provide sufficient electron - photon collision luminosity . compton polarimetry determines the electron beam polarization based on a well - known spin - dependent scattering cross - section @xcite between polarized electrons and photons . the longitudinal electron beam polarization @xmath5 is extracted from the experimental compton scattering asymmetry @xmath6 , according to , @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the theoretical compton scattering asymmetry that can be derived by combining the calculated spin - dependent compton cross section with the appropriate experimental response function @xcite , and @xmath9 is the circular photon beam polarization . the scattering asymmetry @xmath6 can be measured based on the detection of either the scattered photons or the scattered electrons and depends on the energies of the colliding electron and photon beams . for an electron beam of 1.0 gev , the maximum scattering asymmetry for infrared ( 1064 nm ) photons is 1.8% , whereas for green ( 532 nm ) photons , it is 3.5% . for an electron beam of 6 gev , these values are about 10% and 18% , respectively . therefore , compton polarimetry at low beam energies ( @xmath3 2 gev ) is difficult to perform . + external optical cavities have frequently been employed to increase the laser power from a light source through a process of coherent addition . recently optical cavities have been widely employed in many areas such as x-/@xmath10-ray generation via inverse - compton scattering @xcite , high harmonic generation @xcite and electron beam polarimetry @xcite . according to the best of our knowledge , there are only three facilities in the world have ever built a compton polarimeter with an optical cavity ; mainz microtron ( mami ) @xcite , hadron electron ring accelerator ( hera ) @xcite and jlab @xcite . in hall a of jlab , a compton back - scattering polarimeter had been operational since 1999 @xcite . its photon source had a typical circulating power of @xmath2 1.5 kw inside a monolithic fabry - perot cavity where the circularly polarized photons scattered from the longitudinally polarized electrons . it provided 1.0% statistical ( and 1.2% systematic ) precision with @xmath2 25 minutes data taking for 4.6 gev , 40 @xmath1a electrons @xcite . this polarimeter used a continuous - wave ( cw ) infrared ( ir , 1064 nm ) laser as its photon source and had serious limitations in providing a good signal - to - noise ratio for beam energies below 2 gev @xcite . under this circumstance , it is highly desirable to have a shorter - wavelength and higher - power light source since this will result in larger back - scattered electron and photon energies and a larger measured scattering asymmetry , and hence increased ability to control systematic uncertainties . + the lead radius experiment ( prex ) @xcite at jlab aims to provide the first model - independent evidence of the existence of a significant neutron skin in @xmath11pb . prex proposed to obtain a statistical and systematic precisions of 3.0% and 2.0% respectively on the parity - violating electroweak asymmetry of polarized electrons from @xmath11pb to determine the neutron radius of @xmath11pb at 1.0% accuracy . the uncertainty goal for beam polarimetry at 1.06 gev was 1.0% . in order to meet the high - precision requirement , the existing compton polarimeter underwent an upgrade @xcite in 2010 . the upgrade includes a new photon detector with an upgraded integrating data acquisition ( daq ) system , a new electron detector , and a new compton photon source that includes a green laser ( 532 nm ) with a new high - finesse fabry - perot cavity @xcite . + this paper will describe the upgraded experimental setup in hall a at jlab , with an emphasis on the frequency - doubled green laser system and optical cavity . a unique technique to extract the laser beam polarization inside a resonant fabry - perot cavity will be given and finally , the first electron beam polarization measurement results from the prex experiment @xcite at a beam energy and current of 1.06 gev and 50 @xmath1a will also be presented . with an enhancement factor and intra - cavity power of 3,800 and 3.7 kw , we report the highest power compton polarimetry facility operating at 532 nm as compared to existing facilities such as mami @xcite and hall c at jlab @xcite . , d@xmath12 , d@xmath0 and d@xmath13 ) that deflect the primary electron beam and send it through the fabry - perot cavity . the scattered compton electrons and photons will be detected by electron and photon detectors , respectively.,width=294 ] the upgraded compton polarimeter in hall a consists of a magnetic chicane , a photon source that is composed of a laser system and fabry - perot cavity , a photon detector , and an electron detector as shown in fig . [ fig : chicane ] . the electron beam enters from the left . when the four identical dipoles of the chicane , referred to as d@xmath14 , d@xmath12 , d@xmath0 and d@xmath13 , are energized , the beam is deflected vertically and crosses the photon beam enhanced in the fabry - perot cavity that is located at the center of the chicane . the fabry - perot cavity is enclosed in a vacuum chamber that is connected to electron beam pipes from both ends and sits on an optical table where the laser and other optical elements are located . the compton interaction point ( cip ) is at the center of the beam crossing in the cavity . the crossing angle between the electron and photon beams is 24 mrad . the electrons undergo compton scattering with circularly polarized photons resonating in the fabry - perot cavity fed by a cw green laser ( 532 nm ) . the backscattered photons are detected in the photon detector while the scattered electrons can be detected in the electron detector located a few mm above the primary beam in front of d@xmath13 . approximately one electron in every one billion undergoes compton scattering . unscattered electrons , separated from the scattered particles by d@xmath0 in the chicane , continue on into the hall a target for the primary experiment . independent electron and photon analyses give complementary determinations of the electron beam polarization . a scale 3d view of the compton polarimeter in the hall a tunnel at jlab is shown in fig . [ fig : chicane3d ] . + the photon detector is located under dipole d@xmath13 and consist of a single crystal of ce - doped gd@xmath12sio@xmath15 ( gso ) and a single pmt ( photomultiplier tube ) . it is mounted on a motorized table with remote - controllable motion along both axes ( horizontal and vertical ) transverse to the electron beam direction . the scattered photons from the cip go through a thin vacuum window and lead disk in the vacuum pipe before they hit the detector window . the photon detector daq uses a customized 12-bit flash analog - to - digital converter ( fadc ) that integrates the scintillation photon signals from the pmt and samples the data at rates of 200 mw @xcite . + the electron detector consists of four silicon microstrip planes spaced horizontally 1 cm from each other with a 200 micron vertical rising offset between planes . each plane consists of 192 strips of silicon with a width of 240 microns . the planes are inclined at an angle of 58 mrad from the vertical position . the detector is mounted on a translator with a remote - controllable stepper motor and can travel vertically up to 120 mm from the main beam . the optical elements of the polarimeter are mounted on a vibration - damped optical table between dipoles d@xmath12 and d@xmath0 ( fig . [ fig : chicane3d ] ) . a schematic of the optical system of the polarimeter is illustrated in fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] . based on their main functionality , we can categorize the optical elements into four groups necessary for achieving the required power and circular polarization in the cavity . the first group is the laser source that provides a green beam at the wavelength of 532 nm . the second group consists of the elements that transport , align and focus the incident beam for coupling to the optical cavity . the third group includes elements for controlling and measuring the polarization . the last group consists of elements which allow the use of the reflected beam from the cavity in the electronic feedback system to achieve frequency locking of the laser to the cavity . as shown in fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] , the seed laser is a narrow - linewidth ( @xmath3 5.0 khz ) diode pumped nd : yag nonplanar ring oscillator ( npro ) laser ( lightwave 126 ; jdsu ) that delivers a linearly polarized cw ir ( 1064 nm ) beam of up to 250 mw . the output of this laser has been fiber - coupled to a ytterbium - doped fiber amplifier ( ydfa , yar-10k-1064-lp - sf ; ipg photonics ) through a single - mode polarization - maintaining ( pm ) fiber . the ydfa takes @xmath2 10 mw of seed laser and provides a linearly polarized ( extinction ratio : 20 db ) output with a maximum power of 10 w at 1064 nm in cw mode . the frequency doubling crystal is bulk periodically poled mgo : linbo@xmath0 ( ppln , hc photonics ) doped with 5% mgo in order to minimize photo - refractive damage . the crystal is 0.5 mm thick , 3 mm wide and 50 mm long , and the quasi - phase matching ( qpm ) period is 6.92 @xmath1 m with a 50% duty cycle . the input and output surfaces are antireflection ( ar ) coated for 1064 nm and 532 nm , respectively . the crystal is placed in an externally controlled , temperature - stabilized oven developed in - house . the oven is mounted on a stage composed of a four - axis tilt aligner ( 9071-v ; newport ) in order to establish a precise alignment for phase matching . a temperature controller ( tecsource 5305 ; arroyo instruments ) with a nominal resolution of 0.01 @xmath16c provides the required phase - matching temperature for second harmonic generation ( shg ) . the crystal optical axis is matched with the direction of the output polarization ( vertical ) of the ydfa . a pair of 0.5 inch lenses ( l@xmath17 and l@xmath18 in fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] ) with focal lengths of 13.8 mm and 15 mm ( with a total effective focal length of @xmath2 120 mm ) are then used to focus the beam waist diameter ( @xmath2 80 @xmath1 m ) into the center of the crystal . this makes the rayleigh length of the pump laser focus to be around 5 mm and ensures the beam size at the crystal entry and exit faces to be around 400 @xmath1 m . this critical focusing also ensures the incoming beam is not clipped by the tiny crystal thickness while keeping the shg efficiency close to the maximum . the generated green beam is separated from the residual ir beam after the crystal via a pair of 1.0 inch dichroic mirrors ( @xmath19 99% at 532 nm , @xmath20 95% at 1064 nm ) noted as dc@xmath14 and dc@xmath12 ( altos photonics ) . the lenses , oven and dichroic mirrors are all mounted on a separate linear translation stage seated on a rail , and the whole system is contained in an enclosure box . + m and ir pump power of 5 w.,width=283 ] with the experimental setup as described above , we have measured several properties , such as crystal temperature tuning curve , beam quality and power stability , of the second harmonic beam . the measured temperature tuning curve at 5 w ir pump power is shown in fig . [ fig : tempscanfit ] . the red circles show the experimental data while the blue line represents the theoretical fit for the first - order qpm interaction predicted by the sellmeier equation for ppln crystal @xcite . the experimental results give the full width at half - maximum ( fwhm ) phase - matching temperature bandwidth @xmath21 = 0.6 @xmath16c at the phase - matching temperature 64.0 @xmath16c . + ) is used to extract the normalized shg conversion efficiency.,width=291 ] fig . [ fig : ppln_conveff ] shows the average green power ( solid circles ) output from ppln and corresponding phase - matching temperature ( open squares ) at different ir pump powers from the fiber amplifier . it is important to note that the value of the phase - matching temperature changes slightly when the ir pump power is changed . the phase - matching temperature ranges between 64.0 @xmath16c and 64.3 @xmath16c for ir pump power between 200 mw and 5 w. at each power level the crystal is maintained at the peak phase - matching temperature to ensure maximum green power . for a loosely focused gaussian beam , the normalized conversion efficiency @xmath22 for first - order qpm is defined as @xcite , @xmath23 @xmath24 where @xmath25 and @xmath26 are the fundamental and shg powers , @xmath27 is the frequency of the fundamental beam , @xmath28 is the nonlinear coefficient of ppln , @xmath29 is the permittivity of free space , and @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the refractive indexes at these wavelengths . in fig . [ fig : ppln_conveff ] , as the theoretical fit ( green line ) defined by eq . ( [ eq : coneff ] ) shows , the green power varies quadratically with the ir pump power with a normalized conversion efficiency @xmath22 of 1.37%w@xmath32cm@xmath32 . it is necessary to point out that all powers are direct measurements after dc@xmath12 by an optical power meter ( pm140 ; thorlabs ) without correcting for the residual reflection at the crystal face or losses in the dichroic mirrors . the experimental results show that there is no sign of saturation in the shg power at 5 w ir pump power . this is mostly due to a larger beam waist size at the crystal center so that there is no pump depletion . therefore , the achieved conversion efficiency is somewhat lower than the maximum conversion efficiency of 2.62%w@xmath32cm@xmath32 provided by the vendor . all of these considerations suggest that thermal lens effects are negligible . the maximum achieved green power at 5 w ir pump power is 1.74 w with a total conversion efficiency of 34.8% . a primary goal of this work is to develop a stable and good - quality green beam at the watt level , so we did not pursue higher conversion efficiencies . + ) and vertical ( @xmath34 ) directions and continuous lines show the theoretical fits to extract the @xmath35 @xcite values in both directions.,width=294 ] the quality of the green beam is of major importance in power enhancement with an optical cavity , as any deviation from a perfect gaussian profile will lead to a rejection of power by the high - finesse cavity and will not contribute to the power buildup inside the fabry - perot cavity . in order to check the beam quality , we focused the green beam after the ppln into a 200 @xmath1 m waist diameter with an additional lens and measured the beam size at different axial positions . [ fig : ppln_m2 ] shows the green beam profile at 1.74 w monitored by a laser beam profiler ( lba - fw - scor20 ; spiricon ) along with the theoretical fit . closed and open circles are the measured beam diameters in the horizontal ( @xmath36 ) and vertical ( @xmath34 ) directions . the result of the theoretical fits ( solid lines ) to the experimental data determines an @xmath35 @xcite value of @xmath2 1.1 in both dimensions confirming the tem@xmath37 spatial mode in the shg process . however , there is a small astigmatism mainly arising from the difference in refractive indexes along the horizontal and vertical axes of the ppln crystal . as shown in fig . [ fig : powerstability ] , the peak - to - peak stability of green power at 1.74 w is 0.8% for the entire period of 12 hours , while the fundamental ir power stability from the ydfa is measured to be better than 0.6% over 4 hours . + the frequency - doubled green beam based on single - pass shg in a ppln crystal pumped by a ydfa has been used with the high - finesse fabry - perot cavity as a photon source for the compton polarimeter during the three - month run period of the prex experiment @xcite in 2010 . in the following we describe how we establish a frequency locking of this beam to a resonant frequency of the high - finesse fabry - perot cavity . the green beam is propagated through a series of optical elements ( fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] ) to properly match the fundamental cavity mode ( tem@xmath37 ) at the injection point . after exiting the ppln crystal and reflecting from two dichroic mirrors ( dc@xmath38 and dc@xmath39 ) , the green beam is focused by a lens l@xmath40 ( @xmath41 = 75 mm ) at 6.0 cm from the frequency doubling setup with waist diameters 370 @xmath1 m and 450 @xmath1 m in the horizontal and vertical directions . the focusing of the incident beam at the cip is accomplished by three lenses denoted l@xmath14 , l@xmath12 and l@xmath0 , respectively . a diverging lens l@xmath38 ( @xmath42 = -1.0 m ) at 405 mm from the frequency - doubling setup nearly collimates the beam after it passes through an optical isolator ( isolation : 40 db , io-3 - 532-hp ; thorlabs ) and a half - wave plate ( hwp ) . in order to achieve the correct beam waist size at the cavity center , we have two more lenses , l@xmath39 and l@xmath43 ( @xmath44 = -50 mm , @xmath45 = 200 mm ) , installed at 820 mm and 1.0 m from the frequency - doubling setup . here in our setup , l@xmath38 and l@xmath39 are on fixed mounts and l@xmath43 is mounted on a remote controlled translation stage ( m-605.1dd ; physik instrumente ) . this allows fine tuning and precise alignment of the laser beam to the cavity by using another pair of remotely controlled mirrors ( m@xmath38 and m@xmath39 ) that allow four degrees of motion ( 2 translations , 2 rotations ) for the laser beam with respect to the optical axis of the cavity . both the proper focusing and precise alignment of the impinging laser beam to the cavity are needed in order to achieve good mode matching . the mirrors m@xmath46 , m@xmath47 , m@xmath48 and m@xmath49 are fixed at 45@xmath16 with respect to the incident beam . a camera ( ccd@xmath14 ) facing the mirror m@xmath47 monitors the positions of the incident and reflected beams from the cavity . another camera ( ccd@xmath12 ) at the cavity exit is used for monitoring the profile of the transmitted beam from the cavity . + as shown in fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] , our cavity consists of two ( m@xmath50 , m@xmath51 ) identical highly reflective ( r = 99.975% ) concave mirrors ( advanced thin films ) separated by 850 mm . the mirrors have a typical transmittance of 240 ppm ( parts per million ) and total nominal ( scattering and absorption ) loss of @xmath3 10 ppm . this leads to a maximum power enhancement of @xmath52 = 4,000 . the coating is made of alternating dielectric quarter - wave layers of sio@xmath39 and ta@xmath39o@xmath53 on a super polished ( surface rms roughness = 0.5 @xmath54 ) fused silica substrate ( thickness 4 mm , diameter 7.75 mm ) by an ion beam sputtering technique . the mirrors have a typical radius of curvature of 0.5 m that requires a gaussian beam waist diameter of 348 @xmath1 m at the center of the cavity @xcite . this geometry was chosen to maximize the electron - photon collision luminosity when the laser light is frequency locked to the cavity and crosses with the electron beam . + a careful study of beam propagation from the frequency doubling setup to the cavity through each optical element has been performed using optocad @xcite . [ fig : beamtransport ] shows the calculated beam size versus the distance along the beam path from the frequency doubling setup . experimental verification of the laser waist size at the center of the cavity is not possible with the beam profiler . therefore , we created an auxiliary optical path ( 2.375 m ) that has the same path length from the doubling setup to the cavity with all the optical elements in place . instead of m@xmath50 , we used an uncoated mirror substrate made of the same fused silica material with the same radius of curvature . we experimentally checked the beam waist size and location after this mirror substrate , and compared it to our calculation . a small correction with l@xmath43 ( few mm ) is necessary in order to get an average beam size of 350 @xmath1 m at a distance of 425 mm ( corresponding to the cavity center ) from this mirror substrate . at the exit of the cavity , there is a set of optical elements composed of a quarter - wave plate ( qwp@xmath39 ) , a holographic beam sampler ( hbs ) and a wollaston prism ( fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] and fig . [ fig : opticstable ] ) that are used for measuring and monitoring the laser polarization ( discussed in section [ sec : laserpolarization ] ) . the strongest requirements on the design of a fabry - perot cavity in a compton polarimeter are that it must be rigid and must have a small crossing angle with the electron beam . the small crossing angle increases the electron - photon interaction luminosity . the geometry of the cavity is determined by the total distance between the two mirrors ( 850 mm ) , the radius of curvature of the mirrors ( 500 mm ) and the crossing angle between the laser and electron beams . with this design the crossing angle is 24 mrad , the gap between the electron beam and mirror edge is 6.12 mm and the laser beam size on the cavity mirror is 898 @xmath1 m . + a mechanical drawing of the cavity is shown in fig . [ fig : opticstable ] . the cavity and all the other optical elements are mounted on an optical table with a footprint of 1.5 m @xmath55 1.2 m. this table is placed on a laminar flow damping system consisting of four pneumatic posts with auto - leveling valves to isolate the vibrations from the ground . the optical table is located inside a small room equipped with a laminar flow fan filter unit . in order to ensure thermal and mechanical stability , an invar ( 64feni ) frame consisting of three cylindrical rods attached to two vertical plates , each with an octagonal cutout , forms the backbone of the cavity frame . the cavity vacuum chamber is a cylindrical vessel made of stainless steel with a diameter of 4.5 inches ( fig . [ fig : opticstable ] ) connected to two octagonal gimbal mounts through two soft bellows . the bellows allow the gimbal mounts to tilt freely in both the horizontal and vertical planes when they are adjusted by four piezo actuators under atmosphere . however , in our experiment , the bellows were too stiff under vacuum for the piezo actuators to move the gimbals remotely . therefore the procedure involves locking the cavity under atmosphere , then locking the gimbals and drawing vacuum . the cavity mirror is mounted on a mirror holder attached to these gimbal mounts which are also made of invar . each gimbal mount is supported by four stainless steel cylindrical bearings ( c - flex bearing co. ) that form two axes ( horizontal and vertical ) for each gimbal mount and allow them to tilt freely around each axis . the mirror holder is machined such that the rotation axis of each mirror lies on the same axis as the gimbals . the bearings are 0.25 inch in diameter and 0.4 inch in length , and each can support a load up to 100 lbs . two remote controlled picomotors ( 8302 ; newfocus ) attached to each gimbal mount are used for aligning each cavity mirrors by tilting the gimbal mounts in both the vertical and transverse planes with respect to the laser beam propagation direction . a pair of counteracting spring plungers ( maximum load 13 lbs ) are attached to the gimbal mounts to keep the alignment in position . the picomotors are interfaced to the epics @xcite slow control system ( discussed in section [ sec : feedback ] ) that allows remote alignment of the cavity mirrors . + a pair of vacuum window substrates ( w@xmath56 and w@xmath57 in fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] ) that are made of fused silica ( 3 mm thick and 0.7 inch in diameter ) allow the laser beam to enter and exit the cavity via a pair of 0.5 inch turning mirrors ( m@xmath48 and m@xmath49 in fig . [ fig : opticalsetup ] ) oriented at 45@xmath16 with respect to the incident laser beam . the vacuum windows are ar coated for 532 nm and welded to stainless steel flanges ( fig . [ fig : opticstable ] ) by the glass - metal soldering technique . two soft bellows on both sides of each gimbal mount are connected to both sides of the cavity vacuum chamber through a pair of flanges and allow the gimbals to tilt freely . each of the 45@xmath16 turning mirrors is mounted to an aluminum holder that is attached to a stainless steel flange mounted on a post . each aluminum holder has a slit 4 cm long and 1 cm wide that allows the electron beam to pass through . when the cavity is installed in the electron beam line ( fig . [ fig : cavityinstalledhall ] ) , the stainless steel flanges are connected to the beam pipe by another set of soft bellows that isolates any vibrations from the rest of the electron beam pipe . two beam position monitors located on both sides of the cavity are used to monitor changes in beam position of the electron beam during beam tuning and data taking . two ion pumps can provide a vacuum of @xmath2 10@xmath58 torr inside the cavity after several hours of bake - out at @xmath2 100 @xmath59c . maintaining the resonance and therefore the enhancement in the cavity requires feedback control of the laser frequency . the optical frequency stabilization must be better than the free spectral range ( @xmath60=176.5 mhz ) divided by the finesse ( @xmath61=12,000 ) , which is @xmath215 khz ( cavity bandwidth ) . this is equivalent to a stabilization of the 850 mm cavity length to better than the laser wavelength divided by the finesse , which is @xmath2 0.04 nm . the electronic feedback system that controls the laser frequency uses the pound - drever - hall technique @xcite . the error signal is created by phase detection between the photodiode ( pdr in fig . [ fig : cavcontrl ] ) output of the modulated reflection signal and the modulation signal from the function generator ( fg220 , yokogawa ) . the error signal includes information on cavity resonance , and is then used to build the feedback signals supplied on both the fast and slow control ports of the seed laser . the electronic feedback system has been designed and built by saclay @xcite . the simplified flow chart is shown in fig . [ fig : cavcontrl ] . + the optical elements that are critical to beam alignment and polarization control and measurement , the lasers ( seed laser , fiber amplifier and ppln doubling system ) and the locking electronics are all interfaced to a remotely controlled system through a local workstation . electronics specific to the feedback control loop , the function generator ( ramp generator , modulation signal generator ) , the oscilloscope and the workstation are located in the control room . the lasers , stepper and servo motors with their control units , photodiodes , ccd cameras and the preamplifiers are located on the optical table in the hall a tunnel . the monitors related to the cavity resonance mode and beam alignment are connected to cameras ccd@xmath39 and ccd@xmath38 through coaxial bnc cables and are located in the control room . [ fig : cavityfunctionalview ] shows a functional view of the laser and cavity system with control units . + an automatic switching system from open - loop " mode to closed - loop " mode around the cavity resonance region permits the system to transition automatically between the resonant and locked states . it consists of an electronic circuit and an epics program that manage the laser temperature scan via the slow control port of the seed laser . a 10 v peak - to - peak triangular ramp , together with a sinusoidal modulation signal at @xmath62 = 928 khz with 50 mv amplitude , is supplied on the laser piezoelectric transducer ( pzt ) via the fast control port of the seed laser . + two fast photodiodes ( s1223 ; hamamatsu ) are used for monitoring the reflected ( pdr ) and transmitted ( pdt ) signals . they are held at a constant voltage level of 5 v. the currents from the photodiodes are transformed into voltage signals via a trans - impedance amplifier that allows signal transmission across 100 meters of coaxial cables . a band - pass filter is applied on the reflected signal from the cavity after it is mixed with the modulation signal at frequency @xmath62 and amplified . the mixing and filtering extracts an error signal corresponding to the change in reflected light at the laser modulation frequency . the value of @xmath62 was determined by minimizing the laser residual amplitude modulation ( ram ) @xcite . the error signal is injected into a series of three separate integrators ( proportional - integral - derivative or pid ) common to the slow and fast control loops . the two control modes play complementary roles : the slow mode is for compensating the slow drift in laser frequency while the fast mode allows the efficient reduction of the laser frequency jitter . the output signals of these two modules are applied directly to the two laser control ports that control the seed laser frequency . + the vme ( versa module eurocard ) crate , used for controlling the electronics , is located in experimental hall a. the electronics are controlled from a workstation in the control room with the help of interface cards . the interface cards permit us to transmit numerical signals over a network to the optical table area which is about 100 meters from where the vme crate is located . the epics slow control program is used for regulating and activating the entire system from the workstation in the control room . it allows real - time control of analog and digital inputs and outputs to the various crates and modules . the vme crate houses the following cards : an icv150 card that measures the voltages of the control signals ( pdr , pdt , fast ramp , slow ramp ) ; an icv196 card that provides the digital interface between the electronic - card sequencer and the control screens by sending and receiving transistor - transistor logic ( ttl ) signals ; and an mv712 card that allows rs-232 commands to control devices such as the laser , the ppln temperature controller and the fiber amplifier . a servo motor controller is used for controlling the steering mirrors m@xmath38 , m@xmath39 and the focusing lens l@xmath43 . beam position variations are monitored with two quadrant cell photodiodes , noted as 4q@xmath14 and 4q@xmath12 , that detect a small amount of transmitted light ( @xmath63 ) behind m@xmath47 and m@xmath56 . the analog signals read by their electronics are fed to the icv150 card and monitored by the control system . each quarter wave plate ( qwp@xmath38 , qwp@xmath39 ) is controlled by a separate stepper motor controller ( ks491 - 2p , suruga seiki ) . with the help of the slow control interface , we can control the entire locking assembly from the workstation : the locking threshold level , the servo loop gain , the state of the feedback loop and the laser frequency scan program . once the optical cavity is installed in the electron beam line , it is important to check various parameters ( such as cavity finesse @xmath61 , bandwidth @xmath64 and the intra - cavity power @xmath65 ) that are essential to the performance of an operational cavity . two methods have been employed to characterize the cavity : a graphical method and a decay - time measurement method . + the graphical method analyzes the shape of the cavity resonance waveforms ( transmission , reflection and error signals ) while the seed laser frequency is being scanned by a triangular ramp voltage applied to the laser pzt . in this method , we first determine the fwhm of the reflection / transmission peak that corresponds to the cavity bandwidth . then , one converts from time units to frequency units by setting the gap , 2@xmath21 = @xmath66 + @xmath67 , between the two sidebands ( @xmath68 , @xmath69 ) equal to twice the modulation frequency @xmath62 . [ fig : bandwidth ] shows a theoretical fit @xcite to the transmission ( fig . [ fig : bandwidth](a ) ) and reflection ( fig . [ fig : bandwidth](b ) ) signals that are used to extract the cavity bandwidth and therefore the cavity finesse . the measurement shows that the cavity exhibits a typical bandwidth of @xmath2 13 khz with a corresponding finesse of @xmath2 13,300 . since the typical width of the resonance is @xmath2 0.04 nm , the measurement is susceptible to external disturbances and fluctuates for each measurement . in addition , due to a hysteresis exhibited in the laser pzt , the modulation sidebands would not be symmetric around the main peak as shown in fig . [ fig : bandwidth ] . therefore , the finesse measured in this method has a large error at the order of 10@xmath70 20@xmath70 . + once the laser beam and cavity are aligned with respect to each other , the laser frequency can be locked to the fundamental cavity resonance mode via its feedback system . [ fig : scopesignal ] shows a digital oscilloscope trace that includes waveforms corresponding to the locked ( feedback on ) and unlocked ( feedback off ) states of the cavity . in the cavity decay - time measurement method , while the cavity is locked , we switch off the laser diode and immediately record the transmitted power via a fast photodiode ( s1223 ; hamamatsu ) and a digital oscilloscope ( tds3054b ; tektronix ) . for a high - finesse cavity , the cavity decay time @xmath71 is directly related to the cavity parameters by @xcite , @xmath72 where @xmath73 is the cavity length and @xmath74 is the speed of light . here , it is necessary to take into account the decay time of the laser diode ( @xmath75 ) itself in order to determine @xmath76 correctly . s.,width=283 ] fig . [ fig : decaytime ] shows a typical cavity decay curve measured ( black dots ) for the optical cavity and an exponential fit @xcite ( red line ) to extract the decay time . here , after correcting the fitted value of the decay time to the measured laser decay time ( 6 @xmath1s ) @xcite and taking the sampling error of the oscilloscope as 0.5 @xmath1s , we have @xmath71 = 11.40 @xmath77 0.5 @xmath1s with the corresponding @xmath61 = 12,637 @xmath77 554 and @xmath78 = 14.00 @xmath77 0.32 khz from this measurement . + [ cols="<,<,<,<",options="header " , ] after taking into account all the systematic errors described , the total systematic error in the determination of the intra - cavity laser polarization was estimated to be 0.70% . the averaged statistical errors during three - month period of the prex experiment were 0.1% and 0.13% for the left- and right - circularly polarized states respectively . based on the transfer function measurement , the average left- and right - laser polarizations ( @xmath9 = @xmath79 ) with uncertainties during the prex experiment are summarized as @xmath80 , @xmath81 . + so far we have discussed how to make a reliable photon target with a pure circular polarization inside a high - finesse optical cavity for the electron beam so that there is efficient compton scattering . the green cavity has been combined with the photon arm @xcite of the upgraded compton polarimeter to continuously measure the electron beam polarization . the electron beam polarization measurement can be achieved by one of the three ways at the down stream of the optical cavity : detecting the backscattered compton photons , detecting the scattered compton electrons , and detecting both the compton photons and compton electrons simultaneously . at the time we commissioned our laser system and cavity , the electron detector had not been fully commissioned and there is no way to detect the scattered compton electrons . therefore , the results presented here are solely based on the data from the upgraded photon detector and daq that are described in ref . @xcite . in the following section , without going into the details , we will briefly present the results of the electron beam polarization measurement conducted for the first time during the prex experiment with electron beam parameters of 1.06 gev and 50 @xmath1a @xcite . the upgraded compton polarimeter measures the electron beam polarization based on the detection of scattered compton photons during electron helicity reversal at a rate of 120 hz @xcite . the helicity of the electron beam at jlab can be flipped at a rate of between 1 ms to 33 ms at the injector with a pseudo - random pattern . [ fig : triggerrate ] shows the scattered photon rates versus accelerator helicity timing signal ( called the mps signal ) measured with the photon detector for an electron beam energy and current of 1.06 gev and 50 @xmath1a . during the data taking , the laser polarization is flipped periodically between right- and left - circular state and the cavity is locked for @xmath2 90 seconds in each polarization state . between each polarization state , the cavity is out of resonance for @xmath2 40 seconds to measure the background rate , which is subtracted from the signal rate measured when the cavity is locked . lower background rates can be achieved by several steps . low vacuum pressure in the cavity ( 10@xmath58 torr in our case ) can reduce the scattering between electron beam and residual gas . properly controlling the electron beam parameters upstream and carefully centering and focusing the beam at the interaction point is a key to achieve low background rates . during background rate optimization , the electron beam is scanned vertically until it crosses the photon beam at the cip by using all four dipoles connected in series to the power supplies in the compton chicane ( fig . [ fig : chicane ] ) . + the compton photon energy spectrum is measured using the triggered mode of the daq . in this readout mode , a discriminator with a very low threshold is used to trigger a readout of the fadc samples over a 500 ns window , allowing study of the sampled pulse shape and size . the sum of samples in the pulse represents the total energy deposited in the gso crystal for each detected photon . this energy spectrum is plotted in ( fig . [ fig : cptspectr ] ) , with the horizontal axis in raw adc units . to determine the experimental compton asymmetry @xmath6 , the measured adc response is calibrated to the well known compton scattering photon energy spectrum and the result is compared to a full monte carlo simulation of the photon detector by geant4 @xcite . after confirming good agreement with data , this same simulation is then used to calculate the theoretical asymmetry @xmath8 in eq . ( [ eq : cmptasym ] ) . the integrating photon detector daq ( as described in ref . @xcite ) sums the fadc samples over the entire period of stable beam helicity between flips , using a gate supplied by an accelerator timing board . these integrated signals ( @xmath82 ) are used to calculate the asymmetry @xmath6 as : @xmath83 for each laser helicity period with separate sums of integrals for all electron helicity ( @xmath77 ) windows . a separate sum and difference of integrated signals for the adjacent cavity - unlocked periods , @xmath84 , used to determine background for the cavity - locked period . after taking into account the background and helicity - dependent electron beam parameters at the accelerator source , eq . ( [ eq : asymmegan ] ) becomes , @xmath85 where @xmath86 denotes the mean integral per helicity window over each cavity ( locked / unlocked ) period . here , @xmath87 is the measured integrated signal with the laser locked , and includes both the compton - scattered signal @xmath88 and the background signal @xmath89 . @xmath6 can be extracted separately for each laser polarization using one of the three averaging techniques discussed in ref . [ fig : aexp ] shows a histogram of a background - subtracted compton asymmetry taken for every electron helicity pair in a single one hour run . the electron beam polarization is continuously monitored by the compton polarimeter during the prex experiment . as we described in section [ sec : intro ] , the electron beam polarization @xmath5 is extracted from the measured experimental asymmetry @xmath6 , the laser polarization @xmath9 and the theoretical asymmetry @xmath8 , according to eq . ( [ eq : cmptasym ] ) . [ fig : lasercycle ] shows the electron beam polarization measurement based on an average of two experimental asymmetry numbers obtained for the left and right laser cycles during a typical run . the average experimental asymmetry corresponding to the left and right laser cycles for this run are -1.59% @xmath77 0.02% ( stat ) and 1.56% @xmath77 0.02% ( stat ) . after taking the value of @xmath8 as 1.825% and using the asymmetry numbers above , the extracted average electron beam polarization for this run is 87.40% @xmath77 0.70% ( stat ) . + finally , after taking into account all the uncertainties in other parameters ( such as laser polarization , theoretical asymmetry , photon detector gain shift etc . ) , the average beam polarization measured by the compton polarimeter during the prex experiment is @xmath90 . it was compared with an independent mller polarimeter measurement made at different times during the run which gave an average @xmath91 @xcite . the observed difference in electron beam polarization is consistent within the systematic errors between the two measurements . the green fabry - perot cavity provided hall a of jlab with a unique laser source to carry out precision compton polarimetry . after combining with the upgraded compton daq and photon detector @xcite , it extends the operating energy range of the previous compton polarimeter @xcite from 3 11 gev to 1 11 gev . high - precision electron beam polarimetry was tested for the first time at jlab with beam energy and current of 1.06 gev and 50 @xmath1a , and achieved its 1.0% precision goal for the prex experiment . the system we developed allows us to obtain a reliable intra - cavity power and stable photon beam polarization for the long - term operation of the upgraded compton polarimeter . the cavity mechanical and locking stability was excellent during the three - month period of the prex experiment , despite the concern of a very high - radiation and acoustically noisy environment in hall a at jlab . the frequency - doubled green laser power was stable indicating that the ppln crystal could withstand high power for an extended period of time . + the frequency locking of the green laser generated by seeding the nd : yag npro laser to the ydfa makes the intra - cavity power scalable . this allows a possibility of boosting the intra - cavity power further ( 10 kw or more at 532 nm ) by increasing the injection power to the cavity provided there is no thermal problem in the cavity mirrors . a higher intra - cavity power may also be achievable by replacing the current cavity mirrors with higher finesse mirrors which is possible with the current feedback electronics . regarding the intra - cavity laser polarization , it is one of the dominant errors in our polarimeter with an uncertainty of 0.7% . it is dominated by our ability to through direct measurement , effects that might alter the polarization over the numerous re - circulations within the cavity . other factors include analyzing power and photon detector gain shift can also affect the systematic errors in the final electron beam polarization @xcite . recent studies at hera @xcite and jlab hall c @xcite show that it is possible to get @xmath3 0.3% level precision for the intra - cavity laser polarization with proposed techniques . so far this result is only based on scattered photon analysis . this measurement could be combined with an independent electron analysis as demonstrated in hall c at jlab with a reported precision of 0.6% @xcite . all of this encourages us that , with a careful and dedicated study , it should be feasible to get @xmath3 0.5% precision at electron beam energies below 2 gev . + future high - precision parity - violating electron scattering experiments at jlab , such as the moller @xcite , pvdis @xcite , prex - ii @xcite , and crex @xcite experiments , also require electron beam polarimetry with sub-1% precision and would rely on the green compton polarimeter we built . this requires an improvement of the current precision by at least a factor of two . finally , a compton polarimeter with a mode - locked pulsed - laser - based optical cavity @xcite would give a much higher signal - to - noise ratio in scattered compton events and would make the system even more robust and efficient , especially in the more noisy electron beam environment expected @xcite after the upgrade of the cebaf energy to 12 gev . the authors wish to thank the hall a technical staff for their assistance in installing the upgraded system and the jlab accelerator division for their efforts to achieve and maintain the high electron beam quality necessary for running the compton polarimeter . this work is supported by doe grants de - ac05 - 06or23177 , under which jefferson science associates , llc , operate jefferson lab , and de - fg02 - 84er40146 . 00 s. abrahamyan _ et al . _ ( prex collaboration ) , phys . rev . lett . , 108 ( 2012 ) 112502 . d. androic _ et al . _ ( qweak collaboration ) , phys . lett . , 111 ( 2013 ) 141803 . d. wang _ et al . _ ( pvdis collaboration ) , nature , 506 ( 2014 ) 7468 . b. wagner _ _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 294 ( 1990 ) 541 . n. sherman , phys . 103 , ( 1956 ) 1601 . m. baylac _ et al . _ , b , 539 ( 2002 ) 8 . a. narayan _ et al . _ , x , 6 ( 2016 ) , 011013 . i. passchier _ _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 414 ( 1998 ) 446 . _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 329 ( 1993 ) 79 . _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 165 ( 1979 ) 177 . sld collaboration , m. woods , the workshop on high energy polarimeters at nikhef , vol . slac - pub-7319 , slac , 1996 . r. zimmermann and w. hillert , proceedings of the international particle accelerator conference , ( 2012 ) 132 . _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 412 ( 1998 ) 1 . n. falletto _ _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 459 ( 2001 ) 412 . lipps , h. a. tolhoek , physica , 20 ( 1954 ) 85 . prescott , slac preprint tn-73 - 1,1973 . z. huang and r. d. ruth , phys . lett . , 80 ( 1998 ) 976 . graves , w. brown , f.x . kaertner , d.e . moncton , nuclear instruments and methods a , 608 ( 2009 ) s103 . i. pupeza _ et al . _ , nature photonics , 7 ( 2013 ) 608 . v. brisson _ _ , j. inst . , 5 ( 2010 ) _ , prog . in part . and nucl . , 55 , ( 2005 ) 332 . s. escoffier _ _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 551 ( 2005 ) 563 . g. bardin _ et al . _ , conceptual design report of a compton polarimeter for cebaf hall a , ( 1996 ) . m. friend _ _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 676 ( 2012 ) 96 . _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 728 ( 2013 ) 92 . a. rakhman , _ phd thesis _ , syracuse university , ( 2011 ) . fejer , g.a . magel , d.h . jundt , and r.l . byer , ieee j. quantum . , 28 ( 1992 ) 2631 . jundt , opt . , 22 ( 1997 ) 1553 . hum , m.m . fejer , c. r. physique , 8 ( 2007 ) 180 . siegman , lasers " , university science books , mill valley , ca , ( 1986 ) . optocad , tracing gaussian tem@xmath37 beams through an optical set - up , http://home.rzg.mpg.de/~ros/optocad.html[http://home.rzg.mpg.de/ ros / optocad.html ] experimental physics and industrial control system , http://www.aps.anl.gov/epics/ w.p . et al . _ , b , 31 ( 1983 ) 97 . m.j . lawrence , b. willke , m.e . husman , e.k . gustafson , and r.l . byer , j. opt . b , 16 ( 1999 ) 523 . j. poirson , f. bretenaker , m. vallet , and a. le floch , j. opt . b , 14 , ( 1997 ) 20811 . a.m. de rival _ et al . instrum . , 67 ( 1996 ) 2680 . g. rempe , r.j . thompson , h.j . kimble , and r. lalezari , opt . lett . , 17 ( 1992 ) 363 . hood , h.j . kimble and j. ye , phys . a , 64 ( 2001 ) 033804 . smith and d.i . shernoff , appl . , 24 ( 1985 ) 1722 . jones , j. opt . am . a , 3 ( 1941 ) 488 . h. hurwitz and r.c . jones , j. opt . a , 31 ( 1941 ) 493 . b.e.a . saleh and m.c . teich , fundamentals of photonics " , wiley - interscience , second edition , ( 2007 ) root program and library , https://root.cern.ch p. micossi , f.d . valle , e. milotti , e. zavattini , c. rizzo , and g. ruoso , appl . b , 57 ( 1993 ) 95 . d. jacob , m. vallet , f. bretenaker , a.l . floch , and m. oger , opt . 20 ( 1995 ) 671 . s. moriwaki , h. sakaida , t. yuzawa , n. mio , appl . b , 65 ( 1997 ) 347 . j.e . logan , n.a . robertson , and j. hough , opt . comm . , 107 ( 1994 ) 342 . w. winkler , a. rdiger , r. schilling , k.a . strain , k. danzmann , opt . , 112 ( 1994 ) 245 . et al . _ , phys . rev . beams , 10 ( 2007 ) 023501 . s. agostinelli _ _ , nuclear instruments and methods a , 506 ( 2003 ) 250 . k.s . et al . _ , an ultra - precise measurement of the weak mixing angle using moller scattering , proposal for jefferson lab pac 34 , ( 2008 ) . _ , precision measurement of parity - violation in deep inelastic scattering over a broad kinematic range , proposal for jefferson lab pac 35 , ( 2009 ) . et al . _ , precision parity - violating measurement of the neutron skin of lead , proposal for jefferson lab pac 38 , ( 2011 ) . j. mammei _ et al . _ , parity - violating measurement of the weak charge distribution of @xmath92ca to 0.02 fm accuracy , proposal for jefferson lab pac 40 , ( 2013 ) . _ , j. inst . , 7 ( 2012 ) p01017 . _ , j. inst . , 7 ( 2012 ) p01021 . j. benesch , g.b . franklin , b.p . quinn and k.d . paschke , phys . rev . beams , 18 ( 2015 ) 112401 .
Abstract: | [
"a high - finesse fabry - perot cavity with a frequency - doubled continuous wave green laser ( 532 nm ) has been built and installed in hall a of jefferson lab for high precision compton polarimetry . the infrared ( 1064 nm ) beam from a ytterbium - doped fiber amplifier seeded by a nd : yag nonplanar ring oscillator laser is frequency doubled in a single - pass periodically poled mgo : linbo@xmath0 crystal . the maximum achieved green power at 5 w infrared pump power is 1.74 w with a total conversion efficiency of 34.8% . the green beam is injected into the optical resonant cavity and enhanced up to 3.7 kw with a corresponding enhancement of 3800 . the polarization transfer function has been measured in order to determine the intra - cavity circular laser polarization within a measurement uncertainty of 0.7% . the prex experiment at jefferson lab used this system for the first time and achieved 1.0% precision in polarization measurements of an electron beam with energy and current of 1.06 gev and 50 @xmath1a . + compton polarimetry , fabry - perot cavity , laser polarization , polarized electron beam"
] | 9,525 | 9,525 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in numerical analysis there exist numerous examples of objects forming a _ group _ , i.e. objects that compose in an associative manner , have an inverse and identity element . typical examples are the group of orthogonal matrices or the group of runge kutta methods . _ semigroups _ , sets of objects close under composition but not inversion , like for instance the set of all matrices and explicit runge kutta methods , are also well studied in literature . however , there are important examples of objects that are neither a group nor a semigroup . one important case is the class of objects closed under a ` sandwich - type ' product , @xmath0 . for example , the collection of all symmetric positive definite matrices and all selfadjoint runge kutta methods . the sandwich - type composition @xmath1 for numerical integrators was studied at length in @xcite and references therein . however , if inverses are well defined , we may wish to replace the sandwich product with the algebraically nicer _ symmetric product _ @xmath2 . spaces closed under such products are called symmetric spaces and are the objects of study in this paper . there is a parallel between the theory of lie groups and that of symmetric spaces . for lie groups , fundamental tools are the lie algebra ( tangent space at the identity , closed under commutation ) and the exponential map from the lie algebra to the lie group . in the theory of symmetric spaces there is a similar notion of tangent space . the resulting object is called a lie triple system ( lts ) , and is closed under _ double commutators _ , @xmath3 $ ] . also in this case , the exponential maps the lts into the symmetric space . an important decomposition theorem is associated with symmetric spaces and lie triple systems : lie algebras can be decomposed into a direct sum of a lts and a subalgebra . the well known splitting of a matrix as a sum of a symmetric and a skew symmetric matrix is an example of such a decomposition , the skew symmetric matrices are closed under commutators , while the symmetric matrices are closed under double commutators . similarly , at the group level , there are decompositions of lie groups into a product of a symmetric space and a lie subgroup . the matrix polar decomposition , where a matrix is written as the product of a symmetric positive definite matrix and an orthogonal matrix is one example . in this paper , we are concerned with the application of such structures to the numerical analysis of differential equations of evolution . the paper is organised as follows : in 2 we review some general theory of symmetric spaces and lie triple systems . applications of this theory in numerical analysis of differential equations are discussed in 3 , which , in turn , can be divided into two parts . in the first ( 3.13.3 ) , we review and discuss the case of differential equations on matrix groups . the properties of these decompositions and numerical algorithms based on them are studied in a series of papers . polar - type decompositions are studied in detail in @xcite , with special emphasis on optimal approximation results . the paper @xcite is concerned with important recurrence relations for polar - type decompositions , similar to the baker - campbell - hausdorff formula for lie groups , while @xcite employ this theory to reduce the implementation costs of numerical methods on lie groups @xcite . we mention that polar - type decompositions are also closely related to the more special root - space decomposition employed in numerical integrators for differential equations on lie groups in @xcite . in @xcite it is shown that the generalized polar decompositions can be employed in cases where the theory of @xcite can not be used . in the second part of 3 ( [ sec:3.3 ] and beyond ) , we will consider the application of this theory to numerical methods for the solution of differential equations with symmetries and reversing symmetries . by backward error analysis , numerical methods can be thought of as exact flows of nearby vector fields . the main goal is then to remove from the numerical method the _ undesired _ part of the error ( either the one destroying the symmetry or the reversing symmetry ) . these error terms in the modified vector field generally consist of complicated derivatives of the vector field itself and are not explicitly calculated , they are just used formally for analysis of the method . in this context , the main tools are compositions at the group level , using the flow of the numerical method and the symmetries / reversing symmetries , together with their inverses . there is a substantial difference between preserving reversing symmetries and symmetries for a numerical method : the first can be always be attained by a finite ( 2 steps ) composition ( scovel projection @xcite ) , the second requires in general an infinite composition . thus symmetries are generally more difficult to retain than reversing symmetries . for the retention of symmetry , we review the thue morse symmetrization technique for arbitrary methods and present a new yoshida - like symmetry retention technique for self - adjoint methods . the latter has always positive intermediate step sizes and can be of interest in the context of stiff problems , which typically require step size restrictions . we illustrate the use of these symmetrisation methods by some numerical experiments . finally , section 4 is devoted to some concluding remarks . in this section we present some background theory for symmetric spaces and lie triple systems . we expect the reader to be familiar with some basic concepts of differential geometry , like manifolds , vector fields , etc . for a more detailed treatment of symmetric spaces we refer the reader to @xcite and @xcite which also constitute the main reference of the material presented in this section . we shall also follow ( unless otherwise mentioned ) the notational convention of @xcite : in particular , @xmath4 is a set ( manifold ) , the letter @xmath5 is reserved for groups and lie groups , gothic letters denote lie algebras and lie triple systems , latin lowercase letters denote lie - group elements and latin uppercase letters denote lie - algebra elements . the identity element of a group will usually be denoted by @xmath6 and the identity mapping by @xmath7 . [ def:2.1 ] a _ symmetric space _ is a manifold @xmath4 with a differentiable _ symmetric product _ @xmath8 obeying the following conditions : * @xmath9 * @xmath10 * @xmath11 and moreover * every @xmath12 has a neighbourhood @xmath13 such that for all @xmath14 in @xmath13 @xmath15 implies @xmath16 . the latter condition is relevant in the case of manifolds @xmath4 with open set topology ( as in the case of lie groups ) and can be disregarded for sets @xmath4 with discrete topology : a discrete set @xmath4 endowed with a multiplication obeying ( i)(iii ) will be also called a symmetric space . a _ pointed symmetric space _ is a pair @xmath17 consisting of a symmetric space @xmath4 and a point @xmath18 called _ base point . _ note that when @xmath4 is a lie group , it is usual to set @xmath19 . moreover , if the group is a _ matrix _ group with the usual matrix multiplication , it is usual to set @xmath20 ( identity matrix ) . the left multiplication with an element @xmath21 is denoted by @xmath22 , @xmath23 and is called _ symmetry around _ @xmath12 . note that @xmath24 because of ( i ) , hence @xmath12 is fixed point of @xmath22 and it is isolated because of ( iv ) . furthermore , ( ii ) and ( iii ) imply @xmath22 is an involutive automorphism of @xmath4 , i.e. @xmath25 . symmetric spaces can be constructed in several different ways , the following are important examples : 1 . [ item:1 ] manifolds with an intrinsically defined symmetric product . as an example , consider the @xmath26-sphere as the set of unit vectors in @xmath27 . the product @xmath28 turns this into a symmetric space . the above operation is the reflection of points on a sphere . this can be generalized to @xmath29-dimensional subspaces in @xmath30 ( @xmath31 ) in the following manner : assume that @xmath32 $ ] is a full rank matrix . define @xmath33 the orthogonal projection operator onto the range of @xmath12 , @xmath34 . consider the reflection @xmath35 . define @xmath36 . this operation obeys the conditions ( i)(vi ) whenever @xmath37 are @xmath38 full rank matrices . in particular , note that ( i ) is equivalent to @xmath39 , i.e. the reflection is an involutive matrix . [ item:2 ] subsets of a continuous ( or discrete ) group @xmath5 that are closed under the composition @xmath40 , where @xmath41 is the usual multiplication in @xmath5 . groups themselves , continuous , as in the case of lie groups , or discrete , are thus particular instances of symmetric spaces . as another example , consider the set of all symmetric positive definite matrices as a subset of all nonsingular matrices , which forms a symmetric space with the product @xmath42 3 . [ item:3 ] symmetric elements of automorphisms on a group . an automorphism on a group @xmath5 is a map @xmath43 satisfying @xmath44 . symmetric elements _ are defined as @xmath45 it is easily verified that @xmath46 obeys ( i)(iv ) when endowed with the multiplication @xmath40 , hence it is a symmetric space . as an example , symmetric matrices are symmetric elements under the matrix automorphism @xmath47 . [ item:4 ] homogeneous manifolds . given a lie group @xmath5 and a subgroup @xmath48 , a homogeneous manifold @xmath49 is the set of all left cosets of @xmath48 in @xmath5 . not every homogeneous manifold possesses a product turning it into a symmetric space , however , we will see in theorem [ th:2.1 ] that any connected symmetric space arises in a natural manner as a homogeneous manifold . [ item:5 ] jordan algebras . let @xmath50 be a finite - dimensional vector space with a bilinear multiplication @xmath51 such that @xmath52 ( powers defined in the usual way , @xmath53 ) , with unit element @xmath6 . define @xmath54 and set @xmath55 . then , the set of _ invertible _ elements of @xmath56 is a symmetric space with the product @xmath57 in the context of symmetric matrices , take @xmath58 , where @xmath41 denotes the usual matrix multiplication . after some algebraic manipulations , one can verify that the product @xmath59 as in example [ item:2 ] . let @xmath5 be a connected lie group and let @xmath60 be an analytic involutive automorphism , i.e. @xmath61 and @xmath62 . let @xmath63 denote @xmath64 , @xmath65 its connected component including the base point , in this case the identity element @xmath6 and finally let @xmath66 be a closed subgroup such that @xmath67 . set @xmath68 . [ th:2.1 ] the homogeneous space @xmath69 is a symmetric space with the product @xmath70 and @xmath71 is a symmetric space with the product @xmath72 . the space of symmetric elements @xmath71 is isomorphic to the homogeneous space @xmath73 . moreover , every connected symmetric space is of the type @xmath74 and also of the type @xmath71 . the interesting consequence of the above theorem is that _ every connected symmetric space _ is also a homogeneous space , which implies a factorization : as coset representatives for @xmath73 one may choose elements of @xmath71 , thus any @xmath75 can be decomposed in a product @xmath76 , where @xmath77 . in other words , @xmath78 the matrix polar decomposition is a particular example , discussed in [ sec:3.1 ] . the automorphism @xmath60 on @xmath5 induces an automorphism on the lie algebra @xmath79 and also a canonical decomposition of @xmath79 . let @xmath80 and @xmath81 denote the lie algebras of @xmath5 and @xmath66 respectively and denote by @xmath82 the differential of @xmath60 at @xmath6 , @xmath83 note that @xmath82 is an involutive automorphism of @xmath79 and has eigenvalues @xmath84 . moreover , @xmath85 implies @xmath86 . set @xmath87 . then , @xmath88 it is easily verified that @xmath89 \subset \gg{k } , \quad { [ \gg{k } , \gg{p } ] } \subset \gg{p } , \quad { [ \gg{p } , \gg{p } ] } \subset \gg{k},\ ] ] that is , @xmath81 is a subalgebra of @xmath79 while @xmath90 is an ideal in @xmath81 . given @xmath91 , its canonical decomposition @xmath92 is @xmath93 , with @xmath94 and @xmath95 , @xmath96 we have already observed that there is close connection between projection matrices , reflections ( involutive matrices ) and hence symmetric spaces . in a linear algebra context , this statement can be formalized as follows . recall that a matrix @xmath97 is a _ projection _ if @xmath98 . [ th : proj ] to any projection matrix @xmath97 there corresponds an involutive matrix @xmath99 . conversely , to any involutive matrix @xmath100 there correspond two projection matrices @xmath101 and @xmath102 . these projections satisfy @xmath103 and @xmath104 , moreover @xmath105 , i.e. the projection @xmath106 projects onto the @xmath84 eigenspace of @xmath100 . note that if @xmath100 is involutive , so is @xmath107 , which corresponds to the opposite identification of the @xmath84 eigenspaces . a matrix @xmath66 , whose columns are in the span of the @xmath108 eigenspace is said to be _ block - diagonal _ with respect to the automorphism , while a matrix @xmath109 , whose columns are in the span of the @xmath110 eigenspace , is said to be _ 2-cyclic_. in the context of lemma [ th : proj ] , we recognize that @xmath94 is the 2-cyclic part and @xmath111 is the block - diagonal part . namely , if @xmath112 is represented by a matrix , then @xmath113 where @xmath114 restricted to the appropriate subspaces . then , @xmath115 and @xmath116 corresponds to the block - diagonal part @xmath66 and @xmath117 corresponding to the 2-cyclic part @xmath109 . in passing , we mention that the decomposition ( [ eq:2.3 ] ) is called a _ cartan decomposition _ whenever the cartan killing form @xmath118 is nondegenerate , hence it can be used to introduce a positive bilinear form @xmath119 . if this is the case , the linear subspaces @xmath120 are orthogonal . the involutive automorphism @xmath60 need not be defined at the group level @xmath5 and thereafter lifted to the algebra by ( [ eq:2.1 ] ) . it is possible to proceed the other way around : an involutive algebra automorphism @xmath82 on @xmath79 , which automatically produces a decomposition ( [ eq:2.2])-([eq:2.3 ] ) , can be used to induce a group automorphism @xmath60 by the relation @xmath121 and a corresponding group factorization ( [ eq : polardecomp ] ) . thus , we have an `` upstairs - downstairs '' viewpoint : the group involutive automorphisms generate corresponding algebra automorphisms and vice versa . this `` upstairs - downstairs '' view is useful : in some cases , the group factorization ( [ eq : polardecomp ] ) is difficult to compute starting from @xmath12 and @xmath60 , while the splitting at the algebra level might be easy to compute from @xmath112 and @xmath82 . in other cases , it might be the other way around . in lie group theory lie algebras are important since they describe infinitesimally the structure of the tangent space at the identity . similarly , lie triple systems give the structure of the tangent space of a symmetric space . [ sec:2.2 ] ( @xcite ) [ def:2.2 ] a vector space with a trilinear composition @xmath122 $ ] is called a _ lie triple system _ ( lts ) if the following identities are satisfied : * @xmath123=0 $ ] , * @xmath122+[y , z , x ] + [ z , x , y ] = 0 $ ] , * @xmath124 = [ [ x , y , u ] , v , w ] + [ u , [ x , y , v],w ] + [ u , v,[x , y , w]]$ ] . a typical way to construct a lts is by means of an involutive automorphism of a lie algebra @xmath79 . with the same notation as above , the set @xmath90 is a lts with the composition @xmath125 = [ [ x , y ] , z].\ ] ] vice versa , for every lts there exists a lie algebra @xmath126 and an involutive automorphism @xmath60 such that the given lts corresponds to @xmath90 . the algebra @xmath126 is called _ standard embedding _ of the lts . in general , any subset of @xmath79 that is closed under the operator @xmath127 \label{eq : t_x}\ ] ] is a lie triple system . it can be shown that being closed under @xmath128 guarantees being closed under the triple commutator . let @xmath129 be the group of @xmath130 invertible matrices . consider the map @xmath131 it is clear that @xmath60 is an involutive automorphism of @xmath129 . then , according to theorem [ th:2.1 ] , the set of symmetric elements @xmath132 is a symmetric space . we observe that @xmath71 is the set of invertible symmetric matrices . the symmetric space @xmath71 is disconnected and particular mention deserves its connected component containing the identity matrix @xmath133 , since it reduces to the set of symmetric positive definite matrices . the subgroup @xmath63 consists of all orthogonal matrices . the decomposition ( [ eq : polardecomp ] ) is the classical polar decomposition , any nonsingular matrix can be written as a product of a symmetric matrix and an orthogonal matrix . if we restrict the symmetric matrix to the symmetric positive definite ( spd ) matrices , then the decomposition is unique . in standard notation , @xmath134 is denoted by @xmath135 ( spd matrix ) , while @xmath136 is denoted by @xmath137 ( orthogonal matrix ) . at the algebra level , the corresponding splitting is @xmath138 , where @xmath139 is the classical algebra of skew - symmetric matrices , while @xmath140 is the classical set of symmetric matrices . the latter is not a subalgebra of @xmath141 but is closed under @xmath128 , hence is a lie triple system . the decomposition ( [ eq : algebrasplitting ] ) is nothing else than the canonical decomposition of a matrix into its skew - symmetric and symmetric part , @xmath142 it is well known that the polar decomposition @xmath143 can be characterized in terms of best approximation properties . the orthogonal part @xmath137 is the best orthogonal approximation of @xmath12 in any orthogonally invariant norm ( e.g. 2-norm and frobenius norm ) . other classical polar decompositions @xmath144 , with @xmath135 hermitian and @xmath137 unitary , or with @xmath135 real and @xmath137 coinvolutory ( i.e. @xmath145 ) , can also be fitted in this framework @xcite with the choice of automorphisms @xmath146 ( hermitian adjoint ) , and @xmath147 respectively ( where @xmath148 denotes the complex conjugate of @xmath12 ) . the group decomposition @xmath144 can also be studied via the algebra decomposition . in @xcite such decompositions are generalized to arbitrary involutive automorphisms , and best approximation properties are established for the general case . clearly , also other types of automorphisms can be considered , generalizing the group factorization ( [ eq : polardecomp ] ) and the algebra splitting ( [ eq : algebrasplitting ] ) . for instance , there is a large source of involutive automorphisms in the set of involutive _ inner automorphisms _ @xmath154 that can be applied to subgroups of @xmath155 to obtain a number of interesting factorizations . the matrix @xmath156 has to be involutive , @xmath157 , but it need not be in the group : the factorization makes sense as long as @xmath158 is in the group ( resp . @xmath159 is in the algebra ) . as an example , let @xmath160 be the group of orthogonal matrices , and let @xmath161 = i - 2 e_1 e_1^t$ ] , where @xmath162 denotes the @xmath163th canonical unit vector in @xmath30 . obviously , @xmath164 , as @xmath165 ; nevertheless , we have @xmath166 , as long as @xmath167 , since @xmath168 and @xmath169 , thus @xmath170 . it is straightforward to verify that the subgroup @xmath63 of theorem [ th:2.1 ] consists of all orthogonal @xmath171 matrices of the form @xmath172 where @xmath173 . thus the corresponding symmetric space is @xmath174 . matrices belong to the same coset if their first column coincide , thus the symmetric space can be identified with the @xmath175-sphere @xmath176 . the corresponding splitting of a skew - symmetric matrix @xmath177 is @xmath178 thus any orthogonal matrix can be expressed as the product of the exponential of a matrix in @xmath90 and one in @xmath81 . the space @xmath90 can be identified with the tangent space to the sphere in the point @xmath179 . different choices of @xmath156 give different interesting algebra splittings and corresponding group factorizations . for instance , by choosing @xmath156 to be the anti - identity , @xmath180 $ ] , one obtains an algebra splitting in _ persymmetric _ and _ perskew - symmetric _ matrices . the choice @xmath181 $ ] for symplectic matrices , gives the splitting in lower - dimensional symplectic matrices forming a sub - algebra and a lie - triple system , and so on . in @xcite , such splittings are used for the efficient approximation of the exponential of skew - symmetric , symplectic and zero - trace matrices . in @xcite similar ideas are used to construct computationally effective numerical integrators for differential equations on stiefel and grassman manifolds . a similar framework can be used to obtain coordinates on lie groups @xcite , which are of interest when solving differential equations of the type @xmath182 by reducing the problem recursively to spaces of smaller dimension . recall that @xmath183 where @xmath184 obeys the differential equation @xmath185 , where @xmath186 , @xmath187 being the @xmath188th bernoulli number , see @xcite . decomposing @xmath189 , where @xmath190 , the solution can be factorized as @xmath191 where @xmath192 + \sum_{j=1}^\infty 2^{2j } c_{2j } \mathrm{ad}^{2j}_p \pi^{-}x , \quad c_{2j}=\frac{b_{2j}}{(2j ) ! } , \label{eq : pdot } \\ \dot k & = & \mathrm{dexp}^{-1}_k ( \pi^{+}x - 2 \sum_{j=1}^\infty ( 2^{2j}-1 ) c_{2j } \mathrm{ad}^{2j-1}_p \pi^{-}x ) . \label{eq : kdot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that ( [ eq : kdot ] ) depends on @xmath109 , however , it is possible to formulate it solely in terms of @xmath66 , @xmath193 and @xmath194 , but the expression becomes less neat . in block form : @xmath195 where @xmath196 . the above formula paves the road for a recursive decomposition , by recognizing that @xmath197 is the @xmath198 function on the restricted sub - algebra @xmath199 . by introducing a sequence of involutive automorphisms @xmath200 , one induces a sequence of subalgebras , @xmath201 , of decreasing dimention , @xmath202 . note also that the functions appearing in the above formulation are all analytic functions of the @xmath203-operator , and are either odd or even functions , therefore they can be expressed as functions of @xmath204 on @xmath205 . in particular , this means that , as long as we can compute analytic functions of the @xmath204 operator , the above decomposition is computable . thus , the problem is reduced to the computation of analytic functions of the 2-cyclic part @xmath109 as well as analytic functions of @xmath206 ( trivialized tangent maps and their inverse ) . the following theorem addresses the computation of such functions using the same framework of lemma [ th : proj ] . let @xmath109 be the 2-cyclic part of @xmath207 with respect to the involution @xmath100 , i.e. @xmath208 . let @xmath209 . for any analytic function @xmath210 , we have @xmath211 where @xmath212 and @xmath213 . a similar result holds for @xmath206 , see @xcite . it is interesting to remark that if @xmath214 then @xmath215 where @xmath216 as above . in particular , the problem is reduced to computing analytic functions of the principal square root of a matrix @xcite : numerical methods that compute these quantities accurately and efficiently are very important for competitive numerical algorithms . typically , @xmath217 is a low - rank matrix , hence computations can be done using eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the @xmath203 operator restricted to the appropriate space , see @xcite . in particular , if @xmath218 are vectors , then @xmath219 is a scalar and the formulas become particularly simple . these coordinates have interesting applications in control theory . some early use of these generalized cartan decompositions ( [ eq:2.2])([eq:2.3 ] ) ( which the author calls @xmath220-_grading _ ) to problems with nonholonomic constraints can be found in @xcite . in @xcite , the authors embrace the formalism of symmetric spaces and use orthogonal ( cartan ) decompositions with applications to nmr spectroscopy and quantum computing , using adjoint orbits as main tool . generally , these decompositions can be found in the literature , but have been applied mostly to the cases when @xmath221=\{0\ } $ ] or @xmath222=\{0\ } $ ] , or both , as ( [ eq : pdot])-([eq : kdot ] ) become very simple and the infinite sums reduce to one or two terms . the main contribution of @xcite is the derivation of such differential equations _ and _ the evidence that such equations can be solved efficiently using linear algebra tools . see also @xcite for some applications to control theory . let @xmath223 be the group of diffeomorphisms of a manifold @xmath4 onto itself . we say that a map @xmath224 has a symmetry @xmath225 if @xmath226 ( the multiplication indicating the usual composition of maps , i.e. @xmath227 ) , while if @xmath228 we say that @xmath229 is a reversing symmetry of @xmath230 @xcite . without further ado , we restrict ourselves to involutory symmetries , the main subject of this paper . symmetries and reversing symmetries are very important in the context of dynamical systems and their numerical integration . for instance , nongeneric bifurcations can become generic in the presence of symmetries and vice versa . thus , when using the integration time - step as a bifurcation parameter , it is vitally important to remain within the smallest possible class of systems . reversing symmetries , on the other hand , give rise to the existence of invariant tori and invariant cylinders @xcite . it is a classical result that the set of symmetries possess the structure of a group they behave like automorphisms and fixed sets of automorphisms . the group structure , however , does not extend to reversing symmetries and fixed points of anti - automorphisms , and in the last few years the set of reversing symmetries has received the attention of numerous numerical analysts . in @xcite it was observed that the set of fixed points of an involutive anti - automorphism @xmath231 was closed under the operation @xmath232 that mclachlan et al . called `` sandwich product . '' pseudogroup_. ] indeed , our initial goal was to understand such structures and investigate how they could be used to devise new numerical integrators for differential equations with some special geometric properties . we recognise , cfr . [ sec:2.1 ] , that the set of fixed points of an anti - automorphism is a symmetric space . conversely , any connected space of invertible elements closed under the `` sandwich product '' , is the set of the fixed points of an involutive automorphism ( cfr . theorem [ th:2.1 ] ) and has associated to it a lts . to show this , consider the well known symmetric bch formula , @xmath233 @xcite , which is used extensively in the context of _ splitting methods _ @xcite . because of the sandwich - type composition ( symmetric space structure ) , the corresponding @xmath234 must be in the lts space , and this explains why it can be written as powers of the double commutator operators @xmath235 applied to @xmath112 and @xmath236 . a natural question to ask is : what is the automorphism @xmath60 having such sandwich - type composition as anti - fixed points ? as @xmath237 , we see that , by writing @xmath238 , we have @xmath239 . in the context of numerical integrators , the automorphism @xmath60 consists in changing the time @xmath240 to @xmath241 . this will be proved in [ sec:3.4 ] . if @xmath4 is a finite dimensional smooth compact manifold , it is well known that the infinite dimensional group of @xmath223 of all smooth diffeomorphisms @xmath242 is a lie group , with lie algebra @xmath243 of all smooth vector fields on @xmath4 , with the usual bracket and exponential map . it should be noted , however , that the exponential map is not a one - to - one map , not even in the neighbourhood the identity element , since there exist diffeomorphisms arbitrary close to the identity which are not on any one - parameter subgroup and others which are on many . however , the regions where the exponential map is not surjective become smaller and smaller the closer we approach the identity @xcite , and , for our purpose , we can disregard these regions and assume that our results are formally true . there are two different settings that we can consider in this context . the first is to analyze the set of differentiable maps that possess a certain symmetry ( or a discrete set of symmetries ) . the second is to consider the structure of the set of symmetries of a fixed diffeomorphism . the first has a continuous - type structure while the second is more often a discrete type symmetric space . [ th:3.4 ] the set of diffeomorphisms @xmath230 that possess @xmath229 as an ( involutive ) reversing symmetry is a symmetric space of the type @xmath71 . denote @xmath244 it is clear that @xmath60 acts as an automorphism , @xmath245 moreover , if @xmath229 is an involution then so is also @xmath60 . note that the set of diffeomorphisms @xmath230 that possess @xmath229 as a reversing symmetry is the space of symmetric elements @xmath246 defined by the automorphism @xmath60 ( cfr . [ sec:2 ] ) . hence the result follows from theorem [ th:2.1 ] . [ th:3.4b ] the set of reversing symmetries acting on a diffeomorphism @xmath230 is a symmetric space with the composition @xmath247 . if @xmath248 is a symmetry of @xmath230 then so is also @xmath249 , since @xmath250 and the assertion follows by taking the inverse on both sides of the equality . in particular , if @xmath248 is a symmetry of @xmath230 it is also true that @xmath251 is a reversing symmetry of @xmath252 . next , we observe that if @xmath248 and @xmath253 are two reversing symmetries of @xmath230 then so is also @xmath254 , since @xmath255 it follows that the composition @xmath256 is an internal operation on the set of reversing symmetries of a diffeomorphism @xmath230 . with the above multiplication , the conditions i)iii ) of definition [ def:2.1 ] are easily verified . this proves the assertion in the case when @xmath257 has a discrete set of reversing symmetries . in what follows , we assume that @xmath258 is differentiable and involutory ( @xmath259 ) and @xmath260 . acting on @xmath261 , we have @xmath262 where @xmath263 is the tangent map of @xmath264 . the pullback is natural with respect to the jacobi bracket , @xmath265 = \mathcal{t } _ * [ x , y ] \mathcal{t},\ ] ] for all vector fields @xmath266 . hence the map @xmath82 is an involutory algebra automorphism . let @xmath267 and @xmath90 be the eigenspaces of @xmath82 in @xmath268 . then @xmath269 where @xmath270 is the lie algebra of vector fields that have @xmath264 as a symmetry and @xmath271 is the lie triple system , vector fields corresponding to maps that have @xmath264 as a reversing symmetry . thus , as is the case for matrices , every vector field @xmath112 can be split into two parts , @xmath272 having @xmath264 as a symmetry and reversing symmetry respectively . in the context of ordinary differential equation , let us consider @xmath273 given an arbitrary involutive function @xmath264 , the vector field @xmath274 can always be canonically split into two components , having @xmath275 as a symmetry and reversing symmetry respectively . however , if one of these components equals zero , then the system ( [ eq:3.3 ] ) has @xmath264 as a symmetry or a reversing symmetry . let us consider the ode ( [ eq:3.3 ] ) , whose exact flow will be denoted as @xmath276 . backward error analysis for odes implies that a ( consistent ) numerical method for the integration of ( [ eq:3.3 ] ) can be interpreted as the sampling at @xmath277 of the flow @xmath278 of a vector field @xmath279 ( the so called _ modified vector field _ ) which is close to @xmath274 , @xmath280 where @xmath134 is the order of the method ( note that setting @xmath277 , the local truncation error is of order @xmath281 ) . consider next the map @xmath60 on the set of flows depending on the parameter @xmath282 defined as @xmath283 where @xmath284 , with @xmath285 . the map @xmath60 is involutive , since @xmath286 , and it is easily verified by means of the bch formula that @xmath287 , hence @xmath60 is an automorphism . consider next @xmath288 then @xmath289 if and only if @xmath290 , namely the method @xmath291 is _ selfadjoint_. the set of one - parameter , consistent , selfadjoint numerical schemes is a symmetric space in the sense of theorem [ th:2.1 ] , generated by @xmath60 as in ( [ eq:3.4 ] ) . next , we perform the decomposition ( [ eq:2.2 ] ) . we deduce from ( [ eq:3.4 ] ) that @xmath292 hence , @xmath293 is the subalgebra of vector fields that are odd in @xmath282 , and @xmath294 is the lts of vector fields that possess only even powers of @xmath282 . thus , if @xmath279 is the modified vector field of a numerical integrator @xmath291 , its canonical decomposition in @xmath295 is @xmath296 the first term containing only odd powers of @xmath282 and the second only even powers . then , if the numerical method @xmath297 is selfadjoint , it contains only odd powers of @xmath282 locally ( in perfect agreement with classical results on selfadjoint methods @xcite ) . in @xcite it has been shown that it is possible to generalize the polar decomposition of matrices to lie groups endowed with an involutive automorphism : every lie group element @xmath298 sufficiently close to the identity can be decomposed as @xmath299 where @xmath300 , the space of symmetric elements of @xmath60 , and @xmath301 , the subgroup of @xmath5 of elements fixed under @xmath60 . furthermore , setting @xmath302 and @xmath303 , one has that @xmath304 is an odd function of @xmath240 and it is a best approximant to @xmath298 in @xmath63 in @xmath63 right - invariant norms constructed by means of the cartan killing form , provided that @xmath5 is semisimple and that the decomposition @xmath305 is a cartan decomposition . assume that @xmath230 , the exact flow of the differential equation ( [ eq:3.3 ] ) , has @xmath229 as a reversing symmetry ( i.e. @xmath306 , where @xmath307 ) , while its approximation @xmath308 has not . we perform the polar decomposition @xmath309 i.e. @xmath310 has @xmath311 as a reversing symmetry , while @xmath312 has @xmath229 as a symmetry . since the original flow has @xmath311 as a reversing symmetry ( and not symmetry ) , @xmath313 is the factor that we wish to eliminate . we have @xmath314 . hence the method obtained composing @xmath308 with @xmath315 has the reversing symmetry @xmath229 every other step . to obtain @xmath310 we need to extract the square root of the flow @xmath316 . now , if @xmath317 is a flow , then its square root is simply @xmath318 . however , if @xmath319 is the flow of a consistent numerical method ( @xmath320 ) , namely the numerical integrator corresponds to @xmath321 , it is not possible to evaluate the square root @xmath322 by simple means as it is not the same as the numerical method with half the stepsize , @xmath323 . the latter , however , offers an approximation to the square root : note that @xmath324 an expansion which , compared with @xmath321 , reveals that the error in approximating the square root with the numerical method with half the stepsize is of the order of @xmath325 a term that is subsumed in the local truncation error . the choice @xmath326 as an approximation to @xmath310 ( we stress that each flow is now evaluated at @xmath327 ) , yields a map that has the reversing symmetry @xmath275 at each step by design , since @xmath328 note that @xmath329 , where @xmath330 is the inverse ( or adjoint ) method of @xmath331 . if @xmath60 is given by ( [ eq:3.4 ] ) , then @xmath332 and this algorithm is precisely the _ scovel projection _ @xcite originally proposed to to generate selfadjoint numerical schemes from an arbitrary integrator , and then generalized to the context of reversing symmetries @xcite . [ th:3.5 ] the generalized scovel projection is equivalent to choosing the @xmath246-factor in the polar decomposition of a flow @xmath291 under the involutive automorphism @xmath333 , whereby square roots of flows are approximated by numerical methods with half the stepsize . another algorithm that can be related to the generalized polar decomposition of flows is the application of the thue morse sequence to improve the preservation of symmetries by means of a numerical integrator @xcite . given an involutive automorphism @xmath334 and a numerical method @xmath291 in a group @xmath5 of numerical integrators , iserles et al . @xcite construct the sequence of methods @xmath335 } : = \varphi_h , \quad \varphi^{[k+1 ] } : = \varphi^{[k ] } \sigma ( \varphi^{[k ] } ) , \qquad k=0,1 , 2,\ldots . \label{eq : thue}\ ] ] since @xmath336 } = \sigma^0 \varphi^{[k]}$ ] , it is easily observed that the @xmath136-th method corresponds to composing @xmath337}$ ] and @xmath338}$ ] according to the @xmath136-th thue morse sequence @xmath339 , as displayed below in table [ tab:3.1 ] ( see @xcite ) . .thue morse iterations for the method @xmath336}$ ] . [ cols="^,<,<",options="header " , ] iserles et al . ( @xcite ) showed , by a recursive use of the bch formula , that each iteration improves by one order the preservation of the symmetry @xmath340 by a consistent numerical method , where @xmath340 is the involutive automorphism such that @xmath341 . the main argument of the proof is that if the method @xmath342}$ ] has a given symmetry error , the symmetry error of @xmath343})$ ] has the opposite sign . hence the two leading symmetry errors cancel and @xmath344}$ ] has a symmetry error of one order higher . in other words , if the method @xmath291 preserves @xmath345 to order @xmath134 , then @xmath336}$ ] preserves the symmetry @xmath345 to order @xmath346 every @xmath347 steps . as @xmath60 changes the sign of the symmetry error only , if a method @xmath291 has a given approximation order @xmath134 , so does @xmath348 . thus @xmath349 } = \sigma ( \varphi_h)$ ] can be used as initial condition in ( [ eq : thue ] ) , obtaining the conjugate thue morse sequence @xmath350 . by a similar argument , also @xmath351 } : = \varphi_h \hbox { or } \chi^{[0 ] } : = \sigma(\varphi_h ) , \quad \chi^{[k+1 ] } : = \sigma ( \chi^{[k ] } ) \chi^{[k ] } , \qquad k=0,1 , 2,\ldots , \label{eq : thue_compl}\ ] ] generate sequences with increasing order of preservation of symmetry . as an illustration of the technique , consider the spatial pde @xmath352 , where @xmath353 is analytic in @xmath354 . let the pde be defined over the domain @xmath355\times[-l , l]$ ] with periodic boundary conditions and initial value @xmath356 . if @xmath356 is symmetric on the domain , i.e. @xmath357 , so is the solution for all @xmath240 . the symmetry is @xmath358 . now , assume that we solve the equation by the method of alternating directions , where the method @xmath230 corresponds to solving with respect to the @xmath12 variable keeping @xmath14 fixed , while @xmath359 with respect to the @xmath14 variable keeping @xmath12 fixed . the symmetry will typically be broken at the first step . nevertheless , we can get a much more symmetric solution if the sequence of the directions obeys the thue morse sequence ( iteration @xmath336}$ ] ) or the equivalent sequence given by iteration @xmath360}$ ] . this example is illustrated in figures [ fig : alt_dir]-[fig : alt_dir2 ] . for the method of alternating directions for the pde @xmath361 , on a square , with initial condition @xmath362 and periodic boundary conditions . the integration is performed using the first order method @xmath363 ( forward euler ) , where @xmath364 is a circulant divided difference discretization matrix of the differential operators @xmath365 ( second order central differences ) . the experiments are performed with constant stepsize @xmath366 . the order of the overall approximation is the same as the original method ( first order only ) , the only difference is the order of the directions , chosen according to the thue morse sequence . the different symbols correspond to different sampling rates : every step , every second step , fourth , eight , . from top left to bottom right : sequences 0 , 01 , 0110 , 01101001 , etc . ] versus step size @xmath282 for the method of alternating directions for the pde @xmath367 , as above . the basic method @xmath230 ( method 0 " ) is now a symmetric composition with the heun method : half step in the @xmath12 direction , full step in the @xmath14 direction , half step in the @xmath12 direction , all of them performed with the heun method ( improved euler ) . it is immediately observed that the symmetry error is improved by choosing the directions according to the thue morse sequence . the order of the method ( global error ) remains unchanged ( order two ) . ] in a famous paper that appeared in 1990 ( @xcite ) yoshida showed how to construct high order time - symmetric integrators starting from lower order time - symmetric symplectic ones . yoshida showed that , if @xmath230 is a selfadjoint numerical integrator of order @xmath368 , then @xmath369 is a selfadjoint numerical method of order @xmath370 provided that the coefficients @xmath371 and @xmath372 satisfy the condition @xmath373 whose only real solution is @xmath374 in the formalism of this paper , time - symmetric methods correspond to @xmath71-type elements with @xmath60 as in ( [ eq:3.4 ] ) and it is clearly seen that the yoshida technique can be used in general to improve the order of approximation of @xmath246-type elements . a similar procedure can be applied to improve the order of the retention of symmetries and not just reversing symmetries . to be more specific , let @xmath375 be a symmetry of the given differential equation , namely @xmath376 , with @xmath377 , @xmath378 , @xmath379 denoting the pullback of @xmath340 to @xmath380 ( see [ sec:3.3 ] ) . here , the involutive automorphism is given by @xmath381 so that @xmath382 [ prop : yoshida_self ] assume that @xmath383 is the flow of a self - adjoint numerical method of order @xmath368 , @xmath384 , @xmath385 , where @xmath386 , @xmath387 and @xmath274 has @xmath388 as a symmetry . the composition @xmath389}_{h}(t ) = \varphi_{ah}(at ) \sigma(\varphi_{bh}(bt ) ) \varphi_{ah}(at ) , \label{eq : yoshida.2}\ ] ] with @xmath390 has symmetry error @xmath370 at @xmath277 . write ( [ eq : yoshida.2 ] ) as @xmath389}_{h}(t ) = \exp(at f_{ah } ) \exp(bt \d\sigma(f_{bh } ) ) \exp(atf_{ah}).\ ] ] application of the symmetric bch formula , together with the fact that @xmath82 acts by changing the signs on the @xmath90-components only , allows us to write the relation ( [ eq : yoshida.2 ] ) as @xmath391}_{h}(t ) & = & \exp((2a+b)t f + ( 2(at)(ah)^{2p } + ( bt ) ( bh)^{2p } ) k_{2p } \label{eq : yoshida.3 } \\ & & \qquad \mbox { } + ( 2at(ah)^{2p}-bt(bh)^{2p})p_{2p } + \oo{th^{2p+2 } } + \oo{t^{3}h^{2p } } + \cdots ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath392 comes from the @xmath393 term and the @xmath394 from the commutation of the @xmath274 and @xmath395 terms ( recall that no first order commutator appears in the symmetric bch formula ) . the numerical method is obtained letting @xmath277 . we require @xmath396 for consistency , and @xmath397 to annihilate the coefficient of @xmath398 , the lowest order @xmath90-term . the resulting method @xmath399}_{h}(t)$ ] retains the symmetry @xmath340 to order @xmath370 , as the first leading symmetry error is a @xmath400 term . this procedure allows us to gain two extra degrees in the retention of symmetry per iteration , provided that the underlying method is selfadjoint , compared with the thue morse sequence of @xcite that yields one extra degree in symmetry per iteration but does not require selfadjointness . as for the yoshida technique , the composition ( [ eq : yoshida.2 ] ) can be iterated @xmath136 times to obtain a time - symmetric method of order @xmath368 that retains symmetry to order @xmath401 . the disadvantage of ( [ eq : yoshida.2 ] ) , with respect to the classical yoshida approach is the fact that the order of the method is retained ( and does not increase by 2 units as the symmetry error ) . the main advantage is that all the steps are positive , in particular the second step , @xmath402 , whereas the @xmath372 is always negative for @xmath403 and typically larger than @xmath371 , requiring step - size restrictions for stiff methods . in the limit , when @xmath404 , @xmath405 , i.e. the step lengths become equal . thus , the proposed technique for improving symmetry is of particular interest in the context of stiff problems . this is illustrated by the following example and figure [ fig : stiff ] . [ ex:1 ] consider the pde @xmath406 , defined on the square @xmath407\times [ -1,1]$ ] , with a gaussian initial condition , @xmath408 , and periodic boundary conditions . the problem is semi - discretized on a uniform and isotropic mesh with spacing @xmath409 and is reduced to the set of odes @xmath410 , where @xmath411 and @xmath412 , @xmath413 being the circulant matrix of the standard second order divided differences , with stencil @xmath414 $ ] . for the time integration , we consider the splitting @xmath415 , where @xmath416 and @xmath417 and the second order self - adjoint method : @xmath418 we display the global error and the symmetry error for time - integration step sizes @xmath419 $ ] , where the parameter @xmath420 is chosen to be the largest step size for which the basic method @xmath230 in ( [ eq : pde ] ) is stable . the factor @xmath421 comes from the fact that both the yoshida and our symmetrization method ( [ eq : yoshida.2 ] ) require 3 sub - steps of the basic method . so , one step of the yoshida and our symmetrising composition can be expected to cost the same as the basic method ( [ eq : pde ] ) . as we can see in figure [ fig : stiff ] , the yoshida technique , with @xmath422 and @xmath423 , does the job of increasing the order of accuracy of the method from two to four , and so does the symmetry error . however , since @xmath424 , the @xmath372-step is negative , and , as a consequence , it is observed that the method fails to converge for the two largest values of the step size . conversely , our symmetrization method ( [ eq : yoshida.2 ] ) has @xmath425 and @xmath426 , with @xmath402 positive , and the method converges for all the time - integration steps . as expected , the order is not improved , but the symmetry order is improved by two units . the symmetry @xmath60 is applied by transposing the matrix representation @xmath427 of the solution at @xmath428 , before and after the intermediate @xmath402-step . otherwise , the two implementations are identical . ) ( right ) for the basic self - adjoint method ( [ eq : pde ] ) applied to a semidiscretization of @xmath406 . the order with the yoshida techique increases by two units , but the method does not converge for the two largest values of the step size . our symmetrization technique improves by two units the order of retention of symmetry ( but not global error ) . due to the positive step - sizes , it converges also for the two largest values of the step size . see text for details.,title="fig : " ] ) ( right ) for the basic self - adjoint method ( [ eq : pde ] ) applied to a semidiscretization of @xmath406 . the order with the yoshida techique increases by two units , but the method does not converge for the two largest values of the step size . our symmetrization technique improves by two units the order of retention of symmetry ( but not global error ) . due to the positive step - sizes , it converges also for the two largest values of the step size . see text for details.,title="fig : " ] in this paper we have shown that the algebraic structure of lie triple systems and the factorization properties of symmetric spaces can be used as a tool to : 1 ) understand and provide a unifying approach to the analysis of a number of different algorithms ; and 2 ) devise new algorithms with special symmetry / reversing symmetry properties in the context of the numerical solution of differential equations . in particular , we have seen that symmetries are more difficult to retain ( to date , we are not aware of methods that can retain a generic involutive symmetry in a finite number of steps ) , while the situation is simpler for reversing symmetries , which can be achieved in a finite number of steps using the scovel composition . so far , we have considered the most generic setting where the only allowed operations are non - commutative compositions of maps ( the map @xmath230 , its transformed , @xmath359 , and their inverses ) . if the underlying space is linear and so is the symmetry , i.e. @xmath429 , the map @xmath430 obviously satisfies the symmetry @xmath60 , as @xmath431 . because of the linearity and the vector - space property , we can use the same operation as in the tangent space , namely we identify @xmath60 and @xmath432 . this is in fact the most common symmetrization procedure for linear symmetries in linear spaces . for instance , in the context of the alternating - direction examples , a common way to resolve the symmetry issue is to first solve , say , the @xmath12 and the @xmath14 direction , solve the @xmath14 and the @xmath12 direction with the same initial condition , and then average the two results . in this paper we did not mention the use and the development of similar concepts in a more strict linear algebra setting . some recent works deal with the further understanding of scalar products and structured factorizations , and more general computation of matrix functions preserving group structures , see for instance @xcite and references therein . some of these topics are covered by other contributions in the present bit issue , which we strongly encourage the reader to read to get a more complete picture of the topic and its applications . * acknowledgements . * h.m .- k . , g.r.w.q . and a.z . wish to thank the norwegian research council and the australian research council for financial support . special thanks to yuri nikolayevsky who gave us important pointers to the literature on symmetric spaces . j. c. scovel . symplectic numerical integration of hamiltonian systems . in tudor ratiu , editor , _ the geometry of hamiltonian systems _ , volume 22 , pages 463496 . msri , springer - verlag , new york , 1991 . symplectic numerical integration of hamiltonian systems .
Abstract: | [
"a remarkable number of different numerical algorithms can be understood and analyzed using the concepts of symmetric spaces and lie triple systems , which are well known in differential geometry from the study of spaces of constant curvature and their tangents . this theory can be used to unify a range of different topics , such as polar - type matrix decompositions , splitting methods for computation of the matrix exponential , composition of selfadjoint numerical integrators and dynamical systems with symmetries and reversing symmetries . the thread of this paper is the following : involutive automorphisms on groups induce a factorization at a group level , and a splitting at the algebra level . in this paper we will give an introduction to the mathematical theory behind these constructions , and review recent results . furthermore , we present a new yoshida - like technique , for self - adjoint numerical schemes , that allows to increase the order of preservation of symmetries by two units . since all the time - steps are positive , the technique is particularly suited to stiff problems , where a negative time - step can cause instabilities ."
] | 9,080 | 9,080 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: high - energy heavy - ion collisions can produce a hot , dense , and deconfined nuclear medium , dubbed the quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) . the thermodynamic states of a qgp can be specified by the axial chemical potential @xmath0 , besides the temperature @xmath1 and the vector chemical potential @xmath2 . @xmath0 characterizes the imbalance of right - handed and left - handed fermions in a system , and a _ chiral _ system bears a nonzero @xmath0 . chiral domains may be created locally in heavy - ion collisions through various mechanisms on an event - by - event basis ( e.g. topological fluctuations in the gluonic sector , glasma flux tubes , or fluctuations in the quark sector ) @xcite . in a noncentral collision , a strong magnetic field ( @xmath3 t ) can be produced ( mostly by energetic spectator protons ) @xcite , and will induce an electric current along @xmath4 in chiral domains , @xmath5 , which is called the chiral magnetic effect ( cme ) @xcite . on average , @xmath4 is perpendicular to the so - called reaction plane ( @xmath6 ) that contains the impact parameter and the beam momenta , as depicted in fig . [ fig : overlap ] . hence the cme will manifest a charge transport across the reaction plane . in the presence of the cme and other modes of collective motions , we can fourier decompose the azimuthal distribution of particles of given transverse momentum ( @xmath7 ) and pseudorapidity ( @xmath8 ) : 1 + 2v_1 , ( ) + 2v_2,(2 ) + ... + 2a_1 , ( ) + ... , [ equ : fourier_expansion ] where @xmath9 is the azimuthal angle of a particle , and @xmath10 . here the subscript @xmath11 ( @xmath12 or @xmath13 ) denotes the charge sign of the particle . conventionally @xmath14 is called directed flow " and @xmath15 elliptic flow " @xcite . the parameter @xmath16 ( with @xmath17 ) quantifies the electric charge separation due to the cme . an anomalous transport effect can also occur when a chiral system undergoes a global rotation . the fluid rotation can be quantified by a vorticity @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the flow velocity field . for a given vorticity @xmath20 , the chiral vortical effect ( cve ) induces a vector current @xmath21 @xcite . while the cme is driven by @xmath4 , the cve is driven by @xmath22 in a chiral medium . here the subscript v " means vector " , and can be , for example , @xmath23 " ( baryon ) or @xmath24 " ( electron ) . in heavy - ion collisions , @xmath25 is typically larger than @xmath26 by an order of magnitude , making it easier to search for the cve via the baryonic charge separation than the electric charge separation . hence the subscript @xmath11 in eq . [ equ : fourier_expansion ] represents baryon or anti - baryon in the cve search . another complementary transport phenomenon to the cme has been found and named the chiral separation effect ( cse ) @xcite , in which chiral charges are separated along the axis of the magnetic field in the presence of finite density of vector charge : @xmath27 . in a chirally symmetric phase , the cme and cse form a collective excitation , the chiral magnetic wave ( cmw ) , a long wavelength hydrodynamic mode of chiral charge densities @xcite . the cmw , a signature of the chiral symmetry restoration , manifests itself in a finite electric quadrupole moment of the collision system , where the poles " ( equator " ) of the produced fireball acquire additional positive ( negative ) charge @xcite . this effect , if present , will be reflected in the measurements of charge - dependent elliptic flow . there are other chiral magnetic / vortical effects such as the chiral electric separation effect ( cese ) @xcite and the chiral vortical wave ( cvw ) @xcite ; see ref @xcite for a recent review on these effects . this article reviews the experimental results in the past decade to search for the chiral magnetic / vortical effects in high - energy heavy - ion collisions : evidence for the initial magnetic field and vorticity in sec . [ sec : drive ] , the observation of the electric ( baryonic ) charge separation in sec . [ sec : cme ] ( sec . [ sec : cve ] ) , and the manifestation of the electric quadrupole moment in sec . [ sec : cmw ] . an outlook for future development is discussed in sec . [ sec : outlook ] . we may intuitively regard the magnetic field ( vorticity ) as the driving force of the cme ( cve ) , while the chirality imbalance is the initial condition , and the electric ( baryonic ) charge separation is the manifestation . a rough estimate of the initial magnetic field gives @xmath28 , where @xmath29 , @xmath30 is the impact parameter , and @xmath31 is the lorentz factor . therefore a typical au+au collision at @xmath32 gev produces @xmath33 . many computations have attempted to quantify the electromagnetic field on the event - by - event basis ( see e.g. @xcite ) , in terms of the spatial distribution , the orientation fluctuation as well as the dependence on colliding nuclei , centrality and beam energy . a major uncertainty in theoretical calculations of the magnetic field @xmath4 is its duration in the qcd fluid created in the heavy - ion collision ( see e.g. @xcite ) . the time dependence of @xmath4 after the impact of the two nuclei crucially depends on whether / when / how a conducting medium may form and the lifetime of the magnetic field may be elongated . the electric conductivity @xcite and the time evolution of the quark densities @xcite can be studied via directed flow of charged hadrons in asymmetric collisions , such as cu+au . figure [ fig : cuau ] illustrates the transverse plane for a cu+au collision with @xmath34 fm @xcite . the difference in the number of protons creates a strong electric field in the initial stage of the collision , pointing along the arrow in the figure . the lifetime of the electric field might be very short ( e.g. @xmath35 fm/@xmath36 from ref . @xcite ) , but the electric charges from quarks and antiquarks that are present in the early stage of the collision would experience the coulomb force and lift the degeneracy in @xmath14 between positively and negatively charged particles @xcite : v_1^ = v_1 d_e , where @xmath37 denotes the azimuthal angle of the electric field , and the coefficient @xmath38 characterizes the strength of dipole deformation induced by the electric field and is proportional to the electric conductivity of the medium . here @xmath14 represents the rapidity - even component of directed flow that is dominant in asymmetric collisions , while in symmetric collisions @xmath14 conventionally denotes the rapidity - odd component . of positive and negative particles and the difference between the two as functions of @xmath7 in @xmath39 cu+au and au+au collisions @xcite . the phsd model calculations @xcite for charged pions with and without the initial electric field ( ef ) are presented for comparison . ] of positive and negative particles and the difference between the two as functions of @xmath7 in @xmath39 cu+au and au+au collisions @xcite . the phsd model calculations @xcite for charged pions with and without the initial electric field ( ef ) are presented for comparison . ] figure [ fig : v1 ] shows recent star measurements of charge - dependent @xmath40 and the difference @xmath41 as functions of @xmath7 in @xmath39 cu+au and au+au collisions @xcite . for @xmath42 gev/@xmath36 , @xmath41 seems to increase with @xmath7 . the @xmath40 results from au+au collisions have much smaller values , roughly by a factor of 10 , than those in cu+au . note that @xmath43 in au+au collisions is similarly small @xcite . @xmath41 in au+au is consistent with zero . calculations for charged pions from the parton - hadron - string - dynamics ( phsd ) model @xcite , which is a dynamical transport approach in the partonic and hadronic phases , are compared with the data . the phsd model calculates two cases : charge - dependent @xmath40 with and without the initial electric field ( ef ) . in the case with the ef switched on , the model assumes that all electric charges are affected by the ef and this results in a large separation of @xmath40 between positive and negative particles as shown in fig . [ fig : v1](a ) . in fig . [ fig : v1](b ) , the calculations of the @xmath40 with and without the ef are shown together , but note that the ef - on calculation points are scaled by @xmath44 . after scaling by @xmath44 , the model describes rather well the @xmath7 dependence of the measured data for @xmath42 gev/@xmath36 . this qualitative evidence for the strong initial electric field in asymmetric collisions provides an indirect evidence for the strong initial magnetic field in heavy - ion collisions that could leave an imprint on the final - stage particles . the vorticity is induced by the global rotation of the qgp in heavy - ion collisions . in a noncentral collision , the majority of the global angular momentum , @xmath45 , is carried away by spectator nucleons . however , a considerable fraction ( about @xmath46 of @xmath45 could remain in the qgp and be approximately conserved in time @xcite . this implies a relatively long duration of the vortical effects . on average , the angular momentum is pointing in the out - of - plane direction , so the cme and cve are very much alike in terms of their experimental observables . attempts to computate local vorticity @xmath20 and its space - time distribution have also been made @xcite . experimentally global polarization of hyperons such as @xmath47 provides a measure for both the plasma vorticity and the magnetic field . whereas the vortical effects will generate a positive polarization for both @xmath47 and @xmath48 , the coupling of the hadronic magnetic dipole moment to the magnetic field will generate a positive contribution for @xmath47 and a negative one for @xmath48 . therefore , a splitting between @xmath47 and @xmath48 polarization will be a direct evidence for the strong initial magnetic field . recently , preliminary star measurements @xcite have reported the first observation of global @xmath47 and @xmath48 polarization in heavy - ion collisions . at @xmath49 gev , the signal is on the order of a few percent , and displays a weak beam - energy dependence . the average polarization over @xmath47 and @xmath48 evidences the plasma vorticity , while the splitting observation requires much higher statistics to be delivered in the second beam energy scan ( bes - ii ) program at rhic @xcite to signify the magnetic field . the future search for evidence for the initial magnetic field ( vorticity ) is proposed via photon ( vector meson ) polarization measurements @xcite . the initial magnetic helicity ( @xmath50 ) of the collision system can be quite large and bears opposite signs in the upper and lower hemispheres . owing to the chiral anomaly , the helicity can be transferred back and forth between the magnetic flux and fermions as the collision system evolves , so that the magnetic helicity could last long enough to yield photons with opposite circular polarizations in the hemispheres above and below the rp @xcite . a similar asymmetry in photon polarization can also result from the initial global quark polarization @xcite , which could effectively lead to a polarization of photons @xcite . this local imbalance of photon circular polarization could be observed in experiments , e.g. , by studying the polarization preference with respect to the rp for photons that convert into @xmath51 pairs @xcite . similarly , vector mesons that decay into two daughters can also have their polarization preferences measured with the scheme outlined in ref . @xcite , and the helicity separation in this case originates from vorticity @xcite . the discovery of the cme in high - energy heavy - ion collisions would confirm the simultaneous existence of ultra - strong magnetic fields , chiral symmetry restoration and topological charge changing transitions . the experimental searches for the cme have been carried out extensively in the past decade at rhic and the lhc . this section will introduce the observables pertinent to the electric charge separation induced by the cme , present the experimental results and discuss the background contributions due to the coupling of elliptic flow and other physics mechanisms . from event to event , the signs of the @xmath0 values are equally likely , and the signs of finite @xmath52 and @xmath53 will flip accordingly , leading to @xmath54 . figure [ fig : a1 ] presents the star measurements of @xmath55 with the @xmath56 harmonic event plane reconstructed from spectator neutrons @xcite . these results indicate no significant charge dependence in all centrality intervals , with the typical difference between positive and negative charges less than @xmath57 . for positive and negative charges versus centrality for au+au collisions at @xmath58 gev @xcite . , scaledwidth=45.0% ] one therefore has to search for the cme with charge - separation _ fluctuations _ perpendicular to the reaction plane , e.g. , with a three - point correlator @xcite , @xmath59 , where the averaging is done over all particles in an event and over all events . in practice , the reaction plane is approximated with the event plane " ( @xmath60 ) reconstructed with measured particles , and then the measurement is corrected for the finite event plane resolution . the expansion of the @xmath31 correlator , @xmath61 reveals the difference between the _ in - plane _ and _ out - of - plane _ projections of the correlations . the first term ( @xmath62 ) in the expansion provides a baseline unrelated to the magnetic field . the background contribution ( @xmath63 ) is suppressed to a level close to the magnitude of @xmath15 @xcite . the star collaboration first measured the @xmath31 correlator with the @xmath64 harmonic event plane for au+au ( shown with crosses in fig . [ fig : gamma ] ) and cu+cu ( not shown here ) collisions at @xmath65 and @xmath66 gev with data from the 2004/2005 rhic runs @xcite . all the results have been found to be in qualitative expectation with the cme : the opposite - charge ( @xmath67 ) and the same - charge ( @xmath68 ) correlations display the right " ordering . the opposite - charge correlations in cu+cu collisions are stronger than those in au+au , possibly reflecting the suppression of the correlations among oppositely moving particles in a larger system . star also presented @xmath7 and @xmath69 dependences of the signal . the signal has a @xmath69 width of about one unit of rapidity , consistent with small chiral domains . the signal is found to increase with the pair average @xmath7 , and it was later shown @xcite that the radial flow expansion can explain this feature . similar @xmath31 results for 200 gev au+au and 2.76 tev pb+pb were observed by the phenix collaboration @xcite and the alice collaboration @xcite , respectively . phenix also employed a multiparticle charge - sensitive correlator , @xmath70 @xcite , and their preliminary results showed a concave @xmath70 distribution , also evidencing the charge separation effect . the background from conventional physics was studied with heavy - ion event generators mevsim @xcite , urqmd @xcite and hijing @xcite ( with and without an elliptic flow afterburner implemented ) . none of these generators could achieve reasonable agreement with the data . however , these generators do not provide particularly good descriptions of heavy - ion collisions , so the fact that they fail to describe such subtle effects as charge separation provides only somewhat limited support for a cme interpretation of the data . gev @xcite . the grey bars reflect the conditions of @xmath71 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath72 applied to @xmath31 . ] gev @xcite . the grey bars reflect the conditions of @xmath71 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath72 applied to @xmath31 . ] the charge - separation signal was cross - checked with data from the 2007 rhic run ( shown in fig . [ fig : gamma ] ) @xcite . the @xmath31 correlations from these data were measured with respect to both the @xmath56 harmonic event plane ( of spectators at large rapidity ) and the @xmath64 harmonic event planes at mid - rapidity . using the @xmath56 harmonic event plane determined by spectator neutrons ensures that the signal is not coming from three - particle background correlations , and is due to genuine correlations to the reaction plane . another test was carried out by replacing one of the two charged particles in @xmath31 with a neutral particle , e.g. @xmath73 , and the results show no separation between @xmath74 and @xmath75 @xcite . thus the charge separation observed in the @xmath31 correlation between two charged particles is indeed due to the electric charge . femtoscopic correlations are visible in the differential measurements of @xmath31 at low relative momenta , which are related to quantum interference ( hbt " ) and final - state - interactions ( coulomb dominated ) @xcite . the difference between in - plane and out - of - plane correlations in the femtoscopic region can be due to a difference in the emission volumes probed by in- and out - of - plane parts . such a difference may arrise from an azimuthally anisotropic freeze - out distribution coupled with flow . to suppress the contribution from femtoscopic correlations , the conditions of @xmath71 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath72 were applied to the three - point correlator , shown with the grey bars in fig . [ fig : msc ] . excluding pairs with low relative momenta significantly reduces the positive contributions to opposite - charge correlations in peripheral collisions , but the difference between same- and opposite - charge correlations remains largely unchanged and consistent with the expectations of the cme . the @xmath31 correlator weights different azimuthal regions of charge separation differently , i.e. oppositely charged pairs emitted azimuthally at @xmath76 from the event plane ( maximally out - of - plane ) are weighted more heavily than those emitted only a few degrees from the event plane ( minimally out - of - plane ) . it is a good test to modify the @xmath31 correlator such that all azimuthal regions of charge separation are weighted identically . this may be done by first rewriting eq . [ eq : threepoint ] as ( _ + _ -2_rp ) = ( m_m_s_s_)_in - ( m_m_s_s_)_out , [ eq : mmss ] where @xmath77 and @xmath78 stand for the absolute magnitude ( @xmath79 ) and the sign ( @xmath80 ) of the sine or cosine function , respectively . in represents the cosine part of eq . [ eq : threepoint ] ( in - plane ) and out represents the sine part ( out - of - plane ) . a modulated sign correlation ( msc ) is obtained by reducing the @xmath31 correlator @xcite : ( ) ^2(s_s _ _ in - s_s__out ) . [ eq : msc ] the modulated sign correlations are compared with the three - point correlator for au+au collisions at 200 gev in fig . [ fig : msc ] . it is evident that the msc is able to reproduce the same trend as the three - point correlator although their magnitudes differ slightly . star also carried out another approach called the charge multiplicity asymmetry correlation ( cmac ) , whose methodology is similar to the msc , and yielded very similar results @xcite . . charge independent results from the model calculations of mevsim @xcite are shown as grey curves . ] a further understanding of the origin of the observed charge separation could be achieved with a study of the beam - energy dependence of the correlation . the charge separation effect depends strongly on the formation of the quark gluon plasma and chiral symmetry restoration @xcite , and the signal can be greatly suppressed or completely absent at low collision energies where a qgp has significantly shortened lifetime or not even formed . taking into account that the lifetime of the strong magnetic field is larger at smaller collision energies , this could lead to an almost threshold effect : with decreasing collision energy , the signal might slowly increase with an abrupt drop thereafter . unfortunately , the exact energy dependence of the cme is not calculated yet . figure [ fig : lpv_bes ] presents @xmath67 and @xmath68 correlators as functions of centrality for au+au collisions at @xmath81 gev measured by star @xcite , and for pb+pb collisions at 2.76 tev by alice @xcite . in most cases , the difference between @xmath67 and @xmath68 is still present with the right " ordering , manifesting extra charge - separation fluctuations perpendicular to the reaction plane . with decreased beam energy , both @xmath67 and @xmath68 tend to rise up starting from peripheral collisions . this feature seems to be charge independent , and can be explained by momentum conservation and elliptic flow @xcite . momentum conservation forces all produced particles , regardless of charge , to separate from each other , while elliptic flow works in the opposite sense . for peripheral collisions , the multiplicity ( @xmath82 ) is small , and momentum conservation dominates . the lower beam energy , the smaller @xmath82 , and the higher @xmath67 and @xmath68 . for more central collisions where the multiplicity is large enough , this type of charge - independent background can be estimated with @xmath83 @xcite . mevsim is a monte carlo event generator developed for star simulations @xcite . in fig . [ fig : lpv_bes ] , we also show the model calculations of mevsim with the implementation of @xmath15 and momentum conservation , which qualitatively describe the beam - energy dependence of the charge - independent background . the difference between @xmath67 and @xmath68 seems to vanish at low collision energies , but the interpretation involves an ambiguity to be discussed in the sec [ sec : kappa ] . the @xmath31 correlator by construction contains the background terms @xmath84 and @xmath85 , and their difference was originally studied for the flowing cluster " case @xcite : v_2,cl , where @xmath86 is the cluster emission azimuthal angle , and @xmath87 and @xmath88 are the azimuthal angles of two decay products . the flowing cluster can be generalized to a larger portion of or even the whole event , through the mechanisms of transverse momentum conservation ( tmc ) @xcite and/or local charge conservation ( lcc ) @xcite . one useful tool to study the background is the two - particle correlator , @xmath89 , which ideally should be protortional to @xmath90 , but in reality is dominated by backgrounds . for example , the tmc effect leads to the following pertinent correlation terms in @xmath91 and @xmath31 @xcite : & & - , + & & - + & & v_2 , , where @xmath92 , and @xmath93 and @xmath94 represent the @xmath7- and @xmath95-weighted moments of @xmath15 , respectively . the subscript f " denotes an average of all produced particles in the full phase space ; the actual measurements will be only in a fraction of the full space , denoted by @xmath96 " . the background contribution due to the lcc effect has a similar characteristic structure as the above @xcite . it is convenient to express @xmath31 and @xmath91 with a two - component framework @xcite : & & = v_2 b - h , + & & = b + h , where @xmath97 and @xmath23 are the cme and background contributions , respectively . the background - subtracted correlator , @xmath97 , can be obtained from the ensemble averages of several observables : h^= ( v_2 - ) /(1+v_2 ) . the major uncertainty in the above expression , the coefficient @xmath98 , depends on particle charge combination and particle transverse momentum . it may also depend on centrality and collision energy , reflecting slightly different particle production mechanism in different conditions . as a function of beam energy for @xmath99 au+au ( pb+pb ) collisions @xcite . the systematic errors ( grey bars ) bear the same meaning as in fig . [ fig : msc ] . ] as a function of beam energy for @xmath99 au+au ( pb+pb ) collisions @xcite . the systematic errors ( grey bars ) bear the same meaning as in fig . [ fig : msc ] . ] figure [ fig : kappa ] shows the @xmath98 values estimated for au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite , with the @xmath15 measurements by the phobos collaboration @xcite , and with the @xmath15 calculations from the ampt model @xcite . here only the tmc effect has been taken in account , and @xmath98 is typically within @xmath100 $ ] for @xmath101 . the @xmath98 values attained this way will vary slightly if a smaller @xmath102 acceptance is involved . in reality , @xmath98 should be averaged over various mechanisms such as tmc , lcc and resonance decays . the ampt model gives a more comprehensive estimate in fig . [ fig : kappa ] via @xmath103 , where the numerator is solely due to flow backgrounds . for the centrality range of @xmath104 , where the statistical uncertainties are small , the @xmath98 values thus obtained are close to those estimated with the @xmath15 information . figure [ fig : h_bes ] shows @xmath105 as a function of beam energy for @xmath99 au+au ( pb+pb ) collisions @xcite . @xmath106 is depicted with the solid line . in both cases of @xmath98 , @xmath107 demonstrates a weak energy dependence above 19.6 gev , and tends to diminish from 19.6 to 7.7 gev , though the statistical errors are large for 7.7 gev . this may be explained by the probable domination of hadronic interactions over partonic ones at low energies . a more definitive conclusion may be reached with a more accurate estimation of @xmath98 and with higher statistics at lower energies in the proposed phase ii of the rhic beam energy scan program , as illustrated by the shaded band in fig . [ fig : h_bes ] . as a function of @xmath15 for various centrality selections within the @xmath108 centrality range in u+u collisions ( left ) and au+au collisions ( right ) . @xcite ] as a function of @xmath15 for various centrality selections within the @xmath108 centrality range in u+u collisions ( left ) and au+au collisions ( right ) . @xcite ] uranium nuclei have been collided at rhic in order to study the dependence of multiplicity production , flow , and the cme on the initial overlap geometry @xcite . early ideas hold that the prolate shape of uranium nuclei would make it possible to select nearly fully overlapping events with large elliptic flow values , but with small magnetic fields . however , owing to fluctuations , the square of the magnetic field is not particularly small . measurements of very central collisions also demonstrated that the number of produced particles does not depend as strongly on the configuration of the collisions as anticipated in the two - component multiplicity model , leaving the experiments with a significantly reduced ability to independently manipulate the flow and the magnetic field @xcite . figure [ fig : gamma_v2 ] shows measurements of @xmath109 for the @xmath108 centrality range in 193 gev u+u ( left ) and 200 gev au+au collisions ( right ) @xcite . in both u+u and au+au collisions , the signal increases roughly with @xmath15 . this initial observation may suggest that the charge - separation observable is dominated by a @xmath15 dependence . however , the charge separation goes to zero while @xmath15 is still sizable in central au+au and central u+u collisions . model calculations show that the quantity @xmath110}$ ] as a function of eccentricity exhibits the same trend @xcite : although @xmath111 remains large owing to fluctuations , @xmath112}$ ] goes to zero as @xmath113 and @xmath6 become decorrelated in very central collisions . so while fluctuations in central collisions force the participant eccentricity ( positive - definite ) away from zero , the decorrelation of @xmath113 and @xmath6 drives @xmath110}$ ] to zero . the data therefore appear to be in better agreement with a cme interpretation than a flow background interpretation . a phenomenological study for extrapolating both signal and background from au+au to u+u collisions was done in ref . @xcite . another measurement that can clarify the origin of the charge - dependent correlations and the role of the background was suggested @xcite : the correlations measured with respect to the @xmath114 harmonic event plane , @xmath115 , should not contain any contribution from the cme , but it should include the effect of the flow - related background . the correlations due to the background in this case are expected to be somewhat smaller in magnitude as the @xmath114 harmonic flow is not that strong as the elliptic flow . the preliminary results of such measurements by alice are presented in fig . [ fig:4th - harmonic ] @xcite with the same - charge and opposite - charge pair correlations relative to the @xmath114 harmonic event plane as functions of centrality ( left ) , and the charge - dependent parts with respect to the @xmath64 and @xmath114 harmonic event planes ( right ) . the correlations relative to the @xmath114 harmonic event plane are very weak and suggestive of small background contributions . detailed simulations have to be performed to draw more definite conclusion from this measurement . harmonic event plane as functions of centrality . ( right panel ) comparison of the charge - dependent parts in correlations with respect to the @xmath64 and @xmath114 harmonic event planes . @xcite ] harmonic event plane as functions of centrality . ( right panel ) comparison of the charge - dependent parts in correlations with respect to the @xmath64 and @xmath114 harmonic event planes . the chiral vortical effect ( cve ) is related to the cme , and its experimental manifestation is the baryonic charge separation , instead of the electric charge separation , perpendicular to the reaction plane . as a result , the three - point @xmath31 correlator is still applicable , only now between two ( anti)baryons . however , if both particles are ( anti)protons that carry also electric charges , there will be an ambiguity due to the possible signal arising from the cme . the study of the @xmath31 correlator with an electrically neutral baryon , such as @xmath47 , will provide more conclusive evidence for the baryonic charge separation effect . correlation of @xmath47-@xmath116 ( @xmath48-@xmath117 ) and @xmath47-@xmath117 ( @xmath48-@xmath116 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite . ] correlation of @xmath47-@xmath116 ( @xmath48-@xmath117 ) and @xmath47-@xmath117 ( @xmath48-@xmath116 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite . ] although ( anti)@xmath47 s are electrically neutral , it is still a question whether the strange quarks behave the same way as the up / down quarks in the chiral dynamics during the collision . if the answer is no , then ( anti)@xmath47 s may still act like electrically charged particles in the @xmath31 correlation . figure [ fig : lambda_h ] shows the @xmath31 correlation of @xmath47-@xmath118 ( @xmath48-@xmath119 ) and @xmath47-@xmath119 ( @xmath48-@xmath118 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite . note that ( anti)protons have been excluded from the charged hadrons in the correlation to avoid any possible cve contribution . tentatively assuming @xmath47s ( @xmath48s ) are positively(negatively)-charged , we find that the same - charge " and opposite - charge " correlations are consistent with each other , which means no charge - dependent effect . the message is twofold : first , from the @xmath120 correlations @xcite we learn that the different behaviors of same - charge and opposite - charge particle correlations as shown in fig . [ fig : gamma ] are really due to the electric charge , and therefore the null charge - separation effect in @xmath47-@xmath121 indicates that ( anti)@xmath47s manifest no electric charges in the @xmath31 correlation . so the strange quarks inside seem to behave the same way as the up / down quarks in the chiral dynamics . second , the @xmath47-@xmath121 correlation provides a baseline check for the @xmath47-@xmath116 correlation , and any possible signal in the latter should not come from the cme contribution . figure [ fig : lambda_p ] shows @xmath31 correlation of @xmath47-@xmath116 ( @xmath48-@xmath117 ) and @xmath47-@xmath117 ( @xmath48-@xmath116 ) as functions of centrality in au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite . the same - baryonic - charge correlation has a different behavior from the opposite - baryonic - charge correlation from mid - central to peripheral collisions . this baryonic charge separation with respect to the event plane is consistent with the expectation from the cve . more investigations into the background contribution are needed . for example , in analog with the local charge conservation , there could be the local baryonic charge conservation that plays a similar role as lcc when coupled to @xmath15 . the magnitudes of the @xmath47-@xmath116 correlations are much larger than those of the @xmath121-@xmath121 correlations . this is partially because the @xmath122 of baryons is higher than that of mesons , and the correlation strength increases with the average @xmath7 of the two particles in the correlation . a future differential measurement vs the pair average @xmath7 and further correlations between identified particles may provide a better comparison of the correlation strength between the cme- and cve - related correlations . the cmw is a signature of the chiral symmetry restoration in the qgp , and consists of actually two chiral gapless modes traveling at the same speed @xcite : the right - handed ( left - handed ) wave transports the right - handed ( left - handed ) density and current in the direction parallel ( antiparallel ) to the @xmath4 direction . a more general analysis @xcite studied various possible collective modes based on a non - neutral - background qgp ( i.e. with nonzero @xmath2 and/or @xmath0 ) in external electric and/or magnetic fields , and found a new type of collective motion , the chiral electric wave ( cew ) , arising from cese and propagating in parallel / antiparallel to the @xmath123 field . in symmetric collisions there should be no net electric field on average , but asymmetric collisions like cu+au could provide a test ground for the cew measurements . as a function of observed charge asymmetry and ( b ) @xmath15 difference between @xmath124 and @xmath125 as a function of charge asymmetry with the tracking efficiency correction , for @xmath126-@xmath127 au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite . ] the cmw will induce a finite electric quadrupole moment of the collision system , with additional positive ( negative ) charge at the poles " ( equator " ) of the produced fireball @xcite . this electric quadrupole , if boosted by radial flow , will lead to charge - dependent elliptic flow . taking pions as an example , on top of the baseline @xmath128 , the cmw will lead to @xcite v_2(^ ) = v_2^base(^ ) ( ) a_ch , [ eq : v2_slope ] where @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 are the quadrupole moment , the net charge density and the charge asymmetry of the collision event , respectively . as @xmath132 is always positive , the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 of @xmath124 ( @xmath125 ) should be above ( below ) the baseline owing to the cmw . however , the baseline @xmath15 may be different for @xmath125 and @xmath124 because of several other physics mechanisms @xcite . therefore , it is less ambiguous to study the cmw via the @xmath133 dependence of pion @xmath15 than via the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 . taking @xmath126-@xmath127 200 gev au+au for example , pion @xmath15 is shown as a function of @xmath133 in panel ( a ) of fig . [ fig : v2_a ] @xcite . @xmath124 @xmath15 increases with @xmath133 while @xmath125 @xmath15 decreases with a similar magnitude of the slope . note that @xmath15 was integrated over a narrow low @xmath7 range ( @xmath134 gev/@xmath36 ) to focus on the soft physics of the cmw . such a @xmath7 selection also makes sure that the @xmath122 is independent of @xmath133 and is the same for @xmath125 and @xmath124 , so that the @xmath15 splitting is not a trivial effect due to the @xmath122 variation . this @xmath15 splitting was also confirmed by alice results for pb+pb collisions at 2.76 tev @xcite . the @xmath15 difference between @xmath124 and @xmath125 is fitted with a straight line in panel ( b ) . the slope parameter @xmath135 , or presumably @xmath136 from eq . [ eq : v2_slope ] , is positive and qualitatively consistent with the expectation of the cmw picture . the fit function is nonzero at @xmath132 , indicating the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 for @xmath124 and @xmath125 are different , which was also observed in ref . @xcite . the same procedure as above was followed by star to retrieve the slope parameter @xmath135 as a function of centrality for au+au collisions at 200 , 62.4 , 39 , 27 , 19.6 , 11.5 and 7.7 gev , as shown in fig . [ fig : cmw_bes ] @xcite . a similar rise - and - fall trend is observed in the centrality dependence of the slope parameter for all the beam energies except 11.5 and 7.7 gev , where the slopes are consistent with zero with large statistical uncertainties . it was argued @xcite that at lower beam energies the @xmath133-integrated @xmath15 difference between particles and anti - particles can be explained by the effect of quark transport from the projectile nucleons to mid - rapidity , assuming that the @xmath15 of transported quarks is larger than that of produced ones . the same model , however , when used to study @xmath137 as a function of @xmath133 , suggested a negative slope @xcite , which is contradicted by the data . as a function of centrality for au+au collisions at 7.7 - 200 gev @xcite . the grey bands represent the systematic errors . for comparison , we also show the urqmd calculations @xcite and the calculations of the cmw @xcite with different duration times . ] to check if the observed slope parameters come from conventional physics , the same analysis of the monte carlo events from urqmd @xcite was carried out . for au+au collisions at 200 gev , the slopes extracted from urqmd events are consistent with zero for the @xmath138-@xmath139 centrality range , where the signal from the real data is prominent . similarly , the ampt event generator @xcite also yields slopes consistent with zero ( not shown here ) . on the other hand , the simplified cmw calculations @xcite demonstrate a centrality dependence of the slope parameter similar to the data . recently a more realistic implementation of the cmw @xcite confirmed that the cmw contribution to @xmath135 is sizable , and the centrality dependence of @xmath135 is qualitatively similar to the data . a quantitative comparison between data and theory requires further work on both sides to match the kinematic regions used in the analyses . for example , the measured @xmath133 only represents the charge asymmetry of a pseudorapidity slice ( @xmath140 ) of an event , instead of that of the whole collision system . we expect @xmath133 for these two cases to be proportional to each other , but the determination of the ratio will be model dependent . figure [ fig : slope_alice ] shows a comparison in the slope parameter @xmath135 between star results for 200 gev au+au @xcite and alice results for 2.76 tev pb+pb @xcite . overall , the slopes are surprisingly similar when considering the different collision energies and multiplicities , as well as the different kinematic acceptance : the star data estimated @xmath15 for charged pions with @xmath141 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath142 , while the alice data are for unidentified hadrons with @xmath143 gev/@xmath36 and @xmath144 . one drawback with the measurement of @xmath145 is that the observed @xmath133 requires a correction factor due to the finite detector tracking efficiency . a novel correlator @xcite that is independent of efficiency was proposed , q_3 = q_3 - q_3 . [ daq ] here @xmath146 and @xmath147 are the azimuthal angles of particles 1 and 2 , and @xmath148 is the charge ( @xmath149 ) of particle 3 . the single brackets represent the average over particles and events , and the double bracket denotes the cumulant . in the absence of charge dependent correlations , the correlator should be equal to zero . note that when the charge of the third particle is averaged over all particles in the event ( in the specified kinematic acceptance ) , the mean is equal to the charge asymmetry , i.e. @xmath150 . the three - particle correlator ( as in eq . [ daq ] ) for the @xmath64 harmonic was measured by alice and is presented in fig . [ fig : threepart_alice ] as a function of centrality in pb+pb collisions at 2.76 tev gev @xcite . a substantial increase in the correlation strength is seen as the collisions become more peripheral , which can be caused by a combination of several factors . for example , the magnetic field strength increases as the impact parameter increases , and this would cause the stronger correlations due to the cmw . additionally , the lcc effect could play a role @xcite , and neither of these necessarily comes at the expense of the other ; in principle the observable could have contributions from both of these and/or additional contributions from as yet unknown sources of correlation . it was pointed out in ref . @xcite that local charge conservation at freeze - out , when convoluted with the characteristic shape of @xmath151 and @xmath152 , may provide a qualitative explanation for the finite @xmath15 slope observed from data . a realistic estimate of the contribution of this mechanism turns out to be smaller than the measurment by an order of magnitude @xcite . @xcite also proposes a test with the @xmath153 measurement , and the corresponding slope parameters for @xmath153 were reported by star to be consistent with zero @xcite , which further suggests the smallness of this effect . alice measured the three - particle correlator multiplied by @xmath154 for the @xmath155 harmonic and the @xmath114 harmonic @xcite . in both cases , the centrality dependence of the charge dependence is flat , in contrast to the @xmath64 harmonic that has a significant centrality dependence . this may suggest a different nature of the correlation , or reflect a weaker centrality dependence of @xmath153 compared with that of @xmath15 . future measurements of these higher harmonics with better precision will shed light on the true origin of this correlator . a recent hydrodynamic study @xcite suggested that simple viscous transport of charges , combined with certain specific initial conditions , might lead to a sizable contribution to the observed @xmath15 splitting of charged pions . in order for the results of pion splitting to resemble data , the authors had to assume a crucial relation between isospin chemical potential and the electric charge asymmetry , which needs to be verified . furthermore , certain predictions of this model ( e.g. splitting for kaons ) appear to be not in line with current experimental information @xcite . clearly whether such an idea works or not , would need to be thoroughly vetted by realistic viscous hydrodynamic simulations . but all that said , this study poses a very important question : to make a firm case for the observation of anomalous charge transport via the cmw , the normal ( viscous hydrodynamical ) transport of charges should be quantitatively understood . the confirmation of the experimental observation of several chiral anomalous effects will bring forth an exciting program to directly study the non - perturbative sector of qcd . future experimental measurements should aim at more detailed study of the observed signals as well as understanding the background effects . previous sections have covered a few such topics : initial magnetic field and vorticity , correlations with identified particles , higher - harmonic correlations , bes - ii and u+u collisions . in the following , we will focus on the event - shape engineering ( ese ) and isobaric collisions . flow - related backgrounds could be potentially removed via ese @xcite , with which _ spherical _ events or sub - events are selected , so that the particles of interest therein carry zero @xmath15 . a previous attempt was made with the charge - separation observable of cmac ( roughly equivalent to @xmath31 ) , as a function of event - by - event observed @xmath15 " @xcite . however , there are several issues in this approach that prevent a clear interpretation of the result . ref . @xcite studied the flow vector @xmath156 of the sub - event of interest , a : q_x^a & = & _ i^n ( 2_i^a ) [ qx ] + q_y^a & = & _ i^n ( 2_i^a ) , [ qy ] and found that @xmath157 is a good handle on event shape . ( upper ) and @xmath158 ( lower ) as functions of @xmath157 , from ampt simulations . @xcite the solid ( dashed ) line in the lower panel is a linear fit of the full ( open ) data points . ] ( upper ) and @xmath158 ( lower ) as functions of @xmath157 , from ampt simulations . @xcite the solid ( dashed ) line in the lower panel is a linear fit of the full ( open ) data points . ] figure [ fig : ampt_v2_q2 ] shows the event plane resolution ( @xmath159 ) for the sub - events b1 and b2 ( upper ) , and the true elliptic flow @xmath160 and the corrected @xmath161 as functions of @xmath157 ( lower ) , from ampt simulations of @xmath162 au+au collisions at @xmath163 gev @xcite . each ampt event has been divided into three sub - events according to pseudorapidity , @xmath8 : sub - event a contains particles of interest with @xmath101 , and sub - event b1(b2 ) serves as a sub - event plane using particles with @xmath164 ( @xmath165 ) . flow fluctuation causes a positive correlation in flow between sub - events in the same event , and as a result , @xmath159 for sub - event b1 ( b2 ) increases with @xmath157 for sub - event a. the lower panel displays a discrepancy between @xmath160 and the corrected @xmath161 , owing to the difference between the reaction plane and the participant plane @xcite , in terms of non - flow and flow fluctuation . what matters more is the fact that both @xmath15 values decrease with @xmath157 , and drop to @xmath166 , which demonstrates @xmath167 s capability of selecting spherical sub - events in the second harmonic . the upper panel of fig . [ fig : ampt_gamma_q2 ] presents the @xmath31 correlators multiplied by the number of participating nucleons , @xmath168 , as functions of @xmath157 , for @xmath162 ampt events of au+au collisions at 200 gev @xcite . for both the same - charge and the opposite - charge correlators , the true @xmath169 and the corrected @xmath170 are consistent with each other within the statistical uncertainties . this indicates that compared with @xmath15 , @xmath31 is less sensitive to non - flow or flow fluctuation . at larger @xmath157 , the opposite - charge correlators are above the same - charge correlators , suggesting a finite flow - related background . the opposite- and same - charge correlators converge at small @xmath157 . the lower panel shows @xmath171 vs @xmath157 , and again , the two observables seem to coincide . linear fits to both observables yield small intercepts that are consistent with zero . the finite @xmath172 values in ampt events are solely due to background contributions , so the disappearance of background is demonstrated when the correctable " observable ( @xmath172 ) is projected to zero @xmath157 . ref . @xcite has designed a promising recipe for future measurements to effectively remove flow backgrounds and restore the ensemble average of the cme signal . to disentangle the possible cme signal and the flow - related backgrounds , one can utilize experimental setups to either vary the backgrounds with the signal fixed , or vary the signal with the backgrounds fixed . the former approach was carried out by exploiting the prolate shape of the uranium nuclei @xcite . however , it was found that the total multiplicity of detected hadrons is far less dependent on the number of binary collisions than expected @xcite , so it is very hard to isolate tip - tip collisions ( that generate small @xmath15 ) from body - body collisions ( that generate large @xmath15 ) . this significantly reduces the lever arm available to manipulate @xmath15 in order to separate flow backgrounds from the cme . the latter approach ( with the @xmath15-driven backgrounds fixed ) can be realized , especially for mid - central / mid - peripheral events , with collisions of isobaric nuclei , such as @xmath173ru and @xmath174zr @xcite . ru+ru and zr+zr collisions at the same beam energy are almost identical in terms of particle production @xcite , while the charge difference between ru and zr nuclei provides a handle on the initial magnetic field . our current knowledge of the deformity ( @xmath175 ) of ru and zr is incomplete : e - a scattering experiments ( case 1 ) @xcite state that ru is more deformed ( @xmath176 ) than zr ( @xmath177 ) , while comprehensive model deductions ( case 2 ) @xcite tell the opposite , that @xmath178 is smaller than @xmath179 . this systematic uncertainty has different impacts on the signal ( via the initial magnetic field ) and the background ( via the initial eccentricity ) to be discussed later . as a by - product , @xmath15 measurements in central collisions will discern which information source is more reliable regarding the deformity of the zr and ru nuclei . figure [ fig_mag](a ) presents the theoretical calculation @xcite of the initial magnetic field squared with correction from azimuthal fluctuation of the magnetic field orientation , @xmath180}$ ] ( with @xmath181 the pion mass and @xmath182 the azimuthal angle of the magnetic field ) , for the two collision systems at 200 gev , using the hijing model @xcite . @xmath183 quantifies the magnetic field s capability of driving the cme signal in the @xmath31 correlator . for the same centrality bin , the ru+ru collision produces a significantly stronger magnetic field than zr+zr . panel ( b ) of fig . [ fig_mag ] shows that the relative difference in @xmath183 between ru+ru and zr+zr collisions is approaching @xmath184 ( case 1 ) or @xmath185 ( case 2 ) for peripheral events , and reduces to about @xmath186 ( both cases ) for central events . figure [ fig_mag](b ) shows the relative difference in the initial eccentricity , @xmath187 , obtained from the monte carlo glauber simulation . @xmath187 is highly consistent with 0 for peripheral events , and goes above ( below ) 0 for the parameter set of case 1 ( case 2 ) in central collisions , because the ru ( zr ) nucleus is more deformed . the relative difference in @xmath15 should closely follow that in eccentricity , so for the centrality range of interest , @xmath162 , the @xmath15-related backgrounds stay almost the same for ru+ru and zr+zr collisions . @xcite further carried out the projection for the @xmath31 measurements in ru+ru and zr+zr at 200 gev ( 400 million events for each collision type ) , and concluded that a @xmath188 significance can be achieved for the relative difference in the observable between the two collision systems , assuming the flow backgrounds take up to two - thirds of the observable . the results strongly suggest that the isobaric collisions can serve as an ideal tool to disentangle the signal of the chiral magnetic effect from the @xmath15-driven backgrounds . the isobaric collisions may also be used to disentangle the signal of the cmw from background effects . the physics of anomalous transport is at the heart of qcd as a non - abelian gauge theory . the interplay of quantum anomalies with magnetic field and vorticity induces a variety of novel transport phenomena in chiral systems . in heavy - ion collisions , these phenomena make a unique probe to the topological properties of the qgp by measuring the charge dependence of the azimuthal distributions of the produced hadrons . the experimental data from relativistic heavy ion collider at bnl and the large hadron collider at cern provide an evidence for the predicted effects , with magnitude consistent with theoretical estimates . there exist known conventional backgrounds to all of these experimental observables . however at present there is no compelling alternative explanation that can describe all of the data without invoking the anomalous chiral effects . nevertheless , much remains to be done both in experiment and theory to substantiate the existing evidence , and we outlined a few such programs that hopefully will be accomplished in the near future . we thank huan huang and other members of the ucla heavy ion physics group for discussions . this work is supported by a grant ( no . de - fg02 - 88er40424 ) from u.s . department of energy , office of nuclear physics . the authors declare that there is no conflict of interest regarding the publication of this paper . d. e. kharzeev , l. d. mclerran and h. j. warringa , nucl . a * 803 * , 227 ( 2008 ) . d. kharzeev , phys . b * 633 * , 260 ( 2006 ) . d. kharzeev and a. zhitnitsky , nucl . a * 797 * , 67 ( 2007 ) . d. kharzeev , a. krasnitz and r. venugopalan , phys . b * 545 * , 298 ( 2002 ) . i. iatrakis , s. lin and y. yin , phys . lett . * 114 * , 252301 ( 2015 ) . k. fukushima , d. e. kharzeev and h. j. warringa , phys . 104 , 212001 ( 2010 ) . a. m. poskanzer and s. voloshin , phys . c * 58 * , 1671 ( 1998 ) . d. e. kharzeev and d. t. son , phys * 106 * ( 2011 ) 062301 . d. t. son and a. r. zhitnitsky , phys d * 70 * 074018 ( 2004 ) . m. a. metlitski and a. r. zhitnitsky , phys . d * 72 * 045011 ( 2005 ) . y. burnier , d. e. kharzeev , j. liao and h .- u . yee , 052303 ( 2011 ) . g. m. newman , jhep * 0601 * 158 ( 2006 ) . x. g. huang and j. liao , phys . lett . * 110 * , 232302 ( 2013 ) . y. jiang , x. g. huang and j. liao , phys . d * 91 * , 045001 ( 2015 ) . y. jiang , x. g. huang and j. liao , phys . d * 92 * , 071501 ( 2015 ) . kharzeev , j. liao , s.a . voloshin and g. wang , prog . 88 * , 1 ( 2016 ) . a. bzdak , v. skokov , phys . b * 710 * , 171 ( 2012 ) . deng , x.g . huang , phys . c * 85 * , 044907 ( 2012 ) ; phys . b * 742 * , 296 ( 2015 ) . j. bloczynski , x.g . huang , x. zhang , j. liao , phys . b * 718 * , 1529 ( 2013 ) . l. mclerran , v. skokov , nuclear phys . a * 929 * , 184 ( 2014 ) . x. guo , s. shi , n. xu , z. xu , p. zhuang . u. gursoy , d. kharzeev , k. rajagopal , phys . c * 89(5 ) * , 054905 ( 2014 ) . k. tuchin , adv . high energy phys . * 2013 * , 490495 ( 2013 ) . y. hirono , m. hongo , and t. hirano , phys . c * 90 * , 021903 ( 2014 ) . v. voronyuk , v. d. toneev , s. a. voloshin , and w. cassing , phys . 064903 ( 2014 ) . l. adamczyk _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , arxiv:1608.04100 . b. i. abelev _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . * 101 * , 252301 ( 2008 ) . y. jiang , z.w . lin , j. liao , arxiv:1602.06580 . baznat , k.k . gudima , a.s . sorin , o.v . teryaev , phys . c * 93 * , 031902 ( 2016 ) . f. becattini _ _ , arxiv:1501.04468 . f. becattini , l. csernai , d.j . wang , phys . c * 88 ( 3 ) * , 034905 ( 2013 ) . s. floerchinger , u.a . wiedemann , j. high energy phys . * 1111 * , 100 ( 2011 ) . gao , b. qi , s.y . wang , phys . d * 90 ( 8) * , 083001 ( 2014 ) . isaac upsal _ [ star collaboration ] , j. phys . * 736 * , 012016 ( 2016 ) . star collaboration , star note * 0598 * , https://drupal.star.bnl.gov/star/starnotes/public/sn0598 . a.h . tang and g. wang , phys . c * 94 * , 024920 ( 2016 ) . y. hirono , d. e. kharzeev , and y. yin , phys . d * 92 * , 125031 ( 2015 ) . a. ipp , a. di piazza , j. evers , and c. h. keitel , phys . lett . b * 666 * , 315 ( 2008 ) . k. a. mamo and h. u. yee , phys . d * 88 * , 114029 ( 2013 ) . liang and x .- wang , phys . * 94 * , 102301 ( 2005 ) . m. baznat , k. gudima , a. sorin , and o. teryaev , phys . c * 88 * , 061901 ( 2013 ) . deng and x .- g . huang , phys . c * 93 * , 064907 ( 2016 ) l. adamczyk _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . c * 88 * 064911 ( 2013 ) . s. a. voloshin , phys . c * 70 * , 057901 ( 2004 ) [ hep - ph/0406311 ] . b. i. abelev _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . 103 * 251601 ( 2009 ) . 7 i. abelev _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . c * 81 * 54908 ( 2010 ) . a. bzdak , v. koch and j. liao , phys . c * 81 * 031901 ( 2010 ) . n. n. ajitanand , s. esumi , r. a. lacey ( phenix collaboration ) , in : proc . of the rbrc workshops , vol.*96 * , 230 ( 2010 ) : p- and cp - odd ects in hot and dense matter " . b. i. abelev , 021301 ( 2013 ) . n. n. ajitanand , r. a. lacey , a. taranenko and j. m. alexander , phys . c * 83 * 011901 ( 2011 ) . r. l. ray and r. s. longacre , arxiv : nucl - ex/0008009 . s. a. bass _ et al . * 41 * 255 ( 1998 ) . m. gyulassy and x .- wang , comput . * 83 * 307 ( 1994);x.n . wang and m.gyulassy , phys . d * 44 * 3501 ( 1991 ) . f. zhao ( star collaboration ) , nucl . a * 931 * ( 2014 ) 746 . l. adamczyk _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . c * 89 * , 044908 ( 2014 ) . l. adamczyk _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . * 113 * ( 2014 ) 052302 . a. bzdak , v. koch and j. liao , phys . c * 83 * 014905 ( 2011 ) . s. pratt , s. schlichting and s. gavin , phys . c * 84 * , 024909 ( 2011 ) . a. bzdak , v. koch and j. liao , lect . notes phys . * 871 * 503 ( 2013 ) [ arxiv:1207.7327 [ nucl - th ] ] . s. schlichting and s. pratt , phys . c * 83 * , 014913 ( 2011 ) . f. wen , l. wen and g. wang , arxiv:1608.03205 . [ phobos collaboration ] , phys . c * 83 * , 024913 ( 2011 ) . b.b back _ et al . _ [ phobos collaboration ] , phys . c * 72 * , 051901(r ) ( 2005 ) . b. zhang , c.m . ko , b .- a . li and z .- w . lin , phys . c * 61 * , 067901 ( 2000 ) . lin , c.m . ko , b .- a . li and b. zhang , phys . c * 72 * , 064901 ( 2005 ) . lin and c.m . ko , phys . c * 65 * , 034904 ( 2002 ) ; a. j. kuhlman and u. w. heinz , phys . rev . c * 72 * , 037901 ( 2005 ) . s. a. voloshin , phys . lett . * 105 * , 172301 ( 2010 ) . l. adamczyk _ et al . _ [ star collaboration ] , phys . * 115 * , 222301 ( 2015 ) . gang wang _ [ star collaboration ] , nucl . phys a * 904 - 905 * , 248c ( 2013 ) . p. tribedy [ star collaboration ] , charge sensitive cumulants and flow in u+u collisions " , workshop on chirality , vorticity and magnetic field in heavy ion collisions , 2016 ; http://starmeetings.physics.ucla.edu/sites/default/files/pritwish_tribedy.pdf . v. skokov , p. sorensen , v. koch , s. schlichting , j. thomas , s. voloshin , g. wang and h .- u . yee , arxiv:1608.00982 . j. bloczynski , x. g. huang , x. zhang and j. liao , nucl . a * 939 * , 85 ( 2015 ) . s. a. voloshin , prog . 67 * , 541 ( 2012 ) . s. a. voloshin [ alice collaboration ] , nucl . phys . a * 904 - 905 * , 90c ( 2013 ) . gorbar , v.a . miransky , i.a . shovkovy , x. wang , phys . d * 88 ( 2 ) * , 025025 ( 2013 ) . j. c. dunlop , m. a. lisa and p. sorensen , phys . c * 84 * , ( 2011 ) 044914 . j. xu , l. -w . chen , c. m. ko and z. -w . lin , phys . c * 85 * , ( 2012 ) 041901 ( 2012 ) . l. adamczyk _ ( star collaboration ) , phys . * 114 * , ( 2015 ) 252302 . ( alice collaboration ) , phys . c * 93 * , 044903 ( 2016 ) . l. adamczyk et al . [ star collaboration ] , phys . lett . * 110 * , 142301 ( 2013 ) . j. m. campbell and m. a. lisa , journal of physics : conference series * 446 * , 012014 ( 2013 ) . y. burnier , d.e . kharzeev , j. liao , h .- u . yee , arxiv : 1208.2537 ( 2012 ) . h. yee and y. yin , phys . c * 89 * ( 2014 ) 044909 . s. a. voloshin and r. belmont , nucl . phys . a * 931 * , 992 ( 2014 ) . a. bzdak and p. bozek , arxiv:1303.1138 . q .- y . shou [ star collaboration ] , nucl . a * 931 * , 758 ( 2014 ) . y. hatta , a. monnai and b. w. xiao , nucl . a * 947 * , 155 ( 2016 ) . shou [ star collaboration ] , charge asymmetry dependence of @xmath189 @xmath15 in au+au collisions at star " , workshop on chirality , vorticity and magnetic field in heavy ion collisions , 2016 ; http://starmeetings.physics.ucla.edu/sites/default/files/qiye_shou.pdf j. schukraft , a. timmins and s. a. voloshin , phys . b * 719 * , 394 ( 2013 ) . j. -y . ollitrault , a. m. poskanzer and s. a. voloshin , phys . c * 80 * , 014904 ( 2009 ) . deng , x .- huang , g .- ma , g. wang , arxiv:1607.04697 . s. raman , c. w. g. nestor , jr and p. tikkanen , atom . data nucl . data tabl . * 78 * , 1 ( 2001 ) . b. pritychenko , m. birch , b. singh and m. horoi , atom . data nucl . data tabl . * 107 * , 1 ( 2016 ) . p. moller , j. r. nix , w. d. myers and w. j. swiatecki , atom . data nucl . data tabl . * 59 * , 185 ( 1995 ) .
Abstract: | [
"various novel transport phenomena in chiral systems result from the interplay of quantum anomalies with magnetic field and vorticity in high - energy heavy - ion collisions , and could survive the expansion of the fireball and be detected in experiments . among them are the chiral magnetic effect , the chiral vortical effect and the chiral magnetic wave , the experimental searches for which have aroused extensive interest . the goal of this review is to describe the current status of experimental studies at relativistic heavy ion collider at bnl and the large hadron collider at cern , and to outline the future work in experiment needed to eliminate the existing uncertainties in the interpretation of the data ."
] | 11,357 | 11,357 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: suppose we are given a finite family of finite or countable sets @xmath1 with distinguished vertices @xmath2 for @xmath3 . the free product of the sets @xmath4 is given by @xmath5 , the set of all finite words of the form @xmath6 such that each letter is an element of @xmath7 and two consecutive letters arise not from the same @xmath4 . we consider a transient markov chain @xmath8 on @xmath9 starting at the empty word @xmath10 , which arises from a convex combination of transition probabilities on the sets @xmath4 . denote by @xmath11 the distribution of @xmath12 . we are interested in whether the sequence @xmath13/n$ ] converges , and if so , to compute this constant . if the limit exists , it is called the _ asymptotic entropy_. in this paper , we study this question for random walks on general free products . in particular , we will derive three different formulas for the entropy by using three different techniques . let us outline some results about random walks on free products : for free products of finite groups , mairesse and mathus @xcite computed an explicit formula for the rate of escape and asymptotic entropy by solving a finite system of polynomial equations . their result remains valid in the case of free products of infinite groups , but one needs then to solve an infinite system of polynomial equations . gilch @xcite computed two different formulas for the rate of escape with respect to the word length of random walks on free products of graphs by different techniques , and also a third formula for free products of ( not necessarily finite ) groups . the techniques of @xcite are adapted to the present setting . asymptotic behaviour of return probabilities of random walks on free products has also been studied in many ways ; e.g. gerl and woess @xcite , @xcite , sawyer @xcite , cartwright and soardi @xcite , and candellero and gilch @xcite . our proof of existence of the entropy envolves generating functions techniques . the techniques we use for rewriting probability generating functions in terms of functions on the factors of the free product were introduced independently and simultaneously by cartwright and soardi @xcite , woess @xcite , voiculescu @xcite and mclaughlin @xcite . in particular , we will see that asymptotic entropy is the rate of escape with respect to a distance function in terms of green functions . while it is well - known by kingman s subadditive ergodic theorem ( see kingman @xcite ) that entropy ( introduced by avez @xcite ) exists for random walks on groups whenever @xmath14<\infty$ ] , existence for random walks on other structures is not known a priori . we are not able to apply kingman s theorem in our present setting , since we have no ( general ) subadditivity and we have only a partial composition law for two elements of the free product . for more details about entropy of random walks on groups we refer to kaimanovich and vershik @xcite and derriennic @xcite . an important link between drifts and harmonic analysis was obtained by he proved that for symmetric finite range random walks on groups the existence of non - trivial bounded harmonic functions is equivalent to a non - zero rate of escape . karlsson and ledrappier @xcite generalized this result to symmetric random walks with finite first moment of the step lengths . this leads to a link between the rate of escape and the entropy of random walks , compare e.g. with kaimanovich and vershik @xcite and erschler and kaimanovich @xcite asked if drift and entropy of random walks on groups vary continuously on the probability measure , which governs the random walk . we prove real - analyticity of the entropy when varying the probabilty measure of constant support ; compare also with the recent work of ledrappier @xcite , who simultaneously proved this property for finite - range random walks on free groups . apart from the proof of existence of the asymptotic entropy @xmath15/n$ ] ( theorem [ thm : entropy ] ) , we will calculate explicit formulas for the entropy ( see theorems [ thm : entropy ] , [ th : entropy2 ] , [ thm : entropy - groups ] and corollary [ cor : entropy - dgf ] ) and we will show that the entropy is non - zero . the technique of our proof of existence of the entropy was motivated by benjamini and peres @xcite , where it is shown that for random walks on groups the entropy equals the rate of escape w.r.t . the greenian distance ; compare also with blachre , hassinsky and mathieu @xcite . we are also able to show that , for random walks on free products of graphs , the asymptotic entropy equals just the rate of escape w.r.t . the greenian distance ( see corollary [ cor : greenroe ] in view of theorem [ thm : entropy ] ) . moreover , we prove convergence in probability and convergence in @xmath16 ( if the non - zero single transition probabilities are bounded away from @xmath17 ) of the sequence @xmath18 to @xmath19 ( see corollary [ cor : entropy3 ] ) , and we show also that @xmath19 can be computed along almost every sample path as the limes inferior of the aforementioned sequence ( corollary [ cor : entropy2 ] ) . in the case of random walks on discrete groups , kingman s subadditive ergodic theorem provides both the almost sure convergence and the convergence in @xmath16 to the asymptotic entropy ; in the case of general free products there is neither a global composition law for elements of the free product nor subadditivity . thus , in the latter case we have to introduce and investigate new processes . the question of almost sure convergence of @xmath20 to some constant @xmath19 , however , remains open . similar results concerning existence and formulas for the entropy are proved in gilch and mller @xcite for random walks on directed covers of graphs . the reasoning of our proofs follows the argumentation in @xcite : we will show that the entropy equals the rate of escape w.r.t . some special length function , and we deduce the proposed properties analogously . in the present case of free products of graphs , the reasoning is getting more complicated due to the more complex structure of free products in contrast to directed covers , although the main results about existence and convergence types are very similar . we will point out these difficulties and main differences to @xcite at the end of section [ subsec : entropy ] . finally , we will link entropy with the rate of escape and the growth rate of the free product , resulting in two inequalities the plan of the paper is as follows : in section [ sec : preliminaries ] we define the random walk on the free product and the associated generating functions . in section [ sec : entropy ] we prove existence of the asymptotic entropy and give also an explicit formula for it . another formula is derived in section [ sec : dgf ] with the help of double generating functions and a theorem of sawyer and steger @xcite . in section [ sec : groups ] we use another technique to compute a third explicit formula for the entropy of random walks on free products of ( not necessarily finite ) groups . links entropy with the rate of escape and the growth rate of the free product . sample computations are presented in section [ sec : examples ] . let @xmath21 , where @xmath22 . for each @xmath23 , consider a random walk with transition matrix @xmath24 on a finite or countable state space @xmath4 . we assume that the sets @xmath4 are pairwise disjoint and we exclude the case @xmath25 ( see below for further explanation ) . the corresponding single and @xmath26-step transition probabilities are denoted by @xmath27 and @xmath28 , where @xmath29 . for every @xmath23 , we select an element @xmath30 of @xmath4 as the `` root '' . to help visualize this , we think of graphs @xmath31 with vertex sets @xmath4 and roots @xmath30 such that there is an oriented edge @xmath32 if and only if @xmath33 . thus , we have a natural graph metric on the set @xmath4 . furthermore , we shall assume that for every @xmath23 and every @xmath34 there is some @xmath35 such that @xmath36 . for sake of simplicity we assume @xmath37 for every @xmath23 and @xmath34 . moreover , we assume that the random walks on @xmath4 are _ uniformly irreducible _ , that is , there are @xmath38 and @xmath39 such that for all @xmath29 @xmath40 we set @xmath41 and @xmath42 . for instance , this property is satisfied for nearest neighbour random walks on cayley graphs of finitely generated groups , which are governed by probability measures on the groups . let @xmath43 for every @xmath23 and let @xmath44 . free product _ is given by @xmath45 the elements of @xmath9 are `` words '' with letters , also called _ blocks _ , from the sets @xmath46 such that no two consecutive letters come from the same @xmath4 . the empty word @xmath10 describes the root if @xmath47 and @xmath48 with @xmath49 and @xmath50 then @xmath51 stands for their concatenation as words . this is only a partial composition law , which makes defining the asymptotic entropy more complicated than in the case of free products of _ groups_. in particular , we set @xmath52 for all @xmath23 and @xmath53 . note that @xmath54 and @xmath30 as a word in @xmath9 is identified with @xmath10 . the _ block length _ of a word @xmath55 is given by @xmath56 . additionally , we set @xmath57 . the _ type _ @xmath58 of @xmath59 is defined to be @xmath60 if @xmath61 ; we set @xmath62 . finally , @xmath63 denotes the last letter @xmath64 of @xmath59 . the set @xmath9 can again be interpreted as the vertex set of a graph @xmath65 , which is constructed as follows : take copies of @xmath66 and glue them together at their roots to one single common root , which becomes @xmath10 ; inductively , at each vertex @xmath67 with @xmath68 attach a copy of every @xmath69 , @xmath70 , and so on . thus , we have also a natural graph metric associated to the elements the next step is the construction of a new markov chain on the _ free product_. for this purpose , we lift @xmath24 to a transition matrix @xmath71 on @xmath9 : if @xmath72 with @xmath73 and @xmath74 , then @xmath75 . otherwise we set @xmath76 . we choose @xmath77 with @xmath78 . then we obtain a new transition matrix on @xmath9 given by @xmath79 the random walk on @xmath9 starting at @xmath10 , which is governed by @xmath80 , is described by the sequence of random variables @xmath8 . for @xmath81 , the associated single and @xmath26-step transition probabilities are denoted by @xmath82 and @xmath83 . thus , @xmath80 governs a nearest neighbour random walk on the graph @xmath65 , where @xmath80 arises from a convex combination of the nearest neighbour random walks on the graphs @xmath31 . theorem 3.3 in @xcite shows existence ( including a formula ) of a positive number @xmath84 such that @xmath85 almost surely . the number @xmath84 is called the _ rate of escape w.r.t . the block length_. denote by @xmath11 the distribution of @xmath12 . if there is a real number @xmath19 such that @xmath86,\ ] ] then @xmath19 is called the _ asymptotic entropy _ of the process @xmath87 ; we write @xmath88 . if the sets @xmath4 are groups and the random walks @xmath24 are governed by probability measures @xmath89 , existence of the asymptotic entropy rate is well - known , and in this case we even have almost surely ; see derriennic @xcite and kaimanovich and we prove existence of @xmath19 in the case of general free products . our main tool will be the usage of generating functions , which we introduce now . the _ green functions _ related to @xmath24 and @xmath80 are given by @xmath90 where @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath81 . at this point we make the _ basic assumption _ that the radius of convergence @xmath93 of @xmath94 is strictly bigger than @xmath95 . this implies _ transience _ of our random walk on @xmath9 . thus , we may exclude the case @xmath25 , because we get recurrence in this case . for instance , if all @xmath24 govern _ reversible _ markov chains , then @xmath96 ; see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 10.3 ) . furthermore , it is easy to see that @xmath96 holds also if there is some @xmath23 such that @xmath97 for all @xmath98 . the _ first visit generating functions _ related to @xmath24 and @xmath80 are given by @xmath99z^n\ \textrm { and}\\ f(x , y|z ) & : = & \sum_{n\geq 0 } { \mathbb{p}}\bigl[x_n = y,\forall m\leq n-1 : x_m\neq y \mid x_0=x\bigr]z^n,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath100 describes a random walk on @xmath4 governed by @xmath24 . the stopping time of the first return to @xmath10 is defined as for @xmath23 , define @xmath101\,z^n \ \textrm { and } \ \xi_i(z ) : = \frac{\alpha_i z}{1-\overline{h}_i(z)}.\ ] ] we write also @xmath102 , @xmath103 and @xmath104 . observe that @xmath105 ; see ( * ? ? ? * lemma 2.3 ) . we have @xmath106 for all @xmath92 ; see woess ( * ? ? ? * prop . thus , @xmath107 for @xmath108 and @xmath72 , define the stopping times @xmath109 and @xmath110 , which take both values in @xmath111 . then the _ last visit generating functions _ related to @xmath24 and @xmath80 are defined as @xmath112\,z^n,\\ l(x , y|z ) & : = & \sum_{n\geq 0 } { \mathbb{p}}\bigl[x_n = y , t_x > n \mid x_0=x\bigr]\,z^n.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath113 with @xmath114 then @xmath115 this equation is proved completely analogously to ( * ? ? ? if all paths from @xmath72 to @xmath116 have to pass through @xmath117 , then @xmath118 this can be easily checked by conditioning on the last visit of @xmath119 when walking from @xmath120 we have the following important equations , which follow by conditioning on the last visits of @xmath121 and @xmath120 , the first visits of @xmath122 and @xmath119 respectively : @xmath123 g(x , y|z ) & = & g(x , x|z)\cdot l(x , y|z ) = f(x , y|z)\cdot g(y , y|z ) . \end{array}\ ] ] observe that the generating functions @xmath124 and @xmath125 have also radii of convergence strictl bigger than @xmath95 . in this subsection we prove existence of the rate of escape with respect to a specific length function . from this we will deduce existence and a formula for the asymptotic entropy in the upcoming subsection . we assign to each element @xmath108 the `` length '' @xmath126 we extend it to a length function on @xmath9 by assigning to @xmath127 the length @xmath128 observe that the lengths can also be negative . e.g. , this can be interpreted as height differences . the aim of this subsection is to show existence of a number @xmath129 such that the quotient @xmath130 tends to @xmath131 almost surely as @xmath132 . we call @xmath131 the _ rate of escape w.r.t . the length function @xmath133_. we follow now the reasoning of ( * ? ? ? * section 3 ) . denote by @xmath134 the projection of @xmath12 to the first @xmath135 letters . we define the _ @xmath135-th exit time _ as @xmath136 moreover , we define @xmath137 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 . we remark that @xmath140 as @xmath132 , and consequently @xmath141 almost surely for every @xmath142 ; see ( * ? ? ? recall that @xmath143 is just the laster letter of the random word @xmath144 . the process @xmath145 is markovian and has transition probabilities @xmath146 for @xmath147 and @xmath148 ; see ( * ? ? ? * lemma 3.4 ) . this process is positive recurrent with invariant probability measure @xmath149 see ( * ? ? ? * section 3 ) . furthermore , the rate of escape w.r.t . the block length exists almost surely and is given by the almost sure constant limit @xmath150 ( see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.3 ) ) , where @xmath151 [ lemma : tildew - process ] the process @xmath152 is markovian and has transition probabilities @xmath153 furthermore , the process is positive recurrent with invariant probability measure @xmath154 _ remark : _ observe that the transition probabilities @xmath155 of @xmath152 do not depend on @xmath156 . therefore , we will write sometimes an asterisk instead of @xmath156 . by ( * ? ? ? * section 3 ) , the process @xmath157 is markovian and has transition probabilities @xmath158 where @xmath159 $ ] for @xmath160 . thus , @xmath161 is also markovian and has the following transition probabilities if @xmath147 : @xmath162 in the third equality we conditioned on the last visit of @xmath10 before finally walking from @xmath10 to @xmath163 and we remark that @xmath164 . a straight - forward computation shows that @xmath165 is the invariant probability measure of @xmath152 , where we write @xmath166 : @xmath167 now we are able to prove the following : [ prop : ell - existence ] there is a number @xmath168 such that @xmath169 define @xmath170 by @xmath171 . then @xmath172 . an application of the ergodic theorem for positive recurrent markov chains yields @xmath173 if the integral on the right hand side exists . we now show that this property holds . observe that the values @xmath174 are uniformly bounded from above for all @xmath175 : @xmath176 for @xmath177 , denote by @xmath178 the smallest @xmath98 such that @xmath179 . uniform irreducibility of the random walk @xmath24 on @xmath4 implies that there are some @xmath180 and @xmath181 such that for all @xmath182 , @xmath183 with @xmath184 we have @xmath185 for some @xmath186 . thus , for @xmath175 we have @xmath187 observe that the inequality @xmath188 holds if and only if @xmath189 . define the sets @xmath190 ) . we can now prove existence of @xmath191 : @xmath192 since @xmath193 ; see ( * ? ? ? * proof of prop . 3.2 ) . from this follows that @xmath194 tends to @xmath195 almost surely . the next step is to show that @xmath196 to prove this , assume now that we have the representations @xmath197 and @xmath198 . define @xmath199 & & \quad + \bigl(\|x_n\|-{\mathbf{k}}(n)\bigr ) \cdot \big| \log ( 1-\xi_{\max})\bigr|\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath200 & \leq & 3 \cdot m\cdot ( n-{\mathbf{e}_{{\mathbf{k}}(n)}}).\end{aligned}\ ] ] dividing the last inequality by @xmath26 and letting @xmath132 provides analogously to nagnibeda and woess ( * ? ? ? * section 5 ) that @xmath201 almost surely . recall also that @xmath202 and @xmath203 almost surely ; compare ( * ? ? ? * proof of theorem d ) and ( * ? ? ? * prop . 3.2 , thm . now we can conclude : @xmath204 we now compute the constant @xmath195 from the last proposition explicitly : @xmath205 we conclude this subsection with the following observation : [ cor : greenroe ] the rate of escape @xmath131 is non - negative and it is the rate of escape w.r.t . the greenian metric , which is given by @xmath206 . that is , @xmath207 by ( [ gl - equations ] ) , we get @xmath208 since @xmath209 it remains to show that @xmath210 is uniformly bounded in @xmath72 : for @xmath211 , the _ first visit generating function _ is defined as @xmath212\,z^n.\ ] ] therefore , @xmath213 since @xmath214 for all @xmath215 , @xmath216 and @xmath217 is continuous , stricly increasing and strictly convex , we must have @xmath218 , that is , @xmath219 . this finishes the proof . in this subsection we will prove that @xmath131 equals the asymptotic entropy , and we will give explicit formulas for it . the technique of the proof which we will give was motivated by benjamini and peres @xcite , where it is shown that the asymptotic entropy of random walks on discrete groups equals the rate of escape w.r.t . the greenian distance . the proof follows the same reasoning as in gilch and mller @xcite . recall that we made the assumption that the spectral radius of @xmath87 is strictly smaller than @xmath95 , that is , the green function @xmath220 has radius of convergence @xmath96 . moreover , the functions @xmath221 , @xmath222 , have radius of convergence bigger than @xmath95 . recall that @xmath223 for every @xmath222 . thus , we can choose @xmath224 such that @xmath225 for all @xmath222 . we now need the following three technical lemmas : [ lemma : prob - bound ] for all @xmath226 , @xmath227 denote by @xmath228 the circle with radius @xmath229 in the complex plane centered at @xmath17 . a straightforward computation shows for @xmath230 : @xmath231 let be @xmath232 . an application of fubini s theorem yields @xmath233 since @xmath234 is analytic on @xmath228 , we have @xmath235 for all @xmath236 . thus , @xmath237 iterated applications of equations ( [ l - equation ] ) and ( [ gl - equations ] ) provide @xmath238 since @xmath239 , we obtain @xmath240 [ cut - lemma ] let @xmath241 , @xmath242 , @xmath243 be sequences of strictly positive numbers with @xmath244 . assume that @xmath245 and that @xmath246 for all @xmath247 . then @xmath248 . under the made assumptions it can not be that @xmath249 for every indeed , assume that this would hold . choose any @xmath250 . then there is a subseqence @xmath251 with @xmath252 . moreover , there is @xmath253 such that @xmath254 for all @xmath255 . but this implies @xmath256 the last inequality holds for every @xmath250 , yielding that @xmath257 , a contradiction . thus , there is some @xmath258 such that @xmath259 for all @xmath260 . we get for all @xmath260 : @xmath261 taking limits yields that @xmath262 tends to @xmath263 , since the leftmost and rightmost side of this inequality chain tend to @xmath263 . for the next lemma recall the definition of @xmath264 from @xmath265 . [ lemma : sum - bounds ] for @xmath98 , consider the function @xmath266 defined by @xmath267 then there are constants @xmath268 and @xmath269 such that @xmath270 for all @xmath98 and @xmath72 . assume that @xmath271 . recall from the proof of corollary [ cor : greenroe ] that we have @xmath272 . therefore , @xmath273 that is @xmath274 for the upper bound , observe that , by uniform irreducibility , @xmath72 with @xmath271 can be reached from @xmath10 in @xmath275 steps with a probability of at least @xmath276 , where @xmath277 from ( [ def : uniform - irred ] ) is independent from @xmath120 . thus , at least one of the summands in @xmath278 has a value greater or equal to @xmath279 . thus , @xmath280 . now we can state and prove our first main result : [ thm : entropy ] assume @xmath96 . then the asymptotic entropy exists and is given by @xmath281 by ( [ gl - equations ] ) we can rewrite @xmath131 as @xmath282 since @xmath283 we have @xmath284 the next aim is to prove @xmath285 \leq \ell$ ] . we now apply lemma [ cut - lemma ] by setting @xmath286 by lemma [ lemma : prob - bound ] , @xmath287 therefore , @xmath288 decays faster than any geometric sequence . applying lemma [ cut - lemma ] yields @xmath289 by lemma [ lemma : sum - bounds ] , we may apply the dominated convergence theorem and get : @xmath290 recall that _ shannon s inequality _ gives @xmath291 for every finitely supported probability measure @xmath292 on @xmath9 . we apply now this inequality by setting @xmath293 : @xmath294 now we can conclude with fatou s lemma : @xmath295 thus , @xmath296 $ ] exists and the limit equals @xmath131 . the rest follows from ( [ ell0-limit ] ) and ( [ ch - formel ] ) . we now give another formula for the asymptotic entropy which shows that it is strictly positive . [ th : entropy2 ] assume @xmath96 . then the asymptotic entropy is given by @xmath297 _ remarks : _ observe that the sum on the right hand side of theorem [ th : entropy2 ] equals the entropy rate ( for positive recurrent markov chains ) of @xmath152 , which is defined by the almost sure constant limit @xmath298 where @xmath299 is the joint distribution of @xmath300 . that is , @xmath301 . for more details , we refer e.g. to cover and thomas ( * ? ? ? * chapter 4 ) . at this point it is essential that we have defined the length function @xmath133 with the help of the functions @xmath302 and not by the greenian metric . for a moment let be @xmath303 . then : @xmath304 we now replace @xmath120 by @xmath305 in the last equation : since @xmath130 tends to @xmath19 almost surely , the subsequence @xmath306 converges also to @xmath19 . since @xmath307 and @xmath308 , we get @xmath309 where @xmath310 and @xmath311 . by positive recurrence of @xmath152 , an application of the ergodic theorem yields @xmath312 whenever @xmath313 . obviously , for every @xmath314 @xmath315 since @xmath316 we get @xmath317 whenever @xmath313 . in particular , @xmath318 since @xmath319 by ( * ? ? ? * section 4 ) . it remains to show that it can not be that @xmath320 . for this purpose , assume now @xmath320 . define for @xmath258 the function @xmath321 by @xmath322 then @xmath323 observe that @xmath324 as @xmath325 . since @xmath326 and @xmath320 by assumption there is for every @xmath327 and almost every trajectory of @xmath328 an almost surely finite random time @xmath329 such that for all @xmath330 @xmath331 on the other hand side there is for every @xmath332 , every small @xmath333 and almost every trajectory an almost surely finite random time @xmath334 such that for all @xmath335 @xmath336 furthermore , since @xmath337 and @xmath338 there is an almost surely finite random time @xmath339 such that for all @xmath340 and all @xmath341 and @xmath342 @xmath343 choose now @xmath344 . then we get the desired contradiction , when we substitute in equality ( [ q - entropy ] ) the vertex @xmath120 by @xmath305 with @xmath340 , divide by @xmath345 on both sides and see that the left side is in @xmath346 and the rightmost side is bigger than @xmath347 . this finishes the proof of theorem [ th : entropy2 ] . [ cor : entropy2 ] assume @xmath96 . then we have for almost every path of the random walk @xmath87 @xmath348 recall inequality ( [ equ : liminf - h ] ) . integrating both sides of this inequality yields together with the inequality chain ( [ eq : entropy - final ] ) that @xmath349 providing that @xmath350 for almost every realisation of the random walk . the following lemma gives some properties concerning general measure theory : [ lemma : measuretheory ] let @xmath351 be a sequence of non - negative random variables and suppose that @xmath352 almost surely and @xmath353 = c$ ] . then the following holds : 1 . @xmath354 , that is , @xmath355 converges in probability to @xmath263 . 2 . if @xmath355 is uniformly bounded then @xmath356 , that is , @xmath357 as @xmath132 . first , we prove convergence in probability of @xmath351 . for every @xmath358 , there is some index @xmath359 such that for all @xmath360 @xmath361 furthermore , due to the above made assumptions on @xmath362 there is for every @xmath363 some index @xmath364 such that for all @xmath365 @xmath366 > 1-\delta_2.\ ] ] since @xmath367 it must be that for every arbitrary but fixed @xmath333 , every @xmath368 and for all @xmath26 big enough @xmath369\cdot ( c-\delta_1 ) + { \mathbb{p}}\bigl[z_n > c + { \varepsilon}\bigr]\cdot ( { \varepsilon}+\delta_1 ) \leq \int z_n\,d{\mathbb{p}}\leq c+\delta_1,\ ] ] or equivalently , @xmath370 \leq \frac{c+\delta_1 -{\mathbb{p}}\bigl[z_n > c-\delta_1\bigr]\cdot ( c-\delta_1)}{{\varepsilon}+\delta_1}.\ ] ] letting @xmath371 we get @xmath372 \leq \frac{2\delta_1}{{\varepsilon}+\delta_1}.\ ] ] since we can choose @xmath373 arbitrarily small we get @xmath370 \xrightarrow{n\to\infty } 0 \quad \textrm { for all } { \varepsilon}>0.\ ] ] this yields convergence in probability of @xmath355 to @xmath263 . in order to prove the second part of the lemma we define for any small @xmath333 and @xmath98 the events @xmath374 \ \textrm { and } b_{n,{\varepsilon}}:=\bigl[|z_n - c| > { \varepsilon}\bigr].\ ] ] for arbitrary but fixed @xmath333 , convergence in probability of @xmath355 to @xmath263 gives an integer @xmath375 such that @xmath376<{\varepsilon}$ ] for all @xmath377 . since @xmath378 is assumed to be uniformly bounded , we get for @xmath379 : @xmath380 thus , we have proved the second part of the lemma . we can apply the last lemma immediately to our setting : [ cor : entropy3 ] assume @xmath96 . then we have the following types of convergence : 1 . convergence in probability : @xmath381 2 . assume that there is @xmath382 such that @xmath383 whenever @xmath384 . then : @xmath385 setting @xmath386 and applying lemma [ lemma : measuretheory ] yields the claim . note that the assumption @xmath383 yields @xmath387 . the assumption of the second part of the last corollary is obviously satisfied if we consider free products of _ finite _ graphs . the reasoning in our proofs for existence of the entropy and its different properties ( in particular , the reasoning in section [ subsec : entropy ] ) is very similar to the argumentation in @xcite . however , the structure of free products of graphs is more complicated than in the case of directed covers as considered in @xcite . we outline the main differences to the reasoning in the aforementionend article . first , in @xcite a very similar rate of escape ( compare with proposition [ prop : ell - existence ] ) is considered , which arises from a length function induced by last visit generating functions . while the proof of existence of the rate of escape in @xcite is easy to check , we have to make more effort in the case of free products , since @xmath388 is not necessarily bounded for @xmath34 . additionally , one has to study the various ingridients of the proof more carefully , since non - trivial loops are possible in our setting in contrast to random walks on trees . secondly , in @xcite the invariant measure @xmath389 of our proof collapses to @xmath390 , that is , in @xcite one has to study the sequence @xmath391 , while in our setting we have to study the more complex sequence @xmath392 ; compare with lemma [ lemma : tildew - process ] and proposition [ prop : ell - existence ] . in this section we derive another formula for the asymptotic entropy . the main tool is the following theorem of sawyer and steger ( * ? ? ? * theorem 2.2 ) : [ sawyer ] let @xmath393 be a sequence of real - valued random variables such that , for some @xmath394 , @xmath395 where @xmath396 and @xmath397 are analytic for @xmath398 and . denote by @xmath399 and @xmath400 the partial derivatives of @xmath156 with respect to @xmath401 and @xmath163 . then @xmath402 setting @xmath403 and @xmath404 the expectation in theorem [ sawyer ] becomes @xmath405 we define for @xmath222 , @xmath406 : @xmath407 finally , @xmath408 is defined by @xmath409 with these definitions we have @xmath410 and @xmath411 . simple computations analogously to ( * ? ? ? * lemma 4.2 , corollary 4.3 ) yield @xmath412 we now define @xmath413 and @xmath414 and apply theorem [ sawyer ] by differentiating @xmath415 and evaluating the derivatives at @xmath416 : @xmath417 [ cor : entropy - dgf ] assume @xmath96 . then the entropy can be rewritten as @xmath418 @xmath419 in this section let each @xmath4 be a finitely generated group @xmath420 with identity @xmath421 . we assume that the @xmath4 s are pairwise disjoint . the free product is again a group with concatenation ( followed by iterated cancellations and contractions ) as group operation . we write @xmath422 . suppose we are given a probability measure @xmath89 on @xmath423 for every @xmath222 governing a random walk on @xmath420 , that is , @xmath424 for all @xmath425 . let @xmath426 be a family of strictly positive real numbers with @xmath427 . then the random walk on the free product @xmath428 is defined by the transition probabilities @xmath429 , where @xmath430 analogously , @xmath431 denotes the @xmath26-th convolution power of @xmath292 . the random walk on @xmath432 starting at the identity @xmath433 of @xmath432 is again denoted by the sequence @xmath87 . in particular , the radius of convergence of the associated green function is strictly bigger than @xmath95 ; see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 10.10 , corollary 12.5 ) . in the case of free products of groups it is well - known that the entropy exists and can be written as @xmath434 see derriennic @xcite , kaimanovich and vershik @xcite and blachre , hassinsky and mathieu @xcite . for free products of _ finite _ groups , mairesse and mathus @xcite give an explicit formula for @xmath19 , which remains also valid for free products of countable groups , but in the latter case one needs the solution of an infinite system of polynomial equations . in the following we will derive another formula for the entropy , which holds also for free products of _ infinite _ groups . we set @xmath435 . observe that transitivity yields @xmath436 . thus , @xmath437 first , we rewrite the following expectations as @xmath438 thus , @xmath439 recall that @xmath440 almost surely . that is , @xmath12 converges almost surely to a random infinite word @xmath441 of the form @xmath442 , where two consecutive letters are not from the same @xmath443 . denote by @xmath444 the first letter of @xmath441 . let be @xmath445 . for @xmath446 , the integrand in @xmath447 is constant : if @xmath448 then @xmath449 and if @xmath450 then @xmath451 by ( * ? ? ? * section 5 ) , for @xmath23 and @xmath452 , @xmath453 = 1-(1-\xi_i)\,g_i(o_i , o_i|\xi_i ) \quad \textrm { and}\\ { \mathbb{p}}[x_\infty^{(1)}=g ] & = & f(o_i , g|\xi_i ) \ , ( 1-\xi_i)\,g_i(o_i , o_i|\xi_i ) = ( 1-\xi_i)\,g_i(o_i , g|\xi_i).\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall that @xmath454 for each @xmath455 . we get : [ thm : entropy - groups ] whenever @xmath456 for all @xmath222 , that is , when all random walks on the factors @xmath420 have finite single - step entropy , then the asymptotic entropy @xmath19 of the random walk on @xmath432 is given by @xmath457,\ ] ] where @xmath458 consider the sequence @xmath459 . if this sequence converges , its limit must equal @xmath19 . by the above made considerations we get @xmath460 \log \frac{f_i(o_i , gg'|\xi_i)}{f_i(o_i , g'|\xi_i)}\biggr],\end{aligned}\ ] ] if the sum on the right hand side is finite . we have now established the proposed formula , but it remains to verify finiteness of the sum above . this follows from the following observations : @xmath461 is finite . observe that @xmath462 for @xmath463 . thus , @xmath464 this proves claim a. @xmath465 is finite . observe that @xmath466 . obviously , @xmath467 for @xmath468 set @xmath469 . then : @xmath470\cdot \big| \log g_i(o_i , g'|\xi_i)\bigr| \\ & = & \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i^\times } ( 1-\xi_i)\cdot g_i(o_i , g'|\xi_i)\cdot \big| \log g_i(o_i , g'|\xi_i)\bigr|\\ & = & \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i^\times } ( 1-\xi_i)\cdot \sum_{n\in n(g ' ) } \mu_i^{(n)}(g')\cdot \xi_i^n\cdot \big| \log g_i(o_i , g'|\xi_i)\bigr|\\ & \leq & \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i^\times } ( 1-\xi_i)\cdot \sum_{n\in n(g ' ) } \mu_i^{(n)}(g')\cdot \xi_i^n\cdot \max\bigl\lbrace -\log \bigl(\mu_i^{(n)}(g')\,\xi_i^n\bigr ) , -\log(1-\xi_i)\bigr\rbrace\\ & \leq & ( 1-\xi_i ) \cdot \sum_{n\in n(g ' ) } n\,\xi_i^n \cdot\underbrace{\frac{-1}{n } \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i } \mu_i^{(n)}(g ' ) \log \mu_i^{(n)}(g')}_{(\ast ) } - ( 1-\xi_i)\,\log \xi_i \sum_{n\geq 1 } n\,\xi_i^n\\ & & \quad - ( 1-\xi_i)\,\log ( 1-\xi_i ) \sum_{n\geq 1 } \xi_i^n.\end{aligned}\ ] ] recall that @xmath471 together with kingman s subadditive ergodic theorem implies existence of a constant @xmath472 with @xmath473 thus , if @xmath98 is large enough , the sum @xmath474 is in the interval @xmath475 for any arbitrarily small @xmath333 . that is , the sum @xmath474 is uniformly bounded for all @xmath98 . from this follows that the rightmost side of the last inequality chain is finite . furthermore , we have for each @xmath455 with @xmath476 : @xmath477\cdot \big| \log g_i(o_i , gg'|\xi_i)\bigr|\\ & = & \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i^\times } ( 1-\xi_i)\cdot g_i(o_i , g'|\xi_i)\cdot \bigl| \log g_i(o_i , gg'|\xi_i)\bigr|\\ & = & \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i^\times } ( 1-\xi_i ) \cdot\sum_{n\in n(g ' ) } \mu_i^{(n)}(g')\cdot \xi_i^n\cdot \bigl| \log g_i(o_i , gg'|\xi_i)\bigr|\\ & \leq & \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i^\times } ( 1-\xi_i)\cdot \sum_{n\in n(g ' ) } \mu_i^{(n)}(g')\cdot \xi_i^n \cdot \max\bigl\lbrace -\log \bigl(\mu_i(g)\,\mu_i^{(n)}(g')\,\xi_i^{n+1}\bigr),-\log(1-\xi_i)\bigr\rbrace\\ & \leq & -(1-\xi_i ) \cdot \sum_{n\in n(g ' ) } \xi_i^n \cdot \sum_{g'\in\gamma_i } \mu_i^{(n)}(g ' ) \log \mu_i^{(n)}(g ' ) - ( 1-\xi_i)\cdot \log \xi_i \cdot \sum_{n\geq 1 } ( n+1)\,\xi_i^n\\ & & \quad - \log \mu_i(g)- \log ( 1-\xi_i).\end{aligned}\ ] ] if we sum up over all @xmath156 with @xmath478 , we get : @xmath479 convergence of @xmath480 follows from ( [ convergence - hi ] ) , @xmath481 converges since @xmath105 and @xmath482 is convergent by assumption @xmath471 . this finishes the proof of claim b , and thus the proof of the theorem . erschler and kaimanovich @xcite asked if drift and entropy of random walks on groups depend continuously on the probability measure , which governs the random walk . ledrappier @xcite proves in his recent , simultaneous paper that drift and entropy of finite - range random walks on free groups vary analytically with the probability measure of constant support . by theorem [ thm : entropy - groups ] , we are even able to show continuity for free products of finitely generated groups , but restricted to nearest neighbour random walks with fixed set of generators . [ cor : analyticity ] let @xmath420 be generated as a semigroup by @xmath483 . denote by @xmath484 the set of probability measures @xmath89 on @xmath483 with @xmath485 for all @xmath486 . furthermore , we write @xmath487 . then the entropy function @xmath488 is real - analytic . the claim follows directly with the formula given in theorem [ thm : entropy - groups ] : the involved generating functions @xmath489 and @xmath490 are analytic when varying the probability measure of constant support , and the values @xmath491 can also be rewritten as @xmath492 where @xmath493 . this yields the claim . _ remarks : _ 1 . corollary [ cor : analyticity ] holds also for the case of free products of _ finite _ graphs , if one varies the transition probabilities continously under the assumption that the sets @xmath494 remain constant : one has to rewrite @xmath491 as power series in terms of ( finitely many ) @xmath495 and gets analyticity with the formula given in theorem [ thm : entropy ] . 2 . analyticity holds also for the drift ( w.r.t . the block length and w.r.t . the natural graph metric ) of nearest neighbour random walks due to the formulas given 3 . the formula for entropy and drift given in mairesse and mathus @xcite for random walks on free products of _ finite _ groups depends also analytically on the transition probabilities . in this section we consider the case of free products of _ finite _ sets @xmath1 , where @xmath4 has @xmath496 vertices . we want to establish a connection between asymptotic entropy , rate of escape and the volume growth rate of the free product @xmath9 . for @xmath497 , let @xmath498 be the set of all words of @xmath9 of block length @xmath26 . the following lemmas give an answer how fast the free product grows . the sphere growth rate w.r.t . the block length is given by @xmath499 where @xmath500 is the perron - frobenius eigenvalue of the @xmath501-matrix @xmath502 with @xmath503 for @xmath504 and @xmath505 otherwise . denote by @xmath506 the @xmath507-diagonal matrix , which has entries @xmath508-vector with all entries equal to @xmath95 . thus , we can write @xmath509 let @xmath510 and @xmath511 be eigenvectors of @xmath269 w.r.t . the perron - frobenius then @xmath512 are some constants independent from @xmath26 . thus , @xmath513 recall from the perron - frobenius theorem that @xmath514 for each @xmath182 ; in particular , @xmath515 . we also take a look on the natural graph metric and its growth rate . for this purpose , we define @xmath516 that is , the set of all vertices in @xmath9 which are at distance @xmath26 to the root @xmath10 w.r.t . the natural graph metric . we now construct a new graph , whose adjacency matrix allows us to describe the exponential growth of @xmath517 as @xmath132 . for this purpose , we visualize the sets @xmath1 as graphs @xmath518 with vertex sets @xmath1 equipped with the following edges : for @xmath29 , there is a directed edge from @xmath120 to @xmath119 if and only if @xmath33 . consider now directed spanning trees @xmath519 of the graphs @xmath518 such that the graph distances of vertices in @xmath520 to the root @xmath30 remain the same as in @xmath31 . we now investigate the free product @xmath521 , which is again a tree . we make the crucial observation that @xmath522 can be seen as the directed cover of a finite directed graph @xmath523 , where @xmath523 is defined in the following way : 1 . the vertex set of @xmath523 is given by @xmath524 with root @xmath10 . the edges of @xmath523 are given as follows : first , we add all edges inherited from one of the trees @xmath519 , where @xmath10 plays the role of @xmath30 for each @xmath23 . secondly , we add for all @xmath23 and every @xmath525 an edge from @xmath120 to each @xmath526 , @xmath70 , whenever there is an edge from @xmath30 to @xmath119 in @xmath527 . the tree @xmath522 can be seen as a _ periodic tree _ , which is also called a _ tree with finitely many cone types _ ; for more details we refer to lyons @xcite and nagnibeda and woess @xcite . now we are able to state the following lemma : the sphere growth rate w.r.t . the natural graph metric defined by @xmath528 exists . moreover , we have the equation @xmath529 , where @xmath530 is the perron - frobenius eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of the graph @xmath523 . since the graph metric remains invariant under the restriction of @xmath9 to @xmath522 and since it is well - known that the growth rate exists for periodic trees ( see we have existence of the limit @xmath531 . more precisely , @xmath532 tends to the perron - frobenius eigenvalue of the adjacency matrix of @xmath523 as @xmath132 . for sake of completeness , we remark that the root of @xmath522 plays a special role ( as a cone type ) but this does not affect the application of the results about directed covers to our case . for @xmath533 , we write @xmath534 . now we can prove : the volume growth w.r.t . the block length , w.r.t . the natural graph metric respectively , is given by @xmath535 for ease of better readability , we omit the subindex @xmath533 in the following , since the proofs for @xmath536 and @xmath537 are completely analogous . choose any small @xmath538 . then there is some @xmath539 such that for all @xmath540 @xmath541 write @xmath542 . then for @xmath543 : @xmath544{c_\varepsilon + \sum_{k = k_\varepsilon}^n \lambda^k e^{k\varepsilon } } = \lambda e^{\varepsilon } \sqrt[n]{\frac{c_\varepsilon}{\lambda^n e^{n\varepsilon } } + \sum_{k = k_\varepsilon}^n \frac{1}{\lambda^{n - k } e^{(n - k)\varepsilon}}}\\ & \leq & \lambda e^{\varepsilon } \sqrt[n]{\frac{c_\varepsilon}{\lambda^n e^{n\varepsilon } } + ( n - k_\varepsilon+1 ) } \xrightarrow{n\to\infty } \lambda e^{\varepsilon}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the last inequality we used the fact @xmath545 . since we can choose @xmath538 arbitrarily small , we get @xmath546 . analogously : @xmath547{c_\varepsilon + \sum_{k = k_\varepsilon}^n \lambda^k e^{-k\varepsilon } } = \lambda \sqrt[n]{\frac{c_\varepsilon}{\lambda^n } + \sum_{k = k_\varepsilon}^n \frac{e^{-k\varepsilon}}{\lambda^{n - k } } } \xrightarrow{n\to\infty } \lambda e^{-\varepsilon}.\ ] ] that is , @xmath548 . for @xmath533 , define @xmath549 by @xmath550 and @xmath551 . then the limits @xmath552 exist ; see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.3 , section 7.ii ) . now we can establish a connection between entropy , rate of escape and volume growth : [ cor : inequalities ] @xmath553 and @xmath554 . let be @xmath533 and @xmath555 . then there is some @xmath556 such that for all @xmath557 @xmath558 that is , @xmath559 if we let @xmath26 tend to infinity and make @xmath560 arbitrarily small , we get the claim . finally , we remark that an analogous inequality for random walks on groups was given by and more generally for space- and time - homogeneous markov chains by kaimanovich and woess ( * ? ? ? * theorem 5.3 ) . consider the graphs @xmath561 and @xmath562 with the transition probabilities sketched in figure [ entropy - bsp2 ] . we set @xmath563 . for the computation of @xmath84 we need the following functions : @xmath564 \xi_1(z ) & = & \frac{z/2}{1-\frac{z}{2}\frac{\xi_2(z)^2}{2}\frac{1}{1-\xi_2(z)^3/2 } } , & \quad & \xi_2(z ) & = & \frac{z/2}{1-\frac{z}{2}\frac{\xi_1(z)^2}{2}\frac{1}{1-\xi_1(z)^2/2}}. \end{array}\ ] ] simple computations with the help of ( * ? ? ? * section 3 ) and mathematica allow us to determine the rate of escape of the random walk on @xmath565 as @xmath566 . for the computation of the entropy , we need also the following generating functions : @xmath567 thus , we get the asymptotic entropy as @xmath568 . [ entropy - bsp2 ] and @xmath562,title="fig:",width=226 ] consider the free product @xmath570 of the _ infinite _ groups @xmath571 with @xmath572 and @xmath573 for each @xmath574 . we set @xmath575 , @xmath576 , @xmath577 and @xmath578 for @xmath579 . define @xmath580\,z^n,\\ \hat f(b|z ) & : = & \sum_{n\geq 1 } { \mathbb{p}}\bigl[y_n = b , \forall m < n : \lambda(y_m)<1\,\bigl|\ , y_0=(0,0)\bigr]\,z^n,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath581 is a random walk on @xmath582 governed by @xmath583 . the above functions satisfy the following system of equations : @xmath584 from this system we obtain explicit formulas for @xmath585 and @xmath586 . we write @xmath587 for @xmath588 . to compute the entropy rate we have to solve the following system of equations : @xmath589 moreover , we need the value @xmath590 . this value can be computed analogously to ( * ? ? ? * section 6.2 ) , that is , @xmath591 has to be computed numerically from the equation @xmath592 solving this equation with mathematica yields @xmath593 . to compute the entropy we have to evaluate the functions @xmath594 at @xmath595 for each @xmath596 . for even @xmath98 , we have the following formulas : @xmath597 for odd @xmath98 , @xmath598 moreover , we define @xmath599 $ ] . this probability can be computed by conditioning on the first step and solving @xmath600 that is , @xmath601 . observe that we get the following estimations : @xmath602 these bounds allow us to cap the sum over all @xmath603 in ( [ equ - mathcalf ] ) and to estimate the tails of these sums . thus , we can compute the entropy rate numerically as @xmath604 . the author is grateful to frdric mathus for discussion on the problems and several hints regarding content and exposition . 99 a. avez . entropie des groupes de type fini . _ c.r.acad.sci.paris sr . , 275:a1363a1366 , 1972 . i. benjamini and y. peres . tree - indexed random walks on groups and first passage percolation . _ probab . theory related fields _ , 98(1 ) : 91112 , 1994 . s. blachre and p. hassinsky and p. mathieu . asymptotic entropy and green speed for random walks on countable groups . _ ann . of probab . _ , 36(3):11341152 , 2008 . e. candellero and l. gilch . phase transitions for random walk asymptotics on free products of groups . submitted , current version available at arxiv:0909.1893v3 , 2009 . d.i . cartwright and p.m. soardi . random walks on free products , quotients and amalgams . _ nagoya math . j. _ , 102:163180 , 1986 . t. cover and j. thomas . _ elements of information theory_. wiley & sons , 2nd edition , 2006 . y. derriennic . quelques applications du thorme ergodique sous - additif . _ astrisque _ , 74:183201 , 1980 . a. erschler . on the asymptotics of drift . _ j. of math . sciences _ , 121(3):24372440 , 2004 . a. erschler and v. kaimanovich . continuity of entropy for random walks on hyperbolic groups . _ in preparation _ , 2010 . p. gerl and w. woess . local limits and harmonic functions for nonisotropic random walks on free groups . theory rel . fields _ , 71:341355 , 1986 . l. a. gilch . rate of escape of random walks on free products . _ j. aust . _ , 83(i):3154 , 2007 . l. a. gilch and s. mller . random walks on directed covers of graphs . _ j. of theoret . _ , doi 10.1007/s10959 - 009 - 0256 - 0 , 2009 . y. guivarch . sur la loi des grands nombres et le rayon spectral dune marche alatoire . _ astrisque _ , 74:4798 , 1980 . kaimanovich and a.m. vershik . random walks on discrete groups : boundary and entropy . _ ann . of prob . _ , 11:457490 , 1983 . v. kaimanovich and w. woess . boundary and entropy of space homogeneous markov chains . _ ann . of prob . _ , 30:323363 , 2002 . a. karlsson and f. ledrappier . linear drift and poisson boundary for random walks . _ pure appl . , 3:10271036 , 2007 . the ergodic theory of subadditive processes . _ j. royal stat . b _ , 30:499510 , 1968 . s. lalley . finite range random walk on free groups and homogeneous trees . _ ann . of prob . _ , 21(4):20872130 , 1993 . f. ledrappier . analyticity of the entropy for some random walks . _ preprint , available at arxiv:1009.5354v1 _ , 2010 . r. lyons , with y. peres . _ probability on trees and networks_. in preparation . current version available at http://mypage.iu.edu/ rdlyons/ , 2010 . j. mairesse and f. mathus . random walks on free products of cyclic groups . _ j. london math . _ , 75(1):4766 , 2007 . _ random walks and convolution operators on free products . _ phd thesis , new york univ . , t. nagnibeda and w. woess . random walks on trees with finitely many cone types . _ j. theoret . _ , 15:399438 , 2002 . s. sawyer . isotropic random walks in a tree . _ zeitschrift f. wahrscheinlichkeitstheorie _ , 42:279292 , 1978 . s. sawyer and t. steger . the rate of escape for anisotropic random walks in a tree . theory rel . fields _ , 76:207230 , 1987 . long range estimates for markov chains . _ , 109:225252 , 1985 . d. voiculescu . addition of certain non - commuting random variables . _ j. funct . _ , 66:323346 , 1986 . w. woess . nearest neighbour random walks on free products of discrete groups . _ _ , 5-b:961982 , 1986 . w. woess . _ random walks on infinite graphs and groups_. cambridge university press , 2000 .
Abstract: | [
"suppose we are given the free product v of a finite family of finite or countable sets . we consider a transient random walk on the free product arising naturally from a convex combination of random walks on the free factors . we prove the existence of the asymptotic entropy and present three different , equivalent formulas , which are derived by three different techniques . in particular , we will show that the entropy is the rate of escape with respect to the greenian metric . moreover , we link asymptotic entropy with the rate of escape and volume growth resulting in two inequalities . lorenz a. gilch graz university of technology + institut fr mathematische strukturtheorie ( math . c ) + steyrergasse 30 + a-8010 graz + austria + email : [email protected] + url : http://www.math.tugraz.at/@xmath0gilch/"
] | 8,878 | 8,878 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: we are extremely pleased to be able to add our contribution to this collection of works , by many eminent authors in a wide spectrum of fields , in honor of rolf landauer s lifetime of contributions to our understanding of the physical world . we will say a lot more about what those contributions have meant for us below , but we might note one important motivation which we have been given by rolf s many battles with the producers of conference books and special volumes such as this one ! rolf believes strongly that the written word should be taken seriously , and that contributions , seriously written , should not languish on an editor s shelf waiting for slaggart authors or testy co - editors to do their neglected duty . so we have , first and foremost , been assiduous in delivering this contribution to prof . datta by the announced deadline ! as will be evident in our technical discussion below , we are largely mathematical physicists . we would say that rolf generally takes a jaundiced view of such creatures ; for him , there is an absolute need for _ explanation _ and _ understanding _ of scientific truths in the full human sense , not in the purely formal and mathematical sense with which those of our species often content themselves . rolf has challenged us throughout our careers , from our green function studies ( as mere children ) of conductance fluctuations and aharanov - bohm effects in mesoscopic conductors , to our very recent brazen assertions about the efficacy of error correction techniques in quantum information processing he has challenged us to explain , with as much clarity and insight as we could muster , the basic underlying reasons why the assertions that we were making were really true . and , as we feel we have come to understand better as we struggle towards our own scientific maturity , it is in the answers to these questions , posed relentlessly to everyone ( we suspect ) whose article appears in this volume , and not the successful summations of a diagram series , from which true , significant scientific progress is produced . so , we thank rolf greatly for these promptings which he has given to our own work . as one specific illustration of the remarkable flowering of scientific progress which has resulted from the landauer way of thinking , we would like to tell the story , in which one of us ( ddv ) has been a player , of the development of the theory of quantum error correction . this theoretical area , which today has many ardent practitioners ( some more about them below ) , is remarkable in that it was believed to be a strictly non - existent subject as little as two years ago ( at this writing , september 1997 ) . rolf contributed to the belief that quantum error correction could not be done@xcite , as indeed it could not in the original conceptions of quantum computing . his message seemed to be compelling quantum information is a form of analog information . in many respects this statement is entirely correct : what we mean by a qubit is a two - state quantum system which , unlike the conventional bit , can be a continuum of possible states as specified by its wavefunction : @xmath0 here @xmath1 and @xmath2 are arbitrary complex numbers , apart from the normalization condition . ( actually , the permissible state of a qubit is more general ; it can be in a mixed state described by a density operator . ) the availability of this continuum of states is intrinsic to quantum computation ; it appears that any attempt to restrict the qubit to one of a discrete set of states will nullify the great potential capabilities of quantum algorithms . it would make no physical sense to do so in any case , since the unitary evolution of the quantum state under the action of a hamiltonian is naturally a continuous - time process . noting this feature in the earliest speculations about quantum computation , landauer challenged the workers in this infant community with the statement that quantum computation could not be error corrected , and thus lacked a crucial element that defines computation itself . he based these criticisms on the well known defect of classical analog computing : since all states of such a device , and of the quantum computer , are legal computational states , it is argued that there would be no way to distinguish a state to which some noise had been added . thus , there is no correction mechanism , and the computation immediately starts to drift off track . the imagery which has been used by landauer of the situation in digital computation is that of a particle moving along a track of the `` standard '' digital state , with very high potential - energy walls continually `` restandardizing '' the state as the computation proceeded ( by the movement of the ball in this potential - energy maze ) . rolf quite correctly saw no hint of restandardization in any of the quantum computer implementations which were initially discussed , and he offered up detailed criticisms of several of the schemes ; for instance@xcite , in a computation scheme proposed by benioff in which the computation advanced by the propagation of a wavepacket in a one - dimensional periodic potential , landauer pointed out that the phenomenon of one - dimensional localization made it exponentially likely that before completing , the wave packet / computation would be turned around by localization and relection . thus landauer s criticism hung as a bit of a pall over the earlier days of quantum computation , sprinkling a little rain on the otherwise cheerful and naive quantum computation parade . but landauer s criticisms had an extremely important effect ; it got a couple of very original minds like peter shor and andrew steane to _ think _ about whether restandardization _ could _ , despite appearances , be performed in quantum computation . ( berthiaume _ et al._@xcite and bennett _ et al._@xcite were also pursuing lines which was not too far distant from what turned out to be the correct one . ) part of the discovery which shor@xcite , steane@xcite , and then many others developed was a relatively obvious one , namely that quantum states could be _ encoded_. in classical information theory , coding just refers to the use of a string of bits to stand in for the value of one bit ( or perhaps a smaller block of bits ) . the idea is that the redundancy in this encoding allows errors ( at least some errors ) to be caught and repaired ; such is the standard practice in digital communications . it should , of course , be not at all obvious how redundancy can be of any use in quantum computation . redundancy is apparently not very useful in conventional analog computation ; in addition , since quantum states can not be `` cloned '' or copied@xcite , it would seem that even the simplest kind of redundancy is not even possible in principle . what shor and steane discovered was an ingenious way to use an entirely different fundamental quantum property , _ entanglement _ , in the service of redundancy and error correction . entanglement , introduced into quantum physics by schrdinger@xcite in 1935 , is at one level a fairly prosaic mathematical feature of the wavefunction of two ( or more ) particles . it refers to the fact that the composite wavefunction may not be expressible as the product of the states of the two individual particles . for example , for two qubits one may have a state like @xmath3 this inescapable feature of the fundamental principles of quantum physics has a variety of consequences which , depending on your point of view , are deep , profound , bizarre , ridiculous , or some combination of the four . ( indeed , schrodinger recognized the peculiarity of all this ; we highly recommend his brilliantly written articles@xcite from 1935 - 6 on the subject . ) one simple consequence was touched on above : the state of an individual particle can not be described by a pure state @xmath4 in general ; the density operator is given by tracing the full state @xmath5 over the other part of the quantum system . it may be said that all randomness in quantum physics , as described by the probability amplitudes in the density operator , arises from entanglement . so , what shor and steane started with was the idea that the logical @xmath6 and @xmath7 of a qubit could be coded as two orthogonal entangled quantum states ; the simple example which is central to both of their analyses is the coding into the three - qubit states @xmath8 and @xmath9 ; that is , @xmath10 is coded as @xmath11 . the second , more important point has to do with the role of the entanglement of these states it is easy to see that the density operator of any one of the three qubits in the codeword is an equal mixture of @xmath12 and @xmath9 , whether the coded qubit is in the @xmath6 or @xmath7 state . as steane says it , the information about which state the coded qubit lies in is not contained in any single one of the coding qubits ; it is spread out into a `` multi - particle interference , '' which is set up as a result of the entanglement of the encoded state . one would like to think that this lack of information in any one particle means that the coded qubit could be recovered after any interaction by the environment with one of the three coded qubits , since the way that a qubit gets disturbed is by a successful external measurement of its state . this turns out not to work for the three - qubit example above , but it is very definitely on the right track . in fact , this reasoning leads us to what s wrong with the three - qubit code ; it is easy to see that , while a demon making measurements on one qubit can not learn whether the coded qubit is a @xmath6 or a @xmath7 , it can easily learn whether the coded qubit is in the state @xmath13 or @xmath14 . this is so because of the simple algebraic fact that @xmath15 thus , the coding of these states involves product states rather than entangled states , and is therefore quite ineffective at hiding the state of the coded qubit from the environment which is `` measuring '' in this diagonal basis . this result suggests that a quantum code which is completely effective against single - qubit error must be able to make the information about the coded state suitably recondite in _ any _ basis ; one might presume that this will work by making the state appropriately entangled in any basis . one might also have a brief worry that there will some fundamental feature of quantum mechanics which makes the right kind of entanglement unavailable . fortunately this is not the case , and indeed there was no point in the history of the subject when this worry held sway , as shor and steane both immediately found solutions inspired by the three - qubit entangled states . their discoveries , however , involved the invention of new forms of multi - particle entangled states , in shor s case a pair of nine - bit entangled states , and in steane s case a pair of seven - bit states . just in case the reader would like to contemplate these new sorts of entangled states explicitly , we would like to write down a pair of states which were discovered some time after by laflamme _ et al._@xcite and independently by us@xcite ; they are five - qubit states , and they are the smallest states for which one - bit error correction is fully effective : @xmath16 and @xmath17 these new states turn out not only to have the important features we have mentioned for error correction , but they also all appear to exhibit a type of quantum non - locality which is of great interest in the foundations of quantum theory , and may indeed be viewed as the natural extension of the work starting with the seminal paper of einstein , podolsky and rosen , and continuing to the discovery of the greenberger - horne - zeilinger states@xcite . a remarkable feature of the error - correcting properties of these states is that , despite landauer s and other s expectations , the process of error correction has an essentially digital rather than analog character@xcite . we mean this in a rather straightforward operational sense : we find ( divincenzo and shor@xcite give the details for the five - qubit code ) that error detection involves the performance of a series of binary - valued quantum measurements . then these bit values provide an instruction for an error detection step , which involves a discrete rotation of a specific one of the five qubit states . it seems that we can say that the reason for this essentially digital character , despite the analog structure of the state space , is that the code states arrange that any error which the environment can cause by operating ( in any arbitrary way ) on a single qubit acts in a subspace _ orthogonal _ to the state space of the coded qubit itself . thus , the complex coefficients are , to very high accuracy , completely untouched by the error process , and all the error detection and correction steps can work in a way which is oblivious to their values . thus , landauer has turned out to be wrong on this point ; but by his challengings , he has opened up an entirely unanticipated line of investigation in the fundamental properties of quantum mechanics . we will not pursue the details here of how this story has further developed , although we have told just the beginning of what has been a tremendous development in the last two years : the formal conditions have been constructed for entangled states to be effective as correctable code states@xcite , which in turn led to the discovery of a powerful group - theoretic framework which permitted the classification of essentially _ all _ interesting quantum codes of arbitrary block size@xcite ; it has been found how error correction can be implemented fault tolerantly@xcite , that is , in such a way that it is insensitive to errors that occur during the error detection operations themselves ; finally , this has in turn led to a discovery of protocols that permit fully general quantum computation to be performed in the presence of errors and decoherence@xcite . all of this has amounted to a revolution in the way we theorists think about the future prospects for quantum computation . as of this writing , we would say that rolf , while being quite impressed by these developments , and being convinced that they really make quantum computing not such a hopeless enterprise as he once had thought , takes a slightly jaundiced view of these developments . he will make sure that we do nt loose sight of the fact that this theoretical development emphatically does _ not _ solve all ( or perhaps even any ) of the problems which stand in the way of making progress in the laboratory today on the construction of a quantum computer . we expect that rolf s wry commentaries on our efforts will continue to nudge our mathematical efforts in the direction of real progress . we would like to turn now to a different aspect of quantum information and its physical embodiment , which also has its roots in the promptings of rolf landauer . early in the development of the theory of quantum computation , benioff@xcite , feynman@xcite , and deutsch@xcite suggested , by way of existence proofs , some abstract models of quantum systems whose dynamics would result in the execution of some computation . landauer criticized this work very pointedly ; he emphasized that computers are made out of physical apparatus and not out of hamiltonians . and he made the point , as we discussed above , that it does not constitute a serious model of computation if the imperfections in these apparatuses are not dealt with in the analysis he showed how several of the abstract systems which had been proposed , if taken seriously , would exhibit very severe flaws which would preclude their being a serious physical basis for computation . so the situation sat in around 1994 , when shor revolutionized the field@xcite and raised to an altogether higher level of significance the question of whether quantum information really could be embodied physically if a quantum computer to do factoring really could be built . we believe that the existing commentaries which had been put in the literature by rolf made the exploration of possible physical embodiments a much soberer and realistic undertaking than it would have been . models which were current at that time included the spin - polymer concept of lloyd@xcite , and the atomic force microscope `` clockwork '' computer of divincenzo@xcite . both were motivated by the landauer criterion of proposing actual physical embodiments of instruments which could manipulate quantum information , and which were thus subjectable to realistic criticisms based on the criteria of experimental physics . however , both the lloyd and divincenzo efforts look , at the remove of three years , very naive and incomplete compared with the much more impressive recent proposals to realize quantum computation in the laboratory . one enormously impressive stream of ideas and proposals have flowed forth from the group of zoller and cirac@xcite . these workers , armed with a very deep understanding of the state of the art in atomic physics and quantum optics , and informed by the very perceptive general formulations of quantum information processing as conditional dynamics produced by artur ekert at a very important conference in 1994@xcite , have , we think , largely passed the landauer test of giving a thoroughly complete , analyzable , and testable scenario ( actually several different ones ) for quantum computation . here would not be the place to give a long technical description of the cirac - zoller proposals . however , we would like to describe an exercise@xcite which we went through subsequent to their work , and partly motivated by it : we have tried to codify , in a comprehensive but general way , a set of sufficient criteria that any physical system should satisfy if it is to be suitable as a realization of a quantum computer . we would like to review our five criteria , discuss briefly how cirac and zoller have succeeded in meeting these criteria , and finally discuss a new proposal which we have made@xcite for implementing quantum computation in a coupled quantum dot system , discussing how we envision the criteria could be met in this arena . here , then , are the five essential criteria which we perceive for the physical implementation of quantum computation : \1 ) hilbert space control . the available quantum states must be precisely enumerated , and it must be known how to confine the state vector of the quantum system to this part of hilbert space . in addition , the hilbert space should be extendable , preferably with a simple tensor - product structure , by adding particles to the system . for example , @xmath18 spin-1/2 particles have a simple spin hilbert space of @xmath19 dimensions . \2 ) state preparation . within this hilbert space , it must be possible to set the state vector initially to a simple fiducial starting state . a simple example of this , in the spin system , would be to set all the spins in the spin - down state . frequently this only requires being able to bring the system to sufficiently low temperature that it is in its ground state . this is more difficult in some examples than in others . \3 ) low decoherence . this is the criterion most closely tied to the topic of the first part of this paper . the coupling to the environment ( i.e. , to all the rest of the hilbert space of the world ) should be sufficiently weak that quantum interference in the computational hilbert space is not spoiled . given our current understanding of error correction and fault tolerant quantum computation , and given fairly benign assumptions about the nature of the decoherence ( e.g. , that it acts independently on each quantum bit ) reliable computation is possible if the decoherence time exceeds the switching time by @xmath20@xcite . more clever fault - tolerant techniques@xcite may well succeed in making this rather demanding threshold number more relaxed in the future . \4 ) controlled unitary transformations . this is the fairly obvious central requirement of quantum computing : it must be possible to subject the computational quantum system to a controlled sequence of precisely defined unitary transformations . the precision requirements are closely related to the decoherence threshold ; imprecision of unitary operations is a form of decoherence . for convenience of programming , it is very desirable that the elementary unitary transformations be implementable as discrete one- and two - qubit operations . \5 ) state - specific quantum measurements . the readout of a quantum computation , which would consist of some ordinary bit string , is to be the result of a sequence of quantum measurements performed on the computational quantum system . it is very desirable ( although _ not _ necessary ) that these measurements be the textbook projection measurements of individual quanta . it is essential that these measurements can be made on specific , identified subsystems of the computational state ; in the simplest case , this means that it should be possible to do a projection measurement on each qubit individually . recent work in nuclear - magnetic - resonance computation has shown that certain aspects of this criterion can be relaxed@xcite : if many identical copies of the quantum computer are available , then weaker , ensemble measurements , rather than projection measurements , are adequate . it is still necessary that these ensemble measurements be subsystem - specific , though . the cirac - zoller proposal of the ion - trap quantum computer@xcite has done a beautiful job of satisfying these criteria : 1 ) the hilbert space which they employ , the low - lying electronic and spins states of the ions , and the quantized states of vibration of the ions in the trap , have been thoroughly mapped out by atomic physicists in a series of careful experiments spanning many years . extendibility is achieved by adding more atoms in a line to the trap . 2 ) laser cooling techniques have enabled experimentalists to place this system in the ground state . ( there are questions about how well this can be done when many ions are added to the trap . ) 3 ) long coherence times are well known for the internal states of the ions ( although coherence times are a bit more problematic for the vibrational states of the ions , and the recent modifications of the proposals made by cirac , zoller , and collaborators have been partly designed to circumvent this decoherence problem ) . 4 ) precision spectroscopic manipulation of the ion s internal - plus - vibrational states is thoroughly demonstrated , and a complete set of quantum logic operations is known to be achievable . 5 ) the availability of quantum - jump spectroscopy implies that virtually ideal , strong , quantum - specific measurements are available@xcite . it would appear from all this that the landauer plea , that quantum computing be considered at the level of real - world devices , has been completely satisfied . not quite , though : despite its plausibility , the cirac - zoller device is a great extrapolation in scale , and in its simultaneous achievement of a variety of experimental capabilities from any existing experiment in ion - trap physics , and some have questioned whether these extrapolations , especially to very large scale quantum computation ( c. 1000 qubits ) will really be possible . there are other technical objections having to do with the fact that the machine as envisioned does not permit parallel operations , quantum gate operations performed simultaneously on different parts of the device . this is important because , from the theoretical point of view , all the powerful results of fault - tolerant quantum computation need this parallel capability@xcite . so , despite the brilliance of the ion - trap proposal , we have remained motivated to propose other platforms , from very different areas of physics , that have the potential for satisfying the five criteria for the implementation of a quantum computer . it is often speculated that a solid - state physics approach will be the only plausible arena for the massive scale - up of quantum computation which will ultimately be desirable . this is indeed a debatable proposition : our current ability to hold and process untold millions of ordinary bits on a silicon chip in no way translates into a corresponding capability to have and hold a large number of qubits . still , it is a fact that there is a great deal of basic research , projecting forth from the fabulous successes of microelectronics , to understand the quantum properties of small solid state devices , and it is on this fact that we hang our hopes . we have thus been encouraged to work on a proposal for a solid - state quantum computer , one based on quantum dots@xcite . we are sure that the quantum behavior of such structures will be the subject of many other articles in this volume , as the whole topic of quantum interference in mesoscopic structures is another one which sprang largely from the brain of rolf landauer . but we think that the proposal which we have made prescribes a much deeper use of the quantum properties of these structures than has had been contemplated before . our proposal has been outlined in detail elsewhere@xcite , and we will just give a summary here , but with a couple of added features which have come to light recently . we will give this outline by discussing how we envision our five criteria for the realization of quantum computation to be satisfied . for pedagogical reasons , we will visit these five items out of their order above . \1 ) hilbert space : we propose using the real _ spin _ states of electrons confined in an array of quantum dots . gaining control over this hilbert space requires , first , that the number of excess electrons confined to each quantum dot be precisely controlled , and in particular that the electron number be _ odd _ so that the dot has an excess spin-1/2 . at this stage in development of experiments in this area , many groups have succeeded in maintaining some electron number in a dot exactly ; fewer groups have the capability of fixing the _ absolute _ number of excess electrons , but we hope that this will be readily doable in many of the quantum dot experiments which are envisioned . we also require that the electrons populate , with reasonable probability , the lowest - lying electron orbital ; in other words , we want only spin degrees of freedom to be available , but not charge degrees of freedom . this should be achievable by a combination of strong confining potentials ( i.e. , small dots ) and low temperatures . it seems that for dots substantially below 100 nm in size , conventional cryogenics ( necessary for many other aspects of the proposal ) should be sufficient . \2 ) state preparation : not much need be said on this point : any conventional method of preparing the set of spins in a highly spin - polarized state ( as simple , for example , as cooling the spins in a strong magnetic field ) would be satisfactory . \5 ) strong quantum measurement : it is necessary ( unless we adopt the ensemble approach introduced in nuclear - magnetic - resonance quantum computing ) to be able to measure whether the spin of any individual dot is up or down with respect to some quantization axis . single - spin measurements in the solid state are still in the future , but such measurements have been the holy grail of quantum magnetism experiments for many years , and we feel confident that eventually such a measurement will be achieved by some means . we might highlight one suggestion which we have made@xcite for how to do this which integrates well with the technology of single - electron quantum - dot experiments . suppose a tunneling barrier could be introduced into the system whose barrier potential is spin dependent ; such barriers are well known in some areas of magnetic physics , although it has not yet been contemplated how to incorporate them into the processing used to create quantum dots . the gating of such a barrier between two quantum dots , one containing the spin state to be measured , and the other containing no excess electron , could , at some desired instant in time , make it possible for the electron to tunnel through the barrier only if it is in one of the two spin states . then , the presence or absence of the excess electron in the second dot , which can be done by well understood and perfected single - electron electrometry techniques , would serve as the desired measurement of whether the electron had been in the spin up or spin down state . if this technique turns out to be infeasible , we are confident that experimentalists will use their ingenuity to solve this problem in a much more practical way than we can ever envision . \4 ) gate operations : this is at the heart of our quantum dot proposal ; we discuss a few recent further advances in our thinking on this in sec . we envision a variety of mechanisms for effecting one - qubit and two - qubit gate operations on the spin qubits of the quantum dots . our proposals begin with the recent development of the experimental capability to controllably couple or decouple the states of neighboring dots by externally controlling an electric potential barrier between them@xcite . in the present experiments , this capability is used only to demonstrate that the dots can go from a regime where a single added electron enters one of the two dots ( the decoupled situation ) to a regime in which an added electron goes into a delocalized state of the two dots ( the coupled situation ) . we propose using this capability in a more subtle way : it is well known that virtual tunneling of electrons between two spin - degenerate sites leads to an effective exchange coupling between the spins of the two electrons . by turning on tunneling ( by lowering the potential barrier ) for a controlled length of time , a specific two - qubit gate operation could be achieved . the exchange interaction leads to a quantum gate of the `` swap '' type ; for a particular duration of the interaction ( or any odd multiple of the fundamental duration ) , the exchange is complete and gate is just a complete swapping or interchange of the two spin states . this does not constitute a very useful two - qubit quantum gate ; but if the interaction is left on for half of this fundamental swapping time , the resulting `` square - root of swap '' operation , in conjunction with other gates which we will discuss next , would provide an efficient basis for programming any desired quantum computation . square - root - of - swap is still not as powerful a quantum gate as is needed theoretically , because it respects rotational symmetry in spin space . thus , it leaves the total angular momentum of the spin system , and its projection on any quantization axis , unchanged . but in quantum computation it is desirable to be able to rotate the state vector from any state to any other state . for this reason , it is very desirable to supplement the two - bit swap - type gate with other gates which break the spin - space rotational symmetry . this is very easy to do from a theoretical point of view , it just requires adding a simple family of one - qubit gates . unfortunately , the experimental implementation of such gates is surprisingly problematic , as it involves the application of magnetic fields locally to an individual spin ( and not to the surrounding ones ) . this is a daunting technical requirement , which , we readily admit , would require quite heroic experimental efforts to achieve ; we hope that there would be other ways to achieve this which we are still investigating , perhaps if it were possible to perform local electron - spin - resonance operations on the system . but for the time being , we offer a few tentative ideas for how this application of a localized magnetic field might be conceivable , with apologies for not having been able to see how to make it any simpler . since , in the measurement scheme which we have proposed above , we have suggested the incorporation of magnetic materials into the system ( to make the spin - dependent tunneling barrier ) , we could envision using such materials to accomplish the one - bit gates . for example , if a piece of such a magnetized material were placed near the quantum dot , such that by lowering a gate potential , the electron could be made to , at some desired time , partially penetrate the magnetized barrier , the electron spin would precess around this internal magnetization and the one - bit operation could be achieved . a magnetized dot which the spin state could be swapped into and out of could have the same effect . if magnetic materials were undesirable , one could envision various local coil arrangements or magnetized probe tips which could also give the desired one - bit operations . hopefully , more ingenuity will lead to more elegant solutions to this problem . \3 ) coherence times : consideration of this criterion for quantum computation also leads us into speculative territory , but one which we are reasonably hopeful about . in the usual mesoscopic experimental regimes , it was rare to find decoherence times even as long as one nanosecond ; in mesoscopics , however , it was always the decoherence of a _ degree of freedom which was being studied . there is every reason to believe , from a theoretical point of view , that the coherence of electron _ spin _ states should , under favorable circumstances , be much longer . generally speaking , the coupling of the environment to spin is weaker than to charge . there is as yet very little experimental indication of how long these spin coherence times could be . et al._@xcite have observed free induction decay for a population of photoexcited electron spins in a quantum well . the @xmath21 measured in this decay , which is a lower limit on the decoherence time for the spins , was seen to be several nanoseconds . we may in addition consider the decoherence time for the spins of itinerant electrons in a 2d quantum well to be a lower limit on the time for electrons in a similar material but confined to a zero - dimensional structure . for these reasons , we believe that the kikkawa observations should be just considered a very early starting point in the search for long spin coherences , and that increases in these times of many orders of magnitude would not be out of the question . it would indeed be extremely desirable to find a system with a decoherence time of , say @xmath22 sec . , since the speed of the desired gate operations would be scaled to this time ; in any foreseeable experiment it would be very interesting to make the gate times a few orders of magnitude faster than the decoherence time . this would mean gate operations going at a mhz rate , which would we think be a fairly comfortable regime for ac manipulations of low temperature electronic systems . we hope very much to engage in a dialog , in the landauer style , with experimentalists and other interested parties to improve this quantum dot proposal through critical discussion . we are certain that the solutions which we have proposed for satisfying the criteria of quantum computation are not optimal , and perhaps on further examination they will prove to be laughable ; but we can not see any `` show stoppers '' at this point , and we remain optimistic that solid state quantum computation will indeed be possible and will indeed be a very exciting line for fundamental experiments in quantum physics . to obtain a more quantitative understanding of the origin of the exchange coupling occurring in the effective two - spin heisenberg model and to determine its magnetic and electric field dependence , we have begun recently@xcite to investigate coupled quantum dots from a more microscopic viewpoint . in the following we wish to report on these preliminary findings . our investigations have been motivated by recent advances in the physics of semiconductor quantum dots that were fabricated in a 2deg gaas system by tarucha et al . @xcite these experimentalists have demonstrated that such dots are well - described by a parabolic confinement potential ( of energy @xmath23mev ) and that one can fill in one electron after the other ( starting with an empty dot ) in a controlled way . armed with this information it is now reasonable to expect that it should be within experimental reach ( as envisioned in point ( 4 ) of sec . iii ) to couple two such dots ( containing only a few electrons ) via a tunable or non - tunable barrier ( as has already been achieved in bigger dots @xcite ) . the physics of such a system can then be described by adopting the lines of reasoning used in molecular theory . to put it in other words , in the same way as one can consider an isolated quantum dot as an artificial atom that obeys e.g. analogs of hund s rule when electrons are added to the shells , one can now consider the problem of coupled quantum dots as the problem of artificial molecules , or more generally as the problem of quantum dot chemistry . " like in ordinary chemistry , we can use techniques such as the heitler - london method or more refined approaches such as the hund - mullikan ansatz , hybridization etc . to obtain the low - lying energies . one of the main differences between ordinary atoms and quantum dots is that the attractive forces between nuclei and electrons are now replaced by the parabolic confining potential that can be controlled externally by changing the gate voltage . the associated bohr radius @xmath24 ( @xmath25 is the effective electron mass ) is typically in the range of tens of nanometers and thus much larger than in real atoms . one important consequence of this is that ( coupled ) quantum dots are much more sensitive to external magnetic and electric fields . as we will see below it is this field sensitivity which allows one to tune the exchange constant " to zero as a function of uniformly applied external fields , the strengths of which are easily accessible in standard set - ups . to be specific let us consider the simplest case , namely two circular quantum dots of radius @xmath26 lying in the same plane and whose centers are separated by 2@xmath26 . each dot contains one electron of spin 1/2 which interact via the ( possibly screened ) coulomb interaction . it is then straightforward to write down an explicit hamiltonian that captures the physics just described and that will allow us to perform some more concrete evaluations : @xmath27 where @xmath28 + g\mu_b { \bf s}_i\cdot{\bf b}/\hbar \,\ , , \nonumber \\ v_{ij}&=&{e^2\over{|{\bf r}_i-{\bf r}_j|}}\,e^{-\mu @xmath29 describes the effect of the constant magnetic field @xmath30 , and @xmath31 is some electric field applied along the @xmath32-axis connecting the dots . these dots are located at * a*@xmath33 . the coupling of the dots is described in terms of an @xmath34-potential with @xmath35 given by the parabolic confining energy of a single isolated dot . the change of barrier height between the dots can then be described by changing the interdot distance @xmath36 . the last term in @xmath37 is the zeeman term . the coulomb interaction is described by @xmath38 with @xmath39 being some effective screening parameter . the motion of the electrons is assumed to be planar , i.e. @xmath40 . this hamiltonian can not be solved exactly but we can make progress with the help of variational ( or numerical ) techniques to find for instance the exchange constant given by the difference between singlet and triplet energies . in particular , in the heitler - london approximation and making use of the darwin - fock solution for the isolated dots we find ( omitting all details of the calculation @xcite ) , @xmath41\,\ , , \label{exchange}\ ] ] where @xmath42 is the ratio of coulomb energy to confinement energy , and @xmath43 the zeroth - order bessel function . for @xmath44 mev @xcite we have @xmath45 nm and thus @xmath46 . further , the parameter @xmath47 , with @xmath48 being the larmor frequency , describes the effect of the orbital diamagnetism , it becomes appreciable in the tesla range since @xmath49 ( b / t ) . the dimensionless distance between the dots is given by @xmath50 . for the moment we have set @xmath51 and assumed a bare coulomb interaction ( which is a reasonable assumption for the two electron system ) . note that the energy scale of the exchange coupling is given by the confinement energy @xmath52 . a plot of @xmath53 versus magnetic field is given in fig . 1 ( for @xmath54 ) . the most interesting feature of the heitler - london result is the fact that due to the influence of the orbital diamagnetism the exchange @xmath55 passes through zero ( at a field value of about 1 t ) and thus changes from antiferromagnetic ( @xmath56 ) to ferromagnetic ( @xmath57 ) coupling . this suggests again a novel mechanism with which one can tune the exchange coupling j to zero . of course , @xmath55 can also be tuned to zero asymptotically . we stress that the magnetic field is not local but extends uniformly over the two dots , and such a uniform field can be easily accounted for in the xor operation . finally we note that for vanishing b - field and for c values with @xmath58 ( which is in the range of experimental interest ) j is positive for all distances @xmath59 ( i.e. the singlet state is lower in energy than the triplet state ) , as it must of course be the case for a two - electron system on general grounds . the heitler - london approximation for @xmath55 breaks down ( i.e. @xmath55 becomes negative even for @xmath60 ) for certain @xmath59 s when @xmath61 exceeds 2.8 . next , adding an electric field @xmath62 will lead to a simple shift of @xmath55 , @xmath63 this expression is valid for not too large electric fields with @xmath64 not exceeding one . thus , within the heitler - london approximation we find that such a field ( or biasing voltage ) can then be used to also tune the exchange constant . both of these tuning mechanisms could be used alternatively to or in conjunction with a gate between the dots by which one can tune the barrier height by varying the gate voltage ( in our model , this tuning mechanism can be accounted for by varying the dot distance @xmath59 ) . it is interesting to examine the magnetization @xmath65 ( along the @xmath66-axis ) of the coupled dots , as this quantity can give independent information about intrinsic parameters such as the exchange coupling but also about the interplay between orbital diamagnetism and spin paramagnetism . this quantity can also be calculated in the heitler - london approximation@xcite . however , we shall not write down the lengthy expression here and content ourselves with a plot of the magnetization versus b - field , see fig . 2 , where we stay in the low temperature regime of ref.@xcite with @xmath67 k@xmath68 t , which corresponds to an electron temperature of t@xmath69mk . the striking feature to be noted here is the initial diamagnetic response ( with the spins being antiparallel ) followed by a sudden jump at about 1 tesla . indeed , this jump can be traced back to the change of sign in the exchange constant . after the jump , the response becomes diamagnetic again ( with the spins being now parallel ) and finally approaches saturation asymptotically . thus the heitler - london approximation suggests that the sudden switch around 1 tesla allows one to get direct information about the exchange constant from the magnetization . it does not need to be stressed of course that it will be rather difficult to measure the magnetization of only two electrons , as the magnetization is only of the order of a few bohr magnetons . still , in a first set of experiments one can again envision ( as in @xcite ) a scaling up to many independent systems of two coupled quantum dots . also , the present status of cantilever technology is capable of measuring magnetic moments on the order of a single bohr magneton ! it would be interesting to explore the possibility whether one could use magnetic force microscopes etc . to measure such magnetization effects . the above analysis can ( and should ! ) be refined by making use of the hund - mullikan ( or lcao ) method and by including sp - type of hybridization effects ( which however are balanced by orbital field effects ) . these calculations become rather involved @xcite , and we will report on them elsewhere . in principle , it is possible to solve this problem to arbitrary accuracy by making use of powerful numerical techniques developed in molecular physics . [ it is amusing to mention parenthetically that in these numerics one approximates the atomic wave functions by gaussians mainly for technical reasons ; here in our case of quantum dots with parabolic confinement this would in fact be exact and a much better convergence can be expected . ] it is worth mentioning that spin - orbit effects can essentially be neglected in the case of only very few electrons per dot . indeed , the spin - orbit interaction in a quantum dot with parabolic confinement takes the form @xmath70 , where @xmath71 is the angular momentum of the confined electron which is of the order of @xmath72 . thus we can estimate that @xmath73 for above values and with an effective electron mass found in gaas . it is clear by now that the above analysis can be extended to situations with more than one electron per dot , although the complexity of the problem increases rapidly . we hope to report soon on our progress in this direction . finally , it is a most rewarding aspect of this area of research , which we have the privilege to bring to rolf landauer s attention , that even apart from our ultimate goal of building a working quantum computer there is plenty of fascinating and novel physics to be discovered on our way that will keep us ( and hopefully our experimental colleagues ! ) quite busy for a while . r. landauer , `` is quantum - mechanically coherent computation useful ? '' , in _ proc . drexel-4 symposium on quantum nonintegrability quantum - classical correspondence _ , philadelphia , pa , 8 september 1994 ( eds . d. h. feng and b .- hu , international press , boston , to be published ) . r. landauer , `` information is physical , '' proc . workshop on physics and computation physcomp 92 ( ieee comp . press , los alamitos , 1993 ) pp . 1 - 4 . a. berthiaume , d. deutsch , and r. jozsa , `` the stabilisation of quantum computation , '' proc . workshop on physics and computation physcomp 92 ( ieee comp . press , los alamitos , 1993 ) pp . 60 - 62 . c. h. bennett , g. brassard , s. popescu , b. schumacher , j. a. smolin , and w. k. wootters , `` purification of noisy entanglement and faithful teleportation via noisy channels , '' phys . lett . * 76 * , 722 ( 1996 ) . c. h. bennett , d. p. divincenzo , j. a. smolin , and w. k. wootters , `` mixed - state entanglement and quantum error correction , '' phys . a * 54 * , 3824 ( 1996 ) ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9604024 . p. w. shor , `` scheme for reducing decoherence in quantum computer memory , '' phys . a * 52 * , 2493 ( 1995 ) . a. m. steane , `` error correcting codes in quantum theory , '' phys . lett * 77 * , 793 ( 1996 ) . w. k. wootters and w. h. zurek , nature ( london ) * 299 * , 802 ( 1982 ) . c. h. bennett , g. brassard , and n. d. mermin , phys . * 68 * , 557 ( 1992 ) . e. schrdinger , `` die gegenwrtige situation in der quantenmechanik , '' naturwissenschaften * 23 * , 807 - 812 ; 823 - 828 ; 844 - 849 ( 1935 ) . translation : j. d. trimmer , `` the present situation in quantum mechanics : a translation of schrdinger s cat paradox paper , '' proc . . soc . * 124 * , 323 ( 1980 ) . e. schrdinger , `` discussion of probability relations between separated systems , '' cambridge phil . soc . * 31 * , 555 ( 1935 ) ; `` probability relations between separated systems , '' _ ibid . _ , * 32 * , 446 ( 1936 ) . r. laflamme , c. miquel , j. p. paz , and w. h. zurek , `` perfect quantum error correction code , '' phys . lett . * 77 * , 198 ( 1996 ) . see d. p. divincenzo and a. peres , `` quantum code words contradict local realism , '' phys . a * 55 * , 4089 ( 1997 ) . see d. p. divincenzo , j. a. smolin , and p. w. shor , `` quantum channel capacity of very noisy channels , '' phys . a , in press ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9706061 . d. p. divincenzo and p. w. shor , `` fault - tolerant error correction with efficient quantum codes , '' phys . lett . * 77 * , 3260 ( 1996 ) ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9605031 . e. knill and r. laflamme , `` theory of quantum error correcting codes , '' phys . a * 55 * , 900 ( 1997 ) ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9604034 . d. gottesman , `` class of quantum error correcting codes saturating the quantum hamming bound , '' phys . a * 54 * , 1862 ( 1996 ) ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9604038 . a. r. calderbank , e. m. rains , p. w. shor , and n. j. a. sloane , `` quantum error correction and orthogonal geometry , '' phys . rev . lett . * 78 * , 405 ( 1997 ) ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9605005 . p. w. shor , `` fault - tolerant quantum computation , '' proc . 37th symposium on the foundations of computer science ( ieee computer society press , los alamitos , 1996 ) , pp . 56 - 65 ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9605011 . j. preskill , `` reliable quantum computers , '' proc . london , in press ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9705031 . p. benioff , `` quantum mechanical hamiltonian models of turing machines , '' j. stat * 29 * , 515 ( 1982 ) . r. feynman , `` quantum - mechanical computers , '' found * 16 * , 507 ( 1986 ) . d. deutsch , `` quantum computational networks , '' proc . a * 425 * 73 ( 1989 ) . p. w. shor , `` algorithms for quantum computation : discrete log and factoring , '' proc . 35th annual symposium on the foundations of computer science ( ieee computer society , los alamitos , 1993 ) , p. 124 . s. lloyd , `` a potentially realizable quantum computer , '' science * 261 * , 1589 ( 1993 ) ; `` envisioning a quantum supercomputer , '' _ ibid . _ * 263 * , 695 ( 1994 ) . d. p. divincenzo , `` two - bit gates are universal for quantum computation , '' phys . a * 51 * , 1015 ( 1995 ) ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/cond-mat/9407022 . this work started with j. i. cirac and p. zoller , `` quantum computations with cold trapped ions , '' phys . lett . * 74 * , 4091 ( 1995 ) . a. ekert , `` quantum computation , '' in _ atomic physics 14 14th international conference on atomic physics _ , boulder , co , 1994 , aip conference proceedings 323 ( aip press , new york , 1995 ) , p. 450 . d. p. divincenzo , `` topics in quantum computers , '' in _ mesoscopic electron transport _ , ed . g. schoen ( kluwer , 1997 , to be published ) ; proceedings of the nato advanced study institute on mesoscopic electron transport , curacao , june 24-july 6 , 1996 . see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/cond-mat/9612126 . d. loss and d. p. divincenzo , `` quantum computation with quantum dots , '' phys . a * 57 * , 120 ( 1998 ) . see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/cond-mat/9701055 . kitaev , `` fault tolerant quantum computation by anyons , '' http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9707021 . n. a. gershenfeld and i. l. chuang , `` bulk spin resonance quantum computation , '' science * 275 * , 350 ( 1997 ) . a good source for discussion of general progress in the ion - trap computer may be found in r. j. hughes _ et al . _ , `` the los alamos trapped ion quantum computer experiment , '' to be published in fortschritte der physik ; see http://xxx.lanl.gov/abs/quant-ph/9708050 . one experiment which features this capability is c. livermore _ et al . _ , `` the coulomb blockade in coupled quantum dots , '' science * 274 * , 1332 ( 1996 ) . j. m. kikkawa , i. p. smorchkova , n. samarth , and d. d. awschalom , `` room - temperature spin memory in two - dimensional electron gases , '' science * 277 * , 1284 ( 1997 ) . s. tarucha , d.g . austin , t. honda , r.j . van der hage , and l.p . kouwenhoven , phys . lett . * 77 * , 3613 ( 1996 ) . g. burkard , d.p . divincenzo , and d. loss , in preparation .
Abstract: | [
"we discuss a few current developments in the use of quantum mechanically coherent systems for information processing . in each of these developments , rolf landauer has played a crucial role in nudging us and other workers in the field into asking the right questions , some of which we have been lucky enough to answer . a general overview of the key ideas of quantum error correction is given . we discuss how quantum entanglement is the key to protecting quantum states from decoherence in a manner which , in a theoretical sense , is as effective as the protection of digital data from bit noise . we also discuss five general criteria which must be satisfied to implement a quantum computer in the laboratory , and we illustrate the application of these criteria by discussing our ideas for creating a quantum computer out of the spin states of coupled quantum dots ."
] | 9,651 | 9,651 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the discovery of a new class of faint dwarf satellites around the milky way ( mw ; see e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * and references therein ) ) and the andromeda galaxies ( m31 ; see e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) ) has opened a new window for the study of the formation history of large spirals . the new systems show a number of remarkable differences with respect to the `` classical '' dwarf spheroidals ( dsphs ) surrounding the mw and m31 : i ) they have much lower surface brightnesses ( @xmath11 mag ) , for which they were named `` ultra - faint '' dwarfs ( ufds ) ; ii ) they are very metal poor , with large dispersions and [ fe / h ] values as low as @xmath12 dex ( see * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . such extreme abundances are not observed among the classical dsphs where only a few stars with [ fe / h]@xmath13 have been detected @xcite compared to the large number found in the mw halo ; iii ) they generally contain rr lyrae stars that conform to the subdivision into oosterhoff types i ( oo i ) and ii ( ooii ; * ? ? ? * ) d , whereas type ii ( oo ii ) clusters have @xmath14 d ] observed for field and cluster mw variables . so far , the only exception among the ufds is canes venatici i ( cvn i , * ? ? ? * ) , the brightest of the mw ufds , that , like the classical mw dsphs , has instead oosterhoff - intermediate ( oo - int ) properties ( * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * and references therein ) ; and , finally : iv ) the ufds discovered so far outnumber by almost a factor of two the classical dsphs , thus partially reducing the so - called `` missing satellites problem '' @xcite affecting the @xmath15-cold - dark - matter ( @xmath15cdm ) scenario of galaxy formation . with their properties the ufds are potentially much better analogues than the classical dsphs of the `` building blocks '' that contributed to the formation of the two large spirals in the local group . they have absolute luminosities similar to the globular clusters ( gcs ; @xmath16 mag , on average ) but they are much more spatially extended than gcs . with typical half - light radii of @xmath17 100 pc , in fact they equal in size the `` classical '' dsphs . the ufds are found in groups on the sky ( see e.g. fig . 1 of * ? ? ? * ) , have small velocity dispersions , and high mass - to - light ratios . all ufds host an ancient population around 10 gyr old . they have gc - like color - magnitude diagrams ( cmds ) resembling the cmds of metal - poor galactic gcs ( ggcs ) such as m92 ( ngc 6341 ) , m15 ( ngc 7078 ) and m68 ( ngc 4590 ) . some of the mw ufds have a distorted shape due to the tidal interaction with the mw . we are carrying out an extensive observational campaign of the new mw and m31 ufds to study structural parameters and stellar population properties , as well as the variable stars of these systems . we have already published results for bootes i ( boo i , * ? ? ? * ) , cvn i @xcite , canes venatici ii ( cvnii , * ? ? ? * ) , coma @xcite , leo iv @xcite , and ursa major ii ( umaii * ? ? ? * ) among the mw ufds . with the only exception of cvn i , all these dwarfs contain rr lyrae stars with pulsation periods suggesting an oo ii classification . however , only boo i and cvn i contain sufficiently large numbers of variables to be safely classified into oosterhoff types . the classification of the other ufds is less certain given the small numbers of variables they contain . nevertheless , their few variables clearly tend to have oosterhoff type ii properties . thus , in terms of stellar metallicity and pulsation properties of the variable stars , systems similar to the ufds , as they were at earlier times , could resemble the building blocks of the galactic halo . in this paper we extend our analysis to the hercules ufd galaxy ( r.a.@xmath18 , decl.@xmath19 , j2000.0 ) . the galaxy was discovered by @xcite from the analysis of sdss data . the cmd of hercules ( based on follow - up isaac newton telescope - int- data ) shows besides the red giant branch ( rgb ) , also blue and red horizontal branches ( hbs ) . @xcite interpreted this evidence as a possible signature of multiple stellar populations present in the galaxy . a number of studies have been devoted to this galaxy after the discovery paper . cmds of hercules reaching well below the galaxy s main sequence turn - off were published by ( * ? ? ? * in the @xmath1 and @xmath0 bands ) and ( * ? ? ? * in the @xmath20 and @xmath1 bands ) , based on very wide - field observations obtained with the red and blue channels of the large binocular camera ( lbc ; @xcite ) of the large binocular telescope ( lbt ) . according to the @xcite recovery of the galaxy s star formation history ( sfh ) , hercules is old ( @xmath21 12 gyr , with negligible star formation in the last 12 gyr ) and metal - poor ( [ fe / h]@xmath22 dex ) , with an intrinsic spread in metallicity and both [ fe / h ] = @xmath23 dex and @xmath24 dex populations contributing to the sfh . in the literature there are several spectroscopic and photometric determinations of the metallicity of hercules . these studies confirm that hercules shows a spread in metal abundance , with values of the mean metallicity @xmath25 } \rangle$ ] ranging from about @xmath262.0 to @xmath262.7 dex @xcite . the line of sight towards the hercules dsph galaxy is heavily contaminated by galactic foreground stars , making it hard to determine membership from the cmd alone . even when radial velocities are added the selection remains uncertain , because the mean velocity of the hercules dsph galaxy coincides with the velocity of the thick disk ( @xcite ) . indeed , in the @xcite cmd , based on strmgren photometry obtained with the wide field camera of the int , the rgb of hercules is not easily identified due to the halo foreground contamination . these authors used the c1 index in the strmgren system to disentangle the galaxy s rgb and hb stars from the foreground contamination . hercules appears to be highly elongated . the galaxy s structural parameters were obtained by a number of different authors @xcite who , fitting different stellar profiles to their independent photometric datasets , found similar values for the galaxy s central position , position angle ( @xmath27 ) , and ellipticity ( @xmath28 ) , but rather different half - light radii . in a recent analysis , @xcite suggest that the density profiles of relaxed , tidally stripped dwarf spheroidals like hercules are better approximated by a plummer law . moreover , @xcite clearly point out the need for deep photometry in order to properly constrain the structural parameters of the new faint mw satellites . in the following , we shall adopt the structural parameters obtained by @xcite assuming a plummer stellar distribution , namely @xmath29 , @xmath30 and @xmath31 . hercules has no evidence of internal rotation , and a very low velocity dispersion of @xmath32 km s@xmath33 for @xcite or 3.72 km s@xmath33 for @xcite . the explanation of such a large ellipticity in absence of a rotational support might imply that hercules is not in dynamical equilibrium due to strong tidal distortions ( see discussion in * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the latest studies estimate distances in the range of @xmath34 kpc to @xmath35 kpc ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) and a total absolute magnitude ranging from @xmath36 mag to @xmath37 mag ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the study presented in this paper is based on @xmath38 photometric time - series imaging covering a field of view ( fov ) of @xmath39 ( see table [ t : obs ] ) , extending well beyond hercules half - light radius . these data have allowed us to obtain a complete inventory of the variable stars belonging to the galaxy and to trace the corresponding parent stellar populations . this paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we present the observations and the data reduction procedures ; section 3 is devoted to the variable stars , whereas the cmds and the implications for the structure of the hercules ufd are discussed in section 4 . a new estimate of the distance to hercules based on the galaxy s rr lyrae stars is presented in section 5 . finally , the summary and conclusions in section 6 close the paper . time - series observations in @xmath1 and @xmath0 of the hercules ufd were obtained over the period 2007 april to 2009 june , using a number of different telescopes . the collected data and related telescopes / instrumental set - ups are summarized in table [ t : obs ] , where @xmath40 and @xmath41 are the number of frames in the @xmath1 and @xmath0 bands , respectively . pre - reduction of the images was performed by following standard procedures ( bias subtraction and flat - field correction ) with iraf , except for the wfi data , for which the pre - reduction was carried out using the vst - tube pipeline @xcite . we then performed psf photometry using the daophotiv / allstar / allframe packages ( @xcite ) . after an accurate evaluation of the psf of each individual frame , a reference image was built by averaging all the available frames and a source catalogue was extracted from the stacked image . the source list was then passed to allframe , in order to obtain a homogeneous photometry of all images simultaneously , thus providing @xmath42 and @xmath43 instrumental magnitude catalogues for each telescope . typical internal errors of the single - frame photometry for stars at the hb magnitude level ( @xmath44 mag ) are of about 0.01 mag in both bands . the absolute photometric calibration was derived using observations of standard stars in the landolt fields sa 101 , sa 107 , sa 110 and pg1323 @xcite , as extended by @xcite , which were obtained at the int during the night of 2007 april 22 . errors of the absolute photometric calibration are @xmath45 and @xmath46 mag . as the various telescopes we have used define slightly different photometric systems , each individual dataset was tied to the int standard calibration independently . the calibrated catalogues were then combined using daomaster @xcite to create a final list containing positions , robust intensity - weighted mean @xmath1 and @xmath0 magnitudes @xcite , and weighted average values of the @xmath47 and @xmath48 parameters parameter of each star is a robust estimate of the observed pixel - to - pixel scatter of the fitting residuals to the expected scatter , whereas the @xmath48 parameter is related to the intrinsic angular size of the astronomical objects , and for stellar objects should have a value close to zero @xcite . ] for all objects . we have adopted @xmath49 and @xmath50 to select the stellar - like objects imaged in our total fov of about @xmath10 . this selection is reliable for magnitudes brighter than @xmath9 24 mag , while the uncertainty increases at fainter magnitudes . variable stars were identified from the @xmath1 and @xmath0 time - series data , separately . first , we calculated the fourier transforms ( in the @xcite formulation ) of the stars having at least 12 measurements in each photometric band , then we averaged these transforms to estimate the noise and calculated the signal - to - noise ratios ( s / ns ) . results from the @xmath1 and @xmath0 photometries were cross - correlated , obtaining a list of 860 stars with @xmath51 in both photometric bands ( see e.g. @xcite ) . a visual inspection of the light curves allowed us to confirm the variability of 10 of these candidates . we also analyzed in detail all stars falling on the hb , in the region above the hb , where the anomalous cepheids are generally located , and in the blue straggler region , where one may expect to find variables of the sx phoenicis type . no further variable stars were identified , thus confirming the reliability of our procedure to identify variable stars . to study the light curves we used the software graphical analyzer of time series ( gratis ; see e.g. , @xcite ) that , beyond confirming the variability for all the 10 candidates , also provided periods accurate to 4 - 6 decimal places for all of them . the hercules variables include 1 anomalous cepheid ( ac ) and 9 rr lyrae stars , of which 6 are fundamental - mode ( rrab ) and 3 are first - overtone ( rrc ) pulsators . classification and properties of the confirmed variable stars are summarized in table [ t : rr ] , whereas their light curves are shown in figs . [ f : fig1 ] and [ f : fig2 ] . we have assigned to the variables increasing numbers starting from the galaxy center that was set at r.a.@xmath52 , decl.@xmath53 , j2000.0 @xcite . time - series data for the variable stars are provided in table [ t : pho ] . the light curves are very well sampled , and show very little scatter , except for star v10 . the star does not appear to be blended with other stars on the images . we suspect that v10 might be affected by the blazhko effect @xcite . we note that , according to the period , the ac ( star v2 ) could as well be a fundamental - mode rr lyrae star . however , the star s average magnitude is about 0.4 - 0.5 mag brighter than the hb level . this occurrence , together with a too small amplitude for the star s short period , suggest that the variable either suffers from blending by a contaminant star or is , perhaps , an ac . the photometric parameters @xmath47 ( goodness of the psf fitting ) and @xmath48 ( estimate of the object shape ) provided for v2 by the allframe package seem to rule out the presence of detectable companions around the star , thus favoring the ac hypothesis . another possibility is that v2 could be an overluminous rrc as , for instance , v70 in the m3 ggc . however , the period of v2 ( 0.53777 d ) is definitely longer than that of m3-v70 ( @xmath54 d , @xcite , @xcite ) . on the other hand , the mean magnitude and the period of v2 are in very good agreement with the ac period - luminosity relations by ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) , @xcite and ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) , thus favoring an ac classification for v2 . finally , as described in section [ s : cmd ] , the ac classification is further supported by the comparison with evolutionary tracks . the ac , all the rrc variables and three of the rrab stars lie inside the half - light radius of the hercules galaxy . one rrab is just on the border of this region and the remaining two rrab stars lie well outside the half - light radius , with the farthest from the center being confirmed as a member by @xcite on the basis of both radial velocity and strmgren photometry ( see section [ s : cmd ] and figs . [ f : cmd ] and [ f : ad ] for details ) . all the rr lyrae stars fall on the hb of the hercules ufd , and their mean magnitude is consistent , within the errors , with the average luminosity of the hb inferred by fitting the galaxy cmd with the ridge line of the ggc m68 ( see section [ s : cmd ] for details ) . the mean period of the rrab stars is @xmath55 d ( @xmath4=0.03 d ) , thus classifying hercules as an oosterhoff type - ii system . [ f : bailey ] shows the position of the hercules rr lyrae stars on the @xmath0-band period - amplitude ( bailey ) diagram . we have also reported the rr lyrae stars identified in the other mw ufds we have studied so far , for comparison . rrab stars ( star symbols ) lie closer to the loci of the oo ii systems ( from * ? ? ? * solid line ) and the rrc stars fall on the long - period tail of the bell - shaped distribution defined by rrc stars in oo ii systems ( see , e.g. , fig . 9 of @xcite , and fig . 4 of @xcite ) . as shown by @xcite , it is possible to use the shape of an rr lyrae @xmath0-band light curve to obtain an estimate of the star s metallicity . we have performed a fourier decomposition of the @xmath0-band light curves of the variables in hercules and calculated amplitude ratios @xmath56 and phase differences @xmath57 . we list in table [ t : fou ] these quantities up to the term @xmath58 . the fourier parameters were then used along with the formulae provided by @xcite and @xcite for ab- and c - type rr lyrae stars , respectively , to obtain individual metallicities for the hercules rr lyrae stars , except for v10 whose light curve is too noisy for a reliable application of the jurcsik & kovacs method . the metallicity estimates obtained with this technique are reported in column 2 of table [ t : met ] ; they are on the @xcite scale . these individual metallicities were transformed to the @xcite metallicity scale ( using the @xcite transformations for the ab - type variables , and the @xcite recalibration for the c - type rr lyrae stars , see column 3 of table [ t : met ] ) . we then averaged these values ( weighted average ) to obtain our best estimate for the metallicity of hercules old population . our resultant metallicity is @xmath25_{rr , c09 } } \rangle= -2.30 \pm 0.15 $ ] dex . literature values for the hercules ufd s metal abundance are summarized in table [ t : lit_met ] . they were obtained using a variety of different methods and span a rather large range . in particular , we note that the values from @xcite and @xcite are photometric estimates based on fitting the galaxy s cmd with evolutionary tracks , while all other entries in the table are spectroscopic determinations . specifically , the @xcite value is based on abundance analysis of medium - high resolution ( @xmath59 ) spectra of two stars in hercules . the @xcite analysis is based on medium - resolution spectra of 30 red giants in hercules , and the measurement of the equivalent widths of the ca triplet absorption lines . the @xcite study is a re - analysis of the @xcite spectroscopic data , based on an automated spectral synthesis technique . this latter method likely provides systematically lower metallicities ( by @xmath60 dex ) , as discussed by the authors themselves ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? finally , in a recent study , @xcite confirm that a large metallicity spread ( @xmath61}\leq -2.0 $ ] dex , for an average value of [ fe / h]=@xmath62 dex ) exists in hercules , from the analysis of medium - high resolution ( @xmath63 ) spectra of 11 rgb stars . however , taking into account only the red giants with metallicity measurements based on a significant number of iron lines ( @xmath64 ; four stars according to table 6 in @xcite ) , we obtain @xmath65}\rangle=-2.3 \pm 0.2 $ ] dex ( and a range of ( @xmath66}\leq -2.0 $ ] dex ) . this value is in excellent agreement with our estimate from the rr lyrae stars . on this basis , we will adopt the metallicity estimate @xmath67_{rr , c09 } \rangle$ ] obtained from the rr lyrae stars in the following analysis . hercules reddening can be estimated from the galaxy s rr lyrae stars . using the relation for rrab stars by @xcite , that connects the color excess to the star s b - band amplitude , the logarithm of the period and the metallicity , we obtain a mean color excess @xmath68 mag , where we have adopted the individual metallicities on the @xcite scale listed in table [ t : met ] . we also use the method by @xcite , which is based on the rr lyrae s @xmath69 color at minimum light , and obtain @xmath70 mag , by applying the metallicity - dependent relation by @xcite . this estimate is larger than the previous value but , as already pointed out by @xcite and @xcite , sturch s method overestimates the color excess by 0.01 - 0.03 mag . we therefore adopt @xmath71 mag for the reddening . this is in very good agreement with the value of @xmath72 mag derived from the @xcite maps . [ f : cmd ] shows the @xmath0 , @xmath69 cmd of hercules obtained in the present study . in the left panel we plot stellar - like objects within the galaxy s half - light radius ; in the right panel , instead , we show objects outside this region over our fov of @xmath10 . all the rr lyrae stars have been plotted in the left panel of the figure including those falling outside the galaxy half - light radius . the cmd reaches @xmath73 25 mag and appears to be heavily contaminated at each magnitude level by field objects belonging to the mw halo and disk , as well as by background galaxies . our photometry reaches a few magnitudes deeper than the sdss photometry ( see fig . 2 of @xcite ) ; while it is roughly 1 mag shallower than the photometry obtained using the lbt ( fig . 1 in @xcite , and fig . 8 in @xcite ) however , within the errors , it is consistent both in @xmath1 and @xmath0 , with the photometry reported in table 2 of @xcite . in fig . [ f : cmd ] , the main branches of the hercules cmd are barely distinguishable due to the overwhelming contamination by the mw field . to identify stars belonging to hercules we used the method that we have already successfully applied in our previous papers ( see e.g. , @xcite ) . specifically , we used the mean ridgelines of the ggc m68 ( dashed black lines in figure [ f : cmd ] ) , obtained from @xcite @xmath74 photometry to fit the hb and rgb of the hercules ufd , by letting the m68 ridgelines vary within the values of the cluster reddening and distance modulus available in the literature . the `` by eye '' best fit was obtained for a shift of @xmath75 mag in magnitude and @xmath76 mag in color . we adopted m68 for identifying members of the hercules ufd because , like hercules , it is very metal - poor . its metallicity , @xmath77_{m68 } } = -2.27 \pm 0.04 $ ] dex @xcite , is in very good agreement with the mean metallicity obtained in section [ s : met ] from the hercules rr lyrae stars . furthermore , the cluster has a well - defined and tight rgb , as well as an extended hb including stars both redder and bluer than the rr lyrae instability strip ( @xcite ) , thus resulting better suited to identify the galaxy s hb than , for instance , m92 , which instead was used as a fiducial by @xcite . with this procedure we selected as most probable members of the hercules galaxy the sources lying within @xmath78 mag in @xmath69 from the ridgelines of m68 ( black dots in the left panel of figure [ f : cmd ] ) . to account for the larger photometric errors , below @xmath79 mag we extended this range within @xmath80 mag of the ridgeline of m68 ( blue dots ) adopting for m68 a reddening value of @xmath81 mag @xcite the color shifts needed to match the hb and rgb of hercules imply a reddening of @xmath82 mag for the galaxy , in excellent agreement with the value obtained from the rrab stars ( see section [ s : met ] ) . totally similar results are obtained using the ridgelines of the ggc m15 that is slightly more metal - poor than m68 and matches equally well the main branches of the hercules cmd , whereas the ridgeline of the metal - intermediate gc m3 ( ngc 5272 ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) is too red and would require a negative reddening to match the galaxy rgb . with the help of m68 ridgelines , it is possible to determine the average luminosity of the hercules hb in the region of the so - called rr lyrae gap ( @xmath83 mag ) , and to locate the galaxy s main - sequence turnoff at @xmath84 mag . our identification of hercules members is supported by the spectroscopic study of ( * ? ? ? * stars ) and the spectrophotometric analysis of ( * ? ? ? * stars ) , with membership to the hercules ufd confirmed by radial velocity measurements and , for @xcite s sample , also by strmgren photometry ( violet open circles in fig . [ f : cmd ] ) . the excellent agreement between these studies and our results supports the reliability of the procedure we have used to select hercules members and to identify the hb . @xcite compared the galaxy s cmd with the ridge - line of the ggc m92 ( @xmath5 \sim -2.24 $ ] dex ) and m13 ( @xmath5 \sim -1.65 $ ] dex ) and concluded that the morphological features of hercules cmd are generally well described by the ridge line of the old , metal - poor globular cluster m92 . using suitable metal - poor evolutionary tracks and their deep lbt photometry to recover the galaxy s sfh , @xcite and @xcite find that hercules hosts a single old stellar population ( @xmath85 gyr ) , and shows no evidence of significant subsequent star formation events . this is in contrast with the @xcite claim that hercules extended hb showing both a blue and a red component might be the signature of possible multiple stellar populations in the galaxy . however , @xcite s argument can not be considered conclusive , as the morphology of the hb is driven by a complex interplay of different effects , traditionally known in the literature related to ggcs as the `` second parameter problem '' ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . on the other hand , in the region of the cmd above the hb ( @xmath86 and @xmath87 mag ) , there seems to be an overabundance of stars that might represent the signature of an intermediate - age population in hercules . unfortunately , the contamination by field stars in this region of the cmd is very high ( see right panel of fig . [ f : cmd ] ) , thus we can not reach any firm conclusion with our data . an analysis of the existent literature data shows that the hb and the brighter portions of hercules cmd are very poorly populated in the lbt photometry of @xcite and @xcite , likely due to saturation effects , and can not be used to check the possible existence of such an excess above the hb . however , an overabundance of stars brighter than the hb was observed in hercules also by @xcite , who investigated whether they might be variables , based on the magnitude variation in their few ( no more than 3 ) epoch data for the stars . they provide a list of possible variable stars in their table 7 . though we note that these candidate variables are not included in the @xcite final list of hercules members , we checked them in our time series photometry , and do not confirm their variability . however , we have identified an ac variable in this region above the hb , star v2 ( asterisk in fig . [ f : cmd ] , see section [ s : variables ] ) . in fig . [ f : cmd_tracce ] we show an enlargement of the hb region of the cmd in fig . [ f : cmd ] ( with the same color coding ) , where we have plotted the helium burning evolutionary tracks of the stellar model database basti @xcite , for stellar masses in the range of 0.7 to 1.4 @xmath88 ( with a step of 0.1 @xmath88 ) and metal abundance @xmath89 . in particular , the thick ( black and green ) lines are the hb evolutionary tracks for 0.7 and 0.8 @xmath88 , respectively , whereas the thin ( grey ) lines are for @xmath90 including the range of masses corresponding to the hb turnover @xcite . the magenta dot - dashed line represents the zero age horizontal branch ( zahb ) for the same chemical composition . the location of the rr lyrae stars is consistent with the model predictions and suggests an evolutionary effect for some of them . on the other hand , the ac , star v2 , is , as expected , consistent with the evolution of a @xmath91 from the turnover region of the zahb . the origin of acs is still debated ( see e.g. * ? ? ? * and references therein ) and the most widely accepted interpretations are : ( 1 ) they are young ( @xmath92 gyr ) single stars due to recent star formation ; ( 2 ) they formed from mass transfer in binary systems as old as the other stars in the same stellar system . our analysis does not allow us to discriminate between these two scenarios , however , we note that , in the first hypothesis , the comparison of v2 with the evolutionary tracks would suggest the existence in hercules of an intermediate - age population of stars as old as @xmath93 gyrs . fig . [ f : ad ] shows the position of the stars we consider to be members of the hercules galaxy in our fov . symbols and color - coding are the same as in fig . [ f : cmd ] , and the symbol size is inversely proportional to the object s magnitude . the black ellipse corresponds to the half - light radius , the angle position , and the ellipticity obtained for hercules by @xcite . this map confirms that the galaxy is elongated and has an irregular and extended shape . likely , hercules was disrupted due to tidal interaction and is now embedded in the mw halo . our discovery of two rrab variables outside the half - light radius , together with the spectrophotometric identification in the same external region of some stars with confirmed membership by @xcite , support the tidal interaction scenario . [ f : adzoom ] shows an enlargement of the map in fig . [ f : ad ] with the galaxy half - light radius region and all the variable stars identified in the present work . the rr lyrae stars we have detected in hercules give us the opportunity to estimate the distance to the galaxy using these variables as standard candles . the position of the hercules rr lyrae stars in the cmd is in satisfactory agreement with the fiducial - line hb of m68 , although with a significant spread . the most deviating ( brightest ) of the rr lyrae variables , star v9 , is located well outside the galaxy s half - light radius ( see figs . [ f : ad ] and [ f : adzoom ] ) . thus , its high luminosity could be caused by a projection effect . the average magnitude of the rr lyrae stars lying inside the galaxy s half - light radius is @xmath94 mag ( average on 7 stars ) , where the error is the standard deviation of the mean . to obtain the absolute visual magnitude of hercules hb stars , we adopt for the slope of the rr lyrae magnitude - metallicity calibration the value @xmath95 } = 0.214 ( \pm 0.047)$ ] mag dex@xmath33 @xcite , and consider two different calibrations of the zero point . at [ fe / h]=@xmath96 dex , we adopt : @xmath97 mag , that is based on the large magellanic cloud distance modulus of 18.52 @xmath98 mag of @xcite , and , alternatively , @xmath99 mag , from @xcite . adopting for metallicity and reddening the values derived in section [ s : met ] ( @xmath100_{rr , c09}\rangle}= -2.30 \pm 0.15 $ ] dex , and @xmath101 mag , respectively ) we obtain true distance moduli of @xmath102}=20.6\pm 0.1 $ ] mag ( @xmath103}=132 \pm 6 $ ] kpc ) , and @xmath104}=20.7 \pm 0.1 $ ] mag ( @xmath105}=138 \pm 6 $ ] kpc ) , for the @xcite and @xcite calibrations , respectively . the errors on the distance values include the contribution of the uncertainties on the metallicity , the reddening , the adopted slope of the @xmath106}$ ] relation , and the average apparent visual magnitude of the hercules rr lyrae stars . an additional estimate of the distance , based on the rr lyrae stars , can be obtained using the theoretical wesenheit relation in the @xmath38 bands , as defined by @xcite , with the assumption of a suitable evolutionary mass for the metallicity of hercules rr lyrae stars . the resulting distance modulus of @xmath107 mag is in perfect agreement with @xmath102}$ ] . moreover , a distance of @xmath108 kpc is in excellent agreement with the estimates by @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and in statistical agreement with the distance by @xcite . on the other hand , the distance @xmath105}$ ] appears to be only in statistical agreement with all previous determinations . to conclude this discussion , we note that the very long estimate of @xmath109 kpc , obtained by @xcite is likely due to their hb mean magnitude being based on a few stars , of which some are variables observed at random phase , as we have confirmed in our study . finally , the apparent distance modulus adopted in fig . [ f : cmd_tracce ] , @xmath110 mag , corresponds to a true distance modulus of 20.7 mag . however , we should take into account the theoretical uncertainties on the luminosity of the zahb and , in particular , the remark by @xcite that , adopting updated conductive opacities , might cause an increase in the @xmath111 of about 0.06 mag at the metallicity of hercules , and a corresponding decrease in the inferred distance modulus . on this basis , and considering also the results of the theoretical wesenheit relation , we thus conclude that our most reliable estimate for the distance modulus of hercules is : @xmath112 mag . in this paper we have presented the first time - series analysis of the hercules ufd . using a variety of telescope / instrument facilities we secured @xmath113 80 and 50 epochs in @xmath1 and @xmath0 . these data allowed us to detect and characterize 9 rr lyrae stars ( 6 ab- and 3 c - type , respectively ) and one anomalous cepheid . the same observations allowed us to build a deep cmd extending well beyond the galaxy s half - light radius . the main results of this study are listed below : * the average period of the ab - type rr lyrae stars , @[email protected] d , qualifies hercules as an oosterhoff ii system , in good agreement with the vast majority of the ufds investigated so far . this occurrence favors the hypothesis that the ufds could be the `` building blocks '' of the galactic halo , since the pulsation characteristics of their rr lyrae stars are in agreement with the properties of the mw halo variables . * hercules cmd is dominated by a stellar population at least as old and metal - poor as the ggc m68 . this result is in agreement with previous findings . the hb shows some spread . we also detected an overabundance of stars above the hb , thus confirming the previous finding by @xcite . this , along with the detection of an anomalous cepheid very likely belonging to hercules , hints at the possible presence of an intermediate - age population about @xmath93 gyrs old in hercules . * the spatial distribution of hercules stars confirms the elongated shape of this galaxy . the signature that hercules is undergoing tidal disruption is provided by the absence of a clearcut difference between galaxy and field star properties , and by the presence of two rr lyrae stars lying well beyond the galaxy s half - light radius . * the rr lyrae variables were used to obtain independent estimates of the metallicity , reddening and distance to hercules , for which we find [ fe / h]=@xmath115 dex , @xmath6 mag , and @xmath116 mag respectively , in very good agreement with literature values . we thank an anonymous referee for carefully reading the paper and for providing comments that helped to improve the clarity of the manuscript . financial support for this research was provided by cofis asi - inaf i/016/07/0 , by the agreement asi - inaf i/009/10/0 , and by prin inaf 2010 , ( p.i . : g. clementini ) . support for m.c . is provided by proyecto fondecyt regular # 1110326 ; basal center for astrophysics and associated technologies ( pfb-06 ) ; fondap center for astrophysics ( 15010003 ) ; the chilean ministry for the economy , development , and tourism s programa iniciativa cientfica milenio through grant p07 - 021-f , awarded to the milky way millennium nucleus ; and proyecto anillo act-86 . has thanks the u.s . nsf for support under grants ast0607249 and ast0707756 . adn , d. , feltzing , s. , koch , a. , et al . 2009 , , 506 , 1147 adn , d. , eriksson , k. , feltzing , s. , et al . 2011 , , 525 , a153 baldacci , l. , clementini , g. , held , e. v. , marconi , m. , & rizzi , l. 2004 , communications in asteroseismology , 145 , 32 belokurov , v. , zucker , d. b. , evans , n. w. , et al . 2006 , , 647 , l111 belokurov , v. , zucker , d. b. , evans , n. w. , et al . 2007 , , 654 , 897 belokurov , v. , walker , m. g. , evans , n. w. , et al . 2010 , , 712 , l103 benedict , g. f. , mcarthur , b. e. , feast , m. w. , et al . 2011 , , 142 , 187 bersier , d. , & wood , p. r. 2002 , , 123 , 840 blazhko , s. , 1907 , astron . nachr . 175 , 325 buonanno , r. , corsi , c. , bellazzini , m. , ferraro , f. r. , fusi pecci , 1997 , aj , 113 , 706 cacciari , c. , corwin , t. m. , & carney , b. w. 2005 , , 129 , 267 caputo , f. , & deglinnocenti , s. 1995 , , 298 , 833 carretta , e. , cacciari , c. , ferraro , f. r. , fusi pecci , f. , & tessicini , g. 1998 , , 298 , 1005 carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , gratton , r. , dorazi , v. , lucatello , s. , 2009 , a&a , 508 , 695 cassisi , s. , potekhin , a. y. , pietrinferni , a. , catelan , m. , & salaris , m. 2007 , , 661 , 1094 catelan , m. , 2009 , ap&ss 320 , 261 clement & rowe 2000 , aj , 120 , 2579 clementini , g. 2010 , in variable stars , the galactic halo and galaxy formation , eds . n. samus , c. sterken , l. szabados , sternberg astronomical institute publications , p. 111 , ( arxiv:1002.1575 ) clementini , g. , et al . , 2000 , aj , 120 , 2054 clementini , g. , gratton , r. g. , bragaglia , a. , carretta , e. , di fabrizio , l. , & maio , m. 2003 , aj , 125 , 1309 coleman , m. g. , et al . , 2007 , aj , 134 , 1938 dallora , m. , et al . 2006 , apj 653 , l109 dallora , m. , et al . 2012 , apj , accepted , arxiv:1203.5321 di criscienzo , m. , greco , c. , ripepi , v. , clementini , g. , dallora , m. , marconi , m. , musella , i. , federici , l. , di fabrizio , l. 2011 , , 141 , 81 di criscienzo , m. , marconi , m. , caputo , f. 2004 , apj 612 , 1092 durrell , p. r. , & harris , w. e. 1993 , , 105 , 1420 ferraro , f. r. , carretta , e. , corsi , c. e. , fusi pecci , f. , cacciari , c. , buonanno , r. , paltrinieri , b. , & hamilton , d. 1997 , a&a , 320 , 757 frebel , a. , kirby , e. n. , & simon , j. d. 2010 , , 464 , 72 giallongo , e. , ragazzoni , r. , grazian , a. , et al . 2008 , , 482 , 349 grado , a. , capaccioli , m. , limatola , l. , & getman , f. 2012 , memorie della societa astronomica italiana supplementi , 19 , 362 gratton , r. g. , carretta , e. , bragaglia , a. , lucatello , s. , dorazi , v. 2010 , a&a , 517 , 81 greco , c. , et al . 2008 , apj 695 , l83 johnson , j. a. , & bolte , m. 1998 , apj , 115 , 693 jurcsik , j. & kovcs , g. 1996 , a&a , 312 , 111 kaluzny , j. , hilditch , r. w. , clement , c. , & rucinski , s. m. 1998 , , 296 , 347 kapakos , e. , hatzidimitriou , d. , & soszyski , i. 2011 , , 415 , 1366 kirby , e. n. , simon , j. d. , geha , m. , guhathakurta , p. , & frebel , a. 2008 , apj , 685 , l43 kirby , e. n. , guhathakurta , p. , bolte , m. , sneden , c. , & geha , m. c. 2009 , , 705 , 328 kirby , e. n. , guhathakurta , p. , simon , j. d. , et al . 2010 , , 191 , 352 klypin , a. , kravtsov , a. v. , valenzuela , o. , & prada , f. 1999 , , 522 , 82 koch , a. , mcwilliam , a. , grebel , e. k. , zucker , d. b. , & belokurov , v. 2008 , , 688 , l13 kuehn , c. , et al . 2008 , apj 674 , l1381 landolt , a. u. 1992 , , 104 , 340 landolt , a. u. 2009 , , 137 , 4186 lee , y .- w . , demarque , p. , zinn , r 1994 , apj , 423 , 248 marconi , m. , fiorentino , g. , & caputo , f. 2004 , , 417 , 1101 martin , n. f. , de jong , j. t. a. , rix , h .- w . 2008 , apj 684 , 1075 moore , b. , ghigna , s. , governato , f. , et al . 1999 , , 524 , l19 moretti , m.i . , et al . 2009 , apj 699 , l125 morgan , s. m. , wahl , j. n. , & wieckhorst , r. m. 2007 , , 374 , 1421 musella , i. , et al . 2009 , apj 675 , l73 oosterhoff , p. t. 1939 , the observatory , 62 , 104 pearrubia , j. , navarro , j. f. , mcconnachie , a. w. , & martin , n. f. 2009 , , 698 , 222 piersimoni , a. m. , bono , g. , & ripepi , v. 2002 , , 124 , 1528 pietrinferni , a. , cassisi , s. , salaris , m. , & castelli , f. 2004 , , 612 , 168 pietrinferni , a. , cassisi , s. , salaris , m. , & castelli , f. 2006 , , 642 , 797 richardson , j.c . 2011 , , 732 , 76 sand , d. j. , olszewski , e. w. , willman , b. , zaritsky , d. , seth , a. , harris , j. , piatek , s. , saha , a. , 2009 , apj , 704 , 898 schlegel , d. j. , finkbeiner , d. p. , & davis , m. 1998 , apj , 500 , 525 schwarzenberg - czerny , a. 1996 , , 460 , l107 simon , j. d. , & geha , m. 2007 , apj , 670 , 313 stetson , p. b. 1987 , , 99 , 191 stetson , p. b. 1994 , , 106 , 250 stetson , p. b. 2000 , , 112 , 925 sturch , c. 1966 , , 143 , 774 tolstoy , e. , hill , v. , tosi , m. 2009 , , 47 , 371 walker , a. r. 1994 , aj , 108 , 555 walker , a. r. 1998 , , 116 , 220 zinn , r. & west , m. j. 1984 , apjs , 55 , 45
Abstract: | [
"we present the first time - series study of the ultra - faint dwarf galaxy hercules . using a variety of telescope / instrument facilities we secured about 50 @xmath0 and 80 @xmath1 epochs . these data allowed us to detect and characterize 10 pulsating variable stars in hercules . our final sample includes 6 fundamental - mode ( ab - type ) and 3 first overtone ( c - type ) rr lyrae stars , and one anomalous cepheid . the average period of the ab - type rr lyrae stars , @xmath2p@xmath3=0.68 d ( @xmath4 = 0.03 d ) , places hercules in the oosterhoff ii group , as found for almost the totality of the ultra - faint dwarf galaxies investigated so far for variability . the rr lyrae stars were used to obtain independent estimates of the metallicity , reddening and distance to hercules , for which we find : @xmath5=-2.30\\pm0.15 $ ] dex , @xmath6 mag , and @xmath7 mag , in good agreement with the literature values . we have obtained a @xmath8 color - magnitude diagram ( cmd ) of hercules that reaches @xmath9 25 mag and extends beyond the galaxy s half - light radius over a total area of @xmath10 . the cmd and the rr lyrae stars indicate the presence of a population as old and metal - poor as ( at least ) the galactic globular clusters m68 ."
] | 8,172 | 8,172 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: growing attention to cdse / cds core / thick shell nanocrystals ( ncs ) initially reported by two groups @xcite is stimulated by their superior optical properties superior to any other nc hetero - structures prepared up to now . the photoluminescence is never completely quenched in these ncs @xcite and the blinking is almost completely suppressed @xcite . at low temperatures these structures demonstrate suppression of non - radiative auger recombination @xcite and almost 100% photoluminescence quantum yield @xcite . as a result these nc structures demonstrate a very low threshold for optically pumped lasing @xcite . the origin of such outstanding optical properties of the cdse / cds core / thick shell nano - structures ( or giant cdse / cds ncs @xcite ) is not completely understood , but one thing is clear . the very thick shell always prevents carrier escape to the nc , no matter which mechanism is responsible for this escape : direct quantum mechanical tunneling , thermo - ionization of the ncs , or auger auto - ionization of the ncs , where two electron hole pairs were created simultaneously @xcite . the prevention of the nc ionization could explain the blinking suppression ; however , it does not explain the suppression of non - radiative auger recombination of charged excitons , biexcitons @xcite and multi - excitons @xcite . the alloying of the cdse / cds interface in giant cdse / cds ncs could be a reason for auger recombination suppression , as was suggested in several papers of the los alamos group @xcite . this explanation relies on a theoretical prediction that softening of the carrier confined potential could reduce the auger recombination rate by three orders of magnitude @xcite . indeed , growth of the thick shell in the giant cdse / cds core / shell ncs lasted for a week @xcite . the slow growth of the shell at temperatures above room temperature suggests that the strong interface diffusion takes place during the nc growth . the diffusion should lead to alloying adjacent to the surface area and softening of the confinement potential . this alloying assumption was confirmed recently by the demonstration of mixed phonon replicas in the fluorescence line narrowing ( fln ) of cdse / cds ncs with a thick shell @xcite . this argument , however , can not be used to explain the suppression of the auger recombination observed by dubertret group @xcite . the shell of their ncs is grown very fast and that practically excludes any inter - diffusion . in contrast , the fast growth of the lattice mismatched cdse / cds core / shell ncs should obviously results in some intrinsic strains . indeed , the samples exhibit a phonon spectrum of a pure cdse nc , the frequencies of which are shifted from bulk cdse frequencies due to the compressive strain within the nc @xcite . an understanding of the unusual and potentially useful properties of the giant cdse / cds core / shell ncs requires a theoretical description of the fine structure of the band edge excitons , and trions . up to now , the energy spectra of these nc quantum dots were studied only within simplified parabolic band models @xcite , which do not take into account the complex structure of the valence band and the complicated character of inter - particle coulomb interactions . the theoretical description of the energy spectra of the exciton and exciton complexes in these ncs also has some objective complications , because cdse / cds hetero - structures are not well characterized . we know that holes are always localized in cdse , and that the valence band offset is no less than 500mev . however , we do nt know the sign of the band - offset of the conduction band nor its magnitude . a small value of the cdse / cds conduction band offset suggests its complex behavior , because the band offset sign and magnitude should be sensitive to the strain and temperature @xcite . these qualitative data on the band offset suggest that an exciton created in cdse / cds ncs with a thick cds shell should look like a donor center , where a hole is strongly localized in the cdse core while an electron is attracted to this charged core by the coulomb potential . if cdse / cds is the type ii hetero - structure , the core potential in the nc pushes the electron into the cds shell . in the opposite case , if cdse / cds is the type i heterostucture , the core creates an additional well , which increases the electron localization around the hole . the temperature dependence of the cdse and cds energy gaps @xcite suggests that a decrease of temperature should favor type i. as a result , a decrease of the temperature increases the exciton binding energy and , consequently , shortens the radiative decay time of excitons , which is controlled by the electron - hole wave function overlap , and increases the dark - bright exciton splitting.@xcite due to the very strong confinement of holes , the positively charged trion which was observed in the cdse / cds ncs @xcite appears as a doubly - charged donor . the larger coulomb attraction of the electron to the core should significantly increase the electron binding energy and shorten the radiative decay time . the negatively charged exciton should look like a negatively charged donor center d@xmath0 . the binding energy of the second electron in the d@xmath0 center is usually quite small on the order of @xmath1 of the donor binding energy . this energy will be higher , however , in redthe type i cdse / cds core / shell structure , due to an additional attractive potential ( created by the cdse core ) for an electron . finally , a biexciton in these structures looks like the helium atom , with two holes localized in the core and two electrons with opposite spins occupying the same orbit . in this paper , we have calculated the binding energy and the fine structure of the exciton in cdse / cds ncs with a very thick shell as a function of the cdse / cds conduction band offset and the core radius . the calculations takes into account the complex structure of the cdse valence band and inter - particle coulomb and exchange interaction . we have also developed a general theory describing the fine structures and radiative decay time of positively and negatively charged trions . using this theory we have calculated optical spectra of trions in giant cdse / cds core / shell ncs as a function of conduction - band offset and core radius . this paper is organized as follows : in section ii and iii we describe the energy spectra and wave functions of one and two holes localized in the cdse core . in section iv we discuss the energy and the wave function of an electron in a central symmetrical potential created by localized holes and the conduction band offset . in section v we derive the wave functions and the energy of excitons and positively charged trions . in section vi we discuss the fine structure of these excitons and trions . in section vii we calculate the binding energy of the negatively - charged trions . in section viii we consider the radiative decay of all exciton complexes . finally , we discuss obtained results and compare them with available experimental data in section ix . in cdse / cds core shell nanocrystals , the valence band offset is substantially large and the holes are strongly confined in the cdse core . for the heavy ground state holes this potential can be considered as infinitely high in the first approximation . the first quantum - size level of holes in a spherical nc of a semiconductor with the degenerate @xmath2 valence subband is a @xmath3 state.@xcite this state has total angular momentum @xmath4 and it is fourfold degenerate with respect to its projection @xmath5 on the @xmath6 axis . @xcite . the wave functions of these four states can be written as@xcite @xmath7 where @xmath8 are wigner 3j - symbols , @xmath9 are spherical harmonics defined in ref . , and @xmath10 ( @xmath11 ) are the bloch functions of the fourfold degenerate valence band @xmath2 @xcite . the radial functions @xmath12 and @xmath13 corresponding to an impenetrable barrier at the cdse / cds interface with radius @xmath14 can be written in explicit form following refs . and : @xmath15 ~,\nonumber \\ r_0(r ) & = & { a\over a^{3/2}}\left [ j_0(\varphi r / a)- { j_0(\varphi ) \over j_0(\varphi\sqrt{\beta})}j_0(\varphi\sqrt{\beta}r / a ) \right]~ , \label{rfunction}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath16 and @xmath17 are spherical bessel functions , the constant a is determined by the normalization condition @xmath18=1 $ ] and @xmath19 is the ratio of light to heavy hole effective masses : @xmath20 and @xmath21 , respectively . the dimensionless parameter @xmath22 is a first root of the equation @xmath23 , and describes the energy of the lowest hole level @xcite : @xmath24 . the assymetry effects , which include the intrinsic asymmetry of the hexagonal lattice structure of the crystal s field , @xcite and the nonspherical shape of the nc @xcite , split the four - fold degenerate hole state into two two - fold degenerate states with @xmath25 and @xmath26 , respectively : e_1s_3/2 , j_z = e_1s_3/2 - ( j_z^2 - 5/4 ) , + [ splitting ] where @xmath27 where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the intrinsic and size dependent shape contributions which can be found , for example , in ref . . before considering the positively charged excitons , which can be observed in ncs with an extra hole , let us consider the energy spectra of two holes localized in the cdse core . the application of the pauli exclusion principle to the two holes occupying the @xmath3 level is nontrivial . generally , the two holes with momentum @xmath30 according to the momentum summation rule @xmath31 could form four states with the total angular momentum @xmath32 . the wave functions of these states can generally be written as @xmath33 where @xmath34 is the projection of the total momentum @xmath35 on the @xmath6 axis . the pauli hole permutation requirement applied to the wave function described by eq . , however , allows only the two nontrivial solutions . as a result , the two holes occupying the @xmath3 level can only be in a 5-fold degenerate state with total momentum @xmath36 and a state with @xmath37.@xcite hole - hole exchange interaction splits the ground biexciton into the two states with total momentum @xmath36 and @xmath37 . the straightforward calculation of the @xmath38 coulomb interaction with the functions from eq . gives the energy of the corresponding levels : @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the band - edge energy of the two - hole state taking into account the direct coulomb repulsion only , @xmath41 is the exchange splitting and can be written in the following form @xcite @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the dielectric constant of the semiconductor and @xmath44 , @xmath45 . the direct coulomb interaction energy is given by @xmath46 in the spherical ncs , the ground two hole state has total momentum @xmath36.@xcite in the case of the cdse / cds structure with impenetrable interface , when the wave functions are described by eq . , the exchange splitting and coulomb energy can be written as @xmath47 in cdse ncs , where @xmath48 , @xmath49 @xcite and @xmath50 . the nc asymmetry , which lifts the degeneracy of the @xmath3 hole state in eq . , causes further splitting of the two hole states . the corresponding perturbation can be written as@xcite @xmath51 where @xmath52 and @xmath53 are the operators of hole momentum projection acting on the first and second hole , respectively . the resulting two - hole states are described in ref . . the ground two - hole state has angular momentum projection of @xmath54 and energy @xmath55 the first excited state has @xmath56 and energy @xmath57 , which is not affected by perturbations connected with nc asymmetry . finally , the upper state has @xmath54 and the energy @xmath58 two - hole wave functions @xmath59 ( for the energies @xmath60 ) and @xmath61 ( for the fourfold degenerate intermediate level @xmath57 ) are given by@xcite _ 0 ^ 2h , ( r_h1 , r_h2 ) & = & , + _ 1 ^ 2h ( r_h1 , r_h2)&= & ( _ 3/2^h(r_h1)_1/2^h(r_h2)- _ 1/2^h(r_h1)_3/2^h(r_h2 ) ) , + _ 2 ^ 2h ( r_h1 , r_h2)&= & ( _ 3/2^h(r_h1)_1/2^h(r_h2)- _ 1/2^h(r_h1)_3/2^h(r_h2 ) ) , [ biexfunction2 ] where b_0^ = , b_2^= , [ bs ] with @xmath62 . in section ii above we have considered holes in the cdse / cds core / shell ncs assuming that they are very strongly confined in the cdse core . in that case their wave functions are not modified by the coulomb interaction with the electron or by the hole - hole interaction , and are solely determined by the radius of the cdse core . on the contrary , the conduction band offset in such structures is known to be small and even the sign of the band offset is not confirmed . as a result , the band offset itself does not localize ( or only weakly localizes ) an electron in the cdse core . the attractive coulomb potential created by the holes plays an important role in electron localization at the center of the core / shell nc structures . we will show in the next section that the attractive coulomb potential created by holes localized in _ a spherically symmetrical _ cdse core does not have spherical symmetry . in the first approximation , however , the ground electron state is described by the wave function of @xmath63 symmetry , which can be written as _ 1/2^e(r)=r_e^z(r)y_00()u^c_1/2 , [ electronwf ] where @xmath64 are the bloch wave functions of the conduction band and @xmath65 is the electron spin projection . the radial wave function @xmath66 is described by the radial hamiltonian @xmath67 here @xmath68 is the conduction band offset ( cbo ) ( @xmath69 in type ii structures and @xmath70 in type i structures ) , @xmath71 and @xmath72 are the electron effective masses in cdse and cds , correspondingly , and @xmath73 is the effective coulomb potential of one ( @xmath74 ) or two ( @xmath75 ) holes acting on an electron . we use @xmath76 to describe the `` free '' electron problem in the case of the neutral core . the radial wave function @xmath66 is completely defined by eq . and the standard boundary conditions at the cdse / cds interface @xmath77 : @xmath78 later we will need the radial function of the `` free '' resident electron , which remains in ncs after negative trion recombination . its wave function @xmath79 can be written as @xmath80 where @xmath81 is the normalization constant , @xmath82 is the spherical hankel function,@xcite @xmath83 , @xmath84 and @xmath85 is the electron ground state energy level calculated from the bottom of the cds conduction band . this energy is described by the smallest solution of the following equation : @xmath86 where @xmath87 . it is important to note that even if cdse / cds core / thick shell ncs are type i structures , the resident electron is not localized in the cdse core with small radius @xmath14 and is spread over the entire cds shell . the electron localization occurs only if the power of a quantum well @xmath88 is larger than @xmath89 , which is a solution of the following equation : @xmath90 . for @xmath91 the electron delocalization occurs when @xmath92 , the condition which is identical to the standard expression for the critical depth of the 3d potential allowing the electron localization , @xmath93.@xcite however , the large electron effective mass in cds resulting in @xmath94 allows the localization in the cdse core with @xmath95 smaller than @xmath96 : @xmath97 . the electron wave function is strongly modified by a long range coulomb potential created by a hole or holes in the donor - like exciton or the positively charged trion in cdse / cds ncs with a small cbo . electrons are bound to the cdse core by a strong coulomb potential of a single hole or two holes , @xmath98 correspondingly , which are strongly confined by the core potential , similar to an electron in singly or doubly charged donors . this potential always leads to some binding of electrons to the cdse core , even in type ii cdse / cds core / shell structures . the attraction potential of holes is described by the distribution of the hole positive charge within the core of the radius @xmath14 . the straightforward use of the hole wave function definition in eq . gives the charge distribution of the single hole state with @xmath99 and @xmath100 correspondingly : _ 3/2(r)=|^h_3/2(r)|^2&=&(r_0(r)y_00 + 1r_2(r)y_20)^2 + 25r_2 ^ 2(r)(|y_21|^2+|y_22|^2 ) , + _ 1/2(r)=|^h_1/2(r)|^2&=&(r_0(r)y_00 - 1r_2(r)y_20)^2 + 25r_2 ^ 2(r)(|y_21|^2+|y_22|^2 ) , using the definition of spherical harmonics , @xmath101 , from @xcite we arrive to _ m(r)=14 . [ eq:13 ] the charge distribution of two _ isotropic _ holes with @xmath102 , localized in cdse core , @xmath103 can be obtained from the two - hole wave functions @xmath104 defined in eq . : _ j , j_z^2h(r)=d^3r_h1 d^3r_h2|_j , j_z^2h ( r_h1 , r_h2)|^2[(r - r_h1)+(r - r_h2 ) ] to obtain the hole charge distribution for @xmath105 one has to use the two hole wave functions described in eq . ( [ biexfunction2 ] ) . the calculations show that for the four - time degenerate hole state @xmath57 , which is characterized by the angular momentum projections @xmath106 , the charge distribution is spherical and is described as ^2h_1 , 2(r)=24[eq:17 ] for the upper , `` @xmath107 '' , and lower , `` @xmath108 '' , two hole states with @xmath109 similar calculations result ^2h,_0(r)=24[eq:18 ] in the limit @xmath110 eq . is simplified significantly : ^2h,_0(r)=24 . [ eq:19 ] comparison of eq . with eq . shows clearly that in the case @xmath111 , the lowest level is created from two heavy holes , while the uppermost level is created by two light holes . similar comparison of eq . with eq . shows that the middle level is always created by one light and one heavy hole . one can show that only the spherical part of the hole charge distribution contributes to the ground @xmath63 electron state in first order perturbation theory . for the single ( @xmath74 ) and double ( @xmath75 ) hole states this distribution can be written as ^z_0(r)=z4 the coulomb potential created by the hole spherical charge distribution can be written as v^z_coul(r)=-ze^2_0^adr^3^z_0(r)|r -r| [ eq:21 ] where @xmath43 is the dielectric constant , which is considered to be the same in both cdse and cds . equation can be rewritten as : v^z_coul(r)=-ze^2 4 . [ potentialv ] this potential outside the cdse core , @xmath112 , always has a standard coulomb orm , @xmath113 , due to the wave function normalization condition , @xmath114=1 $ ] . inside the core @xmath115 , and the potential depth @xmath116 depends only on the ratio @xmath117 of the light- to heavy - hole effective masses . in cdse where @xmath118 ; @xmath119 . we will consider only cdse / cds core / shell ncs with a very thick shell because these ncs show the most interesting and useful properties . from now on all calculations will be conducted for heterostructure with unlimited cds shell thickness ; later we will discuss the limitations of our approach . the ground state of a weakly bound electron in the donor - like exciton or positively charged trion created in cdse / cds is described by the hamiltonian of eq . with coulomb potential , @xmath120 , described by eq . . introducing dimensionless distance from the nc center , @xmath121 , and dimensionless energies @xmath122 , we obtain the dimensionless hamiltonian , @xmath123 for the radial component of the electron wave function , @xmath124 . in hamiltonian @xmath125 we use @xmath126 , @xmath127 . all energies are calculated from the bottom of the cds conduction band , and the confinement potential @xmath128 created by the conduction band offset is negative in type i , and positive in type ii , cdse / cds hetero - structures . we also introduce the unitless parameter @xmath129 that characterizes the strength of coulomb potential created by holes , where @xmath130 is the bohr radius . a central parabolic part of the hole potential described by eq . becomes important if @xmath131 is large . the wave function of the 1s ground state should be close to the wave function of the harmonic oscillator . in the opposite case of small @xmath131 , the core potential is weak and the electron moves mainly in the coulomb - like potential at large distances from the core . to describe both above - mentioned limits , we select a trial radial function in the following form : @xmath132 where @xmath133 and @xmath134 are dimensionless variation parameters , which will be found using the variational principle , and constants @xmath81,@xmath135 , and @xmath136 , which are completely determined by the interface boundary and normalization conditions . the standard boundary conditions at the cdse / cds interface ( @xmath137 ) described by eq . gives @xmath138 & x \le 1\\ b e^ { \left(1-x \right)/\zeta } \left.\displaystyle { 2 \alpha^2 \zeta \over 2 \left(\alpha ^2 -1\right ) \zeta + \alpha ^2 \mu}\right . & x > 1 ~ , \end{array } \right . \label{trial1abcd}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath135 can be found from the normalization condition @xmath139 ( see appendix ) . using eq . we can find the expectation value for the energy , @xmath140 , of one electron : |e^z_e = _ 0^ r_e^z(x)_r^z(x ) r_e^z(x ) x^2 dx [ trail1total ] to simplify the calculation we approximate the potential , @xmath141 which is inside the core ( @xmath142 ) by the polynomial @xmath143 , where @xmath144 and @xmath145 were selected to satisfy the exact potential properties at @xmath146 . outside the core ( @xmath147 ) the potential is given by @xmath148 according to eq.([potentialv ] ) . the potential and the potential derivatives should be continuous at @xmath149 , which allows us to determine @xmath150 and @xmath151 . next , we vary the coefficients @xmath152 and @xmath153 to fit the polynomial to the function @xmath154 , the form of which depends only on the parameter @xmath117 . the best fit of @xmath154 for @xmath155 was achieved using @xmath156 and @xmath157 . figure [ potential ] shows the dimensionless potential @xmath154 . the cob is introduced via @xmath158 one can see that when the band offset is positive , the electron is pushed away from the cdse core . the negative band offset added to the coulomb attractive potential stimulates electron localization . the second hole localized in the cdse core just increases the magnitude of the attractive potential by a factor of two . -0.1truecm -0.7truecm -0.1truecm using this approximation we were able to develop an analytical expression for the electron binding energy @xmath159 , via parameters @xmath133 and @xmath134 and find the absolute minimum of the total energy and a corresponding pair of @xmath134 and @xmath133 for given @xmath160 , @xmath161 , @xmath162 , and the band offset @xmath128 ( see online supplemental material ) . figure [ bindingenergy ] shows the binding energy of an electron for various core radii and band offsets , calculated for the cases when the cdse core is charged with one ( @xmath74 ) and two ( @xmath75 ) holes . the energy is calculated from the bottom of the of the cds conduction band . the size dependences are calculted for a cdse core with a 2.5 nm radius and shown for five band offsets : @xmath163 mev . one can see that in ncs with small negative or positive band - offset , this energy decreases with a radius increase , while in the case of -100 and -200 mev , it increases following the bottom of the conduction band . the decrease of the binding energy with radius increase in ncs with small negative or positive band - offset is connected with the fact that electron motion in such ncs is controlled by coulomb potential , which decreases with nc size . 0.1truecm -0.7truecm 0.1truecm figure [ bindingenergy ] shows the dependence of the electron binding energy on the band offset,@xmath158 , in ncs with core radius 1.5 , 2.5 , and 3.5 nm radius for the single and doubly charged cdse core . the band offset depends on temperature @xcite , and the shift of the exciton line can be observed in temperature dependence . the fine structure of the excitons and trions is strongly affected by the electron - hole exchange interaction , which can be written in spherical approximation as h_exch= -23a_0 ^ 3(r_e - r_h)_exch ( ) , [ eq:28 ] where,@xmath164 is the lattice constant , @xmath165 is the strength of the exchange interaction ( in energy units ) , @xmath166 are the pauli matrices , and @xmath167 are three matrices of the momentum 3/2 . the strength of the exchange interaction in cubic and hexagonal semiconductors can be determined from the bulk exciton fine structure . in cdse this constant extracted from the bulk exciton splitting @xmath168 mev . @xcite averaging eq . over electron and hole wave functions in the basis of the 8-fold degenerate exciton state @xcite , one can arrive at the following expression for the spin - spin exchange hamiltonian between an electron and a hole : h_exch^1= -_1 ( ) , where the exchange parameter @xmath169 depends strongly on the number of holes in cdse core : _ z=_exch_0^a dr r^2[r_e^z(r)]^2[r_0 ^ 2(r)+0.2r_2 ^ 2(r ) ] , [ exchange ] due to the strong effect of the core charge on the electron radial function , @xmath170 . the radial functions @xmath170 and @xmath171 are defined in eqs . and , respectively . integration in eq . goes only to the core radius @xmath14 because in our approximation the hole wave function @xmath171 vanishes at the cdse / cds interface . one can see from eq . , that if an electron is only weakly localized in the cdse core , then the parameter @xmath172 is small . this parameter is proportional to @xmath173 where @xmath174 is a localization radius of the electron . in fig . a we show the dependence of the exchange energy @xmath175 of the exciton as a function of the conduction band offset for several cdse core radii . one can see that increase of @xmath128 leads to an increase of electron localization in the core always increases @xmath175 . figure b we show the dependence of exciton exchange energy @xmath175 as a function of the cdse core radius for several ncs band offsets . for all reasonable set of radii , @xmath175 increases with the decrease of the nc radius . -0.1truecm -0.7truecm -0.1truecm the ground exciton state in spherical nc of zinc - blende semiconductors is characterized by the total exciton momentum @xmath176 . for the ground 5-fold degenerate dark exciton state @xmath177 , and for the excited 3-fold degenerate bright exciton state @xmath178 . in cubic semiconductor ncs with nonspherical shape and ncs with wurzite lattice structure these states are split into 5 excitons , each of them characterized by the projection of the total mometum on the hexagonal axis @xmath179.@xcite the respective wave functions are constructed from the hole functions of eq . and electron functions of eq . , with the radial functions @xmath180 for the electron moving in the coulomb potential @xmath181 created by one hole localized in the cdse core . the band edge exciton fine structure is completely characterized by two parameters @xmath175 and @xmath182 defined above . in spherical cubic ncs , the splitting between bright and dark excitons is given by @xmath183 . in the case corresponding to @xmath184 , the splitting between the ground dark exciton with @xmath185 and the first excited bright exciton exciton with @xmath186 is @xmath187 . the last case is most probably realized in presently grown cdse / cds ncs.@xcite in the more general case , corresponding to @xmath188 , the exciton fine structure is described by expressions which can be found in refs . , , and . the operator for the electron - hole exchange interaction in the positively charged trion can be written as h_exch(r_1)+h_exch(r_2)= -23a_0 ^ 3_exch [ eq:31 ] where @xmath189 , @xmath190 and @xmath191 , @xmath192 are coordinates and spin matrices of two holes , respectively . the averaging of eq . over radial components of the two hole and electron wave functions results in the effective electron - hole spin exchange hamiltonian h_exch= - 2_2 ( ) , j = j_1+j_2 , where @xmath193 is defined in eq . . the dependences of the trion exchange parameter @xmath193 on the core radius and the conduction band offset are shown in insets of fig . . one can see that due to stronger attraction of the electron to the cdse cores coursed by the second hole , the trion s @xmath193 are larger than those for the exciton . in the absence of the hole level splitting ( @xmath194 ) , the states of the positively charged trion are characterized by the total momentum @xmath195 and the trion wave functions can be generally found as @xmath196 where @xmath197 is the projection of the total momentum @xmath198 on the @xmath6 axis , @xmath199 is the projection of the electron spin on the @xmath6 axis , @xmath200 is the two - hole wave function described by eq . ( [ twoholes ] ) , and @xmath201 is the electron wave function described by eq . ( [ electronwf ] ) with the radial function @xmath202 for the electron moving in the coulomb potential created by two holes . the ground trion state has total momentum @xmath203 and the energy @xmath204 ; the next one has @xmath205 with the energy @xmath206 ; and , finally , the upper state has @xmath207 with the energy @xmath208 . the last trion state is not affected by electron hole exchange interaction because the electron interaction with two different holes exactly compensate each other . the splitting of the two lowest hole states @xmath57 coursed by the exchange interaction is @xmath209 . the order of two excited trion states depends on the relative strength of electron - hole or hole - hole exchange interactions . all these trion states are twofold degenerate with respect of the momentum projection @xmath197 , and their wave functions , @xmath210 , can be written ^tr_1/2,1/2&=&^2h_0,0^e_1/2 , ^tr_3/2,1/2=^2h_2,1^e_1/2 ^ 2h_2,0^e_1/2 , + ^tr_3/2,3/2&=&(2 ^ 2h_2,2^e_1/2-^2h_2,1^e_1/2 ) , ^tr_5/2,1/2=^2h_2,1^e_1/2+^2h_2,0^e_1/2 , + ^tr_5/2,3/2&= & ( ^2h_2,2^e_1/2 + 2 ^ 2h_2,1^e_1/2 ) , ^tr_5/2,5/2=^2h_2,2^e_1/2 , [ tr55 ] . when the ground state of holes is split by a crystal field or when the nc shape is asymmetric , the related perturbation can be written in the basis of the trion functions of eq . . the perturbation does not mix the the trion state with different signs of the spin projections . for the positive spin projections ( @xmath211 , and 1/2 ) the perturbation has the following form : @xmath212 a very similar matrix describes the perturbation created by nonzero @xmath213 on the states with negative angular momentum projections : @xmath214 , and -1/2 . that matrix can be obtained by replacing states @xmath215 in eq . by states with @xmath216 , where @xmath217 . the only difference is the sign of the matrix element taken between states @xmath218 and @xmath219 , which in the last case is @xmath220 . one can see from eq . , that nc asymmetry does not affect the three trion states @xmath221 , @xmath222 and @xmath223 . the energies of these states are e_5/2=e_2- 2_2 , e_3/2=e_2 + 3_2 , and their wave functions , @xmath224 for @xmath225 , and @xmath226 and @xmath227 for @xmath228 are the same as in the spherical case . the other three trion states , @xmath229 and @xmath230 can be found as solutions of the following third order equation : ( e_2-e-2_2)(e_2-e+3_2)(e_0-e)-^2(e_2-e+_2)=0 , [ trionlev ] in the case of small electron - hole and hole - hole exchange interactions @xmath231 , @xmath232 , the approximate solutions of eq . yield e_1/2^e_0^e_2 + _ exc/2 , e_1/2e_2+_2 . the wave functions of these trion states are @xmath233 and @xmath234 , respectively . in the limit of small exchange interaction , the order of the trion levels is independent of the relation between @xmath235 and @xmath193 . the fine structure of the positively charged trion is , ordered upward in energy , the ground twofold degenerate @xmath236 level , followed by the fourfold degenerate @xmath228 level , followed by the twofold degenerate @xmath230 and @xmath225 levels , and finally by the upper twofold degenerate @xmath237 level . the lowest and the uppermost trion states in the limit of large @xmath213 are formed from the lowest and uppermost two - hole states with a total zero momentum projection of two holes @xmath54 , while all intermediate states are formed from the medium fourfold degenerate two - hole level with @xmath238 . the medium level of the trion would be eightfold degenerate if one neglected the splitting caused by the electron - hole exchange interaction proportional to @xmath193 . the limit of small exchange interaction should describe quite well the cdse / cds ncs which have a core radius @xmath239 . in these ncs , the hole - hole exchange interaction , @xmath240mev and @xmath241 mev . the calculations of the electron - hole exchange interaction in fig . [ figexch ] show that @xmath193 is also much smaller than @xmath242 . let us consider now a negatively charged trion formed by the optically excited electron - hole pair and resident electron . the total energy of the negatively charged trion can be generally described as a sum of the two total energies of electrons interacting with the hole described in our case by eq . and the energy of the electron repulsion . in the case of the small conduction band offsets , the binding energy of the trion is mainly controlled by electron - electron and electron - hole coulomb interactions as is true for the negatively charge hydrogen atom . the resulting binding energy in such a case is significantly smaller than the binding energy of the exciton because the coulomb attraction between a second electron and the hole is almost exactly compensated by the coulomb repulsion between electrons . the studies of negatively charged hydrogen atoms ( see for example ref . ) demonstrate that the binding state of doubly charged atom exist only for a singlet state of two electrons occupying the two radial orbits of @xmath63 symmetry . this requirement decreases the coulomb repulsion energy between two electrons . that is why we select the two - electron wave functions of the negative trion @xmath243 as the product of the singlet spin wave function ( antysimmetrical ) and symmetrical radial function of two @xmath63-symmetry electrons in the following form : _ 2e(r_1,r_2)= ( u_1/2^c(e1)u_-1/2^c(e2)- u_-1/2^c(e1)u_1/2^c(e2 ) ) y_00(_e1)y_00(_e2)r_2e(r_1,r_2 ) , where @xmath244 is defined as r_2e(r_1,r_2)=a_2e[r_e^1(_1,_1;r_1/a)r_e^1(_2,_2;r_2/a)+r_e^1(_1,_1;r_2/a)r_e^1(_2,_2;r_1/a ) ] [ wf2e ] with @xmath245 defined in eq . and @xmath246 defined by the normalization condition @xmath247 where the repulsion energy between two electrons @xmath248 can be found as e_coul^2e = = the two - electron trial wave function defined in eq . is described by four fitting parameters , and it generally describes the electron motion on two radial orbits characterized by two different sets @xmath249 , @xmath250 and @xmath251 , @xmath252 . it is important to note that if @xmath253 and @xmath254 , the energy of two electrons in eq . is not reduced to the kinetic energy and repulsion of uncorrelated electrons occupying two different orbits . the total energy of electrons has a contribution from the interference of both orbits and depends on all four parameters . one can find the analytical expression of the expectation energy @xmath255 as a function of four parameters in the online sm . this expression developed within _ mathematica _ were used to find the binding energy of two electrons and a hole . the trion binding energy , which is the difference between the total energy of the trion and the binding energy of the exciton ( see fig . [ bindingenergy ] ) , is shown in fig . [ trionbindingenergy ] as a function of of the nc core radius and band offset . -0.1truecm -0.7truecm -0.1truecm one can see that for large negative values of @xmath128 , the cdse / cds ncs are well - defined type - i structures . the strong confinement allows the two electrons to occupy a ground state level with two opposite spins leading to a large trion binding energy ( see fig . [ figovlp ] ) . decrease of @xmath256 decreases the confinement , and the trion binding energy is mainly controlled by the electron - electron and the electron - hole coulomb interactions . the coulomb repulsion between two electrons forces them to occupy different orbits , which reduces the repulsion and leads to a small , but positive binding energy for the trion . the orbits are characterized by the two radial wave functions , @xmath257 and @xmath258 , the spatial extension of which is characterized by parameters @xmath259 and @xmath260 . the radius of these two orbits is shown in fig . [ trionbindingenergy]c and [ trionbindingenergy]d as a function of core radius and band offset . one can see that one of the orbits is mainly localized in the cdse core while the other explores the cds shell . the radius of the large orbit obviously increases with the decrease of @xmath256 for any core radius , as one can see in fig . [ trionbindingenergy]c . the cbo dependence shown in fig . [ trionbindingenergy]d is more complex , however . the radius of the external orbit is smaller in the nc with a large core radius at large cbos , but it becomes larger at small cbos . this unusual behavior is connected with the increased role that the hole coulomb attraction potential plays in electron localization in core / shell ncs with a small cbo . the optical selection rule and the relative transition probabilities of the excitons in cdse / cds core shell ncs are described by eqs . ( 25)(28 ) of ref . , where the square of the overlap integral , @xmath261 , between the electron and hole wave functions should be written in more general form @xmath262 where @xmath263 is the electron radial function described in eq . , with parameters @xmath133 and @xmath264 that maximized the exciton binding energy . in the cdse / cds core shell ncs , where the electron is not localized in the cdse core , @xmath265 is a strong function of the band offset of the conduction band and of the core radius . in figs . [ figovlp]a and [ figovlp]b we show the dependence of the exciton @xmath265 on the core radius and the band offset , respectively . -0.1truecm -0.7truecm -0.1truecm the experimentally observed increase of the the radiative decay time by a factor of two in the temperature interval from 0 to 150 k @xcite could be connected with a significant decrease of the conduction band offset between cdse and cds shell layers . the decrease of the absolute value of the negative band offset decreases @xmath265 , as one can see in fig . [ figovlp ] c , d and f. the radiative decay time of the optically active excitons is inversely proportional to @xmath265 and is directly proportional to the characteristic exciton decay time , as can be described by @xmath266 where @xmath267 is the refractive index of the media , @xmath268 is the speed of light , @xmath269 is the kane transition matrix element , @xmath270 is the light frequency , and @xmath271 is the depolarization factor , which takes into account the decrease of the magnitude of the light electric field when it penetrates into the nc . in cdse structures @xmath272 should be on the order of 1.7ns.@xcite this value was estimated using @xmath273 , @xmath274mev and @xmath275ev . the depolarization factor @xmath271 generally depends on the nc shape and structure . in giant cdse / cds ncs the depolarization factor can be estimated using @xmath276 ^ 2 $ ] for spherical cds ncs , where @xmath277 is the high frequency dielectric constant of cds and @xmath278 is the dielectric constant of the media surrounding the nc . this results in @xmath279 . the radiative decay times of the bright band - edge excitons has a complicated dependence on the exciton exchange energy @xmath175 and the hole level splitting @xmath213.@xcite the expression for the decay time is significantly simplified when @xmath280 . in this limit the radiative decay time , @xmath281 , of the first optically active exciton can be written as = k_ex2_0 [ exdecay ] this case is realized in giant cdse / cds ncs , due to a small exchange energy . from fig.[figovlp ] one can see that the overlap integral squared decreases by a factor of 23 when cbo decreases from 50 mev to 300 mev . this decrease of @xmath265 is consistent with observed changes in the radiative decay time . one can see also from fig.[figovlp]a that an increase of the core radius leads to a strong localization of an electron in the core and increases @xmath265 significantly . this in turn should shorten the radiative decay time . the fine structure of the band - edge positive charge trions in ncs made of semiconductors with four - fold degenerate or quasi - degenerate valence bands ( like cdse , cds , inas , cdte and etc . ) generally consists of four doubly degenerate states @xmath229 , @xmath225 and @xmath230 and one four - fold degenerated state @xmath228 , whose energies we described above . all of these states are optically active and can decay radiatively with different decay times . this in principle could lead to a very complex dependence of the decay time on the temperature as a result of the thermal population of the different levels within the trion fine structure . the resonant optical excitations of the positively charged trion in ncs with an extra hole and its radiative decay are determined by the probabilities of the optical transitions between one of a hole state , @xmath3 , with @xmath282 and the one of the trion states , @xmath283 [ @xmath284 ; @xmath285 ; @xmath286 ; @xmath287 , and @xmath288 . these probabilities are proportional to the following sum of the matrix element squared : t(m , tr)&= & _ c i , j=1,2 ; i j & = & 2|_m^h(r_h1 ) ( r_e - r_h2 ) | e | _ g , g^tr ( r_e , r_h1 , r_h2 ) |^2 . [ ttr ] the sum takes into account the probability of an electron recombination with two holes ( @xmath289 ) . the sum can be replaced by a factor of two because the matrix elements of the transitions with different hole states are identical , due the symmetrization of the two - hole wave function . here @xmath290 is the polarization of the emitted or absorbed light , and the momentum operator @xmath291 acts only on the valence band bloch functions . the calculation of @xmath292 with the wave functions is straightforward but cumbersome , because the hexagonal axes of a nc ensemble are randomly oriented relative to the light propagation of emission directions . first , let us consider transition probabilities @xmath292 s responsible for the radiative decay of the ground and first excited trion state . we will be considering here only the effect of linearly polarized light , which is sufficient for the description of the radiative decay . for linearly polarized light , @xmath293 in eq . can be written as = e_z_z+[e_-_++e_+_- ] [ pol ] where @xmath6 is the direction of the hexagonal axis of the nc , @xmath294 , @xmath295 , and @xmath296 and @xmath297 are the components of the polarization vector and the momentum operator , respectively , that are perpendicular to the nc hexagonal axis . in studied cdse / cds core / shell ncs , the crystal field and shape asymmetry parameter @xmath213 is much larger than the trion exchange parameter @xmath172 . as a result the trion ground state is @xmath298 . let us calculate the transition probabilities @xmath299 and @xmath300 between the trion ground state and the hole ground state @xmath301 stimulated by the linear polarized light . substituting eq . into eq . and using the trion and hole wave - functions , after some straightforward but cumbersome calculations gives the following : @xmath302 where @xmath303 is the angle between the vector polarization of light @xmath304 and the hexagonal axis of the nc , and where the trion overlap integral squared @xmath305 is determined now by the electron wave function @xmath306 of the trion , which is calculated for the coulomb potential created by two holes . this radial function is described by eq . , with parameters @xmath133 and @xmath264 that maximize the trion binding energy . the dependence of the overlap integral squared calculated for the positively charged trion is shown as functions of the cdse core radius and cbo in figs . 5 c and d. equation describes the probability of the trion ground state radiative decay into the ground hole state . there is nothing , however , that prevents the trion decay into the light hole excited states with @xmath307 . the photon emitted during such decay will be smaller ( by an energy of about @xmath213 ) than the photon emitted during the ground - to - ground transition . this energy will be absorbed by the hole . the probability of observing such a red `` shake up '' line is determined by the four independent transition probabilities : t(-1/2,-1/2 ^ -;)&=&t(1/2,1/2 ^ - ; ) = ( b_2 ^ --b_0 ^ -)^2 ^2 , + t(1/2,-1/2 ^ -;)&= & t(-1/2,1/2 ^ - ; ) = ( b_2 ^ --b_0 ^ -)^2 ^2 , which are much smaller than the probability of the observation of the main line , because @xmath308 for large @xmath213 . summing up the probabilities of the trion radiative decay into the ground and excited hole states over all light polarizations , we obtain the radiative recombination rate of the trion ground state as @xmath309 one can show that the uppermost trion excited state @xmath310 has the same radiative decay rate as the ground one ( @xmath311 ) and they are different from the decay time of the first optically active exciton state only by the overlap integrals ( see eq . ) . comparison of the overlap integral squared for excitons and positively charged trions in fig . [ figovlp ] shows that in ncs with small conduction band offsets they became much larger for the trions due to stronger attraction of electrons to the cdse core . henceforth in this paper we will use notations for the decay times , which are related to the notation of corresponding levels of the positively charged trion : @xmath312 , @xmath313 and @xmath314 and @xmath315 . we find the probability of the transitions from the excited trion states @xmath316 and @xmath317 to the hole @xmath99 state to be t(3/2,(5/2,5/2 ) ; ) = ^2 , t(3/2,(5/2,3/2 ) ; ) = ^2 . [ eq:50 ] the transition to the hole ground state has an energy of about @xmath213 larger then the main transition from the ground state . the total transition probability from the trion @xmath318 states to the hole ground @xmath319 state is described by the sum of the two probabilities : t(1/2,(5/2,3/2);)=t(-1/2,(5/2,-3/2 ) ; ) ) = ^2 . [ eq:51 ] in the same limit of large @xmath213 , transitions from the trion excited state to the hole excited state have nearly the same energy as the main transition from the ground to ground states . when we average all possible crystal orientation and sum up eqs . and , we can find the radiative recombination rate of the trion excited state @xmath228 : @xmath320 similar calculations give us the radiative rates for @xmath230 and @xmath225 excited trion states : @xmath321 the situation is significantly simplified in studied here cdse / cds core / shell ncs . due to small value of @xmath322 , the second trion level is eightfold degenerate with an average decay rate of = 14(++)= k_tr^+2_0 , which coincides with the decay rate of the uppermost and lowest trion states @xmath323 ( see eq . ) . as a result , the positive trion radiative decay time in cdse / cds core / shell ncs does not depend on thermo - population of the fine level structure and is temperature independent . the radiative decay time of the negatively charged exciton leaves a resident electron in ncs . in cdse / cds core / shell ncs , the wave function of the resident electron , @xmath324 , is very different from the electron wave functions of the negatively charged trion , which is mainly controlled by the coulomb interactions . the different size of the electron and hole wave functions significantly decreases the overlap integral , which controls the rate of trion radiative decay . the radiative decay and the resonant optical excitation of the negatively charged trion are determined by the probabilities of the optical transitions between the resident `` free '' electron state , with spin projection @xmath325 and radial wave function @xmath324 , and one of the trion states characterized by the hole momentum projection @xmath326 . these probabilities are proportional to t(s_z , m)= 2|^e_s_z(r_1 ) ( r_1 - r_e2 ) | e | _ m^h(r_h ) _ 2e(r_e1 , r_e2 ) |^2 , [ tr ] where the factor 2 is due to the sum over electron coordinates . the ground negative trion state is formed by the hole with @xmath327 . the probability from the ground state is @xmath328 here , k_tr^-=|r_1 ^ 2dr_1 r_2 ^ 2 dr_2 r_e^0(r_1)r_2e(r_1,r_2)r_0(r_2 ) |^2 , [ eq:61 ] where @xmath244 is the symmetrized two - electron wave function in eq.([wf2e ] ) , @xmath329 is the wave functions of a single hole in eq.([rfunction ] ) , and @xmath330 is the wave function of a single resident electron in eq.([freewf ] ) . figures 5e and 5f show the dependence of the overlap integral squared , @xmath331 , for the negatively charged trion on the cdse core radius , @xmath14 , and the cbo , @xmath256 . one can see from these figures that @xmath331 always increases with @xmath14 and @xmath256 . at the same time the figures show that for each @xmath14 there is critical @xmath256 and vise versa where @xmath331 vanishes . these critical points are connected with the delocalization of the resident electron into the cds shell . as we show above , the delocalization condition is described as @xmath332 . at this condition the spread of the electron wave function into the cds shell vanishes the overlap integral . taking a sum over all light polarizations in eq . , we obtain the radiative decay rate from the negative trion ground state as = . as in the case of the positively charged trion , the radiative decay time of the negatively charged trion is different from the radiative decay time of the first optically active exciton only by the overlap integral . for the negative trion excited states with @xmath307 , we have following transition probabilities : @xmath333 taking a sum of the transition probabilities over all states and light polarizations , we obtain the radiative decay rate of the negative trion with @xmath307 : = . the radiative decay time of the trion excited state , @xmath334 , is the same as one for the ground state : @xmath335 . this paper has developed a theoretical background for qualitative and quantitative analyses of multiple experimental measurements conducted in cds / cds core / thick shell ncs and cdse / cds dots - in - rods nanostructures ( ns ) . the major unusual properties of these ns are connected with the relatively small , and temperature and strain dependent conduction band offset , which provides only weak confinement of electrons in the cdse core , while the large valence band offset in these ns leads to the strong confinement of holes . as a result , the coulomb potential created by strongly confined holes plays an important role in electron confinement . the optical properties of such ns should be considered to be in the _ intermediate _ confinement regime.@xcite the calculation procedure consists of several steps : ( i ) finding the energy spectra and wave function of strongly confined holes ; ( ii ) calculation of the adiabatic coulomb potential creating by the hole charge distribution ; and , finally , ( iii ) calculation the energy spectra of the electron moving into the total potential created by the conduction band offset and by the coulomb potential . in this paper , we realized this program assuming that the thickness of cds shell is much larger than the radius of electron localization around the cdse core . the limit is satisfied in `` giant '' cdse / cds core / shell ncs grown by the los alamos @xcite and deburter@xcite groups . the theory could be extended , however , to quantitative consideration of cdse / cds dots - in - rods ns and/or to take into account the finite thickness of the cds shell . some effects of the finite cds shell can be taken into account quantitatively on the basis of the current calculations if the radius of electron localization around the cdse core , @xmath336 , is smaller than the cds layer thickness . for example , the negative trion ionization energy should be increased on the energy of the first confined level in cds ncs with the same shape and size as original cdse / cds core / shell ncs . the radiative decay of the negative charged trion also does not vanish in nc with finite shell thickness when a delocalization condition is reached . the time can be calculated by replacing @xmath324 in eq . with the wave function of the the first confined level in cds ncs . in the paper we have also derived general expressions for the radiative decay time of the band - edge trions in various ncs . the calculations show that these times are proportional to @xmath337 . the major difference in these times is connected with the square of the overlap integral between electron and hole wave functions in positively charged @xmath338 and negatively charged @xmath331 trions . in cdse / cds core / thick shell ncs where the electron exchange energy becomes smaller than the temperature , the radiative decay time of excitons is two times longer than @xmath339 given by eq . due to the equal population of the dark and bright exciton states . a detailed comparison of our calculations with experimental data on the optical properties of the cdse / cds core / shell ncs requires a knowledge of the temperature dependence of the conduction band offset . this temperature dependence suggested first in ref . is not universal , because it has a strain contribution @xcite and should depend on the sample preparation technique . nevertheless , the decrease of the radiative decay time by a factor of two observed in refs . and is consistent with an increase of the overlap integral squared with the cbo increased from 100 to 300 mev . the small splitting of the dark / bright exciton states measured in the giant cdse / cds ncs @xcite is also in qualitative agreement with our calculations . in summary , we have developed a theory of the optical properties of cdse / cds core / thick shell ncs . the calculations takes into account the complex structure of the cdse valence band and inter - particle coulomb and exchange interaction . the theory describes the fine structures and radiative decay time of excitons and positively and negatively charged trions . the results of our calculations are in qualitative agreement with experimental data available for these ncs . we believe that calculated energy spectra of negatively and positively - charged trions will explain suppression of nonradiative auger processes observed in these structures . the authors thank j. feldman for the critical reading of the manuscript . a.s . acknowledges support of the center for advanced solar photophysics ( casp ) an energy frontier research center founded by obes , os , u.s . is grateful for the financial support received from the swiss national science foundation . l. e. acknowledges support of the office of naval research and alexander - von - humboldt foundation . from the normalization condition for an electron bound to the singly or doubly charged core we obtain the following analytical expression for the normalization constant squared : @xmath340 ^ 2 \over \alpha^3 \left[q\left ( \mu , \alpha , \zeta\right ) + \sqrt{2 \pi } \exp\left(2/\alpha^2\right ) \mathrm{erf}\left(\sqrt{2}/\alpha \right ) p\left ( \mu , \alpha , \zeta\right)\right ] } \end{aligned}\ ] ] 55 b. mahler , p. spinicelli , s. buil , x. qulin , j .- p . hermier , and b. dubertret , nature materials * 7 * , 659 ( 2008 ) . y. chen , j. vela , h. htoon , j. l. casson , d. j. werder , d. a. bussian , v. i. klimov and j. a. hollingsworth , j. am . soc . * 130 * , 5026 ( 2008 ) . p. spinicelli , s. buil , x. qulin , b. mahler , b. dubertret , and j .- hermier , phys . . lett . * 102 * , 136801 ( 2009 ) . c. galland , y. ghosh , a. steinbrck , m. sykora , j. a. hollingsworth , v. i. klimov , and h. htoon , nature * 479 * 203 ( 2011 ) . h. htoon , a. v. malko , d. bussian , j. vela , y. chen , j. a. hollingsworth , and v. i. klimov , nano letters * 10 * , 2401 ( 2010 ) . y .- s . park , a. v. malko , j. vela , y. chen , y. ghosh , f. garca - santamara , j. a. hollingsworth , v. i. klimov , and h. htoon , phys . . lett . * 106 * , 187401 ( 2011 ) . f. garca - santamara , y. chen , j. vela , r. d. schaller , j. a. hollingsworth , and v. i. klimov , nano letters * 9 * , 3482 ( 2009 ) . l. efros , nature materials * 7 * , 612 ( 2008 ) . c. galland , y. ghosh , a. steinbrck , j. a. hollingsworth , h. htoon , and v. i. klimov , nature comm . * 3 * , 908 ( 2012 ) . f. garca - santamara , s. brovelli , r. viswanatha , j. a. hollingsworth , h. htoon , s. a. crooker , and v. i. klimov , nano letters * 11 * , 687 ( 2011 ) . x. y. wang , x. f. ren , k. kahen , m. a. hahn , m. rajeswaran , s. maccagnano - zacher , j. silcox , g. e. cragg , al . l. efros , and t. d. krauss , _ nature _ * 459 * , 686 ( 2009 ) . g. e. cragg and al . l. efros , nano lett . * 10 * , 3131 ( 2010 ) . v. dzhagan , b. dubertret , e. cassette , c. javaux , r. d. rodriguez , and d. r.t . zahn , to be published . g. rain , t. stferle , i. moreels , r. gomes , j. s. kamal , z. hens , and r. f. mahrt , acs nano * 5 * , 4031 ( 2011 ) . s. brovelli , r. d. schaller , s. a. crooker , f. garca - santamara , y. chen , r. viswanatha , j. a. hollingsworth , h. htoon , and v.i . klimov , nature comm . * 2 * , 280 ( 2011 ) . the landolt brnstein database , springer . i. ekimov , f. hache , m. c. schanne - klein , d. ricard , c. flytzanis , i. a. kudryavtsev , t. v. yazeva , a. v. rodina , and al . l. efros , j. opt . soc . am . b * 10 * , 100 ( 1993 ) b. l. gelmont and m. i. dyakonov , sov . phys . semiconduct . * 5 * , 2191 ( 1973 ) . a. r. edmonds , _ angular momentum in quantum mechanics _ princeton university press , princenton , new jersey , 1957 . g. l. bir and g. e. pikus , _ symmetry and strain - induced effects in semiconductors _ ( wiley , new york 1975 ) . l. efros , phys . rev . b 46 , 7448 ( 1992 ) . l. efros , m. rosen , m. kuno , m. nirmal , d. j. norris , and m. bawendi , phys . rev . b * 54 * , 4843 ( 1996 ) . l. efros and a. v. rodina , phys . b * 47 * , 10005 ( 1993 ) . a.v . rodina and al . l. efros , phys . b * 82 * , 125324 ( 2010 ) . l. efros and a. v. rodina , solid state commun . * 72 * , 645 ( 1989 ) . , eds . m.abramowitz and i. a. stegun , national bureau of standards , 1998 . l. d. landau and e. m. lifshitz , quantum mechanics ( non - relativistic theory ) pergamon press , oxford , 1977 . l. efros , _ `` fine structure and polarization properties of the band edge excitons in semiconductor nanocrystals , '' _ ch . 3 in the book _ `` semiconductor and metal nanocrystals : synthesis , electronic and optical properties , '' _ ed . v. klimov , pergamon press ( 2003 ) . h. a. bethe and e. e. salpeter , _ quantum mechanics of one- and two- electron atoms _ , springer - verlag , berlin - gttingen - heidelberg , ( 1957 ) . c. javaux , b. mahler , b. dubertret , a. shabaev , a. v. rodina , al . l. efros , d. r. yakovlev , f. liu , m. bayer , g. camps , l. biadala , s. buil , x. qulin , and j .- hermier , to be published . l. efros and a. l. efros , sov . . semicond . * 16 * , 772 ( 1982 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we present a theoretical description of excitons and positively and negatively charged trions in giant cdse / cds core - shell nanocrystals ( ncs ) . the developed theory provides the parameters describing the fine structure of excitons in cdse / cds core / thick shell ncs as a function of the cdse / cds conduction band offset and the cdse core radius . we have also developed a general theory describing the fine structure of positively charged trions created in semiconductor ncs with a degenerate valence band . the calculations take into account the complex structure of the cdse valence band and inter - particle coulomb and exchange interaction . presented in this paper are the cdse core size and cdse / cds conduction band offset dependences ( i ) of the positively charged trion fine structure , ( ii ) of the binding energy of the negatively charged trion , and ( iii ) of the radiative decay time for excitons and trions . the results of theoretical calculations are in qualitative agreement with available experimental data . = by 60 = 255=255 by -60 by 255"
] | 10,800 | 10,800 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: extremely low mass ( elm ) wds , degenerate objects with @xmath5 ( cm s@xmath6 ) surface gravity or @xmath70.3 @xmath4 mass , are the product of common envelope binary evolution ( e.g. * ? ? ? elm wds are thus the signposts of the type of binaries that are strong gravitational wave sources and possible supernovae progenitors . the goal of the elm survey is to discover and characterize the population of elm wds in the milky way . previous elm survey papers have reported the discovery of 40 wds spanning 0.16 @xmath4 to 0.49 @xmath4 found in the hypervelocity star ( hvs ) survey , the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) , and in our own targeted survey @xcite . we refer to this full sample of wds as the elm survey sample , but reserve the term `` elm wd '' for those objects with @xmath5 . all of our wds are found in short - period , detached binaries , 60% of which have merger times @xmath210 gyr . three notable systems are detached binaries with @xmath240 min orbital periods @xcite . the eclipsing system j0651 + 2844 is the second - strongest gravitational wave source in the mhz range @xcite . we measured its period change in one year with optical eclipse timing @xcite . other results from the elm survey include the first tidally distorted wds @xcite and the first pulsating helium - core wds @xcite . here we present the discovery of 17 new wd binaries identified from spectra previously obtained for the hvs survey of @xcite . @xcite analyzed the visually - identified wds in the original dataset and discovered one elm wd binary @xcite . this approach failed to identify the lowest surface gravity wds . we now fit stellar atmosphere models to the entire collection of spectra not previously identified as wds , and acquire follow - up spectroscopy of new elm wd candidates . the result of this effort is that we find low surface gravity objects that might not be considered wds if not for their observed orbital motion . we chose to call objects with @xmath8 `` elm wds '' because these objects occupy a unique region of surface gravity / effective temperature space that overlaps the terminal wd cooling branch for elm wds ( see figure [ fig : teff ] ) . this region is well separated from both hydrogen - burning main sequence tracks and helium - burning horizontal branch tracks . our objects are systematically @xmath910,000 k too cool , given their surface gravities , to be helium burning sdb stars . @xcite refer to a similar type of object as a `` proto - wd . '' the lowest gravity objects in our sample may indeed have hydrogen shell burning and thus are , properly speaking , proto - wds , but here we address our sample of low gravity objects as elm wds . a variety of observations demonstrate that degenerate helium - core wds exist at our observed temperatures and surface gravities . elm wd companions to milli - second pulsars are directly observed ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) at the temperatures and gravities targeted by the elm survey . the measured radius of the @xmath10 object in j0651 + 2844 , a @xmath11 @xmath12 star , demonstrates it is a degenerate wd @xcite . @xcite account for the unusually long pulsation periods of the elm wd pulsators with low mass wd models . hence , calling our low surface gravity objects elm wds is appropriate . interestingly , we find elm wds in binaries with @xmath130.9 @xmath4 companions and rapid merger times . when these detached binaries begin mass transfer , @xcite show that the extreme mass ratios will lead to stable mass transfer . for the case of massive wd accretors , theorists predict large helium flashes that may ignite thermonuclear transients dubbed `` .ia '' supernovae @xcite or may detonate the surface helium - layer and the massive wd @xcite and produce an underluminous supernova . however , the final outcome of such mergers is uncertain and they may not trigger supernovae explosions @xcite . if the companions are instead neutron stars , this would be the first time a milli - second pulsar is identified through its low - mass wd companion . such systems allow measurement of the binary mass ratio and the neutron star mass through a combination of the pulsar orbit obtained from radio timing and the wd orbit obtained from optical radial velocity observations . the importance of identifying the elm wds in the hvs survey is that the hvs survey is a well - defined and a nearly 100% complete spectroscopic survey . with a complete sample of elm wds we can measure the space density , period distribution , and merger rate of elm wds , and link elm wd merger products to populations of am cvn stars , r crb stars , and possibly underluminous supernovae . in a stellar evolution context , our elm wd survey complements studies of wd binaries with main sequence companions ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) and with sdb star companions ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? sdb stars are @xmath14@xmath15 k helium - burning precursors to wds @xcite . our elm wds , on the other hand , have @xmath14@xmath16 k. we organize this paper as follows . in section 2 we discuss our observations and data analysis . in section 3 we present the orbital solutions for 17 new elm wd binaries . in section 4 we discuss the properties of the elm wd sample . we conclude in section 5 . the hvs survey is a targeted spectroscopic survey of @xmath17 stars with the colors of @xmath183 @xmath4 main sequence stars , stars which should not exist at faint magnitudes in the halo unless they were ejected there . the target selection is detailed in @xcite and spans @xmath19 , @xmath20 . this color selection fortuitously targets wds in the approximate range @xmath21 @xmath14 @xmath16 k and @xmath22 . we separate elm wds from the other stars in the hvs survey using stellar atmosphere model fits to the single - epoch spectra . our initial set of fits uses an upgraded version of the ferre code described by @xcite and synthetic da wd pure hydrogen spectra kindly provided by d. koester . the grid of wd model atmospheres covers effective temperatures from 6000 k to 30,000 k in steps of 500 k to 2000 k , and surface gravities from @xmath23=5.0 to 9.0 in steps of 0.25 dex . the model atmospheres are calculated assuming local thermodynamic equilibrium and include both convective and radiative transport @xcite . we fit 2,000 spectra , mostly from the original hvs survey @xcite but also some newly acquired data @xcite . these 2,000 spectra were not previously analyzed for the elm survey because the spectra were not previously identified as wds . we fit both flux - calibrated spectra ( for improved @xmath14 constraints ) as well as continuum - corrected balmer line profiles ( insensitive to reddening and flux calibration errors ) . for the continuum - corrected balmer line profiles , we normalize the spectra by fitting a low - order polynomial to the regions between the balmer lines . we adopt the parameters from the flux - calibrated spectra , except in cases where the spectra were obtained in non - photometric conditions . the uncertainties in our single - epoch measurements are typically @xmath24500 k in @xmath14 and @xmath25 dex in @xmath23 . from these fits we identify 57 low mass wd candidates . we obtain follow - up spectra for each of the candidate low mass wds to improve stellar atmosphere parameters and to search for velocity variability . observations were obtained over the course of seven observing runs at the 6.5 m mmt telescope between march 2011 and february 2013 . we used the blue channel spectrograph @xcite with the 832 line mm@xmath26 grating , which provides a wavelength coverage 3650 to 4500 and a spectral resolution of 1.0 . all observations were paired with a comparison lamp exposure , and were flux - calibrated using blue spectrophotometric standards @xcite . the extracted spectra typically have a signal - to - noise ( s / n ) of 7 per pixel in the continuum and a 14 km s@xmath26 radial velocity error . we obtained additional spectroscopy for @xmath27 mag elm wd candidates in queue scheduled time at the 1.5 m flwo telescope . we used the fast spectrograph @xcite with the 600 line mm@xmath26 grating and a 1.5 slit , providing wavelength coverage 3500 to 5500 and a spectral resolution of 1.7 . all observations were paired with a comparison lamp exposure , and were flux - calibrated using blue spectrophotometric standards . the extracted spectra typically have a s / n of 10 per pixel in the continuum and a 18 km s@xmath26 radial velocity error . our follow - up observations provide improved stellar atmosphere constraints , from which we determine that 24 ( 42% ) of the candidates are probable elm wds with @xmath8 ( see figure [ fig : teff ] ) . the remaining candidates have either @xmath28 and are normal da wds , or @xmath29 and are presumably halo blue horizontal branch or blue straggler stars . figure [ fig : teff ] plots the distribution of @xmath14 vs. @xmath23 for all of the wds with @xmath30 . previously published elm survey stars are marked with red circles . the observed wds overlap tracks based on @xcite models for he - core wds with hydrogen shell burning ( ( green lines ) * ? ? ? * ) , but do not overlap main sequence nor horizontal branch evolutionary tracks . for reference , we also plot @xcite solar metallicity main sequence tracks for 2 , 3 , and 6 @xmath4 stars ( cyan lines ) . a helium - burning horizontal branch star can have a surface gravity similar to a degenerate he wd ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , but only at a systematically higher effective temperature than that targeted by the elm survey . this is illustrated by @xcite [ fe / h]=-1.48 horizontal branch tracks for 0.488 , 0.495 , and 0.500 @xmath4 stars ( magenta lines ) , as well as the homogenous helium - burning main sequence from @xcite . the zero - age main sequence and helium - burning horizontal branch isochrones ( thick lines ) mark the limits . seventeen of the wds show significant velocity variability , including twelve of the newly identified elm wds . the other elm wds have insufficient coverage for detecting ( or ruling out ) velocity variability . we focus the remainder of this paper on the 17 well - constrained systems . our sample of 17 well - constrained systems contains four @xmath23 @xmath31 objects , objects at the edge of our stellar atmosphere grid that might not be considered degenerate wds if not for their observed orbital motion . we also fit these stars to grids of @xcite models spanning @xmath32 } \le 0.5 $ ] , @xmath33 ( see * ? ? ? * ) but found very poor solutions . this motivated us to perform a new set of stellar atmosphere fits using @xcite hydrogen model atmospheres . the gianninas models employ improved stark broadening profiles @xcite , and the ml2/@xmath34 = 0.8 prescription of the mixing - length theory for models where convective energy transport is important @xcite . we calculate atmosphere models for low surface gravities , and use a grid that covers @xmath14 from 4000 k to 30,000 k in steps ranging from 250 to 5000 k and @xmath23 from 5.0 to 8.0 in steps of 0.25 dex . ccccccccc j0056@xmath350611 & 0:56:48.232 & -6:11:41.62 & @xmath36 & @xmath37 & 0.17 & @xmath38 & 8.0 & 0.69 + j0751@xmath350141 & 7:51:41.179 & -1:41:20.90 & @xmath39 & @xmath40 & 0.17 & @xmath41 & 8.0 & 0.75 + j0755@xmath424800 & 7:55:19.483 & 48:00:34.07 & @xmath43 & @xmath44 & 0.42 & @xmath45 & 9.7 & 0.18 + j0802@xmath350955 & 8:02:50.134 & -9:55:49.84 & @xmath46 & @xmath47 & 0.20 & @xmath48 & 8.2 & 1.19 + j0811@xmath420225 & 8:11:33.560 & 2:25:56.76 & @xmath49 & @xmath50 & 0.17 & @xmath51 & 8.0 & 1.30 + j0815@xmath422309 & 8:15:44.242 & 23:09:04.92 & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & 0.17 & @xmath54 & 6.7 & 1.53 + j0840@xmath421527 & 8:40:37.574 & 15:27:04.53 & @xmath55 & @xmath56 & 0.17 & @xmath57 & 8.0 & 1.69 + j1046@xmath350153 & 10:46:07.875 & -1:53:58.48 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 & 0.37 & @xmath60 & 10.2 & 0.36 + j1104@xmath420918 & 11:04:36.739 & 9:18:22.74 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & 0.46 & @xmath63 & 10.3 & 0.18 + j1141@xmath423850 & 11:41:55.560 & 38:50:03.02 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & 0.17 & @xmath66 & 8.0 & 1.56 + j1151@xmath425858 & 11:51:38.381 & 58:58:53.22 & @xmath67 & @xmath68 & 0.17 & @xmath69 & 8.0 & 2.57 + j1157@xmath420546 & 11:57:34.455 & 5:46:45.58 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 & 0.17 & @xmath72 & 8.0 & 2.29 + j1238@xmath421946 & 12:38:00.096 & 19:46:31.45 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & 0.17 & @xmath75 & 8.0 & 0.68 + j1538@xmath420252 & 15:38:44.220 & 2:52:09.49 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & 0.17 & @xmath78 & 8.0 & 1.28 + j1557@xmath422823 & 15:57:08.483 & 28:23:36.02 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 & 0.49 & @xmath81 & 11.2 & 0.18 + j2132@xmath420754 & 21:32:28.360 & 7:54:28.24 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & 0.17 & @xmath84 & 8.0 & 0.96 + j2338@xmath352052 & 23:38:21.505 & -20:52:22.76 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 & 0.27 & @xmath87 & 9.0 & 1.29 + lccrrcccc j0056@xmath350611 & 33 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath920.45 & @xmath930.374 & @xmath930.12 + j0751@xmath350141 & 31 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath920.94 & @xmath930.182 & @xmath930.37 + j0755@xmath424800 & 26 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath920.90 & @xmath930.468 & @xmath9328 + j0802@xmath350955 & 20 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath920.57 & @xmath930.348 & @xmath9379 + j0811@xmath420225 & 24 & @xmath106 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath921.20 & @xmath930.142 & @xmath93160 + j0815@xmath422309 & 21 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath920.47 & @xmath930.361 & @xmath93620 + j0840@xmath421527 & 19 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 & @xmath920.15 & @xmath930.879 & @xmath93230 + j1046@xmath350153 & 16 & @xmath118 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 & @xmath121 & @xmath920.19 & @xmath930.509 & @xmath9348 + j1104@xmath420918 & 25 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 & @xmath125 & @xmath920.55 & @xmath930.831 & @xmath9339 + j1141@xmath423850 & 17 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 & @xmath920.76 & @xmath930.225 & @xmath9310 + j1151@xmath425858 & 17 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 & @xmath920.61 & @xmath930.277 & @xmath93150 + j1157@xmath420546 & 9 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath137 & @xmath920.44 & @xmath930.382 & @xmath93120 + j1238@xmath421946 & 21 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 & @xmath141 & @xmath920.64 & @xmath930.266 & @xmath937.5 + j1538@xmath420252 & 16 & @xmath142 & @xmath143 & @xmath144 & @xmath145 & @xmath920.76 & @xmath930.222 & @xmath9335 + j1557@xmath422823 & 24 & @xmath146 & @xmath147 & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath920.43 & @xmath930.886 & @xmath9320 + j2132@xmath420754 & 35 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath920.95 & @xmath930.179 & @xmath937.7 + j2338@xmath352052 & 25 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 & @xmath920.15 & @xmath930.554 & @xmath930.95 + our stellar atmosphere fits use the so - called spectroscopic technique described in @xcite . one difference between our work and @xcite is that we fit higher - order balmer lines , up to and including h12 , observed in the low surface gravity elm wds . the higher - order balmer lines are sensitive to @xmath23 and improve our surface gravity measurement . for the handful of wds in our sample with @xmath28 , we only fit balmer lines up to and including h10 since the higher order balmer lines are not observed at higher surface gravity . the lowest gravity wds in our sample show ca and mg lines in their spectra . for reference , the diffusion timescale for ca in a @xmath158 10,000 k , 0.2 @xmath4 h - rich wd is @xmath9@xmath159 yr @xcite . extreme horizontal branch stars , which can have surface gravities comparable to the lowest gravity wds , have longer @xmath9@xmath160 yr diffusion timescales @xcite . these diffusion timescales are shorter than the wd evolutionary timescale , suggesting there may be on - going accretion in these ultra - compact binary systems . near- and mid - infrared observations are needed constrain the possibility of accretion . we defer a detailed analysis of the metal abundances in elm wds to a future paper . for our present analysis we exclude the wavelength ranges where the metal lines are present in our fits . our error estimates combine the internal error of the model fits , obtained from the covariance matrix of the fitting algorithm , and the external error , obtained from multiple observations of the same object . uncertainties are typically 1.2% in @xmath14 and 0.038 dex in @xmath23 ( see * ? ? ? * for details ) . a measure of the systematic uncertainty inherent in the stellar atmosphere models and fitting routines comes from @xcite , who find a systematic uncertainty of @xmath161 dex in @xmath23 . this is corroborated by the difference we observe between the different fitting methods discussed in section 2.1 and here : the mean difference and the dispersion in @xmath14is @xmath162 and in @xmath23is @xmath163 dex . figure [ fig : teff ] plots the properties of the 17 wds with their internal errorbars . we use @xcite evolutionary tracks to estimate wd mass and luminosity . for purpose of discussion , we assume @xmath164 wds have mass 0.17 @xmath4 and absolute magnitude @xmath165 ( see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? we summarize the observed and derived stellar parameters of the 17 new binaries in table [ tab : param ] . position and de - reddened @xmath166-band magnitude come from sdss @xcite and @xmath167 is our heliocentric distance estimate . we calculate orbital elements and merger times in the same way as previous elm survey papers , and so we refer the reader to those papers for the details of our analysis . in brief , we measure absolute radial velocities using the cross - correlation package rvsao @xcite and a high - s / n template . we use the entire spectrum in the cross - correlation . we then use the summed spectra ( figure [ fig : spec ] ) as cross - correlation templates to maximize our velocity precision for each individual object . we calculate orbital elements by minimizing @xmath168 for a circular orbit using the code of @xcite . figure [ fig : pdm ] shows the periodograms for the 17 binaries , and figure [ fig : vel ] plots the radial velocities phased to the best - fit orbital periods . we use the binary mass function to estimate the unseen companion mass ; an edge - on orbit with inclination @xmath169 yields the minimum companion mass @xmath170 and the maximum gravitational wave merger time . table [ tab : orbit ] summarizes the binary orbital parameters . columns include orbital period ( @xmath171 ) , radial velocity semi - amplitude ( @xmath172 ) , systemic velocity ( @xmath173 ) , time of spectroscopic conjunction ( the time when the object is closest to us ) , minimum secondary mass ( @xmath170 ) assuming @xmath169 , the maximum mass ratio ( @xmath174 ) , and the maximum gravitational wave merger time @xmath175 . the systemic velocities in table [ tab : orbit ] are not corrected for the wds gravitational redshifts , which should be subtracted from the observed velocities to find the true systemic velocities . this correction is a few km s@xmath26 for a 0.17 @xmath4 helium wd , comparable to the systemic velocity uncertainty . the orbital solutions constrain the nature of the elm wd binaries . here we discuss the systems with short merger times , massive companions , or that may be underluminous supernovae progenitors . the elm wd j0056@xmath350611 has a well - constrained orbital period of @xmath176 hr and a semi - amplitude of @xmath177 km s@xmath26 . we can calculate its likely companion mass if we assume a distribution for the unknown orbital inclination . although radial velocity detections are biased towards edge - on systems ( see section 4 ) , we will assume that we are observing a random inclination for purpose of discussion . the mean inclination angle for a random sample , @xmath178 , is then an estimate of the most likely companion mass . for j0056@xmath350611 , the most likely companion is a 0.61 @xmath4 wd at an orbital separation of 0.5 @xmath12 . this orbital separation rules out the possibility of a main sequence companion . there is no evidence for a 0.61 @xmath4 wd in the spectrum of j0056@xmath350611 , but we would not expect there to be . if the two wds in this binary formed at the same time , we would expect the 0.61 @xmath4 wd to be 15 - 100 times less luminous than the 0.17 @xmath4 wd for cooling ages of 100 myr - 1 gyr @xcite . a more plausible evolutionary scenario for an elm wd binary like j0056@xmath350611 is two consecutive phases of common - envelope evolution in which the elm wd is created last , giving the more massive wd a longer time to cool and fade ( e.g. * ? * ) . for the most probable companion mass of 0.61 @xmath4 , j0056@xmath350611 will begin mass transfer in 100 myr . @xcite discuss the many possible stellar evolution paths for such a system . this system s mass ratio @xmath1790.37 suggests that mass transfer will likely be stable @xcite and that j0056@xmath350611 will evolve into an am cvn system . the elm wd j0751@xmath350141 has a @xmath180 hr orbital period with aliases ranging between 1.85 and 2.05 hr ( see figure [ fig : pdm ] ) . the large @xmath181 km s@xmath26 semi - amplitude indicates that the companion is massive , regardless of the exact period . the minimum companion mass is 0.94 @xmath4 . assuming a random inclination distribution , there is a 47% probability that the companion is @xmath131.4 @xmath4 . given that the elm wd went through a common envelope phase of evolution with its companion , j0751@xmath350141 possibly contains a milli - second pulsar binary companion . helium - core wds are the most common type of companion in known milli - second pulsar binaries @xcite . we have been allocated cycle 14 _ chandra x - ray observatory _ time to search for x - ray emission from a possible neutron star . for @xmath178 , the companion is a 1.32 @xmath4 wd , and the system will begin mass transfer in 290 myr . the extreme mass ratio @xmath1790.18 means that this system will undergo stable mass transfer and evolve into an am cvn system . as the binary orbit widens in the am cvn phase , the mass accretion rate will drop and the mass required for the unstable burning of the accreted he - layer increases up to several percent of a solar mass . the final flash should ignite a thermonuclear transient visible as an underluminous supernova @xcite . it is also possible that the helium flash will detonate the massive wd in a double - detonation scenario ( * ? ? ? * though see dan et al . if j0751@xmath350141 has a massive wd companion , it is a probable supernova progenitor . the elm wd j0811 + 0225 has an orbital period of @xmath182 hr and a semi - amplitude of 221 km s@xmath26 . these orbital parameters yield a minimum companion mass of 1.20 @xmath4 . that means the companion probably exceeds a chandrasekhar mass . for @xmath178 , the most likely companion is a 1.70 @xmath4 neutron star at an orbital separation of 4.6 @xmath12 . there is no fermi gamma - ray detection at this location , but additional observations are needed to determine the nature of this system . the elm wd j0840 + 1527 has a best - fit @xmath23@xmath183 near the limit of our model grid . its best - fit orbital period is @xmath184 hr with a significant alias at 8.3 hr . assuming this object is 0.17 @xmath4 , its most likely companion is a wd with a comparable mass , 0.19 @xmath4 , at an orbital separation of 1.9 @xmath12 . if , on the other hand , j0840 + 1527 were a 3 @xmath4 main sequence star , its companion would have an orbital separation of 4.3 @xmath12 a separation comparable to the radius of a 3 @xmath4 star , and thus physically implausible . there is no evidence for mass transfer in this system . we conclude that j0840 + 1527 is a pair of elm wds . j1141 + 3850 , j1157 + 0546 , and j1238 + 1946 are the other systems containing wds near the low - gravity limit of our stellar atmosphere model grid , but their @xmath185 - 266 km s@xmath26 semi - amplitudes are significantly larger than that of j0840 + 1527 . if we assume that the objects are 0.17 @xmath4 elm wds , then the binary companions have minimum masses of 0.45 - 0.75 @xmath4 . if we instead assume that the objects are main sequence stars , then the required orbital separations are comparable to the radius of the main sequence star and physically impossible . there is no evidence for mass transfer in these systems . we conclude that j1141 + 3850 , j1157 + 0546 , and j1238 + 1946 are elm wds with likely wd companions . for j1141 + 3850 , there is a 36% probability that the companion is @xmath131.4 @xmath4 , possibly a milli - second pulsar . for j1141 + 3850 and j1238 + 1946 , mass transfer will begin in 7 - 10 gyr , making them am cvn progenitors and possible underluminous supernovae progenitors . the elm wd j2132 + 0754 has a well - constrained orbital period of @xmath186 hr and semi - amplitude of @xmath187 km s@xmath26 . the minimum companion mass is 0.95 @xmath4 , and there is a 48% probability that the companion is @xmath131.4 @xmath4 , possibly a milli - second pulsar . for @xmath178 , the most likely companion is a 1.33 @xmath4 wd that will begin mass transfer in 6 gyr . that makes j2132 + 0754 a likely am cvn progenitor and another possible underluminous supernovae progenitor . the elm wd j2338@xmath352052 has an orbital period of @xmath188 hr and a semi - amplitude of @xmath189 km s@xmath26 . in this case the companion is another elm wd ; for @xmath178 , the most likely companion is a 0.17 @xmath4 wd at an orbital separation of 0.56 @xmath12 . given the unity mass ratio , this system will undergo unstable mass transfer and will merge to form a single @xmath90.4 @xmath4 wd . this system will merge in less than 1 gyr . with these 17 new discoveries , plus the pulsating elm wd discovery published by @xcite , the elm survey has found 54 detached , double degenerate binaries ; 31 of the binaries will merge within a hubble time . table [ tab : summary ] summarizes the properties of the systems . eighty percent of the elm survey binaries are formally elm wd systems . we find low mass wds in compact binaries , binaries that must have gone through common envelope evolution . this makes sense because extremely low mass wds require significant mass loss to form ; the universe is not old enough to produce an extremely low mass wd through single star evolution . yet four objects published in the elm survey have no significant velocity variability , two of which are elm wds ( see table [ tab : summary ] ) . to understand whether or not these stars are single requires that we understand the significance of our binary detections . each elm survey binary is typically constrained by 10 - 30 irregularly spaced velocities with modest errors . given that we determine orbital parameters by minimizing @xmath168 , the @xmath190-test is a natural choice . we use the @xmath190-test to check whether the variance of the data around the orbital fit is consistent with the variance of the data around a constant velocity ( we use the weighted mean of the observations ) . @xmath190-test probabilities for the published elm survey binaries are @xmath191 . in other words , our binaries have significant velocity variability at the @xmath192% confidence level . in the null cases we need to calculate the likelihood of not detecting a binary . this is a trickier problem , and one that we approach with a monte carlo calculation . we start by selecting a set of observations ( times , velocity errors ) and an orbital period and semi - amplitude . we convert observation times to orbital phases using a randomly drawn zero time , and calculate velocities at those phases summed with a randomly drawn velocity error . we perform the @xmath190-test , using 0.01 as a detection threshold . we repeat this calculation 10,000 times for a given orbital period and semi - amplitude , and then select a new orbital period and semi - amplitude to iterate on . this analysis is done for each object . we find that the datasets for our 17 new binaries have a median 99.9% likelihood of detecting @xmath193 km s@xmath26 binaries , a 97% likelihood of detecting @xmath194 km s@xmath26 binaries , and a 44% likelihood of detecting @xmath195 km s@xmath26 binaries . it is no surprise that we are less likely to detect a low semi - amplitude binary , but this analysis suggests that we can be quite confident of detecting @xmath196 km s@xmath26systems . we find very similar likelihoods for detecting binaries containing elm wds in the full elm survey sample . the datasets for the null cases typically contain fewer observations and so are not as well - constrained . for j0900 + 0234 , a 0.16 @xmath4 elm wd with no observed velocity variation @xcite , the likelihoods of detecting a @xmath193 , 100 , and 50 km s@xmath26 binary are 87% , 57% , and 10% , respectively . additional observations are required to claim this elm wd as non - variable . there is , of course , an orbital period dependence to the detections , and periods near 24 hr are the most problematic . taken together , our datasets have a median 39% likelihood of detecting a @xmath194 km s@xmath26 binary at @xmath197 hr . yet we remain sensitive to longer periods : our datasets have median 99% and 98% likelihoods of detecting a @xmath194 km s@xmath26 binary at @xmath198 hr and @xmath199 hr , respectively . figure [ fig : kp ] plots the observed distribution of @xmath171 and @xmath172 for the elm survey binaries . the dashed lines indicate the approximate companion mass assuming @xmath200 is 0.2 @xmath4 and @xmath201 is 60@xmath202 . at @xmath194 km s@xmath26 , we can detect companion masses down to 0.1 @xmath4 at 2 hr orbital periods and 0.55 @xmath4companions at 2 day orbital periods . systems with @xmath203 km s@xmath26 are the realm of @xmath70.2 @xmath4 companions , and we observe a half - dozen systems with these parameters . our incompleteness at @xmath203 km s@xmath26 implies there are quite likely more elm wds with @xmath180.2 @xmath4 companions ; the remaining elm wd candidates that do not show obvious velocity change in a couple observations are possible examples of such low amplitude systems . finally , orbital inclination acts to increase the difficulty of identifying lone elm wds . consider the set of 46 elm wds in table [ tab : summary ] with @xmath5 , two of which are non - variable . their median @xmath172 is 240 km s@xmath26 , a semi - amplitude that would appear @xmath204 km s@xmath26 at @xmath205 . if the 46 objects have randomly distributed orbital inclinations , one object should have @xmath205 and a second @xmath206 . we conclude there is no good evidence for a lone elm wd in our present sample . this is in stark contrast to the population of 0.4 @xmath4 wds in the solar neighborhood , of which 20%-30% are single @xcite . one of the most exciting aspects of our elm wd binaries is that many have gravitational wave merger times less than a hubble time , and in one case as short as 1 myr @xcite . a natural question , then , is what will happen when the wds merge . notably , 5 of our 17 new binaries have probable system masses ( for @xmath178 ) in excess of a chandrasekhar mass . figure [ fig : merge ] plots the distribution of merger time and system mass for the elm survey binaries assuming @xmath178 , except when inclination is known . the majority of our binaries have probable masses below the chandrasekhar mass and are not potential supernova type ia progenitors , but six systems appear to have either neutron star or massive wd companions . the evolution of these six systems depends on the stability of mass transfer during the roche lobe overflow phase , and thus on the mass ratio of the binary . figure [ fig : tau ] plots the distribution of merger time and mass ratio @xmath174 for the elm survey binaries , again assuming @xmath178 except when inclination is known . the chandrasekhar mass systems generally have extreme @xmath207 and so will evolve into stable mass transfer am cvn systems . if the accretors are massive wds , these systems should experience a large helium flash that may appear as an underluminous .ia supernova ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? it is also possible that the helium flash will detonate the massive wd in a double - detonation scenario @xcite . the chandrasekhar mass systems are thus potential supernovae progenitors . however , the outcome of a merger of an elm wd with a massive wd is uncertain ( see * ? ? ? systems with @xmath208 , such as j2338@xmath352052 , will experience unstable mass transfer . these systems may merge @xcite to form a single low - mass wd , r crb star , or helium - burning sdb star . systems with intermediate @xmath209 , such as j0651 + 2844 , will experience either stable or unstable mass transfer depending on their spin - orbit coupling . after we constrain the remaining elm wd candidates plotted in fig.[fig : teff ] we look forward to calculating their space density and merger rate . elm wds binaries are clearly an important channel for am cvn star formation , and thus an important source of strong gravitational waves in the mhz regime . we perform stellar atmosphere fits to the entire collection of single - epoch spectra in the hvs survey and identify 57 new low mass wd candidates . follow - up spectroscopy reveals 17 wds with significant velocity variability , 12 of which are elm wds . presently , the elm survey sample is consistent with all of the elm wds being part of close binaries . elm wds are thus signposts for binaries that are strong gravitational wave sources and possible supernovae progenitors . four binaries in our sample contain @xmath1 objects , objects that might not be considered wds or proto - wds if not for their observed orbital motion . the existence of @xmath1 wds motivates us to develop a new set of stellar atmosphere models following @xcite . interestingly , all of the lowest surface gravity ( @xmath164 ) wds in our sample have metal lines in their spectra . this issue will be studied in detail in a future paper ; infrared observations are needed to constrain the possibility of debris disks as the source of ca and mg accretion in these compact binary systems . recent discoveries of pulsations in several of our elm wd targets @xcite enable us to probe the interiors of low - mass , presumably he - core wds using the tools of asteroseismology . due to the hvs color selection , all of the newly identified systems are hotter than 10,000 k and therefore too hot to show the g - mode pulsations detected in cooler elm wds @xcite . four binaries in our sample have massive @xmath30.9 @xmath4 companions and @xmath210 gyr merger times . if the unseen companions are massive wds , these extreme mass ratio binaries will undergo stable mass transfer and will evolve into am cvn systems and potentially future .ia or underluminous supernovae . thus the systems j0751@xmath350141 , j1141 + 3850 , j1238 + 1946 , and j2132 + 0754 are possible supernova progenitors . the other possibility is that the massive companions in these four binaries are neutron stars . given their past common envelope evolution , the systems quite possibly contain milli - second pulsars . a fifth system , j0811 + 0225 , appears to have a minimum companion mass close to a chandrasekhar mass . we are conducting follow - up optical , radio , and x - ray observations to establish the nature of these extreme mass ratio elm wd binaries . optically visible wd companions of neutron stars are useful for constraining the binary mass ratio and also to calibrate the spin - down ages of milli - second pulsars . given our present observations , we expect that the elm survey will grow to 100 binaries in a few years . a large sample is important for finding more systems like j0651 + 2844 , a 12.75 min period system that provides us with a laboratory for measuring the spin - orbit coupling and tidal heating of a rapidly merging pair of wds . we expect that photometric observations will discover more pulsating elm wds . finally , a larger sample of elm wds will be an important source of gravitational wave verification sources for @xmath210 and other future gravitational wave detection experiments . we thank m. alegria , p. canton , s. gotilla , j. mcafee , e. martin , a.milone , and r. ortiz for their assistance with observations obtained at the mmt observatory , and p. berlind and m. calkins for their assistance with observations obtained at the fred lawrence whipple observatory . we also thank p. bergeron and d. koester for their invaluable assistance in the computation of our stellar atmosphere model grids . this research makes use of the sao / nasa astrophysics data system bibliographic service . this project makes use of data products from the sloan digital sky survey , which has been funded by the alfred p. sloan foundation , the participating institutions , the national science foundation , and the u.s.department of energy office of science . this work was supported in part by the smithsonian institution . _ facilities : _ crcccccccc j0022@xmath351014 & 18980 & 7.15 & 0.07989 & 145.6 & 0.33 & @xmath211 & 0.23 & @xmath212 & 6 + j0056@xmath350611 & 12210 & 6.17 & 0.04338 & 376.9 & 0.17 & @xmath213 & 0.61 & @xmath214 & + j0106@xmath351000 & 16490 & 6.01 & 0.02715 & 395.2 & 0.17 & 0.43 & & 0.037 & 7 + j0112 + 1835 & 9690 & 5.63 & 0.14698 & 295.3 & 0.16 & @xmath215 & 0.85 & @xmath216 & 1 + j0651 + 2844 & 16530 & 6.76 & 0.00886 & 616.9 & 0.26 & 0.50 & & 0.0011 & 3,15 + j0751@xmath350141 & 15660 & 5.43 & 0.08001 & 432.6 & 0.17 & @xmath217 & 1.32 & @xmath218 & + j0755 + 4906 & 13160 & 5.84 & 0.06302 & 438.0 & 0.17 & @xmath219 & 1.12 & @xmath220 & 2 + j0818 + 3536 & 10620 & 5.69 & 0.18315 & 170.0 & 0.17 & @xmath221 & 0.33 & @xmath222 & 2 + j0822 + 2753 & 8880 & 6.44 & 0.24400 & 271.1 & 0.17 & @xmath223 & 1.05 & @xmath224 & 4 + j0825 + 1152 & 24830 & 6.61 & 0.05819 & 319.4 & 0.26 & @xmath225 & 0.61 & @xmath226 & 0 + j0849 + 0445 & 10290 & 6.23 & 0.07870 & 366.9 & 0.17 & @xmath227 & 0.88 & @xmath228 & 4 + j0923 + 3028 & 18350 & 6.63 & 0.04495 & 296.0 & 0.23 & @xmath229 & 0.44 & @xmath230 & 2 + j1005 + 0542 & 15740 & 7.25 & 0.30560 & 208.9 & 0.34 & @xmath231 & 0.86 & @xmath232 & 0 + j1005 + 3550 & 10010 & 5.82 & 0.17652 & 143.0 & 0.17 & @xmath211 & 0.24 & @xmath233 & 0 + j1053 + 5200 & 15180 & 6.55 & 0.04256 & 264.0 & 0.20 & @xmath221 & 0.33 & @xmath234 & 4,9 + j1056 + 6536 & 20470 & 7.13 & 0.04351 & 267.5 & 0.34 & @xmath229 & 0.43 & @xmath235 & 0 + j1112 + 1117 & 9590 & 6.36 & 0.17248 & 116.2 & 0.17 & @xmath236 & 0.17 & @xmath237 & 16 + j1141@xmath423850 & 11620 & 5.31 & 0.25958 & 265.8 & 0.17 & @xmath223 & 1.05 & @xmath238 & + j1233 + 1602 & 10920 & 5.12 & 0.15090 & 336.0 & 0.17 & @xmath239 & 1.20 & @xmath240 & 2 + j1234@xmath350228 & 18000 & 6.64 & 0.09143 & 94.0 & 0.23 & @xmath241 & 0.11 & @xmath216 & 6 + j1238@xmath421946 & 16170 & 5.28 & 0.22275 & 258.6 & 0.17 & @xmath227 & 0.88 & @xmath242 & + j1436 + 5010 & 16550 & 6.69 & 0.04580 & 347.4 & 0.24 & @xmath213 & 0.60 & @xmath243 & 4,9 + j1443 + 1509 & 8810 & 6.32 & 0.19053 & 306.7 & 0.17 & @xmath244 & 1.15 & @xmath245 & 1 + j1630 + 4233 & 14670 & 7.05 & 0.02766 & 295.9 & 0.30 & @xmath246 & 0.37 & @xmath247 & 8 + j1741 + 6526 & 9790 & 5.19 & 0.06111 & 508.0 & 0.16 & @xmath248 & 1.55 & @xmath249 & 1 + j1840 + 6423 & 9140 & 6.16 & 0.19130 & 272.0 & 0.17 & @xmath227 & 0.88 & @xmath250 & 1 + j2103@xmath350027 & 10000 & 5.49 & 0.20308 & 281.0 & 0.17 & @xmath251 & 0.99 & @xmath252 & 0 + j2119@xmath350018 & 10360 & 5.36 & 0.08677 & 383.0 & 0.17 & @xmath253 & 1.04 & @xmath254 & 2 + j2132@xmath420754 & 13700 & 6.00 & 0.25056 & 297.3 & 0.17 & @xmath255 & 1.33 & @xmath256 & + j2338@xmath352052 & 16630 & 6.87 & 0.07644 & 133.4 & 0.27 & @xmath257 & 0.18 & @xmath258 & + nltt11748 & 8690 & 6.54 & 0.23503 & 273.4 & 0.18 & 0.76 & & 7.2 & 5,10,11 + j0022 + 0031 & 17890 & 7.38 & 0.49135 & 80.8 & 0.38 & @xmath259 & 0.26 & & 6 + j0152 + 0749 & 10840 & 5.80 & 0.32288 & 217.0 & 0.17 & @xmath260 & 0.78 & & 1 + j0730 + 1703 & 11080 & 6.36 & 0.69770 & 122.8 & 0.17 & @xmath261 & 0.41 & & 0 + j0755@xmath424800 & 19890 & 7.46 & 0.54627 & 194.5 & 0.42 & @xmath262 & 1.18 & & + j0802@xmath350955 & 16910 & 6.42 & 0.54687 & 176.5 & 0.20 & @xmath260 & 0.76 & & + j0811@xmath420225 & 13990 & 5.79 & 0.82194 & 220.7 & 0.17 & @xmath263 & 1.71 & & + j0815@xmath422309 & 21470 & 5.78 & 1.07357 & 131.7 & 0.17 & @xmath225 & 0.63 & & + j0840@xmath421527 & 13810 & 5.04 & 0.52155 & 84.8 & 0.17 & @xmath257 & 0.19 & & + j0845 + 1624 & 17750 & 7.42 & 0.75599 & 62.2 & 0.40 & @xmath211 & 0.22 & & 0 + j0900 + 0234 & 8220 & 5.78 & & @xmath264 & 0.16 & & & & 1 + j0917 + 4638 & 11850 & 5.55 & 0.31642 & 148.8 & 0.17 & @xmath265 & 0.36 & & 12 + j1046@xmath350153 & 14880 & 7.37 & 0.39539 & 80.8 & 0.37 & @xmath211 & 0.23 & & + j1104@xmath420918 & 16710 & 7.61 & 0.55319 & 142.1 & 0.46 & @xmath266 & 0.70 & & + j1151@xmath425858 & 15400 & 6.09 & 0.66902 & 175.7 & 0.17 & @xmath267 & 0.84 & & + j1157@xmath420546 & 12100 & 5.05 & 0.56500 & 158.3 & 0.17 & @xmath268 & 0.59 & & + j1422 + 4352 & 12690 & 5.91 & 0.37930 & 176.0 & 0.17 & @xmath269 & 0.55 & & 2 + j1439 + 1002 & 14340 & 6.20 & 0.43741 & 174.0 & 0.18 & @xmath213 & 0.62 & & 2 + j1448 + 1342 & 12580 & 6.91 & & @xmath270 & 0.25 & & & & 2 + j1512 + 2615 & 12130 & 6.62 & 0.59999 & 115.0 & 0.20 & @xmath265 & 0.36 & & 2 + j1518 + 0658 & 9810 & 6.66 & 0.60935 & 172.0 & 0.20 & @xmath271 & 0.78 & & 1 + j1538@xmath420252 & 11560 & 5.97 & 0.41915 & 227.6 & 0.17 & @xmath272 & 1.06 & & + j1557@xmath422823 & 12550 & 7.76 & 0.40741 & 131.2 & 0.49 & @xmath273 & 0.54 & & + j1625 + 3632 & 23570 & 6.12 & 0.23238 & 58.4 & 0.20 & @xmath274 & 0.08 & & 6 + j1630 + 2712 & 11200 & 5.95 & 0.27646 & 218.0 & 0.17 & @xmath275 & 0.70 & & 2 + j2252@xmath350056 & 19450 & 7.00 & & @xmath276 & 0.31 & & & & 2 + j2345@xmath350102 & 33130 & 7.20 & & @xmath277 & 0.42 & & & & 2 + lp400@xmath3522 & 11170 & 6.35 & 1.01016 & 119.9 & 0.19 & @xmath269 & 0.52 & & 13,14 73 natexlab#1#1 , h. , allende prieto , c. , an , d. , et al . 2011 , , 193 , 29 , c. , beers , t. c. , wilhelm , r. , et al . 2006 , , 636 , 804 , c. , sivarani , t. , beers , t. c. , et al . 2008 , , 136 , 2070 , c. g. , van kerkwijk , m. h. , koester , d. , & verbunt , f. 2006 , , 456 , 295 , p. , wesemael , f. , & beauchamp , a. 1995 , , 107 , 1047 , l. , shen , k. j. , weinberg , n. n. , & nelemans , g. 2007 , , 662 , l95 , j. m. , kilic , m. , brown , w. r. , & kenyon , s. j. 2011 , , 729 , 2 , w. r. , geller , m. j. , & kenyon , s. j. 2009 , , 690 , 1639 . 2012 , , 751 , 55 , w. r. , geller , m. j. , kenyon , s. j. , & kurtz , m. j. 2005 , , 622 , l33 . 2006 , , 640 , l35 . 2006 , , 647 , 303 , w. r. , geller , m. j. , kenyon , s. j. , kurtz , m. j. , & bromley , b. c. 2007 , , 660 , 311 . 2007 , , 671 , 1708 , w. r. , kilic , m. , allende prieto , c. , & kenyon , s. j. 2010 , , 723 , 1072 . 2011 , , 411 , l31 . 2012 , , 744 , 142 , w. r. , kilic , m. , hermes , j. j. , et al . 2011 , , 737 , l23 , g. , ferraro , f. r. , possenti , a. , & damico , n. 2006 , , 641 , l129 , a. h. , romero , a. d. , althaus , l. g. , & hermes , j. j. 2012 , , 547 , a96 , m. , rosswog , s. , guillochon , j. , & ramirez - ruiz , e. 2011 , , 737 , 89 . 2012 , , 422 , 2417 , b. , rood , r. t. , & oconnell , r. w. 1993 , , 419 , 596 , d. , cheimets , p. , caldwell , n. , & geary , j. 1998 , , 110 , 79 , s. , schaffenroth , v. , hirsch , h. , et al . 2012 , in asp conf . ser , , vol . 452 , fifth meeting on hot subdwarf stars and related objects , ed . d. kilkenny , c. s. jeffery , & c. koen , 129 , a. , bergeron , p. , & ruiz , m. t. 2011 , , 743 , 138 , l. , bertelli , g. , bressan , a. , et al . 2002 , , 391 , 195 , l. , grebel , e. k. , odenkirchen , m. , & chiosi , c. 2004 , , 422 , 205 , u. 2009 , , 47 , 211 , u. , edelmann , h. , lisker , t. , & napiwotzki , r. 2003 , , 411 , l477 , j. j. , kilic , m. , brown , w. r. , montgomery , m. h. , & winget , d. e. 2012 , , 749 , 42 , j. j. , kilic , m. , brown , w. r. , et al . 2012 , , 757 , l21 , j. j. , montgomery , m. h. , winget , d. e. , brown , w. r. , kilic , m. , & kenyon , s. j. 2012 , , 750 , l28 , j. j. , montgomery , m. h. , winget , d. e. , et al . 2013 , , accepted , d. l. , bhalerao , v. b. , van kerkwijk , m. h. , et al . 2013 , , accepted , a. , vennes , s. , & vaccaro , t. r. 2010 , , 516 , l7 , s. j. & garcia , m. r. 1986 , , 91 , 125 , m. , allende prieto , c. , brown , w. r. , & koester , d. 2007 , , 660 , 1451 , m. , allende prieto , c. , brown , w. r. , et al . 2010 , , 721 , l158 , m. , brown , w. r. , allende prieto , c. , kenyon , s. j. , & panei , j. a. 2010 , , 716 , 122 , m. , brown , w. r. , allende prieto , c. , pinsonneault , m. , & kenyon , s. 2007 , , 664 , 1088 , m. , brown , w. r. , allende prieto , c. , swift , b. , kenyon , s. j. , liebert , j. , & ageros , m. a. 2009 , , 695 , l92 , m. , brown , w. r. , allende prieto , c. , et al . 2011 , , 727 , 3 . 2012 , , 751 , 141 , m. , brown , w. r. , hermes , j. j. , et al . 2011 , , 418 , l157 , m. , brown , w. r. , kenyon , s. j. , et al . 2011 , , 413 , l101 , d. 2008 , arxiv:0812.0482 , m. j. & mink , d. j. 1998 , , 110 , 934 , r. l. 1993 , synthe spectrum synthesis programs and line data ( kurucz cd - rom ; cambridge , ma : smithsonian astrophysical observatory ) , j. , bergeron , p. , & holberg , j. b. 2005 , , 156 , 47 , t. r. , dhillon , v. s. , & duck , s. r. 1995 , , 275 , 828 , t. r. , nelemans , g. , & steeghs , d. 2004 , , 350 , 113 , p. , strobel , k. , barnes , j. v. , & anderson , e. 1988 , , 328 , 315 , g. , richer , j. , & richard , o. 2008 , , 675 , 1223 , f. , badenes , c. , thompson , s. e. , & lupton , r. 2009 , , 707 , l51 , k. 1982 , , 253 , 798 , b. 1971 , acta astron . , 21 , 1 , j. a. , althaus , l. g. , chen , x. , & han , z. 2007 , , 382 , 779 , c. , pelletier , c. , fontaine , g. , & michaud , g. 1986 , , 61 , 197 , s. , gnsicke , b. t. , brady , s. , et al . 2012 , , 419 , 817 , a. , nebot gmez - morn , a. , schreiber , m. r. , et al . 2012 , , 419 , 806 , g. d. , weymann , r. j. , & foltz , c. b. 1989 , , 101 , 713 , k. j. & bildsten , l. 2009 , , 699 , 1365 , r. , stensen , r. h. , bloemen , s. , et al . 2012 , , 424 , 1752 , s. a. , fink , m. , kromer , m. , et al . 2012 , , 420 , 3003 , j. d. r. , kaplan , d. l. , shporer , a. , bildsten , l. , & howell , s. b. 2010 , , 716 , l146 , t. m. , langer , n. , & kramer , m. 2012 , , 425 , 1601 , p .- e . & bergeron , p. 2009 , , 696 , 1755 , p .- e . , bergeron , p. , kalirai , j. s. , & gianninas , a. 2010 , , 712 , 1345 , v. , fontaine , g. , brassard , p. , & dupret , m .- a . 2013 , , 762 , 57 , s. , kawka , a. , vaccaro , t. r. , & silvestri , n. m. 2009 , , 507 , 1613 , s. , thorstensen , j. r. , kawka , a. , et al . 2011 , , 737 , l16 , s. e. & weaver , t. a. 1994 , , 423 , 371 table [ tab : dat ] presents our radial velocity measurements . the table columns include object name , heliocentric julian date ( based on utc ) , heliocentric radial velocity ( uncorrected for the wd gravitational redshift ) , and velocity error .
Abstract: | [
"we present the discovery of 17 low mass white dwarfs ( wds ) in short - period @xmath0 day binaries . our sample includes four objects with remarkable @xmath1 surface gravities and orbital solutions that require them to be double degenerate binaries . all of the lowest surface gravity wds have metal lines in their spectra implying long gravitational settling times or on - going accretion . notably , six of the wds in our sample have binary merger times @xmath210 gyr . four have @xmath30.9 @xmath4 companions . if the companions are massive wds , these four binaries will evolve into stable mass transfer am cvn systems and possibly explode as underluminous supernovae . if the companions are neutron stars , then these may be milli - second pulsar binaries . these discoveries increase the number of detached , double degenerate binaries in the elm survey to 54 ; 31 of these binaries will merge within a hubble time ."
] | 9,427 | 9,427 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: cognitive research deals with how people learn and solve problems @xcite . at a coarse - grained level , there are three components of cognitive research : how do people acquire knowledge , how do they organize and retain the knowledge in memory ( brain ) and how do they retrieve this knowledge from memory in appropriate situations including to solve problems . these three components are strongly coupled , e.g. , how knowledge was organized and retained in memory during acquisition will determine how effectively it can be retrieved in different situations to solve problems . we can define problem solving as any purposeful activity where one must devise and perform a sequence of steps to achieve a set goal when presented with a novel situation . a problem can be quantitative or conceptual in nature . using the findings of cognitive research , human memory can be broadly divided into two components : the working memory or the short term memory ( stm ) and the long term memory ( ltm ) . the long term memory is where the prior knowledge is stored . appropriate connections between prior knowledge in ltm and new knowledge that is being acquired at a given time can help an individual organize his / her knowledge hierarchically . such hierarchical organization can provide indexing of knowledge where more fundamental concepts are at the top of the hierarchy and the ancillary concepts are below them . similar to an index in a book , such indexing of knowledge in memory can be useful for accessing relevant knowledge while solving problems in diverse situations . it can also be useful for inferential recall when specific details may not be remembered . the working memory or stm is where information presented to an individual is processed . it is the conscious system that receives input from memory buffers associated with various sensory systems and can also receive input from the ltm . conscious human thought and problem solving involves rearranging and synthesizing ideas in stm using input from the sensory systems and ltm . one of the major initial findings of the cognitive revolution is related to miller s magic numbers 7@xmath02 ( 5 to 9 ) , i.e. , how much information can stm hold at one time . @xcite miller s research found that stm can only hold 5 to 9 pieces of information regardless of the iq of an individual . here is an easy way to illustrate this . if an individual is asked to memorize the following sequence of 25 numbers and letters in that order after staring at it for 30 seconds , it is a difficult task : 6829 - 1835 - 47dr - lpcf - ogb - twc - pvn . an individual typically only remembers between 5 to 9 things in this case . however , later research shows that people can extend the limits of their working memory by organizing disparate bits of information into chunks or patterns . @xcite using chunks , stm can evoke from ltm , highly complex information . an easy way to illustrate it is by asking an individual to memorize the following sequence of 25 numbers and letters : 1492 - 1776 - 1865 - 1945-aol - ibm - usa . this task is much easier if one recognizes that each of the four digit number is an important year in history and each of the three letters grouped together is a familiar acronym . thus , an individual only has to remember 7 separate chunks rather than 25 disparate bits . this chunking mechanism is supported by research in knowledge rich fields such as chess and physics where experts in a field have well organized knowledge . @xcite for example , research shows that if experts in chess are shown a very good chess board that corresponds to the game of a world - class chess player , they are able to assemble the board after it is disassembled because they are able to chunk the information on the board and remember the position of one piece with respect to another . if chess novices are shown the same board , they are only able to retrieve 5 - 9 pieces after it is jumbled up because they are not able to chunk large pieces of information present on the chess board . on the other hand , both chess experts and novices are poor at assembling a board on which the chess pieces are randomly placed before it was jumbled up . in this latter case , chess experts are unable to chunk the random information due to lack of pattern . a crucial difference between expert and novice problem solving is the manner in which knowledge is represented in their memory and the way it is retrieved to solve problems . experts in a field have well organized knowledge . they have large chunks of compiled " knowledge in ltm and several pieces of knowledge can be accessed together as a chunk @xcite . for example , for an expert in physics , vector addition , vector subtraction , displacement , velocity , speed , acceleration , force etc . can be accessed as one chunk while solving problems while they can be seven separate pieces of information for beginning students . if a problem involves all of these concepts , it may cause a cognitive overload if students stm can only hold 5 or 6 pieces of information . experts are comfortable going between different knowledge representations , e.g. , verbal , diagrammatic / pictorial , tabular etc . and employ representations that make problem solving easier . @xcite experts categorize problems based upon deep features unlike novices who can get distracted by context dependent features . for example , when physics professors and introductory physics students are asked to group together problems based upon similarity of solution , professors group them based upon physics concepts while students can choose categories that are dependent on contexts such as ramp problems , pulley problems , spring problems etc @xcite . of course , an important goal of most physics courses is to help students develop expertise in problem solving and improve their reasoning skills . in order to help students , instructors must realize that the cognitive load , which is the amount of mental resources needed to solve a problem , is subjective @xcite . the complexity of a problem not only depends on its inherent complexity but also on the expertise , experience and intuition of an individual @xcite . it has been said that problems are either impossible " or trivial " . a ballistic pendulum problem that may be trivial for a physics professor may be very difficult for a beginning student @xcite . cognitive load is higher when the context is abstract as opposed to concrete . the following wason tasks @xcite are examples of abstract and concrete problems which are conceptually similar , but the abstract problem turns out to be cognitively more demanding . * you will lose your job unless you enforce the following rule : if a person is rated k , then his / her document must be marked with a 3 " . + each card on the table for a person has a letter on one side and a number on the other side . indicate only the card(s ) shown in figure 1 that you definitely need to turn over to see if the document of any of these people violates this rule . + * you are serving behind the bar of a city centre pub and will lose your job unless you enforce the following rule : if a person is drinking beer , then he / she must be over 18 years old " . + each person has a card on the table which has his / her age on one side and the name of his / her drink on the other side . indicate only the card(s ) shown in figure 2 that you definitely need to turn over to see if any of these people are breaking this rule . the correct answer for the abstract case is that you must turn the cards with k and 7 ( to make sure that there is no k on the other side ) . please note that the logic presented in the task is one sided in that it is ok for a document with a 3 to have anything on the other side . the correct answer for the concrete case is beer " and 16 years old " , and it is much easier to identify these correct answers than the correct answers for the abstract case . a major reason for why the cognitive load is high during problem solving in physics is because the laws of physics are abstract . it is important to realize that it is not easy to internalize them unless concrete contexts are provided to the students . another difficulty is that , once the instructor has built an intuition about a problem , it may not appear difficult to him / her even if it is abstract . in such situations the instructor may overlook the cognitive complexity of the problem for a beginning student unless the instructor puts himself / herself in the students shoes . an important lesson from cognitive research is that new knowledge that an individual acquires builds on prior knowledge . this idea is commensurate with piaget s notion of optimal mismatch " @xcite or vygotsky s idea of zone of proximal development " ( zpd ) @xcite . zpd is the zone defined by what a student can do on his / her own vs. with the help of a guide who is familiar with the student s initial knowledge and targets instruction somewhat above it continuously for effective learning . this is analogous to the impedance matching of a transformer in which the power transfer can be maximized if the input and output impedances are matched . another analogy is with light passing through two polarizers placed perpendicular to each other vs. having several polarizers stacked one after another where the transmission axes of adjacent polarizers are slightly different from each other . in the first case of crossed polarizer , no light passes through whereas in the second case most of the light passes through if the angle @xmath1 between the transmission axes of the adjacent polarizers is small enough . similarly , if the instruction is targeted significantly above students prior knowledge , learning wo nt be meaningful and even if the students make an effort to store some hap - hazardous information in their brain till the final exam , it will get shampooed out " soon after that . on the other hand , if the instructional design takes into account students initial knowledge and builds on it , learning will be meaningful . another important lesson from cognitive research is that students must construct their own understanding . this implies that we should give students an opportunity to reconstruct , extend , and organize their knowledge . such opportunities will come from ensuring that the students are actively engaged in the learning process and take advantage of their own knowledge resources and also benefit from interactions with their peers . we now describe computer - based interactive problem solving tutorials that we have been developing that build on introductory physics students prior knowledge and keep them actively engaged in the learning process . the tutorials combine quantitative and conceptual problem solving . they focus on helping students develop a functional understanding of physics while learning useful skills @xcite . it is worthwhile thinking about why quantitative problem solving alone often fails to help most students extend and organize their physics knowledge . without guidance , most students do not exploit the problem solving opportunity to reflect upon what they have actually learned and build a more robust knowledge structure . if only quantitative problems are asked , students often view them as plug - and - chug " exercises , while conceptual problems alone are often viewed as guessing tasks with little connection to physics content . the interactive tutorials we have been developing combine quantitative and conceptual problem solving and provide guidance and support for knowledge and skill acquisition . they provide a structured approach to problem solving and promote active engagement while helping students develop self reliance . other computer - based tutorials are also being developed @xcite . our tutorials are unique in that they focus on helping students learn effective problem solving strategies and the conceptual questions are developed based upon the common difficulties found via research on students difficulties in learning a particular topic in physics . a major goal of an introductory physics course for science and engineering majors is to enable students to develop complex reasoning and problem solving skills to explain and predict diverse phenomena in everyday experience . however , numerous studies show that students do not acquire these skills from a _ traditional _ course @xcite . the problem can partly be attributed to the fact that the kind of reasoning that is usually learned and employed in everyday life is not systematic or rigorous . although such hap - hazardous reasoning may have little measurable negative consequences in an individual s personal life , it is insufficient to deal with the complex chain of reasoning that is required in rigorous scientific field such as physics @xcite . educational research suggests that many introductory physics students solve problems using superficial clues and cues , applying concepts at random without thinking whether they are applicable or not @xcite . also , most traditional courses do not _ explicitly _ teach students effective problem solving strategies . rather , they may reward inferior problem solving strategies in which many students engage . instructors often implicitly assume that students know that the analysis , planning , evaluation , and reflection phases of problem solving are as important as the implementation phase . consequently , they may not discuss these strategies explicitly while solving problems during the lecture . there is no mechanism in place to ensure that students make a conscious effort to interpret the concepts , make qualitative inferences from the quantitative problem solving tasks , or relate the new concepts to their prior knowledge . in order to develop scientific reasoning by solving quantitative problems , students must learn to exploit problem solving as an opportunity for knowledge and skill acquisition . thus , students should not treat quantitative problem solving merely as a mathematical exercise but as a learning opportunity and they should engage in effective problem solving strategies . effective problem solving begins with a conceptual analysis of the problem , followed by planning of the problem solution , implementation and evaluation of the plan , and last but not least reflection upon the problem solving process . as the complexity of a physics problem increases , it becomes increasingly important to employ a systematic approach . in the qualitative or conceptual analysis stage , a student should draw a picture or a diagram and get a visual understanding of the problem . at this stage , a student should convert the problem to a representation that makes further analysis easier . after getting some sense of the situation , labeling all known and unknown numerical quantities is helpful in making reasonable physical assumptions . making predictions about the solution is useful at this level of analysis and it can help to structure the decision making at the next stage . the prediction made at this stage can be compared with the problem solution in the reflection phase and can help repair , extend and organize the student s knowledge structure . planning or decision making about the applicable physics principles is the next problem solving heuristic . this is the stage where the student brings everything together to come up with a reasonable solution . if the student performed good qualitative analysis and planning , the implementation of the plan becomes easy if the student possesses the necessary algebraic manipulation and mathematical skills . after implementation of the plan , a student must evaluate his / her solution , e.g. , by checking the dimension or the order of magnitude , or by checking whether the initial prediction made during the initial analysis stage matches the actual solution . one can also ask whether the solution is sensible and , possibly , consistent with experience . the reflection phase of problem solving is critical for learning and developing expertise . research indicates that this is one of the most neglected phase of problem solving @xcite . without guidance , once a student has an answer , he / she typically moves on to the next problem . at the reflection stage , the problem solver must try to distill what he or she has learned from solving the problem . this stage of problem solving should be used as an opportunity for reflecting upon why a particular principle of physics is applicable to the problem at hand and how one can determine in the future that the same principle should be applicable even if the problem has a new context . the development of the computer - based tutorials to help students learn effective problem solving strategies is guided by a learning paradigm which involves three essential components : modeling , coaching , and weaning @xcite . in this approach , modeling " means that the instructor demonstrates and exemplifies the skills that students should learn ( e.g. , how to solve physics problems systematically ) . coaching " means providing students opportunity , guidance and practice so that they are actively engaged in learning the skills necessary for good performance . weaning " means reducing the support and feedback gradually so as to help students develop self - reliance . each of the tutorials starts with an overarching problem which is quantitative in nature . before using a tutorial , students use a pre - tutorial worksheet which divides each quantitative problem given to them into different stages involved in problem solving . for example , in the conceptual analysis stage of problem solving , the worksheet explicitly asks students to draw a diagram , write down the given physical quantities , determine the target quantity , and predict some features of the solution . after attempting the problem on the worksheet to the best of their ability , students access the tutorial on the computer ( or use a paper version for evaluation purposes as discussed in the evaluation section below ) . the tutorial divides an overarching problem into several sub - problems , which are research - guided conceptual multiple - choice questions related to each stage of problem solving . the alternative choices in these multiple - choice questions elicit common difficulties students have with relevant concepts as determined by research in physics education . incorrect responses direct students to appropriate help sessions where students have the choice of video , audio or only written help with suitable explanations , diagrams , and equations . correct responses to the multiple - choice questions give students a choice of either advancing to the next sub - problem or directs them to the help session with the reasoning and explanation as to why the alternative choices are incorrect . while some reasonings are problem - specific , others focus on more general ideas . after students work on the implementation and assessment phase sub - problems posed in the multiple - choice format , they answer reflection sub - problems . these sub - problems focus on helping students reflect upon what they have learned and apply the concepts learned in different contexts . if students have difficulty answering these sub - problems , the tutorial provides further help and feedback . thus , the tutorials not only model or exemplify a systematic approach to problem solving , they also engage students actively in the learning process and provide feedback and guidance based upon their need . each tutorial problem is matched with other problems ( which we call paired problems ) that use similar physics principles but which are somewhat different in context . students can be given these paired problems as quizzes so that they learn to de - contextualize the problem solving approach and concepts learned from the tutorial . the paired problems play an important role in the weaning part of the learning model and ensure that students develop self - reliance and are able to solve problems based upon the same principle without help . these paired problems can also be assigned as homework problems and instructors can inform students that they can use the tutorials as a self - paced study tool if they have difficulty in solving the paired problems assigned as homework related to a particular topic . we have developed computer - based tutorials related to introductory mechanics , electricity , and magnetism . topics in mechanics include linear and rotational kinematics , newton s laws , work and energy , and momentum . topics in electricity and magnetism include coulomb s law , gauss s law , potential and potential energy , motion of charged particles in an electric field , motion of charged particles in a magnetic field , faraday s law , and lenz s law . figures 3 - 6 show screen captures from a computer - based tutorial which starts with a quantitative problem in which two blocks with masses @xmath2 and @xmath3 are in contact on a frictionless horizontal surface and a horizontal force @xmath4 is applied to the block with mass @xmath2 . students are asked to find the magnitude of force exerted by the block with mass @xmath3 on @xmath2 . we have found that this problem is sufficiently challenging for students in both algebra and calculus - based introductory physics courses that most students are unable to solve it without help . in the tutorial , the quantitative problem is broken down into several conceptual problems in the multiple - choice format that students have to answer . for example , one of the conceptual questions related to the initial analysis of the problem is shown in figure 3 along with a screen capture of a help session that a student is directed to if he / she chooses an incorrect response . figure 4 is a multiple - choice question about the free body diagram and figure 5 is a screen capture of a help screen in which an instructor explains relevant concepts to the students related to difficulty with the question asked in figure 4 . figure 6 is a help screen related to a reflection question in which students are asked about the force exerted by the block of mass @xmath2 on @xmath3 if the force of the hand @xmath4 was applied to the block of mass @xmath3 in the opposite direction ( instead of being applied to the block of mass @xmath2 as in the tutorial ) . below , we describe a case - study to evaluate the tutorials . in one case study , we compared three different groups who were given different aid tools : * group ( 1 ) consists of students who used the tutorials as aid tool . * group ( 2 ) consists of students who were given the solved solutions for the tutorial problems which were similar to the solutions in the textbook s solutions manual . however , the solutions were not broken down into the multiple - choice questions with alternative choices targeting common misconceptions as was done in the tutorials . * group ( 3 ) consists of students who were given the textbook sections that dealt with the relevant concepts as the aid tool and were asked to brush up on the material for a quiz on a related topic . fifteen students were recruited and divided into two pools based upon their prior knowledge . then , the students from each of these pools were randomly assigned to one of the three groups discussed above . during the interview session , students in each group initially answered a pre - questionnaire to determine their level of preparation , their views about problem solving in physics , and their perception of physics instruction . it was interesting to note that a majority of the students ( regardless of the group to which they belonged ) disagreed with the statement when confronted with a physics problem , i first spend a reasonable amount of time planning how to solve the problem before actually solving it " . half of the students also agreed with the statement physics problem solving is all about matching given quantities in the problem to the formula in the book " . half of the students thought that the pace of their introductory physics courses was very fast . after this pre - questionnaire , all students were given the following problem on a worksheet and were asked to solve it to the best of their ability before using their aid tools : * _ an insulating sphere of radius @xmath5 has a spherical cavity of radius @xmath6 located within its volume and centered a distance @xmath7 from the center of the sphere . a cross section of the sphere is shown in figure 7 . the solid part of the insulating sphere has a uniform volume charge density @xmath8 . find the electric field @xmath9 at a point inside the cavity . _ all students identified the correct principle to use ( gauss s law ) when asked to solve the problem to the best of their ability on the worksheet . the above problem is challenging enough that none of the interviewed students could solve it without help . most students initially thought that the problem was relatively easy . except for one student who came up with a different incorrect answer , the rest of the students came up with the same incorrect answer : the electric field is zero everywhere inside the cavity . all of them invoked gauss s law , which states that the total electric flux through a closed surface is equal to the net charge inside the surface divided by @xmath10 . their reasoning for zero electric field in the cavity was based on the incorrect interpretation that whenever the electric flux through a closed surface is zero , the electric field at every point inside the surface must be zero too regardless of whether there was a symmetric charge distribution to justify such claims . thus , students drew a gaussian sphere inside the hole and concluded that the electric field must be zero everywhere inside since the enclosed charge is zero . students ignored the asymmetric charge distribution surrounding the cavity , which is a common difficulty . @xcite among many of the difficulties the interviewed students faced , one difficulty was not recognizing that the charge distribution was not symmetric enough and therefore the net electric field at a point inside the cavity can not be zero . when asked to show why the electric field should be zero everywhere inside , most students drew a spherical gaussian surface inside the hole , wrote down gauss s law in the integral form and pulled out the electric field from inside the integral . interviews show that many students believed that the electric field can always be pulled out from the surface integral regardless of the symmetry of the charge distribution . when pressed harder about why the electric field should be equal everywhere on the gaussian surface and why it can be pulled out of the integral , some students noted that one should not worry about this issue at least in this case since the zero charge enclosed implies zero electric field everywhere inside anyway . their convoluted reasoning showed that many students have difficulty in organizing different knowledge resources and applying them at the same time . after the students tried to solve the problem on the worksheet on their own to the best of their ability , students in group 1 were given the corresponding tutorial to work on , those in group 2 were given a textbook - style solution for the problem ( similar to the solutions in a textbook solution manual ) , and those in group 3 were given the section in the textbook , university physics by young and freedman , which deals with this topic . each student used his / her respective aid tool for the same amount of time ( 20 minutes ) . all students were told that they would have to solve a paired problem involving similar concepts after help from the tools they were provided ( tutorial , textbook - style solution , relevant chapter from textbook ) . all students were informed that aid tool was only for learning the material and could not be used while working on the paired problem they will be given later . the paired problem that followed tested whether students could transfer relevant knowledge acquired from the aid tools to the paired problem . @xcite for example , for the gauss s law problem discussed above , the paired problem was similar to the tutorial problem but was for an infinite solid insulating cylinder with a uniform volume charge and an asymmetric cylindrical cavity inside it . we used a rubric to grade students . the average performance of the tutorial group was approximately @xmath11 . all of them made the correct assumption that the electric field is not zero inside the cavity due to the asymmetry of the charge distribution and explained how gauss s law can not be used in such cases to conclude that the electric field is zero in the cavity . during the interviews , these students were able to explain verbally their thought processes and how they solved the problem to find the electric field . by analyzing the students thought processes during the interviews , it appears that the pattern of reasoning employed by these students was significantly better on an average than the reasoning of students from the other two groups . the other two groups did nt show as much improvement as the tutorial group when graded on a rubric after using the aids . between groups 2 and 3 , the students who used the textbook - style solution as a guide did better on the paired problem than those who used the relevant textbook section . the average performance of group 2 was approximately @xmath12 and group 3 was less than @xmath13 . students who used the textbook - style solution still had difficulties in solving the paired problem and four of them did not solve the entire problem correctly . the solution of the problem involves breaking the problem into subproblems each of which has a spherical symmetry and can be solved by known methods using gauss s law . most of the students in the second group ( those who were given a solution of the type given in solutions manual ) realized that they had to combine or superpose two electric fields . however , their most common difficulty was in using vectors in order to relate the final solution to the solutions to the two subproblems which have a spherical symmetry . the textbook - type solution showed them that calculating the electric field at a point in the cavity involved subtracting from the electric field due to the full insulating sphere as though there was no cavity , the electric field due to an insulating sphere of the size of the cavity . from the surveys given after the paired problem , some students mentioned that the textbook - style solutions did nt explain in words the steps used thoroughly . since the misconceptions students had at the beginning were not explicitly targeted by asking explicit questions in the textbook - type solution ( as was done explicitly in the multiple - choice questions which were part of the tutorials ) , students did not transfer relevant knowledge from the solved example to the paired problem as well as the tutorial group did . all of the students who made use of the textbook as an aid for learning ( rather than the tutorial or the solved example ) did poorly on the paired problem . this finding is consistent with another study that shows that unless introductory physics students have seen solved examples . @xcite students in this group realized that the problem solution could not be that the magnitude of the electric field inside the cavity is @xmath14 because otherwise they would not be given 20 minutes to browse over the section of the textbook trying to formulate a solution . but the responses they provided after browsing over the book were often difficult to understand and dimensionally incorrect . when asked to explain what they had done , students noted that they were not very sure about how to solve the problem . they added that the relevant section of the textbook did not help because it did not have a solved example exactly like the problem that was asked . people do not automatically acquire usable knowledge by spending lots of time on task . limited capacity of stm can make cognitive load high for beginning students . for learning to be meaningful , students should be actively engaged in the learning process . moreover , it is important to consider the difficulty of a problem from students perspective and build on their prior knowledge . we are developing computer - based interactive tutorials for introductory mechanics and electricity and magnetism that are suited for a wide variety of students . the self - paced tutorials combine quantitative and conceptual problem solving . they engage students actively in the learning process and provide feedback based upon their needs . they focus on helping students learn problem solving and reasoning skills while helping them build a more coherent knowledge structure related to physics . they can be used as a self - study tool by students . the paired problems can be incorporated into regular quizzes or assigned as homework problems . we thank daniel haileselassie and josh bilak for help in the development and evaluation of the tutorials and thank f. reif , j. levy , and r. devaty for helpful discussions . we are grateful to the nsf for award due-0442087 . national reserach council , _ how people learn : bridging research and practice _ , committee on learning research and educational practices , eds . m. donovan , j. bransford , and j. pellegrino , national academy press , washington , dc , 1999 ; national reserach council , _ how people learn : brain , mind , experience and school _ , committee on developments in science on learning , eds . j. bransford , a. brown and r. cocking , national academy press , washington , dc , 1999 ; h. a. simon , and c. a. kaplan , _ foundations of cognitive science _ , ( m. i. posner editor , mit press , 1989 ) ; j. r. anderson , _ the adaptive character of thought _ , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum , 1990 ; j. anderson and c. lebiere , _ atomic components of thoughts _ , mahwah nj : lawrence erlbaum , 1998 ; a. newell , _ unified theories of cognition _ , cambridge , ma : harvard university press , 1990 ; a. newell and h. simon , _ human problem solving _ , englewood cliffs nj : prentice hall , 1972 ; e. thorndike , _ human learning _ , new york : century , 1931 ; r. d. tennyson and r. l. elmore , _ learning theory foundations for instructional design _ in instructional design : international perspectives , ( vol . 1 : theory , research , models ) , r. d. tennyson , f. schott , n. seel , and s. dijkstra , mhawah , nj : lawr . erlb . , 1997 ; r. g. glaser , _ education and thinking : the role of knowledge _ , am . psychologist , * 39 * , 93 - 104 , ( 1984 ) . f. reif , _ scientific approaches to science education _ , phys . today * 39 * , 48 , 1986 ; f. reif , _ interpretation of scientific or mathematical concepts : cognitive issues and instructional implications _ * 11 * , 395 , 1987 ; f. reif and s. allen , _ cognition of interpreting scientific concepts : a study of acceleration _ , cognition and instruction * 9(1 ) * , 1 - 44 , ( 1992 ) ; j. mestre and j. touger , _ cognitive research - what s in it for physics teachers ? _ , phys . teach . * 27 * , 447 ( 1989 ) ; e. f. redish , _ implications of cognitive studies for teaching physics _ , am . j. phys . * 62 * , 796 , 1994 ; e. redish , _ teaching physics with the physics suite _ , wiley , 2003 . h. simon , _ how big is a chunk ? _ , science , * 183 * ( 4124 ) , 482 - 488 , 1974 ; p. kyllonen and r. christal , _ reasoning ability is ( little more than ) working memory capacity ? ! _ , intelligence , * 14 * , 389 - 433 , 1990 ; a. baddeley , _ working memory _ , oxford : clarendon press / oxford university press , 1986 ; m. miyake , m. just and p. carpenter , _ working memory contraints on the resolution of lexical ambiguity : maintaining multiple interpretationsin neutral contexts _ , j. memory and language , * 33(2 ) * , 175 - 202 , 1994 ; a. fry , s. hale , _ processing speed , working memory and fluid intelligence : evidence for a developmental cascade _ , psychological science , * 7(4 ) * , 237 - 241 , 1996 ; r. kail and t. salthouse , _ processing speed as a mental capacity _ , acta psychologica , * 86 * , 199 - 225 , 1994 . w. chase and h. simon , _ the mind s eye in chess _ , in visual information processing , ed . w. chase , new york : academic press , 1973 w. chase and h. simon , _ perception in chess _ , cognitive psychology , * 4 * , 55 - 81 , 1973 ; f. gobert and h. simon , _ recall of random and distorted chess positions : implication of the theory of expertise _ , memory and cognition , * 24(4 ) * , 493 - 503 , 1996 ; p. rosenbloom and a. newell , _ learning by chunking : a production system model of practice _ , in production system models of learning and development , eds . d. klahr and p. langley , cambridge , ma : mit press , pp . 221 - 286 , 1987 ; d. broadbent , _ the magic number severn after fifteen years _ , in eds . a. kennedy and a. wilkes , studies in long term memory , ny : wilet , 1975 . j. larkin , and h. simon , _ why a diagram is ( sometimes ) worth ten thousand words _ , in h. a. simon , models of thought ( yale univ . press , new haven ) , vol . ii , pp . 413 - 437 ( 1989 ) ; j. larkin , _ understanding , problem representations , and skill in physics _ in s. f. chipman , j. w. segal and r. glaser ( eds . ) , thinking and learning skills ( lawrence erl . , hillsdale , nj ) , * 2 * , pp . 141 - 159 ( 1985 ) ; j. kaput , _ representation and problem solving : methodological issues related to modeling _ , e. a. silver ( ed . ) , in teaching and learning mathematical problem solving : multiple research perspectives , lawrence erl . , hillsale , nj , pp . 381 - 398 , 1985 ; d. norman , _ things that make us smart _ , addison - wesley , p. 49 , 1993 ; j. zhang , _ the nature of external representations in problem solving _ , cog . 21 , 179 - 217 ( 1997 ) ; j. zhang , and d. norman , " representations in distributed cognitive tasks , cog . , 18 , 87 - 122 ( 1994 ) ; k. reusser , _ tutoring systems and pedagogical theory : representational tools for understanding , planning , and reflection in problem solving _ , in s. lajoie and s. derry ( eds . ) , computer as cognitive tools , lawrence erl . , hillsdale , nj , 1993 ; t. de jong and m. ferguson - hessler , _ cognitive structure of good and poor problem solvers in physics _ psych . * 78 * , 279 - 288 ( 1986 ) ; h. simon , _ on the forms of mental representation _ , in c. savage ( ed . ) , minnesota studies in the philosophy of science ( univ . minnesota press , minneapolis ) , vol . ix , _ perception and cognition : issues in the foundations of psychology _ ( 1978 ) ; h. simon and d. simon , _ individual differences in solving physics problems _ , in models of thought , vol . ii , yale univ . press , ( 1989 ) . m. t. h. chi , p. j. feltovich , and r. glaser , _ categorization and representation of physics knowledge by experts and novices _ , cog . sci . * 5 * , 121 - 152 ( 1981 ) ; p. w. cheng and k. j. holyoak , _ pragmatic reasoning schema _ , cognitive psychology , * 17 * , 391 - 416 , 1985 ; k. johnson and c. mervis , _ effects of varying the levels of expertise on the basic level of categorization _ , 1997 ; p. johnson - laird , _ psychology of reasoning , structure and content _ , cambridge , ma , 1972 ; s. marshall , _ schemas in problem solving _ , new york , ny : cambridge university press , 1995 ; d. bobrow and d. norman , _ some principles of memory schemata _ , in representation and understanding : studies in cognitive science , eds . d. bobrow and a. collins , new york : academic press , pp 131 - 149 , 1975 . b. eylon , and f. reif , effect of knowledge organization on task performance " , cognition and instruction * 1 * , 5 ( 1984 ) ; j. i. heller , and f. reif , _ prescribing effective human problem solving processes : problem description in physics _ , cognition and instruction , * 1 * , 177 , ( 1984 ) . m. chi , r. glaser , and e. rees , _ expertise in problem solving _ , in advances in the psychology of human intelligence , vol . 7 - 75 , r. j. sternberg ( editor ) , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum ( 1982 ) ; r. e. mayer , _ thinking , probelm solving , cognition _ , second edition , new york : freeman , 1992 ; j. larkin , j. mcdermott , d. simon , and h. simon , _ expert and novice performance in solving physics problems _ , science * 208 * , 1335 - 1362 ( 1980 ) ; j. larkin , _ the role of problem representation in physics _ , in d. gentner and a. l. stevens ( eds . ) , mental models ( lawrence erlbaum , hillsdale , nj ) , pp . 75 - 98 ( 1983 ) ; j. larkin , _ cognition of learning physics _ * 49(6 ) * , 534 - 541 , ( 1981 ) ; j. larkin , _ skilled problem solving in physics : a hierarchical planning approach _ , j. of structured learn . * 6 * , 121 - 130 ( 1980 ) ; a. h. schoenfeld , _ mathematical problem solving _ , new york : academic press , 1985 ; a. h. schoenfeld , _ teaching mathematical thinking and problem solving _ , pp . 83 - 103 , in toward the thinking curriculum : current cognitive research ( l. b. resnick and b. l. klopfer eds . ) , washington , dc : ascd , 1989 ; a. schoenfeld and d. j. herrmann , _ problem perception and knowledge structure in expert novice mathematical problem solvers _ , j. exp . psych . , learning , memory , and cognition * 8 * , 484 - 494 ( 1982 ) ; y. anzai and t. yokoyama , _ internal models in physics problem solving _ , cognition and instruction * 1(4 ) * , 397 - 450 , ( 1984 ) ; c. schunn and j. anderson , _ acquiring expertise in science : explorations of what , when and how _ , in designing for science , implications from everyday , classroom and professional settings , eds . k. crowley , c. d. schuun and t. okada , lawrence erlbaum , 2001 . j. sweller , _ cognitive load during problem solving : effects on learning _ , cognitive science * 12 * , 257 , 1988 ; j. sweller , r. mawer , and m. ward , _ development of expertise in mathematical problem solving _ , j. exptal . psychology : general * 112 * , 639 , 1983 . p. wason , _ reasoning about a rule _ , quarterly journal of experimental psychology , * 20 * , 273 - 281 , 1968 ; p. wason and p. johnson - laird , _ psychology of reasoning : structure and content _ , cambridge , ma : harvard university press , 1972 . h. ginsberg , and s. opper , _ piaget s theory of intellectual development _ , englewood cliffs , prentice hall , n.j . , 1969 ; r. gorman , _ discovering piaget : a guide for teachers _ , merrill , columbus , 1972 ; j. piaget , _ the language and thought of a child _ , ny : meridian , ( 1974 ) ; j. piaget , _ success and understanding _ , cambridge , ma : harvard university press , 1978 ; a. lawson , _ a review of research on formal reasoning and science teaching _ , j. research in science teaching , * 22(7 ) * , 569 - 617 , 1985 . l. vygotsky , _ mind in society : the development of higher psychological processes _ , harvard university press , 1978 ; j. wertsch , _ mind in action _ , ny : oxford university press , ( 1998 ) ; j. valsiner , and r. van der veer , _ the encoding of distance : the concept of the zone of proximal development and its interpretations_. in ( r. r. cocking and k. a. renninger eds . ) the development and meaning of psychological distance ( pp 35 - 62 ) , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum associates . c. singh , interactive video tutorials for enhancing problem solving , reasoning , and meta - cognitive skills of introductory physics students " , proceedings of the 2003 physics education research conference , edited by j. marx , s. franklin and k. cummings , aip conf . proc . , volume 720 , melville , new york , 177 - 180 , 2004 . for example , see http://www.andes.pitt.edu/ , http://www.webassign.net , http://www.masteringphysics.com a. collins , j. brown , and s. newman , _ cognitive apprenticeship : teaching the crafts of reading , writing and mathematics _ , in l. b. resnick ( ed . ) , knowing , learning , and instruction : essays in honor of robert glaser " , hillsdale , nj : lawrence erlbaum . , 453 - 494 , ( 1989 ) . m. gick and k. holyoak , _ the cognitive basis of knowledge transfer _ , in transfer of learning : contemporary research and applications , cornier @xmath15 hagman ( eds . ) , new york , academic press ( 1987 ) ; m. gick and k. holyoak , _ schema induction and analogical transfer _ , cognitive psychology , * 15 * , 1 - 38 , 1983 ; k. holyoak , _ the pragmatics of analogical transfer _ , in the psychology of learning and motivation , ed . g. bower , ( vol . 19 ) , new york : academic press , 1985 ; k. holyoak and p. thagard , _ mental leaps : analogy in creative thought _ , cambridge , ma : mit press , 1995 ; r. dufresne , j. mestre , t. thaden - koch , w. gerace and w. leonard , _ knowledge representation and coordination in the transfer process _ 155 - 215 , in transfer of learning from a modern multidisciplinary perspective , j. p. mestre ( ed . ) , 393 pages , greenwich , ct : information age publishing , ( 2005 ) ; j. lobato , _ how design experiments can inform a rethinking of transfer and vice versa _ , educational researcher , 32(1 ) , 17 - 20 , ( 2003 ) ; j. lobato , _ alternative perspectives on the transfer of learning : history , issues and challenges for future research _ , j. learning sciences , * 15(4 ) * , 431 - 439 , ( 2006 ) ; d. j. ozimek , p. v. engelhardt , a. g. bennett , n. s. rebello , _ retention and transfer from trigonometry to physics _ , proceedings of the physics education research conference , eds . j. marx , p. heron , s. franklin , 173 - 176 , ( 2004 ) ; j. d. bransford and d. schwartz , _ rethinking transfer : a simple proposal with multiple implications _ , review of research in education , * 24 * , 61 - 100 , ( 1999 ) ; l. novick , _ analogical transfer , problem similarity and expertise _ , j. experimental psychology : learning , memory and cognition , * 14(3 ) * , 510 - 520 , ( 1988 ) . c. singh , assessing student expertise in introductory physics with isomorphic problems , part ii : examining the effect of some potential factors on problem solving and transfer " , phys . . res . * 4 * , 010105 , ( 2008 ) .
Abstract: | [
"one finding of cognitive research is that people do not automatically acquire usable knowledge by spending lots of time on task . because students knowledge hierarchy is more fragmented , `` knowledge chunks '' are smaller than those of experts . the limited capacity of short term memory makes the cognitive load high during problem solving tasks , leaving few cognitive resources available for meta - cognition . the abstract nature of the laws of physics and the chain of reasoning required to draw meaningful inferences makes these issues critical . in order to help students , it is crucial to consider the difficulty of a problem from the perspective of students . we are developing and evaluating interactive problem - solving tutorials to help students in the introductory physics courses learn effective problem - solving strategies while solidifying physics concepts . the self - paced tutorials can provide guidance and support for a variety of problem solving techniques , and opportunity for knowledge and skill acquisition . address = department of physics and astronomy , university of pittsburgh , pittsburgh , pennsylvania , 15260"
] | 8,712 | 8,712 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: soon after the experimental discovery @xcite of carbon nanotubes , it was suggested @xcite that there might also exist carbon _ nanotori _ , carbon nanotubes in which the ends of the tube are identified and sewn together . within a few years , experimental evidence for such structures emerged @xcite , and since then they have attracted a great deal of experimental @xcite and theoretical @xcite attention . there are a variety of reasons for this intense interest . for example , certain species of carbon nanotori exhibit unusual magnetic properties @xcite , including persistent magnetic moments at nearly zero flux @xcite and colossal paramagnetic moments @xcite . these objects can also display a diverse variety of electric properties : some nanotori are inherently metallic , while others are semiconducting and still others are insulators . as we shall discuss , the most general nanotorus can be parametrized by four integers @xmath0 . together and in various combinations , these describe the radius of the underlying nanotube , the chirality of the underlying nanotube , the length of the underlying nanotube , and the relative twist @xcite that might occur upon sewing opposite ends of the tube together to form the torus . the important point , however , is that nanotori with different @xmath0 are fundamentally physically distinct : they have different sizes , different shapes , and different twisted `` honeycomb '' patterns of carbon atoms laid out on their surfaces . of course , there are certain symmetries of the underlying graphene sheet which lead to trivial equivalences amongst these nanotori . for example , @xmath1 rotations of the underlying graphene sheet will produce identical nanotori . such nanotori are therefore not physically distinct . in this paper , however , we shall demonstrate that there are additional symmetries that relate _ physically distinct _ nanotori to each other , forcing such nanotori to exhibit identical energy spectra and electrical properties . these so - called `` modular '' symmetries therefore transcend the traditional hexagonal lattice symmetries of the graphene sheet , and arise solely in the process of compactifying the graphene sheet in order to form the nanotorus . in some sense , the appearance of these modular symmetries is entirely expected , for they result directly from the geometry of the compactification . however , to the best of our knowledge , the significance and consequences of these symmetries have not been fully appreciated thus far in the nanotorus literature . as we shall demonstrate , these symmetries have a number of profound effects . first , we shall see that use of these symmetries allows us to partition the set of carbon nanotori into distinct equivalence classes as far as their spectral properties are concerned , and leads to a dramatic reduction in the numbers of _ spectrally distinct _ carbon nanotori as compared with the numbers of _ physically distinct _ nanotori . moreover , as we shall show , many of the standard rules of thumb advanced in the literature in order to describe the conductivity properties of these nanotori actually fail to respect these symmetries . such rules of thumb are therefore incomplete as descriptions of the physics of these nanotori , and must be replaced by statements which respect the full symmetry structure of the compactified graphene sheet . finally , we demonstrate that these symmetries even extend to situations in which the carbon nanotori enclose different types of magnetic flux . they thus should have applicability for many of the fascinating magnetic properties of carbon nanotori , including the possibility of persistent currents . in order to explain the origins of these spectral symmetries , we begin with a brief review which will also serve to highlight our notation and conventions . 3.0 truein for the uncompactified graphene sheet , all electron wavevectors @xmath9 are allowed . however , this situation changes when we `` roll up '' one dimension of the graphene sheet to produce a single - walled carbon nanotube , or equivalently when we identify any two carbon atoms on the graphene sheet whose positions differ by an arbitrary lattice vector @xmath14 with @xmath15 . imposing the bloch condition on the electron wavefunctions @xmath16 in addition to the new periodicity condition @xmath17 then restricts @xmath18 to the set of wavevectors satisfying the condition @xmath19 where @xmath20 and @xmath21 . these allowed values of @xmath22 therefore form parallel lines in the @xmath23 plane , and the locations at which these lines intersect the bragg planes in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] determine whether the corresponding @xmath24 nanotube is metallic , semiconducting , or insulating . nanotubes for which @xmath25 ( , @xmath26 ) or @xmath27 ( , @xmath28 ) are dubbed `` zigzag '' or `` armchair '' respectively ; nanotubes with other values of @xmath24 are generally referred to as `` chiral '' . in general , the vector @xmath29 perpendicular to @xmath30 is the tube axis . 2.15 truein we now consider imposing _ two _ non - parallel identifications on the graphene sheet , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] . in general , we consider two arbitrary lattice identification vectors @xmath31 and @xmath32 ; without loss of generality we shall assume that @xmath33 . we shall also assume without loss of generality that the quantity @xmath34 is positive , or equivalently that the relative angle @xmath35 from @xmath30 to @xmath36 lies in the range @xmath37 , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] . such identifications together result in a so - called @xmath0 nanotorus which may be viewed as a @xmath24 nanotube in which opposite ends are joined to each other , potentially with a relative twist angle @xmath35 . this description is especially appropriate if @xmath38 . note that @xmath39 describes the number of hexagonal cells which tile the surface of the resulting donut , and is equal to precisely half the number of carbon atoms in the nanotorus . imposing the double periodicity condition @xmath40 on the electron wavefunction @xmath16 in conjunction with the bloch condition then leads to the constraint in eq . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) as well as the additional constraint @xmath41 where @xmath42 . solving eqs . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) and ( [ eq : tubek2 ] ) simultaneously then yields @xmath43 \nonumber\\ k_y & = & \frac{2\pi}{l_1l_2\sin\theta } \left[-\ell_1 l_2\cos\delta + \ell_2 l_1\cos\beta\right ] \label{eq : torik}\end{aligned}\ ] ] or equivalently @xmath44\nonumber\\ k_y & = & { 2\pi \over \sqrt{3 } n_{\rm hex } } \left [ -\ell_1 ( 2p + q ) + \ell_2 ( 2m+n ) \right]~. \label{eq : torik2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , we see that the allowed electron wavevectors now form a two - dimensional grid of points in the @xmath23 plane . note that there are always exactly @xmath39 allowed wavevectors lying inside the fundamental region bounded by the bragg planes in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] , where points lying on a single bragg plane itself are counted as half and where points lying at the intersections of two bragg planes are counted as a third . whether such nanotori are metallic , semiconducting , or insulating depends on whether these points hit or come particularly close to the intersections of the bragg planes in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] . it is found that nanotori in which both @xmath45 and @xmath46 are multiples of three are metallic , with solutions to eqs . ( [ eq : torik ] ) and ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) that lie precisely on the fermi surface . for practical applications , it proves useful to focus on only those nanotori with @xmath47 , as this condition allows one to bend the nanotube into a nanotorus without excessive strain or deformation of the underlying graphene sheet ( the effects of which would otherwise distort the dispersion relation in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] , and hence the band structure of the torus ) . within this limit , it is then conventional to regard nanotori with @xmath48 ( mod 3 ) but @xmath49 ( mod 3 ) as semiconducting , since the allowed wavevectors come `` close '' to the fermi surface in this limit . all other nanotori are then considered insulating . all of the above results are completely standard , and are well known in the carbon - nanotorus literature . in particular , tori with different values of @xmath0 are physically distinct : they have entirely different arrangements of hexagons tiling their surfaces , with different values of the physical radii @xmath50 , chiral angle @xmath51 , and twist angle @xmath35 . we shall take this to be our definition of `` physically distinct '' . there are , of course , certain trivial identifications which relate different nanotori to each other : for example , the @xmath0 torus and the @xmath52 torus are actually identical , since they correspond to @xmath53 pairs which are related to each other by a uniform @xmath1 rotation . such trivial identifications reflect the underlying hexagonal lattice symmetries of the graphene sheet from which these nanotori are constructed , and result in identical carbon nanotori with identical patterns of carbon atoms on their surfaces . such nanotori are therefore not physically distinct . by contrast , an important question is whether there exist physically _ distinct _ nanotori ( , tori which are _ not _ related by symmetries of the hexagonal lattice ) which nevertheless yield identical grids of allowed wavevectors @xmath23 . if so , we will have found cases of physically distinct tori with different values of @xmath54 which are nevertheless spectrally identical . in other words , such tori will have identical energy spectra and electrical conducting properties . at first sight , it might appear that no such spectral equivalences exist for carbon nanotori . after all , the results in eq . ( [ eq : torik ] ) for carbon nanotori may initially appear to be nothing more than a two - dimensional generalization of the results in eq . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) for carbon nanotubes , and no such spectral equivalences exist for carbon nanotubes . however , it is important to realize that this is not true for carbon nanotori . in particular , it turns out that the set of allowed values of @xmath23 in eq . ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) is actually invariant under two additional symmetry transformations which we shall denote @xmath55 and @xmath56 : @xmath57 under these transformations , it is straightforward to demonstrate that @xmath34 is invariant , while the physical parameters @xmath58 , @xmath59 , @xmath35 , and @xmath51 transform in the following manner : @xmath60 it is important to stress that the individual equations in eqs . ( [ eq : torik ] ) and ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) are not invariant under @xmath55 or @xmath56 ; rather , what is invariant is the _ set _ of values of @xmath23 to which these equations lead . moreover , since these sets of solutions for @xmath23 are invariant under @xmath55 and @xmath56 individually , they are also invariant under any sequence of @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations . for example , under the @xmath61 transformation we find @xmath62 , and this too is a symmetry of the solutions to eq . ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) . it then follows from these observations that any two tori whose defining vectors @xmath30 and @xmath36 differ through @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations share the same electronic spectra but are intrinsically different from each other , that they are isospectral but physically distinct . that they are isospectral follows from the fact that the same set of @xmath23 solutions are selected in each case . by contrast , that they are physically distinct follows from the fact that the fundamental identifications between carbon atoms on the graphene sheet are altered by @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations in a manner that transcends trivial hexagonal lattice symmetries . this is perhaps easiest to see in the case of the @xmath56 transformation , which corresponds to the action @xmath63 . this changes not only @xmath59 but @xmath35 , and thus produces a new torus which has a greater `` twist '' when the ends of the nanotube are joined . it may be less obvious that the @xmath55 transformation also connects physically distinct tori . indeed , this transformation corresponds to the action @xmath64 , and at first glance it might appear that this is merely a trivial relabeling of the two independent periodicities , along with a reflection ( sign flip ) . however , we must remember that the @xmath55 transformation also changes the associated @xmath35 and @xmath51 angles in non - trivial ways . alternatively , we can also appreciate the non - trivial nature of @xmath55 by considering the combination t s t^-1 s^-1 = t s t [ tprimedef ] which corresponds to the action @xmath65 . [ the second equality in eq . ( [ tprimedef ] ) follows as a result of the identity @xmath66 , or equivalently @xmath67 . ] note that @xmath68 is in some sense `` dual '' to @xmath56 : each performs a full twist around a different cycle of the torus . in other words , as illustrated in fig . [ tori ] , while @xmath56 corresponds to cutting through one side of the torus and re - attaching the two edges along with a twist , @xmath68 corresponds to cutting the torus along the other cycle and then twisting along the cut in an analogous manner before attaching the newly adjacent bonds . thus , @xmath68 results in a physically distinct torus , just as @xmath56 does , and furthermore these resulting tori are not related to each other through hexagonal lattice symmetries . it then follows from eq . ( [ tprimedef ] ) that @xmath55 also can not correspond to a lattice symmetry , @xmath55 must connect physically distinct tori as well . indeed , @xmath55 and @xmath68 are interchangeable in the sense that the two generators of the modular group can be considered to be either @xmath69 or @xmath70 . 3.5 truein note that if we define the complex quantity @xmath71 , then the @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations correspond to @xmath72 and @xmath73 respectively . together , these transformations generate the so - called `` modular group '' , which is one of the primordial symmetries associated with toroidal compactifications . in general , any transformation which takes the form @xmath74 where @xmath75 and @xmath76 is a modular transformation . what we have shown , then , is that any two carbon nanotori whose defining parameters are related by a modular transformation are spectrally identical even though they are physically distinct . in other words , any transformation which can be generated through repeated actions of the @xmath55 and @xmath56 generators leads to a spectral equivalence between physically distinct tori . it is important to emphasize that the appearance of these modular symmetries is not a total surprise . modular symmetries often arise in the presence of toroidal compactifications , and are a direct consequence of the underlying geometry of the carbon nanotorus . indeed , the zone - folding of a macroscopic lattice necessarily introduces periodic equivalences of the sort discussed here , and in the case of two dimensions with non - parallel identifications , such periodicities generically lead to modular symmetries . in other words , the underlying toroidal graph is not altered by modular symmetries , and thus the adjacencies of the graph ( and the isospectrality which results ) are preserved intact . however , when applied to the case of carbon nanotori , these symmetries are _ physical _ , in the sense that the nanotori they relate are isospectral but physically distinct . as we shall see , this is particularly significant , allowing these symmetries to have profound effects on the physics of these nanotorus systems and in particular on the range of behaviors they may exhibit . in a sense , these modular symmetries can be viewed as a generalization of a similar set of symmetries that emerge for mbius graphs . to see this , let us imagine taking a long strip of hexagons and gluing opposite ends of this strip together with an arbitrary number of half - twists . at first glance , one might suspect that the resulting spectrum should depend on the actual number of half - twists . however , it turns out that the resulting spectrum depends only on whether this number is even or odd @xcite . this mbius case is , of course , a relatively trivial example of this phenomenon , since it deals with only a single possible kind of twist corresponding to the single periodicity that defines the mbius strip . indeed , for the case of carbon nanotori , our point is that there exists a whole _ group _ of transformations the modular group which is built upon the actions of _ two _ non - commuting underlying generators ( @xmath55 and @xmath56 ) which can be combined and performed in a variety of inequivalent ways . this leads to `` sewing '' and `` gluing '' configurations on the torus which are much more complex than on the mbius strip , and which require greater mathematical machinery to study and this in turn leads to distinctions between the notions of `` physically distinct '' and `` spectrally distinct '' which are even more pronounced than in the mbius case . however , even the relatively simple mbius case illustrates one of our basic themes : there can be lots of physically distinct twisted hexagon strips , yet very few of them are spectrally distinct . it is the preservation of the underlying graph in each case which makes this possible . as a result of these modular symmetries , we can henceforth establish an unambiguous convention for uniquely describing the spectral properties of a given carbon nanotorus : we calculate its complex parameter @xmath77 as defined above , and then use a sequence of @xmath55 and @xmath56 modular transformations as needed in order to bring @xmath77 into a special region of the complex @xmath77-plane known as the `` fundamental domain '' @xmath78 defined by : -0 , ||1where @xmath79 and @xmath80 . note that the condition @xmath81 already ensures that @xmath82 . we can then use the underlying symmetries of the hexagonal graphene lattice in order to bring the resulting angle @xmath51 into the range @xmath83 . note that this convention is tantamount to describing the spectrum of a given carbon nanotorus in terms of that spectrally equivalent nanotorus which is as close to being rectangular as possible . following this procedure therefore provides an unambiguous test of whether any two physically distinct carbon nanotori in fact have the same spectral properties . the existence of these modular symmetries and the spectral equivalences they induce has profound implications for the physics of carbon nanotori . indeed , as we shall see , the use of these modular symmetries will sharpen our ability to classify nanotori on the basis of those physical properties ( such as their metallicities , _ etc . _ ) which ultimately stem from their band structures . furthermore , use of these modular symmetries can even provide _ statistical _ insights into the properties of randomly produced carbon nanotori insights which may ultimately have practical consequences for the manufacture of such objects in environments in which their resulting properties often can not be controlled or engineered in advance . as discussed above , the first and most direct implication of these modular symmetries is that there exist physically distinct nanotori often with markedly different radii and chiral angles which nevertheless possess identical energy spectra and conductivity properties . as an example of this phenomenon , let us consider the @xmath84 , @xmath85 , and @xmath86 carbon nanotori . clearly , we see that these nanotori are physically distinct and are characterized by different sets of cycle lengths @xmath50 , different chiral angles @xmath51 , and different twist angles @xmath35 . as a result , these three tori have entirely different patterns of carbon atoms tiling their surfaces . yet , the latter two nanotori are in fact related to each another by @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations , and consequently they each yield the same spectrum of allowed @xmath22 vectors shown in fig . [ fig : energyspecthreetori ] . similarly the first nanotorus is related to the second two through not only @xmath55 and @xmath56 transformations , but also trivial 60@xmath87 rotations of the underlying graphene sheet . thus , these tori all share identical spectra , and according to the convention specified above , we can describe this spectrum uniquely as having @xmath88 , @xmath89 , and @xmath90 . 3.0 truein second , as a corollary to this observation , we also learn that the usual notions of `` zigzag '' and `` armchair '' notions which are critical for describing the chirality and metallicity of carbon nanotubes no longer hold as special indicators of the spectral properties of corresponding carbon nanotori . in other words , nanotori built from zigzag or armchair nanotubes might have spectral properties which are identical to those of nanotori built from non - zigzag or non - armchair nanotubes ; moreover , these spectral properties might or might not correspond to the special zigzag or armchair angles @xmath91 . as an example , the @xmath92 nanotorus is built from a zigzag nanotube while the @xmath93 nanotorus is built from an armchair nanotube and the @xmath94 and @xmath95 nanotori are built from chiral nanotubes with different chiralities . yet all four nanotori have identical spectral properties which are the same as those of a chiral nanotorus with @xmath96 , @xmath97 , and @xmath98 ( or @xmath99 ) . indeed , using the mathematical results of ref . @xcite , we can show that any carbon nanotorus is spectrally equivalent to one built from a zigzag carbon nanotube . conversely , a carbon nanotorus can have a spectrum which exhibits a zigzag or armchair property that is lacking in the original nanotube from which it is constructed . as an example , the @xmath100 nanotorus is built from a zigzag nanotube and the @xmath101 nanotorus is built from a chiral nanotube . yet both nanotori have the spectral properties of an armchair nanotorus , with @xmath96 , @xmath102 , and @xmath103 . likewise , the @xmath104 nanotorus is built from an armchair nanotube and the @xmath105 nanotorus is built from a chiral nanotube . yet both nanotori have the spectral properties of a zigzag nanotorus , with @xmath96 , @xmath106 , and @xmath107 . third , it turns out that not every possible spectral signature @xmath108 can be realized , even in principle . instead , these three quantities experience internal constraints and correlations which ultimately reflect the fixed hexagonal lattice structure of the underlying graphene sheet and which require that any allowed spectral signature @xmath108 originate from four real integers @xmath0 . these correlations amongst @xmath108 can take a variety of different forms . for example , for odd values of @xmath39 , it turns out that there exist no self - consistent spectral signatures with purely imaginary values of @xmath77 . similarly , for @xmath109 , there are solutions with @xmath110 , but no other inverse integers ; likewise , all of these except for @xmath111 have @xmath26 . in fact , these internal constraints amongst the four real parameters embodied in @xmath112 are sufficiently strong that they effectively eliminate one real degree of freedom from within this parametrization . in other words , although four real degrees of freedom are required in order to parametrize a given physically distinct nanotorus , only three real degrees of freedom are required in order to uniquely describe its spectral properties @xcite . it is easy to understand why such constraints arise . ordinarily , as a question of topology , tori can exist with all shapes and volumes , for there are literally an infinite number of ways in which we can construct a torus by rolling up an unmarked sheet of paper . however , in the case of carbon nanotori , our original `` sheet of paper '' is not unmarked : it is actually a graphene sheet of carbon atoms which has its own hexagonal lattice structure . the existence of such a lattice structure has a number of critical consequences : it forces our toroidal defining vectors @xmath30 to @xmath36 to be _ lattice vectors _ ; it restricts the resulting possible combinations of @xmath39 and @xmath77 to those values consistent with the periodicity of the lattice ; and it breaks the rotational symmetry of our original uncompactified two - dimensional sheet and necessitates the introduction of a new measurable parameter , the angle @xmath51 defined in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] , which describes the orientation of the torus relative to the underlying lattice . conversely , the presence of the hexagonal lattice gives a clear meaning to the twist angle @xmath35 . this quantity would have had no meaning when rolling up an unmarked sheet of paper . fourth , it is clear that the existence of spectral equivalences between different nanotori implies that the number of _ spectrally _ distinct nanotori in any set will necessarily be smaller than the number of _ physically _ distinct nanotori in that set . however , it turns out that the magnitude of this truncation can easily become quite staggering . as an example , let us consider the set of physically distinct @xmath0 nanotori with fixed @xmath113 which can be formed from integers in the range @xmath114 for some cutoff @xmath115 . for concreteness , we shall take @xmath116 . in order to count only physically distinct nanotori , we shall require that @xmath24 be chosen such that @xmath117 . we shall also require , as a rough measure of their physical consistency in three - dimensional space , that each such nanotorus have an outer circumference @xmath59 which is at least triple its inner cross - sectional circumference @xmath58 ; note that other similar mathematical conditions may alternatively be imposed , but the qualitative results to follow are essentially unchanged . given these constraints , we then find through direct enumeration that there are exactly @xmath118 physically distinct carbon nanotori which have @xmath88 . yet , as a result of these spectral equivalences , it turns out that these @xmath118 physically distinct carbon nanotori give rise to only @xmath119 distinct energy spectra ! these distinct energy spectra are listed in table [ nhex18table ] , along with a representative carbon nanotorus in each class . .for @xmath88 and @xmath116 , there are @xmath118 physically distinct carbon nanotori @xmath0 with @xmath120 . however , these exhibit only 14 spectrally distinct energy spectra and band structures , and only four of these correspond to metals . these 14 spectrally distinct values of @xmath121 and @xmath51 are listed above , along with a sample @xmath0 nanotorus in each class . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] this is clearly a major truncation . even with the relatively small value @xmath88 and relatively small cutoff @xmath116 , each spectral signature listed in table [ nhex18table ] is shared by literally hundreds or thousands of physically distinct carbon nanotori . fifth , it is also worth noting that this truncation does not treat metallic and non - metallic nanotori equally . in general , a given @xmath0 carbon nanotorus will be metallic if at least one of its allowed wavevectors @xmath9 lies on the fermi surface , or in this case on one of the six points at which two bragg planes intersect . as is well known , this occurs only when the differences @xmath45 and @xmath46 are each a multiple of three . this implies that in any large set of physically distinct carbon nanotori , approximately one - ninth of the nanotori should be metallic . however , we see from table [ nhex18table ] that four out of the fourteen possible distinct spectral signatures are metallic . this is almost triple what would have been expected , implying that the fraction of spectrally distinct nanotori which are metallic is nearly triple the fraction of physically distinct nanotori which are metallic . in other words , the truncation from the four - parameter space of physically distinct nanotori to the three - parameter space of spectrally distinct nanotori is remarkably sensitive to the metallicity of the nanotori in question . one might argue that both of these effects the huge truncation in the number of distinct spectral signatures and the relative abundance of those which are metallic merely reflect the fact that we restricted our integers @xmath0 to lie within a fixed range bounded by @xmath122 , or that we took a relatively small value of @xmath39 . however , it is easy to demonstrate that the second of these effects is relatively insensitive to the choice of @xmath115 , and that the first of these effects only becomes even more dramatic as @xmath115 is increased . for example , if we restrict our attention to carbon nanotori with @xmath96 , we find that the number of physically distinct nanotori and the number of spectrally distinct nanotori both rise as a function of @xmath115 . however , we see from fig . [ panels ] ( left panel ) that the number of physically distinct nanotori with fixed @xmath39 grows as @xmath123 , as expected , while the number of spectrally distinct nanotori quickly hits a plateau ( right panel ) which remains flat for an increasingly long interval in @xmath115 before a new , hitherto - unrealizable spectral signature becomes possible and a new plateau develops . [ this growth in the number of physically distinct nanotori as a function of @xmath115 can easily be deduced from the observation that the number of quadruplets of integers @xmath0 grows as @xmath124 , while the corresponding number of attainable values of @xmath125 grows as @xmath123 . ] as a result , the number of physically distinct nanotori quickly outpaces the number of spectrally distinct nanotori . moreover , we see from fig . [ panels ] that the number of distinct metallic spectral signatures remains roughly one third ( and not one ninth ) the total number of distinct spectral signatures . we may also consider how these results vary with the choice of @xmath39 . this is shown in fig . [ nhexplot ] where , as functions of @xmath39 and for @xmath116 , we have plotted the number of spectrally distinct carbon nanotori as well as the number of those spectrally distinct carbon nanotori which are metallic . it is clear from these results that the numbers of spectrally distinct nanotori remain relatively small , even though they rise with @xmath39 , as expected . 3.4 truein 0.2truein 3.4 truein -0.1 truein 3.25 truein it is also easy to understand the jagged , oscillating nature of the results in fig . [ nhexplot ] . nanotori must have @xmath126 in order to be metallic , while they must have @xmath127 if they are rectangular , with @xmath128 . thus , one difference between tori with @xmath129 and those with @xmath130 is the existence of additional non - rectangular carbon nanotori with @xmath131 . however , it must also be borne in mind that a random selection of four integers @xmath0 is @xmath132 times more likely to result in an even value for @xmath133 than an odd one . as we see from fig . [ nhexplot ] , the combined effect from these two features is fairly significant . finally , another important implication of these spectral equivalences between physically distinct carbon nanotori concerns the traditional rules of thumb which allow us to determine whether a given carbon nanotorus is metallic , semiconducting , or insulating . throughout the existing literature on this topic , one finds what we shall call the `` rule of three '' : a given @xmath0 carbon nanotorus with @xmath134 will be metallic if both @xmath45 and @xmath46 are multiples of three , semiconducting if @xmath45 is multiple of three while @xmath46 is not , and insulating in all other cases . it is , of course , easy to verify that this characterization of a metallic nanotorus is modular invariant . specifically , if a given nanotorus has @xmath0 parameters which are metallic according to the rule of three , then all other nanotori to which it is spectrally equivalent will also have parameters which are metallic according to the rule of three . in other words , if @xmath45 and @xmath46 are both multiples of three , modular transformations of these parameters will not disturb this property . by contrast , the rule - of - three definition of semiconductors is _ not _ modular invariant even when we preserve the condition that @xmath135 . as a graphic illustration of this point , consider the @xmath136 torus . note that indeed @xmath135 for this torus . according to the standard rule of three , such a torus can be identified as a semi - conductor because @xmath45 is a multiple of three . by contrast , let us now consider the @xmath137 nanotorus . this torus also clearly has @xmath135 . however , because @xmath45 is not a multiple of three , we would expect this nanotorus to be an insulator . indeed , the rule of three tells us to expect this even though our first impression might be that the second nanotorus has larger radii in both directions , and therefore might have energy levels which are more closely spaced . however , even though these tori have very different physical parameters , it turns out that they are related through modular transformations and therefore have identical energy spectra . they therefore also have identical metallicity properties . this provides a graphic illustration that as a mathematical statement , the standard `` rule of three '' fails to characterize the conductivity properties of such nanotori because it is inconsistent with the modular transformations which reflect the additional symmetries of the compactified graphene sheet . in other words , the standard definition for a semiconducting carbon nanotorus fails to be modular invariant , and thus can not be complete as a description of the underlying conductivity properties of the nanotorus . this is yet another consequence of the fact that modular invariance in this context is an actual physical symmetry relating the spectra of physically distinct nanostructures . we close this section with an important comment . throughout this section , our goal has been to illustrate various mathematical ramifications of the modular symmetries which govern the spectra of different carbon nanotori . the specific examples we have provided throughout this section were therefore chosen for their mathematical simplicity as opposed to their phenomenological practicality . for example , we restricted our attention in this section to nanotori with relatively small values of @xmath39 , while realistic carbon nantoroi can be expected to have @xmath138 . likewise , realistic carbon nanotori will generally be quite long and thin , with quantities such as @xmath139 exceeding @xmath58 by an order of magnitude or more . however , all of the conclusions we have drawn in this section continue to hold even when more realistic tori are considered . as an example , let us restrict our attention to carbon nanotori with @xmath140 for which @xmath141 . the latter condition guarantees that our nanotorus remains relatively long and thin even if there are multiple windings of the hexagonal carbon lattice around the tube axis of the torus . taking @xmath142 , we find there are @xmath143 physically distinct nanotori which satisfy these conditions , but only @xmath144 of these are spectrally distinct . furthermore , of these @xmath144 spectral equivalence classes , @xmath119 correspond to metals . we see , then , that even for realistic nanotori , our modular symmetries continue to lead to large classes of spectrally equivalent nanotori and a relative overabundance of classes which are metallic . indeed , in the limit @xmath145 , it is straightforward to show that the number of physically distinct carbon nanotori in each spectral equivalence class also grows to infinity . with an eye towards potential implications of modular symmetries for the magnetic phenomena associated with twisted carbon nanotori @xcite , we now consider the introduction of magnetic fluxes . for full generality , we consider the possibility of _ two _ distinct fluxes : one which travels all the way around ( and through ) the length of the nanotube which forms the torus ; and another , namely the usual aharonov - bohm flux , which pierces the plane of the nanotorus , coming up through the donut hole . we shall denote these fluxes @xmath146 and @xmath147 respectively , as their associated vector potentials @xmath148 and @xmath149 lie parallel to the vectors @xmath30 and @xmath29 in fig . [ fig : torusparam ] , respectively . as is typical for such systems , we then find that we can incorporate the effects of these fluxes by keeping our previous band - structure energy function @xmath150 in eq . ( [ eq : bandstightbinding ] ) unchanged , and simply modifying our constraint equations for @xmath23 in eqs . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) and ( [ eq : torik ] ) so that the integers @xmath151 are shifted according to _ i _ i + _ i_0 where @xmath152 is the flux quantum and where _ 2 _ t + _ 1 _ 1 . note that it is the possible existence of a non - trivial twist angle @xmath35 which is responsible for the distinction between @xmath153 and @xmath147 . we then find that the resulting system continues to exhibit a spectral equivalence under the modular transformations in eqs . ( [ eq : stonindices ] ) and ( [ eq : stonvars ] ) as long as we allow @xmath154 to remain invariant under the @xmath56 transformation and to mix with each other under the @xmath55 transformation : s : . thus , a carbon nanotorus parametrized by @xmath155 will have the same spectral properties as one parametrized by @xmath156 , where these two sets of parameters are related through the modular transformations discussed above . in this paper , we have highlighted and investigated the implications of a geometric symmetry modular invariance which emerges upon the compactification of a graphene sheet to form a carbon nanotorus . although not traditionally considered in the carbon - nanotorus literature , modular invariance plays a critical role in describing the spectral properties of these nanotori and leads to spectral equivalences between physically distinct nanotori . as we have shown , this has profound implications for the classification of carbon nanotori , indicating that large numbers of seemingly unrelated nanotori are in fact completely identical in terms of their spectral properties . along the way , we also showed that the traditional `` rule of three '' classification rubric is incomplete , as it is based on quantities which are do not respect these spectral equivalences . we also found that the fraction of spectrally distinct carbon nanotori which are metals is approximately three times greater than would naively be expected on the basis of standard results in the literature . finally , we also showed that these spectral equivalences can easily be extended to cases in which non - trivial magnetic fluxes are present . the existence of these spectral symmetries also provides a deeper theoretical underpinning to certain results which already exist in the literature . for example , it is well known that many carbon nanotori exhibit persistent currents in the presence of a non - zero magnetic flux @xmath157 . as functions of @xmath158 , these currents typically follow complicated `` sawtooth '' patterns which have a natural periodicity under shifts @xmath159 . it has also separately been observed ( see , , ref . @xcite ) that any such sawtooth pattern is preserved but shifted horizontally upon the introduction of a nanotorus twist in which @xmath160 , where @xmath161 is chosen such that @xmath162 is also a lattice vector . indeed , when @xmath163 , the magnitude of this horizontal shift exactly matches the periodicity of the sawtooth pattern and the net result is unchanged . remarkably , this coincidence is now easy to understand from the point of view of modular transformations : when @xmath163 , the mapping from @xmath164 is nothing but the @xmath56 modular transformation , and as we have shown , modular transformations preserve the electrical properties of the torus , including its persistent currents . we thus see that the periodicity of the sawtooth pattern for persistent currents under shifts @xmath159 a periodicity which can be understood on elementary grounds having nothing to do with modular transformations can now also be interpreted as a spectral equivalence under the @xmath56 modular transformation . moreover , we now see that this is merely the tip of the iceberg , and that these sorts of spectral equivalences actually have a richer structure and context that not only corresponds to the entire modular group but also transcends the specific example of persistent currents . as we have discussed above , the traditional `` rule of three '' is not formulated in a modular - invariant way and is therefore incomplete as a description of the electronic properties of carbon nanotori . however , the full implications of these modular symmetries are significantly broader than just the rule of three : no theoretical result concerning the electronic properties of carbon nanotori can be correct unless it respects these modular symmetries . in other words , no calculation of any electronic property of a given carbon nanotorus in terms of its fundamental defining parameters @xmath0 can be correct unless it yields a result which is invariant under the modular transformations in eq . ( [ eq : stonindices ] ) . in this respect , modular invariance functions for carbon nanotori in much the same way as gauge invariance functions for electromagnetic systems : no theoretical result can be correct unless it can be phrased in terms of quantities which are invariant under the symmetry in question . of course , at a mathematical level , both modular invariance and gauge invariance rest on relatively simple algebraic identities . however , they both provide powerful organizing principles , and have significant physical manifestations and implications for the symmetry structures of the systems in which they appear . needless to say , several additional comments are in order . first , it should be noted that in this paper we have focused on what might called the `` ideal '' nanotorus . in particular , we have not accounted for the fact that the actual physical construction of such a torus in three - dimensional space requires that we introduce both an intrinsic and extrinsic curvature onto our otherwise flat graphene sheet . in this sense , the construction of a carbon nanotorus is different from that of a carbon nanotube ( in which only the extrinsic curvature is non - vanishing ) . the introduction of intrinsic curvature requires that we subject our underlying graphene sheet to considerable strain , deforming not only the positions of carbon atoms but also their relative spacings . these effects have been addressed by a number of authors , using a variety of different techniques @xcite . that said , these spectral equivalences should continue to hold , even in the presence of such deformations . there are several reasons for this . first , in the limit @xmath165 , all effects due to these deformations will be suppressed . however , this is precisely the limit in which nanotori can be constructed from purely hexagonal graphene sheets without the introduction of curvature - inducing pentagonal or heptagonal carbon rings . second , it can be shown that even when such strain is present , maximum toroidal stability occurs when this strain is uniformly distributed along the nanotorus @xcite , and this is precisely the situation in which the techniques of ref . @xcite can be used in order to mathematically rewrite the effects of such strain as arising due to a fictitious magnetic flux . as we have seen , the spectral equivalences we have found continue to exist even when such fluxes are introduced . but most importantly , while _ any _ deformations of the underlying graphene sheet can be expected to have effects on the corresponding band - structure energy function @xmath8 shown in fig . [ fig : energycontours ] , such deformations will not disturb the symmetries inherent in the constraint equations for @xmath166 derived in eqs . ( [ eq : tubek ] ) and ( [ eq : tubek2 ] ) . indeed , these equations reflect nothing more than the effects of toroidal compactification , and their structure leads directly to the modular symmetries inherent in eqs . ( [ eq : torik ] ) and ( [ eq : torik2 ] ) . thus , since these spectral equivalences ultimately stem from these symmetry properties , we are assured that any two tori related by modular transformations will sample the same set of wavevectors @xmath9 . such tori will therefore continue to be spectrally identical regardless of the function @xmath8 , provided the deformations to @xmath8 for the two tori are themselves identical . moreover , as we have argued above , even in cases where these deformations are not identical , they can at most differ by terms which are suppressed by factors of the presumably large nanotori radii . such differences can therefore be safely neglected . a similar conclusion also holds for thermal effects . it might seem , at first glance , that thermal effects could also destroy the spectral equivalences , since they too can have a dramatic effect on the band structure of the underlying graphene sheet @xcite . however , as noted above , these spectral equivalences are a consequence of the geometric symmetries that arise upon _ compactifying _ this sheet ; they are largely independent of the symmetries of the sheet itself . indeed , these modular symmetries exist for _ any _ choices of identification vectors @xmath30 and @xmath36 , even if those vectors are altered by other effects . therefore , as long as the temperature is sufficiently low that the electron coherence length exceeds both the inner and outer toroidal circumferences , the spectral equivalences we have been discussing should remain intact up to terms suppressed by the large nanotori radii . these comments notwithstanding , it still remains true that not all such nanotori are equally likely to appear in nature . in particular , those nanotori whose constructions implicitly involve large numbers of twists are likely to be rather difficult to construct or stablize , as the carbon atoms that constitute the underlying graphene sheet are likely to experience significant strain , leading to major deformations of the underlying carbon bond lengths and angles away from their ideal values . this is especially relevant , given that our statistical discussions in sect . iv implicitly assume that each of the relevant @xmath0 nanotori can appear with equal probability . at a mathematical level , it is difficult to draw a firm boundary between those carbon nanotori which are realizable in nature as _ bona - fide _ molecules and those which are not . however , in this paper we have restricted ourselves to statistical examinations of only those nanotori which already obey certain critical constraints . for example , we have limited ourselves to nanotori in which @xmath58 and @xmath59 are both significantly bigger than the carbon - carbon bond length @xmath7 . thus each twist experienced for the whole nanotorus has only a minor effect on the bond lengths and angles corresponding to each individual carbon atom . in addition , we have further limited ourselves to nanotori which also satisfy @xmath167 . this ensures that each such nanotorus can be realized in three - dimensional space , without the unphysical self - overlapping that would arise if this condition were not met . together , these conditions help to ensure that the strains induced by these modular transformations are not too severe . needless to say , there are many implications of these spectral equivalences which we have not yet explored . it would be interesting , for example , to consider the implications of these symmetries for the existence or absence of persistent currents as well as the existence or absence of colossal magnetic moments . this work is currently in progress . it would also be interesting to understand these modular transformations in terms of fictitious fluxes , using analogues of the techniques presented in ref . @xcite . first , as we have seen , modular invariance is the symmetry which underlies most of the results we have presented in this paper . at a mathematical level , modular invariance is normally just a relabelling symmetry in the sense that two sets of torus parameters related by a modular transformation normally correspond to the same physical torus . this is certainly the case in string theory , and in most other situations in theoretical high - energy physics in which modular transformations have played a significant role ( see , , ref . @xcite ) . however , the case of carbon nanotori is quite different . here , modular transformations relate parameters corresponding to carbon nanotori which are physically distinct . as we have discussed , this is because we are not merely rolling up an unmarked sheet of paper when we subject it to two non - parallel identifications ; we are rolling up a graphene sheet which already has a hexagonal carbon lattice imprinted on it . viewed from this perspective , it is therefore somewhat remarkable that modular transformations continue to play a role , indicating when two distinct nanotori will have the same spectral properties . indeed , in the case of carbon nanotori , we see that modular invariance is thus promoted from a mere relabeling symmetry to something far deeper : _ modular invariance becomes an outright physical symmetry between physically distinct entities_. we know of no other physical situation in which modular invariance plays such a role . second , it is also exciting at a practical level that physically distinct carbon nanotori can have identical energy spectra and electrical properties . since these nanotori are physically distinct , some are likely to be far more complicated to construct in the laboratory than others . nevertheless , these spectral equivalences suggest that it may not be necessary to fabricate a very complex nanotorus ( or generate sizable magnetic fluxes ) in order to obtain a desired spectral property ; there are likely to be far simpler nanotori and/or fluxes which can perform the same function . this could have significant implications for the production and use of such nano - materials . this work was supported in part by the department of energy under grant de - fg02 - 04er-41298 . we are happy to thank p. mceuen , d. ralph , c. stafford , and h. tye for discussions , and we wish to acknowledge the hospitality of the kavli institute for theoretical physics ( kitp ) in santa barbara , california , where this paper was completed . the opinions and conclusions expressed here are those of the authors , and do not represent either the department of energy or the national science foundation . m. terrones , w. k. hsu , j. p. hare , h. w. kroto , h. terrones , and d. r. m. walton , phil . a * 354 * , 2025 ( 1996 ) ; h. r. she , r. martel , and p. avouris , phys . * 84 * , 4441 ( 2000 ) ; m. sano , a. kamino , j. okamura , and s. shinkai , science * 293 * , 1299 ( 2001 ) ; h. watanabe , c. manabe , t. shigematsu , and m. shimizu , appl . phys . lett . * 78 * , 2928 ( 2001 ) . m. f. lin , r. b. chen , and f. l. shyu , solid state commun . 107 , 227 ( 1998 ) ; a. a. odintsov , w. smit , and h. yoshioka , europhys . lett . * 45 * ( 5 ) , 598 ( 1999 ) ; k. sasaki , phys . b * 65 * , 155429 ( 2002 ) ; s. latil , s. roche , and a. rubio , phys . rev . b * 67 * , 165420 ( 2003 ) ; z. zhang , z. yang , x. wang , j. yuan , h. zhang , m. qiu , and j. peng , j. phys . condens . matter * 17 * , 4111 ( 2005 ) ; c. feng and k. m. liew , carbon * 47 * , 1664 ( 2009 ) .
Abstract: | [
"recently there has been considerable interest in the properties of carbon nanotori . such nanotori can be parametrized according to their radii , their chiralities , and the twists that occur upon joining opposite ends of the nanotubes from which they are derived . in this paper , however , we demonstrate that many physically distinct nanotori with wildly different parameters nevertheless share identical band structures , energy spectra , and electrical conductivities . this occurs as a result of certain geometric symmetries known as modular symmetries which are direct consequences of the properties of the compactified graphene sheet . using these symmetries , we show that there is a dramatic reduction in the number of spectrally distinct carbon nanotori compared with the number of physically distinct carbon nanotori . the existence of these modular symmetries also allows us to demonstrate that many statements in the literature concerning the electronic properties of nanotori are incomplete because they fail to respect the spectral equivalences that follow from these symmetries . we also find that as a result of these modular symmetries , the fraction of spectrally distinct nanotori which are metallic is approximately three times greater than would naively be expected on the basis of standard results in the literature . finally , we demonstrate that these modular symmetries also extend to cases in which our carbon nanotori enclose non - zero magnetic fluxes . .7ex .7ex = cmss10 = cmss10 at 7pt epsf"
] | 9,095 | 9,095 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: it is well known that primordial black holes ( pbhs ) could have formed in the early universe @xcite . a comparison of the cosmological density at any time after the big bang with the density associated with a black hole shows that pbhs would have of order the particle horizon mass at their formation epoch : m(t ) 10 ^ 15(t10 ^ - 23 s ) g. pbhs could thus span an enormous mass range : those formed at the planck time ( @xmath1s ) would have the planck mass ( @xmath2 g ) , whereas those formed at 1 s would be as large as @xmath3 , comparable to the mass of the holes thought to reside in galactic nuclei . pbhs would could arise in various ways @xcite . since the early universe is unlikely to have been exactly friedmann , they would form most naturally from initial inhomogeneities but they might also form through other mechanisms at a cosmological phase transition . the realization that small pbhs might exist prompted hawking to study their quantum properties . this led to his famous discovery @xcite that black holes radiate thermally with a temperature t = c^38gmk 10 ^ 26 ( mg)^-1 k 10 ^ -7 ( m)^-1 k. this means that they evaporate on a timescale ( m ) 10 ^ 64 ( m)^3 . only black holes smaller than @xmath4 g would have evaporated by the present epoch , so eqn ( 1 ) implies that this effect could be important only for black holes which formed before @xmath5s . despite the conceptual importance of this result , it is bad news for pbh enthusiasts . for since pbhs with a mass of @xmath4 g , which evaporate at the present epoch , would have a temperature of order 100 mev , the observational limit on the @xmath6-ray background intensity at 100 mev immediately implies that their density could not exceed @xmath7 times the critical density @xcite . not only does this render pbhs unlikely dark matter candidates , it also implies that there is little chance of detecting black hole explosions at the present epoch @xcite . despite this conclusion , pbh evaporations could still have interesting cosmological consequences . in particular , they might generate the microwave background @xcite or modify the standard cosmological nucleosynthesis scenario @xcite or contribute to the cosmic baryon asymmetry @xcite . pbh evaporations might also account for the annihilation - line radiation coming from the galactic centre @xcite or the unexpectedly high fraction of antiprotons in cosmic rays @xcite . pbh explosions occurring in an interstellar magnetic field might also lead to radio bursts @xcite . even if pbhs had none of these consequences , studying such effects leads to strong upper limits on how many of them could ever have formed and thereby constrains models of the early universe . indeed pbhs serve as a probe of times much earlier than that associated with most other relicts " of the big bang . while photons decoupled at @xmath8y , neutrinos at @xmath9 s and wimps at @xmath10s , pbhs go all the way back to the planck time . therefore even if pbhs never formed , their non - existence gives interesting information . we review the formation mechanisms and evaporation constraints on pbhs in section 2 . much of this material is also contained in my contribution to the 1996 chalonge school @xcite . however , there have been several interesting developments since then and these are covered in section 3 . the remaining sections will examine how the pbh constraints are modified if the value of the gravitational constant " @xmath0 was different at early times . as reviewed in section 4 , this idea has a long history and should no longer be regarded as exotic . it arises in various scalar - tensor theories of gravity and these are a natural setting for many currently popular models of the early universe . black hole formation and evaporation could be greatly modified in variable-@xmath0 cosmologies , since many of their properties ( eg . their hawking temperature ) depend explicitly on @xmath0 . however , as emphasized by barrow @xcite and discussed in section 5 , the nature of the modification depends upon whether the pbh preserves the value of @xmath0 at its formation epoch ( corresponding to what is termed `` gravitational memory '' ) or always maintains the changing background value . there would be interesting modifications to the cosmological consequences of pbh evaporations in both cases but they would be more dramatic in the first . barrow & carr @xcite considered the implications of these two scenarios in detail and this work has been taken further with goymer @xcite . we will review the conclusions of these papers in section 6 and highlight a particularly interesting development in section 7 . one of the most important reasons for studying pbhs is that it enables one to place limits on the spectrum of density fluctuations in the early universe . this is because , if the pbhs form directly from density perturbations , the fraction of regions undergoing collapse at any epoch is determined by the root - mean - square amplitude @xmath11 of the fluctuations entering the horizon at that epoch and the equation of state @xmath12 . one usually expects a radiation equation of state ( @xmath13 ) in the early universe . in order to collapse against the pressure , an overdense region must be larger than the jeans length at maximum expansion and this is just @xmath14 times the horizon size . on the other hand , it can not be larger than the horizon size , else it would form a separate closed universe and not be part of our universe @xcite . this has two important implications . firstly , pbhs forming at time @xmath15 should have of order the horizon mass given by eqn ( 1 ) . secondly , for a region destined to collapse to a pbh , one requires the fractional overdensity at the horizon epoch , @xmath16 , to exceed @xmath6 . providing the density fluctuations have a gaussian distribution and are spherically symmetric , one can infer that the fraction of regions of mass @xmath17 which collapse is @xcite ( m ) ~(m ) where @xmath18 is the value of @xmath11 when the horizon mass is @xmath17 . the pbhs can have an extended mass spectrum only if the fluctuations are scale - invariant ( i.e. with @xmath11 independent of @xmath17 ) but this is expected in many scenarios . the fluctuations required to make the pbhs may either be primordial or they may arise spontaneously at some epoch . one natural source of fluctuations would be inflation @xcite and , in this context , @xmath19 depends implicitly on the inflationary potential . pbhs formed before inflation would be drastically diluted but new ones could form from the fluctuations generated after inflation . many people have studied pbh formation in this context @xcite as an important way of constraining the inflationary potential . this was the focus of my 1996 erice lecture , so it will not be covered again here . note that the gaussian assumption has been questioned in the inflationary context @xcite , so eqn ( 4 ) may not apply , but one still finds that @xmath20 depends very sensitively on @xmath11 . in some situations eqn ( 4 ) would fail qualitatively . for example , pbhs would form more easily if the equation of state of the universe were ever soft ( @xmath211 ) . this might apply if there was a phase transition which channelled the mass of the universe into non - relativistic particles or which temporally reduced the pressure . in this case , only those regions which are sufficiently spherically symmetric at maximum expansion can undergo collapse ; the dependence of @xmath20 on @xmath11 would then have the form @xcite = 0.02 ^ 13/2 , which is much weaker than indicated by eqn ( 4 ) , but there would still be a unique relationship between the two parameters . some formation mechanisms for pbhs do not depend on having primordial fluctuations at all . for example , at any spontaneously broken symmetry epoch , pbhs might form through the collisions of bubbles of broken symmetry @xcite . pbhs might also form spontaneously through the collapse of cosmic strings @xcite or domain walls @xcite . in these cases @xmath22 depends , not on @xmath19 , but on other cosmological parameters , such the bubble formation rate or the string mass - per - length . these mechanisms were discussed in more detail in my 1996 erice contribution @xcite . in all these scenarios , the current density parameter @xmath23 associated with pbhs which form at a redshift @xmath24 or time @xmath15 is related to @xmath20 by @xcite _ r(1+z ) 10 ^ 6 ( ts)^-1/2 10 ^ 18(m10 ^ 15g)^-1/2 where @xmath25 is the density parameter of the microwave background and we have used eqn ( 1 ) . the @xmath26 factor arises because the radiation density scales as @xmath27 , whereas the pbh density scales as @xmath28 . any limit on @xmath23 therefore places a constraint on @xmath22 and the constraints are summarized in fig . 1 . the constraint for non - evaporating mass ranges above @xmath4 g comes from requiring @xmath29 . stronger constraints are associated with pbhs smaller than this since they would have evaporated by now @xcite . the strongest one is the @xmath6-ray limit associated with the @xmath4 g pbhs evaporating at the present epoch @xcite . other ones are associated with the generation of entropy and modifications to the cosmological production of light elements . the constraints below @xmath30 g are based on the ( not necessarily secure ) assumption that evaporating pbhs leave stable planck mass relics , in which case these relics are required to have less than the critical density @xcite . the constraints on @xmath22 can be converted into constraints on @xmath19 using eqn ( 4 ) and these are shown in fig . 2 . also shown here are the ( non - pbh ) constraints associated with the spectral distortions in the cosmic microwave background induced by the dissipation of intermediate scale density perturbations and the cobe quadrupole measurement , as well as lines corresponding to various slopes in the @xmath18 relationship . this shows that one needs the fluctuation amplitude to decrease with increasing scale in order to produce pbhs . [ f1 ] [ f2 ] recent hydrodynamical calculations for the @xmath31 case have refined the criterion @xmath32 for pbh formation and this modifies the estimate for @xmath22 given by eqn ( 4 ) . niemeyer & jedamzik @xcite find that one needs @xmath33 rather than @xmath34 to ensure pbh formation , and shibata & sasaki @xcite reach similar conclusions . they also find that there is little accretion after pbh formation , as expected theoretically @xcite . another interesting development has been the application of critical phenomena " to pbh formation . studies of the collapse of various types of spherically symmetric matter fields have shown that there is always a critical solution which separates those configurations which form a black hole from those which disperse to an asymptotically flat state . the configurations are described by some index @xmath35 and , as the critical index @xmath36 is approached , the black hole mass is found to scale as @xmath37 for some exponent @xmath38 . this effect was first discovered for scalar fields @xcite but subsequently demonstrated for radiation @xcite and then more general fluids with equation of state @xmath39 @xcite . in all these studies the spacetime was assumed to be asymptotically flat . however , niemeyer & jedamzik @xcite have recently applied the same idea to study black hole formation in asymptotically friedmann models and have found similar results . for a variety of initial density perturbation profiles , they find that the relationship between the pbh mass and the the horizon - scale density perturbation has the form m = k m_h(- _ c)^ where @xmath40 is the horizon mass and the constants are in the range @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 for the various configurations . since @xmath44 as @xmath45 , this suggests that pbhs may be much smaller than the particle horizon at formation ( although it is clear that a fluid description must break down if they are too small ) and it also modifies the mass spectrum @xcite . there has been particular interest recently in whether pbhs could have formed at the quark - hadron phase transition at @xmath2s . this is because the horizon mass is of order @xmath46 then , so such pbhs would naturally have the sort of mass required to explain the macho microlensing results @xcite . this is discussed in more detail in my other lecture at this meeting . one might expect pbhs to form more easily at that epoch because of a temporary softening of the equation of state . if the qcd phase transition is assumed to be of 1st order , then hydrodynamical calculations show that the value of @xmath16 required for pbh formation is indeed reduced below the value which pertains in the radiation case @xcite . this means that pbh formation will be strongly enhanced at the qcd epoch , with the mass distribution being peaked around the horizon mass . one of the interesting implications of the pbh macho scenario is the possible existence of a halo population of _ binary _ black holes @xcite . with a full halo of such objects , there could then be @xmath47 binaries inside 50 kpc and some of these could be coalescing due to gravitational radiation losses at the present epoch @xcite . current interferometers ( such as ligo ) could detect such coalescences within 50 mpc , corresponding to a few events per year . future space - borne interferometers ( such as lisa ) might detect 100 coalescences per year . if the associated gravitational waves were detected , it would provide a unique probe of the halo distribution ( eg . its density profile and core radius @xcite . kohri & yokoyama @xcite have recently improved the constraints on @xmath48 which come from cosmological nucleosynthesis considerations . constraints from neutrino background have also been presented by bugaev & konischev @xcite . the recent detection of a galactic @xmath6-ray background @xcite , measurements of the antiproton flux @xcite , and the discovery of very short period @xmath6-ray burts @xcite may even provide positive evidence for such pbhs . this is discussed in detail elsewhere @xcite . some people have emphasized the possibility of detecting very high energy cosmic rays from pbhs using air shower techniques @xcite . however , recently these efforts have been set back by the claim of heckler @xcite that qed interactions could produce an optically thick photosphere once the black hole temperature exceeds @xmath49 gev . in this case , the mean photon energy is reduced to @xmath50 , which is well below @xmath51 , so the number of high energy photons is much reduced . he has proposed that a similar effect may operate at even lower temperatures due to qcd effects @xcite . this is discussed further in the contribution of kapusta at this meeting @xcite . however , these arguments should not be regarded as definitive : macgibbon @xcite claim that heckler has not included lorentz factors correctly in going from the black hole frame to the centre - of - mass frame of the interacting particles ; in their calculation qed interactions are never important . most variable - g scenarios associate the gravitational `` constant '' with some form of scalar field @xmath52 . this notion has its roots in kaluza - klein theory , in which a scalar field appears in the metric component @xmath53 associated with the 5th dimension . einstein - maxwell theory then requires that this field be related to @xmath0 @xcite . although this was assumed constant in the original kaluza - klein theory , dirac @xcite noted the the ratio of the electric to gravitational force between to protons ( @xmath54 ) and the ratio of the age of the universe to the atomic timescale ( @xmath55 ) and the square - root of the number of particles in the universe ( @xmath56 ) are all comparable and of order @xmath57 . this unlikely coincidence led him to propose that these relationships must _ always _ apply , which requires g t^-1 , gm / r ~1 , where @xmath58 is the horizon scale . the first condition led jordan @xcite to propose a theory in which the scalar field in kaluza - klein theory is a function of _ both _ space and time , and this then implies that @xmath59 has the same property . the second condition implies the mach - type relationship @xmath60 , which suggests @xcite that @xmath52 is a solution of the wave equation @xmath61 . this motivated brans - dicke ( bd ) theory @xcite , in which the einstein - hilbert lagrangian is replaced by l = r - _ , _ , g^ + l_m , where @xmath62 is the matter langrangian and the constant @xmath63 is the bd parameter . the potential @xmath52 then satisfies = ( ) t , where @xmath64 is the trace of the matter stress - energy tensor , and this has the required machian form . since @xmath52 must have a contribution from _ local _ sources of the form @xmath65 , this entails a violation of the strong equivalence principle . in order to test this , the ppn formalism was introduced . applications of this test in a variety of astrophysical situations ( involving the solar system , the binary pulsar and white dwarf cooling ) currently require @xmath66 , which implies that the deviations from general relativity can only ever be small in bd theory @xcite . the introduction of generalized scalar - tensor theories @xcite , in which @xmath63 is itself a function of @xmath52 , led to a considerably broader range of variable-@xmath0 theories . in particular , it permitted the possibility that @xmath63 may have been small at early times ( allowing noticeable variations of @xmath0 then ) even if it is large today . in the last decade interest in such theories has been revitalized as a result of early universe studies . inflation theory @xcite has made the introduction of scalar fields almost mandatory and extended inflation specifically requires a model in which @xmath0 varies @xcite . in higher dimensional kaluza - klein - type cosmologies , the variation in the sizes of the extra dimensions also naturally leads to a variation in @xmath0 @xcite . the currently popular low energy string cosmologies necessarily involve a scalar ( dilaton ) field @xcite and bosonic superstring theory , in particular , leads @xcite to a lagrangian of the form ( 9 ) with @xmath67 . the intimate connection between dilatons , inflatons and scalar - tensor theory arises because one can always transform from the ( physical ) jordan frame to the einstein frame , in which the lagrangian has the standard einstein - hilbert form @xcite l = |r - 2_,_,|g^ + l_m . here the new scalar field @xmath68 is defined by d= ( ) ^1/2 and the barred ( einstein ) metric and gravitational constant are related to the original ( jordan ) ones by g _ = a()^2 |g_,g = [ 1+^2 ( ) ] a()^2 |g , a/a , where the function @xmath69 specifies a conformal transformation and a prime denotes @xmath70 . thus scalar - tensor theory can be related to general relativity plus a scalar field , although the theories are not identical because particles do not follow geodesics in the einstein frame . the behaviour of homogeneous cosmological models in bd theory is well understood @xcite . their crucial feature is that they are vacuum - dominated at early times but always tend towards the general relativistic solution during the radiation - dominated era . this is a consequence of the fact that the radiation energy - momentum tensor is trace - free [ i.e. @xmath71 in eqn ( 10 ) ] . this means that the full radiation solution can be approximated by joining a bd vacuum solution to a general relativistic radiation solution at some time @xmath72 , which may be regarded as a free parameter of the theory . however , when the matter density becomes greater than the radiation density at @xmath73s , the equation of state becomes that of dust @xmath74 and @xmath0 begins to vary again . for a @xmath75 model , one can show that in the three eras @xcite g = g_0 ( t_0/t_e)^n , a t^(2-n)/3 ( t > t_e ) g = g_e g_0 ( t_0/t_e)^n , a t^1/2 ( t_1<t < t_e ) g = g_e ( t / t_1)^-(n + ) /2 , a t^(2 - n - ) /6 ( t < t_1 ) where @xmath76 is the value of @xmath0 at the current time @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath79 . since the bd coupling constant is constrained by @xmath66 , which implies @xmath80 , eqns ( 14 ) to ( 16 ) imply that the deviations from general relativity are never large if the value of @xmath81 is always the same . however , as we now explain , it is also interesting to consider bd models in which @xmath81 and @xmath63 can vary and thus violate the current constraints . the behaviour of cosmological models in more general scalar - tensor theories depends on the form of @xmath82 but they still retain the feature that the general relativistic solution is a late - time attractor during the radiation era . since one requires @xmath83 to @xmath84 at the epoch of primordial nucleosynthesis @xcite , one needs the vacuum - dominated phase to end at some time @xmath85 1 s. the theory approaches general relativity in the weak field limit only if @xmath86 and @xmath87 but @xmath82 is otherwise unconstrained . barrow & carr consider a toy model in which 2 + 3 = 2(1-/_c)^- where @xmath88 and @xmath20 are constants . this leads to 2 + 3 t^-/(2- ) , /^3 t^(1 - 2)/(1- ) ( t < t_v ) , so one requires @xmath89 in order to have @xmath86 and @xmath90 as @xmath91 . in the @xmath92 case , one finds g t^-2/(3- ) , a t^(1-)/(3- ) , ( t < t_v ) . during the vacuum - dominated era , such models can therefore be regarded as bd solutions in which @xmath63 is determined by the parameter @xmath20 and unconstrained by any limits on @xmath63 at the present epoch . after @xmath93 , @xmath0 is constant and one has the standard radiation - dominated or dust - dominated behaviour . the consequences of the cosmological variation of @xmath0 for pbh evaporation depend upon how the value of @xmath0 near the black hole evolves . barrow @xcite introduces two possibilities : in scenario a , @xmath0 everywhere maintains the background cosmological value ( so @xmath52 is homogeneous ) ; in scenario b , it preserves the value it had at the formation epoch near the black hole even though it evolves at large distances ( so @xmath52 becomes inhomogeneous ) . on the assumption that a pbh of mass @xmath17 has a temperature and mass - loss rate t = ( 8gm)^-1 , - ( gm)^-2 , with @xmath94 in scenario a and @xmath95 in scenario b , barrow & carr calculate the evaporation time @xmath96 for various values of the parameters @xmath81 and @xmath72 in bd theory @xcite . the results are shown in fig . 3(a ) for scenario a and fig . 3(b ) for scenario b. here @xmath97 is the mass of a pbh evaporating at the present epoch , @xmath98 is the mass of a pbh evaporating at time @xmath99 and @xmath100 is the mass of a pbh evaporating at the present epoch in the standard ( constant @xmath0 ) scenario . in scenario a with @xmath101 , there is a maximum mass of a pbh which can ever evaporate and this is denoted by @xmath102 . the results for the scalar - tensor with @xmath82 given by eqn ( 17 ) with @xmath103 are shown in fig . 3(c ) for scenario b with various values of the parameters @xmath104 and @xmath93 . the corresponding modifications to the constraints on @xmath22 in all three cases are shown in fig . 3(d ) , which should be compared to fig . 1 . barrow & carr considered both scenarios a and b but did not attempt decide which was more plausible . in this section we address this question more carefully . the main argument for scenario a comes from an important result of hawking @xcite . he showed that in bd theory , providing the weak energy condition holds , the gradient of @xmath52 must be zero everywhere for stationary , asymptotically flat black holes . this means that such black holes are identical to those in general relativity . this result can be generalized to all scalar - tensor theories and suggests that such theories are in agreement with the `` no - hair '' theorem . numerical calculations support this theorem @xcite . collapse is accompanied by outgoing scalar gravitational radiation , which radiates away the scalar mass until the black hole settles down to the schwarzschild form with a constant scalar field . in particular , harada et al . @xcite have investigated oppenheimer - snyder collapse in which a ball of dust described by a @xmath105 friedmann interior and a schwarzschild exterior collapses to a black hole . in these calculations the scalar field is taken to be constant before the collapse and its back - reaction on the metric is assumed to be always negligible . it is found that , as the collapse proceeds , a scalar gravitational wave propagates outwards before the scalar field settles down to being constant again . it should be stressed that the scalar no hair theorem has only been proved for asymptotically flat spacetimes , so it is not clear that it also applies in the asymptotically friedmann case . while the no hair theorem suggests that @xmath52 should tend to a _ locally _ constant value ( close to the black hole ) , it is not obvious that this needs to be the asymptotic cosmological value . indeed , since the homogeneizing of @xmath52 is only ensured by scalar wave emission , one might infer that this can only be achieved on scales less than the particle horizon . one way to determine what happens is to seek a precise mathematical model for a black hole in a cosmological background . for example , one can try to match a black hole and cosmological solution over some boundary @xmath106 . such a matching is provided in general relativity by the einstein - straus or swiss cheese " model @xcite . here a friedmann exterior is matched with a general spherically symmetric interior . if there is no scalar field , it turns out that the latter has to be the static schwarzschild solution but the situation may be more complicated in the present context due to the presence of scalar gravitational radiation . in general one can show that the following continuity conditions must apply at @xmath106 : = 0 , = [ g _ u^ n^ ] = 0 , = 0 , = 0 where @xmath107 and @xmath108 are 4-vectors normal and tangent to @xmath106 , respectively @xcite . unfortunately , it turns out that an einstein - straus type solution does not exist in bd theory . this is because the only way to satisfy the junction conditions ( 21 ) is if @xmath52 is spatially and temporally constant , which is just the general relativistic case . jacobsen @xcite has addressed the problem analytically by looking for a spherically symmetric solution which represents a perturbation of the schwarzschild solution near the origin but is asymptotically friedmann at large distances , with @xmath52 satisfying the appropriate cosmological conditions . he presupposes that the black hole event horizon is much smaller than the particle horizon , so that the cosmological timescale is much longer than the black hole timescale . in this case , he finds that there is little lag between the value of @xmath52 at the event horizon and particle horizon , which suggests that memory can only be weak . however , it must be emphasized that this conclusion need not follow if the black hole has a size _ comparable _ to the particle horizon at formation and , as indicated in section 2 , this is expected for a pbh . another way to investigate the problem is to study the collapse of dust in a tolman - bondi background using the same approximation employed by harada et al . @xcite , i.e. neglecting the back reaction of the scalar field , but requiring that @xmath52 have the required cosmological time - dependence at large distances . one puts in an initial density perturbation for the dust but assumes that @xmath52 is initially homogeneous . our preliminary numerical calculations @xcite use the characteristic method to determine the evolution of the scalar field perturbation along null and constant - time hypersurfaces . we find that @xmath52 does initially build up near the centre but it then gets smoothed out , tending eventually to homogeneity . although this suggests that there is no gravitational memory , it should be stressed that this conclusion only applies for dust and if one neglects the back reaction . since we lack definite knowledge about the evolution of the scalar field when a black hole forms in a cosmological background , it is useful to consider a range of scenarios which go beyond the two possibilities envisaged by barrow . in general , the background scalar field will have a present value @xmath109 and a value @xmath110 when the black hole first formed . however , it is likely to develop inhomogeneties for at least some intervening period . in the following discussion , we will characterize the degree of gravitational memory by comparing the value of the scalar field at the black hole event horizon ( @xmath111 ) and the cosmological particle horizon ( @xmath112 ) . we first consider the two extreme situations described by barrow @xcite : scenarioa : _ eh(t ) = _ ph(t ) for all t a schwarzschild black hole forms at time @xmath113 with its event horizon radius being @xmath114 . if @xmath115 evolves with time , then the black hole adjusts quasi - statically through a sequence of schwarzschild states approximated by @xmath116 , see fig . 4(a ) . in this scenario there is no gravitational memory . scenario b : _ eh(t ) = _ eh(t_f ) for all t a schwarzschild black hole of size @xmath117 forms at time @xmath113 and , while @xmath115 equals the evolving background value beyond some scale - length @xmath118 , it remains constant within @xmath119 , see fig . 4(b ) . in this case the black hole size is determined by @xmath120 even at the present epoch and this means that the region @xmath121 has a memory of the gravitational `` constant '' at the time of its formation . .2 in neither of these scenarios can be completely realistic since they both assume that @xmath52 is homogeneous almost everywhere . however , even if @xmath52 were homogeneous initially , one would expect it to become inhomogeneous as collapse proceeds . indeed , in the dust case , this is confirmed by the numerical calculations described above @xcite . therefore , if the background value is increasing ( as usually applies ) , one would expect @xmath52 in the collapsing region to become first _ larger _ than the background value on a local dynamical timescale and then _ smaller _ than it on a cosmological timescale . such behaviour would necessarily entail a variation of @xmath52 in space as well as time . we must also allow for the possibility that @xmath52 may vary interior to @xmath119 but on a slower or faster timescale than the background . we therefore propose two further scenarios : .2 in scenarioc : |_eh(t)| |_ph(t)| for all t where the dot represents a time derivative . this implies that the scalar field evolves faster at the event horizon than at the particle horizon until it eventually becomes homogeneous , see fig . we describe this as _ short - term _ gravitational memory and it reduces to scenario a as the timescale to become homogeneous tends to zero . this would apply , for example , if @xmath52 were to change on the dynamical timescales of the black hole since this is usually less than the cosmological timescale . scenario d : [ beta ] |_eh(t)| < |_ph(t)| for all t this implies that @xmath52 evolves faster at the particle horizon than the event horizon , see fig . we describe this is as _ weak _ gravitational memory and it reduces to scenario b when the left - hand - side of eqn ( [ beta ] ) is zero . in this case , the evolution of @xmath52 is again dominated by the black hole inside some length - scale @xmath119 . note that , in either this scenario or the last one , the length - scale @xmath119 need not be fixed , since it could either grow or shrink as scalar gravitational radiation propagates . a particular example of this , to which we return shortly , would be _ self - similar _ gravitational memory , in which the ratio of @xmath111 to @xmath112 always remains the same . .2 in [ f4 ] in general relativity there is an equivalence between a scalar field and a stiff fluid and this can be exploited in studying gravitational memory . in the einstein frame , the energy momentum tensor for a perfect fluid is |t _ = ( + p)u _ u _ + |g _ p where @xmath122 is the velocity of the fluid . if we define a velocity field by [ fvel ] u _ = , this gives |t _ = - + p |g_. by comparing this to the energy - momentum tensor for a scalar field , we find that p = = - |g^ | _ | _ , so we have a stiff fluid . this equivalence applies provided that the derivative of the scalar field is timelike . otherwise the velocity field defined in ( [ fvel ] ) would be imaginary . this is relevant to the gravitational memory problem because we can now interpret the various scenarios discussed in section 6 in terms of the _ accretion _ of a stiff fluid . if the black hole does not accrete at all or accretes very little , this will correspond to strong or weak gravitational memory ( scenarios b and d , respectively ) . however , if enough accretion occurs to homogenize @xmath52 , this will correspond to short - term gravitational memory ( scenario c ) . the faster the accretion , the shorter the memory , so scenario a corresponds to the idealization in which homogenization is instantaneous . a simple newtonian treatment @xcite for a general fluid suggests that the accretion rate in the einstein frame should be = 4r^2_a v_s , where @xmath123 is the accretion radius and @xmath124 is the sound - speed in the accreted fluid . for a stiff fluid , @xmath125 and @xmath126 , while @xmath127 in a friedmann universe at early times , so we have . this can be integrated to give [ mass ] m where @xmath128 is the black hole mass at the time @xmath113 when it formed . if we define a parameter @xmath129 , then eqn ( [ mass ] ) implies mm_f(1 - ) ^-1 as t. if @xmath130 , the black hole could not grow very much . however , if @xmath38 is close to 1 , which must be the case if @xmath131 , then the black hole could grow significantly . in particular , in the limit @xmath132 , eqn ( [ mass ] ) implies @xmath133 , so the black hole grows at the same rate as the universe . this simple calculation suggests that a black hole surrounded by a stiff fluid can accrete enough to grow at the same rate as the universe . since the above calculation neglects the effects of the cosmological expansion , one needs a relativistic calculation to check this . the newtonian result suggests that one should look for a spherically symmetric _ self - similar _ solution , in which every dimensionless variable is a function of @xmath134 , so that it is unchanged by the transformation @xmath135 for any constant @xmath136 . this problem has an interesting but rather convolved history . by looking for a black hole solution attached to an exact friedmann solution via a sonic point , carr & hawking first showed that there is no such solution for a radiation fluid @xcite and the argument can be extended to a general @xmath39 fluid with @xmath137 . lin et al . @xcite subsequently claimed that there is such a solution in the special case @xmath138 . however , bicknell & henriksen @xcite then showed that this solution is unphysical , in that the density gradient diverges at the event horizon . this suggests that the black hole must soon become much smaller than the particle horizon , after which eqn ( 32 ) implies there will be very little further accretion . therefore the stiff fluid analysis suggests that there should be at least _ weak _ gravitational memory . we have seen that studying the formation and evaporation of pbhs can place interesting constraints on models of the early universe even if they never existed . on the other hand , if they did exist , pbhs can provide unique information about times much earlier than those probed by any other relics of the big bang . in particular , they may provide information about the variation of @xmath0 at early times . the precise signature of such a variation depends upon the degree to which a black hole can remember " the value of @xmath0 at its formation epoch . this is still unclear but various methods are being pursued to resolve this issue . zeldovich and i.d . novikov , sov . 10 ( 1967 ) , 602 . s.w . hawking , mnras 152 ( 1971 ) , 75 . carr , in _ observational and theoretical aspects of relativistic astrophysics and cosmology _ , ed . j.l.sanz & l.j.goicoechea ( world scientific , 1985 ) p 1 . s.w . hawking , nature 248 ( 1974 ) , 30 . d.n.page and s.w . hawking , ap.j . 206 ( 1976 ) , 1 . n.a . porter and t.c . weekes , nature 277 ( 1979 ) 199 . zeldovich and a.a . starobinsky , jetp lett . 24 ( 1976 ) 571 . novikov , a.g . polnarev , a.a . starobinsky and ya.b . zeldovich , astron.astrophys . 80 ( 1979 ) 104 . barrow , mnras 192 ( 1980 ) 427 . okeke and m.j . rees , astron.astrophys . 81 ( 1980 ) 263 . p. kiraly et al . , nature 293 ( 1981 ) 120 . rees , nature 266 ( 1977 ) 333 . carr , in _ current topics in astrofundamental physics _ n.sanchez & a. zichichi ( world scientific , 1997 ) , p 306 . j. d. barrow , phys . d. 46 ( 1992 ) , r3227 . j. d. barrow and b. j. carr , phys . d. 54 ( 1996 ) , 3920 . c. goymer and b. j. carr , preprint ( 1999 ) . b. j. carr and s. w. hawking , mnras 168 ( 1974 ) , 399 . carr , ap.j . 201 ( 1975 ) , 1 . khlopov , b.e . malomed and ya.b . zeldovich , mnras 215 ( 1985 ) , 575 . naselsky and a.g . polnarev , sov.astron . 29 ( 1985 ) , 487 . b.j . carr and j.e . lidsey , phys.rev.d . 48 ( 1993 ) , 543 . carr , j.h.gilbert and j.e . lidsey , phys.rev.d . 50 ( 1994 ) , 4853 . p. ivanov , p. naselsky and i. novikov , phys.rev.d . 50 ( 1994 ) , 7173 . j. garcia - bellido , a. linde and d. wands , phys.rev.d . 54 ( 1997 ) , 6040 . a.m. green & a.r . liddle , phys.rev.d . 56 ( 1997 ) 6166 ; 60 ( 1999 ) , 0635616 . l. randall , m. soljacic and a.h . guth , nuc . b. 472 ( 1996 ) , 377 . j. yokoyama , astron . 318 ( 1997 ) , 673 . bassett and s. tsujikawa , preprint ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/0008328 . a.m. green and k.a . malik , preprint ( 2000 ) ; hep - ph/0008113 . bullock and j.r . primack , phys.rev.d . 55 ( 1997 ) , 7423 . p. ivanov , phys . d. 57 ( 1998 ) , 7145 . m.yu . khlopov and a.g . polnarev , phys.lett.b . 97 ( 1980 ) , 383 . m. crawford and d.n . schramm , nature 298 ( 1982 ) , 538 . s.w . hawking , i. moss and j. stewart , phys.rev.d . , 26 ( 1982 ) , 2681 . d. la and p.j.steinhardt , phys.lett.b . 220 ( 1989 ) , 375 . polnarev and r. zemboricz , phys.rev.d . 43 ( 1988 ) , 1106 . s.w . hawking , b. 231 ( 1989 ) , 237 . j. garriga and m. sakellariadou , phys.rev.d . 48 ( 1993 ) , 2502 . r. caldwell and p. casper , phys . 53 ( 1996 ) , 3002 . macgibbon , r.h . brandenberger and u.f . wichoski , phys . d. 57 ( 1998 ) , 2158 . rubin , m.yu . khlopov and a.s . sakharov , grav . supp . 6 ( 2000 ) , 1 . carr , ap.j . 206 ( 1976 ) , 8 . macgibbon and b.j . carr , ap.j . 371 ( 1991 ) , 447 . macgibbon , phys . rev.d . 44 ( 1991 ) , 376 . macgibbon and b.r . webber , phys.rev.d . 41 ( 1990 ) , 3052 . macgibbon , nature 329 ( 1987 ) , 308 . barrow , e.j . copeland and a.r . liddle , phys.rev.d . 46 ( 1992 ) , 645 . dolgov , p.d . naselsky and i.d . novikov , preprint ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/0009407 . j. niemeyer and k. jedamzik , phys.rev.d . 59 ( 1999 ) , 124013 . m. shibata and m. sasaki , phys.rev.d . ( 1999 ) ( in press ) ; gr - qc/9905064 . choptuik , phys . 70 ( 1993 ) , 9 . c. r. evans and j. s. coleman , phys . 72 ( 1994 ) , 1782 . d. maison , phys . lett b 366 ( 1996 ) , 82 . t. koike , t. hara and s. adachi , phys . d 59 ( 1999 ) , 104008 . j. niemeyer and k. jedamzik , phys.rev.lett . 80 ( 1998 ) , 5481 . h. kim , preprint ( 1999 ) . a.m. green and a.r . liddle , phys . d. 60 ( 1999 ) , 063509 . k. jedamzik , phys.rev.d . 55 ( 1997 ) , r5871 ; phys . 307 ( 1998 ) , 155 . k. jedamzik and j. niemeyer , phys.rev.d . 59 ( 1999 ) , 124014 . t. nakamura , m. sasaki , t. tanaka and k. thorn , astrophys.j . 487 ( 1997 ) , l139 . k. ioka , t. tanaka and t. nakamura et al . d. 60 ( 1999 ) , 083512 . k. ioka , astrophys.j . ( 1999 ) ( in press ) . k. kohri and j. yokoyama , preprint ( 1999 ) . bugaev and k.v . konischev , preprint ( 2000 ) ; astro - ph/0005295 . wright , ap.j . 459 ( 1996 ) , 487 . k. maki , t. mitsui and s. orito , phys.rev.lett . 76 ( 1996 ) , 3474 . d.b.cline , d.a . sanders and w. hong , ap.j . 486 ( 1997 ) , 169 . carr , phys . 307 ( 1998 ) 141 . coyne , c. sinnis & r. somerville , in _ proceedings of the houston advanced research center conference on black holes _ ( 1992 ) . f. halzen , e. zas , j. macgibbon , & t.c.weekes , nature 298 ( 1991 ) 538 . a. heckler , phys . 55 ( 1997 ) 840 . a. heckler , phys . b. 231 ( 1997 ) 3430 . j. kapusta , this volume ( 2001 ) . macgibbon , b.j . carr and d.n . page ( 2000 ) . t. kaluza , sitz.d.preuss.akad.d.wiss.physik-mat.klasse ( 1921 ) , 966 . p.a.m.dirac , proc . a165 ( 1938 ) , 199 . p. jordan , _ schwerkraft und weltall _ , vieweg ( braunschweig , 1955 ) . d. sciama , mnras 113 ( 1957 ) , 34 . c. brans and r. h. dicke , phys . 124 ( 1961 ) , 925 . will , _ theory and experiment in gravitational physics _ ( cambridge , 1993 ) . bergmann , int.j.theor.phys . 1 ( 1968 ) r.v.wagoner , phys.rev.d.1 ( 1970 ) , 3209 . k. nordtvedt , astrophys . j. 161 ( 1970 ) , 1059 , a. guth , phys . rev . d. 23 ( 1981 ) , 347 . p.g.o.freund , nuc . b. 209 ( 1982 ) , 146 . k. maeda , class . grav . 3 ( 1986 ) , 233 . kolb , m.j.perry and t.p.walker , phys.rev.d . 33 ( 1986 ) , 869 . callan et al . , nuc . b. 262 ( 1985 ) 597 . t. damour and a.m. polyakov , nuc.phys.b 423 ( 1994 ) 532 . p.j . steinhardt and f.s . accetta , phys . 64 ( 1990 ) 2740 . barrow and p. parsons , phys . d , 55 , 1906 ( 1997 ) . s. w. hawking , commun . phys . 25 ( 1972 ) , 167 . m. a. scheel , s. l. shapiro and s. a. teukolsky , phys . rev . d. 51 ( 1995 ) , 4208 . m. a. scheel , s. l. shapiro and s. a. teukolsky , phys . d. 51 ( 1995 ) , 4236 . j. kerimo and d. kalligas , phys . d. 58 ( 1998 ) 104002 . t. harada , t , chiba , k. nakao and t. nakamura , phys . d. 55 ( 1997 ) , 2024 . a. einstein and e. g. straus , rev . 17 ( 1945 ) , 120 . c. b. g. mcintosh , phys . 43a(1973 ) , 33 . t. jacobsen , phys . 83 ( 1999 ) , 2699 . t. harada , b.j . carr and c.a . goymer , preprint ( 2000 ) . d. n. c. lin , b. j. carr and s. m. fall , mnras 177 ( 1976 ) , 51 . g. v. bicknell and r. n. henriksen , ap . j. 219 ( 1978 ) , 1043 .
Abstract: | [
"we discuss recent developments in the study of primordial black holes , focussing particularly on their formation and quantum evaporation . such studies can place important constraints on models of the early universe . an especially interesting development has been the realization that such constraints may be severely modified if the value of the gravitational constant \" @xmath0 varies with cosmological epoch , a possibility which arises in many scenarios for the early universe . the nature of the modification depends upon whether the value of @xmath0 near a black hole maintains the value it had at its formation epoch ( corresponding to gravitational memory ) or whether it tracks the background cosmological value . this is still uncertain but we discuss various approaches which might help to resolve the issue ."
] | 8,190 | 8,190 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the influence of aperiodic ( dis-)order on the thermodynamic properties and the critical behaviour of spin systems has been an active research area , particularly since the discovery of quasicrystals in 1984 . in view of the many articles existing , we can not give proper credit to all contributors ; instead , we would like to refer the reader to a recent review @xcite which contains a rather complete bibliography on this subject . for ferromagnetic ising systems , heuristic scaling arguments , put forward by luck @xcite , lead to qualitative predictions on the relevance of disorder implemented through an aperiodic variation of the coupling constants which go beyond the original relevance - irrelevance criterion of harris @xcite . for the ising quantum chain ( iqc ) , or the equivalent 2@xmath2 classical ising model @xcite with layered disorder , this relevance criterion reads as follows : the critical behaviour is of onsager - type as long as the fluctuations in the sequence of coupling constants are bounded , whereas for unbounded fluctuations the critical singularities resemble those of the randomly disordered case . this behaviour had first been conjectured by tracy @xcite on ths basis of his results for two different examples of three - letter substitution rules . of particular interest is the marginal case with logarithmically ( in the system size ) diverging fluctuations . here , the critical exponents are predicted to depend continuously on the coupling constants @xcite . meanwhile , some exact results were obtained for substitution chains with marginal fluctuations of the couplings . for a number of substitution chains , the surface magnetisation critical exponent could be calculated @xcite ; and , recently , the correlation length critical exponent was derived for two special substitution rules using an exact renormalisation approach @xcite . all these results are in accordance with luck s predictions . the real space renormalisation method we use in this article is based on the decimation process introduced in ref . our setup is quite different , though ; and in particular we are going to show how _ arbitrary _ substitution rules can be analysed in terms of @xmath3-matrices and their star - product formalism . in this way , the dependence of the critical behaviour on the nature of the fluctuations can be derived explicitly . the analysis is carried out in detail for two - letter substitution chains , with the result that luck s relevance criterion emerges from the renormalisation relations in a natural way . an extended renormalisation scheme for the most general case of @xmath4-letter substitution rules is presented in an appendix and discussed for certain examples . for infinite classes of substitution chains with marginal fluctuations , including the two - letter chains , an analytic expression for the correlation length critical exponent is given . this article is organised as follows . in sec . 2 , we give a brief outline of the model , including some introductory remarks on substitution rules and on properties of the corresponding substitution sequences . then , in sec . 3 , we introduce the renormalisation transformation for a restricted class of @xmath4-letter substitution chains , comprising all two - letter substitution chains . the dependence of the renormalisation flow on the fluctuations of the couplings is shown and the consequences are discussed in detail . subsequently , in sec . 4 , we summarise the implications of our results for the critical properties of the iqc for the three different types of fluctuations in the sequence of the coupling constants . our conclusions and an outlook on future developments are presented in sec . the paper contains two appendices related to the content of sec . 3 : in appendix a , the solution of the eigenvalue problem for the case of a two - letter substitution sequence is derived ; and finally , generalising the discussion of sec . 3 , the renormalisation transformation for arbitrary @xmath4-letter substitution rules is explained in appendix b. the iqc in a transverse magnetic field is defined by the hamiltonian @xmath5 acting on the tensor - product space @xmath6 . here , the @xmath7 denote the transverse fields at the sites . the @xmath8 are site - dependent coupling constants , and the operators @xmath9 denote pauli s matrices acting on the @xmath10th site . in what follows , we consider closed chains with _ periodic _ boundary conditions which are defined by @xmath11 ; various other kinds of boundary conditions can be chosen without changing the key results . for a general set of coupling constants @xmath8 and fields @xmath7 , the iqc can be written as a free - fermion model via a jordan - wigner transformation and can then be diagonalised by a bogoljubov - valatin transformation , resulting in @xcite @xmath12 where @xmath13 , @xmath14 are @xmath15 fermionic creation and annihilation operators and @xmath16 is some constant . the dimensionless excitation energies @xmath17 ( which can be chosen to be positive and ordered , i.e. , @xmath18 , while properly adjusting the constant @xmath16 ) satisfy the linear difference equations @xmath19 normally , one proceeds by eliminating either @xmath20 or @xmath21 . in this way , the problem of diagonalising the @xmath22 matrix @xmath23 can be reduced to the diagonalisation of an @xmath24 matrix . from the set of @xmath15 eigenvalues ( fermion frequencies ) @xmath25 of the latter , the total spectrum of the complete hamiltonian @xmath23 is recovered by considering the sums of the elements of any of its @xmath26 subsets . for periodic boundary conditions , the situation is in fact a little more complicated ; in order to avoid the appearance of a non - local number operator in the fermionic hamiltonian one has to consider so - called _ mixed sector _ hamiltonians . these are obtained by combining the _ even _ sector ( with respect to the operator @xmath27 that commutes with @xmath28 ) of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : qc ] ) with _ periodic _ boundary conditions with the _ odd _ sector of the same hamiltonian with _ antiperiodic _ boundary conditions ( defined by @xmath29 ) , and vice versa @xcite . the iqc is equivalent to the 2@xmath2 classical ising model with a layered modulation of the interactions @xcite . the correspondence shows up through an extremely anisotropic limit ( also called the @xmath30-continuum limit @xcite ) of the coupling constants of the latter , which is believed not to alter the critical behaviour . explicitly , one establishes the following relations : the _ temperature _ @xmath31 of the classical model corresponds to the _ transverse field _ @xmath32 of the quantum chain , the _ free energy _ translates into the _ ground - state energy _ and the counterpart of the _ correlation length @xmath33 parallel _ to the layers is the _ inverse mass gap _ @xmath34 of the iqc . in our setting , the mass gap is just given by the modulus of the smallest fermionic excitation @xmath35 of ( [ ffh ] ) . according to finite - size scaling , we thus expect a scaling behaviour of @xmath35 at the critical point as @xmath36 provided the correlation length scales with a power law at all . hereby , the scaling exponent @xmath37 translates into the correlation length critical exponent @xmath38 parallel to the layers in terminology of the 2@xmath2 statistical system , while @xmath39 retains its unperturbed onsager value @xmath40 . the hamiltonian ( [ eq : qc ] ) is _ critical _ ( in the sense that the energy gap in the excitation spectrum vanishes , i.e. , @xmath41 ) in the thermodynamic limit if the _ geometric mean _ ( rather than the arithmetic mean ) of the couplings , normalised by the variables of the transverse field , is equal to one , i.e. , @xmath42 compare ref . the repetitive structure of the substitution sequences we are going to consider guarantees that the mean is well - defined @xcite . let us now assume that the coupling constants @xmath43 ( @xmath44 ) are chosen from a set of @xmath4 possible values @xmath45 ( @xmath46 ) , the value @xmath45 occuring with a frequency @xmath47 ( where @xmath48 ) . for simplicity , we take the field to be constant , i.e. , @xmath49 . then , condition ( [ eq : critcond ] ) can be fulfilled by choosing @xmath4 positive real numbers @xmath50 with @xmath51 , and setting the couplings to @xmath52 where @xmath53 . unless stated otherwise , this parametrisation of the critical surface will be used in the sequel . let us now consider coupling constants @xmath8 drawn from a set of values @xmath54 , where the label @xmath55 runs over the letters of a ( finite ) @xmath4-letter alphabet @xmath56 . we choose the couplings @xmath8 according to sequences generated by iterated application of a substitution rule @xmath57 on @xmath56 . for the introduction of the concept and some notation , consider a simple example on a two - letter alphabet @xmath58 : @xmath59 we start with an initial word , e.g. @xmath60 , and define @xmath61 . @xmath62 denotes the corresponding substitution matrix ( whose elements count the number of letters @xmath63 and @xmath64 in the words @xmath65 and @xmath66 ) , which has the eigenvalues @xmath67 . the entries of the , statistically normalised , ( right ) eigenvector @xmath68 , corresponding to the perron - frobenius eigenvalue @xmath69 , give the frequencies of the letters in the limit word @xmath70 . in order to ensure that , starting from any seed , the letter frequencies converge to unique , positive values in the limit chain , we restrict ourselves to _ primitive _ substitution rules @xmath71 throughout this paper . for the corresponding substitution matrices @xmath72 , this means that the entries of @xmath73 are _ strictly positive _ for any integer @xmath74 ( and a suitably chosen finite @xmath75 ) . this is obviously true for the examples ( [ eq : sub ] ) . associated to a word @xmath76 of length ( i.e. , number of letters ) @xmath77 , one obtains finite ( closed ) quantum chains with @xmath15 sites by setting @xmath78 whenever the @xmath10th letter of the word @xmath76 is an @xmath63 , and @xmath79 otherwise , the final letter of @xmath76 determining the coupling between the last and the first spin in the chain . while @xmath80 , the largest eigenvalue of the substitution matrix , describes the asymptotic scaling of the chain length with the number of iterations @xmath81 , @xmath82 , the _ fluctuation _ behaviour of the exchange couplings is connected to the second - largest eigenvalue @xmath83 ( where it is the _ modulus _ of the eigenvalue that matters , hence by `` second - largest eigenvalue '' we always refer to the eigenvalue with the second - largest absolute value ) . in order to quantify the fluctuations , let us define @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the average coupling in the limit chain . fluctuations stay _ bounded _ as long as @xmath86 , but for @xmath87 they grow with iterated substitutions as a power of the chain length , @xmath88 , governed by the so - called _ wandering exponent _ @xmath89 that is given by @xmath90 in the limiting case @xmath91 , @xmath92 stays constant when we prolong the chain by complete iteration steps . generically , however , finite fluctuations within the substitutes @xmath93 of the letters @xmath94 will increase the total fluctuation in the vicinity of these points by a certain amount @xmath95 : @xmath96 for some word @xmath97 with @xmath98 and fixed @xmath99 . by repeated use of this argument , we thus expect fluctuations that _ diverge logarithmically _ with the length of the chain ( since the length grows exponentially with the number of iterations ) , see also ref . @xcite . on the other hand , the same argument also shows that , in this case , the fluctuation behaviour is not completely determined by the _ substitution matrix _ , but may also depend on the details of the actual _ substitution rule _ @xcite ; and for special choices the fluctuations may still stay bounded even though the second - largest eigenvalue is @xmath91 . coming back to our examples ( [ eq : sub ] ) , let us concentrate on the three cases @xmath100 ( which yields the famous _ fibonacci sequence _ ) , @xmath101 ( the _ period - doubling sequence _ ) , and @xmath102 ( the _ binary non - pisot sequence _ ) . as the second - largest eigenvalues of the substitution matrices @xmath62 fulfill @xmath103 , @xmath104 , and @xmath105 , this includes an example of bounded fluctuations ( @xmath100 ) , a marginal case with logarithmically divergent fluctuations ( @xmath101 ) and an example of strong fluctuations ( @xmath102 ) , hence all three interesting cases are illustrated @xcite . another substitution chain that is referred to several times in the text is the celebrated _ thue - morse sequence _ @xmath106 rather than reducing the set of linear equations ( [ fermeq ] ) to @xmath15 dimensions , we proceed ( as does ref . @xcite ) with a direct treatment as a @xmath107-dimensional eigenvalue problem of the real symmetric matrix @xmath108{$h_{\scriptscriptstyle n-1}^{}$ } & 0&\makebox[0pt]{$\varepsilon_{\scriptscriptstyle n-1}^{}$}&0\\ 0&0&\cdots&0&0&\makebox[0pt]{$\varepsilon_{\scriptscriptstyle n-1}^{}$ } & 0&h_n^{}\\ \varepsilon_n^{}&0&\cdots&0&0&0&h_n^{}&0 \end{array}\right)\ ; .\ ] ] since @xmath109 is symmetric and bipartite after an appropriate reordering of the basis . ] , the eigenvalues occur in real pairs of opposite sign . but changing the sign of an eigenvalue simply means interchanging the corresponding creation and annihilation operators in eq . ( [ ffh ] ) , thus we can restrict ourselves to the positive part of the spectrum . in what follows , we concentrate on the case of a constant field @xmath110 , where we may set @xmath111 by an appropriate choice of the energy scale . of course , one can not possibly expect analytical results for an arbitrary sequence of couplings . however , for _ substitution _ sequences , more can be said using an exact renormalisation scheme , and , for an interesting class of chains with marginal fluctuations , the scaling exponent @xmath37 ( [ eq : scal ] ) can be determined exactly and given in a closed form . consider now sequences of couplings chosen according to a substitution rule @xmath112 on an @xmath4-letter alphabet @xmath113 . here , the @xmath114 are @xmath4 arbitrary words of finite length in the alphabet @xmath56 . indeed , for the case of _ aperiodic two - letter _ substitution chains , this form imposes no restriction at all , since these can all be generated by substitution rules of the form ( [ subs ] ) . to see this , note that any two - letter substitution rule @xmath115 can be transformed appropriately by inner automorphisms , i.e. , by replacing @xmath116 [ where a natural choice of the word @xmath117 is the common beginning , if any , of the words @xmath118 and @xmath119 , and/or by considering @xmath120 instead . obviously , this does not alter the limit chain . note that this is not possible for certain _ periodic _ chains , namely those which are generated by a substitution rule that replaces all letters by the same word ( the period ) , or by a multiple of it . it is no problem , however , to treat this case separately . the eigenvalue problem for the matrix @xmath109 ( [ fh ] ) can be reformulated using transfer matrices in the usual way . our renormalisation transformation ( rt ) is , however , most conveniently described in terms of the star - product formalism , borrowed from scattering theory @xcite . we therefore introduce new @xmath3-transfer matrices , called @xmath3-matrices from now on , by @xmath121 with @xmath122 where the star - product ( ) of two @xmath123 matrices is defined as @xmath124 in our case , according to eq . ( [ fh ] ) , the elementary @xmath3-matrices are @xmath125 - \varepsilon_{j+1}^{-1 } h & \varepsilon_{j+1}^{-1 } \lambda \end{array } \right ) \ ; , \ ] ] where @xmath126 denotes an eigenvalue may be _ any _ eigenvalue of @xmath109 . only later , after expanding the renormalisation equations in powers of @xmath126 [ eq . ( [ hren ] ) and below ] , we shall restrict ourselves to eigenvalues that vanish in the limit of an infinite system size . ] of @xmath109 . in order to establish the renormalisation scheme , we introduce a number of additional parameters for these @xmath3-matrices . for each letter @xmath127 , we define two asymmetry - coefficients @xmath128 and a field variable @xmath129 that enter the @xmath130 different elementary @xmath3-matrices through ) and ( [ fh ] ) in that the field variables are now labeled in the same way as the coupling constants ( i.e. , as the bonds ) rather then by the sites of the chain . ] @xmath131 the rt now just _ reverses _ the substitution steps . in our framework , this is simply done by building -products of the @xmath3-transfer matrices that correspond to the words @xmath114 given by the substitution rule ( [ subs ] ) . schematically , this works in the following fashion @xmath132 \cdots & \mbox{\large { \mbox{\boldmath $ a_i^{}$ } } } & \mbox{\large { \mbox{\boldmath $ a_j^{}$ } } } & \mbox{\large { \mbox{\boldmath $ a_k^{}$ } } } & \cdots \\ & \multicolumn{3}{c } { \begin{picture}(50,30)(0,0 ) \thicklines \put ( 0,20){\oval(100,35)[br ] } \put ( 50,20){\vector(0,1){5 } } \end{picture } \hphantom{\mbox{\large $ a$ } } \begin{picture}(116,30)(0,0 ) \thicklines \put ( 0,20){\line(0,1){5 } } \put ( 58,20){\oval(116,35)[b ] } \put(116,20){\vector(0,1){5 } } \put ( 58,15){\makebox[0pt]{\large $ \tilde{s}_{a_i^{}|a_j^{}}$ } } \end{picture } \hphantom{\mbox{\large $ a$ } } \begin{picture}(116,30)(0,0 ) \thicklines \put ( 0,20){\line(0,1){5 } } \put ( 58,20){\oval(116,35)[b ] } \put(116,20){\vector(0,1){5 } } \put ( 58,15){\makebox[0pt]{\large $ \tilde{s}_{a_j^{}|a_k^{}}$ } } \end{picture } \hphantom{\mbox{\large $ a$ } } \begin{picture}(50,30)(0,0 ) \thicklines \put ( 0,20){\line(0,1){5 } } \put ( 50,20){\oval(100,35)[bl ] } \end{picture } } & \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath133 denotes the @xmath134th letter of the word @xmath114 . in this way , we obtain renormalised @xmath3-matrices @xmath135 - \varepsilon_{a_j}^{-1 } \tilde{h}_{a_i } & \varepsilon_{a_j}^{-1 } \tilde{\kappa}_{a_i}^-\tilde{\lambda } \end{array } \right ) \ ; , \ ] ] compare eq . ( [ sj ] ) . as an _ additional condition _ on the rt , and in accordance with their initial values , we keep the product of the @xmath136 asymmetry - coefficients @xmath137 fixed : @xmath138 now , the rt for the different parameters can be read off directly from the -product relations . explicitly , we obtain the following recursion relations @xmath139[r]{$\displaystyle h^{(1)}_{a_i}$ } = \makebox[10ex][l]{$\displaystyle h_{a_i}^ { } \ ; , $ } \qquad \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle h^{(k+1)}_{a_i}$ } = \makebox[25ex][l]{$\displaystyle \frac{-\varepsilon_{w_i^k } h_{w_i^k } h^{(k)}_{a_i } } { \varepsilon_{w_i^k}^2 -\lambda_{w_i^k+}^ { } \lambda_{a_i-}^{(k)}}\ ; , $ } \qquad \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\tilde{h}_{a_i}^{}$ } = \makebox[15ex][l]{$\displaystyle h^{(|w_i|+1)}_{a_i}\ ; ; $ } & \\[1 mm ] \label{rg2 } & \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i-}^{(1)}$ } = \makebox[10ex][l]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i-}^{}\ ; , $ } \qquad \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i-}^{(k+1)}$ } = \makebox[25ex][l]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{w_i^k-}^ { } + \frac{h_{w_i^k}^2\lambda_{a_i-}^{(k ) } } { \varepsilon_{w_i^k}^2 - \lambda_{w_i^k+}^ { } \lambda_{a_i-}^{(k)}}\ ; , $ } \qquad \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\tilde{\lambda}_{a_i-}^{}$ } = \makebox[15ex][l]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i-}^{(|w_i|+1)}\ ; ; $ } & \\[1 mm ] \label{rg3 } & \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i+}^{(1)}$ } = \makebox[10ex][l]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i+}^{}\ ; , $ } \qquad \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i+}^{(k+1)}$ } = \makebox[25ex][l]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i+}^{(k ) } + \frac{\lambda_{w_i^k+}^ { } \left[h^{(k)}_{a_i}\right]^2 } { \varepsilon_{w_i^k}^2 - \lambda_{w_i^k+}^ { } \lambda_{a_i-}^{(k)}}\ ; , $ } \qquad \makebox [ 5ex][r]{$\displaystyle\tilde{\lambda}_{a_i+}^{}$ } = \makebox[15ex][l]{$\displaystyle\lambda_{a_i+}^{(|w_i|+1)}\ ; ; $ } & \end{aligned}\ ] ] for the field variables @xmath140 and for @xmath141 that are defined as @xmath142 using eq . ( [ kappacond ] ) , we obtain the renormalised fermion frequencies @xmath143 as @xmath144 note the following properties of our renormalisation approach : * the rt is _ exact _ , since no new parameters are introduced in a renormalisation step . altogether , there are @xmath145 parameters for @xmath4 different couplings : effectively @xmath146 asymmetry - parameters @xmath147 , the @xmath4 fields @xmath129 , and the eigenvalue @xmath126 . note that _ the coupling constants are not renormalised _ in our scheme . * the rescaling factor of the system size is just given by the leading eigenvalue @xmath80 of the substitution matrix corresponding to the substitution rule under consideration . * the critical point of the model , defined by the vanishing of the mass gap ( @xmath148 ) , corresponds to a fixed point of the rt for @xmath126 , as can easily be seen from eqs . ( [ rg2 ] ) and ( [ rg3 ] ) . * the scaling behaviour in the vicinity of the critical point is governed by the leading - order term of the rt as @xmath149 . we now proceed to establish the rt of the spectrum to leading order for @xmath150 explicitly . this is most easily done by noting that , in the product ( [ sren ] ) , the common prefactors @xmath151 of the -products ( [ star ] ) gives rise to higher - order corrections only ; and therefore , for the present purpose , the denominator can be neglected completely . consider first the renormalisation of the field variables . we obtain @xmath152 instead of working directly with the rt for the fields , it is advantageous to consider new variables @xmath153 to linear order in @xmath126 , the rt of @xmath154 then yields the simple matrix form @xmath155 where @xmath156 is just the _ transpose _ of the substitution matrix of @xmath71 . now , take a look at the initial conditions @xmath157}$ ] for @xmath158 which are @xmath159 } = - 2\log \varepsilon_{a_i}$ ] . as stated above , the entries of the ( statistically normalised ) perron - frobenius eigenvector @xmath68 are the asymptotic letter frequencies @xmath160 . we thus obtain @xmath161 = 0\ ] ] for an _ arbitrary _ set of couplings fulfilling the criticality condition ( [ eq : critcond ] ) . hence , @xmath157}$ ] is nothing but an arbitrary ( real ) linear combination of the ( right ) eigenvectors of @xmath156 ( hence of the _ left _ eigenvectors of @xmath162 ) _ excluding _ the perron - frobenius one . thus , for a generic choice of critical couplings , it scales with the second - largest eigenvalue , @xmath163}\| \sim |\lambda_2|^k$ ] , under the iteration @xmath164}={\mbox{\boldmath $ m$}}_{\varrho}^t { { \mbox{\boldmath $ y$}}}^{[k]}$ ] . translated into the terminology of the renormalisation group , we recognise @xmath158 as a _ scaling field _ transforming according to @xmath165 where the corresponding _ renormalisation group eigenvalue _ is just the wandering exponent @xmath89 defined in eq . ( [ beta ] ) . this demonstrates explicitly that power law , logarithmic , or bounded fluctuations lead to relevant , marginal , or irrelevant scaling fields , respectively . we are going to describe below how this affects the critical behaviour . we now proceed to the rt for @xmath166 . defining @xmath167 \prod_{\ell = 1}^{|w_i| } \frac{h_{w_i^\ell}^2}{\varepsilon_{w_i^\ell}^2 } \ ; , \end{aligned}\ ] ] we find , by induction , as the linear part of the rt of @xmath166 @xmath168 setting @xmath169 , this can also be written in a matrix form @xmath170 since all the components of the matrices @xmath171 and of the vectors @xmath172 are positive , the vectors converge to the perron - frobenius eigenvectors of @xmath171 under iteration of the rt . let @xmath173 denote the perron - frobenius eigenvalues of @xmath171 . from eq . ( [ kappacond2 ] ) , we conclude that @xmath174 for further convenience , we transform @xmath175 ( under conservation of the spectrum ) according to @xmath176 with a diagonal transformation matrix @xmath177 . as new entries , we find , dropping the index @xmath31 , @xmath178 this form shows explicitly that , to linear order in @xmath126 , only the _ reduced couplings _ @xmath179 enter in the rt . finally , since the rescaling factor of the chain length is the largest eigenvalue @xmath80 of the substitution matrix , we formally obtain the scaling exponent @xmath37 through @xmath180 let us now look at the different cases of fluctuation behaviour in more detail . because @xmath181 is perpendicular to the perron - frobenius eigenvector of the substitution matrix , and since all other eigenvalues are smaller than one in modulus , we find @xmath163}\|\to 0 $ ] for all substitution chains with bounded fluctuations , hence @xmath182 . evaluating the transformation matrices @xmath171 at this fixed point of the fields , we obtain from eqs . ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) @xmath183 and hence @xmath184 thus we have @xmath185 for substitution chains with bounded fluctuations , and the low - energy spectrum at criticality scales as @xmath186 hereby , the @xmath126-transformation induces a finite renormalisation of the _ fermion velocity _ @xmath187 in comparison to the uniform chain @xmath188}/\lambda}\ ] ] where @xmath189}$ ] is the image of @xmath190}=\lambda$ ] after a @xmath134-fold application of the rt . in general , all renormalisation steps contribute in eq . ( [ vren ] ) . however , if _ all _ eigenvalues of the substitution matrix but the perron - frobenius one are zero , the fixed point of the rt is already reached after the first renormalisation step and @xmath187 is obtained immediately . this is shown below for periodic chains , but also allows to calculate the fermion velocity of the thue - morse and related chains . using the equidistribution property of quasiperiodic _ cut - and - project _ chains , like our first example ( [ eq : sub ] ) with @xmath100 ( the fibonacci sequence ) , the limit in eq . ( [ vren ] ) can be carried through explicitly for these cases , too . since this has already been done in ref . @xcite , we do not repeat the arguments here , and merely cite the result @xmath191 for two couplings parametrised as in eq . ( [ eq : para ] ) . in this short part , we briefly show how the known results for the fermion velocity @xmath187 for _ periodic _ quantum chains can be recovered easily within our renormalisation scheme . by a substitution rule of the form @xmath192 _ any _ periodic chain with period @xmath193 can be generated . in this simple situation , we can take all the fields @xmath194 and asymmetry - parameters @xmath195 to be equal . by virtue of the criticality condition ( [ eq : critcond ] ) , the reduced couplings transform as @xmath196 [ see eq . ( [ hren ] ) ] , and we obtain the ( fermionic ) hamiltonian of a _ uniform _ chain ( @xmath197 ) after a single renormalisation step . note that the additional asymmetry - parameters result in an irrelevant similarity transformation of the matrix ( [ fh ] ) only . the renormalisation factor for @xmath126 can be deduced from eqs . ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) , explicitly it reads ( using eq . ( [ eq : critcond ] ) , and normalising to @xmath198 ) : @xmath199 \label{v } & = & \sum_{k=1}^{|w|}\sum_{l=1}^{|w| } \varepsilon_k^2 \cdots \varepsilon_{k+l-1({\rm mod}\,|w|)}^2 \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath200 . the critical scaling of the fermion frequencies now results in @xmath201 where @xmath187 is given in eq . ( [ v ] ) , and where the well - known scaling behaviour of the uniform chain is recovered for @xmath202 . this result was first derived in the context of the 2@xmath2 classical ising model with layered periodicity in ref . @xcite . in general , there is no closed expression for the fermion velocity @xmath187 . for the special case of a uniform chain of @xmath203-couplings with periodic @xmath204-defects on every @xmath81th site , we derive @xmath205}{\sinh [ \log ( r)]/m } \ ; .\ ] ] note that @xmath206 for @xmath207 ( simple periodic chain ) , but also @xmath208 for @xmath209 since the parametrisation ( [ eq : para ] ) implies that @xmath210 in this limit . we now consider the case where the second - largest eigenvalue(s ) of the substitution matrix ( and of its transpose ) have @xmath211 . let @xmath212 denote the corresponding @xmath81-dimensional ( joined ) eigenspace of @xmath213 , where @xmath214 . by eqs . ( [ y1 ] ) and ( [ y2 ] ) , @xmath215}$ ] converges to the projection of @xmath216}$ ] on @xmath212 under iteration of the rt . the critical surface being @xmath217-dimensional , we can parametrise @xmath218}$ ] in the renormalisation limit as @xmath219 with @xmath81 vectors @xmath220 that span @xmath212 and coefficients @xmath221 , @xmath222 . this implies @xmath223 and , if the vector components @xmath224 are chosen as integers , the entries of the matrices @xmath171 are polynomials with positive coefficients of @xmath81 parameters @xmath225 . if all @xmath226 are equal to 1 , we obviously obtain @xmath227 furthermore , if @xmath215}$ ] converges to an eigenvector of @xmath213 to the eigenvalue @xmath228 , @xmath175 and @xmath229 are related by @xmath230 to obtain the scaling exponent @xmath37 from eq . ( [ zz ] ) , we need to know the perron - frobenius eigenvalues @xmath173 of @xmath171 . there is no explicit solution to that problem in the general case . in what follows , we present the complete answers for a number of more special , yet infinite , classes of substitution rules . let @xmath231 be any word from the alphabet , and @xmath232 its @xmath134th cyclic permutation . consider now a substitution rule @xmath71 of the form ( [ subs ] ) with @xmath233^{l_i } \ ; .\ ] ] one special case is to take equal words @xmath234 for all @xmath235 . the corresponding substitution matrices indeed have @xmath236 as their second - largest eigenvalue , with degeneracy @xmath237 , since the column vectors of @xmath238 differ by scalar factors only . thus the fields stay at their original values and are not renormalised at all . to derive @xmath173 as a function of the parameters @xmath239 , we simply note that the special form of @xmath71 transforms this property to @xmath171 , not just for the point @xmath240 , but _ independently _ of the parameters . we thus obtain @xmath241 and the scaling exponent is given by @xmath242 where the @xmath243 are given in eqs . ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) as functions of the couplings . since @xmath173 are polynomials of the parameters @xmath244 with only positive coefficients , and @xmath245 , we conclude @xmath246 . as a function of the parameters , @xmath37 is either purely _ convex _ , with unique minimum @xmath247 ( the limit of the uniform chain ) , or it is _ constant _ : it is interesting to take a closer look at the latter case . obviously , this means that @xmath249_{ii}$ ] , independently of the parameters . as can be shown , for substitution rules of the form ( [ subs ] ) with ( [ rhoform2 ] ) , this is possible if and only if @xmath231 is a word ( or a power of a word ) with all letters @xmath250 appearing precisely once and if the last letter of @xmath114 is @xmath250 . this means , however , that the resulting chain is _ periodic _ and has bounded rather than logarithmically diverging fluctuations . as stated above , each two - letter substitution chain can be generated by a substitution rule of the form ( [ subs ] ) . for any marginal substitution rule , we can assume that the second - largest eigenvalue of the substitution matrix is @xmath251 . if necessary , this can be achieved by going to @xmath252 . as a consequence , @xmath216}$ ] in eq . ( [ y1 ] ) is eigenvector to the eigenvalue @xmath228 of @xmath213 , and as above the fields are already at their fixed points . in this case , the entries of the transformation matrices @xmath171 are polynomials of a single parameter @xmath253 that determines the critical couplings . the crucial point now is to show that like in the case discussed above the matrices @xmath171 have an eigenvalue @xmath254 independently of @xmath253 and of the detailed form of the substitution rule . this assertion is proved in appendix a. then , the perron - frobenius eigenvalues of @xmath171 are given as above ( [ mu ] ) , and we obtain the critical scaling exponent @xmath255 where @xmath80 is the leading eigenvalue of the substitution matrix . as in the case discussed above , @xmath256 is constant ( @xmath257 ) only for the special case of a periodic chain ( with period @xmath258 ) . otherwise , @xmath37 is a convex function of @xmath253 , with a unique minimum @xmath259 where the ( reduced ) couplings are equal . on the other hand , it is easy to see that the periodic chain with period @xmath258 is the only two - letter substitution chain with bounded letter fluctuations that can be generated by a substitution rule of the form ( [ subs ] ) and that has @xmath254 as the second - largest eigenvalue of the substitution matrix . we thus conclude that @xmath257 _ if and only if _ the fluctuations are bounded , and @xmath260 otherwise . the _ period - doubling chain _ , given by the substitution rule ( [ eq : sub ] ) with @xmath101 , falls into both classes described above . we consider double substitution steps , eliminating blocks of the form @xmath261 and obtain the scaling exponent @xmath262 this result was reported before in ref . if the length of the chain is increased by simple substitution steps , the coefficients @xmath263 in eq . ( [ zz ] ) converge _ separately _ for an even and an odd number of steps . effectively , this can be seen as a renormalisation of the couplings according to @xmath264 in a single renormalisation step . hence we obtain @xmath265 . as an example that is not contained in the above classes , consider the three - letter substitution @xmath266 with eigenvalues of the substitution matrix @xmath267 and @xmath236 . the eigenvector to eigenvalue 1 of the transposed substitution matrix @xmath213 is @xmath268 , and with eq . ( [ y0 ] ) we conclude that @xmath269 and @xmath270 . evaluating the rt of @xmath172 at this fixed point , we obtain the critical scaling exponent @xmath271 note that , for @xmath272 , the fluctuations of the couplings are indeed bounded , and we obtain @xmath273 as it should be . in our last example , the couplings follow the thue - morse sequence on the _ sites _ of the chain , rather than on the bonds as in all cases discussed so far . the coupling constants for a site - problem are given as a function of the two adjacent bonds and thus can take in general @xmath130 different values ( @xmath274 in this case ) . it can , however , easily be shown that this can be reformulated as a bond - problem with a substitution chain on an @xmath130-letter alphabet @xcite . in this case , the resulting four - letter substitution rule is @xmath275 the asymptotic letter frequencies are @xmath276 and @xmath277 ; and so we have @xmath278 ( for @xmath279 ) as the criticality condition ( [ eq : critcond ] ) . a possible parametrisation is @xmath280 , @xmath281 , @xmath282 , and @xmath283 . the eigenvalues of the substitution matrix are @xmath284 , @xmath285 , @xmath285 , and @xmath286 , we thus expect marginal fluctuations , whereas the thue - morse bond - problem has bounded fluctuations . following the above steps , we obtain a scaling exponent @xmath287}{\log ( 2 ) } \ ; .\ ] ] note that for @xmath288 , @xmath272 we obtain another coding of the period - doubling chain , while the special case @xmath289 , @xmath290 leads us back to the thue - morse bond - problem with bounded fluctuations ( with @xmath291 , and thus @xmath273 ) . for @xmath87 , fluctuations diverge with a power law . as a consequence , the vector @xmath215}$ ] finally scales with @xmath292 under the rt . since the matrix elements of @xmath171 are proportional to @xmath293 , at least a part of them eventually diverge like @xmath294 [ note that the components of @xmath181 have different sign because of eq . ( [ y2 ] ) ] . estimating the product of the perron - frobenius eigenvalues @xmath173 by the product of the corresponding traces , we obtain @xmath295 and thus @xmath296 where the _ wandering exponent _ @xmath89 is defined in eq . ( [ beta ] ) . let us discuss this in more detail for the case of two - letter substitutions . we take @xmath297 with corresponding eigenvector @xmath298 of @xmath213 and parametrise the critical couplings as @xmath299 since @xmath300 and @xmath301 have different sign , either one of these two is bigger than one for a fixed value @xmath302 , and without loss of generality we assume @xmath303 . note that we have the following relation @xmath304 we now show that @xmath305 $ ] . from eq . ( [ pminus ] ) , this is immediately clear for @xmath306 , but it also holds for @xmath307 . to see this , consider the products of subsequent couplings of the word @xmath65 . the product of the entire word is given by eq . ( [ product ] ) . if the last letter of @xmath65 is an @xmath63 , this enters @xmath307 and we are done . on the other hand , if the last letter is a @xmath64 , consider the product of all couplings but the last @xmath308 , which is even larger . iterating this argument , we finally arrive at a letter @xmath63 which proves our estimate of @xmath307 . using the standard eigenvalue formula , we obtain the scaling of @xmath173 under the rt , and thereby @xmath309 here , @xmath310 is some constant that may depends on the sign of @xmath311 , but apart from that is independent of @xmath253 and @xmath15 . this scaling form was also predicted in @xcite . in this section , we give a short summary of the results of our renormalisation treatment and discuss their consequences for the critical properties of the iqc . here , the behaviour of the low - energy part of the the spectrum at criticality is essentially the same as for the uniform chain . the correlation length critical exponents stays at its onsager value @xmath312 . for periodic chains ( or periodic variations of the interactions along the layers of the 2@xmath2 statistical system ) , the results from renormalisation show that the smallest fermion frequencies are only altered by a common factor @xmath187 ( fermion velocity ) , thus also conformal properties persist and the whole model is described by the central charge @xmath313 conformal field theory of a massless free majorana fermion : @xmath314 with a fermion velocity @xmath187 given by ( [ v]).the scaling dimensions @xmath315 are odd integers for periodic boundary conditions ( mixed sector hamiltonian ) and odd half - integers for free boundaries @xcite . numerical results @xcite confirm this conformal behaviour even for non - periodic chains with bounded fluctuations . for the critical scaling , we can make the following _ ansatz _ : @xmath316 the index @xmath253 here denotes the dependence on the position on the critical surface . the predicted scaling behaviour @xcite is confirmed analytically for all marginal two - letter substitution chains and some infinite classes of @xmath4-letter substitution chains . @xmath317 converges to the scaling coefficients @xmath263 if we increase the length of the chain @xmath15 by ( multiple ) substitution steps , in other words @xmath318 is asymptotically periodic for @xmath319 with period @xmath320 , where @xmath80 is the scaling factor of the system size . ( [ z ] ) implies @xmath321 , and @xmath273 is only obtained in the limit of the uniform chain where the fluctuations actually vanish . we further note that , in the explicitly solved cases , @xmath37 is invariant under inversion of all couplings . thus this is a symmetry of the lower part of the critical spectrum , while it is easy to see that it is not a symmetry of the entire finite - size spectrum . as a consequence , @xmath37 quadratically approaches the isotropic value @xmath322 for small deviations of the couplings from the uniform strength @xmath323 , as was also predicted by luck @xcite . in the terminology of the 2@xmath2 classical ising model , we have @xmath324 for any marginal disorder within layers of couplings . since the correlation length critical exponent perpendicular to the layers remains @xmath325 , marginal fluctuations introduce a relevant anisotropy of the model , as was noticed in ref . @xcite . due to anisotropic hyperscaling , a _ negative _ specific heat exponent @xmath326 is expected . within the renormalisation approach , the length of the chain @xmath15 is increased by ( multiple ) substitution steps . thus , it is a priori not clear what happens to the scaling dimensions when we increase @xmath15 arbitrarily . indeed , numerical studies ( for free boundary conditions ) show that , if we increase @xmath15 by arbitrary amounts , while @xmath37 converges , @xmath327 stays finite but will not tend to a unique limit . this is in contrast to the bounded fluctuation case . in more detail , the following properties of @xmath327 have been observed in all examples ( of two - letter substitution chains ) studied : * given the couplings , @xmath327 appears to be bounded for all @xmath15 and @xmath10 . * for @xmath328 , the effect of @xmath10 on @xmath329 is a mere shift : @xmath330 . * as a consequence of the rt , @xmath331 , @xmath318 is asymptotically periodic . * the amplitude of @xmath329 vanishes in the limit of the uniform chain , @xmath332 , as @xmath329 approaches continuously the constant value @xmath333 . these points can immediately be translated into properties of the integrated density of states ( idos ) , the inverse of which is given by @xmath334 while the first two points imply the convergence of this quantity , the third point above implies the lower part of the idos to be self - similar with a discrete scaling symmetry @xmath335 where @xmath336 is the asymptotic period of @xmath329 . mind that in general not the spectrum ( the lowest fermion frequencies ) , but only the idos displays this scaling behaviour for @xmath337 . this scaling property has consequences for the possible gap structure of the critical spectrum , where the results of the renormalisation approach at least lead to necessary conditions for gap - labelling theorems . but since within this class more spectral properties can be found analytically using trace maps , we postpone the discussion to a forthcoming publication . in substitution sequences with strong fluctuations , as in our third example , the binary non - pisot sequence [ @xmath102 in eq . ( [ eq : sub ] ) ] , their divergence is described @xcite by the wandering exponent @xmath89 ( [ beta ] ) which determines the exponential closing of the spectral gaps as @xmath338 here , @xmath339 is the second moment of the distribution of coupling constants along the chain @xcite which for the binary non - pisot sequence is given by @xmath340 and compatibility with the uniform case requires @xmath341 and @xmath342 . from the results of the renormalisation approach , @xmath318 should be asymptotically periodic for @xmath331 . this is confirmed by numerical investigations . indeed , the latter suggest the very same properties as given above in the case of marginal fluctuations . in particular , we observe @xmath343 for @xmath344 . again , this means that the integrated spectral density converges in the thermodynamic limit and its lower part shows the following scaling property at the critical point : @xmath345 using a renormalisation approach , we obtained analytic results for the critical behaviour of a class of ising models intermediate between uniformly ( or periodically ) ordered and randomly disordered systems . the systems under consideration are ferromagnetic ising quantum chains whose interaction constants are modulated according to substitution sequences . luck s criterion @xcite for the relevance of aperiodic disorder on the critical behaviour is fully confirmed for these systems , bringing along increasing evidence that the _ fluctuation of the interactions _ is the basic concept that demarcates the onsager universality class from models with weaker critical singularities . for two - letter substitution rules , this analysis was carried out in detail , showing how the renormalisation flow is determined by the nature of the fluctuations . an exact renormalisation formalism for the most general case of @xmath4-letter substitution rules was also presented and applied to examples . a number of quantitative results have been displayed , mainly for the correlation length critical exponent ( resp . the scaling exponent @xmath37 of the mass gap ) , confirming and refining luck s predictions for bounded , marginal , and relevant fluctuations of the coupling constants . in particular , an exact formula has been obtained for the scaling exponent of arbitrary two - letter substitution chains , containing previous results as special cases . in this light , the case of two - letter substitution rules appears to be rather well understood by now . what remains to be done in the @xmath4-letter case is a thorough discrimination between quantum ( substitution ) chains with bounded and with marginal fluctuations of the couplings . this is connected with the problem of determining all substitution rules with second - largest eigenvalue of the substitution matrix on the unit circle , which nevertheless result in a chain with bounded rather than marginal fluctuations . also , the investigation of ordered cases that do not stem from a substitution rule might add some insight as they can possess a higher degree of complexity . unfortunately , renormalisation techniques will probably be unsuitable here . of primary interest are , of course , extensions to higher dimensions . a natural first step is to study two - dimensional statistical systems with two - dimensional rather than one - dimensional variations of the interactions . as can be seen from some special cases @xcite , analytic results are possible in principle , but they are not generic and solvable cases might actually be misleading . further analysis is necessary , and some results can be expected from numerical approaches , especially since structures generated by substitution rules are well - suited for ( numerical ) renormalisation . first results in this direction have been obtained recently @xcite and will be extended soon . part of this work was done while jh was visiting melbourne university . it is a great pleasure to thank paul pearce for his kind hospitality . financial support from the german science foundation ( dfg ) and the studienstiftung des deutschen volkes is gratefully acknowledged . we consider two - letter chains generated by substitution rules @xmath346 which have @xmath347 as the second - largest eigenvalue of the corresponding substitution matrix . as a consequence , one finds the constraints @xmath348 on the words @xmath65 and @xmath66 and the letter frequencies @xmath349 in the limit word , where @xmath350 denotes the number of letters @xmath94 contained in the word @xmath351 . we parametrise the criticality condition ( [ eq : critcond ] ) @xmath352 ( setting @xmath353 ) for the corresponding ising chain by @xmath354 with _ coprime _ integers @xmath134 and @xmath355 , such that @xmath356 . then @xmath357 divides @xmath358 and @xmath359 . the scaling exponent of the critical spectrum is a simple expression of the leading eigenvalues of two matrices @xmath360 where the entries @xmath361 are defined in eqs . ( [ pminus ] ) and ( [ pplus ] ) . they are polynomials in @xmath253 and @xmath362 . in what follows , we prove that @xmath171 have an eigenvalue @xmath254 , _ independently _ of the value of @xmath253 and of the detailed form of the substitution rule @xmath71 . since we have @xmath363 , it suffices to concentrate on @xmath175 . we define two polynomials @xmath364 corresponding to the words @xmath65 and @xmath66 by @xmath365 taking the frequencies @xmath349 of the letters as given , the possible words @xmath65 and @xmath66 are subject to the constraints ( [ eq : wawb ] ) . we define an _ elementary polynomial _ @xmath366 to be the polynomial @xmath364 corresponding to a word @xmath367 of minimal length fulfilling this condition . since @xmath134 and @xmath355 are coprime , each @xmath367 consists of @xmath134 @xmath63 s and @xmath355 @xmath64 s and leads to one of @xmath368 different elementary polynomials possible . let in the following @xmath231 be @xmath65 or @xmath66 . we now introduce a graphical representation of the word @xmath231 and the accompanying polynomials . for given @xmath231 , construct iteratively a step function @xmath369 \to \mathbb{z}$ ] as follows : @xmath370 note that the criticality conditions imply @xmath371 . an example for the case @xmath101 , @xmath372 is shown in figure [ fig1 ] . for @xmath373 ( @xmath374 ) , @xmath375 ( resp . @xmath376 ) is given by the `` sum over the _ upward _ steps '' of @xmath377 ( proceeding in positive @xmath378-direction ) , while @xmath379 ( resp . @xmath380 ) is given by the `` sum over the _ steps '' , each step contributing a term @xmath381 . in our example ( for @xmath373 ) , @xmath382 and @xmath383 . in a first step , we now show that @xmath364 can be expressed as sums over elementary polynomials @xmath384 . _ lemma:_for an arbitrary word @xmath231 fulfilling the criticality condition for given @xmath349 , there are integers @xmath250 and elementary polynomials @xmath385 , such that @xmath386 _ proof:_consider the substrings @xmath387 of @xmath231 of length @xmath357 starting with the letter @xmath388 . for each @xmath387 containing more than @xmath134 @xmath63 s , there has to be an @xmath389 with less than @xmath134 @xmath63 s , because of the criticality condition for @xmath231 . since the number of @xmath63 s contained in successive substrings @xmath387 and @xmath390 differs at most by one , there is at least one substring consisting of @xmath134 @xmath63 s and @xmath355 @xmath64 s . in the graphical representation , this appears as a restriction of @xmath377 to an interval of length @xmath357 with the endpoints of the graph taking the same value . the corresponding term within @xmath364 is obviously some elementary polynomial times a power of @xmath253 . we may now eliminate this substring from @xmath231 ( cut out the interval in the graphical picture ) and start the argument again . we proceed by showing that the elementary polynomials differ only in a ( polynomial ) factor that is independent of @xmath391 . _ proposition:_given @xmath134 and @xmath355 , there are polynomials @xmath392 and @xmath393 such that for every elementary polynomial @xmath394 @xmath395\ ] ] where @xmath396 is a polynomial that does not depend on @xmath391 . _ proof:_an elementary polynomial @xmath394 takes the following general form @xmath397 where @xmath398 are integers . defining @xmath399 the proof then follows by direct calculation . we remark that with this choice of @xmath400 and @xmath401 , @xmath402 can also be shown to be a polynomial in @xmath253 and @xmath362 . now , we are in the position to complete our argument . from eqs . ( [ eq : pab ] ) , ( [ lem ] ) and ( [ prop ] ) , we conclude that @xmath403 thus it follows that @xmath404 , and hence @xmath236 is an eigenvalue of @xmath175 for an _ arbitrary _ value of @xmath253 . the leading eigenvalues of @xmath405 are given by eq . ( [ mu ] ) . in the above discussion , the coupling constants were chosen according to a substitution rule of the special form ( [ subs ] ) . while any ( infinite ) substitution chain with two letters can be generated that way , this is no longer the case for three or more different letters ( resp . couplings ) . in this appendix , we present a generalised version of the renormalisation formalism to deal with the general case . consider a substitution rule of the form @xmath407 the main problem in the general case is to maintain the recursive structure of the renormalisation procedure within the elimination process . by fixing the first letter of the substitutes in eq . ( [ subs ] ) , the appropriate couplings of the renormalised chain were given . this is no longer possible here ; however , we can proceed as follows . * fix any letter @xmath250 within the word @xmath408 , thus defining two words @xmath409 and @xmath410 as shown in eq . ( [ subs2 ] ) . note that the letter @xmath250 appears in the word @xmath114 ( at least for a suitably chosen power @xmath411 of the substitution rule ) for primitive substitutions . * redefine the substitution rule as a function on _ pairs _ of letters in the following way @xmath412 obviously , ( [ subs3 ] ) leads to the same limit chain as ( [ subs2 ] ) . the substitution matrix of @xmath115 has a dimension of at most @xmath130 ( pairs @xmath413 that do not appear in the original chain need not be included in @xmath115 ) . actually , @xmath414 is just the substitution matrix of the corresponding _ site_-problem , where the type of site follows the sequence , and the bond ( resp . the interaction along it ) is a function of its two endpoints @xcite . note , however , that the couplings here are still attached to the bonds . * in the renormalisation formalism , now define @xmath3-matrices , fields and asymmetry - parameters corresponding to pairs of letters @xmath415 renormalisation again means inverting the substitution process by integrating out all degrees of freedom attached to the words @xmath409 and @xmath410 . we obtain renormalised @xmath3-matrices through @xmath416 * the rt ( and their linear orders in @xmath126 ) for the ( at most ) @xmath417 parameters are then obtained analogous to section 3 . for a classification of the critical behaviour based on the fluctuations we need to know about the spectrum @xmath418 of @xmath414 in dependence of the spectrum @xmath419 of @xmath72 . for an appropriate power of @xmath71 , it is indeed possible to show that @xmath418 contains @xmath419 and that all additional eigenvalues are either 1 or 0 . we only sketch the proof here . without restriction of the general case , we can assume that the first and the last letters of all words @xmath114 remain fixed under the substitution ; that is @xmath420 ^ 1 $ ] for the first letter , and equivalently for the last letter . this is always fulfilled by a finite power @xmath421 of the substitution rule . we assume the @xmath4 words @xmath114 to have @xmath134 different first letters and @xmath10 different last letters . taking a look at the associated pair substitution matrix @xmath414 , it is easy to show that @xmath422 since we always have @xmath423 and the numbers @xmath134 and @xmath10 remain fixed because of the above assumption , the traces of @xmath424 and @xmath425 differ only by the constant @xmath426 for arbitrary @xmath81 . we conclude that @xmath418 containes @xmath419 and the all additional eigenvalues are fixed points under any power , thus @xmath285 or @xmath286 . we will , however , not give a detailed discussion of the general case here , but rather illustrate the method by applying it to a special example . consider the substitution rule of the `` circle sequence '' . this example of a quasiperiodic chain ( in the sense that it has a pure point fourier spectrum ) has been studied numerically in ref . @xcite @xmath427 with @xmath252 being of the form ( [ subs3 ] ) . the eigenvalues of @xmath428 are @xmath429 , @xmath285 , and @xmath430 , where @xmath431 is the golden mean we thus expect marginal fluctuations . the asymptotic frequencies of the letters are @xmath432 , @xmath433 , and @xmath434 , respectively . we choose @xmath435 , @xmath436 , and @xmath437 as the parametrisation of the critical couplings @xmath438 . since only the five pairs @xmath258 , @xmath439 , @xmath440 , @xmath441 , and @xmath442 appear in the chain , the dimension of the pair transfer matrix @xmath443 is just five . the spectrum @xmath444 consists of the spectrum @xmath445 and of two additional eigenvalues 1 . identifying pairs of couplings with the first one , we clearly have @xmath446 , @xmath447 , and @xmath448 . thus the vector of the logarithms of the reduced couplings , @xmath449 , is sill perpendicular to the perron - frobenius eigenvector of @xmath414 and converges in the renormalisation limit to a linear combination of two eigenvectors corresponding to an eigenvalue 1 of @xmath450 : @xmath451 . while both parameters , @xmath253 and @xmath452 , enter the transformation matrices @xmath171 of @xmath172 , @xmath452 can actually be eliminated by a similarity transformation . such a behaviour is always to be expected if a parameter is connected to an eigenvector ( like in this case ) that corresponds to an _ additional _ eigenvalue 1 of @xmath453 , not contained in @xmath445 . the perron - frobenius eigenvalues of @xmath171 can be determined explicitly , and we obtain for the scaling exponent @xmath454 finally , we like to show an example of a three - letter substitution rule @xmath455 with bounded fluctuations , which nevertheless has @xmath236 as the second - largest eigenvalue of the substitution matrix . this is the bond substitution that corresponds to the site - problem given by @xmath456 . fluctuations are indeed bounded here , since we just obtain the fibonacci chain by identifying @xmath63 and @xmath64 , but also by identifying @xmath63 and @xmath310 . calculating the scaling exponent by the above method , we obtain @xmath273 , as was to be expected . 99 h. au - yang and b.m . mccoy , theory of layered ising models : thermodynamics , _ phys . rev . * b10 * _ ( 1974 ) 88691 . m. baake , p. chaselon and m. schlottmann , the ising quantum chain with defects ( ii ) . the @xmath457 kac moody spectra , _ nucl . phys . _ * b314 * ( 1989 ) 62545 . m. baake , u. grimm and r. baxter , a critical ising model on the labyrinth , _ int . j. mod . * b8 * ( 1994 ) 3579600 . m. baake , u. grimm and d. joseph , trace maps , invariants and some of their applications , _ int . j. mod . _ * b7 * ( 1993 ) 152750 . berche and b. berche , crossover between aperiodic and homogeneous semi - infinite critical behaviors in multilayered two - dimensional ising models , _ phys . * b * ( to appear ) . b. berche , p .- e . berche , m. henkel , f. igli , p. lajk , s. morgan and l. turban , anisotropic scaling in layered aperiodic ising systems , _ j. phys . _ * a28 * ( 1995 ) l16571 . b. berche , p .- e . berche and l. turban , marginal anisotropy in layered aperiodic ising systems , _ j. phys . i france _ * 6 * ( 1996 ) 62140 . cardy , effect of boundary conditions on the operator content of two - dimensional conformally invariant theories , _ nucl . phys . _ * b275 * ( 1986 ) 20018 ; and : conformal invariance , in : _ phase transitions and critical phenomena _ , eds . c. domb and j.l . lebowitz , academic press , london ( 1987 ) , pp . dumont , summation formulae for substitutions on a finite alphabet , in : _ number theory and physics _ , luck , p. moussa , and m. waldschmidt , springer , berlin ( 1990 ) , pp . e. fradkin , l. susskind , order and disorder in gauge systems and magnets , _ phys . * d17 * ( 1978 ) 263758 . u. grimm , the quantum ising chain with a generalized defect , _ nucl . _ * b340 * ( 1990 ) 63358 . u. grimm and m. baake , non - periodic ising quantum chains and conformal invariance , _ j. stat . phys . _ * 74 * ( 1994 ) 123345 . u. grimm and m. baake , aperiodic ising models , in : _ the mathematics of long - range aperiodic order _ , ed . . moody , kluwer , dordrecht ( 1997 ) , pp . harris , effect of random defects on the critical behaviour of ising models , _ j. phys . _ * c7 * ( 1974 ) 167192 . f. igli and l. turban , common trends in the critical behavior of the ising and directed walk models , _ phys . * 77 * ( 1996 ) 12069 . lieb , t. schulz and d. mattis , two soluble models of an antiferromagnetic chain , _ ann . phys . ( ny ) _ * 16 * ( 1961 ) 40766 . j. kogut , an introduction to lattice gauge theory and spin systems , _ rev . * 51 * ( 1997 ) 656713 . luck , critical behavior of the aperiodic quantum ising chain in a transverse magnetic field , _ j. stat . * 72 * ( 1993 ) 41758 ; and : a classification of critical phenomena on quasi - crystals and other aperiodic structures , _ europhys . * 24 * ( 1993 ) 35964 . f. lunnon and p. a. b. pleasants , quasicrystallographic tilings , _ j. math . pures et appl . _ * 66 * ( 1987 ) 21763 . pfeuty , an exact result for the 1d random ising model in a transverse field , _ phys . lett . _ * a72 * ( 1979 ) 24546 m. queffelec , _ substitution dynamical systems _ , lecture notes in mathematics , vol . 1294 , springer , berlin ( 1987 ) . r. redheffer , difference equations and functional equations in transmission - line theory , in : _ modern mathematics for the engineer _ e. f. beckenbach , mcgraw hill , new york ( 1961 ) , pp . . h. simon , _ ferromagnetische isingmodelle auf aperiodischen strukturen _ , phd thesis , universitt tbingen , dissertations druck darmstadt ( 1997 ) . tracy , universality classes of some aperiodic ising models , _ j. phys . _ * a21 * ( 1988 ) l6035 . l. turban , p .- e . berche and b. berche , surface magnetisation of aperiodic ising systems : a comparative study of bond and site problems , _ j. phys . _ * a27 * ( 1994 ) 634966 . l. turban , f. igli and b. berche , surface magnetization and critical behavior of aperiodic ising quantum chains , _ phys . rev . _ * 49 * ( 1994 ) 12695702 .
Abstract: | [
"some years ago , luck proposed a relevance criterion for the effect of aperiodic disorder on the critical behaviour of ferromagnetic ising systems . in this article , we show how luck s criterion can be derived within an exact renormalisation scheme for ising quantum chains with coupling constants modulated according to substitution rules . luck s conjectures for this case are confirmed and refined . among other outcomes , we give an exact formula for the correlation length critical exponent for arbitrary two - letter substitution sequences with marginal fluctuations of the coupling constants . * aperiodic ising quantum chains * joachim hermisson@xmath0 , uwe grimm@xmath1 and michael baake@xmath0 @xmath0institut fr theoretische physik , universitt tbingen , auf der morgenstelle 14 , d72076 tbingen , germany @xmath1institut fr physik , technische universitt chemnitz , d09107 chemnitz , germany"
] | 10,911 | 10,911 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the disciplined software engineering relies on software architectures to describe systems @xcite . for modeling a software architecture , the academy proposed the architecture description language ( adl ) and their toolsets @xcite . also , the industry has used adls to develop systems . industry examples are ( i ) @xmath0-adl has been used to architect and refine federated knowledge management systems in engineering ingegneria informatica - italy @xcite ; ( ii ) and aadl ( architecture analysis & design language ) is a standard language for the society of automotive engineers @xcite . according to the state - of - the - art @xcite , the following concepts are relevant to describe software architectures : components and connectors ( respectively computational and communication elements ) , architectural constraints , non functional properties , and behaviour . software systems evolve over their life time @xcite . dynamic reconfiguration is when the evolution is performed at runtime with no service disruption . the dynamic reconfiguration can be handled by architectural concepts in an adl . however among many existing adls , only few allow modeling dynamic reconfiguration . @xmath0-adl @xcite , acme / plastik @xcite , c2sadl @xcite , daop - adl @xcite , darwin @xcite , dynamic wright @xcite , rapide @xcite , weaves @xcite , and xadl @xcite are typical examples . nevertheless , there is no current consensus about how adls should address reconfiguration , e.g. , what language constructs should be provided . in this work , the goal is twofold : ( i ) to investigate the adls support for handling dynamic reconfiguration in the literature ; and , ( ii ) to illustrate how four well - known adls support dynamic reconfiguration : @xmath0-adl , acme , c2 sadl and dynamic wright . we chose these four languages because they rely on different paradigms : the higher order typed @xmath0-calculus @xcite , first order predicate logic @xcite , compo - nent- and event - based @xcite , and , graph grammars and communicating sequential processes ( csp ) @xcite , respectively . they also complement each other as @xmath0-adl models the behavior of architectures , acme focuses on the structure , c2sadl make the attention for components and their concurrent events , and dynamic wright supports the definition of structure and behavior . this work is structured as follows . section [ section : motivation ] motivates this work thanks to the example of a tcp / ip stack system . three scenarios illustrate three facets of dynamic reconfiguration . section [ section : concepts ] presents the basics concepts of software architecture and dynamic reconfiguration . section [ section : related - works ] details the related works about dynamic reconfiguration at the architecture level . section [ section : comparison ] compares the four above - mentioned adls in the light of our example of section [ section : motivation ] . section [ section : conclusion ] concludes the paper with open issues that we note in the adl support for dynamic reconfiguration . dynamic reconfiguration aims at modifying the software systems at runtime with no service disruption . critical systems usually want to benefit of a dynamic reconfiguration because any service disruption may have substantial consequences . examples of critical systems are stock market quotation systems , telecommunications systems , safety systems , and air traffic control systems . however , there is no current consensus about how the software architecture should address dynamic reconfiguration at architecture level . does regular syntax for dynamic architectures allow the same reconfigurations as specific language constructs ? should the state of components and connectors be taken into account at the architecture level ? to support this work , we rely on a simplified version of the tcp / ip stack ( fig . [ fig : tcpip - stack ] ) . each of the four layers ( application , transport , internet , and link ) is modeled as a component ( fig . [ fig : tcpip - system ] ) . we consider the three following reconfigurations : 1 . _ switch the application component . _ assume two alternatives : mpeg - decoder and h263-decoder . mpeg - decoder is used if _ bandwidth _ is high ( fig . [ fig : tcpip - mpeg ] ) . otherwise h263-decoder is selected ( fig [ fig : tcpip - h263 ] ) . switching between mpeg and h263 starts a new stream . therefore , no state in the decoder needs be kept . we can therefore replace one component by another . insertion of a new component type . _ presume that the internet protocol version 6 ( ipv6 ) replace the version 4 ( ipv4 ) ( fig . [ fig : tcpip - ipv6 ] ) . the ipv6 component has backward compatibility with the ipv4 component . so it has the ports for both ipv4 ( for compatibility reason ) and for ipv6 ( new feature ) . therefore , the type of the component at the internet layer is changed : it has 2 additional ports . _ update a component type . _ assume that the algorithm of error control of the transport component is improved . when the error control algorithm is changed , the new behaviour needs to know the status of each packet ( acknowledged , sent , timeout , ... ) as well as the content of non - acknowledged packets ( in order to resend them ) . therefore , only the behaviour part of the component should be replaced . the state of the component should be unchanged . these scenarios cover a wide spectrum . they can either be programmed at design - time or be discovered at run - time . they feature reconfiguration at both type and instance level . they target both the structure and the behaviour of the architecture . we investigate the adls literature in order to illustrate how reconfiguration is supported in these scenarios . in this paper , we focus on four adls that are representative of the main trends . each adls complement the other . the complement at the sense for describing an initial architecture as well as dynamic reconfiguration . we choose @xmath0-adl because it provides both description with behaviours thanks to its @xmath0-calculus roots . whilst the acme / plastik is a declarative language with focus on the architecture structure for both descriptions . while c2sadl is used to compose architectures based on component and dynamic reconfiguration based on architectural events . finally , dynamic wright provides support for architectural description based in graph - grammars and dynamic reconfiguration specification with a variant of communicating sequential processes ( csp ) . [ [ software - architecture - concepts ] ] software architecture concepts + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + software architectures + describe systems by specifying their elements and the interactions between them @xcite . in this work , we use the basics concepts defined in @xcite : a _ component _ is an unit of computation and storage ; a _ connector _ is an unit of communication ; and , a _ configuration _ is a specification of a software architecture in terms of components , connectors , and relationship between them . ports , roles , behaviours , constraints , and non - functional properties are other concepts defined in @xcite used to describe these architectural elements . ports and roles are used to define the way of interaction , ports for configurations and components , and roles for connectors . behaviours are the architectural element internal computation . and the last two concepts , constraints and non - functional properties , are used to denote the assertions , invariants , quality of service that architectural elements are expected to meet . also , we consider types and instances of configurations , components , and connectors for modelling a software architectures @xcite . the types are abstractions like classes in the object - oriented paradigm which encapsulate both the structure and the behaviours that can be performed on its structure . these types will be used to build the instances and these instances will be used to describe software architectures . fig . [ code : tcpip - acme ] illustrates in acme the basics concepts with our example tcp / ip stack system ( sec . [ section : motivation ] fig . [ fig : tcpip - system ] ) at instance and type level . the types are defined in the ` family ` statement block ( lines 1 - 18 ) while the instance level in ` system ` ( lines 20 - 30 ) . .... family tcpip_mf { . . connector type tcpip_conn2layers { providedrole source ; requiredrole sink ; } ; component type tcpip_component { port type datafrom extends providedport with { } ; port type datato extends revidedport with { } ; property type layer = enum{application , transport , internet , link } } ; component type tcpip_application extends tcpip_component with { port datareceivedfromtransport : datafrom ; port requiredservice : datato ; property layer = " application " ; } ; . . } system decoderstream : tcpip_mf = new tcpip_mf extended with { component application : tcpip_application ; component transport : tcpip_transpot ; component internet : tcpip_internet ; component link : tcpip_link ; connector application2transport , transport2internet , internet2link : conn2layers ; attchments { application.requiredservice to application2transport.source ; application2transport.sink to transport.service ; transport.requiredservice to transport2internet.source ; transport2internet.sink to internet.service ; internet.requiredservice to internet2link.source ; internet2link.sink to link.service ; } . . } .... [ [ dynamic - reconfiguration - concepts ] ] dynamic reconfiguration concepts + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + a dynamic reconfiguration is a set of operations to modify an existing configuration at runtime . at the software architecture level , the operation is defined in terms of the architectural elements at type or instance level . scenario 1 is an example of reconfiguration at the instance level ( mpeg and h263 share the same type ) ; and scenario 2 is an example of reconfiguration at the type level ( ipv6 extends the type of ipv4 ) . also , the dynamic reconfiguration can be foreseen or unforeseen @xcite . the foreseen is a programmed dynamic reconfiguration specified at design time . while the unforeseen is an ad - doc defined at runtime . example of foreseen and unforeseen is the scenario 1 and 3 , respectively . in the scenario 1 , the architect specify at design time that the system modify itself when the bandwidth change . whereas the behaviour improvement is built at runtime as defined in scenario 3 . medvidovic and taylor @xcite created a classification framework based on architectural elements and illustrated them with the following adls : acme , aesop , c2 , darwin , metah , rapide , sadl , unicon , weaves , and wright . however , this work has no focus on the dynamic reconfiguration . hence , its discussion about dynamic reconfigurations is limited , e.g. all adls were assessed only at the instance level , not at the type level . kacem _ et al . _ @xcite described the capabilities of darwin , archjava , olan , rapide , wright , and acme to support dynamic reconfiguration . they classify the adls as configuration and description language . the configuration language supports the description of a software system and limited dynamic reconfigurations , while the description language supports the specification of modifications to be applied to an existing architecture . despite this work focus is on dynamic reconfiguration , it also presents some limitations such as the fact that the evolution is applied only at instance level and do not take into account the behaviour of the architectural elements . bradbury @xcite and bradbury _ et al . _ @xcite proposed a framework to compare fourteen formal specification approaches which support dynamic software architectures . amongst the criteria , bradbury _ et al . _ considered the basic operations , how they can be composed and whether they apply to variable sets of architectural element types . about the basic operations ( addition and removal of components and connectors ) , bradbury et al . showed that most approaches support them . also , they considered the criterion of operations composition ( basic , sequence , choice , and iteration ) . only 3 approaches ( community , dynamic wright , and gerel ) provide full support while the other only support basic composition . finally , bradury _ et al . _ mentioned that all approaches support only the types of architectural elements defined prior runtime , fixed sets of architectural elements . while adl surveys have reached good understanding of the concepts underlying software architectures ( medvidovic and taylor @xcite ) , this is not true regarding dynamic reconfiguration at the architecture level . even bradbury @xcite and bradbury _ et al . _ @xcite , probably the most complete surveys , do not consider operations such as insertion of configuration and behaviour modification . they do not recognize _ link _ and _ unlink _ as basic operations . however , they present the examples of these operations on some approaches , like gerel and c2sadl . considering the scenarios of section [ section : motivation ] , these related works address only the first scenario ( partially ) but not the two last . consequently , it is clear that to discuss the three scenarios presented in section [ section : motivation ] is essential to have a better understanding of the dynamic reconfiguration issues . these scenarios consider both instance and type levels , the basic operations include configurations , components , and connectors , as well as their structures and behaviours . in this subsection , we describe the scenarios defined in sec . [ section : motivation ] in all four adls : @xmath0-adl ( subsection [ sec : pi - adl ] ) , acme / plastik ( subsection [ sec : acme ] ) , c2sadl ( subsection [ sec : c2sadl ] ) , and dynamic wright ( subsection [ sec : wright ] ) . for each adl we show the purpose , the tcp / ip stack system , a solution for three scenarios , and discussion about this implementation . [ [ purpose - of - the - adl ] ] purpose of the adl + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + @xmath0-adl is based on @xmath0-calculus and it is designed to describe the concurrent and mobile systems @xcite . the description of architectural elements is mainly represented by ports and behaviour . [ [ dynamic - reconfiguration - support ] ] dynamic reconfiguration support + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + this adl provides + support for foreseen and unforeseen dynamic reconfiguration . the foreseen can be described in the behaviour of any architectural elements . while unforeseen needs some support , e.g. , in the virtual machine ( vm ) , in order to obtain a root reference to the reconfigured system . in archware , this issue is addressed by the deep intrication between the toolset ( including the visual and textual editors ) and the vm thanks to the hyper - code technology @xcite . [ [ initial - architecture ] ] initial architecture + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the implementation of tcp / ip stack system is shown in fig . [ code : tcpip - piadl ] . the configuration is composed at lines 1 - 18 basically with a behaviour , statement ` behaviour ` is ... where ... ! ( lines 2 - 17 ) . this architectural behaviour defines the instances of components ( lines 3 - 6 ) and connectors ( lines 7 - 9 ) . the statement ` where ` in behaviour specifies the connections between components and connectors ( lines 11 - 16 ) . the example of component ` tcpip_application ` is partially showed at lines 20 - 35 : two ports and a behaviour . the component behaviour is implemented with two internal methods ( lines 24 - 25 ) and the definition of communication between its ports ( lines 27 - 33 ) . .... archictecture tcpip is abstraction ( ) { behaviour is compose { application is tcpip_application ( ) and transport is tcpip_transport ( ) and net is tcpip_internet ( ) and link is tcpip_link ( ) and app2transp is conn2layers ( ) and transp2net is conn2layers ( ) and net2link is conn2layers ( ) } where { appliation::request unifies app2transp::source and app2transp::sink unifies transport::service and transpost::request unifies transp2net::source and transp2net::sink unifies net::service and net::request unifies net2link::source and net2link::sink unifies link::service } } component tcpip_application is abstraction ( ) { port service is { ... } . port request is { ... } . behaviour is { processrequest is function(d : datatype):datatype { unobservable}. processresponse is function(d : datatype):datatype { unobservable}. choose { via service::wait receive entrydata : datatype . via request::call send processrequest(entrydata ) . or via request::response receive replydata : datatype . via service::reply send processresponse(replydata ) . } } } component tcpip_transport is abstraction ( ) { ... } component tcpip_internet is abstraction ( ) { ... } component tcpip_link is abstraction ( ) { ... } connector conn2layers is abstraction ( ) { ... port source is { ... } port sink is { ... } behaviour is { ... } } .... [ [ scenario-1 ] ] scenario 1 + + + + + + + + + + the implementation of scenario 1 in @xmath0-adl is composed by a component that performs the dynamic reconfiguration ( fig . [ code : scenario1-piadl ] ) . this component has two parameters : the application component and the system component . both are represented as a behaviour . the application component is a mpeg - decoder or h263-decoder . still , this component is structured with seven `` variables '' and a behaviour , lines 2 - 4 and 5 - 27 , respectively . the variables are used for behaviours of components and connectors . to perform the modification , the behaviour component use the following steps : decomposition the system behaviour ( line 6 ) ; assign the behaviours to variables ( lines 8 - 14 ) ; compose a new system behaviour ( lines 16 - 26 ) with a replaced application component ( line 20 ) . .... component reconfiguration is abstraction(application : behaviour , system : behaviour ) { behaviours : sequence[behaviour ] . transport : behaviour . net : behaviour . link : behaviour . app2transp : behaviour . transp2net : behaviour . net2link : behaviour . behaviour is { behaviours : = decompose system . transport : = behaviours::1::bhvr . net : = behaviours::2::bhvr . link : = behaviours::3::bhvr . app2transp : = behaviours::4::bhvr . transp2net : = behaviours::5::bhvr . net2link : = behaviours::6::bhvr . compose { application and transport and net and link and app2transp and transp2net and net2link } where { appliation::request unifies app2transp::source and app2transp::sink unifies transport::service and transpost::request unifies transp2net::source and transp2net::sink unifies net::service and net::request unifies net2link::source and net2link::sink unifies link::service } } } .... [ [ scenario-2 ] ] scenario 2 + + + + + + + + + + the implementation for the unforeseen scenario 2 is shown in fig . [ code : scenario2-piadl ] . this code is applied in a system at runtime to deploy the two new component `` type '' . first , the component type is a new protocol _ ipv6 _ ( lines 1 - 3 ) , and the second is a component to perform dynamic reconfiguration ( lines 4 - 32 ) . in order to execute this dynamic reconfiguration two steps are applied : ( i ) to obtain the root behaviour of the system , and ( ii ) to invoke the computation of the reconfiguration component . both operations are aided by toolset and hyper - code . the code of the reconfiguration component is described using the following steps : ( i ) to decompose the behaviours of the system in components and connectors ( lines 9 ) ; ( ii ) to assign to `` variables '' the instances of components that represent application , transport , and link ( lines 11 - 13 ) ; ( iii ) to attribute connectors to `` variables '' ( lines 15 - 17 ) ; ( iv ) to compose a new system behaviour ( lines 19 - 30 ) with a new instance of the protocol ipv6 component ( line 21 ) . as in the scenario 1 , when performing a new composition , the behaviour of the system is automatically updated . .... component tcpip_ipv6 is abstracion ( ) { ... } component reconfiguration is abstraction(system : behaviour ) { behaviours : sequence[behaviour ] . application : behaviour . transport : behaviour . link : behaviour . app2transp : behaviour . transp2net : behaviour . net2link : behaviour . behaviour is { behaviours : = decompose system . application : = behaviours::0::bhvr . transport : = behaviours::1::bhvr . link : = behaviours::3::bhvr . app2transp : = behaviours::4::bhvr . transp2net : = behaviours::5::bhvr . net2link : = behaviours::6::bhvr . compose { application and transport and link and net is tcpip_v6 and app2transp and transp2net and net2link } where { appliation::request unifies app2transp::source and app2transp::sink unifies transport::service and transpost::request unifies transp2net::source and transp2net::sink unifies net::service and net::request unifies net2link::source and net2link::sink unifies link::service } } } .... [ [ scenario-3 ] ] scenario 3 + + + + + + + + + + in the scenario 3 it is also used the process of decomposition , modification , and composition , as showed above . we use the archware virtual machine facility to get a reference to the root of the target transport component . after , we make a modification into the behaviour of the component . at last , the archware virtual machine synchronize the system with this modification . [ [ summary - of - pi - adl ] ] summary of @xmath0-adl + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + with these implementations , some issues are identified on @xmath0-adl support for dynamic reconfiguration : 1 . changing types needs external help , e.g. toolset , hyper - code and @xmath0-arl . toolset and hyper - code are used for capturing , specifying the changes , and applying the changes . while @xmath0-arl is a language to specify refinements in the system ; 2 . instances modifications can be specified in architectural elements or also with toolset and hyper - code help . at first , usually the dynamic reconfiguration is tangled with nominally behaviour . however , we used other approach with a specific component to specify dynamic reconfiguration ; 3 . for the third scenario , the @xmath0-adl do not provide a mechanism to design the intermediate states for updating the instances with the improvement of behaviour . however , if we use the @xmath0-arl approach , we can have better control ; 4 . also with @xmath0-arl is possible build constraints and non - functional properties for architectural elements . however , it s not used to assess dynamic reconfiguration . [ [ purpose - of - the - adl-1 ] ] purpose of the adl + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + acme / armani is a declarative language based on the first - order predicate logic @xcite . its initial purpose was to define a common interchange language for architecture design tools . also , its statements are designed to describe the architectural structures at instance and type levels . the extensions @xcite to support dynamic reconfiguration preserves these initials purpose , and are named as acme / plastik . thereafter , any configuration and dynamic reconfiguration specified using this extension ( acme / plastik ) are based on the structure of an architecture . [ [ dynamic - reconfiguration - support-1 ] ] dynamic reconfiguration support + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + acme / plastik permits to describe foreseen and unforeseen dynamic reconfiguration . to unforeseen reconfiguration it is possible to describe as a specific behaviour of a configuration with the ` on ( $ conditional\_expression$ ) do { $ operations$ } ` statement . unforeseen reconfiguration can be expressed in a script that will be applied in the system at runtime aided by a toolset provided by the plastik framework . both , @xmath1 and script are composed with acme statements and its acme / plastik extension . the @xmath2 is composed in the armani language @xcite . [ [ initial - architecture-1 ] ] initial architecture + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the example of the tcp / ip stack system in acme is showed in fig . [ code : tcpip - acme ] . the types are specified in the ` family ` statement while the instances are in the ` system ` statement . for types , a connector ( lines 3 - 6 ) and two components ( lines 7 - 11 and 12 - 16 ) are implemented as example . the configuration is composed by the component instances ( lines 21 - 24 ) , connector instances ( lines 26 - 27 ) , and the connections between them ( lines 28 - 37 ) . [ [ scenario-1 - 1 ] ] scenario 1 + + + + + + + + + + the implementation in acme / plastik of scenario 1 is showed in fig . [ code : scenario1-acme ] . the configuration is named with ` streamdecodersystem ` and it extends the ` tcpip_mf ` and ` plastikmf ` . the ` tcpip_mf ` is showed in fig . [ code : tcpip - acme ] while ` plastik_mf ` in @xcite . such configuration consists of : the insertion of two new components ( type and instance ) in lines 2 - 5 and line 6 ; the instantiation of components and connectors ( omitted with comment and @xmath3 in lines 7 - 8 ) ; the linking of components and connectors ( omitted with comment and @xmath3 in lines 7 - 8 ) ; and the specification of two dynamic reconfiguration situations , lines 12 - 19 and 21 - 28 . both dynamic reconfigurations use the same similar description . first , the conditional expressions are ` link.bandwidth = = ' low ' ` and ` link.bandwidth = = ' high ' ` . second , the @xmath1 are described as two unlinking ( lines 13 - 14 , 22 - 23 ) and one linking ( lines 15 - 18 , 24 - 27 ) statements . these @xmath1 specified the replacement of an instance of the component . .... system streamdecodersystem : tcpip_mf , plastikmf { component mpeg - decoder : tcpip_mpegdecoder = new tcpip_application extend with { property decoder - type = " mpeg " ; property algorithm = ... ; } component h263-decoder : tcpip_h263decoder = new tcpip_application extend with { ... } // other instances of component and connector ... // initial attachments ... // programmed dynamic reconfiguration to low bandwidth on ( link.bandwidth = = ' low ' ) do { detach mpeg-decoder.requiredservice to application2transport.source ; detach transport2application.sink to mpeg-decoder.datareceivedfromtransport ; attachments { h263-decoder.requiredservice to application2transport.source ; transport2application.sink to h263-decoder.datareceivedfromtransport ; } } // programmed dynamic reconfiguration to high bandwidth on ( link.bandwidth = = ' high ' ) do { detach h263-decoder.datato to application2transport.source ; detach transport2application.sink to h263-decoder.datareceivedfromtransport ; attachments { mpeg-decoder.requiredservice to application2transport.source ; transport2application.sink to mpeg-decoder.datareceivedfromtransport ; } } } .... [ [ scenario-2 - 1 ] ] scenario 2 + + + + + + + + + + the scenario 2 , an unforeseen insertion of a new component type , is describe with an acme / plastik script in fig . [ code : scenario2-acme ] . for this scenario , the script is composed by : the insertion of a type and instance of a component ( lines 1 - 3 ) , the unlinking of the old component instance ( lines 5 - 6 ) and the linking of the new component ( lines 7 - 10 ) . .... component ipv6 : tcpip_ipv6 = new tcpip_internet extended with { ... } detach ipv4.requiredservice to internet2link.source ; detach link2internet.sink to ipv4.datareceivedfromlink ; attachments { ipv6.requiredservice to internet2link.source ; link2internet.sink to ipv6.datareceivedfromlink ; } .... [ [ scenario-3 - 1 ] ] scenario 3 + + + + + + + + + + the unforeseen upgrade of a behaviour in scenario 3 can be described by the script illustrated in fig . [ code : scenario3-acme ] . this script defines a new version of a component with an improvement on its behaviour . the behaviour in acme / plastik is expressed as a property and it can be also described in other languages , such as external formal languages , see lines 3 - 5 in fig . [ code : scenario3-acme ] . .... component type tcpip_transport extends tcpip_component with { ... property behaviour = { \\ description of behaviour in other languages , e.g. csp } ... } .... [ [ summary - of - acmeplastik ] ] summary of acme / plastik + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the dynamic reconfiguration issues for acme can be summarized as follows : 1 . dynamic reconfiguration in terms of structure is supported by acme / plastik . in terms of behaviour , dynamic reconfiguration is described using any external language embedded inside the property element . usually , this is used for foreseen reconfiguration . this approach is limited in the sense that components and connectors usually needs the dynamic reconfiguration of their behaviour but as acme / plastik does not provides elements for behaviour specification , the architect has to rely on an external language . e.g. if the ` tcpip_transport ` component needs to decide if it has a buffer or not , and if it uses a error detecting or not , and so on . these situations have to be described using an external language ( in general formal languages such as csp ) . 2 . acme / plastik does not provide a mechanism to control the intermediate states of a reconfiguration . e.g. the implementation of the scenario 3 , the architect can not define the approach used to update the instances . 3 . for unforeseen reconfiguration acme / plastik relies on external scripts . this approach requires an external interpreted associated to the adl to interpret the external script in order to reconfigure the system . [ [ purpose - of - the - adl-2 ] ] purpose of the adl + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + initially , the purpose of c2 was to describe the architecture of a software based on a graphical user interface ( gui ) @xcite . therefore , the adl is based on hierarchically concurrent components . c2 also allows the use of messages to notify the architectural elements . c2 is subdivided in 2 languages : c2 idl ( interface description language ) for describing the components types , and c2 adl to specify the configurations . for components it is possible to specify top and bottom ports , to declare internal methods , and to specify the behaviour of its ports . the implementation of the internal methods is done by the developer in the source code generated by a toolset . with c2 adl it is possible to define instances of components and connectors , as well as links between them . [ [ dynamic - reconfiguration - support-2 ] ] dynamic reconfiguration support + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the architectural + modification language ( aml ) was created to extend c2 for supporting dynamic reconfiguration @xcite . aml is a declarative language that uses the structure view of an existing configuration and messages to notify this configuration about a dynamic reconfiguration . this language provides statements to build the scripts that specify dynamic reconfiguration . however , in these scripts it is not possible to determine the moment to apply a dynamic reconfiguration . because that , human intervention is needed via a toolset to trigger dynamic reconfiguration . [ [ initial - architecture-2 ] ] initial architecture + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the tcp / ip stack system is described in c2 idl in fig . [ code : tcpip - c2idl ] and c2 adl in fig . [ code : tcpip - c2adl ] . .... ... component tcpip_transport is interface // define the component ports top_domain is // ports to link high level connectors out ... in receivedata(package : applicationpackage ) ; bottom_domain is // ports to link low level connectors out sendtointernt(package : transportpackage ) ; in ... methods // define interfaces of internal behaviours function pack(data : applicationpackage ) : transportpackage ) ; ... behaviour // describe the external behaviour ... received_messages receivedata ; invoke_methods pack ; always_genarate sendtointernet ; ... end tcpip_transport ... .... .... architecture decoderstream is component_intances { mpeg instantiates tcpip_mpegdecoder ; h263 instantiates tcpip_h263decoder ; transport instantiates tcpip_transport ; internet instantiates tcpip_internet ; link instantiates tcpip_link ; } connectors { application2transport ; transport2internet ; internet2link ; } topology { connector application2transport { top_ports { mpeg filter no_filtering ; } bottom_ports { transport filter no_filtering ; } } connector transport2internet { top_ports { transport filter no_filtering ; } bottom_ports { internet filter no_filtering ; } } connector internet2link { top_ports { internet filter no_filtering ; } bottom_ports { link filter no_filtering ; } } } end decoderstream ; .... [ [ scenario-1 - 2 ] ] scenario 1 + + + + + + + + + + for scenario 1 , for changing the component according to the low or high bandwidth state , it is necessary two c2sadl scripts . in fig . [ code : scenario1-c2sadl ] is described the script for dynamic reconfiguration when bandwidth is low . this script uses two statements , a ` unweld ` for unlinking the @xmath4 instance and ` weld ` for linking the @xmath5 instance . other aml s statements are ` addcomponent ` , ` addconnector ` , ` removecomponent ` , and ` removeconnector ` . all these statements are used with a defined configuration , e.g. line 2 and 3 in fig . [ code : scenario1-c2sadl ] with the configuration named as ` decoderstream ` . despite of the fact that aml statements are based on services of the archstudio tool suite , there are services that are not provided by the aml language , e.g. ` start ( ) ` and ` stop ( ) ` . .... \\ bandwidth is low decoderstream.unweld(mpeg , application2transport ) ; decoderstream.weld(h263 , application2transport ) ; .... [ [ scenario-2 - 2 ] ] scenario 2 + + + + + + + + + + the second scenario , the unforeseen insertion of component instance and type , is inferred as shown in fig . [ code : scenario2-c2sadl ] . inference because both work about aml @xcite stated that it is possible to make insertion and deletion of types . however , they only show examples how to build dynamic reconfiguration at the instance level . et al . _ @xcite mention types and subtypes but at design level . dynamic reconfiguration in fig . [ code : scenario2-c2sadl ] specifies : the insertion of a new type of component ( lines 2 - 5 ) , the creation a new instance of component ( line 9 ) , the unlinking of the instance of ipv4 ( lines 12 - 13 ) , and the linking of the instance of ipv6 ( lines 16 - 17 ) . the component type name is inferred by a toolset before performing dynamic reconfiguration . .... \\ creata a new type of component component tcpip_ipv6 is subtype all < = all tcpip_internet ( ... ) ... end tcpip_ipv6 // create a new instance of component // the name of the type is implicitly discovered decoderstream.addcomponent(tcpip_ipv61 ) ; // unlink the instance of component ipv4 decoderstream.unweld(trasport2internet , tcpip_ipv41 ) ; decoderstream.unweld(tcpip_ipv41 , internet2link ) ; // link the instance of component ipv6 decoderstream.weld(trasport2internet , tcpip_ipv61 ) ; decoderstream.weld(tcpip_ipv61 , internet2link ) ; .... [ [ scenario-3 - 2 ] ] scenario 3 + + + + + + + + + + the third scenario is an improvement of the behaviour that can be modeled by the ` behaviour ` statement via a sequence of invocations to internal methods . example of this change , see line 6 in fig . [ code : scenario3-c2sadl ] , the invocation is modified to verify the received and packed data before sending a transport package to the internet layer . if the change is an improvement of an internal method , it is not possible to describe with c2sadl . .... component tcpip_transport is ... behaviour // describe the external behaviour ... received_messages receivedata ; invoke_methods verifydata , pack ; always_genarate sendtointernet ; ... end tcpip_transport ... .... [ [ summary - of - c2sadl ] ] summary of c2sadl + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + after the c2sadl implementation of the three scenarios , we identified these issues : 1 . archstudio tool provides some services for supporting dynamic reconfiguration , e.g. to start and to stop architectural elements . however , these services are not available in aml . thus , the dynamic reconfiguration specification in aml is limited . 2 . foreseen dynamic reconfiguration needs human intervention because c2sadl do not provide statements for the system apply dynamic reconfiguration . 3 . it does not support the specification of dynamic reconfiguration inside of the architectural elements . because that , the foreseen dynamic reconfiguration is implemented only at the implementation level ; 4 . it does not provide a mechanism for controlling and monitoring the intermediate states of a dynamic reconfiguration ; 5 . it also does not support the assessment of dynamic reconfiguration . [ [ purpose - of - the - adl-3 ] ] purpose of the adl + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + dynamic wright has focus on the structure and behaviour of an architecture @xcite . dynamic wright supports the description of the architectural elements types structures and behaviours , and initial configuration . structure , initial configuration , instances , and links are described in a declarative form , while behaviours are specified in a graph - based and a variant of the communicating sequential process ( csp ) form . [ [ dynamic - reconfiguration - support-3 ] ] dynamic reconfiguration support + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + dynamic wright only supports foreseen dynamic reconfiguration . it is built as a special behaviour of the initial configuration . it has the same base of a `` nominally '' behaviour of architectural elements . the extension described in @xcite proposes additional statements and control events . the statements are ` new ` , ` remove ` , ` attach ` , and ` detach ` . the control events are used to define the specific moment to perform a dynamic reconfiguration . as dynamic wright does not support unforeseen reconfiguration , the scenarios 2 and 3 can not be implemented . [ [ initial - architecture-3 ] ] initial architecture + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the initial configuration of the tcp / ip stack system is illustrated in fig . [ code : scenario1-wright ] . the component and connector types are specified in the ` style ... endstyle ` ( lines 1 - 16 ) statements . the implementation of the ` tcpip_``mpeg - decoder ` component is described with two ports ( lines 3 - 4 ) and a behaviour ( lines 6 - 7 ) . the configuration is described with the ` configuror ... endconfiguror ` statement . the initial configuration instances and connections are specified at lines 18 - 27 . [ [ scenario-1 - 3 ] ] scenario 1 + + + + + + + + + + fig . [ code : scenario1-wright ] also illustrates the specification of scenario 1 . it uses the ` configuror [ initial configuration ] where [ behaviours ] ` statement . _ behaviours _ are special named behaviours of the configuration for specifying dynamic reconfiguration . in this case , there are two specification : lines 29 - 36 for low bandwidth and lines 37 - 44 for high bandwidth . the following steps were used to define the first and the second dynamic reconfiguration situations : 1 . to define a name ( lines 29 and 37 ) . 2 . to specify the control events that define the moment for performing the operations of dynamic reconfiguration ( lines 30 and 38 ) . 3 . to determine the type of configuration to use ( lines 31 and 39 ) . dynamic wright use the term ` style ` for this purpose . 4 . to specify the operations to perform dynamic reconfiguration ( lines 32 - 35 and 40 - 43 ) . 5 . to use the statements of the external choice ( @xmath6 ) and successfully terminate ( @xmath7 ) , lines 36 and 44 . .... style tcpip - style component tcpip_mpeg - decoder port datareceivedfromtransport = ... port requiredservice = ... [ describe the port behaviour using a variant of csp ] computation = ... [ describe the component behaviour using a variant of csp ] ... connector conn2layers role source = ... role sink = ... glue = ... [ describe the connector behaviour using a variant of csp ] constraints ... endstyle configuror decoderstream style tcpip - style new.mpeg : tcpip_mpeg - decoder $ \rightarrow$ new.h263 : tcpip_h263-decoder ... [ other component instances ] $ \rightarrow$ new.app2trans : conn2layers $ \rightarrow$ new.trans2net : conn2layers $ \rightarrow$ new.net2link : conn2layers $ \rightarrow$ attach.mpeg.requiredservice.to.app2trans.source $ \rightarrow$ attach.app2trans.sink.to.transport.service ... [ other attachments ] where waitforbandwidthlow = ( link.control.bandwidthdown $ \rightarrow$ mpeg.control.off $ \rightarrow$ h263.control.on $ \rightarrow$ style tcpip - style detach.mpeg.requiredservice.to.app2trans.source $ \rightarrow$ attach.h263.requiredservice.to.app2trans.source $ \rightarrow$ detach.trans2app.sink.to.mpeg.datareceivedfromtransport $ \rightarrow$ attach.trans2app.sink.to.h263.datareceivedfromtransport ) $ \box$ $ \s$ waitforbandwidthhigh = ( link.control.bandwidthup $ \rightarrow$ h263.control.off $ \rightarrow$ - > mpeg.control.on $ \rightarrow$ style tcpip - style detach.h263.requiredservice.to.app2trans.source $ \rightarrow$ attach.mpeg.requiredservice.to.app2trans.source $ \rightarrow$ detach.trans2app.sink.to.h263.datareceivedfromtransport $ \rightarrow$ attach.trans2app.sink.to.mpeg.datareceivedfromtransport ) $ \box$ $ \s$ endconfiguror .... [ [ summary - of - dynamic - wright ] ] summary of dynamic wright + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the following issues are identified after the implementation of the scenario 1 : 1 . it does not provide operations to define dynamic reconfiguration for the type level of architectural elements ; 2 . this adl provides a refined mechanism of control events to determine the moment to perform a dynamic reconfiguration . although , it does not provide a mechanism to control and monitor the intermediate states . e.g. if the application of the scenario 1 is a banking system , the state must be copied from the instance of the replaced component to the new component . dynamic wright does not provide operations for this purpose . 3 . despite of providing the specification of behaviour for components and connectors , it is not possible to define dynamic reconfiguration for this architectural elements ; 4 . similarly to the other adls , dynamic wright does not provide a mechanism for the assessment of dynamic reconfiguration . the summary of the four adls support for dynamic reconfigurations is shown in tab . [ tab : reconfiguration ] . @xmath0-adl and acme / plastik are the only adls that support both foreseen and unforeseen dynamic reconfigurations . as c2sadl with the aml language do not provide a way to specify an internal initiation of dynamic reconfiguration , foreseen dynamic reconfiguration can not be automatically triggered . dynamic wright supports only foreseen reconfiguration by defining the special behaviour of a configuration . .foreseen and unforeseen dynamic reconfiguration support in adls . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] none of the four adls has a mechanism for assessing the system . @xmath0-adl can rely on @xmath0-aal for defining and analyzing the architectural constraints and non - functional properties . while acme / plastik has armani . even though it has no formal semantics , and therefore , it is not liable to rigorous analysis @xcite . c2sadl provides type verification for events communication . dynamic wright provides a refined mechanism of control events to determine the moment to perform a dynamic reconfiguration . although , the assessment of dynamic reconfiguration is not provided on four adls . in this paper we analysed the support of adls for handling dynamic reconfigurations . we started with a motivation example and some reconfiguration scenarios and we described the example and the scenarios using four well - known adls . we used the example and the specifications to discuss the following issues : ( i ) how each adl addresses the issue of consistently reconfiguring both instances and types ; ( ii ) how each adl takes into account the behaviour of the architectural elements during reconfiguration ; and ( iii ) how each adl supports the assessing of dynamic reconfiguration . in comparison to related works , we analysed some important issues for the dynamic reconfiguration support at the architectural level : foreseen and unforeseen changes ; instance and type level modifications ; structure and behaviour for all architectural elements ; definition of nominally and dynamic reconfiguration behaviour for all architectural elements ; and , the analysis of dynamic reconfiguration . we can conclude that some issues still remain open as no adl provides support for all of them together : how to apply the changes made in type level to their respective instances ? how to control the set of intermediate states of a software system during a dynamic reconfiguration ? how to assess dynamic reconfiguration ? special thanks to collge doctoral international ( cdi)/uni - versit europenne de bretagne ( ueb ) for financial support this work . r. allen , r. douence , and d. garlan . specifying and analyzing dynamic software architectures . in _ proceedings of the 1998 conference on fundamental approaches to software engineering ( fase98 ) _ , lisbon , portugal , march 1998 . an expanded version of a the paper `` specifying dynamism in software architectures , '' which appeared in the proceedings of the workshop on foundations of component - based software engineering , september 1997 . t. v. batista , a. t. a. gomes , g. coulson , c. chavez , and a. f. garcia . on the interplay of aspects and dynamic reconfiguration in a specification - to - deployment environment . in _ proceedings of the 2nd european conference on software architecture _ , ecsa 08 , pages 314317 , berlin , heidelberg , 2008 . springer - verlag . k. h. bennett and v. t. rajlich . software maintenance and evolution : a roadmap . in _ proceedings of the conference on the future of software engineering _ , icse 00 , pages 7387 , new york , ny , usa , 2000 . acm . d. garlan , r. monroe , and d. wile . acme : an architecture description interchange language . in _ proceedings of the 1997 conference of the centre for advanced studies on collaborative research_. ibm press , 1997 . a. gomes , t. v. batista , a. joolia , and g. coulson . . in r. de lemos , c. gacek , and a. romanovsky , editors , _ architecting dependable systems iv _ , volume 4615 of _ lecture notes in computer science _ , pages 237261 . springer berlin / heidelberg , berlin , heidelberg , 2007 . j. magee and j. kramer . self organising system structuring . in _ joint proceedings of the second international software architecture workshop ( isaw ) and international workshop on multiple perspectives in software development ( viewpoints 96 ) on sigsoft 96 workshops _ , isaw 96 , pages 3538 , new york , ny , usa , 1996 . acm press . n. medvidovic , p. oreizy , j. e. robbins , and r. n. taylor . using object - oriented typing to support architectural design in the c2 style . in _ proceedings of the 4th acm sigsoft symposium on foundations of software engineering _ , sigsoft 96 , pages 2432 , new york , ny , usa , 1996 . acm . p. oreizy , m. m. gorlick , r. n. taylor , d. heimbigner , g. johnson , n. medvidovic , a. quilici , d. s. rosenblum , and a. l. wolf . an architecture - based approach to self - adaptive software . , 14(3):5462 , may / june 1999 . p. oreizy , n. medvidovic , and r. n. taylor . architecture - based runtime software evolution . in _ proceedings of the 20th international conference on software engineering _ , icse 98 , pages 177186 , washington , dc , usa , 1998 . ieee computer society . p. oreizy and r. n. taylor . on the role of software architectures in runtime system reconfiguration . in _ configurable distributed systems , 1998 . fourth international conference on _ , pages 6170 , may 1998 . m. pinto , l. fuentes , and j. m. troya . daop - adl : an architecture description language for dynamic component and aspect - based development . in _ proceedings of the 2nd international conference on generative programming and component engineering _ , gpce 03 , pages 118137 , new york , ny , usa , 2003 . springer - verlag new york , inc . r. n. taylor , n. medvidovic , k. m. anderson , j. whitehead , e. james , j. e. robbins , k. a. nies , p. oreizy , and d. l. dubrow . a component- and message - based architectural style for gui software . , 22(6):390406 , june 1996 . j. vera , l. perrochon , and d. c. luckham . event - based execution architectures for dynamic software systems . in _ proceedings of the tc2 first working ifip conference on software architecture ( wicsa ) _ , wicsa , pages 303318 , deventer , the netherlands , the netherlands , 1999 . kluwer , b.v . p. waewsawangwong . a constraint architectural description approach to self - organising component - based software systems . in _ proceedings of the 26th international conference on software engineering _ , icse 04 , pages 8183 , washington , dc , usa , 2004 . ieee computer society .
Abstract: | [
"dynamic reconfiguration is the action of modifying a software system at runtime . several works have been using architectural specification as the basis for dynamic reconfiguration . indeed adls ( architecture description languages ) let architects describe the elements that could be reconfigured as well as the set of constraints to which the system must conform during reconfiguration . in this work , we investigate the adl literature in order to illustrate how reconfiguration is supported in four well - known adls : @xmath0-adl , acme , c2sadl and dynamic wright . from this review , we conclude that none of these adls : ( i ) addresses the issue of consistently reconfiguring both instances and types ; ( ii ) takes into account the behaviour of architectural elements during reconfiguration ; and ( iii ) provides support for assessing reconfiguration , e.g. , verifying the transition against properties ."
] | 8,972 | 8,972 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the study of transport and mixing in coastal flows is of major interest because of their economic and ecological importance . due to the particularities that they present , like influence of complex topography , coastline shape and the direct driving at the surface by highly variable wind forcing , coastal flow dynamics remains still poorly understood . recently , coastal observations and modeling efforts in different regions have been addressed from the lagrangian point of view : @xcite showed that lagrangian coherent structures ( lcss ) computed from velocity fields obtained from hf radar measurements can be used to predict pollutant dispersion in the coast of florida ; @xcite and @xcite detected lcss with hf radar data in the gulf of eliat , israel , and in monterey bay , respectively . @xcite studied small - scale properties of dispersion measurements obtained from hf radar data in the gulf of la spezia , italy . also @xcite have detected lscs in a coastal region with a lyapunov method based on in situ observations . besides radar measurements , lcss obtained from velocity data of high resolution numerical models have been used to analyze the effect of the waves on lcs in the bay of palma , spain @xcite , to study the transport in the tidal flow of ria de vigo , spain @xcite , or to study the water quality of a very small coastal region , the hobie beach , usa @xcite also , data from drifters released in the santa barbara channel were used by @xcite to characterize relative dispersion , very useful to improve lagrangian stochastic models . the application of lagrangian techniques to study the dynamics in a shallow lake ( small closed basin ) has been performed in @xcite . palma is the largest city in the balearic islands . human activities , in particular recreational ones , give to water quality in the bay of palma a large economic value . a proper analysis of transport can be useful to understand the fluid dynamics in the bay and therefore help protect the coastal water . previous studies performed in the bay of palma used eulerian techniques to understand the coastal dynamics @xcite . in this work we study some transport properties in the bay of palma using lagrangian techniques developed from dynamical systems theory . computing both lcss and residence times the bay of palma can be sorted in regions of different properties , for example having more or less connectivity with the open ocean . this kind of studies have demonstrated to be useful to identify pollution pathways or conditions for red tides @xcite . the bay is a semi - enclosed basin located in the southwest of the island of mallorca ( western mediterranean sea ) , whose coastal flow is mainly induced by the wind @xcite . forcing by tides is almost negligible with a tidal amplitude of less than 0.25@xmath1 . this makes the dynamics here different form other locations ( e.g. @xcite ) where tides are dominant , and then provides the opportunity to test the performance of dynamical systems tools in this situation in which forcing only acts directly on the sea surface , and in which there are rather different forcing regimes depending on the season . the lagrangian diagnosis will be obtained from velocity data of a realistic numerical model at high resolution , which resolves spatial scales of a few hundred of meters . we investigate the surface horizontal transport during two months corresponding to different seasons ( autumn and summer ) , and therefore to different wind conditions , in order to highlight the effect of the wind on transport . in the case of july we also study the deepest bottom layer . we compute the barriers and avenues to transport ( lcs ) from lines of high values of finite - size lyapunov exponents ( fsle ) . we also present calculations of residence times and show synoptic lagrangian maps ( slm ) of these times @xcite , which will allow us a detailed visualization of the interchange of fluid particles between the bay and the open sea . the relationship between lcss and areas of different residence times will be analyzed . the organization of this paper is as follows . the data set used in the computations and the area of study is described in section [ sec : data ] . section [ sec : metodo ] presents a brief overview of the lagrangian tools that are used . before presenting the lagrangian results , we show in section [ sec : vel ] a short summary of eulerian results by studying the velocties in the bay . we present in section [ sec : results ] a characterization of stirring in the bay of palma in terms of fsle and residence times . using the definition of lcs given in section [ sec : metodo ] , lagrangian barriers are identified in the domain of interest . we compute escape rates and residence times of fluid particles to describe the transport relation between the bay and the open ocean . we provide possible mechanisms to explain differences in the residences times and fsle between different seasonal months . finally we summarize the main results in section [ sec : conclusion ] . the island of mallorca ( fig . [ fig : location ] ) is part of the balearic islands archipelago and is located in the center of the western mediterranean ( between 39@xmath2 and 40@xmath2n and 2.50@xmath2 and 3.50@xmath2 e ) . the bay of palma is a nearly semi - circular and semi - enclosed basin located in the southwest coast of mallorca and it can reach depths of more than 60 @xmath1 . the bay of palma is defined as the water mass inside the square in fig.[fig : location ] , consisting of a northern limit at 39@xmath234@xmath3n , a southern limit at 39@xmath224@xmath3n , and 2@xmath230@xmath3e and 2@xmath245@xmath3e as the western and eastern limits , respectively . the open boundary to the sea is in the southern part and it is 20 km wide . the size of the bay is smaller than the rossby radius of deformation at these latitudes , and the main circulation is determined by the bathymetry at the bottom layer and by local and remote winds at the surface layer . in particular the studies by @xcite have shown that the major forcing mechanisms come from wind - induced island trapped waves ( itw ) propagating at an island scale and by locally wind - induced mass balance . the intense itw can produce new instabilities which can generate coastal gyres at submesoscale ( see @xcite ) . during summer there are persistent sea breeze conditions . in july and august , the weather is often almost identical from one day to the next . in the vicinity of the bay and along the southern coast of mallorca the breeze blows from the south - west . several studies @xcite , have pointed out that the meteorological conditions of mallorca ( intense solar radiation , clear skies , soil water deficit , dryness , weak surface pressure gradients , etc . ) favors the development of sea breeze , often from april to october , and almost every day during july and august . winds in autumn , and particularly in late september and october are more irregular , with episodes of strong storm activity @xcite . the velocity data sets were obtained from the numerical model roms ( regional ocean model system ) . roms is a free surface , hydrostatic , primitive equation ocean model . the model uses a stretched , generalized nonlinear coordinate system to follow bottom topography in the vertical , and orthogonal curvilinear coordinates in the horizontal @xcite . at each grid point , horizontal resolution @xmath4 is the same in both the longitudinal , @xmath5 , and latitudinal , @xmath6 , directions . we run the simulation with a resolution of @xmath7 ( @xmath8300@xmath1 , roms300 ) , which is itself nested into a larger and coarser grid with @xmath4 = 1/74@xmath2 ( @xmath81500@xmath1 ) . boundary conditions for the coarser domain were taken from daily outputs of the mediterranean forecasting system @xcite . the roms300 domain covers @xmath912@xmath3n - @xmath936@xmath3n ( latitude ) , and @xmath1024@xmath3e - @xmath116@xmath3e ( longitude ) . the total number of grid nodes is 260 @xmath12 148 . vertical resolution is variable with @xmath13 layers in total . all domains were forced using realistic winds provided by the psu / ncar mesoscale model mm5 . the initial vertical structure of temperature and salinity was obtained from the levitus database @xcite . we will manage velocity data from the surface layer and the bottom layer for the grid of @xmath4 @xmath14 300@xmath1 . this domain allows us to analyze the fluid interchange between the bay and the open ocean , using a high resolution velocity field . only horizontal velocities are considered , so that vertical displacements are neglected in the surface layer , and particles in the bottom remain in the bottom layer . this is justified by the small integration times we will use . nevertheless , close to the coast they can have an impact that will be the subject of future work . the output of the model was compared with data from drifters ( see @xcite ) and a reasonable agreement was found , although it improved when adding the influence of wave intensity . thus the present study should be considered as a simplified baseline case against which to compare the future consideration of the full 3d dynamics , or the influence of small scale process such as waves @xcite . we will study two different intervals of time corresponding to two different wind regimes : one starting on october @xmath15th , @xmath16 and finishing on october @xmath17th , @xmath16 ; and the other extending from july @xmath18st , @xmath19 until july @xmath20th , @xmath19 . temporal resolution is 15 minutes and 10 minutes for october and july , respectively , resulting in a total of @xmath21 snapshots of the velocity field for october , and @xmath22 for july . our methodology is based on the lagrangian analysis of marine flows . in the lagrangian view , particles are advected by the flow and their horizontal motion ( neglecting motions between model layers ) is governed by the differential equations @xmath23 where ( @xmath24 ) are the west - east and the south - north coordinates of the trajectories and ( @xmath25 ) are the eastwards and northwards components of the velocity . because of the small sizes involved , we will use a cartesian coordinate system . lcss @xcite , are roughly defined as the material lines organizing the transport in the flow . they are the analogs , for time - dependent flows , of the unstable and stable manifolds of hyperbolic fixed points . among other approaches @xcite , ridges of the local lyapunov exponents provide a convenient tool to locate them . in our case , we use the so - called finite - size lyapunov exponents ( fsles ) which are the adaptation of the asymptotic classical lyapunov exponent to finite spatial scales @xcite . fsles are a local measure of particle dispersion and thus of stirring and mixing , as a function of the spatial resolution , serving to isolate the different regimes corresponding to different length scales of the oceanic flows , very useful in coastal systems @xcite . in fact the first applications of the fsle technique in oceanography were for closed or semi - closed basins @xcite . for two particles of fluid , one of them located at @xmath26 , the fsle at time @xmath27 and at the spatial point @xmath26 is given by the formula : @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the initial distance of the two given particles , and @xmath30 is their final distance . thus , to compute the fsles we need to calculate the minimal time , @xmath31 , needed for the two particles initially separated @xmath29 , to get a final distance @xmath30 ( in this way the fsle represents the inverse time scale for mixing up fluid parcels between length scales @xmath32 and @xmath33 ) . to obtain this time we need to know the trajectories of the particles ( from eqs . ( [ eqsmotiona ] ) and ( [ eqsmotionb ] ) ) which gives the lagrangian character to this quantity . the fsles are computed for the points @xmath26 of a square lattice with lattice spacing coincident with the initial separation of fluid particles @xmath32 . we can obtain a good estimation of the minimal @xmath31 at each site by selecting the trajectory which diverges the first among the four trajectories starting at the neighbors of the given site in the grid of initial conditions . numerically we integrate the equations of motion using a standard , fourth - order runge - kutta scheme , with an integration time step corresponding to the time resolution of the velocity data : @xmath34 minutes in october and @xmath35 minutes in july . we have checked in selected trajectories that using in july the same time step @xmath34 as in october does not alter the trajectories . since velocity information is provided just in a discrete space - time grid , spatiotemporal interpolation of the velocity data is achieved by bilinear interpolation . for the spatial scales that define fsles , we take @xmath36 , i.e. , final separations of about @xmath37 , because of the size of the bay . on the other side , we take @xmath29 equal to @xmath38 , four times smaller than the resolution of the velocity field , @xmath39 . since we are interested only in fast time scales , our integrations are restricted to 5 days . locations for which the final separation at the end of this period has not reached the prescribed @xmath40 ( or for which particles have been trapped by land ) are assigned a value @xmath41 . fsles can be computed from trajectory integration @xmath42 and @xmath43 in time . their highest values as a function of the initial location , * x * , organize in filamental structures approximating relevant manifolds : ridges in the spatial distribution of backward ( forward ) fsles identify regions of locally maximum compression ( separation ) , approximating attracting ( repelling ) material lines or unstable ( stable ) manifolds of hyperbolic trajectories , which can be identified with the lcss @xcite , and characterize the flow from the lagrangian point of view @xcite . attracting lcss associated to backward integration ( the unstable manifolds ) have a direct physical interpretation @xcite . tracers ( chlorophyll , temperature , ... ) spread along these attracting lcss , thus creating their typical filamental structure @xcite . when not stated explicitly , by fsle we will mean the _ backwards _ fsle values . in addition to locate spatial structures , time - averages of fsle give an indication of the intensity of stirring in given areas , which we analyze in sect . [ stirring_mallorca ] . we close this section by noting that the relationship between lcss and lyapunov exponents is based on heuristic arguments which may not be correct in some cases ( see for example @xcite ) . we identify as possible lcss only the locations having the largest values of fsle , which align in linear structures . in this way we effectively select only the highest fsle ridges which are more likely to organize the flow . even in this case , it is possible that the fsle technique identifies regions of high shear which are not hyperbolic and then may lack some of the properties of _ bona fide _ lcss . thus , direct inspection of particle trajectories and comparison with complementary techniques would be needed to confirm the validity of the fsle approach in this situation . one of such complementary techniques is residence time maps that we present in the following section . another characteristic time - scale for transport processes in open flows is the so - called escape rate @xcite . this quantity measures how quickly particles trajectories escape from a domain . if we initiate @xmath44 particles in a flow , we can measure how the trajectories escape the preselected region . in the case in which the decay in the number of particles remaining in the region up to time @xmath45 , @xmath46 , decays exponentially with time , @xmath47 , there is a well - defined escape time defined as the inverse of the escape rate @xmath48 : @xmath49 . for the range of times explored in our work , we will see that the particle escape is close to exponential and then we can estimate the value of @xmath50 . @xmath50 is a global quantity associated to the whole basin . a more detailed description of the transport processes can be obtained by other suitable lagrangian quantities such as residence times @xcite . the particle residence time ( rt ) is defined as the interval of time that a fluid particle remains in a region before crossing a particular boundary . for each fluid particle inside the bay at an initial time , we need to compute two times : the forward exit time , @xmath51 , computed as the time needed for a particle to cross the line delimiting the bay , taking the forward - in - time dynamics ; and the backward exit time , @xmath52 , the same but in the backward - in - time dynamics . the residence time is defined as @xmath53 . rts can be displayed in plots named lagrangian synoptic maps @xcite , in which the residence time of each fluid particle is referenced to its initial position on the grid . a first approach to the transport process in the bay can be a description from the eulerian point of view , by studying averages of the velocity field . to do this we consider separately the meridional @xmath54 and zonal @xmath55 components of the surface flow , and we analyze the time evolution of their spatial averages . figures [ fig : velo ] a ) and b ) show the time series of data taken every 15 min in october and 10 min in july ( black lines ) , and daily average time series ( red lines ) of @xmath56 and @xmath57 for october and july , respectively . the impact of the more variable and stormy weather in october is clear in the high frequency variability of the time - series . during the two months both components of the flow present daily variability related to the presence of land and sea breezes . in july the zonal fluctuations are much more noticeable and regular than the meridional ones , being @xmath58 very small . we have computed the power spectra for both months ( see fig . [ fig : espectro ] ) . in october , in addition to higher power at high frequencies , there are also stronger low - frequency fluctuations . from such features in their spectra of adcp - derived velocities @xcite identified wind - induced island trapped waves as the main source of variability in the bay dynamics , in addition to the local wind ( essentially sea breeze ) . in contrast , the dominant role of sea breeze in july is seen as the very strong dominance of the daily frequency peak at the july zonal spectrum . comparing the velocity components of both months we observe quantitative differences . the values of @xmath57 in the case of october range from -1.0 to 1.5 @xmath59 ( bottom panel of fig . [ fig : velo ] a ) , while in the case of july , @xmath57 is two orders of magnitude smaller , ranging from -0.1 to 0.02 @xmath59 ( bottom panel of fig . [ fig : velo ] b ) . on other hand , @xmath56 are similar during october and july . in october , @xmath56 ranges from -1.5 to 0.5 @xmath59 ( top panel of fig . [ fig : velo ] a ) , the same order of magnitude than the meridional velocity , resulting in circular motions ( clockwise along the bay ) . in july the situation is significantly different . the zonal velocity ranges from -1.5 to 0.7 @xmath59 ( top panel of fig . [ fig : velo ] b ) , much larger than the meridional velocity , resulting in a flow consisting on oscillations along the zonal direction . in october the mean values ( and the standard deviations given in parenthesis ) of the time series are @xmath60 and @xmath61 . in july we have @xmath62 and @xmath63 . the large standard deviation in the zonal velocity in july is an indicator of the large ( breeze induced ) daily fluctuations in this month , but restricted to a single direction of motion . we now describe our lagrangian results . first we compute the temporal average ( over the months of october and july ) of the fsles for the surface layer , and for july in the bottom layer . this calculation helps us to unveil areas of different stirring and the differences between layers and months . the surface computations for the different seasonal months , october and july ( fig . [ fig : promedios_fsle ] a , b ) show different values and spatial distributions of stirring . we use the same colorbar to compare the stirring in both months . the bay of palma appears to be an area with important activity . average fsle field looks more homogeneous in july than in october . during october filamental structures of high values of fsle are accumulated over the northeast side of the bay , forming a linear structure running from north to south - east which comes from similar structures in the instantaneous ( non - averaged ) fields that can act as barriers , therefore dividing the bay in two flow regions of qualitatively different dynamics . the difference in wind regularity and intensity between these months , and the fact that local and remote winds are the main drivers of the bay dynamics , explains the difference in mean stirring distribution among the two months . the importance of wind will be replaced by bottom topography when going to the deep layers . the effect of the terrain topography on stirring is clear in fig . [ fig : promedios_fsle ] c ) , where fsles are computed at the deepest layer for july . the high values of time - averaged fsles are located close to a region of high bathymetry gradient , which seems to act as a barrier along which the flow is stretched . the temporal averages computed in sec . [ stirring_mallorca ] give us a rough idea of stirring in the bay . more detailed information is obtained by looking at non - averaged quantities , that may reveal the existence of barriers to transport . figure [ fig : lcs_oct ] shows the location of the high backward fsle values ( lcss ) , appearing as a network of lines , computed at successive instants of time in october . these temporary structures can remain for one or more days , as happens in october , or they can appear in the same location periodically ( not shown ) . we stress here the appearance of a clear barrier , from north to south - east , that divides the bay in two areas that correlates with the temporal average in fig . [ fig : promedios_fsle ] a ) . this barrier appears in almost the same position in different days , remaining without displacing too much . to effectively see that it acts as a barrier we have considered the evolution of virtual particles released at both sides of the barrier . red and black particles do not mix and they tend to spread along the barrier ( confirming that , as expected , it is an attracting line ) . in july the situation is rather different . lines of high lyapunov exponents ( forward and backwards ) are mainly oriented zonally in the bay ( except close to the opening to the sea ) , which is also the dominant direction of motion . thus , it does not seem that they represent hyperbolic lcs , but rather lines of intense shear between zonally moving strips . in this section we study the surface transport of particles in and out of the bay . to have an idea of the time scales involved in this interchange we proceed by computing the number of particles remaining in the bay , @xmath46 , averaged over different starting times ( separated by @xmath64hours in order to collect the information of diurnal and nocturnal signal ; this gives us 15 different simulations to be averaged for each month ) as a function of the integration time @xmath45 . a particle is considered to leave the bay when crossing the red open - sea boundary in fig . [ fig : location ] , so that particles landing on the coast are considered not escaped . [ fig : promedios_muestreo ] shows the different average decays for october and july . in both cases @xmath46 is reasonably fitted by an exponential in the considered time - range , thus identifying the escape rates @xmath48 = 0.62 and 0.47 @xmath65 , respectively . the corresponding escape times , given by the inverse of the escape rate , are , respectively , @xmath50 = 1.61 and 2.12 @xmath66 . the relative difference of the escape rates of july with respect to october , @xmath67 , is 0.32 . thus the exchange of fluid particles between the bay and the open ocean is a 32@xmath0 more active in autumn than in summer . next we compute synoptic maps of the residence times . as was indicated in sec . [ sec : methods_erslm ] the residence time of the particles throughout the study area is considered as the sum of the entry time ( @xmath68 ) and the escape time ( @xmath69 ) . to compute @xmath69 and @xmath68 particles are initialized every 6 hours in a regular grid of 75@xmath1 spacing and they are integrated forward and backward in time during 5 days . we consider that 5 days is a proper integration time according with the time scales associated with the coastal processes of this small bay , and also owing to the short period of the available data . in these computations we assign the maximum possible value of @xmath51 and @xmath52 ( 5 days ) to the fluid particles that remain in the pre - selected area after the 5 days of integration . in fig . [ fig : snapshots_rt ] we color the initial positions of particles in the bay attending to the time they transit through the bay ( @xmath53 ) for different days . initial positions of particles with short residence times are indicated in blue in fig . [ fig : snapshots_rt ] . regions from where particles have longer residence time ( i.e. take more time between entry and escape ) are marked in red / brown . these maps show that the spatial distribution of residence times of particles can be complex and time depending , presenting different patterns at different times . a number of small structures can be observed , including thin filaments or small lobes . comparing both months , one can see differences in the rt distributions . the most noticeable is the approximate east - west alignment of the zones of similar rt in july , which is not seen in october . also , in october the values of residence times of the particles are smaller , in agreement with the global rate estimations showed before . a common feature is the southwest region with low values of residence times , because in this region there are not coastal boundaries and it is totally open to the ocean . in order to reveal regions with different persistent transport properties we compute time averages of the spatial distributions of residence times . we average 6-hourly snapshots of rt during 15 days ( i.e. 60 snapshots ) for each month . the results , plotted in fig . [ fig : mean_rt ] a ) and b ) , show the common features that , in general , the low values of rt are for particles initiated close to the open ocean , specially in the southwest part , and high values are for particles started near the coast , as expected . however , on average , the residence time is larger in july than in october ( 3.25 days in july and 1.51 days in october ) consistent with the behavior of the corresponding values of @xmath50 . also , in july there is a clear boundary between the interior of the bay to the north , with large average residence times and the open sea to the south , whereas the boundary between high and low residence times in october is well inside the bay , aligned with the lagrangian structure identified from the fsle analysis , as will be discussed in the next section . another feature observed in movies of particle trajectories ( not shown ) is that in october fluid particles tend to circulate mostly clockwise , while in july they are oscillating along the zonal direction ( see section [ sec : vel ] ) . this difference , arising as discussed in sect . [ sec : vel ] from the different regimes of wind forcing , is likely to be responsible for most of the different behavior between both months . we now examine the connection between regions of different residence times with lcss . to compare rt and fsle we have superimposed in fig . [ fig : snapshots_rt ] the filaments of high values of forward ( white ) and backward fsle ( black ) values on the spatial distribution of residence times . the figure shows a good correspondence between many structures of rt and fsle . note that rt is the sum of a forward and a backward exit time , so that some of the strong gradients of rt will correspond to forward and some others to backwards lcss . fig [ fig : snapshots_tb_tf ] shows clearer the correspondence between fsle backwards in time with entry times , and fsle forward with escape times . at least in october , the lcss given by high values of fsle clearly separate regions with different values of residence times , confirming the value of the fsle technique to identify boundaries between different flow regions and barriers to transport . there are however some lines of fsle that are not associated to gradients of rt , and viceversa . for the first this happens mainly because we only integrate 5 days backward and 5 days forward in time , and the time assigned to the particles that not cross the open - ocean boundary in the 5 days of integration corresponds to the maximum time integration ( 5 days ) . this makes the spatial distribution of the residence time more homogeneous . we need to integrate the trajectories longer to unveil more areas with different rt . in the same way not all abrupt changes in rt are captured by fsle lines since we only plot the highest ridges . this illustrates that both techniques have limitations and that the complementary use of both could give a rather complete overview of the geometric structure of flow in marine areas . @xcite studied the relation between residence time and fsle for a wind - forced hydrodynamical model of a shallow lake . they found that areas with long residence time visualize the stable manifolds of the so - called chaotic saddle , a structure controlling the escape properties at long times . in our case , our integrations are restricted to times too short to characterize long - time chaotic behavior , but still there is a good correspondence between the fsle structures characterizing attracting or repelling trajectories , and escape or residence times . [ fig : mean_rt ] a ) shows a time average over october of the spatial distribution of rt , to be compared with the corresponding average figure ( fig . [ fig : promedios_fsle ] a ) for fsle . it is evident that the region in the north and east side of the bay with high values of rt is separated from the rest by a region of high values of fsle . this can be explained by the presence of persistent barriers which do not allow particles to escape from the northeast side of the bay , and thus separating the bay in regions with different residence times . in july the situation is different , because the spatial distribution of fsle ( fig.[fig : promedios_fsle ] b ) and rt ( fig . [ fig : mean_rt ] b ) is almost homogeneous , with higher values over the whole area of the bay , and lower values in the small region bordering the open ocean . this indicates that the instantaneous configurations of high fsle lines ( fig . [ fig : snapshots_rt ] ) are not persistent , and that only there is a persistent large difference between the interior of the bay and its opening to the ocean . the predominantly zonal direction of particle motion in the bay is consistent with the orientation of the boundaries between areas of different rts in july . the differences of residence times and fsles in the two considered months indicate that the dynamics of the flow is qualitatively different , as anticipated by the different wind regimes that are the main drivers of the bay . now we analyze the time evolution of their spatial averages . figures [ fig : fsle_rt ] a ) and b ) show the time series of the spatial mean of residence times ( top panel ) and backward fsle ( bottom panel ) for october and july , respectively . comparison between time evolution of spatial average of the rt for the different months confirms , again , that particles tend to stay longer times in the bay during july than in october . the values of rt vary approximately from 0.25 days to 3 days in october ( fig . [ fig : fsle_rt ] a , top ) , and from 2 days to 6 days in july ( fig . [ fig : fsle_rt ] b , top ) . the same happens with fsle , higher values correspond to july and lower ones to october . diurnal fluctuations , likely related to the effect of the sea breeze , are evident in rt and fsle for both months . in october there are some large fluctuations of low frequency in rt , probably induced by the variability of remote forcing winds . on the other hand , during october , minima of rt correspond to maxima of fsle , and maxima of rt correspond to minima of fsle . in july , the relationship between fsle and rt is looser and only observed in the high - frequency fluctuations . to be more quantitative , pearson correlation coefficient between rt and fsle time series is -0.526 in october , but just -0.223 in july . this difference in behavior probably arises from the fact that high values of fsle determine clear and well - defined barriers to transport only in the case of october ( see sect . [ sec : interchange ] and [ sec : connetion ] ) . in july lines of high fsle remain nearly zonal and parallel to dominant particle direction of motion . thus , as commented in sect . [ sec : lcss ] , they probably represent regions of high zonal shear everywhere in the bay . their high or low values indicate large or small differences in east - west velocities but by themselves they do not imply stronger or weaker escape towards the south . in this subsection we compare the main lagrangian characteristics at the bottom layer , not driven directly by wind , with those at the surface . in fig . [ fig : mean_rt_bottom ] a ) we show an instantaneous map of the residence times in the bottom layer one day of july , overlayed with lines of high fsle values . again , the spatial distribution is inhomogeneous , and we find high values of rt over all the bay except very close to the ocean . the correlation of rt values with fsle lines is weaker than in the upper layer , but still we see that the relatively lower values of rt in the western part of the bay at that particular day appear bounded by backwards fsle lines , indicating a temporal escape route of particles in that region towards the southwest . the spatial distribution of the time average of rt plotted in fig . [ fig : mean_rt_bottom ] b ) shows that highest average values of rt are concentrated in the northwestern region of the bay . [ fig : promedios_fsle ] c ) displays high values of fsle located precisely in the same region where the rt qualitatively change to high values . this suggests the presence of persistent barriers that separate this southeastern region from the rest in this bottom layer . the formation of these persistent lcss is associated to the gradient of the bathymetry ( see fig . [ fig : location ] ) . the time evolution of the spatial average of rt and fsle are plotted in top and bottom panel of fig . [ fig : fsle_rt_bottom ] respectively . contrarily to the surface , in the bottom layer the diurnal fluctuations in the time series of rt disappear , showing that the flow at this depth is not directly influenced by breeze . the rt values are larger than in the surface , and therefore the interchange between the ocean and the bay is less intense at bottom layers . this is a consequence of the slowness of the flow produced by the absence of direct wind forcing at deepest levels . there is a strong negative correlation ( @xmath70 ) between stirring and residence times : when the flow is more dispersive the particles transit during less time over the bay , so that maxima of rt correspond to minima of fsle and vice - versa . properties of coastal transport in the bay of palma , which is a small semi - enclosed region of the island of mallorca , were studied in a lagrangian framework , by using model velocity data at high resolution . we have applied two complementary lagrangian methods ( fsles and rt ) to analyze the small scales of these coastal currents . lcss have been detected as high ridges of fsle , and virtual experiments with particle trajectories have shown that these structures really act as barriers in most cases , organizing the coastal flow . global and average aspects of the transport in different seasonal months show that , in the period studied , in autumn there is more exchange between the bay and the open ocean than in summer . this arises from the different wind regimes in both months , that during july induce a flow that restricts motion of the coastal marine surface to the zonal direction , preventing the flow to enter or escape toward the open ocean . the transport of particles at the deepest layer is less active than at the surface and not directly driven by wind , but influenced by the bottom topography . regions with different values of rt are generally separated by ridges of fsle , proving the fact that fsle separate regions of qualitatively different dynamics also in small coastal regions . thus , we think that these lagrangian quantities can be used as key variables able to determine the dynamics and health of other bays or estuaries , particularly in relation with human activities . future improvements include the adaptation of these methods to three - dimensional spaces and capture three - dimensional effects , such as upwelling and downwelling in coastal areas , and analyzing longer periods of time . i.h - c , c.l and e.h - g acknowledge support from micinn and feder through projects fisicos ( fis2007 - 60327 ) , intense@cosyp ( fis2012 - 30634 ) , and escola ( ctm2012 - 39025-c02 - 01 ) . ao acknowledges financial support from micinn and eu - med programme through projects bus2 ( cgl2011 - 22964 ) and tosca ( 2gmed-09 - 425 ) . we acknowledge the icmat severo ochoa project ( sev-2011 - 0087 ) for the funding of the publication charges of this article . antonov , j. i. , locarnini , r. a. , boyer , t. p. , mishonov , a. v. , and garcia , h. e. : world ocean atlas 2005 , volume 2 : salinity . s. levitus , ed . noaa atlas nesdis 62 , u.s . government printing office , washington , d.c , 2006 . buffoni , g. , falco , p. , griffa , a. , and zambianchi , e. : dispersion processes and residence times in a semi - enclosed basin with recirculating gyres : an application to the tyrrhenian sea , j. geophys . res , 102(c8 ) , 1869918713 , 1997 . dobricic , s. , pinardi , n. , adani , m. , tonani , m. , fratianni , c. , bonazzi , a. , and fernandez , v. : daily oceanographic analyses by mediterranean forecasting system at the basin scale , ocean science , 3 , 149157 , 2007 . dovidio , f. , isern - fontanet , j. , lpez , c. , hernndez - garca , e. , and garca - ladona , e. : comparison between eulerian diagnostics and finite - size lyapunov exponents computed from altimetry in the algerian basin , deep - sea res . i , 56 , 1531 , 2009 . fiorentino , l. a. , olascoaga , m. j. , reniers , a. , feng , z. , beron - vera , f. , and macmahan , j. h. : using lagrangian coherent structures to understand coastal water quality , continental shelf research , 47 , 145149 , 2012 . gildor , h. , fredj , e. , steinbuck , j. , and monismith , s. : evidence for submesoscale barriers to horizontal mixing in the ocean from current meauserements and aerial photographs , journal od physical oceanography , 39 , 19751983 , 2009 . haza , a. c. , zgkmen , t. m. , griffa , a. , molcard , a. , poulain , p .- m . , and peggion , g. : transport properties in small - scale coastal flows : relative dispersion from vhf radar measurements in the gulf of la spezia , ocean dynamics , 60 , 861882 , 2010 . huhn , f. , von kameke , a. , allen - perkins , s. , montero , p. , venancio , a. , and prez - muuzuri , v. : horizontal lagrangian transport in a tidal - driven estuary transport barriers attached to prominent coastal boundaries , continental shelf research , 39 - 40 , 113 , 2012 . lekien , f. , coulliette , c. , mariano , a. j. , ryan , e. h. , shay , l. k. , haller , g. , and marsden , j. : pollution release tied to invariant manifolds : a case study for the coast of florida , physica d , 210 , 120 , 2005 . lipphardt , b. , jr . , small , d. , kirwan , a. , jr . , wiggins , s. , ide , k. , grosch , c. , and paduan , j. : synoptic lagrangian maps : aplication to surface transport in monterey bay , journal of marine research , 64 , 221247 , 2006 . locarnini , r. a. , mishonov , a. v. , antonov , j. i. , boyer , t. p. , and garcia , h. e. : world ocean atlas 2005 , volume 1 : temperature . s. levitus , ed . noaa atlas nesdis 61 , u.s . government printing office , washington , d.c , 2006 . mancho , a. m. , small , d. , and wiggins , s. : a tutorial on dynamical systems concepts applied to lagrangian transport in oceanic flows defined as finite time data sets : theoretical and computational issues , physics reports , 437 , 55 124 , 2006 . oddo , p. , adani , m. , pinardi , n. , fratianni , c. , tonani , m. , and pettenuzzo , d. : a nested atlantic - mediterranean sea general circulation model for operational forecasting , ocean science , 5 , 461473 , 2009 . orfila , a. , jordi , a. , basterretxea , g. , vizoso , g. , marba , n. , duarte , c. , werner , f. , and tintor , j. : residence time and posidonia oceanica in cabrera archipelago national park , spain , continental shelf research , 25 , 13391352 , 2005 . rypina , i. , scott , s. e. , pratt , l. j. , and brown , m. g. : investigating the connection between complexity of isolated trajectories and lagrangian coherent structures , nonlin . processes geophys , 18 , 977987 , 2011 . shadden , s. c. , lekien , f. , and marsden , j. e. : definition and properties of lagrangian coherent structures from finite - time lyapunov exponents in two dimensional aperiodic flows , physica d , 212 , 271304 , 2005 . shadden , s. c. , lekien , f. , paduan , j. d. , chavez , f. p. , and marsden , j. e. : the correlation between surface drifters and coherent structures based on high - frequency radar data in monterey bay , deep sea research part ii : topical studies in oceanography , 56 , 161 172 , 2009 . , e. , rossi , v. , sudre , j. , weimerskirch , h. , lpez , c. , hernndez - garca , e. , marsac , f. , and garon , v. : top marine predators track lagrangian coherent structures , proceedings of the national academy of sciencies of the usa , 106 , 82458250 , 2009 .
Abstract: | [
"coastal transport in the bay of palma , a small region in the island of mallorca , spain , is characterized in terms of lagrangian descriptors . the data sets used for this study are the output for two months ( one in autumn and one in summer ) of a high resolution numerical model , roms , forced atmospherically and with a spatial resolution of 300 m. the two months were selected because its different wind regime , which is the main driver of the sea dynamics in this area . finite - size lyapunov exponents ( fsles ) were used to locate semi - persistent lagrangian coherent structures ( lcs ) and to understand the different flow regimes in the bay . the different wind directions and regularity in the two months have a clear impact on the surface bay dynamics , whereas only topographic features appear clearly in the bottom structures . the fluid interchange between the bay and the open ocean was studied by computing particle trajectories and residence times ( rt ) maps . the escape rate of particles out of the bay is qualitatively different , with a 32@xmath0 more of escape rate of particles to the ocean in october than in july , owing to the different geometric characteristics of the flow . we show that lcss separate regions with different transport properties by displaying spatial distributions of residence times on synoptic lagrangian maps together with the location of the lcss . correlations between the time - dependent behavior of fsle and rt are also investigated , showing a negative dependence when the stirring characterized by fsle values moves particles in the direction of escape ."
] | 8,014 | 8,014 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the quantum ising chain is a useful theoretical laboratory in which fundamental issues concerning quantum many - body systems can be thoroughly investigated , exploiting the exact knowledge of several features of its phase diagram and quantum correlations . many results for its low - energy properties have been derived in the quantum ordered and disordered phases , and , in particular , at the quantum critical point separating the two phases , both in the thermodynamic limit and in the finite - size scaling ( fss ) limit with several types of boundary conditions , see , e.g. , refs . @xcite and references therein . in this paper we extend these analytic results to the case in which boundary fields are present . we present a detailed study of the quantum ising chain in a transverse magnetic field @xcite in the presence of magnetic fields coupled with the order - parameter spin operator , located at the boundaries of the chain . we assume the two magnetic fields to have the same strength and consider two cases : ( i ) the two fields are parallel ; ( ii ) the two fields are oppositely aligned . as expected , in the quantum paramagnetic phase the boundary fields do not change the large - size behavior of low - energies quantities . at the critical point , bulk behavior is independent of boundary conditions . however , the magnetic fields induce a surface phase transition with a corresponding scaling behavior . the quantum ferromagnetic phase is more interesting . if the boundary fields have opposite direction , one observes two different bulk phases . for small magnetic fields , the ground state is ferromagnetic as it occurs in the absence of boundary interactions . on the other hand , kink states @xcite are the relevant low - energy excitations for large boundary fields . the two different phases are separated by a continuous transition that is only characterized by the nature of the two coexisting phases and , indeed , the same transition occurs in ising rings in the presence of a localized link defect @xcite . because of the quantum - to - classical mapping , our results can also be applied to the two - dimensional ising model , and , more generally , to any model in the ising universality class , in a strip geometry . in the two - dimensional case the quantum transition between the ferromagnetic and the kink phase corresponds to the wetting transition , which , in the context of a strip geometry , is sometimes identified as an interface localization / delocalization transition @xcite . our results , therefore , provide new analytic expressions for two - dimensional ising systems at the wetting transition in the presence of boundary magnetic fields . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ model ] we introduce the one - dimensional quantum ising chain with boundary fields . in sec . [ fermmodel ] we compute the low - energy spectrum by exploiting the equivalent quadratic fermionic formulation of the hamiltonian @xcite . explicit calculations are reported in the following sections . [ paramag ] , [ critpoint ] and [ magnphase ] report results for the quantum paramagnetic phase , at the quantum critical point and for the ordered magnetized phase , respectively . [ fktra ] is devoted to the study of the magnet - to - kink transition driven by the boundary fields in the ordered phase . we obtain exact results for the gap , the magnetization profile , the two - point spin - spin correlation function , and the entanglement entropy . in sec . [ comp-2d ] these results are compared with the existing ones for two - dimensional classical models . finally , in sec . [ conclu ] we summarize the main results and draw our conclusions . a number of appendices report the derivations of some of the results . the hamiltonian of the quantum ising chain in a transverse magnetic field is given by @xmath1 where @xmath2 are the pauli matrices . in the following we assume ferromagnetic nearest - neighbor interactions with @xmath3 , and @xmath4 . the ising chain undergoes a continuous transition at @xmath5 @xcite , separating a quantum ferromagnetic phase ( @xmath6 ) from a quantum paramagnetic phase ( @xmath7 ) . in this paper we investigate the effects of boundary magnetic fields aligned along the @xmath8 axis . they give rise to an additional energy term @xmath9 that is added to hamiltonian ( [ isc ] ) . in the following we shall consider the model in the specific case of equal parallel boundary fields ( pbf ) @xmath10 and of equal oppositely - aligned boundary fields ( obf ) @xmath11 it is not restrictive to assume @xmath12 in both cases . we will often use a basis in which @xmath13 is diagonal . states will be labelled as @xmath14 , where @xmath15 is the eigenvalues of @xmath16 . signs will be fixed so that @xmath17 has the form @xmath18 in this basis . in the absence of boundary fields , the hamiltonian commutes with the generator @xmath19 of the @xmath20 transformations @xmath21 and with the operator @xmath22 of the reflection transformations defined by @xmath23 . these operators do not generally commute with @xmath24 . however , note that @xmath25=0 $ ] for obf . in this paper we analyze the low - energy spectrum of the model . in particular , we compute the energy differences between the lowest states and the ground state @xmath26 ( here @xmath27 are the energy eigenvalues ordered so that @xmath28 , and @xmath29 is the gap ) , the local magnetization and the two - point correlation function , @xmath30 for obf , because of the symmetry under @xmath31 , we have @xmath32 and , as a consequence , the average magnetization @xmath33 always vanishes . we also define the integrated correlation @xmath34 and the correlation length @xmath35 with respect to the center of the chain : @xmath36 to determine the spectrum of hamiltonian ( [ isc ] ) , we extend the model , considering two additional spins located in 0 and @xmath37 and the hamiltonian @xmath38 this is the ising hamiltonian with two different couplings on the boundary links and zero transverse field on the boundaries . let us note that the hamiltonian @xmath39 commutes with both @xmath40 and @xmath41 , which can therefore be simultaneously diagonalized . the hilbert space can be divided into four sectors , which we label as @xmath42 , @xmath43 , @xmath44 and @xmath45 , where @xmath46 are the eigenvalues of @xmath40 and @xmath41 . the restriction of @xmath39 to each sector gives rise to the hamiltonian @xmath47 , defined in eq . ( [ isc ] ) , with a boundary term of the form ( [ hb ] ) . hence , the spectrum of @xmath39 also provides the spectrum of @xmath48 . let us also note that @xmath39 is @xmath49 symmetric . indeed , if @xmath50 , then @xmath51 = 0 $ ] . since @xmath52 does not commute with @xmath40 and @xmath41 , the spectrum is necessarily degenerate . moreover , since @xmath52 anticommutes with these two boundary operators , @xmath52 maps sector @xmath42 to @xmath45 and @xmath44 to @xmath43 , so that the restriction of @xmath39 to @xmath53 allows us to compute the full spectrum of @xmath39 . to compute the spectrum of hamiltonian ( [ def - hextended ] ) , we follow ref . @xcite . we first perform a jordan - wigner transformation , defining fermionic operators @xmath54 and @xmath55 @xmath56 where @xmath57 . these relations can be inverted , obtaining @xmath58 thus , hamiltonian ( [ def - hextended ] ) becomes @xmath59 with @xmath60 for @xmath61 . in this formalism @xmath62 and @xmath63 . to go further , let us rewrite @xmath39 as @xmath64,\ ] ] with @xmath65 and @xmath66 symmetric and antisymmetric matrices , respectively . then , we perform a bogoliubov transformation . we introduce new canonical fermionic variables @xmath67 where @xmath68 and @xmath69 are fixed by the requirement that @xmath47 takes the form @xmath70 with @xmath71 following ref . @xcite , we define the vectors @xmath72 the variables @xmath73 satisfy canonical anticommutation relations if the vectors @xmath74 form an orthonormal basis , and so does the set @xmath75 . the vectors @xmath75 satisfy @xmath76 which turns the determination of the energies @xmath77 into an eigenvalue problem . if @xmath77 does not vanish , @xmath74 is given by @xmath78 if @xmath77 is zero , @xmath74 is the null eigenvector of @xmath79 . it is also possible to evaluate the constant @xmath80 in eq . ( [ h1-diag ] ) , which provides the energy of the ground state : @xmath81 the matrix @xmath82 is given by ( we write the @xmath83 matrix @xmath84 for @xmath85 , the generalization to any @xmath0 being obvious ) @xmath86 this matrix @xmath84 has a zero eigenvalue , @xmath87 , with eigenvector @xmath88 . correspondingly , we obtain @xmath89 and @xmath90 which depends only on the boundary fermion operators . note that it can be rewritten as a combination of @xmath40 , @xmath41 , and @xmath52 , hence it does not represent an additional symmetry of the hamiltonian . the presence of a zero eigenvalue was expected , as the spectrum is degenerate . if @xmath91 and @xmath92 do not vanish , since there is only one fermion operator with zero energy , the spectrum is doubly degenerate . let us now consider the nonzero eigenvalues . since the vectors @xmath75 are an orthonormal set , orthogonality with @xmath93 implies @xmath94 . it follows analogously @xmath95 . therefore , we have for @xmath96 @xmath97 where the dots represent a polynomial in @xmath98 and @xmath99 with @xmath100 . it is then easy to verify that @xmath101 = 0.\ ] ] it follows that , if a state @xmath102 satisfies @xmath103 , then we have @xmath104 . analogously , if @xmath105 , we have latexmath:[$\sigma_{l+1}^{(1)}\eta_k |\psi\rangle = s_1 \eta_k sector @xmath46 , then @xmath107 belongs to sector @xmath108 . to conclude , we should determine to which sectors the two degenerate ground states belong . if @xmath91 and @xmath92 are both positive , we expect the ground - state configurations to be ordered . therefore , if on one boundary the spin is directed in the positive @xmath8 direction , we expect the same to occur at the other end of the chain . therefore , we conclude that the ground states belong to sectors @xmath109 and @xmath45 . this identification is supported by exact diagonalization . we can now classify the states . we only consider the states with @xmath110 , to avoid the double degeneracy . then , if @xmath111 we have : * in the sector @xmath112 , @xmath113 , the lowest energy state is the ground state of the hamiltonian and all states are obtained as @xmath114 , @xmath115 , with @xmath116 even . the first excited state is @xmath117 and the energy gap is @xmath118 . * in the sector @xmath112 , @xmath119 , the lowest energy state is the first excited state @xmath120 of the hamiltonian @xmath39 and all states are obtained as @xmath121 , @xmath115 , with @xmath116 odd . in particular , the first excited state in the sector is @xmath122 , so that the energy gap is @xmath123 . the first case is relevant when considering @xmath124 in the boundary hamiltonian @xmath24 , which are identified with @xmath91 and @xmath92 , respectively . the second case is relevant when @xmath125 and @xmath126 have opposite signs : the corresponding gap is obtained by identifying @xmath127 and @xmath128 . the energy spectrum of hamiltonian @xmath39 can be computed exactly , as discussed in [ app.a ] . here we will focus on the case @xmath129 , which allows us to derive the spectrum for parallel or opposite equal magnetic fields at the boundary , cf . ( [ pbfdef ] ) and ( [ obfdef ] ) , respectively . neglecting the irrelevant zero eigenvalue , we obtain @xmath37 elementary excitations whose energy @xmath130 is given by @xmath131 where @xmath132 are the @xmath37 solutions of the equation @xmath133 \sin k l = \label{secular - equation}\\ & & \quad g ( 1 - 2 g \cos k + g^2 - \zeta^4 ) \sin [ k ( l+1 ) ] . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we should consider real solutions in @xmath134 ( correspondingly @xmath135 ) , purely imaginary solutions @xmath136 with @xmath137 ( correspondingly @xmath138 ) , and solutions @xmath139 ( correspondingly @xmath140 ) . equation ( [ secular - equation ] ) has also a spurious solution for @xmath141 for all values of the parameters , which should be discarded . for @xmath142 , there is also a second solution with @xmath143 , which corresponds to a true excitation of the model . for @xmath144 we obtain the equation appropriate for open boundary conditions ( obc ) @xcite , @xmath145 and @xmath146 , which implies an additional zero mode for @xmath39 . this is not surprising as the spectrum has a fourfold degeneracy for @xmath147 : the four sectors are equivalent in the absence of boundary fields . the real solutions of eq . ( [ secular - equation ] ) are obtained by solving @xmath148\cos k + 2 g^2 \cos^2 k}. \label{realtankl}\ ] ] the imaginary solutions are obtained by setting @xmath149 . ( [ secular - equation ] ) then becomes @xmath150 ^ 2 \over ( g - e^h ) ( e^h g - 1 + \zeta^2)^2 } . \label{equazione - j1eqj2-small}\ ] ] the corresponding energies @xmath151 are always smaller than those corresponding to real momenta , hence the localized states are the most important ones in the determination of the low - energy spectrum . for @xmath152 ( paramagnetic phase ) the lowest energy state is a localized state , i.e. , a solution of eq . ( [ equazione - j1eqj2-small ] ) with @xmath137 . for large values of @xmath0 we must consider the poles in the right - hand side of the equation . they are @xmath153 for @xmath152 , the second equation does not have any solution . the relevant pole is the first one , so that the relevant solution can be written as @xmath154 . for large values of @xmath0 , substituting this expression in eq . ( [ equazione - j1eqj2-small ] ) , we obtain @xmath155 correspondingly , we find @xmath156 the energy @xmath157 vanishes with exponentially small corrections . the energy of the second excited state corresponds to the lowest value @xmath158 of @xmath159 satisfying eq . ( [ realtankl ] ) . we obtain @xmath160 and @xmath161 the system is therefore gapped , and the same gap is obtained for both pbf and obf modulo exponentially small corrections , since @xmath162 : @xmath163 note that the same result would have been obtained for obc , confirming that boundary conditions and/or boundary fields are irrelevant in the paramagnetic quantum phase . at the critical point @xmath165 , there are no localized solutions , hence the two lowest energies @xmath166 are obtained by considering eq . ( [ realtankl ] ) . the equation becomes @xmath167 the lowest - energy solutions correspond to momenta that scale as @xmath168 . therefore , we can expand the right - hand side in powers of @xmath159 , obtaining @xmath169 which shows that @xmath170 must diverge for @xmath171 . this fixes @xmath172 with @xmath173 including the corrections , we obtain for the two lowest momenta @xmath174 so that @xmath175 these results imply that the pbf and obf gaps are @xmath176 respectively . note that the amplitude of the @xmath177 term differs from that obtained in the obc case ( corresponding to @xmath178 ) @xcite , @xmath179 indicating that @xmath144 is a surface critical point . as we have discussed in ref . @xcite in the obc case , the corrections of order @xmath177 to the leading behavior can be interpreted as the effect of a nonlinear scaling field associated with @xmath0 : the leading irrelevant boundary operator gives corrections that scale as @xmath180 . the same holds in the presence of boundary fields . indeed , we can define a new length scale @xmath181 so that @xmath182 using the previously reported expressions we obtain @xmath183 note that the same rescaling applies both to pbf and obf , a result which is not obvious in the original formulation , but which has a natural explanation in the present setting in which we consider @xmath39 . indeed , the rescaling should cancel the leading correction in the whole low - energy spectrum of @xmath39 , hence in all low - energy excitation energies @xmath77 . therefore , it should apply to both pbf and obf . since @xmath144 is a surface critical point and the boundary term is a relevant perturbation , we can study the crossover behavior close to @xmath144 . the relevant scaling variable is @xmath184 . therefore , in the limit @xmath185 , @xmath171 at fixed @xmath186 we have @xmath187 where the function @xmath188 depends on the type , obf or pbf , of boundary fields . in the scaling limit defined above , momenta scale as @xmath189 . using eq . ( [ seceq - g1 ] ) , we obtain an implicit equation for @xmath190 : @xmath191 therefore , to compute the scaling function , one determines the two lowest values of @xmath190 satisfying eq . ( [ scaling - b - boundary ] ) and uses them to determine the gap as before . the scaling curves are reported in fig . [ fss - crossover - etab ] . let us now consider the scaling behavior in a neighborhood of the critical point @xmath165 . the corresponding scaling variable is @xmath192 the relevant equations are obtained from eqs . ( [ realtankl ] ) and ( [ equazione - j1eqj2-small ] ) by expanding the right - hand sides in the limit @xmath193 , @xmath171 , @xmath194 at fixed @xmath195 and @xmath196 . as expected , as long as @xmath197 , we obtain a result that is independent of @xmath198 : the fss behavior only depends on the nature of the boundary conditions , but not on the specific values of the boundary fields . a localized state exists only for @xmath199 . if we set @xmath200 , the parameter @xmath201 is a solution of the equation @xmath202 the corresponding excitation energy is @xmath203 note that @xmath204 for @xmath205 , so that @xmath206 in the limit . on the other hand , for @xmath207 we obtain @xmath208 so that @xmath209 , consistently with eq . ( [ cale1_para ] ) . the propagating modes can be written as @xmath210 , where @xmath211 are the positive solutions of the equation @xmath212 with @xmath213 ( the solution with @xmath214 only exists for @xmath215 ) . the corresponding excitation energies are then @xmath216 . using these results we obtain for the energy gap in the fss limit : @xmath217 the two signs refer to the case of parallel ( plus sign ) and opposite ( minus sign ) boundary fields . the curves are reported in fig . [ fss - delta1 ] together with the corresponding obc scaling function . in the paramagnetic phase all curve have a similar shape they coincide asymptotically while in the phase @xmath218 ( @xmath219 ) , the behavior is clearly different . for @xmath220 , we have @xmath221 , @xmath222 , and @xmath223 . it is interesting to discuss the scaling corrections , that can be easily shown to decay as @xmath177 , as it occurs for @xmath144 . in ref . @xcite we argued that such corrections are not associated with irrelevant boundary operators , which give rise to corrections of order @xmath180 , but that they should be interpreted as due to nonlinear scaling fields . the same holds for @xmath197 . first , one should consider the effective length @xmath181 defined in eq . ( [ leff - def ] ) . then , one should consider the nonlinear scaling field @xmath224 associated with @xmath225 and , finally , rescale the energies with the _ sound velocity _ @xmath226 . the nonlinear scaling fields do not depend on the boundary conditions , hence we can use the expressions reported in ref . @xcite : @xmath227 then , we define the new scaling variable @xmath228 and express @xmath211 and @xmath201 as functions of @xmath229 . a somewhat lengthy calculation shows that @xmath230 can be written as in eq . ( [ gap - gcritico ] ) , with @xmath229 replacing @xmath195 , with corrections that scale as @xmath231 . as expected , the leading corrections cancel out . [ magnphase ] let us now consider the case @xmath218 . in the infinite - volume limit , there exist two degenerate ground states @xmath232 and @xmath233 , which differ by the value of the magnetization @xcite @xmath234 where @xmath235 is a bulk magnetic field applied along the @xmath8 direction . for a chain of finite size @xmath0 , the degeneracy is lifted . in the obc case , the energy difference between the two lowest - energy states vanishes exponentially as @xmath0 increases @xcite : @xmath236 . \label{deltaobc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , @xmath237 by symmetry , and @xmath238 these are the standard features of a quantum ferromagnetic phase with a spontaneously broken @xmath49 symmetry . we now extend the discussion to the case in which boundary fields are present , considering equal pbf and obf . to identify localized states , we consider eq . ( [ equazione - j1eqj2-small ] ) . the relevant solutions are associated with the poles in the right - hand side of the equation , see eq . ( [ equazione - poli ] ) . it is immediate to verify that there are no poles for @xmath239 , while a pole exists in the opposite case . therefore , we distinguish three different cases , depending on whether @xmath198 is smaller , larger , or equal to @xmath240 for @xmath241 , the two lowest - energy excitations corresponding to @xmath157 and @xmath242 are localized . we have @xmath243 ( @xmath137 ) with @xmath244 where @xmath245 and @xmath201 is a correction term . let us first obtain a large-@xmath0 expression for @xmath201 that is uniform as @xmath246 . this requires particular care as the right - hand side of eq . ( [ equazione - j1eqj2-small ] ) has a different singular behavior for @xmath144 and @xmath247 . for @xmath144 , it has a simple pole as @xmath248 . on the other hand , for @xmath249 , it has a double pole for @xmath250 . to compute @xmath201 we set @xmath251 in all terms of eq . ( [ equazione - j1eqj2-small ] ) that are not relevant for the singular behavior as @xmath171 , i.e. , we write @xmath252 with @xmath253 equation ( [ eq - magn-1 ] ) is a second - order algebraic equation of @xmath254 , whose solutions are @xmath255 the energies @xmath256 are correspondingly @xmath257 and @xmath258 , @xmath259 . there are now two interesting cases . first , we take the limit @xmath260 at fixed @xmath261 . we can then simplify eq . ( [ epm - general ] ) , obtaining @xmath262 these results imply @xmath263 in the pbf case the gap is finite and proportional to @xmath198 for small fields . instead , @xmath264 vanishes exponentially , as in the obc case ( which corresponds to vanishing boundary fields ) . a second possibility consists in considering the fss limit around @xmath144 . as discussed in ref . @xcite , the ratio @xmath265 is expected to become a function of @xmath266 ( to compare with the formulae of ref . @xcite note that the energy associated with the perturbation is here proportional to @xmath198 , without additional factors of @xmath0 ) . in this limit @xmath267 is proportional to @xmath268 . using the expression for @xmath269 reported in eq . ( [ deltaobc ] ) , we obtain @xmath270 so that @xmath271 note that the scaling function agrees with that predicted in ref . we can also consider the ratio @xmath272 in the same limit , but in this case we obtain that the ratio is simply equal to 1 , i.e. , independent of @xmath268 . the reason can be easily understood . for obf the energy associated with the perturbation is zero the contributions of the two boundaries cancel hence @xmath273 identically . for @xmath274 there are no localized states . the secular equation ( [ realtankl ] ) can be rewritten as @xmath275 for @xmath171 , the solutions can be parametrized as @xmath276 it follows that @xmath277 for large values of @xmath0 we obtain finally @xmath278 note that the correction term @xmath279 diverges as @xmath280 and has a finite limit as @xmath281 . moreover , the explicit form of the hamiltonian is only relevant for the corrections . it follows @xmath282 we obtain finally @xmath283 for obf , the gap vanishes for @xmath171 . however , while the approach is exponential for @xmath241 , we have @xmath284 for large fields . for pbf , the system is gapped as for @xmath285 . however , in this case corrections are of order @xmath180 . the gap equation is particularly simple . we obtain a solution @xmath287 and @xmath288 hence @xmath289 with no @xmath0 dependence . as for the other states we obtain @xmath290 with @xmath291 . it follows @xmath292 , as for @xmath293 . however , corrections , of order @xmath180 , are a factor of five smaller compared to the large - field case . for obf we obtain the asymptotic behavior @xmath294 as in the large - field case , @xmath264 scales as @xmath180 . however , the prefactor differs by a factor of 3 from that obtained for @xmath295 , cf . ( [ deltalk ] ) . we wish now to compute the ground - state magnetization and the corresponding two - point spin - spin correlation function in the magnetized phase , i.e. , for @xmath296 . in the pbf case , the system is magnetized , hence we expect @xmath297 and @xmath298 to be both independent of @xmath299 and @xmath300 , except possibly close to the boundaries , and to be equal to @xmath301 and @xmath302 , respectively , where @xmath301 is given in eq . ( [ modef ] ) . thus , the boundary magnetic fields have the only role of lifting the degeneracy . the obf case is more interesting . in [ app.b ] we have fully characterized the ground state of the model for small values of @xmath303 . we find that for it is ferromagnetic for @xmath285 ( this is consistent with the results for the gap discussed above ) . for @xmath293 kink states @xcite are the relevant low - energy excitations , while for @xmath304 the ground state is a superposition of kink and ferromagnetic states . the exact knowledge of the ground state allows us to compute the ground - state magnetization and the correlation function perturbatively in @xmath303 . for obf we find that @xmath305 vanishes in the low - field case except at the boundaries , depends linearly on @xmath299 for @xmath286 , and varies in a simple fashion for @xmath274 . we expect the same space dependence for all finite values of @xmath306 in the large-@xmath0 universal limit , modulo a multiplicative renormalization . if we set @xmath307 and @xmath308 , so that the center of the chain corresponds to @xmath309 , we predict @xmath310 \displaystyle{m(x)\over m_0 } = \displaystyle{x\over \ell } & \qquad { \zeta = \zeta_c } , \\[2 mm ] \displaystyle{m(x)\over m_0 } = 0 & \qquad { \zeta < \zeta_c}. \end{array } \label{magnetization - scaling}\ ] ] these relation should hold in the limit @xmath311 , @xmath312 at fixed @xmath313 , except possibly at the boundary , i.e. , for @xmath314 . here @xmath301 is the bulk magnetization of the system in the infinite - volume limit defined in eq . ( [ modef ] ) . it is interesting to note that the linear behavior of the magnetization for @xmath315 is due to the fact that the ground state is translationally invariant : the space probability of the kinks is independent of @xmath8 . due to the presence of the boundary fields , the translation invariance of the kink space distribution is not trivial and , indeed , it does not hold for @xmath295 . to check these predictions and study the approach to the asymptotic behavior , we perform numerical simulations using the density matrix renormalization - group ( dmrg ) method @xcite . for convenience , we consider chains with odd @xmath0 , setting @xmath316 ( since we are considering ferromagnetic interactions , the low - energy properties do not depend on this feature , unlike the antiferromagnetic case , see , e.g. , ref . the results for the magnetization are shown in fig . [ magnetization - fasi ] . for @xmath285 , the magnetization vanishes in a large interval around @xmath317 , assuming positive and negative values only close to the boundaries . note that the region in which @xmath318 shrinks as @xmath0 increases , conferming the validity of eq . ( [ magnetization - scaling ] ) in the large-@xmath0 limit at fixed @xmath313 . for @xmath293 we show results for two values of @xmath303 . once we renormalize @xmath319 by using @xmath301 , i.e. , we consider the ratio @xmath320 , results fall one on top of the other , confirming universality . the results are in full agreement with the expressions ( [ magnetization - scaling ] ) . the same arguments apply to the correlation function @xmath298 . extending the small-@xmath303 results of [ app.b ] to the whole low-@xmath303 phase , we predict @xmath321 in the large-@xmath0 limit . therefore , the correlation function should be constant in the magnetized phase , @xmath322 , it should depend linearly on @xmath323 for @xmath304 , while it should have a sinusoidal dependence in the kink phase . again , we check these predictions by comparing them with dmrg data . they are reported in fig . [ gx - fasi ] . the dmrg data approach the theoretical predictions with increasing @xmath0 , confirming the theoretical predictions . as already discussed in ref . @xcite , in the case of obf and for @xmath218 , an interesting universal scaling behavior is observed for @xmath280 . such a transition is uniquely characterized by the nature of two phases occurring for @xmath285 and @xmath324 : on one side the ground state is ferromagnetic , while on the other side kink states are the relevant low - energy excitations . this characterization is confirmed by the analysis of the ising chain on a ring with a bond defect : at the boundary of the two phases one observes @xcite a behavior analogous to the one discussed here . here , we will report the computation of the energy gap the result was already presented in ref . @xcite and additional results for the local magnetization , correlation function , and entanglement entropy . moreover , we will discuss the density of the fermionic modes in the equivalent fermionic picture of the model @xcite , showing that the transition can be interpreted as a localization transition of the fermionic states at the boundaries . the crossover behavior around the transition is parametrized in terms of the scaling variable @xcite @xmath325 then , in the large-@xmath0 limit we have @xmath326 in general , the scaling functions @xmath327 and @xmath328 are expected to be universal modulo a @xmath303-dependent normalization ( which is independent of the observable considered ) of the argument @xmath329 . the @xmath303 dependent prefactor appearing in eq . ( [ etasdef ] ) is the required nonuniversal factor . it is determined in sec . [ sec7.1 ] , analyzing the scaling behavior of the gap @xmath264 . according to renormalization - group theory , this normalization factor is independent of the observable considered , hence also the scaling functions of other observables should be independent of @xmath303 apart from a multiplicative factor ( not present if renormalization - group invariant ratios are considered ) , once @xmath329 is used as scaling variable . the results we will present for the magnetization and the two - point correlation function confirm this prediction . beside the gap @xmath330 , we also consider the integrated correlation @xmath34 defined in eq . ( [ chixidef ] ) . it satisfies the scaling relation @xmath331 where @xmath332 is universal , i.e. , @xmath303 independent . these results allow us to define the rg dimensions of the different operators . in general , we expect @xmath333,\qquad \chi = a_\chi l^{d - y_\sigma } f_\chi [ l^{y_\zeta } ( \zeta-\zeta_c ) ] . \label{scalzetas}\ ] ] comparison with our results allows us to identify @xmath334 , @xmath335 , and @xmath336 . the latter result is consistent with the fact that a bulk magnetic field coupled to @xmath337 drives a first - order quantum transition , see , e.g. , ref . @xcite . by defining @xmath329 as in eq . ( [ etasdef ] ) we have implicitly assumed that we are fixing @xmath303 and varying @xmath198 close to the critical value @xmath338 . in some contexts , however , it is more natural to consider a different point of view . the boundary field strength @xmath198 is fixed ( it should satisfy @xmath339 ) and @xmath303 is varied in a neighborhood of the critical value @xmath340 . in this case we have @xmath341 where the @xmath198 dependent prefactor guarantees that scaling functions are the same for all values of @xmath198 . to determine the scaling behavior of the energy gap @xmath342 , we first simplify the secular equation ( [ secular - equation ] ) , by taking the limit @xmath343 at fixed @xmath329 . in this limit @xmath159 scales as @xmath177 , so that we set @xmath344 . for @xmath171 the secular equation becomes @xmath345 expressing @xmath346 as a function of @xmath347 , we find that the solutions of eq . ( [ sec - etac-1 ] ) satisfy one of the two equations @xmath348 if @xmath349 and @xmath350 are the positive solutions of eqs . ( [ eq - tanz2 - 1 ] ) and ( [ eq - tanz2 - 2 ] ) , respectively , it is easy to verify that @xmath351 for @xmath352 and @xmath353 . for @xmath354 we have instead @xmath355 . for @xmath356 there are also localized solutions with @xmath357 . the parameter @xmath358 satisfies one of the two equations @xmath359 eq . ( [ eq - tanw2 - 2 ] ) has a positive solution @xmath360 for @xmath356 , while eq . ( [ eq - tanw2 - 1 ] ) has a positive solution @xmath361 satisfying @xmath362 only for @xmath363 . these results allow us to determine the scaling function defined in eq . ( [ sca ] ) . we obtain @xmath364 for @xmath365 , @xmath366 for @xmath367 and @xmath368 for @xmath363 . we can easily determine the asymptotic behaviors . for small @xmath329 we have @xmath369 while for @xmath370 we have @xmath371 finally , for @xmath372 we have @xmath373 the theoretical curve is shown in fig . [ deetac ] . the dmrg data confirm the theoretical calculation : the numerical estimates of the ratio @xmath374 clearly approach the scaling curve @xmath375 with increasing @xmath0 . let us now consider the behavior of the correlations close to @xmath376 . the local magnetization @xmath297 and the correlation function @xmath298 are computed exactly in the limit @xmath377 in [ app.b4 ] . as we have already done in sec . [ sec6.2 ] , we extend these expressions to all values of @xmath303 satisfying @xmath6 , by replacing @xmath297 with @xmath378 and @xmath298 with @xmath379 . therefore , we predict for @xmath365 @xmath380,\ ] ] where @xmath381 is the smallest positive solution ( @xmath382 ) of eq . ( [ eq - tanz2 - 2 ] ) , @xmath383 , and @xmath308 , as before . for @xmath356 we have instead @xmath384,\ ] ] where @xmath358 is the solution ( @xmath385 ) of eq . ( [ eq - tanw2 - 2 ] ) . as for the correlation function @xmath298 it satisfies eq . ( [ gij - m ] ) . it is important to stress that the previous expressions , although derived for small values of @xmath303 , are expected to be _ exact _ for any @xmath218 . for instance , since @xmath320 is a dimensionless renormalization - group invariant ratio , it should scale as @xmath386,\ ] ] where @xmath387 is a universal , hence @xmath303 independent , function . the specific features of the model enter in this expression only through the normalization nonuniversal factor @xmath388 and the critical value @xmath338 . the factor @xmath388 does not depend on the observable , hence it can be determined by using any quantity . we use the gap @xmath264 , for which we are able to obtain exact results for any @xmath218 , defining @xmath389 . therefore , @xmath387 as a function of @xmath329 and @xmath390 is @xmath303 independent . therefore , our results , obtained in the limit @xmath391 , hold for any value of @xmath303 satisfying @xmath218 . the previous expressions for @xmath319 hold in the limit @xmath311 , @xmath171 at fixed @xmath313 and smoothly interpolate between the expressions valid in the different phases . note that we have @xmath392 for @xmath393 in all cases . this result does not however necessarily apply to the boundary points , i.e. , for @xmath394 , as the magnetization is not continuous at the boundary . for instance , in the magnetized phase , @xmath395 in all interior points , while @xmath396 and @xmath397 are nonuniversal functions of the field strength @xmath198 . a graph of @xmath320 for several values of @xmath329 as a function of @xmath313 is reported in fig . [ magnxcr ] . as expected , for @xmath398 the magnetization approaches zero exponentially in an interval that is centered in the middle of the chain and that widens as @xmath399 increases . more precisely , for @xmath372 we have @xmath400 and @xmath401 which shows that @xmath319 vanishes except in two tiny intervals close to the boundaries of width @xmath402 . to verify the prediction ( [ gij - m ] ) for @xmath298 we compute the scaling functions associated with @xmath34 and @xmath35 . they are reported in [ app.b4 ] and compared with dmrg data in figs . [ chietacr ] and [ xietacr ] . results with different values of @xmath303 fall on top of the theoretical curve when plotted versus @xmath329 . this confirms our predictions for @xmath298 and the magnetization , as well as the correctness of the nonuniversal prefactor appearing in the definition of @xmath329 . it is interesting to reinterpret our results in the equivalent fermionic picture of the model . in the ferromagnetic phase , i.e. , for @xmath403 , the lowest eigenstates are superpositions of majorana fermionic states localized at the boundaries @xcite . in finite systems , their overlap does not vanish , giving rise to the splitting @xmath404 . the coherence length @xmath405 diverges at the kink - to - magnet transitions as @xmath406 , a behavior analogous to that observed at the order - disorder transition @xmath407 where @xmath408 . within this picture , it is natural to consider @xmath409 which can interpreted as the particle density in the fermionic representation of the ising chain , see eq . ( [ sigma - c - relation ] ) . its large-@xmath0 limit is given by @xcite @xmath410 we consider the difference @xmath411 where @xmath383 , as before . such a quantity has been computed for small values of @xmath303 in [ app.b4 ] . the universality argument we have used for @xmath297 and @xmath298 can be applied to @xmath412 . we therefore predict @xmath413 for @xmath365 and @xmath414 for @xmath356 , where @xmath381 and @xmath358 are determined as in the case of the local magnetization . to verify this prediction we compute @xmath415 numerically for @xmath416 and @xmath417 . the numerical results are compared with theory in fig . [ fig : deltan0 ] . the agreement confirms the analytic prediction . the subtracted fermionic density @xmath418 is reported in fig . [ deltanxcr ] as a function of @xmath313 . for positive values of @xmath329 it has a maximum at the origin and shows that fermions are delocalized . for @xmath419 , @xmath420 is constant , while for negative values of @xmath329 , there is a significant enhancement at the boundary . for @xmath372 , as in the case of the magnetization , @xmath418 is different from 0 only close to the boundary , in an interval of width @xmath421 . it is interesting to consider the behavior of @xmath422 at the boundaries , i.e. , for @xmath423 , which is shown in fig . [ deltanb ] . in the kink phase , such a quantity scales as @xmath424 for @xmath370 . on the other hand it diverges as @xmath425 for @xmath372 , that is when the magnetized phase is approached . as such , it represents a physically relevant order parameter for the transition , which distinguishes the two different phases . finally , we discuss the behavior of the half - chain entanglement entropy @xcite . we divide the chain into two connected parts @xmath426 $ ] and @xmath427 $ ] and consider the von neumann entropy @xmath428 } \ln \rho_{[-\ell,0 ] } , \label{vnen}\ ] ] where @xmath429}$ ] is the reduced density matrix of the subsystem @xmath426 $ ] , i.e. , @xmath430}={\rm tr}_{[1,\ell ] } \;\rho , \ ] ] and @xmath431 is the density matrix of the ground state . the entanglement entropy @xmath432 approaches a constant in the large-@xmath0 limit , except for the critical case @xmath5 where it increases logarithmically @xcite . its large-@xmath0 limit for obc is given by @xcite @xmath433 , \nonumber\\ & & i(z ) = \int_0 ^ 1 { dx\over \sqrt{(1-x^2)(1-z^2 x^2 ) } } . \label{sobc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in fig . [ entaen ] we plot the difference @xmath434 which shows the scaling behavior @xmath435 where @xmath436 is a universal function apart from a multiplicative nonuniversal constant . these results imply that the large-@xmath0 limit of the half - chain entanglement entropy does not depend on the boundary conditions , being the same for obc and obf . however , the @xmath437 corrections are affected by the boundary term ( [ hb ] ) , giving rise to a nontrivial universal behavior around @xmath376 . the results we have obtained allow us to derive exact scaling functions for the classical two - dimensional ising model in a strip @xmath438 in the presence of two equal magnetic fields on the boundaries . this model has been extensively studied , especially in the case of opposite magnetic fields . in this case , the wetting ( or interface localization - delocalization ) transition , which is the analog of the magnet - to - kink transition we are considering here , has been extensively studied @xcite . we can therefore check some of our results , comparing them with the existing ones in the literature . the results for the gap @xmath264 obtained in sec . [ sec7.1 ] can be used to derive the scaling behavior of the longitudinal correlation length @xmath439 , defined by @xmath440 . such a quantity was computed in the restrictive solid - on - solid model in ref . their result is completely consistent with ours . if our scaling quantities @xmath381 and @xmath358 defined in sec . [ sec7.1 ] are identified with the quantities @xmath441 , @xmath442 appearing in ref . @xcite , we obtain exactly the same expression for @xmath443 . several papers study the magnetization profile , which gives information on the behavior of the interface between the two coexisting phases . the behavior in the large - field phase was determined in ref . @xcite by using the restrictive solid - on - solid model . the result is in agreement with our prediction ( [ magnetization - scaling ] ) for @xmath293 . the linear behavior observed at @xmath304 was also derived at the wetting transition by using the solid - on - solid model @xcite . no exact results are instead available for the magnetization profiles in the whole crossover region , which , in the classical case , is usually parametrized in terms of @xmath444l$ ] , where @xmath235 is the boundary field and @xmath445 the corresponding wetting temperature ( in the quantum - to - classical mapping @xmath303 corresponds to @xmath22 , hence this scaling corresponds to varying @xmath303 at fixed @xmath198 ) . however , the numerical results for the magnetization reported in refs . @xcite ( and , in particular , fig . 2 of ref . @xcite ) appear to be in full agreement with our prediction shown in fig . [ magnxcr ] . we consider the one - dimensional quantum ising chain in the presence of a transverse magnetic field @xmath303 @xcite and of boundary magnetic fields aligned with the order - parameter spin operator . in particular , we consider fields with equal strength @xmath198 , which have either the same ( pbf ) or the opposite ( obf ) direction , cf . ( [ pbfdef ] ) and ( [ obfdef ] ) . we assume the chain to have length @xmath0 and derive the finite - size behavior of several quantities in the limit @xmath171 as a function of @xmath198 . we derive analytic predictions for the gap in all phases as a function of the boundary field strength . in the paramagnetic quantum phase , the leading behavior is independent of the boundary conditions . at the critical transition @xmath165 , finite - size scaling depends on the boundary fields . the point @xmath144 , corresponding to open boundary conditions , is a surface critical point . we derive analytic expressions for the scaling functions that parametrize the crossover behavior for @xmath193 and any @xmath198 ( bulk critical behavior ) , and for @xmath165 and @xmath246 ( surface critical behavior ) . in the quantum ferromagnetic phase @xmath218 , if the boundary fields are oppositely aligned , the finite - size behavior drastically changes as @xmath198 varies @xcite . for small @xmath198 , the system is in a ferromagnetic phase in which the gap decreases exponentially with the system size . on the other hand , for large fields , kink propagating modes of momenta @xmath177 are the relevant low - energy excitations , so that the gap decreases as @xmath446 . the two phases are separated by a critical transition at @xmath286 . close to this transition , low - energy properties show a universal scaling behavior in terms of the scaling variable @xmath447 . the transition is only characterized by the nature of the coexisting phases . indeed , the same transition occurs in ising rings in the presence of a localized bond defect @xcite . it is interesting to interpret our results in the context of two - dimensional classical ising models , using the quantum - to - classical mapping . as is well known @xcite , the quantum ising chain of length @xmath0 corresponds to a classical ising model on a strip of width @xmath0 , the transverse field playing the role of the temperature . therefore , our results provide exact predictions for the ising model in an @xmath448 geometry with boundary fields . our results for the gap at the critical point can be used to predict the fss behavior of the longitudinal exponential correlation function @xmath449 as a function of @xmath450 and of @xmath451 , where @xmath65 and @xmath66 are nonuniversal model - dependent constants . moreover , our extensive results at the magnet - to - kink transition for @xmath218 for obf provide predictions for the finite - size scaling functions at the classical wetting transition ( sometimes also called interface localization / delocalization transition @xcite ) in two dimensions . in particular , we have exact predictions for the fss behavior of the magnetization profile and of the correlation function of the layer magnetization in the whole crossover region close to the transition . in the context of the wetting transition , one may also consider a second important surface parameter , which is usually referred to as surface enhancement @xcite . while a boundary magnetic field is the most relevant magnetic perturbation that breaks the @xmath20 symmetry at the boundary , surface enhancement is the most relevant ( energy - like ) perturbation that is @xmath20 invariant . in the context of the quantum chain , such an interaction can be mimicked by adding a term ( @xmath452 , localized at the boundary , to the general ising - chain hamiltonian . it is not difficult to generalize the results presented here to this more general case ( results for the spectrum in the absence of boundary magnetic fields appear in refs . @xcite ) . at the critical point , this would allow us to study the behavior at the ordinary and extraordinary surface transitions ( in the absence of surface enhancement the point @xmath165 , @xmath144 corresponds to the so - called special transition @xcite ) . moreover , a complete understanding of the phase behavior for @xmath218 in the absence of a bulk magnetic field should be possible . in the quantum case , these results would also be relevant for ising quantum rings with localized site defects , a distinct case with respect to that considered in ref . in this appendix we collect results on the spectrum of some matrices that are relevant for the discussion . we begin by considering the @xmath453 matrix ( we write it for @xmath454 ) @xmath455 to determine its eigenvalues , we compute @xmath456 if we set @xmath457 , the determinant @xmath458 satisfies the recursion relation @xmath459 the solution is @xmath460 where @xmath461 and @xmath462 are arbitrary constant . if we require @xmath463 and @xmath464 , we obtain @xmath465 it follows @xmath466 the eigenvalues are solutions of the equation @xmath467 . we obtain @xmath468 eigenvalues given by @xmath469 with @xmath470 . let us now compute the eigenvectors . let @xmath471 be the eigenvector corresponding to eigenvalue @xmath472 . it satisfies the relations @xmath473 the solution of the recursion relation ( [ eigenvectors - relation-2 ] ) is @xmath474 where @xmath475 and @xmath476 are two arbitrary constants . requiring @xmath477 , we obtain @xmath478 , so that @xmath479 where we have rescaled @xmath475 for convenience . requiring the eigenvector to have unit norm , we obtain @xmath480 we also determine the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath481 which differs from @xmath65 only for two matrix elements : @xmath482 and @xmath483 are equal to @xmath484 . setting again @xmath485 and @xmath457 , we obtain @xmath486 using the recursion relation ( [ recursion - an ] ) , we obtain finally @xmath487 where @xmath488 . to determine the spectrum of hamiltonian ( [ def - hextended ] ) , we compute the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath84 defined in eq . ( [ matrixc - def ] ) . we write them as @xmath489 note that nothing forbids @xmath490 to be larger than @xmath491 or smaller that @xmath492 , hence @xmath493 is not necessarily bounded between @xmath494 and @xmath495 . hence , we must consider real values of @xmath159 with @xmath496 and complex values of the form @xmath497 and @xmath498 with @xmath137 . we are not interested in the zero eigenvalue of @xmath84 , hence we will only consider the @xmath499 matrix formed by the first @xmath500 rows and columns , which we label with the symbol @xmath501 . then , we introduce a matrix @xmath502 defined as ( here @xmath503 ) @xmath504 the corresponding secular equations are @xmath505 the determinant @xmath506 has already been computed in [ app.a1 ] : @xmath507 to determine @xmath508 , we expand the determinant with respect to the first and the last rows . we obtain the following recursion relation : @xmath509 a simpler expression is obtain by eliminating @xmath510 and @xmath511 , and expressing the result in terms of @xmath512 and @xmath513 . this can be done by using the recursion relation satisfied by the determinants @xmath506 , see eq . ( [ recursion - an ] ) with @xmath514 . we obtain finally @xmath515 d_{n-2}. \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the recursion relation ( [ rec - cn - eta1-eta2 ] ) is symmetric with respect to the exchange of @xmath91 and @xmath92 . the eigenvalues of @xmath516 are obtained by requiring @xmath517 . setting @xmath518 and @xmath519 , we obtain eq . ( [ secular - equation ] ) . note that we have simplified @xmath520 in the denominators , hence eq . ( [ secular - equation ] ) has a spurious solution for @xmath143 . a true solution with @xmath141 occurs only when the coefficients of @xmath512 and @xmath513 in eq . ( [ rec - cn - eta1-eta2 ] ) both vanish for @xmath141 . this only occurs when @xmath521 . the low - energy behavior of the model with hamiltonian ( [ isc ] ) can be understood analytically in the limit @xmath391 . for @xmath522 , it is trivial to compute the spectrum of hamiltonian ( [ isc ] ) in the presence of the magnetic boundary term ( [ hb ] ) , since @xmath47 is diagonal in the basis in which @xmath16 is diagonal . assuming @xmath523 and @xmath524 , there are two family of states that control the low - energy spectrum . first , we should consider the magnetized states @xmath525 then , we should also consider the @xmath526 states ( we call them kink states @xcite ) @xmath527 if @xmath528 is the hamiltonian for @xmath529 we have ( @xmath3 ) @xmath530 the value of @xmath198 determines which of the states is the ground state of the system . for @xmath339 , the ground state is doubly degenerate and spanned by @xmath531 and @xmath532 , while for @xmath533 the @xmath526 kink states are the lowest - energy ones . for @xmath534 , the magnetized and the kink states are degenerate . we wish now to determine how this picture changes when the perturbation @xmath535 is added . let us first understand the behavior for @xmath339 . for @xmath522 the ground state is doubly degenerate . such a degeneracy is lifted by perturbation ( [ hg - def ] ) . note , however , that @xmath536 vanishes for any @xmath537 . therefore , the energy gap is proportional to @xmath538 , in agreement with the exact results obtained in sec . [ sec5 ] . let us now consider the corrections to the ground state which are proportional to @xmath303 . at order @xmath303 , @xmath531 mixes with the states generated by @xmath539 , so that we can write @xmath540 where @xmath541 , @xmath542 , @xmath201 are of order @xmath303 and state @xmath543 is defined so that @xmath544 for @xmath545 and @xmath546 . requiring @xmath547 to be normalized , we immediately obtain @xmath548 . the coefficients @xmath541 , @xmath542 , and @xmath201 are fixed by the eigenvalue condition @xmath549 we obtain @xmath550 the analysis for @xmath532 is analogous and leads to @xmath551 . once the degeneracy is lifted , the ground state should be an eigenstate of @xmath552 , hence it should be of the form @xmath553 we are now in the position to compute correlation functions on the ground state . for the local magnetization , we obtain @xmath554 this result shows the the ground state does not show a local magnetization , except at the boundaries . for @xmath555 , the local magnetization @xmath297 vanishes as in the zero - field case . the applied field @xmath198 is too small to destabilize the low - energy state . we can analogously compute the correlation function @xmath298 : @xmath556 where @xmath557 . except on the boundaries , the correlation function is equal to the square of the bulk magnetization @xmath302 , as in the zero - field case . let us now consider the large - field region in which the ground state is @xmath526 degenerate and the relevant states are the kink states ( [ kink - states ] ) . the degeneracy is lifted when @xmath558 is included . the full hamiltonian restricted to the subspace spanned by the kink states has the form ( we write it for @xmath559 ) @xmath560 where @xmath561 . the eigenvalues and eigenvectors of this matrix have been computed in [ app.a1 ] . there are @xmath562 energy states @xmath563 with @xmath564 . the ground state corresponds to @xmath565 . the corresponding eigenfunctions are @xmath566 with @xmath567 . using this expression , we can compute the average of @xmath16 . for the average on state @xmath116 , we obtain @xmath568 where @xmath569 . if we now consider the ground state , in the large-@xmath0 limit , we can rewrite eq . ( [ magnetization ] ) as @xmath570 if we define @xmath383 and @xmath308 we obtain the more symmetric form @xmath571 analogously , we can compute the correlation function . we obtain @xmath572 where @xmath573 . focusing again on the ground state and taking the limit @xmath260 , if @xmath574 , @xmath575 , we obtain @xmath576 we should now discuss the behavior of the system in the intermediate case in which kink states and ferromagnetic states are degenerate . for @xmath522 this case corresponds to @xmath577 . as discussed in sec . [ sec5 ] , when the @xmath303 dependent term is added , the intermediate case corresponds to @xmath578 . therefore , to discuss the intermediate case , we set @xmath579 and consider the model restricted to the @xmath500 subspace spanned by @xmath580 , @xmath581 ( @xmath582 ) , @xmath583 . if @xmath584 is the energy of the kink states , the hamiltonian can be written as ( here @xmath503 ) @xmath585 the eigenvalues can be computed using the results of [ app.a1 ] . indeed , @xmath47 has the same form as matrix @xmath586 defined in eq . ( [ matrix - atilde - def ] ) . since @xmath587 , the secular equation ( [ recursion - tildean ] ) becomes @xmath588 which implies @xmath589 as the energy of each mode is given by @xmath590 , the ground state is obtained by taking @xmath591 . the ground - state energy is @xmath592 and the corresponding eigenvector is simply @xmath593 it is easy to compute the local magnetization and the correlation function . we find @xmath594 which shows that @xmath297 varies linearly between @xmath595 and @xmath596 . if we set , as usual , @xmath383 and @xmath308 we obtain in the large-@xmath0 limit @xmath597 the two - point correlation function is also easily computed @xmath598 let us now study the crossover behavior . we consider again the same basis as in [ app.b3 ] . the hamiltonian becomes ( here @xmath503 ) @xmath599 the secular equation is obtained by using the results of [ app.a1 ] , eq . ( [ recursion - tildean ] ) . we set @xmath600 , @xmath601 , @xmath602 , and @xmath590 . since @xmath603 , we obtain @xmath604 \sin k ( l+1 ) = 0.\ ] ] in the kink phase in which @xmath365 , @xmath159 varies between @xmath605 for @xmath419 and @xmath606 for @xmath370 . hence , we write @xmath607 . expanding the secular equation to order @xmath446 we obtain @xmath608 which coincides with eq . ( [ sec - etac-1 ] ) . the solutions of this equation either solve @xmath609 or @xmath610 . the ground state corresponds to the lowest value of @xmath381 that is a solution of eq . ( [ gap - appb ] ) , hence it satisfies @xmath609 . note the limiting values : @xmath611 we wish now to compute the ground - state eigenfunction , which we express as @xmath612 in the basis @xmath613 , @xmath614 , defined in [ app.b3 ] . if @xmath615 , the coefficients satisfy the relations @xmath616 the solution of eq . ( [ rec - alpha - scaling-2 ] ) is @xmath617 the constants @xmath475 and @xmath476 are fixed by condition ( [ rec - alpha - scaling ] ) and by the normalization condition @xmath618 . in the large-@xmath0 limit these two conditions give @xmath619 we can now compute @xmath297 and @xmath298 . for the local magnetization we have @xmath620 in the large-@xmath0 limit , using @xmath621 , we obtain @xmath622 where @xmath383 , @xmath308 . note that the prefactor guarantees that @xmath297 is equal to @xmath623 at the two boundaries . we can also compute the correlation function , which satisfies the relation @xmath624 correspondingly , we obtain @xmath625 and @xmath626 let us finally consider @xmath627 defined in eq . ( [ defden ] ) . for @xmath377 , @xmath628 , so that @xmath629 . using the definition we obtain @xmath630 substituting the explicit expression of @xmath631 and using @xmath609 , we find @xmath632 the above - reported results apply to the kink phase @xmath352 . for @xmath356 the ground state is a localized state with @xmath633 , where @xmath358 satisfies the equation @xmath634 the solutions of this equation satisfy either @xmath635 or @xmath636 . since @xmath637 , the ground state is obtained by considering the largest positive solution of the equation . it is then easy to prove that it satisfies @xmath635 . the solution for @xmath356 is then obtained by analytic continuation of the results obtained for @xmath365 . it is enough to replace @xmath381 with @xmath638 . we therefore obtain @xmath639 note that @xmath640 for @xmath372 , so that @xmath641 in this limit . 99 g. g. cabrera and r. jullien , universality of finite - size scaling : the role of the boundary conditions , phys . rev . lett . * 57 * , 393 ( 1986 ) ; role of boundary conditions in the finite - size ising model , phys . b * 35 * , 7062 ( 1987 ) . a. dutta , u. divakaran , d. sen , b. k. chakrabarti , t. f. rosenbaum , and g. aeppli , quantum phase transitions in transverse field spin models : from statistical physics to quantum information , arxiv:1012.0653v3 ; a. dutta , g. aeppli , b. k. chakrabarti , u. divakaran , t. f. rosenbaum and d. sen , _ quantum phase transitions in transverse field spin models : from statistical physics to quantum information _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2015 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we present a detailed study of the finite one - dimensional quantum ising chain in a transverse field in the presence of boundary magnetic fields coupled with the order - parameter spin operator . we consider two magnetic fields located at the boundaries of the chain that have the same strength and that are aligned in the same or in the opposite direction . we derive analytic expressions for the gap in all phases for large values of the chain length @xmath0 , as a function of the boundary field strength . we also investigate the behavior of the chain in the quantum ferromagnetic phase for oppositely aligned fields , focusing on the magnet - to - kink transition that occurs at a finite value of the magnetic field strength . at this transition we compute analytically the finite - size crossover functions for the gap , the magnetization profile , the two - point correlation function , and the density of fermionic modes . as the magnet - to - kink transition is equivalent to the wetting transition in two - dimensional classical ising models , our results provide new analytic predictions for the finite - size behavior of ising systems in a strip geometry at this transition ."
] | 10,676 | 10,676 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the direct and precise measurement of the self - coupling between the electroweak gauge bosons in @xmath2-pair production will be a crucial step in testing the standard model of electroweak interactions and searching for physics beyond it . it will form an important part of the physics programme at lep2 and at a planned linear @xmath3-collider ( lc ) . as is well known there are three diagrams at tree level that contribute to the amplitude of @xmath4 in the standard model , one with @xmath5-channel neutrino exchange and the other two with a @xmath6 or @xmath7 in the @xmath8-channel , involving the vertices @xmath1 and @xmath0 . one can parametrise the corresponding vertex functions in order to quantify the couplings and to compare them with their form in the standard model . in the most general form respecting lorentz covariance each vertex involves seven complex form factors @xcite , three of which give couplings that violate @xmath9 symmetry . without further physical assumptions one is thus left with 28 real parameters whose simultaneous extraction in one experiment looks quite hopeless . given the limited event statistics expected at both lep2 and the lc one will only obtain meaningful errors on a reduced number of coupling parameters at one time . this may be achieved by imposing certain constraints on the full set of coupling constants ; various suggestions for such constraints based on symmetry considerations have been made in the literature @xcite . one must however keep in mind that experimental values or bounds on couplings that have been obtained with particular constraints can not be converted into results without constraints or with different ones ; the information lost by assuming relations between couplings can not be retrieved . although imposing such constraints is certainly legitimate and can be useful we stress that a data analysis with independent couplings will be valuable , both from the point of view of model independence and the capability to compare results of different experiments . we remark that of course one can also give ( reasonably small ) errors on _ single or few _ couplings in a multi - parameter analysis . in this paper we propose a parametrisation of the couplings which is well adapted to this end , the statistical errors on the different measured parameters being approximately uncorrelated . we will work in the framework of optimal observables , a way to extract unknown coupling parameters introduced for the case of one parameter in @xcite that has since been used for various reactions @xcite . general aspects of this method , in particular its extension to an arbitrary number of parameters , as well as its application to @xmath10 production were discussed in @xcite . in this paper we investigate again the reaction @xmath11 . we concentrate here on the decay channels , where one @xmath2 decays hadronically and the other into an electron or muon and its neutrino . calculated with the born level cross section of the standard model the statistics of these channels is about 3000 events for a collision energy of @xmath12 and @xmath13 integrated luminosity , which are typical planned lep2 parameters , and about 22000 events with @xmath14 at @xmath15 , which might be achieved at the lc . a complementary source of information is the integrated cross section , which is a quadratic function of the triple gauge couplings . the combination of information from the total event rate and from observables that make use of the detailed distribution in the final state has for example been used in @xcite , where @xmath9 violation in the decay @xmath16 was investigated . in sec . [ sec : method ] of this paper we will further develop some aspects of the method of optimal observables , in particular we will show how to apply it without the linear approximation in the coupling parameters that was used in @xcite . in sec . [ sec : diagon ] we then propose a parametrisation of the couplings that simultaneously diagonalises certain matrices connected with our observables and with the integrated cross section . these parameters achieve two goals : their quadratic contribution to the total cross section is a simple sum of squares and the covariance matrix of the corresponding optimal observables is diagonal . the methods which we use for this purpose are borrowed from the theory of small oscillations of a system with @xmath17 degrees of freedom ( cf . e.g. @xcite ) . our parameters correspond to `` normal coordinates '' and their use in an experimental analysis should in our view present several advantages . we give some numerical examples for @xmath2-pair production at lep2 and the lc in sec . [ sec : numeric ] and make some further remarks on how our proposal might be implemented in practice in sec . [ sec : practice ] . the last section of this paper gives a summary of our main points . the method of optimal observables has previously been presented in the approximation that the couplings to be extracted are sufficiently small to allow for a leading order taylor expansion of various expressions . here we show how to use it beyond this approximation . let us denote by @xmath18 the real and imaginary parts of the @xmath1 and @xmath0 form factors minus their values in the standard model at tree level . as the amplitude of our process is linear in these couplings we can write the differential cross section as @xmath19 where @xmath20 is a positive semidefinite symmetric matrix . @xmath21 collectively denotes the set of measured phase space variables . the integrated cross section is @xmath22 with the standard model cross section @xmath23 and coefficients @xmath24 the idea of using integrated observables is to define suitable functions @xmath25 of the phase space variables and to extract the unknown couplings from their measured mean values @xmath26 . let us give the details . from ( [ diffxsection ] ) and ( [ intxsection ] ) we obtain the expectation value @xmath27 $ ] of @xmath28 as @xmath29 - e_0[{{\cal o}}_i ] = \frac{\displaystyle \sum_{j } c_{ij } \ , g_j + \sum_{jk } q_{ijk } \ , g_j g_k}{\displaystyle 1 + \sum_{j } { \hat{\sigma}_{1,j } } \ , g_j + \sum_{jk } { \hat{\sigma}_{2,jk } } \ , g_j g_k}\ ] ] with the standard model expectation value @xmath30 = ( \int d\phi \ , { { \cal o}}_i s_0 ) / \sigma_0 $ ] and coefficients @xmath31 \ , { \hat{\sigma}_{1,j } } { \hspace{6pt},}\nonumber \\ q_{ijk } & = & \frac{1}{\sigma_0 } \int d\phi \ , { { \cal o}}_i s_{2,jk } - e_0[{{\cal o}}_i ] \ , { \hat{\sigma}_{2,jk } } { \hspace{6pt}.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] we remark in passing that the coefficients in ( [ expect ] ) can be written in a compact form as @xmath32 { \hspace{6pt},}\hspace{3em } q_{ijk } { \hspace{0.4em } = \hspace{0.4em}}v_0[{{\cal o}}_i \ , , \ ; s_{2,jk } /s_0 ] { \hspace{6pt},}\nonumber \\ { \hat{\sigma}_{1,j } } & = & e_0[s_{1,j } /s_0 ] { \hspace{6pt},}\hspace{4.4em } { \hat{\sigma}_{2,jk } } { \hspace{0.4em } = \hspace{0.4em}}e_0[s_{2,jk } /s_0 ] { \hspace{6pt},}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath33 = e_0[f g ] - e_0[f ] \ , e_0[g]$ ] is the covariance of @xmath34 and @xmath35 in the standard model . note that @xmath36 is symmetric and positive definite , whereas @xmath37 as a matrix in @xmath38 and @xmath39 is symmetric but in general indefinite . an estimation of the couplings can now be obtained by solving the system ( [ expect ] ) with @xmath27 $ ] replaced by the mean values @xmath26 , @xmath40 = \frac{\displaystyle \sum_{j } c_{ij } \ , g_j + \sum_{jk } q_{ijk } \ , g_j g_k}{\displaystyle 1 + \sum_{j } { \hat{\sigma}_{1,j } } \ , g_j + \sum_{jk } { \hat{\sigma}_{2,jk } } \ , g_j g_k } { \hspace{6pt},}\ ] ] provided of course one has @xmath41 observables for @xmath41 unknown couplings . when the system ( [ mean ] ) is linearised in the @xmath18 it is easily solved by inversion of the matrix @xmath42 . one is however not constrained to do so and can instead solve the exact set of equations ( [ mean ] ) . by multiplication with the denominator it can be rearranged to a coupled set of quadratic equations in the @xmath18 and will in general have several solutions . some of these may be complex and thus ruled out , but from the information of the @xmath43 alone one can not tell which of the remaining real ones is the physical solution . we will come back to this point . the measured mean values @xmath43 are of course only equal to the @xmath27 $ ] up to systematic and statistical errors . we only consider the latter here , which are given by the covariance matrix @xmath44 of the observables @xmath28 divided by the number @xmath45 of events in the analysis . to convert the errors on the observables into errors on the extracted couplings we use the quantity @xmath46 \right ) n v({{\cal o}})^{-1 } { } _ { ij } \left ( { \bar{{{\cal o}}}}_j - e[{{\cal o}}_j ] \right ) { \hspace{6pt},}\ ] ] which depends on the @xmath18 through the @xmath27 $ ] given in ( [ expect ] ) . solving ( [ mean ] ) is tantamount to minimising @xmath47 with @xmath48 , and a confidence region on the couplings is as usual given by @xmath49 with the constant determined by the desired confidence level . there are several possible choices for the covariance matrix @xmath50 in ( [ chi ] ) . it can be 1 . determined from the measured distribution of the observables @xmath28 , 2 . calculated from the differential cross section ( [ diffxsection ] ) , taking for the @xmath18 the values extracted in the measurement , 3 . calculated for vanishing couplings @xmath18 , 4 . calculated as a function of the couplings . choices 1 . and 2 . should lead to the same results in the limit of large @xmath45 where the statistical errors on the measured @xmath44 and @xmath18 become small . comparison of the covariance matrices obtained by these two methods might indeed be helpful to rule out unphysical solutions of ( [ mean ] ) . . in turn will be a good approximation of 2 . if the couplings are small enough . we consider possibility 4 . as the least practical one , except maybe for the case of one coupling . for several couplings the expression of @xmath44 as a function of the @xmath18 involves tensors of rank up to four and is even more complicated than the one for the expectation values ( [ expect ] ) , and the inverse matrix is yet more clumsy . for this reason we will discard choice 4 . in the following . in @xcite we considered an analysis at leading order in the @xmath18 , where one uses the linearised form of ( [ mean ] ) to estimate the couplings : @xmath51 \right ) { \hspace{6pt}.}\ ] ] correspondingly the linear approximation of ( [ expect ] ) is used in the expression ( [ chi ] ) of @xmath47 which then reads @xmath52 where @xmath53 is the inverse covariance matrix of the estimated couplings @xcite . as one works to leading order in the @xmath18 one can approximate @xmath50 by its value for zero couplings , i.e. choose possibility 3 . above . the confidence regions @xmath54 for the measured couplings are then ellipsoids in the space of the @xmath18 with centre at @xmath55 . the optimal observables @xmath56 discussed in @xcite have the property that to leading order the statistical errors on the estimated couplings are the smallest possible ones that can be obtained with _ any _ method , including e.g. a maximum likelihood fit to the full distribution of @xmath21 given by the differential cross section ( [ diffxsection ] ) . note that one can still use the linearised expressions ( [ linearestim ] ) and ( [ linearchi ] ) in an analysis beyond leading order . the error @xmath57 on the couplings will be given by an ellipsoid with defining matrix ( [ couplingscov ] ) , where @xmath50 is the covariance matrix at the actual values of the couplings . these errors will in general no longer be optimal , so that when the leading order approximation is not good one might obtain better errors with a different choice of observables . more importantly , however , the extracted values of the couplings are biased : averaged over a large number of experiments the measured couplings differ from the actual ones by terms quadratic in the @xmath18 . if instead one uses the full expressions ( [ expect ] ) , ( [ mean ] ) and ( [ chi ] ) one has no bias on the extracted coupling parameters , provided the number @xmath45 of events in the analysis is large enough . let us see if we can find optimal observables for this case . to this end we expand the differential cross section around some values @xmath58 of the couplings : @xmath59 the corresponding zeroth order cross sections and mean values are @xmath60 and @xmath61 = ( \int d\phi \ , { { \cal o}}_i \widetilde{s}_0 ) / \widetilde{\sigma}_0 $ ] , respectively . we then can re - express @xmath27 $ ] in ( [ expect ] ) , replacing @xmath18 with @xmath62 , @xmath63 with @xmath64 , and using new coefficients @xmath65 etc . constructed as in ( [ xsectioncoeffs ] ) , ( [ obscoeffs ] ) . making the same replacements in ( [ mean ] ) we have an alternative set of equations to extract the coupling parameters . it can be shown that for sufficiently large @xmath45 the confidence regions obtained from ( [ chi ] ) , ( [ confidence ] ) in a nonlinear analysis are again ellipsoids given by @xmath66 one can then write @xmath67 as in ( [ linearchi ] ) , but with @xmath68 of ( [ couplingscov ] ) replaced by @xmath69 where @xmath70 corresponds to an expansion ( [ newdiffxsection ] ) of @xmath71 about the _ actual _ values of the couplings . the main point of the argument is that for large @xmath45 the statistical errors on the @xmath26 become small , so that the extracted couplings will be sufficiently close to the actual ones to allow for a linearisation of ( [ expect ] ) and ( [ mean ] ) , cf . @xcite , p.695 , and @xcite . finally one can construct new observables @xmath72 from ( [ newdiffxsection ] ) . they will be optimal , i.e. have minimum statistical error if the @xmath58 are equal to the actual values of the @xmath18 . in the appendix we show that , up to linear reparametrisations given in ( [ reparam ] ) , this is the only set of @xmath41 integrated observables that measures the @xmath41 couplings with minimum error . there is hence no choice of observables that would be optimal for _ all _ values of the actual coupling parameters . as these are unknown one can in practice not write down the truly `` optimal '' observables , but our argument tells us how one can improve on the choice in ( [ optimal ] ) if one has some previous estimates @xmath58 of the couplings ( cf . also @xcite ) . one may then choose to perform a leading order analysis as described above , linearising about @xmath73 instead of @xmath74 . a practical way to proceed could be to estimate the parameters @xmath18 at first using the linearised method around @xmath75 . suppose this gives as best estimate some values @xmath76 . then in a second step one could set @xmath77 and use the linearised method around @xmath78 to improve the estimate etc . at this point we wish to comment on the `` optimal technique '' for determining unknown parameters in the differential cross section that has been proposed in @xcite . the `` weighting functions '' @xmath79 there depend on the actual values of the parameters one wants to extract and are thus not `` observables '' . only if one sets the unknown parameters in the @xmath79 equal to some previous estimates of them can one use these functions to weight individual events ; the better these estimates are the more sensitive the functions will be . if one does this then the set @xmath79 is equivalent to our observables ( [ newoptimal ] ) defined for some estimates @xmath58 of the coupling parameters . we finally remark that if @xmath45 is not large enough the statistical errors on the mean values @xmath26 and thus on the measured couplings might be so large that they lead into a region where a linearisation of ( [ expect ] ) is not a good approximation . the covariance matrix @xmath80 is then no longer given by ( [ newcouplingscov ] ) . moreover the errors on the couplings might be asymmetric and the shape of the confidence region defined by ( [ chi ] ) , ( [ confidence ] ) very different from an ellipsoid , so that knowledge of @xmath80 is not sufficient to estimate the errors on the @xmath18 . in such a case we can not say on general grounds how sensitive our observables are . incidentally this also holds for other extraction methods such as maximum likelihood fits , whose optimal properties are realised in the limit @xmath81 . if one is rather far from this limit the sensitivity of a method will have to be determined by other means , e.g. by detailed monte carlo simulations . the method we have outlined can of course also be applied if one chooses to reduce the number of unknown parameters by imposing certain linear constraints on the couplings . one may still use the observables ( [ optimal ] ) corresponding to the _ full _ set of couplings but minimise @xmath47 in ( [ chi ] ) for the _ reduced _ set ; in this case one can of course not take choice 2.for @xmath50 . in general @xmath82 is then different from zero and its value indicates to which extent the particular constraints on the couplings are compatible with the data . if @xmath45 is large enough @xmath82 follows in fact a @xmath47-distribution with @xmath83 degrees of freedom for @xmath41 observables and @xmath84 independent couplings so that its value can be converted into a confidence level @xcite . we conclude with a remark on the use of optimal observables in practice . a realistic data analysis will not be good enough if the born approximation of the differential cross section ( [ diffxsection ] ) is used . both higher - order theoretical corrections , such as initial state radiation and the finite @xmath2 width , and experimental effects like detection efficiency and resolution will modify the observed distribution of the phase space parameters @xmath21 . if they are taken into account in the determination of the coefficients in ( [ expect ] ) , ( [ mean ] ) and of the covariance matrix @xmath50 they will _ not _ lead to any bias in the extraction of the couplings and their errors . while this will presumably be done with sets of generated events and might be computationally intensive one still has to determine only a rather limited number of `` sensitivity '' constants . on the other hand one needs to know the observables @xmath25 of ( [ optimal ] ) as functions over the entire experimental phase space , so that the expressions of @xmath85 and @xmath86 used to construct them will in practice be taken from a less sophisticated approximation to the actual distribution of @xmath21 in order to keep them manageable . the observables are then no longer optimal , and it will depend on the individual case which approximations of @xmath85 , @xmath86 are good enough to obtain observables with a sensitivity close to the optimal one . in @xcite it was shown how with a suitable combination of all semileptonic @xmath87 decay channels one can define observables that are either even or odd under the discrete transformations @xmath9 and @xmath88 , where @xmath89 denotes charge conjugation , @xmath90 the parity transformation , and @xmath91 the `` naive '' time reversal operation which flips particle momenta and spins but does not interchange initial and final state . under the conditions on the experimental setup and event selection spelt out in @xcite we have two important symmetry properties : 1 . a @xmath9 odd observable can only have a nonzero expectation value if @xmath9 symmetry is violated in the reaction . 2 . if the expectation value of a @xmath88 odd observable is nonzero the transition amplitude must have an absorptive part whose phase must satisfy certain requirements in order to give an interference with the nonabsorptive part of the amplitude . we assume in this analysis that any nonstandard physics in the reaction is due to the triple gauge vertices . in the standard model one needs at least two loops to violate @xmath9 ; to a good accuracy the triple gauge couplings are therefore the only possible source of @xmath9 violation . for our process , i.e. @xmath3 annihilation into four fermions , an absorptive part that satisfies the requirements mentioned in point 2 . will appear in the standard model already at next - to - leading order in the electroweak fine structure constant , either through nonresonant diagrams or through loop corrections . to leading order , however , they are only due to the imaginary parts of triple gauge couplings . in this approximation the optimal observables ( [ optimal ] ) are @xmath9 even ( odd ) if they correspond to @xmath9 conserving ( violating ) couplings , and @xmath88 even ( odd ) if they correspond to the real ( imaginary ) parts of form factors . the coefficient matrix @xmath92 is then block diagonal in four symmetry classes of observables and three - boson - couplings : 1 . @xmath9 and @xmath88 even 2 . @xmath9 even and @xmath88 odd 3 . @xmath9 odd and @xmath88 even 4 . @xmath9 and @xmath88 odd . in the leading order analysis one thus can treat these four classes of couplings separately and benefit from a great reduction of unknown parameters . beyond leading order , however , form factors of any symmetry can contribute to @xmath27 $ ] : * in the integrated cross section and thus in the denominator of @xmath27 - e_0[{{\cal o}}_i]$ ] in ( [ expect ] ) couplings of all four classes enter quadratically , couplings of class @xmath93 also appear linearly ; * if @xmath28 belongs to class @xmath93 the numerator of @xmath27 - e_0[{{\cal o}}_i]$ ] has terms linear in the couplings of this class but couplings of all four classes enter quadratically through @xmath94 ; * if @xmath28 belongs to a @xmath9 ( @xmath88 ) odd coupling then the numerator in ( [ expect ] ) is only linear in @xmath9 ( @xmath88 ) odd couplings , but it contains also quadratic terms where a @xmath9 ( @xmath88 ) odd coupling is multiplied with a @xmath9 ( @xmath88 ) even one . we remark that this leads to different behaviours of @xmath27 $ ] as one or more couplings @xmath18 become large : whereas for observables in classes @xmath95 , @xmath96 and @xmath97 the expectation value goes to zero when a coupling of the same class goes to plus or minus infinity the corresponding limit of an observable in class @xmath93 can be a positive or negative constant or zero . in a nonlinear analysis one will therefore in principle have to consider couplings with all symmetries at the same time . in practice one might choose simpler procedures if the linear approximation is expected to be not too bad and if one wants to calculate corrections to it . one might for instance first analyse the four symmetry classes separately , neglecting in each case the contributions of the three other classes at the r.h.s . of ( [ mean ] ) and then refine the analysis of a class by taking the values obtained in the first step for the couplings in the other classes as fixed in ( [ mean ] ) . we emphasise that even beyond the leading order approximation it is still true that a nonzero mean value of a @xmath9 or a @xmath88 odd observable is an unambiguous sign of @xmath9 violation or the presence of absorptive parts in the process , respectively . the extraction of the values of the couplings , however , becomes more involved than in leading order . we shall now propose a method to analyse the data which presents several advantages in view of the basic problem posed by the large number of unknown three - boson couplings : with limited event statistics significant error bounds can only be obtained for subsets of the coupling parameters , but imposing constraints on the couplings to reduce their number entails a loss of information that can not be retrieved . in view of this it should be advantageous to use a parametrisation of the couplings which in a given process and at a given c.m . energy has the following properties : 1 . it allows to find observables which are only sensitive to one particular coupling parameter . 2 . the induced errors on the couplings determined from these observables are statistically independent . with this we can on the one hand give single errors for each parameter , on the other hand we can recover from the single errors the multidimensional error of the full set of couplings , having avoided the loss of information incurred by imposing constraints . from the single errors we can also directly see which combinations of couplings in more conventional parametrisations can be measured with good accuracy and to which one is rather insensitive . let us remark that in the leading order analysis there is a set of observables satisfying point 1 . in _ any _ parametrisation of the couplings . the linear combinations @xmath98 of our optimal observables ( [ optimal ] ) are only sensitive to @xmath18 for each @xmath99 ( cf . also @xcite ) . the errors on the couplings determined from these observables are , however , in general not uncorrelated ; in fact their correlations are the same as those obtained with the original set @xmath28 . this can be seen as follows : going from the @xmath28 to the @xmath100 we must replace @xmath101 so that we have from ( [ couplingscov ] ) @xmath102 in such a case the single errors give an incomplete picture of the situation if correlations are large . this is illustrated in fig . [ fig : correlations ] @xmath93 , where the 1@xmath103 ellipsis for two parameters is shown . their single errors are given by its projection on the coordinate axes and in our example are both rather large . some linear combinations of them are however measurable with much better precision , which one can only recognise if both errors and their correlations are given . in fig . [ fig : correlations ] @xmath95 where a set of couplings leading to uncorrelated errors is used the situation is much simpler . note also that the number of correlations , i.e. off - diagonals in @xmath80 , is yet modest for two couplings but increases rapidly with their number . ( 0,0 ) ( 5502,3031)(889,-4805 ) ( 1981,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5131,-2401)(0,0)[lb ] ( 6391,-3706)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3241,-3706)(0,0)[lb ] ( 1116,-2006)(0,0)[lb ] ( 4176,-2006)(0,0)[lb ] we will now first see that a parametrisation of the couplings satisfying both points 1 . and 2 . above can be found in idealised circumstances , and then mention the restrictions one will encounter under more realistic assumptions . if the leading order analysis is a sufficiently good approximation the solution to our problem is easily found . starting from a set of couplings @xmath18 and the corresponding optimal observables @xmath28 in ( [ optimal ] ) we can go to another set @xmath104 by @xmath105 where we use vector and matrix notation . the coefficients in the expansion of the differential cross section and the optimal observables transform as follows : @xmath106 let now @xmath28 be an arbitrary set of observables related to @xmath18 and define the corresponding @xmath107 related to @xmath104 as in ( [ obstransf ] ) . then we have for the matrices relevant for our analysis the following transformation properties : @xmath108 as shown in @xcite our optimal observables satisfy @xmath109 and @xmath110 so that for them one can choose a transformation @xmath111 which diagonalises all three matrices . this new set @xmath112 of parameters obviously has the properties 1 . and 2 . we were looking for . beyond the linear approximation of ( [ expect ] ) the expectation value of @xmath107 will still receive contributions from several couplings . in fact there is no set of observables for which the full nonlinear expression in ( [ expect ] ) satisfies point 1 . exactly , because the denominator involves quadratic terms in _ all _ couplings , and this can not be changed by any linear transformation of the couplings . if on the other hand the statistical errors are too large the covariance matrix @xmath80 will not give a good picture of the errors as we discussed in sec . [ sec : method ] , and its diagonalisation will not ensure point 2 . in the case however where nonlinear effects in the determination of the couplings and their errors are not too large , i.e. where the leading order expressions are a good first approximation both points 1 . and 2 . above will still be _ approximately _ satisfied in a full nonlinear analysis . we remark that if one has some previous estimates @xmath58 of the couplings that considerably deviate from zero one may reduce nonlinear effects in the determination of the @xmath18 by working with an expansion of @xmath113 around the @xmath58 as shown in sec . [ sec : method ] ; in our diagonalisation programme one will then use couplings @xmath114 instead of @xmath18 , the matrix @xmath70 instead of @xmath115 etc . to the extent that the observables ( [ optimal ] ) are constructed from expressions of @xmath85 and @xmath116 which are only approximations of those that determine the experimentally observed kinematical distribution the matrices @xmath115 , @xmath50 and @xmath117 will not quite be the same and can not be diagonalised at the same time . one can then diagonalise either @xmath50 or @xmath68 because they are by definition symmetric and positive definite , whereas @xmath115 is not necessarily so . again , unless such effects are large one will end up with a matrix @xmath118 that is not diagonal but has relatively small off - diagonals . it should also be borne in mind that the covariance matrix @xmath80 only gives the statistical errors on the couplings , so that even if it is exactly diagonal the final errors may be correlated due to systematics . the choice of transformation in ( [ couplingstransf ] ) to ( [ matrixtransf ] ) is not unique if one does not require @xmath111 to be orthogonal . we see in fact no strong argument in favour of an orthogonal transformation and remark that the various parametrisations of the @xmath1 and @xmath0 couplings in the literature are related by non - orthogonal linear transformations . the freedom to choose @xmath111 can be used to impose additional conditions on the transformation , and the one we propose here is that the transformed quadratic coefficient @xmath119 in the integrated cross section be the unit matrix . in terms of the new couplings one then has @xmath120 where we choose the numbering such that @xmath121 to @xmath122 belong to symmetry class @xmath93 introduced in sec . [ sec : symmetries ] , i.e. they are the @xmath9 and @xmath88 even couplings . only these appear linearly in the cross section , whereas all couplings give a quadratic contribution with coefficient one . having @xmath123 leads to a convenient simplification of ( [ expect ] ) , ( [ mean ] ) . moreover , the measurement of the total cross section gives complementary information on the unknown couplings . rewriting ( [ xsectransf ] ) as @xmath124 we see that measuring a cross section @xmath125 within an error @xmath126 constrains the couplings to be in a shell between two hyperspheres with centre at @xmath127 in the space of all couplings as shown in fig . [ fig : shell ] . their radii are given by @xmath128 here @xmath129\ ] ] is the smallest value the cross section can attain ; that such a minimum exists has been pointed out in @xcite . if in ( [ radii ] ) @xmath130 is positive but @xmath131 negative the couplings are inside the hypersphere with radius @xmath132 , and if both @xmath130 and @xmath131 are negative the ansatz ( [ diffxsection ] ) for the cross section is inconsistent with the data within the error @xmath126 . ( 0,0 ) ( 4647,3843)(1339,-5473 ) ( 4231,-3391)(0,0)[lb ] ( 2611,-1726)(0,0)[lb ] ( 5986,-3661)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3401,-3796)(0,0)[lb ] ( 3601,-3166)(0,0)[lb ] such constraints can be useful to find the physical set of couplings when the solution of ( [ mean ] ) from the measurement of the optimal observables is not unique . if they are strong enough they might even restrict the couplings to the region where ( [ mean ] ) can be linearised and thus simplify their extraction . one can of course use the information from the integrated cross section working with any set of couplings , but again the situation is particularly simple with the form ( [ xsectransf ] ) . we note that the information from the total rate is complementary to what is extracted from the mean values of our observables , which involve normalised kinematical distributions . from an experimental point of view their respective measurements will presumably have quite different systematic errors . let us also recall that the the measurement of the mean values @xmath26 times the number @xmath45 of events obtained with a fixed integrated luminosity combines the information of both @xcite . a nonlinear data analysis as presented in sec . [ sec : method ] can also be done in this case . we draw attention to the fact that unphysical solutions of equation ( [ mean ] ) for @xmath26 and of its analogue for @xmath133 will in general be different . we shall however not elaborate on this point here . another aspect of the couplings with the property ( [ xsectransf ] ) is the following . it is well known that constant coupling parameters deviating from the standard model tree level values lead to amplitudes that violate unitarity @xcite . the coefficients @xmath134 and @xmath135 in the total cross section @xmath103 increase strongly with the @xmath3 c.m . energy @xmath136 and the couplings @xmath18 must vanish as @xmath8 becomes large to ensure a decent high - energy behaviour of @xmath103 . in our new parametrisation the quadratic coefficients in @xmath137 are energy independent , and in this sense the new couplings are at a `` natural scale '' at every energy . to complete this section we show that a transformation with the properties we require always exists , i.e. that we can find a matrix @xmath111 that diagonalises @xmath68 in ( [ matrixtransf ] ) and transforms @xmath138 in ( [ quadrattransf ] ) to the unit matrix . the argument is analogous if one replaces @xmath68 with @xmath50 . by construction both @xmath68 and @xmath138 are symmetric and positive definite , so our problem is the same as finding normal coordinates for a multidimensional harmonic oscillator in classical mechanics ( cf . e.g. @xcite ) . to make this analogy transparent let us write @xmath139 and @xmath140 ; we then have to find @xmath111 so that @xmath141 with @xmath142 being diagonal . the elements @xmath143 of @xmath142 are generalised eigenvalues of @xmath144 satisfying @xmath145 where @xmath146 is the @xmath99-th column vector of @xmath111 . the solution is well known to be @xmath147 where @xmath148 is the orthogonal matrix that transforms @xmath149 to @xmath142 . of course one need not use ( [ solution ] ) in practice as there are convenient algorithms available to find @xmath111 and @xmath142 . in our numerical calculations we have used the routine ` eigenvals ` of the algebraic package maple . we will now give some numerical examples of our method described in the previous section . in this section we will stay within the framework of a leading order analysis of the observables . we start from the results in @xcite , where the sensitivity of optimal observables for semileptonic @xmath150-decays was calculated . we assume a full kinematical reconstruction of the final state , except for the ambiguity one is left with if the jet charge is not known . for the standard model cross section we use the born approximation and neglect effects of the finite @xmath2 width . to describe the triple boson couplings we take the form factors @xmath151 , @xmath152 ( @xmath153 ) of @xcite ; deviations from their standard model tree level values will be referred to as `` anomalous couplings '' . let us first look at a c.m . energy of @xmath12 , which will be attained at lep2 . the coefficient matrix @xmath115 can be found in table 4 of @xcite and in table [ tab : coeff190 ] here we give the diagonal elements of the transformed matrix @xmath118 , ordered according to the symmetry of the corresponding observables . the one standard deviation ellipsoid is diagonal in the couplings @xmath104 , thus its intersections with the coordinate axes equal its projections on these axes . the errors @xmath154 setting all other @xmath155 to zero are then equal to the errors @xmath156 where all other @xmath155 are arbitrary . they are given by @xmath157 and are listed in table [ tab : sens190 ] for an integrated luminosity of @xmath13 . we immediately remark that a negative diagonal element occurs in the transformed coefficient matrix , which is not allowed because @xmath158 is a covariance matrix and thus positive definite . we encounter here a problem of numerical instability : small errors in the calculation of the original matrices @xmath115 and @xmath138 can have a large effect on the smallest generalised eigenvalues @xmath159 and their eigenvectors , even to the point that eigenvalues come out with the wrong sign . this is not only a problem of our particular way of diagonalisation , but also occurs if one diagonalises @xmath115 with an orthogonal matrix ; we find that one of the usual eigenvalues of @xmath115 in the subspace of couplings with symmetry @xmath95 is negative . such instabilities can cause large errors in the matrix inversion of @xmath115 and @xmath50 . one needs @xmath160 to calculate the error on the extracted couplings as can be seen from ( [ chi ] ) and ( [ couplingscov ] ) , and large errors on @xmath161 can lead to large uncertainties in the extracted couplings , irrespective of whether @xmath161 is explicitly used to solve the system ( [ mean ] ) . one will of course aim to calculate @xmath115 and @xmath50 with best possible precision , but such an effort has limits , in particular if they are determined from simulated events and include for instance radiative corrections or detector effects . on a more fundamental level any calculation of these matrices will only be an approximation of the `` exact '' ones that correspond to the kinematical distributions seen in experiment . in this sense it seems quite inevitable that small eigenvalues ( the usual or our generalised ones ) of @xmath115 and @xmath50 and their eigenvectors are sensitive to imprecisions in the calculation and can lead to large errors or uncertainties in the data analysis . this holds of course even if one does not obtain eigenvalues with the wrong sign . we think that also in view of this a diagonalisation is useful , not because it solves the problem but because it makes it explicit ! it allows to easily identify those combinations of couplings which have small corresponding eigenvalues in @xmath115 and @xmath50 and will be the most unsafe ones in the analysis . from ( [ onesigma ] ) we see that they are those combinations for which the statistical errors will be largest . here the most unsafe coupling parameter is @xmath162 . one might thus choose to exclude it , and possibly other couplings , from the analysis and work in the remaining subspace of the @xmath104 where the numerics is more stable and where in any case the experiment is most sensitive . we will come back to this in sec . [ sec : practice ] . .[tab : lr190]diagonal elements @xmath159 of the coefficient matrix restricted to the left or right handed subspace of the couplings as explained in the text . the values in the left handed subspace differ from the corresponding ones in table 1 by at most 3% . [ cols="^ , > , > , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] crrrrrrrrr & & & + @xmath93 & 1.4 & 1.1 & 0.72 & 0.63 & & 0.50 & 0.17 & 0.062 & 0.044 + @xmath95 & 1.3 & 1.0 & 0.79 & 0.26 & & 0.11 & 0.083 & 0.023 & @xmath163 + @xmath96 & 1.2 & 0.58 & 0.32 & & & 0.076 & 0.031 & 0.013 & + @xmath97 & 1.4 & 1.0 & 0.83 & & & 0.24 & 0.040 & 0.026 & + finally we remark that like in the case for @xmath12 those couplings @xmath104 which give the largest statistical errors in the optimal observable analysis are predominantly related to right handed combinations of form factors as can be seen from the comparison of tables [ tab : coeff500 ] and [ tab : lr500 ] . let us sketch how our method of simultaneous diagonalisation might be used in practice . 1 . one first has to choose which matrix to diagonalise simultaneously with @xmath138 . these matrices need not be the same ones to be used in the data analysis itself but may be calculated under further approximations . covariance matrices for the observables and extracted couplings can be evaluated for zero @xmath18 as our entire procedure will only have its desired properties if nonlinear effects are not too large . if one uses the same approximation of the differential cross section ( [ diffxsection ] ) for the construction of the optimal observables ( [ optimal ] ) and the calculation of @xmath115 , @xmath50 and @xmath117 then the latter are all equal and can be diagonalised at the same time . otherwise one has to choose a positive definite symmetric matrix for the diagonalisation , i.e. one of the covariance matrices . the calculation of @xmath80 or of its inverse from ( [ couplingscov ] ) involves however a matrix inversion and might suffer from numerical instabilities , so presumably the best choice will be @xmath50 . 2 . in the next step one carries out the simultaneous diagonalisation of the chosen matrix and @xmath138 as described in sec . [ sec : simultan ] and determines the transformation matrix @xmath111 in ( [ couplingstransf ] ) to ( [ matrixtransf ] ) . at this point it will be useful to test the numerical stability of the transformed matrices , for instance by re - calculating them in the new basis of couplings or by repeating the diagonalisation procedure with slightly modified initial matrices . one might choose to discard some of the new couplings @xmath104 and the corresponding observables from the analysis if the corresponding matrix elements are found to be instable . this does not mean that one has to set these couplings to zero . from the measurement of the total cross section one will obtain limits on them , which will also allow to control the contribution they can give to the mean values of those observables that are kept in the analysis because the matrix @xmath118 is not exactly diagonal and because of nonlinear terms in ( [ mean ] ) . 3 . in the new parametrisation of the couplings one then carries out the analysis of the data . here @xmath164 , @xmath118 , @xmath165 and the other coefficients in ( [ expect ] ) will be determined under the most realistic assumptions and with the best precision one can afford . they will not be exactly diagonal in practice , but should have small off - diagonal elements if the approximations made in step 1 . and in the construction of the optimal observables are sufficiently good . 4 . one can then give both single and multidimensional errors on the measured coupling parameters @xmath104 . at this stage one can also present the results in other , more conventional parametrisations of the couplings and in particular compare with the measurements of other experiments , restricting oneself to whatever subspace of couplings might have been chosen there . in the first part of this paper we have shown how to extract coupling parameters from the measured mean values @xmath26 of appropriate observables without the approximation that the couplings are small . errors on the couplings can be obtained from a @xmath47-fit of the @xmath26 . if one puts constraints on the couplings in order to reduce their number the method also gives an indication of how compatible these constraints are with the data . the `` optimal observables '' discussed in @xcite have statistical errors equal to the smallest possible ones to leading order in the coupling parameters @xmath18 . beyond the leading order approximation one can obtain more sensitive observables if one has some previous estimate @xmath58 for the couplings , expanding the differential cross section around @xmath58 instead of zero and constructing observables from the corresponding expansion coefficients . in the appendix we show that up to linear reparametrisations the choice of optimal observables is unique : any other set of observables must give bigger ( statistical ) errors . in a second part we have proposed to perform the data analysis using a particular parametrisation @xmath104 of the couplings , which is specific to the process and its c.m . energy . it is obtained from the initial set @xmath18 by a linear transformation which diagonalises the covariance matrix @xmath50 of the observables and transforms the matrix @xmath138 of quadratic coefficients in the integrated cross section ( [ intxsection ] ) to unity . in an idealised framework each optimal observable @xmath107 for this parametrisation is only sensitive to one coupling , and the statistical errors on the extracted couplings are uncorrelated . under realistic circumstances both properties can be approximately satisfied provided that the analysis stays in a region of parameter space where the dependence of the mean values @xmath166 on the couplings is not far from linear . various matrices are then approximately diagonal which should generally facilitate the data analysis . in particular one can directly give errors on single or a small number of couplings , which will be necessary to obtain statistically significant results with a limited number of events . at the same time one can readily present multidimensional errors in parameter space , which is essential to compare with the results of measurements that impose various different constraints on the couplings . having approximately diagonal matrices also allows to easily identify those directions in parameter space which can be measured best and those for which the statistical errors will be large and which are likely to be associated with numerical instabilities , for example in matrix inversions . one can thus recognise and seek to remedy such problems in an early stage of the analysis . the measurement of the total cross section @xmath103 gives valuable complementary information on the coupling parameters . its dependence on the couplings is particularly simple in the parametrisation we propose since the quadratic contributions are @xmath167 times the standard model cross section @xmath168 , i.e. they have the same form for all couplings . a measurement of @xmath103 will then restrict the @xmath104 to a shell between two hyperspheres in parameter space . we have given some numerical examples of our method applied to the semileptonic decay channels in @xmath4 . in particular we find that the couplings @xmath104 which can be measured best with unpolarised beams predominantly appear in the amplitude for left handed electrons ( or right handed positrons ) , and that the @xmath104 with the largest statistical errors mainly correspond to the opposite lepton helicity . comparing our results at lep2 and lc energies we see that the coefficients in the linear contributions of the couplings @xmath104 to our observables and to the integrated cross section change much less with energy than in usual parametrisations . this is because in the new parametrisation the quadratic coefficients in the normalised cross section @xmath169 are by construction energy independent . we would like to thank ch . hartmann and m. kocian for their continued interest in optimal observables for triple gauge couplings . we gratefully acknowledge discussions with and remarks by j. blmlein , p. overmann , n. wermes , , and p. m. zerwas . this work has in part been financially supported by the eu programme `` human capital and mobility '' , network `` physics at high energy colliders '' , contracts chrx - ct93 - 0357 ( dg 12 coma ) and erbchbi - ct94 - 1342 , and by bmbf , grant . it was started while one of us ( md ) was at the university of cambridge , and we acknowledge support by the arc programme of the british council and the german academic exchange service ( daad ) , grant 313-arc - viii - vo / scu , which made mutual visits of the cambridge and heidelberg groups possible . in this appendix we show that the set of observables ( [ newoptimal ] ) , obtained from expanding the differential cross section about the actual values of the couplings , is unique in the sense that up to the linear reparametrisations ( [ reparam ] ) it is the only set of @xmath41 integrated observables which in the limit of large @xmath45 leads to the minimum error on the @xmath41 extracted parameters . to keep our notation simple we give the proof for the case that the actual values of the @xmath18 are zero . the expectation value and covariance of functions @xmath34 and @xmath35 are then given by @xmath170 = \frac{\int d\phi \ , f(\phi ) s_0(\phi)}{\int d\phi \ , s_0(\phi ) } { \hspace{6pt},}\hspace{3em } v_0[f , g ] = e_0[f g ] - e_0[f ] \ , e_0[g ] { \hspace{6pt}.}\ ] ] in the general case one has instead of @xmath85 the zeroth order coefficient @xmath171 ( [ newdiffxsection ] ) from the expansion about the appropriate values @xmath58 . for large @xmath45 the covariance matrix for the extracted couplings is given by ( [ couplingscov ] ) . under a linear reparametrisation of observables , @xmath172 where @xmath173 and @xmath174 are constants and the matrix @xmath173 is nonsingular , the matrices @xmath115 from ( [ obscoeffcompact ] ) and @xmath50 transform according to @xmath175 from ( [ couplingscov ] ) we see that the covariance matrix @xmath80 is unchanged under such a transformation . for our proof we can hence restrict ourselves to observables with mean value @xmath176 = 0\ ] ] and with a coefficient matrix @xmath177 . from ( [ obscoeffcompact ] ) we then have the condition @xmath178 = \delta_{ij}\ ] ] and the error on the extracted couplings is given by @xmath179 { \hspace{6pt}.}\ ] ] from @xcite we know that the optimal observables ( [ optimal ] ) lead to the smallest possible error on the @xmath18 , given by the cramr - rao bound . to satisfy our conditions ( [ centred ] ) and ( [ normalised ] ) we take the linear combinations @xmath180 \right)\ ] ] with @xmath181 { \hspace{6pt}.}\ ] ] we assume that the functions @xmath86 are linearly independent . otherwise some of the parameters @xmath18 are superfluous and can be eliminated ; our assumption is thus that the @xmath18 are an independent set of parameters for the anomalous couplings . linear independence of the @xmath182 guarantees that @xmath183 is nonsingular , which has tacitly been used at several instances in our paper . the set @xmath184 is related to the optimal observables @xmath185 by a linear transformation ( [ reparam ] ) and thus gives the same optimal error matrix @xmath80 . the covariance @xmath186 $ ] defines a scalar product on the hilbert space @xmath187 of sufficiently smooth functions of @xmath21 with the property @xmath188 = 0 $ ] . the functions @xmath184 span a subspace @xmath189 of @xmath187 , and we define @xmath190 as the orthogonal complement of @xmath189 with respect to the scalar product @xmath33 $ ] . any set of @xmath41 observables satisfying ( [ centred ] ) can then be written as @xmath191 with @xmath192 , @xmath193 . further decomposing @xmath194 and using the constraint ( [ normalised ] ) we obtain @xmath195 , i.e.@xmath196 finally , we have from ( [ simplecov ] ) , ( [ decompose ] ) , ( [ first ] ) @xmath197 + n^{-1 } v_0[{{\cal o}}^{\it ii}_i , { { \cal o}}^{\it ii}_j ] { \hspace{6pt}.}\ ] ] the first term gives the error on the couplings for the optimal observables @xmath184 , which is minimal . if the observables @xmath28 have minimal error , too , the second term must be zero , so that for each @xmath99 we have @xmath198 = 0 $ ] and thus @xmath199 which completes our proof . in sec . [ sec : simultan ] we mentioned that instead of @xmath26 one may use the product @xmath200 measured with fixed luminosity to extract the couplings @xcite . by an argument analogous to the one of this appendix one finds that up to linear reparametrisations our observables ( [ newoptimal ] ) are again the only optimal ones . in this case linear reparametrisations have to be homogeneous , i.e. one must have @xmath201 in ( [ reparam ] ) , since adding constants to the observables can change the induced errors on the coupling parameters . g. gounaris et al . , `` triple gauge boson couplings '' , report of the `` triple gauge couplings '' working group during the lep2 workshop 19941995 , hep - ph/9601233 , in _ physics at lep2 _ , vol . 1 , g. altarelli and f. zwirner eds . , cern report 1996 , and references therein p. overmann , dortmund preprint do - th 93/24 ; + w. bernreuther , g. w. botz , d. bru , p. haberl and o. nachtmann , z. phys . c68 ( 1995 ) 73 ; + d. bru , o. nachtmann and p. overmann , `` cp violation in radiative @xmath7 decays '' , univ . heidelberg report hd thep9702 ( 1997 ) r. akers et al . ( opal coll . ) , z. phys . c66 ( 1995 ) 31 ; + a. stahl , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) 40 ( 1995 ) 505 ; + aleph coll . , `` search for cp violation in the decay @xmath202 '' , paper contributed to the ichep96 conference , warsaw , 2531 july 1996 , report pa 08 - 030 ; + delphi coll . , `` improved test of cp - violation in @xmath203 using optimized observables '' , paper contributed to the ichep96 conference , warsaw , 2531 july 1996 , report pa 07 - 014 ( 1996 ) ; + n. wermes , `` cp tests and dipole moments in @xmath204-pair production experiments '' , talk given at tau96 workshop , estes park , colorado , usa , 1619 september 1996 , report bonn - he-96 - 10
Abstract: | [
"we show how one can measure anomalous @xmath0- and @xmath1-couplings with minimal statistical error using integrated observables , without having to assume that the anomalous couplings are small . we propose a parametrisation of these couplings which is well suited for the extraction of both single and many parameters , and which leads to a very simple form of the integrated cross section , from which additional information on the couplings can be obtained . hd thep9703 + cpth s4940197 anomalous three gauge boson + m. diehl + _ department of applied mathematics and theoretical physics + silver street , cambridge cb3 9ew , great britain + present address : + centre de physique thorique + ecole polytechnique , f-91128 palaiseau cedex , france _ + and + o. nachtmann + _ institut fr theoretische physik + philosophenweg 16 , d-69120 heidelberg , germany _"
] | 9,642 | 9,642 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the period of enlightenment was a time when spanish physics , which had been lagging behind the level of the rest of europe , was able to recover . however , the political events of the end of the 18th - century , the war of independence , and then the reign of fernando vii ruined the panorama of spanish science . history was sadly to repeat itself with the spanish civil war of 1936 , which brought to nothing the efforts of physicists and mathematicians of the end of the 19th and the beginning of the 20th centuries to regain the time lost during the reign of fernando vii until the `` generation of 98 '' . part of the disastrous situation during the 19th - century can be traced back to the legislation and curricular plans of spain s universities . the faculty of exact , physical , and natural sciences was not created until 1857 , with the ley ( law ) moyano . physics had been relegated to a minor faculty , that of arts , as preparation for the major faculties , and formed part of the `` philosophical institutions '' which were studied in the following order : i. history of philosophy and elements of mathematics ; ii . logic and metaphysics ; iii . general physics ; iv . special physics . all was in a latin which had become progressively less suited to teaching , so that enlightened reformers always attempted to publish textbooks in spanish . physics texts in latin were still being imposed on students even up to the time of the absolutist period of fernando vii @xcite . after the death of fernando vii , an ordinance regulating printing was promulgated in 1834 which allowed a certain freedom in publication , in particular in scientific publishing . one of the consequences of the centralization of curricular plans , such as the plan pidal , was the impulse given to the production of textbooks associated with the new programs of study . they were original productions as well as translations of foreign authors , and formed the beginning of a national scientific output which was to be of greater or lesser quality according to each particular case . the study plans usually counselled the use of certain textbooks which most closely approached the spirit of the courses . the procedure consisted in appointing committees to decide on the most suitable texts which then put forward a number of them to be chosen from . in the meantime , europe was seeing a major change in vision towards atomism thanks to such personalities as herapath , waterston , clausius , van der waals , maxwell , and boltzmann @xcite . imponderable fluids had been abandoned as the explanation of physical phenomena , and mechanics , heat , electromagnetism , and optics had been unified by the concept of energy . teaching was based on a program of mechanical explanations @xcite . the goal of the present communication is to analyze the impact of modern ideas concerning energy and the constitution of matter on the textbooks of 19th - century spain . we have examined 45 works on general physics at secondary and university education levels , with publication dates from the mid 19th - century to the early 20th - century . one of the first things that struck us was the great similarity between the books of different authors . with centralism , teachers were encouraged to write their own textbooks and , indeed , were rewarded for doing so . at the same time , the administration s goal was for teaching to be uniform nationwide . the result was that textbooks were written essentially with the ministerio de fomento s ( ministry of development ) official program as the table of contents , and that the texts served solely to expound known science and in no way to serve as the basis for further research . there were those who , being interested in science teaching , protested about the policy concerning textbooks . representative of them was eduardo lozano y ponce de len . under the pseudonym l. opando y uceda , lozano published `` programas y libros de texto '' ( programs and textbooks ) in _ revista de la sociedad de profesores de ciencias _ @xcite , and under the pseudonym `` un extremeo '' the same article in the journal _ el magisterio extremeo _ ( _ the extremean schoolmaster _ ) @xcite . in this same journal and on the same theme , ildefonso fernndez snchez published another critical article @xcite . in his writings lozano asked for the programs to have reference strictly to the subject matter to be dealt with and not to the methods to be used , and that the programs should include suggestions of the books that were best suited to the subject , but without the obligation of following them . the immediate consequence of that educational policy was that the different editions of textbooks seemed rather to be reprintings : textbook `` immutability '' from one edition to another was astonishing . let us take two cases as example . the _ trait lmentaire de physique _ ( _ elementary treatise on physics _ ) by a. ganot was used in many spanish and european institutes ( secondary education ) and universities . the first spanish language edition dates from 1853 . the 18th spanish edition was printed in 1923 , and even as late as 1945 an edition was published in san sebastin @xcite . in all this time there were only small modifications made with respect to the first french edition . an even more extreme example , since it was a work with even more antiquated ways of putting the material than ganot , was the textbook of @xcite . the 2nd edition dates from 1851 @xcite and the 10th edition from 1870 @xcite . in these twenty years and eight new editions the work remained without a single significant change , notwithstanding the archaic ways of setting forth the subject matter of the first editions . a third example is less disappointing : _ elementos de fsica _ ( _ elements of physics _ ) by enrique iglesias ejarque . the first edition of 1897 @xcite has quite a modern manner of exposition . nevertheless , while the following editions introduce small amounts of additional material into the text , there are never any significant changes . the 8th edition dates from 1924 @xcite and the last that we can find a reference to is the 10th edition in 1933 . clearly one may conclude that physics textbooks had quite a long effective lifetime . while there was a certain degree of difficulty in introducing new material into the textbooks , the great problem was to eliminate content which was included by tradition even though it was antiquated . the case of eduardo snchez pardo , the translator of ganot s work , is significant . in the prologue to that popularly used book : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the editor d. crlos bailly - baillire being for his part desirous that our public in general , and the pupils of our institutes and faculties in particular , follow science in her latest advances , charged us with the translation of the latest edition of the cited treatise on physics . on taking on this commitment , with the object that the spanish edition be more complete , we judged it convenient , corresponding thereby also to the wishes of the editor , to conserve certain theories , the exposition of various experiments , and the description of some of the instruments or apparatus that had figured in earlier editions of the forementioned work , and that in the latest edition had been totally or partially suppressed . ( @xcite @xcite , p. v ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ another of the characteristics of spanish physics textbooks was their orientation to student success in tests and examinations . works that are halfway between textbook and simple program of the curriculum abound . secondary education teachers often encouraged the students to think little about the physical phenomena themselves but to learn definitions , laws , and descriptions of apparatus . as clear examples we could cite , amongst several works , the _ resumen de fsica y nociones de qumica _ ( _ a summary of physics and notions of chemistry _ ) @xcite , and _ definiciones , principios y leyes de la fsica _ ( _ definitions , principles , and laws of physics _ ) @xcite . hence , for most students learning was not meaningful but purely memorization . together with the lack of practical classes , this may have been one of the causes of spanish physics slow rate of development during the 19th - century . in order to analyze what we understand to have been the introduction of modern physics into spanish textbooks , we asked ourselves the following questions relative to the works that we consulted : 1 . [ q1]are imponderable fluids studied in the textbook ? 2 . [ q2 ] is the term caloric used to refer to heat ? 3 . [ q3]does the concept of energy appear in a general form ? [ q4]does the mechanical theory of heat appear ? [ q5]does the kinetic theory of gases appear ? affirmative responses to the first two questions would indicate traditionalism , and to the last three , modernity . we would classify a textbook as modern if questions [ q3 ] and [ q4 ] are answered affirmatively . if the kinetic theory of gases appears as well ( question 5 ) , then we would consider the textbook to be quite complete . table [ tablei ] lists the responses to these questions for the 19th - century textbooks to which we had access . the works are ordered by publication date . when the edition is not given , reference is to the first edition . most of the works consulted belong to the library of the real sociedad econmica de amigos del pas in badajoz ( spain ) . while not exhaustive , the sample is significant , since students of the city of badajoz in the 19th - century were prepared in this centre for the entrance examinations of the schools of engineering ( high - level technical degree courses , rather than purely engineering in the english language sense ) or military academies . . responses to the five questions posed in the text , according to the different works consulted . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] some comments are necessary concerning table [ tablei ] . the books that were published in spain in the 1840s studied imponderable fluids , and dealt neither with energy , nor with the mechanical theory of heat , nor with the kinetic theory of gases . this situation was natural since these concepts were only being developed in europe at this time . however some foreign authors already did not study imponderable fluids ( neither did they use the term caloric to refer to heat ) , and their spanish translations set an example for such fluids to be abandoned . this was the case with the textbook of deguin , translated by venancio gonzlez @xcite . the translator would write his own textbook later @xcite , and despite going through numerous editions , would never abandon imponderable fluids . another textbook of a french author is @xcite , translated by florencio martn castro , although here imponderable fluids were still being studied in the original . the handbook of @xcite presents physics as a science of nature in general , including subjects such as geology and geography . this was the concept of physics that existed in europe at the beginning of the century . on the positive side , the mechanical ideal which was at the base of the development of physics in the 19th - century did indeed have a reflection in spanish textbooks . one reads in the prologue of the work of @xcite : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ( ) effectively , all the phenomena attributed to caloric , to light , and to the electric fluid are mensurable and calculable effects ; all are attributed to forces , all consist of movements , and constitute , in sum , mechanics . ( @xcite @xcite , p. i ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the texts that we were able to consult from the 1850s are mainly editions of the work of @xcite ( @xcite @xcite , @xcite , @xcite ) . the principal characteristic of this text was its immutability , edition after edition . although it studied imponderable fluids , the term caloric was not used , and neither energy , nor the mechanical theory of heat , nor the kinetics of gases appear in the text . the other textbook that we consulted is that of @xcite . although imponderable fluids are studied and the term caloric is used , the author briefly explains the theory of ondulations ( as the mechanical theory of heat was first known ) , and says of that theory that `` it is the one which today seems more correct '' ( p. 173 ) . this work was awarded a prize in a public competition under the auspices of the real academia de ciencias ( gaceta de madrid , 9 september 1854 ) . neither the concept of energy in a general form nor the kinetic theory of gases appear in rodrguez s text . it is interesting too that in this decade there appeared a physics textbook written in latin which followed the scholastic tradition @xcite . the textbooks of spanish authors of the 1860s were still studying imponderable fluids . they were also still using the term caloric to refer to heat , except for the editions of @xcite ( @xcite , @xcite ) , as we noted before . one french - authored textbook , @xcite , did not study imponderable fluids or use the term caloric , but then neither did it use the energy concept or the theories we are looking for . the same was the case with the textbook of @xcite , commented on above . a possible reason for these to be missing is that the translator , ramn de la sagra , used the 7th french edition . the note of modernity is found in the textbook of @xcite , in which there appears an idea concerning the mechanical theory of heat , namely the hypothesis of ondulations , although for didactic purposes the theory of emissions ( caloric ) was preferred . thus , one reads : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the system of ondulations is the most scientific , and the most admitted in modern physics ; but that of emission lends itself more to demonstrations , for which reason it is generally preferred for the explanation of the phenomena of the caloric . ( @xcite @xcite , p. 204 ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the textbooks of the 1870s begin to abandon the traditional theses , and show signs of modernity . the most traditional are @xcite , an 8th edition , and @xcite . the latter already does not use the term caloric , and later editions were progressively modernized . the textbook of @xcite studies imponderable fluids , and uses the term caloric . in its treatment of radiant heat , however , the work seems very modern . as noted above for @xcite , the author prefers the caloric hypothesis for its simplicity in teaching : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the admissible hypothesis is at present that of ondulations , in the light of the advances in modern physics ; but as it simplifies the demonstrations , many physicists prefer the hypothesis of emission to explain the phenomena of heat . ( @xcite @xcite , p. 148 ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the textbooks with a more modern spirit are those of @xcite and @xcite . mximo fuertes acevedo s work neither studies imponderable fluids nor uses the term caloric . but energy does not appear as a general concept either , despite the mechanical theory of heat being explained . adolphe ganot s textbook was much used in europe . the first spanish edition is of the year 1853 . we consulted the 7th spanish edition @xcite . it contains a paragraph explaining the dynamic theory of gases : gases are described as formed by elastic molecules in motion , and the elasticity of a gas at a given volume is proportional to the _ vis viva _ ( total mass of the molecules multiplied by the square of their speed ) . while making use of such concepts as this ( today , of course , replaced by kinetic energy ) , the text does not deal with energy in a general form . as is to be expected with this perspective , imponderable fluids and the term caloric have been forgotten , and the mechanical theory of heat is studied . all the textbooks of the 1880s that we consulted have abandoned imponderable fluids , with the exception of the handbook of @xcite which is already in its 10th edition . of the other works , the most traditional is that of @xcite , since it neither deals with energy in a general way nor introduces the theories we are looking for . we then have the 2nd edition of the work of @xcite , with no substantial changes from the 1st edition . we also consulted a portuguese secondary education textbook , @xcite , which has a similar perspective to those of @xcite ( @xcite , @xcite ) . the textbook of @xcite is the first of the series of books that we consulted in which energy is dealt with in a general fashion . the mechanical theory of heat is studied , but the kinetic theory of gases has still not appeared . the 7th edition of the work of @xcite has almost nothing to do with the 2nd edition that we commented on above @xcite . now , energy and the mechanical theory of heat are presented . in the prologue to the 6th edition , also included in the 7th , one reads : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ with great insistence i have attempted in the treatment of heat to relate together all the phenomena of thermo - dynamic theory . ( @xcite @xcite , p. v ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the outstanding textbook of this decade is that written by @xcite , published in tarragona . the author held the chair of physics and chemistry in the instituto provincial of tarragona . this is a modern text which includes the kinetic theory of gases , and in general explains physical phenomena mechanistically . in the work s prologue , the author speaks about a book of his on mechanics published in 1885 , and gives great importance to this branch of physics : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the criterion that has inspired this treatise responds to the necessity already recognized by all to explain the subject of physics in a single course , always preceded by a short course of mechanics as foundation and basis of the former ( ) . ( @xcite @xcite , p. 3 ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ as a continuation of thermodynamics , @xcite describes the kinetic theory of gases by following the ideas of clausius and introducing the definition of free path of a molecule as the distance travelled between two consecutive collisions . he deduces mariotte s law , obtaining the formula @xmath0 , where @xmath1 is the pressure of the gas , @xmath2 its volume , @xmath3 the number of molecules , @xmath4 the mean velocity , and @xmath5 the mass of a molecule . he also deduces avogadro s hypothesis from the kinetic theory of gases @xcite . as an indication of the little that this personality and his work have been studied , there only appears one book of @xcite in the _ collected catalogue of spain s bibliographic heritage : 19th century _ this is a textbook on elementary chemistry @xcite . the main characteristic of the books of the 1890s is that they all now treat energy in a general form , as well as the mechanical theory of heat . the textbook of @xcite simultaneously uses imponderable fluids and the term caloric , but only as additional information . a more curious case is that of @xcite whose textbook uses the term caloric without studying imponderable fluids . the work of @xcite has the interest of studying heat and light side by side , to bring out their relationship as vibratory phenomena : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ( ) the molecular vibrations of the bodies , transmitted by the aether , produce the feelings of heat in the touch and of light in the sight . ( @xcite @xcite , p. 496 ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ other modern textbooks are those of @xcite , the pharmacist @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . the small book of @xcite contains only definitions and principles . at no time is any idea developed , since the book s object is to serve as a collection of phrases for students to learn in preparation for their examinations . as part of these examination aids , the author prepared two plates which accompany the text , one on units and abbreviations of the decimal metric system , and another on physical units . the kinetic theory of gases does not appear explicitly , but some of its results do . for instance , one can read maxwell s law : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the viscosity of a gas measured by the coefficient of friction is independent of the density . ( @xcite @xcite , p. 60 ) _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ another modern work is that of @xcite . the author indicates on the first page in a footnote that the works that had been consulted were `` spanish : escriche , feli , muoz , rojas , and rodrguez largo . foreign : ganot , jamin , joubert , maxwell , and tyndall '' . the text contains a short paragraph on the theory of gases , in which bernouilli , clausius , and maxwell are cited . a kinetic interpretation of pressure is also given , but neither is the concept of mean free path introduced nor estimates of molecular speeds given . the textbook of @xcite , another modern work , has in the book dedicated to heat an article on the _ thermal constitution of gases _ , in which the kinetic theory is described . a kinetic interpretation of pressure is given , together with an explanation of high molecular velocities , including numerical estimates . a short section is dedicated to the _ height of the atmosphere _ , and another to the _ mean free path _ , in which one reads that `` crookes calls mean free path the space travelled by the molecule between two of those collisions '' . on the other hand , the kinetic theory of gases is not mentioned by @xcite . we also consulted some 20th - century books . they all had a modern perspective . the textbooks of @xcite and @xcite did not include the kinetic theory of gases . the 6th and 8th editions of @xcite ( @xcite , @xcite ) present improvements over the 1st edition . with respect to the kinetic theory of gases , a new paragraph is included to explain molecular velocities . the textbook of @xcite explains van der waals s equation of state . the last textbook that we wish to comment on is a translation of an italian book . it is the work of @xcite , a university textbook of modern physics where the kinetic theory of gases is developed completely . the topics in the book are surprising in their breadth and modernity . as a qualitative summary , figure [ fig1 ] shows the evolution of the responses to the questions that we formulated , according to the data listed in table [ tablei ] . spain s educational policies in the 19th - century encouraged a great similarity between the general physics textbooks of different authors , although there were voices such as that of eduardo lozano y ponce de len , in discord with this policy . this situation led to the differences between the successive editions of a textbook being minimal , and as a result , the effective lifetime of these textbooks was extremely long . a noteworthy example is the spanish translation of the work of a. ganot the 1st edition was published in 1853 and the last we know of was 1945 . likewise , there were difficulties in rooting out the antiquated content of physics textbooks . in many of them , modern and old theories shared the pages . a significant example was the case of eduardo snchez pardo , who amplified his translation @xcite with elements of old editions that had been discarded from consideration in new foreign editions . the result was to help make the recovery of spanish physics was a very slow process . with respect to the term caloric , it was used in the spain of this period with different acceptations : as an imponderable fluid responsible for thermal phenomena ( its original meaning ) , as a synonym for heat ( the latter being understood according to the mechanical theory of heat ) , and as the cause of the phenomena of heat , whatever their nature . also , during the analysis of the sources that were available , we found the orientation towards examination preparation to be excessive in the textbooks that we consulted . some are a simple cookbook of laws and physical phenomena that the students would have to learn if they were to pass their examination . hence , no interest was aroused in reflecting on content or in carrying out experiments in practical classes . certain textbooks shamelessly encouraged totally memoristic learning , so that content was not applied to new situations and was readily forgotten . another fact revealed by the analysis of the textbooks was the speed with which the mechanical theory of heat gained acceptance . this theory had become quite usual in many of the spanish physics textbooks well before the concept of energy had begun to be treated in a general form . while this fact seems disconcerting from today s viewpoint , it must be pointed out that both the mechanical theory of heat and the second law of thermodynamics had been proposed before the law of conservation of energy was generally accepted . the introduction of the kinetic theory into 19th - century spain occurred from approximately the 1870s onwards . in the 1880s , the theory already appears more developed in one of the textbooks that we consulted . this was the work of @xcite , which stands out for its mechanistic deductions of mariotte s law and avogadro s law . the topics dealt with concerning the kinetic theory in the textbooks that we consulted were : generalities of the theory , kinetic interpretation of pressure , molecular velocities , mean free path , height of the atmosphere , and the van der waals equation . lastly it should be remarked that we found no original contribution to kinetic theory in these spanish works of the end of the 19th - century . this work has been partially supported by the dges ( spain ) through grant no . pb97 - 1501 and by the junta de extremadura ( fondo social europeo ) through grant no . ipr98c019 . moreno gonzlez , a. : 1988 , _ una ciencia en cuarentena . evolucin de la fsica en la universidad y otras instituciones espaolas de mediados del siglo xviii a la crisis finisecular del xix _ , csic , madrid .
Abstract: | [
"spain was a scientifically backward country in the early 19th - century . the causes were various political events , the war of independence , and the reign of fernando vii . the introduction of contemporary physics into textbooks was therefore a slow process . an analysis of the contents of 19th - century spanish textbooks is here presented , centred on imponderable fluids , the concept of energy , the mechanical theory of heat , and the kinetic theory of gases . = 10000 = 10000"
] | 9,205 | 9,205 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: elastic scattering from a point defect in a hard - walled , multimode quantum waveguide is a problem which has been the subject of experimental@xcite and theoretical@xcite inquiry in both condensed matter and atomic physics . in this paper , we revisit the problem from an unconventional point of view , reducing it to the scattering of a single effective wavefunction off an array of images . our approach enables us to easily understand complex transport phenomena which have already been observed ( such as conductance dips ) , as well as predict other new ones . the problem of scattering from pointlike impurities in waveguides is a general one , and thus has physical applications in several fields . impurity scattering in quantum wires , and the resulting disorder effects on electron transport , have long been of interest in mesoscopic physics . specifically , the problem arises in the context of two - dimensional electron gases ( 2degs ) confined by quantum wire potentials ; the impurity can represent a defect in the wire . such quantum waveguides can be fabricated at low - temperature @xmath0 interfaces , and are of interest due to their potential role in high - frequency and quantum devices . as carbon nanotubes can behave as few - mode quantum waveguides,@xcite our results are relevant to transport in nanotubes with adsorbed impurities of interest in the study of biosensors . the problem of scattering in confined geometries arises in atom waveguides as well , with potential implications for quantum computing and atom interferometry . in both cases , atoms must maintain coherence as they pass through the waveguide , and the goal is thus to minimize phenomena such as collisional phase shifts.@xcite finally , the wave phenomena arising in quantum waveguides are in direct mathematical correspondence with a number of wave phenomena in other systems : water waves resonantly trapped between an array of cylinders,@xcite large antenna arrays,@xcite and sound waves directed by `` bessel '' line arrays in acoustics . @xcite motivated by the above applications , we examine low - energy scattering of noninteracting particles from impurities in an infinite two - dimensional quantum wire , with hard walls at @xmath1 and @xmath2 the wire ( fig . [ fig : schematic ] ) contains a point impurity , which we model as an @xmath3 wave scatterer of effective radius @xmath4 . our method differs from previous treatments , such as the renormalized @xmath5 matrix method,@xcite in that we use an unconventional approach which combines the following three ideas : 1 . the method of images . 2 . the realization that a confined scatterer , like a free space scatterer , is a rank - one target . we can , therefore , combine the @xmath6 degenerate transverse modes into a basis in which only a single wavefunction scatters . 3 . that the effect of scattering from the waveguide walls is to renormalize this single scattering wavefunction , so that it takes on a new effective value at the scatterer location . using the method of images allows us to explicitly understand how each reflection from the waveguide walls affects the conductance . the fact that the confined scatterer is a rank one target enables us to express the transport properties of the wire entirely in terms of the single scattering wavefunction . finally , the idea of renormalization allows us to fully explain the transport properties of the wire in terms of reflections of this single wavefunction from the waveguide walls . in section [ sec : freespace ] , we review free space multiple scattering , anticipating phenomena which will appear in the wire . section [ sec : wire ] lays out a similar formalism for scattering in the waveguide . in section [ sec : results - and - discussion : ] , we present physical phenomena which we observed in our model , which we interpret in section [ sec : physical ] in terms of interference effects . we relegate mathematical details to appendices [ sec : diffraction]-[sec : kummer ] . in section [ sec : wire ] , we show that the lippmann - schwinger equation for scattering from a confined impurity resembles the free space lippmann - schwinger equation , with the exception that in the wire , a renormalized incoming wavefunction replaces the true one . surprisingly , even for a single confined scatterer , this renormalized wavefunction includes free space _ multiple _ scattering effects . we thus begin by briefly reviewing free space scattering , emphasizing the three phenomena which will reappear in the lippmann - schwinger equation for a single scatterer in the waveguide . consider @xmath6 pointlike impurities in two - dimensional free space , located at @xmath7 let @xmath8 be the potential at @xmath9 due to the @xmath10 scatterer . we seek scattering solutions @xmath11 to the time - independent schrodinger equation@xmath12\psi(\vec{r})=0,\label{eq : schrodinger}\ ] ] under the assumption of low - energy , @xmath3-wave scattering . except as noted , we henceforth use atomic units , where @xmath13 applying the @xmath5 matrix formalism,@xcite we characterize a single scatterer at @xmath14 by its @xmath5 matrix,@xmath15 where @xmath16 is a function of the wavenumber , @xmath17 we choose the functional form of @xmath16 to simulate the scatterer of interest , under the constraint that @xmath16 must satisfy the optical theorem @xmath18 in this paper , we choose@xmath19 which represents a hard disk of scattering length @xmath4 . consider a single scatterer at @xmath20 in our @xmath5 matrix representation , an incident wave @xmath21 scatters into a wavefunction @xmath11 according to the lippmann - schwinger equation@xmath22 where @xmath23\label{eq : freegreens}\ ] ] is the 2d free space advanced green s function satisfying @xmath24 we shall henceforth assume we are using the advanced green s function and omit the superscript on the hankel function ; we shall also omit the implicit @xmath25 dependence in the green s function . any incoming wave @xmath21 must be a solution to the free space schrodinger equation . we can therefore express @xmath21 in the basis of `` cylinder harmonics , '' @xmath26 where @xmath27 correspond to @xmath3,@xmath28@xmath29 waves . an @xmath3 wave scatterer in free space is a rank one perturbation : of all the terms in ( [ eq : freespaceswf ] ) , only the @xmath30 term is nonzero at the scatterer . from ( [ eq : lippmannschwingersingle ] ) , then , only the @xmath3 wave scatters , acquiring a phase shift ; remaining higher partial waves pass through the scatterer unperturbed . while trivial in free space , these facts will reappear more subtly in the wire . the lippmann - schwinger equation describing scattering from a collection of @xmath6 identical point scatterers at @xmath31 is@xmath32 in which we express the @xmath33 recursively as@xmath34 where we have followed foldy s method.@xcite comparing ( [ eq : lippmannschwingermultiple1]-[eq : lippmannschwingermultiple2 ] ) with the single - scatterer version ( [ eq : lippmannschwingersingle ] ) , the @xmath33 are the @xmath35 incoming wavefunctions at each scatterer : @xmath33 is the amplitude incident on the @xmath10 scatterer after scattering from each of the other scatterers . a crucial point is that @xmath33 excludes the singular self - interaction of the @xmath36 scatterer . defining @xmath37 @xmath38 inverting ( [ eq : lippmannschwingermultiple1]-[eq : lippmannschwingermultiple2 ] ) yields@xmath39 where@xmath40 excludes the singular term . an alternate expression of ( [ eq : lippmannschwingermatrix ] ) is as the born series@xmath41\vec{\phi}.\label{eq : expansion}\ ] ] the effective wavefunctions thus have a simple interpretation in terms of interfering paths : the terms in square brackets describe amplitude incident at @xmath14 after interactions with zero , one , two , or three other scatterers respectively . the series continues infinitely . anticipating phenomena that will reappear in the wire , we highlight the following points of this section : 1 . the effect of multiple scattering is to create a new effective incoming wavefunction at each scatterer.[enu : newwf ] 2 . the effective wavefunction at a particular scatterer is a sum of waves scattered from all the _ other _ scatterers , and excludes the ( singular ) self - interaction of the scatterer.[enu : renorm ] 3 . an @xmath3 wave scatterer in free space is a rank one target.[enu : specialwf ] in this section , we examine how confinement in a wire affects the transport properties of a scatterer . applying the method of images , we derive a form of the empty wire green s function . using this form of the green s function , we show that the sole effect of confinement is to renormalize the incoming wavefunction . the image representation allows us to very simply calculate the renormalization coefficient . we define an effective cross section for a confined scatterer , and relate it to the conductance of the wire - impurity system . we derive an effective optical theorem in the wire . finally , applying this formalism , we investigate the behavior of the cross section and conductance as functions of various parameters . in order to write down the lippmann - schwinger equation for an impurity in the wire , we require the green s function @xmath42 of the empty wire . the usual spectral form of the empty wire green s function is@xmath43 where the @xmath44 are the transverse modes for the particular waveguide ( see e.g. datta@xcite ) . in our hard wire , the modes have the form @xmath45 we note that the spectral green s function ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) is a sum over evanescent modes as well as propagating ones . although we could , in principle , proceed using the spectral form ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) of the green s function , the spectral green s function provides little physical insight into the precise mechanism of the scattering . we therefore take an alternative approach , and use the method of images to derive an alternate , equivalent form of ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) for the hard wire . although the problem of an impurity in a hard wire has been the subject of numerous theoretical studies,@xcite the authors are aware of only one work@xcite which applies the method of images : ref . 3 treats the related problem of a point scatterer in a 3d waveguide of rectangular cross section , which the authors reduce to the problem of scattering from an impurity in a finite , 2d box . the method of images has the significant advantage of making multiple scattering effects explicit . we shall thus use the approach of ref . 3 , rather than the more common spectral methods . because our problem of an infinite waveguide is somewhat simpler than the finite box treated in ref . 9 , the role of multiple scattering is more transparent . we are therefore able to explore in detail the considerable effect of multiple scattering on the physical properties of the wire , which , although briefly mentioned , is not examined in ref . 3 . the empty wire green s function @xmath42 satisfies green s equation inside the wire , and is zero on the wire walls : @xmath46 the confined green s function differs from the free space version due to the necessity of including reflections off the walls when describing the response to a point excitation . note the factor of two in ( [ eq : greenwire ] ) , obtained by casting ( [ eq : greens ] ) in atomic units . as in electrostatics , we can linearly combine free space green s functions ( [ eq : freegreens ] ) with point sources in different places , so that the linear combination satisfies ( [ eq : wirebc ] ) . as long as only one of the point sources is inside the wire @xmath47 , our sum will satisfy ( [ eq : greenwire ] ) inside the wire . outside the wire , we discard the solution . if the point source is located at @xmath48 , we use the configuration of image point sources in fig . [ fig : offcenter ] . we reflect the scatterer , creating a series of images such that the position of the @xmath49 image is @xmath50\hat{y}.$ ] this image configuration yields an empty wire green s function of the form @xmath51 the green s function ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) satisfies ( [ eq : greenwire ] ) inside the wire , and ( [ eq : wirebc ] ) on the wire boundaries . outside the wire we implicitly set the green s function to zero . the green s function satisfies the dirichlet boundary conditions because , as we take infinitely many images , the alternating sum of hankel functions converges to zero on the walls . this series converges extremely slowly , precluding its use for numerical purposes ( see the discussion in morse and feshbach@xcite ) . the lippmann - schwinger equation requires knowledge of both the green s function and the incoming wavefunction . in section [ sub : single - scatterer ] , we calculated the green s function for the wire . in this section , we discuss the incident wavefunction . we show that the effects of confinement resemble free space multiple scattering : confinement renormalizes the effective wavefunction at the scatterer from its true value . in the image formalism , the multiple scattering arises due to scattering off images . applying the free space multiple scattering formalism ( [ eq : lippmannschwingermultiple1],[eq : lippmannschwingermultiple2 ] ) to the array of images in fig . [ fig : offcenter ] , we find that the lippmann - schwinger equation for the wire is@xmath52 where@xmath53 recall from our discussion of free space multiple scattering the physical meaning of this recursive lippmann - schwinger equation : the @xmath33 defined in ( [ eq : wavelets1 ] ) are the effective incoming wavefunctions at the @xmath36 scatterer in the array . in a general multiple scattering problem , we would have to stop here and solve numerically . the image array is , however , a special case : not only is it periodic , but the boundary conditions at the wall impose the antisymmetry@xmath54 any wavefunction , incident or scatterered , must be zero on the walls . thus , inside the wire , in the @xmath55 direction , the wavefunction is a superposition of modes ( [ eq : wiremodes ] ) . replacing the wire with an image array requires that we extend these modes outside the wire , into the region @xmath56 keeping the @xmath44 continuous at the walls , we can extend them so that the wavefunction is either symmetric or antisymmetric across the wire walls ; either set forms a basis . however , we know that in the absence of a wall @xmath57 must be continuous also , as we have eliminated the hard walls . the symmetric extension does not satisfy this condition . we therefore discard the symmetric extension , leaving ( [ eq : as ] ) as the proper boundary condition . combining ( [ eq : wavelets1 ] ) and ( [ eq : as ] ) , the equation for the wavelets thus becomes@xmath58\label{eq : wavelets}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined the renormalization sum@xmath59 noting that@xmath60 taking @xmath61 in ( [ eq : wavelets ] ) , we find @xmath62 substituting ( [ eq : as],[eq : zerowavelet ] ) into ( [ eq : ms ] ) yields the lippmann - schwinger equation for scattering from an impurity in a wire:@xmath63\sum_{i=-\infty}^{\infty}(-1)^{i}g_{0}(\vec{r},\vec{r}_{i})\label{eq : mswf}\\ & = & \phi(\vec{r})+s\left[\frac{\phi(\vec{r}_{0})}{1-sg_{r}}\right]g_{w}(\vec{r},\vec{r}_{0}).\label{eq : mswf2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] comparing ( [ eq : mswf2 ] ) to the free space lippmann - schwinger equation ( [ eq : lippmannschwingersingle ] ) for a single scatterer , we see that the wire simply renormalizes the incoming wavefunction at the scatterer to have a new effective value @xmath64 and so our final lippmann - schwinger equation is@xmath65 for convenience , we define a renormalization factor@xmath66 which is the ratio between the original and renormalized incoming wavefunctions at the scatterer . in order to cast the renormalized incoming wavefunction in terms of interfering paths , we expand perturbatively , as we did in ( [ eq : expansion ] ) for free space . for shorthand , define@xmath67 we find@xmath68\phi(\vec{r}_{0})\nonumber \\ & = & \left[1+\mathop{\sum_{i=-\infty}^{\infty}}_{i\neq0}sg_{i\rightarrow0}\right.\label{eq : bouncesfeynman}\\ & & \left.+\mathop{\sum_{i=-\infty}^{\infty}}_{i\neq j}\mathop{\sum_{j=-\infty}^{\infty}}_{j\neq0}sg_{i\rightarrow j}\times sg_{j\rightarrow0}\right]\phi(\vec{r}_{0})\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used ( [ eq : signstrength ] ) . the @xmath69 term of the sum ( [ eq : bouncesfeynman ] ) describes propagation to @xmath70 after scattering from any @xmath71 images , beginning with the first term , which describes free propagation to @xmath70 . alternately , the @xmath69 term corresponds to @xmath72 scattering events combined with any number of reflections off the wall , each of which introduces an additional phase of -1 . [ fig : born ] illustrates the correspondence between scattering from an image and reflecting from the wall . renormalization of the effective wavefunction is simply the manifestation of the identical phenomenon in free space ( see item [ enu : newwf ] in the list of section [ sub : freespacemultiple ] ) . from a semiclassical point of view , the incoming wave , given infinite time to spread , reflects from each possible combination of scatterers before returning to the source . note that @xmath73 is simply the wire s green s function evaluated at the scatterer , with the singular self - interaction of the source removed,@xmath74.\label{eq : gr}\ ] ] this idea , as expressed in ( [ eq : gr ] ) , is the essence of `` renormalized @xmath5 matrix theory.''@xcite the theory , as applied to our case , is equivalent to the idea that in free space multiple scattering , the effective wavefunction at a scatterer excludes the singular self - interaction ( see item [ enu : renorm ] of section [ sub : freespacemultiple ] ) . we note that although we have derived ( [ eq : gr ] ) via images only for the special case of a hard walled guide , the result ( usually derived perturbatively ) is in fact true for an arbitrary guide or confining potential.@xcite we have presented both the image series ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) and the spectral series ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) for the green s function . because the green s function of a system is unique , these two forms must be equivalent . however , the physical relationship between the method of images and the spectral form is far from obvious . the two forms of the green s function highlight different physical phenomena . for example , reflections from the walls , which appear immediately in ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) , are far less obvious in the spectral form ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) . contrastingly , the role of evanescent channels in the scattering , while straightforward in the spectral green s function ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) , is less transparent in the image expansion ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) of the same green s function ( although even the image expansion suggests that evanescent channels will be present in some form , because hankel functions are singular ) . in order to understand the connection between the image and spectral forms of the green s function , we show their equivalence mathematically in appendix [ sec : diffraction ] . in appendix a , we use an integral form of the hankel function to show the equivalence of ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) and ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) . the physical connection between the image and spectral formalisms is diffraction . the images in fig . [ fig : offcenter ] form a periodic array , which is effectively a diffraction grating . we note one small difference from a typical diffraction situation : due to the wire boundary conditions , the incident modes are superpositions of two plane waves each , rather than a single incident plane wave . this difference is trivial , due to the linearity of schrodinger s equation . when such modes are incident on the effective lattice of images , they diffract : plane waves ( or superpositions of plane waves ) striking the grating scatter , at large distances , into sums of plane waves at the bragg angles . the diffracted spectral orders are evident as the quantized wavenumbers appearing in the spectral form of the green s function . as the green s function for each image scatterer is singular , evanescent waves appear in the fresnel regime , near the lattice . we examine these statements rigorously in appendix [ sec : diffraction ] . while the method of images led quickly to the central results ( [ eq : mswf2],[eq : gr ] ) , these results expressed in terms of image sums converge so slowly as to be impractical for numerics . although the spectral form ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) converges more rapidly than the image series ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) , its convergence is still not uniform , as the evanescent modes include a logarithmic singularity . in appendix [ sec : kummer ] , we use kummer s method to accelerate the convergence of the green s function , casting it in the form ( [ eq : limitform ] ) suitable for numerical work . a side benefit of applying kummer s method is that we obtain a more rapidly converging expression for @xmath73 : in appendix [ sec : kummer ] , we show that the series ( [ eq : lambda ] ) for @xmath73 ( which is a schlmilch series ) resums to@xmath75+\frac{i}{2}-\frac{\gamma}{\pi}\label{eq : schlomilchgreens}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath76 is the euler - mascheroni constant . we note that this expression is considerably more complex than the expression ( [ eq : lambda ] ) derived via the method of images . in the image formalism , the expression for the renormalization constant @xmath73 has the intuitive form ( [ eq : lambda ] ) , because removing the contribution of the source simply involves excluding the scatterer itself , while retaining the images . in the spectral formalism , because the singularity is not explicit , its removal is considerably less transparent . in this subsection we define an effective cross section and optical theorem for the confined impurity . as we have shifted from the image formalism ( which applies only to the hard wire ) to the spectral one , where ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) applies generally , the results presented in section [ sub : scattering - in - wire ] apply to arbitrary waveguides , not only hard wires . since the wire is infinite , for calculating transmission / reflection at infinity , we need consider only the open channels . without loss of generality ( due to translational invariance of the wire in the @xmath77 direction ) , suppose the scatterer is at @xmath78 with incident mode @xmath72 , normalized to unit flux , the wavefunction at large distances from the scatterer is@xmath79\label{eq : larger}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which we can read off a scattering matrix@xmath80 where the reflection and transmission coefficients are@xmath81 one can show algebraically ( or verify numerically ) that @xmath82 in this section , we define an effective scattering cross section for the wire . the usual three - dimensional free space differential scattering cross section is@xmath83 where @xmath84 is the number of particles per area scattered into the solid angle @xmath85 , and @xmath86 is the number of incident particles per unit area . expressed in terms of probability currents , the above relation becomes@xmath87 where @xmath88 is the probability current , @xmath89 is the incoming probability current , and @xmath90 is the radial probability current . integrating over solid angles , we find that@xmath91 the optical theorem in free space relates the forward scattering amplitude to the cross section . here , we modify the above free space relations , in order to define a cross section for our confined geometry . with incident mode @xmath92 , the scattering wavefunction is@xmath93 which yields a probability current in the @xmath77 direction@xmath94 integrated over @xmath95 the cross terms cancel , and this current yields a scattered flux@xmath96 going in each direction . as our basis is normalized to unit flux , in our case , the incident flux is simply 1 . we define a differential cross section for the @xmath69 incoming mode , similar to the free space differential cross section ( [ eq : freespxsec]):@xmath97 where we note the exact analogy between plane waves in our waveguide and partial waves in free space . note also that @xmath98 has the correct dimensions of length . in free space , the cross section of a spherically symmetric scatterer is independent of the direction of the incident plane wave . in the waveguide , however , the cross section depends on the incoming mode , because the waveguide breaks spherical symmetry . we can define a total cross section as the average over incoming directions,@xmath99 we note that @xmath100 represents a sort of fraction of the incoming wavefunctions which scatter . flux conservation imposes the bound@xmath101 the maximal value of @xmath100 will , therefore , be @xmath102 , and its minimal value will be 0 . we had previously mentioned that @xmath103 this reduced rank indicates that , as in free space , a basis exists in which a single wavefunction scatters , while the remaining @xmath104 do not . the quantity @xmath105 thus tells us the fraction of the flux of this scattering wavefunction , and should be between 0 and 1 . henceforth we will speak of @xmath106 as the cross section ( as a fraction of the wire width ) . our final cross section is thus@xmath107 and satisfies@xmath108 we note that for @xmath109 impurities in the wire , assuming there are @xmath110 modes available , @xmath111 by arguments analogous to the single scatterer case , with @xmath109 scatterers present , we could choose a basis where only @xmath109 wavefunctions would scatter , while the remaining @xmath112 would be transmitted without any perturbation . the usual free space optical theorem involves the imaginary part of the forward scattering amplitude . one can show that the free space optical theorem constrains @xmath3 via@xmath113 a similar relation holds in the wire , and as it turns out , flux conservation implies that not every value of @xmath114 is physically permissible . unitarity of @xmath115 implies that@xmath116 using ( [ eq : rmatrix]-[eq : trmatrix ] ) in ( [ eq : unitaritycondition ] ) , after some algebra , we find@xmath117 which requires that @xmath114 satisfy the constraint@xmath118 we can express ( [ eq : optical ] ) as an optical theorem , like the one in free space . define the `` forward scattering amplitude '' to be the amplitude which scatters in the direction of the incoming wave:@xmath119 with this definition , our `` optical theorem '' in the wire becomes@xmath120 which is very similar to the 2-d free space optical theorem , @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the forward scattering amplitude . combining ( [ eq : crossmodes ] ) and ( [ eq : optical ] ) allows us to define a cross section,@xmath123 we note that our cross section is trivially related to the conductance of the wire , calculated as in the landauer formalism@xcite as @xmath124 noting that @xmath125 and letting @xmath6 equal the number of open channels,@xmath126 where we have used ( [ eq : rmatrix ] ) , ( [ eq : optical ] ) , and ( [ eq : sigmacalculation ] ) . in this section , we have laid out the formalism which we shall use to examine scattering in the wire . in section [ sec : results - and - discussion : ] , we use our formalism to examine how the cross section and conductance of the confined scatterer vary as the physical parameters of the wire change . confinement - induced effects on transport , in particular `` conductance dips '' as each new mode opens , have been observed experimentally @xcite as well as in other theoretical investigations@xcite of impurity scattering in quantum wires . changes in the transport due to motion of a single defect are studied in relation to universal conductance fluctuations.@xcite theoretically , the observed phenomena are generally explained via mode - mixing effects,@xcite or loosely attributed to multiple scattering from the walls.@xcite in this section , we discuss some confinement induced phenomena as we specifically observe them in our wire . the first quantity we wish to examine is how the cross section of the confined scatterer relates to the free space cross section of the identical scatterer , as a function of energy . the cross section of a free space scatterer is@xmath127 fig . [ fig : freespace ] shows that one feature resulting purely from confinement is the appearance of sharp discontinuities in the cross section as new modes become available ; the effect is present only if the newly opened mode is nonzero at the scatterer . to the left of each mode opening , the scatterer appears entirely transparent , whereas to the right of the mode opening its cross section is the full width of the wire . another point to note is that , while the free space cross section decreases monotonically with @xmath25 , the cross section of the confined impurity does not , and can be nonzero at arbitrarily high @xmath25 . we wish to examine some of the features of the confined cross section in fig . [ fig : freespace ] in greater detail . in particular , we want to look at the resonances , and understand the effect of varying the scatterer position [ fig : xseccond ] shows how the cross section and conductance vary as functions of energy , for three different values of @xmath128 . we observe the general property that resonances in the cross section appear as new transverse modes open @xmath129 unless the newly opened mode is zero at the scatterer . we further observe that the resonances have a universal structure : if a resonance exists at @xmath130 , then@xmath131 as the scatterer position changes , the character , shape , and number of resonances change also . in fig . [ fig : xseccond]a ) , the scatterer is located at @xmath132 , where each of the modes is nonzero . each resonance obeys ( [ eq : sigmaleft]-[eq : sigmaright ] ) . in fig . [ fig : xseccond]c ) , the scatterer position is @xmath133 because @xmath134 , the resonance at @xmath135 is much narrower than the others , and will in fact vanish if we move the scatterer slightly to @xmath136 . in fig [ fig : xseccond]e ) , we observe such missing resonances with the scatterer in the precise center of the wire , all even modes are zero there , and the resonances at @xmath137 have vanished . figs . [ fig : xseccond]b ) , [ fig : xseccond]d ) , and [ fig : xseccond]e ) show the conductance for each scatterer position , which is related to the cross section by ( [ eq : conductancexsec ] ) . discontinuities such as ( [ eq : sigmaleft]-[eq : sigmaright ] ) in the cross section lead to a continuously varying conductance . the impurity reduces the conductance by at most one stairstep . comparing the conductance with ( heavy line ) and without the impurity ( thin line ) , we observe that to the right of each mode opening , the conductance falls , generally to the value of the next - lowest stairstep . from fig . [ fig : xseccond ] , our observations are as follows : ( 1 ) resonances occur for values of @xmath25 at which a new mode opens , unless the new mode is zero at the scatterer . ( 2 ) the general structure of a resonance is that the scatterer becomes transparent immediately before a mode opens , and that its cross section jumps to one immediately after the mode has opened . ( 3 ) the shape and width of the resonances depend on the scatterer position , @xmath138 in section [ sec : physical ] , we shall prove these statements , and explain them in terms of interference effects . although we have examined the case of a repulsive scatterer in fig . [ fig : xseccond ] , our analytic and numerical results indicate that even for an attractive impurity ( @xmath139 ) the conductance is reduced by a single unit immediately after the subband opening @xmath130 , rather than just below it . similar results about the conductance reduction near the opening of each subband appear in other theoretical investigations of quantum wires ; we cite some representative works.@xcite one result@xcite is for a scatterer in a rectangle , and therefore can not be exactly compared to ours . however , the remaining references@xcite treat the infinite wire , and show a slight difference from ours : in refs . 6 and 7 , which examine only attractive impurities , the reduction in conductance appears slightly _ below _ the subband opening . 10 examines both attractive and repulsive scatterers . for repulsive scatterers , ref . 10 presents results similar to our fig . [ fig : xseccond ] , while for attractive scatterers the results of ref . 10 resemble those in refs . 6 and 7 . because delta functions in more than one dimension do not scatter , many different methods exist of representing a point impurity in two dimensions . we have chosen to use a @xmath5 matrix representation as in refs . 12 , 16 , and 17 , and the particular @xmath5 matrix we have chosen in ( [ eq : optical1 ] ) mimics the @xmath3 wave scattering of a hard disk of radius @xmath4 . the references whose results differ from ours have used explicit limiting forms of delta potentials . we attribute the slight difference in results to the different forms and representations of the point impurity . we have observed that the scatterer position in the wire influences not only the width and shape of the resonances , but can even cause a resonance to disappear . between resonances , we note the opposite phenomenon : the scatterer position barely affects the cross section at all . as we vary the scattering length @xmath4 , the cross section behaves very similarly to the free space cross section ( see fig . [ fig : crosssection ] ) . our general observations from the numerical results are the following : ( 1 ) scattering resonances occur where nonzero modes open . ( 2 ) the cross section jumps from zero to @xmath140 across a resonance . ( 3 ) the width and existence of a resonance is influenced by @xmath138 ( 4 ) away from resonances , the cross section behaves like the free space cross section . we have shown that items [ enu : newwf]-[enu : renorm ] in our list of section [ sub : freespacemultiple ] are characteristics of free space scattering which have analogs in the wire . we have yet to examine whether item [ enu : specialwf ] has an analog as well . in this section , we show that in the waveguide , as in free space , a basis exists in which only a single wavefunction scatters . we write this basis explicitly , and show that the scattering of this single wavefunction allows us to explain the confinement - induced phenomena shown in figs . ( [ fig : freespace]-[fig : crosssection ] ) simply , in terms of reflections from the scatterer and its images . in the basis of plane waves , the scatterer couples the channels so that , in general , an incoming mode scatters into all the modes . however , @xmath141=1,\label{eq : ranks}\ ] ] which implies that a particular choice of basis exists in which only @xmath142 of the incoming wavefunctions scatters at all , and is decoupled from the other @xmath143 basis functions . this wavefunction is the analog of the @xmath3 wave in free space . another way of seeing that only one wavefunction scatters is by the following argument : for a given energy , @xmath6 channels are open . any incoming wavefunction is a linear combination of the @xmath6 basis functions@xmath144 ( we require only the left- or right - moving set ) . any linear combination@xmath145 of the @xmath6 basis functions ( [ eq : inclr ] ) which is nonzero at the scatterer will satisfy@xmath146 equivalently , define an @xmath147 matrix @xmath148 such that @xmath149 and a vector of coefficients @xmath150.$ ] then , for any scattering wavefunction , the @xmath151 will satisfy @xmath152 as @xmath148 is a rank 1 matrix , only one solution exists . that solution is simply @xmath153 that is , the single scattering wavefunction is@xmath154 where the choice of sign determines whether the incoming wave is right or left - moving . suppose we take a linear combination of the two so the scattering wavefunction is symmetric in @xmath155 the scattering wavefunction becomes@xmath156\label{eq : swfplane}\ ] ] ( the other linear combination does nt scatter ) . by comparison with ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) , we recognize the above form of the scattering wavefunction as@xmath157 note that all the definitions in this section , and in particular ( [ eq : speqimg ] ) , are independent of the specific form of @xmath158 , and thus apply to arbitrary guides , not only to the hard wire . as we shall discuss later , ( [ eq : speqimg ] ) is particularly important because it shows that for an arbitrary guide , we can obtain the scattering wavefunction entirely from the green s function , which we can approximate semiclassically . we now return to the specific case of the hard wire , and try to understand the scattering wavefunction physically . from ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) , an alternate form of the green s function is@xmath159 where the @xmath160 are the image positions . combining ( [ eq : speqimg ] ) and ( [ eq : hankelgreens ] ) , we find an alternate expression for the scattering wavefunction:@xmath161 eq . ( [ eq : specialbessel ] ) shows that the analog of the free space @xmath3 wave in the hard wire is , as we might have expected , simply the free space @xmath3 wave , plus an infinite series of images a `` hall of mirrors @xmath3 wave . '' we can complete the analogy between free space and our wire by expressing the @xmath143 unscattered wavefunctions in terms of a `` mirrors '' basis . we do so by including higher order mirrored waves as in table [ table : swfs ] . @xmath162 ( twelve modes open)@xmath3 & @xmath163 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 & @xmath166 & @xmath167 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 & @xmath170 & @xmath170 the mirroring , and the signs assigned to each image , are somewhat subtle : only those combinations of free space orbitals which satisfy the boundary conditions , but are also zero at the scatterer , will not scatter . we note that the basis in table [ table : swfs ] is @xmath171 an orthogonal one ; inner products of an @xmath172 wave centered on one image and a @xmath140 wave centered on another image , for example , do not vanish , nor do the various such cross - terms cancel each other . however the important point is that the higher partial waves we have defined are all orthogonal to the mirror @xmath3 wave : higher mirrored partial waves do not scatter , whereas the mirror @xmath3 wave does . we note that the image sums in table [ table : swfs ] converge slowly and are unsuitable for numerical purposes . however , we have the plane wave expansion ( [ eq : swfplane ] ) for the @xmath3 wave , as well as the analogous expansion@xmath173\label{eq : psisplus}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the @xmath3 wave plus @xmath174 images . we can apply the raising operator @xmath175 to these plane wave expansions to obtain plane wave expansions for the higher partial waves . for example , we can obtain plane wave expansions of the waves in table [ table : swfs ] as@xmath176 & = & \frac{1}{k}\partial_{x}\phi_{s}(\vec{r})\\ \phi_{d_{xy}}(\vec{r } ) & = & { \rm im}\left[\hat{l}_{+}^{2}\phi_{s}^{+}(\vec{r})\right ] & = & \frac{2}{k^{2}}\partial_{xy}\phi_{s}^{+}(\vec{r})\\ \phi_{f_{x^{3}-3xy^{2}}}(\vec{r } ) & = & { \rm re}\left[\hat{l}_{+}^{3}\phi_{s}(\vec{r})\right ] & = & \frac{1}{k^{3}}\left(\partial_{x}^{3}-3\partial_{x}\partial_{y}^{2}\right)\phi_{s}(\vec{r}),\end{array}\ ] ] and we could proceed similarly to obtain higher partial waves . we might expect that the cross section is related to the fraction of the single scattering wavefunction which actually scatters , and we might thus expect the cross section to be proportional to the amplitude of the mirror wavefunction at the scatterer . however , some numerics reveal that the mirror wavefunction alone is insufficient to fully describe the scattering . from ( [ eq : crossmodes ] ) and ( [ eq : swfplane ] ) , we find@xmath177 meaning that the relevant quantity is the @xmath178 mirror wavefunction , and that its value at the scatterer alone explains all the scattering phenomena . ( [ eq : sigmaswf ] ) is again independent of the form of the waveguide . we have already discussed how renormalization of the scattering wavefunction arises from interference between all possible bounces off images . the implication of ( [ eq : sigmaswf ] ) is that the value of the resulting interference pattern at the location of the scatterer determines the cross section : at configurations ( wire widths , incident wavenumbers , etc . ) for which this interference is destructive at the scatterer , the scatterer is transparent . if the system is configured so that the bounces interfere constructively at the scatterer , a resonance results . we wish to highlight another important point , which is that combining ( [ eq : sigmaswf ] ) with ( [ eq : gr ] ) and ( [ eq : speqimg ] ) , we find that@xmath179}\right|^{2}\right\ } .\label{eq : semiclassical}\ ] ] the significance of ( [ eq : semiclassical ] ) , which applies to an arbitrary wire , is that the cross section is fully determined by the green s function of the empty guide . this relation is important because the green s function is a quantity which we can approximate semiclassically . substituting the semiclassical green s function into ( [ eq : semiclassical ] ) will give us a semiclassical approximation to the cross section . semiclassical methods may be of use in determining the transport properties of guiding potentials which are more complicated than the hard wire , and thus not amenable to exact quantum treatment . in figs . [ fig : freespace]-[fig : xseccond ] , we observed a reduction in the conductance , which are similar ( although not identical ) to the conductance dips observed in other theoretical investigations.@xcite using our formalism , we can understand the resonances and conductance dips of figs . [ fig : freespace]-[fig : xseccond ] simply , in terms of interference between different paths . again the results of this section do not depend on the specific form of the transverse modes @xmath158 , and consequently apply to a general waveguide . as we showed in ( [ eq : bouncesfeynman ] ) , the renormalized mirror wavefunction contains contributions that have propagated from each of the image scatterers . we are interested in the behavior of a cross section when a mode is about to open . the mirror wavefunction involves only open channels , and is thus discontinuous across a mode opening . using ( [ eq : swfplane ] ) , we can examine the behavior of the mirror wavefunction near @xmath180 , where the @xmath181 mode opens . suppose that the newly opened mode is nonzero at the scatterer , @xmath182 on the left of the mode opening,@xmath183 is finite . immediately after the mode opening , @xmath184 diverges as @xmath185 that is , the mirror wavefunction is always finite immediately before a nonzero mode opens , and diverges afterwards . the value of @xmath186 determines the width of the resonance ( and the lifetime of the corresponding quasibound state ) . however , while the limiting behavior of the mirror wavefunction influences the shape of the resonances , it does not fully describe their shape . as we discussed , the general structure of a resonance is that @xmath187 drops to zero just before the mode opens ; see e.g. fig . [ fig : xseccond ] . clearly the incoming wavefunction , which includes only modes which are already open , can not explain this transparency . the renormalization factor due to the wire , however , includes @xmath188 modes , both evanescent and propagating and unlike the incoming mirror wavefunction , varies continuously across the mode opening . using the expression ( [ eq : kummerform ] ) for @xmath73 , we find that@xmath189 generally . combining ( [ eq : renormalizedswfgr ] ) with the limits ( [ eq : mirrorleft]-[eq : grright ] ) , and using ( [ eq : sigmaswf ] ) , we can show that@xmath190^{2}}{\sqrt{n^{2}-n^{2}}}\right|^{2}.\label{eq : limitsigmaepsilon}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the value of @xmath191 controls the width and structure of the resonance . examining the right side of the resonance,@xmath192 under the assumption that @xmath193 an important point to note is that when @xmath194 as it does at a resonance , the free space properties of the scatterer have little effect on the cross section ( see for example ( [ eq : sigmaright1 ] ) ) , and so the structure of resonances is universal . we would like to note , in passing , that the transparency of the scatterer at certain energies is reminiscent of the ramsauer - townsend effect in free space . in free space , we define the @xmath3 wave phase shift @xmath195 of an @xmath3 wave scatterer by@xmath196 let us define it in the confined scatterer as the phase shift of @xmath197 @xmath3 wave generated from the source and the images , when the incident wavefunction is our mirror @xmath3 wave:@xmath198 comparing to the form ( [ eq : mswf ] ) of the lippmann - schwinger equation , we find that@xmath199 applying ( [ eq : sigmaswf ] ) , we find that@xmath200 so that @xmath201 when @xmath202 and @xmath203 when @xmath204 as in the free space ramsauer townsend effect , the cross section vanishes when our analog of the @xmath3 wave phase shift does . in conclusion , we can make the following general statements about the cross section : 1 . if @xmath205 the cross section will be discontinuous at @xmath206 the limit on the left hand side will be finite , and depend the value of @xmath207 the limit on the right hand side will be unity . 2 . the width and shape of the resonances in item ( 2 ) will depend on @xmath191 . physically this means that one can tune the resonances by sliding the scatterer up and down in the wire , or by changing the nature of the confining potential . having explored the structure of the resonances , we wish to understand them semiclassically , from an interference point of view . we again turn to the hard wire for insight into the scattering processes . the scattering cross section depends only on a single quantity , the renormalized mirror wavefunction . we have previously expressed this renormalized mirror wavefunction as a sum over the different paths ending on the scatterer ( [ eq : bouncesfeynman ] ) . when the interference between these paths is maximally constructive , the cross section is maximal . when it is maximally destructive , the cross section vanishes . in order to make this interference clearer , we shall make a simple approximation . consider the most straightforward case , with the scatterer in the center of the wire ( the case we examined in fig . [ fig : freespace ] ) . the image positions are @xmath208 in the green s function ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) , we replace each hankel function by its asymptotic form , which is equivalent to making a semiclassical approximation . this yields an approximate green s function@xmath209 the contribution from each image carries a phase related to the path length from the image to the observation point , as well as a maslov index @xmath210 describing the sign change after @xmath72 reflections from the wire walls . in the limit that @xmath211 , we see that the contribution propagating to the scatterer from the @xmath69 image has relative phase @xmath212 . for values of @xmath25 such that@xmath213 all the scattered wavelets thus interfere constructively . comparing with fig . [ fig : freespace ] , we see that this constructive interference coincides precisely with the resonances which occur as new modes open . to fully explain the structure of the resonances , and understand the scatterer s transparency just before modes open , we would have to consider the effects of renormalization in this approximation . we shall not pursue the semiclassical limit further here , as we have already examined the exact case in great detail in section [ sub : universal - conductance - reduction ] . however , purely from this simple semiclassical argument , we can see that the resonances induced by the wire are indeed related to interference effects between different reflections . combining the method of images with the idea of a single scattering wavefunction , we have developed a formalism with which to treat scattering from a single impurity confined in a quantum guide . we find many similarities between scattering in the confined geometry and scattering in free space : we have defined meaningful analogs of the free space cross section , optical theorem , partial waves , and ramsauer - townsend effect . although the hard guide is particularly useful for insight , many of our results apply to other types of waveguides also . we have examined the transport properties of a confined scatterer , making several general observations about the existence , locations , and and characters of the resonances . additionally , we have outlined a method for approximating the cross section and conductance semiclassically , for arbitrary guides . we have derived an effective optical theorem for general quantum wire potentials . using the fact that a confined target is rank one , we have described the transport properties of the wire entirely in terms of a single scattering wavefunction , renormalized by reflections from the confining potential . our central result is that the cross section of a confined impurity is@xmath214 where @xmath215 is the renormalized single scattering wavefunction , which includes interference effects due to reflections from the waveguide walls . despite the common use of the hard - walled guide as a theoretical model for 2deg quantum wires,@xcite actual confining potentials for both atom waveguides as well as 2deg quantum wires tend to be soft or even parabolic whereas in nanotube quantum wires , the relevant boundary conditions are periodic ( the periodic boundary case is also exactly solvable via the method of images , although we have not presented the derivation here ) . while the hard wall itself is not the best model for 2degs , it is the ideal system in which to examine how effects like conductance reduction , which are independent of the confining potential and occur in more realistic geometries , arise from simple reflection and interference phenomena . the effects of multiple scattering from the impurity are in fact very similar for general confining potentials ( see e.g. the renormalized t matrix formalism@xcite ) . a second limitation of this work includes the inadequacy of the @xmath3 wave scatterer model at high energies , and in particular at energies which are sometimes relevant when imaging electron flow . in a future publication,@xcite we plan to extend our formalism to treat higher partial waves . another possible extension of this work could be to examine the transport properties of many scatterers in the wire ; for example , explicitly explaining the transition from ballistic to diffusive transport in terms of interference between multiple mirror wavefunctions . jyv was funded during the earliest stages of this work by a fellowship from the national defense science and engineering graduate ( ndseg ) fellowship program . subsequent research was funded by a grant from the national science foundation , nsf che-0073544 , and by the nanoscale science and engineering center ( nsec ) under nsf grant phy-0117795 . jyv is grateful to m. stopa for a helpful critical reading of the manuscript . 24 natexlab#1#1bibnamefont # 1#1bibfnamefont # 1#1citenamefont # 1#1url # 1`#1`urlprefix[2]#2 [ 2][]#2 , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , _ _ ( , ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , , , , * * , ( ) . , _ _ ( , , ) . , thesis , ( ) . , , , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , * * , ( ) . , _ _ , vol . ( , , ) . , * * , ( ) . , , ( ) . , _ _ ( , , ) . , * * , ( ) . in sec . [ sec : greensfunction ] , we used the mathematical equivalence of the wire to a periodic array of image scatterers . further extending the analogy , we now reformulate the problem of the confined impurity as one of diffraction from an infinite , periodic grating , and the scattered wavefunction as a diffracted beam . we wish to note the detail that because of our dirichlet boundary conditions , our incident beam is a sum of two plane waves rather than a single plane wave:@xmath216 due to the linearity of schrodinger s equation , we can consider each of the constituent plane waves as scattering independently . the relevant physics thus reduces to diffraction of a single plane wave incident on a periodic array of scatterers . when our incident wavefunction strikes the diffraction grating , we expect that in the fraunhofer limit , far from the array , the diffracted beam will be a sum of plane waves at the bragg angles ( see fig . [ fig : diffractedbeam ] ) . each order of the diffracted beam will have a different weighting ; our object is to cast our green s function ( [ eq : wiregreens ] ) in a manner that makes these weightings explicit . this formulation is of interest because it is equivalent to determining the transmission and reflection coefficients of our system . namely , if we send in a mode , we would like to know what modes come out and with what intensities , which is precisely what we shall find by casting our scattering wavefunction as a diffracted beam . to begin , we note that bessel functions are regular , and consequently have plane wave expansions . in fact , the well - known integral form of the bessel function@xmath217 expresses the bessel function as an isotropic sum of plane waves emanating in all directions from the origin . we can rewrite ( [ eq : intbessel ] ) in terms of a line integral over @xmath218as@xmath219 where @xmath220 lies along the real axis , going back and forth within the interval @xmath221 . we seek an analogous expression for the hankel function . since @xmath222 is always less than @xmath25 in ( [ eq : intbessel2 ] ) , @xmath223 is always real , and the plane waves in ( [ eq : intbessel2 ] ) do not include evanescent waves . suppose we modify the right - hand side of ( [ eq : intbessel2 ] ) . by permitting @xmath218 to range from @xmath224 to @xmath225 , we may include contributions from all possible evanescent waves , yielding@xmath226 for @xmath227 the corresponding value of @xmath228 , where @xmath229 is imaginary . choosing the positive value makes the evanescent waves die off to the right @xmath230 and diverge to the left @xmath231 therefore , with this choice of sign , we may expect ( [ eq : evanescent_sum ] ) to converge only in the right half - plane . by adding on an evanescent contribution to the bessel function s plane wave expansion , we have in fact arrived ( up to a constant ) at an integral form of the hankel function , valid in the right half - plane only , @xmath232 where@xmath233 eq . ( [ eq : inthankel ] ) is a well - known expansion,@xcite readily obtained by fourier transforming green s equation . consider now the sum@xmath234 which is the green s function for a fully periodic array of scatterers at @xmath235 ( or equivalently , a periodic wire with walls at @xmath236 and a scatterer halfway between ) . based on the physical picture of diffraction ( fig . [ fig : diffractedbeam ] ) , the sum in ( [ eq : althanksum ] ) must be a superposition of plane and evanescent waves at real and complex bragg angles respectively . we wish to find the weighting on each wave ( analogous to the structure factor in x - ray diffraction ) . to find the weights , we calculate the expansion explicitly . using ( [ eq : inthankel ] ) in ( [ eq : althanksum ] ) , we find @xmath237 where we have used@xmath238^{n}=2\pi\sum_{n=-\infty}^{\infty}\delta(k_{y}d-2\pi n),\ ] ] ( similar to stationary phase ) to reach the expression ( [ eq : poisson ] ) . one can , more rigorously , reach ( [ eq : poisson ] ) via the poisson sum formula.@xcite performing the integral in ( [ eq : poisson ] ) yields the final expression@xmath239 where we use the absolute value signs to extend the green s function to converge on @xmath240 and we define@xmath241 where the @xmath242 are the bragg angles@xmath243 and the complex - valued @xmath242 are the result of the logarithmic singularity . the image representation of our wire is not exactly the periodic array of fig . [ fig : diffractedbeam ] . the images alternate in sign , and in general the scatterer is off - center . we can , however , represent our image array as a sum of two arrays , as in fig . [ fig : twoarrays ] . one can easily verify that the green s function for the wire with point source at @xmath244 becomes the sum@xmath245\nonumber \\ & = & -i\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{k_{x}^{(n)}}e^{ik_{x}^{(n)}|x - x_{0}|}\label{eq : imagegreensequal}\\ & & \hspace{.5in}\times\chi_{n}(y)\chi_{n}(y_{0})\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the bragg angles are modified slightly from the case of the periodic wire , and defined by@xmath246 the form ( [ eq : imagegreensequal ] ) is identical to ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) . we have shown that diffraction translates the method of images into the usual eigenfunction expansion of the green s function . form ( [ eq : dattagreenswire ] ) of the green s function converges slowly also . the reason for the slow convergence is the singularity at the source , which is present but disguised in the evanescent modes . we use the kummer method for convergence acceleration,@xcite which also makes the singularity explicit . kummer s method involves adding and subtracting a multiple of the static ( @xmath247 ) green s function . we note that [ 12 ] obtains similar results , via a slightly different procedure . we wish to consider a more rapidly converging form of the green s function:@xmath249\label{eq : quickconverge}\\ & & \hspace{.5in}+\alpha g_{w}(\vec{r},\vec{r}_{0};0)\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath250 is a constant which we shall determine . the static green s function happens to be the potential which solves poisson s equation for a point charge between two grounded , conducting plates,@xcite and we can put it in closed form as follows:@xmath251e^{-\frac{m\pi}{d}\left|x - x_{0}\right|}\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{\pi}\textrm{re } \sum_{m=1}^{\infty}\frac{1}{m}e^{-\frac{m\pi}{d}\left|x - x_{0}\right|}\label{eq : g24}\\ & & \hspace{.5in}\times\left[e^{\frac{im\pi(y+y_{0})}{d}}-e^{\frac{im\pi(y - y_{0})}{d}}\right]\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{\pi}\textrm{re } \sum_{m=1}^{\infty}\left(\frac{z_{+}^{m}}{m}-\frac{z_{-}^{m}}{m}\right)\label{eq : gw5}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where@xmath252 using the identities@xmath253 and@xmath254 we find@xmath255\nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{2\pi}\ln\frac{\cos\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(y - y_{0})\right]-\cosh\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(x - x_{0})\right]}{\cos\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(y+y_{0})\right]-\cosh\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(x - x_{0})\right]}.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] the singularity of the green s function arises from a logarithmic singularity in the hankel term at the source . near the scatterer , the contribution from this term becomes@xmath256 where @xmath76 is the euler - mascheroni constant , while from eq . ( [ eq : limitform ] ) , we find that the limiting behavior of the static green s function is ( after some algebra)@xmath257 in order to cancel the logarithmic singularity in green s function , we thus require that@xmath258 so that@xmath259 & = \nonumber \\ & & \hspace{-1.5in}-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln\left[\frac{kd}{\pi}\sin\left(\frac{\pi y_{0}}{d}\right)\right]+\frac{i}{2}-\frac{\gamma}{\pi}\label{eq : limit6}\end{aligned}\ ] ] our final form for the green s function , using ( [ eq : quickconverge]-[eq : gamma ] ) is@xmath260-\cosh\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(x - x_{0})\right]}{\cos\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(y+y_{0})\right]-\cosh\left[\frac{\pi}{d}(x - x_{0})\right]}.\nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] this expression is of further use in that it allows us to obtain another form of the renormalization constant ( [ eq : lambda ] ) , which we had shown to have the slowly convergent expansion@xmath261 we can now express @xmath73 in an equivalent , but more rapidly convergent expression , suitable for numerical purposes:@xmath262\label{eq : limit9}\\ & = & \sum_{m=1}^{\infty}\left(\frac{1}{ik_{x}^{(m)}}+\frac{d}{m\pi}\right)\chi_{m}^{2}(y_{0})\nonumber \\ & & \hspace{.25in}-\frac{1}{\pi}\ln\left[\frac{kd}{\pi}\sin\left(\frac{\pi y_{0}}{d}\right)\right]+\frac{i}{2}-\frac{\gamma}{\pi}.\label{eq : kummerform}\end{aligned}\ ] ]
Abstract: | [
"this paper develops a scattering theory to examine how point impurities affect transport through quantum wires . while some of our new results apply specifically to hard - walled wires , others for example , an effective optical theorem for two - dimensional waveguides are more general . we apply the method of images to the hard - walled guide , explicitly showing how scattering from an impurity affects the wire s conductance . we express the effective cross section of a confined scatterer entirely in terms of the empty waveguide s green s function , suggesting a way in which to use semiclassical methods to understand transport properties of smooth wires . in addition to predicting some new phenomena , our approach provides a simple physical picture for previously observed effects such as conductance dips and confinement - induced resonances ."
] | 10,699 | 10,699 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the dynamics of evolution depend an organism s fitness landscape " , the mapping from genotypes to reproductive capacity . knowledge of the fitness landscape can help resolve questions such as how quickly a pathogen will acquire drug resistance , or by what pattern of mutations . but direct measurement of a fitness landscape is impossible because of the vast number of genotypes . here we critically examine regression techniques used to approximate fitness landscapes from data . we find that such regressions are subject to two inherent biases that distort the biological quantities of greatest interest , often making evolution appear less predictable than it actually is . we discuss methods that may mitigate these biases in some cases . an organism s fitness , or expected reproductive output , is determined by its genotype , environment , and possibly the frequencies of other genotypes in the population . in the simplified setting of a fixed environment , and disregarding frequency - dependent effects , which is typical in many experimental populations @xcite , fitnesses are described by a map from genotypes to reproductive rates , called the _ fitness landscape_. the dynamics of an adapting population fundamentally depend on characteristics of the organism s fitness landscape @xcite . however , mapping out an organism s fitness landscape is virtually impossible in practice because of the coarse resolution of fitness measurements , and because of _ epistasis _ : the fitness contribution of one locus may depend on the states of other loci . to account for all possible forms of epistasis , a fitness landscape must assign a potentially different fitness to each genotype , and the number of genotypes increases exponentially with the number of loci . as a result of these practical difficulties , fitness landscapes have been directly measured in only very limited cases , such as for individual proteins , rna molecules , or viruses . even in these limited cases genetic variation was restricted to a handful of genetic sites @xcite . alternatively , one might try to infer properties of a fitness landscape from a time - series of samples from a reproducing population . despite considerable effort along these lines @xcite , this approach is difficult and such inferences from times - series can be subject to systematic biases @xcite . as a result , very little is known about fitness landscapes in nature , despite their overwhelming importance in shaping the course of evolution . technological developments now allow researchers to assay growth rates of microbes or enzymatic activities of individual proteins and rnas for millions of variants @xcite . as a result , researchers are now beginning to sample and measure larger portions of the fitness landscapes than previously possible . nonetheless , even in these cases , the set of sampled genotypes still represents a tiny proportion of all genotypes , and likely also a tiny proportion of all viable genotypes . in order to draw conclusions from the limited number of genotypes whose fitnesses can be assayed , researchers fit statistical models , notably by penalized regression , that approximate the fitness landscape based on the data available . this situation is perhaps best illustrated by recent studies of fitness for the hiv-1 virus , based on the measured reproductive capacity of hiv - derived amplicons inserted into a resistance test vector @xcite . these hiv genotypes were sampled from infected patients . ( an alternative approach , often used for measuring activities of an individual enzyme , is to introduce mutations randomly into a wild - type sequence @xcite ) . whereas the entire fitness landscape of hiv-1 consists of reproductive values for roughly @xmath0 genotypes , only @xmath1 genotypes were assayed in the experiment @xcite . researchers therefore approximated the fitness landscape by penalized regression , based on the measured data , using an expansion in terms of main effects of loci and epistatic interactions between loci . the principal goal of estimating the underlying fitness landscape was to assess the extent and form of epistasis @xcite , and , more generally , to understand how adaptation would proceed on such a landscape @xcite . these @xcite and other high - throughput fitness measurement studies @xcite produce massive amounts of data , but not nearly enough to determine an entire fitness landscape . this presents the field with several pressing questions : do statistical approximations based on available data faithfully reproduce the relevant aspects of the true fitness landscape and accurately predict the dynamics of adaptation ? or , do biases arising from statistical fits or measurement noise influence the conclusions we draw from such data ? here , we begin to address these fundamental questions about empirical fitness measurements and how they inform our understanding of the underlying fitness landscape and evolution on the landscape . we study the effects of approximating a fitness landscape from data in terms of main and epistatic effects of loci . we demonstrate that such approximations , which are required to draw any general conclusions from a limited sample of genotypes , are subject to two distinct sources of biases . although these biases are known features of linear regressions , they have important consequences for the biological quantities inferred from such fitness landscapes . these biases systematically alter the form of epistasis in the inferred fitness landscape compared to the true underlying landscape . in particular , the inferred fitness landscape will typically exhibit less local ruggedness than the true landscape , and it will suggest that evolutionary trajectories are less predictable than they actually are in the true landscape . most of our analysis is based on samples from mathematically constructed fitness landscapes . but we argue that the types of biases we identify apply generally , and in more biologically realistic situations . indeed , we show that the same types of biases occur in rna - folding landscapes as well as empirically measured regulatory sequence binding landscapes . although it may be impossible to completely remove these biases , we conclude by suggesting steps to mitigate the biases in some cases . a function that maps genotype to fitness may be written as an expansion in terms of main effects and interactions between loci @xcite : @xmath2 where @xmath3 represents a genetic variant at locus @xmath4 , @xmath5 is the fitness ( typically the logarithm of growth rate ) , and @xmath6 is the number of loci . the nucleotides atgc , or any number of categorical variables , may be encoded by dummy variables , represented by @xmath3 , which equal either @xmath7 or @xmath8 in this study ( see methods ) . the term @xmath9 represents a sum over all pairs of interactions between loci , and the elipses represent higher - order terms , such as three - way interactions . since the statistical model is linear in the coefficients @xmath10 and @xmath11 , etc , the best - fit coefficients can be inferred by linear regression . experimental data are now sufficiently extensive that both the additive and pairwise epistatic coefficients , @xmath10 and @xmath11 , can often be estimated , whereas three - way and higher - order interactions are typically omitted from the statistical model of the fitness landscape . we refer to a statistical model with only additive and pairwise interactions as a quadratic model . even in the quadratic case , the statistical model may involve more free coefficients than empirical observations , so that over - fitting could become a problem . techniques to accommodate this problem , and the biases they introduce , are discussed below . the first type of bias we study arises from the use of penalized regressions which are required when a large number of parameters must be inferred from a limited amount of data . under standard linear regression with limited data , overfitting can cause the magnitudes of inferred coefficients to be large , resulting in positive and negative effects that cancel out to fit the observed fitness measurements . the standard remedy for overfitting is a so - called penalized least - squares regression " , such as ridge or lasso regression @xcite , which constrains the complexity of the inferred model by limiting the magnitudes of the inferred coefficients . for example , in fitting a quadratic landscape to sampled hiv-1 fitness measurements , hinkley et al . employed a form of penalized linear regression in order to avoid overfitting their data @xcite . although often required when fitting complex fitness landscapes to data , the penalized least square regression has some drawbacks . in general , the mean square error of any regression can be decomposed into a bias and a variance . the gauss - markov theorem guarantees that the standard least - squares linear regression produces the lowest possible mean squared error ( mse ) that has no bias , whereas penalized least squares can reduce the mse further by adding bias in exchange for a reduction in variance @xcite . thus , in order to provide predictive power for the fitnesses of un - observed genotypes , these regressions necessarily produce biased fits . while the accuracy of predicting unobserved fitnesses may be improved by such a biased fit , other quantities of biological interest derived from these predictions , such as measures of epistasis , may be distorted by the bias . in order to quantify the biases introduced by penalized least square regression , we compared mathematically constructed fitness landscapes to the landscapes inferred from a quadratic model fit by ridge regression ( similar results hold for lasso regressions , see discussion ) . our analyses are based on two types of mathematical fitness landscapes . the widely used @xmath12-landscapes of kauffman et al @xcite comprise a family of landscapes that range from additive to highly epistatic , depending upon the parameter @xmath13 , which determines the number of ( typically sparse ) interactions between sites . we also study polynomial " landscapes , which consist of additive effects and all possible pairwise and three - way interactions . in these landscapes , the amount of epistasis can be tuned by controlling the proportion of fitness variation that arises from the additive contributions , pairwise interactions , and three - way interactions ( see methods ) . we constructed @xmath12 and polynomial landscapes with only additive and pairwise effects , we sampled genotypes and fitness from these landscapes , and we fit a quadratic model of the landscape based on the sampled data " using penalized least square regression . for both @xmath12 and polynomial landscapes , we found that the inferred landscape tends to overestimate the fitnesses of low - fitness genotypes and underestimate the fitnesses of high - fitness genotypes ( polynomial landscape fig . [ fig : regbias ] , @xmath12 landscape fig . [ fig : regbias_nk ] ) . thus , there is a fitness - dependent bias in the inferred landscape compared to the true underlying landscape . the extent of this bias depends on the amount of penalization used , which in turn depends on the amount of data sampled relative the number of free coefficients in the statistical model . when the number of independent samples equals the number of free coefficients these biases disappear ( fig . [ fig : regbias ] , red curve ) , but whenever data are in short supply these biases arise and they can be substantial in magnitude ( fig . [ fig : regbias ] ) . the only way to avoid this bias entirely is to obtain at least as many independent observations as model parameters , which is typically unfeasible for realistic protein lengths or genome sizes . furthermore , as we will discuss below , these inherent biases have important consequences for our understanding of epistasis in the fitness landscape and for our ability to predict the dynamics of adaptation . , towards the average value , so that the high fitnesses are underestimated and low fitnesses are overestimated . the plot shows the mean ( solid line ) and standard deviation ( shaded area ) , of the distribution of residuals at a given true fitness value @xmath5 , smoothed by a gaussian moving window ( see methods ) . the fewer the observations ( i.e. the smaller the number of genotypes sampled for fitting the statistical model ) , the stronger the effect of this bias , as seen by comparing fits to training datasets of different sizes : 250 sampled genotypes ( red ) , 200 sampled genotypes ( green ) , and 150 sampled genotypes ( blue ) . genotypes were sampled randomly from a quadratic polynomial fitness landscape , which lacks any three - way interactions ( parameters @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 , @xmath17 , and @xmath18 sites ; see methods ) . the training data were fit to a quadratic model , which has @xmath19 parameters , so that the statistical model is well - specified . a test set of 5,000 random genotypes was used to compare the predicted ( @xmath20 ) and true ( @xmath5 ) fitnesses of genotypes . with sufficient sampled data , no penalization is required and the resulting statistical fit contains no bias ( red ) . [ fig : regbias ] ] even when there is sufficient data so that a penalized regression is unnecessary , there is another source of potential bias in the inferred fitness landscape due to variables that are omitted from the statistical model but present in the true landscape , e.g. higher - order interactions between loci @xcite . in this case , the estimated coefficients of the statistical model will be biased in proportion to the amount of correlation between the omitted variables and the included variables @xcite . uncorrelated omitted variables , by contrast , may be regarded as noise , as we discuss below . interactions of different orders , e.g. three - way and pairwise interactions , are generally correlated with each other , unless the genotypes are sampled randomly and encoded as @xmath21 forming an orthogonal basis @xcite . in this case , which rarely applies to samples drawn from an evolving population , the omitted interactions may be regarded as noise and the estimated coefficients are guaranteed to be unbiased . however , even in this case the inferred @xmath5 values may still be biased . fig . [ fig : modelbias ] illustrates the biases arising from model mis - specification . to produce this figure we fit quadratic models to fitness landscapes that contain higher - order interactions . in both the cubic polynomial ( fig . [ fig : modelbias ] ) and @xmath12 ( fig . [ fig : modelbias_nk ] ) landscapes , fitnesses that are very high or very low are likely to contain contributions from higher - order interactions with positive or negative effects , respectively . but these higher - order interactions are not estimated by the statistical model , and so the inferred model overestimates low fitnesses and underestimates high fitnesses . bias arising from model mis - specification is qualitatively similar to bias arising form penalized regression , discussed above . bias from a mis - specified model can be large , but it would be not be visible in a plot of residuals versus _ inferred _ fitnesses . the mis - specified model bias shown in figure [ fig : modelbias ] is a form of _ regression towards the mean _ , and it is present even in a simple univariate regression with a large amount of noise @xcite . the slope in figure [ fig : modelbias ] , which plots true fitness @xmath5 against the residual @xmath22 , arises because the quadratic statistical model can not estimate the higher - order ( cubic ) interactions , which effectively act as noise in the regression . in fact , the slope in the figure equals @xmath23 , where @xmath24 denotes the coefficient of determination of the original regression ( see material and methods for a derivation ) . whether regression towards the mean is viewed as bias depends on the interpretation of the statistical model . if one assumes that the model can not be improved by adding any more predictor variables , i.e. that the noise is caused by purely random factors , as opposed to unknown systematic factors , then the regression results are unbiased and the observed negative slope between @xmath22 and @xmath5 simply reflects the fact that the regression can not estimate the noise . however , in situations when there is a systematic signal that is missing from the statistical model , such as when fitting a quadratic model to a fitness landscape that contains higher - order interactions , then the regression is biased towards the mean in proportion to the amount of variance that is not explained by the model . this phenomenon is not caused by measurement noise but by the omission of relevant variables . in the experiments summarized in fig . [ fig : modelbias ] there is no measurement noise in the fitnesses , and so the negative slope shown in figure [ fig : modelbias ] reflects a true bias : the mis - specified model over - estimates low fitnesses and under - estimates high fitnesses . with carefully tuned parameters , other forms of mis - specified model bias are also possible , see fig . [ fig : modelbias2 ] . in any case , whatever form it takes , mis - specified model bias has consequences for how accurately the landscape inferred from an experiment will reflect the amount of epistasis in the true landscape or predict the dynamics of adaptation , as we will demonstrate below . parameters ) to 5,000 randomly sampled individuals from three different cubic - polynomial landscapes each with with @xmath18 sites and @xmath17 : @xmath25 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 ( red ) , @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 ( green ) , and @xmath25 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 ( blue ) . the larger the value of @xmath31 , the greater the amount of model mis - specification and the stronger the bias . a test set of 5,000 random genotypes was used to compare the predicted ( @xmath20 ) and true ( @xmath5 ) fitnesses of individuals . [ fig : modelbias ] ] a third difficulty that arises when fitting a statistical model to measured fitnesses is the presence of correlations between observed states of loci in sampled genotypes . an adapting population does not explore sequence space randomly , but rather is guided by selection towards higher - fitness genotypes . sequences sampled from a population under selection will thus tend to have correlated loci , due either to shared ancestry or due to epistasis . correlated variables do not themselves bias inferred coefficients ( at least , when the model is specified correctly ) , but they can inflate the variance of those estimates @xcite . predictions from the inferred model are not affected , in expectation , provided the new data have the same correlations as in the original training data . however , in the context of the expansion in eq . [ eq : quad ] , if there are correlations between the included variables , then there are also correlations between the omitted higher - order interactions and the included variables . thus , sampling from a wright - fisher ( wf ) population will exacerbate the mis - specified model bias . as a result , the inferred @xmath10 s and @xmath11 s will be further biased and so too will the inferred fitnesses . to illustrate biases that arise from sampling a population under selection , we simulated wright - fisher populations for 100 generations on cubic polynomial and @xmath12 landscapes . we used large population sizes and mutation rates to produce a large amount of standing genetic diversity for sampling genotypes ( see methods ) . the resulting fits exhibit very high @xmath24 values , in many cases even larger than fits to randomly sampled genotypes . but the large @xmath24 values and apparent lack of bias in the training data are very misleading when the model is misspecified , i.e. when the true landscape contains higher - order interactions . when predicting fitnesses of genotypes just one or two mutations away from the training data we find again large biases and large variance ( polynomial landscape fig . [ fig : wfsample2 ] and @xmath12 landscape fig . [ fig : wfsample_nk ] ) . as before , the resulting bias tends towards intermediate fitness values . ) were computed from cross - validated training data ( red ) , for genotypes sampled one mutation away from the training data ( purple ) , and for genotypes sampled two mutations away from the training data ( cyan ) . the true fitnesses ( @xmath5 ) are determined by a cubic polynomial fitness landscape on @xmath18 sites with @xmath26 , @xmath27 , @xmath28 , and @xmath32 . genotypes for fitting the quadratic statistical model were sampled from the population after 100 generations of wright - fisher evolution , with mutation rate @xmath33 and population size @xmath34 ( see methods ) . [ fig : wfsample2 ] ] one of the motivations for fitting a statistical model of a fitness landscape is to predict the fitnesses of genotypes that were not sampled or assayed in the original experiment . this immediately raises the question , how much predictive power do such statistical fits have , and how does their power depend upon the form of the underlying landscape from which genotypes have been sampled , as well as the form of the fitting procedure ? although extrapolation is easy to visualize in a linear regression with one component of @xmath35 , it can not be plotted as easily in high dimensions , where it is sometimes called _ hidden extrapolation _ @xcite . in the discrete , high - dimensional space of genotypes , no genotype is between any two other genotypes , so that every prediction is in some sense an extrapolation rather than an interpolation . given experimental data , it may be hard to determine if a model is extrapolating accurately or not @xcite . here , we quantify the accuracy of extrapolation explicitly using mathematical fitness landscapes . [ fig : wfsample3 ] illustrates the ability of statistical fits to predict fitnesses of genotypes that were not sampled in the training data , for a range of models and for regressions with varying degrees of mis - specification . this figure quantifies the amount of error when predicting the fitnesses of genotypes that are one or two mutations from the training data , as well as for predicting fitness of random , unsampled genotypes . away from the training data , the bias and variance increase with each mutation , as reflected by the lower squared correlation coefficients between true and inferred values . the predictions are progressively worse as the amount of model mis - specification increases . a statistical model that has a good fit to the training data , i.e. a high @xmath24 , does not necessarily imply that the model can make accurate predictions , especially if there is over - fitting . in fact , fig . [ fig : wfsample3 ] shows that even a high _ cross - validated _ @xmath24 can be misleading in the context of predicting unobserved fitnesses when the model is mis - specified . it is interesting to compare the extrapolative power of landscapes fitted to genotypes sampled from a wright - fisher population , versus genotypes sampled randomly . the dashed line in fig . [ fig : wfsample3 ] indicates the expected @xmath24 for regressions fitted to randomly sampled genotypes . on the one hand , predictions that are local , i.e. within a few mutations from the training data , typically have a higher @xmath24 for a model trained on wf - sampled genotypes compared to a model trained on random genotypes . on the other hand , predictions that are far from the training data ( i.e. predictions for random genotypes ) , typically have much lower @xmath24 for a model trained on wf - sampled genotypes compared to a model trained on random genotypes . thus , samples from a wright - fisher population produce a more biased model , even of the training data , but may nonetheless produce better predictions for local unsampled genotypes , compared to a model fitted to random genotypes @xcite . ) and true fitnesses ( @xmath5 ) , for sequences that are one mutation away from the training data ( purple ) , two mutations away from the training data ( cyan ) , and for random sequences ( black ) . genotypes used as training data were sampled from a wf population after 100 generations of evolution with mutation rates @xmath33 and population size @xmath34 ( see methods ) . landscapes were each instances of a cubic polynomial form , with @xmath31 values ranging from zero to one ( @xmath35-axis ) , with @xmath36 drawn uniformly in range @xmath37 , and with @xmath38 . the number of unique sequences sampled from each wf population varied from 34 to 603 ( not shown ) . [ fig : wfsample3 ] ] the dynamics of an adapting population depend fundamentally on the form of epistasis , that is , the way in which fitness contributions from one locus depend upon the status of other loci . indeed , one of the primary goals in fitting a fitness landscape to empirical data is to quantify the amount and form of its epistasis , in order to understand how adaptation will proceed . given the two sources of biases discussed above , which are inherent to fitting fitness landscapes to empirical data and exacerbated by sampling from populations under selection , the question arises : how do these inferential biases influence the apparent form of epistasis in the fitted landscape ? in this section we address this question by comparing the form of epistasis in the true , underlying fitness landscape to the form of epistasis in the inferred landscape obtained from fitting a quadratic model to sampled genotypes . there are several measures of epistasis known to influence the dynamics of adaptation . we will focus on three measures commonly used in the experimental literature on epistasis . one measure of epistasis , which reflects the degree of predictability in adaptation , is to reconstruct all the possible genetic paths between a low - fitness ancestral genotype and a high - fitness derived genotype sampled from an experimental population @xcite the proportion of such paths that are `` accessible '' , or monotonically increasing in fitness , is then a natural measure of epistasis . when this proportion is high , many possible routes of adaptation are allowable , suggesting that the evolutionary trajectory can not be easily predicted in advance . whereas when this proportion is small , it suggests that the evolutionary trajectory is more predictable , at least in a large population . to generate data similar to what would arise in an evolution experiment , we ran wright - fisher simulations on mathematical fitness landscapes ( see methods ) . each population began monomorphic and the most populated genotype at the end of the simulation was taken as the derived genotype , which typically contained between 5 to 7 mutations compared to the ancestral genotype . genotypes and their associated fitnesses were sampled from the population after 100 generations and used to fit a quadratic model of the landscape . figure [ fig : paths2]a shows an example of all the mutational paths between the ancestral and derived genotypes separated by 5 mutations , for both the true and the inferred fitnesses . since low fitnesses are likely to be overestimated , and high fitnesses are likely to be underestimated , the bias in the inferred landscape tends to eliminate fitness valleys . as a result , the number of accessible paths is higher in the inferred landscape than it is in the true underlying landscape ( fig . [ fig : paths2]a ) . epistasis appears to be less severe , and adaptation appears able to take more paths , than it actually is . this effect occurs systematically , as we have observed it over many realizations of different underlying fitness landscapes ( fig . [ fig : paths2]b ) . -axis ) and inferred ( @xmath5-axis ) landscapes . the inferred landscapes tend to over - estimate the proportion of accessible paths , compared to the true landscape : the proportion of accessible paths was overestimated 3.9-times more often than it was underestimated . in all cases the true landscape was cubic polynomial with @xmath25 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 , and @xmath39 . wf simulation parameters : @xmath33 , @xmath40 , with 500 generated landscapes and simulations . [ fig : paths2 ] ] we also investigated two other measures of epistasis : the number of local maxima in the fitness landscape @xcite , and the prevalence of sign epistasis between pairs of mutations @xcite . both of these quantities are global measures of epistasis , which depend upon the entire landscape , as opposed to the local measure of accessible paths between an ancestral and a derived genotype . generally speaking , local maxima tend to slow adaptation towards very high fitnesses , even though valley - crossing can occur in large populations @xcite . sign epistasis occurs when the fitness effect of a mutation at one site changes sign depending upon the status of a second site . reciprocal sign epistasis is a subset of sign epistasis , and it occurs when the second site also has sign epistasis on the first site . [ fig : max_signep ] compares the true and inferred amounts of these two global measures of epistasis . both quantities can be either underestimated or overestimated by the inferred landscape , depending on the circumstances . when the model is miss - specified ( fig . [ fig : max_signep ] bottom row ) , and without penalization or local sampling of genotypes , both measures of epistasis are heavily underestimated , since the model is unable to capture the local maxima and sign epistasis caused by three - way interactions . but when genotypes are sampled locally ( fig . [ fig : max_signep ] top row ) , i.e. sampled within a few mutations around a focal genotype , and penalized regression is applied , then the inferred landscape is influenced both by penalization bias and extrapolation error . the penalization bias tends to smooth the inferred landscape and eliminate local maxima ; wherease extrapolation adds noise to the estimated fitnesses and it may create spurious local maxima . which of these two effects dominates depends on the amount of data sampled and how it is distributed . sign epistasis appears to be less sensitive to extrapolation and bias when the model is well - specified , presumably because it depends only on the signs of effects and not magnitudes . in all cases considered , however , the inferred landscapes exhibit systematically biased global measures of epistasis . to complement the studies above , which are based on mathematically constructed fitness landscapes , we also investigated more realistic landscapes : computational rna - folding landscapes and empirical data relating regulatory sequences and expression levels ( i.e. a regulatory sequence binding landscape , see methods ) . the rna - folding landscape and the regulatory sequence binding landscape ( fig . [ fig : rnakinney ] ) both exhibit the same form of bias that we observed in the mathematical fitness landscapes . in the case of the rna - folding landscape ( see fig . [ fig : rnakinney]a ) there is no measurement error and sufficient data to avoid the need for penalized regression . thus , the bias towards the mean fitness seen in fig . [ fig : rnakinney]a with @xmath41 is due entirely to model misspecification : the quadratic model does not capture some higher - order interactions that influence rna folding . the regulatory sequence expression level data ( fig . [ fig : rnakinney]b ) , on the other hand , contain some measurement noise which comprises about 10 - 24% of the variance @xcite , whereas the @xmath24 for statistical model is @xmath42 . these numbers suggest that higher - order interactions bias the predictions made from the statistical model of the regulatory sequence binding landscape , as well , at least to some extent . the form of the biases observed when fitting a quadratic model to these realistic fitness landscapes ( fig . [ fig : rnakinney ] ) are similar to the biases observed when fitting quadratic models to @xmath12 landscapes or to polynomial landscapes . therefore we expect that these biases will have similar consequences for measures of epistasis . bias arising in a quadratic fit to ( a ) computational rna - folding landscape ( see methods ) , and ( b ) regulatory sequence binding landscape from kinney et al . @xcite ( see methods ) . the data are discrete in true fitnesses , @xmath5 . circles indicate means of distributions of residuals within each bin , and error bars indicate standard deviations . the quadratic fit exhibits the same type of bias towards the mean fitness as observed in @xmath12 and polynomial fitness landscapes . ] bias arising from a mis - specified model may be reduced by adding relevant missing variables . in the context of the expansion in eq . [ eq : quad ] this requires adding higher - order interactions such as triplets of sites , quartets , etc . in practice , this approach is often infeasible because the number of such interactions is extremely large and relatively few of them may be present in the data . in fig . [ fig : unbias]a we show that the bias in the statistical model can be reduced by fitting a model that includes three - way interactions . however , there is still some residual bias , due to penalized regression . thus , incorporating additional predictor variables effectively trades bias due to model mis - specification for bias due to a more severe penalized regression . it is not always necessary to use penalized regression , especially when higher - order interactions are sparse . in such cases it may be appropriate first to select a limited number of relevant variables , and then to use standard regression that avoids the bias associated with penalization . selecting the variables to use in the statistical model may be done `` by hand '' based on prior knowledge , or by statistical methods such as lasso @xcite ( see methods ) . this approach is expected to perform well only when a relatively small number of variables / interactions are in fact present in the true fitness landscape . as a proof of principle , we have shown how lasso followed by standard unpenalized regression reduces bias in fits to the cubic polynomial and @xmath12 landscapes . notably , lasso is a form of penalized regression that favors sparse solutions . we do not use lasso in this procedure to make predictions , but rather to select the variables to retain for the eventual unpenalized regression . the cubic polynomial landscape contains interactions between all triplets of sites , and so the variables retained by lasso are expected to omit some important variables , leaving some bias . by contrast , the @xmath12 landscape has sparse interactions and the resulting fit of this two - step procedure is therefore expected to be far less biased . both of these expectations are confirmed in fig . [ fig : unbias ] . although this approach may have the benefit of reducing bias in the inferred fitnesses , it will not improve the overall @xmath24 of the fit , or the extrapolative power . reducing bias when fitting a statistical model to ( a ) cubic polynomial landscape , and ( b ) @xmath12 landscape . bias in the inferred fitnesses can be reduced by adding third - order interactions to the statistical model ( quadratic fit in red , compared to cubic fit in green ) . although the green model is correctly specified , some bias still remains due to the penalized regression ( @xmath43 parameters fit with @xmath44 data points ) . further reduction of bias can be achieved by selecting model variables with lasso @xcite , and then performing an unpenalized regression only the selected variables ( blue ) . the variable selection step may omit some important variables , especially when the true landscapes includes a large number of higher - order interactions , as in the cubic polynomial case ( a ) . if the true landscape has a sparse set of interactions ( e.g. the @xmath12 landscape , panel b ) , then bias can be removed almost entirely by this two - step procudure . ( a ) : cubic polynomial landscape with @xmath25 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 . ( b ) : @xmath12 landscape with @xmath45 . a test set of 5,000 random genotypes was used to compare the predicted ( @xmath20 ) and true ( @xmath5 ) fitnesses . ] our ability to measure the genotype - fitness relationship directly in experimental populations is advancing at a dramatic pace . and yet we can never hope to measure but a tiny fraction of an entire fitness landscape , even for individual proteins . as a result , there is increasing need to fit statistical models of landscapes to sampled data . here we have shown that such statistical fits can warp our view of epistasis in the landscape and , in turn , our expectations for the dynamics of an evolving population . we have identified two distinct sources of biases : penalized regression and model mis - specification . our analysis of the effects of penalized regression have been performed using ridge regression , but the same qualitative results hold for lasso regressions ( figs . [ fig : regbias_poly_lasso ] , [ fig : regbias_nk_lasso ] , [ fig : wf_poly_lasso ] , [ fig : wf_nk_lasso ] , [ fig : paths_all_lasso ] analogous to figs . [ fig : regbias ] , [ fig : regbias_nk ] , [ fig : wfsample3 ] , [ fig : wfsample_nk ] , [ fig : paths2]b ) , and also , we expect , for other forms of penalization such as elastic net or the generalized kernel ridge regression in @xcite . notably , the bias arising from penalized regression has a slightly different form depending upon whether genotypes are encoded in the @xmath46 basis relative to the wild - type , in which case inferences will be biased towards the wild - type fitness , or the @xmath47 basis , used here , in which case inferences will be biased towards the average fitness . aside from these biases , we have also shown that statistical fits have poor predictive power . even when a fitted landscape exhibits a large cross - validated @xmath24 value , the fitted landscape generally has poor power to predict the fitnesses of unsampled genotypes , including genotypes within only a single mutation of the genotypes used to fit the landscape . common measures of epistasis may be grossly distorted by statistical fits to sampled data . interestingly , different measures of epistasis can be affected differently . for example , the number of paths accessible between an ancestal and derived genotype will be systematically over estimated in such fits , suggesting that evolution is less predictable than it actually is . the number of local maxima in the inferred landscape can be severly over- or under - estimated , whereas the prevalence of sign epistasis is less prone to bias ( fig . [ fig : max_signep ] ) . estimates of pairwise sign epistasis may be more robust because quadratic fits capture pairwise interactions , whereas the number of local maxima can depend on higher - order interactions . the problems of bias towards smoothness due to penalized regression and ruggedness due to extrapolation error can co - exist in the same dataset , as observed in a recent study of regulatory sequence binding data @xcite . which of these two effects will dominate is unclear , in general , as it depends upon the underlying landscape and the form of sampling . as a result , it is difficult to interpret the predictions made by quadratic fits to fitness landscapes , such as fits made to hiv data @xcite . nevertheless , it is often possible to at least deduce the presence of epistatic interactions from sampled data @xcite . in some cases , such as when the true landscape has sparse high - order interactions between loci , a combination of variable selection followed by unpenalized regression may ameliorate the biases we have identified . however , the degree to which this approach will reduce bias will surely depend upon the biological context . thus researchers should incorporate as much prior biological knowledge as possible when choosing a statistical model and fitting procedure . at the very least , it is important that researchers be aware of the biases inherent in fitting statistical of fitness landscapes to data . in order to build a statistical model with linear and interacting terms ( eq [ eq : quad ] ) , genetic sequences must be encoded as dummy variables , @xmath3 . if there is a well - defined wild - type sequence , then a natural parameterization is using zeros and ones , with the wild - type denoted as all zeros . the coefficients @xmath10 are the effect of single mutations , @xmath11 are the effects of pairs of mutations , and the constant term @xmath48 is the inferred wild - type fitness . in the case of a population with large diversity and no well - defined reference sequence , the reference - free parameterization with @xmath49 may be more appropriate , with @xmath48 then denoting the inferred average fitness @xcite . in this work we used the @xmath49 basis , because a wild - type was not defined , and the polynomial landscapes ( see below ) are defined in the @xmath49 basis . we constructed `` polynomial landscapes '' by terminating the expansion ( eq . [ eq : quad ] ) at the third - order and specifying the coefficients in such a way as to control the contributions to the total variation in log fitness that arise from interactions of each order . in particular , the variance of @xmath5 is @xmath50 where @xmath51 denotes an average over all genotypes in the orthogonal ( @xmath49 ) basis , and the sums are taken overal all sites , pairs of sites , and triplets . the coefficients @xmath10 , @xmath11 , and @xmath52 are chosen from normal distributions with mean zero and variances : @xmath53 @xmath54 @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the fraction of total variance determined by the @xmath4th order , @xmath6 is the number of loci , and the total variance is @xmath57 . for our numerical investigations using the cubic polynomial landscapes we chose @xmath18 . @xmath58 makes no contribution to the variance or the evolutionary dynamics , and was set to zero . we followed a standard @xcite procedure for constructing @xmath12 fitness landscapes . the parameter @xmath59 denotes the length of the binary string defining the genotype ( @xmath60 throughout our analyses ) the logarithm of the fitness of a genotype is calculated as the mean of contributions from each site , which are themselves determined by a table of values each drawn independently from a uniform probability distribution . when @xmath61 , the contribution of a site depends only on its own state : 0 or 1 , and not on the state of other sites . when @xmath62 , the contribution of a site depends on its own ( binary ) allele as well as the states of k other sites , yielding a lookup table with @xmath63 entries thus , there are in general @xmath59 lookup tables each with @xmath63 independently drawn entries , which together determine the contribution of each locus , based on the status of all other loci . under such @xmath12 models , the fitness effect of a substitution depends strongly and randomly on some fraction of the genetic background , determined by @xmath13 . @xmath13 is constant across sites and genotypes for a particular landscape , and the identifies of the @xmath13 sites upon which a given locus depends are drawn uniformly from the @xmath64 possibilities . notably , @xmath61 is an additive landscape , and @xmath65 is additive with sparse pairwise interactions . the amount of total variance in fitness due to the @xmath66th - order interactions is proportional to @xmath67 @xcite . the rna - folding landscape was generated by the vienna rna software @xcite . the target secondary structure was chosen as the most common structure observed in a sample of 10,000 structures generated from random genotypes of length 15 . the fitness function was defined as @xmath68 , where @xmath69 is hamming distance to the target in the tree - edit metric . training data consisted of @xmath70 random genotypes . the data consisted of 129,000 sequences of the _ e. coli _ lac promoter and associated gene expression levels . each sequence contained 75 nucleotides and contained roughly 7 mutations relative to the wild type . _ e. coli _ were facs sorted by expression levels into 9 bins , and the bin numbers serves as the phenotype for fitting the quadratic model . in this case , lasso was used for regression . for more details see @xcite . a quadratic fit with ridge regression was used ( unless otherwise stated ) , which identifies the coefficients that minimize @xmath71 where the last sum is taken over all coefficients denoted as @xmath72 . the first term is the mean squared error , and the last term is the penalization which biases coefficients towards zero . the free parameter @xmath73 was determined by choosing the largest @xmath73 within one standard deviation of the smallest ten - fold cross - validated mean squared error . an alternative form of penalization is lasso @xcite , which has a penalization term of the form @xmath74 . lasso favors sparse solutions of coefficients , and is useful for picking out important variables . ridge and lasso regression were done by matlab version r2013b . monte - carlo simulations of adaptation were based on standard wright - fisher dynamics @xcite . a population consists of @xmath59 individuals , each with a genotype consisting of a bit string of length 20 . the population replaces itself in discrete generations , such that each individual has a random number of offspring in proportion to its fitness , which is determined by its genotype via the fitness landscape . in practice , this is done efficiently with a multinomial random number generator . mutations are defined as bit flips , and they are introduced in every individual at each generation with probability @xmath75 per genome . the number of individuals receiving a mutation is thus binomially distributed , as double mutations are not allowed . the populations were initialized as monomorphic for a low - fitness genotype , chosen by generating 100 random genotypes and picking the one with the lowest fitness . simulations were run for 100 generations , and the resulting population was reduced to unique genotypes , and those genotypes , with the corresponding fitnesses , were used as the training data for regressions . the number of unique genotypes in the population is sensitive to @xmath75 , @xmath59 , the number of generations , and @xmath76 . these parameters were chosen such that there were at least a few hundred unique genotypes , representing substantial diversity in the population . the figures plotting true fitness versus residuals were produced using a gaussian moving window applied to the raw data . for each value of true fitness , @xmath5 , a mean and standard deviation was calculated by weighting all the data points by a gaussian with a width @xmath77 , and normalized by the sum of all the weights for the given @xmath5 value . this procedure provides a sense of the distribution at a given @xmath5 , without regard to the density of points . areas on the extremes of @xmath5 had few points to estimate a mean and variance , and they were excluded if the sum of weights was smaller than the 10% percentile of the distribution of all normalization factors . we used the smoothing parameter @xmath78 for figures [ fig : regbias ] , [ fig : modelbias ] , [ fig : unbias]a , [ fig : modelbias2 ] , and [ fig : regbias_poly_lasso ] ; @xmath79 for figures [ fig : unbias]b , [ fig : regbias_nk ] , [ fig : modelbias_nk ] , and [ fig : regbias_nk_lasso ] ; @xmath80 for figures [ fig : wfsample2 ] and [ fig : wf_poly_lasso ] ; and @xmath81 for figures [ fig : wfsample_nk ] and [ fig : wf_nk_lasso ] . a scatter plot of true fitnesses , @xmath5 , versus estimated fitnesses inferred by regression , @xmath20 , reflects the quality of the statistical fit . one can calculate the slope of @xmath5 versus @xmath20 by using a second regression : @xmath82 where @xmath83 denotes the slope , found by minimizing the mean squared error @xmath84 @xmath85 @xmath86 recall that @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is the residual from the initial regression , and @xmath89 because residuals are uncorrelated with @xmath20 . as a result , we conclude that @xmath90 , which simply reflects the properties of the original linear regression . this result is analogous to plotting residuals on the @xmath5 axis and inferred values on the @xmath35-axis , and observing no relationship . in the main text , by contrast , we show plots of the true values @xmath5 versus the residuals @xmath22 . in this case we observe a `` bias '' , in that genotypes with large @xmath5 are underestimated , and genotypes with small @xmath5 are overestimated . this type of bias is a form of regression towards the mean . we can calculate the slope of @xmath5 versus @xmath20 as follows : @xmath91 and with a similar calculation we find @xmath92 if we have mean - centered data ( @xmath93 ) , then this slope equals the coefficient of determination of the initial regression , denoted @xmath24 . equivalently , the slope in plots of @xmath5 versus @xmath22 equals @xmath94 . we thank a. feder , j. draghi , d. mccandlish for constructive input ; and p. chesson for clarifying the usage of the word between . j.b.p . acknowledges funding from the burroughs wellcome fund , the david and lucile packard foundation , the u.s . department of the interior ( d12ap00025 ) , the u.s . army research office ( w911nf-12 - 1 - 0552 ) , and the foundational questions in evolutionary biology fund ( rfp-12 - 16 ) . lenski re , travisano m ( 1994 ) dynamics of adaptation and diversification : a 10,000-generation experiment with bacterial populations . _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america _ 91:68086814 . blount zd , borland cz , lenski re ( 2008 ) historical contingency and the evolution of a key innovation in an experimental population of escherichia coli . _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america _ 105:7899906 . lee yh , dsouza l , fox ge ( 1993 ) experimental investigation of an rna sequence space . _ origins of life and evolution of the biosphere : the journal of the international society for the study of the origin of life _ 23:36572 . schlosser k , li y ( 2005 ) diverse evolutionary trajectories characterize a community of rna - cleaving deoxyribozymes : a case study into the population dynamics of in vitro selection . _ journal of molecular evolution _ 61:192206 . jimnez ji , xulvi - brunet r , campbell gw , turk - macleod r , chen ia ( 2013 ) comprehensive experimental fitness landscape and evolutionary network for small rna . _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america _ 110:149849 . kinney jb , murugan a , callan cg , cox ec ( 2010 ) using deep sequencing to characterize the biophysical mechanism of a transcriptional regulatory sequence . _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america _ 107:915863 . maharjan rp , ferenci t ( 2013 ) epistatic interactions determine the mutational pathways and coexistence of lineages in clonal escherichia coli populations . _ evolution ; international journal of organic evolution _ 67:27628 . covert aw , lenski re , wilke co , ofria c ( 2013 ) experiments on the role of deleterious mutations as stepping stones in adaptive evolution . _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america _ 110:e31718 . a quadratic model was fit to a cubic polynomial landscape with large negative additive effects , small mean - zero pairwise effects , and positive 3-way effects . the result is a complicated bias in the inferred landscape , with very low fitnesses being underestimated and very high fitnesses being overestimated . nevertheless , the bias from missing , higher - order interactions as in fig . [ fig : modelbias ] may be a generic feature . when the distribution of interaction effects is centered around zero , the model tends to be biased towards the average fitness . ] the inferred number of local maxima and the prevalence of sign epistasis may be under- or over - estimated by a statistical model of the fitness landscape fit to sampled data . in the top row the genotypes were sampled locally " , so that they are close together in hamming distance . the sampled genotypes consist of a focal genotype plus all sequences within one and two mutations , totaling 211 sampled sequences . the true landscape was a quadratic polynomial ( @xmath14 , @xmath15 , @xmath16 ) , and it was fit with a quadratic model by ridge regression ( 211 coefficients ) . this fit did not require a penalized regression , but we imposed some arbitrary values of the penalization parameter , @xmath73 , to demonstrate its effects . when @xmath98 , there is no bias ( not shown ) , but when the penalization is modest @xmath99 , purple dots ) , the number of local maxima is over - estimated . the spurious local maxima are likely due to large extrapolation errors , away from the sampled genotypes . when the penalization is yet larger ( @xmath100 , pink ) , the penalization bias smooths out the inferred landscape and thus under - estimates the number of local maxima . the fraction of inferred sign epistasis ( pluses , upper right cluster ) and reciprocal sign epistasis ( crosses , cluster in the lower left ) , is typically overestimated for locally sampled genotypes . in the bottom row , 5000 genotypes are sampled randomly so that no penalization is required . however , the true landscape in these cases is cubic polynomial ( @xmath25 , @xmath29 , @xmath30 ) , whereas the statistical model is quadratic , resulting in bias from model mis - specification . in these cases , the number of local maxima and the prevalence of sign epistasis are both under - estimated . in all cases , @xmath17 and dashed line indicates the line @xmath101 . ]
Abstract: | [
"the genotype - fitness map plays a fundamental role in shaping the dynamics of evolution . however , it is difficult to directly measure a fitness landscape in practice , because the number of possible genotypes is astronomical . one approach is to sample as many genotypes as possible , measure their fitnesses , and fit a statistical model of the landscape that includes additive and pairwise interactive effects between loci . here we elucidate the pitfalls of using such regressions , by studying artificial but mathematically convenient fitness landscapes . we identify two sources of bias inherent in these regression procedures that each tends to under - estimate high fitnesses and over - estimate low fitnesses . we characterize these biases for random sampling of genotypes , as well as for samples drawn from a population under selection in the wright - fisher model of evolutionary dynamics . we show that common measures of epistasis , such as the number of monotonically increasing paths between ancestral and derived genotypes , the prevalence of sign epistasis , and the number of local fitness maxima , are distorted in the inferred landscape . as a result , the inferred landscape will provide systematically biased predictions for the dynamics of adaptation . we identify the same biases in a computational rna - folding landscape , as well as in regulatory sequence binding data , treated with the same fitting procedure . finally , we present a method that may ameliorate these biases in some cases ."
] | 9,560 | 9,560 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in the standard scenario of planet formation , planetesimals are the precursors of planets . their formation process is one of the unsolved problems of the planet formation theory . beginning with micron - sized dust grains , they grow to centimeter size in a protoplanetary disk via collisional agglomeration @xcite . the least understood growth phase is that of growth from centimeter size to kilometer size . since the gas drag of meter - sized aggregates is weak , they are slightly decoupled from gas with the sub - keplerian velocity . the resulting head - wind decreases their angular momentum and causes inward drift , whose timescale is about a few hundred years @xcite . the growth process in this stage must be faster than this drift timescale . another problem is the sticking probability of the aggregates . in this stage , since the threshold velocity for the destruction is low , their collisions may lead to destruction ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? a very thin and dense layer of settled dust aggregates in the mid - plane of the protoplanetary disk is gravitationally unstable . then the gravitational collapse of the dust layer occurs , and kilometer - sized planetesimals are formed directly @xcite . this scenario has the advantage of a very rapid formation timescale , which is on the order of the keplerian time , thus avoiding the migration of meter - sized aggregates . however , turbulence in the protoplanetary disk may prevent dust from settling to the mid - plane . as dust settles in the protoplanetary disk , a vertical shear velocity develops because the dust - rich gas in the mid - plane rotates with the velocity closer to the keplerian velocity than that of the dust - depleted gas , which may cause turbulence . the turbulence can mix dust with gas and prevent the dust layer from settling into a dense enough sheet for gravitational instability @xcite . problems concerning the gravitational instability of the dust layer still remain unsolved . there are two methods for calculating the dynamics of dust particles in gas : fluid simulation and @xmath0-body simulation . one can consider the particles as virtually fluid and treat them with the euler equation or navier - stokes equation . for example , @xcite performed the two - dimensional numerical simulation to investigate the density evolution of the dust layer due to gravitational instability . they assumed that the dust layer is axisymmetric with respect to the rotational axis . they treated the dust component as a pressure - free fluid because the velocity dispersion of dust is negligible if the stopping time @xmath2 is sufficiently short , where the stopping time @xmath2 is the characteristic timescale for a particle to stop in gas . they found that the dust layer becomes extremely thin if the stopping time is long . @xcite performed the numerical simulation of the gravitational instability of a two - dimensional thin disk and investigated the non - axisymmetric modes . on the other hand , we can investigate the dynamics of particles in gas by using @xmath0-body simulations @xcite . this is straightforward and precise , but the calculation is very time - consuming and the practical number of particles is limited . @xcite performed @xmath0-body simulations of a gravitationally unstable disk with a local - shearing box . they investigated the formation of clumps of planetesimals at t30 au by the gravitational instability . they considered the drag force from the background gas . they showed that the planetesimal clumps form owing to the gravitational instability , which correspond to planetesimals in our calculation . in their simulation , the optical depth is smaller than that in our calculation and the particle disk is unstable even initially . we consider the formation of planetesimals at 1 au , thus we use the large optical depth , and assume the dust layer is initially stable . @xcite performed a set of local simulations of the self - gravitating collisional particle disks without gas using @xmath0-body simulation ( hereafter paper i ) . dust particle dynamics is calculated with the hill equations in a local - shearing box @xcite . they adopted the rubble pile model ( hard and soft sphere models ) as collision models . they found that the formation process is divided into three stages : the formation of non - axisymmetric wake - like structures @xcite , the creation of aggregates , and the rapid collisional growth of the aggregates . the mass of the largest aggregates is larger than the mass predicted by the linear perturbation theory . @xcite adopted the alternative model of collisions , ` accretion model ' ( paper ii ) . in the accretion model , the number of particles decreases as the calculation proceeds ; thereby this model enables us to perform large - scale and long - term simulations . they obtained the final mass of planetesimals as a function of the size of the computational box . @xcite performed the numerical simulations to investigate the validity of the super - particle approximation . they considered the various physics , such as the gas drag , the self - gravity , the physical collision and the turbulence . they treated the collisions as the hard sphere model . they investigated the numerical requirements to study the gravitational instability . to understand the basic dynamics of gravitational instability , we neglected the effect of gas in papers i and ii . however , it is obvious that the gas plays an important role in planetesimal formation when dust particles are small . the interaction with gas through drag is dominant in the dynamical evolution of particles . many authors investigated the effect of gas . the particles drift radially due to gas drag @xcite . as the sedimentation of dust aggregates towards the midplane proceeds , the vertical velocity shear increases . thus , the kelvin - helmholtz instability occurs @xcite . the kelvin - helmholtz instability makes the dust layer turbulent . the turbulent gas prevents the concentration of dust @xcite , and helps the concentration @xcite . the interaction between gas and dust causes the streaming instability @xcite . by the streaming instability , the dust grains concentrate strongly and the large ceres - sized planetesimals form @xcite . the loss of angular momentum due to the gas drag helps gravitational instability @xcite . the time - scale for the dissipative instability is relatively slow , but the dust layer may be unstable even when the toomre s q value is larger than unity . as a first step toward understanding the effect of gas on gravitational instability , we introduce gas as a background laminar flow in the present paper . the aim of the present paper is to investigate the effect of the laminar gas on the planetesimal formation through gravitational instability . the laminar flow causes the dissipation of the kinetic energy and thus radial migration of dust . in 2 , we summarize the results of the linear analysis of the gravitational instability under gas drag . in 3 , we describe the simulation method and the initial condition . in 4 , we present our numerical results . 5 is devoted to discussions . we summarize the results in 6 . the linear stability analyses of the dust layer with a finite thickness were performed by @xcite and @xcite . they assumed that the size of dust aggregates is sufficiently small , in other words , dust is fully coupled with gas , thus they treated gas and dust as one fluid . that introduces no dissipation due to gas drag . they considered the vertical structure of the dust layer , and studied the roche criterion . the linear stability analyses of dissipative gravitational instability were performed by @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . in this section , we summarize the essence of their results . @xcite and @xcite used one component model , i.e. , they neglected the dynamics of gas flow , but they consider the gas drag from the stationary background gas flow . using their results , we discuss conditions for the gravitational instability under the influence of gas drag . we adopt the isothermal equation of state for the dust layer : @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the pressure , @xmath5 is the isothermal sound speed , and @xmath6 is the density of the dust layer . in this equation of state , the velocity dispersion of dust is always constant . clearly , the velocity dispersion must not be constant . it changes owing to several processes such as gas drag , inelastic collisions , and gravitational scattering . this assumption gives us the simple analytical expression of the dispersion relation , with which we can grasp the nature of dissipative gravitational instability . we assume that the gas velocity is equal to the kepler velocity . we consider the reference point that is at the semi - major axis @xmath7 . the kepler angular velocity of the reference point is @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the mass of the central star and @xmath10 is the gravitational constant . we introduce the local cartesian coordinates in which the @xmath11-axis is directed radially , the @xmath12-axis follows the direction of rotation , and the @xmath13-axis follows the direction perpendicular to mid - plane . we define @xmath14 as the deviation velocity field from the local kepler velocity . the basic equations for the dust layer in this frame are given by @xmath15 @xmath16 @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the gravitational potential due to the self - gravity . the simulation results in 4 show that the density fluctuation is not axisymmetric . however , for the sake of simplicity , restricting ourselves to the axisymmetric mode ( @xmath19 ) , we carry out a normal mode analysis in the form of @xmath20 where @xmath21 is the wave number in the @xmath11-direction and @xmath22 is the growth rate . integrating toward @xmath13 , we obtain the equation of perturbed quantities @xmath23 : @xmath24 @xmath25 @xmath26 @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the surface density of the dust layer . @xcite considered the finite thickness model using the softening term @xcite . poisson equation with the softening parameter is @xmath29 where @xmath30 is the scale height of the dust layer and @xmath31 is the softening parameter : @xmath32 for nontrivial solutions , the determinant of the coefficient matrix must vanish . thus the following dispersion relation is obtained @xcite : @xmath33 where @xmath34 . the mode for @xmath35 is unstable , where @xmath36 is the real part of a complex number @xmath37 . in the gas - free limit ( @xmath38 ) and the thin disk limit ( @xmath39 ) , the dispersion relation converges to the conventional dispersion relation of a thin disk @xcite . equation ( [ eq : disp1 ] ) can be written in a non - dimensional form scaled by the length @xmath40 and the time @xmath41 : @xmath42 where we used toomre s @xmath1 given by @xmath43 . a tilde denotes non - dimensional quantity hereafter . a dissipative dust layer is secularly unstable for long - wavelength modes although @xmath44 . the physical mechanism of the instability is explained as follows @xcite . we consider a thin axisymmetric overdense ring and the thick back - ground gas . from the force balance of the self - gravity , we find that the dust rotates faster at the outer edge of the ring . thus , the drag force at the outer edge is strong . this causes the inward drift . conversely , the dust at the inner edge drifts outward . these effects shrink ring radially . figure [ fig : disper.eps ] shows the dispersion relation of the dust layer under gas drag for @xmath45 . we used the thin disk model ( @xmath46 ) . the stopping time is @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 , and @xmath50 ( gas - free ) . all models have the maximum growth rate at @xmath51 . we will see that the growth rate has the maximum value at @xmath52 in [ sec : mugr ] . as the stopping time lengthens , the growth rate shrinks . in the gas - free model , long - wavelength modes are stable , while in the gas model , they are unstable . as discussed in [ sec : dispersion ] , the dust layer is always unstable for long - wavelength modes . however , the timescale of the instability can be longer than the dynamical timescale , because this is the secular instability . therefore , in order to understand what happens , we have to compare the timescale of the instability with those of other processes such as the sedimentation , the radial migration , and the growth of dust aggregates . here , we assume the thin disk approximation ( @xmath46 ) in order to obtain the simple analytical formula . for @xmath53 , @xmath54 is a real positive value . the growth rate for the most unstable mode @xmath54 is a function of @xmath55 , @xmath56 , and @xmath1 . from equation ( [ eq : disp2 ] ) , the partial derivative of @xmath54 with respect to @xmath55 is given as @xmath57 using equation ( [ eq : disp2 ] ) , we can show that the denominator on the right hand side of equation ( [ eq : disp3 ] ) is positive when @xmath58 . hence , the @xmath54 has the maximum value at @xmath59 for a fixed @xmath56 and @xmath1 . the substitution of @xmath59 into equation ( [ eq : disp2 ] ) provides the equation of the maximum growth rate @xmath60 : @xmath61 to obtain the condition that the gravitational instability dominates over the other process ( symbolically denoted by `` x '' ) , we equate @xmath62 with @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the characteristic timescale of a process x , ans solve the resultant equation with respect to q to obtain @xmath1 value : @xmath65 when @xmath66 , gravitational instability is a dominant process compared to the process x. on the other hand , when @xmath67 , the timescale for the process x is shorter than the timescale of gravitational instability . although the dust layer is unstable , the process x is dominant . we can derive the leading term of the power series expansion with respect to @xmath2 for equation ( 13 ) and find the asymptotic solution @xcite . when the gas drag is strong @xmath68 , the growth rate for the most unstable mode is @xmath69 conversely , when the gas drag force is weak @xmath70 and @xmath44 , the growth rate for the most unstable mode is @xmath71 when @xmath72 , the growth rate for the most unstable mode converges to the finite value @xmath73 as @xmath74 , which is the maximum growth rate for the gas - free gravitational instability . the method of calculation is the same as those used in papers i and ii except for including gas , which is based on the method of the local simulation of planetary rings ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? we describe quantities in the non - dimensional form independent of the semi - major axis @xmath7 , and the mass of the central star @xmath9 by scaling the time by @xmath75 , the length by the hill radius @xmath76 , and the mass by @xmath77 , where @xmath78 and @xmath79 is the initial mass of particles @xcite . the initial mass of particles @xmath79 is assumed to be identical . the non - dimensional hill equations for the particle @xmath80 are given by ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) : @xmath81 where @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and @xmath84 are the position , mass , and the stopping time of the particle @xmath80 , @xmath85 is the distance between particles @xmath80 and @xmath86 , and @xmath87 is the velocity field of gas . we neglect the dust back - reaction on gas for the sake of simplicity . we assume that the laminar gas flow , which has the sub - keplerian velocity field : @xmath88 where @xmath89 is the keplerian shear velocity , @xmath90 is the difference from the keplerian velocity . the stopping time @xmath84 depends on the size of particle : @xmath91 where @xmath92 is the power - law index , and @xmath93 is the stopping time of the particle with @xmath94 . in this paper , we adopt @xmath95 and 2/3 . the index @xmath96 corresponds to stokes law ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the calculation box has the periodic boundary condition ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the size of the box is taken as a square @xmath97 where @xmath98 is the most unstable wavelength of gravitational instability and @xmath99 is the non - dimensional parameter . the system is characterized by two non - dimensional parameters , the optical depth and the ratio of the hill radius to the diameter of a particle @xcite : @xmath100 @xmath101 where @xmath102 and @xmath103 are the internal density and initial radius of the particle , respectively . the realistic value for `` solid '' dust particles is @xmath104 for @xmath105 and @xmath106 . however , we adopt @xmath107 in this paper owing to the computational limit ( see papers i and ii ) . we set the optical depth @xmath108 , which is approximately equal to the realistic value @xmath109 for @xmath110 , @xmath111 , and @xmath105 . since our choice of @xmath112 is smaller than the realistic value , a particle used in the simulation is not a realistic dust particle but a ` super - particle ' that represents a group of many small particles that have the same position and velocity . thus the restitution coefficient @xmath113 corresponds to the rate of the dissipation due to collisions between super - particles . the low value of @xmath112 means that the physical size of a particle in our simulation is very large . this implies that the effect of the gravitational scattering is relatively weaker than that of collisions . we investigated the @xmath112 value dependence in paper i and ii in the narrow range ( @xmath114 ) and we confirmed that the formation process does not change in this range qualitatively . however , we show that the collisional growth is important in the final stage where @xmath115 controls the growth rate . thus , we should perform the large @xmath112 value . in the future work , we will concentrate on the collisional growth and perform the @xmath0-body simulations with a realistic @xmath112 value . in the hill coordinates , the keplerian orbit is determined by six parameters : the position of the guiding center , eccentricity @xmath116 , inclination @xmath80 , and two phases for epicyclic and vertical oscillations @xcite . the initial eccentricity and inclination of particles are assumed to follow the rayleigh distribution . we fix @xmath117 according to @xcite . the other parameters are uniformly distributed , avoiding overlapping . we adopt the hard - sphere and accretion models as a collision model ( papers i and ii ) . in the hard - sphere model , the penetration of particles is not possible ( e.g. , paper i , * ? ? ? when a collision occurs , the particle velocity changes instantly . the relative tangential velocity is conserved and the magnitude of the relative normal velocity is reduced by a factor of @xmath113 . we use the constant @xmath113 . we also use the accretion model ( e.g. , paper ii , * ? ? ? * ) . in this model , when two particles collide , if the binding condition is satisfied , the two particles merge into one particle . the binding condition is described by the jacobi integral @xmath118 ( e.g. , paper ii , * ? ? ? * ) . in the hard - sphere model , since a planetesimal consists of many small particles , it can be distorted in shape and break up . on the other hand , in the accretion model , a planetesimal can not be distorted or break up . in this respect , the hard - sphere model is more realistic than the accretion model . however the accretion model has an advantage . first , since the number of particles decreases as the calculation proceeds , this model enables us to reduce the calculation cost . second , we can easily handle size - dependent drag coefficient . in general , the drag coefficient depends on the size of a particle . in the hard sphere model , it is complicated to handle the size - dependent drag coefficient . in the accretion model , we can adopt the size - dependent drag without any difficulty . we have shown that results in the accretion model are the same as those in the hard sphere model in the gas - free model ( paper ii ) . we compare the accretion model with the hard sphere model in the laminar gas flow . we performed simulations with the same model parameters except for collision models ( models 100h0 , 100ac0 , and 100as0 ) in order to check the validity of the accretion model . the initial stopping time of particles is @xmath119 . in the accretion models , we calculate the drag coefficient using the constant model ( @xmath120 ) and the stokes law model ( @xmath96 ) . the left panel of figure [ fig : q_value_accretion.eps ] shows the time evolution of @xmath1 . in the phase where @xmath1 decreases , there are no clear differences among all models . on the other hand , in the phase where @xmath1 increases , the discrepancies appear among them . @xmath1 value in the accretion model with @xmath96 is larger than those in the hard sphere model and the accretion model with @xmath120 . in the stokes law model , as particles grow , the drag coefficient becomes small and thus the dissipation becomes inefficient , which leads to the relatively large velocity dispersion . the right panel of figure [ fig : q_value_accretion.eps ] shows the maximum mass of planetesimals for all models . in the early stage , particles or aggregates do not grow . there the difference in collision models is not important . the difference can be seen in the late stage . in the stokes law model @xmath96 , the drag coefficient changes as particles grow , which affects the evolution of the maximum mass . in the hard - sphere model , the drag coefficient is constant although aggregates grow , therefore the evolution in the hard - sphere model must be similar to that in the accretion model with @xmath120 . however , the difference appears at @xmath121 . the maximum mass of the accretion model with @xmath120 increases , but that of the hard - sphere model does not change . at @xmath121 , there are only a few particles or aggregates . the maximum mass of planetesimals is sensitive to the initial condition and noise . but , at @xmath122 , the maximum mass converges to the same value . the final mass of the planetesimal depends on the size of the computational domain @xcite . the dispersion of the mass of the final state is relatively small . in the early stage where no planetesimals form , the time evolution is quite similar in all models . in the late stage , once planetesimals form , there are no remarkable differences among all models . if we focus on the the evolution of statistical value , such as the velocity dispersion , the number of planetesimals , we can investigate the gravitational instability and planetesimal formation using the accretion model . although the time evolution of the maximum mass of the planetesimal in the late stage depends on the initial noise , the maximum mass finally converge to the same value . therefore , we adopt the accretion model to investigate the gravitational instability from now on . we performed 14 simulations with different disk models . the model parameters are summarized in table @xmath123 . we fixed the following parameters : the optical depth , @xmath124 , the restitution coefficient @xmath125 , the ratio of the hill radius to the diameter @xmath126 , the initial toomre s @xmath1 value @xmath127 , and the size of the computational domain @xmath128 . the basic dependence of planetesimal formation of these parameters was investigated in papers i and ii . ccccc 010as0 & 0.10 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + 025as0 & 0.25 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + 050as0 & 0.50 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + 100as0 & 1.00 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + 200as0 & 2.00 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + 400as0 & 4.00 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + 1000as0 & 10.00 & accretion & 2/3 & 0 + infa & @xmath129 & accretion & - & 0 + 100ac0 & 1.00 & accretion & 0 & 0 + 100h0 & 1.00 & hard & 0 & 0 + 100ac1 & 1.00 & accretion & 0 & 10 + 100as1 & 1.00 & accretion & 2/3 & 10 + 100ac2 & 1.00 & accretion & 0 & 20 + 100as2 & 1.00 & accretion & 2/3 & 20 + [ table : model2 ] figure [ fig : snap_shot ] shows the typical evolution of the simulation ( model 100as0 ) . at @xmath130 , and @xmath47 , particles are distributed randomly and uniformly in the computational box . no gravitational instability occurs , thus we can see no remarkable structures . at @xmath131 , the large non - axisymmetric density structures appear . then , the gravitational instability seems to start . in the model where ( @xmath132 ) , the structure is not clear . for the short stopping time models , the velocity dispersion is small and the critical wave length is short . thus , we can not observe the large density structure clearly . at @xmath133 , particles begin to grow in the dense region . at @xmath134 and @xmath48 , particles continue to grow , and the number of small particles decreases rapidly . the small particles are absorbed by large particles . the rapid collisional growth of particles continues until the one large planetesimal finally forms . the formation process of planetesimals in the laminar gas model is similar to those in the gas - free model ( papers i and ii ) . the gas drag from the laminar gas does not qualitatively change formation process . this process is divided into three stages : the formation of density structures , the creation of planetesimal seeds , and their collisional growth . the linear stability analysis of gas - free gravitational instability shows that the disk is stable when @xmath44 @xcite . as discussed in 3 , the dust layer in the laminar gas disk is secularly unstable although @xmath44 . however , the growth time of the dissipative gravitational instability is longer than the sedimentation in the initial stage . thus , the disk shrinks vertically . as the velocity dispersion and the scale height decrease , the growth rate of the dissipative gravitational instability increases . then , the gravitational instability becomes a dominant process , and the wake - like structures appear . these structures fragment into the seeds of planetesimals . the seeds grow rapidly owing to mutual collisions . finally , almost all mass in the computational domain is absorbed by only one planetesimal in this calculation . the size of the final planetesimal depends on the size of the computational domain ( paper ii ) . [ cols="^,^,^,^ " , ] we assume that the difference in the rotational velocity from the kepler velocity is equal to zero ( @xmath135 ) ( models infa , 010as0 - 1000as0 ) . in the model infa , @xmath136 , i.e. , the drag term is neglected . in other models , the stopping times are @xmath137 and @xmath138 . we adopt the stokes law model , @xmath139 . the top panel of figure [ fig : q_value_hard.eps ] shows the time evolution of toomre s @xmath1 values . in all models , toomre s @xmath1 value initially decreases . in the gas - free model ( model infa ) , the kinetic energy is dissipated only by inelastic collisions . the dissipation timescale due to inelastic collisions is approximately estimated by @xmath140 @xcite . in the laminar gas models , the decrease of toomre s @xmath1 value is caused by the dissipation due to both the gas drag and inelastic collisions . the top panel of figure [ fig : min_q_value.eps ] shows the dependence of the decay time @xmath141 on @xmath142 , where the decay time of toomre s @xmath1 value @xmath141 is defined by @xmath143 where @xmath144 is the minimum @xmath1 value at @xmath145 . the decay time @xmath141 is proportional to @xmath142 for @xmath146 . @xmath1 value is proportional to the velocity dispersion @xmath147 . the inelastic collisions and the gas drag decrease the velocity dispersion . if the drag is sufficiently strong , the decay time scale of the velocity dispersion is on the order of the stopping time . the timescale of the decay of the velocity dispersion due to inelastic collisions is about @xmath148 . thus , when @xmath149 as @xmath150 increases , we can not neglect collisions . therefore the decay timescale of the velocity dispersion is smaller than the stopping time for @xmath149 . in all models , toomre s @xmath1 value has the minimum value @xmath144 at @xmath151 . in the gas - free model , the minimum @xmath1 value is about @xmath152 ( papers i , and ii ) , and according to the linear theory , the critical value of a thin disk is @xmath153 . this is because the decrease in the velocity dispersion due to inelastic collisions is sufficiently slow . however , as shown in figure [ fig : q_value_hard.eps ] , if the gas drag is strong , @xmath1 value becomes smaller than unity . as the stopping time shortens , the minimum @xmath1 value decreases . for example , the minimum @xmath1 value is 0.15 for @xmath154 . the axisymmetric structure starts forming when @xmath1 value is minimum . for example , in the model where @xmath155 , @xmath1 value is minimum at @xmath156 , and we can see the non - axisymmetric structure at @xmath157 . particles are scattered by the non - axisymmetric structures , and the velocity dispersion of particles increases . if the decrease of the @xmath1 value is more rapid than the gravitational instability , the dust layer can not collapse although the dust layer is gravitationally unstable . as @xmath1 value decreases , the timescale of the gravitational instability becomes short , therefore , the critical @xmath1 value is determined by @xmath158 , where @xmath159 is the timescale of the gravitational instability . here , we assume @xmath160 because particles do not grow much before gravitational instability . from equation ( [ eq : crit_q ] ) , we obtain the following condition : @xmath161 the minimum toomre s @xmath1 value as a function of @xmath142 is shown in the bottom panel of figure [ fig : min_q_value.eps ] . strictly speaking , equation ( [ eq : qmin ] ) is valid only when the disk is thin . nevertheless , the analytical expression agrees with the numerical result . we define the scale height of a dust layer as the mean square root of @xmath13 , @xmath162 . we can calculate the mean density of the dust layer from the scale height , @xmath163 . the density at which the self - gravity is equal to the tidal force is called the roche density , which is defined by the following equation ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) : @xmath164 the dust layer may collapse if the dust layer density exceeds the roche density . the linear analysis gives the more precise criterion @xcite . however , the criterion does not change very much . thus , we introduce @xmath165 given by @xmath166 which corresponds to the non - dimensional scale height . the bottom panel of figure [ fig : q_value_hard.eps ] shows the time evolution of @xmath167 . the time evolution of @xmath167 is similar to toomre s @xmath1 . the value @xmath167 has the minimum value @xmath168 at @xmath169 in all models . but , the time evolution of @xmath167 is slower than that of @xmath1 value . this result indicates that the standard hydrostatic relation @xmath170 is not satisfied . figure [ fig : v_over_h ] shows the time evolution of the ratio @xmath171 , which is on the order of the sound crossing time across a scale height . in the gas - free model , the ratio @xmath172 is nearly constant in @xmath173 . the hydrostatic relation is satisfied . in a laminar gas model , the ratio @xmath171 is not constant . as the stopping time decreases , the variation of the ratio becomes steep . especially , those for @xmath174 is prominent . in the model @xmath132 , the ratio @xmath171 increases for @xmath175 . the maximum value is about @xmath176 . the sound crossing time is @xmath177 in the gas - free model . when @xmath146 , the dissipation is faster than the sound crossing . therefore , the velocity dispersion decays before the scale height decays , and the ratio becomes larger than unity . in figure [ fig : v_over_h ] , we can see the oscillation . the period is about @xmath178 , and the amplitude decreases gradually . the reason for the oscillation is not clear . this may be due to some kind of the relaxation process . we can not use the roche density as the collapse criterion for @xmath179 . for @xmath180 , @xmath167 is always larger than unity . but the large particles form . for @xmath181 , @xmath167 becomes unity at @xmath182 , but the large particles start forming at @xmath133 . for @xmath183 , the time when @xmath184 corresponds to the time when the large particles start forming . when we derive the roche criterion , we simply compare the self - gravity with the tidal force . however , we showed that the non - axisymmetric structure develops . the azimuthal motion may be important to discuss the formation of the wake - like structure . therefore , the roche criterion is not applicable . the decay time of @xmath167 value @xmath185 is defined by @xmath186 where @xmath187 is the initial scale height of a dust layer . figure [ fig : min_height_time.eps ] shows @xmath185 as a function of @xmath142 . the decay time of @xmath167 has a minimum value at @xmath188 . for @xmath189 , the decay time shortens with the stopping time . for @xmath189 , the strong coupled particles with gas fall to the midplane at the terminal velocity . the settling time is proportional to @xmath190 . on the other hand , for @xmath191 , the decay time lengthens with longer stopping time . in this regime , the particles oscillate around the equatorial plane @xcite . the decay time scale of the amplitude is proportional to the stopping time . figure [ fig : cluster_number.eps ] shows the time evolution of the number of planetesimal seeds per the area @xmath192 , @xmath193 . we define a particle whose mass is larger than @xmath194 as a seed of planetesimals , where @xmath194 is the planetesimal mass predicted by the linear theory @xmath195 . in all models , @xmath193 has a maximum value at @xmath196 . the number @xmath193 increases rapidly in the early stage , and decreases in the late stage . in the early stage , gravitational instability occurs and the small density fluctuation grows and many planetesimal seeds form . in this stage , the number of seeds increases . they form through the gravitational instability . once many planetesimal seeds form , the mutual collisions among them start . the number of planetesimals decreases rapidly in the late stage . in the final state , almost all particles are absorbed by a few particles . the number of planetesimals in the final state depends on the size of the computational domain ( paper ii ) . the peak of @xmath193 depends on the stopping time @xmath150 . figure [ fig : max_number.eps ] shows the maximum number of the planetesimal @xmath197 as a function of the stopping time @xmath150 . the maximum number of planetesimals @xmath197 has a peak at @xmath198 . as discussed in [ sec : scaleheight ] , the scale height has the minimum value at @xmath198 . the characteristic length scale of gravitational instability corresponds to the scale height . as the characteristic length of gravitational instability shortens , the number of the planetesimals formed increases . figure [ fig : largest_planetesimal.eps ] shows the time evolution of the mass of the largest planetesimal . in all models , the largest planetesimal grows rapidly in @xmath199 , and the growth is stalled at @xmath200 . the growth in the gas - free model is slower than those in the gas models . as discussed in [ sec : qvalue ] , the gas drag enhances the dissipation of the kinetic energy of dust . as the drag becomes stronger , the gravitational instability occurs earlier and the growth becomes more rapid . the final mass of the largest planetesimal is @xmath201 . the clear dependence of the largest mass on the initial stopping time can not be seen . as seeds grow , the stopping time lengthens . in the final state , we can neglect the effect of the drag . therefore , the final mass and the number do not depend on the initial stopping time . large planetesimals sweep small particles in the rotational direction . therefore the final mass depends on the size of the computational domain ( paper ii ) . the difference in rotational velocity between dust and gas causes the radial migration of dust . by neglecting the self - gravity and the time derivatives of equation ( [ eq : hilleqx ] ) and ( [ eq : hilleqy ] ) , we obtain the steady solution : @xcite @xmath202 figure [ fig : maxmass_vx.eps ] shows the time evolution of the radial velocity @xmath203 of the largest particle . in these models , the initial stopping time is @xmath155 . the power - law index and the velocity difference are @xmath204 , @xmath205 , @xmath206 , and @xmath207 ( models 100ac1 , 100as1 , 100ac2 , and 100as2 ) . in all models , the radial velocity @xmath203 is negative at @xmath208 . this corresponds to the radially inward drift . the rotational velocity of gas is slower than the kepler velocity ; dust experiences a headwind , which causes its inward migration . therefore their radial velocities become negative . although @xmath92 is different , if @xmath209 is same , the time evolutions of @xmath210 are similar in the early phase . this is because the planetesimals do not grow sufficiently in @xmath211 . if we estimate the terminal velocity from equation ( [ eq : driftvelo ] ) by the initial stopping time , they are the radial velocity @xmath212 for @xmath213 and @xmath214 for @xmath215 . in models for @xmath120 , the drag coefficient of a particle is independent of its size , thus the radial velocity converges to @xmath216 for @xmath213 and @xmath217 for @xmath215 ; the radial migration does not stop . on the other hand , in models for @xmath96 , as planetesimals grow , the drag coefficient becomes small ; the radial migration stops finally . the radial velocity oscillates with the period of about @xmath218 . this oscillation is caused by the epicycle motion . the gas drag is so weak that the oscillation is not damped . @xcite performed linear analyses of the dissipative gravitational instability of a dust layer . they studied the effect of the stopping time , the thickness of the dust layer , and the velocity dispersion . we summarized the essence of their results in [ sec : disprel ] . the dust layer is always unstable for long wavelength modes . thus , we should compare the timescale of the gravitational instability with those of other processes . under the thin disk approximation ( @xmath46 ) , we derived that simple condition that the gravitational instability dominates the other processes . though the disk thickness can not be neglected and the gravitational wakes is not axisymmetric , this condition corresponds to the occurrence of the gravitational wakes , as shown in [ sec : result ] . to discuss the formation of the self - gravity wakes , toomre s @xmath1 value is more important than the roche criterion @xmath219 . they applied the growth rate of the gravitational instability to the gravitational collapse in the turbulent disks . they assumed the simple turbulence model and studied the particle response to the turbulence flow . the protoplanetary disk can be turbulent due to magnetorotational instability or kelvin - helmholtz instability . they suggested that the standard hydrostatic relation @xmath170 is not satisfied in the turbulent disk and the dust disk can be very thick . the thin disk approximation is clearly not valid . the criterion of the formation of the self - gravitational wakes may change . we plan to study the effect of the turbulence in the next paper . @xcite performed the two - dimensional numerical simulation of the gravitational instability of a dust layer . they found that the dust layer becomes extremely thin if the stopping time is long , such as @xmath220 . this is because the dust settling is faster than the growth of the gravitational instability . however , our results show that the gravitational instability occurs although the stopping time is long . there are some differences between our simulations and theirs . we treated the dust component as particles . but , @xcite treated it as a pressure - free fluid . if the stopping time is short and the velocity dispersion is small , we can treat dust as a pressure - free fluid . the pressure - free fluid model becomes irrelevant for longer stopping times . for @xmath221 , we can use the pressure - free fluid , thus this should not cause the difference . in addition , the velocity dispersion stabilizes the gravitational instability generally . we neglected the dust back - reaction on the gas , but @xcite adopted two - component model and solved the interaction between them . if the dust density is high and the stopping time is short , the dust back - reaction on the gas should be important . the resulting gas flow may change the criterion . we performed three - dimensional local calculation . on the other hand , @xcite assumed that the the dust layer to be axisymmetric with respect to the rotational axis . the gravitational instability forms the non - axisymmetric structures such as the gravitational wakes ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the motion in the azimuthal direction is important to study the structure of the gravitationally unstable disk . to understand the dynamics of planetesimal formation in gas , we need to perform three - dimensional two - component simulations . we should consider the dust back - reaction on the gas and solve the hydrodynamic equations consistently . we will treat the dust component as particles because this method is applicable although the dust is loosely coupled to gas . we plan to study this point in the following papers of this series . we performed local @xmath0-body simulations of the planetesimal formation through gravitational instability . in papers i and ii , we adopted the gas - free model . however the gas is not negligible and is important to the formation of planetesimals . as a first step to understand the effect of gas , we considered gas as the background laminar flow . we neglected the dust back - reaction on the gas for the sake of simplicity . laminar flow causes the dissipation of the kinetic energy and thus radial migration of dust . in 2 , we summarized the results of the linear analysis of the dissipative gravitational instability . to handle the dispersion relation analytically , we imposed the assumptions : the isothermal equation of state , the infinitely thin disk , and the axisymmetric perturbation . simulations show that these assumptions are not valid , but they help us to understand the physical nature of the dissipative gravitational instability . we can use the growth rate to understand the simulation results . the long wavelength modes are always secularly unstable although @xmath44 . therefore , we must compare with the timescale of the gravitational instability with other processes . we provided the equation ( [ eq : crit_q ] ) for the critical @xmath1 value . if @xmath1 is smaller than the critical value , the gravitational instability is a dominant process . the numerical simulations show that the formation process of planetesimals is the same as that in the gas - free model . the formation process is divided into three stages qualitatively : the formation of wake - like structures , the creation of planetesimal seeds , and their collisional growth . by the linear stability analysis , the dust layer in the laminar gas disk is secularly unstable although @xmath44 . the growth time of the dissipative gravitational instability is slower than the dust sedimentation and the decrease of the velocity dispersion when the initial @xmath1 value is sufficiently large . thus , the disk shrinks vertically and @xmath1 decreases . as the velocity dispersion and the scale height decrease , the growth rate of the gravitational instability increases . finally , the gravitational instability becomes dominant . then wake - like structures are formed by the gravitational instability . these structures fragment into planetesimal seeds . seeds grow rapidly owing to the mutual collisions . finally , almost all mass in the computational domain is absorbed by only one planetesimal in the calculation . we investigated the dependence of results on the initial stopping time . the @xmath1 value decreases in the initial stage , and it reaches the minimum . the decay time scale of @xmath1 is proportional to the stopping time for @xmath222 , which is the decay timescale of the velocity dispersion . the minimum @xmath1 is determined by the balance between the dissipation and gravitational instability . at the minimum q , the wake - like structures are formed . the time evolution of the ratio of the dust layer density to the roche density @xmath167 is similar to that of @xmath1 . however the decay time scale of @xmath167 is longer than that of @xmath1 . the time when @xmath184 or @xmath223 does not correspond to the onset of the gravitational instability , such as the formation of the wake - like structures . this indicates that the roche criterion is not applicable in this system . we investigated the time evolution of the number of planetesimal seeds . we define a particle whose mass is larger than @xmath194 as a planetesimal seed , where @xmath194 is the planetesimal mass predicted by the linear theory @xmath195 . the number of planetesimals has a maximum value . after the gravitational instability becomes a dominant process , planetesimal seeds form . in this stage , the number of planetesimal seeds increases . however , in the late stage , the number of seeds decreases by the mutual collisions among them . the maximum of the number of the planetesimal seeds depends on the initial stopping time . the maximum number of planetesimal seeds has a peak at @xmath198 . we are unable to identify a clear difference in the mass of the largest particle in the final state . the final mass of the planetesimal depends on the size of the computational domain @xcite . we also investigated the models where the gas rotational velocity is slower than the kepler velocity . we confirmed that the planetesimal is able to form in the sub - keplerian gas disk . in the initial stage , particles experience a headwind , which causes its inward migration . if we adopt stokes gas drag law , as planetesimals grow , the drag coefficient becomes small ; the radial migration finally slows . almost all mass is absorbed by the largest planetesimal . in the gas - free models , we showed that the final mass of planetesimals depends on the size of computational domain . to investigate the final mass of planetesimals in detail , we should perform larger scale simulations . this remains to be discussed further . in addition , in this paper , we assumed gas to be laminar flow . however , the gas may be turbulent . if the turbulence is strong , the particles are stirred up and the gravitational instability may be prevented . the timescale for the dissipative gravitational instability is long @xcite . however , though the velocity dispersion of dust particles is large and the timescale for the instability is long , the dust layer may disrupt owing to the dissipative gravitational instability over time in the turbulent disk . in the next paper , we will investigate the particle response to the turbulence and the gravitational instability in the turbulent disk .
Abstract: | [
"we investigate the formation process of planetesimals from the dust layer by the gravitational instability in the gas disk using local @xmath0-body simulations . the gas is modeled as a background laminar flow . we study the formation process of planetesimals and its dependence on the strength of the gas drag . our simulation results show that the formation process is divided into three stages qualitatively : the formation of wake - like density structures , the creation of planetesimal seeds , and their collisional growth . the linear analysis of the dissipative gravitational instability shows that the dust layer is secularly unstable although toomre s @xmath1 value is larger than unity . however , in the initial stage , the growth time of the gravitational instability is longer than that of the dust sedimentation and the decrease in the velocity dispersion . thus , the velocity dispersion decreases and the disk shrinks vertically . as the velocity dispersion becomes sufficiently small , the gravitational instability finally becomes dominant . then wake - like density structures are formed by the gravitational instability . these structures fragment into planetesimal seeds . the seeds grow rapidly owing to mutual collisions ."
] | 8,529 | 8,529 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the dynamical density matrix renormalization group ( dmrg ) @xcite and the closely related correction vector dmrg @xcite have been widely used in the last decade to compute the dynamical correlation functions and spectral functions of low - dimensional strongly correlated quantum systems . @xcite although more powerful dmrg approaches have been developed recently , @xcite dynamical dmrg ( ddmrg ) often remains the method of choice because it offers two practical advantages over the other approaches : it is simpler and it can be easily parallelized . for instance , it has been recently shown that ddmrg allows us to investigate features with small spectral weights such as power - law pseudo - gaps in luttinger liquids . @xcite the main drawback of ddmrg is that it always yields the convolution of the desired spectrum with a lorentzian distribution of finite width . therefore , the true spectrum can only be obtained through a deconvolution of the ddmrg spectrum . ( in principle , there are some methods to get around this problem @xcite but they are rarely used in practice . ) deconvolution is a typical ill - conditioned inverse problem , however . @xcite a direct solution of the deconvolution equation usually yields a very noisy and thus useless spectrum . nevertheless , various regularization methods have been successfully used to deconvolve ddmrg spectra for one - dimensional systems and quantum impurity problems . @xcite astonishingly , some of these deconvolution methods even allow us to bypass the finite - size scaling analysis and to obtain the piecewise smooth spectrum of an infinite systems directly from a broadened finite - system ddmrg spectrum . unfortunately , regularization also smooths out the sharp features of the true spectrum . this is a serious issue as the spectra of one - dimensional systems and quantum impurities often exhibit very interesting ( power - law ) singularities . in this paper we present a method , which allows us to determine sharp spectral features in the thermodynamic limit starting from a broadened finite - system ddmrg spectrum . for this purpose we consider the extrapolation to the thermodynamic limit and the deconvolution for the lorentzian kernel to be a single blind deconvolution , @xcite i.e. an inverse problem with an unknown kernel including both the lorentzian broadening and the finite - size effects . the key idea to preserve sharp spectral features in a piecewise smooth spectrum is to impose a minimal distance @xmath0 between extrema of the deconvolved spectrum . to illustrate our method we investigate the single - particle density of states ( dos ) of one - dimensional paramagnetic mott insulators represented by the half - filled hubbard model . @xcite we confirm that this dos has the step - like onset predicted by field - theoretical studies @xcite at least at weak to intermediate coupling up to @xmath1 . the hubbard model @xcite with on - site interaction @xmath2 and nearest - neighbor hopping @xmath3 is a basic lattice model for the physics of strongly interacting electrons , in particular the mott metal - insulator transition . @xcite at half filling ( i.e. , the number of electrons equals the number of sites @xmath4 ) the ground state is a mott insulator for strong interaction @xmath5 , while it is a fermi gas in the non - interacting limit @xmath6 . the hamiltonian of the hubbard model is defined by @xmath7 where the operator @xmath8 ( @xmath9 ) creates ( annihilates ) an electron with spin @xmath10 on the site @xmath11 , @xmath12 , and @xmath13 . the first sum runs over all pairs @xmath14 of nearest - neighbor sites while the other two sums run over all sites @xmath15 . here we will only consider half - filled systems and thus set the chemical potential @xmath16 to have electron - hole - symmetric spectra and a fermi energy @xmath17 . the bulk single - particle dos @xmath18 can be measured experimentally using photoemission spectroscopy or scanning tunneling spectroscopy . theoretically , it can be defined as the average of the local dos @xmath19 where the sum runs over both spins and all sites @xmath15 in the lattice , while @xmath20 is the local single - particle dos at site @xmath15 for spin @xmath10 and can be calculated using @xmath21 for @xmath22 and @xmath23 for @xmath24 . here @xmath25 denotes the eigenstates of the hamiltonian @xmath26 and @xmath27 their eigenenergies in the fock space . the ground state for the chosen number of particles corresponds to @xmath28 . the total spectral weight is @xmath29 we will consider only lattice geometry for which the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) is invariant under the electron - hole transformation @xmath30 . therefore , for half filling the density of states is symmetric , @xmath31 . if the system is translation invariant , the bulk dos and the local dos are identical . for dmrg simulations , however , open boundary conditions are preferred to periodic boundary conditions . in this case , the bulk dos can be identified with the local dos on one of the two equivalent middle sites of the system , i.e. as far as possible from the system boundaries . inverse problems such as ( blind ) deconvolutions @xcite occur in many scientific fields and are among the most challenging numerical computations . experimental measurements and computer simulations often yield approximations of the true quantities which are measured or computed , respectively . it is often assumed that the deviations from exact results can be modelled by a convolution with a smoothing function and an additive noise due to the finite accuracy and resolution of the measurement or simulation process . a typical example of a blind deconvolution is the reconstruction of an original signal from a degraded copy using incomplete information about the degradation process . @xcite here we want to compute sharp spectral features in the piecewise smooth spectrum of an infinite system from a broadened finite - system spectrum calculated with ddmrg . in this section we first show that this task can be formulated as a blind deconvolution problem , then present an algorithm for solving it . let @xmath32 be a spectrum of a finite lattice model with @xmath4 sites . this spectrum is a dirac - comb ( a finite sum of dirac - peaks ) @xmath33 where the sum runs over all hamiltonian eigenstates @xmath25 which contributes to the spectrum , i.e. with a nonzero spectral weight @xmath34 . here @xmath35 denotes the corresponding excitation energies . this spectrum can be broadened with a lorentzian distribution of width @xmath36 @xmath37 to obtain a smooth spectral function @xmath38 with the ddmrg method we can calculate this spectrum for a discrete set of excitation energies @xmath39 . as numerical calculations are always affected by errors , ddmrg actually yields values @xmath40 which are related to the true spectral function by @xmath41 for @xmath42 , where @xmath43 represents the unknown errors . ( it should be noted that ddmrg errors @xmath43 include significant systematic contributions , for instance due to the variational nature of the procedure . @xcite ) in principle , one could determine the true spectrum , i.e. , the excitation energies @xmath35 and the corresponding weights @xmath44 , through this system of equations . in practice , however , this is an ill - conditioned problem except for simple discrete spectra . moreover , we are not interested in resolving the discrete peaks of small systems but in calculating the piecewise smooth spectra of macroscopic systems . the spectrum in the thermodynamic limit is given by @xmath45 note that , generally , the order of the two limits can not be exchanged . typically , the spectral function @xmath46 is piecewise smooth , i.e. , it exhibits one or more continua as well as isolated sharp features such as steps , power - law singularities or cusps . in principle , one should carry out several ddmrg simulations with varying system size @xmath4 and broadening @xmath36 and then extrapolate the numerical data to obtain @xmath46 . in most cases , a simultaneous extrapolation for @xmath47 and @xmath48 is possible @xcite using a constant value of @xmath49 . nevertheless , the computational cost of ddmrg simulations increases very rapidly with smaller @xmath36 and the overall cost of this approach is prohibitive for a full spectrum . indeed , this approach has been mostly used to study isolated spectral features in the thermodynamic limit such as power - law singularities and steps . @xcite as all operations used to define @xmath46 from @xmath50 are linear , the broadened spectrum of the finite system can also be written explicitly as a function of the infinite system spectrum @xmath51 the kernel @xmath52 includes both the finite - size effects and the lorentzian smoothing . its form is not known but it is clear that we must recover a pure lorentzian smoothing in the thermodynamic limit @xmath53 combining eqs . ( [ eq : deconv ] ) and ( [ eq : spec - inf ] ) we obtain a system of equations @xmath54 for @xmath55 , relating the ddmrg data set @xmath56 to the infinite system spectrum @xmath46 . determining @xmath46 from these equations is a so - called inverse problem . @xcite this kind of problem is also called blind deconvolution since our knowledge of the kernel is incomplete . [ strictly speaking , it is not a deconvolution because eq . ( [ eq : inverse - problem ] ) is not a convolution . however , as the kernel approaches the form @xmath57 in the thermodynamic limit , we will use the terminology of deconvolution problems . ] it should be obvious that this is an ill - posed problem . first , the errors @xmath43 and the kernel @xmath52 are not known . second , the problem is sorely underdetermined as we try to reconstruct the function of a continuous variable from a finite number @xmath58 of data points . finally , a convolution with a lorentzian is a smoothing operation and thus the corresponding deconvolution is an extremely ill - conditioned inverse problem : the solution will be extremely sensitive to small changes or errors in the input . various deconvolution methods have been used successfully to deduce piecewise smooth spectra from the broadened finite - system spectra calculated with ddmrg . they include , direct inversion at low resolution , @xcite linear regularization methods , @xcite fourier transform with low - pass filtering , @xcite nonlinear regularization methods such as the maximum entropy method , @xcite parametrization with piecewise polynomial functions , @xcite and a deconvolution ansatz for the self energy . @xcite however , this task has not been viewed as a blind deconvolution so far . instead , it has been considered as the deconvolution of a perfectly known kernel . the need for regularization or filtering techniques has been viewed as the consequence ill - conditioning and under - determination of the problem ( [ eq : inverse - problem ] ) with a lorentzian kernel . all of these methods offer some advantages for particular spectral forms . however , their common drawback is that they are ill - suited for sharp spectral features , such as steps or power - law singularities , within or at the edge of a continuum . either the regularization procedure smooths out true sharp features excessively or it allows the occurrence of deconvolution artifacts ( artificial sharp structures , rapid oscillations or negative spectral weight ) , especially in the vicinity of the true spectrum singularities . naturally , better results can be obtained if we can use _ a priori _ knowledge about the properties of the spectrum @xcite but , in practice , this is a rare occurrence . therefore , we need a better method for solving the inverse problem ( [ eq : inverse - problem ] ) which allows us to determine isolated sharp spectral features accurately while preserving the positivity and the piecewise smoothness of @xmath46 . let the ddmrg data ( [ eq : dmrg - data ] ) be evenly distributed in the energy interval @xmath59 $ ] . the difference between two consecutive energies is @xmath60 . additionally , consider a set of equidistant energies @xmath61 in the interval @xmath62 \subset [ \epsilon_a,\epsilon_b]$ ] . the distance between these energies is @xmath63 . as we will always use @xmath64 , we have @xmath65 . ( typical values are @xmath66 and @xmath67 . ) as in a least - square approach we define a cost function @xmath68 as the sum of the squares of the differences between the ddmrg data and an approximate representation parametrized by a discrete set of variables @xmath69 @xmath70 the absolute minimum of @xmath68 is zero and the corresponding parameters @xmath71 are determined by a linear system of @xmath58 equations @xmath72 using this equation system to determine the parameters @xmath71 would be an unconstrained least - square fit . in the limit @xmath73 ( followed by @xmath74 and @xmath75 ) this equation system becomes equivalent to the inverse problem ( [ eq : inverse - problem ] ) with vanishing errors @xmath76 . thus the absolute minimum of @xmath68 yields the spectrum @xmath46 through @xmath77 if we substitute a lorentz kernel @xmath78 for the unknown kernel , @xmath79 in ( [ eq : linear - system ] ) , we recover the finite - system deconvolution problem defined by equations ( [ eq : spec - finite ] ) and ( [ eq : deconv ] ) for vanishing errors @xmath43 . thus the absolute minimum of the cost function corresponds to the discrete finite - system spectrum @xmath32 through @xmath80 if @xmath81 and @xmath82 otherwise . physically , the solution of the deconvolution problem is unique for vanishing errors @xmath43 and thus the cost function should have a unique absolute minimum . from a mathematical point of view , however , the equation system ( [ eq : linear - system ] ) could have no solution or infinitely many solutions . then any small error @xmath43 can generate wildly different ( and mostly unphysical ) solutions . therefore , as ( [ eq : kernel - limit ] ) holds in the thermodynamic limit , it is possible and preferable to obtain a reasonable approximation of the infinite - system spectrum @xmath46 from the minimization of the cost function ( [ eq : cost - function ] ) with a lorentz kernel under the constraint that the spectral function @xmath46 is physically allowed . for instance , @xmath46 should be positive semidefinite and piecewise smooth . generally , this solution does not correspond to the absolute minimum or even a local minimum of @xmath68 . indeed , the solution of the inverse problem ( [ eq : inverse - problem ] ) corresponds to the value @xmath83 if we assume that the relation ( [ eq : solution ] ) holds . of course , it could be possible to lower the cost function with other configurations @xmath84 but in that case the relation ( [ eq : solution ] ) would no longer hold . note that , this idea has been implicitly assumed in all previous deconvolution schemes of ddmrg data aiming at piecewise smooth spectra so far . however , in these approaches the agreement between solution @xmath84 and numerical data @xmath85 in eq . ( [ eq : linear - system ] ) with a lorentzian kernel is considered essential while the regularization of the solution and the errors @xmath43 are seen as perturbations which should deteriorate the agreement as little as possible . yet a blind deconvolution requires equal balancing of the agreement between solution and numerical data and of the smoothness and stability of the solution . @xcite hence we must take a different point of view : the lorentzian kernel ( [ eq : kernel - limit ] ) is only an approximation of the true kernel @xmath52 and the physical constraints on the deconvolved spectrum @xmath46 are essential in the minimization of the cost function . thus we accept significant deviations of @xmath84 from the conditions ( [ eq : linear - system ] ) yielding the absolute minimum of the cost function , or , equivalently , we assume that the errors @xmath43 can be substantial . therefore , the blind deconvolution problem can be formulated as a least - square optimization under non - linear constraints . we want to minimize the cost function ( [ eq : cost - function ] ) with the lorentz kernel under the constraints that the spectrum @xmath46 has the following properties : 1 . finite band width , i.e @xmath86 for all @xmath87 and all @xmath88 for some finite @xmath89 , 2 . positive semi - definite , @xmath90 , and 3 . piecewise smooth . the first two conditions are easily expressed for the parameters @xmath91 . the somewhat fuzzy concept of a piecewise smooth spectrum must now be formulated more precisely . in principle , we wish that @xmath46 is piecewise continuous and that the distance between discontinuities is larger than a minimal energy difference @xmath0 . as we must work with a finite number @xmath92 of points @xmath93 , we only have a discrete representation of @xmath46 and we have to formulate a `` continuity '' condition for the discrete set of variables as well . therefore , we require that the distance between two significant extrema is larger than a parameter @xmath94 . two neighboring extrema at energy @xmath95 and @xmath96 are significant if there relative height difference is larger than a parameter @xmath97 , @xmath98 this condition can easily be formulated for the parameters @xmath91 . the minimal extremum distance @xmath0 must be chosen carefully . it should be smaller than the distance between actual singularities in the spectrum @xmath46 but a too small value allows many artificial peaks in a deconvolved spectrum . in practice , we have found that we can obtain reasonable solutions to the blind deconvolution problem which look piecewise smooth using @xmath99 . in all examples discussed in this paper every local extremum is considered to be significant ( i.e. , we have used the precision of floating - point arithmetic @xmath100 ) . the cost function is minimized iteratively . iterations are repeated until the procedure converges . each iteration consists in two steps . in the first step the cost function @xmath101 is minimized with respect to each variable @xmath102 successively . this minimization under constraint does not present any difficulty as @xmath101 is a second - order polynomial in each variable @xmath103 . in the second step , we first find the positions @xmath104 of all significant extrema pairs in @xmath105 which are separated by less than a distance @xmath0 . then we interpolate the data @xmath105 linearly from @xmath106 to @xmath107 to smooth out the spectrum around the extrema . in doing so we take care to preserve the total spectral weight @xmath108 the search for extrema and their smoothing is repeated until there is no more close significant extrema in @xmath109 . then we start the next iteration . by design the first step results in a decrease of @xmath101 . the second step nearly always results in an increase of @xmath101 . without the second step , however , we would perform an under - determined ( @xmath110 ) deconvolution devoid of any regularization mechanism and thus obtain a completely useless result . typically , we observe a rapid and monotonic decrease of @xmath101 in the initial iterations followed by a saturation or oscillations in further iterations . therefore , we monitor the changes in the parameters @xmath103 and the normalized cost function @xmath111 to determine converged configurations @xmath71 . convergence requires typically @xmath112 to @xmath113 iterations depending on the quality of the ddmrg data and the complexity of the spectrum . finally , the solution @xmath91 can be smoothened using a narrow lorentzian distribution to obtain a continuous function @xmath114 with @xmath115 . alternatively , we can use a gaussian distribution @xcite of width @xmath116 . the second approach yields sharper ( real or artificial ) features because the tail of a gaussian distribution decreases faster than that of the lorentz distribution . as our minimization problem possesses many local minima , the final results @xmath71 depend somewhat on the criteria for convergence . however , if the final smoothening function is broad enough , the differences are canceled out . if the ddmrg data ( [ eq : dmrg - data ] ) are not evenly distributed in the interval @xmath59 $ ] or if they already exhibit numerous close extrema , it is useful to regularize them before starting the deconvolution iterations using an interpolation and the smoothening procedure described above . the computational effort required by this procedure is negligible compared to the computational cost of the ddmrg simulations yielding the original data . ( our code in the programming language c contains less than 400 lines of instructions and the deconvolution of one spectrum takes less than 30 minutes on a single cpu . ) therefore , we have not bothered to optimize the algorithm . nevertheless , it should be implemented in such a way that it only requires @xmath117 operations rather than the @xmath118 operations of a straightforward implementation . the method described here can be generalized in several ways . for instance , it is possible to use a variable spacing @xmath119 of the ddmrg data points , such as a finer mesh close to sharp spectrum features . however , this does not seem to improve the results in practice because the broadening parameter @xmath36 , not @xmath119 , is the limiting scale . a generalization to variable @xmath36 and @xmath119 , as proposed in ref . for quantum impurity problems , should also be possible but we have not tested it yet . to introduce information about the variation of the spectrum with @xmath36 one could combine ddmrg data obtained for different values of @xmath36 by defining an overall cost function as the sum of the cost functions for each @xmath36 . these generalizations will be tested in future works . as an illustration of our deconvolution procedure we discuss its application to the dos of one - dimensional paramagnetic mott insulators . the nature of mott insulators is a long - standing open problem in the theory of strongly correlated quantum systems . @xcite in a paramagnetic mott insulator quantum fluctuations or frustration of the antiferromagnetic spin exchange coupling prevents the formation of a long - range magnetic order . experimentally , non - magnetic mott insulators have been found in layered organic insulators @xcite as well as in quasi - one - dimensional cuprate chains @xcite and ladders @xcite . despite decades of extensive research the properties of mott insulators , in particular their single - particle dos , are still poorly understood and thus actively investigated . the half - filled hubbard model @xcite with repulsive on - site interaction @xmath2 is a basic lattice model for describing mott insulators and the mott metal - insulator transition . here we consider the case of the one - dimensional hubbard model , which is exactly solvable by bethe ansatz . @xcite at half- filling it describes a paramagnetic mott insulator with a charge gap ( mott - hubbard gap ) @xmath120 for @xmath121 . however , the dos can not be calculated directly from the bethe ansatz . all ddmrg spectra used here have been calculated with a variable number of density - matrix eigenstates kept ( up to 512 ) to reach a discarded weight lower than @xmath122 and to check dmrg truncation errors . typically , convergence was reached after three sweeps for each frequency interval of size @xmath36 . the ddmrg method is presented in detail in ref . . for @xmath6 the exact dos of the tight - binding chain in the thermodynamic limit is @xmath123 for @xmath124 while @xmath125 vanishes for larger @xmath126 . for finite coupling @xmath127 the spectrum consists in two symmetric hubbard bands separated by the gap @xmath128 . low - order strong - coupling perturbation theory @xcite predicts a square - root divergence at the dos threshold for @xmath129 , namely @xmath130 for @xmath131 and @xmath132 otherwise with @xmath133 . because of this strong - coupling result and the result of the hartree - fock ( hf ) approximation it has often been assumed that the dos of one - dimensional mott insulators exhibits a square - root divergence at the spectrum onset @xmath134 like in a one - dimensional band insulator . indeed , in the unrestricted hf approximation the one - dimensional half - filled hubbard model is an antiferromagnetic mott insulator for @xmath121 . its dos is given by @xmath135 for @xmath136 and vanishes otherwise . here @xmath137 is the hf gap . for @xmath6 , @xmath138 and this dos reduces to the dos of the tight - biding chain ( [ eq : dos - tb ] ) . for @xmath139 , @xmath140 and the hf dos shows a square - root divergence at the onset of the spectrum . however , in the weak - coupling limit @xmath141 a field - theoretical analysis @xcite predicts that the dos of one - dimensional mott insulators is constant above the threshold energy @xmath142 , @xmath143 at least for @xmath144 . thus there is a discrepancy between the field - theoretical and strong - coupling predictions for the behavior of @xmath18 just above the threshold energy @xmath142 . ( color online ) dos of a tight - binding chain : ( a ) ddmrg spectrum for a @xmath145-site chain with a lorentzian broadening @xmath146 ( red dashed line ) and result of our deconvolution method with a gaussian broadening @xmath147 ( black line ) . ( b ) enlarged view close to the singularity at @xmath148 on a double logarithmic scale : exact results ( black long - dashed line ) , ddmrg data ( red short - dashed line ) , and the deconvolved spectra @xmath109 for @xmath149 ( black solid line ) and @xmath150 ( blue dash - dot line).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] ( color online ) dos of a tight - binding chain : ( a ) ddmrg spectrum for a @xmath145-site chain with a lorentzian broadening @xmath146 ( red dashed line ) and result of our deconvolution method with a gaussian broadening @xmath147 ( black line ) . ( b ) enlarged view close to the singularity at @xmath148 on a double logarithmic scale : exact results ( black long - dashed line ) , ddmrg data ( red short - dashed line ) , and the deconvolved spectra @xmath109 for @xmath149 ( black solid line ) and @xmath150 ( blue dash - dot line).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] figure [ fig : tb](a ) shows the dos of a tight - binding chain calculated with ddmrg and the result of our deconvolution procedure . the ddmrg spectrum has been calculated in the middle of an open chain with @xmath151 sites using a broadening @xmath146 , which is just broad enough to hide its discreteness . we see that the square - root divergences at @xmath152 have been smoothed into two broad peaks and that there is substantial spectral weight at energies @xmath153 . the deconvolved dos has been determined from these same ddmrg data using a minimal extremum distance @xmath154 and a final gaussian broadening with @xmath155 . we see now that the singularities at @xmath152 are clearly visible as sharp peaks and that there is not any spectral weight at @xmath153 . overall the deconvolved dos is in excellent agreement with the exact spectrum in the thermodynamic limit ( [ eq : dos - tb ] ) . in particular , we do not observe any unphysical artefact such as negative spectral weight . however , in fig . [ fig : tb](a ) we observe two shoulders in the deconvolved dos at energies @xmath156 , which are not present in the exact solution ( [ eq : dos - tb ] ) . an enlarged view close to the singularity at @xmath157 is shown in fig . [ fig : tb](b ) on a double logarithmic scale . we see that the ddmrg data agree with the exact result only at some distance from the singularity . in this figure we also show deconvolved spectra @xmath109 for two different values of the normalized cost function @xmath158 . clearly , they reproduce the square - root divergence at @xmath157 much better than the original ddmrg data . the overall divergent behavior is visible on a broader energy scale for the smaller value of @xmath158 but we see that the reduction of the cost function is also accompanied by stronger oscillations around the exact result . these oscillations correspond to the shoulder seen in fig . [ fig : tb](a ) . the occurrence of artificial shoulder - like structures is the main drawback of our deconvolution procedure . any deconvolution method magnifies the noise ( numerical errors ) which is present in the original data . this the main issue that existing methods try to solve in different ways . @xcite we have systematically tested our deconvolution procedure using exact results for non - interacting systems and purposely adding random numerical errors . we have found that by preventing the formation of local maxima in the deconvolved spectrum our procedure allows us to control the noise magnification only partially . unfortunately , it can not handle extrema ( @xmath159 oscillations ) in the spectrum derivative . thus the magnified noise shows up as shoulder - like structures ( but not as local maxima , discontinuities , or sharp angles ) on an energy scale @xmath0 and gives a rough appearance to some deconvoled spectra presented here . in principle , we should be able to correct this deficiency with a higher - order interpolation procedure in the smoothening step or with a smoothening of the derivative of @xmath46 ( i.e. , the finite differences between the parameters @xmath103 ) . however , we have not yet succeeded in developing a practical algorithm based on these ideas . ( color online ) ( a ) dos of the one - dimensional half - filled hubbard model at @xmath160 calculated with ddmrg in a 128-site chain using a broadening @xmath146 ( red dashed line ) and the result of our deconvolution procedure ( black line ) with a minimal extremum distance @xmath161 and a gaussian broadening @xmath162 . the vertical dashed lines show the exact position of the dos threshold calculated from the bethe ansatz solution . ( b ) enlarged view of the same data around the dos threshold for @xmath163 . additionally , the result of our procedure with @xmath164 ( blue dot - dash line ) and of a deconvolution with linear regularization @xcite ( green dots ) are also shown.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] ( color online ) ( a ) dos of the one - dimensional half - filled hubbard model at @xmath160 calculated with ddmrg in a 128-site chain using a broadening @xmath146 ( red dashed line ) and the result of our deconvolution procedure ( black line ) with a minimal extremum distance @xmath161 and a gaussian broadening @xmath162 . the vertical dashed lines show the exact position of the dos threshold calculated from the bethe ansatz solution . ( b ) enlarged view of the same data around the dos threshold for @xmath163 . additionally , the result of our procedure with @xmath164 ( blue dot - dash line ) and of a deconvolution with linear regularization @xcite ( green dots ) are also shown.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] figure [ fig : onedim4](a ) shows the single - particle dos of the half - filled one - dimensional hubbard model at @xmath160 calculated with ddmrg and the result of our deconvolution procedure . the ddmrg spectrum has been computed @xcite in the middle of an open chain with @xmath151 sites and a broadening @xmath146 . the deconvolved spectrum has been obtained from these ddmrg data using a minimal extremum distance @xmath165 and a final gaussian broadening @xmath166 . the effects of the broadening are clearly visible in the ddmrg data . for instance , although one can recognize the opening of the mott - hubbard gap @xmath128 , spectral weight is clearly visible inside the gap . a point - wise analysis @xcite of the scaling for @xmath47 with @xmath167 is required to confirm that the spectral weight jumps from @xmath168 to a finite value at the onset @xmath169 and that the gap width agrees with the exact results @xmath170 calculated with the bethe ansatz . @xcite however , the behavior for @xmath171 remains uncertain because of the relatively large broadening used in the ddmrg calculation . on the contrary the deconvolved dos clearly shows a gap with the step - like onset ( [ eq : dos - ft ] ) predicted by field theory @xcite at the position @xmath172 given by the bethe ansatz solution . we obtain similarly unambiguous results for @xmath127 up to @xmath173 ( see below ) . therefore , our numerical investigation confirms the field - theoretical prediction @xcite for the onset of the dos in one - dimensional mott insulators . the superiority of the deconvolved spectrum over the original ddmrg data is even more obvious in fig . [ fig : onedim4](b ) which shows an enlarged view of the dos around @xmath172 . in this figure we also show the result of a deconvolution of the ddmrg data with a standard linear regularization method @xcite . ( note that this method yields negative spectral weights for some energies @xmath174 but we show the positive parts only . ) we see that the result of the deconvolution procedure proposed in this work is much superior to that of the standard one , which is too blurred to allow us to determine the true form of the dos at the onset @xmath172 . in addition , fig . [ fig : onedim4](b ) shows the result of our deconvolution procedure for a minimal extremum distance @xmath175 which is deliberately too small . in that case , artificial oscillations on energy scales @xmath176 are clearly visible in the deconvolved spectrum . ( color online ) upper hubbard band in the dos of the one - dimensional half - filled hubbard model at @xmath177 calculated with ddmrg in a 64-site chain using a broadening @xmath178 ( red dashed line ) and the result of our deconvolution procedure ( black line ) with a gaussian broadening @xmath179 . , scaledwidth=48.0% ] in the strong - coupling limit @xmath180 our results are less conclusive . for instance , we show the ddmrg and deconvolved upper hubbard and for a very strong coupling @xmath177 in fig . [ fig : onedim40 ] . the ddmrg spectrum has been calculated in the middle of an open chain with @xmath181 sites using a broadening @xmath178 . the deconvolved spectrum has been obtained from these ddmrg data using a minimal extremum distance @xmath182 and a final a gaussian broadening @xmath179 . two broad peaks are clearly visible at energies @xmath183 as predicted for the strong - coupling limit . however , the widths and heights of these peaks after deconvolution are not compatible with the square - root divergences ( [ eq : dos - scpt ] ) predicted by the low - order strong - coupling expansion . actually , higher - order corrections indicate @xcite that some spectral weight is present below the peak at @xmath184 on a scale set by the effective spin exchange coupling @xmath185 . this width is compatible with our deconvolved spectra for @xmath186 . thus our numerical results agree at least qualitatively with strong - coupling perturbation theory and suggest that the square - root divergences in the dos ( [ eq : dos - scpt ] ) is an artifact of a truncated strong - coupling expansion . nevertheless , for strong coupling such as @xmath177 we are not able to determine the shape of the dos at the onset @xmath172 . in particular , it is not clear if the field - theoretical prediction ( [ eq : dos - ft ] ) is still valid . indeed , if the distance @xmath187 between onset at @xmath169 and peak at @xmath188 becomes smaller than the minimal extremum distance @xmath0 , we can no longer distinguish both structures in the deconvolved spectrum . in practice , the distance @xmath0 must be comparable to the broadening @xmath36 of the ddmrg data to obtain piecewise smooth spectra . therefore , although we can reduce the broadening of isolated spectral structures by several orders of magnitude , we can not resolve distinct spectral features on a scale lower than the original broadening of the ddmrg data . this is a limitation of our deconvolution method that one has to keep in mind . ( color online ) deconvolved dos of the half - filled hubbard model for energies @xmath189 for @xmath6 ( dashed line ) , and from left to right @xmath190 ( red line ) , @xmath191 ( blue line ) and @xmath192 ( green line ) . the result for @xmath177 is shifted to the left by @xmath193 . , scaledwidth=48.0% ] finally , fig . [ fig : onedim ] recapitulates the evolution of the dos as a function of the interaction strength @xmath5 . as the spectrum is symmetric @xmath194 , we show only the deconvolved spectra for positive energies ( i.e. , the upper hubbard band ) . at @xmath6 the spectrum consists in a single band with two clearly visible square - root singularities at the band edges @xmath195 . for weak coupling @xmath127 the band splits into two symmetric hubbard bands separated by a gap @xmath128 , which agrees perfectly with the charge gap calculated from the bethe ansatz solution . at the dos onsets @xmath196 the spectrum exhibits the step - like behavior ( [ eq : dos - ft ] ) predicted by field theory . @xcite there is an apparent plateau between the onset and a strong first peak , which evolves from the square - root singularities at @xmath195 for @xmath6 . additionally , we observe substantial spectral weight and a small second peak at higher excitation energy . however , for weak enough @xmath127 most of the spectral weight lies between the spectrum onset and the first peak . as @xmath127 increases ( compare the spectra for @xmath160 and @xmath1 in fig . [ fig : onedim ] ) , the spectrum and all its features shift to higher excitation energy and the spectral weight becomes more concentrated between the visible peaks . in addition , we note that the separation between onset energy @xmath142 and the strong first peak becomes systematically smaller until it is no longer resolvable with our method , the peak separation increases monotonically from about @xmath197 for @xmath198 to approximately @xmath199 for @xmath200 , and the strength of both peaks become more equal . comparing the dos with the momentum - resolved spectral function and the bethe ansatz dispersion ( see figs . 4 and 5 in ref . ) we note that the strong first peak corresponds to the edge of the spinon branch at momentum @xmath201 , the weak second peak corresponds to the edge of the holon branch at @xmath202 , and the upper edge of the dos spectrum coincide with the edge of the single spinon - holon continuum . finally , we do not observe any spectral weight outside the first lower and upper hubbard bands and these two bands account for the full spectral weight ( [ eq : sum ] ) . thus we conclude that higher - energy hubbard bands do not carry any spectral weight in the bulk single - particle dos . we have presented a blind deconvolution procedure which allows us to obtain piecewise smooth spectral functions for infinite - size systems from the ddmrg spectra of finite systems . it involves a trade - off between the agreement of the deconvolved spectrum to the original ddmrg data and the piecewise smoothness and positivity of spectral functions . in practice , the method reduces to a least - square optimization under non - linear constraints which enforce the positivity and piecewise smoothness . we have tested this deconvolution method on many spectra which are known exactly in the thermodynamic limit , such as the single - particle density of states and the optical conductivity of correlated one - dimensional insulators . @xcite we have found that our method works well for several kinds of singularities ( e.g. power - law band edges , steps , excitonic peaks ) in piecewise smooth spectra . in particular , it allows us to reduce the broadening by orders of magnitude and even to substitute the lorentzian broadening by a gaussian one . its main drawback is the frequent appearance of artificial shoulder - like structures on energy scales @xmath203 . we have demonstrated the deconvolution procedure on the single - particle dos in the one - dimensional hubbard model at half filling . our results show that the dos has a step - like shape but no square - root singularity at the spectrum onset in agreement with a field - theoretical prediction for one - dimensional paramagnetic mott insulators . @xcite in addition , the deconvolution procedure has allowed us to detail the evolution of the dos from the non - interacting limit @xmath6 to the strong - coupling limit @xmath180 . we thank karlo penc and fabian eler for helpful discussions . the gotoblas library developed by kazushige goto was used to perform the ddmrg calculations . some of these calculations were carried out on the rrzn cluster system of the leibniz universitt hannover . e. jeckelmann , f. gebhard , and f.h.l . essler , phys . lett . * 85 * , 3910 ( 2000 ) . e. jeckelmann , phys . b * 66 * , 045114 ( 2002 ) . t.d . khner and s.r . white , phys . rev . b * 60 * , 335 ( 1999 ) . pati , s. ramasesha , z. shuai , and j.l . brdas , phys . b * 59 * , 14827 ( 1999 ) . e. jeckelmann , prog . . suppl . * 176 * , 143 ( 2008 ) . e. jeckelmann and h. benthien , in _ computational many particle physics _ ( lecture notes in physics * 739 * ) , edited by h. fehske , r. schneider , and a. weie ( springer - verlag , berlin , heidelberg , 2008 ) , p. 621 . white and i. affleck , phys . b * 77 * , 134437 ( 2008 ) . a. weichselbaum , f. verstraete , u. schollwck , j.i . cirac , and j. von delft , phys . b * 80 * , 165117 ( 2009 ) . a. holzner , a. weichselbaum , i.p . mcculloch , u. schollwck , and j. von delft , phys . b * 83 * , 195115 ( 2011 ) dargel , a. honecker , r. peters , r.m . noack , and t. pruschke , phys . b * 83 * , 161104 ( 2011 ) . e. jeckelmann , j. phys . : condens . matter * 25 * , 014002 ( 2013 ) . r. peters , phys . b * 84 * , 075139 ( 2011 ) . w.h . press , s.a . teukolsky , w.t . vetterling , and b.p . flannery , _ numerical recipes in c++ the art of scientific computing _ , second edition ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2002 ) , chap . oleary , _ scientific computing with case studies _ ( siam , philadelphia , 2009 ) , chap . 6 and 14 . f. gebhard , e. jeckelmann , s. mahlert , s. nishimoto , and r.m . noack , eur . j. b * 36 * , 491 ( 2003 ) . s. nishimoto and e. jeckelmann , j. phys . : condens . matter * 16 * , 613 ( 2004 ) . s. nishimoto , f. gebhard , and e. jeckelmann , j. phys . : condens . matter * 16 * , 7063 ( 2004 ) . c. raas , g.s . uhrig , and f.b . anders , phys . b * 69 * , 041102(r ) ( 2004 ) . c. raas and g.s . uhrig , eur . j. b * 45 * , 293 ( 2005 ) . e. jeckelmann and h. fehske , rivista del nuovo cimento * 30 * , 259 ( 2007 ) . p. schmitteckert , journal of physics : conferences series * 220 * , 012022 ( 2010 ) . t. ulbricht and p. schmitteckert , euro . * 89 * , 47001 ( 2010 ) . p. campisi and k. egiazarian , _ blind image deconvolution theory and applications _ ( crc press , boca raton , 2007 ) . j. hubbard , proc . london a * 276 * , 238 ( 1963 ) . f.h.l . essler and a.m. tsvelik , phys . b * 65 * , 115117 ( 2002 ) . mott , _ metal - insulator transitions _ ( taylor and francis , london , 1990 ) . f. gebhard , _ the mott metal - insulator transition _ ( springer , berlin , 1997 ) . y. kurosaki , y. shimizu , k. miyagawa , k. kanoda , and g. saito , phys . lett * 95 * , 177001 ( 2005 ) . kim , j.p . hill , h. benthien , f.h.l . essler , e. jeckelmann , h.s . choi , t.w . noh , n. motoyama , k.m . kojima , s. uchida , d. casa , and t. gog , phys . lett . * 92 * , 137402 ( 2004 ) . m. azuma , z. hiroi , m. takano , k. ishida , and y. kitaoka , phys . rev 73 * , 3463 ( 1994 ) . e. h. lieb and f. y. wu , phys . 20 * , 1445 ( 1968 ) . essler , h. frahm , f. ghmann , a. klmper , and v. korepin , _ the one - dimensional hubbard model _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 2005 ) . a. parola and s. sorella , phys . b * 45 * , 13 156 ( 1992 ) . k. penc , k. hallberg , f. mila , and h. shiba , phys . b * 55 * , 15 475 ( 1997 ) . k. penc ( private communication ) . essler , f. gebhard , and e. jeckelmann , phys . b * 64 * , 125119 ( 2001 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we present a numerical method for calculating piecewise smooth spectral functions of correlated quantum systems in the thermodynamic limit from the spectra of finite systems computed using the dynamical or correction - vector density - matrix renormalization group method . the key idea is to consider this problem as a blind deconvolution with an unknown kernel which causes both a broadening and finite - size corrections of the spectrum . in practice , the method reduces to a least - square optimization under non - linear constraints which enforce the positivity and piecewise smoothness of spectral functions . the method is demonstrated on the single - particle density of states of one - dimensional paramagnetic mott insulators represented by the half - filled hubbard model on an open chain . our results confirm that the density of states has a step - like shape but no square - root singularity at the spectrum onset ."
] | 8,017 | 8,017 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: quantum open systems have been a subject of fundamental interest for many years . problems in this category include those of understanding how the irreversibility of time appears in system dynamics , why macroscopic systems can be treated with classical mechanics instead of quantum mechanics , how wave functions collapse as a result of measurements done with macroscopic instruments , and why and how quantum systems approach a thermal equilibrium state through interaction with their environments.@xcite theories of quantum open systems have also been used to construct models of practical interest , in particular to account for line shapes in epr , nmr@xcite and laser spectra,@xcite to evaluate chemical reaction rates@xcite and electron and charge transfer rates@xcite in chemical physics , and to explore the lifetimes of quantum entanglement states in quantum information theory.@xcite the phenomena mentioned above arise from the unavoidable interaction of a system with its environment . in the quantum mechanical case , dissipative systems are often modeled as main systems coupled to heat - bath degrees of freedom at finite temperature . this coupling gives rise to thermal fluctuations and dissipation that drive the systems toward the thermal equilibrium state . the heat - bath degrees of freedom are then reduced using such methods as the projection operator method and the path integral method . the projection operator approach is effective if the interaction between the system and the bath is weak . if one further assumes that the correlation time of the noise arising from the interaction with the bath is very short ( the markovian assumption ) , equations of motion for the density matrix elements can be derived , and these can be solved numerically . the most commonly used equations of this kind are the quantum master equations@xcite and the redfield equation.@xcite it has been proven , however , that quantum master equations and the redfield equation do not satisfy the necessary positivity condition.@xcite careful analyses addressing this problem have been carried out by several researchers.@xcite as a method to preserve positivity , the rotating wave approximation ( rwa ) , which modifies the interaction between the system and the heat bath , has been applied.@xcite however , this may alter the thermal equilibrium state as well as the dynamics of the original total hamiltonian . then , building on these results , it was shown that the violation of the positivity condition results from the markovian assumption . specifically , it was found that even if the dissipation process is markovian , the fluctuation process may not be , because it must satisfy the fluctuation - dissipation theorem.@xcite the time convolution - less ( tcl ) master equation has a wider range of applicability than the quantum master equations and redfield equation , because it allows the system - bath interaction to be non - perturbative and fluctuation and dissipation to be non - markovian.@xcite in order for a non - perturbative treatment to be possible , however , the system hamiltonian and the bath interactions of the tcl equation must commute.@xcite thus , the tcl equation can not be used to treat many important problems involving molecules , atoms , and spins driven by a time - dependent laser or magnetic field . in addition , because of the factorized nature of the system - bath interaction , in the case of a non - commuting excitation , the tcl equation can not be used to calculate nonlinear response functions of the system operator involved in the optical multidimensional spectrum.@xcite path integral monte carlo simulations do not have the limitations of any of the approaches discussed above , and for this reason , they are capable of incorporating imaginary path integrals and unfactorized initial conditions more easily , but this approach is computationally heavy , because the number of paths to be evaluated grows rapidly with time , while sampling fails due to the phase cancellation of wave functions.@xcite much effort has been made to extend the applicability of this method.@xcite because this approach can easily incorporate the semi - classical approximation in the bath , it may have an advantage in the study of polyatomic systems treated in multi - dimensional coordinates , but applications to this point incorporating full quantum dynamics have been limited to relatively small systems . many of the above - mentioned limitations can be overcome with the hierarchal equations of motion ( heom ) for the reduced density matrix , which are derived by differentiating the reduced density matrix elements defined by path integrals.@xcite this approach was introduced to investigate the connection between the phenomenological stochastic liouville equation and the dynamical hamiltonian theory , and was originally limited to the case in which the spectral distribution function takes the drude form ( i.e. , the ohmic form with a lorentzian cutoff ) and the bath temperature is high.@xcite however , with the inclusion of low temperature corrections terms , this temperature limitation has been eliminated.@xcite in addition , with the extension of the dimension of the hierarchy , this approach is capable of treating a great variety of spectral distribution functions.@xcite this formalism is valuable because it can treat not only strong system - bath coupling but also quantum coherence between the system and bath , which is essential to calculate nonlinear response functions . the system - bath coherence becomes particularly important if the bath interaction is regarded as non - markovian , as was found from nonlinear optical measurements in the late 1980s , when laser technology reached the femto - second time scale , which is much shorter than the noise correlation time of environmental molecules.@xcite the heom approach has been used to study such problems , which include multi - dimensional spectroscopy.@xcite recently , it was shown that system - bath coherence also plays an important role in calculations of quantum measures involving concurrence@xcite and non - markovianity@xcite under multiple external perturbations.@xcite because the heom approach is computationally heavy , a variety of methods have been developed to study dissipative dynamics in realistic situations . @xcite it has been applied to the study of multi - dimensional vibrational spectroscopies,@xcite photosynthetic antenna systems,@xcite fermion systems , @xcite quantum ratchets,@xcite resonant tunneling diodes,@xcite and dissociation of tightly bounded electron - hole pairs.@xcite while the applicability of the heom approach continues to expand , the basic nature of the hierarchy elements has not been thoroughly explored . the purpose of this paper is to investigate the role of correlated initial equilibrium states in the heom formalism . until this time , the heom have been derived by assuming a factorized initial state , @xmath0 \exp[-\beta \hat h_b]$ ] , at inverse temperature @xmath1 , where @xmath2 and @xmath3 are the system and bath hamiltonians , respectively , while the true thermal equilibrium state of the system is given by @xmath4 $ ] , where @xmath5 is the system - bath interaction . the difference between the factorized and correlated initial states becomes large for strong @xmath5 . analysis based on an analytic solution of a brownian oscillator system indicates that even if we start from a factorized initial state , the system reaches the true equilibrium state , @xmath6\}$ ] , through transient phenomena arising from the factorized initial state , for example phenomena known as initial sweeping.@xcite with the heom approach , we have run the heom program until all of the hierarchy elements reach the steady state and then used these elements as the initial conditions of the correlated thermal equilibrium state . the accuracy of this method has been confirmed by analyzing multi - dimensional spectra obtained with it.@xcite nevertheless , it would be interesting to derive the heom starting from a correlated initial thermal state in order to obtain an analytically derived expression for the system - bath coherence in the heom formalism . moreover , with a simple generalization , we can also derive the heom in imaginary time , which corresponds to the inverse temperature . we show that the imaginary - time heom is convenient for obtaining correlated thermal equilibrium states and the thermodynamic variables of the reduced system . the organization of the paper is as follows . in sec . ii we present a model hamiltonian and its influence functional with correlated initial states . in sec . iii , we derive the heom from the density matrix elements using the influence functional formalism with the correlated initial states given in sec . ii . in sec . iv , we derive the imaginary - time heom , which is convenient for evaluating correlated thermal equilibrium states and the thermodynamic quantities of the system . in sec . v , to confirm the validity and numerical efficiency of our approach , we report the results of numerical integrations of the heom carried out over real time and imaginary time for a spin - boson system and compare their results . thermodynamic variables and expectation values for the spin - boson system are also calculated as a demonstration . section vi is devoted to concluding remarks . we consider a situation in which the system interacts with a heat bath that gives rise to dissipation and fluctuation in the system . to illustrate this , let us consider a hamiltonian expressed as @xmath7 where @xmath8 is the hamiltonian of the system , denoted by a , defined by the creation and annihilation operators @xmath9 and @xmath10 . the bath degrees of freedom are treated as an ensemble of harmonic oscillators , @xmath11 with the momentum , position , mass , and frequency of the @xmath12th bath oscillator given by @xmath13 , @xmath14 , @xmath15 and @xmath16 , respectively . the system - bath interaction is given by @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the system part of the interaction , and @xmath19 is the coupling constant between the system and the @xmath12th oscillator . the heat bath can be characterized by the spectral distribution function , defined by @xmath20 and the inverse temperature , @xmath21 , where @xmath22 is the boltzmann constant . note that if @xmath9 and @xmath10 respectively represent the creation and annihilation operators of spin states , the above hamiltonian is the spin - boson hamiltonian , @xcite which has been studied with various approaches.@xcite now , let us introduce the fermion coherent state @xmath23 , which satisfies @xmath24 and @xmath25 , where @xmath26 and @xmath27 are grassmann numbers ( g - numbers ) . @xcite note that here we consider a two - level system , but extension to a multi - level system is also straightforward.@xcite in practice , we can treat a g - number system in the same manner as a c - number system , as long as we maintain the time order of the operators in the integral . in the path integral representation , the time propagator of the wave function ( the feynman propagator ) for the total system is expressed as @xmath28 } \int_{{\bold x}(0)={\bold x}_0}^{{\bold x}(t)={\bold x } } d[{\bold x}(\tau ) ] \nonumber \\ & & \times { \rm e}^{\frac{\rm i}{\hbar } s_a[\phi ^{\dag},\,\phi ; \,t ] + \frac{i}{\hbar } \int_0^t d\tau \left [ \frac12{m \dot { \bold x}^2(\tau)}- \frac12 m \omega^2 { \bold x}^2(\tau ) + v ( \tau){\bold x } ( \tau ) \right ] } , \label{gtot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath29 is the normalization constant , @xmath30 $ ] represents a functional integral over a set of grassmann variables , and @xmath31\equiv \pi_j \int d[x_j(\tau)]$ ] denotes path integrals over the bath oscillator coordinates , with @xmath32 , @xmath33 , and @xmath34 . here , the action for the system s hamiltonian , @xmath35 , is denoted by @xmath36=\int^t_{0 } d\tau l_a({\phi}^{\dag},{\phi})$ ] , with the lagrangian @xmath37 the thermal equilibrium state can also be expressed in the path integral representation by making the replacement @xmath38 in eq .. we thereby obtain @xmath39 } \int_{\bar { \bold x}(0)={\bold x}'_0}^{\bar { \bold x}(\beta\hbar)={\bold x}_0 } d[\bar { \bold x}(\tau ' ) ] \nonumber \\ & & \times { \rm e}^{-\frac{\rm 1}{\hbar } \bar s_a[\bar \phi ^{\dag},\,\bar \phi ; \,\beta \hbar ] -\frac{1}{\hbar } \int_0^{\beta \hbar } d\tau ' \left [ \frac12{m \dot { \bar { \bold x}}^2(\tau')}+ \frac12 m \omega^2 \bar { \bold x}^2(\tau ' ) - { \bar v } ( \tau ' ) \bar { \bold x } ( \tau ' ) \right ] } , \label{geqtot}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath40 is the normalization constant , the g - numbers @xmath41 form the coherent representations of the operators @xmath42 for the equilibrium distribution , @xmath43 $ ] is the euclid action of the system obtained from @xmath36 $ ] through the replacement @xmath44 , and @xmath45 . the total density matrix elements is then given by @xmath46 the heat - bath degrees of freedom can be eliminated by integrating over the bath coordinates as @xmath47 . the reduced density operator is then expressed in the coherent representation of the g - numbers as@xcite @xmath48 where @xmath49 } \int_{\bar \phi ( 0)=\phi'_0}^{\bar \phi ( \beta \hbar)=\phi_0 } d[{\bar \phi}^{\dag}(\tau ' ) \bar \phi ( \tau ' ) ] \int_{\phi'(0)=\phi_0'}^{\phi'(t)=\phi ' } { d[{\phi ' } ^{\dag } ( \tau ) \phi ' ( \tau ) ] } \nonumber \\ & & \times \bar \rho_0^{eq}[\bar \phi ^\dag , \bar \phi ; \beta \hbar ] { \rm e}^{\frac{\rm i}{\hbar } s_a[\phi ^{\dag},\,\phi ; \,t ] } f[\bold v ; t , \beta\hbar ] { \rm e}^ { - \frac{\rm i } { \hbar } s_a^{\dag}[{\phi ' } ^{\dag},\,\phi ' ; \,t]}. \label{rhotot1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath50 $ ] is the thermal equilibrium distribution of the system @xmath51 itself , defined by the euclid action , @xmath52 $ ] , and @xmath53 $ ] with @xmath54 is the influence functional for correlated initial states.@xcite employing the counter path illustrated in fig . 1 , we can express the influence functional in the path integral representation as ( see appendix a ) @xmath55 = \int d\bold x \int_{{\bold x}'(t)={\bold x}}^{{\bold x}(t)={\bold x } } d[\tilde { \bold x}(s ) ] e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar } \int_c ds\left [ \frac12{m \dot { \tilde { \bold x}}^2(s)}- \frac12 m \omega^2\tilde { \bold x}^2(s ) + \tilde v_c(s)\tilde { \bold x } ( s ) \right ] } , \label{eq : f_x}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath56\equiv \pi_j \int d[x_j(\tau ) ] \int d[\bar x_j(\tau ' ) ] \int d[x_j'(\tau)]$ ] , with the contour path defined by @xmath57 and @xmath58 with @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 , respectively . the path integral used here to derive the heom is expressed in terms of an influence functional . the calculation of the influence functional for a heat bath consisting of harmonic oscillators is analogous to that of the generating functional for a brownian oscillator system if we regard the system operator in the system - bath interaction @xmath62 as an external force acting on the bath . @xcite then , the influence functional can be calculated analytically and is found to be @xmath63=\exp\left\{{\tilde \phi}[\tilde v_c ; t , \beta\hbar]\right\}$ ] , where the influence phase is expressed as ( see appendix a ) @xmath64 = \frac1{\hbar^2 } \int_c ds '' \int_{c ' } ds ' \tilde v_c(s '' ) \tilde v_{c'}(s ' ) l ( s '' - s ' ) . \label{eq : phita}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath65 represents the counter path for @xmath66 that follows @xmath67 along @xmath68 under the condition @xmath69 and @xmath70 . \label{eq : ltitau}\end{aligned}\ ] ] after dividing the contour of the integral in eq . into @xmath71 , @xmath72 and @xmath73 , we have ( see appendix b ) @xmath74 & = & - \frac1{\hbar^2 } \int_0^t dt '' \int_0^{t '' } dt ' v^\times(t '' ) \left[-i l_1 ( t''-t ' ) v^\circ(t ' ) + l_2(t''-t ' ) v^\times(t ' ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{i}{\hbar^2 } \int_0^t dt '' \int_0^{\beta \hbar } d \tau ' v^\times(t '' ) l ( t '' + i \tau ' ) \bar v ( \tau ' ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac1{\hbar^2 } \int_0^{\beta \hbar } d \tau '' \int_0^{\tau '' } d \tau ' \bar v ( \tau '' ) \bar v ( \tau ' ) \bar l(\tau '' - \tau ' ) , \label{eq : phitb}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we define @xmath75 , @xmath76 and @xmath77 the functionals @xmath78 and @xmath79 represent the commutator and anticommutator of @xmath62 . this form of the influence functional has been used to analytically study quantum brownian systems.@xcite the first term in eq . represents a commonly used influence functional derived from the factorized initial conditions . @xcite the collective bath oscillator coordinate , @xmath80 , is regarded as a driving force for the system through the interaction @xmath81 . the time - dependent kernels are then represented by @xmath82\rangle$ ] and @xmath83 , respectively , where @xmath84 is the heisenberg representation of the operator @xmath85 . @xcite the function @xmath86 is analogous to the classical correlation function of the bath induced noise @xmath87 and corresponds to the fluctuations . the dissipation corresponding to @xmath88 is related to @xmath89 through the quantum version of the fluctuation - dissipation theorem , @xmath90 = \hbar \omega \coth(\beta \hbar \omega/2 ) \bar c [ \omega]/2 $ ] , which insures that the system evolves toward the thermal equilibrium state for finite temperatures.@xcite the second term in eq . consists of the cross - terms between the real - time and imaginary - time integrals that describe the correlation between the initial equilibrium state and the dynamical state at time @xmath91 . this term represents the contribution of the correlated initial conditions and can be regarded as the non - markovian effects with respect to both real and imaginary times . the last term describes the influence of the heat bath on the thermal equilibrium state of the system . in the following sections , in order to derive the imaginary - time hoem , we consider the full equilibrium state of the system , @xmath92 $ ] , by including the last term in @xmath50 $ ] . for @xmath93 , we have@xcite @xmath94 @xmath95 where @xmath96 are the matsubara frequencies . we thus have @xmath97 \cos(\omega t ) \nonumber \\ + i \frac{2}{\beta\hbar } \int_{0}^{\infty } d\omega j(\omega ) \sum_{k=1}^{\infty } \frac{2\nu_k}{\nu_k^2+\omega^2 } \sin ( \nu_k \tau ) \sin(\omega t ) , \label{eq : lfourier}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath98 . \label{eq : lbardef } \end{aligned}\ ] ] for the case @xmath99 , we use the definition given in eq . to obtain @xmath100 @xmath101 \cos(\omega t).\end{aligned}\ ] ] we assume that the spectral density @xmath102 has an ohmic form with a lorentzian cutoff and write@xcite @xmath103 where the constant @xmath104 represents the width of the spectral distribution of the collective bath modes and is the reciprocal of the correlation time of the noise induced by the bath . the parameter @xmath105 is the system - bath coupling strength , which represents the magnitude of damping . with eq . for @xmath93 , we obtain @xmath106 } \right\ } e^{-\gamma t } \nonumber \\ & & + \sum_{k=1}^{\infty } \textcolor{red } { c_k ' \left[\cos ( \nu_k \tau ) -i \sin ( \nu_k \tau ) \right ] } e^{-\nu_k t } , \label{eq : ltitau2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath107 @xmath108 and @xmath109 . at @xmath110 , the above equation reduces to @xmath111 where @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 for @xmath115 , while at @xmath99 , we have @xmath116 and @xmath117 with @xmath118 . here , we choose @xmath119 so as to satisfy @xmath120 , where @xmath121 represents the characteristic frequency of the system . under this condition we can apply the approximation @xmath122 with negligible error at the desired temperature , @xmath123 . we define the equilibrium distribution function of the system under the influence of the heat bath through the replacement of the last term of @xmath124 $ ] ( as expressed in eq . ) appearing @xmath53 $ ] with @xmath50 $ ] . we then obtain @xmath125=\frac{1}{z_b } { \rm exp}&&\left[- \frac1{\hbar } \bar { s_a}[\bar \phi ^ { \dag } , \bar \phi ; \beta \hbar ] \right.\nonumber \\ & & \left . + \sum_{k=0}^{\infty } \frac{\bar c_k}{\hbar^2 } \int_{0}^ { \beta \hbar } d \tau '' \int_{0}^{\tau '' } d \tau ' \bar v(\tau '' ) \bar v ( \tau ' ) \cos \left ( \nu_k ( \tau''- \tau')\right ) \right ] . \label{eq : pci}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the influence functional @xmath126 $ ] is redefined through this replacement as @xmath127 & & = \exp \left [ \left ( -\frac{i}{\hbar } \right)^2 \int_{0}^t dt '' \operatorname{e } ^ { - \gamma t '' } % \left\ { v^{\times}(t '' ) \left ( \int_{0}^{t '' } dt ' \operatorname{e } ^ { \gamma t ' } \theta ( t ' ) % + -i \bar \theta ( \beta \hbar ) \right ) % + \xi(t '' ) % \right\ } \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \exp \left [ \left ( -\frac{i}{\hbar } \right)^2 \int_{0}^t dt''\sum\limits_{k= 1}^{k } \operatorname{e } ^ { - \nu_k t '' } v^{\times}(t '' ) \left ( \int_{0}^{t '' } dt ' \operatorname{e } ^ { \nu_k t ' } \psi_k ( t ' ) % + -i \bar \psi_k ( \beta \hbar ) \right ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \times \exp \left [ - \int_{0}^t dt '' \xi(t '' ) \right ] , \label{eq : influencefcoh}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath128 @xmath129 } \right\ } , \label{eq : thetabar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for @xmath130 , @xmath131 , \label{eq : psi_k}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath132 , } \label{eq : psi_kbar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath133 note that in the high temperature limit , @xmath134 , the noise correlation function reduces to @xmath135 . this indicates that the heat bath oscillators interact with the system in the form of gaussian markovian noise.@xcite the equations of motion for the reduced density operator can be derived by evaluating the time derivative of the wavefunctions on the left - hand and right - hand sides and the influence functional.@xcite if we consider the auxiliary matrix defined by @xmath136 } \int_{\bar \phi ( 0)=\phi'_0}^{\bar \phi ( \beta \hbar)=\phi_0 } d[{\bar \phi}^{\dag}(\tau ' ) \bar \phi ( \tau ' ) ] \int_{\phi'(0)=\phi_0'}^{\phi'(t)=\phi ' } { d[{\phi ' } ^{\dag}(\tau ) \phi ' ( \tau ) ] } \nonumber \\ & & \times \bar \rho^{eq } [ \bar \phi ^\dag , \bar \phi ; \beta \hbar ] { \rm e}^{\frac{\rm i}{\hbar } s_a[\phi ^{\dag},\,\phi ; \,t ] } f_{j_1 , \cdots , j_k}^{(n ) } [ \bold v ; t , \beta\hbar ] { \rm e}^ { - \frac{\rm i } { \hbar } s_a^{\dag}[{\phi ' } ^{\dag},\,\phi ' ; \,t ] } \label{eq : rhon_jk}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath137 & & = \left\ { \textcolor{red } { -\frac{i}{\hbar } } % color \int_{0}^{t } dt ' \operatorname{e } ^ { -\gamma ( t - t ' ) } \theta ( t ' ) % + -i \operatorname{e } ^ { -\gamma t } \bar \theta ( \beta \hbar ) \right\ } ^{n } \nonumber \\ & & \times \prod_{k=1}^k \left\ { \textcolor{red } { -\frac{i}{\hbar } } % color \int_{0}^{t } dt ' \operatorname{e } ^ { -\nu_k ( t - t')}\psi_k ( t ' ) % + -i \operatorname{e } ^ { -\nu_k t } \bar \psi_k ( \beta \hbar)\right\ } ^{j_k } \nonumber \\&&\times f_{ci}[\bold v ; t , \beta\hbar ] \label{auxfv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for nonnegative integers @xmath138 . among the @xmath139 , only @xmath140 has a physical meaning , and the others are introduced for computational purposes . differentiating @xmath141 with respect to @xmath91 , we obtain the following hierarchy of equations in operator form : @xmath142 \hat{\rho}_{j_1 , \dots , j_k}^{(n)}(t ) \notag\\ & & -\frac{i}{\hbar}\hat v^{\times } \hat{\rho}_{j_1 , \dots , j_k}^{(n+1)}(t ) - \frac{i}{\hbar } \sum_{k=1}^k \hat v^{\times } \hat{\rho}_{j_1 , \dots , j_k+1,\dots , j_k}^{(n)}(t ) \notag\\ & & - \frac{i n}{\hbar } \hat{\theta } \hat{\rho}_{j_1,\dots , j_k}^{(n-1 ) } ( t ) - \sum_{k=1}^k \frac{i j_k}{\hbar } \hat{\psi}_k \hat{\rho}_{j_1,\dots , j_k-1,\dots , j_k}^{(n)}(t ) , \label{eq : heom}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath143 is the liouvillian of @xmath2 , and the relaxation operators @xmath144 and @xmath145 are obtained through the replacement @xmath146 and @xmath147 in eqs . and , where @xmath148 and @xmath149 for any operand operator @xmath150 and @xmath151 , and @xmath152 + \sum_{k=1}^k \frac { c_k'}{\nu_k } \right\ } \hat{v}^\times\hat{v}^\times . \label{heomt3}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the above expression is identical to the heom with a factorized initial state and can be truncated in the same manner as in the factorized case for large @xmath153 , where @xmath121 is the characteristic frequency of the system.@xcite if we add the counter term to the hamiltonian , we have an additional term in eq .. @xcite while the terms from the correlated initial state @xmath154 and @xmath155 do not appear in eq . , they define the hierarchy elements for the correlated initial equilibrium state . to demonstrate this point , we consider the initial states of the density operators , obtained by setting @xmath110 in eqs . and : @xmath156 \left(-i \bar \theta ( \beta \hbar ) \right)^{n } \prod_{k=1}^k \left ( -i \bar \psi_k ( \beta \hbar ) \right)^{j_k } \bar \rho [ \bar \phi ^\dag , \bar \phi ; \beta \hbar ] . \nonumber \\ \label{eq : correlatedheom}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath157 and @xmath158 & & = { \rm exp}\left [ - \frac1{\hbar } \bar { s_a}[\bar \phi ^ { \dag } , \bar \phi ; \tau ] \right ] % { \rm exp}\left [ c_0''\int_{0}^{\tau } d \tau '' \int_{0}^{\tau '' } d \tau ' \bar v(\tau '' ) \bar v ( \tau ' ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \times { \rm exp}\left [ \sum_{k=0}^{\infty } \frac{\bar c_k}{\hbar^2 } \int_{0}^{\tau } d \tau '' \int_{0}^{\tau '' } d \tau ' \bar v(\tau '' ) \bar v ( \tau ' ) \cos ( \nu_k \tau'')\cos ( \nu_k \tau ' ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & & \times { \rm exp}\left [ \sum_{k=1}^{\infty } \frac{\bar c_k}{\hbar^2 } \int_{0}^{\tau } d \tau '' \int_{0}^{\tau '' } d \tau ' \bar v(\tau '' ) \bar v ( \tau ' ) \sin ( \nu_k \tau'')\sin ( \nu_k \tau ' ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] and we have @xmath92= z_{b } \bar \rho [ \bar \phi ^\dag , \bar \phi ; \beta \hbar]$ ] . this defines the correlated equilibrium initial conditions of eq .. in the next section , we derive the equations of motion to evaluate these hierarchy elements . the thermal equilibrium state @xmath159 $ ] at time @xmath110 and inverse temperature @xmath160 can be obtained by considering the imaginary - time derivative of the reduced density matrix elements given in eq.([eq : pci ] ) . this is expressed as @xmath161 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,\dots , k^{m}}^{\,[m : l ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{m+1 } = 0}^{k } \bar c_{k^{m+1 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{m+1 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,\dots , k^{m+1}}^{\,[m+1:l ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{m+1 } = 0}^{k } \bar c_{k^{m+1 } } \sin(\nu_{k^{m+1 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,\dots , k^{m+1}}^{\,[m+1:l+1 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar}\sum\limits_{h = 1}^{m - l}\cos(\nu_{k^h } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,\dots , k^{h-1},k^{h+1},\dots , k^{m}}^{\,[m-1:l ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar}\sum\limits_{h = m - l+1}^{{\color{red}{m}}}\sin(\nu_{k^h } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,\dots , k^{h-1},k^{h+1},\dots , k^{m}}^{\,[m-1:l-1 ] } ( \tau ) , \label{eq : imheom}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath162}(\tau)$ ] is the density operator defined in path integral form as @xmath163 } ( \phi _ 0^\dag , \phi ' _ 0 ; \tau ) & & = \int_{\bar \phi ( 0)=\phi'_0}^{\bar \phi ( \tau)=\phi_0 } d[\bar \phi ^{\dag}(\tau ) \bar \phi ( \tau ) ] \prod_{g=1}^{m - l } \left ( \int_0^{\tau } d\tau_g \cos(\nu_{k^g}\tau_g ) \bar v(\tau_g ) \right ) \nonumber \\ & & \times\prod_{g'=m - l+1}^{m } \left ( \int_0^{\tau } d\tau_{g ' } \sin(\nu_{k^{g'}}\tau_{g ' } ) \bar v(\tau_{g ' } ) \right ) \bar \rho[\bar \phi ^\dag , \bar \phi ; \tau ] . \label{eq : imheomelm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the first product in eq . contains @xmath164 factors , and the second contains @xmath165 factors . thus , the expression there is @xmath164th order in @xmath166 and @xmath165th order in @xmath167 . also , @xmath168 } ( \tau)$ ] and @xmath169 } ( \tau)$ ] in eq . denote the hierarchy elements defined by eq . without the index @xmath170 for @xmath171 . note that any exchange of suffixes @xmath172 and @xmath173 in eq . that merely results in the permutation of two cosine factors or two sine factors leaves the total integral unchanged , while one that results in the arguments of a sine and cosine being exchanged will generally cause the total integral to change . to truncate the hierarchy equations , we choose some large value of @xmath174 and set the elements at @xmath175th order to 0 . we thus obtain a closed set of equations up to @xmath176th order . to illustrate the structure of the hierarchy given in eq . , here we write out the equations up to second order . the hierarchy starts from the zeroth - order equation , which is that for the thermal equilibrium state density matrix : @xmath177 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}^{\,[0:0 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{1 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{1 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{1 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^{1}}^{\,[1:0 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{1 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{1 } } \sin(\nu_{k^{1 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \tau).\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , the first order consists of two equations , @xmath178 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1}^{\,[1:0 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar}\cos(\nu_{k^1 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}^{\,[0:0 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{2 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{2 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{2 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:0 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{2 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{2 } } \sin(\nu_{k^{2 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:1 ] } ( \tau),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath179 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar}\sin(\nu_{k^1 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}^{\,[0:0 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{2 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{2 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{2 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:1 ] } ( \tau)+ \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{2 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{2 } } \sin(\nu_{k^{2 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:2 ] } ( \tau),\end{aligned}\ ] ] and the second order consists of three equations , @xmath180 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:0 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \cos(\nu_{k^1 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^{2}}^{\,[1:0 ] } ( \tau)+ \frac{1}{\hbar } \cos(\nu_{k^2 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^{1}}^{\,[1:0 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{3 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{3 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{3 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^2,k^3}^{\,[3:0 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{3 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^3 } \sin(\nu_{k^{3 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^2,k^{3}}^{\,[3:1 ] } ( \tau),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath181 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:1 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \cos(\nu_{k^1 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^{2}}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sin(\nu_{k^2 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1}^{\,[1:0 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{3 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{3 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{3 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^2,k^3}^{\,[3:1 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar}\sum\limits_{k^{3 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^3 } \sin(\nu_{k^{3 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^2,k^{3}}^{\,[3:2 ] } ( \tau),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath182 } ( \tau ) & & = - \hat h_a \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^{2}}^{\,[2:2 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sin(\nu_{k^1 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^{2}}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \tau)+ \frac{1}{\hbar } \sin(\nu_{k^2 } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^{1}}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \tau ) \nonumber \\ & & + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{3 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^{3 } } \cos(\nu_{k^{3 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^2,k^3}^{\,[3:2 ] } ( \tau ) + \frac{1}{\hbar } \sum\limits_{k^{3 } = 0}^{k ' } \bar c_{k^3 } \sin(\nu_{k^{3 } } \tau ) \hat v \hat { \bar \rho}_{k^1,k^2,k^{3}}^{\,[3:3]}(\tau).\end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition , the initial conditions are set as @xmath183}(0)= \bf i$ ] , where @xmath184 is the unit operator , with all other hierarchy elements set to zero . the calculated elements @xmath162}(\beta \hbar)$ ] must be normalized after the integration over imaginary time is carried out by dividing by @xmath185}(\beta \hbar)\}$ ] . a significant difference between the real - time heom , given in eq . , and the above imaginary - time heom is that the former contain damping terms proportional to @xmath104 and @xmath186 , whereas the latter contain sinusoidal terms . the imaginary - time heom readily yield the desired quantities , as they are solved by integrating over the pre - determined interval from @xmath99 to @xmath187 , in contrast to the situation for the real - time heom , in which the integration must be carried out until convergence to the steady state is realized . any equilibrium expectation value of the system can be easily evaluated from @xmath183}(\beta \hbar)$ ] . moreover , we can evaluate the imaginary - time correlation functions@xcite from eq . in the same manner that the real - time correlation functions are evaluated from the real - time heom.@xcite the correlated initial states for the real - time heom can be constructed from the hierarchy elements of the imaginary - time heom . the relations between the real - time and imaginary - time heom elements are similar to the relations between the expectation value of the collective bath oscillator coordinate and the real - time heom elements.@xcite here , we present the relations between the two sets of elements up to second order in the system - bath interaction : @xmath188 } ( \beta\hbar ) , \label{eq : rho000}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath189 } ( \beta\hbar ) + \sum_{k=1}^{k ' } \left(\textcolor{red}{c_k''}\hat { \bar \rho}_{k}^{\,[1:0 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \textcolor{red}{+i c_k ' } \hat { \bar \rho}_{k}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \right ) \right ] , \label{eq : rho100}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath190 } ( \beta\hbar ) \textcolor{red}{-i c_k ' } \hat { \bar \rho}_{k}^{\,[1:1 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \right ) , \label{eq : rho0k0}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath191 } ( \beta\hbar ) + c_0''\sum_{k=1}^{k ' } \left(\textcolor{red}{c_k '' } \hat { \bar \rho}_{0k}^{\,[2:0 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \textcolor{red}{+i c_k'}\hat { \bar \rho}_{0k}^{\,[2:1 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \right ) \right . \nonumber \\ \left . + \sum_{k=1}^{k ' } \sum_{k'=1}^{k ' } \left(\textcolor{red}{c_k''c_{k ' } '' } \hat { \bar \rho}_{kk'}^{\,[2:0 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \textcolor{red}{+2i c_k''c_{k'}'}\hat { \bar \rho}_{kk'}^{\,[2:1]}(\beta\hbar ) \textcolor{red}{- c_{k } ' c_{k'}'}\hat { \bar \rho}_{kk'}^{\,[2:2]}(\beta\hbar ) \right ) \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath192 } ( \beta\hbar ) \textcolor{red}{-2 i c_k ' c_{k ' } ' } \hat { \bar \rho}_{k , k'}^{\,[2:1 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \right . \nonumber \\ & & \left . \textcolor{red}{- c_k ' c_{k'}'}\hat { \bar \rho}_{k , k'}^{\,[2:2 ] } ( \beta\hbar ) \right ) . \label{rho011}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the elements @xmath193 are obtained by setting @xmath194 in eq .. in practice , in order to evaluate the heom elements in the case of correlated initial conditions from the imaginary - time heom , the cutoff , @xmath195 , must be comparable to the cutoff of used for the real - time heom given in eq . , @xmath119 . if we only need the equilibrium distribution , eq . , however , we may choose @xmath195 even slightly smaller than @xmath196 . the equilibrium reduced density matrix has been evaluated from various approaches.@xcite equation allows us to calculate the same matrix elements using the reduced equation of motion approach . moreover , this approach allows us to evaluate the correlated initial conditions of the real - time heom . in this section , we report the results of numerical simulations that demonstrate the applicability and validity of the imaginary - time heom , given in eq . , for the system hamiltonian @xmath197 we chose the system parameters as @xmath198 and @xmath199 or @xmath200 , and the bath parameters as @xmath201 , @xmath202 , and @xmath203 for the system - bath interaction @xmath204 . we truncated the hierarchy by setting @xmath205 } ( \tau)=0 $ ] for @xmath206 in the imaginary - time heom , while we truncated by setting @xmath207 for @xmath208 with @xmath209 in the real - time heom . the 4th - order runge - kutta method was used for both the imaginary - time and real - time integrations with time steps of @xmath210 and @xmath211 , respectively . the real - time heom were integrated from the factorized initial conditions @xmath212 and @xmath213 at @xmath110 , and steady states were realized between @xmath214 and @xmath215 . first , we verified the accuracy of the imaginary - time heom by comparing the equilibrium state obtained from them with the steady state distributions obtained from the real - time heom for the temperatures @xmath216 , and @xmath217 with @xmath218 and @xmath219 . we found that the steady - state calculated from the real - time heom , @xmath220 , deviates from the equilibrium state calculated from the imaginary - time heom , @xmath221 } ( \beta\hbar)/ z_{a}$ ] by less than @xmath222 of difference at @xmath223 . the difference between the two results become larger for larger @xmath1 and for deeper hierarchy elements , because we solved the two kinds of heom using different truncation schemes . other than this difference , however , the imaginary - time heom results are consistent with the real - time heom results . this also indicates that the steady - state elements obtained from eq . indeed represent the correlated thermal equilibrium state defined by eq .. note that we must chose @xmath224 in order to accurately calculate the real - time heom elements for the correlated initial conditions from the imaginary - time heom . then , in order to obtain a better accuracy for deeper hierarchy elements in the imaginary - time heom , we used a small time step in the numerical integrations . for this reason , the computational costs for the real - time and imaginary - time heom were comparable . however , if we merely needed the equilibrium distribution @xmath221 } ( \beta \hbar)$ ] to one percent accuracy , we could use a smaller cuttoff @xmath225 and/or a larger time step for the imaginary - time heom and thereby reduce the computational costs to less than @xmath226 of that for the results reported here . .hierarchy elements calculated from the imaginary - time heom and real - time heom for several values of the inverse temperature , @xmath1 . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] although with the real - time heom , we can calculate only the probability distribution , with the imaginary - time heom we are able to calculate thermodynamic variables via the partition function of the reduced system , @xmath185}(\beta \hbar)\}$ ] . note that the total partition function can be expressed as @xmath227 , where the partition function of the bath is given by @xmath228 because we consider an infinite number of oscillators , however , the partition function of the bath can not be determined . for this reason , we consider the system part , @xmath229 , only . we calculated the helmholtz free energy , @xmath230 , the entropy , @xmath231 , the internal energy , @xmath232 , the heat capacity , @xmath233 , and the susceptibility , @xmath234 , from @xmath229 for several values of @xmath1 . to obtain these quantities , we numerically integrated the imaginary - time heom for fixed @xmath218 and @xmath199 to obtain @xmath229 for @xmath1 satisfying @xmath235 at steps of @xmath236 . for the susceptibility , we also calculated the free energy for @xmath237 in order to evaluate the derivative with respect to @xmath238 at @xmath239 . the quantities mentioned above obtained using the imaginary - time heom are compared in fig . 1 with the corresponding quantities for a system characterized by the canonical distribution , @xmath240\}$ ] , with the same hamiltonian @xmath2 ( with @xmath199 ) and inverse temperature @xmath1 . this corresponds to the partition function of the system in the case that the total partition function takes the factorized form @xmath241\ } tr_b\ { \exp[-\beta \hat h_b]\}$ ] . the thermodynamic quantities are then given by @xmath242 , @xmath243 , @xmath244 , @xmath245 - @xmath246 $ ] , and @xmath247 . also , note that the susceptibility for finite @xmath238 is expressed as @xmath248/2 $ ] . the superscript `` 0 '' on these quantities indicates that these are calculated using the conventional statistical physics approach , which is equivalent to assuming a factorized thermal equilibrium state . as seen in fig . 2 , in both cases of the spin - boson and factorized spin system , the entropy and internal energy decrease with the inverse temperature , while the heat capacities of both systems exhibit maxima at inverse temperatures near @xmath249 , where the thermal excitation energy becomes comparable to the excitation energy . the entropy in the spin - boson case is larger than that in the factorized case at lower temperatures because the spin - boson system involves more degrees of freedom , due to the presence of the system - bath interaction . it is also seen that the internal energy is systematically lower in the spin - boson case than in the factorized case . this indicates that the bath absorbs some of the system energy through the interaction . the degree to which the system energy is absorbed by the bath increases as @xmath1 approaches the thermal excitation energy of the system and , as a result , the heat capacity of the spin - boson system becomes smaller than that of the factorized spin system near the peak position at @xmath249 . compared with the other thermodynamic variables , the difference between the susceptibilities in the two cases is small . this is because the system - bath interaction has the same form as the magnetic excitation , and the effects of @xmath238 are suppressed by the strong system - bath interaction . it is important to note here that those states regarded as the thermal equilibrium states in the two cases compared above are different . in the conventional treatment , the thermal equilibrium state of the system corresponds to the case of a factorized partition function , while in the present treatment of the spin - boson system , we consider the thermal equilibrium state of the total system . although the difference between the equilibrium thermodynamic quantities for the spin - boson system and the factorized spin system are rather minor in the static case considered in fig . 2 , the difference becomes significant when we study the dynamics of the system , because in this case , the positivity condition is often violated in the conventional treatment . this may indicate that treatments based on the canonical distribution are inherently incompatible with dynamical states . by utilizing the hierarchy elements , we can calculate expectation values of the system and bath . for example , the expectation value of the system energy , @xmath250 , is obtained from eq . as @xmath251 using the first element of the hierarchy , the expectation value of the system - bath interaction , @xmath252\}$ ] , is evaluated as @xmath253 where @xmath254 and @xmath255 are obtained from eqs . and , respectively . in fig . 2 , we present the expectation values @xmath250 and @xmath256 and the internal energy of the system , @xmath257 , as obtained by numerically integrating eq . for various coupling strengths , @xmath105 , at @xmath258 and @xmath259 , with a step size of @xmath260 . at those temperatures , the system part of the energy increases linearly , while the interaction part decreases linearly as a function of the coupling strength , @xmath105 , but the rates of decrease and increase are smaller for lower temperatures , because the thermal activity of the bath is lower in this regime . we should mention that the internal energy , @xmath257 , contains the system part of the interaction energy but not the bath part . the system part and bath part of the interaction energies are calculated as @xmath261 and @xmath262 , respectively . the internal energy decreases as a function of @xmath105 because the system part of the interaction energy also decreases as a function of @xmath105 . both the bath and system parts of the interaction energy decrease as function of @xmath105 , but the bath part of the contribution is much larger than the system part , because the bath contains many degrees of freedom . in this paper , we derived the real - time and imaginary - time heom starting from the influence functional formalism with a correlated thermal initial state . it was shown that the thermal equilibrium state calculated from the imaginary - time heom is equivalent to the steady state solution of the real - time heom . because the imaginary - time heom is defined in terms of integrals carried out over the definite time interval from @xmath263 to @xmath264 and because the elements of the imaginary - time heom are real , we were able to calculate the hierarchy elements more easily in this case than in the case of the real - time heom . moreover , using the imaginary - time heom , we were able to calculate the partition function , and from this , we could directly obtain several thermodynamic quantities , namely , the free energy , entropy , internal energy , heat capacity , and susceptibility of the system in the dissipative environment . the expectation values of not only the system energy but also the system - bath interaction energy were also evaluated from the hierarchy elements obtained from the real- and imaginary - time heom . we found that for the purpose of studying equilibrium properties , rather than dynamical behavior , the imaginary - time heom is more usueful than the real - time heom . in this paper , we derived the heom for a system in the energy eigenstate representation , but extension to a system in the coordinate space representation ( or the wigner representation ) is straightforward.@xcite this extension will be helpful for identifying the pure quantum effects , because we can compare the quantum results with the classical results obtained from the classical limit of the imaginary - time heom.@xcite the author is grateful to professor hermann grabert , professor gerhard stock , professor heinz - peter breuer , and dr . lothar mchenber and their group members at the freiburg institute for advanced studies for their hospitality . financial support from the humboldt foundation , the university of freiburg , and a grant - in - aid for scientific research ( a26248005 ) from the japan society for the promotion of science are acknowledged . because the extension to a many oscillator system is straightforward , we start from a single oscillator bath , described by the hamiltonian @xmath265 we then consider the density matrix elements with the three source terms @xmath266 , @xmath267 , and @xmath268 defined by@xcite @xmath269 e^ { \frac{i}{\hbar}\int_0^{t } d\tau \left[\frac12{m \dot { x}^2}- \frac12 m \omega^2 x^2 + v(\tau ) x \right ] } \nonumber \\ & & \times \int _ { \bar x(0)=x_0'}^{\bar x(\beta \hbar)=x_0 } d[\bar x(\tau ' ) ] e^{-\frac1{\hbar } \int_0^{\beta \hbar } d\tau ' \left[\frac12{m \dot { \bar x}^2}+ \frac12 m \omega^2 \bar x^2 - { \bar v}(\tau ' ) \bar x \right ] } \nonumber \\ & & \times \int_{x'(0)=x_0'}^{x'(t)=x ' } d[x'(\tau ) ] e^{- \frac{i}{\hbar}\int_0^{t } d\tau \left[\frac12{m { \dot x}'^2}- \frac12 m \omega^2 x'^2 + v'(\tau)x ' \right ] } . \label{eq : gv}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to evaluate @xmath270 , we start from the feynman propagator for eq . , expressed as @xmath271 e^ { \frac{i}{\hbar}\int_0^{t } d\tau \left[\frac12{m \dot { x}^2}- \frac12 m \omega^2 x^2 + v(\tau ) x \right ] } \nonumber \\ & & = \sqrt { \frac{m \omega}{2 \pi i \hbar \sin ( \omega t ) } } e^{\frac{i}{\hbar}s(x , x_0;t;v ) } , \label{eq : green}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath272 . \label{eq : s_harm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the equilibrium distribution , @xmath273 , is obtained from eq . by replacing @xmath274 with @xmath275 . this yields @xmath276 e^{-\frac1{\hbar } \int_0^{\beta \hbar } d\tau ' \left[\frac12{m \dot { \bar x}^2}+ \frac12 m \omega^2 \bar x^2 - { \bar v}(\tau ' ) \bar x \right ] } \nonumber \\ & & = \frac1{2\sinh\left(\frac{\beta \hbar \omega}2 \right ) } \sqrt{\frac1{2 \pi \langle x^2\rangle } } \exp \left [ - \frac1{2 \langle x^2 \rangle } \left ( \frac{x+x'}{2 } - \bar r[{\bar v } ; \beta \hbar ] \right)^2 \right . \nonumber \\ & & - \left . \frac1{2\hbar^2 } \langle p^2 \rangle ( x - x')^2 + \frac{i}{\hbar } \bar p[{\bar v } ; \beta \hbar ] ( x - x ' ) + { \bar \phi}[{\bar v } ; \beta \hbar ] \right ] , \label{eq : rhoqqt}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath277 @xmath278 @xmath279 = \frac{1}{\hbar } \int_{0}^{\beta\hbar } d \tau ' { \bar v } ( \tau ' ) \bar l ( \tau ' ) , \label{eq:<barr>}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath280 = \frac{i m } { \hbar } \int_{0}^{\beta\hbar } d \tau ' { \bar v } ( \tau ' ) \dot { \bar l } ( \tau ' ) , % \left[\coth \left(\frac{\beta \hbar\omega}2 \right ) \sinh \omega \tau + \cosh \omega \tau \right ] \label{eq:<barp>}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath281 = \frac1{\hbar^2 } \int_{0}^{\beta\hbar } d \tau '' \int_{0}^{\tau '' } d \tau ' { \bar v } ( \tau '' ) { \bar v } ( \tau ' ) \bar l ( \tau '' - \tau ' ) . \label{eq : phita2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we have @xmath282 . % & & = \frac{\hbar}{2m\omega } \frac{\cosh\left ( \frac{\beta \hbar\omega}2 - \omega \tau ' \right ) } { \sinh\left ( \frac{\beta \hbar\omega}2 \right)}. \label{eq : p1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the partition function for the oscillator itself , @xmath283 , can be obtained from eq . as @xmath284 using the counter path , we can express the total density matrix , eq . , as@xcite @xmath285 e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar } \int_c ds \left [ \frac12{m \dot { \tilde x}^2(s)}- \frac12 m \omega^2\tilde x^2(s ) + \tilde v_c(s)\tilde x(s ) \right ] } , \label{eq : gj33}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath286\equiv \int d[x(\tau ) ] \int d[\bar x(\tau ' ) ] \int d[x'(\tau)]$ ] and the contour paths are defined by eqs . and . we can obtain the full density matrix elements by simply replacing the integral @xmath287 in eqs.- with the contour integral @xmath288 . in the wigner representation , we have the distribution @xmath289 after the normalization , this can be expressed as@xcite @xmath290 \right)^2 - \frac1{2 \langle p^2\rangle } ( p-\tilde p[\tilde v_c ; t , \beta\hbar])^2 + { \tilde \phi}[\tilde v_c ; t , \beta\hbar ] \right ] , \label{eq : wignerh}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath291 = -\frac{i}{\hbar } \int_{c } ds ' \tilde v_c(s ' ) l(s'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath292 = \frac{i m}{\hbar } \int_{c } ds ' \tilde v_c(s ' ) { \dot l}(s'),\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath293 & = & - \frac1{\hbar^2 } % \frac1{2 m \hbar \omega } \int_{c } ds '' \int_{c ' } ds ' \tilde v_c ( s '' ) \tilde v_{c ' } ( s ' ) l(s''- s ' ) . % \nonumber \\ & \times & % \left [ \coth\left ( \frac{\beta \hbar\omega}2 \right ) % \cos\left(\omega(s - s')\right ) % + i \sin \left(\omega ( s - s')\right ) \right ] . \label{eq : p2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath294 is the analytically continued matsubara green function obtained from eq . through the replacement @xmath295 , given by @xmath296 and @xmath65 represents the counter path for @xmath66 that follows @xmath67 along @xmath68 under the condition @xmath69 . for the bath hamiltonian appearing in eq . with the interaction @xmath297 , eq . is expressed as eq .. by tracing out @xmath298 and @xmath299 , we obtain the influence functional for correlated initial conditions , @xmath63=\exp\left\{{\tilde \phi}[\tilde v_c ; t , \beta\hbar]\right\}$ ] . 20 a. o. caldeira and a. j. leggett , physica * 121a * , 587 ( 1983 ) . a. j. leggett , s. chakravarty , a. t. dorsey , m. p. a. fisher , a. garg , and z. zwerger , rev . phys . * 59 * , 1 ( 1987 ) . u. weiss , _ quantum dissipative systems _ ( world scientific , singapore , 2008 ) 3rd ed . r. kubo , m. toda and n. hashitsume , _ statistical physics _ ( springer - verlag , 1985 ) vol . * 2*. a. g. redfield , adv . . reson . * 1 * , 1 ( 1965 ) . r. kubo , adv . 15 * , 101 ( 1969 ) . s. mukamel , _ principles of nonlinear optical spectroscopy _ ( oxford university press , new york , 1995 ) . p. hanggi , p. talkner and m. borkovec , rev . phys . * 62 * , 252 ( 1990 ) . r. a. marcus , rev . phys . * 65 * , 599 ( 1993 ) . v. may and o. khn , _ charge and energy transfer dynamics in molecular systems _ ( wiley - vch , berlin , 2003 ) . h. p. breuer and f. petruccione , _ the theory of open quantum systems _ ( oxford university press , new york , 2002 ) . e. b. davies , _ quantum theory of open systems _ ( academic press , 1976 ) . v. gorini , a. frigerio , m. verri , a. kossakowski , and e. c. g. sudarshan , rep . math . phys . * 13 * , 149 ( 1978 ) . h. spohn , rev . phys . * 52 * , 569 ( 1980 ) . p. pechukas , phys . lett . * 73 * , 1060 ( 1994 ) . k. f. f. romero , p. talkner and p. hanggi , phys . rev . * 69 * , 052109 ( 2004 ) . a. frigerio , j. t. lewis and j. v. pul , adv . appl . math . * 2 * , 456 ( 1981 ) . a. frigerio , j. t. lewis and j. v. pul , j. approx . theor . * 45 * , 310 ( 1985 ) . y. tanimura , j. phys . jpn . * 75 * , 082001 ( 2006 ) . r. egger and c. h. mak , phys . rev . b*50 * , 15210 ( 1994 ) . n. makri , j. math . phys . * 36 * , 2430 ( 1995 ) . j. cao , l. w. ungar and g.a . voth , j. chem . phys * 104 * , 4189 ( 1996 ) . n. makri and d. e. makarov , j. chem . * 102 * , 4600 ( 1995 ) ; * 102 * , 4611 ( 1995 ) . m. thorwart , p. reimann and p. hnggi , phys . e * 62 * , 5808 ( 2000 ) . e. bukhman and n. makri , j. phys . a * 111 * , 11320 ( 2007 ) . v. jadhao and n. makri , j. chem . phys . * 129 * , 161102(2008 ) . y. tanimura , phys . * a41 * , 6676 ( 1990 ) . a. ishizaki and y. tanimura , j. phys . . jpn . * 74 * , 3131 ( 2005 ) . r. x. xu , p. cui , x. q. li , y. mo , and y. j. yan , j. chem . phys . * 122 * , 041103 ( 2005 ) . p. han , r. x. xu , b. li , j. xu , p. cui , y. mo and y. j. yan , j. phys . chem . b * 110 * , 11438 ( 2006 ) . y. tanimura and s. mukamel , j. phys . soc . jpn . * 63 * , 66 ( 1994 ) . m. tanaka and y.tanimura , j. phys . . jpn . * 78 * , 073802 ( 2009 ) . m. tanaka and y.tanimura , j. chem . phys . * 132 * , 214502 ( 2010 ) . y. tanimura , j. chem . phys . * 137 * , 22a550 ( 2012 ) . c. kreisbeck and t. kramer , j. phys . lett . * 3 * , 2828 ( 2012 ) . j. ma , z. sun , x. wang , and f. nori , phys . rev . a * 85 * , 062323 ( 2012 ) . ding , r .- x . xu , y .- j . yang , j. chem . phys . * 136 * , 224103 ( 2012 ) . h. liu , l. zhu , s. bai , and q. shi , j. chem . phys . * 140 * , 134106 ( 2014 ) . y. tanimura and r. kubo , j. phys . . jpn . * 58 * , 1199 ( 1989 ) . y. tanimura , t. suzuki and r. kubo , j. phys . * 58 * , 1850 ( 1989 ) . y. tanimura and y. maruyama , j. chem . phys . * 107 * , 1779 ( 1997 ) . t. kato and y. tanimura , j. chem . phys . * 120 * , 260 ( 2004 ) . a. ishizaki and y. tanimura , j. chem . phys . * 125 * , 084501 ( 2006 ) . a. ishizaki and y. tanimura , j. phys . a * 111 * , 9269 ( 2007 ) . a. sakurai and y. tanimura , j. phys . a * 115 * , 4009 ( 2011 ) . a. g. dijkstra and y. tanimura , new j. phys . * 12 * , 055005 ( 2010 ) . l. chen , r. zheng , q. shi and y .- j . yan , j. chem . phys . * 132 * , 024505 ( 2010 ) . l. chen , r. zheng , y. jing , q. shi , j. chem . phys . * 134 * , 194508 ( 2011 ) . b. hein , c. kreisbeck , t. kramer , and m. rodriguez , new j. phys . * 14 * , 023018 ( 2012 ) . c. kreisbeck , t. kramer and a. aspuru - guzik , j. phys . b , * 117 * , 9380 ( 2013 ) . h .- breuer , e .- laine , and j. piilo , phys . rev . lett . * 103 * , 210401 ( 2009 ) . a. g. dijkstra and y. tanimura , phys . lett . * 104 * , 250401 ( 2010 ) . a. g. dijkstra and y. tanimura , phil . a * 370 * , 3658 ( 2012 ) . a. g. dijkstra and y. tanimura , j. phys . * 81 * , 063301 ( 2012 ) . q. shi , l. p. chen , g. j. nan , r .- x . yan , j. phys . chem . * 130 * , 084105 ( 2009 ) . j. hu , r .- x . yan , j. chem . 133 * , 101106 ( 2010 ) . b. l. tian , j. j. ding , r .- x . yan , j. chem . phys . * 133 * , 114112 ( 2010 ) . j. zhu , s. kais , p. rebentros , a. aspuru - guzik , j. phys . b * 115 * , 1531 ( 2011 ) . c. kreisbeck , t. kramer , m. rodriguez , b. hein , j. chem . theor . comp . * 7 * , 2166 ( 2011 ) . j. strmpfer , k. schulten , j. chem . theor . comp . * 8 * , 2808 ( 2012 ) . j. m. moix and j. cao , j. chem . phys . * 139 * , 134106 ( 2013 ) . l. zhu , h. liu , and q. shi , n. j. phys . * 15 * , 095020 ( 2013 ) . a. ishizaki and g. r. fleming , proc . 106 * , 17255 ( 2009 ) . j. strmpfer , k. schulten , j. chem . phys . * 131 * , 225101 ( 2009 ) . j. strmpfer and k. schulten , j. chem . 134 * , 095102 ( 2011 ) . a. g. dijkstra and y. tanimura , new j. phys . * 14 * , 073027 ( 2012 ) . j. s. jin , s. welack , j. luo , x - q li , p. cui , r .- x . xu and y.j . yan , j. chem . phys . * 126 * , 134113 ( 2007 ) . j. s. jin , x. zheng , and y. j. yan , j. chem . * 128 * , 234703 ( 2008 ) . x. zheng , j. jin , s. welack , m. luo , and y- . j. chem . phys . * 130 * , 164708 ( 2009 ) . a. kato and y. tanimura , j. phys . b , * 117*,13132 ( 2013 ) . a. sakurai and y. tanimura , j. phys . jpn , * 82 * , 033707 ( 2013 ) . a. sakurai and y. tanimura , new j. phys . * 16 * , 015002 ( 2014 ) . y. yao , w. yang , y. zhao , j. chem . 140 * , 104113 ( 2014 ) . y. tanimura and s. mukamel , phys . e * 47 * , 118 ( 1993 ) . k. okumura and y. tanimura , phys . e * 53 * , 214 ( 1996).y . tanimura and k. okumura , j. chem . phys . * 106 * , 2078 ( 1997).y . suzuki and y. tanimura , phys . e * 59 * , 1475 ( 1999 ) . j. cao and g. a. voth , j. chem . phys . * 100 * , 5093 ( 1994 ) l. zhu , h. liu , w. xie and q. shi , j. chem . phys . * 137 * , 194106 ( 2012 ) . j. m. moix , y. zhao , and j. cao , phys . b*85 * , 115412 ( 2012 ) . c. k. lee , j. moix , and j. cao , j. chem phys . * 136 * , 204120 ( 2012 ) . y. tanimura and p. g. wolynes , rev . a*43 * , 4131 ( 1991 ) . y. tanimura and p. g. wolynes , j. chem . phys . * 96 * , 8485 ( 1992 ) . t. steffen and y. tanimura , j. phys . 69 * , 3115 ( 2000 ) . y. tanimura and t. steffen , j. phys . * 69 * , 4095 ( 2000 ) .
Abstract: | [
"for a system strongly coupled to a heat bath , the quantum coherence of the system and the heat bath plays an important role in the system dynamics . this is particularly true in the case of non - markovian noise . we rigorously investigate the influence of system - bath coherence by deriving the reduced hierarchal equations of motion ( heom ) , not only in real time , but also in imaginary time , which represents an inverse temperature . it is shown that the heom in real time obtained when we include the system - bath coherence of the initial thermal equilibrium state possess the same form as those obtained from a factorized initial state . we find that the difference in behavior of systems treated in these two manners results from the difference in initial conditions of the heom elements , which are defined in path integral form . we also derive heom along the imaginary time path to obtain the thermal equilibrium state of a system strongly coupled to a non - markovian bath . then , we show that the steady state hierarchy elements calculated from the real - time heom can be expressed in terms of the hierarchy elements calculated from the imaginary - time heom . moreover , we find that the imaginary - time heom allow us to evaluate a number of thermodynamic variables , including the free energy , entropy , internal energy , heat capacity , and susceptibility . the expectation values of the system energy and system - bath interaction energy in the thermal equilibrium state are also evaluated ."
] | 10,977 | 10,977 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: neutrons stars are born in gravitational collapse of massive , degenerate stellar cores . newly born neutron stars are hot and lepton rich objects , quite different from ordinary low temperature , lepton poor neutron stars . in view of these differences , newly born neutron stars are called _ protoneutron _ stars ; they transform into standard neutron stars on a timescale of the order of ten seconds , needed for the loss of a significant lepton number excess via emission of neutrinos trapped in the dense , hot interior . in view of the fact that the typical evolution timescale of a protoneutron star ( seconds ) is some three orders of magnitude longer , than the dynamical timescale for this objects ( milliseconds ) , one can study its evolution in the quasistatic approximation ( burrows & lattimer 1986 ) . properties of static ( non - rotating ) protoneutron stars , under various assumptions concerning composition and equation of state ( eos ) of hot , dense stellar interior were studied by numerous authors ( burrows & lattimer 1986 , takatsuka 1995 , bombaci et al . 1995 , bombaci 1996 , bombaci et al . 1996 ) . the scenario of transformation of a protoneutron star into a neutron star could be strongly influenced by a phase transition in the central region of the star . brown and bethe ( 1994 ) suggested a phase transition implied by the @xmath0 condensation at supranuclear densities . such a @xmath0 condensation could dramatically soften the equation of state of dense matter , leading to a low maximum allowable mass of neutron stars . in such a case , the massive protoneutron stars could be stabilized by the effects of high temperature and of the presence of trapped neutrinos , and this would lead to maximum baryon mass of protoneutron star larger by some @xmath1 than that of cold neutron stars . the deleptonization and cooling of protoneutron stars of baryon mass exceeding the maximum allowable baryon mass for neutron stars , would then inevitably lead to their collapse into black holes . the dynamics of such a process was recently studied by baumgarte et al . it should be mentioned , however , that the very possibility of existence of the kaon condensate ( or other exotic phases of matter , such as the pion condensate , or the quark matter ) at neutron star densities is far from being established . recently , for instance , pandharipande et al . ( 1995 ) pointed out that kaon - nucleon and nucleon - nucleon correlations in dense matter raise significantly the threshold density for kaon condensation , possibly to the densities higher than those characteristic of stable neutron stars . in view of these uncertainties , we will restrict in the present paper to a standard model of dense matter , composed of nucleons and leptons . the calculations of the static models of protoneutron stars should be considered as a first step in the studies of these objects . it is clear , in view of the dynamical scenario of their formation , that protoneutron stars are far from being static . due to the nonzero initial angular momentum of the collapsing core , protoneutron stars are expected to rotate . on the other hand , the formation scenario involves compression ( with overshoot of central density ) and a hydrodynamical bounce , so that a newborn protoneutron star begins its life in a highly excited state , pulsating around its quasistatic equilibrium . in the present paper we study the rotation of protoneutron stars ; pulsations of protoneutron stars will be discussed in a separate paper ( gondek , haensel & zdunik , in preparation ) . some aspects of rapid uniform rotation of protoneutron stars have been recently studied in ( takatsuka 1995 , hashimoto et al . however , the calculations reported by takatsuka ( 1995 ) were actually done for static ( non - rotating ) protoneutron stars , and were then used to estimate the maximum rotation frequency of uniformly rotating protoneutron stars , @xmath2 , via an `` empirical formula '' . it should be stressed , that the validity of such an `` empirical formula '' , which expresses @xmath3 in terms of the mass and radius of the extremal _ static _ configuration with maximum allowable mass , had been checked only in the restricted case of _ cold _ neutron stars ( haensel & zdunik 1989 , friedman et al . 1989 , shapiro et al . 1989 , haensel et al . 1995 , nozawa et al . . only isentropic equations of state were considered by takatsuka ( 1995 ) . hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) calculated the structure of stationary configurations of uniformly rotating protoneutron stars , using a two - dimensional general relativistic code . these authors restricted themselves to the case with zero trapped lepton number . they assumed a constant temperature in the hot interior of the star , and used a zero temperature ( cold ) eos for @xmath4 . it should be stressed , that the assumption of @xmath5 corresponds to an isothermal state in the newtonian ( flat space - time ) theory of gravitation . in general relativity , we will define isothermal state by @xmath6 ( where @xmath7 is the lapse function and @xmath8 is the lorentz factor , see section 3.1 ) , and the effects of the space - time curvature will turn out to be rather important for massive neutron stars . also , their choice for the low density edge of the hot interior can be questioned . finally , their criterion for finding maximally rotating configuration is actually valid only for cold ( @xmath9 ) or isentropic protoneutron stars : its use in the case of the @xmath5 hot interior is unjustified ( see section 3.2 for a correct statement of the stability criterion ) . in a recent paper , lai and shapiro ( 1995 ) have studied the secular evolution , secular `` bar instability '' , and the gravitational wave emission from the newly formed , rapidly rotating neutron stars . however , these authors used unrealistic ( polytropic ) equations of state of neutron star matter . moreover , the calculations were done within newtonian theory of gravitation . in view of this , the internal structure of their models of newly born neutron stars was quite different from that characteristic of the realistic models of protoneutron stars . the problem of the secular `` bar instability '' in rapidly rotating neutron stars was also studied , using general relativity , by bonazzola et al ( 1995 ) . however , numerical calculations were done only for realistic equations of state of _ cold _ neutron star matter . in the present paper we study the properties of uniformly rotating protoneutron stars , using exact relativistic description of the rapid , stationary rotation , combined with realistic equations of state of hot dense matter , used in the whole range of temperatures and densities relevant for protoneutron stars . in particular , we calculate the maximum frequency of uniform rotation of protoneutron stars and its dependence on their baryon mass , and on the thermal state and composition of stellar interior . it is clear , that uniform rotation represents only an approximation to the actual rotational state of a newly born protoneutron star . existing numerical simulations of gravitational collapse of rotating cores of massive stars produce differentially rotating protoneutron stars ( janka & moenchmeyer 1989a , b , moenchmeyer & mueller 1989 ) . however , it should be stressed that the initial rotational state of collapsing core is unknown , and this implies uncertainty concerning the rotational state of resulting protoneutron star . it is reasonable to say , that the actual degree of nonuniformity of rotation of a protoneutron star should be considered as unknown . in the present paper we will not address the question of the physical mechanisms that could `` rigidify '' the rotational motion within the protoneutron star interior . however , we will use the approximation of uniform rotation in order to limit the number the parameter space for our numerical calculation , and also because of the relative simplicity of the stability analysis in this specific , idealized case . within our simplified model , the `` neutrinosphere '' ( which has actually a deformed , spheroidal shape ) will separate hot , neutrino - opaque interior of a protoneutron star ( hereafter referred to as `` hot interior '' ) from a significantly cooler , neutrino - transparent envelope . the actual thermal state of the hot interior of protoneutron star is determined by its formation scenario , and is expected to be influenced by the dissipative processes ( damping of pulsations , viscous damping of differential rotation , neutrino diffusion ) . for simplicity , we will restrict ourselves to two limiting cases : an isothermal ( @xmath6 , see section 3 ) , and an isentropic ( entropy per baryon @xmath10 ) hot interior . we will also consider two limiting cases of the lepton composition of the protoneutron star interior . the first case , referring to the very initial state of protoneutron star , will correspond to a fixed trapped lepton number . in the second case , neutrinos will not contribute to the lepton number of the matter , which will correspond to vanishing chemical potential of the electron neutrinos ; such a situation will take place after a deleptonization of a protononeutron star . the position of the neutrinosphere will be located using a simple prescription based on specific properties of the neutrino opacity of hot dense matter . in all cases , the equation of state of hot dense matter will be determined using one of the models of lattimer and swesty ( 1991 ) . the plan of the paper is as follows . in section 2 we describe the physical state of the interior of protoneutron star , with particular emphasis on the eos of the hot interior at various stages of evolution . we explain also our prescription for locating the `` neutrinosphere '' of a protoneutron star , and we give some details concerning the assumed temperature profile within a protoneutron star . using simple estimates of the timescales relevant for various transport processes , we justify the approximation of stationarity which is used throughout this paper . in section 3 we give a brief description of the exact equations , used for the calculation of stationary configuration of uniformly rotating protoneutron stars . we discuss also stability of rotating configurations with respect to the axially - symmetric perturbations . the numerical method , used for the calculation of rapidly rotating configurations of protoneutron star , is briefly described in section 4 , where we also discuss numerical precision of our solutions . maximum rotation frequency , for various physical conditions prevailing in the hot stellar interior , calculated as a function of the baryon ( rest ) mass of protoneutron star , is presented in section 5 . then , in section 6 we show the validity of an empirical formula , which enables one to express with a surprisingly high precision the maximum frequency of rotating protoneutron stars in terms of the mass and radius of the maximum mass configuration of static ( non - rotating ) protoneutron stars with same eos . in section 7 we study the evolutionary transformation of a rotating protoneutron star into a cold neutron star . we show that , at fixed rest mass and angular momentum , maximum rotation frequency of protoneutron stars imposes severe constraints on the rotation frequency of solitary neutron stars . finally , section 8 contains discussion of our results and conclusion . we consider a protoneutron star ( pns ) just after its formation . we assume it has a well defined `` neutrinosphere '' , which separates a hot , neutrino - opaque interior from colder , neutrino - transparent outer envelope . important parameters , which determine the local state of the matter in the hot interior are : baryon ( nucleon ) number density @xmath11 , net electron fraction @xmath12 , and the net electron - neutrino fraction @xmath13 . the calculation of the composition of hot matter and of its eos is described below . such a situation is characteristic of the very initial stage of existence of a pns . matter is composed of nucleons ( both free and bound in nuclei ) and leptons ( electrons and neutrinos ; for simplicity , we do not include muons ) . all constituents of the matter ( plus photons ) are in thermodynamic equilibrium at given values of @xmath11 , @xmath14 and @xmath15 . the composition of the matter is calculated from the condition of beta equilibrium , combined with the condition of a fixed @xmath16 , @xmath17 where @xmath18 are the chemical potentials of matter constituents . at the very initial stage we expect @xmath19 . electron neutrinos are degenerate , with @xmath20 ( in what follows we measure @xmath14 in energy units ) . the deleptonization , implying the decrease of @xmath16 , occurs due to diffusion of neutrinos outward ( driven by the @xmath21 gradient ) , on a timescale of seconds ( sawyer & soni 1979 , bombaci et al . the diffusion of highly degenerate neutrinos from the central core is a dissipative process , resulting in a significant _ heating _ of the neutrino - opaque core ( burrows & lattimer 1986 ) . this is the limiting case , reached after complete deleptonization . there is no trapped lepton number , so that @xmath23 and @xmath24 , and therefore @xmath25 . neutrinos trapped within the hot interior do not influence the beta equilibrium of nucleons , electrons and positrons , and for given @xmath11 and @xmath14 the equilibrium value of @xmath26 is determined from @xmath27 while @xmath28 . in practice , this approximation can be used as soon as electron neutrinos become non - degenerate within the opaque core , @xmath29 , which occurs after some @xmath30 seconds ( sawyer & soni 1979 , bombaci et al . the neutrino diffusion is then driven by the temperature gradient , and the corresponding timescale of the heat transport ( pns cooling ) can be estimated as @xmath31 s ( sawyer & soni 1979 ) . in principle , the temperature ( or entropy per nucleon ) profile within a pns has to be determined via evolutionary calculation , starting from some initial state , and taking into account relevant transport processes in the pns interior , as well as neutrino emission from pns . transport processes within neutrino - opaque interior occur on timescales of seconds , some three orders of magnitude longer than dynamical timescales . the very outer layer of pns becomes rapidly transparent to neutrinos , deleptonizes , and cools on a very short timescale via @xmath32 pair annihilation and plasmon decay . it seemed thus natural to model the thermal structure of the pns interior by a hot core limited by a `` neutrinosphere '' , and an outer envelope of @xmath33 mev . the transition through the `` neutrinosphere '' is accompanied by a temperature drop , which takes place over some interval of density just above the `` edge''of the hot neutrino - opaque core , situated at some @xmath34 . in view of the uncertainties in the actual temperature profiles within the hot interior of pns , we considered two extremal situations for @xmath35 , corresponding to an isentropic and an isothermal hot interior . in the first case , hot interior was characterized by a constant entropy per baryon @xmath10 . in the case of trapped lepton number , this leads to the eos of the type : pressure @xmath36)$ ] , energy density @xmath37)$ ] , and temperature @xmath38)$ ] , with fixed @xmath39 and @xmath16 . this eos will be denoted by eos[@xmath40 . in the case of an isentropic , zero trapped lepton number eos , we will have eos[@xmath41 . the condition of isothermality , which corresponds to thermal equilibrium , is more complicated . due to the curvature of the space - time within pns , the condition of isothermality corresponds to the constancy of @xmath42 ( see section 3.1 ) . the significance of the @xmath43 condition will be discussed in section 3.1 . in the static case , the isothermal state within the hot interior will be reached on a timescale corresponding to thermal equilibration , which is much longer than the lifetime of a pns . in the case of a rotating pns , the situation can be expected to be even more complicated ( see , e.g. , chapter 8 of tassoul ( 1978 ) ) . nevertheless , we considered the @xmath43 models for several reasons . first , as a limiting case so different from the @xmath10 one , it enables us to check the dependence of our results for rapidly rotating pns on the thermal state of the hot interior . moreover , for the isothermal pns we can apply the criterion of stability with respect to the axi - symmetric perturbations , and this will enable us to calculate the value of @xmath3 for the stable supramassive rotating pns models with an isothermal interior ( see section 3 ) . our calculation of the `` neutrinosphere '' within the hot pns interior was done using a simple method , described below . for a given pns model , the neutrinosphere radius , @xmath44 , has been located through the condition @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the neutrino mean free path which is calculated at the matter temperature @xmath14 , while @xmath47 is the mean energy of non - degenerate neutrinos at ( and above ) the neutrinosphere , @xmath48 . we assumed that opacity above @xmath44 is dominated by the elastic scattering off nuclei and nucleons , so that @xmath49 . then , we determined the value of the density at the neutrinosphere , @xmath34 , for a given static pns model , combining eq . ( [ r_nu ] ) with that of hydrostatic equilibrium , and readjusting accordingly the temperature profile within the outer layers of pns . this value of @xmath34 was then used in the calculations of rotating pns models . let us notice , that similar approximation , in which the `` neutrinosphere '' in rapidly rotating protoneutron star was defined as a surface of constant density , was used by janka and moenchmeyer ( 1989a , b ) . some details concerning actual calculation of the temperature profile in the vicinity of the `` neutrinosphere '' will be given in subsection 3.3 . the starting point for the construction of our eos for the pns models was the model of hot dense matter of lattimer and swesty ( 1991 ) , hereafter referred to as ls . actually , we used one specific ls model , corresponding to the incompressibility modulus at the saturation density of symmetric nuclear matter @xmath50mev . for @xmath35 we supplemented the ls model with contributions resulting from the presence of trapped neutrinos of three flavours ( electronic , muonic and tauonic ) and of the corresponding antineutrinos . in fig . 1a , b we show our eos in several cases , corresponding to various physical conditions in the hot , neutrino - opaque interior of pns . for the sake of comparison , we have shown also the eos for cold catalyzed matter , used for the calculation of the ( cold ) ns models . in fig . 1a we show eos at subnuclear densities . at these densities , both the temperature and the presence of trapped neutrinos stiffen the eos , as compared to the cold catalyzed matter one , and the stiffening is rather dramatic . the constant @xmath14 eos stiffens considerably at lower densities , which is due to the weak dependence of the thermal contribution ( photons , neutrinos ) on the baryon density of the matter ( this effect will be to some extent moderated by the factor @xmath51 in the isothermal pns , see section 3.1 ) . it is quite obvious , that @xmath5 eos becomes dominated by thermal effects below for @xmath52 . on the contrary , for isentropic eos , the effect of the trapped lepton number ( @xmath53 ) turns out to be much more important than the thermal effects . this can be see in fig . 1a , by comparing dash - dotted curve , @xmath54 $ ] , with the dotted line , which corresponds to an artificial ( unphysical ) case with small thermal effects , @xmath55 $ ] . it is clear , that the correct location of the `` neutrinosphere '' , which separates hot interior from the colder outer envelope , should be important for the determination of the radius of pns , and in consequence , of the maximum rotation frequency of a given pns model . it may be useful to compare our subnuclear eos for pns with those used by other authors . the subnuclear eos of pns , used in the papers of hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) and bombaci et al . ( 1995 , 96 ) is very different from that used in the present paper . in particular , hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) used a cold ( @xmath9 ) eos for the densities below @xmath56 . on the other hand , bombaci et al . ( 1995 , 96 ) stop their hot eos at the edge of the liquid interior , and use the @xmath9 ( cold catalyzed matter ) eos for the densities below @xmath57 ; in this way , they seriously underestimate thermal and neutrino trapping effects on the radius of pns . our eos above nuclear density are plotted in fig . the presence of a trapped lepton number softens the eos , while thermal effects always stiffen it with respect to that for cold catalyzed matter . the softening of the supranuclear eos at fixed @xmath16 is due to the fact , that a significant trapped lepton number increases the proton fraction , which implies the softening of the nucleon contribution to the eos . it should be stressed , that in contrast to hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) and bombaci et al . ( 1995 , 96 ) we used a unified dense matter model , valid for both supranuclear and subnuclear densities . also , the fact that we use various assumptions about the @xmath14 and @xmath39 profiles within pns , enables us to study the relative importance of the temperature profile and that of a trapped lepton number , for the pns models . the mass - radius relation for the static pns models calculated using various versions of our eos for the hot interior is shown in fig . we assumed @xmath58 , which was consistent with our definition of the `` neutrinosphere '' . for the sake of comparison , we show also the mass - radius relation for the @xmath9 ( cold catalyzed matter ) eos , which corresponds to cold neutron star models . in the case of the isothermal hot interior with central temperature @xmath59 mev we note a very small increase of the maximum mass , as compared to the @xmath9 case ( c.f . , bombaci et al . 1995 , 1996 ) . however , the effect on the mass - radius relation is quite strong , and increases rapidly with decreasing stellar mass . in the case of the isentropic eos with a trapped lepton number , [ @xmath60 , the softening of the high - density eos due to the trapped @xmath16 leads to the decrease of @xmath61 compared to the @xmath9 case ; as far as the value of @xmath61 is concerned , the softening effect of @xmath16 prevails over that of finite @xmath39 ( this is consistent with results of takatsuka 1995 and bombaci et al . 1995 , 1996 ) . however , the thermal effect on the radius is very important even in the case of @xmath53 . this can be seen by comparing the @xmath54 $ ] curve with that corresponding to the unphysical , fictitious case of @xmath55 $ ] . the very initial state of a pns corresponds to a significant trapped lepton number . with our assumption of a `` standard '' composition of dense matter ( i , e . , excluding large amplitude @xmath0-condensate , or a very large percentage of hyperons in cold dense matter ) , the maximum baryon mass ( baryon number ) of pns is lower than that of cold ns . therefore , in our case a stable pns transforms into a stable ns , and the scenario pns@xmath62black hole , considered by baumgarte et al . ( 1996 ) is excluded . at a given mass , the radius of a pns is significantly larger than that of a cold ns . as remarked by hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) , this should have important implications for rotating pns . it should be stressed , however , that the value of radius , especially for pns which are not close to the @xmath61 configuration , turns out to be quite sensitive to the location of the edge of the hot neutrino - opaque interior ( i.e. , to the value of @xmath34 ) . the choice of bombaci et al . ( 1996 ) would lead to a much smaller effect on @xmath63 , while that of hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) would result in larger values of the pns radii . the eos of pns is evolving with time , due mainly to the deleptonization process , which changes the composition of matter , and also due to changes of the internal temperature of the star . however , these changes occur on the timescales @xmath641 - 10 s , which are three or more orders of magnitude longer than the dynamical timescale , governing the readjustment of pressure and gravity forces . this dynamical timescale @xmath65ms corresponds also to the characteristic periods of the pns pulsations and of their rapid rotation . in view of this , we are able to decouple pns evolution from its dynamics , and treat its rotation in the stationary approximation , with a well defined eos of the pns matter . one of the neglected dynamical processes , implied by the radiative processes and the evolution of the thermal structure of a rotating pns , is the meridional circulation of the matter . strictly uniform rotation is incompatible with an assumption of a steady thermal state , resulting from the diffusive ( radiative ) equilibrium ( see , e.g. , tassoul 1978 ) . the requirement of radiative equilibrium will necessarily imply the existence of a meridional circulation of the matter . however , the velocity of this meridional circulation will be of the order of the stellar radius divided by the thermal timescale ( the timescale of changes of the entropy of the pns interior , which is of the order of neutrino diffusion timescale ) , which is much smaller than the rotational velocity ( see , eg . , section 8 of tassoul 1978 ) . in view of this , we can neglect the effect of the meridional circulation when calculating the mechanical equilibrium of a rapidly rotating pns . finally , let us notice that in a special , idealized case of @xmath66 , the radiative flux vanishes . then , pure uniform rotation can be realized as a steady state of a pns . the problem of the calculation of the stationary state of uniform rotation of cold neutron stars , within the framework of general relativity , was considered by numerous authors ( see the review article of friedman and ipser 1992 , and references therein ) . extensive calculations for a broad set of realistic equations of state of cold dense matter were recently presented in ( cook et al . 1994 ) and ( salgado et al . 1994 ) . here , we will extend the methods used at @xmath9 to the case of hot pns . we will use the notation and formalism developed in the paper of bonazzola et al . ( 1993 ) , hereafter referred to as bgsm . one of the problems introduced by finite temperature is that , if one does not make any other assumption about the equilibrium , the equation of stationary motion does not have a first integral ( bardeen 1972 ) . in the notation of bgsm , the equation of stationary motion ( eq . 3.25 of bgsm ) reads , when the effects of temperature and rigid rotation are included , as @xmath67 where @xmath39 is the entropy per baryon , @xmath14 is the temperature , and @xmath68 $ ] is the so - called pseudo - enthalpy ( or log - enthalpy ) , @xmath7 is the lapse function appearing in the space - time metric , and @xmath8 is the lorentz factor due to rotation . the equation of the stationary motion is to be supplemented with the equations determining the metric functions ( see bsgm for the derivation and the explicit form of the complete set of equations ) . in the expression for @xmath69 , @xmath70 is the energy density ( which includes rest energy of matter constituents ) and @xmath71 is the nucleon rest mass . this equation is the general relativistic equivalent of a well - known newtonian formula ( see e.g. tassoul 1978 ) . it is straightforward to show that a _ sufficient _ condition for ( [ eqsta ] ) to be integrable is @xmath72 . in this case , one obtains a first integral of motion of the form : @xmath73 this enables us to calculate the density profile in the envelope of the pns , because we have assumed a specific @xmath74 profile within it ( see section 3.3 ) . let us stress that , due to the integral term in ( [ firstint ] ) , the pseudo - enthalphy is no more an explicit function of the metric potentials , as it was in bgsm . in fact , one must solve ( [ firstint ] ) to have @xmath69 within the star . in the two particular cases , chosen by us for the hot interior , specific first integrals of eq . ( [ eqsta ] ) can be found . first , in the case of general relativistic thermal equilibrium , @xmath75 , it is easy to show that @xmath76 where @xmath77 is the baryon chemical potential , is indeed the integral of ( [ eqsta ] ) . the constancy of @xmath78 and @xmath79 corresponds to the general - relativistic thermodynamic equilibrium , if we neglect the time dependence of the eos of pns ( i.e. , if we freeze transport phenomena ) . second , in the case of isentropic profile @xmath80 , the thermal term in ( [ eqsta ] ) vanishes and the first integral of eq . ( [ eqsta ] ) reads @xmath81 the instabilities that could develop in rapidly rotating pns , and which could limit the maximum angular frequency of these objects , are of secular and of dynamic type . let us start with the problem of secular stability with respect to the axi - symmetric perturbation of rotating configurations . we denote the total baryon number , total angular momentum , and total entropy of a pns by @xmath82 , @xmath83 , and @xmath84 , respectively . we used the _ secular _ instability criterion of friedman et al . ( 1988 ) , extended to the case of finite temperature . for the purpose of completeness , we restate here their lemma ( and correct a misprint of their paper ) . + * lemma :* consider a three - parameter family of uniformly rotating hot stellar models having an equation of state of the form @xmath85 . suppose that along a continous sequence of models labelled by a parameter @xmath86 , there is a point @xmath87 at which @xmath88 , @xmath89 and @xmath90 vanish and where @xmath91 . then the part of the sequence for which @xmath92 is unstable for @xmath86 near @xmath87 . + similarly as in the case of friedman et al . ( 1988 ) , this lemma follows directly from theorem i of sorkin ( 1982 ) , with his function @xmath84 replaced by @xmath93 , the @xmath94 quantities replaced by @xmath82 , @xmath83 , @xmath84 and the @xmath95 ones by @xmath96 , @xmath97 , @xmath98 . the conditions of the theorem are fulfilled because stellar models are configurations for which @xmath99 is minimized at fixed @xmath82 , @xmath83 and @xmath84 , _ and _ because difference in @xmath99 between two neighbouring equilibria can be expressed as ( bardeen 1970 ) @xmath100 let us stress here that this last equation requires either @xmath98 or @xmath39 to be constant through the whole star , which fixes , in each of these two cases , the temperature profile within the stellar model . we investigated the stability of our models with a specific version of this criterion , in which we choose a continous sequence of equilibria to be a sequence at fixed @xmath82 and @xmath84 . the point of the loss of stability is then simply the point of extremal @xmath83 , i.e. : @xmath101 where @xmath102 is the central density of the star . the instability discussed above is a secular one ; it will develop on the timescale needed to transport the angular momentum within the perturbed model , in order to decrease the energy of the star while changing its shape and structure . however , the timescale of the pns evolution is quite short ( seconds ) , and it is driven by the same transport processes involving neutrinos , as those which are needed to destabilize the star via the axi - symmetric perturbations . in view of this , one might expect that the secular instability described above is not efficient in disrupting the quasi - stationary configuration of rapidly rotating pns . however , we should remember that the above considerations apply to the case of infinitesimal perturbations . transport processes would be crucial for removing the energy barrier separating the initial , secularly unstable configuration , from the dynamically unstable one , which would eventually collapse into a black hole . however , newly born pns are expected to be in a highly excited state , in which various modes of stellar pulsations are excited . one may expect that the energy contained in these pulsations is sufficient to overcome the energy barrier separating the actual metastable , secularly unstable state from the dynamically unstable , collapsing one . in view of this , we expect that the secularly unstable configurations should be treated like unstable ones . therefore , the critical configuration , given by eq.(9 ) , will be thus considered as the last stable one . a rapidly rotating pns can be also susceptible to other types of secular instabilities . the instability with respect to the non axisymmetric perturbations can be driven by the gravitational radiation reaction ( grr ) . however , detailed calculations performed for hot ns suggest , that at the temperature exceeding @xmath103k these instabilities can only slightly decrease the maximum rotation frequency of uniform rotation , due to the damping effect of the matter viscosity ( cutler et al . 1990 , ipser & lindblom 1991 , lindblom 1995 , yoshida & eriguchi 1995 , zdunik 1996 ) . secular instabilities of rapidly rotating ns with respect to the non - axisymmetric `` bar '' mode were recently investigated by lai & shapiro ( 1995 ) and bonazzola et al . while lai & shapiro ( 1995 ) addressed the problem of `` bar '' instability of newly formed ns , they assumed a rather unrealistic `` ellipsoidal model '' , involving only shear viscosity as a source of viscous dissipation , and performed their calculations within the newtonian theory of gravity . on the other hand , in their relativistic calculations bonazzola et al . ( 1995 ) considered only cold ns , and found that the secular `` bar '' instability can set in before the keplerian ( mass shedding ) limit is reached only for sufficiently stiff eos of ns matter . the problem of the `` bar '' instability of pns , with realistic eos of the hot interior , will be investigated by us in the future . in any case , inclusion of possible additional secular instabilities can only decrease the maximum rotation frequency of pns below the values obtained using the simplified approach adapted in the present paper . the fact of the existence of the maximum mass of rotating pns , @xmath104 ( and maximum baryon mass , @xmath105 ) ( see section 5 ) , puts a well defined and stringent limit on @xmath106 which can be reached by pns . configurations with @xmath107 are _ dynamically unstable _ : no stationary solution exists above @xmath108 . at the same time , the angular frequency of rigid rotation can not exceed the keplerian value , @xmath106 . these two conditions , combined with the instability criterion , expressed in eq . ( 9 ) , determine the maximum frequency ( or , strictly speaking , an upper bound on the frequency ) of rigid rotation of pns . practical implementation of these criteria will be described in section 5 . a consistent study of pns would require an exact treatment of the thermal transport in the frame of a non - stationary spacetime . unfortunately , such a study is beyond the scope of the present work , and we have thus chosen to impose `` by hand '' the temperature profile within the star , following prescription described in the subsection 2.3 . we divided the interior of pns into the hot interior ( @xmath109 ) , a layer corresponding to the temperature drop within the `` neutrinosphere '' ( @xmath110 ) , and the low temperature , neutrino - transparent outer envelope with @xmath111 . we have chosen two types of temperature profiles within the hot , neutrino - opaque core @xmath112 : * the isothermal profile : @xmath113 , with @xmath114 , * the isentropic profile : @xmath115 , with @xmath116 . for the transition region and the low temperature envelope , we used a suitable profile @xmath74 : @xmath117 the function @xmath118 was chosen for computational convenience as a suitable combination of an exponential and a gaussian function , selected to lead to @xmath74 of class @xmath119 through the transition ( temperature drop ) region . our typical choice was @xmath120 ; increasing this value up @xmath121 led to a very small increase of the stellar radius . as the mass of a massive pns is almost entirely contained in the hot neutrino - opaque core ( a rough estimate for a typical star gives less than @xmath122 of the total mass for the cool envelope mass ) , we supposed that our stability criterion remained valid also in the case of the presence of the low temperature envelope . we used a code based on the @xmath123 formulation of the einstein equations in stationary axisymmetric spacetimes ( bgsm ) . the four elliptic equations obtained were solved by means of a spectral method , in which the functions are expanded in different polynomial bases ( chebyshev for @xmath124 , legendre for @xmath125 and fourier for @xmath126 ) . we refer the reader to bgsm for a detailed description of the code , including the description of the `` virial '' indicator used for monitoring the convergence and the precision reached . let us just say that the code was modified to take into account thermal effects and , contrary to salgado et al . ( 1994 ) , to converge to the solution with various quantities being held fixed ( for example @xmath127 or @xmath83 or @xmath84 ) . here we briefly outline some of the numerical checks we made . the two - parameters eos was interpolated using bicubic splines subroutine from the nag library . in this way , the thermodynamic functions are of class @xmath128 , but the thermodynamic consistency is not conserved . the global relative error , evaluated by the means of the virial check ( see bgsm ) , is @xmath129 . this relatively `` low '' precision is due to the thermodynamical inconsistencies . we used two grids in @xmath124 for the star and one in @xmath130 for the exterior with @xmath131 in each , and one grid in @xmath125 with @xmath132 . we checked that a greater @xmath133 or @xmath134 does not change the results by more than a few @xmath135 at most , which stays within the global precision reached . let us stress that such a low number of grid points is sufficient to reach high accuracy within a spectral method ( that would not be the case with a finite difference scheme ) . the temperature drop at the `` neutrinosphere '' is not always located on the border of the internal grid in @xmath124 , which could influence the precision ( remember that the spectral methods are very sensitive to discontinuities ) . we checked that , in fact , even when the `` neutrinosphere '' is far from the border of the grid , the global physical quantities of the star did not change much ( we found also relative variations of a few @xmath135 at most ) . for a `` simple '' model where @xmath136 were held fixed , convergence required no more than @xmath137 iterations and @xmath138 minute of cpu time on a silicon graphix indigo@xmath139 workstation . however , the number of iterations can reach @xmath140 if one needs to converge to , e.g. , a keplerian configuration at fixed supra - massive baryon mass . finally , we compared our results at @xmath9 and @xmath141 with the results of another code used by one of us ( p. haensel ) , and found that the relative differences in the global properties of the stellar models are of the order of @xmath142 , which can be imputed to the different interpolation procedures . for a given eos , rapidly rotating pns models can be divided into two families : normal and supramassive one . normal models are those with baryon mass which does not exceed the maximum allowable baryon mass of static ( non - rotating ) configurations , @xmath143 . a _ normal _ rotating model can be transformed into a static configuration of the same baryon mass , through a continuous decrease of @xmath97 . rotation of pns increases their maximum allowable mass with respect to the static case , up to @xmath144 . rotating pns models with @xmath145 are called _ supramassive_. such a supramassive rotating model can not transform into a static model , because in the process of decreasing angular velocity it will collapse into a black hole . the maximum angular velocity of the normal and supramassive rotating models results from different stability conditions . in the case of normal rotating configurations the value of @xmath97 is bound by the mass shedding limit , which corresponds to the keplerian velocity at the stellar equator , @xmath146 . the value of @xmath106 turns out to be rather sensitive to the location of the `` neutrinosphere '' within the pns . this sensitivity is particularly large in the case of the isothermal profile of the hot neutrino - opaque core . this is visualized in fig . 3 , where we show the dependence of the mass shedding limit @xmath106 for pns with baryon mass @xmath147 on the value of @xmath34 , for the central temperatures ranging between 10 and 20 mev . the dependence on the value of @xmath34 weakens with increasing @xmath127 . also , this effect is much less important in the case of isentropic pns . llllll & & & & & + eos & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath104 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 + & @xmath152 $ ] & [ km ] & @xmath152 $ ] & [ km ] & [ hz ] + & & & & & + & & & & & + @xmath9 , @xmath153 & 2.048 & 10.59 & 2.430 & 14.34 & 1625 + @xmath154 , @xmath153 & 2.053 & 11.17 & 2.322 & 14.79 & 1521 + @xmath155 , @xmath53 & 1.957 & 10.85 & 2.180 & 14.40 & 1522 + @xmath156 , @xmath53 & 1.977 & 11.53 & 2.172 & 15.32 & 1388 + & & & & & + & & & & & + for supramassive rotating pns , the limit on @xmath97 has been set by the condition of stability of rotating models with respect to the axi - symmetric perturbations , which was combined with the mass shedding stability condition . our calculations have been performed for both isothermal ( @xmath43 ) and isentropic ( @xmath10 ) hot interiors of pns . in both cases , the absolute maximum of keplerian frequency for rotating models , which were stable with respect to the axi - symmetric perturbations , was obtained for a rotating configuration with a maximum baryonic mass ( and gravitational mass ) , @xmath157 [ @xmath104 ] . actually , rotating configuration with @xmath104 and that with @xmath2 do not generally coincide ( see , e.g. , cook et al . 1994 , stergioulas & friedman 1995 ) . however , the difference is very small , and it could not be detected within the precision of our numerical code . the value @xmath104 depends on the value of @xmath78 in the case of isothermal hot interior , but we preferred to parametrize it in terms of central temperature , @xmath159 . the dependence of @xmath104 on the value of @xmath160 is displayed in fig . 4 a. the effect of temperature on @xmath104 is opposite to that seen for @xmath148 : thermal effects lower the value of @xmath104 as compared to that for cold neutron stars . this is due to the thermal increase of the equatorial radius , which prevails over the thermal stiffening of the central core of pns . the dependence of @xmath161 on the value of @xmath39 in the case of isentropic hot interior of pns is represented in fig . 4 b , in the case of @xmath162 ( trapped lepton number ) and for @xmath53 . the decrease of @xmath161 is there smaller than in the case of the isothermal pns models . in fig . 5 a , 5 b we show our results for the maximum rotation frequency of stable pns models , reached for supramassive configurations . in the case of the isothermal pns , thermal effects tend to decrease the value of @xmath2 , but even in the case of @xmath163mev the relative effect does not exceed ten percent . irregularities at lower @xmath160 result from the limited accuracy of determination of the critical configuration with an isothermal core . maximum rotation frequency in the case of the isentropic hot neutrino - trapped cores of pns is shown , for several values of the central entropy per baryon , in fig . 5 b. the value of @xmath2 is also decreasing with increasing @xmath39 . in general , we find that the decrease of @xmath2 , as compared to cold neutron stars , is in our case smaller than that found by hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) ; this may be due to the lower value of the density at the edge of the hot core , assumed by these authors . some differences may also be due to different supranuclear eos , and to a different treatment of the thermal effects , in particular , to their assumption of @xmath5 . in order to visualize the importance of the relativistic effects on @xmath164 in the isothermal interior of a pns , we show in fig . 6 the temperatures @xmath164 and @xmath78 , for @xmath165 @xmath166 , and a uniform keplerian rotation . as one can see , in the central part of the pns , @xmath14 is about @xmath167 percent greater than @xmath168 . a similar effect is seen also in the case of an isentropic hot interior , which in fig . 6 corresponds to @xmath169 . the calculation of the rotating pns ( and ns ) models is incomparably more difficult than that of the static models . in the case of cold ns , one finds a surprisingly precise universal formula , which relates the maximum rotation frequency to the mass and radius of the maximum mass configuration for the static models ( haensel & zdunik 1989 , friedman at al . 1989 , shapiro et al . 1989 , haensel et al . 1995 , nozawa et al . 1996 ) , @xmath170 where the most recent value of @xmath171 , based on calculations performed for a broad set of realistic _ cold _ eos of dense matter , is @xmath172 ( haensel et al . 1995 ) . the `` empirical formula '' , eq . ( 10 ) , reproduces the values of @xmath2 for cold ns models with typical precision better than @xmath173 ( although in some specific cases the deviations can reach nearly @xmath174 , see nozawa et al . 1996 ) . the validity of the empirical formula for @xmath2 is of great practical importance . for cold eos of dense matter , it enables one to get immediately a rather precise estimate of the value of @xmath2 , using easily calculated static neutron star models , and avoiding in this way incomparably more difficult 2-d calculations of rotating ns models and the analysis of their stability . it is of interest to check , whether `` empirical formula '' is valid also in the case of hot pns . let us notice , that the subnuclear eos of pns , with possible lepton number trapping , is very different from that of cold catalyzed matter ( see fig . 1 ) . in order to check the validity of the empirical formula , we define the eos depending parameter @xmath175 , @xmath176 where the right - hand - side is calculated using exact results for a specific eos . the values of @xmath175 for our models of pns are displayed in fig . 7 a , 7 b. let us notice , that for isentropic hot cores with trapped lepton number the value of @xmath175 shows a decreasing trend with increasing @xmath39 . in the case of isothermal hot cores with @xmath153 we see the opposite trend : the value of @xmath175 tends to increase with central temperature . the value of @xmath177 will lead to a very good empirical formula for pns , with precison comparable to that used for cold ns . within the precision of the empirical formulae , the values of @xmath178 and @xmath179 can be considered as being equal . maximum rotation frequencies and maximum baryon masses of pns with various eos , and corresponding frequencies of cold ns configurations , obtained via cooling at constant @xmath83 and @xmath127 ( @xmath83-losses due to neutrino emission are neglected ) . [ cols= " < , < , < , < " , ] rapidly rotating hot , neutrino - opaque pns evolves eventually into a cold , rotating ns , which under favourable circumstances can be observed as a solitary pulsar . let us assume , that such a transformation took place at constant baryon mass : this assumption is valid if mass accreted after the formation of a pns is negligibly small . ( notice , that we can _ define _ the moment of formation of a pns as that at which the accretion ends ) . second assumption refers to the angular momentum of the star . let us neglect for the time being the angular momentum loss due to emission of neutrinos ( mainly during deleptonization ) , as well as that due to gravitational radiation ( if rotating star deviated from the axial symmetry ) . inclusion of both effects could only _ decrease _ the final angular momentum of the ns . under these two assumptions , the transformation of a pns into a solitary radio pulsar takes place at constant baryon mass , @xmath127 , and angular momentum , @xmath83 . the maximum angular frequency of a solitary radio pulsar of a given baryon mass would be then determined by the parameters of a maximally rotating pns of the same baryon mass . in the present paper we restrict ourselves , similarly as hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) , to the case of rigid rotation of pns . we will first consider `` typical '' range of baryon masses expected for the ns born in a gravitational collapse of a massive stellar core , @xmath180 ( for our eos of dense matter this would correspond to @xmath181 ) . all stars considered are normal , and the maximum initial frequency of pns will be then @xmath182 $ ] , and @xmath183 $ ] , for the limiting case of the zero trapped lepton number , and maximum trapped lepton number neutrino - opaque cores , respectively . the values of these limiting angular frequencies , for the isothermal and isentropic pns cores , are plotted versus @xmath127 in fig . 8 ( thin dashed and dash - dotted lines , respectively ) . our results displayed in fig . 8 lead to some conclusions , relevant to those neutron stars which remained solitary after their birth in the gravitational collapse of a massive stellar core . if the starting configuration ( at the end of significant accretion , after the revival of a stagnated shock ) was that with trapped lepton number and isentropic , then the maximum frequency of such a neutron star , in the gravitational mass range of 1.3 - 1.8 @xmath184 , can not exceed 600 - 900 hz , the lower frequency limit corresponding to the lower mass limit . the corresponding range of minimum periods would be from 1.6 ms to 1.1 ms , respectively . if the `` initial isolated configuration '' ( i.e. , that with no subsequent accretion ) was a little older , and therefore deleptonized , and if we assume that it was isothermal , then the resulting constraints would be less stringent : for the range of masses 1.3 - 1.8 @xmath184 we get minimum rotation periods of 1.25 - 1.1 ms , respectively . in both cases cooling resulted in speeding up of the rotation of the star : such situation is characteristic of `` normal rotating models '' . similar evolutionary considerations can be applied to the `` maximally rotating configurations '' : isentropic one with @xmath169 and isothermal ones with @xmath185mev , 25 mev , respectively . our results are shown in table 2 . the initial `` hot '' configurations are supramassive , and evolve into more compact cool ones ( at constant @xmath186 and @xmath83 ) _ decreasing _ their angular frequency ( slowing down ) . this purely relativistic effect was recently pointed out by hashimoto et al . the `` relativistic slowing down '' during cooling of the maximally rotating isentropic configuration with @xmath169 corresponds to the increase of the period from @xmath187=0.72 $ ] ms up to @xmath188 ms . if such a scenario of formation of solitary pulsars is valid , an absolute limit on their period would be @xmath189 , and not @xmath190 ms , obtained for the @xmath9 eos . the slowing down factor of @xmath191 coincides with that obtained by hashimoto et al . ( 1995 ) for a different eos and a different scenario of formation of solitary cold pulsars . actually , they assumed that the initial configuration is that with @xmath192 . their initial model would to some extent correspond to our isothermal models ( remember however the factor @xmath193 in our temperature profiles , which is absent in their calculations ) . using tables 1 , 2 we obtain @xmath194/p_{\rm min}[t=0]=0.92 $ ] , which is quite close to 1 . in the present paper we studied rapid rotation of protoneutron stars , using a specific model of hot , dense matter . our models of rapidly rotating protoneutron stars were based on several simplifications , which were necessary in order to make the problem tractable . in order to avoid difficulties and/or ambiguities of the largely unknown `` real situation '' , we restricted ourselves to studying idealized , limiting cases . in many places we introduced approximations , which were crucial for making numerical calculations feasible . we assumed rigid rotation within protoneutron star . this simplified greatly our considerations , and reduced dramatically the number of stellar models . actually , our formalism allows calculation of the quasi - stationary differentially rotating configurations , after introducing an additional @xmath195 term appearing on the right hand side of the equation of stationary motion , eq . ( 4 ) ( see section 5.1 of bgsm ) . we plan to perform studies of differentially rotating protoneutron stars in the near future , as the next step in our investigations of dynamics of protoneutron stars . while existing numerical simulations of gravitational collapse of rotating cores of massive stars yield a differentially rotating protoneutron star , the calculations stop too early after bounce . in contrast to our models of protoneutron stars , the object which comes out from the simulations of moenchmeyer and mueller has an extended , very hot envelope , produced by the shock wave immediately after bounce ( janka & moenchmeyer 1989a , b , moenchmeyer & mueller 1989 ) . also , the lack of knowledge of the initial angular velocity distribution within the collapsing core results in the uncertainty in the rotational state of produced protoneutron star . clearly , the study of quasistationary differential rotation of protoneutron stars should take into account all these uncertainties . deleptonization of protoneutron star is connected with energy and angular momentum losses . however , angular momentum taken away by neutrinos is expected to constitute at most a few percent of the total stellar angular momentum ( kazanas 1977 ) . inclusion of this effect would slightly decrease some of our `` evolutionary limits '' of section 7 . our treatment of the thermal state of the protoneutron star interior should be considered as very crude . the temperature profile might be affected by convection . also , our method of locating the `` neutrinosphere '' was very approximate . clearly , the treatment of thermal effects can be refined , but we do not think this will change our main results . our calculations were performed for only one model of the nucleon component of dense hot matter . the model was realistic , and enabled us to treat in a unified way the whole interior ( core as well as the envelope ) of the protoneutron star . however , in view of the uncertainties in the eos of dense matter at supranuclear densities , one should of course study the whole range of theoretical possibilities , for a broad set - from soft to stiff - of supranuclear , high temperature eos . an example of such an investigation , in the case of the _ static _ protoneutron stars , is the study of bombaci et al . ( 1996 ) . in view of the possible importance of the protoneutron star - neutron star connection for the properties of solitary pulsars , similar studies should also be done for rotating proto - neutron stars . the calculations of the present paper were done under the assumption , that the frequency of uniform rotation of protoneutron stars is limited only by the mass shedding and the secular instability with respect to the axi - symmetric perturbations . in view of this , our results can be considered only as upper bounds to the maximum rotation frequency . our main conclusion is that the minimum rotation period of solitary neutron stars , born as rapidly rotating protoneutron stars , is significantly larger , than the corresponding limit for cold neutron stars . inclusion of additional secular instabilities in rapidly , uniformly rotating protoneutron stars can only strengthen this conclusion . we are very grateful to e. gourgoulhon for his help at the initial stage of this project . we are also very grateful to w. dziembowski for introducing us into the difficult subject of meridional circulation . this research was partially supported by the jumelage program `` astronomie france - pologne '' of cnrs / pan , by the kbn grant no . p304 014 07 , and by the mesr grant 94 - 3 - 1544 . the numerical computations have been performed on the silicon graphics workstations , purchased thanks to the support of the spm department of the cnrs and the institut national des sciences de lunivers . bardeen j.m . , 1970 , apj , 162 , 71 bardeen j.m . , 1972 , in `` black holes - les astres occlus '' , les houches , ed . de witt c. & de witt b.s . , gordon and breach sci . pub . , new york baumgarte t.w . shapiro , s.a . teukolsky , 1996 , apj 458 , 680 bombaci i. , prakash m. , prakash m. , ellis p.j . , lattimer j.m . , brown g.e . , 1995 , a , 583 , 623 bombaci i. , 1996 , a&a 305 , 871 bombaci i. , prakash m. , prakash m. , ellis p.j . , lattimer j.m . , brown g.e . , 1996 , reports , in press bonazzola s. , gourgoulhon e. , salgado m. , marck j.a . , 1993 , a&a 278 , 421 bonazzola s. , frieben j. , gourgoulhon e. , 1995 , apj , 460 , 379 brown g.e . , bethe h.a . , 1994 , apj 423 , 659 burrows a. , lattimer j.m . , 1986 , apj , 307 , 178 cook g.b . , shapiro s.l . , teukolsky s.a . , 1994 , apj 424 , 823 cutler c. , lindblom l. , splinter r.j . , 1990 , apj 363 , 603 friedman j.l . , ipser j.r . , sorkin r.d . , 1988 , apj 325 , 722 friedman j.l . , ipser j.r . , parker l. , 1989 , phys . 62 , 3015 friedman j.l . , ipser j.r . , 1992 , phil . trans . lond . a , 340 , 391 haensel p. , zdunik j.l . , 1989 , nature 340 , 617 haensel p. , salgado m. , bonazzola s. , 1995 , a&a 296 , 745 hashimoto m - a , oyamatsu k. , eriguchi y. , 1995 , apj 436 , 257 ipser j.r . , lindblom l. , 1991 , apj 373 , 213 janka h .- t . , moenchmeyer r. , 1989a , a&a , 209 , l5 janka h .- t . , moenchmeyer r. , 1989b , a&a , 226 , 69 kazanas d. , 1977 , nature 267 , 501 lai d. , shapiro s.l . , 1995 , apj , 442 , 259 lattimer j.m . , swesty f.d , 1991 , nucl . a535 , 331 lindblom l. , 1995 , apj 438 , 265 moenchmeyer r. , mueller e. , 1989 , in `` timing neutron stars '' , ed . oegelman h. , van den heuvel e.p.j , kluwer , dordrecht nozawa t. , hashimoto m. , oyamatsu k. , eriguchi y. , 1996 , phys . rev . d 53 , 1845 pandharipande v.r . , pethick c.j . , thorsson v. , 1995 , phys.rev.lett . 75 , 4567 salgado m. , bonazzola s. , gourgoulhon e. , haensel p. , 1994 , a&a 291 , 155 sawyer r.f . , 1980 , apj 237 , 187 sawyer r.f . , soni a. , 1979 , apj 230 , 859 shapiro s.l . , teukolsky s.a . , wasserman i. , 1989 , nature 340 , 451 sorkin r.d . , 1982 , apj 257 , 847 stergioulas n. , friedman j.l . , 1995 , apj 444 , 306 takatsuka t. , 1995 , nucl . a588 , 365 tassoul j.l . , 1978 , `` theory of rotating stars '' , princeton university press , princeton yoshida s. , eriguchi y. , 1995 , apj 438 , 830 zdunik j.l . , 1996 , a&a 308 , 828
Abstract: | [
"rapid uniform rotation of newborn neutron stars ( protoneutron stars ) is studied for a range of internal temperatures and entropies per baryon predicted by the existing numerical simulations . calculations are performed using general relativistic equations of hydrostatic equilibrium of rotating , axially symmetric stars . stability of rotating configurations with respect to mass shedding and the axially symmetric perturbations is studied . numerical calculations are performed for a realistic dense matter equation of state , under various assumptions concerning neutron star interior ( large trapped lepton number , no trapped lepton number , isentropic , isothermal ) . for configurations with baryon mass well below the maximum one for the non - rotating models , the mass shedding limit depends quite sensitively on the position of the `` neutrinosphere '' ( which has a deformed , spheroidal shape ) ; this dependence weakens with increasing baryon mass . the absolute upper limit on rotation frequency is , to a good approximation , obtained for the maximum baryon mass of rotating configurations . empirical formula for the maximum rotation frequency of uniformly rotating protoneutron stars is shown to be quite precise ; it actually coincides with that used for cold neutron stars . evolutionary sequences at fixed baryon mass and angular momentum , which correspond to evolution of protoneutron stars into cold neutron stars are studied , and resulting constraints on the maximum rotation frequency of solitary pulsars are discussed ."
] | 11,080 | 11,080 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the formation mechanism of compact objects , neutron stars ( nss ) and black holes ( bhs ) , is an unsolved problem in high - energy astrophysics . a model for the formation of such objects requires to perform physically - motivated simulations of the core - collapse supernova , which is computationally challenging ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . another possible way to investigate the formation of nss and bhs is to study the birth and evolution of x - ray binaries ( xrbs ) hosting a bh or a ns accreting from a stellar companion . the orbital parameters , peculiar velocities and galactic position of these binaries directly follow from their evolutionary history , and are affected in particular by the conditions at the moment of compact object formation ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; ; @xcite ) . the measurement of pulsar proper motions ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; ; @xcite ) , combined with the study of ns - xrbs ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) , has exposed evidence that some nss receive a low velocity , whereas others a high velocity at formation ( so called _ natal kicks _ , nks ) . the prevailing idea is that nss are formed either in a standard core - collapse supernova ( sn ) , or in a less energetic type of sn expected for star with small cores . the latter can take place either as an electron - capture sn or as an iron core - collapse sn with a small iron - core mass ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . for the case of bhs , observations are rather scarce and patchy , thus it is not yet possible to discriminate between different models of bh formation ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . in this paper , one of our goals is to investigate whether the observed galactic distribution of xrbs hosting a bh ( bh - xrbs ) can reveal something about how bhs are formed . the main underlying idea is that any offset of a bh - xrb from the galactic plane ( assumed as birth place ) is a signature of some peculiar velocity of the system with respect to the circular galactic motion . the magnitude of such velocity gives clues on the sn mechanism , in particular on the magnitude of the nk at birth ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the idea of using the galactic position and/or line of sight velocities of a population of xrbs to investigate the formation of compact objects was employed previously for the ns case ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . + we covered the topic of bh formation in two previous works . in @xcite , we followed the galactic trajectories of a simulated population of bh - xrbs , and investigated which nk distribution gives rise to the observed @xmath0-distribution of bh - xrbs ( where @xmath0 is the height above the galactic plane ) . the aim was to discriminate between _ high _ and _ reduced _ nks for bhs . high nks are larger than the nk expected in a standard formation scenario for bhs , in which the bh forms via fallback of material on to the proto - ns and the nk is caused by asymmetries in the sn ejecta . in the standard scenario , the nk would conserve the linear - momentum and roughly scale as the nk received by the ns multiplied by the ratio between the mass of the bh and the mass of the ns . we call these kicks as _ reduced _ or _ momentum - conserving _ nks . if the ns receives a nk of the order of @xmath1 km / s , a @xmath2 bh would get a nk of @xmath3 km / s . we define _ high _ nks as @xmath4 km / s . in @xcite , we found that high nks , comparable to ns nks , were required . in @xcite , we combined the information from the kinematics and binary evolution of a subset of bh - xrbs to find evidence both for low and high nks . in this paper , we aim at complementing and extending those previous studies . following up on the work by @xcite and @xcite , @xcite found that the root - mean - square ( rms ) value of the height above the galactic plane of bh - xrbs is similar to that of ns - xrbs , suggesting that bhs could also receive a _ high _ kick at formation , or even one as high as nss . in this work , we develop this idea further . we build synthetic populations of bh- and ns - xrbs and we model their binary evolution and their kinematics in the galaxy , to investigate whether different assumptions on compact object formation ( such as a different distribution for the nk and/or a different amount of mass ejected in the sn ) have an imprint on the observed galactic distribution of bh- and ns - xrbs , and we quantify these effects . furthermore , we will dedicate part of this work to discuss a method we previously employed to calculate the minimum peculiar velocity at birth of individual bh - xrbs ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . the difference of the galactic potential value between the observed position @xmath5 and its projection on to the galactic plane was used to analytically derive a lower limit for the peculiar velocity at birth . this method has been recently challenged by @xcite . we investigate how robust our estimate is , i.e. how close this estimate is to the true value of the minimal peculiar velocity at birth , how this estimate scales with the distance from the galactic centre , and how it varies for different choices of the galactic potential . + the paper is structured as follows . in section [ sec : estimate ] we study our estimate for the peculiar velocity at birth of individual bh - xrbs . in section [ sec : bps ] we build synthetic populations of bh- and ns - xrbs for different assumptions on the compact object formation . in section [ sec : results ] we look at the galactic distributions of these synthetic binaries while investigating how they differ , and inferring which nk distribution fits best the observed galactic position of ns- and bh - xrbs . in section [ sec : discussion ] we discuss our findings and in section [ sec : conclusion ] we draw our conclusions . 0.33 0.33 0.33 xrbs are thought to originate from binary progenitors born in the galactic plane , the birth - place of most massive stars ( @xcite ) . when the compact object forms , the binary typically acquires a peculiar velocity . the mass ejection in the sn imparts a recoil velocity to the binary ; the nk adds up vectorially to this velocity , giving the total peculiar velocity of the binary , @xmath6 . such a systemic velocity adds up vectorially to the local galactic rotation and probably has no preferential orientation . the full 3d velocity is measured only for a handful of bh - xrbs ( see @xcite ) . for these , the integration of the orbit backwards in time can in principle provide an estimate for @xmath6 at birth . however , uncertainty in the distance and differences in the galactic potential can prevent a unique determination of the initial position ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . when the full 3d peculiar velocity is not known , one can estimate @xmath6 at birth using a simple model . for an object located at galactic height @xmath0 : the distance from the galactic centre , and @xmath0 : the height above the galactic plane . ] , we expect a trajectory purely perpendicular to the plane to be the one which minimises the initial @xmath6 . in our previous works @xcite and @xcite , we estimated the minimum peculiar velocity at birth of a bh - xrb employing energy conservation along such trajectory , and assuming that the maximum height @xmath0 from the plane is the observed one . we get : @xmath7 } , \label{eq : estimate}\ ] ] where @xmath8 is a model for the galactic potential , @xmath9 is the measured distance of the binary from the galactic centre projected on to the galactic plane , and @xmath0 is the current height above the plane . recently @xcite argued that the difference in the gravitational potential between the observed location and its projection on to the galactic plane is not an accurate estimate of the required minimum peculiar velocity at birth . he suggests that there are always possible trajectories different from a purely perpendicular one which require a lower @xmath10 at birth than the one estimated through equation [ eq : estimate ] to reach the same offset from the galactic plane . we check the validity of our estimate for the peculiar velocity at birth , @xmath11 , for high-@xmath0 sources , performing a monte carlo simulation using the python package for galactic dynamics ( @xcite ) . we simulate @xmath12 points , whose initial conditions are set as follows : 1 ) the initial position is at @xmath13 , where @xmath14 is uniformly distributed between @xmath15 and @xmath16 kpc ; 2 ) the initial peculiar velocity @xmath17 is uniform between @xmath15 and @xmath18 km / s ; 3 ) the orientation of this velocity is uniformly distributed over a sphere . we note that since we are only interested in the minimum value of @xmath17 , the shape of the assumed velocity distribution is not important . we add the circular motion in the galactic disc to the 3d peculiar velocity @xmath6 . we integrate the orbits in the galaxy for @xmath19 gyr , using a 4th - order runge - kutta integrator , and we check for conservation of energy over the trajectory making sure that the relative error on the energy is less than @xmath20 at the final step . we record the positions @xmath21 @xmath18 times over the orbit sampling from constant time steps , along with the initial peculiar velocity @xmath17 . from the simulated points , we select only those ones located at @xmath22 at the sampled times , to represent high-@xmath0 sources . we perform the simulation for three different choices of the galactic potential : model 2 of , @xcite , and the potential from @xcite , which are all multi - component potentials consisting of disc , bulge , and halo . the @xcite potential is made up of two miyamoto - nagai potentials for disc and bulge , and one pseudo - isothermal potential for the halo . the @xcite potential is made up of a power - law density profile with an exponential cut - off for the bulge , a miyamoto - nagai potential for the disc , and a navarro - frenk - white profile for the halo . the potential is composed of two miyamoto - nagai potentials and a wilkinson - evans potential for the halo . we show the rotation curve of each of the three potentials in figure [ fig : rotcurve ] . is the potential used by @xcite ; @xcite is the one we adopted in @xcite ; the is a realistic model for the milky way potential favoured by @xcite . we present the results of this simulation in figure [ fig : density ] . the red line is our estimate for the peculiar velocity taking @xmath23 kpc in equation [ eq : estimate ] and it follows the lower edge of the simulated points . figure [ fig : density ] shows that our analytical estimate ( eq . [ eq : estimate ] ) successfully describes the value and trend of the minimal peculiar velocity as a function of the galactocentric distance . in order to better quantify the goodness of our estimator @xmath11 , we compute the ratio @xmath24 using @xmath25 kpc - wide bins in @xmath26 , for those points which reach a height above the galactic plane along their orbit in the range @xmath27 kpc . the velocity @xmath17 is the actual initial peculiar velocity which we showed in figure [ fig : density ] . we plot @xmath28 in figures [ fig : ratio1 ] , [ fig : ratio2 ] , [ fig : ratio3 ] , for the three different potentials . @xmath11 is an excellent estimator for @xmath29 kpc , since at these radii @xmath28 is equal or greater than @xmath25 . it is less robust in the inner part of the bulge for the @xcite and potentials , but not in the potential , that is fit to the most recent dynamical constraints on the milky way and has a more realistic bulge model ( jo bovy , private communication ) . in the bulge region , our estimate is steeper than the real minimal peculiar velocity for the first two potentials , i.e. , it varies strongly for small variation in @xmath26 . this can be seen in figure [ fig : andrei ] , where for every position @xmath21 we show as a density map the real minimal peculiar velocity at birth necessary to reach that position . we integrated @xmath30 orbits for @xmath19 gyr and using as potential the one in . the contour lines show our analytical estimate @xmath11 ; the discrepancy between the two velocities is evident in the inner region of the galaxy . figures [ fig : ratio1 ] , [ fig : ratio2 ] , [ fig : ratio3 ] also show an increase of the average value of @xmath28 with larger distances @xmath26 . this is an artefact caused by our choice of the @xmath17 initial distribution ( uniform between @xmath31 km / s ) , as the numerator in the ratio @xmath28 can take all the values between @xmath32 and @xmath18 km / s . from our extensive analysis , we find that the estimate @xmath33 accurately represents the real minimal value for the peculiar velocity at distances from the galactic centre @xmath34 kpc , and can be safely applied to estimate the peculiar velocity at birth of xrbs born in the galactic plane . of simulated points which reach that position @xmath21 . the contour lines show our analytical estimate @xmath11 at that position . the estimate differs strongly from the real value in the bulge region ( each solid line differs by @xmath35 km / s from the closest - neighbouring one ) . the potential used is from . ] the estimate @xmath11 is a function of the potential used , in particular in the bulge , as can be seen in figure [ fig : difference ] , where we show @xmath11 for the @xcite , and @xcite potentials , and assuming @xmath23 kpc in eq . [ eq : estimate ] . additionally , from figures [ fig : ratio1 ] , [ fig : ratio2 ] , [ fig : ratio3 ] , we note that the fraction of systems with @xmath36 in the region @xmath37 $ ] kpc also strongly depends on the potential . the minimum values @xmath38 are : @xmath39 , @xmath40 , @xmath41 for @xcite , , @xcite potential respectively , where these lower limits are defined such that @xmath42 of the points in the same bin have a value larger than the lower limit . figure [ fig : density ] also shows that the galactic bulge ( @xmath43 kpc ) is much less populated ( an order of magnitude fewer systems than in regions at larger distance from the galactic center ) . there are two reasons for this : i ) the bulge volume is small ; ii ) it is unlikely for a binary born in the galactic disc to overcome the strong potential well in its motion towards the galactic bulge . the inaccuracy of our analytical estimate in the bulge region affects only the source h1705 - 250 , which is the only bh - xrb located close enough to the galactic centre ( see table [ tab : systems ] ) , at @xmath44 kpc ( @xcite ) . without a measurement of its 3d peculiar velocity , it is impossible to discriminate between a birth in the disc or a birth in the bulge ( hence close to its observed position ) . more in general , bulge sources are not suitable for estimating the peculiar velocities at birth , since the current view on bulge formation is that it was not formed in situ . the bulge population is thought to come from the disc through dynamical instabilities ( @xcite ) , with most of its mass coming from major and minor merger events with satellite galaxies ( @xcite ) . + we compute the minimum peculiar velocity at birth for the seven short - period bh - xrbs studied by @xcite , using the three galactic potentials ( see table [ tab : minvpec ] ) . we add to this sample two other short - period bh - xrbs which we did not consider in @xcite ( xte j1650 - 500 and xte j1859 + 226 ) , due to the lack of a strong constraint on the bh mass ( @xcite ) . for h 1705 - 250 , we put in parenthesis the velocity @xmath11 multiplied by the factor @xmath28 found above . c c c c + source & bovy & pac . & irrgang & repetto et al . + & & & & 2015 + xte j1118 + 480 & 62 & 70 & 68 & 72 + gro j0422 + 32 & 20 & 25 & 22 & 25 + grs 1009 - 45 & 34 & 40 & 37 & 41 + 1a 0620 - 00 & 8 & 10 & 8 & 10 + gs 2000 + 251 & 12 & 15 & 12 & 15 + nova mus 91 & 44 & 51 & 46 & 52 + h 1705 - 250 & 259 ( 262 ) & 363 ( 158 ) & 350 ( 186 ) & 402 + xte j1650 - 500 & 17 & 21 & 16 & - + xte j1859 + 226 & 61 & 68 & 68 & - + we have found an error in the halo component of the @xcite potential that we used for the computation of @xmath11 in @xcite . this mostly affects the bulge source h 1705 - 250 , whereas the other six sources are not greatly affected ( compare third and last column in table [ tab : minvpec ] ) . accounting for the thickness of the galactic disc instead of assuming a birth place at @xmath45 does not significantly affect the minimal peculiar velocity ( see @xcite ) . @xcite used the source h 1705 - 250 to conclude that the difference in the galactic potential between the observed position and the projection of this position on to the galactic plane is not a conservative estimate of the minimal initial velocity of the binary . they show an example of a trajectory for h 1705 - 250 which starts from the galactic plane and ends at the observed position for an initial velocity of @xmath46 km / s , lower than the value provided by eq . [ eq : estimate ] ( see table [ tab : minvpec ] ) . we agree with his conclusion , but only as far as sources close ( or in ) the bulge are concerned . on the contrary , for sources located at @xmath47 kpc , our analytical estimate perfectly matches the real minimal velocity . in @xcite we used the high minimal velocity at birth for xte j1118 + 480 and h 1705 - 250 to claim that at least two out of the seven bh - xrbs we considered were consistent with a high ( or relatively high ) nk . this holds true with our current revision of the minimal velocities at birth , and we find another bh - xrb that is potentially consistent with a relatively high nk : xte j1859 + 226 . the velocities we have been dealing so far with are _ minimal _ velocities , and do not necessarily correspond to _ expected _ ( _ realistic _ ) velocities . in what follows , we study the latter . for the peculiar velocity at birth as a function of the distance from the galactic centre @xmath26 ( projected on to the galactic plane ) for the three different galactic potentials used in this work : @xcite ( dashed line ) , @xcite ( dotted line ) , ( solid line ) . we assumed @xmath23 kpc . ] in this part of the work , instead of dealing with the minimal peculiar velocities , we deal with the expected peculiar velocities . we perform a binary population synthesis study of bh- and ns - xrbs , starting just before the bh / ns formation , varying the conditions at the formation of the compact object . the goal is to investigate the impact that different bh and ns formation assumptions have on the galactic distribution of xrbs containing a ns or a bh . we assume that the binaries are formed in the galactic thin disc , where most of the massive stars reside ( @xcite ) . in this study , we do not account for the possibility that a few systems could have been formed in the halo ( i.e. in star clusters that have now been dissolved ) , and neither of the possibility that a few systems could have been ejected from globular clusters ( gcs ) via n - body interactions . gcs seem to be very efficient in producing ns low - mass x - ray binaries ( ns - lmxbs ) , as @xmath48 of all ns - lmxbs are found in globular clusters , which contain only @xmath49 of all the stars in the galaxy ( @xcite ) . such an investigation is , however , outside the scope of this paper . we take different models for the formation of the compact object . the nk is drawn either from a maxwellian distribution peaked at @xmath50 km / s ( with @xmath51 km / s ) representing a low - nk , or from a maxwellian distribution peaked at @xmath52 km / s ( with @xmath53 km / s ) representing a high - nk . we assume a certain amount of mass ejection in the sn , @xmath54 . bhs are thought to form either via prompt collapse of the progenitor star or via partial fallback of the sn ejecta onto the proto - ns ( see @xcite ) . in our models , the progenitors of bhs either do not eject any mass at collapse , or they eject @xmath55 . stars with a zams - mass larger than @xmath56 are thought to leave a bh behind ( see e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ) . for a progenitor of mass @xmath57 , the helium core mass ( which collapses into a bh ) is between @xmath58 ( @xcite ) , which motivates our ( conservative ) choice for @xmath54 . for the previous models , we assume a bh mass of @xmath59 ( which is the typical mass for bhs in our galaxy ; @xcite ) . we also picture a higher - mass helium star ( @xmath60 ) which directly collapses into a bh with no mass ejection . for nss , the ejected mass is calculated as : @xmath61 , where @xmath62 is the helium core mass ( @xmath63~m_\odot$ ] , see @xcite ) , and @xmath64 . for the bh case the models are : * model 1 : high nk , @xmath65 , @xmath66 ; * model 2 : low nk , @xmath65 , @xmath66 ; * model 3 : high nk , @xmath65 , @xmath67 ; * model 4 : low nk , @xmath60 , @xmath66 . for the ns case the models are : * model 5 : high nk , @xmath54 uniform between @xmath68~m_\odot$ ] ; * model 6 : low nk , @xmath54 uniform between @xmath68 ~m_\odot$ ] . for all the models , we simulate @xmath69 binaries composed of the helium star ( which core - collapses ) and a companion star of @xmath70 . the pre - sn orbital separation is uniformly drawn in the range @xmath71 with zero initial eccentricity , where @xmath72 is the minimal orbital separation such that either one of the two components fills its roche lobe . we calculate the effect of the compact object formation on the orbital properties and on the kinematics of the binary ( for more details on the method , see @xcite ) . in particular , the effect of the mass ejection together with the nk impart a peculiar velocity to the binary : @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the total mass of the binary after the sn , @xmath75 is the magnitude of the nk , @xmath76 its component along the orbital speed of the bh progenitor , and @xmath77 is the _ mass - loss kick _ : @xmath78 the recoil the binary gets because of the instantaneous mass ejection @xmath54 ( @xmath79 is the initial mass of the binary ; @xmath80 is the mass of the companion ; @xmath81 is the initial orbital separation ) . we follow the evolution of the binaries under the coupling between tides and magnetic braking using the method developed in @xcite , and select those systems that start mass transfer ( mt ) , i.e. become x - ray sources , while the donor is on the main sequence . we choose the radial distribution of the binaries to follow the surface density of stars in the thin disc : @xmath82 , with @xmath83 kpc ( @xcite ; @xcite ) , and with a maximum distance from the galactic centre of @xmath84 kpc . concerning the height above the plane , we model it as an exponential with scale height @xmath85 equal to the scale height of the thin disc ( @xmath86 kpc ; @xcite ) . this is a conservative choice for the scale height , being the scale height of massive stars in the disc typically smaller ( @xmath87 pc ; see table 4 in @xcite ) . we assume that the stars follow the galactic rotation , with no additional component . various mechanisms can heat up the stars in the disc , increasing their dispersion velocity , such as encounters with spiral density waves , giant molecular clouds , and various other forms of stochastic heating ( @xcite ; @xcite ; ; @xcite ) . , using a large sample of late - type dwarfs in the milky way disc , measured a dispersion in the three velocity - components of @xmath88 km / s , @xmath89 km / s , @xmath90 km / s at @xmath91 gyr ( see also ) . we neglect this influence , as we expect that for low - mass stars hosted in ( massive ) binaries these velocity would be significantly lower . we integrate the orbit of the binaries for @xmath19 gyr using the potential from @xcite , which is a realistic model for the milky way potential . we record the position along the orbit every @xmath19 myr after @xmath25 gyr . using the catalogue of , we classify the systems into three main groups : 1 . short - period , dynamically confirmed bh - xrbs ( 9 systems ) ; 2 . short - period , dynamically confirmed bh - xrbs + short - period bh candidates ( 15 systems ) ; 3 . short- and long - period , dynamically confirmed bh - xrbs ( 12 systems ) , which we list in table [ tab : systems ] , along with their galactic position @xmath5 derived from their sky - position and distance . dynamically - confirmed bhs are those for which a dynamical measurement of the bh mass is available ( see e.g. @xcite ) . * 3|l| name & r & @xmath92 + & & + + xte j1118 + 480 & @xmath93 @xmath94 & @xmath95 @xmath96 + gro j0422 + 32 & @xmath97 @xmath98 & @xmath99 @xmath100 + grs 1009 - 45 & @xmath101 @xmath102 & @xmath103 @xmath104 + 1a 0620 - 00 & @xmath105 @xmath106 & @xmath107 @xmath108 + gs 2000 + 251 & @xmath109 @xmath110 & @xmath111 @xmath112 + nova mus 91 & @xmath113 @xmath96 & @xmath114 @xmath104 + h 1705 - 250 & @xmath115 @xmath116 & @xmath117 @xmath118 + xte j1650 - 500 & @xmath119 @xmath120 & @xmath121 @xmath122 + xte j1859 + 226 & @xmath123 @xmath124 & @xmath125 @xmath126 + + xte j1550 - 564 & @xmath127 @xmath128 & @xmath129 @xmath130 + grs 1915 + 105 & @xmath131 @xmath132 & @xmath133 @xmath134 + gs 2023 + 338 ( v404 cyg ) & @xmath135 @xmath136 & @xmath137 @xmath138 + + maxi j1836 - 194 & @xmath139 @xmath140 & @xmath141 @xmath142 + maxi j1659 - 152 & @xmath143 @xmath144 & @xmath145 @xmath146 + xte j1752 - 223 & @xmath147 @xmath148 & @xmath149 @xmath150 + swift j1753.5 - 0127 & @xmath151 @xmath126 & @xmath152 @xmath153 + 4u 1755 - 338 & @xmath154 @xmath155 & @xmath156 @xmath102 + grs 1716 - 249 & @xmath157 @xmath158 & @xmath159 @xmath130 + the observed bh - xrbs are both long ( @xmath160 day ) and short orbital period ( @xmath161 day ) , thereby originating from different evolutionary paths . hence , in order to compare the observed systems with the simulated binaries , we need to produce two separate synthetic population of binaries , one population with short - period and one population with long - period , to which we compare the observed binaries according to their type . for the short - period binaries , we follow the binary evolution of simulated binaries using the method we explained in section [ sec : bps ] . for the long period ones , which are driven by the nuclear evolution of the donor , we model them assuming the post supernova orbital separation to be such that @xmath162 , where @xmath163 is the circularised orbital separation and @xmath164 is the eccentricity in the post - sn configuration . this assumption is based on the fact that long - period binaries evolve to longer and longer period during the mt phase , hence : @xmath165 , where @xmath166 is the orbital separation at the onset of mt , and @xmath167 is the observed orbital separation . the assumptions on the compact object formation are the same as for the short - period binaries , as well as the masses of the binary components . since our simulated binaries have a companion mass of @xmath70 , we exclude from the observed sample those binaries with a companion mass : @xmath168 ( gro j1655 - 40 , 4u 1543 - 475 , and sax j1819.3 - 2525 ) . we account for a possible observational bias on the dynamically - confirmed bh - xrbs . in order to get a dynamical measurement of the bh mass , hence fully confirming the nature of the source , high signal - to - noise optical spectra are required ; this might be prevented in regions of high extinctions , i.e. in and close to the galactic plane . we then remove from our simulated populations those binaries which are located at @xmath169 kpc . we note that the lowest @xmath0 in the sample of short - period dynamically confirmed bh binaries is for 1a 0620 - 00 ( @xmath170 kpc ; see table [ tab : systems ] ) . for the long - period binaries , we exclude from the study the sources grs 1915 + 105 ( donor spectral type : k1/5 iii ) and v404 cyg ( donor spectral type : k0 iv ) , which are located at @xmath171 kpc and @xmath172 kpc respectively ( see table [ tab : systems ] ) . these two systems do have a dynamical measurement of the bh mass ( see @xcite ) . in figure [ fig : spectype ] we plot the absolute value of the height @xmath0 versus the spectral type and luminosity class of the @xmath173 to which we add the three bh - xrbs with an intermediate - mass companion . ] dynamically - confirmed bh - xrbs ( the spectral types are from ) . at small @xmath0 , stars have an earlier spectral type and/or are giants or sub - giants . whereas ms / dwarf stars tend to be seen at larger distances above the plane . and the spectral type and luminosity class of the 15 dynamically - confirmed bh - xrbs . when the spectral type of the donor star in the system is not univocally identified , we indicate the range of possible types . ] the only long - period binary in our sample , after removing those sources close to the galactic plane , is xte j1550 - 564 , which has a current orbital separation of @xmath174 , consistent with our assumption on @xmath163 . the galactic population of ns - xrbs consists of more than @xmath175 objects ( see @xcite and references therein ) . for our study , we select the @xmath176 ones with a short - orbital period ( @xmath177 day ; see table 2 in @xcite ) . the identification of a ns - xrb typically occurs via the detection of x - ray bursts which ignite on the surface of the ns . therefore , unlike for bhs , there are potentially no biases against the identification of such systems . the scale height of bh- and ns - xrbs is a proxy of the effect of different compact object formation mechanisms on to the galactic distribution of the binaries . we quantity the scale height of the binaries as the rms of their height @xmath0 as a function of @xmath26 for all points . to plot the results , we bin the systems into @xmath25 kpc - wide bins in the @xmath26-direction . we show the results in figure [ fig : zrms ] for the six models . the monotonic rise of @xmath178 is expected , since the galactic potential becomes weaker further away from the galactic centre , and the binary moves further up for the same initial velocity it is interesting to note that if bhs and nss receive the same nk , they would still show a different scale height , with nss reaching larger distances from the galactic plane ( compare black solid line with grey solid line , and black dashed line with grey dashed line ) . this is due to the fact that for the same linear momentum , a binary with a larger mass receives a lower @xmath17 ( as is shown in figure [ fig : vsys ] ) . if the progenitor of the bh ejects mass at core - collapse as in model 3 ( see black dashed - dotted line in figure [ fig : zrms ] ) , it will move further out from the plane than when no mass is ejected , since the mass ejection adds an extra contribution to @xmath17 . furthermore , @xmath17 does not depend on the mass of the bh when no mass is ejected at bh formation ( black dashed and black dotted lines in figure [ fig : zrms ] ) , since it scales as @xmath179 , for low - mass companion stars ( see equation [ eq : pec ] ) . in figure [ fig : vsys ] we also show as arrows the lower limits on the peculiar velocity at birth of the 9 bh - xrbs we studied in section [ sec : effect ] . it is clear that a high - nk distribution ( darker - grey solid line ) more easily accounts for the higher - velocity systems , as @xmath180 systems lie in or beyond the high - velocity tail of the distribution corresponding to the low - nk model . @xcite found a similar @xmath178 between ns- and bh - xrbs and deduced that bhs should receive nks too , unless differences in the binary evolution and observational biases were strong . we confirm that accounting for binary evolution does not strongly change the galactic distributions of bh- and ns - xrbs . however , the scale height does strongly depend on the position in the disc . we compute the @xmath178 of the observed bh - xrbs , both of the whole sample and of the dynamically - confirmed systems only . we find a rms of @xmath181 kpc and @xmath182 kpc respectively . for the short - period ns systems , we calculate a @xmath178 of @xmath183 kpc , when excluding the source xte j2123 - 058 since its velocity is consistent with being a halo source , as @xcite noted . the error on these @xmath178-values accounts for the uncertainty on the distance to the sources . in figure [ fig : space ] we show the galactic distribution of ns and bh systems ( the lines account for the uncertainty in the distance to the source ) . the result that ns systems should have a larger scale height than bh systems is consistent with what the observed populations show . above the galactic plane of simulated bh- and ns - xrbs for the different models used . ] ( after the formation of the compact object ) of bh - xrbs in model 1 ( black solid line ) and model 2 ( black dashed line ) , and of ns - xrbs in model 5 ( grey solid line ) and model 6 ( grey dashed line ) . the dotted and dotted - dashed dark - grey lines are variations of model 1 ( see section [ sec : discussion ] for details ) . the arrows represent the lower limits on the peculiar velocity at birth for the 9 short - period bh - xrbs using the potential from @xcite . ] is the distance from the galactic center projected on to the plane , and @xmath0 is the height above the plane . one ns - xrb falls off the figure : xte j2123 - 058 . for each source , the line accounts for the uncertainty on the distance . we also show the results from the population study in terms of @xmath178 as a function of @xmath26 : model 1 ( grey lines ) , model 2 ( grey - dashed lines ) , model 3 ( grey - dotted lines ) . ] in the models we used in section [ sec : bps ] , the orbit of the binary progenitors of bh- and ns - xrbs was chosen to be uniformly distributed in the range @xmath184~r_\odot$ ] . it could be that this choice biases our results towards certain values for @xmath17 . to test this , we check how the distribution of the initial orbital separation of the binaries ( i.e. prior to the formation of the compact object ) varies with the magnitude of the nk and of @xmath17 . from figure [ fig : presn ] , it is clear that the majority of the initial orbital separations are constrained to lie within a small range ( @xmath185 ) both for ns and bh systems , and both for high and low nks . furthermore , there is no clear trend of @xmath17 with respect to @xmath186 . we hence conclude that it is unlikely that the peculiar velocities @xmath17 would be very much influenced if the pre - sn orbits had a distribution different from the uniform one we use in our study , or if they were drawn from a smaller range . and the orbital separation @xmath186 of bh- and ns - xrbs prior to the formation of the compact object . each panel corresponds to different assumptions on the nk . the fraction of systems in each 2-dimensional bin is shown ; darker colours correspond to a larger fraction of systems.,title="fig : " ] and the orbital separation @xmath186 of bh- and ns - xrbs prior to the formation of the compact object . each panel corresponds to different assumptions on the nk . the fraction of systems in each 2-dimensional bin is shown ; darker colours correspond to a larger fraction of systems.,title="fig : " ] we now turn to the comparison of the different models with the observed bh - xrbs . in order to compare the simulations with the observed systems , we note that every subgroup of bh binaries of table [ tab : systems ] gives rise to a certain 2d distribution in @xmath26 and @xmath0 . one way of proceeding would be to compare the 2d simulated distribution with the 2d observed one . we compare the data with the simulated populations dividing the galaxy into @xmath25 kpc - wide bins along the @xmath26-direction . this allows to account for the fact that the galactic potential is a strong function of the position in the disk , as we showed in section [ sec : effect ] . for every @xmath26-bin , we compute the cumulative distribution function ( cdf ) of the height @xmath0 above the galactic plane based on the population synthesis results within model 1 and model 2 ( see as an example black and grey lines in figure [ fig : intersection ] , for the bin : @xmath187 $ ] kpc ) . then we calculate where in the cumulative distribution the observed systems lie ( see as an example the intersection between the blue vertical lines and the cdfs in figure [ fig : intersection ] ) . in such a way , we obtain a list of percentiles . if the model is correct , we expect these percentiles to be drawn from the uniform distribution . we note that we have removed from our comparison those sources located in the bulge of the galaxy ( i.e. h 1705 - 250 and maxi j1659 - 152 ) , which could have had a different origin rather than having formed in the plane ( see section [ sec : effect ] ) . we plot the cumulative distribution of these percentiles in figures [ fig : obs1 ] ( short - period confirmed bh - xrbs ) , [ fig : obs2 ] ( short - period confirmed + candidates ) , and [ fig : obs4 ] ( whole sample ) . in the figures , the solid lines correspond to model 1 and the dashed lines correspond to model 2 . we also consider a model which consists of a superposition of model 1 and model 2 in equal parts ( see thin solid in figure [ fig : obs1 ] , in the case of the short - period confirmed bh - xrbs ) . the model which fits best is the one which comes closer to the diagonal line ( that represents the cumulative of a uniform distribution ) . in all three cases , a high nk distribution is the most preferable one . we perform a kolmogorov - smirnov ( ks ) test to measure how close is the distribution of percentiles to the diagonal line of figures [ fig : obs1 ] , [ fig : obs2 ] , [ fig : obs4 ] . we summarise the @xmath188-values and their corresponding probabilities in table [ tab : dvalues ] for every subgroups of bh - xrbs . for each of the sub - groups the high - nk model fits the data best , although in the group with confirmed bhs only , the low - nk is also consistent with the data . for the confirmed+candidate short - period systems as well as for the whole sample , the low - nk model is inconsistent . interestingly , the model in which the bhs receive both low and high nks , fits the data best for the confirmed systems . in these results , we have excluded all the systems in the plane ( both observed and simulated ) . an accurate modelling of the obscured systems would require a model for the galactic extinction in and out of the plane combined with a model for the optical / nir magnitudes of bh - xrbs in their quiescent state . as a first step , we simplistically model the observational effects near the galactic plane including a certain fraction of those simulated points which end up in the galactic disc ( at @xmath189 kpc ) : either @xmath190 , or @xmath191 , or @xmath192 . we compare the galactic distribution of these simulated binaries with the distribution of the whole sample of binaries , including this time the obscured sources grs 1915 + 105 and v404 cyg as well . the results are presented in figure [ fig : obs5 ] and table [ tab : dvalues ] . also when including the obscured systems , the high - kick model is the most successful in reproducing the observed binaries . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] the distance @xmath193 to a bh - xrb is typically estimated by measuring the apparent magnitude of the companion star in a certain colour band , and computing its absolute magnitude . once an estimate of the reddening towards the source is known and the spectral type of the donor star is clearly identified , the distance can be calculated . in the best case scenario , one would have the apparent magnitude of the source in different bands , and then would compute the scatter between the derived distances as estimate of the distance uncertainty . we expect such uncertainties to follow a gaussian distribution . however , in case a range of spectral types is equally probable , we expect the errors on the distance to be distributed more uniformly . to investigate the influence of the uncertainty in the distance , and since for most of the literature there is no easy way of determining the type of error distribution , we randomly generate 100 values for the distance to each bh - xrb , either distributed as a gaussian ( with @xmath194 equal to the distance uncertainty @xmath195 ) or as a uniform distribution in the range @xmath196 . such errors can cause a binary to move from one @xmath26-bin to the adjacent one , affecting the percentile values . however , we find that there is no systematic shift that would make low nks fit best the observed data , @xmath195 being smaller than the discrepancy between the two distributions . for model 1 ( black lines ) and model 2 ( grey lines ) , in the bin @xmath187 $ ] kpc . solid lines correspond to the whole sample of simulated binaries ; dashed lines correspond to the remaining part of the sample after the exclusion of systems close to the galactic plane , i.e. @xmath169 kpc . the blue vertical lines represent the observed @xmath92 of 3 bh - xrbs ( from left to right : 1a 0620 - 00 ; grs 1009 - 45 ; xte j1118 + 480 ) . ] ) . the model which fits best the observed data is the one closer to the diagonal line . ] ( black lines ) , @xmath191 ( darker grey lines ) , or @xmath192 ( lighter grey lines ) . the model which fits best the observed data is the one closer to the diagonal line . ] we compare the observed @xmath0 distribution of ns systems with the distribution of the two simulated population of ns - xrbs in the context of model 5 and model 6 . we perform the comparison in the same way we did for bh - systems in section [ s : rules_for_cumul ] . from figure [ fig : obsns ] we see that none of the distributions ( solid and dashed lines ) fits the data . our goal is not to calibrate the ns nk distribution from the ns - xrb population , nor from a population model of radio pulsars ( cf . ) . nevertheless , we can note that the observed population of ns - xrbs seems to be consistent with nks larger than @xmath197 km / s . this is in line with the catalogue of pulsar proper motions by @xcite , who inferred a mean pulsar birth velocity of @xmath198 km / s . however , the derivation of pulsar velocities from the measured proper motions has to be taken with caution , because of the possible uncertainties in the proper motion measurements as well as in the distance measurements . more in general , underestimating proper motion measurement errors can lead to an overestimate of pulsar velocities , as noted by . the distance to a pulsar is typically estimated through parallax . showed that a more proper bayesian approach to calculate the distance probability function from a single parallax measurement has to be used . such method has not been applied yet to the whole population of pulsars . we show the results of the ks - test for ns systems in table [ tab : dvalues ] : both models have large @xmath188-values . for an illustrative purpose , we also compare the observed population of ns - xrbs to a simulated one in which the nk is drawn from a maxwellian distribution with @xmath199 km / s ( @xcite ) . the results of the ks test favours this distribution : @xmath200 ; see dotted line in figure [ fig : obsns ] . we note that we did not include the long - period ns - xrbs to our study as in the sample of ns - xrbs from @xcite that we are using , there is only one long - period system with a low - mass companion , cygnus x-2 . 1 . in our models of section [ sec : bps ] , we have assumed an ejected mass at bh formation of @xmath15 or @xmath55 . taking @xmath201 would not greatly affect the scale height of the binaries in the case of a high nk distribution , since the typical peculiar velocities are comparable to the case when @xmath55 are ejected ( see dotted line in figure [ fig : vsys ] ) . this is due to the fact that a high ejected - mass is compatible only with the lower - velocity tail of the nk distribution in order for the binary to stay bound . in the case of a low nk distribution , the higher ejected - mass has a greater effect on the average peculiar velocity ( see dashed - dotted line in figure [ fig : vsys ] ) . the ns systems velocities are still larger . in order for bh systems to have the same peculiar velocity as ns systems , we would need that @xmath202 , which follows from the expression for @xmath17 ( equation [ eq : pec ] ) , imposing that @xmath203 and assuming that @xmath204 . this would constraint @xmath54 to be much larger than what is allowed for the binary to stay bound . 2 . in the modelling of the progenitors of bh- and ns - xrbs , we have assumed a flat distribution of the initial orbital separation in the range @xmath184~r_\odot$ ] ( section [ sec : bps ] ) . with this choice , we are including all possible pre - sn orbital separations . in @xcite we verified that larger separations do not contribute to the final separation of the binary ( see their figure 13 ) . this is due to the fact that the strength of the coupling between tides and magnetic braking , which is responsible for the shrinking of a binary to short orbital periods , decreases strongly with larger orbital separations . for long - period bh - xrbs , this choice is also acceptable , as none of the observed binaries in our sample have an orbital separation larger than @xmath205 . there could be of course cases in which the orbit in the post - sn phase is highly eccentric and very wide , but these cases would contribute only to a minority of the systems . more importantly , we have found that the nk distribution does not in fact depend on the pre - sn orbital period ( see figure [ fig : presn ] , where there is no trend of the orbital separation depending on the nk ) . we can also compare the circularised orbital period distribution after the sn in our models , @xmath206 , with the one in @xcite , who did detailed evolutionary calculations of ns - lmxbs . in our models , @xmath206 ranges from @xmath207 days to @xmath208 days , which is compatible with the range shown by @xcite in their figure 1 . we have assumed that the companion of bhs and nss are stars with an initial mass of @xmath70 . @xcite argued that the majority of lmxbs have likely originated from binaries with an intermediate mass companion ( @xmath209 ) . we have checked how our results would be affected when taking a companion of initial mass : @xmath210 . the peculiar velocity right after the bh formation ( see figure [ fig : vsys ] ) would decrease due to the larger binary mass : by a factor of @xmath211 on average . this implies that the nk would need to be even larger in order for the simulated systems to match the observed ones . 4 . the two maxwellian distributions used in section [ sec : bps ] do not correspond to the real physical distributions , but rather are representative of two complementary distributions , one generating large kicks , the other generating low kicks . the choice of two distributions peaked at two different velocities serves the purpose of analysing how close in magnitude are the velocities received by bhs with respect to the velocities received by nss . the nk distribution of nss can be estimated via proper motion studies of pulsars . the pulsar birth speed distribution has been estimated as a maxwellian distribution with @xmath212 km / s by @xcite ; however , one should bear in mind the caveats discussed in section [ sec : obsns ] . for bhs , the number of sources with measured 3d space velocity ( @xmath19 ; see @xcite ) is not sufficient to allow for a calibration of their nk distribution . when comparing the observed bh - xrbs with the synthetic bh - xrbs which result from our population synthesis , we found that the population in which bhs receive high nks best fit the observed data . this conclusion gains strength when including in the comparison between observations and simulated population the sources located in the bulge of the galaxy ( i.e. h 1705 - 250 and maxi j1659 - 152 ) . in this case , the ks - values for the short - period confirmed bh - xrb sample are : @xmath213 , @xmath214 , and for the short - period confirmed + candidates bh - xrb sample are : @xmath215 , @xmath216 . we did not include the long - period ns - xrbs in our study . we can still investigate how much long- and short - period ns - xrbs differ when it comes to the peculiar velocity after the sn , and hence how they differ in terms of the scale height above the galactic plane . we build a population of binaries which evolve into long - period ns - xrbs along the lines of the computational method used for long - period bh - xrbs ( see section [ sec : bps ] ) . we find that the long - period systems have slightly lower peculiar velocities , which results in a slightly lower scale height ( by a factor of @xmath217 , for every radial distance ) . this is due to the fact that the binary , having lower binding energy , can only survive lower kicks . as it was mentioned in the introduction , there is evidence for some nss receiving low kicks at birth : nss residing in double - ns systems ( @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) and nss hosted in a subset of high - mass x - ray binaries ( hmxbs ; @xcite ) . it was suggested that electron - capture sne are too fast for large asymmetries to develop , resulting in a modest kick , of a few @xmath176 km / s at maximum . such kicks are of the order of the low natal kick model we took in our binary population synthesis of section [ sec : bps ] through which we found ( section [ sec : obsns ] ) that high - kick models best fit the galactic distribution of ns - lmxbs : i.e. we did not find any evidence for nss born in an electron - capture sn . this might be due to a different evolutionary path for the progenitors of ns - lmxbs . several studies have investigated the type of sn event ( either a standard collapse of the iron core or an electron capture sn ) as a function of the evolutionary state of the helium star progenitor of the ns as well as the characteristics of the binary orbit . @xcite performed detailed evolutionary sequences of binaries hosting an ns and a helium star . they found that helium stars with an initial mass of @xmath218 could be stripped of a significant fraction of their mass through case bb mass transfer towards an ns companion when the helium star expands as a giant . the low - mass core would then form an ns via electron - capture sn , provided the initial orbital period is sufficiently wide . shorter orbital period would instead result in a white dwarf ( wd ) . we can extrapolate this finding to the short - period systems formed by an ns and a low - mass companion studied in our work . however , we must bear in mind that the stripping effect is less understood for a giant helium star experiencing mass transfer to a low - mass main - sequence star , as indeed mentioned by @xcite . thus we conclude that , heretofore , there is no strong theoretical support for a preference for electron - capture sn in the progenitors of ns - lmxbs . we also wish to note that the study by @xcite highlighted the impossibility of forming short - period ( less than one day ) ns - lmxbs without large natal kicks at birth ( where for large they chose a maxwellian distribution with an average kick of 300 km / s ) . in assessing the quality of the fit of our simulations , we used the classical application of the ks - test . in order to test its validity and determine the _ power _ of the test in distinguishing the two hypothesis we draw samples of various sizes from the simulated populations , and we calculate the @xmath188-value distribution of each of these samples , according to the rules described in section [ s : rules_for_cumul ] . we find that the probabilities follow the classical ks test ( as expected ) to an accuracy ( @xmath219 ) that is comparable to the poisson noise in our simulations ( @xmath220 ) . more interesting is the measurement of how often we obtain @xmath188-values smaller then the ones we measured for our observed samples when _ testing the wrong hypothesis _ - i.e. when using a sample drawn from the high ( low ) nk synthetic population and testing the low ( high ) nk hypothesis ( also known as false negative rate ) . for the bh case , we find @xmath188-values smaller than the ones in table [ tab : dvalues ] in less than @xmath221 of the cases , for the high nk hypothesis , and in more than @xmath222 for the low nk hypothesis . a particularly interesting fact is that @xmath223 for short - period confirmed + candidate bh - xrbs . if we accept the @xmath224 confidence level and use the standard 4-to-1 weighting ( i.e. @xmath225 ) , the test we developed has enough power to distinguish between the high- and low - nk hypothesis in this case , and that the high - nk hypothesis is clearly preferable . this is a _ non_-expected result given the small number of object , and it can potentially dissolve if some of the bh candidates turn out to be ns - xrbs . to calculate what is the optimal number of observed systems to decrease such rate @xmath226 , we draw samples of various sizes from the population synthesis results of model 1 and we test the low - nk hypothesis , and vice - versa . to decrease this rate to the level that in @xmath42 of cases we obtain @xmath227 , we find that it is necessary to increase the size of the observed sample to @xmath3 systems , both in the bh and ns case . in this work we performed a binary population synthesis study of bh- and ns - xrbs , tracing their binary evolution from the moment of compact object formation until the observed phase of mass transfer , and integrated their orbits in the galaxy . the main goal was to investigate whether different assumptions on compact object formation manifest themselves in the galactic distribution of the binaries . we found that these assumptions do affect the scale height of the binaries , which we quantified through their @xmath178 . in particular , we found that if bhs and nss receive the same nk at birth , nss would still have a larger scale height above the galactic plane , due to the fact that their systemic velocities acquired when the compact object is formed are typically larger , their total binary mass being smaller . the larger scale height of ns - xrbs with respect to bh - xrbs is clearly seen also in the observed populations . we also found a clear trend for both populations of increasing scale height for larger galactocentric radii , which should manifest itself , but which is not clearly observed in the current populations ( see figure [ fig : space ] ) . the main outcome of this study is that when analysing the @xmath0-distribution of the observed bh systems as a function of @xmath26 , the simulated population in which at least some bhs receive a ( relatively ) high nk ( @xmath228 km / s ) fits the data best . this is in agreement with previous findings by @xcite , who compared the observed and simulated populations of bh - xrbs only in the @xmath0-direction , whereas we compare the 2d distributions , accounting for how the binaries are distributed along the @xmath26-direction as well . furthermore , we increased the sample of sources adding @xmath229 bh candidates , updated their distances according to the recently published bh catalogue of , and followed the binary evolution of the binaries in a detailed way ( accounting in particular for magnetic braking and tides ) . in this work we also checked numerically the validity of a simple one - dimensional analytical estimate for the peculiar velocity at birth of bh - xrbs which we used in our previous works @xcite and @xcite . we found that this estimate is less reliable for some gravitational potentials for sources in the bulge of the galaxy , i.e at @xmath230 kpc . this was also shown by @xcite , who studied the kinematics of h 1705 - 250 , a bh - xrb close to the galactic bulge . however , the estimate is robust for systems at galactocentric radii larger than @xmath25 kpc . @xcite followed the binary evolution of seven short - period bh - xrbs and estimated their minimal peculiar velocity at birth , to conclude that two out of the seven sources were consistent with a high ( or relatively high ) nk at birth . this conclusion remains valid even in view of the current analysis . @xcite found that the rms - value of the distance to the galactic plane for bh - xrbs was similar to that of ns - xrbs . this was suggestive for bhs receiving a kick - velocity at formation . we revised the distances and updated the sample of bh - xrbs using the catalogue from and we found that ns systems have a larger scale height than bh systems , a trait which is also present in the simulated populations . finally , we found that the comparison of the data to our simulations is limited by the small number of observed bh - xrbs , and thus that more systems should be found to determine in more detail the nk that bhs receive . in this respect , the possible future discovery of new bh transients with gaia ( @xcite ) , and through dedicated surveys such as the galactic bulge survey ( @xcite ) , are promising . sr is thankful to jo bovy for answering her questions concerning galpy and for useful comments on the manuscript . sr wishes to warmly thank her office mates ( pim van oirschot , martha irene saladino , laura rossetto , thomas wevers ) at radboud university for their great moral support during the hectic times of finishing up her thesis . sr wishes to acknowledge melvyn b. davies with whom she started her research on black hole natal kicks . this research has made use of nasas astrophysics data system . o. , 2015 , in points s. , kunder a. , eds , fifty years of wide field studies in the southern hemisphere : resolved stellar populations of the galactic bulge and magellanic clouds vol . 491 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , formation models of the galactic bulge . p. 169 h. m. , 1996 , in wijers r. a. m. j. , davies m. b. , tout c. a. , eds , nato advanced science institutes ( asi ) series c vol . 477 of nato advanced science institutes ( asi ) series c , an observational approach to binary population synthesis . p. 385 g. , 2007 , in st .- louis n. , moffat a. f. j. , eds , massive stars in interactive binaries vol . 367 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , what can we learn about black - hole formation from black - hole x - ray binaries ? . p. 533 j. a. , preto m. , 2002 , in athanassoula e. , bosma a. , mujica r. , eds , disks of galaxies : kinematics , dynamics and peturbations vol . 275 of astronomical society of the pacific conference series , scattering of stars by transient spiral waves .
Abstract: | [
"the aim of this work is to study the imprints that different models for black hole ( bh ) and neutron star ( ns ) formation have on the galactic distribution of x - ray binaries ( xrbs ) which contain these objects . we find that the root mean square of the height above the galactic plane of bh- and ns - xrbs is a powerful proxy to discriminate among different formation scenarios , and that binary evolution following the bh / ns formation does not significantly affect the galactic distributions of the binaries . we find that a population model in which at least some bhs receive a ( relatively ) high natal kick fits the observed bh - xrbs best . for the ns case , we find that a high nk distribution , consistent with the one derived from the measurement of pulsar proper motion , is the most preferable . we also analyse the simple method we previously used to estimate the minimal peculiar velocity of an individual bh - xrb at birth . we find that this method may be less reliable in the bulge of the galaxy for certain models of the galactic potential , but that our estimate is excellent for most of the bh - xrbs . [ firstpage ] x - rays : binaries supernovae : general galaxy : dynamics binaries : general black hole physics stars : neutron"
] | 11,524 | 11,524 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: inflation offers a simple solution to the shortcomings of the standard hot big bang model . in addition , its predictions about the initial density perturbations , leading to the observed structure formation , are in a remarkable agreement with measurements of the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) temperature anisotropies . among the various inflationary models , one should select the ones which lead to a better agreement with data , with the additional requirement that such models should be naturally built within a fundamental theoretical framework . in spite of its enormous success , inflation remains still a paradigm in search of a model . despite the elegance of chaotic inflation @xcite , this simple model faces a fine tuning problem . consistency , between predictions for the amplitude of cmb temperature anisotropies and measurements , requires a tiny coupling constant . to avoid this problem , linde @xcite has proposed hybrid inflation , a model of inflation based on einstein gravity , but driven by a false vacuum . in this model , the inflaton field rolls while another scalar field remains trapped in a false vacuum state . the false vacuum becomes unstable when the magnitude of the inflaton field falls below some critical value , leading to a phase transition to the true vacuum . the energy density is dominated by the false vacuum energy density so that the phase transition signals the end of hybrid inflation . the phase transition at the end of inflation leads to topological defect formation @xcite . theoretically motivated inflationary models can be built in a context of supersymmetry ( susy ) and supergravity ( sugra ) theories . @xmath1 supersymmetric models contain complex scalar fields , which often have flat directions in their potential , thus offering natural candidates for inflationary models . in this framework , hybrid inflation ( driven by the f - terms or the d - terms ) are the most standard models . such inflationary models lead generically to cosmic string formation at the end of the inflationary era . cosmic strings in supersymmetric theories may have new properties , as compared to their non - supersymmetric counterparts ; we do not address this issue here . a gauge symmetry can be broken spontaneously in @xmath1 globally supersymmetric theories , either by adding f - terms to the superpotential or , in the abelian case , by introducing fayet - iliopoulos ( fi ) d - terms . the higgs mechanism leads generically @xcite to abrikosov - nielsen - olesen ( ano ) strings . depending whether they were formed at the end of f- or d - term inflation they are called f - term or d - term strings , respectively . f - term inflation is potentially plagued with the @xmath0-problem , while d - term inflation avoids it . this problem arises from the presence of large corrections ( of the order of the hubble parameter during inflation ) to the inflaton mass , which spoil the required flatness of the inflaton potential . d - term inflation can be successfully implemented in the framework of sugra , while in addition , it can be easily accommodated within string theory models . in the simplest models of d - term inflation within sugra , in which the constant fi term gets compensated by a single complex scalar field at the end of the inflationary era , the d - term strings formed at the end of inflation are topologically stable , since @xmath2 , with @xmath3 the vacuum manifold of the broken u(1 ) symmetry . our study concerns such models . however , they have been proposed @xcite models where d - term strings can become unstable . for example , one can introduce additional matter multiplets so as to obtain a non - trivial global symmetry such as su(2 ) , leading to a simply connected vacuum manifold and the production of semi - local strings . alternatively , it has been suggested @xcite that the waterfall higgs fields are non - trivially charged under some other gauge symmetries @xmath4 , such that the vacuum manifold , @xmath5/ u(1)$ ] , is simply connected , leading to the formation of semi - local strings . d - term inflation requires the existence of a non - zero constant fi term , which can be added to the lagrangian only in the presence of a u(1 ) gauge symmetry . this extra u(1 ) symmetry can be of a different origin . some models have been suggested for field - dependent fi terms , arising in the presence of a chiral superfield @xmath6 shifting under u(1 ) . the imaginary part of the scalar part of the chiral superfield plays the rle of an axion , and cancels the chiral anomaly by shifting under the u(1 ) symmetry . such a u(1 ) symmetry is called _ anomalous _ , or _ pseudo - anomalous _ since the total anomaly vanishes . here the fi term depends on the real part of the chiral superfield . in supersymmetry , models with anomalous fi terms have been developed @xcite within heterotic string theory . in a cosmological setup one has first to assume the stabilisation of the chiral superfield @xmath6 ; the rle of @xmath6 may be played by any modulus ( a dilaton or any volume modulus ) . only if this assumption holds the dilaton - dependent d - term can be considered as a constant fi term . however , the issue of dilaton and moduli stabilisation in the heterotic string theory is far from being resolved . it is still not clear how to derive constant fi terms from string or m - theory and only field - dependent d - terms have been identified . as we will discuss , in absence of constant fi terms , local supersymmetry requires the superpotential to be invariant under the u(1)-gauged symmetry . in the context of theories with large extra dimensions , brane inflation occurs in a similar way as hybrid inflation within supergravity , leading to cosmic string - like objects . in string theories , d - brane @xmath7-anti - brane annihilation leads generically to the production of lower dimensional d - branes , with d3- and d1-branes , which are d - strings , being predominant @xcite in iib string theories . to illustrate brane inflation let us consider @xcite a d@xmath8-@xmath9 system in iib string theory . six of the spatial dimensions are compactified on a torus , while the branes move relatively to each other in some directions . as the two branes approach , the open string modes between the branes develop a tachyon , thus an instability . brane inflation @xcite ends by a phase transition mediated by open string tachyons . since the tachyonic vacuum has a non - trivial @xmath10 homotopy group , one concludes that there must exist stable tachyonic string solutions with @xmath11 co - dimensions ; they are stable bps ( bogomolnyi - prasad - sommerfield ) d@xmath12-branes . since all dimensions are compact these daughter branes are seen as one - dimensional objects for a four - dimensional observer ; they are the d - strings . the d - strings ( d1-branes ) have been identified @xcite in the low - energy supergravity with the d - term strings . the justification for this conjecture is that only d - term strings remain bps states in @xmath13 supergravity . in supergravity , f - term strings break all the supersymmetries , whereas the d - term strings preserve half of it . an interesting and successful brane inflationary model is the d3/d7 one @xcite , which has also an effective description as a d - term inflationary model . the flat direction of the inflaton potential is associated with the shift symmetry , which protects the inflaton field from acquiring a large mass that would spoil the required flatness of the potential . in its original version this model leads to the formation of topologically stable ano bps strings . in a later developed version @xcite of the d3/d7 model , where in terms of an effective gauge theory the model has a local u(1 ) gauge symmetry and a global su(2 ) symmetry , semi - local strings are formed . such strings can unwind without any cost of potential energy . in what follows we concentrate on inflationary models leading to the formation of topologically stable strings . strings formed at the end of an inflationary era , contribute @xcite in the spectrum of temperature anisotropies ; their contribution is heavily constrained from cmb data . compatibility between cmb measurements and theoretical predictions constrain @xcite the parameters space ( mass scales and couplings ) of the inflationary models . these constraints have been obtained @xcite for d - term inflation within minimal sugra . here , we would like to investigate whether the constraints on the parameters space are a result of our choice of minimal supergravity , or whether they are a generic outcome of d - term hybrid inflation . we will therefore examine d - term inflation originated by different choices of the khler potential . the main motivation being that a minimal khler potential can be considered as a peculiar and unmotivated choice @xcite . we base our study in a formulation of supergravity constructed from superconformal theory , since the standard formulation may be insufficient in the presence of constant fayet - iliopoulos terms @xcite . to be able to constrain the parameters space of the models we should know the power spectrum of a cosmic strings network and the allowed upper limit on the cosmic string contribution to the measured temperature anisotropy spectrum . the upper limit imposed on the cosmic string contribution to the cmb data depends on the numerical simulation employed in order to calculate the cosmic string power spectrum . the upper limit found in the literature @xcite is @xmath14 or @xmath15 , depending on the simulation , with @xmath16 confidence level . there are some uncertainties in these results due to the cosmic string evolution codes they are based on was found using the results of ref . @xcite , based on the velocity - dependent one - scale model for the string evolution . this approach is certainly not the best . the upper limit of @xmath15 was found using the results of ref . @xcite ; however recently the authors have corrected @xcite a mistake in their code , which has not been taken into account in ref . note however that the corrected version of the code @xcite seems to give similar results . we believe that the recent publication given in ref . @xcite is the best , at present , approach . ] and therefore in our calculations we use an average value for the upper bound equal to @xmath17 . note that none of the existing simulations take into account a non trivial microstructure of the cosmic strings formed : however they have been shown to be superconducting in supersymmetric abelian symmetry breaking through f- or d - terms @xcite . we plan the rest of the paper as follows : in section ii we address hybrid d - term inflation , first within the standard formulation of supergravity , and subsequently within the effective supergravity theory built upon superconformal field theory . in the rest of the paper we focus on the second approach . we briefly review the effective supergravity formulation because of its consequences for d - term inflation , often not taken into consideration . in section iii we review d - term inflation in minimal supergravity . in section iv we discuss inflation in a supergravity theory with shift symmetry . in section v we consider d - term inflation in supergravity models with higher order terms , including all corrections up to order @xmath18 . we round up our conclusions in section vi . we first review hybrid d - term inflation model in its standard supergravity formulation . following the standard formulation of supergravity @xcite , the general sugra lagrangian for chiral superfields @xmath19 , and a vector superfield , depends on three generic functions : the khler potential @xmath20 , the superpotential @xmath21 , and the kinetic function @xmath22 for the vector multiplets . it can be expressed as an integral over the grassmann variables @xmath23 and @xmath24 ( over superspace ) , as @xcite : @xmath25\nonumber\\ & & + \int { \mathrm{d}}^2\theta [ f_{ab}(\phi_i)w_a^{\ \alpha } w_{\alpha b } + { \rm h.c.}]~ , \label{lagrsugra}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where _ h.c . _ stands for hermitian conjugate . it turns out that the effective lagrangian obtained from eq . ( [ lagrsugra ] ) depends only on one combination of the khler potential @xmath20 and the superpotential @xmath21 , the following : @xmath26 a priori , the only restriction for the choice of the khler potential @xmath27 and the superpotential @xmath28 is that @xmath27 must be a real function and @xmath28 must be a holomorphic function . however , there exists a degeneracy in the choices of @xmath27 and @xmath28 , while the lagrangian is invariant under the _ khler transformation _ @xmath29 assuming that the lagrangian must be invariant also under a gauge symmetry , @xmath28 and @xmath27 must be invariant , at least up to a khler transformation . the gauge kinetic function @xmath22 must be holomorphic and covariant under gauge symmetry . choosing for example the _ minimal khler potential _ @xmath30 the kinetic terms for the scalar parts of the @xmath19 s are simply @xmath31 in minimal sugra , we also set the gauge kinetic function @xmath32 equal to @xmath33 . within this framework of supergravity , and assuming that there is a gauge symmetry , the scalar potential @xmath34 for the scalar components @xmath35 of the superfields @xmath19 reads @xmath36 + \frac{1}{2}\left[{\rm re } f_{ab}(\phi_i)\right]^{-1}\sum_a g^2_a d^2_a~;\ ] ] the first term in the _ r.h.s _ of eq . ( [ formpotenscal ] ) is called _ f - term _ and the second one _ d - term_. while the f - term has in general positive and negative contributions , the d - term is positive definite . @xmath37 is given by @xmath38 where the fayet - iliopoulos term , @xmath39 , is non - zero only if the gauge symmetry is abelian ; @xmath40 is the gauge coupling of the symmetry generated by @xmath41 . assuming a constant fi term , d - term potential may lead to de sitter type of solutions , which is particularly interested for building an inflationary model within supergravity . the standard d - term hybrid inflation model is based on the superpotential @xcite @xmath42 where @xmath43 are three chiral superfields and @xmath44 is the superpotential coupling . this model assumes an invariance under an abelian gauge group @xmath45 , under which the three superfields , @xmath43 , have charges @xmath46 , @xmath47 and @xmath48 , respectively . this model also assumes the existence of a constant fi term . however , the above summarised supergravity formulation ( called hereafter _ standard _ ) is inappropriate to describe d - term inflation @xcite . indeed , in d - term inflation the superpotential vanishes at the unstable de sitter vacuum , as it also vanishes in the absolute minkowski vacuum ; anywhere else the superpotential is non - zero . thus , the standard formulation of supergravity , where the lagrangian depends on @xmath27 and @xmath28 only through the combination given in eq . ( [ kwcomb ] ) is inappropriate , since the theory is ill defined at @xmath49 . in conclusion , d - term inflation in supergravity must be described with a non - singular formulation of sugra when the superpotential vanishes . various formulations of effective supergravity can be constructed from the superconformal field theory ( see , ref . @xcite for a recent review ) . the main idea is , in a first stage , to build a lagrangian with full superconformal theory . in a second stage , the gauge symmetries that are absent in poincar supergravity ( e.g. , local dilatations , local chiral u(1)-symmetry and local s - supersymmetry ) are gauge fixed . starting from this framework in order to derive the effective supergravity theory , one can construct a non - singular theory at @xmath49 , where the action depends on all three functions , @xmath50 and @xmath32 . the superconformal field theory ( scft ) is based on the @xmath51 symmetry . the superconformal lagrangian contains three parts , each of them being separately conformally invariant . for @xmath52 chiral multiplets @xmath53 ( with @xmath54 and some vector multiplets @xmath55 superconformally coupled to supergravity , the superconformal lagrangian reads @xcite @xmath56_d + \left[{\mathcal{w}}(x ) \right]_f + \left[f_{\alpha\beta}(x ) \bar{\lambda}^\alpha \lambda^\beta\right]_f~.\ ] ] the homogeneous function @xmath57 and the holomorphic functions @xmath58 , @xmath59 encode the khler potential , the superpotential and gauge kinetic function , respectively , once the extra gauge symmetries have been gauge - fixed . after constructing the lagrangian , we fix the extra symmetries . fixing local dilatation , the number of chiral scalars is decreased by one : there will be only @xmath60 physical scalar fields in supergravity . fixing s - supersymmetry makes a free fermion field to be removed . one thus makes a transformation from the @xmath52 variables @xmath53 to the _ conformon _ scalar @xmath61 and @xmath60 physical scalars @xmath62 , the @xmath60 chiral superfields of standard supergravity . more precisely , @xmath63 where @xmath64 are a set of holomorphic functions . the khler potential @xmath65 is related to the function @xmath57 , appearing in the superconformal lagrangian , and the conformon superfield @xmath61 through @xmath66 chiral and dilatation symmetry imply that the holomorphic function @xmath67 is @xmath68 apart the local @xmath51 symmetry , the lagrangian may also have some yang - mills gauge symmetries , which commute with local superconformal symmetries . the superconformal functions @xmath69 are invariant , while the superconformal function @xmath32 is covariant under the yang - mills gauge symmetries . the yang - mills transformations of all chiral superfields in the superconformal action are @xmath70 @xmath71 and @xmath72 are @xmath52 holomorphic functions for every symmetry . note that the splitting given in eq . ( [ splitting]a ) is not unique ; the action invariance under khler transformation , eq . ( [ defkahltransf ] ) , has its origin exactly in this remark . the meaning of the value of @xmath73 is the transformation of the conformon field @xmath61 . the invariance of @xmath74 leads to @xcite @xmath75\right\}~,\ ] ] implying that @xmath71 describes the non - invariance of the khler potential @xmath76 given by @xmath77 . note that derivatives @xmath78 ( and @xmath79 ) stand for derivatives w.r.t . @xmath62 ( and @xmath80 , respectively ) . assuming that the transformation of the conformon superfield @xmath61 is given by imaginary constants , then @xmath81 @xmath82 is the gauge coupling constant . if @xmath83 , the conformon superfield @xmath61 transforms under a @xmath84 . only if @xmath85 the symmetry is preserved without corrections of the superconformal u(1 ) . equation ( [ transfofi]a ) shows the superconformal origin of fi terms via the gauge transformations of the conformon field . equation ( [ ralpha ] ) implies that the khler potential is invariant @xcite @xmath86 the function @xmath67 should be invariant under yang - mills transformations , @xmath87 implying @xmath88 since the _ r.h.s . _ of the above equation , eq . ( [ noninv ] ) , is non - zero when fi terms are present , one concludes that the superpotential @xmath28 can not be gauge invariant , if the conformon multiplet @xmath61 transforms under gauge transformations . assuming that @xmath73 is given by eq . ( [ transfofi]a ) , which corresponds to a constant fi term in supergravity , one gets @xcite @xmath89 to construct a formulation of supergravity with constant fi terms from superconformal theory , one finds @xcite that under u(1 ) gauge transformations in the directions in which there are constant fi terms @xmath90 , the superpotential @xmath28 must transform as in eq . ( [ transfow ] ) . as a consequence , we can not keep any longer the charge assignment described in the case of standard supergravity . as it was explicitly shown in ref . @xcite , the gauge fixing of the local dilatational invariance introduces the mass scale @xmath91 , which we set @xmath92 , and fixes the value of the conformon superfield in terms of the khler potential @xmath76 , which depends only on the physical scalars @xmath93 and @xmath94 , namely @xmath95 the value @xmath96 being fixed , we then fix the phase of @xmath61 . the superconformal lagrangian , eq . ( [ lagrangsuperconf ] ) , is invariant under the redefinition @xmath97 for an arbitrary holomorphic function @xmath98 , since this redefinition can be absorbed in a redefinition of @xmath62 . we can check that the effect of this redefinition on @xmath65 and @xmath28 is precisely the khler transformation introduced in eq . ( [ defkahltransf ] ) . two choices have been proposed @xcite in order to fix the phase of @xmath61 . either @xmath99 leading to the standard formulation of sugra , described previously , or alternatively @xmath100 the first choice , eq . ( [ choice1 ] ) , makes sense only for @xmath101 , while the second one , eq . ( [ choice2 ] ) , is appropriate for cases where @xmath67 can become zero . since in what follows we focus on d - term inflation , where the superpotential vanishes during inflation as well as at the end of the inflationary era , we adopt the second choice of gauge fixing . in this case , the form of the lagrangian is explicitly given in refs . we give below several quantities which are of interest for the purpose of our study . to switch to dimensional khler potential and fields , we redefine @xmath62 and @xmath65 , as @xcite @xmath102 @xmath103 is regular at @xmath104 . we denote the scalar part of the superfield @xmath19 by @xmath35 . from now on derivatives @xmath78 stand for derivatives w.r.t . @xmath35 ; we thus use the fields @xmath35 and their complex conjugates @xmath105 to indicate scalar fields . the previous choice of conformon transformation , eq . ( [ transfofi ] ) , now reads @xmath106 . the supergravity lagrangian depends on @xmath107 and @xmath108 . constant fi terms can be introduced for some of the u(1 ) gauge groups . we write below the bosonic and fermionic parts of the lagrangian for the scalar fields @xmath35 , which are relevant for d - term inflation in the context of supergravity formulated using superconformal theory . the part of the bosonic sector which interests us , is @xmath109 with @xmath110\nonumber\\ v_d&=&\frac{1}{2}\left[({\rm re}f)^{-1}\right]^{\alpha\beta } { \mathcal{p}}_\alpha { \mathcal{p}}_\beta~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath111~,\ ] ] and @xmath112 the fermionic mass terms for fermions @xmath113 of chiral supermultiplets @xmath35 are given by the fermionic sector of the lagrangian , namely @xcite @xmath114 -m^{ij}\bar{\chi}_i\chi_j - m_{ij}\bar{\chi}^i\chi^j + e^{-1}{\mathcal{l}}_{\rm mix}~,\ ] ] where @xmath115 and @xmath116 and where the khler metric and khler connection are defined by @xmath117 in addition to the standard mass terms proportional to @xmath118 , some mixing mass terms between the chiral fermions @xmath113 and the gaugino or the gravitino are contained in @xmath119 . they can potentially contribute to the fermionic mass matrix @xcite : @xmath120~,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath121\nonumber\\ v_l^1&=&\frac{1}{2}i{\mathcal{p}}_\alpha\lambda_l^\alpha+m^i\chi_i~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the case of non vanishing @xmath119 , the masses of are obtained by diagonalising the fermionic mass matrix . let us investigate the consequences of a formulation of supergravity constructed from superconformal theory for d - term inflation . first , the transformation of the sugra superpotential given by the eq . ( [ transfow ] ) imposes a modification of the charge assignment of section [ sec : stdsugraformul ] . this charge assignment holds for the global supersymmetric limit . since the charge of the superpotential is given by the sum of the charges of the fields @xmath122 , @xmath123 , we must impose @xcite @xmath124 note that as a consequence , we can relate the fi amplitude to the anomaly of the symmetry u(1 ) @xmath125 similarly to the generation of fi terms with anomalous u(1 ) symmetry within weakly coupled string theories . in ref . @xcite the authors suggest a way to solve the anomalous u(1 ) symmetry . more precisely , the authors introduce new matter superfields , which are not involved in inflation , with appropriate charge assignments so that the anomaly gets cancelled four - dimensional supergravity with fayet - iliopoulos couplings has been recently addressed in refs . @xcite . ] . in order to avoid an @xmath126problem we set @xmath127 . this modification of the charge assignment induces a modification of the d - terms of the scalar potential . since the function @xmath27 is real and @xmath28 is holomorphic , we can check that the expression of the f - terms , eq . ( [ potenfterms ] ) , is identical to the standard formulation of supergravity . concerning the radiative corrections , the modification of the charges induces a modification of the mass terms for the scalar components of the chiral superfields , since part of their mass terms comes from the d - terms . the fermionic lagrangian , eq . ( [ lagrangfermio ] ) , is identical to the expression obtained in the context of standard supergravity given in @xcite . note that in the case of interest , there are no additional contributions to the chiral fermion mass terms from @xmath119 given in eq . ( [ lagrangfermiomix ] ) . the last consequence of the superconformal origin of supergravity concerns the form of the superpotential . we first remark that the transformation of the superpotential , eq . ( [ transfow ] ) , combined with the requirement that the inflaton field should remain uncharged in order to avoid the @xmath0-problem , protect the form of the superpotential @xmath128 all non - renormalisable terms of the form @xmath129 are forbidden . secondly , if we assume in addition that the superfields and the superpotential transform under an r - symmetry as @xmath130 then all terms proportional to @xmath131 , with @xmath132 , and all terms of the form @xmath133 or @xmath134 are forbidden . we end up with a d - term inflation that is precisely described by the minimal superpotential , eq . ( [ superpot ] ) , even if in supergravity non - renormalisable terms can be present . this motivates our choice to consider in this work , the standard form of superpotential . the minimal supergravity description is based on the minimal khler potential @xmath135 and the minimal structure for @xmath22 , namely @xmath136 . the tree level scalar potential reads @xcite @xmath137\nonumber \\ & & + \frac{g^2}{2}\left(q_+|\phi_+|^2+q_-|\phi_-|^2+\xi\right)^2~.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the next step is the calculation of the masses of the components of the superfields @xmath123 . the scalar mass squared can be read directly from the scalar potential @xcite , namely @xmath138 strictly speaking , one must use the charge assignment given by eq . ( [ chargassign ] ) , for example , @xmath139 hereafter we assume @xmath140 and therefore the expression for the scalar masses , eq . ( [ scalmass ] ) , can be approximated as @xmath141 in the inflationary valley , where @xmath142 , the associated dirac fermions have a mass squared @xmath143 unchanged compared to the case of standard minimal supergravity @xcite . using the coleman - weinberg formula , we can then compute the effective inflationary potential , taking into account the tree - level and the one - loop radiative corrections due to the mass splitting between components of the chiral superfields @xmath123 . the effective potential reads @xcite @xmath144 \right\ } ~,\ ] ] where @xmath145 and @xmath146 d - term inflation leads to cosmic strings formation at the end of the inflationary era . consistency between cmb measurements and theoretical predictions constrain the parameters space . the constrains are imposed on the couplings and mass scales . they are shown in fig . [ fig : dtermstandard ] and can be summarised as @xcite @xmath147 the above constraints , eq . ( [ constrdmin ] ) , can be expressed @xcite as a single constraint on the fayet - iliopoulos term @xmath148 , namely , @xmath149 we can therefore see that our assumption that @xmath150 in eq . ( [ approxmass ] ) is justified @xcite , which implies that for the purpose of our study and for minimal d - term inflation , we can neglect the corrections introduced by the superconformal origin of supergravity . moreover , since the tree level potential is given by @xmath151 , the limit @xmath152 should hold since otherwise the energy density would become transplankian and the quantum gravity corrections , which have been so far neglected @xcite , would become important @xcite . + , as a function of the superpotential coupling constant @xmath44 . ] in what follows we address whether the restrictions found in the framework of minimal sugra , are still qualitatively valid for a non - minimal sugra theory . we will thus study d - term hybrid inflation with a superpotential @xmath28 defined by eq . ( [ superpoteninflad ] ) and different choices for the form of the khler potential . we first study hybrid inflation in the context of supergravity , with a khler potential obeying a shift symmetry . this symmetry can be used for model building in the framework of supergravity , while it is also motivated from string theory @xcite . more precisely , the shift symmetry , @xmath153 with @xmath154 a real constant , has been used in order to obtain flat potentials from f - terms in sugra , so that the @xmath0-problem is cured , or to make compatible chaotic inflation , which requires an inflaton field larger than the planck scale , and supergravity @xcite . thus , we consider the following form for the khler potential @xmath155 and minimal structure for the kinetic function . we note that compared to the minimal khler potential , eq . ( [ kmin ] ) , @xmath156 has two additional terms , , @xmath157 and @xmath158 , which do not affect the kinetic terms . comparing with the scalar potential obtained in minimal sugra , we can identify two differences . the first one is that there are several new terms proportional to @xmath164 . these terms will not affect the effective mass terms of the @xmath123 fields , thus they will not affect the inflationary potential , even when one - loop radiative corrections have been taken into account . the second one is that the exponential factor @xmath165 in minimal sugra , has been here replaced by @xmath166 . writing @xmath167 , we get @xmath168 . if we identify the inflaton field with the real part of @xmath122 , then we obtain exactly the same potential as in the minimal case . however , with the present choice for the khler potential , @xmath156 , it would be more logical to identify the inflaton field with the imaginary part of @xmath122 , namely @xmath169 . the reason being that with this choice the exponential term is constant during inflation , thus it can not spoil the slow roll conditions . then we can check that the inflationary potential we get is identical to the usual d - term inflation within the global susy framework . this model has been studied in ref . the result obtained in ref . @xcite is reminded in fig . [ dtermsusy ] . , in the case of the d - term inflation model in the framework of global susy . figure taken from ref . @xcite . ] clearly , in such a model the cosmic string contribution to the cmb anisotropies is dominant , in contradiction with the cmb measurements , unless the superpotential coupling is constrained to be @xmath170 concluding , we state that simply imposing a shift symmetry to the khler potential is not enough to _ escape _ the _ cosmic string problem _ of d - term inflation . in this section , we consider another choice of khler potential that contains non renormalisable terms . more precisely , we consider the following form @xmath171 where @xmath172 are arbitrary functions of @xmath173 . contrary to the previous section , this new form should modify the kinetic terms . the motivation for this choice is that it contains the next - to - minimal khler potential , with all terms up to order @xmath174 . we consider in a first place a reduced version of this potential and then we proceed with the full expression . we remind to the reader that our primary goal is not to build a new model for d - term inflation in the context of supergravity , but to study the robustness of our prediction that there is a dominant contribution of cosmic strings to the cmb temperature anisotropies , unless we fine tune the superpotential coupling constant @xmath44 . we first consider the case of the previous khler potential , eq . ( [ gen ] ) , setting @xmath175 , implying latexmath:[\[k_3=|s|^2+|\phi_+|^2+|\phi_-|^2+f_+\bigg(\frac{|s|^2}{m_{\rm pl}^2}\bigg)|\phi_+|^2+f_-\bigg(\frac{|s|^2}{m_{\rm pl}^2}\bigg ) arbitrary functions of @xmath173 , while the superpotential is given in eq . ( [ superpoteninflad ] ) . one can argue that the khler potential given in eq . ( [ kahlerseto1 ] ) is quite general , since during inflation the higgs fields are small . however , one can also criticise this choice for the following reason : even though @xmath177-terms are indeed negligible as compared to the @xmath178-ones ( the @xmath179-terms are small during the inflationary era ) there is no reason for neglecting @xmath180-terms . they will be taken into account in next section . note that the expression for the effective scalar potential is identical to that of minimal supergravity , except for the expression of @xmath93 . the first derivative of the potential is equal to @xmath194 where @xmath195 @xmath196 ~;\ ] ] @xmath197 denote the first derivative of @xmath172 with respect to @xmath198 . a choice which we will later consider for @xmath199 is @xmath200 in the large @xmath201-limit the effective potential and its first derivative with respect to @xmath201 reduce to @xmath202 \label{limitz1}\ ] ] and @xmath203 respectively . at this point , we would like to note that d - term inflation can be realised with the last 60 e - folds being very close to the critical value @xmath204 , implying that the above reduced formulae , eqs . ( [ limitz1 ] ) , ( [ limitz2 ] ) , _ can not _ be used to compute the predictions of the model regarding the cmb temperature anisotropies . therefore , we disagree with the approach of ref . @xcite , where the authors have used the reduced formulae for the effective potential and its first derivative , to compute the inflaton contribution to the cmb temperature anisotropies . to illustrate the above remark , we represent in fig . [ fig : error ] the error made by this assumption . the cosmic string contribution is drawn as a function of the superpotential coupling constant @xmath44 , considering either the partial or the full scalar potential . one can realise that the error on the cosmic string contribution can reach @xmath205 , leading to a considerable error in the induced constraints on the parameters space . with partial ( dashed line ) or full ( continuous line ) scalar potential . ] the number of e - foldings of inflation between the initial and final value of the inflaton field is @xmath206 f_{v'}(z)}~,\ ] ] where we note that the index @xmath207 denotes the scale responsible for the quadrupole anisotropy in the cmb . for the integral appearing in the above expression for @xmath208 to be correctly defined , one must assume that the function @xmath209 can be inverted . since it is a monotonic and increasing function , one can verify , at least numerically , that the function @xmath210 can be inverted . we denote the inverted function by @xmath211 . the above expression for @xmath208 , eq . ( [ efoldings ] ) , will enable us to write a relation between @xmath148 and @xmath212 . setting @xmath213 , we can fix the value of the inflaton field @xmath214 , responsible for the quadrupole anisotropy of the cmb . d - term inflation leads generically to cosmic strings formation , which also contribute to the cmb temperature anisotropies . the total contribution , from the inflaton field as well as from the cosmic strings , has to be normalised to the value measured by the cobe - dmr experiment . this normalisation will fix the mass scale @xmath215 as a function of the superpotential coupling @xmath44 and the gauge coupling @xmath82 , which are considered here as parameters . thus , we have to calculate both , the cosmic strings contribution and the inflaton field one , and normalise their _ sum _ to cobe - dmr . here we emphasise that different approaches can be found in the literature where the authors do not normalise the sum of the two contributions to the data . clearly not to normalise the sum to the data is a simplification , which may lead to an important error for the result . normalising only the inflationary contribution to the quadrupole absolute value can be considered as an assumption where the cosmic string contribution is neglected . this assumption could be _ allowed _ only if one wants to argue that the cosmic strings are sub - dominant . however , since we already know that cosmic strings are indeed sub - dominant and our aim is to constrain the parameters space and calculate exactly how sub - dominant the strings are , this simplification in the normalisation implies important errors in the calculated cosmic string contribution . from the scalar potential given in eq . ( [ dpotensugranonmin ] ) , one can see that the spontaneous symmetry breaking is generated when @xmath216 takes a vacuum expectation value @xmath215 . thus , the quadrupole contribution to the cmb temperature anisotropies from the cosmic strings formed at the end of hybrid inflation , which is @xmath217 where @xmath218 is the vacuum expectation value of the higgs field responsible for the formation of cosmic strings , is approximately equal to @xmath219 for the contribution from the inflaton field , we evaluate the sachs - wolfe term splitted into the scalar and tensor parts , using @xmath220 and @xmath221 from eqs . ( [ treelevelsc ] ) , ( [ veff ] ) , ( [ inflsc ] ) and ( [ inflsctens ] ) we get @xmath222 and @xmath223 we note that the ratio of the tensor part of the inflaton field contribution to the cosmic strings one is constant , and that the tensor part contribution can be neglected . the tensor over scalar ratio , @xmath224 , is less straightforward and it is given by @xmath225 we then proceed with the cosmic string contribution to the quadruple cmb temperature anisotropy . this contribution in computed as a function of the superpotential coupling @xmath44 , for various values of @xmath82 and @xmath226 , which are considered as parameters . the results are plotted in fig . [ csdelambda ] . from the top to the bottom , respectively . this is for @xmath227 . ] to show the dependence of the cosmic string contribution on the gauge coupling @xmath82 , we draw in fig . [ csdelambdag1 ] the cosmic string contribution for @xmath228 and @xmath229 . clearly , this case ( @xmath228 ) is excluded since the cosmic string contribution is above the allowed one . we note that we do not take @xmath230 higher than 5 , since positivity condition @xmath231 requires @xmath232 @xcite . from the top to the bottom , respectively . this is for @xmath228 . ] we quantify below the constraints on the parameters space imposed from the three - year wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap ) @xcite measurements . we want to set precise constraints on the free parameters since this can be of importance for concluding of whether d - term inflation remains in agreement with cmb data once we also include constraints imposed from the allowed value of the spectral index @xcite . for @xmath233 , there is no parameters space in agreement with measurements . in the range @xmath234 $ ] , the parameters space is extremely small , around @xmath235 ; the presence of @xmath230 enlarges slightly the allowed window . for @xmath227 , the @xmath17 upper limit on the allowed cosmic string contribution to the cmb imposes , at @xmath236 of confidence level , the following constraints : @xmath237 or , equivalently , @xmath238 clearly the new degree of freedom , namely @xmath226 , allows a slightly higher upper bound on the coupling , which is however at best higher by only a factor of 2 , thus concluding that fine tuning is still required . all constraints are equivalent to a single constraint on @xmath239 , or @xmath240 , as already stated in refs . therefore , there is a bijection between the cosmic string contribution and the mass scale of inflation , which nevertheless does not mean that one can normalise only the inflaton contribution to the cmb data . clearly , the error made by this assumption is big when cosmic strings have an important weight , while it is small if the cosmic string contribution is small , of the order the one found here . with the current upper limit of @xmath17 on the allowed cosmic string contribution to the temperature anisotropies , the relative error made on the string contribution , by not normalising the sum , is of the order of @xmath241 . as one can see from figs . [ csdelambda ] , [ csdelambdag1 ] the curve which showing the cosmic string contribution becomes singular at its minimum , for large values of @xmath242 . the reason for this behaviour is that the function @xmath243 , denoting the sum of the cosmic strings and inflaton contributions as a function of @xmath148 becomes non - bijective for certain values of @xmath44 . this implies that there are more than one solutions for the function @xmath244 normalised to the cobe data , for a tiny window of the parameter @xmath44 around the value @xmath245 . we illustrate this in fig . [ multval ] . . in terms of the cosmic string contributions these solutions correspond to @xmath246 and @xmath247 from left to right , equivalently . ] we have checked that this _ degeneracy _ does not influence the validity of our results since the different solutions for the normalisation to cobe are of the same order of magnitude and this behaviour is observed for a tiny parameters space . as a final remark , we would like to note that there is also another point where we disagree with ref . @xcite . in their model specified by the choice of the khler potential and with the simplifications made for the scalar potential , the authors obtain @xcite a value for @xmath239 , required to generate the appropriate magnitude of density perturbations . the authors argue that this value is consistent with the upper limit imposed on @xmath148 so that the cosmic string contribution is within the allowed window , following the results of ref . @xcite . however , the analysis of ref . @xcite was done employing the curvaton mechanism ; a contribution which the authors of ref . @xcite have not considered at all . we proceed with the general case , namely we include all terms of the next to leading order latexmath:[\[k_2=|s|^2+|\phi_+|^2+|\phi_-|^2+f_+\bigg(\frac{|s|^2}{m_{\rm pl}^2}\bigg)|\phi_+|^2+f_-\bigg(\frac{|s|^2}{m_{\rm pl}^2}\bigg ) @xmath172 is just @xmath249 the motivation for such a choice is that beyond the minimal supergravity part of the khler potential , the leading order is @xmath174 , implying that one should consider all corrections up to this order . during inflation , the charged fields @xmath123 vanish , meaning that terms of the form @xmath250 or @xmath251 can be neglected compared to @xmath252-terms , which are in @xmath253 . thus , the next - to - minimal d - term inflationary model should be constructed with khler potential @xmath254 . we again consider the superpotential @xmath255 involving the superfields @xmath122 and @xmath123 with charges @xmath46 and @xmath256 , respectively , under the @xmath45 symmetry of the lagrangian . the charges @xmath256 must satisfy the constraint induced by the superconformal origin of the fi term , as discussed in section [ csqforsugra ] . the d - term part of the scalar potential is thus unchanged as compared the previous section and given by eq . ( [ vdnonmin ] ) . equation ( [ fnew ] ) implies that during inflation @xmath182 is minimised for @xmath267 , thus @xmath268 and inflation is driven by the d - term . the total scalar potential @xmath34 is constant at tree level and equal to @xmath269 . having the scalar potential we calculate the masses of the canonically normalised scalar components of the superfields @xmath123 : @xmath270 whereas from eq . ( [ lagrangfermio ] ) we get the mass squared for their fermionic partners : @xmath271 following the same procedure as in the previous sections , we obtain the effective potential @xmath190 \right\ } ~,\ ] ] where @xmath272 is the same as in section [ secpotenseto ] , eq . ( [ deffv ] ) ; the only difference is the expression for @xmath93 , namely here @xmath273 the first derivative of the scalar potential with respect to @xmath201 reads @xmath274 where @xmath275 is the same as in section [ secpotenseto ] , eq . ( [ deffv ] ) , but @xmath276 is in this case given by @xmath277~. \label{newfz}\ ] ] the number of e - folds and the inflationary contribution to the cmb quadrupole anisotropy are still calculated using eqs . ( [ efoldings ] ) and ( [ dtsurt ] ) , respectively , with @xmath276 given by eq . ( [ newfz ] ) above . the cosmic strings contribution to the cmb temperature anisotropies is the same as in the minimal d - term sugra case . the contribution of cosmic strings to the cmb anisotropies in the whole parameters space is represented in figs . [ csdelambdanonminextc0g2 ] , [ csdelambdanonminextc0b1 ] , [ csdelambdanonminextb1c1 ] . , in the next - to - minimal d - term inflationary model . the value of the gauge coupling constant is fixed and equal to @xmath227 ; there are no cross terms between @xmath122 and @xmath123 , i.e. , @xmath278 . the minimal sugra for @xmath175 is represented by the dashed line , while the different plain lines are calculated for @xmath279 , going from the bottom to the top . a fine tuning of the superpotential coupling @xmath44 is still required , in order to avoid a dominant contribution of cosmic strings . ] , in the next - to - minimal d - term inflation model . the parameter @xmath280 is set equal to @xmath281 ; there are no cross terms between @xmath122 and @xmath123 , ie @xmath278 . the different plain lines are calculated for @xmath282 , going from the bottom to the top . a fine tuning of the superpotential coupling @xmath44 is still is required to avoid a dominant contribution of cosmic strings . ] , in the next - to - minimal d - term inflation model . the parameter @xmath280 is set equal to @xmath281 ; there are no cross terms between @xmath122 and @xmath123 , i.e. , @xmath278 . the different plain lines are calculated for @xmath282 , going from the bottom to the top . a fine tuning of the superpotential coupling @xmath44 is still required , in order to avoid a dominant contribution of cosmic strings . ] studying the above figures one easily concludes that considering a more general form for the khler potential does not solve the fine tuning problem of d - term inflation . the new term in the khler potential , whose weight is given by the parameter @xmath280 , induces an enhancement of the cosmic string contribution at low @xmath44 . we still observe a dominant contribution of cosmic strings if the superpotential coupling @xmath44 is close to unity . therefore , the constraints on @xmath44 found on the previous section remain unchanged as given in eq . ( [ contraintelambdanonmin ] ) . d - term hybrid inflation is a successful and interesting model . in the context of supergravity , d - term inflation avoids the _ hubble - induced mass _ problem , which plagues f - term hybrid inflation , while it can easily be implemented in string theory . in a standard formulation of d - term inflation , where the constant fi term gets compensated by a single complex scalar field , we do not add an additional discrete symmetry , and do not consider non - renormalisable terms in the potential , d - term strings are formed at the end of the phase transitions which signals the end of inflation . these strings are analogous to the d - strings formed at the end of brane inflation , which is the result of brane collisions . d - term inflation can not be studied in the standard formulation of supergravity , which is ill - defined whenever the superpotential vanishes and there are present constant fayet iliopoulos terms . following an effective supergravity formulation based on superconformal theory , the superpotential transforms under the u(1 ) symmetry along the directions where the fi terms are constant . this transformation defines the charge assignments of the superfields . d - term inflation has to be studied within this new formulation of supergravity , which is well defined when the superpotential vanishes . cosmic strings contribute to the cosmic microwave background temperature anisotropies . all current measurements put severe constraints on the allowed cosmic string contribution . to achieve a compatibility between measurements and theoretical predictions one should fine tune the couplings . this was already found in the case of minimal supergravity . it was therefore natural to ask the question of whether this result still holds in non - minimal supergravity . it was previously claimed in the literature that higher order khler potentials suppress the cosmic strings contribution . studying a case of non - minimal supergravity , where we include higher order corrections in the khler potential , as well as supergravity with shift symmetry we conclude that cosmic string contribution will be dominant unless the couplings are fine - tuned . we also find that , as in the minimal case @xcite , the @xmath17 constraint on the cosmic string contribution is equivalent to the constraint @xmath283 we would also like to emphasise that if @xmath215 is higher by a factor of 2 , the cosmic string contributison is of the order of @xmath284 , as show in fig . 7 of ref . @xcite . in conclusion , we definitely disagree with the statement that non - minimal khler potentials avoid the cosmic strings problem , which should imply that fine tuning is not necessary . even though we have not studied a large number of khler potentials , our current findings indicate that the problem of fine tuning is unavoidable unless one considers a more complicated model , for example where strings become topologically unstable , namely semi - local strings . we have not yet studied @xcite the spectral index in our models to check the consistency with the limits imposed by the recent three - year wmap data , which however have been given only for purely adiabatic models . if the spectral index is higher than the one preferred from the measurements and since , in addition , the requirement for very small couplings seems more difficult to be satisfied in string theory , one should then look for mechanisms to suppress the rle of strings , for example by making them unstable , along the lines of refs . @xcite , by adding new terms in the superpotential @xcite , or by considering the curvaton mechanism @xcite . as we were completing this work , ref . @xcite came to our attention . in that study , the authors find , in the context of minimal supergravity , slightly higher upper bounds for the parameters @xmath44 and @xmath82 , whereas the obtain the same with us upper bound on the fi term . this small discrepancy originates from the different analysis followed in ref . @xcite ; the authors perform a full markov - chain - monte - carlo analysis and consider one more parameter , namely the spectral index . it is a pleasure to thank n. chatillon , r. kallosh , p. greene , j. gray , j. martin , a. van proeyen and j. yokoyama for stimulating discussions . jr acknowledges support by the national science foundation under grant no . phy-0455649 and by the university of texas at san antonio , texas 78249 , usa . 10 a. linde , phys . b * 129 * , 177 ( 1983 ) .
Abstract: | [
"d - term inflation is one of the most interesting and versatile models of inflation . it is possible to implement naturally d - term inflation within high energy physics , as for example susy guts , sugra , or string theories . d - term inflation avoids the @xmath0-problem , while in its standard form it always ends with the formation of cosmic strings . given the recent three - year wmap data on the cosmic microwave background temperature anisotropies , we examine whether d - term inflation can be successfully implemented in non - minimal supergravity theories . we show that for all our choices of khler potential , there exists a parameter space for which the predictions of d - term inflation are in agreement with the measurements . the cosmic string contribution on the measured temperature anisotropies is always dominant , unless the superpotential coupling constant is fine tuned ; a result already obtained for d - term inflation within minimal supergravity . in conclusion , cosmic strings and their rle in the angular power spectrum can not be easily hidden by just considering a non - flat khler geometry ."
] | 9,151 | 9,151 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the chemical composition of extremely metal - poor stars is expected to reflect the yields from a quite small number of nucleosynthesis processes . recent abundance analyses for extremely metal - poor stars have provided quite valuable information on the origin of the elements , ( in particular when combined with galactic chemical evolution studies , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and the individual nucleosynthesis processes involved . the rapid neutron capture process ( r - process ) is known to be responsible for about half of the abundances of elements heavier than the iron - group in solar system material . although observational data have been rapidly increasing in the past decade , the astrophysical site of the r - process is still unclear . previous nucleosynthesis studies suggest several possibilities , e.g. , neutrino - driven winds @xcite or prompt explosions @xcite of core - collapse ( type ii / ibc ) supernovae , neutron star mergers @xcite , jets from gamma - ray burst accretion discs @xcite . all the scenarios proposed above involve , however , severe problems that remain to be solved , and no consensus has yet been achieved . models of the r - process nucleosynthesis are usually examined by comparison with the abundance pattern of the r - process component in solar - system material . recent measurements for abundances of neutron - capture elements in very metal - poor stars have been providing useful constraints on these models . @xcite have studied the chemical abundances of the extremely metal - poor star cs 22892052 , the first example of a small but growing class of metal - poor stars that exhibit very large excesses of r - process elements relative to iron ( [ r - process / fe ] @xmath0 ) . an important result of their work is that the relative abundance pattern of the neutron - capture elements from the 2nd to the 3rd peak ( 56 @xmath1 _ z _ @xmath1 76 ) in this star is identical , within observational errors , to that of the ( inferred ) solar system r - process component . this phenomenon is sometimes referred to as `` universality '' of the r - process , having a large impact on the studies of the nature of the r - process , and its astrophysical site . however , the abundance patterns of light neutron - capture elements ( 38 @xmath1 z @xmath1 48 ) in r - process enhanced stars exhibit clear deviations from that of the solar system r - process component @xcite . this suggests the existence of another r - process site which has contributed to the light r - process elements in solar - system material . this process is sometimes called as `` weak r - process '' , while the process that is responsible for heavy neutron - capture elements ( ba @xmath2 u ) is referred to `` main r - process '' . following the previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , @xcite and @xcite have investigated the correlation of sr and ba abundances in very metal - poor stars ( [ fe / h ] @xmath3 ) in some detail . they showed that the dispersion of the sr abundances clearly decreases with increasing ba abundance . this correlation indicates the existence of ( at least ) two processes : one enriches both heavy and light neutron - capture elements , while the other yields light neutron - capture elements with only small production of heavy ones . @xcite discuss the contribution of a primary process which has produced light neutron - capture elements in our galaxy . the abundance patterns produced by the main r - process have been studied previously based on high resolution spectroscopy of metal - poor stars ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) as mentioned above . by way of contrast , the abundance pattern of neutron - capture elements produced by the weak r - process is still unclear . since the abundances of heavy neutron - capture elements yielded by this process are very low , it is quite difficult to accurately measure their abundances in metal - poor stars . in addition , most spectral lines of light neutron - capture elements , in particular those with @xmath4 exist in the near - uv region , in which atmospheric extinction makes the observation with ground - based telescopes difficult . we have been investigating light neutron - capture elements in very metal - deficient stars from near - uv spectroscopy with the 8.2 m subaru telescope . ishimaru et al . ( 2006 , in preparation ) studied the abundances of pd and ag , which exist between the first and second abundance peaks produced by neutron - capture processes , for several metal - poor stars . one of the targets is hd 122563 , a well - studied bright metal - poor ( [ fe / h ] @xmath5 ) giant . this object has very low abundances of heavy neutron - capture elements ( e.g. [ ba / fe ] @xmath6 * ? ? ? * ) , while light neutron - capture elements show large excesses relative to heavy ones ( e.g. [ sr / ba ] @xmath7 ) . therefore , the abundance pattern of neutron - capture elements in this star might well represent the yields of the process producing light neutron - capture elements at low metallicity . in this paper we report the abundance pattern of light and heavy neutron - capture elements in hd 122563 . in 2 we present our near - uv spectroscopy with subaru / hds , while we describe in detail the abundance analysis of neutron - capture elements in 3 . our results are compared with the previous studies in 4 . we discuss the derived abundances of hd 122563 , and the source of neutron - capture elements in 5 . finally , our conclusions are presented in 6 . high dispersion spectroscopy of hd 122563 was carried out with the subaru telescope high dispersion spectrograph ( hds : * ? ? ? * ) in 30 april , 2004 . our spectrum covers the wavelength range from 3070 to 4780 with a resolving power of @xmath8 = 90,000 . the total exposure time is 5400 seconds ( one 600 s exposure plus four 1200 s ones ) . the reduction was carried out in a standard manner using the iraf echelle package . the signal to noise ratio ( s / n ) of the spectrum ( per 0.9 km s@xmath9 pixel ) estimated from the photon counts is 140 at 3100 ; 480 at 3500 ; 860 at 3900 ; 1080 at 4200 and 1340 at 4500 . in order to measure ba lines at 5853 and 6141 , a spectrum obtained during the hds commissioning covering 5090 6410 was used . the s / n ratio of this spectrum is 350 at 6000 . we adopted the line list used in previous studies for line identifications and analyses of neutron - capture elements ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? in addition , the recent measurements of transition probabilities and hyperfine splitting reported for some elements ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) are incorporated . the line list used in the analysis is given in table [ tab : table1 - 4 ] . + equivalent widths of clean , isolated lines are measured by fitting gaussian profile . the results are given in table [ tab : table1 - 4 ] . for our quantitative abundance measurements , we used the analysis program sptool developed by y. takeda , based on kurucz s atlas9/width9 @xcite . sptool calculates synthetic spectra and equivalent widths of lines on the basis of the given model atmosphere , line data , and chemical composition , under the assumption of lte . we adopted the model atmosphere parameters ( effective temperature : @xmath10 , gravity : @xmath11 , micro - turbulent velocity : @xmath12 , and metallicity : [ fe / h ] ) derived by @xcite : @xmath10 = 4570 k , @xmath13 = 1.1 , @xmath12 = 2.2 km s@xmath9 , and [ fe / h ] @xmath14 . the estimated uncertainties are @xmath15 = 100 k , @xmath16 = 0.3 dex , @xmath17 = 0.5 km s@xmath9 , and @xmath18[fe / h ] = 0.19 dex ( honda et al . 2004 ) . the abundance analyses were attempted for 24 neutron - capture elements from sr to th . the effects of hyperfine and isotopic splitting are taken into account in the analysis of ba , la , eu , and yb ( see references in table 1 ) . the derived abundances are given in table [ tab : table2 ] . the abundances determined from individual lines are given in table [ tab : table1 - 4 ] . we used the solar system abundances obtained by @xcite to derive [ x / fe ] values . the size of the random errors are estimated from the standard deviation ( 1@xmath19 ) of the abundances derived from individual lines for elements that have three or more lines available for the abundance analysis . for the abundances of elements based only on one or two lines , we employ the mean of the random errors estimated from those elements with three or more lines available . the uncertainties of model atmosphere parameters result in systematic errors in the abundances of neutron - capture elements . the effects of these uncertainties on the abundance measurements are given in table [ tab : error ] . the behavior of the errors is slightly different for abundances derived from neutral species and those from ionized ones . this should be borne in mind in the discussion on the abundances of light neutron - capture elements , some of which were determined using lines of neutral species . by contrast , such differences do not significantly affect our discussion of the abundance ratios of heavy neutron - capture elements , which were all measured from ionized species . the details of the analysis for individual neutron - capture elements are presented below . for comparison purposes , the abundances of cu and zn were also determined . in addition to the cu 5105 and zn 4810 lines , the uv lines ( 3250 - 3350 ) are also used in the abundance analyses ( table [ tab : table1 - 4 ] ) . although the abundances of sr , y , and zr have been determined by a number of previous studies for hd 122563 , measurements for other light neutron - capture elements are quite limited so far . we have newly detected 5 elements ( nb , mo , ru , pd , and ag ) in our spectrum , and derived an upper limit for a sixth element ( rh ) . two strong lines of ( 4077 and 4215 ) and the weak line of ( 4607 ) were measured . the two resonance lines are so strong that the abundance derived from these lines is sensitive to the microturbulent velocity and treatment of damping . however , the agreement of the abundances derived from and ( see table [ tab : table1 - 4 ] ) suggests the reliability of our measurements . two ( @xmath21 ) lines are detected . the detection of the 3163 line is reported only for canopus by @xcite and for the sun . this line would be useful for abundance analyses because of its strength ( figure [ fig : spectra ] ) . we note , however , that the abundance determined from this line is slightly higher ( by 0.25 dex ) than that from the 3215 line , possibly suggesting a small contamination by other spectral features . however , here we simply adopt the mean of the abundances derived from the two lines . the ( @xmath22 ) 3864 line is detected in cs 22892 - 052 by @xcite . although a blend of a cn line is reported by these authors , that is not severe in hd 122563 , because the carbon abundance of this star is more than 1 dex lower than that of cs 22892052 . we have detected two lines of ( @xmath23 ) . the equivalent width of the 3498 line is measurable due to there being no ( apparent ) blend with other lines . since a strong line exists in the bluer region of the other line at 3728 , we applied the spectrum synthesis technique to the analysis of that line . the ( @xmath24 ) 3692 line exists in the wing of h i line , but is not detected in our spectrum . we determined only an upper limit on the abundance of this element . we have detected two lines of pd . the 3242 line blends with oh lines . the contamination was estimated using the oh line list of @xcite , adjusting the oxygen abundance to match the strengths of neighboring oh lines ( [ o / fe ] @xmath250.4 ) . the 3404 line is clearly detected with no severe blend ( figure [ fig : spectra ] ) . two lines have been measured in some metal - poor stars . the 3280 line is detected , while the 3383 line is not . since nh lines blend with the 3280 line @xcite , we included the nh lines adopted from @xcite in the spectrum synthesis , calibrating the n abundance to reproduce the nh features around the line ( [ n / fe]@xmath26 ) . we note that the n abundance adopted is much lower than those derived by previous works ( e.g.,[n / fe]@xmath7 * ? ? ? this discrepancy is partially due to the inaccurate gf - values used in our analysis . recent studies of n abundances based on nh lines applied corrections of gf - values to the kurucz s list ( e.g. , * ? ? ? in addition to the nh lines , some unidentified feature appears in the red part of this line ( figure [ fig : spectra ] ) . if such unknown lines also affect the line , the values derived from this line must be regarded as an upper limit on the ag abundance . the abundances of ba , la , eu , and yb were derived by a spectrum synthesis technique , taking into account hyperfine splitting . the abundances of other elements were determined by applying a single line approximation , which is justified by the fact that the absorption lines are quite weak in general . in addition to the two resonance lines at 4554 and 4934 , two ba lines in the red region were measured . the line data of @xcite were used for the analysis of ba lines , assuming the isotope ratios of r - process component in solar - system material . there is a small discrepancy between the ba abundances from the two resonance lines and others . a possible reason for this discrepancy is the non - lte effect ( e.g. , * ? ? ? however , we here simply adopt the average of the ba abundances from the four lines . we detected three lines at 3819 , 4129 and 4205 . however , the 4205 line blends with a line , while the 3819 one is affected by a wing component of a strong fe line at 3820 . since these eu lines are quite weak in the spectrum of hd 122563 , in contrast to those in r - process enhanced stars , the effect of the blending is significant . hence , we adopt the result from the 4129 . we note that the eu abundances derived from the excluded lines , within their relatively large errors , agree with the value from the 4129 line . the effect of isotope shift for gd lines was included in the analysis by @xcite for the s - process enhanced star cs 31062 - 050 . this effect is , however , neglected in the present analysis , because the gd lines of hd 122563 are very weak . we have detected three gd lines ( table [ tab : table1 - 4 ] ) . the gd abundance derived from the 3481 line is significantly higher than those from the other two , and an upper limit estimated from another line ( 3331 ) . we regard this as a result of contamination of the 3481 line by some unidentified lines , and exclude this line in the determination of the final gd abundance . yb is the heaviest element detected in our spectrum . we measured two yb lines at 3220 and 3694 . a spectrum synthesis technique was applied to the analysis including the effect of hyperfine splitting for these lines ( sneden et al . 2003 , private communication ) . agreement of the results from the two lines is fairly good . the upper limits of ir and th abundances are obtained from the analyses of 3800 and 4019 line . the line of 4019 is affected by contamination by other lines ( figure [ fig : th ] ) . we analyzed this line using the line list of @xcite for this wavelength region . we adopted @xmath28c/@xmath29c = 5 to estimated the blending of @xmath29ch lines . since the blends of fe and co lines are severe , no clear th feature is identified , although the quality of the spectrum is very high ( s / n = 950 at 4020 ) . we derived the upper limit of the th abundance ( log @xmath30 ( th ) @xmath31 ) from the fitting of synthetic spectra by eye . neutron - capture elements have been studied for this object by many authors . recently , @xcite , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite performed detailed abundance analyses based on high resolution spectroscopy ( @xmath32 ) for this object . @xcite also determined the abundances of eight neutron - capture elements , though their resolving power ( @xmath33 ) is not as high as those in the above studies . recently , @xcite derived the abundances of ge , zr , la and eu from the uv region ( 2410 @xmath2 3070 ) of this object using hubble space telescope , and also uv - blue region ( 3150 @xmath2 4600 ) with keck i hires . figure [ fig : comp ] shows comparisons of the abundances of neutron - capture elements derived by the present analysis with those of previous work . our results are in good agreement with @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . however , the abundances of neutron - capture elements determined by the present analysis are systematically lower than those by @xcite and @xcite . here we inspect the discrepancy between the results of @xcite and ours in some detail , because their work determined abundances of a larger number of elements than @xcite , and they reported the equivalent widths used in the abundance analysis for some lines ( unfortunately , the equivalent widths were not given for the lines for which spectrum synthesis technique was applied ) . the atmospheric parameters adopted in our analysis are in good agreement with theirs : the differences ( our results minus those of @xcite ) of @xmath10 , @xmath13 , [ fe / h ] and @xmath12 are + 70 k , 0.2 dex , 0.07 dex and 0.3 km s@xmath9 , respectively . these differences results in differences of abundances smaller than 0.1 dex for heavy neutron - capture elements ( see table [ tab : error ] ) . therefore , the difference of the adopted atmospheric parameters is not a reason for the abundance discrepancy . we also found good agreements in the equivalent widths of the lines reported by both works . however , the @xmath34 value of the nd 4061 line used by @xcite is lower by 0.25 dex than ours . though the @xmath34 values of la adopted by the two works are quite similar , no information on the treatment of the hyperfine splitting was given by @xcite , while the effect is fully included in our analysis . we adopted recent line data for @xcite and @xcite , which should be more accurate than those used by @xcite . thus , the discrepancy between the results of the two work might be partially explained by the difference of the adopted line data . however , there seems to exist small ( @xmath20.2 dex ) systematic differences , for which no clear reason is identified . we investigated a high quality uv - blue spectrum of hd 122563 , and have detected 19 neutron - capture elements including nb , mo , ru , pd , ag , pr , and sm , which are detected for the first time by our study for this object , and upper - limits for 5 elements including th . the derived abundances are given in table [ tab : table2 ] . in this section , we discuss the abundance pattern of the neutron - capture elements , along with cu and zn , to investigate the origin of neutron - capture elements in this object . the abundance ratio between ba ( or la ) and eu is used as an indicator of the origin of neutron - capture elements . the value of [ ba / eu ] of the solar system r - process component is 0.81 , while that of the s - process component is + 1.45 @xcite . the value of the [ ba / eu ] is 0.50 in hd 122563 . in addition , the value of [ la / eu ] of the solar system r - process component is 0.59 , while that in hd 122563 is 0.50 . these results indicate that the heavy ( @xmath35 @xmath36 56 ) neutron - capture elements of this object are principally associated with the r - process , and the contribution of the ( main ) s - process is small if any . we recall that this object is very metal - poor ( [ fe / h]@xmath37 ) with no excess of carbon ( [ c / fe]=@xmath38 ) . figure [ fig : r ] shows the abundance pattern of hd 122563 , comparing with that of the solar - system r - process component . the solar system r - process abundance pattern is scaled to the eu abundance of hd 122563 . this figure clearly shows that the abundances of light neutron - capture elements ( 38 @xmath1 z @xmath1 47 ) are much higher than those of heavy ones in hd 122563 , compared to the solar - system r - process pattern . this behavior is very different from that found in r - process enhanced stars ( e.g. cs 22892 - 052 , cs 31082 - 001 : * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? although we indicated above that the heavy neutron - capture elements are principally associated with the r - process , figure [ fig : r ] indicates that even in the range 56 @xmath39 @xmath35 @xmath39 59 the abundances in hd 122563 exceed those of the scaled solar r - process , with only la falling on the eu - normalised curve . this suggests that the tendency for the light neutron - capture elements ( 38 @xmath1 @xmath35 @xmath1 47 ) to fall above the scaled solar r - process curve is part of a general , atomic - number dependent , trend . in order to demonstrate this behavior more clearly , figure [ fig : f7 ] shows the logarithmic difference of the abundances of this object from the solar system r - process pattern as a function of atomic number . we also show that of the r - process enhanced star cs 22892 - 052 @xcite in the same way . we find good agreement between the abundance pattern of cs 22892 - 052 and the solar - system r - process one , at least for elements with 56@xmath40 . by way of contrast , our new measurements for hd 122563 clearly demonstrate a quite different abundance pattern from that of the solar - system r - process component and of cs 22892052 . the excess of light neutron - capture elements ( e.g. sr ) with respect to the heavy ones ( e.g. ba ) was known for hd 122563 by previous studies ( see section 1 ) . however , the abundances of elements having intermediate mass ( e.g. mo , pd ) were measured in detail for the first time by the present work . the abundances of these elements are intermediate , and , hence , the abundances of neutron - capture elements gradually and continuously decrease with increasing atomic number from @xmath41 to @xmath42 . this trend is a key to investigating the nucleosynthesis process that is responsible for neutron - capture elements in this object . for comparison purposes , we also attempted to compare the abundances of hd 122563 with the solar system s - process distribution ( figure [ fig : s ] ) . in this case , ba , la , ce , and eu show large deviations from the solar system s - process curve , although the overall abundance pattern from sr to yb seems to be similar . since the s - process abundance pattern in the solar - system is a result of a combination of some individual processes ( at least the weak and main components of the s - process ) , we presume this apparent `` agreement '' is physically not important . we also have detected four neutron - capture elements heavier than eu ( gd , dy , er , yb : @xmath43 64 ) . the abundances of these elements also show a decreasing trend as a function of atomic number , with respect to the solar - system r - process pattern . this also has an impact on the understanding of the origin of neutron - capture elements in this object . th is a radioactive element and is synthesized only by the r - process . the upper limit of the th abundance determined by the present work indicated that this object does not show an excess of th with respect to eu ( and other heavy neutron - capture elements ) , compared to most r - process enhanced stars . the cu and zn abundances of hd 122563 are typical values found in very metal - poor stars ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? that is , no clear difference is found in the abundances of these elements between the stars having high and low abundances of light neutron - capture elements . this result may give a hint for the origins of cu and zn , as well as of light neutron - capture elements , which are still unclear . here we consider the origin of neutron - capture elements in this object based on the abundance pattern determined by the present work . the abundance ratios between light and heavy neutron - capture elements ( e.g. , sr / ba ) in hd 122563 are clearly different from those in r - process enhanced stars , as already mentioned in 1 . therefore , the r - process responsible for the heavy neutron - capture elements in the solar system ( the so - called `` main '' r - process ) is not an important source of , at least , light neutron - capture elements in hd 122563 . the main s - process is also excluded from the possible source of light neutron - capture elements , because that yields even lower abundance ratios between light and heavy neutron - capture elements at low metallicity ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the weak component of the s - process was introduced to interpret the light s - process nuclei in the solar system . however , the gradually decreasing trend of elemental abundances from sr to ba found in hd 122563 does not resemble that of the weak s - process , which predicts a rapid drop of abundances at @xmath44 ( i.e. y or zr ) . it should be noted in addition that the weak s - process is expected to be inefficient at low metallicity , because of the lack of the neutron source @xmath45ne ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) in addition to the lack of iron seeds . thus , another process that has efficiently yielded light neutron - capture elements at low metallicity is required to explain the abundance pattern of neutron - capture elements in hd 122563 . the presence of such a process has been indicated by recent observational studies of metal - deficient stars with no excess of heavy neutron - capture elements ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . this process was called the `` light element primary process '' ( lepp ) by @xcite , who estimated its contribution to the solar abundances . @xcite have shown that such light r - process nuclei ( up to @xmath46 ) are produced in neutrino winds as a result of weak " ( or failed ) r - processing ( see also * ? ? ? it is likely , therefore , that these light neutron - capture elements originate from the core - collapse supernovae , although a contribution from other sources can not be excluded . the abundance pattern of light to heavy neutron - capture elements measured for hd 122563 provides a unique constraint on such model calculations . the abundance pattern of heavy neutron - capture elements of hd 122563 shows a significant departure from the r - process component in solar - system material , though the departure is not as large as that found for light neutron - capture elements ( figure [ fig : r ] ) . figure [ fig : r+s ] shows a comparison between the abundances of elements with @xmath47 measured for hd 122563 ( filled circles ) and the solar - system r - process abundance pattern @xcite , which is scaled to achieve the best fit to the observed data ( the solid line ) . ( recall that the scaling in figure [ fig : r ] was to eu . ) significant disagreements are found for ce and pr , as well as for dy , er and yb . given the fact that the abundance patterns of heavy elements measured for r - process enhanced stars show excellent agreement with that of the solar - system , the different abundance pattern of hd 122563 must be significant . some process that produces a different abundance pattern of heavy neutron - capture elements from that of the main r - process is at least required to explain the abundance pattern of this star . one possibility is to assume a small contribution of the ( main ) s - process . in order to examine this possibility , we adopted the r - process and s - process abundance patterns in the solar - system as determined by @xcite , and searched for the combination that gives the best fit to the abundance pattern of hd 122563 . the result is shown by the dashed line in figure [ fig : r+s ] . in this case , the contributions of the s - process to ba , la , and ce are significant ( @xmath2 70% ) , while those to elements heavier than nd are small ( @xmath48 10% ) . it should be noted that such a small contribution of the main s - process does not affect the abundance pattern of light neutron - capture elements discussed in the previous subsection . the root - mean - square ( rms ) of the logarithmic abundance difference between the observed and calculated abundance patterns is 0.29 dex for the case that a contribution from the s - process is introduced , compared with 0.34 dex if only the r - process is assumed . thus , the fit is slightly better if an s - process contribution is introduced . however , the improved fit comes at the cost of an additional free parameter ( the relative contribution of the s- and r - processes ) , and it is not clear that assuming an s - process contribution is justifiable from the point of view of the star s nucleosynthetic history . in particular , the discrepancy found in the abundance pattern of elements heavier than sm can not be explained by this approach , because the production of such heavy elements by the s - process is very small . this discrepancy leads us to consider an alternative possibility that the heavy neutron - capture elements of this star are also a result of the unidentified ( single ) process that is responsible for the large enhancement of the light neutron - capture elements discussed in 5.2.1 . @xcite have suggested that the small ( but non - negligible ) amount of heavy r - process nuclei ( @xmath49 ) with non solar r - process abundance pattern can be produced in neutrino winds if the entropy of the neutrino - heated matter is enough high ( but smaller than that required for the main r - process ) , in addition to the light r - process nuclei . if this is true , the abundance pattern of heavy neutron - capture elements in this object may give another hint for , or constraint on , the modeling of this process . the differences between the abundance patterns of heavy neutron - capture elements in hd 122563 and the solar - system r - process abundance pattern are not large . further observational data are clearly required to derive definitive conclusions . however , it would be very difficult to improve the measurement of abundances for hd 122563 , because the quality of the spectrum used in the present work is extremely high . one possibility is to reconsider the atomic line data to reduce the uncertainties in abundance measurements . another important observational study is to apply similar analysis to other metal - poor stars having high abundance ratios of light to heavy neutron - capture elements . in particular , measurements for stars with lower metallicity than hd 122563 are important , because no s - process contribution is expected for such stars . we obtained a high resolution , high s / n uv - blue spectrum of the very metal - poor star hd 122563 with subaru / hds . the abundances were measured for 19 neutron - capture elements , among which seven elements are detected for the first time in this star . our new measurements for hd 122563 clearly demonstrate that the elemental abundances gradually decrease relative to the scaled solar r - process abundances with increasing atomic number , at least from sr to yb . we have considered whether the higher abundances of lighter elements can be explained by contributions from the weak s- or main s - processes , and find these not to provide satisfactory explanations . the abundance pattern of elements with @xmath50 does not agree with any prediction of neutron - capture process models known . the abundance pattern of a wide range of neutron - capture elements determined for hd 122563 therefore provides new strong constraints on models of nucleosynthesis for very metal - poor stars , in particular those with excesses of light neutron - capture elements but without enhancement of heavy ones . this work was supported in part by a grant - in - aid for the japan - france integrated action program ( sakura ) , awarded by the japan society for the promotion of science , and scientific research ( 17740108 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science , and technology of japan . most of the data reduction was carried out at the astronomical data analysis center ( adac ) of the national astronomical observatory of japan . aoki , w. , et al . 2002 , apj , 580 , 1149 aoki , w. , et al . 2005 , apj , 632 , 611 asplund , m. , grevesse , n. , & sauval , a. j. 2005 , in asp conf . 336 , cosmic abundances as records of stellar evolution and nucleosynthesis , ed . t. g. barnes iii & f. n. bash ( san francisco : asp ) , 25 asplund , m. 2005 , ara&a , 43 , 481 burris , d. l. , pilachowski , c. a. , armandroff , t. e. , sneden , c. , cowan , j. j. , & roe , h 2000 , apj , 544 , 302 busso , m. , gallino , r. , & wasserburg , g. j. 1999 , ara&a , 37 , 239 cameron , a. g. w. 2001 , apj , 562 , 456 cayrel , r , et al . 2004 , a&a , 416 , 1117 cowan , j. j. , et al . 2002 , apj , 572 , 861 cowan , j. j. , et al . 2005 , apj , 627 , 238 den hartog , e. a. , lawler , j. e. , sneden , c. & cowan , j. j. 2003 , apjs , 148 , 543 ecuvillon , a. , israelian , g. , santos , n. c. , mayor , m. , garcia lopez , r. j. , & randich , s. 2004 , a&a , 418 , 703 freiburghaus , c. , rosswog , s. , & thielemann , f. -k . 1999 , , 525 , l121 hill , v. , et al . 2002 , a&a , 387 , 560 honda , s. , et al . 2004 , apj , 607 , 474 ishimaru , y. & wanajo , s. 1999 , , 511 , l33 ishimaru , y. , wanajo , s. , aoki , w. , & ryan , s. g. 2004 , , 600 , l47 johnson , j. a. & bolte , m. 2001 , apj , 554 , 888 johnson , j. a. 2002 , apjs , 139 , 219 johnson , j. a. & bolte , m. 2002 , apj , 579 , 616 johnson , j. a. & bolte , m. 2004 , apj , 605 , 462 kurucz , r. l. , & bell . b 1995 , kurucz cd - rom , no.23 ( harvard - smithsonian center for astrophysics ) kurucz , r. l. 1993 , kurucz cd - rom , no.13 ( harvard - smithsonian center for astrophysics ) lawler , j. e. , sneden , c. , & cowan , j. j. , 2004 , apj , 604 , 850 lawler , j. e. , bonvallet , g. , & sneden , c. 2001a , apj , 556 , 452 lawler , j. e. , wickliffe , m. e. , den hartog , e. a. , & sneden , c. 2001b , apj , 563 , 1075 mcwilliam , a , preston , g. w. , sneden , c , & searle , l 1995 , aj , 109 , 27 mcwilliam , a 1998 , aj , 115 , 1640 noguchi , k.,et al . 2002 , pasj , 54 , 855 prantzos , n. , hashimoto , m. , & nomoto , k. 1990 , a&a , 234 , 211 sneden , c. , mcwilliam , a. , preston , g. w. , cowan , j. j. , burris , d. l. , & armosky , b. j. 1996 , apj , 467 , 819 sneden , c , cowan , j. j. , ivans , i. i. , fuller , g. m. , burles , s , beers , t. c. , & lawler , j. e. 2000 , apj , 533l , 139 sneden , c. , et al . 2003 , apj , 591 , 936 sumiyoshi , k. , et al . 2001 , apj , 562 , 880 surman , r. , mclaughlin , g. c. , & hix , w. r. 2005 , submitted to ( astro - ph/0509365 ) raiteri , c. m. , gallino , r. , busso , m. , neuberger , d. , & kappeler , f. 1993 , apj , 419 , 207 reynolds , s. e. , hearnshaw , j. b. , & cottrell , p. l. 1988 , mnras , 235 , 1423 rosswog , s. , liebendorfer , m. , thielemann , f .- k . , davies , m. b. , benz , w. , & piran , t. 1999 , a&a , 341 , 499 travaglio et al . 2004 , apj , 114 , 1293 truran , j. w. , cowan , j. j. , pilachowski , c. a. , & sneden , c. 2002 , pasp , 114 , 1293 wanajo , s. , kajino , t. , mathews , g. j. , & otsuki , k. 2001 , , 554 , 578 wanajo , s. , tamamura , m. , itoh , n. , nomoto , k. , ishimaru , y. , beers , t. c. , & nozawa , s. 2003 , apj , 593,968 wanajo , s. & ishimaru , i. 2005 , , in press westin , j. , sneden , c. , gustafsson , b. , & cowan , j. j. 2000 , apj , 530 , 783 woosley , s. e. , wilson , j. r. , mathews , g. j. , hoffman , r. d. , & meyer , b. s. 1994 , , 433 , 229 lcccccc wavelength & l.e.p.(ev ) & log@xmath34 & log@xmath30 & _ w_(m ) & ref + , @xmath51 & & & & & + 3247.53 & 0.000 & 0.060 & 1.04 & 115.1 * & 8 + 3273.95 & 0.000 & 0.360 & 1.24 & 112.3 & 8 + 5105.55 & 1.390 & 1.520 & 0.66 & 3.3 & 2 + , @xmath52 & & & & & + 3302.98 & 4.030 & 0.057 & 2.07 & 20.3 * & 1 + 3345.02 & 4.078 & 0.246 & 1.78 & 19.5 * & 1 + 4722.15 & 4.030 & 0.390 & 2.09 & 14.5 & 5 + 4810.54 & 4.080 & 0.170 & 2.10 & 20.5 & 5 + , @xmath41 & & & & & + 4607.33 & 0.000 & 0.280 & 0.14 & 2.4 & 7 + , @xmath41 & & & & & + 4077.71 & 0.000 & 0.170 & 0.18 & 163.3 & 6 + 4215.52 & 0.000 & 0.170 & 0.03 & 155.6 & 6 + , @xmath53 & & & & & + 3327.88 & 0.410 & 0.130 & 0.98 & 49.3 * & 8 + 3549.01 & 0.130 & 0.280 & 0.97 & 49.0 & 7 + 3584.52 & 0.100 & 0.410 & 0.98 & 44.1 * & 10 + 3600.74 & 0.180 & 0.280 & 1.06 & 68.2 & 7 + 3611.04 & 0.130 & 0.010 & 1.06 & 59.0 & 7 + 3628.70 & 0.130 & 0.710 & 0.90 & 31.8 & 10 + 3710.29 & 0.180 & 0.460 & 0.98 & 82.3 & 10 + 3747.55 & 0.100 & 0.910 & 0.98 & 22.8 & 7 + 3774.33 & 0.130 & 0.210 & 0.91 & 79.0 & 6 + 3788.70 & 0.100 & 0.070 & 0.95 & 66.6 & 6 + 3818.34 & 0.130 & 0.980 & 0.74 & 29.4 & 6 + 3950.36 & 0.100 & 0.490 & 0.94 & 47.4 & 6 + 4398.01 & 0.130 & 1.000 & 0.82 & 28.0 & 6 + 4883.69 & 1.080 & 0.070 & 0.82 & 25.0 & 6 + 5087.43 & 1.080 & 0.170 & 0.91 & 13.8 & 6 + , @xmath54 & & & & & + 3438.23 & 0.090 & 0.420 & 0.57 & 76.8 * & 7 + 3457.56 & 0.560 & 0.530 & 0.17 & 27.3 & 7 + 3479.02 & 0.530 & 0.690 & 0.34 & 16.7 & 7 + 3479.39 & 0.710 & 0.170 & 0.40 & 40.2 * & 7 + 3499.58 & 0.410 & 0.810 & 0.48 & 13.6 * & 7 + 3505.67 & 0.160 & 0.360 & 0.42 & 47.0 * & 7 + 3536.94 & 0.360 & 1.310 & 0.33 & 7.6 * & 7 + 3551.96 & 0.090 & 0.310 & 0.35 & 57.3 * & 8 + 3573.08 & 0.320 & 1.040 & 0.26 & 16.4 & 7 + 3578.23 & 1.220 & 0.610 & 0.29 & 3.8 * & 7 + 3630.02 & 0.360 & 1.110 & 0.28 & 12.8 & 7 + 3714.78 & 0.530 & 0.930 & 0.25 & 13.6 & 7 + 3836.77 & 0.560 & 0.060 & 0.31 & 47.3 & 6 + 3998.97 & 0.560 & 0.670 & 0.07 & 36.1 & 7 + 4050.33 & 0.710 & 1.000 & 0.09 & 11.0 & 7 + 4208.98 & 0.710 & 0.460 & 0.16 & 27.1 & 6 + 4317.32 & 0.710 & 1.380 & 0.08 & 5.3 & 6 + , @xmath21 & & & & & + 3163.40 & 0.376 & 0.260 & 1.30 & 24.2 * & 1 + 3215.59 & 0.440 & 0.190 & 1.65 & 4.5 * & 6 + , @xmath22 & & & & & + 3864.10 & 0.000 & 0.010 & 0.87 & 3.3 & 8 + , @xmath23 & & & & & + 3498.94 & 0.000 & 0.310 & 0.90 & 4.1 & 6 + 3728.03 & 0.000 & 0.270 & 0.82 & 4.7 * & 6 + , @xmath24 & & & & & + 3692.36 & 0.000 & 0.174 & @xmath48 - 1.20 & syn & 6 + , @xmath55 & & & & & + 3404.58 & 0.810 & 0.320 & 1.31 & 6.7 * & 6 + , @xmath56 & & & & & + 3280.68 & 0.000 & 0.050 & 1.88 & 6.5 * & 6 + , @xmath42 & & & & & + 4554.04 & 0.000 & 0.170 & 1.76 & 95.4 * & 6 + 4934.10 & 0.000 & 0.150 & 1.76 & 82.2 * & 6 + 5853.70 & 0.604 & 1.010 & 1.54 & 8.5 * & 6 + 6141.70 & 0.704 & 0.070 & 1.55 & 40.6 * & 6 + @xmath57 & & & & & + 3794.77 & 0.240 & 0.210 & 2.35 & 5.9 * & 7 + 3988.52 & 0.400 & 0.210 & 2.75 & 1.7 * & 4 + 3995.75 & 0.170 & 0.060 & 2.65 & 2.1 * & 4 + 4086.71 & 0.000 & 0.070 & 2.53 & 4.6 * & 4 + 4123.23 & 0.320 & 0.130 & 2.70 & 2.0 * & 4 + @xmath58 & & & & & + 4222.60 & 0.120 & 0.180 & 1.90 & 2.0 * & 6 + 4523.08 & 0.520 & 0.080 & 1.62 & 1.6 * & 10 + 4539.78 & 0.330 & 0.080 & 2.03 & 1.1 & 10 + 4562.37 & 0.480 & 0.190 & 2.01 & 1.4 & 10 + 4572.28 & 0.680 & 0.290 & 1.98 & 1.1 * & 8 + @xmath59 & & & & & + 4179.40 & 0.200 & 0.480 & 2.15 & 7.8 * & 7 + 4189.48 & 0.370 & 0.380 & @xmath48 - 2.15 & & 8 + @xmath60 & & & & & + 3784.25 & 0.380 & 0.150 & 2.14 & 2.0 & 9 + 3826.42 & 0.064 & 0.410 & 2.00 & 2.0 * & 9 + 4061.08 & 0.471 & 0.550 & 2.00 & 5.5 & 9 + 4232.38 & 0.064 & 0.470 & 1.89 & 2.3 * & 9 + @xmath61 & & & & & + 4318.94 & 0.280 & 0.270 & 2.16 & 1.8 * & 7 + 4642.23 & 0.380 & 0.520 & 2.16 & 0.8 & 7 + @xmath62 & & & & & + 3819.67 & 0.000 & 0.510 & 2.95 & syn & 5 + 4129.70 & 0.000 & 0.220 & 2.77 & 9.0 * & 5 + 4205.05 & 0.000 & 0.210 & 2.92 & syn & 5 + @xmath63 & & & & & + 3331.40 & 0.000 & 0.140 & @xmath48 - 2.15 & syn & 7 + 3481.80 & 0.490 & 0.230 & 1.79 & 4.0 * & 7 + 3549.37 & 0.240 & 0.260 & 2.40 & 2.1 & 7 + 3768.40 & 0.080 & 0.360 & 2.48 & 3.8 * & 7 + @xmath64 & & & & & + 3460.97 & 0.000 & 0.070 & 2.42 & 3.2 * & 7 + 3531.71 & 0.000 & 0.770 & 2.81 & 8.3 * & 8 + @xmath65 & & & & & + 3398.94 & 0.000 & 0.410 & @xmath48 - 2.00 & syn & 11 + @xmath66 & & & & & + 3499.10 & 0.060 & 0.136 & 2.75 & 2.7 & 10 + 3692.65 & 0.050 & 0.138 & 2.57 & 4.5 * & 6 + @xmath67 & & & & & + 3701.36 & 0.000 & 0.540 & @xmath483.00 & syn & 8 + @xmath68 & & & & & + 3289.37 & 0.000 & 0.020 & 2.70 & 27.5 * & 8 + 3694.19 & 0.000 & 0.300 & 2.86 & 13.3 * & 8 + @xmath69 & & & & & + 3220.76 & 0.350 & 0.510 & @xmath48 - 1.12 & syn & 7 + 3800.12 & 0.000 & 1.450 & @xmath48 - 1.60 & syn & 7 + @xmath70 & & & & & + 4019.12 & 0.000 & 0.270 & @xmath483.05 & syn & 7 + lccccc species & _ z _ & log@xmath30 & @xmath19 & [ x / fe ] & n + cu & 29 & 0.98 & 0.29 & 1.15 & 3 + zn & 30 & 2.01 & 0.16 & + 0.18 & 4 + sr & 38 & 0.11 & 0.08 & 0.26 & 3 + y & 39 & 0.93 & 0.09 & 0.37 & 15 + zr & 40 & 0.28 & 0.16 & 0.10 & 17 + nb & 41 & 1.48 & 0.17 & 0.13 & 2 + mo & 42 & 0.87 & 0.17 & 0.02 & 1 + ru & 44 & 0.86 & 0.17 & + 0.07 & 2 + rh & 45 & @xmath481.20 & & @xmath48 + 0.45 & 1 + pd & 46 & 1.36 & 0.17 & 0.28 & 2 + ag & 47 & 1.88 & 0.17 & 0.05 & 1 + ba & 56 & 1.62 & 0.12 & 1.02 & 4 + la & 57 & 2.66 & 0.10 & 1.02 & 5 + ce & 58 & 1.83 & 0.18 & 0.64 & 6 + pr & 59 & 2.15 & 0.17 & 0.09 & 1 + nd & 60 & 2.01 & 0.10 & 0.69 & 4 + sm & 62 & 2.16 & 0.17 & 0.40 & 2 + eu & 63 & 2.77 & 0.17 & 0.52 & 1 + gd & 64 & 2.44 & 0.17 & 0.76 & 2 + dy & 66 & 2.62 & 0.17 & 0.99 & 2 + ho & 67 & @xmath482.00 & & @xmath48 + 0.26 & 1 + er & 68 & 2.66 & 0.17 & 0.82 & 2 + tm & 69 & @xmath483.00 & & @xmath480.23 & 1 + yb & 70 & 2.78 & 0.17 & 1.09 & 2 + ir & 77 & @xmath481.60 & & @xmath480.21 & 2 + th & 90 & @xmath483.05 & & @xmath480.34 & 1 + lccccccccccc species & & & & & & & + & @xmath71 & @xmath72 & & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & & @xmath75 & @xmath76 & & @xmath76 & @xmath75 + & @xmath770.22 & @xmath780.17 & & @xmath780.06 & @xmath770.07 & & @xmath770.15 & @xmath780.06 & & @xmath780.23 & @xmath770.26 + & @xmath770.05 & @xmath780.04 & & @xmath770.05 & @xmath780.04 & & 0.00 & @xmath770.01 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 + & @xmath770.13 & @xmath780.12 & & @xmath780.02 & @xmath770.03 & & @xmath770.04 & 0.00 & & @xmath780.01 & 0.00 + & @xmath770.12 & @xmath780.11 & & @xmath770.05 & @xmath780.03 & & @xmath770.03 & @xmath780.05 & & @xmath780.31 & @xmath770.39 + & @xmath770.08 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath770.08 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath780.02 & @xmath770.01 & & @xmath780.16 & @xmath770.09 + & @xmath770.08 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.08 & @xmath770.05 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.10 & & @xmath780.04 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 + & @xmath770.19 & @xmath780.17 & & @xmath780.02 & @xmath770.01 & & @xmath770.03 & @xmath780.00 & & @xmath780.00 & 0.00 + & @xmath770.20 & @xmath780.17 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath770.04 & @xmath780.00 & & @xmath780.01 & 0.00 + & @xmath770.20 & @xmath780.17 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.03 & & @xmath770.04 & @xmath770.01 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.01 + & @xmath770.21 & @xmath780.17 & & @xmath780.00 & @xmath770.01 & & @xmath770.04 & @xmath780.00 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.01 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.01 & & @xmath780.08 & @xmath770.06 + & @xmath770.08 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.00 & @xmath770.00 + & @xmath770.08 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath780.02 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.00 & 0.00 + & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.01 + & @xmath770.08 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.10 & & @xmath780.04 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.00 & 0.00 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.07 & & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.00 & @xmath780.00 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.10 & & @xmath780.04 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.00 & @xmath770.00 + & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath770.11 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.00 & 0.00 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.10 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.10 & & @xmath780.05 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.01 & @xmath770.01 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.09 & & @xmath780.04 & @xmath770.03 & & @xmath780.00 & @xmath780.00 + & @xmath770.09 & @xmath780.08 & & @xmath770.10 & @xmath780.10 & & @xmath780.04 & @xmath770.02 & & @xmath780.03 & @xmath770.02 +
Abstract: | [
"we obtained high resolution , high s / n spectroscopy for the very metal - poor star hd 122563 with the subaru telescope high dispersion spectrograph . previous studies have shown that this object has excesses of light neutron - capture elements , while its abundances of heavy ones are very low . in our spectrum covering 3070 4780 of this object , 19 neutron - capture elements have been detected , including seven for the first time in this star ( nb , mo , ru , pd , ag , pr , and sm ) . upper limits are given for five other elements including th . the abundance pattern shows a gradually decreasing trend , as a function of atomic number , from sr to yb , which is quite different from those in stars with excesses of r - process elements . this abundance pattern of neutron - capture elements provides new strong constraints on the models of nucleosynthesis responsible for the very metal - poor stars with excesses of light neutron - capture elements but without enhancement of heavy ones ."
] | 9,436 | 9,436 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: for many years , the dominant method for discovering massive clusters of galaxies at @xmath11 , has been via x - ray emission from the hot gas in their dark matter potential wells . over the years , the _ rosat _ and _ xmm - newton _ telescopes , in particular , have yielded a handful of well - studied examples e.g. , rdcs j0910 + 5422 @xcite , rdcs j1252.9 - 2927 @xcite , rx j0848 + 4452 ( lynx e ; @xcite ) , xmmu j2235 - 25 @xcite , and xmmxcs j2215.9 - 1738 @xcite . in recent years , it has been realised that , by incorporating deep infrared ( ir ) observations , existing optical imaging techniques can be adapted to successfully detect clusters at redshifts competitive to the existing x - ray surveys . however , because ir observations covering only modest areas ( 120 arcmin@xmath1 - 7.25 deg@xmath1 ) have been available , the ( cluster or candidate ) systems detected to date have been less massive than those discovered from the x - ray surveys ( @xcite ; although see @xcite ) . massive clusters of galaxies are rare , and one requires as widefield a survey as possible to detect them . the largest area _ space telescope survey is the 50 square degree seven passband ( 3.6 , 4.5 , 5.8 , 8.0 , 24 , 70 , 160 @xmath12 ) spitzer wide - area infrared extragalactic survey ( swire ) legacy survey @xcite . we have obtained deep @xmath13band imaging @xcite , and combined this with the pre - existing infrared array camera ( irac ; @xcite ) observations from the swire survey , aiming to select clusters at @xmath14 using a two filter @xmath15 $ ] infrared adaptation of the well - proven optical cluster red sequence ( rs ) method @xcite . the sparcsgillianw / sparcs ] survey @xcite , is now complete and has an effective area ( defined as the usable overlap with swire after excluding chip gaps , regions near bright stars , etc ) , of 41.9 deg@xmath16 . the sparcs catalog contains several hundred cluster candidates at @xmath14 , by far the largest , homogeneously selected sample of its kind . in @xcite and @xcite we presented an overview of the sparcs survey , and reported spectroscopic confirmation of three clusters at @xmath17 and @xmath18 . in this paper , we report spectroscopic confirmation of three additional clusters at @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the paper is organized as follows : in [ observations ] , we describe the imaging and spectroscopic observations , and the data reduction ; in [ analysis ] , we describe the spectroscopic catalog ; in [ results ] , we present our results for the three individual clusters , and estimate the cluster velocity dispersions and dynamical masses ; and in [ discussion ] , we present a discussion and the main conclusions based on our results . we assume a @xmath21-cdm cosmology with @xmath22 and @xmath23 , and h@xmath24 km s@xmath5 mpc@xmath5 . the sparcs / swire survey is comprised of six fields ( see table 1 of * ? ? ? * ) . the three clusters described in this paper were identified as high significance cluster candidates in the 7.9 deg@xmath1 elais - n1 field . a full description of the sparcs data reduction , cluster candidate detection algorithm and catalogs will appear in muzzin et al . 2010 , in preparation . we provide only a brief overview of the main details here . sparcs @xmath0 observations of the northern fields were observed by cfht / megacam for a total integration time of 6000s per pointing . photometry was performed on both the @xmath25 and irac mosaics using the sextractor photometry package @xcite . the total 3.6 @xmath12 magnitude of all sources in the field was computed using a large aperture , equal to the geometric mean radius of the sextractor isophotal aperture . further details of the photometric pipeline may be found in @xcite and @xcite . the depth of the @xmath0 data varies from pointing to pointing depending on the seeing and the sky background , however , the mean 5 @xmath26 depth for extended sources in the elais - n1 field was @xmath27 vega ( 24.2 ab ) . the @xmath28 color of all sources was computed using an aperture of diameter three irac pixels ( @xmath29 ) . no aperture corrections were applied to the @xmath25 photometry because the @xmath30 color aperture was much larger than the median seeing . however , the irac point spread function ( psf ) has broad wings compared to a typical ground - based seeing profile , and it was necessary to apply aperture corrections to the measured 3.6 @xmath12 magnitude before computing the color of each galaxy . galaxy clusters were identified in the sparcs survey , using an algorithm very similar to that described in detail in @xcite , as applied to the spitzer first look survey ( fls ; @xcite ) . for cluster detection in both the fls and sparcs surveys , we used an infrared adaptation of the cluster red - sequence ( crs ) technique @xcite . this algorithm maps the density of galaxies in a survey within narrow color slices , giving greater weight to brighter galaxies , and flagging the highest overdensities as candidate clusters . the one important difference here , compared to @xcite , is that the latter paper used an @xmath31 $ ] color to detect clusters at @xmath32 in the fls . the deeper irac data in swire ( @xmath33s frames ) , compared to the fls ( @xmath34s frames ) , combined with the @xmath15 $ ] color choice , allow sparcs to detect clusters to higher redshift than was possible with the fls dataset . from analysis of the richnesses and colors , sparcs j161641 + 554513 and sparcs j161037 + 552417 were identified as rich cluster candidates at @xmath11 , and sparcs j161315 + 564930 as an unusually rich cluster candidate at @xmath35 ( table [ tab_clusters ] ) . spectroscopic observations of sparcs j161315 + 564930 , sparcs j161641 + 554513 and sparcs j161037 + 552417 were obtained with the low resolution imaging spectrograph ( lris ; @xcite ) on the keck i telescope on the nights of april 3th and april 4th , 2008 . the seeing on both nights was about @xmath36 . lris has beam - splitters that separate the light between two sides : red @xcite and blue @xcite . on the red side , we used the 400 line mm@xmath5 grating which gives a coverage of @xmath37 centered at 8500 , with a dispersion of 1.86 / pixels . all the masks were designed with slits of 11 width , which gave a resolution of @xmath387 - 9 ( fwhm ) over the wavelength interval @xmath386600 - 9600 . for the redshift range of these particular clusters , all of the prominent spectral features e.g. , the 4000 - rest - frame break or [ o@xmath39 emission line , fall in the lris red side wavelength window . we observed one mask each in the case of clusters sparcs j161315 + 564930 and sparcs j161641 + 554513 , and two in the case of sparcs j161037 + 552417 . the total exposure time was 6000s ( @xmath40 ) for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , 8400s ( @xmath41 ) for sparcs j161641 + 554513 , and 8400s ( @xmath42 ) and 7000s ( @xmath43 ) for mask @xmath44 and mask @xmath45 of sparcs j161037 + 552417 ( table 1 ) . the masks contained about 30 slits each ( five of these were alignment stars and the remaining 25 were galaxies , selected according to a sliding scale of priority ) . to reduce the number of slits placed on obvious foreground galaxies , we prioritized slits on galaxies with colors near each cluster s red - sequence . to avoid significant selection bias , we used a very broad cut around the red - sequence , intended to include both star forming and non - star forming systems . slits were placed on galaxies with priorities from 1 to 4 . priority 1 was galaxies with colors within 0.2 magnitude of the rs , and with @xmath46 < 17.0 $ ] ( vega ) . priority 2 was galaxies with colors between 0.2 and 0.6 magnitudes bluer than the rs , and with @xmath47 < 18.7 $ ] . priority 3 was galaxies with same colors as priority 1 , but with @xmath47 < 18.7 $ ] , and priority 4 was galaxies with same colors as priority 2 , but with @xmath47 < 18.7 $ ] . priorities 1 to 4 roughly correspond to bright red - sequence , blue cloud , faint red - sequence , and faint blue cloud galaxies respectively . approximately ten priority 1 galaxies could be accomodated per mask for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , and five per mask for sparcs j161641 + 554513 and sparcs j161037 + 552417 . to reduce the lris data , we adapted custom software , based on that developed by @xcite to reduce vlt / fors2 data . overscan and bias corrections were applied to both the calibration ( bias , flats and lamp arcs ) and to the science ( clusters and standard stars ) frames using the iraf _ lrisbias _ and _ lccdproc _ tasks developed by g. d. wirth and c. fassnacht . after these corrections had been applied , the data were next corrected for geometric distortions across the dispersion axis , and then separated into individual slitlets and reduced using standard long - slit techniques . each individual slitlet was processed using an algorithm similar to that implemented in _ bogus _ ( developed by d. stern , a. j. bunker and s. a. stanford)stern / homepage / bogus.html ] . the flatfield slitlets were normalized and applied to the corresponding science slitlets . the individual 2d spectra were then background - subtracted and fringe - corrected before being stacked to produce a final co - added 2d spectrum . slits longer than 90 pixels ( @xmath48 ) were further corrected for long - slit " distortions . the 1d spectrum of the source ( or sources ) in each slitlet was then extracted using standard iraf tasks . a set of near lamp exposures were used to wavelength - calibrate the observations . lris spectra can suffer significant flexure which may introduce wavelength offsets as large as @xmath49 in the wavelength solution , in the most extreme cases . the offsets in the wavelength calibration due to flexure were corrected by comparing to the wavelengths of known skylines . we estimate the residual uncertainties in wavelength calibration to be at most 1 , which correspond to a redshift uncertainty of @xmath50 at @xmath51 . finally , a relative flux calibration was performed , using a sensitivity function spanning the range 5600 - 9400 which was obtained from long - slit observations of the standard stars feige 34 and feige 67 @xcite . a redshift solution was sought for each object by cross - correlating @xcite each of the lris spectra with observed galaxy templates @xcite using the task _ xcsao _ in the iraf _ rvsao _ package @xcite . if a redshift could be obtained for a spectrum , it was assigned a quality flag , `` q '' , with one of two possible values : 0 or 1 . high - confidence redshifts , unambiguously determined by two or more clear features in the continuum or in absorption , or by obvious emission lines such as [ o@xmath39 ( @xmath52 ) were assigned @xmath53 . lower - confidence redshifts based on ambiguous identification of a few spectral features , often in low s / n spectra , were assigned @xmath54 . in addition to a quality flag , an emission line flag , `` e '' , was also assigned to each galaxy , based on the presence or absence of emission line features . spectra displaying one or more emission feature such as h@xmath55 , [ o@xmath56(@xmath574959,@xmath575007 ) or h@xmath58 in the case of low - redshift ( @xmath59 ) galaxies , or [ o@xmath39(@xmath573727 ) in the case of higher redshift galaxies , were assigned @xmath60 . spectra showing no sign of excess emission above the stellar continuum , were assigned @xmath61 . the total number of galaxies ( cluster members and foreground or background galaxies , excluding stars ) extracted from the fields of sparcs j161315 + 564930 , sparcs j161037 + 552417 and sparcs j161641 + 554513 were 22 , 19 and 34 ( see tables [ tab_en1_240 ] , [ tab_en1_349 ] and [ tab_en1_381 ] ) . occasionally , one or more serendipitous sources fell within a slit . the breakdown by quality flag was 20 , 13 and 14 @xmath53 galaxies , and 2 , 6 and 20 @xmath54 galaxies , respectively . example spectra for a subsample of cluster members ( see section [ cl240 ] for the definition of a `` cluster member '' ) are shown in figure [ cl_specs ] . the left column shows examples of sparcs j161315 + 564930 members , the center column shows examples of sparcs j161641 + 554513 members , and the right column shows exampels of sparcs j161037 + 552417 members . the i d of each object is indicated ( tables [ tab_en1_240 ] , [ tab_en1_349 ] and [ tab_en1_381 ] ) . fluxes are in relative units , and smoothed by 7 pixels ( 1 pix @xmath62 ) . prominent spectral features are indicated by vertical lines . [ results ] in determining cluster membership , and calculating a velocity dispersion and mass , only high confidence , @xmath53 , galaxies were considered . definitive cluster membership was determined using the code of @xcite , which is based on the shifting - gap technique of @xcite . this procedure uses both galaxy angular position and radial velocity information to exclude near - field interlopers . the squares in the left panel of figure [ z_histo_240 ] show the 14 @xmath53 galaxies identified as members of cluster sparcs j161315 + 564930 ( see table [ tab_en1_240 ] ) by the shifting - gap technique . for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , these @xmath53 cluster members fall in the range @xmath63 , indicated by the vertical dashed lines shown in the right panel of figure [ z_histo_240 ] , which shows the redshift histogram for the sparcs j161315 + 564930 field . the properties of the cluster members and non - members are summarized in table [ tab_en1_240 ] . the total 3.6 @xmath12 magnitude ( column 4 in table [ tab_en1_240 ] ) , and @xmath28 color ( column 5 in table [ tab_en1_240 ] ) were calculated as described in section [ photometry ] . in determining membership , we did not require that any @xmath54 galaxies satisfy the shifting - gap criteria ; if their redshifts fell in the range @xmath63 we included them as cluster members " in table [ tab_en1_240 ] , but re - emphasize that we do not utilize them in estimating the cluster mean redshift or velocity dispersion . the total number of cluster members is 16 ( 14 with @xmath53 and 2 with @xmath54 ) , and six foreground / background galaxies . all confirmed members of cluster sparcs j161315 + 564930 were passive ( @xmath61 ) galaxies . in some cases , a redshift was obtained which did not correspond to any galaxy in our photometric catalog . in the case of faint galaxies , this was because a spectroscopic redshift was obtained for a strong emission line galaxy whose continuum fell below the detection threshold of the @xmath25 catalog . in the case of bright galaxies , this was because of blending issues with the irac @xmath64 @xmath65 psf . these galaxies were assigned both a @xmath46$]-band magnitude and a @xmath66 $ ] color of 99 in table [ tab_en1_240 ] . figure [ proj_dist_240 ] shows @xmath67 $ ] color composites of cluster sparcs j161315 + 564930 . the @xmath68 data were obtained from wfc on the isaac newton telescope , and are available with the swire public data release @xcite . the white squares ( green circles ) overlaid on the right panel show the 16 cluster members ( and foreground / background galaxies in the @xmath69 fov ) with spectroscopically - confirmed redshifts from keck / lris ( see table [ tab_en1_240 ] ) . once cluster membership was established , both the redshift and rest - frame velocity dispersion , @xmath70 , of sparcs j003550 - 431224 were then calculated iteratively using the `` robust estimator '' , @xmath71 @xcite . the robust estimator has been shown to be less sensitive than the standard deviation to outliers which may persist even after rejecting interlopers using the shifting - gap technique . the actual estimator used depends on the number of cluster members and is either the biweight estimator for datasets with at least 15 members , or , as here in the case of sparcs j161315 + 564930 with 14 @xmath53 members , the gapper estimator . the gapper estimator is discussed more fully in @xcite , @xcite and @xcite . the line - of - sight rest - frame velocity dispersion , @xmath72 , was calculated directly from the vector of spectroscopic redshift measurements , , as @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the speed of light , and @xmath75 is the estimated dispersion of the measured redshifts with respect to the center of the distribution , @xmath76 . a mean redshift of @xmath77 and a velocity dispersion of @xmath78 km s@xmath5 were calculated for sparcs j161315 + 564930 ( table [ tab_clusters ] ) . the uncertainty on the latter was determined using jackknife resampling of the data . for comparison , a gaussian with an rms of 1230 km s@xmath5 has been overlaid on the redshift histogram in the right panel of figure [ z_histo_240 ] . the line - of - sight rest - frame velocity dispersion can be used to calculate a dynamical estimate of @xmath79 , the radius at which the mean interior density is 200 times the critical density , @xmath80 , and @xmath81 , the mass contained within @xmath79 . in the spherical collapse model , at redshift @xmath82 , @xmath83 can be calculated from @xmath84 where @xmath85 , is the hubble parameter at redshift @xmath82 , and @xmath86 based on its velocity dispersion of @xmath78 km s@xmath5 , we estimate an @xmath87 mpc and a dynamical mass of @xmath88 m@xmath89 for sparcs j161315 + 564930 ( table [ tab_clusters ] ) . although this mass is preliminary ( see section [ richness ] ) , it seems likely that sparcs j161315 + 564930 is an unusually massive cluster , perhaps the most massive cluster in the entire sparcs survey , and comparable in mass to that of cluster ms 1054 - 03 at @xmath90 @xcite . the @xmath66 $ ] vs. @xmath0 color - magnitude diagram for all galaxies ( gray circles ) within a radius of @xmath83 ( @xmath91 mpc ) of the center of sparcs j161315 + 564930 is shown in figure [ colmag_240 ] . this radius is approximately equal to the virial radius . spectroscopically - confirmed galaxies are shown by colored symbols . in this figure ( and in figures [ colmag_349 ] and [ colmag_381 ] ) , cluster members ( @xmath53 or @xmath54 ) are shown by red circles and foreground / background galaxies by blue squares . note that there are several cluster members or foreground / background galaxies shown in table [ tab_en1_240 ] , which fall within a projected radius of @xmath83 of the cluster center , but for which a color could not be determined . these galaxies do not appear in figure [ colmag_240 ] ( or in figures [ colmag_349 ] or [ colmag_381 ] , in the cases of tables [ tab_en1_349 ] and tables [ tab_en1_381 ] ) . seven @xmath53 galaxies were determined to be cluster members of sparcs j161641 + 554513 by the shifting - gap technique . these galaxies are shown by squares in the left panel of figure [ z_histo_349 ] . these galaxies lie in the redshift range @xmath92 , indicated by the vertical dashed lines in the right panel of figure [ z_histo_349 ] . table [ tab_en1_349 ] summarizes the cluster members " , the ten @xmath53 and @xmath54 galaxies with redshifts in this range , and the nine foreground / background galaxies . the right panel of figure [ z_histo_349 ] shows the redshift histogram for the field of sparcs j161641 + 554513 . a gaussian with an rms of 950 km s@xmath5 has been overlaid . figure [ proj_dist_349 ] shows @xmath67 $ ] color composites of cluster sparcs j161641 + 554513 . the white squares ( green circles ) overlaid on the right panel show the cluster members ( foreground / background galaxies ) with spectroscopically - confirmed redshifts ( see table [ tab_en1_349 ] ) which fall within the @xmath93 fov of the image . of the seven @xmath53 cluster members , five were classified as passive ( @xmath61 ) , one was classified as emission line ( @xmath60 ) , and one was classifed as an agn ( @xmath94 ) . the upper left white square in figure [ proj_dist_349 ] corresponds to the agn . there were also three passive @xmath54 cluster members ( table [ tab_en1_349 ] ) . the spectrum of the confirmed agn ( object i d @xmath95 854892 in table [ tab_en1_349 ] ) is shown in the lowest panel of the center column in figure [ cl_specs ] . this source shows nev(@xmath573346,@xmath573426 ) and neiii(@xmath573869,@xmath573968 ) in emission , which are common in agn , as well as prominent [ oii](@xmath573727 ) emission and high - order balmer lines ( h@xmath96 , h@xmath97 and h6 ) also in emission . the cluster mean redshift and velocity dispersion , were estimated iteratively from the seven @xmath53 members , using the gapper estimator . the mean redshift of sparcs j161641 + 554513 was calculated to be @xmath98 . the velocity dispersion was calculated to be @xmath99 km s@xmath5 , which corresponds to @xmath100 mpc , and a dynamical mass of @xmath101 m@xmath89(table [ tab_clusters ] ) . the @xmath66 $ ] vs. @xmath0 color - magnitude diagram for all galaxies ( gray circles ) within a radius of @xmath83 ( @xmath102 mpc ) of the center of sparcs j161641 + 554513 is shown in figure [ colmag_349 ] . the red circles and blue squares indicate those cluster members and foreground / background galaxies which lie within a projected distance of @xmath83 of the cluster center , and for which a color could be determined . seven @xmath53 galaxies were also determined to be cluster members of sparcs j161037 + 552417 by the shifting - gap technique . these galaxies are indicated by squares in the left panel of figure [ z_histo_381 ] . two galaxies , indicated by crosses in figure [ z_histo_381 ] ( i d @xmath95 s 727869 and 734082 in table [ tab_en1_381 ] ) , were identified as near - field interlopers . the seven @xmath53 members lie in the redshift range @xmath103 , shown by the vertical dashed lines in the right panel of figure [ z_histo_381 ] . table [ tab_en1_381 ] summarizes the cluster members " , the ten @xmath53 or @xmath54 galaxies with redshifts in this range , and the 24 foreground / background galaxies . the right panel of figure [ z_histo_381 ] shows the redshift histogram for the field of sparcs j161037 + 552417 . a gaussian with an rms of 410 km s@xmath5 has been overlaid . figure [ proj_dist_381 ] shows @xmath67 $ ] color composites of cluster sparcs j161037 + 552417 . the white squares ( green circles ) overlaid on the right panel show the cluster members ( foreground / background galaxies ) with spectroscopically - confirmed redshifts ( see table [ tab_en1_381 ] ) which fall within the @xmath104 fov of the image . of the seven @xmath53 cluster members , all were classified as emission line ( @xmath60 ) . of the three @xmath54 cluster members , one was classified as passive ( @xmath61 ) , and two as emission line ( @xmath60 ) . the cluster mean redshift and velocity dispersion , were calculated iteratively from the seven @xmath53 members , using the gapper estimator . the mean redshift of sparcs j161037 + 552417 was estimated to be @xmath105 and the velocity dispersion , @xmath106 km s@xmath5 , which corresponds to @xmath107 mpc and a dynamical mass of @xmath108 m@xmath89 ( table [ tab_clusters ] ) . sparcs j161037 + 552417 is significantly less massive than sparcs j161315 + 564930 or sparcs j161641 + 554513 . the much smaller @xmath83 estimated for sparcs j161037 + 552417 , combined with the geometric limitations of lris with respect to the redshift number density yield measurable from a single mask , resulted in a yield of only four spectroscopically confirmed members within @xmath83 from two masks . moreover , because of blending issues with irac s @xmath64 @xmath65 psf , a reliable @xmath66 $ ] color could not be determined for one of these galaxies ( i d @xmath95 4000013 in table [ tab_en1_381 ] ) . figure [ colmag_381 ] shows the @xmath66 $ ] vs. @xmath0 color - magnitude diagram for all galaxies ( gray circles ) within a radius of @xmath109 ( @xmath110 kpc ) of the center of cluster sparcs j161037 + 552417 . the three red circles denote the cluster members with i d @xmath95 s 723814 , 722784 , and 722712 in table [ tab_en1_381 ] . color - magnitude diagrams for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , sparcs j161037 + 552417 and sparcs j161037 + 552417 were presented in figures [ colmag_240 ] , [ colmag_349 ] , and [ colmag_381 ] . column 2 of table [ tab_properties ] shows the @xmath15 $ ] color of the red sequence for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , sparcs j161037 + 552417 and sparcs j161037 + 552417 . the color is calculated from the mean color of the spectroscopically confirmed red - sequence cluster members . also shown in column 2 of table [ tab_properties ] is the color of the rs for three additional clusters , previously reported in @xcite and @xcite . these clusters are sparcs j163435 + 402151 at @xmath111 , sparcs j163852 + 403843 at @xmath112 , and sparcs j003550 - 431224 at @xmath113 ( column 6 ) . for all six clusters a systematic uncertainty in the rs color of 0.15 magnitude has been assumed ( this uncertainty reflects the fact that , at present , we are using the zeropoints provided by elixir for the @xmath0 observations . we expect , in the future , to be able to reduce these photometric uncertainties , using our own internal calibration ) . columns 3 , 4 and 5 of table [ tab_properties ] show the redshift that would be estimated for each cluster based on the measured rs color ( column 2 ) , assuming a solar metallicity single burst bc03 model and a formation redshift of either @xmath114 , 4 or 10 . as can be seen from table [ tab_properties ] ( and the left panel of figure [ zsandmasses ] ) , the photometric redshift inferred from the measured @xmath66 $ ] color has a slight dependence on one s choice of formation redshift , although differences in color between the models at @xmath115 are fairly small ( @xmath116 between @xmath117 and @xmath118 ) . utilizing the colors from the @xmath119 model , the three new clusters presented here were assigned preliminarily redshift estimates of @xmath120 , @xmath121 , and @xmath122 ( table [ tab_properties ] ) . these photometrically estimated redshifts are very similar to , albeit slightly lower than , the spectroscopically determined values of @xmath123 , @xmath124 , and @xmath125 ( column 6 in table [ tab_properties ] ) . the @xmath126 $ ] color vs. spectroscopic redshift for all six sparcs clusters in table [ tab_properties ] is plotted in the left panel of figure [ zsandmasses ] . the solid , dotted and and dashed lines show the bc03 model colors as a function of redshift for formation redshifts of @xmath114 , 4 and 10 . it is clear from figure [ zsandmasses ] that the agreement between the model colors and the observations is very good . with a larger sample of clusters , there may turn out to be small but real discrepancies between the models and the measured rs colors . in the left panel of figure [ zsandmasses ] , the @xmath119 model can be seen to be slightly redder than the observations in the case of five clusters ( or equivalantly , the inferred photometric redshift can be seen to be slightly lower than the spectroscopic redshift ) , but slightly bluer in the case of one cluster ( sparcs j003550 - 431224 ) . these small offsets in color between the models and the observations , can also be seen directly from figures [ colmag_240 ] , [ colmag_349 ] , and [ colmag_381 ] . the solid lines in these three figures show the rs color predicted by the bc03 @xmath119 model _ at the spectroscopic redshift of the cluster _ , and can be seen to be slightly redder than the observed color . a more detailed comparison between the model predictions and the observations will be made in a future paper employing a larger sample of sparcs clusters . despite the aforementioned caveats , and the issue of degeneracies between the photometric redshift of the clusters and the formation redshifts of their galaxies , our overall conclusion is that the inferred one - color photometric redshifts and the spectroscopic redshifts are in excellent ( @xmath127 ) general agreement . in addition to estimating the masses for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , sparcs j161641 + 554513 , and sparcs j161037 + 552417 from the galaxy line - of - sight velocity dispersion , we also estimated the masses from the richness of the clusters , using the @xmath128 richness parameter . @xcite introduced @xmath128 , an adaptation of the @xmath129 richness parameter , intended to utilize two - band photometry to increase the contrast of the cluster with the background , and therefore provide a measurement of the richness that is less sensitive to foreground / background large scale structures . @xmath129 is the amplitude of the three - dimensional , cluster center - galaxy spatial correlation function , @xmath130 @xcite . instead of counting galaxies in a single passband , @xmath128 is obtained by counting galaxies in a color slice centered on the location of each cluster s red - sequence in the @xmath66 $ ] color - magnitude diagram . in computing @xmath128 , we used a slice bounded in color by @xmath66 = \pm0.3 $ ] of the best - fit rs color returned by the cluster finding algorithm ( @xcite ) , and bounded in magnitude by @xmath131 , where @xmath132 is the bc03 @xmath119 model prediction of the characteristic magnitude of a galaxy _ at the photometric redshift _ corresponding to that rs color ( table [ tab_properties ] ) . the background galaxy counts were determined from the color distribution in the entire 7.9 deg@xmath1 elais - n1 field , minus the regions known to contain galaxy clusters . the @xmath128 richnesses of the three clusters were computed to be @xmath133 mpc@xmath134 ( sparcs j161315 + 564930 ) , @xmath135 mpc@xmath134 ( sparcs j161641 + 554513 ) , and @xmath136 mpc@xmath134 ( sparcs j161037 + 552417 ) . based on the empirical calibration of @xmath137 vs. @xmath138 determined by @xcite in the k - band for 15 cnoc1 clusters at @xmath139 , these richnesses correspond to @xmath140 for sparcs j161315 + 564930 , @xmath141 for sparcs j161641 + 554513 , and @xmath142 for sparcs j161037 + 552417 . for comparison , columns 7 and 8 of table [ tab_properties ] show the dynamical mass , @xmath143 , and richness mass , @xmath144 , estimates for all six sparcs clusters . although the uncertainties associated with both of the mass estimators are large , they are consistent with each other at the 1@xmath145 level for five out of the six clusters and at the 2@xmath145 level for the sixth . the agreement between the two mass estimators can be seen in the right panel of figure [ zsandmasses ] . based on all six sparcs clusters spectroscopically confirmed to date , our conclusion is that , in addition to there being excellent agreement between the photometric and spectroscopic redshifts , there is also reasonable agreement between the cluster dynamical and richness mass estimates . the dynamical masses estimates should be considered preliminary at this stage . uncertainties will reduce as more data becomes available from a large spectroscopic follow - up program of sparcs clusters currently being carried out at the gemini telescopes . collectively , the six sparcs clusters confirmed to date ( the three clusters presented in @xcite and @xcite , plus the three clusters presented here ) , demonstrate that , given the availability of infrared observations , the rs technique is an efficient and effective method of detecting _ bona fide _ massive galaxy clusters at @xmath146 . moreover , our studies of these six clusters are showing that it is possible to infer fundamental parameters such as cluster redshift and mass _ from the survey data itself _ ( see also @xcite ) . at @xmath147 , both the optical red - sequence cluster surveys , rcs-1 @xcite and rcs-2 @xcite , and the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ; @xcite ) have shown that it is feasible to measure cosmological parameters from the evolution of the cluster mass function @xcite . in order to do this efficiently , the survey data themselves are used to detect clusters , and also to estimate the redshift and the mass of those clusters . the redshift is estimated from the red sequence color @xcite , and the mass is estimated from the optical richness @xcite . the fact that sparcs is also now demonstrating the practicality of estimating redshifts and masses at @xmath146 from the survey data alone is heartening for the current generation of surveys aiming to utilize optical - infrared high redshift cluster observations to constrain cosmological parameters e.g. , sparcs , the ukirt infrared deep - sky survey deep extragalactic survey ( ukidss dxs ; @xcite),and the irac shallow cluster survey ( iscs ; @xcite ) . these optical - ir surveys will provide complementary samples to those selected using the sunyaev - zeldovich effect , e.g. , the south pole telescope survey ( spt ; @xcite ) , the atacama cosmology telescope ( act ; @xcite ) , and the atacama pathfinder experiment ( apex ; @xcite ) . the complete sparcs catalog contains several hundred cluster candidates at @xmath14 . with new large , homogeneous , reliable @xmath11 catalogs becoming available from sparcs and other surveys in the very near future , the prospects look bright for high redshift cluster and cluster galaxy evolution studies in the coming years . + we thank the referee for useful comments . the authors wish to recognize and acknowledge the very significant cultural role and reverence that the summit of mauna kea has always had within the indigenous hawaiian community . we are most fortunate to have the opportunity to conduct observations from this mountain . this work is based in part on archival data obtained with the spitzer space telescope , which is operated by the jet propulsion laboratory , california institute of technology under a contract with nasa . support for this work was provided by an award issued by jpl / caltech . gw also gratefully acknowledges support from nsf grant ast-0909198 , and from the college of natural and agricultural sciences at ucr . andreon , s. , maughan , b. , trinchieri , g. , & kurk , j. 2008 , , 507 , 147 becker , m. r. , et al . 2007 , , 669 , 905 beers , t. c. , flynn , k. , & gebhardt , k. 1990 , , 100 , 32 bertin , e. , & arnouts , s. 1996 , , 117 , 393 blindert , k. 2006 , ph.d . thesis , university of toronto , canada bremer , m. n. , et al . 2006 , , 371 , 1427 brodwin , m. , et al . 2006 , , 651 , 791 bruzual , g. , & charlot , s. 2003 , , 344 , 1000 carlstrom , j. e. , et al . 2009 , arxiv:0907.4445 demarco , r. , et al . 2005 , , 432 , 381 demarco , r. , et al . 2007 , , 663 , 164 dobbs , m. , et al . 2006 , new astronomy review , 50 , 960 eisenhardt , p. r. m. , et al . 2008 , , 684 , 905 fadda , d. , girardi , m. , giuricin , g. , mardirossian , f. , & mezzetti , m. 1996 , , 473 , 670 fazio , g. g. , et al . 2004 , , 154 , 10 gilbank , d. g. , yee , h. k. c. , ellingson , e. , gladders , m. d. , barrientos , l. f. , & blindert , k. 2007 , , 134 , 282 gioia , i. m. , braito , v. , branchesi , m. , della ceca , r. , maccacaro , t. , & tran , k .- v . 2004 , , 419 , 517 girardi , m. , biviano , a. , giuricin , g. , mardirossian , f. , & mezzetti , m. 1993 , , 404 , 38 girardi , m. , demarco , r. , rosati , p. , & borgani , s. 2005 , , 442 , 29 gladders , m. d. , yee , h. k. c. , majumdar , s. , barrientos , l. f. , hoekstra , h. , hall , p. b. , & infante , l. 2007 , , 655 , 128 gladders , m. d. , & yee , h. k. c. 2000 , , 120 , 2148 gladders , m. d. , & yee , h. k. c. 2005 , , 157 , 1 goto , t. , et al . 2008 , , 60 , 531 hoekstra , h. , franx , m. , & kuijken , k. 2000 , , 532 , 88 jee , m. j. , white , r. l. , ford , h. c. , blakeslee , j. p. , illingworth , g. d. , coe , d. a. , & tran , k .- v . h. 2005 , , 634 , 813 kinney , a. l. , calzetti , d. , bohlin , r. c. , mcquade , k. , storchi - bergmann , t. , & schmitt , h. r. 1996 , , 467 , 38 koester , b. p. , et al . 2007 , , 660 , 239 kosowsky , a. 2003 , new astronomy review , 47 , 939 koyama , y. , kodama , t. , tanaka , m. , shimasaku , k. , & okamura , s. 2007 , , 382 , 1719 krick , j. e. , surace , j. a. , thompson , d. , ashby , m. l. n. , hora , j. l. , gorjian , v. , & yan , l. 2008 , , 686 , 918 kurk , j. , et al . 2008 , astronomical society of the pacific conference series , 399 , 332 kurtz , m. j. , mink , d. j. , wyatt , w. f. , fabricant , d. g. , torres , g. , kriss , g. a. , & tonry , j. l. 1992 , astronomical data analysis software and systems i , 25 , 432 lacy , m. , et al . 2005 , , 161 , 41 lawrence , a. , et al . 2007 , , 379 , 1599 lonsdale , c. j. , et al . 2003 , , 115 , 897 mccarthy , j. k. , et al . 1998 , , 3355 , 81 mccarthy , p. j. , et al . 2007 , , 664 , l17 mullis , c. r. , rosati , p. , lamer , g. , bhringer , h. , schwope , a. , schuecker , p. , & fassbender , r. 2005 , , 623 , l85 muzzin , a. , yee , h. k. c. , hall , p. b. , & lin , h. 2007 , , 663 , 150 muzzin , a. , wilson , g. , lacy , m. , yee , h. k. c. , & stanford , s. a. 2008 , , 686 , 966 muzzin , a. , et al . 2009 , , 698 , 1943 oke , j. b. 1990 , , 99 , 1621 oke , j. b. , et al . 1995 , , 107 , 375 rosati , p. , stanford , s. a. , eisenhardt , p. r. , elston , r. , spinrad , h. , stern , d. , & dey , a. 1999 , , 118 , 76 rosati , p. , et al . 2004 , , 127 , 230 rozo , e. , et al . 2009 , , 703 , 601 rozo , e. , et al . 2009 , arxiv:0902.3702 ruhl , j. , et al . 2004 , , 5498 , 11 shapley , a. e. , steidel , c. c. , pettini , m. , & adelberger , k. l. 2003 , , 588 , 65 shupe , d. l. , et al . 2008 , , 135 , 1050 stanford , s. a. , elston , r. , eisenhardt , p. r. , spinrad , h. , stern , d. , & dey , a. 1997 , , 114 , 2232 stanford , s. a. , holden , b. , rosati , p. , eisenhardt , p. r. , stern , d. , squires , g. , & spinrad , h. 2002 , , 123 , 619 stanford , s. a. , et al . 2005 , , 634 , l129 stanford , s. a. , et al . 2006 , , 646 , l13 , j. , shupe , d. l. , fang , f. , lonsdale , c. j. , & gonzalez - solares , e. 2005 , ssc website release tran , k .- v . h. , franx , m. , illingworth , g. d. , van dokkum , p. , kelson , d. d. , blakeslee , j. p. , & postman , m. 2007 , , 661 , 750 tonry , j. , & davis , m. 1979 , , 84 , 1511 van breukelen , c. , et al . 2007 , , 382 , 971 wilson , g. , et al . 2009 , , 698 , 1934 yee , h. k. c. , & ellingson , e. 2003 , , 585 , 215 yee , h. k. c. , & lpez - cruz , o. 1999 , , 117 , 1985 yee , h. k. c. , gladders , m. d. , gilbank , d. g. , majumdar , s. , hoekstra , h. , ellingson , e. , & the rcs-2 collaboration 2007 , arxiv : astro - ph/0701839 york , d. g. , et al . 2000 , , 120 , 1579 zatloukal , m. , rser , h .- j . , wolf , c. , hippelein , h. , & falter , s. 2007 , , 474 , l5 sparcs j161315 + 564930 & 16:13:14.6 & + 56:49:29.9 & 1 & 16 & 14 & @xmath148 & @xmath149 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 + sparcs j161641 + 554513 & 16:16:41.3 & + 55:45:12.5 & 1 & 10 & 7 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 + sparcs j161037 + 552417 & 16:10:36.5 & + 55:24:16.6 & 2 & 10 & 7 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 + [ tab_clusters ] 1070485 & 243.32851 & 56.821579 & @xmath160 & @xmath161 & @xmath162 & 0 & 0 + 1071085 & 243.31200 & 56.828140 & @xmath163 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 & 0 & 0 + 1071707 & 243.34280 & 56.835220 & @xmath166 & @xmath167 & @xmath168 & 0 & 0 + 1072162 & 243.36000 & 56.840450 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 & @xmath171 & 0 & 0 + 1068630 & 243.33870 & 56.802010 & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & 0 & 0 + 1072641 & 243.30150 & 56.845970 & @xmath175 & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & 0 & 0 + 2000012 & 243.31107 & 56.826047 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath179 & 0 & 0 + 1070775 & 243.31090 & 56.824970 & @xmath180 & @xmath181 & @xmath182 & 0 & 0 + 1066451 & 243.39220 & 56.778770 & @xmath183 & @xmath184 & @xmath185 & 0 & 1 + 2000007 & 243.34483 & 56.772531 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath186 & 0 & 0 + 1066059 & 243.35040 & 56.775040 & @xmath187 & @xmath188 & @xmath189 & 0 & 0 + 1069805 & 243.34230 & 56.814430 & @xmath190 & @xmath191 & @xmath192 & 0 & 0 + 1074041 & 243.28720 & 56.862221 & @xmath193 & @xmath194 & @xmath195 & 0 & 1 + 1072364 & 243.29550 & 56.842720 & @xmath196 & @xmath197 & @xmath198 & 0 & 0 + 1069395 & 243.32159 & 56.810188 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & @xmath201 & 0 & 0 + 1073458 & 243.30260 & 56.855709 & @xmath202 & @xmath173 & @xmath203 & 0 & 0 + 1068289 & 243.33870 & 56.797932 & @xmath204 & @xmath205 & @xmath206 & 1 & 0 + 1071481 & 243.32381 & 56.832401 & @xmath207 & @xmath167 & @xmath208 & 0 & 0 + 1070036 & 243.27380 & 56.817139 & @xmath209 & @xmath210 & @xmath211 & 0 & 0 + 1067689 & 243.27271 & 56.791660 & @xmath212 & @xmath213 & @xmath214 & 1 & 0 + 1065709 & 243.34480 & 56.771900 & @xmath215 & @xmath216 & @xmath217 & 1 & 0 + 2000006 & 243.34517 & 56.771469 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath218 & 1 & 0 + [ tab_en1_240 ] 848097 & 244.17630 & 55.748390 & @xmath219 & @xmath220 & @xmath221 & 0 & 1 + 853440 & 244.18610 & 55.764381 & @xmath166 & @xmath222 & @xmath223 & 0 & 0 + 849838 & 244.17340 & 55.753590 & @xmath224 & @xmath225 & @xmath226 & 0 & 0 + 849110 & 244.19260 & 55.751389 & @xmath227 & @xmath228 & @xmath229 & 0 & 1 + 851083 & 244.17180 & 55.757141 & @xmath230 & @xmath231 & @xmath232 & 0 & 0 + 837239 & 244.26920 & 55.715519 & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & @xmath235 & 1 & 0 + 846319 & 244.25529 & 55.743149 & @xmath236 & @xmath237 & @xmath238 & 0 & 1 + 3000009 & 244.26935 & 55.715914 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath239 & 0 & 0 + 839226 & 244.27161 & 55.721340 & @xmath240 & @xmath241 & @xmath242 & 0 & 0 + 854892 & 244.21670 & 55.768921 & @xmath243 & @xmath244 & @xmath245 & 2 & 0 + 833647 & 244.16330 & 55.704411 & @xmath246 & @xmath247 & @xmath248 & 1 & 0 + 828383 & 244.22971 & 55.688580 & @xmath249 & @xmath250 & @xmath251 & 1 & 0 + 840274 & 244.26221 & 55.724548 & @xmath252 & @xmath253 & @xmath254 & 1 & 0 + 856147 & 244.18530 & 55.772751 & @xmath255 & @xmath256 & @xmath257 & 1 & 0 + 844301 & 244.21809 & 55.736950 & @xmath258 & @xmath259 & @xmath260 & 1 & 0 + 842789 & 244.15030 & 55.732430 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 & @xmath263 & 0 & 1 + 857305 & 244.18820 & 55.776299 & @xmath264 & @xmath265 & @xmath266 & 0 & 0 + 851794 & 244.17329 & 55.759270 & @xmath267 & @xmath234 & @xmath268 & 0 & 1 + 860365 & 244.18150 & 55.786140 & @xmath209 & @xmath269 & @xmath270 & 0 & 1 + [ tab_en1_349 ] 4000013 & 242.65226 & 55.405353 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath271 & 1 & 0 + 723814 & 242.65221 & 55.404598 & @xmath272 & @xmath273 & @xmath274 & 1 & 0 + 722784 & 242.63251 & 55.401890 & @xmath275 & @xmath276 & @xmath277 & 0 & 1 + 718577 & 242.61940 & 55.391060 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 & @xmath280 & 1 & 0 + 722712 & 242.66769 & 55.401711 & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath283 & 1 & 1 + 4000026 & 242.60676 & 55.475206 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath284 & 1 & 1 + 710318 & 242.60490 & 55.370651 & @xmath285 & @xmath286 & @xmath287 & 1 & 0 + 4000010 & 242.67026 & 55.393053 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath288 & 1 & 0 + 728525 & 242.69780 & 55.416550 & @xmath289 & @xmath290 & @xmath291 & 1 & 0 + 4000032 & 242.60455 & 55.371836 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath292 & 1 & 0 + 744358 & 242.57840 & 55.457119 & @xmath293 & @xmath294 & @xmath295 & 1 & 0 + 4000012 & 242.65180 & 55.404111 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath296 & 1 & 0 + 723736 & 242.64661 & 55.404339 & @xmath297 & @xmath298 & @xmath299 & 0 & 1 + 709346 & 242.61549 & 55.368011 & @xmath300 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 & 0 & 1 + 714998 & 242.59080 & 55.381821 & @xmath303 & @xmath304 & @xmath305 & 1 & 1 + 710721 & 242.60280 & 55.371490 & @xmath306 & @xmath307 & @xmath308 & 0 & 0 + 751852 & 242.60730 & 55.476471 & @xmath309 & @xmath310 & @xmath311 & 0 & 1 + 734249 & 242.66650 & 55.430779 & @xmath312 & @xmath313 & @xmath314 & 0 & 1 + 747661 & 242.62151 & 55.465469 & @xmath315 & @xmath316 & @xmath317 & 1 & 1 + 740510 & 242.69310 & 55.447041 & @xmath255 & @xmath318 & @xmath319 & 0 & 1 + 708779 & 242.61410 & 55.366550 & @xmath320 & @xmath321 & @xmath322 & 1 & 1 + 725337 & 242.69600 & 55.408329 & @xmath323 & @xmath324 & @xmath325 & 0 & 1 + 4000015 & 242.60952 & 55.453100 & @xmath178 & @xmath178 & @xmath326 & 0 & 1 + 730800 & 242.66510 & 55.422260 & @xmath327 & @xmath328 & @xmath329 & 0 & 0 + 720317 & 242.64140 & 55.395630 & @xmath330 & @xmath331 & @xmath332 & 0 & 1 + 745152 & 242.66029 & 55.459110 & @xmath333 & @xmath334 & @xmath335 & 0 & 1 + 753137 & 242.63040 & 55.479912 & @xmath336 & @xmath337 & @xmath338 & 0 & 1 + 738292 & 242.63560 & 55.441189 & @xmath339 & @xmath340 & @xmath341 & 0 & 0 + 727869 & 242.68291 & 55.414661 & @xmath333 & @xmath342 & @xmath343 & 1 & 0 + 734082 & 242.71609 & 55.430450 & @xmath344 & @xmath345 & @xmath343 & 1 & 0 + 712763 & 242.63080 & 55.376591 & @xmath346 & @xmath347 & @xmath348 & 1 & 1 + 742510 & 242.67841 & 55.452202 & @xmath349 & @xmath350 & @xmath351 & 1 & 1 + 737166 & 242.70931 & 55.438370 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 & @xmath354 & 1 & 1 + 735789 & 242.69299 & 55.434792 & @xmath355 & @xmath356 & @xmath357 & 1 & 1 + [ tab_en1_381 ] sparcs j161315 + 564930 & @xmath358 & @xmath359 & @xmath360 & @xmath361 & @xmath148 & @xmath151 & @xmath362 + sparcs j161641 + 554513 & @xmath363 & @xmath364 & @xmath365 & @xmath366 & @xmath152 & @xmath155 & @xmath367 + sparcs j161037 + 552417 & @xmath368 & @xmath369 & @xmath370 & @xmath371 & @xmath156 & @xmath159 & @xmath372 + sparcs j163435 + 402151 & @xmath373 & @xmath374 & @xmath375 & @xmath376 & @xmath377 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 + sparcs j163852 + 403843 & @xmath380 & @xmath381 & @xmath382 & @xmath383 & @xmath384 & @xmath385 & @xmath386 + sparcs j003550 - 431224 & @xmath387 & @xmath388 & @xmath389 & @xmath390 & @xmath391 & @xmath392 & @xmath379 + [ tab_properties ]
Abstract: | [
"the spitzer adaptation of the red - sequence cluster survey ( sparcs ) is a @xmath0-passband imaging survey of the 50 deg@xmath1 spitzer swire legacy fields , designed with the primary aim of creating the first large , homogeneously selected sample of massive clusters at @xmath2 . sparcs uses an infrared adaptation of the two - filter cluster red - sequence technique . in this paper we report keck / lris spectroscopic confirmation of two new exceptionally rich galaxy clusters , sparcs j161315 + 564930 at @xmath3 , with 14 high - confidence members and a rest - frame velocity dispersion of @xmath4 km s@xmath5 , and sparcs j161641 + 554513 at @xmath6 , with seven high - confidence members ( including one agn ) and a rest - frame velocity dispersion of @xmath7 km s@xmath5 . we also report confirmation of a third new system , sparcs j161037 + 552417 at @xmath8 , with seven high - confidence members and a rest - frame velocity dispersion of @xmath9 km s@xmath5 . these three new spectroscopically confirmed clusters further demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of two - filter imaging for detecting _ bona fide _ galaxy clusters at high redshift . we conclude by demonstrating that prospects are good for the current generation of surveys aiming to estimate cluster redshifts and masses at @xmath10 _ directly _ from optical - infrared imaging ."
] | 8,944 | 8,944 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: stellar mass loss is of critical importance to the later stages of stellar evolution . stars evolving up the red giant branch ( rgb ) lose mass via stellar winds . the remaining mass of a star leaving the rgb tip is the primary determinant of its position on the horizontal branch ( hb ; e.g. @xcite ) . subsequent mass loss on the asymptotic giant branch ( agb ) ejects the star s entire hydrogen envelope , creating a post - agb star and ( perhaps ) a planetary nebula ( pn ) . the timescale and end - point of agb evolution may therefore not be determined by the nuclear burning rate , but by mass loss @xcite . winds from these stars are the most significant producers of interstellar dust and therefore provided the heavy elements present in population i stars , including the sun and solar system @xcite . debate exists around many finer points of the mass loss process , particularly its variation with fundamental parameters such as luminosity , temperature and metallicity . firstly , the amount of mass loss that occurs on the rgb remains largely unmeasured . rgb mass loss appears to determine the ` second parameter ' ( after metallicity ) that defines the morphology of hbs in globular clusters ( gcs ) @xcite . secondly , it is not proven where dust formation stars , and whether rgb stars can form significant amounts of dust in their ejecta . if many rgb stars do produce dust , it would add a large number of dust factories ejecting dust into a galaxy s interstellar medium ( ism ) ( cf . the missing dust source in many galaxies ; e.g. @xcite ) . @xcite suggest that dust production occurs episodically over a large portion of the rgb , while @xcite have presented evidence that dust production is confined to the rgb tip , though gaseous mass loss is still present all along both the rgb and agb @xcite . dust can also help drive a wind through radiation pressure on grains ( e.g. @xcite ) , though it is not certain whether winds which lack high - opacity amorphous carbon can be accelerated in this manner @xcite . dustless stars typically lose mass via magneto - acoustic processes in their chromospheres @xcite . finally , the composition of circumstellar dust and the chemical processes by which it forms are only partly defined . of particular interest is the rle that metallic iron grains play in dust formation , and how metallicity affects dust production and composition @xcite . in this study , we aim to address these points . to do this , we explore dust production in the galactic globular cluster 47 tucanae ( ngc 104 ) . globular clusters are unique laboratories with which we can study late - stage evolution of low - mass stars : globular clusters contain stars that are among the oldest in the universe , and most clusters are comprised of a single ( or at least dominating ) stellar population with little internal variance in age or chemical composition . comparisons between clusters therefore probe differences in mass loss created by metallicity , while comparisons within clusters probe differences created by stellar temperature and luminosity . throughout this paper , we will refer to similar studies : @xcite , which covers the cluster @xmath0 centauri ( ngc 5139 ; hereafter paper i ) ; @xcite , which covers the cluster ngc 362 ( hereafter paper ii ) ; and a work which accompanies this paper ( submitted apjs ; hereafter paper iii ) . the cluster 47 tuc itself is among the galaxy s most massive and , co - incidentally , one of the closest to us . its distance has been estimated photometrically as 41904700 pc @xcite and kinematically as 4000 pc @xcite , with 4500 pc being the median distance determination in the literature . its mass is 69 @xmath1 m@xmath2 @xcite . its metallicity is determined to be roughly [ fe / h ] = 0.7 , though various studies have placed it anywhere from [ fe / h ] = 0.89 to 0.66 @xcite . the cluster suffers from little interstellar reddening ( @xmath3 mag @xcite ) and is estimated to be over 11 gyr in age @xcite . the cluster hosts an ionised intra - cluster medium ( icm ; @xcite ) . this ionised medium is undetected in any other cluster ( m15 has a neutral medium with a dusty component ; @xcite ) . integrating the observed intracluster electron density over the cluster core yields @xmath40.1 m@xmath2 of h ii , representing @xmath55% of the intracluster hydrogen @xcite . the total stellar mass loss from 47 tuc s stars therefore gives us insight into the fate of gas and dust expelled by stars in this cluster . paper iii more - precisely examines which stars have mid - infrared excess , indicative of dust , finding again that we can not corroborate the presence of dust around the fainter giants . in this work , we use the data and results from paper iii to derive mass - loss rates for individual stars and ( by summation ) the cluster as a whole , and investigate the composition of the circumstellar dust produced by analysing archival mid - infrared ( mid - ir ) spectra . the data for this study come from the accompanying paper iii , which identifies those stars in 47 tuc which have infrared excess , indicative of circumstellar dust . this list of 22 objects is an exhaustive list of those stars in the cluster which we can be relatively certain are producing dust , given currently available data . these objects are listed in table [ mdottable ] , which also includes the parameters we determine in later sections . @l@c@c@c@ c@ c@ c@ c@ c@ c@ c@c@ c@ c@ c@ c@ cl@ star & @xmath6 & @xmath7 & @xmath8 & @xmath9 & @xmath10 & & @xmath11 & @xmath12 & @xmath13 & @xmath14 & & notes + & ( mag ) & ( km / s ) & ( days ) & ( k ) & ( l@xmath15 & @xmath16 & [ 3.6 ] & [ 8 ] & ( % ) & 10@xmath17m@xmath2yr@xmath18 ) & ( kms@xmath18 & ( k ) & sil . & fe & al@xmath19o@xmath20 & feo & + v1 & 4.03 & 20 & 221 & 3623 & 4824 & 0.936 & 1.173 & 2.213 & 3.6 & 21.0 & 4.0 & 900 & 12 & 88 & 0 & 0 & + v8 & 1.6 & 16 & 155 & 3578 & 3583 & 0.904 & 1.210 & 2.135 & 5.9 & 14.7 & 4.0 & 900 & 7 & 85 & 7 & 1 & + v2 & 2.78 & 23 & 203 & 3738 & 3031 & 1.103 & & & 4.3 & 12.0 & 3.8 & 900 & 5 & 95 & 0 & 0 & @xmath21 + v3 & 4.15 & 22 & 192 & 3153 & 2975 & 0.954 & 1.198 & & 3.2 & 9.4 & 3.2 & 1000 & 0 & 100 & 0 & 0 & @xmath22 + v4 & 1.5 & 18 & 165 & 3521 & 2603 & 0.932 & 1.167 & 1.902 & 5.6 & 11.7 & 3.6 & 900 & 2 & 95 & 2 & 1 & @xmath4rgb - tip + v26 & 0.3 & & & 3500 & 2541 & 1.073 & 0.807 & 0.995 & 0.9 & 5.9 & 3.8 & 1000 & & 100 & & & @xmath23 + lw10 & 1.2 & & 221 : & 3543 & 2324 & 1.073 & 0.876 & 1.017 & 0.6 & 4.2 & 3.2 & 1000 & 0 & 100 & 0 & 0 & + v21 & 1.0 & 7 & 76 : & 3575 & 2301 & 0.977 & 1.083 & 1.355 & 1.1 & 4.9 & 3.6 & 1000 & 0 & 93 & 5 & 2 & + lw9 & 1.1 & & 74 & 3374 & 2204 & 0.973 & 1.003 & 1.228 & 1.1 & 6.0 & 3.3 & 950 & & 100 & & & + v27 & 0.3 & & 69 & 3374 & 2140 & 1.023 & 0.929 & 1.218 & 1.4 & 3.3 & 3.6 & 1050 & & 100 & & & + lee1424 & & & 65 & 3565 & 2122 & 1.006 & 1.182 & 1.390 & @xmath244 & 4.4 & 4.0 & 1050 & & 100 & & & + a19 & 0.7 & & 60 & 3526 & 2096 & 1.034 & 0.992 & 1.240 & 0.8 & 3.6 & 4.2 & 1100 & & 100 & & & + lw12&0.6&&116 & 3713 & 2079 & 1.082 & 0.967 & 1.093 & @xmath251 & low + x03 & & & & 3816 & 1640 & & 0.958 & 1.156 & 3.2 & 5.1 & 1.8 & 750 & & 100 & & & @xmath26 + lw19 & 0.1 & & 40 & 3738 & 1638 & 1.078 & 0.991 & 1.080 & @xmath251 & low + v20 & 0.8 & & 232 : & 3602 & 1575 & 1.053 & 0.928 & 1.039 & @xmath251 & low&&&&&&&@xmath27 + v22 & 0.5 & & 62 & 3684 & 1528 & & 2.504 & 2.834 & @xmath251 & low & & & & & & & @xmath23 + v6 & 0.6 & 7 & 48 & 3763 & 1374 & 1.001 & 1.000 & 1.167 & @xmath251 & low & & & & & & & + v5 & 0.7 & 8 & 50 & 3741 & 1363 & 1.003 & 1.100 & & @xmath251 & low&&&&&&&@xmath23 + v18 & 0.3 & 5 & 83 : & 3692 & 1297 & 0.989 & 1.004 & & 2.4 & 5.3 & 2.4 & 800 & 33 & 67 & 0 & 0 & @xmath26 + v23 & 0.5 & & 52 & 3775 & 1259 & 1.023 & 0.985 & & @xmath251 & low&&&&&&&@xmath23 + v13 & & 12 & 40 & 3657 & 1029 & 0.990 & 1.106 & & 1.2 & 4.1 & 2.2 & 800 & 0 & 85 & 15 & 5 & @xmath26 + + accurate or even approximate mass - loss rates are notoriously difficult to measure . one must assume that the wind has certain properties . perhaps the most crucial of these is the relationship between wind velocity and distance from the star . we here assume a constant , spherically - symmetric , purely radiatively - driven wind , starting from a near - stationary , dust - forming layer . as discussed previously ( paper i ; @xcite ) , this may not be the most appropriate description , but suffices due to lack of contrary evidence : we return to this point in the discussion . before calculating an estimated mass - loss rate , we can create a measure of the amount of circumstellar dust surrounding a star , irrespective of most modelling uncertainties . to do this , we define a quantity @xmath11 , the fraction of the star s luminosity that is reprocessed by circumstellar dust . for low optical depths , this should be directly proportional to the surface area of dust grains , therefore approximately proportional to the mass of circumstellar dust . the value of @xmath11 can be determined by taking the difference between the observed sed and model photospheric sed in the infrared ( yielding the infrared excess ) and dividing this by the total photospheric luminosity ( the value given in paper iii ) . we list this quantity in table [ mdottable ] . errors in the value of @xmath11 are introduced by difficulties in determining the integrated luminosity from photometry alone and from the uncertainty in the photospheric spectrum ( both temperature and luminosity ) . the former can be approximated as @xmath28 , or roughly 50% of @xmath11 , but is dominated by photometric uncertainty at short ( 2.210-@xmath29 m ) wavelengths . the latter gives a constant uncertainty of around @xmath30% . we reduce this latter error by fixing the photospheric luminosity to the @xmath31-band flux for all stars except v26 and x03 , which are fixed to the 3.6-@xmath29 m flux . the value @xmath11 could not reliably be measured for several stars with low mass - loss rates . the stars appear to fall into three main categories : those with large ( @xmath45% ) reprocessed flux ( v14 , v8 ) , those with low ( @xmath42% ) reprocessed flux concentrated toward long wavelengths ( v13 and v18 ) , and those stars with low ( @xmath322% ) reprocessed flux concentrated toward shorter wavelengths ( the remainder ) . given the limitations of our understanding and of the model presented above , we stress that the mass - loss rates and velocities we derive are based only on one model for wind acceleration , but should be comparative both internally and with other works which use these same assumptions . under these assumptions , we calculate mass - loss rates by modelling the sed using the radiative transfer package , dusty @xcite . as inputs , we use our interpolated marcs model of the stellar spectrum , and a standard mrn grain size distribution @xcite . within our dusty model , we vary the dust composition , temperature in the dust - forming region ( the inner edge of the dust envelope ) and optical depth of the wind . we change these parameters iteratively until a best fit is achieved . we relate the dusty mass - loss rate ( @xmath33 ) to the actual mass - loss rate ( @xmath34 ) as previously ( paper i ; paper ii ) , using the following formula @xcite : @xmath35 , \label{mdoteq2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for luminosity @xmath10 , dust - to - gas ratio @xmath36 , grain density @xmath37 , and terminal wind velocity @xmath38 . we assume that @xmath39 g @xmath40 for silicates , 4 g @xmath40 for aluminium oxides , 5.7 g @xmath40 for feo , and 7 g @xmath40 for metallic iron . for these three species , we use the optical constants from @xcite ; @xcite ; and @xcite , respectively . the errors in the above assumptions are substantial , and are discussed in section [ mdoterrorsect ] . the dust - to - gas ratio , @xmath36 , can be estimated as : @xmath41 } , \label{psieqn}\ ] ] which is approximately 1/1000 for 47 tuc . this assumes that the fraction of condensed metals is identical for all metallicities . we discuss the accuracy of this assumption in section [ mdoterrorsect ] . table [ mdottable ] shows our calculated mass - loss rates and inferred wind parameters and dust compositions alongside literature pulsation properties . the striking fact about the dust composition is the fraction of iron grains present . the presence of metallic iron in these stars is debatable , as its featureless infrared emission can be mimicked by many other phenomena , including large silicate grains and emission from thick circumstellar molecular layers @xcite . we consider iron to be the most likely source of emission , though the fractions of metallic iron listed in table [ mdottable ] may not be particularly accurate , and we discuss this further in [ dustcompsect ] . many of the mass - loss rates are too low to be sensibly measured : we can merely say that some circumstellar dust probably exists . those rates that can be measured have their seds shown in figure [ sedsfig ] . the photometry is taken from the sources cited in paper iii . mid - ir spectra are included from @xcite ( hereafter vlmo ) , and @xcite ( hereafter lph ) . these objects are summarised in the following luminosity - ordered list : = 1em v1 : this star is clearly identified as the cluster s dominant dust producer by vlmo , lph and @xcite ( hereafter itm ) . v1 has clear excess at all wavelengths @xmath42 m . this excess , which we attribute to metallic iron dust , dominates even over its strong silicate feature . v8 : no silicate feature was seen in this star by vlmo , but a clear silicate and aluminium oxide feature was seen by lph . it has previously been suggested ( lph ; paper i ) that v8 may have variable mass loss . however , the _ akari _ photometry at 3 , 4 , 7 , 11 , 18 and 23 @xmath29 m shows no variation in the ( dominant ) iron contribution . this means that if the mass loss is variable , strong variation only occurs in the silicate production . v8 has a complex ir spectrum showing peaks from silicates , aluminium oxide , and from crystalline minerals at 9.7 , 11.3 , 13.1 , 20 and 32 @xmath29 m . we discuss the carrier(s ) of these bands in [ dustcompsect ] . note that the amplitude of the 10-@xmath29 m silicate peak is substantially over - estimated in our model compared to the 20-@xmath29 m silicate peak . this implies a lower temperature for the silicate grains than the metallic iron grains , which we also discuss in [ dustcondsect ] . v2 : a silicate dust feature was observed by lph , though it was too weak to have been seen by vlmo . iron dominates the ir flux , however . the 10- and 20-@xmath29 m silicate peaks are not well modelled , as in v8 ( see also [ dustcondsect ] ) . v3 : no silicate emission was seen by either lph or vlmo , but strong , featureless ( metallic iron ) emission is present , which is confirmed by _ akari _ photometry . v4 : the spectrum in lph shows complex dust mineralogy , akin to that in v8 . this star is roughly at the rgb - tip , as estimated from the luminosity function . v26 : blended with a star half its brightness , 2.2@xmath43 to the east , the near - ir , _ akari _ and 24-@xmath29 m photometry are affected . the amount of ir excess is difficult to determine here , but is likely to be quite small . no discernible features are present in the spectrum from vlmo . lw10 : also within the dense cluster core , it appears that the _ akari _ photometry ( at 9 & 11 @xmath29 m ) for this object is affected . no features are detectable in the spectrum from vlmo . v21 : observed by lph , the spectrum shows the same features as v8 . these features , and the silicate contribution , are considerably weaker in v21 . v11 : no obvious features were seen in the spectrum of vlmo , this star was only covered by _ spitzer _ at 3.6 and 5.8 @xmath29 m . 9-@xmath29 m photometry suggests it may have some excess there , but both the _ spitzer _ 8-@xmath29 m photometry and the vlmo spectrum ( which covers 9-@xmath29 m ) show no excess . the derived mass - loss rate can probably be treated as a rough upper limit . lw9 & v27 : an excess consistent with circumstellar dust is present in both the _ spitzer _ and _ akari _ photometry . the chemistry can not be well - constrained by this photometry , but it appears that the flux contribution from components other than iron is comparatively small . lee1424 : lacks any data redwards of 9 @xmath29 m , making constraining the mass - loss rate , dust temperature and dust chemistry very difficult . the values given should be treated as order - of - magnitude estimates only . a19 : as lw9 & v27 , however the _ akari _ 7-@xmath29 m data suggests little to no mid - ir excess in this star . v20 & v22 : not shown in figure [ sedsfig ] , they have no near - ir photometry attributed to them , meaning it is difficult to determine the amount of ir excess present . despite this , the dust temperature is relatively - well constrained by the presence of _ spitzer _ 24-@xmath29 m photometry . x03 : located in the cluster core , this star suffers from the same problems as v20 & v22 , but clearly displays a stronger excess , making an approximate determination of the mass - loss rate and wind characteristics possible . v18 : observed by both lph and vlmo , this star has a clear silicate feature . this feature was not claimed in vlmo due to poor signal - to - noise , but the detection appears to match that from lph well . it shows substantial mass loss compared to other stars of similar luminosity . the 10- and 20-@xmath29 m silicate peaks are not well modelled , as in v8 ( see also [ dustcondsect ] ) . v13 : highlighted in both lph and itm , the spectrum of this star shows an excess similar to that of v8 . the contribution of iron dust is comparatively small , though would appear to be non - zero . this star is isolated from the cluster core , but has poor - quality photometry due to its comparative faintness . the accuracy of the wind parameters we find is hard to determine . the major sources of error are listed below : 1 . a 30% uncertainty inherent in dusty due to an unspecified gravitational correction . this uncertainty is exceeded in stars with @xmath44 km s@xmath18 , where the effect of stellar gravity will change the variation of dust particle density with radius from the star ( the stellar mass is unspecified in dusty ) . 2 . uncertainty in the underlying photospheric spectrum . as the iron dust contribution is essentially a modified blackbody , one can fit a dust temperature to the 3.6- to 8-@xmath29 m data and extrapolate this fit backwards to @xmath16-band , where the dust contribution is essentially zero . the photospheric contribution can then be set from the @xmath45 photometry , but the accuracy of this fit depends on the stellar photometry . ( this would equally hold for other possible dust species , e.g. amorphous carbon . ) uncertainty in the amount of ir excess . apart from identifying how much flux is generated by the photosphere , missing photometry and photometric errors cause uncertainty in the combined flux of the ( photosphere + dust ) contributions . 4 . uncertainty in the dust composition . it is not clear for a number of these stars ( v26 , lw9 , v27 , lee1424 , a19 , x03 and any star marked `` low '' ) what the dust chemistry is . many of these stars have insufficient coverage in the 923 @xmath29 m region to determine whether they contain any dust components other than metallic iron . lw10 and v11 are not covered by lph : ground - based spectra by vlmo show no obvious spectral features , so we presume a pure metallic iron wind , but the spectra are of low signal - to - noise . the presence of silicates can significantly increase the implied mass - loss rate due to their low opacity . any carbonaceous dust present would also be hidden by the modified blackbody of metallic iron . carbonaceous dust typically has a higher opacity : if it is present , the implied mass - loss rate would be decreased . uncertainty in grain size distribution and grain shape ( assumed here to be spherical , with radius @xmath46 ) . the relationship between the grains absorption cross - section to radiation ( @xmath47 ) and their mass ( @xmath48 ) . a high grain porosity would also imply a decreased dust density and therefore a higher mass - loss rate . particularly , differences in grain properties between the iron and silicate grains could explain why we model such a high proportion of iron grains in the wind ( see [ dustcompsect ] ) . uncertainty in dust temperature . the dust temperature can only be determined to within @xmath4100 k. as @xmath49 , a 15% error in temperature leads to an error of up to @xmath460% in the flux emitted by the circumstellar dust , depending on the implied error in the radius of the dust shell . this will be most significant in stars that are losing the least mass , as their dust temperatures are more difficult to determine . uncertainty in the wind driving mechanism . we presume here that the winds are sustained by radiation pressure alone . the very low outflow velocities present in at least three cases ( x03 , v18 and v13 ) would suggest that there is insufficient radiation pressure for it to be the sole driver of mass loss . additional energy input , for example from pulsation , would increase the wind velocity and ( by virtue of eq . ( [ mdoteq2 ] ) ) decrease the mass - loss rate . there is a related uncertainty in the dust - to - gas ratio , which is assumed to scale with metallicity . these uncertainties can not be quantified statistically . lllll parameter & @xmath50 & @xmath51 & parameter variation used & other parameters affected + grain size@xmath52 & @xmath5310% & @xmath5330% & low : @xmath54 , @xmath55 nm , @xmath56 nm & @xmath57 k , 90% iron , 10% silicates + & & & assumed : @xmath54 , @xmath58 nm , @xmath59 nm & @xmath60 k , 88% iron , 12% silicates + & & & high : @xmath61 , @xmath58 nm , @xmath59 nm & @xmath60 k , 80% iron , 20% silicates + grain density & 50% & 50% & low : 1.63 g @xmath40 & + & & & assumed ( solid ) : 6.52 g @xmath40 & + dust formation & @xmath5310% & @xmath5320% & low : 750 k & @xmath62 , 92% iron , 8% silicates + temperature & & & assumed : 850 k & @xmath63 , 88% iron , 12% silicates + & & & high : 950 k & @xmath64 , 82% iron , 18% silicates + dust : gas ratio & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & low : 1 / 5000 & + & & & assumed : 1 / 1000 & + & & & high : 1 / 200 & + velocity distribution & @xmath4 + 500% & n / a & assumed : 0 @xmath67 v@xmath68 km s@xmath18 & @xmath60 k + & & & high : 10 km s@xmath18 ( constant ) & @xmath69 k + photosphere & @xmath5312% & @xmath532% & assumed @xmath53 5% in luminosity & @xmath70 decreased from 0.45 to 0.42 + & @xmath5315% & @xmath536% & assumed @xmath53 250 k in temperature & + calculation error@xmath71 & @xmath5330% & & & + total & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & & + + the easiest way to see how these uncertainties affect a star s determined mass - loss rate is to propagate them through the dusty code . the results for v1 ( table [ mdoterrortable ] suggest that , in absolute terms , our mass - loss rates are little more than an educated guess . however , since a large number of other studies use the same assumptions , one can use these rates to trace differences between stars , providing these properties are largely invariant between stars . the parameters listed in table [ mdoterrortable ] have different effects . the grain size , for example , has little effect on the mass - loss rate but significant effects on other wind properties . conversely , the dust - to - gas ratio have significant effects on the mass - loss rate and velocity but little effect on the other wind parameters ( temperature , optical depth and minerology ) . clearly the largest effect on the mass - loss rate is whether the wind has an initial velocity driven by , for example , pulsation . determining the radial velocity profile of the wind would reduce the error substantially . while this has not been done accurately for such low - metallicity , dust - producing giants , inferences from chromospheric line modelling ( e.g. @xcite ; @xcite ; @xcite ) appears to show that wind velocities do not decrease substantially from @xmath410 km s@xmath18 in the stages shortly prior to dust formation . we point out , however , that the highest mass - loss rates ( and by inference the highest wind velocities ) may be ruled out on evolutionary grounds ( [ dustcompsect ] ) . we emphasise that the errors derived above are not formal and are only estimates . these compare relatively well to the adopted error of @xmath45@xmath74 for silicate - dominated winds ( e.g. @xcite ) , where the grain properties are somewhat better determined due to the long history of their study and constraints from their spectral features . in relative terms , however , we can probably assume that the star - to - star variations are much smaller . in particular , the driving mechanism and hence the wind s initial velocity should not differ as markedly as the uncertainties we assume . likewise , the dust - to - gas ratio will only depend on the condensation fraction in the wind , which should not vary as much as a factor of 5@xmath74 between stars at the same metallicity . this reduces the overall error among stars in the same cluster to a factor of @xmath42@xmath74 and allows us to make direct comparisons between stars . the wind parameters listed in table [ mdottable ] pose several problems for stellar wind theory , which we discuss in this section . firstly , the projected terminal velocities we derive are very low , implying radiation pressure from the star is not effective in driving the wind : we must consider whether other processes may contribute to , or dominate , the wind acceleration . secondly , when one considers the evolutionary timescales of the stars in question , our derived mass - loss rates imply that the stars are losing much more material than is predicted from stellar theory . finally , we can use these problems to constrain some of the wind parameters listed in table [ mdoterrortable ] . mass - loss rate , pulsation amplitude and pulsation period are all known to correlate with stellar evolution . this is demonstrated in figures [ hrdvarsfig ] , [ plfig ] and [ mdotrelfig ] . these can be used to help solve the above problems . a major problem when calculating mass - loss rates from metal - poor stars is that the terminal velocities predicted from radiative transfer codes are very low . this is a particular worry with dusty , as no correction is input for stellar gravity . in this situation , it is impossible not to have mass lost from a star when dust is present , whereas the real situation may be that radiation pressure on dust is insufficient for it to overcome the stellar gravity field . assuming the dust layers around these stars do have some outward velocity , a different method of wind acceleration may be required . dusty provides a minimum mass for a radiative transfer model . if a star is less massive than this , the error due to the unspecified correction for stellar gravity will be greater than the 30% inherent in the model . as this error increases to 100% , it is unclear whether radiation pressure is capable of driving the wind . this is a particular concern for the less - luminous stars with high mass - loss rates : x03 , v18 and v13 . while expansion velocities of 34 km s@xmath18 are not unreasonable when compared to halo carbon stars @xcite , the lower velocities we derive for those stars losing less mass become increasingly unreliable due to this error . @xcite predict that stars with metallicities below [ fe / h ] = 1 can not drive winds via radiation pressure , and must rely on acoustic ( pulsation ) driving to eject mass from the star ( see also @xcite ) . at [ fe / h ] = 0.7 , 47 tuc is near this hypothetical limit , meaning we must consider acceleration by pulsation and other sources of energy . the velocity amplitude of the photosphere in these variables ranges from 423 km s@xmath18 , with v1 , v2 and v3 showing line doubling in near - ir and/or line emission in the optical due to the propagation of shocks in the atmosphere ( table [ mdottable ] ; @xcite ; @xcite ) . while this velocity greatly exceeds our calculated wind velocity of @xmath44 km s@xmath18 , the bulk material does not necessarily attain this velocity . nevertheless , the presence of shocks in the extended atmosphere implies that energy is being transferred to larger radii , and implies that this energy is available for driving mass loss . a comparison between the presence of circumstellar dust and pulsation reveals some interesting results . all the stars listed in table [ mdottable ] are variable : lee1424 = acvs002331 - 7222.6 , while x03 shows a variation of @xmath75 mag ( n. matsunaga , private communication ) . conversely , 22 of 43 variable stars show at least probable evidence of ir excess . dust - producing stars therefore appear to be ( in 47 tuc ) exclusively variable , and variable stars tend to be dust producing . in both figures [ hrdvarsfig ] & [ plfig ] there appears no easy way of discerning rgb - pulsators from agb - pulsators : the outliers in figure [ hrdvarsfig ] are such due to crowding in the cluster core ( paper iii ) , while the pulsation periods in figure [ plfig ] do not show the bimodality that one might expect from having rgb and agb stars at different masses . however , a bimodality may exist in mass - loss rate with a transition occurring around 25003000 l@xmath2 ( figure [ mdotrelfig ] ; cf . a similar possible bimodality in the gas - production rate in @xcite ) . the five stars with elevated mass - loss rates are also those with the highest pulsation velocity amplitudes and among those with the longest pulsation periods . as the presence of pulsation and its amplitude both appear to correlate with mass - loss rate , an obvious conclusion would be that pulsation energy is dissipated in the extended atmosphere and helps drive the wind , though we caution that the strongest variables are also the most - luminous stars with the highest capacity for driving a wind through radiation pressure . further evidence that pulsation sets the mass - loss rate can be drawn from the apparent invariance of mass - loss over the narrow range of temperatures we probe ( figure [ mdotrelfig ] ) . the photospheric temperature sets the radius at which dust can condense and therefore ( if other parameters are invariant ) the density of the wind . higher - density winds lead to more - efficient dust formation , as the timescale for collision between dust - forming molecules is shorter . an invariance of mass - loss rate with temperature thus means that the formation of dust has little impact on the mass - loss rates present , providing further evidence that the mass - loss rate is ` hard - coded ' into the wind before the dust - formation radius . if this is true , the rle of radiation pressure on dust may simply be to affect the outflow velocity of the wind . if the wind is acoustically driven by pulsations , then the wind velocity and thus mass - loss rate is liable to be several times greater than the values listed in table [ mdottable ] , since these sources of energy are not included in our model . this poses potential problems , as mass - loss rates this high would lead to the dissipation of the star s atmosphere on much shorter timescales than is inferred from star counts . this problem may be solved if one invokes different parameters for dust in the wind , which could lead to mass - loss rates much smaller than the listed values ( see [ dustcompsect ] ) . in paper iii , we discussed the integrated rgb mass loss for a typical cluster star . we noted it was likely @xmath320.22 m@xmath2 and possibly , to first order , invariant with metallicity . this invariance would further suggest that the primary driver of rgb mass loss is not related to dust production . we had also estimated in paper iii , based on the cluster s luminosity function , that one star reaches the agb tip every 80 kyr . these figures , however , do not correlate with our derived mass - loss rates . we find here that the cluster s @xmath422 dust - producing stars are losing a total of @xmath761.2 @xmath77 m@xmath2 yr@xmath18 of dust - containing wind . above the rgb tip ( @xmath762000 l@xmath2 ) , where dust production is ubiquitous , 13 stars are producing @xmath78 m@xmath2 yr@xmath18 . this implies that a staggering @xmath760.8 m@xmath2 is lost in the @xmath761 myr which a star spends on the agb above the rgb tip . clearly , this is impossible , as this is the entire mass of the star . this argues for a mass - loss rate of order 48 times lower than we measure . if additional wind driving mechanisms are important , this factor will increase further . mass loss via dust - containing winds between 1000 and 2000 l@xmath2 can be similarly determined . here , nine out of the 56 stars in this luminosity range are producing @xmath42 @xmath79 m@xmath2 yr@xmath18 , implying 0.16 m@xmath2 is lost over a 4.5 myr timescale . if one assumes that mass loss from these stars is also lower than measured , and that some or all of these stars are agb stars , this implies that mass loss via non - dusty winds may be of similar or even greater importance in removing the estimated @xmath320.22 m@xmath2 from the star between the middle of the rgb and middle of the agb . at the rates implied in table [ mdottable ] , the iron in the atmosphere of v1 would be entirely ejected within 1000040000 years , depending on the remaining envelope mass ( 0.080.3 m@xmath2 ) . v8 , v2 and v3 would similarly disperse the iron in their atmospheres within timescales of @xmath2590000 years . the padova and dartmouth isochrones used in paper iii predict that these stars ( especially v2 and v3 ) still have several hundred kyr left on the agb , implying that our iron mass - loss rates are ( again ) a factor of several too high . .maximum elemental abundances in dust [ cols= " < , > , > , > , > , > , > " , ] in [ windaccsect ] , we find radiation pressure may not be the dominant driver of winds from metal - poor stars , and is perhaps incapable of driving them in some cases . the simplest solution is to provide momentum from another source , such as stellar pulsations , in order to increase the wind velocity . unfortunately , this also has the effect of increasing the mass - loss rate , which is already higher than stellar evolutionary theory can accommodate ( [ dustevolsect ] ) . while we expect another momentum source to be present in the most - metal - poor stars ( simply because radiation pressure on dust is that inefficient ) , the limits implied by the mass - loss rates imply this is not the case in 47 tuc . a solution to this dilemma should address both these problems by decreasing the mass - loss rate without significantly decreasing the wind velocity . examining table [ mdoterrortable ] , the simplest change would be to bring the dust - to - gas ratio closer to unity , which would decrease the mass - loss rate and increase the wind velocity . alternatively , we may consider measures that would increase the wind velocity without appreciable increasing the mass - loss rate , such as changing the size distribution of grains . the dust - to - gas ratio , @xmath36 , given in eq . ( [ psieqn ] ) , assumes that the dust fraction scales with metallicity ( cf . this will hold true if every dust species condenses with the same efficiency . navely , one may imagine that the fraction of each element condensed would decrease toward low metallicity simply because there is less opportunity for metal - metal reactions to take place in a metal - poor environment . from our conventional understanding , it is difficult to see how the dust - to - gas ratio in the wind could be substantially closer to parity . we can , however , calculate a maximum amount of dust per unit gas volume , by taking the major dust - forming elements ( o , c , fe , si , mg , ca , al ) plus some other potential dust - forming metals ( ni , ti , cr , mn ) and determining how much dust they can form . for 47 tuc , we assume the abundances of most elements are scaled from the solar values of @xcite by [ z / h ] = @xmath80 dex , following @xcite . we take the following exceptions , however : [ fe / h ] = 0.7 dex @xcite ; [ he / h ] @xmath76 0.02 dex @xcite ; [ o / fe ] = + 0.2 dex @xcite ; [ mg / fe ] @xmath76 [ si / fe ] @xmath76 [ ti / fe ] = + 0.23 dex and [ ca / fe ] = 0.0 dex @xcite . table [ psitable ] shows the stages of this calculation , by which we conclude that @xmath81 . here we make the simplistic assumptions that all dust - forming elements start out in the gas phase , that all carbon forms co , that all silicon forms enstatite ( mgsio@xmath20 ) , that iron and nickel condense entirely as pure metals , and that the leftover metals all form their respective oxides . chemical reactions must be calculated on the basis of number density , but these must be converted to mass densities in order to calculate a dust - to - gas ( mass ) ratio . for reference , the same calculation using solar metallicities arrives at @xmath82 . this approach neglects several points . carbon may be enhanced in these stars due to dredge - up 2 m@xmath2 ) , carbon - enhanced stars of @xmath40.8 m@xmath2 exist in globular clusters ( e.g. @xcite ) . ] , but unless it is sufficiently abundant ( c / o @xmath5 0.75 ) to bind all the remaining free oxygen , this does not affect the end result . we also neglect water condensation , which could use up free oxygen , but this would serve to decrease @xmath36 . forsterite ( mg@xmath19sio@xmath83 ) may condense out in preference to enstatite , and calcium and aluminium may form into silicates before enstatite , but these would also decrease @xmath36 where they affect it at all . the formation of feo and iron - rich silicates would increase @xmath36 , but it seems that only a small percentage of iron condenses into non - metallic forms in these stars . our stated value of @xmath84 is therefore a relatively robust maximum value . table [ mdottable ] suggests that the number density of iron grains to other dust species in the winds is very high ( typically 10:1 , where it can be measured ) , but the analysis shown in table [ psitable ] would suggest it is of order 1:2 if all dust is condensed . this would suggest that the fraction of silicate dust that is condensed is quite low ( @xmath45% ) , however we have not yet accounted for two possibilities : that the temperatures of the grain populations may be limited , or that the size distributions ( specifically the surface - area - to - volume ratios ) of silicates and iron may be different . differing grain temperatures between dust species may exist when the wind is sparse enough that dust - gas collisions can not equalise the thermal energy . this would mean that more - opaque grains , like iron , are warmer ; more - transparent grains , like silicates are colder for a given radius , and could explain the difficulties we have in fitting both the metallic - iron continuum , and the 10- and 20-@xmath29 m silicate bands simultaneously ( [ mdotsect ] ) . more significantly , however , if thermal energy can not be equalised via collisions , this will lead to a significant velocity drift between the gas and dust components of the wind . this will substantially decrease the projected mass - loss rate , while the dust outflow velocity will also increase accordingly . if the gas outflow velocity is below the turbulent velocity in the wind , this may allow gas to preferentially fall back , making the star more metal poor . post - agb stars and planetary nebulae are known to be metal - poor for similar reasons ( e.g. @xcite ) , but it is not clear that this process is happening while the stars are still on the agb where the outflow velocities are lower and the wind densities at the dust - formation radius are greater . conversely , if dust grain temperatures are equalised and the formation temperatures of silicates and iron are roughly similar , we may examine the effect of different grain sizes by taking two limiting cases . if we take the limiting case that both silicates and iron grains follow the same continuous distribution of ellipsoids , the silicate condensation fraction is @xmath45% , and we arrive at a value of @xmath85 to 1/3000 if all the iron is condensed this would increase our derived @xmath34 values by @xmath7660% while decreasing @xmath38 by @xmath7630% . this is the opposite effect to that needed to reconcile our observations with evolutionary theory , therefore we consider this scenario unlikely . in the converse limit , silicate and iron dust has condensed efficiently , but the iron grains have average radii 20@xmath74 smaller . this increases @xmath34 by a moderate ( 3060% ) amount , but increases @xmath38 by much more ( 100200% ) , depending on the exact size distribution . if one is prepared to accept that iron grains grow preferentially in one direction , e.g. if magnetic effects are important , needle - like cylinders would be created ( cf . this would lead to a larger @xmath86 , but in this case without an increased @xmath34 . however , if identical fractions of silicates and iron are condensed , the length / radius ratio of the iron grains would need to be a staggering @xmath761200 , meaning that the grains must be smaller as well . for example , a population of grains 5@xmath74 smaller with a length / radius ratio of 10 allows a similar fraction of silicates and iron to be condensed with only a slight increase in @xmath34 . there is no obvious mechanism that would cause iron to be _ preferentially _ condensed at low metallicities , though magnetic effects and/or the basic problem of forming grains may be important ( an iron grain only needs two iron atoms to bond , whereas a silicate grain requires a series of chemical reactions to form mgsio@xmath20 ) . higher partial pressures of iron may also assist here , though it is not clear why this would happen in a metal - poor environment . note that in all cases above , we have assumed grains are homogeneous : our calculation of the wind parameters in [ mdotsect ] assumes all grains are a uniform mix of the included species , while our discussion above takes the opposite limit : where grains of each species exist separately in pure form . in reality , grains aggregate and form inclusions inside each other , which complicates the above arguments . in general , however , the evolutionary constraints provided in [ dustevolsect ] would suggest that dust condensation efficiency is high compared to solar - metallicity stars ( suggesting @xmath87 ) , and the iron grains are smaller and/or more - elongated than both the silicate grains and the assumed mrn distribution . a combination of these effects is likely required to reduce @xmath34 by the factor of 48 required without reducing the outflow velocities , @xmath86 , we derive ( table [ mdottable ] ) . where we are able to determine it , the composition of circumstellar dust and its variation with luminosity is similar to that we see in other clusters in @xcite ( see also figure [ fehfig ] ) . the evolution of dust composition in 47 tuc broadly agrees with that seen in other clusters at this metallicity . metallic iron appears to be ubiquitous around dust - producing stars , while amorphous silicates are produced by most stars without any obvious dependance on luminosity . the published spectra of several stars ( v4 , v8 , v13 , and weakly in v21 ; see @xcite ) show sharp features around 9.7 , 11.3 , 13.1 , 20 and 32 @xmath29 m . @xcite attribute the 20-@xmath29 m feature to iron - rich wstite ( mg@xmath88fe@xmath89o ) , where @xmath90 ) . recent work by niyogi , speck & onaka ( submitted ) suggests that all these features , with the exception of the 13.1 @xmath29 m feature ( which is probably due to an aluminium oxide @xcite ) , can be explained by iron - rich crystalline silicates . here , the 20-@xmath29 m feature is still produced by an fe - o bond , but it exists in a large crystalline lattice of fayalite ( fe@xmath19sio@xmath83 ) or ferrosilite ( fesio@xmath20 ) . iron - rich silicates are not expected to form in circumstellar environments , as their condensation temperatures are below that of both magnesium - rich silicates and metallic iron @xcite . if iron - bearing crystalline silicates are a significant component of some winds , they must exist alongside metallic iron and amorphous silicate species . one way this could occur is if cooling of the wind proceeds at a faster rate than dust condensation , which may occur in the tenuous winds of low - luminosity , metal - poor stars . figure [ fehfig ] shows that globular cluster stars which show a 20-@xmath29 m feature may be confined to luminosities below @xmath44000 l@xmath2 . it is difficult to say much about their metallicity dependance due to insufficient data , especially given silicate production appears to decline below [ fe / h ] @xmath4 1 . interestingly , the winds found in such stars ( x03 , v13 and v18 ) appear to be quite cool . in more - luminous stars , we find wind temperatures to be higher ( @xmath41000 k ) . the condensation of metallic iron before silicates remains a mystery : for pressures where iron condenses around @xmath41000 k , magnesium - rich silicates should have already formed closer to the star ( e.g. @xcite , their figure 2 ) . significant departures from lte , or unusually - high partial pressures of iron ( caused , perhaps , by magnetic confinement or clumping in the wind ) may offer ways to circumvent this problem , but to invoke them as solutions would be speculative without further data . by whichever process metallic iron is created , if radiation pressure is effective in wind driving , metallic iron condensation should have a dramatic effect on the wind . its condensation should cause a rapid acceleration of the wind , dropping the density and preventing other dust species from condensing . this may be what we see in moderately - luminous stars , such as v3 , lw10 and v11 . if radiation pressure is not an effective driver , the general absence of other dust species may be explained if silicates form using iron grains as seed nuclei . in this case , denser or more - metal - rich winds effectively condense silicates onto iron grains via collisions , while less - dense or metal - poor winds expand before much condensation occurs , leaving bare iron grains . this scenario may explain the iron grains found in the interplanetary dust particles known as gems ( glasses with embedded metal and sulphides ; @xcite ) . in the most - evolved stars ( v1 , v8 , v2 and v4 ) , however , we do see silicate emission making an increasingly - strong presence . meanwhile , there is a hint that the temperature in the dust formation zone ( as traced by metallic iron condensation ) may be decreasing . as noted in [ dustcondsect ] , different dust species may also have different temperatures . more detailed modelling of the winds of these stars , allowing for thermal decoupling of the grain species , is required if we are to speculate on factors which cause this temperature change . it could , however , be linked to stronger pulsation of the star and opacity shielding within the wind . in a cooler wind , however , silicates once again condense out in increasing preference to metallic iron , which contradicts our tentative finding that the silicate grains are cooler than the iron grains in these stars . in this work , we have used spectral energy distributions and infrared spectroscopy to establish mass - loss rates and investigate mineralogy around the dust - producing stars in 47 tuc . we summarise our conclusions as follows : the total mass - loss rate is estimated to be @xmath41.2 @xmath74 10@xmath91 m@xmath2 yr@xmath18 , mainly in the form of metallic iron , but this is probably over - estimated by a factor of 48 due to unconstrained properties of the dust grains . it remains unclear whether radiation pressure on dust is capable of driving a wind alone , due to the low projected terminal velocities of the stellar winds . the existence of circumstellar dust appears to correlate with the presence of stellar pulsation . we theorise that such pulsation may inject energy into the wind acoustically . variations in the wind chemistry broadly concur with those found in @xcite , with silicates found preferentially in high - luminosity , high - metallicity winds , while iron is found preferentially in low - luminosity , low - metallicity winds . iron may condense preferentially at low metallicity . alternatively , iron grains may be coated by silicates in dense , metal - rich winds , but this coating process may not be effective in winds around lower - luminosity and metallicity stars . * acknowledgments : * we are grateful to thomas lebzelter for sharing his original data with us . this paper uses observations made using the _ spitzer space telescope _ ( operated by jpl , california institute of technology under nasa contract 1407 and supported by nasa through jpl ( contract number 1257184 ) ) ; observations using _ akari _ , a jaxa project with the participation of esa ; and data products from the two microns all sky survey , which is a joint project of the university of massachusetts and ipac / cit , funded by nasa and the nsf . , s. 2007 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 378 , why galaxies care about agb stars : their importance as actors and probes , ed . f. kerschbaum , c. charbonnel , & r. f. wing , 145
Abstract: | [
"dust production among post - main - sequence stars is investigated in the galactic globular cluster 47 tucanae ( ngc 104 ) based on infrared photometry and spectroscopy . we identify metallic iron grains as the probable dominant opacity source in these winds . typical evolutionary timescales of agb stars suggest the mass - loss rates we report are too high . we suggest that this is because the iron grains are small or elongated and/or that iron condenses more efficiently than at solar metallicity . comparison to other works suggests metallic iron is observed to be more prevalent towards lower metallicities . the reasons for this are explored , but remain unclear . meanwhile , the luminosity at which dusty mass loss begins is largely invariant with metallicity , but its presence correlates strongly with long - period variability . this suggests that the winds of low - mass stars have a significant driver that is not radiation pressure , but may be acoustic driving by pulsations ."
] | 9,660 | 9,660 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: it is now well accepted that the giant planets of the solar system did not have the current orbits when the gas was removed from the protoplanetary disk . the first work showing that the planets had to migrate while interacting with the remaining planetesimal disk was @xcite . this work demonstrated that , in the planetesimal scattering process , on average saturn , uranus , and neptune gain angular momentum and thus migrate outwards , while jupiter loses angular momentum and moves inwards . since then , the process of planetesimal - driven migration was considered to be a fundamental one in shaping the current structure of the solar system . @xcite showed that planetesimal - driven migration can explain the origin of the orbit of pluto and of the resonant populations of kuiper belt objects . however , it appeared soon that planetesimal - driven migration alone is a process too smooth to explain several aspects of the kuiper belt s orbital distribution , e.g. the orbital excitation of the non - resonant objects . @xcite was the first paper showing that a dynamical instability of the giant planets could lead to a global orbital excitation of the kuiper belt , while delivering the giant planets on final orbits roughly similar to the current ones . building on these results , the so - called _ nice model _ @xcite combined the processes of planetesimal - driven migration and dynamical instability into a new global scenario . it suggested that the planets jupiter , saturn , uranus , and neptune formed in a compact configuration with jupiter around 5.45 au , saturn slightly interior to the 2:1 mean motion resonance ( mmr ) with jupiter ( @xmath3 @xmath4 8.65 au ) , and the initial semimajor axes of the ice giants ( uranus and neptune ) in the ranges 1113 au and 13.517 au . the planets were surrounded by a disk of leftover planetesimals , accounting for a total of about 35 @xmath5 , from @xmath016 to 30 au ( where @xmath6 is the mass of the earth ) . in this model the planets interacted with the planetesimal disk and , by planetesimal - driven migration , their mutual separations slowly increased . when jupiter and saturn crossed their mutual 2:1 mmr the full system of the giant planets became unstable and spread further through mutual close encounters . in particular , uranus and neptune were scattered onto orbits with relatively large eccentricities and semimajor axes , which crossed the original trans - neptunian disk . then , following a phase of dynamical friction caused by their interaction with the disk , the orbits of uranus and neptune damped in eccentricity and inclination . a residual planetesimal - driven migration placed the planets on orbits fairly similar to the current ones @xcite . the nice model had great success in explaining many features of our solar system , as : the capture of jupiter s trojans @xcite , the capture of the irregular satellites of the giant planets @xcite , the absence of regular moons beyond oberon s orbit at uranus @xcite , to cite a few . moreover , it was shown that , provided the inner edge of the trans - neptunian disk was at an appropriate distance from the original orbit of neptune , the giant planet instability could have occurred after hundreds of my of evolution , potentially explaining the origin of the so - called late heavy bombardment ( lhb ) of the terrestrial planets @xcite . however , the original version of the nice model presented a major problem ; the initial configuration of the planets was chosen in an ad hoc manner . @xcite performed hydrodynamical simulations of the evolution of the giant planets when they were still embedded in a disk of gas and found that the planets should have acquired a fully resonant configuration , with jupiter and saturn preferentially locked in their mutual 3:2 mmr with jupiter at @xmath05.4 au , saturn and uranus ( ice i ) in the 3:2 mmr , and uranus ( ice i ) and neptune ( ice ii ) in the 4:3 mmr ( although other resonant configurations are also possible ) . the authors also concluded that such a multi - resonant system is compatible with a subsequent evolution similar to that described in @xcite , although the instability in this case happens when a pair of planets leave the original resonant configuration , rather than when jupiter and saturn cross their 2:1 mmr . @xcite investigated whether , under some conditions , this initial multi - resonant configuration could still lead to a _ late _ giant planet instability , in order to explain the putative lhb as in the original @xcite paper . they found that late instabilities are possible , provided that the inner edge of the disk is several au s beyond the outermost planet and about 1,000 pluto - sized planetesimals are embedded in the disk , so to produce an important dynamical self - stirring of the planetesimals population . during the dynamical instability of the giant planets , several dynamical paths are possible , even when restricting the evolutions to those leading to final planetary orbits similar to the current ones . the actual dynamical evolution of the giant planets at the instability time can be constrained by investigating the consequences on the other components of the solar system : the terrestrial planets and the small body populations . the terrestrial planets and the asteroid belt give similar constraints , as investigated in @xcite and @xcite . if the orbits of jupiter and saturn migrate away from each other smoothly and slowly , as in planetesimal - driven migration , the @xmath7 secular frequency ( dominant in the precession of jupiter s longitude of perihelion ) decreases slowly in value and becomes very similar for some time to the @xmath8 secular frequency , dominant in the precession of mercury s perihelion . as a consequence , the orbit of mercury is destabilized @xcite . similarly , the @xmath9 secular frequency , dominant in the precession of saturn s perihelion , as it slows down becomes equal to the frequencies characterizing the precession of the asteroids at low inclination in the inner asteroid belt , so that this region becomes severely depleted @xcite . both papers concluded that the ratio of the orbital periods of jupiter and saturn @xmath10 had to evolve almost discontinuously from @xmath11 to @xmath12 ( the current value is @xmath13 ) . this happens if jupiter and saturn encounter another planet ( uranus or neptune or a third planet of comparable mass ) . the sequence of encounters causes a divergent jump in the semimajor axes of the orbits of jupiter and saturn , and therefore a jump in the @xmath14 ratio . this scenario is commonly known as the _ jumping - jupiter _ model . notice that if the giant planet instability occurred early , the terrestrial planets were possibly not yet fully formed and therefore the constraint on the evolution of @xmath7 relative to @xmath8 does not apply @xcite . however , the constraint set by the asteroid belt is still valid , supporting the need for a _ jumping - jupiter _ evolution regardless of the time of the instability @xcite . given that in a _ jumping - jupiter _ evolution the planet that encounters jupiter is often ejected onto a hyperbolic orbit , @xcite and @xcite suggested that the solar system had originally a third ice giant planet with a mass comparable to uranus or neptune . this scenario increases the probability that a _ jumping - jupiter _ evolution ends with four planets near their current orbits , once the putative fifth planet is ejected after its encounter with jupiter . then , @xcite considered many different initial multi - resonant configurations for jupiter , saturn , uranus , neptune , and the rogue fifth planet , and determined for each of them the probability that the @xmath14 ratio had a jump across the 2.12.3 range and the final planets reached orbits compatible with those of our current solar system . the successful simulations of @xcite have then been used to investigate again the capture of the trojans of jupiter @xcite , the capture of irregular satellites at jupiter @xcite , the excitation of the inclination of the moon iapetus at saturn @xcite , the evolution of the asteroid main belt and of its collisional families @xcite . they have also been shown to be compatible with the survival of the galileans satellites @xcite , despite of the encounters of jupiter with the ejected planet . however , when investigating the dynamical sculpting of the kuiper belt , @xcite and @xcite realized that , of all possible evolutions of neptune consistent with the five - planet _ jumping - jupiter _ model , only some are consistent with the current orbital structure of the trans - neptunian population . in order to get the correct inclinations of the hot population of the kuiper belt objects ( kbo ) , @xcite found that neptune should have migrated more that 5 au from its original resonance by planetesimal - driven migration before that the planets became unstable . this migration should have occurred on a timescale @xmath15 @xmath16 10 my , with the planet on a quasi - circular planar orbit ( @xmath17 0.1 and @xmath18 ) to avoid excessive orbital excitation of the cold classical belt , in the @xmath04245 au region . the planetary instability should have happened when neptune was already at 28 au @xcite in order to explain the so - called _ kernel _ of the cold kuiper - belt ( a clump of objects around 44 au ; @xcite ) . in this case the _ kernel _ would have formed from objects transported outwards in the 2:1 mmr with neptune and released from the resonance when neptune s orbit had a jump of about 0.5 au in semimajor axis , due to a close encounter with another planet . finally , in order to reproduce the observed ratio between the resonant and non - resonant kuiper belt populations , @xcite concluded that the planetesimal - driven migration of neptune should have been characterized by several small amplitude jumps , as those caused by a population of 1,0004,000 pluto - size objects in the disk . the brief review reported above , sets the context that motivated the study reported in this paper . it is clear that the work by @xcite needs to be revisited to test which initial resonant configurations are the most compatible with the new constraints on the dynamical evolution of neptune . this is done in the first part of the paper ( section [ early ] ) . in the second part of the paper ( section [ late ] ) we investigate whether the initial configurations selected in the first part of the work can lead to a _ late _ planetary instability , while still showing an evolution of neptune consistent with kuiper belt constraints . the possibility of a _ late _ instability is far from trivial . in fact , in order to exhibit a long - range planetesimal - driven migration before the planet instability , neptune needs to be embedded in the planetesimal disk . but in this case , neptune would start migrating away from the other planets from the very beginning of the simulation ( corresponding to the gas - removal time ) . this is likely to lead to an instability after just a few 10s of my . if instead the planetesimal disk is relatively far from neptune , the planet can be extracted from its initial resonance at a _ late _ time as in @xcite , but the instability is likely to happen as soon as the initial resonant configuration is broken , i.e. before that neptune can migrate far away . for this problem we will introduce a new concept : that of dust - driven migration , i.e. , migration due to the gravitational interaction of a planet with the dust produced in a distant planetesimal disk , spiraling inward by poyning - robertson drag . we will study the evolution of the system as a function of the dust properties and the numerical resolution used in modeling the planetesimal disk . finally , our results are summarized and discussed in section [ conclusions ] . @xcite characterized the evolution of the giant planets from several possible initial resonant configurations . they assumed that the solar system could have formed with 4 , 5 , or 6 giant planets . the additional planets had a total mass comparable to that of uranus or neptune . they analyzed the rate of success of each configuration by measuring the fraction of the planetary orbital evolutions that fulfilled a set of constraints , namely : the final planetary system is made of four giant planets ( criterion a ) , the orbits of the 4 remnant planets resemble the present ones ( criterion b ) , the proper mode of jupiter s eccentricity ( @xmath19 ) is greater than 0.022 in the final system , i.e. , at least half of its current value ( criterion c ) , and the ratio @xmath14 evolves from @xmath11 to @xmath12 in less than 1 my ( criterion d ) . criterion c is important because it is found that , although encounters between jupiter and an ice giant can excite @xmath19 , not all of them can do it as much as needed . criterion d is important because it is linked with the evolution of the terrestrial planets and of the asteroid belt @xcite . if jupiter and saturn migrate too slowly through the period ratio 2.12.3 , the @xmath20 and @xmath21 resonances sweep through the terrestrial planet region and the inner asteroid belt , resulting in orbital distributions inconsistent with those observed . then , from the success rates , @xcite concluded that a planetary system initially having 5 planets should be preferred . here , we revisit the @xcite work , adding a new constraint on the orbital evolution of neptune from the work of @xcite , namely that neptune should have migrated to @xmath028 au before the onset of the planetary instability . the works by @xcite and @xcite also give other constraints on the migration timescale of neptune and its eccentricity and inclination before the instability . the eccentricity and inclination constraints are met fairly easily because in this scenario neptune evolves in a planetesimal - driven migration without planetary close encounters until the instability phase . as for the migration timescale , @xcite claims that before the planetary instability , once out of resonance , neptune can migrate according to @xmath22 10 my for disks with 20 @xmath5 and according to @xmath22 50 my for disks with 15 @xmath5 . considering that those disks have the same extension , this exemplifies how sensitive the migration timescale can be with respect to the density of the disk . therefore , we decide not to consider the migration timescale as an important parameter at this point , because getting a correct timescale of the migration is probably only a matter of tuning the density and profile of the planetesimal disk . thus we add just one new criterion ( criterion e ) : at the time of the instability @xmath23 has to be in the interval 2729 au . while criteria a to d indicate that the initial solar system most probably hosted five giant planets @xcite , criterion e is a very important criterion that can be used to constrain in which resonant chain these five planets likely were at the end of the gas - disk phase . for simplicity , we consider only the cases of @xcite that involved 5 planets . we also always considered jupiter initially @xmath05.4 au , a distance between the outermost ice giant and the inner edge of the planetesimal disk @xmath24 1 and 2 au and extending to 30 au @xcite , composed by 1,000 planetesimals ( which is the resolution considered by @xcite ) , and two values of surface density ( @xmath25 ) equal to 0.02 and 0.03 @xmath26 . such configuration implies that the mass of the planetesimal disk ranges from @xmath013 @xmath5 ( in the more relaxed configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 5:4 au , and the three equal - mass ice - giant planets placed beyond them ] , with @xmath27 2 au and @xmath28 0.02 @xmath26 ) to @xmath065 @xmath5 ( in the more compact configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 5:4 , with @xmath27 1 au and @xmath28 0.03 @xmath26 ) . to perform our simulations , we used the hybrid integrator in the _ mercury - package _ @xcite , with a time step of half an year . table [ table1 ] gives in column 6 the rate of success for our new criterion e , after 20 runs of each initial configuration from ( * ? ? ? * table 6 in their paper ) . those 20 simulations were composed by 5 simulations for each pair @xmath29 [ 1,2 ] au , and @xmath28 [ 0.02 - 0.03 ] @xmath26 . although we have used two different values of surface density and two values of @xmath30 for the planetesimal disk , we decided to compress the results of all 20 simulations , for each configuration , in table [ table1 ] , column 6 . this is because , concerning our criterion e , only minor differences were observed with these changes . thus , when important , those minor differences will be reported . for completeness and to increase statistics , table [ table1 ] also reports the average of the rate of success for the other criteria taken from ( * ? ? ? * table 6 in their paper ) . because the simulations performed in this work are essentially the same of @xcite , the success rate for criteria a to d are consistent ( within the small number statistics ) with those reported in @xcite thus , we did not report our own results for the criteria a , b , c , and d. rather than that , we decided to check only the success rate relative to the new criterion e , and then , combine our findings with those of @xcite , which have much higher statistics , in order to determine which of the initial planetary configurations are the most compatible with the constraint on the dynamical evolution of neptune , unveiled in @xcite . lccccc 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 5:4 & 24 & 12 & 0 & 2 & 5 + 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 & 30 & 15 & 2 & 5 & 15 + 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 & 47 & 23 & 3 & 3 & 5 + * 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 * & * 32 * & * 13 * & * 4 * & * 7 * & * 65 * + 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 & 38 & 18 & 4 & 4 & 25 + 2:1 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 & 53 & 40 & 2 & 18 & 0 + 2:1 , 4:3 , 3:2 , 3:2 & 73 & 33 & 0 & 18 & 40 + our results can be interpreted as follows : : in these configurations , as it also appears in ( * ? ? ? 16 ) , it is possible that neptune leaves the resonant configuration and migrates ahead the other planets , but not always in the way required in @xcite . indeed , a configuration with initial resonances 2:1 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 never lead to an instability that fulfilled criterion e in our 20 simulations . the evolutions from the 2:1 , 4:3 , 3:2 , 3:2 configuration , on the other hand , had one of the largest rate of success for criterion e. however , such configurations present other major problem , mostly concerning the final orbital separation between jupiter and saturn , which is typically too big . the point is that , because the ratio @xmath14 has to change less than 0.5 if jupiter and saturn are initially in the 2:1 mmr , the mass of the fifth planet should be @xmath01/2 of the mass of neptune . instead , we assumed for this planet a mass equal to that of uranus - neptune , as in @xcite . a smaller mass planet , however , would not excite jupiter s eccentricity enough , so that the criterion c would not be fulfilled . moreover , hydrodynamical simulations @xcite show that in a massive gas - disk , jupiter and saturn would be locked in their mutual 3:2 mmr , rather than 2:1 . the grand tack model @xcite also implies that jupiter and saturn were in their 3:2 mmr at the disappearance of the disk of gas . so , we do nt consider that configurations with jupiter and saturn in the 2:1 mmr are very realistic . : these two configurations are too compact . only one out of 20 simulations for each configuration fulfilled criterion e. usually , the evolution of the planetary system is as in ( * ? ? ? 7 ) , where the instability takes place as soon as one planet goes out of resonance . as a result , no large - range planetesimal - driven migration occurs before the planetary instability . instead , the instability is violent and the evolution of neptune is largely different from that constrained in @xcite ( figure [ fig1 ] top left , in this work ) . nevertheless , although they are low , none of the success rates reported in table [ table1 ] for the configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 are null . thus , even being very unlikely , due to the reasons presented , this configuration can not be ruled out . : this configuration is too loose . @xcite already pointed out that neptune stops farther than 30 au for whatever reasonable disk s parameters starting for this configuration . here , we found that even with the planetesimal disk of lowest mass ( @xmath31 [ 1324 ] @xmath5 ) , ranging from @xmath32 [ 25(26)30 ] au , neptune goes out of resonance and usually migrates all the way up to 30 au or more , before that the planetary instability happens ( figure [ fig1 ] top right ) . however , sometimes the instability can also occur before neptune reaches 30 au , say at @xmath028 au . therefore , although this configuration may also present some problems with the extension of the planetesimal disk , as it will be discussed in the following sections , it does have a good rate of success in fitting criterion e ( 25% success rate ) . : this configuration allows neptune to migrate away from the other planets before the instability , but usually not enough . the instability commonly happen when neptune is around 20 au ( see * ? ? ? * figs 8 and 9 , and figure [ fig1 ] bottom left in this work ) . only for high density disks neptune can migrate fast enough and reach @xmath028 au before the planetary instability . if the disk s density is low , neptune migrates slowly and ca nt go too far into the planetesimal disk . so , this configuration has a low , but non - negligible , success rate of 15% and can not be ruled out . : this is the configuration that presents the highest rate of success , considering all criteria together , so that it is highlighted in bold in table [ table1 ] . this is also the most successful configuration relative to criterion e , with a success rate of 65% independently of the disk setup . the evolution of neptune and of the rest of the planetary system is usually similar to that shown in ( * ? ? ? * figs 12 , 13 , and 14 ) , and satisfies the constraint identified in @xcite ( figure [ fig1 ] bottom right in this work ) . figure [ fig1 ] shows examples of the evolution of the systems corresponding to the descriptions given for each of the resonant chains discussed above ( with the exception of the 2:1 jupiter - saturn resonance , due to the considerations previously made ) . almost all evolutions depicted in figure [ fig1 ] fulfill the criteria a , b , c , and d. criterion c was not fulfilled only for the configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 ( top left ) , where , although the eccentricity of jupiter was excited during the instability , it was quickly damped afterwards ( @xmath33 0.0075 ) due to the strong dynamical friction provided by the planetesimal disk . only the configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 ( bottom right ) fulfilled all constraint together , including our new criterion e. summarizing , when the new constraints on the evolution of neptune from @xcite are considered , the most probable initial configuration of the giant planets was 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 . the configurations 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 , and 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , or 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4;3 also appear possible , but less probable . this seems to be a consequence of the more relaxed orbital separation between the first and second ice giants . therefore , one would expect that any configuration having the first and the second ice giant in distance from the sun in a 2:1 mmr or similarly relaxed could perhaps also work . however , for simplicity , we decide to restrict ourselves only to the cases of @xcite , which we know the rate of success in filling criteria a , b , c , and d. the analysis performed in this section does not take into account the timing of the planetary instability . with the location of the inner edge of the disk that we adopted , all evolutions are relatively fast , and lead to instabilities after a few 10s my . in the next section we analyze whether it is possible to get a late instability out of the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 configuration , under some assumption on the geometry of the disk , still satisfying criterion e on the evolution of neptune . since @xcite presented the _ nice model _ , the existence of a late heavy bombardment of the terrestrial planets has been associated to the possibility that the giant planet instability occurred after hundreds of my of evolution @xcite . actually , the nice model , both in its initial version and from generic initial resonant configurations @xcite , is compatible with both early and late instabilities , depending on the distance of the inner edge of the original trans - neptunian disk and other disk properties ( mass , excitation , etc . ) . thus , the nice model does not prove the existence of a late instability . the timing of the instability can only be determined by looking at other constraints , such as the lunar impact chronology . unfortunately , the latter is still under debate . however , it is not obvious that the nice model can still be compatible with a late instability , if we fix a specific initial resonant configuration and impose a specific evolution of neptune . as explained in the introduction , if the disk is sufficiently close to neptune at the beginning , it is relatively easy that neptune migrates several au away before that the instability happens , but in this case the full dynamical evolution is rapid , as in the previous section . if the initial location of the disk is sufficiently far from neptune , the instability may happen late , but neptune is unlikely to migrate significantly before that the instability happens . moreover , in the case of the most relaxed resonant configurations ( e.g. 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 , which has neptune initially around @xmath024.5 au ) , the requirement that the inner edge of the disk is several au beyond neptune while the outer edge is at @xmath030 au reduces the disk to a ring . this seems implausible , particularly when considering the constraint that the disk should have hosted 1,000 - 4,000 pluto - size bodies @xcite , which would probably be problematic for the late instability as well , because the spreading of the narrow disk would not permit a delay . if one could show that the most developed and constrained version of the nice model is incompatible with a late instability , this would be very important to clarify the chronology of events in the solar system . thus , in this section we try hard to find whether the instability could have happened late and under which conditions . we let the reader judge whether these conditions are realistic or plausible , with our considerations summarized in sect . [ conclusions ] . for this goal , we proceed in steps . first , in sect . [ dr ] , we determine two critical values for the distance of the inner edge of the disk from neptune . one , @xmath34 , is the maximal distance that allows neptune to have a long - range planetesimal - driven migration away from the other planets , as in the previous section . the other one , @xmath35 is the minimal distance of the disk for which the five - planet system remains stable in resonance for all times . clearly @xmath36 and @xmath34 is larger than or equal to the neptune - disk distances considered in the previous section . the problem is that both @xmath35 and @xmath34 depend on disk resolution ( number of planetesimals and individual masses that are used to model the disk ) and that realistic values can not be used in practical simulations . so , we need to estimate trends to evaluate the values of the critical distances . in a second step , in sect [ de ] , we study how a flux of dust from the planetesimal disk , due to collisional planetesimal grinding and poynting - robertson drag , influences planet migration . this depends on total mass flux and individual dust size . the idea is that , under an appropriate dust - flux , neptune may migrate away from its initial location , so that its distance from the planetesimal disk decreases from @xmath37 to @xmath38 . at this point planetesimal - driven migration starts , as in the previous section . if the dust - driven migration is slow enough , the planet instability can occur late , even though it occurs only a few millions of years after the beginning of planetesimal - driven migration . this concept is then proven in section [ dde ] , where we combine in a single simulation dust - driven migration and planetesimal - driven migration , and we obtain an instability after 300 my , with neptune s evolution satisfying criterion e. this simulation is of course performed with an unrealistically low disk - resolution , but is a proof of concept that , for whatever disk resolution , an appropriate dust flux can be found . we finally discuss what a realistic dust flux could be in sect . [ dgl ] the interaction of a planetary system with a planetesimal disk can be very resolution - dependent , i.e. , sensitive on the number of planetesimals used to described the disk in the simulation and to their individual mass . in some cases , as in those of section [ early ] , this problem of sensitivity on disk - resolution is not strong because the distance between the outermost planet and the inner edge of the disk is small , so that there are from the very beginning many planetesimals on unstable orbits that encounter the planet , force its migration and , consequently , bring many new planetesimals to planet - crossing orbit . this is the reason for which @xcite found similar results for test simulations conducted with 100 , 300 , 1,000 , 3,000 , and 10,000 planetesimals in the disk ( same total disk masses ) , so that they decided to use only 1,000 planetesimals in their final simulations . of course , even in these cases , the disk resolution has an influence on how grainy or smooth the planet migration will be , but does nt have a major influence on the amplitude and the timescale of the migration . on the other hand , the resolution of the planetesimal disk becomes a real issue when the inner edge of the disk is far enough from the outermost planet . in this situation , the fraction of the disk that is unstable is small , mostly limited to the volume of the strongest mean motion resonances with the planet . the resonant planetesimals develop planet - crossing eccentricities and , with close encounters , force the planet to move a bit outwards . this moves outwards the resonances as well , destabilizing new planetesimals ( those which were not in resonance at the beginning but are swept by the resonant motion ) . depending on whether the mass of the new unstable planetesimals is larger or smaller than the mass of the original unstable planetesimals , the planet migration will accelerate or damp @xcite . in the damped migration mode , the planet eventually stops migrating while the resonances become empty . if the number of planetesimals is small , the planetesimals are individually more massive to represent a disk with the same total mass . thus , the migration of the planet is more grainy because each encounter between the planet and a planetesimal causes a larger jump in the planet s semimajor axis . of course , there are fewer jumps , so that the planet migrates , on average , by the same amount . but the more jumpy migration of the planet causes the resonances to jump around as well , thus destabilizing more mass from the disk than in the case of a smoother planet migration with the same averaged range . because more mass is transferred from the disk to planet - crossing orbit , the migration of the planet can change , in some cases , from the damped to the accelerated mode . with this issue in mind , we proceed in our study looking for two critical disk distances , for a series of disk resolutions . first , we look for the minimum distance ( @xmath1 ) that the inner edge of the planetesimal disk has to have from neptune ( the outermost planet for our case ) in order to maintain the planets stable for at least 400 my . second , we search for the maximal distance ( @xmath2 ) that neptune can have from the inner edge of the planetesimal disk to evolve as in section [ early ] . from these results we will extrapolate the values of @xmath1 and @xmath2 to realistic almost infinite resolution . once again we consider disks with fixed surface densities ( scaling as @xmath40 ) , because in this case we guarantee always the same amount of mass in the planets mmrs , independently of the resolution of the disk ( apart from stochastic sampling ) . the initial distribution of eccentricity and inclination of the disk was such that @xmath41 and @xmath42 ( the same initial distribution for all disks considered in this work ) . this is the simplest configuration that represents a cold planetesimal disk emerging from the end of the dissipation of the gas nebula . even if the disk was initially more dynamical excited not much differences in the overall evolution are expected because the mmrs inside the disk are very efficient in exciting the disk s eccentricities to planet - crosser values . so , in a very short timescale an initially cold disk would appear like an initially excited one . finally , we consider disks with resolution of 1,000 , 5,000 , 10,000 , 15,000 , and 20,000 planetesimals . the outer edge of the disk is fixed at 30 au . the distance @xmath30 between the inner edge of the disk and the planet ranges from 1 to 7 au , with increments of 1 au . given the great demand of cpu - time required to simulate high - resolution disks , we only considered the most successful initial configuration in section [ early ] , with planets in the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 and 3:2 mmrs . for this configuration , neptune is initially @xmath020 au . for each value of @xmath30 , we considered six different values of @xmath43 . .@xmath1 as a function of @xmath43 for the less resolved planetesimal disk ( 1,000 planetesimals ) . @xmath1 : minimum distance that the inner edge of the planetesimal disk has to have from neptune ( the outermost planet for our case ) in order to maintain the planets stable for at least 400 my . @xmath43 : density of the planetesimal disk , scaled as @xmath40 . the mass of the planetesimal disk , @xmath44 , in earth masses , for each pair @xmath43@xmath1 for the initial configuration 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 , with neptune at @xmath020 au and outer disk edge at 30 au is also shown for reference . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the results of the proof of concept " simulation are shown in figures [ fig4 ] and [ fig5 ] . figure [ fig4 ] shows the evolution of the semimajor axis ( @xmath45 ) , the perihelion distance ( @xmath46 ) and the aphelion distance ( @xmath47 ) for all planets as a function of the time . figure [ fig5 ] brings snapshots of the ( @xmath45 @xmath39 @xmath48 ) and ( @xmath45 @xmath39 @xmath49 ) of the whole system for different times of the evolution ] . the evolution shown in these figures has an instability after about 300 my and the evolution of the planets is in a considerably good agreement with that deduced in @xcite from kuiper belt constraints . particularly , the instability happens when neptune is at @xmath50 au as required . moreover , as we can see from these figures , the evolution of neptune before the onset of the instability , follows closely the assumptions / predictions of tables [ table2 ] and [ table3 ] , and the dust mechanism of section [ de ] . the instability did not happen precisely at the time we targeted , due to the approximations inherent in our linear combination of different processes , which in reality have a non - linear interplay . nevertheless , the instability happens late enough to suggest that the association between a planetary instability and the trigger of the late heavy bombardment is indeed possible . to assess whether the dust fluxes that are needed to migrate neptune into the disk ( see table [ table3 ] ) are reasonable , we turned to the simulation presented in the supplementary material ( s4 ) of @xcite . that simulation considered a disk with initially 60 earth masses , extended from 21 to 34 au the disk was quite excited in eccentricity and inclination within 27 au and dynamically cold beyond it . the planetesimals were assumed to have a size - frequency distribution ( sfd ) similar to that of the hot kuiper belt population in the inner part of the disk ( r @xmath4 27 au ) and similar to that of the cold kuiper belt population beyond it . both sfds were scaled up in number so that the masses in the inner disk and outer disk were respectively 1/3 and 2/3 of the total . the collision probabilities and impact velocities within particles in the inner part of the disk , the outer part or in different parts were evaluated to be @xmath51 km@xmath52y@xmath53 and 0.83 km / s , @xmath54 km@xmath52y@xmath53 and 0.25 km / s , @xmath55 km@xmath52y@xmath53 and 0.68 km / s , respectively . the collisional evolution simulations were conducted with the code boulder , developed in @xcite . the specific impact energy for collisional disruption was assumed to be 1/3 of that of strong ice @xcite . according to these simulations , the disk produced 32 earth masses of dust in 400 my . a total mass of 32 earth masses is big compared to the numbers in table [ table3 ] . on the other hand , not all this dust would survive all the way to neptune - crossing orbit , because the collisional cascade in the dust population comminute grains until they reach the ejection limit @xmath56 . this part of the collisional cascade is not modeled in the boulder code . also , the total amount of dust produced could be reduced by truncating the initial sfd to objects larger than some limit size ; in a new simulation where we retained only bodies with @xmath57 km in the initial sfd the total dust production is reduced to 15 earth masses . another possibility is to increase the specific energy of disruption for the bodies . in fact , @xcite revised the previous estimates of @xcite and concluded that the specific energy for disruption should be similar to that for strong ice in @xcite . a simulation with an initial truncated sfd but with a specific disruption energy 3 times larger produced only 7 earth masses of dust . even more simply , reducing the initial population in the disk would reduce the amount of dust produced , given that the dust production scales as the square of the number of planetesimals in the disk . in conclusion , we think that the dust fluxes listed in table [ table3 ] , required to cause a significant migration of neptune , are reasonable and in the good ballpark of what a massive planetesimal disk can produce . a more relevant problem is the dust production timeline . in the boulder experiments described above , the dust production decays as @xmath58 . in the boulder simulations , the collisional evolution of the dust is not tracked . but the dust collisional lifetime should scale as the square root of the dust production . consequently , the total amount of dust of a given size ( or @xmath59 ) should evolve with time as @xmath60 . because the migration of the planet is linear in the amount of dust that it encounters , the evolution of its semimajor axis should be proportional to @xmath61 . this means that , of the total migration range spanned in -say- 400 my , 1/2 of it is covered in the first 100 my and 13% in the last 100 my . in other words , the time to reach @xmath2 is proportional to @xmath62 , instead of being proportional to @xmath63 as in the case of a linear evolution ( where @xmath64 is @xmath65 au ) . thus , small changes in the flux can make the curve @xmath66 to reach @xmath2 distance early or very late . obtaining a late instability around 400 my requires a more delicate tuning of the dust production than that done in sect . [ dde ] , where we considered that the dust production is constant and the collisional lifetime of dust infinite . it is very likely that , at the disappearance of the protoplanetary disk of gas , the giant planets of the solar system were all in mean motion resonances with each other , because this is the typical outcome of gas - driven planet migration @xcite . @xcite investigated which resonant configurations are more likely to reproduce the current orbital configuration of the giant planets via a phase of dynamical instability , as that described in the nice model . they considered four criteria of success and found a number of initial configurations that meet all of them in a non - negligible fraction of the simulations . all these configurations require the existence of a fifth giant planet , with a mass comparable to those of uranus or neptune , eventually ejected during the instability . more recently , @xcite showed that explaining and reproducing the current orbital structure of the kuiper belt requires that neptune had a specific evolution , reaching a heliocentric distance of @xmath028 au by planetesimal - driven migration before that the instability happened . thus , in section [ early ] of this paper , we have revisited the work of @xcite , adding a new criterion of success from the results of @xcite . of the configurations selected by @xcite , the one denoted 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 ( each integer ratio referring to the mean motion resonance between a pair of adjacent planets ) stands out as the more likely to fulfill the new criterion of success . other configurations ( the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 2:1 , the 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , 3:2 , and the 3:2 , 3:2 , 4:3 , 4:3 ) can not be excluded , but their success rate relative to the new criterion is significantly lower . an open issue with the nice model is the timing of the giant planet instability . if one wants to explain the late heavy bombardment of the moon as a spike in the impact crater rate @xcite , the instability has to have happened late @xcite , unlike in the simulations of section [ early ] , in which the instability occurred after a few 10s of my . it is not obvious that a 5-planet resonant configuration can remain stable for long time and become unstable then , particularly with a specific evolution of neptune as that required to sculpt the kuiper belt . thus , in section [ late ] we investigated whether a late instability from the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 is possible and under which conditions . first , we looked for characteristics of the planetesimal disk that can maintain the planets in stable orbits for 400 my . we found that the evolution and stability of the planets are very sensitive to the resolution of the planetesimal disk . thus , we determined the minimum distance that the inner edge of the planetesimal disk has be away from neptune to keep the planets in stable orbit for 400 my as a function of the surface density of the disk and its numerical resolution . we named this distance @xmath1 ( table [ table2 ] ) . in a second step , we found a characteristic neptune - disk distance , which we named @xmath2 , from where neptune starts a long - range planetesimal - driven migration . thus , for the system to exhibit a late instability together with an evolution of neptune like the one that is needed to sculpt the kuiper belt , neptune needs to be extracted from the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 resonance chain , and to migrate outwards over hundreds of mys until it reaches the distance @xmath2 . to understand how this could be possible , we introduced the concept of dust - driven migration , i.e. , migration due to the gravitational interaction of a planet with the dust produced in a distant planetesimal disk , spiraling inward by poyning - robertson drag . we have shown that a late instability can be achieved when considering a flux of dust ( @xmath67 ) ranging from 7 to 22 @xmath5 per 400 my , depending on the value of @xmath1 ( table [ table3 ] ) . continuing , in section [ dgl ] we evaluated how much dust could be produced from the disk - like configurations that we assumed and found good agreement with the dust flux described above . indeed , we found that the total amount of dust produced in 400 my may vary from @xmath07 @xmath5 to a maximum of about 32 @xmath5 depending on the size frequency distribution ( sfd ) and catastrophic disruption energies assumed for the planetesimal disk and its constituents . finally , we also found that the dust production rate expected for a self - grinding disk is not constant , but it decays as @xmath58 . the abundance of dust , which is also limited by the dust collisional lifetime , should decay as @xmath60 . thus , because the migration of the planet is linear in the amount of dust that it encounters , the evolution of its semimajor axis should be proportional to @xmath61 , which implies that small changes in the flux of dust can result in neptune reaching @xmath2 distance early or very late . therefore , obtaining a late instability around 400 my requires a more delicate tuning of the dust production . summarizing , based on the work of @xcite , and considering the evolution of neptune required to explain the structure of the kuiper belt @xcite , our results indicate that the preferred initial configuration of the giant planets at the time of the dissipation of the gas nebula is the 3:2 , 3:2 , 2:1 , 3:2 , and that , although an early instability reproduces more easily the evolution of neptune required to explain the structure of the kuiper belt , such evolution is also compatible with a late instability . we thank an anonymous reviewer for useful comments and suggestions on the submitted manuscript . r.d . acknowledges support provided by grants @xmath682015/18682 - 6 and @xmath682014/02013 - 5 , so paulo research foundation ( fapesp ) and capes . a.m. acknowledges support by the french anr , project number anr-1313-bs05 - 0003 - 01 projet mojo ( modeling the origin of jovian planets ) . r.s.g . acknowledges his grant no . 307009/2014 - 9 from cnpq , conselho nacional de desenvolvimento cientfico e tecnolgico , brazil . the work of d.n . was supported by the nasa emerging worlds program . 99 batygin , k. , brown , m. e. , & betts , h. 2012 , , 744 , l3 benz , w. , & asphaug , e. 1999 , , 142 , 5 bottke , w. f. , vokrouhlick , d. , minton , d. , et al . 2012 , , 485 , 78 brasil , p. i. o. , roig , f. , nesvorn , d. , et al . 2016 , , 266 , 142 brasser , r. , morbidelli , a. , gomes , r. , tsiganis , k. , & levison , f. h. 2009 , 134 , 1790 burns , j. a. , lamy , p. l. , & soter , s. 1979 , , 40 , 1 chambers , j. e. 1999 , , 304 , 793 deienno , r. , yokoyama , t. , nogueira , e. c. , callegari , n. jr . , & santos , m. t. 2011 , , 536 , a57 deienno , r. , nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & yokoyama , t. 2014 , , 148 , 25 deienno , r. , gomes , r. s. , walsh , k. j. , morbidelli , a. , & nesvorn , d. 2016 , , 272 , 114 fernandez , j. a. , & ip , w .- h . 1984 , , 58 , 109 fernandez , j. a. , & ip , w. h. , 1996 , , 44 , 431 gomes , r. s. , morbidelli , a. , & levison , h. f. 2004 , , 170 , 492 gomes , r. s. , tsiganis , k. , morbidelli , a. , & levison , h. f. 2005 , , 435 , 466 izidoro , a. , morbidelli , a. , raymond , s. n. , hersant , f. , & pierens , a. 2015 , , 582 , a99 kaib , n. a. , & chambers , j. e. 2016 , , 455 , 3561 leinhardt , z. m. , & stewart , s. t. 2009 , , 199 , 542 leinhardt , z. m. , & stewart , s. t. 2012 , , 745 , 79 levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , gomes , r. , & backman , d. 2007 , protostars and planets v , 669 levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , vanlaerhoven , c. , gomes , r. , & tsiganis , k. 2008 , , 196 , 258 levison , h. f. , bottke , w. f. , gounelle , m. , et al . 2009 , , 460 , 364 levison , h. f. , morbidelli , a. , tsiganis , k. , nesvorn , d. , & gomes , r. 2011 , , 142 , 152 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & morbidelli , a. 2007 , , 133 , 1962 nesvorn , d. 2011 , , 742 , 22 nesvorn , n. & morbidelli , a. 2012 , , 144 , 117 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & morbidelli , a. 2013 , , 768 , 45 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , & deienno , r. 2014 , , 784 , 22 nesvorn , d. , vokrouhlick , d. , deienno , r. , & walsh , k. j. 2014 , , 148 , 52 nesvorn , d. 2015 , , 150 , 73 nesvorn , d. 2015 , , 150 , 68 nesvorn , d. , & vokrouhlick , d. 2016 , , 825 , 94 malhotra , r. 1993 , , 365 , 819 malhotra , r. 1995 , , 110 , 420 morbidelli , a. , levison , h. f. , tsiganis , k. , & gomes , r. 2005 , , 435 , 462 morbidelli , a. , tsiganis , k. , crida , a. , levison , f. h. , & gomes , r. 2007 , , 134 , 1790 morbidelli , a. , bottke , w. f. , nesvorn , d. , & levison , h. f. 2009 , , 204 , 558 morbidelli , a. , brasser , r. , gomes , r. , levison , h. f. , & tsiganis , k. 2010 , , 140 , 1391 moro - martin , a. 2013 , planets , stars and stellar systems . volume 3 : solar and stellar planetary systems , 431 petit , j .- m . , kavelaars , j. j. , gladman , b. j. , et al . 2011 , , 142 , 131 . pierens , a. , & nelson , r. p. 2008 , , 482 , 333 roig , f. , & nesvorn , d. 2015 , , 150 , 186 tera , f. , papanastassiou , d. a. , & wasserburg , g. j. 1974 , earth and planetary science letters , 22 , 1 thommes , e. w. , duncan , m. j. , & levison , h. f. 1999 , , 402 , 635 toliou , a. , morbidelli , a. , & tsiganis , k. 2016 , , 592 , a72 tsiganis , k. , gomes , r. s. , morbidelli , a. , & levison , h. f. 2005 , , 435 , 459 walsh , k. j. , & morbidelli , a. 2011 , , 526 , a126 walsh , k. j. , morbidelli , a. , raymond , s. n. , obrien , d. p. & mandell , a. m. 2011 , , 475 , 206
Abstract: | [
"recent works on planetary migration show that the orbital structure of the kuiper belt can be very well reproduced if before the onset of the planetary instability neptune underwent a long - range planetesimal - driven migration up to @xmath028 au . however , considering that all giant planets should have been captured in mean motion resonances among themselves during the gas - disk phase , it is not clear whether such a very specific evolution for neptune is possible , nor whether the instability could have happened at late times . here , we first investigate which initial resonant configuration of the giant planets can be compatible with neptune being extracted from the resonant chain and migrating to @xmath028 au before that the planetary instability happened . we address the late instability issue by investigating the conditions where the planets can stay in resonance for about 400 my . our results indicate that this can happen only in the case where the planetesimal disk is beyond a specific minimum distance @xmath1 from neptune . then , if there is a sufficient amount of dust produced in the planetesimal disk , that drifts inwards , neptune can enter in a slow dust - driven migration phase for hundreds of mys until it reaches a critical distance @xmath2 from the disk . from that point , faster planetesimal - driven migration takes over and neptune continues migrating outward until the instability happens . we conclude that , although an early instability reproduces more easily the evolution of neptune required to explain the structure of the kuiper belt , such evolution is also compatible with a late instability ."
] | 9,577 | 9,577 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in a small metallic island where the charging energy @xmath5 exceeds the temperature @xmath6 ( we use the unit @xmath7 ) , the coulomb interaction affects transport properties through the island . the resulting phenomenon is called the coulomb blockade ( cb ) and such system is named the single - electron transistor ( set ) . cb has been attracted much attention in the last decade @xcite and the nature of the transport properties of set has been clarified . set is interesting because it is regarded as one of the most simple examples of strongly correlated system which can be brought into the non - equilibrium state by applied bias voltage . early investigations consider the case where the tunneling conductance is so small that the higher order quantum fluctuation of island charge is negligible . recently , the quantum fluctuation in set has attracted much attention as one of the basic problems in this field . the quantum fluctuation is quantitatively characterized by the dimensionless parallel conductance : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the quantum resistance and @xmath10 is the parallel tunneling resistance of the source and the drain junctions . there has been much development on theoretical investigation in the whole range of @xmath11 . especially in the _ weak tunneling regime _ ( @xmath12 ) , the life - time broadening of a charge state level is much smaller than the typical level spacing of charge states , and thus the effective two - state model , which is equivalent to the multichannel anisotropic kondo model in the equilibrium state@xcite , well describes the low - energy physics . with this model , it is predicted that the quantum fluctuation of charge causes the renormalization of the conductance and the charging energy below the kondo temperature " @xmath13 @xcite . the renormalization of the conductance is confirmed experimentally as @xmath14 dependence of the conductance peak at low temperature@xcite . it is also predicted that in the non - equilibrium state , the dissipative charge fluctuation causes the life - time broadening of a charge state level and smears the structures of @xmath15-@xmath16 characteristic@xcite . though investigations have revealed much about the quantum fluctuation , most of them have been limited to averaged quantities . in order to understand the nature of the quantum fluctuation , investigations on the higher - order correlation function of fluctuation operators are required . a good starting point may be the investigation on the second moment of fluctuation operators , i.e. , the noise@xcite . the charge noise and the current noise in the weak tunneling regime is also important for practical applications , because it determines the performance of set electrometers @xcite . the current noise is defined by the auto - correlation function of the current fluctuation operator @xmath17 as @xmath18 where @xmath19 means the statistical average . until recently , investigations on the noise have been done using the framework of the orthodox `` theory@xcite , which takes account of the lowest order quantum fluctuation , namely the sequential tunneling ( st ) process . recently , several authors@xcite discussed the higher order quantum fluctuation in cb regime within the co - tunneling theory''@xcite . however , there is no approximation covering both st and cb regime . the aim of the present work is to construct a theoretical framework , which covers both of these regimes for arbitrary @xmath11 and clarify how the quantum fluctuation affects the noise . the keldysh formalism@xcite has been one of the most powerful methods to study the non - equilibrium properties of mesoscopic systems . however to apply this method to set in the two - state limit , one must overcome a technical difficulty : the spin-1/2 operator , which is introduced to restrict charge number states by the strong coulomb interaction , prevents one from utilizing wick s theorem . the most successful treatment to overcome this problem is given in ref . @xcite , in which a formulation of perturbative expansion for the reduced density matrix in the real time domain is developed and the inelastic resonant tunneling processes is treated . the method of ref . @xcite enables one to classify various tunneling processes using diagrammatic techniques , and can be also applied to other systems with the strong local correlation , such as quantum dot@xcite . in spite of these successes , it seems to be still difficult to apply this method for the calculation of higher order correlation functions , since this method requires to solve a special integro - differential equation even for the calculation of the average in the presence of large quantum fluctuation@xcite . in this paper , we investigate the current noise and the charge noise in the regime of large quantum fluctuation of charge out of equilibrium . we adopt the schwinger - keldysh approach and the drone - fermion representation of the effective spin-1/2 operator@xcite . schwinger - keldysh approach enables us to calculate any order moment systematically by the functional derivative technique@xcite satisfying the charge conservation@xcite , and it helps us in manipulating many complicated terms . the drone - fermion representation allows us to utilize the fermionic wick s theorem and to take effects of the strong correlation into account . with the help of this technique , we can extensively take account of the higher order processes of tunneling . we will show that our approximation reproduces the resonant tunneling approximation ( rta)@xcite as for the average current and the average charge . the outline of this paper is as follows . in sec . [ sec : keldysh ] , we briefly summarize the keldysh formalism and introduce an approximate generating functional . we also show that the average and the noise expressions can be derived using the functional derivation . in sec . [ sec : main ] , we actually calculate the average current , the average charge , the current noise and the charge noise . in sec . [ sec : results ] we show numerical results for the noise and give some discussions on the non - equilibrium fluctuation , the thermal fluctuation and the renormalization effect . section [ sec : summary ] summarizes our results . in this section , we give preliminary definitions of the schwinger - keldysh approach and we summarize three useful representations : the _ closed time - path _ , the _ single time _ and the _ physical _ representations ( sec . 2 of ref . @xcite ) . for simplicity , we consider the following action of a free fermion with a linear source term to explain the basic formalism : @xmath20 where the closed time path @xmath21 consists of the forward branch @xmath22 , the backward branch @xmath23 and the imaginary time - path @xmath24 as shown in fig . [ fig : closedtimepath]@xcite . @xmath25 is a grassmann variable satisfying the anti - periodic boundary condition @xmath26 . the complex variable @xmath27 is defined only on the forward and backward branch @xmath28 . the generating functional for the connected closed time - path green function ( gf ) is defined as , @xmath29 \exp \left ( -s/{i}\hbar \right ) . \nonumber\ ] ] gf in the closed time - path representation is obtained by the second derivative of the generating functional with respect to @xmath27 ( @xmath30 ) : @xmath31 hereafter , we use arguments @xmath32 instead of @xmath33 for short . though the closed time - path representation makes the formulation compact , in order to obtain the physical quantities , we sometimes need the single time representation in which the time on @xmath21 is projected onto the real axis . in this representation the degrees of freedoms of fields are doubled which we denote as , @xmath34 etc . here @xmath35 is defined on @xmath36 and @xmath37 is the real time . in the same way as @xmath38 , gf is transformed into @xmath39 matrix in the keldysh space : @xmath40 here , arguments @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the real time and each component is defined with the statistical average in the path integral representation @xmath43 a \exp ( -s/{i}\hbar)/z \right|_{j=0}$ ] as @xmath44 . diagonal components @xmath45 and @xmath46 are the causal and the anti - causal gf , respectively . off - diagonal components are correlation functions , which are written in the operator representation as @xmath47 and @xmath48 @xcite . here the statistical average is defined as @xmath49/z_0 $ ] where the hamiltonian operator @xmath50 is @xmath51 and the partition function @xmath52 is given as @xmath53 $ ] . it is known that four components of eq . ( [ eqn : ctpgfsingle ] ) are not independent . this redundancy is removed by the keldysh rotation@xcite . after the rotation , we obtain the so - called physical representation : @xmath54 gfs denoted by superscripts , @xmath55 , @xmath56 and @xmath57 are advanced , retarded and keldysh components , respectively . in the practical calculations , instead of @xmath58 and @xmath59 , the center - of - mass coordinate @xmath60 and the relative coordinate @xmath61 , @xmath62 are used in most cases . there are the following relations between components of gf : @xmath63 \rangle = g^c(1,2 ) . \label{eqn : comute}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here we introduce a notation @xmath64 whose physical meaning is the spectral density in the energy space . equation ( [ eqn : anti - comute ] ) is derived from the normalization of the step function ( see eq . ( 2.67 ) in ref . @xcite ) . the normalization condition of the density matrix results in an important equation @xmath65 ( see sec . 2.4 of ref . @xcite)@xcite which is equivalent to the following equations : @xmath66 in this section , we introduce our model hamiltonian and derive the generating functional for set , based on which we construct the perturbation theory . figure [ fig : system ] shows the equivalent circuit of a set . a metallic island exchanges electrons with the left ( right ) lead via a tunnel junction characterized by the tunneling matrix element @xmath67 . the island is coupled to leads and a gate via capacitors @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath70 . we consider in the weak tunneling regime @xmath71 and use the two - state model . in this paper , we limit ourselves to the symmetric case : @xmath72 and @xmath73 . the total hamiltonian consists of the unperturbed part @xmath50 and the tunneling part @xmath74 . omitting a trivial constant , the unperturbed part is given as @xmath75 where @xmath76 is the annihilation operator of an electron with wave vector @xmath77 in the left ( right ) lead ( @xmath78 ) or in the island ( @xmath79 ) . the subscript @xmath80 numbers the transverse channels including spin degree of freedom . the density of states is considered as constant in each region : @xmath81 ( @xmath82 ) . the second term is the charging energy and the effective spin-1/2 operator @xmath83 acts on the lowest two charge states . the energy difference between two charge states is given by @xmath84 where @xmath85 is the gate charge . the tunneling hamiltonian @xmath86 describes the electron tunneling across the junctions and simultaneous change of the charge state of the island . @xmath87 is the phase difference between the left and the right leads and parameters @xmath88 characterizes the voltage drop between the left ( right ) lead and the island . the tunneling hamiltonian is adiabatically turned on in the remote past and off in the distant future . it is the widely adopted procedure , which ensures the time translational invariance to describe a stationary state . in order to utilize wick s theorem for fermions , we employ the mapping of the effective spin-1/2 operator onto two fermion operators @xmath89 and @xmath90 @xcite : @xmath91 , where @xmath92 is a majorana fermion operator ( @xmath93 ) . this representation is called drone - fermion representation @xcite , because @xmath94 is a drone " whose only job is to make spin-1/2 operators of different spins commute , rather than anti - commute@xcite . employing the hamiltonian operator in the drone - fermion representation and following the standard manner to introduce a path integral @xcite , we obtain the generating functional in the path integral representation : @xmath95 \exp \left ( -\frac{s}{{i}\hbar } \right ) , \label{eqn : z}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where all field variables are grassmann variables satisfying the anti - periodic boundary condition . the action is given by @xmath96 where , @xmath97 . ( [ eqn : action0 ] ) we introduced auxiliary source fields , @xmath98 and @xmath99 , in order to calculate the average and the noise by the functional derivation . it is noticed that the degrees of freedoms are doubled , as shown in eq . ( [ eqn : fieldsingletime ] ) . after the derivation , these variables are put as @xmath100 and @xmath101 to be related with the parameters of the actual system . by introducing a linear source term @xmath102 , where @xmath38 is a grassmann variable , all fields can be traced out@xcite . in the limit of large transverse - channel number , @xmath103 is expressed as@xcite @xmath104 \right ) \nonumber \\ & \times & \left . \exp \left ( -\frac{1}{2 { i}\hbar } \int_c { { \rm d}}1 { { \rm d}}2 \ , j(1 ) g_{\phi}(1,2 ) j(2 ) \right ) \right|_{j=0 } \nonumber \\ & \times & 2 { \rm e}^{{\rm tr } \left [ \ln g_c^{-1 } \right ] } , \label{eqn : startz}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we omitted the partition function of noninteracting electrons . the trace @xmath105 and the products represent the integration along @xmath21 as follows , @xmath106 = \int_c { { \rm d}}1 { { \rm d}}2 \ , g_c(1,2 ) j(2 ) g_{\phi}(2,1 ) . \nonumber\ ] ] the particle - hole gf @xmath107 , in the closed time - path form is written as @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the number of the transverse channels . the gf for free electron in the lead @xmath110 and the island @xmath111 , @xmath112 , is given as @xmath113 which satisfies the anti - periodic boundary condition : @xmath114 . the @xmath115-field and the @xmath116-field gfs defined by @xmath117 also satisfy the anti - periodic boundary condition . ( [ eqn : startz ] ) , we construct a systematic perturbation expansion in terms of @xmath118 . for example , we show the diagrammatic representation of the zeroth ( @xmath119 ) , the first ( @xmath120 ) and the second order contribution ( @xmath121 ) to the generating functional @xmath122 in fig . [ fig : diagram1 ] . here , solid lines , dotted lines and wavy lines represent gfs for @xmath115-field , @xmath116-field and particle - hole , respectively . practical forms are given as follows : @xmath123 \label{eqn : w0 } , \\ w^{(1 ) } & = & { i}\hbar \ , { \rm tr } \left [ g_c \sigma_c \right ] \label{eqn : w1 } , \\ w^{(2)}_{\text{$c$-field } } & = & \frac{{i}\hbar}{2 } { \rm tr } \left[(g_c\sigma_c)^2 \right ] \label{eqn : w2c},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath124 is the term corresponding to the first diagram in fig . [ fig : diagram1 ] ( c ) , which we call the _ @xmath115-field correction_. the other four diagrams can be written in the same way . here , the self - energy of the @xmath115-field @xmath125 is defined as @xmath126 in a previous paper@xcite , we have shown that the first order contribution causes the divergence at the degeneracy point @xmath127 for average charge . in order to regularize the divergence , we proposed an approximate generating functional obtained by summing up @xmath115-field corrections @xmath128 to infinite order : @xmath129 \label{eqn : wrta } \\ & = & - { i}\hbar \left ( { \rm tr}\left[g_c^{-1}\right ] - \sum_{n=1}^{\infty } \frac{1}{n } { \rm tr } \left[(g_c \sigma_c)^n \right ] \right ) . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] figure [ fig : diagram2 ] ( a ) shows the diagrammatic representation of @xmath130 . the circle represents the self - energy of @xmath115-field and the thick line represents the full @xmath115-field gf defined by the dyson equation @xmath131 whose diagrammatic representation is shown in fig . [ fig : diagram2 ] ( b ) . in sec . [ sec : reformulation ] we will show that @xmath130 reproduces results of rta for the normal metal island . in sec . [ sec : mainbody ] , we calculate the charge noise and the current noise based on @xmath130 . in this section , we summarize expressions for the average and the noise on the basis of functional derivative . relations between physical quantities in the generating functional representation and those in the operator representation are demonstrated in appendix [ appendix : expressions ] . we also show that the gauge invariance of generating functional leads to the charge conservation law . the exact average current expression is given by the functional derivative of exact generating functional @xmath122 with respect to the phase difference@xcite : @xmath132 the center - of - mass coordinate of the phase difference is determined by the josephson relation@xcite . the relative coordinates are put to zero because they are the fictitious variables . from now on , we suppress the equations in the subscript after the vertical bar for short . the average charge is calculated by the functional derivation in terms of the scalar potential of @xmath115-field as @xmath133 the current noise and the charge noise defined as eq . ( [ eqn : siidef ] ) are given by the second derivative with respect to @xmath134 and @xmath135 @xcite : @xmath136 where @xmath137 is obtained from the first term by replacing subscripts @xmath138 with @xmath115 . it is convenient to rewrite eq . ( [ eqn : i - exact ] ) in the form of the linear combination of the tunneling current at the left junction @xmath139 and that at the right junction @xmath140 as @xmath141 . in the same way , ( [ eqn : sii ] ) is written in terms of the correlation function of @xmath142 and @xmath143 ( @xmath144 ) , which we denote by @xmath145 , as @xmath146 here , @xmath147 and @xmath145 are written as @xmath148 by regarding @xmath149 and @xmath150 as formally independent variables . the generating functional eq . ( [ eqn : z ] ) is invariant under the gauge transformation , i.e. , the phase transformation of the @xmath115-field and the change of the @xmath115-field scalar potential : @xmath151 where @xmath152 is defined on @xmath28 . the relation between the gauge invariance and the charge conservation in the non - equilibrium state has been analyzed in ref . for our system , the following expressions of the current continuity and the charge conservation for correlation functions @xmath153 can be proved ( appendix . [ appendix : conservationlaw ] ) . in this section , we derive approximate current noise and charge noise expressions , which is main purpose of this paper . we summarize gfs in the physical representation in sec . [ sec : freegreenfunctions ] which are needed for practical calculations . in sec . [ sec : reformulation ] we calculate the average charge and the average current and show that our approximation completely reproduces the results of rta . we also give some notes on the diagrammatic rule suitable for the functional derivative technique . in sec . [ sec : mainbody ] , we calculate the current noise and the charge noise based on the diagrammatic rule . we will check that our results satisfy the charge conservation law and the fluctuation - dissipation theorem . we summarize the fourier transformation of the retarded and the keldysh component of gfs . hereafter in this subsection , we put the auxiliary source fields as shown in the subscript of eq . ( [ eqn : i - exact ] ) . the solutions of differential equations ( [ eqn : gfc ] ) and ( [ eqn : gfd ] ) imposing anti - periodic boundary condition are@xcite @xmath154 @xmath155 where @xmath156 is a positive infinitesimal number and the @xmath157-function in the energy space is defined as @xmath158 the advanced component is the complex conjugate of the retarded component : @xmath159 . the two components of particle - hole gf are given by , @xmath160 where @xmath161 ( appendix . [ appendix : loop ] ) . @xmath162 is the dimensionless conductance for tunnel junction @xmath163 written in terms of the tunnel resistance @xmath164 as @xmath165 . the spectral density of the particle - hole propagator is given by @xmath166 where the lorentzian cut - off function is introduced@xcite . the keldysh component and the component defined by eq . ( [ eqn : comute ] ) for the @xmath115-field self - energy eq . ( [ eqn : partselfenergy ] ) and those for the particle - hole gf are related to each other : @xmath167 the retarded component of the self - energy is given as @xmath168 where @xmath169 is the digamma function . the full @xmath115-field gf is obtained by solving the dyson equation in the closed time - path representation eq . ( [ eqn : fullgc])@xcite : @xmath170 where we used the definition of @xmath157-function eq . ( [ eqn : deltae ] ) . here we remark the following : equation ( [ eqn : cg ] ) shows that in the limit of @xmath171 , the charge states are independent of the initial equilibrium distribution , because the keldysh component of @xmath115-field gf represents the distribution of charge states . this fact suggests that @xmath130 describes a physically reasonable non - equilibrium stationary state , which should not depend on any initial state . we transform above expressions into single - time representation . employing eqs . ( [ eqn : anti - comute ] ) and ( [ eqn : comute ] ) we obtain @xmath172 here @xmath173 and @xmath174 are written with the fermi function @xmath175 and the bose distribution function @xmath176 . functions @xmath177 and @xmath178 are given by @xmath179 and @xmath180 , respectively . the reason why we adopt the generating functional approach is that once an approximate generating functional is obtained , one can calculate any order moment systematically by the functional derivation . in the following sections we perform practical calculations , employing @xmath130 introduced in sec . [ subsec : w ] . detailed discussions on our approximation are retained in appendix [ appendix : perturbartion ] . the average current is calculated by substituting @xmath130 into eq . ( [ eqn : ir])@xcite : @xmath181 \right| \label{eqn : trace1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we used the fact that the self - energy eq . ( [ eqn : partselfenergy ] ) includes the phase factor through the particle - hole gf eq . ( [ eqn : particlehole ] ) . in the language of feynmann diagrams , eq . ( [ eqn : trace1 ] ) can be rewritten in a compact form : @xmath182{diagram11a.eps } \end{array } - \begin{array}{c } \includegraphics[width=7ex]{diagram11b.eps } \end{array } \right ] \right| \label{eqn : i1}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] solid dots with @xmath37 represents @xmath183 . the circle with @xmath163 is the partial self - energy defined by eq . ( [ eqn : partselfenergy ] ) . here we obtain the diagrammatic rule similar to that of refs . @xcite . ( i ) : : the diagrams corresponding to the functional derivative with respect to @xmath184 is obtained by a series of the following operations ; to put a solid dot onto all possible positions of vertices in a closed diagram , to assign @xmath163 on a circle connected to the solid dot , to multiple @xmath185 , and to assign minus sign if a solid line comes into the solid dot . next we project the fictitious time on @xmath21 to the real axis . as the tunneling hamiltonian is zero on @xmath24 , @xmath186 is zero for @xmath187 or @xmath188 . hence , the diagrams in eq . ( [ eqn : i1 ] ) are rewritten as , @xmath189 \right| , \label{eqn : trace2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we performed the keldysh rotation . @xmath190 is the pauli matrix in the keldysh space @xcite . the trace is carried out over the keldysh space and products represents the integration along the real - time as @xmath191 = \int_{-\infty}^{\infty } { { \rm d}}1 { { \rm d}}2 \ , { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{g}_{\phi}(1,2 ) \tilde{\varphi}(2 ) \tilde{g}_{\phi}(2,1 ) \right ] . \nonumber\ ] ] the phase in the physical representation @xmath192 is written as @xmath193 which leads to a useful relation for the functional derivative technique : @xmath194 by using the property of the gf in the physical representation @xmath195 , and that of a pauli matrix @xmath196 , we can see that the second term of eq . ( [ eqn : trace2 ] ) is minus the complex conjugate of the first term . to generalize this property , we obtain a helpful rule to reduce the number of diagrams : a diagram which is complex conjugate of a certain diagram is obtained by changing the direction of all lines and putting minus sign if the diagram includes odd numbers of vertices without solid dot . by performing the fourier transformation , we rewrite eq . ( [ eqn : i1 ] ) as : @xmath197{diagram11a.eps } \end{array } \right| = 2 e{\rm re } \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \right ] \nonumber \\ \label{eqn : diagram - trace } \\ & = & e \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } \frac { \sigma_{\rm r}^c(\varepsilon ) g_c^k(\varepsilon ) } { 2 } - ( c \leftrightarrow k ) . \label{eqn : iphysical}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the second term @xmath198 is obtained from the first term by swapping superscripts @xmath57 and @xmath21 . by generalizing eq . ( [ eqn : diagram - trace ] ) , we obtain the rule to calculate the diagram : ( ii ) : : put @xmath39 matrix gfs in the physical representation to the corresponding lines and circles , put @xmath199 or @xmath200 to a vertex with or without solid dot . subsequently , carry out the trace over keldysh space and the integration over the frequency @xmath201 . employing eqs . ( [ eqn : anti - comute ] ) and ( [ eqn : comute ] ) , eq . ( [ eqn : iphysical ] ) is transformed into the single time representation : @xmath202 by using eqs . ( [ eqn : correlationalpha ] ) , ( [ eqn : correlationself ] ) and ( [ eqn : correlatonfullgc1 ] ) , and noting @xmath203 , we obtain the final form of the current expression which has the same form as the landauer formula : @xmath204 where , @xmath205 is the effective transmission probability of lead electrons thorough the island : @xmath206 from the second form , we can see our result is equivalent to that of rta@xcite . in the same way as the average current , the average charge is evaluated by substitute @xmath130 into eq . ( [ eqn : q - exact ] ) @xcite , @xmath207{diagram12.eps } \end{array } \right| , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the solid dot with @xmath37 corresponds to @xmath208 whose practical expression is equal to the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eqn : deltaphysical1r ] ) in the physical representation . the diagrammatic rule of functional derivation in terms of the scalar potential is given as follows : ( i ) : : the diagrams corresponding to the functional derivative with respect to @xmath98 is obtained by inserting a solid dot into all possible positions of @xmath115-field gf . following the rule * ( ii ) * , the diagram for average charge can be also calculated : @xmath209 \nonumber \\ & = & \frac{1}{2}+\int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{\pi } \frac{\alpha^r(\varepsilon)}{\alpha^k(\varepsilon ) } { \rm i m } g_c^r ( \varepsilon ) \label{eqn : qrta}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the imaginary part of @xmath210 , which has a peak at @xmath211 , describes the excitation property of the charge state . when the broadening of the peak is sufficiently small and @xmath212 , @xmath210 is approximately given by @xmath213 here @xmath214 is the renormalization factor @xmath215 . the low energy cut - off @xmath216 is @xmath217 where one of three parameters must be much larger than the other two@xcite . the imaginary part of self - energy @xmath218 represents the life - time broadening effect . when the renormalization effect is negligible @xmath219 , it is written as @xmath220 , where @xmath221 and @xmath222 @xmath223 ( @xmath224 ) is equal to the tunneling rate into ( out of ) the island through the junction r estimated by fermi s golden rule . it is noticed that the condition @xmath225 is enough to neglect the broadening of the peak . by using the approximation eq . ( [ eqn : approxg ] ) , eq . ( [ eqn : qrta ] ) for equilibrium state reproduces the result of rta@xcite , @xmath226 . according to ref . @xcite , eq . ( [ eqn : irta ] ) is consistent with the co - tunneling theory and orthodox theory for two - state limit@xcite . we can also confirm that eq . ( [ eqn : qrta ] ) is consistent with the orthodox theory in the following way : in the limit of @xmath227 with keeping @xmath228 or @xmath6 finite , the renormalization factor approaches unity and the imaginary part of eq . ( [ eqn : approxg ] ) reduces to the @xmath157-function @xmath229 . thus , eq . ( [ eqn : qrta ] ) reproduces the result of the orthodox theory @xmath230 where @xmath231 . here , we calculate the current noise and the charge noise based on the reformulated rta . in the following discussions we limit ourselves to zero frequency component @xmath232 where we used a fact that at a stationary state , the time translational invariance is satisfied and the correlation function depends only on the difference of @xmath37 and @xmath233 . from the definition eq . ( [ eqn : sii ] ) , one obtain the current noise by applying the rule * ( i ) * twice . reducing the number of diagrams and using the rule * ( ii ) * , which can be also applied to the calculation of zero frequency noise diagram ( appendix . [ appendix : noiserule ] ) , we obtain @xmath234{diagram13a.eps } \end{array } \delta_{\rm r , r ' } + \begin{array}{c } \includegraphics[width=8ex]{diagram13b.eps } \end{array } - \begin{array}{c } \includegraphics[width=8ex]{diagram13c.eps } \end{array } \right ] \right| - \frac{(\delta \rightarrow c)}{4 } \nonumber \\ & = & 2 \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } { \rm tr } \left [ \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \ , \delta_{\rm r , r ' } + \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r'}(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) - \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r'}(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & - & ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0 \rightarrow { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used a fact that the second term of eq . ( [ eqn : sii ] ) is obtained from the first term by changing @xmath235 to @xmath200 in the physical representation ( appendix . [ appendix : noiserule ] ) . after some straightforward calculations , we obtain the following expression : @xmath236 \label{eqn : siirta } \\ & = & \frac{2}{r_{\rm k } } \int { { \rm d}}\varepsilon [ t^f(\varepsilon ) \ { f^{-}_{\rm l}(\varepsilon ) f^{+}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) + f^{+}_{\rm l}(\varepsilon ) f^{-}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) \ } - t^f(\varepsilon)^2 \ { f^{-}_{\rm l}(\varepsilon ) - f^{-}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) \}^2 ] \label{eqn : siirta_2},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath237 is the other side of @xmath163 ( for example , when the index @xmath238 is @xmath239 the index of the other side @xmath240 is @xmath241 ) . the charge noise is evaluated by adopting the definition eq . ( [ eqn : sqq ] ) and by applying rules * ( i ) * and * ( ii ) * : @xmath242{diagram14.eps } \end{array } \right| -\frac{(\delta \leftrightarrow c)}{4 } = e^2 \hbar^2 \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } { \rm tr } \left [ \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \right ] - ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0 \rightarrow { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 ) \nonumber \\ & = & e^2 \hbar^2 \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } g_c^{-+}(\varepsilon ) g_c^{+-}(\varepsilon ) = \sum_{\rm r , r'=l , r } \frac{e^4 r_{\rm k}}{2 \pi^2 } \int { { \rm d}}\varepsilon \left| g_c^r(\varepsilon ) \right|^4 \alpha^k_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) \alpha^k_{\rm r'}(\varepsilon ) f^{+}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) f^{-}_{\rm r'}(\varepsilon ) , \label{eqn : sqqrta}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we used eqs . ( [ eqn : correlationalpha ] ) and ( [ eqn : correlatonfullgc1 ] ) . equation ( [ eqn : siirta_2 ] ) has the same form as the current noise expression of a point contact without coulomb interaction@xcite . this result is anticipated , because the tunneling current is expressed in the same form as the landauer formula . however there is an important difference as mentioned in ref . @xcite : the effective transmission probability includes the coulomb correlation and the inelastic relaxation effect . here we note the following points . first , our approximation satisfies the charge conservation law : as the approximate generating functional @xmath130 is invariant under the gauge transformation eq . ( [ eqn : gauge_t ] ) , we can show the conservation law , eqs . ( [ eqn : iconserve ] ) and ( [ eqn : sconserve ] ) , for the approximate expressions . especially for zero frequency component , they reduce to equations for the current conservation law , @xmath243 and @xmath244 . it is worth noticing that the gauge invariance is automatically satisfied when @xmath130 consists of closed diagrams . secondly , we can show that our result satisfies the fluctuation - dissipation theorem : at @xmath245 , the current noise expression is reduced to the johnson - nyquist formula @xmath246 where @xmath247 is the conductance expressed as @xmath248 . we discuss the current noise expression in the regime where @xmath225 and the renormalization effect is negligible , @xmath219 . using eqs . ( [ eqn : transmission ] ) and ( [ eqn : approxg ] ) , the first term of eq . ( [ eqn : siirta ] ) is approximately given by @xmath249 where @xmath250 for @xmath251 , @xmath252 is the co - tunneling current from lead r/@xmath253 to lead @xmath253/r , and eq . ( [ eqn : siicotwidth ] ) reproduces the co - tunneling theory @xcite in the two - state limit . equation ( [ eqn : siicotwidth ] ) , which we call the _ co - tunneling theory with life - time broadening _ , is equivalent to the previously proposed equation in ref . @xcite in the limit of @xmath254 . the validity of this approximation is discussed in the next section from the point of view of the numerical results . by taking the limit @xmath227 , with paying attention to the relation @xmath255 \}^2 = \delta(\varepsilon-\delta_0 ) $ ] , we obtain the result of the orthodox theory in the two - state limit : @xmath256 = \alpha_0^{-1 } 2 e \left ( i_{+}- \frac{2 i_{-}^2}{e \gamma } \right ) \label{eqn : siiorth},\ ] ] where @xmath257 . @xmath258 is the average current of the orthodox theory . the second term is related to the part of eq . ( [ eqn : siirta ] ) proportional to @xmath259 , which represents the coulomb correlation and reduces the current noise from the poissonian value . it is noticed that even at small tunneling conductance , the second term is important in st regime . in the same way as above discussions , for @xmath260 and @xmath219 , we obtain the co - tunneling theory@xcite with life - time broadening from eq . ( [ eqn : sqqrta ] ) : @xmath261 in the limit of @xmath227 , we can confirm that our result reproduces the orthodox theory@xcite : @xmath262 = \alpha_0 4 e^2 \gamma_{+ } \gamma_{-}/ \gamma^3 \label{eqn : sqqorth}.\ ] ] in this section we present results obtained by the numerical calculation of eqs . ( [ eqn : siirta ] ) and ( [ eqn : sqqrta])@xcite , based on which we discuss the non - equilibrium fluctuation in sec . [ sec : discussion1 ] and that of thermal fluctuation in sec . [ sec : discussion2 ] . we also discuss the effect of renormalization on the noise at low temperature caused by quantum fluctuation in sec . [ sec : discussion3 ] . in order to clarify the nature of non - equilibrium current fluctuation , we consider the case of zero temperature , where there is no thermal fluctuation . furthermore , we limit ourselves to the condition of the high bias voltage , @xmath263 , where the renormalization effect is negligible . figure [ fig : s ] shows the current noise ( the top panel ) and the charge noise ( the bottom panel ) as a function of the excitation energy @xmath264 for small @xmath11 ( ( a-1 ) and ( b-1 ) ) and those for large @xmath11 ( ( a-2 ) and ( b-2 ) ) . plots are normalized by values of the orthodox theory at @xmath127 . solid lines , dashed lines and dotted lines show results of our approximation ( eqs . ( [ eqn : siirta ] ) and ( [ eqn : sqqrta ] ) ) , the orthodox theory ( eqs . ( [ eqn : siiorth ] ) and ( [ eqn : sqqorth ] ) ) and the co - tunneling theory ( eqs . ( [ eqn : siicotwidth ] ) and ( [ eqn : sqqcotwidth ] ) with @xmath251 ) , respectively . when @xmath11 is small , our results well reproduce the orthodox theory ( ( a-1 ) and ( b-1 ) ) . for large @xmath11 ( ( a-2 ) and ( b-2 ) ) and in cb regime ( @xmath265 ) , they agree well with the co - tunneling theory . figure [ fig : in ] shows the average current ( a ) and the average charge ( b ) estimated by our approximation ( solid lines ) and the orthodox theory ( dashed lines ) . in cb regime , we can see both the average value and the noise are enhanced by the quantum fluctuation . around @xmath127 , the average current and the current noise are strongly suppressed due to the life - time broadening effect @xcite . next , we discuss the validity of the co - tunneling theory with life - time broadening ( see eqs . ( [ eqn : siicotwidth ] ) and ( [ eqn : sqqcotwidth ] ) ; dot - dashed lines in fig . [ fig : s ] ) . as for the charge noise in the limit of @xmath227 , it reproduces the result of the orthodox theory as well as our approximation ( fig . [ fig : s ] ( b-1 ) : the solid line and the dot - dashed line almost overlap each other ) . in st regime it overestimates the current noise ( fig . [ fig : s ] ( a-1 ) ) , because it does not take the coulomb correlation effect into account as mentioned before . we want to stress again that our result reproduces the orthodox theory in the limit of @xmath227 , which can not be achieved by the co - tunneling theory with life - time broadening . the physical picture of the non - equilibrium current fluctuation is understood more clearly with the help of the fano factor defined by @xmath266 . the fano factor is unity when the tunneling event of electrons is poissonian process and is suppressed when tunneling events are correlated . the orthodox theory predicts the sub - poissonian behavior in st regime because of the coulomb correlation : suppose one electron tunnels into the island through one junction , the next tunneling event must be the out going process of another electron through the other junction . in cb regime , the co - tunneling theory predict @xmath267 . it means that co - tunneling events , viz . the simultaneous tunneling events of two electrons through the two junctions , occur randomly . the figure [ fig : fano ] shows the excitation energy dependence of the fano factor obtained by our approximation . in the small @xmath11 limit , our approximation reproduces the orthodox theory in st regime and the co - tunneling theory in cb regime and smoothly interpolate two theories ( the dotted line actually almost coincides with the result of orthodox theory in st regime ) . for larger @xmath11 the fano factor is further suppressed ( the dashed and the solid line ) . especially , our result predicts the value smaller than @xmath268 at the degeneracy point . it is a distinctive result because the orthodox theory predicts the inequality @xmath269 ( p. 137 @xcite ) . next we consider the physical meaning of our result . in cb regime and near the threshold voltage , the origin of the suppression of fano factor is considered to be the enhancement of the effective transmission probability @xmath205 , because the increase in the current noise is much larger then that in the charge noise ( see figs . [ fig : s ] ( a-2 ) and [ fig : s ] ( b-2 ) ) . as the fano factor of the shot noise is approximately given by @xmath270@xcite , the enhancement of the transmission probability results in the suppression of the fano factor . around the degeneracy point , the origin of the suppression of fano factor is different , because the normalized current and the current noise are suppressed as shown in fig . [ fig : in ] ( a ) and fig . [ fig : s ] ( a-2 ) . we consider that the fano factor is suppressed because of the dissipation , i.e. the life - time broadening effect : rta takes account of the dissipation process which is the leak of an electron from the island while another electron tunnels into the island and relaxes to the local equilibrium state of the island . the suppression of the fano factor by the dissipation was previously predicted for the 1d electron channel coupled with a boson bath@xcite . next we discuss the effect of the thermal fluctuation . figure [ fig : nyquist ] shows the temperature dependence of the current noise ( a ) , the average current ( b ) and the fano factor ( c ) at a threshold for various @xmath11 . they are normalized by the value of the orthodox theory at @xmath271 . as the temperature increases , the average current and the current noise increase because of the thermal fluctuation . at sufficiently high temperature @xmath272 , orthodox theory predicts that the average current saturates at @xmath273 and the thermal fluctuation dominates the current noise , i.e. @xmath274 which is the similar form as the johnson - nyquist noise for the ohmic resistance@xcite ( the plot for @xmath275 almost coincides with the orthodox theory ) . our result further shows that the average current and the current noise are suppressed as @xmath11 increases ( panels ( a ) and ( b ) ) . it is considered to be attributed to the higher order tunneling effect : the lifetime broadening caused by the thermal fluctuation is enhanced for the large tunnel conductance . the panel ( c ) is the fano factor versus temperature plot . the fano factor is independent of @xmath11 , which means that the correlation between tunneling events does not depend on @xmath11 . next we consider the renormalization effect at low bias voltage and temperature : @xmath276 . figures [ fig : sqq - low ] ( a ) and ( b ) show the charge noise normalized by @xmath277 at @xmath127 as a function of the temperature and the bias voltage , respectively . the charge noise is suppressed for large @xmath11 , which is attributed to the renormalization of the system parameters . in the regime @xmath278 , where the life - time broadening effect is negligible ( @xmath225 ) , we can approximate eq . ( [ eqn : sqqrta ] ) as @xmath279 instead of eq . ( [ eqn : sqqorth ] ) . here @xmath280 and @xmath281 are tunneling rate eq . ( [ eqn : tunnelingrate ] ) written by using renormalized parameters such as @xmath282 where the renormalization factor @xmath214 is @xmath283 . the lower cut - off energy @xmath216 is @xmath284 for the panel ( a ) and @xmath285 for the panel ( b ) . it is natural to interpret eq . ( [ eqn : chargernormal ] ) that the charge of a carrier is modified as @xmath286 by the renormalization effect . the interpretation is similar to that of the doubling of shot noise at the normal - metal(n)-superconductor(s ) interface . since at ns interface the carrier is @xmath287-charged particle , viz . a cooper pair , the shot noise is twice as large as that at nn interface @xcite . though the normalized charge noise is suppressed with increasing @xmath11 , one see that the charge noise always diverges at @xmath288 for arbitrary @xmath11 in the weak tunneling regime . since the charge noise is related to the charge susceptibility `` for excitation energy @xmath264 , the divergence means that the number of charge changes by one '' at the degeneracy point when we sweep the excitation energy . it is confirmed by the fact that the slope of excitation energy dependence of the average charge ( an inset of fig . [ fig : sqq - low ] ( b ) ) diverges at the degeneracy point . next we discuss the renormalization effect on the fano factor . figure [ fig : fano3 ] shows the excitation energy dependence of the fano factor for various bias voltage . we can see at small bias voltage where the charging energy renormalization is pronounced @xmath289 , the valley structures of curves are widened . the same behavior can be seen in the differential conductance shown in refs . we also see that the fano factor is suppressed with increasing bias voltage at @xmath127 . this suppression is also attributed to the dissipation as discussed in sec . [ sec : discussion1 ] : as the bias voltage increases , the dissipative charge fluctuation is enhanced and thus the fano factor is suppressed . by using the drone - fermion representation and the schwinger - keldysh approach , we have calculated the current noise and the charge noise in the regime of large quantum fluctuations of charge out of equilibrium . we have reformulated and extended rta in a charge conserving way . our approximation interpolates previous theories , the orthodox theory and the co - tunneling theory : our result coincides with the orthodox theory in the limit of @xmath227 and is consistent with the co - tunneling theory in cb regime . the approximation is verified from the fact that the result satisfies the fluctuation - dissipation theorem . in previous papers , we also checked numerically that the energy sensitivity does not exceed the quantum limit@xcite . we showed that at zero temperature and @xmath263 , the life - time broadening caused by non - equilibrium dissipative charge fluctuation suppresses the current noise in st regime . it also suppresses the fano factor more than the coulomb correlation does . especially the fano factor is suppressed below the minimum value predicted by the orthodox theory @xmath268 around @xmath127 . the origin of the suppression is attributed to the charge fluctuation which appears as the enhancement of the transmission probability in cb regime and the dissipation in st regime . at @xmath290 , we showed that the average current and the current noise deviate from the predictions of the orthodox theory with increasing @xmath11 . however , the fano factor is independent of @xmath11 and is proportional to the temperature . it means that the current noise is dominated by the thermal fluctuation and the correlation between the tunneling events does not depends on @xmath11 . at small bias voltage and temperature @xmath276 , the charge noise is suppressed as compared with the prediction of the orthodox theory . we showed that it can be interpreted as the renormalization for the unit of island charge . although the charge is renormalized , the charge noise diverges at @xmath288 for arbitrary @xmath11 in the weak tunneling regime . it means that the quantum fluctuation does not wash out the charge quantization . in this paper , we have limited ourselves to the discussions on the second moment and the zero frequency component , because we think them primitive . the investigation on the frequency dependence of noise will be important to estimate the performance of high - speed set electrometer completely@xcite . the investigation on the higher order moment and the full counting statistics@xcite will help us to understand carriers of strongly correlated system out of equilibrium . we would like to thank y. isawa , j. martinek , yu . v. nazarov and g. johansson for variable discussions and comments . this work was supported by a grant - in - aid for scientific research ( c ) , no . 14540321 from mext . was supported by mext , grant - in - aid for encouragement of young scientists , no . in this appendix , we show the relation between expressions for average and noise in the operator representation and those in the generating functional representation . the variation of the exact action eq . ( [ eqn : action0 ] ) accompanied by the infinitesimal variation of @xmath291 is given as the twisted " combination ( sec . 9.3.2 in ref . @xcite ) of @xmath292 and @xmath291 , @xmath293 where the center - of - mass coordinate of charge is @xmath294 . employing this source term , we can show that the eq . ( [ eqn : q - exact ] ) is equivalent to @xmath295 where @xmath296 : @xmath297 where we used eq . ( [ eqn : anti - comute ] ) to obtain the final form . the second derivative @xmath298 is calculated as @xmath299 here the first term includes the correlation function of 4 field variables on a same branch , @xmath300 , which is not well defined at @xmath301 . usually , an additional operation to determine the order of field variables is required to remove the uncertainty . alternatively , we subtract a term @xmath302 from eq . ( [ eqn : sqq_k ] ) as shown in our definition eq . ( [ eqn : sqq ] ) . here we used the normalization eq . ( [ eqn : normalization ] ) , @xmath303 . as a result , the first term in eq . ( [ eqn : sqq_k ] ) is replaced by @xmath304 , which does not include the uncertainty . ( [ eqn : anti - comute ] ) , we show that our definition is equal to the standard charge noise expression @xmath305 we should stress that our definition does not change the final result because eq . ( [ eqn : sqq2nd ] ) is 0 from the normalization . the exact current expression is obtained in the same way . the source term corresponding to eq . ( [ eqn : ds ] ) is given by @xmath306 which leads to relations @xmath307 where the current operator at junction @xmath163 is defined as @xmath308 in this appendix , we demonstrate the charge conservation law . as @xmath122 is invariant under the transformation eq . ( [ eqn : gauge_t ] ) , we obtain an identity @xmath309 we can derive the other equation , which is obtained from above equation by replacing @xmath138 with @xmath115 . however , the latter equation is not important in the following discussions . by putting the auxiliary source fields as the values given in the subscripts of eq . ( [ eqn : i - exact ] ) , and employing eqs . ( [ eqn : i - exact ] ) and ( [ eqn : q - exact ] ) , we obtain the current continuity equation , eq . ( [ eqn : iconserve ] ) . next we demonstrate the charge conservation law for correlation functions . by acting the operator @xmath310 or @xmath311 on eq . ( [ eqn : identityw1 ] ) , we obtain following two equations : @xmath312 by comparing the left - hand side of the former equation and the right - hand side of the latter equation , by setting the auxiliary source fields as the values given in the subscripts of eq . ( [ eqn : i - exact ] ) , and by using eqs . ( [ eqn : sii ] ) and ( [ eqn : sqq ] ) , we obtain the charge conservation law for correlation functions , eq . ( [ eqn : sconserve ] ) . in this appendix , we calculate the particle - hole gf . we begin with the tunneling action for the large transverse channel obtained from eq . ( [ eqn : action0 ] ) by tracing out the electron degrees of freedom@xcite : @xmath313 . in the physical representation , it is rewritten as @xmath314 , where the vector field @xmath315 is defined in the same way as eq . ( [ eqn : fieldphysical ] ) . each component of @xmath316 can be calculated by utilizing the functional derivation . for example , ( 1,2)-component is @xmath317 . \nonumber \\ \label{eqn : tracea1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as the functional derivative is @xmath318 in the physical representation , the trace yields @xmath319/2 $ ] . here we put @xmath320 and @xmath321 . the other components are evaluated in the same way . then four components are given as @xmath322 where we omitted arguments and coefficients . to obtain this form , we used the normalization eq . ( [ eqn : normalization ] ) or the relation @xmath323 ( see eqs . ( 2.64 ) and ( 2.65 ) in ref . @xcite ) . the following calculations are same as those in ref . @xcite . employing the fourier transforms of the gf defined in eq . ( [ eqn : gfl ] ) , @xmath324 and @xmath325 , we obtain eq . ( [ eqn : alphark ] ) . another loop diagram , the self - energy eq . ( [ eqn : partselfenergy ] ) , can be calculated in the same way . four components are given in the same form as those of eq . ( [ eqn : ph ] ) . by using eqs . ( [ eqn : drk ] ) and ( [ eqn : alphark ] ) , we obtain @xmath326 from these equations , eqs . ( [ eqn : selfenergy ] ) and ( [ eqn : selfenergyr ] ) can be derived . in this appendix , we describe some results of finite order perturbation theory and explain why we introduced eq . ( [ eqn : wrta ] ) which takes account of all orders for @xmath115-field corrections . first , we calculate the first order contribution of average charge by employing @xmath120 , eq . ( [ eqn : q - exact ] ) and rules * ( i ) * and * ( ii)*. @xmath327{diagram15.eps } \end{array } \right| = -\frac{{i}}{2 \pi } \int { { \rm d}}\varepsilon { \rm tr } \left [ \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{\sigma}_c(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & = & -{i}\int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{8 \pi } ( g_c^k(\varepsilon ) g_c^p(\varepsilon ) \sigma_c^p(\varepsilon ) + g_c^k(\varepsilon ) g_c^c(\varepsilon ) \sigma_c^c(\varepsilon)+ 2 |g_c^r(\varepsilon)|^2 \sigma_c^k(\varepsilon ) ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where gf denoted with superscript @xmath328 is given as @xmath329 etc . in the equilibrium state , the second and the third terms of the second line are negligibly small @xmath330 and the first term is simplified to @xmath331 where we utilized the relation @xmath332 . in the limit of zero temperature , eq . ( [ eqn : q2nd ] ) leads to the log - divergence@xcite as @xmath333 . above result suggests that the @xmath115-field correction is responsible for the divergence . it is further confirmed by calculating second order contribution of average current generated from @xmath115-field correction @xmath334 . employing rules * ( i ) * and * ( ii ) * , we obtain @xmath335{diagram16.eps } \end{array } \right| \nonumber \\ & = & 2 e { \rm re } \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } { \rm tr } \left [ \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{\sigma}_c(\varepsilon ) { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \right ] \nonumber \\ & = & e \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{2 h } \sigma^k_{\rm \bar{r}}(\varepsilon ) \sigma^c_{\rm r}(\varepsilon)-(c \leftrightarrow k ) + \delta i^{(2)}_{\rm r } \nonumber \\ & = & \gamma^{+}_{\rm r}(\eta ) - \gamma^{-}_{\rm r}(\eta ) + \delta i^{(2)}_{\rm r}. \label{eqn : i2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first and the second terms of eq . ( [ eqn : i2 ] ) , which are consistent of the expression for co - tunneling current @xcite , also diverge at the degeneracy point . from above discussions , we can deduce that the most simple way to regulate the divergence is to sum up @xmath115-field corrections @xmath128 up to infinite @xmath80 as shown in eq . ( [ eqn : wrta ] ) . it should be noted that the correction term @xmath336 diverges in the limit of @xmath171 . this divergence disappears when we consider eq . ( [ eqn : wrta ] ) as discussed in sec . [ sec : reformulation ] and sec . [ sec : mainbody ] . in this appendix , we demonstrate that the rule * ( ii ) * can be also applied to the calculation of zero - frequency noise . we also demonstrate the rule to calculate the second term of the noise expression eq . ( [ eqn : sii ] ) or eq . ( [ eqn : sqq ] ) . for example , we consider the current noise related to @xmath120 . though we consider the simple case , the following discussions can be generalized . from the definition eq . ( [ eqn : siipart ] ) , the noise diagrams is obtained as : @xmath337{diagram17.eps } \end{array } \right| \delta_{\rm r , r ' } - \frac{(\delta \rightarrow c)}{4}. \label{eqn : sii_1}\ ] ] the integration in terms of @xmath37 in the first term is calculated as @xmath338{diagram17.eps } \end{array } \right| = \int { { \rm d}}t { \rm tr } \left . \left [ \frac{\delta \varphi_{\rm r}}{\delta \varphi_{{\rm r } \ , \delta}(t ) } \sigma_{\rm r } \frac{\delta \varphi_{\rm r'}}{\delta \varphi_{{\rm r ' } \ , \delta}(t ' ) } g_c \right ] \right| \nonumber \\ & = & \int \frac{{{\rm d}}\varepsilon}{h } { \rm tr } \left [ \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{\sigma}_{\rm r}(\varepsilon ) \frac{{\mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0}{2 } \tilde{g}_c(\varepsilon ) \right ] . \label{eqn : trace4}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and thus we can see that the rule * ( ii ) * can be applied for the calculation of the zero - frequency current noise . as for the second term , the derivation @xmath339 appears instead of eq . ( [ eqn : deltaphysical1r ] ) . thus we can derive the rule that the second term is obtained from the first term by replacing @xmath235 with @xmath200 as @xmath340/h $ ] @xcite . as a result , ( [ eqn : sii_1 ] ) is expressed as @xmath341 \delta_{\rm r , r'}/(2 h ) - ( { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^0 \rightarrow { \mbox{\boldmath$\tau$}}^1 ) . \nonumber\ ] ] as for the charge noise , we can repeat the same discussions as above .
Abstract: | [
"by using the drone - fermion representation and the schwinger - keldysh approach , we calculate the current noise and the charge noise for a single - electron transistor in the non - equilibrium state in the presence of large quantum fluctuation of island charge . our result interpolates between those of the orthodox `` theory and the co - tunneling theory '' . we find the following effects which are not treated by previous theories : ( i ) at zero temperature @xmath0 and at finite applied bias voltage @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the kondo temperature `` , we find the fano factor is suppressed more than the suppression caused by coulomb correlation both in the coulomb blockade regime and in the sequential tunneling regime . ( ii ) for @xmath3 , the current noise in the presence of large charge fluctuation is modified and deviates from the prediction of the orthodox theory . however , the fano factor coincides with that of the orthodox theory and is proportional to the temperature . ( iii ) for @xmath4 , the charge noise is suppressed due to the renormalization of system parameters caused by quantum fluctuation of charge . we interpret it in terms of the modification of the unit '' for island charge ."
] | 10,347 | 10,347 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the tight correlation between the mass of a supermassive black hole and the properties of its host galaxies spheroid component is now well established in the local universe ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , indicating a coeval growth history of galaxies and their central black holes . however , the detailed role of this correlation for our understanding of galaxy evolution and black hole growth is still an open question . the standard theoretical scenario explains this relation by joint triggering of star formation and black hole activity via major mergers , while the black hole growth is self - regulated via active galactic nuclei ( agn ) feedback that shuts off star formation and quenches the accretion on to the black hole ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? alternatively , it may be possible to reproduce the observed black hole - galaxy correlations without the need for self - regulation via agn feedback , either as a natural consequence of a common merger history @xcite , or in a black hole growth scenario via gravitational torques @xcite . an observational constraint to distinguish between these alternative scenarios and to constrain individual theoretical models ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) is provided by the redshift evolution of the @xmath1bulge relations . however , direct dynamical black hole mass measurements are not feasible at higher redshifts . while integrated constraints can be obtained from the study of the black hole mass function ( bhmf ) and the agn luminosity function @xcite , the only route for observational studies on individual objects is to use broad line agn samples . the underlying assumption for this approach is that broad line agn obey the same relationship as non - active galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . for broad line agn the black hole mass can be estimated employing the virial method ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the main challenge for these studies is to determine the properties of the agn host galaxy , targeting either the velocity dispersion @xcite , the galaxy luminosity @xcite or the stellar mass @xcite . while early studies suggested a clear trend of positive evolution in the @xmath0-bulge relation , they preferentially focused on luminous quasars and their hosts , sampling from the bright end of the agn luminosity function . more recent studies , using fainter agn , tend to find mild or no evolution @xcite . a compilation of current literature results is shown in fig . [ fig : bhmstevo ] . indeed , sample selection is a particular important issue for these studies , as selection effects are almost inevitable @xcite . in particular , @xcite argued that intrinsic scatter in the @xmath0-bulge relation and a steep exponential cutoff in the galaxy distribution function will lead to biased apparent relations . this bias is exacerbated by the effects of a bright flux limit in the employed agn samples . in ( * hereafter sw11 ) we presented a common framework , based on the bivariate distribution function of black hole mass and spheroid property , to investigate and model the luminosity bias and other selection biases on the @xmath0-bulge relations . we additionally discussed an active fraction bias , which is introduced if only _ active _ black holes are selected and if the probability to be in an active stage depends on black hole mass . it is possible to account for these effects if ( 1 ) the selection function of the respective sample is well known , and ( 2 ) the underlying distribution functions , such as the galaxy distribution function , the active bhmf and the eddington ratio distribution function ( erdf ) , are known . however , in particular at high redshift this is currently not the case . therefore , we are facing the problem that even if we are able to obtain reasonably large agn samples with individual black hole mass estimates and host galaxy property measurements , the interpretation of such results in terms of evolution or non - evolution is challenging due to the sample selection effects . in this paper we present a practical solution to this dilemma . we build on the framework presented in sw11 and give a quantitative assessment of , and a correction procedure for sample selection effects on observations of the @xmath0-bulge relations . we outline a maximum likelihood fitting approach that directly incorporates information on the selection function into the fitting . we also restrict prior knowledge of the underlying distribution functions to a minimum . the method is able to reconstruct the true unbiased @xmath0-bulge relation for an observed sample and thus largely overcomes the limitations imposed by the sample selection . the paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : method ] we present the general maximum likelihood fitting method and its application to the @xmath0-bulge relation for agn . in section [ sec : predict ] we verify the robustness and uncertainties of the method via monte carlo simulations . section [ sec : application ] illustrates the method by its application to representative previous studies and discusses its ramifications for the evolution of the @xmath0-bulge relation . we conclude in section [ sec : conclusions ] . while the main goal of the method presented here is to study the @xmath1bulge relation , it is also applicable to more general cases . identifying and characterizing correlations between two observables is a fundamental aspect of astrophysical research . given a joint distribution of two parameters with non - zero intrinsic scatter , this correlation will often be affected by the specific sample selection . we therefore first outline the general concept of the approach , before applying it to the @xmath1bulge relation . let us assume that there exists a correlation between two observational parameters @xmath6 and @xmath7 for a class of objects . the space density of these objects is given by a bivariate distribution function @xmath8 . marginalizing @xmath9 over @xmath6 gives the distribution function of the variable @xmath7 , and vice versa . in the case of the @xmath1bulge relation @xmath6 is for example the stellar velocity dispersion @xmath10 and @xmath7 is the black hole mass @xmath11 . thus marginalizing their bivariate distribution function over @xmath10 gives the bhmf , while marginalizing over @xmath11 will provide the galaxy stellar velocity dispersion function ( svdf ) . we here assume the following parameterization for the bivariate distribution @xmath12 where @xmath13 is the distribution function in @xmath6 , e.g. the galaxy svdf , and @xmath14 gives the probability of finding the value @xmath7 given @xmath6 . this is the intrinsic correlation between @xmath6 and @xmath7 . we here specifically assume a linear relation @xmath15 with log - normal intrinsic scatter @xmath16 , i.e. @xmath17 the bivariate distribution function @xmath8 describes the intrinsic joint distribution function of @xmath6 and @xmath7 in the universe . in practice , this will not be equal to the observed bivariate distribution for a sample , since this sample is almost always affected by implicit or explicit selection effects . we incorporate these selection criteria into a selection function @xmath18 , where @xmath19 refers to the set of additional parameters present as selection criteria , such as redshift or luminosity . the multivariate distribution @xmath20 for an observed sample is then given by @xmath21 where @xmath22 is a set of normalized distribution functions of the parameters @xmath19 . the respective bivariate distribution @xmath23 is given by integration over @xmath19 . in general @xmath24 . this means the correlation between @xmath6 and @xmath7 , e.g. the @xmath25 relation , fitted directly to the observations is not equal to the intrinsic correlation . ignoring this inequality will lead to a bias ( see sw11 ) . in practice , we are mainly interested in the intrinsic correlation between @xmath6 and @xmath7 , i.e. @xmath14 and less in the full joint distribution function . the information of this intrinsic correlation is contained in the conditional probability function , but in general is not equal to it . there are two options to define the observed correlation between @xmath6 and @xmath7 . first , the relation of @xmath7 at a given @xmath6 , and second the relation of @xmath6 at a given @xmath7 . these are given by the conditional probabilities @xmath26 @xmath27 where @xmath28 gives the probability of finding the property @xmath7 ( e.g. black hole mass ) in a galaxy with properties @xmath6 ( e.g. @xmath29 ) and @xmath19 , while @xmath30 is the probability of finding a galaxy with @xmath6 for given @xmath7 and @xmath19 . we will refer to these as forward and inverse probabilities , respectively . let us assume the special case there are no selection effects on @xmath7 . when we use the bivariate distribution given by equation ( [ eq : psi ] ) the forward conditional probability is given by @xmath31 , i.e. the intrinsic underlying relation is directly recovered in the conditional probability . for the inverse conditional probability it follows in the absence of any selection effects @xmath32 this is already a deviation from the intrinsic relation @xmath14 , even without applying any selection criteria to the sample . in the context of the @xmath1bulge relation the stellar mass function exponentially decreases at the high mass end , which together with the intrinsic scatter leads to a deviation of @xmath33 at the high mass end ( * ? ? ? this can already qualitatively explain the steeper slope found in the @xmath25 relation for galaxies with dynamical black hole mass measurements when fitting the inverse @xmath25 relation @xmath34 instead of the relation @xmath35 @xcite . in practice selection effects are present and can produce a bias , i.e. @xmath36 . however , if we know the selection function of our sample , we can incorporate this knowledge directly into the fitting of the conditional probability to recover the intrinsic relation @xmath14 . the maximum likelihood technique provides a conceptually simple way to achieve this . this method aims at minimizing the likelihood function @xmath37 , with @xmath38 being the product of the likelihoods for the individual measurements . both conditional probabilities , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , can serve as likelihoods , i.e. we either minimize @xmath41 @xmath42 to obtain the best - fitting parameters of @xmath14 . we here refer to the minimization of @xmath43 as forward ml regression and of @xmath44 as inverse ml regression . we emphasize that these maximum likelihood fits go beyond a simple linear regression , since we are not only fitting a model to the data , but incorporate additional information about the data set and the underlying distributions . thereby , the used conditional probability function can have an arbitrarily complex form . we will refer to the more standard approach of fitting the conditional probability @xmath45 without including the effects of sample selection as simple regression. which of the two maximum likelihood fit options ( forward / inverse ) is the preferred choice depends on the specific selection effects , and on the underlying distributions . for example , when there are no selection effects then forward regression is preferable , since the fitted conditional probability is equal to the intrinsic relation @xmath14 . in this case the maximum likelihood fit is equal to a simple regression approach , used in other studies to fit the @xmath25 relation for quiescent galaxies ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) . the inverse ml regression ( using equation [ eq : cond_smu_int ] ) requires additional information about the distribution function @xmath13 and is therefore more complicated to use however , in the presence of selection effects on @xmath7 the inverse ml regression might become preferable , since it can be unaffected by the selection effects , in contrast to the forward ml regression . we will illustrate this below for the @xmath1bulge relation for active galaxies . while other applications of this method are possible , in the following we focus on the specific case of studying the @xmath1bulge relation at high redshift via broad line agn samples . in sw11 we discussed the qualitative influence of sample selection effects on observations of the @xmath1bulge relation for broad line agn samples in detail within our framework of the bivariate distribution function . the @xmath1bulge relation is given by @xmath46 , with @xmath47 being the logarithmic black hole mass and @xmath48 is the logarithm of the host galaxy property , e.g. @xmath10 or @xmath49 , and @xmath50 and @xmath51 are the normalization and the slope of the relation . thus in the above terminology @xmath52 and @xmath53 . with the parametrization of equation ( [ eq : psi ] ) , the bivariate distribution function is @xmath54 where @xmath55 is the spheroid distribution function and @xmath56 is the intrinsic @xmath1bulge relation . integrating this bivariate distribution function over @xmath48 gives the total bhmf . for an agn sample the main selection criteria will be the agn flux . therefore , the selection function will depend on agn luminosity and redshift . the agn luminosity is determined by the black hole mass @xmath0 and the accretion rate , the latter is represented by the eddington ratio @xmath57 , i.e. @xmath58 . this implies a selection function @xmath59 , depending on black hole mass , eddington ratio and redshift . the corresponding distribution function is the bivariate distribution function of black hole mass and eddington ratio for active black holes @xmath60 , with its projections the active bhmf and the erdf . we here make the assumption that the bivariate distribution function of black hole mass and eddington ratio is separable into an independent bhmf and erdf , i.e. @xmath61 where @xmath62 is the erdf , normalized to one and @xmath63 is the active bhmf . this assumption is motivated by results on the local bivariate distribution function of @xmath64 and @xmath65@xcite and by the observation of an eddington ratio distribution of agn that is independent of stellar mass @xcite , suggesting also an independence of @xmath64 [ but see @xcite for evidence of a @xmath64 dependence of the erdf ] . we comment on the consequences of relaxing this assumption below . the active bhmf is related to the total bhmf via the active fraction , which gives the probability for a black hole to be in an active ( type 1 agn ) state as a function of black hole mass and redshift . it is defined by the ratio of active bhmf to total bhmf , @xmath66 . the latter is directly linked to the bivariate distribution of @xmath64 and @xmath48 ( equation ( [ eq : psi_agn ] ) ) . following equation ( [ eq : psio ] ) , the multivariate probability distribution @xmath67 of galaxy property , black hole mass , eddington ratio and redshift is then given by @xmath68 where @xmath59 is the agn selection function of the respective sample . the conditional probability for the forward ml regression then follows as @xmath69 the erdf @xmath70 and the galaxy distribution function @xmath71 cancel out and are not required for the fitting . we require only knowledge of the selection function and of the mass dependence of the active fraction to obtain the intrinsic @xmath1bulge relation from the fit to the conditional probability . the free parameters @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath16 in the intrinsic relation @xmath56 are obtained by minimizing equation [ eq : sx ] . if the erdf is mass dependent it will not cancel out and knowledge of the erdf is additionally required . second , the conditional probability for the inverse ml regression is @xmath72 this is identical to the case without agn selection effects ( equation [ eq : cond_smu_int ] ) , i.e. the conditional probability @xmath73 is not affected by the agn selection . we already discussed this fact in sw11 , but we will use it here to recover the intrinsic relation by the maximum likelihood fit . the only quantity that has to be known to recover the intrinsic relation is the galaxy distribution function . both fitting options have their pros and cons . while the latter is largely unaffected by agn selection effects , it is susceptible to the shape of the galaxy distribution function and also more susceptible to the intrinsic scatter in the relation itself . the former does not require any knowledge about @xmath71 , but demands a proper understanding of the sample selection and also of the underlying distribution function of agn or at least the active fraction for the agn sample . both regression methods constitute an improvement for the determination of the intrinsic @xmath1bulge relation , compared to a standard regression that does not include knowledge of the selection function or galaxy distribution function , as we will illustrate below . in practice , the situation becomes more complicated , since black hole mass and galaxy property measurements have measurement uncertainties . virial black hole masses are associated with a non - negligible uncertainty of @xmath74 dex @xcite , while also agn host galaxy properties at high @xmath75 have significant measurement errors . these lead to second - order dependencies of the conditional probabilities . in sw11 we already studied the consequences of measurement uncertainties on the bivariate distribution and the @xmath1bulge relations . here , we discuss the ramifications of measurement uncertainties on the presented fitting approach . we assume that the black hole mass estimated by the virial method @xmath76 is drawn from a log - normal probability distribution around the true black hole mass @xmath64 , with dispersion @xmath77 , representing the uncertainty in the virial mass estimate , @xmath78 for the galaxy property @xmath48 we also assume a log - normal error distribution @xmath79 with dispersion @xmath80 . the bivariate distribution function for bulge property and virial black hole mass is then @xmath81 the bivariate distribution function is smoothed out by the measurement uncertainties . the conditional probability for the forward ml regression is @xmath82 assuming we know the measurement uncertainties @xmath77 and @xmath80 , these can be directly incorporated into the fit . however , we now introduce a dependence on the galaxy distribution @xmath71 into the forward ml regression which was canceled out before . to avoid this dependence , we can make the simplifying assumption @xmath83 . this approximation is justified for a small measurement error in @xmath48 and in particular in the flat part of the galaxy distribution function . it will break down for high stellar velocity dispersion or high stellar mass , i.e. at the exponential decline of the galaxy distribution function . it can be applied to samples dominated by lower mass galaxies . equation [ eq : condprob_agn_mus ] then simplifies to @xmath84 we will refer to both options as forward ml regression with measurement errors . the conditional probability for the inverse ml regression is given by @xmath85 for this case , the dependence of the conditional probability on the active fraction and on the selection function is not canceled out as it was the case without measurement uncertainty in @xmath64 . this effectively prevents ignoring the agn selection function for the fit of the @xmath0-bulge relations for observational samples . we can again derive an approximation to the probability distribution by making the simplifying assumptions @xmath86 and @xmath87 , for which equation ( [ eq : condprob_agn_smu ] ) reduces to @xmath88 for this approximation no knowledge of the agn selection function and the active fraction is required anymore . the assumption on the selection function depends on the details of the sample selection , but in general will be true in most cases , unless the object is close to the selection threshold ( e.g. to the flux limit of the survey ) . the assumption on the active fraction requires an active fraction with a weak or no black hole mass dependence . this is , for example , the case at @xmath2 , as discussed in section [ sec : app_z15 ] , but not in the local universe @xcite . therefore , in practice some idea about the active fraction is required in any case to judge the validity of this approximation . we will refer to these maximum likelihood fits as inverse ml regression with measurement errors . we here presented several options to fit for the underlying relation using a given sample with measurement uncertainties . which of these is the best choice for the specific sample will depend on the details of the sample selection and our knowledge of this selection function and the galaxy distribution function . formally , the most precise results are obtained using the conditional probabilities for either the forward or inverse ml regression given by equations [ eq : condprob_agn_mus ] and [ eq : condprob_agn_smu ] . this requires knowledge of the selection function , the active fraction and of the galaxy distribution function . to restrict the assumptions for the respective fit , we can also use the approximations given by equations [ eq : condprob_agn_mus_simp ] and [ eq : condprob_agn_smu_simp ] . while not precise , this approach can be justified if the selection function and/or the underlying distributions are only poorly known . to illustrate the method and test its reliability we carried out monte carlo simulations of the @xmath4 relation . for our simulations we chose as representative redshift @xmath89 . for the galaxy spheroid mass function we assume the estimate given in sw11 , which is based on the stellar mass function from @xcite , applying a rough correction for the bulge - to - total ratio to translate it into a spheroid mass function . we set up the simulations by first drawing a large number of objects from the spheroid mass function at @xmath89 . black hole masses are attributed according to the @xmath90 relation from @xcite with log - normal intrinsic scatter @xmath91 . we here assumed a constant active fraction , consistent with recent results on the active bhmf at @xmath2 ( * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * schulze et al . in prep . ) and empirical models @xcite . for the active black holes an eddington ratio was drawn from the @xmath2 erdf from @xcite . black hole mass and eddington ratio define the bolometric agn luminosity . we convert @xmath92 into @xmath93-band magnitude using the agn spectral energy distribution ( sed ) from @xcite and the @xmath94-correction from @xcite . we applied three flux limits to the simulated samples , @xmath95=20 , 22 and 24 mag , respectively , and generated samples of various sizes . for each flux limit and sample size we generated 1000 monte carlo realizations . for simplicity , we first discuss the results without measurement errors . we will discuss the effect of adding measurement errors further below . each simulation realization was fitted by a forward and an inverse ml regression . furthermore , for each regression we fitted the realizations with a different set of free parameters . we first kept all three parameters ( @xmath50 , @xmath51 , @xmath16 ) free . secondly we fixed @xmath16 and finally we also fixed @xmath51 to the input value , leaving only the normalization as free parameter . additionally , we fitted each realization with a simple linear regression , i.e. not including the selection effects , both with @xmath64 and with @xmath48 as dependent variable . in fig . [ fig : mcfit ] , we illustrate the strength of our proposed fitting approach ( shown as black histograms , left for the forward ml regression and right for the inverse ml regression ) , compared to a simple linear regression ( shown as green histograms ) . we use 1000 realizations of a sample of @xmath96 objects at @xmath89 with @xmath97 mag . while the dispersion on the fitting parameters is increased , the bias present in the simple regression approach is removed . in this example we leave all three parameters free in the fit . in fig . [ fig : statsx ] we show the median and 68% confidence limits of the 1000 realizations for a forward ml regression for different flux limits and sample sizes . the magnitude limits of @xmath98 mag correspond to bolometric luminosity limits of @xmath99 , respectively . the left panel shows that we systematically underestimate @xmath16 for a small sample size when keeping it as a free parameter . this is due to the fact that the fitting procedure determines the _ sample _ standard deviation , which is known to be an underestimate of the _ population _ standard deviation . this underestimate for small sample sizes is already present in the conventional fit without including the selection function . since the intrinsic scatter is an important parameter , when the selection effects are included this underestimate is enhanced . also the best - fitting solutions for the normalization @xmath50 and the slope @xmath51 will be biased . therefore , we suggest to fix the intrinsic scatter for small sample sizes , @xmath100 , to avoid this bias . in the following we fix the intrinsic scatter @xmath16 in the maximum likelihood fit . in this case , the slope @xmath51 and normalization @xmath50 are recovered unbiased irrespective of sample size , as shown in the other three panels of fig . [ fig : statsx ] . increasing the sample size mainly reduces the statistical errors , shown by the dashed lines . fixing also the slope and keeping the normalization as only free parameter further reduces the statistical error , while the input is recovered in the mean . we further see that the error is basically independent of the flux limit . however , this assumes perfect knowledge of the selection function and underlying distribution . deeper samples are less susceptible to uncertainties in these and therefore come closer to the statistical errors shown here . in fig . [ fig : statsy ] we show the same for the inverse ml regression . keeping the intrinsic scatter as a free parameter also leads to an underestimate for small sample sizes and we again suggest to fix it for small samples , @xmath100 , to avoid a bias in the slope and normalization . but even when fixing @xmath16 we find in our simulations a small bias in @xmath50 and @xmath51 for very small samples , @xmath101 . however , for such small samples the errors on the best fit are also large . a joint determination of slope and normalization of the relation requires a reasonably large sample . when fixing the slope @xmath51 and only determining the normalization @xmath50 , an unbiased result with small error can be achieved even for relatively small sample sizes , as demonstrated in the right panel of fig . [ fig : statsy ] . we now investigate the consequences of adding measurement errors in the virial black hole masses and in the host galaxy properties to the simulations . we here test our prescription for including these uncertainties , as presented in section [ sec : mu ] and compare them to a regression without measurement errors . we added a log - normal random error of dispersion @xmath102 dex to the black hole mass and a log - normal error of dispersion @xmath103 dex to the spheroid mass of our monte carlo realizations at @xmath89 . for each realization we fixed @xmath51 and @xmath16 and only fit for the normalization @xmath50 . we fitted these with the forward ml regression with measurement errors , i.e. using equation [ eq : condprob_agn_mus ] . the difference to the inverse ml regression with measurement errors is marginal , in particular when the errors in @xmath64 and @xmath48 are of the same magnitude . to test the importance of the full correction for measurement errors , we also fitted the same realisations with the forward and inverse ml regression without measurement errors . the results are shown in fig . [ fig : stats_error ] . we show the median ( filled symbols ) , the 68% confidence limits ( solid lines ) and also the 68% confidence limits for the realizations with zero error in @xmath64 and @xmath48 ( dashed lines ) . in the left panel the result for the forward ml regression with measurement errors is presented . the input value is recovered in the median , while the 1@xmath16 confidence region ( solid lines ) is increased by an approximately constant factor of @xmath104 for our simulation , compared to the case without measurement errors ( dashed lines ) . the fitting method provides unbiased results if selection function , underlying distributions and the value of the measurement error are all known . in the middle and right panels of fig . [ fig : stats_error ] we show the results of applying the forward ml regression and inverse ml regression without measurement errors to the simulations that have errors added . while in the forward ml regression the zero - point @xmath50 is slightly biased towards a lower value , the inverse ml regression results are fully consistent with the input value , only showing an increase in the 1@xmath16 confidence range . thus , not fully including the measurement errors has only a small , second order effect on the best - fitting solution . the monte carlo simulations verify the reliability of the presented maximum likelihood fitting approach to recover the intrinsic @xmath4 relation in the median from a sample affected by sample selection effects . a simple linear regression would provide a biased result in these cases . the method is still reliable if there are measurement uncertainties in the black hole mass and galaxy property . while the most precise results are obtained when the uncertainty is well known and taken into account , over- or underestimating or even ignoring the measurement uncertainty will only have a small effect on the recovery of the intrinsic relation . we now apply our method to a few observational studies from the literature that investigated the evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations . this is meant for illustration of the methodology and constraining power of the approach . an exhaustive investigation of the literature on evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations in consideration of selection effects is beyond the scope of this paper . we note that such an investigation would also be hampered by the fact that many previous literature studies did not use well - defined samples , or at least samples for which a selection function ( however complicated ) could be defined . first , we reinvestigated the qso sample from @xcite . they studied the @xmath4 relation for 89 broad line agn from zcosmos in the redshift range @xmath105 with estimated stellar masses for the host galaxies ( including upper limits ) . the selection function is to first order defined by an @xmath106-band flux limit of 22.5 mag . to fit their @xmath4 relation we need additional information about the underlying distribution functions . we use the same assumptions as above for the monte carlo realizations , i.e. the stellar mass function from @xcite , and a constant active fraction . to investigate the degree of evolution , we assume a redshift evolution in the zero - point @xmath107 . for the local relation we use first the relation by @xcite , with an intrinsic scatter of @xmath108 , consistent with the work by @xcite , and second the recent results by @xcite , with @xmath91 . upper limits are incorporated as described in appendix [ sec : upperlimits ] . for the forward ml regression ( using equation [ eq : condprob_agn_mus ] ) , assuming measurement errors of @xmath109 dex in the stellar mass and @xmath110 dex in the black hole mass estimates , we get @xmath111 , using the @xcite local relation . using the relation from @xcite as zero - point , we find @xmath112 ( i.e. formally a negative evolution ) . for the inverse ml regression and when using approximations for the probability distribution ( equations [ eq : condprob_agn_mus_simp ] and [ eq : condprob_agn_smu_simp ] ) we get consistent results . the null hypothesis of no evolution in the @xmath113relation for both cases lies within @xmath114 of our results , thus it is not rejected with statistical significance . the best fit relation , using the @xcite local relation , is shown in fig . [ fig : fitz_merloni10 ] . note that the given errors are statistical errors from the @xmath115 contour , while uncertainties in the assumptions for the zero - point , the flux limit and the distribution functions are not included . this implies that the uncertainty estimates above are rather optimistic , since they only include statistical uncertainties and not additional uncertainties in the underlying assumptions . the likelihood for the null hypothesis of no evolution is then even higher than the @xmath114 mentioned above when those uncertainties are also included in the confidence determination . to get an estimate for the effect of uncertainties in the underlying distribution function , we varied the assumed stellar mass function from @xcite within their quoted uncertainties . furthermore , we varied the bulge - to - total ratio between our default correction and no correction at all , to investigate the importance of the transformation of the galaxy mass function to a spheroid mass function . the uncertainty in the stellar mass function adds an uncertainty of @xmath116 to the best - fitting @xmath117 , while not applying an bulge - to - total correction increases the best - fitting solution by @xmath118 . even more important is a precise calibration of the local zero - point , as it is illustrated by the opposite trends of evolution found for the local relations by @xcite and @xcite , which is mainly caused by the increase in the zero - point of the @xmath119 relation of @xcite . while the local zero - point of the @xmath119 relation increased in the most recent revised determinations of the relation @xcite , the @xmath120 factor and thus the calibration to the agn samples is not strongly affected by this revision @xcite . using this revised @xmath119 relation significantly reduces the apparent trend of positive evolution , a fact recently noted by @xcite . combined with the correction for the bias caused by sample selection this even suggests or is at least consistent with a negative evolution of the @xmath119 relation where galaxy bulges grow first and the black holes have to catch up . in summary , we see no statistically significant evidence for evolution in the @xmath113relation based on this data set , consistent with our more qualitative analysis in sw11 . studies of the most luminous qsos , observed at high redshift found the largest apparent offsets from the @xmath1bulge relations , by a factor of 10 or more @xcite . at first glance this seems to provide the most convincing evidence for strong evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations . however , these luminous qso studies are only sampling from the bright end of the luminosity function . for this kind of objects the bias caused by selection effects is most severe , as discussed in sw11 . furthermore , current sample sizes at @xmath121 are small , inhibiting firm statistical conclusions . we now endeavor to test quantitatively if the strong apparent offset found in these studies provides any statistically significant evidence for an intrinsic offset , once we account for sample selection . we focus on the highest redshift regime currently studied @xmath3 and the constraints that can be drawn on evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations . we used the sample from @xcite , and restricted it to the six objects selected from the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xmath122 quasar survey @xcite , which approximately might be considered a well - defined sample . for this sample we assume a selection function given by the survey magnitude limit of @xmath123 mag . black hole masses are for some of the objects estimated from the broad lines and for the rest from the bolometric luminosity , assuming eddington limited accretion . bulge masses are derived from dynamical mass measurements ( we assume an average inclination angle of @xmath124 ) , and stellar velocity dispersions were estimated from the width of molecular co line emission . there are still significant systematic uncertainties associated with these measurements and how they relate to galaxy masses and velocity dispersion measured for local galaxies . however , we here only discuss the statistical aspects of the sample . the dynamical range in black hole mass and agn luminosity covered by this sample is small and there is basically no apparent correlation between @xmath0 and either @xmath29 or @xmath125 . we therefore fixed the slope and intrinsic scatter and only fit for an evolution in the normalization , again parametrized by a parameter @xmath117 . for the stellar mass function we assume the mass function for star forming galaxies at @xmath126 from @xcite . we again assume a constant active fraction . using the forward regression with measurement errors we find @xmath127 at @xmath128 confidence , with a best fit of @xmath129 for the @xmath113relation , using the local relation from @xcite . we also varied the mass function according to their uncertainties , as given in @xcite . the best - fitting @xmath130 ranges from @xmath131 to @xmath132 with an @xmath128 confidence interval @xmath133 $ ] . for the local relation from @xcite as zero - point we find a best fit of @xmath134 with @xmath135 at @xmath128 confidence . at any rate the inferred value of @xmath117 is always consistent with zero . assuming a svdf is more problematic . the svdf is well determined for @xmath136 @xcite and there are estimates out to @xmath137 @xcite , but it is observationally unconstrained at higher redshifts . on the other hand , it is not clear at all to what degree the co line width traces the stellar velocity distribution at these redshift . we here simply try to bracket our ignorance about the svdf at @xmath3 and investigate their consequences on the results for the @xmath25 relation . note that for the correction only the shape of the distribution function is important , in particular the location of the schechter function cutoff , not its normalization . we started from the evolution of the stellar mass function between @xmath136 and @xmath126 , comparing the mass functions from @xcite and @xcite . they show a decrease of the break of the mass function of @xmath138 dex . assuming virialized systems , we can convert this into a shift for the svdf . however , this also requires a parameterization of the size evolution of galaxies . at @xmath5 massive galaxies are more compact by a factor of @xmath139 , compared to local galaxies of similar mass ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? assuming similar compact galaxies at @xmath140 this approximately balances out the evolution in the mass function , i.e. no evolution in the break of the svdf would be required , consistent with observations out to @xmath89 @xcite . we use the local svdf from @xcite and converted it to a rough guess for the shape of the svdf at @xmath141 , testing two extreme evolution scenarios : ( 1 ) no effective evolution in the svdf , due to an approximate balance between mass evolution and size evolution of galaxies , ( 2 ) no size evolution , leading to a decrease in the break of the svdf , consistent with the mass function evolution . for the first case we find @xmath142 at @xmath128 confidence , with a best fit of @xmath143 , compared to the local @xmath25 relation of @xcite , while the second case gives @xmath144 at @xmath128 confidence , with a best fit of @xmath145 . in fig . [ fig : fitz_wang10 ] , we show the data and the best - fitting results for the @xmath146 and the @xmath25 relation . while the uncertainties in the parameters are large , due to both the small number statistics and the uncertainty in the underlying distributions , the results are fully consistent with no evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations . thus , even while these @xmath3 qsos show large apparent offsets from the local relation , this can not be taken as evidence for intrinsic evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations up to high @xmath75 . the apparent offset is consistent with being fully caused by agn sample selection effects . even negative evolution in the @xmath1bulge relations at @xmath3 is fully consistent with these data . besides current methodical challenges in determining black hole masses and galaxy properties at @xmath3 , the significance on the @xmath1bulge relation at high @xmath75 is currently limited by small sample sizes and their bright flux limits . ongoing and future surveys , like ukidss , pan - starrs , vista , sumire / hyper - suprime cam , lsst will significantly increase the number of known @xmath3 qsos and future sub - mm observations of their host galaxies , in particular using the atacama large millimeter / submillimetre array ( alma ) , will open a new window to the study of their host galaxies and are able to obtain dynamical masses from molecular line emission for a reasonably large sample of high-@xmath75 qsos @xcite . while we here do not aim at a full investigation of the literature on the evolution of the @xmath1bulge relation , we want to summarize the current constraints we have on evolution or non - evolution . we base this on samples that are representative for the best data at their respective redshift , in terms of depth and well defined sample selection . we include the samples from @xcite and @xcite discussed above . additionally , we augmented this by the samples from @xcite at @xmath147 and @xcite at @xmath148 . @xcite studied a sample of 32 agn at @xmath149 , selected from _ xmm_-cosmos and report basically no offset from the local relation from @xcite for their sample . using the _ xmm_-cosmos soft x - ray flux limit , the stellar mass function from @xcite , and assuming a constant active fraction , we find an insignificant bias for this sample . thus , our inferred intrinsic relation is also fully consistent with the local relation from @xcite . however , compared to the local relation from @xcite the sample is offset by @xmath150 dex . this might indicate a systematic offset in the normalization of the virial black hole mass estimates , for example due to selection effects ( sw11 ) . in the following we use the @xmath1bulge relation from @xcite as local zero - point as a conservative constraint on possible positive evolution . @xcite could resolve the host galaxies for two luminous qsos at @xmath151 , selected from the sdss , with an additional selection criteria @xmath152 mag . to account for the selection effects , we applied this absolute magnitude limit and assume the mass function for star - forming galaxies at @xmath148 from @xcite and a constant active fraction . the best - fitting result for the forward regression is @xmath153 . in fig . [ fig : bhevo_intrinsic ] we summarize our study of the _ intrinsic _ evolution in the @xmath1bulge relation for these four samples . the _ apparent _ offset from the local relation is shown by the open symbols , while our inferred _ intrinsic _ offset is given by the filled symbols . while there is an apparent evolution trend , accounting for selection effects we find an _ intrinsic _ offset that is fully consistent with a non - evolving @xmath1bulge relation out to @xmath3 . however , we note that at @xmath154 the uncertainties on the @xmath1bulge relation are still substantial and future work in particular in this redshift regime is necessary to obtain robust results . for reference we also indicate the case of @xmath155 , predicted by some numerical simulations @xcite , by the dashed dotted line in fig . [ fig : bhevo_intrinsic ] . current data are not able to robustly distinguish between a @xmath155 scenario and a non - evolving @xmath1bulge relation . while the redshift evolution of the @xmath1bulge relation provides important constraints on black hole - galaxy co - evolution , its observational study is hampered by severe selection effects . we presented a novel fitting method to the @xmath1bulge relations and their evolution . this method corrects for the bias on the @xmath1bulge relation caused by sample selection and is able to recover the intrinsic relation in the fitting . it does so by incorporating the selection function of the observational sample and the underlying distribution function into the conditional probability distribution of black hole mass at given bulge property or vice versa . this probability distribution is derived from the bivariate distribution function of @xmath0 and bulge property . the intrinsic relation is reconstructed via a maximum likelihood fit of this conditional probability distribution to the data . since we are not modeling or fitting the full bivariate distribution function but only the conditional probability distribution , we can reduce the set of prior knowledge or assumptions to correct for the selection bias , compared to our discussion in sw11 . we presented two routes to fit the conditional probability : ( 1 ) using the probability of finding @xmath0 at a given bulge property ( forward regression ) , and ( 2 ) using the probability of finding a specific value for the bulge property at a given @xmath0 ( inverse regression ) . for the first case it is essential to properly understand the selection of the sample and have a fair estimate of the black hole mass dependence of the active fraction . for the second case the bulge distribution function and the intrinsic scatter of the @xmath1bulge relation need to be known . when measurement errors on @xmath0 and the bulge property can not be ignored , all of these prior assumptions have to be known for a full correction . we extensively tested the fitting method on monte carlo simulations and verified the reliability of the approach to recover evolution in the normalization unbiased . we also illustrated the method by applying it to literature data from @xmath147 to @xmath3 . the sample of @xcite at @xmath2 already puts significant constraints on the redshift evolution of the @xmath4 relation . assuming the local relation from @xcite , we can constrain the evolution in the @xmath4 relation to @xmath156 out to redshift @xmath5 at @xmath157 confidence . this is in general agreement with our conclusions in sw11 and with recent results at lower redshifts ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? taking these empirical clues together , it becomes apparent that there is currently no evidence for significant positive evolution in the @xmath1bulge relation out to @xmath5 . either black holes and galaxies grow almost co - eval since @xmath5 , or galaxies grow faster and the black holes would have to catch up to end up at the local relation at @xmath136 . the latter is also suggested by observations of @xmath5 smgs @xcite . within @xmath158 most of the black hole growth is governed by secular processes and not by major mergers @xcite . these processes probably grow the black hole at the same rate as the spheroid component . this changes at @xmath154 , beyond the peak of agn activity , where major mergers likely become the dominating black hole growth mechanism @xcite . therefore also a change in the evolution of the @xmath4 relation could be expected at @xmath154 . currently , this redshift regime is still poorly covered by observations , and usually restricted to the most luminous , and hence most biased , qsos . we illustrated the poor constraints that can be drawn from current observations , employing a @xmath3 qso sample based on @xcite . while the sample shows a large _ apparent _ positive offset from the local relation , we find here that there is no _ intrinsic _ offset , i.e. it is fully consistent with no or even negative evolution when sample selection is taken into account . we therefore conclude that even at @xmath154 and in particular at @xmath3 we currently have no statistically significant evidence for evolution in the @xmath4 relation . we confirmed these results by additionally studying the low redshift sample from @xcite and the small @xmath148 sample from @xcite . future studies will reduce the observational uncertainties and increase the sample size and will allow a better assessment of the @xmath4 relation at these early cosmic epochs . we will discuss the requirements on the design of these future studies of the @xmath4 relation in this redshift regime in a companion paper . while selection effects severely complicate the observational study of the @xmath1bulge relation at high redshift , these can be included in the analysis as we have demonstrated here . we anticipate that the method presented here will contribute to an improved understanding of black hole - galaxy co - evolution . however , essential prerequisites are ( 1 ) the use of a well defined sample , i.e. the selection function for the sample has to be under control , and ( 2 ) knowledge of the underlying demographics of galaxies and active black holes over the black hole mass and galaxy property range covered by the observations . given the expected future increase in the size of well defined samples and a better understanding of the underlying black hole and galaxy demographics , we anticipate that we will be able to trace back the cosmic history of the @xmath1bulge relations in the future . we thank knud jahnke for fruitful discussions on this work . we also thank the anonymous referee for an efficient and constructive report that strengthened our conclusions . we acknowledge support by the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft under its priority programme spp1177 , grant wi 1369/23 . as acknowledges support by the china postdoctoral scientific foundation , grant 2012m510256 . aird , j. , coil , a. l. , moustakas , j. , et al . 2012 , apj , 746 , 90 alexander , d. m. , brandt , w. n. , smail , i. , et al . 2008 , aj , 135 , 1968 angls - alczar , d. , zel , f. , & dav , r. 2013 , apj , 770 , 5 , e. f. , mcintosh , d. h. , katz , n. , & weinberg , m. d. 2003 , apjs , 149 , 289 , v. n. , treu , t. , woo , j. , et al . 2010 , apj , 708 , 1507 bezanson , r. , van dokkum , p. g. , franx , m. , et al . 2011 , apj , 737 , l31 bongiorno , a. , merloni , a. , brusa , m. , et al . 2012 , mnras , 427 , 3103 , c. m. & schaye , j. 2011 , mnras , 413 , 1158 borys , c. , smail , i. , chapman , s. c. , et al . 2005 , apj , 635 , 853 canalizo , g. , wold , m. , hiner , k. d. , et al . 2012 , apj , 760 , 38 carrera , f. j. , page , m. j. , stevens , j. a. , et al . 2011 , mnras , 413 , 2791 chae , k .- h . 2010 , mnras , 402 , 2031 cisternas , m. , jahnke , k. , bongiorno , a. , et al . 2011 , apj , 741 , l11 cisternas , m. , jahnke , k. , inskip , k. j. , et al . 2011 , apj , 726 , 57 , d. j. 2006 , mnras , 369 , 1808 daddi , e. , renzini , a. , pirzkal , n. , et al . 2005 , apj , 626 , 680 , r. , falomo , r. , treves , a. , et al . 2010 , mnras , 402 , 2453 , t. , colberg , j. , springel , v. , hernquist , l. , & sijacki , d . 2008 , apj , 676 , 33 , t. , springel , v. , & hernquist , l. 2005 , nature , 433 , 604 draper , a. r. , & ballantyne , d. r. 2012 , apj , 751 , 72 dubois , y. , devriendt , j. , slyz , a. , & teyssier , r. 2012 , mnras , 420 , 2662 , x. , narayanan , v. k. , lupton , r. h. , et al . 2001 , aj , 122 , 2833 , x. , strauss , m. a. , richards , g. t. , et al . 2006 , aj , 131 , 1203 , x. , strauss , m. a. , schneider , d. p. , et al . 2003 , aj , 125 , 1649 , x. , white , r. l. , davis , m. , et al . 2000 , aj , 120 , 1167 , l. & merritt , d. 2000 , apj , 539 , l9 , a. , salimbeni , s. , grazian , a. , et al . 2006 , a&a , 459 , 745 , k. , bender , r. , bower , g. , et al . 2000 , apj , 539 , l13 gebhardt , k. , kormendy , j. , ho , l. c. , et al . 2000 , apj , 543 , l5 graham , a. w. , onken , c. a. , athanassoula , e. , & combes , f. 2011 , mnras , 412 , 2211 , k. , richstone , d. o. , gebhardt , k. , et al . 2009 , apj , 698 , 198 , n. & rix , h .- w . 2004 , apj , 604 , l89 hiner , k. d. , canalizo , g. , wold , m. , brotherton , m. s. , & cales , s. l. 2012 , apj , 756 , 162 , l. c. 2007 , apj , 669 , 821 , p. f. , robertson , b. , krause , e. , hernquist , l. , & cox , t. j. 2006 , apj , 652 , 107 , k. , bongiorno , a. , brusa , m. , et al . 2009 , apj , 706 , l215 , k. , elbaz , d. , pantin , e. , et al . 2009 , apj , 700 , 1820 , k. & macci , a. v. 2011 , apj , 734 , 92 , g. & haehnelt , m. 2000 , mnras , 311 , 576 kelly , b. c. , & shen , y. 2013 , apj , 764 , 45 kocevski , d. d. , faber , s. m. , mozena , m. , et al . 2012 , apj , 744 , 148 kormendy , j. , & ho , l. c. 2013 , arxiv:1304.7762 , a. , menci , n. , maiolino , r. , fiore , f. , & merloni , a. 2010 , mnras , 405 , 29 , t. r. , tremaine , s. , richstone , d. , & faber , s. m. 2007 , apj , 670 , 249 lee , k .- s . , ferguson , h. c. , wiklind , t. , et al . 2012 , apj , 752 , 66 , p. , letawe , g. , courbin , f. , et al . 2005 , nature , 437 , 381 , j. , tremaine , s. , richstone , d. , et al . 1998 , aj , 115 , 2285 maiolino , r. , neri , r. , beelen , a. , et al . 2007 , a&a , 472 , l33 , a. & hunt , l. k. 2003 , apj , 589 , l21 , a. , risaliti , g. , gilli , r. , et al . 2004 , mnras , 351 , 169 mcconnell , n. j. , & ma , c .- p . 2013 , apj , 764 , 184 , r. j. & jarvis , m. j. 2002 , mnras , 337 , 109 , r. j. , jarvis , m. j. , targett , t. a. , dunlop , j. s. , & best , p. n. 2006 , mnras , 368 , 1395 , a. , rudnick , g. , & di matteo , t. 2004 , mnras , 354 , l37 , a. , bongiorno , a. , bolzonella , m. , et al . 2010 , apj , 708 , 137 , a. & heinz , s. 2008 , mnras , 388 , 1011 , n. p. h. , de breuck , c. , lehnert , m. d. , et al . 2011 , a&a , 525 , a43 + nobuta , k. , akiyama , m. , ueda , y. , et al . 2012 , apj , 761 , 143 park , d. , kelly , b. c. , woo , j .- h . , & treu , t. 2012 , apjs , 203 , 6 , c. y. 2007 , apj , 671 , 1098 , c. y. , impey , c. d. , rix , h. , et al . 2006 , apj , 649 , 616 portinari , l. , kotilainen , j. , falomo , r. , & decarli , r. 2012 , mnras , 420 , 732 richards , g. t. , lacy , m. , storrie - lombardi , l. j. , et al . 2006 , apjs , 166 , 470 richards , g. t. , strauss , m. a. , fan , x. , et al . 2006 , aj , 131 , 2766 , d. a. , walter , f. , brewer , b. j. , et al . 2008 , apj , 686 , 851 , b. , hernquist , l. , cox , t. j. , et al . 2006 , apj , 641 , 90 , s. , shields , g. a. , gebhardt , k. , & bonning , e. w. 2007 , apj , 662 , 131 salviander , s. , & shields , g. a. 2013 , apj , 764 , 80 schawinski , k. , treister , e. , urry , c. m. , et al . 2011 , apj , 727 , l31 , m. , wisotzki , l. , & jahnke , k. 2008 , a&a , 478 , 311 schramm , m. , & silverman , j. d. 2013 , apj , 767 , 13 schulze , a. , & gebhardt , k. 2011 , apj , 729 , 21 , a. & wisotzki , l. 2010 , a&a , 516 , a87 + , a. & wisotzki , l. 2011 , a&a , 535 , a87 , f. , bernardi , m. , & haiman , z. 2009 , apj , 694 , 867 , y. & kelly , b. c. 2010 , apj , 713 , 41 , r. k. , bernardi , m. , schechter , p. l. , et al . 2003 , apj , 594 , 225 , g. a. , gebhardt , k. , salviander , s. , et al . 2003 , apj , 583 , 124 , d. , springel , v. , di matteo , t. , & hernquist , l. 2007 , mnras , 380 , 877 , j. & rees , m. j. 1998 , a&a , 331 , l1 , r. s. , hopkins , p. f. , cox , t. j. , robertson , b. e. , & hernquist , l. 2008 , mnras , 391 , 481 targett , t. a. , dunlop , j. s. , & mclure , r. j. 2012 , mnras , 420 , 3621 , s. , gebhardt , k. , bender , r. , et al . 2002 , apj , 574 , 740 trujillo , i. , conselice , c. j. , bundy , k. , et al . 2007 , mnras , 382 , 109 van dokkum , p. g. , franx , m. , kriek , m. , et al . 2008 , apj , 677 , l5 , m. & peterson , b. m. 2006 , apj , 641 , 689 volonteri , m. , & stark , d. p. 2011 , mnras , 417 , 2085 , f. , carilli , c. , bertoldi , f. , et al . 2004 , apj , 615 , l17 , r. , carilli , c. l. , neri , r. , et al . 2010 , apj , 714 , 699 wang , r. , wagg , j. , carilli , c. l. , et al . 2013 , apj , 773 , 44 willott , c. j. , omont , a. , & bergeron , j. 2013 , apj , 770 , 13 , j .- h . , treu , t. , malkan , m. a. , & blandford , r. d. 2008 , apj , 681 , 925 woo , j .- h . , schulze , a. , park , d. , et al . 2013 , apj , 772 , 49 zhang , x. , lu , y. , & yu , q. 2012 , apj , 761 , 5 for agn samples , per definition the black hole is always detected and its mass is estimated via the virial method . however , the host galaxy is not always detected , as it can be outshined by the agn . but , if at least upper limits on the host galaxy property can be set , these objects can be included in the fitting . otherwise their exclusion needs to be reflected in the selection function . we include upper limits on @xmath6 in the following manner , similar to @xcite . first , we compute the probability @xmath159 that a black hole with mass @xmath64 is located in a galaxy with their respective property greater than @xmath160 . for the forward regression without measurement errors we simply assume a uniform distribution in @xmath48 , @xmath161 for the inverse regression without measurement errors we get @xmath162 when we include measurement errors in @xmath48 and @xmath64 , the probability distribution for the forward regression is @xmath163 the likelihood for an upper limit at @xmath128 confidence level is @xmath164 where @xmath159 is one of the above conditional probabilities and @xmath165 is the probability to find the galaxy having @xmath48 greater than @xmath160 . for an upper limit at a different confidence level this probability changes accordingly .
Abstract: | [
"the redshift evolution of the black hole - bulge relations is an essential observational constraint for models of black hole - galaxy coevolution . in addition to the observational challenges for these studies , conclusions are complicated by the influence of selection effects . we demonstrate that there is presently no statistical significant evidence for cosmological evolution in the @xmath0-bulge relations , once these selection effects are taken into account and corrected for . we present a fitting method , based on the bivariate distribution of black hole mass and galaxy property , that accounts for the selection function in the fitting and is therefore able to recover the intrinsic black hole - bulge relation unbiased . while prior knowledge is restricted to a minimum , we at least require knowledge of either the sample selection function and the mass dependence of the active fraction , or the spheroid distribution function and the intrinsic scatter in the black hole - bulge relation . we employed our fitting routine to existing studies of the @xmath1bulge relation at @xmath2 and @xmath3 , using our current best knowledge of the distribution functions . there is no statistical significant evidence for positive evolution in the @xmath4 ratio out to @xmath5 . at @xmath3 the current constraints are less strong , but we demonstrate that the large observed _ apparent _ offset from the local @xmath1bulge relation at @xmath3 is fully consistent with no _ intrinsic _ offset . the method outlined here provides a tool to obtain more reliable constraints on black hole - galaxy co - evolution in the future . [ firstpage ] galaxies : active - galaxies : nuclei - quasars : general"
] | 10,842 | 10,842 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: nanotechnology , as well as biology , biophysics and chemistry are using or studying setups and objects which are smaller and smaller . in these systems , one is usually interested in mean values , but thermal fluctuations play an important role because their amplitude are often comparable to the mean values . this is for example the case for quantities such as the energy injected in the system or the energy dissipated by the system . these fluctuations can lead to unexpected and undesired effects : for instance , the instantenous energy transfer can be reversed by a large fluctuation , leading energy to flow from a cold source to a hot one . these events , although rare , are quantitatively studied by the recent fluctuations theorems ( fts ) . these theorems give fluctuation relations ( frs ) that quantify the probability of these rare events in systems which can be arbitrarily far from equilibrium . fts have been demonstrated in both deterministic systems @xcite and stochastic dynamics @xcite . experiments searching for frs have been performed in dynamical systems @xcite , but interpretations are very difficult because a quantitative comparison with theoretical prediction is impossible . other experiments have been performed in stochastic systems described by a first order langevin equation : a brownian particle in a moving optical trap @xcite and an out - of - equilibrium electrical circuit @xcite in which existing theoretical predictions @xcite were verified . interesting comments on the langevin equation can be found in @xcite . in the present article , we study a thermostated harmonic oscillator described by a second order langevin equation . we experimentally search frs for the work done by an external operator and for the heat dissipated by the system , and present analytical derivations of fts based on experimental observations . this paper is organized as follows . in section [ sec : system : description ] , we present the experimental system , write its energy balance to define the work given to the system together with the heat dissipated . we then introduce the fluctuation relations ( frs ) and the fluctuation theorems ( fts ) . in sections [ sec : tftexp ] , [ sec : ssftrampexp ] and [ sec : sinusexp ] , we present experimental results on the fluctuations of first the work and then the heat . a short discussion on experimental results in given in [ sec : expconc ] . then , in sections [ sec : worktheo ] and [ sec : heattheo ] , we present some analytical derivations of fts based on hypothesis inspired by experimental observations . we compare these analytical predictions to the experimental observations and finally conclude in section [ sec : conc ] . our system is a harmonic oscillator and we measure the non - equilibrium fluctuations of its position degree of freedom . the oscillator is damped due to the viscosity of a surrounding fluid that acts as a thermal bath at temperature @xmath0 . our oscillator , depicted in fig . [ fig : pendulum]a , is a torsion pendulum composed of a brass wire ( length @xmath1 @xmath2 , width @xmath3 @xmath2 , thickness @xmath4 @xmath5 ) and a glass mirror glued in the middle of this wire ( length @xmath6 @xmath2 , width @xmath7 @xmath2 , thickness @xmath8 @xmath2 ) . the elastic torsional stiffness of the wire is @xmath9 @xmath10 . it is enclosed in a cell filled by a water - glycerol mixture at @xmath11 concentration . the system is a harmonic oscillator with resonant frequency @xmath12 @xmath13 and a relaxation time @xmath14 @xmath15 . @xmath16 is the total moment of inertia of the displaced masses ( _ i.e. _ the mirror and the mass of displaced fluid ) @xcite . the damping has two contributions : the viscous damping @xmath17 of the surrounding fluid and the viscoelasticity of the brass wire which can be neglected here . the angular displacement of the pendulum @xmath18 is measured by a differential interferometer @xcite . the measurement noise is two orders of magnitude smaller than thermal fluctuations of the pendulum . @xmath19 is acquired with a resolution of @xmath20 bits at a sampling rate of @xmath21 @xmath13 , which is about 40 times @xmath22 . we drive the system out - of - equilibrium by forcing it with an external torque @xmath23 by means of a small electric current @xmath24 flowing in a coil glued behind the mirror ( fig . [ fig : pendulum]b ) . the coil is inside a static magnetic field . the displacements of the coil and therefore the angular displacements of the mirror are much smaller than the spatial scale of inhomogeneity of the magnetic field . so the torque is proportional to the injected current : @xmath25 ; the slope @xmath26 depends on the geometry of the system . the angular displacement @xmath18 of this harmonic oscillator is very well described by a second order langevin equation : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the thermal noise , delta - correlated in time of variance @xmath8 and @xmath29 the boltzmann constant and @xmath0 the temperature of the system which is the one of the surrounding fluid . the fluctuation dissipation theorem ( fdt ) gives a relation between the amplitude of the thermal angular fluctuations of the oscillator at equilibrium and its response function . for a harmonic oscillator , the equilibrium thermal fluctuation power spectral density ( psd ) is : @xmath30 where @xmath31 . using fdt ( eq . [ eq : fdt ] ) , we measure the coefficient @xmath26 and test the calibration accuracy of the apparatus which is better than @xmath32 . more details on the set - up can be found in @xcite . when the system is driven out of equilibrium using a deterministic torque , it receives some work and a fraction of this energy is dissipated into the heat bath . multiplying eq . ( [ eq : langevin_oscillator ] ) by @xmath33 and integrating between @xmath34 and @xmath35 , we obtain a formulation of the first law of thermodynamics between the two states at time @xmath34 and @xmath35 ( eq . ( [ eq : energy_conservation ] ) ) . the change in internal energy @xmath36 of the oscillator over a time @xmath37 , starting at a time @xmath34 , is written as : @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the work done on the system over a time @xmath37 : @xmath40 and @xmath41 is the heat given to the system . equivalently , @xmath42 is the heat dissipated by the system . @xmath36 , @xmath39 and @xmath41 are defined as energy in @xmath43 units . the internal energy is the sum of the potential energy and the kinetic energy : @xmath44^{2 } + \frac{1}{2 } c \theta(t)^2 \right\}. \label{eq : udef}\ ] ] the heat transfer @xmath41 is deduced from equation ( [ eq : energy_conservation ] ) ; it has two contributions : @xmath45^{2}{\mathrm{d}}t ' + \frac{1}{k_b \ t } \int_{t_i}^{t_i+\tau } \eta(t ' ) \frac{{\mathrm{d}}\theta}{{\mathrm{d}}t}(t ' ) { \mathrm{d}}t ' . \label{eq : qdef}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term corresponds to the opposite of viscous dissipation and is always negative , whereas the second term can be interpreted as the work of the thermal noise which have a fluctuating sign . the second law of thermodynamics imposes @xmath46 to be positive . we rescale the work @xmath39 ( the heat @xmath41 ) by the average work @xmath47 ( the average heat @xmath48 ) and define : @xmath49 ( @xmath50 ) . the brackets are ensemble averages . in the present article , @xmath51 , respectively @xmath52 , stands for either @xmath53 or @xmath54 , respectively @xmath39 or @xmath41 . there are two classes of fts . the _ stationary state fluctuation theorem _ ( ssft ) considers a non - equilibrium steady state . the _ transient fluctuation theorem _ ( tft ) describes transient non - equilibrium states where @xmath37 measures the time since the system left the equilibrium state . a fluctuation relation ( fr ) examines the symmetry of the probability density function ( pdf ) @xmath55 of a quantity @xmath51 around @xmath56 ; @xmath51 is an average value over a time @xmath37 . it compares the probability to have a positive event ( @xmath57 ) versus the probability to have a negative event ( @xmath58 ) . we quantify the fr using a function @xmath59 ( symmetry function ) : @xmath60 the _ transient fluctuation theorem _ ( tft ) states that the symmetry function is linear with @xmath51 for any values of the time integration @xmath37 and the proportionality coefficient is equal to @xmath8 for any value of @xmath37 . @xmath61 contrary to tft , the _ stationary state fluctuation theorem _ ( ssft ) holds only in the limit of infinite time ( @xmath37 ) . @xmath62 the questions we ask are whether fluctuation relations for finite time satisfy the two theorems and what are the finite time corrections . in a first time , we test the correction to the proportionality between the symmetry function @xmath63 and @xmath51 . in the region where the symmetry function is linear with @xmath51 , we define the slope @xmath64 : @xmath65 . in a second time we measure finite time corrections to the value @xmath66 which is the asymptotic value expected by the two theorems . to the applied torque @xmath67 . ] for the transient fluctuation theorem , we choose the torque @xmath67 depicted in fig . [ fig : lineartorque]a ) . it is a linear function of time : @xmath68 with @xmath69 @xmath70 and @xmath71 @xmath72 . the value of @xmath73 is chosen such that the mean response of the oscillator is of order of the thermal noise , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : lineartorque]b ) where @xmath19 is plotted during the same time interval of fig . [ fig : lineartorque]a ) . the system is at equilibrium at @xmath74 ( @xmath75 pn.m and @xmath76 pn.m @xmath77 ) . in this section the starting time @xmath34 of integration of all quantities defined before ( @xmath39 , @xmath36 and @xmath41 ) is @xmath74 . so the work is : @xmath78 @xmath79 , @xmath80 @xmath81 and @xmath82 @xmath83 plotted as a function of @xmath37 . b ) pdfs of @xmath53 for various @xmath84 : 0.31 @xmath79 , 1.015 @xmath81 , 2.09 @xmath83 and 4.97 @xmath85 . continuous lines are theoretical predictions with no adjustable parameters . c ) corresponding functions @xmath86 . the straight continuous line is a line with slope @xmath8 . d ) pdfs of @xmath80 for two values of @xmath84 : 4.97 @xmath79 and 8,96 @xmath81 . e ) corresponding pdfs of @xmath54 . continuous lines are gaussian fits . f ) corresponding functions @xmath87 . the straight continuous line is a line with slope @xmath8 . ] in fig . [ fig : tft]a ) , we represent the time average ( @xmath88 ) of the power injected into the system , the internal energy difference @xmath89 and the time average ( @xmath88 ) of the power dissipated by the system . @xmath88 and @xmath89 are linear in @xmath37 after some short relaxation time @xmath90 defined in the langevin equation : for @xmath84 smaller than @xmath8 , some oscillations around the linear behavior can be seen . the average value of work @xmath47 is therefore quadratic in @xmath37 and is equal to @xmath91 @xmath43 for @xmath92 . the difference between @xmath47 and @xmath93 corresponds to the mean value of dissipated heat @xmath46 ( eq . ( [ eq : qdef ] ) ) . as can be seen in fig.[fig : tft]a ) , @xmath94 is larger than @xmath93 for all times @xmath37 . the average of the dissipated power ( @xmath95 ) is therefore positive for all times @xmath37 as expected from the second principle . for @xmath37 larger than several @xmath90 , the dissipated power is constant and equal to a few @xmath43 per second because @xmath96 and @xmath89 have the same slope after some @xmath90 . so we have the following behavior : the work done by the external work is used by the system to increase its internal energy but a small amount of energy is lost at a constant rate by viscous dissipation and exchange with thermostat . the probability density functions ( pdfs ) @xmath97 of @xmath53 is plotted in fig . [ fig : tft]b ) for different values of @xmath84 . four typical value of @xmath37 are presented : the first is smaller than the relaxation time and the last equals five relaxation times ; the results are the same for any value of @xmath37 . the pdfs of @xmath53 are gaussian for any @xmath37 . we observe that @xmath53 takes negative values as long as @xmath37 is not too large . the probability of having negative values of @xmath53 decreases when @xmath37 is increased . from the pdfs , we compute the symmetry functions . they are plotted in fig . [ fig : tft]c ) as a function of @xmath53 . they all collapse on the same linear function of @xmath53 for any @xmath37 , which implies they all have the same slope @xmath98 . the straight line in fig [ fig : tft]c ) has slope @xmath8 . within experimental error bars , @xmath98 is equal to @xmath8 for all time @xmath37 . therefore work fluctuations for a harmonic oscillator under a linear forcing satisfy the tft . we checked that this property is true for other values of @xmath73 and @xmath99 . the pdfs of @xmath80 are plotted in fig . [ fig : tft]d ) for two values of @xmath84 : they are not symmetric and have exponential tails . the pdfs of @xmath54 can be seen in fig . [ fig : tft]e ) for the same values of @xmath84 . they are qualitatively different from the ones of the work . we have plotted in the same figure the gaussian fit of the two pdfs of the dissipated heat . it is clear that the pdfs of @xmath54 are not gaussian . extreme events of @xmath54 are distributed on exponential tails . these tails can be interpreted noticing that @xmath100 and @xmath36 have exponential tails . the variance of the pdfs of @xmath54 is also much larger than the variance of the pdfs of @xmath53 . we plot on fig . [ fig : tft]f ) symmetry functions @xmath101 for the same times @xmath84 . only the behavior of large events can be analyzed here because the variance is much larger than the mean @xmath102 . as it can be seen in fig . [ fig : tft]f , @xmath101 is not proportional to @xmath54 , therefore tfr is not satisfied for finite time . within experimental resolution , @xmath101 is constant for extreme events and equal to @xmath6 . this behavior can be interpreted by writing for large @xmath54 , @xmath103 where @xmath104 and @xmath105 are the decrease rate on the exponential tails . each coefficient depends on @xmath37 . there is a simple expression of @xmath101 for large fluctuations : @xmath106 in fig . [ fig : tft]c ) , the pdfs of @xmath54 are symmetric around the mean value for the two values of @xmath37 . it is not the case for small @xmath84 . thus we can conclude that @xmath107 and that the symmetry function is so equal to the constant : @xmath108 . as it can be seen in fig . [ fig : tft]e ) , the pdfs become more and more gaussian when @xmath37 tends to infinity . it is expected that for infinite time , the pdf of @xmath54 is a gaussian . thus , tft appears to be satisfied experimentally in the limit of infinite @xmath37 . our interesting finding is that , for @xmath41 tft if not valid for any times . we call a steady state a state in which both forcing and response to the forcing do not depend on the initial time @xmath34 , but only on @xmath37 . this implies that @xmath109 i ndependant of @xmath34 ; and so is @xmath110 . if the torque drifts along time , the mean of @xmath111 is linear with @xmath35 . thus we have to change the definition of the work done on the system to be in a steady state . this is equivalent to a galilean change of reference frame . the work is now defined as : @xmath112 \frac{\textrm d \theta}{\textrm dt}(t ' ) dt ' . \label{eq : work_ssft_def}\ ] ] with this definition , the forcing is @xmath113 and the response to the forcing @xmath114 . when we impose a forcing linear in time ( @xmath115 ) , the first condition ( @xmath116 independent of @xmath34 ) is satisfied . the second ( @xmath110 independent of @xmath34 ) is also satisfied if @xmath117 , _ i.e. _ after a transient state . thus the system is on a steady state . we remark that , in the transient state , this definition of the work reduces to the usual one , because @xmath118 @xmath70 . the average of @xmath39 is quadratic in @xmath37 for any value of @xmath84 . there are no oscillations in time for small @xmath84 . the pdfs of @xmath53 are gaussian for any value of @xmath84 ( fig . [ fig : ssftramp]a ) . probability of negative values is high and decreases with @xmath37 , like in the transient case . the symmetry functions @xmath119 are again proportional to @xmath53 ( fig . [ fig : ssftramp]b ) but the slope @xmath120 is not equal to @xmath8 for smaller @xmath37 and tends to @xmath8 for @xmath121 only , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : ssftramp]c . thus we obtain a fluctuation relation for the work done on the system in this steady state and this relation satisfy the ssft . the slope at finite time is slightly oscillating at a frequency , close to @xmath122 . for various @xmath84 : 0.019 @xmath79 , 0.31 @xmath81 , 2.09 @xmath83 and 4.97 @xmath85 . b ) corresponding functions @xmath123 . c ) the slope @xmath98 of @xmath123 is plotted versus @xmath37 ( @xmath124 : experimental values ; continuous line : theoretical prediction eq.([eq : epsilon_linear ] ) with no adjustable parameters ) . ] for various @xmath84 : 0.019 @xmath79 , 0.31 @xmath81 , 2.09 @xmath83 and 4.97 @xmath85 . b ) corresponding functions @xmath123 . c ) the slope @xmath98 of @xmath123 is plotted versus @xmath37 ( @xmath124 : experimental values ; continuous line : theoretical prediction eq.([eq : epsilon_linear ] ) with no adjustable parameters ) . ] the heat dissipated during this linear forcing has a behavior very similar to the one observed in the transient case ( section [ sec : heattft ] ) . we can so transpose here all what we said in section [ sec : heattft ] . we now consider a periodic forcing @xmath125 . this is a very common kind of forcing but it has never been studied in this context . using fourier transform , any periodical forcing can be decomposed in a sum of sinusoidal forcing . we explain here the behavior of a single mode . we choose @xmath126 @xmath70 and @xmath127 @xmath13 . this torque is plotted in fig . [ fig : sinustorque]a . the mean of the response to this torque is sinusoidal , with the same frequency , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : sinustorque]b . we studied other frequencies @xmath128 . the system is clearly in a steady state . we choose the integration time @xmath37 to be a multiple of the period of the driving ( @xmath129 with @xmath130 integer ) . the starting phase @xmath131 is averaged over all possible @xmath34 in order to increase statistics ; in the remaining of this section , we drop the brackets @xmath132 . . ] integrated over @xmath130 periods of forcing , with @xmath133 ( @xmath134 ) , @xmath135 ( @xmath124 ) , @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) and @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) . b ) the function @xmath140 measured at @xmath141 @xmath13 is plotted as a function of @xmath142 for several @xmath130 : @xmath143 ; @xmath144 @xmath145 ; @xmath146 . for these two plots , continuous lines are theoretical predictions with no adjustable paramaters ( eq . ( [ eq : ssft_sinus_mean_pdf_work ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : ssft_sinus_var_pdf_work ] ) ) . c ) the slopes @xmath147 , plotted as a function of @xmath130 for two different driving frequencies @xmath128 = 64 hz ( @xmath124 ) and 256 hz ( @xmath134 ) ; continuous lines are theoretical predictions from eq . ( [ eq : epsilon_sinus ] ) with no adjustable parameters . ] integrated over @xmath130 periods of forcing , with @xmath133 ( @xmath134 ) , @xmath135 ( @xmath124 ) , @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) and @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) . b ) the function @xmath140 measured at @xmath141 @xmath13 is plotted as a function of @xmath142 for several @xmath130 : @xmath143 ; @xmath144 @xmath145 ; @xmath146 . for these two plots , continuous lines are theoretical predictions with no adjustable paramaters ( eq . ( [ eq : ssft_sinus_mean_pdf_work ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : ssft_sinus_var_pdf_work ] ) ) . c ) the slopes @xmath147 , plotted as a function of @xmath130 for two different driving frequencies @xmath128 = 64 hz ( @xmath124 ) and 256 hz ( @xmath134 ) ; continuous lines are theoretical predictions from eq . ( [ eq : epsilon_sinus ] ) with no adjustable parameters . ] the work is written as a function of @xmath130 , the number of periods of the forcing : @xmath148 the pdfs of @xmath142 are plotted in fig . [ fig : sinuswork]a . work fluctuations are gaussian for all values of @xmath130 as in previous cases . thus symmetry functions are again linear in @xmath142 ( fig . [ fig : sinuswork]b ) . the slope @xmath147 is not equal to @xmath8 for all @xmath130 but there is a correction at finite time ( fig . [ fig : sinuswork]c ) . nevertheless , @xmath147 tends to @xmath8 for large @xmath130 , so ssft is satisfied . the convergence is very slow and we have to wait a large number of periods of forcing for the slope to be @xmath8 ( after @xmath149 periods , the slope is still @xmath150 ) . this behavior is independent of the amplitude of the forcing @xmath73 and consequently of the mean value of the work @xmath151 . the system satisfies the ssft for all forcing frequencies @xmath128 but finite time corrections depends on @xmath128 , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : sinuswork]c . ( @xmath134 ) and @xmath152 ( @xmath124 ) . in the next plots , the integration time @xmath37 is a multiple of the period of forcing , @xmath153 , with @xmath133 ( @xmath134 ) , @xmath135 ( @xmath124 ) , @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) and @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) . continuous lines are theoretical predictions with no adjustable parameters . b ) pdfs of @xmath36 . c ) pdfs of @xmath54 . d ) symmetry functions @xmath101 . e ) the slope @xmath154 of @xmath101 for @xmath155 , plotted as a function of @xmath130 ( @xmath134 ) . the slope @xmath147 of @xmath119 plotted as a function of @xmath130(@xmath124 ) . continuous line is theoretical prediction . ] ( @xmath134 ) and @xmath152 ( @xmath124 ) . in the next plots , the integration time @xmath37 is a multiple of the period of forcing , @xmath153 , with @xmath133 ( @xmath134 ) , @xmath135 ( @xmath124 ) , @xmath136 ( @xmath137 ) and @xmath138 ( @xmath139 ) . continuous lines are theoretical predictions with no adjustable parameters . b ) pdfs of @xmath36 . c ) pdfs of @xmath54 . d ) symmetry functions @xmath101 . e ) the slope @xmath154 of @xmath101 for @xmath155 , plotted as a function of @xmath130 ( @xmath134 ) . the slope @xmath147 of @xmath119 plotted as a function of @xmath130(@xmath124 ) . continuous line is theoretical prediction . ] we first do some comments on the average values . the average of @xmath36 is obviously vanishing because the time @xmath37 is a multiple of the period of the forcing . @xmath156 and @xmath157 have consequently the same behavior and they are linear in @xmath37 , as can be seen in fig . [ fig : sinusheat]a ) but the pdfs of heat fluctuations @xmath158 have exponential tails ( fig . [ fig : sinusheat]c ) . this can be understood noticing that , from eq . ( [ eq : qdef ] ) , @xmath159 and that @xmath36 has an exponential pdf independent of @xmath130 ( fig . [ fig : sinusheat]b ) . therefore , in a first approximation , the pdf of @xmath54 is a convolution between an exponential distribution ( pdf of @xmath36 ) and a gaussian distribution ( pdf of @xmath53 ) . symmetry functions @xmath160 are plotted in fig . [ fig : sinusheat]d ) for different values of @xmath130 ; three different regions appear : \(i ) for large fluctuations @xmath158 , @xmath160 equals @xmath6 . when @xmath37 tends to infinity , this region spans from @xmath161 to infinity . \(ii ) for small fluctuations @xmath158 , @xmath160 is a linear function of @xmath158 . we then define @xmath154 as the slope of the function @xmath160 , _ i.e. _ @xmath162 . this slope is plotted in fig . [ fig : sinusheat]e ) where we see that it tends to @xmath8 when @xmath37 is increased . so , ssft holds in this region ii which spans from @xmath163 up to @xmath164 for large @xmath37 . \(iii ) a smooth connection between the two behaviors . we observe that @xmath147 matches experimentally @xmath154 , for all values of @xmath130 ( fig . [ fig : sinusheat]e ) . so the finite time corrections to the ft for the heat are the same than the ones of ft for work : @xmath165 . these regions define the fluctuation relation from the heat dissipated by the oscillator . the limit for large @xmath37 of the symmetry function @xmath101 is rather delicate and we will discuss it in section [ sec : heat_sinus_theo ] . in the previous sections , we have presented experimental results on a harmonic oscillator driven out of equilibrium by an external deterministic forcing @xmath23 . we operated with two different time - prescriptions : one in which @xmath23 is a linear function of time , and one in which @xmath23 is a sinusoidal function of time . the energy injected into the system is the work @xmath166 of the torque @xmath23 . the pdfs of the work @xmath166 are gaussian whatever the time prescription of @xmath23 is , and work fluctuations satisfy a tft ( @xmath23 linear in time ) and a ssft ( @xmath23 linear or sinusoidal in time ) . the energy dissipated by the system is represented by the heat @xmath167 , and we measured it using the first principle of thermodynamics ( eq . [ eq : qdef ] ) . heat probability distributions are not gaussian and are very different from the ones of the work . they nevertheless satisfy a ssft in both the case of a sinusoidal forcing and a linear forcing . but they do not satisfy a tft in the case of a linear forcing , because the symmetry functions are not linear for all values of dissipated heat @xmath54 . in the next two sections , we use some experimental evidences to derive analytical expressions of the pdfs of work and the heat exchanged on an arbitrary time interval @xmath37 . we then derive fts together with their finite time corrections . in this section , we derive the analytical expression of the pdf of the work given to the system , and defined as the work of the torque applied to the pendulum , which is either linear or sinusoidal in time . experimentally , we observed that the pdfs are always gaussian , so we restrict our task to deriving expressions for the first two moments of the work distribution . to do so , we use experimental observations on the fluctuations of the angle @xmath18 , as described in section [ sec : exp_observations ] below . we then compute in section [ sec : pdf_w ] the mean and the variance of the work @xmath168 in the different experimental situations , and then write formally the corresponding fluctuations relations , from which we obtain analytical expressions of the finite time corrections to the fluctuation theorems . we discuss here the angular fluctuations . we decompose the angle @xmath18 into a mean value @xmath169 and a fluctuating part @xmath170 , writing @xmath171 . the mean value corresponds to an ensemble average . it is obtained experimentally by averaging over realisations of the forcing , and it is presented in fig . [ fig : lineartorque ] and [ fig : sinustorque ] . a first experimental observation is as follows . the measured mean response @xmath169 is exactly equal to the solution of the deterministic second order equation obtained when removing the noise term ( @xmath172 ) in the langevin equation ( [ eq : langevin_oscillator ] ) . we checked this from our data , and found this way a value of the calibration @xmath26 ( see section [ sec : pendulum ] ) in perfect agreement with the one obtained from the application of the fluctuation dissipation theorem . a second experimental observation concerns the probability distribution of @xmath170 in out - of - equilibrium conditions . we know and observed that at equilibrium , @xmath170 has a gaussian distribution with variance @xmath173 , and the associated momentum @xmath33 has fluctuations @xmath174 which also have a gaussian distribution , with a variance @xmath175 . we observe that the statistical properties of angular fluctuations @xmath170 when a torque @xmath67 linear in time is applied are the same as the statistical properties at equilibrium , when no torque is applied . in figure [ fig : fluct_ang_comparison]a , we plot the pdf of @xmath170 measured at @xmath176 together with the gaussian fit of the pdf at equilibrium ( continuous line ) . the two curves matches perfectly within experimental accuracy . thus we conclude that the external driving does not perturb the equilibrium distribution of angular fluctuations , so we use : @xmath177 when the torque is applied ( @xmath134 ) , compared with a gaussian fit of the pdf at equilibrium ( continuous line ) . b ) the measured spectrum of @xmath170 ( @xmath134 ) is compared with the prediction of fluctuation dissipation theorem in equilibrium ( continuous line ) . ] the third experimental observation concerns time correlations . in figure [ fig : fluct_ang_comparison]b , we plot the power spectral density function of @xmath170 when applying an external forcing ( @xmath134 ) . we compare it to the prediction of fluctuation dissipation theorem at equilibrium ( eq . [ eq : fdt ] ) computed using the oscillator parameters . the two spectra are identical , so we can confidently use for our system a description in terms of a second order langevin dynamic where the noise term is not perturbed by the presence of the driving . from the power spectral density function of @xmath18 ( eq . [ eq : fdt ] ) , we derive the autocorrelation function @xmath178 of @xmath170 during a time interval @xmath37 . it is the same at equilibrium and out of equilibrium , and decreases exponentially : @xmath179 where @xmath180 and @xmath181 is defined by @xmath182 and @xmath183 . thus we observe experimentally that when we drive the system out of equilibrum , the angular fluctuations @xmath170 are identical ( with respect to the expressions above ) to those at equilibrium . we verify the same properties for the sinusoidal time prescription of the torque , and use equilibrium expression for the correlation function in the next sections . in figs . [ fig : tft ] , [ fig : ssftramp ] and [ fig : sinuswork ] , we see that the pdfs of the work are gaussian for any integration time @xmath37 and whatever the forcing is . so these distributions are fully characterized by their mean value @xmath47 and their variance @xmath184 . the external torque @xmath23 is determistic , so the mean value of the work done on the system can be written as : @xmath185 we have defined @xmath186 . the value @xmath187 depends on the time - prescription of the torque we apply to the oscillator . choosing @xmath188 describes the linear ramp and @xmath189 corresponds to the sinusoidal forcing . the variance of the pdfs is : @xmath190 this expression involves the autocorrelation function of the angular speed @xmath174 , ( @xmath191 ) . using the expression of the autocorrelation function of angular fluctuations ( @xmath192 , eq . ( [ eq : autocorrelation ] ) ) , we can calculate exactly the expression of @xmath193 : @xmath194 we have calculated the mean value and the variance of the pdfs in the three situations of interest : stationary and transient cases with a forcing linear in time , and stationary case with a forcing sinusoidal in time . details and results can be found in the appendix . in all of the cases , we compare the theoretical pdfs and the symmetry functions with the experimental results . we have plotted in fig . [ fig : tft ] , [ fig : ssftramp ] and [ fig : sinuswork ] our theoretical pdfs and the corresponding symmetry functions with no adjustable parameters . within experimental error bars , our analytical and experimental results are in excellent agreement . @xmath119 is linear in @xmath53 because the pdfs of the work are gaussian . we now want to calculate analytically the corrections to the slope @xmath98 for finite time @xmath37 . for a gaussian distribution , the symmetry function is : @xmath195 the expression of the slope @xmath98 uses only the mean value and the variance of the gaussian distribution . we define @xmath196 , where the correction @xmath197 is a decreasing function of @xmath37 . we obtain @xmath198 for the transient case , which is in agreement with a tft . for the two steady states , there are corrections to the value @xmath8 ; we find : a. linear forcing @xmath199 . \label{eq : epsilon_linear}\ ] ] b. sinusoidal forcing @xmath200 exact values of the coefficients @xmath201 are given in the appendix . these two expressions are in perfect agreement with experimental results as can be seen in fig . [ fig : ssftramp ] and fig . [ fig : sinuswork ] . these corrections depend on the kind of forcing and it is difficult to predict their form for an arbitrary forcing . nevertheless , the two situations we consider are useful as building blocks of such an arbitrary forcing , and they provide a very nice test of our method . we now determine an analytical expression of the pdf of the dissipated heat . to do so , we make the same hypothesis as in the case of the work ( see section [ sec : exp_observations ] above ) , and we complete them by additional assumptions to simplify our derivations . we are interested by pdfs of the heat for integration time @xmath37 large compared to @xmath90 , so that exponential corrections which are scaling like @xmath202 can be neglected . in the case of sinusoidal forcing , this is correct after @xmath203 or @xmath204 periods of forcing ( @xmath205 ) . within this assumption , @xmath206 and @xmath207 are independent , and so are @xmath208 and @xmath209 . additionally , as the equation of motion of the oscillator is second order in time , @xmath18 and @xmath210 are independent at any given time @xmath211 . we use the technique proposed in @xcite . to obtain the pdf @xmath212 of the heat , we define its fourier transform , the characteristic function , as @xmath213 we then write @xmath214 using eq . ( [ eq : qdef ] ) as : @xmath215 where @xmath216 is the joint distribution of the work @xmath168 , @xmath18 and @xmath217 at the beginning and at the end of the time interval @xmath37 . this distribution is expected to be gaussian because @xmath168 is linear in @xmath33 and additionally @xmath18 , @xmath33 and @xmath168 are gaussian . the details of the calculation are given in the appendix . the fourier transform of the pdf of dissipated heat can be exactly calculated : @xmath218 \right.\right . \nonumber \\ & + \left.\left . \frac{-16\cos(\varphi)^2 + 4 + 4 i s(4\cos(\varphi)^2 + 1)}{1+s^2}\right)\right\}. \nonumber \label{eq : fourierpdfheat_linear}\end{aligned}\ ] ] as far as we know , there is no analytic expression for inverse fourier transform of this function , so for the pdf of dissipated heat . however we can do some comments . this expression is very similar to the one found in the case of a brownian particle @xcite . the factor @xmath219 is the fourier transform of an exponential pdf and this is directly connected to the exponential tails of the pdf . moreover the pdf is not symmetric around its mean , because there is a non vanishing third moment . in this expression , only two terms depend on @xmath37 . for large @xmath37 , this expression reduces to : @xmath220 this expression will turn out to be similar to the one obtain with a sinusoidal forcing , as we will comment in the next section . both expressions depend on the non - dimensional factor @xmath221 defined as : @xmath222 all moments of the distribution of @xmath223 are linear with @xmath224 and @xmath225 . so @xmath224 compares the mean value of the angular speed to the root mean square of the angular speed fluctuations . this coefficient @xmath224 increases when the system is driven further from equilibrium . we consider it as a measure of the distance to equilibrium . in our system @xmath221 is positive , but smaller than @xmath8 , so we are out - of - equilibrium but not very far from it ( @xmath226 ) . just like in the experiments , we choose the integration time @xmath37 to be a multiple of the period of the forcing , so @xmath227 and therefore @xmath228 . within this framework , we find that the pdf of @xmath229 is exponential : @xmath230 it is independant of @xmath37 because @xmath229 depends only on @xmath18 and @xmath217 at times @xmath34 and @xmath35 which are uncorrelated . this expression is in perfect agreement with the experimental pdfs for all times ( see fig . [ fig : sinusheat]b ) . some algebra then yields for the characteristic function of @xmath167 : @xmath231 the characteristic function of heat fluctuations is therefore the product of the characteristic function of an exponential distribution ( @xmath232 ) with the one of a gaussian distribution ( @xmath233 ) . thus the pdf of heat fluctuations is nothing but the convolution of a gaussian and an exponential pdf , just as if @xmath168 and @xmath229 were independent . the inverse fourier transform can be computed exactly : @xmath234 \ , , \label{eq : pdfq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath235 stands for the complementary erf function . in fig . [ fig : sinusheat]c , we have plotted the analytical pdf from eq . ( [ eq : pdfq ] ) together with the experimental ones , using values of @xmath236 and @xmath237 from the experiment and no adjustable parameters . the agreement is perfect for all values of @xmath130 , _ i.e. _ for any time @xmath37 . from eq . ( [ eq : pdfq ] ) , we isolate three different regions for @xmath87 : \(i ) if @xmath238 , then @xmath239 . this domain of @xmath240 corresponds to fluctuations larger then three times the average value . the pdf has exponential tails , corresponding to an exponential distribution with a non - vanishing mean . \(ii ) if @xmath241 , then @xmath242 with @xmath243 . in this domain , values of the heat are small and heat fluctuations behave like work fluctuations . the slope @xmath244 is the same as the one found for work fluctuations . the exact correction to the asymptotic value 1 is plotted in fig . [ fig : sinusheat]e and again it describes perfectly the experimental behavior . \(iii ) for @xmath245 , there is an intermediate region connecting domains ( i ) and ( ii ) by a second order polynomial : @xmath246 . these three domains offer a perfect description of the three regions observed experimentally ( fig . [ fig : sinusheat]d ) . now , we examine the limit of infinite @xmath37 in which ssft is supposed to hold . to do so , we distinguish two variables : the heat @xmath223 or the normalized heat @xmath247 . their asymptotic behavior are different because the average heat @xmath237 depends on @xmath37 , more precisely it is linear in @xmath37 . we discuss first @xmath223 . the asymptotic shape of the pdf of @xmath223 ( eq . ( [ eq : pdfq ] ) ) for large @xmath37 is a gaussian whose variance is @xmath236 , the variance of the pdf of @xmath168 . thus , the pdf of @xmath223 coincides with the pdf of @xmath168 for @xmath37 strictly infinite . as we have already shown , work fluctuations satisfy the conventional ssft ; therefore heat fluctuations also satisfy the conventional ssft ( eq . ( [ eq : ssft ] ) ) . we have found three different regions separated by two limit values : the mean and three times the mean . but in the limit of large times @xmath37 , the pdf shrinks and only region ( ii ) is relevant . region ( ii ) corresponds to small fluctuations and it is bounded from above by @xmath248 with the average @xmath237 being linear in @xmath37 . so all the behavior of the fluctuations of @xmath223 for large @xmath37 lays in region ( ii ) where the symetry function is linear and ssft holds . we turn now to the normalized heat @xmath247 . as the average value of @xmath223 is linear in @xmath37 , rescaling by @xmath237 is equivalent to a division by @xmath37 ; the mean of @xmath247 is then @xmath8 . this normalization makes the two limit values constant . the boundary between regions ( ii ) and ( iii ) is @xmath249 and the boundary between ( iii ) and ( i ) is @xmath250 . the function @xmath87 is not linear for large values of @xmath251 but it is linear only in region ( ii ) , for @xmath252 , _ i.e. _ for small fluctuations . so ssft is satisfied only for small fluctuations but not for all values of @xmath247 , and we obtain for @xmath247 a fluctuation relation which prescribes a symetry function that is non - linear in @xmath247 . these two different pictures , in terms of @xmath223 or @xmath247 , results from taking two non - commutative limits differently . the first description using @xmath223 implies that the limit @xmath37 infinite is taken before the limit of large @xmath223 . the second description does the opposite . however , the probability to have large fluctuations decreases with @xmath37 and experimentally , for large @xmath37 , only the region ( ii ) can be seen , and it is the region in which where ssft holds . as we have done in the case of the linear forcing , we introduce a non - dimensional factor @xmath221 such as : @xmath253 the moments of the distribution of @xmath41 are linear with @xmath224 and , like the linear torque , @xmath221 is equal to the amplitude of @xmath33 divided by @xmath254 . we consider it also as a measure of the distance to equilibrium . in our system @xmath221 is positive , but smaller than @xmath8 , so we are out - of - equilibrium but not very far it : here @xmath255 . in this paper , we have studied the fluctuations of energy input and energy dissipation in a harmonic oscillator driven out of equilibrium . this oscillator is very well described by a second order langevin equation . we have performed experiments using a torsion pendulum driven out of equilibrium following a stationary protocol in which either the torque increases linearly in time , or oscillates at a given frequency . we have also studied transient evolutions from the equilibrium state . we have defined the work given to the system as the work of the torque applied during a time @xmath37 . accordingly we have defined the heat dissipated by the pendulum during this time @xmath37 , by writing the first principle of thermodynamics between the two states separated by time @xmath37 . fluctuations relations are obtained experimentally for both the work and the heat , for the stationary and transient evolutions . we have experimentally observed that angle fluctuations of the brownian pendulum have the same statistical and dynamical properties at equilibrium and for any non - equilibrium driving . from this observation , we have derived expressions for the probability density functions of the work and the heat . in our system , fluctuations of the angle are gaussian , and so are fluctuations of the work @xmath53 . so the symmetry functions @xmath119 of the work are linear , and we have calculated exactly the time - correction to the proportionality coefficient between @xmath119 and @xmath53 . these corrections match perfectly the experimental results , both in the case of a forcing linear in time , and sinusoidal in time . we have also computed the analytic expression of the fourier transform of the pdfs of the dissipated heat . for the sinusoidal forcing , we have obtained for the first time an analytic expression of the pdf of the heat . this expression is in excellent agreement with the experimental measurements . for a torque linear in time , the pdf of the heat has no simple expression but its fourier transform gives insight on the behavior of the symmetry function of the heat . it is very similar to the one obtained in the case of a first order langevin dynamics @xcite . we emphasize here that our analytical derivations are strongly connected to experimental observations on the properties of the noise ; and are therefore different from any previous theoretical approach . we have introduced a dimensionless variable @xmath221 which we think is a measure of the distance from equilibrium : the average dissipation rate is proportional to @xmath221 , and it increases when the system is further from equilibrium . @xmath221 is also proportional to the strength of the driving and in the fluctuation relations , it gives a proper unit to measure the amplitude of fluctuations . so @xmath221 plays the same role as the dissipation coefficient ( the viscosity in our case ) in the fluctuation dissipation theorem at equilibrium . we have an expression of @xmath221 for the two different time - prescriptions we have used . these expressions can be generalized : @xmath256 the numerator corresponds to the solution of the langevin equation when removing the thermal noise term ( @xmath257 ) . the denominator corresponds to the variance of thermal fluctuations of angular speed @xmath258 . we thank g. gallavotti for useful discussions . this work has been partially supported by anr-05-blan-0105 - 01 . in this section , we will calculate the mean and the variance of the work given to the system in the cases : 1 . transient state , linear forcing 2 . steady state , linear forcing 3 . steady state , sinusoidal forcing [ tftramp]the torque is : @xmath259 . the mean value of the angular displacement is the solution of eq . [ eq : langevin_oscillator ] : @xmath260 for the work done on the system , the pdfs are gaussian for all integration time @xmath37 . the mean of the pdf of @xmath168 for a given @xmath37 is : @xmath261 \label{eq : meanworkramp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and its variance is : @xmath262 , \label{eq : varianceworkramp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath263 [ ssftramp]the torque is : @xmath259 . the mean value of the angular displacement is the solution of eq . [ eq : langevin_oscillator ] after some @xmath90 . thus the exponential term is vanished : @xmath264 for the work done on the system , the pdfs are gaussian for all integration time @xmath37 . the mean of the pdf is : @xmath265 and the variance is : @xmath266 . \label{eq : varianceworkrampstat}\end{aligned}\ ] ] from this , we deduce : @xmath267 where @xmath268 [ ssftsinus]the torque is @xmath269 . the mean value of the angular displacement is : @xmath270 where @xmath271 for the work done on the system , the pdfs are gaussian for all integration time @xmath37 . the mean of the pdf is : @xmath272 and the variance is : @xmath273 where @xmath274 @xmath275\,.\label{eq : ssft_sinus_var_pdf_work}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ appendixheat ] in this section , we will calculate the fourier transform of the pdf of the dissipated heat in two cases : 1 . linear forcing 2 . sinusoidal forcing we introduce non - dimensional parameters in order to simplify calculations : @xmath276 the mean value and the variance of @xmath277 and @xmath278 can be simply expressed : @xmath279 where @xmath221 is a non - dimensional value . integrating by part , the work @xmath168 can be rewritten : @xmath280-\frac{(d\omega_0)^2}{2}\left[(t_i+\tau)^2-t_i^2\right]+w^{*},\nonumber\\ w^ { * } & = & -(d\omega_0)\int_{t_i}^{t_i+\tau}\tilde{x}(t'){\mathrm{d}}t'.\end{aligned}\ ] ] with these definitions , we obtain : @xmath281 and @xmath282 . like the distribution of @xmath168 , the distribution of @xmath283 is gaussian for all values of @xmath37 and we find : @xmath284 for notational convenience , we introduce a five dimensional vector : @xmath285 . @xmath216 is gaussian and is so fully characterized by the covariance matrix @xmath286 defined as : @xmath287 where @xmath288 denotes the complex conjugate of @xmath289 . so the distribution @xmath216 is written : @xmath290 where @xmath291 denotes the transpose of @xmath289 . we suppose that the integration time is larger than the relaxation time . within this assumption , @xmath206 and @xmath207 are independent , and so are @xmath292 and @xmath293 . as the equation of motion of the oscillator is second order in time , @xmath18 and @xmath33 are independent at any given times @xmath211 . with these hypotheses , we get : @xmath294 the other coefficients of the covariance matrix are : @xmath295 the fourier transform of the pdf of the heat will be calculated here . we define two quantities : @xmath296 one can write @xmath223 as : @xmath297 . the fourier transform can be so written : @xmath298 we use a new variable defined as : @xmath299 with this definition , the argument in the exponential @xmath23 can be rewritten : @xmath300.\end{aligned}\ ] ] changing the integration variable to @xmath301 yields : @xmath302 to make eq . [ eq : gen_heat_lin_exp ] into an explicit expression for @xmath303 , the inverse of matrix @xmath304 is required in the expression for @xmath305 and its determinant . these are obtained as follows . we find : @xmath306 the determinant of the matrix is @xmath307 . for the inverse of this matrix , we get : @xmath308 we now have the material needed to calculate @xmath305 . we find : @xmath309.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the analytic expression of the fourier transform of the pdf of the heat dissipated during a linear forcing is : @xmath310 \right.\right . \nonumber \\ & + \left.\left . \frac{-16\cos(\varphi)^2 + 4 + 4 i \,s(4\cos(\varphi)^2 + 1)}{1+s^2}\right)\right\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ ap : sinus_heat ] we will determine in a first time the gaussian joint distribution @xmath216 of @xmath168 , @xmath207 , @xmath206 , @xmath293 and @xmath292 . for notational convenience , we introduce a five dimensional vector : @xmath311 . the pdf @xmath216 is fully characterized by the covariance matrix @xmath286 . @xmath312 where @xmath313 denotes the complex conjugate of @xmath289 . we suppose that the integration time is larger than the relaxation time . within this assumption , @xmath206 and @xmath207 are independent , and so are @xmath292 and @xmath293 . as the equation of motion of the oscillator is second order in time , @xmath18 and @xmath33 are independent at any given times @xmath211 . with these hypotheses , we get : @xmath314 the covariance matrix is so a diagonal matrix : @xmath315 @xmath36 is a function of the positions and velocities at the beginning ( @xmath34 ) and at the end ( @xmath35 ) . thus , @xmath36 and @xmath39 can be considered as independent . the pdf of @xmath41 is so the convolution between the pdf of @xmath39 which is gaussian and the pdf of @xmath36 : @xmath316 we first calculate exactly the pdf of the variation of internal energy . we have shown that @xmath207 , @xmath206 , @xmath293 and @xmath292 are independent . the fourier transform of the pdf is : @xmath317 where @xmath318 and @xmath319 . the distribution of @xmath18 is gaussian with variance @xmath320 . the distribution of @xmath321 and the distribution of @xmath322 are the same : @xmath323 the fourier transform of this distribution is : @xmath324 . this distribution is the same for @xmath321 and @xmath322 at @xmath34 and @xmath35 . thus the fourier transform of the variation of internal energy is @xmath325 and the probability is : @xmath326 as @xmath36 and @xmath39 are independent , the fourier transform of the dissipated heat can be calculated : @xmath327 this expression can be inversed because it is simply the convolution between a gaussian distribution and an exponential distribution . so we find eq . ( [ eq : pdfq ] ) . 0 d. j. evans and d. j. searles , _ phys . e _ * 50 * , 1645 ( 1994 ) . d. j. evans , d. j. searles , _ advances in physics _ * 51 * ( 7 ) 1529 ( 2002 ) . d. j. evans , d. j. searles and l. rondoni , _ phys . e _ * 71 * ( 5 ) 056120 ( 2005 ) . r. van zon , s. ciliberto , e. g. d. cohen , _ phys . lett . _ * 92 * ( 13 ) 130601 ( 2004 ) . r. van zon and e. g. d. cohen , _ phys . * 91 * ( 11 ) 110601 ( 2003 ) ; _ phys . e _ * 67 * 046102 ( 2003 ) ; _ phys . * 69 * 056121 ( 2004 ) . g. m. wang , e. m. sevick , e. mittag , d. j. searles , d. j. evans , _ phys . rev . lett . _ * 89 * 050601 ( 2002 ) ; g. m. wang , j. c. reid , d. m. carberry , d. r. m. williams , e. m. sevick , d. j. evans , _ phys . e _ * 71 * 046142 ( 2005 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we study experimentally the thermal fluctuations of energy input and dissipation in a harmonic oscillator driven out of equilibrium , and search for fluctuation relations . we study transient evolution from the equilibrium state , together with non equilibrium steady states . fluctuations relations are obtained experimentally for both the work and the heat , for the stationary and transient evolutions . a stationary state fluctuation theorem is verified for the two time prescriptions of the torque . but a transient fluctuation theorem is satisfied for the work given to the system but not for the heat dissipated by the system in the case of linear forcing . experimental observations on the statistical and dynamical properties of the fluctuation of the angle , we derive analytical expressions for the probability density function of the work and the heat . we obtain for the first time an analytic expression of the probability density function of the heat . agreement between experiments and our modeling is excellent ."
] | 9,429 | 9,429 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the essential point of stochastic resonance @xcite is the following : if a stochastic resonator is subjected to an external influence , commonly referred to as the signal , its response exhibits signal features , which are most pronounced at a certain level of noise present in the system . the fascinating aspect of stochastic resonance is therefore that , counter - intuitively , an increasing noise level does not steadily deteriorate the transmission of the signal through the resonator . on the contrary , noise may rather be used to optimise the transmission process @xcite . the implications of these effects are intensively investigated . in biological systems , for example , stochastic resonance apparently plays a role in the neural transmission of information @xcite . from a technical point of view one might possibly see the emergence of a novel type of detector which incorporates an optimal amount of noise to perform best . in this regard superconducting quantum interference devices ( squids ) have been studied @xcite . they may be made to detect weak magnetic fields reasonably well without the usual costly shielding from environmental noise . in recent years it was shown that the performance of a single stochastic resonator can be enhanced , if it is embedded into an ensemble of other stochastic resonators which are properly coupled @xcite@xcite@xcite@xcite@xcite : compared to being operated isolated the response of the resonator to the signal increases within the coupled ensemble . however , if the coupling becomes too strong this response was found to deteriorate again . thus in an ensemble of stochastic resonators the coupling strength turns out to be a second design parameter : apart from the noise level it can be tuned to achieve an optimal performance of the embedded resonator . this effect was called _ array - enhanced stochastic resonance _ @xcite . it will possibly find technical exploitation and might also be relevant to biological systems , for example , coupled neurons . the aim of the present paper is a further investigation of the phenomena related to array - enhanced stochastic resonance . to this end we study a simple prototype system of coupled two - state stochastic resonators under periodic modulation . the model we propose allows to analytically calculate the weak - signal limits of two prominent stochastic - resonance quantities , spectral power amplification ( spa ) and signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) , respectively . following the concept of array - enhanced stochastic resonance both quantities refer to the response of a resonator as part of the coupled ensemble . the impact of the coupling on both response measures will be studied . there is a close link of the present analysis to the work presented in @xcite and @xcite , which to our knowledge are the most comprehensive in the field . however , compared to @xcite , where the spa of a system of globally coupled bistable elements was studied analytically , too , the present approach offers a more refined description , since it allows to avoid a mean - field approximation . compared to @xcite , on the other hand , where the snr of a chain of locally coupled elements was investigated in a ( rather extensive ) simulation , the snr can now be obtained analytically . for a quick review of the results the reader is referred to the 3rd and 4th passage of the summary section . from a conceptual point of view the model proposed here can be seen as an extension of the two - state model developed by mcnamara and wiesenfeld @xcite to study stochastic resonance in noisy bistable systems . instead of considering individual two - state elements as in @xcite these elements are now arranged in a chain . a simple next - neighbour interaction is introduced which brings the model close to the system studied in @xcite . the interaction is chosen in a way that the resulting evolution of the elements is given by glauber s stochastic ising model @xcite . a detailed description of this approach is given in the next section which also provides the necessary background . we note that the connection to the glauber model is made for mathematical convenience . we are not concerned with the observation of stochastic resonance in ising systems which was the central theme in @xcite and @xcite . our purpose will also lead to the assumption of arrhenius - type transition rates of uncoupled unmodulated elements which is unusual in the context of ising systems . first results of the present analysis had been published in @xcite . a further interesting approach to arrays of stochastic resonators is c entered around a response of a more collective nature . here stochastic resonance is studied in the summed output of @xmath0 resonators which need not necessarily be coupled @xcite@xcite@xcite . recently , it was shown analytically that the snr of this output approaches the input snr , if a sufficiently large number of uncoupled resonators is used @xcite . whether in some way coupling may still be beneficial for the collective response of the present model will be the subject of a future study . only the summed output of a very large number of resonators shall be briefly discussed here . it will be shown that in this case the snr always deteriorates under coupling . this indicates that the coupling - induced improvement of the performance of stochastic resonators associated with array - enhanced stochastic resonance is a local rather than a global effect . an early theory of stochastic resonance in noisy bistable systems with one ( generally continuous ) variable was worked out by mcnamara and wiesenfeld @xcite . they studied the effect of a periodic modulation of these systems in a way which is independent of the precise dynamics involved . to this end the behaviour of the bistable system was approximated by a random telegraph process . for simplicity this process was taken to be symmetric , randomly switching between two states @xmath1 . for convenience we shall consider here @xmath2 . the probabilities @xmath3 to find the process in state @xmath4 satisfy @xmath5 and their time - evolution is governed by @xmath6 where @xmath7 denotes the rate of the transition @xmath8 . these rates must be extracted from the precise dynamics at hand . to build a theory of stochastic resonance they were assumed to be approximately given by @xcite @xmath9\ ] ] with @xmath10 being the small parameter of the theory . obviously , at this level the periodic modulation of the bistable system with ( angular ) frequency @xmath11 and phase @xmath12 is taken into account by the cosine term , only . this simple model allows to calculate the long - time limit of the power spectrum of the random telegraph process averaged over a uniformly distributed phase @xmath12 . the spectrum consists of a continuous part and a delta function at modulation frequency @xmath11 . the continuous part of the spectrum is the lorentzian of the unperturbed process times a frequency - dependent prefactor . the latter is close to 1 and governs the modulation - induced transfer of broad - band power to the delta peak in the spectrum . from this spectrum mcnamara and wiesenfeld obtained their central theoretical result with respect to stochastic resonance : an exact analytical expression for the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) of the two - state process . this snr is defined as the ratio of the weight of the delta function to the continuous part of the spectrum at modulation frequency . in view of the present work we shall neglect the signal - induced suppression of the continuous part of the spectrum and consider the linear response approximation of the mcnamara - wiesenfeld result with respect to the small parameter @xmath10 . doing so one finds for the snr @xmath13 if the approximation ( [ mwrate ] ) is performed on a particular noisy bistable system subject to a periodic modulation , the parameters @xmath14 and @xmath10 become functions of noise strength and modulation amplitude , respectively . the dependence of the snr on the noise intensity can then be studied and the occurrence of stochastic resonance may be established for that particular system . as an example the overdamped double - well system was given in @xcite . the model equation reads @xmath15 where @xmath16 is gaussian white noise with @xmath17 and @xmath18 . using a modified kramers formula for the transition rates valid for sufficiently low modulation frequencies mcnamara and wiesenfeld found @xmath19 { } \delta = \frac{a}{d}.\ ] ] the central idea of the present work is to pass from the single bistable element to a set of coupled bistable elements by extending the two - state model of mcnamara and wiesenfeld . to this end we consider a chain of two - state elements which for convenience is taken to be of infinite length . if the elements interact the simple gain - loss balance ( [ mwmaster ] ) has to be modified to describe the evolution of the set of probabilities @xmath20 to find the chain in a particular configuration @xmath21 at time @xmath22 . introducing a formal operator @xmath23 defined for any function @xmath24 by @xmath25 the new gain - loss balance reads @xmath26 with the initial condition @xmath27 the @xmath20 are interpreted as the transition probabilities @xmath28 of a markovian process with infinitely many discrete components . the statistics of the process is fully determined by ( [ master ] ) . to introduce interactions we assume that the transition rates ( [ mwrate ] ) of an element depend on the states of its next neighbours . a simple choice for this coupling controlled by a parameter @xmath29 is @xmath30,\ ] ] where @xmath31 is the mcnamara - wiesenfeld rate ( [ mwrate ] ) . with positive @xmath29 neighbouring elements prefer to be in the same state , whereas they tend to be in opposite states , if @xmath29 is negative . both tendencies grow with growing coupling strength @xmath32 . to avoid negative transition rates @xmath33 has to be required . we note that the assumed type of coupling is thus able to model ferromagnetic - type interactions for which a coupling - induced improvement of the performance of stochastic resonators was found in @xcite and @xcite . for positive @xmath29 the present model is particularly close to the model simulated in @xcite , since both are linear arrays of next - neighbour - coupled elements . for convenience we shall often use the terms ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic coupling instead of coupling with positive or negative @xmath29 . of course , other types of transition rates ( [ transrate ] ) could be considered as well . the advantage of the present choice is that most of the relevant stochastic properties of the resulting model are already known . they were studied by glauber who introduced this model as a stochastic form of the ising model @xcite . ( we note that in the glauber model the term @xmath34 in ( [ transrate ] ) is replaced by a general time - dependent parameter @xmath35 . ) as in the mcnamara - wiesenfeld model it is again possible to find an analytical expression for the snr in leading order of the modulation parameter @xmath10 which is the subject of the next section . the respective analysis is essentially an exploitation of glauber s work . it may be possible to reduce the dynamics of some coupled systems to the two - state model given by ( [ master ] ) and ( [ transrate ] ) and hence to directly employ the snr formula derived in the next section however , this approach is certainly more involved than the rate expansion ( [ mwrate ] ) needed to make use of the mcnamara - wiesenfeld snr . we shall not pursue this more general aspect of the model in further detail . instead we are interested in devising a simple prototype system which allows to study the impact of the coupling on the stochastic - resonance effect . to this end we are looking for simple assumptions on the dependence of the model parameter @xmath14 , @xmath29 , and @xmath10 on some noise intensity and signal amplitude , respectively . we proceed in two steps : first , we retain the glauber s original relation of the present model to the ising model given by the hamiltonian @xmath36 this relation is defined by an assumption on the probability @xmath37 to find the @xmath38-th element in state @xmath39 , if all other elements are fixed : in an adiabatic limit the @xmath37 of both models are to be identical . this implies that @xmath40 holds which allows to establish a relation between the parameters of both models . one finds @xmath41 and @xmath42 , respectively @xcite . the role of the noise intensity is thus played by the temperature @xmath43 . to skip unnecessary parameters we set @xmath44 and @xmath45 . in the present paper we assume that @xmath46 , which shall be referred to as the signal , is given by @xmath47 for weak amplitudes @xmath48 this results in @xmath49 . ( in section [ srsnr ] we shall also consider periodic signals ( [ forcing ] ) with an additional noisy background . ) second , a plausible assumption has to be made on the temperature dependence of the time - scale parameter @xmath50 which is not effected by requiring ( [ detailedbal ] ) . it is assumed that it retains the qualitative dependence ( [ mwparam ] ) found by mcnamara and wiesenfeld for the double - well system , i.e. , @xmath51 with properly scaled temperature @xmath43 . this dependence is typical for many rate processes . an appropriate temperature dependence of @xmath14 is also necessary to turn the elements into stochastic resonators for vanishing coupling . for simplicity @xmath52 is considered . the prototype system we are looking for is thus specified by ( [ master ] ) and ( [ transrate ] ) together with @xmath53 { } \gamma = \tanh \left(\frac{2j}{t } \right ) , \makebox[0.3 cm ] { } \delta = \frac{h_0}{t}.\ ] ] we emphasise that this system is not an approximation of the ising system ( [ hamiltonian ] ) in the same way as the double - well system ( [ doublewell ] ) is approximated by ( [ mwmaster]),([mwrate ] ) , and ( [ mwparam ] ) , respectively : the ising system and the stochastic glauber model are based on totally different dynamical concepts . nevertheless the devised prototype system appears to capture in a simple way the essence of the effect of coupling and forcing on coupled continuous - variable systems like the double well . to motivate this , let @xmath54 denote the height of the barrier to be surmounted in order to escape from state @xmath4 . in a very simple approximation the effect of next - neighbour coupling and forcing on the barrier height could be modelled as @xmath55 @xmath56 comparing this to ( [ hamiltonian ] ) one finds that within this simple picture the effect of coupling and forcing on the barrier heights is the same as their effect on the energy levels of the ising model . ( we note that for coupled double - well systems the chosen approximation would only hold for weak coupling . for strong coupling the systems may no longer be bistable and the entire concept of a simple - minded two - state approximation breaks down . ) within an adiabatic limit and with some noise strength @xmath43 the transition rate @xmath57 of the barrier system would roughly read @xmath58 from here rates of the form ( [ transrate ] ) together with parameters ( [ params ] ) can be obtained in two steps . first , the factor related to @xmath59 is kept as the parameter @xmath14 with a respective choice of @xmath59 . second , the factor related to @xmath60 , which describes the effect of forcing and coupling , is replaced by the respective term of ( [ transrate ] ) , which is easier to handle . a connection between both types of rates is again made by requiring that they lead to identical stationary distributions in the sense of ( [ detailedbal ] ) . a particular close relation between the glauber - dynamics model and the barrier system should thus arise within the regime of quasistatic response . nevertheless we shall not restrict the following investigation of the simple prototype system to the quasistatic regime . whether or not the suggested model provides insights which are also relevant to more realistic settings and possibly helpful in the design of coupled stochastic resonators remains to be seen . the aim of this section is to calculate the snr of the response of a two - state element embedded into the chain of coupled elements given by ( [ master ] ) and ( [ transrate ] ) . this calculation will be done in terms of the parameters @xmath14 , @xmath29 , and @xmath10 and is essentially based on glauber s work . we shall only take account of terms in leading order of the modulation amplitude @xmath10 . the resulting snr will then be an extension of the simplified mcnamara - wiesenfeld result ( [ mwsnr ] ) . at the end of the section the general result will be applied to the prototype system specified by ( [ params ] ) . in addition to the snr we shall also give an analytical expression for the so - called spectral power amplification ( spa ) . following glauber we start by calculating the averages @xmath61 . from ( [ master ] ) one derives @xmath62 . it results in @xmath63 \nonumber \\ & & + \left[1 - \frac{\gamma}{2 } ( r_{k-1,k } + r_{k , k+1})\right ] \delta \cos ( \omega t + \phi)\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath64 . a closed set of equations for the @xmath65 is found by linearising ( [ mean ] ) in @xmath10 . in this case the @xmath66 can be taken from the unperturbed model ( @xmath67 ) . after long times these @xmath66 read @xmath68 with @xmath69 @xcite . the resulting long - time - limit set of equations can be further simplified . since all elements are forced uniformly , a particular element can not be distinguished from any other , once the initial distribution has been forgotten . hence , all elements will have identical statistics and the indices in ( [ mean ] ) can be skipped . together with the previous assumption one obtains @xmath70 obviously , the long - time dynamics of the average @xmath71 is identical to the long - time dynamics of the average of an uncoupled element with rescaled relaxation rate @xmath72 and rescaled modulation term @xmath73 . the resulting long - time limit of the averaged state simply reads @xmath74 @xmath75 { } \tan \psi = - \frac{\omega}{\alpha(1-\gamma)},\ ] ] where @xmath76 is the response to static signals @xmath77 : @xmath78 formally this static response might even exceed @xmath79 . we conclude that in this case @xmath10 is not sufficiently small and the linearisation of ( [ mean ] ) is no longer justified . later on it will be shown that this does not amount to a considerable restriction . the power spectrum of an element is determined from the average @xmath80 . like in @xcite its @xmath22-dependence is removed by averaging @xmath81 over an uniformly distributed initial phase @xmath12 of the modulation term in ( [ transrate ] ) . introducing the correlation function @xmath82 [ \sigma_k(t+\tau)-\langle \sigma_k(t+\tau ) \rangle ] \rangle $ ] one finds @xmath83 the second term on the r.h.s . contributes a delta function with weight @xmath84 at signal frequency @xmath11 to the ( one - sided ) power spectrum as defined below . the first term , on the other hand , forms the continuous part of the spectrum . for the purpose of calculating the snr in leading order of the modulation amplitude @xmath10 it is sufficient to approximate this continuous part by the power spectrum of the unperturbed model . this implies that we neglect any possible signal - induced transformation of the continuous part of the spectrum as we did to obtain the simplified mcnamara - wiesenfeld result ( [ mwsnr ] ) . for the unperturbed model the long - time correlation function @xmath85 is not effected by the average @xmath81 . it also no longer depends on the index of the element . according to glauber @xmath85 reads @xmath86 with modified bessel functions @xmath87 . using the relation @xcite @xmath88 which holds for @xmath89 and @xmath90 the power spectrum @xmath91 is calculated . for the one - sided spectrum defined by @xmath92 at @xmath93 we eventually obtain @xmath94 with @xmath95 and @xmath96 . now the snr of the response of a two - state element embedded into the chain can be calculated , which is the central result of this section . it reads @xmath97 for vanishing coupling it reduces to the simplified mcnamara - wiesenfeld result ( [ mwsnr ] ) . in addition to the effect of the coupling on the snr we also wish to study its impact on the delta peak in the power spectrum . in this regard the spectral power amplification ( spa ) is a convenient measure ( cf . e.g. jung in @xcite ) . it is defined as the ratio of power contained in the signal peaks of output to input spectrum , i.e. , the ratio of the weights of the respective delta functions . because of its dependence on the input spectrum the spa depends on the precise dynamics to be modelled by the two - state chain . for the prototype system specified by ( [ params ] ) the spa reads @xmath98 , or explicitly @xmath99 @xmath100 where @xmath101 is the spa of static signals . obviously , the spa does no longer depend on the signal amplitude @xmath102 . for convenience we also remove the @xmath102-dependence of the snr by considering @xmath103 for the prototype system the parameter @xmath104 involved in the unperturbed spectrum ( [ spectrum ] ) simplifies to @xmath105 @xcite . both quantities , spa ( [ spa ] ) and rescaled snr ( [ snr ] ) , only depend on three parameters : temperature @xmath43 , coupling strength @xmath106 , and signal frequency @xmath11 . restrictions arise from @xmath48 , which lead to a simple expression for @xmath10 , as well as from the linearisation of ( [ mean ] ) , which results in an upper bound on @xmath10 as discussed in connection with ( [ meanstatic ] ) . together one finds @xmath107 it implies that finite @xmath102 place a lower bound on @xmath43 and an upper bound on @xmath106 . however , these restrictions are rather weak : @xmath102 can be made arbitrarily small because its size is immaterial within the present weak - signal approximation . we are now in a position to study the impact of the coupling on the response measures spa and snr of a single resonator embedded into the chain . this will be the subject of the following two sections . the spa ( [ spa ] ) has an unique maximum over temperature @xmath43 and coupling parameter @xmath106 for any time - dependent signal ( [ forcing ] ) . the maximum spa is obtained for a frequency - dependent value @xmath108 which is always positive . in other words : a properly tuned ferromagnetic - type coupling yields the best spa performance of the two - state resonator element which is embedded into the chain . for our simple model this maximum can be studied analytically . the partial derivatives of the spa with respect to @xmath43 and @xmath106 are found to vanish at pairs @xmath109 given by @xmath110 and @xmath111 respectively . for @xmath108 to be real and finite , @xmath112 has to hold . with this restriction ( [ simple2 ] ) has a unique solution @xmath113 for any given @xmath114 . the corresponding @xmath108 is found via ( [ simple ] ) . within the given range of @xmath115 one can easily check on ( [ simple ] ) that @xmath108 is indeed always positive . an inspection of the second derivatives of the spa finally reveals that there is a maximum at @xmath109 . its peak value is implicitly given by @xmath116 from ( [ simple ] ) , ( [ simple2 ] ) , and ( [ spamax ] ) the following features of the maximum can be derived which are shown in fig.1 : tuning the signal frequency @xmath11 from very large to vanishing small values the temperature @xmath115 falls from @xmath117 to @xmath118 . at the same time , the coupling strength @xmath108 as well as the peak height @xmath119 increase from vanishing small to very large values . in addition , an analysis of the curvatures @xmath120 and @xmath121 , both expressed in terms of @xmath115 , shows that the sharpness of the maximum grows as its height increases . this indicates that to achieve optimal performance the system parameters @xmath43 and @xmath106 have to be tuned with increasing accuracy as the signal frequency decreases . fig.1 also includes a comparison to the spa of an uncoupled element . at given @xmath114 this spa has a maximum located at a temperature @xmath122 , implicitly given by @xmath123 on the interval @xmath124 , whereby its peak value is found to be @xmath125 . it can be shown from ( [ simple2 ] ) and ( [ simple3 ] ) that @xmath115 always exceeds @xmath122 . the fact that @xmath108 was found to be never zero also implies that @xmath119 always exceeds @xmath126 . however , looking at fig.1 it is obvious that at frequencies @xmath127 both compared quantities of the coupled element approach those of the uncoupled one and @xmath108 approaches zero . the coupling - induced increase in the spa is thus vanishingly small at sufficiently high frequencies of the signal . this comparison allows to distinguish between two different types of spa behaviour : at low frequencies the spa is enhanced under ferromagnetic coupling whereas at high frequencies it is basicly not , although a tiny increase still occurs . both situations are illustrated at selected frequencies in fig.2 and fig.3 , respectively . the low frequency spa exactly reproduces the qualitative effect found analytically by jung et al . @xcite in a system of globally interacting elements . the high frequency behaviour , on the other hand , where the spa does practically not increase under coupling , has to our knowledge not been reported before . in both cases fig.2 and fig.3 clearly demonstrate that at fixed coupling parameter @xmath106 stochastic resonance occurs : the spa has a maximum over temperature @xmath43 which , unfortunately , can not be established analytically . fig.2(bottom ) shows that while ferromagnetic coupling improves the spa at any fixed temperature @xmath43 this improvement is lost , if the coupling becomes too strong . there is thus an optimal coupling strength @xmath128 for every given temperature , which can even be exactly calculated at any @xmath114 . one finds @xmath129 which is always positive . since the spa does not have a further extremum over @xmath106 , it implies that antiferromagnetic coupling always decreases the spa . moreover , @xmath128 increases with growing temperature t and decreases as the signal frequency grows . in fig.2 the spa at the optimal coupling strength is included ( dash - dotted curves ) . in fig.3(bottom ) , where the high - frequency spa is illustrated , the coupling - induced improvement of the spa is hardly detectable and @xmath128 is almost zero . considering the spa of time - independent signals ( @xmath130 ) given by ( [ spa_static ] ) one finds that it has a maximum over temperature for antiferromagnetic coupling @xmath131 , only , whereby it decreases as the coupling strength @xmath132 grows . for @xmath133 the spa increases with increasing @xmath106 as well as with decreasing @xmath43 . it formally diverges for @xmath134 and @xmath135 , respectively . in both cases the weak - signal limit ( [ range ] ) breaks down . in general , the spa ( [ spa ] ) is given by its static value ( [ spa_static ] ) times a dynamical factor @xmath136 ( cf.([meanresult ] ) ) . here @xmath137 is the ratio @xmath138 of signal frequency to long - time relaxation rate , which also governs the phase shift @xmath139 in ( [ meanresult ] ) . with growing @xmath137 the elements gradually loose their ability to follow the signal : the spa weakens and the phase shift grows . this effect occurs , for example , if the signal frequency @xmath11 increases . subsequently , the spa decreases with growing @xmath11 . the impact of @xmath137 is also responsible for the occurrence of stochastic resonance and optimal coupling in the spa . here a decrease of the long - time relaxation rate @xmath72 plays the crucial role : the elements dynamics slows down as @xmath106 increases or as @xmath43 decreases . thus this slow - down occurs whenever the static spa grows . hence , the dynamical factor always counteracts the static spa as @xmath43 or @xmath106 is changed . eventually , the increase of the monotonous static spa is outperformed by the decrease of the dynamical factor which results into a maximum of the spa over @xmath43 and @xmath106 , respectively . in other words , stochastic resonance and optimal coupling occur . as illustrated in fig.2 the spa can be seen as a transition between two limits , the static spa given by @xmath140 ( @xmath141 , dashed curves ) and @xmath142 ( @xmath143 , dotted curves ) , respectively . since both limits intersect at @xmath144 , i.e. at @xmath145 , the plots nicely show the well - known approximate matching of time scales at the spa peak . this matching does not only occur over @xmath43 ( fig.2 , top ) , but over @xmath106 ( fig.2 , bottom ) , too . if the signal frequency is changed , the peaks of the spa shift whereby all curves share the static spa as a limit . this results into the qualitative frequency dependence found by mcnamara and wiesenfeld for the delta function part of the spectrum of the double - well system ( [ doublewell ] ) . roughly speaking , an improvement of the spa under ferromagnetic coupling only occurs at @xmath146 , where the impact of the static spa is not yet outperformed by the dynamical factor . this explains why there is no improvement at signal frequencies @xmath147 : since under ferromagnetic coupling @xmath148 holds , @xmath146 can not be fulfilled in this case . at @xmath149 ( fig.3 ) the spa is already within line width of the limit @xmath150 , where the impact of the dynamical factor prevails . this limit is basicly given by the modulation term in ( [ simplemean ] ) . its non - monotonous temperature dependence is known to be no longer associated with a matching of time scales @xcite . the static response , which is thus the origin of the coupling - induced enhancement of the spa , can be interpreted as follows . without coupling and for a given fixed signal the two - state elements prefer to be in the state of lowest energy ( [ hamiltonian ] ) or highest barrier ( [ deltau ] ) , respectively . since the signal is homogeneous , this state is the same for all elements . without a signal but under ferromagnetic coupling neighbouring elements tend to be in the same state , too , although they do not favour a particular state @xmath151 or @xmath152 . taking now signal and coupling together , both effects add up . the tendency to find the elements in the state favoured by the signal grows and hence @xmath76 and the static spa grow compared to the uncoupled case . with antiferromagnetic coupling , on the other hand , neighbouring elements prefer to be in opposite states . this counteracts the effect of the signal and leads to a decrease in the spa . finally , the decrease of the static spa with growing temperature directly follows from ( [ detailedbal ] ) . there the imbalance in the distribution of probability between the two states , which dependent on the view taken either differ in energy or barrier height , decreases as the system heats up : the mean response @xmath76 weakens due to increasing fluctuations . the investigation of the snr presented here basicly relies on numerical evaluations of ( [ snr ] ) . an explicit calculation of the power spectrum ( [ spectrum ] ) already yields a rather complicated expression which does not lend itself to a detailed analytical study . at finite signal frequencies @xmath114 the snr displays the same qualitative dependence on temperature @xmath43 and coupling parameter @xmath106 as shown for the spa in fig.2 and fig.3 , respectively . at low frequencies the snr is enhanced under ferromagnetic coupling whereas at high frequencies it is not . due to this close similarity we omitted the respective plots for the snr . we note , however , that this similarity is by no means a trivial result , since the spectrum ( [ spectrum ] ) is itself a non - monotonous function of @xmath43 and @xmath106 . the low - frequency snr qualitatively reproduces the snr behaviour found in a chain of next - neighbour - coupled overdamped double - well systems simulated in @xcite . it is the first analytical confirmation of this behaviour . we note that this correspondence occurs although the simulation in @xcite was performed with strong forcing while the present model is studied within a weak - signal limit . as for the spa , the high - frequency behaviour of the snr has to our knowledge not been reported before . if the elements are not coupled , their snr ( [ mwsnr ] ) does not depend on the signal frequency . this was already found in @xcite , if the signal - induced reduction of the continuous part of the spectrum is neglected , as ( [ mwsnr ] ) clearly shows . under coupling this frequency independence of the snr for ferromagnetic coupling numerical evaluations of ( [ snr ] ) predict a decrease of the snr with growing signal frequency . only in the limit of low and high frequencies the snr approaches constant values . in both cases the snr formula ( [ snr ] ) simplifies significantly . one finds @xmath153 @xmath154 where @xmath155 is the simplified mcnamara - wiesenfeld snr ( [ mwsnr ] ) of uncoupled elements . @xmath156 is the static snr while @xmath157 represents the leading order term of its high - frequency expansion . fig.4 illustrates the typical qualitative behaviour of the snr as a function of the signal frequency . at various frequencies it shows a set of snr curves over temperature @xmath43 and coupling parameter @xmath106 , respectively . the dashed curves represent @xmath156 and @xmath157 , respectively . the apparent fact that the snr decreases with growing signal frequency implies that its static value can not be exceeded at any other signal frequency . then it follows immediately from ( [ snrlim1 ] ) that the coupling - induced enhancement of the snr possesses an upper limit : it can not be better than a factor four . this is a rigorous result for the general chain model and not limited to the prototype system , where a special choice of the parameters was made . due to the simplicity of the chain model this result may well reflect a limit of more general nature for the improvement of a weak - signal snr . fig.5 shows the static snr over temperature @xmath43 . it differs qualitatively from the static spa which according to ( [ spa_static ] ) has a monotonous behaviour . turning briefly to antiferromagnetic coupling one finds that the continuous part of the spectrum is insensitive to the sign of the coupling parameter @xmath106 . now even the static snr decreases under coupling . as shown in fig.4(bottom ) it is found below the high - frequency snr curve , i.e. , here the snr increases with growing signal frequency . since at medium frequencies again a transition occurs between both curves similar to the transition in fig.4(top ) , a second maximum in the snr over @xmath43 may emerge in this situation . the investigation of the impact of the coupling on the snr can also be extended to the more natural situation , where the signal itself is embedded into noise . the question to address is , whether the improvement of the snr , which was established for independent internal noise sources , can still be found with additional coherent external noise . ( this problem does not occur for the spa , where only the height of the signal peak is of interest . ) to study this case it is assumed that the input spectrum consists of the previous signal peak described by @xmath158 and a noise part @xmath159 . within the weak - signal limit it was shown that the signal peak of the input spectrum leads to a respective peak in the output spectrum at signal frequency , only : no additional peaks at multiples of that frequency occur . therefore , any additional contribution to the continuous part of the output spectrum at signal frequency can only arise from @xmath160 . in analogy to ( [ meanresult ] ) one finds that this additional contribution is given by @xmath161 . together with ( [ snr ] ) the resulting snr @xmath162 reads , again in units of @xmath163 , @xmath164 it can be expressed in terms of the snr @xmath165 ( cf.([snr ] ) ) and the input snr @xmath166 written in units of @xmath163 , respectively . one finds @xmath167 @xmath162 is thus a steadily growing function of the previously studied snr @xmath165 , whereby it can not exceed the input snr @xmath168 . ( the latter is a meanwhile well - known result of linear response theory @xcite which is in fact the limit we are taking here . ) since @xmath168 is constant at fixed signal frequency @xmath11 , a coupling - induced increase of @xmath165 will lead to an increase in @xmath162 , too . the improvement of the snr under coupling is thus preserved with external coherent noise . from ( [ noisysnr2 ] ) one can easily show that the maximum enhancement of @xmath162 compared to the uncoupled chain reaches the previously found factor four for vanishing input noise , only . in general , this factor is smaller approaching 1 , if the input noise is so strong that the input snr and hence @xmath162 go to zero . at the end we shall make a brief excursion to the collective response of the chain , which was mentioned in the introduction . we consider the following sum which involves the states of @xmath0 elements : @xmath169 it is not difficult to show that the spa of this new quantity is simply @xmath170 times the previously studied spa ( [ spa ] ) . for the snr , however , this new situation is completely different . previously the continuous part of the spectrum was determined from the auto - correlation function @xmath171 of an element alone ( cf . ( [ correl1 ] ) ) . now this spectrum will involve cross - correlation contributions @xmath172 of different elements @xmath173 , too . the new contributions to the continuous part of the spectrum change the qualitative behaviour of the snr under coupling . we shall demonstrate this in the limit @xmath174 . for this case glauber calculated the unperturbed spectrum @xcite which reads in its one - sided version @xmath175 inserting this spectrum into ( [ snr ] ) , multiplied by @xmath170 due to the mentioned increase of the spa , one finds for the new snr per element @xmath176 which , of course , again reduces to the simplified mcnamara - wiesenfeld snr ( [ mwsnr ] ) for vanishing coupling . clearly , the snr is now a decreasing function of the coupling parameter and the sign of the latter is no longer important . hence , there is a drastic difference in the snr of single and collective response with respect to coupling . of course , we have so far merely investigated the limits of ( [ global0 ] ) , @xmath177 and @xmath174 , respectively . we expect that the snr of the collective response of only a few elements still increases under coupling @xcite . a detailed analysis of the present model with respect to these collective effects will be the subject of a further investigation . in this paper we extended the two - state model of stochastic resonance introduced by mcnamara and wiesenfeld to a chain of infinitely many coupled two - state elements which are periodically modulated . the interaction of the elements was chosen in a way that the chain evolves according to glauber s stochastic ising model . in analogy to the work of mcnamara and wiesenfeld and based glauber s results analytical expressions for the signal - to - noise ratio ( snr ) and the spectral power amplification ( spa ) have been obtained in the limit of weak modulations . here both quantities refer to the response of a single element as part of the chain . instead of approximating the dynamics of a particular coupled system by the chain model , we used the latter to build a prototype system which hopefully captures the essential features of an entire class of coupled stochastic resonators . to this end additional assumptions were made on the dependence of the model parameters on some noise intensity and signal amplitude , respectively . the prototype system was used to study the effect of the coupling on the response of a single resonator embedded into the chain . the results show that array - enhanced stochastic resonance occurs for ferromagnetic - type coupling in spa and snr . the qualitative features of the effects reproduce those previously found in coupled stochastic resonators . the simplicity of the chain model allowed for a detailed analytical investigation of the spa . for the snr the observed effects have been confirmed analytically for the first time . in addition , it was found that the improvement of the single - resonator response compared to the response of the uncoupled resonator still occurs , if the signal is embedded into noise . for the snr this improvement was shown to be limited by a factor four which is reached for vanishing input noise , only . a brief excursion into the collective response of @xmath0 resonators , on the other hand , disclosed that coupling can not improve the snr , if @xmath0 is very large . a closer look at the mechanisms behind the effects revealed that in the present model an improvement of the stochastic resonators under coupling is associated with the regime of quasistatic response . since the model studied here possesses an upper bound to the time scale of its dynamics , the desired improvement is essentially restricted to sufficiently slow signals . for the spa this improvement is based on a stronger tendency of the two - state elements to align in parallel , if signal and ferromagnetic coupling act together , compared to this tendency caused by the signal alone . the reason why the improvement of the spa is lost , if the coupling is too strong , was found to be the slow - down of the system dynamics under coupling : it simply prevents the resonators from responding quasistatically . for review - type articles on stochastic resonance see , e.g. : + p. jung , phys . * 234 * , 175 ( 1993 ) . + f. moss , d. pierson , d. ogorman , int . 4*(6 ) , 1383 ( 1994 ) . + k. wiesenfeld , f. moss , nature * 373 * , 33 ( 1995 ) . + a. bulsara and l. gammaitoni , physics today , march 1996 , 39 ( 1996 ) . + l. gammaitoni , p. hnggi , p. jung , and f. marchesoni , rev . * 70 * , 223 ( 1998 ) + a bibliography on stochastic resonance can be found at http://www.pg.infn.it / sr/. j. k. douglas , l. wilkens , e. pantazelou , and f. moss , nature * 365 * , 337 ( 1993 ) . + s. m. besrukov and i. vodyanoy , nature * 378 * , 362 ( 1995 ) . + j. e. levin and j. p. miller , nature * 380 * , 165 ( 1996 ) . + p. cordo , j. t. ingils , s. verschueren , j. j. collins , d. m. merfeld , s. rosenblum , s. buckley , and f. moss , nature * 383 * , 769 ( 1996 ) . + j. j. collins , t. t. imhoff , and p. grigg nature * 383 * , 770 ( 1996 ) . r. rouse , siyuan han , and j. e. lukens , appl . phys . lett . * 66 * , 108 ( 1995 ) . + a. d. hibbs , a. l. singsaas , e. w. jacobs , a. r. bulsara , j. j. bekkedahl , and f. moss , j. appl . * 77 * , 2582 ( 1995 ) . + a. d. hibbs and b. r. whitecotton , in _ applied nonlinear dynamics and stochastic systems near the millennium _ , ed . by j. b. kadtke and a. bulsara , ajp conference proceedings , vol . 411 , p.227 ( aip , woodbury , new york , 1997 ) . a. bulsara , g. schmera , phys . rev . * e47 * , 3734 ( 1993 ) . + a. bulsara , a. maren , and g. schmera , biol . cybern . * 70 * , 145 ( 1993 ) . + m. e. inchiosa , a. r. bulsara : phys . lett . * a200 * , 283 ( 1995 ) and phys . rev . * e52 * , 327 ( 1995 ) .
Abstract: | [
"the two - state model of stochastic resonance is extended to a chain of coupled two - state elements governed by the dynamics of glauber s stochastic ising model . appropriate assumptions on the model parameters turn the chain into a prototype system of coupled stochastic resonators . in a weak - signal limit analytical expressions are derived for the spectral power amplification and the signal - to - noise ratio of a two - state element embedded into the chain . the effect of the coupling between the elements on both quantities is analysed and array - enhanced stochastic resonance is established for pure as well as noisy periodic signals . the coupling - induced improvement of the snr compared to an uncoupled element is shown to be limited by a factor four which is only reached for vanishing input noise ."
] | 7,992 | 7,992 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: understanding the physics of spacetime singularities is a challenge for any complete theory of quantum gravity . it has been shown that string theory resolves certain seeming singularities , such as orbifolds @xcite , flops @xcite , and conifolds @xcite , in the sense that their physics is completely nonsingular . on the other hand , it has also been argued that certain singularities should not be resolved , but rather must be disallowed configurations in particular , negative mass schwarzschild , which would correspond to an instability of the vacuum @xcite . also , in the study of perturbations of the ads / cft duality various singular spacetimes have been encountered , and at least some of these must be unphysical in the same sense as negative mass schwarzschild . a more general understanding of singularities in string theory is thus an important goal . in this paper we study a naked singularity of a particular type @xcite , which has been dubbed the _ repulson_. a variety of brane configurations in string theory appear to give rise to such a singularity . however , we will argue that this is not the case . rather , as the name might suggest , the constituent branes effectively repel one another ( in spite of supersymmetry ) , forming in the end a nonsingular shell . our interest in this singularity arose from a search for new examples of gauge / gravity duality . in particular , the brane configurations that give rise to the repulson singularity have on their world - volumes pure @xmath3 , @xmath4 gauge theory ( or the equivalent in other dimensions ) , as opposed to the usual pure @xmath3 , @xmath5 , or @xmath3 , @xmath4 with hypermultiplets . we do not precisely find such a duality , in the sense of using supergravity to calculate properties of the strongly coupled gauge theory , but we do find a striking parallel between the moduli space of the large-@xmath0 @xmath6 gauge theory and the fate that we have deduced for the singularity . we also find some clues which allow us to guess at aspects of a possible dual . in section 2 we describe the repulson singularity and the various brane configurations where it arises . in section 3 we deduce the specific physical mechanism by which it is removed . in section 4 we relate this to behavior of yang mills theory with eight supersymmetries . we do not find a duality , in the sense of being able to use supergravity to calculate in the strongly coupled gauge theory , but we find a striking parallel between the physical picture deduced in section 3 and the large-@xmath0 seiberg witten theory . we point out some features suggestive of a dual theory , and remark upon the case of finite temperature . in section 5 we develop two of the dual versions , in terms of bent ns5-branes , and wrapped / fractional d - branes . section 6 offers brief conclusions , and suggestions for future directions . let us consider first the oft - discussed d1d5 system , @xmath7 here @xmath8 run over the 05-directions tangent to all the branes , @xmath9 runs over the 1234-directions transverse to all branes , and @xmath10 runs over the 6789-directions of a @xmath11 , tangent to the d5-branes and transverse to the d1-branes . we have defined @xmath12 with @xmath13 and @xmath14 the volume of the @xmath11 . this configuration leaves 8 unbroken supersymmetries , all of which transform as @xmath15 under the @xmath16 that acts on @xmath17 . at the horizon , @xmath18 , the geometry approaches ads@xmath19 , giving rise to an ads / cft duality @xcite . the tension of the effective string in 6 dimensions is @xmath20 with @xmath21 and @xmath22 . now imagine taking @xmath23 , but keeping the _ same _ unbroken supersymmetry . this is not the same as replacing the d1-branes with anti - d1-branes , which would leave unbroken @xmath24 supersymmetries instead . rather , the solution ( [ 15sol ] ) is simply continued to @xmath23 , so that @xmath25 . this radically changes the geometry : the radius @xmath26 is now a naked singularity @xcite , and the region @xmath27 is unphysical . also , the tension ( [ tension ] ) can vanish and apparently even become negative . in spite of these odd properties , the case @xmath23 can be realized physically . to do this , replace the @xmath11 with a k3 , with @xmath28 d5-branes wrapped on the k3 . then as shown in ref . @xcite , the coupling of the d5-brane to the curvature induces a d1-brane charge @xmath29 . for @xmath30 sufficiently large the solution ( [ 15sol ] ) with @xmath29 ( and with @xmath31 replaced by the metric of a k3 of volume @xmath14 ) would be expected to be a good description of the geometry . the low energy theory on the branes is pure supersymmetric yang mills with eight supersymmetries @xcite , in @xmath32 dimensions . one can understand this from the general result that the number of hypermultiplets minus vector multiplets is @xmath33 , from 1 - 5 strings . continuing to @xmath29 gives @xmath34 , corresponding to the @xmath35 adjoint without hypermultiplets . , we can also study the case of @xmath6 with @xmath36 fundamental flavours . it is amusing to note that the case @xmath37 corresponds to @xmath38 , which means that @xmath39 and the supergravity solution simplifies greatly . this is pertinent for the four - dimensional case which is superconformal . ] by dualities one can find many other brane configurations with singularities of the same sort , and with the same low energy gauge theory in @xmath40 dimensions . our interest in this solution arose from the search for supergravity duals to these gauge theories , and we will return to this point in section 4 . by @xmath41-dualities on the noncompact directions one obtains solutions with d@xmath42 and d@xmath43 charge , for @xmath42 = 0 , 1 , 2 , and 3 . by @xmath41-dualities on the whole k3 one can replace the d@xmath43-branes wrapped on the k3 with d@xmath44-branes wrapped on a nontrivial @xmath45 with self - intersection number @xmath46 . this latter realization can also be obtained as follows . consider @xmath0 d3-branes at a @xmath47 orbifold singularity @xcite . the low energy gauge theory is @xmath48 with hypermultiplets in the @xmath49 . by going along the coulomb branch in the direction diag@xmath50 one gives masses to all the @xmath51 hypermultiplets . this corresponds to separating the branes along the singularity into two clumps of @xmath0 half - branes , which are secretly @xcite d5-branes wrapped on the collapsed @xmath45 ( the half d3-brane charge comes from the @xmath52 @xmath53-field at the orbifold point ) . wrapped d5-branes plus @xmath0 d3-branes , producing gauge group @xmath54 with bifundamental hypermultiplets . the focus of these papers is @xmath55 , whereas ours is the opposite limit @xmath56 . ] a @xmath41-duality on this brane - wrapped ale space results in another dual realization , this time involving a pair of ns5-branes with @xmath0 d@xmath57-branes stretched between them @xcite . finally , by an @xmath58-duality the @xmath59 case can be related to the heterotic string on @xmath11 , with @xmath0 bps winding strings having @xmath60 . these are the strings which become massless non - abelian gauge bosons at special points in moduli space , a fact that will play an important role in the next section . similarly , the @xmath61 case @xmath58-dualizes @xcite to a combination of the kaluza klein monopole and the h - monopole @xcite which is equivalent @xcite to the @xmath62 magnetic black hole in four dimensions . in this heterotic form , these solutions have previously been considered in refs . @xcite . the nature of the singularity was studied in ref . it was shown that massive particles coupled to the einstein metric feel an infinite repulsive potential at the singularity , hence the name _ repulson_. if instead one takes as probes the same kind of d5-brane as forms the geometry , then by the usual supersymmetry argument the potential should vanish . hence there should be no obstruction to building this geometry from a collection of such d5-branes . however , we will find in the next section that this argument fails for a reason specific to the repulson geometry , so that in fact the geometry is smoothed out in a certain way , and the singularity removed . for @xmath23 the gauge theory has no higgs branch ( which would correspond to one or more bound states ) , and so for @xmath63 infrared fluctuations might prevent the existence of a stable object . for this reason we will focus on the d2-d6 example in this section , @xmath64 now @xmath8 run over the 045-directions tangent to all the branes , @xmath9 runs over the 123-directions transverse to all branes , @xmath65 is the metric of a k3 surface of unit volume , and @xmath66 we have inserted @xmath67 . the bps bound for general charges is @xmath68 with @xmath69 and @xmath70 . a d6-brane probe ( wrapped on the k3 ) has a well - defined moduli space . to understand better the physics of the repulson geometry , consider the effective action of such a probe , @xmath71 here @xmath72 is the projection of the world - volume onto the six noncompact dimensions and @xmath73 is the induced metric . we have written this down on physical grounds . the first term is the dirac action with the position - dependence of the tension ( [ tension2 ] ) taken into account ; in particular , @xmath74 . the second and third terms are the couplings of the probe charges @xmath75 to the background . note that to derive this action from the full d6-brane action requires two curvature - squared terms . one appears in the wz action and accounts for the induced d2 charge @xcite . the other appears in the dirac action and produces the @xmath76 term in the tension @xcite . expanding the action ( [ probe ] ) in powers of the transverse velocity gives the lagrangian density @xmath77 the position - dependent potential terms cancel as expected for a supersymmetric system , leaving the constant potential @xmath78 and a nontrivial metric on moduli space as expected with eight supersymmetries . the metric is proportional to @xmath79 we assume that @xmath80 , so that the metric at infinity ( and the membrane tension ) are positive . however , as @xmath81 decreases the metric eventually becomes negative , and this occurs at a radius @xmath82 which is strictly greater than the radius @xmath83 of the repulson singularity . to understand what is happening , note that this kinetic term comes entirely from the dirac term in the action ( [ probe ] ) , and that what is vanishing is the factor @xmath84 in the probe tension . this occurs when @xmath85 , and so before the singularity ( where @xmath86 goes to 0 ) . the negative tension at @xmath87 is clearly unphysical . to see how we should interpret it , recall that the probe is dual to a heterotic winding string , and the vanishing of the tension corresponds to the vanishing of the winding string mass at a point of enhanced gauge symmetry . it is well - known that the latter can be interpreted as the ordinary higgs mechanism . in the higgs mechanism the mass is related to the expectation value by @xmath88 note the absolute value . therefore we should take ( minus ) the absolute value in the first term of the action ( [ probe ] ) and ( [ lag ] ) . now the metric is positive but another problem appears : the potential no longer cancels , but rises as @xmath81 decreases below @xmath89 . this means that we can not move the probe to @xmath90 in a supersymmetric way , and so contradicts the assumption that we can build the repulson geometry by bringing together a succession of wrapped d6-branes . thus we are led to a very different picture : the @xmath0 d6-branes all live on the sphere at @xmath91 . even if we try to build the geometry by starting with coincident d6-branes at @xmath92 , where @xmath93 , and then increasing the coupling , we would expect the system to expand as @xmath94 is increased . we will see an interesting parallel to this behavior in the gauge theory discussion of the next section . with this picture , the geometry ( [ 26sol ] ) is correct only down to @xmath95 . since the sources are all at this radius , the geometry should be flat in the interior @xmath96 : in the interior by continuity of the metric . c. vafa suggests that there may be an ` overshoot , ' by analogy with ref . @xmath97^{-1/2 } \eta_{\mu\nu } dx^\mu dx^\nu + [ z_2(r_{\rm e } ) z_6(r_{\rm e})]^{1/2 } dx^i dx^i + v_*^{1/2 } ds^2_{\rm k3 } \ , \nonumber \\ e^{2\phi } { \hspace{-6pt}&=&\hspace{-6pt } } g^2 { z_2(r_{\rm e})}/ { z_6(r_{\rm e})}\ , \nonumber\\ c_{\it 3 } { \hspace{-6pt}&=&\hspace{-6pt } } c_{\it 7 } = 0 \ . \label{26flat}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the non - zero potential that appeared in the proof - by - contradiction is not a real feature , because the geometry ( [ 26sol ] ) is no longer relevant for @xmath90 . indeed , it is difficult to see how such a potential could be consistent with supersymmetry . now , however , we seem to have another contradiction . there seems to be no obstacle to the probe moving into the flat region ( [ 26flat ] ) , contradicting the conclusion that the d6-branes are fixed at @xmath89 . to see the obstacle we must look more deeply . note that in the interior region the k3 volume takes the constant value @xmath98 , meaning that the probe is a tensionless membrane . a tensionless membrane sounds even more exotic than a tensionless string , but in fact ( as in other examples ) it is actually prosaic : it is best interpreted as a composite in an effective field theory . note that the ratios @xmath99 are equal . this means that a wrapped d4-brane is a massless particle whenever the wrapped d6-brane is tensionless . in fact , it is a non - abelian gauge boson , which together with an r r vector and a wrapped anti - d4-brane form an enhanced @xmath100 gauge symmetry . that is , in the interior geometry there is an unbroken @xmath100 gauge symmetry in six dimensions . for this reason we refer to this as the enhanon geometry , and the radius @xmath101 as the enhanon radius . now , a two - dimensional object in six dimensions would be obtained by lifting a point object in four , and so a magnetic monopole naturally suggests itself . indeed , the wrapped d4-brane is a source of a 2-form r r field strength in six dimensions , and the wrapped d6-brane is the source of the dual 4-form field strength . the mass of a monopole is proportional to the mass of the corresponding @xmath102 boson , so they vanish together when @xmath103 . since the size of the monopole is inverse to the mass of the @xmath102 boson , there is no sense in which a probe can be localized within the enhanon radius . for this same reason the probe begins to expand as it approaches @xmath89 , so it appears that it will essentially melt smoothly into the shell of @xmath0 monopoles at @xmath89 . this has the effect that junction between the exterior geometry ( [ 26sol ] ) and the interior geometry ( [ 26flat ] ) is smoothed . we can estimate this smoothing effect as follows . the mass of a wrapped d - brane is @xmath104 . the probe will cease to be effectively pointlike when @xmath105 leading to @xmath106 thus we have a consistent picture in which the repulson is replaced by a smooth geometry . the same principle holds for other values of @xmath42 . the enhanon locus is @xmath107 , whose interior is @xmath108-dimensional . for even @xmath42 the theory in the interior has an @xmath100 gauge symmetry , while for odd @xmath42 there is an @xmath109 ( 2,0 ) theory . this is consistent with the fact that a k3 with volume @xmath98 is @xmath41-dual to a k3 at an @xmath109 singularity . the details of the smoothing depend on @xmath42 , and for @xmath110 it is likely that the ir fluctuations must be considered . note that our result for the lagrangian density ( [ lag ] ) depends only on three moduli space coordinates , @xmath111 , or @xmath112 in polar coordinates . for a ( 2 + 1)-dimensional theory with eight supercharges , the moduli space metric must be hyperkhler @xcite . a minimum requirement for this is of course that it has four coordinates , and so we must find an extra modulus . on the probe , there is an extra @xmath113 gauge potential @xmath114 , corresponding to the overall centre of mass degree of freedom . we may exchange this for a scalar @xmath115 by hodge duality in the ( 2 + 1)-dimensional world - volume . this is of course a feature specific to the @xmath116 case . to get the coupling for this extra modulus correct , we should augment the probe computation of the previous section to include @xmath114 . the dirac action is modified by an extra term in the determinant : @xmath117 where @xmath118 is the field strength of @xmath114 . furthermore , in the presence of @xmath118 , there is a coupling @xmath119 where @xmath120 is the magnetic potential produced by the d6-brane charge : @xmath121 . adapting the procedures of refs . @xcite , we can introduce an auxiliary vector field @xmath122 , replacing @xmath123 by @xmath124 in the dirac action , and adding the term @xmath125 overall . treating @xmath122 as a lagrange multiplier , the path integral over @xmath122 will give the action involving @xmath126 as before . alternatively , we may treat @xmath118 as a lagrange multiplier , and integrating it out enforces @xmath127 here , @xmath128 are the components of the pullback of @xmath129 to the probe s world - volume . the solution to the constraint above is @xmath130 where the scalar @xmath115 is our fourth modulus . we may now replace @xmath122 by @xmath131 in the action , and the static gauge computation gives for the kinetic term : @xmath132 where @xmath133 and @xmath134 one of the goals of this work is to obtain a useful dual description of the physics of strongly coupled @xmath6 gauge theory ( with eight supercharges and no hypermultiplets ) at large-@xmath0 . this is a necessarily complex undertaking , as there are at least four different theories which play important roles here , and so in the spirit of ref . @xcite , we should carefully determine where each theory has a weakly coupled description , as we change the energy scale . to get to the limit where we obtain the decoupled gauge theory we hold fixed the induced @xmath42-dimensional gauge coupling @xmath135 and , as usual @xcite , hold fixed @xmath136 . let us also define the @xmath57-dimensional t hooft coupling @xmath137 where @xmath0 is the number of d@xmath43-branes wrapped on the k3 . we write the k3 volume as @xmath138 ; the background has a good limit if we hold this fixed as well . then the string metric becomes , in the decoupling limit , @xmath139^{-1/2 } r^{-2}\eta_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu \\\vspace{5pt } & \ ! + \left[\left(1-h_p(u)\right)/h_p(u)\right]^{1/2 } ( 2\pi)^2 ds^2_{\rm k3 } \\ & \ ! + \left[h_p(u)\left(1-h_p(u)\right)\right]^{1/2 } r^2\left(du^2+u^2d\omega_{4-p}^2\right ) \ , . \label{scaledmetric } \end{array}\ ] ] we have abbreviated @xmath140 as @xmath141 , and @xmath142 the dilaton becomes @xmath143 note that the ` 1 ' has scaled out of @xmath144 but not @xmath145 . the case of @xmath146 needs to be discussed separately . the spacetime solution is @xmath147 where @xmath148 . this is sensible only for @xmath149 . at @xmath150 , the inner radius , @xmath151 vanishes : this is the repulson , which is again unphysical , lying inside the enhanon . at @xmath152 , the outer radius , @xmath153 vanishes and the dilaton diverges . near this radius there is a story similar to that at the inner radius : nonperturbative corrections remove the singularity . for @xmath154 , this is understood in terms of ( choke ) f - theory @xcite . for @xmath155 , as here , the details are not so well understood , but should not be relevant to the physics in the enhanon region . returning to @xmath156 , can work out where the supergravity description ( [ scaledmetric],[dilp ] ) is good by demanding @xcite that the curvature in string units and the dilaton both be small . for the curvature , we find @xmath157 where the functions @xmath158 are @xmath159 for all @xmath160 . the first thing we notice about the curvature is its value at the enhanon radius : @xmath161 the control parameter @xmath162 will determine the nature of the phase diagram . the physical interpretation of @xmath163 is the value of the dimensionless t hooft coupling of the @xmath57-dimensional gauge theory at the energy scale @xmath164 , which is an effective uv cutoff . below this scale , since the physics is superrenormalizable , the effective coupling grows , becoming strong at @xmath165 . at this point the gauge theory ceases to be a useful description , we have the right to look for a supergravity ( or other ) dual . if @xmath166 is small , we expect to find a region of the phase diagram where gauge theory is a weakly coupled description . otherwise , we will have only supergravity phases . the interesting case is therefore @xmath167 , so that we have at least one region where the gauge theory is weakly coupled . we will take @xmath168 for the remainder of this subsection . in satisfying this condition , we find that the supergravity geometry is strongly curved at the enhanon radius . since the supergravity fields do not evolve inside the enhanon , this is the maximum curvature . at the enhanon radius , we can also inspect the dilaton ; it is @xmath169 from the equation ( [ dilp ] ) , we find that the dilaton increases monotonically with @xmath170 . it becomes of order one at @xmath171 at radii @xmath172 , we will need to use the @xmath58-dual supergravity description . since at these radii the effect of @xmath145 is very small , by comparison to the effect of @xmath144 , we are in fact matching on to the picture obtained by @xcite for the d@xmath43-branes alone ; the physics involving the k3 is essentially irrelevant . we now need to find the degrees of freedom best suited to describing the physics for @xmath173 . as @xmath170 decreases from @xmath174 , the curvature of the @xmath175 supergravity geometry will become stronger ; it becomes of order unity at @xmath176 at this place , the @xmath177-dimensional gauge theory will take over . we can see this by starting with its dimensionless t hooft coupling as a function of gauge theory energy @xmath178 @xmath179 now , in order to relate @xmath178 to @xmath170 we need an ir / uv relation for the strings stretched between the probe brane and the source branes . since the source branes are distributed on a s@xmath180 shell at the enhanon radius , the relation is @xmath181 , where @xmath182 encodes which brane on the shell the stretched string attaches to . in addition , we have the condition on the control parameter @xmath183 , so that @xmath184 and thus the size of the shell is not important . so the ir / uv relation is to good accuracy @xmath185 . therefore we see that the dimensionless t hooft coupling of the @xmath177-dimensional gauge theory is order one at @xmath186 . it decreases for smaller @xmath170 . we also have the induced lower - dimensional gauge theory with dimensionless coupling @xmath187 the crossover between the @xmath177- and @xmath57-dimensional gauge theories is clearly at @xmath188 . at lower energies _ i.e. _ smaller @xmath170 , the @xmath57-dimensional gauge theory takes over . however , this time its dimensionless t hooft coupling increases as @xmath170 decreases , _ i.e. _ exhibits the opposite behavior to the @xmath177-dimensional gauge theory . this is consistent with the physics of the @xmath5 supersymmetric systems studied in @xcite . the dimensionless t hooft coupling of the @xmath57-dimensional theory becomes strong at @xmath189 let us now recall the enhanon radius , defined by @xmath190 , or @xmath191 . from our previous considerations of a probe in the background of @xmath0 branes , we found that the branes were ( evenly ) distributed on a s@xmath180 shell of this radius . the energy of a string stretched between any two branes in this shell must therefore fall between @xmath192 the energy at which the @xmath42-dimensional gauge theory becomes strong is then precisely the energy at which the physics of the system is described by some theory whose dynamics includes only the bps strings stretched between the source branes ( and of probe branes so close to the enhanon radius that they too can be thought of as source branes ) . at the very lowest energies we can simply use the moduli space description of the physics . the gap that remains in building our phase diagram is an understanding of the physics in the energy range ( [ newrange ] ) . the curvature is strong there and thus we fail to find a supergravity dual for the strongly coupled @xmath57-dimensional gauge theory . a further indication of that failure is the explicit appearance of @xmath193 in the metric ( [ scaledmetric ] ) : in the gauge theory , @xmath193 enters the physics only through the parameter @xmath194 , and therefore should not explicitly appear in a dual description . so we have a mystery here . a natural suggestion for @xmath61 ( with a suitable generalization involving the @xmath109 theory for @xmath195 ) is that the dual is the ( 5 + 1)-dimensional @xmath100 gauge theory in the @xmath0-monopole sector , where they are just becoming massless . note that this @xmath100 gauge theory is part of the bulk physics , so what we are conjecturing is that it is the only relevant part and that the supergravity can be omitted . a weak test is that it give the correct moduli space , and it does . note also that the enhanon geometry has a natural interpretation in the gauge theory : in the @xmath0-monopole sector the higgs field has a zero of order @xmath0 . the function @xmath196 is essentially zero ( the flat interior ) until rising sharply . thus a classical monopole solution of large charge might be expected to have its charge distributed in a thin shell . to go further we need a new expansion to describe this system , which becomes weak for @xmath0 large . it appears that the spacing of the monopoles , of order @xmath197 times the enhanon radius , plays the role of a `` non - commutativity '' parameter , because the sphere has been effectively broken up into @xmath0 domains . in any case , the mysterious dual description should include the dynamics of these stretched strings at large-@xmath0 . again , the case @xmath195 needs special treatment . to orient ourselves , we may review the case of d7-branes by themselves . using the equations ( [ peq3spacetime ] ) , we find that the scalar curvature in string units is @xmath198^{-1 } \,,\ ] ] and this becomes order unity when @xmath199 . substituting this into the dimensionless t hooft coupling on the d7-branes , we find that the gauge coupling is order unity at the same place , and so the @xmath200-dimensional gauge theory and ten - dimensional supergravity parts of the phase diagram fit together as required . the dilaton becomes order unity when @xmath201 , and because @xmath202 , the nature of this theory beyond the supergravity approximation is unclear . let us now add the d3-branes . the effect on the curvature is essentially to multiply the above result by a factor @xmath203 . out at large values of @xmath170 such as @xmath186 and @xmath204 , the effect of the @xmath151-factor must be unimportant , by analogy with the lower-@xmath42 cases . now , recall that at the scale @xmath164 , the @xmath200-dimensional gauge theory crosses over to the @xmath205-dimensional gauge theory , and the coupling must be weak there in order for there to be gauge theory descriptions at all . therefore @xmath206 , and as a consequence we find @xmath207 , a condition necessary for clean separation of some of the phases as in the lower-@xmath42 cases . the remaining conditions needed for clean separation of the other phases involve @xmath204 and remain somewhat puzzling . we assume , by analogy with the @xmath156 cases , that they are met . we summarize our findings in the phase diagram in figure [ fig : phases ] . = 3.5 in 0.2 to get a little more information on the mystery theory we may consider going to finite temperature , or adding energy to the branes . the first change to the supergravity solution is that a nonextremality function @xmath208 appears multiplicatively in @xmath209 : @xmath210 in addition , the harmonic function of the d@xmath42-branes @xmath145 gets altered by nonextremality as if we had not taken the decoupling limit , while @xmath144 is unaltered fixed in the decoupling limit ; it does not scale with the string length . ] specifically , @xmath211 where @xmath212^{1/2 } - { { ( 2\pi)^{p-2}u_0^{3-p}}\over{2c_{p+4}\lambda_p } } \,.\ ] ] note that @xmath213 , and therefore the enhanon at @xmath214u_{\rm e}$ ] is pulled inwards to smaller @xmath170 as the ratio @xmath215 is increased . in order for the supergravity horizon at @xmath216 to lie outside the enhanon locus , we need a sufficiently large energy density @xmath217 on the branes . using the relation @xcite @xmath218 , this implies that @xmath219 where we have used the condition ( [ weak ] ) . this can not be satisfied in the @xmath220-dimensional gauge theory , and this is further evidence that the mysterious theory is not gravitational . although we have failed to find a weakly coupled dual for the gauge theory , a study of the coulomb branch of the gauge theory reveals a striking parallel to our probe computations . focusing on the case @xmath116 , suppose that the condition ( [ weak ] ) holds , so the low energy physics can be described by a @xmath221-dimensional gauge theory . the metric that the probe sees , after applying the scaling of the previous section to eqn . ( [ fourth ] ) , gives the metric on moduli space for the @xmath6 ( 2 + 1)-dimensional gauge theory in the decoupling limit : @xmath222 where @xmath223 the @xmath113 monopole potential is @xmath224 and @xmath225 , and the metric is meaningful only for @xmath226 . our metric ( [ probenear ] ) is the euclidean taub nut metric , with a negative mass . it is a hyperkhler manifold , because @xmath227 , where @xmath228 . it is striking that the moduli space metric is the same as that which can be derived from field theory , where this has the interpretation as the tree - level plus one - loop result . it is also interesting to note that while the scaled supergravity solution failed to give a dual , the result for the probe s moduli space is independent of @xmath14 . both of these facts could be understood if supersymmetry prevented @xmath14 from appearing in the probe metric : one can use @xmath14 as the control parameter to move from weak gauge theory to weak supergravity . on the surface this does not seem to be the case the probe moduli live in a vector multiplet , and so does @xmath14 but a more careful analysis may be needed . so there is a mystery here , perhaps confirming our suggestions in the previous section that there is a useful duality to be found . we see that the enhanon phenomenon is the same as the familiar fact that the tree - level plus one - loop kinetic term goes negative the landau pole . this metric is of course singular , and is therefore incomplete . as shown by seiberg and witten , it receives no perturbative corrections but is fixed nonperturbatively . it is the large @xmath81 expansion of the metric on the moduli space of @xmath0 monopoles . there are nonperturbative instanton corrections to this metric which smooth it out into a generalization of the atiyah hitchin manifold @xcite . in the two - monopole case studies in ref @xcite , the atiyah hitchin manifold is the unique smooth completion of the taub nut metric consistent with the condition of hyperkhlerity . ( see refs . @xcite for examples of generalizations and further study . ) to discuss quantitatively the nonperturbative corrections to the metric on moduli space it is simpler to look at the case @xmath195 . on the gauge theory side , the metric on moduli space is obtained from the seiberg witten curve @xcite , which for @xmath6 is @xcite @xmath229 the point of maximal unbroken gauge symmetry , which in the present case can only be the weyl subgroup , is @xmath230 earlier work on the large-@xmath0 limit @xcite focused on a different point in moduli space , but this highly symmetric point would seem to be the most natural place to look for a supergravity dual . the branch points @xmath231 are at @xmath232 this ring of zeros is reminiscent of the enhanon , and is in fact the same . to see this add a probe brane at @xmath233 , @xmath234 for @xmath235 , there are @xmath236 zeros which closely approximate a ring , @xmath237 the new factor , in parentheses , being @xmath238 . the remaining two zeros are at @xmath239 , or more precisely @xmath240 the correction being exponentially small . on the other hand , for @xmath241 , all @xmath242 branch points lie approximately in a ring , ) or ( [ inner ] ) into the polynomial ( [ poly ] ) produces a solution to order @xmath243 , which can be further improved by an @xmath244 correction to @xmath245 . the difference between the two ranges of @xmath246 is that the terms in parentheses are arranged so as not to circle the origin , so that the @xmath247 root comes back to its original value as @xmath248 increases from zero to @xmath249 or @xmath250 . ] @xmath251 as deduced from the string picture , the probe does not penetrate the interior of the enhanon but rather melts into it . one can extract the moduli space metric from the usual formalism @xcite . we leave a more detailed treatment for the future , but in the probe region @xmath252 it matches the perturbative result @xmath253 this agrees with the d3-brane probe result on the supergravity side if we identify @xmath254 . as mentioned in the introduction , there are a number of @xmath41- and @xmath58- dual pictures where the same physics arises . ( the physics of the heterotic @xmath58-dual for the @xmath116 case is essentially contained in the recent work of ref . @xcite . ) to construct some @xmath41-dual cases , consider @xcite a pair of ns5-branes which are pointlike in the @xmath255 directions , with @xmath0 d@xmath57-branes stretched between them along the @xmath256 direction , where @xmath257 , or 3 . the latter are pointlike in the @xmath258 directions , which are inside the ns5-branes , and also in the @xmath259 directions . all of the branes share the directions @xmath260 . this arrangement of branes , shown in figure [ bendy](a ) preserves eight supercharges . we will state the general @xmath42 case in many of the following formulae . the reader may wish to keep the @xmath116 case in mind for orientation . denoting the separation of the ns5-branes in the @xmath256 direction by @xmath261 , there is a @xmath262-dimensional @xmath6 gauge theory on the infinite part of the world - volume of the d@xmath262-branes , whose coupling is @xmath263 a number of gauge theory facts from the previous sections are manifest here . for example , the fact that ( for @xmath116 ) the coulomb branch of the @xmath6 gauge theory is dual to the moduli space of @xmath0 monopoles of a ( 5 + 1)-dimensional gauge theory follows from the fact that the ends of the d3-branes are membrane monopole sources ( in @xmath264 ) in the ns5-branes world - volume theory . this is an @xmath100 gauge theory spontaneously broken to @xmath113 by the ns5-branes separation . this will always be the relevant ( 5 + 1)-dimensional theory when @xmath262 is odd because we are in type iib string theory . when @xmath262 is even , we are in type iia , and the ( 5 + 1)-dimensional theory is the @xmath109 ( 0,2 ) theory . now place the @xmath256 direction on a circle of radius @xmath265 . there is a @xmath266-dual of this arrangement of branes . the ns5-branes become an @xmath109 ale space @xcite . to see this in supergravity language , we start by smearing the ns5-branes along the @xmath256 space , writing the supergravity solution for the core of the ns5-branes as @xcite ( @xmath267 ) : @xmath268 where @xmath269 is a 3-vector in the @xmath259 plane . we have placed one ns5-brane at @xmath270 and the other at @xmath271 . the condition @xcite @xmath272 defines @xmath273 as a vector @xmath274 which satisfies @xmath275 . applying the usual supergravity @xmath41-duality rules gives : @xmath276 which is the two - centre gibbons hawking metric for the @xmath109 ale space , nonsingular because of the @xmath277 periodicity of @xmath256 , and hyperkhler because of the condition relating @xmath278 and @xmath273 for a supersymmetric fivebrane solution . there are four moduli associated with this solution , forming a hypermultiplet in the @xmath108-dimensional theory . three of them constitute the vector @xmath279 giving the separation between the two centres . the fourth is a ns ns 2-form flux , @xmath280 , through the nontrivial two - cycle ( a @xmath281 ) in the space . this @xmath281 is constructed as the locus of @xmath256 circles along the straight line connecting the two centres @xmath282 and @xmath283 , where they shrink to zero size ; it has area @xmath284 . these four numbers specify the separation of the two ns5-branes in the @xmath266-dual picture . in our case , we have @xmath285 , and so the branes are only separated in @xmath256 , corresponding to having shrunk the @xmath281 away . the flux @xmath286 is kept finite as we send @xmath287 to zero , and is the parameter dual to @xmath261 : @xmath288 ( the full ns5-branes solution , with dependence on @xmath256 , can be recovered in the duality by considering winding strings in the ale geometry @xcite , doing a sum over those modes which is dual to a fourier transform of the fivebrane harmonic function on the @xmath256 circle . ) on the ale space , the @xmath102-bosons for the enhanced @xmath100 gauge symmetry of the @xmath289-dimensional theory are made from a d2- and an anti d2-brane wrapped on the @xmath281 , their masses being @xmath290 , where the flux appears due to the @xmath291 coupling ; there is some induced d0-brane charge . under @xmath266-duality , the stretched d@xmath262-branes become d@xmath292-branes which are wrapped on the @xmath281 , inducing some d@xmath42-brane charge due to the @xmath293 coupling . so the configuration with @xmath0 d@xmath262-branes stretched between the two ns5-branes is dual to the same number of d@xmath292-branes wrapped on the two - cycle of an @xmath109 ale space , giving rise to @xmath0 effective d@xmath42-branes . the gauge coupling in the resulting @xmath57-dimensional @xmath6 gauge theory is given by : @xmath294 as mentioned in the introduction , this configuration is @xmath41-dual to @xmath0 d@xmath295 branes wrapped on a k3 , of volume @xmath14 , the parameter dual to @xmath286 . the things we learned about this original configuration translate into refinements of the dual pictures . for example , the nontrivial metric on moduli space corresponds to the bending @xcite of the ns5-branes away from being flat , resulting from the d@xmath57-branes pull on them ( see figure [ bendy](b ) ) . denoting the radial coordinate in the @xmath258 directions as @xmath81 , ( as we did before ) , the @xmath256 position of a ns5-brane is given by the equation @xmath296 , giving the smooth shape of the ns5-brane for large enough @xmath81 , _ i.e. _ far away enough from the details of the junction itself . the solution for the shape is @xmath297 ( @xmath298 ) , or @xmath299 ( for @xmath146 ) , where @xmath300 and @xmath301 are constants set by @xmath261 , the asymptotic separation of the branes , and @xmath94 and @xmath302 . using this , an expression for the separation @xmath303 of the ns5-branes is @xmath304 notice that this is precisely the functional behavior that we see in the harmonic functions for the supergravity solution of the d@xmath42-d@xmath43 system . the parameters @xmath300 and @xmath301 can be fixed completely by comparing to the large @xmath81 limit of probe moduli space computation done there , although we will not do it here . in the expression ( [ coupling ] ) for the gauge coupling , we should replace @xmath261 by our expression for @xmath303 , giving the running of the coupling with position on the coulomb branch . we recover therefore the singularity in the coulomb branch where the gauge coupling diverges , when the separation @xmath303 of the ns5-branes is of order @xmath302 , resulting in an enhanced gauge symmetry on the ns5-branes ( 5 + 1)-dimensional world - volume . the enhanon is simply the @xmath305 of closest approach of the ns5-branes in the @xmath256 direction . notice that the probe brane we studied previously is a single stretched d@xmath262-brane moving in @xmath258 in this picture . an @xmath81-dependence in the separation between the ns5-branes translates , using ( [ elldual ] ) , into variable @xmath102-boson masses @xmath306 in the @xmath108-dimensional theory , giving the enhanon locus where @xmath307 vanishes . using @xmath307 in the formula ( [ couples ] ) results in the divergence in the @xmath308-dimensional gauge coupling at the enhanon locus . one notable result of this paper is a new mechanism that resolves a large class of spacetime singularities in string theory . this involves a phenomenon , the resolution of a singularity by the expansion of a system of branes in the transverse directions , which is related to that which has recently arisen in other forms @xcite . one difference from @xcite is that the branes are found not at the singularity in the supergravity metric ; rather , the metric is modified by string / braney phenomena in the manner that we have described . our result may point toward a more general understanding of singularities in string theory . in the gauge theory we have found a striking parallel between the spacetime picture and the behavior of large-@xmath0 @xmath6 gauge theories . the most interesting open question is to find a weakly coupled dual to the strongly coupled gauge theory ; our results give many hints in this direction . there are a number of technical loose ends , which include a more complete treatment of the d3-d7 case , and a fuller understanding of the constraints of supersymmetry on the probe moduli space . finally , there are many interesting generalizations , including product gauge groups , the addition of hypermultiplets , and rotation . we would like to thank p. ( bruce willis ) argyres , s. ( andrew jackson ) gubser , a. hanany , a. hashimoto , p. horava , a. karch , r. myers , p. pouliot , s. sethi , a. strominger , and c. vafa for helpful remarks and discussions . this work was supported in part by nsf grants phy94 - 07194 , phy97 - 22022 , and career grant phy97 - 33173 . 99 l. dixon , j.a . harvey , c. vafa and e. witten , nucl . * b261 * , 678 ( 1985 ) . e. witten , nucl . * b403 * , 159 ( 1993 ) hep - th/9301042 ; + p.s . aspinwall , b.r . greene and d.r . morrison , phys . * b303 * , 249 ( 1993 ) hep - th/9301043 . p. candelas , p.s . green and t. hubsch , phys . lett . * 62 * , 1956 ( 1989 ) ; + a. strominger , nucl . * b451 * , 96 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9504090 ; + b.r . greene , d.r . morrison and a. strominger , nucl . * b451 * , 109 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9504145 . g.t . horowitz and r. myers , * 27 * , 915 ( 1995 ) gr - qc/9503062 . k. behrndt , nucl . * b455 * , 188 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9506106 . r. kallosh and a. linde , phys . * d52 * , 7137 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9507022 . m. cveti and d. youm , phys . * b359 * , 87 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9507160 . j. maldacena , adv . * 2 * , 231 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9711200 . m. bershadsky , c. vafa and v. sadov , nucl . * b463 * , 398 ( 1996 ) hep - th/9510225 . s. kachru and e. silverstein , phys . lett . * 80 * , 4855 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9802183 . j. polchinski , phys . rev . * d55 * , 6423 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9606165 . c.v . johnson and r.c . myers , phys . * d55 * , 6382 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9610140 . douglas , jhep * 07 * , 004 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9612126 ; + d. diaconescu , m.r . douglas and j. gomis , jhep * 02 * , 013 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9712230 . a. hanany and e. witten , nucl . * b492 * , 152 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9611230 . johnson , n. kaloper , r.r . khuri and r.c . myers , phys . * b368 * , 71 ( 1996 ) hep - th/9509070 . sorkin , phys . 51 * , 87 ( 1983 ) ; + d.j . gross and m.j . perry , nucl . * b226 * , 29 ( 1983 ) . khuri , phys . * b294 * , 325 ( 1992 ) hep - th/9205051 ; + r.r . khuri , nucl . * b387 * , 315 ( 1992 ) hep - th/9205081 . m.j . duff , r.r . khuri , r. minasian and j. rahmfeld , nucl . * b418 * , 195 ( 1994 ) hep - th/9311120 . s.s . gubser and i.r . klebanov , phys . * d58 * , 125025 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9808075 ; + i.r . klebanov and n.a . nekrasov , hep - th/9911096 . m. green , j.a . harvey and g. moore , class . * 14 * , 47 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9605033 . k. dasgupta , d.p . jatkar and s. mukhi , nucl . * b523 * , 465 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9707224 . bachas , p. bain and m.b . green , jhep * 05 * , 011 ( 1999 ) hep - th/9903210 . r. gopakumar and c. vafa , hep - th/9811131 . l. alvarez - gaume and d.z . freedman , commun . phys . * 80 * , 443 ( 1981 ) . townsend , phys . * b373 * , 68 ( 1996 ) hep - th/9512062 . c. schmidhuber , nucl . * b467 * , 146 ( 1996 ) hep - th/9601003 . n. itzhaki , j.m . maldacena , j. sonnenschein and s. yankielowicz , phys . * d58 * , 046004 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9802042 . c. vafa , nucl . * b469 * , 403 ( 1996 ) m.f . atiyah and n.j . hitchin , _ `` the geometry and dynamics of magnetic monopoles . porter lectures '' _ , princeton university press ( 1988 ) . n. seiberg and e. witten , hep - th/9607163 . g. chalmers and a. hanany , nucl . * b489 * , 223 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9608105 . n. dorey , v.v . khoze , m.p . mattis , d. tong and s. vandoren , nucl . * b502 * , 59 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9703228 . hep - th/9602022 . n. seiberg and e. witten , nucl . phys . * b426 * , 19 ( 1994 ) hep - th/9407087 . argyres and a.e . faraggi , phys . lett . * 74 * , 3931 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9411057 ; + a. klemm , w. lerche , s. yankielowicz and s. theisen , phys . lett . * b344 * , 169 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9411048 . douglas and s.h . shenker , nucl . * b447 * , 271 ( 1995 ) hep - th/9503163 . m. krogh , hep - th/9911084 . johnson , nucl . * b507 * , 227 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9706155 . a. karch , d. lust and d. smith , nucl . * b533 * , 348 ( 1998 ) hep - th/9803232 . k. dasgupta and s. mukhi , jhep * 07 * , 008 ( 1999 ) hep - th/9904131 . e. witten , hep - th/9507121 ; + h. ooguri and c. vafa , nucl . phys . * b463 * , 55 ( 1996 ) hep - th/9511164 . gauntlett , j.a . harvey and j.t . liu , nucl . * b409 * , 363 ( 1993 ) hep - th/9211056 . a. strominger , nucl . * b343 * , 167 ( 1990 ) ; + s. rey , phys . rev . * d43 * , 526 ( 1991 ) ; + c.g . callan , j.a . harvey and a. strominger , hep - th/9112030 . r. gregory , j.a . harvey and g. moore , adv . * 1 * , 283 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9708086 . e. witten , nucl . * b500 * , 3 ( 1997 ) hep - th/9703166 . p. kraus , f. larsen and s.p . trivedi , jhep * 03 * , 003 ( 1999 ) hep - th/9811120 ; + d.z . freedman , s.s . gubser , k. pilch and n.p . warner , hep - th/9906194 ; + a. brandhuber and k. sfetsos , hep - th/9906201 . myers , hep - th/9910053 ; + j. polchinski and m. strassler , in progress ; + s.s . gubser , k. pilch and n.p . warner , in progress .
Abstract: | [
"we study brane configurations that give rise to large-@xmath0 gauge theories with eight supersymmetries and no hypermultiplets . these configurations include a variety of wrapped , fractional , and stretched branes or strings . the corresponding spacetime geometries which we study have a distinct kind of singularity known as a repulson . we find that this singularity is removed by a distinctive mechanism , leaving a smooth geometry with a core having an enhanced gauge symmetry . the spacetime geometry can be related to large-@xmath0 seiberg witten theory . epsf 3.7 in * gauge theory and the excision of repulson singularities * * clifford v. johnson , amanda w. peet , joseph polchinski * @xmath1school of natural sciences institute for advanced study princeton , nj 08540 , u.s.a . @xmath1centre for particle theory department of mathematical sciences university of durham , durham dh1 3le , u.k . @xmath2institute for theoretical physics university of california santa barbara , ca 93106 - 4030 , u.s.a ."
] | 8,829 | 8,829 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: building scalable multi - qubit systems is presently the main challenge towards the implementation of a solid - state quantum information processor @xcite . high - fidelity single qubit gates based both on semi- @xcite and super - conducting technologies are nowadays available . in particular , for the three basic types of superconducting qubits ( charge , flux and phase ) single - qubit operations with high quality factor have been demonstrated in different laboratories @xcite . further improvement has been recently achieved with circuit - qed architectures @xcite . multi - qubit systems instead have been proved harder to operate , the main limitation arising from the broadband solid state noise . the requirements for building an elementary quantum processor are in fact quite demanding on the efficiency of the protocols . this includes both severe constraints on readout and a sufficient isolation from fluctuations to reduce decoherence effects . based on experiments on the different josephson junction ( jj ) setups , there is presently a general consensus on the most common noise spectral forms and on the main consequences on systems evolutions . typically noise is broadband and structured , i. e. the noise spectrum extends to several decades , it is non - monotonic , sometimes a few resonances are present . noise with @xmath0 spectrum is common to virtually all nanodevices . its physical origin varies from device to device and depends on the specific material . different implementations are in fact more sensitive either to charge , flux or to critical current fluctuations with spectral density scaling as the inverse of the frequency . the presence of slow components in the environment makes the decay of the coherent signal strongly dependent on the experimental protocol being used @xcite . measurements protocols requiring numerous repetitions are particularly sensitive to the unstable device calibration due to low - frequency fluctuations . the leading effect is defocusing of the measured signal , analogous to inhomogeneous broadening in nmr @xcite . the intrinsic high - frequency cut - off of @xmath0 noise is hardly detectable , measurements typically extending to @xmath1 hz ( recently charge noise up to @xmath2 mhz has been detected in a set @xcite ) . incoherent energy exchanges between system and environment , leading to relaxation and decoherence , occur at typical operating frequencies ( about @xmath2 ghz ) . indirect measurements of noise spectrum in this frequency range often suggest a white or ohmic behavior @xcite . in addition , narrow resonances at selected frequencies ( sometimes resonant with the nanodevice relevant energy scales ) have being observed @xcite . in certain devices they originate from the circuitry @xcite and may eventually be reduced by circuit design . more often , resonances are signatures of the presence of spurious fluctuators which also show up in the time resolved evolution , unambiguously proving the discrete nature of the noise sources @xcite . such fluctuators may severely limit the reliability of nanodevices @xcite . explanation of this rich physics is beyond phenomenological theories describing the environment as a set of harmonic oscillators . on the other side , an accurate characterization of the noise sources might be a priory inefficient , since a huge number of parameters would be required for a microscopic description . therefore one may follow a different route , consisting in classifying noise sources on the basis of their effects instead of on their nature and to understand , case by case , which is the efficient description of the environment . the required information may in fact depend on the specific protocol , especially when the environment is long - time correlated . this program is meaningful for quantum information where relevant time scales are much smaller than the decoherence time . this means that in the generic favorable situation coupling with the environment has simple effects on the system dynamics . as a difference with condensed matter physics where long time behavior is emphasized and interesting problems involve entanglement of a many - body system . here we illustrate a road - map to treat broadband noise which allows to obtain reasonable approximations by systematically including only the relevant information on the environment , out of the huge parametrization needed to specify it . the multi - stage approach for the different classes of broadband noise has been originally introduced for single qubit gates @xcite . the obtained predictions for the decay of the coherent signal are in agreement with observations in various jj implementations and in different protocols @xcite . we mention the observed decay of ramsey fringes in charge - phase qubits @xcite and recent results on flux / phase qubits @xcite . here we extend the procedure to complex solid - state architectures . as an illustrative case , we perform a systematic analysis of the effects and interplay of low and high frequency noise components in a two - qubit gate in a fixed coupling scheme . such a systematic analysis points out that efficient operations in the solid state require an accurate preliminary characterization of the noise spectral characteristics and tuning appropriately the device working point . the paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we introduce the general framework of solid - state multi qubit gates and illustrate the characteristics of the most common spectral forms . in section 3 we propose a classification of the noise sources and in section 4 we present a multi - stage approach to deal with broadband noise . section 5 is dedicated to adiabatic noise . in section 6 the multistage approach is applied to a universal two - qubit gate . section 7 summarizes our main findings . a multi - qubit gate can be modeled by the following hamiltonian ( @xmath3 ) @xmath4 where for each qubit , labeled by @xmath5 , @xmath6 includes set of parameters intrinsic to the device and time dependent classical control fields . manipulation of tunable fields allows control of the dynamics and design of arbitrary single qubit operations via unitary transformations . interactions among qubits and the needed additional parametrization to describe the multi - qubit gate are included in @xmath7 . depending on the design , the control hamiltonian may span a reduced subspace of the qubit liouville space . in other words , there is a limited number of ports available for control , for tuning , for state preparation and measurement . noise is also coupled via these ports . it is rather usual that only one of the control fields allows the required fast addressing of each qubit . therefore we focus on a model where both the control fields , @xmath8 , and the environment are coupled to a single qubit operator , say @xmath9 , @xmath10 where the polar angles @xmath11 define qubit-@xmath12 working point . the environment hamiltonian is @xmath13 and @xmath14 is a collective environment variable acting on qubit @xmath12 . model ( [ h ] ) implies a projection of the device hamiltonian onto the subspace spanned by the two lowest energy eigenstates for each qubit . this description is valid provided that manipulations with the control fields do not induce leakage to higher energy states of the device @xcite . we leave unspecified the nature of the noise sources described by @xmath15 , relevant cases being either discrete or gaussian fluctuations . in addition , the environment hamiltonian may include correlations among noise sources affecting each qubit . in the spirit of the present analysis , we assume that the only information at our disposal is the power spectrum of @xmath16 fluctuations @xmath17 where @xmath18 denotes the equilibrium average with respect to @xmath13 . we remark that the effect of the environment on the system dynamics is completely characterized by @xmath19 only if the environment is composed of harmonic oscillators or if it is weakly coupled to the system and short time correlated . of course this is not the case if low - energy excitations determine memory effects . this is the typical situation in the solid state where in general additional statistical information on the environment is required . we assume that each noise component @xmath16 has broadband spectrum @xmath20 , @xmath21 followed by a white or ohmic flank at frequencies @xmath22 . low- and high - frequency cutoffs depend on the specific setup . impurities of various origin responsible for random telegraph fluctuations contribute lorentzian peaks to the power spectrum @xmath23 . such a spectrum originates from classical fluctuations @xmath24 , where @xmath25 randomly switches between two values @xmath26 with rate @xmath27 . an ensemble of @xmath28 bistable impurities with a distribution of switching rates @xmath29 , @xmath30 $ ] and average coupling strength @xmath31 , gives rise to @xmath0-spectrum , @xmath32\,\,\omega^{-1}$ ] @xcite . selected lorentzian peaks may be visible in the spectrum if individual impurities are strongly coupled , i. e. when @xmath33 . instead , damped coherent fluctuators at frequencies @xmath34 , in the simplest cases contribute to the total spectrum with additional peaks , @xmath35 . spectroscopic evidence of coherent impurities of frequency @xmath36 close to the qubit larmor frequency has been reported in @xcite . remarkably , the possibility to exploit spurious quantum two - level systems as qubits @xcite or for quantum memory operations has been recently demonstrated @xcite . in these cases a quantum description of the impurity is required @xcite . the above description illuminates that in the solid state we have to deal with broadband and structured noise . in other words , the noise spectrum extends to several decades , it is non - monotonic , sometimes a few resonances are present . the various noise sources responsible for the above phenomenology have a qualitative different influence on the system evolution . this naturally leads to a classification of the noise sources according to the effects produced rather than to their specific nature . the effects of high - amplitude noise at low frequencies , like @xmath0 noise , vary from protocol to protocol . this feature is typical of non - markovian baths . quantum operations necessarily require repetitions of single detections , each leading to boolean answer . therefore , even `` single shot '' measurements result from numerous repetitions of single runs in an overall process which may last minutes . in the presence of low frequency fluctuations this leads to unstable device calibration and random clock frequencies in the various repetitions . as a result , a de - focused signal is observed , a phenomenon analogous to inhomogeneous broadening in nmr . re - focusing protocols , like echo or some dynamical decoupling schemes , allow partial recovery of the signal @xcite . since the environment is long - time correlated , statistical information beyond the power spectrum may be required to describe its effects . this is the case for instance in echo protocols @xcite . environments with long - time memory belong to the class of adiabatic noise , for which the born - oppenheimer approximation is applicable . we classify this part of the noise spectrum as `` adiabatic noise '' . noise at higher frequency , around the system typical scales ( e.g. single qubit larmor frequencies ) , results in incoherent energy exchanges between the quantum device and the environment . in particular , high - frequency noise is responsible for spontaneous decay . for systems relevant for quantum information , the system - bath coupling is rather small , in addition high - frequency noise is short - time correlated . therefore , in simplest cases , effects can be described by a born - markov master equation @xcite . for single qubit gates it leads to the relaxation and secular dephasing times , @xmath37 and @xmath38 @xcite . we classify this part of the noise spectrum as `` quantum noise '' . finally , resonances in the spectrum unveil the presence of discrete noise sources which severely effect the system performances , in particular reliability of devices . this is the case when classical impurities are slow enough to induce a visible bistable instability in the system intrinsic frequency . for instance , single qubit gates in the presence of random telegraph noise ( switching rate @xmath27 ) may display two effective frequencies , @xmath39 and @xmath40 , depending on the impurity state . their visibility is measured by the ratio @xmath41 . beatings can be observed in the `` strong coupling '' regime @xmath42 @xcite . quantum impurities may also entangle with the device . this additionally leads to a variety of features , like peculiar temperature dependencies of decay rates @xcite . under these conditions , knowledge of the power spectrum is absolutely insufficient and in order to describe these effects the relevant system hilbert space has to be enlarged to include the responsible environmental degrees of freedom . effects in general depend on the specific protocol and require a microscopic model of the fluctuators . we classify this part of the noise spectrum as `` strongly - coupled noise '' . each noise class requires a specific approximation scheme , which is not appropriate for the other classes . the overall effect results from the interplay of the three classes of noise . in the following section we will illustrate a multi - scale theory to deal with solid state broadband noise . we are interested to a reduced description of the @xmath43-qubit system , expressed by the reduced density matrix @xmath44 . it is formally obtained by tracing out environmental degrees of freedom from the total density matrix @xmath45 , which depends on quantum ( q ) , adiabatic ( a ) and strongly coupled ( sc ) variables . the elimination procedure can be conveniently performed by separating in the interaction hamiltonian , @xmath46 , various noise classes , e.g. by formally writing @xmath47 adiabatic noise is typically correlated on a time scale much longer than the inverse of the natural frequencies @xmath48 , then application of the born - oppenheimer approximation is equivalent to replace @xmath49 with a classical stochastic field @xmath50 . this approach is valid when the contribution of adiabatic noise to spontaneous decay is negligible , a necessary condition being @xmath51 . this condition is usually satisfied at short enough times , since @xmath52 is substantially different from zero only at frequencies @xmath53 . this fact already suggests a route to trace - out different noise classes in the appropriate order . the total density matrix parametrically depends on the specific realization of the slow random drives @xmath54 and may be written as @xmath55 . the first step is to trace out quantum noise . in the simplest cases this requires solving a master equation . in a second stage , the average over all the realizations of the stochastic processes , @xmath56 , is performed . this leads to a reduced density matrix for the @xmath43-qubit system plus the strongly coupled degrees of freedom . these have to be traced out in a final stage by solving the heisenberg equations of motion , or by approaches suitable to the specific microscopic hamiltonian or interaction . for instance , the dynamics may be solved exactly for some special quantum impurity models at pure dephasing , @xmath57 , when impurities are longitudinally coupled to each qubit @xcite . the ordered multi - stage elimination procedure can be formally written as @xmath58 \ , p[\vec x(t ) ] \ ; tr_{q } \big [ \ , w^{q , sc}\big(t | \vec x(t)\big ) \ , \big]\right\ } \ , .\ ] ] in the following section we concentrate on the elimination of adiabatic noise . the ordered procedure will be illustrated in section 6 for a two - qubit gate . in general , the adiabatic approximation holds true for times short enough to fulfill the necessary condition , @xmath59 . in the peculiar , pure dephasing regime , @xmath57 , relaxation processes are forbidden and the adiabatic approximation is exact for any @xmath60 . in addition , the adiabatic scheme can be applied also in the presence of correlations between processes @xmath61 and @xmath62 @xcite . for the sake of clarity here we consider adiabatic noise affecting independently each qubit . moreover , we exclude time - dependent drives in @xmath8 and in @xmath63 . the procedure can be straightforwardly extended for instance to rabi oscillations and other ac - drives @xcite . suppose we are able to diagonalize , for each realization @xmath56 of the stochastic processes , the system hamiltonian , @xmath64 and denote @xmath65 an instantaneous eigenstate of ( [ eq : hamiltonian - stochastic ] ) with eigenvalue @xmath66 . if the system is prepared in a pure state , @xmath67 , in the adiabatic approximation , each component @xmath68 evolves in time according to @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the dynamic phase . the stray fields @xmath56 affect the time evolution of the gate fidelity via modifications of the phases @xmath71 and of the eigenstates @xmath72 . in addition , @xmath73 reflects imperfect preparation due to the random field . this occurs , for instance , when the system is prepared by a reset to a pure state vector @xmath67 followed by an initialization pulse whose effect depends also on the stray field at @xmath74 . the evolution of the system conditional density matrix can be presented in a compact form @xmath75 \ ; { \mathrm e}^{- i \int_0^t d s \ , \omega_{m p}(s ) } \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the instantaneous splittings appearing in the phase factor are @xmath76 and we have introduced the operator @xmath77 = \ , { \,| \ , { m(\vec x_t ) } \,\rangle \,}{\ , \langle\,{m(\vec x_0 ) } \,|\ , } \rho(0 ) { \,| \ , { p(\vec x_0 ) } \,\rangle \ , } { \ , \langle\,{p(\vec x_t ) } \,|\,}\ ] ] which contains information about the preparation and the eigenstates errors . finally , the average of @xmath78 over the stochastic process yields the system density matrix , which can be presented as a path integral @xmath79 \ , p[\vec x(s ) ] \ , \rho^n\big(t|\vec x(s)\big ) \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath80 $ ] contains information both on the stochastic processes and on details of the specific protocol . it is convenient to split it as follows @xmath81 \,=\ , f[\vec x(s ) ] \ ; p[\vec x(s ) ] \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath82 $ ] is the probability of the realization @xmath83 . the filter function @xmath84 $ ] describes the specific operation . for most of present day experiments on solid - state qubits @xmath84=1 $ ] . for an open - loop feedback protocol , which allows initial control of some collective variable of the environment , say @xmath85 , we should put @xmath84 \propto \ , \delta(\vec x_0 ) = \ , \pi_i \delta(x_{i0})$ ] . a critical issue is the identification of @xmath82 $ ] for the specific noise sources , as those displaying @xmath0 power spectrum . if we sample the stochastic process at times @xmath86 , with @xmath87 and @xmath88 , we can identify @xmath89 = \lim_{m \to \infty } p_{m+1}(\vec x_m , t;\dots ; \vec x_1 , t_1 ; \vec x_0 , 0 ) \ , , \label{sampling}\ ] ] where @xmath90 is a @xmath91 joint probability and we have used the shorthand notation @xmath92 . in the following we will propose a systematic method to select only the relevant statistical information on the stochastic process out of the full characterization included in @xmath82 $ ] . we would like to remark , at this point , that in the adiabatic treatment the word decoherence is perhaps abused . decoherence is ultimately due to entanglement of the qubit to a quantum environment @xcite , whereas classical adiabatic noise produces only de - focusing . however , unless the signal can be _ totally _ re - focused , and this is impossible in practice , the behavior of @xmath93 is the same as for true decoherence @xcite . in other words , although proper and improper mixed states at the fundamental level are well distinct concepts @xcite , they are not distinct in the density matrix description . we also observe that present day `` applied '' research on solid - state coherent nanodevices for quantum information focuses on the `` short - time '' dynamics , since a signal which is almost decayed is useless . in this context , methods as the adiabatic approximation are valuable even if they are not accurate at long time scales and are not valid down to zero temperature . the longitudinal approximation consists in neglecting modifications of the eigenstates @xmath72 and preparation effects . without loss of generality , we may assume vanishing average of the stochastic processes after the preparation pulse , @xmath94 . the longitudinal approximation amounts to put @xmath95 where @xmath96 is an eigenstate of the system hamiltonian @xmath97 . then @xmath98 \approx { \,| \ , { m } \,\rangle \ , } \rho^n_{mp}(0 ) { \ , \langle\,{p } \,|\,}$ ] is a projected element of the initial density matrix and eq.([eq : pathint - adiabatic ] ) simplifies to @xmath99 \ , p[\vec x(s ) ] \ ; { \mathrm e}^{- i \int_0^t \!\!d s \ , \omega_{m p}(s ) } \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the significance of the longitudinal approximation is easily illustrated for a single qubit gate , when the system hamiltonian reduces to @xmath100 in this case , retaining variations of the splitting @xmath39 amounts to consider only fluctuations of the length of the vector @xmath101 . this would be the only effect if the noise would act longitudinally , @xmath102 . variations of the eigenstates @xmath103 originate instead from `` transverse '' variations of @xmath101 . the longitudinal assumption has been performed in ref.@xcite to discuss the effect of gaussian adiabatic environments . the present approach automatically provides constraints on its validity and shows that whereas errors due to transverse fluctuations are weakly dependent on time , phase errors accumulate . therefore , transverse noise in the adiabatic approximation has possibly some effect only at very short times , but the phase damping channel eventually prevails . these considerations strongly depend on the amplitude of the noise . we checked analytically and with simulations that they hold true for realistic figures of noise as those measured in experiments by zorin et al . @xcite . in the longitudinal approximation , diagonal elements of the reduced density matrix in the eigenstate basis , @xmath104 , do not decay . instead , the decay of the off - diagonal elements results from @xmath105 $ ] , where the complex average phase is given by @xmath106 \ , p[x(s ) ] \ , { \mathrm e}^{i \int_0^t \!\!ds \ , \omega[x(s ) ] } \ , .\ ] ] we notice that the longitudinal approximation may be exact for certain protocols , which therefore are not affected by adiabatic transverse noise . for instance , this is the case if the system is described by ( [ eq : hamiltonian - stochastic2 ] ) and it is prepared in a state @xmath107 . if we measure @xmath108 , since @xmath109 do not depend on @xmath110 , the result is not affected by transverse fluctuations and @xmath111 \ , \exp\{{{\cal i } m \,}\ ! \phi(t)\}$ ] . this the case of the decaying oscillations pattern measured with ramsey interference @xcite , if the effect of imperfect @xmath112 pulses is negligible . a standard approximation of the path integrals ( [ eq : pathint - adiabatic],[eq : pathint - adiabatic - longitudinal ] ) consists in neglecting the time dependence in the path , @xmath113 and taking @xmath114=1 $ ] . in this static path approximation ( spa ) the problem reduces to ordinary integrations with @xmath115 . in the single qubit case , for instance , eq.([eq : blur ] ) gives average phase shift @xmath116 where @xmath117 ^ 2 + ( \omega \cos \theta)^2}$ ] . eq.([eq : blur - static ] ) describes the effect of a distribution of stray energy shifts @xmath118 and corresponds to the rigid lattice breadth contribution to inhomogeneous broadening @xcite . in experiments with solid state devices this approximation describes the measurement procedure consisting in signal acquisition and averaging over a large number @xmath119 of repetitions of the protocol , for an overall time @xmath120 ( which may also be minutes in actual experiments ) . due to slow fluctuations of the solid state environment calibration , the initial value , @xmath121 , fluctuates during the repetitions blurring the average signal , independently on the measurement being single - shot or not . the probability @xmath122 describes the distribution of the random variable obtained by sampling the stochastic process @xmath25 at the initial time of each repetition , i. e. at times @xmath123 , @xmath124 . if @xmath125 results from many independent random variables of a multimode environment , the central limit theorem applies and @xmath122 is a gaussian distribution with standard deviation @xmath126 @xmath127 with integration limits @xmath128 , and the high - frequency cut - off of the @xmath0 spectrum , @xmath129 . in the spa the distribution standard deviation , @xmath126 , is the only adiabatic noise characteristic parameter . if the equilibrium average of the stochastic process vanishes , eq.([eq : blur - static ] ) reduces to @xmath130 ^ 2 + ( \omega \cos \theta)^2 } } \ , . \label{spa - oneqb}\ ] ] a convenient approximation is obtained by expanding @xmath131 to second order in @xmath125 , which leads to @xcite @xmath132 the short - times decay of coherent oscillations qualitatively depends on the working point . in fact , the suppression of the signal , @xmath133 $ ] , turns from a @xmath134 behavior at @xmath135 to a power law , @xmath136^{-1/4}$ ] , at @xmath137 . in these limits eq.([ref : quadratic ] ) reproduces known results for gaussian @xmath0 environments . in particular , at @xmath138 we obtain the short - times limit , @xmath139 , of the exact result of ref.@xcite . at @xmath140 the short and intermediate times result of ref . @xcite is reproduced . the fact that results of a diagrammatic approach with a quantum environment , as those of ref . @xcite , can be reproduced and generalized already at the simple spa level makes the semi - classical approach quite promising . it shows that , at least for not too long times ( but surely longer than times of interest for quantum state processing ) , the quantum nature of the environment may not be relevant for the class of problems which can be treated in the born - oppenheimer approximation . notice also that the spa itself has surely a wide validity since it does not require information about the _ dynamics _ of the noise sources , provided they are slow @xcite . going beyond the spa amounts to sample more accurately the stochastic process @xmath83 in ( [ sampling ] ) . the first correction to the spa is obtained by parametrizing the random process as follows @xmath141 . inserting this expression in ( [ eq : pathint - adiabatic ] ) and approximating @xmath82 $ ] in ( [ sampling ] ) with the conditional probability @xmath142 $ ] , we obtain @xmath143 the joint probability depends on the statistics of the noise sources . therefore the first correction to the spa distinguishes discrete and gaussian processes . considering again a single qubit , the average phase ( [ eq : blur ] ) at the working point @xmath144 for generic gaussian noise becomes @xmath145 t \over \omega } \big ] + { 1 \over 2 } \ln \big[1 + i { \sigma^2 \pi(t)\,t \over 3 \ , \omega } \big ] \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath146 is a transition probability , depending on the stochastic process . for ornstein - uhlenbeck processes it reduces to the result of ref . the first correction suggests that the spa , in principle valid for @xmath147 , may have a broader validity . this is illustrated in fig.([figure1 ] ) where the adiabatic approximation ( numerical evaluation of eq.([eq : blur ] ) ) is compared with the exact ( numerical ) dynamics in the presence of @xmath0 noise and with the analytic forms resulting from the spa and its first correction . for @xmath0 noise due to a set of bistable impurities the spa valid also for @xmath148 , if @xmath149 . of course the adiabatic approximation is tenable if @xmath150 . by sampling more accurately the adiabatic process @xmath56 it is possible to selectively include the statistical information needed for the specific measurement process . for instance , echo protocols are able to partly re - focus the signal , in other words de - focusing described by the spa is almost canceled by the echo pulse sequence . the decay of the echo signal is due to the un - canceled dynamics of the low - frequency fluctuations and to quantum noise . the leading effect of adiabatic noise can be estimated by a proper parametrization of @xmath56 , similar to the one considered in the present paragraph @xcite . in the present section we apply the multi - stage approach to a universal two - qubit gate based on a fixed coupling scheme . capacitive and inductive fixed couplings @xcite have been used to demonstrate two - qubit logic gates in different jj implementations @xcite . entanglement is generated by tuning single - qubit energy spacing to achieve mutual resonance . to this end , during the gate operation at least one qubit has to be moved away from the working point of minimal sensitivity to parameters variations , the `` optimal point '' . this has so far represented the main drawback of the fixed - coupling scheme for josephson implementations , with the exception of phase qubits @xcite . more recent proposals have attempted to solve this problem by introducing tunable coupling schemes @xcite . most of them rely on additional circuit elements and gain their tunability from ac - driving @xcite or from `` adiabatic '' couplers @xcite . some of these coupling schemes have been tested in experiments and are potentially scalable @xcite . none of these implementations is however totally immune from imperfections . in general , introducing additional on - chip circuits elements opens new ports to noise . the possibility to employ `` minimal '' fixed coupling schemes has been recently reconsidered in ref . @xcite , pointing out the possibility to single out `` optimal coupling '' conditions which ensure reasonable protection from @xmath0 fluctuations . in order to implement a @xmath151 gate in a fixed coupling scheme we need two resonant qubits with a transverse coupling , as described by the hamiltonian @xmath152 where @xmath153 is the coupling strength , and @xmath154 the pseudo - spin operators whose eigenstates @xmath155 ( eigenvalues @xmath156 ) are the computational states of qubit @xmath12 . eigenvalues and eigenvectors of @xmath157 are given by -6pt @xmath158 where @xmath159 , @xmath160 with @xmath161 and we have used the shorthand notation @xmath162 . the level structure of the coupled system is schematically illustrated in fig.([splittings ] ) . as a result of the diagonal block structure of the hamiltonian ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) in the computational space , the two - qubit hilbert space is factorized in two subspaces spanned by pairs of eigenvectors . a system prepared in @xmath163 , freely evolving for a time @xmath164 , yields the entangled state @xmath165 , corresponding to a @xmath151 operation . the pair of states @xmath166 and @xmath167 span the subspace where the @xmath151 gate is realized , which we name swap - subspace . the subspace spanned by the pair of states @xmath168 and @xmath169 is termed z - subspace . eq.([eq : hamiltonian ] ) models , for instance , capacitive coupled charge qubits or inductively coupled flux qubits @xcite . typically , these system can be driven by pulses acting along the transverse direction , @xmath9 . the same port introduces noise into the system @xcite . this is the case of the charge - phase two - port design of ref . @xcite . ] . here we consider noise sources acting transversely with respect to each qubit , i. e. the interaction hamiltonian takes the form @xmath170 each noise component @xmath16 has broadband spectrum @xmath20 , @xmath21 followed by a white flank at frequencies @xmath171 . correlated noise sources acting on both qubits have been addressed in @xcite . if the system is initialized in the swap subspace , for instance in the state @xmath172 , bitwise readout gives the qubit 1 switching probability @xmath173 , i.e. the probability that it will pass to the state @xmath174 , and the probability @xmath175 of finding the qubit 2 in the initial state @xmath174 . cyclic anti - correlation of the probabilities signals the formation of the entangled state during the @xmath151 operation . in terms of the two qubit reduced density matrix in the eigenstate basis the switching probabilities read @xmath176 + \rho_{00}(t ) + \left [ \ , \rho_{33}(t ) - \rho_{00}(t ) \right ] \sin^2 \frac{\varphi}{2 } \nonumber \\ & & + { \rm re}[\rho_{12}(t ) ] + { \rm re } [ \rho_{03}(t ) ] \sin \varphi \label{eq : psw1 } \\ \!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!\!p^{(2)}(t ) = \langle - | { \rm tr}_1 \rho(t ) | - \rangle & = & \frac{1}{2 } \left [ \ , \rho_{11}(t ) + \rho_{22}(t ) \right ] + \rho_{00}(t ) + \left [ \ , \rho_{33}(t ) - \rho_{00}(t ) \right ] \sin^2 \frac{\varphi}{2 } \nonumber \\ & & - { \rm re}[\rho_{12}(t ) ] + { \rm re}[\rho_{03}(t ) ] \sin \varphi . \label{eq : psw2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the matrix elements entering the above probabilities can be evaluated in the multi - stage approach . we split the interaction as in eq.([int - plit ] ) , @xmath177 . low - frequency noise is treated in the adiabatic and longitudinal approximation . in addition we limit the analysis to the spa . we denote with @xmath178 the eigenvalues of @xmath179 with @xmath180 . _ first stage : elimination of quantum noise _ quantum noise is traced out by solving the born - markov master equation for the reduced density matrix @xcite with eigenvalues parametrically dependent on the random fields @xmath181 . in the system eigenstate basis with @xmath180 ] and performing the secular approximation ( to be self - consistently checked ) it takes the standard form @xcite : @xmath183 where @xmath184 . the rates @xmath185 , @xmath186 depend on the real parts of the lesser and greater green s functions , describing emission ( absorption ) rates to ( from ) the quantum reservoirs @xcite . in addition , for white quantum noise energy shifts are vanishing and do not appear in eq . ( [ eq : coherences ] ) . because of the symmetry of ( [ eq : hamiltonian ] ) , dissipative transitions inside each - swap or z - subspace are forbidden . the allowed inelastic energy exchange processes are evidenced in fig.([splittings ] ) . the only independent emission rates are @xmath187 , @xmath188 . they read @xmath189 \\ \gamma_{20 } = \frac{1}{8 } \ , ( 1-\sin \varphi ) \ , [ c_{x_1}(\omega_{20 } ) + c_{x_2}(\omega_{20 } ) ] \ , , \end{array } \label{eq : ratesgeneral}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the absorption rates , @xmath190 , are related to the spectrum of quantum noise , @xmath191 . emission rates have the same form with @xmath192 replaced by @xmath193 . for the considered initial condition , @xmath194 , the only non vanishing elements of the reduced density matrix in the eigenbasis of @xmath195 are the populations and the swap coherence , @xmath196 . for independent quantum noise sources acting on the two qubits , the swap decay rate reads @xmath197 = \frac{1}{2 } \ , [ \gamma_1 + \gamma_2 ] $ ] , where @xmath198 , @xmath199 , are relaxation rates of the swap levels . from eq.([eq : coherences ] ) we get @xmath200 the secular approximation is valid provided that @xmath201 . this condition is fulfilled , for instance , for white noise levels extrapolated from single charge - phase qubit experiments , as it can be evinced from the slow decay due to quantum noise reported in fig.([figure2 ] ) , gray line . equations ( [ eq : populations ] ) for the populations do not decouple even in the secular limit . general solutions are quite lengthy . here we report the approximate forms in the small temperature limit with respect to the uncoupled qubits splittings , @xmath202 . in this case level @xmath203 remains unpopulated and @xmath204 \quad , \quad \rho_{11}(t ) \approx \frac{1}{2 } \ , e^{- \gamma_{10 } t } \quad , \quad \rho_{22}(t ) \approx \frac{1}{2 } \ , e^{- \gamma_{20 } t } \ , . \label{populations}\end{aligned}\ ] ] _ second stage : elimination of adiabatic noise _ we now consider the effect of low - frequencies in the adiabatic , longitudinal and static path approximations . populations are unaffected by adiabatic noise , whereas the swap coherence , @xmath205 , has to be averaged over @xmath206 . here we disregard the negligible @xmath206 dependence of the rates @xmath207 via @xmath208 . under these simplifying assumption , we are left with the following average @xmath209 with @xmath210}$ ] . the swap splitting can be estimated by treating in perturbation theory @xmath211 , with @xmath180 , with respect to @xmath157 . this leads to @xmath212 the average in eq . ( [ eq : staticint ] ) can be evaluated in analytic form and gives @xcite @xmath213 \label{eq : spa - swap}\ ] ] where @xmath214 , and @xmath215 $ ] is the k - bessel function of order zero @xcite . we considered equal standard deviations for noise sources acting on both qubits , @xmath216 . inserting ( [ populations ] ) and ( [ eq : spa - swap ] ) in ( [ eq : psw1 ] ) and ( [ eq : psw2 ] ) we obtain the switching probabilities in the multi - stage approach . out of phase oscillations signals two - qubit states anti - correlations and follows from @xmath217 $ ] , with @xmath218 + \cos^2\left ( \frac{\varphi}{2}\right ) \approx - \frac{1}{4 } \ , \cos \varphi \ , \left [ e^{- \gamma_{10}t } + e^{- \gamma_{20}t } \right ] + g^2/4 $ ] . the efficiency of the gate results from the interplay of quantum and adiabatic noise . high - frequency noise levels expected from single qubit experiments @xcite weakly affect the switching probability , whose decay is mainly due to low - frequency noise , fig . ( [ figure2 ] ) . remarkably , considerable recovery of short - times oscillation amplitude may be achieved by an optimal choice of the coupling strength , @xmath219 @xcite . this regime is illustrated in fig.([figure3 ] ) . in this article we presented a road - map to treat broadband noise typical of solid state nanodevices . the introduced multi - stage approach allows to obtain reasonable approximations by systematically including only the relevant information on the complex environment , out of the huge parametrization which would be required for a microscopic description . since the environment is in general long - time correlated , the required information depends on the specific protocol . the predictions obtained with the present approach are in agreement with observations in various single qubit jj implementations and in different protocols @xcite . we extended the procedure to deal with complex solid - state architectures . this is a required step in order to predict efficiency and possibly appropriately design of nanodevices for quantum information processing . both because of the complexity of architectures and of the unavoidable broadband nature of solid state noise , theoretical tools allowing systematic and controlled approximations are particularly valuable . as an illustrative case , we performed a simplified analysis of the effects and interplay of low and high frequency noise components in a two - qubit gate in a fixed coupling scheme . our results points out that efficient operations in the solid state require an accurate preliminary characterization of the noise spectral characteristics and tuning appropriately the device working point . we acknowledge support from the eu - eurosqip ( ist-3 - 015708-ip ) . 99 m. nielsen , i. chuang , `` quantum computation and quantum information '' , cambridge univ . press , 2005 . t. hyashi _ et al . _ , lett . * 91 * , 226804 ( 2003 ) ; j. r. petta _ et al . lett . * 93 * , 186802 ( 2004 ) ; j.r . et al . _ , science * 309 * , 2180 ( 2005 ) ; j. gorman , d.g . hasko , and d.a . williams , phys . lett . * 95 * , 090502 ( 2005 ) ; f. h. l. koppens _ et al . _ , nature * 442 * , 766 ( 2006 ) . y. nakamura _ et al . _ , nature * 398 * , 786 ( 1999 ) ; y. yu _ et al . _ , science * 296 * , 889 ( 2002 ) ; j.m . martinis _ et al . _ , lett . * 89 * , 117901 ( 2002 ) ; i. chiorescu _ et al . _ , science , * 299 * , 1869 , ( 2003 ) ; t. yamamoto _ et al . _ , nature * 425 * , 941 ( 2003 ) ; s. saito _ et al . * 93 * , 037001 ( 2004 ) ; j. johansson _ et al . _ , ibid . * 96 * , 127006 ( 2006 ) ; f. deppe _ et al . _ , nat . * 4 * , 686 ( 2008 ) ; d. vion _ et al . _ , science * 296 * , 886 ( 2002 ) . j. koch et al . a * 76 * , 042319 ( 2007 ) ; j. a. schreier _ et al . _ , b * 77 * , 180502(r ) ( 2008 ) . d. i. schuster , _ et al . _ nature * 431 * , 162 ( 2004 ) ; d. i. schuster _ nature * 445 * , 515 ( 2007 ) ; m. gppl _ nature * 454 * , 315 ( 2008 ) ; lev s. bishop _ et al . _ nature physics * 5 * , 105 ( 2008 ) . y. nakamura _ et . al _ , phys . lett . * 88 * , 047901 ( 2002 ) . g. falci , e. paladino , r. fazio , in _ quantum phenomena of mesoscopic systems _ , b. l. altshuler and v. tognetti eds . , proc . of the international school `` enrico fermi '' , varenna 2002 , ios press ( 2003 ) , cond - mat/0312550 . lett . * 94 * , 167002 ( 2005 ) . c. p. slichter _ principles of magnetic resonance _ , springer - verlag , berlin ( 1996 ) s. kafanof _ et al . b , * 78 * , 125411 ( 2008 ) . o. astafiev _ lett . * 93 * , 267007 ( 2004 ) . g. ithier _ et al . _ , b * 72 * , 134519 ( 2005 ) . r.w . et al . _ , phys . lett . * 93 * , 077003 ( 2004 ) ; k.b . cooper _ et al . _ , ibid . * 93 * , 180401 ( 2004 ) . j. eroms _ et al . . lett . * 89 * , 122516 ( 2006 ) . c. h. van der wal , _ et al . _ , science 290 , 773777 ( 2000 ) . t. duty _ et al . _ , phys . rev . b * 69 * , 140503(r ) ( 2004 ) ; y. m. galperin _ 96 * , 097009 ( 2006 ) ; j bergli , y m galperin and b l altshuler , new j. phys . * 11 * , 025002 ( 2009 ) . f. chiarello private communication 2008 . experiment based on the setup of s.poletto _ et al . _ new j. phys . * 11 * , 013009 ( 2008 ) . r. fazio , g. m. palma , and j. siewert phys . 83 * , 5385 ( 1999 ) . , rev . * 60 * , 537 ( 1988 ) . j. claudon _ et al . _ , b * 76 * , 024508 ( 2007 ) ; l. tian and r.w . simmonds , phys . 99 * , 137002 ( 2007 ) ; f. deppe _ b * 76 * , 214503 ( 2007 ) ; z. kim , _ b * 78 * , 144506 ( 2008 ) ; a. lupascu _ _ arxiv:0810.0590 . a. m. zagoskin _ lett . * 97 * , 077001 ( 2006 ) . m. neeley , _ et al . _ nature physics * 4 * , 523 ( 2008 ) . e. paladino _ b * 77 * , 041303(r)(2008 ) . s. ashab _ _ , new j. phys . * 8 * , 103 ( 2006 ) ; n. p oxtoby _ et al . _ new j. phys . * 11 * , 063028 ( 2009 ) . c. cohen - tannoudji , j. dupont - roc and g. grynberg _ atom - photon interactions _ , wiley - interscience ( 1993 ) . e. paladino _ et al . _ , * 88 * , 228304 ( 2002 ) . correlated noise and cross - talk effects have been addressed in a. darrigo _ et al . njp * 10 * , 115006 ( 2008 ) . g. falci _ _ in preparation . w. zurek , physics today * 44 * , 36 ( 1991 ) . g. m. palma , k.a . suominen , a. k. ekert , proc . london a , * 452 * , 567 ( 1996 ) . d. g. cory _ * 81 * , 2152 ( 1998 ) . c. isham , _ lectures on quantum theory : mathematical and structural foundations _ , imperial college press , london ( 1995 ) . y. makhlin , a. shnirman , phys . lett . * 92 * , 178301 ( 2004 ) . a.b . zorin _ et al . _ , b * 53 * , 13682 ( 1996 ) . ( [ ref : quadratic ] ) is also valid for ornstein - uhlenbeck processes , see @xcite . for random telegraph noise the discrete nature of the process modifies this result see e. paladino _ state phys . , * 43 * , 747 ( 2003 ) k. rabenstein , v.a . sverdlov , d.v . averin jetp letters * 79 * , 646 ( 2004 ) . et al . _ , nature * 398 * , 305 ( 1999 ) ; j. q. you _ et al . lett . * 89 * , 197902 ( 2002 ) . . a. pashkin _ et al . _ , nature * 421 * , 823 ( 2003 ) ; a. j. berkley _ et al . _ , science * 300 * , 1548 ( 2003 ) ; t. yamamoto _ et al . _ , nature * 425 * , 941 ( 2003 ) ; r. mcdermott _ et al . _ , science * 307 * , 1299 ( 2005 ) ; j. b. majer _ lett . * 94 * , 090501 ( 2005 ) ; m. steffen _ et al . _ , science * 313 * , 1423 ( 2006 ) ; j.h . et al . _ , nature * 447 * , 836 ( 2007 ) . m. a. sillanp , j. i. park and r. w. simmonds nature * 449 * , 438 ( 2007 ) . averin , c. bruder , phys . * 91 * , 057003 ( 2003 ) ; a. blais _ et al . _ , ibid . * 90 * , 127901 ( 2003 ) ; f. plastina , g. falci , phys . b * 67 * , 224514 ( 2003 ) ; b.plourde _ et al . _ , ibid . * 70 * , 140501(r ) ( 2004 ) ; a.o . niskanen , y. nakamura , j.s . tsai , ibid . * 73 * , 094506 ( 2006 ) ; p. bertet , c. j. harmans , j.e . mooij , ibid . * 73 * , 064512 ( 2006 ) ; y - d wang , a. kemp , k. semba , ibid . * 79 * , 024502 ( 2009 ) . c. rigetti , a. blais , and m. devoret , phys . * 94 * , 240502 ( 2005 ) ; yu - xi liu _ et al . _ , ibid . * 96 * , 067003 ( 2006 ) ; g. s. paraoanu , phys . rev . b 74 , 140504(r ) ( 2006 ) . t. v. filippov _ et al . _ , ieee trans . * 13 * , 1005 ( 2003 ) ; j. lantz _ et al . b * 70 * , 140507(r ) ( 2004 ) ; a. maassen van den brink _ et al . _ , new j. phys . * 7 * , 230 ( 2005 ) . a. izmalkov _ * 93 * , 037003 ( 2004 ) ; m. grajcar _ _ , prb * 72 * , 02503 ( 2005 ) ; t. hime _ et al . _ , science * 314 * , 1427 ( 2006 ) ; a. o. niskanen _ _ , science * 316 * 723 ( 2007 ) ; a. o. niskanen _ et al . _ , nature * 447 * , 386 ( 2007 ) ; j. majer _ _ , ibid . * 449 * , 443 ( 2007 ) ; s. h. w. van der ploeg _ et al . _ , * 98 * , 057004 ( 2007 ) ; a. fay _ * 100 * , 187003 ( 2008 ) ; a. o. niskanen _ et al . _ , b * 77 * , 064505 ( 2008 ) ; k. harrabi _ _ , phys . rev . b 79 , 020507 ( 2009 ) . e. paladino , a. mastellone , a. darrigo , g. falci , arxiv:0906.3115 u. weiss , `` quantum dissipative systems '' , third edition , world scientific 2008 . m. abramowitz , i. a. stegun `` handbook of mathematical functions '' , dover ( 1965 ) . e. paladino _ at al . _ physica e in press ( 2009 ) .
Abstract: | [
"broadband noise represents a severe limitation towards the implementation of a solid - state quantum information processor . considering common spectral forms , we propose a classification of noise sources based on the effects produced instead of on their microscopic origin . we illustrate a multi - stage approach to broadband noise which systematically includes only the relevant information on the environment , out of the huge parametrization needed for a microscopic description . we apply this technique to a solid - state two - qubit gate in a fixed coupling implementation scheme ."
] | 8,747 | 8,747 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in this note , we review the connection between ads / cft duality and quark - gluon plasma ( qgp ) experiments at rhic ( see ref . @xcite for a review of qgp physics ) . rhic stands for relativistic heavy ion collider at brookhaven national laboratory . heavy ion " comes from the fact that it collides heavy ions such as gold nuclei @xmath1au instead of usual @xmath2 , @xmath3 or @xmath4 . the goal of the experiment is to realize the deconfinement transition and form the quark - gluon plasma . in principle , it should be possible to form qgp if one has high enough temperature or high enough density . however , it is not an easy job to confirm qgp formation because of the following problems : first , what one observes is not qgp itself but only the by - products after hadoronization , and one has to infer what had happened from the by - products . second , those secondary particles are mostly strongly - interacting , and the perturbative qcd is not very reliable for the current and near - future experimental temperatures . to resolve these problems , many attempts are made to identify the generic signatures of qgp . some of the generic signatures discussed to date are as follows : 1 . the elliptic flow which may be the consequence of very low viscosity of qgp 2 . the jet quenching 3 . @xmath5-suppression all of these signatures have been discussed in the ads / cft duality , so i review recent developments focusing on these phenomena . d - branes represent a @xmath6 gauge theory . ] since this review is aimed at non - experts , i first give a short course on string theory , in particular emphasizing on how gauge theories and black holes are described in string theory . figure [ fig : string ] shows main ingredients of string theory . there are two kinds of string : open strings with endpoints and closed strings with no endpoints . as i will show you shortly , an open string represents a gauge theory . a closed string represents a graviton . an open string propagates through spacetime just like a closed string , but an open string can also have its endpoints on an object , the so - called d - brane . the open string i consider in this lecture is always of this type . the easiest way to see that an open string represents a gauge theory is look at how the string oscillates . figure [ fig : level1 ] shows the simplest open string oscillation ( in 4 dimensions ) . as you can see , the string can oscillate in two directions . so , the open string has two degrees of freedom at this level . these degrees of freedom represent the two polarizations of the photon . in this sense , the open string represents a gauge theory . of course , our interest here is not qed , but rather qcd , so how can one describe a yang - mills theory ? an open string has endpoints on a d - brane , but if there are @xmath7 coincident d - branes , open strings can have endpoints in various ways ( fig . [ fig : sym ] ) . these new degrees of freedom precisely correspond to @xmath6 degrees of freedom . since these open strings are constrained to have their endpoints on the d - brane , the gauge theory described by the d - brane is localized on the d - brane . the d - branes arise with various dimensionalities . a d - brane with a @xmath8-dimensional spatial extension is called the d@xmath8-brane . namely , the d0-brane is point - like , the d1-brane is string - like , the d2-brane is membrane - like , and so on . thus , the d@xmath8-brane describes a @xmath9-dimensional yang - mills theory . we are interested in 4-dimensional gauge theories , so consider the d3-brane in order to mimic qcd . on the other hand , a closed string represents a graviton . again , the easiest way to see this is to look at how the string oscillates ( fig . [ fig : closed ] ) . in general , the oscillations on a string have two modes : the left - moving modes and right - moving modes . for an open string , these modes mix each other at endpoints , but these modes become independent for a closed string . so , one can oscillate the right - moving mode in one direction and the left - moving mode in the other direction . in a sense , a closed string oscillates in two directions simultaneously . this property explains the spin-2 nature of the graviton . in fact , a graviton also oscillates in two directions simultaneously . strictly speaking , a closed string represents a graviton and two undiscovered scalar particles , the dilaton and the axion . since each mode has two degrees of freedom , a closed string has 4 degrees of freedom at this level ( in 4 dimensions ) . the graviton has only 2 degrees of freedom , and two scalar fields cover the remaining degrees of freedom . we have seen that we can get a gauge theory from the d - brane , but it is not clear if the d - brane is simply described by a gauge theory . this is because string theory is more than a gauge theory , namely it has gravitons . at this point , it is not clear if the effect of gravity can be neglected . according to general relativity , any energy - momentum tensor curves spacetime . the d - brane of course has some energy , so how the d - branes curve spacetime ? since gravity is described by the newton potential _ newton ~ , one can measure the effect of curvature by @xmath10 . according to string theory , the newton constant @xmath11 and the mass @xmath12 of the d - brane are given by g & ~ & g_s^2 , + m & ~ & n / g_s , where @xmath13 is the string coupling constant which governs the strength of the interactions between strings . , which is consistent with the hypersurface picture of the d - brane , and the open strings attached represent the fluctuations of the d - brane . ] so , one gets @xmath14 . this means that as long as @xmath15 , one can neglect the effects of gravity and spacetime remains flat . in this case , the d - brane is simply described by a gauge theory . on the other hand , when @xmath16 , the d - brane starts to curve spacetime , and eventually it should become a black hole . so , in this case , the d - brane can be described by a black hole . the black hole here is not the usual schwarzschild - like black hole . we consider a d - brane , an object with infinite spatial extension . thus , the black hole formed from the d - brane has an horizon which extends indefinitely and is called the black brane . " to summarize , one can describe the d - brane both by a gauge theory and by a black hole ; which description is better depends on the value of @xmath17 . the string coupling and the yang - mills coupling @xmath18 are related by @xmath19 ( see sec . [ sec : details ] ) , so @xmath17 is nothing but the standard t hooft coupling , @xmath20 . this suggests that the black hole is the large t hooft coupling limit of a gauge theory . since t hooft coupling is the effective coupling of a gauge theory , the black hole is the strong coupling limit of the gauge theory ( fig . [ fig : largen ] ) . thus , the strategy here is to use black holes in order to compute gauge theory observables in the strong coupling regime . our argument here is very rough , but more refined version of the argument is known as the ads / cft duality @xcite ( see ref . @xcite for a review ) . the precise correspondence is as follows : + & & _ 5 s^5 . [ eq : dual ] here , @xmath21 means that the theory has 4 supercharges which are the maximum number of supercharges for a 4-dimensional theory . also , @xmath22 stands for the five - dimensional anti - desitter space . desitter was a dutch astronomer who found a solution of einstein equation with a constant positive curvature in 1917 . the space @xmath22 instead has a constant negative curvature ; this explains the prefix anti . " one can reach this correspondence by studying the d3-brane more carefully , but i will skip the argument . instead , i explain the correspondence from the symmetry point of view in appendix . we will use the finite temperature version of the duality and its cousins ; in this case , one needs to replace @xmath22 by a black hole in @xmath22 , which is known as the schwarzschild-@xmath22 black hole : + & & + & & _ 5 ) s^5 . according to the rhic experiment , qgp behaves like a liquid . the ads / cft then implies that a black hole also behaves like a liquid . then , plasma quantities should be calculable from black holes . in fact , black holes and hydrodynamic systems behave similarly . consider adding a perturbation to a black hole , _ e.g. _ , drop some object ( fig . [ fig : hydro ] ) . then , the shape of the black hole horizon becomes irregular , but such a perturbation decays quickly , and the black hole returns to the original symmetric shape . the no - hair theorem is one way to see this . according to the theorem , the stationary black hole is unique and symmetric . thus , the perturbed black hole can not be stable . if you regard this as a diffusion , the diffusion occurs since the perturbation is absorbed by the black hole . this behavior is very similar to a liquid . suppose that one drops a ball in a water pond . then , you generate surface waves , but they decay quickly , and the water pond returns to a state of stable equilibrium . in hydrodynamics , this is a consequence of viscosity . thus , one can consider the notion of viscosity for black holes as well . and the viscosity " for black holes should be calculable by considering the above process . let me remind you of freshman physics of viscosity . as a simple example , consider a fluid between two plates and move the upper plate with velocity @xmath23 ( fig . [ fig : viscosity ] ) . as the fluid is dragged , the lower plate experiences a force . this force is the manifestation of the viscosity . in this case , the force @xmath24 the lower plate experiences per unit area is given by = . the proportionality constant @xmath25 is called the ( shear ) viscosity . microscopically , the viscosity arises due to the momentum transfer between molecules . figure [ fig : viscosity ] shows a close - up view of the fluid and i put an artificial boundary to divide the fluid into two parts . the molecules collide with each other and are exchanged randomly through the boundary . but in the situation where you move the upper plate , the molecules in the upper - half part , on average , have more momentum in the @xmath26-direction than the ones in the lower - half part . these molecules are exchanged , which means that momentum in the @xmath26-direction is transported through the boundary . going back to the black hole , how can one calculate the plasma viscosity ? i will first give a brief explanation and its implications and then i will justify the claim more in detail . there are many ways to compute the viscosity and i will explain one simple method . in the gravity side , the diffusion occurs by black hole absorption . so , it is natural to associate the shear viscosity with the absorption cross section by black holes . ( i explain this point more in detail later . the detailed argument suggests that this is the cross section for the graviton of particular polarization . ) now , there is a general theorem on black holes @xcite that states that the cross section @xmath27 is equal to the horizon area @xmath28 for a broad range of black holes . ] : _ 0_bh = a . [ eq : absorption ] but the horizon area is the famous quantity , namely it represents the black hole entropy , so it must be the plasma entropy in this lecture . ] s_bh = k_b [ eq : entropy ] ( @xmath29 : boltzmann constant ) . then , the shear viscosity divided by the entropy becomes constant .. we consider black holes with infinite extension , so the entropy itself diverges . the area for the absorption cross section should be understood in a similar way . ] the constant can be determined from the argument later and the result is = . [ eq : viscosity_bound ] this value is very small . in comparison , @xmath30 for water is about @xmath31 under normal circumstances . now , the point is that all the relations we used ( cross section versus horizon area , black hole entropy versus horizon area ) are generic , so the result must be universal as well . namely , it does not depend on the details of black holes nor the details of gauge theories . so , the claim is @xcite _ gauge theory plasmas which have gravity duals have a universal low value of @xmath30 at large t hooft coupling . _ this is a rather indirect argument , but this claim has indeed been checked for many known gravity duals . this result is very important , so let me rephrase in a different way ( fig . [ fig : universality ] ) . gauge theories of which we can actually compute the shear viscosity are supersymmetric gauge theories , not the real qcd . we compute the shear viscosity from black holes , but the gravity dual of qcd is not known . so , one can not use ads / cft directly to compute qcd properties . however , as we saw , the quantity corresponding to the shear viscosity is universal on the black hole side , so one can immediately apply the @xmath21 result to the real qcd even though these two theories are completely different . in fact , rhic suggests that qgp has a very low viscosity and the estimated value @xcite ~o(0.1 ) ? is very close to the above ads / cft value . one important point is that the temperature in question is still order of @xmath32 . at this range of temperature , qcd is still strongly coupled and pqcd is not very reliable . in fact , the naive extrapolation of the weak coupling result gives a larger value for @xmath30 . thus , the ads / cft duality which predicts the strong coupling behavior may be useful to analyze qgp . i now describe the relation between the shear viscosity and the absorption cross section . to do so , one first has to understand the interactions of bulk and boundary fields . these fields can interact at the boundary . for example , the graviton produces the back - to - back scattering of gluons ( fig . [ fig : absorption ] ) . the relevant interactions are s_int ~d^4x f_^2 + h^ t_^ym + [ eq : interactions ] ( @xmath33 : dilaton , @xmath34 : graviton , @xmath35 and @xmath36 : the field strength and the energy - momentum tensor of the gauge theory ) . such interactions can be obtained by expanding the d - brane action around the expectation values of the bulk fields . the d - brane is described by the so - called dirac - born - infeld ( dbi ) action . the dbi - action with at most two derivatives contains the following term : ~e^- f_^2 + . if @xmath33 is constant , one gets the standard gauge theory lagrangian with @xmath37 , where @xmath38 . if @xmath33 fluctuates , the action is expanded as ~e^- ( f_^2 + f_^2 ) , where @xmath39 . the second term is nothing but the first term in eq . ( [ eq : interactions ] ) . this fact could be stated as _ bulk field fluctuations act as sources of boundary fields _ i just rephrase the same statement , but this leads to the so - called gkp - witten relation , " which is the definition of the ads / cft . given the interaction term , one can easily calculate the graviton decay rate ( with polarization @xmath40 , where @xmath26 and @xmath41 are directions along the brane ) from the standard field theory formula : _ qft & = & _ + & & ( 2)^4 ^4(p_f - p_i ) |m|^2 + & = & d^4 x e^it . the first equality is just the fermi s golden rule with matrix element @xmath42 . the matrix element is proportional to @xmath43 , so the formula is written by a correlator of the energy - momentum tensor . ( this is an optical theorem . ) the factor @xmath44 is a statistical factor for identical particles in the final state . in black hole description , it is natural to regard this decay rate as the absorption cross section of the graviton . this has been checked for the d3-brane at zero temperature @xcite , so ) is known to hold for the d3-brane at zero temperature but it is unclear if it also holds for generic ads black holes . the problem is that a black hole is the strong coupling limit of a gauge theory , so eq . ( [ eq : correlator ] ) is the strong coupling statement . but , of course , it is not easy to compute the right - hand side in gauge theory . one can compute it in the weak coupling , but weak coupling results differ from strong coupling results in general as we will see in sec . [ sec : others ] . in the special case of the zero - temperature d3-brane , such a comparison actually makes sense due to the nonrenormalization theorem , and this is the case where eq . ( [ eq : correlator ] ) has been checked . but it is an open question if this is also true for generic ads black holes . here , we simply assume that the relation holds at strong coupling . ] _ bh= d^4 x e^it . [ eq : correlator ] we can use this relation to compute the shear viscosity since the viscosity is given by a kubo formula microscopically : = _ 0 d^4 x e^it . this formula has the same form as the absorption cross section , so one can immediately write the viscosity in terms of the cross section : = . we have written plasma quantities in terms of black hole quantities . using eqs . ( [ eq : absorption ] ) and ( [ eq : entropy ] ) , one obtains = = . this is the previous formula ( [ eq : viscosity_bound ] ) . we saw that in gauge theories at strong coupling the ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density is universal . how far has the universality been shown ? recently , the universality has been extended to a variety of situations which are not covered in the original proofs . the shear viscosity was first computed for the d3-brane @xcite . this corresponds to the @xmath21 sym which is a scale - invariant theory . ( actually , the theory has a larger symmetry , a conformal symmetry . see appendix . ) but the universality has been shown even for theories with scales , _ i.e. _ , nonconformal theories . examples include d@xmath8-branes for @xmath45 , the klebanov - tseytlin geometry , the maldacena - nunez geometry , and the @xmath46 system ( these theories also have a reduced number of supersymmetries ) . in fact , various universality arguments were demonstrated for these cases @xcite . however , these proofs did not cover the cases with a chemical potential . so , the natural question is what happens to the universality at finite chemical potential . actually , it is not easy to realize the realistic finite density in ads / cft , _ i.e. _ , baryon number density . but there is a simple alternative . namely , consider charged ads black holes instead of neutral black holes . a black hole is known to obey thermodynamic - like laws and its first law is written as dm = tds_bh+dq ( @xmath47 : black hole temperature , @xmath48 : electromagnetic potential , @xmath49 : black hole charge ) . as one can see , the electromagnetic field @xmath48 plays a role of a chemical potential . in ads / cft , such a charge arises as follows . as in eq . ( [ eq : dual ] ) , the full geometry involves @xmath50 . one can add an angular momentum along @xmath50 , which is known as the spinning " d3-brane solutions @xcite . the angular momentum becomes a kaluza - klein charge after the @xmath50 reduction . what is the gauge theory interpretation of the charge ? the symmetry of @xmath50 corresponds to an internal symmetry of the sym , r - symmetry @xmath51 . this @xmath51 rotates adjoint scalars in the @xmath21 supermultiplet . ( see appendix . ) the r - symmetry group @xmath51 is rank 3 , so one can add at most three independent charges . the three - charge solution is known as the stu solution @xcite . when all charges are equal , the stu solution is the well - known reissner - nordstrm-@xmath22 black hole . thus , the charge in question is a @xmath52 charge . because the charge corresponds to the @xmath52 charge , this is by no means realistic . however , the theory has interesting features which are common to the real qcd . for instance , the phase diagram is qualitatively similar to the qcd diagram @xcite . this system does not represent a realistic chemical potential , but it may mimic the realistic case and one may learn an interesting lesson for gauge theory plasmas at finite density . the shear viscosity for charged ads black holes was computed by 4 groups , and the result turns out to be @xmath53 again @xcite-@xcite . so , the universality seems to hold even at nonzero chemical potential . if this is true for generic chemical potential , @xmath53 may be true even at finite baryon number density . in fact , when there is a chemical potential associated with a global symmetry , the universality has been proven in more general settings as well @xcite-@xcite . the theories described so far all have matter in the adjoint representation and not in the fundamental representation such as quarks . however , the universality has been proven even in the presence of fundamental matter @xcite . one way to include fundamental matter is to include d7-branes in addition to d3-branes . i will describe one simple way to realize fundamental matter in the next section , and the d3-d7 system is an extension of the method . this d3-d7 system is known as karch - katz model @xcite . gauge theory plasmas described so far are stationary ones . the real plasma at rhic is of course a rapidly changing system , and it is desirable to study such a plasma as well . in the gravity side , this corresponds to a time - dependent black hole . the universality has been claimed even for such a case @xcite . we saw that @xmath53 , but this is in the strong coupling limit or in the large t hooft coupling limit @xmath54 . real qcd of course has finite coupling , so how about @xmath30 at finite coupling ? in general , the shear viscosity is given by ~|vl_mfp ( @xmath55 : mass density , @xmath56 : mean velocity , @xmath57 : mean free path ) . at weak coupling , the interaction becomes weaker , so the mean free path becomes larger . the viscosity arises due to the momentum transfer , and the transfer is more effective at weak coupling . so , at weak coupling , one expects @xmath58 . and @xmath7 ( or @xmath18 and @xmath59 ) , so there are two kinds of finite - coupling corrections . first is the finite-@xmath59 correction described here . this corresponds to the so - called @xmath60-corrections in the gravity side . the effective actions of string theory contain higher curvature terms in addition to the einstein - hilbert action ; _ e.g. _ , @xmath61 . the finite-@xmath59 correction comes from such higher curvature terms . on the other hand , the finite-@xmath18 correction comes from the so - called string loop corrections since the string coupling constant is proportional to @xmath62 . such a correction to @xmath25 has never been evaluated . ] for the @xmath21 sym , the finite-@xmath59 correction can be computed , and the correction indeed raises the value of @xmath30 @xcite . the correction is about 9% if one uses @xmath63 ( or @xmath64 ) . thus , the strong coupling result seems a good approximation . the universality does not hold for finite-@xmath59 corrections though , so it is not clear how realistic the result is . figure [ fig : finite_coupling ] shows both the weak coupling result and the strong coupling result . they both increase at weak coupling . however , there is a difference . the viscosity is proportional to the mean free path , so is inversely proportional to the coupling constant . thus , the naive extrapolation of the weak coupling result suggests the perfect - fluid - like behavior in the strong coupling limit . instead , ads / cft tells that @xmath30 can not be small indefinitely and is saturated . incidentally , our problem is the strong coupling problem , so one might wonder how useful lattice computations are . a lattice computation of the viscosity for the pure yang - mills theory has been done in ref . unfortunately , the result has very large error bars , so one can not make a definite statement , but it would be very interesting to make the errors smaller . both from the weak coupling result and the strong coupling result . the red line represents the weak coupling result , _ i.e. _ , a naive extrapolation of the perturbative @xmath21 sym result ( based on ref . the blue line represents the strong coupling result , _ i.e. _ , the @xmath21 ads / cft result with the first order correction in @xmath59 ( based on ref . @xcite ) . ] recently , there has been much discussion on heavy quark dynamics in plasma medium . two applications have been discussed : issues related to @xmath0 suppression and issues related to jet quenching . in this section , i quickly summarize the discussion . since @xmath5 is heavy , charm pair production occurs only at the early stages of the nuclear collision . however , if the production occurs in the plasma medium , charmonium formation is suppressed due to the debye screening . one technical difficulty is that the @xmath65 pair is not produced at rest relative to the plasma . therefore , the screening length is expected to be velocity - dependent . such a computation has been done only for the abelian plasma @xcite . pair , the left configuration is not the lowest energy configuration . instead , the right configuration is energetically favorable . the energy difference is interpreted as a @xmath66 potential . at finite temperature , this is no longer true . for large enough separation of the pair , the left configuration becomes favorable . this phenomenon is the ads / cft description of the debye screening . ] first , one has to understand how to realize a heavy quark in ads / cft . to do so , let us go back to fig . [ fig : sym ] . when there are multiple number of d - branes , an open string can have endpoints in various ways ; there are @xmath67 possibilities . this means that the string transforms as the adjoint representation of @xmath6 gauge theory . now , consider an infinitely long string ( fig . [ fig : quark ] ) . in this case , the string can have endpoints in @xmath7 different ways . this means that the string transforms as the fundamental representation of @xmath6 gauge theory . in this sense , such a long string represents a quark . " such a string has an extension and tension , so the string has a large mass , which means that the long string represents a heavy quark . this kind of string has been widely studied in the past to measure the heavy quark potential @xcite . for a @xmath66 pair , two individual strings extending to the boundary is not the lowest energy configuration . instead , it is energetically favorable to have a single string that connects the pair ( fig . [ fig : wilson ] ) . the energy difference is interpreted as a @xmath66 potential , and one gets a coulomb - like potential for @xmath21 . at finite temperature @xcite , it is no longer true that a string connecting the @xmath66 pair is always the lowest energy configuration ; for large enough separation of the pair ( @xmath68 ) , isolated strings are favorable energetically . this phenomenon is the ads / cft description of the debye screening and @xmath68 may be interpreted as the screening length . references @xcite proposed how to compute the velocity dependence of the screening length . they computed the screening length in the @xmath66 rest frame , _ i.e. _ , they considered the plasma flowing at a velocity @xmath23 . such a plasma wind " is obtained by boosting a black hole . at the leading order in @xmath23 , the screening length is obtained as + & & ( 1-v^2)^1/4 + & ~ & ( ) ^-1/4 for the @xmath21 sym , where @xmath69 is the unboosted energy density . thus , the screening effect becomes stronger than the @xmath70 case . one can also compute the screening length for the other gauge theories @xcite . the leading behavior in @xmath23 seems universal . namely , if one writes the screening length as ( ) ( 1-v^2)^ , the exponent @xmath71 is determined by the speed of sound @xmath72 : 4= 1 - ( 1 - 3c_s^2 ) + [ eq : mu_vs_cs ] when the theory is nearly conformal , _ i.e. _ , @xmath73 . one can make a simple estimate of the exponent for qcd . according to the lattice results cited in ref . @xcite , all groups roughly predict @xmath74 around @xmath75 . bearing in mind that our results are valid to large-@xmath7 theories and not to qcd , eq . ( [ eq : mu_vs_cs ] ) gives @xmath76 . it would be interesting to compare this number with lattice calculations and experimental results . one can also study the screening length at finite chemical potential @xcite . at the leading order , the screening length at finite chemical potential is the same as the one at zero potential for a given energy density . another interesting qgp phenomenon is jet quenching . in the parton hard - scattering , jets are formed , but the jets have to travel in the qgp medium , so the jets are strongly suppressed . this phenomenon is known as jet quenching . so , the interesting quantity is the energy loss rate of partons . the ads / cft descriptions of jet quenching have been proposed recently @xcite-@xcite . the proposals have been quickly extended to the other gauge theories @xcite-@xcite . to discuss jet quenching , one now moves the fundamental string with a velocity @xmath23 along a brane direction . then , the momentum carried by the string flows towards the horizon and one interprets the flow as the energy loss rate . for example , the energy loss rate for the @xmath21 sym becomes = - t^2 . unfortunately , the result obtained in this way has some drawbacks . first , the result is not universal and is model - dependent . second , the black hole results become exact only in the @xmath54 limit , but the result does not have a finite large-@xmath59 limit . these two drawbacks are in contrast to the @xmath30 case . this may suggest that one has to be careful to apply ads / cft to qgp . namely , one should not always take ads / cft results at face value . hydrodynamic description of gauge theory plasmas using ads / cft is very powerful due to the universality . the ads / cft may be useful to analyze experiments . conversely , experiments or the other theoretical approaches ( such as lattice gauge theory ) may be useful to confirm ads / cft . this approach is also important since currently there are many loose ends on the ads / cft derivation . one has to clear up these loose ends , but it may be hard to make further progress within string theory alone . so , the inputs from the other areas may be useful to increase confidence in the ads / cft derivation . on the other hand , one has to be careful to apply ads / cft to qgp if the universality does not hold ( _ e.g. _ , jet quenching ) . in this talk , i emphasized the universality approach , but of course finding the gravity dual of qcd is desirable . the biggest assumption of the universality argument is that such a dual indeed exists , so finding the dual is necessary for the universality approach as well . one well - known model of qcd is the sakai - sugimoto model @xcite . this was a successful model in the confining phase , but unfortunately it is not a good model in the plasma phase . the sakai - sugimoto model involves the d4-brane compactified on a circle . above the deconfinement temperature , the model looks as a true five - dimensional theory . another problem of the current approach concerns the large-@xmath59 limit ; ads / cft and qgp are actually different limits . the large-@xmath59 limit of the ads / cft is @xmath77 and @xmath78 . but of course qgp has a large-@xmath59 since @xmath79 and @xmath80 . we are not taking the same limits , so it is not clear why both give such close results . i would like to thank elena cceres , kengo maeda , and takashi okamura for collaboration and for their comments on the manuscript . it is a pleasure to thank testuo hatsuda , tetsufumi hirano , kazunori itakura , tetsuo matsui , osamu morimatsu , berndt mller , and tadakatsu sakai for useful conversations . i would also like to thank the organizers of various workshops for the opportunity to give this lecture . the research of m.n . was supported in part by the grant - in - aid for scientific research ( 13135224 ) from the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , japan . the precise correspondence between gauge theory and gravity is as follows : + & & _ 5 s^5 . [ eq : dual2 ] one can reach this correspondence by studying the d3-brane more carefully , but instead i explain the correspondence from the symmetry point of view in this appendix . to understand why the @xmath21 sym appears , let us go back to the open string oscillations on the d3-brane . superstring theory actually requires 10-dimensional spacetime for consistency . the open strings on a d - brane are bounded on the d - brane , so the d3-brane represents a 4-dimensional gauge theory , but these open strings still oscillate in the full 10-dimensional spacetime . thus , the simplest open string oscillations have 8 degrees of freedom instead of 2 discussed in the text . what are these degrees of freedom ? in other words , what kind of gauge theory the d3-brane represents ? to see this , note that there are two types of string oscillations . first are the oscillations in the brane and the other are the oscillations out of the brane . from the 4-dimensional point of view ( in terms of @xmath81 representations ) , the former represent a gauge field . the latter represent scalars . the spatial dimension is 9 and the brane dimension is 3 , so there are 6 scalar fields . thus , the gauge theory represented by the d3-brane inevitably comes with scalar fields . the @xmath21 sym is such a theory . the field contents of the @xmath21 sym include the gauge field @xmath82 and the scalars @xmath83 . ( the color indices are suppressed for simplicity . we will also suppress the spinor indices . ) in addition , there are 4 fermions @xmath84 due to supersymmetry ( which comes from the supersymmetry in superstring . ) the lorentz transformation properties are different , but they come from similar string oscillations , which means that all these fields transform as the adjoint representation . namely , the theory has no fundamental representation such as quarks . also , if we have only d3-branes , as in the present case , the directions transverse to the brane are all isotropic . these directions correspond to the scalar fields , so the isotropy means that there is a global @xmath51 symmetry for @xmath83 . such a global symmetry is known as r - symmetry . the action for the @xmath21 sym is given by & = & \ { - f_^2 - ( d__i)^2 - |_i ^d_^i + & & + o(^4 ) + o ( ) } . first 3 terms are standard kinetic terms for the gauge field , the scalar fields , and the fermions . in addition , the action contains interaction terms which are written only schematically ; @xmath85 interactions and yukawa - like interactions . the gauge field and the scalars have mass dimension 1 and the fermions have mass dimension @xmath86 , so all terms in the action have mass dimension 4 , which means that the theory has no dimensionful parameter and the theory is scale invariant . actually , it is often the case in a relativistic field theory that the scale invariance and poincar symmetry @xmath81 combine into a larger symmetry , the conformal symmetry @xmath87 . thus , the @xmath21 sym has the global @xmath88 symmetry . the @xmath22 space is a spacetime with constant negative curvature . we are familiar with spaces with positive curvature , like the sphere , and have no problem visualizing them , but it is more difficult to visualize a space with negative curvature . a space with constant negative curvature is known as a hyperbolic space . one way to visualize a hyperbolic space is illustrated in famous woodcuts by escher ( _ e.g. _ , circle limit iii " ) . it is not easy to visualize @xmath22 , but one can represent @xmath22 as a hypersurface in a flat spacetime , which is useful for our purpose . the @xmath22 space is described by x_0 ^ 2 + x_5 ^ 2 - x_1 ^ 2 - - x_4 ^ 2 = l^2 [ eq : embedding ] in a six - dimensional flat spaceds_6 ^ 2 = -dx_0 ^ 2 - dx_5 ^ 2 + dx_1 ^ 2 + + dx_4 ^ 2 . [ eq : flat ] here , @xmath90 gives the characteristic length scale of the @xmath22 space and it is related to the t hooft coupling from the discussion in the text . note that if all signs are positive in eq . ( [ eq : embedding ] ) , eq . ( [ eq : embedding ] ) defines a sphere . also , eq . ( [ eq : embedding ] ) is a higher dimensional generalization of the standard hyperbola @xmath91 . in this form , it is clear that @xmath22 has a @xmath87 symmetry just like the @xmath21 conformal symmetry ; to say that theories are dual to each other , they should have the same symmetries . in addition , the full geometry in eq . ( [ eq : dual2 ] ) involves @xmath50 which has a @xmath51 symmetry . this is the same symmetry as the @xmath21 r - symmetry . so , the gravity side also has the global @xmath92 symmetry . k. yagi , t. hatsuda and y. miake , _ quark - gluon plasma : from big bang to little bang _ ( cambridge univ . press , 2005 ) . a. strominger and c. vafa , `` microscopic origin of the bekenstein - hawking entropy , '' phys . b * 379 * ( 1996 ) 99 [ arxiv : hep - th/9601029 ] . j. m. maldacena , `` the large n limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity , '' adv . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 231 [ int . j. theor . phys . * 38 * ( 1999 ) 1113 ] [ arxiv : hep - th/9711200 ] . e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space and holography , '' adv . theor . math . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 253 [ arxiv : hep - th/9802150 ] . e. witten , `` anti - de sitter space , thermal phase transition , and confinement in gauge theories , '' adv . * 2 * ( 1998 ) 505 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803131 ] . s. s. gubser , i. r. klebanov and a. m. polyakov , `` gauge theory correlators from non - critical string theory , '' phys . b * 428 * ( 1998 ) 105 [ arxiv : hep - th/9802109 ] . o. aharony , s. s. gubser , j. m. maldacena , h. ooguri and y. oz , `` large n field theories , string theory and gravity , '' phys . rept . * 323 * ( 2000 ) 183 [ arxiv : hep - th/9905111 ] . s. r. das , g. w. gibbons and s. d. mathur , `` universality of low energy absorption cross sections for black holes , '' phys . * 78 * ( 1997 ) 417 [ arxiv : hep - th/9609052 ] . p. kovtun , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` viscosity in strongly interacting quantum field theories from black hole physics , '' phys . rev . lett . * 94 * ( 2005 ) 111601 [ arxiv : hep - th/0405231 ] . d. teaney , `` effect of shear viscosity on spectra , elliptic flow , and hanbury brown - twiss radii , '' phys . c * 68 * ( 2003 ) 034913 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0301099 ] . t. hirano and m. gyulassy , `` perfect fluidity of the quark gluon plasma core as seen through its dissipative hadronic corona , '' nucl . a * 769 * ( 2006 ) 71 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0506049 ] . s. gavin and m. abdel - aziz , `` measuring shear viscosity using transverse momentum correlations in relativistic nuclear collisions , '' phys . * 97 * ( 2006 ) 162302 [ arxiv : nucl - th/0606061 ] . a. adare [ phenix collaboration ] , `` energy loss and flow of heavy quarks in au + au collisions at s(nn)**(1/2 ) = 200-gev , '' arxiv : nucl - ex/0611018 . i. r. klebanov , `` world - volume approach to absorption by non - dilatonic branes , '' nucl . b * 496 * ( 1997 ) 231 [ arxiv : hep - th/9702076 ] . g. policastro , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` the shear viscosity of strongly coupled n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills plasma , '' phys . * 87 * ( 2001 ) 081601 [ arxiv : hep - th/0104066 ] . kovtun , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` holography and hydrodynamics : diffusion on stretched horizons , '' jhep * 0310 * ( 2003 ) 064 [ arxiv : hep - th/0309213 ] . a. buchel and j. t. liu , `` universality of the shear viscosity in supergravity , '' phys . * 93 * ( 2004 ) 090602 [ arxiv : hep - th/0311175 ] . a. buchel , `` on universality of stress - energy tensor correlation functions in supergravity , '' phys . b * 609 * ( 2005 ) 392 [ arxiv : hep - th/0408095 ] . p. kraus , f. larsen and s. p. trivedi , `` the coulomb branch of gauge theory from rotating branes , '' jhep * 9903 * ( 1999 ) 003 [ arxiv : hep - th/9811120 ] . m. cvetic _ et al . _ , `` embedding ads black holes in ten and eleven dimensions , '' nucl . b * 558 * ( 1999 ) 96 [ arxiv : hep - th/9903214 ] . k. behrndt , m. cvetic and w. a. sabra , `` non - extreme black holes of five dimensional n = 2 ads supergravity , '' nucl . b * 553 * ( 1999 ) 317 [ arxiv : hep - th/9810227 ] . a. chamblin , r. emparan , c. v. johnson and r. c. myers , `` charged ads black holes and catastrophic holography , '' phys . d * 60 * ( 1999 ) 064018 [ arxiv : hep - th/9902170 ] . m. cvetic and s. s. gubser , `` phases of r - charged black holes , spinning branes and strongly coupled gauge theories , '' jhep * 9904 * ( 1999 ) 024 [ arxiv : hep - th/9902195 ] . j. mas , `` shear viscosity from r - charged ads black holes , '' jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 016 [ arxiv : hep - th/0601144 ] . d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` hydrodynamics of r - charged black holes , '' jhep * 0603 * ( 2006 ) 052 [ arxiv : hep - th/0601157 ] . o. saremi , `` the viscosity bound conjecture and hydrodynamics of m2-brane theory at finite chemical potential , '' arxiv : hep - th/0601159 . k. maeda , m. natsuume and t. okamura , `` viscosity of gauge theory plasma with a chemical potential from ads / cft correspondence , '' phys . d * 73 * ( 2006 ) 066013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0602010 ] . a. buchel and j. t. liu , `` gauged supergravity from type iib string theory on y(p , q ) manifolds , '' arxiv : hep - th/0608002 . p. benincasa , a. buchel and r. naryshkin , `` the shear viscosity of gauge theory plasma with chemical potentials , '' arxiv : hep - th/0610145 . j. p. gauntlett , e. o colgain and o. varela , `` properties of some conformal field theories with m - theory duals , '' arxiv : hep - th/0611219 . d. mateos , r. c. myers and r. m. thomson , `` holographic viscosity of fundamental matter , '' arxiv : hep - th/0610184 . a. karch and e. katz , jhep * 0206 * ( 2002 ) 043 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205236 ] . r. a. janik , `` viscosity from nonsingularity , '' arxiv : hep - th/0610144 . d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` minkowski - space correlators in ads / cft correspondence : recipe and applications , '' jhep * 0209 * ( 2002 ) 042 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205051 ] . g. policastro , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` from ads / cft correspondence to hydrodynamics , '' jhep * 0209 * ( 2002 ) 043 [ arxiv : hep - th/0205052 ] . c. p. herzog , `` the hydrodynamics of m - theory , '' jhep * 0212 * ( 2002 ) 026 [ arxiv : hep - th/0210126 ] . g. policastro , d. t. son and a. o. starinets , `` from ads / cft correspondence to hydrodynamics . ii : sound waves , '' jhep * 0212 * ( 2002 ) 054 [ arxiv : hep - th/0210220 ] . a. nunez and a. o. starinets , `` ads / cft correspondence , quasinormal modes , and thermal correlators in n = 4 sym , '' phys . d * 67 * ( 2003 ) 124013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0302026 ] . c. p. herzog , `` the sound of m - theory , '' phys . d * 68 * ( 2003 ) 024013 [ arxiv : hep - th/0302086 ] . a. buchel , `` n = 2 * hydrodynamics , '' nucl . phys . b * 708 * ( 2005 ) 451 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406200 ] . k. kovtun and a. o. starinets , `` quasinormal modes and holography , '' phys . rev . d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 086009 [ arxiv : hep - th/0506184 ] . p. benincasa , a. buchel and a. o. starinets , `` sound waves in strongly coupled non - conformal gauge theory plasma , '' nucl . b * 733 * ( 2006 ) 160 [ arxiv : hep - th/0507026 ] . a. buchel , `` transport properties of cascading gauge theories , '' phys . d * 72 * ( 2005 ) 106002 [ arxiv : hep - th/0509083 ] . a. buchel , j. t. liu and a. o. starinets , `` coupling constant dependence of the shear viscosity in n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills theory , '' nucl . b * 707 * ( 2005 ) 56 [ arxiv : hep - th/0406264 ] . s. c. huot , s. jeon and g. d. moore , `` shear viscosity in weakly coupled n = 4 super yang - mills theory compared to qcd , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0608062 . a. nakamura and s. sakai , `` transport coefficients of gluon plasma , '' phys . lett . * 94 * ( 2005 ) 072305 [ arxiv : hep - lat/0406009 ] . m. c. chu and t. matsui , `` dynamic debye screening for a heavy quark - antiquark pair traversing a quark - gluon plasma , '' phys . d * 39 * ( 1989 ) 1892 . j. m. maldacena , `` wilson loops in large n field theories , '' phys . * 80 * ( 1998 ) 4859 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803002 ] . s. j. rey and j. t. yee , `` macroscopic strings as heavy quarks in large n gauge theory and anti - de sitter supergravity , '' eur . j. c * 22 * ( 2001 ) 379 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803001 ] . s. j. rey , s. theisen and j. t. yee , `` wilson - polyakov loop at finite temperature in large n gauge theory and anti - de sitter supergravity , '' nucl . b * 527 * ( 1998 ) 171 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803135 ] . a. brandhuber , n. itzhaki , j. sonnenschein and s. yankielowicz , `` wilson loops in the large n limit at finite temperature , '' phys . b * 434 * ( 1998 ) 36 [ arxiv : hep - th/9803137 ] . h. liu , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , `` an ads / cft calculation of screening in a hot wind , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0607062 . m. chernicoff , j. a. garcia and a. guijosa , `` the energy of a moving quark - antiquark pair in an n=4 sym plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0607089 . k. peeters , j. sonnenschein and m. zamaklar , `` holographic melting and related properties of mesons in a quark gluon plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606195 . e. caceres , m. natsuume and t. okamura , `` screening length in plasma winds , '' arxiv : hep - th/0607233 . s. d. avramis , k. sfetsos and d. zoakos , `` on the velocity and chemical - potential dependence of the heavy - quark interaction in n = 4 sym plasmas , '' arxiv : hep - th/0609079 . h. liu , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , `` wilson loops in heavy ion collisions and their calculation in ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0612168 . m. chernicoff and a. guijosa , `` energy loss of gluons , baryons and k - quarks in an n = 4 sym plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0611155 . c. hoyos , k. landsteiner and s. montero , `` holographic meson melting , '' arxiv : hep - th/0612169 . f. karsch , `` lattice qcd at high temperature and the qgp , '' arxiv : hep - lat/0601013 . h. liu , k. rajagopal and u. a. wiedemann , `` calculating the jet quenching parameter from ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0605178 . c. p. herzog , a. karch , p. kovtun , c. kozcaz and l. g. yaffe , `` energy loss of a heavy quark moving through n = 4 supersymmetric yang - mills plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605158 . j. casalderrey - solana and d. teaney , `` heavy quark diffusion in strongly coupled n = 4 yang mills , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0605199 . s. s. gubser , `` drag force in ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605182 . a. buchel , `` on jet quenching parameters in strongly coupled non - conformal gauge theories , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605178 . c. p. herzog , `` energy loss of heavy quarks from asymptotically ads geometries , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605191 . e. caceres and a. guijosa , `` drag force in charged n=4 sym plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605235 . j. f. vazquez - poritz , `` enhancing the jet quenching parameter from marginal deformations , '' arxiv : hep - th/0605296 . e. caceres and a. guijosa , `` on drag forces and jet quenching in strongly coupled plasmas , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606134 . f. l. lin and t. matsuo , `` jet quenching parameter in medium with chemical potential from ads / cft , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606136 . s. d. avramis and k. sfetsos , `` supergravity and the jet quenching parameter in the presence of r - charge densities , '' arxiv : hep - th/0606190 . n. armesto , j. d. edelstein and j. mas , jet quenching at finite ` t hooft coupling and chemical potential from ads / cft,' arxiv : hep - ph/0606245 . e. nakano , s. teraguchi and w. y. wen , `` drag force , jet quenching , and ads / qcd , '' arxiv : hep - ph/0608274 . j. j. friess , s. s. gubser and g. michalogiorgakis , `` dissipation from a heavy quark moving through n = 4 super - yang - mills plasma , '' jhep * 0609 * ( 2006 ) 072 [ arxiv : hep - th/0605292 ] . j. j. friess , s. s. gubser , g. michalogiorgakis and s. s. pufu , `` the stress tensor of a quark moving through n = 4 thermal plasma , '' arxiv : hep - th/0607022 . j. j. friess , s. s. gubser , g. michalogiorgakis and s. s. pufu , `` stability of strings binding heavy - quark mesons , '' arxiv : hep - th/0609137 . s. s. gubser , `` comparing the drag force on heavy quarks in n=4 super - yang - mills theory and qcd , '' arxiv : hep - th/0611272 . s. s. gubser , `` jet - quenching and momentum correlators from the gauge - string duality , '' arxiv : hep - th/0612143 . p. c. argyres , m. edalati and j. f. vazquez - poritz , `` no - drag string configurations for steadily moving quark - antiquark pairs in a thermal bath , '' arxiv : hep - th/0608118 . p. c. argyres , m. edalati and j. f. vazquez - poritz , `` spacelike strings and jet quenching from a wilson loop , '' arxiv : hep - th/0612157 . s. j. sin and i. zahed , `` holography of radiation and jet quenching , '' phys . b * 608 * ( 2005 ) 265 [ arxiv : hep - th/0407215 ] . t. sakai and s. sugimoto , `` low energy hadron physics in holographic qcd , '' prog . * 113 * ( 2005 ) 843 [ arxiv : hep - th/0412141 ] .
Abstract: | [
"we review the ads / cft description of gauge theory plasmas for non - experts . we discuss the low shear viscosity , jet quenching , and @xmath0-suppression , which are three major signatures for the quark - gluon plasma observed at rhic experiments . based on invited talks presented at frontiers in the physics of quark - gluon plasma \" ( july 7 - 8 2006 , riken ) , string theory and quantum field theory \" ( sep . 12 - 16 2006 , yitp ) , the fall meeting 2006 of the physical society of japan ( sep . 20 - 22 2006 , nara women s univ . ) , ads / cft and strongly coupled quark matter \" ( nov . 21 - 22 2006 , ccast ) , ykis2006 ( nov . 20 - 28 2006 , yitp ) , a string theory workshop at rikkyo univ . ( dec . 26 - 27 2006 ) ."
] | 9,978 | 9,978 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the berry phase @xcite remains a fascinating subject with many consequences in a variety of physical systems @xcite . some time ago we proposed @xcite a number of scenarios in condensed matter settings where the berry phase manifests itself in the phase - coherent quantum dynamics of a particle carrying a spin and moving through orientationally inhomogeneous magnetic fields @xmath0 . such manifestations of the berry phase can occur , e.g. , in semiconductors or metals in the form of persistent currents @xcite or oscillations of the magnetoconductance or universal conductance fluctuations @xcite . as recognized early on@xcite , all these effects share the common feature that the orbital motion of the particle is modified by the berry phase in very much the same way as it is in well - known phase - coherent phenomena based on the aharonov - bohm effect . the first experimental evidence for such a berry phase effect has been recently found in semiconductors @xcite , in which a local effective magnetic field is produced via the rashba effect . however , whereas aharonov - bohm effects occur regardless of the strength @xmath1 of the field , berry phase effects appear only in the adiabatic limit , i.e. , for sufficiently large magnetic fields . this limit requires that roughly speaking the typical orbital frequency of the particle carrying the spin through the field is much smaller than the precession frequency of the spin around the local field direction . in this limit , the spin will remain in its instantaneous eigenstate , i.e. , will continuously align itself along the _ local _ field direction @xmath0 as it moves through the magnetic field texture . if , in addition , the particle trajectory is closed , the spin will acquire a berry phase , which is purely geometric in character . as spin and orbital motion couple via the inhomogeneity of the field , the berry phase can ultimately enter the orbital part of the effective hamiltonian in the same way that the aharonov - bohm phase does . there seems to be general agreement that once the adiabatic limit is reached the results found previously @xcite are correct . the central question then is : what is the proper criterion for the adiabatic regime ? again , there is no issue of contention in ballistic rings , e.g. , for which adiabaticity is reached when @xmath2 , where @xmath3 is the bohr frequency ( to be defined below ) , and @xmath4 is the typical time it takes the particle to go around the ring once . this situation occurs , e.g. , in clean semiconductors . but what about diffusive systems , such as normal metal rings ? it is this question that we have previously addressed in great detail @xcite and that has been recently reconsidered by van langen et al . @xcite , who claim to reach a rather pessimistic conclusion about the observability of the berry phase effect in stark contrast to our findings @xcite . it is the purpose of the present paper to show that the claim of van langen et al . @xcite is not correct . to this end , we first state the problem of adiabaticity in this section again and then provide in the following sections a general discussion on the issue of dephasing induced by inhomogeneous magnetic fields . this discussion is then followed by explicit examples that unambiguously demonstrate the observability of berry phase effects in diffusive systems of immediate experimental interest . now , in the context of weak localization physics we have advanced detailed physical and technical arguments @xcite that adiabaticity is reached more easily in diffusive than in ballistic systems ( all other parameters being equal ) . the physical explanation for this is simple : in diffusive motion around , say , a ring , the particle spends on the average much more time in a given region of field direction than it would do in purely ballistic motion . thus , there is more time for the spin to execute precessions around a given field direction , and thus the spin will have a higher probability of aligning itself along the local field direction than it would in purely ballistic motion . translating this picture into more concrete terms for an electron diffusing around a @xmath5-dimensional ring of circumference @xmath6 with static random disorder , adiabaticity is reached if the zeeman energy , @xmath7 , exceeds the thouless energy , @xmath8 . here @xmath9 is the electron g - factor , @xmath10 is the bohr magneton , @xmath11 is the diffusion constant with @xmath12 being fermi velocity , @xmath13 is the elastic mean free time , and @xmath14 is the elastic mean free path . more generally , we can also allow for the case in which the field reorients @xmath15 times as the particle goes around once the ring . whereas the case of @xmath16 is physically realizable @xcite , it seems very difficult to implement cases with @xmath17 experimentally . still , as the conclusions reached by van langen et al . @xcite are crucially based on the case @xmath18 , we shall include this possibility , and the criterion for adiabaticity as found in ref . @xcite then reads @xmath19 here , the texture dependent vector @xmath20 is some average of the direction of the magnetic field @xcite . the factor @xmath21 accounts for non - uniformity in the direction of the magnetic field , and encodes the fact that the adiabatic approximation becomes exact , regardless of @xmath3 , in the limit of a homogeneous field , for which @xmath22 . in the following discussion , however , we shall for the sake of simplicity omit this factor , noting that its inclusion would render the criterion even less stringent ) @xcite . as in metals one typically has @xmath23 of the order of @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 , we should have , for a ring of circumference @xmath27 , magnetic fields at least of the order of @xmath28 gauss to be within the adiabatic regime . note that without the diffusive factor , @xmath29 , the required fields would be too large to be attainable experimentally ( i.e. , on the order of @xmath30 ) . the regime of adiabaticity defined in eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) follows from a detailed derivation of the cooperon and diffuson propagator based on weak localization techniques and an adiabatic approximation scheme @xcite . this adiabatic approximation is performed in the path intgral representation for the cooperon ( diffuson ) . as emphasized in an analogous discussion of the imaginary - time propagator in the context of persistent currents @xcite , the adiabatic approximation can contain additional angle - dependent terms that are different from the berry phase , and these terms can mask the berry phase in certain physical observables . ( for an explicit example of such a case , see sec . vi f of ref . the origin of this additonal term can be traced back to quantum fluctuations of the particle trajectory , which induce non - smooth variations of the magnetic field ( and thereby violate the smooth variation assumption that underlies the adiabatic approximation)@xcite . an alternative way to express this point is to say that in certain cases the berry phase can be masked by dephasing effects in very much the same way that the aharonov - bohm phase can become unobservable if dephasing influences become too large . such dephasing effects are difficult to calculate for a general texture , but can sometimes be obtained in special cases for which an exact solution is available ( see ref . @xcite and below ) . as suggested in ref . , it is possible to extend the exact solution for a propagator containing a single spin-1/2 particle @xcite to the one containing two spin-1/2 particels . indeed , by following this suggestion van langen et al . @xcite re - calculate the magnetoconductance for a cylindrically symmetrical texture , and claim to find deviations from our adiabatic solution @xcite . ( as we shall show , these deviations are only apparent.)van langen et al . conclude from this observation that the exact solution does not contain the berry phase effect , and thus that the regime of adiabaticity , given in eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) , is invalid . instead , adopting a suggestion made first by stern @xcite , van langen et al.@xcite claim that it is necessary for the much more stringent conditon , @xmath31 to be satisfied in diffusive systems before adiabaticity is reached , and thus before the berry phase effect can become observable in the magnetoconductance . it is specifically this claim that is incorrect . on the contrary , we will show that precisely our adiabaticity criterion , eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) , is appropriate for diffusive systems , and that the observability or non - observability of the berry phase crucially depends on the choice of physical parameters [ in the adiabatic regime given by eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) ] . indeed , van langen et al.@xcite concentrate on the rather unphysical choice that the field winds five times around the ring ( i.e. , @xmath32 ) , and as dephasing effects grow strongly with @xmath15 ( as @xmath33 ; see below ) , it comes as little surprise that berry phase oscillations are not discernible in this extreme case . however , upon choosing @xmath16the physically most relevant case not only do berry phase effects show up in the exact solution , but also they agree well with our previously - obtained adiabatic predictions . van langen et al.@xcite have studied the issue of adiabaticity also in terms of boltzmann equations . due to the coupling of the magnetic field to the orbital motion of the charged electron these boltzmann equations are valid in the diffusive regime defined by @xmath34 , where @xmath35 is the cyclotron frequency . as @xmath35 and @xmath3 are typically of the same order of magnitude in metals , the regime @xmath36 studied by van langen et al . lies _ outside _ the physical regime to which their boltzmann equations can legitimately be applied . still , even if we adopt their academic point of view and ignore such orbital effects ( i.e. set the electron charge to zero ) , the regime @xmath36 is problematic for an additional reason @xcite . if @xmath36 , the zeeman rate @xmath3 is large compared to the elastic collision rate @xmath37 . in this case we expect the zeeman interaction to have a strong dephasing influence on the orbital motion ( for inhomogeneous fields ) , especially when @xmath38 , and the system lies outside the semiclassical regime in the sense of weak localization theory ( see , e.g. , secs . 4 and 10 of ref . and this issue has not been discussed by van langen et al . in the context of their boltzmann equations . finally , none of the effects discussed by van langen et al . in terms of their boltzmann equation have been shown explicitly to be related to the berry phase . without such information at hand it is not possible to tell whether the effects they find are of dynamical ( non - phase - coherent ) or geometrical ( berry phase ) origin , as both of them can occur in an adiabatic approximation to the quantum dynamics . as we are interested in the berry phase effect associated with phase - coherence and occurring in physical observables , we shall not comment any further on the boltzmann equation approach of van langen et al . , and instead shall concentrate on the magnetoconductance expressed in terms of the cooperon propagator @xcite . still , we do wish to point out that although we do not agree with the final conclusions reached by van langen et al . , we have found their work stimulating , inasmuch as it has motivated us to clarify the issue of dephasing which , in turn , has allowed us to establish more concrete predictions about the range of observability of the berry phase in the magnetoconductance of diffusive metallic systems . we consider a quasi - one - dimensional ring of circumference @xmath6 , embedded in a magnetic field texture given by @xmath39 , where @xmath40 is the location on the ring , @xmath41 is the tilt angle of the magnetic field , and @xmath42 is the winding of the magnetic field along the propagation direction . the magnitude @xmath1 and , in particular , the tilt angle @xmath41 are assumed to be constant . it is this special case that can be solved exactly ( as pointed out in ref . ) along the same lines as discussed in ref . for a single - spin propagator . van langen et al . @xcite were the first to write down this solution explicitly for a two - spin propagator . the magnetoconductance resulting from weak localization corrections and in the presence of the field texture @xmath43 has been derived in ref . @xcite and reads , @xmath44 where the effective ( non - hermitian ) hamiltonian @xmath45 is given by @xmath46 where @xmath47 ( with @xmath48 ) are spin-1/2 pauli matrices , and where @xmath49 is the dimensionless adiabaticity parameter [ see eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) ] . the factor @xmath50 is a damping constant expressed in terms of the dephasing length @xmath51 ( which is specified in more detail below ) . note that @xmath52 is introduced here in a phenomenological way with the particular _ ad hoc _ choice that it be a c - number and diagonal in spin space . we now evaluate @xmath53 explicitly , but instead of using the exact eigenstates , as was done by van langen et al . @xcite , we use an alternative approach in terms of unitary gauge transformations , which has the virtue of making the emergence of the berry phase immediately transparent . for this purpose we define unitary transformations @xmath54 and @xmath55 of the form @xmath56 with the property that @xmath57 by noting that @xmath58 , we find @xmath59)^2 + i\kappa\ , ( \sigma_{1z}-\sigma_{2z } ) . \label{uhu}\ ] ] next , we rewrite the matrix elements occurring in @xmath53 : @xmath60 where @xmath61 and @xmath62 is now diagonal in the angular momentum eigenstates @xmath63 , with @xmath64 ( imposing periodic boundary conditions ) , and we find , @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the trace in spin space and @xmath67 here , we have absorbed the integer @xmath68 into @xmath69 . note that two of the eigenvalues of @xmath70 are given by the ( geometric ) berry phase @xmath71 for an effectively integral spin @xcite . the term @xmath72 provides a source of dephasing that can mask the berry phase and more generally the aharonov - bohm effect ( see , sec . [ dephasing ] below ) . all the other off - diagonal terms turn out to be irrelevant in the adiabatic limit ( see sec . [ physical ] ) . to proceed , we express the above operators in the @xmath73-basis @xmath74 where @xmath75 , and @xmath76 . finding the inverse of @xmath77 is then straightforward , and we finally obtain for the magnetoconductance @xmath78 [ \gamma+(m+f)^2]\ , ( \gamma+m^2)^2 \\ \nonumber & + & 4\kappa^2 \{[\gamma+(m - f\cos\eta)^2][\gamma+(m+f\cos\eta)^2]+f^2\sin^2{\eta } ( \gamma + m^2 + f^2\cos^2{\eta})\ } \}^{-1}\,\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath79 , i.e. , we have allowed for an aharonov - bohm flux @xmath80 , with @xmath81 being the flux quantum . the foregoing result is exact and is seen to be identical to the one obtained by van langen et al . @xcite ( for their choice @xmath82 ) . however , our alternative derivation has led us to a form in which the berry phase contribution is made manifest in the terms of the form @xmath83 . next we go over to the adiabatic limit , defined here by @xmath84 , which , for @xmath16 , is equivalent to @xmath85 [ see eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) ] . ( below , in sec . [ observability ] , we give explicit numerical values of @xmath86 for which adiabaticity is reached . ) in this limit we may drop the terms independent of @xmath86 in eq . ( [ moscexact ] ) ( this is justified as terms with large @xmath69 give a negligible contribution to @xmath53 ) . thus , in the adiabatic limit we finally get @xmath87 + ( f^2/2)\sin^2{\eta } \over [ \gamma+(m-\alpha f\cos\eta)^2][\gamma+(m+\alpha f\cos\eta)^2]+ ( \gamma + m^2 + f^2\cos^2{\eta})f^2\sin^2{\eta}}\,\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the sum over @xmath88 has been introduced artificially for later convenience . note that the berry phase @xmath89 couples to the momentum like the aharonov - bohm phase does , i.e. , via @xmath90 . we note that the remaining @xmath41-dependence can not be accounted for by this type of coupling to the momentum . we particularly emphasize that ( apart from the flux appearing in @xmath79 ) the adiabatic limit of the magnetoconductance @xmath91 is independent of the field amplitude @xmath1 ; thus , increasing the field further , say up to @xmath92 ( cf . ( [ schrott ] ) ) , has no effect . it is now instructive to compare eq . ( [ moscadiabatic ] ) with the one previously derived @xcite for arbitrary textures and in the adiabatic approximation scheme for the berry phase . the latter result reads @xmath93[\gamma'+(m+\alpha f\cos\eta)^2]}\,\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where , again , @xmath79 , and @xmath94 , and where we have used some identities to facilitate comparison . note that in general @xmath95 ( see below ) . the virtue of @xmath96 is that it is valid for arbitrary field textures ( with the appropriate berry phase @xcite ) . it is thus important to understand its relation to the special but exactly solvable case . now , by comparing @xmath96 with @xmath91 we see that the two expressions have the same structure with respect to the berry phase , @xmath97 , but differ in additional @xmath41- and @xmath15-dependent terms . ( from now on we put the aharonov - bohm flux @xmath98 to zero but shall return to nonzero flux later . ) particularly important is the additional term in the denominator of @xmath91 , i.e. , @xmath99 ( the physical origin of such additional terms is discussed below in sec.[physical ] ) . it is this term that acts as a _ dephasing source _ for certain tilt angles and windings @xmath15 by suppressing the resonance peaks " that would occur at integral values of the berry phase @xmath89 ( for small enough @xmath100 ) . for @xmath17 the suppression due to this term is so strong that all resonances except the ones at @xmath101 become masked , i.e. , these resonances due to the berry phase are no longer visible in graphs of @xmath91 versus @xmath41 , whereas they do show up in @xmath96 _ provided _ one chooses @xmath100 to be independent of the tilt angle @xmath41 ( and sufficiently small ) . it is this _ ad hoc _ choice for @xmath15 and @xmath100 that has been adopted by van langen et al . in particular , they choose @xmath18 and a constant @xmath102 . as in this case @xmath96 and @xmath91 behave differently for @xmath103 ( see fig . 3 of ref . @xcite ) , van langen et al.@xcite conclude that @xmath91 is not showing adiabatic behavior and , thus , that our criterion for adiabaticity , eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) , is not correct . however , this conclusion of van langen et al . is premature . there are two main reasons for this : first , they have ignored the issue of dephasing induced by the inhomogeneity of the magnetic field , and connected to this , second , the issue of the self - consistency of the semiclassical approximation on which the derivation of the cooperon propagator rests . we now discuss these issues in turn , and then present physical examples to illustrate the general discussion . the _ ad hoc _ choice by van langen et al . @xcite of putting @xmath103 and choosing them to be independent of @xmath41 means that @xmath91 and @xmath96 do _ not _ describe the same physical situation . this is so for the following reason . first we note again that the dephasing parameters @xmath104 are put in by hand " into the cooperon to account for dephasing in a phenomenological way ( this is just dictated by the complexity of the involved many - body problem and by our inability to address this issue in a more systematic way in general ) . in the derivation of @xmath96 dephasing due to the field is only taken into account _ a posteriori _ in terms of a phenomenological parameter @xmath100 , while the exact solution , eq . ( [ moscexact ] ) , not only includes the berry phase but simultaneously also those dephasing effects that are caused by the field through the zeeman coupling . the remaining dephasing effects in @xmath53 or @xmath91 are then included via the phenomenological parameter @xmath52 . obviously , @xmath52 and @xmath100 are in general different for the same physical situation . next , it is a well - known fact in the context of weak - localization phenomena @xcite that dephasing in general depends on the magnetic field @xmath43 penetrating the sample ( as we must allow for there to be any zeeman interaction at all ) . most importantly , @xmath100 not only depends , in general , on the magnitude @xmath1 of the field but also on its tilt angle @xmath41 that the field makes with the @xmath105-axis perpendicular to the ring plane . ( this is already so even without zeeman terms , see , e.g. , sec . 2 of ref . there can be little surprise that the angle dependence becomes even more pronounced in the presence of our inhomogeneous zeeman interaction ) . the various dephasing effects are accounted for phenomenologically in terms of dephasing lengths @xcite , @xmath106 , where the dephasing length @xmath107 contains all field - independent contributions , such as the one coming from inelastic collisons of the diffusing electron with , say , phonons , @xmath108 , where the dephasing time @xmath109 is some inelastic scattering time . the magnetic length @xmath110 contains all effects coming from the field penetrating the sample . if now @xmath111 for some field configurations , we no longer expect to see phase - coherence in general . as a matter of fact , in sec . iv of ref . we have estimated the upper bound of the dephasing length ( due to the inhomogeneous zeeman interaction ) in metallic films to be given by the characteristic field - reorientation length @xmath112 . this estimate follows from the observation that quantum corrections begin to be eliminated when the largest phase - coherent paths enclose roughly one quantum of berry flux . for the symmetric texture considered here we find @xmath113 . obviously , for certain tilt - angles and for @xmath38 this upper bound on the dephasing length quickly becomes smaller than @xmath6 . translated into a dephasing parameter @xmath114 , this estimate reads @xmath115 i.e. , we see that the dephasing becomes explicitly @xmath41-dependent and grows like @xmath33 . thus , it is by no means surprising that the exact solution confirms this general expectation , in the sense that explicit dephasing terms are present in @xmath53 that are field - dependent and which can become so large , for _ particular _ field inhomogeneities , that they completely suppress the resonances in the magnetoconductance , eq . ( [ moscexact ] ) , with respect to the berry phase @xcite , no matter how large @xmath116 is . of course , as implied by above discussion leading to eq . ( [ estimate ] ) , such a dephasing effect must also be accounted for explicitly in @xmath96 , eq . ( [ mosclsg ] ) , by an appropriate choice for the phenomenological damping parameter @xmath100 . in particular , in view of the estimate given in eq . ( [ estimate ] ) , it is reasonable to make the ansatz @xmath117 @xcite . then , choosing the dephasing parameter of @xmath91 to be constant ( i.e. @xmath41-independent ) and much smaller than unity , say @xmath118 , we see that the qualitative discrepancy between @xmath96 and @xmath91 disappears : both expressions show no resonances ( away from @xmath119 ) . ( we note that as @xmath52 and @xmath100 are introduced phenomenologically anyway , there is no need to get quantitative agreement , and it suffices to find the same qualitative suppression of the resonances for @xmath17 in both @xmath96 and @xmath91 . we shall not be making any further use of this ansatz for @xmath100 . ) the suppression of the cooperon due to homogeneous fields is standard @xcite ; the discussion above shows that additional dephasing is induced by the field inhomogeneity . the advantage of having the exact solution for @xmath53 , eq . ( [ moscexact ] ) , at hand is that we can now calculate the field - dependence of such dephasing terms explicitly ; this allows us to make more precise statements than before @xcite about the regime in which one can expect to observe consequences of the berry phase ( see sec . [ observability ] below ) . the magnetoconductance correction @xmath53 is expressed in terms of the cooperon propagator . the derivation of the cooperon is , in turn , performed within the _ semiclassical limit_. in particular , this means that back - reaction effects " , i.e. , non - phase - coherent dynamical effects of the field - dependent zeeman term on the _ orbital motion _ are assumed to be negligibly small throughout . this is a fundamental assumption in weak - localization theory @xcite , and it was explicitly adopted in our derivation of the cooperon and of @xmath96 , too . ( this is emphasized , e.g. , in app . a of ref . . ) evidently , dephasing effects such as the ones discussed in the previous subsection are nothing but such back - reaction effects . thus , if dephasing becomes so large ( as turns out to be the case in the adiabatic limit and for @xmath17 ) that phase - coherence is completely suppressed in the orbital part , the semiclassical approximation breaks down and the self - consistency of the entire treatment is lost @xcite . consequently , the expressions for the magnetoconductance are no longer reliable in the case of complete dephasing , and no weight should be put on conclusions drawn under such circumstances . obviously , semiclassical and adiabatic approximations are interconnected issues , in the sense that the semiclassical approximation might break down in the adiabatic limit and for certain field configurations . in other words , adiabaticity alone is not a sufficient criterion for the observability of berry phase effects , in addition the system must be in the mesoscopic regime characterized by phase - coherence . to summarize our conclusions so far , we have seen that our adiabaticity criterion , eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) , is sufficient for reaching the adiabatic limit involving the berry phase [ cf . ( [ moscadiabatic ] ) and ( [ mosclsg ] ) ] . however , the criterion does not guarantee ( and this was never claimed ) that the berry phase will be observable under all circumstances . as a matter of fact , it can happen that the phase - coherence , which is necessary for observing such quantum phase phenomena , can be destroyed by a variety of dephasing sources , in particular also by magnetic fields penetrating the sample . if dephasing becomes so strong in the adiabatic regime that quantum phase effects of the orbital motion get completely washed out , the semiclassical approximation underlying the derivation of the cooperon breaks down and results based on it ( such as @xmath53 ) are no longer reliable . it is precisely the issues discussed in the last two subsections that have not been taken into consideration by van langen et al . @xcite . in the light of our discussion it should now be clear that the only conclusion one can draw from the observation made by van langen et al . ( namely the non - observability of berry phase effects for @xmath18 within our semiclassical theory ) is that field textures with @xmath17 suppress phase - coherence very efficiently , and thus such extreme textures can not serve as a general test case for the existence of the berry phase and the associated adiabaticity regime at least not within the semiclassical regime to which our results , eqs . ( [ moscexact])-([mosclsg ] ) , are confined . up to now we have mainly concentrated on regimes where @xmath17 . such regimes , however , are of little experimental interest ( quite apart from the difficulty of how to produce them ) since the berry phase effect would be masked by the strong dephasing effect of the field . the situation , however , is entirely different for the case where the magnetic field winds only once around the ring , i.e. when @xmath16 ( such field textures can be produced experimentally @xcite ) . indeed , we shall see now that for @xmath16 the dephasing is sufficiently small and the berry phase has observable consequences within an experimentally accessible regime . we shall illustrate this with two specific examples : first we discuss resonances in the magnetoconductance due to the berry phase ( for vanishing aharonov - bohm flux @xmath98 ) ; then we discuss phase shifts in the aharonov - bohm oscillations induced by the berry phase . we consider first the magnetoconductance as function of the berry phase in the absence of an aharonov - bohm flux , i.e. @xmath120 . we make the realistic assumption that the dephasing length independent of the tilt - angle can be made to exceed @xmath6 , say , @xmath121 , giving @xmath122 ( this value for @xmath52 is 100 times smaller than the one chosen in sec . [ exactsolution ] ) . in fig . 1 , we plot the magnetoconductance @xmath53 , eq . ( ) , as function of the tilt angle @xmath41 in the adiabatic regime , @xmath123 , and find pronounced resonance peaks at the berry phase values @xmath119 in very good qualitative agreement with the general result @xmath96 , given in eq . ( [ mosclsg ] ) , even if we simply choose @xmath124 . for comparison , we also plot ( see fig . 1 ) the magnetoconductance @xmath53 outside the adiabatic regime , i.e. , for @xmath125 , where the resonances are ( nearly ) absent demonstrating that adiabaticity is needed for the emergence of the berry phase . we note that above choice for the adiabatic parameter ( i.e. , @xmath126 ) corresponds to @xmath127 . in particular , if we follow van langen et al . and choose @xmath128 ( i.e. , a typical ratio for a mesoscopic metal ring ) we see that @xmath126 is equivalent to @xmath129 . note that we are orders of magnitude below the regime of eq . ( [ schrott ] ) , where @xmath92 . translated into magnetic fields , @xmath126 corresponds to @xmath130 which , for @xmath25 and @xmath131 @xcite , gives @xmath132 = 4.5 \times 10^{-6 } { d\over l^2 } [ gs ] \ , .\ ] ] to illustrate this with concrete numbers we assume the fermi velocity @xmath133 and the ring circumference @xmath134 , and again @xmath128 . we then find that the field corresponding to @xmath123 is about @xmath135 . the resonance structure due to the berry phase starts to emerge for @xmath86 at around @xmath136 , i.e. , for fields of the order of @xmath137 . finally , we note that when the tilt angle @xmath41 is varied , then typically there will be a concommittant change of the aharonov - bohm flux @xmath98 . this flux , however , can be easily compensated by applying a field perpendicular to the ring such that @xmath98 again becomes an integral multiple of the flux quantum . note that the maximal fields required for this compensation are about ten gauss , or so , for a ring of @xmath134 . thus , such fields would have a negligible effect on the inhomogeneous field required for adiabaticity , except if @xmath41 is very close to @xmath138 . a further experimentally interesting scenario is that of the _ phase shift _ in the aharonov - bohm oscillation induced by the berry phase . in particular , this effect is most pronounced for half - integral berry phases , @xmath139 ( i.e. , @xmath140 or @xmath141 ) , for which we expect [ see eqs . ( [ moscadiabatic ] ) and ( [ mosclsg ] ) ] to get a phase shift in the aharonov - bohm oscillation of the magnetoconductance by the flux value @xmath142 ( i.e. , by one quarter of the flux quantum @xmath143 ) . note that in this case the sign of the oscillation slope ( e.g. at @xmath120 ) gets reversed with respect to the case without berry phase . this sign - reversal is reminiscent of similar effects induced by spin - orbit scattering @xcite ; it is actually not unexpected , as the zeeman term induces an effective spin - orbit coupling due to the inhomogeneity of the magnetic field @xcite . this phase shift is shown in figs . 2a and 2b , which show @xmath144 as function of the aharonov - bohm flux @xmath98 for berry phases @xmath145 and @xmath142 , both in the adiabatic limit ( i.e. , @xmath123 ) and with the choice @xmath146 ( i.e. , @xmath147 ) . for the sake of comparison , in fig . 2d we also show a non - adiabatic case , @xmath148 , for which the phase shift is absent . the phase shift remains discernible down to about @xmath149 before disappearing . the adiabatic limit is fully reached at about @xmath150 , by which not only the phase shift ( which is the important feature ) but also the amplitude becomes identical to @xmath91 given in eq . ( [ moscadiabatic ] ) . the amplitude at @xmath123 increases about by 20 percent upon increasing the field to @xmath150 . to obtain realistic estimates for some physical parameters we now concentrate on a au ring and use the material parameters recently determined by mohanty et al.@xcite ( see sample au-@xmath151 in their table i ) . the relevant values are : @xmath152 and @xmath153 ( at a temperature of @xmath154 ) , which give for the dephasing length @xmath155 . thus , the above choice @xmath156 requires a ring of circumference @xmath157 . in this case , the field corresponding to @xmath126 becomes @xmath158 , and the limiting case , @xmath149 , at which the phase shift emerges , corresponds to @xmath159 @xcite . precisely the same phase shift occurs in @xmath96 , eq . ( [ mosclsg ] ) , as shown in fig . 2 . to get roughly the same amplitudes as in @xmath53 we must account for the @xmath41dependent dephasing in @xmath160 . to this end we choose an effective @xmath161 ( for @xmath162 ) and @xmath163 ( for @xmath140 . this phenomenological choice is not vital for the qualitative behavior of @xmath160 , but it does allow us to estimate an effective dephasing length @xmath164 , as we now explain . first we note that the ( peak - to - peak ) amplitude of the magnetoconductance @xmath53 for @xmath165 is considerably reduced ( by about a factor of @xmath166 ) with respect to that for @xmath145 . as is clear by now , this is due to the @xmath41dependent dephasing terms . now , without such dephasing the aharonov - bohm amplitudes for @xmath145 and @xmath165 would be equal [ see , e.g. , eq . ( [ mosclsg ] ) with a @xmath100 that is @xmath41-independent ] . thus , the reduction of the aharonov - bohm amplitude at @xmath140 ( relative to that at @xmath167 ) serves as a quantitative measure of the @xmath41-dependent dephasing . expressed in terms of an effective dephasing length , @xmath168 , we find @xmath169 m , for the particular values chosen above ( i.e. , @xmath170 , and @xmath157 ) . this dephasing length should be compared with above value @xmath171 ( corresponding to @xmath146 and @xmath157 ) . finally , there is also the usual ( spin - independent ) dephasing arising from the field @xmath172 penetrating a ring of finite width @xmath173 . on the one hand , we need a sufficiently large field so as to reach adiabaticity , and on the other hand such a field can induce dephasing . thus , to satisfy these conflicting requirements in an optimal way we should consider rings with a width @xmath173 as small as possible . to get a rough estimate for such a width , we take for the field @xmath174 and insert this into the standard formula @xcite , @xmath175 . we now require that this dephasing length should not become ( much ) smaller than @xmath107 , so we choose @xmath176 . on the other hand , the field required for adiabaticity is about @xmath177 , and together with @xmath178 and @xmath140 this corresponds to a ring width @xmath173 of the order of @xmath179 . note that as the effective dephasing length is obtained via @xmath180 , the dephasing effect due to @xmath172 penetrating the sample increases @xmath52 by a factor of two ( i.e. , @xmath181 ) . as is seen from fig . 2 , the cases @xmath146 and @xmath181 behave in the same way , i.e. , with phase shift , but the amplitude of @xmath53 for @xmath140 and @xmath181 is now reduced by a factor of @xmath182 compared with @xmath53 for @xmath167 and @xmath146 . ( note that for @xmath167 the magnetic field for the aharonov - bohm oscillations can be chosen to be very small , so that @xmath183 dominates over @xmath184 and thus @xmath146 . ) finally , we note that the field component @xmath174 gives rise to an aharonov - bohm phase @xmath185 that is , in general , not equal to @xmath186 ( with @xmath187 integral ) . therefore , this offset flux @xmath188 must be accounted for in order to assign the above phase shift unambiguously to the berry phase @xmath165 . for instance , for @xmath157 , we need @xmath189 in order to generate one flux quantum @xmath81 through the ring . now consider @xmath140 , and , say , @xmath177 , i.e. , @xmath190 . to compensate the off - set @xmath188 , we need to increase @xmath172 by , say , @xmath191 to @xmath192 , in which case @xmath193 becomes an integer ( @xmath194 ) . the amplitude - reduction mentioned above demands sufficient experimental resolution , which we now estimate . for the parameter values given above for an au ring and for @xmath140 , we find ( cf . fig . 2c ) that the peak - to - peak amplitude of @xmath53 is about @xmath195 for an effective @xmath181 . the relative ratio , @xmath196 , thus becomes of the order of @xmath197 for a ring resistance @xmath198 of the order of @xmath199 m ) ohms @xcite , and @xmath200 m . such sensitivity , as well as all the parameters estimated above , appear to be within present - day experimental reach . further scenarios for the berry phases in transport can be easily worked out ( see also ref . ) . it should be obvious by now that the explicit agreement between @xmath53 in the adiabatic limit and @xmath96 unambiguously demonstrates ( and reinforces the general points made in the previous subsections ) that the adiabaticity criterion , eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) , is sufficient for the existence of the berry phase and that , moreover , there exist physical regimes where this berry phase can be observed in magnetoconductance oscillations ( and other quantities ) . by contrast , the far more stringent criterion eq . ( [ schrott ] ) is certainly not necessary , and therefore sets unwarranted demands on experimental searches for berry phase effects . we now briefly return to the issue of the source of dephasing in the hamiltonian @xmath201 given in eq . ( [ hfinal ] ) , as well as its physical interpretation . for this purpose we assume from the outset that we are in the adiabatic regime , @xmath202 , and simply retain the leading contributions when finding the inverse of @xmath203 . this allows us to identify those terms in the hamiltonian @xmath45 that are responsible for the dephasing . from the matrix representation ( [ matrixh ] ) of @xmath201 it is straightforward to see that only those matrix elements are important in the adiabatic limit that are simultaneously either diagonal or off - diagonal in both spin subspaces . no other matrix elements contribute at the leading order , @xmath204 , for the determinant or sub - determinants of @xmath203 that are necessary to calculate the inverse . thus we can replace @xmath201 by the matrix @xmath205 and we see that it is only the term @xmath206 in @xmath201 that causes dephasing and leads to those @xmath41-dependent terms in @xmath91 that are absent in @xmath96 ( apart from the differences in @xmath52 and @xmath100 ) . now , the first term , @xmath207 , has already been identified in the discussion of the exact solution ( for @xmath16 ) for a propagator containing only a single spin-1/2 @xcite . in a general path - integral approach , this term has been interpreted as a consequence of quantum fluctuations : the particle trajectory fluctuates around its classical path and these fluctuations in turn lead to a fluctuating local magnetic field . such fluctuations , however , violate the standard assumption underlying the adiabatic approximation that the field should vary smoothly as a function of its parameters ( in the present case the parameter is given by the position @xmath208 of the particle on the ring ) . we have pointed out previously ( see sec . vi f in ref . ) that this term might lead to deviations from the adiabatic approximation , which is valid only for smooth variations . the second term , @xmath209 , is new , and describes an effective spin - spin interaction induced by the inhomogeneity of the magnetic field ( i.e. , in the cooperon , the path and its time - reversed partner are interacting with each other via their respective spins ) . this interaction between spin 1 and spin 2 is transmitted via the orbital motion , and in this sense involves a back - reaction of the zeeman term on the orbital motion . however , as pointed out in sec . [ semiclassical ] , such back reactions that act to suppress the phase - coherence are consistently assumed to be negligible in our semiclassical treatment . thus , in ref . we have performed the adiabatic approximation on the propagators for the path and for its time - reversed partner separately and independently , and all possible dephasing effects are included phenomenologically in terms of @xmath100 at the end . this finally explains the apparent discrepancy between @xmath96 and @xmath91 . however , as shown in previous sections , this discrepancy vanishes when allowing for @xmath41-dependent dephasing terms @xmath100 in @xmath96 . by using the exact solution for the cooperon we have shown that the berry phase leads to observable effects in the magnetoconductance oscillation within the adiabatic regime defined by eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) . this is in full agreement with our previous findings @xcite , and in contrast to the claim made by van langen et al . we have pointed out the role of dephasing and emphasized its angle- and winding - dependence . we have illustrated the general discussion with explicit examples which reinforce our optimistic outlook for the experimental search of the berry phase in diffusive metallic samples . we wish to acknowledge discussions with s. van langen and y. lyanda - geller . this work was supported by the swiss national science foundation ( dl and hs ) , the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft as part of sfb 195 ( hs ) , and by the u.s . department of energy , division of materials science , under award no . defg02 - 96er45439 through the university of illinois materials research laboratory ( pg ) . strictly speaking , we should also allow for the possibility that higher orbital momentum states @xmath69 will contribute to adiabatic behavior ( on the scale given by the thouless energy ) by multiplying the right - hand side of eq . ( [ adiabaticity ] ) by some momentum average @xmath210 ( see the analogous discussion in @xcite ) . note that @xmath210 can be quite complicated , as it depends in principle on all parameters occurring in the hamiltonian describing the physical situation at hand . however , typically it turns out that only the lowest few momentum states contribute to physical quantities ( provided the damping is sufficiently small ) ; thus , we will ignore such refinements here and simply put @xmath211 . we have checked the validity of this approximation ( i.e. @xmath211 ) with the exact solution for the magnetoconductance by testing out when the adiabatic limit is fully reached in the various parameter regimes , and found it to be a reasonable approximation in the present situation ( and for @xmath52 not exceeding @xmath212 ) . note that the complete berry phase is usually defined as @xmath213 , with @xmath214 the spin value and for constant tilt angle ( cf . ref . ) . for two spin-1/2 particles the total spin @xmath214 is integral . the berry phase is then equivalent to @xmath215 ( with @xmath216 ) [ see , e.g. , eq . ( [ mosclsg ] ) ] and we shall simply refer to @xmath89 as the berry phase . in particular , @xmath145 and @xmath217 are equivalent in their effect , but they belong to different field configurations . note that the aharonov - bohm resonances in @xmath53 are also suppressed by the @xmath41-dependent dephasing terms , in general , but more gradually than the berry phase resonances , some of which disappear entirely as soon as @xmath17 . this is related to the fact that the berry phase itself depends on @xmath41 whereas the aharonov - bohm phase does not . the additional factor of @xmath218 in @xmath219 is intended to provide a phenomenological account of the smaller period with respect to the berry phase in the cooperon resulting from the interference of the path with its time - reversed partner . for instance , when @xmath162 , one can easily convince oneself that the fluctuations in the individual berry fluxes of spin 1 and spin 2 must exactly cancel each other as the trajectories that the spins describe on the unit sphere in spin space are related by time reversal symmetry . thus , the dephasing must be reduced at @xmath162 . while certainly plausible , this argument is only of suggestive value , as it ignores the effective interaction between the paths ( see sec . ) . also , we ignore for the moment the fact that for @xmath17 such large @xmath52 s actually violate the self - consistency of the semiclassical approximation ( see sec . [ semiclassical ] ) . note that if the suppression of phase coherence is only _ partial _ , the treatment is of course still self - consistent within the semiclassical regime . this is , e.g. , the case for @xmath16 and @xmath140 , for which the berry phase is still visible albeit with a reduced amplitude ( see sec . ) . we mention that the presence of magnetic impurities can help bring the adiabatic limit to lower fields . without going into a detailed analysis , it seems plausible to assume that even for small fields ( say , on the order of tens of gauss ) the magnetic moments of typical impurities will align along the local magnetic field direction ( temperatures should be smaller than the zeeman splitting energy , typically in the sub - kelvin range ) after some relaxation time ( typically on the order of @xmath220 ) . these magnetic impurities will produce short - ranged local fields that couples via the exchange interaction to the electrons passing by , and thus impart information about the field inhomogeneity on to the electron spin .
Abstract: | [
"in a recent preprint ( cond - mat/9803170 ) , van langen , knops , paasschens and beenakker attempt to re - analyze the proposal of loss , schoeller and goldbart ( lsg ) [ phys . rev . b * 48 * , 15218 ( 1993 ) ] concerning berry phase effects in the magnetoconductance of diffusive systems . van langen et al . claim that the adiabatic approximation for the cooperon previously derived by lsg is not valid in the adiabatic regime identified by lsg . it is shown that the claim of van langen et al . is not correct , and that , on the contrary , the magnetoconductance does exhibit the berry phase effect within the lsg regime of adiabaticity . the conclusion reached by van langen et al . is based on a misinterpretation of field - induced dephasing effects , which can mask the berry phase ( and any other phase coherent phenomena ) for certain parameter values . = 0 epsf.sty"
] | 8,409 | 8,409 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: modified gravity ( for a review , see e.g. @xcite ) constitutes an interesting dynamical alternative to @xmath0cdm cosmology in that it is also able to describe with success the current acceleration in the expansion of our universe , the present dark energy epoch . the specific class of modified @xmath1 gravities ( for a review , see e.g. @xcite ) has undergone many studies which suggest that this family of gravitational alternatives for dark energy is able to pass the constringent solar system tests . the investigation of cosmic acceleration as well as the study of the cosmological properties of @xmath1 models has been done in refs . the possibility of a natural unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration becomes a realistic and quite natural possibility in such models , as is demonstrated e.g. in ref . @xcite . recently , the importance of modified gravity models of this kind has been reassessed with the appearance of the so - called ` viable ' @xmath1 models @xcite . those are theories which satisfy both the cosmological as well as the local gravity constraints , which had caused in the past a number of serious problems to some of the first - generation theories , that had to be considered now as only approximate descriptions from more realistic theories . the final aim of all those phenomenological models is to describe a segment as large as possible of the entire history of our universe , as well as to recover all local predictions of einstein s gravity that have been already verified experimentally , with very good accuracy , at the solar system scale . it is remarkable that , as was demonstrated in refs . @xcite , some of these realistic models lead to a natural unification of the early - time inflation epoch with the late - time acceleration stage . let us recall that , in general ( see e.g. @xcite , for a review ) , the total action for the modified @xmath1 gravitational models can be written as [ xxx7 ] s = d^4 x + s_(m ) . here @xmath2 is a suitable function of the scalar curvature @xmath3 , which defines the modified gravitational part of the model . the general equation of motion in @xmath4 gravity with matter is given by [ xxx22 ] g _ f(r ) - r _ f(r ) - g _ f(r ) + _ _ f(r ) = - t_(m ) , where @xmath5 is the matter energy - momentum tensor and @xmath6 is the derivative of @xmath1 with respect to its argument @xmath3 . for a generic @xmath1 model is not easy to find exact static solutions . however , if one impose some restrictions , one can proceed along the following lines . first , we may require the existence of solutions with _ constant _ scalar curvature @xmath7 , and we arrive at f(r_0)r_=g_. [ geneqrc ] taking the trace , we have the condition 2f(r_0)=r_0f(r_0 ) [ b ] and this means that the solutions are einstein s spaces , namely they have to satisfy the equation r_=g_= g _ , [ e ] @xmath8 being a solution of eq . ( [ b ] ) . this gives rise to an effective cosmological constant , namely _ eff==. [ l ] the purpose of our work will be to study the appearance of multiply de sitter space solutions in several realistic models of modified gravity . the occurrence of multiply de sitter solutions plays a fundamental role in modified gravity because it permits to describe the inflation stage as well as current @xmath0cdm cosmology in terms of this theory alone without any need for either fine - tuning of a cosmological constant nor of introducing extra scalar fields . in summary , this is a minimal and at the same time very powerful approach which circumvents some of the hardest problems of present day physics . one may argue that these theories are equivalent to introducing extra scalar fields , but this equivalence has been proven to hold at the classical level only , not at the quantum one . in addition , the cosmological interpretation of modified gravity solutions is different from that of scalar field cosmology . the paper is organized as follows . in the next section we discuss a viable modified gravity model @xcite in an attempt to study de sitter solutions there . it is shown that , for some values of the parameters , it is possible to find several de sitter spaces ( as a rule , numerically , for small values of the curvature exponent ) ; one of them may serve for the inflationary stage , while the other one can be used for the description of the dark energy stage . the evolution of the effective equation of state parameter is investigated numerically . 3 is devoted to the analysis of the same question in a slightly generalized model which is known to describe the unification of the early - time inflation with the late - time acceleration epochs @xcite . the same numerical investigation is carried out , and a multiply de sitter universe solution is constructed . in section 4 , the corresponding problem is investigated for a viable model of tangential modified gravity , proposed in ref . @xcite . having in mind the possibility to use a sds universe for the description of cosmic acceleration , those solutions for modified gravity are investigated in sect . comparison of the free energies of the de sitter and the sds solutions , for the viable model of the second section , is then made . finally , some outlook is given , together with the conclusions , at the end of the paper . in this section we will study de sitter solutions in realistic modified gravity models using a dynamical system approach . we shall start from the following form for the initial action @xmath9 , \label{1.1}\ ] ] where @xmath10 is some function of the geometrical invariants . in order to make use of the method of dynamical systems , we work in the metric corresponding to a spatially - flat frw universe , namely @xmath11 from here , the frw equation can be written in the following way ( for more details see ref . @xcite ) @xmath12 where @xmath13 the `` dot '' over the symbol means derivative with respect to time @xmath14 , while @xmath15 and @xmath16 represent the derivative of @xmath10 with respect to @xmath17 and @xmath18 respectively . in what follows we will mainly concentrate on the simplest case @xmath19 . let us consider the following choice for the function @xmath20 @xcite , which represents a very interesting subclass of viable modified gravitational models @xmath21 where the constant @xmath22 has dimension of mass , while @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 are some positive dimensionless constants . note that here @xmath26 $ ] , @xmath27 , @xmath28 . after making variation , it is chosen @xmath29 . introducing a nonzero constant @xmath25 is here equivalent to introducing a shift in the effective cosmological constant , and for this reason we will assume @xmath30 in our further computations . finally , we can write eq . ( [ 1.3 ] ) for the function in ( [ 1.5 ] ) as @xmath31 , \end{array } \label{1.6}\ ] ] where @xmath32 . this equation can be rewritten as a dynamical system , namely @xmath33 it is easy to see that the critical points of this system are the de sitter points ( @xmath34 ) . to investigate the nature of these points we need to determine them explicitly , a non - trivial problem in the general case . it is however easy to obtain from ( [ 1.6 ] ) the equation satisfied by the critical points @xmath35 : @xmath36 the same result can be obtained directly starting from equation ( [ b ] ) of the previous section . it is convenient to introduce the notation @xmath37 , for further investigation of this equation . so , finally , we have @xmath38 first of all we find one ( trivial ) root of this equation @xmath39 ( it corresponds to @xmath40 ) , what allows us to reduce the order of the equation . ( note also that , if @xmath41 , eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) takes a more complicate form and then it does not have the trivial root @xmath39 . ) but nevertheless the equation still is of @xmath42-order and in the interesting case ( @xmath43 ) ; this is too high and the roots can not be found algebraically . we need a specific discussion of this problem . it is clear that if there are too many ( say 10 or 20 ) de sitter points in the theory , it looks like a classical analogue ( at a reduced scale , of course ) @xcite of the string landscape vacuum structure in which case it will be far from trivial to obtain the standard cosmology . nevertheless , something can be done even in this case , by comparing the energies of the corresponding de sitter solutions , which should in fact differ , as is discussed in sect . v. using descartes rule of signs , we find that eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) can have 2 or 0 positive roots . more detailed information can be obtained by using sturm s theorem . unfortunately it is not possible to apply it in the general case ( for arbitrary @xmath44 ) , so we need to investigate separately each of the different cases , @xmath45 , and see which one is more interesting from a cosmological viewpoint . we have therefore undertaken here a systematic analysis of all possible cases in this region of values of @xmath44 . computations are rather involved ( specially for larger @xmath44 ) , but the final results are not so difficult to describe analytically . we have found , for any of the values of @xmath44 considered , in the range above , that the number of roots depends on the parameter @xmath46 only , and that there is an @xmath47 such that , for @xmath48 , eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) has no positive roots , while for @xmath49 , eq . ( [ 1.9 ] ) has two positive roots . we here now enumerate our results systematically : @xmath50 ; @xmath51 ; @xmath52 ; @xmath53 ; @xmath54 ; @xmath55 ; @xmath56 ; @xmath57 . note also that , near the critical point @xmath47 , both solution are very close to each other when they exist ( a real value of @xmath49 ) , and they are complex conjugate to each other for @xmath48 . this means that , in a situation where these two roots differ substantially , it must necessarily be @xmath58 . the ds - points described above can be used for the construction of inflationary or late - time acceleration behavior ( depending on the value of the scale factor @xmath59 ) . to this aim , the corresponding ds point must be unstable in the inflationary stage but can be either unstable or stable for the late - time acceleration one . however , this is in fact not a strictly necessary condition , since even for stable ds inflation , the exit from it can be achieved by a coupling with matter , through the effect of small non - local term or by some other mechanism . unfortunately , an all - round investigation of stability of the ds point turns out to be very difficult in the general case . for the recent analysis of critical points in more general modified gravity theories depending on all geometrical invariant see ref . @xcite . here we can carry out the analysis on the stability of de sitter points for the model we are dealing with in this section , only for some chosen numerical set of parameters . such computations show that one of the ds points is very likely to be always unstable ( with a smaller value of @xmath60 ) and that another one is very likely to be always stable ( with larger value of @xmath60 ) . this means that there is actually an easy way for the inflationary stage construction ( if the initial conditions lie sufficiently close to the unstable ds point , see fig . [ fig.1 ] ) . however , only within the model under consideration it might be a problem with late - time acceleration , originated from the stable point . the only possibility for late time acceleration is to choose very special parameters , in which the stable point is situated very far away from the unstable one . of course , the problem disappears when one describes only late - time acceleration within such a model , or when one takes into account other terms like the local ones . note however that specific values of the parameters in which both points are unstable can be chosen too , which give rise to a sound theory which provides a unified description of the inflationary and late - time acceleration epochs . ) near the equilibrium points . stars denote the beginning of the trajectories . dashed and dot dashed lines lead to bottom.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] near an unstable point for the dashed and dot - dashed lines of fig . [ fig.1 ] . the time origin corresponds to the stars from the previous graph.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] let us now consider specific numerical results . first , note that a full numerical investigation starting from the inflation ( or from our ds point ) and extending to the late - time acceleration epoch and going through a frw - like stage is not feasible because of the presence of numerical instabilities that prevent such possibility . for this reason , we will investigate the regions near the equilibrium points only , and especially near the unstable one . in fig . [ fig.1 ] the trajectories in the phase plane ( @xmath61 ) are presented for the set of parameters : @xmath62 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , @xmath65 . such small values of @xmath23 and @xmath24 are motivated in @xcite , but the picture is typical in any case . the position of the ds point is specified . we may see one stable point ( with bigger value of @xmath60 ) and another , unstable one . the stars in the graph correspond to the beginning of the trajectories . we see clearly that trajectories can pass sufficiently close to the ds point , and that they escape from it , lead by the two attractors . one of them ( the upper one ) leads to a singularity , while another one ( heading towards the bottom ) , leads to a solution going somewhere in the frw - like region ( this is difficult to analyze exactly , due to numerical instabilities ) . in fig . [ fig.2 ] the evolution of @xmath66 is depicted for two trajectories : the upper one corresponds to the dashed line of fig . [ fig.1 ] , the bottom one to the dot - dashed line of fig . [ fig.1 ] ( both of them lead to the bottom in fig . [ fig.1 ] ) . we see that there actually are trajectories which start from phantom - like solutions and tend to a normal evolution ( when this is possible in the model ) . of course , these are qualitative considerations only , owing to the fact that no matter is taken into account . most probably , inclusion of matter will change the situation . however , it is just remarkable that both the early - time inflation epoch as well as the late - time accelerating one could be obtained in a unified and natural way in such a model , owing to the presence of several ds points . a slightly different choice for the function @xmath2 is motivated by the realistic and viable model which was proposed for the unification of early - time inflation and late - time acceleration in ref . @xcite , namely @xmath67}. \label{2.1}\ ] ] here we imply that @xmath68 , @xmath69 and @xmath8 is positive , what seems reasonable . now , our frw - like equation ( [ 1.3 ] ) reads @xmath70 , \end{array } \label{2.2}\ ] ] where @xmath32 . rewriting this equation under the form of a dynamical system ( [ 1.7 ] ) we find , by introducing the new variable @xmath71 , that the equilibrium points of this system ( which are ds points indeed ) are obtained from the following equation @xmath72x^m+2\kappa^2r_0f_0mx^{m-1}+\\ \\ ( f_0+f_1r_0^m)^2x+r_0(f_0+f_1r_0^m ) ( f_0+f_1r_0^m-4\kappa^2r_0^{m-1})=0 . \end{array } \label{2.3}\ ] ] it is clear that , in the general case ( even for fixed @xmath73 ) , solving this equation will not be an easy thing . we can make use of the following hint . let us require that @xmath74 be a solution of eq . ( [ 2.3 ] ) . this is possible only if there is some relation among the constants of our theory . as we can easily see from ( [ 2.3 ] ) , it must be that @xmath75 . moreover , since @xmath76 , we need that @xmath77 . substituting this condition into ( [ 2.3 ] ) we find an essential simplification of the former equation , namely @xmath78 where the root @xmath74 is already excluded . we now discuss the physical meaning of finding a solution @xmath74 . as a rule this will imply that @xmath8 is the value of the scalar curvature at present time , but in principle @xmath8 is just a parameter of the theory , which could be given any likely value . we can , for instance , fix @xmath8 to have the ds point value which is situated exactly at present time , @xmath79 , or at @xmath80 years . and there is also the possibility to explain late time acceleration if this point is stable . now let us consider other possible roots of eq . ( [ 2.4 ] ) . using sturm s theorem as in the previous section , we find several positive roots ( which correspond to ds points in the past ) and a number of negative roots ( needless to say , only values which are @xmath81 have a physical meaning ) , corresponding to ds points in the future . unfortunately , computations are harder than in the previous case and our calculations have been performed for three specific values of the parameter @xmath82 : 3 , 5 and 7 , only . in any case , the results are very similar for the three situations , what gives us hope that for larger values of @xmath82 result will be also similar . we may predict the upper limit of the ds points in the future only , which is 2 , but in any case this point is not much interesting . concerning the ds points in the past , the picture turns out to be much like the one in the previous case : the number of ds points depends only on a dimensionless parameter for all investigated values of @xmath82 . that is , @xmath83 . and there are two values , @xmath84 and @xmath85 , which are different for each @xmath82 , so for @xmath86 and @xmath87 there are two ds points and for @xmath88 there is no ds point . we have not been able to obtain exact analytical expressions for @xmath84 and @xmath85 and thus give here numerical results only . for @xmath89 @xmath90 , @xmath91 ( as positive roots of @xmath92 ) . for @xmath93 @xmath94 , @xmath95 ( as positive roots of @xmath96 ) . for @xmath97 @xmath98 , @xmath99 ( as positive roots of @xmath100 ) . as we can see , the interval where there are no ds points shrinks when the value of the parameter @xmath82 is increased . if we assume that for larger @xmath82 the number of ds points depends on the parameter @xmath101 only as clearly happens in the investigated cases we do find @xmath84 and @xmath85 for any value of @xmath82 . such investigations show that @xmath84 and @xmath85 slowly change when @xmath82 increases and that the interval without ds points is present even for very big value of the parameter @xmath82 . for example , for @xmath102 we have @xmath103 and @xmath104 . a simple numerical investigation of stability for the existing ds points shows that one of them ( the one with the smaller value of @xmath60 ) is always unstable , but the other one ( with the larger value of @xmath60 ) can either be stable or unstable . from our numerical results , the appearance of unstable ds points pairs relative to the interval @xmath86 seems most probable . note also that the condition @xmath76 means that it actually must be @xmath105 and that in this case it is most likely the one stable and one unstable point show up . now let us consider the evolution equation ( [ 2.2 ] ) from a different point of view . as we already noted , @xmath8 is a parameter of the theory which corresponds to the value of the scalar curvature at some epoch . this means that during the normal evolution of our universe , from large to little ( or zero ) curvature , it becomes @xmath7 at some moment . but , as we can see from eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) , this means that that at this point the coefficient of the higher derivative term ( @xmath106 ) is equal to zero . this is a well - known mathematical problem , which needs special investigation . as we know from mathematics there are two possibilities : the solution of the perturbed equation ( with a higher derivative term ) may tend to the solution of the degenerate equation ( without higher derivatives ) , and then the coefficient of the higher derivative term may tend to zero or not tend to the solution of the degenerate equation . a special investigation of this problem shows that solutions of eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) tend to solutions of the degenerate equation , which is @xmath107 when @xmath108 but not so when @xmath109 . this means that the point @xmath8 is reachable during the evolution from large @xmath3 to zero , but it is not the final point of the evolution , because there is an instability in the future . on the other hand , we have @xmath7 at this point , and therefore @xmath110 . substituting this into ( [ 2.5 ] ) we find a relation among the parameters of the theory which were introduced before , @xmath75 . this means that , generically , if one wants the point @xmath8 to be reachable during evolution , a relation of this sort among the parameters of the theory must be fulfilled . that is , we have two independent parameters only ( or even just one if we consider that @xmath8 is strictly related to our epoch ) . note also that it is impossible to use standard numerical methods near this point for solving eq . ( [ 2.2 ] ) because all available methods need solving the equation with respect to the highest derivative , and it turns out that , near this point , the numerical solution is unstable . ) near equilibrium points . stars denote beginning of trajectories . dashed and dot dashed lines lead to bottom.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] near unstable point for dashed and dot - dashed lines of fig.[fig.1 ] . zero in time corresponds to the stars from the previous graph.,scaledwidth=50.0% ] now let us consider numerical results near the stable points . since the value of @xmath8 is very small in our epoch ( @xmath111 @xmath112 ) , it is impossible to use real values in computations . thus , we have produced a qualitative analysis using the following set of parameters : @xmath113 , @xmath114 , @xmath115 , @xmath97 . as we can see , @xmath116 , and there must be two ds points corresponding to positive @xmath117 . the evolution lines near these points are represented in fig . [ fig.3 ] , where we can trace one stable and one unstable point , stars denoting the beginning of trajectories , as in the previous case . actually , there are three ds points for these chosen parameters . one of them , @xmath118 , which corresponds to @xmath74 , is degenerate and situated out of the graph . the time evolution of @xmath119 is represented in fig . [ fig.4 ] by the dashed and dot - dashed lines . the picture is very similar to the one in the previous section , and the same comments also apply here . thus , we have here shown that the unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration is in principle possible , and even very likely , due to the appearance of several ds points in the evolution of the universe . for a more realistic study , the presence of ( minimally and non - minimally coupled ) matter should be taken into account with care . as a third example , now we discuss a model proposed in @xcite . such model is defined by means of the function [ tan1 ] f(r)=r - f(r)=r - a , where @xmath120 , @xmath121 and @xmath8 are arbitrary parameters . one immediately sees that @xmath122 , as required and , moreover , that [ tan3 ] _ rf(r)=2_eff a. if @xmath123 in the present universe then @xmath124 plays the role of the effective cosmological constant . we also observe that the derivative [ tan4 ] f(r)=1- has a minimum when @xmath7 , which reads [ tan5 ] f(r_0)=1- . in order to avoid antigravity one needs to require [ tan6 ] 0<f(r)<f(r_0)= 1- . the model given by eq . ( [ tan1 ] ) is able to describe late acceleration , since , in general , de sitter critical points exist . they are the solutions of ( [ b ] ) . then , we set k(r)=2f(r)-rf(r ) , [ rkr ] and study ( numerically ) the zeros of this transcendental function ( see fig . [ p : tanh1 ] ) . we see that for suitable choices of the parameters there are one or two de sitter critical points . for @xmath125 and different choices of the parameter @xmath121 : @xmath126 , @xmath127 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath128 , @xmath129 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] for @xmath125 and different choices of the parameter @xmath121 : @xmath126 , @xmath127 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath128 , @xmath129 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] now , we impose @xmath8 to be a de sitter critical point for the model in eq . ( [ tan1 ] ) . this means that ( [ rkr ] ) has to be satisfied for @xmath7 and such a condition fixes one parameter , say @xmath120 . then , we get a= , and introducing , for convenience , the dimensionless variables x=,b_0=r_0b , we obtain f(r_0)=1- . _ eff= , k(r)=- . in order to have @xmath130 and , at the same time , to avoid antigravity , the parameter @xmath131 has to be negative and in the range @xmath132 . by varying @xmath131 in that range , the value of @xmath124 can acquire any desired value . moreover the model has always two de sitter critical points with constant curvatures @xmath133 and @xmath134 . one can see that @xmath135 , while @xmath136 . in fig . ( [ p : tanh2 ] ) we have plotted @xmath137 for some values of @xmath131 . , with @xmath8 as a fixed de sitter solution , for different choices of the parameter @xmath131 : @xmath138 , @xmath139 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath140 , @xmath141 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] , with @xmath8 as a fixed de sitter solution , for different choices of the parameter @xmath131 : @xmath138 , @xmath139 ( picture on the left ) ; @xmath140 , @xmath141 ( picture on the right).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] thus , our study shows the existence of multiply - de sitter universes in more complicated , tangential models . one can prove that other viable @xmath2 gravities introduced in ref . @xcite naturally lead to de sitter solutions too , as demonstrated in ref . in this section we will discuss spherically symmetric exact solutions for the modified gravities above . we mainly concentrate on multiply black hole solutions and on their related entropies and free energies . we have seen in the introduction that , requiring constant curvature solutions , one may consider the simplified form of the equations of motion given in ( [ e ] ) . as a result , @xmath1 modified gravity models admit the following class of general static neutral black hole solutions in four dimensions and with a non vanishing cosmological constant . in order to describe them , recall the metric ds^2=-v(r)dt^2++r^2d_k^2,v(r)>0 , [ ds ] where @xmath142 and the possible horizon manifolds are @xmath143 , the two dimensional sphere , @xmath144 , the two dimensional torus , and @xmath145 , the two dimensional compact riemann surface . the scalar curvature for the _ ansatz _ ( [ ds ] ) reads r=- [ r^2v+4rv+2v-2k ] and this means that every constant curvature solution with @xmath7 has to satisfy the equation r^2v+4rv+2v-2k =- r^2 r_0 . the general solution of this differential equation depends on two integration constants , @xmath121 and @xmath146 , and reads v(r)=+k -- r^2 . the ricci tensor and the scalar curvature have to satisfy the equations r_=g_,r = r_0 , [ e1 ] where @xmath8 is implicitly given by ( [ b ] ) , that is r_0= , now , it is easy to verify that eqs . ( [ e1 ] ) are satisfied only if @xmath147 , while @xmath146 is an arbitrary parameter , which is usually assumed to be non - negative and related to the mass @xmath148 of the black hole by @xmath149 . the special case @xmath150 is also admissible . then , we have v(r)=k -- r^2,c0,v(r)>0 . [ vr ] in principle there are physical solutions of the latter equation for @xmath151 and @xmath152 , which give rise , respectively , to a torus topology and a hyperbolic topology for the horizon manifold ( the so called topological black holes @xcite ) . here we are mainly interested in the usual spherical symmetric horizons and so we only consider in detail the case @xmath153 . as it is well known , in the special case @xmath154 , @xmath155 in ( [ vr ] ) is always positive when @xmath156 , and this corresponds to the anti de sitter ( ads ) solution . on the contrary , when @xmath157 , @xmath155 is positive , for @xmath158 , and this corresponds to the de sitter solution . if @xmath153 and @xmath159 , one has black hole solutions but only if c^2r_0 - 032mg1 . [ bkc ] we see that ( [ bkc ] ) is always satisfied if @xmath156 . this corresponds to the schwarzschild - anti - de sitter ( sads ) black hole . in this case @xmath160 , @xmath161 being the positive root of @xmath162 ( horizon radius ) . if @xmath157 , there are solutions only if @xmath163 . in this case @xmath164 , @xmath161 and @xmath165 being the positive roots of @xmath162 ( horizon and cosmological radius respectively ) . the extremal case @xmath166 is also admissible ( nariai solution ) , but the thermodynamics of such a black hole have to be discussed separately @xcite . at this point , we provide a brief discussion regarding the thermodynamical properties of the above black hole solutions . if one make use of the noether charge method for evaluating the entropy associated with the black hole solutions with constant curvature @xcite in modified @xmath1 gravity models , one has @xcite s= f(r_h ) . [ ve ] where the factor @xmath1 has to be evaluated on the horizon , with area @xmath167 . as a consequence , one obtains a modification of the `` area law '' . several examples have been discussed in @xcite . in the case of a constant curvature solution one has simply @xmath168 , @xmath8 being the solution of eq . ( [ b ] ) , which has been investigated in previous sections . with regard to this , we have found sufficient conditions to have two de sitter solutions . thus , we may investigate their thermodynamical behavior evaluating the associated free energy . the free energy @xmath169 is related to the canonical partition function @xmath170 by = - . on the other hand , a semiclassical approximation gives ze^-i_e , where @xmath171 is the euclidean classical action associated with the de sitter solution . a direct calculation leads to i_e=- and from ( [ b ] ) and ( [ ve ] ) it directly follows that i_e =- s_h=- , [ fe ] @xmath172 and @xmath173 being , respectively , the entropy and the inverse temperature of the black hole . for a generic schwarzschild - de sitter ( sds ) solution , eq . ( [ fe ] ) reads = - . [ fe1 ] the temperature @xmath174 is related to the horizon radius @xmath161 by t_h=== |-| @xmath161 being a positive solution of the algebraic equation r_h^3-r_h+=0 . [ ho ] as a result , we finally have = -|r_h-3mg| . [ fe2 ] in the pure de sitter case @xmath175 , @xmath176 , and so one has [ fds ] for sds one needs to consider separately the two admissible cases @xmath166 and @xmath163 . here we discuss the second one only , that is , the proper sds solution where @xmath177 . in this case , eq . ( [ ho ] ) has one negative root and two distinct positive roots , @xmath161 , the event horizon and @xmath165 , the cosmological horizon , with @xmath178 . the positive roots can be written in the form r_c=,12<_c<1 , r_h= , 0<_h<12 , where _ c=12and _ h=12(3-_c ) . in this way , we get _ c = f_ds , [ fc ] _ h = f_ds , [ fh ] @xmath179 being the expression ( [ fds ] ) . it has to be noted that , in the latter equations , the factors in front of @xmath179 are always smaller than 1 and thus the energies @xmath180 and @xmath181 are always smaller than @xmath179 , independently of the value of the mass . moreover , the factor @xmath182 is a monotone decreasing function of @xmath183 , which is equal to 1 for @xmath184 and to 0 for @xmath166 , while the factor @xmath185 is exactly equal to 0 for @xmath186 and quite small otherwise . its maximum value , a little bit more than @xmath187 , is reached for @xmath188 . this means that the minimum value for the free energy @xmath181 of a sds black hole is obtained for @xmath189 . now , we shall study some models and explicitly compute the corresponding free energy . first of all , as a trivial example , we consider the @xmath190 model described by @xmath191 . this has a stable de sitter solution , with @xmath192 . then , we immediately have _ ds=- . the corresponding sds cosmological and black - hole free energies are plotted in fig . [ p : lacdm ] , as a function of the mass @xmath148 ( in energy units @xmath193 ) . and @xmath181 sds free energies for the @xmath0cdm model.,scaledwidth=40.0% ] as a second example we consider the viable model in ( [ 1.5 ] ) , with @xmath63 , @xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath30 , as discussed in sect . ii . with this choice of parameters , eq . ( [ b ] ) has three real solutions for @xmath196 ( minkowski ) , @xmath197 and @xmath198 . the last one ( @xmath134 ) is stable , while the other two are unstable . for the free energies of the two de sitter solutions we get ^(1)_ds=-23 -,^(2)_ds=-23 - . [ minimods ] we see that ^(2)_ds < f^(1)_ds,~3.636 . independently of the parameter @xmath22 and so the stable de sitter solution with curvature @xmath134 is favorite , from the energetic point of view , with respect to the one with smaller curvature @xmath133 . the sds free energies are plotted in fig . [ p : fcfh ] , as functions of the mass @xmath148 ( in energy units @xmath199 , for @xmath200 . however , it has to be stressed that , for the sds corresponding to the de sitter solution with curvature @xmath134 , the mass needs to be restricted to @xmath201 and thus , for a fixed mass @xmath148 , we can compare the corresponding free energies in this range only . for both the cosmological and black - hole horizons there are critical values of the black hole mass @xmath148 , say @xmath202 , for which @xmath203 . then , we can distinguish three different regions : + ( a ) @xmath204 : in this first case @xmath205 ; + ( b ) @xmath206 : in this second case @xmath207 , but @xmath208 ; + ( c ) finally , for @xmath209 , we have @xmath210 . as we have seen from general considerations , the free energies corresponding to the cosmological horizons are monotonous functions of the mass , while the ones corresponding to the black - hole horizons are convex functions , which reach the minimum at @xmath211 . for our two cases , @xmath133 and @xmath134 , we get m_1~~ , ^(1)_h , min~- , m_2~~ , ^(2)_h , min~- . [ minimum ] then we see that , for the model in ( [ 1.5 ] ) we are dealing with , the configuration with the minimum free energy corresponds to sds with mass @xmath212 and curvature @xmath213 . the associated free energy is given in ( [ minimum ] ) . we also observe that this is smaller than the free energy of the pure de sitter configuration as it is clear from ( [ minimods ] ) thus , it is demonstrated here that multiple de sitter solutions can appear also under the form of sds solutions . in other words , the number of multiply solutions becomes significantly bigger . with the appearance of both ds and sds universe solutions one can suggest various scenarios for the universe evolution . for instance , we can conjecture that a ( pre-)inflationary universe is described by some sds spacetime . as time proceeds , this universe decays and enters into the well known radiation / matter dominance phase . in its further evolution , the universe transits to the ds ( or almost ds ) era , by stability and least - energy principle considerations . the future universe may again appear as an sds spacetime . ): cosmological free energies on the left and black - hole free energies on the right.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] ): cosmological free energies on the left and black - hole free energies on the right.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=40.0% ] . in summary , we have investigated in this paper several viable models of modified gravity which satisfy both the constraints of local as well as cosmological tests . by means of a numerical study , it is demonstrated that some versions of highly non - linear models exhibit multiply de sitter universe solutions which often appear in pairs , being one of them stable and the other unstable . the numerical evolution of the effective equation of state parameter is presented too . as a result , these models can be considered as natural candidates for the unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration through ds critical points . moreover , based on the de sitter solutions , multiply sds solutions can also be constructed . further , we have investigated the thermodynamic properties of these sds universes : their corresponding entropies and free energies have been calculated and compared . sds universe might also appear at the ( pre-)inflationary stage . owing to the highly non - linear structure of the theories under discussion , the ds universes had to be constructed with numerical tools mainly . moreover , in order to simplify the problem , at this first stage of the investigation we did not to consider matter contributions . it is clear that , in the next step , we must necessarily include matter and reconsider the problem in its presence . this has the potential to lead to a sufficiently realistic quantitative description of the universe expansion history , in which modified gravity would be responsible for both acceleration stages : the inflation epoch and the dark energy one . this quantitative analysis will be presented elsewhere . * acknowledgements . * this paper is an outcome of the collaboration program infn ( italy ) and dgicyt ( spain ) . it has been also supported in part by mec ( spain ) , projects fis2006 - 02842 and pie2007 - 50i023 , by agaur ( generalitat de catalunya ) , contract 2005sgr-00790 and grant 2008be1 - 00180 , and by rfbr , grant 06 - 01 - 00609 ( russia ) . the work of p.t . was partially supported by rfbr , grant 08 - 02 - 00923 , and with the scientific school grant 4899.2008.2 of the russian ministry of science and technology . pt thanks alexey toporensky for some useful discussions . the research of ee is partly based on work done while on leave at the department of physics and astronomy , dartmouth college , 6127 wilder laboratory , hanover , nh 03755 , usa . s. nojiri and s.d . odintsov , arxiv:0807.0685[hep - th ] ; t. sotiriou and v. faraoni , arxiv:0805.1726[gr - qc ] ; s. capozziello and m. francaviglia , gen.relat.grav . * 40 * , 357 ( 2008 ) ; f. lobo , arxiv:0807.1640[gr - qc ] . s. capozziello , int.j.mod.phys . d * 11 * , 483 ( 2002 ) ; m. ruggiero and l. iorio , arxiv : gr - qc/0607093 ; a. cruz - dombriz and a. dobado , arxiv : gr - qc/0607118 ; n. poplawski , arxiv : gr - qc/0610133 ; m. c. b. abdalla et al , class . quant . grav . * 22 * , l35 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0409177 ] ; a. brookfield , c. van de bruck and l. hall , arxiv : hep - th/0608015 ; h. oyaizu , m. lima and w. hu , arxiv:0807.2462[astro - ph ] ; b. li , k. chan and m. chu , arxiv : astro - ph/0610794 ; x. jin , d. liu and x. li , arxiv : astro - ph/0610854 ; t. sotiriou and s. liberati , arxiv : gr - qc/0604006 ; t. sotiriou , arxiv:0805.1160[gr - qc ] ; i. navarro and k. van acoleyen , arxiv : gr - qc/0611127 ; a. bustelo and d. barraco , arxiv : gr - qc/0611149 ; f. briscese , e. elizalde , s. nojiri and s. d. odintsov , phys . lett . b * 646 * , 105 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0612220 ] ; b. li and j. barrow , arxiv : gr - qc/0701111 ; v. faraoni , arxiv : gr - qc/0703044 ; arxiv:0706.1223[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0805.1249[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0810.2602[gr - qc ] ; o. bertolami , c. boehmer , t. harko and f. lobo , arxiv:0704.1733[gr - qc ] ; o. bertolami and j. paramos , arxiv:0805.1241[gr - qc ] ; s. carloni , a. troisi and p. dunsby , arxiv:0706.0452[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0707.0106[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0809.3673[astro - ph ] ; j. santos , j. alcaniz , f. carvalho et al , arxiv:0708.0411[astro - ph ] ; arxiv:0807.2443[astro - ph ] ; h. mohseni sadjadi , arxiv:0709.2435[gr - qc ] ; n. lanahan - tremblay and v. faraoni , arxiv:0709.4414[gr - qc ] ; n. goheer , j. leach and p. dunsby , arxiv:0710.0814[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0809.5247[gr - qc ] ; o. lecian and g. montani , arxiv:0807.4428[gr - qc ] ; t. harko , arxiv:0810.0742[gr - qc ] ; b. vakili , arxiv:0809.4591[gr - qc ] ; s. srivastava , arxiv:0809.1950[gr - qc ] ; d. saez , arxiv:0809.1311[hep - th ] ; k. bamba et al , arxiv:0803.3384[hep - th ] , phys.rev . d*77 * , 123532 ( 2008 ) ; arxiv:0801.0954[astro - ph ] , jcap * 0804*,024 ( 2008 ) ; arxiv:0807.2575[hep - th ] . p. mahato , annales de la fondation louis de broglie 32 ( 2007 ) 297 - 310;arxiv:0710.3821 [ astro - ph ] . s. nojiri and s. odintsov , gen . grav . * 36 * , 1765 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0308176 ] ; phys . b * 576 * , 5 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0307071 ] ; phys . * b599 * , 137 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0403622 ] ; arxiv:0801.4843[astro - ph ] ; g. cognola , e. elizalde , s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov and s. zerbini , phys . rev . * d73 * , 084007 ( 2006 ) , [ arxiv : hep - th/0601008 ] ; s. capozziello et al , arxiv : astro - ph/0501426 ; arxiv : hep - th/0512118 ; g. allemandi , a. borowiec , m. francaviglia and s. d. odintsov , arxiv : gr - qc/0504057 ; g. allemandi , m. francaviglia , m. ruggiero and a. tartaglia , arxiv : gr - qc/0506123 ; t. multamaki and i. vilja , arxiv : astro - ph/0612775 ; arxiv:0709.3422[astro - ph ] ; j. a. r. cembranos , phys . rev . d * 73 * , 064029 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : gr - qc/0507039 ] ; t. koivisto and h. kurki - suonio , arxiv : astro - ph/0509422 ; t. clifton and j. barrow , arxiv : gr - qc/0509059 ; i. brevik , arxiv : gr - qc/0601100 ; t. faulkner , m. tegmark , e. bunn and y. mao , arxiv : astro - ph/0612569 ; s. capozziello et al , arxiv:0804.2163[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0712.2980[gr - qc ] ; arxiv:0810.2549[gr - qc ] ; s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov and p. tretyakov , arxiv:0704.2520[hep - th ] ; m. movahed , s. baghram and s. rahvar , arxiv:0705.0889[astro - ph ] ; c. boehmer , t. harko and f. lobo , arxiv:0710.0966[gr - qc ] ; j. miritzis , arxiv:0708.1396[gr - qc ] ; d. vollick , arxiv:0710.1859[gr - qc ] ; j. evans , l. hall and p. caillol , arxiv:0711.3695[astro - ph ] ; t. clifton , arxiv:0807.4682[gr - qc ] ; h. stefancic , arxiv:0807.4428[gr - qc ] ; a. dev et al , arxiv:0807.3445[hep - th ] ; t. kobayashi and k. maeda , arxiv:0807.2503[astro - ph ] ; s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov , phys . d * 74 * , ( 2006 ) 086005 [ arxiv : hep - th/0608008 ] ; arxiv : hep - th/0611071 ; s. capozziello , s. nojiri , s. d. odintsov and a. troisi , phys . b * 639 * , 135 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : astro - ph/0604431 ] . s. tsujikawa , k. uddin and r. tavakol , arxiv:0712.0082 ; s. fay , s. nesseris and l. perivolaropoulos , arxiv : gr - qc/0703006 . g. cognola , m. gastaldi and s. zerbini , arxiv : gr - qc/0701138 ; j.l . cortes and j. indurain , arxiv:0805.3481[astro - ph ] ; s. tsujikawa and t. tatekawa , arxiv:0804.4343[astro - ph ] ; n. deruelle , m. sasaki and y. sendouda , phys.rev . d * 77*,124024 ( 2008 ) ; k. kainulainen and d. sunhede , arxiv:0803.0867[gr - qc ] ; g. cognola and s. zerbini , j.phys . a * 39 * , 6245 ( 2006 ) . s. a. appleby and r. a. battye , arxiv:0705.3199[astro - ph ] ; l. pogosian and a. silvestri , arxiv:0709.0296[astro - ph ] ; s. tsujikawa , arxiv:0709.1391[astro - ph ] ; s. capozziello and s. tsujikawa , arxiv:0712.2268[gr - qc ] . i.brevik , s. nojiri , s.d . odintsov and l. vanzo , hep - th 0401073 , phys.rev . d * 70 * , 043520 ( 2004 ) ; g. cognola , s. nojiri , s.d . odintsov and s. zerbini , hep - th/0501096 , jcap * 0502 * , 010 ( 2005 ) ; f. briscese and e. elizalde , phys . d * 77 * , 044009 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0708.0432 [ hep - th ] ] .
Abstract: | [
"viable models of modified gravity which satisfy both local as well as cosmological tests are investigated . it is demonstrated that some versions of such highly non - linear models exhibit multiply de sitter universe solutions , which often appear in pairs , being one of them stable and the other unstable . it is explicitly shown that , for some values of the parameters , it is possible to find several de sitter spaces ( as a rule , numerically ) ; one of them may serve for the inflationary stage , while the other can be used for the description of the dark energy epoch . the numerical evolution of the effective equation of state parameter is also presented , showing that these models can be considered as natural candidates for the unification of early - time inflation with late - time acceleration through ds critical points . moreover , based on the de sitter solutions , multiply sds universes are constructed which might also appear at the ( pre-)inflationary stage . their thermodynamics are studied and free energies are compared . = 5000"
] | 8,437 | 8,437 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the precision test of the standard model ( sm ) at the lep gave a possibility not only to determine all the parameters and particle masses at the level of radiative corrections but also afforded an opportunity for searching for signals of new heavy particles beyond the energy scale of it . on the base of the lep2 experiments the low bounds on parameters of various models extending the sm have been estimated and the scale of new physics was obtained @xcite . although no new particles were discovered , a general believe is that the energy scale of new physics to be of order 1 tev , that may serve as a guide for experiments at the tevatron and lhc . in this situation , any information about new heavy particles obtained on the base of the present day data is desirable and important . numerous extended models include the @xmath0 gauge boson massive neutral vector particle associated with the extra @xmath1 subgroup of an underlying group . searching for this particle as a virtual state is widely discussed in the literature ( see for references @xcite ) . in the content of searching for @xmath0 at the lhc and the ilc an essential information and prospects for future investigations are given in lectures @xcite . such aspects as the mass of @xmath0 , couplings to the sm particles , @xmath2 mixing and its influence in various processes and particles parameters , distinctions between different models are discussed in details . we shall turn to these papers in what follows . as concerned a searching for @xmath0 in the lep experiments and the experiments at tevatron @xcite , it was carried out mainly in a model - dependent way . a wide class of popular models has been investigated and low bounds on the mass @xmath3 were estimated ( see , @xcite ) . as it is occurred , the low masses are varying in a wide energy interval 400 - 1800 gev dependently on a specific model . these bounds are a little bit different in the lep and tevatron experiments . in this situation a model - independent analysis is of interest . in the papers @xcite of the present authors a new approach for the model - independent search for @xmath0-boson was proposed which , in contrast to other model - independent searches , gives a possibility to pick out uniquely this virtual state and determine its characteristics . the corresponding observables have also been introduced and applied to analyze the lep2 experiment data . our consideration is based on two constituents : 1 ) the relations between the effective low - energy couplings derived from the renormalization group ( rg ) equation for fermion scattering amplitudes . we called them the rg relations . due to these relations , a number of unknown @xmath0 parameters entering the amplitudes of different scattering processes considerably decreases . 2 ) when these relations are accounted for , some kinematics properties of the amplitude become uniquely correlated with this virtual state and the @xmath0 signals exhibit themselves . the rg relations allow to introduce observables correlated uniquely with the @xmath0-boson . comparing the mean values of the observables with the necessary specific values , one could arrive at a conclusion about the @xmath0 existence . the confidence level ( cl ) of these values has been estimated and adduced in addition . without taking into consideration the rg relations the determination of @xmath0-boson requires a supplementary specification due to a larger number of different couplings contributing to the observables . similar situation takes place in the `` helicity model fits '' of lep collaborations @xcite when different virtual states contribute to each of the specific models ( aa , vv , and so on ) . therefore these fits had the goal to discover any signals of new physics independently of the particular states which may cause deviations from the sm . note that the lep collaborations saw no indications of new contact four fermion interactions in these fits . in refs . @xcite the one - parametric observables were introduced and the signals ( hints in fact ) of the @xmath0 have been determined at the 1@xmath4 cl in the @xmath5 process , and at the 2@xmath4 cl in the bhabha process . the @xmath0 mass was estimated to be 11.2 tev . an increase in statistics could make these signals more pronounced and there is a good chance to discover this particle at the lhc . in ref . @xcite the updated results of the one - parameter fit and the complete many - parametric fit of the lep2 data were performed with the goal to estimate a possible signal of the @xmath0-boson with accounting for the final data of the lep collaborations delphi and opal @xcite . usually , in a many - parametric fit the uncertainty of the result increases drastically because of extra parameters . on the contrary , in our approach due to the rg relations between the low - energy couplings there are only 2 - 3 independent parameters for the investigated leptonic scattering processes . as it was showed in ref . @xcite , an inevitable increase of confidence areas in the many - parametric space was compensated due to accounting for all accessible experimental information . therefore , the uncertainty of the many - parametric fit was estimated as the comparable with previous one - parametric fits in refs . @xcite . in this approach the combined data fit for all lepton processes is also possible . from the results obtained on the searching for abelian @xmath0 within the lep experiment data set we conclude that it is insufficient for convincing discovery of this particle as the virtual state . in this situation it is reasonable to analyze the data by using the neural network approach which is able to make a realistic prognoses for the parameters of interest . this investigation was done within the two parametric global fit of the lep2 data on the bhabha scattering process . as the result of all these considerations we derive at the 2@xmath4 cl the characteristics of the @xmath0 ( the vector @xmath6 and axial - vector @xmath7 couplings of the @xmath0 with sm leptons and the @xmath8 mixing ) . the @xmath0 mass is also estimated . due to the universality of the @xmath7 we also derived the model independent estimate of the @xmath0 axial - vector couplings to quarks , @xmath9 . note that the hints for the @xmath0 have been determined in all the processes considered that increases the reliability of the signal . these results may serve as a good input into the future lhc and ilc experiments and used in various aspects . to underline the importance of them we mention that there are many tools at the lhc for the identification of @xmath0 . but many of them are only applicable if @xmath0 is relatively light . the knowledge of the @xmath0 couplings to sm fermions also have important consequences . the paper is organized as follows . in sect . 2 we give a necessary information about the description of @xmath0 at low energies . in sects . 3 - 5 we discuss the origin of the rg relations , their explicit forms for the case of the heavy @xmath0 and consequences of the relations for scattering processes investigated . in sect . 6 the cross sections and the observables to pick out uniquely the virtual @xmath0 in the @xmath10 processes are given . the fits of data are described and discussed . then in sect . 7 the same is present for the bhabha process @xmath11 . the one parametric and two parametric fits are discussed . in sect . 8 the analysis of this process is carried out by using the neuron network approach . the criteria for training the network are introduced which guarantee the 2@xmath4 cl deviations of the data from the model containing the sm with extra @xmath12 . the obtained parameters of the @xmath0 practically coincide with that of derived in the one parameter analysis . in this way we determine the characteristics of the @xmath0 coming from the lep experiments . in sect . 9 we discuss the role of the present model - independent analysis for the lhc experiments . the discussion and comparison with results of other approaches are given in sect . 10 . in the appendix we describe the two - mass - scale yukawa model and analyze in detail how the decoupling of the loop contributions due to heavy virtual states is realized when the mixing of fields is taken into consideration . this point is an essential element of the approach developed . let us adduce a necessary information about the abelian @xmath0-boson . this particle is predicted by a number of grand unification models . among them the @xmath13 and @xmath14 based models @xcite ( for instance , lr , @xmath15 and so on ) are often discussed in the literature . in all the models , the abelian @xmath0-boson is described by a low - energy @xmath16 gauge subgroup originated in some symmetry breaking pattern . at low energies , the @xmath0-boson can manifest itself by means of the couplings to the sm fermions and scalars as a virtual intermediate state . moreover , the @xmath17-boson couplings are also modified due to a @xmath17@xmath0 mixing . in principle , arbitrary effective @xmath0 interactions to the sm fields could be considered at low energies . however , the couplings of non - renormalizable types have to be suppressed by heavy mass scales because of decoupling . therefore , significant signals beyond the sm can be inspired by the couplings of renormalizable types . such couplings can be derived by adding new @xmath16-terms to the electroweak covariant derivatives @xmath18 in the lagrangian @xcite ( review , @xcite ) @xmath19 where summation over all the sm left - handed fermion doublets , leptons and quarks , @xmath20 , and the right - handed singlets , @xmath21 , is understood . @xmath22 denotes the charge of @xmath23 in positron charge units , @xmath24 , and @xmath25 for leptons and 1/3 for quarks . for general purposes we derive the rg relations for the @xmath0 beyond the sm with two light higgs doublets ( thdm ) @xcite . @xmath0 interactions with the scalar doublets can be parametrized in a model - independent way as follows , @xmath26 in these formulas , @xmath27 are the charges associated with the @xmath28 and the @xmath0 gauge groups , respectively , @xmath29 are the pauli matrices , @xmath30 is the generator corresponding to the gauge group of the @xmath0 boson , and @xmath31 is the @xmath32 hypercharge . the yukawa lagrangian can be written in the form @xmath33 \right.\nonumber\\&&\left . + g_{f_{u , i } } [ \bar{f}_l \phi_i^c ( f_u)_r + ( \bar{f}_u)_r \phi^{c+}_i f_l]\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath34 is the charge conjugated scalar doublet . the lagrangian ( [ lscal ] ) leads to the @xmath17@xmath0 mixing . the @xmath17@xmath0 mixing angle @xmath35 is determined by the coupling @xmath36 as follows @xmath37 where @xmath38 is the sm weinberg angle , and @xmath39 is the electromagnetic fine structure constant . although the mixing angle is a small quantity of order @xmath40 , it contributes to the @xmath17-boson exchange amplitude and can not be neglected at the lep energies . in what follows we will also use the @xmath0 couplings to the vector and axial - vector fermion currents defined as @xmath41 the lagrangian ( [ lf ] ) leads to the following interactions between the fermions and the @xmath17 and @xmath0 mass eigenstates : @xmath42f , \nonumber\\ { \cal l}_{z'\bar{f}f}&=&\frac{1}{2 } z'_\mu\bar{f}\gamma^\mu\left [ ( v_f+\gamma^5 a_f)\cos\theta_0 -\right.\nonumber\\&&\quad\left . -(v^\mathrm{sm}_{fz}+\gamma^5 a^\mathrm{sm}_{fz})\sin\theta_0\right]f,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath23 is an arbitrary sm fermion state ; @xmath43 , @xmath44 are the sm couplings of the @xmath17-boson . since the @xmath0 couplings enter the cross - section together with the inverse @xmath0 mass , it is convenient to introduce the dimensionless couplings @xmath45 which can be constrained by experiments . low energy parameters @xmath46 , @xmath47 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 must be fitted in experiments . in most investigations they were considered as independent ones . in a particular model , the couplings @xmath50 , @xmath51 take some specific values . in case when the model is unknown , these parameters remain potentially arbitrary numbers . however , this is not the case if one assumes that the underlying extended model is a renormalizable one . in the papers @xcite it was shown that these parameters are correlated due to renormalizability . we called them the rg relations . since this notion is a key - point of our consideration , we discuss it in detail . what is rg relation ? generally speaking , this is a correlation between low energy parameters of interactions of a heavy new particle with known light particles of the sm following from the requirement that full unknown yet theory extending sm is to be renormalizable . strictly speaking , rg relations are the consequence of two constituencies : 1 . rg equation for a scattering amplitude ; 2 . decoupling theorem . the latter one describes the modification of both the rg operator @xmath52 and an amplitude at the energy threshold @xmath53 of new physics . here , @xmath54- and @xmath55-functions correspond to all the charges @xmath56 and fields and masses @xmath57 of the underlying theory . the rg equation for a scattering amplitude @xmath23 reads , @xmath58 where @xmath23 accounts for as intermediate states either the light or heavy virtual particles of the full theory . the standard usage of the rg equation is to improve the amplitude by solving this equation for the operator @xmath59 calculated in a given order of perturbation theory . however , to search for heavy virtual particles , we will use eq . ( [ rge ] ) in another way . first we note that for any renormalizable theory , the rg equation is just identity , if @xmath23 and @xmath59 are calculated in a given order of loop expansion . in this case ( [ rge ] ) expresses the well known fact that the structure of the divergent term coincides with the structure of the corresponding term in a tree - level lagrangian . for example , in massless qed , the tree - level plus one - loop one - particle - irreducible vertex function describing scattering of electron in an external electromagnetic field @xmath60 , @xmath61 , is if we calculate the rg operator in one - loop order @xmath62 where @xmath63 , @xmath64 are the beta - function and the anomalous dimensions of electromagnetic and electron fields , respectively , and apply it to @xmath65 , we obtain @xmath66 then , accounting for the values of @xmath67 and the factor @xmath68 in @xmath69 , we observe that the first and the last terms in the r.h.s . cancel . since @xmath70-dependent term in @xmath71 is @xmath72 , we see that eq.([rge1 ] ) is identity in the order @xmath73 . next important point is that in a theory with different mass scales the decoupling of heavy - loop contributions at the threshold of heavy masses , @xmath53 , results in the following property : the running of all functions is regulated by the loops of light particles . therefore , the @xmath74 and @xmath75 functions at low energies are determined by the sm particles , only . this fact is the consequence of the decoupling theorem @xcite . the decoupling results in the redefinition of parameters at the scale @xmath53 and removing heavy - particle loop contributions from rg equation @xcite : @xmath76 where @xmath77 and @xmath78 denote the parameters of the sm . they are calculated assuming that no heavy particles are excited inside loops . the matching between both sets of parameters @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath56 , @xmath57 is chosen at the normalization point @xmath79 , @xmath80 the differential operator @xmath81 in the rg equation is in fact unique ; the apparently different @xmath81 in both theories are the same ! note that if a theory with different mass scales is specified one can freely replace the parameters @xmath77 , @xmath78 and @xmath56 , @xmath57 by each other @xcite . an example of the derivation and the main features of the rg relations are shown in the appendix for a simple model with different mass scales . if underlying theory is not specified , the set of @xmath56 , @xmath57 is unknown . the low energy theory consists of the sm plus the effective lagrangian generated by the interactions of light particles with virtual heavy particle states . the low energy parameters @xmath82 of these interactions are arbitrary numbers which must be constrained by experiments . by calculating the rg operator @xmath81 and the scattering amplitudes of light particles in this ` external field ' in a chosen order of loop expansion , it is possible to obtain the model - independent correlations between @xmath82 . these are just the re relations . let us derive the correlations between @xmath50 , @xmath83 appearing due to renormalizability of the underlying theory containing @xmath0 . in our case , the rg invariance of the vertex leads to the equation @xmath84 where @xmath85 and @xmath86 are computed with taking into account the loops of light particles . now we derive the rg relations following from the one - loop consideration . in accordance with the previous sections , the one - loop rg equation for the vertex function reads @xmath87 where @xmath88 and @xmath89 are the tree - level and one - loop contributions to the fermion-@xmath0 vertex . @xmath90 is the one - loop level part of the rg operator . vertex at the one - loop level . ] to calculate these functions , only the divergent parts of the one - loop vertices are to be calculated . the corresponding diagrams are shown in fig . [ f-2 ] . the fermion anomalous dimensions @xmath91 can be calculated by using the diagrams in fig . [ f-3 ] . then , eq.([rgez ] ) leads to algebraic equations for the parameters @xmath50 , @xmath92 and @xmath49 which have two sets of solutions @xcite : @xmath93 and @xmath94 here @xmath23 and @xmath95 are the partners of the @xmath96 fermion doublet ( @xmath97 and @xmath98 ) , @xmath99 is the third component of weak isospin . the first of these relations describes the @xmath0 boson analogous to the third component of the @xmath96 gauge field . the couplings to the right - handed singlet are absent . the second relation corresponds to the abelian @xmath0 . in this case the sm lagrangian appears to be invariant with respect to the @xmath16 group associated with the @xmath0 . the last relation in eq.([rgr2 ] ) ensures the @xmath100 eq.([lyukawa ] ) is to be invariant with respect to the @xmath16 transformations . introducing the @xmath0 couplings to the vector and axial - vector fermion currents ( [ av ] ) , the last line in eq . ( [ rgr2 ] ) yields @xmath101 the couplings of the abelian @xmath0 to the axial - vector fermion current have a universal absolute value proportional to the @xmath0 coupling to the scalar doublet . these relations are model independent . in particular , they hold in all the known models containing the abelian @xmath0 . the most discussed models are derived from the @xmath102 group ( the so called lr , @xmath103-@xmath104 models ) . the tree - level @xmath0 couplings to the sm fermions in the models are shown in table 1 . [ zpcoup ] .the @xmath105 couplings to the sm fermions in the most discussed @xmath102-based models . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^ " , ] the standard @xmath106-fit gives the following constraints for the coupling @xmath107 at the 68% cl : @xmath108 hence it is seen that the most precise data of delphi and opal collaborations give no signal of the chiral @xmath0 at the 1@xmath4 cl . the combined value also shows no signal at the 1@xmath4 cl . from the combined fit the 95% cl bound on the value of @xmath107 can be derived , @xmath109 . supposing the @xmath0 coupling constant @xmath110 to be of the order of the electroweak one , @xmath111 , the corresponding @xmath0 mass has to be larger than @xmath112 tev . a complete two parametric fit of experimental data based directly on the differential cross - sections has been carried out in ref . @xcite . due to only two independent couplings this fit is efficient . in the fitting the available final data for the differential cross - sections of the bhabha process were used . the data set consists of 299 bins including the data of aleph at 130 - 183 gev , delphi at 189 - 207 gev , l3 at 183 - 189 gev , and opal at 130 - 207 gev @xcite . the fitting procedure is similar to that of discussed above for the abelian @xmath0 . the results can be summarized as follows . the parameter space of the chiral @xmath0 is the plane ( @xmath113 , @xmath114 ) . the minimum of the @xmath106-function , @xmath115 , is reached at zero value of @xmath113 ( @xmath116 ) and almost independent of the value of @xmath114 ( the maximal - likelihood values of the couplings ) . the 95% cl area ( @xmath117 ) is shown in figure 3 . [ fig - ch - many ] as one can see , the zero point , @xmath118 ( the absence of the chiral @xmath0 boson ) is inside the confidence area . the value of @xmath106 in this point ( 238.62 ) is indistinguishable from the @xmath119 . in other words , the set of experimental data can not determine the signal of the chiral @xmath0-boson . as also is seen , the value of @xmath113 is constrained as @xmath120 at the 95% cl . this upper bound is in an agreement with the corresponding result of the one - parameter fit ( @xmath121 ) . thus , the @xmath0 mass has to be larger than @xmath122 tev , if the @xmath0 coupling constant @xmath110 is again supposed to be of the order of the electroweak one , @xmath111 . the fit of the differential cross - sections leads to a better accuracy for @xmath113 than the fit of the integrated cross - sections based on the same data . without accounting for the model - independent relations between the @xmath0 couplings it is impossible to obtain such results in this section we discuss all the assumptions giving a possibility to pick out the @xmath0 signal and determine its characteristics in a model independent way . we also note the role of the present results for the future lhc and ilc experiments . as it was already stressed , in searching for this particle at the lep and tevatron a model dependent analysis was mainly used . the motivation for this was the different number of chiral fermions involved in different models ( see , for example , @xcite ) . in this approach , the low bounds on @xmath3 have been estimated and a smallness of the @xmath2 mixing was also observed . on the contrary , in our model independent approach the rg relations between the parameters of the effective low energy lagrangians have been accounted for that gave a possibility to determine not only the bounds but also the mass and other parameters of the @xmath0 . first we note all the assumptions used in our considerations . we analyzed the four - fermion scattering amplitudes of order @xmath123 generated by the @xmath0 virtual states . the vertices linear in @xmath0 were included into the effective low - energy lagrangian . we also impose a number of natural conditions . the interactions of a renormalizable type are dominant at low energies @xmath124 . the non - renormalizable interactions generated at high energies due to radiation corrections are suppressed by the inverse heavy mass @xmath125 and neglected . we also assumed that the @xmath126 gauge group of the sm is a subgroup of the gut group . as a consequence , all structure constants connecting two sm gauge bosons with @xmath0 are to be zero . hence , the interactions of gauge fields of the types @xmath127 , and other are absent at the tree level . our effective lagrangian is also consistent with the absence of the tree - level flavor - changing neutral currents ( fcncs ) in the fermion sector . the renormalizable interactions of fermions and scalars are described by the yukawa lagrangian ( [ lyukawa ] ) that accounts for different possibilities of the yukawa sector without the tree - level fcncs . these assumptions are quite general and satisfied in a wide class of @xmath13 inspired models . within these constraints for the low energy effective lagrangian the rg correlations have been derived . correspondingly , the model independent estimates of the mass @xmath3 and other parameters are regulated by the noted requirements . therefore , the extended underlying model has also to accept them . in this regard , let us discuss the role of the obtained estimates for the lhc . as it is well known ( see , for example , @xcite ) , there are many tools at the lhc for @xmath0 identification . but many of them are only applicable if this particle is relatively light . our results are in favor to this case . next important point is the determination of @xmath0 couplings to the various sm fermions . as we have shown , the axial - vector couplings of the @xmath0 to the sm fermions are universal and proportional to its coupling to the higgs field . hence we have obtained an estimate of the @xmath128 couplings for both leptons and quarks . this is an essential input because experimental analyses for the lhc have mainly concentrated on being able to distinguish models and not on actual couplings . the vector coupling @xmath129 was also estimated that , in particular , may help to distinguish the decay of the @xmath0 resonance state to @xmath130 pairs . since the couplings @xmath131 and @xmath129 were estimated there is a possibility to distinguish this process from the decay of the @xmath132 system . in the literature @xcite on searching for the @xmath0 it is also mentioned that the determination of the @xmath0 couplings to fermions could be fulfilled channel by channel , @xmath133 , . in almost all these considerations the relations between the parameters have not been taken into account . but this is very essential for treating of experimental data and introducing relevant observables to measure . other parameter is the @xmath2 mixing , which is responsible for different decay processes and the effective interaction vertices generated at the lhc @xcite . it is also determined by the axial - vector coupling ( see eq . ( [ grgav ] ) ) and estimated in a model independent way . remind that in our analysis ( in contrast to the approaches of the lep collaborations ) the mixing was systematically taken into account . its value is of the same order of magnitude as the parameters that were fitted in experiments . note also that the existence of other heavy particles with masses @xmath134 does not influence the rg relations which are the consequences of the necessary condition for renormalizability . in fact , this condition ( the structure of a divergence generated by radiation corrections coincides with that of the tree - level vertex ) holds for each renormalizable type interaction . an important role of the model independent results for searching for @xmath0 at the lhc and ilc consists , in particular , in possibility to determine the particle as a virtual state due to a large amount of relevant events . we mentioned already that , in principle , lep experiments were able to determine it if the statistics was sufficiently large . experiments at the ilc will increase numerously the data set of interest . in fact , the observables , introduced in sects . 6 and 7 for picking out uniquely @xmath135 and @xmath136 couplings in the leptonic scattering process , are also effective at energies @xmath137 gev and could be applied in future experiments at ilc . other model independent methods of searching for the @xmath0 as a resonance state are proposed in the literature ( see refs . we do not discuss them here because they take no relations between the parameters into consideration . besides , the main goal of the present paper is to adduce model independent information about the @xmath0 followed from experiments at low energies . different aspects of @xmath0 physics at the lhc are out of the scope of it . in this section we collect in a convenient form all the results obtained and make a comparison with other investigations on searching for @xmath0 at low energies . in fact , this is a large area to discuss . references to numerous results obtained in either model dependent or model independent approaches can be found in the surveys @xcite . further subdivision can be done into the considerations accounting for any type correlations between the parameters of the low energy effective interactions and that of assuming complete independence of them . because of a large amount of fitting parameters the latter are less predictable . now , for a convenience of readers let us present the results of fits of the @xmath0 parameters in terms of the popular notations @xcite . the lagrangian reads @xmath138f , \nonumber\\ { \cal l}_{z'\bar{f}f}&=&\frac{1}{2 } z'_\mu\bar{f}\gamma^\mu\left [ ( v'_f-\gamma^5 a'_f)\right]f,\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the sm values of the @xmath17 couplings @xmath139 where @xmath68 is the positron charge , @xmath22 is the fermion charge in the units of @xmath68 , @xmath140 for the neutrinos and @xmath141-type quarks , and @xmath142 for the charged leptons and @xmath143-type quarks . @xmath144 & @xmath145 , @xmath146 & @xmath147 , @xmath146 & @xmath148 , @xmath144 + + @xmath149 & @xmath150 & - & @xmath151 & 0.437 + + @xmath149 & - & @xmath152 & - & - + @xmath153 & @xmath154 & - & @xmath155 & 1.278 + @xmath156 & @xmath157 & - & @xmath158 & 0.464 + + @xmath149 , @xmath159 & - & @xmath160 & - & - + @xmath144 & @xmath145 , @xmath146 & @xmath147 , @xmath146 & @xmath148 , @xmath144 + + @xmath149 & 68% & @xmath161 & - & @xmath162 & @xmath163 + + @xmath149 & 95% & - & @xmath164 & - & - + @xmath153 & 95% & @xmath165 & - & @xmath166 & @xmath167 + @xmath153 , & & & & & + @xmath168 & 95% & @xmath169 & - & @xmath170 & @xmath171 + + @xmath149 , & & & & & + @xmath153 , & 95% & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & @xmath175 + @xmath168 & & & & & + @xmath149 , & & & & & + @xmath159 & 68% & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & @xmath178 & @xmath179 + the results of the fits of the @xmath0 couplings to the sm leptons obtained from the analysis of the lep experiments are adduced in the tables [ fitmlv]-[fitcli ] and fig . [ fig : fitfigs ] . remind that due to the universality of the axial - vector coupling @xmath180 the same estimates take also place for quarks . first of all , one parameter fits of lep experiments as well as the many - parameter fit for the @xmath181 backward bins show the hints of the @xmath0 boson at the 1 - 2@xmath4 cl . due to this fact , the fits allow to determine the maximum likelihood values of @xmath0 parameters . in spite of uncertainties , these values can be used as a guiding line for the estimation of possible @xmath0 effects in the lhc experiments . the maximum likelihood values are given in table [ fitmlv ] . as is seen , different fits and processes lead to the comparable values of the @xmath0 parameters . in table [ fitcli ] we present the confidence intervals for the fitted parameters . with this table one is able to estimate the uncertainty of the @xmath0 couplings as well as the lower bounds on the parameters . + + in fig . [ fig : fitfigs ] the maximum likelihood values and the cl intervals are drawn for the different values of the @xmath0 mass . all the plots exploit the same color scheme . the values excluded at 95% cl by the many - parameter fit of all the lep2 leptonic processes @xmath182 are shown in gray . the 95% confidence intervals from the one - parameter fit of lep2 @xmath183 are drawn in pink with the maximum likelihood values as the dashed red line . the corresponding results with taking into account the @xmath184 process only are shown in yellow with solid red line for the maximum likelihood values . the maximum likelihood values from the lep1 experiments are represented as dotted blue line . the 95% confidence interval from the one - parameter fit of the lep2 bhabha scattering is shown as the blue crosshatched region with the maximum likelihood values as the dashed blue line . finally , the 68% confidence interval and the maximum likelihood values from the many - parameter fit of the backward bins of lep2 bhabha scattering are shown in green . now we compare the above results with the ones of other fits accounting for the @xmath0 presence . as it was mentioned in introduction , lep collaborations have determined the model dependent low bounds on the @xmath0 mass which vary in a wide energy interval dependently on a model . the same has also been done for tevatron experiments . the modern low bound is @xmath185 gev . it is also well known that though almost all the present day data are described by the sm @xcite , the overall fit to the standard model is not very good . in ref . @xcite it was showed that the large difference in @xmath186 from the forward - backward asymmetry @xmath187 of the bottom quarks and the measurements from the slac sld experiment can be explained for physically reasonable higgs boson mass if one allows for one or more extra @xmath1 fields , that is @xmath0 . a specific model to describe @xmath0 physics of interest was proposed which introduces two type couplings to the hyper charge @xmath188 and to the baryon - minus - lepton number @xmath189 . within this model by using a number of precision measurements from lep1 , lep2 , sld and tevatron experiments the parameters @xmath190 and @xmath191 of the model were fitted . the presence of @xmath0 was not excluded at 68% cl . the value of @xmath190 was estimated to be of the same order of magnitude as in our analysis and is comparable with values of other parameters detected in the lep experiments . the erroneous claim that @xmath190 is two order less then the value derived from our table 4 is , probably , a consequence of some missed factors . the upper limit on the mass was also obtained @xmath192 tev . these two analyzes are different but complementary . a common feature of them is an accounting for the @xmath0 gauge boson as a necessary element of the data fits . the results are in accordance at 68 - 95% cl with the existence of the not heavy @xmath0 which has a good chance to be discovered at tevatron and/or lhc . in this appendix we are going to investigate the yukawa model with a heavy scalar field @xmath103 and a light scalar field @xmath193 @xcite . the goals of our investigation are two fold : 1 ) to derive the one - loop rg relation for the four - fermion scattering amplitude in the decoupling region and 2 ) to find out the possibility of reducing this relation in the equation for vertex describing the scattering of light particles on the external field when the mixing between heavy and light virtual states takes place . consider the four - fermion scattering @xmath196 . the @xmath197-matrix element at the one - loop level is given by @xmath198,\nonumber \\ s_\mathrm{1pr}&=&\sum\limits_{{\phi}_{1},{\phi}_{2}=\varphi , \chi}g_{{\phi}_{1 } } g_{{\phi}_{2}}\left ( \frac{{\delta}_{{\phi}_{1}{\phi}_{2}}}{s - m^2_{{\phi}_{1 } } } + \frac{\pi_{\phi_1\phi_2}(s)}{(s- m^2_{\phi_1})(s- m^2_{\phi_2})}\right ) \nonumber\\ & & \times { \bar\psi}\left(p_{4}\right)\left[1+\gamma\left ( p_{3 } , -p_{4}- p_{3}\right ) \right ] \psi\left(p_{3}\right)\nonumber \\ & & \times { \bar\psi}\left ( p_{1}\right ) \left[1+\gamma\left ( p_{2 } , -p_{1}- p_{2}\right ) \right ] \psi\left ( p_{2}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath199 , @xmath200 is the contribution from the one - particle reducible diagrams shown in figs . [ fig : tree]-[fig : loop ] , and @xmath201 is the contribution from box diagrams . the one - loop polarization operator of scalar fields @xmath202 and the one - loop vertex function @xmath65 are related to the green functions as @xmath203 where @xmath204 is the spinor propagator in the momentum representation . using the dimensional regularization ( the dimension of the momentum space is @xmath206 ) and the @xmath207 renormalization scheme one can compute the renormalization constants @xmath208 , \nonumber\\ \delta\lambda^2&=&\frac{1}{4\pi^2\varepsilon } \left[\left(g_\chi^2 + 6\xi\right)\lambda^2 - 6g_\chi^2m^2-\rho m^2\right ] , \nonumber\\ z_g^{-1}&=&\left[1-\frac{3}{16\pi^2\varepsilon}\left(g_\varphi^2+g_\chi^2\right)\right ] { \left(z_\phi^{1/2}\right)}^\mathrm{t}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] from eq . ( [ app5 ] ) we obtain the appropriate @xmath74 and @xmath75 functions at the one - loop level : @xmath209 then , the @xmath197-matrix element can be expressed in terms of the renormalized quantities . the contribution from the one - particle reducible diagrams becomes @xmath210\psi(p_3 ) \nonumber\\&&\times \bar\psi(p_1)\left[1+\gamma^\mathrm{(fin)}\left(p_2,-p_1-p_2\right)\right]\psi(p_2),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the functions @xmath211 and @xmath212 are the expressions @xmath213 and @xmath65 without the terms proportional to @xmath214 . since the quantity @xmath201 is finite , the renormalization leaves it without changes . introducing the rg operator at the one - loop level @xcite @xmath215 we determine that the following relation holds for the @xmath197-matrix element @xmath216 where the @xmath217 and the @xmath218 are the contributions to the @xmath200 at the tree level and at the one - loop level , respectively : @xmath219 @xmath220.\end{aligned}\ ] ] the first term in eq . ( [ app11 ] ) is originated from the one - loop correction to the fermion - scalar vertex . the rest terms are connected with the polarization operator of scalars . the third term describes the one - loop mixing between the scalar fields . it is canceled in the rg relation ( [ app9 ] ) by the mass - dependent terms in the @xmath74 functions produced by the non - diagonal elements in @xmath221 . ( [ app9 ] ) is the consequence of the renormalizability of the model . it insures the leading logarithm terms of the one - loop @xmath197-matrix element to reproduce the appropriate tree - level structure . in contrast to the familiar treatment we are not going to improve scattering amplitudes by solving eq . ( [ app9 ] ) . we will use it as an algebraic identity implemented in the renormalizable theory . naturally if one knows the explicit couplings expressed in terms of the basic set of parameters of the model , this rg relation is trivially fulfilled . but the situation changes when the couplings are represented by unknown arbitrary parameters . in this case the rg relations are the algebraic equations dependent on these parameters and appropriate @xmath74 and @xmath75 functions . in the presence of a symmetry the number of @xmath74 and @xmath75 functions is less than the number of rg relations . so , one has non trivial system of equations relating the unknown couplings . for example , such a scenario is realized for the gauge coupling . although the considered simple model has no gauge couplings , we are able to demonstrate the general procedure of deriving the rg relations . at energies @xmath222 the heavy scalar field @xmath103 is decoupled . this means , that the four - fermion scattering amplitude is described by the model with no heavy field @xmath103 plus terms of the order @xmath223 . at the tree level , this is the obvious consequence of the expansion of the heavy scalar propagator @xmath224,\ ] ] which is resulted in the effective contact four - fermion interaction in eq . ( [ app10 ] ) @xmath225 so , the tree level contribution to the scattering amplitude becomes @xmath226 \bar\psi\psi\times\bar\psi\psi,\ ] ] and the lowest order effects of the heavy scalar in the decoupling region are described by the parameter @xmath227 , only . decoupling of heavy particles is present also at the level of radiative corrections . the radiative corrections are generally described by various loop integrals in the momentum space ( the passarino veltman functions ) . considering a passarino veltman function with at least one heavy mass @xmath228 inside loop in the low - energy limit , one can see the following asymptotic behavior : the function splits into 1 ) possible energy - independent divergent part ( including also @xmath229 ) and 2 ) energy - dependent finite part which can be expanded by inverse powers of @xmath53 and vanishes at the small energies . the important property is that the @xmath229-term in the divergent part reproduces the logarithm of the cut - off scale . so , such a potentially large term has to be automatically absorbed by the renormalization at low energies and leads to no observable effects . however , if the renormalization is actually performed at high energies ( as in the @xmath207 renormalization scheme ) the potentially large @xmath229-terms should be re - summed manually by the redefinition of the physical couplings and masses at the scale @xmath53 . what is the form of the rg relations in the limit of large @xmath53 ? the method of constructing the rg equation in the decoupling region was proposed in @xcite . it introduces the redefinition of the parameters of the model allowing to remove all the heavy particle loop contributions to eq . ( [ app11 ] ) . let us define a new set of fields , charges and masses @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 , @xmath233 , @xmath234 , @xmath235 @xmath236 where dots stand for the higher powers of @xmath229 responsible for the decoupling at higher loop orders . the differential operator ( [ app8 ] ) ban be rewritten in terms of these new low - energy parameters : @xmath237 where @xmath238 and @xmath239 functions are obtained from the one - loop relations ( [ app6 ] ) and ( [ app15 ] ) @xmath240 hence , one immediately notices that @xmath238 and @xmath239 functions contain only the light particle loop contributions , and all the heavy particle loop terms are completely removed from them . the @xmath197-matrix element expressed in terms of new parameters satisfies the following rg relation @xmath241 @xmath242 @xmath243 where @xmath244 is the redefined effective four - fermion coupling . as one can see , eq . ( [ app20 ] ) includes all the terms of eq . ( [ app11 ] ) except for the heavy particle loop contributions . it depends on the low energy quantities @xmath230 , @xmath231 , @xmath245 , @xmath246 , @xmath234 , @xmath235 . the first and the second terms in eq . ( [ app20 ] ) are just the one - loop amplitude calculated within the model with no heavy particles . the third and the fourth terms describe the light particle loop correction to the effective four - fermion coupling and the mixing of heavy and light virtual fields . due to the mixing term it is impossible to split the rg relation ( [ app18 ] ) for the @xmath197-matrix element into the one for vertices . hence , we are not able to consider eq . ( [ app18 ] ) in the framework of the scattering of light particles on an external field induced by the heavy virtual scalar . but this is an important step in deriving the rg relation for el parameters . fortunately , there is a simple procedure allowing to avoid the mixing in eq . ( [ app20 ] ) . the way is to incorporate the diagonalization of the leading logarithm terms of the scalar polarization operator into the redefinition of the @xmath247 , @xmath248 , @xmath231 , @xmath232 : @xmath249 \left(\zeta^{-1/2}\right)^\mathrm{t } \left(\begin{array}{c}\tilde{g}_\varphi \\ \tilde{g}_\chi \end{array}\right ) , \\ \nonumber\zeta^{1/2}&= & 1-\frac{\tilde{g}_\varphi\tilde{g}_\chi}{8\pi^2\left(\tilde\lambda^2-\tilde{m}^2\right ) } \log\frac{\kappa^2}{\tilde\lambda^2 } % \nonumber\\&&\times \left(\begin{array}{cc}0 & \tilde\lambda^2 - 6\tilde{m}^2\\-\tilde{m}^2 - 6\tilde{m}^2 & 0\end{array}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the appropriate @xmath238 functions @xmath250 contain no terms connected with mixing between light and heavy scalars . so , the fourth term in eq . ( [ app20 ] ) is removed , and the rg relation for the @xmath197-matrix element becomes at @xmath254 eq . ( [ app23 ] ) is just the rg identity for the scattering amplitude calculated in the absence of the heavy particles . the terms of order @xmath245 describe the rg relation for the effective low - energy four - fermion interaction in the decoupling region . the last one can be reduced in the rg relation for the vertex describing the scattering of the light particle ( fermion ) on the external field @xmath255 substituting the virtual heavy scalar : @xmath256 where @xmath257 eqs . ( [ app23])-([app27 ] ) is the main result of our investigation . one can derive them with only the knowledge about the low - energy couplings of heavy particle ( [ app13 ] ) and the lagrangian of the model with no heavy particles . one also has to ignore all the heavy particle loop contributions to the rg relation and the one - loop mixing between the heavy and the light fields . ( [ app23])-([app27 ] ) depend on the effective low - energy parameters , only . but as the difference between the original set of parameters and the low - energy one is of one - loop order , one may freely substitute them in eqs . ( [ app23])-([app26 ] ) . it is also possible to reduce the rg relation for scattering amplitudes to the one for vertex describing the scattering of light particles on the ` external ' field induced by the heavy virtual particle . in fact , this result is independent on the specific features of the considered model . 99 the lep collaborations aleph , delphi , l3 , opal , and the lep electroweak working group , hep - ex/0612034 . g. abbiendi _ et al . _ [ opal collaboration ] , eur . j. * c33 * ( 2004 ) 173 [ hep - ex/0309053 ] ; eur . j. * c6 * ( 1999 ) 1 ; k. ackerstaff _ et al . _ [ opal collaboration ] , eur . phys . j. * c2 * ( 1998 ) 441 . j. abdallah _ et al . _ [ delphi collaboration ] , eur . phys . j. * c45 * ( 2006 ) 589 [ hep - ex/0512012 ] . a. leike , phys . rep . * 317 * ( 1999 ) 143 . p. langacker , arxiv:0801.1345 [ hep - ph ] . t. rizzo , hep - ph/0610104 . a. ferroglia , a. lorca , and j.j . van der bij , annalen phys * 16 * ( 2007 ) 563 - 578 [ hep - ph/0611174 ] . a. gulov and v. skalozub , eur . j. * c17 * ( 2000 ) 685 . a. gulov and v. skalozub , phys . rev . * d61 * ( 2000 ) 055007 . v. demchik , a. gulov , v. skalozub , and a. tishchenko , phys . * 67 * ( 2004 ) 1312 [ yad . fiz . * 67 * ( 2004 ) 1335 ] . a. gulov and v. skalozub , phys . rev . * d70 * ( 2004 ) 115010 . a. gulov and v. skalozub , phys . * d76 * ( 2007 ) 075008 . j.hewett and t.rizzo , phys . rep . * 183 * ( 1989 ) 193 . m. cvetic and b.w . lynn , phys . rev . * d35 * ( 1987 ) 51 . g. degrassi and a. sirlin , phys . rev . * d40 * ( 1989 ) 3066 . t. appelquist and j. carazzone , phys . rev . * d11 * ( 1975 ) 2856 . j. collins , f. wilczek , and a. zee , phys . rev . * d18 * ( 1978 ) 242 . m. bando , t. kugo , n. maekawa , and h. nakano , progress of theor . * 90 * ( 1993 ) 405 . t. rizzo , phys . * d55 * ( 1997 ) 5483 . r. barate _ [ aleph collaboration ] , eur . j. * c12 * ( 2000 ) 183 [ hep - ex/9904011 ] . m. acciarri _ et al . _ [ l3 collaboration ] , phys . * b479 * ( 2000 ) 101 [ hep - ex/0002034 ] . a. babich , g. della ricca , j. holt , p. osland , a. pankov , and n. paver , eur . j. * c29 * ( 2003 ) 103 . w. eadie , d. dryard , f. james , m. roos , and b. sadoulet , _ statistical methods in experimental physics _ , amsterdam , north - holland , 1971 . aleph collaboration , delphi collaboration , l3 collaboration , opal collaboration , sld collaboration , lep electroweak working group , sld electroweak group , and sld heavy flavour group , phys . * 427 * ( 2006 ) 257 [ hep - ex/0509008 ] . v. abazov _ [ d0 collaboration ] , phys . * b517 * ( 2001 ) 282 . a. buryk and v. skalozub , arxiv:0802.1486 [ hep - ph ] . schwind / mlpfit.html a. gulov and v. skalozub , phys . * 70 * ( 2007 ) 1100 - 1106 [ hep - ph/0510354 ] . m. dittmar , a .- s . nicollerat , and a. djouadi , phys . b583 * ( 2004 ) 111 - 120 [ hep - ph/0307020 ] . c. coriano , a. faraggi , and m. guzzi , phys . * d78 * ( 2008 ) 015012 [ arxiv:0802.1792 ] . f. petriello and s. quackenbush , phys . rev . * d77 * ( 2008 ) 115004 [ arxiv:0801.4389 ] . a. gulov and v. skalozub , phys . atom . nucl . * 63 * ( 2000 ) 139 - 143 [ yad . fiz . * 63 * ( 2000 ) 152 - 157 ] .
Abstract: | [
"an approach to the model - independent searching for the @xmath0 gauge boson as a virtual state in scattering processes is developed . it accounts for as a basic requirement the renormalizability of underlying unspecified in other respects model . this results in a set of relations between low energy couplings of @xmath0 to fermions that reduces in an essential way the number of parameters to be fitted in experiments . on this ground the observables which uniquely pick out the @xmath0 boson in leptonic processes are introduced and the data of lep experiments analyzed . the @xmath0 couplings to leptons and quarks are estimated at 95% confidence level . these estimates may serve as a guide for experiments at the tevatron and/or lhc . a comparison with other approaches and results is given ."
] | 8,682 | 8,682 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: mass gap generation and ( chiral ) symmetry breaking in relativistic fermionic systems can arise from a variety of mechanisms which are often related to certain couplings or interaction channels becoming dominant . an apparent counter - example is catalyzed symmetry breaking , first studied in the context of magnetic catalysis @xcite , where mass gap generation is triggered by the presence of a magnetic field even for arbitrarily small values of the interaction strength . this phenomenon can be understood in various ways , the essence being that the long - range fluctuations driving the symmetry - breaking transitions are parametrically enhanced , see @xcite for a recent review . more concretely , a magnetic field induces a fermionic fluctuation spectrum with landau - levels containing a zero mode that leads to an enhancement of the density of states in the ir and to an effective dimensional reduction favoring symmetry breaking . magnetic catalysis has found a rich variety of applications both in particle physics ( chiral phases of qcd ) @xcite and condensed matter physics @xcite . another simple picture for magnetic catalysis has recently been developed within the framework of the functional renormalization group in the context of the @xmath0 gross - neveu model @xcite . in line with the fact that symmetry - breaking phase transitions are often related to fixed points of renormalization group transformations , also magnetic catalysis can be related to the behavior of rg fixed points as a function of the magnetic field . this rg picture has already successfully been applied in the context of qcd @xcite . in the present work , we verify the underlying rg picture of catalyzed symmetry breaking in the context of curved spacetimes . the fact that symmetry breaking and mass generation in fermionic systems can be influenced by negative curvature of the spacetime has been realized early @xcite , and is meanwhile reviewed in textbooks @xcite . the phenomenon is typically studied at mean - field level and occurs in many different fermionic models @xcite . in @xcite , the similarity to magnetic catalysis was realized in terms of an effective dimensional reduction mechanism of the spectral properties of the dirac operator . this justifies the use of the terminology `` gravitational catalysis '' @xcite . in fact , we find in the present work that the effective dimensional reduction and the corresponding enhancement of the density of states in the ir is directly related to the fixed point structure as identified below . from this rg viewpoint , symmetry breaking arises as a consequence of the fact that the coupling value required for criticality becomes arbitrarily small as a function of the curvature ( the catalyzer ) . hence , any finite value of the fermionic interactions ultimately becomes supercritical , typically driving the system towards the ordered phase . we investigate this rg mechanism within the simple @xmath0 gross - neveu model in the present work . we concentrate on two different curved backgrounds with constant negative curvature : a maximally symmetric spacetime ( anti de sitter ) and a purely spatially curved case ( lobachevsky plane ) . for both cases , mean - field studies are already available , see @xcite and @xcite , respectively . whereas the former allows for an analytic treatment in terms of simple functions , the latter is potentially relevant for curved layered condensed matter systems . for instance , the exitonic or anti - ferromagnetic instabilities in graphite and graphene have been associated with quantum phase transitions falling into the @xmath0 gross - neveu universality class @xcite . as catalyzed symmetry breaking is manifestly driven by the long - range modes , the rg analysis allows us to estimate the required curvature in relation to the length scale of the sample . this paper is organized as follows : in sect . [ sec : gnmodel ] , we briefly introduce the model and its formulation in curved space . section [ sec : frg ] is devoted to an evaluation of the rg flow in its simplest formulation . the manifestation of gravitational catalysis is discussed in sect . [ sec : gc ] . we estimate the influence of finite probe length on gravitational catalysis in sect . [ sec : pseudo ] by means of a pseudo - critical coupling . conclusions are drawn in sect . [ sec : conc ] . relevant technical details are deferred to the appendices . we aim at investigating the @xmath0 gross - neveu model @xcite in curved spacetime with metric @xmath1 ( greek indices running from @xmath2 to @xmath3 ) and signature @xmath4 using functional rg methods . the microscopic action functional @xmath5 at some ultraviolet ( uv ) scale @xmath6 depends on the bare coupling constant @xmath7 , the @xmath8 grassmann - valued fields @xmath9 and the @xmath8 conjugated fields @xmath10 , @xmath11 = { } & \!\ ! { \int \!\!\ ! { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ \text{\small{\ensuremath{x } } } } } } } } \ ! \left [ \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{{n } } \bar{\psi}^{i } \slashed{\nabla } \psi^{i } + \frac{\bar{\lambda}_{\lambda}}{2 { n } } \left ( \sum\limits_{i = 1}^{{n } } \bar{\psi}^{i } \psi^{i } \right)^{\!\!\!2 } \right ] \notag \\ = { } & \!\ ! { \int \!\!\ ! { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ \text{\small{\ensuremath{x } } } } } } } } \left [ \bar{\psi } \slashed{\nabla } \psi + \frac{\bar{\lambda}_{\lambda}}{2 { n } } ( \bar{\psi } \psi ) ^2 \right ] \ ! \text { , } \label{eq : gnaction}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath12 is a shorthand for the integral over the @xmath13-dimensional spacetime and @xmath14 is the determinant of the spacetime metric . the differential operator @xmath15 is composed from a set of @xmath16-dimensional gamma matrices satisfying the clifford algebra @xmath17 where @xmath18 is the identity in spinor space . in the present work , we use the irreducible representation , such that @xmath19 specifies the dimension of the @xmath20 matrices as well as the number of dirac components of the fermions . for our computations with fermions in curved space , we have actually used the weldon formalism @xcite which can be viewed as a generalization of the conventional vierbein formalism . however , a mapping to standard vierbein formulas is straightforward . the covariant derivative in the weldon formalism reads @xmath21 accounting for covariance with respect to the spinor and spacetime structure . here , @xmath22 is the affine spin connection , implicitly defined by @xmath23,\\ { \ensuremath{(\mathrm{ii})}}\quad { } & 0 = { \operatorname{tr}}\gamma_{\mu } \text { , } \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath24 the christoffel symbols . can additionally accommodate a @xmath25 gauge field @xmath26 @xcite . in this case , the right - hand side of @xmath27 in ( [ eq : defspincon ] ) would be given by @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the charge under the @xmath25 gauge group . in the present work , we ignore such a @xmath25 gauge sector , setting @xmath30 . ] in the present work , we are interested in a discrete `` chiral '' @xmath31 symmetry , where the nontrivial transformation is defined by @xcite @xmath32 this symmetry acts simultaneously on all flavors . it can spontaneously be broken by a chiral condensate @xmath33 , which for finite interactions goes along with a mass gap generation . incidentally , the @xmath0 gross - neveu model actually has a much larger continuous u(@xmath8 ) flavor symmetry also allowing for more complicated breaking patterns @xcite . condensed matter systems where the gross - neveu model is considered as an effective theory , the low - energy degrees of freedom can be arranged into @xmath34 4-component dirac spinors , corresponding to a reducible representation of the dirac algebra . this reducible representation can be constructed from a suitable combination of 2-component spinors such that @xmath35 in terms of the counting of fermions of the present work , see , e.g. , @xcite for a review . note that the gross - neveu interaction term considered in this work @xmath36 corresponds to @xmath37 in the reducible 4-component notation of @xcite ( or to @xmath38 in the notation of @xcite ) for even @xmath8 . the critical properties of the discrete chiral transition are , however , identical to a 4-component gross - neveu model with a @xmath39 interaction as considered in @xcite . ] in the following , we use the functional renormalization group to compute the rg flow of the gross - neveu coupling as a function of the ( negative ) curvature . we employ the wetterich equation @xcite , describing the flow of a scale - dependent effective action functional @xmath40 as a function of an ir regulator scale @xmath41 , @xmath42 = \frac{{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}}}{2 } { \operatorname{str}}\left [ \left ( \gamma_{k}^{\ensuremath{\text{\tiny{$(2)$ } } } } + r_{k } \right)^{-1 } \partial_{k } r_{k } \right ] \ ! \text{. } \label{eq : wetteq}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the effective average action @xmath40 is related to the standard generating functional for 1pi correlation functions in the limit @xmath43 . towards the uv cutoff @xmath44 , @xmath40 approaches the microscopic action . the regularization is encoded in the regulator function @xmath45 , see below . for reviews of the functional rg adapted to the present context , see refs . @xcite . in the present work , we evaluate the flow within a rather simple approximation for the effective action . for this , we truncate the effective action to @xmath46 = { \int \!\!\ ! { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ \text{\small{\ensuremath{x } } } } } } } } \left [ \bar{\psi } \slashed{\nabla } \psi + \frac{\bar{\lambda}_{k}}{2 { n } } ( \bar{\psi } \psi ) ^2 \right]\text{,}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the only scale dependence lies in the four fermion coupling @xmath47 . furthermore , @xmath48 parametrically depends on the curvature of the background manifold . the ir regularization is ensured by a chirally symmetric regulator of the form @xmath49 where the superscript @xmath50 denotes transposition in dirac space , and @xmath51 represents a spin - valued delta distribution , keeping track of the spinor or conjugate - spinor transformation properties associated with the spacetime arguments . in app . [ app : beta_function ] , we briefly summarize our conventions . for practical computations , we use a callan - symanzik type regulator , that facilitates the use of proper time representations , @xmath52 within our investigations we restrict ourselves to negative curvature , giving rise to gravitational catalysis . it is intuitively clear , that positive curvature ( e.g. , a sphere ) generically suppresses ir modes and thus reduces the density of states of low lying modes @xcite . we also consider the system mainly in the large-@xmath8 limit . at finite @xmath8 , further pointlike fermionic self - interactions are generated which correspond to operators with an explicit curvature dependence . we expect no qualitative modifications from these operators and hence ignore them in the following . this approximation becomes exact in the limit @xmath53 . it is straightforward ( cf . [ app : beta_function ] ) to calculate the flow of the coupling as an implicit functional of the choice of the manifold , which enters via the spectrum of the dirac operator @xmath54 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] for this calculation , it suffices to project the flow onto constant fields @xmath55 , with @xmath56 . here , @xmath57 denotes the spacetime volume . the operator occurring in the trace is related to the square of the regularized fermionic green s function in curved spacetime . this has a direct correspondence to a feynman diagram representation , see fig . [ fig : feynman_graph ] , as the flow in the present simple truncation is driven by a single fermion bubble ( and rg - improved resummations thereof ) . in the following we distinguish between the cases of a maximally symmetric spacetime in sect . [ sec : maximally_symmetric ] which can be treated fully analytically , and a negatively curved space in sect . [ sec : flat_time ] , which is a more interesting case in view of two - dimensional condensed matter systems . the use of a callan - symanzik regulator shape function , cf . ( [ eq : csregulator ] ) , facilitates to rewrite the right - hand side of eq . ( [ eq : betafunction1 ] ) in terms of a simple proper time representation . other shape functions would still permit to use a proper time representation but would lead to more intricate @xmath41 dependencies . the laplace transform of the operator of ( [ eq : betafunction1 ] ) reads @xmath58 which upon insertion into ( [ eq : betafunction1 ] ) yields @xmath59 \text{. } \label{eq : lambdabar}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression inside the super trace is known as the heat kernel @xmath60 of the ( squared ) dirac operator . it satisfies @xmath61 and was calculated in @xcite for any maximally symmetric space , with euclidean signature . for our case the solution to this equation can be obtained in an easier way with a special ansatz ( cf . [ app : heat_kernel ] ) : @xmath62 where @xmath63 , and @xmath64 is the geodesic distance between the points @xmath65 and @xmath66 . the parallel transporter @xmath67 ( wegner - wilson line ) is defined by @xmath68 where @xmath69 denotes the path ordering prescription and @xmath70 is the geodesic between @xmath65 and @xmath66 with @xmath71 and @xmath72 . now we are able to calculate the supertrace as @xmath73 \ ! = - \frac{2 \omega { n}}{(4 \pi)^{\frac{3}{2 } } \sqrt{s } } \ ! \left ( \frac{1}{s } + { { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}}\frac{{\ensuremath{\left\vertr\right\vert}}}{12 } \right ) \ ! { \mathrm{e}}^{- { { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}}\frac{\pi}{4 } } \text{,}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and finally get @xmath74 in terms of the dimensionless coupling , @xmath75 we obtain the beta function @xmath76 @xmath77 this is an ordinary differential equation that parametrically depends on the curvature . it can be solved by straightforward integration : @xmath78 the initial value is given by the dimensionless coupling @xmath79 which in terms of the initial bare gross - neveu coupling reads @xmath80 . for the case of a manifold where the spatial part has a constant negative curvature , we choose a special set of coordinates such that the metric can be expressed as @xmath81 where @xmath82 ( latin indices running from @xmath83 to @xmath3 ) represents the metric of a two dimensional maximally symmetric space and therefore only depends on the spatial coordinates . hence the gamma matrices are time independent as well . the christoffel symbols vanish for every time component @xmath84 and also the curvature tensor vanishes if any index is zero @xmath85 . from eq . ( [ eq : defspincon ] ) @xmath86 , we infer that the spin connection @xmath87 has to be proportional to @xmath18 , @xmath88.\end{aligned}\ ] ] moreover , from eq . @xmath27 , we conclude that @xmath87 even has to vanish completely , @xmath89 this implies that the operator @xmath90 is separable into @xmath91 where the curvature is only induced by the spatial components . for a simpler calculation of the beta function , we perform a wick rotation @xmath92 and perform again a laplace transformation of the operator occurring in eq . ( [ eq : betafunction1 ] ) , @xmath93 we arrive at the euclidean analogue of eq . @xmath94 \text{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , we calculate the super trace again with the aid of the heat kernel using that the differential operator @xmath90 is separable and the delta distribution factorizes in a time like and a spatial part @xmath95 where @xmath96 . the quantity @xmath97 denotes the spatial coordinates of @xmath65 and should be treated as a set of coordinates and not as a vector . both factors satisfy a heat - kernel equation and can be solved analytically , cf . @xcite , @xmath98 where @xmath99 , @xmath100 is the parallel transporter for the spatial part and @xmath101 is the nonnegative spatial geodesic distance between @xmath97 and @xmath102 with @xmath103 . plugging these relations into eq . ( [ eq : betafunction2 ] ) gives @xmath104 the @xmath105 integral is an integral representation of the modified bessel function of the second kind @xmath106 @xcite . therefore , we have @xmath107 with these results we are again able to derive the beta function for the dimensionless coupling @xmath108 , @xmath109 the integration of this ordinary differential equation depending parametrically on the curvature can be cast into an integral representation , @xmath110 this result is qualitatively similar to the maximally symmetric case of eq . . let us now analyze the consequences of the rg flows for the long - range properties of the gross - neveu model . for both background manifolds , @xmath76 considered as a function of @xmath111 is a parabola where the prefactor of the quadratic part is scale and curvature dependent , see fig . [ fig : betafunction ] . for vanishing curvature , the @xmath76 function vanishes at the two fixed points @xmath112 ( gauian ) and @xmath113 which corresponds to the well - known critical coupling of the gross - neveu model in flat space in this regularization scheme @xcite . this critical coupling separates the symmetric phase for @xmath114 where the long range behavior is controlled by the non - interacting gauian fixed point from the chiral symmetry broken phase for @xmath115 . in the latter case , @xmath111 runs to large values towards the infrared . in the present simple truncation , @xmath111 in fact diverges at a finite scale @xmath116 signaling the transition into the ordered regime . the scale @xmath116 is thus characteristic for the physical scales in the ordered phase . in @xcite it has been shown that @xmath116 actually agrees with the value of the dynamically generated fermion mass @xmath117 as obtained in mean - field approximation . since we are working in the large-@xmath8 limit anyway , we will use this mean - field identification in the following : @xmath118 . the existence of the non - gauian fixed point @xmath119 can be attributed to the competition between the power - counting scaling ( the linear coupling term in @xmath76 ) and the interaction terms @xmath120 . in our rg picture , the interaction terms are enhanced by negative curvature as soon as the wavelength of the fluctuations becomes of the order of the curvature scale . as a consequence , the interacting second zero of the @xmath121 function no longer is a true fixed point but becomes scale dependent . this `` pseudo - critical coupling '' @xmath122 moves towards the gauian fixed point for decreasing scale @xmath41 , see fig . [ fig : betafunction ] . any finite initial coupling strength @xmath79 will eventually become larger than @xmath123 for small rg scales @xmath124 . by this mechanism , the system is forced into the symmetry - broken phase even at the weakest initial coupling . we observe this mechanism in both cases of negative curvature , the maximally symmetric as well as the purely spatial curvature case . function of the coupling @xmath125 for different values of the scale dependent negative curvature @xmath126 ( from top to bottom : @xmath127 ) . the black lines depict the @xmath76 functions for the maximally symmetric spacetime ( ads ) , cf . eq . ( [ eq : betafunction_maximally_symmetric ] ) ; arrows indicate the flow towards the ir . the green dotted graphs show the flows for the case of purely spatial curvature ( lobachevsky plane ) , cf . ( [ eq : betafunction_flat_time ] ) . in addition to the gauian fixed point , there exists a non gauian fixed point ( full red circle at @xmath128 for the present regulator scheme ) , separating the symmetric phase for @xmath129 from the broken phase for @xmath130 for zero curvature . for finite curvature , this critical point becomes scale - dependent and moves towards the gauian fixed point for increasing scale dependent curvature , i.e. , with decreasing ir scale for fixed curvature . in the case of vanishing curvature , the symmetry is preserved and no mass is generated for initial values @xmath131 in the blue dashed region.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] as we see in fig . [ fig : betafunction ] the influence of the curvature is somewhat stronger in the maximally symmetric case . as discussed above , we calculate the symmetry breaking scale @xmath116 by searching for a zero of the inverse coupling . the fermion mass @xmath117 corresponding to this scale where the rg flow enters the symmetry - broken regime can thus be computed from the criterion @xmath132 upon partial bosonization ( hubbard - stratonovich transformation ) , @xmath133 is related to the mass parameter of a composite bosonic field . hence the divergence of the fermionic self - interaction simply corresponds to onset of the order parameter @xcite . let us now analyze the two different backgrounds under consideration in detail . in the maximally symmetric case , the fermion mass defined by the criterion eq . can be straightforwardly computed from the running coupling eq . , yielding @xmath134 plots of this gravitationally catalyzed fermion mass are shown as a function of the curvature as solid lines in fig . [ fig : comparison_generated_mass ] . let us discuss this result in various limits . in the zero - curvature limit @xmath135 , we find @xmath136 for @xmath137 . for super - critical couplings @xmath138 , we rediscover the standard mean - field result in @xmath0 , @xmath139 this is in perfect agreement with the known behavior in flat spacetime . provided the fermion system is initially weakly coupled , @xmath140 , a leading order expansion can be performed for any value of the curvature , resulting in @xmath141 } |r| \bar{\lambda}_\lambda } } , \quad \text{for}\,\ , \bar{\lambda}_\lambda \lambda \ll 1,\ ] ] where we have reinserted the dimensionful initial coupling @xmath142 . if we additionally consider the limit of small curvature , we find a linear dependence of the fermion mass on both the curvature as well as the coupling , @xmath143 by contrast , in the limit of large curvature , @xmath144 , we find that @xmath145 . in other words , large curvature induces immediate chiral symmetry breaking , such that the induced mass becomes of the order of the cutoff . incidentally , this result is similar for the large - coupling limit : for @xmath146 , we again find that @xmath147 to leading order independently of the curvature . the above results display explicit uv cutoff and regularization - scheme dependencies . since the @xmath0 gross - neveu model is asymptotically safe and thus non - perturbatively renormalizable @xcite , we can remove the uv cutoff by keeping an ir obvservable fixed while sending @xmath148 . this `` line of constant physics '' defines a renormalized trajectory . this can most conveniently be done in the super - critical regime where @xmath149 such that the fermion mass in flat - space @xmath150 of eq . defines a natural ir renormalization point . at a suitable renormalization point @xmath151 to a specific value . ] in this case , the generated fermion mass in the limit @xmath152 can be written as @xmath153 where the first line holds for arbitrary curvature , and the second line represents a weak - curvature expansion being in perfect agreement with @xcite . we emphasize that the fermions acquire a mass @xmath154 for any given @xmath79 as long as the curvature is nonvanishing . while we expect the tendency to drive the fermion system towards the broken phase through gravitational catalysis to remain also beyond our truncation , fluctuations of bosonic composites entering beyond the large-@xmath8 limit typically provide for an opposite tendency . hence , the status of gravitational catalysis beyond mean - field remains an interesting question . analogously , the effects of beyond - mean - field fluctuations on magnetic catalysis are under active current investigation @xcite . in the case of pure spatial curvature , the criterion eq . can not be resolved analytically , but we can give an implicit equation for the induced fermion mass @xmath117 @xmath155 which can be solved numerically . though the basic picture does not differ much from the maximally symmetric case , there are some interesting differences . as can already be inferred from the beta function in fig . [ fig : betafunction ] ( dotted lines ) , the curvature induced mass in the spatially curved case is smaller than in the maximally symmetric case , cf . fig . [ fig : comparison_generated_mass ] . from top to bottom ( @xmath128 ) . as long as the background manifold is negatively curved , @xmath156 , a finite fermion mass is generated.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=48.0% ] several limits can be discussed in an analytic fashion , using the series representation of @xmath157 developed in app . [ app : curvature_expansion ] . furthermore , we need the integral @xmath158 defined by @xmath159 where @xmath27 fixes the constant of integration . the explicit calculation is done in app . [ app : curvature_expansion ] . the defining equation for the fermion mass in terms of @xmath160 is @xmath161 this representation provides us with some interesting insight . first , we can show that there exists a unique solution to this equation with @xmath162 for any given negative curvature @xmath163 and @xmath164 . this can be seen in two steps . the uniqueness is because the function @xmath165 for @xmath166 is bijective . this property holds , because @xmath157 is positive and therefore @xmath160 is strictly monotonically increasing . owing to @xmath167 for small @xmath168 and @xmath169 for large @xmath170 , the function @xmath160 is not bounded . since by assumption @xmath171 , it follows from eq . that @xmath172 has to hold , which implies that @xmath173 because of the monotonic behavior this demonstrates that @xmath174 as claimed above . let us first check the flat spacetime limit @xmath175 . in complete agreement with eq . , we find again that @xmath176 = 1 - \frac{m_{\text{f},0}}{\lambda},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have used eq . . in the weak coupling regime , we expect the fermion mass to be small compared to the curvature scale , cf . . hence , we need @xmath158 for large argument as provided by eq . , @xmath177 using this asymptotic behavior for @xmath178 , we infer from eq . that @xmath179 , \,\ , \alpha_\lambda= \sqrt{\frac{|r|}{2\lambda^2}}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] if in addition , the curvature is small , i.e. , @xmath180 , we can use the corresponding expansion of eq . and replace @xmath181 . taking differences arising from the dirac representation into account , the exponential inverse - coupling dependence is in perfect agreement with the results of @xcite . despite the overall similarities to the maximally symmetric case , we observe that the weak - coupling and weak - curvature limit of the case with pure spatial curvature shows some distinct differences . in particular , there is an exponential non - analytic dependence of the fermion mass on the coupling as well as on the curvature . this difference is reminiscent to magnetic catalysis in @xmath182 and @xmath183 @xcite , where the fermion gap is analytic in @xmath182 , but shows an essential singularity in the coupling in @xmath183 . also in the present case , such a singularity shows up similar to bcs gap formation , as a consequence of the effective dimensional reduction of the fermionic fluctuation spectrum to @xmath184 @xcite . also in this respect , our functional rg picture is in perfect agreement with previous studies @xcite . at zero curvature , the @xmath0 gross - neveu model exhibits a critical coupling strength corresponding to a quantum critical point above which chiral symmetry is broken at large length scales . this critical coupling manifests itself as a non - gauian fixed point of the rg flow . in the present regularization scheme , we identified @xmath185 , or @xmath128 in dimensionless conventions . as illustrated in fig . [ fig : betafunction ] , the fixed point strictly speaking no longer exists at finite negative curvature . the nontrivial zero of the @xmath121 function becomes scale dependent and eventually merges with the gauian fixed point in the deep ir for @xmath186 , such that only the chirally broken branch of the @xmath121 function remains . let us call the nontrivial zero of @xmath121 a pseudo - critical coupling @xmath187 . we find @xmath188 for the maximally symmetric case , cf . . , and @xmath189^{a } } \right . \!\ ! \sqrt{\frac{|r|}{2k^2 } } \left . \vphantom{\left[\frac{a}{b}\right]^{a } } \right ) } \label{eq : lpsc}\ ] ] for the spatially curved case , cf . . since @xmath190 is a monotonically decreasing function of scale @xmath41 , the coupling @xmath125 can eventually exceed @xmath187 such that the system becomes critical and runs towards the ordered phase . in this sense , @xmath191 can be viewed as a criticality condition @xcite , defining a scale @xmath192 , where the system becomes critical . for lower scale , the system is driven towards the symmetry broken regime which is ultimately entered at @xmath193 defined above . the value of @xmath192 depends on the curvature as well as the initial coupling @xmath79 ( the latter is considered as initially subcritical here and in the following ) . the preceding discussion implicitly assumed that @xmath41 can run over all scales down to @xmath194 , such that the criticality condition can eventually always be satisfied . however , if , for instance , the system has a finite volume characterized by a finite length scale @xmath195 , also the fluctuation momenta are restricted , typically leading to an ir cutoff @xmath196 . one may think of a finite probe length , such as , e.g. , the size of a layer of graphene . this finite probe length @xmath195 can lead to a screening of the gravitationally catalyzed ordered regime if @xmath197 is larger than the would - be critical scale @xmath192 . hence , @xmath198 can be viewed as a lower bound for the coupling strength required for symmetry breaking in a real system of finite length . it thus generalizes the critical coupling at infinite volume and zero curvature to the situation of finite volume and finite curvature . it is instructive to study @xmath187 as a function of the length scale @xmath195 measured in units of a typical curvature length scale which we define by @xmath199 . for finite systems , this gives an estimate for how strongly a probe has to be curved in order to exhibit gravitational catalysis . in turn , for a given curvature of the probe , @xmath187 provides an estimate for the initial coupling strength required for symmetry breaking in the finite system . for instance , for the maximally symmetric case , we read off from eq . that @xmath200 for the spatially curved case , we incidentally find the same result in the limit of small curvature , i.e. , @xmath201 , using the expansion which is accurate even for values of @xmath202 . by contrast , the large curvature limit for the spatially curved case is different , cf . : @xmath203 from eq . , it is obvious that probe length to curvature ratios up to @xmath204 lead to pseudo - critical couplings @xmath187 which deviate from the zero - curvature critical coupling of the gross - neveu model only below the 1% level . significant deviations only occur for @xmath195 being an order of magnitude larger than the curvature scale @xmath205 . from the viewpoint of curvature - deformed condensed matter systems , a ratio of @xmath204 appears to be `` large '' in the sense that loosely speaking a spatially curved @xmath206 planar probe embedded in @xmath0 euclidean space would rather look like a @xmath0 object . another way to interpret these results is the following : consider a finite - probe system with a subcritical bare coupling , @xmath207 , thus being in the symmetric ( e.g. semimetal ) phase . in order to gravitationally catalyze a transition to a broken ( gapped or insulating ) phase , the criticality condition has to be met for a sufficiently large @xmath208 . in view of eq . this requires comparatively strong curvature , i.e. , a small curvature length scale @xmath205 compared with the probe length @xmath195 . we have investigated the phenomenon of gravitational catalysis in the @xmath0 gross - neveu model on specific manifolds with constant negative curvature . while the mechanism had already been studied frequently with mean - field methods as well as from the viewpoint of the fluctuation spectrum of the dirac operator , we have added a new renormalization group picture to the comprehensive understanding of this phenomenon . the essence of this picture is that the critical coupling of the fermionic system , corresponding to a quantum phase transition in flat spacetime , is transmuted into a scale - dependent pseudo - critical coupling that flows to zero as a consequence of long - wavelength fluctuations ( compared to the curvature scale ) . in this manner , the infinite - volume fermion system becomes critical for any arbitrarily weak coupling . we have identified the rg ( pseudo- ) fixed point mechanism for two example manifolds of constant negative curvature : a maximally symmetric spacetime ( anti de sitter ) and a purely spatially curved case ( lobachevsky plane ) . both manifolds support the mechanism of gravitational catalysis , but exhibit a rather different behavior as far as the dependence of chiral symmetry breaking on the coupling and the curvature are concerned . the maximally symmetric case shows a linear dependence ( to leading order ) on both quantities which makes clear that the phenomenon is essentially perturbative , being reminiscent of the `` quantum anomaly '' for fermions in a magnetic field @xcite . by contrast , order parameters indicating the symmetry broken state such as the induced fermion mass exhibit an essential singularity in both the coupling and the curvature for the case of the purely spatially curved case . this is in many respects similar to bcs - type gap formation . again , our renormalization group picture goes hand in hand here with properties of the fermionic fluctuation spectrum , as analyzed in @xcite . as a benefit , the functional renormalization group also gives a simple access to systems of finite extent by identifying the rg infrared cutoff with an inverse length scale . in this manner , we can estimate the fate of gravitational catalysis in finite systems . in fact , the phenomenon only occurs , as long as the curvature radius is sufficiently small compared to the systems length scale . we have been able to phrase this statement quantitatively by introducing a pseudo - critical coupling . thinking in terms of curved layered condensed matter systems , rather large curvatures are needed compared to a realizable probe length in order to drive a sub - critical system into a phase dominated by gravitational catalysis . we would like to emphasize that an immediate application of our results to condensed matter systems would only be possible for reparametrization invariant systems such as fluid membranes @xcite , curvature effects of which can be mapped onto the language of riemannian geometry . for tethered membranes or general lattice systems , further phenomena connected to extrinsic curvature or curvature related defects can be become relevant . in this context , it is interesting to note that an external strain exerted on a graphene sheet in flat space induces a pseudo - magnetic field @xcite , that may also support ( pseudo-)magnetic catalysis . for such systems , we hence expect an interesting interplay between these various effects if we expose them to negative curvature inducing strain . finally , gravitational catalysis may become relevant in the context of asymptotically safe quantum gravity @xcite . in conjunction with fermionic degrees of freedom @xcite , the uv fixed point determining the shape of the universe at highest energies might go along with a negative ( though scale - dependent ) curvature @xcite . whether or not gravitational catalysis in connection with gravitionally modified critical fermion interactions @xcite could become active and impose constraints on the matter content of the universe then is a highly involved question that deserves to be investigated in greater depth . the authors thank astrid eichhorn , lukas janssen , daniel scherer , ren sondenheimer , and andreas wipf for valuable discussions and acknowledge support by the dfg under grants gi 328/5 - 2 ( heisenberg program ) , grk1523 and for 723 . let us first introduce our conventions . in the weldon formalism @xcite , the dirac conjugate spinor @xmath209 is related to the hermitean conjugate of the spinor @xmath210 via the spin metric @xmath211 @xmath212 which is implicitly defined by @xmath213 this gives rise to the following properties of the building blocks of the gross - neveu action : @xmath214 choosing the spin metric @xmath211 to be anti - hermitean in eq . ( i ) is convenient for our metric and clifford algebra conventions , but differs from @xcite . also , the absence of any imaginary factor of `` @xmath215 '' in the fermion kinetic term is due to these conventions . the flow equation uses a rather condensed notation . more concretely , we work in field space parameterized by the collective fields @xmath216 representing grassmann - valued functions on the manifold , reminiscent to nambu - gorkov spinors . for instance , the classical action amended by the regulator term which is used for deriving the flow equation from the functional integral ( cf . @xcite ) , reads in these conventions @xmath217 = { } & s[\phi ] + \frac{1}{2 } { \int \!\!\ ! { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ \text{\small{\ensuremath{x } } } } } } } } \!\!\ ! { \int \!\!\ ! { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ { { } _ \text{\small{\ensuremath{y } } } } } } } } \bar{\phi}(x ) r_{k}(x , y ) \phi(y).\end{aligned}\ ] ] these conventions differ slightly from those commonly used , see , e.g. , @xcite , but turn out to be advantageous for coordinate space computations on curved manifolds . for instance , the representation of the unit element in field space becomes rather intuitive , @xmath218 by @xmath51 , we denote the spin - valued delta distribution , which fulfills @xmath219 therefore , @xmath220 has to hold . with this notation , we indicate that @xmath51 transforms as a spinor in @xmath65 and a dirac - conjugated spinor in @xmath66 , i.e. @xmath51 can be interpreted as @xmath221 , with the standard scalar delta distribution @xmath222 . we remark that there is a difference between @xmath51 and @xmath223 in the spinor structure , since @xmath224 for the evaluation of the flow equation eq . , we proceed in a standard fashion . we decompose @xmath225 into a field - dependent part @xmath226 and a field - independent part @xmath227 in order to expand the wetterich equation in powers of the fields , @xmath228 \text{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath229 & \psi \psi^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{t } } } } \\ \bar{\psi}^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{t } } } } \bar{\psi } & { } \!\!\ ! [ ( \bar{\psi } \psi ) { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}+ \psi \bar{\psi}]^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{t } } } } \ ! { } \end{pmatrix } \ ! \mathbb{1},\\ { \ensuremath{\mathcal{p}}}_{k } = { } & { { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}}k \ ! \begin{pmatrix } \sqrt{\tau}\big ( { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}+ r(\tau ) \big ) & 0 \\ 0 & \sqrt{\tau^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{t } } } } } \big ( { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}+ r(\tau^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{t } } } } ) \big ) \end{pmatrix } \ ! \mathbb{1},\end{aligned}\ ] ] we observe that only the term @xmath230 in eq . can contribute to the flow of @xmath47 . we need @xmath231 with @xmath232 , and therefore only the diagonal of @xmath233 is required . in the limit @xmath234 , only the following terms remain : @xmath235_{11}(x , y ) = - \frac{\frac{\bar{\lambda}_{k}^2}{{n}^{2 } k^{2 } } ( \bar{\psi } \psi)^2}{\tau \big ( { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}+ r(\tau ) \big)^{2 } } \ , \frac{\delta(x , y)}{\sqrt{-g}},\\ & \left[({\ensuremath{\mathcal{p}}}_{k}^{-1 } { \ensuremath{\mathcal{f}}}_{k})^2\right]_{22}(x , y ) = \ ! \left[({\ensuremath{\mathcal{p}}}_{k}^{-1 } { \ensuremath{\mathcal{f}}}_{k})^2\right]^{{\ensuremath{\mathrm{t}}}}_{11}(y , x)\text{. } \ ] ] the lhs of eq . boils down to @xmath236 and the rhs yields @xmath237 \notag \\ & { } = { { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}}\frac{2 \bar{\lambda}_{k}^2}{{n}^2 k^3 } ( \bar{\psi } \psi)^2 { \operatorname{str}}\ ! \left [ \frac { r'(\tau ) } { \big ( { \ensuremath{\mathrm{i}}}+ r(\tau ) \big)^{3 } } \frac{\delta(x , y)}{\sqrt{-g } } \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] inserting the callan - symanzik regulator , we end up with eq . of the main text . following @xcite , we choose for the heat kernel satisfying eq . the ansatz @xmath238 where @xmath239 is a scalar function of @xmath240 the geodesic distance and the proper time @xmath105 . plugging this into equation ( [ eq : heatkernel ] ) using @xmath241 , @xmath242 and @xmath243 n^{\nu } u \text { , } \end{aligned}\end{aligned}\ ] ] cf . @xcite , we get @xmath244 with @xmath245 , @xmath246 . because of the boundary condition for @xmath247 and the regularity of @xmath248 we observe that @xmath249 has to hold , with @xmath222 representing the standard delta distribution . one suitable representation for the delta distribution in 3@xmath13 maximally symmetric space with negative curvature in the limit @xmath250 is @xmath251 next , we factorize @xmath239 into the delta part and an auxiliary function @xmath252 of @xmath240 and @xmath105 , @xmath253 expanding @xmath252 in powers of @xmath254 and using the boundary conditions , @xmath255 leads to @xmath256 with the boundary condition @xmath257 . from equation @xmath86 and the boundary condition , we see @xmath258 plugging this into @xmath27 gives @xmath259 where we have eliminated the constant of integration using equation @xmath260 . from this , we finally get @xmath261 for the detailed analysis of the spatially curved case , the integral representation of the running coupling eq . can be studied in various limits analytically . more specifically , @xmath157 as defined in eq . can be expanded for small and for large values of @xmath262 . let us first consider an expansion of this function about @xmath263 , starting with an expansion of the integrand , @xmath264 using the standard integral @xmath265 the small @xmath262 expansion of @xmath157 can be computed to any order . to order @xmath266 , we find @xmath267 due to the factorial growth of the coefficients , cf . eq . ( [ eq : bessel_integral ] ) , the expansion is an asymptotic series . by comparison with the numerical result , the accuracy of eq . ( [ eq : mfri_small_alpha ] ) turns out to be above 99% up to @xmath268 . a similar approximation can be done for large @xmath262 by expanding @xmath269 which holds for any @xmath270 . next , we employ @xmath271 which can be used for @xmath272 . for @xmath273 , an analytic continuation into the complex is implicitly understood , leading to a replacement of the term @xmath274 by @xmath275 \big ( 1 - ( n \alpha)^2 \big)^{-3/2}$ ] here and in the following . this leads to the convergent series @xmath276\end{aligned}\ ] ] for any @xmath277 . neglecting orders higher than @xmath278 and using @xmath279 for @xmath280 , we arrive at @xmath281 where @xmath282 is the euler - mascheroni constant and @xmath283 is the glaisher - kinkelin constant . the accuracy of this result is above 99% for @xmath284 . with the series ( [ eq : mfri_sum_rep ] ) it is possible to find a series representation for the required integral ( [ eq : def_mfrf ] ) @xmath285 \ ! \text{.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this series is convergent for any @xmath286 . the expansions for small and large @xmath262 are @xmath287 where @xmath288 is defined as the limit @xmath289 v. p. gusynin , v. a. miransky and i. a. shovkovy , phys . d * 52 * , 4718 ( 1995 ) [ hep - th/9407168 ] . v. p. gusynin , v. a. miransky and i. a. shovkovy , phys . b * 349 * , 477 ( 1995 ) [ hep - ph/9412257 ] . v. p. gusynin , v. a. miransky and i. a. shovkovy , nucl . b * 462 * , 249 ( 1996 ) [ hep - ph/9509320 ] . i. a. shovkovy , arxiv:1207.5081 [ hep - ph ] . i. a. shushpanov and a. v. smilga , phys . b * 402 * , 351 ( 1997 ) [ hep - ph/9703201 ] . t. d. cohen , d. a. mcgady and e. s. werbos , phys . c * 76 * , 055201 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv:0706.3208 [ hep - ph ] ] . a. v. zayakin , jhep * 0807 * , 116 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0807.2917 [ hep - th ] ] . a. j. mizher , m. n. chernodub and e. s. fraga , phys . d * 82 * , 105016 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1004.2712 [ hep - ph ] ] . r. gatto and m. ruggieri , phys . d * 82 * , 054027 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1007.0790 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. k. boomsma and d. boer , phys . d * 81 * , 074005 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0911.2164 [ hep - ph ] ] . g. s. bali , f. bruckmann , g. endrodi , z. fodor , s. d. katz and a. schafer , phys . d * 86 * , 071502 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1206.4205 [ hep - lat ] ] . g. w. semenoff , i. a. shovkovy and l. c. r. wijewardhana , mod . lett . a * 13 * , 1143 ( 1998 ) [ hep - ph/9803371 ] . k. krishana , n. p. ong , y. zhang , _ et al . _ , phys . lett . * 82 * , 5108 ( 1999 ) [ cond - mat/9904138 ] . d. v. khveshchenko , phys . lett . * 87 * , 206401 ( 2001 ) [ cond - mat/0106261 ] . h. leal and d. v. khveshchenko , nucl . b * 687 * , 323 ( 2004 ) [ cond - mat/0302164 ] . i. f. herbut and b. roy , phys . b * 77 * , 245438 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0802.2546 [ cond-mat.mes-hall ] ] ; b. roy and i. f. herbut , phys . b * 83 * , 195422 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1102.3481 [ cond-mat.mes-hall ] ] . e. j. ferrer and v. de la incera , phys . * 102 * , 050402 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0807.4744 [ hep - ph ] ] ; nucl . b * 824 * , 217 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0905.1733 [ hep - ph ] ] ; e. j. ferrer , v. de la incera and a. sanchez , phys . lett . * 107 * , 041602 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1103.5152 [ hep - ph ] ] . d. d. scherer and h. gies , phys . b * 85 * , 195417 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1201.3746 [ cond-mat.str-el ] ] . k. fukushima and j. m. pawlowski , phys . d * 86 * , 076013 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.4330 [ hep - ph ] ] . i. l. buchbinder and e. n. kirillova , sov . j. * 32 * , 446 ( 1989 ) ; int . j. mod . phys . a * 4 * , 143 ( 1989 ) . i. l. buchbinder , s. d. odintsov and i. l. shapiro , `` effective action in quantum gravity , '' bristol , uk : iop ( 1992 ) . t. inagaki , t. muta and s. d. odintsov , mod . lett . a * 8 * , 2117 ( 1993 ) [ hep - th/9306023 ] . i. sachs and a. wipf , phys . b * 326 * , 105 ( 1994 ) [ hep - th/9310085 ] . e. elizalde , s. leseduarte , s. d. odintsov and y. i. shilnov , phys . d * 53 * , 1917 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9505065 ] . s. kanemura and h. -t . sato , mod . a * 11 * , 785 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9511059 ] . t. inagaki , int . j. mod . a * 11 * , 4561 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9512200 ] . t. inagaki and k. -i . ishikawa , phys . d * 56 * , 5097 ( 1997 ) . b. geyer and s. d. odintsov , phys . b * 376 * , 260 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9603172 ] ; phys . d * 53 * , 7321 ( 1996 ) [ hep - th/9602110 ] . g. miele and p. vitale , nucl . b * 494 * , 365 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9612168 ] ; p. vitale , nucl . b * 551 * , 490 ( 1999 ) [ hep - th/9812076 ] . t. inagaki , t. muta and s. d. odintsov , prog . suppl . * 127 * , 93 ( 1997 ) [ hep - th/9711084 ] . j. hashida , s. mukaigawa , t. muta , k. ohkura and k. yamamoto , phys . d * 61 * , 044015 ( 2000 ) [ gr - qc/9907014 ] . e. v. gorbar and v. p. gusynin , annals phys . * 323 * , 2132 ( 2008 ) [ arxiv:0710.2292 [ hep - ph ] ] . m. hayashi , t. inagaki and h. takata , arxiv:0812.0900 [ hep - ph ] ; t. inagaki and m. hayashi , arxiv:1003.1173 [ hep - ph ] . s. sasagawa and h. tanaka , prog . . phys . * 128 * , 925 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1209.2782 [ hep - ph ] ] . e. v. gorbar , phys . d * 61 * , 024013 ( 2000 ) [ hep - th/9904180 ] ; ukr . j. phys . * 54 * , 541 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0809.2558 [ hep - th ] ] . d. ebert , a. v. tyukov and v. c. zhukovsky , phys . d * 80 * , 085019 ( 2009 ) [ arxiv:0808.2961 [ hep - th ] ] . d. v. khveshchenko , phys . lett . * 87 * , 246802 ( 2001 ) [ cond - mat/0101306 ] . i. f. herbut , phys . lett . * 97 * , 146401 ( 2006 ) [ cond - mat/0606195 ] . d. j. gross and a. neveu , phys . d * 10 * , 3235 ( 1974 ) . h. a. weldon , phys . d * 63 * , 104010 ( 2001 ) [ gr - qc/0009086 ] . f. hofling , c. nowak and c. wetterich , phys . b * 66 * , 205111 ( 2002 ) [ cond - mat/0203588 ] . l. janssen and h. gies , phys . d * 86 * , 105007 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1208.3327 [ hep - th ] ] ; h. gies and l. janssen , phys . d * 82 * , 085018 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:1006.3747 [ hep - th ] ] . l. janssen , `` critical phenomena in ( 2 + 1)-dimensional relativistic fermion systems , '' phd thesis , fsu jena , http://www.db-thueringen.de/servlets/document + servlet?id=20856 ( 2012 ) . j. braun , h. gies and d. d. scherer , phys . d * 83 * , 085012 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1011.1456 [ hep - th ] ] . c. wetterich , phys . b * 301 * , 90 ( 1993 ) . j. berges , n. tetradis and c. wetterich , phys . rept . * 363 * , 223 ( 2002 ) [ hep - ph/0005122 ] . k. aoki , int . j. mod . b * 14 * , 1249 ( 2000 ) . j. m. pawlowski , ann . * 322 * , 2831 ( 2007 ) [ hep - th/0512261 ] . h. gies , lect . notes phys . * 852 * , 287 ( 2012 ) [ hep - ph/0611146 ] . b. delamotte , lect . notes phys . * 852 * , 49 ( 2012 ) [ cond - mat/0702365 [ cond - mat ] ] . p. kopietz , l. bartosch and f. schutz , lect . notes phys . * 798 * , 1 ( 2010 ) . w. metzner , m. salmhofer , c. honerkamp , v. meden and k. schonhammer , rev . phys . * 84 * , 299 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1105.5289 [ cond-mat.str-el ] ] . j. braun , j. phys . g * 39 * , 033001 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1108.4449 ] . r. camporesi , commun . phys . * 148 * , 283 ( 1992 ) . i. s. gradshteyn and i. m. ryzhik , `` table of integrals , series , and products , '' new york , us : academic press ( 2000 ) . j. jaeckel and c. wetterich , phys . d * 68 * , 025020 ( 2003 ) [ hep - ph/0207094 ] . u. ellwanger and c. wetterich , nucl . b * 423 * , 137 ( 1994 ) [ hep - ph/9402221 ] . h. gies and c. wetterich , phys . d * 65 * , 065001 ( 2002 ) [ hep - th/0107221 ] . v. skokov , phys . d * 85 * , 034026 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1112.5137 [ hep - ph ] ] . j. braun , c. s. fischer and h. gies , phys . rev . d * 84 * , 034045 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1012.4279 [ hep - ph ] ] . v. p. gusynin and s. g. sharapov , phys . lett . * 95 * , 146801 ( 2005 ) [ cond - mat/0506575 ] . d. nelson , t. piran and s. weinberg , `` statistical mechanics of membranes and surfaces , '' singapore , sg : world scientific ( 1989 ) . f. guinea , m. i. katsnelson and a. k. geim , nature phys . * 6 * , 30 ( 2010 ) [ arxiv:0909.1787 [ cond-mat.mes-hall ] ] ; f. guinea , a. k. geim , m. i. katsnelson , k. s. novoselov , phys . b * 81 * , 035408 ( 2010 ) ; n. levy _ et al . _ , science * 329 * , 544 ( 2010 ) . s. weinberg , _ in * hawking , s.w . , israel , w. : general relativity * , 790 - 831 _ ; m. reuter , phys . d * 57 * , 971 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9605030 ] ; m. niedermaier and m. reuter , living rev . * 9 * , 5 ( 2006 ) ; r. percacci , in * oriti , d. ( ed . ) : approaches to quantum gravity * 111 - 128 [ arxiv:0709.3851 [ hep - th ] ] ; m. reuter and f. saueressig , new j. phys . * 14 * , 055022 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1202.2274 [ hep - th ] ] . dona and r. percacci , arxiv:1209.3649 [ hep - th ] ; u. harst and m. reuter , jhep * 1205 * , 005 ( 2012 ) [ arxiv:1203.2158 [ hep - th ] ] ; r. percacci and d. perini , phys . d * 67 * , 081503 ( 2003 ) [ hep - th/0207033 ] . o. lauscher and m. reuter , jhep * 0510 * , 050 ( 2005 ) [ hep - th/0508202 ] . a. eichhorn and h. gies , new j. phys . * 13 * , 125012 ( 2011 ) [ arxiv:1104.5366 [ hep - th ] ] .
Abstract: | [
"catalyzed symmetry breaking arises from a parametric enhancement of critical fluctuations independently of the coupling strength . symmetry - breaking fermionic long - range fluctuations exhibit such an enhancement on negatively curved spaces , as is known from mean - field studies . we study gravitational catalysis from the viewpoint of the functional renormalization group using the @xmath0 gross - neveu model as a specific example . we observe gravitational catalysis towards a phase of broken discrete chiral symmetry both on a maximally symmetric ( ads ) and on a purely spatially curved manifold for constant negative curvature ( lobachevsky plane ) . the resulting picture for gravitational catalysis obtained from the renormalization flow is closely related to that of magnetic catalysis . as an application , we estimate the curvature required for subcritical systems of finite length to acquire a gravitionally catalyzed gap ."
] | 9,655 | 9,655 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: we describe in this paper analysis procedures that can answer two of the most important questions of neutrino research . how can one determine the total solar neutrino fluxes ( @xmath12 , and @xmath10 ) for comparison with solar model predictions ? how can one determine the sterile contribution to the total solar neutrino fluxes ? our answers allow for the possibility of an arbitrary mixture in solar neutrino oscillations of active and sterile neutrinos , but require the correctness of the lma solution of the solar neutrino problems and careful attention to all the sources of error ( theoretical as well as experimental).be and @xmath0b neutrinos are unchanged and the numerical results have not been affected significantly , but the present version is more up - to - date with respect to the input data . we have also added , inspired by the sage discussion , a detailed analysis of what one can learn about @xmath10 neutrinos before there is a dedicated experiment to measure just the @xmath10 neutrino flux . ] we focus first on determining total fluxes by comparing charged current ( cc ) observables measured in different experiments ; this method yields results as independent as possible of uncertainties due to the presence of sterile neutrinos . we then describe how similar techniques can be applied to determine total solar neutrino fluxes using a cc experiment plus a neutrino - electron scattering experiment [ or a neutral current ( nc ) measurement ] , which yields results that depend more on the sterile neutrino mix but which can nevertheless be relatively accurate . the numerical values we estimate for the expected precision with which different quantities can be measured rely upon simulations of the performance of the relevant experiments . therefore the accuracies that we quote are illustrative ; the actual accuracies that are obtainable can only be determined once the experimental uncertainties are known . neutrinos change flavors as they travel to the earth from the center of the sun . this flavor change was seen directly by the comparison of the sudbury neutrino observatory ( sno ) measurement @xcite of the charged current reaction for @xmath0b solar neutrinos with the super - kamiokande measurement @xcite of the neutrino - electron scattering rate ( charged plus neutral current ) . even more clearly , flavor change has been demonstrated by comparing the neutral current measurement by sno with the sno cc measurement @xcite . the conclusion that flavor changes occur among solar neutrinos , if based solely upon the comparison of the sno and super - kamiokande event rates , is valid statistically at about the @xmath13 confidence level @xcite . the neutral current measurement of sno increases the significance level for flavor changes among solar neutrinos to the @xmath14 confidence level . the sno and super - kamiokande results demonstrate simply that new physics is required to resolve the long - standing solar neutrino problem @xcite , i.e. , to understand the origin of the discrepancy between the predictions of the standard solar model @xcite and the observed solar neutrino event rates @xcite . if one includes the results of the chlorine @xcite , kamiokande @xcite , sage @xcite , gallex @xcite , and gno @xcite experiments together with the sno ( cc ) and super - kamiokande results , then the combined measurements require @xcite new physics at @xmath15 and , if the relative temperature scaling of the @xmath8be and @xmath0b neutrino production reactions is taken into account , at @xmath16 . helioseismological measurements confirm the predicted sound speeds of the standard solar model to better than @xmath17% and show that stellar physics can not account for the discrepancies between standard predictions and the observed solar neutrino rates @xcite . the combination of the charged current ( cc ) and the charged plus neutral - current measurement with super - kamiokande has been used by several groups @xcite to determine the flux of active @xmath0b neutrinos independent of the solar model . these model - independent determinations of the active flux exploit the similarity between the response functions in the sno and super - kamiokande detectors @xcite . in addition , if one includes all the experimental data in a global oscillation solution in which the @xmath0b flux is a free parameter , one obtains a similar ( but slightly smaller ) allowed range for the @xmath0b neutrino flux @xcite . the measurement of the nc rate by sno @xcite provides an independent determination of the active @xmath0b neutrino flux . all of the analyses yield the same result : if electron neutrinos oscillate into only active neutrinos , then the total @xmath0b neutrino flux is in excellent agreement with the flux predicted by the standard solar model . this close agreement of the active @xmath0b neutrino flux with the total flux predicted by the standard solar model ( ssm ) @xcite is , if the flux of sterile neutrinos is small , an important confirmation of the quantitative theory of stellar evolution . we summarize below the current best - estimates and the associated @xmath2 uncertainties for the active @xmath0b neutrino flux , @xmath18 . * standard solar model ( bp00 ) prediction @xcite : @xmath19 * comparison of sno and super - kamiokande event rates ( cf . esp . ref . @xcite ) : @xmath20 * sno neutral current measurement ( assuming undistorted spectrum ) @xcite . @xmath21 * global neutrino oscillation analysis ( see table [ tab : fbranges ] this paper and ref . @xcite ) : @xmath22 the agreement , summarized in eqs . ( [ eq : itemfb8ssm])([eq : itemfb8global ] ) , between the ssm calculated flux and the measured active flux suggests that the sterile neutrino contribution to the @xmath0b neutrino flux may be small . in this paper , we ignore this tempting suggestion and instead concentrate on developing methods to determine experimentally the total @xmath0b and @xmath8be neutrino fluxes emitted by the sun , independent of the active - sterile mixture ( for a discussion of earlier investigations of sterile neutrinos see refs . @xcite ) . if we want to understand the particle physics implications of solar neutrino research , we must determine if sterile neutrinos are present in the solar neutrino flux . moreover , the original and still valid goal of solar neutrino research was @xcite to compare solar model predicted and experimentally measured ( total ) solar neutrino fluxes . what is the situation if sterile neutrinos exist ? the total flux of @xmath0b neutrinos could in this case be much larger than the standard solar model prediction ; a major fraction of the total flux that reaches the earth could arrive in a form that is not detected in solar neutrino experiments . the existing data disfavor ( at @xmath23 cl ) oscillation into purely sterile neutrinos . nevertheless , a large sterile component is allowed @xcite if oscillations occur into a combination of active and sterile neutrino states ( see refs . @xcite for a description of the formalism adopted here ) . the flux of sterile neutrinos could in principle be large enough to destroy the apparently excellent agreement between the flux predicted by the ssm and the true flux of @xmath0b neutrinos [ which is assumed to be pure active neutrinos in the comparison shown above in eqs . ( [ eq : itemfb8ssm])-([eq : itemfb8global ] ) ] . a measurement of the total @xmath0b solar neutrino flux , including the sterile component ( if any ) , will provide information that is important for astrophysics and for particle physics . the motivation for investigating sterile neutrinos is not dependent upon the lsnd @xcite results that might suggest the existence of sterile neutrinos . of course , the lsnd results are not supported by other experimental results ( cf . @xcite ) nor by theoretical predictions that have been precisely confirmed ( like the helioseismological verifications of the standard solar model ) , as is the case for the inference of flavor change based upon the sno - super - kamiokande comparison . fortunately , the kamland reactor neutrino experiment @xcite , when combined with the sno measurement of the cc flux , is capable of providing a precise determination of the total , i.e. the active plus the sterile , @xmath0b neutrino flux . we assume throughout this paper the correctness of the currently favored large mixing angle ( lma ) solution to the solar neutrino problem . if the lma solution is not correct , then all global analyses of the available solar and reactor data indicate that either the mass difference , @xmath24 , or the vacuum mixing angle , @xmath25 , will be too small to produce a measurable effect in the kamland experiment ( see e.g. refs . @xcite ) . in this case , kamland will be unable to provide the information required to determine the total @xmath0b neutrino flux . here is the basic physical idea of the method we propose for measuring the total @xmath0b solar neutrino flux . for the kamland @xcite experiment , one will know accurately the flux of anti - neutrinos from the @xmath26 reactors that contribute significantly to the measured anti - neutrino events . from measurements of the total event rate and the energy spectrum induced by the surviving @xmath27 , the kamland experimentalists can determine with precision @xcite the anti - neutrino propagation parameters , @xmath28 and @xmath29 . both the kamland measurement and the cc sno measurements are disappearance experiments for neutrinos ( or anti - neutrinos ) of similar energies . for the cc measurement made with sno , one does not know the total @xmath0b neutrino flux created in the sun . but , assuming conservation of cpt , one can use the propagation parameters @xmath30 and @xmath31 determined by kamland and the measured ( by sno ) cc rate to solve for the flux that gives the observed result . summarizing , for the kamland experiment one knows the total flux but not the propagation parameters , which are measured . for the sno cc experiment , one will know ( from kamland ) the propagation parameters and therefore can measure the total flux . figure [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] shows the results of a refined global solution for the solar neutrino oscillation parameters that was made ( see sec . [ sec : presentknowledge ] and the appendix ) using all the available solar and reactor data . the figure displays the allowed solar neutrino oscillation contours at @xmath2 , @xmath32 , and @xmath33 . the results are obtained by the procedures described most recently in ref . @xcite , where we have used in the present paper the analysis strategy ( a ) ( of ref . @xcite ) including the 1496 day super - kamiokande data sample @xcite as well as the sno cc , nc and day - night observations @xcite . we have also made some improvements ( see the appendix ) in the treatment of the uncertainties in the neutrino cross sections and in the correlation of errors . for comparison , we also show in fig . [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] the small size of the expected allowed region for kamland if this reactor anti - neutrino experiment observes a signal corresponding to the current best - fit point of the solar neutrino analysis . in calculating the kamland allowed region , we have made a conservative estimate ( see sec . [ subsec : precisionb8 ] ) , following the principles discussed in refs . @xcite . figure [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] shows clearly that kamland has the potential for making a precise measurement of the solar neutrino oscillation parameters , provided that the lma is the correct oscillation solution . the only complication involved in determining the total @xmath0b flux from a comparison of the kamland and sno cc measurements results from the fact that for the favored large mixing angle ( lma ) solar neutrino oscillation solution matter effects in the sun and the earth can be significant . matter effects are unimportant for the kamland reactor experiment . the role of matter effects in solar neutrino experiments depends somewhat upon the _ a priori _ unknown active - sterile mixture , which introduces a calculable uncertainty in the inferred total @xmath0b neutrino flux . in summary , the combination of the sno cc neutrino measurement and the kamland anti - neutrino measurement will determine the total ( active plus sterile ) flux , @xmath34 , of @xmath0b solar neutrinos . by subtracting the previously determined flux ( see above ) , @xmath18 , from @xmath35 , one can determine the flux of sterile solar neutrinos . using similar reasoning , we shall also show that the combined super - kamiokande and kamland measurements can be analyzed to yield an accurate value for the total @xmath0b flux , although in this case the results are somewhat more sensitive to the active - sterile admixture . the flux of @xmath8be solar neutrinos , which in the ssm is predicted@xcite to be @xmath36 , can be determined in a model independent way from a global analysis of the solar neutrino data assuming only active neutrino oscillations . for example , the latest analysis by garzelli and giunti @xcite yields @xmath37 at 99% cl . we shall also show in this paper that one can extract the value of the @xmath8be neutrino flux from measurements of the gallium solar neutrino experiments , gallex , sage , and gno and the results of the sno and kamland measurements . the value of the @xmath8be flux that will be derived in this way is relatively insensitive to the assumed neutrino oscillation parameters , although it does depend somewhat on the assumed contributions of the cno , @xmath38 , and @xmath10 neutrino fluxes which we adopt from the standard solar model . the constraint provided by the chlorine experiment is not very useful for determining the total @xmath8be neutrino flux . one can obtain an independent measurement of the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux by comparing data from the kamland experiment with data from the borexino @xcite solar neutrino experiment . if both the kamland and the borexino detectors work as expected , then this method will be more accurate than the methods involving the gallium and chlorine radiochemical detectors . the determination of the total solar neutrino fluxes , and even more so the determination of the sterile components of these neutrino fluxes , requires precision in both the experimental measurements and the theoretical calculations and analyses . we present in the appendix a refined discussion of the theoretical errors , and their correlations , for the absorption cross for the gallium and chlorine solar neutrino experiments . the outline of this paper is as follows . in sec . [ sec : presentknowledge ] , we describe the current experimental knowledge of the @xmath0b solar neutrino flux . our results are summarized in table [ tab : fbranges ] both for the special case of oscillations between purely active neutrinos and for the general case of oscillations between electron neutrinos and an active - sterile neutrino admixture . we limit our analysis to the allowed lma region of solar neutrino oscillations . we show in sec . [ sec : determiningb8total ] how one can use the cc measurements with sno and kamland to determine an accurate total @xmath0b solar neutrino flux including experimental and theoretical uncertainties and the possibility of an appreciable active - sterile admixture . we switch to the @xmath8be flux in sec . [ sec : be7 ] and evaluate how well one can determine the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux by also using the results of the gallium ( gallex , sage , and gno ) solar neutrino experiments or the chlorine experiment . in sec . [ sec : klandes ] , we investigate how well the total @xmath0b and @xmath8be neutrino fluxes can be determined using the combined measurements of kamland and @xmath39 scattering observed in the super - kamiokande ( sec . [ subsec : kamlandsuperkb8 ] ) and borexino ( sec . [ subsec : kamlandborexino ] ) detectors . we show that even in the presence of active - sterile admixtures the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux may be measured with relatively high accuracy by comparing results from the kamland and the borexino experiments . we describe and analyze in sec . [ sec : determiningpp ] three strategies for determining the total @xmath10 solar neutrino flux in the absence of a dedicated experiment that measures separately the @xmath10 neutrinos . we summarize and discuss our principal conclusions in sec . [ sec : discuss ] . we urge the reader to turn first to sec . [ sec : discuss ] and read there the summary and discussion of our main results and their implications . the rest of the paper can then be understood more easily . we generalize in this section the determination of the @xmath0b neutrino flux to the case in which @xmath40 oscillates into a state that is a linear combination of active ( @xmath41 ) and sterile ( @xmath42 ) neutrino states , @xmath43 where @xmath44 is the parameter that describes the active - sterile admixture . this admixture arises naturally in the framework of 4-@xmath45 mixing @xcite . the total @xmath0b neutrino flux can be written @xmath46 where @xmath47 . clearly , the larger the sterile component , the larger the value of @xmath48 that is inferred from the experimental data . we have performed a global analysis of the solar neutrino data treating the total @xmath0b neutrino flux as a free parameter . the details of the analysis procedure are the same as those used in ref . @xcite except where we explicitly state otherwise . we concentrate here on the lma region , @xmath49 , @xmath50 . to take account of the possibility of oscillations into sterile neutrinos , we determine the allowed regions in the parameter space defined by @xmath24 , @xmath51 , and a third parameter , @xmath52 , that is defined by eq . ( [ eq : linearcombination ] ) . it is convenient to introduce the dimensionless parameter , @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the total @xmath0b neutrino flux in units of the predicted standard solar model flux . .the allowed range of the total @xmath0b neutrino flux . the table presents the allowed range of @xmath55 [ defined by eq . ( [ eq : defnfb ] ) ] that was found in a global solution of all the currently available solar and reactor neutrino data . the second column gives the allowed range of @xmath55 for an arbitrary mixture of active and sterile neutrinos and the third column gives the range for the case where only active neutrinos are considered . the results shown were obtained using eq . ( [ eq : fb8determination3 ] ) . [ tab : fbranges ] [ cols="^,^,^",options="header " , ] the largest uncertainties in determining @xmath56 using the chlorine data are caused by the experimental errors in the chlorine absorption rate ( @xmath57 ) and the sno cc absorption rate ( @xmath58 ) . the uncertainty in the chlorine neutrino absorption cross sections are also significant ( @xmath59 to @xmath60 , depending upon the neutrino oscillation parameters ) . to be explicit , the uncertainties in @xmath56 due to the theoretical uncertainties in calculating the chlorine neutrino absorption cross sections that were used in constructing table [ tab : fbecl ] were evaluated from the following equation , @xmath61 ^ 2 + \left[\sum_{{\rm j= ^8b},hep}(f_{\rm be}({\rm c.s.}_j\pm 1 \sigma_{\rm c.s._j } ) - f_{\rm be}(i)\right]^2 \label{appex : chlorineferrors}~.\ ] ] ( see the appendix for more details regarding the treatment of the cross section errors . ) even the cno fluxes ( @xmath62 ) and the sno cc absorption cross section ( @xmath63 ) contribute non - negligible errors . the uncertainty from sterile neutrinos is small ( @xmath64 ) and does not significantly affect the total uncertainty . remarkably , the individual uncertainties in @xmath56 which arise from several different sources are larger than the current best - fit values of @xmath56 ( see table [ tab : fbecl ] ) . for the chlorine based determination , we have computed a representative ( average ) shift in @xmath56 by a monte carlo sampling of the allowed kamland oscillation region shown in fig . [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] . we find @xmath65 this uncertainty is so large as to render not very useful the determination of @xmath56 with the aid of chlorine data . in this section , we show how data from kamland can be combined with @xmath39 scattering data obtained with the super - kamiokande and borexino experiments in order to determine , respectively , the total @xmath0b ( sec . [ subsec : kamlandsuperkb8 ] ) and @xmath8be ( sec . [ subsec : kamlandborexino ] ) solar neutrino fluxes . as discussed before , the advantage of using purely cc measurements to determine the fluxes is that the answers depend only mildly on the active - sterile admixture . on the other hand , @xmath39 scattering measurements have the advantage of smaller uncertainties in the interaction cross sections . moreover , for the determination of the @xmath8be flux , borexino depends less strongly on other neutrino fluxes predicted by the standard solar model than do the radiochemical experiments , chlorine , gallex , sage , and gno . in this section , we show how data from the super - kamiokande and kamland experiments can be combined to measure the total @xmath0b neutrino flux . we shall see that the determination using super - kamiokande and kamland yields , on average , a value for the total flux than is comparable in precision to what is expected to be obtained using sno and kamland . the systematic uncertainties are different in the two experiments , sno and super - kamiokande . therefore , it will be important to compare the total @xmath0b neutrino flux that is inferred using super - kamiokande and kamland with the value that is obtained using sno and kamland . if the uncertainties are correctly estimated , then the two methods should agree within their quoted errors . the advantage of using purely charged current measurements with sno and kamland to determine the total @xmath0b flux is that the answer depends only very slightly upon the unknown active - sterile mixture ( as discussed in sec . [ sec : determiningb8total ] ) . the principal advantages of the super - kamiokande experiment in the present context is that the neutrino interaction cross section is accurately known @xcite and the statistical and systematic errors have already been extensively investigated @xcite . however , as we shall see below , when using super - kamiokande there is a significant uncertainty ( @xmath67% and @xmath68% ) in the total @xmath0b flux due to the active - sterile mixture , at least with our present knowledge of @xmath44 . the average survival probability for @xmath0b solar neutrinos can be written in the form @xmath69 where @xmath70 is the probability of oscillating into active neutrinos and @xmath71 is the ratio of the the @xmath72 and @xmath73 elastic scattering cross - sections . the expected sensitivity of @xmath54 to the principal sources of errors can be calculated from the following equation : @xmath74 we suppose that kamland will observe ( with associated uncertainties that we simulate with a monte carlo ) the rate predicted for the global best - fit point shown in fig . [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] . for purely active oscillations , we find that @xmath75= 1\left[1 \pm 0.054\right ] , ~~\cos^2 \eta = 1.0 , \label{eq : skfboactive}\ ] ] where the first error corresponds to the super kamiokande experimental uncertainty and the second error is caused by the finite size of the allowed kamland region in oscillation parameter space . the combined kamland and super - kamiokande measurement will , for purely active neutrinos , yield a determination for the total @xmath0b flux that is more accurate than can be obtained with the sno cc measurement and kamland . within the 1 @xmath76 lma region , the average uncertainty in the combined kamland and super - kamiokande measurement for the total active @xmath0b neutrino flux is expected to be @xmath77 for purely active neutrinos , super - kamiokande and kamland may provide us with a more accurate determination of the total @xmath0b neutrino flux than sno cc and kamland [ cf . ( [ eq : averagefbsigma ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : activesigmab8kamlandsk ] ) ] . allowing for the currently allowed @xmath2 ( @xmath78% ) sterile admixture , we find for the best fit point @xmath79,~~\cos^2 \eta \geq 0.75 \label{eq : borexinofbosterile}\ ] ] the last error in eq . ( [ eq : borexinofbosterile ] ) corresponds to the present 1@xmath76 uncertainty from the active - sterile admixture @xmath80 . the average uncertainty in the combined kamland and super - kamiokande measurement for @xmath81 is expected to be @xmath82% , within the 1 @xmath76 lma region and if the sterile admixture is as large as currently allowed . in this section , we show how data from the kamland and borexino experiments can be combined to measure the total @xmath8be neutrino flux . the principal advantage of using the borexino experiment for this purpose is that the signal in the borexino experiment @xcite is predicted to be dominated by @xmath8be neutrinos , whereas @xmath8be solar neutrinos are expected to contribute only a relatively small ( and unlabeled ) fraction to the observed event rate in the gallium and chlorine radiochemical measurements ( see table [ tab : garates ] ) scattering . the radiochemical detectors do not have energy resolution , only an energy threshold . ] . however , unlike the cases involving the gallium and chlorine experiments that were discussed in sec . [ sec : be7 ] , which include only @xmath40 ( cc ) absorption , the borexino experiment detects both @xmath83 scattering and @xmath84 and @xmath85 scattering . one must consider in the present case the extent to which the active - sterile neutrino admixture influences the detected event rate for each set of oscillation parameters , @xmath86 , determined by kamland . as we shall see quantitatively in the following discussion , this uncertainty regarding the sterile admixture does not decrease significantly the overall accuracy of the inferred total @xmath8be neutrino flux . the average survival probability for active neutrinos can be written conveniently in the form @xmath87 where @xmath88 is the oscillation probability of neutrino fluxes of source @xmath89 into active neutrinos and @xmath90 is the ratio of the the @xmath91 and @xmath73 elastic scattering cross - sections . the expression for @xmath56 has the same form for the case in which the kamland and borexino experiments are considered together as for the previously discussed cases involving the gallium experiments [ see eq . ( [ eq : fbe ] ) ] and the chlorine experiment [ see eq . ( [ eq : fbechlorine ] ) ] . using the average survival probability defined in eq . ( [ eq : survivalscattering ] ) , we can write @xmath92 \label{eq : fborexino}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the last term of eq . ( [ eq : fborexino ] ) , we include the contributions from @xmath10 , and cno neutrinos . the contribution from @xmath0b neutrinos is negligible because the observed @xmath0b neutrino flux is about a factor of @xmath93 smaller than the predicted ssm @xmath8be neutrino flux and because @xmath0b neutrinos primarily produce high energy recoils electrons that the borexino detector can distinguish from the low energy recoil electrons produced by @xmath8be neutrinos . the expected sensitivity of @xmath56 to different sources of errors is given by @xmath94 in order to estimate the accuracy of this method for determining @xmath56 , we suppose that kamland will observe ( with associated uncertainties that we simulate with a monte carlo ) the rate predicted for the global best - fit point , see ref . @xcite . ] shown in fig . [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] and that borexino also will observe a signal corresponding to this best - fit point ( with associated uncertainties ) . in the absence of any published data , we estimate that - based upon experience in previous solar neutrino experiments @xcite - that borexino will achieve a systematic uncertainty of between @xmath95% and @xmath4% . we estimate in this way that the combined experiments will yield a determination of @xmath56 that is , for purely active oscillations , @xmath96= 1\left[1 \pm { 0.057 } ( \pm { 0.103)}\right ] , ~~\cos^2 \eta = 1.0 , \label{eq : borexinofbeactive}\ ] ] where the first error corresponds to the borexino experimental uncertainty , the second to the uncertainty in the reconstructed kamland region , and the last error is due to the theoretical uncertainty in the predicted cno fluxes . within the 1 @xmath76 lma region , the average uncertainty in the combined kamland and borexino measurement for the total active @xmath8be neutrino flux is expected to be @xmath97 if we allow for a 25% sterile admixture , we find @xmath98 \label{eq : borexinofbesterile}~.\ ] ] the last error in eq . ( [ eq : borexinofbesterile ] ) corresponds to the present 1@xmath76 uncertainty from the active - sterile admixture @xmath80 . the numbers in parentheses in eq . ( [ eq : borexinofbeactive ] ) and eq . ( [ eq : borexinofbesterile ] ) correspond to assuming the larger systematic uncertainty , @xmath99% , for the borexino measured rate . for @xmath100 , the average uncertainty in the combined kamland and borexino measurement is expected to be @xmath101% , within the 1 @xmath76 lma region and if the sterile admixture is as large as currently allowed , in this section , we analyze three strategies for determining the total @xmath10 solar neutrino flux without requiring a dedicated experiment that measures only the @xmath10 neutrinos . we first describe in sec . [ subsec : existingdata ] how one can make a crude determination of the @xmath10 neutrino flux using the measured gallium , chlorine , and sno ( cc ) event rates @xcite and the standard solar model predictions for all but the @xmath0b , @xmath8be , and @xmath10 solar neutrino fluxes . this part of the discussion is similar to the analysis described in ref . @xcite , although we evaluate explicitly the uncertainty caused by the finite size of the allowed region in oscillation parameter space . we then determine in sec . [ subsec : galliumsno ] how well one can infer the @xmath10 flux using just the gallium and the sno measurements and the bp00 predictions for the other neutrino fluxes , especially the @xmath8be neutrino flux . the unknown sterile - active mixture contributes only a negligible error using the strategies described in sec . [ subsec : existingdata ] and sec . [ subsec : galliumsno ] . next , we show in sec . [ subsec : ppkamlandborexino ] how the precision of the determination of the @xmath10 flux can be improved by using , in the future , the results from kamland ( to constrain the neutrino oscillation parameters ) and from borexino ( to constrain the @xmath8be neutrino flux ) . the principle of this strategy has also been discussed by the sage collaboration @xcite . the theoretical error on the @xmath10 neutrino flux is @xmath103% ( see ref . @xcite ) , which is an order of magnitude smaller than the estimated errors that we find in this section on the empirically derived values of @xmath104 . to achieve a precision of @xmath4% or better in the determination of the solar neutrino @xmath10 flux will require a dedicated and accurate experiment devoted to measuring the @xmath10 flux . throughout this section , we treat the @xmath10 flux and the @xmath38 flux as a single variable because they are so closely linked physically @xcite . the two reactions are linked because the @xmath38 reaction is obtained from the @xmath10 reaction by exchanging a positron in the final state with an electron in the initial state . thus the rates for the two reactions are proportional to each other to high accuracy @xcite . for convenience , we denote the sum of the @xmath10 and @xmath38 fluxes as simply @xmath10 . in this subsection , we show how data from the chlorine , gallium , and sno experiments can be combined with the bp00 predictions for the cno and @xmath105 fluxes to determine the total @xmath10 neutrino flux . the reduced @xmath10 solar neutrino flux , @xmath104 defined ( by analogy with @xmath54 ) with respect to the predicted standard solar model sum of the @xmath10 and @xmath38 fluxes , can be written as : @xmath106 & & - f_{\rm be } r^{\rm ^7be , ssm}_{\rm ga } \langle p_{ee}(\delta m^2,\tan^2\theta)\rangle^{\rm ^7be}_{\rm ga } -r^{\rm^8b , ssm}_{\rm ga } \frac{r^{\rm cc , exp}_{\rm sno } } { r^{\rm cc , ssm}_{\rm sno } } \frac{\langle p_{ee}(\delta m^2,\tan^2\theta)\rangle^{\rm ^8b}_{\rm ga } } { \langle p_{ee}(\delta m^2,\tan^2\theta)\rangle^{\rm ^8b}_{\rm sno } } \big ] .\label{eq : fpp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here the sum over @xmath107 in eq . ( [ eq : fpp ] ) refers to the three cno neutrino sources and the @xmath105 neutrinos ( see table [ tab : garates ] ) . we insert in eq . ( [ eq : fpp ] ) the expression for @xmath56 in terms of the chlorine and sno rates and the standard solar model cno and @xmath105 neutrino fluxes . explicitly , @xmath108 & & -r^{\rm ^8b , ssm}_{\rm cl } \frac{r^{\rm cc , exp}_{\rm sno } } { r^{\rm cc , ssm}_{\rm sno}}\frac { \langle p_{ee } ( \delta m^2,\tan^2\theta)\rangle^{\rm ^8b}_{\rm cl } } { \langle p_{ee } ( \delta m^2,\tan^2\theta)\rangle_{\rm sno } } \big ] . \label{eq : fppbechlorine}\end{aligned}\ ] ] for the special case of the best fit point in the lma solution region , we find @xmath109 the first error in eq . ( [ eq : fppbestlma ] ) , ( @xmath110 ) , results from the weighted average experimental error for the gallium experiment @xcite . the second error , ( @xmath111 ) , reflects the uncertainties in the calculated neutrino absorption cross sections on gallium @xcite . the third error , ( @xmath112 ) , is caused by the uncertainties in the calculated standard solar model cno fluxes @xcite . the fourth error , ( @xmath113 ) , derives from the measurement errors in the sno cc experimental data @xcite and neutrino absorption cross section @xcite . the fifth error , ( @xmath114 ) , results from the experimental error for the chlorine event rate @xcite and the sixth error , ( @xmath115 ) , reflects the uncertainties in the calculated neutrino absorption cross sections for chlorine @xcite . the physical constraint , @xmath116 , was imposed in obtaining these errors . within the @xmath2 lma allowed region , we find that the central value of @xmath104 can vary in the range @xmath117 and the best - fit value can be determined with an average uncertainty of @xmath118% . the range of central values of @xmath104 always exceeds the bp00 value because the observed chlorine rate implies a low value of @xmath119 . since the largest contributions to the gallium rate are from @xmath10 neutrino and @xmath8be neutrinos , a low @xmath8be flux implies a relatively high @xmath10 flux . we can summarize as follows the results of the simulations carried out within the @xmath2 allowed lma region for the @xmath10 flux : @xmath120 the first error in eq . ( [ eq : fppsummaryknown ] ) results from the allowed range of neutrino oscillation parameters and the second error results from the uncertainties in all other recognized sources of errors , combined quadratically . the result given in eq . ( [ eq : fppsummaryknown ] ) should be compared with the quoted estimate by the sage collaboration @xcite , @xmath121 . this agreement is very welcome since the sage paper points out that they made several approximations ... whose nature can not be easily quantified . " in this subsection , we determine the range of allowed values for @xmath104 using the bp00 predictions ( and uncertainties ) for the @xmath8be neutrinos as well as the cno and @xmath105 neutrinos . we use in this subsection data only from the gallium and sno solar neutrino experiments . following the same line of reasoning as in section [ subsec : existingdata ] , we find for the best fit point in the lma allowed oscillation region , @xmath122 just as in eq . ( [ eq : fppbestlma ] ) , the first error in eq . ( [ eq : fbbestlmabe7 ] ) , ( @xmath123 ) , is the experimental error from the weighted average event rate in the gallium experiments , the second error,(@xmath124 ) , is due to the neutrino absorption cross section on gallium , the third error , ( @xmath125 ) , is due to the uncertainties in the bp00 predictions of the cno neutrino fluxes , the fourth error , ( @xmath126 ) , contains the uncertainty in the sno cc experimental rate and the calculated absorption cross sections on deuterium . the uncertainty in the bp00 prediction for the @xmath8be neutrino flux contributes the last error , ( @xmath127 ) , in eq . ( [ eq : fbbestlmabe7 ] ) . within the @xmath2 allowed lma region , we find the central value of @xmath104 varies in the range @xmath128 ; the best - fit value of @xmath104 can be determined with an average uncertainty of @xmath129% . we can summarize the determination of @xmath104 as follows : @xmath130 where the first error is the uncertainty due to the neutrino oscillation parameters and the second error contains the uncertainties from all other sources . in this subsection , we show how the uncertainty in @xmath104 could be improved by using the kamland data to determine the neutrino oscillation parameters and the borexino data , together with the kamland oscillation parameters , to constrain @xmath131 . we start with eq . ( [ eq : fpp ] ) but now use @xmath56 as determined from borexino and kamland data [ eq . ( [ eq : fborexino ] ) ] . we find that for the best - fit lma solution ( assuming that borexino finds the rate expected for this best fit point ) , @xmath132 the first error shown in eq . ( [ eq : fppkamlandborexino ] ) , ( @xmath133 ) , is the experimental error on the measured gallium event rate , the second error , ( @xmath124 ) , represents the uncertainties from the calculated gallium cross sections . the third error , @xmath134 , is from the predicted cno fluxes and the fourth error , ( @xmath126 ) , contains the uncertainties from the sno experimental data and calculated deuterium absorption cross sections . the range of oscillation parameters within the kamland reconstructed region gives the fifth error , ( @xmath135 ) , and the sixth error , ( @xmath136 [ @xmath137 ) , results from the uncertainty in the measured borexino event rate [ which we take to be 5% ( 10% ) ] . the unknown active - sterile admixture ( which goes in the direction of lowering @xmath104 ) contributes the last error shown in eq . ( [ eq : fppkamlandborexino ] ) . on average , the the precision expected using the gallium , kamland , and sno experiments is @xmath138 . \label{eq : avfppborexinokamland}\ ] ] the dominant sources of error in eq . ( [ eq : avfppborexinokamland ] ) are the experimental error in the gallium rate and the uncertainties in the calculated gallium absorption cross section . in this section , we review and discuss our principal conclusions . we begin in sec . [ subsec : discusscurrentlyallowed ] by summarizing the experimentally - allowed range that currently exists for the total @xmath0b solar neutrino flux , taking account of the possibility that sterile neutrinos exist . we then summarize in sec . [ subsec : discussb8 ] how well the total @xmath0b neutrino flux , and separately the sterile @xmath0b neutrino flux , can be obtained by combining kamland and sno measurements . next we describe in sec . [ subsec : discussbe7 ] how well the total @xmath8be flux can be determined using data from the kamland , gallium ( gallex , sage , and gno ) , and sno experiments , i.e. , using only cc disappearance experiments . in this same subsection , we summarize the measurement accuracy that can be obtained using data from just the kamland and the borexino ( @xmath39 scattering ) experiments . we describe three strategies ( making use of existing and future solar neutrino measurements and guidance from the bp00 solar model ) for determining the @xmath10 solar neutrino flux without the help of an experiment that measures separately the @xmath10 neutrinos . we point out in sec . [ subsec : discusscrosssections ] ( and in the appendix ) that in order to determine the total @xmath0b or @xmath8be neutrino flux , and _ a fortiori _ to determine the sterile contributions to these fluxes , the correlations among theoretical errors for neutrino absorption cross sections and for solar neutrino fluxes must be treated more accurately than in previous discussions . section [ subsec : discussfocus ] summarizes the main focus of the present paper . we concentrate on procedures to determine experimentally the total solar @xmath0b neutrino flux and the total solar @xmath8be neutrino flux in a universe in which sterile neutrinos might exist . our methods can work only if the lma solution of the solar neutrino problem is correct . the numerical values given here for the precision with which different quantities can be determined are obtained using simulations of how well different experiments may perform . therefore , the numerical values are intended only as illustrative guides to what may be possible . the combined sno cc data and the super - kamiokande @xmath83 scattering data together yield a widely acclaimed agreement between the @xmath0b solar neutrino flux that is predicted by the standard solar model and the empirically inferred @xmath0b neutrino flux . however , this agreement between solar model prediction and solar neutrino measurement is not a unique interpretation of the existing measurements if one allows for the possibility that the incident solar neutrino flux could contain a significant component of sterile neutrinos . we show in table [ tab : fbranges ] and in sec . [ sec : presentknowledge ] that if one takes account of the possibility that sterile neutrinos may exist then the total solar @xmath0b neutrino flux could be as large as @xmath139 times the flux predicted by the standard solar model . in principle , the existing solar neutrino data could be inconsistent with the standard solar model predictions . the total @xmath0b solar neutrino flux , active plus sterile neutrinos , can be determined with a typical @xmath2 accuracy of about @xmath4% by comparing the charged current measurements from the kamland reactor experiment and the sno experiments ( see sec . [ sec : determiningb8total ] ) . the active @xmath0b neutrino flux has been measured by comparing the sno cc flux ( which measures @xmath40 ) with the super - kamiokande neutrino - electron scattering rate ( which measures @xmath40 plus , with less sensitivity , @xmath140 ) . the sno neutral current measurement will provide an additional and , ultimately , more accurate measurement of the total active @xmath0b solar neutrino flux . by subtracting the independently - measured active @xmath0b neutrino flux from the total ( active plus sterile ) @xmath0b neutrino flux , one can determine empirically the sterile component of the solar neutrino flux . the active @xmath0b neutrino flux will eventually be determined accurately by the sno neutral current measurement @xcite . we estimate therefore that the procedure described here has the potential of measuring , or setting an upper limit on , the sterile component of the @xmath0b neutrino flux that is as small as @xmath141% of the total @xmath0b solar neutrino flux . the measurement of the total @xmath0b neutrino flux , and the sterile component of this flux , are independent of solar model considerations . in order to establish the quantitative conclusions , we have performed detailed simulations of the accuracy of the kamland reactor experiment in determining neutrino oscillation parameters ( see fig . [ fig : solarvskamlandreal ] ) and have evaluated the theoretical and experimental uncertainties that affect the different flux determinations ( see sec . [ subsec : precisionb8 ] and the appendix ) . the combined measurements of the super - kamiokande and kamland experiments can be used to determine independently a value for the total @xmath0b neutrino flux . this determination may be as accurate as @xmath6% for purely active neutrinos . with the current limits on the active - sterile admixture , the total @xmath0b neutrino flux could be inferred to an accuracy of @xmath7% or better , as described in sec . [ subsec : kamlandsuperkb8 ] . it will be important to compare the value of the total @xmath0b neutrino flux inferred by combining the kamland and sno charged current measurements with the value obtained using the kamland and super - kamiokande experiments . this comparison will be an important test of whether the systematic uncertainties in the experiment and in the analyses are understood . the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux , active plus sterile neutrinos , can be determined to a @xmath2 accuracy of about @xmath142% by combining measurements from kamland , sno , and the gallium experiments ( see sec . [ sec : be7 ] ) . unlike the purely empirical determination that is possible for the @xmath0b flux , the measurement of the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux requires some assumption regarding the cno solar neutrino fluxes . in our estimates , we have assumed that the standard solar model predictions for the cno fluxes , and their uncertainties , are at least approximately valid . table [ tab : fbe ] shows that as long as the cno fluxes are not a factor of three or more larger than the standard solar model predictions , then they will not significantly limit the accuracy with which the total @xmath8be neutrino flux can be determined . the measured capture rate in the gallium experiments ( gallex , sage , and gno ) currently constitutes the largest recognized uncertainty in the determination of the total @xmath8be flux by the method described here ( see table [ tab : fbe ] ) . the constraints provided by the chlorine experiment are not very useful in providing an accurate determination of the @xmath8be neutrino flux [ see table [ tab : fbecl ] and eq . ( [ eq : averagebe7shiftcl ] ) ] . one can also determine the allowed range of the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux using the data from the kamland reactor experiment and the borexino solar neutrino experiment . we show in sec . [ subsec : kamlandborexino ] that with this method one may hope to obtain a @xmath2 accuracy of @xmath1% or better for the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux , which is more accurate than we estimate will be possible with the gallium and chlorine radiochemical experiments . one can determine an upper limit to the sterile component of the @xmath8be solar neutrino flux by combining the measured rate in the neutrino - electron scattering experiment , borexino , with the @xmath8be total flux inferred from measurements of the kamland , sno , and gallium experiments . if one assumes that the entire signal measured in borexino is due to @xmath40 , then one obtains a minimum value for the active component of the @xmath8be neutrino flux . subtracting this minimum value from the total @xmath8be flux , one will obtain an upper limit to the sterile component of the flux . it seems unlikely that the procedure described here has the sensitivity to measure a value for the sterile component unless the sterile flux is larger than @xmath142% of the total @xmath8be neutrino flux . however , limits on the sterile neutrino admixture can be obtained from the analysis of @xmath0b and kamland neutrino measurements described in sec . [ subsec : discussb8 ] . in order to make a direct and precise measurement of the sterile component of the @xmath8be solar neutrino flux , we need a charged current measurement of the @xmath8be flux . a @xmath8be solar neutrino absorption experiment , e.g. , with a lithium target @xcite or with lens @xcite , would make possible an accurate determination of the sterile @xmath8be neutrino flux by providing a set of experimental constraints that is analogous to what will exist for the sno , super - kamiokande , and kamland experiments . the theoretical uncertainty in the calculated @xmath10 solar neutrino flux is estimated to be only @xmath143 @xcite . therefore , a precise determination of the @xmath10 solar neutrino flux will be of great interest as a crucial test of the theory of stellar evolution . the measurement of the @xmath10 neutrino flux will also provide a critical test of whether the neutrino oscillation theory , which works well at energies above @xmath95 mev , also describes accurately the lower energy neutrino phenomena ( energies less than @xmath144 mev ) . we show in sec . [ sec : determiningpp ] that the @xmath10 flux can be determined with modest accuracy , of order @xmath145% to @xmath146% , using a combination of existing experimental data and some guidance from the bp00 standard solar model . in the future , it should be possible to determine the @xmath10 neutrino flux to an accuracy of @xmath11% using experimental data from the borexino , kamland , and sno solar neutrino experiments and predictions ( in a non - critical way ) from the standard solar model ( see eq . [ eq : avfppborexinokamland ] ) . the unknown flux of sterile neutrinos does not significantly affect the quoted estimates on the accuracy with which the @xmath10 flux can be determined . to measure the @xmath10 flux with an accuracy sufficient to test stringently the standard solar model prediction will require a dedicated and accurate experiment that measures separately the @xmath10 neutrino flux . in order to determine the total @xmath0b or @xmath8be solar neutrino flux , and their sterile components , one must evaluate carefully all known sources of error . in the course of this investigation , we realized that the evaluations of the neutrino absorption cross section uncertainties in previous neutrino oscillation studies , including our own , have not properly taken account of the correlations among the theoretical uncertainties in the cross section calculations ( for an insightful discussion of this point , see ref . we discuss in the appendix how the cross section errors can be treated more correctly . we also emphasize here that it is necessary to treat as fully correlated the uncertainties in the principal cno neutrino fluxes that are obtained from standard solar model predictions . these effects are small compared to other uncertainties in determining solar neutrino oscillation parameters ( the principal goal of nearly all previous oscillation studies ) . the correlations among cross section uncertainties become important only when one wants to make accurate inferences regarding the neutrino fluxes themselves . the main focus in this paper is on determining experimentally the total @xmath0b , @xmath8be , and @xmath10 solar neutrino fluxes in order to make possible more precise tests of solar model predictions . we have also shown that the contribution of sterile neutrinos to the total flux can be measured , or a useful upper limit can be set , for @xmath0b solar neutrinos and for @xmath8be solar neutrinos . jnb acknowledges support from nsf grant no . mcg - g is supported by the european union marie - curie fellowship hpmf - ct-2000 - 00516 . this work was also supported by the spanish dgicyt under grants pb98 - 0693 and fpa2001 - 3031 . we determine , as is conventional for many analyses of solar neutrino data , the allowed regions in the neutrino oscillation space using a @xmath147 function that includes all the relevant data . in the construction of the @xmath147 function , we have followed closely the prescription of ref . @xcite ( see also ref . @xcite ) , but we have included some modifications to this prescription in order to account in more detail for the energy dependence and the correlation of the cross section errors for the chlorine and gallium solar neutrino experiments . for a given experiment @xmath148 ( for example , gallium or chlorine ) , the expected number of events can be written as @xmath149 where @xmath150 labels the solar neutrino fluxes , @xmath89 , and @xmath151 labels the energy bins of energy @xmath152 . the quantity @xmath153 is the cross section for the interaction of a neutrino of energy @xmath152 in the experiment @xmath148 ; @xmath154 is the survival probability of @xmath40 for a given energy @xmath152 at a specified point , @xmath155 , in neutrino oscillation space , because different neutrino species have different probability distributions for the location of their production within the sun . for matter oscillations , the survival probability obviously depends upon where in the sun the neutrino was produced . ] . the error matrix for the neutrino absorption cross sections can be derived using eq . ( [ eqapp : rate ] ) . since the errors are uncorrelated between different experiments , we need to evaluate the following expression for a specified experiment : @xmath156 where @xmath157 is best - estimate for the ( gallium or chlorine ) experimental capture rate and the brackets indicate an average over the probability distribution of uncertainties in the neutrino cross sections . writing out the various terms in eq . ( [ appeq : defnsigma ] ) , we find @xmath158 in the standard ref . @xcite , the cross section error matrix for each experiment is given as : @xmath159 where @xmath160 is the average uncertainty in the interaction cross section of neutrinos of flux type @xmath107 in experiment @xmath148 . equation ( [ sigma2 ] ) is obtained from eq . ( [ eqapp : rate ] ) by neglecting the correlations of the cross section errors among the different neutrino fluxes and by neglecting the energy dependence of the cross section errors . for the gallium detector , neither of these assumptions is correct and even for chlorine the cross section errors for different neutrino sources are strongly correlated . for all but the @xmath0b and @xmath105 neutrino fluxes , either ground state to ground state transitions are the only energetically possible transitions ( which is the case for the chlorine detector ) or the ground state to ground state transitions dominate ( which is the case for the gallium detector ) . thus all the cross sections for the lower energy neutrinos move up or down together , proportional to the square of the dominant matrix element . when considering the gallium experiments , we include the energy dependence of the cross section errors and assume full correlations among the cross section errors of the different neutrino sources that contribute at a specific energy . specifically , we use the results from ref . @xcite for the cross section errors . for continuum sources , we take the fractional error of the interaction cross section in the energy bin @xmath151 to be @xmath161,\ ] ] where @xmath162 are the 3@xmath76 upper and lower limit cross sections given in tables iii and iv of ref . @xcite . for the line sources , @xmath8be and @xmath38 , we use the errors given in eqs . ( 41 ) and ( 42 ) of ref . @xcite . to be complete , we have checked that the shapes of these neutrino lines ( see ref . @xcite ) do not affect significantly the error estimates . the gallium contribution to the cross section error matrix is therefore given by @xmath163 where @xmath164 is the correlation matrix for the cross section errors of the different energy bins . for low energy neutrino sources , the dominant process is the transition to the germanium ground state and for higher energy neutrino sources ( @xmath165 mev ) transitions to excited states dominate . therefore , we assume the cross section errors to be fully correlated between energy bins either below or above @xmath166 mev ( @xmath167 for @xmath168 mev or @xmath169 mev ) . we take the errors to be uncorrelated between one energy bin below @xmath170 mev and one energy bin above @xmath166 mev ( @xmath171 for @xmath172 mev and @xmath173 mev , or @xmath172 mev and @xmath173 mev ) . for chlorine , we take as fully correlated the cross section errors for the @xmath10 , @xmath38 , @xmath8be , and cno neutrinos . the cross section errors for the @xmath0b and @xmath105 neutrinos are uncorrelated with the errors for the lower energy neutrinos but are fully correlated with each other . we can neglect for chlorine the energy dependence of the chlorine to argon cross section errors because the uncertainty for the lower energy neutrinos is determined almost entirely from the ground - state to ground - state matrix element . ( forbidden corrections are unimportant for these low energy neutrinos . ) for the @xmath0b and @xmath105 neutrinos , the absorption cross sections are also dominated by a single ( but different ) transition , in this case the super - allowed transition @xcite , and therefore we can also neglect the energy dependence for the higher energy neutrinos . we adopt the values of the averaged chlorine cross section errors given in refs . @xcite . to be explicit , the chlorine contribution to the cross section error matrix is given by @xmath174 where @xmath175 for @xmath176 or @xmath177 . also , @xmath178 for @xmath179 and @xmath180 . 99 q. r. ahmad _ et al . _ , sno collaboration , nucl - ex/0204008 . q. r. ahmad _ et al . _ , sno collaboration , nucl - ex/0204009 . j. n. abdurashitov _ et al . _ , sage collaboration , astro - ph/0204245 . q. r. ahmad _ et al . _ , sno collaboration , phys . lett . * 87 * , 071301 ( 2001 ) . s. fukuda _ et al . _ , super - kamiokande collaboration , phys.rev . lett . * 86 * , 5651 ( 2001 ) . g. l. fogli , e. lisi , d. montanino , and a. palazzo , phys . d * 64 * , 093007 ( 2001 ) . c. giunti , phys . d * 65 * , 033006 ( 2002 ) ; m. v. garzelli and c. giunti , phys . d * 65 * , 093005 ( 2002 ) . g. fiorentini , f. l. villante , and b. ricci , hep - ph/0109275 . j. n. bahcall , phys . c. * 65 * , 015802 ( 2002 ) . j. n. bahcall , phys . * 12 * , 300 ( 1964 ) ; r. davis jr . * 12 * , 303 ( 1964 ) ; j. n. bahcall and r. davis , science * 191 * , 264 ( 1976 ) . j. n. bahcall , m. h. pinsonneault , and s. basu , astrophys . j. * 555 * , 990 ( 2001 ) . b. t. cleveland , t. daily , r. davis , jr . , j. r. distel , k. lande , c. k. lee , and p. s. wildenhain , astrophys . j. * 496 * , 505 ( 1998 ) . y. fukuda _ _ , kamiokande collaboration , phys . lett . * 77 * , 1683 ( 1996 ) . j. n. abdurashitov _ et al . _ , sage collaboration , phys . c * 60 * , 055801 ( 1999 ) . w. hampel _ et al . _ , gallex collaboration , phys . b * 447 * , 127 ( 1999 ) . e. belloti , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) * 91 * , 44 ( 2001 ) . ( ` http://nu2000.sno.laurentian.ca ` ) . j. n. bahcall , s. basu , and m. pinsonneault , phys . b * 433 * , 1 ( 1998 ) . w. kwong and s. p. rosen , phys . d * 54 * , 2043 ( 1996 ) . f. l. villante , g. fiorentini , and e. lisi , phys . d * 59 * , 013006 ( 1999 ) . j. n. bahcall , m. c. gonzalez - garcia , and c. pena - garay , j. high energy phys . * 08 * , 014 ( 2001 ) . p. i. krastev and a. y. smirnov , phys . d * 65 * , 073022 ( 2002 ) . j. n. bahcall , m. c. gonzalez - garcia , and c. pena - garay , j. high energy phys . * 04 * , 007 ( 2002 ) . a. r. junghans , e. c. mohrmann , k. a. snover , t. d. steiger , e. g. adelberger , j. m. casandjian , h. e. swanson , l. buchmann , s. h. park , and a. zyuzin , phys . * 88 * , 041101 ( 2002 ) . s. m. bilenky , c. giunti , and w. grimus , prog . * 43 * , 1 ( 1999 ) . m. c. gonzalez - garcia and y. nir , hep - ph/0202058 . v. barger , d. marfatia , and k. whisnant , phys . lett . * 88 * , 011302 ( 2002 ) ; v. barger , d. marfatia , and k. whisnant , phys . b * 509 * , 19 ( 2001 ) . d. dooling , c. giunti , k. kang , and c. w. kim , phys . d * 61 * , 073011 ( 2000 ) . c. giunti , m. c. gonzalez - garcia , and c. pena - garay , phys . d * 62 * , 013005 ( 2000 ) . j. aguilar _ et al . _ , lsnd collaboration , phys . rev . d * 64 * , 112007 ( 2001 ) . k. eitel , karmen collaboration , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) * 91 * , 191 ( 2001 ) . a. piepke , kamland collaboration , nucl . b ( proc . suppl . ) * 91 * , 99 ( 2001 ) ; j. busenitz _ et al . , _ , kamland collaboration , `` proposal for us participation in kamland , '' march 1999 ( unpublished ) . may be downloaded from:`http://kamland.lbl.gov/ ` ; k. ishihara for the kamland collaboration , talk at the nufact01 workshop in tsukuba , japan ( may 2430 , 2001 ) . transparencies at:`http://psux1.kek.jp/~nufact01/index.html ` . a. bandyopadhyay , s. choubey , s. goswami , and k. kar , phys . b * 519 * , 83 ( 2001 ) . v. barger , d. marfatia , and b. p. wood , phys . b * 498 * , 53 ( 2001 ) . r. barbieri and a. strumia , j. high energy phys . * 12 * , 016 ( 2000 ) . h. murayama and a. pierce , phys . d * 65 * , 013012 ( 2002 ) . j. n. bahcall , m. c. gonzalez - garcia , and c. pena - garay , hep - ph/0204314 . m. smy , proceedings of the noon2001 workshop , kashiwa , japan , december 5 - 8 , 2001 , hep - ex/0202020 a. de gouvea and c. pena - garay , phys . d * 64 * , 113011 ( 2001 ) . m. c. gonzalez - garcia and c. pena - garay , phys . b * 527 * , 199 ( 2002 ) . g. alimonti _ et al . _ , borexino collaboration , astropart . * 16 * , 205 ( 2002 ) ; a. piepke _ et al . _ , kamland collaboration , nucl . suppl . ) * 91 * , 99 ( 2001 ) . s. nakamura , t. sato , s. ando , t .- s . park , f. myhrer , v. gudkov , and k. kubodera , nucl - th/0201062 . see also , a. kurylov , m. j. ramsey - musolf , and p. vogel , phys . rev . c * 65 * , 055501 ( 2002 ) ; j. f. beacom and s. j. parke , phys . rev . d * 64 * , 091302 ( 2001 ) . m. butler , j .- w . chen , and x. kong , phys . c * 63 * , 035501 ( 2001 ) . r. davis jr . , d. s. harmer , and k. c. hoffman , phys . lett . * 20 * , 1205 ( 1968 ) . j. n. bahcall , phys . c * 56 * , 3391 ( 1997 ) . j. n. bahcall phys . lett . * 71 * , 2369 ( 1993 ) ; phys . d * 49 * , 3923 ( 1994 ) . j. n. bahcall and h. a. bethe , phys . lett . * 65 * , 2233 ( 1990 ) . j. n. bahcall , m. kamionkowski , and a. sirlin , phys . d * 51 * , 6146 ( 1995 ) . j. n. bahcall , _ neutrino astrophysics _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , 1989 ) . j. n. bahcall and r. m. may , astrophys . j. * 155 * , 501 ( 1969 ) . j. n. bahcall , e. lisi , d. e. alburger , l. de braeckeleer , s. j. freedman , and j. napolitano , phys . c * 54 * , 411 ( 1996 ) . j. n. bahcall , p. i. krastev , and a. y. smirnov , phys . d * 62 * , 093004 ( 2000 ) . m. galeazzi , g. gallinaro , f. gatti , p. meunier , s. vitale , a. v. kopylov , v. v. petukhov , e. a. yanovich , and g. t. zatsepin , phys . b * 398 * , 187 ( 1997 ) ; a. kopylov and v. petukhov , hep - ph/0201042 . r. s. raghavan , phys . lett . * 78 * , 3618 ( 1997 ) ; r. s. raghavan , hep - ex/0106054 . m. v. garzelli and c. giunti , phys . b * 488 * , 339 ( 2000 ) . g. l. fogli and e. lisi , astropart . phys . * 3 * , 185 ( 1995 ) with updated uncertainties as discussed in g. l. fogli , e. lisi , d. montanino , and a. palazzo , phys . d * 62 * , 013002 ( 2000 ) . j. n. bahcall , phys . c * 56 * , 3391 ( 1997 ) .
Abstract: | [
"the @xmath0b solar neutrino flux inferred from a global analysis of solar neutrino experiments is within @xmath1% ( @xmath2 ) of the predicted standard solar model value if only active neutrinos exist , but could be as large as @xmath3 times the standard prediction if sterile neutrinos exist . we show that the total @xmath0b neutrino flux ( active plus sterile neutrinos ) can be determined experimentally to about @xmath4% ( @xmath2 ) by combining charged current measurements made with the kamland reactor experiment and with the sno cc solar neutrino experiment , provided the lma neutrino oscillation solution is correct and the simulated performance of kamland is valid . including also sno nc data , the sterile component of the @xmath0b neutrino flux can be measured by this method to an accuracy of about @xmath5% ( @xmath2 ) of the standard solar model flux . combining super - kamiokande and kamland measurements and assuming the oscillations occur only among active neutrinos , the @xmath0b neutrino flux can be measured to @xmath6% ( @xmath2 ) ; the total flux can be measured to an accuracy of about @xmath7% . the total @xmath8be solar neutrino flux can be determined to an accuracy of about @xmath9% ( @xmath2 ) by combining measurements made with the kamland , sno , and gallium neutrino experiments . one can determine the total @xmath8be neutrino flux to a @xmath2 accuracy of about @xmath1% or better by comparing data from the kamland experiment and the borexino solar neutrino experiment provided both detectors work as expected . the @xmath10 neutrino flux can be determined to about @xmath11% using data from the gallium , kamland , borexino , and sno experiments ."
] | 11,503 | 11,503 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: meson - antimeson mixing has traditionally been of importance because it is sensitive to heavy degrees of freedom that propagate in the underlying mixing amplitudes . estimates of the charm quark and top quark mass scales were inferred from the observation of mixing in the @xmath4 and @xmath5 systems , respectively , before these particles were discovered directly . this success has motivated attempts to indirectly detect new physics ( np ) signals by comparing the observed meson mixing with predictions of the standard model ( sm ) . mixing in the kaon sector has historically placed stringent constraints on the parameter space of theories beyond the sm and provides an essential hurdle that must be passed in the construction of models with np . however , anticipated breakthroughs from the b - factories and the tevatron collider have not been borne out the large mixing signal in the @xmath5 and @xmath6 systems is successfully described in terms of the sm alone ( although the parameter spaces of various np models have become increasingly constrained ) . short of awaiting lhcb and the construction of a super - b facility , there is one remaining example for possibly observing indirect signs of np in meson mixing , the @xmath1 flavor oscillations . in this case , the sm mixing rate is sufficiently small that the np component might be able to compete @xcite . there has been a flurry of recent experimental activity regarding the detection of @xmath1-@xmath7 mixing @xcite , which marks the first time flavor changing neutral currents ( fcnc ) have been observed in the charged @xmath8 quark sector . with the potential window to discern large np effects in the charm sector @xcite and the anticipated improved accuracy for future mixing measurements , the motivation for a comprehensive up - to - date theoretical analysis of new physics contributions to @xmath3 meson mixing is compelling . the heightened interest in @xmath1-@xmath7 mixing started with the almost simultaneous observations by the babar @xcite and belle @xcite collaborations of nonzero mixing signals at about the per cent level , , @xmath9 , @xmath10 and @xmath11 are standard and are given in eqs . ( [ xy]),([y - defs ] ) . ] & & y_d = ( 0.97 0.44 0.31 ) 10 ^ -2 , + & & y_d^(cp ) = ( 1.31 0.32 0.25)10 ^ -2 . this was soon followed by the announcement by the belle collaboration of mixing measurements from the dalitz plot analyses of @xmath12 @xcite , x_d = ( 0.80 0.29 0.17)10 ^ -2 , y_d = ( 0.33 0.24 0.15)10 ^ -2 . a preliminary fit to the current database , @xmath13 . these are essentially unchanged from the hfag preliminary results given above and used in our analysis ; the difference will not affect our numerical results . ] by the heavy flavor averaging group ( hfag ) gives @xcite [ hfag ] & & x_d = 8.7^+3.0_-3.4 10 ^ -3 , y_d = ( 6.62.1 ) 10 ^ -3 . since this paper addresses the issue of the mass splitting induced by mixing , our primary concern is with the signal for @xmath14 , seen here to be a 2.4 sigma effect . this is below the generally accepted threshold for `` evidence '' and is more in the nature of a `` hint '' . however , we note that a 2.4 sigma effect will automatically have a non - zero lower bound at @xmath15 confidence - level . for the sake of reference , we cite the one - sigma window for the hfag value of @xmath14 , 5.4 10 ^ -3 < x_d < 11.7 10 ^ -3 , [ xbnds ] or equivalently for @xmath16 itself , 8.7 10 ^ -15 < m_d < 1.9 10 ^ -14 . [ mbnds ] let us briefly describe our strategy for dealing with the above hfag values in light of both sm and np contributions . we shall argue in sect . iii that the sm predictions , although indeed compatible with the observed range of values for the @xmath3 mixing parameters , contain significant hadronic uncertainties . moreover , we do not know the relative _ phase _ between the sm contribution and that from any np model , so that @xmath14 will lie between the extreme limiting cases of constructive and destructive interference . in addition , since the observation of @xmath3 mixing is new , the measurements will fluctuate with future refinements in the analyses and as more data is collected . to best deal with these realities , we will present our results by displaying a given np prediction as a pure np signal ( _ i.e. _ as if there were no sm component ) and for comparison , display curves of constant @xmath14 for the five values x_d = 15.0 10 ^ -3 , 11.7 10 ^ -3 , 8.0 10 ^ -3 , 5.0 10 ^ -3 , 3.0 10 ^ -3 . [ xrange ] this ( approximately hfag 2@xmath17 ) range reveals the sensitivity of @xmath14 to variations in the underlying np parameter space . we will then show the present constraints placed on the np model parameter space , by assuming that the np contribution can not exceed the @xmath18 upper bound on @xmath19 this procedure mirrors that which is traditionally employed in obtaining bounds on np from @xmath4-@xmath20 mixing . @xmath1-@xmath7 mixing at the observed level is much larger than the quark - level ( ` short - distance ' ) sm prediction @xcite but is in qualitative accord with hadron - level ( ` long - distance ' ) sm expectations . however , because the latter are beset with hadronic uncertainties , it can not be rigorously concluded that only sm physics is being detected . in this paper , we will consider a broad menu of np possibilities . as the operation of the lhc looms near , the number of potentially viable np models has never been greater . our organizational approach to analyzing these is to address np models with : 1 . extra fermions ( sect . iv ) a : fourth generation b : heavy vector - like quarks ( 1 ) : @xmath21 singlet quarks ( 2 ) : @xmath22 singlet quarks c : little higgs models 2 . extra gauge bosons ( sect . v ) a : generic z models b : family symmetries c : left - right symmetric model d : alternate left - right models from e@xmath23 theories e : vector leptoquark bosons 3 . extra scalars ( sect . vi ) a : flavor conserving two - higgs - doublet models b : flavor changing neutral higgs models c : scalar leptoquark bosons d : higgsless models 4 . extra space dimensions ( sect . vii ) a : universal extra dimensions b : split fermion models c : warped geometries 5 . extra symmetries ( sect . viii ) a : minimal supersymmetric standard model b : quark - squark alignment models c : supersymmetry with r - parity violation d : split supersymmetry in the above , we have chosen to consider only supersymmetry in sect . viii due to its extensive literature and to cover other extended symmetries elsewhere in the paper . any np degree of freedom will generally be associated with a generic heavy mass scale @xmath24 , at which the np interaction will be most naturally described . at the scale @xmath25 of the charm mass , this description will have been modified by the effects of qcd . these should not be neglected , so we perform our np analyses at one - loop level for the strong interactions . the theoretical background for this is presented in sect . finally , in order to place the np discussion within its proper context , it makes sense to first review sm charm mixing . this is done in sect . the remainder of the paper then amounts to considering charm mixing with lots of ` extras ' . the paper concludes in sect . ix with a summary of our findings . let us first review some formal aspects of charm mixing . the mixing arises from @xmath26 interactions that generate off - diagonal terms in the mass matrix for @xmath1 and @xmath27 mesons . the expansion of the off - diagonal terms in the neutral @xmath3 mass matrix to second order in the weak interaction is [ m12 ] ( m - ) _ 21 = 0bar | h_w^|c|=2 | d^0 + _ n 0bar | h_w^|c|=1 | n n | h_w^|c|=1 | d^0 m_d - e_n+i , where @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the effective @xmath26 and @xmath30 hamiltonians . the off - diagonal mass - matrix terms induce mass eigenstates @xmath31 and @xmath32 that are superpositions of the flavor eigenstates @xmath1 and @xmath27 , @xmath33 where @xmath34 . the key quantities in @xmath1 mixing are the mass and width differences , @xmath35 or equivalently their dimensionless equivalents , x_d , y_d , [ xy ] where @xmath36 is the average width of the two neutral @xmath3 meson mass eigenstates . two quantities , @xmath11 and @xmath37 , which are actually measured in most experimental determinations of @xmath38 , are defined as y_d^(cp ) & & ( _ + - _ -)/ ( _ + + _ - ) = y_d - x_d(-a_prod ) , + y_d & & y_d _ k - x_d _ k , [ y - defs ] where the transition rates @xmath39 pertain to decay into final states of definite cp , @xmath40 is the so - called production asymmetry of @xmath1 and @xmath41 ( giving the relative weight of @xmath1 and @xmath2 in the sample ) and @xmath42 is the strong phase difference between the cabibbo favored and double cabibbo suppressed amplitudes @xcite . the quantities @xmath43 and @xmath44 account for the presence of cp violation in @xmath1-@xmath7 mixing , with @xmath43 being related to the @xmath45 parameters of eq . ( [ definition1 ] ) as @xmath46 and @xmath44 a cp - violating phase of @xmath47 ( if one neglects direct cp - violation ) @xcite . in practice , @xmath48 is measured by comparing decays of @xmath1 into a state of definite cp , such as @xmath49 , to decays of @xmath1 into a final state which is not a cp - eigenstate ( such as @xmath50 ) whereas @xmath51 is extracted from a time - dependent analysis of the @xmath52 transition @xcite . the states @xmath53 allow for effects of cp violation . however , cp violation in @xmath1 mixing is negligible in the standard model and there is no evidence for it experimentally @xcite . many new physics scenarios contain new phases which can induce sizable cp violation in the @xmath3 meson sector . nonetheless , a thorough investigation of such effects is beyond the scope of the present paper . therefore , we shall work in the limit of cp invariance ( so that @xmath54 ) for the remainder of this paper . throughout , our phase convention will be @xmath55 then @xmath56 become the cp eigenstates @xmath57 with @xmath58 . keeping in mind the neglect of cp - violation and also the phase convention of eq . ( [ phase ] ) , we relate the mixing quantities @xmath14 and @xmath9 to the mixing matrix as @xmath59 \ \ , \nonumber \\ & & y_{\rm d } = \frac{1}{2 m_{\rm d}\gamma_{\rm d}}\ , { \rm im}\ , \langle \d0bar | \,i\ { \rm d}^4 x\ , t \big\ { { \cal h}^{|\delta c|=1}_w ( x)\ , { \cal h}^{|\delta c|=1}_w(0 ) \big\ } | d^0 \rangle \ \ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath60 is the weak hamiltonian density for @xmath30 transitions and @xmath61 denotes the time - ordered product . there is no contribution to @xmath9 from the local @xmath26 term , as it has no absorptive part . new physics contributions to @xmath9 have already been addressed in ref . @xcite , so the primary thrust of this paper will be to focus on @xmath14 . the next step , in sect . ii , is to expand the time - ordered product of eq . ( [ ope ] ) in local operators of increasing dimension ( higher dimension operators being suppressed by powers of @xmath62 ) . though the particles present in models with new physics may not be produced in charm quark decays , their effects can nonetheless be seen in the form of effective operators generated by the exchanges of these new particles . even without specifying the form of these new interactions , we know that their effect is to introduce several @xmath26 effective operators built out of the sm degrees of freedom . by integrating out new degrees of freedom associated with new interactions at a scale @xmath24 , we are left with an effective hamiltonian written in the form of a series of operators of increasing dimension . operator power counting then tells us the most important contributions are given by the operators of the lowest possible dimension , @xmath63 in this case . this means that they must contain only quark degrees of freedom . realizing this , we can write the complete basis of these effective operators , which can be done most conveniently in terms of chiral quark fields , [ seriesofoperators ] f | h_np | i = g _ i=1 c_i ( ) f | q_i | i ( ) , where the prefactor @xmath64 has the dimension of inverse - squared mass , the @xmath65 are dimensionless wilson coefficients , operators as @xmath66 and those for @xmath67 operators as @xmath68 . ] and the @xmath69 are the effective operators : l q_1 = ( _ l _ c_l ) ( _ l ^c_l ) , + q_2 = ( _ l _ c_l ) ( _ r ^c_r ) , + q_3 = ( _ l c_r ) ( _ r c_l ) , + q_4 = ( _ r c_l ) ( _ r c_l ) , l q_5 = ( _ r _ c_l ) ( _ r ^ c_l ) , + q_6 = ( _ r _ c_r ) ( _ r ^c_r ) , + q_7 = ( _ l c_r ) ( _ l c_r ) , + q_8 = ( _ l _ c_r ) ( _ l ^ c_r ) . [ setofoperators ] in total , there are eight possible operator structures that exhaust the list of possible independent contributions to @xmath26 transitions . since these operators are generated at the scale @xmath24 where the new physics is integrated out , a non - trivial operator mixing can occur when we take into account renormalization group running of these operators between the scales @xmath24 and @xmath70 , with @xmath70 being the scale where the hadronic matrix elements are computed . we shall work at the renormalization scale @xmath71 gev . this evolution is determined by solving the rg equations obeyed by the wilson coefficients , [ anomeq ] c ( ) = ^t c ( ) , where @xmath72 represents the matrix of anomalous dimensions of the operators in eq . ( [ setofoperators ] ) ( note the transposition ) . ( [ anomeq ] ) can be solved by transforming to the basis where the transpose of the anomalous dimension matrix is diagonal , integrating , and then transferring back to the original basis @xmath73 . at leading order , we have c ( ) = u ( , m ) c(m ) , where @xmath74 is the evolution matrix , obtained from eq . ( [ anomeq ] ) by u ( _ 1,_2 ) = v _ d v^-1 . in the above , @xmath75 is the vector containing the diagonal elements of the diagonalized transposed matrix of the anomalous dimensions @xmath76 , @xmath77 is the matrix that diagonalizes @xmath78 and r(_1,_2 ) . for completeness , we display the matrix of anomalous dimensions at leading - order ( lo ) in qcd @xcite , = ( c c c c c c c c 6- & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & & 12 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & 0 & -6 n_c+ & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & 0 & 0 & 6 - 6 n_c+ & - & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & 0 & 0 & -24- & 6 + 2 n_c - & 0 & 0 & 0 + 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 6- & 0 & 0 + 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 6 - 6 n_c+ & - + 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & 0 & -24- & 6 + 2 n_c - + ) we note that ref . @xcite also includes the next - to - leading order ( nlo ) expressions for the elements in the anomalous dimensions matrix . however , we perform our calculations at lo here since the nlo corrections to the matching conditions in the various models of new physics have generally not been computed . due to the relatively simple structure of @xmath79 , one can easily write the evolution of each wilson coefficient in eq . ( [ seriesofoperators ] ) from the new physics scale @xmath80 down to the hadronic scale @xmath70 , taking into account quark thresholds . corresponding to each of the eight operators @xmath81 ( @xmath82 ) is an rg factor @xmath83 . the first of these , @xmath84 , is given explicitly by r_1(,m)&= & ( ) ^2/7 ( ) ^6/23 ( ) ^6/25 . [ wilson ] and the rest can be expressed in terms of @xmath84 as l r_2(,m ) = [ r_1(,m)]^1/2 , + r_3(,m ) = [ r_1(,m)]^-4 , + r_4(,m ) = [ r_1(,m)]^(1 + ) /6 , + r_5(,m ) = [ r_1(,m)]^(1 - ) /6 , l + r_6(,m ) = r_1(,m ) , + r_7(,m ) = r_4(,m ) , + r_8(,m ) = r_5(,m ) . the rg factors are generally only weakly dependent on the np scale @xmath24 since it is taken to be larger than the top quark mass , @xmath85 , and the evolution of @xmath86 is slow at these high mass scales . in table [ tab : lo ] , we display numerical values for the @xmath83 with @xmath87 tev and @xmath88 gev . here , we compute @xmath86 using the one - loop evolution and matching expressions for perturbative consistency with the rg evolution of the effective hamiltonian . c||c|c|c|c|c @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 + @xmath95 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 + @xmath101 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 & @xmath106 + .05 in we will need to evaluate the @xmath1-to-@xmath7 matrix elements of the eight dimension - six basis operators . in general , this implies eight non - perturbative parameters that would have to be evaluated by means of qcd sum rules or on the lattice . we choose those parameters ( denoted by @xmath107 ) as follows , @xmath108 where latexmath:[$\langle q_i \rangle \equiv \langle { \bar d}^0 @xmath3 meson decay constant . by and large , the compensatory @xmath110-factors @xmath111 are unknown , except in vacuum saturation and in the heavy quark limit ; there , one has @xmath112 . since most of the matrix elements in eq . ( [ me ] ) are not known , we will need something more manageable in order to obtain numerical results . the usual approach to computing matrix elements is to employ the vacuum saturation approximation . however , because some of the @xmath110-parameters are known , we would like to introduce a ` modified vacuum saturation ' ( mvs ) , where all matrix elements in eq . ( [ me ] ) are written in terms of ( known ) matrix elements of @xmath113 and @xmath114 matrix elements @xmath115 and @xmath116 , @xmath117 where we denote @xmath118 as the number of colors and , as in ref . @xcite , define [ bbar ] |b_d^(s ) b_d^(s ) as well as [ eta ] . in our numerical work , we take @xmath119 , which is the most recent result from the quenched lattice calculation @xcite , and use the cleo - c determination @xmath120 @xcite . we urge the lattice community to perform an evaluation of the @xmath121 parameters defined in eq . ( [ me ] ) for the full operator set relevant to @xmath3 meson mixing . theoretical predictions of @xmath14 and @xmath9 within the standard model span several orders of magnitude . roughly , there are two approaches , neither of which give very reliable results because @xmath25 is in some sense intermediate between the heavy - quark and light - quark limits . consider , for example , @xmath122 as given in eq . ( [ ope ] ) @xmath123 to utilize this relation , one inserts intermediate states between the @xmath124 weak hamiltonian densities @xmath125 . this can be done using either quark or hadron degrees of freedom . let us consider each of these possibilities in turn . the `` inclusive '' ( or quark - level ) approach is based on the operator product expansion ( ope ) . in the @xmath126 limit , where @xmath127 is a scale characteristic of the strong interactions , @xmath128 and @xmath129 can be expanded in terms of matrix elements of local operators @xcite of increasing dimensions suppressed by powers of inverse charm quark mass . . ] an instructive example concerns a recent analysis of the leading dimension @xmath130 case @xcite in which the width difference @xmath9 is calculated in terms of quarks ( _ cf _ fig . [ fig : loop ] ) and the mass difference @xmath14 is then found from dispersion relations . the calculation is carried out as an expansion in qcd , including leading - order @xmath131 and next - to - leading order @xmath132 contributions with @xmath133 here , lo and nlo denote only the corrections at that order and not the full quantity computed to that order . because @xmath134 , @xmath38 experiences no @xmath135-quark contribution .- quark contribution to @xmath16 ; its numerical contribution is subleading ( @xmath136 whereas @xmath137 ) . ] this leaves only @xmath138 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 intermediate states contributing to the mixing diagram of fig . [ fig : loop ] . taking @xmath141 , the mixing loop - functions will depend on @xmath142 . table [ tab : qkmix ] examines in detail the loop - functions for @xmath122 and shows the results of carrying out an expansion in powers of @xmath143 . we see that the contributions of the individual intermediate states in the mixing diagram are _ not _ intrinsically small in fact , they begin to contribute at @xmath144 . however , flavor cancellations remove all contributions through @xmath145 for @xmath122 , so the net result is @xmath146 . charm mixing clearly experiences a remarkable gim suppression ! the corresponding result for @xmath16 turns out to be @xmath145 . summarizing , the leading dependences in @xmath143 for the dimension six contributions are y_d^(lo ) ~z^3x_d^(lo ) ~z^2y_d^(nlo ) ~z^2x_d^(nlo ) ~z^2 . [ order ] .flavor cancellations in @xmath122 . [ cols="^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] .05 in we recommend further experimental study of this subject on two fronts . first , of course , is the need to reduce error bars in the measured values of @xmath9 and especially @xmath14 . equally important is continuing the search for evidence of cp violation in mixing for the @xmath1 system . cp violation provides an interesting contrast with @xmath1 mixing because it provides an independent arena for competition between the sm and np signals . there is especially room for improvement in the sm analysis of charm cp violation , and work on this is underway . the work of e.g. was supported in part by the u.s . national science foundation under grant phy0555304 , j.h . was supported by the u.s . department of energy under contract de - ac02 - 76sf00515 , s.p . was supported by the u.s . department of energy under contract de - fg02 - 04er41291 and a.p . was supported in part by the u.s . national science foundation under career award phy0547794 , and by the u.s . department of energy under contract de - fg02 - 96er41005 . j.h . would like to thank the theoretical physics group at fermilab for their hospitality and e.g. , j.h . , and a.p . thank the high energy physics group at the university of hawaii for their hospitality while part of this work was performed . we would like to thank c.f . berger , s. chivukula , b. dobrescu , j. donoghue , k.c . kong , b. lillie , e. lunghi , e. simmons and t. tait for discussions related to this work and especially t. browder , t. rizzo , and x. tata for a careful reading of the manuscript . here , we collect the formulae used throughout the manuscript to compute the contributions to @xmath1-@xmath147 mixing in the various new physics models . the loop functions , first calculated by inami lim , apply for several np scenarios discussed in the text . for a contribution from two internal quarks of the same flavor in the box diagram , the loop function is @xmath148 -{3x^3\over 2(1-x)^3}\ln x\ \ , \ ] ] and for two quarks of different flavors , @xmath149 + ( x_i \leftrightarrow x_j ) \right . \nonumber \\ & & \left . \hspace{5.0 cm } - { 3\over 4(1-x_i)(1-x_j ) } \right ) \ \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the loop functions with one @xmath155 and one sm @xmath156 boson and with two @xmath155 being exchanged in the box diagram are @xmath157\ , \nonumber \\ a_{\rm wh}(x , y ) & = & 2x^2\left[{1\over ( x - y)(1-x)}+{y\ln y\over ( x - y)^2(1-y ) } + { ( x^2-y)\ln x\over ( x - y)^2(1-x)^2}\right . \nonumber\\ & & \left . -{1\over 4}\left ( { x\over ( x - y)(1-x ) } + { y^2\ln y\over ( 1-y)(x - y)^2 } + { x(x+xy-2y)\ln x\over ( x - y)^2(1-x)^2}\right)\right]\ \ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] the coupling of two zero - mode fermions to the @xmath159 gauge boson kk state , @xmath160 , relative to the sm coupling strength is @xmath161 \int_{e^{-\pi kr_c}}^1 dz\ , z^{(1 - 2c_f)}{j_1(x_nz)+\alpha_ny_1(x_nz ) \over |j_1(x_n)+\alpha_ny_1(x_n)|}\ \ , \ ] ] where the roots @xmath162 for the gauge boson kk spectrum are given by @xmath163 = 0\ \ , \ ] ] and @xmath164 is defined by @xmath165 # 1 # 2 # 3 int . . phys . * # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 mod . # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 nucl . # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 phys . # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 phys . rep . * # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 phys . * # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 phys . lett . * # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 rev . # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) # 1 # 2 # 3 z. phys . * # 1 * , # 2 ( # 3 ) a. datta and d. kumbhakar , z. phys . c * 27 * , 515 ( 1985 ) . the babar collaboration , b. aubert , , ` search for @xmath168 mixing using doubly flavor tagged semileptonic decay modes , ' arxiv:0705.0704 [ hep - ex ] . g. burdman and i. shipsey , ann . nucl . part . sci . * 53 * , 431 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310076 ] ; g. burdman , e. golowich , j.l . hewett and s. pakvasa , phys . d * 52 * , 6383 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9502329 ] ; j.l . hewett , t. takeuchi and s.d . thomas , in _ electroweak symmetry breaking and beyond the standard model _ ed . by t. barklow , , world scientific , arxiv : hep - ph/9603391 ; s. bianco , f. l. fabbri , d. benson and i. bigi , riv . nuovo cim . * 26n7 * , 1 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0309021 ] ; a. a. petrov , int . j. mod . a * 21 * , 5686 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0611361 ] ; a. a. petrov , _ in the proceedings of flavor physics and cp violation ( fpcp 2003 ) , paris , france , 3 - 6 jun 2003 , pp mec05 _ [ arxiv : hep - ph/0311371 ] ; h. n. nelson , in _ proc . of the 19th symp . on photon and lepton interactions at high energy lp99 jaros and m.e . peskin , arxiv : hep - ex/9908021 . heavy flavor averaging group , http://www.slac.stanford.edu/xorg/hfag/charm/index.html ; d. asner , ` charm physics ' , talk at the _ workshop on flavor in the era of the lhc _ , cern ( 3/26 - 28/07 ) ; b. peterson , talk given at the _ charm 2007 workshop _ , cornell university , ithaca , ny , august 2007 . e. golowich and a.a . petrov , phys . b * 625 * , 53 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0506185 ] . a. f. falk , y. nir and a. a. petrov , jhep * 9912 * , 019 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911369 ] . s. bergmann , y. grossman , z. ligeti , y. nir and a.a . petrov , phys . b * 486 * , 418 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0005181 ] . y. nir , ` lessons from babar and belle measurements of @xmath169 mixing parameters , ' arxiv : hep - ph/0703235 . particle data group ( w .- m . yao et al . ) , ` review of particle physics ' , j.phys.g33:1-1232,2006 . e. golowich , s. pakvasa and a.a . petrov , phys . * 98 * , 181808 - 1 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0610039 ] . m. ciuchini , e. franco , v. lubicz , g. martinelli , i. scimemi and l. silvestrini , nucl . b * 523 * , 501 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9711402 ] . r. gupta , t. bhattacharya and s. r. sharpe , phys . d * 55 * , 4036 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - lat/9611023 ] . m. artuso _ et al . _ [ cleo collaboration ] , phys . * 95 * , 251801 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0508057 ] . bigi and n.g . uraltsev , nucl . b * 592 * , 92 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0005089 ] . falk , y. grossman , z. ligeti and a.a . petrov , phys . d * 65 * , 054034 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0110317 ] . e. golowich , a.a . petrov and g. yeghiyan ( in progress ) . e. golowich and a. a. petrov , phys . b * 427 * , 172 ( 1998 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9802291 ] . donoghue , e. golowich , b.r . holstein and j. trampetic , phys . d * 33 * , 179 ( 1986 ) . l. wolfenstein , b164 170 1985 . f. buccella , m. lusignoli , g. miele , a. pugliese and p. santorelli , phys . d * 51 * , 3478 ( 1995 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9411286 ] . falk , y. grossman , z. ligeti , y. nir and a.a . petrov , phys . d * 69 * , 114021 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0402204 ] . m.e . peskin and t. takeuchi , d * 46 * , 381 ( 1992 ) . lep electroweak working group , phys . rept . * 427 * , 257 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0509008 ] . see , for example , h.j . he , n. polonsky and s.f . su , phys . d * 64 * , 053004 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0102144 ] . chanowitz , m.a . furman and i. hinchliffe , phys . b * 78 * , 285 ( 1978 ) ; nucl . b * 153 * , 402 ( 1979 ) . babu , x.g . he , x. li and s. pakvasa , phys . b * 205 * , 540 ( 1988 ) . f. gursey , p. ramond and p. sikivie , phys . b * 60 * , 177 ( 1976 ) . j.l . hewett and t.g . rizzo , phys . * 183 * , 193 ( 1989 ) . n. arkani - hamed , a.g . cohen , e. katz and a.e . nelson , jhep * 0207 * , 034 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206021 ] . n. arkani - hamed , a.g . cohen , e. katz , a.e . nelson , t. gregoire and j.g . wacker , jhep * 0208 * , 021 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206020 ] . bjorken , s. pakvasa and s.f . tuan , phys . d * 66 * , 053008 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206116 ] . n. arkani - hamed , a.g . cohen and h. georgi , phys . b * 513 * , 232 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0105239 ] ; for a review , see , m. perelstein , prog . part . * 58 * , 247 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0512128 ] . j. y. lee , jhep * 0412 * , 065 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0408362 ] . c. h. chen , c. q. geng and t. c. yuan , ` @xmath3-@xmath170 mixing and rare d decays in the littlest higgs model with non - unitarity matrix , ' arxiv:0704.0601 [ hep - ph ] . c. csaki , j. hubisz , g. d. kribs , p. meade and j. terning , phys . d * 67 * , 115002 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0211124 ] ; j. l. hewett , f. j. petriello and t. g. rizzo , jhep * 0310 * , 062 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0211218 ] ; m. c. chen and s. dawson , phys . d * 70 * , 015003 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0311032 ] . c. csaki , j. hubisz , g. d. kribs , p. meade and j. terning , phys . d * 68 * , 035009 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0303236 ] . h. c. cheng and i. low , jhep * 0309 * , 051 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308199 ] ; h. c. cheng and i. low , jhep * 0408 * , 061 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0405243 ] . c. t. hill and r. j. hill , arxiv : hep - ph/0701044 ; c. t. hill and r. j. hill , arxiv:0705.0697 [ hep - ph ] . j. hubisz , s. j. lee and g. paz , jhep * 0606 * , 041 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0512169 ] ; m. blanke , a. j. buras , a. poschenrieder , c. tarantino , s. uhlig and a. weiler , jhep * 0612 * , 003 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0605214 ] . m. blanke , a. j. buras , s. recksiegel , c. tarantino and s. uhlig , ` littlest higgs model with t - parity confronting the new data on @xmath169 mixing , ' arxiv : hep - ph/0703254 . see , for example , p. savard , `` searches for extra dimensions and new gauge bosons at the tevatron , '' talk given at the _ xxxiii international conference on high energy physics _ , 26 july-2 august 2006 , moscow , russia ; t. adams , `` searches for new phenomena with lepton final states at the tevatron , '' talk given at _ rencontres de moriond electroweak interactions and unified theories 2007 _ , la thuile , italy 10 - 17 march 2007 ; a. abulencia _ et al . _ [ cdf collaboration ] , ` search for @xmath171 boson decaying to electron - neutrino pairs in @xmath172 collisions at @xmath173 tev , ' arxiv : hep - ex/0611022 . t. g. rizzo , z phenomenology and the lhc , arxiv : hep - ph/0610104 . p. langacker and m. plumacher , phys . d * 62 * , 013006 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0001204 ] . a. arhrib , k. cheung , c. w. chiang and t. c. yuan , phys . d * 73 * , 075015 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0602175 ] . n. g. deshpande , e. keith and t. g. rizzo , phys . lett . * 70 * , 3189 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9211310 ] . k. kiers , m. assis and a. a. petrov , phys . rev . d * 71 * , 115015 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0503115 ] . g. beall , m. bander and a. soni , phys . lett . * 48 * , 848 ( 1982 ) . d. chang , r. n. mohapatra and m. k. parida , phys . d * 30 * , 1052 ( 1984 ) . f. i. olness and m. e. ebel , phys . d * 30 * , 1034 ( 1984 ) ; p. langacker and s. uma sankar , phys . d * 40 * , 1569 ( 1989 ) . t. g. rizzo , phys . d * 50 * , 325 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9311265 ] . z. chacko , h. s. goh and r. harnik , phys . lett . * 96 * , 231802 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0506256 ] ; h. s. goh and s. su , phys . d * 75 * , 075010 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0611015 ] . k. s. babu , x. g. he and e. ma , phys . rev . d * 36 * , 878 ( 1987 ) . e. ma , mod . lett . a * 3 * , 319 ( 1988 ) . b. abbott _ et al . _ [ d0 collaboration ] , phys . lett . * 83 * , 2896 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/9904023 ] . s. davidson , d. c. bailey and b. a. campbell , z. phys . c * 61 * , 613 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9309310 ] . m. leurer , phys . d * 50 * , 536 ( 1994 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9312341 ] . for a summary , see , j. l. hewett and t. g. rizzo , phys . d * 56 * , 5709 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9703337 ] . see , for example , b. grinstein and m. b. wise , phys . b * 201 * , 274 ( 1988 ) ; t. g. rizzo , phys . d * 38 * , 820 ( 1988 ) ; j.l . hewett , phys . lett . * 70 * , 1045 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9211256 ] ; v.d . barger , m. s. berger and r. j. n. phillips , phys . * 70 * , 1368 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9211260 ] . m. misiak _ et al . _ , phys . lett . * 98 * , 022002 ( 2007 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0609232 ] . barger , j.l . hewett and r.j.n . phillips , phys . d * 41 * , 3421 ( 1990 ) . g. isidori and a. retico , jhep * 0111 * , 001 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0110121 ] ; a.j . buras , p.h . chankowski , j. rosiek and l. slawianowska , nucl . b * 619 * , 434 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0107048 ] . s. pakvasa and h. sugawara , 73b 61 1978 . cheng and m. sher , phys . d * 35 * , 3484 ( 1987 ) . l. j. hall and s. weinberg , phys . d * 48 * , 979 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9303241 ] . d. acosta _ et al . _ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev . d * 72 * , 051107 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0506074 ] ; a. abulencia _ et al . _ [ cdf collaboration ] , phys . rev . d * 73 * , 051102 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ex/0512055 ] . r. s. chivukula , n. j. evans and e. h. simmons , phys . d * 66 * , 035008 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0204193 ] . n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen , t. gregoire and j. g. wacker , jhep * 0208 * , 020 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0202089 ] . c. csaki , c. grojean , l. pilo and j. terning , phys . lett . * 92 * , 101802 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308038 ] . c. csaki , c. grojean , h. murayama , l. pilo and j. terning , phys . d * 69 * , 055006 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0305237 ] . y. nomura , jhep * 0311 * , 050 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0309189 ] ; r. barbieri , a. pomarol and r. rattazzi , phys . b * 591 * , 141 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310285 ] ; h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett , b. lillie and t. g. rizzo , phys . d * 70 * , 015006 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0312193 ] ; g. burdman and y. nomura , phys . d * 69 * , 115013 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0312247 ] ; g. cacciapaglia , c. csaki , c. grojean and j. terning , phys . d * 70 * , 075014 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0401160 ] ; h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett , b. lillie and t. g. rizzo , jhep * 0405 * , 015 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0403300 ] . c. csaki , c. grojean , j. hubisz , y. shirman and j. terning , phys . d * 70 * , 015012 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310355 ] . for a review of tev - scale extra dimensional models and their experimental consequences , see for example , j. hewett and m. spiropulu , ann . nucl . part . sci . * 52 * , 397 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0205106 ] ; t. g. rizzo , _ in the proceedings of 32nd slac summer institute on particle physics ( ssi 2004 ) : natures greatest puzzles , menlo park , california , 2 - 13 aug 2004 , pp l013 _ [ arxiv : hep - ph/0409309 ] . i. antoniadis , phys . b * 246 * , 377 ( 1990 ) ; j. d. lykken , phys . d * 54 * , 3693 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9603133 ] ; i. antoniadis and m. quiros , phys . b * 392 * , 61 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/9609209 ] . t. appelquist , h. c. cheng and b. a. dobrescu , phys . d * 64 * , 035002 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0012100 ] . g. servant and t. m. p. tait , nucl . b * 650 * , 391 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206071 ] , new j. phys . * 4 * , 99 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0209262 ] ; h. c. cheng , j. l. feng and k. t. matchev , phys . lett . * 89 * , 211301 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0207125 ] . c. lin , search for universal extra dimensions in the multi - lepton channel at the tevatron , cdf thesis , fermilab - pub-05 - 572-e . h. c. cheng , k. t. matchev and m. schmaltz , phys . d * 66 * , 036005 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0204342 ] . a. j. buras , m. spranger and a. weiler , nucl . b * 660 * , 225 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0212143 ] . n. arkani - hamed , y. grossman and m. schmaltz , phys . d * 61 * , 115004 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9909411 ] . e. a. mirabelli and m. schmaltz , phys . d * 61 * , 113011 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9912265 ] ; g. c. branco , a. de gouvea and m. n. rebelo , phys . b * 506 * , 115 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0012289 ] ; d. e. kaplan and t. m. p. tait , jhep * 0111 * , 051 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0110126 ] ; y. grossman and g. perez , phys . d * 67 * , 015011 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210053 ] ; c. biggio , f. feruglio , i. masina and m. perez - victoria , nucl . b * 677 * , 451 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0305129 ] ; b. lillie , jhep * 0312 * , 030 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308091 ] ; y. grossman , r. harnik , g. perez , m. d. schwartz and z. surujon , phys . d * 71 * , 056007 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0407260 ] ; g. perez and t. volansky , phys . d * 72 * , 103522 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0505222 ] . a. delgado , a. pomarol and m. quiros , jhep * 0001 * , 030 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911252 ] ; w. f. chang and j. n. ng , jhep * 0212 * , 077 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0210414 ] . b. lillie and j. l. hewett , phys . d * 68 * , 116002 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0306193 ] . l. randall and r. sundrum , phys . * 83 * , 3370 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9905221 ] . s. j. huber and q. shafi , phys . b * 498 * , 256 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0010195 ] ; s. j. huber , nucl . b * 666 * , 269 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0303183 ] ; g. burdman , phys . b * 590 * , 86 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0310144 ] ; k. agashe , g. perez and a. soni , phys . rev . lett . * 93 * , 201804 ( 2004 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406101 ] . k. agashe , g. perez and a. soni , phys . d * 71 * , 016002 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0408134 ] . h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett and t. g. rizzo , phys . b * 473 * , 43 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911262 ] ; a. pomarol , phys . b * 486 * , 153 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9911294 ] . y. grossman and m. neubert , phys . b * 474 * , 361 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9912408 ] ; t. gherghetta and a. pomarol , nucl . b * 586 * , 141 ( 2000 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0003129 ] . h. davoudiasl , j. l. hewett and t. g. rizzo , phys . d * 63 * , 075004 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0006041 ] . s. j. huber and q. shafi , phys . d * 63 * , 045010 ( 2001 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0005286 ] ; s. j. huber , c. a. lee and q. shafi , phys . b * 531 * , 112 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0111465 ] ; c. csaki , j. erlich and j. terning , phys . rev . d * 66 * , 064021 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203034 ] ; j. l. hewett , f. j. petriello and t. g. rizzo , jhep * 0209 * , 030 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0203091 ] . k. agashe , a. delgado , m. j. may and r. sundrum , jhep * 0308 * , 050 ( 2003 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0308036 ] . k. agashe , r. contino and a. pomarol , nucl . phys . b * 719 * , 165 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0412089 ] ; k. agashe , a. e. blechman and f. petriello , phys . d * 74 * , 053011 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0606021 ] . h. davoudiasl and a. soni , arxiv:0705.0151 [ hep - ph ] . j. r. ellis and d. v. nanopoulos , phys . b * 110 * , 44 ( 1982 ) . h. p. nilles , phys . rept . * 110 * , 1 ( 1984 ) . h. georgi , phys . b * 169 * , 231 ( 1986 ) . l. j. hall , v. a. kostelecky and s. raby , nucl . b * 267 * , 415 ( 1986 ) . for a comprehensive study of fcnc effects in supersymmetry see , s. bertolini , f. borzumati , a. masiero and g. ridolfi , nucl . b * 353 * , 591 ( 1991 ) ; f. gabbiani , e. gabrielli , a. masiero and l. silvestrini , nucl . b * 477 * , 321 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9604387 ] ; i. i. y. bigi , f. gabbiani and a. masiero , z. phys . c * 48 * , 633 ( 1990 ) . m. ciuchini , e. franco , d. guadagnoli , v. lubicz , v. porretti and l. silvestrini , jhep * 0609 * , 013 ( 2006 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0606197 ] . j. a. bagger , k. t. matchev and r. j. zhang , phys . b * 412 * , 77 ( 1997 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9707225 ] . m. ciuchini , e. franco , d. guadagnoli , v. lubicz , m. pierini , v. porretti and l. silvestrini , d - anti - d mixing and new physics : general considerations and constraints on the mssm , arxiv : hep - ph/0703204 . y. nir and n. seiberg , phys . b * 309 * , 337 ( 1993 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9304307 ] . y. nir and g. raz , phys . d * 66 * , 035007 ( 2002 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/0206064 ] . see , for example , l. e. ibanez and g. g. ross , nucl . b * 368 * , 3 ( 1992 ) . k. agashe and m. graesser , phys . d * 54 * , 4445 ( 1996 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9510439 ] . for a recent summary of constraints on the r - parity violating couplings , see , h. baer and x. tata , _ weak scale supersymmetry : from superfields to scattering events _ ( cambridge university press , cambridge , england 2006 ) . see , also , b. c. allanach , a. dedes and h. k. dreiner , phys . d * 60 * , 075014 ( 1999 ) [ arxiv : hep - ph/9906209 ] ; g. bhattacharyya , ` a brief review of r - parity - violating couplings , ' arxiv : hep - ph/9709395 , and references therein . n. arkani - hamed and s. dimopoulos , jhep * 0506 * , 073 ( 2005 ) [ arxiv : hep - th/0405159 ] ; g. f. giudice and a. romanino , nucl . b * 699 * , 65 ( 2004 ) [ erratum - ibid . b * 706 * , 65 ( 2005 ) ] [ arxiv : hep - ph/0406088 ] .
Abstract: | [
"we provide a comprehensive , up - to - date analysis of possible new physics contributions to the mass difference @xmath0 in @xmath1-@xmath2 mixing . we consider the most general low energy effective hamiltonian and include leading order qcd running of effective operators . we then explore an extensive list of possible new physics models that can generate these operators , which we organize as including extra fermions , extra gauge bosons , extra scalars , extra space dimensions and extra symmetries . for each model we place restrictions on the allowed parameter space using the recent evidence for observation of @xmath3 meson mixing . in many scenarios , we find strong constraints that surpass those from other search techniques and provide an important test of flavor changing neutral currents in the up - quark sector . we also review the recent babar and belle findings , and describe the current status of the standard model predictions of @xmath1-@xmath2 mixing ."
] | 9,277 | 9,277 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: chern - simons quantum field theory in 3-dimensions ( perturbative , or non - perturbative ) produces a plethora of numerical invariants of knotted 3-dimensional objects . we introduce a packaging of these invariants into two power series : one that encodes non - perturbative invariants ( model np ) , and one that encodes perturbative invariants ( model p ) . the paper is concerned with the analytic continuation , the asymptotic behavior and and arithmetic properties of those power series . let us begin with a conjecture concerning the structure of nonperturbative quantum invariants . consider the generating series @xmath0 of the _ witten - reshetikhin - turaev _ invariants @xmath1 ( see section [ sec.cs ] ) of a closed , oriented , connected 3-manifold @xmath2 , using a compact lie group @xmath3 and a level @xmath4 . the power series is known to be convergent inside the unit disk @xmath5 since unitarity implies that @xmath1 grows at most polynomially with respect to @xmath6 ; see @xcite . ( analytic continuation ) for every pair @xmath7 as above , the series @xmath8 has analytic continuation as a multivalued function on @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is a finite set that contains zero and the exponentials of the negative of the critical values of the complexified chern - simons action . a key observation is that @xmath11 may contain elements inside the unit disk @xmath12 despite the fact that the power series @xmath8 is analytic for @xmath13 such that @xmath12 . one may compare this behavior with the power series @xmath14 that define the classical dilogarithm , whose analytic continuation is a multivalued analytic function in @xmath15 . schematically , the analytic continuation of @xmath8 may be depicted as follows : @xmath16 the above conjecture has the following features : * it can be formulated for pairs @xmath17 where @xmath18 denotes a knotted object , i.e. , a knot @xmath19 in 3-space or a closed 3-manifold @xmath2 and @xmath3 denotes a compact lie group . * it implies via elementary complex analysis two well - known asymptotic conjectures in quantum topology ; namely the volume conjecture ( in the case of knots ) , and the witten conjecture ( in the case of 3-manifolds ) . the complex analysis argument uses the cauchy formula to write @xmath1 as a contour integral of @xmath20 and then deform the contour around the singularities of the integrand nearest to the origin . for a detailed discussion , see ( * ? ? ? * sec.7 ) . * it states a precise relation between exact chern - simons theory and its perturbation expansion around a trivial ( or not ) flat connection . namely , perturbation theory is simply the expansion of the multivalued function @xmath8 around one of its singularities . * it explains the effect of complexifying a compact gauge group and to the partition function of the corresponding gauge theory . indeed , analytic continuation captures the critical values of the complexified action ; compare also with @xcite . * the conjecture can be extended to state - sum invariants of sum - product type that generalize @xmath1 and do not necessarily come from topology . * the conjecture has been proven for power series of 1-dimensional sum - product type , which includes the case of the @xmath21 and @xmath22 knots ; see @xcite and @xcite . * the conjecture can , and has been , numerically tested . see section [ sec.evidence ] . our next conjecture is a symmetry conjecture . recall that @xmath2 denotes an oriented 3-manifold ; we let @xmath23 denote the _ orientation reversed _ manifold . ( symmetry ) for every pair @xmath7 with @xmath2 an integer homology sphere , we have : @xmath24 has singularities at @xmath25 . let us make some comments regarding the above _ paradoxical statement _ : * the left ( resp . right ) hand side is given by a convergent power series for @xmath5 ( resp . @xmath26 ) . thus , the power series never make sense simultaneously , but their analytic continuations do . * zagier calls a similar statement in ( * ? ? ? * eqn.7 ) a _ strange identity _ since the the two sides never make sense simultaneously . our symmetry conjecture is closely related to a _ modular property _ , at least for the series studied by kontsevich - zagier ; see ( * ? ? ? * sec.6 ) . * in physics , equation is usually called a _ duality_. * in algebraic geometry and number theory , one may compare with the following symmetry for the polylogarithm : @xmath27 where @xmath28 is the @xmath29-th polylogarithm and @xmath30 is the @xmath29-th bernoulli polynomial ; see ( * ? ? ? * sec.1.3 ) . * in analysis one may use the above symmetry to deduce the asymptotic behavior ( and even more , the asymptotic expansion ) of @xmath8 for large @xmath31 . in particular , if @xmath32 , it follows that @xmath33 for large @xmath31 . * the above symmetry may be explained by the fact that cs changes sign under orientation reversal . since the level is nonnegative , the path integral formula for @xmath8 formally implies the above symmetry . * if we use the normalized invariants @xmath34 and if @xmath2 is an integer homology sphere , then it is possible that @xmath35 * when @xmath32 , it follows that the asymptotic expansion of @xmath36 around its singularities _ uniquely determines _ @xmath36 . indeed , the difference between two determinations is an entire function which is bounded by a constant by the symmetry conjecture . thus , the difference is identically zero . * if @xmath37 is _ amphicheiral _ ( for example , @xmath2 is given by a connected sum @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the orientation reversing involution ) , then equation predicts that @xmath40 . so far , we considered nonperturbative quantum invariants . let us now consider perturbative quantum invariants of pairs @xmath17 . they can be packaged into a power series @xmath41 which is convergent at @xmath42 . for a detailed definition , see section [ sec.cs ] . our next conjecture describes an explicit relation between the perturbative and nonperturbative quantum invariants . ( exact implies perturbative ) for every integer homology sphere @xmath2 we have : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is a holomorphic function of @xmath13 at @xmath42 and @xmath45 denotes the analytic continuation at @xmath46 along _ any _ path that avoids the singularities . as before , we can extend conjecture [ conj.2 ] to pairs @xmath47 , where @xmath19 is a knot in 3-space . in calle s terminology ( see @xcite and also ( * ? ? ? * sec.2.3 ) ) , if @xmath48 denotes the _ alien derivative _ in the direction @xmath13 , conjecture [ conj.2 ] states that : @xmath49 equation is reminiscent of the condition @xmath50 that defines the _ bloch group _ ; see for example @xcite . the series @xmath51 also satisfies a symmetry property : @xmath52 unlike the case of conjecture [ conj.symmetry ] , this is an easy corollary of its very definition . chern - simons theory with complex gauge group was studied extensively by gukov in @xcite . it is an interesting problem to compare forthcoming work of gukov - zagier on modularity properties of the quantum invariants with our conjectures . based on some partial results of @xcite and @xcite and stimulating conversations with o. costin , j. calle and d. zagier , more is actually expected to be true . namely , we expect arithmetic restrictions on the singularities of the series @xmath8 and of its monodromy , local and global . these restrictions lead us naturally to the notion of arithmetic resurgence , and the gevrey series of mixed type . in the rest of the paper , we will formulate these expected algebraic / arithmetic aspects of quantum invariants in a precise way and to expose the reader to the wonderful world of resurgence , introduced by calle in the eighties for unrelated reasons ; @xcite . the logical dependence of the sections is the following : @xmath53{\text{section \ref{sec.cs } } } \arrow{sw}\arrow{se } \node[2]{\text{section \ref{sec.ar } } } \arrow{sw}\arrow{se } \\ \node{\text{section \ref{sec.habiro } } } \arrow{see } \node[2]{\text{section \ref{sec.conj } } } \arrow{s } \node[2]{\text{section \ref{sec.sp } } } \arrow{sww } \\ \node[3]{\text{section \ref{sec.evidence } } } \end{diagram}\ ] ] in this section @xmath2 will denote a closed 3-manifold and @xmath3 will denote a simple , compact , simply connected group @xmath3 . for example , @xmath54 . the witten - reshetikhin - turaev invariant is a map : @xmath55 for a definition of @xmath1 see @xcite . formally , for @xmath4 , @xmath1 is the expectation value of a _ path integral _ with a topological _ chern - simons lagrangian _ at level @xmath6 ; see @xcite . since the chern - simons lagrangian takes values in @xmath56 , it follows that the level @xmath6 has to be an integer number , which without loss we take it to be nonnegative . we can convert the sequence @xmath57 into a generating series as follows : for every @xmath2 and @xmath3 as above , we define : @xmath58 unitarity of the chern - simons theory implies that for every @xmath59 the sequence @xmath57 grows polynomially with respect to @xmath6 . in other words , it was shown in @xcite that there exists positive constant @xmath60 and @xmath61 ( that depend on @xmath2 and @xmath3 ) so that @xmath62 for all @xmath4 . thus , @xmath8 is analytic inside the unit disk @xmath63 . the path integral interpretation of @xmath1 formally leads to a perturbation theory along a distinguished critical point of the chern - simons action , namely the trivial flat connection . this gives rise to a graph - valued power series invariant , which has been defined by le - murakami - ohtsuki in @xcite . additional definitions of this powerful invariant were given by kuperberg - thurston ; see @xcite . more precisely , lmo define a graph - valued invariant @xmath64 where @xmath65 is a completed vector space of jacobi diagrams . a _ jacobi _ diagram of degree @xmath6 is a trivalent graph with @xmath66 oriented vertices , considered modulo the as and ihx relations ; see @xcite . jacobi diagrams are diagrammatic analogues of tensors on a lie algebra with an invariant inner product . indeed , given a simple lie algebra @xmath67 , there is a _ weight system map _ that replaces a jacobi diagram of degree @xmath6 by a rational number times @xmath68 : @xmath69\ ] ] see @xcite . recall the _ borel transform _ : @xmath70 \longto \bq[[z ] ] , \qquad \calb\left(\sum_{n=0}^\infty \frac{a_n}{x^n } \right ) = \sum_{n=0}^\infty \frac{a_{n+1}}{n ! } z^n\ ] ] let @xmath71 denote the borel transform of @xmath72 . in @xcite it was proven that if @xmath2 is a homology sphere and @xmath67 is a simple lie algebra , then the formal power series @xmath72 is gevrey-1 . in other words , @xmath71 is an analytic function in a neighborhood of @xmath42 . our main resurgence conjecture [ conj.1 ] formulated in section [ sec.conj ] below links the singularities of the analytic continuation of the series @xmath73 and @xmath51 to some classical geometric invariants of 3-manifolds , namely the critical values of the complexified chern - simons function . let us recall those briefly , and refer the reader to @xcite for a more detailed discussion . let us fix a closed 3-manifold @xmath2 , and simple , compact simply connected group @xmath3 , and a trivial bundle @xmath74 with the trivial connection @xmath75 . let @xmath76 denote the set of @xmath3-connections on @xmath74 . there is a chern - simons map : @xmath77 where , as common in algebraic geometry , we denote @xmath78 even though @xmath76 is an affine infinite dimensional vector space acted on by an infinite dimensional gauge group , the set @xmath79 of gauge equivalence classes of the critical points of @xmath80 is a compact semialgebraic set that consists of flat @xmath3-connections . up to gauge equivalence , the latter are determined by their monodromy . in other words , we may identify : @xmath81 this gives rise to a map : @xmath82 stokes s theorem implies that @xmath80 is a locally constant map . since @xmath79 is a compact set , @xmath80 takes finitely many values in @xmath83 . let us now _ complexify _ the action ; see also @xcite . this means that we replace the compact lie group @xmath3 by its complexification @xmath84 , the moduli space @xmath79 by @xmath85 , and the chern - simons action @xmath80 by @xmath86 : @xmath87 @xmath86 is again a locally constant map , and takes finitely many values in @xmath88 . thus , we may define the following geometric invariants of 3-manifolds . for @xmath2 and @xmath3 as above , we define @xmath89 under complex conjugation ( but keeping the orientation of the ambient manifold fixed ) , we have @xmath90 . it follows that @xmath91 ( resp.@xmath92 ) is invariant under @xmath93 ( resp . @xmath94 ) . the involution @xmath94 preserves the set of rays through zero . on the other hand , under orientation reversal , we have @xmath95 and @xmath96 , where @xmath97 for @xmath98 and @xmath99 . we thank c. zickert for help in identifying those involutions . thus , a typical picture for @xmath91 and @xmath100 is the following : @xmath101 where the horizontal spacing between two dots in any horizontal line is @xmath102 . complexification is a key idea , theoretically , as well as computationally . for example , @xmath85 is an algebraic variety whereas its real part @xmath103 is only a compact set with little structure . the only systematic way ( known to us ) to give exact formulas for the critical values of @xmath80 is to actually compute the critical values of @xmath86 and then decide which of these are critical values of @xmath80 . for @xmath54 , there are exact and numerical computer implementations for the critical values of @xmath86 : see snap @xcite and @xcite . complexification also reveals the arithmetic structure of @xmath104 : its elements are _ periods _ of weight @xmath105 ( in the sense of kontsevich - zagier @xcite ) , of a rather special kind . namely , the critical values of @xmath86 are @xmath106-linear combinations of the _ rogers dilogarithm _ function evaluated at algebraic numbers . the latter is defined by : @xmath107 for @xmath108 and analytically continued as a multivalued analytic function in @xmath15 . here , @xmath109 is the classical dilogarithm function . for @xmath54 , our identification of the complexified chern - simons action with @xcite is as follows : @xmath110 for higher rank groups , exact formulas for the critical values of @xmath86 may also be given in terms of the rogers dilogarithm function at algebraic numbers . this will be explained in detail in a separate publication . as an illustration of the above discussion let us give an example . if @xmath2 is obtained by @xmath111 surgery on the @xmath22 knot , then @xmath112 consists of @xmath113 points plotted as follows : @xmath114 in this picture , a higher resolution reveals that the points nearest to the vertical axis consist of _ two _ distinct but close pairs . we thank c. zickert for providing us with an exact and numerical computation of the critical values of the complexified chern - simons map . let us end this section with a problem : give an direct relation between the cubic polynomial action and the rogers dilogarithm . a transcendental relation between the chern - simons action and the rogers dilogarithm was given in ( * ? ? ? * sec.6.2 ) , using the third algebraic @xmath19-theory group @xmath115 . so far , the discussion involved closed 3-manifolds . let us now consider knots @xmath19 in the 3-sphere . for simplicity , we will assume that @xmath54 ( so @xmath116 ) in this section . let us fix a knot @xmath19 in 3-sphere and a nonnegative integer @xmath6 . let us denote by @xmath117 the _ kashaev invariant _ of @xmath19 ( see @xcite ) , which is also identified by @xcite with the value of the jones polynomial colored by the @xmath6-th dimensional irreducible representation of @xmath118 evaluated at @xmath119 ( and normalized to be @xmath120 at the unknot ) . thus , we may define : @xmath121 we define the perturbative invariant @xmath122 as follows : * take the sequence @xmath123 $ ] of the jones polynomials of @xmath6 , colored by the @xmath6-dimensional irreducible representation of @xmath118 , and normalized by @xmath124 . see for example , @xcite . * it turns out that there exists a power series @xmath125 $ ] so that @xmath126 $ ] for all @xmath4 ; see for example @xcite . * consider the power series @xmath127 $ ] . * define @xmath128 $ ] . in @xcite ( resp . @xcite ) it was shown that @xmath129 ( resp . @xmath122 ) is analytic for @xmath13 in a neighborhood of @xmath130 . regarding the critical values of the chern - simons action , we will consider only _ parabolic _ @xmath131 representations ; i.e. , those representations so that the trace of every peripheral element is @xmath132 . as in the case of closed 3-manifolds , we may identify the moduli space of _ parabolic _ flat @xmath131-connections on the knot complement with @xmath133 : @xmath134 in addition , we have a map , described in detail in @xcite : @xmath135 @xmath86 is again a locally constant map , and takes finitely many values in @xmath88 , and allows us to define the sets @xmath136 and @xmath137 . let us end this section with an example of the simplest knot @xmath21 and the simplest hyperbolic knot @xmath22 . if @xmath138 is the right hand trefoil knot @xmath21 , then @xmath139 can be plotted as follows : @xmath140 if @xmath141 is the simplest hyperbolic knot , then @xmath142 can be plotted as follows : @xmath143 where @xmath144 is the _ volume _ of @xmath22 ; see @xcite , and numerically , @xmath145 the arithmetic nature of @xmath104 is only the beginning . it turns out that * the _ ray - singer torsion invariants _ associated to a @xmath84-representation of @xmath146 are also algebraic numbers ( this is proven and discussed in detail in @xcite ) , * in case @xmath2 is hyperbolic and @xmath54 the geometric representation is defined over a number field ; see @xcite , * the perturbative expansions of the quantum invariants @xmath1 around an @xmath84-representation of @xmath146 are conjectured to be algebraic numbers ; see for example @xcite and @xcite . the need to formulate these algebricity properties in a uniform way , as well as some results in some key cases , lead us to the notion of an arithmetic resurgent series , which is the focus of this section . along the way , we will also discuss the auxiliary notion of a gevrey series of mixed type , perhaps of interest on its own . _ resurgence _ was coined by calle in his study of analytic continuation of formal and actual solutions of differential equations , linear or not ; see @xcite . an earlier term used by calle was the notion of _ endless analytic continuation_. the concept of resurgence has influenced our thinking deeply . unfortunately , it is not easy to find an accepted definition of resurgence , or a reference for it in the literature . on the other hand , there are several expositions of instances of resurgence , covering special cases of this rather general notion . the curious reader may consult @xcite for a detailed discussion in addition to the original work @xcite . given the gap in the literature , we will do our best to give a working ( and exact ) definition of resurgence , which features some properties which are arithmetically important , and analytically rare . let us begin by recalling the monodromy of multivalued germs of interest in this paper . we refer the reader to @xcite for further details . the next definition is motivated by the types of singularities that appear in algebraic geometry ; see @xcite . a _ multivalued analytic germ _ @xmath147 at @xmath42 is called _ quasi - unipotent _ if its monodromy @xmath148 around @xmath130 satisfies the condition : @xmath149 for some nonzero natural numbers @xmath150 and @xmath151 . it is easy to see that a quasi - unipotent germ @xmath147 can be written as a finite sum of germs of the form : @xmath152 where @xmath153 , @xmath154 , and @xmath155 , where @xmath156 is the ring of power series convergent at @xmath42 ( identified with the ring of germs of functions analytic at @xmath42 ) . see for example , @xcite . series of the form are often known in the literature as series of the _ nilsson class _ ; see @xcite . the rationality of the exponents @xmath157 above is an important feature that always appears in algebraic geometry and arithmetic and rarely appears in analysis . for a further discussion ; see @xcite . we say that @xmath158 is an _ resurgent series _ ( and write @xmath159 ) if * @xmath160 is convergent at @xmath42 . * @xmath160 has analytic continuation as a multivalued function in @xmath161 , where @xmath162 is a discrete subset of @xmath163 . * the local monodromy is quasi - unipotent . in what follows , we will make little distinction between a germ , its analytic continuation , and the corresponding function . so , we will speak about the algebra of resurgent functions . the following definition is motivated by the properties of some power series that are associated to knotted 3-dimensional objects . we say that series @xmath158 is a _ gevrey series of mixed type _ @xmath164 if * @xmath165 and the coefficients @xmath166 lie in a number field @xmath19 , and * there exists a constant @xmath167 so that for every @xmath4 the absolute value of every galois conjugate of @xmath166 is less than or equal to @xmath168 , and * the common denominator of @xmath169 is less than or equal to @xmath170 . if @xmath160 is gevrey of mixed type @xmath164 and @xmath171 , @xmath172 , then @xmath160 is also gevrey of mixed type @xmath173 . let @xmath174 ( resp . @xmath175 ) denote the @xmath176$]-algebra of gevrey series of mixed type ( resp . mixed type @xmath164 ) . the gevrey series of mixed type @xmath177 are precisely the important class of _ arithmetic gevrey series of type _ @xmath150 , introduced and studied by andr ; see @xcite . a @xmath3-_function _ @xmath160 in the sense of siegel is a gevrey series of mixed type @xmath178 which is _ holonomic _ , i.e. , it satisfies a linear ode with coefficients in @xmath176 $ ] ; see @xcite . restricting the functions @xmath179 in to be gevrey series of type @xmath180 , we arrive at the notion of an arithmetic quasi - unipotent germ . we say that a multivalued analytic germ @xmath147 at @xmath42 is _ arithmetic quasi - unipotent _ if it can be written as a finite sum of germs of the form where @xmath181 . combining this definition with the notion of a resurgent function , we arrive at the notion of an arithmetic resurgent function . let @xmath182 denote the countable set of _ periods _ in the sense of kontsevich - zagier ; see @xcite . we say that @xmath158 is an _ arithmetic resurgent series _ ( and write @xmath183 ) if * @xmath160 is a resurgent series . * the singularities @xmath184 of @xmath160 is a discrete subset of @xmath185 , where @xmath185 denotes the set of _ periods _ as defined by kontsevich - zagier ; see @xcite . * the local monodromy is arithmetic quasi - unipotent . * the global monodromy is defined over @xmath186 . in a separate publication we will give the proof of the following proposition which shows that the coefficients of the taylor series at the origin of an arithmetic resurgent function have asymptotic expansions themselves . the transseries conclusion of the proposition below ( without any claims on the mixed gevrey type ) follows from the resurgence hypothesis on @xmath160 alone , and are studied systematically in the upcoming book of costin @xcite , as well as in @xcite . if @xmath158 is arithmetic resurgent , then @xmath187 where the sum is over the finite set of singularities of @xmath160 nearest to the origin , and @xmath188 is a finite sum of series of the form where @xmath189 are gevrey of mixed type @xmath190 ( for some @xmath151 ) . obvious arithmetic invariants of an arithmetic resurgent function @xmath160 are : * the set of singularities @xmath191 . * the local quasi - unipotent monodromy , and its field of definition . * the global monodromy , defined over @xmath186 . this section is logically independent of the rest of the paper and can be skipped at first reading , although it provides some useful examples of arithmetic resurgent functions . a main example of arithmetic resurgent functions comes from the following theorem of andr . @xmath3-functions are arithmetic resurgent with singularities a finite set of algebraic numbers . @xmath3-functions arise naturally in three contexts : * from geometry , related to the regularity of the gauss - manin connection . * from arithmetic . * from enumerative combinatorics . for a geometric construction of resurgent functions , let us recall the following result from @xcite ; see also @xcite . let @xmath192 be a projective non - singular connected curve and @xmath193 the complement of a finite set of points . suppose that @xmath194 is a proper and smooth morphism . for every @xmath195 , the algebraic de rham cohomology @xmath196 is an algebraic differential equation on @xmath197 , and the local system @xmath198 ( for @xmath199 ) is the local system of germs of solutions of that equation . let @xmath148 denote the local monodromy around a point @xmath200 . then , we have the following theorem . @xcite the algebraic differential equation is regular singular and the local monodromy @xmath148 is quasi - unipotent . the @xmath3-functions obtained by theorems [ thm.katz ] and [ thm.andre ] are closely related . the main conjecture is that all @xmath3-functions come from geometry . for a discussion of this topic , and for a precise formulation of the bombieri - dwork conjecture , see the survey papers of @xcite and also @xcite . let us discuss a third source of resurgent functions , which was discovered recently by the author in @xcite . a _ hypergeometric term _ @xmath201 ( in short , _ _ ) in variables @xmath202 where @xmath203 is an expression of the form : @xmath204 where @xmath205 for @xmath206 , @xmath207 for @xmath208 , and @xmath209 are integral linear forms in the variables @xmath202 . we assume that for every @xmath4 , the set @xmath210 is finite . we will call a _ balanced _ if in addition it satisfies the _ balance condition _ : @xmath211 given a @xmath212 , consider the corresponding sequence @xmath213 defined by @xmath214 where the summation index lies in the finite set , and the corresponding generating series : @xmath215.\ ] ] we will call sequences of the form @xmath213 _ balanced multisum sequences_. @xcite for every @xmath212 , the generating series @xmath216 is a @xmath3-function . let us point out that the proof of theorem [ thm.ga ] in general offers no help of locating the singularities of the function @xmath216 . to fill this gap , the author developed an efficient ansatz for the location of the singularities of @xmath216 ; see @xcite . a _ knotted object _ @xmath18 denotes either a closed 3-manifold @xmath2 or a knot @xmath19 in 3-space . a _ pair _ @xmath17 denotes either a closed 3-manifold @xmath2 and a compact lie group @xmath3 , or a knot @xmath217 in 3-space and @xmath54 . if @xmath54 and @xmath2 or @xmath19 is hyperbolic , let @xmath218 denote the critical values of the galois conjugates @xmath219 of the geometric @xmath131-representation . we now have all the ingredients to formulate our arithmetic resurgence conjecture , which is a refinement of the analytic continuation conjecture [ conj.0 ] . ( arithmetic resurgence ) for every pair @xmath17 , @xmath220 and @xmath51 are arithmetic resurgent with possible singularities in the set @xmath221 . if @xmath18 is hyperbolic and @xmath54 , then the singularities of the above functions include @xmath222 . conjecture [ conj.1 ] implies the following corollaries . for every pair @xmath17 , the power series @xmath73 has analytic continuation as a multivalued function on the complement @xmath223 of the finite set @xmath224 . if @xmath2 is a closed hyperbolic 3-manifold , then the witten - reshetikhin - turaev invariants determine the volume of @xmath2 by : r @xmath225 this follows from the fact that @xmath226 has a singularity at @xmath227 and @xmath228 where @xmath229 is a discrete faithful representation . witten s conjecture ( formulated in @xcite ) regarding the asymptotic expansion of the witten - reshetikhin - turaev invariants holds . for every hyperbolic knot @xmath19 in 3-space , the kashaev invariants determine the volume of @xmath19 by : @xmath230 moreover , there is an asymptotic expansion of the kashaev invariants in powers of @xmath231 using proposition [ prop.expar ] . in this section we we describe an arithmetic relation , due to habiro , between the perturbative @xmath51 and the non - perturbative @xmath73 invariants of knotted objects . this section is independent of our conjecture . however , habiro s results * are a good complement of our conjecture , * are important and interesting on their own right , * point to a different arithmetic origin for the invariants of knotted objects . this point of view has been studied by gukov - zagier @xcite . in this section , a knotted object @xmath18 denotes either a homology sphere @xmath2 or a knot @xmath19 . for simplicity , we will assume that @xmath54 . a theorem of habiro implies that @xmath232 determines @xmath233 and vice - versa ; @xcite . let us explain more about habiro s key results . in @xcite habiro introduces the ring @xmath234}=\lim_{\leftarrow n } \bz[q^{\pm}]/((q)_n)\ ] ] where @xmath235 is the quantum @xmath6-factorial defined by : @xmath236 with @xmath237 . in a sense , one may think of elements of the habiro ring as complex - valued _ analytic functions _ with domain @xmath238 , the set of complex roots of unity . this way of thinking is motivated by the following features of the habiro ring , shown in @xcite : * it is easy to see that every element @xmath239}$ ] can be written ( nonuniquely ) in the form : @xmath240 , \quad \text{for } \quad n \in \bn.\ ] ] note however that the above form is not unique , since for example : @xmath241 nevertheless the form can be used to generate easily elements of the habiro ring . * elements of the habiro ring can be evaluated at complex roots of unity . in other words , there is a map : @xmath242 } \longto \bc^{\om } , \qquad f(q ) \longto \left ( f : \omega \longto \bc , \qquad \w \mapsto f(\w)\right).\ ] ] in particular , we can associate a map : @xmath243 } \longto \bc[[z ] ] , \qquad f(q ) \longto \lnp_f(z)=1+\sum_{n=1}^\infty f(e^{2 \pi i / n } ) z^n.\ ] ] * elements of the habiro ring have taylor series expansions around @xmath244 ( and also around every complex root of unity ) . in other words , we can define a map : @xmath245 } \longto \bq[[z ] ] , \qquad f(q ) \longto \lp_f(z)=\calb ( f(e^{1/x})).\ ] ] * as in the case of analytic functions , the maps and are 1 - 1 . thus , @xmath246 determines @xmath247 and vice - versa . however , we need all the coefficients of the power series @xmath246 to determine a single ( eg . the third ) coefficient of @xmath247 . * given a homology sphere @xmath2 , there exists an element @xmath248}$ ] such that its image under the maps and coincide with the non - perturbative and perturbative invariants of @xmath2 discussed in section [ sub.npinvariants ] and [ sub.pinvariants ] . this was a main motivation for habiro , and was extended to knots in 3-space by huynh - le in @xcite . one may ask for an extension of conjecture [ conj.1 ] for the series @xmath246 and @xmath247 that come from the habiro ring . unfortunately , the habiro ring is uncountable ( whereas all quantum invariants of knotted objects lie in a countable subring ) and it has little structure as such . thus , it is unlikely that the series @xmath246 associated to a random sequence of laurent polynomials @xmath249 ( as in ) will be resurgent . concretely , we can pose the following problem with overwhelming numerical evidence : show that @xmath246 is not resurgent when @xmath250 in @xcite , le and the author introduced a countable subring @xmath251}^{\mathrm{hol}}$ ] that consists of elements of the form : @xmath252 , \quad ( f_n(q ) ) \quad \text{is $ q$-holonomic}\ ] ] where @xmath253-holonomic means that @xmath249 satisfies a linear @xmath253-difference equation with coefficients in @xmath254 $ ] ; see @xcite . in @xcite it was shown that the elements @xmath255 and @xmath256 of the habiro ring actually lie in the countable subring @xmath251}^{\mathrm{hol}}$ ] . show that for every @xmath257}^{\mathrm{hol}}$ ] , the series @xmath246 and @xmath246 are arithmetic resurgent . in the next section , we will discuss formulate a resurgence conjecture for some special elements of the habiro ring that do not always come from topology . conjecture [ conj.1 ] and problem [ prob.hab ] ask for proving that certain power series are arithmetic resurgent . however , they do not explain the source of resurgence . usually , resurgence is associated with a differential equation , linear or not ; see for example @xcite and also @xcite . in this section we will give another construction of powers series @xmath258 and @xmath259 which aims to explain the origin of arithmetic resurgence . this section was motivated by conversations with o. costin and j. calle whom we thank for their generous sharing of their ideas . let us first introduce the notion of _ series of sum - product type_. consider function @xmath260 analytic in @xmath261 $ ] with @xmath262 and the corresponding sequence and series of sum - product type : @xmath263 and the corresponding series @xmath264.\ ] ] since @xmath262 , it follows that the formal power series @xmath265\ ] ] is also well - defined . let @xmath259 denote the borel transform : @xmath266.\ ] ] let us now give a flavor of some results from @xcite and @xcite . in the rest of the section , let us consider @xmath260 of the following trigonometric type : @xmath267 where @xmath268 where @xmath269 , @xmath270 , @xmath271 for all @xmath150 , and @xmath272 for all but finitely many @xmath150 . in @xcite we construct elements of the extended bloch group , given by solutions of the algebraic equations : @xmath273 the values of these elements under the rogers dilogarithm defines a set @xmath274 , and its exponentiated cousin @xmath275 . @xcite @xmath258 and @xmath259 are arithmetic resurgent with singularities included in @xmath276 . notice that @xmath277 and @xmath278 where @xmath279 is an element of the countable habiro subring @xmath251}^{\mathrm{hol}}$ ] , where @xmath280 thus , theorem [ thm.cg ] is a special case of problem [ prob.habiro ] . equations appear in the _ dilogarithm ladders _ of lewin and others , whose aim is to produce interesting elements of algebraic @xmath19-theory . for a detailed discussion , see @xcite and @xcite . for the simplest knot @xmath21 and the simplest hyperbolic knot @xmath22 , we have : @xmath281 ( and likewise , equality for the @xmath282-series ) , where @xmath283 are both covered by theorem [ thm.cg ] . the resurgence conclusion of theorem [ thm.cg ] is valid for very general entire functions @xmath260 , with some mild hypothesis . for a detailed discussion , see @xcite and @xcite let us summarize what is known about conjecture [ conj.1 ] . conjecture [ conj.1 ] is known * for all 3-manifolds @xmath2 of the form @xmath284 where @xmath285 is a closed surface and all compact groups @xmath3 . indeed , this follows from the fact that @xmath1 is a polynomial in @xmath6 . thus , @xmath8 is a rational function of @xmath13 with denominator a power of @xmath286 . on the other hand , @xmath287 . * for @xmath288 where @xmath2 is the _ poincare homology sphere _ , or small seifert fibered 3-manifolds , see @xcite . in this lucky case , one uses explicit formulas for the coefficients of @xmath289 given zagier ( see @xcite ) which allow one show resurgence relatively easily . * for the simplest knot @xmath21 ( and also for @xmath290 torus knots ) ; and for the simplest hyperbolic knot @xmath22 ; see @xcite and @xcite . see remark [ rem.sp3 ] . our sample calculations below show the importance of the fractional polylogarithms and their analytic continuation , studied in detail in @xcite . let us confirm conjecture [ conj.1 ] for @xmath291 . for simplicity , we will choose @xmath54 . the case of other lie groups is similar . the witten - reshetikhin - turaev invariant is given by ( * ? ? ? * eqn.2.26 ) : @xmath292 expanding the above as a convergent power series in @xmath231 : @xmath293 and using the _ fractional polylogarithm _ @xmath294 defined for @xmath295 and @xmath5 by the convergent series : @xmath296 it follows that @xmath297 since @xmath298 has analytic continuation as a multivalued function in @xmath15 ( see @xcite ) , it follows that @xmath299 has analytic continuation on @xmath15 . we can further compute the monodromy around @xmath42 and @xmath300 using @xcite . let us confirm conjecture [ conj.1 ] for 3-manifolds of the form @xmath302 . for simplicity , we will choose @xmath54 . the case of other lie groups is similar . the witten - reshetikhin - turaev invariant is given by the famous _ verlinde formula _ @xcite : @xmath303 altough not a priori obvious , it it true that the right hand side of the above expression is a polynomial in @xmath6 of degree @xmath304 . in fact , we have ( * ? ? ? * sec.3 ) : @xmath305 when @xmath306 . for example , we have , @xmath307 it follows that @xmath308 is a rational function with denominator a power of @xmath309 . for example , we have : @xmath310 since @xmath311 is connected for all @xmath312 and @xmath3 , it follows that @xmath313 confirming conjecture [ conj.1 ] . let us give some details about how the work of @xcite and @xcite verify conjecture [ conj.1 ] for the simplest @xmath21 knot . an independent verification of the conjecture , valid for series of sum - product type , can be obtained by @xcite . equation ( 36 ) of @xcite and @xcite imply that we can write : @xmath314 where @xmath315 and @xmath160 is a multivalued analytic function ( analytic at @xmath42 ) : @xmath316 where @xmath317 denotes the _ unique primitive character of conductor _ @xmath318 : @xmath319 together with proposition [ prop.expar ] , this implies that the singularities of @xmath320 are @xmath321 . moreover , the local expansion of @xmath320 around @xmath322 is given by : @xmath323 where @xmath44 is a function holomorphic at @xmath42 . since @xmath324 is multivalued analytic at @xmath15 ( see @xcite ) , this confirms conjecture [ conj.1 ] for @xmath21 . using a mittag - leffler type decomposition for the fractional polylogarithm from ( * ? ? ? * eqn.13 ) , we can also verify the symmetry conjecture for @xmath21 . conjecture [ conj.1 ] gives an exact formula for the singularity of @xmath122 which is nearest to the origin . notice that this singularity does not in general coincide with the critical value of @xmath86 corresponding to the discrete faithful representation . this was indeed observed numerically for several _ twist knots_. let @xmath325 denote the twist knot with negative clasp and @xmath326 full twists , where @xmath327 : @xmath328 in particular , we have : @xmath329 the invariant trace field of @xmath325 is of type @xmath330 $ ] for @xmath331 and @xmath332 $ ] for @xmath333 . it follows that @xmath334 is a subset of a union of @xmath335 ( resp . @xmath336 ) horizontal lines , symmetric with respect to the @xmath13-axis , and a superposition of @xmath105 ( resp . @xmath120 ) copies of the @xmath13-axis for @xmath331 ( resp . @xmath333 ) . this set can be computed exactly and numerically using the methods of @xcite . the corresponding element of the habiro ring is given by : @xmath337 where @xmath338 $ ] denote the @xmath6-cyclotomic polynomial of @xmath325 . the latter may be computed inductively with respect to @xmath6 for each fixed @xmath326 , see @xcite . using this formula , one can compute 500 coefficients of @xmath339 , and then numerically compute the singularity of the series @xmath340 nearest to the origin . the numerical method used was the following : * fix a truncated power series @xmath341 where @xmath342 is a sufficiently large integer ( eg @xmath343 ) . * using the root test , one can compute approximately the radius of convergence @xmath344 of the series @xmath345 * plot @xmath346 for @xmath150 near the inverse of the radius of convergence . the plot reveals a blow - up at certain values @xmath347 of @xmath348 . * this suggests singularities at @xmath349 , and an asymptotic expansion of @xmath166 with a term of the form : @xmath350 in general , we have a finite sum ( over @xmath347 ) of terms of the above form . * one can numerically compute the constants @xmath351 and @xmath352 by fitting data . a fitting method ( also used by zagier in @xcite ) can improve the rate of convergence to @xmath353 for any @xmath75 . we used @xmath354 . this was done for the twist knots of equation . if @xmath355 denote the inverse of the radius of convergence of the series @xmath340 then we obtain numerically that : @xmath356 these numbers agree with the absolute value of @xmath357 for @xmath219 some galois conjugate of the discrete faithful representation . we thank n. dunfield , s. shumakovitch and c. zickert for their help in the numerical computations . additional numerical evidence for @xmath358 and @xmath359 ( and for many series of 1-dimensional sum - product type ) was obtained by @xcite . an early version of these conjectures was delivered by lectures in columbia university , cuny , universit paris vii , and orsay in the fall of 2006 and in aarhus , baton - rouge , hanoi and strasbourg in the summer of 2007 . the author wishes to thank the organizers of the conferences for their hospitality , and also n. a campo , y. andr , n. dunfield , m. kontsevich , w. neumann , t. pantev , d. sullivan , d. thurston , d. zeilberger and c. zickert . above all , the author expresses his gratitude to o. costin , j. calle and d. zagier for many enlightening conversations . in this section we will give a formal proof of the relation among @xmath258 and @xmath259 for series of sum - product type . we will use the notation from section [ sec.sp ] . suppose that @xmath360 for all @xmath361 $ ] . then , it is easy to see that @xmath258 is convergent inside the unit disk @xmath5 . the next theorem describes an explicit relation between @xmath258 and @xmath259 . we have : @xmath362 where @xmath44 is analytic at @xmath42 . we will give only the formal calculation , leaving the analytic details to the reader . below , @xmath44 will denote a germ of an analytic function at @xmath42 . for @xmath4 , let @xmath363 denote the coefficient of @xmath364 in @xmath365 given in . let us fix @xmath366 and consider @xmath6 large enough . then , we have : @xmath367 thus , @xmath368 ignore the @xmath369 terms , and interchange summation and integration . we obtain that @xmath370 where @xmath371 is the @xmath29-polylogarithm . the latter is a multivalued analytic function on @xmath15 with an asymptotic expansion at @xmath300 of the form : @xmath372 where @xmath44 is an analytic function at @xmath42 ; see for example , ( * ? ? ? * eqn.6 ) . thus , @xmath373 letting @xmath374 , and replacing @xmath13 by @xmath375 it follows that : @xmath376 this concludes the formal calculation . in this section we will give a path integral formula for @xmath8 using as input the famous chern - simons path integral studied in the seminal paper of witten ; see @xcite . with the notation of @xcite and with our normalization we have : @xmath377 where @xmath76 is the affine space @xmath76 of @xmath3-connections on the trivial bundle @xmath74 over @xmath2 . since @xmath80 takes values in @xmath88 , we require that the level @xmath6 ( which plays the role of the inverse planck s constant ) be integer . without loss of generality , we assume that @xmath4 . formally separating the @xmath378 contribution in and interchanging summation and integration in , it follows that the above formula is an infinite dimensional analogue of a _ riemann - hilbert problem _ , and was obtained during a conversation with kontsevich in the fall of 2006 . for a detailed discussion on the riemann - hilbert problem , see @xcite . finite dimensional analogues of the riemann - hilbert problem are discussed in @xcite .
Abstract: | [
"the purpose of the paper is to introduce some conjectures regarding the analytic continuation and the arithmetic properties of quantum invariants of knotted objects . more precisely , we package the perturbative and nonperturbative invariants of knots and 3-manifolds into two power series of type p and np , convergent in a neighborhood of zero , and we postulate their arithmetic resurgence . by the latter term , we mean analytic continuation as a multivalued analytic function in the complex numbers minus a discrete set of points , with restricted singularities , local and global monodromy . we point out some key features of arithmetic resurgence in connection to various problems of asymptotic expansions of exact and perturbative chern - simons theory with compact or complex gauge group . finally , we discuss theoretical and experimental evidence for our conjecture ."
] | 7,890 | 7,890 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: long - lived low - mass stars are a local relic of the earliest stages of the galaxy s formation . dubbed the population ii in contrast to the disk population i , these stars make up the galactic halo ( sometimes called spheroid ) . although comprising only a very small faction of the stars in the galaxy , population ii stars provide one of the most important records of galactic history . the population ii luminosity function is of particular interest since its derivation is a requirement in most studies of the stellar mass function . determination of the stellar mass function as function of galactic epoch and metallicity provides significant constraints upon the theory of star formation . evolution of the mass function with time or metallicity might be expected since conditions in star - forming clouds were likely much different in the protogalaxy ( c.f . @xcite ) . moreover , since halo brown dwarfs have faded far below the threshold for even near - infrared detection , the form of the subdwarf mass function near the hydrogen - burning limit represents the most effective technique ( in the absence of gravitational lensing detections ) for estimating the population ii dark matter contribution . despite the intuitive simplicity of the process of counting stars to determine the luminosity function , there have substantial disagreements between different studies in both the normalization and slope of the luminosity function ( see the review of @xcite ) . two recent surveys have measured the space density of very - low - mass population ii stars , the m subdwarfs . counts of faint , distant m subdwarfs using hst ( @xcite ) predict @xmath0 times fewer stars at @xmath1 than are found locally by dahn et al . dahn et al . ( 1995 ) base their study upon a sample of the local high proper motion stars in the lhs catalog ( @xcite ) for which they have measured accurate trigonometric parallaxes . in this paper , we determine the luminosity function of the field population ii m subdwarfs using a new proper motion survey based upon plates taken as part of the first and second palomar sky surveys . in section [ general : halolf ] , we discuss some general problems with the selection of halo stars . in section [ data : halolf ] , we describe the data used in our survey and the methods used to select a halo sample . in section [ lf : halolf ] , we use our data to measure the m subdwarf luminosity function . in section [ discussion : halolf ] , we compare our luminosity function to other published luminosity functions and discuss its significance . in section [ conclusion : halolf ] , we summarize our results . in the appendix , we describe some stars that may be of particular interest . measurement of the population ii luminosity function is considerable more difficult than the measurement of the population i luminosity function , for the simple reason that the population ii represents a tiny fraction of stars locally . one must either count very faint stars at large distances from the galactic plane ( @xcite ) , in which case one sacrifices the ability to obtain spectroscopic data , or else determine some way to identify the local population ii stars by excluding the local @xmath2 of stars that belong to the disk . the latter course requires an efficient method of eliminating the disk stars before time - consuming followup observations are obtained . as members of a high velocity - dispersion , low rotation population , subdwarfs tend to have high heliocentric velocities , and choosing an initial sample of proper motion stars increases the halo contribution from @xmath3 to @xmath4 ( schmidt 1975 ) . such selection criteria introduce some kinematic bias , but lead to a much more manageable sample . nevertheless , such a sample is still dominated by old disk ( population i ) and `` thick disk '' ( intermediate population ii , ipii ) stars . as recognized by schmidt ( 1975 ) and further discussed by bahcall & casertano ( 1986 , hereafter bc ) , even a small proportion of contamination by high velocity disk stars can lead a gross overestimate of the space density of the halo . in order to ensure a pure halo sample for his study , schmidt imposed a restrictive velocity criterion ( @xmath5 km / s ) and then applied a correction to account for halo stars with smaller velocities . bc used monte carlo simulations to estimate a correction factor of 3.03 for a cutoff velocity of @xmath6 km s@xmath7 ( this correction is dependent on the kinematics assumed for the underlying population ) . most recently , this technique has been used to derive a halo luminosity function from the lhs catalog stars with @xmath8 and @xmath9 ( @xcite ) . if trigonometric parallaxes are available for the target stars , then the distances and tangential velocities are estimated easily and the appropriate kinematic criteria can be applied . this is the case for the schmidt ( 1975 ) sample and the dahn et al . ( 1995 ) samples . measurement of a useful trigonometric parallax requires years of observing and the the target must be relatively close ( @xmath10 pc ) . expansion of the sample to cover a larger space volume requires a less direct method of distance estimation . photometric parallaxes provide that method , with the calibrating color - absolute magnitude relations provided by subdwarfs with high quality trigonometric parallaxes . the efficiency of the initial selection of halo candidates can be increased by use of the `` reduced proper motion '' , h , first used by luyten ( 1939 ) . it is defined as @xmath11 where m is the apparent magnitude and m is the absolute magnitude . note that @xmath12 is distance independent and determined entirely by observables . if we assume a color - magnitude relationship , we can plot constant tangential velocity contours on the data . figure [ figure - rpm - demo ] illustrates the concept , where data are plotted for 2111 m dwarfs within @xmath1330 parsecs of the sun(reid et al . 1995 ; hawley et al . 1996 ) . ( note that the increasing proper motion bias for redder stars in the gliese & jahreiss 1991 nearby star catalog is clearly evident . ) the lines illustrate where a disk population with halo - like velocities will lie , and how halo stars will be even more easily distinguished in the diagram . as subluminous stars in the ( m@xmath14 , ( r - i ) ) and ( m@xmath14 , ( v - i ) ) planes , halo stars have systematically larger h than disk dwarfs at a given color , mimicking the effects of increasing @xmath15 . in contrast , the coolest metal - poor subdwarfs are superluminous in the ( m@xmath16 , ( b - v ) ) plane ( gizis 1997 ) , and a cutoff in the ( h@xmath16 , ( b - v ) ) diagram tends to discriminate against lower - abundance stars . we have therefore defined our sample of candidate halo subdwarfs as those stars with reduced proper motion , h@xmath14 , which exceed the value predicted for _ disk _ dwarfs with @xmath17 km s@xmath7 and of the appropriate ( v - i ) or ( r - i ) color . since the halo stars are subluminous , this selection corresponds to a cutoff velocity that is a function of metallicity - an effect which is taken into account in the subsequent analysis . we utilized the techniques described above to define our sample . proper motion stars were identified using the first and second epoch 48-inch schmidt photographic plates , as described in ( section [ mumeasure ] ) . an initial cut of the sample was made to select large tangential velocity stars ( section [ rpm ] ) . we then obtained spectra of each candidate halo star to estimate its metallicity and radial velocity ( section [ spectroscopy : halolf ] ) . table [ table - plates ] lists the fields analyzed in the current survey . in each , the effective area is @xmath18 square degrees , with most having plate material spanning a baseline of at least 40 years . in each case , the first epoch plates were taken with the 48-in . oschin telescope as part of the first palomar observatory sky survey ( hereafter possi ) . for the most part , the second epoch plates were taken in the 1980s by either the 48-in . oschin telescope ( in the course of the palomar observatory second sky survey , possii ) or by the u.k . schmidt telescope ( ukst ) . these second epoch plates were used by tinney , reid , & mould ( 1993 , hereafter trm ) in their determination of the disk luminosity function . all of the possi plates were scanned by the apm facility at the institute of astronomy , cambridge , while the possii / ukst plates were scanned by cosmos at the royal observatory , edinburgh . one additional field , centered near the north galactic pole , was included . as described by reid ( 1990 ) , the second epoch plates for this field were taken at palomar in 1976 , and all plate material was scanned by cosmos . each of these scans yields positions ( both pixel x , y positions on the plate and right ascension , declination positions on the sky ) , magnitudes , and morphological classification as stars , galaxies , `` merged stars '' or noise . all objects classified as noise were excluded from further analysis . as a preliminary to identifying proper motion stars , all objects ( stars and galaxies ) identified in the scans of the plates taken at the same epoch must be matched . in the case of the first epoch possi data , this is straightforward , since the o and e plates ( corresponding roughly to photometric b and r observations ) were taken on the same night . thus there is no real motion between the time of the observations and the plate scans can be matched by demanding positional coincidence to a high level of precision . for our second epoch trm data , the iiiaf ( photometric r ) and iv - n ( photometric i ) plates were not observed on the same night . trm paired the objects identified on their scans using a 3 arcsec box . since the trm plates were taken @xmath19 years apart , this procedure loses the highest ( @xmath20 arcsec yr@xmath7 ) proper motion stars . in our survey , this is not a concern because the 40 year separation between the first and second epoch , with no plates at intermediate epochs , prevents our identifying reliably stars with high proper motion due to the large number of possible pairings . the effective upper limit for our survey is @xmath21=0.375 arcsec yr@xmath7 , and that limit is taken into account in our luminosity function analysis . we should note that the trm detections are restricted to the region within 3 degrees of the plate center in order to avoid the vignetted regions near the edge of the plates , and that the cosmos scans did not cover the entire plate . the appropriate area of the survey is given in table [ table - plates ] . moreover , the the possi field centers do not correspond to the possii / ukst field centers . thus , between one and four possi plates are paired with the trm fields , as listed in table [ table - plates ] . the identification of the proper motion stars was made as follows . first , an initial pairing of objects within a 3 arcsecond box ( @xmath22 ) was made . in each field , the surface density of celestial objects is sufficiently low that matching within this radius results in an unambiguous pairing . figure [ figure - close513 ] illustrates the agreement between the @xmath23 and e magnitudes for one representative pairing ( possii field 513 and possi e102 ) . most of the outliers evident in this plot are correct pairings of extended objects ( galaxies or merged stars ) they are outliers due to differences in the definitions of magnitudes used by the two machines , as well as the different plate characteristics . for this study , we are interested only in stars , so such outliers are unimportant . having paired the unambiguous matches , we obtain a list of unmatched objects these objects have no counterparts within 3 arcseconds at the second epoch and are good candidates for proper motion stars . eliminating paired objects , we find all possible matches within 15 arcsec of unmatched objects . we exclude pairings which have magnitudes inconsistent with the e @xmath23 relation delineated by the close matches inconsistent being defined as a discrepancy of from @xmath241 magnitude @xmath25 to @xmath26 magnitudes at @xmath27 . these limits are `` conservative '' in the sense that some false pairings are included in order to avoid excluding true proper motion stars . the vast majority of objects on the plate should show insignificant proper motion between the two epochs , but directly matching the right ascension and declination catalog positions leads to many ( false ) proper motion objects . those spurious motions arise from systematic errors in the relative positions of the two catalogs ( caused by differing plate centers , inadequacy of the plate model , plate variations , telescope differences , etc . ) these systematic positional errors can be corrected by determining the transformation between the original pixel positions for the two epochs ( @xmath28 and @xmath29 ) . both our own experience with the trm fields and the reid ( 1990 ) analysis showed that a polynomial solution over the entire plate works poorly , producing many false proper motion stars . analysis over smaller regions , however , is effective . each plate was divided into approximately one by one degree regions and the positional transformation determined using second - order two - dimensional polynomials . only stars with @xmath30 matches were used for the initial co - ordinate transformation , iterating twice to exclude objects with large ( @xmath31 ) residuals . we then used these polynomial solutions to determine the proper motions of _ _ a__ll stars in the field . the stars that prove to have @xmath32 arcsec yr@xmath7 are included in our sample of proper motion stars . the selection of the candidate halo stars is described in section [ rpm ] . these proper motions are measured relative to faint stars , which have typical distances of @xmath33 pc . thus we expect the reference frame to have a small , but non - zero , mean proper motion . we derive the conversion from this relative frame to an absolute ( extragalactic ) frame using measurements of objects classified as galaxies . the latter are identified using the @xmath34-parameter defined by picard ( 1991 ) . we take @xmath35 for these purposes , which provides a sample dominated by galaxies . the upper cutoff is taken to exclude the `` fuzziest '' galaxies we found that these `` fuzzy '' galaxies have large spurious proper motions , which we attribute to a combination of the different plate material used at the different epochs , and the different scanning and centroiding techniques used at the apm and cosmos . in figure [ figure - absmu ] , we plot the distribution of galaxy proper motions and stellar proper motions for the fields . it is clear that the galaxies do indeed show a systematic shift with respect to the stars . table [ table - absmu ] lists the median proper motions ( @xmath36 ) derived for the galaxies , which at most amount to @xmath37 mas yr@xmath7 . we have checked these values by comparison with the projection of the solar motion and rotational lag for the ipii and halo populations . the direction of motion derived by the galaxies ( i.e. , the _ sign _ of the proper motions ) agrees with the expectations . these values given in table [ table - absmu ] are used to correct the relative proper motions to an absolute system : @xmath38 we also give the observed standard deviation of the galaxian motions , with values in the range @xmath39 mas yr@xmath7 . these provide an estimate of the uncertainties of our proper motions , but we expect that the extended galaxies should have poorer positions , and hence less accurate proper motions , than is the case for stars . it is evident in table [ table - absmu ] that field 831 shows the largest random errors and has absolute proper motions correction that are discrepant at the @xmath40 mas level from the adjoining fields . r. mendez ( private communication ) has kindly computed model proper motions for this direction based upon the galactic structure model of mendez & van altena ( 1996 ) . the predicted mean stellar proper motions of ( @xmath41 ) = ( @xmath42 ) mas yr@xmath7 are in excellent agreement with our observations in fields 829 and 832 . we take this as confirmation that our simple correction technique using galaxies is adequate for our purposes . the data for field 831 are evidently of lower astrometric quality , but the accuracy remains adequate for identifying the high proper motion stars analyzed in this study . the nltt catalog ( @xcite ) offers an opportunity to check both the completeness and accuracy of our measurements . as noted by many authors , identifying the nltt stars can be difficult since some of the positions are quite poor ( for example , we find a star that matches the magnitudes and proper motion of lp 621 - 64 , but is 10 _ arcminutes _ east of luyten s position ) . excluding stars which are too bright , too faint , or too blue ( i.e. , too faint to be seen on the possii iv - n plates ) , we find that 122 of 137 nltt stars are recovered , indicating a completeness of at least @xmath43 . we find that the standard deviations of @xmath44 and @xmath45 are in the range 10 to 25 mas yr@xmath7 . luyten estimated his motions to be accurate to @xmath46 mas yr@xmath7 . the combination of our uncertainties estimated from the galaxies and the nltt uncertainties account for the observed scatter . selection of halo candidates using reduced proper motion requires photometry in addition to the proper motions . we have used the photometry from the second epoch plates which provides us with r and i measurements for each star ( except in the ngp field , for which we have v and i ) . we adopt the photometric calibration determined by trm using ccd measurements for each plate . because their ( `` palomar '' ) calibration is on a unique system , we describe it briefly here . a complete description is given by trm . the best defined photometric system in r and i for late - type stars is the cousins system ( @xcite ) is cousins r - i , @xmath47 is trm s palomar system , and @xmath48 is gunn r - i . ] however , m dwarfs have strong color terms in this system because the r@xmath49 band filter extends far into the i band as a result , the effective wavelength of the r@xmath49 filter moves redward for cooler stars , as discussed by bessell ( 1986 ) . the possii iiiaf emulsion plus filter combination has a sharper long - wavelength cutoff at @xmath50 , so the color term differs significantly from the standard cousins system . the possii response is close to the gunn r filter defined by thuan & gunn ( 1976 ) . therefore , trm s ccd calibrations of the fields used gunn r@xmath51 and i@xmath51 filters but observed _ cousins _ late - type standards . these ccd magnitudes were matched to the cosmos photographic magnitudes . they found that no significant i color term was necessary to calibrate the observations but , as expected , a strong r color term was necessary . thus , their photometric observations consist of an r magnitude , denoted @xmath23 , an i magnitude , denoted @xmath52 , and a color , denoted @xmath47 , for each star . the relation between the standard cousins color and the palomar color is @xmath53 @xmath54 note that trm use the relation @xmath55 , but examination of their figure 2 indicates that there is no offset between @xmath52 and @xmath56 for @xmath57 , which is the color of the halo stars in our survey . the v and i photometric calibration for the ngp field is described in reid ( 1990 ) . the reduced proper motion diagram for field 513 is shown in figure [ figure - rpm513 ] . the solid line marks the disk main sequence defined by trm , @xmath58 offset to match @xmath59 km s@xmath7 . stars falling below this line ( larger h@xmath14 ) are identified as halo candidates for spectroscopic followup . recently , we have pointed out that the disk main sequence shows evidence for a `` kink '' at spectral type m4.0 v ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . while this feature is not included in the trm calibration , it occurs at @xmath60 , so it is not relevant to the current selection of candidate halo subdwarfs . while our tangential velocity limit is set at @xmath6 km s@xmath7 for solar abundance stars , m subdwarfs are selected at smaller @xmath15 . the esdm enter the candidate pool for @xmath61 km s@xmath7 and the brighter sdm at @xmath62 km s@xmath7 . the most likely contaminants , modestly metal - poor ( @xmath63 \approx -0.6 $ ] ) intermediate population ii m dwarfs , lie @xmath64 magnitudes below the disk main sequence ( @xcite , figure 7 ) , and therefore enter at @xmath65 km s@xmath7 . we obtained optical spectra of the candidate halo stars in order to determine radial velocities and metallicities . the hale 200-in . and the las campanas du pont 100-in . telescopes were used to obtain data in the wavelength range @xmath66 with @xmath67 resolution . these parameters were chosen to correspond to the observations of nearby m dwarfs ( @xcite ; @xcite ) and m subdwarfs ( @xcite ) that we have already published . for the 200-in . observations , we used the double spectrograph ( oke and gunn 1982 ) . in august 1995 , the blue camera was set to observe @xmath68 and the red camera was set to @xmath69 using @xmath70 l / mm gratings blazed at @xmath71 and @xmath72 respectively . in october 1995 , a new red camera was installed in the double spectrograph and was used in all subsequent runs to observe the region @xmath73 at @xmath74 with the @xmath70 l / mm grating blazed at @xmath72 . with this setup , the blue camera was used to cover @xmath75 with a @xmath76 l / mm grating blazed at @xmath77 . in practice , the latter data were useful only for the bluest ( @xmath78 ) stars . the du pont observations used the modular spectrograph with a 1200 line grating blazed at @xmath79 . from these spectra , we determined radial velocities and spectral types . during each observing run , we observed k and m radial velocity standard stars drawn from the list of marcy & benitz ( 1989 ) . a velocity for each candidate halo star was determined by cross - correlating with the best match standard star . comparison of subdwarfs with known radial velocities observed during the same runs shows that the accuracy is @xmath80 km s@xmath7 ( @xcite ) . using these radial velocities , we measured tio and cah bandstrength indices , as defined originally by reid et al . each index measures the ratio of the flux ( @xmath81 ) within the absorption feature to nearby pseudo - continuum points . table [ table - index ] lists the wavelength definitions of the features ( w ) and the pseudo - continuum ( s1,s2 ) points . we have defined a spectral classification system using these indices ( @xcite ) . stars are classified as disk stars ( m v ) , m subdwarfs ( sdm ) , or extreme m subdwarfs ( esdm ) . we have shown on the basis of model atmosphere calculations ( @xcite ) that these empirical classifications correspond to @xmath63 \approx -0.5 $ ] , @xmath63 \approx -1.2\pm 0.3 $ ] , and @xmath63 \approx -2.0 \pm 0.5 $ ] ( where @xmath63\approx[fe / h]$ ] ; @xcite ) . each halo candidate has been classified using this system . in this section , we calculate the i - band luminosity function from the data described in section [ data : halolf ] . the luminosity function , @xmath82 , is defined as the number of stars per cubic parsec per magnitude in a bin centered at @xmath83 . we use schmidt s ( 1968 ) @xmath84 technique to estimate @xmath82 @xmath85 @xmath86 where @xmath87 is the solid angle on the sky of the survey , @xmath88 is the maximum distance that a given star could have been detected in this survey , and @xmath89 is the corresponding volume . a minimum distance , @xmath90 , also appears to account for the distance at which the star would have evaded detection due to the upper proper motion limit of @xmath91 yr@xmath7 . the maximum distance may be limited by either the lower proper motion limit ( @xmath92 yr@xmath7 ) or the limiting magnitudes ( @xmath93 ) , hence for a star , distance d , magnitudes ( r , i ) , @xmath94 ; \rm{dex}[0.2(i_0-i)]\right)\ ] ] we estimate the associated error by assuming that each star contributes an uncertainty of @xmath84 ( @xcite ) . then @xmath95 as noted in section [ general : halolf ] , we apply a tangential velocity cutoff in order to ensure a `` pure '' halo sample . we adopt a value of @xmath96 km s@xmath7 in our main analysis . as a result , a correction must be applied to the apparent luminosity function in order to obtain the space of density of halo stars . thus , @xmath97 the discovery fraction @xmath98 is a function of position on the sky and the adopted @xmath99 . in our case , we compute @xmath98 for each field in the survey . this procedure is described in section [ kinematic : halolf ] . a check on the completeness of the survey can be made by considering @xmath100 which considers the ratio of the volume @xmath101 corresponding to the star s actual distance @xmath102 to @xmath89 . in the case of a spatially uniform sample , such as the halo over the volume probed by this survey , we expect @xmath103 . we find that eight of our nine fields are within @xmath104 of 0.5 for sdm / esdm with @xmath105 km s@xmath7 , and conclude that , as a whole , the survey is complete statistically . we use the photometry and parallax data compiled by gizis ( 1997 ) to determine color - magnitude relations appropriate for each spectral class of star ( m v ; sdm ; esdm ) . there are many sdm and esdm with accurate distance determinations available , mainly due to the efforts of the usno ccd parallax program ( @xcite ) , which allows us to determine the following relations : @xmath106 @xmath107 these relations are valid for @xmath108 . our survey is aimed at the fainter , redder m subdwarfs , but for comparisons to other surveys of higher mass stars it is useful to have an estimate of the main sequence for the bluer subdwarfs . for these stars , the above linear relations are no longer appropriate , due to an inflection in the main sequence at @xmath109 ( c.f . , @xcite ; @xcite ) . unfortunately , there are few parallax k subdwarfs and fewer with red ( ri ) photometry . the hipparcos mission , however , has determined parallaxes for many g subdwarfs . we therefore fit a linear relation to the hipparcos g subdwarfs supplemented by the available k subdwarfs from the fourth edition of the yale parallax catalog ( van altena et al . 1996 ) . in this region , models predict that for @xmath63 \lesssim -1 $ ] the absolute magnitudes are relatively insensitive to metallicity ( @xcite ) . we select only stars with @xmath110 km s@xmath7 to ensure a halo sample . the data are shown are in figure [ figure - hipp ] . there are 29 subdwarfs with @xmath111 , @xmath112 , and @xmath113 . we find @xmath114 this slope is consistent with the slope measured in globular clusters by santiago et al . ( 1996 ) . the above relations can only be used for the ngp field , where we have v and i photometry . unfortunately most sdm and esdm lack r photometry , while we have only r and i data for the remaining fields in our survey . hence we have determined the relationship between @xmath115 and @xmath47 using equation [ ri - ri ] and bessell s ( 1990 ) vri@xmath49 photometry of nearby stars . we find : @xmath116 applying this transformation to the @xmath115 color of each parallax star , we find that @xmath117 @xmath118 relations [ ms - ri - sdm ] and [ ms - ri - esdm ] are valid for @xmath119 . it is possible that the r - i , v - i transformation for the extreme m subdwarfs is not the same as that for disk m dwarfs . while the currently available photometry ( summarized in @xcite ) is unable to resolve this issue , we have obtained spectrophotometry ( @xcite ) which indicates that there is no significant color term for the sdm stars or the earliest ( esdk7 ; esdm0.0 ) extreme subdwarfs . for the g subdwarfs , we transform equation [ ms - vi - sdg ] and obtain : @xmath120 equation [ ms - ri - sdg ] applies for @xmath121 . the luminosity function computed using the techniques described above , although correct in shape , represents only the fraction of the halo that has @xmath122 km s@xmath7 . given a kinematic model of the halo , we can calculate the discovery fraction ( @xmath98 ) for each field using monte carlo simulations . bc have shown that variations of @xmath123 km s@xmath7 in the kinematic parameters ( @xmath124,@xmath125 , @xmath126,@xmath127 ) imply variations of less than @xmath128 in @xmath98 ; sadly , published data for halo stars span a much larger range of kinematics . we therefore compare the observed kinematics of our survey stars to the predictions of representative halo models . analyses of local ( d@xmath129 1 kpc ) halo stars generally derive mild prograde rotation ( e.g. , @xmath130 km s@xmath7 , norris 1986 ) , although recent studies based on more distant ( @xmath245 kpc ) halo stars have found evidence for a retrograde rotating halo ( see the review of majewski 1993 ) . we compare our data to the models of bahcall & casertano ( 1986 , bc ) , norris ( 1986 , n ) , casertano et al . ( 1990 , crb ) , layden et al . ( 1996 , l ) , and beers & sommer - larson ( 1995 , bsl ) . the last is of considerable interest as it features a retrograde rotating halo . for each of these models , we generated a monte carlo simulation of our survey with @xmath131 detected stars . the halo velocities are represented by gaussian distributions in u , v , and w.,@xmath132 ) , v represents motion in the direction of galactic rotation , and w represents motion perpendicular to the galactic plane . ] in table [ table - compareuvw ] , we compare the predictions of the u , v , and w velocity distributions of the models to the actual data for the 35 metal - poor stars with @xmath133 . we emphasize that these are the predicted velocity characteristics of the kinematically - biased observed sample , not the true halo kinematics . we also give the probability that the observed data and the model simulations are drawn from the same distributions , as determined by kolmogorov - smirnov tests . the comparison is most sensitive to the observed v velocities , which are most important in determining @xmath98 . it clear that all the published models agree fairly well with the observed u and w velocity distribution , although the n model is significantly poorer for u , due to its smaller velocity dispersion ( @xmath134 km s@xmath7 ) . the v velocities favor prograde halos , with the bc model ( @xmath135 km s@xmath7 ) yielding too small a mean v velocity and the n model ( @xmath136 km s@xmath137 ) yielding too large a mean velocity . the bsl model s retrograde halo is much less likely than the prograde models . of the published models , the layden et al . model gives the highest probability when all three velocity components are considered . guided by the comparison above , we have constructed a composite kinematic model , taking the parameters derived by norris as a starting point and increasing both @xmath125 to match other studies , and the halo rotation to a value midway between bc and n. the resulting parameters are @xmath138 in km s@xmath7 and we refer to this as our model a. these changes are within @xmath139 of norris s estimated uncertainties . the values of @xmath140 for the bc and n models lie within @xmath141 of the composite values , which are listed in table [ table - corr ] . values of @xmath140 based on the layden et al . halo model are on average @xmath142 smaller . we have also calculated models including the ipii ( bsl , crb ) . only one in @xmath143 ipii stars will enter our @xmath110 km s@xmath7 sample ( although we caution that this number depends upon the assumption of gaussian kinematics ) . since the ipii consists of approximately @xmath144 of stars locally , it will contribute less than @xmath145 of our observed halo sample and thus will not bias significantly our measurements . this can also been seen in table 1 of bc , where it is shown that the kinematic properties of stars in eggen s ( 1979a , 1980 ) proper motion catalog with @xmath146 , @xmath147 and @xmath148 km s@xmath7 are indistinguishable . we expect that the ipii contribution is much less than this , since direct spectroscopic observation shows that most ipii m dwarfs both locally ( nearby stars with @xmath149 km s@xmath7 , gizis 1997 ) and at height of a few kiloparsecs ( @xcite ) are not classified as sdm or esdm . we reject all spectroscopic m v stars from our sample , and therefore we expect negligible ipii contamination . for each field , we calculate the luminosity function using the equations [ equation - firstlf ] to [ equation - lastlf ] using only stars with @xmath150 km s@xmath7 . we combine data for all fields to derive our best estimate luminosity function , calculated for 0.5 magnitude bins , which is listed in table [ table - lf ] . these conservative selection criteria ensure a pure population ii halo sample but suffers from the uncertainty of the kinematic correction . since we have obtained spectroscopy for all of our reduced proper motion selected stars , we have information on the actual space density of metal - poor very - low - mass stars with lower velocities ( @xmath151 km s@xmath7 for esdm ; @xmath62 km s@xmath7 for sdm ) . we have therefore computed the space density of sdm and esdm separately , using the appropriate velocity cutoff for each metallicity class . the completeness corrections , @xmath152 , for these velocity cutoffs are only @xmath153 , since virtually all halo stars have @xmath62 km / s . the resulting luminosity functions for the sdm and esdm are listed in table [ table - lf - lowvtan ] . this luminosity function is remarkably consistent with that estimated from the corrected `` pure '' halo sample . the normalizations differ by no more that @xmath142 from that predicted by our composite model . we discuss these low-@xmath15 samples in more detail in section [ discussion : halolf ] . our measurement of the population ii luminosity function is aimed at only the limited range in luminosity corresponding to the fainter m subdwarfs . nonetheless , these results offer a means of resolving the difference , noted in the section [ halolf - intro ] , between gould et al.s hst starcount analysis at @xmath154 kpc and dahn et al.s local trigonometric parallax sample . before discussing that issue , we consider whether our results can be combined with previous measurements of the bright end of the halo luminosity function . since previous studies of the halo luminosity function have presented @xmath155 for all metallicities combined , we have transformed our data using the relation @xmath156 and the color - magnitude relations given in section [ section : colormag ] . the results for the combined sdm and esdm luminosity function is plotted in figure [ figure - field - mv ] . the other luminosity functions shown are the local trigonometric parallax samples of schmidt ( 1975 ) and dahn et al . , the local photometric parallax sample of bahcall & casertano ( 1986 ) , and the gould et al . hst starcount analysis . we have not plotted dawson s ( 1986 ) statistical analysis of the lhs stars , since it is superceded by dahn et al.s calculations , which have the advantage of improved data for individual stars . schmidt s results have been updated using literature v - band photometry , but there are only 0 - 2 stars per bin , except for the last two bins which have five stars apiece . it should also be noted that , except for the hst data , these estimates of @xmath157(m@xmath16 ) are based on kinematically - selected samples . dahn et al s @xmath15 correction factors , @xmath98 , agree to within 5% with the values predicted by our model a , and we have also used that model to adjust schmidt s data . the bahcall & casertano @xmath157(m@xmath16 ) plotted is derived using their published correction factors . adopting @xmath98 appropriate to model a reduces the inferred space densities by @xmath158 , increasing the discrepancy with respect to the other studies ( including our own results ) . it is obvious from figure [ figure - field - mv ] that there are potential problems involved in combining data from the several investigations to derive a halo luminosity function spanning the full range in absolute magnitude . of the surveys which include brighter stars near the turnoff , schmidt s luminosity function ( as noted originally by schmidt ! ) has too few stars to measure reliably the shape of the luminosity function . the bc dataset has sufficient stars , but there is a clear , systematic offset of almost a factor of two between their derived space densities and dahn et al s results . bahcall & casertano s analysis is based on eggen s ( 1979a , 1980 ) survey of southern ( @xmath159 ) stars with @xmath160 yr@xmath7 and v@xmath161 , but a comparison of both the relative numbers and @xmath162 distributions of such stars shows no evidence for any significant increase in incompleteness at southern declinations . on the other hand , the color - magnitude relation ( from eggen , 1979b ) which bc use to estimate distances is a poor description of the lower pop . ii main sequence ( m@xmath163 ) , and therefore that portion of @xmath157(m@xmath16 ) should probably be excluded . the calibration is likely to be more reliable for the more luminous stars , since the main sequence is consistent with the hipparcos data in figure [ figure - hipp ] for the g subdwarfs . one notable aspect of the eggen / bc sample is that it may be incomplete in the galactic plane , since it is difficult to identify proper motion stars against the dense stellar background . we have simulated halo samples using the bc , a , and l models for both `` all - sky '' ( @xmath159 ) and `` non - plane '' ( @xmath164 and @xmath165 ) selection . the kinematic correction factors ( @xmath140 for @xmath110 km s@xmath7 ) for the `` non - plane '' samples are greater than the `` all - sky '' samples by between 8% and 12% depending on the model . however , our analysis of the eggen ( 1979a , 1980 ) data shows that the derived halo space density for stars with @xmath166 is actually @xmath167 higher than that derived for the entire eggen sample . this suggests that the bc luminosity function is underestimated by @xmath4 due to incompleteness in the galactic plane . this would account for about a third of the discrepancy evident in figure [ figure - field - mv ] . naively combining the higher - luminosity stars from bc with dahn et al . and our own results for fainter stars suggests a rather steep luminosity function . globular clusters provide a potential means of testing this result . figure [ figure - gci ] compares @xmath157(m@xmath14 ) from the field against results for two of the better - studied clusters , using data from piotto et al . ( 1997 ) adjusted to be consistent with the new distances derived by reid ( 1997 ) on the basis of main - sequence fitting . that comparison suggests that the bc results may underestimate the space densities of stars with @xmath168 , consistent with the offset between the bc and dahn et al results plotted in figure [ figure - field - mv ] . it should of course be noted that the field and cluster luminosity functions may differ the present - day luminosity ( mass ) function of globular clusters could be affected by dynamical evolution , or alternatively the initial mass function of field and cluster stars could be different . extension of the dahn et al . sample to brighter absolute magnitudes ( e.g. , expanding the schmidt sample ) should provide the most effective means of confirming the shape of the field luminosity function . the dahn et al . luminosity function , transformed via equation [ ms - vi - esdm ] is also plotted , but the transformation is uncertain since we have assumed all stars to be esdm , which is not the case and in any case , this preliminary dahn et al . luminosity function represents a range of metallicities , so it may not be fair to compare it to the globular clusters . nevertheless it is clear that the dahn et al . luminosity function peaks at a fainter absolute magnitude than the globular clusters . as noted above , figure [ figure - field - mv ] suggests that the gould et al ( 1998 ) hst analysis underestimates the local density of late - type halo subdwarfs by a factor of four . to underscore that point , figure [ figure - field - mi ] plots our luminosity function against a @xmath82 representation of the hst data that was computed by gould ( private comm . ) using the same data and techniques used to derive the @xmath169 luminosity function of gould et al . while our study is limited to a restricted range of luminosity , the space densities , derived from a completely independent sample of nearby subdwarfs , are clearly strongly supportive of the lhs - star analysis . a possible resolution of the discrepancy between the distant - halo and local - halo analyses may lie in the composite nature of the galactic halo . sommer - larsen & zhen ( 1990 ) estimate that at least 40 percent of the local subdwarfs reside in a highly - flattened component , which would essentially be absent from the hst dataset . taken in isolation , this additional component can account only partially for the factor of four offset in the derived densities . however , its presence underlines the substantial extrapolation involved in transforming the observed number density at large distances from the plane to a local halo subdwarf density . an additional contribution could be due to the choice of local calibrating subdwarfs for the gould et al . analysis , which may be biased towards higher metallicities . this would lead to overestimated m@xmath16 and distance , and hence an underestimate of the space density . for a discussion of possible systematic errors , see gould et al.s discussion . the kinematics of the very - low - mass halo stars are consistent with those found for higher mass metal - poor stars . the strongest conclusion is that prograde rotating halos are favored . if the expanded halo sample that includes lower tangential velocity stars is included , then kinematics like those of model a is favored over layden et al.s rr lyrae kinematics , since the expanded luminosity function is more consistent with the model a corrected pure halo sample ( tables [ table - lf ] and [ table - lf - lowvtan ] ) . there _ may _ be an excess of sdm at low velocities over the halo model a predictions . since metallicities of @xmath63 \approx -1.2 \pm 0.3 $ ] are expected to have some ipii contribution , this is not too surprising . if the two best determined bins are used , then the excess is only @xmath170 . chiba & yoshii ( 1998 ) find an excess of @xmath171 in the range @xmath172 \le -1.0 $ ] based upon hipparcos data for red giant and rr lyrae stars , in excellent agreement with our results . the mass function can be estimated using the observed luminosity function and a mass - luminosity relation as follows : @xmath173 this is often parameterized as a power - law with the form @xmath174 since there are no direct determinations of mass for any sdm or esdm stars , we must rely upon theoretical mass - luminosity relations . these must be viewed with caution for example , reid & gizis ( 1997 ) have shown that , in the case of the baraffe et al solar - abundance models , the slope deduced from nearby - star data for the disk mass function depends on the passband used in the analysis . our data do not provide sufficient range in @xmath83 to estimate the mass function reliably , even given a good mass - luminosity relationship , but it does allow us to estimate the relative numbers of sdm and esdm stars at a mass of @xmath175 . we transform the observed pure halo @xmath83 luminosity functions into mass functions using the baraffe et al . ( 1997 ) models . we adopt the @xmath63= -1.0 $ ] and @xmath63= -1.5 $ ] interior models for the sdm and esdm respectively , and fit a power - law to the mass function in order to obtain the best estimate of the numbers . the ratio of sdm to esdm at @xmath176 is 0.38 . in comparison , we obtain a ratio of 0.36 if we adopt the alexander et al . ( 1997 ) models , and 0.60 for the dantona & mazzitelli ( 1996 ) tracks but the latter match the observed @xmath177 main sequence poorly . these results are consistent with the carney et al . ( 1994 ) distribution of metallicities for higher mass stars ( mainly g subdwarfs ) @xmath178 of their stars in a pure ( @xmath179 km s@xmath7 ) halo sample have @xmath63>-1.5 $ ] . thus , the metallicity distribution for the very - low - mass stars of the halo ( @xmath180 ) is apparently the same as that of stars on the upper main sequence ( @xmath181 ) . barring a cosmic conspiracy of offsetting parameters , the most reasonable explanation is that the mass function in the halo is independent of metallicity . although our data is inadequate to constrain the mass function well , we note that the best - fit parameters are @xmath182 for the esdm and @xmath183 for the sdm . these compare with a power - law index of @xmath184 for disk stars in the mass range @xmath185 ( @xcite ) . the consistency of the metallicity distribution and kinematics of the low - mass stars ( sdm and esdm ) is not surprising , but nevertheless important . studies of the halo , whether using evolved stars such as rr lyrae or red giants , or main sequence stars ( f , g subdwarfs ) , assume that the properties of stars in the narrow mass range from just below the turnoff to the tip of the asymptotic giant branch ( @xmath186 , are representative of the halo population as a whole . our results verify one aspect of this assumption for stars near the bottom of the halo main sequence . we have derived a new estimate of the space density of very low mass metal - poor stars . comparisons with other surveys shows that we are in agreement with the dahn et al . ( 1995 ) survey based upon trigonometric parallaxes of lhs catalog stars . this implies that the local space density of metal - poor stars is higher than that predicted by hst observations of more distant stars . our work provides measurements of the kinematics and metallicity distribution of very - low - mass stars . these measurements are consistent with those from studies of higher - mass stars in the halo . we find that the esdm are 2.5 times as common as sdm at @xmath187 . this is consistent with the relative numbers of metal - poor ( @xmath63 \le -1.5 $ ] ) and metal - rich ( @xmath188 > -1.5 $ ] ) g subdwarfs found by carney et al . ( 1994 ) . note that the two metallicity scales are comparable because gizis & reid ( 1997 ) have found agreement between the carney et al . metallicities of fgk subdwarf primaries with metallicities based upon g97 . the agreement of the metallicity distribution at both low and high mass implies that the mass function is not a strong function of metallicity for ( @xmath189 ) halo stars . this result is supported by the general similarity of the mass functions derived for the two metallicity bins considered ; however , those mass functions depend upon uncertain model mass - luminosity transformations . we thank chris tinney and mike irwin for assistance with the plate scans and the staff of palomar observatory for their capable support . we also thank m. schmidt for useful conversations and a. gould for providing the i - band hst luminosity function . j.e.g . is grateful for partial support through greenstein and kingsley fellowships as well as nasa grants go-05353.01 - 93a , go-05913.01 - 94a , and go-06344.01 - 95a , this work is based partly on photographic plates obtained at the palomar observatory 48-inch oschin telescope for the second palomar observatory sky survey which was funded by the eastman kodak company , the national geographic society , the samuel oschin foundation , the alfred sloan foundation , the national science foundation grants ast84 - 08225 , ast87 - 19465 , ast90 - 23115 and ast93 - 18984 , and the national aeronautics and space administration grants ngl 05002140 and nagw 1710 . this research has made use of the simbad database , operated at cds , strasbourg , france . most of our subdwarfs lie at distances of greater than 200 parsecs , and therefore are more difficult to study than lhs catalog subdwarfs . three of our stars , however , are close enough that additional observations may be profitable . all were previously identified by luyten ( 1979 - 1980 ) . the positions ( b1950 , at the epoch given in table [ table - plates ] ) and other data for these stars are given in table [ table - stars ] . spectra of the subdwarfs lp 622 - 7 and lp 382 - 40 are plotted in figure [ figure - stars1 ] . lp 622 - 7 has a proper motion too large to be included in our complete sample , and was observed at the palomar 60-in . in june 1995 . the radial velocity may be unreliable due to a problem with the calibrating arc lamp exposure . lp 589 - 7 is one of the coolest subdwarfs known . its spectral indices are tio5@xmath190 , cah1=@xmath191 , cah2=@xmath192 , and cah3@xmath193 . in figure [ figure - stars2 ] , we show that this star is extremely similar to the esdm5.0 ( @xcite ) star lhs 3061 ( @xmath194 , @xcite ) . the conspicuous tio absorption at @xmath195 distinguishes both these stars and the slightly cooler lhs 1742a ( @xmath196 , esdm5.5 ) from the other two very cool extreme subdwarfs lhs 205a ( @xmath194 , esdm5.0 ) and lhs 1826 ( @xmath83 unknown , esdm6.0 ; @xcite ) . lp 589 - 7 is just as close as lhs 1742a , so it is an excellent candidate for a trigonometric parallax . there is a hint of @xmath197 emission in our spectrum of lp 589 - 7 . the feature , which may not real but lies at the correct wavelength , has an equivalent width of @xmath198 . two sdm systems ( lhs 482 and lhs 2497 ) are known to show emission due to close companions ( @xcite ) . since lp 589 - 7 is near the hydrogen burning limit , any companion must be either a very faint , old white dwarf ( as for the lhs 482 system ) , a nearly equal luminosity m companion ( as for lhs 2497 ) , or else a brown dwarf ( if it proves to be too faint to contribute detectable light ) . alternatively , lp 589 - 7 could a `` young '' metal - poor star with an age of up to a few billion years . if an sb2 , its estimated distance and tangential velocity should be increased by up to @xmath199 . all this is speculative , however , since the @xmath197 feature is weak and may not be real . alexander , d.r . , brocato , e. , cassisi , s. , castellani , v. , ciacio , f. , & deglinnocenti , s. 1997 , , 317 , 90 allard , f. , & hauschildt , p.h . 1995 , , 445 , 433 bahcall , j.n . , & casertano , s. 1986 , , 308 , 347 ( bc ) baraffe , i. , chabrier , g. , allard , f. , & hauschildt , p.h . 1997 , , 327 , 1054 baraffe , i. , chabrier , g. , allard , f. , & hauschildt , p.h . 1998 , , 337 , 403 beers , t.c . , & sommer - larsen , j. 1995 , , 96 , 175 bessell , m.s . 1986 , , 98 , 1303 carney , b.w . , latham , d.w . , laird , j.b . , and aguilar , l.a . 1994 , , 107 , 2240 casertano , s. , ratnatunga , k.u . , bahcall , j.n . 1990 , , 357 , 435 chiba , m. , & yoshii , y. 1998 , , 115 , 168 cool , a.m. , piotto , g. , & king , i.r . 1996 , , 468 , , 655 cousins , a.w.j . 1973 , mem.r.a.s . , 77 , 223 dahn , c.c . , liebert , j. , harris , h.c . , & guetter , h.h . 1995 , the bottom of the main sequence and beyond , edited by c.g . tinney ( berlin , springer ) , p.239 dantona , f. , & mazzitelli , i. 1996 , , 456 , 329 dawson , p.c . 1986 , , 311 , 984 eggen o.j . 1979a , , 39 , 89 eggen o.j . 1979b , , 230 , 786 eggen o.j . 1980 , , 43 , 457 felton , j.e . 1976 , , 207 , 700 gizis , j.e . 1997 , , 113 , 806 gizis , j.e . 1998a , ph.d . thesis , california institute of technology gizis , j.e . 1998b , , 115 , 2053 gizis , j.e . , & reid , i.n . 1996 , , 111 , 365 gizis , j.e . , & reid , i.n . 1997 , , 109 , 894 gliese , w. , & jahreiss , h. 1991 , preliminary version of the third catalog of nearby stars ( cns3 ) gould , a. , flynn , c. , bahcall , j.h . 1998 , , in press hawley , s.l . , gizis , j.e . , & reid , i.n . 1996 , , 112 , 2799 layden , a.c . , hanson , r.b . , hawley , s.l . , klemola , a.r . , & hanley , c.j . 1996 , , 112 , 2110 luyten , w.j . 1939 , publ . minnesota , 2 , 121 luyten , w.j . 1979 , catalogue of stars with proper motions exceeding 0.5 annually ( lhs ) , ( university of minnesota , minneapolis , minnesota ) luyten w. j. , 1979 - 1980 , new luyten catalogue of stars with proper motions larger than two tenths of an arcsecond , ( minneapolis , university of minnesota ) , computer - readable version on adc selected astronomical catalogs vol.1 - cd - rom marcy , g.w . , & benitz , k.j . 1989 , , 344 , 441 majewski , s.r . 1993 , , 31 , 575 mendez , r.a . , & van altena , w.f . 1996 , , 112 , 655 monet , d.g . , dahn , c.c . , vrba , f.j . , harris , h.c . , pier , j.r . , luginbuhl , c.b . , & ables , h.d . 1992 , , 103 , 638 mould , j.r . 1996 , , 108 , 35 murray , s.d . , & lin , d.c . 1996 , , 467 , 728 norris , j. 1986 , , 61 , 667 oke , j.b . , & gunn , j.e . 1982 , , 94 , 586 paresce , f. , de marchi , g. , & romaniello , m. 1995 , , 440 , 216 picard , a. 1991 , , 102 , 445 piotto , g. , cool , a.m. , king , i.r . 1997 , , 113 , 1345 reid , n. 1990 , , 247 , 70 reid , i.n . 1997 , , 114 , 161 reid , i.n . , hawley , s.l . , & gizis , j.e . 1995 , , 110 , 1838 reid , i.n . , & gizis , j.e . 1997 , , 113 , 2246 reid , i.n . , gizis , j.e . , cohen , j.g . , pahre , m.a . , hogg , d.w . , cowie , l. , hu , e. , & songaila , a. 1997 , , 109 , 539 santiago , b.x . , gilmore , g. , elson , r.a.w . 1996 , , 281 , 871 schmidt , m. 1968 , , 151 , 393 schmidt , m. 1975 , , 202 , 22 sommer - larsen , j. & zhen , c. 1990 , , 242 , 10 stobie , r.s . , ishida , k. , & peacock , j.a . 1989 , , 238 , 709 tinney , c.g . , reid , i.n . , & mould , j.r . 1993 , , 414 , 254 ( trm ) thuan , t.x . , & gunn , j.e . 1976 , , 88 , 543 van altena , w.f . , lee , j.t . , & hoffleit , e.d . 1995 , the general catalogue of trigonometric stellae parallaxes , fourth edition ( schenectady , l. davis press ) zinnecker , h. 1995 , the bottom of the main sequence and beyond , edited by c.g . tinney ( berlin , springer ) , p.257 rrlccclc [ table - plates ] 829 & 02 & 00 & + 00 & uk / pii & 1987.83 & eo852 & 1953.78 + 831 & 02 & 40 & + 00 & uk / pii & 1981.92 & eo1283 & 1954.90 + & & & & & & eo1453 & 1955.81 + 832 & 03 & 00 & + 00 & uk / pii & 1986.89 & eo363 & 1951.69 + & & & & & & eo1453 & 1955.81 + 262 & 10 & 15 & + 45 & possii & 1987.34 & eo672 & 1953.12 + ngp & 13 & 04 & + 29 & palomar & 1976.23 & eo1393 & 1955.29 + 868 & 15 & 00 & + 00 & uk / pii & 1987.30 & eo1402 & 1955.30 + & & & & & & eo1613 & 1957.32 + 513 & 15 & 00 & + 25 & possii & 1987.34 & eo102 & 1950.35 + & & & & & & eo87 & 1950.30 + & & & & & & eo1390 & 1955.29 + & & & & & & eo1092 & 1954.49 + 889 & 22 & 00 & + 00 & possii & 1990.55 & eo1146 & 1954.57 + 890 & 22 & 20 & + 00 & possii & 1990.82 & eo364 & 1951.69 + & & & & & & eo1146 & 1954.57 + crrrr [ table - absmu ] & mas & mas & mas & mas + 262 & 2.6 & 5.2 & 13.0 & 13.7 + 513 & 4.4 & 4.2 & 12.1 & 11.8 + 829 & -3.7 & 3.8 & 14.9 & 13.9 + 831 & -2.0 & 2.3 & 17.0 & 16.0 + 832 & -4.3 & 3.9 & 13.6 & 12.6 + 868 & 3.2 & 3.3 & 13.6 & 12.6 + 889 & -0.2 & 4.3 & 10.6 & 10.6 + 890 & -0.9 & 3.4 & 11.9 & 11.5 + ngp & 5.0 & 3.9 & & + cccc [ table - corr ] 829 & 25.32 & 17.3 & 2.07 + 831 & 26.49 & 17.3 & 2.15 + 832 & 25.32 & 17.3 & 2.11 + 262 & 14.56 & 17.3 & 2.30 + ngp & 28.00 & 17.0 & 2.01 + 868 & 25.29 & 17.3 & 2.11 + 513 & 25.29 & 17.3 & 2.18 + 889 & 25.30 & 17.3 & 3.70 + 890 & 25.26 & 17.3 & 3.56 + cccccccc [ table - compareuvw ] @xmath125 & 171 & 171 & 146 & 179 & 165 & 155 & 158 + probability ( u ) & & 0.43&0.15&0.55&0.29&0.19&0.31 + @xmath124 & -234 & -222&-244&-240&-252&-264&-233 + @xmath126 & 76 & 82 & 82 & 84 & 73 & 76 & 85 + probability ( v ) & & 0.37&0.49&0.75&0.22&0.05&0.87 + @xmath127 & 90 & 77 & 86 & 97 & 94 & 105 & 86 + probability ( w ) & & 0.38&0.49&0.32&0.38&0.28&0.49 + rrlrlr [ table - lf ] & & 8.5 & 2.2 & 0.7 & 1.8 & 0.5 & 16 9.0 & 2.0 & 0.6 & 1.6 & 0.5 & 11 9.5 & 2.0 & 0.9 & 1.6 & 0.8 & 5 10.0 & 2.0 & 2.0 & 1.6 & 1.6 & 1 9.5 & 4.6 & 1.8 & 3.9 & 1.5 & 10 10.0 & 3.6 & 1.6 & 2.9 & 1.3 & 5 10.5 & 3.1 & 2.3 & 2.6 & 2.0 & 2 rrlrlr [ table - lf - lowvtan ] & & 8.5 & 2.6 & 0.8 & 2.5 & 0.7 & 20 9.0 & 2.4 & 0.8 & 2.2 & 0.7 & 14 9.5 & 4.4 & 1.3 & 4.1 & 1.2 & 12 10.0 & 3.1 & 1.6 & 2.9 & 1.5 & 4 10.5 & 3.6 & 3.6 & 3.4 & 3.4 & 1 9.5 & 6.9 & 1.8 & 6.6 & 1.7 & 20 10.0 & 2.5 & 1.0 & 2.4 & 1.0 & 6 10.5 & 4.1 & 2.1 & 3.9 & 2.0 & 4 11.0 & & & & & 0 11.5 & & & & & 0 12.0 & 15 . & 15 . & 15 . & 15 . & 1 lrrrrrrrrrrr [ table - stars ] lp 589 - 7 & 28.72333 & + 1.03647 & -0.12 & -0.33 & 15.90 & 1.38 & 11.77 & 64 & 106 & -65 & esdm5 + lp 382 - 40 & 223.53375 & + 23.83433 & -0.28 & -0.09 & 16.47 & 1.08 & 10.59 & 150 & 210 & -230 & esdm2.5/3 + lp 622 - 7 & 227.18958 & -1.02281 & + 0.20 & -0.43 & 13.87 & 0.87 & 9.69 & 69 & 155 & 300 & esdk7/m0 +
Abstract: | [
"we present results of a study of very low mass halo stars . using a sample of proper motion stars identified from plate material taken as part of the first and second palomar sky surveys , we measure the space density , metallicity distribution , and kinematics of the population ii m subdwarfs . our overall luminosity function is in good agreement with previous analyses of the space density of nearby very - low - mass halo subdwarfs , and confirms the discrepancy between local analyses and the space densities inferred from deep hst starcounts . we show for the first time that both the metallicity distribution and kinematics of late - type halo subdwarfs are consistent with those of their higher mass metal - poor counterparts . dividing our sample by abundance , we find no evidence that the mass function of field halo stars is dependent upon metallicity . we provide data for three nearby subdwarfs that may merit additional observations ."
] | 11,289 | 11,289 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: a goal of monte carlo ( mc ) simulations in statistical mechanics @xcite is the calculation of ensemble mean values of thermodynamic quantities . ensemble mean values are multidimensional integrals over configuration space @xmath0 where @xmath1 is the probability of finding a system in the state defined by @xmath2 , and the functional form of @xmath1 depends on the ensemble investigated . mc simulations usually generate a sampling of configuration space @xmath3 by the use of a stochastic process with stationary probability @xmath4 . the quantity @xmath5 evaluated at @xmath6 is the output of the simulation @xmath7 , and its arithmetic mean value @xmath8 , in principle , must approach the ensemble mean value.@xcite in this paper we refer to the set of configurations generated in a monte carlo simulation as a time sequence , and we study the behavior of these temporal sequences @xmath9 and their arithmetic mean , to understand better how mc simulations approach ergodic behavior . it is important to emphasize that there are two time variables to consider . the time variable @xmath10 labels the separate configurations generated in a monte carlo walk . variations of properties with @xmath10 provide information about the short - time behavior of a mc simulation . the time variable @xmath11 labels the total length of the mc walk , and variations of computed properties with @xmath11 provide information about the convergence of the simulation on a long time scale . given an infinite time , the stochastic walker in a mc simulation visits every allowed point in configuration space.@xcite ergodic behavior is reached when the length of the walk is sufficiently long to sample configuration space appropriately.@xcite in practice , this does not mean that the space has been densely covered but that every region with non - negligible probability has been reached . in such a case we can say that the simulation is effectively ergodic or that it has reached the ergodic limit . for a finite walk , in the event of broken ergodicity @xcite , phase space is effectively disconnected . the different disconnected regions ( called components ) are separated by barriers of zero effective probability . if a stochastic walker starts its walk in one of these regions , it may not cross the barriers within the time of the simulation . if the simulation length is increased , some barriers may become accessible for the walker and phase space is better sampled . we can conclude that a time @xmath12 exists such that , for simulation lengths shorter than @xmath12 , the walker becomes trapped in one of the phase space components . for simulation lengths much larger than @xmath12 , phase space is effectively covered by the walker . in this study we imagine a system having more than one time scale @xmath13 . in a monte carlo simulation each scale comes from stochastic processes with different correlation times.@xcite a precise definition of the correlation times for monte carlo processes is given in section iii , but for the moment we can think of these correlation times as identical to physical time scales of the system under study . to understand these time scales more fully , it is useful to focus on an example . prototypical of systems having such disparate time scales are atomic and molecular clusters . typical cluster potential surfaces have many local minima separated by significant energy barriers . @xcite the local minima can be grouped into basins of similar energies , with each basin separated from other basins again by energy barriers . at short monte carlo times a cluster system executes small amplitude oscillations about one of its potential minima . we can think of these vibrational time scales as the shortest time scales that define a cluster system . as the simulation time is extended the system eventually hops between different local minima within the same basin . the time scale for the first hops between local minima can be considered the next shortest time scale for the simulation . at still longer monte carlo times , the system hops between different energy basins defining yet another time scale for the simulation . this grouping of time scales continues until the longest time scale for a given system is reached . at monte carlo times that are long compared to this longest time scale , the simulation is ergodic . consider a system with several time scales as mentioned above . if the length of the simulation is smaller than the smallest correlation time , the walker may become trapped in an effectively disconnected region and the sampling of phase space is incomplete . by increasing the time , the memory of the initial condition in the sampling decreases as the walker crosses to other previously unreachable regions . these oscillations and hoppings can be modeled by a superposition of stochastic processes with different correlation times . these processes with non - zero correlation times are known as _ colored noise _ processes ( as opposed to zero correlation time _ white noise _ processes ) . @xcite from the study of the autocorrelation functions of a stochastic model defined using these colored noise processes , we can verify that , at a fixed run length @xmath11 , there exist two different groups of processes ; those that contribute to the autocorrelation function with terms that decay like @xmath14 ( called _ diffusive _ processes ) , and those that contribute to the autocorrelation function with terms that decay slower than @xmath14 ( called _ non - diffusive _ processes ) . when the time of the simulation is increased , some non - diffusive processes at shorter run lengths , start to contribute to the autocorrelation function like diffusive processes . after the walk length reaches the largest correlation time @xmath15 , all processes contribute to the autocorrelation function with terms that decay like @xmath14 . at this point , the simulation is at the diffusive regime and effective ergodicity has been reached . a principal goal of this work is to investigate the way in which the mc output @xmath9 reaches the diffusive limit ( i.e. the ergodic limit ) by studying the properties of autocorrelation functions under changes of scale in time , @xmath16 with @xmath17 . by time scaling it is possible to infer the decay law of the non - diffusive contributions with respect to the total simulation time @xmath11 . the functional dependence of the non - diffusive contributions on the parameter @xmath18 that is used to scale @xmath11 is determined empirically . we have found the decay law so determined to be a particularly valuable method of concluding when a simulation can be considered ergodic . unlike previous studies @xcite that only have investigated the behavior of certain autocorrelation functions in the ergodic regime , by focusing on the approach to ergodic behavior we have a more careful monitor of the onset of ergodicity . once the non - diffusive contributions have decayed to a point where they are too small to be distinguished from zero to within the fluctuations of the calculation , we can say that the ergodic limit has been reached . the autocorrelation functions we use to measure the approach to the ergodic limit are based on one of the probes of ergodicity developed by thirumalai and co - workers @xcite , and is often called the _ energy metric_. the energy metric has been proposed as an alternative to other techniques @xcite ( like the study of the lyapunov exponents @xcite ) for the study of ergodic properties in molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations . the metric has been used to study the relative efficiency of mc simulation methods as well . @xcite the mc metric as used in the current work can easily be extended from the energy to other scalar observables of the system . we present two key issues in this paper . first , from the knowledge of the decay law of the non - diffusive contributions to the mc metric , we infer how long a simulation must be to be considered effectively ergodic . second , once the ergodic limit is reached , we can compare the results from different numerical algorithms to measure relative efficiencies . because the outcomes of mc simulations are noisy , we have found it useful to separate diffusive and non - diffusive terms in the mc metric with a fourier analysis so that we can neglect the high frequency components of the noise . this technique has given reproducible results . to test the match between the stochastic model and actual monte carlo simulations , we examine the approach to ergodic behavior in simulations of lennard - jones clusters . recently @xcite we have studied the thermodynamic properties of lennard - jones clusters as a function of temperature using both j - walking @xcite and parallel tempering methods . @xcite both simulation techniques require an initial high temperature that must be ergodic when metropolis monte carlo methods @xcite are used . if the metropolis method does not give ergodic results at the initial high temperature , systematic errors propagate to the lower temperatures in j - walking and parallel tempering simulations , and the results can be flawed or meaningless . in most monte carlo simulations of clusters at finite temperatures , @xcite the clusters are defined by enclosing the atoms within a constraining potential about the center of mass of the system . the constraining potential is necessary because clusters at finite temperatures have finite vapor pressures , and the association of any one atom with the cluster can be ill - defined . from experience @xcite we have found that if the radius of the constraining potential and the initial high temperature are not both carefully chosen , it can be difficult to attain ergodicity with metropolis methods . a key concern then is the choice of constraining radius and the choice of initial temperature . we verify the stochastic model by investigating monte carlo simulation results as a function of the temperature and the size of the constraining potential . the contents of the remainder of this paper are as follows . in section ii we motivate the studies that follow by examining numerally the behavior of a set of monte carlo simulations of a 13-particle lennard - jones cluster . this cluster system is used to illustrate the results throughout this paper . in section iii we introduce the stochastic model based on a continuous time sequence . in section iv we extend the model to discrete time sequences characteristic of actual monte carlo simulations . in section v we test the discrete stochastic model with applications to lennard - jones clusters and in section vi we summarize our conclusions . many of the key derivations needed for the developments are found in two appendices . before discussing the major developments of this work , it is useful to understand the nature of the problem we are attempting to solve by examining some numerical results on a prototypical system . we take the 13-particle lennard - jones cluster defined by the potential function @xmath19 + \sum_{i=1}^nv_c ( \vec{x}_i , r_c ) \label{pot}\ ] ] where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are the standard lennard - jones energy and length parameters , @xmath22 is the number of particles in the cluster ( 13 in the present case ) , @xmath23 is the distance between particles @xmath24 and @xmath25 @xmath26 and @xmath27 is the constraining potential discussed in sec . i @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the coordinate of the center of mass of the cluster and @xmath30 is the radius of the constraining sphere . the 13-particle lennard - jones cluster has a complex potential surface with many minima separated by significant energy barriers , @xcite and ergodicity problems associated with the simulation of properties of this system are well - known . @xcite we now consider a metropolis mc simulation of the average potential energy of the system in the canonical ensemble at temperature @xmath31(@xmath32 is the boltzmann constant ) . this average potential energy @xmath33 is defined by @xmath34 and is displayed in the upper panel of fig . 1 as a function of the walk length @xmath10 for 20 independent simulations each initialized from a random configuration . over the maximum time scale @xmath11 of the walks , it apparent that the potential energy averaged over each independent walk has not converged to the same result . such unreproducible behavior is symptomatic of a simulation not yet at the ergodic limit . = .48 the upper panel shows the time evolution " of @xmath33 ( in units of @xmath20 ) for @xmath35 independent experiments . the lower panel shows @xmath36 ( in units of @xmath37 ) vs. @xmath10 for the experiments of the upper panel . @xmath30 has been set to @xmath38 and @xmath31 . at least two basins with different energies are present . clearly , @xmath36 goes to a constant when @xmath10 is increased within the total time scale of the simulation . at the ergodic limit ( i.e. for the maximum walk length @xmath11 greater than that included in fig . 1 ) the averages displayed in the upper panel of fig . 1 must approach the same value for each walker . using related ideas developed elsewhere , @xcite the extent to which the walks approach the same limit can be measured in terms of a metric @xmath36 defined by @xmath39 ^ 2\,\,,\ ] ] in eq . ( [ omega1 ] ) @xmath40 represents the number of independent walks , and @xmath41 is the average potential energy computed in walk @xmath24 at mc time @xmath10 . the metric measures the energy fluctuations in the walk as a function of the walk length . for an ergodic simulation , the metric must decay to zero . for the 20 simulations of the 13-particle lennard - jones cluster , the metric as a function of @xmath10 is plotted in the lower panel of fig . 1 . rather than asymptotically approaching zero , over the short length of the walk displayed here , @xmath36 has decayed to a constant , and as discussed later in this paper , over the time scale of this simulation , @xmath36 can be qualitatively represented by the function @xmath42 where @xmath43 and @xmath44 are coefficients that are dependent on the total walk length @xmath11 . as @xmath11 is increased to a time where the walk is ergodic , @xmath44 must decay to zero . major goals of this work are to understand how @xmath44 decays and to use the discovered decay law to determine the onset of ergodic behavior . our approach is to introduce first a continuous stochastic model of a simulation followed by a discrete model more clearly linked to actual mc studies . we have discussed in the introduction how the output of mc simulations can be considered to be a combination of stochastic processes with different time scales , and how the contributions to autocorrelation function from these processes can vary when the length of the simulation is enlarged . here we present a continuous time model for the stochastic processes that occur in a simulation . even though a mc simulation occurs in a discrete time ( each mc point represents a time unit ) , we find that the continuous model helps to understand better the ideas used in the modeling of the mc output . in this section the ensemble mean value is used to find the expression for the autocorrelation functions of the model . although in actual numerical calculations the ensemble mean is replaced by a mean over a finite number of independent experiments , the results obtained here give information about the limit of an infinite sample . the stationary process used to sample space is a stochastic process . we assume the output of the mc simulation can be modeled by a linear superposition of stochastic processes with different correlation times @xmath45 , @xmath46 where @xmath47 is a constant , the random variable @xmath48 represents white noise processes with zero correlation time ( @xmath49 ) , and the @xmath50 are stochastic processes with correlation times @xmath51 . @xmath48 and @xmath52 have units of the square root of time , and @xmath53 and @xmath54 are constants with units of @xmath55 . if @xmath5 is chosen to be the the @xmath56-coordinate of a particle , @xmath53 and @xmath54 have units of a diffusion constant . consequently we refer to these constants as generalized diffusion coefficients . the white noise process has the following properties @xcite @xmath57 and the remaining colored noise processes are assumed to satisfy @xmath58 so that they represent processes with a memory @xmath59 . even though correlations between processes with different correlation times may be non - zero , we assume the processes to be independent , i.e. @xmath60 the memory function is assumed to be a continuous function that depends only on the distance between @xmath61 and @xmath62 disregarding the time origin ( stationary condition ) . the memory function represents the correlation between two times of the process @xmath63 . in our model we impose the condition @xmath64 the scope and implications of the leftmost inequality are explored in appendix a. in appendix a we also examine the conditions @xmath59 must satisfy in order to yield contributions to autocorrelation function that decay more weakly than @xmath65 . we now assume that this inequality can be taken as a bound to possible maxima of @xmath59 appearing at @xmath66 . the rightmost inequality enables us to assume @xmath59 is normalized @xmath67 we have identified here the time scale @xmath68 with the correlation time of the stochastic process @xmath63 . this identification is valid if @xmath69 which implies that the behavior of @xmath59 at large @xmath61 must be @xmath70 , or smaller . in addition , by the properties of the ensemble mean value , we have that for all real @xmath71 @xmath72 ^ 2\right\rangle \nonumber\\ & \leq & \left\langle g_{\ell}(t/\tau_{\ell})^2\right\rangle + 2\lambda\,\left\langle g_{\ell}(t/\tau_{\ell})\ , g_{\ell}(t'/\tau_{\ell } ) \right\rangle + \lambda^2\left\langle g_{\ell}(t'/\tau_{\ell})^2\right\rangle \nonumber\\ & \leq & \frac1{\tau_{\ell}}\left\ { f_{\ell}(0 ) + 2\lambda\ , f_{\ell}\left(\frac{|t - t'|}{\tau_{\ell}}\right ) + \lambda^2\ , f_{\ell}(0 ) \right\ } \label{a3}\,\,.\end{aligned}\ ] ] equation ( [ a3 ] ) must be true for all @xmath71 . therefore , the discriminant of the polynomial in @xmath71 must be non - positive @xmath73 \left[f_{\ell}\left(\frac{|t - t'|}{\tau_{\ell}}\right ) + \ , f_{\ell}(0)\right]\leq0\,\,.\ ] ] consequently , @xmath74 . other properties of @xmath59 are studied in appendix a. the ensemble mean value @xmath75 is time independent . the ensemble mean value of the noise processes is zero . therefore , @xmath47 must be equal to @xmath75 . processes defined by eq . ( [ eq:2 ] ) have two different components , uncorrelated white noise and correlated processes with correlation time @xmath68 . because the goal of the simulation is the calculation of the ensemble mean @xmath76 by the analysis of the time series , we study the behavior of the temporal mean @xmath77 @xmath78 where @xmath79 is a wiener process , @xcite @xmath80 with @xmath81 , and @xmath82 . equation ( [ eq:3 ] ) implies that the evolution of the temporal mean @xmath77 has the same structure as @xmath5 , with an uncorrelated term and terms with tailed correlation functions . the autocorrelation function of the process @xmath8 at times @xmath61 and @xmath62 is defined by @xmath83 where we have used eqs . ( [ a1 ] ) and ( [ a2 ] ) to neglect terms involving processes with different correlation times . because we have assumed @xmath59 is a continuous function , @xmath59 reaches its maximum and minimum value within any closed interval considered . the @xmath84th non - diffusive contribution to @xmath85 @xmath86 is bounded @xmath87 2 where @xmath88 , and @xmath89 is the time at which @xmath59 reaches its minimum value in the closed interval @xmath90 $ ] . there exists a @xmath91 $ ] @xcite such that , @xmath92 using eqs . ( [ wiener2 ] ) and ( [ tl ] ) in ( [ c1 ] ) , we find that @xmath93 for all times shorter than @xmath94 the autocorrelation function is the sum of _ diffusive contributions _ ( proportional to @xmath65 ) plus _ non - diffusive contributions_. these contributions implicitly depend on @xmath95 through @xmath96 . we assume that @xmath59 satisfies the conditions stated in appendix a , so that the dependence of @xmath59 on @xmath61 is _ weaker than _ @xmath65 ( for total time scales shorter than @xmath68 ; see appendix a ) . we next consider the behavior of eq . ( [ correl ] ) for time scales greater than @xmath94 . under the scale change @xmath97 such that @xmath98 , the contributions to the correlation function from the process with correlation time @xmath94 can be considered diffusive [ in other words , by virtue of eqs . ( [ noise2 ] ) and ( [ ggg ] ) , @xmath99 has become a delta function ] . with @xmath100 , the other processes preserve their old properties . then , the autocorrelation function can be expressed @xmath101 the complete derivation of eq . ( [ urenor ] ) can be found in appendix b. for a times larger than the correlation time @xmath15 , all contributions to the autocorrelation function are diffusive , the simulation can be considered ergodic , the sampling complete , and the temporal mean is equal to the ensemble mean within @xmath102 mean square fluctuations . monte carlo simulations generate discrete sequences @xmath103 of values of the quantity under study . additionally , in actual calculations the ensemble of sequences is represented by a finite rather than an infinite set . in this section , the model developed in the previous section is extended to finite sets of discrete sequences . we express the @xmath40 sequences @xmath104 , where the label @xmath105 ranges from 1 to @xmath40 . the exact ensemble mean value @xmath75 can be obtained in the limit that @xmath40 becomes infinite . in analogy with the model developed in section iii , each output is assumed to have the form @xmath106 where @xmath107 the true ensemble average @xmath75 does not depend on the index @xmath108 . in the discrete case we define a metric @xmath109 ^ 2\,\,,\ ] ] where the bars represent the temporal mean value @xmath110 with @xmath111 observe that in the present case , our finite sample of the infinite ensemble is the set of outcomes from @xmath40 independent numerical experiments . the metric we have defined in eq . ( [ omega ] ) can be contrasted with alternative metrics @xcite previously defined for molecular dynamics simulations . these alternative metrics examine the fluctuations of two simulations initialized from different components of configuration space averaged with respect to all the particles in the system . the metric we use in this work is determined using an average with respect to @xmath40 independent simulations that represent a subset of the full ensemble . using the model presented in eq . ( [ seq ] ) , we now develop a way to predict the behavior of the mc simulation in the non - ergodic and the ergodic regimes . we first consider the case that the total simulation time @xmath11 is larger than the first correlation time @xmath94 but shorter than @xmath112 , i.e. @xmath113 . the expression for @xmath36 is given by @xmath114 ^ 2\nonumber\\ & = & \frac2 m \sum_{i=1}^m\left(\overline{u}^{(i)}_k-\langle u\rangle\right)^2 - \frac4{m(m-1 ) } \sum_{i=2}^m \sum_{j=1}^{i-1 } \left(\overline{u}^{(i)}_k-\langle u\rangle\right ) \ , \left(\overline{u}^{(j)}_k-\langle u\rangle\right)\nonumber\\ & = & 2\,\gamma_0 \,\frac1 m \sum_{i=1}^m \left(\frac{w_k^{(i)}}k\right)^2 + 2\,\gamma_1 \,\frac1 m \sum_{i=1}^m \left(\frac{g_{1;\,k/\tau_1}^{(i)}}k\right)^2 + 2\,\sum_{\ell=2}^{\lambda}\gamma_{\ell } \,\frac1 m \sum_{i=1}^m \left(\frac{g_{\ell;\,k/\tau_{\ell}}^{(i)}}k\right)^2 \nonumber\\ & & + \,4\,\sum_{\ell=1}^{\lambda}\sqrt{\gamma_0 \gamma_{\ell } } \,\,\frac1 m \sum_{i=1}^m\frac{w_k^{(i ) } \,g_{\ell;\,k/\tau_{\ell } } ^{(i)}}{k^2 } + \,4\,\sum_{\ell=2}^{\lambda}\sum_{\ell'=1}^{\ell-1}\sqrt{\gamma_{\ell } \gamma_{\ell ' } } \,\,\frac1 m \sum_{i=1}^m\frac{g_{\ell;\,k/\tau_{\ell}}^{(i ) } \,g_{\ell';\,k/\tau_{\ell ' } } ^{(i)}}{k^2 } \nonumber\\ & & - \frac4{m(m-1 ) } \sum_{i=2}^m \sum_{j=1}^{i-1 } \left(\overline{u}^{(i)}_k-\langle u\rangle\right ) \ , \left(\overline{u}^{(j)}_k-\langle u\rangle\right)\,\ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] if the number of experiments @xmath40 is sufficiently large , we can neglect terms involving processes with different correlation times , and products of sequences belonging to different experiments . under these assumptions we obtain @xmath115 2 equation ( [ om ] ) preserves the form of eq . ( [ correl ] ) . to make this statement explicit , let us rewrite eq . ( [ om ] ) as @xmath116 where @xmath117 in appendix b we present a study of the way non - diffusive contribution become diffusive under time scale changes . if @xmath40 is sufficiently large and @xmath118 , by virtue of appendix b , @xmath119 must roughly be a constant . by _ roughly a constant _ we mean a constant @xmath120 plus some rapidly fluctuating function @xmath121 , with the following properties : a ) @xmath122 and b ) @xmath123 . then @xmath124 if @xmath11 is enlarged , we expect to have a larger value of @xmath125 . @xmath126 is a quantity related to the memory functions @xmath59 with correlation times @xmath127 . in the continuous time model , the colored noise processes contribute to the autocorrelation function with terms proportional to @xmath128 , which are weakly dependent on @xmath61 ( see appendix a ) . we can expect @xmath126 to be weakly dependent on @xmath10 , and for sequences of length @xmath11 and for @xmath40 sufficiently large , we consider this quantity roughly to be a constant @xmath129 where @xmath130 represents additional random noise . then , for a given length @xmath131 , the mc metric @xmath36 can be approximated by @xmath132 where @xmath133 represents remaining stochastic noise from both contributions . in this approximation , @xmath125 and @xmath134 are the quantities that carry the long time dependence . short time features appear in the @xmath14 dependence and in the remaining noise @xmath135 . if the sequences considered are increased in size by a factor of @xmath18 , such that @xmath136 for a given @xmath137 , @xmath125 ( @xmath134 ) is increased ( decreased ) ( see appendix b ) . then , @xmath138 where @xmath139 must go to zero and @xmath140 must approach a constant when @xmath18 is increased . by virtue of the expected behavior of the non - diffusive contributions ( see appendix a ) , we propose the following expression for @xmath139 @xmath141 where @xmath142 is a decreasing function of @xmath18 . moreover , @xmath139 is a sum of non - diffusive contributions . as presented in appendix a , each non - diffusive contribution to the autocorrelation function has a relative variation smaller than the relative variation of the diffusive contribution , namely @xmath143 . if this inequality is applicable to the sum of non - diffusive contributions , we have that @xmath144 for all @xmath17 . then , @xmath145 must be either @xmath146 or @xmath147 with @xmath148 and @xmath149 . equation ( [ upa2 ] ) can be thought as the limit of eq . ( [ upa1 ] ) when the exponent goes to zero . we know of no _ a priori _ argument to justify eq . ( [ upa ] ) . however , as is discussed in section v , our numerical experience has shown eq . ( [ upa ] ) to be obeyed in all cases we have examined . our goal is to develop a criterion to decide when the simulation can be considered ergodic . from the previous considerations it is clear that the ergodic limit is reached when @xmath134 is indistinguishable from zero . the output from a mc simulation is usually noisy . therefore , @xmath135 can not be neglected . a useful way to separate diffusive and non - diffusive contributions and to eliminate the stochastic noise from eq . ( [ d ] ) , is to perform a fourier analysis of the function @xmath150 . let us define the frequencies @xmath151 , with @xmath152 . the discrete fourier transform of the function @xmath150 is the signal @xmath153 @xmath154 2 in general , @xmath155 is negligible except at high frequencies . for small positive values of the frequency we can make the approximation @xmath156 . from this approximation we have @xmath157 the real part of eq . ( [ fs ] ) for positive frequencies is @xmath158 even though simpler than eq . ( [ eq:10 ] ) , we have found eq . ( [ ns ] ) is more sensitive to the deviations of @xmath36 from the approximation eq . ( [ d ] ) . therefore , the data obtained from the real part is of poorer quality than the data obtained from the imaginary part . equation ( [ eq:10 ] ) implies that for a given simulation length @xmath11 , the contributions to the mc metric from the non - diffusive process can be determined from a simple relationship involving the fourier transform of the function @xmath150 at low frequencies . by increasing the length of the run @xmath11 by a factor of @xmath18 , it is possible to observe the dependence of @xmath139 on @xmath159 . the concepts developed in the previous sections are sufficiently general to be applied to any kind of mc simulation . we devote the present section to the application of the developments of this paper to the study of the lennard - jones 13-particle cluster in the canonical ensemble . this system has been introduced previously in sec . ii . some thermodynamic properties of clusters as a function of temperature exhibit rapid changes that are reminiscent of similar changes that occur for the same properties in bulk systems at phase transitions . in a bulk system a phase transition occurs at a single temperature . for clusters the rapid changes in thermodynamic properties occur over a finite temperature interval . to distinguish the temperature range where thermodynamic properties change rapidly in clusters from a true phase transition , we follow berry _ et al . _ @xcite and refer to such changes in physical properties as associated with a phase change . a common property that has been found to be useful in monitoring these phase change intervals of temperature is the heat capacity at constant volume @xcite @xmath160 where @xmath161 represents the classical canonical mean value . in this work we consider the bare metropolis ( met ) , @xcite j - walking ( jw ) , @xcite and parallel tempering ( pt ) @xcite approaches to monte carlo simulations . the free variable of all these methods is the reduced temperature @xmath162 . in pt and jw simulations , the highest temperature used ( @xmath163 ) must be sufficiently large to ensure that met is ergodic.@xcite from experience simulating a variety of systems , we have found that @xmath163 must also be lower than a temperature @xmath164 where cluster evaporation events become frequent . it is useful to think of @xmath164 as the cluster analogue of a boiling temperature . we have found that met is unable to sample the boiling phase change region for clusters ergodically , using total time scales accessible to current simulations . for the results that follow , @xmath165 is chosen to be represented by the potential energy of the system . in general @xmath165 can be any scalar property of the system . we define a pass to represent a set of single particle mc moves taken sequentially over the 13 particles in the cluster . we take @xmath165 to be the potential energy at the @xmath166th pass , in the @xmath167th experiment . using eq . ( [ fs ] ) we can write @xmath168 in the non - ergodic regime , @xmath169 grows with @xmath11 , while in the ergodic regime , the signal @xmath169 approaches a constant . we begin by displaying results obtained for a calculation that has not attained ergodicity over the time scale of the simulation . we examine the 13-particle lennard - jones cluster with the met algorithm setting @xmath170 at a temperature of @xmath171 . the temperature is chosen to be that typically used as the initial high temperature in jw and pt studies of lj@xmath172 . by choosing a large constraining radius , the evaporation events are so frequent at the chosen temperature that attaining ergodicity proves to be quite difficult . we demonstrate the effect of reducing the constraining radius shortly . = .48 the upper panel is the signal @xmath169 ( in units of @xmath37 ) vs. @xmath11 for @xmath170 at @xmath171 . from @xmath173 independent experiments , of lj@xmath172 . the length of the simulation is @xmath174 mc passes . the lower panel shows the time evolution " of @xmath175 ( in units of @xmath20 ) for 15 independent experiments . at least three basins with different energies are present . clearly , the simulation at this scale of time , is not ergodic . the number of replicas used in the calculation is @xmath173 , and @xmath176 . the upper panel of fig . 2 shows the signal @xmath169 [ evaluated using eq . ( [ eq : ft ] ) ] , which grows along the entire simulation . this is the behavior expected in the non - ergodic regime . in the lower panel we can see the time evolution " of the temporal mean values of 15 experiments . = .48 upper panel : @xmath139 ( in units of @xmath37 ) as a function of @xmath177 for @xmath170 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 , and @xmath180 . for the two larger radii the full line is the best fit to the data points , according to eq . ( [ upa ] ) with @xmath145 defined in eq . ( [ upa2 ] ) . the lower panel shows the linear behavior of @xmath181 vs. @xmath177 , for @xmath170 and @xmath178 . @xmath11 has been set to @xmath174 . there are three sets of curves , each of which is indicative of sampling of at least three different energy basins . at low values of @xmath11 the curves in the lower panel differ significantly . at @xmath182 the high energy basin curves begin to decrease in energy . for a value of @xmath11 larger than the data displayed in fig . 2 , the curves can be expected to coalesce with the low energy basin curves . it is clear that for @xmath183 , the simulation is not ergodic . in pt and jw studies it is essential that the initial high temperature walk be ergodic . ergodicity can be attained for lj@xmath172 by reducing the radius of the constraining potential so that evaporation events are rare . we now present a study of @xmath134 as a function of @xmath11 for several values of @xmath30 . to determine @xmath134 , we have calculated the fourier transform function @xmath153 using eq . ( [ eq : ft ] ) at a series of frequencies @xmath184 where @xmath185 has ranged from 1 to @xmath186 . this range of frequencies ensures the linear approximation used in eq . ( [ fs ] ) is valid while including sufficient numbers of points for accuracy.@xcite using eq . ( [ eq:10 ] ) , we have calculated the slope of the imaginary part of @xmath187 as a function of @xmath188 , for these frequencies . the data points appearing in fig . 3 are the mean value over twenty independent calculations of the slope of @xmath187 . = .48 @xmath139 ( in units of @xmath37 ) and its error vs. @xmath177 for @xmath189 and @xmath180 , with @xmath176 . when @xmath139 is on the order of its own error , the simulation can be considered ergodic . for @xmath190 the simulation becomes ergodic at @xmath191 ( @xmath192 ) . for @xmath189 a longer simulation is needed to reach ergodicity . starting from random configurations , we have performed @xmath193 met passes at @xmath171 . after this warmup process , we have created sequences of sizes @xmath194 , @xmath195 , @xmath196 , @xmath197 , @xmath198 . the results are presented in fig . 3 for @xmath170 , @xmath178 , @xmath179 , and @xmath180 . the upper panel shows @xmath139 as a function of @xmath177 , for fixed @xmath176 . we have chosen to present the data using base 2 logarithms for clarity ( each increase by 1 unit of @xmath177 represents a factor of 2 scale increase ) . all the data decrease with increasing @xmath18 , but only @xmath199 and @xmath200 appear to vanish to within the error bars over the time scale of the current simulation . in the lower panel we present @xmath181 as a function of @xmath177 for @xmath201 and @xmath178 . the decay law suggested in eq . ( [ upa ] ) with @xmath145 given by eq . ( [ upa2 ] ) is satisfied for both radii . = .48 the upper panel shows the decay behavior of @xmath139 ( in units of @xmath37 ) as a function of @xmath177 for pt and met , at the temperature of the melting peak of the heat capacity , @xmath202 . from eq . ( [ upa1 ] ) , we plot @xmath203 vs. @xmath204 , to extract the value of the exponent @xmath205 ( the slope of the linear fit ) . we have found @xmath206 for pt , and @xmath207 for met . the straight lines are the best linear fits of the data points . we have stated that the simulation can be considered effectively ergodic when @xmath134 is indistinguishable from zero . in fig . 4 we have plotted @xmath139 and its statistical error as a function of @xmath177 for @xmath208 and @xmath180 . for @xmath209 the crossing point of @xmath139 and its error is at @xmath210 . for @xmath189 the crossing point is at a @xmath211 . we can conclude that for @xmath171 and @xmath209 the simulation can be considered effectively ergodic after @xmath212 met passes . once a constraining radius is chosen , pt and jw simulations require the highest temperature @xmath163 be chosen so that met is ergodic . for a given @xmath30 , the extent of ergodicity can be tested using the same metric that has been used for determining the optimum value of @xmath30 , but by varying the temperature . for the parameters @xmath171 and @xmath209 the simulation is ergodic even at very short sequence lengths . we have found that for @xmath213 the simulations are not ergodic . to be sure that the parameters are appropriate , we have performed a short pt simulation ( @xmath174 passes , ten pt passes consists of nine met passes plus an exchange attempt ) with 40 equally spaced temperatures in the range @xmath214[0.028,0.393 ] in order to obtain a first estimate of the position of the melting and boiling temperature regions . the boiling peak in the specific heat appears to be located at a higher temperature than @xmath214 0.393 . moreover , the value of @xmath215 at @xmath31 is about one - half the value of @xmath215 at the temperature of the melting peak @xmath202 . from these results we feel it is safe to choose @xmath209 and @xmath171 for the calculations that follow . we now illustrate the convergence characteristics of @xmath134 when we increase the total time scale of the calculation by a factor @xmath18 . we illustrate this behavior using a pt simulation of lj@xmath172 , and we focus on results at the temperature of the melting peak in the heat capacity ( @xmath202 ) . we choose this temperature , because from experience @xcite we know the statistical fluctuations are large at the melting heat capacity maximum . the large statistical fluctuations make it possible to emphasize the behavior of @xmath134 . we have run the pt simulation at 40 equally spaced temperatures in the range @xmath214 [ 0.028,0.393 ] . the initial warmup time has been set to @xmath174 met passes , followed by @xmath195 pt passes . following the warm - up period , we perform simulations of @xmath216 , @xmath217 , @xmath218 , @xmath219 , @xmath220 , and @xmath221 pt passes . in each case the initial configuration has been taken to be the last configuration of the previous run . the output of the simulation are sequences of the potential energy . @xmath134 has been determined in the same way as in the calculation of the high temperature parameters ( presented in fig . 3 and fig . 4 ) . the data points appearing in the upper panel of fig . 5 are the mean value over twenty independent calculations of the slope of @xmath187 . in the lower panel of fig . 5 we have plotted @xmath203 as a function of @xmath204 , where @xmath176 and @xmath222 . the slope of the linear fit is the exponent @xmath205 , according to eq . ( [ upa1 ] ) . at the temperature of the melting peak , @xmath206 . it is of interest to perform a similar study of the behavior of @xmath134 as a function of the time scaling for an met calculation . we have taken the final configuration of the pt simulation at @xmath202 as an initial configuration , and we have performed a simple met simulation at that melting temperature . a graph of @xmath139 and @xmath203 as a function of @xmath204 for met is also presented in fig . 5 . from the upper panel of fig . 5 , it is evident that met results are not ergodic within the same scaled time as the pt results . it is also evident that the power law exponent for both met and pt are not distinguishable . similar studies of the power law using the jw method also give the same exponent . neither an increase in the number of temperatures nor changing the distribution of temperatures in both jw and pt simulations has any effect on the calculated exponent . = .48 comparison of the met and jw diffusion coefficients with the pt diffusion coefficient as a function of the reduced temperature . the dashed line represents equivalence between methods . by using the results to compare the relative efficiencies of met , jw and pt simulations for the lj@xmath172 system we have found that pt and jw simulations can be considered ergodic if the run length is on the order of @xmath217 passes , while met simulations that are initialized from configurations generated from an ergodic pt study are ergodic when the total run length consists of @xmath223 passes or more . in order to compare approaches , we have calculated @xmath224 as a function of the reduced temperature , for the three methods . the comparison of diffusion coefficients from different algorithms has also been used by andricioaei and straub @xcite . the comparison of jw and met with pt is presented in fig . the jw and pt simulations are found to have comparable efficiencies using @xmath224 as a measure for all calculated temperatures . at intermediate temperatures , met is significantly less efficient . we have chosen to truncate the jw study at @xmath225 . for temperatures below @xmath225 , jw simulations require significant effort , because a large set of external distributions must be generated . because at temperatures below @xmath225 lj@xmath172 is dominated by structures close to the lowest energy icosahedral isomer , we expect the jw and pt methods to have similar efficiencies ( as measured by @xmath224 ) for all temperatures . in this paper we have presented a study of the approach to the ergodic limit in mc simulations . in all the cases examined , the behavior of the mc metric @xmath36 can be approximated by eq . ( [ d ] ) , and the behavior of @xmath139 satisfies eq . ( [ upa ] ) . because the exponent @xmath205 is smaller than one for all the cases studied , the dependence of the non - diffusive contributions on @xmath36 is weaker ( in the sense of appendix a ) than the diffusive contributions . the assumption on which we have built the stochastic model have been verified numerically for a system having a sufficiently complex potential surface to be viewed as prototypical of a large set of many - particle systems . the mc metric used in this work appears to be a valuable tool to study the ergodicity properties of mc simulations . the non - ergodic components of the mc metric enable the prediction of the minimum length a mc simulation must have in order to be considered ergodic . the comparison of @xmath224 from different algorithms gives a reasonable estimate of their relative efficiencies . from the study of the melting region of 13 particle clusters , we have found that the exponent @xmath205 depends both on the method used and the nature of the potential energy function . we have performed calculations , not discussed in this work , where the functional form of the potential energy is modified . these studies have shown @xmath205 to be dependent on the details of the potential . we have not found the exponent @xmath205 to be a strong function of method . although pt and met have significantly different efficiencies as measured by their relative diffusion coefficients , @xmath205 is nearly the same in the two methods . the difference in the decay of @xmath134 appears to be dominated by the coefficient in eqs.([upa ] ) and ( [ upa1 ] ) rather than the exponent . as discussed in the text , parallel tempering and j - walking studies of many - particle systems must have an initial high temperature component that is chosen so that a met simulation is known to be ergodic . for cluster simulations that require an external constraining potential to define the cluster , the radius of the constraining potential must be carefully chosen in order to achieve ergodic results . we have found the metric and associated decay laws developed in this work to be a particularly valuable method of choosing these initial parameters in both parallel tempering and j - walking simulations . we also remark that the metric introduced here may be a more sensitive probe of ergodicity than may be required in some applications . for example in previous j - walking studies@xcite of the 13-particle lennard - jones cluster , the heat capacity curve determined with a constraining radius of 4@xmath21 is nearly indistinguishable from the curve obtained with a constraining radius of 2@xmath21 . from the results of this work , we know the initial high temperature walk is not ergodic when a constraining radius of 4@xmath21 is used . it is striking that the non - ergodicity as measured by the energy metric is not apparent in the heat capacity curve . we have constructed a metric based on an ensemble of mc trajectories . by using an ensemble we attempt to cover sufficient portions of space so that all components are accessible . in practice only a finite subset of a full ensemble can be included , and it is always possible that components of space are missed . in such a case @xmath134 may decay to zero numerically within the subspace , and the behavior may give misleading evidence that the simulation is ergodic . because components of space may be missed in any finite simulation , it is impossible to guarantee ergodicity . it is hoped by using a sufficiently large ensemble of trajectories to define the metric , the possibility of missing components is minimized . we would like to thank dr . o. osenda for helpful comments . this work has been supported in part by the national science foundation under grant numbers che-9714970 and cda-9724347 . this research has been supported in part by the phillips laboratory , air force material command , usaf , through the use of the mhpcc under cooperative agreement number f29601 - 93 - 0001 . the views and conclusions contained in this document are those of the authors and should not be interpreted as necessarily representing the official policies or endorsements , either expressed or implied , of phillips laboratory or the u.s . government . we have considered two overall time scales for a mc simulation . properties calculated at short times ( labeled @xmath10 in the discrete case ) provide information about each step of the mc process , and properties averaged over the total simulation time ( labeled @xmath11 in the discrete case ) give information about the approach to ergodic behavior . when @xmath11 is sufficiently short we have both diffusive and non - diffusive contributions as a function of @xmath10 . in this appendix we explain the relative time dependence of the diffusive and non - diffusive contributions to the autocorrelation function . it has been assumed that the autocorrelation function eq . ( [ correl ] ) can be expressed as the sum of diffusive terms plus non - diffusive terms , i.e. @xmath226 where @xmath227 increasing the time variables by a factor @xmath17 , such that @xmath228 , with @xmath229 , we can study the relative variations of each contribution to the correlation function , diffusive and non - diffusive ( labeled by @xmath230 ) . in this appendix we only consider values of @xmath18 such that the transformation @xmath231 does not increase the time scale beyond the local correlation time . in appendix b values of @xmath18 are considered that do cross such time scales . by relative variations we mean @xmath232 the relative variation of each non - diffusive contribution is @xmath233 whereas the relative variation of the diffusive contribution is @xmath234 if @xmath235 for all pair of times @xmath61 and @xmath62 and for all @xmath17 such that @xmath236 , we say that the non - diffusive contributions are weaker than the diffusive contribution in their dependence on @xmath61 . we explore , in the remainder of this appendix , the properties @xmath59 must have in order that the inequality @xmath235 is satisfied . if the function @xmath237 @xmath238 satisfies the inequality @xmath239 then , @xmath237 is an increasing function of @xmath12 . for @xmath84 and @xmath61 fixed , the function @xmath240 evaluated in @xmath241 is @xmath242 then , for @xmath243 @xmath244 2 where @xmath245 $ ] . in the limit @xmath246 , and by virtue of the continuity of @xmath59 , the derivative takes the form @xmath247 then , @xmath248 , and @xmath237 is an increasing function of @xmath249 here we have presented the two first conditions @xmath59 must have , namely eqs . ( [ lemma1 ] ) and ( [ lemma2 ] ) . from eq . ( [ schwartz ] ) @xmath250 is a global maximum , and the memory functions must have a positive peak at zero . the area below that peak must be sufficiently large to satisfy eq . ( [ lemma1 ] ) . moreover , @xmath250 must be sufficiently large to satisfy eq . ( [ lemma2 ] ) , even at points where @xmath251 is a local maximum . then , to satisfy this lemma , we need a memory function with a sufficiently large global maximum at @xmath252 . suppose @xmath253 . if @xmath17 , then @xmath254 for all pair of times @xmath61 and @xmath62 . * demonstration : * under the change of scale in time @xmath231 , @xmath255 can be written @xmath256 then , the quotient @xmath257 is @xmath258 2 by eq . ( [ lemma1 ] ) , @xmath259 @xmath61 and @xmath12 . by the * lemma * the numerator is smaller than the denominator . then @xmath260 and then , @xmath261 suppose that @xmath17 is such that @xmath262 , @xmath253 , and all @xmath59 satisfy the lipschitz condition @xcite ( for all closed interval @xmath263 exists a real positive number @xmath264 such that @xmath265 for all @xmath56 and @xmath266 in @xmath263 ) . then @xmath267 if and only if @xmath59 is non - negative in the interval @xmath268 . if @xmath267 , then @xmath269 where the operations to reach eq . ( [ ineq ] ) are valid by using * corollary*. then @xmath270 + \int^{t_>}_{t_1}\!\ ! dt_2 \left[b\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{b\,(t_2-t_1 ) } { \tau_{\ell}}\right)- \,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t_2-t_1}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)\right ] \right\}\\ 0 & < & \int_0^{t_<}\!\ ! dt_1\left\ { \int_0^{t_1}\!\ ! dt \left[b\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{bt}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)- \,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)\right ] + \int_0^{t_>-t_1}\!\ ! dt \left[b\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{bt}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)- \,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)\right ] \right\}\\ 0 & < & \int_0^{t_<}\!\ ! dt_1\left\ { \int_0^{bt_1}\!\ ! dt \,\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)- \int_0^{t_1}\!\ ! dt \,\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right ) + \int_0^{b(t_>-t_1)}\!\ ! dt \,\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)- \int_0^{t_>-t_1}\!\ ! dt \,\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right ) \right\}\\ 0 & < & \int_0^{t_<}\!\ ! dt_1\left\ { \int_{t_1}^{bt_1}\!\ ! dt \,\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right ) + \int_{t_>-t_1}^{b(t_>-t_1)}\!\ ! dt \,\,f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t}{\tau_{\ell } } \right)\right\}\,\,.\label{k1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using the intermediate value theorem , @xcite we have @xmath271\label{propx}\,\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath272 $ ] . let be @xmath273 and @xmath274 the values at which the intermediate value theorem is satisfied , in the intervals @xmath275 $ ] and @xmath276 $ ] respectively @xmath277 then , the remainder can be written as @xmath278+(t_>-t)\,\left[f_{\ell } \left(\frac{t^*_{\beta}(t)}{\tau_{\ell}}\right ) - f_{\ell}\left(\frac{t_>-t}{\tau_{\ell}}\right)\right]\right\}\,\,.\ ] ] by the lipschitz condition , we have that @xmath279\\ & < & \frac{c_{\ell}}{\tau_{\ell}}\,(b-1)\,\left(\frac23\,t_<^3+t_<t_>\ , ( t_>-t_<)\right)\\ & < & \frac23\,t_>^3\,\frac{c_{\ell}}{\tau_{\ell}}\,(b-1)\label{cota}\,\,,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath264 is a suitable positive real constant . using eqs . ( [ propx ] ) and ( [ rem ] ) in eq . ( [ k1 ] ) we have @xmath280 where @xmath281 is a continuous and differentiable function of @xmath61 . the inequality ( [ xx ] ) holds for any @xmath17 . suppose that @xmath282 . then , if @xmath18 is such that @xmath283 where @xmath284 , we have that @xmath285\end{aligned}\ ] ] in contradiction with the hypothesis that @xmath286 is negative . then @xmath287 let us define the function @xmath288 where @xmath289 . the right derivative at @xmath252 of @xmath290 is @xmath291 2 where @xmath292 $ ] and @xmath293 $ ] . thus @xmath294 if the right derivative at 0 of @xmath290 is negative , @xmath290 approaches @xmath295 from below , when @xmath296 . there exists a time @xmath297 , such that @xmath298 , in contradiction with eq . ( [ xxx ] ) . then , @xmath59 must be non - negative for @xmath289 . by the property eq . ( [ schwartz ] ) @xmath250 must be positive . this proves that @xmath299 for @xmath300 . to demonstrate that if @xmath59 is positive yields @xmath301 ( i.e. the converse ) , follow the argument backwards , from eq . ( [ k1 ] ) . @xmath302 in conclusion , if the memory functions are positive , satisfy the lipschitz condition , and satisfy the condition eqs . ( [ lemma1 ] ) and ( [ lemma2 ] ) , the non - diffusive contributions are more weakly dependent on time than @xmath65 . the results of the present appendix are valid in the limit of a complete ensemble . in our numerical experiments only partial samples of the ensemble can be considered . the memory functions that appear in our numerical calculations come from partial mean values of the product of discontinuous functions ( every noise process is a discontinuous function ) . these memory functions are discontinuous . the behavior of the non - diffusive contributions observed in our numerical experiments is in agreement with these analytic ( infinite ensemble limit ) results . we can infer that there might be a version of the theorem applied to discontinuous memory functions , but we have been unable to develop such a theorem . in this appendix we show the behavior of the function @xmath303 when its correlation time is changed according to @xmath304 , with @xmath305 ; i.e. when the total simulation time is scaled to exceed the correlation time of the first colored noise process . where @xmath309 and @xmath310 . we want to compute this contribution both within the neighborhood @xmath311 as well as outside such a region . to do so , we can split the integral in eq . ( [ eq:6 ] ) in three parts where @xmath322 ( @xmath89 ) is the time in the interval @xmath323 $ ] at which the function @xmath303 reaches its maximum ( minimum ) value . because @xmath303 is continuous , there exists @xmath324 $ ] at which we can observe that the correlation time @xmath351 goes to zero when @xmath18 is increased . the function @xmath352 becomes negligible outside a neighborhood of @xmath252 [ observe eqs . ( [ i11 ] ) and ( [ i33 ] ) ] . equation ( [ norm ] ) holds , then , if @xmath18 is sufficiently large , @xmath353 can be considered a delta function . the integrals @xmath316 and @xmath326 become zero , and the integrals involving @xmath252 in the expression of @xmath315 converge to one . @xmath315 becomes the same argument can be used when @xmath18 is such that @xmath356 . after such changes in the time scale , the diffusion coefficient @xmath357 is enlarged , and the non - diffusive contributions are reduced . there is an ultimate scale change , such that @xmath358 . beyond this maximum time scale the process can be considered diffusive . j. p. valleau and s. g. whittington , a guide to monte carlo for statistical mechanics : 1 highways , in _ statistical mechanics , part a : equilibrium techniques _ , modern theoretical chemistry series , vol . 5 , chap . 4 , b. berne ed . ( plenum , new york , 1976 ) .
Abstract: | [
"the approach to the ergodic limit in monte carlo simulations is studied using both analytic and numerical methods . with the help of a stochastic model , a metric is defined that enables the examination of a simulation in both the ergodic and non - ergodic regimes . in the non - ergodic regime , the model implies how the simulation is expected to approach ergodic behavior analytically , and the analytically inferred decay law of the metric allows the monitoring of the onset of ergodic behavior . the metric is related to previously defined measures developed for molecular dynamics simulations , and the metric enables the comparison of the relative efficiencies of different monte carlo schemes . applications to lennard - jones 13-particle clusters are shown to match the model for metropolis , j - walking and parallel tempering based approaches . the relative efficiencies of these three monte carlo approaches are compared , and the decay law is shown to be useful in determining needed high temperature parameters in parallel tempering and j - walking studies of atomic clusters . * pacs * numbers : 05.10.ln , 02.70.lq -30pt 0.0 in = 18.2 cm = 58 = -.35 in = -.3 in specialpagefalse evenfoot oddfoot @page>1 j. p. neirotti , d. l. freeman . and j. d. doll@page=1 * abstract * 2"
] | 9,777 | 9,777 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: this paper addresses the problem of interacting electrons in a band of a two - dimensional crystal . this problem uncovers all the macroscopic properties of the materials of which the maximum interest is centered at the present on the high-@xmath1 superconductors , in particular , on the nature of their normal state . to fix ideas and some notation let us review the highlights of the problem . start with a free theory of , say , electrons in a metal , i. e. , a free fermi gas whose ground state is known and whose low energy elementary excitations are electrons and holes obeying a free dispersion relation . then switch on an interaction among the electrons and ask the question of what the new ground state is and what is the nature of the low energy excitations of the full interacting theory . this program has been successfully addressed by landau in three spatial dimensions @xmath2 where it leads to the famous theory of landau s fermi liquid @xcite and the concept of quasiparticles . things are different in @xmath3 where an exact solution can be found and the behavior of the system is always of the luttinger type@xcite . the case @xmath4 is physically very interesting both in practice ( most of the high-@xmath1 materials are organized in two dimensional layers and experimental data are available ) and under a theoretical point of view . despite the great effort devoted to it , no exact solution is known at the present and the situation remains controversial superconductivity . ] . the ultimate origin of the trouble lies on the very complex nature of the many - body vacuum and the corresponding difficulties of doing perturbations around the fermi surface . the theory of the fermi liquid and the perturbations of it that lead to the bcs and charge density wave instabilities have recently been rephrased as effective field theories @xcite to which renormalization group techniques can be applied @xcite . the main idea of this approach is that , although we are dealing with problems that naturally have an ultraviolet cutoff @xmath5 ( the width of the band ) , we are only interested in the physics at a scale much lower than it , namely , a very narrow strip above and below the fermi surface . by integrating out in the path integral all the momenta above a certain cutoff @xmath6 , we end up with an effective field theory whose couplings are cutoff dependent . the renormalization group transformations are rescalings of @xmath7 . in this way one can visualize the fermi liquid as a fixed point of this rg transformations ( it is gapless ) that flows towards a bcs state when a weak attraction is introduced between the quasiparticles . when comparing the effective field theories that arise in this context with standard quantum field theory , we encounter two main differences . the first one is the nonrelativistic nature of the many body physics where there is a parameter , the fermi velocity , whose typical value is much smaller than the speed of light . this prevents the use of the general theorems concerning renormalizability . the more severe difference lies in the above mentioned nature of the many body vacuum . when treating the interacting system as a perturbation of the free " system constituted by the fixed point , perturbations are to be described around a fermi surface in @xmath8 , a fermi line in @xmath9 , and fermi points in @xmath3 . we are then faced with couplings that are functions of the shape of the fermi surface which is also modified by the interaction . only in the @xmath3 case we deal , as in quantum field theory , with a true vacuum around which one can expand and get a bunch of coupling _ constants_. in ref . @xcite , we developed a model for the electronic structure of free electrons in a two - dimensional honeycomb lattice . this lattice constitutes the basic building block of periodic systems made of identical atoms with planar , threefold coordination . that is the case of graphite , built of carbon atoms . the rapidly growing family of fullerene compounds @xcite can be thought of as closed , curved surfaces derived from the planar honeycomb lattice . these compounds show a variety of unexpected features , the most striking of them being the superconductivity of doped crystals of c@xmath10 molecules @xcite . moreover , this superconductivity can be considered a form of high - t@xmath11 superconductivity , as the number of electrons available to form cooper pairs is unusually low . the main feature that makes the honeycomb lattice the object of our attention in the present context is that its fermi level at half - filling consists of exactly two fermi _ points_. this peculiarity opens the possibility of performing a complete analysis of the problems mentioned above in analogy with the @xmath3 case . in particular it makes of this lattice an ideal laboratory for investigating departures from fermi liquid behavior in @xmath9 which have shown very ellusive in more conventional approaches . the major interest of this investigation relies on the fact , made clear by now from the experiments , that the normal state of high-@xmath1 materials is not of fermi liquid type . besides , it can be directly applied to the physics of the fullerenes that , as mentioned above , are two - dimensional graphitic structures at half - filling @xcite . the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 we review results on the free electrons on the honeycomb lattice that lead to the low energy effective action used as a starting point of our analysis . we emphasize the point that , unlike what usually occurs in many body physics , our effective action constitutes a genuine quantum field theory with a single , well - defined , vacuum state . next the free theory is completed with the addition of the coulomb interaction . in the field theory , this is mediated by an electromagnetic field whose propagator reproduces , in the nonrelativistic limit , the usual four - fermion interaction considered in the many - body approach . we end up with a standard local quantum field theory . a discussion is done on the differences to be expected by the use of the relativistic versus the instantaneous electromagnetic field propagator illustrated by the computation of the density of states in both cases . the results announce an infrared instability which is clarified in section 4 with the help of the renormalization group . section 3 is devoted to the study of the renormalizability of the model . it is shown that , despite its nonrelativistic nature and due to its gauge invariance , it is renormalizable . the fermi velocity and the electron wave function get renormalized while the electric charge does not . sections 4 and 5 contain the analysis of the rg flow of the model and its physical implications . the first section is devoted to the nonrelativistic limit of the theory . we see that the perturbative expansion has an effective coupling given by the ratio of the square of the electric charge and the fermi velocity . the rg shows that this coupling decreases to zero in the infrared although there is no fixed point in the nonrelativistic regime . we then investigate the possibility of having a natural length scale in the theory and make some comments on the system away from half - filling . finally we find an anomalous dimension for the electron wave function at two - loop order that points towards a non - fermi liquid behavior of the system . the previous analysis is completed in section 5 where we study the relativistic regime which is the relevant regime in the infrared . we find a fixed point of the rg flow obtained when the fermi velocity equals the speed of light . next we compare our model with standard rg analysis of the fermi liquid theory and find significant differences both from the technical and from the physical point of view . the most significant one is the anomalous dimension found for the electron green function . we discuss the non renormalization of the electric charge and establish the non - fermi liquid nature of our fixed point . we set our main conclusions and a summary of the more relevant points of the article in section 6 . in this section we first review the one - particle electronic states in the two - dimensional honeycomb lattice , which serve afterwards as a starting point for the many - body problem . the present one - particle description has been worked out with complete detail in ref . @xcite , regarding the conduction band of a two - dimensional graphite layer . the honeycomb lattice has two different atoms per primitive cell , so that two degrees of freedom arise in a variational computation of the energy eigenstates , corresponding to the respective orbitals for the two atoms . in the tight - binding approximation the problem reduces to the diagonalization of the one - particle hamiltonian @xmath12 where the sum is over pairs of nearest neighbors atoms @xmath13 on the lattice and @xmath14 , @xmath15 are canonically anticommuting operators @xmath16 the states which are simultaneously eigenvectors of the hamiltonian and of the lattice generators have to be of the form @xmath17 with coefficients @xmath18 and @xmath19 for black and blank points , respectively , as depicted in figure 1 . obviously , under the action of ( [ 6 ] ) black points are mapped into blank points and viceversa . we have , indeed , @xmath20 where @xmath21 is a triad of vectors connecting a @xmath22 atom with its nearest neighbors , and @xmath23 the triad made of their respective opposites ( see figure 1 ) . therefore , the state ( [ 8 ] ) is an eigenvector of @xmath24 provided that the coefficients @xmath18 and @xmath19 are solutions of the eigenvalue problem @xmath25 the parameter @xmath26 measures the hopping between nearest neighbors and provides the natural energy scale in the one - particle description . the diagonalization of ( [ 9 ] ) gives the band of levels @xmath27 the parameter @xmath28 being the lattice spacing . we will be interested in the consideration of this band at half - filling , which is the pertinent instance for the carbon - based materials and , in particular , graphite layers and undoped fullerenes . the dispersion relation ( [ 12 ] ) has the amazing property that the fermi level at @xmath29 is only reached by six isolated points in momentum space ( see figure 2 ) . these are the six corners of the first brillouin zone and , due to the periodicity of the dual lattice , they correspond to only two independent states . the existence of a finite number of fermi points is quite unusual in more than one spatial dimension . it has important consequences since it makes possible to encode the low - lying excitations about the fermi level into a simple field theory . when considering an arbitrarily large sample , it is appropriate to amplify the region about any of the two independent fermi points by taking the limit @xmath30 . in either case we obtain for the operator @xmath31 in equation ( [ 9 ] ) @xmath32 where is the displacement about the fermi point and @xmath33 stand for the two pauli matrices . the conclusion is that , in the long - wavelength limit @xmath30 , the one - particle ( energy ) eigenstates of the electrons in the honeycomb lattice are given by the field theory of two massless dirac spinors ( one for each independent fermi point ) in two spatial dimensions . this is all about the free theory . we now turn to introduce the electronic interaction by applying the method of second quantization . we remark that , proceeding in this way with the above set of one - particle states , we end up with a formalism which falls more into the framework of quantum field theory than into that of quantum statistical theory . the difference is subtle but significant . in quantum statistical theory the ground state of the system is , in general , a condensate with an extended fermi surface ( in more than one spatial dimension ) and the elementary excitations ( quasiparticles ) are only stable right at the fermi level . the second quantized theory built from the dispersion relation ( [ deq ] ) has , however , a definite vacuum in the sense of quantum field theory . its excitations are similar to the particle - hole excitations of the dirac sea . we may consider separately , for instance , each of the two dirac spinors and work out the many - body electron propagator of the free theory @xmath34 we denote by @xmath35 the electron operator @xmath36 in the interaction representation while @xmath37 . in terms of the respective modes @xmath38 for unoccupied and occupied levels we have @xmath39 where @xmath40 is the fermi velocity and the operators @xmath41 satisfy anticommutation relations @xmath42 taking the statistical average with the system at half - filling , we get for the fourier transform of the propagator @xmath43 @xmath44 is a standard set of @xmath45-matrices satisfying @xmath46 and related to the above quoted pauli matrices by @xmath47 . the above expression coincides precisely with the feynman propagator for a massless spinor in 2 + 1 dimensions , which confirms our assertion that the system at half - filling is equivalent to the dirac sea in quantum field theory . we must notice however the presence of the fermi velocity @xmath48 in front of the spatial part of the scalar product , which is a feature of the many - body theory . in the nonrelativistic approximation , the introduction of the electronic interaction leads , in first instance , to the second quantized hamiltonian @xmath49 we attach to this hamiltonian the name of `` coulomb '' since it describes the instantaneous interaction between electric charges . the model given in terms of the coulomb interaction is , however , a highly nonlocal field theory , what makes very awkward its investigation from a formal point of view . both for the sake of studying the properties of the quantum theory as well as for computational purposes , a complete description of the interaction with the electromagnetic field @xmath50 is more desirable . one of the points that we support in what follows is that , actually , the model of interacting electrons is sensitive to retardation effects of the electromagnetic propagation . the reason for such unconventional behaviour is the massless character of the spinor @xmath51 . this property is not accidental in the description of the two - dimensional layer , as long as the expansion ( [ deq ] ) gives only one marginal operator dictating the long - distance behaviour of the free theory . we propose , therefore , a quantum field theory description based on the second quantized hamiltonian . ] @xmath52 the interaction of the electromagnetic field @xmath53 and the electrons in the layer is described in the standard fashion , by coupling to the conserved current @xmath54 this poses some technical problems since the electromagnetic field propagates in three - dimensional space while we want the dynamics of the electrons to be confined to the two - dimensional layer . although this may not be achieved in general , it turns out to be possible by specializing to the feynman gauge@xcite , which enforces the constraint @xmath55 and has also the property of placing the @xmath56 field in the same direction as the electronic current . in this gauge we have the propagator @xmath57 and the coupling to the 2 + 1 dimensional current is perfectly consistent . in the computation of electronic properties we have just to take care of placing the points @xmath58 on the plane of the two - dimensional layer . with this description we certainly get more than we would need in a nonrelativistic theory , but we can recover at any time the nonrelativistic limit of all quantities by expanding in powers of @xmath59 . it is important to stress that we have to expect , in general , different answers in the computation of a given observable taking ( [ hcoul ] ) or ( [ hq ] ) as starting point . the dimensionality of the system is low enough so that the massless condition of the spinor reflects in the appearance of infrared divergences in perturbation theory . thus , although we should not expect any discrepancy in the computation of local quantities ( like cutoff dependent quantities ) in the nonrelativistic model ( [ hcoul ] ) and in the model given by ( [ hq ] ) in the limit @xmath60 , the response of nonlocal quantities to the interaction turns out to be quite different in the infrared regime . from a technical point of view , perturbation theory looses predictive power because of the mentioned infrared instabilities , and one has to resort to more sophisticated methods in order to obtain information from the quantum theory . let us illustrate the above fact with the computation of the quantum corrections to the density of states @xmath61 near the fermi level ( @xmath62 ) . this observable is given by @xmath63 \label{density}\ ] ] in the theory with the instantaneous coulomb interaction , the density of states is not modified to first order in perturbation theory . the instantaneous interaction can be obtained from ( [ em ] ) , for instance , by considering formally its expression for @xmath64 . in this limit we have , computing always at points @xmath65 in the two - dimensional layer @xmath66 then , it becomes obvious that this kind of interaction can not modify the @xmath67 dependence of the propagator @xmath68 , to the first perturbative order ( see also the discussion at the end of section 4 ) . however , as mentioned above , the propagator ( [ propa ] ) can not be safely used in the computation of nonlocal quantities . this remark is appropriate to the case of the density of states , whose determination in the quantum field theory given by ( [ hq ] ) goes as follows . the inverse propagator may be decomposed , as usual , into a free part and the electron self - energy @xmath69 @xmath70 @xmath69 has a perturbative expansion in terms of one - particle - irreducible diagrams@xcite , which are in general ultraviolet divergent . since our model can be treated as a genuine quantum field theory we expect these divergences to be local and susceptible of being absorbed into @xmath71 . for the moment we are only interested in finite corrections and will leave the issue of renormalization to the next section . to first order in perturbation theory , the relevant diagram is shown in figure 3 and gives ( in the limit @xmath60 ) the finite contribution to @xmath72 @xmath73 when inserted in equation ( [ density ] ) the above expression gives the first quantum corrections to the density of levels @xmath74 it is already appreciated that the perturbative expansion of @xmath61 is not well - defined , since the last integral in ( [ 21 ] ) is clearly divergent . even if we could manage to regularize in some way this infrared divergence , we still would be left with a more serious problem . at the point near which we want to measure the density of levels , i.e. near @xmath62 , the first perturbative correction dominates over the zeroth order term , and one can presume that higher order terms can produce increasingly large powers of @xmath75 . perturbation theory is clearly not reliable in the infrared regime , but the kind of infrared instability described points at new physics near the fermi level . henceforth we will pay attention to the local quantum field theory ( [ hq ] ) , which offers the possibility of analyzing the infrared behaviour by application of renormalization group methods . we study first in this section the renormalization properties of the model . though the many - body theory of the 2d layer has a natural ultraviolet cutoff , we insist in absorbing ultraviolet divergent contributions into bare parameters of the theory since this is a way of extracting relevant information about the scaling properties in the infrared@xcite . as we have mentioned before , the renormalizability of a quantum many - body theory is , in general , a nontrivial issue , since the couplings in the effective theory may depend on the point chosen on the fermi surface . in our case things become much simpler as our low - energy effective theory is a genuine quantum field theory . regarding the usual considerations for renormalizability in field theory , the only condition that we are missing is relativistic invariance since the fermi velocity of the electrons @xmath76 does not match the speed of light @xmath77 that appears in the dispersion relation of photons . for this reason it is still necessary to check that the ultraviolet divergences of the theory can be absorbed into a redefinition of the scale of the fields and of the parameters in the hamiltonian . we present here the analysis at the one - loop level , and conclude with a compelling argument showing that the model is renormalizable to all orders in perturbation theory . the conditions which make the theory renormalizable can be stated more clearly in the lagrangian formalism . corresponding to the hamiltonian ( [ hq ] ) , we have the action @xmath78 in the quantum theory the coefficients of the terms in the action have to be adjusted so as to cancel the ultraviolet divergences . we should start therefore with the bare action @xmath79 the renormalization coefficient @xmath80 may be determined from the electron self - energy @xmath69 , as well as the renormalization coefficient for the fermi velocity @xmath81 . the coefficient @xmath82 is determined from the renormalization of the time component of the interaction vertex . it turns out therefore that the spatial components have necessarily to be renormalized by the product @xmath83 . this is a nontrivial check of the renormalizability of the theory , which arises in the absence of relativistic invariance . provided that it is fulfilled , the renormalized theory may be made finite in terms of renormalized quantities @xmath84 @xmath85 in the previous section we already quoted the one - loop renormalized contribution to the electron self - energy @xmath86 . we deal here with the ultraviolet divergent part of this object , regularizing it by working in analytical continuation to dimension @xmath87@xcite . from the diagram in figure 3 we have @xmath88 in order to ensure the finiteness of the electron propagator we take the renormalization coefficients @xmath89 these coefficients have a more complicated structure than those of a relativistic theory , as long as @xmath48 does not match the speed of light which , in our units , means that @xmath90 . @xmath81 has , for instance , an infinite power series expansion in @xmath48 @xmath91 we will later use this expression in the consideration of the nonrelativistic approximation @xmath92 . now we come to the renormalization of the interaction term in the action ( [ action ] ) . the first quantum corrections to the vertex are given by the diagram in figure 4 , and we denote them symbolically by @xmath93 . the divergent contribution to the time component of the vertex is actually different than that to the spatial components . we find that @xmath94 we may think of @xmath93 as a correction to the bare vertex in ( [ action ] ) . we have then @xmath95 by taking the quotient between ( [ dos ] ) and ( [ uno ] ) , we get an independent determination of the renormalization coefficient @xmath81 @xmath96 it is not obvious that this expression coincides with the alternative form ( [ alt ] ) , though it has to for the theory to be renormalizable . in fact , after using the recursion relations which hold for hypergeometric functions@xcite one can show that the two functions in ( [ one ] ) and ( [ alt ] ) are identical . we then have the nice situation of dealing with a nonrelativistic quantum field theory in which the fermi velocity of the electrons is renormalized exactly in the same way in the different terms of the action . this precise coincidence is not casual . one is led to suspect that it has to be consequence of some symmetry operating in the theory , which turns out to be nothing but gauge invariance . actually , this should automatically lead in the quantum theory to the same renormalization of the kinetic part and the interaction term in the action , @xmath97 . it is not difficult to check that this is satisfied in our model , to the perturbative order in which we are working . from expressions ( [ zpsi ] ) and ( [ uno ] ) we have @xmath98 which become identical after use again of the relations among hypergeometric functions . the gauge symmetry @xmath99 is manifest at the classical level . provided that it holds for the bare action ( [ action ] ) , it ensures that @xmath97 . it is easily seen , by taking a gauge parameter @xmath100 independent of @xmath26 , that it also enforces the same renormalization of the fermi velocity @xmath48 in the different terms of the action . as long as one is able to preserve the gauge invariance in the quantum theory , this turns out to guarantee the renormalizability to all orders of the perturbative expansion . the rest of the renormalization coefficients in ( [ ren ] ) can be obtained from the following remark . the fact that @xmath101 has to equal @xmath82 to all orders in perturbation theory implies , as in standard quantum electrodynamics , that @xmath102 . the renormalization coefficient of the electromagnetic field @xmath103 is determined from the polarization tensor , whose first perturbative contribution shown diagrammatically in figure 5 is a finite quantity @xmath104 we conclude , therefore , that @xmath105 remarking the absence of renormalization of the electric charge to first order in perturbation theory . in this section we seek the connection of our model to the real physics of electrons in a two - dimensional layer . a single graphite sheet or any fullerene aggregate of sufficiently large size is the appropriate physical instance to look at . the first question concerns the magnitude of the parameters pertinent to the real layer . a standard value for the hopping parameter in graphite is @xmath106 . for the nearest neighbor separation in the lattice we can take @xmath107 . from these values and restoring for a moment the dependence on @xmath77 and @xmath108 , the fermi velocity in our model turns out to be @xmath109 . this is certainly much smaller than the speed of light , for which to extract relevant quantities to the electron physics in the layer we will have to take the limit @xmath60 and keep the leading order in previous formulas . for a clearer description of our approach to renormalization group we will quote the renormalization coefficients in this section as functions of the ultraviolet momentum cutoff @xmath110 rather than in terms of the dimensional regularization poles @xmath111 . at the one - loop level this just amounts to replace @xmath111 by @xmath112 in all formulas . the renormalization coefficient of the fermi velocity @xmath113 becomes , for instance , in the nonrelativistic limit @xmath114 it is not difficult to see that at each level of the perturbative expansion the leading order in the nonrelativistic approximation enters with a power @xmath115 . we define , therefore , a consistent perturbative expansion in the nonrelativistic limit by taking @xmath92 ( or , equivalently , @xmath64 ) and @xmath116 this latter quantity becomes then the effective strength of the electronic interaction . in this limit we obtain from ( [ zkin ] ) @xmath117 so that we do not find wavefunction renormalization at the one - loop level in the nonrelativistic limit . we recall also the former result ( [ charge ] ) @xmath118 we have a nonrelativistic quantum theory with no renormalization of the electric charge , but in which the effective strength of the interaction @xmath119 is renormalized . we rely on the original interpretation of renormalization adopted by wilson@xcite to determine the scale dependence of the effective interaction . since we have shown that the model is renormalizable , we may impose the independence of the renormalized theory on the momentum cutoff @xmath110 . by means of renormalization group transformations we are able therefore to relate bare theories at different scales ( different cutoff ) which correspond to the same renormalized theory@xcite . the essential information is encoded in the renormalization group equation , which for the electron propagator , for instance , states that under a change in the scale of the cutoff @xmath110 @xmath120 where @xmath121 the well - known solution to this equation takes the form @xmath122 where the effective parameters are given by @xmath123 increasing the scale @xmath124 of the cutoff is equivalent to measure the observables of the theory at large distance scale . from the one - loop order results of the previous section we see that @xmath125 is constant at this level , while @xmath126 is not . we expect , therefore , the effective coupling of the electronic interaction @xmath119 to have a nontrivial renormalization group flow in the infrared regime . actually , from equations ( [ zetav ] ) and ( [ betav ] ) @xmath127 so that the asymptotic behaviour of the coupling is @xmath128 we have to bear in mind that , when integrating equation ( [ flow ] ) , we are relying heavily on perturbation theory . if we recall our original estimate of the fermi velocity @xmath48 , we see that the coupling @xmath119 of the nonrelativistic theory is not a small parameter but , in fact , larger than one . nevertheless , we know that when dealing with a renormalized quantum theory the statement that a coupling like @xmath119 is small or large applies to a particular energy scale . we then have to be very precise in establishing the regime in which the integration of the renormalization group equation becomes consistent . let us remark that the solution ( [ sol ] ) of the renormalization group equation is equivalent to performing the sum of leading logarithm terms of the perturbative expansion and curing , therefore , the problem of the infrared instability of the density of states addressed at the end of section 2 . taking the limit @xmath129 in the bare theory corresponds to measure at large distances ( or small energies with respect to the fermi level ) and in this regime perturbation theory becomes more and more accurate . this is another instance of a physical system which has strong coupling at certain energies and an asymptotic regime at which perturbation theory becomes reliable , similar to what is believed to be true ( as supported by experiment ) in the quantum field theory of the strong interactions . we are providing the example of a nonrelativistic theory in which this also happens , exchanging the ultraviolet regime in the case of the strong interactions by the infrared regime here . as for the practical application of the flow ( [ sol ] ) , we remark that the nonrelativistic theory appears to be formally incomplete , since it does not give any hint about what the value of @xmath130 has to be . this is related to the unlimited growth of the fermi velocity , and to the fact that , in the nonrelativistic approximation , there is no signal of a renormalization group fixed point . later we will see that in the complete quantum field theory the fixed point is given by @xmath131 , but the flow in the graphite layer may not be necessarily controlled by this value of the renormalized coupling . we believe , anyhow , that the observation of the phenomenon of scaling in the asymptotic region should be possible in a single graphite sheet . regarding the possible existence of a natural infrared cutoff , it can be shown that in our model the coulomb interaction is not screened , in the usual metallic manner , by quantum effects . this is due to the vanishing of the density of states at the fermi level . thus , a finite screening length is only generated by giving to the system an excess of charge , as a consequence of doping . in order to study this effect , we may place the system away from half - filling by introducing a chemical potential @xmath132 for the conserved charge @xmath133 the correct expression of the free electron propagator at finite @xmath132 is@xcite @xmath134 obviously , the @xmath135-dependent part can not change the ultraviolet behaviour of the loop - integrals and the renormalization coefficients of the quantum field theory are not modified by the nonvanishing chemical potential . this may lead , however , to finite corrections . the fermion loop diagram is now nonvanishing , opposite to what happened before at @xmath136 . the computation of ( [ ncharge ] ) gives @xmath137 which , after multiplying by 2 ( the two independent fermi points ) gives the correct number of particles . regarding the polarization tensor , a nonvanishing value of @xmath138 signals the appearance of a photon effective mass . at small @xmath132 one finds actually the estimate for the inverse of the screening length @xmath139 which gives a measure of the screening effects away from half - filling . we now turn , finally , to the issue of whether the electron observables may get anomalous dimensions in the nonrelativistic limit . we remark that the absence of one - loop wavefunction renormalization in the limit @xmath92 is just an accident . the signal of wavefunction renormalization is given by an ultraviolet divergent self - energy contribution of the form @xmath140 to establish the degree of divergence of the local contributions one can safely implement the nonrelativistic limit in the photon propagator , which leads to the expression ( [ propa ] ) . the @xmath67-dependence in the vertex diagram in figure 3 can be absorbed then by a simple change of variables in the loop integral , so that the divergent part of the diagram can not bear any dependence on it . at the two - loop level , the same independence of the local contributions on @xmath67 holds except for the vertex diagrams in figure 6 . in these diagrams the loop integrals overlap in such a way that the previous argument does not apply . by using the nonrelativistic approximation ( [ propa ] ) and after a very lengthy calculation , one obtains from the sum of the two - loop diagrams @xmath141 where @xmath142 is a nonvanishing quantity , @xmath143 . we see therefore that the electron observables acquire anomalous dimensions in the infrared regime . according to equation ( [ rge ] ) , the electron propagator transforms under a change of scale @xmath124 by the factor @xmath144 we have therefore an electronic system which deviates slightly from fermi liquid behaviour . in particular , we have seen that the vanishing of the density of states at the fermi level suppresses the usual screening of the coulomb interaction . this property is maintained in the quantum theory , at least at the one - loop level , since the fermi level is not shifted by quantum corrections . also a gap does not open at the fermi points to the one - loop order ( as it would be if an effective mass for the spinor had been generated in perturbation theory ) . the system is not an insulator , though it does not exhibit usual metallic properties either . in the previous section we have mentioned that the nonrelativistic theory is formally incomplete since it does not know of any bound in the effective fermi velocity @xmath126 of electrons . as this parameter grows steadily at large distances the nonrelativistic approximation becomes less accurate , up to a point in which the power series expansion in @xmath59 looses its meaning . in this relativistic regime , we have to use the full expression of the beta function @xmath145 to analyze the behaviour of @xmath126 . in particular , we are interested in knowing if a possible fixed point of the renormalization group flow exists , characterized by the condition @xmath146 by quoting ( [ alt ] ) in terms of elementary functions , this equation reads , at the one - loop level , @xmath147 for positive @xmath48 , the only solution to ( [ fix ] ) is @xmath148 , ) as @xmath149 . ] which in our units means @xmath48 equal to @xmath77 . thus , the full quantum field theory has a built - in upper bound of the renormalization group flow , and the speed of light turns out to be the fixed point for the fermi velocity of electrons . in fact , it is not difficult to check that the one - loop beta function has a simple zero at @xmath150 , and to compute the flow in the neighborhood of the fixed point . the renormalization group equation for @xmath126 becomes @xmath151 the asymptotic behaviour of the solution is , taking for @xmath130 the fixed point value , @xmath152 in figure 7 we show the plot of this scaling behaviour , which is practically indistinguishable in the range considered from that obtained with the nonrelativistic approximation . recalling the vanishing of the electric charge beta function @xmath153 at the one - loop level , we may assert that to this perturbative order we have identified an infrared fixed point given by @xmath131 and arbitrary ( though small ) value of @xmath125 . the one - loop result is not satisfactory , however , since the independence of @xmath125 on the flow may be destabilized by higher - loop effects . in the renormalization group approach to fermi liquid theory@xcite , the consideration of the one - loop graph in figure 5 is enough since it encodes , via the renormalization group , information of the series of ladder diagrams . in the usual analysis of the many - body theory with an extended fermi surface these are which dominate in the infrared regime . because of the existence of fermi points in the honeycomb lattice at half - filling , though , there is no argument here to conclude the relevance of one set of diagrams against the rest . in our quantum field theory description it seems that no diagram can be discarded a priori . it is also for this reason that there are diagrams which are irrelevant in fermi liquid theory but give rise in our model to wavefunction renormalization and anomalous dimensions in the infrared regime . regarding the renormalization of the electric charge , we have analyzed the polarization tensor @xmath154 to second order in perturbation theory . as stated above , the renormalization of the photon field @xmath56 is directly related by gauge invariance to the renormalization of the charge @xmath155 . computing in the framework of dimensional regularization we have not found any divergent contribution of order @xmath156 to @xmath154 . the reason is the same operating in the one - loop polarization tensor . a nave dimensional analysis of the diagram shows that it should diverge linearly in momentum space . in the dimensional regularization scheme this leads to the appearance of gamma functions at half - integer values of the argument , instead of poles at @xmath157 . we believe that this scheme is the best suited for the regularization of the gauge theory it certainly is not going to break the gauge invariance in any event . if , however , one insists on understanding the regularization in terms of a cutoff dependence , it can be checked that this does not lead either to a renormalization of the scale of the field @xmath50 . one would have to look for divergent contributions of @xmath158 type accompanying the gauge invariant expression ( [ pol ] ) for @xmath154 . these are not present at the two - loop order and one may conjecture , following the above dimensional argument , that they do not appear to any order in perturbation theory . at or near the fixed point , the two - dimensional electron liquid we are describing is definitely not a fermi liquid . the main reason for this assertion is the anomalous dimension acquired by the electron field @xmath51 , which may be obtained from ( [ zpsi ] ) evaluated now at @xmath150 . at the fixed point the behaviour of the green function under a change of scale is @xmath159 or , equivalently , after introducing the precise value of @xmath160 @xmath161 we arrive in this way to solve the problem of the proliferation of @xmath162 terms in the perturbative computation of the density of states . as is well - known , the renormalization group approach succeeds in summing up all these increasingly divergent contributions , in the form of an anomalous dependence on the electron frequency . we have found that this sum is consistently achieved in the relativistic regime , where the fixed point lies and the electron field has a simple , anomalous scaling behaviour . we have studied a system of electrons in the two - dimensional honeycomb lattice interacting via a coulomb potential . the fact that the fermi surface of this lattice at half - filling consists of two isolated points renders the problem similar to the @xmath3 case and allows the formulation of the low energy effective theory as a standard quantum field theory . we have been able to investigate the infrared behavior of the system by using renormalization group techniques and have seen that , indeed , it resembles more that of one - dimensional electrons than that of a two - dimensional fermi liquid . before entering into the analysis of the phenomenological consequences of our work , there are a few points that we would like to emphasize . let us first comment on the use made through the paper of the electromagnetic field propagator . this use is unconventional both from the condensed matter point of view where the photon is mostly absent , and from the quantum field theory since , as we will strength now , we are not dealing with standard massless qed . expression ( [ em ] ) shows the usual three - dimensional photon of qed . this is what we use in our relativistic computations . the constraint that , in the electronic interactions , the two points lay on the lattice plane , allows us to integrate out the perpendicular dimension . the resulting expression read as a propagator on the plane certainly differs from the standard propagator in qed@xmath0 . in particular its infrared behavior is quite different , it goes like @xmath163 instead of the standard @xmath164 . this is the origin of , for instance , the finiteness of the photon self - energy up to the two - loop level and , hence , of the nonrenormalization of the electric charge . let us now comment on the comparison between the instantaneous versus the retarded propagator . the effect of retardation on the infrared behavior of nonlocal quantities has been exemplified with the computation of the quantum corrections to the density of states at the end of section 2 . in the theory given by the coulomb interaction ( [ hcoul ] ) , no one - loop corrections were found to the free value of the density of states . in the theory with the retarded interaction our rg analysis shows that , despite the infrared divergence found at the one - loop level , the approach is consistent in the sense that the perturbative expansion of the nonrelativistic approximation does not have to make sense in the infrared when the fermi velocity is still far from the fixed - point value . hence , we must resort to the full relativistic theory when computing the infrared behavior of nonlocal observables . there , the rg allows to interpret the one - loop infrared instability shown in section 2 as the manifestation , in perturbation theory , of the anomalous dimension . we have then found that our original system flows in the infrared towards a fixed point of the renormalization group that is a relativistic quantum field theory with anomalous dimension of the fermionic propagator . our analysis has important consequences in condensed matter physics . one of the more interesting is the anomalous screening of the coulomb interactions of the model . in a fermi liquid , formation of virtual electron - hole pairs ( i. e. , quantum corrections to the photon self - energy ) generates a new scale , the screening length . this is the basis of the absence of long - range interactions in the ultralocal approach to interacting electrons ( hubbard model ) . what we have seen is that , due to the vanishing of the density of states at the fermi level and to the absence of renormalization of the photon self - energy , there is no metallic screening in our materials @xcite . the robustness of this result stands on the non - renormalization of the chemical potential ( the fermi level remains a set of two points after the corrections due to the interactions ) . moreover we have seen that , although the low energy density of states goes to zero , no finite gap appears in the spectrum of charge excitations . our results rule out the validity of descriptions in terms of on - site interactions only . screening effects are not strong enough to reduce the couplings to simple on - site terms . the one - particle properties are very different from those of a conventional fermi system . the wavefunction renormalization leads to the disappearance of the quasiparticle peak at low energies . thus , no effective description in terms of independent , and coherent , quasiparticles is possible . the situation resembles the 1d luttinger liquid , where any amount of electron - electron interaction suffices to wipe out the quasiparticle pole , leading to incoherent one - particle excitations . finally , the existence of nontrivial scaling laws implies that anomalous exponents should show up in a variety of properties , like the specific heat , susceptibility , etc . the possibility of having an experimental test of these results remains open . to conclude this summary and to point out possible future work , we would like to remark the interest of investigating the connections of our work with the infrared catastrophe mentioned in the introduction as well as with other unconventional fermi liquid behavior discussed in the literature @xcite . on this respect , this work can be seen as a rigorous realization of the ideas settled in @xcite . * acknowledgements * this work has been partially supported by the cicyt . 99 a. a. abrikosov , l. p. gorkov and i. e. dzyaloshinski , _ methods of quantum field theory in statistical physics _ ( dover , new york , 1975 ) . e. m. lifshitz and l. p. pitaevskii , _ statistical physics _ , vol . 2 ( pergamon press , oxford , 1980 ) . f. d. m. haldane , _ j. phys _ * c14 * ( 1981 ) 2585 . p. w. anderson , _ phys . lett . _ * 64 * ( 1990 ) 1839 ; * 65 * 2306 ; * 66 * 3226 . for a recent review on the infrared catastrophe see the talk of p. w. anderson in _ the physics and the mathematical physics of the hubbard model " _ , nato a.r.w . , san sebastian , october 1993 . for a theoretical physicist s vision of the problem see j. polchinski , _ effective field theory and the fermi surface " _ , hep - th-9210046 . g. benfatto and g. gallavotti , _ j. stat . * 59 * ( 1990 ) 541 ; _ phys . rev . _ * b42 * ( 1990 ) 9967 . r. shankar , _ physica _ * a177 * ( 1991 ) 530 . for an extense review see r. shankar , _ renormalization group approach to interacting fermions " _ _ , to appear . wilson , _ phys . rev . _ * b4 * ( 1971 ) 3174 , 3184 . j. gonzlez , f. guinea , and m. a. h. vozmediano , _ nucl . _ * b406 * ( 1993 ) 771 . h. w. kroto , j. r. heath , s. c. obrien , r. f. curl and r. e. smalley , _ nature _ * 318 * ( 1985 ) 162 . w. krtschmer , l. d. lamb , k. fostiropoulos and d. r. huffman , _ nature _ * 347 * ( 1990 ) 354 . a. f. hebard , m. j. rosseinsky , r. c. haddon , d. w. murphy , s. h. glarum , t. t. m. palstra , a. p. ramirez , and a. r. kortan , _ nature _ * 350 * ( 1991 ) 600 . m. j. rosseinsky _ _ , _ phys . _ * 66 * ( 1991 ) 2830 . k. holczer , o. klein , s .- huang , r. b. kaner , k .- j . fu , r. l. whetten and f. diederich , _ science _ * 252 * ( 1991 ) 1154 . for a review on the properties of fullerenes , see k. holczer and r. l. whetten , _ carbon _ * 30 * ( 1992 ) 1261 . j. gonzlez , f. guinea and m. a. h. vozmediano , _ electrostatic screening in fullerene molecules " _ , preprint cond - mat/9303007 ( to be published in _ mod . phys s. sorella and e. tosatti , _ europhys . * 19 * ( 1992 ) 699 , g. santoro , m. airoldi , s. sorella and e. tosatti , _ phys . b _ * 47 * ( 1993 ) 16216 . p. ramond , _ field theory . a modern primer_. ( benjamin / cummings , london , 1981 ) . j. zinn - justin , lectures delivered at the cargse summer school 1973 ( unpublished ) . k. symanzik , in _ particles , quantum fields and statistical mechanics _ ( edited by m. alexanian and a. zepeda ) ( springer verlag , berlin , 1975 ) . d. j. amit , _ field theory , renormalization group and critical phenomena _ , chap . 8 ( mcgraw - hill , new york , 1978 ) . i. s. gradshteyn and i. m. ryzhik , _ table of integrals , series and products _ , p. 1044 ( academic press , new york , 1980 ) . k. g. wilson , _ phys . * 28 * ( 1972 ) 548 . s. a. chin , _ ann . * 108 * ( 1977 ) 301 . x. g. wen , _ phys . _ * b42 * ( 1990 ) 6623 . c. m. varma _ et al . _ , _ phys . * 63 * ( 1989 ) 1996 . * figure 1 : * the planar honeycomb lattice .
Abstract: | [
"a system of electrons in the two - dimensional honeycomb lattice with coulomb interactions is described by a renormalizable quantum field theory similar but not equal to qed@xmath0 . renormalization group techniques are used to investigate the infrared behavior of the system that flows to a fixed point with non - fermi liquid characteristics . there are anomalous dimensions in the fermionic observables , no quasiparticle pole , and anomalous screening of the coulomb interaction . these results are robust as the fermi level is not changed by the interaction . the system resembles in the infrared the one - dimensional luttinger liquid . = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = -1 true cm 21 true cm october 1993 + + ( a renormalization group approach ) _ instituto de estructura de la materia , csic _ + _ serrano 123 , 28006 madrid , spain _ + + _ cantoblanco , 28049 madrid , spain . _ + + _ avda . mediterrneo s / n , 28913 legans ( madrid ) , spain ."
] | 8,900 | 8,900 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: it has long been conjectured , on both theoretical and observational grounds , that the outermost regions of the solar system may contain a large population of small icy bodies . for example , on the basis of theoretical considerations of the genesis of the planetary system from the primordial solar nebula , @xcite suggested that a remnant population of icy planetesimals left over from the planet - building process may exist at the current epoch beyond the orbit of neptune . @xcite and @xcite speculated on a massive comet belt as the source of unexplained perturbations of neptune s orbit [ although this argument must now be discarded as the post-_voyager _ revisions in the planetary ephemeris no longer show any unexplained residuals in neptune s motion ( @xcite ) ] . @xcite analyzed the orbital plane perturbations of comet p / halley and concluded that any comet belt between 40 au and 50 au has a total mass less than @xmath1 . this limit still allows for very large numbers perhaps @xmath2 of cometary bodies . more recently , it has been suggested that the observed short period comets with orbital periods @xmath3 yr the `` jupiter family '' comets originate in a belt of low - inclination bodies just beyond the orbit of neptune , between 35 au and 50 au [ @xcite ] . the older hypothesis that short period comets originate in a population of near - parabolic oort cloud comets which are perturbed into shorter orbits by the giant planets appears unlikely : @xcite have shown that the orbital element distribution of the observed short period comets is inconsistent with a source in the nearly isotropic oort cloud but is compatible with a disk - like source in a trans - neptune comet belt , which they call the `` kuiper belt '' . a possible member of the kuiper belt was first discovered in 1992 at a distance of 41 au from the sun [ 1992 qb@xmath4 , reported in @xcite ] , and several additional discoveries have been reported since suggesting a potential population of @xmath5 bodies larger than @xmath6 km [ @xcite ] . the dynamical structure of this population has been the subject of several recent theoretical studies [ @xcite ] . the first two of these [ @xcite and @xcite ] , studied the long term stability of test particles in low - eccentricity and low - inclination orbits beyond neptune , subject only to the gravitational perturbations of the giant planets in their present orbital configuration . they found orbital instability on short timescales ( @xmath7 yr ) interior to 33 - 34 au , an intricate structure of interspersed regions of stability and instability in the semimajor axis range of 34 au to 43 au , and substantially stable orbits beyond 43 au . the intricacy of the dynamical structure appears to be particularly acute near the locations of orbital resonances with neptune . any primordial trans - neptune population of planetesimals was undoubtedly subject to dynamical evolution during the planet formation process , and the initial conditions assumed in the above studies are not necessarily representative of the state of the kuiper belt at the end of planet formation , as acknowledged in @xcite . the nature of the `` dynamical sculpting '' of the kuiper belt that would have occurred during the late stages of planet formation was the subject of a study by @xcite . this study concludes that the giant planets orbits would have evolved significantly and the kuiper belt would have been sculpted into a highly non - uniform distribution early in solar system history : most of the primordial small bodies in the region beyond neptune s orbit and up to approximately 50 au heliocentric distance would have been swept into narrow regions of orbital resonances with neptune , particularly the 3:2 and the 2:1 orbital resonances which are located at semimajor axes of approximately 39.4 au and 47.8 au , respectively . the orbital inclinations of most of these objects would remain low ( typically @xmath8 ) , but the eccentricities would be excited to significant values , typically @xmath9 . this structure would be largely preserved to the present epoch . pluto ( and its satellite charon ) have long been known to reside in the 3:2 neptune resonance ; the resonance libration protects this pair from close encounters with neptune , despite their neptune - crossing orbit ( with eccentricity @xmath10 ) . several of the newly - discovered kuiper belt objects are also likely residents of this resonance [ @xcite ] . ( however , note that the orbital parameters of most of these objects remain rather poorly constrained pending future follow - up observations . ) in any case , it is clear that the locations of neptune s orbital resonances are particularly interesting with regard to the long term dynamics of the kuiper belt . in the region between neptune s orbit and approximately 50 au heliocentric distance , by far the most important orbital perturbations are due to neptune alone , although the n - body effects of all the planets particularly secular resonance effects also surely play a significant role over the age of the solar system . in this paper , i use the simplest possible dynamical model namely , the circular , planar restricted three - body model to determine the basic phase space structure near the locations of neptune s orbital resonances exterior to neptune s orbit . this model does not reflect the complexities that arise with ( i ) non - zero orbital inclination of the test particle , ( ii ) a realistic representation of neptune s motion ( its time - varying orbit ) , and ( iii ) the perturbations of the other planets . some of these unmodeled effects can lead to important variations in the dynamics . in particular , as mentioned above , secular resonances in certain regions of phase space can drive the inclinations and eccentricities to large amplitudes and further complicate the dynamics near mean motion resonances . nevertheless , this model is a reasonable first approximation because ( a ) the evidence from short period comets suggests a low - inclination source population , ( b ) in the trans - neptunian space , there are no first order orbital resonances with any other giant planets , and ( c ) neptune s eccentricity and inclination do not exceed @xmath11 and @xmath12 , respectively , over billion year timescales under the effects of the mutual gravitational perturbations of the planets . the advantage of this simple model is that it is tractable : it allows for the calculation of 2-dimensional surfaces - of - section in which the phase space structure in particular , the properties of resonance regions can be easily visualized . this provides for relatively straightforward estimation of the widths of resonances and the determination of several interesting dynamical properties of resonant orbits , such as the libration periods and their dependence on orbital eccentricity and libration amplitude . to a considerable degree , most of these properties are preserved in the more realistic situation . in short , this model provides a reasonable baseline " for the phase space structure in the trans - neptune region . the rest of this paper is organized as follows . section 2 describes the technical details of the planar , circular restricted 3-body model for the sun , neptune and a kuiper belt object , including a description of the information that may be gleaned from surfaces - of - section . section 3 provides a detailed look at the phase space structure near the major neptune resonances of interest for the kuiper belt . section 4 summarizes and discusses the results . the classical planar circular restricted three - body problem is a particular case of the general gravitational three - body problem of masses @xmath13 defined by the following restrictions : 1 . the motion of all three bodies takes place in a common plane ; 2 . the third body , @xmath14 , has zero mass ; therefore it does not influence the motion of @xmath15 and @xmath16 ; and 3 . the masses @xmath15 and @xmath16 describe circular orbits about their common center of mass . in the context of this paper , @xmath15 represents the sun and @xmath16 represents neptune . the system is made non - dimensional by the following choice of units : * the unit of mass is taken to be @xmath17 ; * the unit of length is chosen to be , @xmath18 , the constant separation between @xmath15 and @xmath16 ( the mean heliocentric distance of neptune ) ; * the unit of time is chosen such that the orbital period of @xmath15 and @xmath16 about their center of mass is @xmath19 . then the universal constant of gravitation , @xmath20 , and the masses of the sun and neptune are @xmath21 and @xmath22 , respectively , where @xmath23 . for the sun - neptune system , we have @xmath24 , and this value is used throughout this paper . in a reference frame with axes @xmath25 rotating with @xmath15 and @xmath16 and with origin at their center - of - mass , the sun and neptune have fixed coordinates , @xmath26 and @xmath27 , respectively , and the third ( massless ) body has the following equations of motion : @xmath28 where @xmath29 and @xmath30 are the test particle s distance to the sun and to neptune , respectively : @xmath31^{1/2 } , \nonumber\\ & & \\ r_2 & = & [ ( x-1+\mu)^2+y^2]^{1/2}. \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] these equations of motion admit a constant of the motion , the _ jacobi integral _ , given by @xmath32 no other constant of the motion is known . for future reference , we note that the jacobi integral can be expressed in terms of the test particle s semimajor axis , @xmath33 , and eccentricity , @xmath34 : @xmath35 _ surfaces - of - section _ the motion of the test particle takes place on a three - dimensional subspace ( defined by a particular value of @xmath36 ) embedded in the four - dimensional phase space , @xmath37 . the usual two - dimensional surface - of - section ( s - o - s ) is defined by @xmath38 and the coordinates on the section are @xmath39 . the geometrical interpretation is straightforward : we plot the x coordinate and velocity of the test particle at every conjunction with neptune . for orbits exterior to neptune ( strictly speaking , with mean motion smaller than neptune s ) , this occurs every time the test particle is aligned with the sun and neptune and is on the _ opposite _ side of the sun from neptune ; for orbits interior to neptune ( with mean motion larger than neptune s ) , this occurs every time the test particle is aligned with the sun and neptune and is on the _ same _ side of the sun as neptune . for the solar system beyond neptune , only the exterior orbits are of interest . in the s - o - s so defined , _ periodic _ orbits of the test particle appear as discrete points . the successive crossings of this surface by a _ quasiperiodic _ orbit lie on a closed smooth curve , while a _ chaotic _ orbit fills a two - dimensional area . as the regions in the neighborhood of orbital resonances are of particular interest here , the following remarks are in order . * the location of a @xmath40 orbital period resonance is defined by kepler s relation between the orbital period and the semimajor axis : @xmath41 where @xmath42 and @xmath43 are integers . * in general , at any resonance , one finds a family of stable periodic orbits that can be parametrized by the orbital eccentricity ( or , equivalently , the jacobi integral , if we use eqn . [ eq : ares ] in eqn . [ eq : c ] ) such that the semimajor axis equals @xmath44 for all orbits in this family , and the eccentricity ranges from zero to some maximum value , @xmath45 ; for @xmath46 the periodic orbit becomes unstable . * in some neighborhood , @xmath47 of @xmath44 , near each resonance , there exist stable quasiperiodic orbits that librate with finite amplitude about the exact resonant orbit ; the half - width @xmath48 depends upon the mass parameter @xmath22 , the resonance itself ( @xmath44 ) and the jacobi integral @xmath36 . let us consider the neptune - pluto 3:2 resonance as an illustrative example . if pluto s inclination is neglected , and if one assumes a fixed circular orbit for neptune , then the jacobi integral @xmath49 for the sun+neptune+pluto restricted three - body problem . figure 1(a ) is a s - o - s in the neighborhood of the 3:2 neptune resonance for this value of @xmath36 . this section shows examples of all three types of orbits . the center of the smooth curves lying near @xmath50 corresponds to the periodic orbit whose period is exactly 3/2 that of neptune . the smooth curves are quasiperiodic orbits surrounding this exact periodic orbit and represent test particle orbits that librate about the exact resonance ; the size of a smooth curve bears a direct relationship to the amplitude of libration . such librating orbits are phase - protected from having close encounters with neptune even if the orbit is neptune - crossing . it can be seen that , in general , the regions of quasiperiodic orbits are surrounded by chaotic orbits , beyond a certain libration amplitude , the smooth curves dissolve into a chaotic zone . embedded within the `` chaotic sea '' are other stable zones or chains - of - islands that represent other nearby higher order and secondary resonances . the origin of the chaos is due to the overlap of the higher - order and secondary resonances . it is perhaps more meaningful to visualize the resonance zone in variables that can be more directly translated into `` resonance width '' . the latter is traditionally ( and somewhat loosely ) defined as the range in semimajor axis where the orbital perturbations are large . in the restricted three - body problem with @xmath51 , this is the range in which the amplitude of the orbital parameter variations of the test particle is not simply linearly proportional to @xmath22 , but is @xmath52 with @xmath53 . in general , in the neighborhood of any resonance , we find regions of stable , librating orbits surrounded by a substantial chaotic zone where test particles may suffer close encounters with neptune . in this paper , i will define the resonance half - width @xmath48 as the maximum amplitude of the semimajor axis variations of _ stably librating _ resonant orbits . the value of @xmath48 will be estimated from the s - o - s as described below . the phase space structure seen in the @xmath39 plane can also be seen in other ( generalized ) canonical coordinates . for example , in plane polar coordinates the equivalent s - o - s @xmath54 in the inertial reference frame is @xmath55 with the same section condition as in eqn . [ eq : sos ] . the s - o - s condition can be rewritten in terms of polar coordinates as follows : @xmath56 where @xmath57 is the longitude of neptune , and @xmath58 is the mean motion of the test particle . in other words , the @xmath55 plane is equivalent to the @xmath39 plane with points plotted at every conjunction of the test particle with neptune . the @xmath55 s - o - s is shown in figure 1(b ) . carrying this one step further by means of a canonical transformation to delaunay variables , @xmath59 ) where @xmath60 are the mean anomaly and mean longitude and @xmath61 ( cf . chapter xvii in @xcite and chapter 10 in @xcite ) , this same section can also be seen in the @xmath62 plane . the @xmath62 s - o - s is shown in figure 1(c ) . it is evident from the latter figure that for pluto - like resonance - locked orbits ( for the particular value of @xmath36 chosen in this s - o - s ) the mean anomaly at conjunctions with neptune librates about @xmath63 and its maximum libration amplitude is @xmath64 . orbits with larger amplitudes are chaotic . in addition to the maximum amplitude of @xmath65 , the resonance libration region is bounded in @xmath66 as well . now , if we note that ( i ) the jacobi integral provides a relationship between @xmath33 and @xmath34 ( see eqn . ( [ eq : c ] ) ) , and ( ii ) for a particular orbital resonance defined by the ratio @xmath40 of the orbital periods of the test particle and neptune , the librating orbits all have a phase - averaged semimajor axis @xmath67 , then any s - o - s can be labeled uniquely either by the value of @xmath36 or , in the neighborhood of a particular orbital resonance , by the value of @xmath68 ( with the understanding that @xmath67 ) . for example , for the s - o - s in figure 1 , we have @xmath49 ; near the 3:2 resonance , @xmath69 ; therefore , from eqn . ( [ eq : c ] ) we have @xmath70 . thus , the phase space structure in the neighborhood of a particular orbital resonance can be systematically studied in a set of surfaces - of - section where all of them have a common value of @xmath71 but various values of @xmath68 ( hence different values of @xmath36 ) . this allows a visualization of the phase space near an orbital resonance as a function of the mean orbital eccentricity . finally , in figure 1(d ) i have plotted the values of @xmath33 against @xmath65 for the same points represented in figures 1(a c ) . _ note that this is not a surface - of - section . _ one might call it a `` pseudo - surface - of - section '' , for @xmath33 is not a canonical variable . however , the constancy of @xmath36 imposes a relationship between @xmath33 and @xmath34 ( cf . [ eq : c ] ) which ensures that this plot looks very similar to the @xmath62 s - o - s in figure 1(b ) and the stable libration regions and the chaotic regions are easily distinguished . the reason for choosing this non - canonical variable is that the resonance width @xmath48 of the stable libration zone can be readily determined from this figure . therefore , the @xmath72 plane the pseudo - surface - of - section will be used in the next section for a systematic look at the properties of the phase space in the neighborhood of several neptune resonances . the libration timescale in the libration zone and the timescale for orbital instability in the chaotic zone are of particular interest for the dynamics of kuiper belt objects . these libration timescales have been determined for individual resonances and are also given in the next section . typically , the timescale for orbital instability inside the chaotic zone surrounding a resonance is only a few times the libration period . however , close to the boundary between the libration zone and the chaotic zone , this timescale can become exceedingly large . in particular , for pluto - like orbits with eccentricity @xmath10 in the 3:2 neptune resonance , the timescale for instability in the chaotic zone ( for amplitude of the resonance angle greater than @xmath73 ) is @xmath74 yr , but close to the edge of the libration zone this timescale increases by an order of magnitude or more . this is illustrated in figure 2 . in principle , there is an infinite number of orbital resonances in the three - body problem . however , we will see that only a handful warrant any detailed investigation . low - eccentricity orbits in the immediate neighborhood of a planet are unstable . there is a simple explanation for this orbital instability that follows from chirikov s ( 1979 ) `` resonance overlap criterion '' : first order @xmath75 resonances with @xmath76 overlap completely [ @xcite ] . [ numerical experiments by @xcite show that the numerical coefficient on the right hand side in this relation must be revised to 0.44 ] . complete overlap of neighboring resonances results in the destabilization of all periodic and quasi - periodic orbits in the neighborhood of those resonances . in other words , circular test particle orbits are unstable in the immediate neighborhood @xmath77 of a planet s orbit . for neptune ( @xmath24 ) , this criterion shows that all first order resonances with @xmath78 are completely overlapping , so that circular orbits beyond neptune with orbital radii less than about 33 au are unstable . therefore , beyond the semimajor axis range of about 33 au , at most only seven first order @xmath75 resonances with @xmath79 are isolated from each other ( at least for low eccentricities ) . however , i have found numerically that low - eccentricity orbits at the 8:7 and 7:6 neptune resonances are also chaotic . this is not entirely surprising , for the resonance overlap criterion is quite approximate , and wisdom s scaling law is strictly valid only in the asymptotic limit @xmath80 . therefore , only five first order @xmath75 resonances with @xmath81 are of potential significance for the long - term storage of kuiper belt objects . furthermore , since all second and higher order resonances in the first - order resonance overlap region are also destroyed , it follows that there are only seven second order neptune resonances of potential interest : @xmath82 with @xmath83 . of these , i have found numerically that only three ( 3:1 , 5:3 , and 7:5 ) have resonance widths @xmath84 . therefore , the phase space in the neighborhood of only these three second order resonances will be discussed here . figures 310 show the properties of these first and second order neptune resonances . they are arranged in order of decreasing mean heliocentric distance . each figure has seven parts : the first four [ ( a)(d ) ] show the resonance zones in the pseudo - surfaces - of - section [ plots of @xmath72 ] for @xmath86 and 0.4 , respectively ; note that the vertical scale is the same in all these figures , so that the variations in the extent of the libration and chaotic zones with @xmath68 and with the mean distance of the resonance from neptune can be readily discerned . the next two panels [ ( e ) and ( f ) ] show examples of librating , resonance - locked orbits in the rotating reference frame . the last one , panel ( g ) , shows the period of libration as a function of the mean orbital eccentricity and the amplitude of libration of the resonance angle , @xmath87 . a few words are in order regarding the latter variable . for a @xmath40 resonance the resonance angle is defined as follows : @xmath88 where @xmath89 and @xmath90 are the mean longitude and longitude of perihelion of the test particle , and @xmath91 is the mean longitude of neptune . ( note that @xmath42 is a positive integer ; @xmath43 is a negative integer for interior resonances , positive for exterior resonances ; the latter are the only resonances of interest in this paper . ) @xmath87 is the natural variable that arises in the perturbative analysis of orbital resonances , and it can be used to make a first approximation theory that models the resonant motion of the test particle with a single degree - of - freedom pendulum - like dynamical system [ see @xcite ] . for a test particle locked in a stable exterior resonance , @xmath87 librates about a mean value which is usually @xmath63 . [ there are two exceptions to this : ( i ) for sufficiently high eccentricity , librations of the resonance angle about @xmath92 are also possible ; and ( ii ) the 2:1 and the 3:1 resonances allow for asymmetric librations where the center of libration of the resonance angle is displaced away from @xmath63 . these are discussed further below . ] at conjunctions with neptune , the resonance angle is related to the mean anomaly : @xmath93 . therefore , the librations or chaotic variations of @xmath65 evident in the surfaces - of - section are also reflected in the behavior of @xmath87 . the physical significance of the resonance angle can be seen by noting that when the test particle is at perihelion , @xmath94 , so that @xmath95 thus , the behavior of @xmath87 gives a direct measure of the longitude separation of neptune from the test particle s perihelion . this is obviously a critical quantity , especially for high - eccentricity neptune - crossing orbits , as the stable libration of @xmath87 then ensures that the particle is protected from catastrophic close encounters with neptune . the maximum excursion from the center of libration of @xmath87 then gives a measure of the smallest possible separation between neptune and the test particle s perihelion in stable resonance - protected orbits . the resonance libration period as a function of the amplitude of libration of @xmath87 is shown for various values of @xmath68 in the last panel ( g ) of figures 310 . these curves are rather counter - intuitive . recall that in the oft - used pendulum model for non - linear resonances , the pendulum libration period increases monotonically with amplitude and becomes arbitrarily large close to the separatrix ( the orbit that separates the oscillations from rotations of the pendulum ) . in contrast , in figures 310(g ) , we see that , except for the asymmetric librations at the 2:1 and 3:1 resonances , the libration period in general _ decreases _ with increasing libration amplitude . furthermore , near a @xmath43-th order resonance , the leading order ( in eccentricity ) resonance term in the perturbing potential for the test particle is proportional to the @xmath43-th power of the eccentricity , hence the small - amplitude libration period might be expected to vary as @xmath96 ; this analogy from the pendulum model does not hold either , as evident in figures 310(g ) . thus , the standard non - linear pendulum model should be used with caution for orbital resonances . the general characteristics of the phase space near these first and second order neptune resonances are summarized as follows . ( note that the 2:1 and the 3:1 resonances are exceptional in many respects , and are discussed later in detail . ) * in general , the phase space in the neighborhood of a resonance contains a zone of stably librating , resonance - locked orbits surrounded by a zone of chaotic orbits . the width of the resonance zone ( including the stable as well as the chaotic regions ) increases with @xmath68 ; however , the width of the libration zone , in general , shrinks as the resonance separatrix dissolves into a chaotic layer that increases in thickness with @xmath68 . the typical width of a neptune resonance libration zone is @xmath97 , or about @xmath98 au . * the periodic orbit at exact @xmath40 resonance has a @xmath42-fold symmetry in the rotating frame : it makes @xmath42 perihelion passages during a synodic period . the perihelion ( and aphelion ) longitudes are spaced @xmath99 . the quasi - periodic orbits librating about the exact resonance also exhibit @xmath42-fold symmetry in the rotating frame when traced over a complete libration period . for the stable librators ( resonance angle @xmath87 librating about @xmath63 ) , the opposition with neptune occurs near the test particle s aphelion ; hence these may be called `` aphelion librators '' . * for sufficiently large @xmath68 , a new type of periodic ( resonant ) orbit is possible , where one of the @xmath42 perihelion passages during a synodic period occurs near neptune . in fact , the perihelion loop encompasses neptune . for this orbit and for the quasi - periodic orbits in its neighborhood , the resonance angle @xmath87 librates about @xmath92 . these orbits may be called `` perihelion librators '' . however , these perihelion librators are probably not of practical importance , as unmodeled perturbations are likely to destabilize them . * in general , the libration periods are smaller for resonances located closer to neptune , and the libration periods decrease with libration amplitude . typical small amplitude libration periods are ( 1 - 2)@xmath100 yr . the exceptional cases of the 2:1 and the 3:1 resonances are discussed below . _ the 2:1 neptune resonance _ the synodic period of a test particle near the 2:1 resonance is approximately equal to its orbital period . thus , conjunctions with neptune occur every @xmath101 years . the properties of the phase space near the 2:1 neptune resonance are summarized as follows ( cf . figure 4 ) . * the resonance half - width , @xmath48 , increases from @xmath102 to @xmath103 as @xmath68 increases from @xmath104 to @xmath105 . the phase space at this resonance is largely regular ; there is no discernible chaotic zone until the eccentricity exceeds @xmath106 . * for @xmath68 exceeding a critical value ( which is @xmath107 for the 2:1 neptune resonance ) , there are two types of librating orbits : ( i ) symmetric librators whose perihelia librate ( with large amplitude ) with a mean value @xmath63 away from neptune , and ( ii ) asymmetric librators whose perihelia librate ( with amplitude smaller than @xmath108 ) about a mean value which depends upon @xmath68 . ( surprisingly , the orbit with aphelion exactly at neptune s longitude is unstable : it coincides with the separatrix that divides the phase space into the symmetric and asymmetric libration zones . ) the existence of such asymmetric librations has been noted previously ( @xcite , @xcite ) , but the work here provides the first quantitative analysis for the specific case of neptune s resonances . * figures 4(e , f ) show examples of these two types of orbits . note that for the asymmetric librators , there are two independent centers of libration , offset equally on either side of neptune s longitude . upon inspection of the behavior of the resonance angle @xmath87 , it is found that these centers of perihelion libration ( relative to neptune ) vary from @xmath109 for @xmath110 to @xmath111 for @xmath112 . * the phase space for the symmetric librators shrinks rapidly with increasing @xmath68 , while that for the asymmetric librators increases slightly . * at small values of @xmath68 , there is no evidence for a chaotic zone near this resonance , but for @xmath113 , the largest amplitude librators become chaotic . a thin chaotic zone also appears in the neighborhood of the separatrix that separates the asymmetric librations from the symmetric librations . * the eccentricity variations of the resonance - locked orbits have amplitude @xmath114 . ( indeed , within the planar circular restricted three - body model , an initially circular test particle orbit at the 2:1 resonance has its eccentricity pumped up to only @xmath115 . ) the eccentricity variations on the chaotic orbits are generally of considerably larger magnitude . * figure 4(g ) shows libration amplitude vs. libration period . for the asymmetric ( small amplitude ) librators , the libration period decreases monotonically with @xmath68 and increases with libration amplitude ( reminiscent of the standard non - linear pendulum ) . the libration period becomes indefinitely large at the separatrix between the asymmetric and symmetric librators . the small amplitude libration periods are several tens - of - thousands of years long . _ the 3:1 neptune resonance _ the synodic period of a test particle near the 3:1 resonance is half its orbital period . thus , conjunctions with neptune occur approximately every 248 years . the properties of the phase space near the 3:1 neptune resonance ( cf . figure 3 ) are very similar to that near the 2:1 resonance ; some specifics are noted below . * the resonance half - width , @xmath48 , increases from @xmath116 to @xmath117 as @xmath68 increases from @xmath104 to @xmath105 . the phase space at this resonance is regular ; there is no discernible chaotic zone for this range of eccentricities . * for librating orbits , perihelion and aphelion occur at approximately the same longitude relative to neptune . as in the 2:1 resonance , there are two types of librating orbits the symmetric and asymmetric librators ; however , the asymmetric librations appear only at @xmath68 exceeding @xmath118 . * the small amplitude libration periods are very long ( @xmath119 myr ) for low eccentricity @xmath120 orbits , but considerably shorter ( 30,00080,000 yr ) for higher eccentricities . numerical studies of the stability of low eccentricity , low inclination orbits of small objects in the trans - neptunian kuiper belt subject to the gravitational perturbations of the giant planets have shown that the inner edge of the kuiper belt is at about 34 au heliocentric distance ; beyond 34 au and up to about 42 au there are interspersed regions of stability and instability [ @xcite , @xcite ] . this structure bears a complex correlation with the locations of neptune orbital resonances . other studies [ @xcite , @xcite ] suggest that early in the history of the solar system , the majority of kuiper belt objects were swept into eccentric orbits in narrow zones located at neptune s orbital resonances , and that the regions in - between the resonances would have been largely cleared of residual planetesimals . recent and ongoing observational surveys of the outer solar system indicate the presence of a large population of small bodies beyond neptune [ @xcite ] . these are quite likely the source of short period comets [ @xcite , @xcite ] . furthermore , their orbital distribution is likely to hold clues to the formation and early dynamical evolution of the outer solar system [ @xcite ] . all of these considerations have motivated the present study . using the planar circular restricted three body model ( with the sun , neptune and a test particle ) , i have described in this paper the basic phase space structure in the neighborhood of neptune s exterior orbital resonances . the details may be gleaned from figures 310 . a succinct summary of these results is given in figure 11 which shows the locations and widths of the stable resonance libration zones . in general , these stable zones are bounded by chaotic layers of thickness that generally increases with eccentricity and decreases with distance from neptune . ( as the mean semimajor axis and eccentricity of chaotic orbits is not well defined , it is not possible to represent the chaotic layers in such a figure . ) the planar circular restricted three body model is the simplest dynamical model for the orbital dynamics of small objects in the kuiper belt . although this model may appear oversimplified , it provides a reasonable description and explanation for much of the dynamical behaviors found in the numerical studies mentioned above . for example , the location of the inner edge of this belt at @xmath121(3334 ) au is readily understood in terms of orbital instability induced by overlapping first order neptune resonances ; the additional perturbations due to neptune s non - circular , inclined , and time - varying orbit and the perturbations of the other planets do not significantly change the location of this boundary . the relatively isolated first and second order neptune resonances beyond 34 au ( in semimajor axis ) provide narrow stable libration regions for the long term storage of kuiper belt objects in eccentric ( often neptune - crossing ) orbits . this paper provides first approximation estimates for the locations and widths of these regions , and for the dynamical properties of resonant orbits . it also provides a direct visualization in two - dimensional surfaces - of - section of the global phase space structure ( the chaotic and stable regions ) in the vicinity of orbital resonances a characteristic of stable resonant orbits is the libration of the perihelion about a longitude well removed from neptune s location . typical libration periods are several tens - of - thousands of years . the libration zones are generally surrounded by narrow chaotic zones where orbits are unstable on timescales of a few libration periods , or @xmath122 yr . at the boundary between the stable resonance libration zone and the chaotic zone , the timescale for orbital instability may be exceedingly long . this paper also provides a quantitative analysis of libration periods and their dependence on libration amplitudes and orbital eccentricities at all the major exterior mean motion resonances of neptune . of course , the planar circular restricted three body model does not provide a complete picture . indeed , i expect that it underestimates the extent of the chaotic zones and overestimates the sizes of the stable libration zones near neptune resonances . but perhaps the most important missing element is the effect of secular resonances [ see @xcite ] on the long term dynamics of kuiper belt objects . for example , in some regions , secular resonances produce significant inclination excitation ; in such cases , the assumption of planarity becomes a poor approximation . [ pluto s orbit is a case in point ( @xcite ) . ] in order to discern these effects , one has to build much more elaborate analytical models or resort to extensive numerical integrations . as this work was being completed , i became aware of two preprints [ @xcite and @xcite ] on the same subject . these use different approaches to the problem : the present work has focussed on the phase space near mean motion resonances with neptune only and gives results that are exact but for a highly simplified physical model ; @xcite discuss the dynamics near mean motion resonances as well as secular resonances using primarily approximate semi - analytic models ; and @xcite discuss the dynamics near mean motion resonances , secular resonances as well as non - resonant regions using a purely numerical approach . a comparison of the present work with these two preprints follows . morbidelli ( 1995 ) describe semi - analytic and numerical investigations that include the effects of all four giant planets on the dynamics of test particles in the kuiper belt . a comparison of their results for the locations and widths of mean motion resonances ( see their figure 1 ) with the estimates obtained here ( cf . figure 11 ) shows that their models significantly overestimate the sizes of the resonance libration regions . s estimates of the resonance widths were obtained by averaging the planar , circular restricted problem of the four giant planets plus a test particle over fast variables , retaining only the dependence on the resonance angle . thus , their analysis does not account for the overlapping secondary resonances at the edges of the mean motion resonance libration zones that produce a chaotic layer and cause the libration regions to shrink rapidly with increasing eccentricity . this is the explanation for the differences between their figure 1 and figure 11 here . in addition , morbidelli find a singularity in the averaged hamiltonian that causes a great increase in the resonance width near neptune - crossing values of the eccentricity . however , this is an artifact , and does not appear in the unaveraged problem , as is obvious from the surfaces - of - section shown in the present work . the technique i used here does not make any averaging approximations , but uses the full unaveraged hamiltonian for the circular planar restricted problem , albeit without the secular effects of jupiter , saturn and uranus . _ s models also show that secular effects are negligible near mean motion resonances except in the case of the 3:2 neptune resonance . in the special case of the 3:2 resonance , as mentioned above , @xcite had previously shown the existence of the @xmath123 secular resonance embedded within the mean motion resonance ; in addition , analysis of pluto s orbit had also previously revealed the existence of another resonance characterized by the libration of the argument of perihelion ( @xcite ) . both of these resonances have the effect of exciting the inclination of the test particle . these resonances are not modeled in the present work , but morbidelli describe in some detail the location and widths of both these and other secular resonances . however , note that because most regions near secular resonances are regions of orbital instability , they are not likely to be of importance as reservoirs of kuiper belt objects although they may drive their transport to small heliocentric distances at the present epoch . duncan ( 1995 ) have performed quite extensive numerical integrations of test particle orbits subject to the gravitational perturbations of the four giant planets . they describe their results in terms of the stability ( over their integration time of 14 byr ) of orbits with particular initial semimajor axes , eccentricities and inclinations . their main conclusions are consistent with the results of the present work : namely , that particles with low initial inclination ( @xmath124 ) and initial perihelion distance less than @xmath125 au are unstable on timescales short compared to the age of the solar system , except that particles librating in low order mean motion resonances with neptune remain phase - protected from close encounters with that planet . they have also analyzed the 3:2 neptune resonance in more detail for the particular case with initial eccentricities of 0.2 and found three regimes : stable orbits deep in resonance with small libration amplitudes , @xmath126 ; an intermediate region with libration amplitudes in the range @xmath127 where the timescale for instability is @xmath128 yr ; and highly unstable orbits for libration amplitudes exceeding @xmath129 with stability timescales of @xmath130 yr . similar dynamics is found for all the neptune resonances studied in this paper . in comparison , the present work has shown that the region of stability deep in resonance as well as the highly chaotic region at large amplitudes are both explained by the perturbations of neptune alone ( assumed to be on a circular orbit ) ; the intermediate regime where the timescale for instability is @xmath128 yr is very small in the restricted three body model but evidently expands greatly ( at the expense of the stable libration zone ) in the full n - body model for the outer solar system . [ in this context , we note that if malhotra s ( 1995 ) theory for the orbital distribution of kuiper belt objects is correct , then this intermediate libration amplitude regime which allows a long - term leakage of resonant objects may be the primary source of the jupiter - family short - period comets . ] duncan also find that the resonance - protection fails only at inclinations exceeding @xmath131 . thus , we conclude that the planar circular restricted three body model used in the present work provides a fairly good description of these main trends . a clear advantage of this simple model is that its analysis is quite `` inexpensive '' compared to the months of cpu time expended in the numerical simulations by duncan furthermore , the numerical integration of orbits for the age of the solar system at sufficiently high resolution in the space of initial conditions remains beyond the reach of present - day computers , as acknowledged by duncan thus , the global picture of the phase space structure obtained in the present work provides an inexpensive yet reasonably good baseline for understanding the dynamics in the trans - neptunian solar system , and is particularly useful near mean motion resonances . this research was done while the author was a staff scientist at the lunar and planetary institute which is operated by the universities space research association under contract no . nasw-4574 with the national aeronautics and space administration . partial support for this work was also provided by nasa s origins of solar systems research program under grant no . this paper is lunar and planetary institute contribution 870 . 1 the phase space structure in the neighborhood of the neptune - pluto 3:2 orbital resonance determined from the circular planar restricted three - body model . the same surface - of - section is shown in different variables : ( a ) cartesian variables , @xmath39 ; ( b ) plane polar variables , @xmath55 ; ( c ) delaunay variables ( mean anomaly @xmath65 , canonical momentum @xmath132 ) . ( d ) is a pseudo - surface - of - section since the semimajor axis , @xmath33 , is not a canonical variable . however , qualitatively it is very similar to the surface - of - section ( c ) , and it provides a visualization of the resonance width in terms of the semimajor axis and the amplitude of the perihelion libration . 2 the time variation of the semimajor axis for orbits with @xmath133 near the boundary between the stable libration zone and the chaotic zone at the 3:2 neptune resonance ( cf . figure 1 ) . ( the unit of length is neptune s semimajor axis , and the unit of time is neptune s orbital period , approximately 165 yr . ) the jacobi integral for all four orbits is @xmath49 ; the initial conditions @xmath134 for the four orbits are ( a)(-1.6100,0.0,0.0,0.92442 ) , ( b)(-1.6105,0.0,0.0,0.92508 ) , ( c)(-1.6106,0.0,0.0,0.92521 ) , ( d)(-1.6110,0.0,0.0,0.92574 ) . these orbits are all chaotic and are shown in order of decreasing distance to the stability boundary . the orbits in ( a ) , ( b ) and ( c ) become unstable after 7 , 31 and @xmath135 librations ( @xmath136 , @xmath137 and @xmath138 yr ) , respectively . fig . 3 the 3:1 neptune resonance located at @xmath139 ( 62.6 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath140 ; ( b ) @xmath141 ; ( c ) @xmath142 ; ( d ) @xmath143 . the phase space is largely regular at this resonance . the width of the libration zone increases in with @xmath68 . for @xmath144 , the libration zone splits into two zones of asymmetric librations surrounded by a narrow zone of large - amplitude symmetric librations . panel ( e ) shows a symmetrically librating orbit ( with @xmath145 ) in the rotating frame ; panel ( f ) shows an asymmetrically librating orbit ( with @xmath146 ) . the symbols @xmath147 and @xmath148 indicate the fixed locations of the sun and neptune in the rotating frame . panel ( g ) shows the libration period ( in units of neptune s orbital period ) as a function of the maximum excursion of the resonance angle @xmath87 from @xmath63 . note that the center of the asymmetric librators moves away from `` @xmath149 '' with increasing @xmath68 , as indicated by the beginning of the curves labeled by the different values of @xmath68 . the libration period increases with libration amplitude for the asymmetric librators , but decreases with amplitude for the symmetric ( large amplitude ) librators ; at the separatrix on the boundary between the symmetric and asymmetric librations , the libration period becomes indefinitely large ( although this is not quite obvious due to the finite resolution in this figure ) . 4 the 2:1 neptune resonance located at @xmath150 ( 47.8 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath151 ; ( b ) @xmath152 ; ( c ) @xmath153 ; ( d ) @xmath154 . the phase space is largely regular at this resonance ; a chaotic zone appears at large amplitude librations for eccentricity exceeding @xmath106 . the width of the libration zone increases in with @xmath68 . for @xmath155 , the libration zone splits into two zones of asymmetric librations surrounded by a narrow zone of large - amplitude symmetric librations . panels ( e ) and ( f ) show a small - amplitude asymmetrically librating orbit and a large amplitude symmetrically librating orbit ( both with @xmath156 ) in the rotating frame . ( the motion of the test particle over a complete libration period is traced in these figures . ) note that in both types of orbits the perihelion occurs away from neptune s longitude . panel ( g ) shows the libration period ( in units of neptune s orbital period ) as a function of the maximum excursion of the resonance angle @xmath87 from @xmath63 . the center of the asymmetric librators is indicated by the beginning of the curves labeled by the different values of @xmath68 . the libration period increases with libration amplitude for the asymmetric librators , but decreases with amplitude for the symmetric ( large amplitude ) librators ; at the separatrix on the boundary between the symmetric and asymmetric librations , the libration period becomes indefinitely large . 5 the 5:3 neptune resonance located at @xmath157 ( 42.3 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath158 ; ( b ) @xmath159 ; ( c ) @xmath160 ; ( d ) @xmath161 . the width of the libration zone increases for @xmath68 up to @xmath162 , but then shrinks with increasing @xmath68 as the larger amplitude resonant orbits dissolve into the chaotic zone . note that for @xmath163 , the formerly period-2 exact resonant orbit in the surface - of - section becomes a period-3 orbit ; this is merely a reflection of the fact that at large , neptune - crossing eccentricities the perihelion loop results in two conjunctions with neptune in rapid succession [ cf . panel ( e ) and ( f ) ] . panels ( e ) and ( f ) show the periodic orbit at exact resonance , and an orbit librating with finite amplitude , respectively ( both with @xmath156 ) in the rotating frame . ( the motion of the test particle over a complete libration period is traced in these figures . ) note that in both types of orbits the perihelion occurs away from neptune s longitude . panel ( g ) shows the libration period ( in units of neptune s orbital period ) as a function of the libration amplitude of the resonance angle @xmath87 . the libration period increases with libration amplitude only for small @xmath68 ; it decreases with amplitude for larger @xmath68 . 6 the 3:2 neptune resonance located at @xmath164 ( 39.4 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath165 ; ( b ) @xmath166 ; ( c ) @xmath167 ; ( d ) @xmath168 . the width of the main libration zone decreases with increasing @xmath68 , as the chaotic zone surrounding the libration region expands . panel ( e ) shows an example of a stably librating orbit ( with @xmath156 ) in the rotating frame ; note that this is an `` aphelion librator '' : the test particle is near aphelion when passing neptune s longitude , and its perihelion librates about @xmath169 away from neptune . for @xmath163 , a new libration zone appears in which the librating orbits have a perihelion near neptune . this is indicated by the appearance of a chain of two libration islands ( distinct from the main resonance zone ) in panels ( c)(d ) ; these are the `` perihelion librators '' [ cf . panel(f ) ] ; the new libration zone increases with increasing @xmath68 . an example of a perihelion librator is shown in panel ( f ) ; note that one of the two perihelion loops in each synodic period encompasses neptune . panel ( g ) shows the libration period ( in units of neptune s orbital period ) of the aphelion librators as a function of the libration amplitude of the resonance angle @xmath87 . the libration period generally decreases with libration amplitude , except for very small eccentricity ( @xmath170 ) , large - amplitude librators . 7 the 7:5 neptune resonance located at @xmath171 ( 37.7 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath172 ; ( b ) @xmath173 ; ( c ) @xmath174 ; ( d ) @xmath175 . the width of the main libration zone ( for aphelion librators ) decreases rapidly with increasing @xmath68 , as the chaotic zone surrounding the libration region expands . in fact , for @xmath176 [ cf . panel ( d ) ] the aphelion libration zone has completely disappeared . a libration zone for perihelion librators appears at @xmath156 and expands slightly with increasing @xmath68 . panels ( e ) and ( f ) show examples of an aphelion librator with @xmath146 , and a perihelion librator with @xmath156 , respectively . panel ( g ) shows the libration period ( in units of neptune s orbital period ) of aphelion librators as a function of the libration amplitude of the resonance angle @xmath87 . the libration period generally decreases with libration amplitude , except for very small eccentricity ( @xmath170 ) , large - ampitude librators . 8 the neighborhood of the neptune 4:3 orbital resonance located at @xmath177 ( 36.5 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath178 ; ( b ) @xmath179 ; ( c ) @xmath180 ; ( d ) @xmath181 . the libration zone shrinks rapidly with @xmath68 as the larger amplitude librators dissolve into the chaotic zone . for @xmath182 , the formerly period-1 orbit corresponding to exact 4:3 resonance bifurcates into a period-2 orbit in the surface - of - section ; this is merely a reflection of the fact that for a neptune - crossing value of the eccentricity , the perihelion loop causes two conjunctions with neptune in each synodic period . panel ( e ) and ( f ) show examples of small amplitude librating orbit with @xmath145 and @xmath146 , respectively . panel ( g ) shows the period of libration as a function of the libration amplitude of the resonance angle , @xmath87 ( for @xmath86 and @xmath105 ) . the period as well as the maximum amplitude for stable librations decreases with increasing @xmath68 . 9 the neighborhood of the neptune 5:4 orbital resonance located at @xmath183 . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath184 ; ( b ) @xmath185 ; ( c ) @xmath186 ; ( d ) @xmath187 . notice that the main libration zone ( for aphelion librators ) shrinks rapidly with @xmath68 . a libration zone for perihelion librators appears for @xmath188 , as indicated by the appearance of a chain of two libration islands in ( c)(d ) ; this zone increases with increasing @xmath68 . panel ( e ) shows the stable periodic orbit with @xmath156 at the 5:4 resonance ( an aphelion librator ) in the rotating frame coordinates ; panel ( f ) shows an example of a perihelion librator with @xmath156 . notice the four - fold symmetry in the rotating frame . panel ( g ) shows the period of libration for the aphelion librators as a function of the libration amplitude of the resonance angle ( for @xmath86 and @xmath105 ) fig . 10 the neighborhood of the neptune 6:5 orbital resonance located at @xmath189 ( 34.0 au ) . the phase space for orbits with ( a ) @xmath190 ; ( b ) @xmath191 ; ( c ) @xmath192 ; ( d ) @xmath193 . notice that the main libration zone ( for aphelion librators ) shrinks rapidly with @xmath68 ; for @xmath194 the center of this libration zone bifurcates into a period-2 orbit ; this is simply a reflection of the fact that the perihelion loop causes two conjunctions with neptune in rapid succession during each synodic period . also for @xmath194 , a new libration zone appears for perihelion librators [ indicated by the appearance of a chain of two libration islands with centers at @xmath195 in ( b)(d ) ] whose extent increases with increasing @xmath68 . the increased complexity of this libration zone in ( d ) is a reflection of the fact that the perihelion loops for large amplitude librations are so large that there are four conjunctions with neptune during each synodic period . panels ( e ) and ( f ) show examples an aphelion librator and of a perihelion librator with @xmath156 are the 6:5 resonance . notice the five - fold symmetry in the rotating frame . panel ( g ) shows the period of libration as a function of the libration amplitude of the resonance angle , @xmath87 ( for @xmath86 and @xmath105 ) for the aphelion librators . 11 the locations and widths of first and second order neptune resonances in the kuiper belt , as determined by the planar , circular restricted three - body model . the shaded region on the extreme left indicates the chaotic zone of `` resonance overlap '' in the vicinity of neptune s orbit . in the region above dotted line , orbits are neptune - crossing ; these orbits are dynamically short - lived ( due to close encounters with neptune ) , unless protected by orbital resonances .
Abstract: | [
"the solar system beyond neptune is believed to house a population of small primordial bodies left over from the planet formation process . the region up to heliocentric distance @xmath0 ( the kuiper belt ) may be the source of the observed short period comets . in this region , the phase space structure near orbital resonances with neptune is of special interest for the long term stability of orbits . there is reason to believe that a significant fraction ( perhaps most ) of the kuiper belt objects reside preferentially in these resonance locations . this paper describes the dynamics of small objects near the major orbital resonances with neptune . estimates of the widths of stable resonance zones as well as the properties of resonant orbits are obtained from the circular , planar restricted three - body model . although this model does not contain the full complexity of the long term orbital dynamics of kuiper belt objects subject to the full n - body perturbations of all the planets , it does provide a baseline for the phase space structure and properties of resonant orbits in the trans - neptunian solar system . # 1o(#1 ) # 1 # 1to 0pt#1 to appear in the astronomical journal submitted : june 1995 ; revised : august 1995"
] | 9,922 | 9,922 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: single particle tracking microscopy provides the position time series @xmath0 of individual particle trajectories in a medium @xcite . the information garnered by single particle tracking yields insights into the mechanisms and forces , that drive or constrain the motion of the particle . an early example of systematic single particle tracking is given by the work of jean perrin on diffusive motion @xcite . due to the relatively short individual trajectories , perrin used an ensemble average over many trajectories to obtain meaningful statistics . a few years later , nordlund conceived a method to record much longer time series @xcite , allowing him to evaluate individual trajectories in terms of the time average and thus to avoid averages over not perfectly identical particles . today , single particle tracking has become a standard tool to characterise the microscopic rheological properties of a medium @xcite , or to probe the active motion of biomolecular motors @xcite . particularly in biological cells and complex fluids single particle trajectory methods have become instrumental in uncovering deviations from normal brownian motion of passively moving particles . ) as function of the lag time @xmath1 . left : normal diffusion growing like @xmath2 ( 1 ) , restricted ( confined ) diffusion with a turnover from @xmath3 to @xmath4 ( 2 ) , drift diffusion @xmath5 ( 3 ) . right : ergodic subdiffusion @xmath6 ( 1 ) , restricted ergodic subdiffusion turning over from @xmath6 to @xmath4 ( 2 ) , non - ergodic subdiffusion @xmath3 ( 1 ) , restricted non - ergodic subdiffusion turning over from @xmath3 to @xmath7 ( 2 ) , superdiffusion @xmath8 ( 3 ) . here , @xmath9 . note the double - logarithmic scale.,width=332 ] classical diffusion patterns are sketched in the left panel of fig . [ diffusion_modes ] . accordingly , one may observe free diffusion , leading to a linear growth with time of the second moment [ line 1 in fig . [ diffusion_modes ] ] . brownian motion may also be restricted ( corralled , confined ) . confinement in a cell , for instance , could be due to the cell walls . in that case the second moment initially grows linearly with time and eventually saturates to its thermal value equalling the second moment of the corresponding boltzmann distribution [ line 2 ] . in the presence of a drift the second moment grows with the square of time [ line 3 ] . such results are typical for simple fluids . in more complex environments , different patterns may be observed , as displayed on the right of fig . [ diffusion_modes ] . here , subdiffusion may occur , for which the second moment grows slower than linearly with time [ line 1 ] . restricted subdiffusion would depart from this behaviour to reach a plateau [ line 2 ] . driven motion may lead to a superdiffusive power - law form of the second moment with an exponent between 1 and 2 [ line 3 ] . however , as we demonstrate below , subdiffusion may also be non - ergodic , and the associated time averaged second moment may grow _ linearly _ with time [ line 1 ] . similarly strange behaviour may be observed for restricted non - ergodic subdiffusion , which exhibits a _ power - law _ growth , not a saturation to a plateau [ line 2 ] . non - ergodic processes come along with a significant scatter between individual trajectories . this is an effect of the ageing nature of the process that persists for long measurement times . in the following we discuss in detail the behaviour of passive subdiffusive motion in terms of time and ensemble averages and address the peculiarities , that may arise for non - ergodic systems . non - ergodic behaviour of the above sense is indeed observed experimentally . [ christine ] shows the time averaged mean squared displacement for lipid granules in a living fission yeast cell . the motion is recorded by indirect tracking in an optical tweezers setup . initially the granule is located in the bottom of the laser trap potential such that the granule moves freely . eventually the granule ventures away from the centre of the trap and experiences the hookean trap force . as demonstrated in a detailed analysis the granule motion indeed exhibits weak ergodicity breaking , giving rise to the characteristic turnover from an initially linear scaling @xmath2 with the lag time @xmath1 , to the power - law regime @xmath10 @xcite . moreover a pronounced trajectory - to - trajectory scatter is observed , again typical for systems with weak ergodicity breaking . the initially linear scaling @xmath11 turns over to the power - law regime @xmath12 , induced by the restoring force exerted on the granules by the laser trap @xcite . note also the characteristic scatter between individual trajectories . inset : average behaviour of the shown trajectories . in both graphs the unit of @xmath13 is volt@xmath14 , i.e. , the direct output voltage of the quadrant photodiode . the voltage is directly proportional to the distance from the centre of the laser trap.,width=332 ] free diffusion is typically quantified in terms of the second moment . the mean squared displacement @xmath15 is obtained as the spatial average over the probability density function @xmath16 to find the particle at position @xmath17 at time @xmath18 . the quantity ( [ eamsd ] ) therefore corresponds to the ensemble averaged second moment of the particle position , denoted by angular brackets , @xmath19 . in particular , the time @xmath18 enters into eq . ( [ eamsd ] ) only as a parameter . conversely , single particle trajectories @xmath0 are usually evaluated in terms of the time averaged mean squared displacement defined as @xmath20 where we use an overline @xmath21 to symbolise the time average . here @xmath1 is the so - called lag time constituting a time window swept along the time series , and @xmath22 is the overall measurement time . the time averaged mean squared displacement thus compares the particle positions along the trajectory as separated by the time difference @xmath1 . in an ergodic system the time average of a certain quantity obtained from sufficiently long time series is equal to the corresponding ensemble mean @xcite . for instance , for the mean squared displacement ergodicity would imply @xmath23 brownian motion is ergodic , as well as certain stationary processes leading to anomalous diffusion , such as fractional brownian motion considered below . there exist , however , non - ergodic processes , which are intimately connected to ageing properties . in what follows we discuss two prominent models for anomalous diffusion , the stationary fractional brownian motion and the ageing continuous time random walk , and analyse in detail the features of the associated time averaged mean squared displacement . generally , anomalous diffusion denotes deviations from the classical linear dependence of the mean squared displacement , @xmath24 . such anomalies include ultraslow diffusion of the form @xmath25 @xcite . in contrast , anomalous diffusion processes may become faster than ballistic , for instance for systems with correlated jump lengths or in systems governed by generalised langevin equations @xcite . here we are interested in anomalous diffusion with power - law dependence on time @xcite , @xmath26 for which the anomalous diffusion exponent belongs to the subdiffusive range @xmath9 , such that the limit @xmath27 corresponds to brownian motion . the proportionality factor @xmath28 in eq . ( [ aneamsd ] ) is the anomalous diffusion coefficient of physical dimension @xmath29 . the embedding spatial dimension is @xmath30 , and eq . ( [ aneamsd ] ) includes the complete gamma function @xmath31 . subdiffusion of the form ( [ aneamsd ] ) with @xmath9 occurs in the following biologically relevant systems . fluorescently labelled mrna in _ e.coli _ bacteria cells was observed to follow @xmath32 with @xmath33 @xcite . this result is consistent with more recent findings according to which free rna tracers in living cells exhibit @xmath34 , while dna loci show @xmath35 @xcite . telomeres in the nucleus of mammalian cells were reported to follow anomalous diffusion with @xmath36 at shorter times and value @xmath37 at intermediate times , before a turnover to normal diffusion occurs @xcite . also larger tracer particles show anomalous diffusion , such as adeno - associated viruses of radius @xmath38 nm in a cell with @xmath39 @xcite and endogenous lipid granules , of typical size of few hundred nm with @xmath40 @xcite . it should be noted that this subdiffusion observed by single particle tracking microscopy is consistent with results from other techniques , such as fluorescence correlation spectroscopy @xcite or dynamic light scattering @xcite . subdiffusion of biopolymers larger than some 10 kd in living cells is due to molecular crowding , the excluded volume effect in the superdense cellular environment @xcite . larger tracer particles also experience subdiffusion due to interaction with the semiflexible cytoskeleton @xcite . knowledge of the time or ensemble averaged mean squared displacement of an anomalous diffusion process is insufficient to fully characterise the underlying stochastic mechanism , as the associated probability density @xmath16 is no longer necessarily gaussian , and therefore no longer specified by the first and second moments , only @xcite . this property is in contrast to the universal gaussian nature of brownian motion which is effected by the central limit theorem . at the same time the very nature of the anomalous diffusion process may result in decisively different behaviours for diffusional mixing and diffusion - limited reactions @xcite . in biological cells this would imply significant differences for signalling and regulatory processes . for a better understanding of the dynamics in biological cells and other complex fluids knowledge of the underlying stochastic mechanism is therefore imperative . here we discuss the properties of continuous time random walk ( ctrw ) processes with diverging characteristic waiting time with respect to their time averaged behaviour , expanding on our earlier work @xcite . we show that for free motion the lag time dependence of the time averaged mean squared displacement , @xmath41 , is insensitive to the anomalous diffusion exponent @xmath42 for ctrw processes . in contrast , for confined ctrw subdiffusion a universal scaling behaviour emerges , @xmath43 , with dynamic exponent @xmath44 [ curves ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) in fig . [ diffusion_modes ] ] . subdiffusion governed by fractional brownian motion ( fbm ) leads to the scaling @xmath45 of the time averaged mean squared displacement , turning over to a saturation plateau under confinement , @xmath46 [ curves ( 1 ) and ( 2 ) in fig . [ diffusion_modes ] ] . we particularly emphasise the irreproducible nature of the time averaged quantities and their associated scatter around the ensemble mean for ctrw subdiffusion processes . this randomness of the time averages is captured by the distribution function of the amplitude of the time average . we show that even for relatively short trajectories this distribution is a good characteristic for the underlying process . in contrast for fbm processes the scatter typical of many single particle experiments is not found in the long time limit . in the remainder of this work , for simplicity we restrict the discussion to the one - dimensional case ( @xmath47 ) . generalisation to higher dimensions is straightforward . the article is structured as follows . we start with a brief introduction to ctrw and fbm . we then consider the cases of unbounded motion and confined anomalous diffusion in the subsequent two sections . the distribution of the time averages will be presented thereafter . finally , we discuss the velocity autocorrelation functions for subdiffusive ctrw and fbm processes , before presenting a concluding discussion . although both ctrw and fbm give rise to an ensemble averaged mean squared displacement of the form ( [ eamsd ] ) , they are fundamentally different processes , as outlined here . we note in passing that also in the random motion on a fractal support subdiffusion arises @xcite . we will not pursue this type of anomalous diffusion in the following . ctrw theory dates back to the work of montroll and weiss @xcite , and was championed in the analysis of charge carrier motion in amorphous semiconductors by scher and montroll @xcite . ctrw has become a standard statistical tool to describe processes ranging from particle motion in actin networks @xcite to the tracer motion in groundwater @xcite . each jump of a ctrw process is characterised by a random jump length and a random waiting time elapsing before the subsequent jump . at each jump the jump length and waiting time are chosen independently . for a subdiffusive process we assume that the variance of the jump lengths is given by a finite value @xmath48 , and we consider the unbiased case @xmath49 . on a lattice of spacing @xmath50 , we would have @xmath51 . in contrast , the waiting times @xmath52 are drawn from the probability density @xmath53 for large @xmath52 , with @xmath9 . this form of @xmath54 is scale - free , that is , the average waiting time @xmath55 diverges , causing effects such as ageing @xcite and weak ergodicity breaking @xcite . in eq . ( [ wtd ] ) , the quantity @xmath56 is a scaling factor . the anomalous diffusion constant in this case becomes @xcite @xmath57 the scale - freeness of @xmath58 allows individual waiting times @xmath52 to become quite large . no matter how long a given time series is chosen , single @xmath52 values may become of the order of the length of the entire time span covered in the trajectory . an example is shown in fig . [ timeseries ] : the stalling events with large waiting times @xmath52 are quite distinct . for values of the anomalous diffusion exponent @xmath42 that are closer to 1 the stalling is less pronounced . physically , the power - law form of the waiting time distribution @xmath58 may be related to comb models @xcite or random energy landscapes @xcite ; for more details , compare refs . . for brownian motion ( top ) , ctrw ( middle ) , and fbm ( bottom ) the anomalous diffusion exponent for fbm and ctrw is @xmath59 . for ctrw the stalling events are outstanding , while in the case of fbm strong antipersistence occurs . note that the stalling events and the antipersistence are less pronounced for larger values of @xmath42 . typical experimental data include additional noise , such that the appearance of measured data will not display the ideal behaviour shown here.,width=332 ] fbm is a gaussian process with stationary increments . its position is defined in terms of the langevin equation @xmath60 or , alternatively , @xmath61 the motion is driven by stationary , fractional gaussian noise @xmath62 with zero mean @xmath63 and long - ranged noise correlation @xcite @xmath64 contrasting the uncorrelated noise for normal diffusion @xmath27 : @xmath65 . in eq . ( [ fbnoise ] ) the anomalous diffusion exponent is connected to the traditionally used hurst exponent by @xmath66 , and we introduce the abbreviation @xmath67 for consistency with standard fbm notation . for subdiffusion the fractional gaussian noise is anticorrelated , decaying like @xmath68 . this implies that a given step is likely to go into the direction opposite to the previous step . the corresponding oscillating behaviour is seen in fig . [ timeseries ] . the position autocorrelation function of fbm becomes @xmath69 so that at equal times @xmath70 we recover the mean squared displacement ( [ aneamsd ] ) . if the fractional gaussian noise is not considered external , but the validity of the fluctuation - dissipation theorem is imposed , one obtains the generalised langevin equation ( gle ) @xcite , @xmath71 where we write @xmath72 instead of the exponent @xmath42 in eq . ( [ fbnoise ] ) . in the gle ( [ gle ] ) , we defined the coupling coefficient @xmath73}$ ] according to the fluctuation - dissipation theorem , where @xmath74 is the boltzmann constant and @xmath75 the absolute temperature . in what follows we only consider the overdamped limit , in which the inertia term @xmath76 can be neglected . the gle then gives rise to the form @xmath77 of the mean squared displacement . in contrast to fbm , that is , the gle leads to subdiffusion for persistent noise with @xmath78 , while @xmath79 yields superdiffusion . fbm and the related gle are used to describe processes such as long term storage capacity of water reservoirs @xcite , climate fluctuations @xcite , economical market dynamics @xcite , single file diffusion @xcite , and elastic models @xcite . motion of this type has also been associated with the relative motion of aminoacids in proteins @xcite , and the free diffusion of biopolymers under molecular crowding conditions @xcite . let us begin with considering anomalous diffusion on an infinite domain and without drift . to find an analytical expression for the time averaged mean squared displacement ( [ tamsd ] ) we note that even a brownian process recorded over a finite time span @xmath22 will show fluctuations in the number of jumps performed during @xmath22 . to average out these trajectory - to - trajectory fluctuations we introduce the ensemble mean , @xmath80 we can then express the integrand in terms of the variance of the jump lengths , @xmath48 , and the average number of jumps @xmath81 in the time interval @xmath82 , as follows : @xmath83 for a regular random walk on average every jump occurs after the waiting time @xmath55 . thus @xmath84 , and @xmath85 where we defined the diffusion constant @xmath86 $ ] . in the brownian limit the time averaged mean squared displacement ( [ btamsd ] ) in terms of the lag time @xmath1 takes on exactly the same form as the ensemble averaged mean squared displacement ( [ eamsd ] ) as function of time @xmath18 . this is not surprising , as brownian motion is an ergodic process . for sufficient duration @xmath22 of the time records any time average converges to the corresponding ensemble average , and thus the ensemble average in expression ( [ eatamsd ] ) is no longer necessary . the number of jumps of a ctrw process with waiting time distribution of the form ( [ wtd ] ) on average grows sublinearly with time , @xmath87 $ ] @xcite . this time evolution translates into the mean squared displacement ( [ eamsd ] ) with the anomalous diffusion coefficient ( [ an_coff ] ) . combining the time dependence of @xmath88 for ctrw subdiffusion with the definition ( [ eatamsd ] ) we obtain the following result for the time averaged mean squared displacement , @xmath89 in the limit @xmath90 @xcite . this follows from expansion of the relation @xmath91 . the noteworthy feature of this result is that the linear lag time dependence of normal diffusion remains completely unaffected by the anomalous nature of the stochastic process . only the dependence on the overall measurement time @xmath22 witnesses the underlying subdiffusion . ( [ ctrwtamsd ] ) can be understood if we notice that for normal diffusion we have @xmath92 [ since according to einstein @xmath93 where @xmath94 is the mean time between jump events . now , for the subdiffusive case @xmath55 diverges and must be replaced by @xmath95 , which explains the term @xmath96 . [ ctrw_tamsd ] shows 20 trajectories of a ctrw process with @xmath97 , displaying the general trend @xmath98 . , shown for 20 individual trajectories . the overall measurement time is @xmath99 ( a.u . ) . note the local changes of the slope in the trajectories as well as the complete stalling in the lowest curve , all bearing witness to the scale - free nature of the underlying waiting time distribution @xmath100.,width=332 ] rewriting the result ( [ ctrwtamsd ] ) in the form @xmath101 we see that the effective diffusion coefficient @xmath102 decays as function of the measurement time @xmath22 . the longer the system evolves after its initial preparation , the less mobile it appears , consistent with the ageing property of ctrw subdiffusion . for instance , in the picture of the trapping events , in the course of time deeper and deeper traps may be encountered by the diffusing particle , such that it gets more and more stuck . this increasing immobility is mirrored in the form @xmath102 . note that eqs . ( [ ctrwtamsd ] ) and ( [ rew ] ) suggest that from measuring the @xmath1 dependence of an anomalous diffusion process one might draw the erroneous conclusion that normal diffusion were observed . the disparity between the time averaged mean squared displacement ( [ ctrwtamsd ] ) and its ensemble averaged counterpart ( [ aneamsd ] ) demonstrates the weak ergodicity breaking characteristic of a process with diverging time scale @xcite . single or few , long waiting times are also responsible for the pronounced deviations between individual realisations shown in fig . [ ctrw_tamsd ] . this apparent irreproducibility of the time averaged mean squared displacement is again intimately coupled to the weak ergodicity breaking nature of the ctrw subdiffusion process . we will discuss this feature more quantitatively in terms of the distribution @xmath103 as function of the relative deviation @xmath104 of the time averaged mean squared displacement around its ensemble mean in section [ scatter ] . in contrast to the above behaviour of ctrw subdiffusion processes , fbm is ergodic . indeed , by help of the position autocorrelation ( [ fbm_auto ] ) the time averaged mean squared displacement ( [ eatamsd ] ) becomes @xcite @xmath105 exactly matching the ensemble averaged mean squared displacement , @xmath106 . however , ergodicity is reached algebraically slowly @xcite , see also below . in fig . [ fbm_tamsd ] the comparatively minute scatter between individual trajectories supports the ergodic behaviour of fbm processes . the somewhat larger deviations at longer lag times are due to worsening statistics when @xmath107 . . the scatter between individual trajectories is minute , mirroring the ergodicity of this process.,width=332 ] since the motion of tracer particles is typically confined , for example , by the cell walls or internal membranes , we now consider the important case of anomalous diffusion in a bounded domain . in a finite interval @xmath108 $ ] the mean squared displacement of a brownian particle initially released well away from the boundaries will grow linearly in time and eventually turn over to a stationary plateau of magnitude @xmath109 . similarly , if the particle evolves in the confinement of an external harmonic potential of the form @xmath110 , the thermal value @xmath111 $ ] will eventually be attained . how is this behaviour modified for a ctrw subdiffusion process ? under the influence of an arbitrary external potential @xmath112 defining the force @xmath113 , ctrw subdiffusion can be described by the fractional fokker - planck equation @xcite , or , equivalently , in terms of the following coupled langevin equations @xcite : @xmath114 here the position @xmath115 is expressed in terms of the parameter @xmath116 ( the internal time ) , and driven by the white gaussian noise @xmath117 . thus , eq . ( [ le1 ] ) defines standard brownian motion @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is the diffusivity for the normal diffusion process in internal time @xmath116 . laboratory time @xmath18 is introduced by the so - called subordination through the process @xmath120 , given by the probability density function @xcite @xmath121^{1/\alpha } \frac{t}{s^{1 + 1/\alpha}}\right),\ ] ] where @xmath122 is a one - sided lvy stable probability density with laplace transform @xmath123 . thus , eq . ( [ le2 ] ) transforms the brownian process @xmath118 with diffusivity @xmath119 into the subdiffusive motion with generalised diffusivity @xmath28 . on the basis of this scheme , the ensemble averaged position - position correlation in an arbitrary confining potential @xmath124 becomes @xmath125 valid in the limit @xmath126)^{1/\alpha}$ ] , where @xmath127 is the smallest non - zero eigenvalue of the corresponding fokker - planck operator @xcite . ( [ ctrw_conf_ea_auto ] ) demonstrates that , despite the confinement , the process is non - stationary . in result ( [ ctrw_conf_ea_auto ] ) we used the incomplete beta function @xmath128 and defined the first and second boltzmann moments , whose general definition is @xmath129 the partition function reads @xmath130 at large time separation , @xmath131 , the position autocorrelation decays algebraically , @xmath132 towards the value @xmath133 . the corresponding limiting behaviour of the incomplete beta function reads @xmath134 inserting expression ( [ ctrw_conf_ea_auto ] ) into the definition of the time averaged mean squared displacement ( [ eatamsd ] ) we obtain @xcite @xmath135dt.\end{aligned}\ ] ] then , with relation ( [ bet_lim ] ) we arrive at the scaling behaviour @xmath136 valid in the limits @xmath137 and @xmath138 ) ^{1/\alpha}$ ] . result ( [ conf_tamsd ] ) is quite remarkable : instead of the naively assumed saturation toward the stationary plateau a power - law growth @xmath139 is observed . only when the lag time @xmath1 approaches the overall measurement time @xmath22 the singularity in expression ( [ eatamsd ] ) causes a dip toward the plateau of the ensemble averaged mean squared displacement . additionally eqs . ( [ ctrw_conf_ea_auto ] ) and ( [ conf_tamsd ] ) are universal in the sense that the exact form of the confining potential solely enters into the prefactor through the first two moments of the boltzmann distribution corresponding to the confining potential @xmath124 . we note that the asymptotic scaling @xmath140 is consistent with the numerical analysis presented in ref . @xcite . [ confined_ctrw ] depicts the ensemble mean of the time averaged mean squared displacement ( [ eatamsd ] ) for two types of confinement , an harmonic potential and a box potential . the particle is initially placed at the bottom of the potential well and in the middle of the box potential , respectively . this is why at short lag times the particle exhibits the linear scaling @xmath141 typical for unconfined motion , before turning over to the confinement - induced scaling @xmath7 . note that this plot is fit - free , i.e. , the theoretically calculated asymptotic behaviours nicely fall on top of the simulations results . for an harmonic binding potential @xmath142 ( @xmath143 ) and a particle in a box of length @xmath144 ( @xmath145 ) , with @xmath146 , measurement time @xmath147 ( a.u . ) , @xmath148 , and @xmath149 . without fitting , the lines show the analytic results for the transition from @xmath150 for short lag times according to eq . ( [ ctrwtamsd ] ) ( @xmath151 and @xmath152 ) to @xmath7 for long lag times , eq . ( [ conf_tamsd ] ) ( ) . for long @xmath1 , @xmath153 exhibits universal behaviour , in the sense that the curve does not depend on the external field.,width=332 ] as shown in fig . [ conf_scatter ] individual trajectories still exhibit the pronounced scatter typical for ctrw subdiffusion . visually the scatter does not change between the unbiased initial motion and the confinement - dominated part of the process . this is due to the fact that the scatter is caused by the scale - freeness of the waiting times . in our process waiting times and jump lengths are decoupled , corresponding to the subordination property of ctrw subdiffusion @xcite . . the extent of the deviations between the trajectories does not change qualitatively between the initial unbiased motion and the later confinement - dominated regime . the squares ( @xmath143 ) represent simulations results for the ensemble average @xmath154 . same parameters as in fig . [ confined_ctrw].,width=332 ] what happens if we introduce a cutoff in the power - law of the waiting time distribution of the form @xmath155,\ ] ] in which a characteristic time scale @xmath156 is introduced , terminating the power - law scaling ? for the waiting time density ( [ wtd_cutoff ] ) the characteristic waiting time @xmath157 becomes finite . at sufficiently short times one would expect this process to still exhibit the features of ctrw subdiffusion , while at times @xmath158 the process should converge to regular brownian motion with a gaussian propagator . in fig . [ ctrw_cutoff_conf ] we demonstrate that for a suitable choice of the cutoff time @xmath156 the behaviour of the time averaged mean squared displacement @xmath13 under confinement preserves the characteristic non - ergodic features of ctrw subdiffusion , i.e. , the turnover from the initial scaling @xmath3 to the confinement - dominated scaling @xmath159 . below we will show that at the same time the distribution of the time average around its ensemble mean is significantly altered . ) , in the box @xmath160 $ ] with reflecting boundary conditions . the generic behaviour of initial and final scaling , @xmath161 and @xmath7 remains unaltered . we chose @xmath162 , @xmath163 , @xmath164 and overall measurement time @xmath165 ( a.u.).,width=332 ] ergodicity remains unaffected for fbm , that is confined to an interval of size @xmath108 $ ] . namely , convergence of @xmath13 is observed toward the stationary value @xmath109 @xcite . for fbm under the influence of an harmonic potential @xmath110 the position - position correlation can be calculated exactly @xcite . inserting into the ensemble mean ( [ eatamsd ] ) of the time averaged mean squared displacement one can show that the initial behaviour @xmath166 turns over to the stationary value @xmath167 $ ] . in general , the time averaged mean squared displacement for confined fbm converges to a constant : @xmath168 the deviations of the time averaged mean squared displacement @xmath169 between individual trajectories can be quantified in terms of the probability density function @xmath170 of the dimensionless ratio @xmath171 of the time averaged mean squared displacement over its ensemble mean . for an ergodic process this distribution is necessarily sharp , @xmath172 for long measurement time @xmath22 . deviations from this form are expected for non - ergodic processes such as ctrw subdiffusion , but also for relatively short trajectories . we here address both effects and demonstrate that the distribution @xmath170 is a quite reliable means to distinguish different stochastic processes even when the recorded time series are fairly short . for ctrw subdiffusion with power - law waiting time distribution ( [ wtd ] ) the distribution assumes the form @xcite @xmath173 for @xmath174 , where @xmath122 is again a one - sided lvy stable distribution , whose laplace transform is @xmath175 . special cases include the brownian limit ( [ phi1 ] ) for @xmath176 and the gaussian shape @xmath177 for @xmath146 . in fact , we observe an exponentially fast decay of @xmath170 with large @xmath178 for all @xmath9 , compare appendix [ app1 ] . for short trajectories the basic shape of the distribution @xmath170 is surprisingly well preserved @xcite . this is demonstrated in fig . [ ctrw_scatter ] , in which the characteristic asymmetric shape with respect to the ergodic value @xmath179 for the case @xmath97 is reproduced for a process with @xmath180 , even for a lag time as long as @xmath181 . no significant dependence on the confinement is observed . also for larger values of @xmath42 the finite value for small @xmath178 is similarly reproduced for short trajectories @xcite , pointing at the quite remarkably reliability on the shape of the scatter distribution @xmath170 for ctrw subdiffusion . as we show below , the distribution for fbm processes with its zero value at @xmath182 can be clearly distinguished from the ctrw form . of the time averaged mean squared displacement , with @xmath183 for a ctrw process with @xmath97 , @xmath163 , and @xmath180 ( a.u . ) . the filled and open symbols , respectively , represent the unconfined case and confined motion on the interval @xmath184 $ ] . we see quite good agreement with the expected gaussian limiting distribution of the scatter , eq . ( [ phi_gauss ] ) , centred around @xmath182 . in the inset we show the case for the largest measured lag time , @xmath185 , also in good agreement with the predicted shape of the distribution.,width=332 ] a useful parameter to quantify the violation of ergodicity is the ergodicity breaking parameter @xcite @xmath186 eb varies from @xmath187 for @xmath188 monotonically to @xmath189 in the brownian limit @xmath27 . for the special case @xmath146 one finds @xmath190 , while for @xmath191 , @xmath192 . the scatter distribution is sensitive to few extreme events . when these are lacking , the distribution should be significantly different from the form discussed for ctrw subdiffusion with diverging characteristic time scale . indeed , as shown in fig . [ cutoff_scatter ] for the cutoff waiting time distribution defined through eq . ( [ wtd_cutoff ] ) , @xmath170 drops down to zero around @xmath182 and assumes an almost gaussian shape around the ergodic value @xmath179 . note that the simulations were performed with the same parameters as for fig . [ ctrw_cutoff_conf ] , in which the breaking of ergodicity still persists , despite the cutoff . this demonstrates that different quantities have different sensitivity to the cutoff . for ctrw subdiffusion with cutoff , as defined in eq . ( [ wtd_cutoff ] ) . the observed form is clearly different from the much more asymmetric shape in fig . [ ctrw_scatter ] . the value of @xmath170 reaches zero for small values of @xmath178 . an almost gaussian shape centred around the ergodic value @xmath179 is observed . same parameters as in fig . [ ctrw_cutoff_conf].,width=332 ] fbm is based on long - ranged correlations . however , we can obtain an approximate expression for the scatter distribution @xcite @xmath193 where @xmath194 is an intrinsic time scale . expression ( [ fbmscatter ] ) is valid for sufficiently small lag times @xmath1 , for which the correlations are neglected @xcite . note that this distribution is independent of @xmath42 and centred around the ergodic value @xmath179 . in particular , in the long measurement time limit @xmath174 , the distribution converges to the sharp form @xmath195 . also this behaviour is surprisingly well preserved for short trajectories , as demonstrated in fig . [ fbm_scatter ] . of the time averaged mean squared displacement , with @xmath196 for fbm subdiffusion with @xmath97 and @xmath180 ( a.u . ) . the filled and open symbols , respectively , represent the cases for unconfined and confined motion . for small values of the lag time @xmath1 we see quite good agreement with the expected gaussian limiting distribution of the scatter , eq . ( [ fbmscatter ] ) , that is centred around @xmath179 . for larger values of @xmath1 deviations are observed , however , even for @xmath185 the value around @xmath182 is consistently zero . a similar behaviour is found for larger values of @xmath42 @xcite . note that when @xmath174 the process is ergodic and @xmath197 approaches a @xmath198 function.,width=332 ] for fbm one can define a quantity similar to the ergodicity breaking parameter ( [ eb ] ) . namely , without taking the long measurement time limit , we obtain the normalised variance of the time averaged mean squared displacement @xmath199 it turns out that the convergence to ergodicity is algebraically slow , and for subdiffusion @xmath9 one obtains a decay , which is inversely proportional to @xmath22 @xcite : @xmath200 the coefficient @xmath201 here is defined as @xcite @xmath202 it increases continuously from zero at @xmath203 to @xmath204 . the quantity @xmath205 is connected to the probability density ( [ fbmscatter ] ) by @xmath206 , obtained from approximating that the values of @xmath178 may range in the interval @xmath207 , which appears reasonable given the sharp decay of @xmath197 to 0 at @xmath182 for fbm . apart from the fact that @xmath205 explicitly depends on @xmath42 while the approximation leading to eq . ( [ fbmscatter ] ) loses the @xmath42 dependence , both quantities decay @xmath208 , and the internal time scale @xmath194 takes on a role similar to the lag time @xmath1 . a typical quantity accessible from experimental data is the velocity autocorrelation function , which is defined through @xmath209 here the velocity is defined as the difference quotient @xmath210 $ ] . the velocity autocorrelation ( [ autov00 ] ) was suggested as a tool to distinguish between different subdiffusion models @xcite . we show here that for confined processes the shape of the velocity autocorrelation function does not allow for a significant distinction between subdiffusive ctrw and fbm . note that the calculation of @xmath211 amounts to determine four two - point correlation functions of the type @xmath212 . for unbounded ctrw process starting with initial condition @xmath213 , the position correlation function is given by the following expression @xcite , @xmath214^\alpha . \label{autov03}\ ] ] this result for free ctrw is due to the fact that the jump lengths in the interval @xmath215 for @xmath216 have zero mean . with eq . ( [ autov03 ] ) we find @xmath217 0 & \tau\geq\epsilon \end{array}\right . \label{autov04}\ ] ] the velocity autocorrelation function for an unbounded ctrw process does not yield negative values due to the absence of correlations for different jumps . in this case the velocity autocorrelations can be easily distinguished from the behaviour of fbm processes , see below . note that @xmath211 in eq . ( [ autov04 ] ) is non - analytic at @xmath218 , an observation that is confirmed in simulations . the behaviour of the velocity autocorrelations for ctrw subdiffusion are displayed in fig . [ velcorr1 ] . for a confined ctrw process the situation is quite different . to explore the behaviour of the corresponding velocity autocorrelation function we use the general result for the correlation function of confined ctrw , eq . ( [ ctrw_conf_ea_auto ] ) . for simplicity we assume a symmetric potential such that @xmath219 . with the initial condition @xmath213 we obtain @xmath220 figs . [ velcor2 ] and [ velcor3 ] ( for the absolute value ) display excellent agreement of eq . ( [ autov05 ] ) with simulations of ctrw subdiffusion for a lattice of size 10 with reflecting boundary conditions , and @xmath146 . we observe that for confined motion the ctrw velocity autocorrelation function indeed attains negative values and has a minimum on @xmath218 , as the confinement effectively induces correlations . for long @xmath52 the velocity autocorrelation function decays to zero ( from the negative side ) as the power - law @xmath221 valid for @xmath222 . for free fbm the position correlation function ( [ fbm_auto ] ) together with the definition ( [ autov00 ] ) produce the result @xmath223 this function yields negative values for sufficiently long @xmath52 , and its minimum value @xmath224 is assumed at @xmath218 . for long @xmath52 it decays toward zero from the negative side in the power - law form @xmath225 valid for @xmath222 . for confined fbm with @xmath97 . the simulations were performed on the interval @xmath184 $ ] , and @xmath226 ( a.u . ) . for comparison , the velocity autocorrelation for free fbm is drawn based on eq . ( [ autov01]).,width=332 ] we see that both the velocity autocorrelation function of the confined ctrw and the one for free fbm acquire negative values and decay as power - laws for large @xmath52 , see below . further both obtain a sharp minimum for @xmath218 . confined fbm behaves similarly to free fbm , see fig . [ fbm_box ] . from our analysis it becomes clear that the shape of the velocity autocorrelation function may not be a good diagnosis tool to distinguish between subdiffusive ctrw and fbm processes . we note that for ctrw subdiffusion the time averaged correlation functions will be random variables , exactly like the time averaged mean squared displacement . the physical mechanisms leading to subdiffusion in biological cells or other complex systems are varied . the anomalous diffusion of inert biopolymers larger than some 10kd in living cells is due to molecular crowding , these are excluded volume effects in the viscoelastic , superdense cellular environment @xcite . potentially similar effects occur in single file diffusion : a tracer particle diffusing in a one dimensional channel and interacting with other brownian particles will slow down its random motion , and subdiffusion with @xmath146 is observed @xcite . what is the resulting motion like ? consider a particle , that gets repeatedly trapped during its random walk . such trapping may give rise to a broad distribution of waiting times , as embodied in the ctrw model . such broad distribution of trapping times could be due to chemical binding of the tracer particle to its environment on varied time scales , or due to active gelation / de - gelation of the crowding particles . long - tailed trapping time distributions were observed for @xmath227m - sized particles due to interaction with a semiflexible actin mesh @xcite . there , the anomalous diffusion exponent @xmath42 depends on the size of the tracer particles versus the typical actin mesh size . alternatively , motion patterns of fbm type may be due to coupling to the viscoelastic crowding environment @xcite . yet other approaches are based on polymer dynamics . de gennes reptation model of a polymer diffusing in a tube formed by foreign chains in a melt yields subdiffusion with @xmath228 , and was used as a possible explanation of the short time dynamics of telomere motion @xcite . one may speculate whether the widely observed subdiffusion of biomolecules and passive tracers is a mere coincidence of nature that should be attributed to the dense environment in the cell and/or to the wide distribution of obstacles and reactions in the cell . or , maybe , subdiffusion is by itself a goal which was obtained via evolution ? there exist claims that sub - diffusion is useful in certain cellular search strategies @xcite . one may also view subdiffusion to be a sufficiently slow process to help maintaining the organisation of the genome in the nucleus of the cell without the need for physical compartments @xcite . since reactions in many cases are controlled by diffusion , the emergence of slower - than - normal diffusion has far - reaching implications to signalling and regulatory processes in the cell . the standard theories of diffusion - controlled reactions under such circumstances must be replaced by subdiffusion - controlled reaction models . while these issues are clearly important , we here focused more on the characterisation of trajectories of single particles in the cell , in particular , as a quantitative diagnosis method to probe the nature of the stochastic motion in cells and other complex media . single particle tracking microscopy is a widely used technique . it allows one to locally probe complex systems in the liquid phase _ in situ_. in particular it has become one of the standard tools in biophysical , colloidal , polymeric , and gel - like environments . the motion of tracers in these systems is often anomalous . typically the experimentally recorded time series are evaluated in terms of the time averaged mean squared displacement @xmath13 . here we collected the behaviour of @xmath229 for the two most prominent anomalous stochastic processes , the continuous time random walk and fractional brownian motion . for ctrw subdiffusion , connected with ageing and weak ergodicity breaking , in an unconfined system the time averaged mean squared displacement scales linearly in time , @xmath13 [ eq . ( [ ctrwtamsd ] ) ] , renouncing the anomalous nature of the process . only the dependence on the overall measurement time @xmath22 pays tribute to the underlying subdiffusion . this behaviour contrasts the anomalous scaling @xmath230 of the ensemble averaged mean squared displacement . under confinement no plateau value is observed as in the ensemble average , instead , a power - law of the form @xmath43 , eq . ( [ conf_tamsd ] ) , is found . interestingly , this characteristic behaviour is approximately preserved when an appropriate cutoff in the waiting time is introduced . conversely the distribution of the time averaged mean squared displacement around its ensemble mean becomes almost gaussian in presence of the cutoff , while it has an exponential decay and a finite value at @xmath182 when the system is non - ergodic and exhibits ageing . fbm , in contrast , is ergodic , although ergodicity is reached algebraically slowly . free fbm subdiffusion shows @xmath231 , eq . ( [ fbm_free ] ) , while under confinement the plateau value of the ensemble average is reached , eq . ( [ fbm_cnf ] ) . for finite trajectories the distribution of the time averaged mean squared displacement is approximately gaussian for short lag times . our analysis demonstrates how different the two stochastic processes are , despite sharing the same form of the ensemble averaged mean squared displacement . at the same time the velocity autocorrelation of confined ctrw subdiffusion is hardly distinguishable from that of fbm subdiffusion . given a recorded time series of anomalous diffusion from experiment it is important to know more precisely which stochastic process is responsible for the observed behaviour , in particular , with respect to diffusion - limited reactions , general transport behaviour , and related processes such as gene regulation . the analysis presented here , along with complementary tools discussed in refs . @xcite , will be instrumental in the classification of anomalous diffusion behaviour . we thank c. selhuber - unkel and l. oddershede for providing the data used in fig . [ christine ] , and for many useful discussions . partial financial support from the deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft and the israel science foundation is gratefully acknowledged . using the theory of fox @xmath232-functions we obtain the exact form for the distribution @xmath170 of the dimensionless variable @xmath178 @xcite : @xmath233.\ ] ] this function has the series expansion @xmath234^n}{n!\gamma(-\alpha n)},\ ] ] and the asymptotic form @xmath235^{1/(1-\alpha)}\right)\end{aligned}\ ] ] valid at @xmath236 . s. b. yuste , g. oshanin , k. lindenberg , o. bnichou , and j. klafter , phys . e * 78 * , 021105 ( 2008 ) ; e. abad . s. b. yuste , and k. lindenberg , phys . e * 81 * , 031115 ( 2010 ) ; i. m. sokolov , s. b. yuste , j. j. ruiz - lorenzo , and k. lindenberg , phys . e * 79 * , 051113 ( 2009 ) ; d. froemberg and i. m. sokolov , phys . lett . * 100 * , 108304 ( 2008 ) . bouchaud , j. phys . ( paris ) i , * 2 * , 1705 ( 1992 ) ; g. bel and e. barkai , phys . rev . lett . * 94 * , 240602 ( 2005 ) ; a. rebenshtok and e. barkai , _ ibid . _ * 99 * , 210601 ( 2007 ) ; m. a. lomholt , i. m. zaid , and r. metzler , _ ibid . _ , 98 , 200603 ( 2007 ) ; i. m. zaid , m. a. lomholt , and r. metzler , biophys . j. * 97 * , 710 ( 2009 ) ; f. d. stefani , j. p. hoogenboom , and e. barkai , physics today * 62*(2 ) , 34 ( 2009 ) ; g. margolin and e. barkai , phys . 94 * , 080601 ( 2005 ) ; g. aquino , p. grigolini , and b. j. west , epl * 80 * , 10002 ( 2007 ) . r. metzler , e. barkai , and j. klafter , phys . lett . * 82 * , 3563 ( 1999 ) ; europhys . lett . * 46 * , 431 ( 1999 ) . e. barkai , r. metzler , and j. klafter , phys . e * 61 * , 132 ( 2000 ) ; r. metzler , j. klafter , and i. m. sokolov , _ ibid . _ * 58 * , 1621 ( 1998 ) . a. n. kolmogorov , dokl . 26 * , 115 ( 1940 ) ; b. b. mandelbrot and j. w. van ness , siam rev . * 1 * , 422 ( 1968 ) ; h. qian , fractional brownian motion and fractional gaussian noise . in g. rangarajan and m.z . ding ( eds ) , _ processes with long - range correlations _ ( springer , lecture notes in physics , vol.621 ) , pp.22 - 33 . t. e. harris , j. appl . * 2 * , 323 ( 1965 ) ; l. lizana and t. ambjrnsson , phys . . lett . * 100 * , 200601 ( 2008 ) ; l. lizana , t. ambjrnsson , a. taloni , e. barkai , and m. a. lomholt , phys . e * 81 * , 051118 ( 2010 ) ; e. barkai and r. silbey , phys . * 102 * , 050602 ( 2009 ) . m. magdziarz , a. weron , k. burnecki , and j. klafter , phys . * 103 * , 180602 ( 2009 ) . compare also m. magdziarz and j. klafter , phys . e , at press ; k. burnecki and a. weron , phys . e * 82 * , 021130 ( 2010 ) . h. c. fogedby , phys . e * 50 * , 1657 ( 1994 ) ; a. baule and r. friedrich , phys . e * 71 * , 026101 ( 2005 ) ; m. magdziarz , a. weron , and j. klafter , phys . rev . * 101 * , 210601 ( 2008 ) ; m. magdziarz , a. weron , and k. weron , phys . e * 75 * , 016708 ( 2007 ) ; e. heinsalu , m. patriarca , i. goychuk , g. schmid , and p. hnggi , phys . rev . e * 73 * , 046133 ( 2006 ) . a. m. mathai and r. k. saxena , the h - function with applications in statistics and other disciplines ( wiley eastern ltd . , new delhi , 1978 ) ; a. m. mathai , r. k. saxena , and h. j. haubold , the h - function , theory and applications ( springer , new york , 2010 ) .
Abstract: | [
"anomalous diffusion has been widely observed by single particle tracking microscopy in complex systems such as biological cells . the resulting time series are usually evaluated in terms of time averages . often anomalous diffusion is connected with non - ergodic behaviour . in such cases the time averages remain random variables and hence irreproducible . here we present a detailed analysis of the time averaged mean squared displacement for systems governed by anomalous diffusion , considering both unconfined and restricted ( corralled ) motion . we discuss the behaviour of the time averaged mean squared displacement for two prominent stochastic processes , namely , continuous time random walks and fractional brownian motion . we also study the distribution of the time averaged mean squared displacement around its ensemble mean , and show that this distribution preserves typical process characteristic even for short time series . recently , velocity correlation functions were suggested to distinguish between these processes . we here present analytucal expressions for the velocity correlation functions . knowledge of the results presented here are expected to be relevant for the correct interpretation of single particle trajectory data in complex systems ."
] | 8,659 | 8,659 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: two important database operations are sorting and joins . these operations have three primary hardware - related costs : disk access , cpu operation and main memory access . the growth of main memory in current computers implies that main memory databases become more popular . for main memory databases , the bottleneck moves from disk to main memory and the cost for disk access is not an issue anymore . further , the growing cpu - memory gap implies that cpu costs represent an increasingly small portion of the total time . this has been borne out by several studies of dbms @xcite . the impact of the cpu - memory gap was popularized by the paper of wulf and mckee @xcite on the _ memory wall_. the diminishing role of the cpu in the total running time is partially accounted for by increasing cpu speeds and greater on - chip functional parallelism . in part , it is also accounted for because most cpus today implement non - blocking caches and hardware prefetch in order to overlap cpu execution with memory access @xcite . hence , memory access becomes the bottleneck . therefore , we follow the example of previous researchers @xcite in concentrating on main memory as the bottleneck . at the heart of this memory bottleneck lies the _ record retrieval problem _ : the problem of copying records from a source array into a destination array according to a new ordering . in a typical application , one will be given a source data file , a sequence of _ record ids _ ( rids ) for that data file , and a destination file . the task is to copy the source records into the destination file in the order specified by the sequence of rids . fast record retrieval is the key to faster sorting and faster joins . a standard approach for data retrieval accesses the records of the source data file directly according to the sequence of the rids . this implies random access to the main memory . this , for example , is what was done in alphasort @xcite and superscalarsort @xcite , the current record holders for the datamation sorting challenge @xcite . however , the cost of such random access has now become the dominant cost in main memory sorting , since the cpu - memory gap has widened still further since the original work on sorting . ( in fact , alphasort and superscalarsort sort data on disk , but the size of the data file , 100 mb , is small enough that the disk access consists solely of reading the source data file from disk , and writing to a destination data file . ) random access is harmful not just in disk resident databases , but also in main memory resident databases . current dram technologies , such as ddr ram and rambus ram ( rdram ) , extract a large latency penalty for any non - sequential access to ram . this is because the memory chips are divided into memory pages of several kilobytes , and there is a latency penalty for switching to a new memory page @xcite . random access to ram also harms performance in a second manner . random access incurs a heavy penalty when large cache blocks are used . on a cache miss , the entire cache block is loaded into memory . if the record size is small compared to the cache block size , then there is a large overhead to load the entire cache block . for example , for a cache miss on a pentium 4 with ddr-266 ram , approximately 60 ns are spent loading the cache block , and approximately 60 ns are spent waiting on the latency of ddr ram . the trend is toward larger cache blocks . the 128 byte l2 cache blocks of the pentium 4 are four times larger than those of the pentium iii . the ibm power4 processor goes still further using 512 byte l3 cache blocks . the solution to avoid these latency penalties in main memory is to access main memory sequentially . this is similar in spirit to the way in which traditional databases strongly prefer to access disk sequentially . in analogy with operation on disk , two - pass algorithms are a key for faster main memory performance . the dpg - based sorting algorithms immediately yield faster sorting algorithms . both alphasort and superscalarsort sort their data essentially in three phases : extraction of key - pointer pairs ; sorting of the key - pointer pairs ; and copying of the original records into the destination array according to the sorted key - pointer pairs . the last phase is essentially record retrieval . a re - implementation of alphasort and superscalarsort on a ibm p690 turbo shows that the record retrieval phase now dominates the running time . with the dpg record retrieval algorithm replacing the standard record retrieval algorithm , we immediately produce a faster sorting algorithm . in the re - implementation of superscalarsort , the versions with dpg as an accelerator are 27% faster . a direct consequence of faster record retrieval is faster main memory sort - merge joins . for example , in implementing sort - merge join using superscalarsort , we find that the use of dpg sort instead of superscalarsort results in a 27% faster join algorithm .. the dpg record retrieval phase in isolation is 48% faster than traditional record retrieval algorithm . finally , we apply dpg algorithm in the context of _ foreign key joins_. in a foreign key join the join key is the same as the foreign key . we assume that one relation has an secondary index on the join key . foreign key joins have the advantage that one need only rearrange the records of one of the files . this is in distinction to sort - merge join and hash join , which both require to rearrange each of the two files into a new file with join key values in sorted order . foreign key joins require less record retrieval because it is possible to first extract _ join triples _ , ( @xmath0 , rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) , where @xmath3 and @xmath4 are the two relations and @xmath0 is the join key value . assume that @xmath3 references a foreign key of @xmath4 . to construct a join triple , do file scan of @xmath3 , for each record of @xmath3 , its key @xmath0 is extracted . the secondary b - tree index of the join key on @xmath4 is then used to derive the corresponding record i d , rid@xmath2 , with the key value @xmath0 . the standard index lookup is very expensive , we propose a cache efficient b - tree batch lookup to generate the join triples . join triples reduce foreign key join to record pair retrieval . the join triples specify the record pairs , ( rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) , to be retrieved . one can re - order the records of @xmath4 to match the ordering of rid@xmath1 in the sequence of record pairs . recall that , we do file scan for @xmath3 , so rid@xmath1s in the join triples are in sorted order . alternatively , one can sort the join triples according to rid@xmath2 , and re - order the records of @xmath3 to match the ordering of rid@xmath2 in the sorted rid pairs . in either situation , there are fewer record retrievals , and so foreign key join is faster than a general join . the ideas of faster record retrieval can also be applied to the general case of record pair retrieval . many algorithms for spatial join @xcite and temporal join @xcite produce record pairs . unlike equijoin , there is no single search key , and so record retrieval is more difficult . the ideas of this paper are described in terms of foreign key join . however , it is even simpler to translate the ideas into record pair retrieval , since an initial join triple extraction is not required . the _ distribute - probe - gather algorithm _ ( dpg ) is a record retrieval algorithm . given a data file of records and a sequence of record ids ( rids ) for the file , the goal is to copy the records into a destination file with the property that the ordering of records in the destination file corresponds to the ordering of the rids in the given sequence . for example , let the source file , # r # , be the array of records with a secondary b+ tree index on the attribute # a#. we want to place the records of # r # in sorted order according to the values of # a#. the sequence of record ids , # s_rid # , at leaf nodes of the b+ tree is a list of record ids in sorted order according to the value of a. then , the destination file , # d # , below , will contain the corresponding records in sorted order according to the value of # a#. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ for each i , d[i ] = r[s_rid[i ] ] _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ in the case that the sequence of rids is a permutation of the rids for the data file , the sequence of rids acts as a permutation vector . the destination file is then a permutation of the records in the input file . note , however , that the dpg algorithm is not limited to permutations of data . in the case of join , one record from one relation may match more than one records from another relation . in such cases portion of the original records must be duplicated . the dpg algorithm also works for this case . the input for the algorithm is : a list of rids , # rid_list # , and a data file of records , # input#. the dpg algorithm partitions the rids , # rid_list # , into separate runs . it also partitions the data records , # input # , into separate runs . the algorithm makes two passes over the record ids , # rid_list # , and two passes over the records of the data file , # input#. the ideas are presented in the context of main memory databases . we assume that neither the sequence of rids , # rid_list # , nor the data file , # input # , fit in cache . the dpg algorithm applies equally well as an external data retrieval algorithm between disk and main memory . the spirit of the dpg algorithm is : try to transform arbitrary memory access patterns into sequential memory access patterns ; where arbitrary memory access patterns are unavoidable , we try to divide the data into small partitions that fit into the cache . for a sequential access pattern , it is easy to maintain a buffer in cache . in the dpg algorithm we need to read many streams simultaneously , and maintain a buffer for each stream . hence , we want to keep the buffer as small as possible while maintaining reasonable efficiency . we define a buffer in cache to consist of two cache blocks . when a cache block is full , it is written back to main memory and a new cache block is loaded from main memory into cache . on pentium 4 , this is done automatically by the hardware prefetch function unit if the access to main memory is sequential . on other architectures without the hardware prefetch function unit , the software instructions , @xmath5 and @xmath6 , are needed to maintain the buffers . [ [ constraints ] ] * constraints : * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the data records and rids are split into runs of length @xmath7 . the run length @xmath7 is chosen based on two constraints . first , the cache must be able to simultaneously hold both one run of data records of length @xmath7 and one single buffer for the corresponding run of rids . ( this constraint applies in the second phase of dpg . ) second , the cache must simultaneously be able to hold a buffer for each run . ( this constraint applies in the first phase and in the third phase of dpg . ) these constraints are typical of the constraints for two - pass algorithms , such as external sorting . if the data file has @xmath8 records , then the data file is partitioned into @xmath9 sets of consecutive records . assuming an rid consists of a page i d and offset on that page , the high order bits of the page number can be used to efficiently identify the particular partition to which the rid belongs . this assumes that the number of pages in a partition is a power of two , which can be satisfied by appropriate choice of @xmath7 . for the sake of clarity , we assume the rids values are in the rage of @xmath10 and @xmath8 . [ [ three - phases ] ] * three phases : * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + there are three phases in the dpg algorithm . the three phases are also illustrated by pseudo - code in figure [ fig : dpgalgo ] and by the diagram of figure [ fig : dpg ] . 1 . * phase i. * the first phase is the _ distribute _ phase . one _ distributes _ the rids of # rid_list # into appropriate rid runs according to the values of the rids . the first rid run contains the rid values in the range from @xmath10 to @xmath7 , the second rid run contains the rid values in the range from @xmath7 to @xmath11 , and so on . both the access to every rid run and the access to # rid_list # are sequential . therefore , one only needs to maintains a buffer in cache for each rid run and a single buffer in cache for # rid_list # , at the end , we form @xmath9 rid runs and each rid run is a permutation vector . for example , the @xmath12-th rid run is a permutation vector in the range from @xmath13 and @xmath14 . * phase ii . * the second phase is the _ probe _ phase . in this phase , we allocate a second , temporary data file , # internal # , in main memory . the temporary data file has the same size as the original data file , # input # , and is organized into the same number of runs as the original data file . one then proceeds through each of the runs of rids and each of the runs of # input#. the rids from the @xmath12-th rid run are used to probe the @xmath12-th # input # run and the corresponding records are copied into the @xmath12-th # internal # run . + at the end , the @xmath12-th # internal # run contains the same records as the @xmath12-th # input # run , but the order of records in the # internal # run is organized according to the @xmath12-th rid run . both the @xmath12-th rid run and the @xmath12-th # internal # run are accessed sequentially . the @xmath12th # input # run is accessed randomly , but it can fit in cache . hence , every time , one loads the @xmath12-th # input # run entirely into cache and maintains two buffers in cache : one for the @xmath12th rid run and the other for the @xmath12-th # internal # run . * phase iii . * the third phase is the _ gather _ phase . this is an inverse of the _ distribute _ phase and is similar to the merge phase of external sorting . in the _ distribute _ phase , the rids are distributed into runs . as a result of the _ probe _ phase , the records in a given # internal # run are now in the same order as the rids in the corresponding rid run created in phase i. hence , it suffices to gather ( merge ) the records from the # internal # runs in exactly the same order as the order of the rids in # rid_list#. more precisely , if the @xmath12-th rid was distributed to the @xmath15-th rid run during the _ distribute _ phase , then at the @xmath12-th step of the _ gather _ phase , the next record from the @xmath15-th # internal # run is copied to the destination array . one maintains several buffers in cache : one single buffer for # rid_list # , one single buffer for the destination array , and a buffer for each # internal # run . the dpg algorithm is presented more formally in pseudo - code in figure [ fig : dpgalgo ] . the input of the algorithm is an array , # rid # , of _ rids _ ( record ids ) and a data file , # input_rec # , of records . it is desired to retrieve the records from # input_rec # in the order corresponding to # rid#. the retrieved records are then written to # output_rec#. the three phases of the dpg algorithm are illustrated by an example in figure [ fig : dpg ] . the input in this example is the leaf nodes of a secondary b+-tree index . the input contains a sequence of key - rid pairs sorted according to the key values . the output is a sequence of records sorted according to the key values of the secondary index . the output will either be stored again on disk or else pipelined to the next stage . the ability of the dpg algorithm to take advantage of pipelining is an important feature for sorting and joins . the letters # a # , # b # , # c # , ... are used to indicate the sorted keys on the leaf nodes of the index . so ( # a # , 5 ) indicates that the record with the rid value of 5 has a key value of # a#. the first two rows are for phase i , the next three rows for phase ii , and the following three rows for phase iii . the horizontal rectangle of the first row represents a sequence of key - rid pairs sorted according to the key values . the second row represents the runs of rids into which the first row is partitioned . similarly , the third row again represents the runs of rids , but now as part of phase ii . the fourth row is the partitioned runs of input records , and so on . there are 12 elements and 3 runs in the example and each run contains 4 elements . during * phase i * , one has a sequence of key - rid pairs sorted according to the key values and will distribute them into appropriate rid runs . the first rid run will contain rid values from 0 to 3 , the second rid run will contain rid values from 4 to 7 , and the third rid run will contain rid values from 8 to 11 . upon reading the sequence of pairs from the first row , one places the rids in their proper runs . for example , the rid 5 goes to the second rid run , the rid 7 goes to the second rid run , the rid 3 goes to the first rid run , the rid 8 goes to the third rid run , and so on . the third row in the figure presents the end of phase i. in this phase , we do sequential read on a single stream and sequential writes on multiple streams . during * phase ii * , one copies the original data file , # input # , to a temporary data file , # internal#. the input to this phase is the third row . in the third row , each rid run has rid values that correspond to one contiguous range of the # input # file , an # input # run . for example , for the first rid run , we will load the first # input # run into the cache . the first # input # run consists of the first 4 contiguous records . the first rid in the first rid run is 3 and @xmath16 $ ] is in the cache , so one finds this record , # input[3 ] # , in cache and copies it to the buffer maintained in cache for the first # internal # run , and so on . at the end of phase ii , the records in the first # input # run with key values in the sequence of i , l , f , c are reordered as records in the first # internal # run with key values in the sequence of c , f , i , l. the reordering is done according to a permutation specified by the first rid run , 3 , 2 , 0 , 1 . during * phase iii * , we will use the original rid sequence in the list of key - rid pairs to _ gather _ ( merge ) records from all # internal # run . for example , upon reading 5 , we go to the second # internal # run to _ gather _ the record ; upon reading 7 , we go to the second # internal # run to _ gather _ the record ; upon reading 3 , we go to the first # internal # run to _ gather _ the record ; upon reading 8 we go to the third # internal # run to _ gather _ the record , and so on . for this phase , we maintain a buffer for the key - rid list , a buffer for # output # in cache and a buffer for each # internal # run . all buffers are in cache . 0 .... % $ ( for sake of emacs ) let $ l\gets$ ( cache_size/2 ) let $ n\gets$ num_records let num_runs $ \gets n / l$ \rm input : integer \tt rid[num_rids ] , \rm record \tt input_rec[num_records ] ; \rm output : record \tt output_rec[num_rids ] ; \rm parameters : \rm integer \tt rid_run[num_runs][]\tt , \rm record \tt record_run[num_runs ] [ ] ; //phase i : { \it distribute } rid array into runs // with each run of length $ l$ % for $ i$ = 1 , ... , num_runs do % initialize write buffer of rid_run[$i$ ] for each rid , $ r$ , in rid do \ { set { \it run\_num } = $ \lceil{}r / l\rceil$ ; append $ r$ to rid_run[{\it run\_num } ] \ } //phase ii : { \it probe } partitions of input_rec % ( conceptually partition input_rec into partitions of length $ l$ and % for each partition , $ i$ , of input_rec , probe for each rid in rid_run[$i$ ] ) for $ i$ = 1 , ... , num_runs do \ { % initialize read buffer for rid_run[$i$ ] read into memory all records from input_rec[$(i-1)\!*\!\!l\ ! + \ ! 1 $ ] to input_rec[$i\!*\!\!l$ ] allocate memory for $ l$ records to be stored in record_run[i ] for each rid , $ r$ , in rid_run[$i$ ] append input_rec[$r$ ] to record_run[$i$ ] write out record_run[$i$ ] to disk \ } //phase iii : { \it gather } records from record_run [ ] // into output_rec in same order as rid [ ] % for $ i$ = 1 , ... , num_runs do % initialize read buffer of record_run[$i$ ] for each rid , $ r$ , in rid do \ { set { \it run\_num } = $ \lceil{}r / l\rceil$ ; read next record from record_run[{\it run\_num } ] append record to output_rec \ } .... implicit in the description of the dpg algorithm is that the input sequence of rids is distributed uniformly among the set of all rids of the input data file . this is always the case when dpg is applied to retrieve records after sorting key - pointer pairs . in that situation , the key - pointer pairs act as a permutation vector to permute the records in the input data file . if the input sequence of rids is not uniformly distributed , then some rid runs will be larger than other runs . as a consequence , in phase ii , when the partition of the temporary data file ( the partition of # record_run # in figure [ fig : dpgalgo ] ) may be larger than the size of the cache . if only a few of the partitions of the temporary data file are larger than cache then the overall running time is not greatly affected . if there is a great deal of data skew and many of the temporary partitions # record_run # are larger than cache , then the @xmath9 partitions of the input sequence of rids must be chosen on some other basis than the high order bits of the page number . in such cases , one can invoke the data skew handling techniques of dewitt et al . @xcite . their solution , reformulated in our context , is to sample the rids from the rid sequence . the sampled set of rids is then sorted , and partitions of the rids are chosen so as to evenly partition the sampled set . as discussed in the introduction , dpg acts as an accelerator for many main memory sorting algorithms . recall that main memory sorts typically proceed in three phases : 1 . extraction of key - pointer ; 2 . sorting of the key - pointer pairs ; and 3 . copying of the original records into the destination array according to the sorted key - pointer pairs . alphasort @xcite and superscalarsort @xcite are examples of this three - phase sorting paradigm . both sorting algorithms can be considered as main memory sorting algorithms . in principle , the sorting algorithms are single - pass disk - based sorting algorithms . both sorting algorithms were introduced as an answer to the datamation sorting challenge @xcite . the datamation challenge dictates that one is given one million records of 100 bytes . each record has a 10 byte key . the keys are uniformly distributed . at the time of the datamation challenge , external sorting algorithms were required . on today s computers , the data file of 100 mb easily fits in main memory . hence , the only disk - related portion of the datamation challenge is to overlap disk i / o with cpu operation . disk striping has the potential to provide very fast disk i / o . this occurs because the disks are accessed in parallel . in this situation , main memory data retrieval becomes the bottleneck . the dpg algorithm pushes back this main memory bottleneck . by using dpg for data movement , the largest cost of main memory sorting is reduced . we have reimplemented the main memory portion of superscalarsort , both with and without dpg . we use the ideas of dpg to present three new join algorithms : 1.c , 2 and 3 . algorithms 1.a , 1.b and 4 , will be included in the experimental section [ sec : joinexperiments ] for completeness . 1 . sort - merge join 1 . sort - merge join with alphasort ( sort based on @xcite ) 2 . sort - merge join with superscalarsort ( sort based on @xcite ) 3 . sort - merge join with dpg sort ( sort based on dpg ; see [ sec : sortmergejoin ] ) 2 . dpg - sort join ( see section [ sec : foreignkeyjoin ] ) 3 . dpg - move join ( see section [ sec : foreignkeyjoin ] ) 4 . radix join ( from @xcite ) the well - known sort - merge join was introduced by blasgen and eswaran @xcite . there are two steps in sort - merge joins : sort two relations on the join key and scan the sorted relations to do a merge on the join key . applying dpg sort at the first step provides a new faster sort - merge join method , sort - merge join with dpg sort . in sections [ sec : sortmergejoinexperiments ] and [ sec : joinexperiments ] , we experimentally compare different versions of sort - merge join , according to the sorting methods used . specifically , we consider using dpg sort , alphasort and superscalarsort for the sorting step . we next consider joins in which the join key is a foreign key , and it has an index . we denote by @xmath3 a non - indexed relation . we denote by @xmath4 an indexed relation . the notation is motivated by the example of a foreign key join . in a foreign key join , the join key is the same as the foreign key . so , the join key is a set of attributes in the relation @xmath3 that refers to a foreign key from relation @xmath4 . a _ join triple _ is a triple ( @xmath0 , rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) , such that @xmath0 is a key value , rid@xmath1 is the rid of a record from @xmath3 with key @xmath0 , and rid@xmath2 the rid of a record from @xmath4 with key @xmath0 . there are three steps in a foreign key join algorithm with dpg . the first step is to construct join triples . the second step is to use the join triples to copy one of the two relations into a temporary file according to an order derived from the join triples . the third step is to join the temporary file with the remaining relation . we describe the second and third steps initially in section [ sec : foreignkeyjoin ] . we then return to the more technical problem of efficiently constructing join triples in sections [ sec : jointriples ] and [ sec : indexlookup ] . this section describes two dpg join algorithms . it assumes that one has already constructed the join triples . some algorithms for constructing the join triples are described later in sections [ sec : jointriples ] and [ sec : indexlookup ] . assume that one has generated the join triples ( @xmath0 , rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) . it is now possible to ignore the key @xmath0 , and deal directly with the rid pairs ( rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) . we wish to satisfy one of two goals : 1 . [ item : movef ] * dpg - move join : * move the records of @xmath4 into a temporary file according to the ordering of the records of @xmath3 . [ item : mover ] * dpg - sort join : * move the records of @xmath3 into a temporary file according to the ordering of the records of @xmath4 . so , the rid pairs ( rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) will be sorted according to rid@xmath2 . first consider dpg - move join . we will see how to generate the join triples in the order of rid@xmath1 . this is done by scanning the records of the relation @xmath3 in file order ( in order of increasing rid@xmath1 ) . therefore the rid pairs can be used directly as part of a dpg algorithm . the second component of the pair , rid@xmath2 , is the sequence of rids according to which we want to move the records of @xmath4 . this algorithm does not require any sorting or hashing . hence , we call it dpg - move join . next consider dpg - sort join . in this version , we first sort the rid pairs ( rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) according to the order of rid@xmath2 . this is done , for example , with superscalarsort and dpg . the algorithm then reduces to record movement in which we wish to move the records of @xmath3 according to the ordering of rid@xmath2 in the sorted sequence ( rid@xmath1 , rid@xmath2 ) . note that dpg - move join is preferred when the relation @xmath4 is smaller . dpg - sort join is preferred when the relation @xmath3 is smaller . the simplest solution for a foreign key join is to do a file scan of @xmath3 , and for each record of @xmath3 to extract the join key and do an index lookup in the index of @xmath4 . one can then join the record of @xmath3 with the corresponding record of @xmath4 . this involves random access , and is economical only if the join produces very few records . in particular , this will be the case only if the number of records of @xmath3 is small . a better solution is to do a file scan of @xmath3 , and to use the index on @xmath4 to create join triples . to construct the join triples , one scans the relation @xmath3 . for each record of @xmath3 , one extracts the corresponding rid and associated join key @xmath0 . one then looks up the key @xmath0 in the index of @xmath4 . the index lookup yields the final element of the triple , rid@xmath2 . note that the join triple is constructed at the cost of a file scan of @xmath3 and an index lookup in the index of @xmath4 for each record of @xmath3 . usually an index on a data file is much smaller than the full data file . if the index fits entirely in cache , then the index lookup will be significantly cheaper than the file scan . unfortunately , the indexes in many main memory databases generally do not fit in cache . in such cases , the index lookup in the index of @xmath4 will dominate the costs . for example , in a b+ tree indexing @xmath8 records , if an internal node has @xmath17 children , then @xmath18 nodes of the b+ tree must be accessed . each such access will be a random access in main memory . most of the random accesses imply a cache miss . the cost of so many random accesses makes a naive index lookup uneconomical . even if the index is a hash index , at least one random access in memory will be required . luckily , it is possible to execute the index lookup faster than the above analysis would indicate . this is because the construction of the join triples requires many index lookups , with no intervening record accesses . for purposes of join triple construction , _ batch lookup _ of keys in an index suffices . by batch lookup , we assume that an array of join keys is first extracted by scanning the data file of @xmath3 . the batch lookup then produces an array of rids for @xmath4 through the use of the index on @xmath4 . we show that the index lookups can be reorganized into a two - pass algorithm . two such two - pass algorithms are demonstrated : one for b+ tree indexes , and one for hash indexes . note that batch lookup of rids in an index can be substantially faster than individual lookup . rao and ross had previously discussed cache conscious indexes for main memory @xcite . there they present css - trees , which have better cache behavior than either b+ trees or hash indexes . however , they only consider individual lookup of keys in an index , one at a time . in their scenario , a second key is not looked up until the index lookup of the first key has been resolved . [ [ batch - lookup - in - b - tree - indexes ] ] * batch lookup in b+ tree indexes * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + for simplicity , we describe the two - pass lookup for an enhanced b+ tree . the notion of _ enhanced b+ tree _ was introduced by rao and ross @xcite . the idea is that all slots of a b+ tree node are used . this is similar to compact b - trees @xcite or to the isam method introduced by ibm @xcite . in the context of a general b+ tree this can be accomplished by maintaining updates to the b+ tree in a separate index , and then doing a batch update by reorganizing the b+ tree . for brevity , we will sometimes refer to b+ tree , although in all cases , an enhanced b+ tree is intended . assume that we are executing a file scan of @xmath3 with the purpose of constructing the join triples . we collect a sequence of keys from the relation @xmath3 , and we wish to carry out a batch lookup of rids in the enhanced b+-tree . the rids will be used to retrieve records from the foreign relation @xmath4 . we assume that the b+ tree does not fit in cache . our goal is a two - pass algorithm which will efficiently accomplish batch lookup . assume that the b+ tree has @xmath17 entries per node . assume that the b+ tree indexes @xmath8 records . then there are @xmath18 levels . assume further that the first @xmath19 levels ( the top half of the b+ tree ) fit in cache . for @xmath20 , the top half of the tree has approximately @xmath21 slots . for example , if there are @xmath22 records , then there are 32,000 slots , which clearly fit inside cache . the strategy is a two - pass strategy . in the first pass , one performs a lookup of each key , but only using the top half of the b+ tree . as shown in figure [ fig : btree ] , each leaf of the subtree comprising this upper half can be considered as the root of a second subtree comprising nodes in the lower half of the b+ tree . thus , at the end of this first pass , a key can be associated with a leaf of the upper subtree , which is also a root of one of the lower subtrees . after the first pass , one can associate each key with a subtree within the lower half of the b+ tree . so , in the second pass , one loads a subtree from the lower half . one then continues the lookup for all keys associated with the root of the subtree in the lower half . at the end , one then has a sequence of keys and rids . if one wishes to have the keys in the same order as the order of the original rids , then this can also be arranged . in this case , one extends the previous scenario to use the dpg algorithm . the first phase of the dpg algorithm is to _ distribute _ the keys into runs . in the initial lookup of a key in the first half , it was associated with a root of a subtree in the first half . the particular root of a subtree identifies the run into which the key is copied . the second phase of the dpg algorithm is to use the key to _ probe _ the index , in order to find the rid . one completes the lookup of all keys in a run associated with a particular subtree of the b+ tree , before proceeding to the next subtree in the lower half . the resulting rids are stored in a temporary partition or run . this is exactly what was described earlier . finally , the third phase of the dpg algorithm _ gathers _ the rids into a destination array in the same order as that of the original keys . hence , we have completed a batch lookup of the keys , and returned an array of rids in the same order as that of the original keys . [ [ batch - lookup - in - hash - indexes ] ] * batch lookup in hash indexes * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + batch lookup of hash indexes also proceeds in two passes . we assume that the hash array of the hash index stores at each hash entry one key - rid pair . a second hash array associated with the index stores pointers to overflow key - rid pairs that would have collided with an occupied slot in the first hash array . the two - pass lookup for hash indexes proceeds in a very simple manner . we extract the sequence of keys from @xmath3 . as the keys are extracted , the hash values are computed . those key - hash value pairs are saved in an array in an order corresponding to the rid order of @xmath3 . it now suffices to apply the dpg algorithm . the hash array is partitioned into sets of @xmath7 hash slots . in the distribute phase , the hash value acts as an index into the hash array . hence , this becomes the permutation vector of the dpg algorithm . the key and hash value are then written into separate runs according to the partition of the hash array . there is one run of key - hash values for each partition of the hash array . in the probe phase , a run of hash values is loaded into cache along with the corresponding partition of the hash array . as part of the probe phase , the key and hash values from the run are used to look up the the corresponding rid in the partition of the hash array . the rids are then saved in a temporary partition , in the same order as the order in which the key - hash values of the original partition are stored . finally , in the gather phase , the ordering of the key - hash value pairs are used to gather the rids from the temporary partition . as in section [ sec : dpg ] , the rids are gathered into a destination array in an order corresponding the ordering of the original key - hash value pairs . figure [ fig : sorting ] demonstrates the acceleration achieved by superscalarsort when dpg is used . the results are demonstrated on the ibm pseries 690 turbo . the ibm p690 has an l3 cache of size 128 mb . hence , in order to realistically demonstrate dpg , we were forced to increase the size of the database . we chose to implement superscalarsort for a data file of size 512 mb . the record size was treated as a variable , to illustrate the influence of record size . as in the original datamation challenge , the key is 10 bytes . note that the additional speed of superscalarsort with dpg is most pronounced for smaller record sizes . for record sizes of 256 bytes and higher , dpg provides only a small advantage . this is because the ibm p690 has an l3 cache block of size 512 bytes . so , for record sizes below 256 bytes , a cache miss incurs significant overhead in loading a 512 byte cache block . there was some variability in the results because the data was taken on a time - shared , shared memory machine . on the ibm p690 , the l2 cache is shared among two cpus , and the l3 cache is shared among eight cpus . our experiments were run on a single cpu . hence another process on a neighboring cpu could consume some of our cache , thereby affecting the timings . the reported experimental results are the averages of three runs each . we implement two sort - merge join methods : sort - merge join with dpg sort and sort - merge join with superscalarsort . as defined in section [ sec : sortmergejoin ] , sort - merge join with dpg sort applies the dpg sort for the sorting phase and sort - merge join with superscalarsort applies superscalarsort for the sorting phase . as expected , the acceleration in the speed of sort - merge join in figure [ fig : sortmerge ] follows the same pattern as that of figure [ fig : sorting ] for sorting . in this case , we illustrate our results on a database of size 128 mb on the ibm p690 . the ibm p690 has an l2 cache of size 1.4 mb . so , in this case , the l3 cache is acting as the main memory , while l2 cache is acting as the `` cache '' . in figures [ fig : join_nonuniform_1 ] through [ fig : join_dup_3 ] , we now experimentally compare the six join methods originally presented at the begining of section [ sec : joinalgodpg ] . the three join algorithms labelled sort - merge join with dpg sort , dpg - sort join , and dpg - move join are all new . the remaining algorithms , sort - merge join with alphasort , sort - merge join with superscalarsort , and radix join , are all based on sorting or join algorithms from the literature . as explained earlier , we denote by @xmath4 an indexed relation and @xmath3 a relation that has foreign key on the indexed attribute of @xmath4 . we consider both uniform and non - uniform distribution of foreign key values . [ [ the - non - uniform - distribution - of - join - key - values . ] ] * the non - uniform distribution of join key values . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + sort - merge join with alphasort and dpg - sort are the only two of the previously discussed join methods that operate correctly for a non - uniform distribution of join key values . in the following we use count bucket sort for bucket sort . the count bucket sort is as follows : 1 . count the number of elements destined for each bucket . 2 . set bucket boundaries according to the statics computed and distribute elements to buckets . alphasort works for non - uniformly distributed data , because it uses quicksort to sort each run and uses replacement - selection to merge the runs . dpg - sort join works for non - uniformly distributed data too , because we use count bucket sort to sort rids . dpg - sort join sorts the rids according to the lowest @xmath23 bits is enough , @xmath8 is the number of records . in the simulation , we assign the rid values in the range @xmath24 $ ] , the lowest @xmath23 bits is sufficient for sorting . for example , for @xmath25 sorting rids according to the lowest 20 bits is enough . this could be done in two steps with count bucket sort : first do count bucket sort according to the lower 10 bits , then do count bucket sort according to the higher 10 bits . using the unix @xmath26 and @xmath27 functions we generate an exponential distribution of the data as @xmath28 ( @xmath29 is a constant and in our experiments we assign c with @xmath30 ) . a comparison of sort - merge join with alphasort and dpg - sort join on three different computer architectures is provided in the figures [ fig : join_nonuniform_1 ] , [ fig : join_nonuniform_2 ] , and [ fig : join_nonuniform_3 ] . the three different architectures are the ibm power4 pseries 690 turbo , the 3.06 ghz pentium 4 with rambus pc-1200 ram , and the 2.6 ghz pentium 4 with ddr-266 ram , from the comparison , we can see that dpg - sort join is much faster than sort - merge join with alphasort . [ [ the - uniform - distribution - of - join - key - values . ] ] * the uniform distribution of join key values . * + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + first we will show how all algorithms work for uniformly distributed join key values . superscalarsort is a key - prefix - sort explained further in section [ sec : intro ] . it assumes that data is uniformly distributed according to the highest 7 bits of the key . this kind of distribution can be applied to all dpg algorithms , because a unform distribution of the join key values is the only constraint of sort - merge join with dpg and dpg - move join . we also implement the radix join of manegold et al . they describe a variation of hash join for main memory . radix join also requires a uniform distribution of the join key values . otherwise , some of their partitions will be too large to fit into the l2 cache and how to set the boundaries is unknown . we produce uniformly distributed foreign key values using the unix @xmath26 function . a comparison of the different join methods on three different computer architectures as before is provided in the figures . figure [ fig : join_no_dup ] reflects data with no duplicate join key values in the relation @xmath3 . figures [ fig : join_dup_1 ] , [ fig : join_dup_2 ] , and [ fig : join_dup_3 ] , show the same information in which duplicate join key values are allowed . from the comparison , we can see that dpg - move join and radix join are the fastest . dpg - move is better for large records and radix join is better for small records . the use of dpg in the sorting provides an accelerator for existing sorting algorithms . especially for the smaller record sizes , such as 32 bytes and 64 bytes , the performance improvements are really impressive . for the more common case of non - uniform distribution of join key values , dpg - sort join works better than sort - merge join with alphasort across all the tested platforms . for smaller records sizes , such as , 32 , 64 , dpg - sort join is much better than sort - merge join with alphasort . more impressively , on the newer platform , rambus pc-1200 ram , dpg - sort works better than on pc with ddr-266 ram and even works better for larger record sizes , for example 512 bytes . for special case of uniform distribution of join key values , dpg - move join and radix join are the best . the remaining dpg algorithms are also competitive with older algorithms although with a smaller improvement . the dpg algorithm can be easily generalized to multiple passes . this can be useful when there is a very small cache in relation to the size of main memory . however , we do not encounter this scenario in our current experiments . we would like to thank betty salzberg and donghui zhang for extensive conversations and insights into additional situations where distribute - probe - gather can be beneficial . we also gratefully acknowledge the use of the support for the computations on the ibm p690 by the scientific computing and visualization ( scv ) group at boston university . a. ailamaki , d.j . dewitt , m.d . hill , d.a . wood , `` dbmss on a modern processor : where does time go ? '' , _ vldb99 , proceedings of 25th international conference on very large data bases _ , 1999 , pp . 266 - 277 . l. arge , o. procopiuc , s. ramaswamy , t. suel and j.s . vitter , `` scalable sweeping - based spatial join '' , _ vldb 1998 , proceedings of 24th international conference on very large databases _ , 1998 , pp . 570581 . dittrich , b. seeger , d.s . taylor and p. widmayer , `` progressive merge join : a generic and non - blocking sort - based join algorithm '' , _ vldb 2002 , proceedings of 28th international conference on very _ , 2002 . web site : `` latency vs. bandwidth , a performance analysis '' , http://www.lostcircuits.com/memory/latency/2.shtml ; `` inside the eddr chip : combining dram storage and sram speed '' , http://www.lostcircuits.com/memory/eddr/ , nov . 27 , 2000 ; and `` high performance ddr dimms '' , http://www.lostcircuits.com/memory/ddr2/ , july 17 , 2001 . k. keeton , d.a . patterson , y.q . raphael and w.e . baker `` performance characterization of a quad pentium pro smp using oltp workloads '' _ porc . of the int . syp . on computer architecture _ , p0p . 1526 , barcelona , spain , 1998 . s. manegold , p.a . boncz and m.l . kersten , `` what happens during a join ? dissecting cpu and memory optimization effects '' , _ vldb 2000 , proceedings of 26th international conference on very large data bases , september 10 - 14 , 2000 , cairo , egypt _ , 2000 , pp . 339350 . p. trancoso j.l . larriba - pey , z. zhang and j. torellas , `` the memory performance of dss commercial workloads in shared - memory multiprocessors '' , _ int . symp . on high performance computer architecture _ , san antonio , tx , usa 1997 .
Abstract: | [
"retrieval of records on disk is well - known to be at the heart of many database problems . we show that the corresponding movement of records in main memory has now become a severe bottleneck for many database operations . this is due to the stagnating latency of main memory , even while cpu speed , main memory bandwidth , and disk speed all continue to improve . as a result , record movement has become the dominant cost in main memory sorting . we present a new algorithm for fast record retrieval , _ distribute - probe - gather _ , or dpg . dpg has important applications both in sorting and in joins . current main memory sorting algorithms split their work into three phases : extraction of key - pointer pairs ; sorting of the key - pointer pairs ; and copying of the original records into the destination array according the sorted key - pointer pairs . the copying in the last phase dominates today s sorting time . hence , the use of dpg in the third phase provides an accelerator for existing sorting algorithms . dpg also provides two new join methods for foreign key joins : dpg - move join and dpg - sort join . the resulting join methods with dpg are faster because dpg join is cache - efficient and at the same time dpg join avoids the need for sorting or for hashing . the ideas presented for foreign key join can also be extended to faster record pair retrieval for spatial and temporal databases ."
] | 9,458 | 9,458 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: there have been a number of attempts to study hypernuclei containing not only nucleons but also hyperons with strangeness @xcite . it has been of high interest to investigate how the presence of strangeness broadens and/or modifies the knowledge achieved in the field of ordinary nuclear physics . it is a fundamental problem to understand properties of a quantum many - body system in terms of basic interactions between constituent particles . in hypernuclear physics a unified treatment of all the baryon - baryon interactions , especially nucleon - nucleon ( @xmath4 ) and hyperon - nucleon ( @xmath5 ) interactions , will be necessary if one wish to understand general properties of hypernuclei . however , our knowledge on the @xmath5 interaction is quite inadequate in contrast to that of the @xmath6 interaction due to experimental difficulties . in such a situation many - body theoretical studies of hypernuclei could provide alternative information on the @xmath5 interaction . it has been discussed that physics of hypernuclei is different from conventional nuclear physics in some aspects . first , the channel couplings such as the @xmath7-@xmath8 coupling play a significant role in the structure of hypernuclei in contrast to the very limited role of the @xmath9-@xmath10 coupling appeared in nuclear many - body systems @xcite . second , the anti - symmetric spin - orbit force , which is forbidden in ordinary nuclei , emerges in hypernuclei in addition to the symmetric spin - orbit force . the spin - orbit splitting of @xmath11 single - particle levels in @xmath11 hypernuclei was considered experimentally to be much smaller than their nucleonic counterpart @xcite . however , some recent studies as in ref . @xcite suggest that the splitting would not be so small as discussed earlier . it will be highly desirable for the spin - orbit splitting to be established in experiment . the magnitude of the spin - orbit splitting will put further constraints on the @xmath12 interaction . there have been several possibilities of solving the structure of hypernuclei . one possibility is to treat few - body or light hypernuclei by solving the faddeev equation @xcite or by applying the cluster model @xcite . another possibility is microscopic studies of hypernuclei with a larger mass number . while a few lower partial waves play a decisive role in few - body or light hypernuclei , higher partial waves could give some contributions in heavier hypernuclei . these microscopic studies of hypernuclei could make us understand interesting physics of their structure itself , and also help us in determining the @xmath5 interaction . microscopic structure calculation of heavier hypernuclei is usually performed by introducing a @xmath12 effective interaction . for this purpose the @xmath13-matrix theory has been applied in two ways : in some works an effective @xmath5 interaction has been derived by simulating a nuclear matter @xmath13-matrix . in this approach the non - locality and energy dependence of the @xmath13-matrix are neglected , and the effective @xmath5 interaction is represented in the two- or three - range gaussian form with the adjustable fermi momentum @xmath14 . this type of the effective interaction has been referred to as the yng interaction @xcite . the yng interaction has been successfully used in many of hypernuclear structure calculations @xcite . it seems to us that the yng interaction has made an important contribution to the considerable progress in overall description of hypernuclei . the other approach , in the framework of the @xmath13-matrix theory , is to calculate the @xmath13-matrix in finite hypernuclei by treating rigorously the pauli exclusion operator and making a self - consistent calculation of single - particle potential of hyperons @xcite . in contrast to studies of using the yng interaction this approach possibly gives a better description of the state dependence of the effective @xmath5 interaction . it has been established that the @xmath13-matrix can be used as a basic ingredient in constructing a microscopic many - body theory starting with bare interactions . in spite of a marked success in the applications of the @xmath13-matrix theory , we may say from a formal point of view that the @xmath13-matrix is energy - dependent and non - hermitian , and does not have the property of decoupling between a model space of low - lying two - particle states and its complement . the @xmath13-matrix is not considered to be an effective interaction in a formal sense of the effective interaction theory . in order to derive an effective interaction we should add some higher - order corrections such as folded diagrams @xcite . it would be desirable if we could have a theory describing many - body systems in terms of an energy - independent and hermitian effective interaction with the property of decoupling . two of the present authors , k. s. and r. o. , proposed a many - body theory , the unitary - model - operator approach ( umoa ) that was formulated on the basis of such an effective interaction . the umoa was applied to finite nuclei , @xmath15o and @xmath16ca @xcite , and some improvements have been attained . the method may be viewed as an alternative way of deriving an effective interaction in finite many - body systems . a unified study of hypernuclei and ordinary nuclei would be helpful in understanding many - body systems of baryons in a microscopic way . therefore , we extended the formulation of the umoa , in the previous work @xcite , to the description of hypernuclei and made a calculation of the properties in @xmath17o with a realistic @xmath12 interaction . the purposes of this work are to present a general formulation of the extended umoa and apply it to @xmath17o by employing some realistic @xmath12 interactions . this paper is organized as follows : in section 2 we present a general formulation of the umoa for deriving the @xmath18 effective interaction . in section 3 the approximation procedure is given for making actual calculations . in section 4 we apply the umoa to @xmath17o by employing the nijmegen soft - core ( nsc ) @xcite , jlich model - ( j ) and model - b ( jb ) @xcite @xmath12 potentials . in section 5 we make some concluding remarks . we present a formulation of the umoa for applying to a calculation of the properties in @xmath11 hypernuclei , especially , closed - shell nucleus plus one @xmath11 systems . a main purpose is to give a method of calculating an effective interaction between @xmath11 and @xmath19 . in the derivation of the @xmath8 effective interaction we should note that , because of the small mass difference of about 77mev between @xmath11 and @xmath20 , the coupling of the @xmath8 and @xmath7 channels plays an important role . we first consider a two - body hamiltonian of a @xmath7-@xmath8 coupled system given by @xmath21 where @xmath22 @xmath23 and @xmath24 the terms @xmath25 and @xmath26 for @xmath27 and @xmath19 are the kinetic and single - particle potential energies of @xmath28 and @xmath19 , respectively , and @xmath29 is the bare two - body @xmath12 interaction including the @xmath8 and @xmath7 channels . the terms @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the rest masses of @xmath32 and @xmath33 , respectively . the hamiltonian @xmath34 describes a subsystem of interacting two particles @xmath8 or @xmath7 in the one - body potentials @xmath35 , @xmath36 and @xmath37 . in order to derive a @xmath8 effective interaction we introduce a unitarily transformed @xmath5 interaction given by @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the correlation operator defined in a space of two - particle states of @xmath8 and @xmath7 . the @xmath39 is an anti - hermitian operator satisfying @xmath40 in the formulation of the umoa the correlation operator @xmath39 is determined by the equation of decoupling for @xmath41 between a certain model space consisting of low - momentum two - particle states and its complement . this determination of the correlation operator @xmath39 is one of the characteristics of the present approach . for the determination of a @xmath8 effective interaction , we introduce a model space consisting of low - momentum @xmath8 states . let @xmath42 be the projection operator onto the model space . the complement of the @xmath43 space includes a space of high - momentum @xmath8 states referred to as the @xmath44 space and a space of all the @xmath7 states referred to as the @xmath45 space . the condition of decoupling for the transformed interaction @xmath41 is given by @xmath46 hereafter , we refer to the above equation as the decoupling equation . we assume that the one - body part @xmath47 in eq . ( [ eq : tvyn ] ) is decoupled as @xmath48 on the above assumption the decoupling equation ( [ eq : dec ] ) becomes @xmath49 in general , the decoupling equation ( [ eq : decr ] ) does not determine @xmath39 uniquely . the usual restrictive conditions are @xmath50 these conditions are called the minimal effect requirements @xcite , which mean that the transformation exp@xmath51 does not induce unnecessary transformation within each of the @xmath52 and @xmath53 spaces . in the general theory of constructing a hermitian effective interaction , the solution for @xmath54 in eq . ( [ eq : decr ] ) has been known @xcite and is given by @xmath55 with latexmath:[\ ] ] the @xmath59 in eq . ( [ eq : oyn ] ) is the biorthogonal state of @xmath60 satisfying latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{eq : bio } \langle \overline{\psi_{{\sst { \it \lambda n}}k } } where @xmath60 is the @xmath52-space component of @xmath57 defined by latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{eq : psc } that the solution @xmath39 in eq . ( [ eq : syn ] ) is determined dependently on the choice of a set of @xmath63 eigenstates @xmath64 as given in eq . ( [ eq : oyn ] ) . we choose a set of @xmath65 so that they have the largest @xmath52-space overlaps among all the eigenstates in eq . ( [ eq : eige ] ) . this is a usual choice in the derivation of the effective interaction . with the solution @xmath39 in eq . ( [ eq : syn ] ) , the @xmath8 effective interaction in the @xmath52 space is given by @xmath66 it has been known that this @xmath8 effective interaction can be written explicitly @xcite as @xmath67 where @xmath68 ( @xmath69 ) and @xmath70 ( @xmath71 ) are defined through the eigenvalue equation @xmath72 and @xmath73 is given by @xmath74 the @xmath75 is a @xmath42-space operator that agrees with the effective interaction of non - hermitian type . equation ( [ eq : evln ] ) is a formula for converting the non - hermitian effective interaction to the hermitian one . the term @xmath76 in eq . ( [ eq : shyn ] ) is introduced as a self - consistent potential of @xmath32 calculated with the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath77 as @xmath78 ( @xmath79 ) and @xmath80 are the single - particle states of @xmath32 and @xmath19 , respectively . from eqs . ( [ eq : evln])-([eq : nhevln ] ) we see that the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath81 can be calculated once the operator @xmath82 is given . the operator @xmath82 is determined completely , as given in eq . ( [ eq : oyn ] ) , by solving the eigenvalue equation ( [ eq : eige ] ) and selecting @xmath63 eigenstates @xmath65 with the largest @xmath52-space overlaps . it is noted here that eqs . ( [ eq : syn])-([eq : ul ] ) give a set of equations that determines the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath77 self - consistently with the single - particle potential @xmath76 . here we discuss a calculation procedure for obtaining the @xmath8 effective interaction acting in a small model space of low - lying @xmath8 states . we use the harmonic oscillator ( h.o . ) wave functions as basis states . it is desirable that the single - particle potentials of @xmath83 , @xmath33 and @xmath19 in intermediate states are taken into account in a self - consistent way . however , as our main concern is to derive a @xmath8 effective interaction , the self - consistent treatment of @xmath35 would have predominant importance in the present calculation . for this reason we make a self - consistent calculation only for @xmath35 , and as for @xmath37 we employ a fixed potential calculated previously for closed shell nuclei in the umoa @xcite . the effect of the single - particle potential @xmath36 on the @xmath8 effective interaction has not necessarily been clarified , although some calculations with @xmath36 have been made for the @xmath13-matrices in hyperonic nuclear matter @xcite . in the actual calculations made so far the single - particle potential @xmath36 has been considered to be rather shallow @xcite . although we have not known clearly how much the effect of @xmath36 on the @xmath8 effective interaction , we here assume @xmath84 . in solving the self - consistent equation for @xmath35 with @xmath81 we should be careful in the following two respects : ( a ) in the calculation of energies of intermediate states in propagators we should use @xmath35 that is given for @xmath83 states including high - momentum states . in order to do this we need a @xmath8 effective interaction acting in a large model space , because in general the @xmath44 space contains high - momentum @xmath8 states and the @xmath85-space effective interaction @xmath86 is not always well behaved . we thus make a calculation by introducing two model spaces , namely , large and small model spaces . the @xmath8 effective interaction in each of the model spaces is calculated by following a two - step procedure . in the first - step procedure , we define a large model space and calculate the @xmath8 effective interaction and single - particle potential of @xmath83 in high - lying states . the @xmath8 effective interaction acting in this large model space will not be suitable for the effective interaction in a usual sense . by introducing a small model space and using the @xmath8 effective interaction determined in the first - step calculation , we proceed to the second - step calculation where we calculate a @xmath8 effective interaction acting in this small model space of low - lying @xmath87 states . ( b ) it is important in actual calculations how to determine the @xmath88 and @xmath85 spaces because an effective interaction is determined dependently on the choice of the @xmath88 and @xmath85 spaces . if a state in the @xmath88 space mixes strongly with @xmath85-space states in the eigenstate in eq . ( [ eq : eige ] ) , the matrix element of @xmath89 or @xmath54 defined in sec . 2 becomes large and as a result higher - order many - body correlations @xcite give rise to non - negligible contributions . in general , the strong mixing takes place when some of the @xmath88- and @xmath85-space states are quasi - degenerate in energy . for this reason , we should choose the @xmath88 and @xmath85 spaces which are well separated in energy . with due regard to points ( a ) and ( b ) we perform a calculation of the effective interaction through the two - step procedure . in the following subsections we present the two - step method in detail . let us write a two - particle state of @xmath83 and @xmath19 as the product of the h.o . single - particle wave functions in the usual notation as @xmath90 we define a model space denoted by @xmath91 and its complement @xmath92 with a boundary number @xmath93 as @xmath94 we also define a space of all the @xmath7 states denoted by @xmath95 as @xmath96 note that the model space @xmath91 does not contain the @xmath7 states . if we make a graph of two - particle states , the @xmath97 , @xmath92 and @xmath98 spaces are represented in fig . 1 . the @xmath93 means a number such that @xmath99 gives the maximum kinetic energy of the @xmath8 two - particle states in the @xmath97 space . the @xmath100 denotes the unit of the h.o . energy which we use commonly for @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath19 . as we require to introduce a sufficiently large model space in the first - step calculation , we should choose @xmath93 as large as possible . another requirement is that the states in the @xmath91 space should be separated in energy from the states in the @xmath101 space . for this reason , we adopt a model space @xmath97 of a triangular shape . this choice of the @xmath97 space guarantees the separation in energy . [ fig:1 ] = 13 cm in fig . 1 the spaces @xmath102 for @xmath103 and @xmath33 , specified by the numbers @xmath104 and @xmath105 , stand for the excluded spaces due to the pauli principle for nucleons . the number @xmath106 is defined as @xmath107 with the quantum numbers @xmath108 of the highest occupied orbit in the closed - shell core nucleus . the @xmath109 means a number such that @xmath110 gives the maximum kinetic energy of the @xmath12 two - particle states in the @xmath111 and @xmath112 spaces . we then write the @xmath111 and @xmath112 spaces as @xmath113 and @xmath114 we also define the sum of the excluded spaces as @xmath115 furthermore , by using the projection operators , @xmath101 , @xmath116 , @xmath95 and @xmath117 , we introduce projection operators onto the spaces of allowed @xmath12 states as @xmath118 @xmath119 and we also define @xmath120 considering the pauli - exclusion principle for nucleons the terms @xmath121 and @xmath122 should be removed in treating the problem of two - body correlations . however , if we remove all the matrix elements of these terms , this leads to overmuch counting of the pauli principle . the matrix elements which are diagonal in nucleon states should be restored even though nucleons are in occupied states . therefore , instead of @xmath123 , we should use a @xmath12 interaction @xmath124 defined as @xmath125 where @xmath126 denotes the set of the h.o . quantum numbers @xmath127 of an occupied state of a nucleon , and the operator @xmath128 is defined as @xmath129 the two - body @xmath12 equation to be solved in the first - step calculation is now written as @xmath130 where we define @xmath131 as @xmath132 the @xmath133 is the single - particle potential of @xmath32 to be calculated with the @xmath8 effective interaction self - consistently . the number @xmath134 stands for a set of quantum numbers to specify a two - body @xmath12 eigenstate . the unitarily transformed @xmath12 interaction in the first - step calculation is given by @xmath135 the decoupling equation for determining the correlation operator @xmath136 becomes @xmath137 the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath138 in the @xmath97 space is then given by @xmath139 in the first - step procedure we solve the decoupling equation ( [ eq : dece1 ] ) by introducing some assumptions . as we take a sufficiently large number as @xmath140 , we may assume that the one - body potential of @xmath83 for a state in the @xmath101 space is negligible in comparison with the sum of the energies , @xmath141 . therefore , @xmath142 takes nonzero values only for states in the @xmath91 space , and we have @xmath143 the definitions of @xmath97 and @xmath92 in eq . ( [ eq : dtps ] ) allow us to divide a space of @xmath8 states written in relative and center - of - mass ( c.m . ) coordinates into the same subspaces @xmath97 and @xmath92 as @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 are the h.o . quantum numbers of relative and c.m . motions , respectively . the @xmath147 and @xmath148 denote , respectively , spin and angular momentum defined through @xmath149 . the isospin @xmath150 is omitted because @xmath150 takes a constant @xmath151 in the @xmath8 system . a @xmath7 state in the @xmath152 space in fig . 1 is also written by the product of the h.o . relative and c.m . states . the @xmath5 interaction @xmath153 in eq . ( [ eq : vbyn ] ) is not diagonal in the c.m . quantum numbers @xmath154 because the projection operators @xmath97 , @xmath155 and @xmath156 are not diagonal in @xmath154 . thus , the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath157 is not diagonal in @xmath154 . it has been shown , however , in the calculation of ordinary nuclei that @xmath154 non - diagonal elements of the @xmath13-matrix are generally small @xcite . therefore , we make an assumption that the @xmath154 non - diagonal matrix elements of @xmath157 can be neglected . the two - body eigenvalue equation ( [ eq : eige1 ] ) is solved for the relative motion with a fixed set of @xmath158 written by @xmath159 where we rewrite @xmath160 as @xmath161 the @xmath162 and @xmath163 are the kinetic energies of the @xmath5 relative and c.m . motions , respectively . the state @xmath164 expresses a superposition of the @xmath8 and @xmath7 h.o . states and gives a general form of the eigenstate when we consider the @xmath7-@xmath8 coupling and the @xmath12 interaction with the tensor and antisymmetric spin - orbit couplings . the @xmath165 is an additional quantum number specifying a two - body @xmath5 eigenstate . in general , the one - body part @xmath166 does not satisfies the assumption of decoupling in eq . ( [ eq : assume ] ) . however , it has been shown in the calculation in nuclei that if we take a larger number as @xmath167 , the effect of violating the assumption of decoupling becomes considerably smaller @xcite . we have confirmed that this non - decoupling effect becomes negligible in calculating nuclear effective interactions . we here assume this to be the case also in the determination of the @xmath8 effective interaction . furthermore , we introduce another approximation that the sum of @xmath168 and @xmath169 be diagonal in the c.m . quantum numbers @xmath170 and @xmath171 . this assumption has also been made sure to be acceptable in the previous works @xcite . in order to solve the eigenvalue equation ( [ eq : eige1r ] ) we need to calculate the matrix elements of @xmath172 in the relative and c.m . coordinates representation . however , the calculation of these matrix elements is difficult because the term @xmath172 can not be separated into a sum of operators written in relative and c.m . coordinates . therefore , as have made in the previous work @xcite , we employ the angle - average approximation and have @xmath173 where , as was assumed previously , @xmath174 for @xmath175 . the @xmath176 is the h.o . transformation bracket @xcite for the @xmath12 two - body state which depends on the rest masses for @xmath177 and @xmath33 . here the angle - average approximation means that , when a function @xmath178 is given with an angular momentum @xmath179 and its @xmath180-component @xmath181 , we approximate @xmath178 as @xmath182 . in the present case the matrix element on the left - hand side in eq . ( [ eq : uyn ] ) is dependent on the @xmath180-components @xmath183 and @xmath184 of @xmath148 and @xmath171 , respectively . the average over @xmath183 and @xmath184 leads to the expression given in eq . ( [ eq : uyn ] ) . this approximation is essentially the same as has been made to derive an angle - averaged pauli operator by wong and sauer @xcite . the use of the basis states @xmath185 makes it difficult to represent the operator @xmath155 , but it has been confirmed that the angle - average technique works well . we thus make an approximation to the operator @xmath155 as @xmath186 where the summation should be made on the conditions @xmath187 here the coefficient @xmath188 is defined as @xmath189 where in the summation the following conditions should be satisfied @xmath190 furthermore , we need an expression of @xmath191 given in eq . ( [ eq : qynd ] ) in the angle - average approximation @xmath192 where the summation should be made on the same conditions as in eq . ( [ eq : sumc1 ] ) . the coefficient @xmath193 is given by @xmath194 where @xmath195 and @xmath196 should satisfy the conditions given in eq . ( [ eq : sumc2 ] ) . once the set of the eigenstates @xmath197 in eq . ( [ eq : eige1r ] ) is solved , the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath198 acting in the @xmath97 space is given according to eqs . ( [ eq : evln])-([eq : nhevln ] ) by substituting @xmath199 , where @xmath200 is defined as latexmath:[\[\begin{aligned } \label{eq : oyn1 } \hspace{-5mm}\omega _ { \sst { \it yn}}^{\sst ( 1 ) } = \sum_{k_{1},ll'ss'j_{r},n_{c}l_{c } } \overline{q}_{\sst { \it yn}}^{\sst ( 1 ) } \langle \overline{{\it yn};k_{1},ll'ss'j_{r},n_{c}l_{c } } the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath157 thus determined , we calculate a new single - particle potential @xmath202 as an averaged matrix element of @xmath203 . the @xmath202 can be given explicitly in terms of the effective interaction @xmath157 as @xmath204 in the above treatment of the single - particle potential of @xmath32 in the first - step calculation , we do not consider the one - body spin - orbit splitting . the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath205 in eq . ( [ eq : tvln1 ] ) is dependent on the single - particle potential @xmath133 , and @xmath133 is determined with @xmath205 as in eq . ( [ eq : ul1 ] ) . therefore , the equation for determining @xmath205 and @xmath133 should be solved simultaneously . the model space @xmath91 in the first - step procedure is chosen as a _ low - momentum _ space , but the @xmath91 space is still large when we wish to use @xmath205 in the calculation of bound or low excited states of @xmath32 hypernuclei . with @xmath205 , we further proceed to the calculation of the @xmath8 effective interaction acting in a smaller model space and correspondingly the single - particle potential of @xmath32 in low - lying states . we separate the @xmath91 space into the @xmath206 , @xmath207 , @xmath208 and @xmath209 spaces specified by the numbers @xmath140 , @xmath106 , and @xmath210 as shown in fig . 2 . the number @xmath211 is introduced to specify the uppermost bound state of @xmath32 . here these spaces are defined as @xmath212 the @xmath213 space is the excluded space due to the pauli principle for nucleons . we are principally interested in the @xmath8 effective interaction that gives a description of the bound states of @xmath83 . it would be desirable that such a @xmath8 effective interaction satisfies the condition of decoupling between two @xmath8 states consisting of the bound and unbound states of @xmath83 . this requirement is equivalent to the situation that the @xmath8 effective interactions should be decoupled between two @xmath8 states in the @xmath214 and @xmath209 spaces . therefore , we solve the decoupling equation for @xmath215 between the @xmath8 states in the @xmath214 and @xmath209 spaces . the space @xmath208 is not a space to be excluded due to the pauli principle . however , some states in the @xmath208 and @xmath214 spaces overlap each other in energy . therefore , we treat separately the effect of the coupling between the @xmath208 and @xmath214 spaces . actually the interaction between states in the @xmath208 and @xmath214 spaces induces the core polarization in the core nucleus , as discussed in refs . @xcite and @xcite . we take into account the effect of the core polarization in the usual perturbative calculation . = 6 cm in the second - step calculation the unitarily transformed interaction is given by @xmath216 where @xmath217 the term @xmath218 is the self - consistent potential of @xmath32 to be determined in the second - step procedure . the decoupling equation for determining the correlation operator @xmath219 in eq . ( [ eq : tvyn2 ] ) becomes @xmath220 we note here that the assumption of decoupling @xmath221 is satisfied exactly because the two two - body states in the @xmath214 and @xmath209 spaces do not contain a common single - particle state of @xmath83 or @xmath19 . the two - body eigenvalue equation to be solved in the second - step calculation is written as @xmath222 where @xmath223 denotes the total angular momentum , and @xmath224 a set of quantum numbers of a @xmath8 two - body eigenstate . it should be noted that this eigenvalue equation can be solved exactly in the @xmath225 space by the diagonalization of the hamiltonian written with the basis states @xmath226 if the @xmath227 space is chosen suitably as a small space . once a set of the eigenstates @xmath228 in eq . ( [ eq : eige2 ] ) is solved , the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath229 in the @xmath214 space is given from eqs . ( [ eq : evln])-([eq : nhevln ] ) with @xmath230 defined by @xmath231 is calculated with the @xmath8 effective interactions , @xmath229 and @xmath157 , as @xmath232 we solve the set of equations for determining @xmath229 and @xmath233 iteratively until the result converges . we remark here that we employ @xmath157 as the effective interaction in the @xmath213 space in the calculation of @xmath233 . since the effective interaction in the @xmath213 space is unchanged in the transformation made in the second - step procedure , we may write the @xmath8 effective interaction in the @xmath213 space as @xmath234 . we , therefore , have used partly the @xmath87 effective interaction @xmath157 in the calculation of @xmath233 as in eq . ( [ eq : ul2 ] ) . first we note that the one - body hamiltonian @xmath235 in eq . ( [ eq : hln2 ] ) has non - diagonal terms because we did not make the hartree - fock calculation . these terms could bring about sizable corrections to the single - particle energies of @xmath236 . we adopt the same h.o . energy both for @xmath83 and @xmath19 , though it has been considered that the wave function of @xmath83 is basically different from that of @xmath237 . therefore , we must evaluate the corrections arising from the non - diagonal terms of @xmath235 . by taking the diagonal part of @xmath235 as the unperturbed hamiltonian we calculate these corrections perturbatively up to second order as shown in diagram ( a ) of fig . 3 . next , the interaction between the @xmath8 states in the @xmath214 and @xmath208 spaces induces the core polarization in the core nucleus , and is important in the calculation of the corrections . we here assume that these corrections can be calculated approximately , using the interaction @xmath238 it will be desirable to take into account the effect of intermediate nucleon states with high momentum . in this perturbative calculation we include only the nucleon states belonging to the @xmath208 space , that is , the nucleon h.o . state should satisfy @xmath239 , where @xmath240 are the h.o . quantum numbers of a @xmath83 state . the validity of this truncation of nucleon states will be checked in the numerical calculation in the next section by increasing the number @xmath241 . the diagrams corresponding these corrections are given in diagram ( b ) and ( c ) of fig . we performed calculations employing the jlich model - ( j ) , model - b ( jb ) @xcite potentials in the momentum - space representation made by b. holzenkamp and a. reuber . ] and nijmegen soft - core ( nsc ) @xcite potentials for the _ yn _ interaction . we used the h.o . basis states with a common @xmath242mev for @xmath32 , @xmath33 and @xmath19 . the dependence of the effective interaction and single - particle energies on the value @xmath100 has been already discussed in @xmath15o @xcite and we confirmed that the dependence was quite small around @xmath243mev if perturbation corrections were included . as for the nucleon single - particle potential @xmath244 , we used the fixed data @xcite calculated using the paris potential @xcite , and we have assumed that @xmath245 . the boundary numbers @xmath246 , @xmath247 and @xmath109 are taken as @xmath248 , @xmath249 and @xmath250 for @xmath0o . = 13.8 cm we present , in fig . 4 , the @xmath93 dependence of the single - particle energies of @xmath32 including the perturbation corrections shown in fig . 3 . the parameter @xmath93 specifies the @xmath91 space in which the @xmath8 effective interaction @xmath229 is determined rigorously without any approximation as discussed in sec . 3 . therefore , as @xmath140 becomes larger , the calculated result does more accurate . if the result converges at a certain number @xmath251 , we may say that the method of the two - step calculation of the @xmath8 effective interaction would be trustworthy . as shown in fig . 4 , the results are convergent and stable for @xmath252 for each @xmath12 potential . if we take @xmath93 larger than 6 , our model space is considered to be sufficiently large . we note that the model space with @xmath253 corresponds to that used in the @xmath13-matrix calculations made by halderson @xcite and by hao and kuo @xcite . .dependence of typical diagonal matrix elements @xmath254 on @xmath255 in units of mev , where @xmath256 and @xmath257 denote the @xmath32 and @xmath19 single - particle orbits , respectively , labeled as @xmath258 , @xmath259 and @xmath260 , and @xmath223 is the total angular momentum . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] next , the partial - wave contributions to the first - order potential energy of @xmath32 in the 0@xmath1 state are given for the different treatments of the pauli - blocking effect . we see from table 4 that the contributions of the @xmath261 and @xmath262-@xmath263 channels are very different dependently on the @xmath5 interactions employed . in the @xmath261 channel the largest pauli - blocking effect is brought about in the result for the j potential . on the other hand , in the @xmath262-@xmath263 channel we have an extremely large pauli - blocking effect for the nsc potential . this result shows that the nsc potential has the strong @xmath7-@xmath8 coupling in the @xmath262-@xmath263 channel as discussed in ref . the absolute values contributing to the first - order potential energy of @xmath32 in the channels with angular momenta @xmath264 are much smaller than those in the @xmath261 and @xmath262-@xmath263 channels . in table 5 we display the single - particle energies of @xmath32 with the contributions of the perturbation corrections given in fig . 3 , where the pauli - blocking effect is treated accordingly to case ( 3 ) . from this table we see that the j and nsc potentials yield almost the same values of the first - order potential energy pe and the perturbation corrections in spite of having different partial - wave contributions as shown in table 4 . the single - particle energies obtained for the jb potential are most attractive among the @xmath265 interactions used . it should be noted here that the values of the ke plus pe in the 0@xmath266 states for three kinds of @xmath5 interactions are positive ( unbound ) . therefore , the perturbation corrections play a decisive role when we argue that the @xmath32 in the 0@xmath266 states is bound or not . correction ( a ) in fig . 3 is induced by the presence of non - diagonal terms in the one - body hamiltonian @xmath267 . this effect should be treated in the hartree - fock ( hf ) calculation . however , in the present calculation , we treat this effect perturbatively . these non - diagonal terms work to change the single - particle wave function of @xmath32 . therefore , this procedure is indispensable in this approach since we have taken a fixed value of @xmath100 commonly for @xmath32 and @xmath19 . this correction ( a ) contributes most attractively to the single - particle energies among all the corrections in fig . the magnitude of every correction is considerably small in comparison with the first - order potential energies for all the @xmath5 interactions used . all the perturbation corrections contribute , however , attractively to the single - particle energies of @xmath32 , and do not change the mutual spacings of the single - particle states significantly . this trend is very different from the situation observed in ordinary nuclei such as @xmath15o and @xmath16ca , in which the correction terms contribute to about 40@xmath268 of the calculated spin - orbit splitting of the 0@xmath266 or 0@xmath269 states @xcite . the role of many - body correlations , such as the core polarization , does not seem to be important in the spin - orbit splitting of @xmath32 . we have presented a formulation of the umoa to apply it to a structure calculation of hypernuclei . we have introduced a unitary transformation exp(@xmath270 ) , with the correlation operator @xmath270 , that describes two - body correlation of hyperon and nucleon . an equation has been given for determining the correlation operator @xmath270 as the equation of decoupling so that the unitarily transformed interaction does not have non - zero matrix elements between the model space @xmath88 of low - lying @xmath8 states and its complement @xmath85 . the effective interaction has been given by the projected interaction onto the @xmath88 space . the effective interaction thus determined has properties of being hermitian , energy - independent and decoupled between the @xmath88 and @xmath85 spaces . in comparison with the usual @xmath13-matrix approach , the use of such an effective interaction would have some advantages in describing many - body systems . the umoa has been applied to the calculation of the structure of @xmath0o . the @xmath8 effective interaction has been calculated by employing three @xmath12 potentials , namely , the j , jb and nsc potentials . with the @xmath8 effective interaction , we have calculated the single - particle energies of @xmath32 in the 0@xmath1 , 0@xmath2 and 0@xmath3 states . we have seen that how to treat the pauli - blocking effect is very important , especially when we solve the problem of the @xmath7-@xmath8 coupling . in the usual treatment one excludes all the interactions acting in a space of @xmath271 and @xmath272 states in which a nucleon is in occupied states . however , this treatment of the pauli - blocking effect would lead to overmuch counting . we have introduced a new treatment in which , while we exclude the interactions acting among forbidden @xmath5 states as in the usual treatment , we restore the interactions that are diagonal in occupied nucleon states . we have observed that this treatment of the pauli - blocking effect has given rise to a significant effect as compared with the usual treatment . the present results have shown that @xmath32 in the 0@xmath3 state is unbound for the j and nsc potentials and , on the other hand , bound for the jb potential . the spin - orbit splitting of the single - particle levels of @xmath83 in the 0@xmath266 states has been given by 1.41 , 1.57 and 1.66 for the j , jb and nsc potentials , respectively . these values are very large compared with the results in ref . it will be of high interest for the single - particle nature of @xmath32 in @xmath0o to be established experimentally . in the application of the umoa some problems have still remained . the unitarily transformed hamiltonian @xcite contains originally three - or - more - body interactions . the effects of these many - body interactions have been evaluated in the previous works of calculating nuclear properties , and we have concluded that the contributions of these many - body terms are much smaller than those of two - body interactions but sizable in some cases . we therefore should estimate the effects of these many - body interactions also in hypernuclei . another refinement to be made is that , in the present calculation , the single - particle energies of @xmath33 in intermediate states are neglected . however , the single - particle spectrum of @xmath33 has a possibility of giving rise to some contributions to the @xmath8 effective interaction . although the properties of the single - particle energies of @xmath33 have not always been made clear , we should investigate how much the spectrum of @xmath33 affects in the determination of the @xmath8 effective interaction . this problem is also a remaining task in the umoa . the authors would like to thank y. yamamoto and k. miyagawa for useful discussions and their help for using the nijmegen and jlich @xmath265 potential codes . one of the authors ( s. f. ) would like to express his thank to k. takada , m. kamimura and y. r. shimizu for their continuous encouragement and instructive discussions . a. gal , advances in nuclear physics , vol . 8 , eds . m. baranger and e. vogt ( plenum , new york , 1975 ) p. 1 . b. povh , ann . nuc . part . 28 ( 1978 ) 1 . h. band et al . , prog . 81 ( 1985 ) . h. band , t. motoba and j. @xmath273ofka , int . j. mod . a 5 ( 1990 ) 4021 , and references therein . t. motoba , y. akaishi and k. ikeda , prog . 117 ( 1994 ) . b. f. gibson and e. v. hungerford iii , phys . 257 ( 1995 ) 349 . b. f. gibson , i. r. afnan , j. a. carlson and d. r. lehman , prog . 117 ( 1994 ) 339 . w. brckner et al . , phys . . 79 b ( 1976 ) 157 . r. h. dalitz , d. h. davis , t. motoba and d. n. tovee , nucl . phys . a 625 ( 1997 ) 71 . k. miyagawa , and w. glckle , phys . rev . c 48 ( 1993 ) 2576 ; + k. miyagawa , h. kamada , w. glckle and v. stoks , phys . rev . c 51 ( 1995 ) 2905 . t. yamada , h. ohkura , t. motoba and k. ikeda , prog . 117 ( 1994 ) 65 . e. hiyama , m. kamimura , t. motoba , t. yamada and y. yamamoto , prog . 97 ( 1997 ) 881 . h. band and y. yamamoto , prog . theor . phys . 81 ( 1985 ) 9 . y. yamamoto , t. motoba , h. himeno , k. ikeda and s. nagata , prog . 117 ( 1994 ) 361 . h. band , prog . 66 ( 1981 ) 1349 . d. halderson , phys . rev . c 48 ( 1993 ) 581 . j. hao , t. t. s. kuo , a. reuber , k. holinde , j. speth and d. j. millener , phys . 71 ( 1993 ) 1498 ; + t. t. s. kuo and j. hao , prog . 117 ( 1994 ) 351 . m. hjorth - jensen , a. polls , a. ramos and h. mther , nucl . phys . a 605 ( 1996 ) 458 . i. vidaa , a. polls , a. ramos and m. hjorth - jensen , nucl . phys . a 644 ( 1998 ) 201 . t. t. s. kuo and e. osnes , in : folded - diagram theory of the effective interaction in nuclei , atoms and molecules , lecture notes in physics , vol . 264 , ( springer , berlin , 1990 ) . j. hao and t. t. s. kuo , phys . 264 ( 1996 ) 233 . k. suzuki , r. okamoto and h. kumagai , phys . c 36 ( 1987 ) 804 ; + k. suzuki and r. okamoto , prog . theor . ( 1994 ) 1045 . h. kumagai , k. suzuki and r. okamoto , prog . 97 ( 1997 ) 1023 . s. fujii , r. okamoto and k. suzuki , prog . 99 ( 1998 ) 151 . m. m. nagels , t. a. rijken and j. j. de swart , phys . rev . d 15 ( 1977 ) 2547 ; + p. m. m. maessen , t. a. rijken and j. j. de swart , phys . c 40 ( 1989 ) 2226 . b. holzenkamp , k. holinde and j. speth , nucl . phys . a 500 ( 1989 ) 485 ; + a. reuber , k. holinde and j. speth , nucl . phys . a 570 ( 1994 ) 543 . m. lacombe , b. loiseau , j. m. richard , r. vinh mau , j. ct , p. pirs and r. de tourreil , phys . c 21 ( 1980 ) 861 . b. h. brandow , in : effective interactions and operators in nuclei , lecture notes in physics , vol . 40 , ed . b. r. barrett ( springer , berlin , 1975 ) p. 1 . i. shavitt and l. t. redmon , j. chem . 73 ( 1980 ) 5711 . p. westhaus , int . j. quantum chem . 20 ( 1981 ) 1243 . k. suzuki , prog . 68 ( 1982 ) 246 . t. t. s. kuo , p. j. ellis , j. hao , z. li , k. suzuki , r. okamoto and h. kumagai , nucl . phys . a 560 ( 1993 ) 621 . y. yamamoto and h. band , prog . 83 ( 1990 ) 254 . schulze , a. lejeune , j. cugnon , m. baldo and u. lombardo , phys . b 355 ( 1995 ) 21 ; phys . c 57 ( 1998 ) 704 . k. suzuki and r. okamoto , prog . 76 ( 1986 ) 127 . e. m. krenciglowa , c. l. kung , t. t. s. kuo and e. osnes , ann . of phys . 101 ( 1976 ) 154 . b. buck and a. c. merchant , nucl . a 600 ( 1996 ) 387 . c. w. wong , nucl . phys . a 91 ( 1967 ) 399 . p. u. sauer , nucl . phys . a 150 ( 1970 ) 467 .
Abstract: | [
"a method is formulated for the description of lambda hypernuclei in the framework of the unitary - model - operator approach ( umoa ) . the method is applied to @xmath0o . a lambda - nucleon effective interaction is derived , taking the coupling of the sigma - nucleon channel into account . the lambda single - particle energies are calculated for the 0@xmath1 , 0@xmath2 and 0@xmath3 states employing the nijmegen soft - core ( nsc ) , jlich model - ( j ) and model - b ( jb ) hyperon - nucleon potentials . unitary model operator approach ; hypernuclei ; lambda single particle energy ; effective interaction ; nijmegen potential ; jlich potential"
] | 7,965 | 7,965 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: gas cooling plays a key role in galaxy formation . according to the hierarchical structure formation model , galaxies form in gravitationally collapsed dark matter halos . the dissipative baryonic matter cools by emitting radiation and condenses into halos to form galaxies @xcite . subsequently stars form through the radiative cooling of interstellar medium ( ism ; e.g. , * ? ? ? the cooling rate of gas varies with its chemical abundance , because different atoms and molecules have different cooling rates . the chemical abundance of cosmic gas evolves as a function of time and environment . in the early universe , the primordial gas consists of mainly hydrogen ( mass fraction of @xmath3 ) and helium ( mass fraction of @xmath4 ) with a negligible amount of light metals ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ) . throughout this paper , all the elements heavier than helium are collectively called ` metals ' . most metals are produced inside stars and spread out to the space by galactic winds driven by supernova ( sn ) explosions . in the metal - enriched gas , the total cooling rate is significantly enhanced relative to that of the primordial gas by the atomic emission lines from recombination of ionised metals . metals may influence galaxy formation in two different ways . firstly , the sf efficiency is increased owing to the shorter gas cooling time . star formation generally takes place in dusty metal - enriched ism , therefore , the enhanced cooling rate by metals would boost up the sf efficiency . however , the energy / momentum feedback by sne may suppress the subsequent star formation after the initial starburst by heating up the ambient gas . this complicates the situation , and it is not clear whether the net effect of metal cooling and sn feedback would be negative or positive . the feedback process is highly nonlinear , therefore , a direct numerical simulation would be a useful tool to explore the effects of feedback and metal cooling . secondly , the metals dispersed into the igm by sn feedback also enhance the cooling of igm . this can lead to the increase of igm accretion onto galaxies , because colder gas can sink into galaxies more easily . both of the above two effects may affect the galaxy growth and cosmic sf history significantly . therefore it is essential to include the effects of metal cooling and chemical enrichment by feedback in the studies of galaxy formation and evolution , and capture the complex two - way interactions between galaxies and igm . in addition , metal enrichment also affects the equation of state by altering the mean molecular weight of gas , which influences the hydrodynamic calculation of gas thermal state . cosmological hydrodynamic simulations are widely used in the studies of galaxy formation and cosmic sf history ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? most of these works included the treatments of radiative cooling by h & he , star formation , and sn feedback . however , some of the simulations did not include the effects of metal cooling and/or chemical enrichment by galactic wind . furthermore , the effects of metal cooling on galaxy growth and cosmic sf history has not been explored in detail using cosmological hydrodynamic simulations and presented in the literature , as it is costly to run large cosmological simulations with and without the effect of metal cooling . in this paper , we investigate the effects of metal cooling and metal enrichment on galaxy growth and cosmic sf history using a series of cosmological hydrodynamic simulations with and without metal cooling . the aim of this paper is to single out the effects of metal cooling among our simulations . this work can be regarded as our initial step towards the long - term goal of developing more complete cosmological hydrodynamic code with physically motivated models of star formation and feedback . the paper is organised as follows . in [ sec : method ] , we describe our simulation method focusing on how we implement the metal cooling . in [ sec : global ] , we study the metal cooling effects on the global properties , such as cosmic sfr , phase space ( @xmath5 vs. @xmath6 ) distribution of gas , and the evolution of four phases ( hot , warm - hot , diffuse , and condensed ) of baryons . we then study the galaxy mass functions ( [ sec : mf ] ) and gas mass fractions ( [ sec : gasfrac ] ) . finally , we discuss and summarise our findings in [ sec : summary ] . we use the updated version of the tree - particle - mesh ( treepm ) smoothed particle hydrodynamics ( sph ) code gadget-2 @xcite for our cosmological simulations . the gravitational dynamics is computed by a treepm algorithm , which uses a particle - mesh method @xcite for the long - range gravitational force and a tree method for the short - range gravitational force @xcite . this hybrid algorithm makes the gravitational force calculation faster than a tree method and allows better force resolution than a pm method in dense regions . the gas dynamics is computed by an sph method . the sph is particularly useful if the simulation needs to resolve large dynamical range , which is an inevitable requirement for the study of galaxy formation in a cosmological context . therefore a treepm - sph simulation can provide a fast and high resolution calculation for both gravitational dynamics and hydrodynamics . the gadget-2 code adopts the entropy - conservative formulation @xcite , which alleviates the overcooling problem that previous sph codes suffered from . our basic simulations include radiative cooling and heating processes for hydrogen and helium using a method similar to @xcite . an external uv background radiation is treated as a spatially uniform photoionising radiation @xcite , and modified to match the ly@xmath7 forest observations @xcite . implementing star formation and feedback from first principles is not feasible in current cosmological simulations , because the spatial & mass - scales of molecular clouds are not resolved . star formation and sn feedback are represented by the subgrid multiphase ism model developed by @xcite . in the multiphase scheme , a single gas particle represents both hot and cold gas . the stars are formed in the cold portion when the density exceeds a given threshold , @xmath8 , which is derived self - consistently within the multiphase ism model . the related parameters , such as the normalisation of gas consumption time and evaporation efficiency of cold gas , are set to satisfy the empirical kennicutt - schmidt law @xcite . the sn feedback returns some fraction of the cold gas to the hot phase , and increases the thermal energy of the hot gas . as an extension to the multiphase ism model , the simulation includes a phenomenological model for sn - driven galactic wind @xcite . the galactic wind is particularly important for distributing the metals produced by sne into the igm . we use the strong kinematic wind with a velocity of 484kms@xmath9 . it has been shown that this model produces favourable results for the luminosity function of lyman - break galaxies at the bright - end @xcite and the hi column density distribution function @xcite at @xmath1 , when compared to the runs without the wind . however , @xcite pointed out the problems of this galactic wind model by comparing with the observations of civ absorption lines in quasar spectra , and suggested that the momentum - driven wind model @xcite is a more viable model , which can carry more metals with lower wind velocities . in this paper we choose not to modify our galactic wind model in order to single out the effects of metal cooling , and to allow direct comparisons to the previous works @xcite . here we focus on the effects of metal cooling on galaxy growth , while @xcite focused on the civ statistics of the igm . the metallicity of gas particles are also tracked by the code , assuming a closed box model for each gas particle . the yield ( @xmath10 ) of 0.02 is assumed . in principle , there could be a time delay between sn explosions and chemical enrichment of the ambient gas . unfortunately , current cosmological simulations do not have sufficient resolution to track the detailed mixing process of metals . in our simulations , we ignore this time delay and assume an instantaneous mixing within each gas particle . this assumption is reasonable , because the overall time step of the simulations is longer than the mixing time - scale on small scales . ideally we would like to track individual metals and compute the cooling rate of each element at each time - step of the simulation . this approach has been used to study the evolution of individual galaxies @xcite . for cosmological simulations , it requires a large memory to track individual metals and the computation becomes exceedingly expensive ( but see * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * for such an attempts ) . our simulations collectively track the total mass fraction of metals ( @xmath11 ) as the measure of metallicity . we obtain the chemical abundance and cooling rates for a given @xmath12 and temperature by interpolating the table given in ( * ? ? ? * hereafter sd93 ) for the standard collisional ionisation equilibrium model , and create a lookup table . metal cooling is implemented in the full range of metallicity in the table from sd93 , from [ fe / h]=-3 to [ fe / h]=1 . in addition , the metal cooling outside of this range is computed by extrapolating the table . we require that the extrapolation does not go lower than the primordial cooling rate . the primordial abundance pattern is used where [ fe / h ] @xmath13 @xcite , and the solar abundance pattern is used where [ fe / h ] @xmath14 @xcite . for @xmath15 [ fe / h ] @xmath16 , the abundance pattern is computed by interpolating between the primordial and solar abundance patterns . note that , [ fe / h ] = @xmath17 - @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the number density . figure [ fig : xyz_table ] shows the relationships between the metal parameters ( [ fe / h ] , @xmath20 , @xmath21 , and @xmath22 ) and the total metallicity @xmath12 . because the abundance pattern is fixed for a given @xmath12 , [ fe / h ] is a monotonically increasing function of @xmath12 . the main difference between the solar and the primordial abundance pattern is the oxygen or @xmath7-particle enhancement . in the early phase of metal enrichment , type ii sne are the main source of metals and they tend to generate more @xmath7-particles than sn ia . therefore , it is expected that a low metallicity gas to have more @xmath7-particles than the high metallicity one . as mentioned above , we use two different chemical abundance pattern ( at low- and high - end of the @xmath12 values ) to model this evolution in chemical composition . we compute the oxygen abundance based on the table 4 of sd93 . in our code , we incorporate the metal cooling effect by adding the additional cooling contribution from metals on top of the primordial cooling rate , which is computed in a similar fashion as described in @xcite . metal enrichment changes the mean molecular weight @xmath23 , which is needed to compute the temperature and internal energy of gas . in order to compute @xmath23 , we need to know the electron number density @xmath24 , which varies with metallicity . we obtain the values of @xmath24 from sd93 in the same way as we obtained the metal cooling rates . our electron number density estimate ignores the electrons from photoionised metals by the uv background radiation , but we expect that the number of electrons from ionised metals will be small . varying the mean molecular weight @xmath23 also influences the sf threshold density @xmath8 in the multiphase ism model of @xcite , as well as the cold and hot gas fractions of multiphase gas particles . in this paper , we consider two different treatments of @xmath8 . in the ` constant @xmath8 ' model , we take the value of @xmath8 as in the original formulation by @xcite and do not modulate @xmath8 by the varying @xmath23 . in the ` varying @xmath8 ' model , we take into account of the modulation of @xmath8 by the change in @xmath23 . we use three series of simulations with varying box size and resolution . the effects of metal enrichment and metal cooling are tested by comparing the runs listed in table [ tbl : simulation ] . the effects of galactic wind are also tested by turning on and off the wind . the adopted cosmological parameters of all simulations are @xmath25 , which mostly concur with the results of the wilkinson microwave anisotropy probe ( wmap1 ) @xcite . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^,<,^",options="header " , ] our naming conventions for the simulations are as follows . the first part of the run name denotes the particle number and box size used for the simulation series . the run with the extension of ` mc ' ( for ` metal cooling ' ) adopts the ` constant @xmath8 ' model for metal cooling , the run with the extension ` mv ' ( for ` metal , varying ' ) adopts the ` varying @xmath8 ' model , the run with the extension ` nw ' has no galactic wind , and the run without any extension uses the cooling rates for the primordial chemical composition ( i.e. , only h and he ) . the ` n216l10 ' series is the fiducial simulation set in our study . we implement one simulation without galactic wind ( ` n216l10nw ' run ) . the ` n216l10 ' run has the same physical models as the ` q4 ' run used in @xcite and @xcite with no metal cooling . to examine the resolution effect , we implement lower resolution simulations , the ` n144l10 ' series . owing to the comparably small box size and missing long wavelength perturbations , we evolve the n144l10 and n216l10 series only down to @xmath26 . to evolve the simulation toward lower redshifts , we need a simulation with a larger box size . therefore we implement the ` n288l34 ' series , which has a larger box size than other series , but a lower resolution . this series is evolved down to @xmath0 . the runs within the same series use the identical initial condition , which makes the comparison more robust and enables halo - by - halo comparison if needed . in cosmological simulations , dark matter , gas , and stars are represented by particles , and these particles are monte carlo representations of matter distribution . in order to study galaxy formation using a cosmological simulation , we need a working definition for simulated galaxies . in this paper the simulated galaxies are defined as isolated groups of star and gas particles , identified by a simplified variant of the algorithm developed by @xcite . in more detail , the code first computes a smoothed baryonic density field to identify candidate galaxies with high density peaks . the full extent of these groups are found by adding gas and star particles to the groups in the order of declining density . if all @xmath27 is the minimum number of gas and star particles that constitute one isolated group . in this paper we set @xmath28 . ] nearest neighbour particles have lower densities , this group of particles is considered as a new group . if there is a denser neighbour , the particle is attached to the group to which its nearest denser neighbour already belongs to . if two nearest neighbours belong to different groups and one of them has less than @xmath27 particles , these the two groups are merged . if two nearest neighbours belong to different groups and both of them has more than @xmath27 particles , the particles are attached to the larger group , leaving the other group intact . in addition , the gas particles in groups should be denser than @xmath29 . in this paper we are not concerned with groups without star particles . the fraction of such groups are very small , therefore they do not affect our conclusions . % by metal cooling throughout the entire redshift range . ] , but for the n288l34 series , which goes down to @xmath0 . the n216l10mc run is also shown for a resolution comparison . the green dot - dashed line ( hs03 ) is for the analytic model of ( * ? ? ? * eq.(2 ) ) . ] figure [ fig : sfr_n216l10 ] shows the effect of metal cooling and galactic wind on the cosmic sf history for the n216l10 series . the comparison of n216l10mc and n216l10 runs clearly shows that metal cooling enhances the cosmic sfr throughout all redshifts by @xmath30% . previously , ( * ? ? ? 13 ) argued that the sfr density is enhanced by metal cooling mostly at lower redshifts and hardly at high-@xmath31 , however , our simulations suggest otherwise . ( see [ sec : summary ] for more discussion on this point . ) metallicity needs to be higher than @xmath32 to noticeably increase the gas cooling rate , because the metal cooling rate is much smaller than that by h and he at @xmath33 . the metallicity of diffuse igm is generally lower than @xmath34 at @xmath35 , and the metal cooling effect on igm is small . however the local sfr could be enhanced significantly even at high-@xmath31 when the ism is enriched to @xmath36 , which can be easily achieved after a few events of sn ii . our results suggest that star formation at high-@xmath31 can also be enhanced by metal cooling , and not just at low-@xmath31 . we also find that the peak of the cosmic sf history hardly shifts by the introduction of metal cooling , consistently with the estimate by @xcite . the n216l10mv run has a lower sfr at @xmath37 and a higher sfr at @xmath38 than the n216l10mc run . this is because at high-@xmath31 , the value of @xmath8 is higher in the ` mv ' run than in the ` mc ' run due to lower metallicity and mean molecular weight , leading to a larger fraction of gas not being able to satisfy the sf criteria in the n216l10mv run than in the n216l10mc . the opposite is true at @xmath39 . figure [ fig : sfr_n216l10 ] also shows that the sfr in the n216l10nw run is higher than other runs by an order of magnitude . this is because the gas can cool very efficiently without being ejected by the galactic wind . although the current galactic wind models in cosmological simulations are not well established yet and need to be improved , both theoretical and observational studies evidently suggest the important role of galactic wind feedback @xcite . as expected , the n144l10mc run has lower sfr densities at @xmath40 compared to the n216l10 series . this is because a lower resolution run is unable to resolve low - mass halos that would otherwise forms stars in them . when the star formation at high-@xmath31 is underestimated , some of the gas remain unconverted into stars until lower redshift , resulting in a higher sfr at @xmath41 in the n144l10mc run than in the n216l10mc run . figure [ fig : sfr_n288l34 ] shows the cosmic sf history down to @xmath0 for the n288l34 series . again , the sfr density in the n288l34mc run is systematically higher than that in the n288l34 run at all redshifts . moreover , the difference in sfr density between the two runs increases at @xmath39 . by @xmath42 the igm metallicity becomes high enough to noticeably increase the cooling rate , and the accretion of igm onto galaxies becomes more efficient , which later fuels the star formation . our results suggest that the cosmic sfr density is enhanced by metal cooling at @xmath43 by both of the following two effects : 1 ) more efficient igm accretion onto galaxies due to higher metallicity of igm , and 2 ) increased sf efficiency due to higher cooling rate with the contribution from metal cooling . in figure [ fig : sfr_n288l34 ] the analytic model of ( * ? ? ? * eq.(2 ) , hereafter h&s model ) is also shown in the green dot - dashed line . this model is a result of many cosmological sph simulations with increasing resolution , and the authors gave a theoretical interpretation to the empirical fitting formula for the cosmic sfr density . since our runs adopt a lower value of @xmath44 than the original value used to derive the h&s model ( @xmath45 ) , we modify the h&s model by rescaling the @xmath46 parameter in their eq.(2 ) and eq.(47 ) . this reduces the sfr density at @xmath47 by @xmath48% , but not much at @xmath49 . the results of the n288l34 and n216l10mc runs agree well with the h&s model at @xmath41 and @xmath50 , respectively . this is expected , because the n288l34 run adopts the same physical models as in the original simulations that were used to derive the h&s model . at high-@xmath31 , both runs fall short compared to the h&s model owing to insufficient resolution . the metal enrichment and metal cooling also change the phase space distribution ( @xmath51 diagram ) of cosmic gas . figure [ fig : phase.n216l10 ] shows the state of cosmic gas at @xmath1 for the n216l10 series . as shown in panel ( @xmath52 ) , the baryons in the universe can be broadly categorised into four different phases according to their overdensity and temperature : ` hot ' , ` warm - hot ' , ` diffuse ' , and ` condensed ' @xcite . the first two phases are mostly the shock - heated gas in clusters and groups of galaxies . the ` diffuse ' phase is mostly the photoionised igm with lower temperature , which can be observed as the ly@xmath7 forest . the tight power - law relationship between @xmath5 and @xmath6 at @xmath53 and @xmath54k is governed by the ionisation equilibrium @xcite , where @xmath55 is the mean density of baryons at @xmath56 . the ` condensed ' phase is the high density , cold gas in galaxies . because the primordial cooling curve has a sharp cutoff at @xmath57k , the temperature of condensed phase decreases only down to this temperature in figure [ fig : phase.n216l10]a , b . the characteristic finger - like feature at @xmath58 is due to the pressurisation of the star - forming gas by sn feedback in the multiphase ism model of @xcite . a fitting formula for this effective equation of state was derived by @xcite , which is shown by the blue dashed lines . above the sf threshold density @xmath8 , the gas particles in the simulation go into the multiphase mode and are allowed to form stars . the most noticeable and interesting change in the @xmath51 plot by the metal cooling is in the distribution of ` condensed ' gas . star formation and sn explosions occur in the multiphase star - forming gas , therefore the immediate effect of metal cooling appears in the condensed phase . the presence of gas at @xmath59k with metal cooling results from the effective temperature calculation for the multiphase medium , and not from the direct gas cooling down to @xmath59k . according to the multiphase scheme in @xcite , the star forming gas consists of two phases : hot gas ( @xmath60k @xmath61 @xmath62k ) and cold gas ( @xmath63k ) . the effective temperature for the multiphase gas is computed from the internal energy of hot and cold gases , which are derived using the cold gas fraction . the cold gas fraction is computed from the cooling rate of hot gas and the gas density . the original gadget imposes the effective temperature of @xmath64k at the sf threshold density . in our metal cooling scheme , however , the cooling rate of hot gas increases , and the cold gas fraction increases . therefore , the multiphase gas above the sf threshold density with higher metallicity could have lower effective temperature of @xmath59k in our implementation . in the n216l10mc run , the value of @xmath8 was kept fixed as the original value , which causes a sharp edge at @xmath65 for the multiphase gas . in the n216l10mv run , the value of @xmath8 was varied according to the change in mean molecular weight , therefore the condensed gas has a spread in both temperature and density near @xmath65 . galactic wind returns the metal - enriched , star - forming gas to the hot and low density igm , as evidenced in the @xmath66 diagrams . this metal - enriched , low - density ( @xmath67 ) gas is absent in the n216l10nw run , which clearly shows the necessity of galactic wind to explain the metallicity observed in ly@xmath7 forest . the phase distribution of igm in the n216l10 , n216l10mc , and n216l10mv runs are very similar . this is presumably because the effects of metal cooling is not so significant yet in the igm at @xmath68 . as we will discuss in the next section , this is not be the case at @xmath2 . the connection between the four phases of cosmic gas is important in galaxy formation , and it is beneficial for us to study their evolution for a better understanding of metal cooling effects . a conventional view is that the diffuse gas is shock - heated to hot or warm - hot phase , which later cools down to the condensed phase @xcite . @xcite also suggested that some diffuse gas can migrate to the condensed phase without being shock - heated , which they called the ` cold mode ' accretion . figure [ fig : evolv4 ] shows the evolution of mass fractions of different phases . all of our simulations show that the diffuse phase continuously decreases from high-@xmath31 to low-@xmath31 , while the ` warm - hot + hot ' and ` condensed ' phases continuously increase , consistently with the general expectations . the igm ( i.e. , hot + warm - hot + diffuse ) is accreted onto galaxies , to become the condensed phase . the diffuse component ( panel @xmath52 ) decreases from @xmath69% at @xmath70 to @xmath71% at @xmath0 . the ` warm - hot + hot ' component ( panel @xmath72 ) increases from almost zero at @xmath70 to @xmath73% at @xmath0 . the mass fraction of the total igm ( panel @xmath74 ) decreases from @xmath75% at @xmath70 to @xmath76% at @xmath1 . this reflects the increase of the condensed phase ( panel @xmath77 ) from a few percent at @xmath70 to @xmath78% at @xmath1 . these mass fractions are in general agreement with the results of @xcite . the comparison between n288l34 and n288l34mc runs shows interesting differences . at @xmath68 , the mass fractions of all four phases are similar in the two runs . however , at @xmath2 , the igm mass fraction continues to decrease in the n288l10mc run , while it becomes almost constant in the n288l10 run . a similar behaviour is seen for the condensed phase , and the n288l10mc continues to increase its condensed mass . this suggests that the metal cooling enhances the igm accretion onto galaxies mostly at @xmath39 , which supplies the fuel for star formation . the cooling of warm+hot phase into diffuse phase is also enhanced , leading to a larger mass fraction of diffuse component in the n288l34mc run than in the n288l34 run . ( the same is true for n216l10mc and n216l10 runs . ) the n216l10nw run shows stark differences from all other runs . it has a significantly lower igm mass fraction , and a very large mass fraction in the condensed phase . this shows that the igm is mostly enriched by galactic wind , and that most of the masses are returned into the ` warm - hot + hot ' phase , but not to the diffuse phase . galaxy stellar mass function ( gsmf ) tells us how the stellar mass is distributed in different galaxies , and its redshift evolution reflects the growth of structure in the hierarchical universe . figure [ fig : mf_star ] compares the gsmf in different simulations . we only show the range of @xmath80 , which corresponds to the limiting mass of 32 star particles in n216l10 runs . we chose 32 star particles as our resolution limits because all mass function start to turn over around this mass range . panel ( @xmath52 ) shows that the run with no galactic wind ( n216l10nw ) completely overestimates the gsmf , and the run with lower resolution ( n144l10 ) underestimates the number of lower mass galaxies at @xmath81 relative to the n216l10 run . panel ( @xmath72 ) shows that the metal cooling increases the masses of galaxies by @xmath82% at @xmath1 . as a result , both the n216l10mc and n216l10mv runs show a slight increase in the number of galaxies at the massive end , with a slightly stronger enhancement in the n216l10mv run . figures [ fig : mf_star]c , d demonstrate that the metal cooling also changes the redshift evolution of gsmf . in the n216l10mc run , the peak of mass function is shifting more toward the massive side than in the n216l10 run at @xmath1 . from @xmath83 to @xmath1 , the low - mass galaxies merge to form more massive galaxies , increasing the number of galaxies with @xmath84 furthermore . it also seems that the formation of low - mass galaxies ( @xmath81 ) is enhanced by metal cooling at early times ( @xmath85 ) . however we find that the behaviour of mf at the low - mass end is somewhat dependent on the threshold density for the grouping . as mentioned in [ sec : groups ] , our grouping code imposes a threshold gas density of @xmath29 for a gas particle to be part of a galaxy . when we lower this threshold density , we find that the two mfs for the n216l10 and n216l10mc converged , as more particles are incorporated into galaxies at the outskirts of galaxies . metal cooling increases the gas density in galaxies , enabling more low - mass galaxies to satisfy the gas density threshold and to be identified as simulated galaxies . therefore the behaviour of mf at @xmath86 is somewhat dependent on the choice of the outer threshold density of galaxies . figure [ fig : mf_comp ] compares the gas and baryonic ( star + gas ) mfs for the n216l10 series at @xmath1 ( panels @xmath52 & @xmath72 ) , and the redshift evolution of the baryonic mf from @xmath87 to @xmath1 in the n216l10 ( panel @xmath74 ) and n216l10mc ( panel @xmath77 ) runs . here we show only the range of @xmath88 , which corresponds to the limiting mass of 32 gas particles . panel ( @xmath52 ) shows that more gas is converted into stars in the runs with metal cooling ( n216l10mc and n216l10mv ) compared to the n216l10 run , while panel ( @xmath72 ) shows that the baryonic mf is similar in all the runs . as we discussed in [ sec : evolv4 ] , the igm accretion onto galaxies is not so much enhanced yet before @xmath89 due to relatively low igm metallicity , which explains the similarity in the total baryonic mf . in the runs with metal cooling , the peak of gsmf is shifted toward higher mass , whereas the peak of gas mf is shifted toward lower mass . this suggests that the enhanced gsmf at @xmath1 is due to the increased sf efficiency by metal cooling within the galaxies . again , the apparent enhancement in the number of low - mass galaxies in the n216l10mc run compared to the n216l10 run is somewhat dependent on the threshold density of grouping , therefore it should be interpreted with caution . as the accretion of igm onto galaxies become more efficient at @xmath2 due to the increased igm cooling by the metals , we expect that the total baryonic mass of galaxies would be more enhanced at @xmath0 than at @xmath1 . figure [ fig : mf_comp_n288l34 ] shows the mfs at @xmath1 and @xmath0 in the n288l34 series , and it clearly demonstrates that this expectation is true . here we show only the range of @xmath91 , which corresponds to the limiting mass of 32 gas particles . the general trend in the three ( star , gas , and total baryon ) mfs is similar to that we saw in figure [ fig : mf_comp ] , although the difference at @xmath1 between the n288l34 and n288l34mc runs is slightly smaller than in the n216l10 series due to poorer resolution . figure [ fig : mf_comp_n288l34]f shows most prominently the enhancement of the total baryonic mf at @xmath0 in the n288l34mc run owing to the metal cooling . in panels ( @xmath92 ) & ( @xmath93 ) , the n288l34 run actually has a longer tail at the most massive - end than the n288l34mc run . the reason for this feature is not fully clear , but it may be related to the balance between igm accretion and feedback . owing to metal cooling , igm accretion rate increases in the mc run , and the sfr is also enhanced , leading to a stronger feedback . the amount of mass loss is greater in low mass galaxies , but the net heating of igm is more significant for massive galaxies . the mc run has stronger feedback , therefore its feedback heating may become more significant than igm accretion for very massive galaxies . the significant igm heating suppresses the growth of massive - end of mass function from @xmath1 to @xmath0 and results in shorter tail for the mc run at @xmath0 as shown in figure [ fig : mf_comp_n288l34]e , f . for a fixed galaxy baryonic mass , the enhancement of star formation by metal cooling would decrease the gas mass fraction , @xmath94 . figure [ fig : gfrac_evol_n216l10 ] shows @xmath95 as a function of galaxy stellar mass for the n216l10 series . panel ( @xmath52 ) shows the data only from n216l10mc run at @xmath1 , and each data point corresponds to a simulated galaxy . to characterise the distribution , we compute the following two quantities in each logarithmic stellar mass bin : ` average ' and ` median ' . the ` average ' is the ratio of total gas mass to total baryonic mass for all the galaxies in each mass bin , i.e. , @xmath96 . the ` median ' case is simply the median of @xmath95 values in each mass bin . both quantities show a similar trend , however , there is a sharper drop - off at @xmath97 for the ` median ' case in figure [ fig : gfrac_evol_n216l10]a . this mass - scale corresponds to 32 star particles in the n216l10 series . we find that there are many galaxies with @xmath98 above this mass - scale , which causes the sharp drop - off in the ` median ' line . below this limiting mass , galaxies are not resolved well , which results in an underestimate of star formation and an overestimate of @xmath95 . if we had a higher resolution simulation with finer particle masses , this limiting mass - scale would shift to a lower mass . therefore the location of this sharp drop - off is currently determined by the resolution of our simulation . however , dark matter halos would stop forming stars at some lower limiting halo mass , if we had an infinitely high - resolution simulation , this lower limit to the galaxy mass is presumably determined by the photoevaporation of gas by the uv background radiation @xcite . recent works suggest that star formation could be suppressed by the uv background in halos with @xmath99 at @xmath89 . galaxies with @xmath100 would reside in halos with @xmath101 . the n216l10 series would resolve such a halo with @xmath102 dark matter particles , and its mass resolution is actually close to the astrophysical limit for dwarf galaxy formation at @xmath89 . therefore the sharp drop - off in @xmath95 at @xmath100 may not be so far from the true answer . we find that @xmath103 increases with decreasing @xmath104 at all redshifts , regardless of metal cooling and wind effects . this trend is qualitatively consistent with current observations . @xcite estimate the gas fraction as a function of stellar mass using the rest - frame uv - selected star - forming galaxies at @xmath105 , and show that the gas fraction decreases with increasing stellar mass . and using the mean gas and stellar mass , they find the average @xmath106 , which agrees with the predicted gas fraction for massive galaxies in our simulation . in addition , @xcite reported that the average neutral gas fraction is @xmath107 for the local dwarf galaxies selected from the sloan digital sky survey . in our n216l10 series with metal cooling , the ` average ' @xmath95 reaches 0.6 for galaxies with @xmath108 at @xmath1 & 4 . figures[fig : gfrac_evol_n216l10]b , c , d show the redshift evolution of @xmath95 for the n216l10 series . in the runs with metal cooling ( n216l10mc and n216l10mv ) , @xmath95 is lower than in the n216l10 run by @xmath30% at all redshifts for galaxies with @xmath109 . this result suggests that the metal cooling reduces @xmath95 owing to more efficient star formation . the values of @xmath95 seem to be more convergent at the massive - end ( @xmath110 ) . in addition , we find that galaxies in the n216l10nw run are the most gas - rich , because almost no galactic gas is returned to the igm . figures [ fig : gfrac_evol_n216l10]b , c , d also show that @xmath95 is higher at higher redshifts . for example , the well - resolved galaxies with @xmath111 have @xmath112 at @xmath87 , but @xmath113 at @xmath1 . as we saw in figure [ fig : mf_star]d , there is a considerable growth in gsmf from @xmath87 to @xmath1 . together with the decrease in the gas fraction , these results suggest that most of the gas accreted during @xmath114 has been converted into stars . figure [ fig : mgfrac_resolution]a highlights the redshift evolution of @xmath95 from @xmath87 to @xmath0 in the n288l34mc run . the gas mass fraction clearly decreases with decreasing redshift as the gas is converted into stars . the rate of decrease is greater at @xmath115 than at @xmath116 , with @xmath117 & 0.2 for @xmath118 , & 1 , respectively , for galaxies with @xmath119 . figure [ fig : mgfrac_resolution]b shows the effect of resolution on @xmath95 . the location of the drop - off in @xmath95 shifts to lower masses as the resolution is increased from n144l10mc to n216l10mc run . the location of the drop - off is at around our resolution limit the vertical lines in _ panel ( b)_. therefore the values of @xmath95 are overestimated in unresolved galaxies . using cosmological hydrodynamic simulations with metal enrichment and metal cooling , we studied their effects on galaxy growth and cosmic sfr . owing to metal cooling , the sfr density increases about 20% at @xmath1 and about 50% at @xmath0 . our results suggest that metal cooling enhances the star formation through two different processes : 1 ) more efficient conversion of local ism into stars ( i.e. , increase of local sf efficiency ) , and 2 ) the increase of igm accretion onto galaxies . the former process is in effect essentially at all times at @xmath120 , because the local ism can be instantaneously enriched by sn explosions . this process enhances the sfr , but does not noticeably change the total baryonic mass of galaxies . the latter process , on the other hand , can increase the total baryonic mass of galaxies , as well as enhancing the overall sfr density by supplying more gas for star formation . this process becomes effective only at lower redshifts ( @xmath39 ) , because it takes some time to enrich the igm up to @xmath121 . in this paper , we used two different prescriptions for star formation in the runs with metal cooling : 1 ) the ` constant @xmath8 ' scheme and 2 ) the ` varying @xmath8 ' scheme . the value of @xmath8 was fixed in the former scheme , while it was modulated according to the metallicity in the latter scheme . both schemes show similar increase of cosmic sfr density ( see figure [ fig : sfr_n216l10 ] ) , which implies that the overall sf enhancement by metal cooling is not so sensitive to the choice of @xmath8 ( but with some differences as we discussed in [ sec : cos_sfr ] ) . the multiphase ism model for star formation by @xcite contains two free parameters : @xmath8 and the normalisation of gas consumption time - scale , @xmath122 . the values of these two parameters were originally chosen to match the empirical kennicutt - schmidt law @xcite using simulations of isolated disk galaxies . since we did not change the value of @xmath122 in the runs with metal cooling ( as well as @xmath8 in the ` mc ' runs ) , it is possible that our simulations may now violate the kennicutt law . however , as we show in figure [ fig : kenni ] , the plots of @xmath123 vs. @xmath124 for the n216l10 and n216l10mc runs are not so different from each other . this can be understood as follows . as figure [ fig : evolv4]c showed , metal cooling increases the density and lowers the temperature of star - forming gas . the fundamental scaling relationship between sfr and cold gas density does not need to change when the metal cooling is introduced ; the star - forming gas particles would simply slide upward along the kennicutt law , @xmath125 . in the case of n216l10mv run , we varied @xmath8 according to the gas metallicity , primarily scattering it to lower values because higher metallicity increases the cooling rate and lowers @xmath8 . therefore more gas particles become eligible to form stars and @xmath124 is scattered upward above the kennicutt law for a given value of @xmath123 , resulting in a broader deviation from the power - law relationship of the kennicutt law near @xmath126 . at higher values of @xmath123 , @xmath124 is enhanced , but still within the range of the kennicutt law . this difference can be alleviated by adjusting the sf timescale ( see * ? ? ? * ) , however , we try to emphasise the effect of metal cooing on sfr by keeping this parameter the same in all the runs . further investigations of the hi aspect of our simulations is beyond the scope of the present paper , and we will present the results elsewhere . upon evaluating the effect of metal cooling , @xcite considered two different gas phases where the cooling become important . one is the diffuse gas in galactic halos , which must radiate its thermal energy in order to collapse onto the high - density ism , and the other is the multiphase star - forming gas . they argued in their 5.2 that the cosmic sfr density at @xmath127 would not be affected by the metal cooling very much , because at high-@xmath31 cooling is so efficient that the gas in diffuse atmospheres of halos cools nearly instantly , even without any metal cooling . they expected their model results to be largely independent of metal enrichment , because in this regime the evolution of sfr density is driven by the fast gravitational growth of the halo mass function . for the star - forming multiphase ism , they argued that the parameters of their model ( e.g. cold gas evaporation efficiency and gas consumption time - scale ) can be adjusted such that the normalisation of the kennicutt law can be maintained , yielding to first order unaltered model predictions . however , our simulations , in particular the comparison between the n216l10 and n216l10mc run , suggest that the metal cooling can enhance the sfr density even at @xmath127 by @xmath128% . this is because the gas density becomes higher and temperature becomes lower ( see figure [ fig : evolv4]c ) by responding to the enhanced cooling rate by metals . in summary , we consider that our study serves to demonstrate the importance of metal enrichment and metal cooling in galaxy formation , beyond our original motivation to perform a simple numerical study . our study highlights the role of metals at low-@xmath31 and high-@xmath31 to enhance the star formation in the universe , and demonstrates that the metals increase the sf efficiency in the star - forming ism , as well as enabling more igm to accrete onto galaxies and fuel star formation . we expect that metal cooling would also alter some of the galaxy properties such as the mass - metallicity relationship ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and specific sfr ( e.g. , * ? ? ? we plan to investigate these issues in the future , as well as alternative models for star formation and feedback . we thank v. springel for allowing us to use the updated version of gadget-2 code for our study , and for useful comments on the manuscript . kn is grateful for the hospitality of institute for the physics and mathematics of the universe , university of tokyo , where part of this work was done . we are also grateful to the anonymous referee for constructive comments which improved this paper . this research was supported in part by the national aeronautics and space administration under grant / cooperative agreement no . nnx08ae57a issued by the nevada nasa epscor program , by the national science foundation through teragrid resources provided by the san diego supercomputer center ( sdsc ) , and by the president s infrastructure award at unlv . the simulations were performed at the unlv cosmology computing cluster and the datastar at sdsc . d. n. , verde l. , peiris h. v. , komatsu e. , nolta m. r. , bennett c. l. , halpern m. , hinshaw g. , jarosik n. , kogut a. , limon m. , meyer s. s. , page l. , tucker g. s. , weiland j. l. , wollack e. , wright e. l. , 2003 , apjs , 148 , 175
Abstract: | [
"we present the results of a numerical study on the effects of metal enrichment and metal cooling on galaxy formation and cosmic star formation ( sf ) history using cosmological hydrodynamic simulations . we find following differences in the simulation with metal cooling when compared to the run without it : ( 1 ) the cosmic star formation rate ( sfr ) is enhanced by about 50 & 20% at @xmath0 & 3 , respectively ; ( 2 ) the gas mass fraction in galaxies is lower ; ( 3 ) the total baryonic mass function ( gas + star ) at @xmath1 does not differ significantly , but shows an increase in the number of relatively massive galaxies at @xmath0 ; ( 4 ) the baryonic mass fraction of intergalactic medium ( igm ) is reduced at @xmath2 due to more efficient cooling and gas accretion onto galaxies . our results suggest that the metal cooling enhances the galaxy growth by two different mechanisms : ( 1 ) increase of sf efficiency in the local interstellar medium ( ism ) , and ( 2 ) increase of igm accretion onto galaxies . the former process is effective throughout most of the cosmic history , while the latter is effective only at @xmath2 when the igm is sufficiently enriched by metals owing to feedback . method : numerical galaxies : evolution galaxies : formation galaxies : high redshift galaxies : mass function cosmology : theory"
] | 8,343 | 8,343 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the chromosphere is in a highly dynamic state , varying on timescales of minutes or less . much of the dynamics in the magnetized regions associated with the magnetic network and plage are dominated by short - lived , jet - like features . a whole range of names has been applied to describe these chromospheric features . at the quiet sun limb , they are traditionally called spicules , where they are observed in as thin , elongated features that develop speeds of 10 - 30 km s@xmath1 and reach heights of on average 5 - 9 mm during their lifetimes of 3 to 15 minutes @xcite . their widths ( 0.2 - 1 mm ) and dynamics have , until recently , been very close to the resolution limits of observations . as a result of this limitation , the superposition inherent in limb observations , and the difficulty associated with interpreting h@xmath0 data , the properties of spicules have not been very well constrained , which has led to a multitude of theoretical models ( for a review , see , * ? ? ? the same issues have plagued a solid identification of a counterpart to spicules on the disk . observations on the disk in h@xmath0 reveal dark mottles in quiet sun regions . these dark mottles seem similar to spicules , and usually appear in close association with small flux concentrations ( and bright points ) in the magnetic network that outlines the supergranular cells . there has been a long - standing discussion on whether spicules and mottles are the same phenomena . this discussion has focused on the different velocity distributions of mottles and spicules to conclude that mottles are not the disk counterpart of spicules @xcite . however , several groups have used more recent data to argue for a close relationship between mottles and spicules ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? dynamic , jet - like features can also be seen in and around active region plage regions . these features are shorter ( 1 - 4 mm ) and shorter - lived ( 3 - 6 minutes ) and appear to form a subset of what have traditionally been called active region fibrils . there are also fibrils that do not show jet - like behavior ( fig . [ fig_context ] ) . these are apparently low - lying , heavily inclined and more static loop - like structures that connect plage regions with opposite polarity magnetic flux . in the remainder of this paper , we will not discuss these low - lying fibrils , but focus on the motions of the shorter dynamic fibrils ( hereafter abbreviated as dfs ) . only recently have dfs become the focus of detailed study , with several papers studying their dynamics , influence on the transition region and their oscillatory properties @xcite . in the past , several authors have reported periodicities and oscillations in spicule observations , usually with dominant periods of order 5 minutes . such periodicities in radial velocity , half - width and line intensity have been suggested based on older observations at the limb , but their interpretation has been difficult due to the complicated line formation of h@xmath0 , line - of - sight superposition and limited spatial resolution @xcite . more recently , @xcite have discovered significant oscillatory power in dfs in active regions using high - resolution data from the swedish 1 m solar telescope @xcite . not all dfs show oscillations or recurrence , but a significant number do . most of the power in especially more inclined dfs resides in periods between 4 and 6 minutes @xcite . similar periods have been found by @xcite in mottles in enhanced network or weak plage . @xcite and @xcite developed a new numerical model to explain the cause of these ( quasi)periodic mottles or dfs . they compared their model to data from the transition region and coronal explorer ( trace * ? ? ? * ) and suggested that inclined magnetic fields allow leakage of normally evanescent photospheric p - modes ( which have dominant periods of 5 minutes ) into the atmosphere where they form shocks that drive dfs . a recent paper by @xcite uses extremely high resolution observations obtained at the sst and significantly more advanced numerical modelling to show that dynamic fibrils are indeed caused by magneto - acoustic shock waves . in this paper , we directly expand on the work by @xcite . here we perform a more comprehensive analysis of the properties and motion of dfs using the same extremely high spatial and temporal resolution sst dataset of @xcite . in addition , we use advanced 2/3d numerical radiative mhd simulations that include the convection zone , photosphere , chromosphere and lower corona to interpret all of the measurements and correlations found in the sst data analysis , many of which have not been described in @xcite . in [ sec : instrumentation ] we discuss the details of the observations and instrumentation , including a description of a novel , advanced optical setup that allowed a diffraction limited 88 minute long timeseries in linecenter . we describe the typical temporal evolution and measure properties of dfs in [ section : dfdescription ] . this section also deals with intriguing regional differences and correlations in df properties that seem to be related to the oscillatory behavior of dfs . to interpret these findings , we use a numerical model that is described in [ section : discussion ] . this section also summarizes our observational findings and contains a more detailed description of the new model ( introduced by * ? ? ? * ) that explains our observations . our results strongly suggest that dfs naturally form as the result of chromospheric shock waves driven by convective flows and ( global ) oscillations in the photosphere as suggested by @xcite . in [ section : qs ] we discuss in more detail how this model and our observations of active region dfs relate to equivalent quiet sun phenomena . the dynamics of quiet sun mottles have been studied extensively by several groups recently @xcite . while the lack of high spatial and temporal resolution data has made it difficult to properly interpret the findings , this recent work seems to have resolved a long - standing issue @xcite regarding the paths mottles follow during their ascent and descent . @xcite and @xcite use data to establish that mottles follow parabolic paths . in fact , observations by @xcite indicate that spicules at the limb similarly trace parabolic paths . mottles initially appear in the blue wing of extending in the process to lengths of some 2 to 8 mm @xcite . after reaching maximum extent , they fade from the blue wing and appear in the red wing of to recede generally along the same path . throughout most of their lifetime they appear as dark , elongated features in linecenter . the measurements of the parabolic paths traced by mottles have been difficult to interpret . the projected decelerations of the top of the mottle are generally observed to be far less than solar gravity . attempts have been made to interpret such low decelerations as projection effects superposed on ballistic flights . however , the projection angles necessary are typically not compatible with measured doppler shifts @xcite , ruling out a purely ballistic interpretation . in addition , a purely ballistic flight would imply large initial velocities that have not been observed @xcite . these observational findings have been difficult to reconcile with the plethora of models for spicules or mottles @xcite . in [ section : qs ] we describe the similarities between mottles and dfs in more detail , and discuss the applicability of our model to quiet sun mottles . our results are summarized in [ section : summary ] . the observations were obtained with the swedish 1-m solar telesope on la palma . the solar optical universal polarimeter ( soup , * ? ? ? * ) was used to obtain narrow - band images in the linecenter of ( filter fwhm 12.8 pm ) . to compensate for seeing deformations in real - time , the observations were aided by the use of the sst adaptive optics system ( ao , * ? ? ? * ) consisting of a tip - tilt mirror , a bimorph mirror with 37 actuators , a correlation tracker , and a shack hartmann wavefront sensor . as a further measure to reduce seeing aberrations , the data were post - processed with the multi - object multi - frame blind deconvolution image restoration method ( momfbd , * ? ? ? * ) . this method is complementary to the use of ao since it reduces residual aberrations not corrected by the ao and it corrects the areas in the fov that are not used for the ao wavefront sensing . the science cameras consisted of 3 new , high speed cameras of type sarnoff cam1m100 , with a ccd readout time of only 10 ms and an effective exposure time of 15 ms , resulting in a frame rate of approximately 37 frames - per - second ( fps ) . the setup used was specially built for momfbd processing of the data and consisted of one camera behind the soup filter and 2 `` wideband '' cameras in front of the soup filter but after the soup pre - filter ( a 0.8 nm fwhm interference filter centered at 656.3 nm ) . the light for the wideband cameras was split off the main beam by a 90/10 beamsplitter in front of the soup filter and split again evenly for the 2 wideband cameras , which were set up as a phase diversity pair with one camera at 12 mm defocus on a 45 m focal length . a schematic drawing of the red beam optical set - up is shown in fig . [ fig_optical_setup ] . to ensure simultaneous exposure , a specially designed chopper with a useful aperture of 22@xmath222 mm and a variable duty cycle of @xmath3 - @xmath4 was used as a shutter . to guarantee correct labeling of all camera frames , a unique exposure number was generated by the shutter electronics and stored on the camera pcs . this scheme guarantees that simultaneously exposed frames can be uniquely identified , a feature that is required for momfbd processing but difficult to achieve using the internal clock of the observing pcs at the frame rates used . the large data rate produced by the cameras ( 72 mb@xmath5s@xmath1 per camera ) was reduced by a factor of 3 using real - time data compression , sent from the camera computers to disk - writing computers through ordinary gigabit network connections , and then passed through fiberchannel links to the raid controllers of an atabeast system . more details of the data acquisition , as well as first results from this unique dataset are described by @xcite . the observations were obtained on 04-oct-2005 and consist of a time series of about 78 minute duration , centered on one of the larger spots in the young active region ar10813 at s7,e37 . the observing angle @xmath6 between the line - of - sight and the local vertical is @xmath7 ( @xmath8 ) . the field - of - view ( fov ) was about 64@xmath264 at a pixel scale of 0063 . this corresponds to a fov of 46,400 x 46,400 km , with a pixel scale of 45.7 km . the diffraction limit of the sst at 6563 is 0.165 , i.e. , 120 km . the images from all cameras were jointly processed with the momfbd image restoration method , yielding 2 restored images for each restoration ( 1 wide band and 1 ) . since the common field - of - view of the cameras within an momfbd set is separately aligned to sub - pixel accuracy , the restored images have near - perfect alignment . sets from 12 exposures were used per restoration ( i.e. , 36 images in total ) resulting in a time series with 3 fps . for this study , we selected every third image , giving a time series with a fixed cadence of 1 s between images . the time series were corrected for diurnal field rotation , aligned and de - stretched . the ( local ) offsets were determined on the wide band images and subsequently applied to the images . the field of view of the time series contains two small sunspots of noaa active region ( ar ) 10813 . the larger of the spots is split into two parts by a lightbridge as seen in the left panel of fig . [ fig_context ] . the spots are surrounded by areas of plage , which includes some pores to the north of the larger spot . the chromosphere , as imaged in h@xmath0 linecenter ( right panel of fig . [ fig_context ] ) , shows many almost horizontal fibrils that connect the spots to surrounding opposite polarity pores and plage . many of these horizontal fibrils are associated with the superpenumbra of the larger spot . these fibrils are longer ( up to 20 - 40 ) and more static than the dynamic fibrils that are the focus of this paper . most of the dfs are associated with the plage in the region outlined by x=35 - 60and y=20 - 45 . the chromosphere in this region is dominated by relatively short jet - like features that appear to rise and fall within a matter of minutes . during their ascent and descent , individual dfs seem to follow the same , roughly straight , trajectory . at any given time , scores of dfs are visible in this region of interest . dfs often seem to occur in semi - coherent patches which contain several dfs at any given time . the location and orientation of these patches seems to be governed by the topology of the underlying magnetic plage region . within such a patch , it is sometimes difficult to uniquely identify individual dfs because of the semi - coherent behavior over a few arcseconds : some of these coherent fronts show significant substructure . the region which is dominated by dfs appears somewhat brighter in h@xmath0 linecenter than surrounding regions . this may be because hot coronal loops are connected to this region . such a correlation has previously been described by @xcite who find a correlation between the brightness in h@xmath0 linecenter and that of upper transition region moss emission in fe ix / x 171 ( using trace data ) . bright moss emission occurs at the footpoint regions of hot ( @xmath9 mk ) coronal loops . a full disk magnetogram taken by soho / mdi , centered in the middle of the time series , at 09:39 ut on 4-oct-2005 , shows that the two spots and plage in the region of interest share the same polarity ( see contours of fig . [ fig_context ] ) . most of the associated magnetic flux seems to connect to opposite polarity to the north and west of the spots , for example the pores to the north and the plage outside the field of view to the north . this can be deduced from the potential field extrapolation shown in the left panel of fig . [ fig_potext ] . the field extrapolation seems to correlate reasonably well with features outlined by h@xmath0 in some regions , including our region of interest . however , the extrapolation deviates from the h@xmath0 observations in several regions of the active region to the north and east of the spots , as well as close to the pores to the north of the large sunspot . some df properties vary significantly with position in the field of view . several regions were defined : region 1 is at the edge of a plage region where the magnetic field seems more inclined ( see discussion below ) . region 2 covers a dense plage region ( adjacent to region 1 ) where the fields seem more vertical . the average magnetic field strength , as derived from a full - disk mdi magnetogram ( with 2pixels ) , is of order 50 - 100 mx @xmath10 for region 1 , and 150 - 200 mx @xmath10 for region 2 . the other regions contain fewer dfs and their magnetic topology is not as well defined as in regions 1 and 2 . the right panel of fig . [ fig_potext ] illustrates the location of the two main regions ( blue is region 1 , red is region 2 ) . through visual inspection of a time lapse movie of the linecenter images , we found many fibrils in the plage region in proximity to the two spots near the center of the image . we analyzed dfs that occurred throughout the 78 minute long time series . to analyze the properties of the dfs , we manually choose the general direction of a df ( or set of dfs ) . a guideline is drawn in this direction , and a subset of the data , parallel to this guideline , is extracted for further analysis . this procedure results in detailed movies of individual dfs , as well as xt-plots that show the evolution of the extent of the df along the guideline as a function of time . a total of 257 dfs were analyzed in this fashion . in figs . [ fig_spiclife_1 ] , [ fig_spiclife_2 ] , and [ fig_spiclife_3 ] we present the evolution of three typical dfs . figure [ fig_spiclife_1 ] shows a df in region 2 . the six panels show that the df rises rapidly to a maximum length in roughly 130 s and recedes along the same path some 260 s after first becoming visible . it is darker than its surroundings , especially at maximum extension , and seems to follow a straight path in the direction that is shared by all surrounding features . the df has some internal structure , most clearly visible at @xmath11 s and @xmath12 s. the maximum extent is relatively modest at some 2 . despite the substructure , the df is thin with a width of some @xmath13 . it is also well isolated even though a number of other dfs are visible in the immediate vicinity . the length of the df as a function of time is well described by a parabola , as shown in the xt-plot in the top panel of fig . [ fig_spicxt ] . this is the case for the vast majority of the dfs that do not suffer from superposition and where the df guideline was chosen with a correct angle , i.e. where the df motion runs along the guideline . all 257 dfs used in the analysis below meet these conditions . each individual df is therefore fitted with a parabola and the deceleration , maximum velocity ( on ascent or descent ) , maximum extent and duration were derived . to determine the beginning and end points of the parabola , we use the following method . the steep parabolic ascent and descent of a typical df ( and the very high cadence of our data ) allows for a robust determination of the beginning and end time of each df . the intersection ( in the xt-plot ) between the parabolic path and a horizontal line at the beginning time or end time is used to determine the location of the `` root '' of the df at , respectively , the beginning and end of its lifetime . we then use these points in the `` xt''-plot to fit a parabola to the path followed by the df . the prevalence of parabolic paths is illustrated in all three panels of fig . [ fig_spicxt ] , where a wide variety of dfs are evident . the df studied in this case ( top panel ) follows its fitted parabola very well with a constant deceleration given by 216 m s@xmath14 , about two thirds of solar gravity ( 274 m s@xmath14 ) , a maximum velocity of 27 km s@xmath1 , and a maximum extent of some 1800 km . the properties for this df and all others discussed in this paper are measured along the projected path . an example of a much wider df in region 2 is shown in fig . [ fig_spiclife_2 ] . this df has extensive internal structure and rises over a front of about @xmath15 , a width that is largely maintained throughout the descending phase of its relatively short lifetime of 188 s. while rising , the df width is not constant along its axis but the df is wider at the bottom . it is typical that such wide dfs do not rise and fall as a rigid body but rather show phase and amplitude variations in velocity at various positions away from the axis . it is also worth noting that this df clearly becomes darker as it rises and brightens somewhat as it falls back along the same path it rose along . the xt-plot in the middle panel of fig . [ fig_spicxt ] reveals that this df also follows a path that is very close to a parabola with a deceleration of 286 m s@xmath14 , a maximum velocity of 27 km s@xmath1 , and a maximum extent of 1300 km . a longer lived df from region 1 with a lifetime of some 290 s is shown in fig . [ fig_spiclife_3 ] . this df is located in a region where images indicate that highly inclined magnetic field lines connect to the region of opposite polarity plage and pores to the west , in the top right corner of fig . [ fig_context ] . the df is wide , roughly 1 , and relatively long . it is also superposed on another df that is evident in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig_spicxt ] . detailed examination of the movie accompanying fig . [ fig_spiclife_3 ] shows the separate evolution of both dfs . the superposition makes it difficult to determine whether these dfs are formed at the exact same location . residual effects of image distortion from atmospheric seeing can cause the jagged appearance of these xt profiles . despite such distortions and the effects of superposition , a good fit for this df can still be obtained with a deceleration of 200 m s@xmath14 , a maximum velocity of 28 km s@xmath1 , and a maximum extent of some 2000 km . the properties of the parabolic fits to the xt-plots of 257 dfs were calculated . visual inspection of df time lapse movies confirmed the proper alignment of the dfs and quality of the parabolic fits . the upper left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] shows that the dfs suffer a deceleration of on average 146 m s@xmath14 with a significant spread ranging from 40 to 320 m s@xmath14 and a standard deviation of 56 m s@xmath14 . this is significantly less than solar gravity . note that the median of all df properties is illustrated and described in the caption of fig . [ fig_hist ] , whereas we enumerate average values in the text . also note that these deceleration values are twice as high as the values reported in @xcite . the latter were mistakenly divided by two . the maximum df lengths are on average @xmath16 km , ranging from 400 to @xmath17 km with a standard deviation of 620 km , as shown in the upper right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] . the lengths found for dfs are smaller than the widely reported values of @xmath18 to @xmath19 km for spicules at the limb @xcite , but fit well with the values reported in @xcite . on average , the maximum velocity ( on either ascent or descent ) is 18 km s@xmath1 ranging from 8 to 35 km s@xmath1 with a standard deviation of 6 km s@xmath1 , as shown in the middle left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] . the maximum velocity is never observed to be lower than 8 km s@xmath1 . df durations are shown in the middle right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] . the durations vary from 120 to 650 s , with an average of 290 s , and a standard deviation of 85 s. the median duration is lower at 250 s , because of the significant tail of longer duration dfs . in addition to the parabolic fits , we have also measured df widths . to determine the width of a df , we calculate xt-plots ( with x along the direction of the guideline ) for a range of locations that are each offset by one pixel in the direction perpendicular to the guideline . we then find the central axis of the df through visual inspection of the xt-plots : the location with the best - defined xt-plot is chosen as the central axis . starting at this location we find the edges of the df in the direction perpendicular to the df axis . we search for the two positions of maximum intensity gradient furthest from the axis where the df is still visible in the xt-plots . this is done for two different locations along the df , at 50% and at 80% of the maximum extent for a specific time . the width is measured in this fashion at three different times in the df lifetime , at 25% , 50% ( maximum extent ) , and 75% of the df duration . although there is a large spread , we find that the widths of dfs do not vary much with height nor time . the lower left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] includes all the widths measured and shows a mean of 340 km with a standard deviation of 160 km . while the widest df was measured to be 1100 km , most dfs have widths between the difraction limit of 120 km and 380 km , with a significant tail of wider dfs extending to 700 km . based on the shape of the histogram it seems likely that we are not resolving all dfs . however , a significant fraction is clearly resolved . visual inspection shows that the tops of most dfs are very sharply delineated ( see , e.g. , fig . [ fig_spicxt ] ) . furthermore , inspection of xt-plots shows that dfs often are outlined by a bright ring , as shown in fig . [ fig_bright_ring ] . to determine how sharp the transition at the top of the df is , we calculated the distance along the df axis between the location of maximum intensity gradient and the location of maximum intensity in the bright ring above the df . we refer to this measure as the thickness of the bright ring . it is unclear what causes the bright ring . perhaps it is related to the steep transition from chromospheric to coronal temperatures ? detailed radiative transfer calculations will be necessary to determine what causes the bright ring . regardless of the uncertainty in interpretation , we measured the thickness of the bright ring for all 257 dfs and found an average thickness of 240 km with a standard deviation of 120 km . over half are less than 200 km and many are unresolved , as shown in the lower right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] . despite a large spread in properties we find clear differences between df statistics in the two regions defined in the right panel of fig . [ fig_potext ] . on average , dfs in region 1 show lower decelerations , greater lengths , slightly higher maximum velocities , and longer durations than in region 2 ( fig . [ fig_hist ] ) . we also found a slight tendency for dfs to be wider in region 2 ( lower left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) , but found no difference in transition region thickness between the two regions . visual inspection shows that region 2 does show more dfs that are wide with significant substructure , such as the df illustrated in fig . [ fig_spiclife_2 ] . to further illustrate the difference between region 1 and 2 , maps of the location of dfs , color coded to show various properties , are shown in fig . [ fig_regionalmaps ] . as can be seen , there are clear regional differences in deceleration , duration , and length . there is a prevalence of smaller decelerations in region 1 with typical values around 100 m s@xmath14 , versus roughly 200 m s@xmath14 in region 2 . even more clearly , the durations in region 1 are on average about 5 minutes , whereas we find 3 minutes in region 2 . similarly , df lengths in region 1 are typically around @xmath20 km , whereas shorter dfs with lengths around @xmath21 km dominate region 2 . the spatial pattern of maximum velocities is not as clear with a large spread of velocities in both regions . in principle some of these differences could be caused by projection effects due to the angle between the df axis and the line of sight vector . a df that propagates along a direction that is parallel to the direction of the line of sight would not be observed as a moving feature in these movies . to measure the absolute extent , velocity and deceleration along the path of the df , the line of sight needs to be perpendicular to the axis of the df . note that the df durations are independent of the line of sight as they do not suffer from these projection effects . to exclude the possibility that the regional differences in deceleration , velocity and length are caused by projection effects , we try to estimate the absolute direction of propagation of each df . assuming that dfs propagate along the magnetic field , their direction can be estimated from the potential field extrapolation shown in the left panel of fig . [ fig_potext ] . to estimate the effect of projection , we calculate the angle between the line of sight vector and the direction of the magnetic field at a reference height of @xmath22 km above the photosphere . this height was chosen to be very roughly the sum of the top height of the quiescent chromosphere and the typical df length . the angle between extrapolated field lines and the line of sight vector was used to correct the properties of each df for projection . histograms for these corrected values are shown in fig . [ fig_hist_los ] . not surprisingly , all corrected values are larger than the observed values . in addition , the corrected values show the same spatial differences between region 1 and 2 as the uncorrected values . to estimate how reliable the potential field extrapolation is , we measured the mismatch between the direction of the df axis and the direction of the magnetic field as projected onto the surface , and found it to be of order 20 30 degrees . a mismatch of this magnitude can lead to significant errors in calculating the projection angle if the df axis is nearly parallel to the projection of the line of sight vector onto the surface . this means that the corrected values should be considered with caution , especially since the calculations are also based on various assumptions whose validity is unclear . the poor resolution of the mdi magnetogram , the possible non - potentiality of the active region , and the uncertainty in the actual df height with respect to the chosen reference height , all could lead to significant errors in the estimated projection angle . for example , the potential field extrapolation clearly fails in the top part of region 1 where nearly horizontal fields are predicted . such horizontal fields are imcompatible with the visual appearance of linecenter images . in addition , since horizontal fields at this location are almost parallel to the line of sight vector , they lead to very large and obviously erroneous corrections of the local df parameters . despite these reservations , it is very difficult to conceive of a magnetic topology with an orientation to the line of sight that would remove the regional differences for all derived parameters . in addition , the regional differences in duration ( which are independent of projection effects ) as well as the correlations found between various parameters in the following subsection , strongly suggest that regional differences are not caused by projection effects . scatterplots of various df properties reveal intriguing correlations . the most striking correlation , also presented in @xcite , is that between the deceleration and the maximum velocity of the dfs , in which a linear relationship is evident ( upper left panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) . the larger the deceleration the df suffers from , the higher the maximum ( initial or final ) velocity it shows . note that there are , again , significant differences between region 1 and 2 : the dfs in region 2 typically have larger decelerations for a given maximum velocity . a linear fit to the observed relationship between the deceleration and velocity shows that both regions have almost identical slopes . another interesting correlation is that between the maximum length and the duration of a df ( upper right panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) . the longer dfs tend to have longer lifetimes . as expected from the histograms in the upper and middle right panels of fig . [ fig_hist ] , the dfs in region 1 gravitate towards the upper right of this scatterplot . we also find that the maximum velocity and maximum length of dfs is well correlated ( lower right panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) : dfs with higher maximum velocity tend to be longer . however , there is a difference in the slope in regions 1 and 2 . a linear fit for region 1 reveals a slope of 87 km per km s@xmath1 , and 60 km per km s@xmath1 for region 2 . dfs in region 1 are longer for the same maximum velocity . the deceleration of dfs shows a somewhat less clear correlation with the df duration ( lower left panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) . the longest - lived dfs typically suffer from the lowest deceleration . this correlation shows a large spread , and is not quite linear for the total population of dfs . it seems that each region may have its own linear relationship . dfs in region 1 show a more steep dependence of duration on deceleration , whereas those in region 2 show a smaller range of durations , for a range of decelerations that is similar in extent to that of region 1 . based on the correlations described in the above , one would perhaps also expect a correlation between the deceleration and maximum length , or between the maximum velocity and duration . however , such correlations are not clear from the observations , as demonstrated in fig . [ fig_scatterbad ] . the large scatter and different slopes that are evident in the plots that do show correlations may be partially responsible for the lack of clear correlation between deceleration and maximum length or the maximum velocity and duration . however , it is also clear that there are very significant regional differences in fig . [ fig_scatterbad ] , with each region occupying a different area in the scatterplots , and in some cases showing different slopes . it seems probable that such regional differences also are responsible for the lack of clear correlations . when we take the line - of - sight correction into account , none of these correlations , or the lack of correlation , change qualitatively . evidently , the correlation between deceleration and velocity , or that between maximum velocity and length can not change significantly because of projection effects , since both parameters would be corrected by the same factor . the fact that the other correlations , between duration on the one hand , and either deceleration , length or velocity , do not change qualitatively indicates that projection effects do not dominate our dataset . the same arguments also apply to any kind of selection effects that are caused by the fact that dfs with very large line - of - sight velocities could disappear from or be invisible in our relatively narrow ( 128 m ) linecenter bandpass . since dfs are much wider spectral features ( with widths of order 1000 m , see , e.g. * ? ? ? * ) than the width of the bandpass , this means that only features with line - of - sight velocities of order 20 or more km / s would be invisible or only partially visible in the linecenter timeseries . while in a few cases we can see some fading of the df during its descent , it is still possible to trace the top of the df to its end point . given these arguments , the passband effect can only change the derived correlations marginally . note that all of the measurements on which the correlations are based , depend on the identification of a single df rising above the chromospheric background . the latter can be quite noisy and sometimes less well defined . filtergrams taken in the wings of h@xmath0 might be helpful for a more exact determination of the root location of each df , but such filtergrams were unavailable in this dataset . this means that the measured length and maximum velocity could in fact be somewhat higher than reported here . however , given the rapid rise and fall of dfs , the measured duration is quite insensitive to this effect . since we are measuring the acceleration by fitting parabolas to the height profile , the acceleration is also insensitive to the position of the chromospheric background . overall , this implies that the relative uncertainty in determining the roots of dfs are unlikely to qualitatively change the correlations reported here . the interpretation of these correlations , or the lack thereof , will be discussed at length in [ section : discussion ] . the regional differences in df durations evident in the middle right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] , with 3 minute lifetimes dominating region 2 and lifetimes around 5 minutes more dominant in region 1 , suggest a role for chromospheric waves or oscillations in the formation mechanism of dfs . oscillations in the chromosphere are typically not steady harmonic waves , but wave trains of finite duration . for this reason we perform a wavelet analysis of the data , since it allows for localization in time of periodic signals . the mother wavelet we use is the complex valued morlet wavelet ( @xmath23 ) which consists of a plane wave modulated by a gaussian , an appropriate shape for wave trains . to estimate the statistical significance of the wavelet power spectra ( 95 % confidence interval ) , we compare them to theoretical spectra for white noise , following @xcite and @xcite . taking into account the cone of influence @xcite , we calculate for each superpixel the number of wavepackets in the timeseries for which the wavelet power is significant . this is done for a range of wave periods from 150 to 600 seconds . a superpixel is defined as the average of 4x4 original 0.063 pixels . note that the original data is oversampled by a factor of almost 3 with respect to the diffraction limit ( 120 km ) of the sst at the wavelength of . the upper left and upper right panels of fig . [ fig_osc_panels ] show , for each location of the lower left panel , the number of significant wavepackets ( during the timeseries ) for waves with a period of 180 s and 300 s respectively . the lower right panel shows which wave period dominates , i.e. , has the most wavepackets , at each location of the field of view . from this figure , we find that many locations show significant oscillatory power throughout the timeseries . the dominant period of this power varies across the field of view . clearly visible are the dominant 3 minute oscillations in the sunspots around x=27 and y=37 and at x=45 and y=15 . in addition , the dense plage region which we have designated as region 2 , shows a preponderance of 3 minute oscillations . in contrast , region 1 , adjacent to the dense plage region , is dominated by oscillations with long periods around and above 5 minutes . in this region , the magnetic field is more inclined than in the dense plage region . the longer , less dynamic and more horizontal fibrils , such as those in the superpenumbra of both spots , seem to be dominated by oscillations with periods longer than 10 minutes . it is interesting to note that the dominant period in region 2 corresponds exactly to the df duration we observe in region 2 . apparently , dfs typically live for about 3 minutes in this region , which is also the dominant periodicity of the oscillations . likewise , region 1 is dominated by 5 minute oscillations , and contains dfs with lifetimes of order 5 minutes . since the oscillation measurements are based on the same data , it seems clear that some dfs are periodic or recurring . this was also described by @xcite and suggests a relationship between chromospheric waves and dfs , which will be further explored in [ section : discussion ] . most dfs follow parabolic paths with a symmetrical ascending and descending phase . these paths are characterized by a large initial velocity , usually of order 15 - 20 km s@xmath1 ( middle left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) , that decreases linearly with time until the df has retreated completely . at the end of its life , a df s downward velocity is roughly identical to the initial upward velocity . the linear decrease with time of the velocity , i.e. , the deceleration , is usually between 120 and 280 m s@xmath14 ( upper left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) . there is a clear linear relationship between the deceleration and the maximum ( down- or upward ) velocity of the df ( upper left panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) . dfs reach maximum lengths of order 1,000 to 2,000 km ( upper right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) during their lifetimes of 3 to 8 minutes ( middle right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) . the duration and maximum length are well correlated ( upper right panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) , which indicates that uncertainty about the line - of - sight correction may not play an important role in the regional differences we find . we resolve more than half of the dfs we observe . the average thickness is 240 km ( lower left panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) , with a range between the diffraction limit ( 120 km ) and 1000 km . some dfs occur over a wider spatial area , whereas others are very thin and stay thin throughout their lifetime . many of the wider dfs have variable widths as a function of time . these give the visual appearance of a wave front with varying phase speeds or amplitude in the direction perpendicular to the df axis . there is often a brightening above the df , which can be clearly seen in xt-plots ( fig . [ fig_bright_ring ] ) . this brightening might be a sign of increased temperatures at the top of the df . the thickness of this transition is not resolved and is less than 120 km in more than half of the dfs studied ( lower right panel of fig . [ fig_hist ] ) . dfs have significantly different properties in two regions within our field of view . region 2 contains dense plage , i.e. , a collection of strong magnetic field concentrations in which the magnetic field is generally more vertical . region 1 is located at the edge of this dense plage region , where the magnetic field is more inclined , as it connects to relatively nearby opposite polarity plage . the dfs in the dense plage region are shorter ( @xmath24 km ) , have higher decelerations ( @xmath25 m s@xmath14 ) , slightly lower velocities ( @xmath26 km s@xmath1 ) and shorter durations of about 3 minutes ( figs . [ fig_hist ] and [ fig_regionalmaps ] ) . in contrast , the dfs in the region where the field is more inclined are longer ( @xmath27 km ) , have lower decelerations ( @xmath28 m s@xmath14 ) , slightly higher velocities ( @xmath29 km s@xmath1 ) and longer durations of about 5 minutes ( figs . [ fig_hist ] and [ fig_regionalmaps ] ) . in addition , df lifetimes correlate well with the dominant periodicities observed in both regions : 3 minute oscillations dominate in the dense plage region , whereas 5 minute oscillations dominate in the region with more inclined field ( fig . [ fig_osc_panels ] ) . our measurements of dfs and oscillatory power strongly suggest that chromospheric waves drive dfs upward . these chromospheric waves are generated by convective flows and ( global ) oscillations in the photosphere and convection zone . the magnetic field concentrations provide a channel for these disturbances to propagate up through the chromosphere . during their path upwards , they shock and drive chromospheric plasma upwards , forming dfs in the process . this mechanism was originally suggested in rudimentary form by @xcite . some models have further studied the effects of the convective part of the photospheric driver on the chromosphere in the so - called rebound - shock model @xcite . more recently , @xcite included both the convective driver and global oscillations in varying magnetic topologies to directly describe their ( lower resolution ) observations of dynamic fibrils . the latter model s predictions agree well with the current findings . this scenario is confirmed by analysis of advanced numerical simulations ( see @xcite and next subsection ) in which dynamic fibril - like features with properties identical to those in our data occur . from the simulations , it is clear that the observed parabolic paths indicate that dfs are shock driven . when a shock hits the transition region ( i.e , the top of a df ) , the transition region is catapulted upwards at a velocity that exceeds the sound speed in the chromosphere ( @xmath30 km s@xmath1 ) . shock waves generally have velocity profiles in the form of n- or sawtooth shapes ( e.g. * ? ? ? thus , a plasma parcel passing through a shock wave will first experience a sudden kick in velocity - the shock itself and thereafter a gradual linear deceleration as the shock recedes . assuming a shock wave with amplitude or shock strength of @xmath31 and linear deceleration @xmath32 @xmath33 it is trivially verified that a plasma parcel passing through the shock will describe a parabolic path ; integrating gives a parcel position that moves as @xmath34 df formation from chromospheric shocks is compatible with the fact that we do not find any dfs with initial ( maximum ) velocities of less than 10 km s@xmath1 . waves with smaller amplitudes will not form shocks and hence dfs . the observed lower limit to the maximum velocities provides an estimate of the sound speed in the upper chromosphere ( 10 km s@xmath1 ) . its value is compatible with chromospheric temperatures from solar models . more generally , the observed maximum velocities provide a robust estimate of the mach number of chromospheric shocks . our observations indicate that shocks with mach numbers of 1 through at least 3.5 are ubiquitous in the magnetized chromosphere , and drive dfs . analysis of numerical simulations @xcite further shows that several different effects influence the shock formation and evolution so that the observed correlations ( e.g. , between deceleration and velocity ) and regional differences follow naturally . the oscillatory power spectrum of the photospheric driver is dominated by power at 5 minutes . the chromosphere acts as a filter to the input from below , filtering out waves with periods that are longer than the local acoustic cutoff period . in general , the acoustic cutoff period depends on the inclination of the magnetic field lines to the vertical @xcite . under conditions of vertical magnetic field ( e.g. , region 2 ) , this means that the chromosphere is dominated by oscillations and waves with periods at the acoustic cutoff of 3 minutes . as a result , the dfs formed in the dense plage of region 2 are driven by shocks with periods of 3 minutes and thus have lifetimes of order 3 minutes . in contrast , the inclined field , such as that found in region 1 , increases the acoustic cutoff period . this allows the photospheric waves with periods of 5 minutes to leak into the chromosphere , develop into shocks and form dfs with similar lifetimes . since most of the oscillatory power in the photosphere occurs for periods of 5 minutes , the driver in inclined field regions is generally stronger than in regions with more vertical field . this effect is enhanced by the fact that , in dense plage regions , the amplitude of convective flows and global oscillations is generally reduced at the photospheric level . dfs that form along inclined field lines also experience only the component of gravity along the magnetic field , so that decelerations are generally lower in the inclined field region . the observed correlation between deceleration and maximum velocity can be understood in terms of shock wave physics and the fact that dfs are driven by single shocks . for a given wave period , n-shaped shock waves will show a steeper decline with time in velocity for a greater shock strength . in other words , dfs with higher maximum velocity , i.e. , those that are driven by stronger shocks , will show greater deceleration , for a given df lifetime . it is the combination of these effects that explains the observed regional differences and correlations . region 2 contains more vertical field , so that only 3 minute power drives the chromospheric waves and shocks . given the photospheric power spectrum and the reduced power in dense plage regions , this leads to lower amplitudes , i.e. , lower maximum velocity . in addition , the short lifetimes and more vertical field lead to higher decelerations , and shorter lengths . conversely , region 1 contains more inclined field , allowing the full photospheric peak power at 5 minutes to leak into the chromosphere to drive dfs . as a result , the velocity amplitude is greater , and the longer lifetimes and less vertical field lead to lower decelerations and longer lengths . these findings are confirmed when comparing the observations with recent advanced numerical radiative mhd simulations that include the convection zone , photosphere , chromosphere , transition region and corona @xcite . the equations of mhd are solved using an extended version of the numerical code described in @xcite and in more detail by nordlund & galsgaard at http://www.astro.ku.dk/@xmath35kg . the code functions by using a sixth order accurate scheme to determine partial spatial derivatives . the equations are stepped forward in time using the explicit 3rd order predictor - corrector procedure by @xcite , modified for variable time steps . in order to supress numerical noise , high - order artificial diffusion is added both in the forms of a viscosity and in the form of a magnetic diffusivity . thermal conduction along the magnetic field in the corona and transition region is treated by operator splitting and using a multi - grid solver . the radiative flux divergence from the photosphere and lower chromosphere is obtained using the method of @xcite based on group mean opacities as modified by @xcite to account for scattering . for the upper chromosphere , transition region and corona we assume effectively thin radiative losses . for the middle and upper chromosphere we parametrize the optically thick radiative losses in strong lines and continua from hydrogen and singly ionized calcium by using escape probabilities calculated in 1d with the code of @xcite . further description of the 3d code may be found in @xcite . the 2d simulations described here are run on a grid of @xmath36 points spanning @xmath37 mm@xmath38 . in height , these models cover a region from 2 mm below to 10 mm above the photosphere . the grid has uneven spacing in the vertical , @xmath39 , direction with a grid size of 30 km in the photosphere and chromosphere becoming gradually larger in the corona . we have also run 2d calculations on coarser grids of @xmath40 and @xmath41 points , as well as 3d runs of @xmath42 points spanning @xmath43 mm@xmath44 , with results similar to those reported here . at the start of a given simulation , a potential magnetic field is added to a model of the solar atmosphere . the resultant model is then allowed to evolve in time until a quasi - steady state is achieved . this takes on the order of a half hour solar time . the models are convectively unstable due the radiative losses in the photosphere . this results in a temperature structure similar to that derived in semi - empirical solar models . the average temperature at the bottom boundary is maintained by setting the entropy of the fluid entering the computational domain . the bottom boundary , based on characteristic extrapolation , is otherwise open , allowing fluid to enter and leave the computational domain as required . the magnetic field at the lower boundary is advected with the fluid . to prevent coronal cooling the upper temperature boundary is set to evolve towards a temperature of @xmath45 k on a timescale of 10 100 s. ( in the 3d models coronal temperatures are maintained by self consistent magnetic dissipation . ) a snapshot of the temperature structure in the lower part of the model including the convection zone , photosphere , and chromosphere is shown in fig . [ sim_snapshot ] . waves generated by convection propagate through the chromosphere , steepen and form shocks roughly 1 mm above the photosphere . in regions above the level where plasma @xmath46 the propagation is modified by the magnetic field and the waves are subjected to reflection , refraction and mode coupling as described by @xcite . of interest to us here are the shocks that propagate along field lines that enter the coronal plasma as indicated in fig [ sim_snapshot ] . these shocks lift and accelerate the transition region as they propagate into the corona . plotting the motion of the transition region along one such field line as a function of time , e.g. a xt plot , reveals that the position of the transition region describes a parabola ( fig . [ sim_xt ] , compare with fig . [ fig_spicxt ] ) . in the left panel of fig . [ sim_xt ] the logarithm of the temperature is shown , the right panel shows the velocity . it is worth noting that except for a brief moment in the early ascending phase the simulated df shows both upflowing and downflowing velocities along its length at a given time . during descent , the df has only downflowing plasma . note also that near its base the simulated df shows downflows for a major portion of its lifetime . we have measured the transition region motion along several field lines in several ` df - like ' events and fitted the motion with parabolas . the resulting correlation between measured maximum velocities and decelerations ( fig . [ sim_dec - maxv ] ) show the same trend as found in the observed dfs ( upper left panel of fig . [ fig_scattergood ] ) : large decelerations are correlated with large maximum velocities . the range in maximal velocities and decelerations is approximately the same as that found in the observed dfs , and the slope in the correlation is about the same . inspection of fig . [ sim_xt ] also indicates that the simulated dfs have the same range of heights and durations that the observed dfs display . higher resolution 3d simulations with varying magnetic topologies will be necessary to explain the range of df widths , the internal df substructure , and what determines the sometimes sheet - like structure of some dfs . such simulations will also help to fully explain the range of periods and lifetimes that we observe . how do these findings relate to quiet sun phenomena such as mottles and spicules at the limb ? there are many similaties between mottles and dfs . both phenomena appear as highly dynamic , dark features in the wings and core of . they are associated with magnetic flux concentrations that can be observed as bright points in the blue wing of . more importantly , like dfs , mottles also follow parabolic paths . in an excellent analysis of the dynamics of inclined mottles ( which they refer to as disk spicules ) @xcite find that : * mottles seem to be generated several hundred kilometers above the photosphere , * mottles undergo real mass motion of order 10 - 30 km s@xmath1 , extending up to 2 - 10 mm during their lifetime of 2 - 15 minutes , * most mottles are observed to ascend and descend , * mottles in weak plage , or the interior of network cells are more vertical and shorter than the more inclined quiet sun mottles , * the appearance of mottles is varied , they can be thick , thin , tapered or not , curved or straight , * some mottles show downward motion close to their base during the ascending phase , * the decelerations observed in mottles are too small to be consistent with a purely ballistic flight ( at solar gravity ) and the observed doppler shifts , * the largest doppler signal appears at the beginning of the ascending phase , and at the end of receding phase , * the observed velocity profiles are compatible with impulsive acceleration and constant deceleration afterward . * the maximum upward velocity is usually identical in amplitude to the maximum downward velocity , * there is a linear relationship between the duration and the maximum length of mottles , * there is a correlation between the average velocity and maximum length , * nearby mottles are often found to be driven by a common disturbance . these findings agree strikingly well with our observations and modelling of dfs , with only a few discrepancies . the lifetimes and maximum lengths of the mottles @xcite analyzed are typically longer than those of the dfs we describe . we believe this is in part a selection effect , as we chose to focus only on highly dynamic and shorter features in our dataset . we note that our dataset also contains a large number of highly inclined fibrils that are longer lived and less dynamic than the dfs ( see , e.g. , fig . [ fig_osc_panels ] ) . in addition , preliminary analysis of high - quality sst data of quiet sun mottles indicates that the most inclined mottles are on average longer , but that many of the mottles actually show lengths ( 1,000 - 5,000 km ) that are similar to those of dfs . until further detailed analysis , it can however not be excluded that dfs associated with plage are on average somewhat shorter in length and lifetime than quiet sun mottles . preliminary analysis of our numerical simulations suggests that these differences could be related to large scale differences in magnetic topology . further work is necessary to establish the exact relationship between mottles and dfs . however , it should be noted that in addition to these striking similarities with mottles , recent observations of limb spicules @xcite show clear parabolic paths with decelerations and maximum velocities of the same order as those reported for mottles @xcite and those we find for dfs . older observations of limb spicules have also shown evidence for correlations between velocities and maximum lengths @xcite , and between duration and height @xcite . these correlations are similar to the ones we find for dfs . in addition , @xcite has reported on collective behavior of spicules or mottles over several thousand kilometers . as discussed also by @xcite , these similarities strongly suggest that chromospheric shock waves cause significant excursions of the upper chromosphere in both active region and quiet sun . such a scenario was proposed by @xcite using sst and trace data . further detailed analysis of our numerical simulations can help shed light on several unresolved issues , such as the role of reconnection in forming quiet sun jets , or whether the observed height of limb spicules can be explained by the mechanism proposed here . @xcite suggest that it is possible that limb spicules consist of two populations : jets that are driven by shocks ( as described in this paper ) , and jets caused by reconnection . the latter jets could form a subset that on average is taller than the shock driven jets , and perhaps be a part of a continuous spectrum of reconnection jets that includes surges , macrospicules and upflow events @xcite . these taller jets may be the features that have uv counterparts ( e.g , observed by sumer ) , which @xcite calls `` spicules '' . the combination of high - resolution chromospheric data and advanced numerical simulations strongly suggests that dfs are formed by upwardly propagating chromospheric oscillations / waves . these waves are generated in the convection zone / photosphere as a result of global p - mode oscillations and convective flows . the magnetic topology acts as a filter , so that only waves of certain periods can propagate into and through the chromosphere , forming shocks along the way , up to regions where h@xmath0 is formed . * dfs follow a parabolic path * dfs in dense plage regions are shorter , slower , undergo larger deceleration and live shorter * dfs in regions adjacent to dense plage regions are longer , faster , undergo less deceleration , and live longer * dfs in dense plage regions show periodicities around 180 s * dfs in regions adjacent to dense plage regions show periodicities around 300 s * the velocity and deceleration of all dfs is well correlated : the higher the velocity , the more deceleration * this correlation is reproduced well in numerical simulations where dfs are driven by shocks caused by upward propagating waves in the chromosphere . * dfs in the simulations follow parabolic paths as well . * the simulations reproduce the observed values of maximum velocities , decelerations and lengths well . from the results describe above and by @xcite , it seems clear that in active regions , most dynamic fibrils are formed by chromospheric shocks driven by convective flows and oscillations in the photosphere . , g. b. , bjelksj , k. , korhonen , t. k. , lindberg , b. , & petterson , b. 2003 , in innovative telescopes and instrumentation for solar astrophysics . keil & s.v . , vol . 4853 , 341350
Abstract: | [
"we present unprecedented high resolution h@xmath0 observations , obtained with the swedish 1-m solar telescope , that , for the first time , spatially and temporally resolve dynamic fibrils in active regions on the sun . these jet - like features are similar to mottles or spicules in quiet sun . we find that most of these fibrils follow almost perfect parabolic paths in their ascent and descent . we measure the properties of the parabolic paths taken by 257 fibrils , and present an overview of the deceleration , maximum velocity , maximum length and duration , as well as their widths and the thickness of a bright ring that often occurs above dynamic fibrils . we find that the observed deceleration of the projected path is typically only a fraction of solar gravity , and incompatible with a ballistic path at solar gravity . we report on significant differences of fibril properties between those occurring above a dense plage region , and those above a less dense plage region where the magnetic field seems more inclined from the vertical . we compare these findings to advanced numerical 2d radiative mhd simulations , and find that fibrils are most likely formed by chromospheric shock waves that occur when convective flows and global oscillations leak into the chromosphere along the field lines of magnetic flux concentrations . detailed comparison of observed and simulated fibril properties shows striking similarities of the values for deceleration , maximum velocity , maximum length and duration . we compare our results with observations of mottles and find that a similar mechanism is most likely at work in the quiet sun ."
] | 11,001 | 11,001 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: particle gels form in suspensions if short - range attractions act between contacting surfaces of particles . depending on the strength of the attraction , one can distinguish them as two types : strongly and weakly aggregated particle gels @xcite . in strongly aggregated particle gels , on which we focus in this work , particles once joined hardly separate at room temperature @xcite . the attractions also prevent tangential displacements of contacting particles @xcite , thus particles form sample - spanning loose networks . their remarkable and complex mechanical properties under external stress are essentially due to the response of a deformable disordered network formed with all the particles . under shear stress , one can sketch out deformation of a particle gel as follows @xcite : * the system is elastic under very low stresses . if the stress is released , the system comes back to the original shape ; * for larger stress , a particle gel may undergo finite deformations , though it does not flow . this is the plastic regime , and it gives malleability ; i.e. , the system mostly keeps the deformed shape if stress is released ; * beyond a yield stress , the particles network is ruptured and the particle gel flows . fluids exhibiting these behavior are called _ yield stress _ ( or _ bingham plastic _ ) fluids @xcite . since the yield stress is the highest stress that can prevent flow , it can be considered as the strength of particle gels . naturally , this strength relates to the strength of the particle connections . in a particle gel under shear stress , transmitting stresses break a portion of particle connections and the sample spanning network is torn apart . the yield stress of particle gels is higher when the packing fraction of particles is larger . in many cases , this variation appears to follow a power law with exponents between 4 and 5 @xcite . under compressive stress , the behavior of a particle gel looks different , due to confinement @xcite . compressive stress appears naturally in a number of applications , for example paste drying @xcite or ceramic processing @xcite . osmotic compression is a generic important case . in this kind of compression process , liquid removal tends to pack the particles into a smaller volume . as long as the applied stress is lower than the strength of the gel , it will retain the volume . if the stress exceeds a compressive yield stress @xmath2 , network restructuring leads to the loss of a part of the liquid phase , and particles reorganize into a smaller volume @xcite . the deformation stops when the mechanical resistance of the network equals the stress . thus , unlike the shear case , deformation does not continue with a constant applied stress @xcite . the growth of mechanical resistance , i.e. compressive consolidation , also shows a highly nonlinear dependence on the packing fraction , typically power - law relations @xmath3 with exponents between 3.2 and 4.5 @xcite . the highly nonlinear dependency of the compressive yield stress @xmath2 on the packing fraction @xmath4 relates to the heterogeneity of the network structure of particles @xcite . the fractal model @xcite successfully captures such packing - fraction dependence of rheological proprieties by considering the characteristic structure of strongly aggregated particle gels . in the model , a particle gel is assumed to be an assembly of fractal flocssuch structural correlation is evidenced by scattering observations @xcite . the entire sample is filled up with flocs of a fractal dimension @xmath0 , and the correlation length @xmath1 is equivalent or proportional to the average size of the flocs . thus , the correlation length @xmath1 can be associated with the packing fraction @xmath4 by using the fractal dimension @xmath0 : @xmath5 , where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the spatial dimension and proportional coefficient . under this assumption , a gel of a higher packing fraction consists of a higher number of smaller flocs of the same fractal dimension @xmath0 . by deducing average mechanical responses of the flocs , the fractal model predicts a power - law dependence of the shear modulus on @xmath4 with an exponent @xmath8 , where @xmath9 is the fractal dimension of the backbone structure . although this theoretical prediction has often been cited in the literature , we should pay attention to the scope of the model . since fractal correlation yields in the formation process of particle gels , there is no clear reason for @xmath0 and @xmath9 to be kept constant during the compression process . actually , some scattering observations indicate that the compression process changes the local structure ( fractal dimension ) @xcite . to make progress in macroscopic modeling of aggregated colloidal or particle gels @xcite , we need to settle such microstructural issues . there is a recent two - dimensional(2d ) simulation work to support the application of the fractal model to compression processes @xcite . gels which were ( i ) directly prepared to the packing fraction @xmath4 , or ( ii ) prepared by compression from a lower packing - fraction gel @xmath10 showed the same structural characteristics . however , the investigated range of packing fractions was relatively high ( @xmath11 ) . since the fractal model targets on strongly aggregated gels , we should compare simulations at lower packing fractions . indeed , our 2d simulation investigates a wider range of packing fractions ( @xmath12 ) . this article reports results of numerical simulation for compression of particulate networks to discuss the consolidation behavior with restructuring . experimentally observed time evolution of compressed gels should be affected by both the hydrodynamic and network resistances @xcite . but , we here focus on studying the latter ; our simulation work investigates the quasi - static structural evolution determined by the balance between external stresses and network strength at long time . this limitation to quasi - static aspects is common with the above - mentioned fractal model . so , compression considered in this work is sufficiently slow , such as osmotic compression . a contact model is employed to simulate sticky and breakable connections between contacting particles . in granular physics , there are many prior studies to investigate cohesive granular system @xcite . their simulation methods are an extension of the discrete element method @xcite ; the rolling friction has been additionally included into the contact model . though our target is a suspension system , the spirit of the modeling is almost the same . in granular physics , there are also some studies on compression of cohesive powders @xcite , which obtained many common insights with our study . 2d simulation results are reported here . one obvious benefit of studying 2d systems is easy recognition of the structure changes . though the density - density correlation is an effective tool to capture special sorts of heterogeneous structures , it might not capture all features of random structures . 2d experimental system has also been studied to observe the microstructure change under shear @xcite . though we do not expect qualitative difference between 2d and 3d systems , this point should be checked by 3d simulation of the same modeling , which we hope to report in future work . we use fractal aggregation models to generate the initial configurations . networks of particles are formed in a rectangle box of sides @xmath13 and @xmath14 with periodic boundary conditions . we combine two processes . the first step models a formation process of fractal clusters in the dilute limit ; the reaction - limited hierarchical cluster - cluster aggregation model was employed @xcite . each cluster consists of @xmath15 particles . the second step is to build a network with them . @xmath16 of the generated clusters are randomly placed in the box while avoiding overlap with each other , and then they are moved with a random walk . collisions of clusters always lead to coalescence , so a single cluster is formed in the periodic boundary space after a while ( see , e.g. , [ fig_snapshots ] ( a ) , below ) . thus , we can generate random networks of a packing fraction @xmath17 , where @xmath18 is the radius of a particle . one can deduce structural features of the formed networks by evaluating the density - density correlation function @xmath19 ( see appendix [ appendix_density - correlation ] ) . we prepared 10 samples of @xmath20 particles in a box @xmath21 . the packing fraction is @xmath22 . [ 223812_16oct12 ] shows the averages and standard deviations of their correlation functions @xmath19 . a power - law decay of correlation is seen in the finite range @xmath23 . the slope indicates fractal dimension @xmath24 , which is almost the same fractal dimension as the clusters generated by the aggregation model . though a crossover behavior is seen in the range @xmath25 , the correlation decays out after that . prepared in the box @xmath26 . the averages and standard deviations were taken over 10 samples . the red line indicates the slope corresponding to @xmath27 . ] our contact model is designed to simulate strongly aggregated particle gels . the contact model used in the original discrete element method ( dem ) @xcite takes into account friction forces for the sliding mode , which is essential to simulate dense granular systems . for cohesive granular systems , the rolling friction has been added @xcite . this extension is also required to reproduce the behavior of particle gels having chain - like local structures . our implementation is similar to the model used for cohesive granular systems . since the dynamic friction , which is modeled in typical contact models , is unclear for colloidal systems , this part is different in our model . though a brief summary will be given below , the detailed descriptions of our implementation were given in another paper @xcite . we assume that interactions acting among particles are only short range forces . no interparticle interaction acts between two particles before getting into contact . once the gap between two particles becomes zero , a cohesive force starts to act between them . for simplicity , our simulation model assumes immediate bond generation , which is expected to give the upper limit of the consolidation behavior . when compression - rate dependence is problem , the condition of bond generation can be crucial . finite compression rates can suppress bond generation , leading to a weaker consolidation . the forces and moments are assumed to be hookian : let us consider the contact interactions between particles @xmath28 and @xmath29 . the center - to - center distance between them is @xmath30 , and the gap @xmath31 . the normal ( separation / overlap ) displacement is related to the normal element of the contact force , @xmath32 where @xmath33 for @xmath34 and @xmath35 otherwise . @xmath36 is the normal unit vector defined by @xmath37 . the second term of eq . is added to avoid significant overlap between particles . the sliding displacement @xmath38 relates to the tangential part of the contact force , @xmath39 the sliding displacement @xmath38 is the tangential projection of the deviation vector between the original contact points @xmath40 and @xmath41 , @xmath42 where the vectors @xmath43 and @xmath44 indicate the original contact points from the respective centers of the particles and are fixed with them . the bending angle @xmath45 ( @xmath46 is related to the moment acting on the rolling mode , @xmath47 these elastic relations are broken when the force or moment exceed threshold values . we assume simple criteria given with three threshold values : the critical normal force @xmath48 , critical sliding force @xmath49 , and critical rolling moment @xmath50 . when the pulling force exceeds the value ; @xmath51 , the bond is broken and the two particles separate . when the tangential force or rolling torque exceeds the threshold value ; @xmath52 or @xmath53 , both the sliding displacement @xmath54 and rolling angle @xmath55 are reset to zero , which releases the tangential parts of the stored energy . the maximum strains are related to the threshold forces and moment as follows : @xmath56 , @xmath57 , and @xmath58 . it must be noted that in our simple model the bond strength of the tangential mode does not depend on the normal load . however , the enlarged contact area due to the normal load may change the tangential strengths @xcite . our neglect of this effect can affect simulations at higher packing fractions . a particle @xmath28 may be in contact with other particles @xmath29 . the total contact force and torque acting on the particle @xmath28 can be written as follows : @xmath59 particles are immersed in a viscous fluid , so that hydrodynamic interactions also act on them . for micro or nano - sized particles , the particle reynolds number is extremely small , so the stokes equations should be used to evaluate the hydrodynamic interactions among many particles @xcite . however , we do not go into the detailed hydrodynamics here . hydrodynamic interactions in the stokes regime are scaled with the velocities of particles . if the slow compression limit is considered , flows induced by particle movements are negligible in comparison with the contact forces . they just work as energy dissipators . indeed , some experimental observations suggest that a solvent flow does not contribute the rearrangements of particles in a slow sedimentation of colloidal gels @xcite . as an approximation , the stokes formula is used in this work ; the force and torque acting on a particle @xmath28 are proportional to the translational velocity @xmath60 and angular velocity @xmath61 , respectively : @xmath62 where @xmath63 is the viscosity of the solvent . since the interparticle interactions are assumed to be sufficiently stronger than thermal agitations , brownian forces are also neglected in this work . consequently , newton s equations of motions are given as the sum of the contact forces and hydrodynamic interactions , @xmath64 since particle inertia is very small for colloidal systems , it is a good approximation to neglect the inertia terms ( the left hand sides ) and solve the force balance equations @xcite . as explained later ( sect . [ 141932_2nov12 ] ) , however , we took a different strategy to find the static equilibriums . the compression is externally controlled . for simplicity , we focus on examining the uni - axial compression along the @xmath65 axis in this work . the periodic boundaries at @xmath66 and @xmath67 of the simulation box introduced in section [ sec_preparation_fractal_gel ] are replaced by two flat walls . these walls can move along the @xmath65-axis like pistons , and they are assumed to be semipermeable ; liquid passes through them , while particles do not . when particles get in contact with the walls , they are rigidly fixed there ; particles contacting with the wall move together as one object . the periodic boundaries along the @xmath68-axis are still used during the compression simulation . the stress - controlled compression , in which an external stress is applied to cause the compression , is similar to typical experimental situations , such as osmotic compression . however , due to the higher efficiency of the simulation , we use strain - controlled compression . this also allows us to have better statistics in our data . this work investigates the slow compression limit ; the time scale of compression is much longer than the relaxation time of particle motions . in this case , the results obtained with the strain - controlled compression are essentially equivalent to the ones with the stress - controlled compression . the compressive stress balancing the network resistance is evaluated from the total forces acting on the walls from particles . since particles directly connecting to the walls ( called wall particles ) no longer have any mechanical freedom , the forces between wall particles @xmath28 and particles @xmath29 contacting with them are summed up as follows : @xmath69 when we refer to `` compressive stress '' in this 2d simulation work , our simulation box is assumed to have a thickness of particle diameter @xmath70 . therefore , the compressive stresses are given as @xmath71 and @xmath72 . our compression simulations are performed in a stepwise manner in order to obtain numbers of equilibriums by a single simulation run . compression steps are given by two increment ratios @xmath73 and @xmath74 ; the initial compression from @xmath75 to @xmath76 is given as @xmath77 , and the @xmath78-th packing fraction as @xmath79 . the increment ratio @xmath74 is determined with the number of steps @xmath80 from @xmath81 to @xmath82 : @xmath83 . the strain - controlled compression is simply realized by translations of the walls with the velocity @xmath84 , so that the packing fraction increases continuously . when it reaches a target packing fraction @xmath85 , the translations of the walls are suspended to await the equilibrium . usually , the excess stress due to the quickness of the compression is relaxed by spreading the deformations into the entire system . the following criteria are examined every @xmath86 time steps of the simulation : * the relative difference between the top and bottom stresses is smaller than a threshold value @xmath87 : @xmath88 , where @xmath89 is the average , @xmath90 . * the relative change of the compressive stress for the last @xmath91 steps is smaller than a threshold value @xmath92 : @xmath93 , where @xmath94 is the one of @xmath86 steps before . * no bonds were broken for the last @xmath86 steps . thus , the compressive stress @xmath95 balancing the network of packing fraction @xmath85 can be determined . once @xmath95 is determined , the compression continues again for the next target @xmath96 . in order to reduce finite size effects , the simulation box needs to involve a sufficient number of typical structures . the compressive stress to balance sparse networks is very low , and the most of particles are slightly stressed . in this case , the relaxation time is significantly long . usually , the overdamped equations of motion , which are given by dropping the right hand sides of eqs . due to the negligible inertia of particles , are used to simulate colloidal suspensions . however , we have taken a different approach for efficiency . as restricting our scope in the slow compression , we may be allowed to optimize some parameters for a faster simulation . in the slow compression limit , velocities of particles are also slow . in this case , the contact forces dominate the displacements of particles . this is why a reduced viscosity @xmath97 still leads to the same equilibrium configurations with a shorter time . the following viscosity gives the critical damped motion in terms of the rolling mode . @xmath98 though it is not simple problem to find the best value , we used @xmath99 in the equation of motion . this arbitrary selection of the viscosity is justified only if the compression is considered slow enough . this point will be checked in sect . [ 141944_21nov12 ] . the introduced 2d contact model ( see sect . [ 112400_22dec12 ] ) is relatively simple , but it still has 7 parameters to be given . traditional experimental measurements to characterize the particle - particle adhesion determine the pull - off force @xcite , which corresponds to @xmath48 in this work . in recent years the atomic force microscope became a reliable method , which provides more precise data for normal force - displacement relationships @xcite . however , there are fewer experimental measurements to determine the parameters of the other modes @xcite . the experimental measurement of the three - point bending test by using optical tweezers is remarkable @xcite , which provides parameters for the rolling mode , @xmath50 and @xmath100 ( or @xmath101 ) . in any case , all parameters for a single system have never been determined so far . thus our knowledge of the contact forces is still limited , so that we need to set the parameters by hand . but , we may have a certain level of confidence by reproducing a similar bending behavior with the three - point bending measurements . our selected parameters are intended to imitate the observed mechanical behavior : a small extent of elastic deformation and irreversible reorganization due to a critical moment . we have selected two sets of the parameters called bond 1 and bond 2 , which are shown in [ bond_parameters ] . bond 1 has the same strengths for the three modes , while bond 2 is 5 times stronger for the normal and sliding mode than the rolling mode . both have the same maximum strains ; elastic deformations give 5% of the radius . 12cmlccc & & bond 1 & bond 2 + normal strength & @xmath102 & 1 & 5 + sliding strength & @xmath103 & 1 & 5 + rolling strength & @xmath104 & 1 & 1 + normal strain & @xmath105 & 0.05 & 0.05 + sliding strain & @xmath106 & 0.05 & 0.05 + rolling strain & @xmath107 & 0.05 & 0.05 + parameter in eq . & @xmath108 & @xmath109 & @xmath109 + the simulation for the three - point bending test consists of the following three steps : 1 . prepare a linear chain under no stress . apply the forces @xmath110 at the central particle and @xmath111 at both the ends , and wait for equilibrium . 3 . stop applying the forces , and wait for equilibrium . the three snapshots i iii in [ fig_three - point - bending ] ( a ) and ( b ) show the configurations of the respective equilibriums of the bond 1 simulation . though the data is not shown here , the results of bond 2 are similar . the two results were obtained with two slightly different forces : ( a ) @xmath112 , ( b ) @xmath113 . if the external force did not reach the threshold , the initial linear shape remained after the test ( see ( a)iii ) . on the other hand , if the bond stress exceeded the threshold value , some irreversible rearrangement took place . as a result , the initial shape was not recovered ( see ( b)iii ) . in the latter case , the bending deformation proceeds until the moment acting on the broken bond becomes smaller than the threshold due to the increase of the bending angle . this is why the small increment of the applied forces leads to the visible difference of the deformation ( see ii of ( a ) and ( b ) in [ fig_three - point - bending ] ) . the slight bending deformation seen by ( a)ii is close to the limit of elastic deformation of this cluster . thus , the parameters were chosen to simulate some brittle behavior of colloidal aggregates ; the local structures remain unless bond breakups take place . in this test , the rolling mode of the contact model is responsible for the cluster s deformation . ) is applied , the elastic deformation is seen ( a ) , and when it is slightly larger ( @xmath114 ) , the bond breakups cause the plastic deformation ( b ) . ] the initial configurations ( sect . [ sec_preparation_fractal_gel ] ) are fractal - like networks with a packing fraction @xmath115 , where @xmath26 and @xmath116 for bond 1 simulation . since the calculation cost of the bond 2 simulation is higher , smaller system size , @xmath117 and @xmath118 , is simulated . the first target packing fraction is set to @xmath119 . the increment ratio and the number of compression steps are @xmath120 and @xmath121 , respectively . the compression finally reaches to @xmath122 . the relaxation time depends on the parameters of the bonds . to account for this , the wall velocities are set to @xmath123 and @xmath124 for the bond 1 and bond 2 simulations , respectively , where @xmath125 . in the equilibrium checks ( sect . [ sec_uniaxial_compression ] ) after every @xmath126 time integration steps , @xmath127 is used for both the simulations , and @xmath128 and @xmath129 for bond 1 and for bond 2 simulations , respectively . as explained in sect . [ 141932_2nov12 ] , it is useful to introduce artificial parameters to speed up the compression simulation . therefore we started to check that our method reproduced the quasi - static compression as expected . if compression is too fast , the regions near the wall are easily crushed . so , we examined the uniformity of the deformations along the compression axis . the uniformity of compression can be seen via the @xmath65 dependence of the packing fraction @xmath130 , which is defined as the packing fraction in the sliced ranges : @xmath131 ( where @xmath132 was chosen ) . due to the heterogeneous structure and finite system size , the uniformity can not be judged with a single compression simulation . this is why we took the averages over 10 simulation runs with different initial configurations . [ 232801_24oct12 ] shows the results for the bond 1 simulations , where every second compression step is plotted . although we can see an undesirable drop at the middle of the first compression ( @xmath133 ) , the compression is satisfactorily uniform along @xmath65-axis after that . the steep drops at both the edges relate to the integrity of the walls ; particles connecting to the walls are not allowed to move ( see section [ sec_uniaxial_compression ] ) . equivalent results were also obtained with the bond 2 simulation with a slower compaction speed ( see sect . [ 100129_27dec12 ] ) . dependence of packing fractions @xmath130 are shown for every second compression step ( @xmath134 , @xmath135 ) . the solid line indicates the initial configuration . ] once the system reaches a static equilibrium under a compressive stress @xmath89 , further compression requires a finite increment : @xmath136 . therefore , the balancing stress @xmath89 can be considered as the strength of the gel network , i.e. , the _ compressive yield stress _ @xmath2 @xcite . a simulation run of the stepwise compression ( sect . [ 141932_2nov12 ] ) finds a series of @xmath2 _ vs. _ @xmath4 relations . [ fig_compression_curves ] plots the results of the bond 1 and bond 2 simulations , where the unit of the stress is @xmath137 . the compression from @xmath138 to @xmath139 shows wide ranges of @xmath2 ( about four decades ) . these results indicate significantly rapid compressive - strain hardening . is evaluated by the simulations of stepwise compression . its averages and standard deviations taken over 10 runs are shown . the red squares represent the result of the bond 1 simulations , and the blue circles of the bond 2 simulations . the dotted curve shows the fitting function of eq . , and ( solid and dashed ) straight lines show the power - law functions . the arrows indicate ranges of the three regimes : ( i ) elastic - dominant regime , ( ii ) single - mode plastic regime , and ( iii ) multi - mode plastic regime . the average exponents @xmath140 are written on the figure . ] simulation provides various information , which allow us to understand the compression . some of data indicate that there are three regimes in the compression process , which will be seen in the following section . [ [ bond - creation ] ] bond creation + + + + + + + + + + + + + bond creation is essential to understand the irreversible consolidation of the compression . due to heterogeneous structure of the networks , the compressive deformations are not affine . consequently , two separated particles may come in contact and newly bond with each other . the mean contact number per particle reflects new bond creations . the result of bond 1 simulation is shown in [ fig_contact_number_energy ] ( a ) . the compression continuously changes the value from 2 to about 4 with increasing rate , so we do not see distinct regimes in this . . the rates are obtained by normalizing with the compressive strain @xmath141 . the averages and standard deviations are taken over 10 runs of the bond 1 simulation . ] [ [ stored - and - dissipated - energies ] ] stored and dissipated energies + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the bonds have finite strength , and they can be broken up or irreversibly reorganized by certain applied stress . such events cause the plastic deformation of the networks , which contribute the irreversibility . the translations of the wall by external stress inject energy into the system . part of the energy are stored in contact bonds first and dissipated as bond ruptures . we can see this energy flow in the successive increments of the total stored and dissipated energies for each compression step ( [ fig_contact_number_energy ] ( b ) ) . the total dissipated energy exceeds the total stored energy at the early stage , @xmath142 . accordingly , we can identify the boundary of two regimes : elastic dominant regime ( i ) and plastic regime ( ii ) . [ [ bond - rupture ] ] bond rupture + + + + + + + + + + + + the accumulated numbers of the bond ruptures @xmath143 were recorded as distinguishing the stress modes causing the breakup , where the @xmath144 indicates ` connection break ' , ` sliding ' , or ` rolling ' . the rupture rates @xmath145 can be defined as the number of breakups normalized with the total particle number and relative compressive strain : @xmath146 [ bond_ruptures ] shows the results of both the bond 1 and bond 2 simulations . at lower packing fractions , only rupture events occur due to rolling . this indicates that compression of loose networks is achieved by bending deformations of particulate chains . when the compaction reaches a certain point , further compression requires sliding or separation of contacting particles . the onset of this mixed - rupture mode depends on the parameters of the contact forces . the connection breaks start between @xmath147 and @xmath148 in bond 1 simulations , and between @xmath149 and @xmath150 in bond 2 simulations . they split the plastic deformation into two parts : single - mode plastic regime ( ii ) below and multi - mode plastic regime ( iii ) above . are compared for two types of bond : ( a ) bond 1 and ( b ) bond 2 . the bond ruptures are recorded by the causing stress . the rates of the separation due to normal forces are plotted by squares , the ones of the regeneration due to sliding forces or rolling moments by triangles and circles , respectively . ] the date shown in the previous section indicate that three distinct behaviors can be recognized in the compression process . let us discuss them one by one here . [ [ i - elastic - dominant - regime ] ] ( i ) elastic dominant regime + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + there is no percolation path in the 10 initial configurations of @xmath151 ( see [ fig_snapshots ] ( a ) ) . hence , no compressive stress is required to compress them in the slow compression limit . after some compaction , the first spanning path appears , and the network begins to resist the compressive stress . at the gel point , a single - linking chain ( percolation path ) resists the external stress between top and bottom . this system - spanning cluster is deformed as a whole , so that strains of single bonds can be very small . therefore , the dominant response to the external stress is elastic deformation ; the work by compression is stored in the contact bonds ( see [ fig_contact_number_energy ] ( b ) ) . in this range , the power - law form expanding at the gel point @xmath152 is suitable to capture the @xmath2-@xmath4 curve @xcite : @xmath153 in [ fig_compression_curves ] , the dotted curve shows the fitting result with the function for the bond 1 simulation data of @xmath154 . the fitting gives the extrapolated gel point as @xmath155 . the evaluated exponent @xmath156 represents some nonlinearity . the compression induces some new contacts , so that the numbers of percolation paths are increased . the rise of resistance due to such increasing paths can be a plausible interpretation of the nonlinearity in this elastic - dominant regime . it must be noted that our simulation results in this range might have large statistical fluctuations . the typical length scale of the structure is comparable to the system size ( compare the drawn circle and the box size in [ fig_snapshots ] ( a ) ) , and consequently only a few paths enter the averaging . therefore , the gel point @xmath152 obtained in the above fitting has only limited significance . [ [ ii - single - mode - plastic - regime ] ] ( ii ) single - mode plastic regime + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + by considering two data ( [ fig_contact_number_energy ] ( b ) and [ bond_ruptures ] ) , we identified the single - mode plastic regime in the ranges : @xmath157 for bond 1 simulations and @xmath158 for bond 2 simulations . this @xmath4-dependence of the consolidation behavior has been discussed with a scaling concept @xcite . the power - law relationships of @xmath2 and @xmath4 have been also observed in experiments @xcite : @xmath159 a similar power - law behavior can be seen in our simulation results ( [ fig_compression_curves ] ) . the least squares fitting gives the almost same exponents : @xmath160 and @xmath161 , for the bond 1 and bond 2 results , respectively . let us look more closely at this regime . [ fig_snapshots ] ( b ) shows the configuration of particles at the beginning of this range ( @xmath162 ) in a bond 1 simulation . at the gel point , a single linking path spanned the entire box . in contrast , multi - linking structures span the system here . since the maximum bending moment of a random - walk chain is proportional to the inverse of the chain size , the supportable loads of larger loops are smaller . the variety of the mesh sizes indicates a heterogeneity of the local strengths . though large empty spaces remain , the relatively dense meshes fill the space from the bottom to the top ( [ fig_snapshots ] ( b ) ) . further compression requires destroying a part of them . as shown in [ bond_ruptures ] , the rolling - mode ruptures are the only rupture events seen in this range . therefore , the size of the responsible mesh structures determines the compressive yield stress @xmath2 . thus , in the single - mode plastic regime , the length scale is essential ; the compression breaks larger and weaker structures into smaller and more robust structures . fractal model was employed to give the length scale from the packing fraction @xcite ( see sect . [ sec_structure_compression ] ) . according to the nature of a fractal , a portion of a fractal cluster is also a small fractal cluster . if the compression of fractal networks causes only fragmentation of fractal clusters into smaller pieces , it can be expected that the correlation length is decreased while keeping the same fractal dimension . this optimistic expectation leads us to employ the fractal model for the compression problem . we will check this point in the next section . , whose packing fraction is @xmath22 . the configurations ( b ) and ( c ) show the beginning of the _ single - mode plastic regime _ ( @xmath162 ) and the _ multi - mode plastic regime _ ( @xmath163 ) , respectively , and ( d ) shows @xmath164 . the red circles express the correlation lengths ; their diameters are @xmath165 , which will be evaluated in the later section ( sect . [ sec_structure_compression ] ) . ] [ [ iii - multi - mode - plastic - regime ] ] ( iii ) multi - mode plastic regime + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the onset of connection breaks indicates that the compression enters a new regime . this transition point depends on the parameters of the bonds . we consider the data above @xmath163 and @xmath166 in bond 1 and 2 simulations as the multi - mode plastic regime . in these ranges , the compression curves look to follow a power law . however , the evaluated exponents are totally different with each other : @xmath167 and @xmath168 . it is by chance that the exponent of bond 2 simulations is similar with the one in the single - mode plastic regime . the exponent in this regime is easily affected by the parameters of the contact model , that implies absence of a simple scaling law . [ fig_snapshots ] ( c ) depicts the beginning of this regime of a bond 1 simulation ( @xmath163 ) . there are still large loops remaining , but they look like voids due to the denser surroundings . here , we can easily find dense meshes and trimers ( a trimer can be considered as the building block of a close packing ) . if they are next to each other , the entire object can be considered as a lump . the same scenario of the _ single - mode plastic regime _ seems to work ; denser mesh domains are piled up over the entire system . however , due to the finite size of particles , the mechanical response of denser meshes is not the same as looser ones . the crush of them involves sliding ruptures and connection breaks , which are seen in [ bond_ruptures ] . since the criteria of destruction includes the all three modes , the compression curve depends on the details of the contact force . this regime terminates due to the close packing , where rigidity of particles prevents reorganizations of particles . since our simplified contact model is not accurate for that , we can not specify the upper end of the range . during compression , separated particles can newly come into contact . consequently , mesh size decreases as @xmath4 is increased by compression . if we employ the fractal model @xcite to explain the @xmath4-dependence of @xmath2 , the structure change needs to follow a special manner ; the fractal dimension @xmath0 characterizing the local structures does not depend on the packing fraction @xmath4 , and the correlation length @xmath1 is a decreasing function of the packing fraction @xmath4 , @xmath169 . the fractal dimension @xmath0 can be estimated from the density - density correlation function @xmath19 ( see [ appendix_density - correlation ] ) . [ fig_ddc ] shows averages of the correlation functions @xmath19 of every second compression step , @xmath134 ( @xmath170 ) , of the bond 1 simulation results . the results of the bond 2 simulations were almost the same . the correlation of the density is mostly decreasing functions of the two - point distance @xmath171 . the correlation of the configuration before compression is the largest and reaches the farthest distance ( solid line ) . the compression reduces this correlation in a continuous manner . of compressed networks are shown . the solid line shows the initial configuration @xmath172 , and the dashed or dotted lines the every second compression step @xmath134 ( @xmath173 ) . they are averaged values over 10 runs of simulations . ] the fractal correlation appears as a straight slope in the log - log plot of @xmath19 , i.e. , @xmath174 . though the straight lines can be recognized in the initial configuration , the compressed networks show slightly curved lines . in order to make them easier to see , we introduce the fractal dimension profile @xmath175 from the local slope of the correlation function at each distance @xmath171 : @xmath176 the results are shown in [ 143513_26nov12 ] ( a ) . as mentioned in sect . [ sec_preparation_fractal_gel ] , the initial configurations ( solid line ) consist of three parts : a fractal plateau ( @xmath177 ) indicating @xmath178 , crossover range ( @xmath179 ) , and 2d - like uniform network ( @xmath180 ) . thus , though the recognizable fractal plateau is limited , the @xmath175 profiles of the initial configurations agree with the expected behavior as fractal networks . evaluated by eq . are plotted . the solid line shows the initial configuration @xmath172 , and the dashed or dotted solid lines the every second compression step @xmath134 ( @xmath173 ) . the numerical values indicate the packing fractions . ( b ) the @xmath4-dependence of the correlation length @xmath181 ( see the definition in the text ) . ] once the networks are compressed , the fractal correlations are affected immediately . indeed , the first compression step of our simulation ( @xmath182 ) shows the entire change of @xmath175 : a narrower plateau indicating a rise of the fractal dimension , and shifts of the crossover and uniform ranges to shorter lengths . these results suggest that not only long - distance correlations , but short - distance correlations can be affected by the compressive deformation at the early stage . this tendency continues for the further compression . though the profiles @xmath175 for the compressed networks indicate that mono - fractal assumption does not work , it may be worth determining the @xmath4 dependence of the correlation length @xmath1 . since the slopes of @xmath19 in [ fig_ddc ] are not constant , it is ambiguous to determine @xmath1 from them . in our purpose , we may consider the correlation length as the length scale where the network looks uniform . the typical length scale for the uniformity can be determined by evaluating fluctuation of local densities @xcite . the local densities are defined by boxes of size @xmath183 , which are denoted by @xmath184 . if the size of box is larger than the correlation length @xmath1 , the local densities show little fluctuation ; the system looks uniform . thus , the standard deviation of the local densities normalized by the global density , @xmath185 , measures the uniformity . due to the finite system size , we compare here the lengths showing a common finite fluctuation , @xmath186 . the actual values of the correlation lengths @xmath1 should be larger than the evaluated lengths @xmath187 , so a common arbitrary factor may be given to adjust . [ 143513_26nov12 ] ( b ) shows the result of the lengths @xmath187 satisfying @xmath188 . we find a power - law relation between @xmath1 and @xmath4 with an exponent @xmath189 . the obtained exponent is a little bit smaller than the fractal assumption : @xmath190 . the evaluated correlation lengths , @xmath191 , are also shown as the diameter of the circles drawn in [ fig_snapshots ] . we focused on investigating compression of particle gels . inspired by scaling theory for polymer gels , the fractal model has been introduced to explain the packing fraction dependence of particle gels rheology @xcite , and referred for the compression process @xcite . the model assumes that the structure of a particle gel is fractal network . however , the simple question whether a particle gel under compression is fractal network or not , has left unanswered . we have aimed to answer this question by introducing a particle - scale simulation model in the limit of strongly aggregated particle gels . in this case , the cohesive force among contacting particles is assumed to be so strong that brownian forces do not affect the structural evolution of gels . our simulation reproduced the reasonable consolidation behaviors as @xmath4 _ vs_. @xmath2 relationships in the case of quasi - static compression . by monitoring various particle - scale information , i.e. , mean contact number , stored / dissipated energy , and number of bond ruptures , we identified the three distinct regimes : ( i ) elastic dominant regime , ( ii ) single - mode plastic regime , and ( iii ) multi - mode plastic regime . at the gel point , there are many `` dead end '' branches , where the particles in such branches do not contribute to the strength of the network @xmath2 . compression makes separated particles come into contact , so that the mesh size becomes smaller and smaller . this explanation is already known and qualitatively true for the most part . such shrinkage of the typical length scale causes a transition of the local mechanical response from ( ii ) to ( iii ) in the plastic regimes . while the length scale is large enough , the rolling mode is the responsible for the deformation . at a certain length scale , the sliding and normal modes become more important for further compression . thus , we confirmed that a single regime could never cover the wide range of packing fractions in spite of subtle appearance in the @xmath4 _ vs_. @xmath2 relationships . the simulation results also provided an insight that heterogeneity in the local mesh sizes plays some roles in the way of reorganization under compression and overall network strength . mechanical correlations ( connectivity ) determine which parts of the network are destroyed under an applied stress . if a percolation path consisting of robust domains is built , they support a large fraction of the applied stress . in this case , the weakest domain in the path is most probable to be destroyed . this restructuring yields a smaller and robuster domain , which results in the reinforcement of the percolation path . however , such mechanism is subtle because compression is not continuing deformation and tends to reduce the heterogeneity . in order to see whether the fractal assumption remains or not in particle gels under compression , we evaluated the density - density correlation @xmath19 for the simulation results . the evaluated fractal dimension profile @xmath175 says that compression affects both the local structure and correlation length in the early stage . thus , our results are contradictory to the application of the fractal model to compression processes . however , the fractal dimension profiles @xmath175 show a systematic change in the _ single - mode plastic regime_. this result seems to indicate required ingredients to upgrade the fractal model for compression processes . the simulation model of this work is simple ; we neglect various factors in real particle gels to make clear the focus of study and to optimize the simulation speed in order to achieve large system sizes . for example , we employed a simple contact model , which depends on only configuration of particles and has no history dependence . however , cohesion between particles in real system may be more complex , e.g. the bonding or breakup may require certain time periods . in order to deal with such systems , our quasi - static simulation framework needs to be extended . this extension is relevant for the future work because there are many experimental works investigating on the time / rate - depending aspects of colloidal gels and yield stress fluids @xcite . the authors would like to thank prof . morton denn for valuable suggestions on the manuscript , and rs would like to express his gratitude to prof . richard buscall for fruitful discussions , valuable suggestions , and warm encouragement . in order to study colloidal gels , we need to have some tools to characterize random structured systems . the density - density correlation function @xmath192 is used for this purpose . the local density function @xmath193 is defined as follows : @xmath194 by taking the average over the entire space of the system , the density - density correlation function @xmath192 is defined as follows : @xmath195 when the system is isotropic , the correlation is given in terms of the distance , @xmath196 , which can be obtained by taking averages over all directions : @xmath197 the correlation function @xmath19 can be regarded as a conditional probability to find particles . since it is normalized by the entire probability , the value 1 means no correlation . it is known that strongly aggregated gels have structures involving fractal correlations . the local structures are equivalent to fractal flocs . for fractal flocs , the relation between the number of particles @xmath198 and the radius of gyration @xmath199 follows a power - law : @xmath200 the exponent @xmath0 is called fractal dimension . therefore , the average packing - fraction profile of the clusters is given as follows : @xmath201 where @xmath171 is the distance from the center of mass . since fractal gels can be considered as cluster - filling networks , the local structure should coincide with this density profile . consequently , the density - density correlation function @xmath19 has the same functional form : @xmath202 . in a fractal gel , the correlation reaches a finite distance , which is called the correlation length @xmath1 . for @xmath203 , the correlation does not remain : @xmath204 if the local densities are evaluated in boxes of size @xmath1 , the system should look uniform . 52ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.106.118302 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) @noop , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) in @noop _ _ , ( , ) chap . @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.99.028303 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop _ _ ( , , ) in @noop _ _ ( ) pp . @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop * * , ( ) @noop _ _ ( , ) in @noop _ _ , ( )
Abstract: | [
"the compressive yield stress of particle gels shows a highly nonlinear dependence on the packing fraction . we have studied continuous compression processes , and discussed the packing fraction dependence with the particle scale rearrangements . the 2d simulation of uniaxial compression was applied to fractal networks , and the required compressive stresses were evaluated for a wide range of packing fractions that approached close packing . the compression acts to reduce the size of the characteristic structural entities ( i.e. the correlation length of the structure ) . we observed three stages of compression : ( i ) elastic - dominant regime ; ( ii ) single - mode plastic regime , where the network strengths are determined by the typical length scale and the rolling mode ; and ( iii ) multi - mode plastic regime , where sliding mode and connection breaks are important . we also investigated the way of losing the fractal correlation under compression . it turns out that both fractal dimension @xmath0 and correlation length @xmath1 start to change from the early stage of compression , which is different from the usual assumption in theoretical models ."
] | 8,984 | 8,984 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: einstein s theory of general relativity is described by a complicated set of coupled , nonlinear partial differential equations . like the maxwell equations of classical electromagnetism , the einstein equations are over - determined , and can be separated into hyperbolic evolution and elliptic constraint equations , as in the arnowitt deser misner ( adm ) decomposition @xcite . the complexity of these equations is such that analytic solutions have been found for only very special configurations , and numerical studies arguably provide the only means to explore a wide variety of astrophysical and theoretically significant problems @xcite . unfortunately , these numerical solutions are often prone to various instabilities , which we divide into three classes : ( 1 ) continuum instabilities , ( 2 ) numerical instabilities and ( 3 ) artificial long - term `` instabilities '' ( alti ) . _ continuum instabilities _ exist in the formulation of the continuum problem ( and thus are naturally reflected in any consistent numerical scheme ) , and are characterized by the solution itself or some perturbation of it either `` blowing up '' at a finite time or growing fast in time . these instabilities may reflect physical phenomena , such as turbulence in fluids or the threshold of black hole formation @xcite , or may be an artifact of the formulation of the problem . for instance , ill - posed problems suffer from these instabilities , which also manifest themselves as numerical ones ( see @xcite , and @xcite for an illustration in numerical relativity ) . _ numerical instabilities _ are characterized by errors that , at a fixed time , _ increase _ as the discretization scale is decreased . these instabilities are present in many discretization schemes for well - posed problems that appear `` natural '' , such as the forward - time , centered - space scheme for the advection equation . finally , _ alti _ are sometimes exhibited even by numerically _ stable _ implementations , whenever errors grow too fast for the desired simulation time - scale and available computational resources . although these may not be instabilities in the strict sense , given that as defined here they are not present at the continuum and do go away with resolution , they are problematic in practice as they limit the time - length of a reliable simulation . in this paper we focus on this long - term error growth together with the application of the techniques described in @xcite , which throughout this work we refer to as paper i. the stability of finite difference approximations ( fdas ) for simple initial value problems ( ivp ) with constant coefficients and periodic boundaries is often analyzed in discrete fourier space , by examining the norm of the amplification matrix . this method , however , does not generalize in a straightforward way to more complicated problems , such as those with variable coefficients or those with boundaries . a more powerful technique is based on the energy method @xcite , also used to identify well - posed continuum problems . this method can be used in all problems for which the continuum energy method applies , e.g. , quasi - linear parabolic and symmetric hyperbolic partial differential equations with appropriate boundary conditions . the discrete formulation reproduces the continuum analysis , including the calculation of a discrete energy estimate , which can be used to meet sufficient conditions for a stable numerical method . combining these estimates with the consistency of the discrete system with the continuum problem , stability of the linear problem is equivalent to convergence via the lax equivalence theorem @xcite . while our focus in general relativity is on the nonlinear einstein equations , stability of the linearized equations is obviously a necessary step for solving non - linear problems , in particular those with smooth solutions . in the absence of matter , smooth solutions are indeed expected in general relativity when appropriate slicing conditions are used @xcite . as described in paper i , a discrete energy estimate can be obtained when using finite difference operators that satisfy _ summation by parts _ ( sbp ) @xcite , a discrete version of integration by parts , as well as appropriate boundary conditions @xcite and time integrators @xcite . paper i presents and extends these techniques in the context of numerical relativity . in this paper we demonstrate these techniques using some common test problems employed in the field . we evolve klein gordon scalar fields and maxwell fields on fixed schwarzschild spacetimes . we also consider gauge wave spacetimes , obtained via coordinate transformations of flat spacetime . we show that we naturally obtain stable and convergent numerical schemes by construction , even when an inner boundary is used to remove the black hole singularity ( black hole excision ) @xcite . a second goal of this paper is to understand some causes of long - term error growth ( alti ) , and ways of eliminating or minimizing it by achieving _ strict stability _ @xcite . numerical solutions of the einstein equations are frequently plagued by such long - term errors . since at least some of these appear in numerically stable implementations , their cause is often attributed to the formulation of the equations . while this may be the case in a number of problems , as discussed below , some numerical experiments of simple differential equations with no continuum instabilities also display this same artificial long - term instability even when discretized in a numerically stable way. hence , it is important to devise _ numerical _ techniques to control this spurious growth in the numerical error . we find that this spurious error growth is allowed in the absence of sharp energy estimates for the discrete problem . this can arise , from among other reasons , because the discrete derivatives fail to satisfy the leibnitz rule . with this observation in mind , we discuss here a method to remedy some of these problems by constructing schemes that suppress excitations of alti . this work is organized as follows : we first summarize , in section ii , some results from paper i , in order to introduce some notation . section [ strict ] discusses the notion of strict stability , and we present simple examples of `` natural '' schemes that are numerically stable but not strictly stable , for which the errors grow fast in time . we then explain the basic strategy to achieve strict stability , and show how this eliminates alti . in section [ equations ] we present some test problems from numerical relativity : three - dimensional scalar and electromagnetic fields propagating on a fixed schwarzschild black hole geometry , and one - dimensional perturbations of a dynamical slicing of flat spacetime ( `` gauge wave '' ) . the first cases allow us to test black hole excision , while the gauge wave has a time dependent background without a sharp energy estimate . however , a sharp energy estimate does exist for the subsidiary constraint system , and it can be used to understand the nature of the alti and suppress them . although more work would need to be done , these observations and ideas could be useful when evolving einstein s equations in more complicated situations . in section [ simulations ] we present numerical simulations of the systems discussed in section [ equations ] . finally , in appendix [ smallness ] we discuss cubical excision boundaries for black hole spacetimes . we first review the construction of numerically stable finite - difference schemes using the discrete energy method for linear , symmetric hyperbolic initial - boundary value problems ( ibvps ) with maximally dissipative boundary conditions . while the discussion here is brief , further information can be found in the standard text by gustaffsson , kreiss , and oliger @xcite , works by olsson @xcite , and paper i , for their particular application in numerical relativity . sufficient conditions for a stable discretization are fulfilled when : 1 . the continuum problem can be shown to be well posed using the energy method . 2 . spatial difference operators that satisfy sbp on the computational domain are used . boundary conditions are imposed via orthogonal projections @xcite . the semi - discrete equations are integrated with a _ locally stable _ time integrator , e.g. , third or fourth order runge kutta @xcite . optionally , explicit dissipation may be added using operators that do not spoil the energy estimates , and different ways of writing the discrete equations may be explored to achieve strict stability . as an example , consider a set of linear , symmetric hyperbolic equations on a one - dimensional domain , @xmath0 $ ] . this domain is discretized with points @xmath1 , @xmath2 , where @xmath3 , and a discrete scalar product , @xmath4 is introduced for some positive definite matrix with elements @xmath5 . in the limit @xmath6 this scalar product approaches the continuum one given by @xmath7 the standard continuum derivative operators and scalar products satisfy integration by parts : @xmath8 similarly , a discrete difference operator @xmath9 is said to satisfy sbp , if there is a scalar product with respect to which @xmath10 holds . the simplest difference operator and scalar product that satisfy sbp on this domain are @xmath11 where @xmath12 , @xmath13 , @xmath14 , and the scalar product is diagonal : @xmath15 for @xmath16 . higher order operators satisfying sbp have been constructed by strand @xcite . domains with inner boundaries in several dimensions introduce additional complexities , and we refer the reader to paper i for more information . we sometimes use explicit numerical dissipation . for that purpose we modify near boundaries the standard kreiss oliger dissipative operator for second order derivatives , @xmath17 , so that it does not spoil the semi - discrete estimate , i.e. , so that it satisfies @xmath18 . the operator @xmath17 , which is fully described in paper i , is added to the right - hand side of the evolution equations . in the absence of inner boundaries , it is ( on each direction ) @xmath19 we discretize the equations in time using the method of lines , and use third - order runge kutta to integrate the equations . more precisely , for the ordinary differential system @xmath20 we integrate the solution @xmath21 , defined at time @xmath22 , to the advanced time , @xmath23 , obtaining @xmath24 , through @xmath25 where @xmath26 throughout this paper we call artificial long - term instabilities ( alti ) those instabilities that are _ neither _ numerical the errors at a fixed time do not become larger when the resolution is increased , but rather converge to zero_nor _ true instabilities of the continuous solution . these instabilities , as shown in some examples below , can appear quite generically in long - term simulations . there are least two possible ways to suppress alti s : 1 . constructing _ strictly stable _ discretizations with respect to a conveniently defined energy . the equations are written such that a sharp continuum estimate also holds for the semi - discrete equations . the semi - discrete energy will then closely mirror the continuum energy estimate . explicit numerical dissipation can be used to eliminate high frequency errors , shifting the spectrum of the amplification matrix . although the latter solution is easy to implement , it may not be effective if the alti excites low frequency modes . the first solution , on the other hand , does not introduce artificial damping , but such a discretization may be difficult or even impossible to find for generic systems of equations . for example , no general sharp estimate for the full einstein equations is known at this time . thus , these two possibilities can be seen as complementary to each other . the energy of a solution , @xmath27 , of a set of linear partial differential equations is defined as @xmath28 where @xmath29 is a positive definite symmetrizer for the system . this energy is not unique , reflecting the freedom in choosing the symmetrizer , @xmath29 . the energy method provides an estimate for the growth rate of the energy in the form of an inequality , say , @xmath30 and thus provides a bound to the energy growth . this bound may be much larger than the actual growth rate for the continuum solution , in which case we say that the energy estimate is _ coarse . _ when the estimate is close to the actual energy growth rate of a solution , the estimate is _ sharp . _ while the behavior of the continuum solution is independent of a particular bound , as we discuss in this paper , numerical solutions sometimes do have a large growth if this is allowed . thus , the sharper the bound is , the smaller the possible spurious growth in the numerical solution . finding a sharp estimate is problem - dependent , and the definition of a convenient energy has to be analyzed on each case . one usually attempts to find a sharp energy bound by exploiting the freedom in choosing the symmetrizer . for example , a well - defined local physical energy exists in many physically motivated problems , which can be used to select a preferred symmetrizer . the evolution equations must be written such that they are symmetrizable with respect to this energy , but this is in general possible . although a locally positive definite energy for the einstein equations does not exist , relatively sharp estimates exist for some problems @xcite . the energy method can be used to derive discrete estimates . using difference operators that satisfy sbp and representing the boundary conditions through orthogonal projections , the semi - discrete calculation mirrors the continuum analysis . when a discrete energy estimate is present , the discrete system is numerically stable by construction . a discrete system with the same energy estimate as the continuum problem may be defined as strictly stable . however , we are particularly interested in systems for which the energy estimate is sharp , and we therefore reserve the term _ strictly stable _ for discrete systems that match a sharp continuum energy estimate . assuming a sharp energy estimate exists for the continuum problem , in this paper we consider how the discrete problem might be implemented to preserve this sharp estimate at the numerical level . this can be exploited to achieve long - term stability in an otherwise numerically stable but long - term unstable scheme . throughout this paper we only use numerically stable schemes , even when not explicitly mentioned . therefore , we concentrate on their long - term stability . finally , we note that the sharp energy estimates discussed here are for semi - discrete systems , where time is continuous but space has been discretized . a sharp estimate may , in principle , be lost owing to error introduced by the temporal integration . the experiments presented in this paper and in @xcite suggest that ( at least in the cases considered ) if strict stability is lost , the effects are not serious . the semi - discrete analysis appears to adequately represent the fully discrete simulation . consider the initial - boundary value problem defined by the equation @xmath31 , \qquad t\ge 0 \ ; , \label{1d}\ ] ] together with some initial data and maximally dissipative boundary conditions . let us consider the numerically stable discretization defined by @xmath32 with the discrete derivative , @xmath9 , given by eq . ( [ simpled ] ) , third - order runge kutta for the time integration [ cf . ( [ eq : rk3 ] ) ] , and maximally dissipative boundary conditions imposed through orthogonal projections . figure [ conv_simple_eq ] shows results from simulations using this numerical scheme and @xmath33 as initial data and @xmath34 as boundary conditions , which corresponds to the time - independent solution @xmath35 . the figure plots the @xmath36 norm of the errors with respect to the exact solution as a function of time , at different resolutions ( obtained on uniform grids , where the number of points ranges from @xmath37 to @xmath38 ) . at a fixed time , the errors decrease with resolution , verifying that , as expected , the scheme is numerically stable . at fixed resolution , however , the error grows as a function of time , i.e. , the solution has long - term error growth , or alti . norm of the solution error for eq . ( [ 1da ] ) as a function of time at many different discretization scales , with initial data @xmath39 and boundary conditions @xmath34 . the solution is calculated with a numerically stable discretization that is not strictly stable . although convergent , the error in the solution clearly displays an exponential growth . the cfl factor used is 0.8 . , height=226 ] . [ conv_simple_eq ] to understand this behavior we examine an energy norm of the solution . let the continuum energy is used to denote that this is the first energy defined for this system . ] be ( using @xmath40 ) @xmath41 we obtain an energy estimate by taking a time derivative in both sides of eq . ( [ cenergy1 ] ) and using the evolution equation ( [ 1d ] ) , obtaining @xmath42 that is , @xmath43 only integration by parts was used to derive this estimate , between eqs . ( [ before ] ) and ( [ after ] ) . now consider the discrete problem . we define a semi - discrete energy analogous to that one defined in eq . ( [ cenergy1 ] ) , namely @xmath44 the derivation of the above continuum energy estimate can be repeated at the semidiscrete level , provided the difference operator satisfies sbp , since only integration by parts was used at the continuum . therefore , the same estimate holds for the semi - discrete energy defined in eq . ( [ denergy1 ] ) . that is , @xmath45 the continuum estimate , eq . ( [ bad_estimate ] ) , and the semi - discrete counterpart , eq . ( [ bad_destimate ] ) , guarantee that the norm of the continuum and numerical solutions will grow with a rate bounded by @xmath46 . as these are estimates , this does not mean that the exponential growth actually occurs . indeed , the continuum solution does not grow , since eq . ( [ 1d ] ) is the advection equation with the time - independent change of variables , @xmath47 . with this transformation , eq . ( [ 1d ] ) becomes @xmath48 . however , the results shown in fig . [ conv_simple_eq ] indicate that an exponential growth does appear in the numerical solution . we now define a new energy , . ] that allows for a sharper energy estimate and , consequently , a better discrete system . let this new energy ( defined with @xmath49 ) be @xmath50 as before , an estimate is obtained by differentiating in time , substituting in the evolution equations , and using integration by parts to get @xmath51 in deriving the estimate ( [ good_estimate ] ) we have used the leibnitz rule , in the third equality . the analogous semi - discrete energy is now @xmath52 however this semi - discrete energy will not , in general , satisfy a discrete version of the continuum estimate given in ( [ good_estimate ] ) . the reason is that although @xmath9 satisfies sbp , it does _ not _ generally satisfy the leibnitz rule , which was necessary in deriving the estimate ( [ good_estimate ] ) . it can actually be checked that , because of this , discretizing the system as in eq . ( [ 1da ] ) will _ not _ reproduce the continuum estimate , i.e. @xmath53 an alternative is to rewrite the evolution equation ( [ 1d ] ) such that the leibnitz rule is unnecessary to obtain the continuum estimate , eq . ( [ good_estimate ] ) . then a semi - discrete version of this estimate does hold if the difference operator satisfies sbp . to do so we write eq . ( [ 1d ] ) as @xmath54 this gives the same estimate as before : @xmath55 ^ 2 \le 0 . \label{est1}\ ] ] however , in deriving the estimate ( [ est1 ] ) we have only used integration by parts , and not the leibnitz rule . therefore , the semi - discrete energy estimate @xmath56 follows immediately if the semidiscrete equation is written as @xmath57 and @xmath9 satisfies sbp . figure [ comparison_discretizations ] shows numerical results obtained by evolving eq . ( [ 1d ] ) using two discretizations , given by eqs . ( [ 1da],[1dc ] ) . ( [ 1d ] ) and ( [ rearrange1 ] ) are equivalent , they have the same set of solutions . however , their discrete counterparts , eqs . ( [ 1da ] ) and ( [ 1dc ] ) , _ do not _ have the same solutions at fixed resolution . in one case the solution error grows as a function of time , in the other case it does not . it is experimentally found that in this example ( and others discussed below ) the growing numerical error in the non - strictly stable discretization is manifest in high frequency modes , which can be eliminated by adding a small amount of dissipation , as is also shown in figure [ comparison_discretizations ] . ) . the dotted line shows the one of the lines of fig.1 , i.e. , the @xmath36 norm of the error for a non - strictly stable discretization , given by eq . ( [ 1da ] ) . the solid line shows the error for the same simulation with some numerical dissipation ( @xmath58 ) . the dashed line , in turn , shows the error for the ( non - dissipative ) strictly stable discretization given by eq . ( [ 1dc ] ) . in all these runs @xmath59 and cfl=0.8 . even though both the strictly stable and the non - strictly but dissipative schemes give long term stability , the former discretization is much more accurate.,height=226 ] consider now an equation with variable - coefficients in the principal part and a lower order term that in principle allows for energy growth , @xmath60 defined on a compact domain @xmath0 $ ] . for simplicity we assume that @xmath61 , and define the energy @xmath62 . homogeneous boundary conditions are given at @xmath63 . rewriting the equation as @xmath64 , one can easily show , using only integration by parts , that the estimate @xmath65 holds . therefore , writing the semi - discrete equation as @xmath66 gives the same semi - discrete energy estimate , @xmath67 if @xmath68 then @xmath69 and the continuum and discrete solutions can not grow in time . equations with features similar to those of eq.([shift_eq ] ) with @xmath68 appear in the klein gordon and maxwell fields on fixed black hole backgrounds , as discussed later in this paper , where the shift plays the role of @xmath70 . if @xmath71 the energy may grow , already at the continuum ; for example , if @xmath72 . in that case one may want to discretize in a way such that artificial numerical growth is avoided as much as possible . for example , if @xmath72 , discretizing as in eq . ( [ discr ] ) gives @xmath73 which is the same equation satisfied by the continuum energy . fast growing numerical errors can arise even in numerically stable discretizations . in some cases they can be traced to the failure of the leibnitz rule for discrete derivatives , and failure of sharp continuum energy estimates to hold in the discrete problem . the use of difference operators satisfying sbp , appropriate numerical boundary conditions , and rearrangement of terms , give raise to strictly stable schemes which satisfy sharp semidiscrete energy estimates , if such estimates are available at the continuum . the goal of these rearrangement of terms is actually not only to avoid the leibnitz rule . clearly , since the growth rate for the energy usually involves derivatives , in general there would still be a discrepancy between the analytical and numerical estimates even if the leibnitz rule was satisfied , arising from the difference between numerical and analytical derivatives . these differences , however , can also be controlled by appropriately rearranging terms ( see , for example , sections [ wave_eqs]-[max_eqs ] , and refs . @xcite ) . in the following we discuss more complex examples : the propagation of scalar and electromagnetic fields on the schwarzschild spacetime in three dimensions , and one - dimensional linear perturbations of gauge waves . in the former cases , we do have readily available sharp energy estimates derived from physical principles . in the latter a sharp estimate is available for the subsidiary system describing the constraint evolution . in this section we describe some model problems commonly used in relativity , while corresponding numerical results are presented in the following section . the first two problems are klein gordon and maxwell fields on a schwarzschild black hole background , and linearization perturbations of the gauge wave is the third one . black holes contain physical curvature singularities that can not be included on the computational domain . black hole excision eliminates this problem by removing a region around the singularity from the computational domain @xcite . this region must lie within the event horizon , and be _ causally disconnected _ from the spacetime outside the black hole so that the excised region does not affect the physics outside the hole . as discussed in the appendix , this region must be carefully chosen for these conditions to hold . numerical implementations of excision have traditionally presented a challenge in deciding how points near the inner boundary are updated . especially in higher dimensions , many combinations of one - sided derivative stencils , interpolation , and extrapolation have been investigated , mostly through experimentation @xcite ( for an alternative excision strategy using pseudospectral methods see @xcite ) . however , as explained in paper i , derivative operators that satisfy sbp together with a diagonal inner product uniquely specify the excision algorithm . the procedure is unambiguous , and for linear problems guarantees a stable implementation . we follow this procedure , detailed in paper i , to excise the singularity . we consider three - dimensional evolutions on a schwarzschild background , in either painlev ' e gullstrand ( pg ) and kerr - schild ( ks ) coordinates . the four - dimensional metric , written in terms of adm quantities , is @xmath74 in pg coordinates @xmath75 while in ks coordinates @xmath76 where @xmath77 and @xmath78 is the black hole s mass . we excise a cubical excision region centered on the black hole , and require the length of the cube , @xmath79 , to satisfy @xmath80 , or @xmath81 . larger cubes , as discussed in the appendix , result in excision boundaries that are _ not _ purely outflow . the massless klein gordon scalar wave equation , @xmath82 , where @xmath83 is the inverse four - dimensional metric , can be be written as @xmath84 where we have introduced new variables @xmath85 and @xmath86 to write the system in first order form . additionally , we define @xmath87 , where @xmath88 is the inverse of the three - metric , @xmath89 , and @xmath90 . this formulation has a number of desirable features when the background metric is stationary @xcite . for example , eqs . ( [ eq : wave1 ] ) are symmetric with respect to the physical energy , and a straightforward estimate shows that this energy does not grow when maximally dissipative boundary conditions , which are automatically constraint - preserving for this formulation , are given . moreover , eqs . ( [ eq : wave1 ] ) have been written such that the leibnitz rule is not needed to guarantee that the energy will not grow . for this reason , we refer to the discretization obtained by replacing @xmath91 by @xmath92 in eqs . ( [ eq : wave1 ] ) as _ energy preserving _ or _ strictly stable_. the physical energy , however , is not positive definite inside the black hole , since the killing vector becomes space - like there . we nevertheless choose this energy - preserving discretization , since it guarantees long - term stability if the computational domain does not include the black hole . more sophisticated formulations and discretizations , which are globally symmetric hyperbolic and conserve the physical energy in the exterior region , up to a distance arbitrarily close to the event horizon , can also be constructed @xcite . as a second example of classical fields on a black hole background we choose the vacuum maxwell equations . we write the maxwell equations in terms of the faraday tensor , @xmath93 , and its dual @xmath94 } & = & 0 \nonumber \\ \nabla_{[a } { } ^{\star}f_{bc ] } & = & 0 . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the dual of the faraday tensor is @xmath95 , where @xmath96 is the completely anti - symmetric symbol . contracting the above equations with a time - like vector field @xmath97 we get the evolution equations : @xmath98c}u^c),\nonumber \\ { \cal l}_u { } ^{\star}f_{ab } & = & - 2 \nabla_{[a}({}^{\star}f_{b]c}u^c ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] defining a foliation by dragging an initial space - like hypersurface along the integral curves of the vector @xmath97 ( each labeled with the proper time of the integral lines of @xmath97 , @xmath99 ) , and pulling back the above equations onto each of these hypersurfaces we get @xmath100c}u^c),\nonumber \\ { \cal l}_u \phi_{\star}({}^{\star}f_{ab } ) & = & - 2 \partial_{[a}\phi_{\star}({}^{\star}f_{b]c}u^c ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath101 is the pull - back map into the hypersurface . notice that only exterior derivatives appear in the equations , so the geometry only enters through the star operation . the electric and magnetic fields are typically defined as @xmath102 , and @xmath103 , allowing one to decompose @xmath93 and @xmath104 into ( @xmath105 defined by @xmath106 ) @xmath107 } + { \varepsilon}_{ab}{}^{cd } b_c n_d , \nonumber\\ \ , { } ^{\star}f_{ab } & = & 2 b_{[a } n_{b ] } + { \varepsilon}_{ab}{}^{cd } e_c n_d . \end{aligned}\ ] ] contracting eqs . ( [ eq : max_evol_2 ] ) with @xmath108 , we get @xmath109 as with the klein - gordon equation , this system is symmetric hyperbolic outside the event horizon , where @xmath97 is time - like , and only strongly hyperbolic inside the event horizon , where @xmath97 is _ space - like _ , since the symmetrizer is not positive - definite there . we supplement the above equations with a no - incoming radiation boundary condition . no condition is needed to preserve the constraints , for they propagate along @xmath97 , as are the outer boundaries . thus , we set the incoming modes to zero at a boundary with normal @xmath110 , via the projector defined as @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the eigenvector basis , @xmath113 is the co - basis , we define @xmath114 and where the sum extends only over eigenvectors with positive eigenvalues . as with the scalar field , we ask whether the maxwell equations can be written such that the discrete problem has a sharp energy estimate , giving numerical solutions without alti . the background spacetime is invariant under time translations , implying a conserved quantity or energy . this energy is the integral of @xmath115 , where @xmath97 is the killing vector field ( timelike outside the black hole ) over the hypersurface . for the pg foliation this energy is @xmath116\ , dv.\ ] ] just as with the klein gordon equation , this expression is not positive - definite inside the horizon , reflecting a property of the geometry , not of the equation or coordinates used . to discretize the above system we use the method of lines and substitute in eqs . ( [ max1],[max2 ] ) the partial derivatives with difference operators satisfying sbp . in this way strict stability with respect to the discretized version of the above energy is attained . one simple and common test for numerical implementations of the einstein equations is a gauge wave defined by @xmath117 which describes flat spacetime with a sinusoidal coordinate dependence , of amplitude @xmath118 , along the @xmath119 direction . the non - trivial adm variables for this metric are @xmath120 together with the gauge condition @xmath121 we evolve the einstein equations using the symmetric hyperbolic formulation presented in @xcite with dynamical lapse and the time - harmonic gauge . the formulation is cast in first order form by introducing the variables @xmath122 and @xmath123 . rather than solving the full einstein equations here , we study linear perturbations of a background metric given by eq . ( [ gaugewavemetric ] ) . furthermore , we simplify the system by allowing perturbations depending only on @xmath124 , in the form @xmath125 this restriction can be justified by noting that full non - linear evolutions of data defined by eq . ( [ gaugewavemetric ] ) show that only these variables vary dynamically @xcite , and variations in all other variables are consistent with round - off error . the resulting linearized equations are ( henceforth dropping the @xmath126 notation ) @xmath127 where we have defined @xmath128 . this system is symmetric hyperbolic ; three characteristic speeds are @xmath129 and the other two @xmath130 . we consider here an initial boundary value problem on the domain @xmath131 $ ] . we implement boundary conditions via the orthogonal projector method described in appendix d of paper i. the positive / negative eigenmode decomposition of the matrix @xmath132 is @xmath133 ( see paper i ) . here , the matrix @xmath118 is the principal part , and @xmath29 is its symmetrizer . for one - dimensional problems , @xmath134 , and @xmath135 is the matrix that diagonalizes @xmath118 , i.e. , @xmath136 , with @xmath137 a diagonal matrix . the system must satisfy two constraint equations , corresponding to the definition of the variables @xmath138 and @xmath139 . when linearized , these constraints are @xmath140 the other constraints are automatically satisfied owing to the restricted form of the allowed perturbations . despite the simplicity of this system , the numerical integration of these equations reveals some interesting features . indeed , straightforward discretizations of this system have lead to exponentially growing solutions with quickly growing constraint violations . that this instability has been observed by different groups in a variety of situations , led to the speculation that constraint violations _ drive _ the instability . we offer here a different interpretation of the results by examining the evolution of the constraints . evolution equations for the constraints can be obtained by taking the time derivative of @xmath141 and @xmath142 , and substituting in the einstein equations , giving @xmath143 these equations can be integrated in closed form to yield @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 are free functions determined by the initial data : @xmath147 clearly the constraint behavior is _ purely oscillatory_. hence , any growth in the constraints observed during evolution must be purely numerical . we will show in the next section that this is indeed the case , and that the error growth can be eliminated . we now present some numerical simulations of the model problems discussed in the previous section . for the black hole tests , we examine configurations where the computational domain is outside the black hole and others that do contain an excised black hole . the former configuration allows us to investigate the evolution of a symmetric hyperbolic system with boundary interactions without the difficulties introduced by excision . we then examine the more demanding case in which excision is required , and the evolution systems here considered are only strongly hyperbolic inside the black hole . this section presents numerical results for the massless klein gordon scalar field on a schwarzschild black hole background . we present some tests of our code , and then discuss differences between the strictly stable and non - strictly stable discretizations . consider an uniform computational domain that _ does not _ contain the black hole , @xmath148 ^ 3 $ ] . initial data with compact support are given to @xmath149 , the time derivative of the scalar field , as @xmath150 ^ 4 \label{eq : initial_data_1 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] when @xmath151 ^ 3 $ ] , and zero otherwise . all other fields are initially set to zero . is of order one despite the large factor in its definition , @xmath152 . ] this data is then evolved using two possible discretizations . the first one is that one obtained by direct substitution of partial derivatives by discrete ones in eq . ( [ eq : wave1 ] ) , this is the strictly stable discretization . the second one is obtained by expanding all derivatives of products with the product rule and then replacing partial derivatives of field variables by their discrete counterparts . we refer to this as the `` na " i ve '' discretization . both discretizations were used to evolve for around 250 crossing times , under different choices of courant factor ( @xmath153 ) . in all cases we found no sign of long term growth when monitoring the variables , though a closer inspection reveals several salient features of the obtained solutions . namely , a self - convergence analysis show results consistent with second order accuracy for a few crossing times ( with better values for the smallest @xmath154 ) . however , at later times , the observed convergence rate deteriorates considerably and achieve artificially large values . the time at which this behavior starts coincides with the fields mostly leaving the computational domain . for instance , figure [ conserve_straight_outside ] displays the @xmath36 norm of @xmath149 obtained with the strictly stable and `` na " i ve '' discretizations . the figure shows the @xmath36 norms of @xmath149 calculated at two resolutions , for 250 crossing times . the large decrease in the norm is a sign that basically most of the fields leave the domain after a few crossing times . both discretizations give a long - term stable algorithm for this case . but , as we will discuss later , the nave discretization without dissipation becomes long - term unstable when the black hole is included on the domain . norm of @xmath149 in a scalar field evolution outside the black hole for about 250 crossing times . the figure compares results for a nave discretization ( see text ) , and a strictly stable discretization at two resolutions , @xmath155 and @xmath156 . the domain is @xmath157 $ ] , @xmath158 , and no dissipation is added to the solution . , width=321 ] to verify that we get the expected self - convergence factor in long term simulations when the fields do not decay to very small values after having left the domain , we now show results of a complementary set of tests on the domain @xmath159 $ ] , @xmath160 $ ] . here we concentrate in what corresponded to the worst case scenario considered , given by @xmath161 . we set the incoming modes on all outer faces to zero , except on the @xmath162 face , where the time derivative of the incoming fields is set to @xmath163 $ } & \nonumber \\ 0\qquad\qquad\qquad\mbox{otherwise } & { } \nonumber \end{array } \right . \label{eq : incoming_modes } \end{aligned}\ ] ] this boundary condition is imposed through an orthogonal projection , as explained in paper i. initial data is given by @xmath164 ^ 4 \ ; , \label{eq : initial_data_1b } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and both discretizations ( strictly and non - strictly stable ) are evolved . figure [ long_conv ] shows the self - convergence factor ( as before , in the @xmath36 norm ) of @xmath165 and @xmath149 versus time for the strictly stable discretization ( similar factors are obtained for the non - strictly stable one ) at the resolutions @xmath166 , @xmath167 and @xmath168 . convergence factors close to the expected value of two are observed , with no qualitative difference in the convergence factor as time progresses . ( solid line ) and @xmath165 ( dashed line ) on a domain outside the black hole , using the strictly stable scheme ( similar factors are obtained for the naive one ) , for about @xmath169 crossing times . these factors are calculated using resolutions of @xmath170 , @xmath167 , and @xmath168 . the obtained factors are close to the expected value of two . the courant factor is @xmath171 , and no dissipation is used . , height=226 ] in this section , the computational domain contains the black hole , which is excised with an inner cubic boundary centered on the black hole . the domain is defined on @xmath172 ^ 3 $ ] , and the excision cube has a total length of @xmath173 . thus , the faces of the inner boundary are at @xmath174 . we first verify that the excision algorithm does not display alti when employing the strictly stable scheme . as mentioned earlier , very little freedom is available in constructing difference operators that satisfy sbp . indeed , for our second - order code with a diagonal scalar product , the stencils are uniquely specified . figure [ long_excision ] shows the @xmath36 norms of @xmath149 and @xmath165 for a long up to @xmath175 evolution ( with no dissipation ) , designed to detect slowly growing modes . as shown in this figure , the algorithm specified by requiring sbp and the equations arranged so as to preserve the energy is long - term stable even with excision boundaries . for this run non - trivial initial data are given , as before , only to @xmath149 . @xmath176 ^ 3 ( r0-r ) & \mbox{if $ |r - r_0|\le |\delta |$ } \\ 0 & \mbox{otherwise \ , . } \end{array } \right . \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath177 and @xmath178 . when studying the convergence of the code one again faces the fact that after a few crossing times the convergence value become meaningless . the behavior observed is analogous to the case where the black hole was outside the computational domain . namely , close to second order convergence is seen during the first few crossing times , and unrealistically high values are obtained afterwards . in fig . [ convergence_excision ] we show a short - term convergence test ( about two crossing times ) with excision . fig . [ norm_excision ] shows the corresponding @xmath36 norms for @xmath165 and @xmath149 . norms of @xmath149 ( solid line ) and @xmath165 ( dashed line ) are shown for about 2500 crossing times . no slowly growing unstable modes are detected in these runs . this run was performed with @xmath179 grid points , @xmath180 , and no dissipation is used . , height=226 ] ( solid line ) and @xmath165 ( dashed line ) using the same configuration as in fig . [ long_excision ] . the self - convergence test is performed on uniform grids with @xmath181 , and @xmath182 grid - points . the convergence factor is close to the expected value of two . the measured convergence factor drops slightly from near two after one crossing time , when most of the field has left the domain and afterwards increases to unrealistic high values . , height=226 ] norms for the runs shown in fig.[convergence_excision ] . the relative difference in the norms for @xmath165 at any two different resolutions , is at most about one percent . similarly for @xmath149 , except at the last point shown , where this field has mostly left the grid . , title="fig:",height=226 ] norms for the runs shown in fig.[convergence_excision ] . the relative difference in the norms for @xmath165 at any two different resolutions , is at most about one percent . similarly for @xmath149 , except at the last point shown , where this field has mostly left the grid . , title="fig:",height=226 ] as in the previous case , we also compare results obtained with the strictly stable and the nave discretizations . long term stability was found for both cases when the computational domain was outside the black hole . with excision , however , the solution obtained with the nave discretization quickly becomes corrupted , as shown in fig . [ conserve_straight_inside ] . as shown in this figure , the amplitude decreases with resolution , indicating that the growth is spurious and that the nave discretization suffers from alti . the strictly stable discretization , however , with a sharp semi - discrete energy estimate , remains well - behaved . the alti that contaminate the navely discretized solution are found to be of high - frequency type , which can be managed by adding explicit dissipation . figure [ conserve_straight_dissip ] shows results using the same initial configurations , except that now dissipation is added to the nave discretization . now all of the runs produce long term stable simulations . norm of @xmath149 in a scalar field evolution on a domain containing an excised schwarzschild black hole . the solid and dot - dashed lines show the @xmath36 norm of @xmath149 obtained using the nave discretization of the wave equation . although the amplitude decrease with resolution , this solution quickly becomes long - term unstable , indicating an artificial instability . the strictly stable discretization ( shown with dashed and dotted lines ) , however , remains long term stable and well - behaved . the results are calculated with the resolutions @xmath183 and @xmath184 , @xmath158 , and no dissipation is added . , height=226 ] norm of @xmath149 in a scalar field evolution on a domain containing an excised schwarzschild black hole . the solid and dot - dashed lines show the solutions obtained using the nave discretization with dissipation , the latter eliminating the artificial instability noted in fig . [ conserve_straight_inside ] . the strictly stable discretization ( shown with dashed and dotted lines ) , without dissipation , is shown for comparison . the results are calculated with the resolutions @xmath183 and @xmath184 , @xmath158 , and the dissipation parameter is @xmath185 . , height=226 ] as with the scalar field tests above , we perform tests with the maxwell equations on two kind of domains . specifically , we choose 1 . computational domain outside the black hole : @xmath186 ^ 2 $ ] and @xmath187 $ ] ; 2 . computational domain including part of the black hole : @xmath188 ^ 3 $ ] . the singularity is excised by means of a cubical region defined by @xmath189 ^ 3 $ ] . the initial data describe a `` pulse '' of electromagnetic field given by @xmath190 ^ 8 \epsilon_{ij3 } ( x^j - x_o^j ) & \mbox{if $ |r - r_0| < \delta$ } \\ 0 & \mbox{otherwise \ , , } \end{array } \right . \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath191 stands for @xmath192 and @xmath193 , @xmath194 is a strength parameter , @xmath195 is the location of the pulse s center , and @xmath126 its width . we discretize in a strictly stable way , as explained in section [ max_eqs ] . let @xmath196 , @xmath197 and @xmath198 , and we set the dissipation to zero . figure [ maxwell12 ] shows @xmath199 vs. time for four different resolutions ( @xmath200 and @xmath182 grid - points , corresponding to @xmath201 and @xmath168 , respectively ) , while the inset shows the decay in time for a long - term run with the coarsest resolution . figure [ maxwell11 ] shows the self - convergence factor of @xmath202 for a short time , computed with @xmath179 , @xmath203 and @xmath182 grid - points , and @xmath203 , @xmath204 , and @xmath182 grid - points . as expected , the factor gets closer to two when resolution is increased . norm of @xmath202 vs. time in an evolution of the maxwell fields at four different resolutions for a strictly stable discretization . the computational domain is outside the black hole . the inset shows a long - term evolution , @xmath205 , using the coarsest resolution . the runs were performed on uniform grids with resolutions @xmath170 , @xmath167 , @xmath206 and @xmath168 , and the courant factor is @xmath207 . , height=226 ] for the runs of fig . [ maxwell12 ] . the factors improve with resolution , in the sense that they closer to the expected value of two . the labels @xmath37-@xmath208-@xmath209 and @xmath208-@xmath210-@xmath209 indicate the number of grid points in each direction used to perform the self - convergence test . , height=226 ] now let @xmath196 , @xmath211 and @xmath212 . in contrast to the scalar field runs , solutions of the maxwell equations without explicit dissipation diverge at long times , even with a strictly stable discretization . the reason for this appears to be that the energy inside the black hole is not positive definite and boundedness ( either at the continuum or numerical level ) is not guaranteed ( it is not clear why this divergence does not appear in the scalar field case , when the singularity is excised , since the energy is also non - positive definite in that case . ) . high frequencies are seen in the solution , and we therefore add a small amount of dissipation , @xmath213 . figures [ maxwell22 ] and [ maxwell21 ] show the norms and convergence data similar to the figures for the domain outside the black hole . as before , the simulations are long - term stable for long times . the self - convergence factors for the coarsest resolutions drop quickly from their initial value , indicating that the coarsest solutions are not in the convergent regime . in addition to effects caused by the fields leaving the computational domain , using a cubical excision boundary forces us to excise very close to the black hole , where the spacetime and field gradients are very large , effectively requiring higher resolution . norm of @xmath202 vs. time in an evolution of the maxwell fields on a computational domain containing an excised black hole for a strictly stable discretization . the norms are shown for four different resolutions , and the inset shows a long - term evolution , @xmath205 , at the coarsest resolution . the runs were performed on uniform grids with resolutions @xmath170 , @xmath167 , @xmath206 and @xmath168 . the courant factor is @xmath180 , and dissipation is added to the evolution equations , with @xmath213 . , height=226 ] . the self - convergence factors are calculated from @xmath202 . the excision boundary is very close to the black hole , and the large gradients encountered in the fields and spacetime near the excision boundary require very high resolution to resolve them adequately . the coarsest solutions are not resolved well enough to be in the convergence regime . however , it can be seen from the figure that the convergence improves with resolution . the labels @xmath37-@xmath208-@xmath209 and @xmath208-@xmath210-@xmath209 indicate the number of grid points in each direction used to perform the self - convergence test . , height=226 ] the gauge wave is a useful test problem for examining some of the difficulties found in the simulation of the einstein equations ( see @xcite ) , and to illustrate the usefulness of the techniques presented in paper i. to this end , we present results obtained using a straight - forward discretization of the right hand side of eqs . ( [ gauge1])([gauge5 ] ) , and show results obtained for long term evolutions with and without dissipation . moreover , we consider cases both where the constraints are initially satisfied , and where they are not . the latter illustrates that even when large constraint violations are introduced in the initial data , the solutions to the linearized equations remain well behaved . this , of course , may not necessarily be the case for the non - linear einstein equations , as for these relatively large amplitudes the linearized system need not be a close approximation to the non - linear ones . or even if the amplitudes were small , there could be purely non - linear effects in the solution which would naturally be missed in a linearized analysis @xcite . for these tests we adopt trivial initial data for all fields , except for @xmath214 , @xmath138 and @xmath215 , which have compact support in @xmath216 $ ] and are given by @xmath217 ^ 4 , \\ d_{xxx } & = & \mu \partial_x g_{xx } , \\ k_{xx } & = & -\frac{\xi}{2 } \partial_x g_{xx } \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath218 , @xmath219 , and @xmath220 are constants . we set @xmath221 in the background solution and the computational domain is taken to be @xmath222 $ ] . boundary conditions are applied via olsson s projection operators . here , as we are interested in the long term behavior of the solution , we couple the incoming modes the outgoing ones such that @xmath223 for cases where the constraints are initially satisfied , we choose @xmath224 , @xmath225 ; otherwise we set @xmath226 , @xmath225 and @xmath227 . in all these simulations a courant factor of @xmath180 is used , to compare with similar simulations @xcite . figures [ gaugewave_c_straight]-[gaugewave_g_straight ] show results for constraint - satisfying initial data , without dissipation . figure [ gaugewave_c_straight ] shows the @xmath36 norm of the constraint , @xmath228 and its convergence to zero with increasing resolution . initially the norm @xmath228 is almost constant . however , at later times a clear exponential mode is observed . while the solution is well - behaved for longer times with increasing resolution , this approach is impractical for long runs . figure [ gaugewave_con_straight ] shows the convergence ( to zero ) factors in the @xmath36 norm obtained for @xmath228 . for the highest resolutions , the factor is very close to its expected value . an exponential behavior for @xmath214 is also seen in figure [ gaugewave_g_straight ] . even though in principle this quantity could already grow at the continuum , the fact that at fixed time the norm of @xmath214 decreases with increasing resolution suggests that , as discussed below , this is an artifact of an alti . norm of @xmath228 vs. number of crossing times for four different resolutions . after an initial stage where the constraints are well behaved a clear exponential mode dominates the solution.,height=226 ] . [ gaugewave_c_straight ] as a function of number of crossing times , comparing runs with @xmath37 and @xmath208 points ( dotted line ) , @xmath208 and @xmath209 points ( dashed line ) and @xmath209 and @xmath229 points ( solid line ) . notice that even when the solutions are growing exponentially ( see figs.[gaugewave_c_straight],[gaugewave_g_straight ] ) , the constraints converge to zero.,height=226 ] . [ gaugewave_con_straight ] norm of @xmath214 vs. number of crossing times for four different resolutions with no dissipation . at early times , the norm remains fairly constant but at later ones an exponential growth dominates the solution.,height=226 ] . [ gaugewave_g_straight ] the alti for @xmath228 are , as in the previous examples , found to be of high frequency type and , therefore , the addition of dissipation eliminates these growing modes . figures [ gaugewavediss_g_straight][gaugewavediss_con_straight ] illustrate the behavior of simulations with the same initial data and boundary conditions as those of figures [ gaugewave_c_straight]-[gaugewave_g_straight ] , except that now some dissipation is added , @xmath58 . the norm of @xmath142 is illustrated in fig . [ gaugewavediss_c_straight ] , where now only a slow growth is observed at late times . [ gaugewavediss_con_straight ] shows , as before , the convergence factors ( to zero ) for @xmath142 , in the @xmath36 norm . finally , figure [ gaugewavediss_g_straight ] shows the @xmath36 norm of @xmath214 for different resolutions . only a linear growth is observed in the solution is found ; furthermore , this growth decreases with resolution . norm of @xmath214 vs. number of crossing times for four different resolutions . only a small growth is observed in the solution.,height=226 ] . [ gaugewavediss_g_straight ] norm of @xmath228 vs. number of crossing times for four different resolutions . convergence to zero is observed and only slow ( linear ) growth is observed.,height=226 ] . [ gaugewavediss_c_straight ] vs. number of crossing times comparing runs with @xmath37 and @xmath208 points ( dotted line ) , @xmath208 and @xmath209 points ( solid line).,height=226 ] as a last example we consider initial data violating the constraints . here , similarly good behavior is observed when dissipation is employed , in the sense that , as predicted by the continuum analysis of section [ eqs_gauge ] , the constraints oscillate in time . for instance , figure [ gaugewavediss_con_straight ] shows the @xmath36 norm of the constraint @xmath141 vs. time . as expected , these converge to a roughly constant behavior as resolution is increased , and no growth is observed . norm of @xmath230 vs. number of crossing times for three different resolutions , corresponding to the case where the initial data does not satisfy @xmath231 . as expected from the continuum analysis , even in this case the norm does not grow in time . , height=226 ] the construction of stable numerical methods for ibvps often involves a mixture of intuition and experimentation . the choice of numerical scheme and boundary conditions are often considered as necessarily separate ingredients . for certain problems , however , the energy method for discrete systems is an integrated , systematic method for creating numerically stable schemes and analyzing their behavior . while this method has not yet been widely used in general relativity , many current outstanding problems in the field vitally depend on understanding the subtle interplay of boundaries with the interior computational domain . in this paper we have applied the discrete energy method to test problems commonly found in numerical relativity and analyzed the numerical and long - term stability of the resulting schemes , with and without black hole excision . we have also investigated the numerical origin of fast growing modes which may artificially appear in numerical solutions , and used the energy method to discuss possible remedies . in particular , we have presented explicit examples of the techniques described in paper i and discussed what leads to alti and a way to remove or alleviate them . a message from this work is that it is not sufficient to construct numerically stable implementations , but also special care must be taken to devise suitable _ numerical _ methods to rule out , or alleviate alti . ( for a somewhat related approach , see the recent work @xcite ) . to illustrate how this is achieved we have adopted a series of examples , which although considerably simpler than einstein equations , are relevant in the context of numerical relativity . in particular , in efforts to deal with black hole spacetimes and to understand the source of problems encountered with the gauge wave test . as shown throughout this work , even though there are examples in which low - frequency alti are present and for which no sharp estimate is known , a careful analysis and grouping of the variables and/or the addition of ( controllable ) artificial dissipation may in many cases be crucial in handling otherwise artificial long term instabilities . it is expected that these techniques will be important in a number of fronts , in particular in the simulation of einstein s equations . we wish to thank g. calabrese , o. sarbach , j. pullin , e. tadmor , p. olsson , and h .- o . kreiss for helpful discussions , and e. schnetter for helpful comments on the manuscript . this work was supported in part by nsf grants phy0244699 , phy0312049 ; nasa - nag5 - 1430 ; the horace hearne jr . lab for theoretical physics , conicet , and secyt - unc . computations were done at lsu s center for computation and technology and parallelized with the cactus toolkit @xcite . is an alfred p. sloan fellow . black hole excision removes the singularity by placing an inner boundary on the computational domain . while the boundary removes the singularity , the question now becomes finding physically and mathematically consistent inner boundary conditions . clearly , a general solution to this problem for an arbitrary boundary is unknown . the time - development of this boundary presents a further complication . namely , if the boundary becomes time - like , it will encounter the singularity in a finite amount of time . these two issues can be resolved simultaneously by adopting an inner boundary with a space - like world tube . this ensures it will not hit the singularity and that no boundary conditions are necessary if all the characteristics speeds are within the light cone , as the past domain of dependence of boundary points is wholly contained on the previous time slice . some freedom remains in choosing the particular region to be excised , and clearly the largest possible excision boundary is preferable to avoid the strongest gradients of the spacetime . to illustrate some of these issues we now examine cubical excision for both the schwarzschild and kerr black holes , looking for the _ largest possible _ space - like excision cube . as we discuss below , the _ shape _ of the boundary plays a crucial role in satisfying the spacelike condition . we examine one face of the cube , a @xmath232 face . the condition that this surface is space - like implies that @xmath233 , as @xmath234 is the normal to the surface . since the coordinates are fixed _ a - priori , _ we can only vary the position of the boundary to meet this condition . we find that this condition is quite difficult to satisfy , and possible for only very slowly spinning black holes . to see this in detail , consider the kerr metric in kerr schild form @xcite . the quantity @xmath235 is @xmath236 where @xmath237 is related to the cartesian coordinates by @xmath238 the space - like character requirement on the surface implies that @xmath239 for the schwarzschild black hole , @xmath240 , @xmath241 , and the above condition becomes @xmath242 the corner of the cube is the limiting point ( @xmath243 ) for the largest cube , giving the bound @xmath244 , or @xmath245 . for the spinning black hole , the analysis is slightly more involved . the limiting point for the largest cube is given by @xmath246 , @xmath247 , giving the condition @xmath248 examining this condition shows that cubical excision can not be used when @xmath249 , as shown in fig . [ kerr_excise ] . furthermore , the singularity is not at a point , but is ring - like , implying that the cube may not be arbitrarily small . finding the minimum sized cube is more involved , as the faces of the cube need to be examined in addition to the corners @xcite . this limitation of cubical excision for the schwarzschild spacetime was noted before @xcite , by requiring that the excision boundary has no in - coming modes in a particular formulation of einstein equations . a similar analyzis to that of @xcite for the kerr spacetime and cubical excision regions has also recently presented in @xcite . here we would like to point out the following . first , when the eigenmodes are complete and the speeds are physical ( they lie within the null cone ) those results and the one presented here are equivalent , as it is rooted in the physical nature of the excision boundary . second , when dealing with a formulation admitting eigenspeeds outside the light cone , or a non - complete set of eigenmodes , the current straightforward analysis provides necessary conditions that have to be met . these necessary conditions are useful when dealing with any formulation , in particular one whose eigenspeeds might not be known . finally , we emphasize that these results are coordinate dependent ; nevertheless , for the families often used in numerical relativity tests , the same result applies . in particular for the family of slicings reported by martel and poisson @xcite ( which contains both the kerr schild and painlev ' e gullstrand slicings of schwarzschild ) . h. friedrich and a. rendall , in _ einstein s field equations and their physical implications _ , lecture notes in physics , edited by b. g. schmidt ( springer - verlag , berlin , 2000 ) , pp . 127 - 223 ; o. reula , living rev . * 1 * , 3 ( 1998 ) . m. scheel , talk at `` miniprogram on colliding black holes : mathematical issues in numerical relativity '' , institute for theoretical physics , university of california at santa barbara , january 10 - 28,2000 .
Abstract: | [
"the energy method can be used to identify well - posed initial boundary value problems for quasi - linear , symmetric hyperbolic partial differential equations with maximally dissipative boundary conditions . a similar analysis of the discrete system can be used to construct stable finite difference equations for these problems at the linear level . in this paper we apply these techniques to some test problems commonly used in numerical relativity and observe that while we obtain convergent schemes , fast growing modes , or `` artificial instabilities , '' contaminate the solution . we find that these growing modes can partially arise from the lack of a leibnitz rule for discrete derivatives and discuss ways to limit this spurious growth ."
] | 11,274 | 11,274 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the third author of this paper still vividly recollects his visit to victor klee at the university of washington ( seattle ) in august 2000 . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ we had a memorable drive in vic s car from the hotel to the math department . vic skipped all the small talk and immediately asked : `` do you think that the simplex method is polynomial ? '' i still remember how awkward i felt to be asked this question by the very person who had provided the first and seminal insights into it . my ( then as now quite irrelevant ) opinion shall remain between vic and me forever . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the seminal work referred to above is of course the 1972 paper of klee and minty entitled `` how good is the simplex algorithm ? '' it deals with the number of iterations that may be required in the worst case to solve a linear program ( lp ) by dantzig s _ simplex method _ @xcite , which was at that time the only available practical method . klee and minty exhibited a family of lps ( now known as the _ klee - minty cubes _ ) for which the number of iterations is _ exponential _ in the number of variables and constraints . dantzig s specific _ pivot rule _ for selecting the next step is just one of many conceivable rules . the question left open by the work of klee and minty is whether there is some _ other _ rule that provably leads to a small number of iterations . this question is as open today as it was in 1972 . nowadays , the simplex method is no longer the only available method to solve lps . in particular , there _ are _ proven polynomial - time algorithms for solving lps khachiyan s _ ellipsoid method _ @xcite and karmarkar s _ interior point method _ @xcite that are based on techniques developed originally for nonlinear optimization . it is still unknown , though , whether there is a _ strongly _ polynomial - time algorithm for solving lps , that is , an algorithm for which the number of arithmetic operations does not depend on the bit lengths of the input numbers . [ [ the - p - matrix - linear - complementarity - problem . ] ] the p - matrix linear complementarity problem . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + in this paper we are concerned with pivoting methods for the _ p - matrix linear complementarity problem _ ( p - lcp ) , a prominent problem for which neither polynomial - time algorithms nor hardness results are available . in general , an lcp is given by a matrix @xmath0 and a vector @xmath1 , and the problem is to find vectors @xmath2 such that @xmath3 it is @xmath4-complete to decide whether such vectors exist @xcite . however , in a p - lcp , @xmath5 is a p - matrix ( meaning that all principal minors are positive ) , and then there are unique solution vectors @xmath6 for every right - hand side @xmath7 @xcite . the problem of efficiently finding them is unsolved , though . megiddo has shown that the p - lcp is unlikely to be np - hard . for this , he considers the following ( more general ) variant : given @xmath5 and @xmath7 , either find @xmath6 that satisfy ( [ eq : lcpdef ] ) , or exhibit a nonpositive principal minor of @xmath5 . np - hardness of the latter variant would imply that @xmath8 @xcite . there is a different notion of hardness that might apply to the p - lcp as a member of the complexity class @xmath9 @xcite . this class has complete problems , and no polynomial - time algorithm is known for any of them . it has recently been shown that the famous problem of finding a nash equilibrium in a bimatrix game is @xmath9-complete @xcite . some researchers consider this to be an explanation why ( despite many efforts ) no polynomial - time algorithm has been found so far . incidentally , this is the _ second _ problem for which megiddo showed in his technical report @xcite that it is unlikely to be np - hard . however , it is currently not known whether the p - lcp is also ppad - complete . there are various algorithms for solving p - lcps , among them the classic method by lemke @xcite as well as interior point approaches @xcite . still , there is no known polynomial - time algorithm for p - lcps . for example , the complexity of interior point algorithms depends linearly on a matrix parameter @xmath10 @xcite that is not bounded for p - matrices . in this work , we focus on combinatorial methods for p - lcps and in particular on _ simple principal pivoting methods _ that share their essential idea with the simplex method . [ [ simple - principal - pivoting - methods . ] ] simple principal pivoting methods . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let @xmath11 , and let @xmath12 be the @xmath13 matrix whose @xmath14th column is the @xmath14th column of @xmath15 if @xmath16 , and the @xmath14th column of the @xmath13 identity matrix @xmath17 otherwise . if @xmath5 is a p - matrix , then @xmath12 is invertible for every set @xmath18 . we call @xmath18 a _ basis_. if @xmath19 , we have discovered the solution : let @xmath20 if on the other hand @xmath21 , then @xmath22 and @xmath23 defined above satisfy @xmath24 and @xmath25 , but @xmath26 fails . in _ principal pivoting _ , one tries to improve the situation by replacing the basis @xmath18 with the symmetric difference @xmath27 , where @xmath28 is some nonempty subset of the `` bad indices '' @xmath29 . the greedy choice is to let @xmath28 be the set of all bad indices in every step . for some p - lcps , however , this algorithm cycles and never terminates @xcite . , one such example is the p - lcp ( [ eq : morrismq ] ) whose digraph model ( see next paragraph ) appears in figure [ fig : uso ] . cycling occurs for any of the three start bases just below the top vertex in figure [ fig : uso ] . ] in _ simple principal pivoting _ , @xmath28 is of size one , and a _ pivot rule _ is employed to select the bad index . simple principal pivoting methods are sometimes called _ bard - type _ methods and were first studied by zoutendijk @xcite and bard @xcite . for a detailed exposition on simple principal pivoting methods see , for instance , ( * ? ? ? * section 4.2 ) or ( * ? ? ? * chapter 4 ) . [ [ the - digraph - model - and - unique - sink - orientations . ] ] the digraph model and unique sink orientations . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + there is a natural digraph model behind principal pivoting , first studied by stickney and watson @xcite . the graph s vertices are all bases @xmath18 , with a directed edge going from @xmath18 to @xmath30 if @xmath31 and @xmath32 . to be nondegenerate , meaning that @xmath33 for all @xmath18 and @xmath14 this is no serious restriction since a nondegenerate problem can always be obtained from a degenerate one by a symbolic perturbation of @xmath7 . ] the underlying undirected graph is the graph of the @xmath34-dimensional cube . a principal pivot step considers the cube that is spanned by the outgoing edges at the current vertex , and it jumps to the antipodal vertex of some subcube of it . a simple principal pivot step can be interpreted as the traversal of an outgoing edge , and this is the analogy with the simplex method for linear programming . the above digraph has the following specific property : every nonempty subcube ( including the whole cube ) has a unique sink , and the global sink corresponds to the solution of the p - lcp @xcite . in the terminology of szab and welzl @xcite , we are dealing with a _ unique - sink orientation _ ( uso ) . the goal of this paper is to deepen the understanding of the uso description of simple principal pivoting methods for the p - lcp . on a general level , we want to understand whether and how algebraic properties of a p - lcp ( which are well studied ) translate to combinatorial properties of the corresponding uso ( which are much less studied ) , and what the algorithmic implications of such translations are . the principal motivation behind this research is the continuing quest for a polynomial - time p - lcp algorithm . in this paper , the concept of a uso serves as the main tool to obtain two more positive results for simple principal pivoting . we believe that this combinatorial approach has some untapped potential for the theory of ( simple ) principal pivoting methods for lcps . [ [ the - randomized - method - of - murty - and - the - morris - orientations . ] ] the ( randomized ) method of murty and the morris orientations . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the simple principal pivoting method of murty ( also known as the _ least - index _ rule ) @xcite works for all p - lcp instances , but it may take exponentially many iterations in the worst case @xcite . as a possible remedy , researchers have considered _ randomized _ methods . the two most prominent ones are randomizedmurty ( which is just the least - index rule , after randomly reshuffling the indices at the beginning ) , and randomedge ( which performs a purely random walk in the uso ) . however , morris found a family of p - lcp instances ( we call their underlying digraphs the _ morris orientations _ ) on which randomedge spends a long time running in cycles and thus performs much worse than even the exhaustive search algorithm @xcite . for randomizedmurty there are as yet no such negative results on p - lcp instances . in particular , on murty s worst - case example , this algorithm takes an expected _ linear _ number of steps @xcite ; the expected number of steps becomes quadratic if we allow arbitrary start vertices @xcite . on general p - lcp instances , the expected number of iterations taken by randomizedmurty is _ subexponential _ if the underlying digraph is acyclic @xcite , but it is unknown whether this also holds under the presence of directed cycles ( as they appear in the morris orientations , for example ) . we prove that not only the randomized variant , but actually _ any _ variant of the least - index rule obtained by some initial reshuffling of indices leads to a _ number of iterations on the morris orientations . in particular , this `` kills '' another family of potentially bad instances for the randomizedmurty rule . [ [ k - matrix - linear - complementarity - problems . ] ] k - matrix linear complementarity problems . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + a _ k - matrix _ is a p - matrix so that all off - diagonal elements are non - positive . lcps with k - matrices ( k - lcps ) appear for example in free boundary problems ( * ? ? ? * section 5.1 ) and in american put option pricing @xcite . it is known that every k - lcp instance can be solved in polynomial time ( even by a simple principal pivoting method @xcite , see also ( * ? ? ? * section 4.7 ) ) , but we prove something stronger : _ every _ simple principal pivoting method takes only a linear number of iterations . we obtain this result by showing that in k - lcp - induced usos , _ all _ directed paths are short . our approach is to extract combinatorial structure from the algebraic properties of k - matrices . subsequently , we use the distilled combinatorial information to get our structural results . [ [ lcps - with - sufficient - matrices - and - the - criss - cross - method . ] ] lcps with sufficient matrices and the criss - cross method . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let us step back and take a broader view that brings together lp , the p - lcp , pivoting methods , and computational complexity : linear complementarity problems with _ sufficient _ matrices generalize both lp and the p - lcp while still being amenable to pivoting approaches . the _ criss - cross method _ @xcite may be considered an extension of murty s algorithm . in fact , the results of @xcite make lcps with sufficient matrices the largest known class of lcps for which megiddo s techniques of @xcite still apply , so that np - hardness is unlikely . determining the complexity of sufficient matrix lcp remains a tough challenge for the future . now we formally introduce the digraph model behind p - lcps and show some of its basic properties . the model was first described by stickney and watson in 1978 @xcite . we use the following notation . let @xmath35:=\{1,2,\ldots , n\}$ ] . for a bit vector @xmath36 and @xmath37 $ ] , let @xmath38 be the element of @xmath39 defined by @xmath40 this means that @xmath38 is obtained from @xmath41 by flipping all entries with coordinates in @xmath42 . instead of @xmath43 we simply write @xmath44 . under this notation , the ( undirected ) _ @xmath34-cube _ is the graph @xmath45 with @xmath46\}.\ ] ] a _ subcube _ of @xmath47 is a subgraph @xmath48 of @xmath47 where @xmath49 for some vertex @xmath41 and some set @xmath50 $ ] , and @xmath51 . [ def : uso ] let @xmath52 be an orientation of the @xmath34-cube ( a digraph with underlying undirected graph @xmath47 ) . we call @xmath52 a _ unique - sink orientation _ ( uso ) if every nonempty subcube has a unique sink in @xmath52 . figure [ fig : uso ] depicts a uso of the 3-cube . the conditions in definition [ def : uso ] require the orientation to have a unique global sink , but in addition , all proper nonempty subcubes must have unique sinks as well . in figure [ fig : uso ] there are six 2-dimensional subcubes , twelve 1-dimensional subcubes ( edges ) and eight 0-dimensional subcubes ( vertices ) . for edges and vertices , the unique - sink condition is trivial . the figure also shows that usos may contain directed cycles . ( @xmath53 for an outgoing edge ; @xmath54 for an incoming edge ) . the unique global sink and a directed cycle are highlighted . [ fig : uso ] ] if @xmath55 is the vertex set of a subcube ( as defined above ) , then the directed subgraph of @xmath56 induced by @xmath55 is denoted by @xmath57 . it is convenient to view the orientation of the @xmath34-cube @xmath47 as a mapping @xmath58 , where @xmath59 if the edge between @xmath41 and @xmath44 is oriented towards @xmath44 , and @xmath60 if it is oriented towards @xmath41 . to encode a vertex @xmath41 along with the orientations of its incident edges , we can then use a _ configuration _ of @xmath34 bits and @xmath34 signs , where the @xmath14th sign is @xmath61 ( see figure [ fig : uso ] ) . if an orientation @xmath52 of @xmath47 contains the directed edge @xmath62 , we write @xmath63 , or simply @xmath64 if @xmath52 is clear from the context . let @xmath52 be an orientation of the @xmath34-cube and let @xmath65 $ ] . then @xmath66 is the orientation of the @xmath34-cube obtained by reversing all edges in coordinates contained in @xmath67 ; formally @xmath68 if @xmath52 is a uso , then @xmath66 is also a uso for an arbitrary subset @xmath65 $ ] . this proposition can be proved by induction on the size of @xmath67 ; it essentially suffices to show that under @xmath69 , the whole cube still has a unique sink . now we can derive the _ unique - completion property_. its meaning is that we can prescribe the bits for some coordinates and the signs for the remaining coordinates , and in a uso there will always be a unique vertex that satisfies the prescription . in particular , it follows that any uso ( and any of its subcubes ) also has a _ unique source_. in fact , the unique - completion property characterizes unique - sink orientations . [ lem : ucp ] an orientation @xmath52 of the @xmath34-cube @xmath47 is a unique - sink orientation if and only if for every partition @xmath35=a\cup b$ ] and every pair of maps @xmath70 , @xmath71 there exists a unique vertex @xmath41 such that [ eq : ucp ] @xmath72 first suppose that @xmath52 is a uso . let @xmath73 and consider the subcube @xmath74 . let @xmath75 . as we have just noted , @xmath66 is a unique - sink orientation , and thus the subcube @xmath74 has a unique sink @xmath41 with respect to @xmath66 . this vertex @xmath41 is the only vertex that satisfies ( [ eq : ucp]a ) and ( [ eq : ucp]b ) . conversely , let @xmath52 be an orientation of the @xmath34-cube which satisfies the unique - completion property and let @xmath76 . set @xmath77 and @xmath78\setminus c$ ] , and let @xmath79 for @xmath80 and @xmath81 for @xmath16 . then the unique vertex @xmath41 satisfying ( [ eq : ucp]a ) and ( [ eq : ucp]b ) is the unique sink of the subcube @xmath74 . [ [ p - lcp - induced - usos . ] ] p - lcp - induced usos . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + we now formally define the uso that is induced by a nondegenerate p - lcp instance @xmath82 @xcite . for @xmath36 , let @xmath83 : v_j=1\}$ ] be the canonical `` set representation '' of @xmath41 . then the unique - sink orientation @xmath52 induced by @xmath82 is @xmath84 recall that @xmath12 is the ( invertible ) @xmath13 matrix whose @xmath14th column is the @xmath14th column of @xmath15 if @xmath16 , and the @xmath14th column of the @xmath13 identity matrix @xmath17 otherwise . in this way , we have reduced the p - lcp to the problem of finding the sink in an implicitly given uso . access to the uso is gained through a _ vertex evaluation oracle _ that for a given vertex @xmath36 returns the orientations @xmath85 of all incident edges . in this setting , the aim is to find the sink of the uso so that the number of queries to the oracle would be bounded by a polynomial in the dimension @xmath34 . in the case of a p - lcp - induced uso , a ( strongly ) polynomial - time implementation of the vertex evaluation oracle is immediate from . from the sink of @xmath52 , we can reconstruct solution vectors @xmath22 and @xmath23 as in . the fact that the @xmath34-cube orientation defined in this way is indeed a unique - sink orientation was proved by stickney and watson @xcite . not every uso is p - lcp - induced ; for @xmath86 , the p - lcp - induced usos are characterized in @xcite , but for @xmath87 , we have only a necessary condition . this condition was originally proved by holt and klee for polytope graphs oriented by linear functions @xcite . every p - lcp - induced uso of the @xmath34-cube satisfies the _ holt - klee condition _ , meaning that there are @xmath34 directed paths from the source to the sink with pairwise disjoint sets of interior vertices.[thm : hk ] in the uso setting resulting from p - lcps , simple principal pivoting can be interpreted as follows : start from any vertex , and then proceed along outgoing edges until the global sink ( and thus the solution to the p - lcp ) is reached . a _ pivot rule _ r determines which outgoing edge to choose if there is more than one option . here is the generic algorithm , parameterized with the rule r. it outputs the unique sink of the given uso @xmath52 . @xmath88 choose @xmath36 choose @xmath89 according to the pivot rule r @xmath90 @xmath41 [ alg : pivot ] note that when @xmath52 contains directed cycles as in figure [ fig : uso ] , this algorithm may enter an infinite loop for certain rules r , but we consider only rules for which this does not happen . in the uso setting we are restricted to _ combinatorial _ rules . these are rules that may access only the orientations of edges @xmath91 ( as given by the vertex evaluation oracle ) but not any numerical values such as @xmath92 that define these orientations . let us now introduce the combinatorial pivot rules that are of interest to us . we write them as functions of the set @xmath93 of candidate indices . the first one is murty s least - index rule @xmath94 that simply chooses the smallest candidate . in the cube , this may be interpreted as a `` greedy '' approach that always traverses the first outgoing edge that it finds ( in the order of the cube dimensions ) . to it is easy to prove by induction on @xmath34 that this rule leads to a finite number of iterations , even if the uso contains directed cycles . the rule has a straightforward generalization , using a fixed permutation @xmath95 : choose the index @xmath96 with the smallest @xmath14 such that @xmath97 . this just reshuffles the cube dimensions by applying @xmath98 , and with @xmath99 , we recover murty s least - index rule . the natural randomized variant of @xmath100 is randomizedmurty : at the beginning , choose the permutation @xmath98 uniformly at random from the set @xmath101 of all permutations , and then use @xmath100 throughout . finally , randomedge stands for the plain random walk : in each iteration , simply choose a random candidate . to unlike the previous rules , randomedge may lead to cycling in @xmath102 , but the algorithm still terminates with probability @xmath103 , and with an expected number of at most @xmath104 iterations . this is a simple consequence of the fact that there is always a short directed path to the sink . [ lem : hamming ] let @xmath105 be the global sink of an @xmath34-cube uso @xmath52 , and let @xmath36 be any vertex . if @xmath106 is the hamming distance between @xmath41 and @xmath107 , then @xmath52 contains a directed path of length @xmath106 from @xmath41 to @xmath107 . morris proved that under @xmath108 , algorithm [ alg : pivot ] may be forced to perform an expected _ exponential _ number of iterations @xcite . more precisely , at least @xmath109 iterations are required on average to find the sink of the @xmath34-cube uso generated ( as described in section [ sec : uso ] ) by the @xmath110 , with @xmath111 here , @xmath34 must be an odd integer in order for @xmath5 to be a p - matrix . to prove this result morris first extracted the relevant structure of the underlying uso , and then showed that on this uso , randomedge runs in cycles for a long time before it finally reaches the global sink . it was left as an open problem to determine the expected performance of randomizedmurty , the other natural randomized rule , on this particular uso . we solve this open problem by showing that for _ any _ permutation @xmath98 , @xmath100 incurs only @xmath112 iterations on the @xmath34-dimensional morris orientation . in particular , this bound then also holds for randomizedmurty . [ thm : general ] for any @xmath113 , algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with @xmath114 finds the sink of the @xmath34-dimensional morris orientation after at most @xmath115 iterations , from any start vertex . computational experiments suggest that the worst running time is attained for the identity permutation if the algorithm starts from @xmath116 ( the global source ) . therefore we analyze this case thoroughly and compute the precise number of iterations . [ thm : id ] algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with @xmath117 finds the sink of the @xmath34-dimensional morris orientation after @xmath118 iterations , starting from @xmath116 . experimental data suggest that this is an upper bound on the number of iterations for any permutation @xmath98 and start vertex @xmath116 . allowing start vertices different from @xmath116 , we get slightly higher iteration numbers , but @xmath99 continues to be the worst permutation . in view of this , we conjecture that @xmath119 iterations actually suffice for all @xmath98 and all start vertices . this would mean that the bound in theorem [ thm : general ] is still off by a factor of @xmath120 . [ [ the - combinatorial - structure . ] ] the combinatorial structure . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + the @xmath34-cube uso resulting from ( [ eq : morrismq ] ) can be described in purely combinatorial terms ( * ? ? ? * lemma 1 ) . here we make its structure even more transparent by exhibiting a _ finite state transducer _ ( finite automaton with output ) with just two states that can be used to describe the uso , see figure [ fig : morrisfst ] . for the remainder of this section , we fix @xmath34 to be an odd integer and we are considering the @xmath34-dimensional morris orientation @xmath56 . ] the orientation is then determined for each vertex @xmath121 as follows . if @xmath122 , then @xmath41 is the global sink . otherwise choose some @xmath14 in @xmath35 $ ] so that @xmath123 and consider the bit string @xmath124 as the input string to the transducer . in other words , the transducer is reading the input from right to left , starting immediately to the left of some @xmath116 . the output string @xmath125 then determines the orientation of each edge incident to @xmath41 . the choice of @xmath14 does not matter , because after reading any zero , the transducer is in the state @xmath126 . for instance , let @xmath127 and let @xmath128 . then the transducer takes @xmath129 , outputs @xmath54 and switches to state @xmath130 ; reads @xmath131 , outputs @xmath53 and switches to @xmath126 ; reads @xmath132 , outputs @xmath53 and stays in @xmath126 ; reads @xmath133 , outputs @xmath54 and switches to @xmath130 ; and finally reads @xmath134 , outputs @xmath54 and switches to @xmath126 . the resulting configuration for @xmath41 is @xmath135 . figure [ fig : uso ] depicts the morris orientation for @xmath86 . it can easily be checked that the above procedural definition of the orientation is equivalent to the one given in ( * ? ? ? * lemma 1 ) . in particular , we obtain a uso . it has the remarkable symmetry that the set of configurations is closed under cyclic shifts . [ [ pivoting . ] ] pivoting . + + + + + + + + + from the transducer we can easily derive the sign changes in the configuration @xmath136 that are caused by a pivot step @xmath137 . we always have @xmath138 and @xmath139 . if @xmath140 , we get @xmath141 . in processing @xmath41 and @xmath142 , the transducer then performs exactly the same steps , except that at the @xmath14th coordinate different transitions are used to get from @xmath130 to @xmath126 . but this implies @xmath143 for @xmath144 . here is an example for such a pivot step ( with @xmath145 ; affected signs are indicated ) : @xmath146 if @xmath123 , we get @xmath147 , meaning that at the @xmath14th coordinate the transducer stays in @xmath126 for @xmath41 but switches to @xmath130 for @xmath142 ( assuming that @xmath142 is not the sink ) . this implies that signs change at all coordinates @xmath148 , @xmath149 down to ( and including ) the next coordinate @xmath106 ( wrap around possible ) for which @xmath150 . in our example we have such a step for @xmath151 : @xmath152 in both @xmath41 and @xmath142 , the signs in the block of @xmath103 s at indices @xmath153 alternate . [ [ levels . ] ] levels . + + + + + + + it will be useful to define the following function on the vertices of the cube . let @xmath154 be the number of coordinates where @xmath155 appears . formally , @xmath156 the number @xmath154 is called the _ level _ of @xmath41 . from the two types of pivots , it is easy to see that the value of @xmath157 does not increase along any directed edge ( * ? ? * lemma 3 ) . indeed , if @xmath142 is an out - neighbor of @xmath41 , then either @xmath158 ( this happens in every pivot of type , and in pivots of type with an odd block of @xmath103 s at indices @xmath153 ) , or @xmath157 decreases to the next possible value : @xmath159 , or @xmath160 if @xmath161 . in particular , the values of @xmath157 lie in the set @xmath162 . the sink is the only vertex at level 0 . let us make a small digression and briefly explain why randomedge is slow on @xmath52 . let @xmath163 . so the outdegree of @xmath41 is @xmath164 . now let @xmath41 be a vertex at level @xmath103 . in pivots of type , @xmath165 decreases by one , whereas in pivots of type that do not reach the sink , @xmath165 increases by one . the latter occurs if and only if randomedge pivots at the unique @xmath155 , which happens with probability @xmath166 . at level @xmath103 , we can thus interpret randomedge as a random walk on the integers , where @xmath167 with probability @xmath168 , and @xmath169 with probability @xmath170 . therefore the walk is strongly biased towards @xmath116 , but in order to reach a neighbor @xmath142 of the sink , we need to get to @xmath171 . this takes exponentially long in expectation @xcite . [ [ a - quadratic - bound - for - textscmurty_pi . ] ] a quadratic bound for @xmath100 . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + to prove theorem [ thm : general ] we first derive a ( somewhat surprising ) more general result : for _ any _ pivot rule , starting from any vertex @xmath41 with @xmath172 for some @xmath106 , it takes @xmath112 iterations to reach a vertex @xmath142 with @xmath173 . this can be viewed as a statement about the uso induced by the @xmath34-dimensional morris orientation on the cube facet @xmath174 . the statement is that in this induced uso , all directed paths are short ( in particular , the induced uso is acyclic ) . [ lem : poten ] let @xmath36 be a vertex , and let @xmath106 be any index for which @xmath175 . starting from @xmath41 , algorithm [ alg : pivot ] ( with an arbitrary pivot rule r ) reaches a vertex @xmath142 satisfying @xmath176 after at most @xmath177 iterations . we employ a nonnegative potential that decreases with every pivot step . by a cyclic shift of coordinates we may assume that @xmath178 , and thus @xmath179 . let us define @xmath180 : v_j = 0 \text { and } \phi(v)_j={-}\},\\ n_1(v ) & : = \{j\in[n ] : v_j = 1 \text { and } \phi(v)_j={-}\}. \end{aligned}\ ] ] the _ potential _ of @xmath41 is the number @xmath181 now we will observe how the potential changes during a pivot step @xmath182 . we always have @xmath138 , @xmath139 . there are two cases . if @xmath140 , as in , the configurations of @xmath41 and @xmath142 differ only at index @xmath14 . hence @xmath183 and @xmath184 . therefore @xmath185 . in the other case we have @xmath123 , as in . if @xmath186 , we are done , since then @xmath187 . otherwise , @xmath41 is of the form @xmath188 with @xmath189 . if @xmath190 is odd , there is an even number of @xmath103 s between @xmath191 and @xmath192 , implying that @xmath193 and @xmath194 . we then have @xmath195 . if @xmath190 is even , there is an odd number of @xmath103 s between @xmath191 and @xmath192 , implying that @xmath196 and @xmath197 . since @xmath198 in this case , we get @xmath199 . to summarize , the potential decreases by at least 1 in every pivot step @xmath200 , and as long as @xmath41 is not the sink , we have @xmath201 . the highest potential is attained by the source , @xmath202 . therefore after at most @xmath177 steps we have @xmath133 . if @xmath41 happens to be at level 1 already , we obtain a better bound , since @xmath203 in this case . in fact , the vertex with largest potential in level 1 such that @xmath179 is @xmath204 , and its potential is @xmath205 . [ cor : poten ] let @xmath36 be a vertex at level 1 , and let @xmath106 be any index for which @xmath175 . starting from @xmath41 , algorithm [ alg : pivot ] ( with arbitrary pivot rule r ) reaches a vertex @xmath142 satisfying @xmath176 after at most @xmath206 iterations . now @xmath100 comes in : we will apply either lemma [ lem : poten ] or corollary [ cor : poten ] to vertices @xmath41 with @xmath207 and @xmath208 , for some @xmath14 . the next lemma shows that the @xmath103 s at coordinates @xmath209 will stay . [ lem : visonly ] let @xmath210 $ ] . after algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with @xmath211 visits a vertex @xmath41 with @xmath208 , it will visit only vertices @xmath142 satisfying @xmath212 . at every iteration , the algorithm replaces the current vertex @xmath41 with @xmath213 , where @xmath214 is the smallest index such that @xmath215 . it follows that coordinates @xmath209 will be touched only if @xmath216 for all @xmath217 . when this holds for the first time , we have @xmath218 the unique - completion property ( lemma [ lem : ucp ] ) then implies that we have already reached the sink . now we can put it all together . let @xmath41 be the start vertex , and let @xmath14 be the largest index such that @xmath207 ( if no such index exists , @xmath41 is the sink , and we are done ) . lemmas [ lem : poten ] and [ lem : visonly ] show that after at most @xmath219 iterations , we additionally have @xmath220 ( since the next pivot step flips @xmath221 ) . at this point @xmath41 is at level 1 , since there is a unique @xmath155 : at coordinate @xmath96 . after the flip at coordinate @xmath96 , we repeatedly apply corollary [ cor : poten ] together with lemma [ lem : visonly ] to also produce @xmath103 s at coordinates @xmath222 , at which point we have reached the sink . this takes at most @xmath223 more iterations , summing up to a total of @xmath224 a better bound in the case of the identity permutation can be achieved by thoroughly examining the run of the algorithm , as we do next . [ [ the - identity - permutation . ] ] the identity permutation . + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + let us now go on to prove theorem [ thm : id ] . for this , we first identify certain `` milestone '' vertices that are visited by algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with @xmath117 , and then we count the number of iterations to get from one milestone to the next . let us define @xmath225 [ lem : l4 ] if algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with @xmath117 starts at the vertex @xmath226 , @xmath227 , it gets to the vertex @xmath228 in @xmath229 iterations . the algorithm starts at @xmath230 , and then proceeds by the rules of pivoting and in four phases ( recall that @xmath231 always pivots on the leftmost @xmath53 ) : * it pivots on the coordinates @xmath232 , @xmath233 , , @xmath103 and thus reaches the vertex + @xmath234 after @xmath235 iterations . * it pivots on the coordinates @xmath236 , @xmath120 , @xmath237 , , @xmath238 , @xmath239 and thus reaches the vertex + @xmath240 after @xmath235 iterations ; * it pivots on the coordinates @xmath238 , @xmath241 , , @xmath236 and thus reaches the vertex + @xmath242 after @xmath14 iterations ; * it pivots on the coordinates @xmath103 , @xmath243 , @xmath244 , , @xmath232 and thus reaches the vertex + @xmath245 after @xmath235 iterations . therefore it takes @xmath229 iterations to get from @xmath226 to @xmath228 . the previous lemma allows us to count the number of iterations from @xmath246 to @xmath247 . the following lemma takes care of the remaining iterations . [ lem : l6 ] if algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with @xmath117 starts at the vertex @xmath247 , it gets to the global sink in @xmath248 iterations . the proof is similar to the proof of lemma [ lem : l4 ] , except that here only the first phase takes place : if the algorithm starts at the vertex @xmath249 , it pivots on coordinates @xmath34 , @xmath250 , , @xmath103 and thus reaches the sink after @xmath248 iterations . by lemmas [ lem : l4 ] and [ lem : l6 ] , the overall number of iterations from the source to the sink is @xmath251 in this section we examine _ k - lcps _ , the linear complementarity problems @xmath110 where @xmath5 is a k - matrix . we introduce two simple combinatorial conditions on unique - sink orientations and prove that one of them implies that all directed paths from @xmath116 are short , and the other one implies that all directed paths in the orientation are short . we show that k - lcp orientations satisfy these conditions and conclude that a simple principal pivoting method with an arbitrary pivot rule solves a k - lcp in linearly many iterations , starting from any vertex . a unique - sink orientation @xmath52 is _ 2-up - uniform _ if whenever @xmath253 is such that @xmath254 and @xmath142 is the source of @xmath255 , then the orientation of the subcube @xmath74 is uniform ( see figure [ fig:2uu ] ) . the essential fact we use is that a subcube of a k - uso is also a k - uso , as was observed already by stickney and watson ( * ? ? ? * lemma 1 ) . thus it suffices to prove 2-up - uniformity for k - lcps of dimension 2 . hence suppose that @xmath257 is a @xmath258 k - matrix , so @xmath259 and @xmath260 . then @xmath261 and nonsingular . now 0 is the source of the orientation induced by the @xmath110 if and only if @xmath262 . hence @xmath263 , which proves uniformity . one particular nice property of a 2-up - uniform orientation is that all paths from the vertex 0 to the sink @xmath107 have the shortest possible length , equal to the hamming distance @xmath264 of @xmath107 from @xmath116 . to prove this statement , we use the following lemma . suppose for the sake of contradiction that @xmath140 , @xmath266 and @xmath269 , and that @xmath267 , @xmath270 and @xmath271 . let @xmath272 and consider the subcube @xmath74 ( see figure [ fig : uni - proof1 ] , left ) : we observe that @xmath273 because otherwise the subcube would not contain a sink . but then it follows from 2-up - uniformity of @xmath52 that @xmath274 , a contradiction . it follows from lemma [ lem : crufa - up ] by induction that if @xmath142 is a vertex on any directed path starting from @xmath116 , and if @xmath147 , then @xmath274 . hence all edges on a directed path from @xmath116 to @xmath107 are oriented from 0 to 1 , and therefore the length of a directed path from @xmath116 to @xmath107 is @xmath264 . what is the actual strength of this theorem ? we know that from any vertex of a unique - sink orientation there _ exists _ a path to the sink of length at most @xmath34 ( lemma [ lem : hamming ] ) . it has also long been known how to find such a path from the vertex 0 in the case of a k - uso @xcite . the novelty is that _ any _ directed path starting from 0 reaches the sink after the least possible number of iterations . hence a simple principal pivoting method with an _ arbitrary _ pivot rule finds the solution to a k - lcp in at most @xmath34 iterations . in view of this result , it is natural to ask whether it also holds if the path starts in some vertex different from 0 . imposing 2-up - uniformity is insufficient , as we can observe by looking at the morris orientations . if we swap 0 s and 1 s in any morris orientation , we get a 2-up - uniform orientation . hence all directed paths from 0 to the sink are short ; indeed , 0 is the sink of the orientation after swapping , so all such paths have length 0 . nevertheless , long directed paths ( and even directed cycles ) do exist in this orientation . therefore we introduce the following stronger combinatorial property of usos , which turns out to be satisfied by k - usos as well . [ cor:2n ] algorithm [ alg : pivot ] with an arbitrary pivot rule r , starting at an arbitrary vertex of the corresponding uso , finds the solution to an @xmath34-dimensional k - lcp in at most @xmath280 iterations . as a consequence , we get a result for a larger class of lcps . if @xmath5 is a _ principal pivotal transform _ * section 2.3 ) of a k - matrix @xmath281 , then @xmath5 is a p - matrix ( * ? ? ? * theorem 4.1.3 ) , and the uso @xmath52 induced by the @xmath110 is isomorphic to the uso @xmath282 induced by the @xmath283 for suitable @xmath284 . it follows that corollary [ cor:2n ] also applies to the @xmath110 , even though @xmath5 is not necessarily a k - matrix itself . our proof of theorem [ thm:2lu ] is based on the following crucial fact , which extends lemma [ lem : crufa - up ] . informally , it asserts that once we have a @xmath285 in some coordinate , we will always have a @xmath285 . if @xmath266 , the claim follows from lemma [ lem : crufa - up ] . so let us suppose that we have @xmath140 , @xmath286 and @xmath269 , and that @xmath267 , @xmath270 and @xmath287 . let @xmath288 . we observe that @xmath273 so that the subcube @xmath74 contains a sink . but then it follows from 2-up - uniformity of @xmath278)}$ ] that @xmath64 , a contradiction ( see figure [ fig : uni - proof1 ] , right ) . let @xmath14 be a fixed coordinate . suppose in the considered directed path there is an edge @xmath269 such that @xmath140 . as a consequence of lemma [ lem : crufa ] , all vertices @xmath142 on a directed path starting at @xmath41 satisfy @xmath147 . it follows that in any directed path no more than two edges appear of the form @xmath289 for any fixed @xmath14 : possibly one with @xmath123 and one with @xmath140 . this fact then implies that the length of any directed path is at most @xmath280 . the strength of 2-uniformity can perhaps be explained by its being equivalent to what we call _ local uniformity_. a uso @xmath52 is _ locally up - uniform _ if for every @xmath290 such that @xmath291 and @xmath292 for all @xmath293 , the orientation of the subcube @xmath74 is uniform . a uso @xmath52 is _ locally uniform _ if both @xmath52 and @xmath278)}$ ] are locally up - uniform . local up - uniformity allows for a slight improvement in solving a k - lcp . when following a directed path starting in 0 , instead of traversing one edge at a time we can perform a `` greedy '' principal pivot : jump straight to the sink of the subcube induced by outgoing edges . unlike the general p - matrix case , it can not lead to cycling . due to local up - uniformity , it will never increase the number of iterations and may sometimes reduce it . the answer to this question is negative . it can be shown that the number of @xmath34-dimensional locally uniform usos is asymptotically much larger than the number of k - usos . a lower bound of @xmath294 on the number of locally uniform usos can be derived by an adaptation of develin s construction @xcite of many orientations satisfying the holt - klee condition . an upper bound of @xmath295 on the number of p - usos ( and thus also k - usos ) follows from develin s proof of his upper bound on the number of lp - realizable cube orientations . a. borici and h .- j . pricing american put options by fast solutions of the linear complementarity problem . in e. j. kontoghiorghes , b. rustem , and s. siokos , editors , _ computational methods in decision - making , economics and finance _ , volume 74 of _ applied optimization_. kluwer acad . dordrecht , 2002 . f. holt and v. klee . a proof of the strict monotone @xmath120-step conjecture . in _ advances in discrete and computational geometry _ , volume 223 of _ contemp . _ , pages 201216 .
Abstract: | [
"we study the behavior of simple principal pivoting methods for the p - matrix linear complementarity problem ( p - lcp ) . we solve an open problem of morris by showing that murty s least - index pivot rule ( under any fixed index order ) leads to a quadratic number of iterations on morris s highly cyclic p - lcp examples . we then show that on k - matrix lcp instances , _ all _ pivot rules require only a linear number of iterations . as the main tool , we employ _ unique - sink orientations _ of cubes , a useful combinatorial abstraction of the p - lcp ."
] | 9,157 | 9,157 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the primordial cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) was generated when photons first decoupled from the baryonic fluid when the universe was only 400,000 years old . the vast majority of these photons travel unperturbed to the present day , and features of their angular power spectrum such as acoustic peaks and the damping tail @xcite record valuable information about cosmological parameters @xcite . baryons and dark matter evolve from small inhomogeneities at decoupling into increasingly complicated large - scale structure which can subtly perturb the observed pattern of cmb anisotropies . assuming that the primordial cmb is gaussian , non - gaussian correlations in the observed map can be used to reconstruct the intervening large - scale structure @xcite . in addition to the importance of learning about the large - scale structure itself , reconstruction of the weak - lensing potential generated by structure is essential to constraining tensor perturbations . weak lensing converts a fraction of the e - mode polarization generated by scalar perturbations at the last - scattering surface into b - mode polarization in the observed map . only by subtracting this b - mode polarization can one conclusively detect the primordial b - modes which serve as a model - independent signal of tensor perturbations @xcite . understanding lensing reconstruction requires a more detailed discussion of how weak lensing affects the cmb . weak gravitational lensing deflects the paths of cmb photons as they travel from the last - scattering surface to the observer . this deflection is accomplished by a projected lensing potential which is a weighted line - of - sight integral of the gravitational potential between the observer and the surface of last - scattering . at each point on the sky , lensing remaps the temperature and polarization to that of a nearby point at the last - scattering surface , the deflection angle being the gradient of the aforementioned projected lensing potential . assuming that this deflection angle is small , the temperature at any point can be expanded in a taylor series in the gradient of the lensing potential . in fourier space , this expansion appears as a series of convolutions of individual temperature and projected potential modes . the observed temperature - squared map in fourier space also appears as a convolution of individual fourier modes . subject to an overall normalization dependent on the scale of the fourier mode , these convolutions cancel in such a manner that each fourier mode of the temperature - squared map acts as an estimator for the _ same _ fourier mode of the projected lensing potential . lensing reconstruction as outlined above has been considered previously @xcite . in these works , two sources of noise were identified , and a filter of the temperature - squared map in fourier space was chosen to minimize the variance associated with lensing reconstruction subject to these noise sources . the first source is intrinsic signal variance ; the observed large - scale structure is one arbitrary member of an ensemble of realizations allowed by theory . the second source of noise , endemic to this method of lensing reconstruction , is a consequence of the nature of the primordial cmb . like the large - scale structure itself , the pattern of cmb anisotropies at the last - scattering surface is only one of many possible realizations allowed by theory . we do not know _ a priori _ which of these realizations nature has provided us , and this uncertainty hinders our ability to deconvolve the effects of lensing from true anisotropies at the last - scattering surface . even if the true pattern of anisotropies at the last - scattering surface was known , the finite amount of power in the cmb at small scales would still constrain lensing reconstruction . silk damping at the last - scattering surface suppresses cmb power at small scales , while the finite resolution of any real experiment would limit the detection of any signal that is present at small scales . lensing reconstruction fails below scales at which there is sufficient power , for the same reason that any remapping is indistinguishable given a uniform background . here , we consider a third source of noise neglected in previous studies . the filtered temperature - squared map is an unbiased estimator for the lensing potential in the approximation that a correlation between two given temperature modes is induced only by the single lensing mode whose wavevector is the sum of that of the two temperature modes . in actuality , any combination of two or more lensing modes whose wavevectors sum to this total induce correlations between the two temperature modes . there are many such combinations , but since these correlations add incoherently we do not expect a systematic bias . nonetheless , for estimators of each individual lensing mode we must use our knowledge of other lensing modes to subtract off this unwanted bias . this is an iterative process , and since our knowledge of the lensing map is imperfect it induces noise in lensing reconstruction . we calculate this additional variance for various estimators constructed from cmb temperature and polarization maps , and show how it compares to the dominant noise sources for an all - sky cmb experiment with a noise - equivalent temperature of 1 @xmath1k @xmath2 . since the lensing - potential power spectrum is a measure of the theoretical uncertainty with which we can predict the value of a given lensing mode , this noise associated with lensing reconstruction causes a systematic overestimation of the lensing - potential power spectrum . this systematic bias must be accounted for in order to compare observations with theoretical predictions . this paper is organized as follows . in [ s : lensing ] , we define the formalism we will use to explore the effects of weak lensing on the cmb . the taylor expansion of the lensed cmb map in gradients of the lensing potential is given in both real and fourier space , and the power spectra and trispectra of various components of the cmb temperature map are listed for later use . in [ s : estimators ] , we show that the fourier modes of the temperature - squared map when properly filtered can serve as estimators for the fourier modes of the displacement map with the same wave vector . using the power spectrum and trispectrum given in the preceding section , we calculate the variance associated with this estimator including a new component neglected in previous studies . this variance is evaluated numerically using the currently favored @xmath0cdm cosmological model with baryon density @xmath3 , matter density @xmath4 , cosmological constant density @xmath5 , hubble parameter @xmath6=0.65 , and power - spectrum amplitude @xmath7 . we then use the displacement estimator for individual fourier modes to construct an unbiased estimator for the lensing - potential power spectrum in [ s : power ] , and calculate the variance and covariance associated with this estimator . a few concluding remarks about the implications of our work for future studies are given in [ s : disc ] . the appendix contains useful formulae related to additional estimators of lensing based on polarization and a combination of temperature and polarization . we consider weak lensing under the flat - sky approximation following refs . @xcite . as discussed before @xcite , weak lensing deflects the path of cmb photons resulting in a remapping of the observed temperature pattern on the sky , @xmath8 \nonumber\\ & \approx & { \theta}({\hat{\bf n } } ) + \nabla_i { \phi}({\hat{\bf n } } ) \nabla^i { \theta}({\hat{\bf n } } ) + \frac{1}{2 } \nabla_i { \phi}({\hat{\bf n } } ) \nabla_j { \phi}({\hat{\bf n } } ) \nabla^{i}\nabla^{j } { \theta}({\hat{\bf n } } ) + \ldots\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath9 is the unlensed primary component of the cmb in a direction @xmath10 at the last scattering surface . the observed , gravitationally - lensed temperature map @xmath11 in direction @xmath10 is that of the unlensed map in direction @xmath12 where @xmath13 represents the lensing deflection angle or displacement map . although a real cmb map will include secondary contributions such as the sz effect @xcite , we assume that such effects can be distinguished by their frequency dependence @xcite . they will not be further considered in this paper . a noise component denoted by @xmath14 due to finite experimental sensitivity must be included as well . thus the total observed cmb anisotropy will be @xmath15 . taking the fourier transform of the lensed map @xmath11 under the flat - sky approximation , we write @xmath16 where @xmath17 + \frac{1}{2 } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf l''}}{(2\pi)^2}}{\phi}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime\prime } } } } ) \\ & & \quad \times { \phi}({{\mathbf{l}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime\prime } } } } ) \ , ( { { \mathbf{l^{\prime\prime}}}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \left [ ( { { \mathbf{l^{\prime\prime}}}}+ { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}- { { \mathbf{l}}})\cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}\right ] + \ldots \ , . \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] cmb correlations in fourier space can be described in terms of a power spectrum and trispectrum as defined in the usual manner , @xmath18 where the angle brackets denote ensemble averages over possible realizations of the primordial cmb , large - scale structure between the observer and the surface of last - scattering , and instrumental noise . the subscript @xmath19 denotes the connected part of the four - point function and the superscript @xmath20 denotes the temperature map being considered ( @xmath21 or @xmath22 ) . the lensing - potential power spectrum can be defined analogously , @xmath23 where here the angle brackets denote an average over all realizations of the large - scale structure . we make the assumption that primordial fluctuations at the last - scattering surface are gaussian . gaussian statistics are fully described by a power spectrum ; the gaussian four - point correlator , @xmath24 is zero . the instrumental noise @xmath22 is also assumed to be gaussian , as is the lensing potential @xmath25 . this second assumption is justified because the dominant contributions to the lensing potential come from intermediate redshifts @xmath26 at which linear theory holds . using these definitions , we can calculate the anticipated power spectrum and trispectrum of the observed cmb map . because the instrumental noise is uncorrelated with the signal , the power spectrum of the observed map is the sum of signal and noise power spectra , @xmath27 the power spectrum of the noise component is given by : @xmath28 where @xmath29 is the fraction of the sky surveyed , @xmath30 is the variance per unit area on the sky , and @xmath31 is the effective beamwidth of the instrument expressed in terms of its full - width half - maximum resolution @xmath32 . a cmb experiment that spends a time @xmath33 examining each of @xmath34 pixels with detectors of sensitivity @xmath35 will have a variance per unit area @xmath36 @xcite . the power spectrum of the lensed cmb can be determined by inserting eq . ( [ e : thetal ] ) into eq . ( [ e : specdef ] ) as discussed in @xcite , @xmath37 \ , c_l^{{\theta}{\theta } } + { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf l}_1}{(2\pi)^2 } } c_{| { { \bf l}}- { { \bf l}}_1|}^{{\theta}{\theta } } c^{\phi\phi}_{l_1 } [ ( { { \bf l}}- { { \bf l}}_1)\cdot { { \bf l}}_1]^2 \ , . \label{e : lenpow}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this result is given to linear order in the lensing - potential power spectrum @xmath38 . lensing neither creates nor destroys power in the cmb , but merely shifts the scales on which it occurs as seen by the fact that @xmath39 the observed cmb trispectrum can be calculated in a similar manner ; under our assumptions of gaussian instrumental noise and no secondary anisotropies the trispectrum of the lensed component @xmath40 is the sole contribution to the total observed trispectrum , @xmath41 [ ( { { { \bf l}_1}}+ { { { \bf l}_3 } } ) \cdot { { { \bf l}_4 } } ] + c^{{\phi\phi}}_{|{{\bf l}}_2+{{\bf l}}_3| } [ ( { { { \bf l}_2}}+{{{\bf l}_3 } } ) \cdot { { { \bf l}_3 } } ] [ ( { { { \bf l}_2}}+{{{\bf l}_3 } } ) \cdot { { { \bf l}_4 } } ] \big ] + \ , { \rm perm . } \ , . \nonumber \\ \label{e : trilens}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the term shown above is manifestly symmetric under the interchange @xmath42 , while the `` + perm . '' represents five additional terms identical in form but with the replacement of @xmath43 and @xmath44 with the other five combinations of pairs . the total trispectrum is symmetric under the interchange of any given pair as one would expect . having established a formalism within which to analyze weak lensing , we now consider the problem of reconstructing the lensing potential from an observed cmb temperature map . in this section , we examine lensing reconstruction following the approach of ref . @xcite , largely adopting their notation as well . the only important difference in notation is that we use @xmath40 to denote the lensed temperature field and @xmath45 for the unlensed field following ref . @xcite and most recent papers . ref . @xcite uses the opposite convention . for @xmath46 and to linear order in @xmath25 , @xmath47 where @xmath48 and @xmath49 . note that @xmath50 differs from the unmarked @xmath51 that first appeared in eq . ( [ e : specdef ] ) in that it denotes an ensemble average only over different gaussian realizations of the primordial cmb and instrument noise ; a fixed realization of the large - scale structure is assumed . for the purposes of estimating the large - scale structure actually realized in our observable universe , this is the appropriate average to take to ensure that our estimators are truly unbiased for a typical realization of the primordial cmb . when calculating the noise associated with lensing - potential estimators and again for power spectrum estimation in [ s : power ] , we will return to the full unmarked ensemble average . ( [ e : ea ] ) , an immediate consquence of eq . ( [ e : thetal ] ) , suggests that a temperature - squared map appropriately filtered in fourier space can serve as an estimator for the deflection field @xmath52 . hu and okamoto define five different estimators for the deflection field constructed from various combinations of the temperature and polarization ; we discuss the temperature - squared estimator in this section and relegate the analogous formulae for polarization estimators to the appendix . the minimum - variance temperature - squared estimator derived in ref . @xcite is @xmath53 where @xmath54 @xmath55^{-1 } \ , , \ ] ] and @xmath56 . substitution of eqs . ( [ e : ea ] ) , ( [ e : bias ] ) , ( [ e : filt ] ) , and ( [ e : norm ] ) into eq . ( [ e : est ] ) shows the desired result , @xmath57 namely that @xmath58 is indeed an unbiased estimator for the deflection field in fourier space . we now proceed to calculate the variance of this estimator . at first , we assume a complete knowledge of all lensing modes not examined by this estimator . in that case , we find @xmath59 where @xmath60 . evaluating the four - point function in the integrand of eq . ( [ e : estvar , cmb ] ) to second order in the lensing field , we obtain @xmath61 \nonumber \\ & & \quad \times \bigl [ { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}\cdot ( { { { \bf l}_2}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] - \frac{1}{2 } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf l'}}{(2\pi)^2}}{\phi}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) { \phi}(-{{\mathbf{l}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl\ { c_{l_1}^{{\theta}{\theta } } ( { { { \bf l}_1}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl [ { { { \bf l}_1}}\cdot ( { { \mathbf{l}}}+ { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] + c_{l_2}^{{\theta}{\theta } } ( { { { \bf l}_2}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl [ { { { \bf l}_2}}\cdot ( { { \mathbf{l}}}+ { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] \bigr\ } \biggr ] \nonumber \\ & & \quad \times \biggl [ \bigl ( c_{l_{1}^{\prime}}^{{\theta}{\theta } } + c_{l_{1}^{\prime}}^{{\theta}{\theta}{{\rm n } } } \bigr ) ( 2 \pi)^2 \delta_{{\rm d}}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) + { \phi}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) { f_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } ' , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) - { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf l'}}{(2\pi)^2}}c_{l^{\prime}}^{{\theta}{\theta } } { \phi}({{{\bf l}_1 } } ' - { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) { \phi}({{{\bf l}_2 } } ' + { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl [ { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}\cdot ( { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' - { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] \nonumber \\ & & \quad \times \bigl [ { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}\cdot ( { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' + { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] + \frac{1}{2 } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf l'}}{(2\pi)^2}}{\phi}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) { \phi}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl\ { c_{l_{1}^{\prime}}^{{\theta}{\theta } } ( { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' \cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl [ { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' \cdot ( { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] + c_{l_{2}^{\prime}}^{{\theta}{\theta } } ( { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' \cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigl [ { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' \cdot ( { { \mathbf{l^{\prime}}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \bigr ] \bigr\ } \biggr ] { \rm + perm . } \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] the terms given explicitly in eq . ( [ e:4pt , cmb ] ) correspond to the correlations between @xmath62 and @xmath63 and those between @xmath64 and @xmath65 . the `` + perm . '' stands for two additional terms , identical in form , arising from the pairings @xmath66 and @xmath67 . this expression indicates how uncertainty in the cmb at the last - scattering surface propagates into uncertainty in lensing reconstruction for a particular realization @xmath68 of the large - scale structure . to linear order in eq . ( [ e:4pt , cmb ] ) , correlations between the modes @xmath69 and @xmath64 are induced by those lensing modes whose wavevectors are the sums of any pair of wavevectors of these four modes . these lensing modes are precisely those forming the diagonals of the quadrilaterals depicted in fig . [ f:2quad ] . in practice , we do not know the large - scale structure between us and the last - scattering surface , so we assume a variance given by eq . ( [ e : lenpowdef ] ) with a model - dependent power spectrum @xmath70 . we must average eq . ( [ e : estvar , cmb ] ) over different realizations of the large - scale structure ( denoted by @xmath71 ) to obtain the total expected variance of our estimator , @xmath72 where @xmath73 the assumption that the lensing potential is gaussian imposes the constraint @xmath74 which closes the quadrilaterals of fig . [ f:2quad ] . the average of the four - point correlation function in eq . ( [ e : estvar ] ) can be calculated by further averaging eq . ( [ e:4pt , cmb ] ) over the large - scale structure . terms linear in the lensing field vanish when averaged over different realizations of the large - scale structure . quadratic terms in the lensing field arise as products either of two linear terms or of a zeroth and second - order term . averages over the product of two linear terms produce the connected part of the four - point correlation function , the trispectrum defined in eq . ( [ e : specdef ] ) . averages over the product of a zeroth and second - order term have no connected portion , but instead furnish an implicit dependence on @xmath70 in the total observed power spectrum of eq . ( [ e : temptot ] ) . the final result of averaging over the large - scale structure can be expressed in terms of the observed power spectrum and trispectrum , @xmath75 \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the trispectrum can written in terms of @xmath76 as @xmath77 this form of the trispectrum is consistent with that of eq . ( [ e : trilens ] ) given directly in terms of power spectra . since @xmath78 , @xmath79 and the first term of eq . ( [ e:4pt ] ) vanishes . the remaining two terms containing pairs of delta functions , inserted into eq . ( [ e : estvar ] ) , yield the dominant contribution to the variance , @xmath80 \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath81 . notice that @xmath82 is zeroth order in the lensing potential @xmath25 ; it depends on the lensing potential power spectrum @xmath83 only implicitly though the total observed power spectrum @xmath84 . the ellipsis represents terms of higher order in @xmath83 that we now proceed to calculate . these terms arise from the trispectrum term of eq . ( [ e:4pt ] ) after @xmath85 is removed . substituting these results into eq . ( [ e : estvar ] ) , we find that to first order in @xmath83 , @xmath86 \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath87 is given by , @xmath88 the first - order contribution to the noise @xmath87 involves integrals over the lensing - potential power spectrum , and thus probes lensing modes with wave vectors different from that of the estimator @xmath58 . it can be interpreted physically as interference from these other modes in the determination of the mode @xmath89 being estimated . the filter @xmath90 was chosen to optimize the signal - to - noise ratio in the absence of the first - order contribution @xmath87 ; it is no longer an optimal filter once this additional noise is taken into account . as long as @xmath91 , the noise reduction that can be attained by re - optimizing our filter will not be significant . formulas analagous to those presented here relevant to the construction of estimators using polarization data are given in the appendix . the significance of @xmath87 for two different experiments is shown in fig . [ f : plrec ] using the currently favored @xmath0cdm cosmological model with baryon density @xmath3 , matter density @xmath4 , cosmological constant density @xmath5 , hubble parameter @xmath6=0.65 , and power - spectrum amplitude @xmath7 . the planck experiment is equivalent to a one - year , full - sky survey with temperature and polarization sensitivities of 12.42 and 26.02 @xmath92 respectively and resolution @xmath93 arcminutes as described in [ s : lensing ] . the reference experiment has the same resolution but superior sensitivities of 0.46 and 0.65 @xmath94 for temperature and polarization . these estimates of experimental parameters are identical to those given for the planck and reference experiments of ref . the @xmath95 and @xmath96 estimators have noise power spectra intermediate to those of the @xmath97 and @xmath98 estimators , while the @xmath99 estimator has substantially higher noise because the primordial cmb lacks true b - modes in the absence of inflationary gravitational waves . we see that for planck , with its comparatively inferior polarization sensitivity , the @xmath97 estimator will be best although it will be unable to detect individual fourier modes of the deflection field at the @xmath100 level . the reference experiment , and further experiments with similar sensitivity and even higher resolution , should be able to push @xmath100 detection of individual @xmath89 modes to @xmath101 by primarily relying on the @xmath98 estimator . in these cases the secondary noise @xmath102 is only smaller than the dominant noise @xmath103 by a factor of a few , whereas for higher sensitivity ( noisier ) experiments like planck it is smaller by at least an order - of - magnitude . this illustrates an interesting point , apparent from fig . [ f : plrec ] , that the zeroth - order noise @xmath82 declines dramatically with decreasing sensitivity until it becomes dominated by cosmic variance while the @xmath87 is largely unaffected by instrument sensitivity . the reasons for this trend are that instrument noise appears in @xmath81 through its contribution to the denominator of @xmath104 as shown by eqs . ( [ e : filt ] ) and ( [ e : norm ] ) . decreasing instrument noise raises the value of @xmath104 thereby lowering @xmath82 . by contrast instrument noise is reflected in @xmath87 through its effects on both @xmath105 and @xmath104 as shown in eq . ( [ e:1st ] ) . smaller instrument noise raises @xmath104 as before , driving @xmath87 up in this case , but this is compensated by a decrease in @xmath105 which appears as a prefactor outside the integrals . these two effects largely cancel each other out , rendering @xmath87 remarkably insensitive to instrument noise . although complete reconstruction of the deflection field @xmath89 can be an enormously powerful tool , such as for b - mode subtraction @xcite , for some purposes estimates of the lensing - potential power spectrum @xmath106 are sufficient . this power spectrum is a model - dependent prediction of theories of large - scale structure formation , and therefore estimates of the power spectrum from real data could be used to test these theories as well as the consistency of other determinations of cosmological parameters . furthermore , since estimates of all the modes @xmath89 with @xmath107 can be combined to estimate @xmath106 , @xmath100 detection of the power spectrum can be pushed to much higher @xmath108 than can that of individual modes . the deflection - field estimator @xmath58 derived in the preceding section can be used to construct an estimator for @xmath106 . our first guess for an appropriate lensing - potential power spectrum estimator is @xmath109 where @xmath110 is the area of the sky surveyed and @xmath111 is an annulus of radius @xmath108 and width @xmath112 . we ensemble average our estimator over different realizations of the cmb and large - scale structure using eq . ( [ e : prodave ] ) by bringing @xmath113 from the left to the right - hand side . this yields @xmath114 \ , .\ ] ] the definition of the dirac delta function , @xmath115 implies that @xmath116 . furthermore , in the limit that @xmath112 is small compared to the scales on which @xmath117 is varying , we can evaluate the integrand of eq . ( [ e : naive2 ] ) at its central value @xmath118 and extract it from the integral . the integral over the annulus @xmath111 cancels the factor @xmath119 in the denominator , reducing eq . ( [ e : naive2 ] ) to @xmath120 \ , .\ ] ] @xmath121 is indeed an estimator for the lensing - potential power spectrum @xmath106 , albeit a biaed one . note that the _ bias _ in the power - spectrum estimator @xmath121 is precisely the same as the _ variance _ shown in eq . ( [ e : prodave ] ) with which we were able to determine each individual lensing mode . this is no coincidence ; it reflects the fact that there are no grounds _ a priori _ on which to differentiate the variance with which we can reconstruct individual modes @xmath89 from the intrinsic variance @xmath122 of the underlying distribution from which they are drawn . to obtain an unbiased estimator to compare with theoretical predictions , we subtract off this unwanted reconstruction variance , @xmath123 \ , .\ ] ] since @xmath87 as defined in eq . ( [ e:1st ] ) itself depends on @xmath106 , this subtraction and evaluation must be performed iteratively until a self - consistent solution is obtained . the variance of our estimator @xmath124 can be calculated in the usual manner , @xmath125 evaluating this expression requires us to calculate @xmath126 \left [ { { \mathbf{d}}_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \cdot { { \mathbf{d}}_{\theta\theta}}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \right ] \rangle \ , .\ ] ] since @xmath58 is a quadratic estimator in the temperature map , eq . ( [ e : dl2 ] ) includes the following integral over the eight - point correlation function in fourier space , @xmath127 \left [ { { \mathbf{d}}_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \cdot { { \mathbf{d}}_{\theta\theta}}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \right ] \rangle = \frac{{a_{\theta\theta}}^2(l_{1}^{\prime } ) { a_{\theta\theta}}^2(l_{2}^{\prime})}{(l_{1}^{\prime})^2 ( l_{2}^{\prime})^2 } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf k}_1}{(2\pi)^2 } } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf k}_3}{(2\pi)^2 } } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf k}_5}{(2\pi)^2 } } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf k}_7}{(2\pi)^2 } } \nonumber \\ & & \quad \times \big\ { { f_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf k}_1 } } , { { { \bf k}_2 } } ) { f_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf k}_3 } } , { { { \bf k}_4 } } ) { f_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf k}_5 } } , { { { \bf k}_6 } } ) { f_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf k}_7 } } , { { { \bf k}_8 } } ) \langle { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_1 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_2 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_3 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_4 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_5 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_6 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_7 } } ) { \theta}^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf k}_8 } } ) \rangle \big\ } \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath128 , @xmath129 , @xmath130 , and @xmath131 . a fully general eight - point correlation function consists of a connected part , as well as terms proportional to the product of lower - order correlation functions . under the assumption that both the primordial cmb and the lensing potential are governed by gaussian statistics , all correlation functions higher than the four - point have vanishing connected parts @xcite . the temperature eight - point correlation function will therefore be composed of three groups of terms ; membership in a group being determined by whether the term contains zero , one , or two factors of the trispectrum . since the trispectrum given in eq . ( [ e : trilens ] ) is first order in the lensing - potential power spectrum @xmath106 , terms of these three groups are zeroth , first , and second order respectively in @xmath106 . combinatorics determines the number of terms in each group . there are : @xmath132 different ways of dividing @xmath133 into four pairs , and hence there will be 105 terms in the group containing no trispectra . similar calculations reveal that there are @xmath134 terms in the second group and @xmath135 terms in the third group . many terms in all three groups will vanish for the same reason that the first term vanished in the four - point correlation function of eq . ( [ e:4pt ] ) ; these terms are proportional to a dirac delta function evaluated at nonzero argument . consider now the first group of terms , those that are zeroth order in @xmath106 . the 60 nonvanishing terms in this group each contain four dirac delta functions ; they can be further segregated into the 12 terms that allow two of the integrals over @xmath136 appearing in eq . ( [ e:8pt ] ) to be immediately evaluated via dirac delta functions , and the 48 terms that allow evaluation of three @xmath136 integrals . the first 12 terms , inserted into eq . ( [ e:8pt ] ) and appropriately evaluated using the normalization of eq . ( [ e : norm ] ) , yield @xmath137 + \ldots \ , , \ ] ] while the remaining 48 terms give the final result to zeroth order in @xmath106 , @xmath138 \nonumber \\ & & \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad \quad + \frac{(2 \pi)^2}{a l^4 } \frac{2}{(2 \pi l \delta l)^2 } \int_{a_l } \frac{d^2 { { { \bf l}_1}}'}{(2 \pi)^2 } \ , \int_{a_l } \frac{d^2 { { { \bf l}_2}}'}{(2 \pi)^2 } \ , \frac{{a_{\theta\theta}}^2(l_{1}^{\prime } ) { a_{\theta\theta}}^2(l_{2}^{\prime})}{(l_{1}^{\prime})^2 ( l_{2}^{\prime})^2 } { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf k}_1}{(2\pi)^2 } } f_{{\theta}{\theta}}({{{\bf k}_1 } } , { { { \bf k}_2 } } ) p({{{\bf k}_1 } } , { { { \bf k}_2 } } , { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath139 when @xmath140 is subtracted from @xmath141 in eq . ( [ e : sigpv ] ) , the first term in the square brackets of eq . ( [ e : zeropv ] ) will be eliminated . minimizing the variance associated with this estimator then consists of making an optimal choice of @xmath142 . the first noise term is proportional to @xmath143 . for a survey of area @xmath110 , @xmath144 is the specific area of an individual mode in @xmath145 space and @xmath146 is the area in @xmath145 space over which the power - spectrum estimator takes an average . this ratio is therefore the inverse of the number of individual @xmath58 modes whose inverse variances are added to determine the inverse variance of @xmath124 . it is obviously minimized by choosing @xmath147 . the second term , that involving @xmath148 , differs from the first noise term in that a dirac delta function has been used to evaluate an additional @xmath136 integral rather than an annulus integral . since the integrands are of the same order , we expect the second noise term to be suppressed relative to the first by a factor @xmath149 where @xmath150 is set by the resolution @xmath32 of the survey . under the conservative assumption @xmath151 , namely that we are probing scales well above our resolution , this term is assured to be small . we neglect such terms for the remainder of this paper . if we insert the portions of the eight - point correlation function that are first and second order in @xmath106 into eq . ( [ e:8pt ] ) and evaluate using eq . ( [ e:1st ] ) , we find @xmath152 \ , , \ ] ] and @xmath153 this result agrees with that given in ref . @xcite after subtracting our newly derived term @xmath87 . the term @xmath87 and corresponding terms for polarization - based estimators have two principal effects on power spectrum estimation . as shown in eq . ( [ e : finvar ] ) , they provide a fractional contribution to the variance of roughly @xmath154 when @xmath122 dominates the variance as in the reference experiment in the right - hand panel of fig . [ f : plrec ] . for the @xmath0cdm cosmological model considered here this represents an increase of @xmath155 in the variance of the @xmath98 estimator for @xmath156 . more importantly , @xmath87 acts as a bias for the naive estimator @xmath121 as shown by eq . ( [ e : naive3 ] ) . if this bias is not calculated and subtracted iteratively to form the unbiased estimator @xmath124 as in eq . ( [ e : pestsub ] ) , @xmath122 will be _ systematically _ overestimated by @xmath157 at low @xmath108 and by increasingly larger amounts at @xmath158 as the signal @xmath159 begins to plummet while @xmath87 remains comparatively flat . having evaluated the variance of our estimator @xmath124 , we consider whether this estimator has a substantial covariance @xmath160 the estimator @xmath121 as defined in eq . ( [ e : naive ] ) implies that : @xmath161 \left [ { { \mathbf{d}}_{\theta\theta}}({{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \cdot { { \mathbf{d}}_{\theta\theta}}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \right ] \rangle \ , , \ ] ] which can be evaluated using the same integral over the eight - point correlation function described in eq . ( [ e:8pt ] ) . whereas 60 of the 105 zeroth - order terms in @xmath106 coming from this equation were nonvanishing for the variance , for the covariance only 52 terms are nonzero provided that the widths @xmath112 and @xmath162 are chosen so that the annuli @xmath111 and @xmath163 do not overlap . this leads to a result analogous to eq . ( [ e : zeropv ] ) , @xmath164 note that the eight terms missing from the covariance when compared to the variance have altered the first term of eq . ( [ e : zerocv ] ) , and that it was precisely these terms that provided the dominant contribution to the variance of eq . ( [ e : finvar ] ) when @xmath142 was chosen appropriately . we therefore find that to zeroth order in @xmath106 , the covariance is given by @xmath165 where we have extracted the @xmath166 from the annular integrals since they are slowly varying over the widths @xmath112 and @xmath162 . for the same reasons that terms of this form were a subdominant contribution to the variance as discussed previously , we expect the covariance to be suppressed as well . if we define the ratio @xmath167 we can quantify this suppression . the triple integral of eq . ( [ e : fincov ] ) , appearing in the numerator of @xmath168 , involves integration over annuli with radii @xmath108 and @xmath169 and one integration over all fourier space . the triple integrals in the variances @xmath170 and @xmath171 appearing in the denominator of @xmath168 each consist of a single integration over an annulus of radius @xmath108 and @xmath169 respectively and two integrations over all fourier space . if we make the crude assumption that the integrand is constant , the ratio @xmath168 will simply be the ratio of these areas , @xmath172 the ratio @xmath168 is evaluated numerically for planck in fig . [ f : cov ] as a function of @xmath108 for various fixed values of @xmath169 . the estimators @xmath124 and @xmath173 were chosen such that @xmath174 , while integrals over fourier space were cut off at @xmath175 . substituting these values into eq . ( [ e : rcovest ] ) , we expect @xmath176 . this crude estimate is surprisingly close to the numerically obtained results of fig . [ f : cov ] ; in particular the slope of the curves is approximately 1/2 on this log - log plot . even at @xmath101 , @xmath177 suggesting that covariance in power - spectrum estimation can safely be neglected for planck . the estimate of eq . ( [ e : rcovest ] ) implicitly depends on the experimental resolution @xmath32 because the integrand appearing in expressions for the variance and covariance decreases rapidly for @xmath178 . for future experiments with better resolution than planck , @xmath179 will be higher implying by eq . ( [ e : rcovest ] ) that covariance will be even more negligible . weak gravitational lensing induces non - gaussian correlations between modes of the observed cmb temperature map as shown in eq . ( [ e : ea ] ) . these correlations , and assumptions about the gaussian nature of the primordial cmb , can be used to construct several temperature and polarization - based estimators of the fourier modes @xmath89 of the deflection field . this procedure was outlined in ref . @xcite , however in calculating the noise associated with this reconstruction , an assumption was made that the observed temperature map was gaussian . in the presence of lensing this assumption is invalid ; when calculating the variance of quadratic estimators all permutations of the observed trispectrum must be taken into account . one such permutation reflects the desired correlation making our estimator sensitive to @xmath89 , but the remaining two permutations induce additional variance proportional to the lensing - potential power spectrum @xmath106 . while subdominant , this variance will become increasing significant for future experiments as shown in the right - hand panel of fig . [ f : plrec ] . since the power spectrum @xmath106 is itself a measure of uncertainty in the deflection field , this additional variance in lensing reconstruction acts as a bias during power - spectrum estimation because there is no _ a priori _ way to distinguish it from the intrinsic variance of the underlying distribution . our calculation of the dependence of this variance on @xmath106 allows it in principle to be subtracted iteratively , which will prevent a systematic @xmath157 overestimate of @xmath106 at low @xmath108 . we close by considering several possible observational obstacles to the scheme for lensing reconstruction and power - spectrum estimation presented above . one hindrance is secondary contributions to the cmb such as the sz and isw effects . these effects increase the total temperature power spectrum appearing in the denominator of the optimum filter @xmath104 of eq . ( [ e : filt ] ) as would additional instrumental noise . they also correlate with the large - scale structure at low redshifts inducing further non - gaussian couplings and additional variance to lensing reconstruction . fortunately for our purposes the frequency dependence of the thermal sz effect differs from that of a blackbody . it can therefore be separated in principle from the lensed primordial cmb by an experiment with several frequency channels @xcite . the isw effect can not be removed in this manner , but is too small to significantly inhibit lensing reconstruction . polarization - dependent secondary effects are expected to appear at higher orders in the density contrast @xcite , and we therefore anticipate that they will not make a contribution at the levels considered here . a potentially more serious problem is that of galactic foregrounds , which though uncorrelated with the lensing signal may be substantial at certain frequencies . significant polarization has also been observed in some of these sources @xcite . we hope to understand and minimize the effects of galactic foregrounds in future work , and to pursue further refinements of lensing reconstruction . we thank wayne hu for useful discussions . this work was supported in part by nasa nag5 - 11985 and doe de - fg03 - 92-er40701 . kesden acknowledges the support of an nsf graduate fellowship and ac acknowledges support from the sherman fairchild foundation . here we provide the appropriate formulas for deriving the variance associated with polarization - based estimators of the deflection field @xmath89 . the cmb polarization can be decomposed into e and b - modes @xcite . these modes are mixed by weak lensing such that to linear order in @xmath68 , @xmath180 \phi({{\bf l}}-{{\bf l}}_1 ) \left [ ( { { \bf l}}-{{\bf l}}_1 ) \cdot { { \bf l}}_1 \right ] \ , , \nonumber \\ \tilde b({{\bf l } } ) & = & b({{\bf l } } ) - { \int \frac{d^2 { \bf l}_1}{(2\pi)^2 } } \left[e({{\bf l}}_1 ) \sin 2 ( \varphi_{{{\bf l}}_1 } -\varphi_{{\bf l } } ) + b({{\bf l}}_1 ) \cos 2 ( \varphi_{{{\bf l}}_1 } -\varphi_{{\bf l}})\right ] \phi({{\bf l}}-{{\bf l}}_1 ) \left [ ( { { \bf l}}-{{\bf l}}_1 ) \cdot { { \bf l}}_1 \right ] \ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we can exploit the sensitivity of the polarization modes to the lensing potential to construct lensing estimators from quadratic combinations of polarization modes . we generalize eq . ( [ e : ea ] ) to arbitrary combinations @xmath181 of @xmath45 , e , and b - modes as first derived in ref . @xcite , @xmath182 where @xmath183 \cos 2 ( \varphi_{{{\mathbf{l } } } } -\varphi_{{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \ , , \nonumber \\ f_{eb}({{\mathbf{l } } } , { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) & = & \left [ c_{l}^{ee } ( { { \mathbf{l}}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l } } } ) + c_{l^{\prime}}^{bb } ( { { \mathbf{l}}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \right ] \sin 2 ( \varphi_{{{\mathbf{l } } } } -\varphi_{{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) = f_{be}({{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } , { { \mathbf{l } } } ) \ , , \nonumber \\ f_{bb}({{\mathbf{l } } } , { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) & = & \left [ c_{l}^{bb } ( { { \mathbf{l}}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l } } } ) + c_{l^{\prime}}^{bb } ( { { \mathbf{l}}}\cdot { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \right ] \cos 2 ( \varphi_{{{\mathbf{l } } } } -\varphi_{{\mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) \ , . \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] in deriving these results we used parity considerations to demand @xmath184 . using these relations , we follow the approach of ref . @xcite to derive symmetric lensing estimators @xmath185 and @xmath186 { f_{xx'}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ) \ , .\ ] ] we have explicitly symmetrized our estimators for @xmath187 to simplify the form of the optimal filter . the normalization bias of the estimators is removed by choosing @xmath188^{-1 } \ , , \ ] ] and @xmath189 { f_{xx'}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ) \right]^{-1 } \ , .\ ] ] the minimum - variance filters @xmath190 for the various cases @xmath181 are given by @xmath191 using these optimal filters for the estimators defined in eqs . ( [ e : estxx ] ) and ( [ e : estxx ] ) , we can calculate the variances for these estimators in a fashion entirely analogoug to eq . ( [ e : estvar ] ) , @xmath192 @xmath193 \left [ x^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } ' ) x'^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) + x'^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } ' ) x^{{\rm t}}({{{\bf l}_2 } } ' ) \right ] \rangle { f_{xx'}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ) { f_{xx'}}({{{\bf l}_1 } } ' , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) \nonumber \\ & & \quad \quad - ( 2 \pi)^2 \delta_{{\rm d}}({{\mathbf{l}}}- { { \mathbf{l^{\prime } } } } ) c_{l}^{dd } \ , . \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] as for that of the temperature estimator , these variance will consist of zeroth - order terms in @xmath106 , @xmath194 and @xmath195 , and first - order terms , @xmath196 @xmath197 \nonumber \\ & & \quad \quad \quad + c_{|{{{\bf l}_1}}-{{{\bf l}_2}}'|}^{\phi\phi } \bigl [ f_{xx'}(-{{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) f_{x'x}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } , { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' ) + f_{xx}(-{{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) f_{x'x'}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } , { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' ) \nonumber \\ & & \quad \quad \quad \quad + f_{x'x'}(-{{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) f_{xx}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } , { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' ) + f_{x'x}(-{{{\bf l}_1 } } , { { { \bf l}_2 } } ' ) f_{xx'}(-{{{\bf l}_2 } } , { { { \bf l}_1 } } ' ) \bigl ] \big\ } \ , , \nonumber \\\end{aligned}\ ] ] the filters given in eq . ( [ e : filtxx ] ) are no longer optimal in the presence of this additional noise , but the difference between these filters and the optimal filters should be negligible provided that @xmath198 , @xmath199 . for the purposes of power - spectrum estimation , the terms @xmath200 and @xmath201 are not only an additional contribution to the variance , but are also a systematic bias if not subtracted iteratively following eq . ( [ e : naive3 ] ) . a final point to consider is that the six different estimators @xmath202 defined in this paper are not independent , as they are constructed from only three distinct maps . the covariance matrix for the six estimators will therefore not be diagonal , and this needs to be taken into account if the estimators are to be linearly combined to produce a single minimum - variance estimator . the off - diagonal elements of the covariance matrix can be evaluated in a straightforward manner involving pairs of double integrals similar to those of eqs . ( [ e : xxvar ] ) and ( [ e : xxvar ] ) . p. j. e. peebles and j. t. yu , astrophys . j. * 162 * , 815 ( 1970 ) ; r. a. sunyaev and ya . b. zeldovich , astrophys . space sci . * 7 * , 3 ( 1970 ) ; j. silk , astrophys . j. * 151 * , 459 ( 1968 ) ; w. hu and s. dodelson , ann . astrophys . * 40 * , 171 ( 2002 ) . g. jungman _ et al . _ , d * 54 * , 1332 ( 1995 ) ; j. r. bond , g. efstathiou , and m. tegmark , mon . not . r. astron . soc . * 291 * , l33 ( 1997 ) ; m. zaldarriaga and d. n. spergel , astrophys . j. * 488 * , 1 ( 1997 ) ; d. j. eisenstein , w. hu , and m. tegmark , astrophys . j. * 518 * , 2 ( 1999 ) . d. n. spergel and d. m. goldberg , phys . d * 59 * , 103001 ( 1999 ) ; d. m. goldberg and d. n. spergel , phys . rev . d * 59 * , 103002 ( 1999 ) ; a. cooray and w. hu , astrophys . j. * 534 * , 533 ( 2000 ) ; m. zaldarriaga and u. seljak , phys . rev . d * 59 * , 123507 ( 1999 ) ; h. v. peiris and d. n. spergel , astrophys . j. * 540 * , 605 ( 2000 ) . g. giardino _ et al . _ , astrophys . * 387 * , 82 ( 2002 ) ; f. r. bouchet , s. prunet , and s. k. sethi , mon . not . r. astron . 302 * , 663 ( 1999 ) ; s. prunet , s. k. sethi , and f. r. bouchet , mon . not . r. astron . 314 * , 348 ( 2000 ) .
Abstract: | [
"weak gravitational lensing by intervening large - scale structure induces a distinct signature in the cosmic microwave background ( cmb ) that can be used to reconstruct the weak - lensing displacement map . estimators for individual fourier modes of this map can be combined to produce an estimator for the lensing - potenial power spectrum . the naive estimator for this quantity will be biased upwards by the uncertainty associated with reconstructing individual modes ; we present an iterative scheme for removing this bias . the variance and covariance of the lensing - potenial power spectrum estimator are calculated and evaluated numerically in a @xmath0cdm universe for planck and future polarization - sensitive cmb experiments ."
] | 8,725 | 8,725 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: two - dimensionally extended materials , or membranes , have been paid much attention to in various fields of study , such as lipid bilayers @xcite and surfactants @xcite in soft - matter and biophysics @xcite . alongside , many theoretical studies on those membrane - type objects have been done toward a general understanding of physical properties of such materials @xcite . some of them were simulation approaches @xcite and others were with field theoretical techniques @xcite . for example , one of the authors studied the pore formation in a binary giant vesicle of two - component lipid bilayer , and reproduced its dynamical shapes in the field - theoretical approach with some numerical calculations @xcite . although most of the works contributed successfully to our knowledge of individual membranes , it can be said that we are yet very far from the general understanding . in this work , we aim to give some new insight to the general understanding of the physical properties of soft - material membranes by studying mathematical models on discretized surfaces both analytically and numerically . that is to say , we propose a family of fluid particle models of two - dimensional lattice as simpler models of membranes : tightly pack molecular particles on a given lattice , and give the particles dynamics by some stochastic process , or by a set of mathematical rules . for more simplicity , we consider single - component , single - layered incompressible systems , and assume no explicit viscosity and an upper bound for the flow velocities on the particles . after the formulation , we construct two stochastic models of 2d lattice liquid , as our first steps . one of them is found to be the vicious random walk @xcite in its densest phase and a version of the dynamic lattice liquid model ( dll model ) @xcite in two dimensions . the dynamics of these models is given by completely independent time steps and would not generate various fluid dynamical phenomena such as lasting convective flows , while our formulation does not exclude such possibilities . in fact , the other model is constructed as the flow model with a mathematical rule , which has no corresponding known models . we further restrict ourselves to a finite flat honey - comb lattice and simulate the two models with their highest mobility . comparing with similar lattice models such as various lattice random walks or the loop gas model ( sos model ) @xcite , we show some statistical properties of the models by the simulation results . the results tell that the flow model may exhibit some anomalous diffusion , in terms of time - averaged mean square displacements ( tamsd ) , and the ergodicity with its fairly long relaxation time . relations to other models and some possible extensions of the models will also be discussed in the final section . there are various situations of the membrane systems , and each situation would deserve a single mathematical model in order to simulate it . however , since we aim to construct a basic model to be utilised for those various situations , we focus exclusively on a very simple but basic situation among them as a building block . first , we focus on a single - component and single - layered molecular system on a two - dimensional surface , treating the surrounding medium as a kind of heat bath to the surface . in other words , we introduce some rules or external forces onto the elements of the membrane rather than consider the interactions between the membrane and the medium . secondly , we focus exclusively on a simple classical interaction such as `` collision '' , neglecting any other complicated interaction between the elements of the membrane . let us call this ` no explicit viscosity ' . thirdly , we assume that the density fluctuation can be negligible and two elements would not occupy the same location of the surface at any time . this would correspond to the incompressibility condition of the surface from the two - dimensional fluid point of view . to summarise , we assume and focus on a single - component and single - layered incompressible particle systems with no explicit viscosity on a two - dimensional surface exposed in an external ( random ) field . now , we are ready to define the 2d lattice liquid models . given a two - dimensional lattice @xmath0 , a 2d lattice liquid model can be defined as a mathematical model of the particles which can only reside at the sites of the lattice @xmath0 , covering all or almost all of the sites , and which flow inside @xmath0 as molecular - dynamical units of liquid do inside them . here , the particles represent the elements of the membrane , and are assumed to be of the same physical properties : their sizes , masses , and so on . the word ` liquid ' comes directly from two parts of the above definition , one of which is that the particles cover all or almost all of the sites of @xmath0 , and the other of which is that the particles flow . obviously , there is an ambiguity on the phrase `` all or almost all '' . to avoid this ambiguity in this paper , we force each site to hold only and exactly one particle at a time , covering _ all _ the sites . we call it `` the occupation number is exactly one everywhere '' . although we can make some of the sites empty or put as many particles as possible , the assumption of the density fluctuation eliminates the latter and we simply omit the former in this paper . note that the definition of the lattice liquid would not exclude these cases and would be worth studying elsewhere . one can consider the boundary conditions in the presence of boundary of the surface . there are two types of boundary conditions , one of which is on particles dynamical degrees of freedom , and the other of which is on their internal degrees of freedom , such as particle species . the former type of boundary conditions are naturally embedded in the lattice on which we define the model . on the latter , since we only consider single - component systems , there is no boundary condition on the particle species . to complete the definition of the model , the particles `` flows '' should be defined by imposing a set of mathematical rules on the flows . this consequently determines the dynamics of the system . before going into the details of the rules , let us introduce the lattice conventions and consider the configuration space of the model to begin . a lattice @xmath0 is defined by a set of sites @xmath1 and a set of bonds @xmath2 . a bond @xmath3 is connecting a pair of the sites , @xmath4 , which are called neighbouring sites or in the neighbourhood . the lattice spacing @xmath5 the shortest length of the bonds specifies a fine aspect of the lattice . we consider only the cases with the same bond length , unless otherwise stated . for that reason we set @xmath6 without loss of generality . the total number of the sites and the total number of the bonds are denoted by @xmath7 and @xmath8 , respectively . we abbreviate them by @xmath9 and @xmath10 for simplicity . the degree of the site , @xmath11 , is the number of the bonds connected to the site @xmath12 . if there is only one value for @xmath11 on @xmath0 , we write it by @xmath13 for short , and we consider mainly such cases . in the later sections of some numerical calculations , we focus on the honeycomb lattices of various sizes as a series of examples . on a given lattice @xmath0 , under any set of the rules of the movements , a flow of a particle can be sketched schematically in fig.[fig : worldlines ] below . introducing the minimum time lapse @xmath14 , a particle at the site @xmath12 at the time @xmath15 flew from the site @xmath16 at @xmath17 with the velocity @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is implicitly taken as a unit ( @xmath20 ) . then , the particle at @xmath12 at @xmath15 flows toward @xmath21 at the future time @xmath22 , subject to some fluctuation @xmath23 by external forces . explicitly writing the time dependence of the variables , @xmath24 denotes the flow velocity of the particle from @xmath17 to @xmath15 , and @xmath25 does from @xmath15 to @xmath22 . we denote the latter velocity by a redundant variable @xmath26 for convenience . the solid continuous line in fig.[fig : worldlines ] represents the particle travelling in @xmath27-dimensional space - time , and all the particle movements can be represented by such world - lines . namely , the configuration of the system at a certain time @xmath15 , can be uniquely given by a set of the flow velocities : \{_i(t ) } for all i v ( ) . accordingly , the time evolution is realised by mapping a configuration @xmath28 to another configuration @xmath29 at a successive time , while a particle at @xmath12 travels to @xmath30 with the velocity @xmath31 such that : i^= i+^_i(t ) , _ i^(t+t ) = ^_i(t ) . for consistency , @xmath18 and @xmath32 can not take completely arbitrary values , but are subject to the constraint that @xmath33 and @xmath34 map @xmath35 to itself and they are bijective . in other words , the configuration space is given by the whole set of such bijections . such a space is highly complicated in general , however one assumption actually makes the space more tractable . we assume the following upper bound for the velocities : |_i| 1 for all i v ( ) . this means that the particles are prevented from jumping in between non - nearest neighbouring sites . therefore , the assumption is not too restrictive in the physics context . when the bond lengths are all the same , this leads the absolute value @xmath36 takes either @xmath37 or @xmath38 . accordingly , the velocity @xmath18 takes one of @xmath39 values . since @xmath40 obeys the same , the velocity change @xmath41 takes at most one of @xmath39 values as well . with the upper bound of the velocities and the assumption of the occupation number , a configuration of the particles can be represented by a collection of oriented non - intersecting loops on @xmath0 . in order to illustrate this fact , let us give a set of random velocities , @xmath42 , with the condition @xmath43 . all particles potentially try to move toward the directions they have been kicked by some external forces . however , this does not necessarily give movements to the particles due to the frustration of such momenta ( fig.[fig : frustration - circ](a ) ) . the frustration is an outcome of the excluded volume effect of the particles together with the restriction of the occupation number . in order to generate convective flows , some part of the `` potential '' movements generated by the forces must be enclosed so that the particles can move ( fig.[fig : frustration - circ](b ) ) . + ( a ) + ( b ) hence , the relevant part of the configuration @xmath33 can be represented by a collection of _ oriented _ non - intersecting loop graphs on @xmath0 . we label the space of the oriented non - intersecting loop configurations by @xmath44 . we also label the loop configuration without the orientations by @xmath45 for later use . formal definition of the ( oriented ) loop configurations in graph theory , refer to appendix [ ap : loops ] . note that , if and only if @xmath46 , the above algorithm coincides with a version of the dll model @xcite . in what follows , we focus on the situations where the loop configuration solely plays a crucial role . as was stated before , the set of mathematical rules of the particle - flows give the principal part of the definition of the model . however , regardless of how and what sort of the rules are imposed , they are to be expressed in the form of the velocities and the velocity changes : @xmath33 and @xmath47 , or in the form of the present loop configuration and the resulting one , @xmath48 , representing the velocities . so , we formulate the 2d lattice liquid models as a family of statistical models defined with such variables . one of the most straightforward expressions of the propagator would take the form of : [ eq:1stprop ] & & g ( x_1 , x_2 , ; g , t ; g^ , t^ ) & & or g ( x_1 , x_2 , ; \{_i(t ) } , t ; \ { _ j(t^ ) } , t^ ) , or as its ensemble : [ eq:2ndprop ] & & z^g ( x_1 , x_2 , ; g , t ; t^ ) & & _ g^ ( ) g ( x_1 , x_2 , ; g , t ; g^ , t^ ) , where the @xmath49 s are other unspecified parameters to prescribe the propagator . if all the processes are statistical from the beginning , @xmath50 , even the initial configuration is given by some distribution , the following quantity would be the partition function in question : & & z(x_1 , x_2 , ; t , t^ ) & & _ g ( ) p_init ( g ) z^g ( x_1 , x_2 , ; g , t ; t^ ) , where the function @xmath51 is the statistical weight of the configuration @xmath52 . practically , we will focus on the second expression ( [ eq:2ndprop ] ) of the propagator and the first one ( [ eq:1stprop ] ) for the construction of the second . let us construct a more concrete yet abstract form of the propagator by the probabilities of the configurations . for the time step of @xmath19 , given the present configuration @xmath53 , let us define @xmath54 as the `` potential '' probability of a particle remaining at the site @xmath12 , and @xmath55 is the `` potential '' probability of the particle at @xmath12 being kicked toward one of the nearest neighbouring sites @xmath56 . they satisfy : [ eq : px - const ] p(i)+_j x(i;j ) = 1 , where the summation is over all nearest neighbouring sites to @xmath12 . in general , @xmath54 and @xmath55 may carry the information from the past , but we ignore it in the rest of this manuscript . recall that some of the kicks with the `` potential '' probabilities might not be performed due to the before mentioned frustration . suppose non - frustrated part of the particles are expressed in the configuration @xmath57 . the complementary graph can be given with its projection @xmath58 on @xmath45 by @xmath59 . then , the probability of having @xmath57 in @xmath0 , @xmath60 , can be given by the product of the loop probability @xmath61 of having @xmath57 in @xmath58 and the probability @xmath62 of the frustration in @xmath63 as follows : p(g^ ) = p_l(g^ ) p_f(|g^ ) , where the initial configuration @xmath53 is implicit , and the loop probability can be expressed by multiplying the probabilities @xmath55 s along the oriented loops : p_l(g^ ) _ _ i , j e(g^ ) x(i;j ) . note that the definitions of the above probabilities need some minor extensions to the subgraphs for their consistency . for the detailed definition of the probability functions and their properties , refer to appendix [ ap : pfpl ] . the probability @xmath60 is nothing but the first expression ( [ eq:1stprop ] ) of the propagator for one time step . accordingly , the second expression ( [ eq:2ndprop ] ) of the propagator for one time step is : z^g(g , t ; t+t ) & = & _ g^ ( ) p ( g^ ) . specifying its @xmath53 dependence by @xmath64 , the propagator for a longer time span can be expressed by : & & z^g(g^(0 ) , t ; t^ ) & & = _ g^(1 ) ( ) _ g^(k-1 ) ( ) _ k=1^k p(g^(k ) ; g^(k-1 ) ) , where @xmath65 . hence , the construction of the propagator reduces to a detailed construction of the probability functions , @xmath62 and @xmath61 . note that the above expression actually corresponds to the discretised version of the path integral . given the probabilities , an expectation value of some physical quantity @xmath66 for @xmath19 can be given as usual by the form of : _ g & = & _ g^ ( ) o p(g^ ; g ) . it is obvious that the set of the mathematical rules of the particle - flows give the principal part of the definition of the 2d lattice liquid model as well as of its formulation . in fact , one can easily imagine the following three sorts of the rules for the particle - flows . namely , the particles flow according to some stochastic process , or subject to some external thermodynamic forces from the surrounding medium , or obeying some physics laws with their ( fluid ) dynamical properties such as the langevin - type equation or the navier - stokes equation in the low @xmath67 single - component limit . in order to avoid ambiguities on discretisation and limiting procedures in the equation - based approaches , we deal only with the stochastic cases here . some relations to thermodynamic or equation - based approaches will be discussed later . in this section , we construct and formulate one of the simplest stochastic models , the stochastic markovian model , whose rules are as simple as assigning simple kicks to push the particles and arresting them at the end of each step . the model is turned out to be equivalent to the vicious random walk in its densest phase and a version of the dll model on two - dimensional lattice . the precise definition of the rules are given as follows . first , let @xmath54 be non - negative constant , and @xmath55 be of isotropic kicks such that : [ eq : bounds4p ] p(i ) & = & p , x(i;j ) & = & x(i ) . here , we restrict them to be strictly independent of the past , ensuring that the process is markovian . second , we assign the kicks according to the above probabilities , @xmath68 and @xmath69 , and those kicks are projected onto some oriented loop configuration @xmath53 . perform the moves of @xmath53 . thirdly , as a key part of the rules , we force : [ def : sto ] _ j(t+t ) = _ i(t ) i , where @xmath70 . this means that the configuration of the velocities is set at every step by the fluctuation @xmath71 only . accordingly , one of the two sets , @xmath33 and @xmath72 , becomes redundant . note that @xmath73 inherits the upper bound from @xmath36 : @xmath74 . practically , it follows @xmath75 . the probability of an oriented loop configuration @xmath53 on the sublattice @xmath76 can be written by : p_l ( g ) = _ _ i , je(g ) x(i ) . if @xmath11 s are all the same as of regular lattices , the above probability can be simplified as : p_l ( g ; x ) = x^l(g ) , where we specify @xmath77 as an argument , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 denotes @xmath80 for @xmath81 of @xmath53 , _ i.e. _ , the total length of the loops in @xmath53 . note that @xmath77 plays the role of the fugacity of the bonds in @xmath53 . if we further define the probability of a non - oriented loop configuration @xmath76 on the sublattice @xmath76 , summing up all the orientations of @xmath76 , it follows that : p_l ( g ; x ) = 2^(g ) x^l(g ) , where @xmath82 by definition , @xmath83 counts the number of the loops in @xmath76 , and the factor ` 2 ' indicates the directions of each oriented loop in @xmath53 . accordingly , the propagator , or the partition function , can be written down by : [ eq : part_sto ] g^sto ( x ) = _ g ( ) p_l(g;x ) p_f ( |g ; x ) , which is equivalent to unity by definition . @xmath84 gives the probability of the no - loop configuration . the probabilities @xmath62 and @xmath61 take physical values , @xmath85 and @xmath86 for @xmath87 . it should be mentioned here that if @xmath88 is set to be one for any @xmath76 then the partition function reduces to that of the non - oriented non - intersecting loop configurations on a lattice , which is known as the loop gas model @xcite : @xmath89 with @xmath90 . so , @xmath88 plays a crucial role in our model . as in the definition ( [ def : sto ] ) , the present configuration is always trivial so that the above expression ( [ eq : part_sto ] ) is exact at any @xmath15 . therefore , the propagator can be expressed by : z^sto(x ; t ; t+t ) = g^sto(x ) . hence , it can be summarised and simplified to the propagator of the time lapse @xmath15 as follows : z^sto(x ; t ) = ^t / t . the expectation value of a physical quantity @xmath66 is given in a conventional manner : _ t & = & ^t / t , & = & _ g ( ) op_f ( |g ; x ) p_l(g;x ) . before giving our simulation results , let us show some simple relations and calculations on an isotropic regular lattice . on an isotropic regular lattice , such as a square lattice with periodicities , the one - point function of the velocity can trivially be given by : = 0 , by symmetry . similarly , the expectation value of the absolute value of the velocity at @xmath12 can be given by : = = i , where @xmath91 is the expectation value of the length of the loops : @xmath92 . besides , the variance of the velocity becomes : = = , where the normalised lattice spacing is used . with the above facts , one can state that each particle behaves like a random walker on the given lattice with the constant trapping ratio of @xmath93 , where a particle moves to a certain direction with the probability @xmath94 . namely , for any @xmath95 for large @xmath0 or small @xmath15 : & = & 0 , & = & t , where @xmath96 denotes the position of the @xmath97-th particle at the time @xmath15 . however , it should be noted that the system is not a collection of independent simple random walks , as our particles do not occupy the same site at the same time . in fact , the system is in the densest phase of the vicious random walks mutually avoiding @xmath98 particles random walks on a lattice with @xmath98 sites @xcite . the difference between this system and a collection of the independent simple random walks can be clearly shown by the spacial correlation of the velocities . for example , the spacial correlation of a nearest pair of the system is given by : , whereas those of the simple random walks is given by a simple product of one - point functions : @xmath99 . in the previous sections , we have formulated the model where the streamlines are temporally generated and live only for the duration of @xmath19 . because the probability of the shortest loop in a honeycomb lattice is at most @xmath100 in the bulk , @xmath91 seems to be very small . we infer in the model ( i ) that the stochastic process realises the solid - like nature of the membrane rather than its liquid nature as the dll model targeted supercooled liquids . in this section , we intend to explore another class of stochastic models where the particles keep flowing on the membrane rather than obeying the ` stop and go ' evolution . in order to realise this phenomenon , we take the simplest way : if no fluctuations are added to the system , the particles keep flowing along the oriented loops . this rule can be expressed by the relation in the absence of the fluctuations : [ def : stof ] _ i(t+t ) = _ i(t ) . now , it is evident that the key point of the construction lies on how to add stochastically generated fluctuations onto the existing streamlines . in order to avoid complications for realising the relation ( [ def : stof ] ) and the frustrations in terms of @xmath47 , let us formulate the above addition in terms of the oriented loop configurations . say , @xmath101 is the initial configuration and @xmath102 is the resulting configuration . the arithmetic rule ( addition / subtraction ) for the oriented loop configurations can be illustrated in a multiplicative form by : g g_i = g_f ( ) , where @xmath103 stands for the stochastically generated fluctuations , and vanishing @xmath103 is given by the no - loop configuration @xmath104 naturally satisfying the rule ( [ def : stof ] ) . in @xmath45 , there is a natural definition of such an additive operation as the symmetric difference . we extend and modify it to our case for @xmath105 . let @xmath106 , @xmath107 be elements in @xmath44 . if @xmath107 consists of the same sites and bonds with opposite directions as those of @xmath106 , then we call @xmath107 the inverse of @xmath106 , denoting it by @xmath108 . the additive operation between @xmath106 and @xmath107 is defined in the multiplicative form by : g_1 g_2 = g , such that the directed bonds of the elements satisfy : [ eq : symdiff - directed ] g & = & g_1 g_2 - g_1 g_2 ^ -1 - g_1 ^ -1 g_2 , while the disconnected sites are removed from @xmath53 . the above addition trivially satisfies the followings : g_1 i ( ) & = & i ( ) g_1 = g_1 g_1 ( ) , g_1 g_2 & = & i ( ) g_2 = g_1 ^ -1 , where @xmath104 behaves as the zero in the addition and the identity in its multiplicative form . the problem of this definition is that @xmath53 is in the corresponding ( directed ) cycle space but not necessarily in @xmath44 . to avoid this unwanted situation , we propose the following projected addition for @xmath53 in eq . ( [ eq : symdiff - directed ] ) : [ def : addition ] g_1 g_2 & = & g g ( ) , g_1 g_2 & = & g_2 g ( ) . in the second line , we call @xmath106 is non - additive to @xmath107 , or vice versa . this projection drastically changes the algebraic nature of the operation . in fact , it breaks the commutativity : @xmath109 , and the associativity : @xmath110 . so , the ordering of the operations matters in this case . it should be mentioned here that we can create some different definitions of the addition simply by different projections of @xmath111 onto @xmath44 . as a starting point , we stick to the above definition and will mention another possibility later . note also that , precisely speaking , @xmath103 is either a candidate for a fluctuation or a fluctuation which sometimes does nothing , because of the projection . if the configuration at the time @xmath95 is given by @xmath112 , the configuration @xmath113 at the time @xmath114 can be expressed by a series of successive additions of @xmath103 to @xmath112 : g(t_0+t ) = g(t_0 ) . [ def : flow - part ] the multiplication in the r.h.s . means the multiple application of the loop additions , @xmath115 , and the addition should be done from right to left . the factor expresses nothing but a configurational and kinetic path between two configurations . finally , we complete the definition of the stochastic flow model by stochastically giving @xmath103 in the same manner as in the previous section . namely , assign the `` potential '' probabilities of a particle remaining at the same position and of a particle at @xmath12 being kicked toward one of the nearest site @xmath56 by @xmath68 and @xmath55 , respectively . for the isotropic distribution , @xmath55 can be simplified to @xmath116 . then , project the velocity changes onto the space of the oriented loop configurations @xmath44 , and add it to the current configuration in the end . the degrees of freedom of @xmath41 and @xmath18 are same as @xmath39 , as long as an additional upper bound for @xmath41 is not imposed . so , their spaces differ only by the meanings of @xmath68 and @xmath55 . for simplicity , we neglect this difference and distribute the probabilities isotropically . note that the addition rule implicitly introduced the upper bound for @xmath23 such that @xmath117 . now , we have formulated how the fluctuations are given and added to existing flows . the propagator with the initial configuration @xmath118 can now be written down by : & & z^flow(x ; g_i , t_0 ; t+t_0 ) & & = _ g_t / t ( ) _ g_1 ( ) _ j=1^t / t g_i(t_0 ) , where the probability @xmath119 of having the loop @xmath53 in @xmath0 is the same as in the stochastic markovian model . note the process of this model is also markovian . in this section , we perform numerical calculations on the proposed models and show their statistical properties for further investigation , some of which reveal very interesting features of the models . we restrict the lattice @xmath0 to be as simple as the finite rectangular honeycomb lattice of roughly @xmath120 hexagons for odd @xmath98 , labelling it by @xmath121 . precisely speaking , we define the lattice @xmath121 by piling @xmath122 and @xmath98 aligned hexagons alternatively up to @xmath98 rows so that the lattice becomes left - right symmetric ( fig.[fig : hn ] ) . .,width=188 ] for odd @xmath98 , the lattice becomes actually top - bottom symmetric as well , and therefore symmetric under discrete rotations . in the case of a finite lattice with boundary , there are the boundary sites and bonds which face the outer region of the lattice on its planar embedding . among such sites , some have smaller degrees from those in the bulk . in the case of the honeycomb lattice , there are degree - two boundary sites . accordingly , we can assign two different probabilities : @xmath123 in the bulk and @xmath124 for the boundary sites of degree two . we choose the highest mobility @xmath125 , @xmath126 , and @xmath127 for numerical calculations . as two models share the oriented non - intersecting loop configurations as an input to the system , the input data has been generated in common for a million of time steps for various sizes , @xmath128 . below is the basic information of @xmath121 : dim v(_h_n ) & = & ( n+1)(2n+1)-4 , dim v_b ( _ h_n ) & = & 4n , dim e(_h_n ) & = & 3n^2 + 52 n - 92 , f & = & n^2 - , for odd @xmath129 . @xmath130 is the set of all the boundary sites of degree two . the number of faces is denoted by @xmath131 . we first plot the probability @xmath132 of the no - loop configuration , or of the total frustration , for different sizes in fig.([fig : pf - log ] ) . we have observed that it decays approximately exponentially with respect to the area of the lattice . the @xmath77-axis stands for the area of the lattice counted by the number of hexagonal faces in @xmath0 . there can be obviously seen a scalability . the error bars are given at the 95% confidence level.,width=302 ] here , we propose the approximate functional form of @xmath62 for general shape of the honeycomb lattice with @xmath131 connected faces : p_f ( ) e^- . [ eq : pfapprox ] note the form may not well approximate if @xmath0 takes an extreme shape such as a lattice with small @xmath131 or of aligned faces . fitting the data in fig.[fig : pf - log ] with the above function actually leads to @xmath133 . we have also calculated @xmath62 by hand in the case of the honeycomb lattice of 2 piles of 3 hexagons , @xmath134 , and confirmed that the extrapolation from @xmath134 gives @xmath135 . this result further indicates that the system gradually changes its nature between frustration dominant surface to loop dominant surface as the size changes around @xmath136 . next , we plot the number of events for the total length of the loops @xmath137 , which is equivalent to the number of the moving particles in one time step ( fig.[fig : looplen_dist ] ) . -axis is the length in the unit of the lattice spacing . the @xmath138 shows the number of events in a million trials . periodic oscillations seem to suggest the multiple entries of the same type of loops , e.g. , two length - six loops at once contributes to the length - twelve event.,width=302 ] it is remarkable that the leading contribution is not necessarily from length - six loops , and neither is the sub - leading contribution from length - ten loops . for instance , on @xmath139 , the leading and sub - leading contributions are from length-24 and length-30 loops , resp . we have confirmed that the proposed form of @xmath62 can explain nicely the @xmath98-dependence of the probability of length - six loops . we also report the proportionality of the mean loop length @xmath91 w.r.t . the area of the lattice : |l ~0.01763 f , for @xmath140 . as for the loop number distribution , we find that they obey the poisson distribution in an accurate way with the mean @xmath141 approximately proportional to the number of the faces @xmath131 : not so trivial , suggesting that there is a relatively stable value of the loop number per unit surface as well as that of the total length of the loops per unit surface . together with the average absolute value of the velocity and other basic numbers of @xmath121 , we list them in table [ table : hn ] . . the basic numbers of @xmath121 for various @xmath98 . [ cols=">,>,>,>,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] the above averages include the data from the beginning , and therefore we neglected the relaxation time @xmath142 from @xmath104 to quasi - critical states . the relaxation time @xmath142 which will be shown shortly is not very long compared to @xmath143 . so , it would not spoil the accuracy of the statistics much . in this flow model , the distribution of the loop number behaves rather gaussian than poisson . in addition , @xmath91 and @xmath141 no longer obey simple proportional relations to the area of the lattice . the former has a rather correlation to the number of the sites @xmath9 , as @xmath144 is almost independent of the size @xmath98 . the value @xmath145 gives the ratio of the moving particles among all , while @xmath146 is of the trapped particles . nearly constant value of @xmath145 might suggest that the value is intrinsically universal for all honeycomb lattices . the average loop number @xmath141 is not so stabilised compared to the average loop length @xmath91 . it should be remarked here that the projection in our addition ( [ def : addition ] ) would certainly change the probability of the fluctuations , but only its characteristic time scale . so , we claim that the above values and qualitative arguments are characteristic in this type of models , regardless of the addition rule defined earlier . it is the dynamical aspect of the model that the addition rule makes different . in this stochastic flow model , the particles are basically trapped in the sites alike in the stochastic markovian model . but , once they are involved in the streamlines , they keep moving until it is stopped by a fluctuation . coarse - graining of the pathway actually make itself look like a brownian motion , but it is actually much more complicated . let us quantify it by the tamsd of eq . ( [ eq : tamsd ] ) . we picked up a particle situated at the centre of the lattice and calculated the tamsd ( fig.[fig : msd11 - 41 ] ) , where the lower limit of the time is set by the relaxation time @xmath147 : @xmath148 , @xmath149 , so that at @xmath150 the particles are randomised enough on @xmath0 from the initial configuration . @xmath151 is set to be the end of the simulation : the million - th step . , for various sizes in the log - log format . the @xmath77-axis is the time lapse @xmath15 , while the @xmath138-axis is the square distance in the unit of the lattice spacing squared . the dashed lines are all exactly calculated asymptotic values for various @xmath98.,width=302 ] as one can see from the left side of fig.[fig : msd11 - 41 ] , the particle starts moving at a certain rate of @xmath145 , and diffuses like liquid , slightly faster than the brownian motion . at around @xmath152 , the exponent @xmath153 in @xmath154 reaches the brownian one , and later decreases to the anomalous diffusion of @xmath155 in a strange way . finally , it approaches its asymptotic value . by the times the particles approach the asymptotic values , we can read off the relaxation times , @xmath142 . their orders of magnitude are roughly the same we set for the initial time @xmath156 for tamsds . it can be said that the system is generally in an anomalous diffusion process where @xmath157 in the short range , and @xmath155 in the distance . there can be found a strange and interesting plateau as well in the middle of the curve for each size of the lattice , but we have not yet obtained any clear explanation of the plateau . we will further mention this in the final section . there is a closest model to compare with our model ( ii ) , which is the non - reversal random walk . in that model , a random walker can bring a little memory for its past path so that it will not come back to the memorised positions . usually , the walker memorises only the previous position in order not to come back at once . the model is sometimes known as a polymer chain model with excluded volume . in our flow model , a particle movement is always associated with a ring of movements and can not reverse immediately . this minimum regulation matches with that of the non - reversal walker . in addition , because the non - reversal walker is not bounded by any loop - like relation to neighbours , we deduce that it gives the upper limit for the tamsd of our model . we define the stochastic flow model ( ii ) and the non - reversal random walk on the lattice @xmath158 , and compare them in terms of their tamsds in fig.[fig : comparisonii_21 ] . notice that the constant trapping ratio is equipped with the non - reversal walkers to keep the pace of his first step with the flows in our model . . the line for the non - reversal random walk is given with the trapping time consistent with the original model , and the asymptotic value for @xmath158 is shown.,width=302 ] as for the ergodicity , we claim that the ergodicity weakly holds in our model ( ii ) of the lattice liquid . in order to illustrate this , we have calculated the asymptotic value of the msd with some assumption as follows . assume that , in the limit of @xmath159 , the time correlation of every particle on @xmath0 vanishes so that a particle situated at any of the sites on @xmath0 at a certain time @xmath95 is to be drifted to every site with equal footing in the infinite future . then , the asymptotic value of @xmath160 can simply be given by the average of the square distances of all the relevant pairs of the sites on @xmath0 . on the rectangular honeycomb lattice @xmath121 , we derived its exact formula and the leading terms are given by : [ eq : asymptotic_approx ] _ t+ = 18 ( 7 n^2 + 10 n ) + o(1 ) . in the case of @xmath161 , the exact values are up to first five digits : [ eq : asymptotic ] 116.75 , 409.04 , 876.45 , 1518.9 , 2336.4 . see appendix [ app : aymptotic ] for the exact form of an arbitrary @xmath98 . the time - averaged msds in fig.[fig : msd11 - 41 ] , [ fig : comparisonii_21 ] approach the calculated asymptotic values ( [ eq : asymptotic ] ) and are stabilised around them as the time grows . therefore , we can state that our models are surely ergodic in this sense . in this paper , we have proposed and formulated a family of models , called the 2d lattice liquid models , as one sort of the simplest models of single - component , single - layered , incompressible fluid particle system on a membrane without explicit viscosity and density fluctuation . the model is formulated as a particle system on a lattice , but the configurations are found to be expressed by the sets of oriented non - intersecting loops , due to the restriction on the occupation number and the upper bound for the velocities . following the formulation , we have constructed two models of the lattice liquid . one of them is the stochastic markovian model ( i ) which is found to be another manifestation of the vicious random walks in its densest phase and the dll model in two dimensions . we have dealt with the model on the isotropic lattice , and derived a few basic quantities of the model . we have also shown that the difference between our model and a collection of non - interacting simple random walks by distinct two - point functions . the other model is the stochastic flow model ( ii ) where the set of rules are given in eqs.([def : stof ] , [ eq : symdiff - directed ] , [ def : addition ] ) . the first rule ( [ def : stof ] ) is on the stability of the existing flow and is written in the euler formulation . we have utilised the notion of the oriented loop configurations @xmath44 and formulated the model . in order to interpret the fluctuation as a direct consequence of the kicks by the environment , it is worth rewriting the rule in the original lagrangian formulation . in this paper , we have focused on the construction of the model itself , and neglected this point . in numerical calculations , we have realised both models on the rectangular honeycomb lattice @xmath121 of various sizes in one million time steps . from the input data of the models on @xmath121 , we have found that the probability of the no - loop configuration , @xmath132 , has a scaling relation with the area of the lattice , and we have proposed the functional form ( [ eq : pfapprox ] ) for a general size of the honeycomb lattice as an approximation . we briefly report here that the probability of one - loop length - six configurations and that of length - ten can also be explained by the proposed form of @xmath62 . this might suggest that the form of @xmath62 with other additional criteria can explain how the distribution of the total length of the loops takes such a peculiar form in fig.[fig : looplen_dist ] . the area laws of the average loop length @xmath91 and the average loop number @xmath141 are also to be explained . we do not know the answers yet . in the numerical calculations of the flow model ( ii ) , we have shown the probability of how many fluctuations of @xmath162 had been added in a million trials . as @xmath98 goes over @xmath163 , the system seems to be stuck against the projected addition . this reduction of the fluctuations is entirely due to the definition of the projected addition . because of the second line of the projection rule ( [ def : addition ] ) , if @xmath164 is huge enough as a set , many elements of @xmath44 become non - additive . even so , practically speaking in quasi - critical states , there are about 30% vacant faces . therefore , the system can not be entirely frozen , changing only the time scale for its dynamics . it is the msd on which the time scale matters . especially , the emergence of the plateaus in fig.[fig : msd11 - 41 ] might be because of this strong restriction of the fluctuations . we then expect that softening the projection in the addition may change the intermediate plateau part of the msds , and this point is to be explored more elsewhere @xcite . there are many related statistical models . particularly , the vicious walk and the dll model are the closest ones to the model ( i ) . the vicious walk is the model of mutually avoiding multiple particle system so that its densest phase inevitably coincides with ours with the simplest stochastic process . the dll model is the model of cooperative particle rearrangement for supercooled liquids and polymer melts , usually equipped with volume fluctuations and their temperature dependence . in both cases , the dynamics is governed by completely independent time steps , and they surely overlap with this sort of the models among the family of our models . especially in the dll model , the dynamics is usually equipped with the temperature dependence of @xmath69 , so it would be intriguing to investigate another manifestation of the temperature dependence and multi - component systems @xcite in both contexts . in addition , the loop gas model is one of the closest models . letting all @xmath62 be one , one automatically obtains the partition function of the loop gas model from that of our stochastic markovian model of the lattice liquid . the loop gas model can be described in the @xmath165 spin model on the lattice by expressing all the loop graphs in terms of @xmath165 spin variables @xcite . to avoid complications , we have not included this algebraic description of our models . also , in the presence of the @xmath62 less than unity , the loop probabilities of both models become different . we can quantify them by the use of number series known as the derangement number and its related series . to invoke the expression , the models must be first written in the form of algebras . we have put aside this procedure , and therefore , to be given elsewhere @xcite . we are afraid that the constructed models are not so applicable and not ready to be compared to experiments , except for a few cases in a very different context . because we used the honeycomb lattice as an explicit example , the current model might be able to be applied directly to a particle system of the same situation : a bigger sort of particles form a most densely packed crystal sitting at the centres of the faces while smaller particles moving in between them . because of the set - up , the msd of the flow model actually resembles that of the super - cooled polymer melt @xcite . since their dimensions are different , we consider this happens by accident though . in order to apply 2d lattice liquid models to soft - material membranes directly , one should remove or relax some of the assumptions we used in this paper for convenience . namely , the assumptions are such that the system must be single - component , single - layered , incompressible , non - explicitly - viscous , less density fluctuating . also , we have not used interactions between particles . note that they are not the requirements nor the definitions of the 2d lattice liquid models . among them , double - layer can easily be embedded just by folding a layer into two , but the interactions between two layers are not obvious . the simplest one is to introduce the interaction between layers only at the common boundary of two layers , possibly as a boundary condition . our construction itself is ready to be extended to the multi - component case where there are more than one particle species and the interaction between different species should be introduced as well . the simplest one will be the ising - type nearest neighbour interaction with which one can observe the phase separation according to some temperature . this might also turn on the effective viscosity in the model . note the concept of the temperature can naturally be installed by letting @xmath166 be a function of @xmath67 , for example , by @xmath167 and @xmath168 . thermodynamic behaviour will depend on the manifestation of the functional forms of @xmath77 and @xmath68 . some of the above proposals will be studied elsewhere @xcite another very interesting yet possibly very hard model to solve is the fluid model with memory effect . as we mentioned in the manuscript , the `` potential '' probabilities can potentially carry the information from the past so that the past partially control the forthcoming event through the probabilities . here , we have only dealt with markov processes in both models , and the problem is beyond our scope of this manuscript . * acknowledgements * the authors acknowledge prof . k. yasuoka , prof . y. masubuchi , prof . s. yasuda , dr . t. akimoto , and all the members of the group _ multiscale simulation for softmatters _ for their stimulating discussions . one of the authors ( yi ) would like to thank prof . k. nagayama for his advice and encouragement , and s. ishimoto for his support . this research was supported by _ core research for evolutional science and technology ( crest ) of japan science and technology agency corporation ( jst)_. to begin with , let us define the ( oriented ) loop configurations on @xmath0 . for a given lattice @xmath0 , a one - loop graph , or configuration , is defined by a sequence of sites and bonds with no repeating sites and no ends . the object is the same as simple cycles in graph theory . an oriented one - loop graph is defined in the same way and is given by a one - loop graph with an orientation of the bonds representing its sequence . the space of the non - oriented non - intersecting loop configurations @xmath45 on @xmath0 is the whole set of the non - intersecting combinations of such one - loop graphs . the space of the oriented non - intersecting loop configuration @xmath44 is those of the oriented one - loop graphs . these spaces can be decomposed into ( oriented ) @xmath169-loop subspaces , or can be defined by them . let @xmath170 be a one - loop graph on @xmath0 for @xmath171 . then , a @xmath169-loop graph @xmath172 is defined by : g_k = _ i=1^k l_i , s.t . l_i _ j = for i j. collecting all such @xmath169-loop graphs in @xmath45 constitutes the @xmath169-loop subspace @xmath173 of @xmath45 : _ k ( ) \ { g_k } , _ k ( ) ( ) . when @xmath0 is finite , there exists the maximum number of co - existing non - intersecting loops on @xmath0 . denoting it by @xmath174 , one can write down the decomposition as : & & l ( ) = _ k=0^k_max l_k ( ) , & & s.t . l_i ( ) _ j ( ) = for ij . in the same manner , one can decompose the oriented space @xmath44 into the oriented @xmath169-loop subspaces : & & _ k ( ) \ { g_k } , _ k ( ) ( ) , & & ( ) = _ k=0^k_max _ k ( ) , & & s.t . _ i ( ) _ j ( ) = for ij , where @xmath175 is an oriented @xmath169-loop graph in @xmath44 . if we introduce the function @xmath176 which counts the number of elements of a set , then the uniqueness of the no - loop configuration in both spaces is trivially given by @xmath177 and @xmath178 . we label this unique configuration by @xmath104 . similarly , @xmath179 due to the orientations . one can further observe the relation : @xmath180 for @xmath181 . the algebraic structure of the space @xmath44 directly corresponds to the physical relations between the states on @xmath0 . however , even for a very basic question of how many configurations are in the space @xmath44 , we have not known any clear answer yet for an arbitrary size of the lattice . in fact , it is shown that counting the number of self - avoiding walks ( saws ) for fixed ends on a given graph is @xmath182-complete @xcite . @xmath182 is a class of the problems for counting and , roughly speaking , they are expected to be as hard as @xmath183-complete problems such as the prime number decomposition of an arbitrary large number . therefore , one can expect that counting the number of the elements of @xmath44 is as hard as @xmath183-complete problems as well , because a non - intersecting loop is nothing but a self - avoiding walk ending at its start @xcite . below , we illustrate the structure of the spaces in terms of the cycle space in graph theory . we restrict ourselves to the planar cases unless otherwise stated . when @xmath0 is planar , _ i.e. _ , @xmath0 can be embedded on a plane with no bonds crossing , the space @xmath45 can be spanned by the set of the smallest loops which are the perimeters of the interior faces of @xmath0 . in graph theory , there is the so - called cycle space @xmath184 which is generated by all the simple cycles and whose basis is given by the fundamental cycles . the addition generates the cycle space from the basis , and makes it the vector space of @xmath185 , where @xmath186 and @xmath187 are the number of the bonds and the number of the sites , respectively . the concepts of @xmath45 and the cycle space @xmath184 are very close to each other , but not always the same because of the presence of the intersecting loops in the cycle space . in fact , there is a necessary and sufficient condition for their equivalence that the degrees of the sites must be less than four everywhere : @xmath188 for all @xmath189 . otherwise , the addition allows intersecting loops . therefore , ( ) cycle ( ) , in general , and @xmath45 is not necessarily a vector space but can be spanned by the set of the smallest loops . when @xmath0 is a planar honeycomb lattice of a finite size , ( ) = cycle ( ) _ 2^e - v+1 , and ( l ( ) ) = 2^e - v+1 = 2^f , where @xmath131 denotes the number of the interior faces and the second equality is given by euler s formula on a planar graph . its basis can be given by the set of the smallest loops . note that , in general , ( l ( ) ) 2^e - v+1 . in the case of the oriented loop configurations @xmath44 , the relation is not as simple as above . we can only provide an estimate for the number of the elements to close . in the case of @xmath190 , & & 2^f+1 -1 < ( ( _ h_n,3 m ) ) < & & 2^ f - 2^(f+1 ) + 2f + 1 . a more refined relation will be given elsewhere @xcite . in this section , we define the probability functions of the no - loop configuration and of having ( oriented ) loops on the given graph , @xmath62 and @xmath61 , respectively . that is to say , the complementary functions satisfying : @xmath191 . upon their definitions , we will show some of the basic properties of the probability functions . note that the word ` loop graph ' indicates the same object as the loop configuration in the original context , but the latter emphasises an outcome of some stochastic process . on the loop graphs as events of the stochastic process , we define the following probability functions . let @xmath192 be the probability of having the loop graph @xmath172 in @xmath0 . let @xmath193 be the probability of having any loop graph on the graph @xmath194 . let @xmath88 be the probability of the graph @xmath195 being completely frustrated , _ i.e. _ , having no loops . here , the graph @xmath196 is an extended graph of @xmath76 such that it additionally includes all the bonds adjacent to the sites in @xmath76 , in order to precisely explain and estimate the stochastic nature of our model . introducing the complementary graph @xmath197 to a loop graph @xmath198 , the probability function @xmath199 of having the loop graph @xmath198 in @xmath0 is given by the product of the probability @xmath200 of the loop configuration @xmath198 on the graph @xmath198 , and the probability @xmath201 of all the other sites being frustrated : p(l ) = p_l(l ) p_f(|l ) . by definition , the following equalities and inequalities hold : [ eq : ineq ] p_l ( ) & = & _ g_k>0 ( ) p(g_k ) , p_f(g ) & = & 1 - p_l(g ) , p_f ( ) = 1- p_l ( ) = 1 , 0 & & p_l(g ) 1 , 0p_f(g ) 1 . in the third line , for finite @xmath76 and @xmath0 , the equalities @xmath202 and @xmath203 only hold when @xmath76 or @xmath0 is linear or the assignment of the `` potential '' probabilities of the particles moving are unnaturally given in the non - stochastic limit . therefore , we assume @xmath204 and @xmath205 for finite size @xmath76 and @xmath0 . letting @xmath198 be the naive projection of the oriented loop graph @xmath206 by removing the orientations , and assuming that the different oriented loop graphs which share the same projected loop graph @xmath198 are equiprobable , then the mapping of the oriented loop graphs by the probability functions become apparent as : p(g_k ) & = & p_l(g_k ) p_f(|g_k ) , p(g_k ) & = & 2^k p(g_k ) , p_l(g_k ) & = & 2^k p(g_k ) , p_f(g_k ) & = & p_f(g_k ) . @xmath175 is not a subgraph of @xmath0 so that the complementary graph is defined by the projected graph @xmath172 : @xmath207 . one can interpret that the same projection is done for the @xmath62 as well . because the frustrations in disconnected graphs are independent , the following relation holds : for two disconnected graphs , @xmath208 : p_f(g_1 g_2 ) = p_f(g_1 ) p_f(g_2 ) g_1 g_2 = . note that , using the above definitions and successive application of the relations , one can obtain @xmath192 in a nested expression of the loop probabilities only in this section , we calculate the asymptotic value of the mean square displacements , @xmath209 , which is the average of @xmath210 over @xmath97 , in the limit of @xmath211 . before going into the actual calculation , we fix the notations and introduce some functions to facilitate it . number the position on @xmath0 starting from 0 to @xmath212 , and assign a pair of integers to the @xmath68-th site , @xmath213 . the position of the @xmath68-th site , @xmath214 , on the two - dimensional @xmath215 plane can be given by , for the @xmath216 honeycomb lattice : & & p_x = p mod col , p_y = [ p / col ] , & & x_p = p_x , y_q = 32 p_y + 14 ( -1)^p_x+p_y+1 , where @xmath217 , and @xmath218 $ ] denotes the greatest integer which does not exceed @xmath219 . @xmath220 takes the value from @xmath37 to @xmath221 , while @xmath222 . @xmath223 are all integers . the lattice spacing is taken to be a unit length . the square distance between @xmath68-th and @xmath224-th positions are : & & r_q , p - q^2 = ( x_p - x_q ) ^2 + ( y_p - y_q ) ^2 & & = 34 \ { ( p_x - q_x)^2 + 3 ( p_y - q_y)^2 } & & + 18 \{1 - 6(-1)^p_x+p_y ( p_y - q_y ) } ( 1 - ( -1)^(p_x - q_x ) + ( p_y - q_y ) ) . note that we used the following identity : @xmath225 for @xmath226 . replacing @xmath227 by @xmath228 , one can rewrite this as @xmath229 : [ c3 ] r_q,(k , l)^2 & = & 34 k^2 + 94 l^2 + 18 c(q , l ) - 8 c(q , l ) ( -1)^k+l , where @xmath230 from this expression , one can verify that @xmath231 is integer . assume that , in the limit of @xmath159 , all the pairs of the sites are independent to each other so that the asymptotic value of @xmath209 can simply be given by the average of the square distances of all the relevant pairs in @xmath232 combinations . namely , the value leads to the expression : [ eq : r_inf ] [ eq : r^2 ] & & _ t & & = _ relevant . here , the word `` relevant '' means that some sites at the boundary can not contribute to the above , because our flow dynamics can only involve those points which have more than one bond . for instance , regardless of the value of @xmath98 , the following two sites should always be excluded : q = \ { ( 0,0 ) , ( 2n,0 ) } . besides , when @xmath98 is odd , the following two sites are to be taken into account in the same manner : q = \ { ( 0,n ) , ( 2n , n ) } . they are connected only one nearest neighbouring site , so that the particle can not reach these four points via our flow dynamics . therefore , the square distances related to these points do not contribute to the above calculation . substituting ( [ c3 ] ) into ( [ eq : r^2 ] ) and subtracting such unnecessary terms from the sum , we obtain for odd @xmath98 : & & & & = & & & & 18 ( 7 n^2 + 10 n ) , up to @xmath233 . in the cases of @xmath234 , the exact values are given in the manuscript up to first five digits . h. noguchi and g. gompper , phys . e * 73 * , 021903 ( 2006 ) ; t. akimoto , e. yamamoto , k. yasuoka , y. hirano , and m. yasui , phys . lett . , * 107 * , 178103 ( 2011 ) ; h. noguchi , j. chem . phys . * 134 * , 055101 ( 2011 ) ;
Abstract: | [
"a family of models of liquid on a 2d lattice ( 2d lattice liquid models ) have been proposed as primitive models of soft - material membrane . as a first step , we have formulated them as single - component , single - layered , classical particle systems on a two - dimensional surface with no explicit viscosity . among the family of the models , we have shown and constructed two stochastic models , a vicious walk model and a flow model , on an isotropic regular lattice and on the rectangular honeycomb lattice of various sizes . in both cases , the dynamics is governed by the nature of the frustration of the particle movements . by simulations , we have found the approximate functional form of the frustration probability , and peculiar anomalous diffusions in their time - averaged mean square displacements in the flow model . the relations to other existing statistical models and possible extensions of the models are also discussed ."
] | 11,055 | 11,055 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the ground state of a weak - disorder quantum hall bilayer has an exciton condensate when the total landau level filling factor @xmath0 and the semiconductor quantum wells are close together . the condensate state is characterized by spontaneous inter - layer phase coherence.@xcite condensate properties are often probed most effectively by transport experiments , both because the two - dimensional electron system is buried beneath the surface of a three - dimensional host and because these measurements probe@xcite condensate superfluidity . indeed , the presence of a condensate has been inferred on the basis of wide variety of transport anomalies.@xcite although these experiments do not directly measure the condensate order parameter , it is generally acknowledged that they do not allow plausible alternate explanations . on the other hand the transport properties of systems in which the condensate is believed to have formed have largely defied attempts to achieve fully quantitative interpretations . this conundrum is related in part to the importance of edge states in quantum hall transport@xcite and , as we explain in this paper , to the sensitivity of transport measurements to disorder and to contact properties that are not normally characterized . the description that we develop for transport in the deeply coherent regime is based on a microscopic mean - field theory of the exciton condensate state , on a scattering formulation of transport theory,@xcite and on a two - channel contact model which accounts explicitly for the two contact layers . we show that transport properties can be non - trivial even when the current is small enough that the coherence order parameter is time - independent.@xcite a simplified version of this picture with a single parameter , which we refer to as _ p - ology _ , allows for virtual occupation of a pair - breaking edge channel and can be used to provide an approximate description of the crossover between strong and weak interlayer coupling regimes . our paper is organized as follows . in section ii we explain the general philosophy of our approach , which has similarities to theories of the non - equilibrium properties of both superconductors @xcite and magnetic conductors.@xcite the edge state physics of quantum hall systems is essential to the way in which the theory is developed . indeed , the presence of edge states at the fermi level , even when the bulk is gapped , is responsible for many of the complications which make the transport anomalies difficult to describe quantitatively . in section iii we detail the landauer - buttiker theory that we use to describe transport of the mean - field - theory quasiparticles , and illustrate it by evaluating two probe conductances for systems with well developed coherence . in section iv we discuss transport in the case of a non stationary condensate , focusing on the simplest case in which both coherent and incoherent inter - layer tunneling are absent and illustrating our picture by calculating the interlayer voltage for a drag experiment with a grounded drag layer . in section v we develop _ p - ology _ , which is intended to describe the influence of weaker coherence but assumes that quasiparticle transport is still edge dominated . this phenomenology makes it clear that large longitudinal drags are always present when the hall drag voltage drops below its quantized value , as seen in experiment.@xcite sec . vi contains a summary of our main results and discusses their relationship to other ideas for explaining the transport properties of coherent bilayers . in this paper we adopt a hartree - fock - like mean - field description of the exciton condensate which is similar to the mean - field - theories used , generally successfully , to describe transport in metallic ferromagnets and superconductors . this type of theory has an @xmath1 vector order parameter constructed in our case from the pseudospin-@xmath2 layer degree of freedom , and an associated pseudospin effective magnetic field which arises from microscopic exchange interactions . for a typical bilayer with weak single - particle tunneling , the exchange field exceeds the single - particle symmetric - antisymmetric level splitting , @xmath3 , by many orders of magnitude . @xmath3 is therefore normally negligible in the description of the quasiparticle properties . the dynamics of the order parameter , on the other hand , is described by a landau - lifshitz - like equation which depends only on an external field term proportional to @xmath3 , on other terms proportional to order parameter derivatives and on transport currents.@xcite ( characteristic length scales then emerge from a comparison of @xmath3 and the coefficients of the order - parameter derivative terms . ) the @xmath3 term must be present@xcite to allow consistently for the net interlayer charge transfer which occurs in many transport experiments . typical electrical measurements performed on a coherent quantum hall bilayer involve establishing a source to drain voltage bias which injects transport quasiparticles , and measuring local electrochemical potentials at positions along the sample perimeter . when the quantum hall effect is well developed the transport quasiparticles are localized at the sample edges . electrochemical potential measurements therefore often reflect properties of the bulk condensate somewhat indirectly . contacts to the coherent bilayer resemble normal metal - superconductor junctions , at which normal currents are converted into supercurrents . this conversion between normal current and supercurrent is accomplished via andreev scattering . a similar conversion process occurs in a coherent bilayer ; even for vanishingly small single - particle tunneling a quasiparticle that has a definite layer quantum number in the leads becomes coherently mixed between the layers far away from the leads . the order parameter exchange field provides a broken symmetry contribution to the quasiparticle hamiltonian with a large inter - layer tunneling amplitude . this process does not violate charge conservation since an excitonic supercurrent is always launched to compensate@xcite for charge transfer between layers . when the condensate is described collectively , the full system of equations consists of a landau - lifshitz - like equation for the condensate with a _ pseudospin - transfer _ torque@xcite term to account for normal current to exciton super current conversion , combined with a transport theory for quasiparticles influenced by the condensate . the two sets of equations need to be solved self - consistently . at low temperatures , inelastic scattering is weak and quasiparticle transport can be described using the landauer - buttiker formalism . application of this picture is complicated in coherent quantum hall bilayer systems by the role of chiral edge states , which can carry nearly dissipationless currents by a mechanism completely different from superfluidity . two signature properties of coherent bilayers are i ) the quantization of hall drag resistance at @xmath4 ( the hall resistance is quantized whether measured in the layer in which current is flowing or in the layer in which no current flows ) , and ii ) the absence of longitudinal drag at filling factor @xmath5 per layer . together the two properties suggest that a quantum hall effect is established at a filling factor related to the combined densities of the two layers , and that the quasiparticle current flows coherently through both layers ; there is no layer dependence in chemical potential measurements . because of the quantum hall effect , and its associated bulk gap , the bilayer coherent quasiparticles must flow at the sample edges . since these properties are normally measured in samples in which @xmath3 is extremely small , the quasiparticle current in the drag layer must be exactly compensated by a condensate counterflow supercurrent . we will be interested in analyzing transport both in four - probe geometries , which include voltage - probe contacts in addition to the current source and drain contacts , and in two - probe geometries in which the additional voltage probe contacts are absent . as we explain , some interesting information about the system can be obtained from two - probe measurements . one interesting issue that arises in the two - probe case concerns a theory of the maximum conductance possible when source and drain contacts are connected to opposite layers . our analysis relates two - probe conductances to the influence of the condensate on electron scattering near the contacts , information which will prove helpful in analyzing four - probe experiments . an appropriate microscopic model for the _ normal _ contact region in which interlayer coherence is absent plays an essential role in our analysis . we assume that the active area of the bilayer in which coherence is established is incompressible and surrounded by a single current - carrying edge state channel shared between the two layers.@xcite as a convenience we imagine the leads as consisting of narrow hall bars with separate @xmath6 states in the two layers and associated ingoing and outgoing states which can be viewed as being located to some degree on opposite edges of these leads . we recognize that this is a somewhat idealized model of the incoherent bilayer contacts , but believe that it is general enough to capture all the essential physics . the contacts are indeed realistically viewed as narrow hall bars , but the filling factors in each layer depends on the device layout , especially on the arrangement of the main top and bottom gates.@xcite because there is a single channel in the active region , however , we can in principle always identify a linear combination of lead channels into which electron waves incident from the sample are transmitted and also a linear combination of lead channels which is responsible for all transmission . the incoming and outgoing channels in the leads in our model should be understood as represented these sample - dependent channels . with this understanding , even if other channels are present they do not contribute to transport . when the temperature @xmath7 , this description should apply on the bilayer @xmath8 hall plateau , which can in principle extend over the filling factor range @xmath9 . at finite temperatures there will always be corrections due to thermally excited mobile bulk carriers , and these corrections will be small over a narrower filling factor range . the single edge state in the active area is a certain coherent superposition of the top and bottom edge states , to be specified more completely below . under most circumstances the quasiparticles have equal weight in the two layers corresponding to the pseudospin order parameter lying in the @xmath10-plane . the phase relationship between quasiparticle components in the two layers is dictated by the local direction of the pseudospin effective zeeman field . occupied edge states therefore add to the condensate strength . this picture is summarized schematically in fig.[fig : edgestates ] . occupation of the orthogonal quasiparticle state with the opposite interlayer phase would be pair breaking , _ i.e. _ it would weaken the condensate . this state has higher energy and does not participate in low temperature , low bias - voltage transport . later we consider the possibility of virtual occupation of the pair - breaking edge - state channel when the condensate is weak . coherent quantum hall bilayer . the normal region has two layers , each with a left - going and right - going channel that can transmit electrons toward or away from the coherent layer . on a @xmath6 plateau the coherent region supports a single edge channel with an inter - layer phase relationship that is dictated by the local condensate phase . shaded regions schematically represent places where scattering in the contacts takes place . like a ferromagnet , and unlike a @xmath11 superconductor , the ordered region has conducting quasiparticles . unlike typical ferromagnets , the conducting pseudospins are localized at the sample edge and share the same pseudospin state , in the jargon of magnetism the system is half - metallic . ] disorder gives rise to a random potential difference between edges which mixes edge state channels . this can give rise to memory of the layer from which an electron has been injected that persists along the edge . when layer memory is important for the electrical measurements we need to employ a different formulation of the scattering transport theory which has a larger number of free parameters . the description of scattering at a junction separating two incompressible states , one representing the contact arms taken to have @xmath12 , and one representing the active area having @xmath8 , represents a new and interesting example of the application of landauer - buttiker transport theory to the qhe@xcite regime . in this case the two arms can be alternatively thought of as a combined system with two edge states , or as two separate leads attached to the bulk . in coherent bilayer transport experiments current is often injected into or drained from only one layer . we model separate - contacting to a single layer simply by setting the current to zero for one of the layers . in this way one arm of the contact acts like a voltage probe and the other like a current probe . in experiment the voltage on the open layer can normally not be read externally , although our theory does predict its value . the bulk of the bilayer contains a single edge state , as is appropriate for @xmath8 . the scattering problem near a contact , depicted in fig . [ fig : edgestates ] , is then defined via transmission probabilities from the upper `` coherent '' edge state to top and bottom edge states in the arms , @xmath13 , and from top and bottom edge states into the lower coherent edge state , @xmath14 , as well as the layer - diagonal reflection probabilities ( @xmath15 ) , the cross - layer ( andreev ) reflection probabilities ( @xmath16 ) , and finally the probability for a coherent edge state to bypass a lead , @xmath17 . note that we adopt the convention that the first index of a transmission or reflection probability denotes the outgoing scattering state channel , while the second index specifies the incoming channel . using the above scattering probabilities , one can relate the electrochemical potentials of incoming and outgoing states for the problem illustrated in fig . [ fig : edgestates ] : @xmath18 unitarity and microreversibility@xcite impose the following conditions on the scattering probabilities : @xmath19 eqs . ( [ eq : unitarity ] ) demonstrate that there are only three independent scattering probabilities which fully characterize a lead / coherent sample junction . we choose these to be @xmath20 , and @xmath21 . as a convenience we will assume in our discussion that all contacts are identical ; differences between contacts could readily be accounted for in interpreting experiments if they were adequately characterized . the way a particular contact connects to the outer world specifies additional relations between ` in ' and ` out ' electrochemical potentials . for example , when the top arm is open , one has @xmath22 . this applies equally well to voltage probes . when a voltage probe is connected to the the top layer only , for example , we set @xmath22 as usual . however we also set @xmath23 . even though the bottom layer chemical potential is not _ read _ externally it is still true that no current is flowing to the outside through this arm . contacts that are not layer selective are electrically connected to the same external reservoir and therefore can be represented by setting @xmath24 , whether used as simply as voltage probes or as a current source or drain . when current is allowed to flow between contact arms through an external resistor , the difference between their chemical potentials is proportional to this current . the unitarity and microreversibility relations , eqs . ( [ eq : unitarity ] ) ensure that the voltage probe readings made by probes that contact both layers or either layer individually agree . . there are a large variety of possible measurements in which two of the four contacts are used as source and drain and two as voltage probes . contacts are normally connected to only one of the two layers , as described in the text . ] having described the scattering problem near the contacts , we can proceed to calculate various experimentally relevant quantities . in general the effective single - particle scattering problem for the quasiparticles must be solved together with equations for the condensate . ( the quasiparticle mean - field hamiltonian and hence the transmission probabilities depend on the condensate configuration , which is in turn influenced by the transport currents . ) at small voltages and currents , however , we can neglect this dependence , and treat the transmissions and reflections as constants dependent on the equilibrium condensate configuration . the typical experimental setup is depicted in fig . [ fig : setup ] . in the two - probe case the additional voltage probes are absent and it does not matter which pair of contacts we take as a source and a drain . the three reflection probabilities that characterize the contacts , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 can be determined by three independent measurements which take advantage of the freedom that the current at both source and drain can flow through only one layer or through both . we take these experiments to be _ parallel flow _ , _ drag _ , and _ tunneling _ measurements . in _ parallel flow _ the layers are shorted at both source and drain . in _ drag _ , current flows in from and out through the drive layer ; no current flows through the drag layer arms at either source or drain , or obviously at any voltage probes which might be present . finally , in the _ tunneling _ measurement current is injected into one layer , and extracted from the other one . in most of this paper we assume that the condensate is time independent . for tunneling experiments this requires that currents be smaller than a critical tunneling current.@xcite we find that the parallel , drag , and tunneling linear conductances are given respectively by @xmath27 in the above expression for @xmath28 the skipping probability , @xmath17 , is given by @xmath29 , as dictated by eqs . ( [ eq : unitarity ] ) . the drag conductance was evaluated for the case of a floating drag layer , _ i.e. _ an uncontacted drag layer . the same expression holds in the case of a grounded drag layer with a large ( compared to the critical tunneling current ) total current flowing through the bilayer . when the drag layer is grounded , the condensate phase will be time - dependent as discussed in the next section . one might view as ideal the situation in which the two - layers behave identically , the skipping probability is small , and there is no memory of incoming layer when reflection by the active coherent region occurs . these conditions together imply that @xmath30 , @xmath31 and give ideal values for @xmath32 , and for @xmath33 . the parallel flow two - contact conductance is the usual ideal quantum hall effect value , while the drag and tunnel conductances are half as large . the maximum possible tunnel conductance is actually somewhat larger and reached at @xmath34 , when it becomes @xmath35 . for these values @xmath36 . vanishing normal reflection and maximum andreev reflection seem unlikely in semiconductor bilayers , since reflection in the same layer should be , if anything , more likely than reflection to the other layer . a more plausible extreme set of values might be @xmath30 , @xmath37 and @xmath38 which yields @xmath39 , and @xmath40 . experimental two - probe tunnel resistances in the neighorhood of @xmath41 are indeed commonly observed in coherent bilayers . even for a strong static condensate the maximum tunneling conductance is always associated with a large resistance , which can be viewed as a contact resistance . in this sense there is no ideal dissipationless josephson effect in semiconductor bilayers . the finite resistances do not necessarily , as it is often assumed,@xcite imply that the condensate is lost because of disorder and/or quantum fluctuations . we will return to this point in the the discussion section . measurements of two - probe linear conductances for several different contacting geometries can determine the numerical values of @xmath42 , @xmath43 and @xmath44 , and in this way shed light on the nature of the lead / active region junction . so far we have been concerned with problems with a time - independent condensate . there is a class of experiments , however , in which the contacting geometry and bias voltages lead to a net current flow between layers which exceeds the critical value . the interlayer current flow can either be forced by the contacting geometry , as in counterflow and tunneling experiments , or implied by quasiparticle transport theory . an example of the second case is provided by a drag experiment in which the drag layer is grounded , _ i.e. _ it is connected to the drain contact rather than floating as in the classic drag experiment . the description of the two types of experiments is slightly different : in counterflow and tunneling , there _ must _ be interlayer current , and the full system of equations for the condensate and quasiparticles needs to be solved to find it , as well as the corresponding distribution of interlayer voltages . in the drag experiment with a grounded drag layer , on the other hand , there is always a current path connecting source and drain that lies in the drive layer only . however if a naive landauer - buttiker description with a time - independent condensate predicts an interlayer current larger than the condensate can deliver , there must be an interlayer voltage to ensure that almost all the current flows through the drive layer . we leave calculating the full i - v curve for tunneling experiments to future work,@xcite and concentrate here on a simpler case of a drag experiment with the drag layer grounded at the drain . we will show that the measurement of the interlayer voltage generated in this type of measurement can provide a test of the strong - coherence theory developed in the previous section . for definiteness , let as assume that electrons are injected into the west bottom layer in fig . [ fig : setup ] , and extracted from both north top and bottom layers , going counter - clockwise along the sample edge . application of the landauer - buttiker formalism predicts that the current that exits through the drag ( top ) layer , @xmath45 , is @xmath46 where @xmath47 is the total current through the system . when this current exceeds the critical tunneling current the condensate can not be stationary@xcite and a finite interlayer voltage , developed through interlayer polarization , should be measurable . this additional voltage will reduce the current flowing to ground through the drag layer to a value below the critical current . experimentally , the total current is quite often much larger than the critical tunneling current . in this case interlayer tunneling can be neglected altogether and the interlayer voltage can then be found from the condition that the entire current flows through the drive layer . the latter condition follows from the fact@xcite that for a non stationary condensate collective tunneling becomes an ineffective sink for condensate currents , and the interlayer resistance due to incoherent tunneling is much larger than the resistance associated with the carrying the current in the drive layer only . since we neglect real interlayer electron transfer , we can remove the time dependence of the condensate by switching to a frame rotating with the order parameter . it must be noted that the distribution of interlayer electrostatic potentials has to be calculated taking full account of a bilayer electrostatics , modified by the presence of the condensate.@xcite however , for a well developed qhe the top and bottom edges running from west to north , and from north to west must be equipotentials . moreover , the interlayer voltage must be equal at the above edges , otherwise there would be an ever - increasing counterflow from one edge to the other . in principle , this can be counteracted by counterflow decay due to real tunneling , which we take to be negligible at present , or phase slippage events,@xcite but these should not occur at small currents , since vortices are pinned . hence we conclude that the rate at which the order parameter rotates , @xmath48 , where @xmath49 is its phase must be constant at the system edge , and it is this value of @xmath50 at the edge that is measured by a voltage probe as an interlayer electrochemical potential difference . the latter statement assumes that the quasiparticle dynamics is fast on the condensate time scales , thus the quasiparticles are in equilibrium with the local instant value of the condensate . now let us calculate the value of the interlayer electrochemical potential difference that is necessary for the absence of the current through the drag ( top ) layer . switching to a rotating frame corresponds to a gauge transformation @xmath51 , where @xmath52 is the annihilation operator in the top and bottom layers , respectively . this transformation removes the time dependence of the order parameter by shifting the electrochemical potentials in the top and bottom layers by @xmath53 . since the quasiparticles now see a time - independent spontaneous tunneling amplitude , we can apply landauer - buttiker formulae to the above shifted electrochemical potentials substituting @xmath54 in eq . ( [ eq : chempots ] ) . note that @xmath55 remains unchanged . the electrochemical potential difference is found from the condition that there is no current flowing out of the top layer at north , and the _ unshifted _ electrochemical potential in north top arm coincides with the drain electrochemical potential . the result is @xmath56 where , as before , @xmath47 is the current flowing through the bilayer . we note that the conductance in this case is still given by the corresponding expression in eq . ( [ eq : conductances ] ) . the interlayer voltage , eq . ( [ eq : interlayerv ] ) , depends on the same set of reflection probabilities that can be , in principle , extracted from the two - probe conductances measurements . ( see eqs . ( [ eq : conductances ] ) ) . confirmation of this prediction would provide strong confirmation that the strong coherence regime modeled in the previous section can be achieved experimentally . when the charge gap responsible for the quantum hall effect is reduced , disorder enables quasiparticles to deviate from perfect chiral routes around the sample perimeter and travel across the bulk . processes of this type , although always present at finite temperatures , are extremely weak when the quantum hall effect is well developed . the bulk scattering events which lead to deviations from a perfect quantum hall effect are normally well characterized by the value of the longitudinal resistance measured in a four - probe geometry . in this section we show that in coherent bilayers , longitudinal voltages can develop in both drag and drive layers when the current source and drain contacts are layer selective , even when transport is perfectly localized at the edge and the quantum hall effect is still perfect when the source and drain contacts are not layer selective . the longitudinal voltages emerge when interlayer coherence is weak enough to permit evanescent conduction in the _ pair - breaking _ bilayer edge channel , leading to a non - negligible layer - memory length . below we explain a model intended to describe electrical measurements in this regime , which we refer to the weak coherence regime . we start this discussion of deviations from the strong coherence case by briefly reviewing the main assumptions made in the previous section . there it was assumed that an electron arriving at a voltage probe travelled in a single chiral channel localized along the edge of the active coherent region . under such an assumption , unitarity of scattering near the probe ensures that selective voltage probes connected to either layer measure the same electrochemical potentials . on the other hand , electrons propagating along the aforementioned edge channel could have come from either top or bottom layers of , say , an upstream current probe , and these upstream probes could have different electrochemical potentials in top and bottom layers . in order to allow for the possibility of layer memory being retained between probes , we have to weaken our assumptions about electron propagation between probes . losing _ which layer _ memory is , of course , a process of quantum mechanical scattering , which happens on a certain length scale around a contact . up to now , we have been assuming that this length scale is small , which corresponds to what we are referring to as the strong coherence regime . as coherence is weakened , say , by increasing temperature or changing the total filling fraction , one can imagine a situation when this _ which layer _ memory length becomes considerable and eventually comparable to the system size . indeed , as we explain below , there are good reasons to expect that disorder can cause this length to become comparable to sample dimensions even when the normal quantum hall effect is still reasonably well established . voltage probe readings will then depend on which layer is contacted . quasiparticle transport in this regime is most generally described by a phenomenology which allows all possible chiral transmission coefficients between neighboring two - layer contacts . the most general model consistent with a perfect @xmath6 integer quantum hall effect in the active region , when normally contacted , is one in which outgoing electrons in a lead are either reflected within the same lead or transmitted to the nearest downstream contact but satisfy the constraint @xmath57 below we will construct a one - parameter landauer - buttiker - type parameterization to describe the weak coherence regime , which is less general but physically transparent . in order to capture layer memory we need to relax the microscopic single - channel edge model for the active region edge . in order to explain the main ideas we apply this approach mostly to the case of drag experiments , although the same type of analysis could ( and has been ) applied to tunnel , counterflow , and a wide variety of other contacting arrangements . longitudinal drag always accompanies weakening coherence in bilayers , and has previously been analyzed using an effective medium theory due to stern and halperin which associates longitudinal drag with loss of coherence in the bulk of the system.@xcite we show here that longitudinal drag should still be expected even when transport currents still flow perfectly chirally at the edge of the system and the normal quantum hall effect is still accurately quantized . we expect our model to be most relevant at low temperature and small @xmath58 when the bulk effective medium theory appears to fail.@xcite our approach provides a complementary understanding of the large longitudinal drag resistances that can appear in coherent bilayers . in what follows we assume that current is injected into and drained from the bottom layer so that the top layer is the drag layer . we assume that electrons flow counter - clockwise around the sample as in fig . [ fig : setup ] . quantities related to the edge running from the electron source to the electron drain ( simply source and drain from now on ) are labeled with the superscript `` + '' , and those for the edge running from drain to source - with the superscript `` - '' . for the `` + ' ' ( `` - '' ) edge , the coordinate along the edge , @xmath59 , is counted from the source ( drain ) . correspondingly , the distances from source to drain ( along `` + '' edge ) , and from drain to source ( along `` - '' edge ) are denoted @xmath60 . for simplicity , we take all contacts to be identical . finally , we neglect the `` skipping '' probability @xmath17 , and the `` andreev '' reflection probability , @xmath26 ( see eqs . ( [ eq : unitarity ] ) ) . complications which arise when these assumptions are relaxed will be discussed below . to describe the loss of _ which layer _ memory with a minimal set of parameters , we assume that electrons reflect in the same layer in the leads with probability @xmath61 . these values are appropriate ( dictated by eqs . ( [ eq : unitarity ] ) ) near the strong coherence limit if andreev and skipping probabilities are neglected , and there is a symmetry between layers . to specify position - dependent transmissions , we assume that if a voltage probe is physically close to a lead , electrons retain full memory of the lead from which they originate , _ i.e. _ @xmath62 , while @xmath63 . for a voltage probe located far from a lead , on the other hand , the layer memory is completely lost , @xmath64 . the simplest single - length - scale and layer - symmetric@xcite _ ansatz _ for the loss of _ which layer _ memory is as follows : @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the characteristic memory - loss length scale . a similar _ ansatz _ was used previously@xcite to describe bilayer transport at total filling factor @xmath67 . having defined the transmission probabilities , we can now write down the equations for the voltmeter readings . given top and bottom layer incoming electrochemical potentials @xmath68 and @xmath69 , the equations for voltmeters readings along the edges are @xmath70 when these equations are written in the form @xmath71 the matrix @xmath72 satisfies the property @xmath73 . thus , the presence of a voltmeter does not alter readings of any voltmeters placed downstream . we can therefore characterize a given edge by a position dependent chemical potential . ( this property can be traced to our assumption in this section that andreev scattering in the contact regions is not important . ) to close eqs . ( [ eq : chempot_xdep ] ) we need to relate @xmath74 to @xmath75 and the current flowing through the system . taking into account that @xmath74 correspond to readings of voltmeters situated just before the west ( source ) and east ( drain ) leads , respectively , and that the top arm is open at east and west , we can apply eqs . ( [ eq : chempot_xdep ] ) for @xmath76 to get the boundary conditions , @xmath77 the expression for the current , defined as the one flowing through the bottom arm of west or east contacts is @xmath78 eqs . ( [ eq : chempot_xdep ] ) , ( [ eq : boundarycond ] ) , and ( [ eq : totalcurrent ] ) allow for a full characterization of electrical measurements on a bilayer under the conditions of weak coherence , and imply a well defined @xmath8 qhe when the layers are regularly contacted . the considerations above are simplified in several ways , but have the advantage that they leads to a theory with a single parameter , which can be fixed by one measurement and compared with the wide variety of alternate measurements on the same sample that differ only by switching contacts between top and bottom layers or using a probe to contact both layers . more complete theories depend on aspects of the contacts that are not characterized in typical experiments . in what follows we present examples of quantities that can be calculated in the present simple framework for the typical experimental geometry of fig . [ fig : setup ] . we then compare our predictions to the experimental results of refs . [ ] , [ ] , and [ ] , where longitudinal and hall drags are measured as a function of total filling factor@xcite or effective layer distance.@xcite the longitudinal drag resistance is normally defined in terms of the difference between probe voltage values measured in the drag layer and along the same edge . the hall drag is defined similarly , except that the voltage probes are placed on opposite edges . the geometry of kellogg _ et al . _ @xcite corresponds to that described in fig . [ fig : setup ] . the longitudinal drag resistance is measured with source and drain being at the west and north contacts , while voltage probes situated at the south and east contacts , fig . [ fig : setup ] . if we denote the length of the square mesa edge as @xmath79 , in this setup @xmath80 and @xmath81 . the longitudinal drag resistance is then @xmath82 . the hall resistance is measured between the south and north contacts with the source and drain being at the west and east , respectively . thus in the hall drag measurement @xmath83 , and the hall drag resistance is given by @xmath84 . it is natural to express the resistances in terms of the parameter @xmath85 , the probability of retaining layer memory while transiting one edge of the sample , hence _ p - ology_. by solving eqs . ( [ eq : chempot_xdep ] ) , ( [ eq : boundarycond ] ) , and ( [ eq : totalcurrent ] ) one obtains the following expressions : @xmath86 the values of these drag resistances do not depend on whether the drag layer is grounded or not ( as in section [ sec : timedepcond ] we assume a current much larger than critical tunneling one flowing through the bilayer ) . longitudinal drag resistance also does not depend on a particular chirality of electron motion around the sample ( assumed counter - clockwise in fig . [ fig : setup ] ) , while the hall drag resistance changes its sign with a change in the chirality . the configuration used for the measurement of the longitudinal drag resistance described above is also convenient to measure the four - probe interlayer resistance . this resistance is defined in the same way as the longitudinal drag resistance , except the voltage at the east contact is measured in the drive layer : @xmath87 . this resistance does depend on whether the drag layer is grounded or not , and direction of electron motion around the sample . to proceed we combine the present considerations with those from section [ sec : timedepcond ] . then in the case of a counter - clockwise propagation ( as shown in fig . [ fig : setup ] ) we obtain @xmath88 while for clockwise propagation ( _ i.e. _ the opposite to the one shown in fig . [ fig : setup ] ) we get @xmath89 here the superscripts specify the drag configuration that the interlayer resistances pertain to . we observe that in the case of a floating drag layer the interlayer resistance is an odd function of the magnetic field , while in the grounded drag layer case it does not have a definite parity for @xmath90 . we note once again that the expression for the interlayer resistance for the grounded drag configuration assumes that the total current floating through the bilayer is much larger than the critical tunneling one , which typically holds in drag experiments . finally , we can also make predictions for two - probe quantities , in particular , for how the values of conductances described in section [ sec : lb ] change with deviation from the strong coherence limit . the most interesting cases measure tunneling conductances . we assume a tunneling geometry that is identical to that of the hall drag measurements described above , except that source and drain contacts are attached to opposite layers . this leads to @xmath91 this value applies to currents small compared to the critical one . we emphasize that all expressions in eqs . ( [ eq : resistances ] ) , ( [ eq : resis_interlayer ] ) , and ( [ eq : condpology ] ) are expected to be more reliable close to strong coherence , @xmath92 , where the quantum hall effect in the parallel channel is well - developed , and transport is edge - dominated . for instance , the formal limit @xmath93 in the expression for @xmath94 is meaningless . it is derived under the assumption that the condensate must be dynamical in the grounded drag case when the total current is much larger then the critical tunneling current , in order to prevent current from floating through the drag layer , as would be predicted by naive close - to - strong - coherence landauer - buttiker theory . ( see section[sec : timedepcond ] for the discussion of this point . ) we observe that @xmath95 in eq . ( [ eq : resistances ] ) is a positive non - monotonic function of parameter @xmath96 , vanishing both for @xmath97 ( strong coherence ) and @xmath93 ( weak coherence ) . it reaches a maximum of @xmath98 at @xmath99 , or @xmath100 . the positiveness of @xmath95 as defined above implies that the sign of the voltage drop in the drag layer is opposite to the sign of the longitudinal voltage in the drive layer , as found experimentally . since @xmath95 and @xmath101 depend on a single parameter , the relationship between @xmath95 and @xmath101 is universal in this simplified theory . one quantity of interest characterizing the rate at which longitudinal drags grow as the hall drag deviates from perfect quantization : @xmath102 in refs . [ ] and [ ] a maximum drag resistivity of @xmath103 was observed at the lowest temperatures ( @xmath104mk ) both by varying the total filling and by varying the effective layer distance , and the extracted slope of the parametric @xmath105 dependence was @xmath106 . so we see the in the case of aforementioned experiments the present theory predicts a longitudinal drag about twice as large as observed . the discrepancy is most likely due to the fact that in experimental systems deviations from perfect parallel transport hall conductance and loss of layer memory appear together . ( this point is discussed at greater length in the following section . ) when the ordinary hall conductance is not perfectly quantized some of the transport is able to travel from source to drain without passing the longitudinal hall voltage probes , reducing the measured voltage difference . although eqs . ( [ eq : resistances ] ) are not in quantitative agreement with experiment , they do clearly demonstrate that longitudinal drag _ must _ accompany deviations from perfect hall drag quantization . large longitudinal drags do not imply phase separation into coherent and incoherent regions , and , in our view , this macroscopic phase separation is unlikely to be present in samples studied experimentally . we note that the strong coherence limit eq . ( [ eq : condpology ] ) gives a value of tunneling conductance close to the one observed in experiment at low temperature and small @xmath58(e.g . in refs . [ ] and [ ] ) . however , the conductance deteriorates much faster with decreasing coherence than predicted by eq . ( [ eq : condpology]),when the value of @xmath96 is taken from hall drag measurements . ( this dependence is reported in ref . this may indicate that the critical current has decreased to a value smaller than the smallest measurement current levels used in these experiments . in ref . [ ] a rectangular sample was used , and the longitudinal and drag resistivities per square , @xmath107 and @xmath108 ( @xmath109 and @xmath79 being the width and length of the active area ) were reported . for the sample studied @xmath110 . the explicit expressions for resistances for this case are not very instructive so we present our findings graphically , comparing the parameter - free implicit dependence of @xmath111 on @xmath112 predicted here , with the experimental results reported in ref . [ ] and with the theoretical results in ref . [ ] . we note that close to the strong coherence limit ( @xmath113 ) and at low temperatures our curve appears to be close to the one observed in experiment , whereas at higher temperatures the one predicted by stern and halperin@xcite is a good match , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : resistances ] ( note a change in the sign convention for the hall drag resistance ) . in the experiment of ref . [ ] the spontaneous coherence state is destroyed by changing filling factor , rather than effective layer separation . we still apply our contact model to predict the outcome of four - probe measurements though , as discussed in section [ sec : lb ] . on @xmath112 . solid lines represent the experimental data of ref . [ ] , where the filling fraction was varied from @xmath114 to @xmath115 . the maximum in the longitudinal resistivity at low temperatures is reached around @xmath116 the dotted line corresponds to the semicircle law of ref . [ ] , the dashed line is the prediction of this paper . ] we can conclude from this analysis that the presence of a non - zero longitudinal drag and an imperfectly quantized hall drag alone do not necessarily imply that inter - layer coherence is lost over a large fraction of the sample area . in this section we present a theoretical estimate of the value of layer - memory - loss length , @xmath66 , introduced in the previous section , that is based on a highly simplified model of electron propagation along the edge and intended to capture the essential roles of layer asymmetric disorder and interlayer coherence . we map the problem of transport electrons propagating along an edge onto that of bilayer electrons in a single chiral charge - carrying channel which propagates at the magnetoplasmon velocity , @xmath117 . layer antisymmetric disorder and interlayer coherence are taken into account by fields that act on the @xmath118 and @xmath119 components of the _ which layer _ pseudospin degree - of - freedom . the schrdinger equation for the problem reads @xmath120 where , as before , @xmath59 is the coordinate along the edge . without loss of generality , we can assume that the part of the exchange field due to the interlayer coherence has only a @xmath121 component and for simplicity we take it to be spatially independent . the @xmath122 term in eq . ( [ eq:1dse ] ) accounts for the difference between the disorder potentials in the two layers ; we assume that @xmath123 changes sign on the disorder correlation length scale @xmath124 , which is usually assumed to be comparable to the distance to the dopant layer and therefore much longer than a magnetic length . because it is first order in derivatives , eq . ( [ eq:1dse ] ) maps to the time dependent schrdinger equation for a local spin in a time dependent magnetic field with components @xmath125 . for weak coherence , the regime of present interest , @xmath126 , so that the _ local _ eigenstates of eq . ( [ eq:1dse ] ) correspond to a definite layer index almost everywhere in space ( or at almost all times in the local spin mapping ) , except for branching points at which the disorder potential changes its sign . near such points , we can map eq . ( [ eq:1dse ] ) to the well - known landau - zener problem,@xcite in which an electron has a probability to follow the instantaneous trajectory ( _ i.e. _ retain its layer index ) and a probability of following the adiabatic path under the influence of @xmath127 , changing its layer index . the large value of @xmath117 favors the former process can be dominant and prevent an electron from losing its layer memory . at each landau - zener branching point , _ i.e. _ each instantaneous level crossing , the probability to follow the nonadiabatic path and stay in the same layer is @xmath128 correspondingly , the probability to stay on the adiabatic path is @xmath129 , which would mean retaining the layer index . we introduce probabilities @xmath130 for an electron to be in the locally high and low energy states in a region where @xmath131 after @xmath132 landau - zener branching events . using the branching rules we find that these probabilities satisfy @xmath133 it follows that the transport quasiparticle layer polarization @xmath134 satisfies @xmath135 in the continuum limit . we identify the layer - memory loss length with the characteristic length which emerges from this analysis of polarization decay : @xmath136 since the edge magnetoplasmon velocity in large hall bar samples@xcite has a logarithmic enhancement related to the long - range of the coulomb interaction @xmath137 . furthermore @xmath72 can be @xmath138 due to weakened screening on hall plateaus , whereas @xmath127 has a maximum value @xmath138 when coherence is complete . from these estimates it is clear that the layer memory length on the right hand side of eq . ( [ eq : memorylength ] ) must become large as interlayer coherence is weakened , leading to longitudinal and hall voltages whenever current source or drain contacts are layer selective as explained in the previous section . these layer memory effects can in principle be separated experimentally from normal deviations from perfect quantum hall effects , also expected to become stronger when coherence weakens , by comparing measurements made with layer selective and non - selective source and drain contacts . in this article we have developed a landauer - buttiker description of quasiparticle transport in separately - contacted bilayer quantum hall superfluids . for well developed condensates we first assume that current is carried between leads by a conducting channel consisting of quasiparticles that occupy both layers simultaneously and have inter - layer phase coherence . when this assumption applies , voltages measured along the sample edge have the same value for probes that contact both layers and probes that contact either of the individual layers . we refer to this regime as the _ strong coherence _ regime . we show that two - probe conductances are then dependent on the three independent landauer - buttiker scattering probabilities that characterize the link between two - layer leads and the condensate edge . assuming that all contacts to the system are identical , these three parameters can be determined by separate two - probe conductance measurements for parallel , drag , and tunnel contacting geometries . the two - probe linear conductance values predicted in this approach tend to range from @xmath139 to @xmath140 depending on the contacting geometry and the contact scattering properties . indeed these values appear to be generally consistent with coherent bilayer experiments performed at low temperature and small @xmath58 values.@xcite at higher temperatures and larger @xmath58 conductances tend to decrease . a part of the decrease is readily accounted for by deviations from a perfect quantum hall effect due to scattering across the bulk of the sample , which is always present at finite temperature and beyond the scope of the present theory . tunnel conductances decrease more rapidly than parallel transport or two - probe drive - layer conductances in drag experiments however . this observation points to the development of layer memory in quasiparticle transport . we have therefore elaborated our strong coherence scattering formalism to allow for layer memory , which we relate microscopically to disorder at the edge and resulting evanescent transport in the pair - breaking bilayer edge - state channel . this picture leads to a layer memory length which is proportional to @xmath141 , where @xmath127 is the bulk quasiparticle gap of the coherent state . in addition to accounting for two - point tunnel geometry conductances that are much smaller than @xmath140 , this analysis shows that longitudinal drag voltages and deviations from quantized hall drag voltages develop when layer memory lengths become comparable to distances between contacts . we refer to this circumstance as the _ weak coherence _ regime . in this way we are able to establish a relationship between hall drag voltages and the longitudinal drag voltages which appear at weak coherence which is qualitatively consistent with experiment.@xcite this picture also accounts for the sign of the longitudinal drag voltage which is opposite to the sign of the longitudinal voltages in the drive layer . we have considered the transport properties of coherent bilayers in both time - independent condensate , and time - dependent condensate ( interlayer current above the critical tunneling current ) cases . in either regime measured voltages reflect the properties of fermionic quasiparticle waves at the interface between the sample and bilayer leads . when the condensate is time - dependent , differences between chemical potentials measured by leads attached to different layers can reflect mainly this time dependence , and therefore the physics which controls its value in a particular geometry . generally , the phase variation rate assumes a value sufficient to pump the required amount of current between layers via external electrical connections between layers , via inelastic quasiparticle tunneling between layers ( the mechanism which appears to dominate experimentally at large bias voltage ) , or via local dynamic fluctuations of the condensate ( as in the model used by hyart and rosenow,@xcite discussed further below ) . in some cases a finite phase variation rate is necessary to make sure that current _ does not _ flow between layers , as in the grounded drag configuration discussed in section [ sec : timedepcond ] of this paper . before comparing the present considerations to related theoretical work , we would like to point out that a substantial part of the literature on the transport anomalies of coherent quantum hall bilayers addresses tunneling@xcite and drag@xcite experiments separately . in our view , an adequate understanding of the superfluid transport anomalies can be achieved only by describing all possible transport measurements within the same framework . this point is emphasized further below . one approach that is usually applied only to tunneling experiments accounts for collective fluctuations of bosonic particle - hole pairs.@xcite these theories assume that tunneling can be treated as a weak perturbative correction to a condensate with an interlayer phase precessing at an average rate proportional to the inter - layer potential @xmath142 , _ i.e. _ @xmath143 . this picture is close to the one we employ when the tunneling current is much larger than its critical value , except that the fermionic quasiparticle degrees of freedom on which we focus do not appear explicitly . we return to this point below . a perturbative treatment of tunneling can be valid only when the system does not possess _ spontaneous _ long - range order . indeed the absence of spontaneous long range order , even at @xmath11 , appears likely in this system because of the presence of meron condensate textures that are known to be induced by potential fluctuations . a recent careful examination of a large body of experimental data by hyart and rosenow@xcite has shown that tunneling and closely related loop counterflow tunneling experiments can be accounted for by a weak - tunneling bosonic picture with phenomenological phase correlation lengths and times , presumed to be related respectively to the typical distance between merons and the time scale of their fluctuations . this picture leads to a non - linear bilayer tunneling i(v ) curve with a characteristic current scale @xmath144 proportional to the bare tunneling amplitude @xmath145 , a maximum differential conductance at zero bias that is proportional to @xmath146 , where @xmath147 is the phase fluctuation correlation time , and a region of sharply negative differential resistance . in comparison , the picture which underlies the present work is one in which the characteristic current is a critical current below which the condensate is time - independent , and the differential conductance at zero bias is limited by quasiparticle scattering properties to values below around @xmath148 in the strong coherence regime and to smaller values in the weak coherence regime . we will argue below that the characteristic current scale should be the same size in both pictures . nevertheless it should be possible to distinguish the two pictures experimentally . as we have previously emphasized,@xcite we have assumed that the condensate can be time - independent if the net current carried between layers inside the active region of the coherent bilayer is sufficiently small . when the condensate is time - independent , voltage measurements reflect only elastic quasiparticle scattering rates . for example all drag transport measurements ( including drag - counterflow@xcite ) in which there is no net current flow between layers can be consistently understood in terms of the scattering properties of quasiparticles alone . for tunneling , series counterflow,@xcite and other measurements in which there is net current - flow between layers , the condensate can be static only if the supercurrent injected into the sample by andreev quasiparticle scattering can be sunk by time - independent coherent condensate tunneling . the critical current in essence@xcite is the maximum possible value of @xmath149 where @xmath150 is the full sample area . here @xmath132 is the condensate density which is equal to @xmath151 in the absence of disorder and quantum fluctuations . it is quite clear that the experimental critical currents , if non - zero , are much smaller than the value which would be obtained using this value of @xmath132 and setting @xmath152 everywhere . it is natural to ascribe the large reduction in critical currents to the presence of the merons,@xcite which are known ( see refs . [ ] and [ ] and references therein ) to be induced by disorder in coherent bilayers and assumed to be present in all experimental samples . since the phase of the condensate winds by @xmath153 around a meron core , setting the spatially average value of @xmath154 , it is clear that the presence of merons will drastically influence the critical current . it seems clear that the presence of disorder in bilayers implies that long - range spontaneous phase order is not present even at @xmath11 . as first emphasized in ref . [ ] , and later detailed in ref . [ ] , the evolution of transport anomalies with in - plane fields suggests a correlation length @xmath155 , possibly related to the distance between merons , which is comparable to the spatial separation distance between the bilayer and the set - back dopant layer . long - range phase order will , however , certainly be induced in response to the non - zero inter - layer tunneling amplitude present in every sample . assuming that the degree of long - range order is determined by a balance between the coupling of the condensate to inter - layer tunneling , and the exchange fields associated with meron - induced condensate phase variation , we conclude that the effective condensate density is reduced from its uniform system value by a factor of @xmath156 , where @xmath157 is the condensate stiffness . with this modification @xmath158 in eq . ( [ eq : isink ] ) gives as a critical current , the same characteristic interlayer current value that emerges from the perturbative condensate tunneling theory . we remark that this critical current estimate is not sensitive to the detailed meron - core configuration , so thermal or quantum fluctuations in meron positions will produce small relative fluctuations in critical current values . in summary , the transport anomalies of coherent quantum hall bilayers are similar to those of superconductors connected to normal metal leads , but are enriched by the possibility of contacting the two - layers separately , and by the presence of processes including transport through external conducting links , which violate separate particle - number conservation in the two layers . this paper describes a conceptual framework for describing these anomalies which combines a landauer - buttiker picture of quasiparticle transport with a description of pseudospin - pumping by time - dependent condensates . coherent bilayers are very sensitive to disorder because it tends to induce merons ( vortices ) in the order - parameter field and limit the maximum counterflow supercurrents which can be sunk by coherent interlayer tunneling . we have argued that critical currents remain finite even when merons are present because of the distortion of meron configurations by inter - layer tunneling . the authors acknowledge helpful interactions with w. dietsche , p. r. eastham , j. p. eisenstein , a. d. k. finck , b. i. halperin , k. von klitzing , b. rozenow , l. tiemann , e. tutuc , and y. yoon . we are grateful to j.p . eisenstein , a. d. k. finck , and e. tutuc for providing their experimental data . p - ology _ discussion in section [ sec : pology ] elaborates on ideas developed in collaboration with j.p . this work was supported by welch foundation grant tbf1473 , and the nsf - nri swan project .
Abstract: | [
"we discuss two phenomenological descriptions of low - current transport in bilayer quantum hall system with exciton condensates , one based on a landauer - buttiker description of andreev scattering at contacts to coherent bilayers and one based on a simplified single - parameter _ p - ology _ description of the weak to strong interlayer coupling crossover . the andreev scattering phenomenology in intended to apply when the condensate is well developed and is used to predict current - voltage relationships for a variety of two contact geometries . we also apply this formalism to circumstances in which the tunnel current exceeds its critical value and the condensate is time - dependent . the _ p - ology _ approach is used to establish the universal development of large longitudinal drags , even in homogenous coherent samples , as the condensate weakens and the hall drag is reduced ."
] | 10,542 | 10,542 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the abundance - metallicity relation of low mass extremely metal - poor ( emp ) stars ( @xmath4 \la -3 $ ] ; @xmath5 \equiv \log_{10 } ( n_{\rm x}/n_{\rm y } ) - \log_{10 } ( n_{\rm x}/n_{\rm y})_\odot$ ] where @xmath6 and @xmath7 are the abundances of elements x and y , respectively ) and very metal - poor ( vmp ) stars ( @xmath8 \la -2 $ ] ) has been clarified by observations of very high quality spectra ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? this relation is expected to provide the information of supernovae ( sne ) of population ( pop ) iii ( the first generation ) massive stars ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and the first stage of galactic chemical evolution ( gce ) ( e.g. , * ? ? ? the emp stars are considered to have suffered the injection of heavy elements from one or a few sne ( e.g. , * ? ? ? a halo interstellar medium becomes gradually homogeneous with metallicity @xcite . although recent studies of the star formation in the first stage of gce have been in progress , the characteristics of first generation stars , such as initial mass function , have not been clarified . in order to clarify such characteristics , we should investigate nucleosynthesis in the candidates of the first generation stars as well as the observed variations of the abundance distributions of the emp and vmp stars . recent observations have indicated that the abundance ratios [ x / fe ] averaged in the metal - poor stars with @xmath4 \la -2 $ ] are between @xmath9 and 0.5 for most of observed elements @xcite . their scatter around the average values deduced from the new observation is much smaller than found in earlier studies . the elemental abundance distribution of the metal - poor stars is not so different from that of the solar - system composition . therefore , the small scatter is considered to suggest primordial burst of high - mass stars or the very rapid mixing of matter from different bursts of early star formation . from theoretical viewpoint , @xcite compared the pop iii hypernova ( hn ) yields with the abundance pattern of emp stars with the metallicity range @xmath10 < -3.5 $ ] in @xcite . they adopted the mixing - fallback model for the hne . the hn yields give good agreement with the observed abundances for c , na , mg , al , si , ca , ni , and zn . they also compared the pop iii sn and hn yields integrated over the salpeter initial mass function ( imf ) with the abundances of vmp stars in the metallicity range @xmath11 < -2.0 $ ] in @xcite . they reproduced the observed trends of abundance ratios for c , o , na , mg , al , si , ca , cr , ni , and zn . the sn and hn yields of n , k , sc , ti , mn , and co are short for explaining the observed yield ratios , although sc and ti may be improved in the high - entropy explosion models . the yields of mn and co may be reproduced by the modification of electron fraction @xmath12 , of which value is still uncertain in the innermost region of sne and hne . additional nucleosynthesis processes also remain open for these elements . during a sn explosion , the collapsed core becomes extremely high temperature and high density , and neutrinos are produced through pair creation . the neutrinos are almost thermalized by neutrino - nucleus scattering at the center . they pass away through the neutrino sphere with carrying the gravitational binding energy of the core . the neutrino irradiation lasts for about @xmath13 s. the total number of neutrinos emitted in a sn is very huge , i.e. , about @xmath14 . the neutrinos interact with nuclei in the surrounding stellar material to produce new species of nuclei . this is called the @xmath0-process . the @xmath0-process is expected to be an important production process for some elements in pop iii sn explosions . the @xmath0-process is important for the synthesis of light elements , li and b @xcite , f ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , and some heavy neutron - deficient nuclei such as @xmath15la and @xmath16ta @xcite . the @xmath0-process products are synthesized through the spallations by neutrinos from abundant seed nuclei . it also produces protons and neutrons and their capture reactions also enhance the abundances of some elements . for pop iii sne , the seed nuclei are @xmath17-nuclei abundantly produced in complete and incomplete si burning during the explosions . thus , the @xmath0-process in pop iii sne will produce additional some odd-@xmath1 elements . we note that most of the nucleosynthesis calculations including the @xmath0-process have been carried out using spherical explosion models @xcite . although the total neutrino energy should be close to the gravitational binding energy released from the collapsing core , properties of the neutrinos are still uncertain . the properties strongly depend on explosion mechanism but details of the mechanism have not been clarified . on the other hand , aspherical explosions have been investigated recently ( e.g. * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? in such a case , aspherical structure of neutrino sphere can be formed and the properties of the neutrinos are also still uncertain . therefore , the dependence of the abundances of pop iii sne and hne on neutrino properties should be investigated . in this study , we focus on the effect of the @xmath0-process on the production of odd-@xmath1 iron - peak elements , sc , mn , and co , during pop iii sn and hn explosions . we calculate the sn nucleosynthesis including the @xmath0-process . then , we investigate the dependence of the abundances of sc , mn , and co in the sn ejecta on the energy of neutrinos , the stellar mass , and the explosion energy . sc , mn , and co are expected to be at least partly synthesized through the @xmath0-process . we also indicate whether the abundance ratios of sc , mn , and co to fe reproduce those observed in the emp stars when we take into account the @xmath0-process . in 2 we explain stellar evolution models and the explosion models of sne and a hn . we also describe the nucleosynthesis models including the @xmath0-process and the neutrino irradiation models . in 3 we show the abundance distributions of sc , mn , and co in the ejecta of the sn and hn models . we explain additional production of these elements through the @xmath0-process . in 4 we explain the effect of the @xmath0-process on the abundance ratios of sc , mn , and co to fe and the dependence on the neutrino irradiation strength . we also compare our results with the abundance ratios observed in the emp stars . in 5 we discuss other production processes of sc , mn , and co proposed in recent studies and the effect of the @xmath0-process . finally , we summarize this study in 6 . we calculate the evolution of population iii stars for initial masses of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 from zero - age main - sequence to the onset of the core collapse . we use a henyey - type stellar evolution code including a nuclear reaction network with about 300 isotopes to calculate detailed nucleosynthesis and energy generation . the input physics is the same as the models used in @xcite . sn explosions are calculated using a hydrodynamical code of spherically symmetrical piecewise parabolic method @xcite . we set the explosion energy of the 15 and 25 @xmath2 sn models to be @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the explosion energy in units of @xmath20 ergs . we also calculate the explosion of a hn for the 25 @xmath2 star model with @xmath21 . the location of the mass cut of the sn explosions is determined as follows . for the 15 @xmath2 star model , we set the location of the mass cut at @xmath22 ( @xmath23 being the mass coordinate of a star ) to obtain the ejected @xmath24ni mass of 0.07 @xmath2 . in the case of 25 @xmath2 sn , we set the mass cut location at @xmath25 , so that large ( co , zn)/fe ratios are obtained . this location corresponds to the bottom of the layer where electron fraction @xmath12 is close to 0.5 @xcite . a large amount of @xmath24ni is produced in the region of @xmath26 ( see 3.2 for details ) . since the location of the mass cut is deep , this model ejects the @xmath24ni mass of 0.36 @xmath2 . this model corresponds to a sn with the explosion energy of @xmath27 and yielding a large @xmath24ni amount ( @xmath28(@xmath24ni)@xmath29 ) such as sn 2005bf @xcite . note that the mixing - fallback model is not applied to these cases . in the case of the 25 @xmath2 hn model , we apply the mixing - fallback model @xcite . this model approximates aspherical effects of hn explosions @xcite . during aspherical explosion , the central core of a star first collapses . then , jet - like explosion ejects the surrounding stellar materials . some of the materials in an inner region may fallback to the central core from off - axis direction of the jet . there are three parameters in the mixing - fallback model ; the initial mass cut @xmath30(ini ) , the outer boundary of the mixing region @xmath31(out ) , and the ejection factor @xmath32 . the initial mass cut corresponds to the mass of the initially collapsing core . the outer boundary of the mixing region corresponds to the location where the surrounding materials infall to the core during the explosion . the ejection fraction is the ejected material fraction in the mixing region . details of the mixing - fallback model have been described in @xcite . the values of the mixing - fallback parameters should be related to the explosion features such as asphericity and energy deposition rate @xcite . however , the explosion mechanism has not been clarified . therefore , we determine these parameter values similar to case a in @xcite . the location of the initial mass cut is set as @xmath33 , which is the bottom of the @xmath34 layer . this condition deduces large zn / fe ratio @xcite . the outer boundary of the mixing region is determined as @xmath35 where the mass fraction of @xmath24ni decreases to @xmath36 . the ejection factor is determined as @xmath37 in order to yield [ o / fe ] = 0.5 . the electron fraction in complete and incomplete si burning regions is not modified in this study . the @xmath24ni mass of each explosion model is listed in table 1 . a huge amount of neutrinos are emitted during sn explosions . for spherically symmetrical sn explosions , neutrinos are emitted isotropically from the neutrino sphere and carry the majority of gravitational energy of a proto - neutron star . on the other hand , aspherical sne and jet - like explosion would emit neutrinos anisotropically . in this case neutrino irradiation may be very strong in a specific direction . since we assume spherically symmetrical sn explosions , we assume isotropic neutrino emission . the strength of the neutrino flux is determined by the total neutrino energy . the adopted values of the total neutrino energy are @xmath38 ergs , @xmath39 ergs , and @xmath40 ergs . the first value corresponds to normal neutrino irradiation and is almost equal to the gravitational binding energy of a 1.4 @xmath2 neutron star @xcite . we assume that the neutrino luminosity decrease exponentially with time . the decay time of the neutrino luminosity is set to be 3.0 s. the spectra of the sn neutrinos are assumed to obey fermi distribution with zero chemical potentials . the temperatures of @xmath41 , @xmath42 and @xmath43 , @xmath44 are set to be @xmath45 mev/@xmath46 and 4 mev/@xmath46 , respectively . this set of the neutrino temperatures is the same as in @xcite and @xcite . we note that @xcite provided the sn yields adopting the @xmath41 and @xmath42 temperature of @xmath47 mev and @xmath48 ergs . therefore , we briefly mention the yields obtained using this parameter set . detailed nucleosynthesis during the sn explosions is calculated by postprocessing using a code of @xcite to which the @xmath0-process reactions in @xcite were added . we should note that the evolution of neutrino luminosity and energy spectra of hne may be different from that of sne . the neutrino emission from rapidly accreting disks surrounding black holes during gamma ray bursts and hne has been investigated ( e.g. , * ? ? ? they showed that @xmath49 and smaller amount of @xmath50 are mainly emitted from the accretion disks with slightly hard energy spectra compared with those from proto - neutron stars . however , the evolution of neutrino emission during hn explosions is still largely uncertain . on the other hand , the main contribution of the @xmath0-process is neutral - current interactions , which do not depend on neutrino flavors @xcite . furthermore , the yields of the @xmath0-process products depend on both neutrino energy spectra and the total neutrino energy . roughly speaking , a larger total neutrino energy corresponds to harder neutrino energy spectra @xcite . therefore , we set the total neutrino energy as a parameter . the value of total neutrino energy @xmath51 ergs may be too large even in the hn model . if an element is not produced abundantly through the @xmath0-process with @xmath51 ergs , the @xmath0-process contribution should be very small for the production of the element . ccccc no neutrinos & @xmath52 & @xmath53 & @xmath54 & @xmath55 + @xmath56 & @xmath52 & @xmath57 & @xmath58 & @xmath59 + @xmath39 & @xmath60 & @xmath61 & @xmath62 & @xmath63 + @xmath40 & @xmath64 & @xmath65 & @xmath66 & @xmath67 + @xmath56 ( @xmath68=8 mev ) & @xmath52 & @xmath69 & @xmath70 & @xmath71 + no neutrinos & @xmath72 & @xmath73 & @xmath74 & @xmath75 + @xmath56 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 + @xmath39 & @xmath80 & @xmath81 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 + @xmath40 & @xmath84 & @xmath58 & @xmath85 & @xmath86 + @xmath56 ( @xmath68=8 mev ) & @xmath76 & @xmath87 & @xmath63 & @xmath88 + no neutrinos & @xmath89 & @xmath90 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 + @xmath56 & @xmath89 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 + @xmath39 & @xmath89 & @xmath96 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 + @xmath40 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 & @xmath101 & @xmath102 + @xmath56 ( @xmath68=8 mev ) & @xmath89 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath83 + we explain the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co as well as the contribution of the @xmath0-process for their production . figure 1@xmath105 shows the distributions of the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the 15 @xmath2 sn model without taking into account the @xmath0-process . in this figure , the main product in the range of @xmath106 is @xmath24ni . in this region a large amount of iron - peak elements are produced through complete si burning . we call this region the ni layer . in the region outside the ni layer , incomplete si burning occurs during the explosion and a large amount of si as well as a smaller amount of iron - peak elements are produced . we call this region ( @xmath107 ) the si / s layer . the characteristics of the mass fractions and main production sites of sc , mn , and co without the @xmath0-process are explained as follows . 1 . small mass fraction of sc is produced at @xmath108 . the mass fraction is about @xmath109 at the maximum . most of sc is produced through incomplete si burning . most of mn is produced in the si / s layer through incomplete si burning . the mass fraction at the maximum is about @xmath110 , which is much larger than that of sc . a part of mn is also produced in the ni layer but the mass fraction is much smaller . co is also produced in the ni layer . the mass fraction of co is about @xmath111 throughout this layer . hereafter we consider the effect of the @xmath0-process on the production of sc , mn , and co. figures 1@xmath112 and 1@xmath113 show the distributions of the mass fractions taking into account the @xmath0-process with @xmath114 ergs and @xmath40 ergs , respectively . [ [ sc ] ] sc ^^ we see that additional sc is produced in the si / s layer ( @xmath115 ) and in the ni layer . the mass fraction of sc is less than @xmath109 . most of the sc is first produced as @xmath116ti and @xmath116v . in the ni layer , a large amount of @xmath117ti is produced through complete si burning . at the same time , @xmath116ti and @xmath116v are partly produced through neutron- and proton - captures of @xmath117ti . without the @xmath0-process , however , the produced @xmath116ti and @xmath116v are smoothly captured or decomposed again during the explosion . with the @xmath0-process , additional protons are produced through the @xmath0-process , so that some @xmath116v is produced again by the proton capture . [ [ mn ] ] mn ^^ we see the increase in the mass fraction of mn in the ni layer by about three orders of magnitude compared with the case without the @xmath0-process . the mass fraction in the si / s layer also increases by about a factor of 1.4 . during the sn explosion , mn is produced as @xmath118co . the amount of @xmath118mn originally produced in the sn is much smaller . in the si / s layer , @xmath118co is produced by @xmath119fe(@xmath120co or photodisintegration from @xmath24ni . when the @xmath0-process is considered , @xmath118co is also produced through @xmath24ni(@xmath121co after the production of @xmath24ni through complete and incomplete si burning . since the decay time of the neutrino luminosity is longer than the time scale of si burning , the neutrino irradiation proceeds after ceasing si burning . [ [ co ] ] co ^^ when we consider the @xmath0-process , the mass fraction of co increases by about a factor of three throughout the ni layer . the main production region of co is not changed when we consider the @xmath0-process . most of co is produced as @xmath122cu and about @xmath123 of @xmath122co is produced as @xmath122ni . we see increase in the mass fractions of @xmath122cu and @xmath122ni similarly in the ni layer . most of @xmath122cu and @xmath122ni are produced through the captures of protons and neutrons by @xmath124ni . the protons and neutrons are produced through the @xmath0-process even after the cease of complete si burning . therefore , the additional production raises the mass fraction of co. we also consider the case of larger neutrino irradiation with @xmath56 ergs . the distributions of the mass fractions are shown in fig . we see that the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the ni layer are larger by a factor of @xmath125 than those in the case of @xmath48 ergs . the dependence of the obtained mass fractions on the total neutrino energy is slightly smaller than the linear one . in this case all three elements are mainly produced in the ni layer although mn is mainly produced in the si / s layer in the case of the former cases . the mass fractions of the 25 @xmath2 sn model without the @xmath0-process is shown in fig . 2@xmath105 . in this figure , the ni layer where complete si burning occurs is in the range between @xmath126 and @xmath127 in the mass coordinate . the si / s layer which suffered incomplete si burning is between @xmath127 and @xmath128 . the ejected masses of these layers are larger than the corresponding layers in the 15 @xmath2 sn model . the distributions of the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the 25 @xmath2 sn model are roughly similar to those of the 15 @xmath2 sn model . most of sc is produced in outer part of the si / s layer ( @xmath129 ) . mn is mainly produced in the si / s layer , too . most of co is produced in the ni layer . the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co with the @xmath0-process of @xmath48 ergs are shown in fig . when we consider the @xmath0-process , their increase is seen in the ni layer . for sc , the mass fraction reaches about @xmath130 . it is about @xmath131 for mn but the main mn production is still in the si / s layer . increase in the abundance by the @xmath0-process is seen in the si / s layer . for co , the abundance increases by about a factor of two . the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in the case of a larger neutrino irradiation ( @xmath51 ergs ) are shown in fig . we obtain larger ones for sc , mn , and co. the mass fraction of sc in the ni layer is about @xmath132 , which is larger than that of the 15 @xmath2 sn . for mn and co , the abundances in the ni layer are close to those of the 15 @xmath2 sn . the increase in the mn abundance in the si / s layer is also seen . we explain effects of the @xmath0-process on the production in the 25 @xmath2 hn model with @xmath133 . figure 3@xmath105 shows the distribution of the mass fractions in the 25 @xmath2 hn model without the @xmath0-process . the mass coordinate ranges of the ni and si / s layers are @xmath134 and @xmath135 , respectively . the mass contained in each of the two layers for the 25 @xmath2 hn is larger than that of the corresponding layer of the 25 @xmath2 sn model . we see that the mass fractions of sc , mn , and co in each burning region are not so different from those in the 25 @xmath2 sn ; most of sc and mn are produced in the si / s layer and co is produced in the ni layer . the average value of the co mass fraction in the ni layer is larger than that in the 25 @xmath2 sn . the distribution of the mass fractions in the 25 @xmath2 hn model with the @xmath0-process ( @xmath48 ergs ) is shown in fig . 3@xmath112 . increase in the mass fraction by the @xmath0-process is mainly seen for sc and mn . as shown in the cases of the sne , additional sc is produced in the ni layer . in addition , some mn is also produced in there . since the range of the ni layer is large , the contribution from the ni layer is larger than that from the si / s layer in this case . on the other hand , clear effect of the @xmath0-process is not seen for co. figure 3@xmath113 shows the mass fractions in the 25 @xmath2 hn model with larger neutrino irradiation ( @xmath51 ergs ) . as same as the sn case , the sc abundance in the ni layer is larger by about a factor of ten than that in the case of the normal neutrino irradiation ( @xmath48 ergs ) . the mass fraction of mn is similarly larger . in the si / s layer , the mn amount also increases . on the other hand , the mass fraction of co does not so change even with large neutrino irradiation . co is produced through complete si burning in the ni layer and most of it is not decomposed during the explosion . since hne produce large amount of co even without neutrino irradiation @xcite , the additional production through the @xmath0-process hardly affects the co production . we have shown that some amounts of sc , mn , and co are produced through the @xmath0-process and the following capture reactions of neutrons and protons . this additional production increases the total abundances of these elements in pop iii sn and hn explosions . hereafter we show the distributions of abundance ratios in the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 sn and the 25 @xmath2 hn models . we also compare our results with the observed abundances of low mass emp stars . as a reference of the observed abundances , we use the abundance ratios to fe averaged in the data of 22 low mass halo stars with [ fe / h ] @xmath136 in @xcite . we show the abundance ratios in the 15 @xmath2 sn model in fig . the ratios of [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] are listed in table 1 . the abundance ratios of the three elements are much smaller than the corresponding solar ratios . for other elements , the abundance ratios of odd-@xmath1 elements are smaller than those of the even-@xmath1 elements in the neighbors . when we consider the @xmath0-process , the ratios [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] increase by @xmath137 dex ( see table 1 ) . thus , the @xmath0-process raises the abundances of these elements . since the fe abundance is not altered by the @xmath0-process , the increase in the abundance ratios is due to the increase in the abundances by the @xmath0-process . larger irradiation of neutrinos enhances the abundances of these elements . in the case of @xmath40 ergs , the abundance ratios for mn and co are larger than the corresponding solar ratios ( see table 1 and fig . the abundance ratios of v , mn , and co are larger than those of the even-@xmath1 elements ti , cr , and fe , respectively . we see that [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] for @xmath138 ergs and @xmath40 ergs increase by @xmath139 dex and @xmath140 dex , respectively , compared with those with @xmath48 ergs . the total neutrino energies with @xmath141 ergs and @xmath40 ergs are three times and ten times larger than that with @xmath142 ergs . simple consideration leads to that the abundances of odd-@xmath1 elements produced through the @xmath0-process are proportional to the neutrino flux , i.e. , the total neutrino energy . numerical simulations of the @xmath0-process show that this property is approximately correct . the reaction rates of the @xmath0-process are proportional to the total neutrino energy . at the same time , production rates of protons and neutrons produced through the @xmath0-process are also proportional to the total neutrino energy . the increase in the production rates brings about the increase in the production of odd-@xmath1 elements through proton- and neutron - captures . however , decomposition rates of the odd-@xmath1 elements through proton- and neutron - captures also increase . thus , the abundances produced through the @xmath0-process increase less than proportional to the total neutrino energy . we compare the obtained [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] with the corresponding observed results . the observed [ sc / fe ] averaged in 22 low mass emp stars is 0.06 . this value is slightly larger than the solar ratio and is still much larger than the calculated abundance ratio even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation . for mn , the observed [ mn / fe ] is @xmath143 . this abundance ratio is larger than the ratio without the @xmath0-process and is reproduced by the result with the @xmath0-process of the normal neutrino irradiation ( @xmath48 ergs ) . on the other hand , the mn / fe ratio in the case of @xmath51 ergs is much larger than the largest value in the observed ratios . the observed [ co / fe ] is 0.31 , which is larger than the solar ratio . it is larger than the value in the sn model even with the largest neutrino irradiation . figure 5 shows the abundance ratios of the 25 @xmath2 sn model . when we do not consider the @xmath0-process , the abundance ratios of sc , mn , and co are much smaller than the corresponding solar ratios ( see also table 1 ) . the @xmath0-process also enhances the production of these elements . when we consider the @xmath0-process , the sc / fe ratio in this model is larger than that in the 15 @xmath2 sn model . this is because the seed nucleus of @xmath116v , i.e. , @xmath117ti , is abundantly produced in complete si burning for the 25 @xmath2 sn . however , the sc / fe ratio is smaller than the observed ratio even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation . on the other hand , the mn / fe ratio in this model well reproduces the observed ratio in the case with the @xmath0-process of normal neutrino irradiation . the model with the largest neutrino irradiation ( @xmath51 ergs ) overproduces mn . the observed co / fe ratio is reproduced by the 25 @xmath2 sn model with the largest neutrino irradiation @xmath51 ergs ; large neutrino irradiation is required similarly to the 15 @xmath2 sn case . figure 6 shows the distribution of the abundance ratios of the 25 @xmath2 hn model with @xmath144 . in this model we considered mixing - fallback as described in 2.1 . when we do not consider the @xmath0-process , the [ sc / fe ] and [ mn / fe ] are @xmath145 and @xmath146 , respectively ( see also table 1 ) . the mn / fe ratio is much smaller than the corresponding ratios in the other two models . mn is mainly produced in the si / s layer without the @xmath0-process ( see fig . 3@xmath105 ) , whereas the range of the ni layer in the hn is larger than in the 25 @xmath2 sn . on the other hand , the co / fe is larger than those in the other sn models ( see also table 1 ) . as shown in fig . 3@xmath105 , the hn provides a large amount of co through complete si burning . the mass fraction of co in the ni layer is of order @xmath147 for the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 sn models , and @xmath148 for the 25 @xmath2 hn . when we consider the @xmath0-process , the abundance ratios of sc and mn increase with the total neutrino energy . however , the co abundance scarcely changes even taking into account the @xmath0-process . the @xmath0-process raises the abundances of sc and mn in the ni layer . although it also enhances the co abundance there , the contribution from the @xmath0-process is hindered by large co production through complete si burning . we also compare our results with the observed ones . the obtained sc / fe ratio is smaller than the observed ratio . even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation , the abundance ratio is smaller by about 0.5 dex . the mn / fe ratio is marginally consistent with the observed ratio in the largest neutrino irradiation case . at the same time , the co / fe ratio is also marginally consistent with the observed ratio despite the @xmath0-process ; the smallest co / fe ratio is reproduced . the hn model reproduces the observed mn / fe ratio when the @xmath0-process with large neutrino irradiation is taken into account . it reproduces the observed co / fe ratio even without the @xmath0-process . when we do not consider the @xmath0-process , the abundance ratios of sc / fe , mn / fe , and co / fe in the pop iii sne are smaller than the corresponding observed ratios . on the other hand , the observed mn / fe ratio is reproduced by the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 sn models with the @xmath0-process . the observed co / fe ratio is marginally reproduced by the 25 @xmath2 hn model even without neutrino irradiation . thus , we can say that the @xmath0-process in the pop iii sne produce most of mn observed in low mass emp stars . the @xmath0-process also produces sc but the abundance is still short of the reproduction of the observed sc / fe ratios . hne may provide co being abundant enough to reproduce the observed co / fe ratios . we briefly mention the abundance ratios in the case of the @xmath0-process with @xmath47 mev and @xmath48 ergs , which has been adopted in @xcite . the abundance patterns in the 15 and 25 @xmath2 sn and the 25 @xmath2 hn models are shown as dotted lines in figs . the values of [ sc / fe ] , [ mn / fe ] , and [ co / fe ] are tabulated in table 1 . the yields of sc , mn , and co in this neutrino parameter set are larger by about 0.1 dex than those in the case of @xmath45 mev . they are still smaller than those in the case of @xmath45 mev and @xmath150 ergs . therefore , the dependence on the neutrino temperature is not strong for the sc , mn , and co yields . the abundance pattern of vmp stars are considered to reflect partly mixed interstellar materials in the early universe . recently , the averaged abundance pattern of vmp stars with @xmath11 < -2.0 $ ] in @xcite has been reproduced by the pop iii sn and hn yields integrated over the salpeter imf function @xcite . however , the evaluated [ sc / fe ] and [ mn / fe ] are still short of the observed ratio . we discuss the enhancement of these ratios by the @xmath0-process . @xcite evaluated the sc / fe ratio as [ sc / fe ] = @xmath151 whereas the observed value is [ sc / fe ] = @xmath152 . in this study , we showed that the @xmath0-process raises the sc yield by 1.1 dex at the maximum . however , this enhancement is still short for reproducing the observed value . production sites other than the @xmath0-process is needed to reproduce it ( see 5.2 ) . the [ mn / fe ] ratio observed in vmp stars is @xmath153 . the evaluated value of [ mn / fe ] is @xmath154 . when we take into account the @xmath0-process , this value increases by @xmath155 dex with @xmath48 ergs and @xmath156 dex with @xmath150 ergs . the increase by the @xmath0-process with @xmath157 ergs will provide better fitting of the pop iii sn and hn yields to [ mn / fe ] in vmp stars . the pop iii sn and hn models in @xcite indicate [ co / fe ] close to the lowest ratio in vmp stars ; [ co / fe ] = @xmath158 . taking into account the @xmath0-process with @xmath48 ergs , [ co / fe ] increases by @xmath159 dex in sne and it does not in hne . this enhancement is enough to reproduce the average [ co / fe ] ratio in vmp stars . the @xmath0-process of the pop iii sne and hne is one of the preferable sites of the mn and co in vmp stars . we have shown that sc , mn , and co are produced through the @xmath0-process in the pop iii sne and hne . for other than mn , the @xmath0-process in the sne and hne does not produce large enough abundances to reproduce the abundances observed in low mass emp stars . so , we will discuss other synthesis processes proposed in recent studies . [ [ sc-1 ] ] sc ^^ _ aspherical explosions _ as shown in previous studies ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) , spherically symmetrical sn and hn models do not provide enough amount of sc to reproduce the observed abundance of low mass emp stars . on the other hand , aspherical explosion and jet - like explosion produce larger amount of sc @xcite . in the case of spherical explosions , low - density structure enables to supply larger amount of sc @xcite . thus , higher temperature and low density , which are realized by aspherical explosions , are one of the favorable environments to produce sc . the amount of sc produced in sne and hne is also sensitive to @xmath12 in complete si burning region . large @xmath12 value ( @xmath160 ) brings about a large amount of sc @xcite . _ nucleosynthesis in innermost region of sne _ detailed thermal evolution of the innermost region of sn ejecta , i.e. , the neighbor of the `` mass cut has not been solved strictly . however , recent progress of hydrodynamical calculations has gradually revealed thermal evolution in such a deep region . at the same time , detailed nucleosynthesis in such a deep region has also been investigated . @xcite investigated the nucleosynthesis in convective bubbles in the innermost region of sn ejecta and in early stage of neutrino - driven winds . they used results of two - dimensional hydrodynamical calculations by @xcite . @xcite examined the simulations of one - dimensional self - consistent treatment of core - collapse sne with modified neutrino cross sections to explode . they also investigated the nucleosynthesis in the innermost region just above the mass cut produced self - consistently . both of the studies showed that the electron fraction @xmath12 exceeds 0.5 in such regions , which enhances the production of sc . in the latter study , they took into account all charged - current weak - interactions that changes @xmath12 in the ejecta . they obtained that the amount of sc with @xmath161 is produced in the innermost region with @xmath160 . the sc / fe ratio evaluated in their study is slightly smaller than the averaged abundances observed in low mass emp stars @xcite . thus , the sc / fe ratio is larger than our result . they also showed that a significant amount of nuclei with mass of @xmath162 in this region , especially light @xmath163-nuclei such as @xmath164mo and @xmath165ru ( the @xmath166-process ; * ? ? ? * ) . it is noted that the region of @xmath160 is convectively unstable so that the region will mix with outer smaller @xmath12 region in dynamical time scale . however , they expected that the @xmath12 remains high in an average sense . indeed , the former study took into account the convection in two - dimensional simulations and obtained @xmath160 . we also note that neutral - current @xmath0-process reactions were not included in @xcite . they also pointed out that neutrino - induced spallation reactions can change the final abundances of some nuclei . we expect that these reactions enhance the abundance of sc and that the sc / fe ratio becomes close to the observed ratio . it is also noted that materials blown off in neutrino - driven winds in early time after a sn explosion can achieve large @xmath12 value . accordingly , the @xmath167-process can take place in the materials . this synthetic process is strongly preferable for the production of the light @xmath163-nuclei @xcite . however , the contribution of the @xmath167-process in neutrino - driven winds to sc production is small . [ [ mn-1 ] ] mn ^^ the amount of mn produced in sne and hne is strongly sensitive to electron fraction @xmath12 in incomplete si burning region @xcite . their hn models modifying @xmath12 value to @xmath168 produce enough amount of mn to reproduce the observed one in low mass emp stars . however , hn models , whose @xmath12 in incomplete si burning region is not modified , indicated that the amount of mn is less than the observed value . aspherical explosions suppress mn production @xcite . we have shown that the mn production during sn explosions is mainly due to the @xmath0-process rather than to the incomplete si burning . the @xmath0-process with normal neutrino irradiation ( @xmath48 ergs ) in sne reproduces the mn / fe ratio averaged in low mass emp stars even without @xmath12 modifications . in the case of @xmath150 ergs , the mn amount marginally reproduces the upper limit of the observed mn abundance . in the case of @xmath51 ergs , however , the sn models overproduce mn . thus , the @xmath0-process in the pop iii sne is one of the main production processes of mn observed in low mass emp stars . the observed abundance constrains the total neutrino energy @xmath169 in sne . the observational constraint is @xmath170 ergs . [ [ co-1 ] ] co ^^ a large amount of co can be produced through complete si burning in aspherical explosion @xcite . for spherical explosions , @xcite pointed out that the co abundance is significantly enhanced for @xmath160 in the case of hne . however , the co / fe ratio in @xcite is still smaller than the observed ratio in @xcite . their model corresponds to a normal sn explosion . therefore , hne ( @xmath171 ) with @xmath172 produce co of which amount reproduces observed co / fe ratio in low mass emp stars . neutral - current @xmath0-process reactions may help additional production in the deep region just above the mass cut . however , in the case of hne , large amount of protons are also produced through @xmath17-rich freeze out . this effect may hinder the proton production by the @xmath0-process . the nucleosynthesis in pop iii sne have been conducted in several groups . here , we briefly compare with the abundances of sc , mn , and co of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 pop iii sn models in @xcite , hereafter abbreviated to ww95 , ( z15a and z25b models ) and in @xcite , abbreviated to cl04 . the sn nucleosynthesis models in ww95 include the @xmath0-process . the temperature of @xmath41 in ww95 is assumed to be 8 mev , which is larger than the one adopted in this study . the sn nucleosynthesis with updated physics inputs of ww95 has been shown in @xcite but the pop iii sn nucleosynthesis has not been calculated . the nucleosynthesis models in cl04 do not include the @xmath0-process . the explosion models in cl04 were set to be the ejected mass of @xmath24ni equal to 0.1 @xmath2 . @xcite indicate [ sc / fe]=@xmath98 for @xmath173 model ; the sc / fe is much larger than our result . on the other hand , cl04 indicates sc / fe slightly larger than our results of sn models without the @xmath0-process ( [ sc / fe]=@xmath174 for 25 @xmath2 model ) . although the sc / fe in ww95 is much larger than the other models , it is still smaller than the observed ratio . therefore , other synthesis processes such as discussed above are necessary for sc production . the mn / fe shown in ww95 is smaller than the observed ratio ( [ mn / fe]@xmath175 ) . the 15 @xmath2 model in cl04 also indicates the mn / fe smaller than the observed one ( [ mn / fe]@xmath176 ) . the 25 @xmath2 model in cl04 indicates larger mn / fe ratio , which is comparable to the observed one ( [ mn / fe]@xmath177 ) . we showed that the @xmath0-process increases the mn abundance , but difference of stellar evolution models may affect the abundance . the 15 @xmath2 models of ww95 and cl04 show [ co / fe ] of @xmath178 and @xmath179 , which are larger than the ratio of our sn models . their 25 @xmath2 models indicate the co / fe similar to our results without the @xmath0-process . the evaluated co / fe ratios are still short of the observed ratio , so that hne will have an important role for co production in the early universe . among li , be , and b , @xmath180li and @xmath181b are mainly produced through the @xmath0-process . when the @xmath0-process is not considered , the li / fe and b / fe ratios are much smaller than the corresponding solar ratio . sn explosions with the neutrinos of @xmath182 ergs bring about li yield ratio of [ li / fe ] @xmath183 . they also produce b of which yield ratio to fe is larger than the solar ratio . therefore , sn explosions may contribute to the b production in the early universe . the @xmath180li is mainly produced as @xmath180be in the he - rich region . the @xmath181b is produced as @xmath181c and @xmath181b in c - enriched oxygen layer and c - enriched he layer . the li and b production in hne is less effective than that in sne . higher maximum temperature in the he layer decomposes @xmath180be and @xmath181c produced through the @xmath0-process and the following @xmath17-captures . in addition , strong explosion makes the region of c - rich oxygen layer small . [ [ f ] ] f ^ the @xmath0-process is a main f production process in sne @xcite . the f / fe ratio including the @xmath0-process is much larger than the one without the @xmath0-process . the seed nucleus of f in the @xmath0-process is @xmath184ne . most of f is produced in o and ne - enriched region . stellar mass dependence of the f / fe ratio is small in the sn models . on the other hand , the hn model shows smaller f / fe ratio . the hn explosion brings about stronger explosive ne burning , so that the o and ne - enriched region becomes smaller . figures @xmath149 show that the @xmath0-process scarcely affects the yields of na and al . furthermore , the yield ratios are much smaller than the observed ratios even in the case of the largest neutrino irradiation . although the @xmath0-process enhances the abundances of na and al in incomplete si burning region , na and al are mainly produced in carbon and neon shells . the yields produced in the outer two shells strongly depend on the nucleosynthesis in stellar evolution . @xcite successfully reproduced relatively large [ na / fe ] and [ al / fe ] observed in two hyper - metal - poor stars . they considered that the effect of overshooting during presn evolution and extensive matter mixing and fallback during sn explosions with small explosion energies . [ [ v ] ] v ^ vanadium is mainly produced as @xmath185mn in incomplete si burning region in sne . in the case of the hn model , it is mainly produced in complete si burning region . additional production through the @xmath0-process from @xmath186fe in incomplete si burning region contributes to the enhancement of v in sne . low metallicity stars with @xmath187 } \la -2 $ ] indicate the v abundance ratios of @xmath188 } \la 0.6 $ ] ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? the average abundance ratio is reproduced by the 15 and 25 @xmath2 sn models with the @xmath0-process of @xmath189 ergs . in order to reproduce the v / fe ratios , strong neutrino irradiation in the sne is favored . in the case of the hn model , v is also produced through the @xmath0-process . however , the produced abundance is much smaller than that produced in complete si burning region . the chemical compositions of low mass emp stars are expected to be injected from one or a few sn or hn explosions evolved from population iii massive stars . the abundance ratios of odd-@xmath1 elements to fe observed in these stars are close to the corresponding solar ratios . on the other hand , the abundances produced in complete and incomplete si burning in sn explosion models are still in short . in this study , we investigated the @xmath0-process of odd-@xmath1 iron - peak elements , sc , mn , and co , in the sn and hn explosions of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 pop iii stars . then , we compared the abundance ratios of these elements in the sn and hn models with those observed in the emp stars . the obtained results are summarized as follows . 1 . sc , mn , and co are produced through the @xmath0-process and the following capture reactions of protons and neutrons in complete and incomplete si burning region of pop iii sne . the produced amounts of these elements are roughly proportional to the total neutrino energy . 2 . the observed mn / fe ratio averaged in low mass emp stars is reproduced by the 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 pop iii sn models with the @xmath0-process . therefore , the @xmath0-process in pop iii sne is one of the main synthesis processes of mn observed in low mass emp stars . the observed mn abundance constrains the total neutrino energy to @xmath170 ergs . this @xmath169 value is roughly consistent with the gravitational binding energy of a typical neutron star . in the case of the 25 @xmath2 pop iii hn model , large neutrino irradiation enables to reproduce the observed mn / fe ratio . 3 . the observed co / fe ratio is reproduced by the sn models . however , required total neutrino energy is @xmath190 ergs , which is larger than typical value of the gravitational binding energy of a proto - neutron star . complete si burning in pop iii hne should be favorable to co production rather than the @xmath0-process of sne and hne . although larger amount of sc is produced through the @xmath0-process , the sc / fe ratio is still smaller than the ratio observed in low mass emp stars . explosive nucleosynthesis during aspherical explosions and in a deep region just above the mass cut would be favorable to produce sc and co. the @xmath0-process and the capture reactions of protons and neutrons may also enhance the production of sc , mn , and co in these environments . we would like to thank anonymous referee for valuable comments . numerical computations were in part carried out on general common use computer system at astronomical data analysis center ( adac ) of national astronomical observatory of japan . this work has been supported in part by the ministry of education , culture , sports , science and technology , grants - in - aid for young scientist ( b ) ( 17740130 ) , and scientific research ( s ) ( 18104003 ) , ( c ) ( 16540229 , 18540231 ) . t.y . was supported by the 21st century coe program `` exploring new science by bridging particle - matter hierarchy in graduate school of science , tohoku university . argast , d. , samland , m. , gerhard , o. e. , & thielemann , f .- k . 2004 , , 356 , 873 cayrel , r. , et al . 2004 , , 416 , 1117 chieffi , a. & limongi , m. 2004 , , 608 , 405 colella , p. & woodward , p. r. 1984 , j. comput . phys . , 54 , 174 domogatsky , g. v. , eramzhyan , r. a. , & nadyozhin , d. k. 1978 , in neutrino physics and neutrino astrophysics , ed . m. a. markov et al . ( moscow : nauka ) , 115 frhlich , c. , et al . 2006a , , 637 , 415 frhlich , c. , martnez - pinedo , g. , liebendrfer , m. , thielemann , f .- k . , bravo , e. , hix , w. r. , langanke , k. , & zinner , n. t. 2006b , , 96 , 142502 goriely , s. , arnould , m. , borzov , i. , & rayet , m. 2001 , , 375 , l35 heger , a. , kolbe , e. , haxton , w. c. , langanke , k. , martnez - pinedo , g. , & woosley , s. e. 2005 , phys . b , 606 , 258 hix , w. r. & thielemann , f .- k . 1996 , , 460 , 869 honda , s. , aoki , w. , kajino , t. , ando , h. , beers , t. c. , izumiura , h. sadakane , k. , & takada - hidai , m. 2004 , , 607 , 474 iwamoto , n. , umeda , h. , tominaga , n. , nomoto , k. , maeda , k. 2005 , science , 309 , 451 iwamoto , n. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , thielemann , f .- k . , & hix , w. r. 2006 , in international symposium on the origin of matter and evolution of galaxies 2005 , ed . s. kubono et al . ( san francisco : aip ) , 409 janka , h .- th . , buras , r. , & rampp , m. 2003 , nucl . phys . a , 718 , 269 kobayashi , c. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , & ohkubo , t. 2006 , , 653 , 1145 kotake , k. , sawai , h. , yamada , s. , & sato , k. 2004 , , 608 , 391 lattimer , j. m. & prakash , m. 2001 , , 550 , 426 maeda , k. & nomoto , k. 2003 , , 598 , 1163 mclaughlin , g. c. & surman , r. 2007 , , 75 , 023005 nomoto , k. , tominaga , n. , umeda , h. , kobayashi , c. , & maeda , k. 2006 , nucl . a777 , 424 norris , j. e. , ryan , s. g. , & beers , t. c. 2001 , , 561 , 1034 pruet , j. , hoffman , r. d. , woosley , s. e. , janka , h .- buras , r. 2006 , , 644 , 1028 pruet , j. , woosley , s. e. , buras , r. , janka , h .- t . , & hoffman , r. d. 2005 , , 623 , 325 rauscher , t. , heger , a. , hoffman , r. d. , & woosley , s. e. 2002 , , 576 , 323 scheck , l. , plewa , t. , janka , h .- th . , kifonidis , k. , & mller , e. 2004 , , 92 , 011103 shigeyama , t. & tsujimoto , t. 1998 , , 507 , l135 tominaga , n. , maeda , k. , umeda , h. , nomoto , k. , tanaka , m. , iwamoto , n. , suzuki , t. , & mazzali , p. 2007a , , 657 , l77 tominaga , n. , umeda , h. , & nomoto , k. 2007b , , 660 , 516 tominaga , n. , et al . 2005 , , 633 , l97 umeda , h. & nomoto , k. 2002 , , 565 , 385 umeda , h. & nomoto , k. 2005 , , 619 , 427 wanajo , s. 2006 , , 647 , 1323 woosley , s. e. , hartmann , d. h. , hoffman , r. d. , & haxton , w. c. 1990 , , 356 , 272 woosley , s. e. & weaver , t. a. 1995 , , 101 , 181 yoshida , t. , kajino , t. , & hartmann , d. h. 2005a , , 94 , 231101 yoshida , t. , kajino , t. , yokomakura , h. , kimura , k. , takamura , a. , & hartmann , d. h. 2006a , , 649 , 319 yoshida , t. , kajino , t. , yokomakura , h. , kimura , k. , takamura , a. , & hartmann , d. h. 2006b , , 96 , 091101 yoshida , t. , terasawa , m. , kajino , t. , & sumiyoshi , k. 2004 , , 600 , 204 yoshida , t. , umeda , h. , & nomoto , k. 2005b , , 631 , 1039
Abstract: | [
"we investigate the effects of neutrino - nucleus interactions ( the @xmath0-process ) on the production of iron - peak elements in population iii core - collapse supernovae . the @xmath0-process and the following proton and neutron capture reactions produce odd-@xmath1 iron - peak elements in complete and incomplete si burning region . this reaction sequence enhances the abundances of sc , mn , and co in the supernova ejecta . the supernova explosion models of 15 @xmath2 and 25 @xmath2 stars with the @xmath0-process well reproduce the averaged mn / fe ratio observed in extremely metal - poor halo stars . in order to reproduce the observed mn / fe ratio , the total neutrino energy in the supernovae should be @xmath3 ergs . stronger neutrino irradiation and other production sites are necessary to reproduce the observed sc / fe and co / fe ratios , although these ratios increase by the @xmath0-process ."
] | 9,739 | 9,739 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: carrier dynamics in metals and semiconductors in the presence of external electromagnetic fields , the potentials of which usually vary on scales considerably large than the interatomic spacing , have been conveniently described by semiclassical transport theories . the semiclassical dynamics together with the boltzmann equation produce accurate descriptions of electrical and thermal conduction@xcite . in the larger picture , semiclassical approaches are indispensable in problems involving both position and momentum , since in quantum mechanics position and momentum can not be determined simultaneously . in recent years efforts have been made to extend the semiclassical theory to spin transport and generation@xcite . the attempts to resolve the challenges inherent in treating the transport of non - conserved quantities constitute a vibrant ongoing effort@xcite . a fundamental feature of semiclassical transport is its accounting for the finite extent of particles in real and reciprocal space . this feature is most naturally incorporated into the dynamics of wave packets@xcite where the notion of a wave - packet center in real space and @xmath0-space is retained . the carrier dynamics are described in terms of the displacement of these points under the action of external fields . the finite extent of the wave packet has important consequences for transport theory . for example , our recent research on spin transport has shown that , due to the fact that the spin and charge centers of a wave packet do not coincide , the expressions for the spin density , torque and current distributions are , in the language of wave packets , expressed as series of multipole terms@xcite . it has been demonstrated , in addition , that the wave packet formalism captures the physics connected with adiabatic motion and the berry phase , in particular the berry - curvature correction to the semiclassical equations of motion@xcite . the berry phase , which until berry s seminal article@xcite was not taken into account , appears naturally as part of the wave packet distribution function . the berry - curvature correction to the wave packet equations of motion is believed to play an important role in the anomalous hall effect@xcite and in spin transport@xcite , among other phenomena . semiclassical transport theory is not restricted to wave packet dynamics . wave packets , which may be constructed out of one band eigenstate@xcite or out of a superposition of eigenstates of several degenerate bands@xcite , represent pure states . in order to treat mixed states ( incoherent superpositions of eigenstates ) one must resort to a more general formalism . this is the principal motivation behind the current article . the most general description of a quantum mechanical system is based on the density operator . in this article we start from the density operator and formulate a theory of carrier dynamics in metals and semiconductors . we focus on non - interacting systems in which disorder is weak , strong spin - orbit interactions are present and a weak slowly - varying electric field is acting . these systems have come under intense scrutiny in recent years along with the take - off of spintronics@xcite . in such non - interacting systems the formalism may be simplified by defining a reduced one - particle density operator@xcite . since the bloch bands are clearly resolved the reduced density operator for this system may be expanded in a basis of bloch wave functions . the density matrix which emerges from this expansion may be defined as a wigner function . this function is used to study single particle dynamics and formulate definitions of macroscopic quantities . we focus on a number of fundamental aspects of adiabatic particle dynamics and demonstrate their relevance to transport phenomena . we pay particular attention to the band mixing induced by the electric field , which gives rise to a non - adiabatic correction to the wave functions . we also address several important questions concerning the relationship between the wigner function formalism and the wave - packet formalism@xcite . we discuss the way the carrier position is to be found and , where possible , compare the result with the expression for the real - space center of a wave packet . the requirement that the particle position be gauge invariant results in a gauge - dependent shift in the position at which the wigner function is evaluated . this shift was also found by littlejohn and flynn@xcite in the study of coupled - wave equations . this gauge - dependent shift is a consequence of the freedom of choosing the real - space center of a wave packet by changing the phase of the wave function@xcite . the gauge - dependent shift in the position of the wigner function must be taken into account when many - particle distributions , such as the particle number density , are expressed in the crystal - momentum representation . the carrier velocity may be derived directly from the particle position , recovering the berry - phase physics known from previous work@xcite . we also show that a spin velocity may be defined in such a way that spin transport may be described in an analogous fashion to charge transport . we discuss , in addition , important consequences of finite particle size . the wigner distribution is a quantum entity which takes into account the finite extent of the particles in real and reciprocal space . the distribution of , for example , spin for a single carrier , may not coincide with that of charge and the macroscopic spin distribution will be composed of a series of multipoles . the spin current and spin torque distributions are in turn composed of series of multipoles which we discuss and compare with those found in our previous work on spin transport@xcite . the outline of this article is as follows . we present the fundamentals of the single particle density matrix formalism in section ii . we determine the carrier position and velocity , emphasizing the gauge - dependent shift in the former and the berry - phase correction in the latter . we calculate the particle spin , torque and spin velocity and define a modified spin velocity which satisfies an equation analogous to the charge velocity . in section iii we demonstrate the modifications which must be made to extend the theory to many non - interacting particles . we define the charge and current densities and show the equation of continuity they satisfy . in the case of spin we define the spin , spin current and spin torque distributions and show the equation of continuity satisfied by them in the clean limit . in section iv we demonstrate the effect of local gauge transformations and the modifications which must be made to the dipoles in the charge- and spin - related distributions in order to make them gauge covariant . we conclude with a brief summary of our findings . we consider systems described by a hamiltonian having the following general form : @xmath1 the term @xmath2 is composed of the usual kinetic - energy contribution and the contribution due to the lattice - periodic potential . the term @xmath3 represents the spin - orbit interaction term involving the carrier spins and the lattice - periodic potential . we restrict our attention to the limit in which this spin - orbit interaction is sizably stronger than the disorder broadening and the thermal broadening . in this limit the system may also be described in terms of well - defined bands . the eigenstates of @xmath4 , which have the periodicity of the crystal , are given by : @xmath5 these wave functions are of the bloch form , that is @xmath6 , where the functions @xmath7 represent the lattice - periodic parts of the @xmath8 . the @xmath7 are spinors with the full periodicity of the lattice . since the hamiltonian contains strong spin - orbit interaction terms , which may depend on wave vector and position , it is not illuminating to decompose the eigenfunctions into an orbital and a spin part . we take the system under study to be described by a density operator @xmath9 . it is not our concern in this article to determine an expression for the density operator for a given system , since methods of finding the density operator have been studied extensively in the past@xcite , much work being done in the context of spin orientation of carriers in the non - degenerate limit . we assume the form of @xmath10 to be known and study the role it plays in the dynamics of charge and spin . the density operator may be expanded in the hilbert space spanned by a complete orthonormal set of bloch wave functions @xmath11 as @xmath12 in the approach we follow , all the time dependence of the density operator is contained in the wave functions , so that @xmath13 does not have time dependence . in thermal equilibrium it is diagonal and its elements , @xmath14 , are equal to the fermi - dirac function @xmath15 , where @xmath16 is the band energy . the expectation value of any operator @xmath17 is found from the formula @xmath18 = & \displaystyle { \rm tr } \ , \sum_{{\bf k } , { \bf k } ' } \rho({\bf k } , { \bf k } ' ) a({\bf k } ' , { \bf k } ) . \end{array}\ ] ] the notation @xmath19 stands for the matrix elements of the operator @xmath17 , namely @xmath20 . the operation denoted by tr is simply the matrix trace , which does not include the wave - vector summation . if the operator @xmath17 is replaced by the identity matrix we obtain @xmath21 . for a single particle , the normalization condition on the density operator is @xmath22 . in order to make transparent the analogy with the language of wave packets , center of mass and relative coordinates may be defined in @xmath0-space such that * q * = @xmath23 and @xmath24 . the density operator as a function of these coordinates can be re - expressed as @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 is the periodic part of the bloch wave at @xmath28 . the wigner function corresponding to the one particle density matrix is found through the transformation @xmath29 for the sake of concreteness the integrals are represented as three dimensional . nevertheless , the theory applies to systems of any dimensionality . the wigner function plays the role of a distribution function in the variables * q * and * r*. technically , however , it is not a distribution since it may take negative values@xcite . the inverse transformation is @xmath30 finally , replacing the vector summations by integrations we are able to represent the density operator in the following form @xmath31 where @xmath32 . for the remainder of this section , the wigner function @xmath33 will frequently be abbreviated to @xmath34 . the variables * q * and * r * are simply labels for the carriers , not physical observables . in particular , the dummy variable * r * in the fourier expansion of the density matrix is simply the fourier dual of * q * and must not be confused with the position operator @xmath35 appearing in the density operator . it does not correspond to an actual position . if we consider a particle in one band , labelled @xmath36 , @xmath34 reduces to a scalar , which will be denoted by @xmath37 . the position of the particle can be found as the expectation value of the position operator , which yields @xmath38 here @xmath39 . the integrand is not gauge invariant but the integral can be shown to be by changing the variable of integration * r * to @xmath40 . the connection @xmath41 has no position dependence , therefore the jacobian of the transformation is unity . the expectation value of the position operator is @xmath42 where @xmath43 is defined in the same way as @xmath44 but with * r * replaced by @xmath45 . the gauge invariance of ( [ rnew ] ) will emerge below . we conclude that @xmath46 is to be interpreted as a label for the charge carrier , while the effective particle position is @xmath40 . neither the label @xmath46 nor the gauge field @xmath47 are by themselves gauge invariant , but together they form a gauge - invariant quantity which represents the true position of the carrier . this result was also found earlier , in somewhat different circumstances , in the work of littlejohn and flynn@xcite . in the one - band limit , a clear connection can also be made with the dynamics of wave packets . the gauge - dependent shift in * r * reflects the freedom of changing the phase of the wave functions @xmath11 , @xmath48 in ( [ rhodef ] ) . it is the same freedom one has in defining the center of mass of a wave packet , demonstrated by sundaram and niu@xcite , by changing the overall phase of the wave function@xcite . for multiple bands , the expression for the particle position is ( the einstein summation convention will be used henceforth ) @xmath49 one can rewrite this expression as @xmath50 and make the substitution @xmath51 as in the single band case . although @xmath47 is a matrix the jacobian of this transformation is unity . finally , the expectation value of the position operator can be expressed formally as @xmath52 unlike the single band case , the expression @xmath53 is a formal abbreviation for the taylor expansion about @xmath45 , that is @xmath54 @xmath55 higher order . expression ( [ rnew ] ) identifies the position of a particle . to determine if a particle is localized at its position one must calculate the variance of the position operator , the expectation value @xmath56 , and ensure that is does not diverge . it is shown in the appendix that the variance does not diverge and that this result applies to any number of bands . we consider a system acted on by a weak external electric field . the effect of this electric field is incorporated fully into the gauge invariant crystal momentum through the addition of the electromagnetic vector potential @xmath57 . because the bloch functions retain translational symmetry the electromagnetic vector potential does not enter the travelling - wave part of the wave functions , which have the form @xmath58 . the lattice - periodic functions @xmath59 depend implicitly on time only through the crystal wave vector @xmath60 . however , the presence of the external electric field results in a non - adiabatic mixing of the bands with the result that the perturbed lattice - periodic functions , @xmath61 , have the following form to first order in the electric field@xcite @xmath62 the phase @xmath63 includes the dynamical phase and the berry phase . the differential @xmath64 is equivalent to @xmath65 since @xmath66 . the result expressed by ( [ nonadb ] ) is general . moreover , although its derivation relies on the assumption that the bands are non - degenerate it can be shown that , when calculating _ intrinsic _ contributions to transport ( for the definition of intrinsic please see the appendix and our recent work@xcite ) , the result also holds for degenerate bands with the difference that the sum must exclude _ all _ bands which are degenerate in energy with band @xmath67 . the proof of this statement is given in the appendix . henceforth , @xmath68 and @xmath69 will be abbreviated to @xmath70 and @xmath71 respectively . as stated above , given that the @xmath72 are functions of @xmath73 only , one may replace @xmath64 in ( [ nonadb ] ) by @xmath65 , where @xmath74@xmath75 . equation ( [ nonadb ] ) can then be written as @xmath76 where the connection @xmath77 . the @xmath78 form a complete set . they are , however , _ not _ eigenstates of the _ time - dependent _ hamiltonian @xmath79 . in the evaluations of matrix elements in this paper the only property of the basis functions that is used is their bloch periodicity . therefore the results which are expressed in terms of the lattice periodic bloch functions hold as well for the @xmath80 as for the @xmath81 . in the absence of disorder , since all the time dependence is contained in the wave functions , the density matrix @xmath13 in ( [ rhodef ] ) can only depend on the wave vector * k * , not on the crystal wave vector @xmath82 . as a result the wigner function @xmath83 only depends on the wave vector * q * , not on @xmath73 . it is customary to consider only a subset of the hilbert space which contains the bands that are relevant to transport , which in semiconductors usually refers to the topmost filled valence bands and/or the lowest filled conduction bands . since the gauge of the @xmath78 is not fixed we impose the following gauge - fixing condition _ in the subspace _ under consideration @xmath84 & \displaystyle 0 , \,\,\ , { \rm for } \,\,\ , n \,\,\ , { \rm out \,\,\ , of \,\,\ , subspace } , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath85 . this condition fixes the phase(s ) @xmath86 in ( [ nonadb ] ) . we shall henceforth work only with the basis set @xmath87 . the particle velocity can be derived directly from ( [ rmb ] ) by evaluating the time derivative @xmath88 using equation ( [ gf ] ) , the differential @xmath89 becomes , after a little straightforward algebra , @xmath90 the abbreviation @xmath91 stands for the matrix elements of the time - dependent hamiltonian @xmath92 in the presence of an electric field , @xmath93 . in one band it is easily shown that ( [ drdt ] ) becomes @xmath94 the berry curvature for band @xmath36 , @xmath95 , is given by @xmath96 and @xmath97 represents the curl operator in reciprocal space . the quantity @xmath98 is defined as @xmath99 . equation ( [ vel ] ) is the analog of the semiclassical equation of motion found by sundaram and niu@xcite . writing @xmath100@xmath101 we obtain for electrons in a single band : @xmath102 for multiple bands , an elegant result is obtained by introducing the covariant derivatives@xcite @xmath103 and @xmath104 , where @xmath105 . making use of these derivatives , equation ( [ drdt ] ) can be written in the manifestly gauge covariant form @xmath106_{n'n } - i[\frac{d}{d\tilde{q}_\alpha } , \frac{d}{dt}]_{n'n}. \end{split}\ ] ] it is important to point out that , from the gauge - fixing condition ( [ gf ] ) which defines @xmath107 , it is evident that @xmath107 is gauge covariant , implying that the time derivative @xmath64 is itself gauge - covariant . this is a peculiarity of the gauge - fixing condition we have chosen . the fact that carriers have a finite extent in real and wave - vector space has profound implications for particle dynamics and transport . these implications were pointed out in a previous publication @xcite using the semiclassical language of wave - packets and will be elaborated in this section from the density matrix point of view . for the sake of clarity we will specialize in spin , although the discussion in this section applies to any quantity . when considering the transport of spin in a system composed of many carriers , one must associate a spin distribution with each individual carrier . a center of spin may be defined for each particle by @xmath108 . this definition may be troublesome if the expectation value of the spin operator were zero , but its only purpose is to illustrate a physical principle . evidently , if one replaced the spin operator with the charge or mass one would obtain the particle position as given by ( [ r ] ) , which we will refer to as @xmath109 . it is obvious from the definition of @xmath110 that in the general case there is no reason for the center of the spin distribution of an individual particle to be the same as the actual particle position . this center will be different for each component of the spin operator . furthermore , since spin is not conserved in the presence of e.g. spin - orbit interactions , @xmath110 may also be a function of time . this suggests that the spin distribution of one carrier will in general have a different shape than its charge distribution , and that the time development of the two distributions may be quite different . these facts are illustrated in figs . 1 and 2 . to evaluate the average carrier spin consider the expectation value of the operator @xmath111 , which stands for any one component of the spin operator . the result is @xmath112 where @xmath113 are the matrix elements of the spin operator . in the presence of spin - orbit interactions a spin torque is associated with the spin of every carrier , which accounts for the non - conservation of spin , as shown in fig . 2 . the average carrier torque is found by evaluating the expectation value of @xmath114 $ ] . the result is @xmath115 where @xmath116 . as a result of the distinction between @xmath110 and @xmath117 , in calculations of spin - related quantities which use the center of charge as the reference , multipole terms must be taken into account in addition to the average quantities calculated above . for example , in the distribution of spin a spin dipole will be present , as well as higher order multipole terms , which are assumed small . the spin dipole is found as the expectation value @xmath118 , evaluated in the appendix , and yields the gauge field @xmath119 in contrast to @xmath110 , @xmath120 is well defined . similarly , in the distribution of torque of an individual particle a torque dipole will be present . the torque gauge field @xmath121 is given , as shown in the appendix , by @xmath122 @xmath120 and @xmath123 are gauge dependent . it will prove useful to define gauge - covariant dipoles as @xmath124 and @xmath125 respectively . the remainder of the discussion of these gauge - covariant spin and torque dipoles is deferred to section iv . we define the spin velocity as the expectation value @xmath126 , where products of non - commuting operators are assumed to be symmetrized . the result is @xmath127 the spin velocity @xmath128 is given by @xmath129 = & \displaystyle { \frac{d \bar{\bf m}^s}{d t } } - \bar{\bf m}^\tau . \end{array}\ ] ] in order to write the velocity in a gauge covariant form , we replace in the above @xmath130 and @xmath131 . this yields immediately @xmath132 equation ( [ vsps ] ) is the gauge - covariant form of equation ( 10 ) in ref . [ 2 ] , the integrand of which represents the spin velocity . the first term in ( [ vsps])is a convective contribution and represents a moving electron transporting its average spin along with it . the second term is the time derivative of the spin dipole while the last term is the torque dipole which takes into account the non - conservation of spin . we may incorporate @xmath133 into a modified spin velocity@xcite , which we shall call @xmath134 , by @xmath135 . the modified spin velocity is given simply by : @xmath136 the importance of this definition of the velocity will be seen in the following section , when the macroscopic spin current is introduced . we will consider the macroscopic distributions of charge and spin starting from the formalism we have developed . in particular , our discussion of the corrections to the spin density , current and torque distributions is motivated by the observation that the existing literature has omitted various contributions to spin transport . several works have used semiclassical concepts but did not arrive at answers containing all the terms we have derived . the particle number density is defined by the formula : @xmath137.\ ] ] the trace operation tr involves integration over * r*. the procedure we follow has affinities with the coarse graining of electrodynamics in material media @xcite . the size of the carriers is taken to be smaller than the length scale of the wigner function . we regard the @xmath138-function as a sampling function@xcite with a width somewhere between the microscopic scale of the carriers and the macroscopic scale of the wigner function . the rationale for regarding the @xmath138-function as a sampling function comes from the realization that often the physics of the problem does not require absolute resolution of position , provided that the resolution is finer than the length scale of the external field . since the variance of @xmath35 is finite , the @xmath138-function may be expanded in a taylor series about the dummy variable * r * in the form @xmath139 $ ] . the expansion is truncated at the first order for simplicity but we will show in the next section that all the terms may be recovered in a concise and elegant fashion . the number density can be expressed as : @xmath140 in the above @xmath34 stands for @xmath141 , an abbreviation which will be frequently used in the remainder of the article . note that the gauge field @xmath142 in ( [ ndip ] ) plays the role of a dipole . the charge density is defined by the formula @xmath143.\ ] ] the charge @xmath144 is not to be confused with the wave vector * q*. the charge current density @xmath145 is defined by the equation @xmath146.\ ] ] the charge equation of continuity in the absence of external sources and disorder , @xmath147 is readily verified from the first - principles definitions of the charge and current densities . when the @xmath138-function is expanded the current density takes the form @xmath148 the velocity matrix elements @xmath149 as shown in the appendix , where @xmath150 . since in the equation of continuity it is the gradient of the current that appears , we have not included in ( [ jq ] ) corrections to the current which arise from the fact that the velocity distribution of a single carrier is different from its charge distribution . these corrections are in principle present but have been omitted for simplicity . in homogeneous systems the gradient term in ( [ jq ] ) drops out of the equation of continuity and , based on equations ( [ drdt ] ) and ( [ jq ] ) , the charge current can be expressed as the time rate of change of the gauge field @xmath142 @xmath151 the spin density is defined as @xmath152,\ ] ] while the torque density takes the form @xmath153\ ] ] and the spin current density is defined as @xmath154.\ ] ] in the absence of disorder the spin equation of continuity is @xmath155 which is verified from the first - principles definitions introduced above . the @xmath156-functions are expanded in the same way as for the particle number density , whereupon the spin density can be expressed as @xmath157 and the torque density is @xmath158 ignoring the gradient term , the spin current is @xmath159 in analogy with the modified spin velocity of the previous section , a modified spin current @xmath160 may be defined by : @xmath161 = & \displaystyle { \rm tr } \int \frac{d^3q}{(2\pi)^3 } \,\rho\,\left(\frac{1}{2}\{{\frac{d \bar{\cal r}}{d t } } , \bar s\ } + { \frac{d \bar{\bf p}^s}{d t}}\right ) . \end{array}\ ] ] the equation of continuity satisfied by this current in the clean limit is : @xmath162 in many models , such as the spherical four - band luttinger model@xcite , the rhs vanishes when all bands in the subspace are taken into account . in that case the spin current @xmath160 is conserved . much effort has been devoted to finding a conserved spin current . in our previous work @xcite we have argued , based on semiclassical ideas , that the closest one can come to a conserved spin current is by including the torque dipole in the definition of the current . in this article we have derived this current from a density matrix point of view and show that it supports our earlier conclusions . to date , the definition @xmath160 is the closest one has come to a conserved spin current . moreover , as shown also by zarea and ulloa @xcite , the behavior of the modified spin current may be rather different from that of @xmath163 . we have argued in section ii that in discussing transport of an observable one must take into account the fact that the distribution of that observable for each individual carrier in general involves a dipole correction , and in principle also higher - order corrections . if the quantity being transported is not conserved then the determination of its rate of change also involves a dipole correction . the existence of what appears to be a sound physical argument for the inclusion of these corrections suggests that objects such as the spin dipole and the torque dipole are not simply mathematical artifacts meant to facilitate calculations . it is appropriate to investigate whether they are in fact fundamental quantities with a true physical meaning . if that were the case , they ought to be expressible in a gauge - covariant way and to give rise to observable effects . in addition to these considerations , our aim of providing a physically transparent formalism requires a test of the gauge covariance of the macroscopic quantities and equations of motion we have derived in this article . the physics contained in them must be independent of the choice of basis functions . furthermore , the physical discussion can become cluttered with futile and meaningless objects if it is formulated in terms of gauge - dependent objects . in contrast , the gauge - covariant expressions we derive below are simple , elegant and transparent . a general local gauge transformation is represented by @xmath164 , with @xmath165 and @xmath67 and @xmath36 are indices of bands in the subspace under consideration . under this operation @xmath166 in which @xmath167 stands for @xmath168 . the berry curvature for one band @xmath95 is discussed extensively in the paper of sundaram and niu@xcite . one important additional detail which emerges from the transformation given by ( [ rtrans ] ) and the definition @xmath169 is the fact that , if the curvature is non - zero , one can not make a gauge transformation to eliminate @xmath170 . it can be easily shown that , whereas @xmath170 is gauge dependent , the berry curvature is gauge covariant . therefore if @xmath95 is non - zero in one gauge it is non - zero in all gauges and there is no gauge in which @xmath170 can be zero . as a result , in systems in which the curvature is non - zero the gauge - dependent position shift is necessarily present in the wigner function . it can be regarded as a ` penalty ' for working with the position operator in a basis of definite wave vector . the wigner function itself changes under the gauge transformation defined above . using ( [ wigout ] ) , we find that , to first order in @xmath171 , the wigner function changes as @xmath172 where @xmath173 ( the opposite of the gauge connection @xmath142 ) . all the macroscopic densities defined in the previous sections are covariant under a local gauge transformation . this will be demonstrated for the spin density . under the above gauge transformation , the gauge field @xmath120 transforms as @xmath174 the matrix elements of the transformed gauge field @xmath175 are given by @xmath176 and the transformed spin operator @xmath177 . to first order the extra terms acquired by the spin density under a gauge transformation are @xmath178 so that the spin density remains gauge covariant . the cancellation remains true for all orders in the expansion . similarly , the charge and current densities do not acquire additional terms under the local gauge transformation introduced above . the extra terms appearing as a result of the transformation cancel when the trace is taken . when the change in the wigner function under a gauge transformation is taken into account the overall expressions are gauge covariant . equation ( [ ndip ] ) for the particle number density can be formally written the following way @xmath179 re - expressing the integrand in this manner is tantamount to making , in the density matrix , the replacement @xmath180 . to ensure the gauge covariance of the number density the fourier dual * r * is replaced by the true position @xmath181 , as illustrated in fig . this is the same position as found in section ii . if the subspace contains one band expression ( [ nmod ] ) is an exact result , not simply a formal way of writing the number density . examining more closely the spin density as given in ( [ s ] ) it is evident that , whereas the spin density itself is gauge covariant , its individual constituents are not . if one were to consider the integrand of the dipole term in ( [ s ] ) without the wigner function , this quantity would not by itself be gauge covariant . we have already constructed a gauge - covariant spin dipole @xmath182 . in terms of the gauge - covariant spin dipole , the spin density can be re - expressed as @xmath183 it can be formally written the following way @xmath184.\ ] ] the gauge - covariant spin dipole @xmath185 , as pointed out above , is the result of a carrier s center of spin being different from its center of charge . in the same way the gauge - covariant torque dipole has been defined by @xmath186 . carrying out an identical manipulation to that for the spin density , use of the gauge - covariant torque dipole allows us to rewrite the torque density formally as @xmath187.\ ] ] a similar formal expression exists for the spin current . evidently , since these expressions are simply a rewriting of the spin , torque and current densities , the equation of continuity satisfied by them is unaltered . we remark that the gauge - covariant quantities introduced throughout this paper are well defined . in fact , even though the density matrix was expressed in a basis of extended bloch states , by means of various manipulations we have been able to obtain well - defined formulas for all the objects relevant in transport . finally , as described by dudarev _ et al . _ @xcite in the context of atomic physics , optical lattices can be constructed which mimic the spin - orbit interaction . in such a lattice , a wave packet can be constructed using cold atoms and the evolution of its centers of mass and spin can be followed . in the same spirit , kato _ et al . _ @xcite have shown that it is possible to follow the motion of a spin packet in solid state systems , which demonstrates the feasibility of an analogous experiment in ingaas . this would provide a way to measure a spin dipole directly . we have formulated a theory suitable for describing the dynamics of particles in both single and multiple bands . the one - band results known from the wave - packet formalism , including the terms connected to the berry phase , emerge from our theory . the formalism can be applied to any clean system regardless of the dimensionality of the hilbert space under consideration . as a result of the gauge degree of freedom of the basis functions , the position vector which is used as a label of the carrier must be modified by a gauge - dependent shift in order to obtain the true particle position . we have shown the way to define macroscopic density distributions for conserved and non - conserved operators . in the case of spin we have highlighted the correspondence between the multipole terms which appear in the density - matrix formalism and those found earlier in the wave - packet formalism and we have shown that experiments can be performed to identify the effect of a spin dipole . dc was supported by the nsf under grant number dmr-0404252 . qn was supported by the doe under grant number de - fg03 - 02er45958 . we will present in this appendix some of the proofs and evaluations which require lengthier calculations and would interrupt the flow if incorporated into the main text . for all derivations except the first , the @xmath78 and @xmath72 are interchangeable . the perturbed eigenfunctions are given by eq.([nonadb ] ) : @xmath188 for a set of degenerate bands the equilibrium part of the density matrix is proportional to the identity matrix @xmath189 and will have the form @xmath190 , where @xmath191 is usually the fermi - dirac distribution . transport theory often distinguishes between intrinsic effects , which are due to the equilibrium part of the density matrix , and extrinsic effects , which are due to the non - equilibrium correction to it . if we wish to evaluate the expectation value of an operator @xmath17 using the equilibrium part of the density matrix for a set of degenerate bands , which for simplicity here we will take as being two dimensional , the following quantity must be evaluated : @xmath192 the perturbed wave functions are given by : @xmath193 & \displaystyle { | \bar u_{2 } \rangle } = { | u_{2 } \rangle } - \frac{{\langle u_{1 } | i\hbar{\frac{d } { d t } } | u_{2 } \rangle}}{\varepsilon_2 - \varepsilon_1}{| u_{1 } \rangle } - \sum_{n\ne 1,2}\frac{{\langle u_{n } | i\hbar{\frac{d } { d t } } | u_{m } \rangle}}{\varepsilon_m - \varepsilon_n}{| u_{n } \rangle}. \end{array}\ ] ] the expectation values are : @xmath194 & \displaystyle { \langle \bar u_2 | \hat a | \bar u_2 \rangle } = a_{22 } - \frac{{\langle u_{1 } | i\hbar{\frac{d u_{2}}{d t } } \rangle}}{\varepsilon_2 - \varepsilon_1}a_{21 } - \frac{{\langle u_{2 } | i\hbar{\frac{d u_{1}}{d t } } \rangle}}{\varepsilon_2 - \varepsilon_1}a_{12 } + \sum_2^{out}. \end{array}\ ] ] in the above @xmath195 and @xmath196 stand for the sums involving the bands outside the degenerate manifold and @xmath197 . the denominators of the terms involving @xmath198 and @xmath199 have opposite signs . therefore , adding up the expectation values we obtain : @xmath200 therefore the terms with diverging denominators cancel out . in the general case , the expectation value of the position operator is given by @xmath201 we can expand the integrand in the above equation and obtain @xmath202 & \displaystyle + { \langle i{\frac{\partial \bar u_{n'-}}{\partial { \bf q } } } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\ [ 2.2ex ] & \displaystyle + { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | i{\frac{\partial \bar u_{n+}}{\partial { \bf q } } } \rangle } \\ [ 2.2ex ] & \displaystyle + { \bf r}{\langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle}. \end{array}\ ] ] all four brackets represent integrals of products of lattice periodic functions and exponentials . they will all eventually be proportional to @xmath203 . because of this fact the first term above integrates to zero . the partial derivatives in the second and third terms are evaluated by expanding the lattice periodic bloch wave functions about * q * , treating * q * as a small parameter @xmath204 in the limit in which @xmath205 @xmath206 consequently @xmath207 and the expectation value of the position vector yields , finally @xmath208 the spin gauge field is found in an analogous fashion to the expectation value of the position operator @xmath209 expanding the above , @xmath210 & \displaystyle + { \langle i{\frac{\partial \bar u_{n'-}}{\partial { \bf q } } } | \hat s e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\ [ 2.2ex ] & \displaystyle + { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | \hat s e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | i{\frac{\partial \bar u_{n+}}{\partial { \bf q } } } \rangle } . \end{array}\ ] ] using the same arguments as in the previous section , the first term integrates to zero , and after evaluating the brackets involving the exponential and the lattice - periodic functions , we obtain in the limit @xmath211 @xmath212 an almost identical derivation applies for the expectation value @xmath213 . the only difference is that , since @xmath214 may be a function of wave vector , an additional term involving @xmath215 is generated . however , that term drops out when the anti - commutator is taken , leaving us with the result @xmath122 since the expectation value of the carrier position has been shown above to contain no divergences , if the expectation value @xmath216 is not divergent then the variance @xmath217 is also finite . to see that the variance of the particle position does not contain any divergences , we need to evaluate the expectation value @xmath216 this requires us to evaluate the matrix element @xmath218 first note that an expression of the form @xmath219 can be written as @xmath220 & \displaystyle + 2{\frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}}}\cdot[{\frac{\partial a}{\partial { \bf q } } } bcd + ab { \frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}}}(cd ) ] \\ [ 2.2ex ] & \displaystyle - \frac{\partial^2 a}{\partial q^2}bcd - 2{\frac{\partial a}{\partial { \bf q } } } \cdot b{\frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}}}(cd ) \\ [ 2.2ex ] & \displaystyle - ab \frac{\partial^2 b}{\partial q^2 } ( cd ) . \end{array}\ ] ] in the case we are considering , all the products involve brackets which are proportional to @xmath203 . as a result , all the terms on the first line vanish under integration with respect to * q * and only the terms on the second line need to be evaluated . writing them out explicitly , @xmath221 & \displaystyle - { \langle \frac{\partial^2 \bar u_{n'-}}{\partial q^2 } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } - { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | \frac{\partial^2 \bar u_{n+}}{\partial q^2 } \rangle } \\[2.2ex ] & \displaystyle + 2i{\bf r}\cdot({\langle { \frac{\partial \bar u_{n'-}}{\partial { \bf q } } } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } + { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | { \frac{\partial \bar u_{n+}}{\partial { \bf q } } } \rangle})\\[2.2ex ] & \displaystyle - 2{\langle { \frac{\partial \bar u_{n'-}}{\partial { \bf q } } } | e^{i{\bf q}\cdot\hat{\bf r } } | { \frac{\partial \bar u_{n+}}{\partial { \bf q } } } \rangle}. \end{array}\ ] ] in order to evaluate the differentials , the wave functions are expanded as in ( [ uexpand ] ) except that now the expansion must be made to second order in * q*. the final result is @xmath222 & \displaystyle + \frac{1}{2}{\langle { \frac{\partial \bar u_{n'}}{\partial \tilde{\bf q } } } |}\cdot{| { \frac{\partial \bar u_{n}}{\partial \tilde{\bf q } } } \rangle } - \frac{1}{4}({\langle \frac{\partial^2\bar u_{n'}}{\partial \tilde q^2 } | \bar u_n \rangle } \\ [ 2.2ex ] & \displaystyle + { \langle \bar u_{n ' } | \frac{\partial^2 \bar u_{n}}{\partial \tilde q^2 } \rangle } ) ] . \end{array}\ ] ] this is clearly finite so the variance of the position operator is finite . the velocity matrix element @xmath223 is easily evaluated as @xmath224 & \displaystyle = \int d^3r ' \ , \bar u_{n'- } ( { \bf r } ' ) e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot{\bf r } ' } \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot { \bf r } ' } \bar u_{n+}({\bf r } ' ) \\ [ 2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle = \int d^3r ' \ , e^{i{\bf q}\cdot { \bf r } ' } \bar u_{n'- } ( { \bf r } ' ) ( e^{-i{\bf q}_+\cdot\hat{\bf r } ' } \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot\hat{\bf r } ' } ) \bar u_{n+}({\bf r } ' ) \\[2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle = \delta({\bf q})\int d^3r ' \ , \bar u_{n ' } ( { \bf r } ' ) \tilde { \bf v } \bar u_{n}({\bf r } ' ) = \delta({\bf q}){\langle \bar u_{n ' } | \tilde { \bf v } | \bar u_{n } \rangle}. \end{array}\ ] ] in the above we have abbreviated @xmath225 . we also need to evaluate the commutator @xmath226 . one half of the commutator is evaluated as @xmath227 & \displaystyle = { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } \hat { \bf v}[-i{\frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}_+ } } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } ] | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\[2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle = -i{\frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}_+ } } { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\[2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle + { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } { \frac{\partial \hat { \bf v}}{\partial { \bf q}_+ } } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\ [ 2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle + { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | i{\frac{\partial \bar u_{n+}}{\partial { \bf q}_+ } } \rangle } , \end{array}\ ] ] while the other is @xmath228 & \displaystyle = { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | [ i{\frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}_- } } e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } ] \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\[2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle = i{\frac{\partial } { \partial { \bf q}_- } } { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle } \\[2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle - { \langle i{\frac{\partial \bar u_{n-}}{\partial { \bf q}_- } } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } \hat { \bf v } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | \bar u_{n'+ } \rangle } \\[2.2 ex ] & \displaystyle - { \langle \bar u_{n'- } | e^{-i{\bf q}_-\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } { \frac{\partial \hat { \bf v}}{\partial { \bf q}_- } } e^{i{\bf q}_+\cdot ( \hat{\bf r } - { \bf r } ) } | \bar u_{n+ } \rangle}. \end{array}\ ] ] all the brackets in the above two equations are proportional to @xmath229 , causing most of the terms to cancel . we are left with : @xmath230 the operator @xmath232 must be invariant under gauge transformations . from the expansion of the density operator in bloch eigenstates , @xmath233 it is evident that , if the wave functions change according to @xmath234 , then @xmath235 must transform to @xmath236 . using the definition of @xmath13 in terms of the wigner function , @xmath237 and remembering that @xmath238 and @xmath239 , we obtain @xmath240 the matrices @xmath241 and @xmath242 may be expanded about their arguments as : @xmath243&\displaystyle o(\tilde{\bf q}_- ) = o(\tilde{\bf q } ) - \frac{{\bf q}}{2 } \cdot { \frac{\partial o ( \tilde{\bf q})}{\partial \tilde{\bf q } } } + o(q^2 ) . \end{array}\ ] ] then , to first order in @xmath244 , abbreviating @xmath245 to @xmath171 and @xmath246 to @xmath247 , @xmath248&\displaystyle = o^{-1 } \rho_q o + \frac{{\bf q}}{2 } \cdot ( { \frac{\partial o^{-1}}{\partial \tilde{\bf q}}}\rho_q o - o^{-1 } \rho_q { \frac{\partial o}{\partial \tilde{\bf q } } } ) \\[2.2ex]&\displaystyle = \tilde\rho_q + \frac{{\bf q}}{2 } \cdot ( { \frac{\partial o^{-1}}{\partial \tilde{\bf q}}}o \tilde\rho_q - \tilde \rho_q o^{-1}{\frac{\partial o}{\partial \tilde{\bf q } } } ) , \end{array}\ ] ] where @xmath249 . the last line is obtained by inserting @xmath250 or @xmath251 as appropriate . since @xmath252 , we have @xmath253 and @xmath254 finally , writing @xmath255 , we recover formula ( [ rhogt ] ) for the transformation of @xmath231 . n. w. ashcroft and n. d. mermin , _ solid state physics _ , 2@xmath256 edition ( saunders college publishing , new york , 1976 ) . d. culcer , j. sinova , n. a. sinitsyn , t. jungwirth , a. h. macdonald , and q. niu , phys . * 93 * , 046602 ( 2004 ) . d. culcer , y. g. yao , a. h. macdonald , and q. niu , phys . b ( 2005 ) . j. sinova , d. culcer , q. niu , n. a. sinitsyn , t. jungwirth , and a. h. macdonald , phys . lett . * 92 * , 126603 ( 2004 ) . s. murakami , n. nagaosa , and s .- c . zhang , science * 301 * , 1348 ( 2003 ) . s. murakami , n. nagaosa , and s .- c . zhang , phys . b * 69 * , 235206 ( 2004 ) . s. zhang , phys lett * 85 * , 393 ( 2000 ) . s. zhang and z. yang , phys . lett . * 94 * , 066602 ( 2005 ) . l. hu , j. gao , and s. q. shen , phys . b * 70 * , 235323 ( 2004 ) . j. inoue , g.w.bauer , l. w. molenkamp , phys . b * 67 * , 033104 ( 2003 ) . e. g. mishchenko , a. v. shytov , and b. i. halperin , phys . lett . * 93 * , 226602 ( 2004 ) . o. v. dimitrova , phys . b * 71 * , 245327 ( 2005 ) . g. y. guo , y. yao , and q. niu , phys . lett . * 94 * , 226601 ( 2005 ) . y. yao and z. fang , cond - mat/0502351 . j. callaway , _ quantum theory of the solid state _ ( academic press , new york , 1976 ) . g. sundaram and q. niu , phys . b * 59 * , 14915 ( 1999 ) . m. v. berry , proc . london ser . a , * 392 * , 45 ( 1984 ) . d. culcer , a. h. macdonald , and q. niu , phys . b * 68 * , 045327 ( 2003 ) . t. jungwirth , q. niu , and a. h. macdonald , phys . lett . * 88 * , 207208 ( 2002 ) . yugui yao , leonard kleinman , a. h. macdonald , jairo sinova , t. jungwirth , ding - sheng wang , enge wang , and qian niu , phys . lett . * 92 * , 037204 ( 2004 ) . d. culcer , y. g. yao , and q. niu , phys . b ( 2005 ) . r. shindou and k. imura , nucl . b * 720 * [ fs ] , 399 ( 2005 ) . s. a. wolf , d. d. awschalom , r. a. buhrman , j. m. daughton , s. von molnar , m. l. roukes , a. y. chtchelkanova , and d. m. treger , science * 294 * , 1488 ( 2001 ) . hammar and m. johnson , phys . lett . * 88 * , 066806 ( 2002 ) . y. k. kato , r. c. myers , a. c. gossard , and d. d. awschalom , science * 306 * , 1910 ( 2004 ) . j. wunderlich , b. kaestner , j. sinova , and t. jungwirth , phys . lett . * 94 * , 047204 ( 2005 ) . y. kato , r. c. myers , a. c. gossard , and d. d. awschalom , phys . * 93 * , 176601 ( 2004 ) . l. e. reichl , _ a modern course in statistical physics _ ( university of texas press , austin , 1980 ) . an interesting recent article , g. a. fiete and e. g. heller , phys . a * 68 * , 022112 ( 2003 ) , discusses this topic from a somewhat different point of view . r. g. littlejohn and w. g. flynn , phys . a * 44 * , 5239 ( 1991 ) . m. marder , _ condensed matter physics _ ( john wiley , new york , 2000 ) . dyakonov and v. i. perel , jetp lett . * 35*a , 459 ( 1971 ) . dyakonov and v. i. perel , sov . jetp * 33 * , 1053 ( 1971 ) . dyakonov and v. i. perel , sov . solid state * 13 * , 3023 ( 1972 ) . dyakonov and v. y. kachorovskii , sov . . semicond . * 20 * , 110 ( 1986 ) . e. l. ivchenko , y. b. lyanda - geller , and g. e. pikus , sov . jetp * 71 * , 550 ( 1990 ) . g. e. pikus and a. n. titkov in _ optical orientation _ ( elsevier science publications , amsterdam , 1984 ) . a. g. aronov , yu . b. lyanda - geller , and g. e. pikus , sov . jetp * 73 * , 537 ( 1991 ) . y. qi and s. zhang , phys . b * 65 * , 214407 ( 2002 ) , ibid . * 67 * , 052407 ( 2003 ) . u. fano , rev . * 29 * , 74 ( 1957 ) . a. messiah , _ quantum mechanics _ ( dover publications , new york , 2000 ) . ping zhang , junren shi , di xiao , and qian niu , phys . lett * 96 * , 076604 ( 2006 ) . jackson , _ classical electrodynamics _ , 3@xmath257 edition ( john wiley @xmath258 sons , 1999 ) , section 6.6 ( pp . 248 - 258 ) . j. m. luttinger , phys . rev . * 102 * , 1030 ( 1956 ) . m. zarea and s. e. ulloa , phys . b * 73 * , 165306 ( 2006 ) . a. m. dudarev , r. b. diener , i. carusotto , and q. niu phys . rev . lett . * 92 * , 153005 ( 2004 ) y. kato _ et al . _ , nature * 427 * , 50 ( 2004 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we investigate the dynamics of bloch electrons using a density operator method and connect this approach with previous theories based on wave packets . we study non - interacting systems with negligible disorder and strong spin - orbit interactions , which have been at the forefront of recent research on spin - related phenomena . we demonstrate that the requirement of gauge invariance results in a shift in the position at which the wigner function of bloch electrons is evaluated . the present formalism also yields the correction to the carrier velocity arising from the berry phase . the gauge - dependent shift in carrier position and the berry phase correction to the carrier velocity naturally appear in the charge and current density distributions . in the context of spin transport we show that the spin velocity may be defined in such a way as to enable spin dynamics to be treated on the same footing as charge dynamics . aside from the gauge - dependent position shift we find additional , gauge - covariant multipole terms in the density distributions of spin , spin current and spin torque ."
] | 9,482 | 9,482 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the phenomenon of shear localization during high strain - rate deformations of metals @xcite is a striking instance of material instability in mechanics , that has attracted considerable attention in the mechanics literature ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) as well as a number of mathematical studies ( @xcite and references therein ) . material instability is typically associated with ill - posedness of an underlying initial value problem , what has coined the term _ hadamard instability _ for its description in the mechanics literature . it should however be emphasized that while hadamard instability indicates the catastrophic growth of oscillations around a mean state , what is observed in localization is the orderly albeit extremely fast development of coherent structures : the shear bands . the latter is a nonlinear phenomenon and a linearized analysis can only serve as a precursor to such behavior . we work with the simplest model capturing the mechanism of shear band formation , a simple shear motion of a non - newtonian fluid with temperature decreasing viscosity @xmath0 , @xmath1 where @xmath2 describes the strain - rate sensitivity which typically in these problems satisfies @xmath3 . mathematical studies of , for power law viscosities @xmath4 , @xmath5 , show that the uniform shear is asymptotically stable for @xmath6 @xcite , but indicate unstable response in the complementary region @xmath7 , @xcite . the mathematical analysis has not so far characterized the precise behavior in the instability region ; however , detailed and resolved numerical studies ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) show that instability is followed by formation of shear bands . the difficulty is that in order to analyze the unstable regime one needs to account for the combined effect of parabolic regularizations in conjunction to ill - posed initial value problems . an asymptotic theory for calculating an effective equation for the compound effect is proposed in @xcite . it is based on the theory of relaxation systems and the chapman - enskog expansion and produces an effective asymptotic equation . for a power law the effective equation changes type from forward to backward parabolic , across the threshold @xmath8 of the parameter space . the criteria of @xcite are based on asymptotic analysis and as such are formal in nature . our objective , here , is to develop a mathematical theory for the onset of localisation and the emergence of a nonlinear localized state , thus providing a rigorous justification to the behavior conjectured by the effective equation in @xcite . we employ the constitutive hypothesis of an _ exponential law _ for the viscosity coefficient , @xmath9 the model for the exponential law admits a special class of solutions describing uniform shearing @xmath10 the graph @xmath11 describing the average stress vs. average strain response is monotonically decreasing , and thus the deformation of uniform shear is characterized by strain softening response . we set the following goals : 1 . to study the linearized problem around the uniform shearing solution and to assess the effects of the various parameters of the problem 2 . to inquire whether there are special solutions of the nonlinear problem that indicate the emergence of localized deformations and formation of shear bands . since the base solution around which we linearize is time - dependent the linearized analysis necessarily involves analysis of non - autonomous systems and also perturbations have to be compared against the base solution . we perform a linearization using ideas of relative perturbations @xmath12 leading to linearized system @xmath13 with @xmath14 computed by @xmath15 . this problem turns out to have the following behavior : 1 . [ en : introa]for the case without thermal diffusion @xmath16 : + when @xmath17 the high frequency modes grow exponentially fast with the exponent of the order of the frequency what is characteristic of ill - posedness and _ hadamard instability_. + when @xmath2 the modes are still unstable but the rate of growth is bounded independently of the frequency . in fact , the behavior in that range is characteristic of _ turing instability_. 2 . the effect of thermal diffusion ( @xmath18 ) for the non - autonomous linearized model can also be assessed : perturbations do grow initially in the early stages of deformation , but over time the effect of the diffusion intensifies and eventually the system gets stabilized . for a quantitative description of the above qualitative statement we refer to lemmas [ lemdecay ] and [ lembound ] . in addition , this behavior can also occur for the full solution of the nonlinear problem subject to simple shear boundary conditions as indicated in numerical simulations presented in figure [ mtstb ] . this type of metastable response was already conjectured ( for a somewhat different model ) in numerical experiments of @xcite . the linearized analysis presented here offers a theoretical explanation of this interesting behavior . in the second part of this article we consider the adiabatic variant of the model with exponential constitutive law . the system is expressed for @xmath19 in the form @xmath20 and is now considered on the whole space @xmath21 . for the system , we construct a class of localizing solutions @xmath22 \sigma ( x , t ) & = \sigma_s ( t ) \frac{1}{\phi_\lambda ( t ) } \ , \sigma_\lambda \big ( \sqrt{\lambda } x \phi_\lambda ( t ) \big ) , \\[2pt ] \theta(x , t ) & = \theta_s(t ) + \lambda \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } ( \theta_s(t ) - \theta_0 ) + \theta_\lambda \big ( \sqrt{\lambda } x \phi_\lambda ( t ) \big ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath23 depends on the parameter @xmath24 , and is determined via the solution @xmath25 of the singular initial value problem , with @xmath26 . the existence of the solution @xmath25 is established in theorem [ connection ] where most importantly its behavior at the origin and at infinity is made precise . the emerging solution depends on three parameters : @xmath27 linked to the uniform shear in , a parameter @xmath28 which can be viewed as a length scale of initial data , and a parameter @xmath29 determining the size of the initial profile . to our knowledge this is the first instance that the compound effect of hadamard instability and parabolic regularizations is mathematically analyzed in a nonlinear context . the reader should contrast the nonlinear response captured by the exact solution to the response of the associated linearized problem . the solutions indicate that the competition among hadamard instability and momentum diffusion in a nonlinear context can lead to a nonlinear coherent structure that localizes in a narrow band ( see theorem [ shearband ] and remark [ rmkbeh ] ) . by contrast , for a linear model , the combined effect of hadamard instability and parabolicity leads to unstable oscillatory modes growing in amplitude ( see ) . this justifies the scenario that nonlinearity can kill the oscillations caused by hadamard instability so that the non - uniformity of deformation produced by the instability merges into a single localized zone . it would be interesting to explore this type of response for other models related to material instability in solid mechanics . the exposition is organized as follows : section [ secdescription ] presents a description of the problem and the formulation via relative perturbations . the linearized analysis is presented in section [ stabar ] , first the part that can be done via spectral analysis for autonomous systems , and then the part concerning the effect of thermal diffusion , which is based on energy estimates for a non - autonomous linear system . detailed asymptotics for the eigenvalues and the connection with hadamard and turing instabilities are presented there . the presentation of the localized solutions is split in sections [ seclocal]-[seclocalii ] : section [ seclocal ] presents the invariance properties , the _ ansatz _ of localized solutions , and also introduces the relevant auxiliary problem , . the construction of solutions to the singular initial - value problem , and the proof of their properties is the centerpiece of our analysis and forms the objective of section [ secss ] . the construction is based on a series of steps , involving desingularization , a nonlinear transformation , and eventually the existence of a heteroclinic orbit via the poincar - bendixson theorem . the construction of the localized solutions is then effected in section [ seclocalii ] . in this work we study the onset of localization and formation of shear bands for the model describing shear motions of a non - newtonian fluid with viscosity @xmath30 decreasing with temperature . for concreteness we take a viscosity satisfying the exponential law and are interested in the range where the rate sensitivity @xmath31 is positive and small . the model then becomes @xmath32 and describes shear motions between two parallel plates located at @xmath33 and @xmath34 with @xmath35 the velocity in the shear direction , @xmath36 the shear stress , @xmath37 the temperature , and @xmath38 depicting the strain rate . the boundary conditions are taken @xmath39 equation reflects prescribed velocities at the boundaries , while manifests that the bounding plates are adiabatic . note that implies that the stress satisfies @xmath40 and that @xmath41 the initial conditions are @xmath42 throughout the study we will consider two cases : when @xmath43 the process is adiabatic and the resulting model will be the main object of study , as it is the simplest model proposed for studying the phenomenon of formation of shear bands . the case @xmath18 will also be studied in section [ stabar ] as a paradigm to assess the effect of thermal diffusion . the problem , , admits a class of special solutions describing uniform shear @xmath44 for the special case of the exponential law , @xmath45 and @xmath46 read @xmath47 these are universal solutions , _ i.e. _ they hold for all values of the parameters @xmath31 , @xmath48 , @xmath49 in the model including the limiting elliptic initial value problem when @xmath50 , @xmath43 . the graph @xmath51 is viewed as describing the stress vs. average strain response . as the graph is decreasing , it means that there is always softening response in the course of the deformation . the system has served as a paradigm for the mathematical study of the phenomenon of shear bands ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) occurring during the high strain - rate deformations of metals . formation of shear bands is a well known material instability that usually leads to rupture , and has received considerable attention in the mechanics literature ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) . the reader is referred to @xcite for a description of the problem intended for a mathematically oriented reader that is briefly also outlined below . it was recognized by zener and hollomon @xcite ( see also @xcite ) that the effect of the deformation speed is twofold : ( a ) to change the deformation conditions from isothermal to nearly adiabatic ; under nearly adiabatic conditions the combined effect of thermal softening and strain hardening tends to produce net softening response . ( b ) strain rate has an effect _ per se _ and induces momentum diffusion that needs to be included in the constitutive modeling . a theory of thermoviscoplasticity is commonly used to model shear bands and we refer to @xcite for various accounts of the modeling aspects . the basic mechanism for localization is encoded in the behavior of the following simple system of differential equations @xmath52 ( which is the adiabatic case @xmath43 of ) . this model is appropriate for a non - newtonian fluid with temperature dependent viscosity , and is also a simplification of the models proposed in @xcite to capture the mechanism for shear band formation in high strain - rate plastic deformations of metals . the argument - adapted to the language of a temperature dependent fluid - goes as follows : as the fluid gets sheared the dissipation produces heat and elevates the temperature of the fluid . the viscosity decreases with the elevation of the temperature and the fluid becomes softer and easier to shear . one eventuality is that the shear deformation distributes uniformly across the material in the same manner as it does for the usual newtonian fluids . this arrangement is described by the uniform shearing solution . a second mode of response is suggested when comparing the behavior of the fluid in two spots : one hot and one cold . since the viscosity is weaker in the hot spot and stronger in the cold spots , the amount of shear generated in the hot spot will be larger than the shear generated in the cold spot and in turn the temperature difference will be intensified . it is then conceivable that the deformation localizes into a narrow band where the material is considerably hotter ( and weaker ) than the surrounding environment . the two possibilities are depicted in fig . [ shearflow ] . the outcome of the competition of thermal softening and momentum diffusion is captured by the behavior of solutions to . a series of works analyze the system mostly for power law viscosities @xmath53 these studies show stable response @xcite when @xmath54 , and indicate unstable response @xcite but without characterizing the behavior in the complementary region @xmath55 . more precisely , in the unstable regime tzavaras @xcite shows that development of shear bands can be induced by stress boundary conditions leading to finite - time blow - up , and that their occurrence is associated with a collapse of stress diffusion across the band . on the other hand , bertsch , peletier and verduyn - lunel @xcite show that if the problem has global solutions and there is a sufficiently large initial temperature perturbation , then a shear band appears as the asymptotic in time state . careful and detailed numerical investigations @xcite indicate that instability is widespread in the parameter regime @xmath55 and is typically followed by the development of shear bands . the behavior in the instability domain " is at present poorly understood , especially regarding the precise mechanism of formation of the shear band . the reason is the response in this regime results from the competition between an ill - posed problem and a parabolic regularization , and little mathematical theory is available to study such effects . nevertheless , an asymptotic theory similar to the chapman - enskog expansion is used by katsaounis - tzavaras @xcite to calculate an effective equation for the compound effect of thermal softening and strain - rate sensitivity . the effective equation changes type from forward to backward parabolic across the instability threshold , and thus provides an asymptotic criterion for the onset of localization . in the present work , we will develop a mathematical framework for studying the competition and for examining the conjecture of @xcite . our analysis is facilitated by the use of the exponential law inducing special scaling properties on the resulting system of partial differential equations . in the mechanics literature shear localization is typically associated with hadamard - instability . this is easily put on display for , by considering the limiting case @xmath50 and @xmath43 . in the parlance of mechanics , this corresponds to rate - insensitive deformations and absence of heat conduction , and leads to the system of conservation laws @xmath56 for @xmath57 the wave speeds are both imaginary , @xmath58 , and the linearized initial value problem for is ill - posed . two questions then emerge : 1 . to assess the combined effect of the competition between hadamard instability and momentum diffusion and/or heat conduction ( as manifested by small @xmath2 and @xmath18 respectively ) . while hadamard instability indicates the catastrophic growth of oscillations around a mean state , it does not by itself explain the formation of coherent structures typically observed in localization . the latter is an outcome of the nonlinear effects and has to be assessed at the level of the nonlinear problem . the first objective is to develop quantitative criteria for the stability of the uniform shearing solutions . since the basic solutions are time dependent an issue arises how to define their stability . following @xcite , we call the uniform shearing solution _ asymptotically stable _ if perturbations of the solution decay faster than the basic solution , and we call it _ unstable _ if they grow faster than the uniform shearing solution . it is expedient to introduce a relative perturbation formulation of the problem : for the _ exponential law _ , we introduce the state @xmath59 describing the relative perturbation and defined through the transformation @xmath60 where @xmath61 is given by and satisfies in particular that @xmath62 using and we derive the system satisfied by the relative perturbation @xmath59 in the form @xmath63 \theta_t - \kappa \theta_{xx } & = \sigma_s ( t ) \ , \big ( \sigma \ , u -1 \big ) , \\[2pt ] \sigma & = e^{-\alpha \theta } u^n . \end{aligned}\ ] ] note that the uniform shearing solution is mapped to the state @xmath64 , @xmath65 and @xmath66 , and the latter is an equilibrium for the system . the problem then becomes to study the stability of the equilibrium @xmath67 for the non - autonomous system . in this section we present an analysis of the linearized system . since the uniform shearing solution is time - dependent the linearized analysis will seek to classify the precise growth in - time of perturbations . we compute the linearized problem , using the ansatz @xmath68 where @xmath69 is a small parameter measuring the size of the perturbation and @xmath70 . expansion of the equation @xmath71 gives to the leading order of @xmath69 @xmath72 while linearizing the other two equations gives @xmath73 collecting the equations together and neglecting the terms of @xmath74 we obtain the linearized system : @xmath75 { \bar \theta}_t - \kappa { \bar \theta}_{xx } & = \sigma_s ( t ) \ , \big ( ( n+1 ) { \bar u}- \alpha { \bar \theta}\big ) , \\[2pt ] { \bar \sigma}&= n { \bar u}- \alpha { \bar \theta}. \end{aligned } \right .\ ] ] the boundary conditions and and the transformations and , imply that the induced boundary conditions for the linearized system are @xmath76 in view of the transformations and , the relation between the original solution @xmath77 and the solution of the linear problem is as follows @xmath78 our analysis of the linearized equation is facilitated by introducing the transformation of variables @xmath79 where @xmath80 is a rescaling of time , defined by @xmath81 the map @xmath80 is invertible and its inverse is given by @xmath82 one computes that @xmath83 satisfy the linear system @xmath84 \frac{{\partial}{\hat \theta}}{{\partial}\tau } - \kappa c_0 e^{\alpha \tau } { \hat \theta}_{xx } & = ( n+1 ) { \hat u}- \alpha { \hat \theta } , \\[2pt ] { \hat \sigma}&= n { \hat u}- \alpha { \hat \theta } , \end{aligned } \right .\ ] ] with boundary conditions @xmath85 for further reference , we record that the original variables @xmath86 and the solution @xmath87 of the rescaled problem - are related through the formulas @xmath88 we next consider the system @xmath89 \frac{{\partial}{\hat \theta}}{{\partial}\tau } - k { \hat \theta}_{xx } & = ( n+1 ) { \hat u}- \alpha { \hat \theta } , \end{aligned } \right .\ ] ] with boundary conditions . note that in the thermal diffusion coefficient @xmath90 is time dependent , while in this coefficient is frozen in time . we analyze the solutions of via an eigenvalue analysis . this provides the following information : 1 . for @xmath91 it provides the stability or instability properties of the linearized system . 2 . for @xmath92 the eigenvalue analysis will only offer an indication of the effect of thermal diffusion on the linearized analysis . this will be complemented by an energy estimate analysis of the exact system in the following section . the solutions of - are expressed as a cosine fourier series @xmath93 where the fourier coefficients @xmath94 satisfy the ordinary differential equations @xmath95 the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath96 are the roots of the binomial equation @xmath97 * the mode @xmath98*. for @xmath99 the equation becomes @xmath100 and has two eigenvalues @xmath101 and @xmath102 . this corresponds to marginal stability for the linearized system . however , any instability associated with the eigenvalue @xmath101 is eliminated by , which imply for the perturbation @xmath103 in the condition @xmath104 . indeed , the system for @xmath105 takes the form @xmath106 this implies , using , , and the boundary condition , that @xmath107 and clearly @xmath108 decays . thus , the @xmath109-th mode decays . * the modes @xmath110*. for these modes the eigenvalues are @xmath111 where the discriminant @xmath112 since @xmath113 we conclude that @xmath114 in summary : 1 . if @xmath115 then all modes @xmath116 are unstable . 2 . if @xmath92 the first few modes might be unstable , that is the modes @xmath117 for which @xmath118 , but the high frequency modes are stable . 3 . the higher @xmath119 the fewer the number of unstable modes . for @xmath119 larger than a certain threshold ( here equal to @xmath120 ) all modes are asymptotically stable . we analyze the behavior of the linearized modes as a function of @xmath117 and discuss the nature of the instability in the various special cases of interest . the analysis reveals the role of the parameters @xmath121 regarding the nature of the instability . in this regime @xmath122 one eigenvalue is negative and the other strictly positive and increasing with @xmath117 . using the taylor series development @xmath123 we obtain the following asymptotic developments for the eigenvalues @xmath124 referring to the formulas , and , we see that the @xmath117-th mode of the perturbation grows to the leading order like @xmath125 clearly the perturbation grows much faster than the uniform shearing solution @xmath126 given by where the growth is logarithmic , and the behavior is characteristic of _ hadamard instability _ , that is the high frequency oscillations grow at a catastrophic rate . in this case the eigenvalues of the @xmath117-th mode are given by the formulas @xmath127 again we have one negative and one positive eigenvalue and thus unstable response in this regime as well . using once again the taylor expansion we obtain the asymptotic expansions @xmath128 for the positive and negative eigenvalues respectively . the positive eigenvalue @xmath129 satisfies the following properties : @xmath130 set @xmath131 and recall that @xmath132 satisfies the identity @xmath133 differentiating , we derive @xmath134 next , using the elementary bound @xmath135 for @xmath136 we obtain @xmath137 _ + ( x ) & = - + ( n x + ) < < . @xmath137 this shows that @xmath138 and provides and . then follows from . the following remarks are in order : observe first that , by virtue of , and , the @xmath117-th mode of the perturbation grows like @xmath139 clearly the perturbation grows much faster than the uniform shearing solution @xmath126 , but the rate of growth is bounded in @xmath117 . on the other hand , the growth becomes very fast as the rate sensitivity @xmath140 . the behavior in this regime is characterized by _ turing instability_. recall , that turing instability @xcite corresponds to the following scenario that occurs in some instances of dynamical systems . there are two dynamical systems @xmath141 where the spectrum of both matrices @xmath142 and @xmath143 lies in the left - hand plane , but the trotter product of the two systems @xmath144 exhibits unstable response . indeed , the dynamical system with @xmath115 may be visualized as the trotter product of the two systems @xmath145 and @xmath146 each of and has spectrum in the left half space but the eigenvalues of have unstable response . in this regime the eigenvalues are given by and they are real and have the properties @xmath147 therefore , the high modes are stable , but the low modes might be unstable if @xmath119 is sufficiently small . the most unstable " mode is the first mode . one can again carry out the large @xmath117 asymptotics of the eigenvalues . the result , in the case that @xmath148 , reads @xmath149 a similar formula holds when @xmath150 . consider now the linearized system with boundary condition @xmath151 . since we are interested in perturbations of the uniform shearing solution we will consider initial data that satisfy @xmath152 and thus focus on solutions with @xmath153 the objective is now to analyze the effect of the time - dependent diffusion on the dynamics of the system . the linearized analysis of the system with frozen coefficients suggests to expect that diffusion stabilizes the system and its effect is intensified with the passage of time . indeed , here we provide a rigorous proof of this statement via energy estimates . [ lemdecay ] there exist @xmath154 and @xmath155 such that @xmath156 and @xmath157 we multiply @xmath158 by @xmath159 and @xmath160 by @xmath161 and obtain the identities @xmath162 using cauchy - schwarz inequality , gives @xmath163 in view of , we may use the poincare inequality @xmath164 combining the above , we note that for @xmath142 a positive constant we have @xmath165 next we select @xmath142 such that @xmath166 , and deduce that for @xmath142 thus selected there is a choice @xmath167 such that @xmath168 select now @xmath169 such that @xmath170 for @xmath171 ( recall from that @xmath172 when @xmath173 ) . on the interval @xmath171 , we have the differential inequality @xmath174 the latter implies and yields , upon using gronwall s inequality and , @xmath175 and concludes the proof the next lemma provides control of the intermediate times . [ lembound ] there exist @xmath176 and a constant @xmath177 such that @xmath178 using again and we have for any @xmath179 @xmath180 select now @xmath143 large so that @xmath181 for all @xmath182 , and then we obtain @xmath183 from where follows via gronwall s inequality . we conclude now the analysis of stability . suppose that for some @xmath184 the initial data satisfy @xmath185 and are controlled in @xmath186 by @xmath187 then , imply @xmath188 together they imply that the state @xmath189 is stable in @xmath186 , and in fact on account of it is asymptotically stable . we state the result in the following : for the initial - boundary value problem , with @xmath18 , if the initial perturbation @xmath190 satisfies @xmath191 then the equilibrium @xmath189 is asymptotically stable in @xmath186 . the proof of the above lemmas and the analysis of the linearized problem with frozen coefficients indicate that the perturbation of the base solution may drift far from the origin until eventually it is recaptured as the effect of the diffusion intensifies with time . this phenomenon of _ metastability _ also appears in numerical experiments for the nonlinear problem ; an instance of these experiments appears in figure [ mtstb ] . we solve numerically the rescaled system for @xmath192 . the initial conditions are perturbations of the uniform shearing solutions and they are : @xmath193 and @xmath194 , where @xmath195 is a small gaussian perturbation centered at the middle of the interval . the numerical method is based on adaptivity in space and time . an adaptive finite element method is used for the spatial discretisation while a runge - kutta method with variable time step is used for the discretisation in time . further details concerning the numerical scheme and the adaptivity criteria can be found in @xcite . in figure [ mtstb ] the evolution in time ( in natural logarithmic scale ) is presented for the original variables @xmath35 and @xmath37 in ; @xmath37 is sketched in natural logarithmic scale . we notice that , after a transient period of localization , thermal diffusion dominates the process , inhomogeneities of the state variables dissipate , and eventually the solution approaches a uniform shearing solution . ( left ) , @xmath196 ( right).,title="fig:",width=302,height=226 ] ( left ) , @xmath196 ( right).,title="fig:",width=302,height=226 ] we consider next the problem on the whole real line and put aside the boundary conditions . the objective is to construct special solutions that capture a process of localization . this is done over three sections . the present one is preliminary in nature and discusses various properties that make the construction feasible and the setting of the problem . the main step is performed in section [ secss ] where a special class of self - similar solutions are constructed . the localized solutions are then presented in section [ seclocalii ] . we consider on @xmath197 and recall the notation @xmath198 . the uniform shearing solutions are defined by solving . introduce the transformation @xmath199 which involves a passage to relative perturbations ( as in section [ secrelpert ] ) and a change of time scale from the original to a rescaled time @xmath80 . the scaling @xmath80 is precisely the one used in the linearized analysis of sections [ secchatime ] and [ seclinfroz ] ; it is defined by @xmath200 it satisfies @xmath201 where @xmath202 is as in , @xmath203 . the scaling @xmath204 satisfies @xmath205 as @xmath206 , and @xmath80 is invertible with inverse map given by @xmath82 the functions @xmath207 satisfy the system of partial differential equations @xmath208 { \hat \theta}_\tau - \kappa c_0 e^{\alpha \tau } { \hat \theta}_{xx } & = \big ( { \hat \sigma}\ , { \hat u}-1 \big ) , \\[2pt ] { \hat \sigma}&= e^{-\alpha { \hat \theta } } { \hat u}^n . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we emphasize that * for @xmath18 the system is non - autonomous , which is natural in view of the nature of the transformation . * notably , for @xmath43 the system becomes autonomous . next , we consider the adiabatic case @xmath43 where takes the form @xmath209 { \hat \theta}_\tau & = \big ( { \hat \sigma}\ , { \hat u}-1 \big ) , \\[2pt ] { \hat \sigma}&= e^{-\alpha { \hat \theta } } { \hat u}^n \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] to understand the long time response of we perform a formal asymptotic analysis following ideas from @xcite . fix an observational time scale @xmath169 and introduce the change of variables @xmath210 one easily checks that @xmath211 satisfies the system @xmath212 \tfrac{1}{t } \ , { \tilde \theta}_s & = \big ( { \tilde \sigma}\ , { \tilde u}-1 \big ) , \\[2pt ] { \tilde \sigma}&= e^{-\alpha { \tilde \theta } } { \tilde u}^n . \end{aligned}\ ] ] we are interested in calculating the equation describing the effective response of for @xmath169 sufficiently large . this asymptotic analysis involves a parabolic equation @xmath158 , which can be thought as a moment equation , and equations @xmath160 and @xmath71 , which may be thought as describing a relaxation process towards the equilibrium curve described by @xmath213 note that the equilibria are a one - dimensional curve parametrized by @xmath214 . to calculate the effective equation we perform a procedure analogous to the chapman - enskog expansion of kinetic theory . we refer to ( * ? ? ? * sec 5 ) for the details of the asymptotic analysis . the procedure produces the following effective equation @xmath215 which captures the effective response up to order @xmath216 . the leading term is backward parabolic and the first order correction is fourth order . one checks that the effect of the fourth order term is to stabilize the equation , in the sense that the linearized equation around the equilibrium @xmath217 is stable ( see @xcite for the details ) . it was further shown in @xcite that admits special solutions that exhibit localization , which is not surprising as the leading response in is backward parabolic . localized solutions of a similar nature will be constructed here directly for the system . this is a more unexpected " behavior , because is at least _ pro - forma _ a hyperbolic - parabolic " system , and the explanation for this behavior lies precisely in the asymptotic relation between and . it is easy to check that for @xmath43 the system is invariant under the one - parameter scaling transformation @xmath218 for any @xmath219 . it is also easy to check that this is the only scaling transformation under which the problem is invariant . this transformation has the distinctive feature that the scaling of space is independent of the scaling of time . finally , the system is not scaling invariant when the thermal diffusion @xmath49 is positive . the scaling invariance motivates a change of variables and a related _ ansatz _ of solutions . introduce a variable in time scaling @xmath220 , the variable @xmath221 , and the change of variables @xmath222 we denote by @xmath223 and by @xmath224 . introducing to , we obtain that the function @xmath225 satisfies the system of partial differential equations @xmath226 { \bar \theta}_\tau - \frac{\dot r}{r } \left ( \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } + \xi { \bar \theta}_{\xi } \right ) , - \kappa c_0 \frac{e^{\alpha \tau}}{r^2 ( \tau ) } { \bar \theta}_{\xi \xi } & = \big ( { \bar \sigma}\ , { \bar u}-1 \big ) , \\[2pt ] { \bar \sigma}&= e^{-\alpha { \bar \theta } } { \bar u}^n . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the resulting system depends on the choice of the scaling function @xmath227 . we will be interested in solutions that are steady states in the new variables . of course such solutions are dynamically evolving in the original variables . there are two cases that produce simplified results of interest : 1 . consider the case @xmath18 , and select @xmath228 . then the system is consistent with the ansatz of steady state solutions @xmath229 and the latter are constructed by solving the system of ordinary differential equations @xmath230 -\frac{\alpha}{2 } \left ( \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } + \xi { \bar \theta } ' \right ) - \kappa c_0 { \bar \theta } '' & = { \bar \sigma}\ , { \bar u}-1 , \\[2pt ] { \bar \sigma}&= e^{-\alpha { \bar \theta } } { \bar u}^n . \end{aligned}\ ] ] + since @xmath231 as @xmath232 increases , solutions of will produce defocusing solutions for . a study of is expected to give information about the convergence to the uniform shearing state in the non adiabatic setting . this is not the focus of the present work and we will not deal further with the system . 2 . instead we consider the case @xmath43 . we may now select any exponential function for @xmath227 but are most interested in @xmath233 with @xmath24 as this produces focusing solutions . with this selection , @xmath229 is a steady solution for with @xmath43 provided it satisfies @xmath234 \lambda \left ( \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } + \xi { \bar \theta } ' \right ) & = { \bar \sigma}\ , { \bar u}-1 , \\[2pt ] { \bar \sigma}&= e^{-\alpha { \bar \theta } } { \bar u}^n , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath24 is a parameter . note that : * the form of the transformation is motivated by the scaling invariance . * the scaling connects the two variables and produces interesting systems even in the case @xmath49 positive when the system is not scale invariant . we are ready to state and prove the main result of the paper . this concerns the adiabatic case @xmath378 of system , taken now on the whole real line @xmath379 and expressed in terms of the variable @xmath19 in the form : @xmath380 our analysis is based on the transformations of section [ seclocal ] and the self - similar solution constructed in section [ secss ] . [ shearband ] let @xmath381 and @xmath247 be given . for any @xmath24 , the system admits a special class of solutions describing localization of the form : @xmath382 \label{locsigma } \sigma ( x , t ) & = \sigma_s ( t ) \left ( \tfrac{\alpha}{c_0 } t + 1 \right ) ^ { - \tfrac{\lambda}{\alpha } } \sigma_\lambda \left ( \sqrt{\lambda } x \left ( \tfrac{\alpha}{c_0 } t + 1 \right ) ^{\tfrac{\lambda}{\alpha } } \right ) , \\[2pt ] \label{loctheta } \theta(x , t ) & = \left ( 1 + \lambda \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } \right ) \theta_s ( t ) - \lambda \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } \theta_0 + \theta_\lambda \left ( \sqrt{\lambda } x \left ( \tfrac{\alpha}{c_0 } t + 1 \right ) ^{\tfrac{\lambda}{\alpha } } \right ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath46 , @xmath45 are the uniform shear solutions in , @xmath203 , while @xmath383 is an even function defined on @xmath384 , which solves the initial value problem , with @xmath385 for @xmath386 . [ rmkbeh ] 1 . 2 . because @xmath387 goes to infinity in time , the level curves of @xmath388 accumulate along the @xmath389 axis in the @xmath390 plane . the functions , , thus describe a localizing solution where the flow tends to concentrate around @xmath33 as the time proceeds . the solution , , is defined on @xmath391 and emanates from initial data @xmath392 \sigma ( x,0 ) & = \sigma_s ( 0 ) \sigma_\lambda \big ( \sqrt{\lambda } x \big ) , \\[2pt ] \theta(x,0 ) & = \theta_s ( 0 ) + \theta_\lambda \big ( \sqrt{\lambda } x \big ) \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the initial data depend on two parameters : the parameter @xmath28 which can be thought as a length scale in initial data , and @xmath29 in which describes the amplitude of the initial perturbation . this parametric family of solutions is valid for any @xmath24 . if @xmath28 is large then the length scale of the initial perturbation is short while the growth in time and the rate of localization for the solution become fast . we introduce the changes of variables and the stationary variant of , which once combined together reads @xmath393 we select @xmath394 with @xmath24 . according to the analysis in section [ secinvariance ] the function @xmath395 is sought as a solution of defined on the interval @xmath396 . the desired @xmath395 is constructed as follows . first , observe the relation between the system and the system . let @xmath29 be fixed , and let @xmath397 be the solution of with @xmath26 and , defined for @xmath398 . this solution is well defined by theorem [ connection ] . using a direct computation , the smoothness properties in ( iii ) of theorem [ connection ] , and we conclude that 1 . the function @xmath399 defined by @xmath400 satisfies on @xmath401 and the condition @xmath402 . if we extend @xmath399 on @xmath403 by setting @xmath404 for @xmath405 , the resulting function @xmath406 , @xmath407 is a solution of defined on the whole real line that is even . noting that @xmath408 we combine with and to arrive at , , . in figure [ uqsol ] the profiles of @xmath409 and @xmath410 in and , respectively , are drawn at various instances of time from @xmath411 to @xmath412 . to achieve these profiles , we construct numerically the heteroclinic orbit for whose existence is justified in proposition [ thode ] . the construction is simple , if one exploits the special properties of system , and proceeds as follows : initial conditions @xmath413 are selected close to the equilibrium @xmath303 inside the region @xmath311 and in the direction of the stable manifold of @xmath284 for the linearized problem . then is solved backward in time , using an ode solver , and since @xmath414 is an unstable node ( for the forward problem ) the resulting orbit is a good approximation of the heteroclinic . for the integration of we use an explicit runge kutta predictor - corrector method of order ( 4,5 ) with adaptive time stepping . then @xmath29 is selected by choosing an appropriate parametrisation @xmath344 following the construction in . , and @xmath410 , .,title="fig:",width=302,height=226 ] , and @xmath410 , .,title="fig:",width=302,height=226 ] for the numerical runs the constitutive parameters are @xmath415 , @xmath416 . the parameters related to the solution are @xmath417 , @xmath418 while for the selected reparametrization of the heteroclinic orbit the value of @xmath419 . once the heteroclinic has been constructed , the profiles @xmath420 are computed via the changes of variables and . finally , @xmath409 and @xmath410 are computed by , respectively with @xmath417 , and are presented in fig [ uqsol ] . in this section we consider the system of ordinary differential equations @xmath235 \nu \left ( \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } + \xi \theta ' \right ) & = \sigma \ , u -1 , \\[2pt ] \sigma & = e^{-\alpha \theta } u^n \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] on the domain @xmath236 with @xmath237 , subject to the initial condition @xmath238 this is an auxiliary problem that will be studied in detail in this section . we emphasize that it does not coincide with the integrated form of , however it will be used together with additional properties in order to construct solutions of and localizing solutions for in the following section . in this section , we are interested in constructing solutions @xmath239 for the singular initial value problem , for any @xmath237 . the following elementary remarks are in order : 1 . when @xmath240 , simplifies to @xmath241 \sigma ( 0 ) & = \sigma_0 \end{aligned } \right . \left \ { \begin{aligned } \sigma \ , u & = 1 \\[2pt ] \theta & = \frac{n+1}{\alpha } \log u \end{aligned } \right . .\ ] ] the solution of is computed explicitly by @xmath242 2 . when @xmath243 , the system is invariant under the family of scaling transformations @xmath244 for @xmath245 . there is a special solution of that is self - similar with respect to the scaling invariance and reads @xmath246 this solution does not however satisfy the initial condition . we next construct a function @xmath239 which satisfies , for all values of @xmath237 and @xmath247 . we will show that the constructed solution will have the inner behavior of and the outer behavior of . [ connection ] let @xmath247 be fixed . let us note @xmath248 . given @xmath237 there exists a solution @xmath249 of , defined for @xmath250 and satisfying the properties : 1 . it achieves the initial data @xmath251 where @xmath29 as in and @xmath252 , @xmath253 are defined via @xmath254 2 . as @xmath255 it has the limiting behavior @xmath256 \theta ( \xi ) & = - \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } \log \xi + o(1 ) . \end{aligned}\ ] ] 3 . the solution has the regularity @xmath257 , @xmath258 , @xmath259 . it satisfies @xmath260 and has the taylor expansion as @xmath261 , @xmath262 where as usual @xmath263 ( but the rate may degenerate as @xmath264 tends to @xmath109 ) . _ step 1 . _ motivated by the special solution we introduce a change of variables in two steps : @xmath265 \theta ( \xi ) & = - \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } \log \xi + { \bar \theta } ( \xi ) & & = - \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } \log \xi + \theta ( \log \xi ) , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] indeed , we easily check that @xmath266 satisfies the system of equations @xmath267 \nu \xi \ , { \bar \theta } ' & = { \bar \sigma } \ , { \bar u } -1 , \\[2pt ] { \bar \sigma } & = e^{-\alpha { \bar \theta } } { \bar u}^n \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] in the second step , we introduce in the change of independent variable @xmath268 and derive that @xmath269 satisfy @xmath270 \nu \frac{d\theta}{d\eta } & = \sigma \ , u -1 , \\[2pt ] \sigma & = e^{-\alpha \theta } u^n \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the system is far simpler than the original in that it is autonomous and non singular . we next consider and perform a further simplification , via the change of dependent variables @xmath271 note that @xmath272 . we now compute @xmath273 and @xmath274 in summary , we conclude that @xmath275 satisfies the autonomous system of ordinary differential equations @xmath276 where @xmath277 there are two advantages in relative to : 1 . is expressed via only two independent variables @xmath278 . the equilibrium at infinity in is pulled at the axis for via the transformation . we perform a phase space analysis of and establish the existence of a heteroclinic connection . we show : [ thode ] consider the autonomous planar system of differential equations with @xmath279 defined by . for any @xmath237 the system has the following properties : * @xmath280 has two equilibria @xmath281 , @xmath282 in the first quadrant . both @xmath283 and @xmath284 are hyperbolic points , @xmath283 is a repelling node while @xmath284 is a saddle point . * there exists a heteroclinic orbit connecting @xmath283 to @xmath284 . _ proof of proposition [ thode ] . _ 1 . the system has the special solution @xmath285 this solution splits the phase portrait into the left and right plane and acts as a barrier from crossing from the one side to the other . the equilibria of are computed by solving @xmath286 and they are @xmath287 and @xmath288 and @xmath289 . focusing on the behavior in the first quadrant we neglect the equilibrium @xmath290 . a computation shows @xmath291 -2 \tfrac{n+1}{n } a & \tfrac{\alpha}{n\nu } c_\nu \end{pmatrix } .\ ] ] at the equilibrium @xmath283 we have @xmath292 and we have eigenvalues @xmath293 with eigenvector @xmath294 , and @xmath295 with eigenvector @xmath296 . in view of , we have @xmath297 . the local behavior of solutions of around the equilibrium @xmath283 is that of a repelling node . standard phase plane theory for second order systems ( _ e.g. _ @xcite ) states that there is a small neighbourhood of the equilibrium @xmath283 such that for any given solution @xmath298 of there are constants @xmath299 , @xmath300 such that @xmath301 as @xmath302 . 4 . at the point @xmath303 equation gives @xmath304 the eigenvalues @xmath305 , computed by @xmath306 are @xmath307 with eigenvector @xmath308 and @xmath309 with eigenvector @xmath310 . @xmath284 is a saddle point . 5 . consider the region @xmath311 bounded by the curves * @xmath312 is the @xmath313-axis defined by the equation @xmath314 , * @xmath315 is the horizontal line @xmath316 , * @xmath317 is the parabola @xmath318 . + the region @xmath311 is expressed as @xmath319 see figure [ fig : phase2 ] . + + we will show that @xmath311 is negatively invariant . + indeed , the flow of is parallel to @xmath312 as indicated in ( b ) . on the horizontal line @xmath320 the system gives @xmath321 on the curve @xmath322 the system gives @xmath323 therefore @xmath311 is negatively invariant . 6 . for completeness we also show that the vector @xmath324 associated to the eigenvalue @xmath325 at @xmath284 points towards the interior of the region @xmath311 . recall that @xmath284 is the upper right corner of the region @xmath311 and that * the tangent vector to @xmath315 is @xmath326 , * the tangent vector to @xmath317 at @xmath303 is @xmath327 , * the eigenvector @xmath328 . + we will show that @xmath329 this then implies that the vector @xmath330 when placed at the corner @xmath284 points strictly towards the interior of @xmath311 . to show recall that @xmath307 and use and to rewrite @xmath331 where @xmath332 this shows @xmath333 and concludes . it is easy to check that there can be no closed limit cycle in @xmath311 because in that region @xmath334 the poincar - bendixson theorem implies that there exists a heteroclinic orbit joining @xmath335 and @xmath336 which emanates along the direction of the stable manifold at @xmath336 and progresses backwards in time towards the node at @xmath335 . we turn now to defining the solution of , . let @xmath337 stand for a parametrization of the heteroclinic orbit . in view of and the fact that @xmath338 , there exists a constant @xmath299 such that @xmath339 due to the fact that the vertical axis is a trajectory of its own and thus distinct from the trajectory we are considering , and due to the form of the phase portrait we can assert that @xmath340 . for any @xmath341 the function @xmath342 offers an alternative parametrization of the same heteroclinic orbit . applying to this parametrization yields @xmath343 choose @xmath344 such that @xmath345 and let @xmath298 denote the corresponding parametrization of the heteroclinic : @xmath346 the selected parametrization satisfies as @xmath302 @xmath347 where as usual @xmath348 as @xmath302 . recalling the changes of variables and we define @xmath349 the function clearly satisfies the system and , since @xmath350 as @xmath351 , it satisfies @xmath352 \theta ( \xi ) & = - \tfrac{n+1}{\alpha } \log \xi + o(1 ) , \end{aligned}\ ] ] as @xmath353 goes to infinity , which shows . in the last step , we study the behavior near the ( apparent ) singular point at @xmath354 and prove that the solution is in fact regular there and satisfies , and . clearly and @xmath160 imply that @xmath355 as @xmath261 . let @xmath252 and @xmath253 be defined by . since @xmath356 , gives @xmath357 now , , , imply @xmath358 and together with and provide . observe now that @xmath359 using , and , we obtain @xmath360 \\ & = \tfrac{1}{n } u^3 b - u \tfrac{\alpha}{\nu n } \frac{c_\nu}{b } \big ( b - \frac{1}{c_\nu } \big ) \\ & = \tfrac{1}{n } \tfrac{u_0 ^ 3}{c_\nu } e^{3 \eta}(1 + o(1 ) ) - \tfrac{\alpha}{\nu n } u_0 o(1 ) e^{2\eta } \qquad \mbox{as $ \eta \to -\infty$ } \end{aligned}\ ] ] and thus @xmath361 since @xmath362 \cap c^1(0,1)$ ] the mean value theorem implies @xmath363 and implies @xmath364 exists and @xmath365 . we conclude that @xmath366 has the taylor expansion @xmath158 . in turn , @xmath367 , @xmath368 , @xmath369 and @xmath370 achieves the taylor expansion @xmath160 . turning to @xmath371 , observe that by and @xmath71 @xmath372 while @xmath373 in addition , @xmath374 combined with the formula @xmath375 gives @xmath376 this shows @xmath377 has the taylor expansion @xmath71 at the origin . we considered the system as a paradigm to study the onset of localization and formation of shear bands and to examine the role of thermal softening , strain - rate hardening and thermal diffusion in their development . the stability of the uniform shear solution leads , in general , to the analysis of a non - autonomous system . the present model has the remarkable property that the system of relative perturbations is autonomous in the adiabatic case ( @xmath421 ) . a study of linearized stability for the case with no thermal diffusion @xmath378 shows that : ( i ) for @xmath17 the high frequency modes grow exponentially fast , with the exponent proportional to the frequency , what is characteristic of ill - posedness and hadamard instability . ( ii ) when @xmath2 the modes are still unstable but the rate of growth is bounded independently of the frequency . the behavior in that range is that characteristic of turing instability . the effect of thermal diffusion ( @xmath18 ) for the non - autonomous linearized model was also assessed ; it was shown that perturbations grow in the early stages of deformation , but over time the compound effect of diffusion stabilizes the response of the system . then we turned to the nonlinear system and constructed a class of self - similar solutions on the real line , leading to the explicit solutions , , . their construction is based on the self - similar profiles of , , in turn determined by a suitable heteroclinic connection . they depend on three parameters : @xmath27 linked to the uniform shear in , a parameter @xmath28 which can be viewed as a length scale of initial data , and @xmath29 determining the size of the initial profile . the solutions presented in fig [ uqsol ] evidently exhibit localisation : as time increases a coherent structure forms with the deformation localizing in a narrow band . in this self - similar solution there is no trace of the oscillations . a comparison with the modes of the linearized problem indicates that the nonlinearity suppresses the oscillations and a seamless coherent structure emerges as the net outcome of hadamard instability , rate dependence , and the nonlinear structure of the problem . , _ localization and shear bands in high strain - rate plasticity_. in nonlinear conservation laws and applications , a. bressan , g .- q . chen , m. lewiscka and d. wang , eds ; i m a vol . math . appl . , 153 , springer , new york , 2011 , pp 365 - 378 .
Abstract: | [
"shear localization occurs in various instances of material instability in solid mechanics and is typically associated with hadamard - instability for an underlying model . while hadamard instability indicates the catastrophic growth of oscillations around a mean state , it does not by itself explain the formation of coherent structures typically observed in localization . the latter is a nonlinear effect and its analysis is the main objective of this article . we consider a model that captures the main mechanisms observed in high strain - rate deformation of metals , and describes shear motions of temperature dependent non - newtonian fluids . for a special dependence of the viscosity on the temperature , we carry out a linearized stability analysis around a base state of uniform shearing solutions , and quantitatively assess the effects of the various mechanisms affecting the problem : thermal softening , momentum diffusion and thermal diffusion . then , we turn to the nonlinear model , and construct localized states - in the form of similarity solutions - that emerge as coherent structures in the localization process . this justifies a scenario for localization that is proposed on the basis of asymptotic analysis in @xcite ."
] | 9,011 | 9,011 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the two - dimensional ( 2d ) ferromagnetic xy model has had a long history of studies concerning the dynamics of spinwaves at low temperatures . it was first analyzed by villain@xcite and by moussa and villain@xcite , for low temperatures , in the harmonic approximation . they found that the dynamic structure function @xmath1 has a spinwave peak of the form @xmath3 where @xmath4 is the critical exponent describing the decay of the static spin - spin correlation function , and @xmath5 is the spinwave frequency at wavevector @xmath6 . nelson and fisher@xcite treated the model in a fixed - length hydrodynamic description , obtaining the following expression around the spinwave peak , @xmath7 where for small @xmath8 , @xmath9 , with @xmath10 being the spinwave velocity . these theoretical approaches led to spinwave peaks diverging unphysically at the spinwave frequency . here we describe an alternative theoretical description in which the divergence does not occur . at higher temperatures , the spinwave or harmonic approximation begins to fail , and xy magnets are known to undergo a topological phase transition@xcite associated with the unbinding of vortices . we generally consider temperatures below this unbinding temperature @xmath11 , where a spinwave approximation will be valid . at very low temperatures any nonlinear effects should be very weak , do not lead to vortex production , and can be included as the damping or scattering of the spinwave modes , that results in a spinwave lifetime . thus our approach will be to start from the harmonic approximation to the spin hamiltonian , @xmath12 , and then include the damping that results from the terms fourth order in spin operators ( @xmath13 ) in an expansion of the original full spin hamiltonian , @xmath14 . the resulting damping strength @xmath0 will imply a finite lifetime @xmath15 for the spinwave modes . we are interested to investigate whether the presence of such lifetime effects can eliminate the divergence of the dynamic structure function @xmath1 at the spinwave frequency . we calculate the spinwave damping by a feynmann diagram technique for finite temperatures , applied to the fourth - order hamiltonian @xmath13 , using the leading diagrams to second order in @xmath13 . the only diagrams we include are those that give a contribution to the _ imaginary part _ of the spinwave energy , i.e. , to the damping or inverse lifetime . these are the terms that involve a _ dynamical _ effect on the spinwave energies . the associated integral expressions for these diagrams require the evaluation of four - dimensional integrals involving a delta - function . methods for evaluating this type of integral in three dimensions have been developed by gilat and co - workers ; here we show how to extend their work and apply the same technique in four dimensions . in principle , we could also use the feynmann technique to determine the leading changes in the _ real part _ of the spinwave energy , @xmath16 , due to the perturbation @xmath13 . this real part would result as the usual effect due to finite temperature : a shift in the spinwave frequencies to lower values as the temperature increases . it is essentially a _ static _ effect , primarily due to the renormalization of the nearest neighbor exchange interaction strength @xmath17 with temperature . calculation of these spinwave frequency shifts by the feynmann technique would require including diagrams first order in @xmath13 ; the so - called single - loop diagrams . in this paper , however , we are primarily concerned with accounting for dynamical effects . we will include the renormalization of the spinwave energies using the memory function formalism , combined with some input information from classical monte carlo ( mc ) data . in the memory function approach , the position of the spinwave peak in @xmath1 does not occur exactly at the zero - temperature dispersion relation , @xmath5 , but rather , close to the value @xmath18 , where @xmath19 is the temperature - dependent second moment . @xmath19 can be estimated from static quantities , either using low - temperature analytic expressions or results from monte carlo , the latter being necessary for temperatures approaching @xmath11 . the memory function approach already includes to leading order the exchange strength renormalization , as can be seen in the shift in the position of the spinwave peaks . thus we use it rather than making any renormalization of the exchange @xmath17 . a few comments can be made about how the damping @xmath0 is included into the memory function calculation . note that the damping calculation sketched above is completely independent of the memory function calculation ; the latter is a formalism for calculating dynamic correlations for a given hamiltonian and operators . due to the xy symmetry of the model , the natural coordinates of the spins are the in - plane angle @xmath20 and out - of - plane spin component @xmath21 . fourier transforming and using a standard canonical transformation , the hamiltonian is written in terms of creation and annihilation operators @xmath22 and @xmath23 , with time dependencies varying as @xmath24 and @xmath25 , respectively . once damping is included , the time dependencies become @xmath26 and @xmath27 , respectively . henceforth the calculation proceeds as usual in the memory function approach , except for this small modification of the operator time dependencies via the shifted operator frequencies , @xmath28 . in the memory function calculation , spinwave sum and difference processes enter . these are characterized by combinations of frequencies , @xmath29 , where @xmath6 is the wavevector at which the dynamic correlations are measured , and @xmath30 is summed over to include all possible such processes . based on the above modifications of the operator frequencies , there also results the modification for these processes , @xmath31 . the damping rates for different wavevectors always add for both types of processes . the paper is organized as follows : first , in sec . [ model ] , we present the model and develop the expansion of the hamiltonian to quartic order in creation / annihilation operators . in sec . [ diagrams ] , the expressions for the damping via the feynmann technique are presented . then we show how these are evaluated using the gilat procedure . in sec . [ memory ] , the key aspects of the memory function calculation of @xmath1 are reviewed , together with a focus on the modification due to the damping . some details of the monte carlo and spin dynamics simulations are summarized in sec . [ mc+sd ] . this is followed in sec . [ results ] by presentation of the results both for very large and relatively smaller systems , in order to discuss the dynamical finite size effects . the memory function results also are compared with standard monte carlo spin - dynamics calculations of the dynamic correlation functions in order to evaluate the validity and accuracy of the method . our conclusions are presented in sec . [ conclusions ] . the ferromagnetic spin hamiltonian under consideration is @xmath32 where the first sum is over all sites @xmath33 of a 2d square lattice , the second is over all nearest neighbor displacements @xmath34 , @xmath17 is the nearest neighbor coupling strength , and each @xmath35 is a three - component classical spin - vector . because each bond is counted twice , a factor of @xmath36 is included on @xmath17 . we primarily concentrate on the xy model , with anisotropy parameter @xmath37 , however , for completeness , formulas covering the easy - plane anisotropy range , @xmath38 , are presented . in order to develop the damping as a perturbation of the harmonic approximation , we need to expand the full spin hamiltonian , including the harmonic ( quadratic ) and quartic deviations from the ground state . the ground state corresponds to spins aligned in any direction within the xy plane . writing the spins in hamiltonian ( [ hamil ] ) using coordinates @xmath39 and @xmath40 , @xmath41 the hamiltonian becomes @xmath42 ~ , \ ] ] where we use a simplified notation for the nearest neighbors , @xmath43 . at low temperature , it is reasonable to expand for small @xmath40 and @xmath44 , keeping up to quartic order in these , obtaining , @xmath45 where the harmonic and quartic hamiltonians are @xmath46,\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath47 ~ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is convenient to carry out the calculations in wavevector space by defining fourier transforms @xmath48 together with a similar definition for @xmath49 . here @xmath6 denotes a two - dimensional wavevector , the sums are over the first brillouin zone ( bz ) , and @xmath50 is the total number of lattice sites . then we rewrite @xmath12 and @xmath13 as @xmath51 ~ , \ ] ] and @xmath52 for the square lattice , with coordination number @xmath53 , the @xmath54 function @xmath55 is an even function of @xmath6 , i.e. , @xmath56 . the sums in ( [ h1 ] ) are constrained to @xmath57 . using the following canonical transformation to creation / annihilation operators , @xmath58 @xmath59^{1/4 } , \quad\quad \beta_{\bq}=\left[\frac{1-\gamma_{\bq } } { 4s^2(1-\lambda\gamma_{\bq})}\right]^{1/4 } ~ , \ ] ] the quadratic hamiltonian is diagonalized , @xmath60 ~ , \ ] ] @xmath61 the diagonal parts of @xmath13 can then be written as @xmath62 where @xmath63 we have dropped terms in @xmath13 whose expectation values in the ground state are zero . note also that if a particular @xmath64 is zero , then @xmath65 diverges , however , when this occurs the corresponding factors multiplying @xmath65 go to zero faster , canceling the divergence . the time evolution of the creation / annihilation operators as given from the harmonic hamiltonian is @xmath66 as discussed in the introduction , the effect of the @xmath13 perturbation is to shift the spinwave frequencies , in the most general case , by some complex self - energy @xmath67 . for the moment , we ignore the real part of @xmath67 , whose effect will be included by the memory function approach , and concentrate instead on the contributions to the imaginary part of @xmath67 , which determine the spinwave damping . to find @xmath67 , the contributions of @xmath13 to the single particle green s function will be evaluated , keeping only the diagrams that have a nonzero imaginary part . the lowest order diagrams that satisfy this requirement are found to be second order in @xmath13 ; there is no contribution from first order diagrams . following the standard procedure,@xcite the time - ordered zero - temperature green s function , in second order , is @xmath68 here @xmath69 is the time ordering operator , and @xmath70 is the ground state of @xmath12 . physically , this green function represents the amplitude for a quasiparticle ( i.e. , spinwave ) created at time @xmath71 in state @xmath72 to be destroyed at time @xmath73 in state @xmath74 , after undergoing two scattering events due to @xmath13 . the free - particle green function , @xmath75 involves no scattering . due to momentum conservation , these green functions are proportional to the kronecker delta , @xmath76 , so we can drop the double momentum indices . also , because of time translational invariance , they depend only on the time difference @xmath77 . introducing the time fourier transforms , @xmath78 the free propagator becomes the well - known expression , @xmath79 where @xmath80 . we apply the rules for feynmann diagrams to evaluate the full propagator , @xmath81 , in terms of @xmath82 and @xmath83 . the free propagator @xmath84 is represented as a straight line with an associated momentum @xmath30 and frequency @xmath85 . the interaction term in ( [ h_1 ] ) is represented as a wavy line as in fig . [ aq1q2q3q4 ] , with an outgoing straight line ( free propagator ) for each creation operator and an incoming straight line for each destruction operator , both with assigned momentum and frequency . the two leading diagrams that contribute to @xmath86 are shown in fig . [ diagrams ] . following the standard feynmann rules for these diagrams , with summations over the intermediate frequencies and wavevectors , and using momentum and frequency conservation at each junction , @xmath86 can be written as @xmath87 where the self - energy function due to the scattering parts of the diagrams is @xmath88 ~ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath89 is a sum over the `` direct '' and the `` exchanged '' diagrams ; the factor of 4 is the multiplicity of each of these under rearranging the exterior lines . @xmath89 is seen to be @xmath86 with its incoming and outgoing lines removed . the full interacting propagator @xmath81 can be approximated as a sum over repeated applications of @xmath90 , i.e. , @xmath91 which , after summing , leads to the well - known dyson equation , @xmath92 the location of the pole gives the perturbed quasiparticle energy , @xmath93 , and the damping @xmath94 is given by @xmath95 to apply the result to the system at finite temperature @xmath69 , and obtain the self - energy associated with the temperature green s function , the integrals over frequency are transformed to sums according to @xmath96 @xmath97 thus the frequency integrals in ( [ sigma ] ) become @xmath98 [ n(\omega_{\bq}+\omega_{\bk+\bp-\bq})-n(\omega_{\bp } ) ] } { \omega-(\omega_{\bk+\bp-\bq}+\omega_{\bq}-\omega_{\bp } ) } ~ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where the bose factors are @xmath99 the latter form applies to the classical limit . the imaginary part of @xmath100 is derived from the analytic relation , @xmath101 where @xmath102 takes the principal part and @xmath103 is the usual delta - function . because @xmath6 and @xmath104 each have two components , the sum in ( [ sigma ] ) is equivalent to a four - dimensional integration , once we take the continuum limit . each dimension converts as , for example , @xmath105 , where @xmath106 is the system size , in terms of the lattice constant @xmath107 , leading to @xmath108 the factors of @xmath50 here are canceled by those in the expression for @xmath109 , leading to a size - independent result . thus there finally results for the damping function , @xmath110 where the kernel @xmath111 is given by @xmath112 \times \nonumber \\ & & [ n(\omega_{\bq})-n(-\omega_{\bk+\bp-\bq } ) ] [ n(\omega_{\bq}+\omega_{\bk+\bp-\bq})-n(\omega_{\bp } ) ] ~ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] we use this result to calculate the damping at the spinwave frequency : @xmath113 , in the thermodynamic limit @xmath114 . note that in the classical limit , the bose factors are simply proportional to temperature . therefore , we only need to calculate @xmath115 at one temperature ( @xmath116 ) and then scale with @xmath117 to get its value at other temperatures . the summation / integration in ( [ gamma ] ) involving a delta function presents an interesting mathematical problem in its evaluation . general integrals of this form ( i.e. , with one delta - function ) in @xmath118 dimensions can be considered , @xmath119 where @xmath120 is a @xmath118-dimensional vector . in two dimensions , for example , the delta - function will pick off a particular contour that contributes to the integral ; in three dimensions that contour will actually be a surface , and in four dimensions it will be a three - dimensional volume . depending on the form of the function @xmath121 , the contributing region need not be simply connected , but may consist of separated distinct parts . for the higher dimensional cases , it is difficult to visualize the region or regions that contribute to the integral . thus it is necessary to have a way to evaluate the integral without appealing directly to geometrical properties . in a series of papers , gilat and co - workers@xcite have considered how to evaluate these integrals in three dimensions , in work related the calculation of spectral density functions . we have used the `` linear analytic '' ( la ) method@xcite of gilat and raubenheimer , extended to four dimensions , which gives good precision for few sample points , at little cost in complexity . suppose we calculate @xmath122 over a small range of @xmath85 and then take the limit @xmath123 . to do so , a 4d cubic grid of small cells of size @xmath124 is set in the @xmath120-space . then we consider the contribution of each cell to @xmath122 , thereafter summing over the cells . suppose the cells are small enough so that the kernel @xmath125 has only a small variation within a cell , and , therefore , we can use its value at the cell center , @xmath126 . then we can write @xmath127 @xmath128 the idea of the la method is to expand @xmath121 around the cell center , @xmath129 shifting coordinates to @xmath130 , and writing the gradient at the cell center as @xmath131 , where the unit vector @xmath132 points along the gradient evaluated at the cell center , we have @xmath133 @xmath134 the variable @xmath135 is a rescaling of @xmath85 . if we use the integral representation of the delta function , in the form , @xmath136 then the contribution from one cell is found to be @xmath137 where the @xmath138 are the values of parameter @xmath135 at the 16 corners of the cell , i.e. , @xmath139 with all 16 possible choices of the signs , and @xmath140 is the number of minus signs used in each @xmath138 . one can note that similar simple formulas result for this type of integral in other dimensions as well.@xcite in the actual application of eq . ( [ dcell ] ) , inside the cell , the parameter @xmath135 will range between minimum and maximum values : @xmath141 these values hold at two opposite corners of the cell . by eq . ( [ w - omega ] ) , there will be a corresponding range of @xmath85 over which this cell contributes to @xmath122 . then for the general problem where @xmath142 is desired over a large range of @xmath85 , what is done is to set a uniform grid of @xmath85-values , finding the contribution of each cell to @xmath122 for each value on the grid , say , @xmath143 . typically it works well to have the grid fine enough so that each cell contributes to @xmath142 at many different @xmath144 . for the damping problem , eq . ( [ gamma ] ) , we have the replacements , @xmath145 with the 4d variable @xmath146 . we want to find @xmath147 right at @xmath148 for some particular wavevector , @xmath30 . to accomplish this , we set a range @xmath149 , and define the grid of values @xmath150 , using @xmath151 . for the integrations over @xmath6 and @xmath104 , the cell sizes actually can be quite large : we used the cell width @xmath152 , where @xmath153 is a `` system size , '' which gave results consistent with those using much smaller cells ( larger @xmath154 ) . that is , each axis , @xmath155 , @xmath156 , @xmath157 , @xmath158 , was partitioned into 41 cells . first , to get good precision , a narrow range symmetrical around the spinwave frequency was used : @xmath159 , @xmath160 . second , for comparison , the behavior of the damping function was calculated over the whole range of possible spinwave frequencies , i.e. , @xmath161 , @xmath162 . in both of these approaches , interpolation on the @xmath85-grid gives @xmath163 . the scheme was found to be very robust , with both approaches agreeing to better than one percent precision . we should also note one other important calculational detail . because eq . ( [ dcell ] ) depends on the reciprocal gradient of @xmath164 , it is necessary to avoid any points in the @xmath165-space where this gradient vanishes . we accomplished this by taking wavevectors @xmath166 , ( at @xmath153 ) , and then shifting the @xmath165-cell center positions slightly from the usual values : @xmath167 , @xmath168 . here @xmath169 , etc . , are integers ranging from 0 to @xmath170 , and we used @xmath171 to shift the @xmath165-cells away from high symmetry points . the choice of an odd number for @xmath154 also helps to avoid certain high symmetry points . some slight improvement in precision can be achieved with a larger value of @xmath154 , however , at the expense of a tremendous increase in cpu time , which varies as @xmath172 . at @xmath153 , the typical relative errors in @xmath147 were found to be much less than one percent , when compared to calculations using @xmath173 . some results for the damping function , which is proportional to @xmath117 , are shown in fig . [ gam_omega - fig ] for @xmath37 . in general , it is found that @xmath147 either has a cusp or a peak at the spinwave frequency ( arrows in fig . [ gam_omega - fig ] ) . the damping strength increases with @xmath174 , as seen in fig . [ gam_k - fig ] . along the ( 11 ) direction , however , @xmath115 tends to saturate halfway out in the zone . keeping in mind that @xmath175 , the damping strength we find here is quite weak , especially when we consider its effects at @xmath176 where the spinwave approximation is valid . at small nonzero values of the anisotropy parameter @xmath177 , there will be only a very slight change in @xmath115 , because @xmath177 does not appear explicitly in @xmath13 , but only enters the calculation via the dispersion relation and via the @xmath178 and @xmath179 functions of ( [ canonical ] ) . to demonstrate this effect , fig . [ gam_lambda - fig ] shows @xmath115 at various values of @xmath177 for @xmath180 along the ( 10 ) direction . in general , the damping decreases with increasing @xmath177 , i.e. as the system becomes more isotropic . the calculation of the memory function requires the knowledge of @xmath115 over the entire bz . we can reduce the region of calculation to @xmath181 , because , by symmetry , @xmath182 , and @xmath183 . in this region @xmath115 was calculated on a uniform square grid with spacing @xmath184 . linear interpolation was used to get values between these grid points . for the calculation of the dynamic correlation function @xmath185 , we use the memory function formalism due to reiter and sjlander,@xcite who applied the procedure to the isotropic heisenberg model . the technique is based on a low - temperature expansion of the memory function.@xcite the formalism was applied to the 1d isotropic antiferromagnet in an external field by de raedt et al@xcite and to a 1d easy - plane antiferromagnet by gouva and pires.@xcite more recently , it was also applied to 2d easy - plane ferromagnets by menezes et al,@xcite although some numerical difficulties inhibited numerical evaluation of the analytic formulas . some of these problems were surpassed in the work of pereira et al.@xcite in all of these works , no mode damping was included . the presence of damping actually relieves the numerical difficulty of the problem , as we see below . the dynamic correlation function is defined in terms of the fourier transformed spin - fields as @xmath186 where @xmath178 is any component of @xmath187 , and by symmetry , @xmath188 . in this and following formulas for correlation functions , we note the distinction between continuum ( functions of @xmath6 ) and discrete ( subscripts @xmath6 ) fourier transforms , which are related by factors of @xmath2 for each dimension.@xcite this is necessary so that we can make a careful comparison between the theory and the mc - sd simulations , _ including the absolute magnitudes_. specifically , the continuum correlation function in ( [ sqw ] ) , which gives a thermodynamic weight over a _ wavevector range _ @xmath189 , is related to the discrete correlation at a _ specific _ wavevector @xmath6 , using discrete fourier transforms as defined in ( [ fourier ] ) , by@xcite @xmath190 in the analytic calculations , many intermediate quantities are discrete functions , however , for the comparison with the mc - sd data , both results will be converted and displayed as continuum quantities . due to the symmetry in the @xmath191-plane , the calculation is carried out by making averages of the rotationally symmetric quantity , @xmath192 , with @xmath193 . then in the memory function calculation , the continuum dynamical structure function can be written in terms of a second - order memory function , @xmath194 , to be described below , according to @xmath195 ^ 2 + \left [ \omega ~{\rm i m } ~ \sigma_{\bq}^{\perp}(\omega ) \right]^2 } ~ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath196 is the liouville operator , and the second moment @xmath197 is determined from a ratio , @xmath198 the location of the spinwave peak that results from eq . ( [ sqw - memory ] ) is very sensitive to the value of @xmath197 , therefore we are especially concerned to get an accurate evaluation of it . the denominator of ( [ moment2 ] ) is a static correlation function , whose value will be taken from the monte carlo simulations , although for low temperatures it can be evaluated approximately as [ sqperp ] @xmath199 @xmath200 the numerator of ( [ moment2 ] ) has been shown@xcite to have a leading low - temperature dependence , also related to static nearest neighbor correlations , @xmath201 the correlation @xmath202 , therefore its contribution can be ignored for small @xmath177 . there being two bonds per lattice site , the in - plane near - neighbor correlation is related to the average energy per bond by @xmath203 this correlation can also be obtained from the mc simulations , although a good low - t approximation is @xmath204 a comparison of the analytic and mc static parameters will be given below . to the leading order in temperature , the time - dependent memory function has been shown to be given from @xmath205 @xmath206 where @xmath207 is projection onto the non - secular variables , see ref . , whose action is equivalent to @xmath208 using expressions ( [ mapping ] ) expanded to second order in @xmath39 , @xmath40 , and ( [ canonical ] ) , it is straightforward to write the spins @xmath209 in terms of the creation / annihilation operators . in the leading order in temperature , the resulting expressions involve expectation values of products of four creation / annihilation operators . the damping is included in the time evolution according to , @xmath210 then , there results , after some manipulations , expressions to give the memory function , @xmath211 the two terms correspond to spinwave sum ( @xmath212 ) and difference ( @xmath213 ) processes , with weights @xmath214 where @xmath215 \bigr\ } ~ , \end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath216 \bigr\ } ~ . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the frequencies and damping rates of these processes are @xmath217 @xmath218 finally , the frequency - dependent memory function is given by the one - sided fourier - laplace transform , @xmath219 from this expression , eq . ( [ m - memory ] ) , and equations following , we obtain a sum over all the sum / difference processes , @xmath220 \nonumber \\ & & + w_{- } \bigl [ \frac{\omega+\omega_{-}-i\gamma_{-}}{(\omega+\omega_{-})^{2}+\gamma_{-}^{2 } } + \frac{\omega-\omega_{-}-i\gamma_{-}}{(\omega-\omega_{-})^{2}+\gamma_{-}^{2 } } \bigr ] \bigr\ } ~ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] where the @xmath221 dependencies of @xmath222 , and @xmath223 have been suppressed . this is the expression used to evaluate @xmath224 , and thus the dynamic structure function , via eq . ( [ sqw - memory ] ) . to evaluate ( [ sigma_sum ] ) on a discrete @xmath225 lattice , the wavevector @xmath6 must be one of the allowed values , @xmath226 where @xmath227 and @xmath228 are integers . it is also necessary to make the summations over @xmath104 such that the vectors @xmath229 are both given by integers times @xmath2 . thus , it is convenient to change from the summation over @xmath104 to a summation over a new variable @xmath30 defined by @xmath230 where @xmath231 and @xmath232 are integers . then , we also have @xmath233 equal to an allowed wavevector . this insures that the sums will be over spinwaves that are allowed on the given finite lattice . this approach is essential for calculation of the finite size dynamical effects . on the other hand , for the infinite sized system , no variable change is needed , and there is the usual replacement , @xmath234 . note that in the limit of zero damping , eq . ( [ sigma_sum ] ) is inapplicable , except for the continuum limit ( i.e. , @xmath114 ) . the resulting continuum integrals for the infinite system are singular , and the analytic relation ( [ delta - relation ] ) must be applied , leading to @xmath235 \nonumber \\ & & + p \int d^{2}p ~ w_{- } \bigl [ \frac{1}{\omega+\omega_{- } } + \frac{1}{\omega-\omega_{- } } \bigr ] \nonumber \\ & & -i \pi \int d^{2}p ~ w_{+ } \bigl [ \delta(\omega+\omega_{+ } ) + \delta(\omega-\omega_{+ } ) \bigr ] \nonumber \\ & & -i \pi \int d^{2}p ~ w_{- } \bigl [ \delta(\omega+\omega_{- } ) + \delta(\omega-\omega_{- } ) \bigr ] \bigr\ } ~ .\end{aligned}\ ] ] indeed , in the very low temperature range ( @xmath236 ) where the damping is extremely weak , it may be more efficient to use this expression rather than eq . ( [ sigma_sum ] ) , which has poorer convergence with @xmath154 . ( [ sigma_int ] ) was applied by pereira et al.@xcite ; the imaginary part can be evaluated by techniques described here ( sec . [ integration ] ) , and the principal - valued real part can be calculated by an extension@xcite of techniques used in 1d.@xcite in ref . the last expression was found to give finite amplitude spinwave peaks , without damping present . before presenting the results obtained via the memory function approach , the key aspects of the monte carlo and spin - dynamics simulations are summarized . to test the validity of the memory function technique , we compare it with numerical simulations on @xmath237 square lattices ( @xmath238 , @xmath37 ) using monte - carlo and spin - dynamics ( sd ) simulations , which include effects due to all thermodynamically allowed excitations . as mentioned above , we also use some data for static correlations from the monte carlo calculations as input to the memory function dynamical calculations . the techniques used here have been described in ref . and are based on the simulation methods developed in ref . . in the mc calculation , we applied a combination of metropolis single - spin moves and over - relaxation moves that modify all three spin components , and in addition , wolff single - cluster operations@xcite that modify _ only _ the @xmath191 spin components . the over - relaxation and cluster moves are important at low temperatures , where the @xmath191 spin components tend to freeze and single spin moves become inefficient . in the combined mc - sd simulations , a set of mc generated states from thermodynamic equilibrium at temperature @xmath69 are used as initial conditions for numerical integrations in time via a fourth order runge - kutta scheme . specifically , the first 4000 mc steps were used for equilibrating the system . then , every 400 mc steps a state was taken to initiate the sd integration . this was repeated 500 times ; the displayed @xmath1 data are averages over the 500 time integrations . the total mc sequence was then @xmath239 steps ; every 25 steps a state was used to calculate averages of the static correlation functions . in the time integration , the basic runge - kutta time step was @xmath240 , and every 11 time steps , data samples ( for @xmath241 , etc . ) were saved for @xmath6 s in the ( 10 ) , ( 01 ) , and ( 11 ) directions only ( due to machine memory restrictions ) . a total of @xmath242 data samples were saved , followed by applying a fast - fourier - transform to obtain @xmath243 . the total time of integration of @xmath244 is large enough so that no smoothing window is necessary for the data generation . then the frequency resolution of these results is good , @xmath245 , so that any fine details in the low temperature results should be visible . for the lowest temperatures ( @xmath246 ) , where we wanted to see the complex fine details due to the finite size effects , some simulations were made saving data samples every 28 times steps , leading to a total integration time @xmath247 , and frequency resolution @xmath248 . first , a comparison of the low-@xmath69 formulas and static mc results needed as input to the memory function formalism is presented . then dynamical results from the memory function and from md - sd will be presented for large systems , and finally , for smaller systems , where the finite size features will be analyzed . the continuum static structure function , @xmath249 was measured directly in the mc simulations . a comparison with the results based on the low - temperature expression ( [ sqperp ] ) is given in fig . [ sq - fig ] . there we also show a fit of the mc data to a form similar to the analytic expression , but with a fitting coefficient ( @xmath250 ) and power ( @xmath251 ) , @xmath252 from the fits , the parameter @xmath250 is somewhat larger than the low - temperature limit , @xmath253 . this can be expected due to the renormalization of the effective @xmath17 to lower values with temperature . the power @xmath251 falls with increasing @xmath69 , which must also be due to anharmonic effects . there is little difference between the low - t expression and the mc data at the lowest temperature . the deviations between the mc and low - t theory increase substantially by @xmath254 , especially at higher wavevectors . note that the fits are only shown for demonstration ; we used the mc data itself as inputs to the memory function calculations . the other static input to the memory function calculation , for determining the second moment , is the quantity @xmath255 , which is related to the nearest neighbor correlation @xmath256 by eq . ( [ lsls ] ) . estimates of that latter from the mc evaluation of the average energy per spin [ eq . ( [ s0sa - en ] ) ] are compared to the theoretical expression ( [ s0sa - theory ] ) in fig . [ s0sa - fig ] . the analytical expression is seen to give results consistent with the mc data up to @xmath257 . when combined to give the second moment , the mc data produces results as shown in fig . [ moment2-fig ] . it is essentially this quantity that has the strongest influence on the locations of the spinwave peaks in @xmath1 . these are the data used as input to the memory function calculation . we evaluate @xmath194 by using the sum over discrete wavevectors @xmath104 as displayed in eq . ( [ sigma_sum ] ) , and then apply eq . ( [ sqw - memory ] ) to determine @xmath193 . if @xmath154 is taken large enough , then the sum should be a good approximation to the infinite size limit . in general , we can see whether larger @xmath154 is necessary by the presence of finite size features in the data for @xmath224 and @xmath243 . typically we used @xmath258 to give a reasonable approximation to the continuum limit for @xmath259 and larger @xmath6-values ; at lower temperatures or wavevectors even larger @xmath154 is necessary to smooth out all the finite size features , due to the very weak damping . in fig . [ sigt3qpi4pi4-fig ] , some typical results for the real and imaginary parts of @xmath194 are shown for @xmath37 , @xmath260 , and @xmath261 , where @xmath262 was used in the sum . the resulting dynamical structure function is compared to the corresponding mc - sd data for @xmath238 in fig . [ sxxt3qpi4pi4-fig ] . at the ( zero-@xmath69 ) spinwave frequency @xmath263 , i m @xmath194 achieves its minimum value , which is not zero due to the presence of the damping , while re @xmath194 has a small nonzero value there as well . the spinwave peak in the memory data occurs at @xmath264 , which is just slightly greater than the associated value of the second moment , @xmath265 . the spinwave peak position will occur where the denominator of eq . ( [ sqw - memory ] ) achieves its minimum value , which gives , to a good approximation , @xmath266 for this case , the memory function data give @xmath267 , which is consistent with this relation . the peak position is very sensitive to the value of the second moment , which is why we have tried to estimate it as accurately as possible from the static mc data . still , the mc - sd data show the spinwave peak closer to @xmath268 , slightly lower than the memory function prediction . using eq . ( [ sqw - memory ] ) , the spinwave peak height is proportional to @xmath269^{-1}$ ] , while the peak width is approximately equal to @xmath270 . when compared to the mc - sd data , the memory function calculation usually overestimates the peak height and underestimates the peak width , although both are in reasonable agreement with the mc - sd data . in fact , these errors tend to be larger at lower temperature . in figs . [ sxxt1-fig][sxxt5-fig ] , we display some further comparisons of the memory function calculations and mc - sd results at other values of @xmath6 for temperatures ranging from @xmath271 to @xmath272 . for the lower temperatures there is very good agreement between the memory theory and mc - sd peak positions , while the peak heights and widths do not agree as well . on the other hand , at higher temperatures the opposite is true : the memory data show greater errors in the peak positions , especially at large @xmath8 , but the peak heights and widths are predicted very well . probably these discrepancies are caused by a fairly large _ underestimate _ of the damping strength at low temperature , as well as errors in the estimate of the second moment at higher temperatures . however , in general , the tails of the spinwave peaks far from @xmath5 are described very well by the memory function calculations . when we consider the results using relatively smaller values of wavevector , @xmath243 shows not only a spinwave peak , but additional features ( small peaks ) which depend on the system size . these features are obvious in the mc - sd @xmath1 data shown above . similar size - dependent dynamical features have been noticed in earlier mc - sd simulations of xy - symmetry@xcite and easy - axis symmetry@xcite magnets , but without a clear theoretical explanation . we now consider a closer look at the details of these features , making a comparison with the memory function calculations at smaller values of @xmath154 . some examples showing the resulting memory function data for @xmath243 for @xmath238 systems are given in fig . [ sxxt3q16]a [ @xmath273 , @xmath274 , fig . [ sxxt3q9]a [ @xmath275 , @xmath274 , and fig . [ sxxt1q5]a [ @xmath276 , @xmath277 . in fact , there appear various sequences of small peaks . the number of separate sequences appears to depend on the wavevector in integer units of @xmath2 . note that the logarithmic scale exaggerates the size of these subpeaks , they are typically a few orders of magnitude smaller than the spinwave peak . for sufficiently low temperatures , these effects also appear clearly in the mc - sd results : see figs . [ sxxt3q16]b , [ sxxt3q9]b and [ sxxt1q5]b , although the corresponding features there are smeared out compared to the memory function calculation . the effects are also present at larger wavevectors , however , in that case there are many more of these finite size subpeaks , which tend to merge together into a smoother background . these extra peaks can each be associated with particular spinwave sum or difference process . to see that this is the case , consider first the difference processes , whose frequencies @xmath278 are always less than the spinwave frequency @xmath5 . a plot of the weights @xmath279 [ eq . ( [ weights ] ) ] that determine the contributions to the memory function versus the corresponding frequencies @xmath280 , can show how strongly each process [ i.e. , each @xmath30 as defined in ( [ k - discrete ] ) ] contributes to i m @xmath224 and hence to @xmath1 . in fig . [ omminust3q16 ] , we made such a plot for an even integer @xmath6 , namely , @xmath281 , for @xmath238 and @xmath260 . each dot there corresponds to one allowed wavevector @xmath30 ; some of the values of @xmath30 in units of @xmath2 are indicated there . the sequence of @xmath30 s , ( 8,0 ) , ( 8,1 ) , ( 8,2 ) , etc . , leads to multiple contributions at zero frequency , that is , a weak central peak , which is a general result for any even integer @xmath6 . the sequence , ( 9,0 ) , ( 9,1 ) , ( 9,2 ) , etc . , produces a sequence of small peaks in @xmath1 out to @xmath282 , and , the next sequence , ( 10,0 ) , ( 10,1 ) , ( 10,2 ) , etc . , gives a sequence of peaks out to @xmath283 , and so on . each of these @xmath30-sequences can be identified with corresponding peak - sequences in the memory function calculation of @xmath1 , as seen in fig . . indeed , for the wavevector @xmath281 , there are @xmath284 of these sequences below the spinwave peak , including the ones that contribute only at @xmath285 . the higher sequences are more spread out , and merge with the other ones , making a complicated fine structure in @xmath1 . similar features are seen in the mc - sd data , fig . [ sxxt3q16]b , although it is clear that the individual peaks of each sequence are smeared out , resulting in one wider feature from the entire sequence . another example of these finite size features , for an odd integer wavevector , @xmath286 is shown in fig . [ ompmt3q9 ] , again for @xmath238 and @xmath260 . for this smaller integer wavevector there are now only 5 sequences of fine - structure difference process peaks . it is significant that there is no such peak at zero frequency . this is clearly caused by the absence of any allowed spinwave difference process exactly at @xmath287 , although there are many such processes with very weak weights _ close _ to @xmath287 . in general , for any odd integer wavevector , @xmath1 will have a relative minimum at @xmath285 , because of the absence of allowed difference processes there . in fig . [ ompmt3q9 ] we also show some of the weights of the sum - processes , @xmath288 , indicated by plus signs . for either sum or difference processes , numbers in parenthesis refer to the values of @xmath30 in units of @xmath2 . the sum frequencies must fall above the spinwave frequency @xmath5 . comparing figures [ ompmt3q9 ] and [ sxxt3q9 ] , we see that the finite size features above @xmath5 in @xmath1 can each be identified with a particular spinwave sum process . the identification , however , is somewhat more complex than that for the difference processes , because the different sequences of processes overlap in frequency . the match between the sum peak frequencies in the memory data and the mc - sd data is not as good as for the differences processes below @xmath5 . we can note that at these higher frequencies , any relative errors appear larger on an absolute scale , and , the spinwave sum / difference frequencies do not include any exchange softening effects . finally we show another example , for @xmath289 at @xmath290 , @xmath238 in fig . [ ompmt1q5 ] , where both the difference and sum processes are shown . in this case there are only 3 dominant sequences of difference processes leading to finite size features . although the memory function formalism applied above , strictly speaking , applies to low temperatures , it is interesting to consider what kind of predictions it makes if applied at higher temperatures . it is clear from the above comparisons between mc - sd data and the memory function data that at low temperatures , where the spinwave approximation should be valid , the damping of the modes has been underestimated . this is seen especially in the @xmath271 memory data where all the finite size features , as well as the spinwave peak , are too narrow . thus it is interesting to see whether the spinwave width and shape are better described by this theory at higher temperature , because the theoretical damping rates grow as @xmath117 . the other reason to look at higher temperature is to consider how the background intensity in @xmath1 for frequencies @xmath291 , depends on the temperature . for one thing , the increase in temperature should spread all of the finite - size effect peaks and smooth the spinwave background , but can be expected to raise its intensity as well . for comparison , as @xmath69 crosses the vortex unbinding temperature @xmath11 , previous mc - sd simulations@xcite show that this background grows with @xmath69 , until it dominates over the spinwave peak . the effect has been described by a theory employing a gas of freely moving vortices,@xcite although simulations have given some indication that vortex lifetimes@xcite are rather too short to take this theory literally , and , vortices tend to be pinned by the lattice and also have complex motions not resembling free translation . thus it is interesting to compare the memory approach to the mc - sd data at higher temperatures , where the latter will include effects due to all possible types of excitations , beyond linear spinwaves . for @xmath37 , the vortex unbinding temperature has been estimated to be @xmath292 . in fig . [ hi - t - sxx ] , we show some comparisons of the continuum ( @xmath293 ) memory and mc - sd ( @xmath238 ) data for @xmath1 , at temperatures @xmath294 for two particular values of @xmath6 . as already seen , the spinwave peak locations in the mc - sd data here also fall lower than the memory function theory prediction . also , there is a significant growth of the low - frequency background ( @xmath291 ) in the mc - sd data and in the memory function calculations . for @xmath295 the low - frequency background already dominates over the spinwave peak , if the latter can be seen at all . the effect is stronger in the mc - sd data : there is a clear excess of intensity around zero - frequency in @xmath1 in the md - sd data compared to the memory function data . this effect is absent at @xmath296 , however , where the mc - sd and memory data coincide for low frequencies ; in this low temperature region the spinwave approximations used in the memory approach are valid . for temperatures near and above @xmath11 , this extra central peak intensity , not described within the spinwave picture of the memory function approach , may possibly be attributed to nonlinear excitations , including specifically , vortices . this is consistent with the phenomenological vortex gas description of mertens et al:@xcite the excess central peak component is stronger for lower wavevectors , because the vortex pairs being generated above @xmath11 disorder the spins on long length scales . the presence of spinwave damping included into the memory function approach has been suggested here as a way in which finite amplitude spinwave peaks result in the 2d xy model , canceling the divergences in previous theories . a rough calculation of the damping strength has been made using the feynmann diagram technique applied to the quartic corrections of the harmonic hamiltonian . the diagrams used involve only two scattering events ; clearly this gives an underestimate of the damping , and it is likely that including the third order diagrams could make a substantial modification to the results . generally the damping @xmath115 obtained increases away from the center of the brilluoin zone , being close to zero near the center and being greatest along the ( 11 ) direction . in this classical calculation , the damping varies as the square of the temperature ; this results in extremely weak damping strength ( @xmath297 ) for temperatures below @xmath298 . as the temperature approaches and passes @xmath11 , the damping becomes comparable to the spinwave frequency . the comparison of the memory function data and mc - sd data for @xmath1 is good in several aspects : the theory gives finite spinwave peaks , they are positioned correctly for low temperatures , and the multiple finite - size - effect peaks are reproduced as in the mc - sd data . the most significant problem in the memory function approach is the extremely narrow peak widths clearly caused by an underestimate of the true damping strength , especially at lower temperatures and wavevectors . for very low temperatures in the present theory , the longest wavelength spinwaves will not scatter even once before crossing the entire system . of course , this is a quantum picture , applied to the classical system , so perhaps a better approach in this low - t limit would be to consider some kind of adiabatic scattering in the nonuniform potential due to the spinwave population . this would essentially be the equivalent of the quantum calculation at very high order diagrams rather than at the lowest order . when the memory calculation is carried out for large systems , that is , in the continuum limit , the finite - size peaks merge into a smooth background . indeed , in this limit , the spinwave peak itself has contributions on the high frequency side from spinwave sum processes , and on the low frequency side from spinwave difference processes . the combination of all of these contributions , essentially an infinite number of sum and difference processes , leads to an overall smooth and nondivergent spinwave peak . even in the limit of _ zero damping _ , the spinwave peak are nondivergent , according to continuum calculations [ using eqs . [ sigma_int ] ] by pereira et al.@xcite however , when damping is included , the heights of the spinwave peaks are smaller , and we expect the results to be more realistic . in the memory function theory , the spinwave peak height was seen to be proportional to @xmath269^{-1}$ ] . the function @xmath299 , to a leading approximation , is proportional to the temperature @xmath69 . from eq . ( [ sqw - memory ] ) , in regions away from the spinwave peak @xmath1 should be proportional to @xmath299 . thus we see that the memory function theory demonstrates how the background grows with temperature while the spinwave peak relatively tends to fall . for high enough temperature , the distribution of spinwave difference processes near zero frequency dominates the spectrum of @xmath1 , leading to a central peak stronger than the spinwave peak . clearly this means applying the theory well above the limiting temperature where we expect spinwave approximations to be valid . however , this gives results very similar to those in the mc - sd simulations , although the latter can be expected to include nonlinear effects such as vortices . in fact , we have seen a strong indication for nonlinear effects ( beyond spinwave difference processes ) above @xmath11 as extra intensity in @xmath1 near zero frequency in the mc - sd data . in conclusion , application of the memory function formalism , including a leading approximation to the mode damping , has been shown to accomplish three things for the xy model : i ) produce nondivergent spinwave peaks ; ii ) explain the finite size features in @xmath1 both above and below @xmath5 ; iii ) explain the background in @xmath1 below @xmath5 for the infinite system . note that strictly speaking , damping is necessary only for item ii ) , because @xmath1 can not be calculated in the memory function formalism for a finite system without damping . the continuum memory function approach gives finite size spinwave peaks and a low - frequency background even in the absence of damping . the theory also suggests that a sizable contribution to the growth of the central peak for @xmath69 above @xmath11 may be due to spinwave difference processes . the excess central peak intensity in the mc - sd data , when compared to the memory function data , must be due to nonlinear excitations , and gives evidence for dynamical effects due to vortices . gmw thanks universidade federal de minas gerais for their hospitality and support on this project . the authors thank the support by nsf - int-9502781 , nsf cda-9724289 , fapemig , and cnpq . permanent address : department of physics , kansas state university , manhattan , ks 66506 - 2601 . [ email : [email protected]_ ] . j. villain , j. phys . ( paris ) * 35 * , 27 ( 1974 ) . f. moussa and j. villain , j. phys . c * 9 * , 4433 ( 1976 ) . d. r. nelson and d. s. fisher , phys . b * 16 * , 4945 ( 1977 ) . v. l. berezinskii , sov . jetp * 32 * , 493 ( 1970 ) ; * 34 * , 610 ( 1972 ) . j. m. kosterlitz and d. j. thouless , j. phys . c*6 * , 1181 ( 1973 ) r. d. mattuck , _ a guide to feynmann diagrams in the many - body problem _ , mcgraw - hill international book company ( 1976 ) . a. l. fetter and j. d. walecka , _ quantum theory of many - particle systems _ , mcgraw - hill , new york ( 1971 ) . a. a. abrikosov , l. p. gorkov and i. e. dzyaloshinski , _ quantum field theoretical methods in statistical physics _ , pergamon press , oxford ( 1965 ) . g. gilat and j. raubenheimer , phys . rev . * 144 * , 390 ( 1966 ) . g. gilat and z. kam , phys . rev . lett . * 22 * , 715 ( 1969 ) . g. gilat , j. comp . * 10 * , 432 ( 1972 ) . in two - dimensions , ( [ dcell ] ) becomes @xmath300 and in three dimensions , @xmath301 for arbitrary dimension @xmath118 , the generalization is @xmath302 g. reiter and a sjlander , phys . lett . * 39 * , 1047 ( 1977 ) ; j. phys . c : solid state phys . * 13 * 3027 ( 1980 ) . h. mori , prog . * 33 * , 423 ( 1965 ) . b. de raedt , h. de raedt and j. fivez , phys . b * 23 * , 4597 ( 1981 ) . m. e. gouva and a. s. t. pires , j. phys . c : solid state phys . * 20 * , 2431 ( 1987 ) . s. menezes , a. s. t. pires and m. e. gouva , phys . b * 47 * , 12280 ( 1993 ) . a. f. a. pereira , m. s. thesis , universidade federal de minas gerais , brazil ( 1999 ) . a. f. a. pereira , m. e. gouva and g. m. wysin , unpublished . the usual conversion from discrete to continuum fourier weights is to divide by the volume @xmath303 per allowed point in @xmath6-space : @xmath304 the @xmath305 normalization of the fourier transform definition ( [ fourier ] ) simplifies many formulas in this paper , including the @xmath50-independent discrete correlation ( [ sqperp ] ) . distributing this weight over the @xmath6-space volume @xmath306 , leads to an @xmath50-_dependent _ continuum correlation @xmath307 . to avoid this @xmath50-dependence in the continuum quantity , it is only necessary to use the alternative fourier transform definitions , @xmath308 this would complicate many intermediate formulas , but in the end the continuum @xmath1 will be independent of @xmath50 and also have a prefactor of @xmath309 . g. m. wysin , unpublished . m. e. gouva , unpublished . m. e. gouva and g. m. wysin , phys . b * 56 * , 14192 ( 1997 ) . c. kawabata , m. takeuchi and a.r . bishop , j. magn . mater . * 54 - 57 * , 871 ( 1986 ) ; j. stat . phys . * 43 * , 869 ( 1986 ) ; g.m . wysin and a.r . bishop , phys . b * 42 * , 810 ( 1990 ) ; u. wolff , nucl . phys . * b300 * , 501 ( 1988 ) ; phys . lett . * 62 * , 361 ( 1989 ) . evertz and d.p . landau , phys . b * 54 * , 12302 ( 1996 ) . d. p. landau , j. mag . mater . * 200 * , 231 ( 1999 ) ; m. krech and d. p. landau , phys . b * 60 * , 3375 ( 1999 ) . m. e. gouva , g. m. wysin , s. a. leonel , a. s. t. pires , t. kamppeter and f. g. mertens , phys . b * 59 * , 6229 ( 1999 ) . mertens , a.r . bishop , g.m . wysin and c. kawabata , phys . b * 39 * , 591 ( 1989 ) . d.a . dimitrov and g.m . wysin , phys . b * 53 * , 8539 ( 1996 ) ; j. phys . c * 10 * , 7453 - 65 ( 1998 ) .
Abstract: | [
"the effect of damping of spinwaves in a two - dimensional classical ferromagnetic xy model is considered . the damping rate @xmath0 is calculated using the leading diagrams due to the quartic - order deviations from the harmonic spin hamiltonian . the resulting four - dimensional integrals are evaluated by extending the techniques developed by gilat and others for spectral density types of integrals . @xmath0 is included into the memory function formalism due to reiter and solander , and menezes , to determine the dynamic structure function @xmath1 . for the infinite sized system , the memory function approach is found to give non - divergent spinwave peaks , and a smooth nonzero background intensity ( `` plateau '' or distributed intensity ) for the whole range of frequencies below the spinwave peak . the background amplitude relative to the spinwave peak rises with temperature , and eventually becomes higher than the spinwave peak , where it appears as a central peak . for finite - sized systems , there are multiple sequences of weak peaks on both sides of the spinwave peaks whose number and positions depend on the system size and wavevector in integer units of @xmath2 . these dynamical finite size effects are explained in the memory function analysis as due to either spinwave difference processes below the spinwave peak or sum processes above the spinwave peak . these features are also found in classical monte carlo spin - dynamics simulations . = 1 = 1 = 250 = 350"
] | 10,088 | 10,088 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: since the mid-1990s we built visual interactive maps of bibliographic and database information at strasbourg astronomical observatory , and some of these , with references , are available at murtagh [ 2006d ] . the automated annotation of such maps is not easy . at the time of writing zdnet and the bbc ( british broadcasting corporation ) use interactive annotated maps to support information navigation . in zdnet s case , some prominent terms are graphically presented and can be used to carry out a local search ; and in the bbc case , terms relating to downloadable radio programs are displayed in moving sizes and locations . in the work described in this article , we adopt a different approach : we select the terms of interest in a manual or semi - automated way . this not only represents expert user judgement but also allows for inclusion of rare or very frequent terms . in one of our three case studies , we use an automated way to select such terms . for selected terms , we use their inter - relationships to build a hierarchy and use this as a central device for summarizing information and supporting navigation . `` ontologies are often equated with taxonomic hierarchies of classes ... but ontologies need not be limited to such a form '' [ gruber 2001 ] . gruber is cited in gmez - prez et al . [ 2004 ] as characterizing an ontology as `` an explicit specification of a conceptualization '' . in wache et al . [ 2001 ] , ontologies are motivated by semantic heterogeneity of distributed data stores . this is also termed data heterogeneity and is counterposed to structural or schematic heterogeneity . ontologies are motivated by wache et al . [ 2001 ] `` for the explication of implicit and hidden knowledge '' , as `` a possible approach to overcome the problem of semantic heterogeneity '' . so , ontologies may help with integration of diverse , but related , data ; or they may help with clarifying or disambiguating distinctions in the heterogeneous data . ontologies are likely to be of immediate help in supporting querying . for example , the query model may be based on the ontology ( or ontologies ) used . there is extensive activity on standards and software , relating more to the above - mentioned schematic rather than semantic heterogeneity , and a useful survey of this area is denny [ 2004 ] . denny takes an ontology in a broad - ranging view as a knowledge - representation scheme . a short review of some recent approaches in this area follows . ahmad and gillam [ 2005 ] develop a semi - automated approach using text with no markup . multiword expressions are determined , and frequency of occurrence information is used to point to term or phrase importance . a stop list is used to avoid irrelevant words . part of speech analysis is not used . a semantic net is formed to allow development of the ontology elements . abou assali and zanghi [ 2006 ] use syntactic part of speech tagging to determine the nouns . these authors retain sufficiently frequent nouns . they apply the notion of weak subsumption : if for the most part a word is in a text that another is in , and not vice versa , then this leads to a hierarchical relationship . chuang and chien [ 2005 ] assert that multiway trees are appropriate for concept hierarchies , whereas binary trees are built using hierarchical clustering algorithms . hence they modify the latter to provide more appropriate output . ( a formal approach for mapping a binary hierarchical classification tree onto a multiway hierarchy is described in murtagh [ 2006b ] . ) a hierarchical clustering has often been used to represent an ontology . note that this is usually not a concept hierarchy . a concept hierarchy is based on a subsumption relationship between terms , whereas a hierarchical clustering is an embedded set of clusters of the term set . later in this article ( section [ secorientree ] ) , we show a way to derive a concept hierarchy , involving subsumption of terms , from a hierarchic clustering . a hierarchic clustering is typically a binary , rooted , terminal labeled , ranked tree , and a concept hierarchy is typically a multiway , rooted , terminal and non - terminal labeled , ranked tree . by starting with the former ( binary ) tree representation , we have an extensive theoretical and formal arsenal at our disposal , to represent the main lines of what we need to do , and to help to avoid ad hoc , user parameter - based , `` engineering '' approaches . as seen later in this work , we start by laying the foundations of our perspective by basing this on binary trees , and later proceed to the multiway tree . an alternative approach can be found in ganesan et al . [ 2003 ] , where similarities or distances on trees are redefined and re - axiomatized for the case of multiway trees . an alternative representation for an ontology is a lattice , and formal concept analysis ( fca ) is a methodology for the analysis of such lattices . if we have a set of documents or texts , @xmath0 , characterized by an index term set @xmath1 , then as janowitz [ 2005 ] shows , hierarchical clustering and fca are loosely related . hierarchical clustering is based on pairwise distances or dissimilarities , @xmath2 ( @xmath3 is the set of non - negative reals ) . fca is based on partially ordered sets ( posets ) such that there is a dissimilarity @xmath4 ( @xmath5 is the power set of the index terms , @xmath1 ) . other approaches ( rule - based ; machine learning approaches , etc . ; layered , engineering , approaches with maintenance management see maedche [ 2006 ] ) are also available . one difficulty with such `` engineering '' approaches is that there is an ad hoc understanding of the problem area , and often there is dependence on somewhat arbitrary threshold and selection criteria that do not generalize well . our approach formalizes the problem area the information space in terms of its local or global topology . where we do have selection criteria , such user interaction is at the application goal level . visualization is often an important way to elucidate semantic heterogeneity for the user . visual user interfaces for ontological elucidation are discussed in murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] , with examples that include interactive , responsive information maps based on the kohonen self - organizing feature map ; and semantic network graphs . a study is presented in murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] of client - side visualization of concept hierarchies relating to an economics information space . the use of `` semantic road maps '' to support information retrieval goes back to doyle [ 1961 ] . motivation , following murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] , includes the following : ( i ) visualization of the semantic structure and content of the data store allows the user to have some idea before submitting a query as to what type of outcome is possible . hence visualization is used to summarize the contents of the database or data collection ( i.e. , information space ) . ( ii ) the user s information requirements are often fuzzily and ambiguously defined at the outset of the information search . hence visualization is used to help the user in his / her information navigation , by signaling the relationships between concepts . ( iii ) ontology visualization therefore helps the user before the user interacts with the information space , and during this interaction . it is a natural enough progression that the visualization becomes the user interface . this article is organised as follows . to begin with , in section [ sect2 ] , we table the issue of whether or not there is inherent hierarchical structure in a text , or a collection of texts . in section [ sect3 ] we show how we can rigorously determine the extent of inherent hierarchical structure in a text . this quantifying of inherent hierarchical structure is then used in subsections [ sect41 ] , [ sect42 ] , [ sect52 ] and [ sect7 ] . a text provides both global and linear semantics , and how we can process these two different perspectives on a given text is discussed in section [ sect4 ] . a central aspect of our approach is a new distance or metric , which we have recently introduced and exemplified on another data analysis problem . this new distance is described in subsection [ sect5 ] . in section [ sect6 ] we apply what we have described in earlier sections to the selection of salient and characteristic pairs and triplets of terms , and also the selection of pertinent terms . our motivation is not just the traditional view of phrase counting ( even though we incorporate this view ) but rather the characterization of text content using its internal ( local hierarchical ) structure . a natural approach to defining a concept hierarchy lies in use of a hierarchical clustering algorithm . however , the latter forms an embedded sequence of clusters , so that a hierarchy of concepts must somehow be derived from it . in section [ secorientree ] we first of all show that `` converting '' any hierarchical clustering into a hierarchy of concepts is relatively straightforward . however we do have to face the problem of a unique , and beyond that best , solution . we show how we can admirably address this need for a unique solution . our innovative approach is based on the foundations laid in sections [ sect2 ] and [ sect4 ] of this article . we analyze three different data sets in this work : firstly a set of documents , with some degree of heterogeneity , to illustrate our key goal ; secondly a homogeneous text , partitioned into successive textual segments ; and thirdly a small homogeneous text , partitioned at the sentence level , proxied by lines of text . we select terms , indeed nouns , in a partially automated way , since this crucial aspect of ontology design may benefit from being user - driven , and may have scalability advantages . in later sections we address the issue of finding and presenting structure in text . we link such structure with the textual content . consequently a key , initial question is to know whether or not there is structure present , and to what extent . a first problem to be addressed is whether or not the document has any hierarchical structure to begin with . as input , we have possibly a fully tagged document ( based , e.g. , on part - of - speech tagging , schmid [ 1994 ] ) . however in this work , we start with free text , because it is the most generally available and applicable framework . additional information provided by part - of - speech tagging can be of use to us , as we will show later . next we consider the issue of whether or not a document has sufficient inherent hierarchical structure to warrant further investigation . we could approach this problem by fitting a hierarchy , and there are many algorithms for doing so ( such as any hierarchical clustering algorithm ; de soete [ 1986 ] describes a least squares optimal fitting approach ) . however departure from inherent hierarchical structure is not easily pinpointed . after all , we have an output induced structure , and we are told , let s say , that the fit is 80% ( defined as @xmath6 where @xmath7 is input dissimilarity , @xmath8 is tree or ultrametric distance read off the output , and the sums are over all pairs ) , which is not very revealing nor useful . an alternative `` bottom - up '' approach is pursued here , which allows easy assessment of inherent structure , and also pinpointing where this occurs or does not occur . a formal definition of hierarchical structure is provided by ultrametric topology ( in turn , related closely to p - adic number theory ) . the triangular inequality holds for a metric space : @xmath9 for any triplet of points @xmath10 . in addition the properties of symmetry and positive definiteness are respected . the `` strong triangular inequality '' or ultrametric inequality is : @xmath11 for any triplet @xmath10 . an ultrametric space implies respect for a range of stringent properties . for example , the triangle formed by any triplet is necessarily isosceles , with the two large sides equal ; or is equilateral . in an ultrametric space ( i.e. , a space endowed with an ultrametric , or an ultrametric topology ) , one `` lives '' , so to speak , in a tree . all `` moves '' between one location and another are as if one descended the tree to a common tree node , and then reclimbed to the target point . topologically , an ultrametric goes a lot further : all points in a circle or sphere are centers , for example ; or the radius of a sphere is identical to its diameter . the triangle property respected by any triplet of points in an ultrametric space affords a useful way to quantify extent of hierarchical structure . we will describe our `` extent of hierarchical structure '' , on a scale of 0 ( no respect for ultrametricity ) to 1 ( everywhere , respect for the ultrametric or tree distance ) algorithmically . we examine triplets of points ( exhaustively if possible , or otherwise through sampling ) , and determine the three angles formed by the associated triangle . we select the smallest angle formed by the triplet points . then we check if the other two remaining angles are approximately equal . if they are equal then our triangle is isosceles with small base , or equilateral ( when all triangles are equal ) . the approximation to equality is given by 2 degrees ( 0.0349 radians ) . our motivation for the approximate ( `` fuzzy '' ) equality is that it makes our approach robust and independent of measurement precision . this approach works very well in practice [ murtagh 2004 ; 2006a ] . we may note our one assumption for our data when we look at triangles in this way : scalar products define angles so that by assuming our data are in a hilbert space ( a complete normed vector space with a scalar product ) we may proceed with this analysis . this hilbert space assumption is very straightforward in practice . when finite ( as is always the case for us , in practice ) , we are using a euclidean space . often in practice , for arbitrary euclidean data , there is very little ultrametricity as quantified by the proportion of triangles satisfying the ultrametric requirement . but recoding the data can be of great help in dramatically increasing the proportion of such ultrametricity - respecting triangles [ murtagh 2004 ; 2005a ] . if we recode our data such that each pairwise distance or dissimilarity is mapped onto one element of the set @xmath12 , then as seen in subsection [ sect5 ] below the triangular inequality becomes particularly easy to assess for existence of , or non - existence of , a locally ultrametric relationship . in our use of free text , we have already noted how a mapping into a euclidean space gives us the capability to define distance in a simple and versatile way . in correspondence analysis [ murtagh 2005b ] , the texts we are using provide the rows , and the set of terms used comprise the column set . in the output , euclidean factor coordinate space , each text is located as a weighted average of the set of terms ; and each term is located as a weighted average of the set of texts . ( this simultaneous display is sometimes termed a biplot . ) so texts and terms are both mapped into the same , output coordinate space . this can be of use in understanding a text through its closest terms , or vice versa . a commonly used methodology for studying a set of texts , or a set of parts of a text ( which is what we will describe below ) , is to characterize each text with numbers of terms appearing in the text , for a set of terms . the @xmath13 distance is an appropriate weighted euclidean distance for use with such data [ benzcri 1979 ; murtagh 2005b ] . consider texts @xmath14 and @xmath15 crossed by words @xmath16 . let @xmath17 be the number of occurrences of word @xmath16 in text @xmath14 . then , omitting a constant , the @xmath13 distance between texts @xmath14 and @xmath15 is given by @xmath18 . the weighting term is @xmath19 . the weighted euclidean distance is between the _ profile _ of text @xmath14 , viz . @xmath20 for all @xmath16 , and the analogous _ profile _ of text @xmath15 . ( our discussion is to within a constant because we actually work on _ frequencies _ defined from the numbers of occurrences . ) correspondence analysis allows us to project the space of documents ( we could equally well explore the terms in the _ same _ projected space ) into a euclidean space . it maps the all - pairs @xmath13 distance into the corresponding euclidean distance . for a term , we use the ( full rank ) projections on factors resulting from correspondence analysis . as noted , this factor space is endowed with the ( unweighted ) euclidean distance . we will also take into consideration the strongest `` given '' in regard to any classical text : its linearity ( or total ) order . a text is read from start to finish , and consequently is linearly ordered . a text endowed with this linear order is analogous to a time series . if we use the correspondence analysis ( full dimensionality ) factor coordinates for each term , then the textual time series we are dealing with is seen to be a multivariate time series . just as the way we code our input data plays a crucial role in the resulting analysis , so also the recoding of pairwise distances can influence the analysis greatly . in murtagh [ 2005a ] we introduced a new distance , which we will term the `` change versus no change '' , cvnc , metric , and showed its benefits on a wide range of ( financial , biomedical , meteorological , telecoms , chaotic , and random ) time series . motivation for using this new metric is that it greatly increases the ultrametricity of the data . the cvnc metric is defined in the following way . take the euclidean distance squared , @xmath21 for all @xmath22 , where we have terms @xmath23 in the factor space with coordinates @xmath24 . it will be noted below in this section how this assumption of euclidean distance squared has worked well but is not in itself important : in principle any dissimilarity can be used . we enforce sparseness on our given squared distance values , @xmath25 . we do this by approximating each value @xmath26 , in the range @xmath27 , by an integer in @xmath28 . the value of @xmath29 must be specified . in our work we set @xmath30 . the recoding of distance squared is with reference to the mean distance squared : values less than or equal to this will be mapped to 1 ; and values greater than this threshold will be mapped to 2 . thus far , the recoded value , @xmath31 is not necessarily a distance . with the extra requirement that @xmath32 whenever @xmath33 it can be shown that @xmath31 is a metric [ murtagh 2005a ] : * theorem : * _ the recoded pairwise measure , @xmath34 , defined as described above from any dissimilarity , is a distance , satisfying the properties of : symmetry , positive definiteness , and triangular inequality . _ to summarize , in our coding , a small pairwise dissimilarity is mapped onto a value of 1 ; and a large pairwise dissimilarity is mapped onto a value of 2 . identical values are unchanged : they are mapped onto 0 . this coding can be considered as encoding pairwise relationships as `` change '' , i.e. 2 , versus `` no change '' , i.e. 1 , relationships . then , based on these new distances , we use the ultrametric triangle properties to assess conformity to ultrametricity . the proportion of ultrametric triangles allows us to fingerprint our data . for any given triplet ( of terms , with pairwise cvnc distances ) , if the triplet is to be compatible with the ultrametric inequality , each set of three recoded distances is necessarily of one of the following patterns : trivial : : : at least one ( recoded ) distance is 0 , in which case we do not consider it . equilateral : : : recoded distances in the triplet are 1,1,1 or 2,2,2 , defining an equilateral triangle . ultrametric isosceles : : : recoded distances in the triplet are 1,2,2 in any order , defining an isosceles triangle with small base . non - ultrametric : : : recoded distances in the triplet are 1,1,2 in any order . the non - ultrametric case here is seen to be an isosceles triangle with large base . we could `` intervene '' and change one of the values to make it ultrametric . if we change the 2-value to a 1-value , this will produce an equilateral triangle , which is ultrametric . in this case , we are approximating our three values optimally from below , and the resulting ultrametric is termed the subdominant , or maximally inferior , ultrametric . the associated stepwise algorithm for constructing a hierarchy is known as the single link hierarchical clustering algorithm . on the other hand , we could change one of the 1-values to a 2 . this is not unique , since we could change either of the 1-values . the resulting hierarchy is termed the minimally superior ultrametric . the associated stepwise algorithm for constructing a hierarchy is known as the complete link hierarchical clustering algorithm . all of this is very clear from the case considered here . the recoding into the cvnc metric is a particular example of symbolic coding . see murtagh [ 2006c ] . in the next section , we will show the usefulness of this cvnc metric for quantifying inherent hierarchical structure . in this section we first describe the data set used . next , based on the foundation of the previous section , we quantify inherent hierarchical structure in our data . this justifies going further , to harness and exploit this structure . we use 14 texts taken from wikipedia ( mid-2006 ) , and coverted to straight text from html . table [ tabprop ] shows the numbers of words in each . .properties of texts used . [ cols= " < , < , > , > , > " , ] to the extent that our data satisfies , globally and throughout , the ultrametric inequality , we can adopt any of the widely used hierarchical clustering algorithms ( single , complete , average linkage ; minimum variance , median , centroid ) to induce an identical , unique hierarchy . but when we find our data to be , say , 86% ultrametric , as is not untypically the case in practice , then we must consider carefully what our aim is . if we wished to look at each and every isosceles triangle , then in the case of the artificial intelligence text this means , out of a total of 2,027,795 triplets ( i.e. , @xmath35 ) we must consider 1,007,597 . what we will do instead is return to taking our text as a time series . we have 231 unique nouns in the artificial intelligence text . in the text , these nouns are used , in total , on 405 occasions . so our text is a time series of 405 values . for successive nouns in this textual time series , the cvnc metric has an evident meaning : _ we are noting semantic change versus lack of change as we read through the text_. we examine successive triplets in the textual time series . for the artificial intelligence text , we find 45% of the triplets to be equilateral ; 37% of the triplets are isosceles ; and 18% of the triplets are non - ultrametric . the isosceles triplets point to a dominance or subsumption relationship that will be of use for us in a concept hierarchy . say we have a triplet @xmath36 . say , further , that the cvnc distance between @xmath37 and @xmath38 is 1 , so therefore there is no change in progressing from use of term @xmath37 to use of term @xmath38 . however both @xmath37 and @xmath38 are at cvnc distance 2 to term @xmath39 , and this betokens a semantic change . so the relationship is simply represented as @xmath40 . the term @xmath39 dominates or subsumes @xmath37 and @xmath38 . the following results hold . firstly , say that a successive triplet of values , in any order , is found as @xmath36 , and later in the text , again , this triplet is found in any order . then the relationship between the three recoded distances in both cases will be identical . _ for a given triplet , in any order within the triplet , the relationship is unique . _ secondly , consider any other term , @xmath41 , such that some or all of the terms @xmath36 are found to have a relationship with @xmath41 . as an example , we meet with @xmath42 at one point in the text , and later we meet with @xmath43 . then there is no influence by @xmath41 on the relationship ensuing from the @xmath43 triplet , vis - - vis the relationship ensuing from the earlier @xmath42 triplet . _ we have locality of the relationship in any given triplet , from successive terms . the relationship is strictly local to the given triplet . _ among the isosceles triangles in the artificial intelligence text , we find the following relationships . .... ( computer science ) branch ( home computer ) world ( analysis systems ) formalism ( analysis systems ) reasoning ( expert system ) conclusion ( expert system ) amounts ( example networks ) reasoning ( networks learning ) reasoning ( pattern recognition ) capabilities ( control systems ) computation ( consciousness systems ) logic ( medicine computer ) commentators ( computer technology ) commentators ( application feature ) os ( application feature ) languages ( libraries systems ) specialist ( libraries systems ) programmers ( software engineering ) development ( software engineering ) practices ( programs example ) logic ( example type ) logic ( projects publications ) life ( publications bayesian ) life ( bayesian networks ) life ( cybernetics systems ) agents ( systems control ) agents ( wiki web ) website ( wiki web ) category ( algorithm implementations ) projects ( algorithm implementations ) demonstrations ( implementations research ) demonstrations ( research group ) demonstrations .... however there are other isosceles triplets that are less self - evident . for this reason therefore we take all texts . for the 14 texts , we have 6439 nouns , and 1470 unique nouns . with our cvnc metric on all pairs of nouns , the complete link hierarchical clustering method gives 21 clusters in all . while one application of the foregoing is to deriving common pairs and triplets of terms , in practice it would be better to combine all relationships into a `` bigger picture '' . we will address this below in section [ secorientree ] . presenting a result with around 1500 terms does not lend itself to convenient display . we ask therefore what the most useful perhaps the most discriminating terms are . in correspondence analysis both texts and their characterizing terms are projected into the same factor space . see figure [ caout ] . so , from the factor coordinates , we can easily find the closest term(s ) to a given text . we do this for each of the 14 texts , and find the closest terms , respectively , as follows : .... bayesian automaton brain captcha psychologists image maps logic topologies databases agents representation game games .... a hierarchical clustering of these is shown in figure [ den15 ] . the ward minimum variance method is used , as being appropriate for structuring data well ( see murtagh [ 1984b ] ) and also having an agglomerative criterion that is appropriate for the prior euclidean embedding ( viz . , inertia - based in both cases ) . the data clustered are exactly those illustrated in the best planar projection of figure [ caout ] : these are 14 texts in a 4048-dimensional term space . due to centering in the dual spaces , the inherent dimensionality of both text and term spaces are : min@xmath44 = 13 . based on the dual spaces , we carry out the eigen - reduction in the space of smaller original dimensionality ( viz . , the space of the terms , which are in a 14-dimensional space ) , and then subsequently project into the 4048-dimensional space . proceeding further , the 5 closest terms to any given text , based on the full inherent dimensionality of this data ( viz . , smaller of dimensionality of texts , and dimensionality of terms ) , are as follows . .... text and set of 5 closest characterizing terms : artificial intelligence bayesian intelligence consciousness brains chatterbots artificial life automaton automata biology chemical allelomimesis artificial neural networks brain prediction forecasting aircraft epitomes captcha captcha captchas robot intelligence chemistry computational linguistics psychologists logics morphology pragmatics logicians computer vision image images diagnosis dimensionality dimensions evolutionary computation maps intelligence robot biology chemistry fuzzy logic logic mapping animals brakes armies genetic algorithms topologies communications music finance representations machine translation databases chemistry database memory robot multi - agent system agents agent robotics cybernetics robot semantic network representation database map namespaces robot turing test game chatterbot consciousness memory intelligence virtual world games gameplay topography communication representations .... we have noted in the introduction how a hierarchical clustering may be the starting point for creating a concept hierarchy , but the two representations differ . in this section we show how we can move from an embedded set of clusters , to an oriented tree . orientation in the latter case aims at expressing subsumption . consider the dendrogram shown in figure [ den1 ] , which represents an embedded set of clusters relating to the 8 terms . we will consider first such a strictly 2-way hierarchy , where we assume that no two agglomerations take place at precisely the same level . in the later case study , in subsection [ sect7 ] , we will consider the practical case where agglomerations take place at the same level . rather than the 14 texts used in section [ sect6 ] , to clarify the presentation in this section we will take just one text . we took aristotle s _ categories _ , which consisted of 14,483 individual words . we broke the text into 24 files , in order to base the textual analysis on the sequential properties of the argument developed . in these 24 files there were 1269 unique words . we selected 66 nouns of particular interest . a sample ( with frequencies of occurrence ) : man ( 104 ) , contrary ( 72 ) , same ( 71 ) , subject ( 60 ) , substance ( 58 ) , ... no stemming or other preprocessing was applied . for the hierarchical clustering , we further restricted the set of nouns to just 8 . ( these will be seen in the figures to be discussed below . ) the data array was doubled [ murtagh 2005b ] to produce an @xmath45 array , which with removing 0-valued text segments ( since , in one text segment , none of our selected 8 nouns appeared ) gave an @xmath46 array , thereby enforcing equal weighting of ( equal masses for ) the nouns used . the spaces of the 8 nouns , and of the 23 text segments ( together with the complements of the 23 text segments , on account of the data doubling ) are characterized at the start of the correspondence analysis in terms of their frequencies of occurrence , on which the @xmath13 metric is used . the correspondence analysis then `` euclideanizes '' both nouns and text segments . we used a 7-dimensional ( corresponding to the number of non - zero eigenvalues found ) euclidean embedding , furnished by the projections onto the factors . a hierarchical clustering of the 8 nouns , characterized by their 7-dimensional ( euclidean ) factor projections , was carried out : figure [ den1 ] . the ward minimum variance agglomerative criterion was used , with equal weighting of the 8 nouns . figure [ den2 ] shows a canonical representation of the dendrogram in figure [ den1 ] . both trees are isomorphic to one another . figure [ den2 ] is shown such that the sequence of agglomerations is portrayed from left to right ( and of course from bottom to top ) . we say that figure [ den2 ] is a canonical representation of the dendrogram , implying that figure [ den1 ] is not in canonical form . in figure [ den3 ] , the canonical representation has its non - terminal nodes labeled . next , figure [ den4 ] shows a superimposed oriented binary rooted tree , on @xmath47 nodes , which is isomorphic to the dendrogram on @xmath48 terminal nodes . this oriented binary tree is an inorder traversal of the dendrogram . sibson s [ 1973 ] `` packed representation '' of a dendrogram uses just such an oriented binary rooted tree , in order to define a permutation representation of the dendrogram . from our example , the packed representation permutation can be read off as : @xmath49 : for any terminal node indexed by @xmath14 , with the exception of the rightmost which will always be @xmath48 , define @xmath50 as the rank at which the terminal node is first united with some terminal node to its right . discussion of combinatorial properties of dendrograms , as related to such oriented binary rooted trees , and associated down - up and up - down permutations , can be found in murtagh [ 1984a ] . , but now with successively _ later _ agglomerations always represented by _ right _ child node . apart from the labels of the initial pairwise agglomerations , this is otherwise a unique representation of the dendrogram ( hence : `` existence '' and `` object '' can be interchanged ; so can `` disposition '' and `` fact '' ; and finally `` name '' and `` disposition '' ) . in the discussion we refer to this representation , with later agglomerations always parked to the right , as our canonical representation of the dendrogram.,width=529 ] , with non - terminal nodes numbered in sequence . these will form the nodes of the oriented binary tree . we may consider one further node for completeness , 8 or @xmath51 , located at an arbitrary location in the upper right.,width=529 ] finally , in figure [ den5 ] , we `` promote '' terminal node labels to the nodes of the oriented tree . we will use exactly the procedure used above for defining a permutation representation of the oriented tree . first the left terminal label is promoted to its non - terminal node . next , the right terminal label is promoted as far up the tree as is necessary in order to find an unlabeled non - terminal node . this procedure is carried out for all non - terminal labels , working in sequence from left to right ( i.e. , consistent with our canonical representation of the dendrogram ) . the rightmost label is not shown : it is at an arbitrary location in the upper right hand side , with a tree arc oriented towards the top non - terminal node of the dendrogram , now labeled as `` motion '' . in this section , we have specified a consistent procedure for labeling the nodes of an oriented tree , starting from the labels associated with the terminal nodes of a dendrogram . we start therefore with embedded clusters , and end up with terms and directed links between these terms . there is some non - uniqueness : any two labels associated with terminal nodes that are left and right child nodes of one non - terminal node can be interchanged . this clearly leads to a different label promotion outcome . our promotion procedure was motivated by the permutation representation of an oriented binary tree , as described above . here too we do not claim uniqueness of permutation representation . but we do claim optimality in the sense of parsimony , and well - definedness . in the case of a multiway tree with very few distinct levels , the promotion procedure becomes very simple , but continues to be non - unique . in the previous subsection , we discussed an algorithm which takes a hierarchical clustering , and hence a dendrogram , into an inorder tree traversal , and hence a permutation of the set of terms used . the formal procedure discussed in the previous subsection suffers from non - uniqueness : alternative permutations could be defined . this leads us to question the relationship of subsumption ( or direction in the oriented tree ) . in this section we will develop another approach which is even more closely associated with the data that we are analyzing . we have already seen that triangle properties between triplets of points , or data objects , are fundamental to ultrametricity and hence to tree representation . a dendrogram , representing a hierarchical clustering , allows us to read off , for all triplets of points , either ( i ) isosceles triangles , with small base , or ( ii ) equilateral triangles , and ( iii ) no other triangle configuration . the reason for the last condition is simply that non - isosceles , or isosceles with large base , triangles are incompatible with the ultrametric , or tree , metric . we will leave aside for the present the equilateral triangle case . firstly , it implies that all 3 points are _ ex aequo _ in the same cluster . secondly , therefore we will treat them altogether as a concept cluster . thirdly , the equilateral case does not arise in the example we will now explore . and [ den3 ] , with clusters indicated by ellipses . shown here are ellipses covering the clusters at nodes 7 , 6 , 5 , and 3.,width=529 ] in figure [ den6 ] , cluster number 3 indicates the following isosceles triangle with small base : ( ( existence , object ) position ) . our notation is : ( ( x , y ) z ) , such that triplet x , y , z has small base x , y , and the side lengths x , z and y , z are equal . this is necessarily implied by relationships represented in figure [ den6 ] . so , motivated by this triangle view of the cluster number 3 part of the dendrogram we will promote `` position '' to the cluster number 3 node . similarly we will promote `` motion '' to the cluster number 5 node . note the consistency of our perspective on the cluster number 3 and 5 nodes relative to how the associated terms here form an isosceles triangle with small base . we will straight away generalize this definition . in any case of a node in the form of nodes 3 or 5 , where we have a 2-term left subtree , and a 1-term right subtree , where left and right are necessarily labeled in this way given the canonical representation of the dendrogram , then : _ the left subtree is dominated by the right subtree_. we will next look at cluster number 6 ( remaining with figure [ den6 ] ) . as always for such trees , the node corresponding to this cluster has two subtrees , one to the left ( here : 3 ) and one to the right ( here : 5 ) . since our dendrogram is in canonical form , any such node has a subtree with smallest non - terminal node level to the left ; and the subtree which was more recently formed in the sequence of agglomerations to the right . based on either or both of these criteria which serve to define what are the left and right subtrees we define the ordering relationship : _ the left subtree is dominated by the right subtree_. figure not available : see pdf version of paper at www.cs.rhul.ac.uk/home/fionn/papers/auto_onto.pdf figure [ concepts ] summarizes the concept relations that we can derive in a similar way from any dendrogram . figure [ aristontoex ] indicates how the concept relations , shown in figure [ concepts ] , are to be used . firstly the term set is summarized , using our selection of terms . scaling to large data sets is addressed in this way . secondly , in our interactive implementation ( web address : + thames.cs.rhul.ac.uk/@xmath52dimitri/textmap ) , we allow the terms shown to continually move in a limited way , to get around the occlusion problem , and we also allow magnification of the display area for this same reason . thirdly , terms other than those shown are highlighted when a cursor is passed over them . next , double clicking on any term gives a ranked list of text segment names , ordered by frequency of occurrence by this term . clicking on the text segment gives the actual text at the bottom of the display area . are shown in decreasing size ( and in rainbow colors , from red ) , with other terms ( in all , 66 ) displayed with a dash , and all text segments ( in all , 24 ) represented by an asterisk . the principal factor plane of a correspondence analysis ( based on the 24 text segments @xmath53 66 terms frequencies of occurence ) output is used.,width=529 ] we proceed now to a third case study of this work , where we have a multiway hieararchy ( and not a binary hierarchy ) from the start . we require a frequency of occurrence matrix which crosses the terms of interest with parts of a free text document . for the latter we could well take documentary segments like paragraphs . oneill [ 2006 ] is a 660-word discussion of ubiquitous computing from the perspective of human computing interaction . with this short document we used individual lines ( as proxies for the sequence of sentences ) as the component parts of the document . there were 65 lines . this facilitates retrieval of a small segment of such a single document . we chose this text to work with because it is a very small text ( a single text compared to the data used in section [ sect6 ] , and a far smaller text compared to that used in section [ secorientree ] ) . based on a list of nouns and substantives furnished by the part - of - speech tagger ( schmid , 1994 ) , we focused on the following 30 nouns : support = @xmath54 `` agents '' , `` algorithms '' , `` aspects '' , `` attempts '' , `` behaviours '' , `` concepts '' , `` criteria '' , `` disciplines '' , `` engineers '' , `` factors '' , `` goals '' , `` interactions '' , `` kinds '' , `` meanings '' , `` methods '' , `` models '' , `` notions '' , `` others '' , `` parts '' , `` people '' , `` perceptions '' , `` perspectives '' , `` principles '' , `` systems '' , `` techniques '' , `` terms '' , `` theories '' , `` tools '' , `` trusts '' , `` users '' @xmath55 . this set of 30 terms was used to characterize through presence / absence the 65 successive lines of text , leading to correspondence analysis of the @xmath56 presence / absence matrix . this yielded then the definition of the 30 terms in a factor space . in principle the rank of this space ( taking account of the trivial first factor in correspondence analysis , relating to the centering of the cloud of points ) is min ( @xmath57 ) . however , given the existence of zero - valued rows and/or columns , the actual rank was 25 . therefore the full rank projection of the terms into the factor space gave rise to 25-dimensional vectors for each term , and these vectors are endowed with the euclidean metric . define this set of 30 terms as the _ support _ of the document . based on their occurrences in the document , we generated the following _ reduced _ version of the document , defined on this support , which consists of the following ordered set of 52 terms : reduced document = `` goals '' `` techniques '' `` goals '' `` disciplines '' `` meanings '' `` terms '' `` others '' `` systems '' `` attempts '' `` parts '' `` trusts '' `` trusts '' `` people '' `` concepts '' `` agents '' `` notions '' `` systems '' `` people '' `` kinds '' `` behaviours '' `` people '' `` factors '' `` behaviours '' `` perspectives '' `` goals '' `` perspectives '' `` principles '' `` aspects '' `` engineers '' `` tools '' `` goals '' `` perspectives '' `` methods '' `` techniques '' `` criteria '' `` criteria '' `` perspectives '' `` methods '' `` techniques '' `` principles '' `` concepts '' `` models '' `` theories '' `` goals '' `` tools '' `` techniques '' `` systems '' `` interactions '' `` interactions '' `` users '' `` perceptions '' `` algorithms '' this reduced document is just the `` time series '' of the nouns of interest to us , as they are used in traversing the document from start to finish . each noun in the sequence of 52 nouns is represented by its 25-dimensional factor space vector . out of 43 unique triplets , with self - distances removed , we found 31 to respect the ultrametric inequality , i.e. 72% . our measure of ultrametricity of this document , based on the support used , was thus 0.72 . for a concept hierarchy we need an overall fit to the data . using the euclidean space perspective on the data , furnished by correspondence analysis , we can easily define a terms @xmath53 terms distance matrix ; and then hierarchically cluster that . consistent with our analysis we recode all these distances , using the cvnc mapping onto @xmath58 for unique pairs of terms . now approximating a global ultrametric from below , achieved by the single linkage agglomerative hierarchical clustering method ( and this best fit from below , termed the subdominant or maximal inferior ultrametric , is optimal ) , and an approximation from above , achieved by the complete linkage agglomerative hierarchical clustering method ( and this best fit from above , termed a minimal superior ultrametric , is non - unique and hence is one of a number of best fits from above ) , will be identical if the data is fully ultrametric - embeddable . if we had an ultrametricity coefficient equal to 1 we found it to be 0.72 for this data then it would not matter what agglomerative hierarchical clustering algorithm ( among the usual lance - williams methods ) that we select . in fact , we found , with an ultrametricity coefficient equal to 0.72 , that the single and complete linkage methods gave an identical result . this result is shown in figure [ fig1 ] . a convenient label promotion procedure to apply here is first to re - represent the terminal labels from left to right as : @xmath54 `` users '' , `` trusts '' , @xmath59 , `` agents '' , `` algorithms '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` goals '' , `` perspectives '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` tools '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` techniques '' @xmath55 ; and @xmath54 `` methods '' @xmath55 . this is the canonical form , with ordering of left and right subtrees now extended to all subtrees . next , we must in fairness take the nodes at level 2 as being _ ex aequo _ , @xmath54 `` tools '' @xmath55 ; @xmath54 `` techniques '' @xmath55 ; and @xmath54 `` methods '' @xmath55 . similarly at level 1 , we also have two clusters that are _ ex aequo _ : @xmath54 `` users '' , `` trusts '' , @xmath59 , `` agents '' , `` algorithms '' @xmath55 ; and @xmath54 `` goals '' , `` perspectives '' @xmath55 . figure not available : see pdf version of paper at www.cs.rhul.ac.uk/home/fionn/papers/auto_onto.pdf figure [ ubiq ] shows our resulting scheme where level 1 clusters dominate level 2 clusters . this provides our ontology . the granularity of this one document is , as mentioned above , line - based , and there are 65 lines in all . hence retrieval of one or more of these document snippets is supported , and the ontology is based on a 30-noun document support . having first appraised text collections in terms of their local hierarchical structure , we then proceeded in this work to show how this new methodology could be employed for a wide range of tasks that include : * finding salient pairs and triplets of terms , which are not necessarily in sequence ; * permitting us to consider any given text as a whole with all pairwise relationships between terms , or alternatively as a time series with relationships restricted to terms that are successive in sequence ; * passing seamlessly from the exploration of local hierarchical structure to global hierarchical structure ; * especially when global hierarchical structure is manifest , being able to use any of a wide range of agglomerative clustering criteria to furnish the same resultant hierarchy ; * determining a hierarchy of concepts from the embedded , partially ordered subsets provided by a hierarchical clustering ; * obtaining unique results when given a 2-way hierarchical clustering tree , and then readily generalizing this to the practical case of multiway trees ; * exemplifying an efficient and an effective textual data processing pipeline ; and * through the measurement of local hierarchical structure , having available an approach to validating the appropriateness of any data for this data analysis pipeline . by analysis of text through local hierarchical relationships between terms we determine extensive internal textual structure , without being stifled by the more traditional approach of fitting some global structure , such as a hierarchy , to the text . a ( local ) hierarchical structure is a powerful one : it includes peer as well as subsumption types of relationships . we stress that we can find very pronounced hierarchical structures of this sort if we encode the text is novel ways . an example is to start with a euclidean spatial embedding of the terms and documents ( or segments of a document ) , which is quite traditional ; and then look at interrelationships between terms using `` relatively close / similar '' versus `` relatively distant / new '' ( and this alone can be shown to have metric properties ) . another example of an encoding - related strategy is not to take into consideration all interrelationships between terms , but only between successive terms , and thereby view the text as a particular type of time series . user interactivity with the system is to select the terms of interest ( people s personal names , industrial product names , location or venue names , etc . ) . the interrelationships between these terms are then explored through their local hierarchical links . our general application targeted is , as stated in murtagh et al . [ 2003 ] , to have readily available a self - description of data , as a basis for visually - based interactive and responsive querying of , retrieval from , and navigation of data collections . this work was carried out in the context of the european union sixth framework project , `` ws - talk , web services communicating in the language of their community '' , 20042006 . pedro contreras and dimitri zervas contributed to this work . the textmap demonstrator was developed by dimitri zervas . : : abou assali , a. and zanghi , h. 2006 . automated metadata hierarchy derivation . in _ proc . ieee ictta06 _ ( damascus , syria ) . : : ahmad , k. and gillam , l. ( 2005 ) . automatic ontology extraction from unstructured texts . in _ odbase 2005_. : : benzcri , j.p . _ lanalyse des donnes , tome i taxinomie , tome ii correspondances _ , 2nd ed . ( dunod , paris ) . : : chuang shui - lung and chien lee - feng ( 2005 ) . taxonomy generation for text segments : a practical web - based approach , acm transactions on information systems . 23 , 363396 . : : de soete , g. ( 1986 ) . a least squares algorithm for fitting an ultrametric tree to a dissimilarity matrix . _ pattern recognition letters _ , 2 , 133137 . : : denny , m. ( 2004 ) . ontology tools survey , revisited , at + http://www.xml.com/pub/a/2004/07/14/onto.html , july 2004 . : : doyle , l.b . semantic road maps for literature searches . _ journal of the acm_. 8 , 553578 . : : ganesan , p. , garcia - molina , h. and widom , j. ( 2003 ) . exploiting hierarchical domain structure to compute similarity _ acm transactions on information systems_. 21 , 6493 . : : gmez - prez , a. , fernndez - lpez , m. and corcho , o. ( 2004 ) . _ ontological engineering ( with examples from the areas of knowledge management , e - commerce and the semantic web ) _ ( springer , berlin ) . : : gruber , t. ( 2001 ) . what is an ontology ? , http://www-ksl.stanford.edu/kst/what-is-an-ontology.html , sept . : : janowitz , m.f . cluster analysis based on abstract posets , preprint . also presentation , enst de bretagne , 30 oct . 2004 ; dimacs , 9 mar . 2005 ; and sfc , 31 may 2005 . : : maedche , a. ( 2006 ) . _ ontology learning for the semantic web _ ( kluwer , dordrecht ) . : : murtagh , f. ( 1984a ) . counting dendrograms : a survey . _ discrete applied mathematics _ , 7 , 191199 . : : murtagh , f. ( 1984b ) . structures of hierarchic clusterings : implications for information retrieval and for multivariate data analysis . _ information processing and management _ , 20 , 611617 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2004 ) . on ultrametricity , data coding , and computation , _ journal of classification , 21 , 167184 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2005a ) . identifying the ultrametricity of time series , _ european physical journal b _ , 43 , 573579 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2005b ) . _ correspondence analysis and data coding with r and java _ ( chapman & hall / crc ) . : : murtagh , f. ( 2006a ) . ultrametricity in data : identifying and exploiting local and global hierarchical structure , arxiv : math.st/0605555v1 19 may 2006 . : : murtagh , f. ( 2006b ) . the haar wavelet transform of a dendrogram , + arxiv : cs.ir/0608107v1 28 aug 2006 , forthcoming in _ journal of classification_. : : murtagh , f. ( 2006c ) . symbolic dynamics in text : application to automated construction of concept hierarchies , _ festschrift for edwin diday _ , in press . available at : www.cs.rhul.ac.uk/home/fionn/papers : : murtagh . f. ( 2006d ) . visual user interfaces , interactive maps , references , theses , http://astro.u-strasbg.fr/@xmath52fmurtagh/inform : : murtagh , f. , taskaya , t. , contreras , p. , mothe , j. and englmeier , k. ( 2003 ) . interactive visual user interfaces : a survey , _ artificial intelligence review _ , 19 , 263283 . : : oneill , e. ( 2006 ) . understanding ubiquitous computing : a view from hci , in discussion following r. milner , ubiquitous computing : how will we understand it ? , _ computer journal _ , 49 , 390399 . : : schmid , h. ( 1994 ) . probabilistic part - of - speech tagging using decision trees . in _ proc . new methods in language processing _ ( see treetagger site ) . : : treetagger , www.ims.uni-stuttgart.de/projekte/corplex/treetagger/ decisiontreetagger.html : : sibson , r. ( 1973 ) . slink : an optimally efficient algorithm for the single - link cluster method , _ computer journal _ , 16 , 3034 . : : wache , h. , vgele , t. , visser , u. , stuckenschmidt , h. , schuster , g. , neumann , h. and hbner , s. ( 2001 ) . ontology - based integration of information a survey of existing approaches . in _ proceedings of the ijcai-01 workshop : ontologies and information sharing_.
Abstract: | [
"we study the notion of hierarchy in the context of visualizing textual data and navigating text collections . a formal framework for `` hierarchy '' is given by an ultrametric topology . this provides us with a theoretical foundation for concept hierarchy creation . a major objective is _ scalable _ annotation or labeling of concept maps . serendipitously we pursue other objectives such as deriving common word pair ( and triplet ) phrases , i.e. , word 2- and 3-grams . we evaluate our approach using ( i ) a collection of texts , ( ii ) a single text subdivided into successive parts ( for which we provide an interactive demonstrator ) , and ( iii ) a text subdivided at the sentence or line level . while detailing a generic framework , a distinguishing feature of our work is that we focus on _ locality _ of hierarchic structure in order to extract semantic information . * categories and subject descriptors : * h.5 ( information interfaces and presentation ) , i.5.3 ( clustering ) , h.5.2 ( user interfaces ) , i.7.2 ( document preparation ) , h.3 ( information storage and retrieval )"
] | 10,101 | 10,101 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: tidal theories have gained great attention in the last decade due to the large number of discovered close - in planets which orbit their parent stars with periods of a few days . according to classical theories ( e.g. darwin 1880 ; kaula 1964 ; mignard 1979 ) , the long - term tidal evolution of these planets results in orbital decay and circularization , on time - scales which depend on the physical properties of the interacting systems ( hut 1981 ; dobbs - dixon , lin & mardling 2004 ; ferraz - mello , rodrguez & hussmann 2008 ; jackson , barnes & greenberg 2009 ; rodrguez & ferraz - mello 2010 ) . the rotation of short - period planets is also affected by tidal interactions . it is nowadays accepted that the spin rate of planets soon after their formation was much higher than their orbital mean motion ( e.g. agnor , canup & levison 1999 ; kokubo & ida 2007 ) . however , the cumulative tidal effects causes the planet to spin down , reaching its stationary value in time - scales much shorter than those needed to circularize the planet orbit . this evolution ultimately results in the synchronous rotation ( the spin state in which the orbital and rotation periods coincide ) , which occurs when the planet orbit is circularized ( hut 1981 ; ferraz - mello et al . 2008 ) . for non - circular orbits , the synchronous rotation only occurs if an additional torque acts to counteract the tidal torque . the additional gravitational torque may be generated by planets with a rocky - like composition having a permanent equatorial deformation or frozen - in figure ( see goldreich & peale 1966 ; greenberg & weidenschilling 1984 ) . these torques , in contrast to the tidal ones , are conservative . in the context of the two - body problem , the gravitational interaction of the star with an asymmetric planet drive the planet rotation into different regimes of motion , including oscillations around exact spin - orbit resonances ( goldreich & peale 1966 ) . when dissipative tidal effects are taken into account , the oscillations are damped and the planet rotation is trapped into a resonance . indeed , the rotational motion of some solar system bodies can be explained by the combined effects of the tidal and asymmetric torques ( goldreich & peale 1966 ; greenberg & weidenschilling 1984 ; correia & laskar 2009 ) . mercury is an example of a rocky planet with a rotation state currently evolving in the 3/2 spin - orbit resonance ( pettengill & dyce 1965 ) . several models of the secular spin evolution of mercury have been developed , including i ) the chaotic evolution of its orbit ( correia & laskar 2004 ) ; ii ) effects of the core - mantle friction ( correia 2006 ; correia & laskar 2009 ) ; iii ) the evolution starting with retrograde and subsequent synchronous motion combined with impact events ( correia & laskar , 2012 ; wieczorek et al . 2012 ) ; iv ) the consideration of non - linear tidal theories ( makarov 2012 ) . however , despite the large amount of previous works , the question on how the current resonant state of mercury was achieved still remains under discussion . concerning the rotation of earth - like close - in extrasolar planets , a near synchronous motion is usually assumed in view of tidal evolution . however , correia , levrard & laskar ( 2008 ) have shown that when an additional torque is considered , the equilibrium rotation of tidally evolved planets can assume rotational states which depart from synchronism . moreover , as the capture probability in a non - synchronous spin - orbit resonance requires a non - circular orbit ( goldreich & peale 1966 ; celletti & chierchia 2008 ) , the rotation of several recently discovered super - earth planets in eccentric orbits can be currently evolving under a resonant motion , provided the planet figure can support a permanent equatorial deformation . as the eccentricity is tidally damped , several resonant trappings would become unstable and the planet rotation ultimately reaches synchronization for almost circular orbits . however , the locking in a non - synchronous resonance with the very short orbital period can protect certain planet s longitudes from solar radiation , providing more favorable conditions with respect to habitability as compared to non - resonant rotation ( dobrovolskis 2007 ) . moreover , heller , leconte & barnes ( 2011 ) studied the equilibrium rotation of super - earths and the implications on their habitability . they found that , under assumption of an evolution driven by tidal torques , the equilibrium value of the rotation period of gj 581 * d * is probably about two times smaller than the orbital period . in a recent work , callegari & rodrguez ( 2012 ) have analysed the rotation of extrasolar planets with orbital periods less than 33 days and masses below the mass of neptune . depending on one parameter related to the equatorial ellipticity and also on the orbital eccentricity , they identified regions of chaotic rotation in the phase space of some particular planets like 55 cnc**e * * , gj 1214**b * * , gliese 876**d * * , among others . the present investigation aims at two main aspects : i ) how the orbital evolution of the planet , due to tidal interaction with the central star , is altered when the asymmetric torque is considered ; and ii ) to analyse the occurrence of captures in spin - orbit resonant motions under combined effects of both torques for the planets kepler-10**b * * , 55 cnc**e * * and gj 3634**b**. these planets are examples of hot super - earths , which are close - in planets having a few earth - masses with a rocky - like composition . we are interested in the past behavior in the history of the rotation and the subsequent evolution to synchronization . we also discuss the possibility of a current evolution of the rotation of these planets into a super - synchronous resonance state . moreover , we investigate the implications on the orbital evolution due to such temporary resonant trappings . despite the continuously growing number of discovered planets , their rotation state and equilibrium figures remain unknown . in this work , we perform several numerical simulations of the evolution of the systems , assuming several values of unknown parameters , such as equatorial ellipticity and initial rotation . the results allow us to understand the past history of these systems , their current orbital configuration and final rotational states . it should be noted that the majority of previous works concerning spin - orbit interactions with tidal dissipation have been addressed in the context of a fixed keplerian orbit , with constant values of semi - major axis and eccentricity ( e.g. , celletti , froeschl & lega 2007 ; celletti & chierchia 2008 ) . this assumption is adequate for solar system bodies , where tidal interactions are weak and , consequently , variations of orbital elements are small . on the other hand , the existence of extrasolar planets with orbital periods of a few days indicates that their current orbital configurations would be the consequence of strong tidal interaction with the host star . in this case , the keplerian approximation is no longer valid . thus , we analyse spin - orbit interactions as the orbit evolves due to tidal effects . solving the exact equations of motion of the problem , we show that the forces arising from the potential of a asymmetric planet also contributes to the orbital variation , accelerating the orbital decay and the eccentricity damping , but only in the cases in which the rotation is locked in resonance . the spin - orbit problem can also be modeled by the use of averaged equations of motion , where only terms with secular and resonant arguments are retained ( e.g. celletti & chierchia 2008 ; correia & laskar 2009 ) . through this model , we compute the averaged variations of semi - major axis and eccentricity due to the combination of asymmetric and tidal forces . we also give an explicit expression for the critical value of the equatorial prolateness , for which a given spin - orbit resonance would become unstable . the study of the particular cases of 2/1 , 3/2 and 1/1 spin - orbit resonances indicates a good agreement with the results of the numerical simulations of the exact equations . this paper is structured as follows . in section [ model ] , we present the exact equations of motion of the spin - orbit problem . section [ num ] shows the results of the numerical simulations , illustrating the evolutions of kepler-10**b * * , gj 3634**b * * and cnc 55**e**. we show that , assuming a nonzero value of the equatorial ellipticity , different temporary resonant trappings of the rotation can occur , with implications in the orbital decay and circularization . an analytical approach in the context of the averaged equations is shown in section [ mean ] , explaining the results obtained in the numerical simulations . finally , section [ discussion ] is devoted to discussion and conclusions . with the reference axis @xmath0 , which is assumed coincident with the orbital pericenter direction . the angle between the long axis and the star - planet direction is given by @xmath1 , where @xmath2 is the true anomaly of the planet . ] we consider a planet orbiting a central star with a period of a few days . hereafter , we refer to @xmath3 and @xmath4 as the planet and star masses , respectively ; @xmath5 and @xmath6 as the planet radius and the instantaneous star - planet distance , respectively . the elements @xmath7 stand for the semi - major axis , eccentricity and mean - motion of the astrocentric orbit of the planet , respectively . we suppose that the rotating planet body can be approximated by a homogeneous triaxial ellipsoid , with the equatorial axes @xmath8 and @xmath9 and the rotation axis @xmath10 . we assume that @xmath11 and @xmath10 is normal to the orbital plane ( i.e. , no obliquity is considered ; planar problem ) . in addition , we assume that the equatorial asymmetry ( @xmath12 ) corresponds to a frozen - in body or permanent deformation of the planet . the assumption above can be supported under consideration of a rocky composition of the planet body . this is the case of super - earth planets , which are the subject of the present investigation . the gravitational potential of the planet at the distance @xmath6 from its centre is given by ( e.g. beutler 2005 , p. 102 ) @xmath13 where @xmath14 is the gravitational constant and the angles , which has not been included in the present paper ( see ferraz - mello et al . @xmath2 and @xmath15 are defined in figure [ elips ] . note that @xmath16 is the angular rotation velocity of the planet . the parameter @xmath17 describes the equatorial ellipticity of the planet s gravity field and is related to the principal momenta of inertia @xmath18 through @xmath19 , where @xmath20 is the structure constant given by @xmath21 and @xmath22 is the polar moment of inertia . we neglect the contribution of terms arising from the oblateness of the rotating body , that is , @xmath23 and higher order terms . in fact , in the planar problem , the gravitational potential corresponding to the @xmath23term depends only on the distance @xmath6 . in this case , the potential generates a radial force with zero torque that does not affect the rotation evolution . at the distance @xmath6 from the centre of the planet , the gravitational field @xmath24 gives rise to a force on a point mass @xmath4 which is given by adopted in beutler ( 2005 ) , the corresponding force is computed as the positive gradient of the potential . ] @xmath25 where @xmath26 and @xmath27 are unit vectors with origin in the star ( see fig . [ elips ] ) . the force @xmath28 alters the orbital component of the angular momentum , whereas the reaction force governs the evolution of the spin through the creation of the torque on the planet given by @xmath29 where @xmath30 and @xmath31 . thus , @xmath32 note that , for @xmath33 and @xmath19 , the above equation agrees with the classical expression for the torque ( e.g. danby 1962 ; goldreich & peale 1966 ) . the effects of the dynamical tides are raised by the gravitational action of the star on the inelastically deformed rotating planet . due to the internal viscosity of the body , there exists a delay @xmath34 ( time lag ) between the star perturbation and the maximum deformation . the relationship between @xmath34 and tidal frequencies ( which are linear combinations of @xmath35 and @xmath36 ) depends on the internal rheology , which is poorly known even for solar system bodies . for sake of simplicity , in this work , we adopt a linear model with constant @xmath34 ( darwin 1879 ; mignard 1979 ; hut 1981 ; rodrguez et al . 2011a ) ; for a review of other tidal models , the reader is referred to efroimsky & williams ( 2009 ) and ferraz - mello ( 2012 ) . according to mignard ( 1979 ) , the tidal force and torque are given by @xmath37,\ ] ] and @xmath38,\ ] ] where @xmath39 and @xmath40 is the second degree love number . in this paper , we only consider the tides raised by the star on the planet , neglecting the tides raised on the star by the planet . indeed , the strength of stellar tide is proportional to the planet mass and can be safely neglected in the case of super - earths ( see rodrguez & ferraz - mello 2010 ) . note however that , after circularization of the planet orbit , stellar tides may be the only source of orbital decay . in the reference frame centered in the star ( see figure [ elips ] ) , the exact equations of motion of the planet can be now written as @xmath41 the perturbing forces @xmath28 and @xmath42 alter the keplerian orbit of the planet which is defined by the first term of the first equation , while the corresponding torques in the second equation produce variations of the planet rotation . note that , in the planar case , this last equation can be written in scalar form , because both torques are normal to the orbital plane . in this section we apply the analytical model described in the previous section , in order to investigate the motion of three known super - earths planets , namely kepler-10**b * * , 55 cnc**e * * and gj 3634**b**. for this task , the exact equations of motion ( [ mov1 ] ) were integrated numerically using the ra15 code ( everhart 1985 ) . we stress that no scaling parameter , often used to accelerate the tidal evolution , was used in our simulations ( see , for instance , tittemore & wisdom ( 1988 ) , for the validity of the usage of the scaling parameter ) . table 1 shows the physical parameters and current orbital elements of the systems considered in this paper . [ tab1 ] .physical parameters and current orbital elements of the analysed systems ( @xmath43batalha et al . 2011 ; @xmath44gillon et al . 2012 ; @xmath45bonfils et al . 2011 ) . the first two planets were discovered through the transit technique , allowing us a good estimation of their radii . @xmath46 and @xmath47 stand for mass and radius of the earth , respectively . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] numerical integrations require a setting of the initial configurations of the systems . in the case of problems including dissipative processes , the choice is complicated , mainly , due to the inadequacy of the simulations of the past evolution of dissipative systems through integrations backward in time ( see details in michtchenko & rodrguez 2011 ) . however , as shown in that paper , the final state of a migrating system is independent of its initial position in the phase space , defined by three values of parameters : the mass and semi - major axes ratios and the total angular momentum . as a consequence , to assess the orbit configuration in the past , we have to set solely the starting semi - major axis value . the initial eccentricity should satisfy the conservation of the total angular momentum of the system . the total angular momentum of the system is composed of the orbital component written as @xmath48 , and the rotational component given by @xmath49 . using kepler s third law , it is easy to show that the ratio of rotational and orbital components is of the order of @xmath50 ( see rodrguez et al . 2011a ) ; since @xmath51 , the contribution of rotation to the total angular momentum can be neglected . therefore , considering that the orbital angular momentum is nearly conserved during tidal migration , we obtain that @xmath52 where the subscripts ini " and current " stand for initial and current orbital elements , respectively . in this way , choosing an initial value for the semi - major axis and knowing the current values of @xmath53 and @xmath54 , equation ( [ am ] ) allows us to constrain the initial value of the eccentricity ( see next section and specially figure [ am - fig ] ) . it should be emphasized that the value obtained in such a way must be considered as an approximation of the initial value of the eccentricity , since the planets may belong to systems with two or more planets . the value of @xmath34 is determined by the relationship between the tidal frequency @xmath55 and the quality factor @xmath56 . in the case of a linear approximation , we have @xmath57 , where @xmath58const . it is known that , in the fourier spectrum of the tidal potential , the most important frequencies ( that is , those involved in terms of order zero and order one in the eccentricity ) are @xmath59 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 . the first one is associated to the term which is independent of the eccentricity , while the two last frequencies correspond to terms which are proportional to @xmath54 ( darwin , 1879 ; ferraz - mello et al . 2008 ) . using the frequency @xmath62 and a modified version of the quality factor written in terms of the love number @xmath40 as @xmath63 , we obtain @xmath64 actually , the spin rotation of exoplanets is not available from observations , thus we choose its initial value arbitrarily but considering a super - synchronous motion ( @xmath65 ) . finally , according to callegari & rodrguez ( 2012 ) , the equilibrium shape attained by the planet due to the gravitational interaction with the star , results in a prolateness , or equatorial ellipticity , which can be computed as @xmath66 . knowing that @xmath19 we can obtain the magnitude of @xmath17 for the planets with estimated radius . for the planets kepler-10**b * * and 55 cnc**e * * ( see section [ k10 ] and [ 55cnc ] ) , we obtain @xmath67 and @xmath68 , respectively , assuming @xmath69 . for sake of comparison with some rocky solar system tidally evolved bodies , we note that @xmath70 in the case of mercury ( smith et al . 2012 ) , @xmath71 for titan ( iess et al . 2010 ) and @xmath72 for io ( schubert et al . 2004 ) . the integration of the exact equations of motion usually requires a long computation time . for this reason , we decided to work with a small set of initial spin - orbit configurations and physical parameters . a statistical analysis taking into account many different initial conditions could give us a more accurate global picture of the past spin - orbit evolution of the planets . as pointed out by correia & laskar ( 2009 ) , such statistical study is more adequate in the context of the averaged equations of the spin - orbit problem ( see section [ mean ] ) . ( solid black curve ) . the dotted line corresponds to the case @xmath73 , where the trappings 2/1 and 3/2 occur . after escaping from the 3/2 resonant motion , the rotation follows the sts towards a synchronization between the rotation and orbital motions . ] kepler-10**b * * is a very close - in planet with a period of @xmath74 0.84 days , orbiting an old ( @xmath75 12 gyr ) sun - like star ( batalha et al . the physical parameters and the current orbital elements of the planet are summarized in table 1 . the estimated mass and radius values ( @xmath76 , @xmath77 ) suggest a rocky composition of the planet , which can be considered as a super - earth ( valencia 2011 ) . the transit technique measurements do not allow a reliable estimation of the current orbital eccentricity , which was arbitrarily fixed at zero in this work . this choice is supported by our numerical simulations of the whole system , which includes also the exterior companion , kepler-10 * c*. the results have shown that the long - term evolution , due to the coupled effect of tides and mutual interaction , could result in the complete circularization of both planetary orbits ( rodrguez et al . , in preparation ) . we adopt the initial semi - major axis at @xmath78 au , which provides @xmath79 through equation ( [ am ] ) . in addition , we set @xmath80 and @xmath81 . for the tidal parameter , we assume @xmath82 ( a value usually adopted for rocky planets ) and , solving equation ( [ k2dt ] ) , we obtain @xmath83 1.1 min . in section [ sett ] we have estimated that , for kepler-10**b * * on its current orbit , @xmath67 . it should be emphasized that @xmath17 would be smaller if the frozen - in shape of the planet was attained at larger distances than @xmath84 . hence , in order to investigate different possible scenarios , we consider three different values of @xmath17 , namely , @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 . for kepler-10**b * * depending on the value of @xmath17 . different evolutions are observed , including captures in 2/1 , 3/2 and 1/1 spin - orbit resonances ( sors ) . the solid black curve corresponds to the evolution for @xmath88 ( i.e. , when only the tidal torque exist ) and coincides with the stationary tidal solution ( sts , see text for discussion ) of the rotation . the captures in the synchronous motion are detailed on the small panel . ] figure [ stat - k10 ] shows the variation of @xmath89 as a function of the eccentricity of kepler-10**b**. the curve with segments line corresponds to the stationary tidal solution ( hereafter sts ) of the rotation ( @xmath90 ) , obtained when only the tidal torque is considered . the sts is a function which depends only on the planet eccentricity , and is given by @xmath91 ( see equations ( 42 ) or ( 43 ) of hut ( 1981 ) ; see also section [ mean ] for more details ) . the stationary rotation evolves with the tidally damped eccentricity and the system reaches synchronization ( @xmath92 ) only for circular orbits . note that for small values of @xmath54 , there follows that @xmath93 ; for this reason , the sts is also called pseudo - synchronous solution ( but this is valid only for @xmath94 ) . the solid black curve in figure [ stat - k10 ] corresponds to the result of the numerical simulation performed with @xmath88 ( only tidal forces are considered ) . in this case , the stationary rotation is attained almost instantaneously ( when compared to the time of circularization ) . note that both curves are in good agreement , at least for @xmath95 ; hence , in this eccentricity interval , we can refer to the solution obtained with @xmath88 as sts . we also note that the curve for @xmath88 reaches the sts for @xmath89 close to two ; however , this is incidental and unrelated with the 2/1 trapping . figure . [ rot - k10 ] shows the time variation of @xmath89 . for the three considered values of @xmath96 , the rotation rapidly encounters the value @xmath97 and thus the planet rotation is captured in the 2/1 spin - orbit resonance ( hereafter sor ) . on one hand , for @xmath98 and @xmath99 , the rotation escapes from the 2/1 trapping approximately at 80 kyr , when the rotation drops to the value @xmath100 , implying capture into 1/1 sor and synchronous motion . however , it is worth noting that , for @xmath98 , the synchronism is attained in a form of jump , whereas for @xmath99 the rotation evolves without capture for a very short time before the 1/1 sor ( see small panel in fig . [ rot - k10 ] ) . we have also plotted the result for @xmath88 , showing that synchronization is attained around 400 kyr . it is interesting to note that the introduction of the equatorial asymmetry of the planet reduces the time to reach synchronization ; for instance , for @xmath98 , it is reduced by a factor of 5 . on the other hand , when @xmath73 , the 2/1 sor is destabilized at around 48 kyr giving rise to the trapping in the 3/2 sor ( @xmath101 ) . thus , the permanence of the rotation in the 2/1 sor is temporary and its duration clearly depends on the @xmath17 value . the rotation evolves in a mercury - like state for some time , when a new instability occurs , after which an evolution free of trapping starts . note that during the period of non - capture , the rotation returns to the stationary value , as can be seen in the dotted curve of fig . [ stat - k10 ] when @xmath102 . finally , the synchronization is reached at around 270 kyr . and @xmath54 depend on the specific capture in which the rotation is trapped in . as different values of @xmath17 lead to several captures , different scenarios are expected for the orbital evolution , despite the final values of the elements being the same for all @xmath17 ( see next figure ) . ] shows the final evolution . the orbital decay continues until circularization is achieved . the current semi - major axis of kepler-10**b * * coincides with the one obtained in the simulation . ] figures [ ae - zoom - k10][ae - k10 ] show the time evolution of semi - major axis and eccentricity of kepler-10**b**. we note that , when the rotation evolves under capture in resonance ( that is , for @xmath96 ) , the rates of variations of the elements are larger than the one corresponding to the pure tidal case ( @xmath88 ) , with the difference increasing as the eccentricity is damped ( when the comparison is done for a given sor ) . moreover , for the same value of @xmath17 , the rate of orbital decay and circularization seems to depend on the specific sor in which the planet rotation is trapped in . for example , in the case of @xmath73 , the evolutions of @xmath53 and @xmath54 show two different regimes as the rotation evolves first in the 2/1 and then in 3/2 trappings ( see section [ mean ] ) . we note that the time necessary to get an orbit with @xmath103 is much greater for @xmath104 . in fact , when the rotation evolves without capture , the time - scale for circularization increases , according to figures [ ae - zoom - k10 ] and [ ae - k10 ] . it is worth noting that , in the case of @xmath96 , the synchronous motion can be attained even for @xmath105 . for instance , in the case of @xmath99 , the system is captured in 1/1 sor at roughly 120 kyr , when @xmath106 . this fact confirms the classical result that , for eccentric orbits , the synchronous motion is only possible if there exists an additional torque which counteracts the tidal torque ( see goldreich & peale 1966 ; ferraz - mello et al . 2008 and references therein ) . we also note that after circularization , the 1/1 sor is the only possible resonant motion . figure [ am - fig ] shows the evolution of the system in the plane of orbital elements @xmath53 and @xmath54 . the solid line shows the result of numerical simulation in the case of @xmath98 . the dashed line corresponds to equation ( [ am ] ) , which is independent on the value of @xmath17 . note as both curves are in very good agreement , in such a way confirming our assumption about the conservation of the orbital angular momentum ( section [ sett ] ) . . the solution of equation ( [ am ] ) is shown by the dashed line and is compared to the result of the numerical simulation for the case @xmath98 , giving a good agreement ( the curves for the other two @xmath17 values also agree with the solution of equation ( [ am ] ) , but are not shown here for sake of simplicity ) . the starting position of the planet is indicated by the star symbol . ] gj 3634 b is a super - earth planet with mass @xmath107 orbiting a m2.5 dwarf each 2.65 days with an eccentricity of @xmath108 ( bonfils et al . since there is no transit detection for this planet , its radius is unknown . however , valencia , sasselov & oconnell ( 2007 ) have shown that there is a maximum radius that a rocky terrestrial planet may achieve for a given mass . a larger radius would imply a large amount of water and even the possibility of a massive volatile envelope . indeed , for a planet with mass @xmath109 the maximum terrestrial radius would be 11,600 km ( @xmath110 ) , which result in a mean density of @xmath111 . hence , we assume for gj 3634 b that @xmath112 to obtain @xmath113 . the adopted initial orbital elements are @xmath114 au and @xmath115 , while @xmath116 , @xmath81 and @xmath82 ( @xmath117 min ) . at the current value of the semi - major axis the estimated value of @xmath17 is @xmath118 ( section [ sett ] ) ; in this work , we perform the analysis using two values of @xmath17 : @xmath86 and @xmath87 . as a function of @xmath54 ( left panel ) and the time evolution of @xmath53 ( right panel ) for the planet gj 3634**b**. depending on @xmath17 , the planet rotation may be currently evolving in either 2/1 or 3/2 sor . note that the time - scale of orbital decay is drastically reduced provided the planet can support a permanent deformation resulting in a nonzero @xmath17 value . the vertical and horizontal dotted lines indicates the current values of @xmath54 and @xmath53 , respectively , title="fig : " ] as a function of @xmath54 ( left panel ) and the time evolution of @xmath53 ( right panel ) for the planet gj 3634**b**. depending on @xmath17 , the planet rotation may be currently evolving in either 2/1 or 3/2 sor . note that the time - scale of orbital decay is drastically reduced provided the planet can support a permanent deformation resulting in a nonzero @xmath17 value . the vertical and horizontal dotted lines indicates the current values of @xmath54 and @xmath53 , respectively , title="fig : " ] figure [ rot - exce - gj3634 ] shows the variation of @xmath89 as a function of @xmath54 ( left panel ) and the time variation of @xmath53 ( right panel ) . for @xmath99 , the rotation is rapidly trapped in the 2/1 sor , remaining in such resonant configuration during the most time of the tidal eccentricity damping . only at low eccentricities , close to 0.032 , the system leaves the 2/1 sor dropping directly into the synchronous motion . at variance , for @xmath73 , the rotation quickly reaches the stationary ( non - resonant ) state given by the sts curve ( @xmath88 ) in figure [ rot - exce - gj3634 ] ( left ) . the system evolves along the sts curve up to close approach to the 3/2 sor . then , the system is captured and remains in this resonance until dropping in the synchronized state , at @xmath119 . in both cases , the final configuration of the planet s orbit is characterized by circularization and synchronization , as in the case of kepler-10**b**. however , the current eccentricity of the gj 3634**b * * is different from zero ( its location at 0.08 is shown by the dotted vertical line in the left panel of figure [ rot - exce - gj3634 ] ) . note that the current eccentricity is reached when the rotation still evolves in the 2/1 or 3/2 sor ( depending on @xmath17 ) . this fact suggests that gj 3634**b * * could be presently involved in one of such resonant trappings , in particular , it could be found in a mercury - like rotational state ( @xmath120 ) . however , it should be kept in mind , that this conclusion depends on the choice of specific values of @xmath17 and @xmath121 . indeed , the results of an additional simulation performed with @xmath122 , have shown that the trapping of the system in the 3/2 sor is destabilized at @xmath123 . since @xmath124 , the planet rotation would be currently evolving without capture ( along the sts ) for such a small @xmath17 value . the semi - major axis evolution ( figure [ rot - exce - gj3634 ] , right panel ) shows that the tidal decay is faster when the rotation of the planet is trapped in the 2/1 and 3/2 spin - orbit resonant motions . the fact that the current eccentricity of the planet orbit is different from zero suggests that , in the absence of other perturbations , the orbital decay when @xmath92 or @xmath125 ( see equation ( [ a-11-tot2 ] ) ) . ] of the planet is presently in progress and , consequently , the final semi - major axis will be smaller than the current one . 55 cnc**e * * is a hot super - earth planet , with the mass @xmath126 and the radius @xmath127 , orbiting a sun - like star each 0.74 days with @xmath128 ( winn et al . 2011 ; gillon et al . the averaged density of the planet is comparable to that of earth , suggesting a rock - iron composition supplemented by a significant mass of water , gas , or other light elements ( @xmath129 ) indicate that the possibility of 55 cnc**e * * to be a mini - neptune instead of a super - earth should not be ruled out . ] ( winn et al . 2011 ) . for numerical simulations , we adopt @xmath130 au , @xmath131 , @xmath80 and @xmath81 . the tidal history of the system indicates that the magnitude of @xmath121 must be higher than the commonly adopted values for rocky planets ( ferraz - mello 2012 ) . in this work , we use @xmath132 ; this value allows us to obtain @xmath133 s. we perform numerical simulations for two different values of @xmath17 : @xmath85 and @xmath86 . for the purpose of further comparison with the results reported in callegari & rodrguez ( 2012 ) , we also consider the values @xmath134 and @xmath135 . figure [ rot - exce-55cnc ] shows the evolution of rotation as a function of the planet s eccentricity . the captures inside the 5/2 , 2/1 , 3/2 , 4/3 and 1/1 resonances can be observed . for @xmath134 , the planet rotation evolves under capture in the 3/2 sor almost up to the orbital circularization , with @xmath89 roughly varying between 1.46 and 1.54 . as a function of @xmath54 ( in logarithmic scale ) , for the planet 55 cnc**e**. we have used @xmath98 in addition to the value adopted in callegari & rodrguez ( 2012 ) @xmath134 . also values ten times smaller were taken into account for sake of completeness . the vertical dotted line indicates the current value of @xmath54 , namely , 0.057 . the trappings in the rsos 5/2 , 2/1 , 3/2 , 4/3 and 1/1 appear during the evolutions . note the large amplitude oscillation of @xmath89 inside the 3/2 and 4/3 cases with @xmath17 of the order of @xmath85 . depending on @xmath17 , 55 cnc**e * * can be an example of a planet currently evolving in the 5/2 , 2/1 or 3/2 sor . ] together with the sts curve . as for previously analysed planets , the orbital decay is faster when the planet rotation is trapped in a resonant motion . the current value of @xmath53 is obtained for all values of @xmath17 . ] in a recent work , callegari & rodrguez ( 2012 ) have shown that , for @xmath128 and @xmath136 ( or @xmath134 ) , the phase space of the rotation ( @xmath137 ) of 55 cnc**e * * , between the main spin - orbit resonances , is dominated by a large region of chaotic motion . this region increases as larger values of the eccentricity are considered . capture in spin - orbit resonance can work as a mechanism to prevent a chaotic rotation , provided that the dissipation is large enough in order to ensure the corresponding trapping . according to our simulations ( see figure [ rot - exce-55cnc ] ) , destabilizations of different resonances occur as the eccentricity is tidally damped ( see also next section ) , giving rise to new temporary trappings with a subsequent evolution to synchronism . in this way , a chaotic behavior of the rotation can be avoided by a continuous evolution under resonant motion . it is important to note that , at least for the cases shown in figure [ rot - exce-55cnc ] , there is no interval of non - resonant motion between two successive trappings , as in the case of kepler-10**b * * ( see figure [ rot - k10 ] for @xmath99 and @xmath87 ) . an additional simulation done with @xmath138 ( not shown in figures ) , has resulted in a 2/1 trapping until @xmath139 , indicating that the planet rotation may be currently evolving in resonant motion , for such a small value of @xmath17 . figure [ elem-55cnc ] shows the time variation of semi - major axis . it is worth noting that the orbital decay results in a more rapid evolution towards @xmath84 when the planet rotation is trapped in a sor . also , the rate of variation depends on the specific resonance . from figure [ elem-55cnc ] we see that the evolution when @xmath140 , ( capture in 2/1 ) is almost two times faster than the one for @xmath134 ( 3/2 capture ) . we will return to this discussion in the next section . in order to better understand the results previously obtained through numerical simulations of the exact equations of motion , in this section , we develop an analytical approach in the context of the averaged equations of the spin - orbit problem . the equation of motion for the spin in equation ( [ mov1 ] ) can not be solved analytically . however , because we are interested in the evolution inside spin - orbit resonances , we will consider planetary spin rates having values such that @xmath141 , where @xmath142 is a half - integer . our investigation is restricted to the cases @xmath143 , @xmath144 and @xmath145 but can be easily extended to any other sor . we introduce the `` resonant '' angle @xmath146 , where @xmath147 is the mean anomaly of the planet orbit and @xmath15 was defined in section [ model ] . note that the angle @xmath148 gives the orientation of the long axis whenever the planet passes through the pericenter of its orbit ( i.e. , @xmath149 when @xmath150 , see figure [ elips ] ) . it is easy to show that , inside the spin - orbit resonance given by the parameter @xmath142 , the resonant angle is a slowly varying variable when compared to the orbital period of the planet . indeed , we can write that @xmath151 , where @xmath152 and , consequently , @xmath153 . now , replacing @xmath15 by @xmath154 in equation ( [ t22 ] ) and averaging over the orbital period , we obtain the classical result for the averaged torque on the planet produced by the permanent equatorial deformation ( see goldreich 1966 ; goldreich & peale 1966 ) : @xmath155 where @xmath156 are power series of @xmath54 with the leading term of order @xmath157 ( see appendix a for a literal expansion up to seventh order ) . the averaged tidal torque on the planet is given by @xmath158 where @xmath159 and @xmath160 is a suitable function , whose expansion in powers of @xmath54 is shown in appendix a ( hut 1981 ) . at resonance , the equilibrium solution of the rotation is given by the condition @xmath161 and , resolving for @xmath162 , we obtain @xmath163 if we know the maximum value that @xmath148 can reach without disturbing the trapping in the @xmath142sor , we may obtain the minimum value of @xmath17 necessary for capture in the same resonant motion . replacing @xmath143 in equation ( [ j22-gral ] ) and expanding the ratio @xmath164 in powers of @xmath54 , up to order 6 , we obtain @xmath165 we note that , for @xmath166 , the above expression is the same obtained in ferraz - mello et al . ( 2008 ) , for synchronous asymmetric planets . should be done , where @xmath167 is the phase lag of the tidal wave whose frequency is @xmath168 . ] the averaged variation of the orbital elements can be obtained using the euler - gauss equations ( see beutler 2005 , p. 230 ) , which are written in terms of the radial and transverse components of the perturbing force . the result for the semi - major axis is @xmath169 replacing @xmath162 by the corresponding expression given in equation ( [ j22 - 11 ] ) , we obtain @xmath170 in the context of the linear tidal model , the averaged variation of the semi - major axis due to tides is given by equation ( 9 ) of hut ( 1981 ) , valid for any values of @xmath142 and @xmath54 . the expansion up to @xmath171 reads @xmath172}+{\cal o}(e^8).\ ] ] replacing @xmath143 in the above equation we obtain @xmath173 the total averaged variation of the semi - major axis is then given as @xmath174 and thus @xmath175 at the same order of approximation , the above equation coincides with the result of previous works ( see ferraz - mello et al . ( 2008 ) and references therein ) . when only the tidal torque on the planet is taken into account , the non - resonant sts is given by equation ( [ sync ] ) . in this case , the synchronism is possible only for circular orbits . if instead of @xmath143 , we replace @xmath176 in equation ( [ a - tide - gral ] ) , we obtain @xmath177 we define @xmath178 as the ratio between averaged semi - major axis variation in the @xmath142sor ( @xmath179 ) and in the tidal stationary solution of the rotation ( @xmath180 ) , that is @xmath181 comparing equations ( [ a-11-tot2 ] ) and ( [ a-11-tide - stat ] ) , we note that @xmath182 , indicating that the rate of semi - major axis decay is stronger when the rotation is locked in the 1/1 sor , compared to the case when it evolves following the sts . this result is in agreement with wisdom ( 2008 ) , who has shown that the rate of energy dissipation in a body with synchronous rotation is larger than in a asymptotic non - synchronous rotation . we repeat the procedure described in the previous section to obtain the averaged variation of the planet eccentricity . the resulting expressions are : @xmath183 @xmath184 @xmath185 @xmath186 similarly to the semi - major axis variation case , @xmath187 , where @xmath188 is the analogous for the eccentricity of equation ( [ ra ] ) . we analyse in this section the spin - orbit behavior when the planet evolves in the 3/2 and 2/1 sors , employing the same method described in the previous section has no term independent of @xmath54 and thus equation ( [ j22-gral ] ) can not be expanded around @xmath189 . ] . we have @xmath190 and @xmath191 as a function of orbital eccentricity , for @xmath145 , 3/2 and 1 . in the cases of @xmath192 the ratio of rates of variation of @xmath53 in the sor and in the sts increases for small @xmath54 , showing that the orbital decay is enhanced ( when compared with the evolution in the sts ) whenever the planet rotation evolves under resonance with the orbital motion . ] figure [ razao ] shows a plot of @xmath178 for the three analysed resonances as a function of the eccentricity . on one hand , we note that @xmath193 and @xmath194 increase for small eccentricity , indicating that the major effect on the orbital evolution due to the resonance captures occurs as @xmath54 decreases , in agreement with the results of the numerical simulations ( see figures [ ae - zoom - k10 ] , [ rot - exce - gj3634 ] and [ elem-55cnc ] ) . on the other hand , for large @xmath54 , @xmath195 is small ( mainly in the case @xmath144 ) as also shown in figures [ ae - zoom - k10 ] and [ rot - exce - gj3634 ] , where there is a small difference between the evolutions with and without @xmath17 ( i.e , @xmath196 ) . when the synchronous motion is analysed , we note in figure [ razao ] that @xmath197 is an increasing function of @xmath54 , indicating that the orbital decay when the rotation is trapped in the 1/1 sor is large for large @xmath54 . however , as simulations show , synchronism is attained for very low values of @xmath54 , making the orbital decay almost negligible . the results above are also valid for @xmath198 . it is interesting to note that @xmath178 and @xmath198 are only functions of the eccentricity and do not depend on any physical parameter . it is worthwhile mentioning that @xmath199 averages to zero unless the condition @xmath141 is assumed ( whit @xmath142 integer ) , that is , the averaged orbital evolution due to the triaxial torque is expected only for resonant cases . as it has been noted , equation ( [ j22-gral ] ) can be used to obtain the minimum value of @xmath17 necessary for the stability of the @xmath142sor . calling @xmath200 the one value given by the right hand of equation ( [ j22-gral ] ) , the stability condition for a resonant spin state requires that @xmath201 . the above condition is frequently found in literature as strength criterion of the resonance ( see murray & dermott 1999 , p. 205 ) . figure [ c22 ] shows the functional dependence of the absolute value of @xmath200 with the eccentricity , obtained for kepler-10**b**. the dashed horizontal lines represent three values of @xmath17 used in the numerical simulations shown in section [ k10 ] , namely , @xmath202 and @xmath87 . the case @xmath145 , shown by the blue curve , indicates that @xmath203 for @xmath204 , @xmath205 for @xmath206 and @xmath207 for @xmath208 . a good agreement is obtained doing the comparison with the results of the numerical simulations for kepler-10**b * * , shown in figure [ rot - exce - k10 ] . note as the 2/1 sor destabilizes when @xmath209 , @xmath206 and @xmath208 . the same can be observed for the 3/2 sor , in which the rotation escapes from the trapping when @xmath123 if @xmath73 , in concordance we use @xmath210 , taking also into account that truncated series in @xmath54 were used for the same figure . ] with the result of figure [ c22 ] ( orange curve ) . since for roughly @xmath211 the condition @xmath201 is satisfied more easily for @xmath143 as compared to @xmath192 , there is no problem in understanding the occurrence of synchronous motion for very small eccentricity , as can be also verified in figure [ rot - exce - k10 ] . it is worth noting that instead to compute a critical @xmath17 value , the condition for stationary solutions @xmath212 also enables us to obtain a critical value of @xmath54 for a given fixed @xmath17 . the resonant motion would destabilize whenever the eccentricity becomes smaller than the critical value for each sor . this approach is more convenient in those cases for which the observations allow an estimation of @xmath17 ( see correia & laskar ( 2004 ) for the study of the rotation of mercury ) . given by equation ( [ j22-gral ] ) and calculated with parameters of the planet kepler -10**b**. the calculation of @xmath200 can be used as a guide to investigate the stability of a given sor as a function of eccentricity ( see text for discussion ) . note that in the case of @xmath143 we have @xmath213 for @xmath214 ( see equation ( [ j22 - 11 ] ) ) , indicating that the synchronism is the only possible resonant motion for circular orbits ( see goldreich & peale 1966 ; celletti & chierchia 2008 ; callegari & rodrguez 2012 ) . ] as a function of the orbital eccentricity for kepler-10**b * * , resulting from the analysis of numerical simulations of the exact equations of motion ( see section [ k10-res ] ) . if a comparison with the results of figure [ c22 ] is done , we obtain a good agreement for the values of @xmath54 for which each sor destabilizes ( see text for details ) . ] the numerical exploration of the planet rotation which is subject to the conservative triaxial gravitational torque of the star shows different behaviors , including the oscillation around the equilibrium points of spin - orbit resonances ( see callegari & rodrguez 2012 and references therein ) . when dissipative effects produced by tidal torques are included , the rotation of close - in bodies can be captured in a resonant motion ( goldreich 1966 ; goldreich & peale 1966 ; celletti & chierchia 2008 ) . the capture in a specific resonance depends on the eccentricity @xmath54 and on parameters related to tides and equatorial ellipticity ( @xmath56 and @xmath17 , respectively ) . hence , since @xmath54 is tidally damped during the inward migration , each specific capture should become unstable and the rotation can achieve another resonant state , which , at the same time , should result in a temporary trapping . when the orbit is circularized , the final evolution results in the synchronization between the orbital and rotational periods ( i.e , the 1/1 spin - orbit resonance ) . in this paper , we analysed the coupled spin - orbit evolution of kepler-10**b * * , gj 3634**b * * and 55 cnc**e * * short - period super - earth planets . the numerical simulation of the exact equations of motion have shown that , depending on @xmath17 , the rotation displays a number of resonance trappings for which @xmath141 , including the cases @xmath215 , 2 , 3/2 , 4/3 and 1 . moreover , the results indicate that gj 3634**b * * can be an example of an exoplanet with a rotation state similar to mercury s rotation ( @xmath144 ) , provided the body figure can support a permanent equatorial asymmetry as small as @xmath73 . 55 cnc**e * * can currently evolve under 5/2 or 3/2 trappings if @xmath216 and under 2/1 if @xmath140 or even if @xmath17 is as small as @xmath217 . the rotation of 55 cnc**e * * may have a chaotic behavior for @xmath216 ( callegari & rodrguez 2012 ) . however , we have shown that a scenario is possible in which the rotation evolves to synchronism through successive trappings in sor . indeed , the eccentricity damping due to tides provides the destabilization mechanism required to escape from one given capture and subsequently evolve to lower order resonances ( see correia & laskar 2004 , 2009 ) . we have shown that different spin - states corresponding to various resonance captures can occur in extrasolar systems . although the 1/1 spin - orbit coupling is the final state of evolution , it is not reached in every case as present configuration . for current non - circular orbits , trappings in the 3/2 sor or other resonance configurations can be sustained over long times . the latter would depend on the orbital eccentricity , the planet s @xmath17 value and its dissipation factor . given that these parameters are not well - determined for terrestrial extrasolar planets , we note that the 1/1 coupling may not be the current rotation state of some planets . this would have consequences on the stellar insulation and therefore on the evolution of the atmosphere and surface of the planet . when only the tidal torque is taken into account ( @xmath88 ) , the rotation evolves to the stationary tidal solution ( sts ) . we have shown that under assumption of @xmath96 , the evolution along spin - orbit resonance ( sor ) leads to higher rates of orbital decay and circularization than the corresponding ones when the rotation evolves in the sts . moreover , for a given @xmath17 value , the variation rates of the elements depend on the specific trapping in which the rotation is trapped in , and increases with @xmath142 ( see figure [ ae - zoom - k10 ] ) . we have also calculated the averaged rates of variations of semi - major axis and eccentricity including the gravitational and tidal torques . moreover , through the analytical calculation of the critical value of @xmath17 it is possible to predict the values of the eccentricity for which a given sor would become unstable . the comparison with the direct numerical simulations have shown a good concordance for the analysed planets . the importance of the @xmath17 value on the rotational history of the planet is illustrated in the example of kepler-10**b**. it is worth noting that the planet rotation of kepler-10**b * * can evolve under the influence of the 2/1 sor for longer time - scales ( i.e. , small @xmath54 ) provided the planet figure can support a permanent equatorial deformation characterized by @xmath216 . for smaller @xmath17 , the 2/1 resonant state would become unstable for relatively large eccentricity ( figures [ c22 ] and [ rot - exce - k10 ] ) . we stress that the results of the numerical simulations provide different possible spin - orbit evolutions depending on the considered initial values of elements and rotation . the @xmath56 value and the specific tidal model would also play an important role in determining the rotation history of the planet , since the temporary trapping in sor depends on the rate of eccentricity damping , which is @xmath56-dependent . in fact , in a recent paper , makarov ( 2012 ) has applied the model by efroimsky ( 2012 ) and successfully explained the current resonant state of mercury within the considered model . our results concerning the association of the critical @xmath17 value with the capture probability are not new in the context of averaged equations of the spin - orbit problem ( see for instance correia & laskar 2004 , 2009 ) . however , in this work , we are able to compare the results of the averaged equations with those resulting from the numerical simulations of the exact equations of motion . a model of planet interior including the effect of viscous friction at the core - mantle boundary would provide quantitatively different results ( see peale 2005 , and correia & laskar 2009 , for the case of mercury ) . according to previous works the chances of resonant capture increase if the latter effect is taken into account ( goldreich & peale 1967 ; peale & boss 1977 ) . however , in order to highlight the contribution of @xmath17 to the orbital evolution , in this paper we adopt a simple model neglecting a possible layered structure of the planet . in the present study we have assumed constant @xmath17 values . however , depending on the adjustment to hydrostatic equilibrium @xmath17 may be itself time - dependent . the time - scale for adjustment to the completely relaxed state depends on material parameters , e.g. , rigidity and viscosity which are highly temperature dependent . furthermore , it will depend on the spin - orbit coupling the planet is trapped in . for the application to terrestrial planets given here the constant , i.e. frozen , @xmath17 configuration is justified because adjustment of solid rocky planets to equilibrium usually occurs on geological time - scales . therefore , the states described here do not necessarily represent hydrostatic configurations . in this work we have considered a model of one interacting planet , despite the fact that kepler-10**b * * and 55 cnc**e * * belongs to multiple - planet systems with exterior ( more massive ) companions . previous works have shown that the mutual secular interaction with the companion may affect the eccentricity evolution of the tidally evolved planet , increasing the circularization time - scale ( mardling 2007 ; rodrguez et al . 2011a ; rodrguez et al . moreover , the planetary perturbations can produce large excursions of the innermost planet eccentricity , providing a mechanism for increasing or decreasing the capture probability of the spin - orbit resonances ( correia & laskar 2004 , 2009 ) . however , a numerical simulation of 55 cnc system including the exterior companion 55 cnc**b * * has shown little differences with the single planet case . indeed , the evolution of the inner orbit eccentricity is almost not affected by the mutual interaction between the planets and thus the rotation evolution of 55 cnc**e * * can be safely analysed within the one planet model . an investigation about the rotation of asymmetric close - in super - earths including an exterior companion will be addressed in a future investigation . the authors acknowledge the support of this project by fapesp ( 2009/16900 - 5 ( a.r ) ; 2006/58000 - 2 ( n.c ) ) and cnpq . the authors also gratefully acknowledge the support of the computation centre of the university of so paulo ( lcca - usp ) . we are grateful to the reviewer for his / her valuable comments . we show here the explicit expressions for the functions @xmath156 and @xmath218 . the exact form of @xmath156 is given by
Abstract: | [
"we investigate the spin behavior of close - in rocky planets and the implications for their orbital evolution . considering that the planet rotation evolves under simultaneous actions of the torque due to the equatorial deformation and the tidal torque , both raised by the central star , we analyze the possibility of temporary captures in spin - orbit resonances . the results of the numerical simulations of the exact equations of motions indicate that , whenever the planet rotation is trapped in a resonant motion , the orbital decay and the eccentricity damping are faster than the ones in which the rotation follows the so - called pseudo - synchronization . analytical results obtained through the averaged equations of the spin - orbit problem show a good agreement with the numerical simulations . we apply the analysis to the cases of the recently discovered hot super - earths kepler-10**b * * , gj 3634**b * * and 55 cnc**e**. the simulated dynamical history of these systems indicates the possibility of capture in several spin - orbit resonances ; particularly , gj 3634**b * * and 55 cnc**e * * can currently evolve under a non - synchronous resonant motion for suitable values of the parameters . moreover , 55 cnc**e * * may avoid a chaotic rotation behavior by evolving towards synchronization through successive temporary resonant trappings . celestial mechanics planets and satellites : general ."
] | 10,308 | 10,308 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: superconducting films are candidate substances for the improvement of electronics technology in a myriad of applications . while the low resistance is very attractive in this regard , it has proved difficult to control the nonlinear behaviour of such materials in response to electromagnetic field@xcite . when a magnetic field is strong enough to penetrate into a superconductor in the form of quantised magnetic flux tubes , the vortex state obtains as a mixed state of superconducting phase punctuated by the vortices themselves . vortices are surrounded by a supercurrent and can be forced into motion by the current resulting from an applied field . as a topological defect , a vortex is not only stable under perturbations@xcite but can not decay . the collection of vortices in a type - ii superconductor forms what is called vortex matter , and it is this which determines the physical properties of the system rather then the underlying material properties , in particular driving phase transitions@xcite . in the mixed state , a superconductor is not perfect ; it exhibits neither perfect diamagnetism nor zero electrical resistance . the transport current @xmath0 generates a lorentz force @xmath1 on the vortex and forces it into motion , dissipating energy . in reaching thermal equilibrium , energy is transferred via interactions between phonons and quasiparticle excitations . small - scale imperfections such as defects scatter the quasiparticles , affecting their dynamics . in _ superconductors , impurities are plentiful and vortices experience a large friction . this implies a fast momentum - relaxation process . in contrast is the _ clean _ limit , where impurities are rare and no such relaxation process is available . it is in this situation of slow relaxation that the hall effect appears . generally , the @xmath2-@xmath3 phase diagram@xcite of the vortex matter has two phases . in the _ pinned phase _ vortices are trapped by an attractive potential due to the presence of large - scale defects , thus resistivity vanishes . this phase contains what are known as glass states . there is then the _ unpinned phase _ in which vortices can move when forced and so a finite resistivity appears . this phase is also known as the flux - flow region and can be of two types . one type is a liquid state where vortices can move independently ; the other type is a solid state in which vortices form a periodic abrikosov lattice@xcite resulting from their long - range interacton . one model for the transition between the pinned and unpinned phases appears in @xcite . in the unpinned phase , the system is driven from equilibrium and experiences a relaxation process . there are several ways to describe such a system . a microscopic description@xcite invoking interactions between a vortex and quasi - particle excitations at the vortex core provides a good understanding of friction and sports good agreement with experiments in the sparse - vortex region @xmath4 . there is also a macroscopic description , the london approach , where vortices are treated either as interacting point - like particles or an elastic manifold subject to a pinning potential , driving force and friction@xcite . in the small - field region , vortices behave as an array of elastic strings . in the dense - vortex region @xmath5 , where the magnetic field is nearly homogeneous due to overlap between vortices , ginzburg - landau ( gl ) theory , which describes the system as a field , provides a more reasonable model . in dynamical cases , time - dependent gl ( tdgl ) theory is appropriate@xcite ; in gl - type models , additional simplification can come from the lowest landau level ( lll ) approximation which has proven to be successful in the vicinity of the superconducting - normal ( s - n ) phase transition line @xmath6 . this has been pursued in the static case@xcite ( without driving force ) and in the dynamic case with a time - independent transport current@xcite . it may be noted that in the glass state , zero resistance within the lll approximation can not be attained@xcite . based on tdgl theory , we will study the dynamical response of a dense vortex lattice forced into motion by an alternating current induced by an external electromagnetic field . vortices are considered which are free from being pinned and thermally excited , which in addition to thermal noise would produce entanglement and bending . we assume the vortices can transfer work done by an external field to a heat bath . experimentally , a low - temperature superconductor far away from the clean limit is the best candidate for attaining these conditions . we do not consider thermal fluctuation effects specific to high - temperature superconductors . in a dissipative system driven by a single - harmonic electric field @xmath7 , long after its saturation time we can expect the system to have settled into steady - state behaviour , where the vortices are vibrating periodically with some phase . the tdgl model in the presence of external electromagnetic field is analysed and solved in . the dynamical s - n phase transition surface @xmath8 is located in @xmath9-space . this surface coincides with the mean - field upper - critical field @xmath10 in the absence of the applied field , and with the phase - transition surface in the presence of the constant driving field considered by hu and thompson@xcite . we will provide an analytical formalism for perturbative expansion in the distance to @xmath11 , valid in the flux - flow region . the response of vortex matter forced into motion by the transport current is studied in . the current - density distribution and the motion of vortices are treated in . in analysing the vortex lattice configuration in , a method is utilised whereby the heat - generation rate is maximised . next are discussed power dissipation , generation of higher harmonics , and the hall effect . an experimental comparison is made in with far - infrared ( fir ) measurement on nbn . finally , some conclusions are made in . let us consider a dense vortex system prepared by exposing a type - ii superconducting material to a constant external magnetic field @xmath12 with magnitude @xmath13 . we also select the @xmath14 axis of the superconductor to be in the @xmath15 direction . let the superconductor carry an alternating electric current along the @xmath16 direction , generated by an electric field @xmath17 as shown in . such a system when disturbed from its equilibrium state will undergo a relaxation process . for our system , the tdgl equation@xcite is a useful extension of the equilibrium gl theory . in the dense - vortex region of the @xmath2-@xmath3 phase diagram , vortices overlap and a homogeneous magnetic field obtains . describing the response of such a system by a field , the order parameter @xmath18 in the gl approach , is more suitable than describing vortices as particle - like flux tubes , as is done in the london approach@xcite . a strongly type - ii superconductor is characterised by its large penetration depth @xmath19 and small coherence length @xmath20 , @xmath21 . the difference between induced magnetic field and external magnetic field is @xmath22 . in the vicinity of the phase - transition line @xmath10 vortices overlap significantly , and @xmath23 making @xmath24 small . in this case , the magnetic field may be treated as homogeneous within the sample . we will have in mind an experimental arrangement using a planar sample very thin compared with its lateral dimensions . since the characteristic length for inhomogeneity of electric field@xcite @xmath25 is then typically large compared with sample thickness , this implies that the electric field may also be treated as homogeneous throughout@xcite , eliminating the need to consider maxwell s equations explicitly . in equilibrium , the gibbs free energy of the system is given by@xcite @xmath26&=&\int\td { \bf r } \bigg\ { \frac{\hbar^2}{2m_{ab}}|{\bf d}\psi|^2 + \frac{\hbar^2}{2 m_c}|\partial_z \psi|^2 \nonumber\\ & & { \ \ \ \ } -\alpha ( \tnst - t)|\psi|^2+\frac{\beta}2 |\psi|^4 \bigg\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath27 is the critical temperature at zero field . covariant derivatives employed here preserve local gauge symmetry and are two - dimensional ; @xmath28 and @xmath29 . governing the dynamics of the field @xmath18 is the tdgl equation @xmath30 this determines the characteristic relaxation time of the order parameter . microscopic derivation of tdgl can be found in @xcite in which the values of @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 are studied . in the macroscopic case , these are viewed simply as parameters of the model . at microscopic scale , disorder is accounted for by @xmath33 , the inverse of the diffusion constant ; the relation of @xmath33 to normal - state conductivity is discussed in . in standard fashion , @xmath34 while @xmath35 . our set of equations is completed@xcite by including ampre s law , writing for the total current density @xmath36 as we shortly make a rescaling of quantities , we have written @xmath37 subscripts here for clarity . the first term is the normal - state conductivity . the second term can be written using a maxwell - type equation relating the vector - potential with the supercurrent , @xmath38 .\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is a gauge - invariant model ; we fix the gauge by considering the explicit vector potential @xmath39 and @xmath40 , corresponding to an alternating transport current . each vortex lattice cell has exactly one fluxon . we do not assume the electric field and the motion of vortices are in any particular direction relative to the vortex lattice , by way of rendering visible any anisotropy . for convenience , we define some rescaled quantities . the rescaled temperature and magnetic field are @xmath41 and @xmath42 . @xmath43 denotes the mean field upper - critical field , extrapolated from the @xmath27 region down to zero temperature . in the @xmath44-@xmath45 plane of the crystal we make use of _ magnetic length _ @xmath46 . we define @xmath47 where @xmath48 . the scale on the @xmath14-axis is @xmath49 with @xmath50 . the coordinate anisotropy in @xmath15 is absorbed into this choice of normalisation , as can be seen in . the order parameter @xmath18 is scaled by @xmath51 . the time scale is normalised as @xmath52 . therefore , frequency is @xmath53 . note that @xmath54 is then inversely proportional to @xmath45 . the amplitude of the external electric field is normalised with @xmath55 so that @xmath56 . after our rescaling the tdgl equation takes the simple form @xmath57 where the operator @xmath58 is defined as @xmath59 with our specified vector potential , covariant derivatives are @xmath60 , @xmath61 and @xmath62 . we define @xmath63 for convenience . the tdgl equation is invariant under translation in @xmath15 , thus the dependence of the solution in the @xmath15 direction can be decoupled . @xmath58 is not hermitian ; @xmath64 where the conjugation is with respect to the usual inner product , defined below . we will make extensive use of the eigenfunctions of @xmath58 and @xmath65 in what follows . the eigenvalue equation @xmath66 defines the set of eigenfunctions of @xmath58 appropriate for our analysis ; this can be seen in . the convention is that @xmath67 when and only when @xmath68 . taking corresponding in @xmath58 and switches it in the resulting @xmath69 to get the ` corresponding ' eigenfunction @xmath70 for @xmath65 . ] eigenfunctions of @xmath65 to be @xmath71 , the orthonormality @xmath72 may be chosen , so long as @xmath73 . shown in , crystal structure determines linear combinations of these basis elements with respect to @xmath74 ; the resulting @xmath75 functions are then useful for expansion purposes below . the inner product is @xmath76 where the brackets @xmath77 denote an integral over space and time . to define averages over only time or space alone , we write @xmath78 or @xmath79 respectively . ; ( b ) typical small angle , plotted for @xmath80 . in the static case , both @xmath81 and @xmath80 are two particular angles will correspond to the same energy . the applied constant magnetic field @xmath82 is along the @xmath83 direction and time - dependent oscillating electric field @xmath84 is in the @xmath16 direction . @xmath85 is the the apex angle of the two defining lattice vectors . the two vectors for the rhombic vortex lattice are @xmath86 and @xmath87 where @xmath88 . the motion of vibrating vortices , indicated by the red arrow , is disccused in . , title="fig:",width=151 ] ; ( b ) typical small angle , plotted for @xmath80 . in the static case , both @xmath81 and @xmath80 are two particular angles will correspond to the same energy . the applied constant magnetic field @xmath82 is along the @xmath83 direction and time - dependent oscillating electric field @xmath84 is in the @xmath16 direction . @xmath85 is the the apex angle of the two defining lattice vectors . the two vectors for the rhombic vortex lattice are @xmath86 and @xmath87 where @xmath88 . the motion of vibrating vortices , indicated by the red arrow , is disccused in . , title="fig:",width=151 ] states of the system can be parametrised by @xmath89 . by changing temperature @xmath90 , a system with some fixed @xmath91 may experience a normal - superconducting phase transition as temperature passes below a critical value @xmath92 . such a point of transition is also known as a _ bifurcation point_. the material is said to be in the normal phase when @xmath18 vanishes everywhere ; otherwise the superconducting phase obtains , with @xmath18 describing the vortex matter . because of the vortices , the resistivity in the superconducting phase need not be zero . the s - n phase - transition boundary @xmath92 separates the two phases . to study the condensate , we will use a bifurcation expansion to solve . we expand @xmath18 in powers of distance from the phase transition boundary @xmath93 . as in the static case , we can locate the dynamical phase - transition boundary by means of the linearised tdgl equation@xcite . this is because the order parameter vanishes at the phase transition , and we do not need to consider the nonlinear term . the linearised tdgl equation is written @xmath94 of the eigenvalues of @xmath58 , only the smallest one @xmath95 , corresponding to the highest superconducting temperature @xmath93 , has physical meaning . the s - n phase transition occurs when the trajectory in parameter space intersects with the surface @xmath96 where the lowest eigenvalue is calculated in ; @xmath97 utilising a @xmath45-independent frequency @xmath98 and amplitude @xmath99 of input signal , we write @xmath100 in the absence of external driving field , @xmath101 , the phase - transition surface coincides with the well - known static - phase transition line @xmath102 in the mean - field approach . with time - independent electric field at @xmath103 , where the vortex lattice is driven by a fixed direction of current flow , the dynamical phase - transition surface coincides with that proposed in @xcite , but with a factor of @xmath104 . this amplitude difference is familiar from elementary comparisons of dc and ac circuits . in the above equation , we can see that in the static case @xmath101 , the superconducting region is @xmath105 . in addition when @xmath106 , the superconducting region in the @xmath45-@xmath90 plane is smaller than the corresponding region in the static case , as can be seen in ( a ) . finally , increasing frequency will increase the size of the superconducting region , as in ( b ) ; in the high - frequency limit , the area will reach its maximum , which is the superconducing area from the static case . as with any damped system , response is diminished at higher frequencies . the superconducting state does not survive at small magnetic field ; for example at @xmath107 in ( a ) , the material is in the normal state over most of the @xmath2-@xmath3 phase diagram . later in this paper we will consider interpretation of this phenomenon . in particular , when discussing energy dissipation in , we will see that the main contribution to the dissipation is via the centre of the vortex core . at small magnetic field , since there are fewer cores to dissipate the work done by the electric field , the superconducting state is destroyed and the order parameter vanishes . as a function of @xmath45 for various @xmath99 at @xmath108 and ( b ) @xmath93 as a function of @xmath99 for various @xmath109 at @xmath110 . the straight line in ( a ) is the @xmath101 curve and corresponds to the mean - field phase - transition line @xmath102 . states above each line are normal phase while the region below each line is superconducting . @xmath99 suppresses the superconducting phase as shown in ( a ) , while @xmath109 removes this suppression effect , as shown in ( b ) . , title="fig:",width=158 ] as a function of @xmath45 for various @xmath99 at @xmath108 and ( b ) @xmath93 as a function of @xmath99 for various @xmath109 at @xmath110 . the straight line in ( a ) is the @xmath101 curve and corresponds to the mean - field phase - transition line @xmath102 . states above each line are normal phase while the region below each line is superconducting . @xmath99 suppresses the superconducting phase as shown in ( a ) , while @xmath109 removes this suppression effect , as shown in ( b ) . , title="fig:",width=158 ] that the vortex matter dominates the physical properties of the system is especially pronounced in the pinning - free flux - flow region . here we solve by a bifurcation expansion@xcite . since the amplitude of the solution grows when the system departs from the phase transition surface where @xmath111 , we can define a distance from this surface as @xmath112 and expand @xmath18 in @xmath113 . the tdgl in terms of @xmath113 is @xmath114 where @xmath115 is the operator @xmath58 shifted by its smallest eigenvalue . @xmath18 is then written @xmath116 and it is convenient to expand @xmath117 in terms of our eigenfunctions of @xmath118 @xmath119 in principle , all coefficients @xmath120 in can be obtained by using the orthogonal properties of the basis , which are explained in . inserting @xmath18 from equation into tdgl equation , and collecting terms with the same order of @xmath113 , we find that for @xmath121 @xmath122 and for @xmath123 @xmath124 for @xmath125 @xmath126 and so on . observing , the solution for the equation is @xmath127 where @xmath128 is a particular linear combination of all eigenfunctions with the smallest eigenvalue . the coefficient of @xmath129 can be obtained by calculating the inner product of @xmath130 with , @xmath131 in the same way , the coefficient of the next order @xmath132 , can be obtained by finding the inner product of @xmath133 with the @xmath125 equation , @xmath134 the inner product of @xmath135 on gives the coefficient for @xmath136 @xmath137 and @xmath138 the solution of tdgl is then @xmath139 in this paper we will restrict our discussion to the region near @xmath93 where the next - order correction can be disregarded ; @xmath140 we would like to emphasise that our discussion at this order is valid in the vicinity of the phase - transition boundary and in particular for a superconducting system without vortex pinning . in such a system , vortices move in a viscous way , resulting in flux - flow resistivity ; no divergence of conductivity is expected . our results based on were calculated at @xmath129 order , where only the lowest eigenvalue @xmath141 of the tdgl operator @xmath58 makes an appearance . the next - order correction is at order @xmath132 , and there is now a contribution from higher landau levels . from the symmetry argument in @xcite , as long as the hexagonal lattice remains the stable configuration for the system , the next - order contribution comes from the sixth landau level with a factor @xmath142 . even in the putative case of a lattice deformed slightly away from a hexagonal configuration , the next contributing term is @xmath143 , since in our system the lattice will remain rhombic . the vortex lattice has been experimentally observed since the 1960s and its long - range correlations have been clearly observed@xcite with dislocation fraction of the order @xmath144 . remarkably , the same techniques can be used to study the structure and orientation of moving vortex lattice with steady current@xcite , and with alternating current in the small - frequency regime@xcite . in this subsection , we will discuss the configuration of the vortex lattice in the presence of alternating transport current in the long - time limit . in the dynamical case , the presence of an electric field breaks the rotational symmetry of an effectively isotropic system to the discrete symmetry @xmath145 . in contrast , a rhombic lattice preserves at least a symmetry of this kind along two axes , and the special case of a hexagonal lattice preserves sixfold symmetry . the area of a vortex cell is determined by the quantised flux in the vortex , which is @xmath146 in terms of our rescaled variables . as shown in , we choose a unit cell @xmath147 defined by two elementary vectors @xmath148 and @xmath149 . we will first construct a solution for an arbitrary rhombic lattice parameterised by an apex angle @xmath85 . consideration of translational symmetry in the @xmath150 direction leads to the discrete parameter @xmath151 . in we show that in the long - time limit the lowest - eigenvalue steady - state eigenfunctions of @xmath58 must therefore combine to form @xmath152{2 \sigma}\sum_{l=-\infty}^{\infty } e^{i \frac{\pi}2 l(l-1 ) } e^{i k_l ( x- v \sin\omega \tau/\omega ) } u_{k_l}(y,\tau ) .\ ] ] here @xmath128 is normalised as @xmath153 the function @xmath154 is given by @xmath155 ^ 2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath156 } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in analogy with a forced vibrating system in mechanics , a phase @xmath157 and a reduced velocity @xmath158 have been introduced for convenience in . the zero electric - field limit , large - frequecy limit and zero frequency limit are consistent with previous studies concluded in . in our approximation , the @xmath159 in is a time - independent quantity from and @xmath160 where @xmath161 . in the small signal limit @xmath162 , @xmath159 reduces to the abrikosov constant . the abrikosov constant with either @xmath80 or @xmath163 minimises the gl free energy in the static state@xcite . to be more explicit , @xmath159 can be expanded in terms of the amplitude of input signal . in powers of @xmath164 , @xmath165 and we find it convenient to write in terms of @xmath166 . the first term in @xmath159 is the abrikosov constant @xmath167 for hexagonal lattices @xmath168 , whereas for a square lattice @xmath169 . the next term in @xmath159 is @xmath170 with a coefficient @xmath171 we see that at high frequency , the correction in higher order terms of @xmath166 can be disregarded . in this section we discuss the current distribution and motion of vortices , energy transformation of the work done on the system into heat , nonlinear response and finally the hall effect . in addition to the conventional conductivity attributable to the normal state , there is an overwhelming contribution due to the superconducting condensate in the flux - flow regime , tempered only by the dissipative properties of the vortex matter . in this section we will examine the supercurrent density to investigate the motion of the vortex lattice . we consider a hexagonal lattice in a fully dissipative system ; the non - dissipative part known as the hall effect will be discussed in . the supercurrent density @xmath172 is obtained by substitution of the solution into . @xmath173 and @xmath174 where @xmath175 and @xmath154 is given in . observing , we conceptually split the current into two components . one part is the circulating current surrounding the moving vortex core as in the static case ; we refer to this component as the _ diamagnetic current_. the other part which we term the _ transport current _ is the component which forces vortices into motion . : ( a ) @xmath176 ; vortex cores move to the right . ( b ) @xmath177 ; vortex cores move to the left . vortices are drawn back and forth as the direction of the transport current density alternates . the magnitude of the current density has maximal regions which tend to circumscribe the cores ; the maxima in these regions move in the plane and their manner of motion can be described as leading the motion of the vortices by a small phase . the average current in a unit cell leads the motion of the vortex in time by a phase of @xmath178 . , title="fig:",width=158 ] : ( a ) @xmath176 ; vortex cores move to the right . ( b ) @xmath177 ; vortex cores move to the left . vortices are drawn back and forth as the direction of the transport current density alternates . the magnitude of the current density has maximal regions which tend to circumscribe the cores ; the maxima in these regions move in the plane and their manner of motion can be described as leading the motion of the vortices by a small phase . the average current in a unit cell leads the motion of the vortex in time by a phase of @xmath178 . , title="fig:",width=158 ] the diamagnetic current may be excised from our consideration by integrating the current density over the unit cell @xmath147 ; that is , we consider @xmath179 . we have @xmath180 and @xmath181 with our conventions , the transport current is along the @xmath16-direction . considering the lorentz force between the magnetic flux in the vortices and the transport current , we expect the force on the vortex lattice to be perpendicular . we identify the locations of vortex cores to be where @xmath182 . the velocity of the vortex cores turns out to be @xmath183 along the @xmath150-direction . note that vortex lattice moves coherently . the vortex motion the electric field with a phase @xmath184 which increases with frequency and reaches @xmath178 asymptotically . the maximum velocity of vortex motion @xmath185 decreases with increasing frequency . in we show the current distribution and the resultant oscillation of vortices . as anticipated , the transport current and the motion of vortices are perpendicular as the vortices follow the input signal . the current density diminishes near the core ; it is small there compared to its average value . in steady - state motion , since the vortices move coherently in our approximation , the interaction force between vortices is balanced as in the static case . since the system is entirely dissipative , the motion that the vortices collectively undergo is viscous flow . the vortex lattice responds to the lorentz driving force as a damped oscillator , and this is the origin of the frequency - dependent response . in static case the system is described by the gl equation . solving this equation , which is but with zero on the left - hand side , will select some lattice configuration . the global minima of the free energy correspond to a hexagonal lattice , while there may be other configurations producing local minima . in the static case the lattice configuration can be determined in practice by building an ansatz from the linearized gl solution@xcite and then using a variational procedure to minimise the full free energy . in the dynamic case , there is no free energy to minimise ; we must embrace another method of making a physical prediction regarding the vortex lattice configuration . let us follow @xcite and take as the preferred structure the one with highest heat - generation rate . though we have at present no precise derivation , our physical justification of this prescription is that the system driven out of equilibrium can reach steady - state and stay in condensate only if the system can efficiently dissipate the work done by the driving force . therefore , whatever the cause , the lattice structure most conducive to the maintenance of the superconducting state will correspond to the maximal heat generation rate . the heat - generating rate@xcite is @xmath186 \big\ } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath159 is given explictly in and is the only parameter involving the apex angle @xmath85 of the moving vortex lattice . here @xmath159 plays the same rle as the abrikosov constant @xmath187 in the static case . corresponding to maximising the heat - generating rate , the preferred structure can be obtained by simply minimising @xmath159 with respect to @xmath85 . this shows from the current viewpoint of maximal heat - generation rate that vortices are again expected to move coherently . in or it is seen that the moving lattice is distorted by the external electric field but this influence subsides at high frequency . numerical solution for minimising @xmath85 shows that while near the high - frequency limit there remain two local minima for @xmath159 with respect to @xmath85 , the solution near @xmath81 is favoured slightly over that at @xmath188 as the global minimum . this is as presented in ( a ) . the two minima tend to approach each other slightly as the frequency begins to decrease further . in an experimental setting , this provides an avenue for testing the empirical validity of the maximal heat generation prescription , in particular in terms of the direction of lattice movement@xcite . we put forth the physical interpretation that at high frequency the friction force becomes less important , and the distortion is lessened . since interactions dominate the lattice structure the system at high frequency will have many similarities with the static case . energy supplied by the applied alternating current is absorbed and dissipated by the vortex matter , and the heat generation does not necessarily occur when and where the energy is first supplied . in , we show an example of this transportation of energy by the condensate . on the left is shown a contour plot of the work @xmath189 done by the input signal ; points along a given contour are of equal power absorption . on the right of is shown the heat - generating rate@xcite , @xmath190 . the periodic maximal regions are near the vortex cores in both patterns . and @xmath191 : ( a ) work @xmath192 and ( b ) heat generating rate @xmath193 . the vortex cores are denoted by ` @xmath194 ' in both figures , shown in the @xmath150-@xmath16 plane . the maximum displacements of vortex cores are shown by the arrow . the maximal region around the core in ( a ) is elongated by the current . the similar horizontal broadening around the core in ( b ) is caused by the vortex motion . energy is transported ; maxima in ( a ) and ( b ) do not coincide . , title="fig:",width=158 ] and @xmath191 : ( a ) work @xmath192 and ( b ) heat generating rate @xmath193 . the vortex cores are denoted by ` @xmath194 ' in both figures , shown in the @xmath150-@xmath16 plane . the maximum displacements of vortex cores are shown by the arrow . the maximal region around the core in ( a ) is elongated by the current . the similar horizontal broadening around the core in ( b ) is caused by the vortex motion . energy is transported ; maxima in ( a ) and ( b ) do not coincide . , title="fig:",width=158 ] in ( b ) , one can see that the system dissipates energy via vortex cores . from a microscopic point of view , cooper pairs break into quasiparticles inside the core ; these couple to the crystal lattice through phonons and impurities to transfer heat . the interaction between vortices and excitation of vortex cores manifests as friction@xcite . the power loss of the system averaged over time and space is @xmath195 . @xmath196 \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath197 is a bessel function of the first kind . ( upper panel ) and expansion parameter @xmath113 ( lower panel ) as a function of frequency @xmath109.,width=340 ] in is shown the power loss and also @xmath113 as a function of frequency . @xmath113 is proportional the density of cooper pairs , and can be thought of as an indication of how robust is the superconductivity . as frequency increases , while @xmath113 tends to an asymptotic value , @xmath198 achieves a maximum and then decreases ; this maximum is due to fluctuations of order parameter caused by the input signal . in a fully dissipative system as considered here , the maximum of each curve is not a resonance phenomenon but is instead caused by fluctuation of the order parameter resulting from the influence of the applied field . a parallel may be drawn between what we have observed in this section and the suppression of the superconductivity by macroscopic thermal fluctuations commonly observed in high - temperature superconductors . in our case , the vortices in a high-@xmath199 superconductor undergo oscillation due to the driving force of the external field . we may think of this as being analogous to the fluctuations of vortices due to thermal effects alone in a low-@xmath199 superconductor . although the method of excitation is different , the external electromagnetic perturbation in the present case essentially plays the same rle as the thermal fluctuations in low-@xmath199 situation . finally , we point out that @xmath113 seems to be an appropriate parameter for determining the amount of power loss . generically , it seems that for points deeped inside the superconducting region , that is at large @xmath113 compared with its saturation value at high @xmath109 , the power loss due to the dissipative effects of the vortex matter becomes suppressed . we suggest the possibility that this effect , which is navely intuitive , is in fact physical and more widely applicable than merely the present model . the practical application of superconducting materials is dependent on how well one can control the inherent nonlinear behaviour . in this section we will focus on the generation of higher harmonics in the mixed state , in response to a single - frequency input signal . the periodic transport current @xmath200 is an odd function of input signal , and it turns out that the response motion also contains only odd harmonics . from we can calculate the fourier expansion for transport current . @xmath201 , \ ] ] where the fourier coefficient @xmath202 is @xmath203 e^{-i(2n+1)\theta } .\ ] ] we see the response goes beyond simple ohmic behaviour and the coefficients are proportional to @xmath113 . experimentally , one way of measuring these coefficients is a lock - in technique@xcite which is adept at extracting a signal with a known wave from even an extremely noisy environment . to make contact with more standard parameters and satisfy our intuition , we expand the first two harmonics in terms of @xmath164 . the fundamental harmonic , @xmath204 expanded in powers of @xmath205 is @xmath206 where @xmath207 . the first term is the ohmic conductivity denoted as @xmath208 , and is reminiscent of drude conductivity for free charged particles . this is not an unexpected parallel , since the cooper pairs in a superconducting system can be imagined to behave like a free - particle gas . taking this viewpoint , in the small - signal limit , the ratio @xmath209 gives the relaxation time of the charged particles . subsequent higher - order corrections all contain @xmath54 in such a way that their contributions are suppressed at large @xmath54 . the coefficient of the @xmath210 harmonic expanded in powers of @xmath205 is @xmath211 which decreases quickly with increasing @xmath54 . in , we show the generation of higher harmonics for three different states in the dynamical phase diagram . for each harmonic labeled by @xmath212 , @xmath213 as a function of @xmath109 has the same onset as @xmath113 . we can see that @xmath213 reaches a maximum and then starts to decay while @xmath113 saturates . the coefficients of harmonics with @xmath214 decay to zero in the high @xmath109 limit , where the state is well inside the superconducting region . we pointed out in and reaffirm here that @xmath113 plays a significant rle in determining the extent of nonlinearity in the system . in turn , the parameter which controls this is @xmath54 . when @xmath54 is large , @xmath113 is brought closer to its saturation value @xmath215 , causing the higher harmonics to be suppressed , and also lessening distortion of the vortex lattice . finally , for a given harmonic , @xmath213 is generally smaller when @xmath215 is smaller ; this can be seen by comparing ( a ) and ( c ) of . one might point out that the nonlinear behaviour is decreased at , for example , large @xmath54 . nevertheless , we view the parameter @xmath216 as more intrinsic to the system , rather than simply characterising the input signal . a limited parallel can be drawn between the effect of thermal noise in high-@xmath199 superconducting systems , and the effect of the electromagnetic perturbation in our present case . it seems that in either case the fluctuation influence can be reduced by moving the state deeper inside the superconducting region . [ r][r]@xmath217 [ r][r]@xmath218 [ r][r]@xmath219 [ r][r]@xmath220 in contrast to the fully dissipative system we have considered , in this section we will discuss an effect caused by the non - dissipative component , namely the hall effect . in a clean system , vortices move without dissipation ; a transverse electric field with respect to current appears . the non - dissipative part is subject to a gross - pitaevskii description , using a type of nonlinear schrdinger equation@xcite , with a non - dissipative part to the relaxation @xmath33 from . the fully dissipative operator @xmath58 in our previous discussion can be generalised by using a complex relaxation coefficient @xmath221 . we thus define @xmath222 the ratio @xmath223 is typically on the order of @xmath224 for a conventional superconductor , and @xmath225 for a high-@xmath199 superconductor@xcite . the hall effect is small here . in normal metals , the non - dissipative part gives the cyclotron frequency . if @xmath226 is the relaxation time of a free electron in a dirty metal , then for typical values of @xmath227 the hall effect becomes negligible . because the supply of conducting electrons is limited , the transverse component increases at the expense of the longitudinal component as the mean free path of excitations grows it is equivalent to an increase in the imaginary part of the relaxation constant at the expense of the real part . the eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of @xmath228 can be obtained easily by replacing the @xmath164 in previous results with @xmath229 , @xmath54 with @xmath230 and @xmath231 with @xmath232 . the transport current along the @xmath150-direction is no longer zero in the presence of the non - dissipative component ; it is propotional to @xmath233 . the frequency - dependent hall conductivity can be obtained from the first - order expension in @xmath164 , @xmath234 while the hall contribution in the @xmath16 direction is expected to be negligible , as it is of the order of @xmath235 . in principle , the crossover between non - dissipative systems and dissipative systems can be tuned using the ratio @xmath233 . in a non - dissipative system , which is the clean limit , the hall effect is important and taking account of the imaginary part of tdgl is necessary . on the contrary , in a strong dissipative system where excitations are in thermal equilibrium via scattering , the tdgl equation gives satisfactory agreement . far - infrared spectroscopy can be performed using monochromatic radiation which is pulsed at a high rate , known as fast far - infrared spectroscopy . this technique sports the advantage of avoiding overheating in the system , making it a very effective tool in observing the dynamical response of vortices . in particular , one can study the imaginary part of conductivity contributed mainly from superconducting component . in is shown a comparison with an nbn experiment measuring the imaginary part of conductivity . the sample has the gap energy @xmath236 mev . the resulting value of @xmath237 is larger than the value expected from bcs theory@xcite . we consider frequency - dependent conductivity in the case of linearly polarised incident light with a uniform magnetic field along the @xmath15 axis . the theoretical conductivity contains both a superconducting and a normal contribution . the total conductivity is obtained from the total current as in where the normal - part conductivity in the condenstate is the conductivity appearing in the drude model . according to our previous discussion , the nonlinear effect of the input signal on nbn is unimportant in the thz region , which corresponds to @xmath238 . an approximation where the flux - flow conductivity includes only the term @xmath239 from , and hall coefficient @xmath240 from is shown in and the agreement with experiment is good . the nave way in which we have treated the normal - part contribution is essentially inapplicable to the real - part conductivity . this is because the real - part conductivity contains information about interactions with the quasi - particles inside the core , making further consideration necessary@xcite . [ r][r]@xmath241 k and @xmath242 t calculated using of @xcite . normal - state conductivity is @xmath243 @xmath244 and relaxation time of an electron @xmath245 fs are taken from @xcite . the theoretical curve has one fitting parameter @xmath246.,title="fig:",width=226 ] the time - dependent ginzburg - landau equation has been solved analytically to study the dynamical response of the free vortex lattice . based on the bifurcation method , which involves an expansion in the distance to the phase transition boundary , we obtained a perturbative solution to all orders . we studied the response of the vortex lattice in the flux - flow region just below the phase transition , at first order in this expansion . we have seen that there are certain parameters which can be tuned using the applied field and temperature , providing a feasible superconducting system where one can study precise control of nonlinear phenomena in vortex matter . under a perturbation by electromagnetic waves , the steady - state solution shows that there is a diamagnetic current circulating the vortex core , and a transport current parallel to the external electric field with a frequency - dependent phase shift and amplitude . vortices move perpendicularly to the transport current and coherently . using a technique of maximising the heat - generation rate , we showed that the preferred structure based on energy dissipation is a hexagonal lattice , with a certain level of distortion appearing as the signal is increased or the frequency is lowered . energy flowing into the system via the applied field is dissipated through the vortex cores . we showed that the superconducting part may be thought of as having inductance in space and time . we have written transport current beyond a simple linear expression . a comparison between different harmonics of three different states in our four - dimensional parameter space indicated that the nonlinearity becomes unimportant at high frequency and small amplitude , and the influence of the input signal is decreased when the system moves deeper inside the superconducting region , away from the phase - transition boundary . to observe the configuration of moving vortices , techniques such as muon - spin rotation@xcite , sans@xcite , stm@xcite and others@xcite seem to be promising options . to provide the kind of input signal considered here , methods such as short - pulse fir spectroscopy as used in @xcite might be applied . the coefficient we defined in corresponds to conductivity . we have also seen that a simple parametrisation by complex quantities like conductivity and surface impedence is insufficient to capture the detailed behaviour of the system ; in performing experiments , it should be kept in mind that the nonlinearity can be measured in terms of more appropriate variables as we have shown . we have viewed the forcing of the system by the applied field to be somewhat analogous to thermal fluctuations , in the sense that they both result in vibration of the vortex lattice . hence , the influence of the electromagnetic fluctuation is stronger at the nucleation region of superconductivity than deep inside the superconducting phase . besides , since at high frequency the motion of vortices is limited , the influence from electric field is suppressed , as is the hall effect . fruitful discussions with b. rosenstein , v. zhuravlev , and j. kolek are greatly appreciated . the authors kindly thank g. bel and p. lipavsk for critical reading of the manuscript and many useful comments . the authors also have benefitted from comments of a. gurevich . we thank j. r. clem for pointing out to us reference @xcite . ` nsc99 - 2911-i-216 - 001 ` we follow @xcite to estimate the coefficient @xmath33 which characterises the relaxation process of the order parameter . @xmath33 is the inverse of the diffusion coefficient for electrons in the normal state . for a strongly - scattering system , as in the dirty limit@xcite , the ratio between the relaxation times of order parameter @xmath247 and the vector potential ( or current ) @xmath248 is @xmath249 by definition of the thermal critical field @xmath250 and @xmath251 , as in @xcite , we know the ratio of the two parameters is @xmath252 the coherence length at zero temperature can be written in terms of @xmath43 as @xmath253 and in terms of effective mass as @xmath254 . as a result , @xmath255 with @xmath33 , we can retrieve the experimental quantities from the rescaled ones used in calculation . using the @xmath37-subscripted original variables , we write the electric field @xmath256 , and the frequency @xmath257 . the current density @xmath258 . in the case of linear response , we have @xmath259 where @xmath260 . we consider the linearised time - dependent ginzburg - landau equation , which has been written in our chosen gauge . we wish to find the set of eigenfunctions of @xmath58 corresponding to the lowest eigenvalue . based on knowledge of the solution in the static case , we solve the now time - dependent problem by making the following ansatz@xcite . the electric field along the @xmath16-direction breaks rotational symmetry in the @xmath150-@xmath16 plane , so we write @xmath261 after substitution of @xmath262 for @xmath263 in , comparison of coefficients of powers of @xmath16 gives the following differential equations in @xmath231 . @xmath264 the solutions are @xmath265 .\ ] ] for a steady - state solution , @xmath266 , we have @xmath267 . @xmath268 as with @xmath269 , we have here @xmath270 . @xmath271 where @xmath272 is a normalisation constant . the resulting eigenvalue is @xmath273 now , although in a more realistic treatment of the system , one may introduce some boundary condition restricting @xmath274 to a certain set of values , here we simply select the smallest eigenvalue @xmath275 available to us by setting @xmath274 to zero . thus equipped with the set of eigenfunctions corresponding to our lowest eigenvalue , we deem them to be the first elements of our basis , labeled by @xmath141 and @xmath74 . these eigenfunctions of @xmath58 are @xmath276 with @xmath277 ^ 2 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath278 } .\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the same way , the corresponding eigenfunctions of @xmath279 can be obtained . @xmath280 with @xmath281 where @xmath282 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] according to our normalisation condition . the lowest eigenvalue of @xmath279 is @xmath283 . in the @xmath284 limit , the system reduces to the case of constant electric field . the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues are then consistent with those obtained by hu and thomson@xcite . in the limit of zero electric field , the eigenfunctions and eigenvalues reduce to those of the lowest landau level static - state solution@xcite . this is also the same in the @xmath285 limit . 99 d. e. oates , _ overview of nonlinearity in hts : what we have learned and prospects for improvement _ , j. supercond . novel magn . * 20 * , 3 ( 2007 ) ; j. c. booth , s. a. schima , d. c. degroot , _ description of the nonlinear behavior of superconductors using a complex conductivty _ , ieee trans . appl . supercond . * 13 * , 315 ( 2003 ) ; a. v. velichoko , m. courier , j. lancaster , a. porch , _ nonlinear microwave properties of high @xmath199 thin films _ , supercond . technol . * 18 * r24 ( 2005 ) m. tinkham , _ introduction to superconductivity _ , mcgraw - hill , new york ( 1996 ) d. charalambous , e. m. forgan , s. ramos , s. p. brown , r. j. lycett , d. h. ucko , a. j. drew , s. l. lee , d. fort , a. amato , u. zimmerman , _ driven vortices in type - ii superconductors : a muon spin rotation study _ , phys . rev . b * 73 * , 104514 ( 2006 ) b. rosenstein , d. li , _ ginzburg - landau theory of type ii superconductors in magnetic field _ , rev . phys . * 82 * , 109 ( 2010 ) and references therein a. a. abrikosov , zh . eksperim , i teor . fiz . * 32 * , 1442 ( 1957 ) a. gurevich , e. h. brandt , _ ac response of thin superconductors in the flux - creep regime _ , phys . b * 55 * , 12706 ( 1997 ) n. b. kopnin , _ theory of nonequilibrium superconductivity _ , university press , oxford ( 2001 ) m. w. coffey , j. r. clem , _ unified theory of effects of vortex pinning and flux creep upon the rf surface impedance of type - ii superconductors _ , phys . lett . * 67 * , 386 ( 1991 ) j. i. gittleman , b. rosenblum , _ radio - frequency resistance in the mixed state for subcritical currents _ , phys . * 16 * , 734 ( 1966 ) c .- r . hu , r. s. thompson , _ dynamic structure of vortices in superconductors . ii . @xmath4 _ , phys . b * 6 * , 110 ( 1972 ) ; r. s. thompson , c .- r . hu , _ dynamic structure of vortices in superconductors _ , phys . * 27 * , 1352 ( 1971 ) g. w. crabtree , d. o. gunter , h. g. kaper , a. e koshelve , g. k. leaf , v. m. vinokur , _ numerical simulation of driven vortex systems _ , phys . b * 61 * , 1146 ( 2000 ) ; d. y. vodolazov , f. m. peeters , _ rearrangement of the vortex lattice due to instabilities of vortex flow _ , phys . b * 76 * , 014521 ( 2007 ) d. li , a. malkin , b. rosenstein , _ structure and orientation of the moving vortex lattice in clean type - ii superconductors _ , phys . b * 70 * , 214529 ( 2004 ) b. rosenstein and v. zhuravlev , _ quantitative theory of transport in vortex matter of type - ii superconductors in the presence of random pinning _ , phys . b * 76 * , 014507 ( 2007 ) j. b. ketterson , s. n. song , _ superconductivity _ , university press , cambridge ( 1998 ) l. l.gorkov , g. m. eliashberg , zh . eksp . . fiz . * 54 * , 612 ( 1968 ) ; a. schmid , phys . materie * 5 * , 302 ( 1966 ) g. lasher , _ series solution of the ginzburg - landau equations for the abrikosov mixed state _ * 140 * , a523 ( 1965 ) d. li , b. rosenstein , _ lowest landau level approximation in strongly type - ii superconductors _ , phys . b * 60 * , 9704 ( 1999 ) p. kim , z. yao , c. a. bolle , c. m. lieber , _ structure of flux line lattices with weak disorder at large length scales _ , phys . b * 60 * , r12589 ( 1999 ) d. charalambous , p. g. kealey , e. m. forgan , t. m. riseman , m. w. long , c. goupil , r. khasanov , d. fort , p. j. king , s. l. lee , f. ogrin , _ vortex motion in type - ii superconductors probed by muon spin rotation and small - angle neutron scattering _ , phys . b * 66 * , 054506 ( 2002 ) a. t. fiory , _ quantum interference effects of a moving vortex lattice in al films _ , phys . * 27 * , 501 ( 1971 ) m. o. sonnaillon , f. j. bonetto , _ a low - cost , high - performance , digital signal processor - based lock - in amplifier capable of measuring multiple frequency sweeps simultaneously _ , rev . inst . * 76 * , 024703 ( 2005 ) y. ikebe , r. shimano , m. ikeda , t. fukumura , m. kawasaki , _ vortex dynamics in a nbn film studied by terahertz spectroscopy _ , phys . b * 79 * , 174525 ( 2009 ) p .- j . lin , p. lipavsk , _ time - dependent ginzburg - landau theory with floating nucleation kernel : far - infrared conductivity in the abrikosov vortex lattice state of a type - ii superconductor _ , phys . b * 80 * , 212506 ( 2009 ) a. m. troyanovski , j. aarts , p. h. kes , _ collective and plastic vortex motion in superconductors at high flux density _ , nature , * 339*,665(1999 ) t. h. johansen , _ gallery of abrikosov lattices in superconductors _ , ` http://www.fys.uio.no/super/vortex ` c. f. lo , _ propagator of the general driven time - dependent oscillator _ , phys . rev . a * 47 * , 115 ( 1993 ) b. rosenstein , private communication , unpublished .
Abstract: | [
"the dynamical response of the abrikosov vortex lattice in the presence of an oscillating driving field is calculated by constructing an analytical solution of the time - dependent ginzburg - landau equation . the solution is steady - state , and work done by the input signal is dissipated through vortex cores , mainly by scattering with phonons . the response is nonlinear in the input signal , and is verified for consistency within the theory . the existence of well - defined parameters to control nonlinear effects is important for any practical application in electronics , and a normalised distance from the normal - superconducting phase - transition boundary is found to be such a parameter to which the response is sensitive . favourable comparison with nbn experimental data in the optical region is made , where the effect is in the linear regime . predictions are put forward regarding the suppression of heating and also the lattice configuration at high frequency ."
] | 9,360 | 9,360 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: partial orders are a principle tool for modelling `` true concurrency '' semantics of concurrent systems ( cf . @xcite ) . they are utilized to develop powerful partial - order based automatic verification techniques , e.g. , _ partial order reduction _ for model checking concurrent software ( see , e.g. , ( * ? ? ? * chapter 10 ) and @xcite ) . partial orders are also equipped with _ traces _ , their powerful formal language counterpart , proposed by mazurkiewicz @xcite . in _ the book of traces _ @xcite , trace theory has been used to tackle problems from diverse areas including formal language theory , combinatorics , graph theory , algebra , logic , and _ concurrency theory_. however , while partial orders and traces can sufficiently model the earlier than " relationship , janicki and koutny argued that it is problematic to use a single partial order to specify both the earlier than " and the not later than " relationships @xcite . this motivates them to develop the theory of _ relational structures _ , where a pair of relations is used to capture concurrent behaviors . the most well - known among the classes of relational structures proposed by janicki and koutny is the class of _ stratified order structures _ ( _ so - structures _ ) @xcite . a so - structure is a triple @xmath0 , where @xmath1 and @xmath2 are binary relations on @xmath3 . they were invented to model both the earlier than " ( the relation @xmath1 ) and not later than " ( the relation @xmath2 ) relationships , under the assumption that system runs are described by _ stratified partial orders _ , i.e. , step sequences . they have been successfully applied to model inhibitor and priority systems , asynchronous races , synthesis problems , etc . ( see for example @xcite and others ) . _ com__bined _ trace _ ( _ comtrace _ ) notion , introduced by janicki and koutny @xcite , generalizes the trace notion by utilizing step sequences instead of words . first the set of all possible steps that generates step sequences are identified by a relation @xmath4 , which is called _ simultaneity_. second a congruence relation is determined by a relation @xmath5 , which is called _ serializability _ and in general _ not _ symmetric . then a comtrace is defined as a finite set of congruent step sequences . comtraces were introduced as a formal language representation of so - structures to provide an operational semantics for petri nets with inhibitor arcs . unfortunately , comtraces have been less often known and applied than so - structures , even though in many cases they appear to be more natural . we believe one reason is that the comtrace notion was too succinctly discussed in @xcite without a full treatment dedicated to comtrace theory . motivated by this , janicki and the author have devoted our recent effort on the study of comtraces @xcite , yet there are too many different aspects to explore and the truth is we can barely scratch the surface . in particular , the huge amount of results from trace theory ( e.g. , from @xcite ) desperately needs to be generalized to comtraces . these tasks are often non - trivial since we are required to develop intuition and novel techniques to deal with the complex interactions of the `` earlier than '' and `` not later than '' relations . this paper gives a novel characterization of comtraces using labeled so - structures . such definition is interesting for the following reasons . first , it defines exactly the class of labeled so - structures that can be represented by comtraces . it is worth noting that this point is particularly important . even though it was shown in @xcite that every comtrace can be represented by a labeled so - structure , the converse could not be shown because a class of labeled so - structures that defines precisely the class of comtraces was not known . the closest to our characterization is the _ combined dependency graph _ ( _ cd - graph _ ) notion ( analogous to _ dependence graph _ representation of traces ) introduced recently by kleijn and koutny @xcite , but again a theorem showing that combined dependency graphs can be represented by comtraces was not given . our approach is quite different and based on some new ideas discussed in section 4 of this paper . second , even though the step sequence definition of comtraces is more suitable when dealing with formal language aspects of comtraces , the labeled so - structure representation is more suitable for a variety of powerful order - theoretic results and techniques available to us ( cf . @xcite ) . finally , the labeled so - structure definition of comtrace can be easily extended to _ infinite comtraces _ , which describe nonterminating concurrent processes . the labeled poset representation of infinite traces is already successfully applied in both theory and practice , e.g. , @xcite . although such definition is equivalent to the one using quotient monoid over infinite words @xcite , we believe that infinite labeled posets are sometimes simpler . indeed the celebrated work by thiagarajan and walukiewicz ( cf . @xcite ) on linear temporal logic for traces utilizes the labeled poset characterization of infinite traces , where _ configurations _ of a trace are conveniently defined as _ finite downward closed subsets _ of the labeled poset representation . we will not analyze infinite comtraces or logics for comtraces in this paper , but these are fruitful directions to explore using the results from this paper . the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 , we recall some preliminary definitions and notations . in section 3 , we give a concise exposition of the theory of so - structures and comtraces by janicki and koutny @xcite . in section 4 , we give our definition of comtraces using labeled so - structure and some remarks on how we arrived at such definition . in section 5 , we prove a representation theorem showing that our comtrace definition and the one by janicki and koutny are indeed equivalent ; then using this theorem , we prove another representation theorem showing that our definition is also equivalent to the cd - graph definition from @xcite . in section 6 , we define _ composition _ operators for our comtrace representation and for cd - graphs . finally , in section 7 , some final remarks and future works are presented . the _ powerset _ of a set @xmath3 will be denoted by @xmath6 , i.e. @xmath7 . the set of all _ non - empty _ subsets of @xmath3 will be denoted by @xmath8 . in other words , we let @xmath10 denote the _ identity relation _ on a set @xmath3 . if @xmath11 and @xmath12 are binary relations on a set @xmath3 ( i.e. , @xmath13 ) , then their _ composition _ @xmath14 is defined as @xmath15 . we also define @xmath16 the relations @xmath17 and @xmath18 are called the _ ( irreflexive ) transitive closure _ and _ reflexive transitive closure _ of @xmath11 respectively . a binary relation @xmath19 is an _ equivalence relation _ relation on @xmath3 if and only if ( iff ) @xmath11 is _ reflexive _ , _ symmetric _ and _ transitive_. if @xmath11 is an equivalence relation , then for every @xmath20 , the set @xmath21_r { \triangleq}{\{y\;|\;y\;r\;x \wedge y\in x\}}$ ] is the equivalence class of @xmath22 with respect to @xmath11 . we also define @xmath23_r\mid x\in x\}}$ ] , i.e. , the set of all equivalence classes of @xmath3 under @xmath11 . we drop the subscript and write @xmath21 $ ] when @xmath11 is clear from the context . a binary relation @xmath24 is a _ partial order _ iff @xmath11 is _ irreflexive _ and _ transitive_. the pair @xmath25 in this case is called a _ partially ordered set _ ( _ poset _ ) . the pair @xmath25 is called a _ finite poset _ if @xmath3 is finite . for convenience , we define : @xmath26 a poset @xmath25 is _ total _ iff @xmath27 is empty ; and _ stratified _ iff @xmath28 is an equivalence relation . evidently every total order is stratified . for every finite set @xmath3 , a set @xmath29 can be seen as an alphabet . the elements of @xmath30 are called _ steps _ and the elements of @xmath31 are called _ step sequences_. for example , if the set of possible steps is @xmath32 , then @xmath33 is a step sequence . the triple @xmath34 , where @xmath35 denotes the step sequence concatenation operator ( usually omitted ) and @xmath36 denotes the empty step sequence , is a monoid . let @xmath37 be a step sequence . we define @xmath38 , the number of occurrences of an event @xmath39 in @xmath40 , as @xmath41 , where @xmath42 denotes the cardinality of the set @xmath3 . then we can construct its unique _ enumerated step sequence _ @xmath43 as + @xmath44 + we will call such @xmath45 an _ event occurrence _ of @xmath46 . for instance , if we let @xmath47 , then @xmath48 we let @xmath49 denote the set of all event occurrences in all steps of @xmath50 . for example , when @xmath47 , @xmath51 we also define @xmath52 to be the function that returns the _ label _ of @xmath53 for each @xmath54 . for example , if @xmath55 , then @xmath56 . hence , from an enumerated step sequence @xmath57 , we can uniquely reconstruct its step sequence @xmath58 for each @xmath59 , we let @xmath60 denote the consecutive number of a step where @xmath53 belongs , i.e. , if @xmath61 then @xmath62 . for our example , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , etc . it is important to observe that step sequences and stratified orders are interchangeable concepts . given a step sequence @xmath65 , define the binary relation @xmath66 on @xmath67 as + @xmath68 intuitively , @xmath69 simply means @xmath53 occurs before @xmath70 on the step sequence @xmath65 . thus , @xmath71 iff @xmath72 ; and @xmath73 iff @xmath74 . obviously , the relation @xmath66 is a stratified order and we will call it the stratified order _ generated by the step sequence _ @xmath65 . conversely , let @xmath75 be a stratified order on a set @xmath76 . the set @xmath76 can be represented as a sequence of equivalence classes @xmath77 ( @xmath78 ) such that @xmath79 the sequence @xmath80 is called the step sequence _ representing _ @xmath75 . a detailed discussion on this connection between stratified orders and step sequences can be found in @xcite . in this section , we review the janicki koutny theory of stratified order structures and comtraces from @xcite . the reader is also referred to @xcite for an excellent introductory survey on the subject with many motivating examples . a _ relational structure _ is a triple @xmath81 , where @xmath3 is a set and @xmath82 , @xmath83 are binary relations on @xmath3 . a relational structure @xmath84 is an _ extension _ of @xmath85 , denoted as @xmath86 , iff @xmath87 , @xmath88 and @xmath89 . a _ stratified order structure _ ( _ so - structure _ ) is a relational structure @xmath90 such that for all @xmath91 , the following hold : @xmath92 when @xmath3 is finite , @xmath12 is called a _ finite so - structure_. [ def : sos ] the axioms imply that @xmath93 is a partial order and @xmath94 the axioms and imply @xmath95 is a _ strict preorder_. the relation @xmath1 is called _ causality _ and represents the earlier than " relationship while the relation @xmath2 is called _ weak causality _ and represents the not later than " relationship . the axioms model the mutual relationship between earlier than " and not later than " relations , provided that _ the system runs are stratified orders_. historically , the name `` stratified order structure '' came from the fact that stratified orders can be seen as a special kind of so - structures . for every stratified poset @xmath96 , the triple @xmath97 is a so - structure.[prop : soss ] we next recall the notion of _ stratified order extension_. this concept is extremely important since the relationship between stratified orders and so - structures is exactly analogous to the one between total orders and partial orders . let @xmath98 be a so - structure . a _ stratified _ order @xmath75 on @xmath3 is a _ stratified extension _ of @xmath12 if and only if @xmath99 . the set of all stratified extensions of @xmath12 is denoted as @xmath100 . [ def : extsos ] szpilrajn s theorem @xcite states that every poset can be reconstructed by taking the intersection of all of its total order extensions . janicki and koutny showed that a similar result holds for so - structures and stratified extensions : let @xmath101 be a so - structure . then + @xmath102 [ theo : szpstrat ] using this theorem , we can show the following properties relating so - structures and their stratified extensions . for every so - structure @xmath101 , 1 . @xmath103 2 . @xmath104 [ cor : szpstrat ] * 1 . * see ( * ? ? ? * theorem 3.6 ) . * 2 . * follows from * 1 . * and theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] . _ comtraces _ were introduced in @xcite as a generalization of traces to represent so - structures . the _ comtrace congruence _ is defined via two relations _ simultaneity _ and _ serializability_. let @xmath105 be a finite set ( of events ) and let @xmath106 be two relations called _ serializability _ and _ simultaneity _ respectively and the relation @xmath4 is irreflexive and symmetric . the triple @xmath107 is called a _ comtrace alphabet_. [ def : comalpha ] intuitively , if @xmath108 then @xmath39 and @xmath109 can occur simultaneously ( or be a part of a _ synchronous _ occurrence in the sense of @xcite ) , while @xmath110 means that @xmath39 and @xmath109 may occur simultaneously or @xmath39 may occur before @xmath109 . we define @xmath111 , the set of all possible _ steps _ , to be the set of all cliques of the graph @xmath112 , i.e. , + @xmath113 for a comtrace alphabet @xmath114 , we define @xmath115 to be the relation comprising all pairs @xmath116 of step sequences such that + @xmath117 + where @xmath118 and @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 are steps satisfying @xmath122 and @xmath123 . we define _ comtrace congruence _ @xmath124 . we define the comtrace concatenation operator @xmath125 as @xmath126\circledast[t ] { \triangleq}[r\ast t]$ ] . the quotient monoid @xmath127)$ ] is called the monoid of _ comtraces _ over @xmath128 . [ def : commonoid ] note that since @xmath5 is irreflexive , @xmath129 implies that @xmath130 . we will omit the subscript @xmath128 from the comtrace congruence @xmath131 , and write @xmath132 and @xmath133 when it causes no ambiguity . to shorten our notations , we often write @xmath134_{\theta}$ ] or @xmath134 $ ] instead of @xmath134_{{\equiv}_{\theta}}$ ] to denote the comtrace generated by the step sequence @xmath135 over @xmath128 . let @xmath136 where @xmath39 , @xmath109 and @xmath137 are three atomic operations , where + @xmath138 + assume simultaneous reading is allowed . then only @xmath109 and @xmath137 can be performed simultaneously , and the simultaneous execution of @xmath109 and @xmath137 gives the same outcome as executing @xmath109 followed by @xmath137 . we can then define the comtrace alphabet @xmath114 , where @xmath139 and @xmath140 . this yields @xmath141 . thus , @xmath142 = { \bigl\ { \{a\}\{b , c\},\{a\}\{b\}\{c\}\bigr\}}$ ] is a comtrace . but @xmath143 . [ ex : comtrace1 ] even though traces are quotient monoids over sequences and comtraces are quotient monoids over step sequences , traces can be regarded as special kinds of comtraces when the relation @xmath144 . for a more detailed discussion on this connection between traces and comtraces , the reader is referred to @xcite . let @xmath145 . we define the relations @xmath146 as : 1 . @xmath147 2 . @xmath148 . [ def : s2inv ] it is worth noting that the structure @xmath149 is exactly the _ cd - graph _ ( cf . definition [ def : comdag ] ) that represents the comtrace @xmath150 $ ] . this gives us some intuition on how koutny and kleijn constructed the cd - graph definition in @xcite . we also observe that @xmath151 is usually _ not _ a so - structure since @xmath152 and @xmath153 describe only basic `` local '' causality and weak causality invariants of the event occurrences of @xmath65 by considering pairwise serializable relationships of event occurrences . hence , @xmath152 and @xmath153 might not capture `` global '' invariants that can be inferred from of definition [ def : sos ] . to ensure all invariants are included , we need the following @xmath154-closure operator . for every relational structure @xmath155 we define @xmath156 as + @xmath157 [ def : so - cl ] intuitively @xmath154-closure is a generalization of transitive closure for relations to relational structures . the motivation is that for appropriate relations @xmath82 and @xmath83 ( see assertion ( 3 ) of proposition [ prop : so - cl ] ) , the relational structure @xmath158 is a so - structure . the @xmath154-closure operator satisfies the following properties : let @xmath155 be a relational structure . 1 . if @xmath83 is irreflexive then @xmath159 . 2 . @xmath160 . @xmath156 is a so - structure if and only if @xmath161 is irreflexive . 4 . if @xmath12 is a so - structure then @xmath162 . 5 . if @xmath12 be a so - structure and @xmath163 , then @xmath164 and @xmath165 is a so - structure . [ prop : so - cl ] given a step sequence @xmath145 and its respective comtrace @xmath166\in { \mathbb{s}}_{\theta}^*/\!\equiv$ ] , we define the relational structures @xmath167 as : + @xmath168.[def : s2sos ] the relational structure @xmath167 is called the _ so - structure defined by the comtrace _ @xmath166 $ ] , where @xmath169 , @xmath170 and @xmath171 are used to denote the event occurrence set , causality relation and weak causality relation induced by the comtrace @xmath172 respectively . the following nontrivial theorem and its corollary justifies the name by showing that step sequences in a comtrace @xmath172 are exactly stratified extension of the so - structure @xmath173 , and that @xmath167 is uniquely defined for the comtrace @xmath172 regardless of the choice of @xmath174 . for each @xmath175 , the relational structure @xmath167 is a so - structure and @xmath176 . [ theo : com2sos ] for all @xmath177 , 1 . @xmath178 2 . @xmath179 [ cor : com2sos ] even though theorem [ theo : com2sos ] shows that each comtrace can be represented uniquely by a labeled so - structure , it does not give us an explicit definition of how these labeled so - structures look like . in this section , we will give an exact definition of labeled so - structures that represent comtraces . to provide us with more intuition , we first recall how mazurkiewicz traces can be characterized as labeled posets . a _ trace concurrent alphabet _ is a pair @xmath180 , where @xmath181 is a symmetric irreflexive binary relation on the finite set @xmath105 . a _ trace congruence _ @xmath182 can then be defined as the smallest equivalence relation such that for all sequences @xmath183 , if @xmath184 , then @xmath185 . the elements of @xmath186 are called _ traces_. traces can also be defined alternatively as posets whose elements are labeled with symbols of a concurrent alphabet @xmath180 satisfying certain conditions . given a binary relation @xmath187 , the _ covering relation _ of @xmath11 is defined as @xmath188 . an alternative definition of mazurkiewicz trace is : a trace over a concurrent alphabet @xmath180 is a finite labeled poset @xmath189 , where @xmath190 is a labeling function , such that for all @xmath191 , 1 . @xmath192 , and 2 . @xmath193 . [ def : ltraces ] a trace in this definition is only identified unique up to _ label - preserving isomorphism_. the first condition says that immediately causally related event occurrences must be labeled with dependent events . the second condition ensures that any two event occurrences with dependent labels must be causally related . the first condition is particularly important since two immediately causally related event occurrences will occur next to each other in at least one of its linear extensions . this is the key to relate definition [ def : ltraces ] with quotient monoid definition of traces . thus , we would like to establish a similar relationship for comtraces . an immediate technical difficulty is that weak causality might be cyclic , so the notion of `` immediate weak causality '' does not make sense . however , we can still deal with cycles of a so - structure by taking advantage of the following simple fact : _ the weak causality relation is a strict preorder_. let @xmath101 be a so - structure . we define the relation @xmath194 as + @xmath195 since @xmath95 is a strict preorder , it follows that @xmath196 is an equivalence relation . the relation @xmath196 will be called the _ @xmath95-cycle equivalence relation _ and an element of the quotient set @xmath197 will be called a _ @xmath95-cycle equivalence class_. we then define the following binary relations @xmath198 and @xmath199 on the quotient set @xmath197 as @xmath200 \widehat{{\prec } } [ \beta ] { \stackrel{\textit{\scriptsize{df}}}{\iff}\ } ( [ \alpha]\times[\beta])\;\cap { \prec}\not=\emptyset \hspace*{3mm}\text { and } \hspace*{3 mm } [ \alpha ] \widehat{{\sqsubset } } [ \beta ] { \stackrel{\textit{\scriptsize{df}}}{\iff}\ } ( [ \alpha]\times[\beta])\;\cap { \sqsubset}\not=\emptyset \label{qsos}\end{aligned}\ ] ] using this quotient construction , every so - structure , whose weak causality relation might be cyclic , can be uniquely represented by an _ quotient so - structure . the relational structure @xmath201 is a so - structure , the relation @xmath199 is a partial order , and for all @xmath202 , 1 . @xmath203 \widehat{{\prec } } [ \beta]$ ] 2 . @xmath204 \widehat{{\sqsubset } } [ \beta ] \vee ( \alpha\not=\beta \wedge [ \alpha]=[\beta])$ ] follows from definition [ def : sos ] . using ( [ qsos ] ) and theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] , it is not hard to prove the following simple yet useful properties of @xmath95-cycle equivalence classes . let @xmath205 be a so - structure . we use @xmath65 and @xmath206 to denote some step sequences over @xmath8 . then for all @xmath191 , 1 . @xmath207=[\beta ] \iff \forall \lhd \in ext(s),\ ; \alpha \simeq_{\lhd } \beta$ ] 2 . @xmath208v$ ] 3 . @xmath207 { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\ ; } } [ \beta ] \implies \exists\lhd \in ext(s),\;\omega_{\lhd } = u[\alpha][\beta]v$ ] [ prop : covlsos ] each @xmath95-cycle equivalence class is what juhs , lorenz and mauser called a _ synchronous step _ they also used equivalence classes to capture synchronous steps but only for the special class of _ synchronous closed _ so - structures , where @xmath209 is an equivalence relation . we extend their ideas by using @xmath95-cycle equivalence classes to capture what we will call _ non - serializable sets _ in arbitrary so - structures . the name is justified in assertion ( 1 ) of proposition [ prop : covlsos ] stating that two elements belong to the same non - serializable set of a so - structure @xmath12 iff they must be executed simultaneously in every stratified extension of @xmath12 . furthermore , we show in assertion ( 2 ) that all elements of a non - serializable set must occur together as a single step in at least one stratified extension of @xmath12 . assertion ( 3 ) gives a sufficient condition for two non - serializable sets to occur as consecutive steps in at least one stratified extension of @xmath12 . before we proceed to define comtrace using labeled so - structure , we need to define _ label - preserving isomorphisms _ for labeled so - structures more formally . a tuple @xmath210 is a _ labeled relational structure _ iff @xmath211 is a relational structure and @xmath212 is a function with domain @xmath3 . if @xmath211 is a so - structure , then @xmath85 is a _ labeled so - structure_. given two labeled relational structures @xmath213 and @xmath214 , we write @xmath215 to denote that @xmath216 and @xmath217 are _ label - preserving isomorphic _ ( _ lp - isomorphic _ ) . in other words , there is a bijection @xmath218 such that for all @xmath219 , 1 . @xmath220 2 . @xmath221 3 . @xmath222 such function @xmath223 is called a _ label - preserving isomorphism _ ( _ lp - isomorphism _ ) . note that all notations , definitions and results for so - structures are applicable to labeled so - structures . we also write @xmath224 $ ] or @xmath225 } $ ] to denote the lp - isomorphic class of a labeled relational structure @xmath226 . we will not distinguish an lp - isomorphic class @xmath227 } $ ] with a single labeled relational structure @xmath85 when it does not cause ambiguity . we are now ready to give an alternative definition for comtraces . to avoid confusion with the comtrace notion by janicki and koutny in @xcite , we will use the term _ lsos - comtrace _ to denote a comtrace defined using our definition . given a comtrace alphabet @xmath114 , a _ lsos - comtrace _ over @xmath128 is ( an lp - isomorphic class of ) a finite labeled so - structure @xmath228 } $ ] such that @xmath190 and for all @xmath191 , 1 . @xmath207 ( { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\cap \hat{{\prec } } ) [ \beta ] \implies \lambda([\alpha])\times \lambda([\beta ] ) \nsubseteq ser$ ] 2 . @xmath207 ( { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\setminus \hat{{\prec } } ) [ \beta ] \implies \lambda([\beta])\times \lambda([\alpha ] ) \nsubseteq ser$ ] 3 . @xmath229)},\ ; a\cup b = [ \alpha ] \implies \lambda(a)\times \lambda(b ) \not \subseteq ser$ ] 4 . @xmath230 5 . @xmath231 we write @xmath232 to denote the class of all lsos - comtraces over @xmath128 . [ def : lcomtrace ] let @xmath136 , @xmath233 and @xmath234 . then we have @xmath235 . the lp - isomorphic class of the labeled so - structure @xmath236 depicted in figure [ fig : f1 ] ( the dotted edges denote @xmath95 relation and the solid edges denote both @xmath93 and @xmath95 relations ) is a lsos - comtrace . the graph in figure [ fig : f2 ] represents the labeled quotient so - structure @xmath237 of @xmath85 , where we define @xmath238 . @xmath239[f-]{a } \ar@{-->}[dr]\ar@/^/[rr ] \ar@/_1.5pc/ [ ddrr ] & & * + [ o][f-]{c}\ar@/_/ @{-->}[dd]\\ & * + [ o][f-]{c } \ar[ur]\ar[dr ] & \\ * + [ o][f-]{b } \ar[ur]\ar@/_/[rr]\ar@/^1.5pc/ [ uurr ] & & * + [ o][f-]{b}\ar@/_/ @{-->}[uu ] } $ ] @xmath240{a } \ar@{-->}[dr]\ar@/^1pc/[drr ] & & \\ & * + [ f-]{c } \ar[r ] & * + [ f-]{b , c}\\ * + [ f-]{b } \ar[ur]\ar@/_1pc/[urr ] & & } $ ] the lsos - comtrace @xmath224 $ ] actually corresponds to the comtrace @xmath241 $ ] , and we will show this relationship formally in section [ sec : representation ] . [ ex : comtrace2 ] definition [ def : lcomtrace ] can be extended to define _ infinite comtrace _ as follows . instead of asking @xmath3 to be finite , we require a labeled so - structure to be _ initially finite _ @xcite ) , i.e. , @xmath242 is finite for all @xmath243 . the initially - finiteness not only gives us a sensible interpretation that every event only causually depends on finitely many events , but also guarantees that the covering relations of @xmath244 and @xmath245 are well - defined . since each lsos - comtrace is defined as a class of lp - isomorphic labeled so - structures , dealing with lsos - comtrace might seem tricky . the _ no autoconcurrency _ property , i.e. , the relation @xmath5 is irreflexive , gives us a _ canonical _ way to enumerate the events of a lsos - comtrace very similar to how the events of a comtrace are enumerated . given a step sequence @xmath246 and any function @xmath223 defined on @xmath247 , we define @xmath248 , i.e. , the step sequence derived from @xmath135 by applying the function @xmath223 successively on each @xmath249 . note that @xmath250 denotes the _ image _ of @xmath251 under @xmath223 . given a lsos - comtrace @xmath252 } $ ] over a comtrace alphabet @xmath114 , a stratified order @xmath253 can be seen as a step sequence @xmath254 . 1 . for every @xmath255 ( @xmath256 ) , @xmath257 2 . @xmath258 . [ prop : validss ] proposition [ prop : validss ] ensures that @xmath259 is a valid step sequence over @xmath128 . recall that @xmath260 denotes the enumerated step sequence of @xmath65 and @xmath261 denotes the set of event occurrences . bijection _ @xmath262 as + @xmath263 by proposition [ prop : validss ] , the function @xmath264 is well - defined . moreover , we can show that @xmath264 is uniquely determined by @xmath85 regardless of the choice of @xmath253 . given @xmath265 , let @xmath266 and @xmath267 . then @xmath268 . [ prop : uniquexi ] henceforth , we will ignore subscripts and reserve the notation @xmath269 to denote the kind of mappings as defined above . we then define the _ enumerated so - structure _ of @xmath85 to be the labeled so - structure @xmath270 , where @xmath271 for @xmath259 and @xmath253 ; and the relations @xmath272 are defined as + @xmath273 clearly , the enumerated so - structure @xmath274 can be uniquely determined from @xmath85 using the preceding definition . from our construction , we can easily show the following important relationships : 1 . @xmath275 and @xmath85 are lp - isomorphic under the mapping @xmath269 . 2 . the labeled so - structures @xmath276 and @xmath277 are lp - isomorphic under the mapping @xmath269 and @xmath278 . [ prop : isoext ] in other words , the mapping @xmath279 plays the role of both the lp - isomorphism from @xmath275 to @xmath85 and the lp - isomorphism from the stratified extension @xmath280 of @xmath275 to the stratified extension @xmath96 of @xmath85 . these relationships can be best captured using the commutative diagram on the right . @xmath281_{\displaystyle \xi } \ar@{^{(}->}[d]_{\displaystyle id_{\sigma } } & ( x,{\prec},{\sqsubset},\lambda ) \ar@{^{(}->}[d]^{\displaystyle id_{x } } \\ ( \sigma,\lhd_{u},\lhd_{u}^{\frown},\ell ) \ar@{->}[r]^{\displaystyle \xi } & ( x,\lhd,\lhd^{\frown},\lambda)}$ ] we can even observe further that two lsos - comtraces are identical if and only if they define the same enumerated so - structure . henceforth , we will call an enumerated so - structure defined by a lsos - comtrace @xmath85 _ the canonical representation _ of @xmath85 . recently , inspired by the dependency graph notion for mazurkiewicz traces ( cf . * chapter 2 ) ) , kleijn and koutny claimed without proof that their _ combined dependency graph _ notion is another alternative way to define comtraces @xcite . in section [ sec : representation ] , we will give a detailed proof of their claim . given an comtrace alphabet @xmath282 , a _ combined dependency graph _ ( _ cd - graph _ ) over @xmath128 is ( a lp - isomorphic class of ) a finite labeled relational structure @xmath283 } $ ] such that @xmath190 , the relations @xmath284 are irreflexive , @xmath285 is a so - structure , and for all @xmath286 , @xmath287 @xmath288 @xmath289 @xmath290 + we will write @xmath291 to denote the class of all cd - graphs over @xmath128 . [ def : comdag ] cd - graphs can be seen as reduced graph - theoretic representations for lsos - comtraces , where some arcs that can be recovered using @xmath154-closure are omitted . it is interesting to observe that the non - serializable sets of a cd - graph are exactly the _ strongly connected components _ of the directed graph @xmath292 and can easily be found in time @xmath293 using any standard algorithm ( cf . * section 22.5 ) ) . + cd - graphs were called _ dependence comdags _ in @xcite . but this name could be misleading since the directed graph @xmath292 is not necessarily acyclic . for example , the graph on the right is the cd - graph that corresponds to the lsos - comtrace from figure [ fig : f1 ] , but it is not acyclic . ( here , we use the dotted edges to denote @xmath294 and the solid edges to denote _ only _ @xmath295 . ) thus , we use the name `` combined dependency graph '' instead . @xmath296[f-]{a } \ar@{-->}[dr ] \ar@/_1.5pc/ [ ddrr ] & & * + [ o][f-]{c}\ar@/_/ @{-->}[dd]\\ & * + [ o][f-]{c } \ar[ur]\ar[dr ] & \\ * + [ o][f-]{b } \ar[ur]\ar@/_/[rr]\ar@/^1.5pc/ [ uurr ] & & * + [ o][f-]{b}\ar@/_/ @{-->}[uu ] } $ ] this section contains the main technical contribution of this paper by showing that for a given comtrace alphabet @xmath128 , @xmath297 , @xmath232 and @xmath291 are three equivalent ways of talking about the same class of objects . we will next prove the first representation theorem which establishes the representation mappings between @xmath297 and @xmath232 . let @xmath298 and @xmath299 be stratified order structures such that @xmath300 . then @xmath301 . [ prop : stratsubset ] follows from theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] . for the next two lemmata , we let @xmath85 be a lsos - comtrace over a comtrace alphabet @xmath114 . let @xmath302 be the canonical representation of @xmath85 . let @xmath303 and @xmath304 . since @xmath65 is a valid step sequence in @xmath31 ( by proposition [ prop : validss ] ) , we can construct @xmath305 } = ( \sigma_{u},{\prec}_{[u]},{\sqsubset}_{[u]})$ ] from definition [ def : s2sos ] . our goal is to show that the stratified order @xmath305}$ ] defined by the comtrace @xmath150 $ ] is exactly @xmath306 . @xmath305 } \subseteq ( \sigma_{u},{\prec}_{0},{\sqsubset}_{0})$ ] . [ lem : l1 ] by proposition [ prop : so - cl ] , to show @xmath305 } = ( \sigma_{u},{\prec}_{u},{\sqsubset}_{u})^{\lozenge } \subseteq ( \sigma_{u},{\prec}_{0},{\sqsubset}_{0})$ ] , it suffices to show that @xmath307 . since @xmath274 is the canonical representation of @xmath85 , it is important to observe that @xmath308 . ( @xmath309 ) : assume @xmath310 . then from definition [ def : s2inv ] , @xmath311 . since @xmath312 , it follows from definition [ def : lcomtrace ] that @xmath313 or @xmath314 . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath314 , then by theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] , @xmath315 . but since we assume that @xmath303 , it follows that @xmath316 and @xmath317 , a contradiction . hence , we have shown @xmath313 . ( @xmath318 ) : can be shown in a similar way . @xmath305 } \supseteq ( \sigma_{u},{\prec}_{0},{\sqsubset}_{0})$ ] . [ lem : l2 ] in this proof , we will include subscripts for equivalence classes to avoid confusing the elements from quotient set @xmath319 with the elements from the quotient comtrace monoid @xmath320 . in other words , we write @xmath207_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] to denote an element of the quotient set @xmath319 , and write @xmath150_{\theta}$ ] to denote the comtrace generated by @xmath65 . let @xmath321 . to show @xmath305 } \supseteq s'$ ] , by proposition [ prop : stratsubset ] , it suffices to show @xmath322 } ) \subseteq ext(s')$ ] . from theorem [ theo : com2sos ] , we know that @xmath322_{\theta } } ) = { \{\lhd_w\mid w\in [ u]_{\theta}\}}$ ] . thus we only need to show that for all @xmath323_{\theta}$ ] , @xmath324 . we observe that from @xmath65 , by definition [ def : commonoid ] , we can generate all the step sequences in the comtrace @xmath150_{\theta}$ ] in stages using the following recursive definition : @xmath325 since the set @xmath150_{\theta}$ ] is finite , @xmath150_{\theta}=d^n(u)$ ] for some stage @xmath326 . for the rest of the proof , we will prove by induction on @xmath327 that for all @xmath328 , if @xmath329 then @xmath330 . + * base case : * when @xmath331 , @xmath332 . since @xmath333 , it follows from proposition [ prop : isoext ] that @xmath334 . + * inductive case : * when @xmath335 , let @xmath40 be an element of @xmath336 . then either @xmath337 or @xmath338 . for the former case , by inductive hypothesis , @xmath339 . for the latter case , there must be some element @xmath340 such that @xmath341 or @xmath342 . by induction hypothesis , we already known @xmath343 . we want to show that @xmath324 . there are two cases to consider : + _ * case ( i ) : * _ + when @xmath341 , by definition [ def : commonoid ] , there are some @xmath344 and steps @xmath345 such that @xmath346 and @xmath347 where @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 satisfy @xmath348 and @xmath349 and @xmath129 . let @xmath350 and @xmath351 be enumerated step sequences of @xmath206 and @xmath40 respectively . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath352 . by definition [ def : extsos ] , there are @xmath353 and @xmath354 such that @xmath355 . we now consider the quotient set @xmath356 . by proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ( 1 ) , @xmath357 . since @xmath355 , it follows that @xmath207_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0 } [ \beta]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] . thus , from the fact that @xmath358 is partial order , there must exists a chain @xmath200_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}=\ ; [ \gamma_1]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } \;{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\ ; [ \gamma_2]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\;{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\ ; \ldots\;{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\;[\gamma_k]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\;= [ \beta]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } \label{eq : chain1}\end{aligned}\ ] ] then by theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] and the fact that @xmath343 , we know that @xmath359 for all @xmath255 . in other words , since the chain implies that every @xmath360 must always occur between @xmath53 and @xmath70 in all stratified extensions of @xmath361 and @xmath362 , we also have @xmath359 . hence , by proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ( 1 ) , we have @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{a}}$ ] for all @xmath255 , @xmath256 . also from of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] and that @xmath364 , we know that for each @xmath360 , either @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{b}}$ ] or @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{c}}$ ] . now we note that the first element on the chain @xmath365_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}=[\alpha]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{c}}$ ] and the last element on the chain @xmath366_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}=[\beta]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{b}}$ ] . thus , there exist two consecutive elements @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] and @xmath367_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] on the chain such that @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{c}}$ ] and @xmath367_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{b}}$ ] . but then it follows that * @xmath367_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\times [ \gamma_i]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq ser$ ] and @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\ ; } } [ \gamma_{i+1}]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] * @xmath368_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } \hat{{\prec}}_{0 } [ \gamma_{i+1}]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\bigr)$ ] since @xmath343 and @xmath369 these contradict of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] since @xmath274 is a lsos - comtrace . + _ * case ( ii ) : * _ + when @xmath342 , by definition [ def : commonoid ] , there are some @xmath344 and steps @xmath345 such that @xmath370 and @xmath371 where @xmath119 , @xmath120 , @xmath121 satisfy @xmath348 and @xmath349 and @xmath129 . let @xmath372 and @xmath373 be enumerated step sequences of @xmath206 and @xmath40 respectively . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath352 . by definition [ def : extsos ] , there are @xmath374 and @xmath375 such that @xmath313 . by proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ( 1 ) , @xmath357 . thus , using a dual argument to the proof of case ( i ) , we can build a chain @xmath200_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}=\ ; [ \gamma_1]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } \;{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\ ; [ \gamma_2]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\;{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\ ; \ldots\;{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\;[\gamma_k]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\;= [ \beta]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } \end{aligned}\ ] ] we then argue that there are two consecutive elements on the chain such that @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{b}}$ ] and @xmath367_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq { \overline{c}}$ ] , which implies 1 . @xmath376_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\times [ \gamma_{i+1}]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}\subseteq ser$ ] and @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}_{0}}^{\mathsf{cov}\ ; } } [ \gamma_{i+1}]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] 2 . @xmath363_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0 } } } \hat{{\prec}}_{0 } [ \gamma_{i+1}]_{\equiv_{{\sqsubset}_{0}}}$ ] since @xmath343 and @xmath377 these contradict of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] . we also need to show that the labeled so - structure defined from each comtrace is indeed a lsos - comtrace . in other words , we need to show the following lemma . let @xmath114 be a comtrace alphabet . given a step sequence @xmath378 , the lp - isomorphic class @xmath379},{\prec}_{[u]},{\sqsubset}_{[u]},\ell \right ] } $ ] is a lsos - comtrace over @xmath128 . [ lem : l3 ] the proof of this lemma is straightforward by checking that @xmath379},{\prec}_{[u]},{\sqsubset}_{[u]},\ell \right ] } $ ] satisfies all conditions . let @xmath128 be a comtrace alphabet . 1 . the mapping @xmath380 is defined as + @xmath381 } , $ ] + where the function @xmath382 is defined in section [ sec : steps ] and @xmath383 is the so - structure defined by the comtrace @xmath172 from definition [ def : s2sos ] . the mapping @xmath384 is defined as + @xmath385 [ def : repmaps ] intuitively , the mapping @xmath386 is used to convert a comtrace to lsos - comtrace while the mapping @xmath387 is used to transform a lsos - comtrace into a comtrace . the fact that @xmath386 and @xmath387 are valid representation mappings for @xmath388 and @xmath232 will be shown in the following theorem . let @xmath128 be a comtrace alphabet . 1 . for every @xmath389 , @xmath390 . 2 . for every @xmath391 , @xmath392 . [ theo : rep ] * 1 . * the fact that @xmath393 follows from lemma [ lem : l3 ] . now for a given @xmath389 , we have @xmath394 . thus , it follows that @xmath395 * 2 . * assume @xmath270 is the canonical representation of @xmath85 . observe that since @xmath396 , we have @xmath397 let @xmath398 . we will next show that @xmath399 and @xmath400 } $ ] . fix an arbitrary @xmath401 , from lemmas [ lem : l1 ] and [ lem : l2 ] , @xmath305 } = ( \sigma,{\prec}_{0},{\sqsubset}_{0})$ ] . from theorem [ theo : com2sos ] , @xmath402})\bigr\ } } = [ u]$ ] . and the rest follows . the theorem says that the mappings @xmath386 and @xmath387 are inverses of each other and hence are both _ bijective_. using theorem [ theo : rep ] , we are going to show that the _ combined dependency graph _ notion proposed in @xcite is another correct alternative definition for comtraces . first we need to define several representation mappings that are needed for our proofs . let @xmath128 be a comtrace alphabet . 1 . the mapping @xmath403 is defined as + @xmath404 + where @xmath65 is any step sequence in @xmath172 and @xmath405 and @xmath406 are defined as in definition [ def : s2inv ] . the mapping @xmath407 is defined as @xmath408 . the mapping @xmath409 is defined as + @xmath410 . [ def : drepmaps ] before proceeding futher , we want to make sure that : 1 . @xmath407 is a well - defined function . 2 . @xmath403 is a well - defined function . given a cd - graph @xmath411 } \in { \mathsf{cdg}}(\theta)$ ] , let @xmath412 } = d_1^{\lozenge}$ ] . we know that @xmath85 is uniquely defined , since by definition [ def : comdag ] , @xmath413 is a so - structure , and so - structures are fixed points of @xmath154-closure ( by proposition [ prop : so - cl ] ( 4 ) ) . we will next show that @xmath85 is a lsos - comtrace by verifying the conditions of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] . conditions and are exactly and . : suppose for contradiction that there exist two distinct non - serializable sets @xmath207,[\beta]\subset x$ ] such that @xmath207({{\hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\cap \hat{{\prec}})[\beta]$ ] and @xmath414)\times \lambda([\beta ] ) \subseteq ser$ ] . clearly , this implies that @xmath415 , and thus by the @xmath154-closure definition , @xmath70 is reachable from @xmath53 on the directed graph @xmath416 , where @xmath417 . now we consider a shortest path @xmath418 + @xmath419 + on @xmath420 that connects @xmath53 to @xmath70 . we will prove by induction on @xmath421 that there exist two consecutive @xmath422 and @xmath423 on @xmath418 such that @xmath424 $ ] and @xmath425 $ ] and @xmath426 , which contradicts with @xmath414)\times \lambda([\beta ] ) \subseteq ser$ ] . + * base case : * when @xmath427 , then @xmath428 . since @xmath207({{\hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\cap \hat{{\prec}})[\beta]$ ] , we have @xmath429 , which by implies @xmath430 . + * inductive case : * when @xmath431 , we consider @xmath432 and @xmath433 . if @xmath434 $ ] and @xmath435 $ ] , then by @xmath207({{\hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\cap \hat{{\prec}})[\beta]$ ] , we have @xmath436 , which immediately yields @xmath437 . otherwise , we have @xmath438\cup [ \beta]$ ] or @xmath439 $ ] . for the first case , we get @xmath207\hat{{\sqsubset}}[\delta_2]\hat{{\sqsubset}}[\beta]$ ] , which contradicts that @xmath207{{\hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}[\beta]$ ] . for the latter case , we can apply induction hypothesis on the path @xmath440 . and can also be shown similarly using `` shortest path '' argument as above . these proofs are easier since we only need to consider paths with edges in @xmath294 . * 2 . * by the proof of ( * lemma 4.7 ) , for any two step sequences @xmath50 and @xmath65 in @xmath441 , we have @xmath442 iff @xmath443 ) = { \mathsf{ct2dep}}([t])$ ] . thus the mapping @xmath444 is well - defined . the mapping @xmath407 is injective . [ lem : dlinj ] assume that @xmath445 , such that @xmath446 $ ] . since @xmath154-closure operator does not change the labeling function , we can assume that @xmath447 $ ] and @xmath448 . we will next show that @xmath449 . ( @xmath450 ) : let @xmath286 such that @xmath451 . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath452 . since @xmath451 , by , @xmath453 . thus , by , @xmath454 . but since @xmath448 , it follows that @xmath455 ( by proposition [ prop : so - cl ] ) . thus , @xmath456 and @xmath457 , a contradiction . ( @xmath458 ) : can be proved similarly . by reversing the role of @xmath459 and @xmath460 , we have @xmath461 . thus , we conclude @xmath462 . we are now ready to show the following representation theorem which ensures that @xmath463 and @xmath464 are valid representation mappings for @xmath232 and @xmath291 . let @xmath128 be a comtrace alphabet . 1 . for every @xmath465 , @xmath466 . 2 . for every @xmath391 , @xmath467 . [ theo : deprep ] * 1 . * let @xmath468 and let @xmath469 . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath470 and @xmath471 . from how @xmath386 is defined , @xmath472 . thus , it follows that @xmath473 . but this contradicts the injectivity of @xmath464 from lemma [ lem : dlinj ] . let @xmath391 and let @xmath474 . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath475 and @xmath476 . since @xmath477 , if we let @xmath478 , then @xmath479 . thus , we have shown that @xmath480 and @xmath481 , contradicting theorem [ theo : rep ] ( 2 ) . this theorem shows that lsos - comtraces and cd - graphs are equivalent representations for comtraces . the main advantage of cd - graph definition is its simplicity while the lsos - comtrace definition is stronger and more convenient to prove properties about labeled so - structures that represent comtraces . we do not need to prove another representation theorem for cd - graphs and comtraces since their representation mappings are simply the composition of the representation mappings from theorems [ theo : rep ] and [ theo : deprep ] . recall for a comtrace monoid @xmath127)$ ] , the comtrace operator @xmath125 is defined as @xmath126\circledast[t ] = [ r\ast t]$ ] . we will construct analogous composition operators for lsos - comtraces and cd - graphs . we will then show that lsos - comtraces ( cd - graphs ) over a comtrace alphabet @xmath128 together with its composition operator form a monoid isomorphic to the comtrace monoid @xmath127)$ ] . given two sets @xmath482 and @xmath483 , we write @xmath484 to denote the _ disjoint union _ of @xmath482 and @xmath483 . such disjoint union can be easily obtained by renaming the elements in @xmath482 and @xmath483 so that @xmath485 . we define the lsos - comtrace composition operator as follows . let @xmath486 and @xmath487 be lsos - comtraces over an alphabet @xmath114 , where @xmath488 } $ ] . the _ composition _ @xmath489 of @xmath486 and @xmath487 is defined as ( a lp - isomorphic class of ) a labeled so - structure @xmath490 } $ ] such that @xmath491 , @xmath492 , and @xmath493 , where + @xmath494 + @xmath495 observe that the operator is well - defined since we can easily check that : for every @xmath496 , @xmath497 . we will next show that this composition operator @xmath498 properly corresponds to the operator @xmath125 of the comtrace monoid over @xmath128 . let @xmath128 be a comtrace alphabet . then 1 . for every @xmath499 , @xmath500 2 . for every @xmath501 , @xmath502 [ prop : hom1 ] * 1 . * assume @xmath503 } $ ] , @xmath504 } $ ] and @xmath505 } $ ] . we can pick @xmath506 and @xmath507 . then observe that a stratified order @xmath75 satisfying @xmath508 is an extension of @xmath509 . thus , by theorem [ theo : rep ] , we have @xmath510\circledast [ { \mathsf{map}}(\lambda_2,\lhd_2 ) ] = [ { \mathsf{map}}(\lambda,\lhd ) ] = { \mathsf{lct2ct}}(q)$ ] as desired . * 2 . * without loss of generality , we can assume that @xmath511 $ ] , @xmath512 $ ] and @xmath513 = \mathbf{r}\circledast \mathbf{t}$ ] , where @xmath514 . by appropriate reindexing , we can also assume that @xmath515 . under these assumptions , let @xmath516 } $ ] , @xmath517 } $ ] and @xmath518 } $ ] , where @xmath519 is simply the standard labeling functions . it will now suffice to show that @xmath520 . ( @xmath521 ) : let @xmath522 . by definitions [ def : s2inv ] and [ def : s2sos ] , we have + @xmath523 + @xmath524 + thus , by proposition [ prop : so - cl ] ( 5 ) , we have @xmath525 as desired . furthermore , by proposition [ prop : so - cl ] ( 5 ) , @xmath526 is a so - structure . ( @xmath527 ) : by definitions [ def : s2inv ] and [ def : s2sos ] , we have @xmath528 and @xmath529 . since we already know @xmath526 is a so - structure , it follows from proposition [ prop : so - cl ] ( 5 ) that + @xmath530 let @xmath531 denote the lp - isomorphic class @xmath532 $ ] . then we observe that @xmath533 ) = \mathbb{i}$ ] and @xmath534 $ ] . by proposition [ prop : hom1 ] and theorem [ theo : rep ] , the structure @xmath535 is isomorphic to the monoid @xmath536)$ ] under the isomorphisms @xmath380 and @xmath384 . thus , the triple @xmath537 is also a monoid . we can summarize these facts in the following theorem : the mappings @xmath386 and @xmath387 are monoid isomorphisms between two monoids @xmath536)$ ] and @xmath535 . similarly , we can also define a composition operator for cd - graphs . let @xmath538 and @xmath539 be cd - graphs over an alphabet @xmath114 , where @xmath540 } $ ] . the _ composition _ @xmath541 of @xmath538 and @xmath539 is defined as ( a lp - isomorphic class of ) a labeled so - structure @xmath542 } $ ] such that @xmath491 , @xmath492 , and + @xmath543 + @xmath544 from this definition , it is straightforward to show the following propositions , which we will state without proofs . for every @xmath545 , @xmath546 . let @xmath128 be a comtrace alphabet . then 1 . for every @xmath499 , @xmath547 2 . for every @xmath548 , @xmath549 [ prop : hom2 ] putting the two preceding propositions and theorem [ theo : deprep ] together , we conclude : the mappings @xmath463 and @xmath464 are monoid isomorphisms between two monoids @xmath535 and @xmath550 . the simple yet useful construction we used extensively in this paper is to build a quotient so - structure modulo the @xmath95-cycle equivalence relation . intuitively , each @xmath95-cycle equivalence class consists of all the events that must be executed simultaneously with one another and hence can be seen as a single `` composite event '' . the resulting quotient so - structure is technically easier to handle since both relations of the quotient so - structure are acyclic . from this construction , we were able to give a labeled so - structure definition for comtraces similar to the labeled poset definition for traces . this quotient construction also explicitly reveals the following connection : a step on a step sequence @xmath135 is not serializable with respect to the relation @xmath5 of a comtrace alphabet if and only if it corresponds to a @xmath95-cycle equivalence class of the lsos - comtrace representing the comtrace @xmath134 $ ] ( cf . proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ) . we have also formally shown that the quotient monoid of comtraces , the monoid of lsos - comtraces and the monoid of cd - graphs _ over the same comtrace alphabet _ are indeed isomorphic by establishing monoid isomorphisms between them . these three models are formal linguistic , order - theoretic , and graph - theoretic respectively , which allows us to apply a variety of tools and techniques . an immediate future task is to develop a framework similar to the one in this paper for _ generalized comtraces _ , proposed and developed in @xcite . generalized comtraces extend comtraces with the ability to model events that can be executed _ earlier than or later than but never simultaneously_. another direction is to define and analyze infinite comtraces ( and generalized comtraces ) in a spirit similar to the works on infinite traces , e.g. , @xcite . it is also promising to use infinite lsos - comtraces and cd - graphs to develop logics for comtraces similarly to what have been done for traces ( cf . @xcite ) . i am grateful to prof . ryszard janicki for introducing me comtrace theory . i also thank the mathematics institute of warsaw university and the theoretical computer science group of jagiellonian university for their supports during my visits . it was during these visits that the ideas from this paper emerge . this work is financially supported by the ontario graduate scholarship and the natural sciences and engineering research council of canada . the anonymous referees are thanked for their valuable comments that help improving the readability of this paper . 19 e. clarke , o. grumberg and d. peled , _ model checking _ , mit press , cambridge , 1999 . t. h. cormen , c. e. leiserson and r. l. rivest , _ introduction to algorithms _ , second edition , mit press , 2001 . b. a. davey and h. a. priestley , , cambridge university press 2002 . v. diekert , on the concatenation of infinite traces , proc . of stacs , _ lncs _ 480 ( 1991 ) , 105117 . v. diekert and g. rozenberg ( eds . ) , . world scientific 1995 . v. diekert and y mtivier , , _ handbook of formal languages , vol . 3 : beyond words _ , pp 457 - 533 , springer 1997 . v. diekert , m. horsch , m. kufleitner , on first - order fragments for mazurkiewicz traces , _ fundam . _ 80(1 - 3 ) : 1 - 29 , 2007 . j. esparza and k. heljanko , _ unfoldings a partial - order approach to model checking _ , springer 2008 . a. farzan and p. madhusudan , causal dataflow analysis for concurrent programs , proc . of cav , _ lncs _ 4144 ( 2006 ) : 315328 . a. farzan and p. madhusudan , causal atomicity , proc . of tacas 2007 , _ lncs _ 4424 ( 2007 ) , 102116 . p. c. fishburn , _ interval orders and interval graphs _ , j. wiley 1985 , new york . h. gaifman and v. pratt , partial order models of concurrency and the computation of function , _ proc . of lics87 _ , pp . 7285 . p. gastin , infinite traces , proc . of semantics of systems of concurrent processes , _ lncs _ 469 ( 1990 ) , 277308 . t. gazagnaire , b. genest , l. hlout , p. s. thiagarajan , s. yang , causal message sequence charts , _ theor . 410(41 ) : 40944110 , 2009 . r. janicki , relational structures model of concurrency . , 45(4 ) : 279320 , 2008 . r. janicki and m. koutny , invariants and paradigms of concurrency theory , proc . of _ parle _ 91 , _ lncs _ 506 , springer 1991 , pp . 5974 . r. janicki and m. koutny , structure of concurrency , , 112(1 ) : 552 , 1993 . r. janicki and m. koutny , semantics of inhibitor nets , _ information and computation _ , 123(1 ) : 116 , 1995 . r. janicki and m. koutny , fundamentals of modelling concurrency using discrete relational structures , _ acta informatica _ , 34 : 367388 , 1997 . r. janicki and m. koutny , on causality semantics of nets with priorities , _ fundamenta informaticae _ 34 : 222255 , 1999 . r. janicki and d. t. m. l , modelling concurrency with quotient monoids , proc of petri nets 2008 , _ lncs _ 5062 , springer 2008 , pp . 251269 . r. janicki and d. t. m. l , modelling concurrency with comtraces and generalized comtraces , submitted in 2009 . available at : http://arxiv.org/abs/0907.1722 g. juhs , r. lorenz , s. mauser , causal semantics of algebraic petri nets distinguishing concurrency and synchronicity , _ fundamenta informatica _ 86(3 ) : 255 - 298 , 2008 . g. juhs , r. lorenz , s. mauser , synchronous + concurrent + sequential = earlier than + not later than , proc . of acsd06 , turku , finland 2006 , pp . 261 - 272 , ieee press . h. c. m. kleijn and m. koutny , process semantics of general inhibitor nets , _ information and computation _ , 190:1869 , 2004 . j. kleijn and m. koutny , formal languages and concurrent behaviour , _ studies in computational intelligence _ , 113:125 - 182 , 2008 . d. t. m. l , studies in comtrace monoids , master thesis , dept . of computing and software , mcmaster university , canada , august 2008 . a. mazurkiewicz , concurrent program schemes and their interpretation , tr daimi pb-78 , comp . science depart . , aarhus university , 1977 . v. pratt , modeling concurrency with partial orders , _ international journal of parallel programming _ , 15(1):3371 , 1986 . e. szpilrajn , sur lextension de lordre partiel , _ fund . mathematicae _ 16 , 386389 , 1930 . p. s. thiagarajan and i. walukiewicz , an expressively complete linear time temporal logic for mazurkiewicz traces , _ inf . comput . _ 179(2 ) : 230249 , 2002 . * 1 . * ( @xmath551 ) : since @xmath207=[\beta]$ ] , we know that @xmath552 or @xmath553 . the former case is trivial . for the latter case , by theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] , we have @xmath554 and @xmath555 . but this implies that @xmath556 . ( @xmath557 ) : the case when @xmath552 is trivial . assume that @xmath558 and @xmath556 . thus , by theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] , @xmath559 and @xmath457 . but this means @xmath53 and @xmath70 belong to the same equivalence class . * suppose for a contradiction that all @xmath560 can not be written in the form of @xmath561v$ ] . this implies that there exists some @xmath562 $ ] such that for all @xmath560 , @xmath563 . but by theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] , this yields @xmath564 and @xmath565 , contradicting with @xmath566 $ ] . assume @xmath207 { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\ ; } } [ \beta]$ ] . suppose for a contradiction that there does not exist @xmath560 such that @xmath561[\beta]v$ ] for some step sequences @xmath65 and @xmath206 . then , by theorem [ theo : szpstrat ] , there must exist some @xmath567\cup[\beta])$ ] , such that @xmath568 . since @xmath569\cup[\beta]$ ] , this yields @xmath207{\sqsubset}[\gamma ] { \sqsubset}[\beta]$ ] , which contradicts that @xmath207 { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\ ; } } [ \beta]$ ] . assume @xmath570 and @xmath558 . thus , @xmath571 . thus , by corollary [ cor : szpstrat ] ( 2 ) , we have @xmath572 . hence , by of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] , @xmath573 . since @xmath4 is irreflexive , this also shows that any two distinct @xmath53 and @xmath70 in @xmath251 have different labels . thus , @xmath257 for all @xmath255 . * 2 . * from the proof of * 1 . * , we know that @xmath570 and @xmath558 implies @xmath573 . thus , @xmath574 for all @xmath255 . observe that from proposition [ prop : validss ] , we have @xmath575 . it remains to show that @xmath576 for all @xmath577 . suppose for a contradiction that @xmath578 for some @xmath577 . from the definition above , there are two distinct elements @xmath202 , such that @xmath579 and @xmath580 and @xmath581 . since @xmath5 is irreflexive , @xmath582 . thus , by of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] , @xmath583 or @xmath584 . without loss of generality , we assume @xmath583 and that @xmath585 for some event @xmath586 . again by of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] , we know that elements having the same label are totally ordered by @xmath93 . thus , if @xmath587 is the number of elements in @xmath3 labeled by @xmath39 , then we have @xmath588 and @xmath589 . but then @xmath590 implies that @xmath591 , while @xmath592 implies that @xmath593 , which is absurd . let @xmath594},{\prec}_{[u]},{\sqsubset}_{[u]},l \bigr)$ ] . from theorem [ theo : com2sos ] , @xmath85 is a labeled so - structure . it only remains to show that @xmath85 satisfies conditions of definition [ def : lcomtrace ] . : assume @xmath207 ( { { \hat{{\sqsubset}}}^{\mathsf{cov}\;}}\cap \hat{{\prec } } ) [ \beta]$ ] and suppose for a contradiction that @xmath414)\times \lambda([\beta ] ) \subseteq ser$ ] . then from proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ( 3 ) , there exists @xmath595 such that @xmath596[\beta]w$ ] . from theorem [ theo : com2sos ] , since we have @xmath597\bigr\ } } = ext(s_{[u]})$ ] , it follows that @xmath598[\beta]w ) \in [ u]$ ] . but @xmath414)\times \lambda([\beta ] ) \subseteq ser$ ] implies @xmath599\cup [ \beta]v ) \in [ u]$ ] . hence , @xmath600\cup [ \beta]v$ ] is also a stratified extension of @xmath85 , which contradicts that @xmath207 \hat{{\prec } } [ \beta]$ ] . using a similar argument , we can show using proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ( 1,4 ) and using proposition [ prop : covlsos ] ( 1,2 ) . : since @xmath601 , it follows from corollary [ cor : szpstrat ] that there exists @xmath595 where @xmath602 . since @xmath603\bigr\ } } = ext(s_{[u]})$ ] , there exists a sequence @xmath604 $ ] such that @xmath605 . this implies @xmath53 and @xmath70 belong to the same step in @xmath606 . thus , we have @xmath573 .
Abstract: | [
"this paper defines a class of labeled stratified order structures that characterizes exactly the notion of _ _ com__bined _ traces _ ( i.e. , _ comtraces _ ) proposed by janicki and koutny in 1995 . our main technical contributions are the representation theorems showing that comtrace quotient monoid , _ combined dependency graph _ ( kleijn and koutny 2008 ) and our labeled stratified order structure characterization are three different and yet equivalent ways to represent comtraces . + * keywords . * causality theory of concurrency , combined traces monoids , step sequences , stratified order structures , label - preserving isomorphism ."
] | 11,034 | 11,034 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the number of astrophysical sources thought to possess surface magnetic fields above the quantum critical field strength of g has been steadily growing in recent years . the five presently known soft gamma - ray repeaters ( sgrs ) and six or seven anomalous x - ray pulsars ( axps ) are believed to be magnetars , neutron stars having surface fields in the range @xmath0 g ( duncan & thompson 1992 ) . in addition , the parkes multibeam survey ( manchester et al . 2001 ) has discovered at least six new radio pulsars that have surface fields near or above critical , and several with fields comparable to those of some of the magnetars . the radiation processes that determine the observed x - ray and gamma - ray spectra in these sources are operating in the extreme relativistic and quantum regimes and thus require treatment that is accurate in such environments . one process that is particularly important in the source emission models is resonant compton scattering , in which electrons scatter photons at the cyclotron resonance with a cross section much larger than at continuum energies . relativistic electrons can blue - shift low energy photons into the resonance , upscattering the photons into a high - energy continuum ( daugherty & harding 1989 , dermer 1990 ) . the quantum electrodynamical ( qed ) cross section for compton scattering at the cyclotron fundamental ( herold 1979 ) and higher harmonics ( daugherty & harding 1986 , bussard , alexander & mszros 1986 ) , accurate in arbitrarily high magnetic fields , has been known for some time . however , these derivations do not treat the natural line widths that render the cross section finite at the cyclotron resonances . in order to use such rates in spectral calculations in astrophysical models , the line widths that originate from the lifetimes of the excited landau states must be included in the cross section ( wasserman & salpeter 1980 ) . the width of the @xmath1th resonance is equal to the cyclotron decay rate from that state ( pavlov et al . 1991 ) , and the prescription for incorporating the widths in the qed cross section in the high - field regime has been discussed by harding & daugherty ( 1991 ) and graziani ( 1993 ) . including resonant line widths in the scattering cross section necessarily requires spin - dependent decay rates , which appear in an infinite sum over landau state @xmath1 and spin of the intermediate virtual states , even in the case of ground state - to - ground state scattering in the fundamental . different spin states have different decay rates , and thus different resonant energy denominators . since the electrons and positrons in intermediate states have non - zero momentum parallel to the magnetic field , it is important to use basis states that yield a spin dependence that is lorentz invariant , i.e. boosts along the magnetic field do not lead to a mixing between the spin states . as is true for all quantum processes , the spin - dependent rates and cross sections depend on the choice of electron wavefunctions in a uniform magnetic field . historically , several choices of wavefunctions have been used in calculations of the scattering cross section and cyclotron decay rates . the two most widely used wavefunctions are those of johnson & lippman ( 1949 ) and sokolov & ternov ( 1968 ) . the johnson & lippman ( jl ) wavefunctions are derived in cartesian coordinates and are eigenstates of the kinetic momentum operator . the sokolov & ternov ( st ) wavefunctions , specifically their `` transverse polarization '' states , are derived in cylindrical coordinates and are eigenfunctons of the magnetic moment operator . given the different spin dependence of the st and jl eigenstates , one must use caution in making the appropriate choice when treating spin - dependent processes . herold , ruder & wunner ( 1982 ) and melrose and parle ( 1983 ) have noted that the st eigenstates have desirable properties that the jl states do not possess , such as being eigenfunctions of the hamiltonian including radiation corrections , having symmetry between positron and electron states , and diagonalization of the self - energy shift operator . as found by graziani ( 1993 ) , the st wavefunctions also diagonalize the landau - dirac operator , and are the physically correct choices for spin - dependent treatments and for incorporating widths in the scattering cross section . although the spin - averaged st and jl cyclotron decay rates are equal , the spin - dependent decay rates are not , except in the special case in which the initial momentum of the electron parallel to the field vanishes . perhaps the most fundamental argument against use of the jl wavefunctions is that radiative corrections cause excited jl landau levels to become unstable to spin - flip transition within landau states on timescales comparable to the timescale for decay to a lower landau state . these radiative corrections to the magnetic moment break the spin degeneracy of both the st and jl excited landau states ( herold , ruder & wunner 1982 ) , causing spin - dependent energy level shifts , and implying a dependence of the rates for spin - flip transitions within a landau state on the choice of wavefunctions . the rates of such spin - flip transitions within split st landau states have been evaluated ( geprgs et al . 1994 ; see also parle 1987 ) , and are found to be of order of for , which is negligible compared to decay rates between landau states . the existence of such relatively long - lived states is a premise of the s - matrix formalism and is also essential to any astrophysical calculations involving spin - dependent transitions between landau states . in contrast , it is anticipated that since the jl eigenstates do not diagonalize the self - interaction hamiltonian including radiation corrections ( i.e. the mass operator ) , the associated mixing incurred in s - matrix evaluations will render spin - flip transition rates with fixed comparable to ordinary cyclotronic rates with changes in , a situation that is unphysical . in this paper we discuss the lorentz tranformation characteristics of cyclotron decay rates for both st and jl formulations , and derive simplified expressions for the decay rates from an arbritrary excited landau state to the ground state . we show that the st eigenstates preserve separability of the spin dependence under lorentz boosts along the local magnetic field , a desirable property that does not extend to the jl formalism , for which such lorentz boosts mix the corresponding spin states . in the st formulation , by taking advantage of its spin - state preserving characteristics , our analytic simplifications can be elegantly applied to the spin - dependent decay rates ; in the jl formalism the simplifications can be compactly applied only to the spin - averaged rates . the resulting expressions replace integrals over emergent photon angle with series of legendre functions of the second kind , which correspond to sums of elementary functions , easily yielding simple asymptotic forms . the expressions derived here should have wide applicability to modeling cyclotron emission , compton scattering and other qed processes in super - critical fields . for such magnetar - type fields , resonant scattering takes place primarily at the fundamental , since the cyclotron energy exceeds 1 mev . although the resonant scattering line widths formally involve infinite sums over landau states , in the case of the fundamental resonance the sum is dominated by the @xmath2 state , whose width is equal to the @xmath3 cyclotron decay rate . for cyclotron scattering in higher harmonics @xmath4 , the intermediate sums in the vertex functions have the largest contributions from the @xmath5 state . however , for , cyclotron transitions to the ground landau state dominate ( sokolov , zhukovskii & nikitina 1973 , white 1974 , harding & preece 1987 ) , so that cyclotron decay rates for @xmath3 transitions treated in this paper should be good approximations to the widths of excited states , a circumstance pertinent to astrophysical models of magnetars . this presentation of spin - dependent cyclotron rates appropriately focuses first on the formulation generated using the _ transverse polarization _ eigenstates of the dirac equation derived by sokolov & ternov ( 1968 ) for electrons in a uniform magnetic field * b*. explicit forms for them can also be found in herold , ruder & wunner ( 1982 ) and harding & preece ( 1987 ) , whose exposition on cyclotron emission essentially forms the basis of results developed here . herold et al . observed that these states diagonalize the operator that describes the electronic self - energy shift in an external magnetic field . another attractive feature of the sokolov & ternov eigenstates is that they possess charge conjugation symmetries , i.e. between electron ( positive energy ) and positron ( negative energy ) : see eq . ( 12 ) of herold , ruder & wunner ( 1982 ) . an additional asset of these wavefunctions that is enunciated here is that they yield cyclotron rates whose spin dependence is effectively separable from lorentz transformations along the field : i.e. such boosts do not mix spin states . this is a very useful characteristic that is not present in the johnson & lippmann formalism addressed in section [ sec : jlformalism ] below . herold , ruder & wunner ( 1982 ) obtained general expressions in their eq . ( 17 ) for the spin - dependent cyclotron rate for transitions between arbitrary landau levels , but for the case of zero initial momentum parallel to the field . latal ( 1986 ) independently obtained similar results for cyclotron transitions to the ground state , but retained arbitrary initial momenta along * b * ; his eq . ( 22 ) forms the starting point for the exposition here . denoting as the spin quantum number of the initial electron , ground state transitions are characterized by a single final spin . the energy level quantum numbers are initially , and after the transition . latal s spin - dependent _ total _ rates can be written in the form @xmath6 where is the magnetic field strength , expressed dimensionlessly hereafter in units of the quantum critical field gauss , and the _ spin - averaged _ , total cyclotron transition rate for is given by @xmath7 \label{eq : gammave_st}\\[-5.5pt ] & \times & \ ; \dover{(1-\xi)^{n-1}}{(1+\xi)^{n+1}}\biggl ( 1 + 2nb - \dover{1}{\xi } \biggr ) \ ; \exp \biggl ( - n\ , \dover{1-\xi}{1+\xi } \biggr ) \ ; .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] here is the compton wavelength of the electron over , and other quantities in this equation are defined as follows . for initial and final dimensionless momenta ( i.e. , in units of ) , and respectively , parallel to the field , the electron s initial energy and final energy , both dimensionless ( i.e. , in units of ) , are @xmath8 this convention of using dimensionless energies and momenta will be adopted throughout the paper . the integration variable is the angle cosine of the emitted photon with respect the magnetic field direction , i.e. for photon wavenumber vector . no integration by parts has been performed when obtaining eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) , so that the cyclotron rate , differential in photon angles , , again averaged over initial electron spins , corresponds directly to the integrand of eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) : @xmath9 corresponding spin - dependent differential cyclotron rates can be deduced from eq . ( [ eq : gamma_st ] ) in similar fashion . the remaining variable , , emerges naturally from energy - momentum conservation in the interaction . only momentum parallel to the field is conserved , since the system is not translationally - invariant orthogonal to * b*. hence cyclotron emission satisfies two such conservation relations : @xmath10 \label{eq : e_p_conserve}\\[-5.5pt ] p & = & q + \omega\mu\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for . here is the dimensionless photon energy , having been scaled by . the elimination of from the system in eq . ( [ eq : e_p_conserve ] ) leads to the identities @xmath11 \label{eq : omega_ident}\\[-5.5pt ] \omega ( 1-\mu^2 ) & = & ( 1-\xi ) \ , ( e_n - p\mu ) \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] that are simultaneously satisfied , with @xmath12 being the specialization of the definition in eq . ( 11b ) of latal ( 1986 ) . the angle integration in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) for the cyclotron rate is non - trivial , due largely to the complicated dependence of on , and the presence of the exponential . this completes the definitions relevant to eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) . however , we also note that the identities in eq . ( [ eq : omega_ident ] ) combine to yield @xmath13 which is precisely the argument of the exponential in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) . this factor results from the specialization of associated laguerre functions that are formed from the spatial integration ( fourier transform ) of the eigenfunctions . since is lorentz invariant under boosts along * b * , so also is . furthermore , forming using eq . ( [ eq : e_p_conserve ] ) , and then eliminating using the second identity in eq . ( [ eq : omega_ident ] ) , quickly leads to the equivalence @xmath14 when weighted by top and bottom , this is a ratio of invariant products of four - momenta associated with the interaction ; i.e. is also a lorentz invariant for boosts along the field , which can be inferred directly from eq . ( [ eq : kappa_def ] ) . there is no need to compute eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) as it stands for arbitrary . instead , one can appeal to a simple lorentz transformation protocol . consider boosts along the field between the inertial frame where the initial electron possesses momentum along the field , and that frame where the initial parallel momentum is zero . in this latter `` rest '' frame let be the photon angle cosine with respect to * b * , be the initial parallel momentum , and the initial electron energy be denoted @xmath15 then , for a dimensionless boost velocity and lorentz factor along * b * , the initial electron quantities in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) satisfy @xmath16 \label{eq : lorentz_boost}\\[-5.5pt ] p & = & \gamma ( p_0 - \beta \erg_n ) \;\equiv\ ; -\gamma\beta\erg_n\quad , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] from which is established . the photon angle cosine satisfies the aberration formula @xmath17 this latter relation identifies a suitable change of variables for the angle integration , for which . other transformation identities include and , from which the invariance in form of is established via the definition in eq . ( [ eq : xi_def ] ) . it then follows , after a modicum of algebra , that this pure change of variables leads to an alternative form for the rate in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) : @xmath18 with @xmath19 where , now is obtained from eq . ( [ eq : xi_def ] ) using the correspondences , and . accordingly , this identifies attractive lorentz transformation behavior , with the rate reduced ( i.e. lifetime dilated ) by just the lorentz factor of the boost . moreover , such boosts along the field keep the spin states `` separated , '' i.e. there is no implied mixing of states incurred by such transformations . this inherent simplicity is an appealing characteristic of the sokolov & ternov states , and was identified by graziani ( 1993 ) ; it is not exhibited in the johnson & lippman formalism explored in sec . [ sec : jlformalism ] . clearly , this extraction of cases via a simple modification factor outside the integral is expedient for the subsequent analytic developments . while the integral expressions for the cyclotron rates can be routinely evaluated numerically , they can also be represented by compact analytic series in terms of elementary functions that are readily amenable to computation . the integration variable for in eq ( [ eq : inb_def ] ) is not the most convenient ; a more expedient choice for the purposes of analytic reduction is @xmath20 the integration is even in , and since , the integration range maps over to @xmath21 after a modest amount of algebra , the change of variables then leads to the form @xmath22 this integral can be evaluated in terms of appell functions , the degenerate , two - dimensional hypergeometric functions , using eq . 3.385 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) . such a step does not facilitate evaluation , since appell function expositions usually develop double , infinite power series representations ( e.g. see burchnall & chaundy 1941 ; exton 1976 ) . analytic progress is quickly made via taylor series expansion of the exponential around . the order of integration and the infinite summation can then be interchanged because the integration is uniformly convergent on the interval , since is strictly less than unity . another change of variables , with the definition @xmath23 then establishes @xmath24 with @xmath25 using the identity 8.715.2 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) gives an integral representation of the legendre function of the second kind : @xmath26 these special functions are finite sums of elementary logarithmic and polynomial functions of ( e.g. see abramowitz & stegun 1965 ) . note that the are generalizable to associated legendre functions , defined in 8.703 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , from which . it follows from eqs . ( [ eq : jzn_def ] ) and ( [ eq : qnu_def ] ) that @xmath27 and relevant properties of the and functions are listed in the appendix . computational issues for the are discussed there also , and an expedient approach for integer is to compute the using the recurrence relation in eq . ( [ eq : jrecurrence ] ) . the final result of these analytic reductions is @xmath28 which expresses the spin - averaged cyclotron rate as a comparatively simple series of elementary functions . for low values of , this series is rapidly convergent for all , typically requiring 34 terms to achieve 0.01% accuracy . such a rate of convergence renders the series evaluation computationally much more efficient than a numerical integration of eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) by simpson s rule or a quadrature technique . the appearance of the legendre functions of the second kind , , in the series expansion for the rate is a result of the cylindrical symmetry imposed by the presence of the external magnetic field . evaluations of eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_red ] ) are presented in fig . [ fig : cyc_st_ave ] for different values of and for , demonstrating the well - known rapid increase of the rate with when . the dependence on is relatively weak for supercritical fields . the figure also clearly exhibits the property , which can , with extensive effort , be deduced from the integral form for the spin - averaged rate in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_alt ] ) . this decline of with increasing is evident in the asymptotic approximations for and derived shortly . [ fig : cyc_st_ave ] also exhibits the logarithm of the ratio @xmath29 of the spin - dependent rates for ; higher cases display similar behavior . this curve illustrates how the rate is approximately independent of initial spin when , whereas initial states lead to much faster transition rates ( by of order ) when , reflecting the well - known dominance of non - spin - flip cyclotron transitions by non - relativistic electrons ( e.g. see melrose & zheleznyakov 1981 ) . now consider the two pertinent asymptotic limits for the spin - averaged rate in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_red ] ) . when , and . using the first identity in eq . ( [ eq : j_nu_ident ] ) , eq . 8.771.2 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) can then be invoked to obtain the leading order dependence of , noting the specialization of the common hypergeometric function . the result , for general arguments , is @xmath30 here , represents the gamma function . this is the leading order ( ) term in the series evaluation of , and hence this result is readily checked by taking the limit of eq . ( [ eq : inb_alt ] ) . the doubling formula for the gamma function , in eq . 8.335.1 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , can now be used to yield an asymptotic form @xmath31 which is just eq . ( 31d ) of latal ( 1986 ) . this form illustrates the strong dependence of the cyclotron rates on both and . a sample case of the limit in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_lownb ] ) is displayed in fig . [ fig : cyc_st_ave ] . this limit can only be compared with the well - studied classical cyclotron limit in a restricted fashion , since it is still an essentially quantum result . moreover , it incorporates the intrinsically relativistic effect of spin - orbit coupling . observe that eq . ( [ eq : gammave_lownb ] ) , in conjunction with eq . ( [ eq : gamma_st ] ) , reproduces both the non - spin - flip ( ) and spin - flip ( ) st rates encapsulated in eqs . ( 18 ) and ( 21 ) , respectively , of melrose & russell ( 2002 ) , or equivalently , the specialization of eq . ( 18 ) of herold , ruder & wunner ( 1982 ) . classical formulations of cyclotron emissivities ( e.g. see eq . ( 6.19 ) of bekefi 1966 ) yield rates that depend on components of the electron velocity perpendicular to the field : . here the classical rate effectively represents the limit of a sum over various transitions , with . by invoking the correspondence , it is quickly established that , the same dependence as in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_lownb ] ) . yet in general , the classical does not equal the quantum , since here contributions are omitted from consideration . however , in the particular case of , there is only a single final state , namely , and with the prescription , eq . ( 6.19 ) of bekefi ( 1966 ) specializes to yield , which is precisely the value obtained in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_lownb ] ) . derivation of the , ultra - quantum limit is slightly more involved . in this situation , and so that the entire series in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_red ] ) is retained . the key useful result is derived in the appendix , in eq . ( [ eq : j_n_taylor_zeq1 ] ) , which establishes as . including the next order logarithmic contribution then leads to an approximate form for in eq . ( [ eq : inb_taylor_series ] ) , so that it then follows that @xmath32 here , is the incomplete gamma function in 8.350.1 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) . note that the same result can be derived directly from the limit of eq . ( [ eq : inb_alt ] ) using the integral definition of the incomplete gamma function . the weak dependence of the rate on in this limit is now apparent , and is evinced in fig . [ fig : cyc_st_ave ] by the crowding of curves for supercritical fields . in the limit of , further specialization is possible using the limit as , derived in the appendix , to yield the approximation @xmath33 this ultra - quantum result corresponds to the limit given in eq . ( 32a ) of latal ( 1986 ) , though the numerical coefficient of latal s does not agree exactly with the factor in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_highnb_too ] ) , the difference being around 10% . however , the expressions for quantum cyclotron transition rates derived in eq . ( 9 ) of sokolov , zhukovskii & nikitina ( 1973 ) and eq . ( 2.56 ) of white ( 1974 ) reduce exactly to eq . ( [ eq : gammave_highnb_too ] ) in the limit , confirming the asymptotic analysis here . a sample case of this limit is displayed in fig . [ fig : cyc_st_ave ] , the precision of which is around 2% relative to the exact result , and better than eq . ( 32a ) of latal ( 1986 ) . the first order correction to this asymptotic limit that would follow from the logarithmic term in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_highnb ] ) is relative to the leading order contribution in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_highnb_too ] ) . in the frame , the spin - averaged differential cyclotron rates can be immediately extracted from eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_alt ] ) using the prescription implied by eq . ( [ eq : gammave_diff_def ] ) . however , given that eqs . ( [ eq : omega_ident ] ) and ( [ eq : xi_def ] ) define a one - to - one correspondence between the angle cosine and the energy of the emitted cyclotron photon , the differential rates can suitably be presented as differential photon spectra , . the photon energy is , so that the kinematic bound translates to @xmath34 the change of variables is then defined by two branches , @xmath35 with the factors inside the square root reflecting the kinematics associated with both the cyclotron radiation and the one - photon pair creation interactions . this has a jacobian , leading to the spin - averaged differential spectrum @xmath36 \label{eq : dgammave_domega_st}\\[-5.5pt ] & \times & \dover{(\erg_n-\omega ) nb-\omega } { \sqrt{(\erg_n-1-\omega ) ( \erg_n+1-\omega ) } } \ ; \exp \bigl ( - n\ , \dover{\omega}{\omega_- } \bigr ) \ ; .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] this spectral rate is summed over the polarizations of the radiated photons . note that a factor of has been included to account for the two branches of the relation between and . observe also that this spectrum can be obtained directly from eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_alt ] ) and the form for in eq . ( [ eq : inb_alt ] ) by using the correspondence . key characteristics of the differential spectrum include its broadening and shifting to higher energies as increases , behavior that is largely governed by the kinematic result in eq . ( [ eq : omega_bounds ] ) . an exponential decline is present in cases until a sharp kinematic peaking at overtakes it . in cases , this exponential contribution is dominated by the power - law factor , leading to a steeply - rising spectrum . when , nearly all of the radiative power in the spectrum is confined to energies . in the opposite domain , , the spectra are extremely narrow , and little insight is gained by attempting an involved comparison with the classical limit ; most classical results are rendered for sums over a multitude of transitions . to conclude the formalism based on sokolov & ternov states , expressions for the cyclotron energy loss rate , or power , can be expeditiously presented . the development of such rates parallels that for , with the inclusion of an extra ( dimensionless ) weighting factor to the differential decay rate . hence , one can quickly write down @xmath37 & = & \dover{\fsc m_ec^3}{\lambar}\ , \dover{n^n}{(n-1)!}\ , \dover{b}{e_n } \int_{-1}^1 \dover{\omega \ , d\mu}{(e_n - p\mu)^2 } \label{eq : powerave_st}\\[2pt ] & \times & \ ; \dover{(1-\xi)^{n-1}}{(1+\xi)^{n+1}}\biggl ( 1 + 2nb - \dover{1}{\xi } \biggr ) \ ; \exp \biggl ( - n\ , \dover{1-\xi}{1+\xi } \biggr ) \ ; .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] as the spin - averaged power , using eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) . this can be conveniently transformed to the integration variable , representing the frame , using an analysis similar to that presented in sec . [ sec : st_lorentz ] . the only change is the manipulation of the additional factor inside the integration , for which the lorentz transformation relations in eqs . ( [ eq : lorentz_boost ] ) and ( [ eq : aberration ] ) quickly yield . since is even in , it follows that the term proportional to in the transformed integrand of eq . ( [ eq : powerave_st ] ) does not contribute . therefore , comparison with eqs . ( [ eq : gammave_st_alt ] ) and ( [ eq : inb_def ] ) then indicates that @xmath38 is the form for the cyclotron power for general , with @xmath39 where is given by eq . ( [ eq : phi_def ] ) . this expression for the power is identical to that in eq . ( 28 ) of latal ( 1986 ) , who illustrated the magnetic field and dependence in his fig . 1 . the spin - dependent powers are , of course , just given by additional multiplicative factors : for . observe that the dependence has now disappeared from the analysis , highlighting the fact that is a lorentz invariant for boosts along * b*. this follows from the exact compensation of time dilation and photon redshifting effects when integrating over all angles ; such an attractive invariance property for the total power clearly does not extend to its differential counterpart . the integral for can be manipulated in similar fashion to that for . since the only difference is an extra factor , which translates to a factor in the light of eq . ( [ eq : phi_def ] ) , it follows that can be worked into the form of eq . ( [ eq : inb_alt ] ) , but with the extra factor . the subsequent developments in sec . [ sec : st_analytic ] rapidly lead to the identity @xmath40 \label{eq : knb_alt_too}\\[-5.5pt ] & \equiv & \sum_{k=0}^{\infty } \dover{(-n)^k}{k!}\ , \biggl ( 1 - \dover{k}{n } \biggr ) j_{n+k}(z_n ) \;\ ; , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] for insertion into eq . ( [ eq : powerave_st_alt ] ) . given this form , asymptotic limits can be routinely obtained by replicating the approaches of sec . [ sec : stasymptotics ] . when , it is evident that , since then , as can be inferred for from eq . ( [ eq : j_n_lownb ] ) . furthermore , for , the result in eq . ( [ eq : j_n_taylor_zeq1 ] ) quickly yields a leading order contribution . then the identity and eq . ( [ eq : gamma_inc_limit ] ) can be used to derive the limiting form as . the results are @xmath41 while the case here replicates that inferred from eq . ( 31 ) of latal ( 1986 ) , the result differs from the numerical result in eq . ( 32a ) of latal ( 1986 ) by around 10% . the mean cyclotron photon energy is just the ratio of to , so that one quickly deduces from a comparison of eq . ( [ eq : powerave_asymptotics ] ) with eqs . ( [ eq : gammave_lownb ] ) and ( [ eq : gammave_highnb_too ] ) that when , as expected from classical cyclotron theory , and that when . note that latal ( 1986 ) misses the factor ( see his eq . ( 32b ) for the domain ) due to the imprecise nature of his estimates of the pertinent numerical factors in and . these behaviors of are reflected by the differential spectral form in eq . ( [ eq : dgammave_domega_st ] ) , where for the spectrum is essentially a delta function pinned at the cyclotron harmonic energy , and where for and the spectrum is somewhat broad but markedly asymmetric , skewed strongly towards . a complementary formulation of the cyclotron problem was provided by daugherty & ventura ( 1978 , hereafter dv78 ) using wavefunctions derived by johnson & lippmann ( 1949 ) . this is essentially the foremost presentation in the literature of cyclotron radiation calculations that specifically uses the johnson & lippmann eigenstates , hereafter referred to as jl states . these states are eigenvalues simultaneously of the dirac hamiltonian and the kinetic momentum operator , where is the vector potential , and therefore are not eigenstates of any physically meaningful spin operator ( see melrose & parle 1983 ) . the relative lack of symmetry in the jl states between the electron and positron wavefunctions leads to more complicated lorentz transformation characteristics for the cyclotron rates for boosts along the magnetic field , as shall become evident below . the spin - averaged rate should ( and does ) , of course , reduce to the sokolov & ternov formalism result in eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) . for direct comparison with the sokolov & ternov formalism results above , it is necessary to generalize the cyclotron emission results in the appendix of dv78 to treat arbitrary transitions , specifically their eqs . ( a2 ) and ( a3 ) . this is a routine s - matrix calculation in quantum electrodynamics , and essentially parallels the cyclotron absorption calculations presented in sec . ii of dv78 . the reader is therefore referred to dv78 for relevant background and some definitional material , and here only a detailed outline of the derivation is provided . wherever possible , the same notation as used in the st formulation above is adopted . the starting point is eq . ( a1 ) of dv78 , which can be integrated over photon solid angles to yield the spin - dependent cyclotron rate @xmath42 where is the density of photon states in a box of size ; this size establishes the normalization of the wavefunctions . note that is dimensionless because of the adopted convention of dimensionless photon energies . a sum over the photon polarization states has been effected , with the standard convention for the labelling of the photon polarizations being adopted : refers to the state with the photon s _ electric _ field vector parallel to the plane containing the magnetic field and the photon s momentum vector , while denotes the photon s electric field vector being normal to this plane . also , @xmath43 is the relevant integration over the final parallel momentum of the electron and the coordinate defining the mean location of the final electron wavefunction perpendicular to * b*. here is the normalizing time for the qed perturbation calculation . the central contribution to the integrand comes from @xmath44 the s - matrix element for cyclotron emission that is analogous to eq . ( 14 ) of dv78 that describes cyclotron absorption . here @xmath45 is the fourier transform of the spatial portion of the interaction amplitude , basically the vertex function of melrose and parle ( 1983 ) , but with the temporal phase factors already extracted . the initial electron wavefunction is , and can possess either spin designation ( note that this spin notation differs from the notation adopted by dv78 ) ; the final electron wavefunction , , is an , ground state , so that an explicit spin label is suppressed . expressions for these spatial parts of the johnson & lippmann eigenfunctions of the dirac equation are given eq . ( 10 ) of dv78 ; these do not exhibit the same charge conjugation symmetry that the sokolov & ternov `` transverse polarization '' states do . in eq . ( [ eq : vfi_def ] ) , is one of the two `` polarization matrices '' in eq . ( 15 ) of dv78 , representing contracted products of polarization vectors and the dirac matrices . since the and functions possess the dimensions of , it follows that and consequently and are dimensionless . observe also that the temporal integration over the wavefunction products has already been performed leading to the function in eq . ( [ eq : sfi_def ] ) that expresses energy conservation . finally , note that defines the mean location of the initial electron wavefunction perpendicular to * b * , i.e. is a counterpart to . the squaring of the matrix elements in eq . ( [ eq : phi_sigma_def ] ) is performed using the approach of , for example , bjorken & drell ( 1964 ) for handling the function . the result is @xmath46 in parallel with the developments leading to eq . ( 19 ) of dv78 . integrations analogous to those in eq . ( [ eq : vfi_def ] ) have been performed analytically in dv78 for the cyclotron absorption case , resulting in the appearance of associated laguerre functions that are characteristic of magnetized qed calculations involving either free electrons or electron propagators . here , since specialization to the case is made , these functions reduce to simple combinations of power - laws and exponentials , viz . , @xmath47 in the notation of eq . ( 18 ) of dv78 . as these spatial integrations embody translational invariance along the field , they yield a function expressing conservation of momentum parallel to * b * , i.e. establishing , and completing the conservation laws in eq . ( [ eq : e_p_conserve ] ) . a simple crossing symmetry manipulation of eq . ( 16 ) of dv78 facilitates the evaluation of eq . ( [ eq : vfi_def ] ) , and also eq . ( [ eq : phi_sigma_def ] ) , which can be compared closely with eq . ( 19 ) of dv78 . using the identity in eq . ( [ eq : omegasq ] ) , and reverting to the notation , a modest amount of algebra then yields relatively compact expressions for the spin - dependent cyclotron emission rate in the johnson & lippmann formalism : @xmath48 \label{eq : gamma_jl_too}\\[-5.5pt ] & \times & \ ; ( e_n+1)\ , ( e_0 + 1)\ , \bigl\ { \lambda^{\zeta}_{\parallel } + \lambda^{\zeta}_{\perp } \bigr\}\quad .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] the different photon polarization and electron spin combinations yield the following contributions : @xmath49 \label{eq : lambda_par}\\[-3.5pt ] \lambda^{-1}_{\parallel } & = & 2nb\ ; \biggl\ { \biggl ( \dover{q}{e_0 + 1 } + \dover{p}{e_n+1 } \biggr)\ , \dover{\omega ( 1-\mu^2)}{2nb } - \dover{\mu}{e_n+1}\ , \biggr\}^2 \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] for the polarization , and @xmath50 \label{eq : lambda_perp}\\[-5.5pt ] \lambda^{-1}_{\perp } & = & \dover{2nb}{(e_n+1)^2 } \nonumber \end{aligned}\ ] ] for photons of polarization . it is now almost trivial to demonstrate that for the case , eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_too ] ) in concert with eqs . ( [ eq : lambda_par ] ) and ( [ eq : lambda_perp ] ) reduces to eqs . ( a2 ) and ( a3 ) of daugherty & ventura ( 1978 ) , when and , respectively . accordingly , eqs . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_too][eq : lambda_perp ] ) serve as a generalization of the cyclotron emission rates presented in dv78 to arbitrary transitions . the isolation of the photon polarization contributions in this development is an attribute that is absent from the exposition in the appendix of daugherty & ventura ( 1978 ) . such an isolation expedites the algebraic developments that reduce this form into expressions that much more closely resemble those in the sokolov & ternov formulation , i.e. eqs . ( [ eq : gamma_st ] ) and ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) . the analytic reduction is routine , but lengthy , involving the expedient use of several identities . among these are eqs . ( [ eq : e_p_conserve][eq : xi_def ] ) , which can be used to quickly derive @xmath51 the latter of which is just a rearrangement of eq . ( [ eq : xi_altern ] ) . for the case , it is just a short path to yield the equivalences @xmath52 \label{eq : lambda_1_alt}\\[-5.5pt ] \lambda^{+1}_{\perp } & = & \biggl\ { -\dover{\omega}{e_n+1}\ ; \dover{(e_0 + 1)\mu -q}{e_0 + 1 } \biggr\}^2\quad , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] and for , a moderate amount of work to yield @xmath53 with this assembly of tools , and various algebraic manipulations , one is lead to the following final forms for the spin - dependent cyclotron rates in the johnson & lippmann formulation : @xmath54 where eq . ( [ eq : kappa_def ] ) gives in terms of , and the spin - dependent factors in the integrand are @xmath55 \label{eq : x_def}\\[-5.5pt ] x_{-1 } & = & 2 \bigl ( 1 + 2nb - \dover{1}{\xi } \ , \bigr ) - x_{+1}\quad .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] these are clearly forms resembling the integral that latal ( 1986 ) derived , though indicating a slightly more complicated differential distribution than for the st case . the average of the factors is obviously @xmath56 from which it is evident that the spin - averaged cyclotron rate for this johnson & lippmann formulation is identical to that of the sokolov & ternov formalism , i.e. eqs . ( [ eq : gamma_st ] ) and ( [ eq : gammave_st ] ) , as should be the situation . such degeneracy between formalisms also prevails for the power radiated when averaged over the initial electron spins . note that while the spin - dependent rates are generally different for the two sets of wavefunctions , in the limit , it is clear from eq . ( [ eq : x_def ] ) that so that the two formalisms become degenerate in this limit . this is a consequence of the mathematical identity of the sokolov & ternov and johnson & lippmann eigenstates in the special case of . as with the analysis in sec . [ sec : stformalism ] , it is instructive to discern the lorentz transformation behavior of the johnson & lippmann rates . such a development closely parallels that in sec . [ sec : st_lorentz ] , again writing the relevant integrals in terms of variables in the frame in which . with the identities and , it can be quickly established that @xmath57 which can be used also for . as for the cyclotron power considerations of sec . [ sec : power_st ] , since the spin - averaged integrand or is even in , the term proportional to in eq . ( [ eq : x_1_lorentz ] ) contributes exactly zero to the integral in eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_fin ] ) . this simplification clearly also applies to . it then follows that an alternative form for the rate in eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_fin ] ) is @xmath58 this form conveniently avails itself of the analytic developments of sec . [ sec : st_analytic ] , so that no further reduction of integrals is necessary : the evaluation of as a series of legendre functions of the second kind in eq . ( [ eq : inb_alt_too ] ) is immediately applicable . such a simplification can not be applied to the spin - dependent cyclotron powers , a point that is addressed below . the lorentz - transformed expression for the cyclotron rates in eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_final ] ) is attractively simple , but is not as elegant as its equivalent for the sokolov & ternov formulation , as embodied in eqs . ( [ eq : gamma_st ] ) and ( [ eq : gammave_st_alt ] ) . here , boosts along the field do not introduce simple time dilation factors of , essentially amounting to a mixing of jl spin states induced by such transformations . this less than ideal characteristic is a consequence of the fact that the jl wavefunctions are eigenstates of a somewhat convoluted spin operator that is not symmetric under charge conjugation ( e.g. , see melrose & parle 1983 ) , nor is it manifestly covariant under boosts along the field . in contrast , the st `` transverse polarization '' wavefunctions are eigenstates of the component along * b * of the magnetic moment operator ( here and are matrix vectors for the dirac algebra ) , and such eigenstates exhibit both appropriate symmetry between positrons and electrons , and simple transformation properties for boosts parallel to the field . the sensitivity of the spin - dependent cyclotron rates , and in particular their lorentz transformation characteristics , to the choice of spin eigenfunctions is naturally expected , since the inherently relativistic effect of spin - orbit coupling is explicitly incorporated in the dirac equation in an external field , thereby emphasizing the interpretative importance of the choice of wavefunctions . the greater elegance of the results in sec . [ sec : stformalism ] is yet another argument in favor of usage of sokolov & ternov states for the cyclotron problem , and therefore for other qed processes where spin - dependent cyclotron rates are required . note that the differential spectrum for spin - dependent considerations can be routinely obtained in a manner similar to the derivation of eq . ( [ eq : dgammave_domega_st ] ) , observing that can be replaced by in eq . ( [ eq : x_1_lorentz ] ) , or , as desired , and then using the substitution . the ratios of the jl rates in eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_final ] ) to their st counterparts are plotted in fig . [ fig : cyc_jl_st_ratio ] , being specifically given by @xmath59 in general , this ratio is less than unity for and greater than unity for ; it is also clearly a monotonically increasing function of for , and decreases monotonically with for . this ratio approaches unity for either ( dotted line ) or for , and in the case of also for . in the limit , the ratio approaches when , the maximum departure from unity in this case . in the domain , as , for the minimum in the ratio is and occurs for . the significant deviations from unity underline the importance of the choice of wavefunctions when retaining spin dependence . this becomes a profound issue for resonant compton scattering problems ( e.g. see graziani 1993 ) , where , as discussed above , the spin - dependent cyclotron lifetime is required to render the intermediate electron states metastable and thereby truncate the divergent resonance at the cyclotron frequency . it is also pertinent to handling resonances in magnetic coulomb scattering ( e.g. langer 1981 ) , two - photon pair creation in strong fields ( e.g. kozlenkov & mitrofanov 1986 ) , magnetic photon splitting above pair creation threshold ( discussed briefly in baring 2000 ) , and other general external field problems involving electrons either in free states or as propagators ( graziani , harding & sina , 1995 ) . to conclude this section , a brief exposition of the spin - dependent powers is offered . the spin - averaged power is , of course , that in eq . ( [ eq : powerave_st_alt ] ) . to retain spin dependence in the jl formalism , one proceeds by weighting the integrand of eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_fin ] ) with a factor . guided by the analysis in sec . [ sec : power_st ] , terms that are odd in contribute zero , and the by now routine manipulations yield the form @xmath60 \label{eq : power_jl_spins}\\[-3.5pt ] & \times & \hskip -5pt \biggl\ { \biggl\lbrack 1 - \dover{\zeta ( \gamma + \erg_n)}{\erg_n ( \gamma\erg_n+1 ) } \ , \biggr\rbrack\ , k_n(b ) + \zeta\ ; \dover{2\gamma\beta^2\ , ( nb)^3}{\erg_n^3 ( \gamma\erg_n+1)}\ , l_n(b ) \biggr\ } \ , , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where is the integral in eq . ( [ eq : knb_def ] ) , or equivalently , the series in eq . ( [ eq : knb_alt_too ] ) , and the term emerges from a term in the integrand resulting from the product , and corresponds to @xmath61 eq . ( [ eq : power_jl_spins ] ) is clearly not as elegant as the corresponding st result , namely , but does reduce to this simpler form in the limit , as expected . furthermore , averaging eq . ( [ eq : power_jl_spins ] ) over spins then yields exactly , so that degeneracy between the jl and st formalisms is realized when spin information is not explicitly retained . note that asymptotic limits of for small and large can be readily obtained but are not particularly elucidating for the purposes of this exposition . this paper presents useful analytic developments of spin - dependent cyclotron decay rates / widths for general transitions between landau states , expressing these in terms of various series of legendre functions of the second kind . the rates and the radiated cyclotron powers are derived using two popular eigenstate formalisms appropriate for the dirac equation in a uniform magnetic field , namely that due to sokolov & ternov ( 1968 ) , and that due to johnson & lippmann ( 1949 ) . the resulting expressions are eq . ( [ eq : gammave_st_red ] ) for the cyclotron rate and eq . ( [ eq : powerave_st_alt ] ) in conjunction with eq . ( [ eq : knb_alt_too ] ) for the sokolov & ternov formulation , and eq . ( [ eq : gamma_jl_final ] ) for the rate and eq . ( [ eq : power_jl_spins ] ) for the power for the johnson & lippmann case . these compact forms can be expediently used in astrophysical models , since they generally amount to rapidly convergent series of elementary functions . these spin - dependent results are particularly important for addressing resonant cyclotronic divergences that appear in various higher - order qed mechanisms in external magnetic fields . the johnson & lippmann developments extend the work of daugherty & ventura ( 1978 ) to arbitrary transitions , while the series development permits a more accurate determination of asymptotics of the sokolov & ternov rates than that offered in latal ( 1986 ) . in addition , the lorentz transformation characteristics of the rates are derived for boosts along the magnetic field , yielding a simple time dilation multiplicative factor in the st case , but a slightly more complicated and less ideal dependence on boost lorentz factor for the jl analysis , where spin - state mixing is implied by such boosts . such comparitive complexity of the jl formalism is more pronounced for the radiated power . this comparison again underlines the superior attributes of sokolov & ternov eigenstates for use in evaluating rates and cross sections of magnetized processes in quantum electrodynamics . we thank the referee , carlo graziani , for incisive comments that were helpful to the polishing of the manuscript . we also thank joe daugherty for the provision of materials pertaining to the johnson & lippmann formalism , and plg acknowledges the assistance of stefan coltisor during the early stages of the development of the decay rates using the johnson & lippmann wavefunctions . in performing this research , we are grateful for the generous support of the nasa astrophysics theory program , the research corporation ( grant cc5813 ) , and the national science foundation ( reu and grant ast-0307365 ) . this appendix provides several identities germane to the developments in the text , principally in relation to the legendre functions of the _ second kind _ , , which form the basis of the series expansions for the cyclotron rates . they can be defined in terms of hypergeometric functions ( e.g. see eq . 8.820.2 of gradshteyn & ryzhik 1980 ) , or alternatively the integral representation in eq . ( [ eq : qnu_def ] ) . for integer indices , the specialization of interest here , they are simple combinations of logarithmic and polynomial functions ( e.g. see abramowitz & stegun 1965 ) , that lead to similar simplicity for the using eq . ( [ eq : jnu_ident ] ) . observe that , where the associated legendre functions are defined in 8.703 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) . note also the alternative identities @xmath62 embodied in the results 8.734.3 and 8.752.5 in gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) . explicit functional forms for some of the are given in abramowitz & stegun ( 1965 ) and eq . 8.827 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , from which the following identities for the first few can be formed : @xmath63 j_2(z ) & = & -1 + \dover{3z^2}{2 } - \dover{3z\ , ( z^2 - 1)}{4 } \ , \log\bigl\vert \dover{z + 1}{z - 1 } \bigr\vert\quad , \label{eq : j_n_ident}\\[2pt ] j_3(z ) & = & -\dover{13z}{6 } + \dover{5z^3}{2 } - \dover{(5z^2 - 1)\ , ( z^2 - 1)}{4 } \ , \log\bigl\vert \dover{z + 1}{z - 1 } \bigr\vert\quad .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] an effective way to derive expressions for the in terms of elementary functions , at least for low , is to use the rodrigues formula in 8.836.1 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , and then invoke eq . ( [ eq : jnu_ident ] ) . an alternative approach is to use identities 8.831.2 and 8.831.3 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , to arrive at a relation between and a sum of legendre polynomials and a logarithmic term . this quickly yields @xmath64 \label{eq : j_n_series}\\[-5.5pt ] & = & \dover{1}{2}\,\bigl [ p_{n-1}(z ) - z\ , p_n(z)\bigr ] \ , \log\bigl\vert \dover{z + 1}{z - 1 } \bigr\vert - \sum_{k=1}^{n-1 } \dover{1}{k}\ , p_{k-1}(z)\ , p_{n-1-k}(z ) + z \sum_{k=1}^{n } \dover{1}{k}\ , p_{k-1}(z)\ , p_{n - k}(z)\quad , \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] a form that clearly displays the combined logarithmic and polynomial character of these functions , and which is useful for asymptotic results , explored just below . there are various possible approaches to numerical calculations of the functions for integer indices . options include direct use of eq . ( [ eq : j_n_series ] ) , combined with an efficient algorithm for computing the legendre polynomials for arguments , such as invoking recurrence relations ( e.g. see eq . 8.5.3 of abramowitz & stegun 1965 ) , which are numerically accurate for upward recurrence in the polynomial index . alternatively , direct recurrence of the functions , which satisfy the same relations as the , is viable , though this is only stable for downward iterations in when . this approach therefore requires evaluation of the for two particular initial values , perhaps via the hypergeometric function series using the identity in eq . 8.1.5 of abramowitz & stegun ( 1965 ) . however , probably the most expedient numerical technique is to use the recurrence relation for the functions directly : @xmath65 this identity can be deduced after a modicum of algebra from eq . 8.5.3 of abramowitz & stegun ( 1965 ) . note that strong cancellation often arises between the last two terms of this equation , so that for large and , the values of decline exponentially with according to eq . ( [ eq : j_n_lownb ] ) . starting with initial values prescribed by eq . ( [ eq : j_n_ident ] ) , this technique is stable to upward recurrence in for any , the range of arguments appropriate for the cyclotron problem . this quickly yields suitably precise values ( numerically tested for ) for a range of indices required in the series summations that appear in the cyclotron rates and powers , for example in eqs . ( [ eq : gammave_st_red ] ) and ( [ eq : knb_alt_too ] ) . the use of this recurrence becomes superfluous typically for , since such indices are generally required only in the classical cyclotron limit when , and the asymptotic limit in eq . ( [ eq : j_n_lownb ] ) is then the preferred computational tool . now focusing on asymptotics issues , two limiting values of are required for the analysis in sec . [ sec : st_analytic ] . the limit is routinely derived , and is listed in eq . ( [ eq : j_n_lownb ] ) . since , the other limiting domain is . this is a somewhat more involved case . by inspection of eq . ( [ eq : j_n_series ] ) , as , the logarithmic terms approach zero since . the legendre polynomials thus simplify to approximately unity , to leading order , and it follows that in the neighborhood of , @xmath66 defines the leading order terms to the taylor series expansion . insertion in eq . ( [ eq : inb_alt_too ] ) then yields @xmath67 correct to order . here , is the incomplete gamma function , and can be introduced using the series identity 8.354.1 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) . another identity required for the development of eq . ( [ eq : gammave_highnb_too ] ) pertains to the evaluation of for large . for low values of , say , one can use 8.352.1 of gradshteyn & ryzhik ( 1980 ) , namely @xmath68 as an efficient series evaluation for either the or incomplete gamma functions . for larger , one can appeal to the identity , together with stirling s expansion and identity 6.5.25 of abramowitz & stegun ( 1965 ) , namely , to establish the results @xmath69 retaining the next order contributions to and then yields corrections of approximately to the two ratios in eq . ( [ eq : gamma_inc_limit ] ) . abramowitz , m. & stegun , i. a. 1965 , _ handbook of mathematical functions _ , ( dover , new york ) . baring , m. g. 2000 , , @xmath7062 , 016003 . bekefi , g. 1966 , _ radiation processes in plasmas _ , ( wiley and sons , new york ) bussard , r. w. , alexander , s. b. & mszros , p 1986 , , @xmath7034 , 440 . bjorken , j. d. & drell , s. d. 1964 , _ relativistic quantum mechanics _ , ( mcgraw - hill , new york ) burchnall , j. l. & chaundy , t. w. 1941 , quarterly j. math.,@xmath7012 , 112 . daugherty , j. k. & ventura , j. 1978 , , @xmath7018 , 1053 . daugherty , j. k. & harding , a. k. 1986 , , @xmath70309 , 362 . daugherty , j. k. & harding , a. k. 1989 , , @xmath70336 , 861 . dermer , c. d. 1990 , , @xmath70360 , 197 . duncan , r. c. & thompson , c. 1992 , , @xmath70392 , 9 . exton , h. 1976 , _ multiple hypergeometric functions and applications _ , ( ellis horwood ltd . , chichester ) . geprgs , r. , riffert , h. , herold , h. , ruder , h. & wunner , g. 1994 , , @xmath7049 , 5582 . gradshteyn , i. s. and ryzhik , i. m. 1980 , _ table of integrals , series and products _ , ( academic press , new york ) . graziani , c. 1993 , , @xmath70412 , 351 . graziani , c. , harding , a. k. & sina , r. 1995 , , @xmath7051 , 7097 . harding , a. k. & preece , r. d. 1987 , , @xmath70319 , 939 . harding , a. k. & daugherty , j. k. , 1991 , , @xmath70374 , 687 . herold , h. , ruder , h. & wunner , g. 1982 , , @xmath70115 , 90 . johnson , m. h. , & lippmann , b. a. 1949 , phys . rev.,@xmath7076 , 828 . kozlenkov , a. a. & mitrofanov , i. g. 1986 , , @xmath7064 , 1173 . langer , s. h. 1981 , , @xmath7023 , 328 . latal , h. g. 1986 , , @xmath70309 , 372 . manchester , r. n. et al . 2001 , , @xmath70328 , 17 . melrose , d. b. & parle , a. j. 1983 , aust . j. phys . , @xmath7036 , 755 . melrose , d. b. & russell , k. 2002 , j. phys . a : math . gen.,@xmath7035 , 135 . melrose , d. b. & zheleznyakov , v. v. 1981 , , @xmath7095 , 86 . parle , a. j. 1987 , aust . j. phys . , @xmath7040 , 1 . pavlov , g. g. , bezchastnov , v. g. , mszros , p. & alexander , s. g. , 1991 , , @xmath70380 , 541 . sokolov , a. a. , zhukovskii , v. ch . & nikitina , n. s. 1973 , phys . lett.,@xmath7043a , 85 . sokolov , a. a. & ternov , i. m. 1968 , synchrotron radiation , ( pergamon press , oxford ) . wasserman , i. & salpeter , e. 1980 , , @xmath70241 , 1107 . white , d. 1974 , , @xmath709 , 868 .
Abstract: | [
"cyclotron decay and absorption rates have been well studied in the literature , focusing primarily on spectral , angular and polarization dependence . astrophysical applications usually do not require retention of information on the electron spin state , and these are normally averaged in obtaining the requisite rates . in magnetic fields , higher order quantum processes such as compton scattering become resonant at the cyclotron frequency and its harmonics , with the resonances being formally divergent . such divergences are usually eliminated by accounting for the finite lifetimes of excited landau states . this practice requires the use of spin - dependent cyclotron rates in order to obtain accurate determinations of process rates very near cyclotronic resonances , the phase space domain most relevant for certain applications to pulsar models . this paper develops previous results in the literature to obtain compact analytic expressions for cyclotron decay rates / widths in terms of a series of legendre functions of the second kind ; these expressions can be expediently used in astrophysical models . the rates are derived using two popular eigenstate formalisms , namely that due to sokolov and ternov , and that due to johnson and lippmann . these constitute two sets of eigenfunctions of the dirac equation that diagonalize different operators , and accordingly yield different spin - dependent cyclotron rates . this paper illustrates the attractive lorentz transformation characteristics of the sokolov and ternov formulation , which is another reason why it is preferable when electron spin information must be explicitly retained ."
] | 10,582 | 10,582 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: despite significant advancement over the last two decades , the galactic center magnetosphere is still not well understood ; however , determining the geometry and strength of the magnetic field in this region is crucial to developing an understanding of the dynamics of the galactic center . one reason that the magnetosphere is of interest lies in the galactic center s role as an active galactic nucleus . in the central engines of galaxies , magnetic fields are believed to be important in angular momentum transport and jet dynamics . the most striking evidence for the existence of magnetic fields in the galactic center is the existence of the non - thermal filaments ( ntfs ) of the galactic center radio arc ( gcra ) @xcite . radio polarization measurements have confirmed the synchrotron nature of the emission from these filaments and support the notion that the filaments trace magnetic field lines @xcite . almost all of the confirmed ntfs that have been discovered in the galactic center region are aligned with their long axes within 20@xmath1 of perpendicular to the plane of the galaxy @xcite . the presence of these filaments has led to the idea that these filaments trace the inner part of a dipole or _ poloidal _ magnetic field . in many cases ntfs are observed to be interacting with galactic center molecular clouds . the best example of this is in the center of the gcra where the 25 km s@xmath0 molecular cloud associated with g0.18 - 0.04 ( the sickle ) is coincident with the filaments @xcite . the lack of observed distortion of the filaments allows one to set a lower limit for the strength of the magnetic field . this argument yields @xmath2 @xcite . the association of molecular clouds with ntfs gives additional evidence for the dynamical importance of these fields and has motivated the idea that the generation of the relativistic electrons required to create these ntfs could occur as a result of a molecular cloud / magnetic flux tube interaction . the specific mechanism thought to be responsible for the generation of these relativistic electrons is magnetic reconnection between the fields in the flux tube and those in the cloud ( @xcite ; for a review , see @xcite ) . magnetically aligned dust grains are known to emit polarized radiation in the far - infrared and submillimeter . thus , polarimetry at these wavelengths has proven to be a reliable technique for measuring the projected , line - of - sight integrated magnetic field configuration . previous polarimetry data have shown that the field in the dense molecular clouds is not generally consistent with the poloidal field traced by the filaments . @xcite have shown that in the molecular cloud m-0.13 - 0.08 , the field is nearly parallel to the galactic plane , indicating that gravitational rotation and infall have sheared out the field into a _ toroidal _ configuration . in addition , 60 @xmath3 m polarimetry of the molecular cloud associated with the sickle indicates that the field in this region is parallel to the galactic plane @xcite . @xcite have constructed a model that connects poloidal and toroidal fields . because the magnetic flux is frozen into the matter , differential rotation and infall can shear an initially poloidal field into a toroidal one in sufficiently dense regions of the galactic center . @xcite have shown that on large scales , the dust in the central molecular zone ( cmz ) of the galaxy is permeated by a field that is oriented in a direction parallel to the plane of the galaxy . they compare their observation to the spatial distribution of the direction of faraday rotation in the galactic center and show that these two different techniques for sampling fields yield results that are consistent with such a model . we extend the ideas that underlie the above model to the inner 30 parsecs of the galactic center . when resolved with sub - arcminute resolution in the submillmeter @xcite , this region exhibits a clumpiness resulting from spatial density variations . we find that in less dense regions , the magnetic field that permeates the dust is poloidal , consistent with that found in the filaments . in these regions , the matter density is too low for gravity to shear the field into a toroidal configuration . in the dense molecular clouds , however , the field appears to be generally toroidal , indicating that in such regions , the energy density of gravity dominates that of the permeating magnetic field . section 2 describes the observations . in section 3 , the data are discussed . finally , conclusions are presented in section 4 . the data were obtained using the university of chicago 32-pixel polarimeter , hertz @xcite at the caltech submillimeter observatory on mauna kea , hawaii in april of 2001 . the beam size of hertz is 20fwhm with a pixel spacing of 18 . the central wavelength of the hertz passband is 350 @xmath3 m with a @xmath4 of 0.1 . the observing technique used with hertz involves a combination of high frequency `` chopping '' in which the array footprint is alternately pointed at the source and a reference position 6 away in cross - elevation and low frequency `` nodding '' during which the source is alternately placed in the right and left beams of the telescope . one undesirable complication that this observational scheme introduces is the problem of polarized flux in the reference beam . this problem is discussed in detail in [ sec : refbeam ] . for a full description of the observing and analysis procedures see @xcite and @xcite . during the observations , a total of 158 new polarization measurements were obtained having a polarimetric signal - to - noise greater than 3 . these data are given in tables 1 through 7 . the magnetic field vectors inferred from these data are shown in blue in region iii of figure [ fig : scuba ] . the black vectors in this region are those from @xcite . also shown in this figure are 100 @xmath3 m data from the kuiper airborne observatory @xcite of the arched filaments ( region ii ) and 60 @xmath3 m data @xcite of the sickle ( region i ) . the 100 @xmath3 m and 50 @xmath3 m data have beam sizes of 35@xmath5 and 22@xmath5 , respectively . the contours trace 850 @xmath3 m flux @xcite . major molecular features are labeled . the molecular cloud m-0.13 - 0.08 ( commonly called the 20 km s@xmath0 cloud ) has an elongated shape , and its long axis is oriented at a shallow ( 15@xmath1 ) angle to the galactic plane ( see fig . [ fig : scuba ] ) . the cloud is thought to be located in front of the galactic center since it appears in absorption in the mid - infrared @xcite . in projection , the long axis of this cloud points in the direction of sgr a*. this fact suggests that this cloud is undergoing a gravitational shear as it falls toward sgr a*. this is supported by other observations including a high velocity gradient along the long axis @xcite , increasing line widths and temperatures along the cloud in the direction of sgr a * @xcite , and an extension of the cloud detected in nh@xmath6 emission to within 30@xmath7 of sgr a * in projection @xcite . @xcite have discovered that the magnetic field structure is such that the field is parallel to the long axis of the cloud . they point out that for gravitationally sheared clouds , a consequence of flux - freezing is that regardless of the initial configuration of the field , the field will be forced into a configuration in which it is parallel to the long axis of the cloud . in addition , these authors note that this is not only true for the dense material inside of the cloud , but also for the more diffuse molecular material that belongs to the ambient region . they note that the southern end of this cloud exhibits a flare both morphologically and in magnetic field structure . they suggest that this flare is a connection to the large scale poloidal field traced by the ntfs . our 7 new vectors in this region provide additional support for this interpretation , but a more extensive polarimetric mapping of this cloud is necessary before a complete interpretation is made . the h ii region g0.18 - 0.04 ( commonly called the `` sickle '' ) can be seen in 20 cm thermal emission in figure [ fig:20 cm ] . it is believed to be the ionized surface of a molecular cloud that is interacting with the radio arc @xcite . its molecular counterpart can be seen in figure [ fig : cs]b . it has been suggested that this interaction is responsible for producing the relativistic electrons necessary to light up the radio arc via magnetic reconnection @xcite . the relationship between the geometry of the cloud and its magnetic field structure is similar to that of m-0.13 - 0.08 . the cloud is elongated parallel to the plane of the galaxy and its magnetic field as inferred from far - infrared polarimetry is parallel to the long axis . these similarities to m-0.13 - 0.08 suggest a similar origin of the field geometry . one difference between this cloud and m-0.13 - 0.08 is that in the case of the former there is no observed flaring of the field . in fact , the stark 90@xmath1 difference between the toroidal field observed in the molecular material and the pristine poloidal geometry of the superposed radio arc suggest that there is little connection between the toroidal field and the poloidal field in this vicinity . there are several possibilities for why this might be the case . first , the polarimetry coverage may be too limited in this region . more data taken in surrounding region may reveal a connection to a poloidal field . second , this cloud may be more evolved than m-0.13 - 0.08 , and so we may be observing a magnetic field that has had enough time to shear into a more parallel configuration than that of m-0.13 - 0.08 . finally , because this molecular cloud is farther from the dynamical center of the galaxy than is m-0.13 - 0.08 , the tidal forces on it are weaker , thus allowing for a more uniform shearing along its length . m+0.11 - 0.08 and m+0.07 - 0.08 are two peaks of a molecular cloud complex that , like m-0.13 - 0.08 and the molecular cloud associated with the sickle , is elongated nearly parallel to the plane with its long axis pointed toward sgr a*. the radial velocity of this complex has been measured to be @xmath850 km s@xmath0 ( see fig . [ fig : cs]c ) . the inferred magnetic field configuration for this complex displays a geometry that is quite unique . the field appears to tightly wrap around the southern and eastern edges of this cloud . the implication of this curvature of the magnetic field is that the cloud is moving toward the sgr a * region in projection and is sweeping up magnetic flux from the intercloud medium . the direction of travel inferred from the polarization data indicates that in projection , this cloud is moving toward a region dominated by a poloidal field ( see northeast side of m-0.02 - 0.07 in fig . [ fig : scuba ] ) . as the cloud moves through the less dense intercloud medium , this poloidal flux then is wrapped around the cloud into a toroidal configuration as seen along the eastern edge of the cloud . the result is an observed transition between poloidal and toroidal fields . interior to this cloud complex , there are few measurements ; however , those that exist hint at a field that is parallel to its long axis , similar to that of m-0.13 - 0.08 and the molecular cloud associated with the sickle . the 350 @xmath3 m polarimetric observations of m-0.02 - 0.07 , the cnd , and co+0.02 - 0.02 provide evidence for a magnetic field structure that is contiguous with that derived from the 100 @xmath3 m polarimetric observations of the arched filaments to form an `` x - shaped '' feature that we will refer to as the `` x polarization feature . '' the feature extends ( in the coordinate system of fig . [ fig : scuba ] ) from ( -1 , 13 ) down through ( 5 , 0 ) . the organization of the magnetic field vectors appears to be on scales ( 30 pc ) significantly larger than those of typical galactic center molecular clouds ( 5 - 10 pc ) . this fact reinforces the notion that the vectors trace a single global field that is subject to environmental forces . it is likely that the x polarization feature is a line - of - sight superposition of regions of poloidal and toroidal fields . the orientation of the observed magnetic field at any given location depends on the relative polarized emission from poloidal and toroidal regions that intersect the line of sight . for example , the poloidal field is seen to dominate in the eastern part of the m-0.02 - 0.07 cloud and at the western edge of the arched filaments . the toroidal field dominates at the eastern edge of the arched filaments and around the cnd . the two fields mix in co+0.02 - 0.02 . another example of line - of - sight mixing of poloidal and toroidal fields occurs at the western edge of the arched filaments . here , there exist several magnetic field vectors oriented perpendicular to the plane that are in close proximity to the g0.08 + 0.15 , a ntf that traces the poloidal field . just to the north , the magnetic field vectors return quite abruptly to a toroidal configuration in the vicinity of the molecular features that correspond to the arched filaments . it is possible that the molecular material at @xmath9 km s@xmath0 ( see fig . [ fig : cs]a ) is displaced along the line of sight from g0.08 + 0.15 , and the net polarization observed consists of contributions from dust associated with the respective neighborhoods of these two features . to the south of g0.08 + 0.15 , the vectors again become indicative of a field distorted by gravity as they wrap around the molecular cloud visible in figure [ fig : cs]d . figure [ fig : pvf ] shows the relationship between galactic center polarization measured by hertz versus the 350 @xmath3 m flux measured by sharc , a 350 @xmath3 m photometer with a 15@xmath5 beam @xcite . a linear fit gives a slope of -0.67 . in this plot , we have included all points with a polarization signal - to - noise ( s / n ) greater than 3 and have corrected the polarization by @xmath10 in order to account for the systematic overestimation of polarization @xcite inherent in the conversion from @xmath11 and @xmath12 to @xmath13 and @xmath14 . figure [ fig : pvf ] shows a depolarization effect associated with an increase in 350 @xmath3 m flux . because of a concern over a selection effect that systematically excludes low polarizations at low fluxes , the test was repeated with a s / n cutoff of 1 . for this case , the slope decreases to -0.73 , thus exonerating figure [ fig : pvf ] of this effect . the test was repeated for the 11 individual hertz pointing corresponding to both this work and that of @xcite . a polarization versus flux comparison using the relative fluxes obtained simultaneously with the polarizations gives an average slope of [email protected] . this number is the mean of the slopes for each of the 11 fields . the error is the standard deviation of these slopes . these numbers are similar to the values found by @xcite for various galactic molecular clouds . @xcite suggest three possibilities for the depolarization effect ( see also @xcite and @xcite ) . first , the lower polarization could be due to poor grain alignment or low polarization efficiency in the cores of these clouds . second , the depolarization could be a result of a geometrical cancellation of the front and back of a three dimensional field that is threaded through the optically thin cloud . finally , it is possible that the spatial structure of the magnetic fields in the cores of clouds is too small to be resolved by hertz s beam . the evidence for depolarization in the galactic center does not provide enough information to differentiate among the three proposed explanations ; however , it does indicate that the depolarization effect is observable in clouds that are a factor of @xmath810 larger than molecular clouds in the disk of the galaxy . historically the lack of information concerning the degree of grain alignment and relative strength of the line - of - sight component of the magnetic field have limited the ability of far - infrared and submillimeter polarimetry to provide information concerning the strengths of magnetic fields . we will show that in the galactic center the additional information concerning magnetic fields ( i.e. the ntfs ) can lead to a model - based estimate of a characteristic global magnetic field strength estimate . in studying the magnetic field in the central 30 pc of the galaxy , we revisit the model of @xcite as it applies to the galactic center . specifically , we keep in mind that the galactic center is clumpy and that some regions seem to contain a field that is poloidal while others contain a field that is toroidal . in the spirit of this model , we adopt a picture in which gravity is assumed to dominate the dynamics in regions of toroidal fields . conversely , in regions of poloidal fields , magnetic fields are assumed to be energetically dominant . figure [ fig : phiflux ] illustrates the dependence of the polarization angle on the flux measured by sharc @xcite . in this figure , the absolute deviation from a poloidal field ( @xmath16 ) is plotted against 350 @xmath3 m flux . this relationship shows that for regions having higher flux ( and thus higher column densities ) , the field is toroidal and the dynamics are gravity - dominated . for lower intensities , poloidal fields are observed indicating that there are regions of low density in which the dynamics are dominated by the energy density associated with the magnetic field . somewhere between these two extremes is a flux for which the energy density of the poloidal field equals that of the gravitational energy density . in order to proceed with the estimate , we will assume that this density corresponds to a measured angle @xmath17 . this choice is somewhat arbitrary . in order to find the flux corresponding to this angle , we perform various binnings as shown in figure [ fig : binned ] . linear fits to each of these four plots give a flux of 125 jy beam@xmath0 . to a crude approximation , this energy balance condition is represented by @xmath18 here , the kinetic energy density of material orbiting in the gravitational potential well of the galaxy is equated to the magnetic energy density . the key to this problem now becomes the estimate of @xmath19 and @xmath20 . the velocity , @xmath20 , can be estimated from typical cloud velocities @xcite and is expected to be between @xmath21 km s@xmath0 . the density can be determined as follows . the brightness one observes from a thermal source having an optical depth @xmath22 is @xmath23 where @xmath24 is the planck function . in the case of 350 @xmath3 m observations , the optical depth is generally small . for @xmath25 , @xmath26 sharc measures @xmath27 , the flux of the incoming radiation where @xmath28 is the solid angle subtended by a sharc array element . from these equations , it is possible to express the optical depth of the dust as a function of temperature and measured flux . @xmath29 alternatively , we can express the optical depth as a function of grain properties along the line of sight . once again we are working in the limit @xmath25 . we can imagine a column of dust along the line of sight that extends through the entire depth of the galactic center . the optical depth is proportional to the number density of dust grains along the line of sight ( @xmath30 ) . it is also proportional to the typical geometrical cross - section of each of the grains ( @xmath31 ) ; however , since the grain sizes are generally much smaller than the wavelenth of the radiation , the efficiencies of the grains for emitting , scattering or absorbing light are much lower than this blackbody approximation indicates . thus we write the optical depth as @xmath32 where @xmath33 is the emissivity of the dust grains and is generally much less than unity for submillimeter radiation . once the @xmath30 is found , the total dust mass observed by a sharc beam is @xmath34 here , @xmath35 is the distance to the source and @xmath36 is simply the physical size of sharc s beam at a distance @xmath35 . @xmath37 and @xmath38 are the density and volume of a dust grain , respectively . if we then make the appropriate substitutions and assume a gas - to - dust ratio , @xmath39 , we get the following expression for the total mass . @xmath40 putting in the appropriate numbers for 350 @xmath3 m radiation yields @xmath41 the density can be calculated by assuming a value for the depth of the dust layer ( @xmath42 ) . @xmath43 we use the following grain properties @xcite for our grain model . these are @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , and @xmath47 . in addition , pierce - price , et al . ( 2000 ) have used scuba to map the central molecular zone ( cmz ) at 450 and 850 @xmath3 m . they have found the dust temperature to be relatively uniform over the cmz and adopt a value of 20 k. with these numbers , one can get an estimate of the magnetic field strength as a function of velocity of the material and the thickness of the dust . @xmath48 based on cs measurements of the cmz @xcite , most molecular material has v @xmath49 150 km s@xmath0 . the cmz has a projected diameter of 200 pc . assuming cylindrical symmetry , this is approximately the scale of the material along the line of sight . because of the clumpy nature of the central 30 pc , this value @xmath42 is most likely overestimated , thereby making the above estimate of @xmath50 conservatively low . in performing differential measurements using chopping techniques , polarized flux in the reference beam positions is always a potential hazard . because of the extended nature of the dust in the galactic center , it is of particular importance to understand the possible effect of reference beam contamination on the data presented here . several attempts have been made to quantify this issue @xcite . the goal of this section is to assess the level of reference beam contamination in our data . note that throughout this analysis quantities pertaining to the `` reference beam '' such as @xmath51 and @xmath52 refer to the average of these quantities over the multiple reference beam positions used in the observations . since the quantitative result of this work centers on the relationship shown in figure [ fig : phiflux ] , we are concerned primarily with the polarization angle ( @xmath14 ) , and so we wish to estimate the maximum effect of polarized flux in the reference beam on @xmath14 . the difference between the source polarization angle ( @xmath53 ) and that measured ( @xmath54 ) is given by @xcite as @xmath55 . \label{eq : rberr}\ ] ] here , @xmath51 is the polarization in the reference beam , @xmath56 is the difference between the measured polarization angle and the polarization angle of the reference beam ( @xmath57 ) , and @xmath58 is the ratio of flux in the reference beam to that measured for a given source ( @xmath59 ) . alternatively , since @xmath60 , @xmath58 can be expressed as @xmath61 . here , @xmath62 is the intrinsic source flux . it is desirable to estimate the maximum effect the reference beam contamination could have on these measurements . specifically , we wish to understand how reference beam contamination could affect the results shown in figures [ fig : phiflux ] and [ fig : binned ] . to do this we need to find @xmath58 , @xmath63 , @xmath64 , and @xmath65 . we find from the scuba survey @xcite , the average ratio of the flux in the main beams of our six sources to that in the reference beams is @xmath66=1.9 . this leads to @xmath67 . the average 350 @xmath3 m polarization measured by hertz in the galactic center is 1.9 % . thus , we assign @xmath68 . finally , we need to make an estimate of @xmath64 and @xmath65 , the quantities describing the polarization properties of the reference beam flux . to do this , we note that @xcite have mapped the central molecular zone(cmz ) in 450 @xmath3 m polarimetry . they find the average polarization into a 6@xmath69 beam is 1.4 % and that the field is uniformly toroidal . because they use a 30@xmath69 chop throw , their reference beam is well off of the cmz and the contamination should be negligible . ignoring any wavelength dependence , we set @xmath70=0.014 and @xmath71=-58.4@xmath1 , the polarization angle that corresponds to a toroidal field . the difference between the measured and actual polarization angle ( @xmath72 ) under the above assumptions is plotted versus measured polarization angle ( @xmath54 ) in figure [ fig : ccurve ] . the maximum error in ( @xmath72 ) is @xmath1520@xmath1 . note that the amplitude of this error is independent of the chosen value of @xmath71 since the curve simply shows the error in the measured polarization angle as a function of the difference between the measured polarization angle and the reference beam polarization angle . ( in this case , we have set the reference beam polarization angle to an `` arbitrary '' value . ) the potential error induced by reference beam contamination is systematically about twice that of our maximum allowable statistical error . ( a signal - to - noise ratio of 3 implies @xmath73 . ) though this is potentially large , it is not large enough to cause poloidal fields to be measured as toroidal and vice - versa . therefore , it is unlikely that the relationship shown in figures [ fig : phiflux ] and [ fig : binned ] is caused by reference beam contamination . we can quantitatively estimate the potential effect of reference beam contamination on the data . this histogram in figure [ fig : ccurve ] shows the number of measurements having a polarization angle in each of the 10@xmath1 bins . as an unfortunate coincidence , the error is not symmetric with respect to our data and thus it is expected that there will be a bias in our field strength estimate . we have applied this correction to the data and the resulting @xmath14 v. @xmath74 plots have the same basic appearance ; however the equilibrium point once the correction is applied is 168@xmath152 jy ( sharc beam)@xmath0 . this implies a 30 % increase in our magnetic field strength estimate . it must be noted that because the large scale field in the galactic center has been found to be toroidal by @xcite , it is possible that a significant amount of dust is present along the line of sight to the central 30 pc that is permeated by this toroidal field and will emit polarized radiation accordingly . in this case , the large scale contribution to the polarized flux can be modeled by a uniform sheet of polarized flux . in this case , chopping can be an advantage in observing magnetic fields in the central 30 pc as it removes the contribution from a uniform field in the foreground and background dust . this model may also explain the lack of polarization measurements by @xcite in the central 30 pc in regions where hertz sees a poloidal field . because of the 6chop , hertz may be sampling a smaller volume along the line of sight than that of @xcite . in the latter case , line - of - sight superposition of the uniform sheet and the polarized emission detected by hertz may cancel , resulting in unpolarized radiation . as described above , submillimeter and far - infrared polarimetry provides an additional method for estimating the magnetic field strength at the galactic center , a quantity that has proven to be controversial . @xcite have argued that the magnetic field strength must exceed @xmath81 mg in order to maintain the linearity of the ntfs . on the other hand , @xcite have derived fields of 10 - 100 @xmath3 g for the arched filaments and the radio arc using faraday rotation measurements . using equipartition arguments , @xcite have found a field of the same order in the plumes that make up the extension of the radio arc on the eastern side of the galactic center lobe . more recently , zeeman splitting measurements have been done in the central 30 pc both using oh masers and h i emission @xcite . these studies show a line - of - sight field of a few mg . our estimate is in agreement with the notion that there is a pervasive mg field in the galactic center , thought obtaining a more accurate number will require a larger sample of polarization measurements with corresponding fluxes . it has been discovered that many of the ntfs in the galactic center are associated with molecular clouds @xcite . this has led to the suggestion that the source of the relativistic electrons in the ntfs is due to magnetic reconnection @xcite . the magnetic reconnection is believed to be precipitated by the collision of the cloud with a magnetic flux tube either by distorting the fields in the flux tube or by forcing these fields into contact with those in the cloud . in the galactic center , relatively diffuse molecular gas is supported by magnetic pressure ( fig . [ fig : model1]a ) ; however , this material is free to collapse along the field lines . as the gas collapses , gravitational energy becomes increasingly important . gravity can accelerate the cloud and the resulting differential motion between the material in the cloud and that of the ambient medium can begin to shear the magnetic field ( fig . [ fig : model1]b ) . this shear continues until the field is more toroidal than poloidal ( fig . [ fig : model1]c ) . note that the field external to the clouds is still quite poloidal because magnetic energy dominates the dynamics of this region . finally , if the gravitational energy is large enough , and the system is given the time to evolve , the oppositely - oriented fields in the center of the cloud may be squeezed together to enable reconnection . this process releases energy that can produce the relativistic electrons required to `` light up '' the filaments . submillimeter and far - infrared polarimetry in concert with radio and submillimeter photometric observations present a picture of molecular material of various sizes at various evolutionary stages according figure [ fig : model1 ] . from the polarimetry data in figure [ fig : scuba ] , we can see examples of each of the four panels in figure [ fig : model1 ] . the area to the north and east of m-0.02 - 0.07 is an example of the situation depicted in figure [ fig : model1]a . here , the molecular material is not very dense and the magnetic field is perpendicular to the galactic plane . an example of figure [ fig : model1]b is the molecular cloud complex containing m0.07 - 0.08 and m0.11 - 0.08 . here the field is seen to be shearing around the front edge of m0.07 - 0.08 , making a transition from poloidal to toroidal at the southern edge of the cloud . the 20 km s@xmath0 cloud ( m-0.13 - 0.08 ) is thought to be shearing out its magnetic field as it falls toward sgr a * @xcite . the flare seen at the southern end may indicate that it has not yet reached the point where magnetic reconnection is occurring and hence best matches figure [ fig : model1]c . the interaction of the sickle with the gcra gives the best example of figure [ fig : model1]d . here , the magnetic field in the molecular cloud is observed to be nearly perfectly aligned with the direction of both the long axis of the cloud and the galactic plane . filaments , namely those of the gcra , are observed , and appear to diffuse into g0.18 - 0.04 , the h ii region associated with this interaction . the clumpiness of the h ii region and the structure of the filaments themselves may stem from the irregularities of the interior of the cloud where reconnection takes place . it is possible that there are similar occurrences in places such as the arched filaments where there is also an observed transition from toroidal to poloidal fields adjacent to an ntf ( in this case , the northern thread ) . in order to test this idea with respect to other filaments and clouds in the galactic center , more complete polarimetric coverage of the central 30 parsecs is required . other scenarios for the explanation of the variety of fields in the central 30 pc can not yet be ruled out . winds produced by large explosions could be responsible for the poloidal fields seen in this region . however , there are several reasons to favor the association of the poloidal fields with a global field . first of all , the spatial proximity of the poloidal fields in the dust to the ntfs lends evidence to this association . second , the @xmath83 mg field strength we derive is consistent with lower limits of the field found in ntfs . third , to date we have not been able to locate any sources of a wind on large enough scales that couple to the magnetic field geometries observed . finally , we see transitions from poloidal to toroidal fields that correspond to dynamics of galactic center molecular clouds , indicating that these two fields have the same origin and that the initial configuration was poloidal . dowell , c. d. , lis , d. c. , serabyn , e. , gardner , m. , kovacs , a. , & yamashita , s. 1999 , in asp conference series 186 : the central parsecs of the galaxy , ed . h. falcke , a. cotera , w. duschl , f. melia , & m. rieke , 453465 pierce - price , d. , richer , j. s. , greaves , j. s. , holland , w. s. , jenness , t. , lasenby , a. n. , white , g. j. , matthews , h. e. , ward - thompson , d. , dent , w. r. f. , zykla , r. , mezger , p. , hasegawa , t. , oka , t. , omont , a. , & gilmore , g. 2000 , apj , 545 , l121 l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath76 & @xmath77 & @xmath78 & @xmath79 & @xmath80 + @xmath81 & @xmath76 & @xmath82 & @xmath83 & @xmath84 & @xmath85 + @xmath81 & @xmath86 & @xmath87 & @xmath88 & @xmath89 & @xmath90 + @xmath81 & @xmath91 & @xmath92 & @xmath93 & @xmath94 & @xmath95 + @xmath96 & @xmath75 & @xmath97 & @xmath98 & @xmath99 & @xmath100 + @xmath101 & @xmath75 & @xmath102 & @xmath103 & @xmath104 & @xmath105 + @xmath106 & @xmath81 & @xmath102 & @xmath107 & @xmath108 & @xmath109 + @xmath76 & @xmath110 & @xmath111 & @xmath112 & @xmath113 & @xmath109 + @xmath76 & @xmath75 & @xmath114 & @xmath115 & @xmath116 & @xmath117 + @xmath86 & @xmath75 & @xmath118 & @xmath112 & @xmath119 & @xmath120 + @xmath91 & @xmath75 & @xmath121 & @xmath122 & @xmath123 & @xmath124 + l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath125 & @xmath126 & @xmath127 & @xmath128 & @xmath129 + @xmath75 & @xmath96 & @xmath130 & @xmath131 & @xmath132 & @xmath133 + @xmath81 & @xmath75 & @xmath134 & @xmath135 & @xmath136 & @xmath85 + @xmath81 & @xmath81 & @xmath137 & @xmath138 & @xmath139 & @xmath140 + @xmath81 & @xmath125 & @xmath141 & @xmath142 & @xmath89 & @xmath143 + @xmath81 & @xmath144 & @xmath145 & @xmath146 & @xmath104 & @xmath147 + @xmath81 & @xmath96 & @xmath148 & @xmath142 & @xmath149 & @xmath100 + @xmath81 & @xmath101 & @xmath150 & @xmath151 & @xmath152 & @xmath153 + @xmath125 & @xmath75 & @xmath154 & @xmath155 & @xmath156 & @xmath157 + @xmath125 & @xmath81 & @xmath158 & @xmath159 & @xmath160 & @xmath133 + @xmath125 & @xmath125 & @xmath161 & @xmath107 & @xmath162 & @xmath163 + @xmath125 & @xmath144 & @xmath164 & @xmath165 & @xmath166 & @xmath167 + @xmath125 & @xmath96 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & @xmath170 & @xmath153 + @xmath125 & @xmath101 & @xmath171 & @xmath112 & @xmath172 & @xmath157 + @xmath125 & @xmath106 & @xmath121 & @xmath173 & @xmath174 & @xmath175 + @xmath144 & @xmath81 & @xmath161 & @xmath176 & @xmath177 & @xmath178 + @xmath144 & @xmath125 & @xmath179 & @xmath180 & @xmath181 & @xmath182 + @xmath144 & @xmath144 & @xmath183 & @xmath180 & @xmath184 & @xmath157 + @xmath144 & @xmath96 & @xmath185 & @xmath186 & @xmath187 & @xmath188 + @xmath144 & @xmath101 & @xmath130 & @xmath189 & @xmath190 & @xmath191 + @xmath144 & @xmath106 & @xmath192 & @xmath193 & @xmath194 & @xmath175 + @xmath96 & @xmath81 & @xmath195 & @xmath196 & @xmath197 & @xmath198 + @xmath96 & @xmath125 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & @xmath104 & @xmath201 + @xmath96 & @xmath144 & @xmath202 & @xmath203 & @xmath204 & @xmath120 + @xmath96 & @xmath96 & @xmath205 & @xmath159 & @xmath206 & @xmath207 + @xmath96 & @xmath101 & @xmath150 & @xmath138 & @xmath208 & @xmath147 + @xmath101 & @xmath81 & @xmath209 & @xmath142 & @xmath210 & @xmath211 + @xmath101 & @xmath125 & @xmath212 & @xmath213 & @xmath214 & @xmath188 + @xmath101 & @xmath144 & @xmath215 & @xmath200 & @xmath216 & @xmath182 + @xmath101 & @xmath96 & @xmath217 & @xmath218 & @xmath219 & @xmath220 + @xmath101 & @xmath101 & @xmath221 & @xmath127 & @xmath222 & @xmath223 + @xmath106 & @xmath125 & @xmath224 & @xmath225 & @xmath226 & @xmath90 + @xmath106 & @xmath144 & @xmath227 & @xmath122 & @xmath228 & @xmath163 + l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath144 & @xmath199 & @xmath229 & @xmath230 & @xmath231 + @xmath75 & @xmath101 & @xmath232 & @xmath233 & @xmath234 & @xmath235 + @xmath81 & @xmath96 & @xmath236 & @xmath180 & @xmath237 & @xmath100 + @xmath81 & @xmath101 & @xmath238 & @xmath103 & @xmath194 & @xmath95 + @xmath125 & @xmath81 & @xmath239 & @xmath98 & @xmath240 & @xmath167 + @xmath125 & @xmath144 & @xmath158 & @xmath241 & @xmath242 & @xmath243 + @xmath125 & @xmath101 & @xmath244 & @xmath241 & @xmath245 & @xmath246 + @xmath144 & @xmath101 & @xmath195 & @xmath241 & @xmath204 & @xmath247 + @xmath96 & @xmath81 & @xmath248 & @xmath200 & @xmath249 & @xmath95 + @xmath96 & @xmath144 & @xmath250 & @xmath196 & @xmath251 & @xmath231 + @xmath96 & @xmath96 & @xmath252 & @xmath253 & @xmath254 & @xmath246 + @xmath96 & @xmath101 & @xmath255 & @xmath115 & @xmath256 & @xmath85 + @xmath96 & @xmath106 & @xmath257 & @xmath151 & @xmath258 & @xmath95 + @xmath101 & @xmath81 & @xmath259 & @xmath196 & @xmath260 & @xmath247 + @xmath101 & @xmath125 & @xmath261 & @xmath262 & @xmath263 & @xmath264 + @xmath101 & @xmath144 & @xmath265 & @xmath266 & @xmath267 & @xmath268 + @xmath101 & @xmath96 & @xmath269 & @xmath176 & @xmath270 & @xmath182 + @xmath101 & @xmath101 & @xmath271 & @xmath233 & @xmath272 & @xmath273 + @xmath106 & @xmath81 & @xmath274 & @xmath193 & @xmath275 & @xmath85 + l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath125 & @xmath276 & @xmath277 & @xmath278 & @xmath279 + @xmath75 & @xmath144 & @xmath280 & @xmath281 & @xmath282 & @xmath129 + @xmath75 & @xmath96 & @xmath195 & @xmath283 & @xmath284 & @xmath285 + @xmath75 & @xmath101 & @xmath286 & @xmath266 & @xmath287 & @xmath288 + @xmath81 & @xmath125 & @xmath289 & @xmath283 & @xmath290 & @xmath288 + @xmath81 & @xmath96 & @xmath291 & @xmath292 & @xmath293 & @xmath285 + @xmath81 & @xmath101 & @xmath294 & @xmath295 & @xmath296 & @xmath297 + @xmath81 & @xmath106 & @xmath183 & @xmath298 & @xmath299 & @xmath279 + @xmath125 & @xmath81 & @xmath300 & @xmath295 & @xmath301 & @xmath302 + @xmath125 & @xmath125 & @xmath158 & @xmath283 & @xmath303 & @xmath304 + @xmath125 & @xmath144 & @xmath305 & @xmath306 & @xmath307 & @xmath308 + @xmath125 & @xmath96 & @xmath158 & @xmath253 & @xmath309 & @xmath198 + @xmath125 & @xmath101 & @xmath310 & @xmath311 & @xmath312 & @xmath304 + @xmath125 & @xmath106 & @xmath313 & @xmath176 & @xmath314 & @xmath302 + @xmath144 & @xmath81 & @xmath315 & @xmath306 & @xmath316 & @xmath317 + @xmath144 & @xmath125 & @xmath318 & @xmath277 & @xmath319 & @xmath320 + @xmath144 & @xmath144 & @xmath318 & @xmath277 & @xmath321 & @xmath191 + @xmath144 & @xmath96 & @xmath322 & @xmath107 & @xmath323 & @xmath167 + @xmath144 & @xmath101 & @xmath324 & @xmath103 & @xmath325 & @xmath147 + @xmath144 & @xmath106 & @xmath326 & @xmath189 & @xmath327 & @xmath178 + @xmath96 & @xmath75 & @xmath328 & @xmath165 & @xmath329 & @xmath198 + @xmath96 & @xmath81 & @xmath330 & @xmath200 & @xmath331 & @xmath332 + @xmath96 & @xmath125 & @xmath183 & @xmath266 & @xmath333 & @xmath268 + @xmath96 & @xmath144 & @xmath334 & @xmath98 & @xmath335 & @xmath167 + @xmath96 & @xmath96 & @xmath336 & @xmath241 & @xmath337 & @xmath297 + @xmath96 & @xmath101 & @xmath338 & @xmath339 & @xmath340 & @xmath273 + @xmath96 & @xmath106 & @xmath341 & @xmath342 & @xmath343 & @xmath188 + @xmath101 & @xmath81 & @xmath344 & @xmath229 & @xmath345 & @xmath105 + @xmath101 & @xmath125 & @xmath346 & @xmath347 & @xmath348 & @xmath211 + @xmath101 & @xmath96 & @xmath349 & @xmath138 & @xmath350 & @xmath285 + @xmath106 & @xmath144 & @xmath351 & @xmath352 & @xmath353 & @xmath223 + @xmath106 & @xmath96 & @xmath354 & @xmath102 & @xmath355 & @xmath178 + l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath81 & @xmath255 & @xmath262 & @xmath356 & @xmath188 + @xmath75 & @xmath125 & @xmath357 & @xmath358 & @xmath359 & @xmath360 + @xmath75 & @xmath144 & @xmath361 & @xmath362 & @xmath363 & @xmath364 + @xmath75 & @xmath96 & @xmath202 & @xmath362 & @xmath365 & @xmath366 + @xmath75 & @xmath101 & @xmath315 & @xmath277 & @xmath367 & @xmath285 + @xmath81 & @xmath75 & @xmath368 & @xmath213 & @xmath369 & @xmath105 + @xmath81 & @xmath81 & @xmath370 & @xmath295 & @xmath371 & @xmath372 + @xmath81 & @xmath125 & @xmath373 & @xmath358 & @xmath327 & @xmath374 + @xmath81 & @xmath144 & @xmath83 & @xmath375 & @xmath287 & @xmath120 + @xmath81 & @xmath96 & @xmath193 & @xmath362 & @xmath376 & @xmath167 + @xmath81 & @xmath101 & @xmath377 & @xmath292 & @xmath378 & @xmath379 + @xmath81 & @xmath106 & @xmath380 & @xmath213 & @xmath381 & @xmath157 + @xmath125 & @xmath75 & @xmath382 & @xmath169 & @xmath383 & @xmath188 + @xmath125 & @xmath125 & @xmath142 & @xmath384 & @xmath385 & @xmath386 + @xmath125 & @xmath96 & @xmath202 & @xmath281 & @xmath387 & @xmath264 + @xmath125 & @xmath101 & @xmath388 & @xmath283 & @xmath389 & @xmath390 + @xmath125 & @xmath106 & @xmath315 & @xmath159 & @xmath391 & @xmath105 + @xmath144 & @xmath75 & @xmath392 & @xmath393 & @xmath394 & @xmath157 + @xmath144 & @xmath81 & @xmath148 & @xmath200 & @xmath395 & @xmath191 + @xmath144 & @xmath125 & @xmath300 & @xmath292 & @xmath396 & @xmath397 + @xmath144 & @xmath144 & @xmath398 & @xmath292 & @xmath399 & @xmath360 + @xmath144 & @xmath96 & @xmath400 & @xmath277 & @xmath401 & @xmath402 + @xmath144 & @xmath101 & @xmath403 & @xmath180 & @xmath404 & @xmath379 + @xmath144 & @xmath106 & @xmath205 & @xmath169 & @xmath405 & @xmath406 + @xmath96 & @xmath125 & @xmath286 & @xmath306 & @xmath407 & @xmath408 + @xmath96 & @xmath144 & @xmath88 & @xmath203 & @xmath409 & @xmath410 + @xmath96 & @xmath96 & @xmath199 & @xmath196 & @xmath411 & @xmath191 + @xmath96 & @xmath101 & @xmath341 & @xmath218 & @xmath412 & @xmath320 + @xmath96 & @xmath106 & @xmath413 & @xmath414 & @xmath415 & @xmath117 + @xmath101 & @xmath125 & @xmath416 & @xmath298 & @xmath417 & @xmath246 + @xmath101 & @xmath144 & @xmath392 & @xmath213 & @xmath418 & @xmath207 + @xmath101 & @xmath96 & @xmath419 & @xmath189 & @xmath376 & @xmath317 + @xmath101 & @xmath101 & @xmath420 & @xmath421 & @xmath319 & @xmath80 + l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath125 & @xmath422 & @xmath289 & @xmath363 & @xmath124 + @xmath81 & @xmath125 & @xmath423 & @xmath233 & @xmath190 & @xmath95 + @xmath81 & @xmath144 & @xmath424 & @xmath425 & @xmath426 & @xmath85 + @xmath81 & @xmath101 & @xmath427 & @xmath428 & @xmath429 & @xmath175 + @xmath125 & @xmath75 & @xmath430 & @xmath138 & @xmath431 & @xmath80 + @xmath125 & @xmath81 & @xmath315 & @xmath203 & @xmath345 & @xmath140 + @xmath125 & @xmath125 & @xmath202 & @xmath311 & @xmath432 & @xmath153 + @xmath125 & @xmath144 & @xmath433 & @xmath218 & @xmath434 & @xmath85 + @xmath125 & @xmath96 & @xmath326 & @xmath435 & @xmath436 & @xmath386 + @xmath144 & @xmath75 & @xmath291 & @xmath103 & @xmath437 & @xmath211 + @xmath144 & @xmath81 & @xmath183 & @xmath283 & @xmath302 & @xmath167 + @xmath144 & @xmath144 & @xmath438 & @xmath295 & @xmath439 & @xmath211 + @xmath96 & @xmath75 & @xmath161 & @xmath241 & @xmath440 & @xmath406 + @xmath96 & @xmath125 & @xmath289 & @xmath283 & @xmath441 & @xmath288 + @xmath96 & @xmath106 & @xmath442 & @xmath193 & @xmath443 & @xmath124 + @xmath101 & @xmath81 & @xmath444 & @xmath445 & @xmath441 & @xmath406 + @xmath101 & @xmath125 & @xmath199 & @xmath200 & @xmath446 & @xmath397 + l c c c c c @xmath75 & @xmath96 & @xmath324 & @xmath241 & @xmath447 & @xmath163 + @xmath75 & @xmath101 & @xmath448 & @xmath165 & @xmath449 & @xmath211 + @xmath81 & @xmath81 & @xmath352 & @xmath298 & @xmath450 & @xmath386 + @xmath81 & @xmath106 & @xmath392 & @xmath229 & @xmath451 & @xmath120 + @xmath125 & @xmath101 & @xmath135 & @xmath452 & @xmath453 & @xmath374 + @xmath96 & @xmath75 & @xmath244 & @xmath138 & @xmath454 & @xmath455 + @xmath96 & @xmath81 & @xmath276 & @xmath295 & @xmath456 & @xmath374 + @xmath96 & @xmath125 & @xmath457 & @xmath384 & @xmath458 & @xmath140 + @xmath96 & @xmath144 & @xmath151 & @xmath384 & @xmath459 & @xmath406 + @xmath101 & @xmath81 & @xmath460 & @xmath186 & @xmath461 & @xmath188 + @xmath101 & @xmath125 & @xmath225 & @xmath281 & @xmath462 & @xmath463 + @xmath101 & @xmath96 & @xmath464 & @xmath311 & @xmath465 & @xmath243 + @xmath106 & @xmath144 & @xmath466 & @xmath241 & @xmath467 & @xmath100 +
Abstract: | [
"we report the detection of polarized emission in the vicinity of the galactic center for 158 positions within eight different pointings of the hertz polarimeter operating on the caltech submillimeter observatory . these pointings include positions 2 offset to the e , ne , and nw of m-0.02 - 0.07 ; positions to the se and nw of the 20 km s@xmath0 cloud ( m-0.13 - 0.08 ) , co+0.02 - 0.02 , m+0.07 - 0.08 , and m+0.11 - 0.08 . we use these data in conjunction with previous far - infrared and submillimeter polarization results to find that the direction of the inferred magnetic field is related to the density of the molecular material in the following way : in denser regions , the field is generally parallel to the galactic plane , whereas in regions with lower densities , the field is generally perpendicular to the plane . this finding is consistent with a model in which an initially poloidal field has been sheared into a toroidal configuration in regions that are dense enough such that the gravitational energy density is greater than the energy density of the magnetic field . using this model , we estimate the characteristic strength of the magnetic field in the central 30 pc of our galaxy to be a few mg ."
] | 8,135 | 8,135 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the observation of bose - einstein condensation ( bec ) in 1995 was the culmination of a series of experiments carried out with atomic neutral gases @xcite in which macroscopic samples of matter were cool down until quantum degeneracy was reached . as it is well known , the method of evaporative cooling was the essential technique to reach temperatures below the @xmath0k degrees , necessary for the realization of bec . this technique works in several stages by lowering the temperature at each step as highly energetic particles are removed from the system . condensation in macroscopic samples was finally attained at 150 nk at a density of 2.5 @xmath1 @xmath2 @xmath3 for @xmath4rb atoms @xcite , and below @xmath5 @xmath0k at a density of 1 @xmath1 @xmath6 @xmath3 for @xmath7na atoms @xcite . while there is well established knowledge of ground state and non - equilibrium properties of trapped bec , mostly within the hartree - fock - bogoliubov mean - field approach @xcite , those predictions are restricted to the very low temperature regime where the transition to bec has already occurred . thus , there is interest in describing the dynamics or kinetics of the formation of the condensate , taking into account the essential mechanism of atomic collisions that end up equilibrating the system once , say , a evaporative cooling step has been performed . the incorporation of collisional effect has been the main goal in all the formulated kinetic theories so far that describe the dynamics during the formation of a bose - einstein condensate @xcite . the present work is within such a dynamical description context and it is particularly concerned with the derivation , in the weak coupling limit and the markov approximations , of irreversible master equations for the one body reduced density matrix operator . to be precise , our aim is the description of the time evolution of the occupation numbers as the bec transition takes place . similarly to earlier kinetic formulations , @xcite we work in the born and markov approximations to straightforwardly derive irreversible master equations that describe the dynamics during the formation of a condensate . as we explain below , we have added the important contribution of bogoliubov to take into account the role played by the condensate below the transition temperature . we derive kinetic equations appropriate for temperatures @xmath8 and for @xmath9 . the equations describing the relaxation towards equilibrium for @xmath10 allow us to demonstrate that the ideal bose - einstein distribution with negative chemical potential is the stationary solution for both the ground and excited states , and that the total number of particles as well as the total energy are conserved along the thermalization of each cooling step . however , since this equation is unable of describing the dynamics for the ground and excited states when the chemical potential becomes zero , that is , for the dynamics below @xmath11 , we derive a novel kinetic equation to properly describe the evolution in time of a weakly interacting bose gas for @xmath12 . in particular , we consider the fact that when the chemical potential becomes zero , the particles in the separate ground and excited states are not conserved . thus , we propose to replace the interaction term of the master equation , accounting for every single collision event , by an interaction potential in which the colliding particles arising from the ground state are treated within the bogoliubov approximation @xcite . technically speaking , we shall consider that the creation and annihilation operators involving the ground state @xmath13 and @xmath14 can be substituted by @xmath15 , with @xmath16 the number of particles in the condensate . such a practice is well justified by the fact that the number of of particles in the ground state , when the chemical potential is zero , becomes macroscopic , i.e. @xmath17 and thus the matrix elements of the hamiltonian in the number - occupation states appear simply as @xmath15 . this procedure leads us to obtain a new kinetic equation for the particles in the excited states , exhibiting the correct limits . the equilibration after each cooling stage can thus be analyzed for all temperatures , above and below @xmath11 . for the numerical simulation of the kinetic equations we propose here a protocol of energetic cooling . this scheme consists of several cooling steps in which the temperature in the closed system is decreased while maintaining constant the number of particles . the temperature at each cooling step is lowered by transferring particles from higher energy levels and distributing them in levels with lower energy . interatomic collisions re - thermalize the gas to a lower temperature . in contrast with the evaporative cooling technique , this scheme prevents the system against decreasing the number of particles , yet , by reducing its energy , its density at the center of the trap increases and , thus , degeneracy can be reached . this protocol may represent an alternative route for the experimentalists to achieve the degeneration regime with a much larger number of atoms than usual . although it is not the purpose of this article , we suggest that the transferring to lower energy levels may be implemented by means of impulsive anti - stokes stimulated raman scattering @xcite with properly tailored ultrashort microwave pulses , similarly to techniques used with light in single - molecule wavepacket interferometry @xcite . this work is organized as follows . in section ii we present the derivation of the kinetic master equations describing the growth dynamics of the condensate for temperatures above and below the critical temperature defining the transition . in section iii we present numerical results that model the energetic cooling process as several stages are performed in a bosonic gas towards the formation of a condensate . finally , in section iv a summary of this work is given . as envisaged by einstein and stated in textbooks , there are two routes to achieve the condensation in a macroscopic system . one is by lowering the temperature and maintaining constant the density and the other is by increasing the density and keeping constant the temperature . the implementation of the first method requires to put the closed system in thermal contact with a reservoir at a lower temperature , wait for the system to reach thermal equilibrium and then repeat the scheme until the system reaches the transition temperature . the second route conceives an open system that increases its density being in contact with a reservoir at fixed temperature . as before , the system reaches an equilibrium state after a relaxation time , and again is placed in contact with a reservoir with larger chemical potential , as part of the sequence , until the transition is reached . it is important to note that both procedures ensure that the onset of condensation may be achieved in a reversible way . in practice none of these methods is performed in the laboratory . in actual experiments , the observation of the bec transition requires to perform several cooling stages in a thermally isolated bose gas , in which a given equilibrium state is perturbed reducing its energy ( and the number of atoms in evaporative cooling ) and then , by a necessarily irreversible process , the system reaches a new equilibrium state with a lower temperature . this cooling is repeated until the system attains the critical temperature @xmath11 at which the transition to condensation occurs . our aim in this work is to describe , through quantum kinetic equations , the dynamical process that takes place during the thermalization at each cooling step . to accomplish this goal in this section we derive the kinetic equations that describe the relaxation process towards the stationary or equilibrium state in each cooling step . as we shall see , such a description requires to take into account that the cooling process must be divided in two parts , one for temperatures above the critical temperature @xmath11 at which the gas is in the normal phase , and the other for temperatures below @xmath11 when the bec transition to occurs . the hamiltonian that describes the system consists of an ideal term @xmath18 that takes into account a isotropic harmonic confinement of the atoms , perturbed by a weakly interacting part @xmath19 that models the collisions among the particles . in a second quantization formalism these terms are : @xmath20 where @xmath21 are the eigenenergies of a single particle confined in a harmonic potential of frequency @xmath22 in three dimensions , @xmath23 . since the energy of each single particle is characterized by three quantum numbers @xmath24 , @xmath25 , and @xmath26 their corresponding quantum state is denoted as a vector @xmath27 . @xmath28 and @xmath29 are the operators that create and destroy particles in the state @xmath27 . in the expression for single particle energy @xmath21 we have omitted the ground state energy @xmath30 , and as we recall below , this fixes the bec transition at @xmath31 . writing @xmath32 the degeneracy of each energy is given by @xmath33 regarding the interacting term , we shall assume that the ultracold gas is very diluted and consequently only @xmath34-wave binary collisions are relevant for the dynamics@xcite . this two - body interaction can be modeled by a contact potential whose interaction strength is proportional to the @xmath34-wave scattering length @xmath35 , assumed positive throughout , @xmath36 here and henceforth we identify the transition amplitude elements of equation ( [ interac ] ) as @xmath37 : @xmath38 where @xmath39 . our starting point is the derivation , in the weak coupling limit and the markov approximation , of an irreversible master equation for the one body reduced density matrix operator@xcite . this is the quantum boltzmann equation for the operator @xmath40 that we define below . as it is well known , the essence of a boltzmann equation is to consider that collisions among the particles are responsible for driving the system towards thermal equilibrium . once in equilibrium every thermodynamic property depends on single particle properties only . having in mind this idea , we write first the expectation value of any @xmath41-body single particle operator @xmath42 in the occupation number representation : @xmath43 where @xmath44 is a one - body operator and @xmath45 is the density matrix of the whole system . the occupation numbers @xmath46 satisfy @xmath47 . from this expression we can identify the one body reduced density matrix operator @xmath48 : @xmath49 where @xmath50 we notice that by setting @xmath51 the one body reduced density matrix operator becomes the average occupation number in the state @xmath27 : @xmath52 in order to derive the quantum kinetic master equation for @xmath48 , and in particular the equation for the average occupation number @xmath53 , we start by considering the schrdinger equation for the full density matrix of the system , @xmath54 . \label{ecrho}\ ] ] after we substitute this equation into the resulting expression for the time derivative of equation ( [ gamma ] ) we obtain : @xmath55 \ } , \label{qkme}\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath56 . then , we substitute @xmath57 in equation ( [ qkme ] ) and we obtain , @xmath58 \ } + \frac{i}{\hbar } \text{tr } \ { \rho ( t ) \left [ v , \gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \}. \label{qkme2}\ ] ] to find an expression for the density matrix @xmath59 we work in the born approximation , where the perturbative character of the interaction term @xmath19 is considered . by keeping the first order of the interaction potential for @xmath45 we get : @xmath60,\ ] ] with @xmath61 . now , we insert this last expression for @xmath45 into the quantum kinetic equation ( [ qkme2 ] ) and we obtain : @xmath62 + \frac{i}{\hbar } \text{tr } \rho_g ( t ) \left [ v , \gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \nonumber\\ & + & \left(\frac{i}{\hbar}\right)^2 \int_0^t d\tau \text{tr } \ { \rho_g ( t ) \left [ e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } ve^{\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } , \left[h_0,\gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \right]\ } \\&+ & \left(\frac{i}{\hbar}\right)^2 \int_0^t d\tau \text{tr } \ { \rho_g ( t ) \left[e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } ve^{\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } , \left[v,\gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \right]\ } .\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to have the final form of the quantum kinetic master equation , we should take into account the markov approximation which consists in neglecting memory effects in the interacting kernel . such an approximation is directly related to the time scales involved in the collision integrals . in other words , we must compare the time scale during the relaxation process against the correlation time arising from the duration of a single collision . such comparison leads us to analyze the collision integrals on the right - hand side of the last equation . the elastic collision rate in @xmath4rb is approximately ten per second @xcite . let us denote by @xmath63 such an elastic collision rate . since the correlation time involved in a collision is much shorter than the time scale on which the system relaxes to equilibrium , we can extent the upper limit of the collision integrals . that is , if @xmath64 , @xmath65 thus , the kinetic equation takes the form : @xmath66 + \frac{i}{\hbar } \text{tr } \rho_g ( t ) \left [ v , \gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \nonumber\\ & + & \left(\frac{i}{\hbar}\right)^2 \int_0^{\infty } d\tau \text{tr } \ { \rho_g ( t ) \left [ e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } ve^{\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } , \left[h_0,\gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \right]\}\nonumber\\ & + & \left(\frac{i}{\hbar}\right)^2 \int_0^{\infty } d\tau \text{tr } \ { \rho_g ( t ) \left[e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } ve^{\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } , \left[v,\gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{j } } \right ] \right]\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is the irreversible master equation for the one body reduced density matrix operator @xmath67 from which collective phenomena that include the formation of vortex states and collective excitations can be treated@xcite . here we restrict our attention to the evolution in time of the average occupation number @xmath68 , that is , we consider @xmath69 in equation ( [ eccin - t ] ) @xmath70 \nonumber\\ & + & \left(\frac{i}{\hbar}\right)^2 \int_0^{\infty } d\tau \text{tr } \ { \rho_g ( t)\nonumber\\ & \times & \left[e^{-\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } ve^{\frac{i}{\hbar}h_0\tau } , \left[v,\gamma_{\vec{i } \vec{i } } \right ] \right]\}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] to evaluate the trace on the right - hand side of equation ( [ maineq ] ) we use wick s theorem to separate each collision term into products of one body reduced density matrix operators . then , after we substitute both , the ideal and interaction contributions given in ( [ ideal ] ) and ( [ interac ] ) respectively , and consider the summation over repeated indices we find : @xmath71 \nonumber\\ & + & 2 \text { } v_{\vec{i } \vec { \eta } \vec{l } \vec{i } } v_{\vec{k } \vec{l } \vec{k } \vec { \eta } } \text { } \delta _ { \epsilon_{\vec{\eta } } -\epsilon_{\vec{l } } } n_{\vec{i } } n_{\vec{k } } \left ( n_{\vec{l } } - n_{\vec{\eta } } \right ) \},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath72 is a dimensionless time . the terms in the sum on the right - hand side express the energy conservation through the kronecker delta - functions . since we are dealing with a closed system the total energy @xmath73 and the total number of particles @xmath41 must be conserved . by a simple substitution one can show that the stationary solution of equation ( [ eccin ] ) for both , the ground state , and the excited states , is the bose - einstein distribution @xmath74 - 1 } , \label{bed}\ ] ] where the temperature @xmath75 and the chemical potential @xmath0 can be obtained by imposing the associated normalization conditions on the total energy @xmath76 , and on the total number of particles @xmath77 . however , if we consider @xmath78 in the bose - einstein distribution ( [ bed ] ) and substitute it in on the right - hand side of equation ( [ eccin ] ) , we find that the left - hand side is zero if and only if @xmath79 . in other words , for finite temperatures @xmath80 , the ideal distribution for the excited states @xmath81 - 1 } , \label{bose - ex1}\ ] ] is not the stationary solution . this result is inconsistent with the fact that a non - uniform ideal bose gases can exhibit the bose - einstein transition in two and three dimensions . therefore , equation ( [ eccin ] ) can only be correct for @xmath10 where @xmath82 . here , we should emphasize that bec transition occurs in an ideal gas at at @xmath31 since the ground state energy @xmath83 has been neglected . from a theoretical point of view , the occurrence of the transition to bose - einstein condensation in an ideal gas depends on both , dimensionality and the confining potential where the atoms move @xcite . the combined aspects of dimensionality and isotropy , mathematically expressed in the density of states , determine if bec can occur in an ideal gas @xcite . a 2d ideal uniform bose gas does not exhibit bec , by contrast to the 2d harmonically trapped one . regarding the 3d case , both the homogeneous and the harmonically trapped gas can have the transition . however , on the experimental side where interactions participate , the ultracold atomic gases require to be confined in an external potential . since in the present work we are dealing with a harmonic potential , the ideal distribution ( [ bose - ex1 ] ) should be the stationary solution for the excited states below @xmath11 in 2d and 3d cases , that is , when chemical potential @xmath0 becomes zero . as mentioned above , however , this does not occur . at equilibrium , the ideal ditribution @xmath84 given by ( [ bose - ex1 ] ) does not satisfy eq . ( [ eccin ] ) for particles in the excited states unless @xmath79 . this result suggests that equation ( [ eccin ] ) is unable to describe the dynamics for temperatures below the critical temperature @xmath11 . therefore , taking into account the underlying physics , an alternative kinetic equation for @xmath78 and @xmath9 must be derived to properly describe the time evolution and equilibration of the gas . the most important property of a dilute bose gas that has experienced the transition to the condensate state is that as a result of having chemical potential equal to zero , the ground state becomes macroscopically populated . as a consequence of this fact the intensive thermodynamic variables , that adjust to the extensive ones , are exclusively determined by the particles occupying the excited states only . perhaps a most relevant effect when a bose gas has chemical potential equal to zero , is that the number of particles @xmath41 is no longer a thermodynamic variable . although in the whole system the number of particles @xmath41 remains constant , the number of particles in the ground and excited states separately are not conserved since there is no energy cost in adding particles from the excited to the ground state and viceversa since @xmath85 . therefore , if one looks at the isolated fractions of particles in the ground and excited states , a continuous process of creation and annihilation of particles ( having @xmath85 ) takes place in each one of them . the physical process exposed above has not been considered previously , neither in the treatments involving kinetic descriptions , nor in the present one depicted in section [ sectiona ] . that is , for temperatures below @xmath11 the non conservation of particles in the separated fractions of ground and excited states has not been considered properly in the derivation of the kinetic equations describing the relaxation to the equilibrium state . the binary collisions are the key element where the non conservation of particles can be taken into account . since such collisions are the elementary mechanism to reach thermal equilibrium and they involve particles in the ground and excited states , we must have special care in each collision event . up to now , each pair of particles coming from either the ground state , or the excited states , transform after the collision into a pair of particles that again can occupy the ground state or the excited states , in such a way that there is no distinction between the fractions of particles in the ground and excited states respectively . however , if we consider the fact stated in the above paragraph regarding the non conservation of particles in the separate ground and excited states , and that the occupation number in the ground state becomes macroscopic @xmath17 , we can proceed in a different way treating separately the ground state and the excited states . in particular , we can explicitly assume that below the critical temperature , the fraction of the particles in the excited states participating in the collision process is not conserved . this procedure lead us to derive a new kinetic equation for the excited states . then , by considering the fact that the _ total _ number of particles is conserved we can obtain the number of particles in the ground state by subtracting the particles in the excited states from the total number of particles @xmath41 . to model a process in which the number of particles in the excited states is not conserved , we first rewrite the interaction term given in equation ( [ interac ] ) including separately the ground and excited states : @xmath86 where we have made explicit the fact that the ground state is not included in the sums . to take into account that the dynamics in the excited states ( when @xmath31 ) is dictated with no constrains under conservation of the number of particles in such states , we propose to replace the interaction term given in equation ( [ full - int ] ) by @xmath87 in this expression we have replaced the creation and annihilation operators @xmath13 and @xmath14 by @xmath15 . this is the bogoliubov approximation @xcite . the aim behind such an assumption is to consider the macroscopic character of the particle population in the ground state @xmath16 for temperatures ranging below the critical temperature @xmath11 . taking the expectation value of any single - particle operator lead us obtain a quantity proportional to @xmath16 . to justify our suggestion let us consider one of terms of the interaction potential ( [ full - int ] ) , @xmath88 this term represents the anhilation of particles in the states @xmath89 and @xmath90 , and creation of particles in the states @xmath91 and @xmath92 . if such a term is substituted by @xmath93 the number of particles in the excited states is explicitly not conserved , although of course , the missing particle belongs to the ground state . in other words , every interaction term in which the ground state participates is now omitted and the total number of particles in the system is conserved . after the expression ( [ int - ex ] ) for the interaction potential is substituted in the master kinetic equation ( [ maineq ] ) we obtain : @xmath94 \nonumber\\ & & + 2 \text { } v_{{\vec i } { \vec \eta } { \vec l } { \vec i } } v_{{\vec k } { \vec l } { \vec k } { \vec \eta } } \text { } \delta _ { \epsilon_{\vec \eta } , \epsilon_{\vec l } } n_{\vec i } n_{\vec k } \left ( n_{\vec l } - n_{\vec \eta } \right ) \ } \nonumber\\ & & + n_{0}\sum_{{\vec k } { \vec i } \neq 0}v_{{\vec \eta}{\vec k}{\vec i } { \vec 0 } } ^2\ { \text { } 2\delta_{\epsilon_{\vec \eta}+\epsilon_{\vec i},\epsilon_{\vec k}}[n_{\vec k}(1+n_{\vec \eta}+n_{\vec i})-n_{{\vec i}}n_{\vec \eta}]\ } \nonumber\\ & & + \delta_{\epsilon_{\vec \eta},\epsilon_{\vec k } + \epsilon_{\vec i}}[n_{\vec i } n_{\vec k}-n_{\vec \eta}(1+n_{\vec k}+n_{\vec i})]+ \nonumber \\ & & + 2n_{{\vec 0}}^2\sum_{\vec{k}}\delta_{\epsilon_{\vec \eta},\epsilon_{\vec k } } v^2_{{\vec \eta}{\vec k}{\vec 0}{\vec 0}}(n_{\vec k}-n_{\vec \eta } ) .\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath95 being @xmath96 is the number of particles in the ground state . by substituting @xmath97 - 1 } , \label{bose - ex}\ ] ] one can show that this is the correct stationary solution of eq . ( [ eccin2 ] ) for the excited states , that is , the bose - einstein distribution for zero chemical potential . here the temperature @xmath75 can be obtained by imposing the associated normalization condition on the total energy @xmath98 . it is important to emphasize that eq . ( [ eccin2 ] ) for @xmath99 can be obtained in a direct way from eq . ( [ eccin ] ) , for @xmath100 , by separating the contributions of the ground and excited states , and considering that just those terms proportional to @xmath96 must be retained . that is , if in the separated sums of ground and excited states one neglects those terms in which the number of particles in the ground state does not appear , the derivation of the master equation is sensibly simplified . in the preceding section we derived the kinetic equations that model a weakly interacting bose gas confined in a harmonic potential under non - equilibrium conditions . these equations for the occupation numbers describe the thermalization process before and after the occurrence of a bec transition in the gas , eqs . ( [ eccin ] ) and ( [ eccin2 ] ) respectively . that is , for temperatures above the critical temperature @xmath11 where the chemical potential varies as temperature decreases , and for temperatures below @xmath11 where the chemical potential remains equal to zero . in this section we present numerical results that model the cooling process as several cooling stages are performed , both for @xmath101 and @xmath102 . while our goal is to show that the growth of a bec can be described via successive thermalization processes , solving numerically equations for @xmath82 and @xmath31 , ( [ eccin ] ) and ( [ eccin2 ] ) respectively , we shall also point out along the way the difficulties posed by a finite - size calculation . from now on we use dimensionless units @xmath103 . the frequency @xmath22 will also be used as a dimensionless value , however , as it will be specified we shall compare different cases by keeping constant the so - called generalized density @xmath104 , as indicated by the thermodynamic limit in gases harmonically confined @xcite . the sums over the states on the right hand side in the kinetic equations for @xmath82 and @xmath31 ( eqs . ( [ eccin ] ) and ( [ eccin2 ] ) ) extend to infinite , and therefore , an infinite number of coupled equations for the occupation numbers @xmath105 must , in principle , be solved . in a real situation , however , prior to the first cooling stage , the gas has been precooled by some other methods and the atoms in the bose gas do not occupy very high energy levels , namely , the ratio of their occupation numbers compared to those in the lowest levels is negligible . a simple calculation shows that for @xmath106 and a typical trap frequency @xmath107 hz , the maximum level occupied in the harmonic confinement corresponds to @xmath108 energy levels . in principle , considering such as the highest occupied level would be a good starting point for studying the dynamics of the condensation , and thus solving a finite number of equations . as we argue in the next paragraph , @xmath109 is still an unattainable situation . as we discuss below , we shall use @xmath110 as the maximum energy level and even this within the ergodic " approximation introduced in the following subsection . there are two numerical tasks that become impracticable as the highest energetic level in the sums of kinetic equations grows . one is the number of coupled kinetic equations that have to be solved and the other is the determination of the collision integrals @xmath111 . due to the degeneracy that grows with the energy level ( see eq . ( [ degeneracy ] ) ) , the number of coupled equations to be solved increases exponentially . for instance , for @xmath112 energy levels , there are @xmath113 states , while for @xmath114 one finds @xmath115 states , and thus , those are the number of non - linear coupled equations to solve in each case . on the other hand , since the right hand side of eqs . ( [ eccin ] ) and ( [ eccin2 ] ) involves an enormous number of sums , to be calculated at each time step , the calculation is even harder . for example , for @xmath114 , the number of operations per iteration is of the order of @xmath116 . we have estimated the time needed for this in a standard workstation , yielding of the order of @xmath117 seconds . this poses a very stringent restriction in the number of states ( and thus , levels ) that we can practically include . therefore , we shall adopt the ergodic assumption " proposed in ref . @xcite to deal with the dynamical description of the interacting bose gas . the basic idea of the ergodic assumption is that the number of particles in a state @xmath118 depends only on the energy of the state @xmath119 , with @xmath120 , just as in thermal equilibrium . we then write @xmath121 , namely asserting that states with the same energy have the same population . we recall that there are @xmath122 states with the same energy . to implement the ergodic hypothesis , we can consider that the initial state is one of thermal equilibrium and then assume it remains ergodic throughout . using this hypothesis we define an ergodic collision kernel @xcite as @xmath123 with @xmath124 standing for all values @xmath125 . this collision kernel must be numerically obtained . here we have calculated the kernel for @xmath126 . the ergodic kinetic equation for @xmath10 is now , @xmath127 , \end{aligned}\ ] ] while the kinetic equation for @xmath102 becomes , @xmath128 + \nonumber\\ & & + n_{0}\sum_{k i}i_{m k i 0}\{2\delta_{\epsilon_{m}+\epsilon_{i},\epsilon_{k}}[n_{k}(1+n_m+n_i)-n_i n_m]+\delta_{\epsilon_{m},\epsilon_{i}+\epsilon_{k}}[n_i n_k - n_\eta(1+n_k+n_i)]\}.\nonumber\\ & & n_{0}(\tau)=n-\sum_{m}n_m(\tau)\end{aligned}\ ] ] and we recall that the sums in the former case start with 0 , while in the latter they begin with 1 . using the ergodic approximation lead us to reduce significantly the number of coupled equations . that is , for @xmath129 , one must solve only @xmath129 non - linear coupled equations . nevertheless , the ergodic collision kernel given by equation ( [ kernel ] ) still remains as a numerical challenge since the number of terms in the sums grow exponentially . for @xmath130 levels the estimated time to calculate the ergodic kernel is approximately @xmath131 seconds , while for @xmath114 it reduces to @xmath132 seconds , a reasonable time . to the best of our knowledge , @xmath133 levels for the calculation of the ergodic collision integrals @xmath134 is the highest performed so far . we shall use this number of levels , within the ergodic hypothesis , to numerically simulate an energetic cooling protocol , as it is now described . for our study we propose an energetic cooling protocol . this scheme consists in maintaining fixed the number of particles during the whole cooling process while several energetic cooling stages lead the system to decrease its temperature . the basic idea of cooling consists in transferring particles from higher energy levels to lower ones . the system , being then out of equilibrium , will evolve to the equilibrium state via the kinetic equations . once in equilibrium with a lower temperature , the process of particle redistribution is performed several times to follow the evolution towards condensation . fig.[fig1 ] illustrates , in a diagram @xmath41 vs @xmath80 , a possible sequence of an energetic cooling process . the horizontal dashed ( red ) line shows a non - equilibrium process at constant number of particles that , starting from a temperature @xmath8 , crosses the solid ( black ) line which represents the number of particles @xmath41 in the excited states as a function of the critical temperature @xmath11 , namely , the onset of bose - einstein condensation . for @xmath31 , for @xmath135 , while the dashed horizontal line represents a cooling sequence at constant number of particles.,width=336 ] an energetic cooling mechanism may be implemented via stimulated anti - stokes raman - like " processes , as described in section i. the numerical simulation is initiated by distributing @xmath41 particles following the bose - einstein statistics in the first 40 levels . to perform the first energetic cooling step we remove the particles lying , say , in level @xmath136 , and distribute them uniformly in the level @xmath137 for @xmath138 . the system is allowed to evolve @xcite through equations ( [ eccinergo ] ) , for @xmath139 which corresponds to @xmath9 , until it reaches the equilibrium state associated to this first cooling stage . this process is successively repeated to follow the transition towards the condensation transition . once the transition is crossed , the dynamics should follow that of equations ( [ eccinergomu ] ) , corresponding to @xmath99 and @xmath9 . as we shall discuss in detail , due to the finite number of particles , there is a clear crossover between the solutions of the two ergodic sets of equations , rather than a sharp , discontinuous transition , as expected in the thermodynamic limit . to make use of the energetic cooling protocol we prepare the initial state considering the maximum energy level allowed by our computational capabilities . to ensure that all the particles participate in the dynamics during each energetic cooling step , it is necessary to select initial appropriate values of @xmath0 and @xmath80 . in fig . [ fig2 ] we plot the occupation number as a function of energy level in a harmonic oscillator for three pairs of values of @xmath80 and @xmath0 , indicated in the figure . as it can be seen from this plot , the number of particles below the level @xmath140 depends on the values of @xmath80 and @xmath0 . given a fixed values of @xmath80 and @xmath0 , one can estimate the relative number of particles above @xmath140 through @xmath141 with @xmath142 and @xmath143 the corresponding value of @xmath41 for an infinite " number of states @xmath144 . and temperature @xmath80 . the vertical line indicates the maximum number of energy levels considered in our numerical simulations.,width=336 ] for practical purposes we have selected two pairs of initial values of temperature @xmath80 and chemical potential @xmath0 to illustrate the predictions of the kinetic equations for @xmath139 and @xmath99 ( equations ( [ eccinergo ] ) and ( [ eccinergomu ] ) ) . these values are , ( @xmath145 ) and ( @xmath146 ) . such values of @xmath80 and @xmath0 ensure that less than 6 and 8 percent of particles respectively will remain above the @xmath140 level . thus , one can make certain that the majority of the particles will participate in the dynamics , at each cooling stage across the condensation transition . up to @xmath140 energy level the number of particles in each case is @xmath147 and @xmath148 . the critical temperatures for @xmath149 and @xmath135 are @xmath150 and @xmath151 respectively . first we proceed to analyze the predictions of equations ( [ eccinergo ] ) for @xmath149 , namely for the initial state @xmath145 . in fig . [ fig3a ] we plot the growth of the normalized number of particles in the ground state @xmath96 along the whole cooling protocol as a function of the dimensionless time @xmath152 , with a time step of @xmath153 @xcite . as it can be seen from figure [ fig3a ] , the growth of @xmath96 as a function of time is not a linear function . at earlier cooling stages there is an efficient cooling . then , once the system enters into the condensation transition the growth rate of particles in the ground state decreases . this fact is a consequence of having most of the particles in the ground state and an almost empty population in the excited states . we notice that this is accompanied by the fact that in the latest stages the chemical potential is essentially zero ; we further discuss this point below . the cooling process modeled through the protocol allows us to follow the evolution of the temperature and chemical potential as consecutive energetic cooling stages are carried out . at each energetic cooling stage the gas thermalizes at well defined values of @xmath0 and @xmath80 ; these are obtained by fitting the bose - einstein distribution function to the corresponding stationary distributions @xmath154 at each stage , namely , the stationary values are fit with @xmath155 with @xmath139 since we are following the dynamics across the transition with the kinetic equation ( [ eccinergo ] ) . in fig . [ fig3b ] we plot the stationary distributions of the occupation numbers @xmath154 . different curves correspond to equilibrium values @xmath80 and @xmath0 , at different cooling stages as indicated in the legend . the curves lying on the points correspond to the best bose - einstein distribution fit . as one can observe from this figure , as @xmath80 decreases and @xmath0 approaches zero from below , the number of particles in the condensate becomes the majority with respect to those associated to the excites states . as a matter of fact in figure [ fig3b ] we have omitted the stationary distributions of @xmath96 associated to @xmath156 and @xmath157 and @xmath158 and @xmath159 , since they would appear out of scale . different curves in [ fig3b ] indicate the path towards the onset of degeneracy , that is , the behavior of the ground state occupation number as @xmath160 . two important facts we stress here , first , that around @xmath161 , bec seems to develop ; but second , due to finite , actually rather small , number of particles , the chemical potential does not become zero , although it does becomes very small . that is , it is not possible to observe a sharp transition . this can be further observed in fig . [ fig4 ] where we plot the chemical potential @xmath0 as a function of @xmath80 , for @xmath162 and @xmath135 number of particles . from this figure one can observe how for @xmath135 the transition becomes more apparent and it should tend towards a true sharp transition in the thermodynamic limit @xmath163 @xcite . this behavior may seem to indicate that , since the chemical potential does not become zero unless in the thermodynamic limit , the kinetic equations for @xmath139 may suffice to describe the dynamics correctly , as done in refs . @xcite for example . it is the purpose of this section to highlight the importance of the kinetic equations for @xmath78 . as a function of @xmath80 along the whole sequence of energetic cooling . circles and squares are symbols that label @xmath162 and @xmath135 respectively for kinetic equation ( [ eccinergo ] ) for @xmath82 . black solid line is associated to the thermodynamic limit.,width=336 ] to enquiry the predictions of kinetic equations for @xmath31 and then to contrast them with those associated to the equation for @xmath82 we proceed in an analogous way to that described above . that is , we simulate numerically the scheme of an energetic cooling protocol but now with equations ( [ eccinergomu ] ) for @xmath31 . we illustrate our numerical results for @xmath135 initiating at @xmath164 ( @xmath151 ) . since the chemical potential in this case is zero we obtain the value of @xmath80 by fitting to the stationary occupation numbers the ideal bose - einstein distribution for @xmath31 , @xmath165 in fig . [ fig5a ] we plot the time evolution of the condensate @xmath96 during the whole energetic cooling process . once more , at the start , the cooling is very efficient , but as @xmath166 , it slows down since there are very few particles in the excited states . in fig . [ fig5b ] , we plot the number distribution as a function of the energy level , for different temperatures . bec is clearly described for @xmath9 by using the corresponding equations ( [ eccinergomu ] ) tailored for @xmath99 . this dynamics is very precise , less sensitive to finite size effects , and can be extended with no problem all the way to @xmath167 . we now compare the solutions both for @xmath168 with @xmath99 , in the light of finite size effects and the limited number of levels we can use . in figs . [ fig6a ] and [ fig6b ] we illustrate in a diagram @xmath169 vs @xmath170 the stationary normalized number of particles in the ground and excited states for @xmath135 along the cooling process . [ fig6a ] shows a cooling process starting at a temperature @xmath8 and going to a temperature as low as possible , using the kinetic equations for @xmath139 , eq . ( [ eccinergo ] ) . [ fig6b ] shows a cooling initiating at @xmath8 but using equations ( [ eccinergomu ] ) valid for @xmath99 only and , again , going towards @xmath167 . the curves in black are the results in the thermodynamic limit , showing the above mentioned sharp transition . several comments are in order . first of all , the solution for @xmath139 , while the bec transition is rather smooth , simply due to finite size effects , it appears that it can be extended to very low temperatures , near @xmath167 , where it is supposed no to be quite valid . this robustness is because the chemical potential can become very small , though not quite zero , see fig . as we discuss below , the solution for @xmath139 becomes numerically unstable as @xmath166 . on the other hand , the kinetic equations for @xmath99 become extremely good in the vicinity @xmath167 , notwithstanding the small number of particles . this is so , because @xmath114 energy levels suffices to describe the part of the gas in the excited states . as expected , this solution becomes less confident as @xmath171 from below , and similarly to the equations for @xmath139 near absolute zero , the numerical description for @xmath168 becomes unstable as bec transition is approached . one expects that in the limit of very large number of particles , and large number of levels included in a numerical calculation , the limitations of both descriptions in the regions where are not supposed to be valid , should be more apparent . this is further discussed below . [ fig7a ] and [ fig7b ] show details of calculations near @xmath167 and @xmath139 , eq . ( [ eccinergo ] ) , and for near @xmath11 and @xmath99 , eq . ( [ eccinergomu ] ) , respectively . the purpose of these figures is to exemplify the numerical instabilities of the corresponding descriptions . [ fig7a ] shows the number of particles in the condensate , with @xmath139 , with a very large number of particles , @xmath172 , which can be performed due to the very small value of the temperature . one sees , first , that the solution deviates from the that of the thermodynamic limit ( solid line ) , then it becomes unstable . the simpler explanation is that , at these temperatures @xmath0 must be zero , but the fitted bose - einstein distribution given by eq . ( [ bed ] ) can not take @xmath99 for a divergence would occur . although not shown here , the solution for @xmath99 fits smoothly the solid curve all the way down to @xmath167 . on the other hand , fig . [ fig7b ] shows the stationary total occupation number in the excited states for @xmath99 and @xmath9 . similarly to the previous case , as @xmath11 is approached , a numerical difficulty arises in the form of a double valued solution . again , this exhibits that this solution requires not only more particles but more equations for higher energy levels . it is satisfactory , nevertheless , to find that , apart from near the vicinity of @xmath11 , the solution for @xmath99 , which explicitly takes the bogoliubov approximation into account , fits extremely well the curves of the thermodynamic limit . we have studied the cooling process that leads a low - interacting bose gas confined in a harmonic potential to reach the bose - einstein transition . for this purpose we modeled the reduction of temperature in the gas through an energetic cooling protocol . in an analogous way to the evaporative cooling mechanism , the fundamental principle behind such a process , is that the temperature in a gas can be reduced in several stages by removing selectively the most energetic particles , and then allowing the system to thermalize to an equilibrium state with a lower temperature . the essential mechanism that leads the low interacting gas to reach the equilibrium state are the inter particle collisions . thus the path to equilibrium at each cooling step can be followed dynamically through a quantum kinetic boltzmann description . we derived the equations that describe the relaxation to the equilibrium in the gas taking into account that the cooling process must be divided in two parts , one for temperatures above the critical temperature @xmath11 at which the gas is in the normal phase , and the other for temperatures below @xmath11 when the transition to bose - einstein condensation takes place . to derive the irreversible master equations for the one body reduced density matrix operator in both cases ( @xmath10 and @xmath12 ) , we worked in the born and markov approximations that assume the perturbative character of the interaction term that represents the collisions among the particles , and that memory effects of the collision kernel are negligible , respectively . among the dynamics of any one - body reduced density matrix operator @xmath173 , we specifically followed the evolution in time of the occupation number operator @xmath174 to determine the particle population , in a single quantum state @xmath175 , as a function of time during the thermalization process . first , based on the fact that bose - einstein condensation can occur in a harmonically trapped bose gas in two and three dimensions , we derived for @xmath10 the kinetic equation that describes the relaxation to a stationary state of a collection of particles out of equilibrium , eq . ( [ eccin ] ) . we demonstrated that such equation satisfies that the total energy and the total number of particles are conserved , and that the ideal bose - einstein distribution with @xmath176 is the stationary solution of equation ( [ eccin ] ) for both the ground state , and the excited states . however , since equation ( [ eccin ] ) does not describe the dynamics for the ground and excited states when the chemical potential becomes zero or the temperature diminishes below @xmath11 , we derived a new kinetic equation , taking into account the underlying physics using the bogoliubov approximation @xcite , to properly describe the evolution in time of a low - interacting bose gas for @xmath12 . the quantum kinetic equation for @xmath12 was derived considering the physical significance of the fact that the chemical potential remains unchanged at the occurrence of the bose - einstein transition . in other words , we took into account that the thermodynamic state of the system is solely determined by the particles occupying the excited states . and therefore , considering the fact that the number of particles @xmath41 is no longer a thermodynamic variable although the total number of particles in the whole system remains constant . to derive a new kinetic equation considering this facts , we proposed to replace the interaction term that accounts for every single collision event , by an interaction potential in which the colliding particles arising from the ground state are treated within the bogoliubov approximation . this means that the creation and annihilation operators involving the ground state @xmath13 and @xmath14 can be substituted by @xmath16 , being @xmath16 the number of particles in the condensate . such an assumption lead us to end up with an equation , eq . ( [ eccin2 ] ) , that describes the dynamics below @xmath11 for which the chemical potential no longer varies , but is equal to zero . we have presented a numerical simulation employing equations ( [ eccin ] ) and ( [ eccin2 ] ) to model the process of the bose - einstein condensation . to achieve this purpose we implemented an energetic cooling protocol . this scheme consist of maintaining fixed the number of particles during the whole cooling process while several energetic cooling stages lead the system to decrease its temperature . to lower the temperature we considered a given number of particles distributed according to the bose - einstein statistics , then , we removed the particles occupying the highest excited states and distribute them uniformly in the remaining lowest states . the system was allowed to evolve via the kinetic equations towards the equilibrium state . the process of particle redistribution is repeated successively to follow the evolution towards the condensation . in our numerical simulation we were able to handle with up to 40 energy quantum levels of the harmonic oscillator in 3d . to the best of our knowledge this is the highest energy level numerically computed up to now . we solved the system of coupled kinetic equations considering the ergodic assumption . the cooling sequence allowed us to follow the sequence of the growing of particles in the ground and excited states . c. w. gardiner , p. zoller , r. j. ballagh , and m. j. davis , phys . lett . * 79 * , 1793 ( 1997 ) ; d. jaksch , c. w. gardiner , k. m. gheri , and p. zoller , phys . a * 58 * , 1450 ( 1998 ) ; c.w . gardiner and p. zoller , phys . a * 58 * , 536 ( 1998 ) ; d. jaksch , c. w. gardiner , and p. zoller , * 56 * , 575 ( 1997 ) ; c. w. gardiner and p. zoller , phys . a * 55 * , 2902 ( 1997 ) ; m. d. lee and c. w. gardiner phys . rev . a * 62 * 033606 ( 2000 ) . w. brenig , _ statistical theory of heat : non - equilibrium phenomena _ ( springer - verlag , berlin,1989 ) , p214 - 220 , j. keiser , _ statistical theory of non - equilibrium processes _ ( springer , berlin , 1987 ) , p161 - 169 ( 1987 ) , h.j . kreuzer,_non- equilibrium thermodynamics and its statistical foundation _ ( clarendon press , oxford,1981 ) , p296 - 321 . such effect is a consequence of demanding that the majority of particles participate in the dynamics , that is , that they occupy states below @xmath179=40 . for @xmath180 and @xmath181 , the values of @xmath80 and @xmath0 are @xmath182 , @xmath183 , @xmath184 and @xmath185 respectively .
Abstract: | [
"the dynamics of bose - einstein condensation in a three - dimensional harmonic trap is studied explicitly including the bogoliubov approximation for temperatures below the critical one . to model the evolution towards equilibrium at each cooling step , we derive quantum kinetic equations that describe the dynamics of the gas for temperatures above and below the transition temperature . these equations , valid in the born and markov approximations , consider the essential role of the chemical potential as the main parameter that signals the transition . the kinetic equation that describes the growth of the condensate below the transition temperature is derived within the bogoliubov approximation . to illustrate our results we propose an energetic cooling protocol and simulate the whole sequence of the formation of a condensate ."
] | 8,868 | 8,868 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: open clusters are considered excellent laboratories for studies of stellar evolution and the dynamics of stellar systems . a large fraction of galactic open clusters are situated close to the galactic plane , thus potentially making them appropriate objects for probing the structure and evolution of the galactic disc although the presence of dust in the galactic plane restricts their usefulness in this sense . one of many important aspects in open cluster studies is related to the effects of mass segregation ; that is , the more massive member stars in the cluster will be more centrally concentrated and/or have a distinct distribution in velocity space compared to the lower - mass members . the key observational questions of interest in open star cluster research include whether or not mass segregation exists in a given star cluster and , if so , what the extent of this effect is in relation to the cluster s age . for cluster samples as a whole , the similarities and differences of the effects of mass segregation for clusters of various ages , abundances and galactocentric distances are of great interest . all of these properties are related to the formation process as well as the dynamical evolution of clusters . they are also ( sometimes significantly ) influenced by the galactic tidal fields , in particular in the outer regions of a given cluster . young open clusters are important stellar systems for our understanding of the star - formation process . in very young clusters , most of the low - mass stars will still be in their pre - main - sequence ( pms ) evolutionary stage , and one may expect to derive global stellar initial mass functions ( imfs ) that are not yet significantly affected by the effects of stellar and dynamical evolution . however , if a significant amount of `` primordial '' mass segregation ( i.e. , mass segregation intrinsic to the star - formation process itself ) is present , this would seriously complicate the interpretation of an observed stellar luminosity function ( lf ) at a given position within a star cluster in terms of its imf @xcite . in this paper , we use photographic plate material with longer time baselines than published previously , in order to determine the proper motions and membership probabilities of stars in the regions of two very young galactic open clusters ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 . we aim to quantify the possible effects of mass segregation and place these objects in the context of their expected future evolution . ngc 2244 ( also referred to as ngc 2239 ) is the core ob cluster of the monoceros ob2 ( mon ob2 ) association , embedded in the rosette nebula ( ngc 2237/2246 ) , a well - developed `` blister '' hii region . this system is located in the northwest quadrant of the rosette molecular cloud complex , which itself is one of the most massive giant molecular cloud ( gmc ) complexes in the milky way ( see @xcite ) ; such gmc complexes are particularly conducive to the formation of massive ob stars . because of the strong ionizing radiation from the massive ob stars in the core of ngc 2244 ( see , e.g. , @xcite for a census of the ob stars in the cluster ) , the cluster has excavated the gmc complex , allowing us a deeper look into the cloud than otherwise possible . ngc 2244 represents the youngest of two or three subgroups of ob stars and stellar aggregates in the mon ob2 association @xcite . since ngc 2244 is one of the youngest star - forming open clusters in the milky way , and relatively nearby , it has been the subject of a number of detailed studies . using the webda open cluster database @xcite as our guide , the equatorial coordinates of the cluster center are @xmath3 , and the galactic coordinates @xmath4 , i.e. , the cluster is located quite close to the direction of the galactic anticenter . @xcite , using near - infrared imaging from the two micron all - sky survey ( 2mass ) , estimated a mean visual extinction , @xmath5 mag within a radius of 10 arcmin centered on the apparent center of the hii region . they pointed out that this independent low near - infrared extinction estimate was consistent with previous estimates in the optical , which is also supported by results from co and c@xmath6o maps ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) . in the optical , the most comprehensive extinction analysis for the cluster was published by @xcite , who reported a mean reddening of @xmath7 mag , with a non - negligible amount of differential reddening across the cluster : their reddening values for individual cluster stars range from @xmath8 to 0.98 mag . this is fully consistent with the results of @xcite ; and references therein ) , who found @xmath9 mag from the individual reddening values for 28 cluster member stars brighter than @xmath10 mag , and a smaller amount of differential reddening , ranging from @xmath11 to 0.56 mag . they also found that ngc 2244 is most likely characterized by a `` standard '' reddening law , with a total - to - selective extinction ratio of @xmath12 . as such , we adopt a foregound reddening of @xmath7 mag in this paper . the distance to ngc 2244 is reasonably well established , at @xmath13 kpc , and generally consistent among different distance indicators used in the literature ( see also @xcite for a review ) . for instance , @xcite obtained @xmath14 pc from the distance moduli of the individual ob - type stars in the cluster . more recently , @xcite derived a distance of @xmath15 kpc to the cluster based on spectroscopic observations of one of the cluster member stars , the eclipsing binary v578 mon ( hd259135 ) . @xcite derived a distance modulus of @xmath16 based on @xmath17 photometry , corresponding to @xmath18 kpc . this larger distance value seems to be favoured by many authors in the field ( e.g. , @xcite ) , and as such we will adopt it here as well . for the age of ngc 2244 , most authors agree on a value of 24 myr for the main sequence ( ms ) turn - off age ( @xcite and references therein ) . in addition , recently an age estimate of @xmath19 myr was derived from the age of the eclipsing binary v578 mon @xcite . based on high spatial resolution multi - filter photometry of ngc 2244 , @xcite concluded that while most of the cluster stars are aged up to 3 myr , significantly younger low - mass stars ( 5% or more of the cluster stars ) exist in the cluster as well , indicating that star formation is still in progress in the rosette nebula / ngc 2244 region ( see also @xcite , the latter authors found a ms turn - off age of 1.9 myr , but a pre - ms age spread of about 6 myr ) . however , they also note that up to 45% of the cluster stars may be older than 3 myr , thus suggesting an earlier star - forming episode in the region . moreover , the dynamical age of the nebula is just @xmath20 myr @xcite , while the dynamical age of the hi shell is as old as 4 myr ( see @xcite ) . the first proper motion study of this cluster @xcite identified 22 probable members . subsequently , @xcite performed more precise proper motion measurements of 287 stars down to @xmath21 mag and selected 89 stars with membership probabilities , @xmath22 , and data quality , @xmath23 , in an area of @xmath24 arcmin@xmath25 . however , @xcite cautioned that their `` member '' sample may contain several non - cluster members of the mon ob2 association because of the large rectangular field of view employed by the @xcite study compared to the cluster s angular size of @xmath26 arcmin and the roughly spherical shape described by @xcite . using the @xcite astrometric membership determinations , combined with spectroscopically determined stellar mk classifications of 193 stars by @xcite , @xcite redetermined the membership probabilities of the brightest cluster stars ( 30 ob stars and 21 pre - ms members and candidates brighter than @xmath27 mag ) . @xcite and @xcite redetermined the cluster s stellar membership probabilities based on the early astrometric data first analyzed by @xcite . they confirmed 92 ( out of 202 ) stars as physical members of the cluster , with @xmath28 . in this paper , we will analyze high - quality , wide - field photographic plates of shanghai astronomical observatory , with an maximum likelihood algorithm involving careful assessment of the distributions of both the proper motions and the positions , thus allowing us to arrive at a valuable , independent estimation of membership probabilities . ngc 6530 is another prime example of an extremely young open cluster that has been the subject of a number of previous studies . as the core cluster of the sgr ob1 association , it is projected onto the eastern part of the lagoon nebula ( m8 ) , which is one of the brightest nearby nebulae and hii regions @xcite . the lagoon nebula is the illuminated part of the gmc from which the cluster formed by generating a `` blister '' hii region due to the ionizing radiation from its hot massive stars ( e.g. , @xcite . once again , this allows us to probe into the depths of this gmc region much better than would have been possible otherwise . the equatorial coordinates of ngc 6530 are @xmath29 and the galactic coordinates @xmath30 , i.e. , the cluster is located in the direction not far from that of the galactic center . this implies that one has to be very careful in disentangling cluster members from field interlopers ( see also @xcite . as a case in point , in early work on this cluster , @xcite obtained photo - electric magnitudes and colors for 118 stars in the ngc 6530 region and proposed that a band of its low - mass members above the ms in color - magnitude space may be pms stars that are still in the stage of gravitational contraction . it has since been shown ( e.g. , @xcite ) that many of these pms candidates are , in fact , foregound or background field stars ( see the discussions in @xcite , and @xcite ) . subsequently , the properties of this very young cluster have been studied extensively by different authors , leading to an age estimate of 1.53.0 myr @xcite , and the cluster s distance to the sun has been estimated to be in the range from 0.62.0 kpc @xcite . the most recent median age estimate for the cluster , based on ground - based @xmath31 photometry down to @xmath32 mag @xcite is 2.3 myr , i.e. , well inside the range quoted by previous authors , although the same team also derived a much younger median age of 0.8 myr ( @xcite ; see also @xcite for the pre - ms stars ; @xcite ) . both estimates are not necessarily in conflict with each other , because the cluster appears to host stars formed over a significant length of time . while @xcite argued that star formation in the cluster may have been ongoing since a few @xmath33 ago , until the present , @xcite based on their detailed study of low - mass pms stars argue that the time - scale for star formation in ngc 6530 must have been much shorter , starting only a few @xmath34 yr ago . nevertheless , this clearly implies that the cluster environment has been an active star - forming environment for a significant period ( see also @xcite ) . more specifically , @xcite conclude , based on a detailed analysis of the distribution of optical / infrared - excess stars throughout the region , that star formation has proceeded rather undisturbed and for a longer period in the northern cluster region than near the cluster center . this is in support of suggestions by @xcite and @xcite that the star - formation activity may have proceeded from north to south in the cluster region , which is further supported by a spatial age segregation analysis by @xcite . the most recent distance estimate to ngc 6530 , based on @xmath31 photometry , was derived by @xcite , @xmath35 pc , corresponding to a distance modulus @xmath36 mag . this is towards the bottom end of the range in possible distances quoted by a variety of authors , @xmath37 pc ( @xcite , their table 1 ) , generally obtained photometrically from the brightest cluster member stars . in contrast , it is significantly larger than the distance obtained from hipparcos parallaxes of seven member stars , @xmath38 pc @xcite . in other recent studies , both @xcite and @xcite determined a best distance estimate to ngc 6530 of @xmath39 kpc [ @xmath40 mag , based on optical photometry and a detailed consideration of the extinction across the cluster ( see also @xcite ) . in this paper , we opt to use the @xcite distance determination , @xmath35 pc . following the webda compilation of cluster parameters , we adopt a mean reddening @xmath41 mag ( @xcite ; see also @xcite ) , in addition to a foreground reddening of @xmath42 to 0.20 mag @xcite . there is significant variation in reddening across the ngc 6530 region , as is evident from both the distribution of stars in color - magnitude space and from the spatial variation of stellar density ( @xcite , and references therein ) . in fact , the amount of differential reddening ranges from @xmath43 to 0.50 mag across the cluster ( @xcite ; also @xcite , but see @xcite ) , although @xcite also uncovered evidence for the presence of a large number of heavily reddened objects , characterized by @xmath44 mag . @xcite were the first to determine the membership probabilities of 363 stars in a @xmath45 region centered on ngc 6530 from relative proper motion data with a time baseline of 34 years . they found 76 stars with membership probabilities , @xmath46 , greater than 0.5 with @xmath47 mag . more recent studies resulted in firm membership determinations for 451 stars with @xmath48 @xcite , and 237 stars @xcite , the latter study based on spectroscopic observations around the lithium and h@xmath49 lines . @xcite has suggested that the cluster may contain @xmath50 members . it should be noted that a reliable stellar membership determination is crucial for resolved star cluster studies . the shanghai astronomical observatory has in its archives wide - field photographic plates with a long time baseline of these two open clusters , thus providing valuable , independent observational materials for high - accuracy measurements of stellar proper motions , and for the determination of cluster membership . this constitutes a strong starting point for further detailed cluster studies , including those dealing with the effects of mass segregation , as we show in this paper . in this paper , we use photographic plate material with longer time baselines or higher quality than published previously , in order to determine the proper motions and membership probabilities of stars in the regions of both clusters ( sect . [ obs.sec ] ) . we present a new , detailed investigation of these two clusters based on our membership determination ( sect . [ members.sec ] ) , of their stellar luminosity functions and the observed effects of mass segregation ( sect . [ results.sec ] ) . in sect . [ discussion.sec ] we discuss the clusters in the context of their evolutionary state and summarize the main results obtained in this paper . for the open clusters ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 , all photographic plates used for the proper motion reduction were taken by the 40-cm refractor telescope ( with a focal length of 6895 mm ) at the sheshan ( z s ) station of the shanghai astronomical observatory , operated by the chinese academy of sciences . for ngc 2244 , four plates for each of the first and second epochs were taken in 19631964 , and 19981999 , respectively , spanning a time baseline of 35 years . for ngc 6530 , two first epoch plates and four second plates were taken in 1912 and 1999 , respectively , spanning 87 years . the field of view achieved is @xmath51 and @xmath52 , for the first and second epoch plates , respectively . no filter was used to obtain these plates ; their sensitive wavelength region is close to the @xmath53 band and the 30 min exposure time resulted in a brightness limit of about 16 mag . the stellar coordinates on the plates of both clusters were measured with the photometrics data systems ( pds ) microdensitometer @xcite at the dominion astrophysical observatory ( dao ) in canada . for each plate , raster scanning was performed over the full @xmath54 central regions of the clusters . the scanning diaphragm used had a size of @xmath55 m squared , with both a step length and line separation of @xmath56 m ; a speed of 15 mm s@xmath2 was used . in the region where we performed the full scan , stellar images were extracted and their rectangular coordinates , @xmath57 , obtained using the processing software provided by dao . after the preliminary identification , the measured coordinates on each plate were transformed linearly to a unified system using six plate constants , and those with residual errors @xmath58 m were excluded . the cross - identification resulted in a final set of 498 stars for ngc 2244 and 365 stars for ngc 6530 , respectively , with each star appearing on at least one plate of both the early _ and _ later epochs . in the reduction of our proper motion data , an iterative central - overlap technique @xcite was used . for ngc 2244 , 78 tycho-2 stars were selected as reference stars ; their reference positions and proper motions were adopted based on the tycho-2 catalogue @xcite . during the iterative solution , three stars with extraordinarily large residual errors were removed . the final solution provided us with robust position and proper motion data of 495 stars in the cluster region . similarly , 79 tycho-2 catalogue stars were used as reference stars for ngc 6530 , and only 1 star with an extremely large residual error in the iterative solution was removed . this resulted in a total of 364 stars with final position and proper motion values . the internal levels of uncertainty on the position and proper motion of the individual stars are given in table 1 . estimating the membership probability of the observed cluster stars involves a careful assessment of the distributions of both the proper motions and the positions . we assume that in position space the surface number density of the field stars follows a uniform distribution , @xmath59 , while the cluster members approximately follow a gaussian profile ( see , e.g. , @xcite , for a preliminary analysis of the stars in the ngc 6530 region with membership probabilities @xmath60 ) , @xmath61 , with a central density , @xmath62 , and a dispersion , @xmath49 . then , @xmath63 where @xmath64 denotes the distance of the @xmath65 star to the cluster center . let @xmath66 and @xmath67 be the normalized @xmath59 and @xmath61 , respectively , and @xmath68 . then we have @xmath69 ( by definition ) , and @xmath70 both the field stars and the cluster members have independent proper motion and position distributions . we assume that the field star proper motion is characterized by an elliptical gaussian distribution , and that of the cluster stars is a circular gaussian function . the overall distribution function for the field stars , @xmath71 , and for the cluster stars , @xmath72 , can then be written as : @xmath73\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] and @xmath74\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here , @xmath75 is the reduced proper motion of the @xmath65 star and @xmath76 are the estimated observational errors . @xmath77 and @xmath78 are the distribution centers of the field stars and cluster members in the vector point diagram ( vpd ) , respectively , whereas @xmath79 and @xmath80 are the intrinsic proper motion dispersions of the field stars and the cluster members respectively , and @xmath81 is the correlation coefficient . together with the parameters @xmath49 and @xmath82 , there are 10 parameters awaiting determination . these parameters were estimated by means of a maximum likelihood method . when searching for the maximum of the likelihood function , a bipartition algorithm was adopted @xcite , and the ( internal ) uncertainty of the parameter estimation was evaluated based on the second derivatives of the likelihood function @xcite . in order to get a handle on the external uncertainty of our proper motion determinations , we compared our derived proper motion values to those derived from the tycho-2 catalogue , for the 78 stars in ngc 2244 and the 79 stars in ngc 6530 in common in both data sets . this resulted in a mean deviation of @xmath83 mas yr@xmath2 , with a dispersion of @xmath84 mas yr@xmath2 , in very good agreement with the internal level of accuracy of the tycho-2 catalogue . after the distribution parameters are determined , the membership probability of the @xmath65 star can be calculated as : @xmath85 table 2 gives the maximum likelihood estimates of the distribution parameters , and the corresponding uncertainties , for both clusters . we used the distribution parameters to calculate the membership probabilities of the individual stars in the ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 regions . figure 1 shows the vpd for both ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 ( see also the preliminary analysis by @xcite ; the solid points represent the stars with membership probabilities , @xmath60 , whereas the crosses indicate the @xmath86 . the open circles have @xmath46 values in between these boundaries . the vpds already show that our membership determination appears to be quite effective . to underscore this point , fig . 2 shows the histograms of the membership probabilities ; the left - hand panel is for ngc 2244 and the right - hand panel for ngc 6530 . returning to the clusters vpds , both @xcite and @xcite published vpds for ngc 2244 based on independent proper motion analyses . although their samples of cluster members are much smaller than ours ( of order 100 member stars ) , the vpds are qualitatively similar in extent as well as morphology . we note , however , that in particular the @xcite vpd appears somewhat more elongated in the @xmath87 direction than our vpd in fig . 1 . we will return to this issue below . from fig . 2 , one can deduce _ quantitatively _ that the discrimination of membership for ngc 2244 is quite effective . of the total of 495 stars , about 16% , or 78 stars , have probabilities in the range of @xmath88 . as an aside , we note that a comparison of the membership histograms in @xcite and fig . 2 shows that our membership determination is more efficient than theirs . meanwhile , for ngc 6530 , the separation of members from the field stars is even more effective , with only a few stars having probabilities around @xmath89 , i.e. , only 4.4% ( or 16 stars ) have @xmath88 ; 451 stars have @xmath60 ( see also @xcite for a discussion of the results in relation to the earlier work by @xcite ) . we note that in the context of ngc 6530 , the @xcite and @xcite studies cover a much smaller field of view ( diameter @xmath90 arcmin ) than our observations presented here ( sect . [ obs.sec ] ) , although at a higher spatial resolution . secondly , the @xcite sample , which in essence only covers the cluster core , is fainter ( @xmath91 mag ) than ours ( @xmath92 mag ) . as such there is virtually no overlap between both data sets . star counts allow us to statistically determine the properties of clusters with respect to the surrounding stellar background . the cluster radius itself is one of the most important cluster parameters , and particularly useful for dynamical studies . from our results , the member stars of both ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 show an obvious concentration on the sky , while this is clearly not the case for field stars . in essence , this supports the result for ngc 2244 by @xcite based on the cluster s vpd . they determined robust membership probabilities for 92 stars in the area using both the cluster s vpd and its membership probability histogram , akin to our fig . 2 . in the vpd they clearly showed the ( elliptical ) distribution of the proper motions of the cluster members around a centroid , and the very small dispersion of stars with @xmath93 , clearly setting them apart from the field stars , with @xmath94 ( see also @xcite ) . as regards ngc 6530 , @xcite and @xcite provided compelling evidence for the superiority of the membership determinations in the present data set compared to that presented by @xcite . in order to derive the radial stellar surface density , we first chose the cluster center as the median coordinates of all the member stars with @xmath95 . the adopted centers are at the ( j2000.0 ) equatorial coordinates of @xmath96 for ngc 2244 and @xmath97 for ngc 6530 , respectively . these updated center positions are slightly different from the values provided by webda , although the displacements between our new center coordinates and those provided by webda are well inside the respective cluster core radii ( see below ) . for comparison , @xcite determined the 2mass center position of ngc 2244 as being very close to the centroid determined from our proper motions , resulting in j2000.0 equatorial coordinates of @xmath98 . the radial number density profile , shown in fig . 3 , was constructed by performing star counts inside increasing concentric annuli around the cluster center and normalized by the surface areas covered by the respective annuli . figure 3 shows the radial surface number density profiles of the cluster members @xmath99 and the field stars @xmath100 in our observational fields of view , on the left - hand side for ngc 2244 and on the right - hand side for ngc 6530 . in each panel , the profiles for the cluster members and the field stars are completely different , with the field star distributions essentially flat , whereas the cluster members exhibit obvious concentrations towards the cluster centers . this result shows once again that our membership determinations are reasonably robust and reliable . the basic structural parameters were derived by fitting the two - parameter surface density @xcite profile to our observational data in a least - squares sense . we used fitting radii of 32 and 33 arcmin for ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 , respectively . the core radii thus obtained are @xmath101 arcmin for ngc 2244 and @xmath102 arcmin for ngc 6530 , corresponding to @xmath103 and @xmath104 pc , respectively . meanwhile , the half - number radii ( i.e. , the radii on either side of which half of the member stars are located ) of the clusters were also determined , as 14 arcmin for ngc 2244 and 21 arcmin for ngc 6530 , or @xmath105 and @xmath106 pc , respectively . our main reason for using the clusters half - number radii instead of their half - light radii is practical : the position and proper motion information , eventually leading to membership probabilities , is based on the results from the pds scans . during this process , some of the brightest stars had to be avoided because of saturation effects on the photographic plates ( which would lead to unacceptably large positional uncertainties for our analysis ) . in other words , our sample of cluster members is incomplete at bright magnitudes , and the membership probabilities of the ( few ) brightest stars are unknown . the half - number radii are not significantly affected by the omission of these few stars , which would have an extraordinarily large contribution to the clusters total fluxes , however . although @xcite found that the radial profile in the near - infrared of the ngc 2244 member stars disappears into the background field star population at a radius of about 20 arcmin , our radial profile in fig . 3 clearly shows that we can follow the cluster s profile out to almost 30 arcmin . this is in keeping with the cluster radius of 11.8 pc derived by @xcite , which at an assumed distance of 1.4 kpc corresponds to about 29 arcmin . our size determination for ngc 6530 is less clear - cut , as fig . 3 shows : the radial profile composed by its member stars appears to merge with the field star population at a radius of around 20 arcmin , although this value is rather uncertain . we believe , therefore , that our result is in reasonable agreement with the diameter of roughly 35 arcmin quoted by @xcite . for both clusters , the model profiles tend to roughly follow the observational data points in the outer regions , but not in detail . this suggests that both clusters do not have well - defined outer radii , but are instead characterized by a significant amount of substructure . there is , in fact , strong evidence that ngc 2244 possesses distinct substructures . @xcite , using 2mass near - infrared imaging , found that the cluster is resolved into an extended distribution of stellar sources associated with its compact core in the south center of the blister hii region , but also into a clear elongated density enhancement in the west . 6530 also exhibit distinct substructures : in a region towards the northwest of the actual cluster center there appears to be a density enhancement of slightly older stars than in the rest of the cluster ( e.g. , @xcite ) . in addition , the vpds of both clusters ( fig . 1 ; see also @xcite , in particular ) appear to have axial ratios significantly deviating from unity . finally , @xcite and @xcite point out that instead of using a @xcite profile , a more appropriate radial density profile might be represented by a @xmath107 profile , following suggestions by @xcite regarding the radial density distributions of embedded star clusters . in fig . 3 , we show the best - fitting @xmath107 profiles for both clusters . for ngc 2244 , the best - fitting profile follows @xmath108 , while the equivalent profile for ngc 6530 is @xmath109 . we note that whereas the fit to the ngc 6530 radial profile is statistically good , the ngc 2244 distribution is better approximated by a king profile . @xcite provided their @xmath110 observations centered on ngc 2244 with the kpno 0.9 m telescope and a tektronix 2048@xmath1112048 ccd , covering a 2800 arcmin@xmath25 area . this resulted in accurate photometric data for a total of 773 stars in the cluster region , down to @xmath112 mag . by matching our photographic plate observations to the @xcite sample using a conservative matching tolerance of 0.3 arcsec , 323 stars in common were identified . furthermore , using a quadratic function , our initial instrumental magnitudes , @xmath113 , were converted to the @xmath53 magnitudes in the @xcite system . as regards ngc 6530 , @xcite performed @xmath31 observations of the ngc 6530 region using the eso 2.2 m telescope at la silla , characterized by a field of view of @xmath114 arcmin@xmath25 . the limiting magnitude of their work is @xmath115 mag . we compared our @xmath113 instrumental magnitudes with the @xmath53 magnitudes of 62 stars in common with @xcite s sample . except for a few stars , we found an obvious linear correlation between the magnitudes , which we used to convert our @xmath113 photometry to the b magnitudes in the @xmath110 system . figure 4 shows the comparison between our instrumental @xmath113 photometry and the @xmath53 magnitudes of @xmath110 system , for both clusters . the photometric uncertainties in both our own data and those taken from the literature are small : @xcite state that their uncertainties are @xmath116 mag for stars brighter than @xmath117 mag , and `` do not become appreciable until @xmath118 mag '' . the photometric uncertainties in the @xcite data have a mean value of 0.02 mag , with a maximum error @xmath119 mag . for member stars in a given open cluster , all at roughly the same distance , the range in visual magnitudes corresponds to that in luminosity . in addition , when only main - sequence stars are considered , the stellar luminosity is a proxy for the stellar mass . in order to assess the effects of mass segregation , we first examined the luminosity functions of the member stars in different ( radial ) ranges of the clusters . figures 5 and 6 show the @xmath120 luminosity functions of stars with membership probabilities @xmath121 in the two cluster regions . figures 5a ( top ) and b ( middle ) show the luminosity functions of the ngc 2244 cluster members in the inner @xmath122 and outer @xmath123 areas of ngc 2244 , where @xmath124 arcmin is the half - number radius derived from our full sample of 216 member stars . 5c ( bottom ) shows the cumulative distributions for both radial regions . figures 6a ( top ) , b ( middle ) , and c ( bottom ) show the equivalent results for ngc 6530 ( see also @xcite ) . here , we derived a half - number radius of @xmath125 arcmin from our total sample of 250 member stars . from these two figures , the effects of mass segregation are evident : the relative fraction of brighter stars ( or , equivalently , more massive stars ) is higher in the inner than in the outer regions . as an alternative approach to investigate these mass segregation effects , we calculated the half - number radii for member stars in different absolute magnitude ranges , i.e. , for @xmath126 and @xmath127 mag . the results of this exercise are listed in table 5 ( see @xcite for a complementary discussion related to ngc 6530 ; in particular their table 6 ) . it can be seen that for both clusters , the brighter members are characterized by smaller half - number radii another indication of the existence of mass segregation in these clusters . to further examine the mass segregation effects , we also investigated the radial density distributions of member stars ( @xmath95 ) in different luminosity ranges in the clusters , which are shown in figs . 7 ( for ngc 2244 ) and 8 ( for ngc 6530 ) . in each cluster , a position - dependent lf is found . in essence , the fainter ( i.e. , lower - mass ) stars are spread throughout the entire cluster in both objects , while the brighter ( massive ) stars are predominantly located in the inner region . if the mass segregation effects solely result from the process of two - body relaxation and the associated energy equipartition , one should find some evidence for this effect not only in the spatial distribution of the cluster members , but also in their velocity distribution : the more massive members will have a smaller velocity dispersion than the less massive stars . accordingly , for true cluster members ( with @xmath128 ) in different magnitude ranges , the intrinsic proper motion dispersions @xmath129 as derived from the observed dispersions @xmath130 , and the mean errors intrinsic to the stellar proper motions were investigated . the final results are shown in figs . it can be seen from these figures that the intrinsic proper motion dispersions are not significantly different for various magnitude groups . thus , our data do not support any significant velocity ( dispersion)-mass correlation , neither in ngc 2244 , nor in ngc 6530 ( see also @xcite ) . the traditional explanation for ( position dependent ) mass segregation in an open cluster is that it results from a situation in which all cluster stars approach energy equipartition . however , this is unlikely the case for ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 , since both clusters are very young , low - density objects ( but see @xcite for counterarguments ) . with ages of only around 23 myr , their ages are comparable to the time - scale of about only one or two crossing times . theoretically , the nature and degree of `` primordial '' mass segregation , i.e. , mass segregation intrinsic to the star - formation process itself , is presumably determined by the properties of the interactions of protostellar material during the star - forming episode in a cluster . more massive stars are subject to more mergers , hence accrete even more mass ( cf . @xcite and references therein ) , and therefore dissipate more kinetic energy . in addition , they tend to form near the cluster center , in the highest - density region , where the encounter - rate is highest @xcite . this will lead to an observed position - dependent stellar mass function containing more low - mass stars at larger radii compared to the mass function in the cluster center ( although low - mass stars are still present at small radii , see also the discussions in @xcite ; but see @xcite for arguments in favor of excluding primordial mass segregation to explain recent observations of the arches cluster near the galactic center ) . from an observational point of view , the study of very young star clusters still embedded in the molecular clouds from which they originated might give us a handle to constrain the degree of primordial mass segregation . in the milky way , in three such young star clusters mass segregation effects have been studied in great detail in the past two decades . while @xcite suggested , based on ground - based observations , that the brighter stars in ngc 2024 ( and the mon r2 complex at large ) seem to be more centrally concentrated than the fainter cluster members , this evidence was deemed inconclusive by @xcite . they argued that this result was based on an incomplete sample of cluster members , although mass segregation might be limited to the massive , bright ob stars forming in the very center . these same authors argued that for masses below @xmath131 , mass segregation effects in the mon r2 complex amount to only a @xmath132 result . secondly , a combination of both ground - based ( e.g. , @xcite and _ hubble space telescope ( hst ) _ observations ( e.g. , @xcite ) of the orion nebula cluster ( onc ) , and in particular of its very core , the trapezium stars , have presented clear evidence for mass segregation for the @xmath133 component , with some evidence for general mass segregation down to @xmath134@xmath135 ( @xcite ; see also the review by @xcite ) . finally , r136 , the central cluster in 30 doradus in the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ; age @xmath136 34 myr ; cf . @xcite ) , has been studied extensively , both from the ground and with the _ a variety of techniques have revealed a significant overabundance of high - mass stars in its very center , thus supporting strong mass segregation ( e.g. , @xcite ) . thus , in most of the ( still partially embedded ) young star clusters that can be resolved in individual stars , mass segregation effects are observed , although to varying degrees . this underlines the importance of our understanding of the physical processes involved in the formation and evolution of star clusters , and in particular of the imf , which will ultimately determine the time - scale on which a young star cluster will eventually be destroyed . we may conclude from the above discussion that the observed spatial mass segregation in the young open clusters ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 might have resulted from a combination of both initial conditions in the early stages of evolution and , possibly , two - body relaxation process . the latter process will lead to a manifestation of cluster - wide mass segregation on the half - mass relaxation time - scale . however , it will proceed much faster in higher - density regions in the cluster , and among the more massive stars both of these conditions favor an decreased time - scale in the cluster center . finally , we will consider the long - term fate of the two young clusters discussed in this paper in relation to their ( observed ) imf and velocity dispersion . both clusters have been scrutinized with the aim of determining their stellar make - up . because of their very young ages , the stellar content in essence reflects the mass distribution at the time of their birth , as insufficient time has passed for any significant number of stars to have undergone a full cycle of stellar evolution ( and neither for significant dynamical evolution to have occurred , as argued above ) . @xcite determined the imf of ngc 2244 in the mass range @xmath137 . they found a flat imf slope , with @xmath138 , where the equivalent slope of the @xcite imf would be @xmath139 . their result is in close agreement both with that of @xcite in the range from @xmath140 to @xmath141 , and with that of @xcite for stars with masses in excess of @xmath142 , @xmath143 . such a flat imf implies that the cluster s stellar population contains too many massive stars with respect to their lower - mass counterparts for it to survive the dynamical effects leading to cluster dissolution for any significant amount of time ( see , e.g. , @xcite in the context of the young massive cluster m82-f ; and @xcite for theoretical arguments in support of this notion ) . the precise dissolution time - scale depends sensitively on the imf mass range ( kouwenhoven et al . , in prep . ) this conclusion is supported by arguments related to the cluster s velocity dispersion . its intrinsic overall velocity dispersion is @xmath144 mas yr@xmath2 ; at the adopted distance , @xmath18 kpc , this is equivalent to @xmath145 km s@xmath2 . myr by @xcite . ] this large linear velocity dispersion is significantly in excess of the `` typical '' velocity dispersions older open clusters in the milky way characterized by a salpeter - type imf , or equivalent ( de grijs et al . , in prep . ) . thus , the combination of these arguments leads us to conclude that ngc 2244 will most likely dissolve on a short time - scale ( see also @xcite for a more conservative back - of - the - envelope calculation supporting our conclusion ) . if not due to internal two - body relaxation effects , then most likely because of external shocks expected to operate near its location in , or close to , the galactic disk ( although we note that these effects may not be very significant in the galactic anticenter direction ) ngc 6530 , on the other hand , exhibits a power - law imf slope of @xmath146 for stellar masses between 0.6 and @xmath147 @xcite , fully consistent with the @xcite imf . they note that the cluster imf peaks towards smaller masses and then declines . this is in keeping with the detailed photometric study of @xcite , who quote an imf slope of @xmath148 , largely independent of the mass to luminosity conversion employed . its intrinsic velocity dispersion is @xmath149 mas yr@xmath2 ; at the adopted distance , @xmath35 pc , this is equivalent to @xmath150 km s@xmath2 , i.e. , much closer to the dynamical state required for longer - term survival , although still fairly large ( de grijs et al . , in prep . ) . in the absence of sizeable external perturbations , we speculate , therefore , that ngc 6530 has the potential to survive for a significant length of time , possibly of order a few @xmath151 yr . however , we also note that the cluster is situated very close to the galactic plane in the direction of the galactic center , such that external perturbations are unlikely to remain insignificant for any length of time . finally , we point out that the large velocity dispersions obtained for both young clusters imply that these objects are unlikely to survive for any significant length of time . the velocity dispersions of ` classical ' old ( @xmath152 yr ) bound open clusters are of order @xmath153 km s@xmath2 as shown by , e.g. , @xcite in what is probably the most comprehensive study of open cluster velocity dispersions available to date . a small subset of these measurements have since been confirmed in more recent studies of individual objects ( de grijs et al . , in prep . ) . for instance , the velocity dispersion of the @xmath154 myr - old @xcite central cluster in coma berenices is @xmath155 km s@xmath2 ( @xcite ; cf . @xmath156 km s@xmath2 measured in the cluster core by @xcite ) ; that of m67 ( at an age of @xmath157 gyr ; @xcite ) ranges from @xmath158 km s@xmath2 , with a best estimate of @xmath159 km s@xmath2 ( see * ? ? ? * de grijs et al . , in prep . ) , while the velocity dispersion of praesepe ( m44 ) is @xmath160 km s@xmath2 @xcite , at an age of @xmath161 myr @xcite . m35 ( @xmath162 ; @xcite ) is characterized by @xmath163 from @xmath164 km s@xmath2 @xcite to @xmath165 km s@xmath2 @xcite . although we refer the reader for further details on the kinematic structure and long - term stability of galactic open clusters to a forthcoming paper ( de grijs et al . , in prep . ) , these examples show that in order for an open cluster to survive for a few @xmath151 yr , its velocity dispersion needs to be sufficiently small so as to prevent early dissolution of the cluster due to internal kinematic effects . neither of the clusters discussed in this paper satisfies this empirical condition . the only old ( @xmath166 ; @xcite ) galactic open cluster with a measured velocity dispersion in excess of the range indicated above is m11 , with @xmath163 from @xmath167 km s@xmath2 @xcite to 2.9 km s@xmath2 @xcite ; the latter measurement was later reduced to 2.0 km s@xmath2 @xcite . this high velocity dispersion , for an ostensibly stable _ massive _ open cluster , is still more than a factor of two below that of ngc 6530 , which is both significantly less massive and less compact than m11 , and thus less stable to kinematic dissolution . 1 . from the photographic plate data of the shanghai astronomical observatory , the proper motions of stars in the region of the open clusters ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 were reduced by means of a central - overlapping technique , and the distribution parameters of the clusters as well as the membership probabilities of the individual stars in the cluster region were determined using a maximum likelihood principle . both clusters show clear evidence of mass segregation , but there is no definite evidence for a velocity ( dispersion)-mass ( or , equivalently , a velocity - luminosity ) dependence in these clusters . the observed mass segregation might be due to a combination of both initial conditions and relaxation processes . based on arguments related to the clusters imfs , in conjunction with our new measurements of their internal velocity dispersions , we provide strong arguments in favor of the dissolution of ngc 2244 on very short time - scales , while we speculate that ngc 6530 may be more stable against the effects of internal two - body relaxation . rdg was partially supported by an `` international joint project '' grant , jointly funded by the royal society in the uk and the chinese national science foundation ( nsfc ) . lc & jlz want to thank dr . peter stetson of dao for his kind help in measuring plates with the pds machine . lc and jlz are supported by the nsfc ( grant nos . 10333050 , 10333020).this research has made use of the webda database , operated at the institute for astronomy of the university of vienna . baba , d. , et al . 2004 , apj , 614 , 818 berghfer , t . w. , & christian , d. j. 2002 , a&a , 384 , 890 blitz , l. , & stark , a . a. 1986 , apj , 300 , l89 bonnell , i. a. , bate , m. r. , clarke , c. j. , & pringle , j . e. 1997 , mnras , 285 , 201 bonnell , i. a. , & davies , m. b. 1998 , mnras , 295 , 691 bonnell , i. a. , bate , m. r. , & zinnecker , h. 1998,mnras , 298 , 93 bonnell , i. a. , bate , m. r.,clarke , c. j. , & pringle , j. e. 2001a , mnras , 323 , 785 bonnell , i. a. , clarke , c. j. , bate , m. r. , & pringle , j . e. 2001b , mnras , 324 , 573 brandl , b. , sams , b. j. , bertoldi , f. , eckart , a.,genzel , r. , drapatz , s. , hofmann , r. , lwe , m. , & quirrenbach , a. 1996 , apj , 466 , 254 campbell , b. , et al . 1992 , aj , 104 , 1721 carpenter , j. m. , meyer , m. r. , dougados , c. , strom , s . e. , & hillenbrand , l. a. 1997 , aj , 114 , 198 chen , w. p. , chiang , p.s . & 2004 , chjaa , 4 , 153 chernoff , d. f. , & shapiro , s. l. 1987 , apj , 322 , 113 chernoff , d. f. , & weinberg , m. d. 1990 , apj , 351 , 121 chini , r. , & neckel , t. 1981 , a&a , 102 , 171 cudworth , k. 1976 , aj , 81 , 519 damiani , f. , et al . 2004 , , 608 , 781 damiani , f. , prisinzano , l. , micela , g. , & sciortino , s. 2006 , a&a , 459 , 477 de grijs , r. , gilmore , g. f. , johnson , r. a. , & mackey , a. d. 2002a , , 331 , 245 de grijs , r. , gilmore , g. f. , mackey , a. d. , wilkinson , m. i. , beaulieu , s. f. , johnson , r. a. , & santiago , b. x. 2002b , , 337 , 597 girard , t. m. , grundy , w. m. , lpez , c. e. , & van altena , w. f. 1989 , aj , 98 , 227 goodwin , s. p. 1997 , mnras , 284 , 785 hensberge , h. , pavlovski , k. , & verschueren , w. 2000 , a&a , 358 , 553 higuera g. , m. a. , uribe , a. , & barrera , r. s. 2002 , rev . . de conf . ) , 14 , 33 hillenbrand , l. a. 1997 , aj , 113 , 1733 hillenbrand , l. a. , & hartmann , l. e. 1998 , apj , 492 , 540 hg e. , fabricius c. , makarov v.v . , urban s. , corbin t. , wycoff g. , bastian u. , schwekendiek p. & wicenec a. 2000 , a&a , 355 , l27 hunter , d. a. , shaya , e. j. , holtzman , j. a. , light , r. m. , oneil , e. j. , & lynds , r. 1995 , apj , 448 , 179 jones , b. 1971 , aj , 76 , 470 kalirai , j. s. , fahlman , g. g. , richer , h. b. , & ventura , p. 2003 , aj , 126 , 1402 king , i. 1966 , aj , 71 , 64 lada , c. j. , gottlieb , c. a. , gottlieb , e. w. , & gull , t. r. 1976 , apj , 203 , 159 lada , e. a. , depoy , d. l. , evans , n. j. , & gatley , i. 1991 , apj , 371 , 171 larson , r. b. 1991 , in : fragmentation of molecular clouds and star formation , iau symp . 147 , falgarone , e. , boulanger , f. , & duvert , g. , eds . , dordrecht : kluwer , p. 261 larson , r. b. 1993 , in : the globular cluster galaxy connection , smith , g. h. , & brodie , j. p. , eds . , asp conf . 48 , ( asp : san francisco ) , p. 675 larson , r. b. 2003 , asp conf . ser . , 287 , 65 li , j. z. 2005 , apj , 625 , 242 li , j. z. , & smith , m. d. 2005a , a&a , 431 , 925 li , j. z. , & smith , m. d. 2005b , aj , 130 , 721 lohman , w. 1972 , astron . nachr . , 293 , 259 loktin , a. v. , & beshenov , g. v. 2001 , astr . , 27 , 386 malumuth , e. m. , & heap , s. r. 1994 , aj , 107 , 1054 marschall , l. a. , van altena , w. f. , & chiu , l .- t . 1982 , aj , 87 , 1497 massey , p. , johnson , k. e. , & degioia - eastwood , k. 1995 , apj , 454 , 151 mathieu , r. d. 1984 , apj , 284 , 643 matthews , w. g. 1967 , apj , 147 , 965 mccall , m. l. , richer , m. g. , & visvanathan , n. 1990 , apj , 357 , 502 mcnamara , b. j. , & sanders , w. l. 1977 , a&a , 54 , 569 mcnamara , b. j. , & sekiguchi , k. 1986 , aj , 310 , 613 mermilliod , j .- c . , & paunzen , e. 2003 , a&a , 410 , 511 odenkirchen , m. , soubiran , c. , & colin , j. 1998 , newa , 3 , 583 ogura , k. , & ishida , k. 1981 , pasj , 33 , 149 park , b .- , & sung , h. , 2002 , aj , 123 , 892 paunzen , e. , & netopil , m. 2006 , mnras , 371 , 1641 prez , m. r. , the , p. s. , & westerlund , b. e. , 1987 , pasp , 99 , 1050 prez , m. r. , jones , m. d. , the , p. s. , & westerlund , b. e. 1989 , pasp , 101,195 prez , m. r. 1991 , rev . mex . a&a , 22 , 99 portegies zwart , s. f. , gaburov , e. , chen , h .- c . , & grkan , m. a. 2007 , mnras ( letters ) , in press ( astro - ph/0702693 ) prisinzano , l. , damiani , f. , micela , g. , & sciortino , s. 2005 , a&a , 430 , 941 prisinzano , l. , damiani , f. , micela , g. , & pillitteri , i. 2007 , a&a , 462 , 123 rauw , g. , naz , y. , gosset , e. , stevens , i. r. , blomme , r. , corcoran , m. f. , pittard , j. m. , & runacres , m. c. 2002 , a&a , 395 , 499 russell , j. l. 1976 , ph.d . thesis , university of pittsburgh sabogal - martnez , b. e. , garca - varela , j. a. , higuera g. , m. a. , uribe , a. , & brieva , e. 2001 , rev . a&a , 37 , 105 sagar , r. , & joshi , u. c. 1978 , mnras , 184 , 467 salpeter , e. e. 1955 , apj , 121 , 161 smith , l. j. , & gallagher , j. s. iii 2001 , mnras , 326 , 1027 sterzik , m. f. , alcala , j. m. , neuhuser , r. , & schmitt , j. h. m. m. 1995 , a&a , 297 , 418 stilburn , j. r. , stetson , p. b. , & fisher , w. a. 1992 , jrasc , 86 , 140 sung , h. , bessell , m. s. , lee h .- w . , kang , y. h. , & lee , s .- w . 1999 , mnras , 310 , 982 sung , h. , chun , m .- y . , & bessell , m. s. 2000 , aj , 120 , 333 the , p .- s . 1960 , apj , 132 , 40 townsley , l. k. , feigelson , e. d. , montmerle , t. , broos , p. s. , chu , y .- h . , & garmire , g. p. 2003 , apj , 593 , 874 turner , d. g. 1976 , apj , 210 , 65 van altena , w. f. , & jones , b. f. 1972 , a&a , 20 , 425 van den ancker , m. e. , the , p. s. , feinstein , a. , vzquez , r. a. , de winter , d. , & prez , m. r. 1997 , a&as , 123 , 63 van schewick , h. 1958 , veroff . sternwarte , no . 51 verschueren , w. 1991 , ph.d . thesis , vrije univ . brussels ( vub ) walker , m. f. 1957 , apj , 125 , 636 wang , j. j. , chen , l. , & zhao , j. h. 1996 , acta astr . sin . , 37 , 68 wang , j. j. 1997 , annals of shanghai observatory , acad . sinica , 18 , 45 wen , w. , zhao , j .- l . , & chen , l. 2006 , chin . a&a , 30 , 274 williams , j. p. , blitz , l. , & stark , a. a. 1995 , apj , 451 , 252 zhao , j .- l . , chen , l. , & wen w. 2006 , chja&a , 4 , 435 zhao , j. l. , & he , y. p. 1987 , acta astr . sin . , 28 , 374 cccccc [ tab1 ] @xmath49 & @xmath168 & @xmath169 & & @xmath168 & @xmath170 + @xmath171 & @xmath172 & @xmath173 & & @xmath174 & @xmath175 + @xmath176 & 1.39 mas yr@xmath2 & 8.88 mas yr@xmath2 & & 0.95 mas yr@xmath2 & 2.74 mas yr@xmath2 + @xmath177 & 1.56 mas yr@xmath2 & 9.54 mas yr@xmath2 & & 1.21 mas yr@xmath2 & 4.05 mas yr@xmath2 + cccc @xmath178(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath179 & & @xmath180 + @xmath181(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath182 & & @xmath183 + @xmath184(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath185 & & @xmath186 + @xmath187(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath188 & & @xmath189 + @xmath190(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath191 & & @xmath192 + @xmath193(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath194 & & @xmath195 + @xmath196(mas yr@xmath2 ) & @xmath197 & & @xmath198 + @xmath199 & @xmath200 & & @xmath201 + @xmath202 & @xmath203 & & @xmath204 + @xmath205 & @xmath206 & & @xmath207 + rrrrrrrrr 1 & 06 31 35.826 & + 04 30 51.70 & @xmath2086.142 & 0.919 & 4.685 & 0.405 & 8.720 & 0.62 + 2 & 06 32 10.470 & + 04 57 59.75 & @xmath2081.600 & 1.486 & @xmath2080.421 & 2.184 & 8.350 & 0.92 + 3 & 06 31 36.322 & + 04 55 59.53 & 0.336 & 0.464 & @xmath2084.710 & 1.008 & 8.830 & 0.89 + 4 & 06 31 38.396 & + 05 01 36.38 & @xmath2081.673 & 0.639 & @xmath2080.232 & 1.303 & 8.110 & 0.89 + 5 & 06 31 16.839 & + 04 37 25.92 & @xmath2080.074 & 0.425 & @xmath2083.398 & 1.127 & 9.039 & 0.73 + rrrrrrrrr 1 & 18 04 25.848 & @xmath20824 23 08.27 & 6.469 & 0.815 & @xmath2086.376 & 2.249 & 8.55 & 0.94 + 2 & 18 06 04.702 & @xmath20824 11 43.84 & 5.989 & 0.591 & @xmath2088.649 & 1.670 & 8.64 & 0.83 + 3 & 18 04 15.222 & @xmath20824 11 00.07 & 2.958 & 0.877 & @xmath2082.713 & 1.067 & 9.12 & 0.99 + 4 & 18 02 39.798 & @xmath20824 14 47.40 & 7.732 & 0.405 & 0.474 & 3.538 & 9.22 & 0.74 + 5 & 18 04 14.538 & @xmath20824 14 36.31 & 8.511 & 0.853 & 9.241 & 1.665 & 9.35 & 0.00 +
Abstract: | [
"we derive the proper motions , membership probabilities , and velocity dispersions of stars in the regions of the young ( @xmath0 myr - old ) open clusters ngc 2244 ( the central cluster in the monoceros r2 association ) and ngc 6530 ( the dominant cluster in the sgr ob1 association ) from photographic plate material obtained at shanghai astronomical observatory , with time baselines of 34 and 87 years , respectively . both clusters show clear evidence of mass segregation , but they do not exhibit any significant velocity - mass ( or , equivalently , a velocity - luminosity ) dependence . this provides strong support for the suggestion that the observed mass segregation is at least partially due to the way in which star formation has proceeded in these complex star - forming regions ( `` primordial '' mass segregation ) . based on arguments related to the clusters published initial mass functions , in conjunction with our new measurements of their internal velocity dispersions ( @xmath1 and 8 km s@xmath2 for ngc 2244 and ngc 6530 , respectively ) , we provide strong arguments in favor of the dissolution of ngc 2244 on very short time - scales , while we speculate that ngc 6530 may be more stable against the effects of internal two - body relaxation . however , this latter object may well be destroyed by the strong tidal field prevalent at its location in the galactic plane in the direction of the galactic center ."
] | 10,618 | 10,618 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: constraints on dark matter self - scattering cross - section can be obtained from astrophysical observations . upper limits on the cross - section per unit mass , @xmath6 have been computed , most famously , from the bullet cluster @xcite which is a plane of the sky collision between two galaxy clusters . the distribution of mass was measured using lensing , and that of the gas using observations of its x - ray emission . from the consistency of the mass - to - light ratios of the sub - cluster and the main cluster , which implies that very little dark matter was lost due to self - interaction during the merger , @xcite derive an upper limit on the cross - section , as @xmath7 @xmath3 g@xmath4 . based on the same argument , but using @xmath8-body simulations to model the collision , @xcite derive @xmath9 @xmath3 g@xmath4 . the authors note that because the separation on the sky between the centroid of the visible galaxies and dark matter is consistent with zero , the dark matter s interaction cross - section is @xmath10 @xmath3 g@xmath4 . relaxed clusters offer a different route to the upper limit on @xmath6 . random scattering between dark matter particles will tend to make the dense cluster core more spherical . @xcite used an elliptical core of ms2137 - 23 to place an upper limit of @xmath11 @xmath3 g@xmath4 . the value relies on the assumption that the measured ellipticity comes solely from the cluster core , instead of projection of mass from outside the core , and that there has been no recent merger activity in the cluster . this is the most stringent upper limit on @xmath6 from astrophysical observations . clusters also present a potential opportunity to measure a lower limit on @xmath6 ( c.f . @xcite ) consider galaxies in the central regions of a cluster . these galaxies , usually ellipticals , consist of a compact stellar component and a more extended dark matter halo . as galaxies orbit the cluster centre , they move through the ambient dark matter halo of the cluster . the galaxies stellar matter and dark matter interact with the ambient dark matter differently . the motion of stars is subject to the gravitational field of the cluster and is unaffected by individual dark matter particles . the galaxies dark matter particles , on the other hand , can interact and scatter off the cluster s dark matter , thereby retarding the forward motion of galaxy s dark matter , making it lag behind the stellar component of the galaxy . if the scattering cross - section and the density of dark matter are large enough , this drag force will eventually result in a spatial separation between the stellar and dark matter components of the galaxy , which might be detectable . one can quantify the above scenario and estimate the separation as a function of relevant parameters . assume that the mass of the core of the cluster interior to the centre of the galaxy is @xmath12 , the dark matter and the stellar masses of the galaxy are @xmath13 and @xmath14 , respectively , and their average distance from the core are , @xmath15 . let the cross - sectional area of the galaxy s dark matter halo be @xmath16 . the force of gravity between the cluster core and the two components of the galaxy are , respectively , @xmath17 @xmath18.\label{newtdm}\ ] ] in the second equation gravity is partly counteracted , or screened by the self - interaction and scattering between the core s and galaxy s dark matter particles . the quantity @xmath19 is the covering factor , or the ` optical depth ' , and is assumed to be small . over time , the difference in the two accelerations amounts to a displacement , or separation @xmath20 if ( i ) the galaxy orbit were exactly radial , ( ii ) the cluster s dark matter space density scaled as @xmath21 , so @xmath22 were independent of radius at all epochs , ( iii ) the spatial distribution of stars and dark matter within the galaxy were point - like , and ( iv ) the expression in the square brackets in eq . [ newtdm ] were an appropriate way to quantify the retarding force , then the displacement would be exactly @xmath23 . of these , assumption ( iv ) is the least objectionable and will lead to a relatively small error . assumption ( iii ) , if it is not valid and dark matter halos are actually extended and overlapping , will tend to underestimate the force in equation ( [ newtdm ] ) and hence the separation @xmath24 . then a larger cross - section would be required to produce a given displacement . hence a point - like mass distributions is conservative , if a lower limit on @xmath6 is being sought . assumptions ( i ) and ( ii ) , and the @xmath25 dependence of @xmath24 in eq . [ disp ] combined summarize the dynamical evolution of the cluster and the galaxy s orbit , and are not necessarily independent of each other . for a typical relaxed cluster the central density profile is not too far from @xmath21 , however , it is not expected to be exactly that , and would have most likely varied over time . consequently , the shape of the galaxy s orbit and how it evolved in the past is important , and would constitute the largest source of uncertainty in @xmath24 . equation [ disp ] can be rewritten as @xmath26 thus , for typical values of masses and distances , and assuming that the self - scattering cross - section is at most a few decades below the most stringent astrophysically obtained upper limit , the separation between the dark and visible components of galaxies will be or order of kpc , and hence potentially observable . our order - of - magnitude estimate can be compared to the results of @xmath8-body simulations carried out by @xcite , who modeled the bullet cluster . for the specific geometry and parameters of that cluster , and assuming @xmath27 @xmath3 gm@xmath4 , the separation between the stellar and dark matter in the sub - cluster can be read off from their figure 5 , as @xmath28 kpc . this is smaller than the separation we get for the parameters assumed in eq . [ dispunits ] . the main difference between the two estimates is due to the nature of the encounters in the two cases . in the bullet cluster , the two merging clusters made one passage past each other , so that the sub - cluster spent little time in the dense core region of the larger cluster . for the bullet cluster , the current separation of the sub - components is 720 kpc . a merger velocity of 4700 km s@xmath4 ( following * ? ? ? * ) gives an encounter time of @xmath29 yrs . the velocity may well be significantly lower @xcite . but @xcite report that velocity of @xmath30 2800 km s@xmath4 would not greatly change their results . in the scenario we outlined above , the galaxies have been orbiting the inner cluster core for about a hubble time . also , @xmath31 kpc is a more appropriate value for the bullet cluster . taking these in to account , eq . [ dispunits ] gives @xmath32 kpc , comparable to their estimate of @xmath28 kpc . thus , the bullet cluster itself is a ( limited ) test of eq . [ dispunits ] . this comparison with the bullet cluster demonstrates that the longer duration of the encounter and smaller distances in our scenario give rise to a larger separation , more likely to be detected . abell 3827 is rather unique ; it is a nearby example of a multiple galactic cannibalism in progress , where the massive central ellipticals are closely surrounded by lensed images . the cluster s dynamical state , its proximity to us , and the fortuitous lensing configuration make it a prime candidate for detecting any displacement between the dark and visible matter due to non - zero dark matter scattering cross - section . in this paper we use strongly lensed images to reconstruct the mass distribution in the core of abell 3827 . as we will show , the core contains a galaxy whose visible and total mass are apparently separated by a few kpc . one possible interpretation of this result is the scenario described in the previous section . the cluster s lensing features were recently discovered by @xcite , whose findings we summarize below . abell 3827 ( @xmath33 ) appears to be in the last stages of merger @xcite . the outer cluster looks smooth and relaxed , and there are no significant secondary galaxy concentrations . the core of the cluster contains five ellipticals , called @xmath34 , within @xmath35 kpc of the centre , which appear to be in the process of spiraling inwards to form a single central galaxy . these ellipticals have probably undergone several orbits around the centre and have been tidally stripped , as evidenced by the extended @xmath36 diffuse light around the core . @xcite estimate the velocity dispersion of the cluster to be @xmath37 km s@xmath4 , making abell 3827 a rather massive cluster . the relative radial velocities of @xmath38 are within 400 km s@xmath4 of each other . the velocity of @xmath39 is about @xmath40 km s@xmath4 compared to the systemic velocity . @xmath41 is probably not a part of the cluster core because its velocity is about @xmath42 km s@xmath4 and its magnitude is @xmath43 fainter compared to that of the other four ellipticals . the cluster core lenses ( at least ) two background sources ; the main source , at @xmath44 , is extended and consists of at least three knots , @xmath45 . all three appear to be lensed into quads , but in one quad only three images are identified , and in another , only two . the second source , at @xmath46 , forms a single arc ; a counter arc may be lost in in the glare of the ellipticals . based on their spatial distribution , the images of the quads can be labelled by their time order , even though time delays have not been measured ( cf . accordingly , we will write @xmath47 to mean the @xmath48th arriving image of the @xmath49th knot within source @xmath50 . the images to the north - east of the cluster s centre of light are the 1st arriving ones ; the two sets of images in the west are ( clockwise ) the 3rd and 2nd arriving , and finally the images to the south - east are 4th arriving . the 2nd and 3rd arriving images are close together and form a nearly merging pairs across the critical curve . one can loosely divide the lens modeling methods into two categories , depending on the prior information they use . the fixed - form methods assume that mass follows light , and parametrize this relation with a handful of scalings . free - form methods use different types of priors ; most notably they do not require that mass trace light . the authors of the discovery paper , @xcite carried out a lensing mass reconstruction using lenstool , a fixed - form method @xcite . the reconstruction reproduces the positions of only 5 of the 10 images well . the mean scatter between observed and recovered images is less than @xmath51 , while the astrometric uncertainty is @xmath52 . overall , the mass model has @xmath53 per degree of freedom , indicating that there is additional information in the astrometry . this is not surprising ; the dynamical state of the cluster core is probably unsettled , so it is quite possible that light does not follow mass . this , combined with fact that abell 3827 has a relatively large number of lensed images ten makes a free - form reconstruction a logical choice . we use a free - form reconstruction method , pixelens @xcite . the reconstruction is done in a circular window , which is divided into many equal - sized square pixels . the mass within each pixel is uniformly distributed but each pixel s mass value is allowed to vary independently of others . pixelens takes advantage of the fact that the lensing equation is linear in the mass pixels and in the coordinates of the source , and so it is relatively straightforward to come up with solutions that reproduce image positions exactly . in fact , since the unknowns outnumber the knowns ( coordinates of the lensed images ) by a large factor , an infinity of solutions are possible . pixelens generates a user - specified number of individual models , according to a weak and adjustable prior of which the ensemble average is considered in this paper . the prior and the model - sampling technique are motivated and explained in detail in the above papers , so here we just remark on two points that are important for the modelling . first , along with the image positions , a notional centre must be given . the default behaviour of pixelens is to require the local density everywhere to point at most @xmath54 away from the centre . in this work we increase the allowed angle ( called dgcone for `` density - gradient cone '' ) somewhat , typically to @xmath55 this allows more substructure , as appears to be demanded by the data . second , to account for the mass exterior to the modeling window , pixelens can add external shear of any magnitude . the shear axis can be within @xmath54 of a user - specified shear direction , denoted by shear . we typically set shear 60 on the basis of the axis of the diffuse light on arcminute scale around the cluster core which permits any shear orientation from @xmath56 to @xmath57 . the version of the lens - reconstruction software used is included as an online supplement . other examples of free - form techniques for cluster lenses are described in @xcite and @xcite . to start with , we create a reference , or fiducial reconstruction . it uses all the 10 images identified by @xcite . as the centre we use the centre of light ( also the centre of their figure 2 frame ) , which is about @xmath58 west of n2 . at the redshift of the cluster , @xmath59 , the critical surface mass density for sources at infinity is @xmath60 gm/@xmath3 , and @xmath61 corresponds to 1.93 kpc , for @xmath62 , @xmath63 , and @xmath64 . the diameter of the reconstruction window was set to 29 pixels , with the scale of @xmath65/pixel , so the angular and physical size of the window are about @xmath66 and 77 kpc , respectively . the fiducial pixelens reconstruction is shown in figure [ kmass ] ; the mass density contours are spaced by @xmath67 . the map is an average of 500 individual models . ( the mass map is not sensitive to the number of individual models in the ensemble as long as it is greater than @xmath68 , the pixel size within the range @xmath69-@xmath58 per pixel , or the orientation of the reconstruction window with respect to the cardinal directions . ) figure [ massenc ] is a plot of mass enclosed as a function of radius . our fiducial reconstruction is indistinguishable from the average of 18 reconstructions discussed in sections [ effp ] and [ effs ] , and shown as the red thick line . the thin dotted lines are all the 18 models , and the errorbars represent their rms dispersion . the two blue solid flanking lines enclose 90% of the 500 individual mass models of the fiducial reconstruction . note that at large radii , i.e. outside the images , the enclosed mass begins to level off since the image positions do not require any mass at those radii . however , the 90% errorbars are fully consistent with the density profile continuing on with the same slope as at smaller radii . figure [ karriv ] shows the arrival time contours of the @xmath70 and @xmath71 knots of source @xmath50 . from the contours , we see that the model indicates extra images appearing next to the first arriving image of @xmath70 . these may be spurious , or may actually be present , depending on the local mass substructure . they do not , however , affect the larger - scale features of the mass maps , which are the focus of this paper . the plot of arrival - time contours also provides a simple model for the ring - like extended image ( cf . * ) which in this case arises from the extended source @xmath50 . detailed comparison would , however , be very difficult because the ring is faint and in many places overlaid with the light from the ellipticals . we have not attempted to use the arc @xmath72 as a lensing constraint , since it has no identified counter image . in principle it is possible to extract some strong - lensing information from this arc . if pointlike features could be identified , they could be put in as multiple - image constraints in the usual way . another possibility would be to assume two fictitious image positions along the arc , which in models would have the effect of forcing a critical curve to pass through the arc . the mass contours in figure [ kmass ] show deviations from circular symmetry , which are due to mass inhomogeneities in the lens . we isolate these by subtracting a smooth component , as follows . figure [ profile ] shows pixel mass as a function of the distance from the centre of the fiducial reconstruction . as already mentioned when discussing figure [ massenc ] , the lack of lensing constraints beyond about 20 kpc leads pixelens to put very little mass into those pixels ; so the tapering off of points in figure [ profile ] is an artifact . the average projected density profile slope where the images constrain the mass well , i.e. around @xmath73 , is @xmath74 , and is representative of most mass maps in this paper . this is shown as the thick straight line in this log - log plot ; the other two lines have slopes of @xmath75 and @xmath76 , and represent the reasonable range of possible power - law slopes . to isolate the mass inhomogeneities we subtract circularly symmetric density profile of slope @xmath77 from the reconstructed mass maps ; a change of @xmath78 in the assumed smooth profile slope would not have made a significant difference . the normalization of the subtracted profile is adjusted such that the contours of substructure , or the excess mass density left after the subtraction of the smooth cluster profile , contain 0.5 , 1 , 2 , 4 and 8 % of the total mass within the full @xmath66 window . this normalization is calculated separately for each mass map and each of the five contour levels . figure [ fiducial ] shows the five contour levels of the mass substructure , as red solid lines ; thicker lines represent contours of smaller enclosed mass . images are shown as black solid dots , and labeled at the periphery of the figure . the arc @xmath79 has no detected counter images . image @xmath80 was not identified by @xcite , but looking at their figure 2 , the present authors feel @xmath80 is the location of that image . it is not used in the fiducial reconstruction but is used in some other ones . galaxies are denoted by green squares and labeled as in @xcite ; @xmath41 is a smaller square because the galaxy is probably background and less massive . figure [ fiducial ] shows that the mass substructure does not trace the visible galaxies , an indication that the cluster core is not in equilibrium , but is dynamically disturbed . there is one dominant mass clump , to the north east ( upper left ) of galaxy @xmath81 , but not centered on @xmath81 . this clump is the main subject of the paper , and we will refer to it as the ne-@xmath81 clump . a smaller clump is between galaxies @xmath82 , and seems to be avoiding @xmath83 . the following sections will demonstrate that even though the details of the reconstructions differ , the main features of this fiducial mass map , and most importantly the existence and location of ne-@xmath81 clump , and the lack of mass associated with @xmath83 , are robust to changes in priors , centre of the reconstruction window , and , to some degree , the subsets of images used in reconstruction . figure [ lots3 ] shows maps of substructure mass contours for nine reconstructions . the image set used is the same as in the fiducial case , but the priors are different . the assumed values of dgcone , and shear are shown in each panel . since the cluster core is most likely not in equilibrium , we tried three different lens centres . the fiducial one is called @xmath84 , and was identified by @xcite as the cluster s centre of light ; it sits between @xmath83 and @xmath85 . centre @xmath86 is shifted by @xmath87 from @xmath84 and is close to @xmath85 . centre @xmath88 is shifted by @xmath89 with respect to @xmath84 ; it coincides with the location of galaxy @xmath83 , the central - most elliptical in the core . the three choices for the lens centre are used in the reconstructions of the three rows of figure [ lots3 ] , respectively . their location is marked with a cross . ( we remark again that the lens centre in pixelens is needed because the density gradients , used for dgcone , are calculated with respect to the lens centre . the other utility of the lens centre will be put to use in section [ cent ] . ) figure [ lots3 ] shows that all reconstructions , with the possible exception of the middle panel of the third row , require a mass lump to the ne of galaxy @xmath81 . the size and position of the lump vary between panels , but in none of these is the lump centered on @xmath81 ; it is always to the upper left of that galaxy . the other common feature is that @xmath83 has relatively little excess mass associated with it . the nearby mass clump sometimes encompasses @xmath85 or @xmath39 , but not @xmath83 . figure [ lots4 ] shows the effect of leaving out some of the lensed images from the reconstruction . the images plotted in each panel are the only ones used in the corresponding reconstruction . the lens centre is always @xmath84 , and the pixelens priors are shown in each panel . most changes to the image set makes little difference to the global features of the recovered mass maps , and specifically the ne-@xmath81 mass clump . since this mass clump is of primary interest for us , we examine its dependence on the images more closely . from this figure , and other reconstructions not shown here , we know that the single most important image that determines the location of the clump near @xmath81 is image @xmath90 . in the lower right panel @xmath90 was not used , and the mass clump moved to a different , lower , or more southerly , location . in that reconstruction , both the mass distribution and the image configuration have an approximate bilateral symmetry , with the axis inclined by @xmath91 to the @xmath92-axis . the location of @xmath90 predicted by such a bilaterally symmetric mass distribution would have been very close to the observed @xmath93 . however , the observed @xmath90 is about @xmath94 clockwise from @xmath93 . to make that happen , one needs a large mass clump roughly where pixelens puts the ne-@xmath81 clump . this can be understood in terms of the arrival time surface . @xmath90 is a saddle point image . a sufficiently large mass just outside of the image circle will create a local bump in the arrival time surface and a saddle point will be created between it and the centre of the lens . in section [ expl ] we will present additional arguments to show why @xmath90 requires a large mass to exist beyond the location of galaxy @xmath81 . one might be tempted to say that @xmath90 has been misidentified , and is actually much closer to @xmath93 . if that is assumed , the reconstructed mass and observed galaxy positions bear no correspondence to each other , as shown in the lower right panel of figure [ lots4 ] . furthermore , the imaging data as presented in @xcite shows a definite , though faint smudge at the location of @xmath90 . we conclude that @xmath90 is real , and hence the true mass distribution is close to what our fiducial reconstruction looks like . the mass substructure , i.e. the excess left after subtracting the smooth cluster profile , of all eighteen reconstructions of figures [ lots3 ] and [ lots4 ] are superimposed in figure [ superpose ] . for clarity , we plot only the contours enclosing 1% of the total mass in every reconstruction . the figure highlights the features common to most reconstructions : the massive ne-@xmath81 mass clump , and the secondary clump around galaxies @xmath85 and @xmath39 , which avoids @xmath83 . the main goal of the paper is to estimate the lower limit on the dark matter cross - section using eq . [ dispunits ] as applied to galaxy @xmath81 and the ne-@xmath81 mass clump . in this section we estimate the parameters associated with the ne-@xmath81 clump , namely , its mass , @xmath13 , size , @xmath95 , and distance from @xmath81 , @xmath24 , and give a measure of dispersion in these properties between reconstructions . figure [ superpose ] gives a visual impression of the systematic uncertainties in our reconstructions . because the shape and location of the ne-@xmath81 clump is not exactly the same in various reconstructions , there is no unique way of quantifying its average properties and estimating the dispersion in these properties between the various mass maps . we chose to use an iso - density mass substructure contour to define the clump , and the corresponding mass excess within that contour as the clump s mass , its center of mass as the center of the clump , and the enclosed area , @xmath50 , to define the size of the clump , i.e. @xmath96 . first , we need to decide what to take as the boundary of the clump . in most reconstructions , including the fiducial one , the mass substructure contours containing 0.5 and 1% of the total mass are disjointed , and enclose separate mass clumps , while the contours containing 4 and 8% of the total mass form one contiguous region . this suggests that @xmath97 of the total recovered mass is in the individual clumps , therefore we take the closed 1% contour located to the ne of the @xmath81 galaxy as defining the clump . two of the reconstructions , the bottom middle in figure [ lots3 ] and the bottom right in figure [ lots4 ] have no excess mass at 1% level in the vicinity of @xmath81 , so we exclude them . with these choices , the average and rms dispersion in the mass of the ne-@xmath81 clump based on the 16 maps is @xmath98 , its distance from the centre of the elliptical @xmath81 is @xmath99 , and its size @xmath100 . our fiducial reconstruction gives @xmath101 , @xmath102 , and @xmath103 , all of which are within the rms of the 16 maps , so when estimating @xmath6 in section [ dmx ] we will use the fiducial values . we also need to estimate @xmath104 , the clumps distance from the cluster centre . equation [ disp ] assumes that the centre of the elliptical galaxy and the centre of its displaced dark matter halo are equidistant from the cluster centre , i.e. @xmath105 since the displacement @xmath24 is small . therefore we take @xmath106 , same for all reconstructions . the uncertainty in @xmath104 comes from the uncertainty in the location of the cluster centre . in section [ cent ] below we show that the latter is of order @xmath107 , which translated into a fractional error , which is smaller than that in the other two relevant lengths , @xmath24 or @xmath95 . while the errors in the estimated properties of the ne-@xmath81 mass clump are relatively small , @xmath108 , we stress that these are not the main sources of uncertainty in estimating the parameters of the dark matter particle cross - section , @xmath6 . the dominant sources of uncertainty are the unknown dynamics of the cluster , the evolution in cluster core s density profile slope , and the galaxy orbit shape , especially that of elliptical @xmath81 ( see section [ intro ] ) , and can not be quantified using lensing data . to properly address these one would need to carry out a series of n - body simulations with a range of initial conditions . based on their observations , @xcite quote image astrometric uncertainty of @xmath52 . since pixelens reproduces image positions exactly , we need to check if astrometric errors could have affected our results . here we redo the fiducial reconstruction but randomly shift the observed images within @xmath109 of their true positions . five realizations are shown in figure [ fake ] . to reduce run - time , we used 300 models to create an ensemble , instead of the usual 500 . since all five reconstructions look very similar and have small rms dispersions ( @xmath110 and @xmath111 ) , smaller than the ones presented in the section [ props ] we conclude that astrometric errors have not affected our results . in addition to the ne-@xmath81 clump , the other notable feature of the reconstructions is that regardless of the input model parameters ( see figures [ fiducial]-[fake ] ) there is very little mass excess associated with @xmath83 , the centrally located elliptical galaxy . this suggests that the peak of the mass distribution is not very close to @xmath83 . here we ask which one of our three trial centres , @xmath84 , @xmath86 , or @xmath88 comes closest to the true cluster centre , defined as the location of the largest mass concentration . we use the following procedure . a pixelens pixel can assume any mass value provided it agrees with the image positions and priors , like dgcone and shear . if there is no smoothing , the resulting maps usually show a lot of fluctuations between neighbouring pixels . to avoid that , we impose a nearest neighbour smoothing constraint by requiring that a pixel can not have a mass value larger than twice the average of its eight neighbours . the only exception to this rule is the pixel at the centre of the reconstruction window , which has no imposed upper bound . it is reasonable to suppose that the closer the reconstruction centre is to the real centre , the more mass the central pixel will contain . from our total ( not substructure ) mass maps we calculate the fraction of total mass contained in the central pixel . for the centres @xmath84 , @xmath86 and @xmath88 we calculate that percentage of mass as @xmath112 , @xmath113 , and @xmath114 respectively . these values are averages and rms for the three sets of three maps shown in figure [ lots3 ] . recall that @xmath88 is centered on galaxy @xmath83 , whereas @xmath84 and @xmath86 correspond to blank spots between @xmath83 and @xmath85 . since the central pixel of @xmath88 contains the least mass , and has the smallest dispersion of the three cases , it supports our finding in the earlier sections that there is very little excess mass associated with the optical light of elliptical @xmath83 . of the three , centre @xmath86 is closest to the largest concentration of mass in the cluster . finding the centre of the cluster is not the main goal of the paper , however this section demonstrates that the uncertainty in the location of the centre is of order of @xmath107 , and hence smaller than fractional uncertainties in the other length measurements entering eq . [ dispunits ] , i.e. @xmath24 and @xmath95 , therefore when estimating @xmath104 it is reasonable to use @xmath84 as the centre of the cluster , as we have done in section [ props ] . to further test the robustness of the ne-@xmath81 mass clump we carry out a reconstruction where pixelens is allowed to add point masses at specified pixel locations . in other words , we allow some pixels to override the nearest neighbour constraint described in section [ cent ] . we chose pixels containing the observed galaxies @xmath81-@xmath39 , and use pixelens command ptmass x y area1 area2 , where x and y is the location of the point mass , and area1 area2 are the lower and upper limits on the area enclosed by its einstein ring . we used @xmath115 and @xmath0 arcsec@xmath116 as representative values for mass associated with individual galaxies . figure [ ptmass ] shows the results . the contour levels of the mass substructure are the same as before , at 0.5 , 1 , 2 , 4 , and 8% of total . there is a substantial amount of mass associated with individual galaxies , including @xmath81 , but a large mass to the upper left of @xmath81 is still required , as shown by the 1% substructure mass contour . in fact , the ne-@xmath81 clump , without the @xmath81 point mass , roughly contains @xmath117 , similar to what we find for the fiducial reconstruction , in section [ dmx ] . also consistent with earlier findings , is that compared to other ellipticals , @xmath83 has the least amount of mass associated with it . in this section we create a series of four synthetic mass distributions that illustrate why an excess mass lump is needed where pixelens places it , to the north east of @xmath81 . these synthetic maps have mass distributions similar enough to the real cluster to make the comparison meaningful . however the images produced by them do not attempt to exactly reproduce the observed images . in figure [ fourmassc ] the mass map in the upper left is roughly what abell 3827 would look like if mass followed light , in other words , mass clumps are placed at the observed locations of galaxies @xmath81-@xmath39 , indicated by the green squares . the blue contour has the critical surface mass density for @xmath118 . the black solid dots are the locations of the observed images of source @xmath70 . the four extended islands of red points mark the locations of images produced by this synthetic mass configuration . these images were selected such that the second arriving images cluster around the observed @xmath119 . the other images were unconstrained . the locations of the 1st , 2nd and 3rd arriving images can be relatively well reproduced by the mass - follows - light scenario . however , the 4th arriving images are consistently far from the observed @xmath90 . this is the basic reason why mass - follows - light models do not work . what does one have to do to ( approximately ) reproduce @xmath90 ? in the upper right panel of figure [ fourmassc ] we move the mass clump associated with @xmath81 to the left ( east ) . the 4th arriving images are hardly affected . next , in the lower left panel we keep the mass clump at its original position but increase its mass by @xmath120 . the configuration of images changes but the location of @xmath90 is still not reproduced . finally , in the lower right panel we move the mass clump to the left _ and _ increase its mass by @xmath120 . now the bulk of the 4th arriving images move to where the observed location of @xmath90 . this is basically the mass distribution that pixelens finds , with its massive ne-@xmath81 clump . a further test of the veracity of pixelens s reconstructions is to use the images created by the synthetic mass distributions of the previous section as input for pixelens . we use the mass distributions of the upper left and lower right panels of figure [ fourmassc ] . for each of these we take two quads from the red dots in figure [ fourmassc ] , for a total of eight images to be used as lensing constraints . the two panels of figure [ pxmass ] show the synthetic mass distributions as the smooth contours , while the jagged contours are the pixelens reconstructions . the black mass contours are at 0.25 , 0.5 , 0.75 and 2 of the critical surface mass density for @xmath118 , while the blue contour is at the critical density . the magenta empty circles are the images used in the reconstruction . the first of the two synthetic mass models ( left panel ) is approximately elliptical and does not have a mass lump to the left of the centre . pixelens recovers the mass map quite well ; most importantly it does not create a fictitious massive clump near the 4th arriving image . the second synthetic mass map ( right panel ) does have a mass clump , and pixelens recovers it well . the reconstructions of the preceding sections and the tests with synthetic lenses show that the two main features of the lensing mass reconstructions are robust . ( 1 ) the ne-@xmath81 mass clump is present consistently in most reconstructions , and it is never centered on galaxy @xmath81 . ( 2 ) the second , less massive clump is near galaxies @xmath85 and @xmath39 , but avoids @xmath83 , so that there is no excess mass associated with that central elliptical . we interpret ( 1 ) to mean that the visible and the dark components of @xmath81 are separated , and we hypothesize that the cause of the separation is the scenario described in section [ intro ] , namely that the scattering between the galaxy s and the cluster s dark matter particles induced the galaxy s halo to lag behind its stellar component . other interpretations of the observed separation are discussed in section [ other ] . conclusion ( 2 ) also speaks to the dynamically disturbed nature of the cluster core , though there is not enough information to speculate what happened to the halo of @xmath83 and how the mass clump is related to the nearby @xmath85 and @xmath39 . we now concentrate on ( 1 ) , and estimate @xmath6 from eq . [ dispunits ] and the parameters based on the reconstructions presented in sections [ effp ] and [ effs ] and summarized in section [ props ] . we do not consider the rms dispersions quoted in that section here , because the main source of uncertainty is not in the measured properties of the ne-@xmath81 clump , but in the dynamics of the cluster . for a conservative lower limit on @xmath6 we want to use the smallest linear distances , @xmath104 , @xmath95 , and @xmath24 consistent with the reconstruction , so we use the sky projected quantities , and make no attempt to estimate the corresponding three - dimensional values . to obtain @xmath12 we measure the projected mass within @xmath104 from figure [ massenc ] and halve it to account for the core being a sphere instead of a long tube ; @xmath121 . one major source of uncertainty is related to the quantity @xmath22 entering eq . [ dispunits ] . first , if @xmath22 depends on radius , i.e. distance from cluster center , then the unknown shape and ellipticity of @xmath81 s orbit and hence how it ` samples ' @xmath22 becomes an issue . second , the radial dependence of @xmath22 may well be time dependent . from our lensing reconstruction we can measure how this quantity scaled with radius at the present epoch . the projected @xmath122 , which implies that the space density @xmath123 , and mass enclosed @xmath124 , so @xmath125 . this is a relatively weak radial dependence , but it does not tell us much about the temporal dependence . in future work , these uncertainties can be constrained through n - body simulations that sample possible merger histories and have the present day configuration resembling abell 3827 . the other large source of uncertainty is also related to cluster dynamics , and it is @xmath5 , the duration of the encounter , because it can not be measured directly from the reconstruction . a lower limit on @xmath5 would be one dynamical time at the present radius if @xmath81 , roughly @xmath126yr . the upper limit is the age of the universe , @xmath127 yrs . the most likely @xmath5 would probably correspond to several dynamical times within the extended core region of the cluster , or @xmath128 yr . putting all the parameters together in to eq . [ dispunits ] we express the lower limit on the dark matter self - interaction cross - section as @xmath129 while this value is safely below the astrophysically measured upper limit on self - scattering , it is interesting to compare it to the estimates of the self - annihilation cross - section for dark matter particles , because in most particle models the latter are expected to be larger than the scattering cross - sections . to facilitate the comparison we express our result in terms of cross - section per particle of mass @xmath130 , and attach a subscript to indicate that this refers to self - scattering , @xmath131 if the dark matter particle is a thermal relic , its self - annihilation cross - section can be expressed in terms of dark matter density and typical velocity @xcite , @xmath132 a different constraint comes from considering the observed abundance of annihilation by - products . for neutrinos , @xcite get an upper bound which is more stringent than provided by other experimental and observational considerations , @xmath133 for a range of particle masses between @xmath134 and @xmath135 gev . while our result is well above ( i.e. inconsistent with ) the thermal relic estimate , @xmath136 , for particle masses above @xmath134 mev , it is comparable to @xmath137 , especially if particle mass is somewhat below @xmath138 gev . here we offer other interpretations for the separation between the ne-@xmath81 mass clump and the elliptical galaxy @xmath81 . \(i ) the ne-@xmath81 mass clump could belong to the line of sight structures , and not the cluster core , or galaxy @xmath81 . in that case the alignment of ne-@xmath81 clump with the cluster ellipticals is not expected . however , there are no additional light concentrations in the direction of the ne-@xmath81 clump , so if this mass is external to the cluster core , it would still need to have a very high mass - to - light ratio . \(ii ) the ne-@xmath81 mass clump could be primarily due to the baryonic gas associated with galaxy @xmath81 , which has been separated from its parent galaxy by ram pressure of the cluster gas . however , in the cluster s core one would expect the gas of individual ellipticals to have been stripped and dispersed on short time - scales , and in the case of a late stage merger , as in abell 3827 , long before the galaxies of the merging clusters reach the new common cluster core . observations of other massive clusters do not show x - ray emitting gas associated with individual galaxies in the core . examination of an archival chandra image of abell 3827 also shows no discernible substructure ( proposal i d 08800836 ) . ( iii ) because the visible and dark components of @xmath81 have different spatial extents , the gravitational field gradient of the cluster could have resulted in different forces acting on the two components , which could lead to the observed separation . however , it is hard to imagine how tidal forces would lead to such a large offset . another possibility is that the stellar component of @xmath81 is wobbling around the centre of its dark matter s potential well . separation due to this effect have been observed , but only for the central cluster galaxies . @xmath81 is not the central elliptical ; @xmath81 and ne-@xmath81 clump are both about @xmath0 kpc from cluster s largest mass concentration ( section [ cent ] ) . \(iv ) finally , because the lensed images are faint , extended and close to bright ellipticals , the identification and location of images could be partially wrong . since image positions are the most important input for pixelens mass reconstruction , misidentified images could lead to wrong recovered mass maps . additional observations would help ; for now we note that random astrometric uncertainties , of order @xmath139 , in the image positions do not affect the main features of the reconstruction ( section [ uncert ] ) . in this paper we argue that if the dark matter self - scattering cross - section is only a few orders of magnitude below its most stringent astrophysically determined upper limit , @xmath140 @xmath3 g@xmath4 , then it should be detectable in the cores of massive galaxy clusters . the dark matter particles of individual galaxies that have been orbiting the cluster centre for about a hubble time will be scattering off the dark matter of the cluster , resulting in a drag force , not experienced by the visible stellar component of the galaxies . over time this drag will amount to a spatial separation between the dark and visible components of the galaxy , whose magnitude is estimated by eq . [ dispunits ] . we suggest that at least one elliptical in the core of abell 3827 is an example of such a scenario . our free - form lensing reconstructions show that there a massive dark clump , the ne-@xmath81 clump , located about @xmath141 , or @xmath1 kpc from the centre of light of @xmath81 . we performed many mass reconstructions to test the robustness of the ne-@xmath81 clump , and quantified the uncertainty in its properties . a series of synthetic mass models , presented in section [ tests ] , further support the existence of the clump and its separation from the visible component of @xmath81 . we interpret this clump as the dark matter halo of @xmath81 which is lagging behind its stellar counterpart . if this interpretation is correct , we estimate the lower limit on the cross - section as given in eq . [ estim ] . the largest source of systematic uncertainty in this equation relates to the unknown dynamics of the cluster and central galaxies , the shape and inclination of the orbit of @xmath81 , and the true three dimensional distances and separations within the core . in section [ other ] we note that other interpretations of the observed separation can not be ruled out at this point . future observations as well as numerical simulations should be able to differentiate between the various scenarios , and also quantify the uncertainties associated with the dynamical state of the cluster . using purely collisionless simulations . the stellar and dark matter components of superimposed , mass distributions of different several orbits around the cluster centre the two components wobble there is no need for non - zero @xmath6 , section [ intro ] , check if an observable separation can develop over a hubble time . as already mentioned , abell 3827 is special in having very favorable parameters for the detection of the dark matter - light offset . first , a3827 is a very massive cluster , hosting several massive ellipticals in the very core . @xcite note that within a similar radius , abell 3827 is slightly more massive than abell 1689 @xcite , a cluster with over 100 strong lensing features . they also note that the central galaxy of abell 3827 is perhaps the most massive cd galaxy in the local universe . second , the fortuitous location of the background source a produces strong lensing features that are optimal in configuration and distance for mass reconstruction in the most relevant regions ; the low redshift of abell 3827 and source a ensure that the images are close to the cluster centre , @xmath142 . these factors make it unlikely that there are many other clusters out there where the offset would be detectable . llrw would like to thank henry lee for discussing with her the images of this unusual object prior to publication , keith olive for discussions about particle dark matter , and larry rudnick for help with chandra data archive . beacom , j. f. , bell , n. f. & mack , g. d. 2007 , phys.rev.lett . , 99 , 231301 bertone , g. , hooper , d. & silk , j. 2005 , phys.rept . , 405 , 279 carrasco , e. r. , gomez , p. l. , verdugo , t. , lee , h. , diaz , r. , bergmann , m. , turner , j. e. h. , miller , b. w. & west , m. j. 2010 , apj , 715 , l160 clowe , d. , bradac , m. , gonzalez , a. h. , markevitch , m. , randall , s. w. , jones , c. , zaritsky , d 2006 , apj , 648 , l109 coe , d. , fuselier , e. , bentez , n. , broadhurst , t . , frye , b. , ford , h. , 2008 , apj , 681 , 814
Abstract: | [
"if dark matter has a non - zero self - interaction cross - section , then dark matter halos of individual galaxies in cluster cores should experience a drag force from the ambient dark matter of the cluster , which will not affect the stellar components of galaxies , and thus will lead to a separation between the stellar and dark matter . if the cross - section is only a few decades below its current astrophysically determined upper limit , then kpc - scale separations should result . however , such separations will be observable only under very favorable conditions . abell 3827 is a nearby late stage cluster merger with four massive central ellipticals within @xmath0 kpc of each other . the ten strong lensing images tightly surrounding the ellipticals provide an excellent set of constraints for a free - form lens reconstruction . our free - form mass maps show a massive dark extended clump , about @xmath1 kpc from one of the ellipticals . the robustness of this result has been tested with many reconstructions , and confirmed with experiments using synthetic lens mass distributions . interpreted in terms of dark matter collisionality , our result yields @xmath2 @xmath3 g@xmath4 , where @xmath5 is the merger s age ."
] | 8,663 | 8,663 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: one of the main industrial applications of bitumen is as a binder in asphalt pavement [ ] . bitumen links together mineral aggregates and filler particles to form a cohesive asphalt on the road surface . over the years , a chemical reaction takes place in bitumen increasing the number of heavy aromatic molecules [ ] . this process is called chemical aging . the aromatic molecules in bitumen , especially the asphaltene molecules , tend to align to form nanoaggregates . the aging reaction leads also to an increase in the nanoaggregate size [ ] correlated with an unwanted increase in bitumen viscosity and brittleness [ ] . the change in bitumen mechanical properties , which go from `` liquid - like '' to more `` solid - like '' during chemical aging finally results in cracks in the pavement and road deterioration . to prevent or reverse the effects of chemical aging , a first step is to gather more knowledge about the nanoaggregate structure and stability in bitumen . much progress has been made over the last 50 years in the experimental and numerical literature to determine the structure of the nanoaggregates and the conditions under which they are formed . one can cite in particular the design of the yen - mullins model [ , ] describing the nanoaggregate structure , the determination of the critical nanoaggregate concentration in different solvents [ , ] , the evaluation of the average size and polydispersity of a nanoaggregate [ ] on the experimental side . on the numerical side , different stable conformations of nanoaggregates were identified depending on the asphaltene structure using molecular mechanical calculations [ ] and molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations [ ] . md simulations were also used to determine the molecular orientation inside the nanoaggregates [ ] , and the effects of solvent and presence of other molecules on the nanoaggregate structure [ ] . however , analytical models for the thermodynamics stability and dynamics of the nanoaggregates in relation to their structure are still quite rare , to the notable exception of ref . [ ] . the purpose of this paper is precisely to suggest simple and generic models , which can reproduce md results on the nanoaggregate stability . we present molecular dynamics results concerning the nanoaggregate size in the stationary regime . in bitumen , nanoaggregates are composed of asphaltene molecules , the most heavy and aromatic fraction in bitumen , but also of lighter aromatic molecules like resin and resinous oil [ ] . we give results on the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing a given number of aromatic molecules and the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing a given number of asphaltene molecules . the two probabilities are shown to differ qualitatively . we first model the simpler case , where only asphaltene molecules are counted . the focus in this case is to establish a mechanism for the nanoaggregation of asphaltene molecules . from this aggregation mechanism , a master equation and a statistical mechanics model are derived and provide a simple theoretical framework for interpreting the simulation results on nanoaggregate stability . the results of the master equation approach are also compared to the aggregation dynamics observed in the md simulations . then , the more complicated case where all aromatic molecules are counted is discussed in terms of statistical mechanics arguments . the md simulations carried out in this work are based on the four - component united - atom - unit model developed in ref . [ ] in the framework of the cooee project [ ] . the model is shown to reproduce a generic bitumen reasonably well [ ] . the simulations were performed on graphic - processor - units ( gpu ) using the roskilde university molecular dynamics ( rumd.org ) package [ ] . the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ sec : results ] , we provide simulation details , give a definition of a linear nanoaggregate , and present the md results about the probability of having a nanoaggregate of a given size . section [ sec : mastereq ] is devoted to model the results on the stability of linear aggregates where only asphaltene molecules are counted with a master equation approach . in sec . [ sec : statmech ] , a related statistical mechanics model is described and shown to reproduce the md results on asphaltene nanoaggregate stability . the more complicated case where all aromatic molecules are counted in a nanoaggregate is also discussed in sec . [ sec : statmech ] in terms of statistical mechanics arguments . [ sec : discussion ] includes a comparison of our results to existing experimental and numerical results and discuss the limit of our model . finally , sec . [ sec : conclu ] contains a summary and a conclusion . before presenting the molecular dynamics ( md ) results on nanoaggregate stability , we mention a few details about the simulations and define precisely a nanoaggregate . as mentioned in the introduction , the simulation method and molecular potentials are described in details in ref . only information necessary to understand the study on nanoaggregate stability carried out in the present paper is given here . the simulated system contains four types of molecule , chosen to resemble the sara classification [ ] : a saturated hydrocarbon , a resinous oil molecule , which is denoted aromatic in the sara scheme , a resin molecule and an asphaltene molecule . the molecular structures chosen are shown in fig . [ fig : molecule ] . the main system studied in this paper contains @xmath0 saturated hydrocarbons , @xmath1 resinous oil molecules , @xmath1 resin molecules and @xmath1 asphaltene molecules , which corresponds to @xmath2 united atom units . the methyl ( ch@xmath3 ) , methylene ( ch@xmath4 ) , and methine ( ch ) groups are represented by the same united atom unit of molar mass 13.3 g@xmath5mol@xmath6 and the sulfur atoms are represented by a united atom unit with a different molar mass 32 g@xmath5mol@xmath6 . the potential between the united atom units contains four terms : an intermolecular potential , corresponding to a lennard - jones potential with parameters @xmath7 @xmath8 and @xmath9 k , where @xmath10 is the boltzmann constant and three terms for the intramolecular potential . these three terms describe the bond length between two connected particles , the angle between three consecutive particles , and the dihedral angle between four consecutive particles . the parametrization of the intramolecular potential is described in details in refs [ ] . the simulations are performed in the canonical ensemble ( nvt ) at a constant temperature @xmath11 k and a constant density . the density @xmath12 kg@xmath5l@xmath6 is chosen to obtain an average pressure around the atmospheric pressure . a nos - hoover thermostat is used . the time step is @xmath13 fs and the duration of the simulations is @xmath14 ns . eight independent simulations are performed at the same state point . the molecular dynamics package rumd [ ] is used to perform the calculation . + it was shown in a previous work [ ] that the asphaltene , resin , and resinous oil molecules tend to align with respect to each other . they align at a distance of around @xmath15 , close to the minimum of the lennard - jones potential between the molecules . the lennard - jones potential used in the md simulations mimics the @xmath16-stacking interaction observed between aromatic molecules experimentally . the alignment of aromatic molecules in bitumen is the basis of the nanoaggregate formation . the definition of a nanoaggregate is described in detail in ref . it is based on the following rule : two aromatic molecules are nearest neighbors in the same nanoaggregate if they are `` well - aligned '' and `` close enough '' . a nanoaggregate is composed of all molecules connected by this rule . moreover , the asphaltene molecule chosen in this model has two parts , a flat head and a flat body which can rotate with respect to each other . for this reason , aromatic molecules can align in the direction of an asphaltene body or in the direction of an asphaltene head , thus creating branched nanoaggregates . these branches can link together purely linear nanoaggregates . we believe this is one mechanism explaining the formation of clusters of nanoaggregates , also observed experimentally [ ] . in this paper , we focus on purely linear nanoaggregates . it means that any aromatic molecules linked to an asphaltene head will not be considered as part of this asphaltene nanoaggregate . we define a linear aggregate as composed of asphaltene bodies , resin and resinous oil molecules , and not asphaltene heads because heads are the smallest parts and probably lead to the smallest interaction energy . figure [ fig : linearaggregate ] shows conformations of two molecules corresponding to limiting cases of the nanoaggregate definition used in this paper . figures [ fig : linearaggregate](a ) and ( b ) show two conformations of two asphaltene molecules where these molecules are considered as nearest neighbors . conversely , figs [ fig : linearaggregate](c ) to ( e ) show three conformations where the two molecules are not considered as nearest neighbors . a picture of a linear nanoaggregate obtained from the md simulations is shown in fig . [ fig : linearaggregate](f ) . note that this nanoaggregate is not typical as a resin and a resinous oil molecule are aligned on the same side of an asphaltene body . ( color online ) ( a ) to ( e ) scheme of limiting cases illustrating whether a molecule is or is not the nearest neighbor of the first molecule . the first molecule is an asphaltene molecule and is black . the second molecule is green if it is the neighbor of the first one and red otherwise . ( a ) head - to - head conformation . ( b ) head - to - tail conformation . ( c ) non - aligned molecules . ( d ) molecule aligned to the head of the asphaltene molecule . ( e ) molecules far from each other and aligned . modified with permission from c. a. lemarchand , t. b. schroder , j. c. dyre , and j. s. hansen , j. chem . 139 , 124506 ( 2013 ) . copyright 2013 american institute of physics . ( f ) snapshot of a linear nanoaggregate , obtained in molecular dynamics . asphaltene molecules are in blue , resin molecules in red and resinous oil molecules in green . , title="fig : " ] ( color online ) ( a ) to ( e ) scheme of limiting cases illustrating whether a molecule is or is not the nearest neighbor of the first molecule . the first molecule is an asphaltene molecule and is black . the second molecule is green if it is the neighbor of the first one and red otherwise . ( a ) head - to - head conformation . ( b ) head - to - tail conformation . ( c ) non - aligned molecules . ( d ) molecule aligned to the head of the asphaltene molecule . ( e ) molecules far from each other and aligned . modified with permission from c. a. lemarchand , t. b. schroder , j. c. dyre , and j. s. hansen , j. chem . 139 , 124506 ( 2013 ) . copyright 2013 american institute of physics . ( f ) snapshot of a linear nanoaggregate , obtained in molecular dynamics . asphaltene molecules are in blue , resin molecules in red and resinous oil molecules in green . , title="fig : " ] sections [ sec : simulationdetail ] and [ sec : defnanoaggregate ] gave necessary information about the simulations and the definition of linear nanoaggregates . the results of the molecular dynamics simulations concerning the nanoaggregate size and stability can now be presented . there are different possibilities to quantify the size of a linear nanoaggregate . for example , it can be quantified as the total number of aromatic molecules or as the number of asphaltene molecules which it contains . the first definition makes use of the fact that nanoaggregates are not only composed of asphaltene molecules , but also of smaller aromatic molecules . the second definition accounts for the fact that asphaltene molecules are the largest aromatic molecules and probably the most important in the nanoaggregate stability . this is why experimentalists often define the nanoaggregate size as the latter [ ] . the molecular dynamics simulations enable us to study the consequences of both definitions on the nanoaggregate stability . we quantify the stability as the probability of having a nanoaggregate of a given size in the stationary regime . the probability @xmath17 of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 aromatic molecules is defined as : @xmath19 where @xmath20 is the number of linear aggregates containing @xmath18 aromatic molecules and @xmath21 is the total number of linear aggregates . in a similar way , the probability @xmath22 of having a nanoaggregate with @xmath18 molecules of type @xmath23 is defined as @xmath24 where @xmath25 is the number of linear aggregates containing @xmath18 molecules of type @xmath23 and @xmath26 is the total number of linear aggregates containing at least one molecule of type @xmath23 . the type @xmath23 can be @xmath27 for asphaltene , @xmath28 for resin , @xmath29 for resinous oil or @xmath30 for resin and resinous oil . the probabilities @xmath31 and @xmath32 are plotted in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( b ) and ( c ) , respectively . the probabilities @xmath33 and @xmath34 are plotted in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( d ) . two main points can be noticed in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] . the probability @xmath35 of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 aromatic molecules seems to have two slopes in a log - lin scale , _ i. e. _ can be described by a biexponential . on the contrary , when only asphaltene molecules are counted , the probability @xmath36 has only one slope , _ i. e. _ can be characterized as a simple exponential . for the probability @xmath37 of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 resin or resinous oil molecules , the biexponential shape seems to be prevailing . it is the same for the probability @xmath38 of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 resin molecules . for the probability @xmath39 of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 resinous oil molecules , the monoexponential shape seems to be recovered . the transition between the two slopes is not sharp for the probability @xmath38 . to highlight the existence of the two slopes in this case in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( d ) , a dashed line was drawn in continuation of the line corresponding to the first slope . it departs further and further away from the second slope . the rest of the paper is devoted to understand the molecular dynamics results presented in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] . more specifically , the paper is aimed at unraveling some of the dynamical and thermodynamical origins lying behind the monoexponential and biexponential behaviors . a dynamical approach will first be proposed for the monoexponential behavior . in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( b ) , the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules was shown to be monoexponential . the aim of this section is to establish a simple aggregation mechanism reproducing this behavior . the mechanism will be used to derive a master equation which provides a dynamical framework for understanding the monoexponential behavior . a simple mechanism which can be written in the asphaltene aggregation problem is @xmath40 where @xmath41 denotes an aggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules . the assumptions lying behind this mechanism are the following : only one asphaltene molecule at a time can attach to or detach from an existing aggregate , the medium is homogeneous and the aggregation dynamics is not limited by diffusion . the same mechanism was already suggested in ref . [ ] to model asphaltene aggregation from a thermodynamical point of view , but the possibility to obtain a master equation from this mechanism and consequently to model the dynamics of asphaltene aggregation was left aside . to obtain a master equation linked to this aggregation reaction , we make supplementary assumptions : the reaction rate constants do not depend on the size @xmath18 of the aggregate and the attachment rate does not depend on the probability of having free asphaltene molecules in the medium . under these assumptions , the master equation linked to the aggregation reaction eq . can be written as : @xmath42 where @xmath43 is the attachment rate constant , @xmath44 the detachment rate constant and @xmath45 the probability of having an aggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules at time @xmath46 , given that its initial size was @xmath47 . the probability denoted @xmath31 in sec . [ sec : mdresults ] corresponds to the stationary state to eqs . and and depends neither on time @xmath46 nor on the initial condition @xmath47 . the master equation eq . was solved analytically in the 1950 s [ , ] for different boundary conditions . this master equation and its generalized version in which the rate constants depend on the aggregate size @xmath18 have also been extensively used to model different stochastic processes such as alcohol clusters [ , ] , biological adhesion clusters [ ] or aggregation in freeway traffic [ ] , to cite only a few . the expression of this master equation deserves some further clarification in connection to the specific aggregation reaction used . following the law of chemical kinetics , the attachment rate linked to the aggregation mechanism should be @xmath48 , because the probability of having a collision between two small spherical molecules is usually proportional to the product of their concentrations . we can give empirical reasons explaining why it is not proportional to the probability @xmath49 of having a free asphaltene molecule here . we assume that the attachment rate is not due to the collision between two small spherical molecules , but limited by the steric hindrance around the aggregate and the orientation of the free asphaltene molecule @xmath50 . the attachment reaction is successful if the free asphaltene molecule is well oriented and placed at a reactive end of the aggregate . the number of free asphaltene molecules is higher than the number of any aggregate of a given size at any time in our md simulations ( not shown ) . as the number of free asphaltene molecules is high enough , there is always a free asphaltene molecule nearby an aggregate but it is not always well - oriented and prevent other molecules from approaching due to the density of the system . thus , the attachment rate is independent of the free asphaltene concentration and the attachment rate constant @xmath43 is averaged over possible orientations . the boundary condition eq . needs also some explanation . it corresponds to the fact that the system is closed . in other words , the total number of asphaltene molecules is kept constant . as the free asphaltene molecules are involved in each aggregation reaction , the derivative with respect to time of the probability @xmath51 to have a free asphaltene molecule depends on infinitely many terms . it leads to @xmath52 these series are then simplified using the fact that at every time @xmath46 : @xmath53 , to give the boundary condition eq . . to test the validity of this master equation for the present problem , two different quantities are evaluated : the stationary probability of having a nanoaggregate of a given size , as shown in sec . [ sec : mdresults ] and the aggregation dynamics , quantified as the time evolution of the fraction of aggregated asphaltene molecules . the stationary distribution of the master equation eq . with the boundary condition eq . is easy to derive . in the stationary state , the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules depends neither on time nor on the initial size of a nanoaggregate . for this reason , the stationary probability will be denoted @xmath31 . it satisfies the following equation : @xmath54 the solution of this equation is a geometrical law [ , ] . by induction and using the fact that @xmath55 , one can show that the solution of this equation is : @xmath56 in a log - lin scale , the stationary probability predicted by the master equation approach is a straight line of the form : @xmath57 it is a monoexponential distribution , as observed in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( b ) , obtained in md . the exponential distribution can be used to fit the molecular dynamics data , as shown in fig . [ fig : aonlybb ] . the value of the dynamical parameter @xmath58 is , in this case , @xmath59 . the master equation framework provides a dynamical interpretation of the parameter @xmath58 as the ratio between the attachment and detachment rate constants . figure [ fig : aonlybb ] also shows the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules obtained in md simulations for two different system sizes and the corresponding exponential fits . the results for a system containing @xmath1 asphaltene molecules and for a system containing @xmath60 times less molecules agree surprisingly well , giving the values @xmath59 and @xmath61 respectively . it shows that , while finite size effects are present , they are not very important when it comes to the number of asphaltene molecules in a nanoaggregate . more specifically , the relative probability of small nanoaggregates is accurately described even in the small system . the probability of having larger nanoaggregates is not so well described in the small system , as expected , but does not affect much the value of the parameter @xmath58 since these nanoaggregates are rare even in the large system . it is important to note , however , that physical properties due to large nanoaggregates or to nanoaggregates filling up the box in one direction , such as residual stresses , could be affected by finite size effects . as shown above , the stationary state predicted by the master equation agrees with the md results on the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules . if the master equation eq . correctly describes the aggregation process , it should also reproduce the aggregation dynamics . checking this fact is the purpose of this section . to compare the prediction of the master equation approach and the molecular dynamics results , we quantified the aggregation dynamics in the following way . we used the fraction @xmath62 of aggregated asphaltene molecules versus time . the fraction @xmath62 of aggregated asphaltene molecules is defined as the ratio of the number of asphaltene molecules in all aggregates containing at least two asphaltene molecules and the total number of asphaltene molecules in the system . the fraction @xmath62 verifies : @xmath63 where @xmath64 is the fraction of free asphaltene molecules . the fraction of free asphaltene molecules is defined as @xmath65 where @xmath66 is the number of asphaltene molecules in aggregate containing one asphaltene molecule and @xmath67 is the total number of asphaltene molecules in the system . the fraction @xmath64 can be expressed in terms of the probability @xmath68 of having an asphaltene aggregate of size @xmath69 at time @xmath46 and of the average size of an asphaltene aggregate @xmath70 , given that all aggregates had size 1 initially . indeed , we know that : @xmath71 where @xmath72 is the number of aggregates containing one asphaltene molecule and @xmath73 is the total number of aggregates containing at least one asphaltene molecule , as in eq . [ eq : padef ] . we also know that : @xmath74 where @xmath75 is again the total number of asphaltene molecules and @xmath73 is the total number of aggregates containing at least one asphaltene molecule . it is easy to show that @xmath76 and finally that @xmath77 to obtain the dynamics predicted by the master equation eq . with the specific boundary condition eq . , a numerical implementation of the scheme was carried out . in the numerical implementation the time step @xmath78 is a hundred times smaller than the inverse of the detachment rate constant @xmath79 . an aggregate can attach to a single molecule with the probability @xmath80 and release a single molecule with the probability @xmath81 . an aggregate of size @xmath69 can attach to a molecule but can not release one . the total number of molecules is kept constant in the numerical implementation of the master equation . the total number of molecules is chosen to be @xmath82 to reduce the statistical noise . initially , in the numerical implementation of the master equation , all the aggregates are of size @xmath69 . the fraction @xmath64 of free asphaltene molecules can be obtained through this numerical implementation . it depends _ a priori _ on the two rate constants @xmath43 and @xmath44 . however , the ratio @xmath83 is known from the stationary state result . it leaves us with one dynamical parameter , say @xmath43 , to fit . the initial state in the molecular dynamics simulations is not as well defined as in the master equation approach . to reach the desired density , a first md simulation where the system is compressed is performed . during the compression period , the asphaltene molecules begin to aggregate , but the data can not be recorded . the data are recorded just after the compression period , in a state where small asphaltene aggregates are already formed . the fraction of free asphaltene molecules in that state is @xmath84 . it is a second fitting parameter . the curve predicted by the numerical implementation of the master equation was shifted in time so that time @xmath85 corresponds to @xmath84 as in the md simulations . figure [ fig : dynamics ] shows the fraction of aggregated asphaltene molecules versus time in the molecular dynamics simulations and in the master equation approach . both results agree well , indicating that the master equation approach correctly describe the aggregation process of asphaltene molecules . the value of the dynamical parameter @xmath43 is found to be @xmath86 s@xmath6 . it is worth mentioning that the inverse rate constant @xmath87 s is much larger than the upper limit @xmath88 s , needed for an asphaltene molecule to diffuse of a distance equals to the average distance @xmath89 nm between the centers of mass of @xmath90 aromatic molecules in a homogeneous system of volume @xmath91 nm@xmath92 minus the intermolecular distance @xmath93 @xmath8 in an aggregate . this characteristic time is evaluated using the diffusion coefficient of a single asphaltene molecule in the docosane solvent : @xmath94 [email protected]@xmath6 and the formula @xmath96 for three - dimensional diffusion . this time is an upper limit because only the distance between centers of mass is considered , whereas molecules are extended in space and can be close to each other even if the distance between their centers of mass is larger than @xmath97 . we can conclude from that fact that the nanoaggregation process is not limited by diffusion . in fig . [ fig : dynamics ] , there seems to be a discrepancy between the master equation approach and the md results at long times . this could indicate the existence of another aggregation process , taking place at a longer time scale . checking carefully the existence of this second process requires further investigation . the master equation approach related to the aggregation reaction eq . is able to reproduce both the stationary behavior and the dynamics of the asphaltene aggregation process at intermediate time scales . it indicates that the assumptions made to derive the master equation eq . are relevant . the master equation approach gives a dynamical framework to interpret the monoexponential distribution observed in md . even if the same master equation has already been used in the general field of clustering processes [ ] , it is the first time , to our knowledge , that it is applied to asphaltene aggregation in molecular dynamics simulations . section [ sec : mastereq ] provided a dynamical interpretation of the monoexponential behavior of the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules based on a master equation description on a simple aggregation reaction . the aim of the present section is to describe a statistical mechanics model based on the same aggregation scheme and consistent with the monoexponential behavior . in this section , we will also look into possible thermodynamical interpretations of the biexponential behavior , obtained when all aromatic molecules are counted . to formulate a simple statistical mechanics model linked to the aggregation reaction eq . , some assumptions are needed . we make the following common assumptions : 1 . the nanoaggregates are linear . 2 . the system is homogeneous and isotropic on average and the nanoaggregates are rigid . 3 . the aggregation process occurs at a characteristic time much larger than the equilibration of the pressure , temperature and solvent molecules . the system is dilute enough to consider no interaction between the nanoaggregates except through the aggregation reaction . in other words , the solution of nanoaggregates of different sizes in a solvent is ideal . the free energy of a nanoaggregate depends linearly on its size . the idea of considering a mixture of free molecules and dimers as an ideal mixture with an aggregation reaction occurring at a larger time scale dates back to the beginning of the 20@xmath98 century [ ] as is nicely explained in the recent review [ ] . the set of assumptions was then completed to include the case of linear aggregates of any size and widely used to describe rodlike micelles [ ] , linear polymer chains [ ] , and discotic liquid crystals [ ] . we propose in this section our own version of the derivation applied to the case of linear asphaltene aggregates and obtain an analytical formula for the probability of having an aggregate of a given size . the analogy between linear assembly in discotic liquid crystals and asphaltene aggregates was also made in ref [ ] , which derives very similar equations to the ones presented in this section , but do not present a successful comparison with their coarse - grained simulations of asphaltene - resin nanoaggregates at high density . the assumption of having an ideal mixture can be relaxed to take into account more complicated interactions between the aggregates such as excluded volume interactions [ ] , the gain in entropy when the chain breaks [ ] and interactions due to the flexibility of the aggregates [ ] , to cite only a few . for the sake of simplicity , these interactions are neglected in the case of linear asphaltene aggregates . the validity of the assumptions made in this section will be discussed in sec . [ sec : assumption ] . concurrently to these approaches expressing the probability of having an aggregate of a given size , another theory of aggregation based on statistical thermodynamics was developed by wertheim [ ] . this theory considers molecules of a reference liquid , typically a lennard - jones fluid , with a finite number of binding sites . the potential modeling the interaction between the binding sites is designed to take into account steric hindrance . the theory then counts the number of molecules with no bond on a given binding site instead of the number of aggregates of a given size . it is a clever way to count physically meaningful graphs . the outcome of the theory is an expression for the equilibrium pressure and the concentration of free molecules versus the composition of the system . these predictions were successfully checked numerically for strongly associating fluid [ ] . however , this theory does not provide an expression for the probability of having an aggregate of a given size . for this reason , it is not considered in further details in this section but is mentioned for the sake of completeness . in the framework of the common assumptions stated above , the free energy of the system can be written as [ ] : @xmath99 where @xmath100 is the number of nanoaggregates containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules , @xmath101 the volume of the system , @xmath102 the effective free energy of an aggregate , @xmath10 the boltzmann constant and @xmath103 the temperature . the first term in eq . corresponds to the free energy of an ideal mixture of ideal gas and the second term corresponds to the energy of the aggregates . the effective free energy @xmath102 is to be understood as the energy of an asphaltene aggregate when the degrees of freedom due to solvent molecules have been integrated out . the expression eq . for the free energy of the system holds for each value of the number @xmath100 of aggregates of a given size , because a state of local equilibrium acting on entropy , pressure and solvent molecules is assumed for each step along the aggregation reactions . the total equilibrium of the system depends now only on the equilibrium of the aggregation reactions . the condition for chemical equilibrium of each aggregation reaction @xmath104 is @xmath105 where @xmath106 is the chemical potential of an asphaltene aggregate of size @xmath18 . using the definition of the chemical potential @xmath107 , we can obtain after some calculations the well - known mass action law : @xmath108 where @xmath109 is the equilibrium constant of the reaction @xmath104 . the equilibrium constant is given by : @xmath110 we now make use of assumption 5 , stating that the free energy of a nanoaggregate depends linearly on its size . this assumption amounts to write the effective free energy @xmath102 as : @xmath111 where @xmath112 is the free energy of a single asphaltene molecule and @xmath113 is the effective free energy between two asphaltene molecules . using this form in the expression of the equilibrium constant eq . gives : @xmath114 thus , the equilibrium constant does not depend on the size @xmath18 of the considered nanoaggregate under the set of assumptions considered . by induction , it is now easy to show from eq . that @xmath115 to compare the model to the simulations results it is more useful to obtain the probability @xmath31 of having a nanoaggregate of size @xmath18 , which is defined in eq.[eq : padef ] @xmath116 where @xmath117 is the total number of asphaltene nanoaggregates . to express @xmath31 , we make use of the conservation of the total number @xmath75 of asphaltene molecules : @xmath118 having this in mind , one can show ( see appendix [ ap : paramp ] ) that @xmath119 where @xmath120 and @xmath121 we have now recovered the exponential distribution observed in the md simulations and fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( b ) . the md simulations provide a value of the parameter @xmath58 characterizing the exponential distribution : @xmath122 . according to the thermodynamical interpretation eq . , it leads to the value @xmath123 the simple statistical mechanics model provides an interpretation for the parameter @xmath58 in terms of an effective free energy @xmath113 between two asphaltene molecules . within the assumptions of this simple model , the effective free energy is the interaction energy between two asphaltene molecules when the degrees of freedom related to solvent molecules are integrated out . the physical meaning of free energy @xmath113 depends on its definition in the framework of the assumptions made here , but also on the validity of these assumptions . this will be discussed in the next section . the validity of each assumption and its consequences on the physical meaning of the free energy @xmath113 will now be listed . 1 . _ linear dependence of @xmath102 on the size @xmath18 of the nanoaggregate . _ + it is very easy to check that the potential energy , and not the free energy , of a nanoaggregate in vacuum depends linearly on its size . the potential energy of a linear nanoaggregate of size @xmath18 is plotted versus @xmath18 for nanoaggregates in vacuum in fig . [ fig : potenergya ] . the origin of the energy is set arbitrarily to zero in this figure . the nanoaggregate used to plot this figure is a linear nanoaggregate containing five asphaltene molecules found in one simulation . to find the potential energy of an aggregate of size @xmath124 , only the first @xmath18 asphaltene molecules in the aggregate were considered in vacuum . this figure clearly shows that the potential energy of a nanoaggregate in vacuum is linear and the slope @xmath125 corresponding to the interaction energy between two asphaltene molecules is equal to @xmath126 in practical terms , it means that when an asphaltene molecule is added to a nanoaggregate of size @xmath18 , this asphaltene molecule interacts with the energy @xmath127 @xmath128 with the molecule at the end of the nanoaggregate but do not interact with the other ones , which are further away . + the fact that the potential energy of a nanoaggregate in vacuum depends linearly on its size is a good indication that it might also be the case for the effective free energy @xmath102 of a nanoaggregate in a solvent . in that case , the effective free energy @xmath113 corresponding to the slope of @xmath102 versus the size @xmath18 of the nanoaggregate is well defined . + we remind the reader that the potential energy of a nanoaggregate in vacuum and the effective free energy @xmath102 are not identical and the slopes @xmath113 and @xmath125 are indeed quite different . within the framework of the statistical model presented in sec . [ sec : thermomodel ] , the two causes of this difference are : the interaction between the asphaltene molecules and the solvent and the entropic effects due to the effective integration of the degrees of freedom of the solvent . to quantify the effective free energy @xmath113 properly , a possibility is to set up umbrella sampling simulations controlling the distance between the center of mass of two asphaltene molecules in a bath of docosane molecules at the same temperature and pressure as the one used in the md simulations . the free energy of this system can be derived in terms of the distance between the two asphaltene molecules . the effective free energy @xmath113 would then be the difference between the free energy of such a system when the two asphaltene molecules are far away and the free energy of the system when the two asphaltene molecules are aligned and close . implementing umbrella sampling simulations is beyond the scope of this paper . moreover , the free energy @xmath113 found with this method might be slightly different from the value @xmath129 @xmath128 , found using the statistical mechanics model of sec . [ sec : thermomodel ] , because of the other assumptions made to derive this model . _ asphaltene nanoaggregates . _ + to derive the statistical mechanics model in sec . [ sec : thermomodel ] , we only considered the aggregation of asphaltene molecules , whereas resin and resinous oil molecules are also part of the nanoaggregates . the degrees of freedom related to the position of resin and resinous oil molecules should be integrated in an effective way to obtain the free energy @xmath113 , just as it was done for the degrees of freedom related to the solvent . the fact that the monoexponential behavior is valid for the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules means that this effective integration can be done . linear nanoaggregates . _ + the nanoaggregates considered in the simulations are only some linear portions of bigger branched nanoaggregates . the existence of the branches could also produce some degrees of freedom to be integrated to obtain the effective free energy @xmath113 . 4 . _ dilute limit . _ + the assumption stating that the solution of nanoaggregates is ideal neglects the interaction between the nanoaggregates . some of these interactions , for example between the nanoaggregates @xmath41 , @xmath130 and @xmath50 , are later taken into account through the aggregation reactions corresponding to the asphaltene aggregation . but in the md simulations , the asphaltene molecules interact in a more complicated way . they can not for example be too close to each other , due to short range repulsion . this could be taken into account through excluded volume interactions . it is known [ , ] , that taking into account excluded volume interactions preserves the monoexponential behavior . consequently , excluded volume interactions might play a role in the value of the effective free energy @xmath113 . _ time scale of the aggregation reactions . _ + to derive the statistical mechanics model , we assumed that the aggregation reactions occurred on a time scale much larger than the time scale associated with the equilibrium of pressure , entropy , and solvent molecules for a given number of each nanoaggregate . it is very difficult to predict the effect of the relaxation of this fundamental assumption . one way to check the assumption , however , is to compare once again the characteristic time of the aggregation reaction @xmath87 s and the upper limit @xmath88 s for the diffusion of an asphaltene molecule . a factor @xmath131 exists between the two characteristic times which should be enough to ensure the validity of the assumption . _ rigidity of the nanoaggregates and isotropy of the system . _ + [ sec : relaxrigidity ] the assumptions of rigid nanoaggregates and isotropic system can be considered together , because if they are both relaxed , they lead to a new term in the free energy of the system [ ] . this term depends on a persistence length @xmath132 and reads as [ , ] @xmath133^{1/2 } \nabla[\rho_n(\mathbf{u})]^{-1/2},\ ] ] where @xmath134 is the number density of asphaltene molecules part of a nanoaggregate of size @xmath18 oriented in the direction @xmath135 with respect to some reference direction and @xmath136 is the corresponding solid angle . this term is helpful to describe the nematic phase of liquid crystals , where long range order is seen . the addition of this term in the free energy expression leads to a biexponential behavior [ ] , which is not observed for the probability of having a linear nanoaggregates with @xmath18 asphaltene molecules . consequently , the assumption of rigid nanoaggregates and isotropic system probably holds , at least in an effective way , for the probability of having a linear nanoaggregate with @xmath18 asphaltene molecules and does not participate in the value of the effective free energy @xmath113 . the addition of this flexible term to the free energy is potentially of interest to explain the biexponential behavior of the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 aromatic molecules . to summarize , one can say that the statistical mechanics model developed in sec . [ sec : thermomodel ] provides a thermodynamical interpretation of the monoexponential behavior based on the effective free energy between two asphaltene molecules . this effective free energy should be understood as the interaction energy between two asphaltene molecules when all the degrees of freedom related to solvent molecules , resin and resinous oil molecules and branched nanoaggregates have been integrated out . the picture emerging from the study of the probability of having a linear nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules is that asphaltene bodies interact with an effective energy through the aggregation reaction . this leads to a monoexponential behavior . we know that the probability of having a linear nanoaggregate with @xmath18 aromatic molecules has a different behavior . it is biexponential as shown in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( a ) . this section is devoted to identifying possible statistical mechanics explanations for this different behavior . the first explanation that comes to mind is that when all molecules are counted , different interaction energies are involved . each interaction energy taken separately would lead to a specific monoexponential behavior and the combinations of several interaction energies could lead to a bi- or multiexponential behavior . to test this idea , we set up one - dimensional lattice monte - carlo simulations . a linear lattice of @xmath137 sites is created . each site can contain one asphaltene molecule , one resin molecule , one resinous oil molecule or nothing . one site can not contain two molecules . the total numbers of asphaltene molecules , resin molecules , and resinous oil molecules are constant . a monte - carlo move consists in exchanging the content of two sites providing that the content is different . this condition makes the molecules indiscernible . the system is initialised with the largest possible aggregate where all asphaltene molecules are next to each other , then comes resin molecules and then resinous oil molecules . ten million ( @xmath138 ) monte - carlo moves are realised using the metropolis algorithm . the algorithm converges quite quickly despite its elementary implementation . the potential energy of a nanoaggregate is calculated in the following way : when two asphaltene molecules are next to each other the interaction @xmath139 between two asphaltene molecules is added , when a resinous oil molecule is next to an asphaltene molecule or another resinous oil molecule the interaction energy @xmath140 is added , finally when a resin molecule is next to any other molecule the interaction energy @xmath141 is added . as two molecules can not be on the same site , effective excluded volume interactions are created . the assumptions underlying the establishment of the one - dimensional lattice monte - carlo simulations are similar to the ones made in sec . [ sec : thermomodel ] except for excluded volume interactions : 1 . the nanoaggregates can only be linear because the system is one - dimensional . 2 . the nanoaggregates are rigid . the system is one dimensional , so isotropy is not a criterion . 3 . the only energies involved are those related to the aggregation process . all potential energies related to interaction with and within solvent molecules are averaged out . no kinetic energy is involved . 4 . the system is not dilute and excluded volume interactions are taken into account . 5 . the energy of a pure asphaltene nanoaggregate depends linearly on its size . one of the main advantages of lattice monte - carlo simulations compared to the analytical approach is to take into account resin and resinous oil molecules and not only asphaltene molecules . we checked that in the dilute limit , when only asphaltene molecules are present in the monte - carlo simulations , the same monoexponential behavior with the same value for the parameter @xmath58 as the one predicted by the analytical approach is recovered . in the lattice monte - carlo simulations , it is possible to obtain a biexponential behavior for the probability of having @xmath18 molecules in a nanoaggregate as can be seen in fig . [ fig:1dlatmc]a . the biexponential behavior is characterized by the presence of two straight lines with different slopes in a log - lin scale . the biexponential behavior occurs in the lattice monte - carlo simulations when the interaction energies @xmath139 between asphaltene molecules on the one hand and @xmath140 and @xmath141 with resin and resinous oil molecules on the other hand are substantially different . for example , the choices @xmath142 @xmath128 , @xmath143 @xmath128 and @xmath144 @xmath145 at the same temperature and same volume as the md simulations give a biexponential behavior very close to the one obtained in md in fig . [ fig : pdfall ] ( a ) . it is shown in fig . [ fig:1dlatmc ] ( a ) . however , the biexponential behavior does not have the same causes as in the md simulations . in the monte - carlo simulations , the biexponential behavior is due to the fact that pure resin or resinous oil nanoaggregates and pure asphaltene nanoaggregates are formed . there are very few mixed nanoaggregates . thus , the first slope in the biexponential behavior is due to resin and resinous oil nanoaggregates and the second slope is due to asphaltene nanoaggregates . one consequence of this fact is that the probability of having a nanoaggregate with @xmath18 resin or resinous oil molecules has a monoexponential behavior with a slope very close to the first slope of the biexponential behavior . in the same way , the probability of having a nanoaggregate with @xmath18 asphaltene molecules has a monoexponential behavior with a slope very close to the second slope of the biexponential behavior . this can be seen in fig . [ fig:1dlatmc](a ) . on the contrary , in the md simulations , the two slopes of the biexponential behavior do not correspond to two different slopes in two different monoexponential behaviors . this can be seen in fig . [ fig:1dlatmc](b ) . the existence of mixed nanoaggregates can be checked directly in the md simulations . [ fig:1dlatmc](c ) displays the ratios @xmath146 , @xmath147 , and @xmath148 of asphaltene , resin , and resinous oil molecules respectively versus the size of the aggregate . for a given molecule type @xmath149 , the ratio @xmath150 is defined as : @xmath151 where @xmath152 is the number of molecules of type @xmath149 in the aggregate and @xmath18 the total number of molecules in the aggregate . [ fig:1dlatmc](c ) shows that there is indeed a change in the nanoaggregate composition with their size . the ratio of asphaltene molecules increases versus the size of the aggregates until it reaches an approximately constant value for aggregates of size @xmath153 . at the same time , the ratio of resin molecules decreases versus the size of the aggregates and reaches an approximately constant value for aggregates of size @xmath153 , while the ratio of resinous oil molecules is roughly constant . however , for any size the nanoaggregates contain all molecule types . we can conclude that , the biexponential behavior in md is probably not only due to the difference in effective interaction energies involved . another possible explanation of the biexponential behavior obtained for the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 aromatic molecules , is that it derives from the nanoaggregate flexibility . as mentioned in sec . [ sec : assumption ] , if the aggregates are flexible and the system is not isotropic , an extra term in the free energy of the system should be considered ( see eq . ) . this leads to a biexponential behavior . the existence of the biexponential behavior can be explained qualitatively in this way : bent nanoaggregates , less stable than straight ones , tend to be smaller and are responsible for the first slope of the biexponential behavior ; on the contrary straight nanoaggregates are larger and give rise to the second slope [ ] . this additional term is of course well - suited to explain the biexponential behavior observed for the probability of having a nanoaggregate with @xmath18 aromatic molecules . however , we are not convinced that it is the main reason explaining the biexponential behavior , but there are indications that it might play a role . first , some nanoaggregates are bent . a picture of a bent nanoaggregate can be seen in fig . [ fig : flexchain](a ) . to quantify the variation of the rigidity of an aggregate with the distance inside this aggregate , we computed the orientation correlation function @xmath154 , where @xmath155 is the unit vector normal to the molecule @xmath156 in a given linear aggregate , @xmath157 stands for the @xmath158 neighbor of molecule @xmath156 in the same linear aggregate , and @xmath159 corresponds to the average over different nanoaggregates and over time . [ fig : oriencorrel ] shows the variation of the orientation correlation function @xmath154 with @xmath160 . the error bars corresponding to the standard deviation over eight independent simulations are very large for this plot and are not shown for the sake of visibility . considering the large errors , only a qualitative discussion on the average trend is possible . we can see that there is , on average , an initial decrease of the orientation correlation with the number of neighbors . this trend shows that nanoaggregates are not perfectly rigid . for larger distances and consequently larger nanoaggregates , the orientation correlation seems to plateau around the value @xmath161 . this last trend matches the qualitative picture of small aggregates being more bent than larger aggregates . the change in the nanoaggregate composition observed in fig . [ fig:1dlatmc](c ) could explain the change in the nanoaggregate rigidity with the nanoaggregate size : aggregates containing many asphaltene molecules tend to be longer and more rigid . second , the system is not strictly isotropic . the isotropy was quantified using the nematic order parameter @xmath162 [ ] . to define the nematic order parameter , the following order tensor needs to be defined for each nanoaggregate : @xmath163 where @xmath18 is the number of molecules in the considered linear nanoaggregate , @xmath164 and @xmath165 cartesian coordinates , @xmath156 the index of a molecule inside the aggregate , @xmath155 the unit vector normal to molecule @xmath156 , and @xmath166 the kronecker delta . the nematic order parameter @xmath162 is the largest eigenvalue of the order tensor @xmath167 averaged over different nanoaggregates and time . the nematic order tensor is equal to @xmath69 in a system where all aggregates are perfectly aligned and to @xmath168 in a perfectly isotropic system . in the md simulations , the nematic order parameter is equal to @xmath169 where the error is the standard deviation corresponding to eight independent simulations . the value of the nematic order parameter indicates a system closed to being isotropic but not quite . it can be due to the fact that some linear nanoaggregates are branches of bigger aggregates . they can be connected through asphaltene heads and the angle between an asphaltene head and an asphaltene body is fixed by the dihedral potential and does not vary this much from one asphaltene molecule to another [ ] . it can also be due to steric hindrance : long nanoaggregates can not interpenetrate each other and consequently tend to align . the facts that nanoaggregates are flexible and that the system is not perfectly isotropic are consequently a plausible explanation for the biexponential behavior of the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing a given number of aromatic molecules . ( color online ) picture of a bent nanoaggregate , obtained in molecular dynamics . the color code is the same as in fig . [ fig : linearaggregate ] . ] the fact that the nanoaggregates are not strictly rigid and that the system is not strictly isotropic was also valid when we looked at the probability of having a nanoaggregate containing @xmath18 asphaltene molecules . however , the fact that this probability has a monoexponential behavior means that the additional term eq . can be neglected in this case . it could be because the effective persistence length is longer when only asphaltene molecules are considered . our bitumen model is quite simplified compared to a real bitumen . in this section , we will compare our results to other md results and to experimental results . we will also discuss the new idea that such a simplified model can bring to the field of asphaltene nanoaggregation and the specific aspects of asphaltene nanoaggregation which are neglected in this simplified model . our model relies on the fact that the @xmath16-stacking interaction is the origin of the nanoaggregate formation . in our md simulations , the @xmath16-stacking is modeled through the lennard - jones potential . recent molecular dynamics simulations of asphaltene molecules in toluene [ ] reported that the @xmath16-stacking interaction is indeed the most important one to explain the nanoaggregate formation , which justifies our model . in our md simulations , the average number of asphaltene molecules in a linear nanoaggregate is given by the exponential distribution . we can compare the average and standard deviation predicted by the exponential distribution to experimental results . to do that , we considered a renormalized distribution of the nanoaggregate size , where the aggregate of size @xmath69 are left out . in other words , free asphaltene molecules are not considered here as a nanoaggregate . the corresponding probability reads : @xmath170 in this case , the average number of asphaltene molecules in linear nanoaggregates is @xmath171 the average number of aromatic molecules in linear aggregates can be computed directly from the md results and is @xmath172 . these results are in agreement with the general consensus that nanoaggregates contain less than @xmath173 molecules [ ] . our simulation also offers a precise quantification of the polydispersity of the nanoaggregate size . the standard deviation of the distribution given in eq . is : @xmath174 again , the standard deviation on the number of aromatic molecules in linear nanoaggregates can be computed from the md results and is @xmath175 . these results are compatible with previous md results reporting for example that : for asphaltene nanoaggregates in toluene , the number of asphaltene molecules in the largest aggregate varies from 2 to 18 depending on the asphaltene structure [ ] ; for asphaltene nanoaggregates in vacuum , the number of asphaltene molecules in any aggregate varies from 1 to 5 and the precise distribution depends both on temperature and the asphaltene structure [ ] . on the experimental side , recent laser - based mass spectrometry experiments [ ] were able to obtain not only the average size of a nanoaggregate but also the polydispersity . the aggregation numbers are found to range roughly from @xmath176 to @xmath177 or from @xmath177 to @xmath178 depending on the bitumen chemical composition . it is also compatible with our results . moreover , our simulations bring the idea , already suggested in ref . [ ] without a successful match to simulation results at high density , that the simple monoexponential distribution is a typical distribution of the number of asphaltene molecules in linear aggregates . this distribution is consequently a good basis to model more complicated cases . one of these more complicated cases is considered here : when all aromatic molecules are counted in the nanoaggregates the probability of having a nanoaggregate of a given size becomes biexponential . the biexponential distribution can be seen as a modification of the exponential distribution when the flexibity of the aggregates and the anisotropy of the system are taken into account . many more specific aspects relevant for bitumen science can be considered and are not treated here . for example , the effect of having branched nanoaggregates on the distribution of the nanoaggregate size could be addressed . furthermore , it seems that the presence of long aliphatic chains in the asphaltene molecules modifies the typical structure of a nanoaggregate [ ] enhancing t - shaped geometry ( @xmath16-@xmath179 interaction ) and offset @xmath16-stacked geometry ( @xmath179-@xmath179 interaction ) compared to @xmath16-@xmath16 geometry [ ] . it would be very interesting to consider the effect of adding asphaltene and resin molecules with long aliphatic chains in our simulations on the shape of the nanoaggregate size distribution compared to the simple exponential distribution . in conclusion , we have shown that the aggregation reactions give a good description of the stability of linear asphaltene nanoaggregates as observed in molecular dynamics ( md ) simulations . from these aggregation reactions , we derived a master equation able to reproduce the monoexponential behavior of the stationary probability of having a nanoaggregate containing a given number of asphaltene molecules in md . the parameter of the monoexponential behavior is interpreted as the ratio between the attachment and detachment rate constants of a single asphaltene molecule to a nanoaggregate . the master equation approach is also able to reproduce the aggregation dynamics . from the same aggregation reactions , we also derived a statistical mechanics model giving a thermodynamics interpretation of the monoexponential behavior . the main parameter is then the effective free energy between two asphaltene molecules , when the degrees of freedom corresponding to solvent molecules , resin , and resinous oil molecules and branched nanoaggregates are integrated out . finally , a possible thermodynamic explanation for the biexponential behavior , observed for the stationary probability of having a nanoaggregate of @xmath18 aromatic molecules in md , is the flexibility of these nanoaggregates . to continue this work on bitumen nanoaggregate two directions are possible and equally interesting . a first direction is to consider a simpler system without resin and resinous oil and even without any possibility of branching . then , the integration of the degrees of freedom related to the solvent molecules could be done and the effective energy could be evaluated in an independent way . this direction would lead to a quantitative understanding of the effective free energy between two asphaltene molecules . the second and opposite direction is to add more molecule types to resemble a real bitumen . for example asphaltene molecules without a head and with long alkyl chains could be added and the consequences of this addition on the probability of having a nanoaggregate of a given size investigated . interesting md simulations have been performed recently using many molecules types [ ] and could serve as an inspiration . another interesting route is to quantify the evolution of the nanoaggregate size distribution with the composition of the bitumen mixture . this work is sponsored by the grants 1337 - 00073b and 1335 - 00762b of the danish council for independent research @xmath180 technology and production science . it is in continuation of the cooee project ( co@xmath4 emission reduction by exploitation of rolling resistance modeling of pavements ) , sponsored by the danish council for strategic research . the centre for viscous liquids dynamics `` glass and time '' is supported by the danish national research foundation s grant dnrf61 . the probability @xmath31 of having a nanoaggregate with @xmath18 asphaltene molecules is defined as : @xmath181 where @xmath182 is the number of aggregates with @xmath18 asphaltene molecules and @xmath117 the total number of asphaltene nanoaggregates . according to eq . , @xmath183 so that one can express the total number of asphaltene nanoaggregates : @xmath184 to obtain the last expression eq . , we assume that the number of asphaltene molecules is very large , so that the sum goes to infinity and that the ratio @xmath185 is smaller than 1 , _ i. e. _ the volume @xmath101 is big enough for the aggregates to develop given the total number of asphaltene molecules and the equilibrium constant . inserting the expression eq . of the total number of asphaltene aggregates back into eq . gives : @xmath186 it is a geometrical law of the form @xmath187 and the parameter @xmath58 can be identified as : @xmath188 an expression for @xmath72 , the number of asphaltene aggregates of size @xmath69 , is given by the conservation law : @xmath189 , where @xmath75 is the total number of asphaltene molecules . it leads to : @xmath190 the last expression eq . is a quadratic equation , whose solutions are : @xmath191 where @xmath192 the solution @xmath193 is the physical one , because in the limit where there is no interaction between the asphaltene molecules and even a large repulsion , all molecules should be in aggregates of size @xmath69 . in mathematical terms , it gives : @xmath194 only @xmath193 satisfies this last equation . it leads finally to : @xmath195 which is the same result as eq . . another useful expression is the one giving the equilibrium constant @xmath196 in terms of the parameter @xmath58 : @xmath197 finally , it is noteworthy that the minimization of the free energy of the system as given in eq . subject to the conservation condition eq . leads to the same result . the minimization can be done using a lagrange multiplier to guarantee the conservation of the total number of asphaltene molecules . in this calculation , the free energy @xmath102 of an aggregate should be expressed right away as @xmath198 , where the arbitrary origin of the energy @xmath199 should be equal to @xmath200 . in this case , @xmath113 represents the energetic penalty of having a free end . j. f. branthaver , j. c. petersen , r. e. robertson , j. j. duvall , s. s. kim , p. m. harnsberger , t. mill , e. k. ensley , f. a. barbour , and j. f. schabron , tech . shrp - a-368 , strategic highway research program ( 1993 ) . o. c. mullins , h. sabbah , j. eyssautier , a. e. pomerantz , l. barr , a. b. andrews , y. ruiz - morales , f. mostowfi , r. mcfarlane , l. goual , r. lepkowicz , t. cooper , j. orbulescu , r. m. leblanc , j. edwards , and r. n. zare , energy & fuels * 26 * , 3986 ( 2012 ) .
Abstract: | [
"asphaltene and smaller aromatic molecules tend to form linear nanoaggregates in bitumen . over the years bitumen undergoes chemical aging and during this process , the size of the nanoaggregate increases . this increase is associated with an increase in viscosity and brittleness of the bitumen , eventually leading to road deterioration . this paper focuses on understanding the mechanisms behind nanoaggregate size and stability . we used molecular dynamics simulations to quantify the probability of having a nanoaggregate of a given size in the stationary regime . to model this complicated behavior , we chose first to consider the simple case where only asphaltene molecules are counted in a nanoaggregate . we used a master equation approach and a related statistical mechanics model . the linear asphaltene nanoaggregates behave as a rigid linear chain . the most complicated case where all aromatic molecules are counted in a nanoaggregate is then discussed . the linear aggregates where all aromatic molecules are counted seem to behave as a flexible linear chain . corresponding author : c. a. lemarchand , e - mail : [email protected]"
] | 11,190 | 11,190 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: by now , jump - diffusion processes and more general lvy processes or lvy driven processes are widely used in models of the stock dynamics and term structure models , under both historic and risk neutral measure . however , only discrete time series of empirical data are available , therefore the problem of identification of the jump and diffusion components is a non - trivial task . the problem of the identification of the diffusion component was considered in detail in ait - sahalia ( 2002 , 2003 ) ; in the present paper , the focus is on the jump component . clearly , the presence of jumps is most prominent in prices of contingent claims near expiry , especially for out - of - the money options , and therefore it is natural to extract information about the jump part of the process by using empirical data for out - of - the - money european options . carr and wu ( 2003 ) showed that in the presence of jumps , the prices of out - of - the - money european options near expiry are of order @xmath3 , where @xmath3 is the time to expiry , and use this observation to test for the presence of jumps . however , the results in carr and wu ( 2003 ) are qualitative rather than quantitative . the principal aim of the present paper is to derive simple analytical formulas which can be used for the identification of the jump part of a lvy process ( under a risk - neutral measure chosen by the market ) ; the straightforward generalizations to mean - reverting processes driven by lvy processes ( the ornstein - uhlenbeck type processes ) , stochastic volatility models with jumps and lvy - driven term structure models will be published elsewhere . the first group of results of the present paper are formulas for @xmath0 , or time decay , of out - of - the money european call and put options on a stock , at expiry . contrary to the gaussian case , @xmath0 for the former ( resp . , the latter ) is shown to be negative if there are positive ( resp . , negative ) jumps . in other words , we prove that near expiry , these prices are linear functions of time to expiry ( up to relatively small errors ) , and calculate the coefficients . the results are explicit analytical expressions in terms of the parameters which characterize the process . by using these formulas and empirical data for options near expiry as in carr and wu ( 2003 ) , it is possible to identify the jump part of a particular lvy model . after that , by using the data for options far from expiry , one can identify the first instantaneous moment of the process , and calculate the diffusion coefficient by subtracting the second instantaneous moment of the jump part of the process . this gives a new identification method for the diffusion component . by using the formulas for the @xmath0 s for the european put and call , we obtain approximations for the american put price and early exercise boundary near expiry . the pricing of american options in the gaussian case is well understood see e.g. musiela and rutkowski ( 1997 ) , karatzas and shreve ( 1998 ) , carr and faguet ( 1994 ) , carr ( 1998 ) , longstaff and schwartz ( 2001 ) , clment et al . ( 2002 ) , and the bibliography therein . in the infinite horizon case , explicit analytical formulas are obtained , and in the finite horizon case , a number of efficient numerical methods are developed . although explicit formulas are not available in the finite horizon case , several general results are proved for this case as well . consider the american put with the strike price @xmath4 and maturity @xmath5 , on a non - dividend paying stock ; the riskless rate @xmath6 is constant . let @xmath7 be the optimal exercise price of the american put . if the stock log - price @xmath8 follows the brownian motion , then the asymptotic behavior of @xmath9 is known both near expiry : @xmath10 as @xmath11 ( see , e.g. , barles _ ( 1995 ) and lamberton ( 1995 ) ; an asymptotic formula for the put price is also available ) , and for small values of @xmath12 : for any @xmath13 , @xmath14 ( see , e.g. musiela and rutkowski ( 1997 ) ; ( [ asymprgauss ] ) is formulated as follows : if the riskless interest rate is zero , then the early exercise of the american put is not optimal ) . notice that ( [ asbgauss ] ) implies that @xmath15 and that ( [ exlim ] ) and ( [ asymprgauss ] ) do not agree well when both the riskless interest rate and time to expiry vanish . in levendorski ( 2003 ) , a variant of carr s randomization method was developed for wide families of lvy processes , and as a by - product , it was shown that for many families of non - gaussian processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , the analogs of ( [ exlim ] ) and ( [ asymprgauss ] ) agree much better . namely , @xmath16 where @xmath17 depends on some of parameters which characterize the price process , and is _ smaller _ than the strike price , @xmath4 . moreover , it was proved that @xmath17 vanishes with @xmath12 , and therefore , @xmath18 notice that ( [ asymprlevy ] ) looks more natural than ( [ asymprgauss ] ) , and may be of some importance in today s almost deflationary world . further , if the difference @xmath19 is sizable , then any numerical procedure or parameters fitting procedure which does not take this fact into account , may produce significant errors near expiry and strike . hence , the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary has practical implications for the parameters fitting and development of accurate numerical methods . however , the proof in levendorski ( 2003 ) has three disadvantages , which stem from the use of the wiener - hopf method . first , the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary results from long calculations without clear intuition . next , the approximate formulas for the put price are expressed in terms of the factors in the wiener - hopf factorization formula , hence , they are complicated for practical use , and finally , the method in levendorski ( 2003 ) is not directly applicable to a popular class of variance gamma processes , which was used in carr et al ( 2002 ) , madan and hirsa ( 2003 ) , and carr and hirsa ( 2003 ) for pricing of american put . the generalization of the method for more general classes of processes seems impossible . here we prove ( [ exlimlevy ] ) and ( [ asymprlevy ] ) by using a much simpler argument . we obtain an efficient approximation for the put price near expiry , and formulate the result about the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary in a more meaningful form . also , we extend the result in levendorski ( 2003 ) to variance gamma processes , and in addition , we find a condition on a process which ensures that the behavior of the boundary is even more regular than in the gaussian case : there exists a negative constant @xmath20 s.t . @xmath21 we prove that the limit of the boundary at expiry is located where @xmath22 of the european call is equal to the riskless rate . ( if the @xmath22 of the european call at expiry is less than the riskless rate for all spot prices less than the strike , then the limit is the strike . ) when the corresponding equation is solved , one can use the formulas for @xmath0 s of the european call and put and obtain an efficient approximation to the put price near expiry . the formulas are fairly simple and can be used for parameters fitting purposes near expiry , both for the european options and american put . they also can be used to improve performance of numerical methods : when using the backward induction , one can start not at expiry , where the value function is most irregular but close to it , and use the analytical approximation as the basis for the backward induction . we demonstrate how large the deviations from the standard behavior of the early exercise boundary and put price can be by using the empirical data for the american put documented in carr et al . we found that the non - standard behavior should be observed for reasonable values of the riskless rate : typically , the margin between the strike and boundary is 10% or more , and for the spot price in the 5%interval around the strike , the jump premium " in the put price over the pay - off is @xmath23 or more , where @xmath3 is the time to expiry ( with the normalization @xmath24 for a business year ) . the last aim of the paper is to describe the restrictions on the log - price process under an emm , which should be satisfied if the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is observed . as ( [ exlim ] ) , ( [ exlimlevy ] ) and ( [ superregular ] ) imply , various types of the behavior of @xmath9 near expiry are possible however , for many families of processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , namely , hyperbolic processes , normal inverse gaussian processes ( nig ) , and truncated lvy processes of the extended koponen s family ( a.k.a . kobol processes , a.k.a . cgmy model ) of order @xmath25 , the behavior of the early exercise boundary is non - standard for all parameters values . this means that if in the empirical studies , the early exercise boundary for put options on a particular stock exhibits the standard behavior near expiry , then the use of any of the processes above to model the log - price dynamics under a risk - neutral measure chosen by the market is inconsistent with the data . normal inverse gaussian processes , hyperbolic processes and kobol processes of order greater than 1 are processes with sample paths of infinite variation . notice that the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is proved for much wider classes of infinite variation lvy processes as well . for processes with finite variation jump component , the prominent examples being variance gamma processes and kobol processes of order less than 1 , both the non - standard behavior ( [ exlimlevy ] ) and super - regular " behavior ( [ superregular ] ) of the early exercise boundary are possible , depending on parameters of the process ; there are also borderline cases , when we are able only to prove that ( [ exlim ] ) holds . according to a recent empirical study in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , finite variation processes fit empirical data better . even for a finite variation process , if we fix all the parameters of a process except for the drift @xmath26 , let @xmath27 and change @xmath26 accordingly so that the stock remains a martingale , then below a certain critical value of @xmath12 ( depending on the parameters of the process ) , the non - standard behavior is observed , and as @xmath12 decreases further , the optimal exercise price goes to zero uniformly over the interval @xmath2 . it is natural to ask how robust the result about the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is . in levendorski ( 2003 ) and the present paper , it is assumed that dynamics of log - prices @xmath8 follows a non - gaussian lvy process under a risk - neutral measure chosen by the market . this simplest choice of a non - gaussian risk - neutral measure for pricing of the american put was employed in carr et al ( 2002 ) , madan and hirsa ( 2003 ) , carr and hirsa ( 2003 ) , where parameters fitting and computational issues where addressed . better fit can be achieved with stochastic volatility models with jumps but the method in levendorski ( 2003 ) can not be generalized for stochastic volatility models . the method of the present paper can be applied to stochastic volatility models ( and term structure models ) , and under certain parameter restrictions , the margin between the early exercise boundary and strike can be derived . further , in levendorski ( 2003 ) and the present paper , the formulas for the margin are derived in two different approximate models , and in cases which were considered in the both papers , the formulas for the margin are the same . the identical results in two approximations allows one to hope that the margin in the continuous time model is the same . as a proven theorem , we can only claim that the margin in the approximate model is not less than in the continuous time model . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . in section [ levy ] , we recall the definition of lvy processes , and give examples of several families of lvy processes used in empirical studies of financial markets . in section [ europe ] , @xmath0 s of out - of - the - money european put and call options are calculated , and in section [ amerput ] , the approximate formulas for the american put price and early exercise boundary near expiry are derived . in section [ implications ] , we consider several families of lvy processes used ( and suggested for use ) in empirical studies of financial markets , and discuss the implications of non - standard behavior of prices and early exercise boundary for the choice of a family of processes , and parameters fitting in more detail . in section [ empirics ] , we derive properties of the early exercise boundary for kobol processes , for parameters values documented in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , and show that the margin between the strike price and early exercise boundary can be significant indeed : more than 10% . in the appendix , the technical proofs are given . recall that a lvy process is a process with stationary independent increments ( for general definitions , see e.g. sato ( 1999 ) ) . a lvy process may have a gaussian component and/or pure jump component . the latter is characterized by the density of jumps , which is called the lvy density . we denote it by @xmath28 . also , a lvy process can be completely specified by its characteristic exponent , @xmath29 , definable from the equality @xmath30=e^{-t\psi(\xi)}$ ] ( we confine ourselves to the one - dimensional case ) . if @xmath31 is a lvy process with finite variation jump component , then the characteristic exponent is given by @xmath32 where @xmath33 and @xmath26 are the variance and drift coefficient of the gaussian component , and @xmath34 satisfies @xmath35 equation ( [ psi1 ] ) is a special case of the lvy - khintchine formula ; for the general case , see e.g. sato ( 1999 ) . wide families of jump - diffusion processes used in the theoretical and empirical studies of financial markets are lvy processes with finite variation jump component . 0.1cm_example 2.1 . _ let @xmath36 be a lvy process with the lvy density @xmath37 where @xmath38 , and @xmath39 . then @xmath40 where @xmath41 and @xmath42 are the variance and drift of the gaussian component . the @xmath43 is holomorphic in the strip @xmath44 . in order that @xmath45 $ ] be finite , we need to impose an additional condition @xmath46 . for the sake of brevity , we will consider below the exponential jump - diffusions with the characteristic exponent of the form ( [ jumpdif ] ) . the generalization to the case of lvy densities given by general exponential polynomials on positive and negative half - axis is straightforward . 0.1cm_example 2.2 . _ variance gamma processes ( vgp ) have been developed and used by madan and co - authors in a series of papers during 90th ( see madan et al . ( 1998 ) and the bibliography there ) . the characteristic exponent of a vgp without the diffusion component can be represented in the form @xmath47,\ ] ] where @xmath48 and @xmath49 . the condition @xmath45<+\infty$ ] imposes an additional restriction @xmath46 . 0.1cm_example 2.3 . _ truncated lvy processes ( tlp ) constructed by koponen ( 1995 ) were used for modeling in real financial markets in bouchaud and potters ( 1997 ) , cont et al . ( 1997 ) and matacz ( 2000 ) ; a generalization of this family was constructed in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 ) and called the extended koponen family of tlp processes . later , this generalization was used in carr et al . ( 2002 ) under the name cgmy - model . as a.n . shiryaev remarked , the name tlp was misleading , and so starting with boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002a-2002c ) , we use the name kobol processes . the characteristic exponent of a kobol process is of the form @xmath50,\ ] ] where @xmath51 , and @xmath42 . the condition @xmath45<+\infty$ ] imposes an additional restriction @xmath52 . ( in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002b ) , the reader can also find a formula for the kobol process of order @xmath53 ) . for @xmath54 , the equation ( [ kbl1d ] ) is obtained from ( [ psi1 ] ) with the lvy density given by @xmath55 and @xmath56 ( that is , there is no gaussian component ) . in the case @xmath57 , instead of ( [ psi1 ] ) , the general form of the lvy - khintchine formula is needed ( see sato ( 1999 ) and boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) ) . kobol processes of order @xmath58 are finite - variation processes , and the ones of order @xmath59 are infinite - variation processes . other examples of infinite variation processes are hyperbolic processes ( hp ) , normal inverse gaussian processes ( nig ) and normal tempered stable ( nts ) lvy processes of order @xmath60 ; in the general classification of boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002a-2002c ) , hp and nig are processes of order 1 . hyperbolic processes were constructed and used by eberlein and co - authors ( see e.g. eberlein and keller ( 1995 ) , eberlein et al . ( 1998 ) , eberlein and raible ( 1999 ) ) ; hyperbolic distributions were constructed in barndorff - nielsen ( 1977 ) . normal inverse gaussian processes ( nig ) were introduced in barndorff - nielsen ( 1998 ) and used to model german stocks in barndorff - nielsen and jiang ( 1998 ) ; generalization of the class nig , namely , the class of normal tempered stable ( nts ) lvy processes , was constructed in barndorff - nielsen and levendorski ( 2001 ) and barndorff - nielsen and shephard ( 2001 ) . as kobol processes , ntslp can be of any order between 0 and 2 . 0.1 cm _ example 2.4 . _ the characteristic exponent of an nts lvy process is of the form @xmath61,\ ] ] where @xmath62 @xmath63 , and @xmath64 . the condition @xmath45<+\infty$ ] imposes an additional restriction @xmath65 . with @xmath53 , we obtain the characteristic exponent of nig processes . 0.1cm_remark 2.1 . _ for the explicit calculations in the next two sections , it is important that the characteristic exponent of any of lvy processes considered above admit the analytic continuation into the complex plane with cuts @xmath66 , [ i{{\lambda_+ } } , + i\infty)$ ] , where @xmath52 and @xmath67 , and the analytic continuation is defined by the same formula ( in example 2.4 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 , and in example 2.1 , the characteristic exponent is analytic in the complex plane with two poles at @xmath70 and @xmath71 ) . this property is unnecessary if we want to obtain only qualitative results . for instance , the existence of a non - vanishing margin between the strike and early exercise boundary will be proved for more general class of lvy processes with the jump part of infinite variation . to simplify the presentation , we normalize the strike price to 1 . let @xmath31 be a lvy process of any class considered above . let @xmath72 and @xmath73 be the price of the european call and put option , respectively , at time @xmath74 , and the spot price @xmath75 . denote by @xmath76 , and @xmath77 , the opposite to the @xmath78 of the out - of - the - money european call and put options , respectively , at expiry ( the option s @xmath0 is the derivative of the option price with respect to time ) : for @xmath79 , @xmath80 and for @xmath81 , @xmath82 if the process is gaussian , then the prices of out - of - the - money european call , @xmath83 , and put , @xmath84 , vanish faster than any power of @xmath3 , as @xmath85 , hence the limits ( [ cc ] ) and ( [ cp ] ) equal 0 . the next theorem and lemma show that in the case of non - gaussian lvy processes which we consider , both @xmath86 and @xmath77 , exist and do not vanish . the intuition is that when the jumps are present , the value of waiting of a positive ( respectively , negative ) movement in the price is larger than in the gaussian case . [ margin1 ] let @xmath31 be any of lvy processes considered above . then 0.cm a ) for @xmath79 , the limit ( [ cc ] ) exists , and it is positive ; 0.cmb ) for @xmath81 , the limit ( [ cp ] ) exists , and it is positive ; 0.cmc ) the time decay at expiry , of out - of - the money european call , @xmath87 @xmath88 and put , @xmath77 , depends only on the positive and negative jump parts of the process , respectively , but not on the drift and gaussian component . notice that the intuition behind the independence of the time decay at expiry of the gaussian component is simple : the movements caused by the latter are of order @xmath89 , on average , and therefore the main contribution to the price of an out - of - the - money option , ( almost ) at expiry , can come from the jumps in the corresponding direction only ( for a rigorous proof , see the appendix ) . we start with the simplest case of a pure jump process ( example 2.1 with @xmath56 ) . let @xmath90 be the infinitesimal generator of @xmath36 . then the price @xmath91 of a contingent claim with the terminal pay - off @xmath92 can be represented in the form @xmath93g(x+\mu \tau).\ ] ] for the pure jump process , @xmath90 acts as follows : @xmath94 and since @xmath95 for processes in example 1.1 , we conclude that @xmath90 is a bounded operator in @xmath96 . hence , if @xmath97 is bounded ( the case of the put option : @xmath98 ) , we can write ( [ europclaim ] ) in the form @xmath99 if the put option is out - of - the - money , that is , @xmath81 , then for small @xmath3 , @xmath100 , hence the zero - order term in ( [ europclaim2 ] ) is zero , and @xmath101 by dividing by @xmath102 and passing to the limit , we obtain @xmath103 it remains to calculate @xmath104 at @xmath81 . we have @xmath105 and by calculating the integral , we obtain @xmath106 the case of the call option requires essentially the same calculations but @xmath90 should be regarded as a bounded operator in a space of continuous functions , which grow as @xmath107 as @xmath108 ( for details , see boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) ) , and the result is @xmath109 similarly , @xmath110 and @xmath111 for more general exponential jump - diffusions can be calculated . moreover , the proof above gives @xmath112 and @xmath113 provided @xmath114 and @xmath115 ( the latter condition is necessary for the stock to be priced ) . we conjecture that ( [ ccgen ] ) and ( [ cpgen ] ) are valid for any lvy process satisfying ( [ denspos1 ] ) . however , we were unable to prove ( [ cc])([cp ] ) in the full generality , and so in the proof of theorem [ margin1 ] for the other families of lvy processes listed above , we calculate the limits @xmath110 and @xmath111 directly , by using the formulas for the characteristic exponents . in the case of nts lvy processes and nig , set @xmath116 . now , for any @xmath31 of kobol , nts , and vgp classes , and for @xmath117 and @xmath118 , define @xmath119.\ ] ] [ gen ] let @xmath31 be a vgp , kobol , or nts lvy process . then for @xmath79 , @xmath120 and for @xmath81 , @xmath121 in the appendix . in the gaussian case , @xmath122 , and since @xmath123 depends linearly on @xmath29 , we conclude that @xmath123 depends on the jump component of the process only . hence , @xmath76 , and @xmath77 , depend on the jump component only . the fact that the former depends on the positive jumps only , and the latter on the negative ones , follows by inspection of the lvy - khintchine formula : for @xmath118 ( resp . , @xmath117 ) , @xmath124 is independent of the density of negative ( resp . , positive ) jumps . in the appendix , we will calculate @xmath124 for each family of processes , and derive from ( [ genc])([genp ] ) the following formulas : \1 ) for kobol processes of order @xmath125 : @xmath126 the integrals converge since @xmath127 and @xmath128 ; \2 ) for vgp : @xmath129 the integrals converge since @xmath130 ; \3 ) for nts lvy processes @xmath131^{\nu/2}}{z(z+1)}dz,\quad x<0;\\ \label{cpnts } { { \mathcal p}}(x)&=&\frac{{\delta}}{\pi}\sin\frac{\pi\nu}{2}\int^{+\infty}_{{\alpha}+{\beta } } \frac{e^{-xz}[(z-{\beta})^2-{\alpha}^2]^{\nu/2}}{z(z+1)}dz,\quad x>0;\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath53 , formulas for nig processes obtain . the integrals converge since @xmath132 , @xmath133 , and @xmath128 . by direct inspection of formulas ( [ cckbl])([cpnts ] ) , we conclude that with @xmath134 , the integrands decay as @xmath135 as @xmath136 for processes of order @xmath137 ; if @xmath31 is a vgp or exponential jump - diffusion , then the integrands decay faster than @xmath138 , for any @xmath139 . therefore , with @xmath134 , the integrals diverge if and only if the jump component of @xmath31 is a process of order @xmath140 . further , the integrands are positive monotone continuous functions of @xmath141 . by using the monotone convergence theorem , we deduce [ margin2 ] a ) for processes of order @xmath58 , vgp , and exponential jump - diffusion processes in example 2.1 , there exist finite limits @xmath142 \b ) for nig , and kobol and nts lvy processes of order @xmath143 , the limits @xmath144 and @xmath145 exist but are infinite . \c ) @xmath146 is an increasing continuous function , which maps @xmath147 onto @xmath148 , and @xmath149 is a decreasing continuous function , which maps @xmath150 onto @xmath151 . _ remark 3.1 . _ a ) it is possible to derive formulas for @xmath86 and @xmath77 , for the case of hyperbolic processes , and that part b ) of theorem [ margin2 ] holds in this case . b ) can be proved for more general classes of lvy processes . for instance , @xmath152 can be proved if in a neighborhood of 0 , the density of positive jumps , @xmath153 , admits a lower bound via @xmath154 , where @xmath155 . then there exists a density @xmath156 such that @xmath157 and @xmath158 where @xmath159 . clearly , @xmath110 can not increase if we replace @xmath153 with @xmath160 . the argument in the proof of theorem [ margin1 ] for the jump - diffusion case shows that the contribution of @xmath156 to @xmath110 is bounded uniformly in @xmath79 , and the proof for kobol processes shows that @xmath161 gives a contribution which is unbounded as @xmath162 . 0.1 cm to finish this section , we list approximate formulas for european call and put options near expiry , which follow from theorem [ margin1 ] and the put - call pairity . of course , these approximations are too inaccurate in a very small neighborhood of the strike if the process is of order @xmath163 . for @xmath81 : @xmath164 for @xmath79 : @xmath165 assume that @xmath144 and @xmath145 exist . they are measures of the influence of positive and negative jumps , respectively , and the emm condition is naturally formulated in terms of @xmath166 and @xmath144 and @xmath145 . as it was shown above , the limits ( finite or infinite ) exist for the families of processes in examples 2.12.4 . [ emm ] let @xmath31 be a lvy process with finite variation jump component . then @xmath167 is a local martingale if and only if @xmath168 since the gaussian component @xmath169 and jump component @xmath170 of a lvy process are independent , @xmath167 is a local martingale if and only if for any @xmath171 and @xmath172 , @xmath173e\left[e^{y_t}\right]\\ & = & e^{(\mu - r+{\sigma}^2/2)t+x_s}e\left[e^{y_t}\right ] , \end{aligned}\ ] ] whereupon @xmath174,\ ] ] and @xmath175 - 1,\ ] ] which is @xmath176 ( here @xmath177 denotes the transition kernel of the semigroup @xmath178 , @xmath179=\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}p_t(z)f(y+z)dz.\right)\ ] ] divide by @xmath180 : @xmath181 and pass to the limit @xmath182 ; the result is ( [ emm1 ] ) . we rewrite ( [ emm1 ] ) as @xmath183 for processes without the gaussian component , ( [ emm2 ] ) is simpler : @xmath184 the first theorem below shows that if negative jumps are present but their influence is not very large , and compensated by a positive drift ( which clearly decreases the value of waiting ) , then the early exercise boundary converges to the strike price . moreover , the convergence is more regular than in the gaussian case in the sense that ( [ superregular ] ) holds . let @xmath185 be the early exercise boundary . the continuous time model can be approximated by a discrete time model with small time steps @xmath186 . in the discrete time approximation , the option can be exercised at @xmath187 only . denote by @xmath188 the optimal exercise boundary at the last moment before the expiry , and set @xmath189 . one should expect that the behavior of @xmath190 for small @xmath191 is a good proxy for the behavior of the optimal exercise boundary near expiry . in particular , @xmath192 if the limit in the lhs exists . the proof of a simplified version @xmath193 is straightforward : as we make the class of admissible stopping times smaller , the price of the american put does not increase , therefore the early exercise boundary does not go down . we were unable to prove the equality ( [ just ] ) but the inequality ( [ just2 ] ) suffices to make the conclusion that if the early exercise boundary in the discrete time approximation exhibits the non - standard behavior in the limit @xmath194 , then the behavior of the early exercise boundary in the continuous time model is also non - standard . [ extrastan ] let @xmath31 be a vgp or kobol process of finite variation , without gaussian component , or an exponential jump process . let @xmath195 then @xmath196 in other words , _ if @xmath22 of the out - of - the - money european put , at the expiry and strike , is less than the drift , then the slope of the boundary near expiry equals the @xmath22 . _ at @xmath197 , a put owner must be indifferent between exercising and holding the put , therefore @xmath190 is the solution to the equation @xmath198 ( the lhs is the value of the put if it is exercised , and the rhs is the expected present value of the put if it is kept alive ) , equivalently , @xmath199 assume that for small @xmath200 , @xmath201 , then @xmath202 , hence @xmath203 . by using the taylor formula and dividing by @xmath191 , we obtain @xmath204 then we pass to the limit @xmath205 @xmath206 condition @xmath207 is necessary lest the assumption @xmath208 lead to a contradiction ; and the condition ( [ cneg ] ) suffices for the inequality @xmath208 to hold for small @xmath191 . now assume that ( [ cneg ] ) fails . this happens when either the drift is negative or the influence of negative jumps is too large . hence , the value of waiting should increase , and the optimal exercise boundary should be lower . as we will see , apart from the borderline case @xmath209 , the value of waiting becomes so large that @xmath190 remains bounded away from 0 , as @xmath205 . [ thm : finvar ] let @xmath31 be a vgp or kobol process of finite variation , without gaussian component , or an exponential jump process . then a ) if @xmath209 , then the limit @xmath210 exists , and it is equal to 0 ; \b ) if @xmath211 then the limit ( [ barh ] ) exists . it is negative , and can be found from the equation @xmath212 which has a unique solution . in other words , _ if @xmath22 of the out - of - the - money european put , at the expiry and strike , is bigger than the drift , then the limit of the early exercise boundary at expiry is less than the strike . it is located where @xmath22 of the out - of - the - money call , at expiry , is equal to the riskless rate . _ we start with part b ) . first of all , we notice that due to ( [ emm3 ] ) , ( [ cneg2 ] ) is equivalent to @xmath213 therefore on the strength of theorem [ margin2 ] , c ) , the solution @xmath214 to ( [ formpos1 ] ) exists and it is unique . secondly , the reader may be surprised that the answer is formulated in terms of the density of positive jumps , but the proof shows that this is a consequence of the put - call pairity ( for european options ) . since @xmath215 is a ( local ) martingale under the risk - neutral measure , we have @xmath216 hence , we can rewrite the rhs in ( [ exb1 ] ) as @xmath217 ( essentially , this is the put - call pairity ) , and therefore , ( [ exb1 ] ) can be written as @xmath218 we see that if @xmath219 is negative for small @xmath191 , then @xmath220 depends only on the upper tail of the probability density . by dividing by @xmath191 and passing to the limit , we obtain ( [ formpos1 ] ) . thus , part b ) has been proved . in part a ) , @xmath209 , hence from ( [ emm1 ] ) , @xmath221 , and if we assume that for some sequence @xmath222 , the sequence @xmath223 remains bounded away from 0 , then by dividing by @xmath224 in ( [ exb2 ] ) and passing to the limit , we obtain an inequality , contradiction . in the following theorem , we allow for a gaussian component . [ gauss ] let @xmath31 be a vgp or kobol of order @xmath58 , or exponential jump - diffusion process , with a gaussian component . then a ) if @xmath225 , then the limit @xmath214 exists . it is negative , and can be found from ( [ formpos1 ] ) ; \b ) if @xmath226 , then the limit @xmath214 exists , and it is equal to 0 . by repeating the proof of theorem [ thm : finvar ] , we obtain a ) , and similar arguments show that under condition @xmath226 , an assumption that the behavior of the boundary is non - standard , leads to contradiction . this gives b ) . we see that in the case @xmath226 , the result is weaker than in the pure jump case , where we can single out the case when the boundary is more regular than in the gaussian case . according to part b ) of theorem [ margin2 ] , now @xmath227 as @xmath228 . by using this observation , and repeating the proof of part a ) of theorem [ thm : finvar ] , we obtain [ thm : infvar ] let @xmath31 be a nig or kobol or ntsl process of infinite variation . then the limit @xmath229 exists . it is negative , and can be found from the equation ( [ formpos1 ] ) . _ remark 4.1 . _ if the density of positive jumps satisfies the conditions in remark 3.1 b ) , then @xmath152 , and repeating the proof of theorem [ thm : finvar ] , we obtain that @xmath214 is negative . let @xmath31 be a process from any of families in examples 2.12.4 . let @xmath230 but the lvy density and the diffusion coefficient of the gaussian component remain fixed . then the drift of the process changes with @xmath12 and converges to a finite value . by the direct inspection of ( [ formpos1 ] ) , we conclude that if the early exercise boundary exhibits the non - gaussian behavior ( [ exlimlevy ] ) near expiry , then the early exercise price near expiry vanishes with @xmath12 as well . the same argument as in the gaussian case shows that for any @xmath102 , @xmath231 as @xmath230 ( see ( [ asymprgauss ] ) ) , therefore we conclude that the optimal exercise price tends to zero uniformly on the interval @xmath2 . notice that if @xmath31 is a vgp or a kobol process of order @xmath232 , or exponential jump - diffusion ( as in example 2.1 ) , then for large @xmath12 , ( [ formpos1 ] ) has no solution , but for sufficiently small @xmath12 , equation ( [ formpos1 ] ) has a unique solution , and this solution tends to 0 together with @xmath12 . this means that for sufficiently low levels of the riskless rate , all the processes considered above should lead to the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary . by using the approximate formulas for the european put and call near expiry at the end of section 3 , we obtain approximate formulas for the american put price near expiry : @xmath233 notice that this approximation is too inaccurate very close to the strike , especially for infinite variation processes . the behavior of the early exercise boundary near expiry can be used to determine the type of a lvy process , which can be used to model the log - price dynamics under the risk - neutral measure . this choice of a risk - neutral measure was used in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , hirsa and madan ( 2003 ) and carr and hirsa ( 2003 ) . empirical studies of financial markets clearly indicate the presence of both downward and upward jumps ( under historic measure ) , therefore if the boundary exhibits the standard behavior , then one may not use simultaneously a process of order @xmath234 under the historic measure and lvy process under a risk - neutral measure ( chosen by the market ) . indeed , as it is shown in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , p.312 , the difference between the historic and risk - neutral lvy densities must be of finite variation , therefore a process of infinite ( finite ) variation under the historic measure must remain a process of infinite ( finite ) variation under an emm . processes of order @xmath235 can be used for modelling of log - price dynamics both under historic and risk - neutral measure but additional restrictions on the density of the upward jumps must be imposed . another possibility is to use one - sided kobol processes with densities of positive jumps of an order different from the one for positive jumps ( see boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002b ) ) . the characteristic exponents of these strongly asymmetric kobol processes are of the form @xmath236\\ & & \hskip1 cm + c_-\gamma(-\nu_-)[(-{{\lambda_-}})^{\nu_-}-(-{{\lambda_-}}-i\xi)^{\nu_-}],\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath237 , @xmath238 , and @xmath239 ( for the formulas in the case @xmath240 , see boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2000 , 2002b ) ) . the analogs of ( [ cckbl ] ) and ( [ cpkbl ] ) are @xmath241 if a finite variation process is chosen for modelling of the american put on a particular stock , then the choice of parameters of the process is constrained by the observed behavior of the early exercise boundary : a. if the non - standard behavior ( [ exlimlevy ] ) is observed , then the constraint is @xmath242 ; b. if the super - regular " behavior ( [ superregular ] ) is observed , then the constraint is @xmath243 ( and probably , there is no gaussian component ) ; however , as empirical examples in the next section show , this possibility is unlikely to realize ; c. if @xmath244 but the super - regular " behavior ( [ superregular ] ) is not documented , then the constraint is @xmath245 , and the gaussian component is admissible . still another possibility is to assume that under an emm chosen by the market , the rate of decay of the density of positive jumps is very large ; then @xmath244 for processes of order @xmath235 , and @xmath214 is negative but very close to 0 for processes of order @xmath246 . for kobol , this means that the steepness parameter @xmath247 must be large in modulus . if under the historic measure , the @xmath247 is not large , this interpretation presumes that the agents in the market are very risk averse . the formulas for @xmath0 of out - of - the money european call and put options , at expiry , can also be used to infer the type of an appropriate family of processes , and parameters of the process . in particular , if @xmath0 at expiry quickly grows as the spot price approaches the strike price , then processes with infinite variation jump component must be used , otherwise the processes with finite variation jump component . the aim of this section is to demonstrate how large the margin between the strike and early exercise boundary and the jump premium " in the american option price over the payoff @xmath248 can be for realistic values of parameters . we use risk - neutral parameters values of the kobol processes with a diffusion component , which were obtained for several stocks in carr et al . ( 2002 ) ( table 3 on p.327 in op . cit . ) . 0.1 cm _ example 5.1 . _ only in one case : ibm1111 , the process is of order @xmath249 : the risk - neutral parameters are @xmath250 , and @xmath251 ( in carr et al . , these parameters are denoted @xmath252 , and @xmath253 ) . since @xmath249 , the non - standard behavior of the early exercise boundary is guaranteed but the gap between the strike price and boundary is small unless the interest rate is very small indeed . it is seen from figure 1 , where we plot the graph of @xmath214 as a function of @xmath12 , that for @xmath254 , @xmath214 is about @xmath255 , and for @xmath256 , @xmath214 is close to 0.01 , so the gap is clearly seen . in figure 2 , we plot the graph of @xmath0 at expiry , for out - of - the - money european call and put ( graph of @xmath110 , for small @xmath79 near zero , and put , @xmath111 , for @xmath81 ) . both are unbounded in a neighborhood of @xmath257 . since the density of positive jumps decays very fast ( the steepness parameter @xmath258 is very large ) , the time decay of out - of - the - money puts is very small unless the spot price is very close to the strike . the density of positive jumps decays faster than the one of negative jumps ( @xmath259 ) , therefore the @xmath0 for the out - of - the - money call is smaller than the one for out - of - the - money put , for the same distance from the strike . 0.1 cm _ example 5.2 . _ for amzn1014 , the parameters are @xmath260 the fairly large @xmath261 indicates that the intensity of jumps is large , and relatively small values of @xmath262 and @xmath247 imply that there are many large jumps , especially negative ones ( recall that @xmath262 characterizes the rate of decay of the density of negative jumps ) . therefore , even not very close to expiry , the owner of an out - of - the - money european option can expect that with a non - negligible probability the option will become in - the - money . hence , the price of these out - of - the - money options is sizable , especially the one of the put . figure 3 demonstrates this effect . we plot graphs of @xmath146 and @xmath149 in a neighborhood of zero . further , @xmath263 , therefore for reasonable @xmath12 , we have @xmath242 , and the behavior of the early exercise boundary is non - standard . since the intensity of large negative jumps is significant , the value of waiting is very large , and the gap between the strike and optimal exercise boundary is also large . from ( [ amputapprox ] ) and figure 3 , we can conclude that even at 5% below the strike , the option value of waiting ( the difference between the american put price and the pay - off @xmath248 ) is of order @xmath23 ; @xmath24 is one year . in the next two figures 4 and 5 , we plot the graph of @xmath146 farther from the strike , and the graph of @xmath214 as the function of @xmath12 . in figure 6 , we plot both the early exercise boundary , at expiry , @xmath264 , as a function of @xmath12 , and that of the early exercise boundary far from expiry , @xmath265 ( the early exercise boundary in the infinite time horizon case ) . similar results are valid for the other stocks documented in carr et al . for several families of lvy processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , we have proved that the time decay of out - of - the - money european options at expiry is not negligible , and derived explicit formulas . these formulas can be used to make numerical calculations near expiry more accurate both for european options , and american ones . by using the same formulas , we proved that the optimal exercise boundary for the american put is separated from the strike price by a non - vanishing margin on the interval @xmath2 , and that as the riskless rate vanishes , the optimal exercise price goes to zero uniformly over the interval @xmath2 . the last result may be especially interesting since the current levels of interest rates are rather low . furthermore , we discussed the restrictions on the process under the risk - neutral measure which the non - gaussian behavior of the early exercise price near expiry imposes , and suggested a natural asymmetric extension of the kobol family ( a.k.a . cgmy model ) , which can be used for any type of the behavior of the boundary . we showed that for the risk - neutral parameters obtained for several stocks in carr et al . ( 2002 ) , the behavior should be non - standard , and the margin between the strike and the early exercise boundary be quite sizable : more than 10% , up to expiry . the jump premium over the payoff is shown to be sizable as well . further , we assume that @xmath46 ; the results for the case @xmath266 obtain by passing to the limit @xmath267 in the formulas for the case @xmath46 . for any @xmath268 , the price of the european call option is given by @xmath269 } { -i\xi(1-i\xi)}d\xi\ ] ] ( see e.g. boyarchenko and levendorski ( 1999 , 2002b ) ) . clearly , the limit @xmath110 is independent of @xmath12 , therefore we may set @xmath270 . the characteristic exponent of a process without the gaussian component is of the form @xmath271 where @xmath272 grows as @xmath273 in the complex plane with the cuts @xmath66 $ ] and @xmath274 , for processes of order @xmath137 . in the complex plane outside two poles @xmath275 . for vgp , @xmath272 grows as @xmath276 , and for exponential jump processes , @xmath272 decays as @xmath277 . set @xmath278 , and write ( [ callprice ] ) as @xmath279 } { -i\xi(1-i\xi)}d\xi.\ ] ] let @xmath31 be a kobol or nts lvy process of order @xmath280 . then we can find @xmath281 s.t . since @xmath283 is bounded away from zero on the line @xmath284 , the integrand in ( [ callprice2 ] ) admits an upper bound via @xmath285 it follows that the integral over @xmath286 makes a contribution of order @xmath287 since @xmath288 , we have @xmath289 on the set @xmath290 the @xmath79 is fixed , therefore for sufficiently small @xmath102 , @xmath291 is negative and bounded away from zero , and therefore , @xmath292 is negative and bounded away from zero , uniformly in @xmath293 and @xmath294 in the half - plane @xmath295 . this means that we can use the cauchy theorem and push the line of the integration in ( [ au1 ] ) down : @xmath296 , and obtain that the integral in ( [ au1 ] ) is zero . hence , @xmath297 by using essentially the same argument as in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) , where a similar integral ( 5.33 ) was transformed to the integral over the banks of the cut @xmath298 $ ] in the complex plane , and after the change of variables @xmath299 and @xmath300 on the left and right banks , respectively , to an integral over @xmath301 ( equation ( 5.37 ) in boyarchenko and levendorski ( 2002b ) ) , we obtain , for @xmath302 , @xmath303 as @xmath304 , @xmath305 , therefore by passing to the limit in ( [ genc2 ] ) , we obtain ( [ genc ] ) . recall that the calculations above were made for a kobol or nts lvy process of order @xmath306 . if @xmath31 is a vgp , then we make essentially the same argument by using any @xmath307 . if @xmath31 is a hyperbolic process , nig , or kobol or nts lvy process of order @xmath59 , then we start with the integration by part in ( [ callprice2 ] ) , by using @xmath308 after that we obtain an absolutely converging integral , and can repeat the constructions above with straightforward changes . in the end , we obtain @xmath309dz+o(1).\ ] ] by integrating by part back , and passing to the limit @xmath293 , we obtain ( [ genc ] ) . to finish the proof of ( [ genc ] ) , it remains to show that the result does not change when we add a gaussian component . let @xmath31 be any of the processes above , without a gaussian component , and let @xmath310 be a lvy process with the same drift " term and jump density as @xmath31 , and with the diffusion coefficient @xmath33 . let @xmath311 be the probability density of @xmath310 , and @xmath312 be the probability density of the brownian motion with the volatility @xmath33 . the @xmath312 is the convolution of @xmath177 and @xmath312 , therefore for @xmath81 , @xmath313 take @xmath314 . in the region @xmath315 , the gaussian density is @xmath316 , for any @xmath317 , therefore we may replace the outer integral with the integral over @xmath318 , and add @xmath319 . but then on the support of the integrand , for a fixed @xmath79 , @xmath320 is bounded away from zero , uniformly in @xmath3 . define @xmath321 as @xmath110 but assuming that the log - price follows the jump part of the process . then we can represent the inner integral in the form @xmath322 and therefore , @xmath323 now , define @xmath324 to be @xmath325 for all @xmath326 . then for small @xmath3 , the integral above does not change but now @xmath327 is a continuous bounded function on @xmath328 . by using the super - exponential decay of the gaussian density , we can restore the @xmath329 , and after that pass to the limit and obtain @xmath330 . this finishes the proof of ( [ genc ] ) . [ [ proof - of - cckblcpnts - and - cpjumpccjump - for - jump - processes - with - non - zero - drift ] ] proof of ( [ cckbl])([cpnts ] ) , and ( [ cpjump])([ccjump ] ) for jump processes with non - zero drift ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ let @xmath31 be a vgp . we have @xmath333.\ ] ] if @xmath118 , then the terms with @xmath247 cancel out , and @xmath334 hence , @xmath335 . if @xmath117 , then the terms with @xmath262 cancel out , and @xmath336 thus , @xmath337 . \2 . let @xmath31 be a kobol process . in the case @xmath118 , @xmath338\\ & = & ic\gamma(-\nu)[({{\lambda_+}}-z - i0)^\nu-({{\lambda_+}}-z+i0)^\nu]\\ & = & ic\gamma(-\nu)(z-{{\lambda_+}})^\nu i(e^{-i\pi\nu}-e^{i\pi\nu})\\ & = & 2c\gamma(-\nu)\sin(\pi\nu)(z-{{\lambda_+}})^\nu.\end{aligned}\ ] ] similarly , in the case @xmath117 , @xmath339 \3 . let @xmath31 be an nts lvy process . if @xmath340 , then @xmath341\\ & = & i{\delta}[({\alpha}^2-({\beta}-z+i0)^2)^{\nu/2}-({\alpha}^2-({\beta}-z - i0)^2)^{\nu/2}]\\ & = & i{\delta}({\alpha}-{\beta}+z)^{\nu/2}[({\alpha}+{\beta}-z+i0)^{\nu/2}-({\alpha}+{\beta}-z - i0)^{\nu/2}]\\ & = & i{\delta}({\alpha}-{\beta}+z)^{\nu/2}(z-{\alpha}-{\beta})^{\nu/2}(e^{i\pi\nu/2}-e^{-i\pi\nu/2})\\ & = & -2\sin\frac{\pi\nu}{2}((z-{\beta})^2-{\alpha}^2)^{\nu/2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath342 , then similarly , we obtain the same expression but without the minus sign . finally , if @xmath31 is an exponential jump - diffusion process , then the same proof as in lemma [ gen ] shows that for the call , it suffices to consider the pure jump process , and that in this case , ( [ callprice3 ] ) holds . since @xmath343 the integrand in ( [ callprice3 ] ) has the only pole @xmath344 in the plane @xmath345 . we push down the line of integration , and on crossing the pole , apply the residue theorem . the result is @xmath346 and by passing to the limit , we obtain ( [ ccjump ] ) . ( [ cpjump ] ) is proved similarly . cont , r. , potters , m. , and bouchaud , j .- p . : scaling in stock market data : stable laws and beyond " , in dubrulle , b. , f. graner , and d. sornette ( eds . ) . scale invariance and beyond ( proceedings of the cnrs workshop on scale invariance , les houches , march 1997 ) . berlin : springer 1997 \28 . lamberton , d. : critical price for an american option near maturity . in bolthausen , e. , m. dozzi , f. russo ( eds . ) seminar on stochastic analysis , random fields and applications . boston basel berlin : birkhaser 1995
Abstract: | [
"we derive explicit formulas for time decay , @xmath0 , for the european call and put options at expiry , and use them to calculate analytical approximations to the price of the american put and early exercise boundary near expiry . we show that for many families of non - gaussian processes used in empirical studies of financial markets , the early exercise boundary for the american put without dividends is separated from the strike price by a non - vanishing margin on the interval @xmath1 . as the riskless rate vanishes and the drift decreases accordingly so that the stock remains a martingale , the optimal exercise price goes to zero uniformly over the interval @xmath2 . the implications for parameters fitting are discussed ."
] | 9,709 | 9,709 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the phenomena of diffusion and transport over a potential energy landscape play a key role in a number of processes in physics , chemistry and biology @xcite . josephson tunneling junctions , superionic conductors , phase - locked - loop frequency control systems , charge density waves are a few examples of systems in which these processes in periodic potential are important @xcite . in recent years the interest has been growing to experimental studies of manipulating the particle diffusion by external fields . one can effectively control the diffusion processes by varying the field parameters . for instance , huge enhancement in diffusivity ( exceeding its value in the same system without extra forcing by a factor of order hundreds ) was observed in studying particle diffusion in colloids with optical traps ( optical vortices ) @xcite . large increase in diffusivity was also observed in studies of paramagnetic particle diffusion on surfaces of garnet ferrites influenced by external time - periodic magnetic field @xcite . in the same manner diffusivity growth with shaking strength was noticed in experiments with granular gas @xcite . it turned possible to increase the diffusivity of ions in membrane channels by varying the external electromagnetic field @xcite . one can increase the rates of diffusion - limited physical processes , and effectively separate micro- and nano - particles of different nature by varying diffusion coefficients in different directions @xcite . despite these remarkable achievements , quantitative description of such enhanced diffusion under the influence of external forces remains fragmentary to date . special cases of underdamped and overdamped physical systems are often considered . in overdamped systems inertial effects may be neglected , significantly simplifying the mathematical treatment of the problem . in underdamped systems on the other hand the viscous decay of oscillations occurs on times long compared with the oscillation period in the potential ; such systems are harder to investigate , and the progress in studying these is more limited compared with overdamped ones . first detailed studies of a brownian particle motion in a washboard potential ( _ i.e. _ a periodic potential tilted with an additional constant force field ) were carried out by h. risken and colleagues @xcite , for all values of the friction . it was shown that at low friction the appearance of locked ( in which the particle oscillates around one minimum of the potential ) and running ( where the particle travels through many potential periods , not getting trapped at separate minima ) solutions was important for the particle ensemble behavior . at small temperatures running solutions appear abruptly at the external force value exceeding certain critical @xmath3 ; at smaller forces a single class of solutions ( locked ) is realized . systematization of the results of these studies may be found in authoritative monograph @xcite . approximate solution of the fokker - planck equation ( fpe ) for the coordinate and velocity distribution function was the central moment of these studies . two different approaches were used , that were checked to produce compatible results . in the first of these @xcite by expanding the distribution function in hermite functions in velocity and fourier - series in space coordinate , the fokker - planck equation was transformed into an infinite set of coupled equations for the expansion coefficients . these equations were solved by a matrix continued fraction method . particle flux was then expressed through the expansion coefficients , after appropriate series truncation . at smaller friction progressively more terms must be kept , making this method less efficient . another approach @xcite is best suited for low friction , when the energy becomes a slow variable ( changing on friction dissipation timescales ) . the distribution function was rewritten in the energy and configuration space coordinate variables , fpe was solved in these new variables with the help of physically - motivated self - consistent ansatz . many illuminating results were obtained for the distribution functions at various parameter values , stability domains of locked and running solutions , plots of the mean particle velocity , etc . diffusion properties however remained not studied . this matter was partly addressed in other works , based on simulations of the stochastic langevin equation . early systematic study of diffusion by means of numerical simulation of the langevin equation in periodic potential with extra constant forcing was undertaken in @xcite ( similar simulations were reported in @xcite for forcing with a time - periodic component ) . costantini & marchesoni analyzed both overdamped and underdamped settings . at low dissipation they observed significant enhancement of the spatial diffusion near the critical force @xmath3 ( @xcite , fig . 1 : diffusivity ten times larger than its post - maximum value at @xmath4 , at the temperature equal to 0.6 of the potential well depth @xmath5 ) , and related that to features of the particle jump statistics and locked - to - running transition . further progress in studies of the diffusion under the action of constant force was made in @xcite . time - dependence of the particle ensemble dispersion was studied in @xcite . it was shown for the first time that in underdamped systems a special regime of dispersionless transport was realized , in which dispersion virtually does not change with time , on certain limited interval of time . the authors explained this phenomenon , they showed that strongly non - equilibrium distribution of particles in space ( with steep front and exponential tail ; formed as the particles first exit their original potential well ) persists for long times , before eventually broadening and assuming normal gaussian shape . the temperature dependence of the diffusivity was studied as well @xcite . the authors observed that the maximal diffusivity @xmath6 was achieved near the @xmath3 . at low friction @xmath6 was shown to depend abnormally on the temperature increase with decreasing temperature @xmath7 . fitting ( for the three temperatures studied ) yielded @xmath8 relation . the presence of such abnormal temperature dependence is one important aspect in which underdamped systems differ from overdamped ones . in fact , certain peculiarities in diffusivity at low temperatures are observed ( for driven brownian particles in space - periodic potentials ) in overdamped situation as well . p. reimann and colleagues @xcite showed analytically that for a sinusoidal in space potential at external constant force value near @xmath9 , the value required for direct particle pull over the potential barrier ( eq . [ eq : flat ] below , p. ) , the ratio of @xmath10 to the diffusivity value @xmath11 in the viscous medium without lattice and bias forces grows at temperature decreasing @xmath12 . yet the diffusivity itself still vanishes at @xmath13 , as @xmath14 @xcite , and grows monotonically for all @xmath7 . regions with @xmath15 were obtained in overdamped problem in @xcite ( cf . fig . 6 ) for specially crafted exotic potential , flat apart from narrow peaks . the authors linked this abnormal diffusivity behavior to the large ratio of relaxation to escape time in such a system . similar abnormal @xmath16 behavior was found in @xcite ( cf . 24 ) for piecewise linear potential at extreme asymmetry , essentially sawtooth . so , while possible at large friction , special atypical conditions must be met for existence of parameters @xmath17 at which @xmath15 . on the contrary , such parameters exist universally in the problem with small friction ( @xcite , more below ) . another distinction of the diffusivity in overdamped problem is that the maximum in @xmath18 is achieved close to the @xmath9 . whereas at low friction @xmath19 is achieved at ( typically much smaller ) @xmath20 . experimental data for diffusion of colloidal particles in a tilted potential created with laser traps @xcite , fig . 1 , agreed reasonably well with this analytic @xcite @xmath18 dependence . the potential barrier height and the free diffusion coefficient were treated as fit parameters . similarly , diffusivity in @xcite ( fig . 7 ) showed peaked at @xmath9 behavior , and agreed fairly well with analytic predictions from @xcite with the potential form inferred from independent study of the colloidal particle spatial distribution function . in this work colloidal particles diffused over the potential created by the bottom grid of colloidal spheres , and extra constant forcing was due to gravity ( controlled by the sample inclination angle ) . different limiting cases of analytic predictions @xcite for the mean particle velocity and diffusivity were compared with experimental results at different settings , and showed good agreement . the physical reason behind the abnormal temperature dependence of diffusivity in underdamped systems is traced to increasing jump length of running particles ( before getting retrapped at another potential minimum ) with the temperature decrease @xcite . this phenomenon being absent in overdamped systems ( as these have no proper running states ) . the maximal diffusivity is achieved at forcing near @xmath20 , as at this value populations of locked and running particles are about equal , and it is the mutual motion between these two populations ( with temperature - independent running particle speed ) that leads to fast spreading of the particle packet , manifested as giant diffusion @xcite . more thorough analysis of ( the temperature- and force - dependence of ) the diffusion in underdamped systems was carried out in @xcite . it was shown by numeric simulations of the langevin equation that the phenomenon of diffusivity growth with the temperature decreasing ( in the current work called tad , `` temperature - abnormal diffusivity '' ) was only manifested in a narrow interval of applied external forcing . study in a wide range of temperatures demonstrated that the diffusivity grew with decreasing temperature as @xmath21}$ ] for certain @xmath22 , checked valid for @xmath23 $ ] ; whereas the power - law fit @xmath8 proposed in @xcite could approximate the results only in the narrow temperature range studied by the authors . we showed that the main exponential growth resulted from such of the correlation time at the temperature decreasing ( found from the simulation results ) . the diffusion properties were further elucidated and systematized for a broad range of the forces @xmath24 , friction coefficients @xmath25 and temperatures @xmath7 in @xcite , in sinusoidal 1d potential in underdamped setting . we introduced a velocity potential @xmath26 , which in part governed time evolution of certain slow ( not changing much on times of order one period @xmath27 of small oscillations in the potential , rather evolving on viscous dissipation timescales ) velocity variable , defined through a discrete quantity , maximal velocity in such consecutive oscillations . with certain reservations that @xmath26 also defined the velocity distribution function @xmath28 agreeing well with the one found numerically . the latter showed clear bimodal structure with maxima at @xmath29 ( locked states ) and @xmath30 ( running ones ) at intermediate forcing values . in this region of forcing values tad was observed . analytic expressions for the mean particle velocity @xmath31 and diffusivity were obtained with the model @xmath28 , good agreement was shown with direct langevin equation simulation results . simple fits were proposed determining the model parameters [ entering @xmath26 and @xmath28 ] through @xmath24 and @xmath25 , which apart from usefulness for experimentalists / applications allowed one to comprehend the features of transport and diffusivity in all the physical parameter space . physical reason for the @xmath33}$ ] scaling was explained . more detail in the introductory part of sec . [ s : results ] , p. below . in practical applications periodic in time external forces ( electromagnetic , acoustic , etc . ) are more straightforwardly realized than constant forcing . it is natural to study how the findings for the constant forcing problem are modified for the time - periodic forcing setup , both from theoretical and practical point of view . by changing the diffusivity with the aid of periodic external fields it is possible to create surface structures with prescribed properties ; influence the dynamics of point defects , under irradiation in part ; alter the dislocation motion dynamics ; increase chemical reaction rates in selected directions ; manipulate the efficiency of processes in biological systems , to mention just a few applications @xcite . most of the works on periodic forcing deal with ratchet - type systems @xcite or stochastic resonance . studies focusing on diffusion properties are scarce . we are not aware of any works that systematically study the combined dependence of the diffusivity on the temperature , the forcing amplitude and frequency in a representatively broad range of these parameters . dependence of the diffusivity on the interplay between the external periodic ( piecewise constant , eq . [ f : pcp ] on p. below ) forcing and the lattice force was studied in @xcite in 2d overdamped setup . the forcing frequency was fixed at one value . it was shown that in a system with a sum of yukawa potentials at square grid nodes the particle diffusivity was significantly enhanced for certain intricate set of bands ( `` a - windows '' ) of the forcing amplitudes and orientations with respect to the grid . at special forcing arrangement tad was observed for some diffusivity tensor components , and one of its principal values increased exponentially with inverse temperature . the other diffusivity tensor principal value decreased exponentially at the same time . it is likely that multi - dimensionality effects were crucial for tad . instead of having two , locked and running , populations in 1d accounting for ( already sophisticated in this case ) diffusion features , flows in higher dimensional problems are far more complex , known to result in further peculiarities in transport and diffusion @xcite . underdamped 1d system was studied in @xcite , with a sinusoidal potential ( same as eq . [ ux ] below ) and sinusoidal in time forcing . diffusivity enhancement by orders of magnitude was seen . tad was observed for some ( low ) forcing frequencies , at the forcing amplitude @xmath34 studied . dependence of the diffusivity on the forcing frequency was studied in more detail in @xcite , and was shown to be nonmonotonic at large forcing amplitudes ( @xmath34 and @xmath35 , at @xmath36 k , @xmath37 . ) at @xmath34 the maximum in the frequency dependence of the diffusivity @xmath38 persisted for all the temperatures studied , corresponding frequency @xmath39 increasing from @xmath40 to @xmath41 ( in units of the potential eigenfrequency ) at @xmath7 varying from 120 to 360 k , @xmath42 $ ] . the goal of the present work is to investigate in detail the dependence of the diffusivity on the amplitude and the frequency of uniform time - periodic external forcing in a 1d underdamped space - periodic system , and conditions under which tad is realized . we mainly study piecewise constant periodic ( pcp : eq . [ f : pcp ] ) forcing as this case is more straightforward to relate to the results for constant forcing . the equations solved and the methods used are described in sec . [ s : setup ] . [ s : results ] we show how the diffusivity changes with the pcp forcing frequency @xmath0 , starting from the understood results at constant forcing , @xmath43 . we observe that tad is realized for some ( intermediate ) forcing amplitudes . [ s : dvst ] is devoted to studying the @xmath16 behavior at fixed @xmath0 . the results for the diffusivity in the case of sinusoidal in time forcing are shown in sec . [ s : fsin ] . we conclude in sec . [ s : concl ] . in this paper the 1d dynamics of a particle subject to external forcing @xmath44 is described by the langevin equation : @xmath45 where @xmath46 is the time , @xmath47 is the particle coordinate , @xmath48 is its mass , @xmath25 is the friction coefficient . overdot stands for time differentiation . @xmath49 represents thermal fluctuations , described by gaussian white noise with correlation @xmath50 here @xmath51 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath7 is the temperature . the potential energy @xmath52 is taken @xmath53 where @xmath54 is the lattice constant and @xmath5 is the potential barrier height . the lattice force @xmath55 acting upon the particle is @xmath56 quantity @xmath57 corresponds to the minimal external force needed to drag the particle over the potential barrier separating potential minima on the 1d lattice at large friction . we use the same physical parameters as in @xcite , typical for adatom diffusion on close - packed metal surfaces . namely , values @xmath58 for the activation barrier and the lattice constant are adopted . two possibilities for the external periodic forcing are studied : piecewise constant periodic ( * pcp * ) driving @xmath59\ ] ] and sinusoidal one , @xmath60 @xmath0 is the angular frequency of the external force and @xmath61 is its amplitude . it is convenient to use dimensionless time @xmath62 and space coordinate @xmath63 , normalizing the physical values to the period of small oscillations @xmath64 at the potential minimum in the absence of friction , and to the lattice spatial period @xmath54 respectively : @xmath65 dimensionless temperature @xmath66 and friction coefficient @xmath67 are further introduced : @xmath68 definitions ( [ dimtx],[dimtgamma ] ) differ from such in @xcite by extra factors of 2 appearing in the definition of @xmath62 , and consequently in @xmath66 and @xmath67 as well . current definition makes interpreting the results easier ( @xmath69 corresponds to one oscillation period at small @xmath67 ) . for more straightforward comparison with our previous works we also use another dimensionless temperature in the figures , @xmath70 the parameters of the dimensionless problem are @xmath71 , @xmath72 , @xmath67 , @xmath66 . in the new variables the equation of motion has form eq . 1 with unit new mass , potential @xmath73 with no prefactors and the external forcing amplitude made dimensionless with a @xmath74 multiplier . below lowercase @xmath75 s ( frequencies ) , and corresponding periods @xmath76 denote dimensionless quantities . physical frequencies and periods are obtained by respectively dividing and multiplying these by the the period @xmath77 of small oscillations in the lattice potential at @xmath78 . overdamped problem is characterized by @xmath79 , whereas @xmath80 ( equivalently , @xmath81 ) corresponds to underdamped dynamics . we study the underdamped case here . friction coefficient @xmath82 we use corresponds to the same physical value as in earlier studies @xcite . we solve stochastic equation ( [ langevin],[xi_cor ] ) numerically using a verlet - type algorithm @xcite with a time step @xmath83 somewhat shorter than @xmath84 of the period of oscillation @xmath77 . the statistic averaging is performed over the ensemble consisting of at least @xmath85 particles . to verify the modeling consistency some computations were performed with @xmath86 . the initial conditions are set as follows . each particle is placed at @xmath87 , its velocity chosen at random , with maxwellian distribution for a given @xmath7 . thermalization over 100 oscillation periods , in the potential @xmath52 but without the @xmath88 , is then used to get equilibrium particle distribution over both coordinate and velocity . tests show that the distribution function does not change after that time . in the process of such thermalization the particles can jump to nearby elementary cells of the lattice . such relocated particles are returned back to the initial cell by translation over an integer multiple of the lattice constant , to get diffusion of all particles starting from the initial cell of the lattice . the diffusivity is computed based on the dispersion @xmath89 of the particle distribution in the limit of large times : @xmath90 angle brackets @xmath91 with no subscripts mean averaging over the ensemble . @xmath92 and @xmath93 are dimensionless in our notation . the physical diffusivity is @xmath94 . for each diffusivity calculation we find time @xmath95 , after which the dispersion grows linearly with time ( if averaged over the forcing period ) . the @xmath92 is calculated as @xmath96 at @xmath97 . it is known that in systems with low dissipation transient regimes of anomalous diffusion can be realized @xcite , characterized by @xmath98 the process with @xmath99 is referred to as superdiffusion , whereas subdiffusion is characterized by @xmath100 . stages of anomalous diffusion were observed in our simulations . the choice of initial conditions above aided in having these stages in clear form . we determine the exponents @xmath101 by the least - square linear fitting between @xmath102 and @xmath103 on the time - interval of interest . in @xcite it was shown that depending on the value of the external force ( constant in that study ) different functional dependences of the diffusivity on the temperature were realized . plots of the diffusivity as a function of the external force at several temperatures ( based on @xcite , recomputed for the current units ) are shown in fig . [ f : difconstf ] . there are three regions of @xmath61 values ( i iii ) , with qualitatively different dependence of the diffusivity @xmath104 on @xmath7 . in region i diffusion is enhanced as external force @xmath61 value increases , whereas in region iii diffusion is inhibited as @xmath61 increases . in regions i and iii @xmath104 grows with @xmath7 increasing . contrary to this ( normal temperature behavior ) in region ii @xmath104 grows as @xmath7 decreases . this is the region of `` temperature - abnormal diffusivity '' ( tad ) . the _ diffusion process _ at sufficiently late times is normal , @xmath105 , however the _ diffusion coefficient _ @xmath106 ( abnormally ) increases as the temperature decreases . . 1 : @xmath107 [ @xmath108k for the potential characteristic of the h - adatom diffusion on metal surface ( [ u0a ] ) ] , 2 : @xmath109 , 3 : @xmath110 , 4 : @xmath111 , 5 : @xmath112 , 6 : @xmath113 , 7 : @xmath114 . + bottom : the effective velocity potential in the three force regions . left , middle and right diagrams correspond to @xmath115 , 0.095 and 0.25 respectively.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=47.0% ] + . 1 : @xmath107 [ @xmath108k for the potential characteristic of the h - adatom diffusion on metal surface ( [ u0a ] ) ] , 2 : @xmath109 , 3 : @xmath110 , 4 : @xmath111 , 5 : @xmath112 , 6 : @xmath113 , 7 : @xmath114 . + bottom : the effective velocity potential in the three force regions . left , middle and right diagrams correspond to @xmath115 , 0.095 and 0.25 respectively.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=12.3% ] @xmath116 . 1 : @xmath107 [ @xmath108k for the potential characteristic of the h - adatom diffusion on metal surface ( [ u0a ] ) ] , 2 : @xmath109 , 3 : @xmath110 , 4 : @xmath111 , 5 : @xmath112 , 6 : @xmath113 , 7 : @xmath114 . + bottom : the effective velocity potential in the three force regions . left , middle and right diagrams correspond to @xmath115 , 0.095 and 0.25 respectively.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=10.0% ] @xmath116 . 1 : @xmath107 [ @xmath108k for the potential characteristic of the h - adatom diffusion on metal surface ( [ u0a ] ) ] , 2 : @xmath109 , 3 : @xmath110 , 4 : @xmath111 , 5 : @xmath112 , 6 : @xmath113 , 7 : @xmath114 . + bottom : the effective velocity potential in the three force regions . left , middle and right diagrams correspond to @xmath115 , 0.095 and 0.25 respectively.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=10.0% ] @xmath117 in @xcite it was seen that tad is also possible at time - periodic external forcing . at such forcing tad was only observed in a limited interval of the forcing frequencies . studies were carried out at @xmath118 , that would correspond to region iii for the same amplitude of constant forcing ( see fig . [ f : difconstf ] ) , so tad would not be observed at such @xmath61 value were the forcing @xmath88 constant . to understand physical reasons of the abnormal temperature dependence of the diffusivity in these two different ( time - periodic , and constant ) forcing regimes we consider the periodic forcing regime in more detail below . for piecewise constant periodic ( pcp ) forcing one can use intuition gained in the constant forcing problem for the time intervals in which @xmath44 stays constant , the findings are thus easier to interpret . most of the results in this work are for the pcp forcing setup . in @xcite we showed that the transport properties of an ensemble of underdamped particles in a washboard potential can be found by considering a simpler problem of the overdamped motion in effective potential @xmath26 in velocity space . the problem showed similarities with the problem of active brownian particle motion @xcite . whether the particle belongs to locked [ tending with time to @xmath29 , one minimum of @xmath26 ] or running [ tending to @xmath30 , another minimum of the asymmetric double - well potential @xmath26 ] population in the absence of noise is determined by the particle s initial state ( its velocity , if placed at the potential minimum at @xmath120 ) . it was shown that region ii of the force values , the region in which tad is observed , is precisely the region where both locked and running solutions are simultaneously possible . the @xmath26 was also instrumental for proposing a model distribution function @xmath28 , and for defining diffusivity through kubo relation . the analytic predictions for @xmath104 and @xmath31 based on the model @xmath28 agreed well with direct numerical simulation results for all values of @xmath121 , temperatures in the range @xmath122 $ ] , friction @xmath123 $ ] ( in the definitions of dimensionless quantities adopted here , eqs . ( [ dimtx],[dimtgamma ] ) ; agreement getting progressively better at smaller @xmath67 ) . in the expression for the diffusivity , ( the analytic prediction for ) the correlation time @xmath124 factor was shown to be responsible for the main features in @xmath125 dependence , numerically found in earlier study @xcite . namely , @xmath124 showed proper nonmonotonic dependence on @xmath24 , with a maximum near @xmath20 , progressively more pronounced at smaller @xmath7 . @xmath124 increased at temperature decreasing @xmath126 $ ] ( for certain @xmath22 ) ; this increase at low @xmath7 reflected the kramers rate for transitions in the double - well velocity potential @xmath26 , between the wells corresponding to locked and running states . schematics of the effective velocity potential in the three regions of the applied force are shown in the bottom insets in fig . [ f : difconstf ] . the first inset corresponds to @xmath127 , at which only locked solutions exist . in the second inset @xmath128 , corresponding to the maximal diffusivity ; both types of solutions coexist at this force value . finally @xmath129 corresponding to region iii is shown in the third inset ; at this @xmath61 only running solutions are realized . the boundaries between regions i iii depend on @xmath25 and @xmath48 ( on @xmath67 in the dimensionless problem ) . at smaller @xmath67 these boundaries move to the left , to the lower force values , and the width of region ii decreases . in the current study we use the same fixed values of @xmath25 and @xmath48 as in @xcite , and investigate the features of @xmath130 at the three values of the external forcing amplitude listed above . it may be expected that the same picture for different temperature behaviors of the diffusivity , with analogous three regions i iii of the external force amplitudes , holds for pcp driving , at least at small frequencies @xmath0 . the description with the effective potential is applicable , the potential @xmath26 keeping constant form for each of the two half - periods of the external forcing [ on which @xmath44 stays constant , this @xmath24 value defining corresponding @xmath131 . ] below we show that in fact the situation is more subtle . similar three regions of the external force amplitudes @xmath61 exist , differing in qualitative @xmath16 dependence . tad is realized in certain range of intermediate @xmath61 , smoothly dependent on @xmath0 . at decreasing temperatures the dependence @xmath16 starts progressively deviating from such at constant forcing . for any fixed @xmath0 at temperatures below certain critical @xmath132 , normal temperature dependence of the diffusivity is restored . we demonstrate these features by analyzing @xmath130 in sequence for the above values of @xmath61 ( @xmath115 , 0.095 , 0.25 ) , that correspond to regions i , ii , iii in the constant external force problem . we observe transient anomalous diffusion phase , and see how its characteristics relate to the diffusivity in the asymptotic late time regime , when normal diffusion regime sets in . the properties of this anomalous diffusion stage are different in the three regions of the applied force amplitudes ; this translates into different functional dependence of the diffusivity on the temperature . here we investigate how the diffusivity changes with ( dimensionless ) frequency @xmath72 of the external forcing at forcing amplitude @xmath127 . we show that the diffusivity stays nearly constant at small frequencies , up to reciprocal of the superdiffusion stage duration . at frequencies above this the diffusivity drops according to a power - law with exponent related to the exponent of the superdiffusion . this power - law dependence holds up to frequencies a few times less than the lattice potential eigenfrequency . the diffusivity grows with the temperature ( normal temperature behavior ) , related to the superdiffusion stage duration increasing with @xmath7 . figure [ f : sigma006 ] shows the growth of the particle dispersion with time . at constant external forcing this growth demonstrates a clear superdiffusion stage , @xmath133 , @xmath134 , that switches to normal diffusion ( same power - law growth but with @xmath135 ) after certain time @xmath136 . the @xmath136 as well as the superdiffusion exponent @xmath101 depend on @xmath71 and other problem parameters , @xmath67 and @xmath66 . for the values used @xmath137 , @xmath138 . lowercase @xmath139 s everywhere are dimensionless , normalized to the period of small oscillations at the lattice potential minimum at @xmath140 , @xmath141 @xmath89 and @xmath92 are dimensionless dispersion and diffusivity . ( region i ) for different force frequencies . @xmath136 denotes the end of the superdiffusion stage at constant forcing . @xmath76 is the period of the external periodic forcing . 1 : @xmath143 , 2 : @xmath144 , 3 : @xmath145 , 4 : @xmath146 ( constant external force . ) straight dashed and dotted lines show the power - law fitting behavior of the dispersion.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] curves 13 correspond to three different frequencies . oscillations in @xmath147 are clearly seen with double forcing frequency , @xmath148 . these are particularly large at @xmath75 around @xmath149 ( curve 2 ) . at these values , interestingly , intervals of @xmath150 decreasing with time are observed . this effect can be seen in earlier works @xcite . at frequencies below @xmath149 the curves @xmath150 closely follow that at @xmath146 ( constant external force , curve 4 ) . at higher frequencies the superdiffusion phase effectively ends after one period @xmath139 of the external force , normal diffusion sets in ( in a sense that averaged over the forcing period @xmath151 ) . higher frequencies of the forcing correspondingly result in lower diffusivity , as the stage of @xmath89 growing with time faster than linearly ends earlier than at lower @xmath75 s . these results suggest the following approximations for the smoothed over the forcing period dispersion @xmath152 , valid not too close to the transition moments between different diffusion regimes : @xmath153 here @xmath154 ( for the approximately boltzmannian initial distribution of the particles in @xmath155 well of the potential ) , @xmath156 , @xmath157 is close to the first potential well exit time . constants are chosen in such a way that the spline approximation ( [ sigma2fiti ] ) is continuous . quantities @xmath101 , @xmath158 depend on the problem parameters , @xmath66 , @xmath71 and @xmath67 . at fixed values of these parameters , the last approximation yields the dependence of the diffusivity @xmath159 on the forcing period @xmath139 @xmath160 or on its frequency @xmath161 @xmath162 the diffusivity thus should stay about constant at @xmath163 , and at larger forcing frequencies drop with @xmath75 according to the power law , with exponent equal to @xmath164 , determined by the superdiffusion exponent . figure [ f : domega006 ] shows simulation results for @xmath165 . dotted lines show approximations eq . [ domegafiti ] . dashed lines show the diffusivity at constant forcing with the same @xmath61 value . these results confirm the features suggested by eq . [ domegafiti ] , away from transition frequency @xmath149 and up to @xmath166 . @xmath167 at any @xmath75 , and decreases with @xmath75 , up to the frequency values a few times smaller than the potential eigenfrequency . on the forcing frequency at @xmath168 ( triangles ) and @xmath169 ( circles ) . the dashed line asymptotes show the diffusivity values at constant forcing with the same @xmath115 . the slanting dotted line shows the power law drop of @xmath92 at intermediate @xmath75 s . , scaledwidth=47.0% ] further ramification might have been added in eqs . ( [ sigma2fiti][domegafiti ] ) for the case @xmath170 , changing @xmath157 to @xmath171 ; that would indeed lead to @xmath172 increasing at @xmath173 . with our parameters , however , resulting approximations are an overstretch ; the diffusion gets markedly nonequilibrium at such high @xmath75 s , resulting in the complex @xmath172 behavior at @xmath75 approaching @xmath174 . more on this in sec . [ s : highomega ] . finally , fig . [ f : sigmat006 ] shows @xmath150 for a range of temperatures at constant forcing . despite the superdiffusion exponent @xmath101 is seen to decrease with the temperature , the duration of the superdiffusion stage @xmath175 grows fast with the temperature . as a result the dispersion is larger for larger temperatures at any given time . at late times this translates into diffusivity being larger at larger temperatures ; so normal ( increasing ) @xmath16 dependence is realized at force amplitudes in region i. ) . 1 : @xmath176 , 2 : @xmath168 , 3 : @xmath142 , 4 : @xmath177 . the short - dashed straight lines show power - law fits for the transient superdiffusion stage , and the late - time normal diffusion regime.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] here we repeat analysis of the previous section for periodic forcing with amplitude @xmath128 ( the value at which the maximal diffusivity is achieved at constant forcing ) . in the same manner as for the forcing amplitude in region i , transition from initial superdiffusion stage to normal diffusion at late times is observed , at time @xmath136 . at forcing frequency @xmath75 growing , the diffusivity again decreases only slightly from @xmath179 till @xmath75 reaches @xmath180 . it decreases fast , according to the same power law @xmath181 , at larger @xmath75 s , up to @xmath182 . contrary to the case of weaker forcing considered in the previous section , superdiffusion duration @xmath175 now _ decreases _ with the temperature . this leads to diffusivity growing at temperature decrease ( tad ) , at moderately low frequencies . this is the main effect we intended to find in the periodic driving setup , extending our previous findings at constant forcing @xcite . figure [ f : sigma0095 ] shows growth of the particle dispersion with time . again the superdiffusion stage is observed , and it ends after one period of pcp forcing or after @xmath136 ( the end time of superdiffusion at constant forcing ) , whichever is smaller . thus the same approximations eq . ( [ sigma2fiti][domegafiti ] ) are applicable for the ( averaged over @xmath139 ) dispersion growth @xmath152 and dependence of the diffusivity on the forcing frequency @xmath165 . simulation results for @xmath165 ( fig . [ f : domega0095 ] ) again agree with prediction ( eq . [ domegafiti ] ) . ( region ii ) for different force frequencies . curves 15 , bottom to top : ( dimensionless ) @xmath183 @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 , 0 ( constant forcing ) . , scaledwidth=47.0% ] on the external force frequency @xmath75 , at @xmath168 ( triangles ) and @xmath169 ( circles ) . the dashed line asymptotes show the diffusivity values for constant forcing with the same @xmath178 . dotted line shows the power law drop of @xmath92 at higher @xmath75 s . the dot - dashed horizontal line asymptote ( for high @xmath75 ) is at the diffusivity value in the lattice periodic potential in the absence of extra driving , @xmath188 , for @xmath142.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] as @xmath172 does not vary much at @xmath163 , tad must be observed at small frequencies , at it is observed at constant forcing ( @xcite : @xmath189 decreases with the temperature when @xmath61 is in region ii ) . such an abnormal dependence on the temperature is due to longer jumps the particles perform on average at lower temperatures . this in turn follows from lower probability at lower temperatures to turn the running particle into a locked state : such a transition requires certain threshold energy transfer to such a particle , and at lower temperatures the probability of such a transfer decreases exponentially with inverse temperature . hence the running particle travels at about the stationary speed @xmath190 ( the speed fluctuating around this average due to the lattice potential ) for increasingly longer distances before getting trapped again in some next well of the potential , resulting in larger diffusivity at smaller temperatures . this mechanism is not applicable in region i , where only locked solutions are realized . in terms of the dispersion evolution features , this phenomenon of the diffusivity growing at the temperature decreasing results from the superdiffusion duration @xmath191 growing at temperature decreasing , as fig . [ f : sigmat0095 ] demonstrates . this qualitatively differs from the situation at forcing amplitude in region i ( end of the previous section ) . we note that @xmath101 increases with the temperature decreasing , same as in region i. ) . 1 : @xmath176 , 2 : @xmath168 , 3 : @xmath142 , 4 : @xmath177 . @xmath178.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] at higher frequencies , on the other hand , the diffusivity starts increasing with the temperature ( normal behavior ) . this results from @xmath136 decreasing with the temperature , as can be seen in fig . [ f : sigmat0095 ] . despite @xmath179 is larger at smaller temperature @xmath192 , as @xmath75 grows the @xmath193 starts decreasing according to the power law earlier [ at @xmath75 s near the smaller @xmath194 than @xmath195 for @xmath196 does . and the exponent of this power - law decreases with @xmath7 decreasing , @xmath197 therefore at larger frequencies , commensurate with @xmath198 , the diffusivity starts increasing with the temperature , _ tad disappears_. as it is the case for the forcing amplitude in region i , @xmath172 decreases monotonically with @xmath75 from @xmath199 , up to the frequency values @xmath200 ( at frequencies so high the particle transport becomes substantially non - equilibrium , that affecting the functional dependence @xmath172 , as discussed in sec . [ s : highomega ] below ) . for strong forcing ( region iii , in which the diffusivity decreases with @xmath61 in constant forcing setup , and increases with the temperature ) we demonstrate in this subsection that the dependence of dispersion on time shows new features . after initial superdiffusion stage at times @xmath202 , prolonged dispersionless stage sets in , till @xmath203 . in this stage the dispersion stays nearly constant . as at weaker external forcing ( regions i , ii ) , both these stages may be interrupted earlier in the case of high forcing frequency ( after about a period of the forcing ) . at late times normal diffusion takes place . dependence @xmath172 is nonmonotonic here , agreeing with findings in @xcite . @xmath104 reaches a maximum near @xmath204 . tad is observed at intermediate frequencies . figure [ f : sigma025 ] shows the particle dispersion as a function of time . at low frequencies of the forcing , superdiffusion is observed till @xmath205 . dispersionless stage is realized later , at @xmath206 . physically @xmath136 is the time at which the particle distribution function in velocities assumes its stationary form . the distribution in space is still strongly non - equilibrium at @xmath136 , it has exponential tail and sharp front @xcite ( in the direction of @xmath24 ) . it takes till @xmath207 for the distribution function to assume approximately gaussian shape in space ( if averaged over the potential spatial period ) . on interval @xmath208 dispersion does not increase siubstantially . after @xmath207 normal diffusion sets in , @xmath209 at @xmath210 . ( region iii ) for different force frequencies . curves 15 : ( dimensionless ) @xmath183 @xmath211 , @xmath184 , @xmath185 , @xmath186 , @xmath187 . dotted lines show power - law fitting behavior of the dispersion.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] the whole curve @xmath147 differs insignificantly from @xmath147 in constant forcing setup if the forcing frequency @xmath212 . this @xmath147 dependence is modified at higher frequencies of the external forcing ( in a similar way to the behavior discussed in sec . [ s : regioni][s : regionii ] at weaker forcing ) . for @xmath213 the dispersionless stage is interrupted after about one period of external force , after which time approximately linear dependence ( if averaged over times @xmath214 ) sets in , @xmath215 , @xmath92 equal to its asymptotic ( at @xmath216 ) value . at yet higher forcing frequencies , @xmath217 , dispersionless stage is not realized at all , normal diffusion sets in right after the prematurely interrupted superdiffusion stage . similarly to the previous sections , described above dependence of @xmath218 on @xmath219 can be schematized by the following continuous piecewise linear approximation ( meaningful not too close to switching time - points @xmath220 ) : @xmath221 here @xmath222 , @xmath156 ; @xmath223 assumed . as before , @xmath172 can be found from this , showing the same power law decay as in eq . [ domegafiti ] at @xmath224 , and additional , linearly growing with @xmath75 feature at intermediate frequencies : @xmath225 simulation results for @xmath172 are shown in fig . [ f : domega025 ] for two temperatures . they indeed show the features suggested in eq . [ domegafitiii ] . at high frequencies , @xmath224 , the superdiffusion stage switches to normal diffusion earlier than at @xmath136 , at time @xmath226 . this behavior is the same as for the forcing amplitude in regions i ii . thus in the same manner the diffusivity grows as @xmath75 decreases , as the longer interval ( till @xmath227 ) of superdiffusive dispersion growth is used at the forcing period @xmath139 getting longer . however at smaller frequencies , @xmath228 , it is the dispersionless phase that gets interrupted prematurely ( _ i.e. _ it is not realized in full , till @xmath207 , as it would have at @xmath146 ) , so the earlier such a switch occurs ( _ i.e. _ the shorter the @xmath139 ) , the higher diffusivity is obtained in the late - time normal diffusion stage . this explains the growth of @xmath172 with @xmath75 at @xmath229 . the maximum in @xmath172 is thus observed , at @xmath230 . on the forcing frequency , at @xmath168 ( circles ) and 0.194 ( triangles ) . the dashed lines show approximately linear growth at @xmath231.,scaledwidth=47.0% ] this differs from monotonically decreasing @xmath172 in regions i , ii . such a nonmonotonic dependence @xmath172 was observed in @xcite ; the forcing studied was sinusoidal in time , its amplitude ( indeed ) corresponded to region iii in terminology of this work . @xmath232 together with @xmath233 increase with the temperature . the maximal value of the diffusivity ( achieved at @xmath232 ) increases as the temperature decreases , due to the dispersionless stage duration @xmath234 growing fast at temperature decreasing . and so does @xmath172 at a given @xmath75 near @xmath198 in a limited range of temperatures . so abnormal temperature dependence of the diffusivity ( tad ) is realized in intermediate region of the forcing frequencies around @xmath198 . the temperature dependence of the diffusivity is studied in more detail in sec . [ s : dvst ] below . as the simulation results suggest , the power law decay of @xmath172 at large @xmath75 s ( figs . [ f : domega006 ] , [ f : domega0095 ] , [ f : domega025 ] ) does not hold at frequencies that are too high , above @xmath235 of the eigenfrequency at the lattice potential minima . this is due to the diffusion process becoming markedly non - equilibrium . the distribution function in velocities differs significantly from such at constant forcing at all times ; description in terms of the velocity potential @xmath26 is no longer useful . to analyze this we introduce kinetic temperature @xmath236 ( _ i.e. _ , made dimensionless with the same multiplier @xmath237 as @xmath238 ) , and study its evolution at different @xmath75 s : fig . [ f : tkin ] , bottom . at low frequency , @xmath239 does not change ( only shows random noise ) after one period @xmath76 of the forcing . at larger @xmath240 regular oscillations in @xmath239 are observed at all times , with amplitude of order 5% of the average @xmath239 value . that average is about 10% higher than the average @xmath239 at @xmath145 . @xmath239 averaged over the forcing oscillation period grows for about @xmath241 until it reaches its stationary value . @xmath242 and @xmath185 . @xmath115 . note that time normalized to one _ forcing _ period @xmath139 ( rather than to @xmath77 as in the previous @xmath46-dependence graphs ) is shown along the abscissa axis.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.1354% ] @xmath242 and @xmath185 . note that time normalized to one _ forcing _ period @xmath139 ( rather than to @xmath77 as in the previous @xmath46-dependence graphs ) is shown along the abscissa axis.,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.0% ] together with @xmath239 , @xmath147 also shows transient behavior at @xmath243 . we illustrate this in the top graphs in fig . [ f : tkin ] , by plotting @xmath244 in settled `` normal diffusion '' regime this quantity must coincide ( in average over the forcing period of duration @xmath139 ) with the diffusivity , as in such a regime theoretically @xmath245 for @xmath246 . these results in part mean that the rule of superdiffusion or dispersionless stage ( however these are modified in the high - frequency regime ) terminating and turning into normal diffusion after one period of forcing no longer applies at high forcing frequencies . this leads to the @xmath172 derivation based on approximations eqs . ( [ sigma2fiti],[sigma2fitiii ] ) progressively less accurate at higher @xmath75 s , the power - law decay first slowing down , and then going into a completely different regime at @xmath75 approaching @xmath174 . at @xmath247 the diffusivity tends to the diffusivity of particles in the lattice periodic potential in the absence of extra driving @xmath88 . such an asymptote is shown by the horizontal dot - dashed line in fig . [ f : domega0095 ] . having studied how the temperature behavior of diffusion changes at gradual forcing frequency increase , here we investigate in more detail how the diffusivity changes with the temperature at fixed frequency . besides theoretical importance , the results are of interest to experimentalists . oftentimes changing the frequency in the system is problematic , while changing the temperatures is simpler ; so the findings in this section are more straightforward to test . @xmath248 at + ( left ) : @xmath145 , force amplitudes @xmath249 0 ( squares , and linear fit ) , 0.06 ( circles ) , 0.095 ( diamonds ) , 0.25 ( triangles ) ; + ( right ) : @xmath178 , top to bottom : @xmath183 0 ( squares ) , @xmath186 ( triangles ) , @xmath185 ( diamonds ) , @xmath250 ( circles ) , @xmath184 ( pluses).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=23.8% ] at + ( left ) : @xmath145 , force amplitudes @xmath249 0 ( squares , and linear fit ) , 0.06 ( circles ) , 0.095 ( diamonds ) , 0.25 ( triangles ) ; + ( right ) : @xmath178 , top to bottom : @xmath183 0 ( squares ) , @xmath186 ( triangles ) , @xmath185 ( diamonds ) , @xmath250 ( circles ) , @xmath184 ( pluses).,title="fig:",scaledwidth=24.0% ] @xmath251 @xmath252 @xmath117 @xmath117 @xmath253 left part of fig . [ f : dtomega0001f ] shows how the diffusivity changes with @xmath238 at fixed @xmath254 . for the forcing amplitude in region i the diffusivity monotonically grows with the temperature , this ( normal ) behavior agreeing with such at constant forcing @xcite . for @xmath61 in regions ii and iii tad is observed , as already noted in sec . [ s : regionii][s : regioniii ] . tad is confined to limited ( from below ) temperature intervals , contrary to the tad behavior observed in @xcite for constant forcing . in @xcite the diffusivity was numerically checked growing ( only in region ii at @xmath146 ) at temperature decreasing down to @xmath176 . such a behavior was understood theoretically , dependence @xmath255 $ ] was predicted at low temperatures going all the way down to 0 , and agreed well with simulation results . in the current setup with periodic forcing , similar temperature dependence is observed too , @xmath256 but only above certain temperature . the growth slows down as the temperature keeps decreasing , @xmath104 reaches maximum @xmath257 at certain @xmath258 , and starts decreasing with further decrease in @xmath7 . the behavior at lower temperatures is well approximated by @xmath259 in the absence of forcing we observe @xmath260 ( corresponding dimensionful quantity @xmath261 ) classical arrhenius temperature behavior of the diffusivity . @xmath262 decreases with @xmath61 , whereas @xmath263 increases . @xmath258 and @xmath10 increase with @xmath61 as well . temperature behavior of the diffusivity is related to such of the superdiffusion stage duration @xmath264 and @xmath157 . these times may be inferred from simulations of the particle dispersion evolution with time , fig . [ f : sigma3f ] . for the forcing amplitude in region i , @xmath157 ( the time at which superdiffusion starts , about the potential well escape time ) increases with the temperature decreasing . @xmath175 at the same time decreases . this is seen to result in the diffusivity growing with the temperature , agreeing with the results shown in the @xmath145 part of fig . [ f : dtomega0001f ] . in region ii @xmath157 increases with the temperature decreasing as well . @xmath264 however also increases with the temperature decreasing ( middle graph in fig . [ f : sigma3f ] , curves 35 ) contrary to the behavior for @xmath61 in region i. tad is realized at these temperatures . at temperature @xmath265 ( @xmath266 in this graph ) @xmath136 becomes equal to @xmath76 , the period of forcing . at this temperature the maximal diffusivity is achieved , corresponding to the longest actual superdiffusion stage at the given forcing frequency . tad is only realized at temperatures above @xmath267 : even though @xmath264 ( superdiffusion duration at constant forcing ) still grows at further temperature decrease together with @xmath136 , in periodic forcing setup superdiffusion effectively ends earlier , at @xmath227 . it is this superdiffusion interruption at @xmath227 that makes @xmath16 behavior at lower temperatures to diverge in the periodic forcing setup from that at constant forcing . in the constant forcing problem , based on the same logic , tad must be realized all the way down to @xmath268 ; in agreement with conclusions in @xcite . it is clear from this argument that there is no uniform convergence with @xmath75 of @xmath269 curves to @xmath270 . at @xmath75 getting smaller @xmath269 gets close to such a @xmath16 curve for constant forcing on longer @xmath7-interval , down to progressively lower temperatures . however at any @xmath75 there exists @xmath271 such that normal temperature dependence of the diffusivity is restored at @xmath272 . this non - uniform convergence is shown in the right plot in fig . [ f : dtomega0001f ] . the same behavior is observed in region iii . the maximal diffusivity is achieved at @xmath267 corresponding to the longest superdiffusion stage at the given @xmath75 . the lowest temperature at which tad is realized is the one at which @xmath136 reaches the period of external force @xmath139 ( more precisely , the time of superdiffusion interruption at a given @xmath75 ) . at this temperature @xmath273 crosses zero value . the interval of temperatures , in which tad is observed , is wider than at forcing in region ii , due to the presence of dispersionless phase ( curve 4 in the right plot in fig . [ f : sigma3f ] ) . experimentally it is simpler to observe tad at larger @xmath61 , at which within the period of @xmath88 the superdiffusion stage is used to larger extent ; and the temperature interval of tad is thus wider . @xmath117 @xmath274 @xmath274 @xmath242 + @xmath242 @xmath275 @xmath275 @xmath242 presented study of the diffusion under external forcing can be summarized by the following schematics , fig . [ f : dtomega ] . force amplitudes fall into three regions , i iii . in region i the diffusivity grows with the temperature increasing . in regions ii iii the dependence @xmath16 is nonmonotonic , it shows a maximum at certain @xmath258 . below @xmath258 the temperature dependence of the diffusivity is normal , @xmath276 . temperature interval of tad exists above @xmath258 , @xmath15 . in the forcing frequency dependence of the diffusivity , on the other hand , it is regions i and ii that look alike : at the frequency decreasing from a fraction of the potential eigenfrequency the diffusivity grows monotonically , getting to a flat region at @xmath163 , in which it virtually reaches its limiting @xmath179 value . in region iii the @xmath172 curve passes through a maximum , near @xmath204 , corresponding to the end time of superdiffusion stage @xmath136 at constant forcing . at frequencies getting smaller , the forcing period contains progressively longer interval of `` would - be '' ( in the constant forcing problem ) dispersionless and ( at yet smaller frequencies ) normal - diffusion time - interval , resulting in @xmath104 decreasing at such further @xmath75 decrease . @xmath277 @xmath242 @xmath242 @xmath277 here we show the frequency dependence of the diffusivity for sinusoidal in time external forcing . we observe the same features in @xmath172 as we saw for pcp forcing . main conclusions of the sections above thus appear not to depend critically on specific form of time - dependence of the ( smooth enough , symmetric ) forcing . figure [ f : dfsin ] presents a comparison between diffusivities at sinusoidal in time and pcp forcing . at small frequencies the diffusivity stays close to its value at @xmath146 . in regions i and ii of the external forcing amplitude @xmath172 starts decaying according to a power law at @xmath278 , @xmath136 being the superdiffusion stage ending time at constant external forcing with the same amplitude @xmath61 . in region iii @xmath172 grows linearly with @xmath75 at intermediate @xmath75 s , reaches a maximum , then shows a power - law decay at larger frequencies . for all force amplitudes the power law decay switches to more complex behavior at @xmath75 reaching about @xmath279 of the potential eigenfrequency . presence of periodic forcing of any form of time - dependence leads to significant enhancement in diffusivity . this enhancement is somewhat smaller for sinusoidal forcing in regions i , ii ( can be understood , as at the same @xmath61 the average over period forcing @xmath280 is smaller for sinusoidal than for pcp forcing ) . in region iii the maximum in diffusivity is achieved at smaller @xmath232 , and the value of @xmath10 is larger than such a maximal diffusivity at corresponding @xmath281 under pcp driving with the same amplitude @xmath61 . this can be understood from the same argument , as in region iii the diffusivity _ decreases _ with the forcing increasing , all other parameters kept constant . we investigated enhancement of diffusion in 1d space - periodic underdamped systems by external time - periodic fields . we showed that the diffusion can be enhanced by orders of magnitude at certain choice of temperatures @xmath7 , forcing amplitudes @xmath61 and frequencies @xmath75 . three regions of @xmath61 exist , i iii , in which dependences of diffusivity @xmath104 on @xmath7 and @xmath75 differ qualitatively . at all @xmath61 there is an interval of small frequencies , in which @xmath104 depends only weakly on the frequency , approaching the limiting value @xmath179 . this value coincides with @xmath104 at constant bias force with the same value @xmath61 in the case of piecewise constant in time periodic ( pcp ) forcing , the form @xmath88 of forcing we focused on in this study . at larger frequencies , from @xmath149 corresponding to the superdiffusion stage ending time @xmath136 , to about @xmath282 ( dimensionful frequency @xmath283 of the potential eigenfrequency @xmath284 ) @xmath285 decays with @xmath0 according to a power - law . the exponent of this decay is related to the superdiffusion stage exponent @xmath101 . at yet larger frequencies non - equilibrium effects slow down the power - law decay of @xmath285 , and , after a local maximum in @xmath285 near @xmath286 , @xmath104 tends to its asymptotic value coinciding with the diffusivity in the absence of external forcing . at small forcing amplitudes , in regions i and ii , @xmath285 decreases monotonically with frequency @xmath0 from its value at constant forcing , all the way till the non - equilibrium effects become critical , at @xmath287 . at stronger forcing , region iii , @xmath172 is nonmonotonic , a maximum is reached at @xmath288 . @xmath172 grows monotonically on @xmath289 , this growth is approximately linear on certain interval to the left of @xmath198 . we studied the temperature dependence of the diffusivity at fixed @xmath75 . contrary to the constant forcing problem @xcite the diffusivity increases with the temperature for all @xmath61 when the temperature is below certain frequency - dependent threshold value . limited temperature intervals exist for the force amplitudes in regions ii and iii , in which the diffusivity decreases with the temperature ( `` temperature - abnormal diffusivity '' , tad ) . the physical reason behind the strong diffusivity enhancement is emergence of two populations of particles under the action of external force , locked and running ones . at optimal @xmath61 and @xmath7 the number of particles in the two populations is comparable , long flights of the running particles relative to the locked population take place with significant probability , resulting in giant enhancement of diffusion . for comparison we studied diffusivity under sinusoidal in time driving . we saw that the same features in @xmath172 are observed in the three regions of force amplitudes as in pcp driving case . we thus conjecture that the qualitative features of @xmath290 behavior are insensitive to specific functional dependence of the ( symmetric , smooth enough in @xmath46 ) external force on time . the effects investigated allow for simple experimental verification . diffusion of particles on solid body surface is one natural arena for this . such systems are characterized by low dissipation @xcite . another field to study tad in is in propagation of magnetic particles on non - magnetic substrate , acted upon with electromagnetic fields . abnormal diffusion enhancement could be manifested in , _ e.g. _ , enhanced growth of islands of the new phase at decreasing temperatures . once verified experimentally , the effect of abnormal diffusion enhancement can find applications in a number of new technologies : in sorting of particles , manufacturing surface structures with required properties , controlling penetration of particles through biological and artificial membranes , in memristors , devices with charge density waves , etc . 50ifxundefined [ 1 ] ifx#1 ifnum [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo ifx [ 1 ] # 1firstoftwo secondoftwo `` `` # 1''''@noop [ 0]secondoftwosanitize@url [ 0 ] + 12$12 & 12#1212_12%12@startlink[1]@endlink[0]@bib@innerbibempty @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) , , and , eds . , @noop _ _ , , vol . ( , , ) , ed . , link:\doibase 10.1007/978 - 1 - 4419 - 1543 - 6 [ _ _ ] ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1016/s0370 - 1573(98)00029 - 5 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/c0sm01051k [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.3762/bjnano.7.31 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1088/0034 - 4885/76/4/046602 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.81.387 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjst / e2013 - 02071 - 2 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop _ _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.96.190601 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.105.230602 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.104.248001 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1002/adma.201203500 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/s10404 - 013 - 1291 - 9 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01325627 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01323506 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1016/0375 - 9601(79)90384 - 0 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01321244 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01352745 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1007/bf01485833 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/epl / i1999 - 00510 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.76.4874 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.82.2820 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.98.020602 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.92.250601 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.80.021123 [ * * , ( ) ] http://stacks.iop.org/1367-2630/7/i=1/a=029 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.87.010602 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.65.031104 [ * * , ( ) ] @noop * * , ( ) link:\doibase 10.1016/j.physa.2004.04.019 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1140/epjb / e2013 - 40866 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.77.041107 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1039/c4sm02387k [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/100/50005 [ * * , ( ) ] , , and , eds . , @noop _ _ , vol . ( , , ) , ed . , @noop _ _ ( , , ) @noop _ _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1209/0295 - 5075/97/60004 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1140/epjst / e2010 - 01270 - 7 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1134/s0021364012030083 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1088/1742 - 6596/514/1/012045 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.70.051104 [ * * , ( ) ] , @noop _ _ ( , , ) link:\doibase 10.1103/physrevlett.101.190603 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1103/physreve.80.062102 [ * * , ( ) ] , link:\doibase 10.1103/revmodphys.79.1381 [ * * , ( ) ] link:\doibase 10.1080/00018732.2012.706401 [ * * , ( ) ]
Abstract: | [
"we present a study of diffusion enhancement of underdamped brownian particles in 1d symmetric space - periodic potential due to external symmetric time - periodic forcing with zero mean . we show that the diffusivity can be enhanced by many orders of magnitude at appropriate choice of the forcing amplitude and frequency . the diffusivity demonstrates tad , abnormal ( decreasing ) temperature dependence at forcing amplitudes exceeding certain value . at any fixed forcing frequency @xmath0 normal temperature dependence of the diffusivity is restored at low enough temperatures , @xmath1 in contrast with the problem with constant external forcing . at fixed temperature at small forcing frequency the diffusivity either slowly decreases with @xmath0 , or ( at stronger forcing ) goes through a maximum near @xmath2 , reciprocal superdiffusion stage duration . at high frequencies , between @xmath2 and a fraction of the oscillation frequency at the potential minimum , the diffusivity is shown to decrease with @xmath0 according to a power law , with exponent related to the transient superdiffusion exponent . this behavior is found similar for the cases of sinusoidal in time and piecewise constant periodic ( `` square '' ) forcing ."
] | 10,925 | 10,925 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: electron scattering is one of the most important processes in determining the emergent thermal spectrum from models of optically thick accretion discs around black holes and neutron stars . electron scattering opacity generally dominates absorption opacity in the atmospheres of the innermost regions of such discs @xcite . in the case where coherent ( thomson ) scattering is a good approximation , the resulting local thermal spectrum of some annulus in the disc is generally harder than a blackbody with the same effective temperature , due to incomplete thermalization at the scattering photosphere . however , incoherent ( compton ) scattering in the disc surface layers by thermal electrons can reduce this spectral hardening by increasing the energy exchange between the photons and the plasma @xcite . in addition to the disc atmosphere itself , many models invoke a powerful corona above the disc consisting of high temperature or nonthermal electrons that compton upscatter disc photons to produce the energetically significant hard x - rays that exist in certain classes of active galactic nuclei and in certain black hole x - ray binary accretion states ( e.g. @xcite ) . these hard x - rays in turn interact with the relatively cool disc atmosphere to produce reflection spectra that are widely observed in many black hole sources ( e.g. @xcite ) . in this work we explore turbulent comptonization , which is the effect of comptonization by bulk , turbulent electron motions on photon spectra @xcite . in sources with radiation pressure dominated accretion flows , bulk velocities may exceed thermal electron velocities , a phenomenon first pointed out in @xcite . the turbulent speeds @xmath0 on the outer scale of an mhd turbulent cascade will be of order the alfvn speed , and the ratio of this to the root mean square electron thermal velocity is therefore @xmath1 here @xmath2 , @xmath3 , and @xmath4 are the gas , radiation , and magnetic pressures , respectively , and @xmath5 is the ratio of the proton to electron mass . stratified shearing box simulations of magnetorotational turbulence generally have disc atmospheres that are supported by magnetic fields rather than thermal pressure @xcite . hence the first factor generally exceeds unity in an otherwise radiation pressure dominated disc . bulk speeds on the outer scale of the turbulence will therefore exceed the electron thermal speeds whenever the radiation pressure to gas pressure ratio exceeds the ratio of the proton to electron mass ratio , and even smaller depending on how magnetically supported is the disc atmosphere . in this regime , bulk comptonization by the turbulence may dominate thermal comptonization in determining the shape of the spectrum emitted by a local patch of the disc . this regime is commonly reached for near eddington accretion on black holes of all mass scales . indeed , the inner disc solution of the standard geometrically thin model of @xcite gives vertically averaged radiation to gas pressure ratios of approximately @xmath6 where @xmath7 is the ratio of turbulent stress to thermal pressure , @xmath8 is the black hole mass , @xmath9 is the radiative efficiency of the disc as a whole , @xmath10 is the luminosity in eddington units , and @xmath11 is the radius in the disc in units of the gravitational radius @xmath12 . hence the radiation to gas pressure ratio of the innermost disc will generally exceed the proton to electron mass ratio for near - eddington accretion even for stellar mass black holes , and certainly for supermassive black holes . on the other hand , energy exchange between the photons and the plasma is generally dominated by true absorption opacity in standard disc models for the most supermassive black holes @xcite , which may reduce bulk comptonization by turbulence in these sources . we are also motivated by observational evidence in many sources for a cooler , more optically thick medium that also compton upscatters disc photons in high luminosity sources , but not to the high energies usually associated with the more traditional external corona . the soft x - ray excess of the type 1 seyfert ngc 5548 was fit by @xcite with a warm ( @xmath13 kev ) optically thick ( @xmath14 ) comptonizing medium . similar parameters were obtained for the soft x - ray excess of the type 1 seyfert mrk 509 by @xcite : @xmath15 kev and scattering optical depth @xmath16 to @xmath17 . @xcite fit the soft x - ray excess of the extreme narrow line seyfert 1 re j0134 + 396 assuming extra comptonization within the disc atmosphere itself with @xmath18 kev and @xmath19 . such a spectral decomposition is consistent with the lack of short time scale variability in the soft x - ray excess compared to the hard x - rays in this source @xcite . @xcite fit the soft x - ray excesses of eleven bright quasars with comptonization in a medium with @xmath20 kev and @xmath21 . @xcite fit soft intermediate state spectra of the black hole x - ray binary gx 339 - 4 with a comptonizing medium with @xmath22 kev and @xmath23 . thermal comptonization fits to the soft x - ray spectra of a number of ultraluminous x - ray sources have @xmath24 kev and @xmath25 @xcite . such fits have been nicely confirmed with _ nustar _ and _ xmm - newton _ spectra of the ultraluminous x - ray sources ngc 1313 x-1 and x-2 , which require warm @xmath26 kev , optically thick @xmath27 comptonizing media @xcite . @xcite and @xcite suggest that one way of forming these optically thick cool coronae is by a radiation pressure driven outflow . the alternative we consider here is bulk comptonization by turbulence in the disc atmosphere itself . comptonization by bulk motions in the accretion flow has also been considered by others . @xcite considered bulk comptonization in converging flows and shocks . starting from this seminal work , bulk comptonization by radial flows has been calculated in detail by numerous authors @xcite . @xcite included bulk comptonization in their monte carlo calculations of photon spectra from radiation mhd simulations of super - eddington accretion flows , and found that it produced significant spectral hardening which resembled spectra of ultra - luminous x - ray sources . here we focus on smaller scale bulk comptonization by turbulence within the disc atmosphere itself . turbulent comptonization has also been invoked in other areas of astrophysics . @xcite and @xcite used then current limits on cosmic microwave background temperature anisotropies to constrain possible turbulent energy on cosmological scales prior to recombination . @xcite considered comptonization by alfvnic turbulence in a relativistic outflow as a model for the spectrum of gamma - ray bursts . the purpose of this paper is to determine how photon spectra produced by turbulent comptonization depend on properties of the turbulence itself , and how to resolve and interpret this effect in radiation mhd simulations . the structure of this paper is as follows . in section [ sec_general ] we show that the macroscopic physical origins of turbulent comptonization energy exchange are work due to radiation pressure and viscous dissipation due to the radiation viscous stress tensor , and we discuss why this requires us to treat divergenceless turbulence separately from turbulence with non - zero divergence . in section [ sec_energy_exchange ] we discuss the consequences of this for correctly implementing radiative transport in simulations , and derive the appropriate radiation energy equation in both lab and fluid frame variables . in section [ sec_incompressible ] we address the conjecture of @xcite that turbulent comptonization can be treated as thermal comptonization by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave " temperature critically dependent on the photon mean free path . we show this is true only for divergenceless turbulence , derive the exact wave temperature with an analytic solution of the radiative transfer equation , and use this result to discuss how the wave temperature depends on the power spectrum of the turbulence . to provide physical insight , we also perform an intuitive , heuristic calculation of the wave temperature which well approximates the analytic solution . in section [ sec_compressible ] we consider bulk comptonization by turbulence with non - zero divergence . we show that comptonization by turbulence whose wavelengths are short relative to the photon mean free path can be treated as thermal comptonization with an equivalent temperature given by the full turbulent power . in the limit of extremely optically thick turbulence , we show how the evolution of local photon spectra can be understood in terms of compression and expansion of the strongly coupled photon and gas fluids . in section [ sec_discussion ] we discuss our results , and we summarize our findings in section [ sec_conclusion ] . in order to determine how photon spectra produced by turbulent comptonization depend on properties of the turbulence itself , it is useful to understand the distinct macroscopic physical origins of net energy exchange due to this effect . we show that these are simply the work done by radiation pressure and radiation viscous dissipation , and discuss the major consequences of this . we limit our consideration in this paper to non - relativistic velocities . before proceeding , we define terms and quantities that will be used repeatedly . by bulk comptonization we mean comptonization by bulk motions in general , and by turbulent comptonization we mean bulk comptonization specifically due to turbulence . we denote the characteristic photon mean free path @xmath28 , where @xmath29 is the electron density and @xmath30 is the thompson cross section . we denote the typical length scale for bulk velocity variations @xmath31 , such as the wavelength if there is a well - defined spatial period . unless otherwise stated , by the terms optically thin and thick we mean @xmath32 and @xmath33 , where @xmath34 and @xmath35 are the minimum and maximum length scales in the turbulent cascade , respectively , not referring to the optical depth that a photon would need to travel to escape the medium . net energy exchange due to bulk comptonization is simply the net energy exchange between gas mechanical energy and radiation . inside the photosphere , the mechanical energy loss rate per unit volume to radiation is @xmath36 where @xmath37 is the lab frame radiation pressure tensor . this can also be written as @xmath38 where @xmath39 is the trace of the radiation pressure tensor , @xmath40 is the radiation viscous shear stress tensor , and @xmath41 is the velocity shear tensor . we see that the energy exchange is separated into two pieces , one due to only a diverging velocity field and another due to a shearing velocity field in the presence of a radiation viscous shear stress tensor . the first piece has contributions from two effects , ordinary work done by radiation pressure , and radiation viscous dissipation . the former effect is first order in velocity since it is due to the contribution to @xmath42 that is zeroth order in velocity . energy exchange due to viscous effects , on the other hand , is second order in the velocity , as @xmath43 and the relevant contribution to @xmath42 must themselves be at least first order in velocity since they are a consequence of the velocity field . @xcite conjectured that turbulent comptonization can be treated as thermal comptonization by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave " temperature critically dependent on the photon mean free path . this is physically intuitive for divergenceless turbulence since in this case energy exchange is entirely due to radiation viscous dissipation and is therefore second order in velocity . in section [ sec_incompressible ] we prove this conjecture for an arbitrary , divergenceless velocity field of uniform density , derive the exact expression for the wave temperature , and show how it is related to the standard expression for radiation viscosity in the optically thick limit . the connection between bulk comptonization and the radiation viscous shear stress tensor is useful because it correctly suggests that the wave temperature can be written in terms of @xmath43 . since pressure work , on the other hand , is an effect first order in velocity , and since comptonization by a velocity field with non - zero divergence is a combination of pressure work and radiation viscous dissipation , it is not surprising that in this case bulk comptonization can not be treated as thermal comptonization , as we show in section [ sec_compressible ] . but in the optically thin limit , i.e. when the mean free path is significantly larger than the largest length scale in the turbulence , energy exchange that is first order in velocity vanishes since photons are equally likely to downscatter as they are to upscatter . bulk comptonization by a velocity field with non - zero divergence is then solely due to radiation viscous dissipation , and in section [ sec_compressible ] we show that it may be treated as thermal comptonization by solving the kompaneets equation with a wave temperature equivalent to the full bulk power . in the optically thick case , i.e. when the mean free path is significantly smaller than the smallest scale in the turbulence , the lowest order energy exchange is the work done by radiation pressure to compress the gas , since it is first order in velocity and since radiation viscous effects are suppressed by a factor @xmath44 ( section [ sec_incompressible ] ) . @xcite assumed that effects first order in velocity always vanish on average for turbulent eddies , but in the optically thick limit photons trapped in a converging ( diverging ) region undergo systematic upscattering ( downscattering ) . in the extremely optically thick limit in which the photon and gas fluids are strongly coupled , velocity convergence corresponds to compression in which gas mechanical energy is transferred locally to the photons . in section [ sec_compressible ] we show that in this process a locally thermal photon distribution remains thermal and only changes temperature , completely analogous to the evolution of the cosmic microwave background radiation under the expansion of the universe . unlike energy exchange due to viscous dissipation , this process is reversible . the effect of this process on the emergent spectrum of the disc will depend primarily on how effectively photons are able to escape from such regions to the observer . self - consistent radiation mhd simulations of turbulent , radiation pressure dominated accretion flows now exist , both in local vertically stratified shearing box geometries @xcite and in global simulations @xcite . although these simulations use frequency integrated equations , the emergent radiation spectrum can be computed , including the effects of bulk comptonization , using post - processing monte carlo simulations . indeed , this has already been done by @xcite . however , in order for such calculations to be self - consistent , the frequency integrated radiation mhd equations used in the simulations themselves must include energy exchange due to bulk comptonization . we now discuss the consequences of the macroscopic physical origins of such energy exchange detailed in section [ sec_general ] for ensuring this effect is captured in simulations . we then proceed to derive the appropriate frequency integrated source terms due to compton scattering for the gas and radiation energy equations in both lab frame and fluid frame variables . using these results , we discuss the extent to which bulk comptonization is captured by existing radiation mhd simulation codes . the decomposition of bulk comptonization energy exchange into pressure work and radiation viscous dissipation shows that radiation mhd schemes that neglect contributions to the viscous stress tensor that are first order in velocity can not capture bulk comptonization energy exchange due to a shearing velocity field or any optically thin velocity field with non - zero divergence . as these effects are second order in velocity , we also note that a necessary , but not sufficient , condition for capturing these effects is inclusion of energy terms second order in velocity . without such terms , turbulence in this form , instead of exchanging energy with photons , will eventually cascade down to the gridscale ( or viscous or resistive scale if the code has explicit viscosity or resistivity ) , and increase the internal energy of the gas . gas internal energy may then be exchanged with photons through thermal comptonization . the omission of viscous dissipation by radiation therefore does not prevent the eventual transfer of turbulent energy to radiation , but it may have other physical effects that can in turn affect radiation spectra . to derive the appropriate frequency integrated source terms due to comptonization , we start with the zeroth moment of the radiative transfer equation , correct to order @xmath45 and @xmath46 @xcite , @xmath47+\frac{v_i}{c } n^i\biggr\}\cr + \left({18\over5}+{17\over5}\epsilon{\partial\over\partial\epsilon } + { 11\over20}\epsilon^2{\partial^2\over\partial\epsilon^2}\right ) \left(n^{ij}{v_iv_j\over c^2}-{v^2\over3c^2}n\right ) . \label{eqpsaltis}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath48 is the photon energy , and the various angle - averaged moments are defined in terms of the energy and direction ( @xmath49 ) dependent photon occupation number @xmath50 by @xmath51 in principle , the energy equation is obtained by writing eq . ( [ eqpsaltis ] ) in terms of moments of the specific intensity and then integrating over all frequencies . unfortunately , we can not integrate over terms multiplied by @xmath52 without prior knowledge of the spectrum . for the purpose of simulations , then , we make two approximations . first , we observe that the fractional energy change per scattering off of non - relativistic electrons is small , so that only regions inside the photosphere contribute to comptonization . since the stimulated scattering terms are already order @xmath52 and in these regions departures from isotropy are order @xmath53 , we make the following approximation for these terms : @xmath54 second , we assume that the spectrum can be approximated by a bose - einstein distribution with temperature @xmath55 . with these approximations , eq . ( [ eqpsaltis ] ) yields @xmath56 this is the correct energy equation , but in order for it to capture second order energy exchange , the substituted value of @xmath57 must be calculated with a moment closure scheme that does not neglect contributions to the radiation viscous stress tensor that are first order in velocity . for example , it is not adequate to calculate @xmath57 by substituting @xmath58 into the first moment equation . here . ] this is equivalent to flux limited diffusion in the diffusion regime , such as that implemented in @xcite . these do , however , capture energy exchange due to pressure work in the optically thick regime . to show this , we substitute into eq . ( [ integrated1 ] ) the standard closure relation , @xmath59 which gives @xmath60 we see that energy exchange second order in velocity is not present . furthermore , we see that energy exchange due to a converging velocity field is indeed the work done by radiation pressure to compress the gas , @xmath61 . the m1 closure scheme @xcite , implemented in , e.g. , @xcite , also captures first order energy exchange but not second order energy exchange . this scheme assumes that there exists a frame in which @xmath62 . the lab frame radiation pressure tensor can then be expressed in terms of the energy density and flux @xcite : @xmath63 where @xmath64 and @xmath65 to show that second order energy exchange is not captured , we consider the case of a non - zero radiation viscous shear stress tensor due to a non - relativistic velocity field in an otherwise homogeneous medium . the lowest order contribution to the flux must be first order in velocity . in this scheme , then , the radiation viscous shear stress tensor is zero to first order in velocity , and hence second order energy exchange , which requires a contribution first order in velocity ( eq . [ energy_exchange ] ) , is not captured . another way to understand why both flux - limited diffusion and the m1 closure scheme fail to capture second order energy exchange is to observe that they both bridge generic optically thick conditions with optically thin conditions , while optically thin turbulence does not fall into either category . in optically thin turbulence , the turbulence length scales are optically thin ( @xmath66 ) , but conditions are otherwise optically thick ( @xmath67 ) , since we are far enough inside the photosphere that photons must scatter many times before escaping . it seems that only a more sophisticated approach , such as explicitly solving the transfer equation as done by @xcite , can capture this effect . we note that @xcite add an artificial viscosity to the m1 closure scheme in order to address a numerical problem associated with artificial shocks in their simulations . they assume a kinematic radiation viscosity given by @xmath68 which , as they acknowledge , underestimates the actual viscosity in the optically thick limit by a factor of @xmath69 ( eq . [ scattering_nu ] ) . since we show ( section [ sec_incompressible ] ) that the viscosity is smallest in the optically thick limit ( eq . [ scattering_nu_k ] ) , this artificial viscosity always underestimates the actual radiation shear stress tensor , and therefore only partially captures secord order energy exchange . for completeness , we also write eq . ( [ integrated1 ] ) in terms of fluid frame radiation variables , indicated by subscript zero : @xmath70 since @xmath71 eq . ( [ integrated2 ] ) simplifies to @xmath72 @xcite ( hereafter s04 ) conjectured that comptonization by turbulence can be treated as thermal comptonization by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave " temperature given by @xmath73 where @xmath74 is the temperature corresponding to the total electron energy density @xmath75 at wavenumber @xmath76 . equation ( [ twave1 ] ) generalizes s04 eq . ( 8) , @xmath77 which gives @xmath78 for a kolmogorov spectrum , @xmath79 , with maximum wavelength @xmath80 . equation ( [ twave1 ] ) is a weighting scheme of the form @xmath81 with the weighting function @xmath82 given by @xmath83 this scheme roughly gives full weight to wavelengths less than @xmath84 and zero weight to wavelengths greater than @xmath84 . for a periodic velocity field , since the modes are discrete , eq . ( [ eq_scheme_form ] ) is more clearly written @xmath85 where @xmath86 is the temperature of mode @xmath87 . for the remainder of this section we use eq . ( [ twave2 ] ) since it is more useful for applications to radiation mhd simulations , but note that all results also hold for eq . ( [ eq_scheme_form ] ) , as this is just the continuum limit . we also define @xmath88 = @xmath89 , the optical depth divided by @xmath90 across a mode with wavenumber @xmath76 . ( [ twave3 ] ) , for example , can then be written , @xmath91 the structure of this section is as follows . in section [ sec_exact ] we build on s04 by proving that comptonization by an arbitrary velocity field of uniform density can indeed be treated as thermal comptonization , provided that the field is divergenceless and the photon escape probability is sufficiently small . the exact equivalent wave temperature is of the form eq . ( [ twave2 ] ) , with the weighting function @xmath82 given by @xmath92 where @xmath93 . \label{eq : qdefinition}\ ] ] the limiting cases of @xmath82 are @xmath94 we plot @xmath95 and @xmath82 in fig . [ mcdata1 ] . since log scaling is used , the curve for @xmath95 disappears for @xmath96 . we see that @xmath95 does roughly approximate @xmath82 . in section [ sec_heur ] , to provide physical insight into the exact solution , we also find a heuristic , approximate expression for @xmath78 , also plotted in fig . [ mcdata1 ] , with a simple physical model motivated by ideas put forth in s04 . finally , in section [ sec_spec ] we use the correct expression for @xmath78 to discuss how the wave temperature depends on the power spectrum of the turbulence and determine which turbulent wavelengths contribute most to comptonization . to derive eqs . ( [ twave2 ] ) and ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) , we first find an expression for the wave temperature in terms of the second moment of the occupation number , since it is the latter which gives rise to the radiation shear stress tensor . we start with the zeroth moment of the radiative transfer equation , eq . ( [ eqpsaltis ] ) , correct to order @xmath45 and @xmath46 . note that terms of order @xmath46 are second order in velocity since for comptonized photons @xmath97 . consider a solution for the angle dependent occupation number @xmath98 constructed with the expansion @xmath99 where @xmath100 is formally @xmath87th order in velocity . we make the ansatz that @xmath101 is independent of position and angle , so that to second order in velocity eq . ( [ eq_expansion_1 ] ) is @xmath102 to second order in velocity the zeroth moment equation then simplifies to @xmath103 we also invoke the first moment of the transfer equation , @xcite eq . we multiply this by @xmath104 , so that in steady state , to second order it becomes @xmath105 substituting eq . ( [ eq_first_moment ] ) into eq . ( [ eq_zeroth_simplified ] ) gives @xmath106 we average this over space to obtain @xmath107 this is the kompaneets equation with a bulk comptonization contribution to the temperature given by @xmath108 to evaluate eq . ( [ eq_twave_n ] ) , we need to derive @xmath109 to first order in velocity . we start with the radiative transfer equation , eq . ( a1 ) of @xcite , correct to order @xmath45 and @xmath46 , and substitute in eq . ( [ eq_expansion_2 ] ) . in steady state , to first order in velocity , the transfer equation then simplifies to @xmath110 if the density is constant and the velocity field is divergenceless with sinusoidal mode decomposition @xmath111 then the solution is given by ( appendix [ transverse_solution ] ) @xmath112 where @xmath82 is given by eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) . finally , we evaluate eq . ( [ eq_twave_n ] ) by plugging in eq . ( [ eq_nij ] ) to get @xmath113 since the modes are sinusoidal , eq . ( [ eq_twave4 ] ) simplifies to @xmath114 which is equivalent to eq . ( [ twave2 ] ) . if , however , one solves the kompaneets equation with an escape probability term , @xmath115 , we must also add such a term to the radiative transfer equation , which may affect the occupation number second moment . for an optically thick system , for example , we must require that this term be small compared to the term that sets the diffusion time scale . this term comes from the term @xmath116 , which is approximated by @xmath117 the diffusion timescale is set by the second derivative term , @xmath118 which gives the condition @xmath119 we now discuss the extent to which , in this case , radiation viscous dissipation can be described by a coefficient of kinematic viscosity @xmath120 , which is usually defined by @xmath121 where @xmath122 is the fluid mass density . first we find the radiation shear stress tensor corresponding to eq . ( [ eq_nij ] ) by frequency integrating and subtracting off the scalar radiation pressure , which gives @xmath123 incidentally , we note that eq . ( [ eq_twave_n ] ) can then alternatively be written in terms of the radiation viscous shear stress tensor , @xmath124 according to eqs . ( [ eq_kinematic ] ) and ( [ eq_vis_p ] ) , although we can not in general define a kinematic viscosity coefficient , for any single velocity mode the kinematic radiation viscosity is given by @xmath125 so that the radiation viscous shear stress tensor can be written @xmath126 however , in the optically thick limit ( i.e. @xmath127 ) , the kinematic viscosity is independent of @xmath128 , @xmath129 so that in this limit the kinematic viscosity is well - defined for an arbitrary ( divergenceless ) velocity field . we also note that in this limit eq . ( [ eq_twave4 ] ) agrees with the heating temperature " in @xcite , @xmath130 they also mention that this can be understood in terms of the kinematic radiation viscosity given by eq . ( [ scattering_nu ] ) . from the more commonly cited value , @xmath131 , in , e.g. , @xcite , @xcite , and @xcite . the reason for the discrepancy is that the more commonly cited value , first derived by @xcite , assumes pure absorption , while eq . ( [ scattering_nu ] ) is correct for pure scattering ( @xcite ; @xcite ) . ] to provide physical insight into our analytic solution given by eqs . ( [ twave2 ] ) and ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) , we now find a heuristic , approximate expression for @xmath132 with a simple physical model motivated by ideas put forth in s04 . to do this , we first consider the wave temperature of a single mode with wavenumber @xmath133 , which we denote @xmath134 . s04 suggested that photons can only sample turbulent velocities on scales @xmath135 , since longer turbulent wavelengths will advect photons back and forth with the flow without allowing the photons to sample " their velocities . a rough interpretation of this reasoning leads to @xmath136 if one then assumes that the wave temperature of an arbitrary field is the sum of the wave temperatures of its modes , then eq . ( [ twave1 ] ) follows . but a more subtle interpretation of this reasoning suggests that @xmath134 is determined by the second moment of the distribution of velocity differences between subsequent scatterings , @xmath137 . in the long wavelength limit , velocity differences between subsequent scatterings are negligible and so the wave power does not contribute to comptonization . in the short wavelength limit , velocity differences allow photons to sample the full power of the wave . this model of comptonization suggests that we define @xmath138 where @xmath139 before proceeding , we note that defining @xmath137 is potentially tricky because the distribution of @xmath140 for a photon is dependent on its current location , in effect introducing correlations into subsequent @xmath140 s . in other words , subsequent @xmath140 s are not independent . but if the escape probability is low enough , a condition we quantify below , then the set of @xmath140 s encountered by a photon before it escapes is indistinguishable from a set of @xmath140 s independently drawn from the position - averaged @xmath140 distribution . the order of @xmath140 s is different in the two cases , but the total photon energy change does not depend on the order because the fractional photon energy change per scattering is small for @xmath141 . with these potential problems accounted for , we proceed to calculate @xmath142 . first we find the proportionality constant between @xmath142 and @xmath137 by evaluating both sides in the short wavelength limit . in this limit , the full wave power must contribute , so @xmath143 . to evaluate @xmath137 in this limit , let @xmath144 be any normalized distribution of velocities . then , @xmath145 therefore , @xmath146 we now calculate @xmath147 for the position - averaged @xmath140 for a single , divergenceless ( i.e. transverse ) mode with wavelength @xmath148 , @xmath149 let @xmath150 be the probability density that a photon travels a displacement @xmath151 between scatterings . then , at a given position @xmath152 , @xmath153 averaging over all positions in a volume @xmath154 , this is @xmath155 for a single mode , eq . ( [ vel_field ] ) gives @xmath156 and @xmath157 the probability that a photon with mean free path @xmath158 travels a distance between @xmath159 and @xmath160 is @xmath161 . let @xmath162 , where @xmath163 is the angle between the photon propagation direction and the @xmath164-axis , so that @xmath165 . then , expressing @xmath166 in spherical polar coordinates and invoking axisymmetry about the @xmath164-axis , equation ( [ eq : dv2deltar ] ) becomes @xmath167 ^ 2 e^{-s / l}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is easily evaluated by performing the integral over @xmath164 first , giving @xmath168 . \\ & = 2 \sigma_{{\bf v}}^2\left[1 - \tau_k \tan^{-1}\left(\frac{1}{\tau_k}\right)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] eq . ( [ fheur ] ) then gives @xmath169 the limiting cases are @xmath170 by comparison , the exact solution for a single mode is determined by eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) . our heuristic result is plotted in fig . [ mcdata1 ] , and is remarkably close to the exact solution . in particular , it is a much better approximation than the rough weighting function , eq . ( [ twave3 ] ) , also shown in fig . [ mcdata1 ] . our model based on the second moment of the velocity difference distribution therefore captures the essential physics of comptonization by a single mode . before proceeding to define @xmath171 for an arbitrary velocity field , we quantify the condition that the escape probability be low enough , presupposed by our derivation of @xmath147 . since the distribution of velocity differences , as a function of position , repeats every quarter wavelength , our results should be valid provided photons travel a distance @xmath172 in the @xmath164 direction that is greater than @xmath173 before escaping . for an ( optically thick ) random walk , @xmath174 , where @xmath175 is the average number of scatterings . since @xmath176 , where @xmath177 is the escape probability per unit time during the average time @xmath178 between subsequent scattering events , @xmath179 for optically thick modes . up to a factor of unity , this agrees with eq . ( [ eq_escape_constraint1 ] ) . we now use our model to compute @xmath171 for an arbitrary velocity field in terms of @xmath180 . proceeding analogously to the single mode case , we define @xmath181 where @xmath182 is the temperature corresponding to the full electron energy density of the velocity field . to simplify this , we compute @xmath183 ^ 2 p_{\delta { \bf r}}(\delta { \bf r } ) d^3 \delta { \bf r } d^3 { \bf r } \notag\\ & = \frac{1}{v}\int \sum_i \left({\bf v}_i({\bf r}+\delta { \bf r})-{\bf v}_i ( { \bf r})\right)^2 p_{\delta { \bf r}}(\delta { \bf r } ) d^3 \delta { \bf r } d^3 { \bf r } \notag\\ % & = \frac{1}{v}\int \sum_i \left ( \delta { \bf v}_i(\delta { \bf r},{\bf r } ) % \right)^2 p_{\delta { \bf r}}(\delta { \bf r } ) d^3 \delta { \bf r } % d^3 { \bf r}\notag \\ & = \sum_i \langle ( \delta { \bf v}_i)^2 \rangle . \label{deltavcalc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] to get from line 2 to line 3 we made use of the orthogonality for distinct sinusoidal modes . that is , for two distinct modes , @xmath184 and @xmath185 , @xmath186 , and any displacement @xmath187 , @xmath188 then , since @xmath189 , eqs . ( [ fheur ] ) , ( [ theur ] ) , and ( [ deltavcalc ] ) give @xmath190 or , alternatively , @xmath191 eq . ( [ theur2 ] ) is the same as the exact solution for the wave temperature , eq . ( [ twave2 ] ) , except that here the heuristic weighting function is used . note that in our heuristic derivation it is the orthogonality of distinct modes that allows us to express the wave temperature of an arbitrary velocity field as a sum over the wave temperatures of its modes . unsurprisingly , orthogonality was used analogously to prove eq . ( [ twave2 ] ) . therefore , our model based on the second moment of the velocity difference distribution captures the essential physics of comptonization by an arbitrary , divergenceless velocity field . we now analyse the dependence of @xmath132 on the power spectrum of the turbulence . for the remainder of this section , we write @xmath76 in units of @xmath192 for clarity ( i.e. @xmath193 and @xmath194 denote optically thick and thin scales , respectively ) . if the turbulence is completely optically thin on all scales ( @xmath195 ) , then @xmath196 , independent of the energy spectral index , @xmath197 . however , if some scales in the turbulent cascade are optically thick , then @xmath197 will affect @xmath132 . for the case where all scales in the turbulence are optically thick ( @xmath198 ) , eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) implies that @xmath199 integrating this over an energy spectrum @xmath200 then gives @xmath201 for a broad power spectrum , i.e. @xmath202 , this simplifies to @xmath203 this is illustrated in fig . [ ueff_p ] . note that @xmath204 drops significantly for @xmath205 , because then the energy bearing modes are on the largest scales . these are the most optically thick and therefore the most downweighted in their contribution to bulk comptonization . we next analyse whether @xmath204 , for a given spectral index @xmath197 and range of modes , @xmath206 , is dominated by small or large scales . in other words , we examine which turbulent modes in a given spectrum contribute most to bulk comptonization . the relative contribution of a scale with wavenumber @xmath76 is @xmath207 where , from eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) , @xmath208 for optically thick ( @xmath209 ) scales , and @xmath210 for optically thin ( @xmath211 ) scales . now consider an underlying power spectrum with some @xmath212 and @xmath213 . we see that for @xmath214 the exponent in eq . ( [ contribution ] ) is always positive , and so small scales contribute most to bulk comptonization , regardless of @xmath212 and @xmath213 . this is physically intuitive ; for @xmath214 , the turbulent power is concentrated on small scales . since the weighting factor @xmath82 also favors small scales , they of course contribute most . for @xmath215 , the exponent is always negative , and so large scales always contribute most . in this case , the turbulent power is so concentrated on large scales that they contribute more even though @xmath82 favors small scales . for @xmath216 , we first consider the part of the spectrum with @xmath194 ( if it exists ) . since @xmath210 , small scales contribute more than large scales for these modes . now consider the part of the spectrum with @xmath193 ( if it exists ) . here , large scales contribute more than small scales . therefore , looking at the entire power spectrum , it is intermediate scales that contribute most , assuming it is broad enough to include regions of both small and large @xmath76 . if it is not sufficiently broad , then whether small or large scales contribute most depends on @xmath212 and @xmath213 relative to @xmath217 ( the optically thin to thick transition wavenumber ) . these results are depicted in fig . [ ueff_dist ] . the curve in this figure shows the values of @xmath197 and @xmath76 such that the derivative of @xmath218 is zero , using the full analytic expression for @xmath82 from eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) . to connect this figure to our discussion , draw a horizontal line from @xmath212 to @xmath213 at a given value of @xmath197 . if the line lies in the lower ( upper ) region , then small ( large ) scales contribute most . if the line straddles the two regions , then for the part of the line that lies in the lower region small scales contribute most , and for the part that lies in the upper region large scales contribute the most . in this case , then , for the entire spectrum it is the scales that straddle the curve which contribute most . note that for @xmath214 and @xmath215 a spectrum can never straddle the curve , whereas for a kolmogorov spectrum ( @xmath219 ) , e.g. , it can , if @xmath220 . @xcite conjectured that comptonization by turbulence can be treated as thermal comptonization by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave " temperature . in section [ sec_incompressible ] we proved this under certain conditions , one of which is that the turbulence be divergenceless . in this section we investigate comptonization by velocity fields with non - zero divergence , an effect that usually can not be treated as thermal comptonization , with the aim of understanding how it impacts radiation spectra in generic , turbulent regions of stratified accretion disc atmospheres . while we do not have an exact solution for comptonization by an arbitrary velocity field with non - zero divergence , we have solutions for two limiting cases . the trivial case is the optically thin case , i.e. when the mean free path is significantly larger than the largest length scale in the turbulence , @xmath221 . electron velocities sampled " by photons are uncorrelated and so compton scattering should depend on only the total spatial average distribution of electron velocities . this is , therefore , the one case where comptonization by a velocity field with non - zero divergence can be treated as thermal comptonization , by solving the kompaneets equation with @xmath132 given by @xmath222 note that although we formally write @xmath132 as a function of @xmath84 , in this limit @xmath132 is independent of @xmath84 . energy exchange first order in velocity vanishes since photons are equally likely to downscatter as they are to upscatter . bulk comptonization is then solely due to radiation viscous dissipation ( see section [ sec_general ] ) . as viscous effects are second order in velocity , it is unsurprising that they can be characterized by a temperature . we also note that in this limit the wave temperature is the same as that for a divergenceless velocity field , eq . ( [ eq_limits ] ) . optically thin bulk comptonization is therefore a single phenomenon that depends on only the mean square speed of the velocity field . to arrive at this result with a more formal approach , we start with the zeroth moment of the radiative transfer equation , eq . ( [ eqpsaltis ] ) . in the limit of optically thin turbulence the radiation variables must be homogeneous and isotropic , so that @xmath223 , and @xmath224 . then , averaging eq . ( [ eqpsaltis ] ) over the largest scale @xmath35 gives @xmath225\biggr\}. \label{eqkomp}\end{aligned}\ ] ] this is the kompaneets equation , with the contribution from the velocity field to the comptonization temperature given by eq . ( [ compressible_thin ] ) . in the optically thick case , i.e. when the photon mean free path is significantly smaller than the smallest scale in the turbulence , the lowest order energy exchange is the work done by radiation pressure to compress the gas , since it is first order in velocity and since radiation viscous effects are suppressed by a factor @xmath44 ( section [ sec_incompressible ] ) . we focus on the extremely optically thick case , which we define as the limit in which photon diffusion is negligible relative to photon advection , so that the photon and gas fluids are strongly coupled . if we define @xmath226 , the photon number density at energy @xmath48 , and @xmath227 , the total photon number density , then the advection and diffusion fluxes are given by @xmath228 and @xmath229 respectively . the extremely optically thick limit is then given by @xmath230 in this case , velocity convergence corresponds to compression in which gas mechanical energy is transferred locally to the photons . we expect that photons with wavelength @xmath231 are effectively compressed at a rate given by the velocity difference across @xmath231 , @xmath232 so that , for example , a locally thermal photon distribution remains thermal and only changes temperature , completely analogous to the evolution of the cosmic microwave background radiation under the expansion of the universe . this is equivalent to a fractional energy change per scattering given by @xmath233 since @xmath234 we now confirm that eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) correctly describes extremely optically thick compton scattering in a converging or diverging flow , both by providing a heuristic argument and by deriving it from the radiative transfer equation . before proceeding , we note that the study of photon upscattering by a converging velocity field can be traced back to @xcite and @xcite , who , along with later authors , made detailed spectral calculations for specific velocity fields in shocks and spherically accreting systems . in fact , eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) can equivalently be stated as the upscattering timescale @xmath235 given in @xcite . in this section , by contrast , we have been investigating how this effect manifests itself locally in a generic , turbulent region of a stratified disc atmosphere , with the goal of resolving and interpreting it in spectral calculations of radiation mhd simulations . we have been focusing on the extremely optically thick case , in which the photon and gas fluids are strongly coupled , because the physics is both relevant and intuitive . in the moderately optically thick case , on the other hand , i.e. @xmath236 such as photon upscattering in a radiation pressure dominated shock @xcite , diffusion competes with advection so that photon distributions at neighboring fluid elements mix . photon upscattering in such a converging flow may not be viewed as simply the compression of a photon fluid strongly coupled to the gas , and photon upscattering in which a photon thermal distribution is not preserved can occur . to heuristically derive eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) , consider a disturbance converging in the @xmath237 direction given by @xmath238 for a 3d random walk , the average distance between scatterings traveled by a photon in the direction of convergence is @xmath239 . since the fractional energy change per scattering for low energy photons is @xmath53 , at @xmath240 this gives @xmath241 in agreement with eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) . we now derive eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) with the radiative transfer equation , eq . ( [ eqpsaltis ] ) . if we ( 1 ) omit stimulated scattering terms to facilitate comparison with simulations , ( 2 ) substitute in the standard closure relations for the first moment in the optically thick limit , @xmath242 and @xmath243 and ( 3 ) substitute in the photon number density @xmath244 , then the radiative transfer equation to second order in velocity and first order in @xmath245 becomes @xmath246 neglecting stimulated scattering , this is @xcite eq . ( 18 ) , cast in the physically revealing form of a fokker - plank equation . the terms inside the divergence operator correspond to spatial drift ( i.e. photon advection ) and spatial diffusion , respectively . the next term corresponds to energy drift due to photon upscattering ( downscattering ) in the presence of a converging ( diverging ) velocity field . the remaining terms correspond to energy drift and diffusion due to thermal comptonization . note that even though @xcite start with a zeroth moment equation correct only to first order in @xmath53 , their resulting equation is the same because with the standard closure relation ( eq . [ closure1 ] ) the second order terms cancel . the fractional energy change per scattering given by eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) follows from the bulk upscattering term . in the extremely optically thick limit the spatial diffusion term is negligible , and so photons are advected with the velocity field and upscatter according to eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) . the effect of this process on the emergent spectrum of the disc will depend primarily on how effectively photons are able to escape from converging ( or diverging ) regions to the observer . we have investigated how photon spectra produced by turbulent comptonization depend on the properties of the turbulence itself , and how to resolve and interpret this effect in radiation mhd simulations . our principle results are as follows . first we address the conjecture of @xcite that turbulent comptonization can be treated as thermal componization by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave " temperature . for comptonization by divergenceless turbulence , which is due to the radiation viscous shear stress tensor and is therefore an effect second order in velocity , this conjecture holds provided that the density is uniform and the escape probability is sufficiently small ( eq . [ eq_escape_constraint1 ] ) . the correct wave temperature can be expressed in terms of the radiation viscous shear stress tensor ( eqs . [ eq_twave_n ] and [ eq_twave_p ] ) and is in turn given by eq . ( [ twave2 ] ) . this is a weighting over the velocity power at each scale in the turbulence , with the weighting function given by eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) . optically thin scales have unit weight factors , implying that the power at these scales contributes fully to the wave temperature . optically thick scales , on the other hand , are downweighted by a factor proportional to one over the square of the optical depth across those scales . this downweighting arises because bulk comptonization is sensitive to the difference in bulk fluid velocity between subsequent scatterings , as demonstrated by our heuristic argument in section [ sec_incompressible ] . these velocity differences are much smaller than the velocity amplitude on some scale if the photon mean free path is much smaller than that scale . we note that our expression for the wave temperature of divergenceless turbulence assumes a uniform density . furthermore , it is non - local in that it is expressed in terms of the mode decomposition of the entire velocity field . although a generic velocity field has density variations , if the largest turbulent length scale @xmath35 is smaller than the scale on which the density varies then we can define the wave temperature for regions of order @xmath35 . if the density also varies on smaller scales , then we can define the wave temperature for smaller regions by omitting contributions from larger modes . assuming these modes would be significantly downweighted anyway , this procedure would likely capture nearly all comptonized power in the turbulence . for turbulence with non - zero divergence , bulk comptonization energy exchange is due to both work done by radiation pressure and radiation viscous dissipation . since pressure work is an effect first order in velocity , it can not be treated with an equivalent temperature . but in the optically thin limit , i.e. when the mean free path is significantly larger than the largest length scale in the turbulence , energy exchange first order in velocity vanishes since photons are equally likely to downscatter as they are to upscatter . bulk comptonization by a velocity field with non - zero divergence is then solely due to radiation viscous dissipation , and it may be treated as thermal comptonization . the wave temperature is given by the full power in the turbulence , eq . ( [ compressible_thin ] ) , directly analogous to the optically thin limit of divergenceless turbulence . in the optically thick case , i.e. when the mean free path is significantly smaller than the smallest scale in the turbulence , the lowest order energy exchange is the work done by radiation pressure to compress the gas , since it is first order in velocity and since radiation viscous effects are suppressed by a factor @xmath44 . the extremely optically thick limit , defined as the limit in which spatial photon diffusion is negligible relative to photon advection , is given by eq . ( [ eq_extremely_optically_thick ] ) . in this limit , the photon and gas fluids are strongly coupled , so that velocity convergence corresponds to compression in which gas mechanical energy is transferred locally to the photons . photons upscatter with fractional energy change given by eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) . in this process a locally thermal photon distribution remains thermal and only changes temperature , analogous to the evolution of the cosmic microwave background radiation under the expansion of the universe . unlike energy exchange due to viscous dissipation , this process is reversible . the effect of this process on the emergent spectrum of the disc will depend primarily on how effectively photons are able to escape from such regions to the observer . for moderate optical depths , such as photon upscattering in a radiation pressure dominated shock @xcite , diffusion competes with advection so that photon distributions at neighboring fluid elements mix . the effect of photon upscattering in a converging region on local spectra is more complex and depends on the details of the flow . it is important to note that optically thick comptonization by a velocity field with non - zero divergence may be very sensitive to the time dependence of the velocity field . this is important because usually post - processing monte - carlo simulations invoke time - independent atmospheres with the assumption that they approximately capture the effects of interest . for example , consider comptonization in a converging region . a time - independent velocity field results in the accumulation of photons and subsequent upscattering to high energies at the point of zero velocity . if the region is near the photosphere , the emergent spectrum will be strongly upscattered . but in a time - dependent velocity field photons have a limited time to upscatter before converging regions become diverging regions , and so the effect on the emergent spectrum is significantly different . real accretion flows are spatially stratified . simulations of magnetorotational turbulence generally indicate that this turbulence dominates the fluid velocities in the midplane regions of the accretion flow . this turbulence is largely incompressible ( divergenceless ) , although it generally excites compressible spiral acoustic waves @xcite . sufficiently far from the midplane , magnetic forces always dominate thermal pressure forces , and support the flow vertically against the tidal gravitational field of the compact object . such regions are dominated by parker instability dynamics , and exhibit considerable compressive behavior ( i.e. the flow has non - zero divergence ) with large density fluctuations @xcite . in order for radiation mhd simulations to properly account for energy exchange due to turbulent comptonization so that post - processing monte carlo simulations of photon spectra are self - consistent , they must include energy terms second order in velocity and use a moment closure scheme that correctly captures contributions to the radiation stress tensor that are first order in velocity . the appropriate energy equation source terms in lab and fluid frame variables are given by eqs . ( [ integrated1 ] ) and ( [ eq_intergrated2 ] ) , respectively . flux - limited diffusion and the m1 closure scheme are insufficient because they neglect the lowest order contribution to the radiation stress tensor . in this case , instead of exchanging energy with photons , turbulence will eventually cascade down to the gridscale ( or viscous or resistive scale if the code has explicit viscosity or resistivity ) and increase the internal energy of the gas . gas internal energy may then be exchanged with photons through thermal comptonization . the omission of viscous dissipation by radiation therefore does not prevent the eventual transfer of turbulent energy to radiation , but it may have other physical effects which can in turn affect radiation spectra . radiation pressure dominated accretion flows may have bulk velocities that exceed thermal electron velocities . turbulent comptonization , which is the effect of comptonization by bulk , turbulent electron motions on photon spectra , should be significant in such sources . for turbulence with zero divergence , bulk comptonization is equivalent to a radiation viscous shear stress tensor acting on the fluid . the resulting comptonized spectrum can be calculated by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave " temperature , which is a weighted sum over the power present at each scale in the turbulent cascade ( eq . [ twave2 ] ) . bulk comptonization by turbulence with non - zero divergence is due to both pressure work and radiation viscous dissipation . in the limit of optically thin turbulence , pressure work has negligible effect on photon spectra and radiation viscous dissipation alone can be treated as thermal comptonization with a temperature equivalent to the full turbulent power ( eq . [ compressible_thin ] ) . in the limit of extremely optically thick turbulence ( eq . [ eq_extremely_optically_thick ] ) , radiation viscous dissipation is suppressed , and the evolution of local photon spectra can be understood in terms of compression and expansion of the strongly coupled photon and gas fluids . photons upscatter with fractional energy change given by eq . ( [ upscattering_fraction ] ) . in this process a locally thermal photon distribution remains thermal and only changes temperature . the effect of this process on the emergent spectrum of the disc will depend primarily on how effectively photons are able to escape from such regions to the observer . modeling turbulent comptonization will ultimately require detailed analysis of radiation mhd simulations and post - processing monte - carlo simulations . by exploring how photon spectra produced by turbulent comptonization depend on the properties of the turbulence itself , we have laid the groundwork necessary to make sure this effect is both captured and correctly interpreted in these simulations . we thank aristotle socrates for useful discussions . we also thank donald pakey for forwarding errata to the paper by @xcite , and li xue and feng yuan for hosting ob at xiamen university and shanghai astronomical observatory where part of this work was carried out . we gratefully acknowledge support by nasa astrophysics theory program grant nnx13ag61 g , and the international space science institute ( issi ) in bern . bachetti m. et al . , 2013 , apj , 778 , 163 blaes o. m. , hirose s. , krolik j. h. , 2007 , apj , 664 , 1057 blaes o. m. , krolik j. h. , hirose s. , shabaltas n. , 2011 , apj , 733 , 110 blandford r. d. , payne d. g. , 1981a , mnras , 194 , 1033 blandford r. d. , payne d. g. , 1981b , mnras , 194 , 1041 chan k.l . , jones b.j.t . , 1975 , apj , 200 , 454 colpi m. , 1988 , apj , 326 , 223 collinson j. s. , ward m. j. , done c. , landt h. , elvis m. , & mcdowell j. c. , 2015 , mnras , in press [ arxiv:1502.05850 ] davis s. w. , blaes o. m. , hirose s. , krolik j. h. , 2009 , apj , 703 , 569 davis s. w. , blaes o. m. , hubeny i. , turner n. j. , 2005 , apj , 621 , 372 davis s. w. , done c. , blaes o. m. , 2006 , apj , 647 , 525 done c. , davis s. w. , jin c. , blaes o. m. , ward m. , 2012 , mnras , 420 , 1848 gladstone j. c. , roberts t. p. , done c. , 2009 , mnras , 397 , 1836 guan x. , gammie c. f. , 2011 , apj , 728 , 130 haardt f. , maraschi l. , 1991 , apj , 380 , 51 heinemann t. , papaloizou j. c. b. , 2009a , mnras , 397 , 52 heinemann t. , papaloizou j. c. b. , 2009b , mnras , 397 , 64 hirose s. , krolik j. h. , stone j. m. , 2006 , apj , 640 , 901 hirose s. , krolik j. h. , blaes o. m. , 2009 , apj , 691 , 16 hubeny i. , blaes o. m. , krolik j. h. , agol e. , 2001 , apj , 559 , 680 jiang y .- f . , stone j. m. , davis s. w. , 2013 , apj , 778 , 65 jiang y .- f . , stone j. m. , davis s. w. , 2014a , apj , 784 , 169 jiang y .- f . , stone j. m. , davis s. w. , 2014b , apj , 796 , 106 kawashima t. , ohsuga k. , mineshige s. , yoshida t. , heinzeller d. , matsumoto r. , 2012 , apj , 752 , 18 kolehmainen m. , done c. , daz trigo m. , 2011 , mnras , 416 , 311 laor a. , netzer h. , 1989 , mnras , 238 , 897 lightman a. p. , white t. r. , 1988 , apj , 335 , 57 levermore c. d. , 1984 , j. quant . transfer , 31 , 149 magdziarz p. , blaes o. m. , zdziarski a. a. , johnson w. n. , & smith d. a. , 1998 , mnras , 301 , 179 masaki i. , 1971 , pub . japan , 23 , 425 mckinney j. c. , tchekhovskoy a. , sadowski a. , narayan r. , 2014 , mnras , 441 , 3177 mehdipour m. et al . , 2011 , a&a , 534 , a39 mihalas d. , mihalas b. , 1984 , foundations of radiation hydrodynamics ( new york : oxford univ . press ) middleton m. , done c. , ward m. , gierliski m. , schurch n. , 2009 , mnras , 394 , 250 miller k. a. , stone j. m. , 2000 , apj , 534 , 398 niedwiecki a. , zdziarski a. a. , 2006 , mnras , 365 , 606 ohsuga k. , mineshige s. s. , 2011 , apj , 736 , 2 payne d. g. , blandford r. d. , 1981 , mnras , 196 , 781 pozdnyakov l. a. , sobol i. m. , & sunyaev r. a. , 1983 , astrophys . space phys . , 2 , 189 psaltis d. , 2001 , apj , 555 , 786 psaltis d. , & lamb f. k. , 1997 , apj , 488 , 881 ross r. r. , fabian a. c. , 1993 , mnras , 261 , 74 sadowski a. , narayan r. , tchekhovskoy a. , abarca , d. , zhu y. , mckinney , j. , 2015 , mnras , 447 , 49 sadowski a. , narayan r. , tchekhovskoy a. , zhu y. , 2015 , mnras , 429 , 3533 shakura n. i. , sunyaev r. a. , 1973 , a&a , 24 337 shimura t. , takahara f. , 1995 , apj , 445 , 780 socrates a. , 2010 , apj , 719 , 784 socrates a. , davis s. w. , blaes o. m. , 2004 , apj , 601 , 405 stobbart a .- m . , roberts t. p. , wilms j. , 2006 , mnras , 368 , 397 straumann n. , 1976 , helv . acta , 49 , 269 svensson r. , zdziarski a. a. , 1994 , apj , 436 , 599 takeuchi s. , ohsuga k. , mineshige s. , 2013 , pasj , 65 , 88 thomas , l.h . , 1930 , q.j . math . , 1 , 329 thompson c. , 1994 , mnras , 270 , 480 titarchuk l. , mastichiadis a. , kylafis n. , 1997 , apj , 487 , 834 weinberg s. , 1971 , apj , 168 , 175 weinberg s. , 1972 , gravitation and cosmology ( new york : wiley ) yoshida t. , isobe n. , mineshige s. , kubota a. , mizuno t. , saitou k. , 2013 , pasj , 65 , 48 zeldovich ya . b. , illarionov a. f. , sunyaev r. a. , 1972 , sov . jetp , 35 , 643 beginning with eq . ( [ eq_transfer_first_order ] ) , we prove that the steady state occupation number second moment for a divergenceless velocity field of uniform density to first order in velocity is given by eq . ( [ eq_nij ] ) . first we find the solution for a single mode given by @xmath247 for this mode , the transfer equation is @xmath248 where we assume @xmath249 and @xmath250 , which we can check later . then , the transfer equation is @xmath251 first we address the @xmath164-dependence . because this equation is linear , it must be that @xmath252 is a superposition of a sine and a cosine , @xmath253 this gives two coupled integral equations for @xmath254 and @xmath255 , @xmath256 and @xmath257 it seems that both @xmath254 and @xmath255 are proportional to one power of @xmath258 . writing @xmath259 and @xmath260 , and @xmath261 , we then obtain @xmath262 and @xmath263 observing that letting @xmath264 and @xmath265 be odd and even , respectively , is a consistent solution , the @xmath266 integral of @xmath265 vanishes , and the two equations can be combined to give a single equation for @xmath264 , @xmath267 we then solve this equation with a series expansion of odd powers of @xmath268 : @xmath269 gives @xmath270 which is just the expansion of @xmath271 , so that @xmath272 substituting this back into the integral equation gives @xmath273 , which completes the solution . so far then , we have @xmath274\sin \left({2\pi z\over\lambda}\right)\biggr\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath275 . \label{eq : qexact}\ ] ] note that @xmath276 in the optically thin limit , and @xmath277 in the optically thick limit . this solution is consistent with our assumptions and solves eq . ( [ eq_transfer_first_order ] ) to first order in velocity . the second moment is @xmath278 where @xmath279 is given by eq . ( [ eq : analyticsol ] ) . ( [ eq_transfer_first_order ] ) is linear , the solution for an arbitrary , divergenceless velocity field of uniform density is then given by eq . ( [ eq_nij ] ) .
Abstract: | [
"radiation pressure dominated accretion discs around compact objects may have turbulent velocities that greatly exceed the electron thermal velocities within the disc . bulk comptonization by the turbulence may therefore dominate over thermal comptonization in determining the emergent spectrum . bulk comptonization by divergenceless turbulence is due to radiation viscous dissipation only . it can be treated as thermal comptonization by solving the kompaneets equation with an equivalent wave \" temperature , which is a weighted sum over the power present at each scale in the turbulent cascade . bulk comptonization by turbulence with non - zero divergence is due to both pressure work and radiation viscous dissipation . pressure work has negligible effect on photon spectra in the limit of optically thin turbulence , and in this limit radiation viscous dissipation alone can be treated as thermal comptonization with a temperature equivalent to the full turbulent power . in the limit of extremely optically thick turbulence , radiation viscous dissipation is suppressed , and the evolution of local photon spectra can be understood in terms of compression and expansion of the strongly coupled photon and gas fluids . we discuss the consequences of these effects for self - consistently resolving and interpreting turbulent comptonization in spectral calculations in radiation mhd simulations of high luminosity accretion flows . [ firstpage ] accretion , accretion discs radiation mechanisms : non - thermal turbulence galaxies : active x - rays : binaries ."
] | 11,353 | 11,353 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: successful development of the van der waals ( vdw ) heterostructures @xcite based on stacking of two - dimensional ( 2d ) crystals and graphene layers ( gls ) promises a significant progress in infrared ( ir ) and terahertz ( thz ) optoelectronics @xcite . the unique properties of gls provide an opportunity to create new effective photodetectors operating in a wide range of photon energies @xcite . supplementing their design by the band structure engineering using 2d - materials for the barrier layers opens up new prospects in further enhancement of the detector performance . recently , new ir and thz detectors using gl - vdw heterostructures were proposed and evaluated : + ( i ) thz photodetectors based on a double - gl structure , in which the _ intraband _ inter - gl resonant transitions are assisted by ir or thz photons @xcite . the resonant nature of such transitions , in which the electron momentum is conserved @xcite , promotes their elevated probability and , hence , the elevated quantum efficiency . these photodetectors require inclined radiation incidence or a radiation coupler ( grating structure ) ; + ( ii ) thz and ir photodetectors based on the gl - vdw heterostructures using the photon - assisted _ interband _ transitions between the neighboring gls @xcite ; + ( iii ) thz detectors based on the gl - vdw heterostructures operating as hot - electron bolometers using the effect of the emission from gls of the electrons , heated by the thz radiation , due to the _ intraband _ ( drude ) absorptions in gls @xcite . in this paper , we propose and evaluate the ir photodetectors based on the gl - vdw heterostructures with different numbers of the active undoped gls placed between the emitter and collector and separated by the inter - gl barriers ( glips ) . these photodetectors are using the _ interband _ photoexcitation of the electrons in gls from the valence band states to the exited states slightly below or higher than the barrier edge . the photoexcited electrons transfer ( by tunneling through the barrier top or directly ) to the continuum states above the barrier and propagate through the barrier layers . the gl - vdw double - gl photoconductive device with the emitter and collector gls separated by the barrier and using a similar mechanism was recently proposed @xcite fabricated and measured @xcite . however , as we demonstrate below , the insertion of the inner gls , which provides the extra electron photoemission and capture , can lead to a dramatic increase in the glip responsivity . this is due to the photocurrent gain associated with the redistribution of the electric field in the heterostructure and leading to amplification of the electron injection from the emitter . thus the glips in some sense resemble quantum - well infrared photodetectors ( qwips ) typically using iii - v materials and extensively studied , fabricated , and used in applications during two decades @xcite . such a similarity is due to the propagation of the photoexcited electrons over the barriers with their fraction being captured back to the bound states ( in gls and qws , respectively ) . a relatively low capture probability results in the elevated values of the detector responsivity . apart from this , in both glips and qwips the detector detectivity increases with an increasing number of gls and qws ( see , for example , @xcite ) . the main difference between the glips and qwips is in the use of the interband ( in glips ) and intraband ( in qwips ) transitions . this allows eliminating the grating structures required in the n - qwips for radiation coupling . in realistic glips with a relatively large conduction band off - set , the proper electron photoexcitation requires higher photon energies @xmath0 than in qwips . this implies that the glips might generally operate at shorter radiation wavelengths than the qwips . however , modifying the shape of the barriers by doping of the inter - gl layers , one can achieve an effective electron photoescape at fairly low photon energies ( in far - ir range ) . as shown in @xcite , the probability of the electron capture into the gls can be much smaller than that for the qws ( see , for example , @xcite ) since doping of the qws in the qwips leads to the inclusion of the electron - electron scattering mechanism of the capture . smaller capture efficiency is beneficial for a higher detector responsivity @xcite ( see also , @xcite ) . the absence of the gl doping promotes lower electron emission of the thermalized electrons than that in the doped qws and , hence , leads to a smaller dark current . finally , the probability of the electron photoexcitation from the gls is substantially higher than from the qws . these glip features ( the sensitivity to the normally incident radiation and higher photoexcitation and lower capture probabilities ) provide potential advantages of the glips over the qwips and some other photodetectors . the photodetectors based on gl - vdw heterostructures with the tunneling transparent inter - gl barrier layers considered recently @xcite and the glips with relatively thick layers studied in the present paper are analogous . however their operation principles are quite different : the photo - stimulated cascade tunneling between gls in @xcite and the photoexcitation of electrons to the continuum states and propagation in glips . in the latter device , only a small fraction of the propagating electrons can be captured to the gls . such a distinction results in different spectral properties and other detector characteristics . in particular , in the glips under consideration , the photoexcitation probability can be much larger than the probability of the inter - gl photo - stimulated transfer . this is due to the diminished wave function overlap in the neighboring gls @xcite . apart from this , the glips considered here and the hot - electron glips using the bolometric mechanism @xcite are characterized by a rather low capture probability of electrons in the continuum states @xcite . this promotes high values of the detector responsivity @xcite this is in contrast with the detection mechanism associated with the cascade inter - gl photo - stimulated tunneling . the spectral ranges of the photodetectors using the inter - gl photo - stimulated cascade transfer 20 and the electron heating @xcite from one side and the spectral range of the glip operation can be essentially different . one important feature of the glips is that their operation do not require the mutual alignment of the gls . various device models used for studies of the vertical electron transport in qws ( and gls ) introduce the concept of an `` ideal '' emitter ( which provides as many injected electrons as the bulk of the structure `` requires '' ) . in the framework of this concept , the electric - field distributions are assumed to be uniform . a more accurate consideration of the transport phenomena in such structures ( including glips ) in the dark conditions and under irradiation accounts for the self - consistent electric field distributions and the nonideality of the emitter @xcite . this paper uses this more accurate approach . the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 , we describe the possible glip device structures and the glip operation principle . section 3 deals with the device mathematical model . the latter includes the equation for the self - consistent electric potential and the equations governing the electron balance in the gls . in the latter equation , the electron capture into the gls is described phenomenologically invoking the concept of the capture parameter @xcite ( see , also , @xcite . in section 4 , we derive the dark current in the glips as a function of the structural parameters and the applied voltage using the model described in sec . 3 . in section 5 , we calculate the photocurrent ( the variation of the current under the incident radiation ) . the expressions obtained in sections 4 and 5 are then used in sec . 6 for the derivation of the glip detector responsivity , photoelectric gain , and detectivity . in section 6 , we compare the glips with some other ir photodetectors . in the conclusion section , we draw the main results of the paper . in the appendix , we discuss some simplifications of the main model . we consider the glips based on the gl heterostructure which consists of the @xmath1 inner gls clad between the @xmath2 barrier layers with the top and bottom contact gls . the conduction band offsets between the emitter gl and the barrier layer , @xmath3 , as well as between the inner gls and the barrier layers between them , @xmath4 , are smaller than the pertinent offsets in the valence band . generally , the materials of the emitter barrier layer and of other barrier layers can be different , so that @xmath5 . the top and bottom gls are assumed to be doped to provide their sufficiently high lateral conductivity . these extreme gls serve as the tunneling emitter ( injecting electrons into the gl - heterostructure bulk ) and the collector , respectively . the top and bottom gls are supplied with contacts between which the bias voltage @xmath6 is applied . we consider the gl heterostructures with either the n - type or p - type doping of both the emitter and collector gls and undoped inner gls and the barrier layers , i.e. , the heterostructures with different types of the emitter and collector can also be treated in the framework of our model . the applied voltage in such heterostructures , stimulates the electron tunneling through the barriers with triangular tops . the thermalized electrons tunneling from the gls and the electrons excited by the incident ir radiation propagate over the barriers . figures 1(a ) and 1(b ) show schematically the glips based on gl - vdw heterostructures considered in @xcite and their band diagrams . figure 1(c ) corresponds to the glips with the bound - to - continuum tunneling and photon - assisted transitions considered in the present work . figure 2 shows the band diagrams of the glip ( with the structure of figure 1(c ) ) using the interband intra - gl photoexcitation with the sequential tunneling of the photoexcited electrons ( a ) in dark conditions and ( b ) under the strong ir irradiation at the sufficiently high bias voltage ( @xmath7 , where @xmath8 is the electron charge and @xmath9 is the temperature in the energy units ) . the applied voltage induces the extra carriers of the opposite signs and changes the electron fermi energies in the emitter and collector gls . the electron fermi energies , @xmath10 and @xmath11 , in these gls ( at their equal doping ) are different : @xmath12 and @xmath13 here @xmath14 is the fermi energy in the extreme gls at their donor ( upper sign for the n - type contact gls ) or acceptor ( for the p - type contact gls ) density equal to @xmath15 , @xmath16 is the planck constant , @xmath17 cm / s is the electron and hole velocity in gls , and @xmath18 and @xmath19 . hence , the bias voltage can to some extent affect the emitter injection characteristics decreasing the electron activation energy in the emitter @xmath20 ( see the appendix ) . to enhance the electron collection by the collector , the bottom gl can be replaced by a doped multiple - gl or by a thick wider band - gap doped collector region . in principle , the glips with the n - type emitters can be supplied with p - type collectors and vice versa . the operation of the glips with the device structure and the band diagrams corresponding to figures 1(c ) and 2 considered below is associated with the following . the incoming ir photons generate the electron - hole pairs ( due to the photon absorption and the vertical interband transitions ) in each gl . depending on the ratio @xmath21 $ ] , the photogenerated electrons appear in the continuum states above the barriers directly ( if @xmath22 ) or via the intermediate excited state with the energy @xmath23 with respect to the dirac point following the electron tunneling through the triangular barrier top @xcite [ see figure 2(b ) ] . upon the photoexcitation to the states over the barriers , the electrons propagate toward the collector . during the electron transport over the barrier , a fraction of the propagating electrons is captured into the gls . since we consider devices with the barriers , in which the conduction band off - set @xmath4 and the quantity @xmath24 are smaller than the valence band off - set , the escape of the photogenerated holes from the gls can be neglected . the glip barriers in the devices under consideration can be made of the van der waals structures with the inse , ws@xmath25 , and other barrier layer materials @xcite . the poisson equation governing the electric potential distribution @xmath26 in the direction perpendicular to the gl plane ( the @xmath27direction ) and the equations governing the electron balance in each gl at the steady - state irradiation are presented in the following form : @xmath28 @xmath29 here @xmath30 and @xmath31 are the 2d densities of electrons and holes in the inner gls with the index @xmath32 ( @xmath33 and @xmath34 corresponding to the emitter and collector gls , respectively ) , @xmath35 is the density of the electron current across gls , @xmath36 is the capture efficiency for the electrons crossing the @xmath37gl @xcite , @xmath38 and @xmath39 are the rates of the tunneling emission of the thermalized electrons and the tunneling emission of the electrons photoexcited ( photogenerated ) from the gl valence band in the @xmath37th gl , @xmath40 is the probability of the interband photon absorption in gls , ( @xmath41 is the fine structure constant , where @xmath42 is the speed of light in vacuum and @xmath43 is the barrier material refraction index ) , @xmath44 is the probability of the photoexcited electrons tunneling escape from the @xmath37th gl to the continuum states above the inter - gl barriers , @xmath45 is the ir radiation intensity ( photon flux inside the heterostructure ) , @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the thickness of the inter - gl barrier layer and its dielectric constant , respectively , and @xmath48 is the dirac delta function ( which reflects narrow localization of the electron and hole charges in the gls ) , in contrast to qwips using the intraband transitions , the photoexcitation rate in glips is virtually independent of @xmath49 . both thermalized electron tunneling rate @xmath38 and the escape probability of the photoexcited electrons @xmath44 from the @xmath50-th gl ( and , hence , the photoemission rate ) can markedly , namely , exponentially increase with the electric field in the barrier under this gl @xmath51 . the escape probability of the photoexcited electrons is also determined by the effective energy of the photoexcited electron @xmath52 . although the parameter @xmath36 characterizing the capture into the @xmath50-th gl depends , to some extent , on the local electric field , this dependence is much weaker than the field - dependence of the tunneling from the gls . in reality , @xmath36 is most likely to be a functional of the electric - field spatial distribution @xcite . this is particularly true if the energy relaxation length @xmath53 is larger or comparable with the heterostructure thickness @xmath54 . the dependence @xmath55 versus @xmath6 is smoothly decreasing with @xmath6 ( see , the previous calculations @xcite ) . hence , in the simplest approach can be presented as a function of the average field ( in fact , of the bias voltage ) as assumed in the following . in line with this , we set @xmath55 , where @xmath56 is a function of @xmath6 . the tunneling rates of the thermalized and photoexcited electrons ( neglecting the intraband drude absorption in the emitter gl due to relatively high energies of ir photons ) can be presented as @xmath57 @xmath58 here @xmath59 is the field characterizing the tunneling through the triangular barrier top @xcite ( see also @xcite ) , @xmath60 is the electron mass in the barrier material , @xmath61 is the maximum current density which can be extracted from an _ undoped _ gl ( @xmath62 ) at a given temperature , @xmath63 is the try - to - escape time , @xmath64 is the characteristic time of the photoexcited electrons energy relaxation , and @xmath65 $ ] if @xmath66 and @xmath67 if @xmath68 . the factor @xmath69 accounts for the difference in the tunneling transparency of the thermalized and photoexcited ( with the energy @xmath24 ) electrons . assuming @xmath70 ev and @xmath71 ( @xmath72 is the free electron mass ) , we obtain @xmath73 v/@xmath74 m . at @xmath75 , the right - hand side of equation ( 3 ) corresponds to @xmath76 ( i.e. , the majority of the photogenerated electrons leaves the gls . in the opposite case @xmath77 , @xmath78 . the energy relaxation of photoexcited electrons in the gl - structures under consideration can be associated with ( i ) the emission of optical phonons with the transition of an electron to a low energy state in the gl conduction band ( at @xmath79 , where @xmath80 ev is the optical phonon energy ) , ( ii ) the electron recombination assisted by the emission of optical phonon ( when @xmath81 , and ( iii ) the collisions of the photoexcited electrons with the thermal electrons and holes ( in a wide range of ir photon energies @xmath0 . according to the above , one can set @xmath82 here @xmath83 is the time of spontaneous optical phonon emission in gls and @xmath84 is the time of the photoexcited electrons relaxation on the thermalized electrons ( and holes ) in the gls . the latter is much shorter in both undoped and doped gls ( see , for example , @xcite ) . in the following we assume that @xmath85 considering only the mechanism ( iii ) . since @xmath84 depends on the electron density , we distinguish @xmath86 in the emitter gl and @xmath64 in the inner gls . as demonstrated in the appendix , @xmath87 . although the ratio @xmath88 can be estimated for the heterostructures with different barrier layers , we will mainly considered is as a phenomenological parameter . in equation ( 3 ) , we have neglected the thermionic emission from the gls . the pertinent contribution is proportional to the factor @xmath89 . the latter is assumed to be small compared with the factor @xmath90 in equation ( 3 ) at the actual values of the electric field in the barriers and @xmath91 k and lower . equation ( 1 ) is supplemented by the following boundary conditions : @xmath92 the current density @xmath35 is equal to the density of the current injected from the emitter gl through a pertinent barrier . considering both the injection of the thermalized electrons from the doped emitter gl and the escape of the electrons photoexcited in this gl , one can use the following formula relating this current density and the electric field @xmath93 : @xmath94 here @xmath95 $ ] is the work function from the emitter to the barrier layer normalized by the conduction band offset . the factor @xmath96 is associated with an increase of the thermalized electron density by the electric field in the emitter barrier layer @xmath93 in the glips with the -type emitter layer ( see the appendix ) . one needs to stress that the value of @xmath97 in the glips with the emitter gl of p - type is larger whereas @xmath98 is smaller ( @xmath99 ) then those for the glips with the n - type emitter gl ( due to different signs of the fermi energy counted with respect to the dirac point ) . versus @xmath100 of glips with ( a)different @xmath1 for @xmath70 ev and @xmath101 , ( b)different @xmath1 for @xmath70 ev and @xmath102 , , and ( c ) different @xmath4 at @xmath103 and @xmath102 . , width=264 ] in the absence of irradiation ( @xmath104 ) , the current across the glip constitutes the dark current , so that @xmath105 . as follows from equations ( 2 ) , ( 3 ) , and ( 7),the electric fields in the barriers are the following functions of the dark current density : @xmath106 in the near emitter barrier ( @xmath107 ) , and @xmath108 in other barriers ( @xmath109 ) . taking into account conditions ( 6 ) and using equations ( 8) and ( 9 ) , we obtain @xmath110 equation ( 10 ) yields the following expression for the dark current - voltage characteristics @xmath111 \biggr\},\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq11 ] where @xmath112 . from equation ( 11 ) we obtain @xmath113.\ ] ] [ eq12 ] here the quantity @xmath114\ ] ] changes from @xmath115 if @xmath116 to @xmath117 at @xmath118 . hence @xmath119 is rather smooth function of @xmath6 . consequently , at moderate voltages @xmath116 , corresponding to the most practically interesting conditions when the dark current is small , @xmath120\nonumber\\ \simeq\frac{\gamma^{3/2}v}{(\gamma^{3/2 } + n)d } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq14 ] @xmath121\nonumber\\ \simeq \frac{v}{(\gamma^{3/2 } + n)d}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq15 ] it is instructive that , according to equation ( 12 ) , @xmath122 being proportional to @xmath123 strongly increases with decreasing capture efficiency @xmath56 , particularly if @xmath124 ( i.e. , at @xmath125 . this implies that at sufficiently small @xmath56 when @xmath126 , the net dark current can exceed the current of the tunneling thermalized electrons ( which is approximately proportional to the number of inner gls @xmath1 ) , i.e. , the main component of the dark current is associated with the current injected from the emitter controlled by the tunneling from the internal gls being , certainly , smaller than @xmath127 . another feature of the glip current - voltage characteristics and the electric - field spatial distributions given by equations ( 12 ) - ( 14 ) is their weak dependence on the parameters of the emitters @xmath97 and @xmath98 ( at @xmath128 and particularly when @xmath129 ) . the latter says that if @xmath124 , the tunneling emitter under consideration can be considered as an ideal . one needs to stress that due to a decreasing voltage dependence of the capture efficiency @xmath56 , this dependence provides an increasing pre - exponential extra factor in the dark current - voltage relation given by equation ( 12 ) and enhances its steepness . considering the equality of the electric fields in all layers except the emitter barrier layer [ see equations ( 8) and ( 9 ) ] and using equations ( 13 ) , the charge density of the gl adjacent to the emitter gl @xmath130 is given by @xmath131 depending on the emitter gl doping ( n- or p - type ) ) , which determines @xmath97 ( @xmath132 and and @xmath133 in the n- and p - type emitter gl , respectively ) , the charge density @xmath134 can be both negative ( i.e. , the electron density exceeds the hole density ) and positive ( the hole density is larger than the electron density ) , whereas the charge densities of other inner gls @xmath135 ( @xmath136 ) are equal to zero . the case @xmath132 when @xmath137 and @xmath138 , corresponds to the potential in the glip heterostructure profile schematically shown in figure 2(a ) . figure 3 shows examples of the normalized dark current density @xmath139 versus the normalized voltage @xmath100 calculated using equation ( 11 ) for the glips with @xmath140 ev and different number of the inner gls @xmath1 for different parameters @xmath4 and @xmath56 . the comparison of the plots in figures 3(a ) and 3(b ) confirms a weak dependence of the dark current on the number of gls @xmath1 and a pronounced rise of the dark current with decreasing capture efficiency @xmath56 ( particularly at lower normalized voltages @xmath141 ) . higher dark currents at smaller band - offsets @xmath4 are naturally attributed to tunneling emission strengthening from all the gls with decreasing of the tunneling barrier height @xmath4 . as follows from equation ( 12 ) and figure 3 , @xmath122 drastically decreases with decreasing voltage . however , at small voltages , @xmath142 can be so small that the tunneling exponent @xmath143 becomes smaller than the thermionic exponent @xmath144 @xcite . this implies that at such voltages , the tunneling injection from the emitter gl gives way to the thermionic emission . this determines the minimal value of @xmath6 , at which equations ( 11 ) - ( 13 ) are still valid : @xmath145 . at @xmath146 , @xmath147 . this implies that the dependences shown in figure 3 are correct up to small values of @xmath141 ( at @xmath148 for @xmath149 ev ) we limit our consideration of the glip operation primarily by the situations when the incident ir radiation is relatively weak . in the case of irradiation , equations ( 9 ) and ( 10 ) should be replaced by more general equations accounting for the tunneling emission of both the thermalized and photoexcited electrons . since the photoexcitation leads to the variations of the electric fields in the barrier layers , equation ( 10 ) in this situation should be replaced by the following equation which governs the photocurrent density @xmath150 : @xmath151}\nonumber\\ + \sum_{n = 1}^{n}\frac{1}{\ln [ j_{0}/(j_{dark}p + j_{photo}p - e\beta\,i\theta_n)]},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath44 is defined by equation ( 4 ) and @xmath122 is governed by equation ( 10 ) leading to equation ( 11 ) and its consequences . at relatively low ir radiation intensities , such as @xmath152 , the electron photoexcitation can be treated as a perturbation . considering this , into the quantities @xmath153 and @xmath44 in equation ( 17 ) on can insert the unperturbed values of the electric fields , namely , @xmath154 and @xmath155 . as a result , for the photocurrent density @xmath156 from equation ( 17 ) we obtain @xmath157}{p\beta}\biggr ] } { \biggl ( \displaystyle\frac{\theta_{dark}^2}{\gamma^{3/2 } } + n\biggr)}\nonumber\\ \times \frac{1}{1 + \displaystyle\frac{\tau_{esc}}{\tau_{relax } } \exp\biggl ( \frac{\eta^{3/2}\,e_{tunn}}{e_b^{(dark)}}\biggr)}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq18 ] here @xmath158 characterizes the glip in dark . according to equations ( 8) and ( 9 ) , @xmath159 is expressed via the dark current density and , invoking equation ( 12 ) , via the voltage : @xmath160 ^ 2\nonumber\\ = \gamma^3\biggl[1 + \frac{v\,\ln(1/kp)}{(\gamma^{3/2 } + n)de_{tunn}}\biggr]^2.\end{aligned}\ ] ] if @xmath161 or at moderated voltages @xmath162 , one can put in equation ( 18 ) @xmath163 , so that one obtains @xmath164}{p\beta}\biggr]}{1 + \displaystyle\frac{\tau_{esc}}{\tau_{relax}}\exp\biggl [ \frac{\eta^{3/2}(\gamma^{3/2 } + n ) \,de_{tunn}}{v}\biggr]}\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq20 ] the appearance of @xmath165 in equation ( 20 ) is associated with the contribution of the photoexcitation from the emitter gl . since normally @xmath166 , for the glips with not too large gls ( @xmath167 ) , equation ( 20 ) can be simplified and presented in the following form : @xmath168 } .\ ] ] [ eq21 ] it is worth noting that the photocurrent density given by equations ( 18 ) , ( 20 ) , and ( 21 ) exceeds the current created by the electrons photoexcited from the emitter gl by a factor @xmath169 , which can be very large . this is because the photoemission from the inner gls stimulates a strong injection of the thermalized electrons from the emitter gls resulting in a substantial amplification of the photocurrent . taking into account equation ( 20 ) , one can find small variations of the electric fields caused by the irradiation in all barrier layers @xmath170 as functions of the bias voltage @xmath6 and the radiation intensity @xmath45 . in particular , the electric field in the emitter barrier layer @xmath171 ( as under the dark conditions ) . however , due to the attenuation of the ir radiation as its propagates across the glip structure , the electric - fields in the consequent gls slightly increase : @xmath172 ( such a change is proportional to the radiation intensity @xmath45 , which is weak in the case under consideration ) . the photoexcitation leads to the variations of the electric fields in the barrier layers : an increase in @xmath173 and in a decrease in @xmath174 . at sufficiently strong irradiation , the electric field in the emitter barrier @xmath173 can become larger than the electric field in the bulk @xmath174 . in this case , the gl adjacent to the emitter gl is charged positively , and the potential profile becomes similar to that shown schematically in figure 2(b ) . an high radiation intensities , the electric field in the heterostructure bulk drops , so that the potential drop across the emitter layer tends to the applied voltage @xmath6 . this implies that @xmath173 tends to @xmath175 . consequently , the net current density tend to a value which roughly can be estimated as @xmath176^{-1}$ ] . however at very high radiation intensities , the glip operation might , in particular , be complicated by the following effects : the saturation of the interband absorption @xcite , the influence of elevated density of the photoexcited electrons on their escape @xcite , and the influence of the space - charge of the electrons propagating across the barrier layers on the electric - field distributions . these effects are beyond of our model framework . and different @xmath4 and ( b ) @xmath177 ev and different @xmath1 at @xmath178 ( @xmath179 , and @xmath180),width=264 ] at different normalized voltages @xmath141 and ( b ) for different ratios @xmath88 at @xmath178 ( @xmath70 ev , @xmath181 , and @xmath102).,width=264 ] the detector responsivity @xmath182 is usually defined as @xmath183 here @xmath184 is the device area , @xmath185 is the incident ir radiation power , and @xmath186 is the incident ir radiation flux ( hence , @xmath187 , where @xmath188 is the coefficient of the ir radiation reflection from the glip top . considering this and using equation ( 21 ) , we arrive at the following formula for the glip responsivity : @xmath189 } .\ ] ] here @xmath190 , where @xmath191 is the characteristic responsivity and the factor @xmath192 is determined by the conditions of reflection of the incident ir radiation from the glip top interface ( the presence or absence of an anti - reflection coating ) and its propagation across the heterostructure . the reflection from the substrate can also affect the value of @xmath193 . in the simplest case , the reflection factor @xmath193 can be expressed via @xmath43 : @xmath194 . the deviation of the nominator in equation ( 23 ) from unity reflects the dependence of the responsivity on the emitter parameter @xmath165 . this deviation practically vanishes at large @xmath1 and @xmath128 . in the latter limit , the emitter can be considered as an ideal ( i.e. , providing the necessary injection to compensate the photoexcitation from the inner gls @xcite ) , and the glip responsivity is practically independent of @xmath1 if the average electric field @xmath195 is fixed . since in glips the coefficient @xmath196 is relatively large and the capture efficiency @xmath56 is relatively small ( @xmath197 @xcite ) compered to the standard heterostructures , the characteristic responsivity @xmath198 can be fairly large . indeed , setting @xmath199 ev and @xmath101 , we obtain @xmath200 a / w figures 4 and 5 show the responsivity , @xmath201 ( normalized by the reflection factor @xmath193 ) spectral characteristics of the glips with different band offsets @xmath4 , number of the barrier layers @xmath1 , normalized voltages @xmath100 , capture efficiency @xmath56 , and @xmath88 . in these and the next figure it is assumed that the electron fermi energy in the emitter gl @xmath140 ev . figure 6 shows the responsivity @xmath201 as a function of the normalized voltage calculated for the glips with different @xmath4 . among the main features of the responsivity spectral dependence , the following should be pointed out : ( a ) weak dependence of the spectral characteristics on thee number of the gls @xmath1 ; ( b ) an increase in the responsivity with decreasing capture efficiency @xmath56 ; ( c ) a marked shift of the responsivity maximum toward larger photon energies with increasing the band - offset @xmath4 , normalized voltage @xmath141 , and relative escape time @xmath88 ; ( d ) the responsivity maxima correspond to the photon energies markedly smaller than @xmath202 , so that the glips can exhibit relatively high response at @xmath203 . a fairly pronounced dependence of @xmath201 on @xmath141 ( i.e. , the applied voltage ) implies the possibility of an effective voltage control it is important to stress that at small values of the capture parameter @xmath56 , the photocurrent can markedly exceed the current created solely by the electrons photoemitted from the gls due to the effect of photoelectric gain , which implies that the electron photoemission stimulates much stronger tunneling emission from the emitter . taking into account that the net photoemission rate from all gls is equal to @xmath204 } , \ ] ] the photocurrent density ( 21 ) ) can be presented as @xmath205 where @xmath206 is the photoelectric gain . due to small values of @xmath56 in glips , @xmath207 even at fairly large ( but realistic ) @xmath1 . the dark current limited detector detectivity , @xmath208 , and its normalized version @xmath209 are expressed via the responsivity and the dark current density as ( for example , @xcite ) : @xmath210 here for @xmath122 , @xmath201 , and @xmath211 one can use equations ( 12 ) , ( 23 ) , and ( 25 ) , respectively . considering this , we find ( at @xmath212 ) @xmath213}{1 + \displaystyle\frac{\tau_{esc}}{\tau_{relax}}\exp\biggl ( \frac{n\eta^{3/2}de_{tunn}}{v}\biggr ) } \label{eq29}\end{aligned}\ ] ] here @xmath214[eq30 ] equation ( 29 ) immediately shows that the glip detectivity increases with the increasing number of the inner gls @xmath1 , while the responsivity ( see equation ( 23 ) ) is a weak funcion of @xmath1 . indeed , at large @xmath1 , @xmath215 , but @xmath201 is virtually independent of @xmath1 . some deviation from the latter is associated with the emitter effect ( characterized by @xmath165 ) . the spectral dependence of @xmath216 repeats that of @xmath201 ( see figures 4 and 5 ) . the detectivity @xmath216 markedly increases with the decreasing voltage @xmath6 . this is owing to the pertinent drop of the dark current . however , since at small values of @xmath6 , the tunneling current from the emitter gl can become smaller than the thermionic current , substituting @xmath217 ( see above ) to equation ( 30 ) , we obtain the following estimate for the maximum of @xmath216 : @xmath218}.\ ] ] [ eq31 ] at @xmath219 , the parameter @xmath69 can be small . in this case , equation ( 31 ) yields @xmath220 [ eq32 ] and differerent @xmath4 for @xmath221ev , @xmath179 , and @xmath180 . , width=264 ] the comparison of glips and qwips ( based , in particular , on ingaas / algaas and other heterostructures with the n - type qws ) intended for the operation in mid- and near ir ranges , shows that glips can exhibit the following advantages : ( i ) sensitivity to normally incident radiation ( no radiations coupling structures are needed ; ( ii ) higher probability of the photo - assisted escape from the gl bound states to the continuum states above the barriers due to a relatively large universal constant @xmath222 . ( compare with @xmath223 for a gaas qw with the typical electron density @xmath224 @xmath225 @xcite ) ; smaller capture efficiency of the electrons propagating over the barriers the into the gls ( up to the orders of magnitude - compare the data from @xcite and @xcite ) . these advantages imply that the glip responsivity can exceed that of qwips . since the modulation bandwidths of both glip and qwips is determined by the vertical electron transport across the barrier layers , one might assume that these bandwidths are can close to each other . as follows from equation ( 21 ) and equation ( 4 ) from @xcite , the responsivity , @xmath201 , of a glip and the responsivity , @xmath226 of a lateral gl - photodiode ( glpd ) with a lateral p - i - n junction , are ( at @xmath75 ) approximately equal to @xmath227 respectively . hence , @xmath228 since , the capture efficiency @xmath56 can be very small , the above ratio can exceed unity . since the electron transit time in the glips ( which are vertical transport devices ) ) can be shorter than in the glpds ( with the lateral transport ) , the glips can surpass the glpds in speed . in the double - gl glips @xcite and the utc - pds based on inas / inp heterostructures @xcite , the electrons photoexcited in the emitter transfer ( via the tunneling through the triangular barrier ) to the undoped drift region . in contrast to the double - gl glips and utc - pds , in which the responsivity is determined by the escape of the electrons photogenerated in the emitter layer , the glips can exhibit the effect of amplification of the current produced the electrons photoexcited from the inner gls . this effect in the glips works at a weak electron capture into the inner gls , i.e. , if @xmath229 , but at moderate modulation frequencies . the glip , double - gl glip , and utc - pd response at relatively high modulation frequency is affected by the electron transit across this region . one can assume that the electron transit time in utc - pds can be somewhat shorter than in the glips because of better transport properties of the drift region materials in the former devices . however , the delay in the escape of the photoexcited electrons from the emitter limited by their diffusion ( or in the best case , by the drift in the built - in electric field ) across the heavily doped emitter layer , can be the main factor limiting the utc - pd modulation bandwidths . this implies that the glips ( without such a delay in the emitter gl ) can exhibit a high - speed performance close to that of the utc - pds and , hence , compete with the latter . similar ir photodetectors can be based on the hgcdte heterostructures with multiple zero - gap qws , although the specifics of these heterostructures requires a separate study . we proposed the glips - infrared photodetectors based on vdw hetereostructures with gls serving as the emitter , collector and absorbing layers . the glips exploit the interband electron transitions between the valence band in the gls and the continuum states in the conduction band of the barrier materials . the glips should be able to operate in different ranges of the ir spectrum depending on the values of the conduction band offset between the gl and the barrier layer material . we showed that due to small capture probability of the excited electrons into the gls together with a relatively strong interband photon absorption , the glips can exhibit elevated photoelectric gain and responsivity . an increase in the number of gls in the glip heterostructure can provide relatively high values of the glip detectivity . among other glip advantages are highly conducting transparent contact gl layer , sensitivity to normally incident radiation and high speed operation . the glips , which add the diversity to the ir and thz detector technology , can surpass other already realized and newly proposed photodetectors for the imaging and optical communication systems and thz photomixers . the tunneling rates of the thermalized and photoexcited electrons depends on the electric field , @xmath230 , at the gl . in equation ( 4 ) we set the escape frequency equal to @xmath231 and @xmath232 for the thermalized and photoexcited electrons respectively . thus , it was assumed that @xmath233 is an exponential function of @xmath234 . for more accurate calculations of the escape frequency @xmath233 as a function of the quantity @xmath69 we found the schrodinger equation solutions with the complex energy for gls embedded in a dielectric in the transverse electric field . the gl potential was modeled by a one - dimensional delta - well @xcite : @xmath235 , where @xmath236 is the dirac delta - function and @xmath237 is the electron wave function localization length . this quantity depends on the in - plane electron momentum due to the mismatch of dispersion laws in the gl and the barrier layer @xcite . figure 7 shows the @xmath233 vs @xmath69 dependences calculated for different values of electric field @xmath230 using the above approach . the related dependences calculated using the above simplified formula are also shown by dashed lines for the material parameters corresponding to ws@xmath25 barrier layers ( @xmath70 ev , @xmath71 , and @xmath238 v/@xmath74 m ) . at small @xmath69 the fit is not so ideal but can be considered as reasonable somewhat affecting the shape of the glip spectral characteristics only at @xmath219 . the inverse relaxation time assumed to be primarily determined by the electron - electron scattering , so @xmath239 as functions of @xmath69 in the undoped gls ( @xmath62 ) and doped emitter gl ( @xmath240 mev ) at @xmath241 and @xmath91 k are gls shown in figure 7 by the dotted lines . these curves were obtained by calculating the imaginary part of the electron rpa self - energy @xcite . as follows from figure 7 , in the most interesting actual range of @xmath242 the order - of magnitude estimates yields @xmath243 s and @xmath244 . the latter characteristic times are markedly smaller that the characteristic time of the spontaneous emission of optical phonons @xmath83 for both the intraband and interband electron transitions . thus , for glips with ws@xmath25 barriers one can arrive at the following rough estimate : @xmath245 . as a function of the normalized photon energy @xmath69 for different electric fields @xmath230 calculated using a rigorous model ( solid lines ) and a simplified model with constant pre - exponential factor ( dashed lines ) . the dotted lines correspond to the inverse relaxation time @xmath246 associated with the scattering on the thermalized electrons ( and holes ) for the undoped and doped gls ( @xmath62 mev and ( @xmath240 mev , respectively ) at @xmath91 k. , width=283 ] neglecting above the local dependence of the capture parameter , we found that the electric field distribution across the device structure includes a low - field domain ( in the near emitter barrier ) with @xmath247 and a high = field domain occupying the rest of the structure ( bulk ) where @xmath248 ( see equations ( 8) and ( 9 ) . however , if @xmath36 depends on @xmath249 , the near emitter domain might be extended to a few barriers @xcite . it is worth mention that if the capture efficiency @xmath36 is a sufficiently strong function of @xmath249 , the monotonic electric - field spatial distributions can become unstable against the perturbation with the length @xmath250 @xcite . such an instability can lead to quasi - chaotic spatio - temporal electric field variations , which eventually result in the formation of stable quasi - periodic electric - field distributions @xcite . the electric field in the emitter barrier induces extra electrons in the emitter gl and , hence , leads to an enhancement in the electron fermi level or the hole fermi level if this gl is donor or acceptor doped , respectively . as a result , the parameter @xmath165 can markedly depend on @xmath173 ( decreasing with increasing @xmath173 ) somewhat affecting the current - voltage characteristics . considering this effect , we find @xmath251 @xmath252 . hence @xmath253^{3/2}.\ ] ] setting @xmath254 ev and @xmath241 , one obtains @xmath255 v/@xmath74 m . if @xmath256 , @xmath257 . in this case , @xmath258 , where @xmath259 > 1.\end{aligned}\ ] ] [ eq37 ] at @xmath260ev , @xmath261 ev , @xmath262 , and @xmath241 one obtains @xmath263 . thus , at not too large voltages and emitter electric fields , the injection ( from the contact ) of the extra electrons in the emitter gl does not affect the shape of the current - voltage characteristics , but leads to a replacement of the quantity @xmath61 by @xmath264 . if the emitter barrier layer has the thickness @xmath265 different from @xmath46 , equation ( 6 ) should be modified . the ir irradiation can somewhat reinforce the thermionic electron emission from the emitter gl due to heating high - density 2d electron plasma in the doped emitter gl ( see @xcite ; this effect was disregarded in section 5 ) . the electron photoexcitation can lead to a heating of the carriers in the emitter gl slightly modifying the injection properties of the emitter . however , in the regimes considered above , the emitter properties weakly affect the glip characteristics , particularly , for the multiple gl devices ( @xmath266 ) . this mechanism as well as the photoemission from the emitter gl can be crucial for the double - gl glips without the inner gls ( i.e. , with n=0 ) @xcite . the operation principle of the double - gl glips is similar to that used in the uni - travelling - carrier photodiodes ( utc - pds ) @xcite . but such glips , being potentially interesting , do not exhibit the effect of photoelectric gain , which can substantially increase the responsivity . the bolometric mechanism associated with the electron heating due to the drude absorption can be efficient at the relatively low radiation frequencies in the gl devices with all of the gls doped @xcite ( not considered here ) . the evaluation of the glip dynamic response to transient ir radiation requires a substantial generalization of our model . it will be done elsewhere . here we refrain to a qualitative reasoning . the dynamic operation of the glips under consideration is determined by following characteristic times : the electron transit time across the glip @xmath267 , the time of the gls charging by the injected current due to the electron capture @xmath268 and the time of emptying of the gls by the electron photoexcitation from the gls @xmath269 . the transit time can be estimated as @xmath270 , where @xmath271 is the average electron velocity across the barrier layers . the latter can be set to be equal to the electron saturation velocity @xmath272 . the characteristic times @xmath268 and @xmath269 decrease with an increasing dc component of the incident ir radiation intensity . at small capture parameters , even at fairly strong irradiation , @xmath273 . at the modulation frequencies of the incident ir radiation @xmath274 , the glip responsivity is well described by the above formulas [ e.g. , by equation ( 28 ) ] . in this modulation frequency range , the responsivity is about @xmath275 and virtually independent of the number of the gls @xmath1 . however , in the range @xmath276 , the electron capture does not manage to provide the gl recharging . as a result , the electric field @xmath173 and the current injected from the emitter gl do not follow the temporal variations of the ir radiation . this implies that the mechanism of the photoelectric gain is effectively switch - off . this leads to smaller values of the responsivity , which dependence on both @xmath56 and @xmath1 is rather complex . at higher modulation frequencies @xmath277 , the responsivity markedly drops with increasing frequency @xmath278 . the electron transit time @xmath267 limits the glip modulation bandwidths . setting @xmath279 cm / s and @xmath280 nm , we obtain @xmath281 thz . the effect of the structural parameters on the dependences of the responsivity of single- and multiple - qwips on the radiation modulation frequency was studied previously @xcite . however , the results of these studies can not be directly applied to glips . recent experimental studies of the high - speed operation of the photodetectors based on double - gl vdw heterostructures with the interband photoexcitation @xcite appears to be fairly promising . the authors grateful to v aleshkin , a dubinov and a satou for useful discussion and to n ryabova and s boubanga - tombet for assistance . the work at riec and uoa was supported by the japan society for promotion of science ( kakenhi grants no.23000008 and no.16h06361 ) . v r , d s and v l acknowledge the support by the russian scientific foundation ( grants no.14 - 29 - 00277 and no.16 - 19 - 10557 ) and the ministry of education and science of the russian federation ( grant no.16.19.2014/k ) . the work at rpi was supported by the us army research laboratory cooperative research agreement . xia , f. et al . 2009 photocurrent imaging and efficient photon detection in a graphene transistor . _ nano lett . _ * 9 * 1039 mueller t , xia f n a and avouris p 2010 graphene photodetectors for high speed optical communications _ nat . _ 4297 301 song j c w , rudner m s , marcus c m and levitov l s 2011 hot carrier transport and photocurrent response in graphene _ nano lett . _ * 11 * 4688 ryzhii v , ryzhii m , mitin v and otsuji t 2010 terahertz and infrared photodetection using p - i - n multiple - graphene - layer structures _ j.appl.phys_*107 * 054512 liu c h , chang y - c , norris t b and zhong z 2014 graphene photodetectors with ultra broadband and highresponsivity at room temperature _ nat.nanotechnol . _ 9273 kim c o , kim s , shin d h , kang s s , kim j m , jang c w , joo s s , lee j s , kim j h , choi s .- h and hwang e 2014 high photoresponsivity in an all - graphene p - n vertical junction photodetector _ nat.commun . _ * 5 * 53249 ryzhii v , ryabova n , ryzhii m , baryshnikov n v , karasik v e , mitin v and otsuji t 2012 terahertz and infrared photodetectors based on multiple graphene layer and nanoribbon structures _ _ * 20 * 15 tredicucci a and vitielo m s 20014 device concepts for graphene - based terahertz photonics _ ieee j. sel quantum electron . _ * 20 * 8500109 ryzhii v , otsuji t , aleshkin v ya , dubinov a a , ryzhii m , mitin v and shur m s , 2014 voltage - tunable terahertz and infrared photodetectors based on double - graphene - layer structures _ appl . * 104 * 163505 britnell l et al . 2012 electron tunneling through ultrathin boron nitride crystalline barriers _ nano lett . _ * 12 * 1707 georgiou t et al 2013 vertical field - effect transistor based on graphene - ws@xmath25 heterostructures for flexible and transparent electronics _ nat . nanotechnol . _ * 7 * 100 britnell l , gorbachev r v , geim a k , ponomarenko l a , mishchenko a , greenaway m t , fromhold t m , novoselov k s and eaves l 2013 resonant tunneling and negative differential conductance in graphene transistors _ nat . commun . _ * 4 * 1794 feenstra r m , jena d and gu g 2012 single - particle tunneling in doped graphene - insulator - graphene junctions _ j. appl _ * 111 * 043711 vasko f t 2013 resonant and nondissipative tunneling in independently contacted graphene structures _ phys . rev.b _ * 87 * 075424 ryzhii v , otsuji t , ryzhii m , aleshkin v ya , dubinov a a , svintsov d , mitin v and shur m s 2015 graphene vertical cascade interband terahertz and infrared photodetector _ 2d materials _ * 2 * 025002 ryzhii v , satou a , otsuji t , ryzhii m , aleshkin v ya , dubinov a a , v. mitin v and shur m s 2014 graphene vertical hot electron terahertz detectors _ j appl . * 116 * 114504 ryzhii v , ryzhii m , v. mitin v , shur m s , satou a and t. otsuji t 2013 terahertz photomixing using plasma resonances in double - graphene layer structures _ phys . _ * 113 * 174505 ma q , andersen t i , l. nair n l , gabor n m , massicotte m , lui c h , young a f , fang w , watanabe k , taniguchi t , kong j , gedik n , koppens f h l and jarillo - herrero p 2016 tuning ultrafast electron thermalization pathways in a van der waals heterostructure _ nat . * 12 * 455 ershov m , ryzhii v and hamaguchi c 1995 contact and distributed effects in quantum well infrared photodetectors , appl . * 67 * 3147 thibaudeau l , bois p and duboz j y 1996 a self - consistent model for quantum well infrared photodetectors _ j. appl . phys . _ * 79 * 446 ryzhii v 1997 characteristics of quantum - well infrared photodetectors _ j. appl . phys . _ * 81 * 6442 ryzhii v , khmyrova i , ryzhii m , suris r and hamaguchi c 2000 phenomenological theory of electric - field domains induced by infrared radiation in multiple quantum well structures _ b _ * 62 * 7268 gong c , zhang h , wang w , colombo l , wallace r m and cho k 2013 appl . phys . lett . * 103 * 053513 band alignment of two - dimensional transition metal dichalcogenides : application in tunnel field effect transistors gierz i , calegari f , aeschlimann s , chavez cervantes m , cacho c , chapman r t , springate e , link s , starke u , ast c r and cavalleri a 2015 tracking primary thermaliza- tion events in graphene with photoemission at extreme time scales _ phys . lett . _ * 115 * 086803 ishibashi t , furuta t , fushimi h , kodama s , ito h , nagatsuma t , shimizu n and miyamoto y 2000 inp / ingaas uni - traveling - carrier photodiodes ieice trans . * 938 dyakonov m and shur m s 1998 consequences of space dependence of effective mass in heterostructures _ j. appl . phys . _ * 84 * 3726 massicotte m , schmidt p , vialla f , schadler k g , reserbat - plantey a , watanabe k , taniguchi t , tielrooij k j and koppens f h l 2016 picosecond photoresponse in van der waals heterostructures _ nat . nanotechnol . _ * 11 * 42
Abstract: | [
"we propose and evaluate the graphene layer ( gl ) infrared photodetectors ( glips ) based on the van der waals ( vdw ) heterostructures with the radiation absorbing gls . the operation of the glips is associated with the electron photoexcitation from the gl valence band to the continuum states above the inter - gl barriers ( either via tunneling or direct transitions to the continuum states ) . using the developed device model , we calculate the photodetector characteristics as functions of the gl - vdw heterostructure parameters . we show that due to a relatively large efficiency of the electron photoexcitation and low capture efficiency of the electrons propagating over the barriers in the inter - gl layers , glips should exhibit the elevated photoelectric gain and detector responsivity as well as relatively high detectivity . the possibility of high - speed operation , high conductivity , transparency of the glip contact layers , and the sensitivity to normally incident ir radiation provides additional potential advantages in comparison with other ir photodetectors . in particular , the proposed glips can compete with unitravelling - carrier photodetectors . + * keywords * : graphene , van der waals heterostructure , infrared photodetector +"
] | 9,462 | 9,462 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the statistical treatment of systems driven far from equilibrium presents exciting theoretical challenges @xcite . lacking the unified understanding afforded equilibrium phenomena by the work of boltzmann and gibbs , we are exploring unknown territory without recourse to an established theory . our physical intuition , developed in the context of equilibrium systems , can be misleading when faced with nonequilibrium problems . we therefore turn our attention to computational ` experiments ' in which a manifestly nonequilibrium state can be established and studied , seeking to identify key features shared by many nonequilibrium systems . while real physical systems are unquestionably important , complications and subtle details may obscure such common features . while motivated by realistic problems , microscopic rules and boundary conditions are chosen simple enough to facilitate a comprehensive computational study of the full parameter space . many of the questions relevant in equilibrium remain interesting , especially as concern the nature of phase transitions and the principle of universality . the richness of nonequilibrium phenomena is often surprising , as the relaxation of the detailed balance constraint allows a variety of unexpected possibilities : in contrast to equilibrium , the _ dynamics _ now affects the stationary ( long - time ) properties of the system . particularly dramatic effects have been observed in models where the violation of detailed balance is combined with spatial anisotropies and dynamic conservation laws @xcite . there , _ effective _ long - range interactions can be induced even if the microscopic rules are perfectly local in space and time @xcite . in this paper , we consider a model from this class , namely , a lattice gas of two species of particles and holes on a fully periodic lattice in two spatial dimensions . to drive the system out of equilibrium , we bias the hopping rates of the two species in opposite directions , reminiscent of an ` electric ' field , @xmath0 , acting on opposite ` charges ' ( though we stress that there is _ no coulomb interaction _ ) . a nonzero charge current signals the nonequilibrium steady state . the two species interact through an excluded volume constraint and nearest - neighbor attractions . we choose the interactions carefully , in order to unify three important models which appear as limiting cases of our more general theory . first , by letting all particles attract each other , irrespective of their identity ( charge ) , the non - driven limit corresponds to the familiar ising lattice gas @xcite . this well - known equilibrium model will serve as an anchor for our studies of driven systems . turning the bias on but removing all members of one species , we recover the _ driven _ ising lattice gas introduced by katz et al kls ( the kls model ) . the third limit , obtained by letting the interaction strength vanish , corresponds to a non - interacting two - species model first proposed by schmittmann et al @xcite ( the shz model ) . while the klsmodel phase - separates , via a continuous transition , into high- and low - density strips _ aligned _ with the field @xcite , the shz model orders into _ transverse , _ charge- _ _ _ _ and mass - segregated , strips @xcite , similar to jamming instabilities in traffic models @xcite . if a charge imbalance is imposed , these strips drift @xcite . our study will allow us to bridge the gap between these very different scenarios . to set the scene , we briefly survey some of the relevant previous work . as a single parameter modification of the ising lattice gas , the kls model is a _ minimal model _ for the study of nonequilibrium steady states ( ness ) . particle hops along one direction ( parallel to the @xmath1-axis ) occur at the normal equilibrium rate , as if in contact with a heat bath at temperature @xmath2 . particle hops in the other direction ( parallel to the @xmath3-axis ) are enhanced ( suppressed ) in the positive ( negative ) direction by coupling to an external field , @xmath0 . with periodic boundaries in the @xmath3-direction , a nonzero current is maintained , and the system settles into a ness . at half - filling , there remains a continuous transition , though with @xmath4 increasing monotonically with @xmath0 and saturating at @xmath5 @xcite . the transition falls into a novel universality class with exponents distinct from the ising ones @xcite . the critical behavior is strongly anisotropic , with distinct sets of exponents characterizing fluctuations _ perpendicular _ and _ parallel _ to @xmath0 . there has been some discussion regarding the nature of these fluctuations , with some authors disputing the original claim that the correct mesoscopic description is gaussian in the perpendicular direction @xcite . though the anisotropy makes numerical investigations of the critical behavior quite subtle and computationally intensive , recent high precision monte carlo studies compare the two mesoscopic descriptions . the results are in complete agreement with the predictions of the original field theory @xcite . as a final note , we mention that the combination of anisotropic dynamics and a conservation law introduces power law correlations at all @xmath6 eff - lr , a manifestation of the relaxation of the detailed balance constraint . these correlations are revealed by the structure factor , which has a discontinuity singularity at the origin . in this sense , even the ` disordered ' phase is quite non - trivial . turning to multispecies versions , the simplest ( ` shz ' ) model @xcite allows _ two _ different types of particles , distinguished only by their interaction with the external field . positive ( negative ) particles are biased to hop in the positive ( negative ) @xmath3-direction , and interact only via an excluded volume constraint . the temperature is absorbed into @xmath0 and the only parameters are @xmath0 , the overall mass density @xmath7 , and the overall charge density ( i.e. , the density difference of the two species ) , @xmath8 . here , the mechanism for ordering is the mutual volume exclusion of the particles , so that at sufficiently strong @xmath0 and large @xmath7 , the system locks into a high density strip _ perpendicular _ to @xmath0 , with positive and negative particles blocking each other . for non - zero charge density @xmath8 , this strip is found to drift in the direction of the minority species @xcite . depending on where the phase boundary is crossed , first - order or continuous transitions are observed @xcite . various other remarkable properties have been discovered . for a range of aspect ratios , configurations with non - zero winding number ( ` barber poles ' ) are quite frequently observed , _ in addition _ to the usual transverse strips , raising the possibility of bistability @xcite . power law correlations characterize the disordered phase , with _ directionality - dependent _ exponents @xcite . another subtle issue concerns the lower critical dimension : while an exact solution for a strictly one - dimensional model , characterized by a single ` lane ' parallel to @xmath0 , precludes a transition @xcite , monte carlo data for a ` two - lane ' model indicate the presence of a macroscopic cluster in finite systems @xcite . very subtle finite - size effects control the decay of this cluster in the thermodynamic limit @xcite . in this paper , we consider the two - species model at finite @xmath2 and @xmath0 , where interparticle interactions are expected to play an important role . by varying @xmath2 , @xmath0 , and @xmath8 , the fraction of the _ total _ population which are of the _ minority _ species , we can interpolate smoothly from the kls model to the ( non - interacting ) two - species shz model . hence , we expect a competition between the two types of ordered configurations parallel vs transverse strips favored by these two limits . as @xmath8 varies from @xmath9 ( kls model ) to @xmath10 ( equal numbers of each ) , there should be some critical @xmath8 where the preferred order switches . to explore these phenomena in more detail , we map out the phase diagram in @xmath11 @xmath8 and @xmath2 , for a range of system sizes . the energy scale is set by our choice of the interparticle attraction @xmath12 , and the overall mass density @xmath7 is fixed at @xmath10 so that the ising critical point remains accessible . many questions arise in connection with earlier work . how do nearest - neighbor attractions modify the two - species transition ? what will be the effect of a few ` impurities ' ( i.e. , minority particles ) on the kls transition ? at what concentration do the ` impurities ' become relevant and change the nature of the transition ? preliminary results , focusing on a restricted parameter space , were already reported in @xcite ; here , we explore a much wider parameter range , including several system sizes . we will be able , if not to answer these questions fully , then to at least suggest the character of their resolution sufficiently to guide further research . our main results are as follows . at fixed @xmath0 and sufficiently small @xmath8 , a line of continuous transitions emerges from the pure kls ( @xmath13 ) point , in the @xmath8-@xmath2 plane . this line separates the disordered phase from an ordered one , characterized by a particle - rich strip parallel to @xmath0 . as we increase @xmath8 , we encounter a bicritical point , where the transition line splits into a line of continuous order - disorder transitions , from disorder into a strip transverse to @xmath0 , and a line of first - order transitions along which transverse and parallel order coexist . if we fix @xmath8 and lower @xmath2 , we first observe the transition from disorder into the transverse strip , followed by a transition into parallel order . this topology persists at higher @xmath0 , except that all lines are shifted to slightly higher temperatures . the size - dependence of the phase diagram is subtle , since the main features are controlled by _ different _ scaling variables . on the one hand , the transition into the transverse strip is controlled by the _ effective _ drive @xmath14 where @xmath15 is the system size in the drive direction . on the other hand , the bicritical point appears to depend on the scaling variable @xmath16 which translates into the number of _ rows _ ( transverse to @xmath0 ) which can be filled with the minority species . finally , the pure kls point requires finite - size scaling at fixed shape factor @xmath17 @xcite , in two spatial dimensions . the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . we first describe in detail the microscopic model and the observables which are used to locate the different phases . we then present our simulation results , beginning with the structure of typical configurations in different parts of parameter space and their associated order parameters . by monitoring the signatures of first and second order transitions , we compile a cut through the phase diagram at fixed @xmath0 , with variable @xmath8 and @xmath2 . the phase boundaries and their dependence on system size are analyzed in some detail . to complete the picture , we present two cuts at different but fixed temperatures , crossing the phase boundaries by varying @xmath0 and @xmath8 . we conclude with a brief summary and a discussion of some open questions . we consider periodic square lattices of size @xmath18 , in two spatial dimensions , with @xmath0 parallel to the ( positive ) @xmath3-axis . a configuration is specified by the set of occupation variables , @xmath19 , where @xmath20 takes three values , @xmath21 denoting a positive ( negative ) particle or a hole at lattice site @xmath22 . often , we will only need to distinguish particles from holes , via @xmath23 . all lattices are half filled , i.e. , @xmath24 , so that the ising critical point remains accessible . an important parameter is the fraction of negative particles ( the ` minority species ' ) in the system : @xmath25 . clearly , we only need to consider the sector @xmath26 , from having no negative particles at all to equal numbers of each species . for later reference , we also introduce the charge density , @xmath27 . the nearest - neighbor attraction is modelled by the ising hamiltonian @xmath28we choose attractive interactions , @xmath29 , regardless of species . while many other choices are possible and interesting , ours provides maximum linkage to known cases : ising , kls and shz . the monte carlo dynamics conserves the number of each species and is specified as follows . an update attempt begins by picking a bond at random . if the bond connects a particle - hole pair , the contents are exchanged with the metropolis rate @xmath30 \right\ } $ ] @xcite . hence , at @xmath31 we recover the equilibrium ising model with conserved magnetization , coupled to a heat bath at temperature @xmath2 . we will set @xmath32 and measure @xmath0 in units of this ( arbitrary ) energy scale . @xmath2 will be quoted in units of the onsager temperature , @xmath33 . the change in @xmath3-coordinate , due to the proposed move , is denoted by @xmath34 , and @xmath35 is the associated change in internal energy . the term @xmath36 models the gain or loss of energy from the coupling to @xmath0 ; if @xmath37 is positive ( negative ) the move is favored ( unfavored ) . our model , in which @xmath0 and @xmath2 are varied independently , raises an interesting issue . if the ratio @xmath38 is quite large , it becomes almost impossible for particles to hop backwards . in a finite system , this implies that a relatively small fraction of the minority species provided the ` right ' fluctuation occurs is sufficient to form a stable blockage . even though such a fluctuation becomes less probable in a larger system , the dynamics nevertheless becomes nonergodic in the limit @xmath39 . in principle , this can be avoided by introducing , e.g. , a small probability for particles to exchange places @xcite . to limit the number of parameters , we circumvent these problems here by considering different initial configurations and a range of system sizes . the dynamics is diffusive , and therefore conserves both charge and mass density . though the _ local _ effect of the external field is analogous to the effect of an electrostatic potential on electric charges , the boundary conditions exclude the possibility of a _ global _ hamiltonian description . as overall density is conserved , we expect ordered configurations to be strips of higher density coexisting with strips of lower density . we therefore introduce the fourier transform of the local mass variable , @xmath40which is labelled by ( integer ) wavenumbers , @xmath41 , @xmath42 . the structure factor , @xmath43 then serves as a good order parameter , since it is sensitive to _ mass - segregated _ strip configurations . for example @xmath44 will be @xmath45 for a strip aligned with the field , characteristic of kls order ; similarly , @xmath46 will detect a strip transverse to @xmath0 which develops in the shz ( two - species ) model ; and both are normalized to @xmath47 for a disordered configuration . we also monitor a ` susceptibility ' , i.e. the fluctuations of the order parameter : @xmath48 \nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] we note that @xmath49 involves the fourier transform of the _ mass _ variable and is therefore not sensitive to any charge - segregated structures . replacing @xmath50 by @xmath51 in eq . ( [ s ] ) generates structure factors which respond to charge inhomogeneities . we have monitored these and their fluctuations throughout , and found that their behavior is consistent with the mass - based quantities . when @xmath52 is calculated , the average is taken over multiple steady - state configurations of a monte carlo run , with a typical run lasting @xmath53 m ( @xmath54 ) monte carlo steps ( mcs ) , and @xmath55 bond update attempts per mcs . data are collected every @xmath56 mcs ; fluctuations of observables indicate that this interval is sufficient to produce uncorrelated data in the largest @xmath57 systems considered . typically , the initial @xmath58 m mcs are discarded to ensure that data are taken from the steady state . near critical points and at low temperatures these numbers require modification , due to long correlation times and long - lived metastable states . in such cases the only recourse is a careful analysis of individual , very long runs . when that is necessary we will measure a quantity closely related to @xmath52 : @xmath59which measures the type of order present in a _ single _ configuration . we can then track @xmath60 for different @xmath61 s and @xmath62 s over the course of a run and see precisely how the averages are generated . finally , at each bond update we tally the quantity @xmath63 , which is then averaged over a run to give the charge current @xmath64 . however , it is not particularly illuminating to compare @xmath65 for different values of the effective drive @xmath38 . we are more interested in a quantity which is a property of the gross structure of the steady state , namely , the conductivity @xmath66 defined via @xmath67 . [ fig1 ] now that we have described the various quantities which will be used to probe the behavior of our model , we turn to the presentation of the data . in this section we seek the location and character of transitions by scanning in @xmath8 and @xmath2 at fixed drive @xmath0 . we choose @xmath68 since this intermediate value still allows for a significant fraction of backward jumps , thus avoiding the spurious metastable configurations discussed above . at the same time , it is large enough to induce measurable currents and other clear signatures of far - from - equilibrium behavior . the two order parameters @xmath44 and @xmath46 and their fluctuations are monitored in order to identify the different phases . large peaks in their fluctuations , or the presence of hysteresis , are used as indicators of continuous vs first order transitions , respectively . for clarity , we first present a quick overview of the topology of the phase diagram , and then turn to the details of the data which underlie this picture . [ fig3 ] fig . [ fig1 ] shows the phase diagram in the @xmath8-@xmath2 plane , at @xmath68 , for two different system sizes . three phases are found : a homogeneous , disordered phase ( do ) , a transverse strip ( ts ) phase as in the two - species model , and a parallel strip ( ps ) phase as in the kls model . the value of @xmath8 determines which phase is observed : at @xmath69 there is only one species of particles , and a single transition is observed from disorder into the parallel strip . as @xmath8 increases , this transition persists until the number of the minority species is sufficient to create a blockage and form the transverse strip . from here on , _ two _ transitions are observed : from disorder into the transverse strip , and at a lower temperature from the transverse strip into the parallel strip . upon increasing @xmath8 further , only the do - ts transition can be detected . although the ts - ps line can not have a critical endpoint for reasons of symmetry , for @xmath70 it occurs at such a low temperature that it can not be observed in simulations of a reasonable length . now that we have briefly discussed the phase diagram we can look in more detail at the phases and their boundaries . before presenting the data ( structure factors , their fluctuations , currents ) we will begin with some pictures of typical configurations at various points in the phase diagram . this way the reader can develop some intuition about the model . all pictures show @xmath71 lattices , with @xmath0 pointing up . white ( black ) pixels are positively ( negatively ) biased particles , blue - green ( gray in print ) pixels are holes . we will begin at the right side of the phase diagram and explore how typical configurations change as we move left , decreasing the fraction of the population which belongs to the minority species . [ fig5 ] in fig . [ fig3 ] we present four configurations at @xmath72 : the first picture is at @xmath73 , well above @xmath74 . unsurprisingly , this configuration lacks any visible structure since it falls deep into the homogeneous phase . this will be the only picture presented for the homogeneous phase , as the only _ visible _ feature which changes with @xmath8 is the ratio of white to black pixels . the next picture is at @xmath75 , and now we begin to see the two - species type phase separation . lowering the temperature further to @xmath76 , the horizontal strip appears quite clearly , though it remains diffuse at the boundaries , and there are many ` travelers ' ( isolated particles ) moving through the remainder of the system . at this temperature backward hops of particles are not too improbable , occuring with a rate @xmath77 , and thus a fair number of holes are able to enter the strip and allow particles to slip through the blockage . finally at @xmath78 we are deeply inside the ordered phase , and the boundaries of the strip are very sharp and travelers are few . at this temperature , holes are rarely able to penetrate into the interior of the strip . the irregular shape of the interface between the two species is a result of the quench from disorder ; a more gradual lowering of the temperature would result in a smoother interface . lowering @xmath8 to @xmath79 ( fig . [ fig5 ] ) , only @xmath80 rows of the minority species are left . the first frame shows a configuration just below criticality at @xmath81 . though a blockage can still form , the strip is no longer symmetric with respect to @xmath82 and @xmath83 . this leads to a drifting of the strip : occasionally , the rather thin blockage of the minority species is opened by backward hops , and the majority species pours through . these particles then travel quite rapidly around the periodic lattice and attach to the back of the majority blockage , the net result being an _ upward _ drift of the strip . lowering @xmath2 further to @xmath84 ( third frame ) it appears that interfaces _ parallel _ to @xmath0 are becoming favorable ; this type of configuration is common at these intermediate values of @xmath8 : here , parallel and transverse strips compete with each other . indeed the final frame ( @xmath85 ) shows the preferred low temperature configuration : a single strip of _ mixed _ charge parallel to @xmath0 , raising the possibility of a sequence of _ two _ transitions as a function of @xmath2 . now that we have developed a qualitative notion of the various regions in the phase diagram , we turn to a more quantitative analysis of the phases and their boundaries . as in the preceding section , we present the order parameters and their fluctuations as a function of @xmath2 , for a range of @xmath8 , though with one important difference : we will show data for at least _ two _ system sizes . while this can not replace a high - precision finite - size scaling analysis of the transitions , it is intended to provide a rough picture of how the fluctuations of the order parameter scale with system size . [ fig10 ] we begin as before at @xmath72 , with equal numbers of each type of particle . in figs . [ fig10 ] and [ fig11 ] , @xmath86 and its fluctuations are plotted as a function of @xmath2 for two system sizes ( @xmath71 and @xmath87 ) ; @xmath88 is not shown as the only transition here is from the homogeneous phase into the transverse strip . in both systems , @xmath86 goes smoothly to zero as @xmath2 is increased . a clean peak in @xmath89 is also observed in each system , increasing in amplitude with the system size . these two observations are consistent with a continuous transition into the transverse strip at @xmath72 , and we therefore use the location of the peak in @xmath89 to locate the phase boundary in fig . 1 , with @xmath90 and @xmath91 . reducing @xmath8 to just a few rows of the minority species introduces some new features into the data , which we describe briefly before continuing our analysis . here , we still observe the transition described above , with the same behavior of @xmath86 and @xmath89 . however , now that the strip is no longer symmetric , it drifts . the ordered phase therefore fluctuates significantly , and @xmath92 develops a shoulder at about @xmath93 of the value it reaches at the transition . we will see below that the fluctuations of the ordered phase can obscure the transition in smaller systems . [ fig11 ] [ fig14 ] upon reducing @xmath8 further we observe a sequence of _ two transitions _ as a function of @xmath2 . [ fig14 ] shows both order parameters , @xmath86 and @xmath88 for @xmath80 rows of the minority species : @xmath94 in the @xmath71 system . also shown in fig . [ fig15 ] is @xmath89 for @xmath80 rows of the minority species in both the @xmath71 and the @xmath87 system . we have omitted the @xmath87 data for the order parameters to keep the plot uncluttered . as before , @xmath86 and @xmath92 signal a continuous transition into the ts phase as @xmath2 is lowered , though the signal in @xmath89 is much more pronounced in the @xmath87 system . and also as before , there are significant fluctuations associated with this phase , due to strip drifting . specifically , in the @xmath87 system @xmath89 actually has a broad secondary peak in the ordered phase . the large magnitude of this signal is is quite unexpected and awaits a satisfactory explanation . for now , we only note that _ lowering _ @xmath2 _ increases _ the effective bias , @xmath38 , and therefore enhances fluctuations associated with the drive . lowering @xmath2 further we observe @xmath86 falling abruptly , while @xmath88 climbs rapidly , suggesting a discontinuous transition from the horizontal strip ( ts ) into the vertical strip ( ps ) . in the neighborhood of such a transition , one expects to see metastability of the unfavored phase , and this is indeed the case as shown in fig . [ fig16 ] . here we have plotted _ time traces _ ( as opposed to configurational averages ) of structure factors for individual configurations , @xmath95 and @xmath96 , defined in eqn . ( [ tt ] ) . clearly , when @xmath95 ( @xmath96 ) @xmath97 the configuration is a perfect vertical ( horizontal ) strip . sufficiently close to the transition , the time traces reveal the expected behavior , as the system switches between the two ordered phases . notice the length of the run shown : @xmath98 m mcs , which is a factor of @xmath98 longer than typical runs , indicating that the lifetimes of metastable configurations are already quite long even in the @xmath71 system , rendering such behavior nearly unobservable in the @xmath87 system . [ fig15 ] [ fig16 ] at smaller values of @xmath8 we are nearing the junction of the three phase boundaries , which considerably complicates the analysis of data from small systems in a couple of ways . the sequence of transitions ( do - ts followed by ts - ps ) becomes difficult to resolve , as they are quite close in temperature , and massive fluctuations from the first - order ts - ps line may wash out the signal in @xmath89 which locates the continuous do - ts line . and if the junction of the three lines is indeed a nonequilibrium bicritical point , we can expect unexplored finite - size effects to interfere with the analysis . we can , however , make some progress based on the assumption that the relevant control parameter near the bicritical point is the number of rows of the minority species . this hypothesis will be treated in more detail below , in the sections on scaling arguments . at precisely one row of the minority species it is no longer possible to accurately resolve the two transitions in the @xmath71 system . a weak transverse ordering is observed , with @xmath86 reaching at most @xmath99 of perfect order . in the vicinity of the ps - ts first - order transition , huge fluctuations associated with switching between metastable configurations are observed , which wash out the signal of the do - ps transition . however , it is interesting that these transitions can be resolved in larger systems at precisely one row of the minority species : there , these two transitions are sufficiently far apart in temperature since ( as we will see below ) @xmath100 increases with @xmath15 across the do - ts transition . this likely explains why the do - ts transition is not observed in the @xmath71 system . [ fig25 ] below one row of the minority species we no longer observe the transverse order , though we caution that this may be strictly correct only for the _ finite _ system . with @xmath8 just below a single row of the minority species , the high temperature phase is homogeneous and the low temperature phase is the parallel strip . in the vicinity of the transition , huge fluctuations are observed in @xmath46 and especially @xmath101 , where the fluctuations are an order of magnitude larger than the signal at the do - ts boundary . in this region neither @xmath102 nor @xmath46 posesses a well - defined average ; timetraces indicate vigorous competition between the two ordered phases . we conjecture that we are close to the bicritical point in the finite system , and are therefore unable to resolve the transition without some knowledge of scaling to guide the analysis . at smaller @xmath8 we are farther from the bicritical point , and the complications from the presence of the minority species are less severe . fig . [ fig25 ] shows @xmath44 for two system sizes at exactly one - half row of the minority species . we have not shown @xmath46 , as the signal has become insignificant . @xmath101 shows the low - temperature configuration to be a single parallel strip , the smooth approach to zero again suggesting a continuous transition . and indeed , the data for @xmath103 is consistent with this conjecture , with a sharp peak which increases with system size . the amplitude of the peak is smaller by a factor of five than the peaks observed near the bicritical point , suggesting that it is associated with fluctuations about a well - defined average , as opposed to transitions into and out of the ordered phase . timetraces support this conjecture . charge currents were also measured in order to look for signatures of the various phases and transitions . we note however that as we are changing @xmath2 , we are also changing the _ effective _ bias @xmath104 , and therefore a more appropriate quantity is the conductivity , @xmath105 . in fig . [ fig28 ] we plot @xmath66 as a function of @xmath106 for each @xmath8 discussed in this and the following sections ; we present only data for the @xmath71 system as there are no significant differences between the two system sizes . at temperatures below @xmath107 ( @xmath108 ) the conductivity vanishes in the @xmath72 systems ; as the temperature is raised the effective drive is reduced , and backward hops occasionally occur , allowing a small current to trickle through the blockage . upon raising the temperature further , the conductivity changes slope at @xmath109 in the @xmath71 system , which _ does not _ coincide with the phase transition . rather the maximal conductivity occurs in the disordered phase , but at a temperature which is not too large , so that backward hops are not so common as to begin reducing the current . the transition apparently corresponds instead to the _ inflection point _ ( @xmath110 ) , where the curvature changes sign . at @xmath111 , the conductivity has a slope discontinuity in the @xmath71 system at @xmath112 , slightly above the critical temperature @xmath113 . though there should be an inflection point in @xmath66 near the transition , our data are not precise enough to locate it . at @xmath94 and below , the conductivity drops smoothly to zero with @xmath2 , showing no indication of either transition . apparently , @xmath52 and @xmath114 are far more sensitive to the transitions in our model . [ fig28 ] we close this section on the @xmath8-@xmath2 phase diagram with a summary of the results . the picture at higher @xmath8 is clear : a clean continuous transition into the horizontal strip , with @xmath100 decreasing with @xmath8 . when @xmath8 is reduced to approximately three rows of the minority species , the signal of the transition remains clear , though it now sits atop a shoulder of fluctuations of the ordered phase . at yet smaller @xmath8 , a second transition appears between the two ordered phases at lower @xmath2 ; it has the characteristics of a first - order transition . at even lower @xmath8 , at approximately one row of the minority species , both fluctuations perpendicular and parallel to @xmath0 become so violent that the do - ts transition is only seen in larger systems , as the two transitions nearly overlap in the @xmath71 system . close to the @xmath69 point , the transition is once again clean and apparently continuous into a vertical strip of mixed charge . of course , all these statements are based on an analysis of _ finite _ systems . in order to draw robust conclusions , a more systematic analysis of larger samples is required . in the preceding section we studied a slice of the phase diagram at constant @xmath0 , varying the fraction of the minority species and the temperature . varying @xmath2 effectively varies both the strength of particle - particle attractions _ and _ the strength of the bias , since the relevant quantities in the rates are @xmath115 and @xmath38 . in this section we consider a different cut through the phase diagram . by varying @xmath0 and @xmath8 at fixed @xmath2 , the interparticle attractions are held constant while the strength of the bias is varied . in this way we can study directly the competition between the drive and the attractive interactions . in the following , we choose a value for @xmath2 , and then scan in @xmath0 for several values of @xmath8 . the temperatures are chosen by reference to the kls temperature : @xmath116 is above the critical temperature of the kls model at saturation , and @xmath117 is at the critical temperature for @xmath68 , studied in the previous section . at this stage , we have only data for @xmath71 systems , and are therefore as yet unable to speculate on results for larger systems . however , they cast a new light on the more detailed results of the previous sections . [ fig36 ] as before , we first survey the phase diagram with the help of some typical configurations . the qualitative picture will then be made more quantitative in the next section , by examining the behavior of currents and order parameters . [ fig36 ] shows a series of configurations at various @xmath8 for @xmath119 . the first frame clearly shows the transverse strip at @xmath72 , and the absence of travelers suggests that the strip is stationary . in the next frame we have reduced @xmath8 to @xmath120 , reducing the thickness of the minority species to exactly two rows . consequently we now see some travelers trickling through a break in the blockage . watching an animation in this region of the phase diagram reveals an interesting behavior : the strip is mostly quiescent , except for a few particles hopping back and forth at the particle - hole interface . aside from the different ratio of @xmath82 to @xmath83 , these configurations look similar to the @xmath72 strip . then , a sudden large fluctuation opens up a hole in the minority blockage : the @xmath82 particles pour through , and the strip fluctuates and drifts partway around the lattice , until the blockage is reestablished . reducing @xmath8 further to @xmath79 ( third frame ) we see a strip in the middle of one of these fluctuation events . in contrast to @xmath111 where such large fluctuations are relatively rare , the situation is now reversed ; i.e. , the quiescent periods become less frequent . in the fourth frame , we set @xmath121 , and while the strip is still clearly visible it now drifts continuously . the final two frames show @xmath122 and @xmath123 . now there is no longer any clear evidence of phase separation . this rough picture is consistent with our earlier investigation of the two - species transition , where we observed transverse order at and above a single row of the minority species . [ fig37 ] fig . [ fig37 ] presents the phase diagram at @xmath116 . the boundary separates a horizontal strip at high @xmath0 and @xmath8 from a homogeneous phase at small @xmath0 and @xmath8 . as we are above the critical temperature for the kls model at saturation bias , the vertical strip does not appear at any @xmath0 ; at low @xmath8 ( where we might otherwise expect to see such ordered configurations ) the system simply remains disordered for any @xmath0 and @xmath8 . [ fig38 ] and [ fig39 ] show @xmath46 and @xmath124 for several values of @xmath8 ; in the interest of clarity @xmath125 is plotted for only four @xmath8 s . as @xmath0 is increased the system [ fig38 ] [ fig39 ] orders into a transverse strip , with @xmath46 saturating at smaller values as @xmath8 is decreased . at @xmath121 ( exactly one row of the minority species ) @xmath52 saturates at only @xmath126 , indicating that the transverse ordering is rather weak , though comparison with the data for @xmath127 shows dramatically different behavior . here @xmath46 reaches a maximum of only @xmath128 , and the behavior can hardly be called ` saturation ' . @xmath124 also signals a transition , though the clean , sharp spike at @xmath72 becomes a broad bump at @xmath121 , and shows no signal at @xmath127 . the susceptibility also indicates a difference in the ordered phases at different @xmath8 : at large @xmath8 increasing @xmath0 suppresses fluctuations , while at smaller @xmath8 ( when the strip begins drifting ) increasing @xmath0 enhances fluctuations . it is important to note that the fluctuations at high @xmath0 are fluctuations about the ordered phase , as @xmath124 is always @xmath129 to @xmath130 orders of magnitude larger than @xmath103 . though the data is not included in the plots , we have checked the behavior of the ordered phase for @xmath0 as high as @xmath98 . the fluctuations for small @xmath8 ( @xmath131 ) saturate and bounce around a well - defined average , while for larger @xmath8 they are suppressed . this is true for @xmath121 and greater ; at @xmath127 the magnitude of fluctuations in either direction are comparable . we also examined the conductivity across the phase boundary . we do not present the data here , as it is qualitatively similar to the data in fig . [ fig28 ] . again , the transition apparently coincides with the inflection point of the conductivity . in the preceding section we found a simple phase diagram , with a single boundary separating two - species order from the homogeneous phase . since the temperature was chosen well above the maximum kls transition temperature , @xmath133 , the kls ordered phase could not be observed . now , we lower the temperature to @xmath134 and explore the corresponding ( @xmath8-@xmath0 ) slice of the phase diagram ( fig . [ fig41 ] ) . as [ fig41 ] long as we remain at @xmath70 , we observe a transition similar to the one at @xmath116 : from the homogeneous phase into two - species order . in contrast , for @xmath135 the kls transition is observed , since the minority species is too scarce to form a blockage and @xmath136 . between these two limiting values of @xmath8 we are again in the vicinity of the bicritical point , and the situation becomes complicated due to the competing types of order . [ fig42 ] shows typical configurations at two different values of @xmath8 for various @xmath0 . for @xmath137 these configurations look much as they did at [ fig42 ] @xmath116 , so they need not be included . the @xmath94 , @xmath119 configuration shows some very interesting structure , almost ` equal parts ' kls and two - species order , suggesting some serious competition between the two phases . we stress that this is a _ typical _ configuration . when @xmath8 is reduced to a single row ( @xmath121 ) this competition is reduced , and we see instead a kls phase with some local two - species order . this trend continues upon reducing @xmath8 to zero , where at high @xmath0 the kls order is observed . the other panels show @xmath94 and @xmath138 at smaller values of @xmath0 , @xmath139 and @xmath140 respectively . these @xmath0 values were chosen because they maximize the two - species order for these @xmath8 s . in each case the strip drifts rapidly around the lattice . interestingly , as the majority species is piled onto the back of the drifting strip it builds long fingers , leading to a very irregular interface . pictures at smaller @xmath8 s are not shown , as they do not form the transverse strip at smaller @xmath0 . in the next section we locate these boundaries and study the phases in greater detail by examining the behavior of @xmath52 , @xmath114 , and @xmath66 . in fig . [ fig44 ] we plot @xmath52 for the high-@xmath8 phases . for @xmath72 and @xmath120 , @xmath46 shows the system ordering into the two - species phase much as in the previous section . there is , however , one notable new feature for @xmath111 : we see a slight suppression of @xmath46 over an intermediate range of @xmath0 , from about @xmath141 to @xmath142 . in this range backward hops occur frequently enough to occasionally open a hole in the minority blockage , allowing the majority species to pour through until the blockage reforms . increasing @xmath0 reduces the likelihood of such events , until the strip is perfect except for some surface diffusion at the particle - hole interface . at @xmath94 the behavior changes dramatically . after maximizing the two - species order at @xmath143 , increasing @xmath0 further suppresses @xmath46 and enhances @xmath44 , until both saturate below @xmath58 . the system can hardly be said to have switched to kls order , though neither is it precisely disordered either . to understand this peculiar behavior , we recall that @xmath2 ( and therefore @xmath115 ) is held constant , so that increasing @xmath0 favors interfaces _ parallel _ to @xmath0 . yet , the number of minority particles is large enough to form bubbles of local two - species order , as one can discern from the top left panel of fig . [ fig42 ] . apparently the competition between the two phases is very balanced in this small system . it would be interesting to simulate larger systems and explore whether this type of ` phase competition ' persists , or whether the kls order eventually becomes stable . additional information is provided by the susceptibilities . observations of @xmath124 are consistent [ fig44 ] [ fig47 ] with a continuous transition from disorder into the transverse strip at small @xmath0 . seeking a signature of the kls phase , we show @xmath144 and @xmath124 for @xmath94 in fig . fig47 . here we observe a second peak in @xmath124 at @xmath145 , which corresponds to @xmath146 in fig . this peak is rather broad and its amplitude is more than twice that of the first peak ( associated with the do - ts transition ) . perhaps it suggests a first - order transition which would be observed in a larger system , separating the two - species phase from the kls phase . finally , at higher @xmath0 both @xmath124 and @xmath103 fluctuate around nonzero values , reflecting the fluctuations of the competing phases . we note no signal of a transition in @xmath103 . we now continue by looking at the data for @xmath121 , shown in fig . fig48 , where we have plotted @xmath52 for each type of order . we observe that [ fig48 ] the transverse strip only makes a brief appearance , with @xmath147 reaching a maximum of only @xmath148 . at higher @xmath0 , the parallel strip stabilizes and reaches a value slightly above @xmath149 . however , we observe no clear signature of a distinct transition between the two types of order . there is a vague remnant in @xmath125 of the double peak structure seen at @xmath94 , and then a broad , messy bump in @xmath103 before it settles down to capture the fluctuations of the ordered phase . only further investigation of larger systems can determine whether these weak signals in fact indicate a transition . it is clear , however , that the high @xmath0 phase here is not the ` phase competition ' seen previously at @xmath94 , since neither @xmath46 nor @xmath150 contain any trace of it . upon reducing @xmath8 below @xmath138 we find that the transverse strip has essentially disappeared . meanwhile , @xmath44 looks similar to fig . [ fig48 ] , saturating to about @xmath151 , indicating that the kls strip has formed . apparently the system is unable to completely order at any @xmath0 , since @xmath152 . we stress that this behavior is due to the proximity of the kls phase transition , not due to some residual competition with the transverse strip . finally , we note that the behavior of the susceptibility is consistent with a continuous transition into the parallel strip . the conductivities are shown in fig . [ fig52 ] . at @xmath72 and @xmath120 , @xmath66 has much the same form as seen before , decreasing monotonically with @xmath0 . this is no longer the case when @xmath8 is reduced to @xmath79 . now @xmath66 develops a broad minimum which coincides with the appearance of the [ fig52 ] two - species order , followed by a small peak at @xmath153 before falling off with @xmath0 . the peak coincides with the crossing of @xmath46 and @xmath44 , which suggests that the current is maximized by the ` phase competition ' . with the current maximized , increasing @xmath0 simply reduces @xmath66 ; indeed a glance at the raw data for the current shows that this is the case . the data for @xmath121 shows the same nonmonotonic structure as for the @xmath94 data . again , the peak corresponds to the crossing of the two order parameters , and then falls off with increasing @xmath0 . this similarity suggests that perhaps the high @xmath0 phase at @xmath94 is in fact the parallel strip , and such behavior would be observed in a larger system . for values of @xmath8 below @xmath138 we no longer observe the secondary peak , nor do we observe any phase competition . we must , however , leave questions about the nature of the high-@xmath0 phase open to further study . now that we have surveyed the phase diagram in some detail , we turn to look closely at some of the boundaries with the help of some scaling arguments . considering fig . [ fig1 ] again , we note two potentially troubling features . first , there is a shift in @xmath100 across the do - ts boundary of about @xmath154 between the two system sizes . we will characterize this shift using a mean - field scaling argument . second , we note that the bicritical point has shifted towards the @xmath69 axis in the larger system . it has been alluded to before that the number of rows of the minority species , rather than the fraction @xmath8 , might be the controlling variable . we will investigate this suggestion more carefully by considering some larger systems and rectangular geometries . finally we study the @xmath69 phase transition , using scaling arguments developed for the kls model . the shift in @xmath100 with system size is most pronounced at @xmath72 . previous work on the two - species model with @xmath155 treated the ordered phase in a mean - field approximation by solving equations of motion for the two different charge densities @xcite . * * * * it was found that the scaling functions depend on the combination @xmath156 , indicating that the effective bias @xmath38 introduces a new length scale . this scaling implies an infinite - volume limit in which @xmath38 @xmath157 as @xmath158 , while keeping @xmath156 fixed . earlier analyses of the _ ordered phase _ based on these ideas have worked quite well , so that we now attempt to extend this approach to analyze quantities near criticality and [ fig31 ] [ fig32 ] for @xmath159 . there is no reason to expect success a priori , as both critical fluctuations and nonzero @xmath12 may modify the scaling variables and the mean - field exponents . in figs . [ fig31 ] and [ fig32 ] we have plotted @xmath46 and @xmath124 for @xmath160 . ( we have divided @xmath124 , eqn . ( [ delta ] ) , by the volume in order to compare different system sizes more easily . ) rather than crossing the phase boundary by varying @xmath2 we have opted instead to vary @xmath0 since this allows us to vary the effective bias @xmath38 at _ constant _ interaction strength , @xmath115 . while the collapse of @xmath46 in fig . [ fig31 ] is not perfect , the mean - field scaling argument accounts for most of the shift in @xmath100 . there is a shift in the peak of @xmath161 of about @xmath162 between the largest and smallest systems ; if the same data were plotted without rescaling , the shift in @xmath163 is about @xmath164 . also of note is the extremely weak dependence on the transverse dimension , as predicted by the scaling argument . we also examined the same quantities for @xmath155 . interestingly , the data collapse for @xmath160 is better than in the @xmath155 case . this is somewhat surprising , as the original scaling argument was derived for @xmath155 , and we would expect the interactions to perhaps modify it . whatever the resolution of this puzzle , it is apparent that the scaling argument presented here explains the pronounced shift in @xmath100 seen in the phase diagram : increasing @xmath15 requires a corresponding decrease in the effective bias @xmath38 . another issue concerns the location of the junction of the three phase boundaries , shown in fig . it is clear that the junction moves toward the @xmath69 axis as the system size is increased . in fact , in both systems the boundaries merge just below a _ single row _ of the minority species , which naturally corresponds to a smaller @xmath8 in the larger system . in fig . [ fig33 ] we have replotted the data from fig . [ fig1 ] , [ fig33 ] replacing @xmath8 with @xmath165 , which is simply the _ number of rows _ of the minority species . near the junction of the three lines we have also included results from a few other system sizes with rectangular geometries . plotted vs. @xmath165 , the junctions of the boundaries coincide , within the error bars , for all system sizes , suggesting that the onset of the two - species order occurs , at least in relatively small finite systems , when there are sufficient minority particles to form a single row . the crucial question concerns the extrapolation of this result to an appropriate thermodynamic limit . if the system size goes to infinity in the most naive way , i.e. , @xmath166 at fixed aspect ratio @xmath167 , the particle density associated with a ` single row ' vanishes . it is possible that the do - ps transition exists in an infinite volume only at @xmath69 , and any _ finite density _ of ` disorder ' ( i.e. , the minority species ) induces the two - species order . preliminary studies @xcite indicate that the minority species does indeed constitute a relevant perturbation to the kls fixed point . we will have to leave discussion of this issue to future work and for now limit ourselves to statements about finite systems . at @xmath69 there is only one species , and we observe the kls transition at _ finite _ @xmath0 . though a great deal of study has been devoted to this transition at infinite @xmath0 , there has been no detailed work at finite @xmath0 . here we present a basic finite - size scaling ( fss ) analysis of this transition , in order to locate @xmath168 , and also to demonstrate the subtleties which can arise when studying phase transitions with anisotropic , nonequilibrium dynamics . field - theoretic studies of the kls model @xcite indicate that the critical behavior is strongly anisotropic , meaning that correlation lengths diverge with different exponents in the field direction and perpendicular to the field . specifically , the fluctuations perpendicular to the field are gaussian @xmath169 while those parallel to the field are not @xmath170 . correlations therefore grow faster in the parallel direction as @xmath171 , suggesting an analysis of rectangular samples such that the anisotropic aspect ratio @xmath172 is held fixed @xcite . while there is some discussion regarding the correct mesoscopic model @xcite , detailed numerical simulations show that the exponents cited above are the correct ones @xcite . in the following we will use only the phenomenological result of leung for the scaling of the order parameter at fixed @xmath173 : @xmath174where @xmath52 refers to @xmath44 . a detailed discussion of the subtleties of the fss analysis for the kls model and precision numerical results can be found in @xcite . [ fig34 ] presents our data for the scaled order parameter at @xmath175 ; the same data for saturation @xmath0 can be found elsewhere @xcite . this data is not intended as a test [ fig34 ] of the mesoscopic model , it merely is meant to indicate that the exponents at infinite @xmath0 are consistent with those at finite @xmath0 , and to determine @xmath176 . the data collapse is comparable to that seen at saturation @xmath0 , with the high temperature ( upper ) branch collapsing quite well and the low temperature ( lower ) branch showing small , but systematic deviations from scaling . these deviations remain unexplained . they are possibly due to corrections to scaling or perhaps the asymptotic region is only observed very close to @xmath100 . we have seen how subtle are the issues surrounding the transition at @xmath69 . perhaps a fruitful way to proceed when @xmath177 is to adopt the technique introduced by caracciolo _ et al_. @xcite , directly measuring finite volume correlation lengths for various geometries and volumes . in this way we may develop some understanding of how to approach the infinite volume limit in a simple way , minimizing corrections to scaling which would complicate an uninformed analysis . we have compiled a detailed phase diagram for a system of two species of particles , interacting via attractive ising interactions , and driven into opposite directions by an external `` electic '' field , @xmath0 . the purpose of our analysis was to unify previous studies which were restricted either to just one species or to having only excluded volume interactions . in the former case , particles order into a single strip aligned with the field direction while in the second model , the two oppositely driven species form a jam in the shape of a transverse strip . we monitor structure factors , their fluctuations , and , if necessary , their time traces to identify the location and character of the transitions . most of our data are taken at fixed @xmath0 , varying the fraction @xmath8 of the ` minority ' species and temperature @xmath2 . at high @xmath8 , we observe a continuous transition from a disordered phase into the transverse strip , as the temperature is lowered . noting a significant system - size dependence of the critical line , we invoke a mean - field scaling argument @xcite which suggests that @xmath156 is a good scaling variable . this is confirmed quite satisfactorily by our data . at smaller @xmath8 ( @xmath178 for a @xmath71 system ) we observe two transition as @xmath2 is lowered : first into the transverse strip ( continuous ) , and then into the parallel strip ( first order ) . and finally at the smallest @xmath8 a single , continuous transition is observed into the parallel strip . the junction of the three phases disorder , transverse and parallel strip appears to be a multicritical point . analyzing data for a range of system sizes suggests that its location scales with @xmath179 , rather than @xmath8 ; i.e. , the relevant quantity is the number of _ rows _ which can be formed by the minority particles . depending on how the thermodynamic limit is approached , the multicritical point can shift to @xmath69 . several projects suggest themselves to extend this work . first , an analysis of larger systems at fixed @xmath2 could clear up some questions , especially regarding the fate of the ` phase competition ' which is observed close to the multicritical point . many of the ` transitions ' in the @xmath71 system require an analysis of larger lattices in order to confirm their existence . second , a look at structure factors in the disordered phase is likely to reveal the presence of long - range correlations . since these are known to be quite distinct in the kls @xcite and shz @xcite models , it would be interesting to investigate how the crossover occurs . such a study would also yield considerable insight into the type of noise terms which would have to be added to the mean - field equations in order to capture fluctuations and critical properties accurately . these equations would then provide a reliable starting point for an analysis of the kls transition in the presence of a few minority charges , in order to understand the true nature of the kls critical point : does it mark the beginning of a critical line , or is it a multicritical point ? * acknowledgements . * we thank r.k.p . zia , i. georgiev , u.c . tuber , a. gambassi , m. gubinelli , g. korniss , and h.k . janssen for fruitful discussions . this work was supported in part by nsf grants dmr-0088451 , dmr-0414122 , and sbe-0244916 , as well as the jeffress memorial trust , grant no . j-594 . zhang , j - s . wang , j.l . lebowitz and j.l . valls , j. stat . phys . * 52 * , 1461 ( 1988 ) ; p.l . garrido , j.l . lebowitz , c. maes and h. spohn , phys . a * 42 * , 1954 ( 1990 ) ; g. grinstein , j. appl . phys . * 69 * , 5441 ( 1991 ) ; b. schmittmann and r.k.p . zia , j. stat . * 91 * , 525 ( 1998 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we present a monte carlo study of a lattice gas driven out of equilibrium by a local hopping bias . sites can be empty or occupied by one of two types of particles , which are distinguished by their response to the hopping bias . all particles interact via excluded volume and a nearest - neighbor attractive force . the main result is a phase diagram with three phases : a homogeneous phase , and two distinct ordered phases . continuous boundaries separate the homogeneous phase from the ordered phases , and a first - order line separates the two ordered phases . the three lines merge in a nonequilibrium bicritical point ."
] | 10,459 | 10,459 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: cellular automata ( ca ) models for solar flares are successful in explaining solar flare statistics ( peak flux , total flux , and duration distributions ; lu & hamilton 1991 ( hereafter lh91 ) ; lu et al . 1993 ; vlahos et al . 1995 ; georgoulis & vlahos 1996 , 1998 ; galsgaard 1996 ) . they simplify strongly the details of the involved physical processes , and achieve in this way to model large volumes with complex field topologies and a large number of events . on the other hand , mhd simulations give insight into the details of the local processes , they are limited , however , to modeling relatively small fractions of active regions , due to the lack of computing power , yielding thus poor statistics and difficulties in comparing results to observations ( e.g. mikic et al . 1989 ; strauss 1993 ; longcope & sudan 1994 ; einaudi et al . 1996 ; galsgaard & nordlund 1996 ; hendrix & van hoven 1996 ; dmitruk & gomez 1998 ; galtier & pouquet 1998 ; georgoulis et al . 1998 ; karpen et al . 1998 ; einaudi & velli 1999 ) . the _ global _ mhd flare models are still in the state of rather qualitative flare scenarios . the mhd and the ca approach to solar flares seem to have very little in common : the former are a set of partial differential equations , based on fluid - theory and maxwell s equations , whereas the latter are a set of abstract evolution rules , based ( in the case of solar flares ) on the analogy to critical phenomena in ( theoretical ) sand - piles . the scope of this paper is to bridge the gap in - between these two approaches : the solar flare ca models are re - interpreted and extended so as ( i ) to make these models completely compatible with mhd and with maxwell s equations , and so that ( ii ) all relevant mhd variables are made available ( e.g. the current and the electric field , which so far were not available in ca models ) . in an earlier paper ( isliker et al . 1998 ) , we have analyzed the existing solar flare ca models for their soundness with mhd . we asked the question whether the fields in these ca models and the evolution rules can be interpreted in terms of mhd . it turned out that these models can indeed be interpreted as a particular way of implementing numerically the mhd equations . this fact is not trivial , since these models had been derived in quite close analogy to the sand - pile ca model of bak et al . ( 1987 and 1988 ) , with vague association of the model s variables with physical quantities . for instance , some authors ( lu et al . 1993 ) explicitly discuss the question whether their basic grid variable is the magnetic field or not , without reaching to a definite conclusion . isliker et al . ( 1998 ) brought forth not only how the existing ca models are related to mhd and what simplifications are hidden , but also where they differ from or even violate the laws of mhd and maxwell s equation . important is the fact that though the existing ca models can be considered as a strongly simplified numerical solution of the ( simplified ) mhd equations , _ they do not represent the discretized mhd equations _ : the time - step and the spacing between two grid sites are not small ( in a physical sense ) , but finite ; they are a typical temporal and spatial scale of the diffusive processes involved ( see isliker et al . 1998 ) . from the point of view of mhd , the main short - comings of the existing ca models are ( isliker et al . 1998 ) : ( 1 ) there is no control over consistency with maxwell s equations . interpreting , for instance , the vector - field in the ca models as the magnetic field leads to the problem that the gradient of the field ( @xmath0 ) can not be controlled . ( 2 ) secondary quantities , such as currents , are not available , and they can not be introduced in the straightforward way by replacing differential expressions by difference - expressions , since , as mentioned , the grid - size must be considered finite ( see also app . this lack of knowing how to calculate derivatives made it also useless to interpret the primary vector - field in the ca models as the vector potential ( to avoid the @xmath0-problem ) , since @xmath1 could not be derived . the physical interpretation of these ca models remained so far problematic . there are two basically different ways of developing ca models for flares further : ( i ) either one considers ca models _ per se _ , tries to change the existing models further or invent new ones , with the only aim of adjusting them to reproduce still better the observations , i.e. one makes them a tool the results of which explain and maybe predict observed properties of flares . in this approach , one has not to care about possible inconsistencies with mhd or even maxwell s equations , the various components of the model are purely instrumentalistic . ( ii ) on the other hand , one may care about the physical identification and interpretation of the various components of the model , not just of its results , and one may want the ca model to become consistent with the other approach to solar flares , namely mhd . in the approach ( ii ) , some of the freedom one has in constructing ca models will possibly be reduced , since there are more boundary conditions to be fulfilled in the construction of the model : the observations must be reproduced and consistency with mhd has to be reached . ( trials to construct new ca models which are based on mhd and not on the sand - pile analogy were recently made by einaudi & velli ( 1999 ) , macpherson & mackinnon ( 1999 ) , longcope and noonan ( 2000 ) , and isliker et al . ( 2000a ) . ) our aim is in - between these two alternatives : we construct a set - up which can be superimposed onto each classical solar flare ca model , and which makes the latter interpretable in a mhd - consistent way ( by _ classical _ ca models we mean the models of lh91 , lu et al . 1993 , vlahos et al . 1995 , georgoulis & vlahos 1996 , 1998 , galsgaard 1996 , and their modifications , which are based on the sand - pile analogy ) . the set - up thus specifies the physical interpretation of the grid - variables and allows the derivation of quantities such as currents etc . it does not interfere with the dynamics of the ca ( unless wished ) : loading , redistributing ( bursting ) , and the appearance of avalanches and self - organized criticality ( soc ) , if the latter are implied by the evolution rules , remain unchanged . the result is therefore still a ca model , with all the advantages of ca , namely that they are fast , that they model large spatial regions ( and large events ) , and therewith that they yield good statistics . since the set - up introduces all the relevant physical variables into the context of the ca models , it automatically leads to a better physical understanding of the ca models . it reveals which relevant plasma processes and in what form are actually implemented , and what the global flare scenario is the ca models imply . all this was more or less hidden so far in the abstract evolution rules . it leads also to the possibility to change the ca models ( the rules ) at the guide - line of mhd , if this should become desirable . not least , the set - up opens a way for further comparison of the ca models to observations . in sec . 2 , we introduce our set - up . applying it to several ca models ( sec . 3 ) , we will demonstrate the usefulness and some of the benefits such extended models ( i.e. classical models extended with our set - up ) provide over the classical ca models , and we will reveal basic physical features of the ca models . the potential of the extended models to explain more observational facts than the classical ca models is , among others , outlined in the conclusions ( sec . 4 ) . the set - up we propose can be superimposed onto solar flare ca models which use a 3d grid and a basic 3d vector grid - variable , say @xmath2 . the corresponding set of evolution rules is not changed . ( with a few modifications , the set - up can also be superimposed onto ca models which use a scalar field in a planar grid , which our set - up necessarily interprets as slab geometry , as will become clear later . ) we introduce our model on the example of the solar flare ca model of lh91 , which we summarize here in order to make the subsequent presentation more concrete : in the lh91 model , to each grid - site @xmath3 of a 3d cubic grid a 3d vector @xmath4 is assigned . initially , @xmath4 is set to @xmath5 , everywhere . the system is then loaded with the repeated dropping of increments at randomly chosen sites @xmath3 ( one per time - step ) @xmath6 where @xmath7 has all its components as random numbers uniformly distributed in @xmath8 $ ] . after each loading event , the system is checked for whether the local stress , defined as @xmath9 where the sum goes over the six nearest neighbours of the central point @xmath3 , exceeds a threshold @xmath10 , i.e. whether @xmath11 where @xmath12 is used . if this is the case , the field in the neighbourhood of the critical site is redistributed according to @xmath13 for the central point , and @xmath14 for its six nearest neighbours . in such a redistribution event ( burst ) , energy amounting to @xmath15 is assumed to be released . the grid is scanned again and again to search for second , third etc . generation bursts , until the system is nowhere critical anymore and returns to the loading phase ( the details we apply concerning the temporal evolution of the model are given in app . a ; they are not explicitly stated in lh91 ) . the field outside the grid is held constant and assumed to be zero . we turn now to introducing our set - up , starting with a specification : we interpret the vector @xmath4 at the grid sites @xmath3 to denote the local vector - field , @xmath16 . note that this was not specified in the classical ca models . lu et al . ( 1993 ) for instance discuss this point : it might also have been thought of as a mean local field , i.e. the average over an elementary cell in the grid . guided by the idea that we want to assure @xmath17 for the magnetic field @xmath1 , which is most easily achieved by having the vector - potential @xmath2 as the primary variable and letting @xmath1 be the corresponding derivative of @xmath2 ( @xmath18 ) , we furthermore assume that the grid variable @xmath2 of the ca model is identical with the vector - potential . the remaining and actually most basic problem then is to find an adequate way to calculate derivatives in the grid . in general , ca models assume that the grid - spacing is finite , which also holds for the ca model of lh91 ( as shown in detail by isliker et al . 1998 ) , so that the most straightforward way of replacing differential expressions with difference expressions is not adequate ( see the detailed discussion in app . b.1 , below ; vassiliadis et al . ( 1998 ) suggested to interpret ca models as the straightforwardly discretized ( simplified ) mhd equations , which we find problematic for the reasons given in app . b.1 , and we therefore do not follow this approach , here ) . consequently , one has to find a way of continuing the vector - field into the space in - between the grid - sites , which will allow to calculate derivatives . there is , of course , an infinite number of possibilities to do so , and the problem can not have a unique solution . adequate possibilities definitely include : a ) continuation of @xmath2 with the help of an equation ( e.g. demanding the resulting @xmath1-field to be potential or force - free ) ; b ) interpolation , either locally ( in a neighbourhood ) , or globally ( through the whole grid ) . trying several methods , we concluded that 3d cubic spline interpolation is particularly adequate to the problem since it has remarkable advantages over other methods ( e.g. it does not introduce oscillations in - between grid - sites , which would strongly influence the values of the derivatives , and it well reproduces the derivatives of analytically prescribed primary fields ) . the process of evaluating different continuation methods we went through , as well as the comparison of spline interpolation to other continuation - methods are described in app . b. the 3d interpolation is performed as three subsequent 1d interpolations in the three spatial directions ( press et al . 1992 ) . for the 1d splines , we assume natural boundaries ( the second derivatives are zero at the boundaries ) . moreover , since in the ca model of lh91 it is assumed that around the grid there is a zero field which is held constant ( see sec . 2.1 ) , we enlarge the grid by one grid point in all directions to include this constant zero - layer explicitly , using it however only for the interpolation . in the interpolation , the derivatives at the grid - points are immediately given by the analytically differentiated interpolating polynomials . with the help of this interpolation , the magnetic field @xmath1 and the current @xmath19 are calculated as derivatives of @xmath2 , according to the mhd prescription : @xmath20 @xmath21 to determine the electric field @xmath22 , we make the assumption that under coronal conditions the mhd approach is in general valid , and that @xmath22 is reasonably well approximated by ohm s law in its simple form , @xmath23 , with @xmath24 the diffusivity and @xmath25 the fluid velocity . since the classical ca models use no velocity - field , our set - up can yield only the resistive part , @xmath26 in applications such as to solar flares , where the interest is in current dissipation events , i.e. in events where @xmath24 and @xmath19 are strongly increased , eq . ( 9 ) can be expected to be a good approximation to the electric field . theoretically , the convective term in ohm s law would in general yield just a low - intensity , background electric field . ( 9 ) needs to be supplemented with a specification of the diffusivity @xmath24 : isliker et al . ( 1998 ) have shown that in the classical ca models the diffusivity adopts the values @xmath27 at the unstable ( bursting ) sites , and @xmath28 everywhere else . this specifies eq . ( 9 ) completely . _ remark 1 : _ it is worthwhile noting that , since spline interpolation has the property to be the least curved of all twice differentiable interpolating functions , the grid - size is a typical smallest - possible length - scale of field structures , or , if we would think the ca to model mhd turbulence , it is something like an average smallest possible eddy - size . _ remark 2 : _ with our set - up , field lines are made available : the interpolation was introduced to define derivatives at the grid - sites , but it can as well be used to determine the vector - potential , and therewith the magnetic field and the current , in between the grid sites . however , it is important to note that this field in between the grid sites is not used for the time - evolution of the model , it merely allows to visualize the evolution in the standard way through field - lines , if wished so ( second order derivatives in - between the grid - sites , if needed , would have to be done numerically , since else their numerical values would depend on the order in which the three 1d interpolations are done ) . _ remark 3 : _ in this paper , we do not change the rules of the classical ca models to which we apply our set - up except for the definition of energy release ( sec . our aim here is to show the usefulness of the set - up and to give some results and reveal some aspects by extending published , classical ca models . while the redistribution rules have in detail been shown to represent diffusion events and fit nicely into an mhd scenario ( isliker et al . 1998 ) , the loading process is strongly simplified and poorly follows a reasonable flare scenario : for instance , the loading process acts independently everywhere in the simulation box , whereas according to a realistic flare scenario ( see e.g. parker 1993 ) disturbances should appear independently only on one boundary ( the photosphere , due to random foot - point motions or newly appearing flux ) , and propagate then into the interior of the simulation box along the magnetic field lines . to translate such a realistic loading scenario into the language of ca models has not been undertaken , so - far . we just note that it would be quite straightforward to introduce a velocity field into the ca models : e.g. isliker et al . ( 2000a ) propose a ca model which uses a velocity field for the loading phase , but this model does not fall into the category of classical ca models since it does not follow the sand - pile analogy and uses different , mhd based , evolution rules . we leave the problem of introducing a velocity field and a more physical loading process into the classical ca models for a future study . in isliker . 2000b , we will among others analyze in details what this simplified loading process physically represents . our first application is to the ca model of lh91 ( see sec . the lh91 model has a fairly long transient phase and reaches finally a stationary state , the so - called soc ( self - organized criticality ) state , in which spatially spreading series of bursts ( avalanches ) appear , alternating with quiet loading phases . the lh91 model gives basically three results concerning flare statistics , namely the distributions of total energy , peak - flux and durations , which are all power - laws with slopes that are in good agreement with the observations ( lu et al . 1993 , bromund et al . 1995 ) . superimposing our mhd - frame onto the lh91 model such as it stands does not change anyone of the three results , since at this first stage we are not interfering with the dynamics ( i.e. the evolution rules ) . the set - up allows , however , to address several questions in mhd language : our main aim in the subsequent applications is to demonstrate that the set - up indeed yields a new and consistent interpretation of ca - models , to illustrate the behaviour of the secondary variables ( currents , magnetic fields ) , and to reveal major features of them . ( in the subsequent runs , we use a grid of size @xmath29 , as lh91 did to derive their main results . ) first , we turn to the question what the global fields ( vector - potential , magnetic field , current ) look like during the soc state . thereto , the temporal evolution of the model is stopped at an arbitrary time during soc state ( in a phase where there are no bursts , i.e. during loading ) , and the magnitude of the fields at a cut with fixed @xmath30-coordinate are shown as a function of the @xmath31- and @xmath32-coordinates in fig . 1 . @xmath33 obviously exhibits a large - scale organization over the whole grid , it forms a global convex surface ( fig . this convex surface has a slight random distortion over - lying , which visually can not be discerned in fig . 1(a ) , but becomes visible in the plot of @xmath34 ( fig . 1(b ) ) , the curl of @xmath2 , which still exhibits large - scale organization all over the grid , but is clearly wiggled . finally , @xmath35 shows no left - overs of a large scale organization anymore , it reflects the random disturbances of the convexity of @xmath36 ( fig . 1(c ) ) . the large - scale structures shown in fig . 1 are always maintained during the soc state , neither loading nor bursting ( and avalanches ) destroy them , they just tremble a little when such events occur . soc state in the extended lh91 model thus implies large - scale organization of the vector - potential and the magnetic field , in the characteristic form of fig . 1 . the large - scale organization of @xmath2 is not an artificial result of our superimposed set - up , but already inherent in the classical lh91 model : in the classical lh91 ca model , there is only one variable , the one we call here @xmath2 , whose values are not affected by the interpolation we perform since it is the primary grid variable , so that fig . 1(a ) is true also for the classical , non - extended lh91 model . the large scale structure for the primary grid - variable @xmath37 is the result of a combined effect : the preferred directionality of the loading increments ( see sec . 2.1 ) tries to increase @xmath37 throughout the grid . the redistribution events , which already in bak et al . ( 1987 ; 1988 ) were termed diffusive events , and which in isliker et al . ( 1998 ) were analytically shown to represent local , one - time - step diffusion processes , smooth out any too strong spatial unevenness of @xmath2 , and they root the @xmath2-field down to the zero level at the open boundaries . the result is the convex surface of fig . 1(a ) , blown - up from below through loading , tied to the zero - level at the edges , and forced to a maximum curvature which is limited by the local , threshold dependent diffusion events . as the soc state , so is the large - scale structure of @xmath37 independent of the concrete kind of loading , provided it fulfills the conditions that the loading increments exhibit a preferred directionality and are much smaller than the threshold ( with symmetric loading , the soc state is actually never reached , see lh91 and lu et al . ( 1993 ) ) . to make sure of the importance of the boundaries , we performed runs of the model with closed boundaries , and we found that neither a large - scale structure was developed in @xmath37 , nor the soc state was reached . to illustrate the role of the current at unstable sites and during bursts , we plot in fig . 2 the magnitude of the current before and after a typical burst : obviously , the current at the burst site @xmath38 has high intensity before the burst ( fig . 2(a ) ) , and is relaxed after the burst ( fig . inspecting a number of other bursts , we found that , generally , at sites where the lh91 instability criterion is fulfilled , the current is increased , too , and that bursts dissipate the currents . this is a first hint that classical ca models can be interpreted as models for energy release through current - dissipation . after the burst , at the neighbouring site @xmath39 , the intensity of the current is increased , and indeed the presented burst gives rise to subsequent bursts , it is one event during an avalanche . the magnetic field at the bursting site is reshaped , in a way which is difficult to interpret when using only the magnitude of it ( @xmath34 ) for visualization . may - be field line plots would help visualization , but we leave this for a future study . we now turn to the question what relation the energy release formula of lh91 ( eq . 6 ) has to the respective mhd relations : in parallel to using the formula of lh91 , we determine the released energy in the following ways , closer to mhd : first , we assume it to be proportional to @xmath40 ( with the diffusivity @xmath41 at unstable sites , see sec . 2.2 ) , which we linearly interpolate between the two states before and after the burst . this is done in two ways , ( i ) summing over the local neighbourhood , @xmath42 and ( ii ) without summing , but just taking into account the current at the central point , @xmath43 and finally , we monitor the change in magnetic energy due to a burst using the difference in magnetic energy in the local neighbourhood , @xmath44 ( in eqs . ( 10 ) , ( 11 ) , ( 12 ) , we assume @xmath45 and @xmath46 for the grid - spacing @xmath47 and the time - step @xmath48 , since , according to isliker et al . ( 1998 ) , in the classical ca models both values are not specified and set to one . ) the corresponding distributions of total energy and peak - flux are shown in fig . 3 , together with the distributions yielded by the energy - release formula of lh91 , eq . ( 6 ) ( the duration distribution remains the same as in the classical lh91 model , namely a power - law , and is not shown ) . obviously , the four ways of defining the released energy give basically similar results , with larger deviations only at the low and high energy ends ( note that the energy in fig . 3 is in arbitrary units ) . using the formula of ohmic dissipation does thus not change the results of the classical lh91 model . with an estimate of the numerical value of the anomalous resistivity and of the typical size of a diffusive region or the typical diffusive time , it would be possible to introduce physical units . we did not undertake this , since all three parameters are still known only with large observational and theoretical uncertainties . from the similarity of the distributions of the extended model with the ones of the classical lh91 model ( fig . 3 ) , and from fig . 2 , where it was seen that an instability is accompanied by an enhanced current , we are led to ask directly for the relation of @xmath49 to @xmath19 , which we plot as a function of each other in fig . 4 . obviously , the two quantities are related to each other : above @xmath50 , the current is an approximate linear function of the stress , around @xmath50 the current is zero , and below there is again an approximate linear relationship , with negative slope , however ( above @xmath50 the current @xmath19 is actually preferably along @xmath51 , whereas below it is preferably along @xmath52 , i.e. @xmath19 is an approximatly linear function of @xmath49 in the whole range , it merely changes its directivity at @xmath50 with respect to @xmath49 ) . in appendix c , we show analytically why with our set - up a more or less close relation between @xmath49 and @xmath19 has to be expected . of particular interest in fig . 4 is that if @xmath53 is above the threshold @xmath12 , then @xmath54 is also reaching high values : obviously , large values of @xmath53 imply large values of @xmath54 . this confirms the statement made above : the extended ca models can be considered as models for energy release through current dissipation . it also explains why the energy distributions remain very similar when the lh91 formula for the amount of energy released in a burst ( @xmath55 , eq . ( 6 ) ) is replaced by ohmic dissipation ( @xmath56 , sec . 3.1.3 ) : bursts occur only for large stresses @xmath53 , where @xmath54 is also large and an approximate linear function of @xmath53 , so that the distributions of @xmath57 and @xmath58 can be expected to be the same in shape . georgoulis and vlahos ( 1996 , 1998 ) introduced power - law distributed increments for the loading . the main result of such a way of driving the system is that the power - law indices of the energy - distributions depend on the power - law index of the distribution of the loading increments , explaining thus the observed variability of the indices through the variability of the intensity of the driving . we generalize their way of power - law loading , which is for a scalar primary field , to a vector field in the following way : the anisotropic directivity of the loading increment @xmath59 is kept ( see sec . 2.1 ) , but @xmath60 is now distributed according to @xmath61 with @xmath62 $ ] and @xmath63 , the power - law index , a free parameter . simulations were performed for @xmath64 and @xmath65 . interested in global features implied by the ca model , our concern here is the structure of the magnetic field . it turns out that the magnetic field exhibits still a large scale organization , which is very similar to the one of the @xmath1-field of the ( extended with our set - up ) lh91 model ( fig . 1(b ) ) : for @xmath66 , the respective plots are visually indiscernible , and for @xmath67 the overall shape is still roughly the same , it merely seems slightly more distorted . thus , though the statistical results depend on @xmath63 , the strength and variability of the loading , the structure of the magnetic field remains approximately the same as in the case of the extended model of lh91 . large - scale organization ( in the characteristic form of fig . 1 ) must consequently be considered as an inherent property of soc state , through the mechanism explained in sec . 3.1.1 . vlahos et al . ( 1995 ) introduced anisotropic bursts for solar flare ca models , which lead only to small events , but yield a steep distribution at small energies , predicting thus a significant over - abundance of small events with a significant contribution to coronal heating . we have first to generalize the anisotropic evolution rules , which are again for a scalar primary field , to the case of a primary vector field . a natural generalization would be to apply the anisotropic rules to the absolute magnitude of @xmath2 , but it turns out that this causes the algorithm to get trapped in infinite loops ( two neighbouring grid - sites trigger each other mutually for ever ) . the same holds if we apply the anisotropic rules to the absolute magnitudes of the three components of @xmath2 independently . we finally applied the anisotropic rules to the three components of @xmath2 directly , not using absolute magnitudes , as also vlahos et al . ( 1995 ) did not use absolute magnitudes , and this turned out to lead to a stationary asymptotic state : the anisotropic stress in the @xmath31-component is thus defined as @xmath68 where @xmath69 stands for one of the six nearest neighbours . the instability criterion is @xmath70 and the redistribution rules become @xmath71 for the central point and @xmath72 for those nearest neighbours which fulfill the instability criterion ( eq . 15 ) , where the primed sum is over those neighbours for which eq . ( 15 ) holds . the rules for @xmath73 are completely analogous ( so that actually there are 18 possibilities to exceed the threshold ( eq . 15 ) at a given site ) . the released energy is assumed to amount to @xmath74 we performed a run where only the anisotropic burst - rules were applied , in order to isolate their effect , although the anisotropic burst - rules are used always together with the isotropic ones by vlahos et al . ( 1995 ) , since alone they can not explain the complete energy distributions of flares . in fig . 5 , the magnitude of the magnetic field at a cut through the grid is shown ( fixed @xmath30 ) , for an arbitrary time ( in the loading phase ) during the asymptotic stationary state of the model . clearly , there is no overall large scale structure anymore , except that the magnetic field along the boundaries is increased . the magnetic field topology is thus nearer to the concept of a random , relatively unstructured magnetic field than the magnetic field topology yielded by the isotropic models in soc state . the anisotropic burst rules do not yield large - scale structures , as they are , when used alone , also not able to lead the system to soc state : this is obvious from the energy distributions they yield , which are much smaller in extent than the ones given by the isotropic rules ( see vlahos et al . 1995 ) , and confirmed by the result of lu et al . ( 1993 ) that isotropy of the redistribution rules at least on the average is a prerequisite to reach soc state , at all . the anisotropic bursts occur independently in all directions and are in this way not able to organize the field in a neighbourhood systematically , and , as a consequence , also not in the entire grid . the inquiry of the relation of the energy release formula eq . ( 18 ) , which is different from the isotropic formula ( eq . 6 ) , to mhd based formulae we leave for a future study . we just note that the distributions the anisotropic model in our vector - field version yields are at lower energies , smaller in extent , and steeper than the ones of the isotropic models . we have introduced a new set - up for classical solar flare ca models which yields , among others , consistency with maxwell s equations ( e.g. divergence - free magnetic field ) , and availability of secondary variables such as currents and electric fields in accordance with mhd . both are new for solar flare ca models . the set - up specifies the so far open physical interpretation of the ca models . this specification is to some extent unavoidably arbitrary , and it would definitely be interesting to see what alternative interpretations would yield if they can be derived consistently . we can claim , however , that the interpretation we chose is reasonable , it is well - behaved in the sense that the derivatives of analytically prescribed vector - potentials are reproduced and that the abstract stress - measure of the ca models is related to the current , due to general properties of spline interpolation . the central problem which was to solve is how to calculate derivatives in a ca model , i.e. how to continue the primary grid - variable in - between the grid sites , since the notion of derivatives is alien in the context of ca models quite in general . in this article , our main aim with the introduced set - up was to demonstrate that the set - up truly extends the classical ca models and makes them richer in the sense that they contain much more information , now . the main features we revealed about the ca models , extended with our set - up , are : * 1 . large - scale organization of the vector - potential and the magnetic field : * the field topology during soc state is bound to characteristic large - scale structures which span the whole grid , very pronounced for the primary grid variable , the vector - potential , but also for the magnetic field . bursts and flares are just slight disturbances propagating over the large - scale structures , which are always maintained , also in the largest events . the magnitude of the current , as a second order derivative of the primary field , does not show any obvious large - scale structure anymore , it reflects more or less only the random fluctuations of the large - scale organized magnetic field . it is worthwhile noting that the large - scale structure of the primary grid - variable is not an artificial result of our set - up , but a natural consequence of the soc state in which the system finds itself . the appearance of large - scale structures for the primary grid variable was shown here for the first time . it may have been known to different authors , but it never has explicitly been shown : soc models for flares are derived in analogy to sand - pile dynamics , and the paradigm of a pile reappears in the field topologies of the solar flare ca models . * 2 . increased current at unstable grid - sites : * unstable sites are characterized by an enhanced current , which is reduced after a burst has taken place , as a result of which the current at a grid - site in the neighbourhood may be increased . * availability of the electric field : * the electric field is approximated with the resistive part of ohm s law in its simple form , which can in general be expected to be a good approximation in coronal applications and where the interest is in current - dissipation events , e.g. in the case of solar flares . energy release in terms of ohmic dissipation : * we replaced the some - what _ ad hoc _ formula in the ca models to estimate the energy released in a burst with the expression for ohmic dissipation in terms of the current . the distributions yielded in this way are very similar to the ones based on the ad hoc formula , so that the results of the ca models remain basically unchanged . * ca as models for current dissipations : * as a consequence of point 2 and 4 in this list , and of the fact that there is an approximate linear relation between the current and the stress measure of the ca , we can conclude that the _ extended _ ca models can be considered as models for energy release through current dissipation . our set - up is to be contrasted to the recently suggested mhd - derived ( not based on the sand - pile analogy ) ca models of einaudi & velli ( 1999 ) , macpherson & mackinnon ( 1999 ) , longcope and noonan ( 2000 ) , and isliker et al . ( 2000a ) . they all suggest new evolution rules , derived from mhd , and all in different ways ( they actually focus on different processes , namely the microscopic , macroscopic , and mesoscopic physics , respectively , in active regions ) . our set - up , on the other hand , uses existing ca models , does not interfere ( if not wished ) with their evolution rules , does also not change their main results , as shown , but reinterprets them , extends them essentially , and makes them compatible with mhd . the set - up we introduced allows different future applications and posing questions which could not be asked so far in the frame of ca models . in preparation is a study ( isliker et al . 2000b ) to reveal in detail what physical flare scenario the extended ca models imply . we will address the questions : ( 1 ) how to interpret the small scale processes of the models ( loading and bursting ) in terms of mhd ; ( 2 ) what the _ global _ flare - scenario implied by the models is ; ( 3 ) whether the global magnetic field topology of the models can be considered to represent observed magnetic topologies in active regions ; ( 4 ) what spatio - temporal evolution of the electric field during flares is yielded by the models . a different future application we plan with ca models extended with our set - up is the introduction of particles into the models , with the aim to study thermal emission , particle acceleration , and non - thermal emission . this will allow a much deeper comparison of the ca models to observations than was possible so far , and this is actually the most important benefit of the set - up we introduced . such comparisons will allow a new judgment of the adequateness or not of classical ca models ( in their current form ) to the problem of solar flares , beyond the three statistical distributions of the primarily released energy . solar flare ca models which include particle acceleration would represent the first global and complete model for solar flares . we thank k. tsiganis and m. georgoulis for many helpful discussions on several issues . we also thank g. einaudi for stimulating discussions on mhd aspects of flares , and the referee a.l . mackinnon for useful comments . the work of h. isliker was partly supported by a grant of the swiss national science foundation ( nf grant nr . 8220 - 046504 ) . the temporal evolution of the ca models presented in this article is governed by the following rules : * initializing * loading * scanning : create a list of the unstable sites ; if there are none , return to loading ( 1 ) * scanning and bursting : redistribute the fields at the unstable sites which are in the list created in the scannings 2 or 4 * scanning : create a list of the unstable sites . if there are any , go to bursting ( 3 ) , else return to loading ( 1 ) the extra scannings 2 and 4 are needed for causality : if a site becomes unstable through a burst in the neighbourhood , then it should be redistributed in the subsequent scan , and not in the same as the primary unstable site . the same is true for the scanning 4 , since in the next bursting phase ( if any ) only those sites should burst who had become unstable through a burst in their neighbourhood during the foregoing time - step . as a time - step is considered one scanning of the grid , point 3 . the released energy per time - step is the sum of all the energy released by bursts in this time - step ( a burst is considered a single redistribution event in 3 ) . we term a flare or avalanche the loop 3,4 , from the occurring of the first burst in 3 until the activity has died out and one returns via the scanning 4 to loading ( 1 ) . the duration of the flare is the number of time - steps it lasted , the total flare energy is the sum of all the energies released in the duration of the flare , and the peak flux or peak energy is the maximum of the energies of all the time - steps of the flare . we mentioned in sec . 2.2 that other possibilities for continuation of the vector - potential besides spline interpolation would be : a ) continuation of @xmath2 with the help of an equation ; b ) other kinds of interpolation , either locally ( in a neighbourhood ) , or globally ( through the whole grid ) . possibility a ) implies that an equation has to be solved in each time - step ( after each loading and after each burst ) , in the worst case numerically , with open boundary condition and the @xmath4 given at the grid - sites . this computational effort might slow down the algorithm of the model considerably ( and bring it near to the computational effort of mhd equation integration ) . besides that , the problem is what equation to use : to make the magnetic field always a potential field ( i.e. using a corresponding equation for the vector - potential @xmath2 ) implies that , from the point of view of mhd , at all times a very well - behaved magnetic field resides in the ca , with no tendency towards instabilities , which makes it difficult to understand why bursts should occur at all , since critical quantities such as currents do not become excited . a better candidate could be expected to be force - freeness , except that , possibly , one may be confronted with incompatibility of the boundary conditions with the vector - potential values given at the grid - sites , i.e. existence - problems for solutions eventually arise . though definitely possibility a ) can not be ruled out on solid grounds , we found it more promising to proceed with possibility b ) , interpolation . a guide - line for choosing a particular interpolation method is the reasonable demand that the interpolation should not introduce wild oscillations in - between grid - sites , for we want to assure that the derivatives at the grid sites , which are very sensitive to such oscillations , are not random values solely due to the interpolation , but that they reflect more or less directly the change of the primary grid - variable from grid - site to grid - site . this calls for interpolating functions which are as little curved as possible . the easiest and fastest way of interpolating would be to perform local interpolations around a point and its nearest neighbours ( e.g. using low - order polynomials or trigonometric functions of different degrees ) . this interpolation leads , however , to ambiguities for the derivatives : the derivatives , say at a point @xmath3 , are not the same , if the used interpolation is centered at @xmath3 , with the ones calculated with an interpolation centered at e.g. @xmath75 . in this sense , local interpolation is not self - consistent , the derivatives at a grid - site depend on where the used interpolation is centered . finally , we are left with global interpolation through the whole grid . among the candidates are , besides more exotic interpolating functions , polynomials of degree equal to the grid size , trigonometric functions ( also in the form of fourier - transforms ) , low - order smooth polynomials ( e.g. splines ) . the first candidate , polynomials of a high degree @xmath76 ( with @xmath76 the number of grid points in one direction ) , we reject immediately since it is notorious for its strong oscillations in - between grid - sites , mainly towards the edges of the grid . we tried the second candidate , trigonometric interpolation , in the form of discrete fourier transform . testing this by prescribing analytic functions for @xmath77 and comparing the numerical derivatives with the analytic ones , it turned out that there arise problems with representing structures in @xmath2 as large as the entire grid ( the wave - number spectrum is too limited ) , and with structures as short as roughly the grid - spacing ( different prescribed short structures are taken for the same ) . trying cubic spline - interpolation , we found that it does not suffer from the problems stated for the other types of interpolation : neither does it introduce wild oscillations , unmotivated by the values at the grid - sites , nor does spline interpolation have problems with describing large or small scale structures ( if a functional form of @xmath2 is prescribed , then the analytic derivatives and the derivatives yielded by the interpolation give very close values , in general ) . moreover , based on results of sec . 3 , app . c , and isliker et al . ( 1998 ) , there is another reason why spline - interpolation is particularly adequate to our problem : it relates the quantity @xmath49 ( eq . ( 2 ) ) , which measures the stress at a site in the ca model , closely to @xmath78 , the laplacian of @xmath2 ( see app . the latter is related to the current ( @xmath79 ) , which , from the point of view of mhd , can be considered as a measure of stress in the magnetic field configuration . if this relation would not hold , then the redistribution rules ( eqs . ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) ) of the ca would not be interpretable as the diffusion process revealed by isliker et al . ( 1998 ) , and the instability criterion ( eq . 3 ) would not be so closely related to the current ( see sec . 3 and app . we had rejected above ( sec . 1 , sec . 2.2 ) the use of difference expressions to calculate derivatives , stating that differencing is not in the spirit of ca models quite in general , since the nature of ca is truly discrete . we think it worthwhile to make this argument more concrete and to show what problems arise if differencing were used : isliker et al . ( 1998 ) have shown that the classical solar flare ca are not just the discretized form of a differential equations . instead , they describe the time - evolution of a system by rules which express the direct transition from a given initial to a final state which is the asymptotic solution of a simple diffusion equation . the time - step corresponds therewith to the average time needed for smallest scale structures ( structures as large as a neighbourhood ) to diffuse , and the grid - size corresponds to the size of these smallest occurring structures . assuming that the ca models were just discretized differential equations would lead to severe mathematical and physical contradictions and inconsistencies ( continuity for @xmath80 is violated ( with @xmath47 the grid - size ) , and negative diffusivities appear ) . therewith , in order to be consistent with the evolution rules , which assume a finite grid - size , one can not assume for the purpose of differentiating this same grid - size to be approximately infinitesimal . there are several equivalent ways to define numerical derivatives with the use of difference expressions : there are e.g. the backward difference @xmath81 , and the forward difference @xmath82 . both should give comparable values in a given application , else , in the context of differential equation integration , one would have to make the resolution higher . in the case of ca - models , we find that the two difference expressions yield values which differ substantially from each other : e.g. for an initial loading of the grid with independent random values for the @xmath2-field , the difference between the backward and the forward difference expression can be as large as the field itself . such an initial condition would of course not make sense in the context of partial differential equations , in the context of ca , however , it is a reasonable starting configuration , and the evolution is unaffected by such an initial loading . moreover , when the ca models we discuss in this article have reached the soc state , then the differences between e.g. the backward- and forward - difference expressions can be as large as 400% . there is no way to reduce this discrepancy , since grid - refinement is principally impossible for ca : the evolution is governed by a set of rules , and making the grid spacing smaller by introducing new grid - points in - between the old ones would actually just mean to make the grid larger , since the evolution rules remain the same , there are no rules for half the grid - spacing . the stress measure of lh91 , @xmath84 , can be related to continuous expressions by representing the values of @xmath85 as taylor - series expansions around @xmath3 , setting the spatial differences to @xmath86 . it turns out that e.g. @xmath87 and so on for the other two components . _ in general , _ it is therefore _ not _ adequate to consider @xmath49 to be a good 4th order approximation to @xmath88 , since higher order corrections can be large , they depend on the way the vector potential is continued in - between grid - sites . if we had , for instance , chosen global polynomial interpolation instead of spline - interpolation , the higher order terms would not be negligible , above all towards the edges of the grid , since polynomial interpolation is known for introducing fluctuations near the edges of the grid . consequently , @xmath49 would be a bad approximation to @xmath88 . in order @xmath49 to be a good approximation to @xmath88 , interpolation with , for example , 3rd order polynomials would be an optimum choice ( @xmath49 would be an exact approximation to @xmath88 ) . thus , 3rd order polynomials would be the choice for local interpolation , which , however , is not applicable , since it introduces discontinuities in @xmath1 and @xmath19 ( see app . the way out of the dilemma we suggested in this article is the use of cubic splines , which provide global interpolation with 3rd order polynomials , with @xmath1 and @xmath19 continuous , and only third order derivatives are discontinuous ( this is the price of the compromise ) . for splines then , eq . ( c.1 ) writes as @xmath89,\end{aligned}\ ] ] due to the discontinuities in the 3rd order derivatives ( the superscripts @xmath90 and @xmath91 refer to the right and left derivative , respectively ) . thus , in case where the third order right and left derivatives are not too different , @xmath49 is a good approximation to @xmath88 . isliker , h. , anastasiadis , a. , vlahos , l. , 2000a , a solar flare model in between mhd and cellular automaton , in the fourth astronomical conference of the hellenic astronomical society , eds . seimenis , j. et al .
Abstract: | [
"a set - up is introduced which can be superimposed onto the existing solar flare cellular automata ( ca ) models , and which specifies the interpretation of the model s variables . it extends the ca models , yielding the magnetic field , the current , and an approximation to the electric field , in a way that is consistent with maxwell s and the mhd equations . applications to several solar flare ca models during their natural state ( self - organized criticality ( soc ) ) show , among others , that ( 1 ) the magnetic field exhibits _ characteristic large - scale organization _ over the entire modeled volume ; ( 2 ) the magnitude of the current seems spatially dis - organized , with no obvious tendency towards large - scale structures or even local organization ; ( 3 ) bursts occur at sites with increased current , and after a burst the current is relaxed ; ( 4 ) by estimating the energy released in individual bursts with the use of the current as ohmic dissipation , it turns out that the power - law distributions of the released energy persist . the ca models , extended with the set - up , can thus be considered as _ models for energy - release through current - dissipation_. the concepts of power - law loading and anisotropic events ( bursts ) in ca models are generalized to 3d vector - field models , and their effect on the magnetic field topology is demonstrated . = cmr8 = cmcsc10 = ~ # 1#1"
] | 9,599 | 9,599 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: stability and interactions in biological and soft - matter systems often depends on the underlying properties of electrostatic interactions @xcite . charges on macromolecular surfaces in aqueous environments , as in the case of membranes , self - assembled micelles , globular proteins and fibrous polysaccharides , affect a wealth of functional , structural and dynamical properties @xcite . the traditional approach to charged ( bio)colloidal systems has been the mean - field poisson - boltzmann ( pb ) formalism applicable at weak surface charges , low counter - ion valency and high temperature @xcite . the limitations of this approach become practically important in highly - charged systems where counterion - mediated interactions between charged bodies start to deviate substantially from the mean - field accepted wisdom @xcite . one of the fundamental recent advances in this field has been the systematization of these non - pb effects based on the notions of _ weak _ and _ strong _ coupling approximations . the latter approach has been pioneered by rouzina and bloomfield @xcite , elaborated later by shklovskii _ et al . _ @xcite , levin _ et al . _ @xcite , and brought into final form by netz _ these two approximations allow for an explicit and exact treatment of charged systems at two disjoint _ limiting conditions _ whereas the parameter space in between can be analyzed only approximately @xcite and is mostly accessible solely _ via _ computer simulations @xcite . in the absence of a general approach that would cover thoroughly all the regions of the parameter space one has to take recourse to various partial formulations that take into account only this or that facet of the problem . in this respect the counterion - only or the one - component coulomb fluid model system has proved to be of substantial value @xcite . heuristically as well as numerically . a proper understanding of the behavior of charged systems would thus start with the analysis of counter - ion distribution around charged macromolecular surfaces , neglecting completely the effects of salt . both the weak and the strong coupling approximations are based on a functional integral or field - theoretic representation @xcite of the grand canonical partition function of a system composed of fixed surface charges with intervening mobile counterions , and depend on the value of a single dimensionless coupling parameter @xmath0 @xcite . the distance at which two unit charges interact with thermal energy @xmath1 is known as the bjerrum length @xmath2 ( in water at room temperature , one has @xmath3 nm ) . if the charge valency of the counterions is @xmath4 then the aforementioned distance scales as @xmath5 . similarly , the distance at which a counterion interacts with a macromolecular surface ( of surface charge density @xmath6 ) with an energy equal to @xmath1 is called the gouy - chapman length , defined as @xmath7 . a competition between ion - ion and ion - surface interactions can be quantitatively measured with a ratio of these characteristic lengths , that is @xmath8 , which is known as the ( netz - moreira ) electrostatic coupling parameter @xcite . the weak coupling ( wc ) regime @xmath9 ( appropriate for low valency counterions and/or weakly charged surfaces ) , is characterized by the fact that the width of the counterion layer @xmath10 is much larger than the separation between two neighboring counterions in solution and thus the counterion layer behaves basically as a three - dimensional gas . each counterion in this case interacts with many others and the collective mean - field approach of the poisson - boltzmann ( pb ) type is completely justified . on the other hand in the strong coupling ( sc ) regime @xmath11 ( appropriate for high valency counterions and/or highly charged surfaces ) , the mean distance between counterions , @xmath12 , is much larger than the layer width ( _ i.e. _ , @xmath13 ) , indicating that the counterions are highly localized laterally and form a strongly correlated quasi - two - dimensional layer next to a charged surface . in this case , the weak - coupling approach breaks down due to strong counterion - surface and counterion - counterion correlations . since counterions can move almost independently from the others along the direction perpendicular to the surface , the collective many - body effects that enable a mean - field description are absent , necessitating a complementary sc description @xcite . the range of validity of both limiting theories at intermediate values of the coupling parameter has been explored thoroughly in the literature @xcite . formally the weak coupling limit can be straightforwardly identified with the saddle - point approximation of the field theoretic representation of the grand canonical partition function , and is reduced to the mean - field pb theory in the lowest order for @xmath14 . the quadratic fluctuations around the mean field provide a second - order correction to the mean - field solution for small finite @xmath15 @xcite . the strong coupling approximation has no pb - like correlates @xcite since it is formally equivalent to a single particle description obtained from a systematic @xmath16 expansion in the limit @xmath17 , and corresponds to two lowest order terms in the virial expansion of the grand canonical partition function . the consequences and the formalism of these two limits of the coulomb fluid description have been explored widely and in detail ( for reviews , see refs . @xcite ) . considering the inhomogeneity of charged surfaces in various biological contexts it has always been of interest to investigate not just electrostatic interactions between symmetrical charged surfaces , _ i.e. _ those bearing equal charges of the same sign , but also interactions between surfaces bearing unequal charges or even charges of opposite sign @xcite . this problem has a venerable history starting from the seminal work of parsegian and gingell @xcite who formulated a linearized pb theory of the interactions in the presence of salt . the linearization _ ansatz _ was later generalized in the work of lau and pincus @xcite and ben - yaakov _ et al . _ @xcite who formulated the appropriate non - linear mean - field theory of non - symmetric electrostatic interactions . it is thus our goal in this contribution to show how and to what extent the asymmetry in the distribution of charges on two apposed planar surfaces affects the interactions between macromolecular surfaces carrying them . below we shall present a complete analysis of the asymmetric case in the weak coupling limit , _ i.e. _ the mean - field poisson - boltzmann theory supplemented with a quadratic - fluctuations analysis , as well as in the strong coupling limit _ via _ the asymptotic strong - coupling theory and evaluate how these analytical results compare with extensive numerical simulations . we will show that in their respective regimes of validity ( _ i.e. _ small / large couplings ) both approximations present a very accurate quantitative statistical description of the system . in our model system we consider uniform surface charge distributions on two plane - parallel surfaces ( located at @xmath18 ) given by the surface charge density of the form @xmath19 we may interchangeably use the half - separation @xmath20 , or @xmath21 to identify the surface - surface distance . we assume furthermore that the charge of both bounding surfaces is compensated by mobile counterions of charge valency @xmath4 immersed in an aqueous medium of dielectric constant @xmath22 and distributed in between the two surfaces ( see fig . [ fig : geometry ] ) . we thus neglect all coions . this approximation is relevant for low salt concentrations where the debye screening length is much larger than the scales of interest @xcite . we consider the surfaces as impenetrable to counterions and neglect the dielectric discontinuity across the bounding surfaces which was addressed at various levels of approximation in @xcite . without loss of generality we can assume here that @xmath23 and @xmath24 it will be helpful for our later developments to introduce an _ asymmetry parameter _ @xmath25 that will allow us to quantify the dissimilarity between the two bounding surfaces as @xmath26 furthermore , by suitably normalizing the results one can concentrate exclusively on the interval @xmath27 . all other cases can be mapped onto this interval with appropriate rescaling of the parameters . the values @xmath28 and @xmath29 represent exceptional points in the parameter space : @xmath28 is the standard symmetric case ( @xmath30 ) already amply treated in the literature , and @xmath29 represents the antisymmetric case ( @xmath31 ) with no counterions between surfaces that reduces to the trivial case of a planar capacitor . these two well - understood limiting cases will be thus omitted from our discussion . counterions between the surfaces satisfy electroneutrality condition that can be written in the form @xmath32 where @xmath33 denotes the ( infinite ) area of each surface . because of the asymmetry present in the system , we have two length scales describing the interaction of the counterions with each of the bounding surfaces . these two length scales are given by the corresponding gouy - chapman lengths associated with the two surfaces as @xmath34 for the same reason we can thus define two different coupling parameters @xmath35 each one being defined by the ratio between the bjerrum length and the corresponding gouy - chapman length . in what follows , we rescale the surface separation as @xmath36 ( or the rescaled half - distance as @xmath37 ) with respect to plate 1 . with an appropriate rescaling one could also equivalently define all dimensionless lengths with respect to plate 2 . thus the minimal set of dimensionless parameters that fully characterize the system in the thermodynamic limit is given by @xmath38 . other physical quantities such as the mean electrostatic potential @xmath39 , number density of counterions , @xmath40 , and the pressure , @xmath41 , acting on each surface can be rescaled as well . we shall use the standard rescaled electrostatic potential @xmath42as well as the rescaled density and pressure @xmath43 where @xmath44 , and all the other quantities have been defined above . in the weak coupling regime , the leading contribution to the partition function comes from the saddle - point configuration of the local fluctuating electrostatic potential , @xmath45 @xcite . the saddle - point configuration can be straightforwardly translated into a solution of the pb equation and corresponds to an exact asymptotic result in the limit @xmath14 @xcite . for a system containing only counterions , the pb equation for the dimensionless potential , @xmath46 , can be written in the standard form @xcite @xmath47 with boundary conditions @xmath48 integration of the pb equation gives rise to the first integral of the system of the form @xmath49 where the constant @xmath50 is nothing but the mean - field pb pressure acting between the bounding surfaces @xcite and @xmath51 is the pb number density profile of counterions between the surfaces . the normalization factor @xmath52 follows from the electroneutrality condition ( [ eq : electroneutral ] ) as @xmath53 the nature of the solution @xmath54 obviously crucially depends on the sign of the pressure @xmath50 @xcite . different forms are obtained for positive and negative pressures , corresponding to repulsion and attraction between the bounding surfaces respectively . we review these different cases separately . in the case of repulsive pressure the appropriate solution of eq . ( [ eq : pbeq ] ) can be written as @xmath56 where the constants @xmath57 and @xmath58 are obtained from the boundary conditions ( [ bc - rep ] ) and satisfy the set of two equations @xmath59 eliminating @xmath57 we obtain an equation for @xmath60 of the form @xmath61 the solution of this equation provides the final result for the repulsive pb pressure @xmath50 . note in particular that in rescaled units and by definition one has @xmath62 where @xmath63 . once @xmath60 is known , the parameter @xmath57 can be simply obtained from eqs . ( [ z01 ] ) or ( [ z02 ] ) and thus the potential @xmath64 , eq . ( [ psi0 ] ) , is fully determined . the density profile of counterions then follows from @xmath65 a positive ( repulsive ) solution for the pressure as considered in this section is always possible for any given asymmetry parameter @xmath25 ( excluding the trivial case of @xmath66 ) . in particular , it easily follows that within the mean - field theory two surfaces of equal sign ( @xmath67 ) always repel , that is at all separation distances @xmath68 . when the surfaces bear charges of opposite sign @xmath69 , they attract at large separations ( see below ) and a repulsion emerges only at sufficiently small separations . at small separations @xmath70 , we can obtain the limiting solution for @xmath60 and thus the limiting small - distance pressure @xmath50 as @xmath71 for arbitrary @xmath72 as noted in scetion [ sec : geo ] . this is of course nothing but the ideal - gas osmotic pressure of counterion confined between the two plates ( _ i.e. _ , @xmath73 in actual units ) , which dominates over the energetic contributions at small separations . at large separations @xmath74 and for @xmath67 , we obtain the asymptotic expansion @xmath75 , \label{rep - limit - zeta}\ ] ] which is valid for @xmath76 . thus in the limit @xmath77 , the pressure behaves as @xmath78 which agrees with the asymptotic pressure between two equally charged surfaces ( @xmath79 ) . for smaller @xmath25 than determined above , _ i.e. _ for @xmath80 , one needs to invoke a different asymptotic expansion and specifically for @xmath81 ( one surface being neutral ) , one obtains @xmath82 this latter asymptotic result may be obtained from the one in eq . ( [ rep - limit ] ) by redefining @xmath83 . this may be understood simply by noting that because of symmetry a system with @xmath67 may be decomposed into two halves each with an effective asymmetry parameter @xmath84 . an attractive pressure on the mean - field level is possible only if the surfaces are oppositely charged @xmath69 . the appropriate solution in this case is given by @xmath86 where the constants @xmath57 and @xmath87 can again be obtained from boundary conditions , this time in the form @xmath88 eliminating @xmath57 we obtain an equation for @xmath60 as @xmath89 in this case we have in rescaled units @xmath90 and for the density profile of counterions @xmath91 the asymptotic form of the attractive pressure at large separations @xmath92 can be derived as @xmath93 where @xmath69 as noted above . for infinite separations , this pressure does _ not _ vanish and exponentially approaches @xmath94 since for @xmath95 the system behaves partially as a simple capacitor . in the case of charged surfaces with opposite sign ( @xmath69 ) , the large - distance attraction regime and the short - distance repulsion regime merge at the point of zero pressure , @xmath97 , where the surfaces are at equilibrium . in this case , the pb solution for the potential reads @xmath98 and the density profile of counterions is given by @xmath99 where @xmath57 is found from the boundary conditions as @xmath100 , and the _ bound - state separation _ , @xmath101 , follows in rescaled units as @xmath102 the surfaces attract for @xmath103 and repel for @xmath104 . in the vicinity of @xmath105 , that is for @xmath106 , the pressure behaves as @xmath107 this concludes the calculation of the inter - surface pressure on the mean - field pb level strictly valid for @xmath14 . the preceding results may be summarized in a phase diagram shown in fig . [ fig : bound - sc ] in terms of @xmath101 and the asymmetry parameter @xmath25 displaying the mean - field attraction and repulsion regimes separated by the boundary line ( [ eq : pb_a * ] ) . the forms of the pressure here are completely consistent with those derived by lau and pincus @xcite _ via _ a different route . the first non - zero correction to the saddle point is second order in the fluctuations of the local electrostatic potential around the mean - field pb solution , @xmath108 . our goal here is to calculate the corrections in pressure , @xmath109 , stemming from these quadratic fluctuations , which leads then to the total wc pressure @xmath110 this approach has correlates in many diverse areas of physics where fluctuations around a mean - field solution are important @xcite and goes under different names , though the physics is always the same . we may conventionally refer to the mean - field pb term , @xmath111 , and the fluctuations contribution , @xmath109 , as the _ zeroth - order _ and the _ second - order _ correction terms on the wc level , respectively . this procedure formally also corresponds to a series expansion in powers of @xmath0 ( loop expansion ) around the asymptotic mean - field solution ( @xmath14 ) @xcite and is thus expected to be valid for sufficiently small coupling parameters as will be determined later . note also that in this latter sense the second - order pressure turns out to be proportional to @xmath0 , that is @xmath112 , and thus corresponds to a first - loop correction @xcite . in order to proceed , one needs to evaluate the appropriate hessian of the field action in the partition function and study its fluctuation spectrum ( see refs . @xcite for more details ) . the hessian of the field action can be derived in the form @xmath113 where @xmath114 is the inverse coulomb operator and @xmath115 is the zeroth - order pb density as derived in the previous section . hence , @xmath116 the corresponding correction , @xmath117 , to the free energy of the system is then given by the trace - log of the hessian . it can be written equivalently in the following form @xcite @xmath118 this form can be derived rather straightforwardly by using the argument principle @xcite and converting the discrete sum of eigenvalues of the hessian operator into an integral over the transverse wave - vector @xmath119 , with density of modes @xmath120 of the logarithm of the secular determinant @xmath121 of the same operator . the index @xmath122 in the secular determinant refers to the eigenvalue equation that can be derived in the form @xmath123 by simply writing @xmath124 for the quotient @xmath125 , and noting that the secular determinant depends explicitly also on the value of the inter - surface spacing , @xmath20 , the free energy contribution from the quadratic fluctuations can be equivalently expressed exactly in a dimensionless form as @xmath126 where @xmath127 , @xmath128 and the rescaled area @xmath129 . here the secular determinant of the hessian for homogeneous transverse modes has been written as a function of dimensionless quantities @xmath130 , @xmath128 . this determinant has to be standardly regularized so that all irrelevant constants , _ i.e. _ all the terms not depending on the separation between the bounding surfaces , are dropped , amounting to a rescaling @xmath131 this corresponds to a subtraction of the part of the free energy for two separate interfaces at infinite separation from the total free energy . in the next step one has to calculate the secular determinant @xmath132 for each of the pressure regimes separately , since the appropriate eigenfunctions of the hessian depend on the mean - field solution that in its turn depends on the sign of the interaction pressure , see eq . ( [ sign - eigen ] ) . in what follows we shall follow closely the derivations in refs . @xcite . the total pressure in the weak - coupling limit is thus the sum of the pb pressure and the quadratic fluctuations correction and can be written as @xmath133 in this regime the secular determinant of the hessian , eq . ( [ eigf ] ) , can be obtained by solving @xmath134 with appropriate boundary conditions implying continuity of the solution and its derivative across the bounding surfaces at @xmath18 . the general solution of eq . ( [ sec - rep ] ) for various regions in the perpendicular direction can be written in the form @xmath135 where @xmath136,\\ & & y_{2}=\cfrac{q^2}{q^2+\alpha^2}\>e^{-qz}\left[1- \cfrac{\alpha}{q}\,\tg\,\alpha ( z - z_0)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] taking into account the continuity of the solution and its derivatives we get a set of four homogeneous equations for the coefficients @xmath137 and @xmath138 . the solution exists only if the ( secular ) determinant of this system equals zero . thus we derive the secular determinant of the hessian operator in this case in the rescaled form @xmath139 where @xmath140 the regularized form of the secular determinant is obtained by taking the quotient as indicated in eq . ( [ renorm ] ) . while doing this , it is important to realize that @xmath141 also depends on the inter - surface distance . in fact from eq . ( [ rep - limit ] ) it follows that the appropriate limit of @xmath141 is @xmath142 in the regularization of the secular determinant this limiting behavior should be consistently taken into account . finally , the dimensionless quadratic fluctuations free energy @xmath143 can be calculated numerically _ via _ eqs . ( [ second - f ] ) and ( [ eq : seculard_final ] ) . the fluctuations contribution to the pressure , @xmath144 , then follows from eq . ( [ secondord ] ) . the asymptotic form of the second - order dimensionless pressure can be obtained analytically . note that at large separations @xmath145 , a repulsive mean - field pressure @xmath55 , as considered in this section , is possible only for non - negative @xmath25 . for not too small @xmath146 , _ i.e. _ when @xmath147 , we find @xmath148 while for @xmath81 , _ i.e. _ when @xmath80 , we get @xmath149 again the difference in the two cases above is due to the symmetry of the problem in the latter case , that can be described by redefining @xmath83 and discarding the sub - dominant terms . the second - order pressure is obviously _ attractive _ and in this regime leads to a reduction of the total pressure from the mean - field value @xmath50 . this clearly shows that electrostatic correlations favor attraction between two repelling asymmetrically charged plates . however , the total pressure never becomes negative as the fluctuations are assumed to be small within the second - order weak - coupling analysis . in this case the secular determinant of the hessian , eq . ( [ eigf ] ) , is obtained by solving @xmath150 the general solutions for particular regions in the @xmath151 direction are @xmath152 where @xmath153,\\ & & y_{2}=\cfrac{q^2}{q^2-\alpha^2}\,e^{-qz}\left[1+\cfrac{\alpha}{q}\,\cth\,\alpha ( z - z_0)\right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] again the solution exists only if the determinant of the system of equations , which connect coefficients @xmath154 and stems from the application of the boundary conditions at @xmath155 , is identically zero . this again defines the secular determinant @xmath124 appropriate for this case . it is easy to show that the secular determinant @xmath124 can be obtained from the @xmath55 result , eq . ( [ eq : seculard_final ] ) , simply by substituting @xmath156 and so we can write @xmath157 where @xmath158 here we can again regularize the secular determinant to discard divergences , eq . ( [ renorm ] ) . again one has to be careful by taking the correct limit for @xmath141 in the above regularization scheme . in this regime , the appropriate limit is given by @xmath159 as follows straightforwardly from eq . ( [ att - limit ] ) . the fluctuations contribution to the pressure , @xmath144 , can then be evaluated numerically from eq . ( [ secondord ] ) . the asymptotic form of @xmath144 for @xmath74 can be derived analytically as @xmath160 which is applicable only for charged surfaces of opposite sign , @xmath161 , which can attract ( @xmath85 ) at large separations . the function @xmath162 is defined as @xmath163 for @xmath164 , and @xmath165 for @xmath166 . the second - order pressure thus asymptotically decays exponentially and can be only attractive . for not too small values of @xmath25 , it is thus qualitatively very different from the case @xmath167 . the total weak - coupling pressure , @xmath168 , is shown in fig . [ fig : wc_p ] for a few different asymmetry parameters and a relatively small value of the coupling parameter @xmath0 . as noted above the foregoing weak - coupling analysis is valid as long as the quadratic corrections are sufficiently small so that the series expansion around the mean - field solution does not diverge @xcite . as an approximate measure for the validity regime of this scheme , one can require that the second - order correction term is smaller than the leading order term , _ i.e. _ @xmath169 this leads to a useful criterion identifying the regime of coupling parameters and distances in which the weak - coupling theory is applicable . for @xmath55 and by employing the closed - form expressions obtained for large separations @xmath92 , we find the validity condition @xmath170 this indicates that at a given non - vanishing @xmath0 , the weak - coupling scheme becomes increasingly more accurate at larger separations , while as the surfaces get closer a smaller coupling parameter needs to be chosen . on the other hand , for @xmath85 ( which occurs for @xmath161 ) and at large separations @xmath92 , we obtain @xmath171 the right hand side here is exponentially large meaning that for charged surfaces of opposite sign , the weak - coupling analysis performs far better at finite coupling parameters and smaller inter - surface separations than for the surfaces of equal sign ( @xmath67 ) . finally , note that for @xmath96 that corresponds to the equilibrium phase boundary line in fig . [ fig : bound - sc ] for @xmath161 , we deal with a situation where the leading order term is zero and the fluctuations are _ dominant _ at any finite value of @xmath0 . the convergence of the loop expansion has to be determined in this case by evaluating the higher order terms which we shall not consider in this paper . the strong - coupling approximation coincides with the lowest order non - trivial expansion of the partition function in terms of the fugacities of the counterions . this expansion may be expressed as a @xmath16 series expansion @xcite , whose leading order term ( @xmath17 ) corresponds to the so - called sc theory . we will not delve into the strong - coupling expansion in more detail since it has been exhaustively reviewed in the literature @xcite . on the leading order , the free energy is obtained as @xmath172 where @xmath173 is electrostatic interaction energy of charged surfaces @xmath174 with @xmath33 representing surface area of each plate , and @xmath175 and @xmath176 are electrostatic interaction energies between a single counterion and individual charged surfaces , _ i.e. _ @xmath177 since in the strong - coupling regime the free energy is given _ via _ simple quadratures , it is much simpler to evaluate it than on the weak - coupling level . defining the rescaled free energy @xmath178 we obtain @xmath179.\ ] ] differentiating the free energy with respect to the surface - surface distance @xmath180 we get the corresponding pressure acting between the bounding surfaces @xmath181 . \label{eq : p_sc}\ ] ] the dependence of this dimensionless pressure on the separation for different values of @xmath25 is presented in fig . [ fig : sc_p ] . note that the sc pressure can become attractive for _ both _ like - charged and oppositely charged surfaces which contrasts with the mean - field theory that does not allow attraction between like - charged surfaces . this is because of the strong electrostatic correlations mediated by counterions between the charged surfaces for @xmath182 and has been investigated throughly before for equally charged surfaces @xcite . our results show that a similar attraction mechanism holds for asymmetrically charged surfaces in the sc limit . the pressure exhibits two well - defined limiting laws obtainable for small and large inter - surface separations . for small separations @xmath70 , we have @xmath183 for arbitrary @xmath72 as noted in section [ sec : geo ] . for large separations @xmath74 , we obtain @xmath184 note that in the limit @xmath185 the sc pressure coincides with the pb result on the leading order ( compare eqs . ( [ rep - limit1 ] ) and ( [ psc_limit ] ) ) and represents the ideal - gas osmotic pressure of counterions which dominates over the electrostatic contributions . the pb and sc forms for @xmath161 coincide also in the limit of @xmath74 ( compare eqs . ( [ att - limit ] ) and ( [ newlimit ] ) ) and reduce to the pressure in the capacitor . the dependence of the pressure on the inter - surface separation points to the existence of a bound state defined _ via _ @xmath186 . the sc bound - state separation @xmath101 can be expressed analytically as @xmath187 and is presented in fig . [ fig : bound - sc ] as a function of @xmath25 . obviously both like - charged and oppositely charged surfaces can form bound states at small surface - surface separations . the bound - state separation approaches infinity and the surfaces _ unbind _ asymptotically as @xmath188 , that is when one plate becomes electroneutral . finally one can also derive the explicit form of the counterion density as a function of the normal coordinate @xmath151 . this can be read off simply from the integrand in eq . ( [ deff ] ) , that is @xmath189 , where @xmath190 is a normalization factor @xcite . according to the electroneutrality condition , we normalize the density as @xmath191 , or in rescaled units @xmath192 where we have defined @xmath193 with @xmath194 being the gouy - chapman length with respect to plate 1 . from here , the density profile is obtained as @xmath195 } , \label{denssc}\ ] ] as a function of @xmath151 and @xmath25 . the regime of applicability of the leading order sc theory follows from a simple criterion that has been discussed and confirmed previously in the case of equally charged surfaces by both mc simulations and higher - order calculations @xcite . the generalization to asymmetrically charged surfaces is straightforward . for large couplings , counterions are strongly attracted to an oppositely charged surface as the counterion - surface interaction becomes large and equivalently , the gouy - chapman length , @xmath10 , and the thickness of the counterionic layer at the surface become small . the layer thickness has to be compared with the typical lateral spacing between counterions @xmath196 . for counterions sandwiched between two asymmetrically charged surfaces , this latter quantity follows from the local electroneutrality condition as @xmath197 up to a factor of the order unity and assuming that the surfaces are sufficiently close so that they may be strongly coupled _ via _ the counterions as will be determined consistently here . in rescaled units , one gets @xmath198 where @xmath199 . obviously , @xmath200 becomes large relative to the layer thickness as @xmath0 grows . note that on the other hand the lateral coulomb repulsion between counterions in this quasi - two - dimensional layer becomes much larger than the thermal energy , _ i.e. _ @xmath201 , indicating that counterions form a strongly correlated liquid in which they are highly localized within correlation holes of lateral size @xmath202 @xcite . thus for surface - surface separations , @xmath68 , smaller than the correlation hole size , _ i.e. _ @xmath203 counterions can move almost independently from each other in the direction normal to the surface and one can safely assume that the effective surface - surface interaction as well as the counterionic density profile follow only from the interactions of _ individual _ counterions with the bounding charged surfaces . the counterion - counterion interactions contribute on the sub - leading order and matter at larger separations . this picture is of course confirmed on a systematic level by the sc expansion analysis @xcite , and the above equation sets a criterion for the validity regime of the single - particle leading order sc theory ( @xmath204 ) , when applied to finite coupling parameters . we performed monte - carlo ( mc ) simulations in order to study the system of two asymmetrically charged surfaces beyond the analytical limits of weak and strong coupling discussed above . all simulations were performed in the canonical ensemble ( nvt ) using the standard metropolis algorithm @xcite . the mobile counterions were modeled as point charges @xcite enclosed in a simulation box bounded in @xmath151 direction by two charged surfaces of distance @xmath138 and surface charge densities @xmath205 and @xmath206 ( compare fig . [ fig : geometry ] ) . periodic boundary conditions were applied in the lateral directions parallel to the bounding surfaces . the lateral size of the charged surfaces , @xmath207 , which is set equal to the lateral size of the simulation box , was held fixed throughout all the simulations . the number of counterions , @xmath208 , was varied between 60 and 1800 , depending on the system parameters in order to fulfill the electroneutrality condition . the counterions interact through the coulombic potential @xmath209 with @xmath210 being the charge of the @xmath211-th counterion and @xmath212 the separation distance between the @xmath211-th and the @xmath213-th counterions ( with @xmath214 ) . the interaction energy of the @xmath211-th counterion with the charged surfaces in the simulation box are given by @xmath215 ^ 2}\bigg ) + \frac{\pi}{2}\bigg\}\bigg ] , \label{coulomb_wallterm}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath216 and @xmath206 is surface charge density of the @xmath217-th surface ( with @xmath218 ) and @xmath219 is the normal distance between the @xmath211-th counterion and the @xmath217-th surface . the long - ranged coulomb interactions in this system were accounted for _ via _ a charged sheet scheme similar to that proposed by torrie and valleau @xcite . this scheme makes use of the counterion profile in the simulation box in order to calculate an external field , stemming from the long - ranged interactions . this external field is iteratively updated and self - consistency is achieved normally in a few iterations . in the course of simulations , new configurations were created by trial displacements of the counterions and equilibration was accomplished by running through @xmath220 configurations . the @xmath221 following configurations were then used for the production runs . the pressure @xmath41 was calculated in the production runs according to the contact - value theorem as @xmath222 where @xmath223 is the density of counterions at contact with the @xmath217-th surface . in thermodynamic equilibrium , the pressure does not depend on which surface ( @xmath224 or @xmath225 ) is chosen in order to calculate the pressure from the above equation , and the contact condition at both surfaces leads to precisely the same value for the pressure . all simulations were conducted at fixed temperature @xmath226 k , lateral simulation box size @xmath227 and dielectric constant @xmath228 , which is assumed to be the same throughout the system . the simulations were performed at different values of the coupling parameter @xmath0 and the asymmetry parameter @xmath25 . we explored the @xmath0 parameter space extensively by using @xmath229 , @xmath230 and @xmath231 in order to cover exhaustively both the weak coupling and the strong coupling regimes . the concurrent values of the asymmetry parameter were always taken as @xmath232 at each value of the coupling parameter . the results are plotted in the form of rescaled density and pressure as previously defined in this paper ( section [ sec : rescal ] ) . in order to asses the validity of the weak and strong coupling results presented above for asymmetrically charged surfaces , we performed extensive mc simulations and compared them to analytical results in both limits . it transpires from this comparison that the simulation results corresponding to an exact evaluation of the partition function are always bracketed by the wc and the sc limiting forms , smoothly approaching them in the appropriate limits of the coupling parameter @xmath0 . first we compare the density profiles of simulations with theoretical results given by eqs . ( [ denswc1 ] ) and ( [ denswc2 ] ) for the pb limit ( solid lines ) and eq . ( [ denssc ] ) for the sc limit ( dashed lines ) . as seen from fig . [ dens ] the theoretical pb and sc rescaled density profiles represent two extremal cases and all mc simulations results with finite values of @xmath0 are located consistently between these two limits . the mc results for small @xmath0 are almost exactly spot on the pb prediction , while larger discrepancies are observed as @xmath0 grows . for large enough @xmath233 , the mc results slowly converge to the sc result . this is especially clear for surfaces with charges of equal sign , @xmath234 , whereas for surfaces with opposite sign , @xmath235 , there is no big difference between pb and sc profiles . next we consider the inter - surface pressure as obtained from the simulations ( symbols in fig . [ fig : sim_pressure ] ) as well as the pb theory , eqs . ( [ pres - pb - rep ] ) and ( [ pres - pb - att ] ) , and the sc theory , eq . ( [ eq : p_sc ] ) ( solid and dashed lines , respectively ) . the pb result is expected to be valid for separations @xmath236 @xcite ( see also section [ sec : wc_crit ] ) . therefore , for @xmath237 the pb line expectedly agrees nicely with the simulation data ( open squares ) in the whole range of separations shown in the figure . upon closer inspection , however , we find small deviations from the pb result as shown in the insets in fig . [ fig : sim_pressure ] for all three values of the asymmetry parameter @xmath25 . in this case , the fluctuation correction to the mean - field pressure accurately compensates for these deviations and adding the second - order correction to the pb pressure leads to a total wc pressure , eq . ( [ secondord ] ) ( shown as a dotted line in the inset ) that matches the simulation data perfectly . note that the pressure changes can be drastic even on the wc level as @xmath25 assumes different values . for @xmath238 and 0 the wc pressure is strictly repulsive , while it turns attractive and leads to a bound state ( zero pressure point ) for @xmath239 . in the intermediate regime of coupling parameters , the simulation results for the pressure are clearly bracketed by the two limiting analytical forms , given by the pb plus the second order correction and the sc expressions of the interaction pressure . the sc prediction is expected to be valid for separations @xmath240 as discussed in section [ sec : sc_crit ] . consistently , the interaction pressure starts off close to the strong coupling limit at small separations and then smoothly converges to the weak coupling limit for larger separations . this is strictly true for @xmath238 and 0 . in the case of @xmath241 the difference between the strong and weak coupling results for the rescaled interaction pressure is marginal and the simulation data and the analytical results nearly coincide for all rescaled separations @xmath242 . we emphasize that the pressures and the density profiles are plotted here in _ rescaled representation _ ; in actual units , fig . [ fig : sim_pressure ] corresponds to different ranges of separation , @xmath138 , for the wc and sc regimes as the gouy - chapman length , @xmath10 , is typically very different between the two limits ( small at high couplings and large at small couplings as may be realized , _ e.g. _ , by changing the counterion valency at fixed surface charge densities and bjerrum length ) . for large values of the coupling parameter the simulation results for the interaction pressure expectedly follow very closely the strong coupling prediction for a wider range of inter - surface separations . the correspondence between the sc theory and simulations is better for @xmath241 than for @xmath238 , which can be again traced back to the fact that the strong and the weak coupling results are very close to one another for charged surfaces of opposite sign in the whole range of rescaled separations , whereas they differ significantly in the case of surfaces of equal sign . for intermediate and large couplings , we have not attempted to compare our data with the second - order wc approximation as this approximation breaks down at the range of distances shown in the figures ( section [ sec : wc_crit ] ) . note also that in all cases considered here the theoretical and the simulated values of the interaction pressure converge for very small surface - surface separations . in fact , the sc and pb results coincide in the leading order as the rescaled distance , @xmath68 , tends to zero , eqs . ( [ rep - limit1 ] ) and ( [ psc_limit ] ) , since both are dominated by the osmotic pressure of counterions . the sub - leading corrections for very small @xmath68 are different in the pb and sc limits and on this level the simulation data with finite @xmath0 are generally expected to agree better with the sc prediction at small separations @xcite . we now consider the simulated bound - state separation , @xmath101 , as a function of the coupling parameter in fig . [ fig : bound_xi ] ( symbols ) . for @xmath234 , the pb theory ( @xmath14 ) gives only repulsion and predicts no bound state . while the sc theory predicts a closely packed bound state with @xmath243 given by eq . ( [ eq : d*_sc ] ) , explicitly here @xmath244 . as seen , by increasing the coupling parameter the simulation data for @xmath101 ( filled squares ) decrease monotonically and rather slowly converge to the sc prediction ( dotted line ) . the comparison is again worse for the @xmath238 than for the @xmath241 case ( dashed line and filled circles ) . for @xmath234 , even at @xmath245 the difference between the simulations and the analytical result is still close to 10% . the deviations are quite pronounced for smaller values of the coupling parameter . the opposite is true for @xmath241 . here , the simulation results are close to the strong - coupling analytical limit in the whole range of @xmath0 values . for @xmath246 we can discern , see inset in fig . [ fig : bound_xi ] , weak coupling behavior that starts off with the pb - predicted value @xmath247 in the limit of @xmath248 ( eq . ( [ eq : pb_a * ] ) , solid line ) , that later follows the pb plus second - order corrections line ( dot - dashed line ) and then rapidly approaches the strong - coupling result @xmath249 ( dashed line ) . as already noted the differences between strong and weak coupling in this case are marginal in the rescaled representation . the dependence of @xmath105 on @xmath25 in fig . [ fig : bound_zeta ] complements the above observations . the bound - state separation diverges for @xmath250 both in simulations as well as in the analytical limits . here we reproduce the simulation results at @xmath234 and @xmath251 , which again clearly show the convergence to the sc result for @xmath234 and the crossover from the pb result ( solid line ) to the sc result ( dashed line ) for @xmath235 upon increasing the coupling parameter . the quantitative agreement between the simulations and the analytical results in the two limiting cases of pb and sc is excellent . note here again that the second - order wc expansion ( dotted line in the inset ) begins to fail at small separations as it deviates from the limiting pb results as well as from the simulation data . since the pb pressure is zero on the pb phase boundary line , the validity of the second order wc correction can be assessed analytically only by performing a two - loop calculation which goes beyond the scope of this paper . to summarize , we have derived theoretical forms for the interaction pressure as well as the counterionic density profiles of asymmetrically charged planar surfaces with neutralizing counterions in between . based on the field - theoretical methods we analyzed two different regimes of weak and strong coupling as defined by the electrostatic coupling parameter @xmath0 . the crossover between these two regimes is studied _ via _ monte - carlo simulations . for small values of @xmath0 , the system is described very well by the _ weak coupling _ ( wc ) theory , that in the lowest ( zeroth ) order coincides with the mean - field poisson - boltzmann ( pb ) result . the second order of wc corresponds to a first - order loop expansion and represents the contribution from correlated quadratic fluctuations around the mean - field or saddle - point solution . this second - order correction , which is proportional to @xmath0 , always lowers the interaction pressure between the surfaces and thus leads to an attractive contribution to the total interaction pressure . since it corresponds to an expansion of the partition function around the mean - field saddle point it has to be smaller , in absolute terms , than the mean - field result . net attraction given by second - order fluctuations term ( for interacting surfaces of equal sign ) is therefore inconsistent with the nature of the wc approximation . for large values of the coupling parameter @xmath0 , the weak coupling approach breaks down and the virial expansion amounting to the _ strong coupling _ ( sc ) approximation must be used . the sc approach is effectively a one - particle theory and takes properly into account the strong correlation and interaction of the counterions with external surface fields on the leading order @xcite . following standard procedures , we derived an analytical expression for interaction pressure in the sc limit . the interaction pressure in this case is always lower than the pb result and can be negative ( corresponding to a net attractive force ) even for charged surfaces of equal sign . we compared both our theories , _ i.e. _ wc with second - order corrections and sc , with monte - carlo simulations . we found very good agreement for both theories in their expected regime of validity . as expected , the wc approach is valid for separations @xmath252 . the second - order correction improves the small discrepancies between pb and mc results at large separations but it tends to fail for smaller distances when discrepancies get more pronounced . on the other hand , the sc theory describes the behavior perfectly at small separations @xmath253 . for small enough coupling parameter @xmath0 , the validity of the pb approximation spreads to smaller separations , @xmath68 , where pb and sc results nearly coincide ( in the rescaled representation ) . therefore , we may conclude that for sufficiently small @xmath0 , the pb result is valid on the whole interval @xmath68 . note that the second - order wc correction term consistently diverges ( toward large negative values ) for small inter - surface separations , @xmath254 , irrespective of @xmath25 , which makes it in general inapplicable in this limit . the reason for this is simple . for small inter - surface separations the mean - field solution becomes more and more homogeneous , almost a constant , and the interaction free energy approaches its standard zero - frequency van der waals form that diverges for small separations . in the case of surface charges with equal sign , @xmath67 , the wc theory predicts no attraction and hence no bound state . the attraction and the corresponding bound state appear only for coupling parameters @xmath0 that are large enough , as predicted by the sc theory . in the case of charged surfaces of opposite sign , @xmath161 , the attraction appears also in wc limit above a threshold value @xmath255 that represents the equilibrium surface - surface separation . it is notable that for charged surfaces of opposite sign , the wc analysis in general performs much better than for the surfaces of equal sign and that the sc and the wc results are very close to one another for charged surfaces of opposite sign in the whole range of rescaled separations , whereas they differ significantly in the case of surfaces of equal sign . there is also only a marginal difference between the pb and sc counterion density profiles in the rescaled representation for surfaces of opposite sign . a reasonable explanation for this would be in our opinion that for oppositely charged surfaces the counterions mostly feel the effect of the strong uniform external field provided by the surface charges , which acts similarly in the strong as well as the weak coupling limit . thus the mean - field and the strong - coupling approaches should converge . in the case of similarly charged surfaces , the mean - field theory depends more on the local counterion density whereas the strongly coupled counterions still feel mostly the external field . thus the difference between the wc and the sc frameworks in the @xmath161 and @xmath67 cases . our results support an emerging new paradigm , according to which the wc and the sc limit bracket the exact results for the interaction pressure between charged surfaces neutralized by mobile counterions . they indeed provide quantitatively correct results for the interaction pressure in the limit of small and large inter - surface separations , while at intermeditae separations the exact results are always located between the two limits . it thus seems advisable that in analyzing the electrostatic interactions in colloidal systems one always calculates both analytic limits , the wc as well as the sc , in order to get a good handle on the range of values that the interaction can assume for any value of the electrostatic coupling parameter . in future we intend to study the same system in the presence of added salt and dielectric discontinuities . m.k . and r.p . would like to acknowledge the financial support by the agency for research and development of slovenia ( grants p1 - 0055(c ) , z1 - 7171 , l2 - 7080 ) . this study was supported by the intramural research program of the nih , national institute of child health and human development . this research was supported in part by the national science foundation under grant no . phy05 - 51164 . in our model excluded - volume counterion - counterion repulsions are neglected . these two - body interactions will be irrelevant in the leading order within the strong - coupling limit @xcite . however , the counterion size ( or the counterion - wall exluded - volume interactions ) is incorporated exactly by taking @xmath256 as the closest - approach surface - surface distance leaving out the counterion diameter from the actual distance . on a more fundamental level it is indeed possible to incorporate excluded- volume effects within a modifed poisson - boltzmann formulation as in _ e.g. _ : i. borukhov , d. andelman , h. orland , phys . lett . * 79 * 435 ( 1997 ) ; electrochimica acta * 46 * 221 ( 2000 ) . r. r. netz , eur . j. e * 3 * 131 ( 2000 ) ; r. menes , p. pincus , b. stein , phys . e * 62 * 2981 ( 2000 ) ; j. schmit , r. menes , p. a. pincus , phys e * 66 * 061502 ( 2002 ) ; m. m. hatlo , r. a. curtis , l. lue , j. chem . phys . * 128 * 164717 ( 2008 ) .
Abstract: | [
"we compare weak and strong coupling theory of counterion - mediated electrostatic interactions between two asymmetrically charged plates with extensive monte - carlo simulations . analytical results in both weak and strong coupling limits compare excellently with simulations in their respective regimes of validity . the system shows a surprisingly rich structure in terms of interactions between the surfaces as well as fundamental qualitative differences in behavior in the weak and the strong coupling limits ."
] | 9,021 | 9,021 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: the path integral ( pi ) has been used in quantum physics since the revolutionary work of feynman @xcite , although the basic observation goes back to dirac @xcite who appreciated the rle of the lagrangian in short - time evolution of the wave function , and even suggested the time - slicing procedure for finite , i.e. , non - infinitesimal , time lags . since then the pi approach yielded invaluable insights into the structure of quantum theory @xcite and provided a viable alternative to the traditional operator - formalism - based canonical quantization . during the second half of the 20th century , the pi became a standard tool in quantum field theory @xcite and statistical physics @xcite , often providing the easiest route to derivation of perturbative expansions and serving as an excellent framework for ( both numerical and analytical ) non - perturbative analysis @xcite . feynman pi has its counterpart in pure mathematics , namely , in the theory of continuous - time stochastic processes @xcite . there the concept of integration over a space of continuous functions ( so - called fluctuating paths or sample paths ) had been introduced by wiener @xcite already in 1920 s in order to represent and quantify the brownian motion . interestingly enough , this so - called wiener integral ( or integral with respect to wiener measure ) was formulated 2 years before the discovery of the schrdinger equation and 25 years before feynman s pi formulation . the _ local time _ for a brownian particle ( in some literature also called _ sojourn time _ ) has been of interest to physicists and mathematicians , since the seminal work of paul lvy in 1930 s @xcite . in its essence , the local time characterizes the time that a sample trajectory @xmath1 of a given stochastic process spends in the vicinity of an arbitrary point @xmath2 . this in turn defines a sample trajectory @xmath3 of a new stochastic process . a rich theory has been developed for local - time processes that stem from diffusion processes ( see , e.g. , ref . @xcite and citations therein ) . for later convenience , we should particularly highlight the ray knight theorem which states that the local time of the wiener process can be expressed in terms of the squared bessel process @xcite . in contrast to mathematics , the concept of the local time is not uniquely settled in physics literature . various authors define essentially the same quantity under different names ( local time , occupation time , traversal time , etc . ) , and with different applications in mind . for example , in ref . @xcite the _ traversal time _ is used to study quantum scattering and tunneling processes , in @xcite the small - temperature behavior of the equilibrium density matrix is analyzed with a help of the _ occupation time _ , while in ref . @xcite the large - time behavior of path integrals that contain functionals of the _ local time _ is discussed . the aim of this paper is to derive a local - time pi representation of the bloch density matrix , i.e. , the matrix elements @xmath4 of the gibbs operator . this can serve not only as a viable alternative to the commonly used feynman kac representation but also as a powerful tool for extracting both large and small - temperature behavior . apart from the general theoretical outline , our primary focus here will be on the low - temperature behavior which is technically more challenging than the large - temperature regime . in fact , the large - temperature expansion was already treated in some detail in our previous paper @xcite . last but not least , we also wish to promote the concept of the local time which is not yet sufficiently well known among the path - integral practitioners . the structure of the paper is as follows . to set the stage we recall in the next section some fundamentals from the feynman pi which will be needed in later sections . in section [ sec : heuristic ] we provide motivation for the introduction of a local time , and construct a heuristic version of the local - time representation of pi s . the key technical part of the article is contained in section [ sec : lt ] , where we derive by means of the replica trick the local - time representation of the bloch density matrix . relation to the sturm liouville theory is also highlighted in this context . a local - time analog of the feynman salam formula @xcite is presented in section [ sec : functionals ] and its usage is illustrated with a computation of the one - point distribution of the local time . since a natural arena for local - time pi s is in thermally extremal regimes , we confine our attention in section [ sec : asymp ] on large- and small-@xmath5 asymptotic behavior of the bloch density matrix . there we also derive an explicit leading - order behavior in large-@xmath5 ( i.e. , low - temperature ) expansion . the analysis is substantially streamlined by using the rayleigh ritz variational principle . finally , section [ sec : conclusion ] summarizes our results and discusses possible extensions , applications , and future developments of the present work . for the reader s convenience the paper is supplemented with appendix which clarifies some finer technical details . consider a non - relativistic one - dimensional quantum - mechanical system described by a time - independent hamiltonian @xmath6 where @xmath7 . throughout this paper we will study the matrix elements @xmath8 of the gibbs operator @xmath9 , where @xmath10 is the inverse temperature and @xmath11 is the boltzmann constant . the matrix @xmath12 , known also as the bloch density matrix , is a fundamental object in quantum statistical physics , as the expectation value of an operator @xmath13 at the temperature @xmath14 can be written in the form @xmath15 where @xmath16 is the partition function of the system . in case of need , ensuing quantum mechanical transition amplitudes can be obtained from ( [ rhodef ] ) via a wick rotation which formally amounts to the substitution @xmath17 , converting thus the gibbs operator @xmath9 to the quantum evolution operator @xmath18 . the matrix elements in eq.([rhodef ] ) can be represented via the path integral as @xcite @xmath19 \right\}\ , .\ ] ] this represents a sum " over all continuous trajectories @xmath20 , @xmath21 $ ] , connecting the initial point @xmath22 with the final point @xmath23 . it should be noted that the integral @xmath24 $ ] is the classical euclidean action integral along the path @xmath20 with @xmath25 . in the following we will denote the euclidean action as @xmath26 . the integrand in @xmath26 , i.e. , @xmath27 , can be identified with the classical hamiltonian function , in which the momentum @xmath28 is substituted for @xmath29 . one can also regard ( [ pix ] ) as an expectation value of the functional @xmath30 $ ] over the ( driftless ) brownian motion with the diffusion coefficient @xmath31 , and duration @xmath32 , that starts at point @xmath33 , and terminates at @xmath34 . the latter stochastic process is also known as brownian bridge . the purpose of this section is twofold . firstly , we would like to motivate a need for reformulation of pi s in the language of local - time stochastic process . in particular , we point out when such a reformulation can be more pertinent than the conventional `` sum over histories '' prescription . secondly , we wish to outline a heuristic construction of the local - time representation of pi s . more rigorous and explicit ( but less intuitive ) formulation of pi s over ensemble of local times will be presented in the subsequent section . to provide a physically sound motivation for the local - time representation of pi s we follow exposition of paulin _ . @xcite . to this end we first consider the diagonal elements of the bloch density matrix , i.e. , @xmath35 ( often referred to as the boltzmann density ) . upon shifting @xmath36 , and setting @xmath37 , @xmath38 ( @xmath39 is the thermal de broglie wavelength ) , the pi ( [ pix ] ) can be reformulated in terms of dimensionless quantities @xmath40 and @xmath41 as @xmath42 \right\ } .\ ] ] note in particular , that in contrast to @xmath43 the measure @xmath44 does not explicitly depend on @xmath5 , and thus @xmath5-dependent parts in the pi are under better control . such a rescaled representation is particularly useful when discussing large- and/or small-@xmath5 behavior of the path integral in question . path fluctuations in the potential are controlled by @xmath45 , and the factor @xmath5 quantifies the significance of the potential @xmath46 with respect to the kinetic term . for small @xmath5 ( i.e. , high temperature ) , typical paths @xmath47 stay in the vicinity of the point @xmath33 , as depicted in fig . [ fig : paths ] , are plotted as functions of the dimensionless time @xmath40 . the solid green path , representing a typical trajectory with a high value of @xmath5 , exhibits large fluctuations , whereas the dashed red path , corresponding to small @xmath5 , stays in the vicinity of the initial and final point @xmath33 . on the right , two local - time profiles @xmath48 are shown . the broad one ( solid green ) arises from the violently fluctuating path @xmath49 , whereas the narrow one ( dashed red ) corresponds to the path with small fluctuations . on the left , we depict a generic potential @xmath50 . ] and therefore a systematic wigner kirkwood expansion can be readily developed by taylor - expanding the potential part of the action @xcite . when @xmath5 is large ( i.e. , low temperature ) , the trajectories @xmath49 fluctuate heavily around the value @xmath33 , and the potential term @xmath46 dominates over the kinetic one . from the statistical physics point of view , the most important contribution to the low temperature behavior of the path integral ( [ pixresc ] ) should come from those paths that spend a sizable amount of time near the _ global _ minimum of the potential @xmath50 . for this reason , it is important to be able to keep track of the time which a given path spends in an infinitesimal neighborhood of an arbitrary point @xmath0 . let us define , for each wiener trajectory @xmath20 present in the feynman path integral ( [ pix ] ) the ensuing _ local time _ as @xmath51 since the local time @xmath52 is a functional of the random trajectory @xmath53 for @xmath54 , it represents a random variable . from the definition ( [ ltdef ] ) we can immediately see that @xmath55 for all @xmath56 , @xmath57 and that @xmath3 has a compact support . in addition , it can be proved @xcite that local - time trajectories @xmath3 are , with probability one , continuous curves which ( similarly as trajectories in the underlying wiener process ) are nowhere differentiable . in fig . [ fig : paths ] we depict two examples of representative local - time trajectories . an extensive mathematical discussion of properties of the local time can be found , e.g. in refs . @xcite . with the definition ( [ ltdef ] ) the potential part of the euclidean action can be recast into form @xmath58 . a local - time representation of the bloch density matrix @xmath12 is then given by @xmath59 \ \!\delta \ ! \left ( \int_\mathbb{r } dx \ \ ! l^x - \beta\hbar \right ) \exp \left[-\frac{1}{\hbar } \int_\mathbb{r } dx \ \ ! l^x v(x ) \right ] , \ ] ] where the pi `` sum '' is taken over all local - time trajectories @xmath60 , with @xmath0 being the independent variable ( not to be mistaken with the wiener trajectory @xmath20 ) . the @xmath61-function enforces the normalization constraint mentioned above . basically , transition to the local - time description represents a change ( or a functional substitution ) of stochastic variables @xmath62 . the weight factor @xmath63 appearing in ( [ heurform ] ) can be formally written in the form @xmath64 \ = \ \exp \left[-\frac{1}{\hbar}\int_{0}^{\beta\hbar}\!\ ! d\tau \ \ ! \frac{m}{2}\dot{x}^2 \right ] \ \ ! \det\left(\frac{\delta l^x(\beta\hbar)}{\delta x(\tau ) } \right)^{-1}\ , . \label{iii.7.a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is a function of @xmath33 , @xmath34 ( which are implicitly present in @xmath65 ) and @xmath5 , and a functional of the local time @xmath60 . of course , these cavalier manipulations do not have more than a heuristic nature , and it is , indeed , a non - trivial task to determine @xmath63 directly from ( [ iii.7.a ] ) . for this reason , we will in the following section tackle this problem indirectly . in this section , we present a derivation of the local - time representation of the bloch density matrix ( [ rhodef ] ) . initially , we limit ourselves to considering the case of the diagonal part , @xmath66 , and arrive at the key result ( [ diaglapl ] ) , which expresses the matrix elements in the ensuing laplace picture with respect to @xmath5 . this intermediate outcome is shown to agree with the sturm liouville theory . in the next step , we generalize the latter result to the off - diagonal elements ( @xmath67 ) . the inverse laplace transform will then yield the sought local - time representation of pi [ cf . ( [ offdiag ] ) ] . it follows from the definition ( [ rhodef ] ) that the function @xmath12 satisfies the heat equation @xmath68 \rho(x_a , x_b,\beta ) \ = \ 0\ , , \ ] ] with the initial condition @xmath69 . this is merely a wick - rotated ( @xmath70 ) analogue of the schrdinger equation . the feynman kac formula @xcite then ensures that the pi ( [ pix ] ) can be calculated by solving corresponding parabolic differential equation ( [ diffusioneq ] ) . in the laplace picture eq . ( [ diffusioneq ] ) takes the form @xmath71 \widetilde{\rho}(x_a , x_b , e ) \ = \ \delta(x_a - x_b)\ , , \ ] ] with @xmath72 . ( [ lapdifeq ] ) implies that @xmath73 is nothing but the green function of the operator @xmath74 . with the benefit of hindsight , we represent the green function @xmath73 as a path integral over fluctuating fields so - called functional integral @xcite . this is rather standard strategy in quantum field theory @xcite , and in our case it yields @xmath75 } } { \int_{\psi(x_{-})=0}^{\psi(x_{+})=0 } \mathcal{d}\psi(x ) \ \ ! e^ { -\frac{1}{2 } \mathcal{a}^e[\psi ] } } \ , , \ ] ] where @xmath76 & \ \equiv \ \int_{x_{-}}^{x_{+ } } \!\!\!dx \ \ ! \psi(x ) \left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2 m } \frac{d^2}{d x^2 } + v(x ) + e \right ] \psi(x ) \nonumber\\[2 mm ] & \ = \ \int_{x_{-}}^{x_{+ } } \!\!\!dx \left [ \frac{\hbar^2}{2 m } \psi'(x)^2 + ( v(x ) + e ) \psi(x)^2 \right],\end{aligned}\ ] ] is the euclidean action functional of the field - theoretic path integral . the super - index `` @xmath77 '' in @xmath26 indicates the shift in the potential @xmath50 by the amount @xmath77 . here , we have confined our quantum - mechanical system within a finite box @xmath78 $ ] , with @xmath79 and @xmath80 . a real scalar field @xmath81 satisfies dirichlet boundary conditions @xmath82 so as to ensure the validity of the operations being performed . since we will ultimately want to invert the laplace transform to regain from @xmath83 the original bloch density matrix @xmath12 , we can not treat the denominator in ( [ fieldrepre ] ) as an irrelevant normalization constant ( which is the usual practice in quantum field theory ) but we have to take care of its @xmath77-dependence . to this end we take advantage of the formula @xmath84 which is a simple version of the so - called _ replica trick_. [ the usual replica - trick formula ( cf . e.g. , ref . @xcite ) can be obtained from ( [ rep.1a ] ) by integrating both sides with respect to @xmath85 and subsequently dividing by @xmath86 . ] with the help of ( [ rep.1a ] ) we can rewrite ( [ fieldrepre ] ) as a multidimensional functional integral @xmath87 } \ , , \ ] ] where the multiplet @xmath88 is a @xmath89-component replica " field in @xmath90 dimensions , @xmath91 denotes the scalar product @xmath92 , and we have rescaled the fields by a factor of @xmath93 in passing . the factor @xmath94 results from a pi generalization of the well know mean - value identity @xmath95 valid for any two vectors in @xmath89-dimensional statistically isotropic environments . as a side remark , note that we may now invert the laplace transform , using the trivial identity @xmath96 to obtain the representation @xmath97 } \ , .\ ] ] upon scaling @xmath98 , this agrees with the formula ( 2.9 ) in ref . @xcite . though the result ( [ replrepre ] ) generalizes to arbitrary number of dimensions of the @xmath0-space , i.e. , @xmath99 , our further development will be illustrated ( for simplicity s sake ) only on the one - dimensional case . in order to derive the weight factor @xmath63 ( cf . ( [ iii.7.a ] ) ) we have arrived at the representation ( [ replrepre ] ) with @xmath89 replica fields . this form is still not very transparent , and a further simplification step is needed to get rid of an explicit dependence of the measure on @xmath89 . to this end , we note that @xmath100 $ ] is in fact the action of a @xmath89-dimensional harmonic oscillator with the `` time '' variable @xmath0 , `` position '' variable @xmath101 , mass @xmath102 , and time - dependent `` frequency '' @xmath103 . considering for a moment only diagonal matrix elements , @xmath66 , spherical symmetry in the replica field space allows to reduce the path integral ( [ afterrepl ] ) to its radial part . due to the boundary conditions , @xmath104 , only the zero - angular - momentum ( @xmath40-wave ) contribution is non - vanishing ( generally a weighted sum over radial pi s with different angular momenta would be required ) . this will be rigorously justified at the end of this section . the corresponding _ radial _ pi representation for ( [ afterrepl ] ) reads @xcite @xmath105 } \ , .\ ] ] here , the radial part @xmath106 of the @xmath89-dimensional replica field @xmath107 is always non - negative , i.e. , @xmath108 ; the area of a unit sphere in @xmath89 dimensions , @xmath109 , may be replaced by its small-@xmath89 asymptotic form @xmath110 ; and @xmath111 have been introduced to regularize the origin of the @xmath107-space . the new action functional @xmath112 \ \equiv \ \mathcal{a}^e[\eta ] \ + \ \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\ ! dx \ \ ! \frac{(d\!-\!1)(d\!-\!3)}{8 \eta^2(x ) } \ , , \ ] ] is the euclidean action functional of the _ radial harmonic oscillator _ it contains an additional centrifugal potential term ( edwards gulyaev or langer term @xcite ) , which emerges from bessel function @xmath113 present in the finite sliced form of the radial pi ( [ diaglapl ] ) . at this point we should stress that in contrast to the quantum - mechanical radial pi , one can use safely the asymptotic expansion for the bessel function @xmath113 ( see , e.g. ref . @xcite ) : @xmath114 > 0)\ , , \nonumber \\[2 mm ] & & y_j \ = \ ( m/\varepsilon \hbar)r_jr_{{j-1}}\ , , \label{asymptot - b}\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the euclidean pi sliced form . here the infinitesimal `` time '' slice @xmath115 is related to the number of slices @xmath116 via the relation @xmath117 . in quantum mechanic this is a problematic step because ( [ asymptot - b ] ) requires @xmath118 > 0 $ ] while there @xmath118 = \mbox{re}[(m / i\varepsilon \hbar)r_jr_{{j-1 } } ] = 0 $ ] . fortunately , the pi for radial harmonic oscillator is exactly solvable even in the case of @xmath0-dependent oscillator frequency . the solution reads @xcite @xmath119 \right\ } \nonumber \\[2 mm ] & = & \ \frac{\hbar^2}{m } \frac{\sqrt{\eta_1 \eta_2}}{g(x_1 ) } i_{d/2 - 1}\left(\frac{\hbar^2}{m } \frac{\eta_1 \eta_2}{g(x_1)}\right ) \exp\left[- \frac{\hbar^2}{2 m } \left(\frac{f'(x_2)}{f(x_2 ) } \eta_2 ^ 2 - \frac{g'(x_1)}{g(x_1 ) } \eta_1 ^ 2 \right ) \right ] . \label{radialhosol}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the functions @xmath120 and @xmath121 are two independent solutions of the differential equation @xmath122y(x ) \ = \ \left [ -\frac{\hbar^2}{2 m } \frac{d^2}{dx^2 } + v(x ) + e \right ] y(x ) \ = \ 0\ , , \ ] ] with the initial conditions @xmath123 and @xmath124 , and @xmath125 and @xmath126 . in addition , the wronskian @xmath127 is independent of @xmath0 , as can be proved by differentiation and by using the fact that @xmath128 and @xmath129 both satisfy eq . ( [ diffeqfg ] ) . by equating the values of @xmath130 at points @xmath131 and @xmath132 , and taking into account the initial conditions for @xmath128 and @xmath129 , we find a useful identity @xmath133 . now , the pi in ( [ diaglapl ] ) can be sliced at point @xmath33 , and expressed as @xmath134 the limits in eq . ( [ diaglapl ] ) are readily carried out with the help of the asymptotic formulas @xmath135 , and @xmath136 , valid for @xmath137 . subsequent integration over @xmath138 brings ( [ diaglapl ] ) to form @xmath139 where @xmath140 solves eq . ( [ diffeqfg ] ) with initial conditions @xmath141 and @xmath142 , and @xmath143 solves the same equation with @xmath144 and @xmath145 . the denominator in ( [ diaggreenexpl ] ) is the wronskian @xmath146 . the full derivation is given in appendix [ sec : app ] . although rather explicit , eq . ( [ diaggreenexpl ] ) is not well suited for the laplace transform inversion , since functions @xmath120 and @xmath121 contain @xmath77 in a non - trivial way , which , in addition , significantly hinges on the actual form of @xmath50 . for formal manipulations it is still better the employ the pi representation ( [ diaglapl ] ) . for instance , using eq . ( [ inverselap ] ) we can easily invert the laplace transform to return from @xmath77 back to the @xmath5-variable , namely @xmath147 } \ , . \label{boltzmann.ii}\end{aligned}\ ] ] note that we have utilized the asymptotic form @xmath110 which holds for @xmath148 . we shall see shortly that ( [ boltzmann.ii ] ) can be straightforwardly related to the local - time pi representation of the boltzmann density matrix . let us finally comment on the higher - angular - momentum terms which , as claimed , should not contribute to the expression ( [ diaglapl ] ) . for arbitrary angular momentum @xmath149 , we employ formula ( [ radialhosol ] ) with a slight modification @xmath150 . now , for example , in the limit @xmath151 , this goes like @xmath152 , which , multiplied by the prefactor @xmath153 , implies the behavior @xmath154 . that is , only the ( @xmath155)-term can give a non - vanishing contribution . consider again eq . ( [ lapdifeq ] ) and a finite interval @xmath156 $ ] . the corresponding green function of the operator @xmath157 can be easily constructed ( at least formally ) with the help of the sturm liouville theory @xcite . an immediate consequence of the latter is that for @xmath158 the green function has the form @xmath159 where the functions @xmath120 and @xmath121 satisfy eq . ( [ diffeqfg ] ) with the initial conditions @xmath160 and @xmath161 , and @xmath162 and @xmath163 , respectively . in addition , the above green function should be symmetric due to the hermitian nature of @xmath164 . the sturm liouville theory ensures that the solution to the second - order differential equation ( [ diffeqfg ] ) is unique , when specifying the values of @xmath165 and @xmath166 at some point @xmath167 . therefore , the functions @xmath128 and @xmath129 must coincide with @xmath168 and @xmath169 of eq . ( [ diaggreenexpl ] ) , and the diagonal part of ( [ sturmgreen ] ) , i.e. @xmath170 , reduces to expression ( [ diaggreenexpl ] ) . this is an important consistency check of our representation ( [ diaglapl ] ) . let us now generalize the pi representation ( [ diaglapl ] ) to the full bloch density matrix , i.e. , we wish to include also the off - diagonal matrix elements , @xmath67 . if we go back to the replica representation ( [ afterrepl ] ) , we realize that the requirement @xmath67 spoils rotational symmetry in the replica field space , and thus precludes straightforward reduction to a radial path integral . instead of refining the reduction procedure , we simply make a guess , which , as we prove in appendix [ sec : app ] , coincides with the well - established sturm liouville formula ( [ sturmgreen ] ) . our guess is based on mathematical results presented in @xcite . in particular , we claim that the extension of the representation ( [ diaglapl ] ) to off - diagonal matrix elements should read @xmath171 } \ , , \ ] ] with the action functional @xmath172 \ \equiv \ \mathcal{a}^e[\eta ] \ + \ \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\ ! dx \ \ ! \eta^2(x)}\ , , \ ] ] where @xmath173 $ ] is defined in eq . ( [ actionho ] ) , and @xmath174 is a piecewise constant function @xmath175 \\ ( d-1)(d-3 ) & { \rm otherwise } . \end{cases}\ ] ] at this point we can invert the laplace transform with the help of eq . ( [ inverselap ] ) . as a result , we obtain the sought local - time pi representation of the bloch density matrix ( [ rhodef ] ) , namely @xmath176 } \ , .\ ] ] here , integrations over @xmath177 run from @xmath178 to @xmath179 , i.e. , the paths @xmath177 are non - negative . comparing this result with the anticipated heuristic form ( [ heurform ] ) , we can identify @xmath180 . representation ( [ offdiag ] ) allows us to identify the weight factor ( [ iii.7.a ] ) with @xmath181 \ = \ \frac{2}{d^2 } ( \eta_- \eta_+)^{\frac{1-d}{2 } } \eta(x_a ) \eta(x_b ) \exp \left\ { -\int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\!\ ! dx \left[\frac{\hbar^2}{2 m}{\eta'}^2 + \frac{m}{\hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2 } \right ] \right\ } .\ ] ] contrary to expectation , the right - hand - side of this expression does not depend on @xmath5 . sub - index @xmath89 in @xmath182 indicates that the weight factor must be regularized when we pull it out of the pi ( [ offdiag ] ) . by analogy with quantum mechanics one can represent ( [ offdiag ] ) in the discretized time - sliced form . in such a case the weight @xmath182 would be a product of terms involving the bessel functions @xmath113 , if @xmath183 , or @xmath184 , if @xmath185 ( see ref . @xcite ) . last but not least , expressions ( [ offdiag])-([weights ] ) indicate that the square root of @xmath3 is ( at least from physicist s point of view ) more convenient variable to describe local - time trajectories than @xmath3 alone . formula ( [ offdiag ] ) provides a way of rewriting the pi ( [ pix ] ) in terms of the local time . in this section , we consider more general scenario , in which the initial path integral is of the form @xmath186 \ \ ! \exp\left\{-\frac{1}{\hbar } \int_{0}^{\beta\hbar } \!\!\!d\tau \left[\frac{m}{2}\dot{x}^2 + v(x ) \right ] \right\ } , \ ] ] where @xmath128 is an arbitrary functional of the local time @xmath187 , which itself is ( as seen in section [ sec : heuristic ] ) a functional of the paths @xmath20 . relation ( [ pifunc ] ) represents a local - time analog of the feynman salam formula @xcite . to bring it into more manageable form , we may observe that for any @xmath2 , the action of @xmath3 in the pi ( [ pifunc ] ) can be taken over by the functional derivative @xmath188 , acting on the exponential . this becomes transparent after rewriting the potential part as @xmath189 . the entire functional @xmath190 $ ] can be therefore pulled out of the path integral , which then allows to write @xmath191 \rho(x_a , x_b,\beta ) \ , .\ ] ] when we employ the local - time representation of pi for @xmath12 ( cf . ( [ offdiag ] ) ) , each functional derivative @xmath192 will produce the term @xmath193 . in such a way @xmath194 can be written as @xmath195 e^ { - \mathcal{a}^{e=0}_\delta[\eta ] } \ , , \label{ltfunc}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , strictly speaking , the functional @xmath196 $ ] is regularized in such a way that it depends on @xmath3 only for @xmath197 $ ] , and @xmath198 are sent to @xmath199 only at the end of the calculation . first , let us make the simple observation that the formula ( [ ltfunc ] ) reduces to ( [ offdiag ] ) for the choice @xmath190 = 1 $ ] . one of the most important mean values of a local - time functional , as evaluated with eq . ( [ ltfunc ] ) , is the mean of @xmath200 which gives the moment - generating functional . the local - time moment structure is particularly pertinent in various perturbative expansions , including low- and high - temperature expansions ( see section [ sec : asymp ] ) . another important example , namely the case of a one - point distribution function will be discussed in the following subsection . in passing we should note , that should we have started from ( [ replrepre ] ) and repeated the above procedure , an analog of eq . ( [ ltfunc ] ) for higher - dimensional spaces , @xmath99 , could be easily obtained . this would include the @xmath89-dimensional replica field @xmath107 in the @xmath201-dimensional euclidean configuration space . simple , though quite important consequence of eq . ( [ ltfunc ] ) is that it readily provides the @xmath116-point distribution functions of the local time . this is achieved when we set @xmath190 = \prod_{n=1}^n \delta ( l^{x_n } - l_n ) $ ] . in order to see what is involved let us now illustrate the calculation for @xmath202 ( with @xmath203 ) . our discussion will be greatly simplified by considering only a free particle ( i.e. , @xmath204 ) that starts and ends at the origin , i.e. , @xmath205 . this corresponds to a stochastic process known as brownian bridge . our goal is to derive the one - point distribution function , denoted @xmath206 , of the local time at @xmath207 . we define @xmath206 by eq . ( [ pifunc ] ) with @xmath190=\delta ( l^0 - l ) $ ] , and calculate it from the representation ( [ ltfunc ] ) as follows . in the laplace picture , @xmath208 , the path integral ( [ ltfunc ] ) can be sliced at @xmath209 so that @xmath210 the @xmath211-integration can be done easily by realizing that @xmath212 . furthermore , the limits in @xmath111 and @xmath89 can be carried out with the help of formulas ( [ etalimminus ] ) and ( [ etalimplus ] ) from appendix [ sec : app ] . consequently , we obtain @xmath213 , \ ] ] where , for the free - particle case , @xmath214/\sqrt{2me/\hbar^2}$ ] , and @xmath215/\sqrt{2me/\hbar^2}$ ] , as one can straightforwardly verify . in the limit @xmath216 , ( [ ex1 ] ) reduces to @xmath217 and its inverse - laplace transform yields @xmath218 we stress that @xmath206 thus obtained is , in fact , the ( unnormalized ) _ joint _ probability density for stochastic events @xmath219 " and @xmath220 " . by bayes theorem of the probability calculus , the desired conditional probability density @xmath221 $ ] is obtained from ( [ ltfree ] ) by dividing @xmath206 by the brownian - bridge probability density @xmath222 $ ] , which is ( omitting again normalization ) @xmath223 ( see , e.g. , ref . normalization factors mutually cancel in the fraction and we arrive at @xmath224 \ = \ \frac{\hbar^2 l \exp\left(- \frac{l^2 \hbar^2}{2\beta m } \right)}{{\beta m}}\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] which is clearly normalized to @xmath225 . one can proceed along the same lines also in more complicated higher - dimensional ( @xmath226 ) cases . our result agrees with the one found through other means in ref . a compelling feature of the local - time representation ( [ offdiag ] ) is that it naturally captures both small- and large-@xmath5 asymptotic regimes . this should be compared with the feynman kac pi representation ( [ pix ] ) , which is typically suitable only for the small-@xmath5 ( i.e. , large - temperature ) analysis . the latter is epitomized either by wkb approximation @xcite or wigner kirkwood expansion @xcite . in the large-@xmath5 ( small - temperature ) limit , the spectral representation of the gibbs operator , @xmath227 , reduces the bloch density matrix to the ground - state contribution @xmath228 that is not evident from the feynman kac pi representation @xcite . in connection with eq . ( [ spectralasymp ] ) it is useful to remind that in @xmath229 the discrete bound states can all be chosen to be real @xcite , so that the bloch density matrix is real and symmetric and can be written in the form @xmath230 let us first comment on the small-@xmath5 regime of the local - time representation , assuming @xmath66 for simplicity . this case was discussed in detail in our previous article @xcite . there one should first taylor - expand the potential @xmath50 around the point @xmath33 , and then expand the exponential part containing the structure @xmath231 , where @xmath232^m\ , .\end{aligned}\ ] ] after the term @xmath233 is factored out of the integral , the individual summands of the ensuing series are of the form ( [ ltfunc ] ) with the potential @xmath204 , and functional @xmath190 \propto \prod_n l^{x_n}/\hbar$ ] . the latter can be related to the power expansion in @xmath5 presented in @xcite through the equality of representations ( [ pifunc ] ) and ( [ ltfunc ] ) . the whole bloch density matrix ( containing also off - diagonal elements ) can be treated similarly in a full analogy with ref . @xcite . the large-@xmath5 expansion of eq . ( [ offdiag ] ) can be conveniently studied after rescaling @xmath234 , in which case we can write @xmath235 & \times & \ \delta \ ! \left ( \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\!\ ! \eta^2 dx - 1 \right ) \exp \left\ { -\int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\!\ ! dx \left[\frac{\beta \hbar^2}{2 m}{\eta'}^2 + \beta v(x)\eta^2 + \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2 } \right ] \right\ } \nonumber \\[3 mm ] & = & \ \lim_{d \rightarrow 0 } \frac{2}{d^2 } \lim_{\eta_\pm \rightarrow 0 } ( \eta_- \eta_+)^{\frac{1-d}{2 } } \frac{\beta \delta^2}{\delta j(x_a ) \delta j(x_b ) } \int_{c - i\infty}^{c+i\infty } \frac{d \kappa } { 2\pi i } \int_{\eta(x_-)=\eta_-}^{\eta(x_+)=\eta_+ } \mathcal{d}\eta(x)\nonumber\\[1 mm ] & \times & \ \exp\left\ { - \beta \left[\int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\!\ ! dx \left(\frac{\hbar^2}{2 m}{\eta'}^2 + v(x)\eta^2 - \kappa \eta^2\right ) + \kappa \right ] \right\}\nonumber\\[1 mm ] & \times & \ \left . \exp\left\ { - \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } \!\!\ ! dx \left [ \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2 } + j\eta \right ] \right\}\right|_{j=0 } , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath236 is an arbitrary real number . with the _ method of images _ @xcite we can rewrite the radial pi involved as a superposition of two genuine one - dimensional pi s @xcite @xmath237 - \langle j|\eta \rangle \right\ } \exp\left [ - \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } dx\ \ ! \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2}\right]_{\!r}\nonumber \\[3 mm ] & & \mbox{\hspace{10mm}}= \ \int_{\eta(x_-)=\eta_-}^{\eta(x_+)=\eta_+ } \mathcal{d}\eta(x ) \exp\left\{-\beta\left[\langle \eta| \hat{h}| \eta \rangle -\kappa\left(\langle \eta|\eta \rangle -1 \right ) \right ] - \langle j||\eta| \rangle \right\}\nonumber \\[1 mm ] & & \mbox{\hspace{14 mm } } \times \ \exp\left [ - \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } dx\ \ ! \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2}\right]\nonumber \\[1 mm ] & & \mbox{\hspace{10 mm } } -\ \cos(\pi d/2 ) \int_{\eta(x_-)=-\eta_-}^{\eta(x_+)=\eta_+ } \mathcal{d}\eta(x ) \exp\left\{-\beta\left[\langle \eta| \hat{h}| \eta \rangle -\kappa\left(\langle \eta|\eta \rangle -1 \right ) \right ] - \langle j||\eta| \rangle \right\ } \nonumber \\[1 mm ] & & \mbox{\hspace{14 mm } } \times \ \exp\left [ - \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } dx\ \ ! \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2}\right ] , \label{method - images-1aa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where dirac s notation was employed . a few comments are in order about the right - hand - side of the above relation . first , it should be noticed the presence of the parity - even terms @xmath238 in pi s . second , pi s differ by their respective dirichlet boundary conditions . third , the super - index `` @xmath239 '' was used to stress the restricted nature of the fluctuations in the radial pi measure while the measure without `` @xmath239 '' represents a usual one - dimensional pi measure , i.e. @xmath240 here `` @xmath241 '' denotes de witt s `` equivalence '' symbol @xcite . finally , the correct time - sliced form of the exponential with the centrifugal potential is ( cf . e.g. , refs . @xcite ) @xmath242_{\!r } \ \lim_{n\rightarrow \infty}\prod_{k=1}^n \sqrt{2\pi \frac{\beta \hbar^2}{m } \frac{\eta_k\eta_{k-1}}{\varepsilon } \tilde{\delta}_k } \ \ ! \exp\left(-\frac{\beta \hbar^2}{m } \frac{\eta_k\eta_{k-1}}{\varepsilon } \tilde{\delta}_k \right ) i_{\frac{d-2}{2}}\left ( \frac{\beta \hbar^2}{m } \frac{\eta_k\eta_{k-1}}{\varepsilon } \tilde{\delta}_k\right ) , \nonumber \\[2 mm ] & & \exp\left [ - \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } dx\ \ ! \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2}\right ] \ \lim_{n\rightarrow \infty}\prod_{k=1}^n \psi_{\frac{d-2}{2}}\left(-\frac{\beta \hbar^2}{m } \frac{|\eta_k\eta_{k-1}|}{\varepsilon } \tilde{\delta}_k\right ) , \label{centrifugal - slicing-1a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath243 \\ 1 & { \rm otherwise } , \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] and ( see , e.g. , refs . @xcite ) @xmath244 \ = \ e^x \sqrt{\frac{2 x } { \pi } } k_p(x)\ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] [ @xmath245 and @xmath246 are the modified bessel functions of the first and the second kind , respectively . ] in cases when @xmath247 meaning that @xmath248 ( e.g. , `` typical situation '' for very fine time slicings ) the asymptotic form of @xmath249 holds . with help of the preceding asymptotic behavior one obtains @xmath250\nonumber \\[1 mm ] & \sim & \ \prod_{k=1}^n \exp\left[- \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2 } \frac{\delta_k}{8|\eta_k\eta_{k-1}| } \ \!\varepsilon + { \mathcal{o}}(\varepsilon^2 ) \right]\nonumber \\[1 mm ] & \sim & \ \exp\left [ - \int_{x_-}^{x_+ } dx\ \ ! \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2}\frac{\delta(x)}{8 \eta^2}\right ] . \label{48.aa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] potential singularities of the integral at @xmath251 can be regularized , e.g. , by a principal value prescription . unfortunately , the formula ( [ 48.aa ] ) can not be directly used in our case because the boundary values @xmath252 and @xmath253 are arbitrarily close to zero , and hence the assumed asymptotic behavior for @xmath254 is not fulfilled . this situation can be rectified by factorizing out the problematic boundary points as @xmath255 & & \sim \ \frac{1}{\pi}\left(\frac{\beta \hbar^2}{2 m \varepsilon}\right)^{d-1 } \left(|\eta_-\eta_{1}||\eta_+ \eta_{_{n-1}}|\right)^{(d-1)/2}\ \ ! \prod_{k=2}^{n-1 } \exp\left[- \frac{m}{\beta \hbar^2 } \frac{\delta_k}{8|\eta_k\eta_{k-1}| } \ \!\varepsilon + { \mathcal{o}}(\varepsilon^2 ) \right ] . \ ] ] here we have utilized the asymptotic form @xmath256 valid for @xmath257 and @xmath258 ( @xmath259 ) . the passage from the radial pi ( [ offdiagrescaled ] ) to the ordinary ( 1-dimensional ) pi brings about an important advantage , namely , one can perform the wkb approximation . in particular , one can use the laplace s formula of the asymptotic calculus @xcite @xmath260 \ = \ \sqrt{\frac{2\pi}{\beta g''(t_0 ) } } \ \ ! f(t_0 ) \ \ ! \exp\left[-\beta g(t_0 ) \right ] \ + \ { \mathcal{o}}\left ( \frac{\exp\left[-\beta g(t_0 ) \right]}{\beta^{3/2 } } \right ) , \label{laplace}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath261 being a solution of @xmath262 ( provided @xmath263 has a smooth absolute minimum at the interior point @xmath264 ) . in case of need , the full asymptotic expansion can be found , e.g. , in ref . @xcite . in our case the customary pi substitution @xmath265^{-1/2}\ , , \label{vi.49a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] should be employed @xcite . here @xmath266 is the ground state energy and the difference operators ( lattice derivatives ) are defined as @xcite @xmath267\ , , \;\;\;\;\ ; \overline{\nabla } \eta(x ) \ = \ \frac{1}{\varepsilon}\left[\eta(x ) \ - \ \eta(x-\varepsilon ) \right]\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath268 being the hermitian operator on the space of `` time - sliced '' functions with vanishing end points , i.e. , @xmath269 . the ensuing determinant @xmath270 in ( [ vi.49a ] ) can be conveniently computed by means of the gelfand yaglom method @xcite ( or shifting method @xcite ) . there the determinant @xmath271 where @xmath272 is finite in the @xmath273 limit and fulfills the differential equation @xmath274 d(x ) \ = \ 0\ , , \label{vi.51a}\end{aligned}\ ] ] with the cauchy conditions @xmath275 and @xmath276 . the solution @xmath272 can be written as a linear combination of two independent solutions of ( [ vi.51a ] ) . one is immediate , namely the wkb solution @xmath277 . a second solution can be constructed with the help of dalambert s formula directly from @xmath277 in the form ( cf . e.g. , ref . @xcite ) @xmath278 it is simple to verify that ( [ vi.52a ] ) is again a solution of ( [ vi.51a ] ) . the cauchy conditions in the gelfand yaglom method uniquely fix the constants in front of the two independent solutions so that the full solution @xmath272 acquires the form @xmath279 as a result we obtain in the large @xmath116 ( i.e. , small @xmath115 ) limit @xmath280 \ \stackrel{\varepsilon \rightarrow 0}{\longrightarrow } \ \frac{\eta_+ \eta_-}{\varepsilon } \int^{x_+}_{x_- } \frac{dx}{\eta_0 ^ 2(x)}\ , . \label{vi.55aa}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the great advantage of the gelfand yaglom method is that it does not require any detailed knowledge of the spectrum of the operator whose determinant is being computed . it also shows that the determinant in ( [ vi.49a ] ) diverges linearly with @xmath116 in the large @xmath116 limit . we now substitute for @xmath281 in ( [ laplace ] ) the functional expression @xmath282 \ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where , @xmath277 comes from the path that minimizes the functional @xmath283 . according to the rayleigh ritz variation principle ( see , e.g. , refs . @xcite ) , such a function @xmath177 is the ground - state wavefunction of the hamiltonian @xmath164 , i.e. , @xmath284 with @xmath285 . with a hindsight , we have used the latter value of @xmath286 already in eqs . ( [ vi.49a ] ) , ( [ vi.51a ] ) and ( [ vi.55aa ] ) . notice that the stationary point in @xmath286 is real but the integration contour in @xmath286 is parallel to the imaginary axis . both reality and positivity of @xmath177 pose no restriction in the rayleigh ritz principle , because the ground state can always be chosen real and positive @xcite . putting it all together , we get the leading large-@xmath5 behavior in the form @xmath287 as it should be ( cf . ( [ spectralasymp2 ] ) ) . we conclude the discussion of low - temperature expansion by noting that the rayleigh ritz variation principle states that _ all _ eigenvalues and ( normalized ) eigenvectors of @xmath164 come from stationary solutions of @xmath288 , and conversely @xcite . in the spirit of the wkb approximation one should sum over all path integrals evaluated about _ all _ stationary solutions . it is , however , only the ground state configuration @xmath289 that acquires the global minimum and which gives the larges contribution to the wkb approximation . this fact was implicitly used in our preceding reasonings . should we have included also other stationary solutions we would recover higher order terms in the spectral expansion of the bloch density matrix ( [ spectralasymp2 ] ) . in this paper , we have derived the local - time pi representation of the bloch density matrix . we have shown that the result obtained , apart from being of interest in pure mathematics ( stochastic theory , sturm liouville theory , etc ) , can serve as a useful alternative to the traditional feynman kac pi representation of green functions of fokker planck equations . furthermore , by analytically continuing the result back to the real time via the inverse wick rotation , @xmath290 , one obtains the local - time pi representation of quantum - mechanical transition amplitudes , i.e. , matrix elements of the evolution operator @xmath291 . from the physicists point of view , perhaps the most important application of local - time pi s lies in statistical physics , and namely in the low and high temperature treatments of the bloch density matrix . this is because in conventional pi s only a very tiny subset of paths gives a relevant contribution in these asymptotic regimes . in particular , the high - temperature regime of the boltzmann density function @xmath292 is dominated by paths that spend a sizable amount of time in the vicinity of the point @xmath0 . similarly , the low - temperature regime is controlled by paths with a large local time near the global minimum of the potential . here we have exemplified the conceptual convenience of the local - time formulation by providing a generic analysis of the low - temperature behavior of the bloch density matrix . our formulation proved to be particularly instrumental in obtaining the correct asymptotic behavior ( known from the spectral theory ) which is otherwise notoriously difficult to obtain within the feynman kac pi framework @xcite . as a byproduct we have uncovered an interesting connection between a low - temperature pi expansion , the gelfand yaglom formula and the rayleigh ritz variational principle . in order to further reinforce our analysis , we formulated a local - time analog of the feynman matthews salam formula which is ( similarly as its qft counterpart ) expedient in number of statistical - physics contexts . the prescription obtained was substantiated by an explicit calculation of a one - point distribution function of the local time . it appears worthwhile to stress that our local - time representation ( with its build - in replica field trick ) is in its present form applicable only to one - dimensional quantum mechanical systems . with a hindsight we reflected this fact already in our choice of the incipient pi ( [ pix ] ) where we assumed @xmath293 and @xmath294 . though one may easily proceed up to eq . ( [ replrepre ] ) without any restriction on the value of @xmath201 ( in fact , eq . ( [ replrepre ] ) is valid for any @xmath99 with @xmath295 ) , a further progress in this direction is hindered by the fact that the replica fields depend on a @xmath201-dimensional argument @xmath0 , and thus the pi in ( [ replrepre ] ) can no longer be regarded as a quantum mechanical pi ( i.e. , pi over fluctuating paths ) . in effect , we can not use existing mathematical techniques of the pi calculus ( e.g. , transformation of pi s to polar coordinates ) , that we have employed to get the radial pi ( [ diaglapl ] ) . the issue of the extension of our local - time pi representation to higher - dimensional configuration space is currently under active investigation . the authors acknowledge a. alastuey , h. kleinert , z. haba and d.s . grebenkov for fruitful discussions . the work has been supported by the gar grant no . ga14 - 07983s . was also partially supported by the ctu in prague grant no . sgs13/217/ohk4/3t/14 and by the dfg grant : kl 256/54 - 1 . in this appendix we show that the representation ( [ laploffdiag ] ) reduces to the well established result ( [ sturmgreen ] ) of the sturm liouville theory . since @xmath83 is symmetric in @xmath33 and @xmath34 , we will assume , without loss of generality , that @xmath296 . the path integral in ( [ laploffdiag ] ) can be expressed via eq . ( [ radialhosol ] ) as @xmath297 the limits in eq . ( [ laploffdiag ] ) can be carried with the help of the asymptotic formulas @xmath135 , and @xmath136 , valid for @xmath298 . we obtain @xmath299 & & \xrightarrow{d \rightarrow 0 } \ \frac{1}{\sqrt{\eta_a } } \exp \left ( -\frac{\hbar^2}{2 m } \frac{f'_1(x_a)}{f_1(x_a ) } \eta_a^2 \right)\ ! , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath140 satisfies eq . ( [ diffeqfg ] ) with initial conditions @xmath300 and @xmath301 , and similarly , we find @xmath302 where @xmath303 satisfies eq . ( [ diffeqfg ] ) with initial conditions @xmath304 and @xmath305 . formula ( [ laploffdiag ] ) then reduces to @xmath306 & & \times \ \ ! \exp \left [ - \frac{\hbar^2}{2 m } \left ( \frac{w(g_2,f_1 ) \eta_a^2}{f_1(x_a ) g_2(x_a ) } + \frac{w(g_3,f_2 ) \eta_b^2}{f_2(x_b ) g_3(x_b ) } \right ) \right]\ , , \end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath307 and @xmath143 satisfy eq . ( [ diffeqfg ] ) with initial conditions @xmath308 and @xmath309 , and @xmath310 and @xmath311 , respectively . the wronskian @xmath127 is independent of @xmath0 , as discussed in section [ sec : radial ] , and antisymmetric , i.e. , @xmath312 . wronskians @xmath313 and @xmath314 assume a particularly simple form when evaluated at points @xmath34 and @xmath33 , respectively , due to the initial conditions satisfied by @xmath169 and @xmath315 . we find @xmath316 and @xmath317 . rescaling @xmath318 , @xmath319 , and using the relation @xmath320 we obtain @xmath321 the integrations are readily performed using the formula @xcite @xmath322 yielding @xmath323 to prove equality with ( [ sturmgreen ] ) , we only have to show that @xmath324 this is done by realizing that @xmath143 , being a solution of the second - order linear differential equation ( [ diffeqfg ] ) , can be uniquely composed as a linear combination of two other solutions @xmath140 and @xmath303 , @xmath325 indeed , thus defined @xmath169 satisfies the initial conditions @xmath310 and @xmath311 . the low temperature expansion is typically obtained indirectly via duality approaches . among these , a particularly powerful non - perturbative approximation scheme is the so - called _ variational _ or _ optimized _ perturbation theory @xcite . f. steiner , _ path integrals in polar coordinates from ev to gev _ , in _ path integrals from mev to mev , bielefeld , 1985 _ , edited by m.c . gutzwiller et al . ( world scientific , singapore , 1986 ) pp . 335 - 359 .
Abstract: | [
"* abstract * + we derive a local - time path - integral representation for a generic one - dimensional time - independent system . in particular , we show how to rephrase the matrix elements of the bloch density matrix as a path integral over @xmath0-dependent local - time profiles . the latter quantify the time that the sample paths @xmath1 in the feynman path integral spend in the vicinity of an arbitrary point @xmath0 . generalization of the local - time representation that includes arbitrary functionals of the local time is also provided . we argue that the results obtained represent a powerful alternative to the traditional feynman kac formula , particularly in the high and low temperature regimes . to illustrate this point , we apply our local - time representation to analyze the asymptotic behavior of the bloch density matrix at low temperatures . further salient issues , such as connections with the sturm liouville theory and the rayleigh ritz variational principle are also discussed ."
] | 8,848 | 8,848 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: let @xmath9 be a group with a generating set @xmath10 , and acting on a set @xmath1 . the ( simplicial ) schreier graph @xmath11 of the action @xmath12 is the graph with the set of vertices @xmath1 , where two vertices @xmath13 and @xmath14 are adjacent if and only if there exists @xmath15 such that @xmath16 . the schreier graphs are generalizations of the cayley graph of a group , which corresponds to the action of a group on itself by the left multiplication . the growth of cayley graphs ( growth of groups ) is one of the central objects of study in geometric group theory . the celebrated theorem of m. gromov characterizes groups of polynomial growth . many classical groups ( like linear groups , solvable groups , hyperbolic groups , etc . ) have either polynomial or exponential growth . the first group of intermediate growth between polynomial and exponential was constructed by r. grigorchuk @xcite . nowadays , the grigorchuk group is the best known example of automaton groups ( also known as self - similar groups , or groups generated by automata ) . in this paper , we consider the growth of schreier graphs of automaton groups . every automaton group @xmath9 generated by an automaton @xmath17 over some alphabet @xmath1 naturally acts on the set @xmath18 for every @xmath19 , and on the space @xmath0 of right - infinite sequences over @xmath1 . we get the associated sequence of finite schreier graphs @xmath20 of the action @xmath21 , and the family of orbital schreier graphs @xmath22 for @xmath2 of the action of @xmath9 on the orbit of @xmath4 . the schreier graphs @xmath23 and @xmath5 provide a large source of self - similar graphs , and were studied in relation to such topics as spectrum , growth , amenability , topology of julia sets , etc . ( see @xcite ) . it was noticed in @xcite that for a few automaton groups the sequence of schreier graphs @xmath23 converges to a nice metric space with fractal structure . further , this observation lead to the notion of a limit space of an automaton group , and , more generally , to a limit dynamical system @xcite . the expanding property of this dynamical system corresponds to the contracting property of a group , what brings us to the important class of contracting automaton groups . namely the strong contracting properties of the grigorchuk group was used to prove that it has intermediate growth , while in general a contracting group may have exponential growth . at the same time , all orbital schreier graphs @xmath5 of contracting groups have polynomial growth @xcite . the degree of the growth is related to the asymptotic characteristics of the group such as the complexity of the word problem , the hausdorff dimension of the limit space , the exponent of divergence of geodesics in the associated gromov - hyperbolic self - similarity complex , etc . ( see @xcite ) . most of the studied automaton groups are generated by polynomial automata . these automata were introduced by s. sidki in @xcite , who tried to classify automaton groups by the cyclic structure of the generating automaton . a finite automaton is called polynomial if the simple directed cycles away from the trivial state are disjoint . the term polynomial " comes from the equivalent definition , where a finite automaton is polynomial if the number of paths of length @xmath24 avoiding the trivial state in the automaton grows polynomially in @xmath24 . it is an open problem whether contracting groups and groups generated by polynomial automata are amenable . however , it is known that these groups do not contain nonabelian free subgroups @xcite ( but may contain free semigroups and be of exponential growth ) , and that groups generated by polynomial automata of degree @xmath25 ( bounded automata ) are amenable @xcite . in @xcite v. nekrashevych introduced a general approach to the existence of free subgroups in automaton groups , and applied it to contracting groups and to groups generated by polynomial automata . in order to eliminate one of the cases , he proved that the orbital schreier graphs @xmath5 are amenable , and conjectured @xcite that these graphs may have subexponential growth . this conjecture was based on the results from @xcite , where it is shown that for the group generated by one of the simplest polynomial automata all schreier graphs @xmath5 have intermediate growth . the main goal of this paper is to prove this conjecture . [ theorem_main ] let @xmath9 be a group generated by a polynomial automaton of degree @xmath7 . there exists a constant @xmath26 such that all orbital schreier graphs @xmath27 for @xmath2 have subexponential growth not greater than @xmath28 . in order to prove theorem 1 we establish certain weak contracting properties of groups generated by polynomial automata . in particular , we prove that the word problem in these groups is solvable in subexponential time bounded above by @xmath29 for some constant @xmath30 . we also prove theorem [ theorem_main ] for a more general class of automata ( see theorem [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] in section [ generalized version ] ) , which generalizes both polynomial automata and contracting groups . in section [ section_examples ] we apply theorem [ theorem_main ] and its generalized version to construct automaton groups with schreier graphs @xmath5 of intermediate growth . in the first example we consider a class of automaton groups , whose schreier graphs @xmath5 are a generalized version of the @xmath8-periodic graph of intermediate growth studied in @xcite . basically , this example shows that for many polynomial automata the schreier graphs @xmath5 have intermediate growth . another example comes from the well - known hanoi tower game on @xmath31 pegs . this game was modeled by automaton groups @xmath32 in @xcite , and , using known estimates on the complexity of the hanoi tower game , it was noticed that the orbital schreier graph @xmath33 for @xmath34 has intermediate growth . the automata generating groups @xmath32 for @xmath34 are not polynomial , but we apply similar arguments to prove that all orbital schreier graphs @xmath35 have intermediate growth . in this section we recall all needed definition , see @xcite for a more detailed introduction . * spaces of words . * let @xmath1 be a finite alphabet with at least two letters . denote by @xmath36 the set of all finite words over @xmath1 ( including the empty word denoted @xmath37 ) . the length of a word @xmath38 is denoted by @xmath39 . let @xmath40 be the space of all infinite sequences ( words ) @xmath41 , @xmath42 , with the product topology of discrete sets @xmath1 . the space @xmath0 is homeomorphic to the cantor set , i.e. , it is compact totally disconnected metrizable topological space without isolated points . * automata . * an invertible _ automaton _ @xmath17 over the alphabet @xmath1 is the triple @xmath43 , where @xmath10 is the set of states of the automaton , @xmath44 is the transition function , and @xmath45 is the output function such that for every @xmath46 the map @xmath47 is a permutation on @xmath1 . all automata in the paper are invertible , and further we omit the term invertible . an automaton is _ finite _ if the set of its states is finite . an automaton @xmath17 is represented by a directed labeled graph ( moore diagram ) , whose vertices are the states of @xmath17 , and for every state @xmath46 and every letter @xmath48 there is an arrow @xmath49 labeled by the pair @xmath50 . this diagram contains complete information about the automaton , and we identify the automaton with its moore diagram . the notation @xmath17 is also used for the state set of the automaton @xmath17 , so that one can talk about a state @xmath51 . a subset @xmath52 ( with induced edges ) is a _ subautomaton _ of @xmath17 if @xmath53 for every @xmath54 and @xmath48 . * automaton groups . * for every state @xmath51 and every finite word @xmath55 there exists a unique path in the automaton @xmath17 starting at the state @xmath56 and labeled by @xmath57 , @xmath58 , , @xmath59 for some @xmath60 . then the word @xmath61 is called the image of @xmath62 under @xmath56 , and the end state of this path is denoted by @xmath63 . in other words , for every finite word @xmath64 we define the _ image @xmath65 of @xmath66 under @xmath56 _ and the _ state _ @xmath63 recursively by the rules @xmath67 for every @xmath48 and @xmath64 . the action of states of @xmath17 on the set @xmath18 can be given by the automaton @xmath68 obtained from @xmath17 by passing to the power @xmath18 of the alphabet @xmath1 . the automaton @xmath68 is defined over the alphabet @xmath18 , and has the same states as @xmath17 , but the arrows are @xmath69 labeled by @xmath70 for every @xmath51 and @xmath71 . in the same way we get an action of every state @xmath51 on the space @xmath0 by looking at the infinite paths in the automaton . since the automata are invertible , all transformations @xmath51 are also invertible . the group @xmath9 generated by all states @xmath51 is called the _ automaton group _ generated by @xmath17 . since every state preserves the length of words in its action on @xmath72 , the states act by isometries on the space @xmath0 , and every automaton group is a subgroup of @xmath73 . the automaton groups generated by @xmath17 and @xmath68 coincide viewed as subgroups of @xmath73 with the natural identification @xmath74 . all automata in the paper are supposed to be minimized , i.e. , different states of a given automaton act differently on @xmath0 . hence we identify the states with the respective transformations of @xmath0 . an alternative approach is through self - similar actions . a faithful action of a group @xmath9 on the set @xmath75 is called _ self - similar _ if for every @xmath76 and @xmath64 there exist @xmath77 and @xmath78 such that @xmath79 for all @xmath80 . the element @xmath81 is called the _ restriction ( state ) of @xmath82 at @xmath66 _ and is denoted by @xmath83 . we are using left actions , i.e. , @xmath84 , and hence the restrictions have the property @xmath85 every self - similar action of a group @xmath9 is given by the _ complete automaton _ @xmath86 of the group , whose states are the elements of @xmath9 , and the arrows are @xmath87 labeled by @xmath88 for every @xmath76 and @xmath48 . an automaton group @xmath9 is called _ contracting _ if there exists a finite subset @xmath89 with the property that for every @xmath76 there exists @xmath90 such that @xmath91 for all words @xmath64 of length @xmath92 . the smallest set @xmath93 with this property is called the _ nucleus _ of the group . notice that a finitely generated contracting group can be generated by a finite automaton . a group @xmath9 generated by a finite automaton is contracting if and only if the complete automaton @xmath86 of the group contains only finitely many simple directed cycles . throughout the paper by a _ cycle _ in an automaton we mean a simple directed cycle . states that lie on cycles are called _ circuit_. an element @xmath82 of an automaton group @xmath9 is circuit if there exists a nonempty word @xmath64 such that @xmath94 . * polynomial automata . * a cycle in an automaton is called trivial if it is a loop at the state acting trivially on @xmath0 ( trivial state , denoted @xmath95 ) . a finite automaton @xmath17 is called _ polynomial _ if different nontrivial cycles in @xmath17 are disjoint . a polynomial automaton @xmath17 is _ of degree @xmath7 _ if the largest number of nontrivial cycles in @xmath17 connected by a directed path is equal to @xmath96 . a finite automaton @xmath17 is polynomial ( of degree @xmath97 ) if and only if the number of directed paths in @xmath17 of length @xmath24 that do not pass through the trivial state is bounded by a polynomial in @xmath24 ( of degree @xmath97 ) . the set of all states ( transformations of @xmath0 ) of all polynomial automata of degree @xmath97 forms a group @xmath98 called the _ group of polynomial automata of degree _ every finitely generated subgroup of @xmath98 is a subgroup of some automaton group generated by a polynomial automaton . we classify the states of a polynomial automaton @xmath17 as follows . a state @xmath51 is _ finitary _ if there exists @xmath90 such that @xmath99 for all @xmath71 . the finitary states are precisely the elements of @xmath100 . the states from @xmath101 are called _ polynomial of degree @xmath7_. for every polynomial automaton @xmath17 there exists @xmath24 such that for every @xmath51 and @xmath71 the state @xmath63 is either circuit or has degree less than the degree of @xmath56 . notice , that if @xmath51 is a nontrivial circuit state , then for every @xmath24 there exists precisely one word @xmath71 such that @xmath56 and @xmath63 have the same degree as polynomial states , and @xmath102 for all @xmath103 , @xmath104 , has degree less than the degree of @xmath56 . * schreier graphs . * let @xmath9 be an automaton group generated by a finite subset @xmath10 . the _ schreier graph @xmath105 _ is the graph with the set of vertices @xmath18 , where two vertices @xmath66 and @xmath106 are adjacent if there exists @xmath15 such that @xmath107 . orbital schreier graph @xmath108 _ for @xmath2 is the graph whose vertex set is the orbit @xmath109 and two vertices @xmath66 and @xmath106 are adjacent if there exists @xmath15 such that @xmath107 . the orbital schreier graphs @xmath110 are precisely the connected components of the schreier graph @xmath111 of the action @xmath112 . every orbital schreier graph @xmath5 is a limit of the finite schreier graphs @xmath23 in the local gromov - hausdorff topology on pointed graphs . * growth of graphs . * let @xmath113 be a locally finite connected graph . the _ growth function _ @xmath114 of @xmath113 with respect to its vertex @xmath66 is equal to the number of vertices in the closed ball @xmath115 of radius @xmath24 centered at @xmath66 . there is a partial order on the growth functions . given two functions @xmath116 we say that @xmath117 has _ growth _ not greater than @xmath82 ( denoted @xmath118 ) if there exists a constant @xmath119 such that @xmath120 for all @xmath90 . if @xmath118 and @xmath121 then @xmath117 and @xmath82 are called equivalent @xmath122 and have the same growth . formally , by the growth we can understand the equivalence class of a function . then , for any two vertices of the graph @xmath113 , the respective growth functions are equivalent , and one can talk about the growth of @xmath113 . a graph @xmath113 has _ subexponential growth _ if its growth function has growth not greater than the exponential growth @xmath123 with @xmath124 , and is not equivalent to it . the growth is _ superpolynomial _ if it is greater than every polynomial function , and the growth is _ intermediate _ if it is superpolynomial and subexponential . let @xmath9 be a finitely generated group with finite generating set @xmath10 . the _ length _ @xmath125 of @xmath76 with respect to @xmath10 is equal to the distance between the trivial element @xmath95 and @xmath82 in the cayley graph @xmath126 , i.e. , @xmath127 and @xmath128 the growth function @xmath129 of the group @xmath9 is the growth function of the cayley graph @xmath126 with respect to the vertex @xmath95 , i.e. , @xmath130 is equal to the number of elements @xmath76 of length @xmath131 . the growth functions of the cayley graphs @xmath132 and @xmath133 , for any two finite generating sets @xmath134 and @xmath135 , are equivalent . the growth of schreier graphs @xmath136 of an automaton group @xmath9 also does not depend on the choice of a finite generating set @xmath10 of the group . working with automaton groups it is useful to assume that a generating set @xmath10 is _ self - similar _ ( automaton ) , i.e. , @xmath137 for every @xmath46 and @xmath64 . for example , we will frequently use the following observation . if there is a presentation @xmath138 for @xmath139 then for every @xmath64 we get the _ induced presentation _ @xmath140 where @xmath141 , and @xmath142 for @xmath143 . in particular , if @xmath10 is self - similar then @xmath144 and @xmath145 . also , it is usually assumed that @xmath10 is _ symmetric _ , i.e. , @xmath146 . all logarithms in the paper are with base @xmath147 , except if directly indicated . usually , a logarithm appears as @xmath148 , and the base can be hidden in the constant @xmath149 . also ( to avoid some multiple brackets ) we use the convention that @xmath150 and @xmath151 so that @xmath152 for all @xmath153 , otherwise one can just replace @xmath154 by @xmath155 . let us recall how to prove that for contracting groups the schreier graphs @xmath5 have polynomial growth ( see ( * ? ? ? * section 2.13.4 ) , @xcite ) . let @xmath9 be a finitely generated contracting group with nucleus @xmath93 , and let @xmath10 be a finite symmetric self - similar generating set of @xmath9 that contains @xmath93 . we can choose a constant @xmath149 such that @xmath156 for all @xmath157 and every word @xmath64 of length @xmath158 . consider an element @xmath76 and let @xmath138 for @xmath139 with @xmath159 . then @xmath160 and hence the element @xmath83 has length @xmath161 . it follows that @xmath91 for all words @xmath64 of length @xmath162 . this justifies the term contracting group : the length of restrictions exponentially decreases ( contracts " ) until they become elements of the nucleus . now consider the schreier graph @xmath163 for a sequence @xmath164 . let @xmath165 be the ball of radius @xmath24 in the graph @xmath5 centered at the vertex @xmath4 . notice that if @xmath166 for @xmath167 and @xmath168 then @xmath169 . let @xmath31 be the least integer greater than @xmath148 . then each sequence in the ball @xmath165 is of the form @xmath170 for some @xmath171 and @xmath172 for some @xmath173 . hence @xmath174 which is a polynomial in @xmath24 . more precise estimate can be given using the contracting coefficient of the group ( see ( * ? ? ? * proposition 2.13.8 ) ) . we want to apply similar arguments to groups generated by polynomial automata , and first we will establish certain weak contracting properties of these groups . [ lemma_weak_contr_poly ] let @xmath9 be a finitely generated subgroup of @xmath98 . there exists a constant @xmath149 such that for every @xmath76 and every word @xmath64 of length @xmath175 the state @xmath83 is either circuit or belongs to @xmath176 . to prove lemma [ lemma_weak_contr_poly ] we use induction on @xmath7 . however there is one slight difficulty , that in order to apply the induction hypothesis we may need to consider the length of the element @xmath83 for a different generating set than the length of @xmath82 . to overcome this problem we will make a few assumptions so that the groups involved in the induction have consistent generating sets . without loss of generality , we can assume that the group @xmath9 is an automaton subgroup of @xmath98 . let @xmath10 be a finite symmetric self - similar generating set of @xmath9 . let @xmath177 be an automaton subgroup of @xmath9 generated by @xmath178 for @xmath179 . the generating set @xmath180 is again symmetric and self - similar . notice that , in general , the group @xmath177 may not coincide with @xmath181 . let us prove that the length of cycles in the complete automaton @xmath86 of the group @xmath9 is bounded . without loss of generality , by passing to a power of the alphabet , we can assume that the alphabet @xmath1 and the generating set @xmath10 satisfy the following conditions : + 1 ) for every @xmath46 and @xmath48 the state @xmath182 is either circuit or has degree less than the + degree of @xmath56 ; + 2 ) for every nontrivial circuit state @xmath46 there exists ( unique ) @xmath48 such that @xmath183 + ( every cycle in @xmath10 is a loop ) . + ( for example , one can pass to the alphabet @xmath184 , where @xmath31 is a multiple of the length of every cycle in @xmath10 , and is greater than the diameter of @xmath10 ) . let us prove that then every cycle in the automaton @xmath86 is a loop , i.e. , for every circuit element @xmath76 there exists a letter @xmath48 such that @xmath185 . assume @xmath94 for a nonempty word @xmath186 and let @xmath138 for @xmath139 with @xmath159 . notice that @xmath187 for every @xmath188 , because otherwise @xmath94 can be expressed as a product @xmath189 with @xmath190 . over all presentations of @xmath82 as a product @xmath191 we consequently for @xmath192 choose the one with the largest number of circuit generators from @xmath193 and then with the largest number of the rest generators from @xmath180 . consider the induced presentation : @xmath194 where @xmath142 with @xmath141 . by our choice of the presentation @xmath138 we should get @xmath195 then @xmath196 where @xmath197 is the first letter of @xmath198 , and we get @xmath199 . it also follows that @xmath200 for @xmath201 , @xmath202 , and in its induced presentation @xmath203 every generator @xmath204 belongs to the set @xmath205 . in particular , the length of @xmath206 with respect to the generating set @xmath205 of the group @xmath207 is not greater than @xmath24 . further we will use this property without specifying the generating set . to the rest of this section we always assume that the group @xmath9 and the generating set @xmath10 satisfy the above assumptions . we will prove a slightly stronger formulation of lemma 1 . * lemma 1*. * _ there exists a constant @xmath149 such that for every @xmath208 for @xmath139 and every word @xmath64 of length @xmath209 either @xmath210 and in the induced presentation @xmath211 every generator @xmath212 belongs to @xmath205 , or the element @xmath83 is circuit , @xmath213 for some @xmath48 , and the induced presentations of @xmath83 and @xmath214 coincide as words in generators . _ the proof goes by induction on @xmath7 . for @xmath215 the group @xmath9 is a subgroup of the group @xmath100 of finitary elements . there exists a constant @xmath149 such that for all words @xmath66 of length @xmath158 we have @xmath99 for every @xmath46 ( actually by our assumption 1 ) on the generating set @xmath10 we can take @xmath216 ) . hence for every product @xmath208 for @xmath139 we get @xmath217 and in the induced presentation of @xmath83 every element is trivial . we assume the lemma holds for the groups @xmath218 ( with @xmath7 replaced by @xmath31 ) for @xmath219 with some common constant @xmath220 . let @xmath76 be a circuit element and @xmath185 for a letter @xmath48 . let @xmath221 , @xmath139 , be a presentation such that the induced presentation of @xmath222 coincides with @xmath223 as a word in generators . then for every word @xmath64 either @xmath224 and every generator in the induced presentation of @xmath83 belong to @xmath205 , or @xmath94 ( in the case @xmath225 ) and the induced presentation of @xmath83 coincides with @xmath223 . consider the product @xmath226 for @xmath227 , @xmath228 , and its restrictions @xmath229 for words @xmath64 of length @xmath230 . we have the following cases . if @xmath231 then @xmath232 , so further assume @xmath233 and let us look at @xmath234 . by the assumption on the length of the word @xmath66 the element @xmath234 either belongs to @xmath235 or it is circuit ( with the specific induced presentation ) . + if @xmath236 then @xmath237 for @xmath238 . + if @xmath234 is circuit and @xmath239 then @xmath240 is circuit , here @xmath241 . + if @xmath234 is circuit and @xmath242 then @xmath243 for @xmath238 . + hence in all cases the element @xmath244 for @xmath245 is either circuit , or belongs to @xmath207 , or it is of the form @xmath246 for @xmath238 . in the last case we can apply the same arguments to the product @xmath246 . after @xmath7 steps we get either a circuit state or an element of @xmath207 . in the worst case we need to take the words of length @xmath247 choose a constant @xmath248 such that @xmath249 is greater than the value of the equation above . then the element @xmath240 for words @xmath64 of length @xmath250 is either circuit or belongs to @xmath207 , and the conditions on the induced presentation of @xmath240 are satisfied . let @xmath251 be circuit elements and consider the product @xmath252 for @xmath253 . assume @xmath254 is expressed as a product in generators of length @xmath255 with the same properties as the one of @xmath82 above , and @xmath81 is expressed as a product of @xmath24 generators from @xmath205 . then the element @xmath256 for @xmath64 of length @xmath257 with @xmath258 is either circuit or belongs to @xmath207 with the specific induced presentation . now consider an arbitrary element @xmath259 for @xmath139 . let us partition the product @xmath260 on blocks @xmath261 such that every block @xmath262 contains only generators from @xmath205 ( may be trivial ) , and @xmath254 is either a generator from @xmath263 , or @xmath254 is circuit and the induced presentation of @xmath264 coincides with the presentation @xmath254 for some @xmath48 . notice that the sum of lengths of all @xmath262 and @xmath254 is equal to @xmath24 . by passing to the induced presentation of the state @xmath265 on any letter @xmath48 we can assume that every element @xmath254 is circuit . consider every product @xmath266 , @xmath267 , and so on , in the presentation ( [ eqn_lemma_g = ghgh ... ] ) . every such block restricted to a word of length @xmath268 is either circuit or belongs to @xmath207 . hence the state @xmath83 for words @xmath64 of length @xmath269 can be expressed as a product ( [ eqn_lemma_g = ghgh ... ] ) with @xmath270 positions with some circuit elements @xmath254 . applying the same procedure @xmath271 times we get either a circuit state or an element of @xmath207 . choose a constant @xmath149 such that @xmath272 ( here we use @xmath273 ) . then @xmath83 for @xmath64 of length @xmath274 is either circuit or belongs to @xmath207 , and in both cases it has the required induced presentation . the word problem in every finitely generated subgroup of @xmath98 is solvable in subexponential time . we use the same notations and assumptions as above . consider an element @xmath259 for @xmath139 . let @xmath31 be the least integer greater than @xmath275 . the element @xmath82 is trivial if and only if it acts trivially on @xmath184 and every element @xmath83 for @xmath276 is trivial . notice that the size of @xmath184 is subexponential in @xmath24 . consider the induced presentation @xmath277 with @xmath278 . if @xmath279 for all @xmath188 , then the problem reduces to the word problem in the group @xmath207 . otherwise , @xmath83 is circuit and there exists @xmath48 such that the induced presentation @xmath280 coincides with the presentation @xmath277 letter by letter , i.e. , @xmath281 for all @xmath188 . then @xmath83 is trivial if and only if it acts trivially on @xmath1 and every element @xmath282 for @xmath201 , @xmath283 , is trivial . again the problem reduces to the word problem in @xmath207 . by induction we conclude that the word problem is solvable in subexponential time with an upper bound @xmath284 for some constant @xmath220 . we are ready to prove the main result . [ theorem_growth_schreier_poly ] let @xmath9 be a finitely generated subgroup of @xmath98 . there exists a constant @xmath149 such that every orbital schreier graph @xmath27 for @xmath2 has subexponential growth not greater than @xmath285 . the proof goes by induction on @xmath7 . for @xmath215 the group @xmath286 is finite , and every schreier graph @xmath5 has at most @xmath287 vertices . we can also start the induction from @xmath288 using the fact that in this case the group @xmath289 is contracting ( see @xcite ) . we suppose by induction that the statement holds for the group @xmath207 and every schreier graph @xmath290 has subexponential growth not greater than @xmath291 with some constant @xmath220 . fix a sequence @xmath164 and consider the ball @xmath165 in the graph @xmath163 of radius @xmath24 centered at the vertex @xmath4 . if @xmath166 for @xmath167 and @xmath168 then @xmath169 . hence for every fixed @xmath31 each sequence in the ball @xmath165 is of the form @xmath170 for some @xmath171 and @xmath172 for some @xmath292 , where @xmath293 it follows that @xmath294 . let @xmath295 be the ball of radius @xmath24 in the group @xmath207 with respect to its generating set @xmath205 . let @xmath31 be the least integer greater than @xmath296 given in lemma [ lemma_weak_contr_poly ] . then for every @xmath297 there exists @xmath48 such that @xmath185 . hence @xmath298 where @xmath299 for @xmath48 . by induction hypothesis the size of the orbit @xmath300 is not greater than @xmath301 . let us estimate the size of the orbits @xmath302 . let @xmath48 be the first letter of the word @xmath66 and consider the following cases . if @xmath303 then for @xmath304 we have @xmath305 for some @xmath306 ; and for @xmath307 with @xmath201 , @xmath308 , we have @xmath309 for some @xmath306 and @xmath310 . hence we get estimates @xmath311 for @xmath201 , @xmath283 . if @xmath312 for @xmath313 then for @xmath304 we have @xmath314 for some @xmath315 and @xmath310 ; and for @xmath307 with @xmath201 , @xmath283 , we have @xmath316 for some @xmath306 and @xmath310 . hence we get estimates @xmath317 for some constant @xmath248 . as a corollary we recover the following result from ( * ? ? ? * corollary 4.6 ) . the orbital schreier graphs @xmath5 for @xmath2 of groups generated by polynomial automata are amenable . theorem [ theorem_main ] can be generalized to automaton groups with a certain combination of contracting and polynomial properties . [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] let @xmath17 be a finite automaton with subautomaton @xmath318 such that different cycles in @xmath319 are disjoint , and the group generated by @xmath318 is contracting . let @xmath9 be the automaton group generated by @xmath17 . there exists a constant @xmath149 such that every orbital schreier graph @xmath27 for @xmath2 has subexponential growth bounded above by @xmath285 , where @xmath7 is the maximal number of different cycles in @xmath319 connected by a directed path . the proof goes by induction on @xmath7 following the same strategy as in the proof of theorem [ theorem_growth_schreier_poly ] . first , we make a few assumptions about the generating sets to make our life easier . we can assume that the generating sets @xmath17 and @xmath318 are symmetric , and @xmath318 contains the nucleus @xmath93 of the contracting group @xmath320 . let @xmath180 for @xmath321 be the largest subautomaton of @xmath17 such that @xmath322 contains at most @xmath31 cycles connected by a directed path . then every @xmath180 is also symmetric and self - similar . we pass to a power of the alphabet so that every cycle in @xmath319 , and hence in @xmath323 , is actually a loop ; and for every @xmath324 and @xmath48 either @xmath325 or @xmath182 is circuit . let @xmath177 be the group generated by @xmath180 . in particular , @xmath326 and we use notation @xmath327 . the group @xmath328 is contracting with nucleus @xmath93 . indeed , by construction , there are no cycles in @xmath329 , and hence @xmath330 for all @xmath331 and all words @xmath66 of length greater than the diameter of @xmath329 . [ lemma_cycles_are_loops_generalized ] the length of cycles in the complete automaton @xmath86 of the group @xmath9 is bounded . take a circuit element @xmath76 . let @xmath94 for a nonempty word @xmath66 , and @xmath332 for every beginning @xmath106 of @xmath66 . over all presentation of @xmath82 as a product @xmath191 for @xmath139 with @xmath159 , we consequently choose the one with the largest number of circuit elements @xmath333 and then with the largest number of any elements @xmath333 , for @xmath321 . consider the induced presentation : @xmath334 where @xmath142 with @xmath141 . notice , that this presentation also satisfies the above assumptions , as is the induced presentation @xmath335 for every iteration @xmath336 of the word @xmath66 . in particular , every @xmath337 is actually circuit , because otherwise the presentation given by @xmath335 would contain more circuit generators than the chosen one . two consecutive elements @xmath337 and @xmath338 in the presentation can not both lie in @xmath93 . indeed , in this case @xmath339 for all sufficiently large @xmath106 . hence @xmath335 can be expressed as a product of less than @xmath24 generators for large enough iteration @xmath336 , contradicting @xmath159 . our choice of the presentation @xmath138 and the assumptions on the generating set @xmath10 force @xmath340 for every @xmath341 . hence @xmath342 ( here @xmath343 ) , where @xmath42 is the unique letter such that @xmath344 . if @xmath345 for @xmath346 then @xmath347 and we still get @xmath342 with @xmath348 . assume @xmath349 , and hence @xmath350 with @xmath351 . consider the induced presentations of @xmath352 for every @xmath353 . if @xmath341 then the @xmath188-th generator in the presentation of every @xmath352 remains the same and is equal to @xmath337 . let us trace the positions with elements from @xmath93 . if @xmath345 then the @xmath188-th element in the presentation of @xmath352 is equal to @xmath354 . hence these @xmath188-th elements change according to the vertices of the path in the nucleus @xmath93 that starts at the state @xmath337 and goes along arrows with left label @xmath197 . it follows that every position is pre - periodic . we can eliminate the pre - periods by passing from the presentation @xmath355 to the induced presentation @xmath356 for large enough @xmath357 , and hence we assume that every position repeats periodically . if @xmath357 is a multiple of the lengths of every cycle in @xmath93 , then the induced presentation of @xmath352 coincides with @xmath191 letter by letter , and hence @xmath356 . it follows that the length of the word @xmath66 is bounded by the least common multiple of the length of cycles in the nucleus @xmath93 . if @xmath358 then @xmath359 , @xmath360 , and we can apply the same arguments . let @xmath361 be the upper bound on the length of cycles in @xmath86 . just to notice , in general , we can not pass to a power of the alphabet to transform every cycle into a loop , i.e. , to make @xmath362 , as was possible in the case of polynomial automata . further , we will use the fact proved in lemma [ lemma_cycles_are_loops_generalized ] , that if @xmath363 for @xmath364 is circuit and @xmath94 then @xmath365 for every @xmath77 , @xmath366 , and the length of @xmath367 with respect to @xmath368 is not greater than the length of @xmath82 with respect to @xmath180 . the formulation of lemma 1 remains the same ( with @xmath369 ) . [ lemma_weak_contr_poly_generalized ] there exists a constant @xmath149 such that for every @xmath259 for @xmath139 and every word @xmath64 of length @xmath209 the element @xmath83 is either circuit , or @xmath224 . the proof is basically the same as the one of lemma 1*. let us indicate only the main argument . we assume the lemma holds for the groups @xmath218 for @xmath370 with some common constant @xmath220 . let @xmath76 be a circuit element . consider the product @xmath226 for @xmath253 and its restrictions @xmath229 for words @xmath64 of length @xmath371 . we have the following cases . if @xmath224 then @xmath232 . so further assume @xmath372 , and hence @xmath83 and @xmath82 lie on the same cycle . there exists a nonempty word @xmath106 of length @xmath373 such that @xmath374 . let us look at @xmath234 , which either belongs to @xmath235 or is circuit . if @xmath236 then @xmath375 for circuit @xmath376 and @xmath377 . otherwise @xmath234 is circuit , and let @xmath378 be the length of the cycle at @xmath234 . then the length of the word @xmath379 is a multiple of @xmath380 and of @xmath357 . if @xmath381 then @xmath382 and the state @xmath240 is circuit ; otherwise @xmath383 . hence in all cases the state @xmath384 for a word @xmath4 of length @xmath385 is either circuit , or it belongs to @xmath207 , or it is of the form @xmath386 for circuit @xmath387 and @xmath238 with @xmath388 . eventually , in the worst case , we will need to consider the product @xmath226 for circuit @xmath82 and @xmath389 . in this case we can apply the same arguments as in the proof of lemma [ lemma_cycles_are_loops_generalized ] . the rest of the proof is the same . now we can return to the growth of schreier graphs . if @xmath288 then the group @xmath9 is contracting and the statement holds . we suppose by induction that the statement holds for the group @xmath207 with some constant @xmath220 . take a sequence @xmath164 and consider the schreier graph @xmath163 . we will use the estimate . let @xmath295 be the ball of radius @xmath24 in the group @xmath207 with respect to its generating set @xmath205 . let @xmath31 be the least integer greater than @xmath296 from lemma [ lemma_weak_contr_poly_generalized ] . then for every @xmath297 there exists a nonempty word @xmath106 of length @xmath373 such that @xmath390 . hence @xmath391 where @xmath392 . by induction hypothesis the size of the orbit @xmath300 is not greater than @xmath301 . let us estimate the size of the orbits @xmath393 . if @xmath394 then for every @xmath395 we get @xmath305 for some @xmath396 . if @xmath397 for @xmath398 , @xmath399 , and @xmath400 , then for every @xmath395 we get @xmath314 for some @xmath401 and @xmath310 . summarizing all estimates we get @xmath402 for some constant @xmath248 . * omega - periodic graphs*. let @xmath403 be the binary alphabet . for every finite word @xmath404 over @xmath1 consider the automaton @xmath405 shown in figure [ fig_automatonomega ] , where we use notation @xmath406 and @xmath407 . every automaton @xmath405 is polynomial of degree @xmath408 . the automaton @xmath405 is a subautomaton of @xmath409 , and we get an increasing chain of polynomial automata @xmath410 for every @xmath42 . hence every orbital schreier graph @xmath411 for @xmath2 is a subgraph of @xmath412 . this allows us to construct the schreier graph @xmath411 consequently as @xmath413 , by looking at the action of the states @xmath414 . we start from the orbital schreier graphs @xmath415 of the automaton @xmath416 . the transformation @xmath417 is called the adding machine , because its action on a sequence @xmath418 corresponds to the addition of @xmath419 to the binary number @xmath420 . in particular , the infinite cyclic group generated by @xmath416 acts faithfully on every its orbit on @xmath0 . hence every schreier graph @xmath415 for @xmath2 is a line , i.e. , its vertices can be identified with @xmath421 via the map @xmath422 , and the edges are @xmath423 for all @xmath424 . notice that for every state @xmath425 of the automaton @xmath405 if @xmath426 , for @xmath427 , and we take the first position @xmath24 with @xmath428 , then @xmath429 and @xmath430 . it follows that each @xmath425 preserves the orbits of the action of @xmath417 on @xmath0 . hence the orbits of @xmath431 for every word @xmath66 coincide with the orbits of @xmath432 , and we can identify the vertex set of every schreier graph @xmath411 for @xmath2 with the set @xmath421 . every state @xmath425 of the automaton @xmath433 acts on the infinite sequences as follows @xmath434 for every @xmath2 and @xmath435 . notice that every sequence from @xmath0 appears in for suitable numbers @xmath436 . further , for every fixed @xmath437 , the edges defined by , when @xmath4 runs through @xmath0 , are periodic , namely , these edges are invariant under the shift @xmath438 on @xmath421 . it follows that all schreier graphs @xmath411 for @xmath2 are unions of periodic subgraphs on @xmath421 , and hence they are @xmath8-periodic in the terminology of @xcite . the schreier graph @xmath439 ( see figure [ fig_omegagraph ] ) was defined in @xcite as an example of a graph of intermediate growth ( its growth is equivalent to @xmath440 ) connected to the long range percolation on @xmath421 . all orbital schreier graphs @xmath441 for @xmath2 of the automaton @xmath442 were studied in @xcite , where it was proved that the family of these graphs contains uncountably many pairwise nonisomorphic graphs , all of them except @xmath443 are locally isomorphic , and all have intermediate growth . the groups generated by @xmath442 and @xmath444 are the same , and the automata @xmath445 are just different generating sets of this group . hence the schreier graphs @xmath446 also have intermediate growth . the schreier graphs @xmath411 for every nonempty word @xmath66 have growth not less than the growth of @xmath441 or of @xmath446 . hence their growth is superpolynomial , and then theorem [ theorem_main ] implies that all orbital schreier graphs @xmath411 for @xmath2 and @xmath447 have intermediate growth . actually , if we take the automaton shown in figure [ fig_automatonomega ] and change the labels of the edges passing from the states @xmath448 in any way we want , we still get the automaton whose all schreier graphs @xmath5 have intermediate growth . more generally , if we take any polynomial automaton @xmath17 over @xmath1 that contains @xmath449 ( with any labels at @xmath450 ) as a subautomaton , then all orbital schreier graphs @xmath451 have intermediate growth . * nonpolynomial example . * consider the automaton @xmath318 over the alphabet @xmath403 shown in figure [ fig_automnonpoly ] . the automaton @xmath318 is not polynomial , but satisfies the conditions of theorem [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] . the group @xmath452 is the infinite cyclic group , which coincides with the automaton group generated by the subautomaton of @xmath318 with states @xmath453 . the group @xmath454 is contracting with nucleus @xmath455 , while the group @xmath9 generated by @xmath318 is not contracting . theorem [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] implies that all orbital schreier graphs @xmath456 for @xmath2 have subexponential growth . to obtain a lower bound we can use the previous example . we notice that the group @xmath454 acts faithfully on every its orbit on @xmath0 . the states @xmath457 act similarly to the states @xmath458 , namely , @xmath459 and @xmath460 for @xmath2 and @xmath461 . it follows that the schreier graph @xmath441 can be seen as a subgraph of the schreier graph @xmath456 via the map @xmath462 for every @xmath2 . hence all orbital schreier graphs @xmath456 have intermediate growth . * hanoi graphs*. the hanoi tower game on @xmath31 pegs is played with @xmath24 disks of distinct size placed on @xmath31 pegs , @xmath463 . initially , all disks are placed on the first peg according to their size so that the smallest disk is at the top , and the largest disk is at the bottom . a player can move only one top disk at a time from one peg to another peg , and can never place a bigger disk over a smaller disk . the goal of the game is to transfer the disks from the first peg to another peg . more generally , one can take any two configurations of disks and ask a player to transform one configuration to another one , where a configuration is any arrangement of @xmath24 disks on @xmath31 pegs such that a bigger disk does not lie on a smaller disk . for more information about this game , its history , solutions , and open problems , we refer the reader to @xcite and the references therein . the hanoi tower game is modeled by the hanoi graphs @xmath464 . the vertices of the graph @xmath464 are the configurations of @xmath24 disks on @xmath31 pegs , and two configurations are adjacent if one can pass from one to another by a single disk move . then the hanoi tower game is equivalent to finding a path in the graph @xmath464 between two given vertices . in particular , the diameter of the hanoi graph gives an upper bound on the optimal number of steps in the hanoi tower game . it was noticed in @xcite that the game can be also modeled by a finite automaton @xmath465 over the alphabet @xmath466 , called the hanoi towers automaton on @xmath31 pegs . in this model , the pegs are identified with the letters of the alphabet @xmath1 , and the disks are labeled by @xmath467 according to their size . then the configurations of @xmath24 disks on @xmath31 pegs can be encoded by words of length @xmath24 over @xmath1 , where the word @xmath62 corresponds to the unique configuration in which the disk @xmath188 is placed on the peg @xmath197 . the automaton @xmath465 has the trivial state @xmath95 and the state @xmath468 for every transposition @xmath469 on @xmath1 with two arrows @xmath470 labeled by @xmath471 and @xmath472 , and the loop at @xmath468 labeled by @xmath473 for every @xmath474 . for example , the automaton @xmath475 is shown in figure [ fig_automhanoi ] ( the loops at the trivial state @xmath95 are not drawn ) . the action of the state @xmath468 on a word of length @xmath24 corresponds to a single disk move between the pegs @xmath188 and @xmath476 . hence the schreier graph @xmath477 is precisely the hanoi graph @xmath464 . the complexity of the hanoi tower game highly depends on whether @xmath478 or @xmath34 . in the case @xmath478 , the hanoi graph @xmath479 has diameter @xmath480 , and this is the smallest number of steps to win the game . the automaton @xmath481 is bounded and generates a contracting group . all orbital schreier graphs @xmath482 for @xmath2 have polynomial growth of degree @xmath483 . for @xmath34 , the hanoi tower game can be solved in subexponential number of moves , asymptotically in @xmath484 moves ( see @xcite ) . in particular , the diameter of the hanoi graph @xmath464 and the schreier graph @xmath477 is asymptotically @xmath484 . one can apply this asymptotic estimates to the orbital schreier graphs @xmath485 for @xmath2 . it is easy to see that the growth function @xmath129 of each graph @xmath485 satisfies @xmath486 , where @xmath487 is the diameter of the graph @xmath477 . hence the upper bound on the diameter of @xmath477 implies a superpolynomial lower bound on the growth of @xmath485 , namely @xmath488 with some constant @xmath119 . this was used in ( * ? ? ? * theorem 2.1 ) to conclude that the schreier graph @xmath489 for @xmath34 has intermediate growth between @xmath490 and @xmath491 for some constants @xmath492 . the automaton @xmath465 for @xmath34 is not polynomial , and does not satisfy the assumptions of theorem [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] . however , we can apply similar ideas to give the subexponential upper bound @xmath493 on the growth of every schreier graph @xmath485 for @xmath2 . to provide an upper bound we follow similar arguments as in the proofs on theorems [ theorem_growth_schreier_poly ] and [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] . we will show only the case @xmath494 , the general case is analogous . let @xmath32 be the automaton group generated by @xmath465 . notice that for every state @xmath56 of the automaton @xmath465 and every word @xmath64 if @xmath495 then @xmath496 and @xmath497 . it immediately follows that every cycle in the complete automaton @xmath498 of the group @xmath32 is a loop labeled by @xmath473 for some letter @xmath48 . the group @xmath499 is contracting with nucleus @xmath500 . then for every @xmath501 , @xmath502 , the restriction @xmath83 belongs to @xmath93 for all words @xmath66 of length @xmath503 . hence every schreier graph @xmath482 has subexponential ( polynomial ) growth not greater than @xmath504 and the automaton @xmath475 . for @xmath48 denote by @xmath505 the subautomaton of @xmath475 consisting of states that fix the letter @xmath13 . the group generated by @xmath505 acts on the words over @xmath506 in the same way as the group @xmath499 acts on @xmath507 , and that is where we can apply the inductive arguments . in particular , if @xmath138 for @xmath508 then for every word @xmath64 that contains at least @xmath154 letters different from @xmath13 the restriction @xmath83 belongs to @xmath475 , in other words , @xmath83 fixes one more letter except @xmath13 . take two different letters @xmath509 and consider elements @xmath221 for @xmath510 and @xmath511 for @xmath512 . take an arbitrary word @xmath64 of length @xmath513 with @xmath514 . if the word @xmath66 contains at least @xmath154 letters not equal to @xmath13 then @xmath515 . otherwise , @xmath66 contains at least @xmath154 letters equal to @xmath13 , and then @xmath516 contains at least @xmath154 letters equal to @xmath13 . since @xmath517 , we get @xmath518 . it follows that for every word of length @xmath519 there exists a letter @xmath306 such that every generator in the induced presentation of @xmath520 belongs to @xmath521 ( i.e. , @xmath240 is circuit ) . let us prove that there exists a constant @xmath248 such that for every product @xmath522 , @xmath523 , and every word @xmath64 of length @xmath524 there exists @xmath48 such that every generator @xmath212 in the induced presentation @xmath525 belongs to @xmath505 ( hence @xmath83 is circuit , here @xmath213 ) . we partition the presentation @xmath138 on blocks @xmath526 such that every @xmath527 contains only generators from @xmath528 for some letter @xmath48 ( depending on @xmath188 ) . consider the products @xmath529 , @xmath530 , , and their restrictions on words @xmath66 of length @xmath531 . using the above property we get that the element @xmath83 can be expressed as a product with @xmath532 elements @xmath254 . applying the same procedure @xmath533 times , we get an element with needed properties . the existence of the constant @xmath248 follows . consider the schreier graph @xmath534 for @xmath164 . we will use estimate with @xmath31 being the least integer greater than @xmath535 . then @xmath536 where @xmath537 consists of those elements @xmath538 that can be expressed as a product of no more than @xmath24 elements from @xmath505 . every element @xmath304 fixes every occurrence of the letter @xmath13 in the sequence @xmath539 , and changes every other letter in the same way as the group @xmath499 acts on @xmath506 . hence the orbit @xmath540 has subexponential growth not greater than @xmath541 . we get the upper bound @xmath542 for some constant @xmath149 . * weakly contracting groups . * one of the main properties used in the proof of theorems [ theorem_main ] and [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] leads us to the following definition . we say that a group @xmath9 generated by a finite automaton is _ weakly contracting _ if the length of cycles in the complete automaton @xmath86 of the group is bounded . every finitely generated contracting group is weakly contracting . the groups generated by polynomial automata , the groups from theorem [ theorem_growth_schr_general ] , and the hanoi towers groups are also weakly contracting . it is natural to ask which properties can be generalized to this class of groups . is the word problem in weakly contracting groups solvable in subexponential time ? do weakly contracting groups not contain nonabelian free subgroups ? do the orbital schreier graphs @xmath5 of weakly contracting groups have subexponential growth ?
Abstract: | [
"every automaton group naturally acts on the space @xmath0 of infinite sequences over some alphabet @xmath1 . for every @xmath2 we consider the schreier graph @xmath3 of the action of the group on the orbit of @xmath4 . we prove that for a large class of automaton groups all schreier graphs @xmath5 have subexponential growth bounded above by @xmath6 with some constant @xmath7 . in particular , this holds for all groups generated by automata with polynomial activity growth ( in terms of s. sidki ) , confirming a conjecture of v. nekrashevych . we present applications to @xmath8-periodic graphs and hanoi graphs . + * mathematics subject classification 2000 * : 20f65 , 05c25 , 20f69 . + * keywords * : automaton group , schreier graph , subexponential growth ."
] | 8,854 | 8,854 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in this paper , we present a multirate method that is suited for integrating systems of ordinary differential equations ( odes ) which arise from step models describing nanostructure evolution . the strength of our method , in comparison to other existing multirate schemes , is its order of accuracy : our method is fourth order provided solutions are sufficiently smooth . a multirate method is basically one that takes different step sizes for different components of the solution @xcite . when might such a need for different time steps arise ? one situation where multirate methods may be more efficient than single rate ones is when a few of the components contain time singularities or are _ locally stiff_. in this case , ( explicit ) single rate methods are likely to use small time steps for all the components , whereas a multirate one uses small time steps just for singular / locally stiff ones . we believe that this strategy significantly improves the efficiency of solution . integration by our multirate method occurs in two stages . we first use an `` outer '' integrator to handle the non - singular/ non - stiff components and then an `` inner '' integrator to handle the singular / stiff ones . to perform the second inner integration , a small number of components from the outer solution must be interpolated . the high order of accuracy of the multirate scheme relies on the interpolation being of a sufficiently high order . one of our key results in this paper is that for a multirate method to be @xmath0 order , the interpolation must be @xmath1 order . we demonstrate our method by using a fourth order runge - kutta method ( with error control ) for the inner and outer schemes and coupling them together with cubic interpolants . multirate schemes were first studied by gear and wells @xcite . further treatments can be found in @xcite , and the references therein . however , considering the wide variety of methods which researchers have used to improve the performance and accuracy of integration codes , it is surprising to learn that multirate schemes have received only modest attention . this is even more surprising , given that algorithms using somewhat similar concepts are well developed for the numerical solution of pdes e.g. adaptive mesh refinement ( amr ) in the field of hyperbolic pdes @xcite . the applications of multirate methods seem mostly confined to @xmath2-body problems @xcite , and equations arising from electrical networks @xcite . the work presented here is , as far as we are aware , the first instance of a multirate scheme applied to a problem in surface evolution . our method is fairly similar to the one described in @xcite , which is second order . for example : we first advance and interpolate the slow components , and then integrate the fast components this is the `` slowest first '' paradigm described in @xcite . we also automatically detect the fast components by looking at the error estimates produced using an embedded formula . the main differences are that : ( i ) our method is fourth order in time for sufficiently smooth solutions and ( ii ) our method is most effective when applied to the types of odes that commonly arise in models of step surface evolution . we will discuss ( ii ) in more detail later on in the paper , but for now we make the comment that a necessary but not sufficient condition for our method to work is that the ode system be locally coupled . the strengths of our method are that automatic step size selection is simple to implement , and that there is a lower overhead cost because we do not have to interpolate all the slow components of the solution this is one of the benefits of specializing to locally coupled systems . the outline of this paper is as follows : in section [ sec : physical_motivation ] , we discuss why step models are studied and explain the physics behind the equations . in section [ sec02:governing ] we present the step equations , and in section [ sec03:properties ] we describe features of the equations that require special attention . in section [ sec04:code ] we give the details of the numerical method and in particular , we discuss the important issue of interpolation in section [ interpolation ] . we validate our code and present our results in section [ sec05:implementation ] and summarize our findings with a conclusion in section [ sec61:discussion ] . the surface dynamics of crystal structures has received much recent attention @xcite because of its relevance to the fabrication of nano - scale electronic devices , such as quantum dots @xcite . of interest to us here is the behavior of _ vicinal _ surfaces below the roughening temperature @xmath3 . for any given material , a surface forming a small angle with a high symmetry plane of the crystal is called vicinal . the roughening temperature is the critical temperature below which steps become thermodynamically stable . thus , a microscope image of a surface below @xmath4 , with a slight miscut angle , appears as made from a series of terraces separated by steps of atomic height see figure [ fig : silicon ] for an example in silicon . as the surface evolves , the steps move and change their shape , but the steps are well defined and have a lifetime that is long enough to be directly observable . when the temperature is increased above @xmath4 , a _ kosterlitz - thouless _ phase transition occurs @xcite , and the surface becomes statistically rough as characterized by the divergence of the height height correlation function @xcite . for many physical applications ( such as epitaxy ) the operating temperatures are below @xmath3 , and this mesoscale description of a surface in terms of steps and their evolution is very useful . a step model can account for finite size effects occurring at the atomic scale , while remaining computationally simple simulations with step models can be done over much longer time periods than , for example , with atomistic models of the surfaces . the step s shape can , in general , be very complicated . thus , quantitative descriptions for how steps interact with one another can be very difficult to derive , and a complete description of an arbitrarily shaped nanostructure in terms of its steps is currently not available . as a result , theoretical studies have been restricted to simple nanostructure geometries and step shapes . the bcf model , proposed by burton , cabrera and frank @xcite in 1951 , deals with a monotonic step train consisting of an infinite number of parallel steps see figure [ fig : geombcf ] . in this model , the steps edges are separated by atomically smooth terraces , and each step position is uniquely described by a single scalar quantity @xmath5 where the index @xmath6 labels the step . using this model , burton , cabrera and frank were able to describe the evolution of a ( 1 dimensional ) stepped surface , under non - equilibrium conditions , in terms of its steps . in 1988 , rettori and villain @xcite considered a 2d array of circular mounds , and incorporated the effects of step line tension into the bcf model . the nanostructures that they studied consist of a finite number of concentric circular layers , in a `` wedding cake '' configuration see figure [ fig : wedcake ] . this step system can also be used to describe the `` healing '' of small circular pits @xcite produced by scanning tunneling microscopes . the radius of each layer @xmath7 is assumed to be a continuous function of time . physical considerations then lead to a set of locally coupled odes for the radii . similar sets of equations can be found in @xcite . there are two main competing physical processes that take place on a stepped surface , in the absence of evaporation and desorption . the first one is the diffusion of adsorbed atoms ( `` adatoms '' ) across terraces , which is characterized by a diffusivity @xmath8 . the second one is the attachment - detachment of adatoms at step edges , which is characterized by the kinetic coefficients @xmath9 and @xmath10 see figure [ fig : tranprostepsurf ] . experimental evidence @xcite suggests that , for some materials , attachment from the terrace above requires overcoming a higher activation energy barrier than attachment from the terrace below , so that @xmath11 . however , in this paper we consider only @xmath12 , and disregard this ( possible ) asymmetry in the step attachment - detachment known in the literature as an ehrlich - schwoebel ( es ) barrier @xcite . furthermore , we neglect the diffusion of adsorbed vacancies and the diffusion of adatoms along step edges @xcite . in this section , we present the ( non - dimensional ) evolution equations for a finite axisymmetric nanostructure with @xmath13 steps , relaxing in the absence of deposition and evaporation see figure [ fig : wedcake ] . derivations of these equations can be found in @xcite . every step in the structure is subject to two physical effects that drive its motion . the first is a _ step - line tension _ , arising from a gibbs - thomson mechanism @xcite . an isolated , circular step of radius @xmath14 , on top of an infinite substrate , initially devoid of adatoms , reduces its perimeter ( and hence its radius ) by emitting adatoms at a rate proportional to its curvature @xcite i.e. @xmath15 . the second effect is a _ repulsive interaction with neighboring steps _ , characterized by a potential function that is inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the steps @xcite . steps in the bulk of the structure ( with a smaller curvature ) tend to be less affected by the step - line tension compared to steps near the top . let @xmath16 @xmath17 be the positions of the steps numbered starting from the top of the nanostructure . thus @xmath18 , with @xmath19 the radius of the innermost step and @xmath20 the radius of the outermost step . define @xmath21 , @xmath22 , and @xmath23 , by : @xmath24{4.6in}{{${\displaystyle \left . \begin{array}{lclcl } \lambda_1 & = & \lambda(\rho_{1 } , \rho_{2})\/,\\ \lambda_n & = & \lambda(\rho_{n-1 } , \rho_{n } ) + \lambda(\rho_{n } , \rho_{n+1})\/ , \quad \mbox{for } \;\ ; 2 \leq n \leq n-1\/,\\ \lambda_n & = & \lambda(\rho_{n-1 } , \rho_{n})\/ , \end{array } \ ; \right\}\/$}}}\ ] ] @xmath25{4.6in}{{${\displaystyle \hspace*{0.50 in } \mbox{where } \quad \lambda(\rho_i , \rho_j ) = \frac{2\,\rho_i}{\rho_i+\rho_j}\ , \frac{1}{(\rho_i-\rho_j)^3 } + \frac{1}{\rho_j}\ , \left(\frac{\rho_i}{\rho_i^2-\rho_j^2}\right)^2\,,}\/$}}\ ] ] @xmath26 @xmath27 where @xmath28 , @xmath29 , and @xmath30 ( as well as @xmath31 below ) are non - dimensional constants . then the step - flow equations are @xmath32 the non - dimensional constants are as follows : * the parameter @xmath33 measures the strength of the step - step interactions relative to the strength of the step line tension . it is given by @xmath34 where @xmath35 is the step - step interaction coefficient @xcite , @xmath36 is the step stiffness @xcite , @xmath37 is the height of a single step , and @xmath38 is a typical value for the radii for example , it could be the initial radius of the final step in the structure . _ we note that , in many experimental situations , @xmath39_. * the parameters @xmath40 are given by @xmath41 where @xmath42 is the adatom attachment - detachment coefficient at a step , and @xmath43 is the adatom terrace diffusivity . the ratio @xmath44 where @xmath45 and @xmath46 is a typical terrace width , measures the competition between diffusion and attachment - detachment see equation ( [ eqn : sec20:deltan ] ) . * the dimensionless parameter @xmath31 is given by @xmath47 where @xmath48 is the atomic area , @xmath49 is the boltzmann constant , @xmath50 is the absolute temperature , @xmath51 is the equilibrium density of adatoms at a straight , isolated , step and @xmath52 is a typical bulk step velocity . we note that , of the physical parameters involved in the definitions of the non - dimensional constants above , some such as the terrace diffusivity @xmath43 , have been extensively tabulated @xcite , while others such as @xmath51 and @xmath52 , can be inferred from experiments @xcite . however , for the purposes of simulation , we can take @xmath53 without loss of generality , by an appropriate rescaling of the step radii and time . equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) constitute a pentadiagonal system , of the form @xmath54 where all the @xmath55 have the same functional form , with the exception of @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 , and @xmath59 which govern the behavior of the first and final two steps . notice that if @xmath60 denotes the common rate function for the bulk of the steps ( @xmath61 ) , then @xmath62 in this paper , we present a multirate method for integrating the equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) , when @xmath63 . however , we believe that the method presented here should be applicable to _ general sets _ of locally coupled odes , which are _ locally stiff _ ( see section [ local ] ) . in fact , our multirate method was designed to specifically tackle this problem . let us now turn our attention to the difficulties that arise when solving equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) numerically . the axisymmetric step - flow equations possess a number of peculiar properties which pose problems for standard integrators hence the need for a multirate algorithm . for example , the singular collapse of the innermost step and stiffness , localized to only a few of the components , are two ( different ) situations under which a standard integrator is forced to use small time steps . in these cases , a single rate method uses small time steps for all components . in contrast , a multirate method will use small time steps only when it has to , so that most of the components are integrated with a large time step . this strategy improves the efficiency of the integration . the singular collapse of the innermost step causes a loss in accuracy for most high order integrators near the point of collapse . hence , we implement a low - order simple euler routine for the innermost step and its neighbors . away from the singular step , we implement a fourth order multirate method with error control , which is able to efficiently integrate locally stiff components . equations ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) have the property that @xmath64 in a finite time . the top step always undergoes a monotonic collapse because its radius always decreases under the effect of step - line tension . as the top step shrinks , it emits adatoms , causing the radii of the second and subsequent steps to grow as these are absorbed . when the top step completely disappears , the number of layers in the structure is reduced by one . as a result of the sequential collapse of top steps , a macroscopically flat region called a facet forms and grows on the top of the structure . provided that the collapse of the top steps is tracked accurately , and the topmost @xmath65 is removed at each collapse , the growth of the facet is automatically accounted for . when the first collapse occurs , @xmath66 , @xmath67 , @xmath68 and @xmath69 replace @xmath70 , @xmath68 , @xmath71 and @xmath72 in ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) , and ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) applies when @xmath73 . a similar replacement occurs for the second and subsequent collapses . in this way , a given index tracks always the same step throughout the integration . let @xmath74 be the collapse time for @xmath19 . then it can be shown @xcite that as @xmath75 , @xmath76 for some constants @xmath77 and @xmath78 . the square root behavior in ( [ square_root ] ) comes from the fact that the leading order behavior for @xmath79 in equation ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) stems from a line tension : @xmath80 . thus the derivatives of @xmath19 are divergent at the time of collapse . since ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) is a locally coupled set of equations , we also expect @xmath81 , for @xmath82 , to be singular but for the solutions to become more regular near @xmath83 as @xmath84 becomes larger . since the accuracy of high order integrators usually relies on the solution having enough bounded derivatives , this means that standard high order solvers will lose accuracy near the time of collapse . for example , consider a method with truncation error @xmath85 for smooth solutions @xmath86 , and time step @xmath87 . let @xmath88 be a time @xmath89 steps away from @xmath83 , so that @xmath90 . then , given the square root singularity in ( [ square_root ] ) , the error near @xmath83 will be increased to @xmath91 furthermore , consider the issue of automatic time step selection in an adaptive integration code . this is usually done by estimating the local truncation error , and updating the time step size with a formula for the truncation error that assumes a smooth solution . for example , consider a runge - kutta scheme using an embedded higher order formula to estimate the local truncation error . such an algorithm updates the time step size using a formula like @xcite @xmath92 where @xmath93 is the order of the integrator . equation ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) is invalid near a time singularity , because from ( [ eq100 ] ) , the error near @xmath83 does not scale as @xmath94 . the resulting behavior is somewhat unpredictable : an adaptive integrator may take a very large number of tiny steps rendering it very inefficient or it may simply abort , stating that the specified error tolerance is not achievable . the aim of this subsection is to attempt to quantify the classes of systems for which the approach in this paper is effective . before explaining what we mean by local stiffness , we first introduce some notation . for @xmath95 , let @xmath96 be the solution of the ode system for some initial condition @xmath97 . for some integer @xmath98 , let @xmath99 be the solution with initial condition @xmath100 , where @xmath101 is the kronecker delta , and @xmath102 is small . finally , let @xmath103 and @xmath104 . we say that the @xmath105 component of the ode system is _ strongly local _ if ( i ) the system is locally coupled and ( ii ) given any @xmath106 , for all @xmath107 , there exists an integer @xmath108 independent of @xmath107 such that for @xmath109 , @xmath110 . if every component is strongly local , we say that the ode _ system _ is strongly local . therefore , a system is strongly local if a small perturbation to any one of its components remains localized in component number . now we explain local stiffness . recall that an ode is stiff when the ratio of the slowest and fastest time scales is much greater than one . the simplest example of this is a situation where the solution of interest is strongly stable , so that small perturbations decay very rapidly , relative to the principal time scale of evolution . now consider again the perturbation described in the previous paragraph . we say that the @xmath105 component of an ode system is _ locally stiff _ if ( i ) it is strongly local and ( ii ) @xmath111 rapidly in time , relative to the principal time scale of evolution . hence , the @xmath105 component of the solution is locally stiff if a perturbation to it remains localized in component number _ and _ decays rapidly in time . if every component is locally stiff , the the solution is globally stiff . once strong locality has been established in an ode system , individual solution _ components _ can be designated as either being ( locally ) stiff or non - stiff . for the rest of this paper , when we refer to `` stiff components '' of the solution , we mean that the components are locally stiff . a `` non - stiff component '' is one that evolves on a time scale comparable to the principal time scale . with this in mind , we can design multirate strategies that handle stiff and non - stiff components separately . for example , we expect to be able to integrate all non - stiff components with large time steps using explicit solvers . if the number of stiff components is relatively small , we can use the same explicit method on the stiff components also , but with much smaller time steps because of stability constraints . if on the other hand the number of stiff components is fairly large , we should resort to a fully implicit stiff solver . at this point it is worth comparing our approach with other work in the literature dealing with problems involving disparate time scales . gear and kevrikidis @xcite propose their `` projective integration '' method to deal with situations where there is a _ gap _ in the spectrum of time scales : the main evolution of a ( stable ) solution occurs slowly , with perturbations decaying much more quickly . for a linear problem , this corresponds to a situation where the eigenvalues can be separated into two groups : one set of moderate sized eigenvalues , and another set with large negative real parts . projective integration requires two ode solvers : an `` inner '' and an `` outer '' integrator . the idea is to take many small steps using the inner solver so that the fast modes are damped out , followed by a large _ projective _ step with the outer integrator . the process is then repeated . this method ( which is not multirate ) is well - suited to handling problems where many , or all , of the solution components are rapidly attracted to a slowly varying manifold . note that there is no notion of `` locality '' in this approach : the fast modes can potentially be coupled with all the slow ones . our multirate method also involves an `` inner '' and an `` outer '' integrator . as discussed above , the property of local stiffness means that a certain subset of the solution components have much stronger stability than the others . these stiff components are handled by an `` inner '' integrator while the non - stiff ones are taken care of using an `` outer '' solver . however , in contrast to the work of gear and kevrikidis , our method is more suited to systems where a small fraction of the components is stiff at any time during the integration . in fact , in terms of the ode s evolution in time , one can think of projective integration as using the inner / outer integrators in `` series '' , whereas our multirate method uses them in `` parallel '' . we will now show that @xmath112 , the radius of a bulk step , in ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) is strongly local provided @xmath113 and hence , away from the facet and the substrate , any stiffness that arises is localized . for a bulk step , the physical origin of the rapid decay comes from the nature of step interactions in equation ( [ eqn : sec20:lambda ] ) . steps strongly repel each other when they get too close together . consider a configuration where some of the steps in the bulk are tightly bunched together , and most of the other steps are widely spaced apart . in this case , a step strictly ( two steps away , at least , from the edge ) inside a bunch is strongly stable , and hence stiff , because small perturbations in its trajectory are opposed by strong interactions from the neighboring steps . on the other hand , widely spaced steps do not experience such large forces , and respond to perturbations on much slower time scales . it turns out that these `` step bunching '' configurations are quite common in practice and are produced by the natural time evolution of the system . in fact , the step bunching instability @xcite is a well - studied phenomenon in epitaxial growth , with applications in quantum dot technology @xcite and nanolithography @xcite . to analyze the decay of solutions , the direct approach would be to compute the jacobian matrix and analyze its eigenspectrum . unfortunately , while the jacobian for the system in ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) can be computed analytically by linearizing at any fixed set of radii @xmath114 , the expressions involved are very complicated , and do not give much insight as to why the equations should be stiff . instead , we present below a less rigorous calculation , which allows us to relate the degree of local stiffness to the step spacing . our approach is based on the fact that the number of equations , @xmath2 , is generally rather large , and that the solutions of interest have a step spacing that is , piecewise , nearly constant . by this we mean that the step spacing @xmath115 changes slowly with @xmath116 , except for a few places where it may change abruptly the effect of these changes is much harder to analyze , and our method of attack ignores them since it is only valid far away from these rapid transition regions . however , the results of our numerical calculations indicate that their presence does not invalidate our analysis . we begin by considering a configuration of steps which has a nearly constant step spacing , and expand the solution in the form @xmath117 + @xmath118 , where @xmath119 is a constant , @xmath120 is the ( constant ) leading order step spacing and @xmath121 . substituting this expression into the step flow equations , and ignoring the equations for the boundary steps ( corresponding to @xmath122 and @xmath123 ) , results in the following leading order equation for the perturbation @xmath124 @xmath125 where @xmath126 is the discrete laplacian : @xmath127 . to show that equation ( [ conststepspacingpert ] ) has the property of strong locality , we consider the solution to the problem with the initial condition @xmath128 , given by @xmath129 with @xmath130 . when @xmath131 , @xmath132 exponentially because the integrand in ( [ conststepspacingiv ] ) is @xmath133-periodic . hence the delta function initial condition remains localized for all @xmath107 . also , note that equation ( [ conststepspacingpert ] ) has free normal modes given by @xmath134 and @xmath135 is the wave - number . it follows that the time scales behave like the fourth power of the step spacing . hence , widely spaced steps evolve on a slow time scale whereas step bunches , which consist of sets of tightly packed steps , give rise to fast time scales and local stiffness . the goal of our method is to efficiently solve a system of locally coupled odes where only a few of the components are stiff . a standard explicit integrator would take small time steps for all components of the solution . in contrast , our multirate method takes large steps for the non - stiff components , and small steps for the stiff ones . the algorithm starts by taking an explicit , global time step , say : from @xmath136 to @xmath137 . an embedded formula is then used to obtain an estimate of the local truncation error ( lte ) for each component of the solution . in general , some of the ltes will be unacceptably large ( because the associated solution components are stiff ) , while others will have acceptable sizes . the algorithm checks if the components with acceptable ltes satisfy the preset tolerance levels . if they do not , the step size is reduced and another global time step is attempted . if they do , a second round of integration is performed to correct the components with large ltes . hence , the algorithm is as follows : * take a step from @xmath138 to @xmath139 . * let @xmath140 be the lte for the @xmath141-th component , let @xmath142 be the @xmath143 percentile of all the ltes , and let @xmath144 be the required error tolerance for @xmath84-th component . for example , if @xmath145 , then @xmath146 of the errors are larger than @xmath147 . if @xmath148 , @xmath147 is the median . * for some real number @xmath42 , flag all the components whose ltes are greater than @xmath149 ( our code uses @xmath150 ) as being possibly stiff . * check if the unflagged solution components satisfy the tolerance requirements , i.e. @xmath151 where @xmath152 is taken over all unflagged components only . * * * if they do , the step is successful . the step size is increased using the formula ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) with @xmath153 as the ratio of errors . * * perform a second integration to correct the flagged components ( see figure [ fig4 ] ) . * * increase the step size according to formula ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) . increase @xmath154 and go back to step 1 . * * * if they do not , the step is not successful . reduce the step size according to ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) with @xmath155 as the ratio of errors . * * do not increase @xmath154 and go back to step 1 . [ algorithm2 ] the second integration is basically done only for the stiff components , and it involves many small sub - steps within the interval @xmath156}\/$ ] to ensure stability . although this second round of integration takes a large number of steps , it only needs to be done for a small subset of the solution components . to perform the second integration , values for the non - stiff components at all times @xmath157 along the boundaries of any stiff set of steps are needed see figure [ fig4 ] . for example , in the case of a pentadiagonal system , the values of two non - stiff components are needed on each side of a stiff region . one way to generate dense output from the non - stiff components , between @xmath158 and @xmath159 , is through interpolation . in this paper we use cubic interpolatants which are generated by using the intermediate stage function evaluations in a runge - kutta method . in section [ interpolation ] , we give more details on the construction of these interpolants and demonstrate that cubic interpolation is consistent with a multirate method that is globally fourth order . once solution components have been flagged as requiring re - integration , the local coupling means that some of the non - stiff components may also have to be re - integrated . because ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) is a pentadiagonal system of equations , if only @xmath160 and @xmath161 are stiff components with large ltes , then all three of the components @xmath162 and @xmath161 must be re - integrated as a set , using the dense output from @xmath163 , @xmath164 , @xmath165 and @xmath166 as ` boundary conditions ' . hence , the algorithm is slightly wasteful in that although @xmath167 was deemed accurate enough , it still had to be integrated for a second time . note that our algorithm uses the lte in a different way from conventional embedded rk methods : instead of immediately scaling the time step if the smallest lte is greater than the tolerance level , we make a note of _ which _ components had the largest ltes by analyzing their distribution : it might not be efficient to retake the time step for every component , if only a few of them are inaccurate . the largest ltes ( in the sense of being larger than @xmath168 in algorithm [ algorithm2 ] ) are discarded , and then the time step scaled according to the largest of the remaining errors . hence , we get a larger time step for a majority of the solution components , and the way that this time step is adjusted throughout the course of the integration is not affected by the presence of a few either rapidly varying or stiff components . for the rest of this paper , we will call the first time stepper @xmath169 ( used to generate the ltes in the first place ) , and the second time stepper @xmath170 ( used to re - integate stiff components with large ltes ) . in general , @xmath169 and @xmath170 do not have to be the same method , or of the same order , but @xmath169 has to be able to generate estimates of the local truncation error . in our code , @xmath169 is a cash - karp runge - kutta formula @xcite and @xmath170 depends on the solution component : if the re - integration involves the innermost step ( see section [ treatment ] ) , we take @xmath170 to be a simple - euler routine which adjusts its step size by step doubling ; otherwise @xmath171 . in other words , there are two possibilities which can arise when performing the re - integration with @xmath170 : 1 . the re - integration involves solution components which include the innermost step . in the following analysis , we will assume this is @xmath70 . [ case1 ] 2 . the re - integration does not involve the innermost step . [ case2 ] the reason to distinguish between these two cases is that ( [ case1 ] ) will involve integration of singular trajectories ( see equation ( [ square_root ] ) ) , but in general , ( [ case2 ] ) will not . using step doubling in ( [ case1 ] ) is a fairly crude way of adjusting the time step . however , resorting to an embedded formula is not possible when ( [ stepsizecontrol ] ) breaks down , so using step doubling to monitor the quality of the solution is reasonable in this case . from equation ( [ square_root ] ) , we have seen that @xmath172 in a singular fashion , causing problems for standard high order integrators . our treatment uses a simple euler method whenever the re - integration of @xmath70 and neighboring singular components is involved : this is `` optimal '' in the sense that simple euler produces results that have the same accuracy as higher order methods ( due to the singular nature of @xmath70 ) but is computationally cheaper . furthermore , we are able to extract the time of collapse , @xmath173 , using linear interpolation , which is consistent with simple euler s order of accuracy . our method involves solving for @xmath174 instead of @xmath175 . note that from ( [ square_root ] ) , @xmath176 as @xmath75 ( the collapse time ) for some constants @xmath177 and @xmath178 , which means that @xmath179 has exactly one derivative at @xmath83 . our main reason for solving for @xmath179 , instead of @xmath70 , is not to improve accuracy , but rather to enable the algorithm to ` step through ' the singularity at @xmath180 , and use linear interpolation to obtain @xmath83 , the time of collapse of the innermost step . taking square roots to recover @xmath70 will will result in a drastic loss in accuracy near @xmath83 . at time @xmath107 close to @xmath83 , consider taking a time step of size @xmath181 with component @xmath179 using simple euler . let @xmath182 be the result of taking this time step using a ` perfect ' integrator , producing the exact solution at @xmath183 , given @xmath184 . then , since the truncation error in simple euler is @xmath185 from ( [ rho_sq ] ) , we have @xmath186 therefore , if @xmath187 ( @xmath107 sufficiently far away from the singularity ) then the lte for @xmath70 , @xmath188 , is @xmath189 . however , if @xmath190 ( @xmath107 is very close to @xmath173 ) , then the lte for @xmath70 is @xmath191 , which is not a big improvement over ( [ eq100 ] ) . note that these estimates for the lte are independent of the order of @xmath170 . when @xmath170 has ` overstepped ' @xmath83 resulting in @xmath192 and @xmath193 for times @xmath194 ( @xmath195 ) , we set @xmath196 as an approximation to the collapse time . once @xmath70 has collapsed at @xmath83 , it is removed from the system ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrho1 ] ) ( [ eqn : sec20:eqnrhon ] ) , the number of equations drops by one , and @xmath197 replaces @xmath184 as the new top step . the key to making our multirate method high order lies in the ability to generate dense output from the non - stiff components with high accuracy . one way to generate dense output is to use interpolation and @xmath139 , the function that we derive does not actually pass through @xmath139 . hence strictly speaking , it is not an interpolant , though we will continue to refer to these approximating functions as `` interpolants '' for convenience . ] . for some integrators , such as backward differentiation formulae ( bdf ) , is it obvious how to derive an interpolant that is consistent in order with the underlying integrator bdf use extrapolation to advance the solution in time . for other integrators , such as runge - kutta schemes , constructing the interpolant is less obvious and this is the focus of the section . note that we need to generate interpolants _ during run time _ using only the function evaluations that have already been computed by the integrator within each time step . the extra constraint of generating the interpolants during run time adds a non - trivial complication to the `` traditional '' interpolation problem , which has been studied extensively @xcite . having successfully integrated the non - stiff components from @xmath138 to @xmath139 , we have the point values @xmath198 and the derivative @xmath199 at our disposal to construct the interpolant between @xmath138 and @xmath139 . we do _ not _ have information about the derivative @xmath200 . however , because we are constructing these interpolants during run time , we are at liberty to use the intermediate function evalulations inherent in the application of runge - kutta : this is valuable information that is not usually available in the traditional interpolation problem . we have seen that our method performs integration in two phases : first we integrate a large number of non - stiff components , then we integrate a small number of stiff ones . ideally , we would like the two integrations to have the same order . this is only possible if the interpolation of the non - stiff components is of a sufficiently high order otherwise large interpolation errors will contaminate the accuracy in the stiff components . in the following paragraphs , when we generate dense output between points @xmath107 and @xmath183 , we define an interpolant to be order @xmath201 when the interpolation error is @xmath202 . let us assume that our inner and outer solvers are both @xmath0 order . first of all , let us calculate @xmath201 in terms of @xmath154 if we want our method to be globally @xmath0 order . for simplicity , we assume in this calculation that the effects of round - off error are negligible . consider the ode system @xmath203 let us assume that we have taken a macro step of size @xmath181 and advanced the non - stiff components @xmath204 successfully from time @xmath107 to @xmath183 . also assume that we have taken @xmath2 micro steps of size @xmath205 , @xmath95 , for the stiff components @xmath206 so that @xmath207 . after taking these @xmath2 steps , the total error in @xmath206 will be @xmath208 the first term is the sum of the local truncation errors caused by taking @xmath2 steps each of size @xmath205 . the second term is the sum of the interpolation errors : note that to advance @xmath209 , an evaluation of @xmath210 in between @xmath107 and @xmath183 , in general , is required for the non - stiff neighbours of @xmath209 and this incurs an interpolation error of size @xmath202 . therefore the error in @xmath211 is also @xmath202 and the error in @xmath209 is @xmath212 . it is clear that ( [ toterr ] ) simplifies to @xmath213 and so for our multirate method to be globally @xmath0 order , we require @xmath214 that is , we can afford for the order of the interpolation to be one less than the order of the integrator . for example , if our integrator is fourth order ( @xmath215 ) , we need to be able to construct cubic interpolants during run time . if our integrator is second order , then linear interpolation should be sufficient as observed in @xcite . we will now illustrate how these interpolants are constructed by taking the classical 4th order ( non - adaptive ) runge - kutta formula as an example and applying it to the autonomous ode system @xmath216 : .coefficients in classical rk4 [ cols= " < , < , < , < , < " , ] we used our multirate code to solve the simple wave equation @xmath217 . by discretizing using the method of lines and one - sided ( `` upwind '' ) differences in space , we obtained @xmath2 coupled ordinary differential equations which were solved using the initial condition @xmath218 and periodic boundary conditions . unlike the axisymmetric step equations , this discretization of the wave equation does not have any time singularities and we expect fourth order convergence for every component . this is confirmed in figure [ fig : convergence ] . although @xmath181 and @xmath219 constantly change because our algorithm uses adaptive step size control , we take @xmath220 as a measure of the average step size where @xmath221 is the final integration time . for the single rate method , @xmath2 is the number of steps and for the multirate method , @xmath2 is the total number of micro - steps . in the multirate code , a maximum macro - stepsize @xmath222 was imposed , and all but the first and final macro - steps had size 1 . the exact solution comes from solving the linear system of odes exactly using an eigenfunction expansion . as the integration progresses , the fraction of components that has to be reintegrated increases gradually as the solution broadens and its amplitude decreases : see figure [ fig : wave ] . a matlab multirate code that produces the results in figure [ fig : wave ] is given in the appendix . figure [ fig5](a ) shows the results of an integration with @xmath223 . note that only those steps which are near the facet tend to pack closely together , but steps which are far away move relatively slowly and do not deviate significantly from their initial uniform configuration . this expanding front of closely packed steps represents the @xmath224 expansion of the facet radius @xcite . figure [ fig5](b ) illustrates the separation in time scales of the solution components and shows which components of the solution are integrated for a second time . as expected , our algorithm takes large time steps for components which are far away from the facet . near the facet and the collapsing top step , many relatively small steps are taken . for the rapidly varying components in this figure , only a representative sample of the meshpoints @xmath138 from the @xmath170 integration are shown . in contrast , when @xmath225 , steps can be closely packed even away from the facet . the plots in figure [ fig6 ] show that a step bunching instability arises when @xmath226 is sufficiently small and are qualitatively very different to those in figure [ fig5 ] . the instability originates from steps with smaller radii and gradually spreads outwards so that more and more steps bunch up . our multirate scheme performs a second integration when bunching and local stiffness arise : therefore , our algorithm gradually becomes less efficient over time . however , as long as the fraction of bunched steps is not too large , our algorithm remains competitive compared to a standard adaptive 4th/5th order runge - kutta code . when the fraction of bunched steps becomes close to unity , the optimal strategy is to have the algorithm detect this automatically , and then switch to a fully implicit , single - rate stiff solver . we leave this as future work , noting that inversion of the pentadiagonal jacobian only costs @xmath227 operations ( where @xmath2 is the total number of existing steps ) . in this paper , we present a multirate integration scheme that is designed to efficiently solve the systems of odes that arise in the relaxation of crystal mounds . these odes have two properties that call for a multirate strategy : the singular collapse of the innermost step and local stiffness . our method automatically detects singular / stiff components in the solution and disregards them when computing the size of the bulk ( macro ) time step . the result is that the bulk timestep can be much larger than in a single rate method . the trade - off is a re - integration of the stiff components which usually consists of a small fraction of the total number of equations in the ode system . our method is globally fourth order when applied to odes which have sufficiently smooth solutions for example , the step equations studied in @xcite and the wave equation discretized through the method of lines in section [ subsec : error - spread ] . however , the time singularities present in the axisymmetric step - flow equations mean that near times of collapse , the integration of steps near the facet suffers a loss in accuracy . to specifically deal with the singular inner trajectories , our method couples a simple euler routine to the bulk solver . given that the truncation error reduces to @xmath228 near the collapse time , independent of the method order , simple euler is the preferred method because it is computationally cheaper . furthermore , the use of linear interpolation to extract collapse times is consistent with the method s order . the high order accuracy of our algorithm ( when applied to bulk steps ) relies on the ability to generate high order interpolants during the run - time of a one - step integration method . our algorithm generates these interpolants by using the intermediate stage function evaluations of an embedded runge - kutta ( rk ) formula . specifically , our method computes @xmath229 order interpolants that are consistent with the @xmath230 order accuracy of the integrator . however , for general @xmath0 order rk formulae , we do not know if it is always possible to construct interpolants that have order @xmath231 . we see four main possible extensions to this work . the first is to generalize our multirate paradigm so that it can be used for ( i ) higher order runge - kutta formulae and ( ii ) multistep methods ( e.g. bdf , adams etc . ) we believe that it should be possible to make _ any _ method multirate the main obstacle in doing this is to derive interpolants of a suitably high order . the second is to explore in more detail the types of pdes that our multirate method can apply to . typically , large systems of odes result from discretizations of pdes and it is for large ode systems that our method becomes competitive with single rate methods . we think that a basic requirement of the discretization is that it should be strongly local . however , we have not fully explored which discretizations are strongly local and which are not . for example , a one - sided , upwind discretization @xmath232 of the advection equation @xmath233 is strongly local only when @xmath234 . for @xmath235 , a kronecker delta initial condition is unstable and does _ not _ remain localized . a discretization using centered differences @xmath236 yields a system of odes that is never strongly local for any @xmath237 . for nonlinear equations , our method seems to be efficient for step - flow like odes with repulsive dipolar step - step interactions . we were able to show that the linearized step flow odes are strongly local ; however , we do not know if linearizing an ode system is always sufficient to show strong locality . the third is to explore how the choice of parameters @xmath238 and @xmath239 in algorithm [ algorithm2 ] affect the efficiency of the integration and if there are optimal values of @xmath238 and @xmath239 . a `` good '' choice for @xmath238 and @xmath239 will result in small number of re - integrated components and a large macro - time step . if @xmath238 is too large and @xmath239 too small , the algorithm behaves like a single rate method . on the other hand , if @xmath238 is too small and @xmath239 is too large , many non - stiff components will be re - integrated along with the stiff ones , rendering the method inefficient . furthermore , our choice of @xmath147 as the @xmath143 percentile of the ltes is somewhat arbitrary ( but seems to generate reasonable results ) . another possibility is to take the mean this amounts to increasing the sensitivity of the bulk step size to the presence of one or two extremely stiff components . clearly , the performance of our multirate method is tied to the distribution of ltes , its moments , and identification of the `` largest errors '' . quantification of the `` largest errors '' and deciding which moments to use is work in progress . in summary , this work contributes to the currently growing body of research in multirate methods . we hope that the strategies adopted in this paper can be carried over to other physical problems and used to improve the efficiency and accuracy of future multirate algorithms . * acknowledgements * + we thank dionisios margetis for many helpful discussions and meetings . rrr was partially supported by nsf grant dms-0813648 . here we give the details of a matlab multirate code to solve a wave equation . % parameters for integrator desired_error = 1e-6 ; % desired error per step mr = 1 ; % set mr=1 for multirate mode , mr=0 for single rate t= 20 ; t = 0 ; dt = 0.1 ; dt_max = 1.0 ; k = -3 ; p = 30 ; % approx percentage of components to reintegrate safety = 0.95 ; while t < t [ unew , error , k ] = rk_onestep(t , u , dt,[1 n ] ) ; % % % % % start of multirate modification % % % if mr = = 1 % flag large errors flags = error > 10^k*percentile(error , p ) ; for i=1:length(flags ) if flags(i ) = = 1 r = i ; break ; end end for j = length(flags):-1:1 if flags(j ) = = 1 s = j ; break ; end end % just to be safe r = r - w ; s = s+w ; [ unew , num_micro_steps ] = micro_integrate(t , t+dt , u , unew , ... [ r s],k , desired_error*1e-3 ) ; end % % % end of multirate modification % % % max_error = max ( max(error(1:r-1 ) ) , max(error(s+1:end ) ) ) ; r = ( desired_error / max_error ) ^(1/5 ) ; if r<1 % step failed dt = dt*safety*max(0.1,r ) ; trynum = trynum+1 ; if trynum>10 sprintf('10 failed attempts ! ' ) return end elseif r>1 % step succeeded [ r s ( s - r ) ( s - r)/n ] t = t+dt ; u = unew ; trynum = 0 ; numsteps = numsteps+1 ; dt = dt*safety*min(5,r ) ; if t+dt > t dt = ( t - t ) ; end if dt > dt_max dt = dt_max ; end end if t > t1 & & plot_number = = 1 subplot(4,2,1 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t1 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,3 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) ; plot_number = 2 ; elseif t > t2 & & plot_number = = 2 subplot(4,2,2 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t2 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,4 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) ; plot_number=3 ; elseif t > t3 & & plot_number = = 3 subplot(4,2,5 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t3 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,7 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) ; plot_number=4 ; elseif t > t4 & & plot_number = = 4 subplot(4,2,6 ) plot(x , unew,'linewidth',2 ) ; xlabel('x ' ) ; ylabel('u(x , t ) ' ) ; tit = sprintf('t=%f',t4 ) ; title(tit ) ; axis([-l/2 l/2 0 1 ] ) ; subplot(4,2,8 ) spy(flags,20 ) title('flagged components ' ) end end y_current = y1 ; t = t1 ; trynum = 0 ; numsteps = 0 ; while t < t2 [ y_new , error ] = rk_onestep(t , y_current , dt,[r-2,s+2 ] ) ; r = ( desired_error / max(error(r : s ) ) ) ^(1/5 ) ; if r<1 % step failed dt = dt*max(0.1,r ) ; trynum = trynum+1 ; if trynum>10 sprintf('10 failed attempts ! ' ) return end elseif r>1 % step succeeded t = t+dt ; numsteps = numsteps+1 ; trynum = 0 ; y_new(r-2 ) = interpolate(t , y1(r-2),y2(r-2),t1,t2,k(r-2 , : ) ) ; y_new(r-1 ) = interpolate(t , y1(r-1),y2(r-1),t1,t2,k(r-1 , : ) ) ; y_new(s+1 ) = interpolate(t , y1(s+1),y2(s+1),t1,t2,k(s+1 , : ) ) ; y_new(s+2 ) = interpolate(t , y1(s+2),y2(s+2),t1,t2,k(s+2 , : ) ) ; y_current = y_new ; dt = dt*min(5,r ) ; if t+dt > t2 dt = ( t2-t ) ; end end end y2 = y_current ; a2 = 1/5 ; a3 = 3/10 ; a4 = 3/5 ; a5 = 1 ; a6 = 7/8 ; b21 = 1/5 ; b31 = 3/40 ; b32 = 9/40 ; b41 = 3/10 ; b42 = -9/10 ; b43 = 6/5 ; b51 = -11/54 ; b52 = 5/2 ; b53 = -70/27 ; b54 = 35/27 ; b61 = 1631/55296 ; b62 = 175/512 ; b63 = 575/13824 ; b64 = 44275/110592 ; b65 = 253/4096 ; k1 = dt*f(t , y , cpt ) ; k2 = dt*f(t+a2*dt , y+b21*k1,cpt ) ; k3 = dt*f(t+a3*dt , y+b31*k1+b32*k2,cpt ) ; k4 = dt*f(t+a4*dt , y+b41*k1+b42*k2+b43*k3,cpt ) ; k5 = dt*f(t+a5*dt , y+b51*k1+b52*k2+b53*k3+b54*k4,cpt ) ; k6 = dt*f(t+a6*dt , y+b61*k1+b62*k2+b63*k3+b64*k4+b65*k5,cpt ) ; k = [ k1 ' k2 ' k3 ' k4 ' k5 ' k6 ' ] ; m. kitamura , m. nishioka , j. oshinowo , y. arakawa , in - situ fabrication of self - aligned ingaas quantum dots on gaas multiatomic steps by metalorganic chemical vapor deposition , appl . 66 ( 26 ) ( 1995 ) 36633665 . j. g. mclean , b. krishnamachari , d. r. peale , e. chason , j. p. sethna , b. h. cooper , decay of isolated features driven by the gibbs - thomson effect in an analytic model and a simulation , phys . rev . b 55 ( 3 ) ( 1997 ) 1811 1823 . a. ichimiya , y. tanaka , k. ishiyama , quantitative measurements of thermal relaxation of isolated silicon hillocks and craters on the si(111)-(7x7 ) surface by scanning tunneling microscopy , phys . 76 ( 25 ) ( 1996 ) 4721 4724 .
Abstract: | [
"we present a multirate method that is particularly suited for integrating the systems of ordinary differential equations ( odes ) that arise in step models of surface evolution . the surface of a crystal lattice , that is slightly miscut from a plane of symmetry , consists of a series of terraces separated by steps . under the assumption of axisymmetry , the step radii satisfy a system of odes that reflects the steps response to step line tension and step - step interactions . two main problems arise in the numerical solution of these equations . first , the trajectory of the innermost step can become singular , resulting in a divergent step velocity . second , when a step bunching instability arises , the motion of steps within a bunch becomes very strongly stable , resulting in `` local stiffness '' . the multirate method introduced in this paper ensures that small time steps are taken for singular and locally stiff components , while larger time steps are taken for the remaining ones . special consideration is given to the construction of high order interpolants during run time which ensures fourth order accuracy of scheme for components of the solution sufficiently far away from singular trajectories . multirate , runge kutta , interpolation , stiffness , step equations 65l05 , 65l06 , 82d25"
] | 9,806 | 9,806 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: in the field of coding theory , calculations of good upper and lower bounds on the size of a code serves as a benchmark for code design . techniques of constructing subspace codes for error correction in random network coding ( also called ` projective space codes ' ) are similar to the techniques used to construct binary codes . a projective space code is defined as a subset of subspaces of a vector space . the viewpoint of lattice theory for projective space codes has already been suggested @xcite . a lattice is a partially ordered set in which any two elements have a least upper bound and a greatest lower bound . the set of all subspaces of a vector space is called a projective space and the set of all subsets of a set is called a power set . both the power set and the projective space form lattices under inclusion order . a ` lattice scheme ' is defined as a subset of a lattice . it has already been observed in @xcite that binary codes and projective space codes are lattice schemes . binary codes are power set schemes and projective space codes are projective space schemes . the lattice framework common to projective space codes and binary codes have also been observed in @xcite and @xcite . the authors of @xcite establish that the projective space codes are analogs of classical binary codes . they also investigate the notions of linearity and complements of a code . in @xcite , the relationship between binary codes and projective space codes is investigated thoroughly using the framework of lattices and a generalized notion of orthogonal complement is introduced for lattices . one of the ways to generate a bound on the code size is to capture a bare minimum structure for the bound through an appropriate mathematical abstraction and generalize the approach . for example , the introduction of ` association schemes ' captured the notion of sphere packing and sphere covering arguments in traditional coding theory @xcite and strengthened the bounds by a linear programming approach . in our paper , the notion of singleton bound is generalized using the framework of lattices . since error correcting codes for random network coding was proposed in @xcite , there has been a lot of activity in the theory of projective space codes . the authors of @xcite consider projective space codes in which all the subspaces are of the same dimension . such codes are called constant dimension codes . the koetter - kschischang singleton bound ( kks bound ) for constant dimension codes was derived and achieved asymptotically in @xcite . in the case of binary codes , hamming distance between two binary vectors is a metric on the binary coding space . similarly the subspace distance , introduced in @xcite , between two subspaces of a vector space is a metric on the projective space . in a projective space , the number of elements in a sphere of a particular radius depends on the center of that sphere @xcite . however , in the case of binary codes , the number of elements in a sphere depends only on the radius of the sphere and not on the center of the sphere . so the subspace distance on the projective space behaves differently from the hamming distance on the usual binary vectors . as noted in @xcite , the anticode bound introduced in @xcite gives a setting in which one can get tighter sphere packing bounds for constant dimension codes . a close look at the bounds for subspace distance and non - existence of nontrivial perfect codes has been given in @xcite . an appropriate generalization for singleton bounds ( analogous to association scheme for sphere packing / covering bounds ) is not known yet . in this paper , we propose that the lattice framework is appropriate for generalizing singleton bounds . we derive an upper bound on the size of a lattice scheme , which will be called lattice singleton bound ( lsb ) for the remainder of the paper . we get the kks bound and the classical singleton bound as special cases of the lsb . while most results in projective space codes assume that the dimensions of the subspaces in the code are constant , a few papers in literature have considered codes with non - constant dimension . in particular , the authors of @xcite derive a gilbert - varshamov type bound , which we will term as ` etzion vardy- gilbert varshamov bound ' ( ev - gvb ) , for non - constant dimension codes . we derive a _ new _ upper bound on the code size for non - constant dimension codes by applying the lsb to the projective lattice . to the best of our knowledge , our singleton bound is the first upper bound for non - constant dimension codes . the construction of constant dimension codes have been the main focus in the field of code constructions for projective spaces . the first constant dimension subspace codes introduced in @xcite achieve the kks bound asymptotically . and there is no known code constructions that exactly achieve the singleton bound proposed in @xcite . the question of achieving that singleton bound is an open question . a large class of constant and non - constant dimension codes using ferrer s diagrams and lifted rank metric codes are constructed in @xcite . the authors of @xcite report marginal improvements over the size of the code compared to the codes of @xcite . a plot of code sizes of the codes reported in @xcite compared to a plot of our upper bound shows that both the reported codes have code sizes that are close to optimal . this also establishes that our upper bound is tight for atleast certain coding parameters . the contributions of this paper are as follows : 1 . we derive a singleton bound in the framework of lattices . we recover the singleton bound for binary codes and the singleton bound for constant dimension subspace codes ( kks bound ) as special cases of our lsb . we obtain a new singleton bound for non - constant dimension subspace codes . we compare our bound on the code size with the code sizes of non - constant dimension codes found in the literature . we also compare our upper bound with a gilbert - varshamov type lower bound . the plots reveal that our bound is tight for certain parameters of the code . the paper is organized as follows : we introduce the preliminaries of lattices in section [ sec_lat_prelims ] . section [ sec_lat_sch ] introduces the idea of lattice schemes where it is shown that classical codes and subspace codes are both lattice schemes . section [ sec_main_res ] introduces the singleton bound in the framework of lattice schemes and contains the main theorem of this paper . section [ sec_main_res ] contains the main distinguishing feature of projective space codes which we believe make singleton type bounds weak in projective spaces . in section [ sec_upp_bou ] , we obtain a new upper bound for non - constant dimension codes and plot our upper bound with ev - gvb along with different codes constructed in the literature . finally , in section [ sec_conc ] , we conclude by summarizing our contributions and discussing the scope for future work . _ notations : _ a set is denoted by a capital letter and its elements will be denoted by small letters ( for example , @xmath0 ) . the set @xmath1 is defined as @xmath2 . all the sets considered in this paper will be finite . given a set @xmath3 , @xmath4 denotes the number of elements in the set and for a subset @xmath5 of @xmath3 , @xmath6 denotes the complement of the set @xmath5 in @xmath3 . for two sets @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath8 denotes the cartesian product of the two sets , i.e. @xmath9 . @xmath10 represents the symmetric difference of sets , i.e. @xmath11 . a lattice will be denoted by @xmath12 and sometimes we will drop the join and the meet notation , simply calling it @xmath13 . @xmath14 denotes the finite field with @xmath15 elements where @xmath15 is a power of a prime number . @xmath16 denotes all the non zero elements of @xmath14 . the symbol @xmath17 denotes a vector space ( generally over @xmath14 ) . for a subset @xmath18 of @xmath17 , @xmath19 denotes the linear span of all the elements in @xmath18 . given two subspaces @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath20 denotes the smallest subspace containing both @xmath5 and @xmath7 . let @xmath17 be a @xmath21 dimensional space over @xmath14 . then the symbol @xmath22 denotes the grassmanian , i.e. the set of all @xmath23 dimensional subspaces of @xmath17 . the number of elements in @xmath22 is denoted as @xmath24 . @xmath25 denotes the @xmath21 dimensional vector space of @xmath21-tuples over @xmath14 . given a vector @xmath26 , @xmath27 denotes the @xmath28-th co - ordinate of @xmath29 . the support of @xmath26 ( denoted by @xmath30 ) is defined as the set of indices where the vector is non - zero . @xmath31 denotes the vector space @xmath25 with the hamming metric , i.e. @xmath32 . this section serves as a quick introduction to lattice theory . all the lattice theory definitions and theorems required for the rest of the paper are given in this section . we follow notations and definitions from @xcite . [ def_poset_order ] a _ poset _ is a pair @xmath33 , where @xmath34 is a set and @xmath35 is a binary relation ( called the _ order relation _ ) on the set @xmath34 satisfying : 1 . ( reflexivity ) for all @xmath36 2 . ( antisymmetry ) if @xmath37 , then @xmath38 3 . ( transitivity ) if @xmath39 , then @xmath40 for the remainder of the paper , @xmath34 denotes a poset with @xmath35 as the order relation . if @xmath41 and @xmath42 , then we use the shorthand @xmath43 . @xmath41 is read as `` x is less than y '' or `` x is contained in y '' . an _ upper bound _ ( _ lower bound _ ) of a subset @xmath3 of @xmath34 is an element @xmath44 containing ( contained in ) every @xmath45 . the _ least upper bound _ ( _ greatest lower bound _ ) of @xmath3 is the element of @xmath34 contained in ( containing ) every upper bound ( lower bound ) of @xmath3 . if a least upper bound , or a greatest lower bound of a set exists , it is unique due to the antisymmetry property of the order relation ( definition [ def_poset_order ] ) . the least upper bound of a set @xmath3 is denoted by sup @xmath3 and the greatest lower bound is denoted by inf @xmath3 . a _ lattice _ @xmath13 is a poset which has the property that @xmath46 , the sup@xmath47 exists and inf@xmath47 exists . the sup@xmath47 is denoted by @xmath48 ( read as `` a _ join _ b '' ) and the inf@xmath47 is denoted by @xmath49 ( read as `` a _ meet _ b '' ) . the lattice itself is denoted by @xmath12 . we will assume , for the purposes of the paper , that all the lattices are finite and have a unique greatest element denoted by @xmath50 , and a unique least element denoted by @xmath51 . a _ sublattice _ of a lattice @xmath13 is a subset @xmath52 of @xmath13 that satisfies the following condition : @xmath53 a map @xmath54 from @xmath13 to @xmath52 is said to be a _ lattice homomorphism _ if it satisfies the following conditions : 1 . @xmath55 2 . @xmath56 further , if @xmath54 is bijective , then we say that @xmath13 and @xmath52 are _ let @xmath57 and @xmath58 denote the power set of @xmath3 . we can view @xmath59 as a poset where set inclusion is the order relation . the power set under this order is a lattice . for any subsets @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath60 and @xmath61 . further , the lattice generated by subsets of @xmath62 is a sublattice . notice that @xmath63 and @xmath64 . @xmath65 one can completely specify an order of a poset ( finite ones ) by a _ hasse diagram _ , like the one shown in fig . [ fig_power_set ] . if @xmath66 and there is no @xmath67 such that @xmath68 , we say that `` @xmath69 _ covers _ @xmath70 '' . in the hasse diagram of a lattice , @xmath70 and @xmath69 are joined iff @xmath69 covers @xmath70 or @xmath70 covers @xmath69 . the diagram is drawn in such a way that if @xmath69 covers @xmath70 , then @xmath69 is written above @xmath70 . clearly , @xmath66 iff there exists a path from @xmath70 moving up to @xmath69 . the order relation is completely specified by such a diagram . naturally , @xmath50 will be the topmost element and @xmath51 will be the lowest element . ): a lattice of subsets ] for a set @xmath3 , @xmath71__pow(@xmath3)__@xmath72 will denote lattice of the power set of @xmath3 with union and intersection as join and meet of the lattice respectively . a lattice @xmath12 is _ distributive _ if the following conditions hold : 1 . for all @xmath73 2 . for all @xmath74 it is immediate that for any set @xmath3 , @xmath71__pow__(@xmath3)@xmath72 is a distributive lattice . however all lattices are not distributive , as seen in the examples below . let @xmath17 be a vector space of dimension @xmath21 over a field @xmath75 . the class of all the subspaces of @xmath17 , denoted by @xmath76 , can be ordered under inclusion in a manner similar to a set . the join of two subspaces @xmath5 and @xmath7 will then be the smallest subspace containing both @xmath5 and @xmath7 . this means that @xmath77 and the largest subspace contained in both @xmath5 and @xmath7 is @xmath78 . so the meet of @xmath5 and @xmath7 is @xmath78 . such a lattice will be denoted as @xmath79 . clearly @xmath80 and @xmath81 . this lattice will be called the _ projective lattice_. this lattice is not distributive . to see this , we consider the vector space @xmath82 over @xmath83 . the hasse diagram of @xmath84 is shown in fig . [ fig_subspace ] . here , @xmath85 , @xmath86 and @xmath87 . clearly , @xmath88 and thus @xmath84 is not distributive . @xmath84 is identified by the name _ m@xmath89_. @xmath65 : a lattice of subspaces , also called @xmath90 the above lattice is not distributive , i.e. @xmath91 fails for three distinct subspaces @xmath92 . if @xmath93 , one can prove that @xmath94 and thus it behaves partly distributively . this property is captured in the following definition : a lattice @xmath12 is _ modular _ if the following condition holds : + ( modularity ) if @xmath95 , then @xmath96 if the lattice is distributive , the modularity condition holds . this means that _ any distributive lattice is modular_. however @xmath79 is a modular lattice that is non distributive . the observation that for @xmath71__pow(@xmath3)__@xmath72 , any two elements @xmath97 satisfy @xmath98 , and in an analogous fashion , for @xmath79 , any two elements @xmath97 satisfy @xmath99 , seems to suggest that modular lattices must satisfy an equation of the form @xmath100 for some real - valued function @xmath101 on the lattice . this is indeed true and in turn , such a function helps characterise modular lattices . we need the following few definitions and results to make the characterisation precise . an _ isotone valuation _ on a lattice @xmath13 is a real valued function @xmath101 on @xmath13 that satisfies : 1 . ( valuation ) for all @xmath102 , @xmath103 2 . ( isotone ) @xmath104 additionally , the isotone valuation is called _ positive _ , if @xmath105 . @xmath106 is said to be the distance induced by @xmath101 . * pg.230 , th.1 ) [ thm_pseudo_metric ] given a lattice @xmath13 and an isotone valuation @xmath101 , the function @xmath107 is a metric iff @xmath101 is positive . in general , @xmath108 is a pseudo metric . in a lattice @xmath12 , a _ chain _ @xmath109 is a subset of @xmath13 with the property that for all @xmath110 , @xmath66 or @xmath111 . we say that in a chain , any two elements are comparable . given two elements @xmath112 , a chain @xmath113 of @xmath13 with the property @xmath114 is called a _ chain between @xmath70 and @xmath69_. the _ length _ of the chain is defined as @xmath23 . the _ height _ of an element @xmath29 in a lattice @xmath13 is the maximum length of a chain between @xmath51 and @xmath29 . it is denoted by @xmath115 . the number @xmath116 is called _ the height of the lattice _ @xmath13 or the _ dimension of _ @xmath13 . note that the chain from @xmath51 to @xmath51 contains only one element , and thus @xmath117 . we need an additional property to characterise modular lattices . a lattice is said to have the _ jordan - dedekind property _ if all maximal chains between two elements have the same finite length . all lattices need not have the jordan - dedekind property . for example , in the @xmath118 lattice , shown in fig . [ fig_hasse_diag_n_5 ] , there are two maximal chains from @xmath119 to @xmath120 . the maximal chain @xmath121 has three units of length and the other maximal chain @xmath122 has a length of two units . thus @xmath118 does not satisfy the jordan dedekind property . it turns out that modularity is closely related to this property . lattice : a lattice without jordan - dedekind property ] [ jd ] ( * ? ? ? * pg.41 , th.16 ) let @xmath12 be a lattice of finite length with the height function @xmath123 , then the following conditions are equivalent : 1 . @xmath13 is a modular lattice . 2 . @xmath13 has the jordan - dedekind property and @xmath123 is a valuation . the @xmath118 lattice shown in fig . [ fig_hasse_diag_n_5 ] does not satisfy the jordan - dedekind property and therefore , due to theorem [ jd ] , @xmath118 is non - modular . the height function @xmath123 is a positive isotone evaluation for modular lattices . therefore from theorem [ thm_pseudo_metric ] , the distance function induced by @xmath123 is a metric on the modular lattice . all the lattices , considered in this paper , will be modular . we will use this observation in the next section to define a coding metric for the definition of lattice schemes . we , therefore , have the following proposition which follows from theorem [ thm_pseudo_metric ] . [ thm_height_metric ] let @xmath13 be a modular lattice of finite length with the height function @xmath123 , then @xmath124 is a metric on @xmath13 . clearly @xmath125=1 $ ] iff @xmath29 covers @xmath51 . such elements are called _ atoms _ of the lattice . the atoms of the lattice are analogues of the singletons in lattice of sets ( one dimensional spaces in the lattice of subspaces ) . a _ geometric modular lattice _ is a modular lattice of finite height in which every element is a join of atoms . further , if the geometric modular lattice is distributive , then it will be called _ geometric distributive_. the lattice of subsets is a an example of a geometric distributive lattice and the lattice of subspaces is an example of a geometric modular lattice . is shown . in part ( b ) , a non - geometric , non - distributive modular lattice @xmath126 is depicted . ] however , all modular ( distributive ) lattices are not geometric . for example , consider the sublattice ( in fact , a chain ) @xmath127 of @xmath71__pow(@xmath128)__@xmath72 ( shown in part ( a ) of fig . [ fig_nongeometric ] ) . @xmath129 is not geometric because @xmath128 can not be obtained as a join of atoms of @xmath130 ( since there is only one atom in @xmath129 ) . @xmath129 is distributive since it is a sublattice of distributive lattice viz . therefore @xmath130 is an example of non - geometric distributive lattice . in order to construct a non - geometric non - distributive modular lattice , we will consider a sublattice of @xmath131 . for the sake of presentation , we will represent a vector @xmath132 by the natural number @xmath133 . for example , @xmath134 will be represented as @xmath135 . consider the sublattice @xmath136 of @xmath131 . @xmath126 is modular since it is a sublattice of a modular lattice viz . @xmath126 is not distributive because it contains a copy of @xmath137 as a sublattice ( @xmath137 is non - distributive ) . it can be verified that @xmath138 can not be obtained as a join of atoms of @xmath126 and thus @xmath126 is non - geometric . therefore @xmath126 is an example of non - geometric non - distributive modular lattice . henceforth all the lattices are assumed to be geometric modular unless otherwise mentioned . in order to develop a lattice based framework for singleton bounds , we need a definition of a code in this framework . in this section , we define ` lattice schemes ' which will serve as analogues of codes . we will show that hamming space , rank metric space and the projective spaces are examples of lattice schemes . although some of these observations have been mentioned in @xcite , we repeat it for the sake of continuity . a lattice scheme , which is analogous to a code , is defined as follows : let @xmath13 be a lattice and @xmath139 be the metric induced by the height function @xmath123 of the lattice @xmath13 . a _ lattice scheme _ @xmath109 in @xmath140 is a subset of @xmath13 and the _ minimum distance of @xmath109 _ , denoted by @xmath119 is defined as @xmath141 the dimension of a lattice scheme is defined as @xmath142 . a coding space @xmath143 is a metric space where @xmath3 is a set and @xmath144 is a metric on @xmath3 . a code @xmath109 in a coding space @xmath143 is a subset of @xmath3 . the connection between lattice schemes and codes is made precise in the following definition . [ def_transform ] let @xmath109 be a lattice scheme in @xmath140 and @xmath145 be a code in a coding space @xmath146 . we say that the _ code _ @xmath145 is _ equivalent to a lattice scheme _ @xmath109 , if there exists a function @xmath147 , that satisfies the following conditions : 1 . @xmath148 2 . @xmath149 for all @xmath150 @xmath151 is called a transform for the code @xmath145 . a transform @xmath151 of a code is one - one . to prove this fact , assume @xmath152 , then @xmath153 . by 2 ) of definition [ def_transform ] , this would imply @xmath154 . and since @xmath144 is a metric , we have @xmath155 . @xmath65 when a lattice scheme is equivalent to a code , we also say the code is equivalent to the scheme . a transform for a code preserves the distance between any pair of codewords . therefore whenever a lattice scheme is equivalent to a code , the lattice scheme will have the same minimum distance as the code . the following proposition follows from definition [ def_transform ] , [ prop_dist_preserve ] let @xmath109 be a lattice scheme with minimum distance @xmath119 that is equivalent to code @xmath145 with minimum distance @xmath156 , then 1 . @xmath157 2 . if @xmath158 , then there exists @xmath159 such that the lattice scheme @xmath5 is equivalent to the code @xmath160 since ` @xmath109 is equivalent to @xmath145 ' , the first part follows from the definition . for the second part , since @xmath109 is equivalent to @xmath145 , there exists a transform @xmath151 . we define @xmath161 . clearly @xmath159 and the function @xmath151 still serves as a lattice transform for the code @xmath162 . thus @xmath5 is equivalent to @xmath162 . due to the above proposition , given a lattice scheme equivalent to a code , we can talk of the minimum distance without specifying whether it is the minimum distance of the code or the minimum distance of the scheme . from the second part of the proposition [ prop_dist_preserve ] , we can infer that the subsets of codes are equivalent to certain subsets of schemes . therefore , if we prove that a coding space itself is equivalent to some lattice , then any code in the coding space is equivalent to a scheme in the lattice . we use this observation to establish that every binary code is equivalent to a scheme in the power set lattice . [ exmpl_binary_codes ] let @xmath163 , @xmath164_pow(@xmath3)_@xmath72 and @xmath165 . @xmath13 is a geometric distributive lattice and @xmath166 as seen in the previous section . consider codes in the coding space @xmath167 where @xmath168 is the hamming distance between two vectors . we claim that the entire coding space @xmath169 is equivalent to the power set lattice @xmath13 . to see this let , @xmath170 it can be verified that @xmath171 ( where @xmath172 represents the symmetric difference operator ) and that @xmath173 is onto . further , @xmath174 . the number of elements in @xmath175 will be the hamming weight of @xmath176 . thus @xmath177 . therefore , @xmath173 is the power set lattice transform for the binary code . since the map is onto , @xmath173 is a bijective map . by application of the second part of proposition [ prop_dist_preserve ] , we see that every binary code is equivalent to a power set lattice scheme . @xmath65 the lattice of subspaces , discussed in the previous section , also provide examples of lattice schemes . in a projective lattice , the metric induced by the height function is the subspace distance . therefore , any subspace code is equivalent to a lattice scheme in the projective lattice . let @xmath17 be a vector space over @xmath178 is a projective lattice with height function @xmath179 . the coding space is @xmath180 where @xmath181 represents the subspace distance defined in @xcite . for any two subspaces @xmath5 and @xmath7 , @xmath182 . since @xmath183 , the metric induced by the height function is the subspace distance . the identity map can be a transform in this case . and thus , subspace schemes are equivalent to subspace codes.@xmath65 lattice schemes in the above lattice correspond to subspace codes in projective spaces @xcite . certain constant dimension subspace code constructions , described in @xcite , make use of the rank distance gabidulin codes @xcite . the rank metric codes are actually equivalent to gabidulin codes since they are ` lifted ' from gabidulin codes . we show that rank distance codes are equivalent to certain schemes in the projective lattice . we also show that the lifting function is a transform . let @xmath184 denote the space of @xmath185 matrices over @xmath14 . for @xmath186 , define @xmath187 . this coding space is the rank distance space . we claim that the rank distance space is equivalent to a scheme in the projective lattice . consider the projective lattice @xmath188 with the height function @xmath179 . define a transform @xmath151 as follows : @xmath189 } \end{aligned}\ ] ] notice that @xmath190 for any @xmath5 in @xmath191 . therefore subspaces whose dimension is not @xmath192 are not in the range of @xmath151 . therefore @xmath151 is an example of a transform that is not onto . the function @xmath151 defined above is called the lifting of @xmath5 in @xcite . the authors of @xcite establish that @xmath193 . thus rank metric codes are equivalent to schemes in the projective lattice and @xmath151 is the projective lattice transform for the rank metric code . @xmath65 all our main results on the bounds and their behavior are derived in this section . we introduce the notion of puncturing a scheme and investigate the effects of puncturing on the minimum distance of a lattice scheme . it will be proved that , after puncturing a scheme , the maximum drop in minimum distance will be two . however , if the lattice is known to be distributive , it is shown that the maximum drop in minimum distance is one . this observation will be applied repeatedly until the minimum distance drops to zero . we will need the following definition of _ whitney number of the second kind _ , from @xcite , to state the lattice singleton bound : the _ whitney numbers _ @xmath194 of a lattice @xmath13 in a lattice with height @xmath123 and @xmath195 is defined as @xmath196 the whitney numbers of a lattice count the total number of elements in the lattice of a given height . a scheme @xmath109 is said to be _ punctured to @xmath197 _ if @xmath198 for some @xmath199 . if @xmath200 has a height of @xmath201 , the scheme @xmath109 is said to be _ punctured by a dimension_. note that for a @xmath199 , @xmath202 is a sublattice of @xmath13 @xcite . for two lattice elements @xmath200 and @xmath203 of equal height , we have @xmath204 . this means that the whitney numbers of two different punctured lattices remain the same , as long as the elements that puncture the scheme are of the same height . we need the following lemma ( called the ` distance drop lemma ' ) to establish the proof of the main theorem later . [ lem_drop_dist ] let @xmath109 be a scheme in @xmath140 with minimum distance @xmath119 , and let @xmath109 be punctured by a dimension to @xmath197 , then 1 . @xmath13 is distributive @xmath205 @xmath206 2 . in general , @xmath207 proof of 1 ) : we assume @xmath13 is distributive . let @xmath208 , @xmath209 and @xmath210 . we have to show that @xmath211 for all @xmath212 . by the definition of @xmath139 , @xmath213 - h[\tilde{a } \wedge \tilde{b } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since the lattice is distributive , we can write it as , @xmath214 - h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the height function is a valuation and thus satisfies @xmath215 + h[x \wedge y ] = h[x ] + h[y]$ ] . we use this in the above equation to obtain , @xmath216 + h[w ] - h[a \vee b \vee w ] - h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] since @xmath217 , it must be that @xmath218 \leq h[i ] = n$ ] . using this inequality and @xmath219 = n-1 $ ] , we get @xmath220 + ( n-1 ) - n - h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] clearly @xmath221 and therefore @xmath222 \leq h[a \wedge b]$ ] . using this , the definition of @xmath223 and the fact that @xmath119 is the minimum distance of the scheme @xmath109 , we finally get @xmath224 proof of 2 ) : we have to show that @xmath225 for all @xmath212 . again by the definition of @xmath139 , @xmath226 - h[\tilde{a } \wedge \tilde{b}].\end{aligned}\ ] ] repeatedly using the fact that the height function is a valuation and thus satisfies @xmath215 + h[x \wedge y ] = h[x ] + h[y]$ ] , we get , @xmath227 + h[b ] + 2h[w ] - h[a \vee w ] \\ - h[b \vee w ] - 2h[a \wedge b \wedge w ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] clearly @xmath221 and therefore @xmath222 \leq h[a \wedge b]$ ] . additionally @xmath228 and @xmath229 , which means @xmath230 , h[\tilde{b } ] \leq h[i ] = n$ ] . using this inequality and @xmath219 = n-1 $ ] , we get the following : @xmath231 + h[b ] + 2(n-1 ) - 2n - 2h[a \wedge b ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] using the definition of @xmath223 and the fact that @xmath119 is the minimum distance of the scheme @xmath109 , we finally get , @xmath232 the distance drop lemma states that in a non - distributive lattice , the drop in the minimum distance after puncturing a dimension , can be at most two units . so it would be interesting to know if it is possible that the drop of two units is exhibited by some scheme in a non - distributive lattice . the following example constructs such a scheme . [ example_proj_space ] let @xmath17 be a three dimensional space , over @xmath233 , spanned by @xmath234 . let @xmath235 @xmath236 , @xmath237 @xmath238 and @xmath239 @xmath240 . we have @xmath241 but @xmath242 . note that @xmath243 ( that is , the sublattice generated by @xmath244 , @xmath245 and @xmath246 is not distributive ) as expected . if our scheme contained @xmath247 and @xmath246 , then puncturing the scheme with @xmath246 would have left @xmath246 as it is and punctured only the remaining two subspaces . the above example clearly illustrates that the lack of distributivity in a lattice can drop the distance of a punctured scheme by two units . we will now derive a singleton bound for lattice schemes , that establishes an upper bound on the cardinality of the scheme , for a given minimum distance for geometric modular lattices . [ theorem_lsb ] if @xmath248 is a geometric modular lattice with height @xmath123 and @xmath249 , @xmath139 is the metric induced by the height function , and @xmath109 is a scheme of @xmath13 with minimum distance @xmath119 , then @xmath250 where 1 . @xmath251 , when @xmath13 is _ distributive _ , 2 . @xmath252 , when @xmath13 is _ modular_. given the lattice @xmath13 , pick an element @xmath200 of height @xmath253 ( which always exists in a geometric modular lattice ) . now puncture the lattice by a dimension to get a new geometric modular lattice @xmath129 with height @xmath253 and suppose that drop in minimum distance of the scheme , after puncturing a dimension , is at most @xmath254 . if @xmath255 is the minimum distance of the punctured scheme @xmath197 , then @xmath256 . if @xmath257 , then all elements in the punctured scheme @xmath197 are still distinct . we repeat the puncturing operating on the new lattice . the puncturing is repeated maximum number of times so that the minimum distance of the punctured scheme does not drop to zero . in other words , we keep puncturing the lattice , until the minimum distance of the punctured scheme is just short of zero . let us say that the original lattice was punctured @xmath258 times . since the minimum distance of the punctured scheme is still non zero , the punctured scheme contains exactly the same number of elements as @xmath109 . at this stage , the minimum distance of the scheme is non - zero and all the elements of the punctured scheme are in a lattice of height @xmath259 . clearly the number of elements in the scheme @xmath109 is upper bounded by the total number of elements in the punctured lattice . thus @xmath260 if the minimum distance of the scheme , after being punctured @xmath258 times , is @xmath261 , then @xmath262 and @xmath261 is the smallest number such that @xmath263 . this implies that @xmath264 . from the lemma [ lem_drop_dist ] , we know that @xmath265 for a distributive lattice and @xmath266 for a modular lattice . thus @xmath267 for a distributive lattice and for a modular lattice , @xmath252 . this completes the proof . we remark that the bound does not equal @xmath268 , for the case @xmath269 , which should yield only two elements . the bound is weaker for large minimum distance because we have no information about the range of heights of the elements of the scheme . we can tighten the bound by systematically puncturing and projecting a dimension as done in @xcite . also , as noted in example [ example_proj_space ] , puncturing a dimension of a scheme does not reduce the heights of the elements of the scheme in a uniform manner . so we need the following definition , given two elements @xmath270 and @xmath200 in a lattice @xmath13 , define @xmath271 to be equal to an element of height @xmath272 that is contained in @xmath273 . in particular , if @xmath200 is fixed and @xmath274 , the set @xmath275 is said to be _ punctured and projected by a dimension_. thus when @xmath276 , @xmath271 is arbitrarily chosen to be an element immediately below @xmath270 in the hasse diagram of the lattice . for all other cases , @xmath277 . the following example illustrates that puncturing a dimension reduces the heights of different elements of a scheme by different amounts . it also demonstrates that puncturing and projecting by a dimension equally reduces the heights of all elements of a scheme . in example [ exmpl_punc_proj ] is shown here . the dark arrow shows that after puncturing and projecting by @xmath246 both @xmath244 and @xmath245 can drop to the same subspace @xmath278 . however , puncturing by @xmath246 alone drops @xmath245 to @xmath278 but not @xmath244 . ] [ exmpl_punc_proj ] let @xmath17 be a three dimensional space , over @xmath233 , spanned by @xmath234 . let @xmath235 @xmath279 , @xmath237 @xmath280 and @xmath239 @xmath279 . [ fig_puncture ] shows how puncturing and projecting drops the heights of all elements by one unit . thus the dimension of @xmath244 remains the same after puncturing by @xmath246 but the dimension of @xmath245 drops by one unit . however , after puncturing and projecting the lattice by @xmath246 , both @xmath244 and @xmath245 drop by a height of one unit . to be precise , define @xmath281 and observe that @xmath282 . but @xmath283 . to define @xmath284 we need to choose a one dimensional subspace of @xmath244 . for instance , we can choose @xmath285 . @xmath65 we can now establish that puncturing and projecting a dimension of a scheme can drop the minimum distance of the scheme by at most two units . this lemma is useful since it tells us that every time we puncture and project by a dimension , all the elements in the scheme drop once in height . [ lemma_punctured_drop ] let @xmath109 be a scheme in a lattice @xmath140 with minimum distance @xmath119 , and let @xmath249 and let @xmath199 such that @xmath286 . if the maximum height of @xmath109 was @xmath287 and the minimum height of @xmath109 was @xmath192 , then the maximum height of @xmath288 is @xmath289 and the minimum height is @xmath290 . additionally @xmath291 by definition of @xmath288 , all the elements of @xmath288 have lost a unit of height . so the only thing to establish is that @xmath292 . the proof is very similar to the previous lemma . by the definition of @xmath139 , @xmath293 + h[\overline{b \wedge w } ] - 2h[\overline{a \wedge w } \wedge \overline { b \wedge w } ] . \end{aligned}\ ] ] from the definition of @xmath294 , it follows that @xmath295 and thus @xmath296 \leq h[x \wedge w]$ ] for all @xmath297 and thus , @xmath298 - 1 ) + ( h[b ] - 1 ) - 2h[a \wedge b ] \end{aligned}\ ] ] and therefore from the formula for height we get , @xmath299 we will need lemma [ lemma_punctured_drop ] to get the following improvement on the code size , [ thm_tighter_bound ] let @xmath109 be a scheme in a geometric modular lattice @xmath13 with minimum distance @xmath119 . let @xmath192 denote the smallest height of all the elements in @xmath109 and @xmath287 denote the largest height of all the elements in @xmath109 . then , @xmath300 let @xmath200 be an element of height @xmath253 and @xmath301 . by lemma [ lemma_punctured_drop ] , the punctured and projected scheme in @xmath129 has a maximum height of @xmath302 , a minimum height of @xmath290 and a minimum distance drop of at most two units . now the proof proceeds in a manner similar to the proof of the theorem [ theorem_lsb ] . after puncturing @xmath303 times , the elements of the scheme will have a maximum height of @xmath304 and a minimum height of @xmath305 and the theorem is proved . we will now apply theorem [ theorem_lsb ] and theorem [ thm_tighter_bound ] to two important lattice schemes ( namely the power set lattice and the projective lattice ) and derive the corresponding lsb . the lsb that we obtain coincides with the singleton bound found in the literature . first , we derive the classical singleton bound as a corollary to the lsb theorem . let @xmath109 be a code in @xmath306 , with minimum distance @xmath119 , then @xmath307 in example [ exmpl_binary_codes ] , @xmath308 is the number of subsets of size @xmath309 in the scheme @xmath109 , given that @xmath310 . using the fact that @xmath13 is geometric and distributive , @xmath251 . first we observe that , @xmath311 and @xmath312 applying the lsb theorem , we get , @xmath313 which is the singleton bound for @xmath306 . now we derive the kks bound reported in @xcite . it follows as a direct corollary to theorem [ thm_tighter_bound ] when the lattice is chosen to be the lattice of subspaces . if @xmath314 and @xmath315 , then @xmath316 let @xmath317 where @xmath109 is chosen to be a subset of the grassmanian @xmath22 . then @xmath314 and the lattice coefficients @xmath318 . now apply theorem [ thm_tighter_bound ] to @xmath109 . the distance drop lemma , used in the main theorem , along with example [ example_proj_space ] clearly shows that at every step of puncturing the distance can drop by at most two units . on the other hand , one can construct examples where distance drop is one unit . now suppose some scheme achieves the lsb ( and thus the kks bound ) . then that scheme has elements which consistently drop by a distance of two units _ irrespective _ of which element is puncturing it . and this should happen at every puncturing step until the minimum distance drops to zero . since this seems highly unlikely , we conjecture the following : _ conjecture : _ there are no schemes that can achieve the lsb for projective spaces . in particular , there are no constant dimension codes that can achieve the kks bound . it is clear that many examples fit into the framework of lattice schemes and the proposed lsb specializes to the known singleton bounds in literature . in this section , we will show that the lsb gives a new upper bound when applied to projective spaces . a family of non - constant dimension code constructions in projective spaces have been reported by @xcite and @xcite . our lsb plots show that the code sizes , of both reported codes , are near optimal for certain fixed values of the coding parameters . singleton bound in projective spaces will be specified using gaussian numbers ( they are the @xmath15-analogues of binomials @xcite ) . lower bounds on code sizes based on sphere covering methods can be found in @xcite . upper bounds on code sizes for projective space codes , found in the literature , are for constant dimension codes . the following bound is an upper bound on the code size of a non - constant dimension code in a projective space . let @xmath109 be a code in @xmath319 ( where @xmath17 is vector space over @xmath14 ) , with minimum distance @xmath119 , then @xmath320 where @xmath321 denotes the gaussian number . the @xmath322 lattice with @xmath323 is a modular geometric lattice . we note that @xmath324 the gaussian number @xmath325 is the total number of @xmath52-dimensional subspaces of an @xmath326-dimensional space over @xmath14 and thus by theorem [ theorem_lsb ] , @xmath327 where @xmath328 . the bound is weak when the minimum distance @xmath119 is comparable to the code dimension @xmath21 . however when the minimum distance is smaller than code dimension , the tightness of the bound is not apparent . therefore we investigate the behaviour of our bounds , at such ranges , by plotting it with other bounds in the literature . we will compare our bound ( lsb ) to the gilbert varshamov bound ( ev - gvb ) proposed in @xcite for various values of the minimum distance . further , we will plot points achieved by various codes in the literature . the plot is shown in fig . [ fig_drawing ] . the minimum distance of the projective code and the finite field size has been fixed at @xmath329 and @xmath268 respectively , throughout this section . the plot clearly shows our upper bound above the ev - gv lower bound . the points marked etzsilb codes and khks code are the code parameters reported in @xcite and @xcite respectively , for @xmath330 and @xmath331 . [ fig_drawing ] shows that the etzsilb codes and khks codes are close to optimal for @xmath330 and @xmath331 . the khks code sizes are roughly @xmath332 bits away from the upper bound . it has already been observed that the distance drop in projective spaces is variable and thus we believe that our bound is weak for larger values of @xmath119 . in this paper , we introduced the notion of lattice schemes which serve as analogues of codes . we derived a general notion of singleton bound for which the classical singleton bound for binary codes and the singleton - like bound for constant dimension subspace codes were special cases . we proved that puncturing a dimension gives a tight bound for distributive lattices but not for projective lattices . however , it was seen that puncturing and projecting a dimension gives a tighter bound , for projective lattices . this leads us to conjecture that it is not possible to achieve the kks bound . the upper bound derived in the paper seems to be tighter when the minimum distance is much smaller than the code dimension . a next step would be to tighten the bounds for large minimum distances . it would be interesting to investigate whether there exists lattice schemes that achieve the lsb with equality . in particular , it would be very interesting to know if there exists a reed solomon - like scheme which specializes to the different counterparts in binary and subspace codes . also , whether quantum codes are lattice schemes can be investigated .
Abstract: | [
"the binary coding theory and subspace codes for random network coding exhibit similar structures . the method used to obtain a singleton bound for subspace codes mimic the technique used in obtaining the singleton bound for binary codes . this motivates the question of whether there is an abstract framework that captures these similarities . as a first step towards answering this question , we use the lattice framework proposed in @xcite . a lattice is a partially ordered set in which any two elements have a least upper bound and a greatest lower bound . a ` lattice scheme ' is defined as a subset of a lattice . in this paper , we derive a singleton bound for lattice schemes and obtain singleton bounds known for binary codes and subspace codes as special cases . the lattice framework gives additional insights into the behaviour of singleton bound for subspace codes . we also obtain a _ new _ upper bound on the code size for non - constant dimension codes . the plots of this bound along with plots of the code sizes of known non - constant dimension codes in the literature reveal that our bound is tight for certain parameters of the code ."
] | 8,014 | 8,014 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: wireless powered communication network has arisen as a new system with stable and self - sustainable power supplies in shaping future - generation wireless communications @xcite . the enabling technology , known as simultaneous wireless information and power transfer ( swipt ) , has particularly drawn an upsurge of interests owing to the far - field electromagnetic power carried by radio - frequency ( rf ) signals that affluently exist in wireless communications . with the transmit power , waveforms , and dimensions of resources , etc . , being all fully controllable , swipt promises to prolong the lifetime of wireless devices while delivering the essential communication functionality , as will be important for low - power applications such as rf identification ( rfid ) and wireless sensor networks ( wsns ) ( see @xcite and the references therein ) . on the other hand , privacy and authentication have increasingly become major concerns for wireless communications and physical ( phy)-layer security has emerged as a new layer of defence to realize perfect secrecy transmission in addition to the costly upper - layer techniques such as cryptography . in this regard , relay - assisted secure transmission was proposed @xcite and phy - layer security enhancements by means of cooperative communications have since attracted much attention @xcite . in particular , cooperative schemes can be mainly classified into three categories : _ decode - and - forward ( df ) _ , _ amplify - and - forward ( af ) _ , and _ cooperative jamming ( cj ) _ @xcite with cj being most relevant to phy - layer security . specifically , coordinated cj refers to the scheme of generating a common jamming signal across all single - antenna relay helpers against eavesdropping @xcite , while uncoordinated cj considers that each relay helper emits independent artificial noise ( an ) to confound the eavesdroppers @xcite . it is expected that in the scenarios where the direct link is broken between the transmitter ( tx ) and the legitimate receiver ( rx ) , some of the relays have to take on their conventional role of forwarding the information while others will perform cj @xcite . a recent paradigm that generalizes all the above - mentioned cooperation strategies is _ cooperative beamforming ( cb ) mixed with cj _ @xcite , where the available power at each relay is split into two parts : one for forwarding the confidential message and the other for cj . however , mixed cb - cj approaches may be prohibitive in applications with low power devices because idle relays with limited battery supplies would likely prefer saving power for their own traffic to assisting others communication . in light of this , swipt provides the incentive for potential helpers to perform dedicated cb mixed with cj at no expense of its own power , but opportunistically earn harvested energy . motivated by this , our work considers secrecy transmission from a tx to a legitimate rx with the aid of a set of single - antenna wireless energy harvesting ( weh)-enabled af - operated relays in the presence of multiple single - antenna eavesdroppers . as a matter of fact , cooperative schemes that involve weh - enabled relays was recently investigated in @xcite . we consider the use of the _ dynamic power splitting ( dps ) _ receiver architecture , initially proposed for swipt in @xcite , which divides the received power with an adjustable ratio for energy harvesting ( eh ) and information receiving ( ir ) . weh - enabled relays using dps receivers have also been considered in @xcite and @xcite , without ( w / o ) and with secrecy consideration , respectively . note that there is also interest in addressing the threat that weh receivers may attempt to intercept the confidential messages in swipt - enabled networks @xcite . nevertheless , we will focus on exploiting the benefits of weh - enabled relays when they are trustful . in particular , motivated by the strong interest in swipt and the vast degree - of - freedom ( dof ) achievable by cooperative relays , this paper aims to maximize the secrecy rate with the aid of weh - enabled af - operated relays , subject to the eh power constraints of individual relays by jointly optimizing the cb of the relays and the cj covariance matrix . in this paper , we assume that there is no direct link between the source and destination nodes , and perfect global channel state information ( csi ) is available for the case of centralized optimization . it is worth pointing out that although our setting may look similar to @xcite , their optimal cb - cj design is not applicable to ours due to the multiplicative nature in beamforming weights incurred by the power splitting ( ps ) ratios that intrinsically poses more intractability to our optimization problem . further , our work also differs from @xcite where an efficient algorithm was proposed to maximize the secrecy rate for the optimization of the ps ratios and af relay beamforming . the difference is twofold . first , an was not considered in the second transmission phase in @xcite and in addition , their algorithm only converged to a local optimum , as opposed to our work that gives the global optimal solutions for cb . the rest of the paper is organized as follows . section [ sec : system model ] describes two types of weh - enabled rx architecture for the af relays and defines the secrecy rate region of the relay wiretap channel . section [ sec : problem formulation ] then formulates the secrecy rate maximization problems that jointly optimize the an ( or cj ) and the af - relay cb for the weh - enabled relays operating with the two types of rx . the problems are respectively solved by centralized schemes in section [ sec : centralized ] and distributed approaches in section [ sec : distributed ] . section [ sec : numerical results ] provides simulation results to evaluate the performance of the proposed schemes . finally , section [ sec : conclusion ] concludes the paper . _ notations_we use the uppercase boldface letters for matrices and lowercase boldface letters for vectors . the superscripts @xmath0 , @xmath1 , @xmath2 and @xmath3 represent , respectively , the transpose , conjugate , conjugate transpose operations on vectors or matrices , and the optimum . in addition , @xmath4 stands for the trace of a square matrix . moreover , @xmath5_{i , j}$ ] denotes the @xmath6th entry of a matrix , while @xmath7 and @xmath8 represent the euclidean norm and the entry - wise absolute value square of a vector , respectively . also , @xmath9 denotes a diagonal matrix with its diagonal specified by the given vector and @xmath5_{i=1}^n$ ] represents an @xmath10 vector with each element indexed by @xmath11 . furthermore , @xmath12 and @xmath13 stand for product and hadamard product , respectively . @xmath14 denotes the field of complex ( real ) matrices with dimension @xmath15 and @xmath16}$ ] indicates the expectation operation . finally , @xmath17 is short for @xmath18 . in this paper , we consider secrecy transmission in a swipt - enabled wsn , where a tx ( alice ) wants to establish confidential communication with the legitimate rx ( bob ) with no direct link but with the aid of @xmath19 weh - enabled sensors operating as af relays , denoted by @xmath20 , in the presence of multiple eavesdroppers ( eves ) , denoted by @xmath21 , all equipped with single antenna . we assume that there is no direct link from the tx to any of the eves , due to , for instance , severe path loss or shadowing , as illustrated in fig . [ fig : system model ] . we consider a two - hop relaying protocol based on two equal time slots and the duration of one transmit - slot is normalized to be one unit so that the terms `` energy '' and `` power '' are interchangeable with respect to ( w.r.t . ) one transmit - slot . at the receiver of each af relay , we introduce two types of weh - enabled receiver architecture , namely , _ static power splitting ( sps ) _ ( fig . [ fig : subfig : sps rx ] ) and _ dps _ ( fig . [ fig : subfig : dps rx ] ) , both of which allow the relay to harvest energy and receive information from the same received signal . specifically , the receiver first splits a portion of @xmath22 , of the received power for eh and the rest @xmath23 for ir , @xmath24 . the @xmath22 portion of harvested power is further divided into two streams with @xmath25 used for generating the an to confound eves and @xmath26 used for amplifying the received signal , where @xmath27 is the @xmath11th element of the received signal @xmath28 , and @xmath29 denotes the eh efficiency . note that dps with adjustable @xmath22 s is presently the most general receiver operation because practical circuits can not directly decode the information from the stream used for eh @xcite and sps is just a special case of dps with @xmath30 , @xmath24 , fixed for the whole transmission duration . however , sps , advocated for its ease of implementation , is introduced separately in the sequel for its simplified relay beamforming design . in the first transmit - slot , the received signal at each individual relay can be expressed as @xmath31 where the transmit signal @xmath32 is a circularly symmetric complex gaussian ( cscg ) random variable with zero mean and unit variance , denoted by @xmath33 , @xmath34 denotes the complex channel from the tx to the @xmath11th relay , @xmath35 is the transmit power at the tx , and @xmath36 is the additive white gaussian noise ( awgn ) introduced by the receiving antenna of the @xmath11th relay , denoted by @xmath37 . as such , the linearly amplified baseband equivalent signal at the output of the @xmath11th relay is given by @xmath38 where @xmath39 denotes the complex af coefficient , and @xmath40 denotes the noise due to signal conversion from the rf band to baseband , denoted by @xmath41 . since @xmath42 is constrained by the portion of the harvested power for forwarding , i.e. , @xmath26 , @xmath39 is accordingly given by @xmath43 where @xmath44 denotes the phase of the af coefficient for the @xmath11th relay . next , we introduce the cj scheme . denote the cj signal generated from @xmath19 relays by @xmath45^t$ ] and define its covariance matrix as @xmath46 $ ] . then the coordinated cj transmission can be uniquely determined by the truncated eigenvalue decomposition ( evd ) of @xmath47 given by @xmath48 , where @xmath49)$ ] is a diagonal matrix with @xmath50 s denoting all the positive eigenvalues of @xmath47 and @xmath51 is the precoding matrix satisfying @xmath52 . note that @xmath53 denotes the rank of @xmath54 which will be designed later . as a result , the cj signal can be expressed as @xmath55 where @xmath56 s are drawn from the columns of @xmath57 , and @xmath58 s are independent and identically distributed ( i.i.d . ) complex gaussian variables denoted by @xmath59 , which is known as the optimal distribution for an @xcite . on the other hand , @xmath60 , @xmath24 , denotes the power constraint for jamming at the @xmath11th relay , which implies that @xmath61 where @xmath62 is a diagonal matrix with its diagonal @xmath63 ( a unit vector with the @xmath11th entry equal to @xmath64 and the rest equal to @xmath65 ) . note that the cj scheme proposed above is of the most general form . for the special case when @xmath66 , i.e. , @xmath67 , each relay transmits a common jamming signal @xmath68 with their respective weight drawn from @xmath69 @xcite . this case is desirable in practice since it has the lowest complexity for implementation . in summary , the transmitted signal at the @xmath11th relay is given by @xmath70 according to together with , , and , the transmit signal from all relays can be expressed in vector form as @xmath71 where @xmath72 and @xmath73 are , respectively , diagonal matrices with their diagonals composed of @xmath74 @xmath75 and @xmath76 . in addition , @xmath77_{i=1}^n$ ] , @xmath78_{i=1}^n$ ] , and @xmath79_{i=1}^n$ ] . @xmath80 in the second transmit - slot , the received signal at the desired receiver , i.e. , bob , is given by @xmath81 where @xmath82_{i=1}^n$ ] comprises complex channels from the @xmath11th relay to the rx and @xmath83 is the corresponding receiving awgn . by substituting into , @xmath84 can be expressed as @xmath85 the received signal at the @xmath86th eve , @xmath87 , is given by @xmath88 where @xmath89_{i=1}^n$ ] denotes the complex channels from the relays to the @xmath86th eve and @xmath90 is the awgn at the @xmath86th eavesdropper . the mutual information for the rx ( bob ) is given by @xmath91 , and that for the @xmath86th eve is @xmath92 , @xmath93 , where @xmath94 and @xmath95 , which denote their respective signal - to - interference - plus - noise ratios ( sinrs ) , are given at the top of next page . next , we define the secrecy rate region that consists of all the achievable secrecy rate for the relay wiretap channel given transmit power @xmath35 , denoted by @xmath96 , which is given by @xcite @xmath97 in this section , we consider the secrecy rate maximization problem by jointly optimizing the an beams , relay beam and their power allocations for weh - enabled af relays operating with sps , i.e. , @xmath30 , @xmath24 , is fixed . by replacing @xmath39 with , @xmath98 in at the next page becomes @xmath99 and @xmath100_i\triangleq h_{sr_i}h_{r_id}\sqrt{\tfrac{\eta\bar\alpha_i(1-\bar\alpha_i)|h_{sr_i}|^2p_s}{(1-\bar\alpha_i)(|h_{sr_i}|^2p_s + \sigma_{n_a}^2)+\sigma_{n_c}^2}}.\ ] ] in addition , @xmath101 and @xmath102 in can also be combined as @xmath103_{i , i},\ ] ] where @xmath104_{i , i}=\frac{\eta\bar\alpha_ip_s|h_{sr_i}|^2|h_{r_id}|^2((1-\bar\alpha_i)\sigma_{n_a}^2+\sigma_{n_c}^2 ) } { ( 1-\bar\alpha_i)(|h_{sr_i}|^2p_s+\sigma_{n_a}^2)+\sigma_{n_c}^2}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] as a result , @xmath105 can be rewritten as @xmath106 where @xmath107_{i=1}^n$ ] . similarly by letting @xmath108_i\triangleq h_{sr_i}h_{r_ie , k}\sqrt{\frac{\eta\bar\alpha_i(1-\bar\alpha_i)|h_{sr_i}|^2p_s}{(1-\bar\alpha_i)(|h_{sr_i}|^2p_s + \sigma_{n_a}^2)+\sigma_{n_c}^2}}\ ] ] and @xmath109_{i , i}\triangleq\frac{\eta\bar\alpha_ip_s|h_{sr_i}|^2|h_{r_ie , k}|^2((1-\bar\alpha_i)\sigma_{n_a}^2+\sigma_{n_c}^2 ) } { ( 1-\bar\alpha_i)(|h_{sr_i}|^2p_s+\sigma_{n_a}^2)+\sigma_{n_c}^2},\ ] ] we have @xmath110 by some simple manipulation , is reformulated as a per - relay jamming power constraint given by @xmath111 now , the secrecy rate maximization problem w.r.t . @xmath112 s , @xmath44 s and @xmath47 for sps - based relays can be formulated as @xmath113 @xmath114 here , we consider the secrecy rate maximization problem for weh - enabled af relays with adjustable ps ratios @xmath115 by jointly optimizing the an beams , relay beam , weh ps ratios @xmath115 , and an ps ratios @xmath116 . first , consider the following variable transformation : @xmath117 using this , @xmath118 can then be expressed as @xmath119 , where @xmath120_{i=1}^n$ ] and @xmath121_{i=1}^n$ ] . moreover , @xmath122 and @xmath123 can be simplified as @xmath124 and @xmath125 , respectively , where @xmath126_{i=1}^n$ ] with @xmath127 , @xmath24 , and @xmath128_{i=1}^n$ ] . similarly , we have @xmath129 , @xmath130 , and @xmath131 , where @xmath132_{i=1}^n$ ] , @xmath133 . then we apply the above transformation to @xmath134 ( c.f . ) and @xmath135 ( c.f . ) , @xmath93 , to get and ( see next page ) . now , we can recast the constraints w.r.t . @xmath47 , @xmath22 s , and @xmath112 s to those w.r.t . the transformed variables @xmath136 s and @xmath137 s . in accordance with , the optimization variables , @xmath22 s and @xmath112 s , can be alternatively given by @xmath138 where @xmath139 . replacing @xmath22 s and @xmath112 s with , is reformulated as @xmath140 on the other hand , since @xmath141 and @xmath142 , @xmath24 , after some simple manipulation , it follows from that @xmath143 as such , the secrecy rate maximization problem for dps - based relays becomes @xmath144 in this section , we resort to centralized approaches to solve problem @xmath145 and @xmath146 , respectively , assuming that there is a central optimizer that is able to collect all csis including @xmath147 , @xmath148 and @xmath149 , perform the optimization , and broadcast to relays their individual optimized parameters . to start with , we recast @xmath145 into a two - stage problem by introducing a slack variable @xmath150 . first of all , we solve the epigraph reformulation of @xmath145 with a fixed @xmath151 $ ] as @xmath152 defining @xmath153 as the optimum value of @xmath154 and denoting @xmath155 , the objective function of @xmath145 is given by @xmath156 where @xmath157 in the objective function has been omitted and we claim a zero secrecy rate if admits a negative value . as a result , @xmath145 can be equivalently given by @xmath158 note that this single - variable optimization problem allows for simple one - dimension search over @xmath159 $ ] , assuming that @xmath160 is attainable given any @xmath150 in this region . as the physical meaning of @xmath161 in @xmath154 can be interpreted as the maximum permitted sinr for the best eavesdropper s channel , feasibility for a non - zero secrecy rate implies that @xmath162 where cauchy - schwarz inequality has been applied in @xmath163 and @xmath164 follows from @xmath165 , @xmath166 . the above epigraph reformulation of non - convex problems like @xmath145 has been widely employed in the literature @xcite , and @xmath167 admits the same optimal value as @xmath145 while @xmath154 with the optimal @xmath150 provides the corresponding optimal solution to @xmath145 . we summarize the steps for solving @xmath145 here : given any @xmath159 $ ] , solve @xmath154 to obtain @xmath160 ; solve @xmath167 via a one - dimensional search over @xmath150 . before developing solutions to @xmath154 , we have the lemma below . @xmath160 is a concave function of @xmath150 . [ lemma : concavity of h_1(tau ) ] see appendix [ appendix : proof of concavity of h_1(tau ) ] . using lemma [ lemma : concavity of h_1(tau ) ] , it is easy to verify that @xmath168 is also a concave function of @xmath150 according to the composition rule @xcite , which allows for a more effective search for the optimum @xmath150 , e.g. , bi - section method , than the exhaustive search used in @xcite . moreover , although @xmath160 is not differentiable w.r.t . @xmath150 , the bi - section method can still be implemented , the algorithm involving which is similarly applied in solving @xmath146 and thus will be given later in section [ sec : proposed solutions for dps ] . in the sequel , we focus on solving @xmath154 . by introducing @xmath169 and ignoring the rank - one constraint on @xmath170 , @xmath171 can be alternatively solved by @xmath172 note that the objective function has been multiplied by @xmath150 compared with that of @xmath154 for ready computation of @xmath160 . although @xmath173 is made easier to solve than @xmath154 by rank relaxation , it is still a quasi - convex problem considering the linear fractional form of the objective function and constraints , for which charnes - cooper transformation @xcite will be applied for equivalent convex reformulation . specifically , by substituting @xmath174 and @xmath175 into @xmath173 , it follows that @xmath176 problem @xmath177 can now be optimally and efficiently solved using interior - point based methods by some off - the - shelf convex optimization toolboxes , e.g. , cvx @xcite . we have the following results : 1 . the optimal solution to @xmath177 satisfies @xmath178 ; 2 . @xmath179 , where @xmath180 is given by @xmath181 in which @xmath182 is given in appendix [ appendix : proof of rank - one solution with cj for sps ] ; 3 . @xmath183 . [ prop : rank - one solution with cj for sps ] see appendix [ appendix : proof of rank - one solution with cj for sps ] . proposition [ prop : rank - one solution with cj for sps ] implies that the rank - one relaxation of @xmath173 from @xmath154 is tight for an arbitrary given @xmath150 . the @xmath184 s and @xmath185 s can thus be retrieved from the magnitude and angle of @xmath186 , respectively , by applying evd to @xmath187 . similar to section [ sec : optimal solutions for sps ] , in this section , we aim at solving the two - stage reformulation of @xmath146 by introducing a slack variable @xmath188 $ ] . first , for a given @xmath150 , we solve @xmath189 next , denoting @xmath190 by @xmath191 , where @xmath192 is the optimum value for problem @xmath193 , we solve the following problem that attains the same optimum value as @xmath146 : @xmath194 where @xmath195 is similarly derived as @xmath196 so that we directly arrive at @xmath197 , denoted by @xmath195 . we claim that @xmath198 can be solved by bi - section for @xmath150 over the interval @xmath199 $ ] assuming that @xmath191 is valid for any given @xmath150 ( otherwise a zero secrecy rate , i.e. , @xmath200 , is returned . ) , since @xmath191 has the following property . @xmath191 is a concave function of @xmath150 . [ lemma : concavity of h_2(tau ) ] the proof is similar to that for lemma [ lemma : concavity of h_1(tau ) ] , and thus is omitted . it is also seen that how to attain @xmath191 forms the main thrust for solving @xmath146 . however , the constraints in , and are not convex w.r.t . @xmath136 and/or @xmath137 , @xmath24 , due to their high orders and multiplicative structure . @xmath193 thus turns out to be very hard to solve in general . to cope with these non - convex constraints , we introduce the following lemma . the restricted hyperbolic constraints which have the form @xmath201 , where @xmath202 , @xmath203 , are equivalent to rotated second - order cone ( soc ) constraints as follows . @xmath204[lemma : hyperbolic to soc ] for convenience , denoting @xmath205 , @xmath206 , @xmath207 by @xmath208 , @xmath209 , and @xmath210 , respectively , @xmath24 , can be rewritten as @xmath211 according to and , it is easily verified that @xmath212 . hence , is eligible for lemma [ lemma : hyperbolic to soc ] , which is reformulated into the soc constraint : @xmath213 similarly , can be simplified as @xmath214 , and after some manipulation , it is recast into a constraint of the restricted hyperbolic form as @xmath215 is thus , in line with lemma [ lemma : hyperbolic to soc ] , equivalent to an soc constraint given by @xmath216 at last , is a linear constraint w.r.t . @xmath208 and @xmath209 given by @xmath217 @xmath218 note that have so far been equivalently transformed into the soc constraints , the linear constraints , as well as , the latter two of which are jointly convex w.r.t . @xmath208 and @xmath209 , @xmath24 . however , is still not convex w.r.t . @xmath210 , @xmath24 , yet . to circumvent this , in the sequel we propose to solve problem @xmath146 by alternating optimization . the upshot of the algorithm is that first we fix @xmath47 by @xmath219 and thus @xmath210 by @xmath220 , @xmath24 , and solve problem @xmath221 ( @xmath193,@xmath198 ) with fixed @xmath47 as @xmath221 ( @xmath222,@xmath223 ) in the sequel . ] to find the optimal @xmath224 , @xmath225 and @xmath226 via @xmath222 and @xmath223 ; then with @xmath227 , @xmath24 , we devise the optimal solution derived in section [ sec : optimal solutions for sps ] to obtain the optimal cj covariance , viz @xmath228 , and thus @xmath229 , @xmath24 ; finally , by updating @xmath230 and @xmath231 , @xmath24 , problems @xmath221 and @xmath145 are iteratively solved until they converge . the remaining challenges lie in solving problem @xmath222 now that , and are all made convex w.r.t . their variables @xmath208 , @xmath209 , @xmath24 . similar to that for @xmath154 , we introduce @xmath232 and @xmath233 and exempt problem @xmath222 from @xmath234 and @xmath235 as follows : @xmath236 @xmath191 ( c.f . ) and are given at the top of next page . recalling the procedure to deal with @xmath173 , we now apply charnes - cooper transformation to convert @xmath237 into a convex problem , denoted by @xmath238 , by replacing @xmath239 and @xmath240 with @xmath241 and @xmath242 , respectively . the solution for @xmath238 is tight and characterized by the following proposition . we have the following results : 1 . the optimal solution to @xmath238 satisfies @xmath243 such that @xmath244 ; 2 . @xmath245 is given by @xmath246 where @xmath247 , @xmath248 , and @xmath249 is given in appendix [ appendix : proof of rank - one solution with cj for dps ] ; 3 . @xmath250 , of which the diagonal entries compose a vector denoted by @xmath251 , can be reconstructed by @xmath252 with rank one . [ prop : rank - one solution with cj for dps ] see appendix [ appendix : proof of rank - one solution with cj for dps ] . the @xmath253 s and @xmath112 s are thus attained according to via evd of @xmath254 and @xmath255 . the proposed algorithm for solving @xmath146 is presented in table [ table : algorithm i ] . ' '' '' @xmath228 ; @xmath256 that denotes the optimum value for @xmath145 given @xmath257 , @xmath24 @xmath258 , @xmath259 @xmath260 @xmath261 , @xmath262 , @xmath24 , and solve @xmath221 : @xmath263 , @xmath264 , @xmath265 , @xmath266 , @xmath267 @xmath268 , @xmath269 solve @xmath222 and @xmath191 @xmath270 @xmath271 , where @xmath272 and @xmath273 denotes an arbitrary small value . @xmath274 @xmath275 @xmath276 , @xmath277 , and obtain @xmath278 according to @xmath279 , @xmath24 , and solve @xmath145 via @xmath154 and @xmath167 @xmath280 , @xmath281 , and obtain @xmath282 and @xmath283 according to @xmath284 , @xmath24 update @xmath285 according to @xmath278 , @xmath282 , @xmath283 , and @xmath228 ' '' '' in this section , we investigate heuristic algorithms to solve problems @xmath145 and @xmath146 in a completely distributed fashion . note that different from the paradigm of _ distributed optimization _ that allows for certain amount of information exchange based on which iterative algorithms are developed to gradually improve the system performance , we herein assume that each individual relay can only make decision based on its local csis , namely , @xmath34 , @xmath286 , @xmath287 , @xmath24 , and there is no extra means of information acquisition for ease of implementation . the purpose for such an algorithm is twofold : on one hand , we aim to answer the question that in the least favourable situation , namely , no coordination over the relays , how to improve the achievable secrecy rate of the system ? on the other hand , it provides a lower - bound for the centralized schemes proposed in section [ sec : centralized ] , which sheds light upon the trade - off achievable between secrecy performance and complexity . besides , we emphasize the jamming scheme that is different from the cj in the centralized schemes . unlike the cj signal coordinately transmitted by all relays , in the distributed implementation , each relay is only able to generate its an locally , i.e. , @xmath288^t$ ] , in which @xmath289 s are i.i.d . an beams , denoted by @xmath290 . this type of cj is known to be uncoordinated with the covariance matrix given by @xmath291)$ ] . in this section , we assume that each relay consumes all of its remaining power from af for an , i.e. , @xmath292 , @xmath166 ( c.f . ) . hence , the an design solely depends on @xmath22 s and/or @xmath112 s . first , we propose a heuristic scheme for the @xmath11th af relay to decide on @xmath112 , @xmath24 , which is given by @xmath293 where @xmath294 is a constant controlling the relay s level of jamming . for example , a larger @xmath295 indicates that each relay prefers to splitting a larger portion of power for jamming and vice versa . the intuition behind is that if the @xmath11th relay observes that @xmath296 , which means that a nonnegative secrecy rate is achievable even if there is only itself in the system , it will shut down the an ; otherwise , it will split up to @xmath295 portion of the harvested power for jamming . in an extreme case of @xmath297 , probably when an eve is located within the very proximity of this relay , it allocates the maximum permissible portion of power , i.e. , @xmath295 , for an . next , since an individual relay can not evaluate the secrecy performance of the whole system , @xmath44 s are simply chosen to be the optimum for the multi - af relaying without security considerations , i.e. , @xmath298 , @xmath24 . following the same designs for @xmath112 s and @xmath44 s in section [ sec : distributed alg . for sps ] , the remaining task for weh - enabled relays operating with dps is to set proper values for @xmath22 s . we choose @xmath22 s that maximize the `` hypothetical sinr '' . this `` hypothetical '' sinr may not be the actual sinr for the destination , but just a criterion calculated based on the `` hypothetical '' received signal seen by the @xmath11th relay , given by @xmath299 the corresponding sinr is thus expressed as @xmath300 where @xmath301 . consequently , the maximization of w.r.t . @xmath22 , @xmath24 , is formulated as @xmath302 the optimal @xmath22 , @xmath24 , to @xmath303 is @xmath304[prop : optimal alpha to distr ] it is easy to verify that problem @xmath303 is convex and the minimum solution of its objective function derived from the first - order derivative happens to fall within the feasible region of @xmath22 , which is seen in . with @xmath112 s , @xmath44 s and @xmath22 s set , each af relay is then able to decide its relay weight and an transmission . in this section we compare our proposed schemes operating with sps or dps with some benchmarks . in the centralized case , the optimal solution for sps in section [ sec : optimal solutions for sps ] is denoted by _ cj - sps _ , while algorithm [ table : algorithm i ] in section [ sec : proposed solutions for dps ] is denoted by _ cj - dps_. the distributed schemes in section [ sec : distributed alg . for sps ] and section [ sec : distributed alg . for dps ] are referred to as _ distributed - sps _ and _ distributed - dps _ , respectively . to demonstrate the effectiveness of our an - aided secure multi - af relay beamforming algorithms , we also provide three benchmark schemes : _ nocj - sps _ , _ nocj - dps _ and _ random ps_. for _ nocj - sps _ , we solve problem @xmath145 by replacing @xmath47 with @xmath305 . similarly , for _ nocj - dps _ , we initialize @xmath306 and quit the loop in algorithm [ table : algorithm i ] after the very first time of solving problem @xmath221 . _ random ps _ , on the other hand , picks up i.i.d . @xmath22 and @xmath112 uniformly generated over @xmath307 $ ] , respectively , and co - phases @xmath308 , @xmath24 . consider that @xmath19 weh - enabled af relays and @xmath309 eavesdroppers are located within a circular area of radius @xmath310 . specifically , we assume that their respective radius and radian are drawn from uniform distributions over the interval @xmath311 $ ] and @xmath312 , respectively . we also assume that the channel models consist of both large - scale path loss and small - scale multi - path fading . the unified path loss model is given by @xmath313 where @xmath314 , @xmath315 denotes the relevant distance , @xmath316 m is a reference distance , and @xmath317 is the path loss exponent set to be @xmath318 . @xmath34 , @xmath286 , and @xmath319 , @xmath166 , @xmath133 , are generated from independent rayleigh fading with zero mean and variance specified by . the simulation parameters are set as follows unless otherwise specified : the radius defining the range is @xmath320 m ; the transmit power at the source is @xmath321dbm ; the noise variances are set as @xmath322dbm , @xmath323dbm , @xmath324 , and @xmath325 , @xmath93 ; the eh efficiency is set to @xmath326 . also , numerical results were averages over @xmath327 independent channel realizations . here , we evaluate the performance of the proposed centralized designs in section [ sec : centralized ] . the efficiency of the alternating optimization that iteratively attains numerical solution to @xmath146 is studied in fig . [ fig : alternating sec vs iter ] , which shows the increment of the achievable secrecy rate after each round of the iteration . the most rapid increase is observed after the first iteration , which illustrates that the optimization of the ps ratios , @xmath22 s , accounts for the main factor for the secrecy rate performance gains over a sps scheme that sets @xmath328 . it is seen that the alternating algorithm converges within the relative tolerance set to be @xmath329 , after an average of @xmath330@xmath331 iterations for several channel realizations , which appears reasonable in terms of complexity . dbm , @xmath332 , and @xmath333.,width=288 ] fig . [ fig : centralized compare vs n ] shows the achievable secrecy rate for the legitimate rx with the increase in the number of af relays by different schemes . as we can see , the secure multi - af relaying schemes assisted by the transmission of an outperforms that without an for both sps and dps . in addition , with the increase in @xmath19 , the role of cj gradually reduces for both schemes of sps and dps this is because as @xmath19 gets larger , the optimal designs tend to suppress the interception at the most capable eavesdropper more effectively with @xmath19 dof , enforcing the numerator of @xmath334 to a relatively low level , which can also be observed from @xmath335 in fig . [ fig : subfig : eve s rate vs n ] , and therefore the optimal amount of power allocated to an beams inclines to be little ; otherwise the jamming yielded will be detrimental to the reception at the legitimate rx . besides , given the same number of af relays , the secrecy performance gains brought by the proposed schemes with cj are more prominent in the presence of more eavesdroppers , since it is hard to reduce all the eavesdroppers channel capacity without resorting to cj properly . db for @xmath332 and @xmath336 , respectively.,width=288 ] fig . [ fig : centralized compare sec vs eves ] shows the achievable secrecy rate for the legitimate rx versus the number of eavesdroppers by different schemes . first , similar to the results shown in fig . [ fig : centralized compare vs n ] , the proposed an - aided multi - af relaying designs operating with dps - enabled relays , viz _ cj - dps _ , perform best among all the schemes . secondly , as @xmath309 goes up , the an - aided schemes , _ cj - dps _ and _ cj - sps _ , allow the secrecy rate to drop slowly , in other words , more robust against multiple eavesdroppers , while the secrecy rate of their nocj counterparts almost goes down linearly with @xmath309 . furthermore , with @xmath309 increasing , for example , more than @xmath337 , the increase in the number of relays , from @xmath332 to @xmath338 , can not replace the role of cj as shown in fig . [ fig : centralized compare vs n ] and [ fig : centralized compare sec vs eves ] , since in the presence of many eavesdroppers , more relays may also result in improved eavesdroppers decoding ability w / o the assistance of cj . it is also noteworthy that with @xmath339 , there is little use of cj by the centralized schemes , which was also observed in @xcite . for @xmath332 and @xmath336 , respectively.,width=288 ] [ fig : centralized compare sec vs ps ] provides simulation results of different schemes by varying the source transmit power . it is seen that with more power available at the source , the advantage of cj is more pronounced , since given other variables fixed , larger @xmath35 indicates larger feasible regions for @xmath145 and @xmath146 . furthermore , as similarly seen in fig . [ fig : centralized compare vs n ] , with a mild number of eavesdroppers ( @xmath333 ) , subject to the same @xmath35 , a large number of cooperative relays enables more dof in designing the optimal @xmath22 s and @xmath44 s , which alleviates the dependence on an beams to combat eves . here , we study the performance of the distributed schemes , namely , _ distributed - sps _ and _ distributed - dps _ in section [ sec : distributed ] . as mentioned earlier , these heuristics are provided as benchmarks to demonstrate what can be done under the extreme `` no - coordination '' circumstance , in comparison with _ random ps_. note that any other distributed schemes with certain level of cooperation among relays are supposed to increase the secrecy performance up to the proposed centralized algorithms , namely , _ cj - dps _ and _ cj - sps _ , at the expense of extra computational complexity and system overhead . db and @xmath333.,width=288 ] fig . [ fig : distributed compare sec vs n ] provides the results for the achievable secrecy rate of various schemes versus the number of relays . _ distributed - sps _ and _ distributed - dps _ , are observed to be outperformed by their centralized counterparts though , they are considerably superior to _ random ps_. it is also seen that the performance gap between the centralized and distributed approaches is enlarged as @xmath19 increases , which is expected , since larger @xmath19 yields more dof for cooperation that is exclusively beneficial for the centralized schemes . furthermore , compared with the centralized schemes , the distributed ones are more vulnerable to the increase in the eavesdroppers number . db and @xmath19=8.,width=288 ] in fig . [ fig : distributed compare sec vs eves ] , we investigate the relationship between the secrecy rate performance and the number of eavesdroppers by different methods . as can be observed , compared with the centralized schemes , the secrecy rates achieved by _ distributed - sps _ and _ distributed - dps _ both reduce more drastically with the increase in @xmath309 due to the lack of effective cooperation . also , the advantage of dps over sps for the distributed schemes is compromised since @xmath22 s are not jointly designed with other parameters . at last , a similar observation has been made as that for fig . [ fig : distributed compare sec vs n ] , that is , larger @xmath19 yields more visible performance gap between the centralized and distributed approaches . and @xmath333.,width=288 ] in fig . [ fig : distributed compare sec vs ps ] , we examine the effect of increasing the transmit power at the source on the secrecy performance of different schemes under the same settings as those in fig . [ fig : centralized compare sec vs ps ] . among all the presented designs , _ cj - dps _ still achieves the best secrecy rate as observed in other examples . also , the fact that larger @xmath19 benefits more from cooperative designs is corroborated again due to the same reason as that for fig . [ fig : distributed compare sec vs n ] and [ fig : distributed compare sec vs eves ] . furthermore , the secrecy rate of _ distributed - sps _ or _ distributed - dps _ is quickly saturated when @xmath340db while that for their centralized counterparts still rises at fast speed . this paper studied secure communications using multiple single - antenna weh - enabled af relays assisted by an via cj for a swipt network with multiple single - antenna eavesdroppers . using ps at the relays , the achievable secrecy rates for the relay wiretap channel were maximized by jointly optimizing the cb and the cj covariance matrix along with the ps ratios for relays operating with , respectively , sps and dps . for dps , reformulating the constraints into restricted hyperbolic forms enabled us to develop convex optimization - based solutions . further , we proposed an information - exchange - free distributed algorithm that outperforms the random decision . as the optimal solution to @xmath177 is proved to be optimal to problem @xmath154 , the optimum value for @xmath177 is @xmath341 . hence , we identify the property of @xmath160 by investigating @xmath177 , with its lagrangian given by @xmath342 where @xmath343 denotes a tuple consisting of all the primal and dual variables . specifically , @xmath344 , @xmath345 and @xmath346 are lagrangian multipliers associated with @xmath347 , @xmath348 and the first constraint of @xmath177 , respectively ; @xmath349 are the dual variables associated with the sinr constraint for the @xmath86th eve , respectively ; @xmath350_{i=1}^n)$ ] with each diagonal entry @xmath351 denoting the dual variable associated with the per - relay power constraint ; @xmath352 is the lagrangian multiplier associated with @xmath353 . in addition , @xmath354_{i=1}^n)$ ] . the karush - kuhn - tucker ( kkt ) conditions for are partially listed as follows : the associated dual problem is accordingly given by @xmath356 where @xmath344 , @xmath345 , and @xmath352 are given by , respectively . since it is easily verified that @xmath177 satisfies the slater condition , the strong duality holds @xcite . this implies that the dual optimum value in @xmath357 is @xmath160 , which turns out to be a point - wise minimum of a family of affine functions and thus concave over @xmath159 $ ] @xcite . pre- and post - multiplying @xmath359 with the left hand side ( lhs ) and right hand side ( rhs ) of , respectively , and substituting @xmath360 into , @xmath361 can be rewritten as @xmath362 introducing the notation of @xmath5_{\rm offd}$ ] to represent a square matrix with its diagonal entries removed , it follows from that @xmath363_{\rm offd}=\boldsymbol 0.\ ] ] by subtracting from , @xmath344 can be rewritten as @xmath364_{\rm d}\notag\\ & + \left[\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\boldsymbol y_2\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\right]_{\rm d}+\sum_{k=1}^k\theta_k p_s\tilde{\boldsymbol h}_{se , k}^\dag\tilde{\boldsymbol h}_{se , k}^t,\label{eq : y1 intermediate2}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath5_{\rm d}$ ] denotes a square matrix with only the diagonal remained . observing that @xmath365_{\rm d}^{-1}\left[\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\boldsymbol h_{re , k}^\dag\boldsymbol h_{re , k}^t\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\right]_{\rm d}\nonumber\\ & = { \rm diag}\left([|h_{r_ie , k}|^2\left.\middle/\right.|h_{r_id}|^2]_{i=1}^n\right)\notag\\ & \equiv \boldsymbol r_{ed , k},\label{eq : r_{ed , k}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] @xmath361 can be finally recast as @xmath366 where @xmath367_{\rm d}-\left(\left[\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\boldsymbol h_{rd}^\dag\boldsymbol h_{rd}^t\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\right]_{\rm d}-\boldsymbol d_{\hat{sd}}\right ) \left(\lambda\boldsymbol i-\sum_{k=1}^k\theta_k\left(\frac{1}{\tau}-1\right)\boldsymbol r_{ed , k}\right).\end{aligned}\ ] ] in the following , we show that @xmath368 is a positive definite matrix . note that since @xmath369 is a diagonal matrix , its definiteness is only determined by the signs of its diagonal entries , for which we commence with the discussion in three difference cases below . 1 . * case i * : @xmath370 such that @xmath371_{i , i}<0 $ ] . since @xmath372_{\rm d}-\boldsymbol d_{\hat{sd}}\right]_{i , i}=$ ] + @xmath373 , it follows from that @xmath374_{i , i}>0 $ ] in this case . * case ii * : @xmath370 such that @xmath371_{i , i}>0 $ ] . we have @xmath375_{\rm d}\right]_{i , i}-[\boldsymbol w_0]_{i , i}\vert h_{r_id}\vert^2(\lambda^\ast-\sum_{k=1}^k\theta_k\left(\frac{1}{\tau}-1\right)[\boldsymbol r_{ed , k}]_{i , i})\ge 0 $ ] in accordance with , which implies that @xmath374_{i , i}=\left[\left[\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\boldsymbol y_2\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\right]_{\rm d}\right]_{i , i}-[\boldsymbol w_0]_{i , i}\vert h_{r_id}\vert^2(\lambda-\sum_{k=1}^k\theta_k\left(\frac{1}{\tau}-1\right)[\boldsymbol r_{ed , k}]_{i , i})+[\boldsymbol d_{\hat{sd}}]_{i , i}(\lambda-\sum_{k=1}^k\theta_k\left(\frac{1}{\tau}-1\right)[\boldsymbol r_{ed , k}]_{i , i})>0 $ ] ( c.f . ) . * case iii * : @xmath370 such that @xmath371_{i , i}=0 $ ] . in this case , it follows that @xmath374_{i , i}= \left[\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\boldsymbol y_2\boldsymbol w_0^{\frac{1}{2}}\right]_{i , i}$ ] + @xmath376 . it is noteworthy that the number of @xmath11 s such that @xmath371_{i , i}=0 $ ] can not exceed one . this can be proved by contradiction as follows . if @xmath377 , @xmath378 , such that @xmath371_{i_1,i_1}=0 $ ] and @xmath371_{i_2,i_2}=0 $ ] , it implies that @xmath379_{i_1,i_1}=\sum_{k=1}^k\theta_k[\boldsymbol r_{ed , k}]_{i_2,i_2}$ ] , which contradicts to the fact that for any two independent continuously distributed random variables , the chance that they are equal is zero . in summary , @xmath374_{i , i}\ge 0 $ ] , @xmath24 . if @xmath374_{i , i } > 0 $ ] , then it is obvious that @xmath380 . next , we show that it still holds true in the case that @xmath381 , such that @xmath374_{i^\prime , i^\prime}=0 $ ] , @xmath382 , by definition . define the null - space of @xmath369 by @xmath383 and multiply @xmath384 and @xmath385 , @xmath386 , on the lhs and rhs of @xmath368 , respectively . if @xmath387 , it is straightforward to obtain @xmath388 ; otherwise , it follows that @xmath389_{i^\prime}\vert^2>0 $ ] , as @xmath390_{i^\prime}\neq 0 $ ] in probability . this completes the proof . as a result , @xmath344 in is shown to always take on a special structure , that is , a full - rank matrix minus a rank - one matrix . note that this observation plays a key role in proving the rank - one property of @xmath391 , which is also identified in ( * ? ? ? * appendix c ) . finally , multiplying both sides of by @xmath391 , as per , we obtain the following equation : @xmath393 which further implies that @xmath394 . in addition , since the optimality of @xmath177 suggests that @xmath395 , @xmath396 is thus proved . as @xmath391 can be decomposed as @xmath397 by evd , results in @xmath398 , which further implies that @xmath399 therefore , admits a unique solution @xmath182 up to a scaling factor , which is given by @xmath400 consequently , we have @xmath401 , where @xmath402 . on the other hand , by plugging @xmath401 into the equality constraint of @xmath177 , we have @xmath403 , which yields @xmath404 at last , we show @xmath405 of proposition [ prop : rank - one solution with cj for sps ] . for the case of @xmath406 , it is obvious that @xmath407 . for the case of @xmath408 , only a sketch of the proof is provided here due to the length constraint . according to , first it is provable that @xmath409 is a full - rank matrix when @xmath177 obtains its optimum value ; next , observing that @xmath410 , it follows that @xmath411 as a result of @xmath412 ; then according to , @xmath413 is thus obtained . for convenience of the proof , the optimum value for @xmath237 and @xmath415 are denoted by @xmath416 and @xmath417 , respectively . assuming that @xmath418 is the optimal solution to @xmath237 , it is easily verified to be feasible for @xmath415 as well , which implies that @xmath419 . on the other hand , if @xmath415 returns an optimal solution of @xmath420 , by defining @xmath421 and @xmath422 , @xmath24 , we show that @xmath423 is also feasible for @xmath237 as follows . as for , @xmath424 where @xmath163 is due to , and @xmath164 comes from @xmath425 and @xmath426 . similarly , @xmath427 + @xmath428 can be proved to satisfy as well . in addition , @xmath429 , @xmath24 , i.e. , holds true . these feasibility implies that @xmath430 . by combining the above two facts , we have @xmath431 and complete the proof . then , we apply the charnes - cooper transformation again to @xmath415 , the result of which is denoted by @xmath432 , to study the property of @xmath433 and @xmath250 . it is noteworthy that the charnes - cooper transformed constraint of admits the form given by @xmath434 , @xmath24 , where @xmath435 is the column vector inside @xmath7 of the lhs of and @xmath436 indicates the rhs expression . since it is easily checked that @xmath437 as a result of feasibility , we have @xmath438 , which implies that @xmath439 according to schur complement . it thus follows that holds true , @xmath440 : @xmath434 . as such , we can show that can be recast into a constraint without @xmath441 , i.e. , not related to @xmath442 , @xmath443 , following the same procedure as ( * ? ? ? * appendix iii ) by exploiting ( * ? ? ? * _ lemma 2 _ ) . similarly , the charnes - cooper transformed constraint of can also be rewritten without @xmath442 , @xmath443 . hence , the partial lagrangian for @xmath432 in terms of @xmath442 and @xmath443 can be expressed as ( [ eq : lagrangian of ( p2.1-sdp - eqv ) ] ) ( see top of next page ) , where @xmath445 denotes a tuple comprising all the associated primal and dual variables : @xmath344 , @xmath345 , and @xmath349 are lagrangian multipliers associated with @xmath442 , @xmath443 , and , @xmath93 , respectively ; @xmath346 is the dual variable associated with the only equality constraint ; @xmath446_{i=1}^n)$ ] and @xmath447_{i=1}^n)$ ] denote those associated with @xmath448 and @xmath449 , @xmath24 , respectively ; finally , the diagonal entry of @xmath450_{i=1}^n)$ ] denotes the dual variable associated with @xmath451 , @xmath24 . the kkt conditions related to are accordingly given by 1 . * case i * : @xmath456 , @xmath133 . in this case , since @xmath457 ( c.f . ) due to the strong duality , it is easily verified that @xmath458 and therefore @xmath459 . * case ii * : @xmath460 such that @xmath461 . according to , @xmath462 , which is a positive semidefinite diagonal matrix . according to the similar argument made in * case iii * of appendix [ appendix : proof of rank - one solution with cj for sps ] , it is thus shown that @xmath249 has maximum one zero diagonal entry and the positive definiteness of @xmath463 can be proved by definition without difficulty . as @xmath344 ( c.f . ) again complies with the difference between a positive definite matrix and a rank one matrix , i.e. , @xmath464 , it turns out that @xmath465 according to . then , following the same procedure as that in appendix [ appendix : proof of rank - one solution with cj for sps ] , @xmath466 of proposition [ prop : rank - one solution with cj for dps ] can be proved ( details omitted for brevity ) . finally , it is verified that @xmath238 is related to @xmath250 merely with its diagonal entries , viz @xmath467_{i , i}$ ] , @xmath166 , ( c.f . , ) . furthermore , denoting @xmath468_{i , i}^{1/2}]_{i=1}^n$ ] by @xmath251 , it is easily checked that the diagonal entries remain the same after we replace @xmath250 with @xmath252 . combining the above two facts , we arrive at the conclusion that such modification does not affect its optimality while returning a rank - one @xmath250 for @xmath238 , which completes the proof for @xmath405 . e. tekin , s. member , and a. yener , `` the general gaussian multiple - access and two - way wiretap channels : achievable rates and cooperative jamming , '' _ ieee trans . inf . theory _ 54 , no . 6 , pp . 27352751 , jun . 2008 . j. zhang , m. c. gursoy , `` relay beamforming strategies for physical - layer security , '' in _ proc . ieee annual conference on information sciences and systems ( ciss10 ) _ , princeton , usa , mar . 2010 , pp.16 . y. yang , q. li , w .- k . ma , j. ge , and p. c. ching , `` cooperative secure beamforming for af relay networks with multiple eavesdroppers , '' _ ieee signal process . 1 , pp . 3538 , jan . 2013 . h. xing , k .- k wong , z. chu , and a. nallanathan , `` to harvest and jam : a paradigm of self - sustaining friendly jammers for secure af relaying , '' _ to appear in ieee trans . signal process . _ , available on - line at arxiv:1502.07066v3 . z. ding , k. k. leung , d. l. goeckel , and d. towsley , `` opportunistic relaying for secrecy communications : cooperative jamming vs. relay chatting , '' _ ieee trans . 10 , no . 6 , pp . 17251729 , jun . 2011 . y. yang , q. li , w .- k . ma , j. ge , and m. lin , `` optimal joint cooperative beamforming and artificial noise design for secrecy rate maximization in af relay networks , '' in _ proc . ieee workshop on signal processing advances in wireless communications ( spawc ) _ , darmstadt , de , jun . 2013 , pp.360364 . q. li , y. yang , w .- k . ma , m. lin , j. ge , and j. lin , robust cooperative beamforming and artificial noise design for physical - layer secrecy in af multi - antenna multi - relay networks , " _ ieee trans . signal process . 1 , pp . 206220 , jan . k. ishibashi , `` dynamic harvest - and - forward : new cooperative diversity with rf energy harvesting , '' in _ proc . ieee international conference on wireless communications and signal processing ( wcsp ) _ , hefei , cn , oct . 2014 , pp . 15 . a. nasir , x. zhou , s. durrani , and r. kennedy , `` relaying protocols for wireless energy harvesting and information processing , '' _ ieee trans.wireless commun . 36223636 , jul . z. ding , s. perlaza , i. esnaola , and h. poor , `` power allocation strategies in energy harvesting wireless cooperative networks , '' _ ieee trans . wireless commun . _ , vol . 13 , no . 2 , pp . 846860 , feb . 2014 . s. timotheou , i. krikidis , g. zheng , and b. ottersten , `` beamforming for miso interference channels with qos and rf energy transfer , '' _ ieee trans . wireless commun . _ , vol.13 , no.5 , pp . 26462658 , may 2014 . m. zhao , x. wang , and s. feng , `` joint power splitting and secure beamforming design in the multiple non - regenerative wireless - powered relay networks , '' _ ieee commun . 9 , pp . 15401543 , sept . 2015 . d. ng , e. lo , and r. schober , `` robust beamforming for secure communication in systems with wireless information and power transfer , '' _ ieee trans . wireless commun . _ , vol . 13 , no . 8 , pp 45994615 , aug . 2014 . q. li , q. zhang , and j. qin , `` secure relay beamforming for simultaneous wireless information and power transfer in non - regenerative relay networks , '' _ ieee trans . 5 , pp . 24622467 , jun . 2014 . q. li and w .- k . ma , `` spatially selective artificial - noise aided transmit optimization for miso multi - eves secrecy rate maximization , '' _ ieee trans . signal process . 27042717 , may 2013 .
Abstract: | [
"this paper studies secrecy transmission with the aid of a group of wireless energy harvesting ( weh)-enabled amplify - and - forward ( af ) relays performing cooperative jamming ( cj ) and relaying . the source node in the network does _ simultaneous wireless information and power transfer ( swipt ) _ with each relay employing a power splitting ( ps ) receiver in the first phase ; each relay further divides its harvested power for forwarding the received signal and generating artificial noise ( an ) for jamming the eavesdroppers in the second transmission phase . in the centralized case with global channel state information ( csi ) , we provide closed - form expressions for the optimal and/or suboptimal af - relay beamforming vectors to maximize the achievable secrecy rate subject to individual power constraints of the relays , using the technique of semidefinite relaxation ( sdr ) , which is proved to be tight . a fully _ distributed _ algorithm utilizing only local csi at each relay is also proposed as a performance benchmark . simulation results validate the effectiveness of the proposed multi - af relaying with cj over other suboptimal designs . artificial noise , cooperative jamming , amplify - and - forward relaying , secrecy communication , semidefinite relaxation , wireless energy harvesting . [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ] [ proposition ] [ section ] [ section ] [ section ]"
] | 9,590 | 9,590 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: over the past few years , the increasingly stronger exclusion limits set by the large hadron collider ( lhc ) on colored top partners have put significant pressure on the classic solutions to the hierarchy problem . the absence of beyond - the - standard model ( bsm ) signals has , at the same time , sparked a renewed interest in models of neutral naturalness , where the top partners do not carry standard model ( sm ) color charge . the prime example in this class is the twin higgs ( th ) model @xcite , where the top and gauge partners are complete singlets under the sm , and the sensitivity to ultraviolet ( uv ) scales is softened thanks to a discrete @xmath2 symmetry . by construction , the collider phenomenology of the lowest - lying states in th is very challenging , and rare decays of the higgs into long - lived twin particles typically constitute the most promising signatures @xcite . however , these signals display a strong sensitivity to the unknown parameters of the model that limits to some extent their robustness . for example , in the fraternal th model @xcite , where only the third generation of twin particles is introduced to avoid the cosmological problems associated with light degrees of freedom , the lightest twin glueball can be long - lived . it decays into sm particles through mixing with the higgs , with a width proportional to @xmath6 , where @xmath7 is the confinement scale of twin qcd . as a consequence , the twin glueball displaced decays are observable at the lhc only in a relatively narrow range of twin confinement scales , while naturalness considerations allow a wider uncertainty on @xmath7 . on the other hand , a robust deviation from the sm is provided by higgs couplings modifications proportional to @xmath8 that arise due to the pseudo - goldstone nature of the higgs , where @xmath9 is the scale of spontaneous @xmath2 breaking and @xmath10 is the electroweak symmetry breaking ( ewsb ) higgs vacuum expectation value ( vev ) . still , the future lhc precision on higgs couplings measurements will be limited to @xmath11-@xmath12 @xcite . altogether , these considerations suggest that it is not inconceivable that the lhc may remain blind to a th model with @xmath13 tev . the low - energy theory of th , however , requires uv completion at a relatively low scale @xmath14 tev . the extended theory necessarily contains new particles , some of which can give visible signals at colliders . while more model - dependent , these signatures may turn out to be key to the discovery of the model . for example , non - supersymmetric uv completions generically predict the existence of new exotic fermions , charged under both the sm and twin gauge symmetries . these vector - like fermions were already introduced in the original th paper @xcite , to cut off the residual logarithmic divergences in the higgs potential . furthermore , they appear in composite th completions @xcite , where they are resonances of the strong sector , and in uv completions with extra dimensions @xcite , where they are kaluza - klein ( kk ) excitations of bulk fields whose zero modes are removed through boundary conditions or orbifold projections . some of these fermions carry sm color ( as well as twin electroweak ) charge and can therefore be produced with large rates at the lhc or at a future @xmath15 tev collider , depending on their masses . the phenomenology of these ` exotic quarks ' was presented in ref . @xcite , where it was shown that future searches for their signals can test large regions of the parameter space of the fraternal th . in this paper we explore the phenomenology of other states that can be expected to accompany the exotic quarks ( which were labeled by @xmath16 in ref . @xcite ) , in a non - supersymmetric uv completion of th . we focus primarily on the mirror partners of the exotic quarks , which are vector - like ` exotic fermions ' that carry twin color and sm electroweak charges ( labeled by @xmath17 in ref . in addition we consider exotic vector particles , including both bifundamentals under @xmath18 , where @xmath19 and @xmath20 denote the sm and twin weak groups , respectively , and bifundamentals under the color symmetries @xmath21 . the electroweak bifundamentals , which we label @xmath22 , are necessary to restore at high energy the @xmath23 ( or @xmath24 ) symmetry that protects the pseudo - goldstone higgs . on the other hand , the @xmath25 bifundamentals , dubbed @xmath26 , appear in models where the sm and twin color groups are embedded into an @xmath27 symmetry . this is not strictly required for a consistent uv completion , so the presence of @xmath26 is somewhat more model - dependent . as discussed in ref . @xcite , stop searches based on @xmath28 plus missing transverse energy ( met ) constitute a robust probe of the exotic quarks . given the absence of any signals in the first @xmath29 fb@xmath30 of data collected by each of atlas and cms at @xmath31 tev , we estimate that the current lower bound on the vector - like mass of the @xmath16 is approximately @xmath32 tev . if the masses of the exotic fermions respect the @xmath2 symmetry , as we assume in the first part of this paper , the same lower bound applies to @xmath33 , the mass of the @xmath17 . as a consequence the uncolored exotic fermions have a very suppressed electroweak pair - production , even at a @xmath15 tev collider . on the other hand , if the colored exotic vector @xmath26 is heavier than the exotic fermions , its decays can provide a sizable production rate for the @xmath17 . we sketch the corresponding phenomenology , finding that it is qualitatively similar to that of the exotic quarks : the most promising signature is @xmath34 , accompanied either by large missing transverse energy ( met ) or by the displaced decay of a twin particle @xcite . we find that the best strategy to pin down the presence of the @xmath26 and @xmath17 would be to require an additional @xmath5 boson in the final state , since this is generated very rarely in the decays of the exotic quarks . we also outline the phenomenology of the electroweak bifundamental vectors , showing that some of them can mix with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and therefore be singly produced in the drell - yan process . on the other hand , we find that the @xmath35 parameter of electroweak precision tests ( ewpt ) requires their masses to be at least @xmath36 tev , implying that they are likely out of the lhc reach , but may be discovered at a @xmath15 tev collider . notice that from a phenomenological perspective , @xmath37 is independent from @xmath33 . furthermore , @xmath38 breaks the @xmath2 only softly , thus preserving the cancellation of @xmath39-loop quadratic divergences in the higgs mass . since @xmath40 only couples to the sm through the electroweak interactions , the experimental constraints still allow it to be relatively light . it is therefore logical to analyze the region of parameter space where @xmath41 , to which the second part of this paper is devoted . we find that for @xmath33 in the few hundred gev range , one of the exotic fermions , @xmath42 , naturally has a very suppressed decay width . this implies that once produced through the electroweak interactions , @xmath43 pairs form bound states held together by the twin strong force , which eventually annihilate back to the sm . we study in detail the associated resonance signals , which provide a novel phenomenological aspect of th models . in addition , we consider the significant effects that a relatively light color bifundamental vector may have on the bound state decays . a light @xmath26 is expected to be accompanied by a light excited gluon ( for which we will use the name ` kk gluon ' in analogy to an extra - dimensional model ) in realistic models , so for completeness , we also summarize the main constraints on the kk gluon . finally , we inspect closely the consequences on naturalness of the @xmath2-breaking exotic fermion masses . while the @xmath39-loop effects are mild , we identify a @xmath44-loop quadratically divergent contribution to the higgs mass that can be important for light @xmath26 . the remainder of the paper is organized as follows . in sec . [ exoparticles ] we introduce the exotic states that are the subject of this paper . for concreteness we do this in the context of a two - site model , which provides a convenient minimal description , but many of our results are general , and also apply to more elaborate constructions . section [ z2preserve_pheno ] presents the phenomenology of the scenario where the exotic fermion masses respect the @xmath2 symmetry . in [ subs pheno:1 ] we compute the pair - production cross section of the color bifundamental vector , and estimate the main signals arising from cascade decays that involve the @xmath17 . the salient properties of the weak bifundamental vectors are discussed in [ subs pheno:2 ] . section [ z2break ] contains the discussion of the @xmath2-breaking scenario , which gives the main novel results of our paper . the phenomenology of @xmath45 bound states is studied in [ subs z2break:1 ] , whereas [ subs z2break:2 ] focuses on the bound states containing the @xmath46 partner of @xmath42 , whose signals are more model - dependent . in [ subs z2break:3 ] we discuss the effects of a light @xmath26 on the bound state physics , and in [ subs z2break:4 ] we summarize the main properties of the kk gluon , which is expected to have a mass comparable to that of @xmath26 . to conclude the section , the consequences on naturalness of the @xmath2 breaking in the exotic fermion masses are presented in [ subs z2break:5 ] . finally , our conclusions are drawn in sec . [ conclusions ] . for the sake of completeness , the detailed construction of a two - site model for the electroweak sector is given in app . [ su4exo ] . appendix [ so8exo ] contains some details about the additional states that appear if the global symmetry of the th is extended from @xmath23 to @xmath24 , which ensures custodial protection of the @xmath47 parameter . the phenomenologies of the new exotic states are qualitatively similar to the ones already considered . the simplest way to introduce the exotic fermions is to follow the approach of the original th paper @xcite , where the symmetries of the top yukawa were extended to @xmath48 . adopting the notation of ref . @xcite , where in particular the sm @xmath46 is embedded in the lower right corner of @xmath23 , we have @xmath49 where @xmath50 , @xmath51 and @xmath52 . the color and twin color gauge groups are embedded in the diagonal of @xmath27 . the ` exotic ' fermion doublets @xmath53 and @xmath54 are given vector - like masses , @xmath55 if the masses in eq . respect the @xmath2 symmetry , then @xmath56 cuts off the logarithmic divergences in the higgs potential arising from eqs . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) , ( [ eq : mass ] ) , leaving a finite and calculable result . in this paper we also consider the @xmath2-breaking scenario @xmath38 , in which case the residual logarithmic divergences need to be cut off by additional states with larger , @xmath2-symmetric masses . the phenomenology of the states belonging to @xmath57 , which carry sm color and twin electroweak charges , was extensively discussed in ref . @xcite . inserting in eq . the expression of the higgs field in the unitary gauge , @xmath58 leads to the mass mixing of the up - type component @xmath59 with the top quark , and the corresponding heavy mass eigenstate was labeled @xmath60 . the down - type component does not mix , and was labeled @xmath61 . these exotic quarks are pair - produced through qcd and decay into sm tops plus twin gauge bosons @xmath62 ( henceforth we denote the twin partners of the sm particles with a hat ) , followed by the decay of the twin gauge bosons into twin fermions . thus the ` irreducible ' signal of the exotic quarks is @xmath28+met , where the twin particles escape detection . in addition , depending on the parameters in the twin sector , some of the twin particles produced in the cascade can decay back to the sm with long lifetimes , giving rise to @xmath28+displaced vertex signatures . for example , the decay @xmath63 is followed by twin hadronization , and some of the resulting twin bottomonia or twin glueballs can have macroscopic lifetimes . the twin leptons that arise from the decay of @xmath64 can also give displaced signals , through mixing with the sm neutrinos . the reach of the searches for these exotic signatures extends above @xmath44 tev at the lhc and above @xmath1 tev at a future @xmath15 tev collider , often surpassing that of the searches for stop - like signals based on large met @xcite . notice that the mass mixing between @xmath59 and the top quark implies the theoretical lower bound @xcite @xmath65 in addition , we estimate that stop searches currently set an experimental lower bound @xmath66 in this paper we focus instead on the fermions contained in @xmath17 , which carry twin color and sm electroweak charges and whose phenomenology was so far unexplored . in a uv completion , it is also plausible that new vector particles exist , that allow for the restoration of the full @xmath67 $ ] symmetry at high energies . for @xmath27 , the new states include ` exotic vectors ' which transform as the bifundamental representation of @xmath21 , denoted by @xmath68 in this work , as well as the excited state of the gluon ( labeled @xmath69 ) and that of the twin gluon . for @xmath23 , among the new vectors we expect exotics which transform as the bifundamental of @xmath70 , denoted by @xmath71 , in addition to excitations of the sm and twin gauge bosons . all these particles can be described , for example , in a two - site model . on one site , there is a full @xmath72 gauge symmetry . all the fields in eq . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) live on this site , so the yukawa interaction respects the symmetry . on the second site , only @xmath73 is gauged . all the light sm and twin fermions , as well as the right - handed exotic fermions @xmath74 , live on this second site . the gauge symmetries on the two sites are broken down to the diagonal subgroup by the vevs of link fields , which also generate the mass terms for the exotic fermions in eq . . for a strongly coupled uv completion , the first site can be viewed as the hidden local symmetry from the strong dynamics @xcite . its gauge coupling , which we denote @xmath75 for @xmath27 and @xmath76 for @xmath23 , is expected to be very large and the particles living on that site are composite degrees of freedom of the strong dynamics . the second site represents the elementary gauge fields and fermions . the two - site model can also be viewed as a deconstruction @xcite of an extra dimensional model @xcite . the details of the two - site model for @xmath23 are given in app . [ su4exo ] . .quantum numbers of the exotic fields under the sm and twin gauge symmetries . ( @xmath77 is the twin hypercharge . ) the fields in the upper part of the table are dirac fermions , while those in the lower part are complex vectors . [ cols="^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^,^ " , ] in this section we outline the phenomenology of the exotic off - diagonal states , with the exception of the exotic quarks @xmath78 , which were thoroughly studied in ref . the quantum numbers of the particles are collected in table [ tab : charges ] . in this section we assume that the masses of the exotic fermions respect the @xmath2 symmetry . in addition to the mixing of @xmath59 with the sm top quark , the lagrangian in eqs . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) , ( [ eq : mass ] ) yields a mixing of the top - component exotic fermion @xmath79 with the twin top , @xmath80 where @xmath81 . the mixing is diagonalized by the rotations @xmath82 where @xmath83 and @xmath84 are mass eigenstates . for the remainder of this section we assume @xmath85 , so @xmath86 . the mixing angles are given by @xmath87 while the masses read , at first order in @xmath88 , @xmath89 on the other hand , @xmath90 does not mix with any other state . the decays of the @xmath91 can be understood using the goldstone equivalence theorem . plugging the expression of @xmath92 expanded to @xmath93 @xcite into the top yukawa , we find , for @xmath94 , @xmath95 + \mathrm{h.c.},\ ] ] where @xmath96 and @xmath97 are the would - be goldstone bosons eaten by the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , @xmath98 is the physical higgs boson , and @xmath99 corresponds to the longitudinal component of the twin @xmath100 . . shows that the largest decay widths of @xmath84 are those into @xmath101 , with a small component of @xmath102 parametrically suppressed by @xmath8 . the couplings mediating the additional decays @xmath103 and @xmath104 , which are @xmath105 , can not be neglected . notice , however , that since @xmath106 , the latter is actually a @xmath107-body decay . ] the @xmath42 , on the other hand , decays to @xmath108 with unity branching ratio . the theoretical and experimental constraints in eqs . , require @xmath32 tev ( we take @xmath109 tev as benchmark in this paper ) . for a @xmath2-symmetric spectrum this constraint also applies to @xmath33 , implying that the pair production of the @xmath110 via the electroweak interactions is suppressed even at a future @xmath15 tev collider . however , if @xmath111 the decays of the exotic vector @xmath26 can provide a much larger production rate for the uncolored exotic fermions . the @xmath26 is a bifundamental of @xmath21 , therefore it can be pair - produced in the process @xmath112 . the couplings of @xmath26 to the gluons arise from the kinetic lagrangian @xmath113 where the covariant derivative is defined as @xmath114 . here @xmath115 , @xmath116 are the generators in the fundamental of @xmath117 , and twin color indices and interactions are understood but suppressed . notice that the coefficient of the last term in eq . would be arbitrary , if we were only imposing the low - energy @xmath117 gauge symmetry . we have set this coefficient to the value that corresponds to @xmath26 gauging part of the ( spontaneously broken ) extended @xmath27 gauge symmetry in the uv , as in the two - site model . using the couplings derived from eq . , the cross section for pair production of @xmath26 can be readily computed @xmath118 , \label{gg to xx}\ ] ] where @xmath119 and an extra factor of @xmath120 was included , due to the twin color sum . by convoluting with the @xmath121 parton luminosity , we obtain the hadronic cross section shown in fig . [ fig : rrxsec ] . colliders for the exotic vector @xmath26 and kk gluon @xmath122 . in addition , for comparison we show the cross section for a dirac fermion @xmath47 in the fundamental representation of color . all cross sections were computed at lo with factorization and renormalization scales set to @xmath123 , using mstw08lo parton distribution functions ( pdfs ) . the ratio @xmath124 varies between 3.0 and 3.7 for the masses and energies considered . notice that @xmath125 contains the factor @xmath120 resulting from the sum over twin color . the different scaling of @xmath126 with the mass is due to the @xmath127-initiated component.,width=302 ] the @xmath128 also couples , with strength @xmath75 , to the fermions transforming in the fundamental of @xmath27 , namely @xmath129 , @xmath130 and @xmath131 . for example , @xmath132 notice that the exotic vector carries sm electric charge @xmath133 , and twin electric charge @xmath134 . the right - handed bottom quarks @xmath135 and exotic fermions @xmath74 , as well as the fermions of the first two generations , live instead on the @xmath136 site and therefore do not couple directly to the exotic vector . . dictates the decay of the @xmath26 : the main channels are @xmath137 , shown in the top panel of fig . [ fig : spectrum_z2sym ] . in addition , fermion mixings generate a small width for @xmath138 . if @xmath139 , the qcd pair production of @xmath26 followed by the decays @xmath140 provides the largest production mechanism for the @xmath110 . a sketch of the corresponding spectrum is given in the bottom panel of fig . [ fig : spectrum_z2sym ] . on the other hand , if @xmath141 the only kinematically allowed decay of the exotic vector is @xmath142 . under the minimal assumption that the @xmath64 and twin bottom escape undetected , most decay patterns of @xmath143 lead to the @xmath34+met final state , resulting in a ` stop - like ' signal . therefore it would be difficult to distinguish the @xmath26 signal from those of the exotic quarks @xmath60 and @xmath61 , which mostly produce @xmath28+met final states . in addition , it would be challenging to tell the very existence of the exotic fermions @xmath110 . for this purpose the most promising channel seems to be @xmath144 followed by @xmath145 . these decays yield an extra @xmath5 or @xmath98 , resulting in signals with extra jets ( @xmath146-tagged or not ) and/or leptons . among these the @xmath147+jets+met signature is particularly interesting , because it can arise from the exotic quarks only through the suppressed @xmath148 decay @xcite . exotic vector @xmath26 . the superscripts indicate the ( sm , twin ) electric charges . _ bottom panel : _ sketch of the colored spectrum in the @xmath2-preserving case @xmath149 , under the assumption that @xmath150 . the small @xmath151-@xmath60 and @xmath152-@xmath153 mixings are neglected in the color scheme . the mass splittings among the exotic fermions are @xmath154 and @xmath155.,width=453 ] exotic vector @xmath26 . the superscripts indicate the ( sm , twin ) electric charges . _ bottom panel : _ sketch of the colored spectrum in the @xmath2-preserving case @xmath149 , under the assumption that @xmath150 . the small @xmath151-@xmath60 and @xmath152-@xmath153 mixings are neglected in the color scheme . the mass splittings among the exotic fermions are @xmath154 and @xmath155.,width=377 ] the off - diagonal vectors contained in @xmath23 form a bidoublet of @xmath18 , which under the sm electroweak symmetry decomposes into two @xmath156 , @xmath157 and @xmath158 . these particles can be described in a two - site model , where the gauge symmetry on the ` strong ' site is @xmath159 , and on the ` elementary ' site it is @xmath160 ^ 2 $ ] . the symmetries are broken to the diagonal subgroup by the vev of a bifundamental link field @xmath161 , @xmath162 , whereas the higgs @xmath92 in eq . transforms in the fundamental representation of the strong gauge symmetry . this leads to the following masses for the @xmath23 exotic vectors ( see app . [ su4exo ] for details ) @xmath163 where @xmath76 is the gauge coupling on the strong site , and the small corrections due to ewsb were neglected . an experimental lower bound on the masses of the @xmath22 comes from the @xmath35 parameter of ewpt , for which the two - site structure leads to the result @xmath164 requiring @xmath165 implies , choosing for example our benchmark @xmath109 tev and @xmath166 , a lower bound @xmath167 gev , or @xmath168 tev and @xmath169 tev . these can be taken as rough reference for the phenomenology . notice that @xmath23 does not contain the custodial symmetry that protects the @xmath47 parameter , which therefore would receive large corrections at tree level . these in turn would push the scale of the vector resonances much higher : for example , in the limit @xmath170 we find @xmath171 , so requiring that @xmath172 leads to @xmath173 tev . however , this issue can be solved by extending the uv symmetry to @xmath174 @xcite , which guarantees that @xmath175 at tree level . in this case additional states are present both in the gauge and in the fermion sector , to fill multiplets of the larger symmetry . while the new states include some exotic ones , their phenomenology is not expected to be qualitatively different from that discussed here , as explained in app . [ so8exo ] . the real component of @xmath176 , which we dub @xmath177 , and @xmath178 have the right quantum numbers to mix with the sm @xmath5 and @xmath4 , respectively , and therefore can be singly produced at hadron colliders in @xmath179 annihilation . their decays are mediated by the couplings of the @xmath22 to fermions , which arise from the kinetic term of @xmath180 under the @xmath48 symmetry on the strong site . then @xmath181 \quad \to \quad \frac{g_\rho}{\sqrt{2}}(\bar{q}_{3l}^a \slashed{\mathcal{w}}^\dagger \tilde{q}_{3l}^a + \bar{q}_{3l}^b \slashed{\mathcal{w } } \tilde{q}_{3l}^b ) + \mathrm{h.c.}.\ ] ] expanding in components , retaining only couplings of @xmath176 and @xmath178 and rotating to the basis of mass eigenstate fermions , we arrive at @xmath182 + \mathrm{h.c.},\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath183 and @xmath184 are the sine and cosine , respectively , of the mixing angle between the top and the exotic quark @xmath60 @xcite . depending on the relative hierarchy between the masses of the exotic particles , we can envisage two situations : * for @xmath185 , the dominant decays are @xmath186 and @xmath187 . it follows that single production of @xmath176 leads to the @xmath188+met and @xmath189+met final states , whereas single production of @xmath178 leads to @xmath190+met and @xmath191+met ; * for @xmath192 only the direct decays into light states are open , @xmath193 and @xmath194 . the main decays are summarized in fig . [ fig : su4decay ] . . the superscripts indicate the ( sm , twin ) electric charges . ] the lower bound @xmath195 tev from the @xmath35 parameter suggests that these exotic vectors are likely out of the lhc reach , but may be discovered at a future @xmath15 tev collider . on the other hand , the states contained in @xmath196 carry a non - vanishing twin electric charge , therefore their mixing with the sm gauge bosons is proportional to the breaking of the twin @xmath197 , which is more model - dependent . if this breaking is negligible or absent , @xmath196 can only be pair - produced through the electroweak interactions , with very suppressed cross section . notice that in ref . @xcite the limit @xmath198 was considered , corresponds to @xmath9 in the notation of sec . 2.1 of ref . @xcite . ] in which case @xmath199 decouples and only @xmath200 remains in the low - energy spectrum . before concluding this section , we wish to comment on the assumption we have made so far , that the twin particles produced in the cascade decays of the exotic vectors do not give any signals in the lhc detectors , effectively contributing to the missing energy . in the fraternal th scenario , in each event a @xmath201 pair is produced , held together by a string of the twin strong force this bound state hadronizes either via string fragmentation , leading to production of twin bottomonia , or via twin gluon emission , leading to production of twin glueballs . depending on the values of @xmath202 and @xmath7 , the resulting twin hadrons can travel a macroscopic distance before decaying within the detector , giving rise to displaced signatures . the twin leptons can also be produced through the decays of @xmath64 , and have long - lived decays trough mixing with the sm neutrinos . in these cases , the searches for long - lived particles in association with sm objects provide a sensitivity complementary to ( and possibly stronger than ) that of searches based on large missing energy , as thoroughly studied for the exotic quarks in ref . @xcite . in this section we consider a region of parameters where the vector - like masses of the exotic fermions softly break the @xmath2 symmetry , @xmath41 . for small @xmath33 the mass matrix in eq . is diagonalized by @xmath203 here @xmath84 and @xmath83 are mass eigenstates with @xmath204 , where we have assumed @xmath205 . for example , for @xmath206 gev we find @xmath207 gev , @xmath208 gev and @xmath209 gev , with mixing angles @xmath210 and @xmath211 . a sketch of the spectrum is given in fig . [ fig : spectrum_z2break ] . since @xmath212 , the dominant decay of @xmath42 is into the three - body final state @xmath213 . the partial width can be obtained by adapting the results for the decay of a chargino into a neutralino and a pair of sm fermions in a supersymmetric standard model @xcite . summing over all @xmath214 pairs , we find -breaking case @xmath215 . for definiteness we took @xmath216 . the small @xmath151-@xmath60 and @xmath152-@xmath153 mixings are neglected in the color scheme . the mass splittings among the exotic fermions are @xmath154 and @xmath217 . , width=377 ] @xmath218 where we neglected the small corrections due to the mixing angles , setting @xmath219 . we find that for the parameter region @xmath220 gev which we are interested in , @xmath221 is always satisfied . as a consequence , when a @xmath43 pair is produced at the lhc via the electroweak interactions , it forms a bound state held together by the twin color force . furthermore , as will be discussed in detail momentarily , the annihilation of the @xmath222 bound states is much faster than the decay of the individual @xmath42 s , leading to resonance signals . on the other hand , @xmath84 decays into @xmath223 , where the twin @xmath64 can be on - shell or off - shell . the corresponding width , being suppressed by @xmath224 , satisfies @xmath225 across all parameter space , implying the formation of additional bound states containing @xmath84 . however , if the @xmath223 final state is on - shell , which occurs in a significant portion of parameter space , tev we have @xmath226 gev . ] the decay of the individual @xmath84 s is faster than the annihilation of @xmath227 and @xmath228 bound states . thus we will first concentrate on the signals from @xmath45 bound states , which appear to be more generic , and comment later about the observability of the @xmath229 and @xmath228 bound states , which requires the @xmath84 to have a @xmath107-body decay , _ i.e. _ @xmath230 . the @xmath231-wave @xmath45 bound states are a pseudoscalar and a vector , which we label @xmath232 and @xmath233 , respectively , following the sm bottomonium conventions . at hadron colliders , the @xmath233 is produced in @xmath127 annihilation via @xmath231-channel @xmath234 , see the first diagram of fig . [ fig : upsilon decay ] . the cross section is proportional to the width for the decay @xmath235 , to the photon and @xmath5 are defined as @xmath236 and @xmath237 , respectively . ] @xmath238,\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath239 is the wavefunction at the origin . we will return momentarily to the evaluation of this quantity . the cross section for drell - yan ( dy ) production is then @xmath240 where @xmath241 $ ] is the @xmath127 parton luminosity . the parton luminosities are computed using the mstw08nlo @xcite pdfs evaluated at @xmath242 . . in the middle diagram the @xmath4 s are longitudinally polarized , and the amplitude is dominated by exchange of a virtual twin top.,width=491 ] since @xmath243-@xmath244 gev , to evaluate @xmath239 we apply the standard coulomb approximation , where the effects of confinement are neglected . then for the ground state ( see for example ref . @xcite for a general discussion ) @xmath245 where @xmath246 is the quadratic casimir of the fundamental representation of @xmath25 , and @xmath247 is the running twin qcd coupling evaluated at @xmath248 , the inverse of the average distance between the two constituents , related to the bohr radius @xmath249 $ ] by @xmath250 . using eq . we compute the @xmath233 production cross section at the lhc : for example , for @xmath206 gev , @xmath251 at @xmath31 tev varies between @xmath252 and @xmath253 fb for @xmath254 $ ] gev . what are the main decays of @xmath233 ? as a consequence of twin color conservation , in the perturbative approximation the leading contribution to the twin hadronic width comes from @xmath255 . thus , as for the sm @xmath256 and @xmath257 , the strong decays are suppressed , leading to large branching fractions for the decays into fermion - antifermion pairs , mediated by the weak interactions : the @xmath233 decays into sm quarks about @xmath258 of the time , see fig . [ fig : upsilonbr ] . , whose width scales as @xmath259 , where @xmath260 , leading to a very suppressed branching ratio @xmath261 , not shown in fig . [ fig : upsilonbr ] . ] as a function of @xmath262 . the twin confinement scale is set to @xmath263 gev . solid ( dashed ) curves denote decays into final states containing at least one detectable sm particle ( only twin particles or sm neutrinos).,width=302 ] experimentally , the most promising decay is into sm dileptons , which provides a very clean final state and benefits from a sizable branching ratio @xmath264 , with mild dependence on @xmath33 . the signal cross section is shown in solid blue in the left panel of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] , as a function of @xmath265 , for three representative choices of the twin confinement scale : @xmath263 gev is the approximately @xmath2-symmetric value , while for @xmath266 gev the lightest twin glueball decays far out of the detector , and finally for @xmath267 gev the lightest twin glueball decays promptly @xcite . in the last two cases the displaced decay signatures @xcite of the twin glueballs are washed out . then the exotic fermion signals , such as @xmath268 , play an even more important role in probing the th model at colliders . we compare the signal cross section to the current atlas exclusion @xcite , based on @xmath269 fb@xmath30 at @xmath31 tev , reported as a solid orange curve . interestingly , a non - trivial constraint , @xmath270 gev , can already be extracted for larger @xmath267 gev . in the same figure we also show the projected constraint after @xmath271 and @xmath272 fb@xmath30 , obtained by rescaling the current cross section bound @xmath273 , with @xmath274 the integrated luminosity . the amplitude for the decay of @xmath233 into two transverse gauge bosons is velocity - suppressed , and therefore negligible . thus the only sizable decay width of the spin-@xmath39 bound state into two gauge bosons is @xmath275 ( depicted in the middle diagram of fig . [ fig : upsilon decay ] ) , mediated by the coupling of @xmath42 to the longitudinal @xmath4 , which originates from the top yukawa @xmath276 where @xmath277 was defined in eq . . the total width of the @xmath233 is of @xmath278-@xmath244 mev , which on the one hand is much smaller than the lhc experimental resolution , and on the other hand satisfies @xmath279 across all parameter space considered here , guaranteeing that the bound state annihilation occurs before the individual constituents can decay . production at the @xmath31 tev lhc , multiplied by the branching ratio into one family of sm leptons , as a function of @xmath280 . three different choices of the twin confinement scale @xmath7 are considered . the dashed blue lines include also the contribution of @xmath281 , which is expected only for @xmath282 ; see text for details . in orange , the current constraints from the atlas dilepton resonance search ( solid ) , as well as the projections to the end of run 2 ( dashed ) and to the high - luminosity lhc ( dotted ) . _ right panel : _ similar to the left panel , but for @xmath283 . the @xmath284 annihilation signal is expected only if @xmath230 . in the gray - shaded region , this condition requires @xmath285 gev , which leads to a tuning worse than @xmath286 in the higgs mass for a cutoff of @xmath287 tev . , title="fig:",width=302 ] production at the @xmath31 tev lhc , multiplied by the branching ratio into one family of sm leptons , as a function of @xmath280 . three different choices of the twin confinement scale @xmath7 are considered . the dashed blue lines include also the contribution of @xmath281 , which is expected only for @xmath282 ; see text for details . in orange , the current constraints from the atlas dilepton resonance search ( solid ) , as well as the projections to the end of run 2 ( dashed ) and to the high - luminosity lhc ( dotted ) . _ right panel : _ similar to the left panel , but for @xmath283 . the @xmath284 annihilation signal is expected only if @xmath230 . in the gray - shaded region , this condition requires @xmath285 gev , which leads to a tuning worse than @xmath286 in the higgs mass for a cutoff of @xmath287 tev . , title="fig:",width=302 ] the pseudoscalar @xmath232 is produced in photon fusion , with cross section @xmath288 where @xmath289 is the width for @xmath290 , and @xmath291 is the @xmath292 luminosity @xcite . numerically , the production of @xmath232 is roughly two orders of magnitude smaller than that of @xmath233 : for the benchmark @xmath206 gev , @xmath293 varies from @xmath294 to @xmath295 fb for @xmath296 $ ] gev . in addition , the @xmath232 width is dominated by decays into twin hadrons . in the perturbative approximation , these can be parameterized by the @xmath297 process , which has a branching ratio of @xmath298-@xmath299 across the parameter space . this suppresses the branching ratios into sm final states , among which @xmath292 and @xmath300 would be most promising experimentally , to the few percent level . thus detection of the @xmath232 appears challenging even with high luminosity . the total width of @xmath232 is a factor @xmath301-@xmath302 larger than @xmath303 due to the unsuppressed decay into twin hadrons . we conclude this subsection with a comment on the validity of the coulomb approximation for the bound states , which applies if @xmath304 where @xmath305 is the bohr radius , defined below eq . . in the entire parameter space shown in fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] we have @xmath306 , confirming the applicability of the coulomb treatment . for even larger @xmath7 the effects of confinement become important , and the approximation will not be valid . next , we turn to the possible observation of bound states containing @xmath84 , in particular the spin-1 @xmath227 state , labeled by @xmath307 , and the electrically charged @xmath228 vector , @xmath308 . if @xmath84 decays into on - shell @xmath223 , its lifetime is in the range @xmath309 . since ( barring @xmath310 factors ) @xmath311-@xmath244 mev , this implies that the constituent @xmath84 s likely decay before the bound states they form can annihilate . conversely , for @xmath230 we find @xmath312 mev , which guarantees signals from @xmath307 and @xmath284 . in the remainder of this subsection we discuss the corresponding phenomenology . the @xmath284 is produced in the charged dy channel , and decays primarily into sm fermion pairs . subleading decays are into @xmath313 and into @xmath314 , where @xmath315 is a neutral electroweak gauge boson . the @xmath316 widths arise from the interaction in eq . , after @xmath84-@xmath317 mixing . the mixing also implies that the mass of @xmath284 is expected to be slightly smaller than that of @xmath233 , since @xmath318 . the most promising signal is @xmath319 , whose cross section at the @xmath31 tev lhc is shown in the right panel of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] , together with the constraint from the current atlas @xmath320 resonance search @xcite and its projections to the end of run 2 and to the hl - lhc . for the sake of simplicity , in this figure the @xmath84-@xmath317 mixing was neglected , leading to the simplifications @xmath321 and @xmath322 . on the other hand , if the decay @xmath323 is fast , the electroweak production of a @xmath324 pair is followed by the formation of a @xmath325 bound state instead . provided its angular momentum is not too large , this bound state could annihilate on a time scale shorter than the @xmath42 lifetime . electric charge conservation forces the annihilation channel to be @xmath326 , thus giving rise to the @xmath4+met signature . the @xmath307 phenomenology is qualitatively similar to that of the @xmath233 . one important quantitative difference is that the mass of @xmath307 is @xmath327 smaller , which increases from @xmath328 at @xmath329 gev to @xmath330 at @xmath331 gev for @xmath332 tev . for comparison , the experimental resolution at dilepton invariant mass of @xmath39 tev is @xmath333 in the @xmath334 channel and @xmath335 in the @xmath336 channel @xcite , suggesting that the two - peak structure formed by the @xmath233 and @xmath307 would likely be resolved in the dielectron channel , while a single broader peak would be observed in dimuons . for simplicity , here we ignore the @xmath84-@xmath317 mixing that generates the small mass splitting between the resonances , and simply show in the left panel of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] ( dashed blue ) the sum of the @xmath233 and @xmath307 dilepton signals as a function of @xmath337 . the @xmath307 contributes about half compared to the @xmath233 , due to a smaller branching ratio into dileptons . a comparison of the two panels of fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons ] shows that for @xmath230 , the reach in the @xmath338 and @xmath339 final states is similar . we conclude with a comment on the pseudoscalar states @xmath340 and @xmath341 , whose production cross sections at the lhc are tiny . in fact , since @xmath84 has zero electric charge , @xmath340 is not produced in photon fusion , while the production of @xmath342 in @xmath343 fusion is very suppressed by the small @xmath4 pdf . so far we have neglected the effects of the @xmath27 off - diagonal vector @xmath26 on the physics of the bound states composed of exotic fermions . however , since the coupling @xmath75 is expected to be naturally rather large , a relatively light @xmath26 can have significant effects on the bound state phenomenology , which will be discussed here . through the coupling in eq . , the @xmath344-channel exchange of the exotic vector mediates the decay of @xmath233 into @xmath345 , which is depicted in the last diagram in fig . [ fig : upsilon decay ] . the width is @xmath346 where the interference with the @xmath231-channel @xmath234 exchange was neglected . thus for sufficiently light @xmath26 the @xmath233 acquires a large branching fraction into @xmath345 , which in particular dilutes the dilepton rate . at the same time , the exotic vector also mediates @xmath233 production in @xmath345 annihilation , with cross section given by a formula similar to eq . . the total effect on the dilepton signal is shown in the left panel of fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] , where @xmath347 gev was assumed . gev the condition in eq . is not satisfied , hence the bound states can not be described within the coulomb approximation . in this case we replace eq . with the ansatz @xmath348 , which is motivated by the physical picture of a string with linear potential , and holds to reasonable accuracy for the lowest - lying sm bottomonia . for example , from the measured value of the electronic width of the @xmath257 @xcite one extracts @xmath349 , where the number in parentheses was obtained using our ansatz with @xmath350 mev . ] @xmath351 signal from the @xmath233 , for twin confinement scale @xmath347 gev . the dashed and dotted blue curves show the cross section in presence of a light exotic vector . the orange curves show the current and projected experimental constraints , similarly to fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons].,title="fig:",width=302 ] @xmath351 signal from the @xmath233 , for twin confinement scale @xmath347 gev . the dashed and dotted blue curves show the cross section in presence of a light exotic vector . the orange curves show the current and projected experimental constraints , similarly to fig . [ fig : upsilondileptons].,title="fig:",width=302 ] for this larger confinement scale , which is at the upper edge of the plausible range in the fraternal th @xcite , the increased @xmath233 production cross section implies that masses @xmath352 gev are ruled out already at the time of writing , and the hl - lhc will be able to probe up to @xmath353 tev . however , as shown by fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] , an exotic vector with mass @xmath354 and coupling @xmath355-@xmath356 can suppress the dilepton rate significantly . this is accompanied by a large increase of the @xmath357 signal , shown in the right panel of fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] together with the current @xcite and projected experimental constraint .- tagging efficiency and kinematic acceptance : @xmath358 and @xmath359 for @xmath360 tev , @xmath361 for @xmath362 tev , valid in the range @xmath363 $ ] tev . we thank a. coccaro for useful clarifications about ref . @xcite . ] interestingly , even for a very light and strongly coupled @xmath26 the @xmath233 resonance in the @xmath345 final state would remain hidden after the hl - lhc . notice also that , since @xmath26 only couples to the left - handed @xmath17 , the exotic vector exchange does not mediate the decay of the pseudoscalar @xmath232 into bottom quarks . a relatively light @xmath26 also provides , through its decays , an additional mechanism for production of exotic fermion bound states . in particular , the process @xmath364 , where the @xmath143 production is via qcd ( see eq . ) , is followed by formation of a twin qcd string between the @xmath42 and @xmath365 . based on a simple counting of degrees of freedom , we can estimate that the resulting bound state will be a @xmath233 with probability @xmath366 , or a @xmath232 with probability @xmath367 . then the dominant final state is expected to be @xmath368 , stemming from @xmath369 . notice that the total width of the exotic vector is @xmath370 ( where we have assumed that @xmath37 is too large for @xmath26 to decay into the exotic quarks @xmath16 ) , which for @xmath371 implies a broad resonance . although phenomenologically interesting , a light @xmath26 is however potentially problematic for two reasons . first , it should be accompanied by a light kk gluon , which is subject to strong experimental constraints . second , the @xmath2 breaking @xmath38 leads to a @xmath44-loop quadratically divergent correction to the higgs mass that is negligible for large @xmath372 , but can become important if the exotic vector is light , thus increasing the fine - tuning . these aspects are discussed in the next two subsections . in the minimal version of the two - site model , from the kinetic term of the link field @xmath373 , link field by @xmath373 , to distinguish it from the @xmath23 one that we labeled @xmath161 . ] @xmath374 $ ] , one finds that the mass of kk gluon @xmath122 is related to the mass of @xmath26 by @xmath375 , where @xmath376 . because @xmath377 , this would give @xmath122 a mass similar to , but slightly higher than @xmath378 . however , this relation can be violated by higher dimensional operators . for example , @xmath379 with a spurion @xmath380 inserted on the @xmath136 site makes @xmath381 twice as big as @xmath382 ( if one ignores @xmath383 ) . in summary , @xmath384 is expected to be of the same order as @xmath378 , although with some freedom . since the kk gluon , being a sm color octet , has a very large production cross section at hadron colliders ( see fig . [ fig : rrxsec ] ) , it is then important to take it into account in the discussion of a light @xmath27 exotic vector . the partonic cross section for @xmath385 , which mediates kk gluon pair production , can be found for example in ref . @xcite , and has a structure similar to eq . . the couplings of @xmath122 to fermions read approximately @xmath386 whereas the coupling to the @xmath387 is strongly suppressed by @xmath388 . therefore the kk gluon decays into @xmath28 and @xmath345 with approximate branching ratios @xmath389 and @xmath390 , respectively . since the total width is @xmath391 , the kk gluon , like the @xmath26 , is expected to be a broad resonance . the leading constraint on @xmath122 pair production comes from the @xmath392 final state , where the @xmath393 fb upper limit on the four tops cross section @xcite translates into @xmath394 tev . fb limit is for the case of a @xmath392 contact interaction , which we believe to be the best available approximation , because @xmath122 is a broad resonance . ] however , the kk gluon can also be singly produced in @xmath345 annihilation , with cross section @xmath395 the large coupling @xmath75 can compensate the suppressed @xmath345 pdf , leading to competitive constraints from searches for @xmath28 resonances . from the cms analysis in ref . @xcite we obtain @xmath396 tev for @xmath397 , see fig . [ fig : kkgluontt ] . annihilation , multiplied by the branching ratio into @xmath28 , for two representative values of @xmath398 . the mstw08lo pdfs were used , evaluated at @xmath399 . in red , the cms bound from the first @xmath31 tev data.,width=302 ] the couplings of @xmath122 to the third - generation sm fermions , eq . , could also lead to constraints from flavor observables . we focus on the down - quark sector , which gives the strongest bounds . integrating out @xmath122 and applying fierz transformations , we obtain the effective lagrangian @xmath400 we observe that since the coupling of @xmath122 to the @xmath387 is very suppressed , only ll operators are generated with relevant size , whereas experimentally , the strongest bounds are on the coefficients of lr operators . applying to the down - type quarks the rotation that diagonalizes the mass matrix and selecting the @xmath401 operator that contributes to kaon mixing , we find ( see for example ref . @xcite ) @xmath402 where @xmath403 are elements of the cabibbo - kobayashi - maskawa matrix , and we assumed the coefficient of the operator to be real . defining the coefficient of @xmath404 as @xmath405 , the experimental bound reads @xcite @xmath406 . this can be translated into @xmath407 tev , which is weaker than the lhc constraints for a typical coupling @xmath408-@xmath356 . notice , however , that if the operator in eq . were generated with an unsuppressed phase , the bound on the imaginary ( @xmath409-violating ) part would read @xmath410 @xcite , leading to @xmath411 tev . thus , to envisage a kk gluon lighter than @xmath412 tev we need to postulate that its couplings respect @xmath409 invariance @xcite . since the @xmath2 symmetry is crucial in protecting the higgs potential from large radiative corrections , a @xmath2-breaking spectrum for the exotic fermions necessarily has implications on naturalness . the contribution to the potential from the top sector of eqs . ( [ eq : yukawa ] ) , ( [ eq : mass ] ) is finite for @xmath413 @xcite , but if this relation is violated then the logarithmic divergences do not cancel exactly , leading to an additional contribution @xmath414}{\left(\tilde{m}_a^2 - y_t^2 f^2\right ) \left(\tilde{m}_b^2 - y_t^2 f^2\right ) } + o(h^4),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath415 is the cutoff . unless the splitting between @xmath37 and @xmath33 is very large , this extra term is of moderate size and does not require significantly more tuning . notice also that in the region of parameters studied here , @xmath416 , the sign of the extra mass term is negative and thus does not help to achieve @xmath417 , which is needed for a realistic model . an additional , small source of @xmath2 breaking is therefore still required . in passing we note that in the opposite regime @xmath418 , the @xmath2 breaking from the exotic fermion masses may be sufficient for realistic ewsb . closer inspection reveals that the @xmath2-breaking @xmath38 also gives rise to a @xmath44-loop quadratic divergence in the higgs mass . this can be understood by noticing that due to the couplings in eq . , the wavefunction of @xmath419 is renormalized by a loop of @xmath26 and @xmath420 , @xmath421 , whereas the wavefunction of @xmath422 is renormalized by a loop of @xmath26 and @xmath423 , with renormalization constant @xmath424 . for @xmath38 we have @xmath425 , leading to a @xmath44-loop quadratic contribution to the physical higgs mass , @xmath426 for light @xmath26 , this correction is important and an increased fine - tuning is required to obtain @xmath427 gev : for example , taking @xmath428 tev , @xmath429 , @xmath430 and a cutoff @xmath431 tev , we find a tuning of @xmath432 ( we take @xmath433 at scale @xmath415 ) . , since in this limit the result is most transparent . in our actual parameter space we have @xmath434 , but eq . still provides a reasonably accurate estimate of the fine - tuning . ] this shows that large effects of the exotic vector on the physics of the exotic fermion bound states , such as those illustrated by fig . [ fig : upsilonlambda20 ] in [ subs z2break:3 ] , would be associated with a stronger fine - tuning . it is important to stress , however , that the bound state signals discussed in [ subs z2break:1 ] and [ subs z2break:2 ] do not need to carry a naturalness price tag , because the @xmath26 may simply be heavy , strongly suppressing the correction in eq . . an independent @xmath44-loop tuning arises if the twin confinement scale @xmath7 differs from the @xmath2-symmetric value @xmath435 gev @xcite . this requires a splitting of the standard and twin qcd couplings at high scale , @xmath436 . the associated @xmath44-loop contribution to the higgs mass can be roughly estimated as @xcite @xmath437 for reference , if twin qcd is not gauged ( @xmath438 ) this estimate gives @xmath439 tuning , where we used @xmath440 at high scale . in this paper we studied the collider phenomenology of the exotic states which appear in the non - supersymmetric uv completions of the th model . these exotic states carry charges under both the sm and twin gauge groups , so they constitute a window to the twin sector . they may also provide the first experimental hint of the th , given that the low energy effective theory is quite elusive and may even escape future lhc detection for some range of underlying parameters . the exotic quarks @xmath16 that carry the sm color and twin electroweak charges were the subject of a previous study @xcite . here we extended the analysis to several other states , including the exotic fermions @xmath17 , which are charged under the sm electroweak and twin color groups , as well as the exotic vectors @xmath22 and @xmath26 , which transform in the bifundamental of @xmath18 and @xmath21 , respectively . as in ref . @xcite , due to naturalness considerations the low energy theory was assumed to be approximately described by the fraternal th model . the collider phenomenology of the exotic fermions @xmath17 crucially depends on their masses . if the vector - like masses of the @xmath16 , @xmath37 , and of the @xmath17 , @xmath33 , are linked by the @xmath2 symmetry , then theoretical and experimental constraints on the exotic quarks require @xmath441 tev . in this case the exotic fermions have very suppressed electroweak pair production , but they can still be produced with significant rate in the decays of @xmath26 . we found that the ensuing signals are qualitatively similar to those of the exotic quarks , consisting primarily in @xmath28+met . a potential handle to pin down the @xmath17 is to require an additional @xmath5 boson , which is rarely produced in the decays of the @xmath16 . however , since the direct experimental constraints on the masses of the @xmath17 are rather weak , because they only carry sm electroweak charges , it is interesting to consider the case where @xmath442 tev . this soft @xmath2 breaking does not generate 1-loop quadratic divergences for the higgs mass , and hence does not introduce significant fine - tuning . the second part of the paper is therefore devoted to the study of this scenario . we found that in this case , at least one of the exotic fermions has a very suppressed decay width . as a consequence , its pair production through the drell - yan process is followed by the formation of twin qcd bound states , which then annihilate primarily into sm particles . the associated resonance signals , typical of hidden valley models @xcite , provide a novel aspect in the phenomenology of the th . we also discussed the significant effects that a relatively light @xmath27 exotic vector can have on the bound state phenomenology . notice that while in this paper we focused on the decays of the bound states into sm particles , which are dominant , mixed sm / twin decays may provide rare but striking signatures if some of the twin particles are long - lived . for example , the charged bound state @xmath284 can decay into @xmath443 . if the hadronization of the twin gluons produces the lightest twin glueball , the latter can travel a macroscopic distance and decay through mixing with the higgs , leading to the @xmath444+@xmath445 displaced vertex ) signature . we also sketched the phenomenology of the @xmath23 exotic vectors . some of them have the right quantum numbers to mix with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and can therefore be singly produced in hadron collisions . we found that their contribution to the @xmath35 parameter of ewpt likely puts them out of the lhc reach , but they could discovered at a future @xmath15 tev collider . to avoid the large @xmath47 parameter constraint that would further push up their masses , the @xmath23 group may be extended to an @xmath24 , which contains the custodial symmetry to protect the @xmath47 parameter . in this case there will be more exotic states , both in the vector and the fermion sectors . however , as shown in app . [ so8exo ] , their phenomenologies are not qualitatively different and hence are well covered in this study . * acknowledgments * we thank y. bai , a. coccaro , r. harnik , g. marques tavares , t. tait and j. zupan for useful discussions . this work was performed in part at the aspen center for physics , which is supported by national science foundation grant phy-1066293 . hc and es were supported in part by the us department of energy grant de - sc-000999 . yt was supported in part by the national science foundation under grant phy-1315155 , and by the maryland center for fundamental physics . we describe here a two - site model where the gauge symmetry is @xmath159 on the first ( ` strong ' ) site , and @xmath160 ^ 2 \subset su(4)'\times u(1)_x'$ ] on the second ( ` elementary ' ) site . the gauge symmetries are broken to the diagonal subgroup by the vev @xmath162 of a link field @xmath161 that transforms as @xmath446 , where @xmath447 and @xmath448 . the covariant derivative for @xmath161 is then @xmath449 the strong gauge fields are defined as @xmath450 where the @xmath451 matrix @xmath22 was defined in table [ tab : charges ] together with the quantum numbers of its components , and @xmath452 . setting @xmath453 and @xmath454 , eq . can be rewritten as @xmath455 where @xmath456 . it is immediate to see that the sm and twin hypercharges are identified with @xmath457 and @xmath458 ( for fields neutral under @xmath27 ) , matching the normalization of ref . the elementary gauge bosons read instead @xmath459 the kinetic term of @xmath161 is @xmath460/4 $ ] , which setting @xmath161 to its vev yields @xmath461 + ( a \to b).\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus the @xmath22 acquire a mass @xmath462 , while the mixing between strong and elementary states is diagonalized by , for example for the charged ` @xmath19 ' states : @xmath463 which leaves the @xmath464 massless , while @xmath465 . similar rotations diagonalize the mixing of the neutral ` @xmath19 ' and all the ` @xmath20 ' fields . we also need to take into account the symmetry breaking due to the vev of @xmath92 , which lives in the strong site and also has @xmath466 . its covariant derivative is @xmath467 , with @xmath468 defined in eq . . in the vacuum of eq . , the kinetic term @xmath469 gives @xmath470 + \tfrac{1}{2 } s_h^2 [ ( \tilde{w}_a^3 - \tilde{b}_a)^2 + 2 \tilde{w}_a^+ \tilde{w}_a^- ] \nonumber \\ + & \ , s_h c_h [ ( \tilde{w}_b^3 - \tilde{b}_b)\mathcal{w}_{1r}^0 + \tilde{w}^+_b \mathcal{w}_2 ^ 0 + \mathrm{h.c . } ] \nonumber \\ + & \ , s_h c_h [ ( \tilde{w}_a^3 - \tilde{b}_a)\mathcal{w}_{1r}^0 + \tilde{w}^-_a \mathcal{w}_1^+ + \mathrm{h.c.}]\ , \big\}\end{aligned}\ ] ] where we have defined @xmath177 . notice that the imaginary counterpart of @xmath471 does not mix with any other field . the masses of the @xmath22 resulting from @xmath472 were given in eq . , neglecting small corrections due to ewsb ( i.e. proportional to @xmath473 ) . at @xmath474 , the @xmath4 and @xmath5 masses have the standard expressions @xmath475 and @xmath476 , provided we identify the sm parameters as @xmath477 the contribution to the @xmath35 parameter is computed from @xcite @xmath478 where @xmath479 is the self - energy between the states @xmath480 and @xmath481 , defined through the following effective lagrangian in momentum space ( the @xmath482 is omitted for brevity ) @xmath483 notice that it is natural to assume that the light sm fermions live on the elementary site . therefore the strong ( tilded ) fields do not couple to light fermions , and once they are integrated out , only oblique corrections are generated @xcite . to integrate them out we proceed diagrammatically , noticing that at @xmath474 only exchange of the states @xmath484 and @xmath471 is relevant . the result was given in eq . . the @xmath47 parameter can be computed from the corrections to the @xmath485 masses at @xmath486 , @xmath487 and @xmath488 . for @xmath170 we find @xmath489 leading to @xmath490 where in the last equality we took the leading order in @xmath491 , and employed the fact that for @xmath170 , @xmath492 . quantitatively , requiring @xmath493 gives @xmath494 tev . in this appendix we comment about the additional states that are present in th models where the global symmetry is extended from @xmath23 to @xmath24 . in the gauge sector , the adjoint representation of @xmath24 decomposes under the @xmath495 subgroup as @xmath496 . the @xmath497 contains @xmath498 ( @xmath499 ) , where the @xmath500 are the gauge bosons of @xmath501 , identified with the @xmath502 of eq . , while the @xmath503 are new vectors that gauge @xmath504 . the phenomenology of the latter has been studied in the context of custodial composite higgs models , see for example ref . the decomposition of the @xmath505 is entirely analogous , with @xmath506 . the @xmath507 contains the exotic vectors , that include both the @xmath22 and additional states . however , there will still be only one linear combination of the exotic vectors that mixes with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 , and can therefore be singly produced at hadron colliders . its phenomenology will be qualitatively similar to the one we outlined for the @xmath22 . in the fermion sector , the number of fields in @xmath508 needs to be doubled to form a fundamental representation of @xmath24 . in our formalism , this can be done by extending the fields carrying twin color as follows @xmath509 where the fields in each set of parentheses transform in the same way under the @xmath510 gauge group , but have different hypercharges or twin hypercharges . all fields except @xmath511 , @xmath512 acquire vector - like masses with their vector - like partners , as in eq . ( [ eq : mass ] ) . the sm and twin electric charges of these fields are @xmath513 with the sm and twin charges swapped for @xmath514 and @xmath515 . the phenomenology of the @xmath516 doublet is familiar from custodial composite higgs models , see for example ref . @xcite and references therein . for the extra copy of the exotic quarks , the upper component of @xmath517 has twin electric charge @xmath518 and behaves similarly to @xmath61 , whereas the lower component has zero twin electric charge and can mix with the sm top , in analogy with @xmath60 . therefore the phenomenology of the additional exotic quarks is not expected to differ qualitatively from the one presented in ref . likewise , the upper component of @xmath519 has sm electric charge @xmath518 and behaves similarly to @xmath42 , whereas the lower component has zero sm electric charge and can mix with the twin top , in analogy with @xmath84 . thus the phenomenology of the exotic fermions is qualitatively well captured by restricting the attention to the @xmath17 , as we did in this paper . g. burdman , z. chacko , r. harnik , l. de lima and c. b. verhaaren , `` colorless top partners , a 125 gev higgs , and the limits on naturalness , '' phys . rev . d * 91 * 055007 ( 2015 ) , arxiv:1411.3310 [ hep - ph ] . r. barbieri , d. greco , r. rattazzi and a. wulzer , `` the composite twin higgs scenario , '' jhep * 1508 * 161 ( 2015 ) , arxiv:1501.07803 [ hep - ph ] . m. bando , t. kugo , s. uehara , k. yamawaki and t. yanagida , `` is rho meson a dynamical gauge boson of hidden local symmetry ? , '' phys . * 54 * 1215 ( 1985 ) . n. arkani - hamed , a. g. cohen and h. georgi , `` ( de)constructing dimensions , '' phys . rev . * 86 * 4757 ( 2001 ) , arxiv : hep - th/0104005 . collaboration , `` search for resonances below @xmath523 tev from the mass distribution of @xmath146-jet pairs in proton - proton collisions at @xmath524 tev with the atlas detector , '' atlas - conf-2016 - 031 , june 2016 . collaboration , `` search for new phenomena in @xmath28 final states with additional heavy - flavour jets in @xmath521 collisions at @xmath524 tev with the atlas detector , '' atlas - conf-2016 - 104 , september 2016 . collaboration , `` search for @xmath28 resonances in boosted semileptonic final states in @xmath521 collisions at @xmath525 , '' cms - pas - b2g-15 - 002 , march 2016 .
Abstract: | [
"the twin higgs model is the preeminent example of a theory of neutral naturalness , where the new particles that alleviate the little hierarchy problem are standard model ( sm ) singlets . the most promising collider search strategy , based on rare higgs decays , is nevertheless not effective in significant regions of the parameter space of the low energy theory . this underlines the importance of phenomenological studies on ultraviolet completions of the twin higgs model , which must lie at a scale lower than @xmath0-@xmath1 tev . we pursue this course in the context of non - supersymmetric completions , focusing on exotic fermions that carry sm electroweak and twin color charges , as well as on exotic vectors that transform as the bi - fundamental of the electroweak or color groups . both @xmath2-preserving and @xmath2-breaking mass spectra are considered for the exotic fermions . in the former case they must be heavier than @xmath3 tev , but can still be sizably produced in the decays of the color bi - fundamental vector . in the @xmath2-breaking scenario , the exotic fermions can have masses in the few hundred gev range without significantly increasing the fine - tuning . once pair - produced through the electroweak interactions , they naturally form bound states held together by the twin color force , which subsequently annihilate back to sm particles . the associated resonance signals are discussed in detail . we also outline the phenomenology of the electroweak bi - fundamental vectors , some of which mix with the sm @xmath4 and @xmath5 and can therefore be singly produced in hadron collisions ."
] | 11,664 | 11,664 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: if @xmath13cdm is correct , then all dark matter halos hosting galaxies from those hosting dwarfs to those hosting giant clusters should be filled with substructure @xcite . dark - matter only simulations over a vast range of particle masses and physical scales show that substructure persists down to the resolution limit of @xmath13cdm simulations @xcite . the basic expectation is that the mass function of subhalos rises steadily to masses well below the molecular cooling limit of @xmath14 @xcite , with thousands of sites for potentially star - forming satellites . observations of our own milky way , on the other hand , have revealed the presence of only @xmath15 confirmed satellite galaxies @xcite , the faintest of which were all discovered by the sloan digital sky survey ( sdss ) @xcite . however , the sdss covers only a fraction of the sky and is incomplete to the most distant and faintest satellites of the milky way . any solution to the mismatch between the predicted abundance of subhalos and the observed counts of satellite galaxies around our own milky way will likely involve the discovery of ultra - faint satellites in unprobed regions of the sky , at large distances , and with surface brightnesses low enough that they lie just outside current detection limits @xcite . over the last several years , searches by panstarrs and vst atlas have failed to lend critical support to this idea finding far fewer dwarf galaxy satellites than expected @xcite . however , the recent discovery of up to nine new ultra - faint satellites in the southern sky by the dark energy survey ( des , * ? ? ? * ; * ? ? ? * ) , the detection of three more faint dwarf satellite candidates @xcite , and ongoing efforts to discover dwarfs at large distances @xcite provide an exciting glimpse into the near future and point to a much larger population of as - yet - undiscovered dwarf galaxies in the local volume . interestingly , most of the newest milky way satellite candidates were all discovered near the large magellanic cloud ( lmc ) . while this could be nothing more than a location - based selection effect ( the lmc happens to lie next to the region probed by the year one data release of des ) , @xcite show that several of the candidates could very well be satellites of the lmc , and their discovery highlights the potential for discovering ultra - faint satellites of other more massive dwarf satellites , or of isolated dwarf galaxies in the local group . the scale - free nature of the subhalo mass function in @xmath13cdm suggests that groups of subhalos should be common @xcite . because low - mass halos form earlier , are denser , and fall into smaller hosts before larger ones @xcite , it is likely that satellites of satellites or of lower mass isolated halos may have survived longer than their counterparts that fell directly into the milky way @xcite . this suggests that one way to search for ultra - faint galaxies might be as satellites of known dwarf galaxies . associations and pairs of satellite galaxies in the local group have been observed for some time @xcite , and several milky way satellites are suspected to host their own satellites @xcite . once a group of satellites falls into the milky way , however , tidal forces will eventually disassemble the group and wipe out evidence of coherent structure @xcite . isolated massive dwarfs in the local group may serve as complementary targets in the hunt for ever - fainter dwarfs ( which presumably probe the lowest mass dark matter subhalos ) . @xcite suggest that even already - merged satellites of isolated dwarfs could be detected as ghost halos " of ancient stellar populations surrounding their hosts . despite the obvious challenge of detecting ultra - faints at large distances , isolated dwarfs also make efficient use of telescope pointings , removing some of the chance inherent in any random ultra - faint search without losing any of the search volume . in the near future , large - area , deep - sky surveys such as lsst , des , panstarrs , and skymapper will push current detection limits to lower surface brightness and may be able to see ultra - faint satellites of isolated dwarf galaxies if they exist @xcite . dynamical measurements of most milky way dwarf spheroidals ( dsphs ) show that , despite having luminosities that vary over nearly five orders of magnitude , they have almost the same central densities , comparable to dark matter halos with @xmath16 @xcite . this is surprising , not only because this is well above the mass where physical processes are believed to prevent star formation , but because the mass function of potentially star - forming subhalos should be heavily populated by smaller halos . segue 2 may be the first of these long - searched - for small subhalos to be identified @xcite , as it appears to have a total dark matter mass @xmath17 . however , based on its metallicity , @xcite hypothesize that segue 2 is a bare remnant of a much larger galaxy that has been severely tidally stripped . the common central density for observed dsphs might signify a low - mass cutoff in galaxy formation . halos with slightly lower central densities may have been unable to shield themselves from the reionizing background , perhaps due to having a lower baryon fractions than their denser counterparts @xcite . alternatively , ( * ? ? ? * hereafter b10 ) suggest that the apparent common mass scale is a selection effect , and that a large population of unobserved stealth galaxies " may reside in halos with masses just below those that host observed dwarfs . these low - mass halos have shallow potential wells , and therefore the galaxies that form within them have larger effective radii and lower surface brightnesses , allowing them to more easily avoid detection @xcite . the number of these stealth galaxies expected to exist is sensitive to the presence of a low - mass cutoff in galaxy formation , as the lowest mass halos are expected to host the puffiest " galaxies in this picture . the heating of accreted gas or the prevention of gas accretion by the ambient ionizing uv background created when the first galaxies formed can arrest or prevent star formation in the smallest dark matter halos , suggesting a threshold in halo mass below which all halos remain dark @xcite . it is possible , however , that some very low mass halos were able to form some population ii stars _ before _ reionization @xcite . if star formation ceased after this time , it would cause them to have uniformly ancient stellar populations @xcite with extremely low metallicity @xcite . remarkably , this appears to be the case with the known ultra faint dwarfs of the milky way @xcite . several authors have shown that photoheating prevents gas from condensing in halos with masses that lie just below or at the common halo mass scale for milky way satellites @xcite . however , the specific timing of the onset and end of reionization , the spectrum of the background radiation , the ability of gas to temporarily shield itself from these high energy photons , and particularly the mass resolution , can have a large effect on the number and minimum halo mass of galaxies in any simulation @xcite . moreover , prescriptions for how stars and supernovae return energy back to the interstellar medium ( ism ) will affect the formation history of small galaxies in the presence of an ionizing background . in what follows , we present a series of simulations of galaxy formation within small dark matter halos run with the ` gizmo ` code @xcite in psph - mode " @xcite . ` gizmo ` implements the feedback in realistic environments ( fire ) @xcite feedback scheme for converting gas into stars and capturing the energy fed back from those stars into the surrounding medium . using these simulations , we find that the subhalos of the halos that surround @xmath18 dwarf galaxies should form stars fairly abundantly , and produce potentially observable ultra - faint satellite galaxies of known classical dwarfs in the local group . further , the ultra - faint dwarfs in our simulations with @xmath19 that form in isolation or as satellites within subhalos of @xmath20 all have completely ancient stellar populations , as is seen for the known population of the milky way . they also have low - surface brightnesses , as expected for stealth galaxies " forming in halos of these low masses , but may be within the detection capabilities of future surveys . this paper is organized as follows : in section [ sec : sims ] , we give the details of our simulations , including halo finding and merger - tree analysis . section [ sec : results ] outlines our main results , including the @xmath21 relation for our galaxies and their star formation histories . in section [ sec : det ] , we use the exploring the local volume in simulations ( elvis ) suite of dark - matter - only local group simulations @xcite to determine how common these objects should be and the likelihood of their detection . we compare to several recent works in section [ sec : compare ] , and summarize our results and conclude in section [ sec : dis ] . we present six cosmological zoom - in simulations of four isolated dwarf galaxy halos using two implementations of subgrid physics . the four host halos are @xmath22 and @xmath23 , which have @xmath24 virial masses of @xmath25 ; and @xmath26 and @xmath27 , which have @xmath28 ( see table 1 for precise numbers ) . the @xmath23 halo was simulated three times two runs varied the specific subgrid feedback implementation , while the third used a different choice of gravitational softening ( see below ) , resulting in changes in the star formation histories of the main galaxies ( see @xcite for details ) . we refer to these three cases as @xmath29 ( run with the fiducial parameters the same parameters as @xmath22 , @xmath26 , and @xmath27 ) , @xmath30 , and @xmath31 . the subscripts refer to when the halos formed their stars . every run has a dark matter force softening of @xmath32 to @xmath33 pc and a dark matter particle mass of @xmath34 except @xmath27 , which uses @xmath35 . the @xmath26 and three @xmath23 simulations are identical to the ultrafaint " and dwarf runs presented by @xcite . and @xmath26 were also previously presented in @xcite as @xmath36 and @xmath37 respectively . ] the initial conditions were generated using ` music ` @xcite , and selected from a cosmological box run at low resolution to @xmath24 . @xmath22 , @xmath23 , and @xmath26 were all selected from @xmath38 boxes to have typical values of spin parameter @xmath39 , concentration , and formation time for their mass range , and also to have small lagrangian volumes @xcite . @xmath27 was selected from a @xmath40 box and required to have no other halos of @xmath41 or more of its mass within @xmath42 at @xmath43 and a small lagrangian volume . all dwarfs in this work are isolated . once the halos are identified , the particles are traced back in time and an enclosing lagrangian volume is chosen and re - simulated at higher resolution with dark matter and gas , buffered by dark matter - only regions of increasing particle mass . this process is done according to the zoom - in techniques outlined by @xcite and with the goal of minimizing low resolution particles within the halos of interest . all simulations begin at a redshift of @xmath44 and have @xmath45 contamination from low resolution particles within a distance of @xmath46 at all redshifts . all simulations were run using the fully conservative cosmological hydrodynamic code ` gizmo ` @xcite in psph - mode " . this code adopts the lagrangian pressure - entropy " formulation of the smooth particle hydrodynamic ( sph ) equations , ameliorating previous difficulties sph codes had in modeling multiphase fluids @xcite . for feedback and star formation we use the feedback in realistic environments ( fire ) scheme @xcite . fire tracks momentum imparted locally from stellar radiation pressure , radiation pressure on larger scales via the light that escapes star - forming regions , hii photoionization heating , supernovae ( type i and ii ) heating , momentum and mass loss and stellar winds from o - type and agb stars . each star particle has an age determined by its formation time , an initial mass function ( imf ) taken from @xcite , and a metallicity inherited from its parent gas particle . the star particle then loses mass and creates metals according to the ` starburst99 ` stellar population synthesis model @xcite and the input imf . our simulations use an ambient ionizing uv background from @xcite , which starts at @xmath47 and completes reionization by @xmath48 . the fire implementation has as few free parameters as possible , with star formation in the multiphase ism naturally self - regulating . giant molecular clouds ( gmcs ) form , and then are subsequently heated and disrupted by the stars that form within the self - gravitating , molecular gas . in order to ensure that the gas within the gmcs reaches a density high enough to form stars ( @xmath49 ) , the code requires extremely high mass and spatial resolution . every run uses a gas particle mass of @xmath50 except for @xmath27 , which uses @xmath51 . the gas force resolution varies from @xmath52 in all runs except one version of @xmath23 ( see below ) . the @xmath29 run uses the fiducial subgrid parameters . in @xmath30 and @xmath31 , mass , momentum , and energy are deposited to particles within the sph kernel according to a mass - weighting scheme , rather than volume - weighting as in the fiducial runs . in addition to this change , @xmath30 was run to test equal softening lengths for the dark matter and the gas ( 25 pc ) . all three runs of @xmath23 end up with stellar masses in the central galaxies that differ by only @xmath53 , suggesting that the major differences between the runs are more a result of stochasticity than the changes to the feedback implementation and softening length ( see section [ sec : sample ] ) . we use the amiga halo finder ( ` ahf ` , * ? ? ? * ) to identify gravitationally bound dark matter , stellar and gas particles in each snapshot of the simulation . because pure particle - matching algorithms generally underperform relative to more sophisticated methods in terms of detection and removal of spurious interlopers between snapshots @xcite , we track particle overdensities between simulation snapshots using the ` consistent - trees ` software @xcite . this is particularly important given our focus on subhalos . because the current stable version of ` consistent - trees ` which makes use of the ` rockstar ` @xcite halo finder does not track baryonic particles , we build a pipeline between ` ahf ` and ` rockstar ` that allows for a seamless transition between the ` ahf ` halo catalogs and the merger trees this pipeline uses the halo phase space information combined with the dark matter particle ids to match each halo in the catalogue to a ` consistent - trees ` merger tree . ` rockstar ` and ` consistent - trees ` were used to determine the peak virial mass and infall times for subhalos . all other halo , galaxy and stellar quantities were obtained from the ` ahf ` halo catalogs or the raw particle files . all runs were initialized and simulated assuming the wmap-7 cosmology @xmath54 , @xmath55 , @xmath56 , @xmath57 , @xmath58 and @xmath59 @xcite . further detail on the fire/`gizmo ` code can be found in @xcite . [ cols="<,^,^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] [ tab : tablebig ] figure [ fig : dm_hists ] shows the dark matter distributions of all six runs in greyscale with the stellar mass density overlaid in color . the physical scales of the panels are identical : the white line in the lower left corner of each visualization indicates @xmath60 . for our detailed analysis , we focus on objects with @xmath61 in order to avoid effects from spurious star formation at our resolution limit . the gas density required to form stars in our simulations is quite high and can only occur in dense , molecular , self - gravitating regions . this onerous minimal criteria suggests that the formation of this minimum stellar mass represents a physical star formation episode . requirement have at least 16 star particles and had @xmath62 dark matter particles at peak mass . all but one had @xmath63 dark matter particles at peak mass , corresponding to typical initial baryonic particle numbers of @xmath64 before feedback dispelled most of these . ] furthermore , we find that below a subhalo mass of @xmath65 our results become far less stable against the stochasticity in star formation ( see below ) . we therefore consider only as robust those objects that form within halos that have a minimum dark matter particle number @xmath66 and refer to satellites that meet both this requirement and the stellar mass cut as massive satellites " . @xmath22 has two satellite galaxies that meet both of these requirements . only one subhalo the most massive in each of the runs of @xmath23 forms a massive satellite " . in @xmath30 there is a second satellite that meets the stellar mass but not the dark matter particle number cut . because all three runs of @xmath23 use identical initial conditions , each subhalo in @xmath30 has a corresponding subhalo in the other runs that shares a majority of the dark matter particles . the subhalos corresponding to this second satellite host galaxies below the stellar mass cut in @xmath29 and @xmath31 . in figure [ fig : dm_hists ] , stars are shown in this particular subhalo for all three runs of @xmath23 . importantly , although the three subhalos that host the second satellites of @xmath23 are effectively identical , they produce galaxies that differ by a factor of @xmath67 in stellar mass due to only minor changes in parameters between the runs . this motivates the fairly large dark matter particle number we require to consider a system well resolved . @xmath68 and @xmath69 for the central galaxy ( central ) , most - massive satellite ( 1st satellite ) , and second - most - massive satellite ( 2nd satellite ) and @xmath31 , the 2nd satellite is the second most massive satellite in stellar mass . in these two runs only , the 2nd satellites are selected as the satellites that correspond to the high stellar mass outlier in run @xmath30 . only the 1st satellites in @xmath23 runs qualify as massive satellites " . ] in all six runs can be found in table 1 . in the tables , figures and throughout the text , @xmath68 is @xmath70 for centrals and @xmath71 for satellites . values in parentheses indicate satellite systems that we regard as too poorly resolved to trust for detailed analysis . they are included here for completeness . the 2nd satellites of all @xmath23 runs fall into this category , as well as all satellites of the isolated ultra - faints @xmath26 and @xmath27 . in figure [ fig : dm_hists ] , the dark matter distribution is shown for all dark matter particles located within @xmath72 of the virial radius of the halo listed in each panel . star particles are only shown if they reside within any halo that currently has @xmath73 in stars in the inner @xmath74 of a central ( satellite ) galaxy or are in a corresponding halo in the other two runs of @xmath23 . many of the other subhalos also contain star particles ( see figure 2 ) , but they are not shown so that we may focus on systems that are reasonably well resolved . the radial extent of the galaxies was chosen by inspecting their stellar mass profiles ( each central galaxy also has a _ very _ diffuse stellar halo that we aim to avoid ) . the galaxy stellar masses are all computed using these radial limits . in all six runs , the dark matter halos hosting the central galaxies contain significant substructure . the leftmost panel of figure [ fig:3panel ] shows the current subhalo mass function for all six runs . we plot all subhalos with @xmath75 , which corresponds to @xmath76 . @xmath22 , with the highest virial mass , has both the most and the most massive subhalos . the subhalo mass functions for the three runs of @xmath23 lie predictably on top of each other . as expected , the two isolated ultra - faints " ( @xmath77 ) form far fewer subhalos ( at fixed mass ) than their more massive counterparts . the satellite stellar mass functions are shown in the middle panel of figure [ fig:3panel ] . they are intriguingly steep , rising to as many as fifty tiny satellites in the case of @xmath22 . however , the majority of these star - forming satellites form only a single star particle , and this potentially exciting behavior will need to be confirmed at much higher resolution . in order to make this clear , the dark green shaded region shows the average stellar mass of a single star particle , while the light green shaded region shows the mass range for all other objects that form with @xmath78 ( fewer than 16 star particles ) . in all six simulations , a total of @xmath79 subhalos form at least one star particle , but a mere six of them form galaxies with @xmath61 ( and only five of these also meet the @xmath80 requirement ) . it is these , the most massive satellites , that will be the focus of our analysis ( along with the centrals themselves ) . the @xmath81 relation for the five resulting massive satellites " ( filled triangles ) , their less - well - resolved counterparts ( open triangles ) , and all central galaxies ( filled circles ) , is shown in the right panel of figure [ fig:3panel ] . plotted are the six central galaxies along with the 1st and 2nd satellites of each host ( detailed in table 1 ) for each run . although 18 symbols are shown , we only regard the 11 filled points as reasonably well - resolved . all of the well - resolved systems in this work lie only slightly offset from the extrapolated abundance matching relationship from @xcite , which has been constrained down to a stellar mass of @xmath82 . this abundance matching relation , obtained by updating the @xcite relation with a faint - end slope derived from the measurements of the gama survey @xcite , accurately reproduces the stellar mass functions of the milky way and andromeda satellites , as well as the stellar mass function of the local field , when applied to the elvis simulations @xcite . we do not find the bending " of the @xmath21 relation reported by @xcite at @xmath83 . instead , the relation maintains a fairly steady power - law down to @xmath84 . we do see a qualitatively similar break to that seen by @xcite but at a significantly lower halo mass of @xmath85 . below this point it is clear that we are witnessing a large amount of stochasticity , the onset of which corresponds to the scale of extremely faint galaxies ( @xmath86 ) , as opposed to the results of @xcite , where stochasticity sets in near the masses of classical dsphs ( @xmath87 ) . however , it is in this regime where our resolution is severely limited these galaxies have @xmath88 star particles . at this time we are unable to determine whether the apparent break and associated stochasticity in our relation at small mass are physical or simply artifacts of resolution , although it is intriguing that the break witnessed by @xcite occurs at the mass of @xmath89 of their baryonic particles as well . future work at higher resolution will allow us to explore this question more fully . the most massive satellite of @xmath22 represents an interesting statistical rarity ( see section [ sec : elvis ] ) in that the mass of the subhalo hosting this satellite is just over @xmath90 of the mass of its host , and the satellite itself has @xmath91 of the stellar mass of its central galaxy . @xmath22 is clearly undergoing a major merger ( see figure [ fig : dm_hists ] ) and the associated large satellite has properties that are distinct from the other satellites described in this work . most notably , its stellar mass is two orders of magnitude greater than the other massive satellites " , and it s stellar and dark matter masses are both larger than those of the central hosts of @xmath26 and @xmath27 . for identification only ( with no relation to the structural properties of the satellite ) , we refer when necessary to this most massive satellite as dsph " , and all other satellites as ultra - faint " satellites . the broader term ultra - faints " is reserved for all galaxies , centrals and satellites , that have @xmath19 in our simulations . the top panel of figure [ fig : sfh_h12 ] shows the cumulative fractional star formation histories ( sfh ) for @xmath22 ( solid line ) and its two massive satellites " . the sfh of its large , dsph " satellite ( @xmath92 ) is shown by the dotted line . its second , ultra - faint " satellite ( @xmath93 ) is shown by the dashed line . the shaded band corresponds to the epoch of reionization in our simulations . the bottom panel presents similar histories for the three @xmath23 runs along with the single most massive ultra - faint " satellite ( @xmath94 ) that forms in each run ( dashed lines ) . in both panels , the short vertical lines at the top mark the first virial crossing of the satellites . the massive dsph " satellite of @xmath22 demonstrates a particularly interesting sfh . it stops forming stars shortly after the epoch of reionization for almost @xmath95 ( from @xmath96 to @xmath97 ) . however , it manages to keep some of its gas on hand in a state that is just below the threshold for star formation . upon infall into the virial radius of @xmath22 at a lookback time of @xmath98 , followed by pericentric passage @xmath99 later , its ism is compressed enough to create a new burst of stars , all of which are concentrated at the center of the satellite and were formed in situ . the central galaxy of @xmath22 itself also appears to experience a related ( albeit mild ) burst . this type of bimodal star formation history was suggested by @xcite as a signature of massive reionization fossils " . our dsph " satellite has a slightly higher @xmath100 than the range given in that work , and its rebirth of star - formation was triggered by a merger rather than by a change in its halo concentration ( as originally suggested by @xcite ) ; it is nevertheless similar in its qualitative nature . in our simulations , halos with @xmath101 appear to robustly maintain star formation to @xmath24 . this massive satellite at @xmath102 seems to mark a transition point where reionization begins to favor uniformly ancient star formation . the influence of its impending merger was enough to trigger a rebirth . the ultra - faint " satellites shown in figure [ fig : sfh_h12 ] all form in halos smaller than this , with @xmath103 . they all form their stars entirely before @xmath104 and are quenched over @xmath105 before their infall onto the larger hosts , indicating that their star formation is shut down by reionization rather than environmental processes . importantly , these subsequent mergers do not trigger fresh star formation , as was seen in the more massive satellite . these small halos are either quenched during reionization or shortly thereafter , running out of fuel after the fresh gas supply was shut off by the ambient uv field . this tendency for our ultra - faint galaxies in @xmath103 halos to quench early is illustrated more clearly in figure [ fig : sfh_ufds ] , where we have plotted the cumulative fractional star formation histories for all seven ultra - faints " formed in our simulations , e.g. all ultra - faint " satellites from figure [ fig : sfh_h12 ] ( dashed lines ) , along with @xmath26 and @xmath27 ( solid lines ) . we also include the unresolved 2nd satellite of @xmath30 ( dotted line ) due to it s high stellar mass and to illustrate its similar sfh . from figure [ fig : sfh_ufds ] it is clear that , in every case , reionization plays a significant role in the shutting down of star formation in our ultra - faints " . not only were @xmath106 of all stars in all seven of these objects formed before @xmath107 , four of the objects form over @xmath108 of their stars before the completion of reionization at @xmath109 . ) . short vertical lines along the top axes indicate infall times of the satellites . top : @xmath110 central ( solid ) along with its two satellites . the massive dsph " satellite is shown by the dotted line and it displays a late - time burst in conjunction with its recent infall . the ultra - faint " satellite ( dashed ) is quenched early , during reionization ( shaded band ) , well before it is accreted . bottom : @xmath111 centrals ( solid ) and the most massive ( ultra - faint ) satellites ( dashed ) in each run . [ fig : sfh_h12 ] ] ) . the sfh of the unresolved outlier that passes the stellar mass cut ( see section [ sec : sample ] for details ) is also shown ( dotted line ) . all seven of these systems have ancient stellar populations , similar to those observed for the ultra - faint galaxies of the milky way . [ fig : sfh_ufds ] ] it is beyond the scope of this paper to investigate a statistically significant sample of hydrodynamic simulations of @xmath25 dwarfs in order to estimate the frequency with which they will host satellites above a given mass . however , if we assume an @xmath69 - @xmath71 relation similar to that presented in figure 2 , we can make an estimate using dark - matter - only simulations . we do so using the exploring the local volume in simulations ( elvis ) suite of collisionless zoom - in simulations of local group - like environments @xcite . we select all isolated ( @xmath112 for all more massive halos ) dwarf - size dark matter halos ( @xmath113 ) in the 12 local group - like pairs and the 24 isolated elvis simulations , and determine the fraction of those hosts that have @xmath114 subhalos with @xmath115 . this is the halo mass that corresponds to @xmath116 according to figure 2 . forms a well - resolved satellite . although we focus here on satellites of isolated dwarfs , we note that this criteria would suggest the existence of @xmath117 undetected ultra - faint stealth galaxies " within @xmath118 of the milky way . ] we similarly compute the fraction of dwarf halos that have a very large subhalo with @xmath119 , set by the most massive satellite of @xmath120 ) . figure [ fig : ngtn ] shows the probability for an isolated dwarf halo in elvis to have @xmath121 satellites of at least these two peak virial masses within a projected distance of @xmath122 ( the typical virial radius for our dwarfs ) as a function of @xmath123 . according to figure [ fig : ngtn ] , isolated halos with @xmath124 will have one or more subhalos that could host @xmath125 satellites about @xmath126 of the time . the likelihood that an isolated dwarf in the same mass range hosts a satellite as massive @xmath127 , however , is just under @xmath128 . using both sdss and the semi - analytic models of @xcite applied to the ms - ii simulation @xcite , @xcite show that the probability for a central galaxy to host a satellite a given fraction of its stellar mass , @xmath129 , decreases as a strong function of @xmath130 until @xmath131 , becoming independent of @xmath130 for centrals below the stellar mass of the milky way . although the stellar masses of the central galaxies in our simulations lie far below their stellar mass range ( @xmath132 ) , this decoupling of the probability from @xmath130 for satellites of dwarf galaxies allows us to make a comparison with the probabilities they find . their figure 2 suggests that for all central galaxies with @xmath133 , there is a @xmath134 chance that they host a satellite with stellar mass @xmath135 similar to our ultra - faints " . this is roughly consistent with the @xmath136 probability we find . they also find that the likelihood for a satellite as massive in proportion to its central as dsph " ( @xmath137 ) , is vanishingly small . again , according to their figure 2 and assuming that the lack of dependence of this probability on @xmath130 for dwarfs , there is only about a @xmath138 chance for a central to have such a massive satellite , which is again roughly consistent with the results shown in figure [ fig : ngtn ] . range @xmath139 with n or more subhalos with @xmath140 ( thick line ) and @xmath141 ( thin line ) that are found within @xmath122 of their host galaxy . in all of our hydrodynamic runs , all subhalos with @xmath142 have formed a galaxy with @xmath61 , while the most massive satellite , dsph " , forms in a subhalo with @xmath143 . according to these dark - matter only simulations , @xmath144 of isolated dwarfs should have a massive satellite " within their virial radii , but only @xmath145 should host a satellite as massive as dsph " . [ fig : ngtn ] ] our ultra - faint galaxies with @xmath146 all reside within low mass halos ( @xmath77 ) . they also have extremely diffuse stellar distributions , as expected for the ultra - faint , low dark - matter mass , stealth galaxies " discussed in b10 . figure [ fig : rhalf_v_l ] shows the projected ( 2d ) half stellar - mass radii , @xmath147 , of our simulated galaxies vs their total stellar mass . the central galaxies are shown as colored circles and the satellites as triangles ( the single unresolved satellite with @xmath61 is shown as an open triangle ) . the open black circles show observed milky way dwarfs @xcite . the black points with error bars are the half - mass radii and stellar masses of the eight recently reported ultra - faint satellite candidates from @xcite , and the single blue square with error bars is hydra ii from @xcite . the surface brightness detection limit for sdss is shown as a solid black line in the figure . it represents a constant peak central surface brightness for a plummer profile @xmath148 and corresponds to a surface brightness of @xmath149 for solar absolute magnitude @xmath150 and assuming a stellar mass - to - light ratio of @xmath151 . except for @xmath26 , all of our simulated ultra - faint " dwarfs have surface brightnesses fainter than @xmath152 , and would qualify as stealth galaxies " . ( see @xcite ) . while this suggests that we are dynamically well resolved , the effect on the baryonic component within this radius is harder to determine . in lower resolution runs , the satellites half - mass radii do vary by about a factor of two , but in both directions ( some are larger , some smaller ) . higher resolution simulations would be particularly useful for solidifying the expectations for the sizes of these galaxies . ] the dashed line in figure [ fig : rhalf_v_l ] shows a surface brightness of @xmath153 , a limit that will likely be achieved by upcoming surveys such as the large synoptic survey telescope ( lsst ) . once the full co - added lsst data is collected , satellites this faint should be able to detected out to @xmath154 over half the sky @xcite . , vs @xmath69 for all resolved galaxies in our simulations ( filled circles and triangles ; colors are the same as in figure [ fig:3panel ] ) , the one unresolved satellite with @xmath155 ( open triangle ) , as well as for observed milky way dwarfs ( * ? ? ? * open circles ) , the newly discovered des ultra - faint dwarf candidates ( * ? ? ? * black points with error - bars ) , and hydra ii ( * ? ? ? * blue square ) . the solid line represents a surface brightness limit of @xmath152 while the dashed line shows @xmath153 . both lines and the hydra ii data point assume a stellar mass - to - light ratio of 1 . satellites as massive as dsph " , which occur around @xmath156 of isolated dwarfs ( see figure [ fig : ngtn ] ) , should be currently visible , but most of the satellites lie just out of reach , and will visible only with future surveys such as lsst or potentially even des . [ fig : rhalf_v_l ] ] in the more immediate future , the dark energy survey ( des ) is already online . des will only be able to detect ultra - faint objects of this kind out to about @xmath118 , and is only slated to cover @xmath157 of the sky over its first 5 years . however , des contains within its footprint the dwarf galaxy phoenix . phoenix has a stellar mass of @xmath158 and is about @xmath159 away . it is falling into the milky way with a velocity of @xmath160 @xcite and is likely on first approach , meaning that it is a good analog to the isolated systems simulated in this work . this suggests that phoenix may be an excellent dwarf galaxy candidate to host an ultra - faint satellite detectable in the immediate future . it also has an advantage over more distant dwarfs like cetus or aquarius in that it is close enough that low luminosity satellites such as the ultra - faints " predicted in this work have a greater chance of being visible . although , according to figure [ fig : ngtn ] , there is only a @xmath144 chance that phoenix will host a subhalo massive enough to form a @xmath161 satellite , once the volume that lies between us and phoenix has been factored in , we find that the probability for finding an ultrafaint in its field increases to anywhere between @xmath162 according to the elvis simulations and depending on the specifics of abundance matching for @xmath163 satellites . in general , for future telescopes that have a limited number of pointings available , targeting the @xmath164 region around isolated dwarf galaxies should prove to be a much more efficient strategy than pointing into blank sky , as it should increase the chances of observing an ultra - faint satellite by @xmath8 . @xcite run a series of 12 zoom - in simulations of local group - like environments at three levels of resolution , both with baryons and with dark matter only . they run each simulation with and without a cosmic uv background that turns on sharply at @xmath165 , and argue that the onset of the ionizing background radiation sets the mass scale at which all halos become dark . their simulations shut down star formation in over @xmath166 of halos with present - day virial masses less than @xmath167 . their figure 2 does seem to show convergence in their highest resolution simulation run with reionization , but the gas particle mass in their highest resolution run ( @xmath168 ) is an order of magnitude higher than the total stellar mass formed in most of the the satellites that form in our simulations , indicating that they would fail to detect these galaxies . furthermore , their reionization turns on at a higher redshift than does ours ( @xmath47 ) , which may lead to a higher halo mass cutoff for star formation . @xcite run a zoom - in simulation of a small group of seven dwarf galaxies with a range of virial masses ( @xmath169 @xmath170 ) . they find that galaxies only form in the halos with present day @xmath171 , and of the halos that form galaxies , the two with @xmath172 only form stars long after the end of reionization . although they do not model @xmath173 cooling nor self - shielding in their simulations , they do approximate the effects of @xmath173 cooling and run a parallel simulation without a cosmic uv background . in their reionization - free simulation , all dwarfs form stars , but they show that the gas in the three low mass halos never reaches the column density required for self shielding . their baryonic particle mass is @xmath174 , the same particle mass we achieve in the low resolution runs of @xmath23 ( see @xcite for details ) . in our low resolution runs , each of the most massive subhalos forms an object with stellar mass similar to its high resolution counterpart , but at this resolution each satellite object consists of only @xmath175 star particles . while it is difficult to say conclusively that resolution is the main driver of their apparent halo mass limit for star formation , in general it has been the case that every time resolution is increased in simulations , the minimum virial mass for a halo that can form stars has approached lower values @xcite . in addition to enabling the formation of galaxies with @xmath69 lower than the low resolution baryonic particle mass , higher resolution simulations allow for a more accurate description of shielding , which will also affect the minimum halo mass that can form stars . furthermore , resolving the formation of dense substructures that collapse under self - gravity and become self - shielding requires resolving the jeans / toomre mass of the galaxies , which can be as low as @xmath176 ( and corresponds to a required force / gravitational softening of at least @xmath177 ) in baryon - poor dwarfs . our simulations do not escape the challenges of imperfect resolution , but because our particle mass is an order of magnitude lower than most simulations that attempt to form galaxies in low mass halos , we can push down the predicted low mass limit for the halos that can form ultra - faint satellites . rather than attempt to make a prediction for the low__est _ _ mass halo that can form a galaxy , we predict that ultra - faint dwarf galaxies _ can _ form in dark matter subhalos as low mass as @xmath65 . while we can not state with certainty that these galaxies are fully converged in our high resolution runs , the stellar masses of the satellites do show a better convergence between low and high resolution runs than do the centrals . ( see @xcite for a discussion of the convergence of the centrals ) . additionally , at these low masses , we still see sensitivity to spatial resolution and feedback ( e.g. the second satellite of @xmath30 ) . more and higher resolution runs of dwarfs with @xmath178 that vary feedback prescriptions , reionization onset and spectrum , and particle mass are needed to fully probe the low mass end of the simulated stellar mass function and the @xmath81 relation . in the @xmath13cdm paradigm , all dark matter halos , from those around giant galaxy clusters to those hosting ultra - faint galaxies , should be filled with subhalos . we have used ultra - high resolution ( @xmath179 ) simulations with the psph version of ` gizmo ` @xcite and the feedback in realistic environments ( fire ) prescriptions @xcite to predict that subhalos of isolated dwarf halos should form galaxies . most of the subhalos around dwarf galaxies are expected to be of low - mass ( @xmath180 ) and we predict that some should host ultra - faint galaxies with @xmath181 . if these tiny satellites are observed , it would provide evidence that dark matter substructure persists to very small scales , as predicted in the standard paradigm . using the dark - matter - only simulations of the elvis suite , we show that each isolated field dwarf ( @xmath182 ) galaxy in the local group has about a @xmath126 chance of hosting at least one satellite with @xmath116 . the extended @xmath164 regions around known field dwarfs in the local group should prove to be fruitful search areas for ultra - faint satellites , as each pointing towards a dwarf also contains all of the volume of the milky way dark matter halo along the line of sight to that region . the phoenix dwarf galaxy in particular is an excellent target due to its proximity to the milky way and the high probability that it is on first infall . although we consider only isolated dwarfs in this work , it is worth noting that some satellites of the milky way may also have their own satellites . @xcite show , using the elvis simulations , that approximately @xmath183 of milky way satellites ( but as many as @xmath184 depending on the infall time and mass of the group ) , fell in as a part of lmc - size groups , and that several of the recent des satellites are likely satellites of the lmc . a simple calculation for a rigid satellite assuming the common halo mass scale for milky way dwarf spheroidals ( @xmath185 ) orbiting a milky way - size host ( @xmath186 ) shows that fornax could potentially hold on to ultra - faint satellites residing within its inner @xmath187 . leo i and leo ii could each host ultra - faints out to @xmath188 , and sculptor out to @xmath189 , assuming each satellite is on first infall . this suggests that these galaxies might also be suitable candidates to host satellites of satellites " . we do not see a sharp cut - off or break in the @xmath81 relation , at least for @xmath140 . we do , however , see a sharp cut - off in halos that host galaxies with uniformly ancient stellar populations . the ultra - faint dwarfs in our simulations form most of their stars in the first billion years after the big bang and are subsequently deprived of the cold gas required for star formation due to the ionizing background radiation , and not by infall into a more massive dark matter halo . we predict that below a critical mass threshold ( @xmath190 , @xmath191 ) all galaxies are ubiquitously ancient and , unlike more massive galaxies ( @xmath192 ) that are nearly uniformly star forming in the field @xcite , both central and satellite ultra - faint galaxies should all be quenched . for satellites with @xmath193 , it is likely that infall time is one of the primary factors in quenching their star formation . massive satellites ( @xmath194 ) have been shown to have extremely long quenching timescales , probably due to the cutting off of the fresh gas supply after infall @xcite . slightly less massive galaxies ( @xmath195 ) are likely quenched over much shorter timescales by the tidal or ram - pressure forces they experience upon falling in as satellites @xcite . however , it is likely that the quenching of ultra - faints is completely independent of their infall time , and set by the timing of the onset of and the mass they had at reionization . the precise stellar masses of the ultra - faint " dwarfs in our simulations are likely also sensitive to the reionization redshift ( with an earlier onset of reionization likely to quench star formation in higher mass halos ) and may also be sensitive to star formation physics at very low metallicities . we plan to explore these dependencies in future work , but here we point out that it is possible to form ultra - faint satellites of regular dwarf galaxies and highlight that they are quenched by reionization rather than infall . the recent discovery of up to nine milky way dwarf satellite galaxy candidates in the southern sky by des @xcite has important consequences for our understanding of star formation in low mass galaxies . of particular interest is des j0344.3 - 4331 ( eridanus ii ) , because of its large distance from the milky way ( @xmath196 ) @xcite . at this distance , whether the satellite is on first infall or even headed out after a pericentric passage , it was likely accreted within the last @xmath197 . given that the initial age estimate for eridanus ii shows that it likely has an ancient stellar population ( @xmath198 ; * ? ? ? * ) , this would mean that it was quenched long before infall . if confirmed in follow - up observations , eridanus ii would be the first known ultra - faint galaxy shown to be quenched in the field , supporting our findings that , below a critical mass scale @xmath199 , all galaxies host ancient stellar populations quenched by reionization - related feedback , and not by environmental processes . this would be a clear example of a reionization fossil " , as first discussed by @xcite . we thank m. c. cooper for helpful discussions . this work used computational resources granted by nasa advanced supercomputing ( nas ) division , nasa center for climate simulation , teragrid and by the extreme science and engineering discovery environment ( xsede ) , which is supported by national science foundation grant number oci-1053575 and aci-1053575 , the latter through allocation ast140080 ( pi : boylan - kolchin ) . support for this work was also provided by nasa through _ hubble space telescope _ theory grants ( programs ar-12836 and ar-13888 ) from the space telescope science institute ( stsci ) , which is operated by the association of universities for research in astronomy ( aura ) , inc . , under nasa contract nas5 - 26555 . cw and oe were supported by _ hubble space telescope _ grants hst - ar-13921.002-a and hst - ar-13888.003-a , and sgk by the national science foundation grant ast-1009999 . support for pfh was provided by the gordon and betty moore foundation through grant # 776 to the caltech moore center for theoretical cosmology and physics , an alfred p. sloan research fellowship , nasa atp grant nnx14ah35 g , and nsf collaborative research grant # 1411920 . dk received support from national science foundation grant number ast-1412153 , funds from the university of california , san diego and xsede allocation tg - ast-120025 . n. et al . , 2002 , in society of photo - optical instrumentation engineers ( spie ) conference series , vol . 4836 , survey and other telescope technologies and discoveries , tyson j. a. , wolff s. , eds . , pp . 154164 s. , bessell m. , schmidt b. , francis p. , 2007 , in astronomical society of the pacific conference series , vol . 364 , the future of photometric , spectrophotometric and polarimetric standardization , sterken c. , ed .
Abstract: | [
"we present fire/`gizmo ` hydrodynamic zoom - in simulations of isolated dark matter halos , two each at the mass of classical dwarf galaxies ( @xmath0 ) and ultra - faint galaxies ( @xmath1 ) , and with two feedback implementations . the resulting central galaxies lie on an extrapolated abundance matching relation from @xmath2 to @xmath3 without a break . every host is filled with subhalos , many of which form stars . our dwarfs with @xmath4 each have @xmath5 well - resolved satellites with @xmath6 . even our isolated ultra - faint galaxies have star - forming subhalos . if this is representative , dwarf galaxies throughout the universe should commonly host tiny satellite galaxies of their own . we combine our results with the elvis simulations to show that targeting @xmath7 regions around nearby isolated dwarfs could increase the chances of discovering ultra - faint galaxies by @xmath8 compared to random halo pointings , and specifically identify the region around the phoenix dwarf galaxy as a good potential target . the well - resolved ultra - faint galaxies in our simulations ( @xmath9 ) form within @xmath10 halos . each has a uniformly ancient stellar population ( @xmath11 ) owing to reionization - related quenching . more massive systems , in contrast , all have late - time star formation . our results suggest that @xmath12 is a probable dividing line between halos hosting reionization fossils \" and those hosting dwarfs that can continue to form stars in isolation after reionization . [ firstpage ] galaxies : dwarf galaxies : star formation"
] | 8,976 | 8,976 | 12,000 |
Write an abstract for the following acadamic paper. | Paper: we have recorded the flight of a fly during take off and landing using digital high speed photography . it is shown that the dynamics of flexible wings are different for these procedures . during this observation fly flew freely in a big box and it was not tethered .
Abstract: in this fluid dynamics video , we demonstrated take off and landing of a fly . the deformation of wings is in focus in this video .
Paper: recently , there has been a great deal of activity aimed at studying the synchronization of coupled oscillators of diverse nature @xcite . the theory of synchronization implies that even in uncoupled state the individual elementary units exhibit self - sustained oscillations . however no less interesting are the systems where local coupling is essential for the very generation of oscillations and not only for their modulation or phase adjustment . as far back as in early 1970s , smale @xcite constructed a counterintuitive mathematical example of a biological cell modeled by the chemical kinetics of four metabolites , @xmath0 , such that the reaction equations @xmath1 for the set of metabolites , @xmath2 , had a globally stable equilibrium . the cell is `` dead '' , in that the concentrations of its metabolites always tend to the same fixed levels . when two such cells are coupled by linear diffusion terms of the form @xmath3 , where @xmath4 is a diagonal matrix with the elements @xmath5 , however , the resulting equations are shown to have a globally stable limit cycle . the concentrations of the metabolites begin to oscillate , and the system becomes `` alive '' . in smale s words : _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ there is a paradoxical aspect to the example . one has two dead ( mathematically dead ) cells interacting by a diffusion process which has a tendency in itself to equalize the concentrations . yet in interaction , a state continues to pulse indefinitely . _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the reaction equations involved in smale s model were too general to appeal to any specific process . since then , inspired by his pioneer work , a number of models have been proposed containing biologically plausible mechanisms by which coupling of identical nonoscillating cells could generate synchronous oscillations . among them are a model of electrically coupled cells , characterized by an excitable membrane and calcium dynamics @xcite , a model in which coupling a passive diffusive cytoplasmic bulk with an excitable membrane ( having an activator - inhibitor dynamics ) produces a self - sustained oscillatory behavior @xcite , an analog operational - amplifier implementation of neural cells connected by passive coupling ( where conductance of the resistive connection simulates the diffusion coefficient ) @xcite , etc . the authors of the last model suggested a term awakening dynamics for the phenomenon . the subject of the present paper is an emergence of collective oscillations in a system of coupled nonoscillatory consumer - resource ( cr ) pairs . owing to simplicity , this model in a sense may be considered minimal . our choice of coupled cr equations as a matter of enquiry is dictated primarily by the ubiquity and importance of cr interactions . cr models are the fundamental building blocks used in mathematical description and simulation of ecosystems . depending on a specific nature of the involved cr interactions , they can take the forms of predator - prey , plant - herbivore , parasite - host , and victim - exploiter systems @xcite . however applications of the cr models extend far beyond the ecology and are found wherever one can speak of win - loss interactions . in its broad meaning , resource is any substance which can lead to increased growth rate of the consumer as its availability in the environment is increased . as this takes place , the resource is certainly consumed . consuming the resource means tending to reduce its availability . when carefully examined , cr models are identified in the following fields : epidemiology ( susceptible and infected ( * ? ? ? * ch . 10 ) ) , laser dynamics ( photons and electrons ( * ? ? ? 6 ) ) , labor economics ( share of labor and employment rate @xcite ) , theoretical immunology ( antigens and b lymphocytes @xcite ) , kinetics of chain chemical reactions ( lipid molecules and free radicals @xcite ) , and in numerous other studies from diverse disciplines . we consider the situation when each of two consumer species exploits one respective resource only . as explained in appendix , terms `` consumer '' and `` resource '' in our model may bear not only their literal ecological meaning , but the physical meaning of photon density and population inversion in a laser cavity as well . both resources are being supplied with constant rates like in a chemostat and consumed according to a simple mass - action kinetics . the resources are thought to be noninteractive . when uncoupled , self - inhibition of the individual consumer population is due to intraspecific interference . the coupling is assumed to originate solely from the interspecific interference competition between the consumers and quantitatively expressed by a bilinear term combining the competitor densities . the per individual loss rate of either consumer is proportional to the density of its counterpart . representation of competition between species in terms of loss - coupling dates back to the classical model of lotka volterra gause ( lvg ) @xcite . the lvg model operates with carrying capacities of the species , rather than referring explicitly to any essential resources . as shown by macarthur @xcite , lvg equations may be considered as a quasi - steady - state approximation to the cr equations accentuating resource - mediated nature of competition , under the assumption of relatively rapid dynamics of the involved resources . thereafter trophic competition have developed into a major descriptor of competition in the ecological literature generally , and in conceptualizing ecosystems as systems of coupled cr oscillators specifically @xcite . in contrast to the prevailing models of competition we consider the case of pure interspecific interference competition between the consumers with no consumption - induced contribution . actually , our model is nothing more nor less than lvg equations augmented with the rate equations for the resources . another key assumption of the model is that the dynamics of the consumers is much faster than that of the resources . from a physical perspective , by and large similar equations with the like time hierarchy ( fast consumer and slow resource ) have been in use for coupled longitudinal modes in a semiconductor laser with an intracavity - doubling crystal since the work of baer @xcite . these equations have been treated mostly numerically . the notable analytical result belongs to erneux and mandel @xcite who succeeded to show that the system admits antiphase periodic solutions by reducing it to the equations for quasi - conservative oscillator . however this result has to do with the onset of low - amplitude quasi - harmonic oscillations . unlike their study , our approach deals with well - developed high - amplitude essentially nonlinear oscillations . besides , we propose the model to be valid not only for competing laser modes , but for loss - coupled lasers as well . we analyze the model using geometric singular perturbation technique according to which the full system of equations is decomposed into fast and slow subsystems . as we shall see below , the model reveals qualitatively different behavior at intense and weak competition between the consumer species . if coupling is strong , one of the consumers wins and completely dominates . when coupling is weak , the model exhibits low - frequency antiphase relaxation oscillations with each species alternatively taking the dominant role . the two - consumer , two - resource model we consider is the following nondimensional system of four ordinary differential equations : [ coupled - uv ] @xmath6 here dots indicate differentiation with respect to the nondimensional time variable @xmath7 , @xmath8 and @xmath9 ( @xmath10 ) are quantities measuring the respective population sizes of @xmath11th resource and @xmath11th consumer , @xmath12 ( @xmath10 ) is the inflow rate of @xmath11th resource , @xmath13 is a parameter representing consumer self - limitation , @xmath14 ( @xmath15 and @xmath16 ) quantifies the inhibitory effect of @xmath17th consumer on the growth of @xmath11th consumer due to coupling , and @xmath18 is a singular perturbation parameter indicating that the dynamics of the consumers is much faster than that of the resources . it should be mentioned that being proportional to its dimensional prototype , @xmath9 directly represents population density of consumer species and is always nonnegative . quantity @xmath8 , however , is not a population size in the true sense of the word . it is rather an affine transformation of a population size of the form @xmath19 , where @xmath20 and @xmath21 are scaling constants . this is done for reasons of mathematical convenience . unlike a purely linear transformation , an affine map does not preserve the zero point , so in @xmath22 corresponds to zero population size in reality . nevertheless , from here on we shall apply the term `` resource '' to @xmath8 for brevity . for more details and discussion on the derivation of the model from different perspectives the reader is referred to appendix . when @xmath23 , the communities are uncoupled and completely independent . an isolated cr pair is governed by equations [ isolated - uv ] @xmath24 there exist two nonnegative steady states : [ steady - uv ] @xmath25 the linearization of takes the form @xmath26 where ( @xmath27 , @xmath28 ) is one of the above steady states . at , one eigenvalue is negative and one is positive : @xmath29 , @xmath30 . thus is a saddle point . at , @xmath31 and @xmath32 , so the steady state is a stable node / focus . specifically , focus is the case for @xmath33 whence one obtains an asymptotic estimate @xmath34 fig . [ fig01]c illustrates this focus - node bifurcation numerically . damped oscillations is a well - known inherent feature of the photon - carrier dynamics in class - b lasers . an isolated cr system admits therefore , only solution which tends asymptotically towards the unique steady state . periodic solutions are excluded . however the temporal dynamics of approaching this steady state essentially depends on the interplay between @xmath35 and @xmath36 , and is worth another look . there are in fact three timescales , @xmath37 , @xmath38 and @xmath39 , involved in the cr system when it is overdamped , and two@xmath37 and @xmath38when underdamped . system is singularly perturbed because the derivative of one of its state variables , @xmath40 , is multiplied by a small positive parameter @xmath35 . singular perturbation cause two - time - scale behavior of the system characterized by the presence of slow and fast transients in the system s response to external stimuli . replacing @xmath7 in with a fast time variable @xmath41 and setting @xmath42 we obtain the fast subsystem [ isolated - fast ] @xmath43 where prime means differentiation with respect to @xmath44 . in the stretched timescale @xmath44 the slow resource variable @xmath45 , according to , is replaced by its initial value and reckoned as constant parameter . equation is of a logistic type which has the solution @xmath46 valid for @xmath47 . after a lapse of considerable time ( in the fast scale ) @xmath40 converges to either of two fixed points depending on a sign of @xmath45 : @xmath48 it means that every single trajectory starting within the positive quadrant of @xmath49 plane far enough from the stable steady state will run almost parallel to the vertical axis and hit the line @xmath50 practically in a finite time of order @xmath37 . this is shown in fig . [ fig01]a b . now set @xmath42 in to get the slow subsystem [ isolated - slow ] @xmath51 the equation describes a slow manifold consisting of two lines in the @xmath49 plane : @xmath52 and @xmath53 . by , the former attracts all the trajectories in the first quadrant , while the latter all those in the second . inasmuch as the quasi - steady state of , @xmath54 , is an isolated root of and @xmath28 is a stable solution of for any @xmath55 , the assumptions of tikhonov s theorem @xcite are satisfied , and one may proceed to approximate @xmath45 and @xmath40 in terms of the solution of the reduced system in the slow timescale . it means that after arriving at the slow manifold @xmath52 , the representing point of the full system will move along the manifold toward the equilibrium point with a characteristic velocity of order @xmath38 . in the immediate proximity to equilibrium the behavior of the trajectory is determined by the type of the fixed point , whether it is a node or a focus . eventually this depends on the value of @xmath36 . namely , close to a stable node , the system has two distinct real negative eigenvalues , one fast ( @xmath56 ) , and one slow ( @xmath57 ) : @xmath58 since @xmath59 , trajectories starting off the associated eigenvector 2 ( which is tangent to the slow manifold @xmath52 ) converge to that vector along lines almost parallel to eigenvector 1 ( which is parallel to the vertical axis @xmath40 ) . as they approach vector 2 they become tangent to it and move along it up to the very nodal point ( fig . [ fig01]a ) . the characteristic time constant of this final stage is of order @xmath39 . in the vicinity of a stable focus the motion is qualitatively different : trajectories still keep converging to the equilibrium , but no longer follow the slow manifold @xmath52 ( fig . [ fig01]b ) . the reason is that for a focus eigenvectors are complex . recalling that condition must be true for a focus , calculate the eigenvalues in a limit case of @xmath60 : @xmath61 loosely speaking , one may think that near a focal point separation of state variables into slow and fast ones ceases to have its conventional meaning . there is no point to talk about motion along the slow manifold since there are no reduced one - dimensional systems corresponding to the neighborhood of a focus . the perturbation parameter @xmath35 affects only the frequency of damped oscillation , but not the damping rate . the radius of the focal spiral uniformly shrinks with a time constant of order @xmath38 . to @xmath38 for small @xmath36 there is a way to recast the equations near the focal equilibrium @xmath62 in a convenient form where the perturbation parameter @xmath35 does not multiply any right hand side . namely , performing the scaling @xmath63 , @xmath64 and @xmath65 , where @xmath66 , one obtains @xmath67 here dots stand for differentiation with respect to the time variable @xmath68 . equations represent a weakly perturbed hamiltonian system . for @xmath69 the system is pure hamiltonian and admits the first integral @xmath70 which is a conserved quantity ( @xmath71 ) . the periodic solutions of the hamiltonian system form a one - parameter family with the equilibrium @xmath72 as center point . the condition @xmath73 makes equations quasi - conservative with phase trajectories slowly spiralling to the equilibrium ( fig . [ fig02 ] ) . system can be rewritten as a second order differential equation for @xmath74 only : @xmath75 this is the equation for a nonlinear quasi - conservative oscillator . as is seen from , for @xmath76 and @xmath77 the oscillator is not only quasi - conservative , but also a quasi - linear with the frequency @xmath78 . these conditions motivate introducing the new variable @xmath79 . as a result one obtains @xmath80 this equation of quasi - conservative , quasi - linear oscillator will be used later on when analyzing the onset of synchronous periodicity . in the following , we will distinguish two main types of coupling : strong , @xmath81 , and weak , @xmath82 . physically feasible equilibria , or fixed points , @xmath83 , of are those for which @xmath84 . we denote the interior fixed point by @xmath85 , where the subscripts stand for the consumers . lack of a certain index at a boundary fixed point means that the consumer concerned is not present ( extinct ) . thus @xmath86 and @xmath87 designate either of one - consumer equilibria corresponding to dominance , while @xmath88 means both consumers having been washed out . model has four feasible steady states . to @xmath38 for small @xmath36 [ ss ] @xmath89 where @xmath90 . boundary equilibria @xmath91 , @xmath92 and @xmath93 always exist . @xmath94 exists if [ existf12 ] @xmath95 in case the expression with `` @xmath96 '' in is realized , while in case the one with `` @xmath97 '' is feasible . @xmath91 is always unstable , because two of the four associated eigenvalues are positive : @xmath98 correct to @xmath38 in @xmath35 , the eigenvalues for @xmath92 and @xmath93 are [ lambdaf1f2 ] @xmath99 whence it follows that and are stable when [ stabilityf1f2 ] @xmath100 respectively . the necessary and sufficient conditions for all the eigenvalues of the jacobian matrix , @xmath101 evaluated at @xmath94 , to have negative real parts are , from the routh hurwitz criterion , [ routh ] @xmath102 where @xmath103 , @xmath104 , @xmath105 and @xmath106 are the coefficients of the characteristic polynomial @xmath107 of : @xmath108 to analyze the validity of we put @xmath109 , where @xmath110 . then for to be true , @xmath111 should be met , which is incompatible with strong coupling , yet possible for weak coupling . conditions and are always valid . as is known , guarantees a simple complex conjugate pair of eigenvalues corresponding to a linearization about steady state @xmath94 to have negative real part . for @xmath111 it boils down to @xmath112 whence it follows that @xmath113 with regard to a fairly small value of @xmath35 , may be thought to be broken under most physically meaningful conditions unless coupling is infinitesimally weak . hence , normally , condition of the routh hurwitz criterion is never fulfilled and the interior fixed point @xmath94if it exists is always unstable by growing oscillations . existence and stability conditions of possible nonnegative equilibrium points are summarized in table [ tab1 ] . .existence and stability conditions of nonnegative equilibria of system . [ cols="<,<,<",options="header " , ] [ tab1 ] strong coupling in makes possible bistability of boundary equilibria , as evident from table [ tab1 ] . when both @xmath92 and @xmath93 are stable with an unstable coexistence steady state @xmath94 , the system being studied is able to exhibit a hysteresis effect . given the strong coupling , suppose , that the inflow of resource 2 is kept at some constant level , @xmath114 , while the inflow of resource 1 , @xmath115 , steadily increases from a value less than @xmath116 along the line @xmath114 in the @xmath117 parameter plane , as shown in fig . [ fig03]a . referring to and , one sees that initially @xmath92 is unstable , @xmath93 is stable and @xmath94 does not exist with the complete dominance of consumer 2 . within the interval @xmath118 steady state @xmath92 becomes stable yet empty and @xmath94 becomes existent ( according to ) yet unstable , so the situation remains unchanged until point @xmath119 in fig . [ fig03]a has been reached from the left . for a larger @xmath115 , state @xmath93 gives up its stability and the system jumps to @xmath92 . consumer 2 gets washed out , while consumer 1 takes over . if now we start reducing @xmath115 , the system remains in @xmath92 until @xmath115 drops to the lower critical value @xmath116 , beyond which @xmath92 is no longer stable and there is a reverse jump to @xmath93 . in other words , as @xmath115 progresses along @xmath114 there is a discontinuous switch from consumer 2 to consumer 1 at @xmath120 , while as @xmath115 retraces its steps , there is a discontinuous switch from consumer 1 to consumer 2 at @xmath116 . [ fig03]b illustrates how the steady state level of consumer 1 responds to infinitesimally slow changes of the inflow rate of its own resource . the hysteresis is made possible thanks to the concurrent stability of both boundary equilibria and instability of the interior fixed point for @xmath121 . in terms of electronics , such a situation would describe a flip - flop circuit bistable multivibrator having two stable conditions , each corresponding to one of two alternative input signals . as seen from table [ tab1 ] , the very existence of interior equilibrium @xmath94 in a case of weak coupling ( condition ) implies instability of both boundary fixed points , @xmath92 and @xmath93 . system happens to possess four nonnegative steady states , none of them being stable . as we have found , @xmath94 is unstable through growing oscillations . in such a case , the model would thus be expected to have a limit cycle in its four - dimensional phase space corresponding to self - sustained oscillations . as is known , hopf bifurcations come in both super- and subcritical types . if a small , attracting limit cycle appears immediately after the fixed point goes unstable , and if its amplitude shrinks back to zero as the parameter is reversed , the bifurcation is supercritical ; otherwise , it s probably subcritical , in which case the nearest attractor might be far from the fixed point , and the system may exhibit hysteresis as the parameter is reversed . to check whether the bifurcation is supercritical or subcritical , we employ the averaging method @xcite . for negligible @xmath36 the problem reduces to weakly coupled quasi - conservative oscillators . introduce the new time @xmath122 , where @xmath123 . the new dynamic variables @xmath124 and @xmath125 are defined by formulas @xmath126 and @xmath127 . thus the variables @xmath124 and @xmath125 are the respective deviations of @xmath128 and @xmath129 from their standalone steady state values . with these new variables equations become [ hamilton4 ] @xmath130 where dots mean differentiation with respect to @xmath68 and @xmath131 are the scaled coupling strengths . for brevity , we restrict our consideration to the case of identical cr pairs and symmetric coupling setting @xmath132 and @xmath133 . with these assumptions system can be transformed to two coupled second - order equations for quasi - conservative , quasi - linear oscillators . this can be done as follows . first , and are solved for @xmath134 and @xmath135 . secondly , and are differentiated with respect to time to get @xmath136 and @xmath137 . thirdly , @xmath134 , @xmath135 , @xmath138 and @xmath139 are plugged into the equations for @xmath136 and @xmath137 . and finally , @xmath125 are replaced by the new variables @xmath140 : @xmath141 . as a consequence , we arrive at the following coupled equations : @xmath142 where @xmath143 we seek the solution of in the quasi - harmonic form @xmath144 where @xmath145 and @xmath146 are slowly varying amplitudes and phases , and @xmath147 is the frequency of the synchronous oscillations . differentiating the assumed form of @xmath140 and equating the result to the assumed form of @xmath148 yields the first pair of relationships between @xmath145 and @xmath146 : @xmath149 then , differentiating @xmath148 and substituting the resulting expression for @xmath150 as well as the assumed forms for @xmath140 and @xmath148 into yields the second pair of equations relating @xmath145 and @xmath146 . separating into equations for the rate of change of @xmath145 and @xmath146 one obtains @xmath151 where @xmath152 to this point no approximations have been made except of the expansion in powers of @xmath153 in . averaging equations over the period @xmath154 and considering @xmath145 , @xmath146 , @xmath155 and @xmath156 to be constants while performing the averaging , one obtains the following equations describing the slow variations of @xmath145 and @xmath146 : [ aver1 ] @xmath157 where @xmath158 . any stable fixed points of could mean that the phase difference between the coupled oscillators do not change in time ( @xmath159 ) , and the oscillations are periodic with constant amplitudes @xmath145 . thus , finding the conditions when these fixed points are stable would mean finding the conditions at which the synchronization occurs . equations show that the first approximation of the averaging method does not predict any nonzero steady - state amplitudes . the reason for this seems to lie in the fact that the even terms in do not contribute to the value of integral . to take account of them we have to employ in what follows the second approximation of the averaging method . as to the phase difference , @xmath160 , we see that stable is only antiphase steady - state regime with @xmath161 . let @xmath162 be the vector of the right - hand sides of . also denote the operation of averaging by the angle brackets @xmath163 . then @xmath164 will mean the right - hand sides of . following the conventional procedure we retain only vibrational terms in @xmath162 , @xmath165 and integrate @xmath166 up to an arbitrary function of the amplitudes chosen for simplicity to be equal to zero : @xmath167 now , upon calculation of the jacobian matrix @xmath168 , we can write down the second approximation symbolically as @xmath169 ( the terms now neglected by averaging are of a higher order of magnitude with respect to the small parameters than the terms neglected in the first approximation . ) due to the symmetry of the case we may set @xmath170 enabling us to present the resulting equations of the second approximation as compact as possible : [ aver2 ] @xmath171 the stable steady - state solution for the phase difference is @xmath161 . inserting this value into and putting @xmath172 we get three different steady - state solutions for @xmath20 ( including the trivial one ) , of which only one , @xmath173 being stable . formula indicates a soft transition to sustained oscillations as the coupling parameter @xmath174 is progressively increased from a critical value . thus we expect that the hopf bifurcation is supercritical . [ fig04 ] plots @xmath175 phase planes for coupling strength below and above the hopf bifurcation . when @xmath176 ( consumers are decoupled ) the internal equilibrium is a stable focus ( fig . [ fig04]a ) . for @xmath177 ( very weak coupling ; just below the bifurcation ) @xmath94 is still a stable focus , though a very gently winding one : the decay is slow ( fig . [ fig04]b ) . for @xmath178 ( very weak coupling ; just above the bifurcation ) there is an unstable focus at @xmath94 and a stable oval limit cycle of small size representing low - amplitude quasi - harmonic oscillations ( fig . [ fig04]c ) . on further increasing of coupling strength the limit cycle continuously grows in size and takes an irregular shape indicating nonlinearity of the synchronous oscillations ( fig . [ fig04]d f ) . as a practical matter , the range of very weak coupling not too far away from the hopf bifurcation , where oscillations are quasi - linear and quasi - harmonic , is of less concern to us than is the range of far more feasible not - too - weak coupling , corresponding to well - developed substantially nonlinear oscillations . we are going to demonstrate that given conditions , system exhibits relaxation oscillatory behavior , with the two coupled cr pairs being antiphase locked . by the assumption , @xmath179 , meaning that system is singularly perturbed . the slow variables are resources , @xmath180 and @xmath181 , and the fast variables are consumers , @xmath182 and @xmath183 . the standard practice of reducing such systems is the adiabatic elimination of the fast variables , when the left - hand side in the fast equation is replaced by zero , thus turning this differential equation into an algebraic equation . it is assumed that the fast variables quickly relax to their momentary equilibrium , quasi - steady - state , values obtained from the algebraic equations , in which the slow variables are treated as parameters . `` frozen '' slow variables do not move substantially in this short adaptation time of the fast variables . quasi - steady - state values of the fast variables can then be expressed by values of the slow variables . the fast variables hastily adapt to the motion of the slow variables . the former are entrained by the latter . the utility of quasi - steady - state approximation is that it allows us to reduce the dimension of the system by retaining only slow variables in the model . one has to establish the validity of the adiabatic elimination in each specific case by using the recommendations of the singular perturbation theory @xcite . in particular , tikhonov s theorem @xcite requires the quasi - steady state of the fast equations to be stable . to decompose the full system into fast and slow subsystems , introduce fast time variable @xmath41 . now rescale by replacing @xmath7 with @xmath184 and , after taking @xmath42 , it becomes [ fast ] @xmath185 where prime means differentiation with respect to @xmath44 . this is the fast subsystem , where @xmath180 and @xmath181 are replaced by their initial values and treated as parameters . it yields inner solution , valid for @xmath47 . setting @xmath42 in leads to the slow subsystem [ slow ] @xmath186 which produces outer solution , valid for @xmath187 . in this singular limit as @xmath188 , the subsystem defines a slow flow on the surface ( slow manifold ) given by . outer solution is valid for those @xmath180 and @xmath181 , for which the quasi - steady states of the fast subsystem are stable . we anticipate the dynamics of the full system in its four - dimensional phase space @xmath189 to consist of two typical motions : quickly approaching the slow manifold , and slowly sliding over it until a leave point ( where the solution disappears ) is reached . after that , the representing point may possibly jump to another local solution of . thus , we ought to find all quasi - steady states of the fast subsystem , map the domains of their stability onto the slow phase plane @xmath190 , and then investigate the dynamics of the slow subsystem with piecewise continuous functions . fast subsystem , which is nothing but the conventional lvg model , has four quasi - steady states three boundary and one interior denoted by @xmath191 ( the slow variables are deemed to be frozen ) : [ qss ] @xmath192 existence and stability of these quasi - steady states is determined by @xmath190position of a representing point in the phase plane of the slow subsystem , shown in fig . [ fig05]a . @xmath191 , @xmath193 and @xmath194 always exist for all @xmath180 and @xmath181 from the positive quadrant of the slow phase plane . for not - too - weak coupling , such that @xmath195 , @xmath196 exists for all @xmath180 and @xmath181 satisfying the condition @xmath197 , i.e. within the opening of the angle formed by lines @xmath198 and @xmath199 in fig . [ fig05]a . the opening shrinks as the coupling strengths get weaker . jacobian matrix of the fast subsystem , @xmath200 has the following sets of eigenvalues at : [ eigqss ] @xmath201 based on one concludes that @xmath191 ( the origin ) is always an unstable node for all @xmath180 and @xmath181 from the positive quadrant of the slow phase plane . @xmath193 is a stable node for @xmath202 , i.e. below the line @xmath203 in fig . [ fig05]a , otherwise it is a saddle . similarly , @xmath194 is a stable node for @xmath204 , i.e. above the line @xmath205 in the plane of slow variables , otherwise it is a saddle . the interior quasi - steady state , @xmath196 , is always a saddle . the performed typology of fixed points of the fast subsystem leads to three qualitatively different phase portraits depicted by fig . [ fig05]b d . suppose initially @xmath193 is stable and @xmath194 is not . consumer 1 completely dominates . this corresponds to slow variables @xmath180 and @xmath181 being somewhere below the line @xmath205 of fig . [ fig05]a . fast subsystem has phase portrait of a type shown in fig . [ fig05]b . while @xmath180 remains much greater than @xmath206 , the dynamics of the resources ( treated as bifurcation parameters in reference to the consumers ) is described by a system of two independent equations [ slow - piecewise1 ] @xmath207 which is a piecewise version of the slow subsystem for @xmath208 and @xmath209 . system has stable steady state @xmath210 where @xmath211 . this equilibrium lies in the upper left corner of fig . [ fig05]a . while heading to , the trajectory crosses the line @xmath205 and enters the domain of bistability of both @xmath193 and @xmath194 . fast subsystem takes new phase portrait of a type presented by fig . [ fig05]c . however the dominance of consumer 1 persists . upon introducing the deviations @xmath134 and @xmath212 from the respective steady states , the system becomes [ slow - piecewise1-xi - eta ] @xmath213 whence one finds @xmath214 it follows from , that the dynamics of variable @xmath180 is faster than that of @xmath181 due to small @xmath36 . clearly , the representing point must have relaxed to the vertical line @xmath215 well before approaching the horizontal line @xmath216 . further developments depend on whether the involved individual cr systems are overdamped or underdamped . if @xmath36 is great enough to damp intrinsic oscillations in the constituent cr pairs , the representing point will slide along the nullcline @xmath217 ( slow manifold of the system ) , steadily tending to point ( fig . [ fig06]a ) . if @xmath36 is small in terms of the condition , then the individual cr pairs are underdamped . in the immediate vicinity of @xmath218 the division of variables on slow and fast ones loses its meaning and the reduced equation is no longer valid . instead of one should write down two equations : [ constituent - u1v1 ] @xmath219 however this system is identical to equations for an uncoupled cr system and , in essence , describes convergence to a focal point via dying oscillations . in the plane of slow variables @xmath190 these oscillations manifest themselves in damped transverse fluctuations superimposed on the independent vertical motion along the nullcline @xmath217 ( @xmath220 ) toward point ( fig . [ fig06]b ) . by virtue of the condition , the trajectory has to cross the line @xmath199 on its way toward the neighborhood of steady state . as soon as this has happened , node @xmath193 in the plane @xmath221 will be absorbed by saddle @xmath196 . a new phase portrait of the fast subsystem takes on the appearance of fig . [ fig05]d . consumer 1 rapidly washes out , and the alternative boundary quasi - steady state @xmath194 becomes stable , with consumer 2 dominating . in terms of the four - dimensional phase space of full system , the representing point is now in the other stable branch of the slow manifold . the motion over this alternative branch obeys the piecewise subsystem [ slow - piecewise2 ] @xmath222 with the initial conditions @xmath223 and @xmath224 . the dynamics of is basically similar to that of analyzed above . system has a stable steady state @xmath225 where @xmath226 . this equilibrium lies in the lower right corner of fig . [ fig05]a . variable @xmath181 , being more rapid in comparison to @xmath180 , quickly enters the neighborhood of the nullcline @xmath227 given by @xmath228 , and then depending on the value of @xmath36finally approaches the nullcline either monotonically ( fig . [ fig06]a ) or via damped oscillations according to equations [ constituent - u2v2 ] @xmath229 ( fig . [ fig06]b ) . system describes underdamped intrinsic oscillations of uncoupled consumer 2 for small @xmath36 . at the same time , @xmath180 steadily and independently tends to @xmath230 . again , because point is located below the line @xmath231 ( on the strengths of the condition ) , the trajectory would certainly cross that line at a point @xmath232 , whereupon node @xmath194 would be absorbed by saddle @xmath196 . the system returns to the first branch of the slow manifold , and thereby the oscillatory cycle gets closed . fig . [ fig07 ] shows the results of a numerical integration of system for the case of underdamped individual consumer - research pairs . the two coupled communities execute self - sustained relaxation oscillations which are antiphase - locked . the resources @xmath180 and @xmath181 demonstrate sawtooth periodic pulses . the oscillation range for the resource levels remains finite and , what is important , it does not depend on the intrinsic second order loss @xmath36 ( measuring intraspecific interference ) . the times of motion over either branch of the slow manifold and add up to give a predominant contribution to the period of oscillations , @xmath233 . these times are determined mainly by the dynamics of the slow resource variables @xmath180 and @xmath181 and , to a zeroth approximation in @xmath35 and @xmath36 , can be found as solutions to the equations of motion and with respective boundary conditions @xmath234 and @xmath235 . in this way one obtains a quite simple estimate for the period : @xmath236 it is interesting that , according to , the period depends on the ratio of the two resource inflows , @xmath115 and @xmath237 , rather than on each of them individually , and does not depend completely on concrete value of @xmath36 . the consumers @xmath182 and @xmath183 change periodically between extinction and respective constant levels @xmath115 and @xmath237 . very brief transient from zero to flat nonzero level within each cycle is accompanied by a highly pronounced spiky overshoot . the magnitude of the spike tends to infinity as @xmath60 , in view of and . depending on the intensity of intraspecific interference , the overshoot may or may not be followed by a tail of fading high - frequency oscillations , when a consumer variable falls below its steady - state value and then bounce back above , taking some time to settle close to its steady - state value . in signal processing , such a kind of transient oscillations is known as `` ringing '' . there is no ringing if the involved cr pair does not oscillate due to significant intraspecific interference . ringing takes place if intraspecific interference is negligible and therefore the involved cr pair is characterized by underdamped intrinsic oscillations . the `` pitch '' of ringing is just the frequency of these intrinsic oscillations . one notices that when one consumer is very scanty , the coupled system behaves like an isolated cr pair . another essential feature of the dynamics is the role of the resource variables in determining when the consumers emerge and wash out . when @xmath180 , for example , rises above a threshold value ( determined by the amount of losses experienced by @xmath182 ) then @xmath182 comes into dominance causing @xmath183 in turn to disappear . so except for their transient spiking and ringing , the consumer levels , either flat nonzero or essentially zero , are determined by the hysteretic cycling of the respective resources . scrutinizing a cycle of consumer oscillations one may distinguish four parts within it : @xmath182 is essentially zero , while @xmath183 is approximately equal to its uncoupled steady - state value , @xmath237 . @xmath180 increases due to its inflow until it overcomes losses for consumer 1 ; with a sufficient resource stock , @xmath182 now emerges . the population exhibits a spike due to the fast time scale of the consumer equations . the sharp increase in population saturates the available resource level , so @xmath180 drops . cross - losses cause @xmath183 to wash out ; @xmath182 and @xmath180 relax to quasi - steady - state values , as if there were only one isolated cr pair . @xmath183 is essentially zero . @xmath181 is increasing , like @xmath180 did in part 1 ; @xmath181 surpasses the losses , @xmath183 emerges and the subsequent cross - losses cause @xmath182 to wash out . the spiking @xmath183 also causes a substantial decrease in the available stock of the associated resource . the sequence begins again . presenting his famous model smale remarked that `` it is more difficult to reduce the number of chemicals to two or even three '' @xcite . as distinct from smale s example , coupling in our case makes self - sustained synchronous oscillations possible for just two variables . as we have seen , phase trajectory of the system constantly moves from the neighborhood of unstable boundary equilibrium @xmath92 where only consumer 1 is present , to the neighborhood of @xmath93 where consumer 2 completely dominates , back to @xmath92 , and so on in cyclic alternation . this kind of trajectory was termed `` heteroclinic cycle '' by kirlinger @xcite . a heteroclinic cycle occurs when the outflow ( unstable manifold ) from one saddle point is directly connected to the inflow ( stable manifold ) of another saddle point , and vice versa . it is closely related to another notion of the nonlinear dynamics , a homoclinic cycle , which emerges when the unstable and the stable manifolds of the same saddle coincide and form a closed loop . homo- and heteroclinic cycles are not robust structures in the sense that infinitesimally small change of system parameters destroy them . however in the practical sense , any limit cycle passing in close proximity to saddle points will be indistinguishable from a heteroclinic cycle ( fig . [ fig08 ] ) . the only difference is strict periodicity , although the period of the limit cycle in a neighborhood of the heteroclinic cycle may be long . besides , at the threshold of homo-/heteroclinic bifurcation the period is susceptible to external noise . in the context of our model , as coupling becomes stronger , the stable limit cycle swells and passes closer and closer to boundary fixed points which are node - saddles or focus - saddles ( fig . [ fig04]d f ) . depending on the interplay between the parameters , eventually it may bang into one or both of these equilibria creating either a homoclinic or heteroclinic cycle , respectively . this corresponds to @xmath238 and @xmath239 . on further increasing the coupling , the saddle connection breaks and the loop is destroyed . it is worth noting that heteroclinic cycles were first found by may and leonard @xcite in a classical lvg system with competing three species . however in their model the cycle is not truly periodic : as time goes on , the system tends to stay in the neighborhood of any one boundary equilibrium ever longer , so that the `` total time spent in completing one cycle is likewise proportional to the length of time the system has been running . '' moreover , may and leonard state that `` the phenomenon clearly requires at least three competitors , which is why it can not occur in models with two competitors . '' this statement is echoed by vandermeer @xcite who extended their theory on higher dimensions : `` it appears to be the case that all cases of an odd number of species follow this basic pattern , whereas all cases of even number of species result in extinction of half of the components , leaving the other half living independently at their carrying capacities . '' in view of our results , the above conclusion is by far and away true providing one stays within the framework of classical lvg equations , which in fact imply a high rapidity of the resource dynamics . in our model of just two competitors the slowness of the resource relative to the consumer is essential for the oscillations to occur , because it provides the necessary inertia to the system . physically , our model is most likely feasible because it is based on the well - established rate equations for semiconductor lasers , and therefore should be considered as a model of anti - phase synchronization of two lasers via their loss - coupling . ecologically , the feasibility of the model is tightly bound to justification of the adopted time hierarchy in system . time scales are usually inverted in ecosystems , as opposed to lasers , the most common case being rapid consumption of food by species . however it seems reasonable to propose that our model may describe the first level of an ecosystem , at which the consumers are autotrophs and the resources are mineral nutrients . the ability to exploit different substrates leads to a possibility of stable coexistence of different organisms descending from the common ancestor . divergent evolution is just the formation of new species : due to mutations two populations emerge with the same genetic code but having proteins able to process different substrates . providing the environmental conditions are quite stable on the evolutionary timescale , the inflows of inorganic substrates from the surroundings may be considered constant and the washout time of a substrate may occur much longer than the life expectancy of a species ( recall the definition of @xmath35 from ) . we proposed a model of two cr pairs linked by interspecific interference competition . when uncoupled , an individual cr pair has a unique stable steady state and does not admit periodic solutions . if intraspecific interference within the species is strong enough , the equilibrium is nonoscillatory ( stable node ) , otherwise the steadying occurs by decaying oscillations ( stable focus ) . when coupled , the model behaves differently at strong and weak competitive interaction between the consumers . when coupling is strong , one of the consumers wins . which consumer wins or loses depends critically on the relative intensities of the resource inflows and coupling strengths . in the case of bistability , when the system acts like a bistable multivibrator ( flip - flop circuit ) , the winner may be determined by the initial conditions . any static coexistence of competing consumers is not possible . when coupling is moderately weak , the model reveals low - frequency antiphase relaxation oscillations represented by a continuous flow of rectangular pulses . the system works as an astable multivibrator continually switching between its two states , neither of which is stable . the consumers can not coexist even dynamically : in each of two alternating states one consumer completely dominates and the other is on the verge of extinction . the most intriguing feature of the model is that each of the participating cr pairs taken separately does not oscillate ; both communities are completely quiescent , however , in interaction , when coupled in a nonlinear way , the resulting system turns into a relaxation oscillator . one way or the other , it is believed that the proposed model for coupling - induced oscillations in nonoscillatory cr pairs can be considered as a minimal in that class of population - dynamical systems and its mechanism can be applied to networks with large numbers of nonoscillatory elements and complex architecture . the author declares that there is no conflict of interests regarding the publication of this paper . of all types of interactions between individuals of the same population ( intraspecific interactions ) or individuals of different populations ( interspecific interactions ) of the same trophic level competition is most commonly encountered . in a broad sense , competition takes place when each species ( individual ) has an inhibiting effect on the growth of the other species ( individual ) . an inhibiting effect should be understood to mean either an increase in the death rate or a decrease in the birth rate . here dots indicate differentiation with respect to time @xmath7 , @xmath241 represents the total biomass of @xmath17th resource ( prey ) , @xmath242 stands for the total biomass of @xmath11th consumer ( predator ) species , the constant @xmath243 defines the growth rate of @xmath17th resource , @xmath244 is the carrying capacity of @xmath17th resource , @xmath245 is the rate of uptake of a unit of @xmath17th resource by each individual of @xmath11th consumer population , @xmath246 is the conversion efficiency parameter representing an amount of @xmath17th resource an individual of @xmath11th consumer population must consume in order to produce a single new individual of that species , @xmath247 is the loss rate of @xmath11th consumer due to either natural death or emigration . all parameters in are nonnegative . macarthur assumed population dynamics of the resources to be much faster than that of the consumers which enabled him to approximate @xmath241 in by its quasi - steady - state value derived by setting the right - hand side of to zero . as a result , he succeeded to reduce slow - scale equation to the well - known lvg model @xcite more recently , such an asymptotic reduction has also been carried out for a model of competition where species ( with continuous trait ) consume the common resource that is constantly supplied , under the assumption of a very fast dynamics for the supply of the resource and a fast dynamics for death and uptake rates @xcite . cr model assumes that competition within and between consumer species is purely exploitative : individuals and populations interact through utilizing ( or occupying ) common resource that is in short supply . quite on the contrary , lvg model describes competition strictly phenomenologically , as direct interference where consumers experience harm attributed to their mutual presence in a habitat ( e.g. through aggressive behavior ) . however we have to stress that neither macarthur s reduction claims that interference competition entirely results from `` more fundamental '' trophic competition , nor it urges us to hastily consider direct competition as some derived concept . what it actually states is that at slow - time scale associated with dynamics of the consumers , the effects of exploitation competition are indistinguishable from those of interference competition . and at slow - time scale , coefficients @xmath249 of merely add to interference coefficients @xmath250 which are to be present primordially in . most mathematical models dealing with coupled cr pairs or multilevel trophic chains ignore contributions of intraspecific and interspecific interference . indeed , the empirical data like @xcite do indicate that @xmath251 may be negligible in comparison with @xmath249 . still , works advocating the explicit account for direct interference show that incorporation of self - limitation and cross - limitation terms in the equations at the consumers level can provide for the stable coexistence of many species on few resources @xcite , @xcite . instead of the logistic mode of resource supply , as is the case in macarthur s model , our model is based on so - called `` equable '' mode of resource exploitation @xcite , by which the quantities of available resources are held constant by a continuous - flow system . according to and , a constant concentration of @xmath17th resource ( @xmath15 ) flows into a defined volume with the rate @xmath253 while unused resource flows out with the per capita rate @xmath254 , in much the same manner as in a chemostat @xcite . in more exact terms , the true chemostat model for one substrate and one species looks as follows : @xmath255 where the rate of substrate uptake is expressed by the monod formula @xmath256 , @xmath257 is a saturation constant numerically equal to the substrate concentration at which the uptake rate is half the maximum , @xmath258 is the dilution rate defined as the rate of flow of medium over the volume of the bioreactor , and @xmath259 is an input concentration of the substrate . besides , in and intraspecific competition strength @xmath265 ( @xmath10 ) measures direct interference of individuals within @xmath11th consumer population with each other resulting in an additional per capita loss rate @xmath266 ; interspecific competition strength @xmath267 ( @xmath268 ; @xmath269 ) quantifies direct interference effect from @xmath68th consumer on @xmath11th consumer resulting in an additional per capita loss rate , @xmath270 , of the latter . equations contain two important assumptions . first , they assume that the resources are noninteractive . on higher trophic levels , however , resources may interact and the possibility of competition among the resources was originally pointed out by lynch @xcite . since then , a whole series of theoretical papers have been published on two - predator , two - prey systems with interference competition between two self - reproducting prey species based on the lotka volterra equations . specifically , kirlinger @xcite describes the model in which each predator specializes on one prey only , while xiang and song @xcite treat a similar model in which each predator is allowed to feed on both prey . a second assumption of our equations is that the consumers interact only directly , through interference competition , and can not compete through their use of resources , as each consumer specializes on one resource only . the theory of pure trophic competition in equable models has been developed in the works @xcite . intraspecific interference competition is allowed within the consumers as well . even though the available amount of any resource happened to be of a constant level , the population size of the associated consumer would remain finite due to self - limitation caused by direct intraspecific interference . the novelty of model is that it considers time hierarchy of macarthur s cr equations to be reversed by assuming dynamics of the consumers to be much faster than that of the involved resources and articulates the importance of direct competition mechanisms within the framework of this assumption . the parameters @xmath274 , @xmath275 and @xmath276 reflect the rapidity of the dynamics of @xmath181 , @xmath182 and @xmath183 with reference to that of @xmath180 it is assumed that @xmath277 and @xmath278 . in studying the effect of coupling , the parameters of interest are obviously the coupling strengths , @xmath279 and @xmath280 . the parameters of interest are also those which characterize the difference between the states of the uncoupled systems . the resource income rates @xmath115 and @xmath237 are used as the control parameters that distinguish the relative base states of the two systems . laser rate equations originally proposed by statz and demars @xcite are differential equations that relate two quantities : injected carrier density ( @xmath284 ) and photon density ( @xmath285 ) . for a single - mode semiconductor laser , these equations take the form ( * ? ? ? 6 ) where dots mean differentiation with respect to time @xmath7 , @xmath287 is the injection current density ( pump parameter ) , @xmath288 is the magnitude of the electron charge , @xmath289 is the active - layer thickness , @xmath290 is the confinement factor accounting for the fraction of the light power contained in the active region , @xmath291 is the group velocity of light that can be expressed through the speed of light in vacuum ( @xmath292 ) and the group refractive index of the dispersive semiconductor material ( @xmath293 ) as @xmath294 , @xmath20 is the gain coefficient , @xmath295 is the carrier density at transparency corresponding to the onset of population inversion , @xmath296 is the lifetime of the electrons in the conduction band before being lost by escape from the active region , @xmath297 is the lifetime of photons inside the cavity before going out of the cavity or being absorbed inside the cavity . in the contribution of spontaneous emission is neglected . typical parameter values for a semiconductor laser ( mostly borrowed from @xcite ) are given in table [ taba1 ] . these numerical values are used in the calculations throughout the present paper , unless otherwise noted . lll + ( r)1 - 2 notation & meaning & value + @xmath287 ( @xmath298 ) & pump current density & @xmath299 ( 1.19375 ) + @xmath289 & active layer thickness & @xmath300 + @xmath290 & confinement factor & @xmath301 + @xmath293 & group refraction index & @xmath302 + @xmath20 & differential gain coefficient & @xmath303 + @xmath295 & carrier density at transparency & @xmath304 + @xmath296 & carrier lifetime & @xmath305 + @xmath297 & photon loss time & @xmath306 + @xmath35 & @xmath307 & @xmath308 + @xmath258 ( @xmath36 ) & intrinsic second order loss & @xmath309 ( 0.01 ) + consider two ( not necessarily identical ) lasers of type and introduce additional intensity - dependent losses such that each laser , @xmath11 , of the two has a total loss represented by the sum of the constant loss , @xmath310 , plus the loss proportional to its own intensity , @xmath311 , plus the loss proportional to the intensity of the other laser , @xmath312 : where @xmath314 ( @xmath10 ) is the second order loss constant of the isolated @xmath11th laser and @xmath315 is the coupling strength measuring the cross - loss effect of @xmath11th laser on @xmath17th laser . thus according to , two lasers happen to be cross - coupled through their resonators , so that each of them can modulate the cavity loss of the other . technically , intensity - dependent intrinsic and cross - losses may be implemented , for example , using an intracavity electro - optic modulator fed by a current proportional to the output power @xcite . we will consider the pump currents @xmath316 and @xmath317 , and the coupling strengths @xmath318 and @xmath319 , as free parameters of the model . for the present , we can not judge with any confidence the numerical value of @xmath320 , however , as it is demonstrated in the main body of the paper , the exact value of the intrinsic second order loss is not all that critical and does not affect principal results of our analysis , providing that this parameter is small in a sense . for the purposes of model calculations , we adopt @xmath320 to be somewhat less than @xmath321 . presumably , hofelich - abate and hofelich @xcite were first to introduce ( in general form ) an intensity - dependent self - limitation term in the photon - density rate equation . later , that has been done in an explicit form of the second order loss @xcite . those and subsequent studies @xcite showed efficient damping of relaxation oscillations in the presence of intensity - dependent losses . as to the formal analysis of laser coupling via intensity - loss cross - modulation , very few attempts have been done so far to consider such a mechanism e.g . @xcite and @xcite . the former work , however , does not treat intrinsic second order losses . the works which address loss - coupled modes of a single laser rather than loss - coupled single - mode lasers are much more plentiful and varied , and we refer the reader for the reviews in ( * ? ? ? * ch . 8) and 12 ) . in his seminal paper @xcite , baer studied multimode regime of nd : yag ( neodymium - doped yttrium aluminum garnet ) laser with the intracavity - doubling ktp ( potassium titynal phosphate ) crystal both experimentally and numerically , and proposed the following rate equations for two coupled longitudinal modes : where @xmath323 and @xmath324 ( @xmath10 ) are the respective gain and intensity of @xmath11th mode , @xmath325 is the fluorescence lifetime , @xmath326 is the small - signal gain ( pump parameter ) for @xmath11th mode , @xmath327 is the saturation parameter which determines how strongly the intensity depletes the available gain , @xmath328 is the cross - saturation parameter for modes 1 and 2 , @xmath296 is the cavity round - trip time , @xmath329 is the loss of @xmath11th mode , @xmath35 is the nonlinear coupling coefficient , which models the intracavity - doubling crystal as an intensity - dependent loss in the laser resonator . the last two terms in and represent second order losses that are due to intracavity second - harmonic generation and sum - frequency generation , respectively . numerical calculations revealed antiphase synchronous oscillations in . in antiphase state , either mode has precisely the same time profile being shifted by @xmath330 of a period from its counterpart . this type of dynamics was later observed in a multimode @xmath331:yag laser with intracavity doubling crystal @xcite . for @xmath284 antiphase oscillators , the phase shift between any nearest neighbors is @xmath332 of a period . the scaling @xmath334 turns into nondimensional form . since the lasers are made of the same material , we can put @xmath335 , @xmath336 , @xmath337 , @xmath338 , @xmath339 , @xmath340 , @xmath341 , and @xmath342 , whence @xmath281 , @xmath282 and @xmath283 , and we arrive , dropping the prime at @xmath7 , at the set of equations . s. smale , `` a mathematical model of two cells via turing s equation , '' in _ some mathematical questions in biology v _ ( j. d. cowan , ed . ) , vol . 6 of _ lectures on mathematics in the life sciences _ , pp . 1526 , providence , ri : american mathematical society , 1974 . y. loewenstein , y. yarom , and h. sompolinsky , `` the generation of oscillations in networks of electrically coupled cells , '' _ proceedings of the national academy of sciences of the united states of america _ , vol . 98 , no . 14 , pp . 80958100 , 2001 . i. szatmri and l. o. chua , `` awakening dynamics via passive coupling and synchronization mechanism in oscillatory cellular neural / nonlinear networks , '' _ international journal of circuit theory and applications _ , vol . 36 , no . 5 - 6 , pp . 525553 , 2008 . d. s. chernavskii , e. k. palamarchuk , a. a. polezhaev , g. i. solyanik , and e. b. burlakova , `` a mathematical model of periodic processes in membranes ( with application to cell cycle regulation ) , '' _ biosystems _ , vol . 9 , no . 4 , pp . 187193 , 1977 . t. baer , `` large - amplitude fluctuations due to longitudinal mode coupling in diode - pumped intracavity - doubled nd : yag lasers , '' _ journal of the optical society of america b : optical physics _ , vol . 3 , no . 9 , pp . 11751180 , 1986 . m. devetter and j. sed , `` the relative role of interference competition in regulation of a rotifer community during spring development in a eutrophic reservoir , '' _ international review of hydrobiology _ , vol . 93 , no . 1 , pp . 3143 , 2008 . f. m. stewart and b. r. levin , `` partitioning of resources and the outcome of interspecific competition : a model and some general considerations , '' _ american naturalist _ 107 , no . 954 , pp . 171198 , 1973 . a. ghosh , b. k. goswami , and r. vijaya , `` nonlinear resonance phenomena of a doped fibre laser under cavity - loss modulation : experimental demonstrations , '' _ pramana - journal of physics _ , vol . 75 , no . 5 , pp . 915921 , 2010 . j. tian , y. yao , j. j. xiao , x. yu , and d. chen , `` tunable multiwavelength erbium - doped fiber laser based on intensity - dependent loss and intra - cavity loss modulation , '' _ optics communications _ , 285 , no . 9 , pp . 24262429 , 2012 . a. kellou , k. at - ameur , and f. sanchez , `` suppression of undamped oscillations in erbium - doped fibre lasers with intensity - dependent losses , '' _ journal of modern optics _ , 45 , no . 9 , pp . 19511956 , 1998 . f. li , j. n. kutz , and p. k. a. wai , `` characterizing bifurcations and chaos in multiwavelength lasers with intensity - dependent loss and saturable homogeneous gain , '' _ optics communications _ , vol . 285 , no . 8 , pp . 21442153 , 2012 . a. el amili , g. kervella , and m. alouini , `` experimental evidence and theoretical modeling of two - photon absorption dynamics in the reduction of intensity noise of solid - state er : yb lasers , '' _ optics express _ , vol . 21 , no . 7 , pp . 87738780 , 2013 .
Abstract: | [
"the paper concerns two interacting consumer - resource pairs based on chemostat - like equations under the assumption that the dynamics of the resource is considerably slower than that of the consumer . the presence of two different time scales enables to carry out a fairly complete analysis of the problem . this is done by treating consumers and resources in the coupled system as fast - scale and slow - scale variables respectively and subsequently considering developments in phase planes of these variables , fast and slow , as if they are independent . when uncoupled , each pair has unique asymptotically stable steady state and no self - sustained oscillatory behavior ( although damped oscillations about the equilibrium are admitted ) . when the consumer - resource pairs are weakly coupled through direct reciprocal inhibition of consumers , the whole system exhibits self - sustained relaxation oscillations with a period that can be significantly longer than intrinsic relaxation time of either pair . it is shown that the model equations adequately describe locally linked consumer - resource systems of quite different nature : living populations under interspecific interference competition and lasers coupled via their cavity losses ."
] | 11,563 | 11,563 | 12,000 |
Subsets and Splits